Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout99-01191 LAW (ll'FICns OF 1.liSLlE DAVID JACQBSON III fill PIlIIIlY fiTIlllWl' filJITIl^ 11^l\lllfilllJIICl.I'^ 17111.fi261l ....,p. C I': ,'.) ',- 1:'1"'_\ ,.-" ...'h "'" ,_. -'~ 33'1\^ II .. iJ'1 . ", '. I ,III I ", 1'1111 " . ...."'. ' " '~~".~'t, '",1I1111ll/IIIIIIIII,IIIIIIII' Rohur! L, O'Brlun, llRlJ, O'Brien, Durio & Seherur 17 WUR! South Street CnrllRlu, PA 17013 '. II '" \70\ ;o,-:~432 03 '1,.,111",/11,"""111/1,,111",",111111111,1,11111,,,/111'" .-, RONA~P W, NIK~AU~, P,M,P./ ~Aap./ ana MARY NIKtAU~, Pldnt:ifflll v, IN 'l'UIll OOURT 0l1' oOMMOIi' P~IIlA~ OV' O~'BIIlR~~n COUNTY, PIllI'l'l'l'~YHV~Ii'IA OA~1ll 1i'0. 99-1191 OIVIH OIVI~ AOTIOIi' - I,AW mRliIAIUlIT FINNlIlUAIi, DltfltnQI\ll1: QQM~~ ANP NOW, aomea Pldnl:Hfl'l, HOnAld W, N.i.ltll'lua, n,M,p, MI\ClD, Ell1c\ Mm:y l'Iil\lAua (hereinflf\:er referred to rla II PlaintHfs II), by and t:hrough their Counael, Law Offioea of CrAig A, Diehl, and file t:hia Complaint, rel'lpeatfully stating in aupport thereof I 1.. P1Ed.nt:Hf/ol arB adt\lt .i.nd.i.vidIlAl.s with a business ac\dress of 3466 Trindle Hoad, CAmp Hill, Cumberland County, Pennl'lylvania 17011-4467, , 2, PefendElllt, .MArgaret [i'inl1egan, .i.s an fldult individual with a residential Address of 526 mnola Hoad, Apt, 1, West l~airv.i.ew, Cwnber1and County, Pennnylvflnia 17065, 3, Plaintiff, Dr, Honald W, l'Iiltlaus, D.M,D" is in the business of treating pal:ients fOJ: anoring and sleep apnea, 1%1 and orafaoial pRin, 4, On or nbollt May 12, 1990, Defendant;, Mal:gHl'et l~innegHn (hereinafter referred to as II Defet1dant.II ), prosented herself to Plaint.iff, Honald W, Niltlaus, D.M,D., for a diagnostio appointment regarding 'I'MJ problems, 5, It is Plaintiffs' offioe polioy to reqllire patienta to PAY /:m:.o/:t:i.OfJ viuit(l /II: I:ho I:ima of Pf\ml~, 6, Whul1 Dol:olll\lInl: Wi\fl r.lll/\miIlUd by Plul.nt.1f:l: on M/lY 12, 1.9911, u\le rUd Ilot PAY I:OL" her 01:1'.100 v.1nH / bll\: I.nrHon\:rlll tlH\t ahe WOlllc\ PRY {:Ol: it III: tho t:lmo 01: hur noxt: vJ.uJ.l:, 7, A\: l:hB \:i.I\IB of DBfenrj,mt'f.l Illwolld VJ.u.i.t:, f~hB PIIJ.Q 'l'\~O HnndrBQ [i'ort:y ~nQ 00/100 ($240,00) Dolluro townrc1a l:hB diagnostic ff,lB of 'l'hree IJundred l~U:l:y-S:l.x Elnc\ 00/100 (~~366, 00) DoJ.llu'a, leuving ~ bulanc.f,l due ~l: I:h~t: l:ill1e of One lJunc1rerl Si>\t:een ~nrl 00/100 ($1:1.6,00), 0, At the time of Defendllnt's second v.1Bit, ahe s.1gl1ec1 ~ l~J.nancd.a1. Agreement for a l:hree (3) 1I10nl:h t reatmenl: period l:anging f;l:om One 'l'hOlIl3~nd 'l'hree Hundred l~orl:y I\nd 00/100 ($1,340,00) Dollars 1:0 One 'l'houaand l~ive Hlmdred Sixl:y ilnd 00/100 (f,n,560,OO) Dollars, with a provision thereln indioating that she was not to pay 1110re. I:han 'l'hree Hundred and 00/100 ($300,00) Dollal-s per month after tho three lI10nth period was oompletecl. A true and oor.reot oopy of aaid Agreement is attaohed hereto aa Exhlbit "A" and ia inoorporClted herein aa J.f fully sel: forth, 9, Plaintiffs did not: charge Defendant any finClnoe ohurges " purauant to the terms of the l~in~noif\l Agreement executed by Defendant, 10, Defendant was treated by Plaintiff from May, 1990, through Septell,ber, 1990, wJ.th the total treatment. fee beJ.ng One 'l'housand l'IJ.ne Hundred Sixty-Six and 00/100 ($1,966,00) Dollar.s, '" 11, Defendant made paymenta towards her treatment fee totaling One 1'houaand One Hundred Sixty-l~our and 00/100 ($1 / 16~. 00) Dollars, thereby leaving a bRlanoe of m.i.Slht lIundl:ed 1'wo and 00/100 ($fl02,OO) Dollnru (luo on .I:he t:L'llnt:l\\ont /:00. 12, 'I'hu pnYl\\Ontfl llufolltlnlll: mUd(l W(~l:(~ r\ur:l.nlJ t:ho l\\ollt:lw 0/: \TlIne, July F.lnri Septembllr, 1090, 1.3, Dul:endalll: l\\adf~ no furthor pnyment:fJ on her nCJoo\lnt 1:01' her Olltatand.1ng d:l.ngnout:I.CJ fee bnlal1CJe I1l1d/or treatment feu balol1oe, :i.4, 'I'hu rJontraot between the pnrl:.l.e/ol Wf~a negotintor.! and exeCJ\lted ill cumberlnnd Count:y, PennaylvnllJ.1I / Elnd J.n Donai-derntion of Plnintiffs' treat:mont of PefendElnt:, Defendant: agreerl to pay Pla.l.ntHfa aertain sUma <la doa.i.gnat:ed :In the l~inaIlD:l.EI1. Agreement:. 15, 'l'he tot:al aum rel11E\J.n:l.ng due and owing I:rom Defel1r.1ant to l'la:l.nt.i.ff ia l'Iine Ilunc:1n~d Iilighteen and 00/100 ($910,00) Do11E11:S, 16, Despite Plaint:l.ffs/ demElnda, Defendant haa fa:l.lec:1 Elnd/or refused to pay t:he outatanding suma due 01' any part thereof, to Plaint.1ff for Defendant's diagnosis and tl'eatment, 17, By reElaon of Defendant's oonduot in fa:l.ling and refusing to comply with the terms 0/: the l~inmlCJial Agreement between the pl\rt.i.es, Defendant. hRs br('.ll\ohed the Agreement. between the part.iea thereby ol\ua:l.ng damage 1:0 PlAintiffa, ;1. 