Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout99-01195 CIIIlTIS It, J.ONI/ 1'11'111'1111'11'1)' ('1111I1"'111111<1 ('1111111)' Om' ('""11111111''' SIIIIIIII' ("III lis"', 1'1\ 1'101.1 .....,. It I <~",'.;",-..._..,.........' 1 1r:'"..<<LIW1~ --~~~"'~" j.....':;:'...-.::.-..:-;.:;,....., __ (0[0 0 3'0 o)~~~~[: 0 .3 3: ! r Illt'lOIl ! ......u....... 11S8H4 I/,S. 'OUT Ita f I'PJ'l'llll 13I1IF'I~ElR 1m 1 130X 5311 Mrr.r,lilll13'j'OWN. I'll 17062 Ilz~oal t~o~aaole L7qe t~ 1~/071qq P R A~~ TrM~ ~~~ RTN TO a~NO a 4:1: P " Iq I ,\<; lea N~wr OMI' PA 1(~/4-9"la I~I!.TI.JRN TO af:!NlIl!i~1 \ raU';I."11\0 \ 11111,1111111111111,111,1,11",1111111,",1111111,111,1,111"I IOlltS,1l11111GlM) I OoIIlIJllll\11I10\1\ . \IY Clllllll1n . 449 fill, SIIPOI" (lCi I flllllO 111f4 1/49 PIl, StipeI', (16 I, *; 674 A,2d 1127, **1 1996 P(I, StipeI', UiXJS 987, "'** DeNNIS 1', I3ROWNe AND sHARoN I3ROWNe, \'I\s WIFe APpel.I-ANT v, NATIoNWIDe MUTUAl, INsuRANce COMPANY, APpel.l-F-e NO, WII'IAf~RI!3I3URG 19\>5 SUPF-IUOR COURT 01' PF-NNsY~VANIA 449 PIl, Sllper, 6611 674 A,2d t12711996 1'11, Sllpel', I-f.XIS 067 pecember 5, 1995, Arglleel April 10, 1996, Flied SUQSIlQUIlNT ~tISTORYI [***1] Petition for Allowance of Appeal Pen led september 24, 1\>96, RepClrtedlltl 19116 Pa, I-F-XI6 1927, PRIOR l'lISTORVI Appeal from the Order entered Jllnllery 10, 1995 In the Court of Common PleaD of Pauphln county, Civil Division, at No, 2661 S 1994, Before HOOVf.R, J, PISPOSITION! Reversed and the court Is ordored to relnstete the award of the arbitrators, CORIl TIlRM$1 social secmlty, dlsa\.1ll1ty benefits, subrogation, slcle, arbitration award, disability, arbitrator, ar\.1ltrlltlon, recovering, benefits palel, coordination, tortfellsor, dipping, Insurer, dou\.1le, offset, worleer"s compensation, right of subroglltlon, first pllrty benefits, \.1eneflts aVallllble, payments received, duplication, uninsured motorist, Injured party, third pllrty, recoverllblo, prechlslon, reinstate, deducteCl, Insured COUNSHL! I,awrence J, Neary, HElI'rls\.1uro, for eppellants, Douglas Johnson, Relldlng, for appellee, . JUDGIlSI Bf.FOREI DEL SOLf., SAYI-OI~ AND Hf.STER, JJ, Judge saylor concurs In the result, OPINIONIlVI Dfl- SOI-E oPINION, [*662] [**1127] OPINION BY DEL SOLf., JtI Flledl April 10, 1996 This Is an eppeal from II trial court order which grf1l1ted a moUon to Correct/Vacatean Arbitration aWllrd, The court reduced the arbitration Ilward by $ 106,727,00, which It found WIIS the amount of Social Security dlsllblllty benefits thllt had besn paid or were payable to Appellents, We reverse and direct the court to reinstate the arbitration award, Appllllllnts Ill'e the Insureds under a policy Issued by Appellee, Nationwide, A c1l1lm IIglllnst Netlonwlde was mlldo by Appellants for Uninsured Motorist Benefits as a result of IIn an [,~663] automobile IIccldent willcll occurred In 1992 IIlld Injured Appellent/husband, Wilen the parties were llnable to agree all tile Ol11ount of benefits due, tho Illattor was arbitrated In accordance with tile terms of tile policy willch called for I1I'bltratlon of disputes under the PennsylVf.1I1la Arbitration Act of 1927, 5 r,s, [***2] 146, et soq" replluled, nl All award for ,.'/rll\r1evll'l,Jll~!l7411522(T(tl2c5l\!lc!l7cc74053 709321 &_,hrowaoTypc~TI\XTONLY &_Olllah=F 9/29/99 \oxls,col11(SM) I Oct II \)ilC\II110\11-, hy ClIlIlIil\1- 44!.l PII, filipaI'. ()() 1 PIIll1l2111'4 Appollan\s was I1wlo Wllll n specific notntlo\1 \hntlt Incl\lllod nn orf60t for pUl'tlclllal' Itoms, Illlt thn\ n\1 offse\ wns \10\ made for Socllll Seclll'lty I>enofl\s paid or payaple, One arl>ltrattJr cHssen\eel from the pOI'\lon of the nwanl Wlllch did not Ilucluct Social Seclll'l\y ellsllPIIl\y benefits, The Arhltrntors later Isslleel n clnrlflcatleJf1 of tllolr (**t120] nwnnlln response to n request Py Nntlonwlele, Thorenftor, Natlonwlele fIIoll a MotlQn to correcl/Vllcnto lIHI Arl]ltl'ntlon AWllrrlto which nn A\1swor was fllpd ami ornlllrOUI1111\1t wns prllsontoll, Thll sole Issue hefore thll court WilS whllthor Soclnl Seclll'lty (lIanhlllty hllneflts ShOll lei be deehlcteel from tile arl]ltrn\lon nwnrcl (lI1del' the tllrms of fi 1722 of tho