HomeMy WebLinkAbout99-01184
\..'
\,1;
"
"
.' H'"
I'
.,
,
.,
,F'
~ ;;,
t
'... ..
\J .,.
.~ "
j;'
. "
.'.
1/
'/'I
"
I.,
I
'3"
~
il
.,
I.
"
./
...
i',
,I"
"
'I
.,
"I\ull"ll Wnllln, I'h,l>.
/./r:I'IHI1d/'.IXflr%/1{.'./
--..... ...
I~ 1\'\"\'0(.'//1111,\'
2111 Nlllllh .1211\1 NIHJI,I
,-- - --_.._",::-::=--:::::C:-C::::::::-.::C::,C--:'C:::".:,-::,='::',::'.7"~:'C'::C::;:;-.:::c::::::::..--,,==::~~""'I'_~^~!~J
('II'/)7C11-IHH
1'''>\ 171 7J'/C1I. IV,I2 .
IIM^II"I'WillllIl,I'I"'"!!"l1u.'"111
CIJ/i'I'()J)V IcY AWA'I'I()N
Chlllll Mlltlh~w UIII'luw, J)UII l/l~1H1l
1'lIr~IIIHI llrlll111hll'lllW
1,)'I\I\~ Z~hl'hl((
1)1I1~N uf ICVlllnllllunll)/~U/I)l). 11/:lI1)1)
J)1I1~ uf .l~lllll'll II/III/I)I)
ANH~HHll\cnl 111'U~Clhll'C
IntervlowH with MlIl\how'H mothol', L)'nno Zohl'ln!l
Intol'vloWH with MlIl\how'H ththol', Ill'lun BlIl'low
Inl\ll'vloWH with MlIl\how Bnrlow
Intol'vlow with ,Inok JllmlHon, MH, Zohl'lng'H ho)'/l'IolI<l
1Ill0l'vlow with ROHO Sohwnrtl, II oloHo l\'Iond oJ'tho 1\111111)'
I'R)'llholo!llonlloRtlllg of'Mntthow Bnrlow: RorHchnoh Inkhlot TOHt, Tlwmntlo Appol'coption TORI
PHyoholo!llcnl tORtlng of'MI', Unl'low, MH, Zohl'lng, MI', JnmlHon: MlnnoRotn MllltlphnHlc
I'ol'sonnllty Invonlol')' (MMI'I)
Rovlow of' 1'0col'dH:
Solootod Hchooll'ocol'llH lin'nlHho<l hy MI', Unrlow
LottoI' Ih1ll1 MI', Unl'low nnll pOHtonl'd f'rnm Mntthow, 1\lrnlHho<l h)' MH, Zohl'lng
llllcllllrfllllld, 1)11111
Mntthow hns hoon living with his lhthol' slnoo tho n!loof six, wholl hlH (1nl'OntH Hopnl'lltod un<l
HllhHO'lllontiy <llvlll'ood, Untlll'ocolltly Ihol'o wns no Ibnllnl vlsltntlonngl'ooll1onl, Ills molhol' Hnw
him on 1Ilt0l'l1ntinll wookondll, Sho hnH novol' 1'0'llloslod pl'lllontlod Sl1nlll1OI' vlHltntloll, he.onllHo
ncool'lllllg to hol', MI" Unrlow WOllld novol' hllvo ulllllvcdlt.
For Iho pnst Rovol'nlmonthH Mnl\how hnH 1'0'llloHtod to gonnd llvo with hlH mothol', Ilowovcl', hlH
Ihthol'holllwOH IhntlhlH IH not Inlho hoy's hOHt Inlol'oHIH, 110 cltos tho fhot thnt MH, Zchrlng's Iwo
oldcl'sollH fhllll n pl'ovloUH Illnl'l'llIgo hoth Ilollnto Irnllhlo hOOUUHO Rho cOlllduollllnnugo tholll,
II
In AIIllust, 11)1)1) n hOl\l'lnglVnH hold In Cumhol'lnnd Count)' Courtl'ollnnlluglho mnttcl' of' cUHlod)'
of Mntthow, Onl)' Ms, ZohrlulltcHIllled, Jlldllo Guido thon ol'dol'ed n (1s)'ohololllonl ovuluutlon,
110 nlHo onlorod Il1\ll'ouHod vlllltntlon hetwoon Mntthow nnd his mothel', nllouHt two wl)okollda 011
nlld OliO Wookllnd ofl',
('IINSIII:I,ITII'N. HVM,IIAIIIIN' i'SI'nll II IIliIlM'\'
l.u//I'llIlI \', /lW/(I\I' , , ,/'(llIU 2
IIINUINOH
1I..lIm IIn..lmv
CLINICAL INTHIWIIlW AND nl\IIA VIOHAI. on/wlw ATIONIi
Ilrllln 1llll'lnw, 1I1l0 31), wns pllllotllllllhr his IIppnlntl11onts, 110 WIIS olls\1l1l1y drossOlllllld 1I01llly
Ilrolll11od, Fromlho O\1lsol ho Ollpl'ossod Olllllompl townrd his ox-wlfo, 110 l\'oll\lonlly dlllrossocl
11110 01'1110111 sllll01l1Onls IIh0\11 hol', ovon WllOlI lI1y qllosllUllS \VOI'O I'olnled In somolhlnll olso,
MI', Bllrlnw xnlll IImt Ms, Zohdllg hud uhnndollod Mntlhow Iwloe, Tho I1I'SI limo sho loft,
Mnllhow wns 3 Ill' A luw l110lllhs Inlor sho 1'011lrl1od, hili lull nlluln 2 III YOIII'S lulol', Sho roporledl)'
wllllllllly left Mlltlhow wllh his flllhol' IIl1d IlIdlellto(llhnl sho WIIS xUllxl10d wl\h overy"olhor-
wookelld vlsllu\loll,
MH, Zohrlng novoI' II110ndod Hohool oOlllorolloos, Evon Ihollgh Hho hlld vlHUlIllolI I\'om Fl'lduy 10
HlllldllY, xho ol\en Wlllled 1111 Hnlll1'Cluy 111\01'110011 to plol( him liP, sho ropol'tedly nevor reqlloxled
udcllllonnlllmo wllh Mntlhow, Hlloh ns oxtollded holldnYH,
Tho ISHllo of ollHlody Ollmo lip Ihl' Iho I1rst limo ellrllol' thlH yOlll', when MI', Ulldow Ihreulolled to
1lI0 Ihr ohllll xllpport, MH, Zohrhllllhon reportedly told MlIllhow, "Tr,1I yOllr fhther If ho l1Ios Ihr
ehlld slIppnrl, 1'111 golllg 1011lo Ihr ellHtody,"
Mr, Ullrlow Clllh1\H thlll ho hus hcon IIn exoll1plll1'Y fUlhol', Mlltlhew Ix dolllg wolllll Hohool
(ropl1l'todly I'clldlllgIII Iho oollogo lovol) lIud ho doos 1\ot gOllllto t1'ClIIhlo. MI', Bnrlow IIl1rlhllloH
Ihlx to tho slrlotmloH Ihut ho mnlnlulllH, slleh IIH vlHl\lng fi'\CllldH' homos ollly when II Plll'OllllH
prosulI!, 110 f01l1'H Ihlllll' Mllllhow goos to IIvo with hlH mothol', Ihoro will bo nomloH 1lI\(1
Mllllhow will slnok ofl'on hlH homowork, liS wellns porhllpx filII III wUh Iho Wl'llllg erowd, Also,
slllco Mlltlhow WOllld ho ehllllglllg Hohools, ho WOllld nol ho nhlo to sco hlH ollrronl frlondH,
Mr, Bnrlow IIdmllH belllg Hlrlet, bllt ho Illllllllnlns Ihllt ho hnH luw rilles IInd Ihnt he IH eOllslslenl,
t\lIhollgh he IH pl'OlId 01' MlIlthew's good n\(ll1Il0l'H, ho dOOH nol trllHt Ihnt hlH HOII elllllllllke
eOlllmoll-HOllxe deelslollS Inlllll\lI11l1lur HltllntlollH, For this rellson, he believe IIml Mnlthew lIeods
eloso Hllpervlsloll,
Mr. Blldow dosedbod his own 1\II1111y hlHlory, Been\1He of hlH fhther'H .lob, tho filllll1y Illoved
fi'oqllenlly, lIe went (olhlll' dlffol'ont sehoolH. Ho dcserlbed his Hither IIH eusy-golnglllld I\l11ny,
hilt IIIHO IIH commllndlngl'CHI1Col. His molhol' WIlH n "nol'l1\1I1 Ozzlo-lInd-HIIl'l'iel hOIlHCllllllll", hilt
slrlcl: "When OVOI'Yllnc olHo hlld (0 ho In III 10:00, I hlld III ho Innl 9:00," ho xllld, AH II sllldonl
BrllIn did wollin mlllh, hUI hllted relldlug, lIe mlsscd gl'lldllllllng with hlH CIIlHH heolluHo he flllled
Zel/l'llIg I'. /1(//'/01\'. . .l'age J
English. II~ got hIs CHID nlngu 31, prhlll\1'lIy 10 plonso his 1110lhor, bllt ho (1lso 1I(l(locllhlll ho
ro~~lvod Iho hi ghost soure for Ihu sohool dlstl'let.