10, 'l'he l~inanoial Agreement: between the pardea :l.s a valid and enforoeable oontraot between the. parties, 19, Plaintiffs hElve fully performed all of the:l.r obligations dea:l.gnElted by the terms 01: the Agreement between the plu'tiea and therefore, have performed I\ny and all oondit.ions preoedent, if any to Defendants to perform, 21, 'I'he Agreement: aa exeouted by tho parties 13peoifioRlly Elddressea the Infll1l1er and amount of payment to be made by Defendnnt to Plaint.i.ffs, 22, 'l'he lI91:eemfJnt lliUl not baen aJI:el'un or modHied in Any respeot whatsoever, ;<l3, DuJ:anr\un\: mal:r'll:i.II11y brellohod tlw 1:\l1:ms oJ: tho I\Greament when she fa:l1ecl to mi~ke PHYments \:0 Plui.ntH 1:1'1 pursuant \:0 \:he t:el:lllS oJ: I:he AGreement:. between the pllrt ies, 21, By rf3ason 0/: Del:andant's breHoh, I)efendunl: beoame /.I11c1 is Hable to pay to Plldnt.l..ffs clam/.lges pursuant t:/;J the terms of: the rinana.1al Agreement between the parties, 25, Therefore, PlaintifJ:s lire enti.tled to recover from lJefendoml: damagell i.n thi.1I /.Iotio11 equal to the sum due from pla:l.nt::l.ff as oons.i.derat:l.on of the l\gl.'eement, which is Ejqual to l'Ii.ne Hundred ruighteen and 00/100 ($910,00) Dollars, plus oosts of this aot.icm. WHmlm[i'ORill, P1a:l.nt:l.ffiJ, Honald W, l'Ii.k1aus D,M,D" MI\GD, and Mary l'Iiltlaua, respectfl\lly request that this Honorable Court enter' judgment. for Plaintiffs /.Ind against Defendant, awarding plai.ntiffa dillllages for the aum of l'I:t.ne Hllndrf3d lilightf3en and 00/100 ($91.0,00) Dollars, oosts and expenses of this legal aotion, and suqh other relief /.IS thia Court deems just and proper, Hespeatfully subm.1tted, 1,IIW O!~l~lCIilS or CHl\ICl 1\, DImIIL , Date I J1...,.~ /, ~ " lii'L By I C..., (1, I1dJ.. crAi~ll, ~aqnire Attorney I,D, No. 52001 3464 'l'rindle Hoad Camp Hill, PA 17011 ('71.7) 763-7613 Attorney for Plaintiffs ....... '," P' II: I. ff .' , (\, , ., W' , " Ii'. .,.... ,. ,.. jl II." I I I I. :(' ~,'I IP '" 1'111. (".1 " 1'1 /',; ;I.j L', t.,' 'fll, I..: .J__; t'~ ~) ('\ tn ..1 , . ~ ~ . ~ I i I ~ ~! [ I ~ [ ~ ~ ~ ~. ~. ~ ~ ~ ~ ; ~ [ ,. IIV" :\lrlll/llhl . ,,," ."..i"." ,."" ,... . . ,l; ===r:\? -- , -- - -- - OJ { i, I' !) ~ ~ . . . .'. ., '. . I]?-~:~~L--~-~~:L' ~~~----~--- -~~~~~-~-----~ ~-~--~----- ~~-~~~~i--~--7-~----------- ~-I+-----------~~---------- ~ .,, 8 ~ ~ ,':" ". . ~il~- ~ -~-----~--~~--------- 11.0R ~,~~~~ '. . I,;. . .. I" .:::::~~ ' . " ,I . . ~- -~-~~-~~--~-r~-------~-- 5 u~ II ' ..... '" '. ~BI ------- \ u .~.tl (J)- Q\ QI ~8 d z H - aJ ~, ffi lilli" -r.: ll~~ ~ ., ~ .n , B~ IX: Ii \~ C.!l r~ or.:( -' 1!~ or.:( u l{J \" ~ U, ffi~1 :z l1: ~~ c( ~ Z I o~ m~ III I, 0 ~ [ I: ,2.! :s .- II, I~ , ~ I " g 11 'll!1 ~ B ~5 . , ~. ~ i ~ ~ ~g ~~B~ . ~ ~) l~' ~ I i ~ ~ l ~ ~' 1l{J U i!il! ~J ~, " .., DJ ,,[1 " "I ~ " ~.. - . 11I11I11I11I III III III VI ~ , "'~ ~~ ~ ..,~:G~ ': I I:: ., .... ".c:'t:I~ 'J ' .J.' ,0'0 (U.Q A'.fJ "BL . , : I I ~!. h '~R ]:ftL, M ~ ~ 11 ~;i~~ ,; ~ - n ~ 1 ~~ ~ll~ - 0 ~ll;a~ j, rr15~ ~ , fu !, 1 ~ [ ,!fl' t\1'Il~..... ~ tl f.lll 11~1J'~ ... .:: " - "~~ 1 f\ I~~ (}\ ,~lfi I~ 1M ~ ~I ~ N ~ . n ~" fl Ii ('I iii ~ a - c7 ' OJ. 3" II': r:l 1 g I l'J !! " (~ ,~ I En. i _ ~ ,Il 1l.tJ IQJ ~ m ~ ~ \ ffl ~ ~,~ 1:: _' ~. 1, iii ,,- ft H"1;' g -Ilr.J F'~ <<U '.!!I-:.~IU'm.' ~ d' L~ I ~~u hI lY'pJ 1~,ngD\~~ ~ ~ gi: ~ ~~m~l ~ ~: I I: .II ~ !l' . N ad u~ J>,",,, .. \ - ~ 'g jj '..' .a, II i ~ '" hI.L'l ~ Ii,g> .'J ffi " . ~~ & .- ~:>, '1 Ul t; '!'J ~ r. li,n I~" 'm;Z ~ Nfl ~ ~ lo;~~"~u~t~~~m ~~,~~ ll~n~~,_ ]~ ",,1] ~.l'l'rJt1g ~ ,5... Iii ~ u urn ~f ail-lli'fl f1j ~ ~ ,- n=B if I -~.... :l; EO . L 1! 'If Ii ~ E \1~ 'l1 0 III ~ ] ~ B ~ ~ ~ ~ (IU AD l g,\ ~.Ij 18. :r4!.l~ i i.j. ~l B' ,~'r.:ot3't1'" << 'O~1XUll~!:l GlII\!!g tl' B"'Ia,~ 'i.1 5 t;, lil':;~!:'iil~ !i'ir]Jiii!f!.~$Jl lil '0 E '_.13.513.Jo." ~ 'tU~ 8 tl ~ ~ .. ~~ I~~ ~gi ll~ :~~:l ~~ ~il~~t,"'J'O In";' :;: ,..: N M -f III .d": al crl ,6 ''0 ~'t) ~ ,~n .f.i tl'N 1. ~ ~ ~, I.j B 'm ~ ~ 'l!~ l.t \~J'l. 0 i .. 1_ c.!:; 0' 43 al 13 I. I~ ' .!:! ,\:, B g~n (l'~ 1ilU iii >< 8 , . J --_...---- '\'\1 ". ~.., t.. t:: t;!" r;) .. :J.-r - I, llij ~I.'i l.~f: r,) ~.~ t.i~ o. n::j' ,.._.J;", \'11 ::1'(0 ~\~; , "1 rl:'!~, ~ hT! llJl r...: ~. es ~R ". ,I' , .' " ., " ,. d' I ;r " . , Ro,;n,.trt U!. nll~,H419J, :'/),3, , , , fir , \"., , " , , , , 1'~'U~ll'll 'tl/l~Il>-,fl.4~r.4"1~' )1,<.t"~..v, . . , , , DII~'1l - . , . ,;t, " ~ I '. i , ,'14,~ B~GG'tr~IIld/~ flL,~4 .:~ ~n~r Ef~tU, fP41\M~t.!al\l" 17Q11 .r'1/9191!. -- . 1. ,- '(m) m.ml "i 'II 'I '.:,' ,. , '~'UMPOi\d~I"ND~nULAn JOXN1' INJI,ORMA'I'ION ' . " '( " ,". ......i.. ,.. .., ..... .. i...lv' I. "1." "'1'."" I, '.,...~ It... ~".". '" '" ,,,,,.,, '''p'. j.v "''''''''''. v,Lbh vlll I""V' ..' l.I,I. ........, ,., .... "'''''' .....,. 'h ...... .. "h', .:, ' " . " ' \, , ;, " .....II."." · ...,... j.. " l" ".....""1" II" '!P." ,,' ..",~ ..." "'''''''h'. .. .... .m...,., ..... 