Mr, BlIrlow hilS beon soll~ol11ployed liS II onrponler for 14 yenrs, Ho know he WllS gplng 10 bo n
ollrp~nler slnoe Ihe IIgo of nine, Prior tQ working Oil his own he workod fhrvnl'lolls oOnlrnO\ll\,S
Inl\IIIIHO dhl olhor \Ilbor work, Ho met Lynne Zehring 1IIIho Penn Nnllonlll Rnce COmMO wherll
Ihey bolh worl,ocl,
Tlw Illllrrlllge wns rooky, whloh he IIUdbnlos Ihls 10 his wlfo.'s Infhlolity,
Mr, Bnl'low mh1\lls 10 Ilslng mllrljlll\ll11 slnoe his leens, A fow months IIgo Mlluhew 1'0111\(1
ml\l'ljllllnlllnll d\'llwer In his flllhel"s room, Nnw Mr, Bmlow ollllms 10 hllVo qllH nslng
mnrljllllnfl, heellllSo he doosll'l wllnl to rlHk losing MIIlIhow. llowllvor, In his own defenso ho
sllltod thlll Ms, Znhrlng IInd hOI' boyfHolu\ hnve hrngged IIbolll smoking mllrl,lllllnn themselves.
Mr, Bnrlow lI(hnlls 10 drinking IIlooho\ spol'lldlollllYI for e>\I\I1\l1lo, Iwo beors pOI' dlly Ihr Ihlll'
clllYs, nnd thol1 J1er1llIPS nOlhlng for Iwo weoks,
110 Is sllll oloso 10 his plll'enls, Ho seos Ihom IIbollt onoo pOI' n1l1nlh IInd Inlks 10 Ihem 011 the
phol1o, His lolher \lIkes MIIlIhow !ishlng In tho S\mllnor.
Mr, Bnl'low hilS IllItoclln Ihe pllst, bllt Is not In II relllllonshlp III present. Ills life revolves mOllnd
his work I1nd his son,
BEllA VIORAL OBSERVATIONS WITII MA'lTIIEW
Mr, Bnrlow WIIS qlllte oOl\1fortnblo with Mnllhew, lie spoke to him 11111 Ilnll bill respeelt\llnnd
sOlllellmes plllyfhllone of voloo. The Iwo .01' them joked together (Imlng Iho Inlorvlow, MIIlIhow
WIIS oll\lllollS In his fnlher's eOll1pllny. AI Ilrst his vOleo WIlS hesltllnt IInd reslrnlned, bllt liS tho
session progressed, he bcelll11e 1110re relllxed. Ilowevor, he novol' 1I)l)lllllred oOl11pletely lit ellso
with his 111Iher d\lrlng the Interview.
MI'. BlIrlow did nollhrolllen MlIlIllllW, nOl' did he orltlcize hlllllnlllY presence. When the slll\lect
of Ill'llcles OlunC up, he expllllned Ihnt he Inslsled ollgoocl Ill'llcles boclluse this WIIS .Ihe ollly wny
Mlltthew ooulcl expoello em'n n Bcholnrshlp nln good college, Mntthew's fneinl expression nl
tllllt point Indlcnted Ihllt he hnd pl'Obnbly helll'cllhls lootme sevel'lll times before,
.,
PSYCHOLOGICAL TEST RESULTS
MI'. BlIl'low's MMI'I wns within nOl'lllnlllmlts, The vnlldlty senles Indlentod mild defensiveness,
whleh Is Iyplenl for this type of sltllntlon. There wns evldenoe of Interpel'sonnlmlst\'llstllnd
sensitivity to helng contl'olled by olhol's. Mr, Bnrlow Is IIpl to resist 01' retnllnle ngnlnst othors
Zvlil'(u!: ", /111I'((1\1', , ,"O!:V .,
whol) ho hollo\lOs tho)' 111'0 Ir)'lulllo eonlrol him, Ilowovor, thero la no ovldonoo oflcl1(lolWY
IOWllrd ph)'slolll vlolonoo, Mr, Ullrlow Is uptlo 110 1I000mmO(llIlInllllnd eonollllltllrY liS louglls ho
I~ols Ihlll ho Is 110lnll rospoetl,d, Ilowovol', ho Olin ollslI)' boeol11o IIl1llry with 11\110 provoellllon,
lint! Is 'lul\1k to hlllmo olhor pooplo,
',ynnll Zllhl'lllll
I .Y1\110 Zohrll\ll, 1I110 4~, IIppourod for hor IIppoll\ll\Wl1ls 01\ limo, Sho WlIs ellslllllly drossod IInd
\WIl-lll'oOlne(l, She presentod horsolf liS slneoro Iu wl\lllhlll to holp her SOil, She SlIld Ihllll ()
yelll'S IIgo she hlld left MlIl\how wilh his thlhol' hoollUso sho fCllrod Ihlll MI', !lurlow woul'l oomo
1\1\01' hor or son(1 aomoono to hurt hol' If sho hl\d Il\kol1lho hoy wllh hor, Ilowovor, now Ihl\l
Ml\l\how hilS oxpl'ossod II strunll (Ioslro (olivo with hor, she teols sho mnst support him In I1l1l1g
1'01' ouslml)', Although shols ourrontl)' wnrklnll soeond shll\, sho phllls to go 10 In\o nlghlshil\ If
Mlltthew Ilunws to live with hol', so thllt sho will ho homo with him 11\ tholll\ornol1l\s,
Llko Mr, BlIl'low, sho WIIS qlllok 10 orltlolze hor Oli'HpOIlSO, Sho dosllrlhod him liS oOl1trollhlg IInd
IIl\rollSOl1l1hlo, POI' oxumplo, sho wonl(1 sonlllthnos usk MlIl\how to lIuk his I\llhor If ho 00111(1
spol\d HOmo holldllYs with her whon ho IIml his I'lIthol' hlld 1\0 plllna, MI', Ullrlow wonld rospond
Ihrollllh MUl\how, "Tell YOIII' 1110m It's not hor (IllY," flho ulso oompll\lnod Ihl\l Mr, BlIl'low
olu'sod In Ii'ont of MlIl\how und thut ho IIlIowod tho hoy to wllloh R-rUlcd n1l1vlos. Il1l1ddltlon, sho
WIIS llonool'llod thllt Mr, IJllrlmv sllIokod mllrl.llllll1l1 lit homo,
Ms, Zohl'lng sym(1l1lhlzos with Mlltthow, She SIlYS thllt MlIl\how WIIUts to 10llVo "1'01' tho Sll1110
rOllsons I did," Whon sho WIIS IIvll1g with MI', !llll'loW, ho hOllght ovor)' (11000 ol'l\ll'\llturo In tho
hOllso. Ho I1IlIdo 1111 tho doolslons, Al\cl' sho 101\, "Brlun IIlwlI)'S sot thc I'Illos Ihr vlsltlltlou," Sho
novoI' IIskod to tllko Mul\how fhl'l\ wcok 01' two In tho snmmol' hool\IISO "thoro Is IIIl WilY Brllln
would hllVo ngreod to 1(,"
Now, Mntthow Is I'oportedly compll\lnhlgto hor thllt his I'nthor Is ull1'clIsonnhlo, nnd thnt nil thoy
do Is nght. Altlwugh Mlltthcw Is n good studont, his fhthcr nlwllYs SIlYS ho onn do hottor. Now
thnt Mntthow Is mnlurlug IInd oxprcsslng his own oplulous moro oponly, tho clllshos with his
I'nthel' hnvo Intcnsllled,
Sho stntod thnt whon MIIUhow Is with hor, dlsolpllno Is not 1\ problom, IIlthough sho did
noknowledgo thllt sho IHSOll1othnos "too soil, too kind," Whon sho dlsnpprovcs ofsolllothlnll ho
sn)'s 01' dOoH, she dlsoussos It with him, They ropOl'tcdly rmoly nrguo, Mntthow docs hllVo choro!!
lit hcl' house, Inoludlng dlshos, olonnlnll his l'Oomllnd holplng with Yllnl work, For this ho
rccolvos IIn II110wllnoe,
When ( nskl.'d Ms. Zohrlng why she noVoI' nUl.'ndcd Brinn's telloher oonlol'Onocs, sho roplied thnt
sho wouldn't hllve beon wolcolllo thoro by Mr. Bllrlow. She gllve thc IIIIIllO rellson Ihl'not
IIllendlng Mntthow's 1l1l1ll0S, Throughollttho ovnllllltlou Ms. Zehring Illnll1tlllned thnt sho hilS
ZQ(/I'(Ii!J\'. nW((JII'" ,('<lIW,!
lllwllYS 10w(1 Mnttl\Ow, bllllhnl she nlso fellln\hnl~lnle(1 nn(llhrenlonoll by his fnlhel', Yel sl10
dOllied I hIli 110 wn~ phY~I(lnlly vlolenl. At WOl'sl, he WIIS oplnlonolo(1 nncllll'Ulll1lOnlntlvo,
Ms, Zohrll1U Illls bO~nl111n'l'le(llwlee. She hns IWo sons, lIuod 21l1l1(119, fl'ol11 hor 1ll'slmlll'l'IlIue.
When tlw old"r son WIIS 15, ho Il1slsle~1 011 going 10 live wllh his Hllhor, Ills Yonngel' hrolhor
IhliowClI shorllY Iherellftcr, Her YOl1ngel' son Is now nl Iho Comp Hill SllIle Corrcctlonlll Fnclllly,
nlloucdly Illl' stcllling n mll1lblkc,
Ms, Zehrlnu descrlbe(1 hor porsonnl nnd fllmily hlslory, Sho Is Iho sceond of fonr ehlldron. Sho
gruw np 1111.0\11111011 nnd .Ionoslown, Sho desorlbell hol' molhor liS pollIO IInd (jlllol, 1101' I11olhol'
did 1101 dls\llpllno Iho \lhlhlren, bnt lold Iholr Hlthol' whon Ihoy (lid son1Ulhlng wrong. 1101' HIther
WIIS vory mnoh Il1lorosled In the OllldoOl's, IIl1d sho I\ocompnnlod him on his lIsslgllnlOllls for Iho
Fish IInd Clnmo Commission, whoro 11\l workod In his Spllro limo, As sho grow Inlo ndolosoono\l
hor flllhor boelllne "very IIptlght," Ho WIIS physlolllly lIhllslvo, Whon Ms, Zohrlng WlIS II sCl1lor
In high sohool, sho 100 homo IIlbw wocl~s prior to grlldlllltlon, hecnllse her flllhol' hml hOlllon hol',
Sho doscrlbed horself 1I~ IIn ontgolng, kind pOl'son In hlUh school, bill nol n very good stlldellt.
Sho WIIS IIlwllys somewhlll of II tomboy, prolbl'rhlg IIcllvlly to stndylng,
She met hol' llrsl hllsblllld 111 high school. Thoy mnrrled II fow YOlll'S Inlor whon sho bCellll1\l
progllllnl with hor oldest son. Sho doserlbed hor hils blind liS h11mlllln'o. Sho hml hopod ho WOllld
mnll\rc, hilI hc novel' (\ld, Whon hor sons wero Ihreo IInd fo\ll' yellrs old, he WIIS scnllo prison for
soiling drugs, Sho snhsoqllenlly dlvoroo(1 him, .
Ms, Zehring hilS workod IIllho Reoso's plnnl for 17 yellrs. Dnrlng lIlnyoITsho workod onlho
Jllnltorlnl cmw nll'ol1l1 Nnllonlll Rlleo COllrsc, whoro sho mot Mr, BlIl'low.
Sho clnlms Ihllt lIOor thoy wero mllrdod, sho did IIl1lho hO\ISOWOl'k IInd chllllflbmlng ortho
ohlldron, evonlhOllgh sho workod 1\IIHh11o on tho nlghl shlO, Whon sho nsked Mr, BllI'low 10
holp ho ronlsod.
Ms, Zohrlng mol hor cllrronl hoyli'lond, .Inok .Il1111lson, nl work, Sho donlcs 1111\1 ho wns Iho rOllsol!
sho 100 hor hllsbllnd, Sho rellll'lled to Mr, Bnl'low only hocllnso ho boggcd hCI' to como homo,.