'h. ".' .. ....h..',...... ' tQ~~ or ~Oh~al WroatMont 18 ~O.Pti.ou tO~Q'to~. to.aint_in tho ' ...,1... " "",, "It..... hi", .,". '"'' ." · "..... ., ,.".. .... tO~"ito~ VAti~q with o_~h in4iYi~"_1'an~ io not inolQdod in ~D"t tI;OU,tmont, Xt Addl'tlon_llJ_lIO',h IIO\lOUG_li~, X Will to.O,Onlll\On!\ 'the allpl/Opl;'ia~o' lIot'Vioau td,lioWIllV':.'out" til!o~'op~. , ' " ., , , ' ,: " ' "" , · ....... ,... ,..,... I. "'h.,.,.. .. I. ""1.", .. ""'~II' I,. . ~,........ ,..", ..,....., """.b.l.l ......,.., ""~""hl, "~ I ..h.' .,.., ,.".. .. ',,".. ".'.".... '''' "V..,.." .. ., .. ~L.. . ''''h' .., "'"1''' I. \ '''''.'' , . /.l /'oJ .', ..&::-'~ _, .h.... """'; bo n,oo~lat~ bo~oll~ tho allticipatod ,.onbhu,odditionol 00110 will be . ;"V"I' .. 'I' IIV......" ., 10' M', "'h" f. '"..._ ,.. ""'h, .,\ '. J, " , " 'hi. .... '1""" 'h. """"""""h...,.. ...,.,..... ., >h. l.. \ t'ohtiol1qh~),l,mU8'01.0 t:~'\lOI:.OI1Il whioh mAY !n'VQ1Vo 8'po'0Ial OXol/olue ,e1oo'l:\'o'. "'''''' '. """".., ..,'....", 'h..." ,..... h", '''''," "'"'' ,.,.... ,. "j"'~\"" """"'''' '....".."", i.........".. ""'''''' ". 'Id ...... . ",. . t:Oq'tnv~ ,,~.NIS..bt'oI1Uo"banoo"u olool:rio seimulll~ion mil:.' be usod, . ' , , , , " , " ' " \'opr'9UstO\l\' ol'dillllqo iu tiMo OOI,ISUlUillV to 'tobi'!ool:e" :tf H is lOll: Ol;' ,.....,., I. ~""""'" 'h.,. 'h. '." ., "'V""., .,. ..,......". I 'h'.h',,, , t<r", (,,,,, 'h".)" \ O~I lorm. WOB,'f ~9"f .'~.I f "h .f thou t prof"'jl . gu 1 d."".. "." b,' d "Hm'hlo I ,WolI I '01, fl, H'.. '''!'VI tf'" II "",-d. 'or., ":;, .tI .,... .. ..no .", ......... ..,.... .. ,... .h,.... 'I', "h.. ....... " h,.i'h ,......1..... .. ,........ """" ., .. ....... .., """"'1 I".... II." I"" ,,,. """',, .. """', "" '......I", L. ..~"... "'l~l . "" ........ I. "" "......., ... .,. ".1" I""",.... .....01.,.,.. , ,your Pl'oblo~ ill bO\lohtll\1Uib\I~b1clll 'Ol.' l>Upl~ollG'lonu, \'o'u~' sillnabure " li'lIl1itiul YOUl' \\l\do'tutlllidillll, IIlld '),lolauh"l'ol1 Il.U l.'uqUh'od. '. ' . 'I' f. ~hlll1~ YOU tot ~O"l/ Qoo~hl;'llbio~, . "j, . , " - , , , X ho~'ob~ Ilul:hod~u 'tho, I.'ololluo lIlo to boo tot ,l\ofIOld ~I' llikhuu UlIma as I:ho o~'illil1a~" , 6'"- '),,1-'18 -- . bl'i'.l'll , ot 1I11~"OI\l\ 1111 (P"ll. 'a,.). II' , jll. ll1Od!oolil1tOl.'IUOl:iol\ about: Y ot I:ho rolu080. iI tho " , ".d, ' . , """ (./ ~~. ....::"-c: I~ rlU~~NJ.!LA.!:!.~!-'T!~"t~YlV. fill! 11\.... .... m".m,".. '"_ emlJlIl or e:m,1MoN PI."AH NO'IIC~ Of' AI'I'r:AI. IIHlM .IIJPIIJI^I. P'HlIIlI'T PISTnIPT ,IUIlTIOI: ,IUI)(lM/;NT ~/'v'L ..... .....1...__.__ '19 -//91 r:OfylMON f'l.hW Nil NoTIO/; Of AI'I'I'AI. Nnll{;o 1\ UiVtlll thulllHl Ilppullunllws lilud 11\ lhlt ilhnvtJ Cmltl of COI1l11WIl PI\ldS Iltl Hppunlllon,llhu IlHIWlIunt 1I1I1IIUIIIII hy Illu nhllhl1 Jlluh:o UIl UlI! IllltllUllclIII llll! cmu IHulltilllllJll hlllow. ' 'tj"J,,~-(il' Iir,..-~t.Mf1-. Nh\lOhl\WI' IIlNN1WhN 'Ailll'tfirf.-il~ ~i'~.P;^HT" -... .-. ..__u_ . i:'l',r- " . '1-i-l';;il-""II"l,-t1I1""!l'-h'~'''--Il"f".,.,-:-h__._.n_.--_._--.--. " "..- JJ9.:.l.::0~Jl~()I!!!!:.U!i!!!:l.r?.Y~..__....._ ""H' - .'r tou, Ph 17025 5~6 11l101n \lond I AI'~ till "''''~'i'~/~~i'T-... .]":..~;2:-:"~~:;I~-n';' f.~i\i"~f"jjii,- Huu~ I'llll'viu\~ iI'.'_.'"" ...-.--.._---~--_._~._- N:lkll\\Ifl v. Nl\rllUL'U~ lI:lllllulIun ". ... "'i~~.":"";o:'~~'iii"ii;'i'i.,.~~~r"-"".'-~ii;;~~;~;~ rS ;~~~, "";;III,~0.i"",,- 1J}(j . 1/f.U.J.----.....---..J.-~-..- I If ilI'lU /liI/H !Vas Clmf1lilllt (.\"1m Pit. n.c,fJ.",I'. No. WO/II>') ill iwrillll Il/Iloro Oii(fi"r Jmtlr;l/, II/! MUST I'II.F. A COMI'/.AINT wltllill (W"'''Y (201 <I1/1'''''tl//' tilillY /li.l NOTICf (II API'F.A~, tJpOllllo lI!i OV 11) _ 911-C)OOP494 I. T 10 ~____--=: Thl\ 1,look' will Itll .11J;,.;;j"O-"il;rwii;,;; '-jiil. IHlIIIIIII" i' Il.C.I'..I.!', Nil, IllOIlIl, This Notlnll of ^IIIHtIlI, whurl IIlC:ulvlIfl hy thu Dislllc\ JmliclJ, will "SLII'i:nS\,/)I,^U III Ihol",11I1ll1l111 101 1'0"'11,,1011 il1lhi. '''ISII, ---~--.-.----~-~---.----..-.-~--...------...._ '-0 ...__________..._._________0.__._ -- ..-..--------. m5.i!ji;~/jji;v(J7j;;;;ii~~,_IJ~il.I;~"..ij;;i'ljili;~- __n__ I, " , .. " .._..__h_..~__.~_._._.._._.__.__..__... ........______.___... __. ...___. ._.__,., .. ___ '_n_u_'.~.. __ , -0-'....... ~_ -.- _.... ..._~~_._. ...._.__~___~_._. ..... -..-~~.-......~..____.9..._.._.___._... l'flAP.CIf'F- TO. /;NT/;Il RUL/; TO FILl: COMPLAINT ANP nUL/; TO FII.F- (rill., s",:rioll of 101'11I 1011/1 ,/S",I ()N~ I' wl/l'" "I'II/II/il/It tVi" Orl'ENDANrISllI/I'<I, II.C.I',.JJ'. N(I, roOIf!! ill I/{:t/ooll/llnr/l Oislli"r J/lsri"/I, If NO I' USED, I'II/Incll frolll C1l1JlY of IIotica af al'I "'ii' In /1/1 sVI'l"1<II,,,o" ///l/I/II/mll. f'f1AF-CIf'~ I Tll I'tl'\holll~"HY. ;1 '!:nll" '"111"1"";" Ill', & Hl"~.!.-~~.l(llll~__ , iIIlPllllllul.1, \0 filII II c(llIlpl"lnt In Ihl. "PI","1 /1 (I'l/lIV ul ,I/l/IOIIIIII(S) , ; ''',,'''''''''' ,',,,,,. ,,, .J1-'l.:lI '?l.UVL ..., '''''''I' '"'''''' '"'' ,',," ~"' '?m'I'" ~:r '" '''Ii", '''''' 'I,"""'''"'''' ,,' """ ""." . . ~ _.OO~I~~J;~'lI.lfll'f;;;~ flUL/; 1 Tn _..I~l:'-.