Howovcr, nOel' Iwo yenrs sho mmld nb longol' Sllll1d II, so sho 100 lI!lnln, Inking hol' tWllllldol'
boys \Vlth hol',
NOVOl'tholoss, sho olllhns sho hilS nl\Vllya lovod Mntlhow, She d~ac1'ibed lholl' I'ollltlonshl(llls
oloso, 1-10 oonndcs In hol', Thoy ol\loy tholr limo togothcl',
Ms, Zohrlng donlos (h'ug nnd 1I1ellholllhuso, bUI ndmltn to drinking ono glnss or wino holhl'll hcd,
ldll'/lIlI I', /lW(OIl'. , ./)(/II~ 6
PHYC\IOl,CIWCAI, THHT IUiHIJ\;rH
Ms, i',ohrlnll's MMI'I hullplIlollmlu'kod Iluf'unslvol1oss nnllll doslr!) 10 prosonl horsolfln IIn
Ill1rl'nllsllonlly positive IIllht, Tho ollnlcn\ scnlos woro within tho nornH\1 \'III1IlO, but Indlolllod II
IOl1l10noy 10 nvoltl (Ionllnll with oonli'onlnllon, Sho Is sonsltlve 10 tho rellcllons of t\IPso III'llIl1HI
hor,lIl\C1 trll's 10 mlnlmlzo Intprpl'l'solllll pOl1l11ol, Hho hils 111110 Inslllhl Inlo hor OWI1 omo\lmm\
t\lI1ollonlnll, ospoollllly In torl\1S ol'rocollnlz,lnllnnd oxprosslullnnllor In nnnppl'llprlnto n1lll1nOl',
nEllA VloML OUHEIW A'I'lONS WITH MATTlmw
Ms, Zohrln!! IInd Mn\lhow woro plllyl\llnnd IIl'fllollol1nlo with ono IInolhor, They Sill close
(o!!olhor on Iho SOlll,lIl1d nmln\llluod nppl'llprlnlo oyo oonlnol wllh onoh othor, Ms, Zohrlng spolw
10 Mnllhuw lUll clIIIII IIll10 of voloo,lIl1d ho rospolHle(lln kind, Dllrlll!! Iho hrlof Intorvlows Ihoro
WIIS nooeonslon In which she IInd to confronl 01' roprhllnl\C1 Mnllhcw, Ho npl101ll'cd mmo rolnxod
with his molhcl' Ihlln with his filtller,
MlIlIhllw IIl1rln,v
CLINICAL INTBRVIllW AND BEHAVIORAL OBSERVATIONS
14-Y(lnNlld Mntlhow Is IIn ntl\'llo\lvo younl,\ lIlnn ol'lI1o(lIul\1 holl,\hl 1II\(1 hulld, Ho Is IIn\lsllnlly
woll-l11nnllorod olllllpnrcd toolhor youl1gslors, 110 prosentod hhllsclf ns slncoro nnd eortnlllln his
dosll'c to live with his mothor,
In his 1IIltlnl h1tolvlow Mntlhow SlIld thnl ho nnd his fillhol' nr!!IIO nhout Hlltl1pld, sll1nllthll1l,\s,"
11m oxnlllplo, whon ho I,\ols hOll1o 1\'0111 school ho hilS 10 onll his fnlhol', ) I' ho wnl1ts 10 !!O Ion
li'lolld's hOllso, his fnther s01110\lll10S snys "No" Ihl' no !!ooel rOlison, Ills MhoI' nlso Ihl'blds hi 1\1 to
IIslon to rnp lI1uslo, ovon Iholll,\h his tillhol' Hhns novoI' IIslolled 10 n rnp song hI his 111'0," His
lilI1Hll' obJoCls 10 tho wny ho drossos, nlthoul,\h ho did 101 hlll1BOI his onl' plol'ood,
Mnllhow nlso slIld tlllIl Ills tillhol' Slit him downli.1r 11I1 ho\ll' whon ho WIIS lII'ollnd 10 YOIII'S old,
lolling hlmlhllt his mothol' wus II sllllulld II whol'O, (MI', BlIl'low donlos thlsl ho dOOR mll1\lt Ihul
ho ollllod his ox-wlf'u nlllll',) Mntlhow compllllllod lhlll his Huhol' hilS mlldo dOl'OI,\1I1ory omnmonts
IIbollt him, nlthollgh ho hllsll't dono so IlItoly, Howovcl', Mlltlhow foUlhllt his mothol"s
hoyfl'lond, Jllok, lI'ollts him 11101'0 IIko n son,
Altholll,\h Mlltlhow hnd SOI11O vnl!lIo oomplnlnls nholll his fnlhcl', ho cOllld 1I0t dcsorlbo IIl1ythlng
boyolld II BOllurnl "1101 gottlng nlollg," Ho Rnld Ihnl ho docsn't hnlo his fnlhor, hilI Ihll\ hOJIISI
Willits to IIw with his 11\0thol', When) nskcd him how onOIl ho clllls hol', ho ropllod Ihllt ho onl\s
1101' 1'l\1'01y, "llIslllllly IbrgcI," ho sllld, In his fll'stlntol'vlow, In whloh ho WIIS hl'OlIght by his
iMIfII/RI',/Iwll/II'",/'<IIw7
mnther on n CohnnllllH !lny mnmlnu (when sohnlll wns olnsutl,) he snl(1 thnt ho IHI(I hoen wllh his
molher nil WeOk\l1HI, 111111 WOnt hnlno 10 his Ihlhor's Iho provlolls nlghl (SnndIlY) liS nSllnl, Whonl
nsk\ld why Iw (lIdl1'l.hlll\ sloop nvor nt his nllllhor's hnllsll, slnoe slw \VIIS bringing hlmlhr Iho
npplllnlnwnl 1110 nllxl Il\nl'l1lnll, Mnllllow ropllod, "1 UIIOSS I didn't think nfll,"
For mnny yonrs Mlluhow hns boon tho Intonnotllllry belwoon his pl\ronls, 1I1stolU\ of Inlklng 10
onoll othor, thoy ooml1l1l11lcnlo throllgh him, "Toll ynur mnthor , "~II nnd "Toll yoill' lillhor , , ," mo
typlon!. 110 noklll1wlodgo(lthnl Ihls hns buon nwkwmd thr him, nlthough ho IHIS booome IIHollln
It,
Mnllhow dlHOIIsso(1 school nllel his snolnlllfo, 110 snltl thnt sohoolls dlmoull,lInd Ihnt ho hnll In
wnrk hnl'd 10 Iloop hlH grndell lip, Tho IIrgl1l11Ul1ls with hili nllhor stross him 0111, IIl1d Inlorlbro with
his IIblllty \0 oonoonll'lllo, To rolllx, he uoos Into hlurnnmlllld IIstonll In music,
Ho hllll mlln)' (\'Ionds III sohonl, nlld lbols oont1donlln hili soolnllllb, 1-10 nlso hnll n glrlO'lond, hilt
Rho III Involvu(lln I11I1I1Y l\ctlvlllos nnd ho doos not got 10 ROO 1101' ns ollon liS hc WOl\ld IIko, Ho
doni os hnvlllg II110d IlIl1rl.lunnll, but ndmlls tn drinking II10ohollll II n'lend's hOllso 111111 lIummOI',
110 told his mothcr IIbuIII this, bllt not his flit her,
I'SYCHOLOCIICAL TEST RESULTS
Conl\'llry to tho UOUChlllllllt del11ellllOr thllt MlIlthow presontod h)lntorvlow, his psyohologlool test
reHults Indlootlld ll1uoh olllotlonlll tl\l'l1loll, He ReemS to hllve 1111 overly serious, posshnlsllo
oUllook on 111'0, He Is drlvon to sueoeO(l, bllt Is IIlso trollbled hy his bellefthlltll hl&h price must
be plIld for success, Mlltthew fccls II trel11endous responsibility In the pl'escnt sltlllltlou,lInd fellI'S
thlll whotevel' hllpflens, he will dlsllppolnt uue of his J1l1l'ents, He seel11a to I'ellol'd decisions I11l1de
todllY 1111 hllvlug slllnlOcllnt And pel'l11l1nent h1lPIIOI, He Is IInxlons lIud 10nely,lInd IClIl's the futlll'e,
Although In the Interview Mlltthew oXJ1l'essed II atl'ong dosll'o to live with his l11othel', Ihe
J1syohologlellllesllng IlIdlcntes Ihllt he docs nol view her liS pl'edlolllble In her mu'tlll'lng. Nor
doos he view his fllthel'lIs cl11011onllUy supporllve, I-IIs I'esponso 10 CIIl'd V ou ho ROl'sollllUh RUIllS
lip his pl'edlolllllenl: "A bridge going OVOI' n Sll'el\ll1 lIud the I'ofleotlonln the Wllter, There lire two
IIIUgntors poking out of tho wlltel' on the sides of this bridge." Thns, even when things look cllll11,
MlIllhew Is eVllI' II10rt 10 dllnger IInd Allooll, lnlhls rospeet he rescmbles his l11othel'.
He resembles his 1I\lhcr In his hloek-lInd-whlte view of tho world, Thlngll lire wondol'l\ll, nt. else
they 111'0 tOl'rible. Rmlollllltlonls hlll'd to come h)l,
MlIllhew foe Is II slrong COll1l11ltment to his 11lInlly, He WlIuts hoth his plll'onls tn be hllppy, In
eontl'URt to whnt he expressed In Iho Interview, the J1syehologlellllesllng I'ofleots consldernhle
lvh,.{II11 I', /lwloll', , ,I'om' H
1Il1lhlvnlolleo nllllllllonvlnu hla 1\'lh"r'9 home, 110 11IIS alrong ,Ionhla nhonl wholhor Ihla la Iho
!'Iuhl (loolslOII, 11I1(1 Ihla Is nul onl)' heOnlla\! ho Inl110lpnl09 hlH lil1llOl"S dlanppolnlnlOlll,
,IIIOII,IIIll\IHnll
MI" ,Inmlann Is Ma, Zehrlnu's hnyf\'lond, Thoy hnvo lIVlld logothol' fhr elghl yonl's, 110 snld Ihnl
Mntthow hnH wnnlollln live wllh tholll fhr n lonllllmo, "It'a n rOI\IU\llhl' him," anld MI', ,Inmlson,
"AI his fnlllOl"s, hla f\lthol' Is wnlehlnll OVOI' him nlllho 111110,"
Mr, ,Inmlson deallrlhed Ms, Zohrlng ns II eoncerned molllOr, AHol' lonvln!! Mr, BlIl'low tho Ilrsl
limo, sho relunlUd hocAUSO of Mntthcw, nol heonuso sho loved her hushnnd, I III seos I11l1eh
nffeollon holween mother IInd son, They hngl\llC1 kiss Whenlhoy greet elll)h othllr 11I1(\ whenlhey
sny gooll.llYo,
Mr, .JAmison Sllld thnl MI', Bnrlow hll(llrled to Inrn Mnllhow lIunlnsl him, hUllhnl Mnllhew hnd
mnde lIP hlH'own.mhlll, One dny Ihe hoy sllld to MI', .Jnmlson, "YoU're not suoh n blld guy nHer
nil," Mr, .J1II11lson slIld IIml he Is plltlenl wilh Mnllhew IInd Ihlll he listens 10 him, unlike Mr,
Bnrlow who Jusl wllnls to oonlrol him,
MI', .Jm11lson Is hlmselfn pl'Oducl ofll dlvorccd flll11l1y, so he knows how hmd Ills 011 n ohlld, lie
hopes 10 provide n wnnn fllmlly hOl11e for Mnllhew, He works the Ilrst shin nt Rcese's, III
vnrlous In\lor Johs, Thus, he would be home when Mnllhew COI11es home from sehool, He
el\loys stnylnu hOllle, workfnglnlhe ynrd nnd piny hIll the Ilullnr, Mnllhew hns oxprossed nn
Inl!lrest In Il.1l1rnlngto piny tho gnllllr,
I did 1I0t ohserve Mntthew together wilh Mr, ,IlImlson, hut they olloh stilted thllt Ihey get II10ng
woll with ono nnothor,
Mr, .Jomluon's MM!'I wos mlllllly wllhln nonnlllllmils, l1utlndlolltod somo Inlorporsonlll
dlmoultles, 1-10 IIppellrs 10 oonform 10 other people's requosts IIl1d oxpeetntlons, hnt ho tonds to
hnrbor rosentmellt nnd Is pl'One to explosive ontbursts of nnllor, ospcolnlly when hc foels roJooled
01' dismissed, 01' when he Is undor stross, l'le Is soolnlly oUlllolng, hUI ho nlso noods tlmo III\1no
Ihr roflootlon, I-Ils moods onn bo unJ1rcdlctllblc,
nOS\! Sohwnl'tz
Ms, Schwl\l'tz hns bcon n frlond of tho fllllll1y fhr IIInllY YOl\l's. Sho ngl'llCd to bc Intorvlewed nt the
rcquost of Mr, Bllrlow, Unlll recently sho hlld been bost IHends with Ms, Zohrlng, Mntthow hns
nlwnys onlled her "Aunt Roso,"ul1d sho nlwnys rognrded him ns n nophew, Ms, Schwnrlz Isn't
cionI' on why Ms, Zehring suddonly cooled lownrd h01', Shc sllld thllt Ms, Zohrlng hml clnhncd
thlll Ms, Sehwnrlz hnll lhi'ontoncd hel',
lV/willi: I', /lur/oll'. , ."IIIN ~
Hlw d\lllorlboll MIIUhow'1I pll1'lll1l11 1111 bnlh vory IIll1bbmn, Hho 111110 1,"I(lllml II\W hllll 110\111 Mlluhow
bohllWIII II cllrll1l.llllllllnvll1l.l wny towllrd hili Hllher, 1II1111hlll hili Hl\llOr III 11011lli 00111rollhll! IIH
Mil. Z\lhrlnu dUllorlboll hll\l,
Mil, S\lhWllrl~ bllYII MIIUhuw 1\10111 of hili ololholl, II IIlnrlulllIlI II rowllrd iiII' hili I1mklnl! honlll' roll
II eOllplu of yUllrll nl!o, lmd IIhu oonllllllod 10 Ink\l hll11 pn IIhopphw Irlpll wllh Iwr oWI\ 1101\, H110
IInld Ilml MnUhuw'lI 1110lher dO\lIlI1'1 blly hll\l clolhell, uvcl1lhnlll!h Ilhe oOllltl IIfford 10 do 110,
Mil, Schwllrli': WIIlIl!tHHIIi'lel\dll Wllh MH, Zehrhw whol\ Iho IIlUor 1Ill0WOll hor 1I0nll 10 I!O 10 IIw
wllh th\llr 1\llhor, "II no-uoncl (lrlmlnlll," Mil. Sohwnrli': hollovclI Ihllt tlw rUllllon Iho oldcIII 1I0l\.Iun
Willi hCClIllllo hu (lonld 1101 Bcl 1I10111! with Mr, .Inl11l 110 1\ , Rhu lill\l'1I thllt I I' MIIUhcw I!OCII 10 IIvu
. with hili l11olhor, he will hnvo dlfllclllly IIvhw with Mr. .Il1mlllol\ nlllll,lI11 hili IWo 011101' brnthorH
did,
Hovlow IIf Doonnlllnls
. Mr. Bllrlow 1\ll'l\llIhed IIl1mplell of Mnuhuw'lI lIellOOlworll, 1111 well 1111 ncndollllc IIchl\lvOlllOlll
IIWl\l'ds 111\(1 hili roporl ollrd from Insl Hohool yonI', HlIIBrndcII woro mOHlly 11\ Iho 90'11, tho 10woIII
Brlldo IIn 86, .
Ms, Zohrll\B brouBht 11\ n pOll I onrd Ihnl Mnllhow hnd writ Ion hor 111111 Docombor frnm Dlsnoy
World, 01\ thlll ollrd ho hnd wrlUol\, "llovo IImlmlllS YOII vory 11l1l0h\ Wo will bll homo Into
TIIOlldIlY," Ho IId(lod II p.II,; "))lId III booomlnB IIl1bclIl'I\hlo," Rho IIlso pl'Ovldod n \loPY 01'11 6-
PIIBo 10Uor Ihllt Mr, Barlow hml wrlllon to hor IlIlIt .Il1nllllry, Tho 10Uor WIIS '1l1lto InOllllJmlllory,
1I00llslnB hor soverlll tlII10S of IIhllndol\ll\B MuUhow, mocklnB hor 111'0 slylo, untl thrclltolllnB hcr
with nolllllowlllB hcr 10 scc MIIUhow 1111111.