&.u~I~.E1!...~:tklClIlH..... ._____ .____...._, 111'1'11111111151 AH?1l D. Horur 1 guq, NillII/!{)(d/lpullllll(jJ (1) You mo notlllotl tl10t a rulo 18 l1oroby ClI1lored upon you 10 1/10 a oomplolnlln till a uppool wlll1ln lwenty (20) dqya , after the dato of aorvloe of Il1la rulo upon you by pornonul aorvlco or by oorlll/od or ro\]lalored Illall. . (2) If you do not fllo n oomplalnt wltl1ln Il1la limo, Il JUDGM/;NT OF NON PROS Will. I3E ENTr:n/;p AGAINST YOU UPON PRA/;eIPE, (3) Tho doto of aervlce of :h19 rule II HO/vlce won by Illolllu 1110 dnta 110 1II11\] , Dolo: i!/.tuJ- J<. . 10 9 9 ~ WI/Un ...~ Protfwflnfaf)1 Copy (1/001/ ... CO/1ft Fllo COP.I ro/low... 11"1'/1/1011". eoill' "'"k ...... 1I1'''I//Iooeol'1' Oo'rl......()..!. COl'1' '. tc r~.l , (~ .o:e In \ \ , '1'''' . I'I."? (\J "'j ,'.- :.,:1 ji':! :'j" e )..' !" {I l:~: :-', "lie. ).,~I ('/I' '\1 I (J l/} I' , (": 11'1; ,. ,':. ..... ;.~,I(h " :j,; .,'Jll. () fJ' ~~.j 0, u -.-.---.......---.-. -..., .-.-----.---..-.----.. -..., ..'. ....-.-., ..-;-..-..-.,.- ...... ~+.,'--'... ..-._~--_. ..,-_.,--._~--- PROOI' 01' flllRVICJ: Of' NO'l'lcll OF, AflPt:A1- AND nUl-I' TO I'll-I: OQMflLAINT 11'/119/>100101 sorvloo MilSI' UtI FIWO WITNIN T/iN (10) OA V,IJAI'Tf.fll//l1I1J lira 110/10/1 01 oppolll, Ollook sppl/osb/fl /!oxos) aowllONWMI.TlIOF I'CNNSVI,VANIA COPNTV OF__ '" AFFIDAVITI I hllluhV 11V1I1H /If 111111111 Ihol 1 IIIIVIlt! [I 0 onpv 01 Ihll Nnlloonl Appool, Cnlllll1l"" 1'11I11i Nn, __, npnll Ihu Ql51rllll .111511011 1,011UII01011 Ihll/olll nil (rIa/a ut sOlvleol_._...l____...._._._, 10~_, [I hV pOI5oIl0110rvl"" IJ hV h:llrllf!olll (rolllltorolllll1oll,IUllllu/', tOllol,l\ OtlllohClllll/lruln, mlllllpnlllhllll1111ll1l1l0, (1I0IllVI__.._n_......__ ._.._....~ _____--_~-_ , nil ~ , III --Cl hV pllllnllllllo,vh:n [I hV (00111l1Illlll/01lIl\lll'lldIIl10Il,10III'01'5 /ooolpl ottRcholt hOIRlo. 01111 fllrlhol 1111'1 l'IOIVOII 1110 IMo In filII 0 Cnlllllllllllt 1I00omllOIIvIIIII Iho ohovo Notlco III AIIlIool 1I110l1 \ho 01'1101100111 tll' whomlho 111l101V1I1 "dlhpllllIl nl1____~__.....__...__., 10____, 0 hV IJllllllnnl 5"'Vlco (] hV (ooltlllodl (r(lIlI"",ollI moll, 101111or'l rocolllt IIII"choll horotll, . o ,\ \ \ \ " sWaim IAl'flliMfiOI ANn SlJIlsonlnHO IlJ:t'OIH:, MI. THIS ,DAYOf__~~_,10.~~. , '. Sly",,,mu 01.,;;;;; iliff.tV,., of ,,(fIe/1I1 bllltJflJ IV/Will affir/.v7t;;,;n;;;;,...,--u_- Till, 0/ o(//el,1 Mv 001111111111011 oHplrol 011 ,10~. 'I , \ ,I , , \ : ~- \ I ' , \ '. II . . " \ , TlIIIlIS TO NPTIFY YOU 'nIATI Jl.dgl1\OI1I: . POll' l:'J./U.N'UUII r~: JJUU'l1anl WIHl enlered 10': (NAme) --NllU.~lJa..._nlt-l_NR~ .._ll.....-w !il ,}Ldumonl wos enlered l'Oulnal: (!>jamll) -LtJJNEClAN, MARGAnJ'l'l! ___.... ___...... In Ihe OIl1OlJrl of $ Eiti4....liP_ onl (DRill 0' ,}(IC1QIIIOIII)..........2/PJ /9!L.___ '-11.11- ~ 1"'~';1 l!J';, , :.., I.orl 1I111i I' 1 tHU.~L,fllf GP\11,10NWi:AI.TII OF I'IlNNSYLVANIA r.OdNTY c.'f', Omm,U\LAlro r-iii;;;;;i<<.-...az:t-~~.-~---~==~-:.:.....___;.1:.::.~~':':';~:,=~" I pg.~. 02 .~, I.,f"~ 1....'1 . ROaER~ V, H~N~OV~ I """It I 190.1 1J'.l'oh'l'N a'!'IIl;:E'~ ~~l IfX~I. I' P., ~~~~~171 761.P~03 17011'0000 KARU~~~W F~I'l'WKU^N Gab ~~O~~ ~tO ^P~," 1 W.OT V~r.nVluw/ V^ 17025 " " " - o Dale"dalll~ ura jOlnlly und eove'Qlly :lable, o Daml1Ua6 will bo l\l\nAe~e\1 \"11 o Tille clIse dismissed wllhvlll nrell1dlco, O 11111011111 01 Judrll1\olll 8ul)j,,01 10 . Alludllllul1VAGI ~ of 1006 $_ . o I.evy Is uluyed lor _ dOyr. or 0 llol1orolly slnyod. -.., U Olllaollol1 10 I~vy has baan filod und houling will ba 110ld, I Dille ~ Ploo~: TI/1101 .--'- - '___'.'_h_. ._ ................ (1 ,'-((11 ("l:J,' "', l1~ NOTIO/: OF plv~G~m'l'rrAANaORIPT ~AI~T ICI:' II "If. ~ru .It.:,'; ~Ii ~I~ua/ nn, , MRO, ", W.' 345 6 'l'R:n'lO~Q R04\D PA1i1' "I~", 1'/\ ~ '7011 L VB. ().f;r~I'j[)MiT ,.."y, ,1.1 ^(': ;.tl'~ rl' J:I'l'WI!:QMf I U1.RQM\l>T sao ~OLA no ^Pw.ff 1 lfl$PT ~WInVI"l'l, 1''' 1'10;\U ~ J OOr.ilUINo,: ciV-;PP004!14 .90 I. Dllla FlluCl: 1:1/01/90 . . . t. I . I ---.....- qla~:s-Im .J '1 ---------- (Date & TIIM) _~r AI11~lInl 01 ,hldU/11onl Judglllonl Cosle Inluru~1 on J\I\IUITlonl Altornoy Foos Tolal $ 611.o.Q $ R::ti $-- $__a.ll.ll $ 664 .5Q $.-. $ 1'051 ,luCOll1onl Credils Pool JUOllll1el1! Coola IUi."Aa~:.;.::;:;;"l (lartlfloC/ Judgmenl Tolal $ -"'1"_- _.~,,-,., . -~ -I ...~ ANV PART V HAU Tltl! AlOIn '0 APPEA~ WITHIN 30 DAVS ArTEI1 Hll! ENTnV or JUOl.'lMENT OY rl~INQ A NOTICl! OF API'ttAL WITH TIIIl rI10fl10NOTAI1V'OI.l!I1K or mE OOUI1T or OOMMON PLeM, OIVI~ DIVIGION, yOU ~um INOLUPIl A COllY Or ~OjEl. ql')J" uoo aN ITI1 c!J:!. ..rOBMWITII YOUAflOnC!i,J;I,~ APPSAI., '/ '~/" 6'\4 'JiJlt""", al-#'l_ Palo .. 0.. -. . ...-' .' ~.. 4~~:L1t9\1~~.~~~Q;., 10011. '.'Y llla. I 11110 io n 11'110 ~nd f;d~p(,y 01 He llfCOI~1 Ih~' '(lilIlIUS 1:01I!11J1'.,'V,<I\i(~lIl(~I1I(lIi"i' .. :: ~) ju Q I '/ "..... . /1,' / f ..1 .r"~' ::. "'f .1 ... T -.I - Ollie - . .....;, 0';,1';"'" " '"'' 1, , ufotrlcl Juct~t)(J , My con'fI1I5~loll axpllOs 'I 'HI Mrnd,\y ol.IIII1lU"y, AOPC31590 2000 , I' .,.' SI:Mil,. . ".111'" " C.l.'