INTEIU'll.ETNflONS
AllhollghMIIUhcw SIlYS ho wllnls to IIvc with his mothor, ho Is nol liS solllod In hili deolslon III1.he
IIppCllrs to be. Tho II1l1ln Issuc hero Is the confllot with hili Ihthel', mlhor Ihon II 10ngll\I! for his
mother, As ovldonco of Ihlll, ho I'lIroly cullll hili molhor botweoll vllllts,
Whllo hili mother clolmll sho hllll IIlwuys loved MoUhow und Willits 10 ho purl of hili 111'0, Hho hilS
not demonlllmlcd this In hcr hehovlor. Hcr IlIck of Involvement 111 hili Hcholllllnd IIpol.tll muy
how becn dlle to hor fenrs of MI'. Burlow'lI IInl!er, but II younl! child does not understul\d this,
Anotllllr npporol\t oOl\trmllctlon between whnl Mil, Zchrlng IInYII IInel whnt IIho doell III evldcnllll
hcr Helf'.hnposed work scheelulo. Dul'lng Iho COlll'lIe of'lhlll evnlulltlon Ms. Zehring chllngcel her
wmll hours to second shin, sllch tllIIl IIho III not nvnllllble 10 pick np Mlllthew on Frleloy ovenlngll,
l~llI'llI!I \', /1(//'1(11\'.. .I'il!1~ 10
1\ Is pfconcol'l\ 111111 sho ,lops not IlIkc llllvnnllll!o oflho opporlll11llY to spol\lll11oro limo with hor
son nnw, mtho\, Ihlln wlllllhl' Iho llnloonlO nflho CO\lrt's (Ioclslon nn Iho cllstml)' 11111\101',
^lIholll!h Ms. Zohl'hlll elnll11s lhllt "wo hnvo to \lolllhl' OVOI')' OXll'lImlnlllo wo nsk j~ll'," sho wn\lhl
I)'plenll)' hllve Mlllthow nsk. his I\lIhol' fo\' llxlrn tlmo wllh he 1', I'nthor IIl1\n dOlllhlll wllh Iho
sll\lI\llnn hel'sclf, Ms, zohrlnu's Inok ofllssortlvenoss Is n potontllll pro\lhllll. Slw n1l\)' nol \10
n\lloln IlIf;ollhn\'llo with Mnllhcw whon Ills noeOSSIlI')' In do so.
MI'. Unrlow erlldlls h\l11l1oll'onlh'ol)' fill' Mnlthcw's IIchlovOn1Onts nncl good n1l1l11101'S. While ho
hils elll'tlllnl)' hC1l1l11 sll'onu Intllloneo, he flllls 10 \,coolllllzc othol' p,mple's IntllliJnec In MII\lhow's
lifo, ospoolnll)' Ms. Zohl'lng Iivon Iho\lgh his 11111lhol' Ilf~S nol \Icon II slrong physlclIl prosoncc In
his 1110, sho hilS sorvmllls II k.lnd Ill' ollsls lhl' him, IIrotl'elll whon ho Is illIgI')' wllh his I\I\hol',
MI'. UlIl'IOW \lollows Ihlll Mnlthow oontlnlles 10 no cd stronll discipline In ordol' to contln\le 10
lIehlovo IInd tn sIn)' mil '11' tl'n\lhlo, Ilowovel', MlIlIhow hilS Intel'llllllzed n sll'onllllohlovomonl
mollvll. 1'10 slrlvos \loOII\lSO Ihls Is somothlng ho wllnls 1'01' hhnsolf, It Is no longoI' 11000SSIlI')' (11'11
oVel' WIIS) to leotnr(J hll11nnd hllpoSO high dOl11l1nds lln him, slnco ho IIlrolldy doos 1111\1 Ihl'
hhllsol f.
Novorlholess, IIko most IIdolosconls, ho stllll'cq\llroH n hllslc set ofl'lIles nnd ennsc(l\lonCoH Ihl' his
holll\vlOl', Ills flllher Is 1lInt'1l IIklll)' Ihlln his 1110ther to he oonslstenl In this II1'0n,
MlIlIhow's eX(1ol'lllnceH wilh his molhol' hnve hoon II1l1lnly positive. Of OOIl\'SO, slnco sho Ion his
lllthor, ho hilS nllVCI' sponl1110l'e thlln II cOllplo of dll)'S IIln tlmo with her, 1'10 Is Idcllllzhlll whllt It
WOllld \10 IIko to IIvo pormllnonlly wllh ho\" 110 longs In rcollptlll'O Iho oIose \lond with hol' Ihllt ho
hilS mlssod slnee ho WIIS II smnll child, He hilS Ilrown \1(1 In Iho pel'lphery of his mother's lifo, nml
he Is In Iho proeess oftr)'lng to mllke Ronso of IIlIll.
When Mlltthew Is upsot with his filther, he cOlllplnlns 10 his Illothor. This trlllllers oil! cmotlonlll
relicti OilS within hor, such Ihnt she tends 10 relive hcr OWI111111lcr townnl MI', Bn1'lnw, IIncl 10
beeome ovcrproteetlve of Mntthew, It Is very hllrd fOl' her 10 be ohjeetlve In such II sltlllltlon,
Fllrlhermore, ovcr Ihe )'onl's, MnUhow hns come to bellevc tlml this Is whnt sho wnllts 10 hOllr
fl'Om him.
\loth )lnronts hnvc I11nllgllcd thc olher to Mntthew, He Is ellught In tho mlddl'l, sllch thlll he folll's
showing nil)' t)')le o,fllflollllol1 01' 10)'1111)' 10 one )llll'ent WhOll he Is with Ihe othcr,
Mothllr 1ndJcl1\:llfl thlll'. 1'.11(1 /Jon hilB I nel!. (Jill'.ed tha rlm1!ro to (Jollie l.t.vo
wHh hat', lIe,1' stal:ud nliHjOI\ I:hll\: thfl ald,ld Wi-tnl:H to l1ve w,lth hill'
1B thllt "hr.~ can't OOllllnUn,lci.ILll w.lth hIs fat:lllll'," MQt:hor' l.lVllS wl\:h
hor poyfd,ond .t.n (1 d.l.f,tOI:Ol\t Iwhool dll3t:dot:,
(i, 'l'lm Do fondllllt' ~J [lol:lll:.lon 011 oUlltOlty 113 (ltl t()11()W~11 Ii'other
hi.ll:l beem tho prlllll1l'Y CUtltoCUi,l.1 pnl'Ont of thls nh:l.I,d for. ill'. least
oll)hl: yallrll, 'J'hu [)hl.1.d .t.8 dolng l'In.l..1. In Bohool, hau fr:l.ondr~, i.lnd
f1eemfJ 1'.0 bo woll ad:luBtod, '1'1l01'1) llllvo bO~lIl no Pohavi.ol:'al probloms
frol1\ the f!'ather' H pors[lOot.t.Vll, 110 I'mllllVI1B that. tho t'oquost for a
nwHoh ln OUIltClCly 113 rolatod to the faot that ho onlyrooontly
fHnd [or support from tho Mothor arKI t:llIlt: tho Mother 1ncllooted to
hlm that t3h~) would pur~lue an aot:Jon for custody, '1'11 a Iwn
appal:'antly has now stated that: ho wants to go ltve w1t:h hls Mothor,
[i'a\:her bellovos \:hls Is (Unlt1\:ly ro.l.lltod \:0. Mother' EJ pu\:l:.lng
p.rOS8\1rO on hlm \:0 l'Ian\: \:0 do tllat PUOaUl3ll of tho support lSBIlO,
Also, ~'Il\:hel: ind1\lo\:rlilthat the non hilfl not llkod tho faol: that he
.ts subjocl: to 110100 dlfwlpllrHl tn,m l~al:llBr.
7, Need for uopal:ate counsel 1:0 rllpr:osonl: chl.lctl Ne:l.thal1
party requesl:od,
0, Nood for .1 ndepondont psychologloal oV(11uoti.on or
cO\lllseHng I None rOllullfll:ed and the Conc:LUal:or doos not be.l:l.ova
any .tn necessary.
9. A hOilrl.IH] I.n tills mal:l:or will l:aklJ a full day.
10, Ot 1)(:) 1: mllt:\:OI:~l or 0010111001'.111 'l'h111 .\.13 11 ()fHlB of (;l l~Durtllen
yellt' old who hilll 11Ilon l.i.v,lng wHh 1\.\11 l"at:hlll' [Of' ovor 11 YO/II:, 'I'he
fourteen YfJilr old a[l[l13ars 1:0 b[1 do!.n'.) vory W(3,11 !.n I:lohool and
othorw1so, ^ooorcHng to Mo\:llllt', wHhln tho lilst f.UI'I lIIont:hs, ho has
silld that ho want:u to COm() l.lve with h.1.1l I~(lt.hor and t:he only reason
is that "ho oan't: oommunloato with hls father,"
The oono111ator suggestecl 1:0 tho p~.r.tieA that they
In,,olvo a psyohologist: to bll a th!.rd (lilrty to f'ind out what 18
reallY going on w1th t:he son, J.f anythlng, to determine who\:hor or
not he has really atated a c1oairo to l1\ove from the Father's house
1nto the Mol:her's house iwd what: .1.13 the basis for that movement.
Father was ilgreEli1blll 1:0 have the pSYlJho!O\l.1.sl: .\.nvo!vud, but Mother
WI'lS adamant that no [.lsyoholog:l.st be involvecl. Bhe stated qu.l.t:e
flrl1\ly that she wantod a Court hear.1.ng,
Clearly/ the Court wU.l havll to del:8rmine firs\: why a
modHicat.lon of tho eXlst:lng Cl1sl:odlal l1choaule nhould occur, The
ch1ld has boen dolngquite woll wlth tho Father and thero really
doell not SllfJl1\ to be a basis for the child to move to the Mother's
house. 'I'ho Mother has only soon the oh.U.d on an altornaUng
weekend bl1s.ls over the last eIght or l1\orfJ yean~. 'rho Court wl11
have to F.Icl.'ut1.rd.za very oaroful.ly the chIld's statomenl: .I.f: he, in
fact, doos Indlcate a preforonc13 to I1\OVO nOl1 frolll 1"ather'l3
l:esJdence to ~1l)lher' 8, '1'ho Court wU.1 hnve to look t:o sell whel:hor
I.YNNH M, Zl\IlHINCI.
I'IIIlnUI'I'
VH,
: IN TilE COlJRT of COMMoN I'LI-:AI,
: ClJMBIiHl.ANp COIINTY, I'liNNsYLV AN1A
,
, .
: NO, I)\)_ II 'j); I( t((,,/
,
IIRIAN lvi, 11M! .OW,
Dolcndnl11
: cIVil. ACTIoN -I.AW
: CIJHTC1DY
Willlili.(!F COl lit[
AND NOW,npol1 oonHldcl'lItlon orllw IIl1l1chud Complnlnt, It IH hOl'oh)' llhwtod thllt tho
plll'lloH IIIl1I tholl' I'cHpootlve cOlll1Hol I1pponl' hol\1l'o _V!1J~Jl[irL~.~I'lf!L.. tho Cnl1cllllltol'. ol1lho
~'11. dn)' or ..._L\PLL\___...., I \)1)1) III ..':,UJ.L.p,m. nt --2.o::L,.s.L..UijA-.S/~c?, ftJf-1ft1;
----____._. P0I1I1H)'11'1II1In, Ibl' n Pl'o-llonl'll1!! cnHlod)' Confol'ol1co, At Hnch COl1lol'ol1co,
nil 01'1\11'1 will ho mndo to l'uHolvo tho ISHnuH 111 dlHPlltu; 01' II' this Cnl1l1ot ho noennlp\lHhod, tll
dol1no IInd 11111'l'OW tho ISHllos 10 ho honi'd h)' tho Coul'I, nml In 011101' Inlo n Tompol'lll')' Ol'dol', All
ohlldl'oll IIgo 111'001' oldol' mny nt tho l'uljnuHI orolthol' IItlOI'llO)' 01' plll'l)', ho pl'OHcllt nt tho
uonfol'ollcu, Fnll\ll'll to nppulII' nt thu Conlol'ul1\~o nH\)' pl'ol'ldu !!l'ollndH !ill' tho onll')' of n
tumpol'lIl')' nl' punnnnul11 Ol'dol',
ThL\, l'1'()lhol1ollll')' Hhlllll101 Hond notluu 10 thu Dolcndnnl 111 nceol'dnnco with Loenl Rille
206-6,IIH HOl'I'IolJ Hhnll he cflceted UpOI1 the Dufondnnl hy counsul nl!' PlnlnlitT,
1"01' Ihe COlll'l.
Dnte Or()l'd\II':_2'-IOj~L.._ By:_ .-;1I1~~(t<Ld'-.~1'2~~.
CUslody Cuudllntol' 1~1
YOU SllOlJLD TAKE TIllS PAPER TO YOUR LA WYER AT ONCE, IF YOU DO
NOT IlA VE A LA WYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, 00 TO OR TELEP1IONE TilE
OFFICE SET FORTH BEI.OW TO FIND OUI' WIIERE YOU CAN OET UiOAL I IELP,
COURT ADMINISTRATOI{
ClJMBERI.AND COUNTY COURTIIOlJHE,4th FLOOR
I COURTHOUSE SQUARE
CARI.ISLE, l'ENNHYLV ANIA 1701J ~3H7
(717) 240-6200
".
L~,
"
",I:,
rIH'i', :1::
!",' '-l,
(,';1
./. \ ('1
h:l.. I
i:.:'\.,' r.:
t,1;
I - .....
II, (./\
() (PI
j' l~
..
""
:~.I. r
I). .'
If,
. I
'I,j
,: ';ll
1,'--,:
,I. ....
1'1(1.}
t,',!Cl,
~"l
t.)
~
,~\
i~, ~~~~ '~.
\\l'\
'I .\,~ .
...... J "
,~,\ '\
V) ~ ~,J
\ '\' V)
~ V) ~
" ......
f;l ~
.... r'
~ r-..
:'\\:. t~
~,
'~''''
~
e i... 4-1 IJ 1>1 I ~
4., ~ [3
III TJ III [-I
~ lJ) WI
~ L ,~ 'H B ~ ~ ;' ,
~ ~ ~ .-1 CU rr.
III f:} 0 ~l~ ~
, , f4
tl ~ .-1 l!l ~
[) . I ~ ~ ~ J i
~8~ I
I> ""
~~ rtl ~
, J
, :i1 0
. o<iIl-l :El tl
~ ~ El ~ ~
' Il !q
,--1
d
I; j,
.
MAl? " 5 1999
\:!
, .
~~ 'I-! -I-' ~
4~ ~1 ~
,~ ;~ 'rl
lJ '0 I I
,~ m ~
Rl 4-1
rl QI ;-~
~ ~ ~ ~ Il. A
, Il.
(j) un
~ ,
-101 ~ r..
u 0
mU~ pl
~ u ~ E I :.1l ~
... rn ~
~ ~ I ~ ~ al , ffi J ~
III
I SO ~ ~ m
, fiJ
o -IS ~
!ill U ,l
"
~I
.
, ,
JUL 2\ ,~n9
~
15 ~ "H
'1-1 ~J
~ 41 ~
8.:- ~ ,m '0
[j~ ,..1 ~i
"" (.\1 'I-I' ~ ~di
l!l I ~~ 0
0 m ,-)
~U~ . ;0 Vol ~
'<I' Ul 0
~ ~ l'j CO I> ,-] Ul .
.-- ~I fllll1 fll ~ ! II
u~~ .-- r,10 ,
I rLl 1':0' r "ci
f~~ f" l~ "~j
'" d "I
'" . I-I ...
:tl It: ;'-1}
~~~ . ~ ~ I-I ~ ., ~I
(\,
0 fll -. [;
III Z lei ~
.
.. , '
J U L 2 G 1999
, '
J.'fNNm M, ~,1!HIlUNO!
Pln.lnI:1J:f
IN '1'111" COUR'l' aI!' COMMON PI,I"l\S Ol!"