~~ll~\yli ~IJII.rlr_l~i.~I'l!IY I v ilt<I!iI __p mllll\1111 11l1MMllN !'1.rAH NOTIG~ Of' APProAI. IIIOM JIIIlIlMI.PlllllllllT PISTIlIOT ,llIsTlor: ,/UPCHvH:NT llIlMMllN!'I.I',11I Nil. it) //'1/ /1. C, , ,<,'i,_.__ NOT/GJ: qr: ^"PI:AI. "-NnllI1H I. fIIVUII 111111 tlw IIPllullant Iw~ t!lud III tlw illlOVU COUll Ilf Co 111 III on flllloIS illl il\l!lllulllllnl thu jlul1l11l1l1111tllllhllIHI!ly \IlU ()l~lllnl JlIJ\!I:lI UIl lilt! ilnlu ulld ill Illu (:111\1 IIll1lltlunutl lJulllw. fiAi-(i(ilii',,;o'llcl.j'''-'tl I'IAIlI'AIU'.'I' 1'111,"1'''''11 ~f,il'"'''''III;- ~.rr"~'i,,,il'-- ,1,11.11 l'ldd.d ,IOdd I ^:Il_. /11 i"'i~~!'/;'I',~"~'" . . ./:,,':';'.~~';,n';lrl":' "iliM-~i'ili"; di:(i-y I ~"^\I,'iil-p-'; !U1, Illi N~~,-;'ilr4Ii',;,-------.---..._n- 111"',1.,(1;; ;l';ohll'(l 1111\\ IOVl' ,.. .._~-_.-.--._......._._--.---.~......_---_._..._-~~_...- 'TAli' "rCllllltl ',IOlll j,'.ifl-I,/II'I/ II" I/O.!:i ,,,,, "," ,'elL.l!lll,' ;.!ilJ /,,'1'1'( t Il' t llllflgltll . .... -t-I-"-ti'fl-iil"'o~t"'r',,'i~ll:;'"f'"~i;\il'-A-T-iii"N-ti.'( 'n"'"li~i,-i'-'" ... ....-.~._---_._----- .... .Y;{l,): rt j // ()i!)~/L'/I'( I M._____..!_:.L~~~I~;t :: ~.~' IllqUhlld tllHlm Pa, /( iI/'/>lI/lil/ll \'ViiS (:1,'/11I,1/11 (,/1/1 /'", 1/,0'/',/,/'. Nil. 10011r," III I/(.'lillll /",/11//1 DistriC.'1 ,IUsli(:lI, 1/1.' MtlS7 rll.I' A COMPLA/NT Ivltll/II 1I'V/!/iW (;/01 dill'" iI/l"r lilillll Ii/" Nonr,'r: II/ N'/'flt~, OV 1ll \JlI.O(IIII)/I'I" m._.. . I. ! .I.~ ="=::::::C:-::-::=:~'.m n._ Till. 1I111"k will 111I \ilJlwll ON I. Y wlwlI lill, 1111'"11,," I, 11.<:,1',,1.1', Nil, 1001111. Thh NlIth:u of AlljlUIlC whlln IlIlwlvud by Iho f)j~ltjl~\ IU$lh:u, willllllUllllll lIS " SI.II'i:IISI:Di:^H \11 IIw l"IIIJI'''"1 'Ill 11t1l.""llIlIllI Ih.. ""Stl. -._-~--'-----"~'-'--~"'-'~-'_.'---- --.-.-- '........-.-.--..----.......-....-.------...-.- -..- -~- ---..-.... ....... ..-. SI!Jn;l.ijjij'I-IJTlII~ltllllll;;i~,;.I; ';J;"Til~;j,il~"--' --__..... ... .w_ ~____'_H__..._...... ..._____.__-.. .____~....... ____ PI1Ar:CIPJ: TO f.NTr:H RIH.J: TO FILl: OOMl'tAINT AND RUt" TO FILE Irlll., SIIetioll 0(/01'1I' to/m (/,,>1/ ONt. \' IVIIIIII ill'IWIl,."/t lVi" orrfNoANr IS/.'o 1',1. 11.(.'.1',,1.1'. Nil. /00/(11;11 i/l.'liOIlIIt/row OMri"l .lilSt;I:O, 1/' Nor tI.I'fO, ,1"11I,,11 /rll/ll ',"'/lY o( ""111.'11 O/III'1'1i1l1 totli' SOll'Of/ /11'0/1 1I/1I'olllilil, I'HAJ:OIPf.'.To 1""II\111lnllllV .-------- .--.-.. . _._--_._-~.- ......._._--~._-- 1'"111'11I10 lipoll 00.. (r.01l111H111 1'11111' No. ~IX....- p,., I. '1l'\I, 1111'1."", , I I II I - ..~-_.- -.---, illlPllllllUhl. to IUu il (,lIInpla '" 11 t I $ llppnil 'I ' ./ 'N~'ltJ()f"/I/II'l1fJlJ(JI /1. ~ --( .'/I~ ,_ C_I \Villill] IWIIIIIV ,;?O\ ""v' ",('''' "" vi"" 1"'1.111.11 ,,,f1," lI1ltrv lit 1,,,lu'11l111l "' 1111111"01, '} JLcl:uJ!l)()ULlLd./..JjJ+_______ .t;lfllllllllllyuf ~f1()fI"'n (1 ~iJ IlIfofllOl-lm1ftlfltf- . ._____~__, llppnUllo(s) ^lJ.ull I), 1111','111', J';lIq. nULl:, To ,_~.',..'.- ..,H.. .'1.' 1.-':'1111 _ N{/IIlfJu( 111I/wll/lOfll (3) Tho dalo 01 aervlce of :hlo rule If aBlyloe waa by 111011lB Iho dolo ol.fJ,fIlIIlt1g, 'J I) rJ l.! )/ I} Dale: _ nllJ ..::L-..,19_L.L._ "~L_ , I -\.. SigfUJIUfO (1) Yo II are notlflecllhot a rule 10 11llroby onloraclllpon you to fllo a complnlnl Inlhla uppeul wllhlnlwenly (20) days oller the date of oervloe 01 thla rule lIpon YOll by puraonal sorvlce or by oorllfled or roglolered '11Oil:,,' "" (2) If you do nolllle a oom11101111 wllhlnlhln tlI110, II JUDGMJ:m OF NON PRO~ Will. BE ENT~~~P, AGAINST YOU UPON PRAl:CIPE"" \ , ,/ (,1 . '" (/t;I , , ~1Jl l"_:'" f1~:'~"'iltd~ym uil/ill7. ' ,I "11, . "."..... Wllllll.... "",thollillmyCOI'Y Omo/l.... COllf'PiloCnpv YIlI/OW'" Afll>""'''''. Copy l'lnh ...... Afll'OI"'il COflY (10111......1) ,/ COllY flflQOF OF SlllWICI: OF NOTICI: ai' API'I:AI. ANP nUI.I: TO FII.1: COMfll..AINT (Tlllslllnol nl Rmy/oo MImI' /IF "//.Ii/) \Vlll/1N rt:N (10) OAY.'J APl/mlll/llfI tlw IIntlnn ollil'pnnl, GIllick nl'l'lInnl)/1I /JOXOU) _.h__..._+__._____~._. .. __ ~.._..... OOMMON\'IUAI.T11 01' I'JI~INQVl.VI\NII\ OOIJNTV Cl,,___d!.!.!!.~~:d"'!.'..d____.___.__ :" AFFIDAVIT, I 1I11"lhy 'IVIIIII'" ,,1111111 111"11 "" VII" ." r.~r ~ OIlIlY III Iho NIIII"o III ^llfl~1I1. C:II/1lIl\(~1 !'III'" Nil. 'fJr"II'iI., 11i"'" Ih"..I)I~III"1 .111111011 11011ulill\l1l1 IIIIIIIIIIi 1111 (rlo11/!olslwl",..)....3?IA,.I.f.:(\.. "-, to.l'''.., 1.1 IIYIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIV"'" I.~I/hy 11:11I1111111111111111110111111 lilHlI,.III1I1II1I" IlIIwllll ~1I11"II11" )11I111111,111111 IIflllll Ihll IIflfll,II11I1, (III/II"').. ''P/' t. ~II(". 11' IJ ~ lJ~jtl.k.l.... ..._... ......................, IIIi 3_iji/.!t:r.:-A.__, 10 .1'i-1: I I,y fllllllllllll '"lvi,," Ik.l~ hy 1""111/1",11 111111"111111'11 /IlIIII, 1111111111" 10,,"1111 ~1I~"II1111 111110111. SWOIlN (^"I'IIlMI!