ClIMBlUlU,l\ND COllN'l'Y, I.'1!:NNSYINl\NII\
v,
BRIAN M, Bl\RLOW,
Do J'ondnn I:
00-1104 CIVIL ~IURM
Q!~P1!liLQF COllET
AND NOW, th.l.~ 6th d<lY of l\Ugllut, 100D, \:111s hear.l.ng
is contlnued ~o the [1artloB m<lY undorgo a custody oV<lluatlon
w.l.th II competent [1aycho10g1st to he I\grood upon hy the parties,
If tho Pi\rt.l.eu cannol: il\Jl:oo upon tho psychologlot or
psyohlatrlal'. to u~o, tho Court wi.ll entor an ordel' at the
roqUOBt qf o.l.thor party appo.t.ntlng 1\1'1 oxport, The co~ts of
evaluatlon to be sharod equally hy tho [1llrtlos,
Pond1ng further hearlng .t.n thll3 I1\lltter, prlmllry
physloal oustocly shllll contlnue .t.n father sub:lect to perlocls of
pllrt.t.al oustocly wlth mother as the partles shllll I\greo, It:\.s
.the Court I s del'll ro tho t Ma I: thaw shall sponcl as muoh t.t.me w.i.t:h
mother as posalblel bUI: 11'1 no event shall I:he v.t.s.t.tatlon be
less than two weekends on and one weekend off, sald oyole to be
repoated untll I:ho next hearlng,
Nelther parent is to c1.t.l3ouss th.t.s oase wlth Matthew
or wlt.h eaoh other oxcopt In the praaenoe of tho pBychologlst
ogreed to by oounsel and appo.t.ntod by tho Court, Neither party
i.a to USI) any .l.110gal drllgll In tho home or Ilroltnd Matthew,
Nolther party 113 to dloparago the other party .t.n front of
Matthew, Th.t.s Court w111 Bchoclulo nnothor honrlng at tho
roquest of any pllrty,
By tho Court,
WI1HIHiAH, Ihu plll'lIUII hllvv rUlIlllwd 1II1 hllurhll II 1l1'VU1l1O III 1I11c1 ll10rulhru dUHlru 10 hllVll
HlllllU IlIcorp\ll'lIlucI IIH 1111 Orcl\ll' 01'<'0111'\,
NOW, Tlllm IWOltli, thu PlIl'lluH hUI'U\OIlHltlllll\y 1I111'\iU IIllcl Hllp\IIIIIU IIH l'nIlOIl'H:
I. Tlw plIl'lluH HI 11\ 1\ Hhlll'U IUIWI uIIH\OII)' Ill' thu \lhl\cI IIH \lullllucI hy 23 PII. (-'.H,A.
~5301l!11lllll,
2, )llIlhul', 111'11111 M. 11111'1011', Hhllll hu ullllllmllo pl'll1l1ll')' ph)'HlulIl UlIHlocly nf MII\Ihllll'
Ii, lIul'lolI',
3, Molhlll', I,Ylll1o M, Z\lhl'lnll, shull hu ulltl\\ml to pU1'111l1 ellstocly of thu millOI' child
IIH 1'nllowH:
(II) ^ItUl'Illlto WUUI;UllclH from Fl'ldu)' III (l:OO p.llJ, unlll HumlllY III 6:00 P,I\1,
I-IoWUVCl', Hhould Mothul' hu WOl'klllll sueolHl Hhln, thu weukullIltlllJuH shull hu nOI\1 H\ltunluy III
9:001l,1lJ, unlll H\l\1duy ut 6:00 P,I11,
,
(h) ^ltul'Ilulu hollclllYH of'l\lIstUI', MUll10rlul fluy, Fourth of July, I.lIhol' ))IIY,
ThllllkHlllvlnllllnd Null' Yuur'H \)IIY, Ihlllll):OOU,I\1, ulIllI 7:00 P,I11,
(e) ChrlHtnlllH EVIl untlllJ:OO p.m. und Ihlln C'hrlslnHIH cluy ul 6:0.0 p,m, 11lJ11I
,lI\1111111'Y 2, III 6:00 p.llJ, "
(d) Flllhur Hhull hu untitled In I)UHtody on Fulhul"s DIlY IIlld Mn!hul' HI1I\1I hu
enllllud In ellHlody on Mothul"H Duy, the IlmuH hulll!! Ihlllll):OO U,IlJ, unlll 7:00 P,IlJ., or us U!!l'eud
hy Ihu PlIl'lloH, l'eglll'dluHS of whut Ihe weekend SI)I1Odulu IlJU)' nlhel'wlHll provide,
(0) The pu\'ell! wholH In ho I'euelvlng the ehlld shull he l'eSpOIlHlhle IIII' providing
Il'lInHpol'tutlon,
4. Mother shull he entitled 10 l'nm (4) ll'UekH HlIl11llJel' vueUllnn, ulld Hhllll provide
Ilotlee 10 Fulhe\' hy Muy 1,2000 ot'the Hpecll1e Il'\'ekH, Ilowel'el', If Mlltlhew IH II'l1I'klllglhe
pu\'lIeH I'euognl~e Ihullt muy Ilot hu pnsHlhlu 1'01' Mothc\' to cXCl'clsu ulll'nu\' (4) wueks of Slllllmel'
cuslody,
.
5, The hlllllll\)' lIuhu(ll\le IInlllhu lIuhull\llu Ihl' Mo\llUr'lI 1)1\)' lIull F/llhul"lIlJl\)' IIh/lll
pro I'll II nI'UI' lllllOr IlmulI j1l'\ll'hlod Ihr 1'IIIIIIIIIonll11d 01111111I1)',
(1, The pllrllulIlIgree th/llnoilhul' wlllnllll~o hili or Iwr rluhtll wilh r(llIpuoltll\ll\ll11lnI11'
uhlld 11111111'I11111 /lnll Intel'l'ero wllh Iho olher pllrt)',ll\ohl(lIl1g tho 1I0hodlllhw ol'l'llIlllItllln
IIITl1l1UOlllOlIllI, The p/lrlloll 1'1\1'11101' /lUIW Ihlll thoy \\'1111\01 hlll'/llIlIor 111/111gn olluh olhur In tho prclI"
UIlUO or tho 11111101' ohllll, 1111 holh pllrIlOlll'llCO!lIlI~.u \1111\ lI\1uh Olllld\lotlll dotrlll1\lnt/lllolho hOllt
Illlorolllllllllll 11'011\11'0 or the ohlld.
7, li/leh pllrl)' Iwkllowludgellllmt tho Htlp\lllltlollllllillr Illld o'l\llIllhlo, Ihllllt III holng
olllorod IlItol'ohnlllll'il)'. Ilnll thntlt IlInnllho rOlllllt or 1111)' 11111'0111101' \11111\10 Illflllol\ce, Thill
Hllplll/ltllllllllHllt1l leg/ll encol h/ll'o heoll 1\111)' oXlll/llllolI 10 Mothor h)' hOI'log/l1 00/1111101, MAX .1.
HMITlI, .IRq Hllljlllre.lllld to F/lthor h)' hllllog/ll 00\1111101. At JHTIN F, cllmOAN, 1\11'11111'0,
II, Tho p/lrlloll wlllllook tho /111111111/11100 or lhlllllnuor/lhlo COlll'l11l rOllol\'lng /In)'
dlflcrol)oo whloh 11111)' /lrlllO, 111111 whldl IIIf1crol1colI 0llnll111 he 11l1\Iollhly 1'011011'011. uonool'l1lng .
ullllllllly 11ll11lerll horoll),
9. F/llhor /lnd Molhol' Ilgroe thlllll CII\II'I Order onelll1lplllIlIl/lg Ihl) prll\'11I11I1)1I herein
lIet fbrlh IIhllll he entered hy the COllrt ol'Collll1lllnl'lell1l ol'Cnlllherlllnll COlln\y, 1'(1)1)1I)'I\'lInlll. .
IN WITNHHS WIIEREOF, tho I'llrtlell herelo, Inlolllllng to he lounll)' hOlll)d herehy, IIf1lx
lhelr hllllllll IInd 11011111 helow, tho dill' IIncl )'ellr Iil'lIt Ilhllvc \\,rlllel),
---r!l;({ySalJ2Q.____.
WITNEHS //
.... C .'
j~~Z~i~7_l~~;ti,(;J{f-~..-.....h..-
~.{~ J a .
WI'I'Nii~H---flO--h.,
h_;2J&'Lh.__tM_':9:-)~
BRIAN M, BARLOW