\)I~NIl f>lJI1!iqllll!l:1J ""FOlll: MI' T1i11L.311t_llAY or.._-mll.,<.J\.... ...__, t1l9El. (,:,/'1', ~ 1.2 ~ ' ~~~ .l _I_..;..~~... . ~'__'_h.____I.,. S/VII',",. ul II "J~e:h\.\~::':t'~.~~/I",~'~____. Till. "' ul/M., My 001111111111nl1 "" flit III ""..____ [I IlIId '"llltlll 111111 !.'"IVllt! 11111 1111111 III Filu" C'''''Vlililll 1Il:""trlll.lllyilll 1111I IIIIllVII Nlllir.II III ^IJlllllIl 1!1I011 t1w Olll'ullllllllllll Whl1ll1ll111 [111111 WllllllltltulIIIl1 III1.n .,,S.l)I.Ui:H,. ....., 111.9(, 1."1 hy 1111111111111 ""vli:II Ikl-flY (""111/10111 ('"!1I""I01I1 trl~II, .111111111'1111'''''1'1 II 11 1II: l\lll 1 Itlll 11111 , . .~c;:"~~:r~c(~:.4~~-,- . 1 , rlfJfIllW"'flll,lfimlf ,IIL..~, '"] NolRllol nlllll a u; Uo~la NO\IlIY PII"II" ~~ milt, lJnllpll 11 Ollll"IY My ~m~1881c\\\'E~Plroo 1'01> 1\1,20U1 emhnf, nnl1Gvhll\IIb t,r,!lt'I,Ilnll 111 ~t .1'llor, ( _l to ) c. \I-l "11 .",:, I '\J!j , I , \' i.' :11'1 "" ,..., i I ~ .I ( F. , 1.1 , '/1.\ 'T! ,1;\\ ,...: .. I , , ;'1"1 (,') I " " :., "') ...1 :~ llDNDIIR It. Oonlp,-", "'Ill' ,1 lillI/III ~ 1M ,ddlUOfl.1 IIIVlOlI. I ~l,a Wlllh to rualllvo 'hv I 1 Ooml"1I. lI.ml 3, .n.~.. h, fllllowlIlll '. Of 'I. /00' .11111 on ..0 K!II" J I "'11"\ VOII' "'1ll1 'lid IlJd'... 11111"1 "VIU" of Ihl. 101111 10 Ihlll WCl con lupll. ' I ,,11Im hI, ollld 10 VOll, I · AlIIIch thll fOlln 10 tll. hUllt pI 11\, ,n,lIlllollO, 01 unlhq Illnk 11111'011 1, (] AddruuoQ'.' A(ldfau rion n(,l1 p"mI1. J I.. I ~ -WIlt" "l\llIllOnIC 1IIlIItIllll,"'ll" nil 1he IlHl1111IIU ~"Iow lh, "Ucl'l\\lmbul. 2. (] nfJPH Ill'ad pQlI.vyrv ' , I ~ , 1'" ",t\lln "'Ulll' will ,h~w fa wholllll" IUUelO VJII (hIlIY'"d Inti IhD dltl C .,11 - - t" - f I 8 1!!I!\'!J1'.lli.------...__._________. ___._ .0 !iliLrul!Un8l10r 01 .l!!l~ '.1 f/' Alllolo AIllIro",od 1111 . .' 411, Arllnlo N,IInliul. ,. .. J II .. \::lr, '\ ~rlo, R, \\,'l, ~\" \IIUl; ~-._Z._18L..Ji13.-!lJ.1l_ ", () 1'1' Borvlull Tvpo .. , I ?'1SL> -'r\ Nl\ ""~ 1'4:.nl'\ L nnlll~loroll {J 1111\11011 II . l'fl Corlllloll lJ QPD .Il' Q ll/~ \ \: I \\ () '1\ 1'1 D \ \ lJ UKfll'" 011 (] no\llln Aooolnl lur R I . I 1" '7.ll,iiuOf ~.~~Illlill\JtI'o on i II ! hlll;\OI~rQ (AlIdl~"-cilI'---'--- n.7iiiilrmo ,~\(il~n (Onlv II lOllllnloll Jl : ___ 4.)J~,.-', ____ ""d fllo I~ !loldl I I 0, 81\1110 Ill. IAuorlll: ' , , ,I' , , J I I PilFQltn 30";D.U0I11Ir~t.Hj91. ~\J',GI'OI\.ii=iiU" 'PQMES'rlO RIiTURN flECIlIPT : l,.-~~~~~:~:~b:l~~;::~~~~.ti.:llrl"I.II.I..IVI':- I lO~IO~~~U ~~:~:o~~ fl~~o]:~~~;,;;:-J..-.: . rlll11 yotll n.m. .nd.duII" on thl I\lVP", of Ihl~ hHm 10 th.l WI II'" fooll . Ittllln thl. olld 'Q you, I · AU.oh till. form ICl Ih, .holll nllh, 1Il.lIpIDeo. Of O. II lhlt bllck II "lltU 1, [] AchlruuQu'QAchi;OIl don no' pl1mH, , III 'I · wmo"n,lumn,c.lllln.quo.l.d"OI'llhllT1.lIpllcoh,loWlhOltUClflI1umbol. 2 [] tiCJDtflotQ(! Dollva. rv J 'P . Thl "'llllll n,clIll'l wlll.how In whom the 'IItelo w,. d,IlV'IIIlI.llll Ihl dlte I / B !I.!.!ll'!!!!!:...~ __~__________ _ ..Q\!!l,ullJ!!!!Uno~lol tllr 00, lJ3' Alllulo Ai1dro~.o.d 1111 . 4.0' Alllulo N. "'nllor I ~"l>-\~"'~" -Y,,';'\ \ <'-lL ___.~LJJ!I..l73 920 j II \ \ <.\ '^^ 4~, BorV/lIo TvI>U I "'0 Pf f:. ,,' "II')' \l) ~ e... [j AOIII~luroll fJ InlUrnd I! \ "\'D\ '3.~o:.\...." 'S,-\ f '" \- 11.Qorllllod [] GOfl r '. C'. /). L1 aKllIO.. Moil IJ AOIlUII Aouolpt fOl . I B.m.lJ\ \\\" ,l\,. I."){) 1 \ -~-_.-. rj::.:..Ml~lft Ii " 1. Dlltlf' flol 01 . r.~ ". I . . I : ! ~ljjlulill'-j^ddro.~lIlif"-'- .-.--..---.-- -ii, Add o,,"u', Adii,ii"iDllI ii'tiijilealolt ,.11 I .. .____~ _____._ olld fuol, ,,~Idl I I~O,lln.tur 001111 L '.\.'" ": If { uorl1l1o, 111111 ~u..,orO"m_3tHI4 OOMI1STIC RETUnN nl1CEIPT I ............, I \ , I IWNAI.1l W, NnQ.Atlll, P,M,Il, MAOj)"I\nd MAIW NIKLAl1S.. Pllllnt1ff y, I IN Tim CO{JR1' OF COMMoN Pf.lJAs I Cl1MnUHI.ANP COUNTY, PENNSY\NANIA I I I NO, 99-1101 MAHOAIUl'I' FINNEOAN. Dllfullllllnt , I I CIVIL ACTION - LAW ANsWlclt '1'0 PLAIN'I'IIIIIS' CQMI'LAIN'I' ANI> NOW COIl1US Dufundlllll. MlIl'gnrul Flnnuglln, hy 11I111 throllgh his ollnnslll, Ihll Lllw Offleus of Losllu I), Jl\lmhsoll, IInd rlIUh Ihls Answlll's IInd IIWI'S lis follows I , I, Admlttcd to Ihu hcst of Ill)' knowludgo, Infol'lIlllt1on, lind, !lOllllf, 2, Admitted, 3, Admlttlld to thu hust of lilY knowledgu, Infol'lIllltlon, IInd billiot', 4, Adll1lttlld, 5, Dunled, Anol' 1'0llsonllhllJ lnyosllglltlon. j)cfondnnt IlIoks Infol'lnlltloll 01' '. I(nowledgll s\lffiole11l1o flll'lll II hllsls to thll hulllJf liS 10 lIw tmlh of the IIVCl'I\1enls cOlltlllned In , lho pllI'lIgl'llph IIl1d SlllllC 111'0 thul'of'ore denied, stl'lel proof Illllng dl1nlllllded IItll'lnl, If l'elevlIlIl, 6, DUllled, Ancl' rellsonnhlu IlIvostlgllllon, Defundllnl IlIoks Infol'llllllloll 0(' kllowledgc slIfTiolenl to 1'o1'1ll II hllsls to the helluf ns to thu tmlh of lho IIVel'lnenls uOlltllhtcd III Iho plll'llgl'l\ph IIl1d SIIIllO IIl'e lhol'lJflll'e denlcd, sll'ict pl'llof hulng dCl\1nnded 1I1tl'llll. If l'eleVllnt. 7, Dllnlcd, Anul' I'cnsonllhlc InvcslIgllt!on, Dcfcndllnl hIcks Infol'lnlltlon Ill' knowlcdgu sllfficlcnl to f01'1ll II hllsls 10 the holleI' liS to lhe Imth of tho IIVel'lnOllls clllltlllned In tho plll'llgl'lIph nnd SlIllle 111'0 thel'et'oro dcnlcd. sll'lcl proof helng dUl\1l1ndcd 11111'1111, If l'Cluvllnt. II, DUIlIIlII, ^ftUI' I'1l1ISo1ll1h11l hlVustlglllloll, ))0 1\1lI1111 111 IlIllks 1111'01'11111I1011 01' kllowludgu sufflell'llt 10 lill'l11 II hllsls 10 IIw holloI' liS to Ihu lnllh of thp IIvcnnunls eonlllhlelllll tho PIIl'I\gl'lIph 1111(1 SlII1\llllrll !Iwl'ul\lro (IUllllld, sll'lel proof lwl11g dUll1l1llded IIllrllll, If rolovllnl, 9, Donled, Aftor rOllsollllhlll IllvoslIglllloll, l)llfulllIIIIlI IlIoks Infol'llllltloll or IlnOwlo(lgo sUfflelUnlto lim11 II hllsls 10 lhu hollot' liS III Ihu II'Ulh of lhu flVOl'll1llllls eonllllnoll In thu P1U'1I11l'llph lIurl SII1I10 111'0 Ihol'uforo dOlllod, sll'lol pl'oof lwlllg dllll1l1ndud 11111'1111, If 1'010VIIIll. 10, DUlllud, Aftel' I'UIISOllllhlu Illvos!lgll!lllll, Dllfundlllll IlIcks Illfol'lnlltloll lll' kllllWlcdgo sllfflclonl 10 fOl'm II hils Is In thu holluf liS 10 Iho ll'luh nf Iho IIVlll'l1101lls oonllllned III thu PlIl'lIgl'llph 1I11t! SlIlIlIJ I!I'C thul'uforu donlud, SII'IIlI pmof Iwl11ll dUll1l1l1dlld lit tl'IIII, It' l'oluvlInl. II, Donled, Aftul' I'UIISOllllhlu IlIvostlgll!lon, Dofondllnt Inoks Infol'l11l1l1on or knowledge suff'lcllllllto 1'01'11111 hllSl1I 10 Ihu holleI' liS tn tho truth of fhu nvernlOuls cnntllllled In Ihu plll'l\gl'lIph IInd SlInllJ 1II'1l Ihel'ufol'u dOlllud, stl'lul pl'oof hulng dUll10nded ot tl'llll, If 1'0lOVf\llt. 12, Admltlod, 13, Dunlud, Aftul' 1'0llSOllllhlll Invusllglllllln, Defent!1I1l1 IlIcks Infol'1I111t1on 01' knowledge sufflolontlo 1'01'111 II hllsls tn tho helieI' liS to thu Il1Ilh of tho IIVel'menls eOllllllned In the plll'l\gl'llph IInd SIIII1U IIl'e thol'lJl\lre (IUllled, sll'lct pl'oof holllg domllnded nl trllll, If 1'0luVllnl, 14, Admhlud, 15, Conclllslon of 11111' In which 110 IInSWel' Is I'equired, If' nil lI11swer Is deemed neCeSSlIl'Y, IIftel' rellsnnllhle InvusIlgllllon, Defendll111 IlIcks 1111'01'1111111011 01' knOWledge sufficient 10 fOl'mll hils Is to Ihu holleI' liS 10 the Il'lIlh of tho IIVCl'l11cnls eonllllned In the 11IIl'lllJI'IIph IIml some lire thul'ufol'o donlod, sll'Iet pl'onf' hulng domllnded 11111'1111, If I'olcvllnl. 2 Hi, Donlcd, If IIn IInslVCI' Is IICOlHcl1 llOCOSSIII'Y, IIflcl' rClIsonn\llc hlVcs!lgllllon, Dcl\Jnllllnt IlIo~s Inli1l'l11l1lhlll or ~nowlcdg\l snff'lcllllH 10 limn II \lllsls 10 Iho \lollef liS to Iho lrulh of tho III'crmcnts colHllhlOllln Ihc plll'Uul'lIph IInd SII1110 111'0 thorolbl'll ,Ionlcd, stl'lol proof \loinu dCI11I111\lollllllrllll, If roloVIIIH, 17, Conolnslon of IlIw to whloh no IInsWol' Is rllqulrod, If IIn IIUsWOI' Is Iloomcd nocossllry, lIf'lel' rollsoIH\\lh: Invesllllllllon, Dot\Jmlllnl IlIcks Inlbl'lTlllllol1 or knowlodgo SUff'iClllnl 10 lill'l11 II \lllsls 10 Iho \lollllf lis 10 Iho lrulh of tho IIverl110nts oontlllnodln Iho plIl'llgl'llph lilli' sllnlU lire Ihoroforo denlod, Sll'lo( pl'Oof \lolng dOl11l1nllodllt IrllIl, If I'lllovllnl, Ill. ConohlSlon of IIIW 10 whloh 110 IInswor is rcqulrcd, If' 111\ IInswor Is doomcd 1I0oossnry, IIftor rOllsonllhlo Invos!lgll!lol1, Dofomlllnlllloks IlIfon11l111on or koowlcdgll sufflolenl to fbn11 II bllsls to tho hllllof liS 10 Iho Imth of IhullvOrnlOnls oontlllncd In IhullllrnUl'il(1h IIl1d SlImo nro Ihoroforo donlcd, slrlot proof bolllg dUl11l1llllcl1 nlll'llIl, If roleVllnt, 19, Conolusion oflllw 10 whioh no III1SWllr Is rUl(ulrcd, If nil IInsWor Is dClll11ed nec~Hsllry, tho )llnlllllff tidlcd 10 f\llrtll his ohllgll!loll of Ihe ngrcol11ollt belwcun thll pllr!lcs, 21, (.1'10) Admitted, 22, Admlttcd, 23, Conclllslon of IlIw to which no IIl1swur Is rcqnlrcd, If 1111 IInSWCl' Is dccmcd IIcccHsllry, IIflcr rCIISOllllhlu Invc!ltlgllUolI, Dufcndllnllncks Informnllon 01' knoWlcdgo sufflclunl to form II hllsls 10 tho hcllof liS 10 tho lruth of Iho IIVcrmontH oontlllncd In Iho pllmgrllph IInd sllmo Ill'll Ihorctbro dOlllod, Hldct pl'Oof hclng domlllldcd 11111'1111, If rOIUVIIIIl. 24, Conclusion of IlIw 10 whloh no IInsWcr Is rcqulrod, If IIn IInSWCI' Is dClllucd 3 nllOllHHlIl'Y, IInul' I'fJIIHOllllhlfJ InvuHlIllllllnll, Dofumlll1lt III0kH Infonnllllnn 01' kllowlfJlIllfJ HnffiIJIIJlll In fOl'lllII 11IIHIH In Ihu hullel' IIH In Ihu tnllh ul' Ihu IIVUl'IllulllH onllllllllollln thu pll1'llllrnph IIllll Hmnll IIl'elhul'ulbl'U dUlllfJd, Htl'lp! Pl'(lol' huhlll IlullllIl\llullllt 11'1111, 11'1'01uvlIllt, 2~, COlwhlHlon of IIIII' 10 whluh Iln IlllHlVUI' IH l'u[jllh'UII. If IIIl IIIlHWel' IH duullloII nUOUHHlIl'Y, II nUl' l'uIIHOllllhlp InvuHlIlllltlOll, J)ufumlllnt IlIokH Inl'nnnllllnn nl' kllowlpdllU Hnf'l'lolulll In lil1'lllll 11IlHIH In thp hullul' IIH 10 fhp Imth uf Iho IIvul'IllPlllH OlllHlllllod In lhp PIIl'II1l1'llph IInlt HUlllP III'U Ihl1l'ul'ol'ullunlpd, IIIr10t pl'nol' hphtll dOllllllldulllIllrllll, If I'UluVlIlI1. WmCllIWOlm, J)ef'ondunt l'oHpooll\llIy l'uqllPlIl1I IhlH hOllnrnhlu conn dlHllllHH Ihp I'IIIIIIIII'I'H' Cnmpllllnt wilh pl'u.lndlop IInd IIII'llI'd lhp Dul'ulldlllll oOHIH 111\11 OXPOIIHPH III0uI'I'od III thlH 10UIIlllotlnn IIH 1I'01lllH IIIIY lIud 1111 nthul' I'ullol'duulllod IIPPl'o(ll'llItu, Dlllu: ~ I~. ff Uy I 4 RONALP W. N"<~AUS, P,M,P, MAGP" and MARY NII<LAUS, PIEllntlff VS MARGAr-{I=T FINNF-GAN, Pefendant IN THF- COURT OF COMMON PI.F-AS OF OUMBF-I~~.ANP COUNTY, PI=NNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION" LAW NO. 99-1191 .NQT10F- OF ARElIT.R8I10N 1'lt;ABl~ As OhEllrmEln of the 130Elrd of AroltrEllors Elppolnled In tile ElI)oVI3 oaptloned . . Of1~I3, Illave fixed Friday, JElnLIElry 21, 2000 Elt1 :300'010011 p,m, In the Flftll Floor hearing Room, OLlmberlElnd OOLlnty OOUrlhoLIs8 CElrllsle, Pennsylvania, ElS the time Elnd plaoe for the Hearing, Anyone finding this lime Llnsullaole will please malle appropriate arrangements wllll all OOLlI1sellnvolved for another lime, InolLldlng the sOhedLlllng of the Court Room, Date: 1);- )O{) -/. ' 00: V Craig A. Diehl, Esquire 3464 Trlndle Road Camp Hili, PennSYlvania 170'11 VJol'm C, Oswstowloz, Esquire 236 South Hanover Street Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013 --~ ' -i---~~~ ..:?CB.-~ Robert L. O'Brien, EsqLllre, Cl1alnmm (Allen D. Moyer, Esquire 8150 Derr~1 Street Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 1711'1 ~ol1n BElrE.H1slll, EsqLllre 35 Easl Higl1 Street Suites 201-202 Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013 Vpumberland County Prothonotary VCumberland County COllrt Administrator JUDGMENTS, GENERAL1.Y ........-.",... rA? ~ ('~Il ,1.\ ~ (iSIHJ, GcnerallYlln conlraclllCllDns Prcl'crdlct Inlercst may be all'arded III ordn III I'r"I'l~nt unjusl cnrlchmcnt or 10 .1I'01d Illjllstice,1' In l'flnllllt'1 rll!i"S, hOll'cl'cr, fl succcssful plalntlO' Is Clltllled to I'l'<l.jlltl/:I1I"l1t intercst at Ihe Slallllory nile as 1\ mlltt,!r of rll1hl." TIIII!!, It Illust be awardcd despite Ihe good fallh of thl1 1'1\11)' "[IIlI,'st. Ing thc claim," El'cll If the Isslle of pro.judgmcllt inl'lrcsl Is' not l,lIh,nlll('" to the jl~I'>', the trial COlln und Ihe sllpl~rlor coull 1111\)' Inold Ihe verdict to Inclllde It." II0II'eve/" If not /'l'qunsll'd ".'forll tho jlldgment becomes fillal, II party's right 10 prc.j\ltlgnll~nt Interest Is w1\lved.1i Pro.jlldgmenl Intc/,cst is calclllalcd 1'1'0111 Iho 1/1110 tho debt becon1es clue 01' payable." 1111 !/Iuslral/o,,: The IrI\11 cOllrt clTcd III SllSI"'IHIIIl!\ Illler. cst frOI11 the close of trial through the dat.~ of final JlIdg. 111 UIl t, a delay of 11101'0 thull tll'O >'carsl el'ell If Iho deJlI>' II'US dlle to the COllrt's 01l'1l ncglect, It dldllol hl1\'O dlscre. 52, ~ 65:144. 53. Thomos 1/, Ross Il1c. V Selg. rreld (1991) 405 Super ct 558, 592 A2d 1.153, opp dell 529 Po 622, 600 A2d ;;38; Kessler I' Old Cluo I'd I\lul. ! I1S. CO, (1990) 391 Super ('t 1'/5, 5','0 A2d 569; \'c/" l1el' V Sho(fer (1985) 3.1'/ SlIpor Ct 206, 500 A2" 479,Rnbell WOolel' Co. V FldelllY /laok (1984) 330 Super CI 523, ,1'/9 A2d 102'/; na!lel 1\1I010!i COIJ), I' lndll,l"ol Fuels COIl'. (198,1) 326 Supcr Cl ]'1,4'/3 A2d 58.1. "oootolloosl COlllmeot NOI".... l\lIoll'ao(e or preJudgmcol Inlel"sl on builder's recovery In (Ic:tltl/l fn,. hrc.1ch of con!>lr\lcllon cOlllnH:l, (10 AI.R3d 48'/. 1.011' IlOI'Il'l\'si WiI,'s, P,,'JlIdg. lOCOI I111clO,1 ood "day dOlnol:", l1\\'lInls all bll'lU:h of COlli/act IInd rclalcd dal11agesl,\ c:nlllJ1,lI'i\tl\'o ollOl)'sls or Nell' Y"lk, Ohio Ill1d pcoos)'ll'oola 101\', 23 111l'1 I. nul' 109'/ (SlIIllOH'I', I'.IS;.). ;.1. (']"Id & Cn. \' NOIII\l'.H,1 Tlro. 11101' I.'nlp. (19SiJ) 28\ SIII'O! ('I 69, .\,'I,\2d 1151. 1'5, \""OCI v 510",1'", (1985) H'/ SlIP"I ('I .'116, ~(J() ,"d .1'19. $Ii, 1\1',,101 I' [lId f1l11l,d 1\1111. 111'" Co. (19\)(1) .1!)1 SlIl"" ('I 1'/:;,5'/0 A2d fi69, ;'1. "nbell 11'0,'1..,. CII, I' Flddll)' 11001: (19S.I) 3:W SlIl''' I (,'1.1,'3, ,1'/(1 "2d I on, ))''',''1 1\1101011 ("1/1" \' 10dl";!II,,1 FlIds ('nlp, (19.~.') 3.'(, SIll"" <'I 1",.II.1/\2d ~8,1; (}'Ihkll \' ('{l1I1l1l01l\~'I'lIllhl IlI'P'1 IIr 1'.d,ll" lI'dr,lIl' (IIIS2) (,,/ (.'lllIllllr (., ;"111, .1-1/1 A2d 1))2, .1/!i .K1:\:....~. Q1t?:,tilo1.v--. (}';.JII'1~.,d."," J,'I,/"... 4 n J~\;,"'- 0 ~~,J~ I~W\":'3 ~ .n("..\. J.I(H,,,,...,.~~'(,..I' (l"'.l".~' ,l{" ~ I\\'\. I3f.1.l"c;,.l'o"k I. P".Q,. ~\I"\JI""l I'),. 4..11.,.'-. G, II,., a\L'lLt..l~;.,.~/(, I't) ft ('.1:.1 ~~i1 p 1JV; c., ., f.' }l h.. "", il',ll ..~ ;II" I\l , !jJ,\.:' I". I UJ I:'~l'; !'::'Il(l.., ~ . :JJ ~~;r) "/' ~';f.') l'"Jj~ :'I,:",j \:i' ":;'1:') 4")i ~'j(d . :':) j\.J ;r~1 .., r,) ;}J , ," Iii ~ r' f &.\. ~ "'" \ ~l ... , ~