Mo\or Vohlclll I'lnn\1clnl Reo\Jonslhlllty I.nw (MVI'RI.), 75 Pn,C,S,A, 1701 ot seq, Thll court rulllelthal Social Secmlty ellsal>lIty honoflls plllel nnel paynlJlll to Appelln\1ts must 1>0 doelllr.tllel fl'omtllo nwarcl, IHHI red(ICoclthll arbltl'a\ol'r.' award accorcllnoly, Wo reverSll, ' - - - - - . - - . - - . . - - - - -l'ootnotllS' . - - . . - . - - . - . - . . - - nl An aoreement which proVleles for Arbitration \IIHllll' the Act of 1027 pOl'mlts modlflcntlon 01' cOl'l'llcllon of an I1I'I]l\l'lItlon Ilwllrd whllre It Is contrary to IlIw llndls suchllHlthnellt been II verdict of 11 jury the court WOllldhllVe entflred a dlfforent Judomont 01' 11 jlldoment not.wlthstanellng the Vfl relict , Soe 501(b) of the Act of 1000 set forth In the hlotorlol1l note Immedllltely follOWing 42 Pa,C,S,A, fi '7302, Soe ulso Selecteel Risks Ins, co, v, Thompson, 363 Pa, Supel', 34, 525 A,2d 411 (1007), affirmed 1\1 port, reversed In part, 520 Pn, 130, 552 A,2d 1302 (10119), - - - . . . . . . - . . . - - . -I:nd footnotes- - - - - - . - - - . . . - - - - [***3] Atlss(le Is the language of fi 1722 ami the recovery of Soclnl SocUl'lty disability payments, fi 1722, PreclUsion of recovering I'eqlllred benefits In any action for damages against a tortfessor, or In any l,nlnsmed or underlnsured motorist proceeding, arising out of the malntennnce or lIse of a motor vehicle, IlIJerson who Is eligible to receive benefits under the coverages set forth In this Sllbc laptel', 01' worker's componsatlon, 01' any program, OI'OUP contrf1ct or other al'rnngel1lent for payment of benefits os deflnodln section 1719 (relating to coordination [*664] of benefits) shnll PO pl'oclueled from recovol'lno the amount of peneflts pnld 01' paynble under this subchnpter, or worl<er's compensation, 01' any program, grollp contract 01' othol' fll'l'angement for payment of benefits as defined In section 1719, 75 Pa,C,S,A, fi 1722, In Interprotlng 9 1722 to determine whether Social Security disability peyments were oncompassedlnthe lan9Uage of "any proOl'am, group contra,ct or other arrangement" the trial coult lool<ed to the language of fi 1710 and a decision ofthls c:nurt which concerned application of fi 1719. soctlon 1710 entitled "coordination of benoflts" stotes In relevant pal'll [***41 . (a) General rule, . Except for workers' compensation, 0 policy of Insurance Issuoel or delivered pursuant to this subchapter shall be primary, Any program, group contract or other orrnngoment for payment of benefits such os destrlbed In section 1711 (relating to requlrod benefits [modlcal)) 1712(1) ond (2) (relalll19 to availability of benefits [medlcol andlncol1le loss)) or 1'115 (relatll1g to the , availability of mlequate limits [medlcnl, Incol11o lOBS, occldel1tnl denth and funel'6l]) sholl bo construed to contain a provision that 011 benefits provided therein .,.Irolrlcvc'l_I1l=!l740522 nm205nBo!l7cc7405J 70!.lJ2\ &,..browHcTypc=TEXTONL Y &,..fllltslt=F 9/291!.l!.l 1\ll;IS,C01l1(SM) lOot 1\ ()nollmolll . h>, Clt!ltlon . 449 P!I, SUPOI', f1(i I PII803 (lf4 shl1l1 hlllnllxc\lss of Melnot In elllpllcl1tlon of I1ny vl1l1ell1nd colloctlhlll first pl1l'ty IllJnoflts provlrlodln Boctlon 1711, 1712 01' 1715 01' WOI'I<lll's' componsl1tlon, (Il) Poflnltlon, . As IIsodln this socllon thlllol'm "PI'OOI'I1Il1 OI'Ollp cpnll'l1ct 01' olhol' IlI'l'I1nooll1ont" InclllClos, hilt Is not IImltod I'll, honoms pl1Yl1lllo hy 11 hospital plnn corporl1Uon 01' 0 pl'nfesslonolhllultl1 Slll'Vlco cOl'pol'l1tlon, , " 75 PI1,C,5,A, G 171 0, Notlno th!1t 50cl!11 511CUl'lty ellsohlllly honoflls 01'0 not spllclflr.nlly montlonlld Inolthel' G 17;!2 01' !l1710, tho tl'll1l COIIl't WIlS OUlcloellJY tills COIIl't's doclslonln l'anlcl101l1 v, I-Iborty Mlltlml Inslll'l1nco [*n5] Co" 435 1'11, 5\1pol', 290, 645 A,2d 065 (1991\), Therein the plaintiff slJllfJht to collor.t Incomo loss bonoflts but his Insul'ol' cll1ll11oel that It WI1S ontlLled to set offs for slcl< tlmo paymonts I'ecolvod hy pllllntlff froll1 his omployer I1nel $oclal Security benoflts thai: plaintiff WflS I'ecelvlno, The I'Mlchel1l [*665] court concluded thllt 9 1719 must pelntel'pretllrl to tl1ko Into consldel'l1tlon pl'OOl'l1ms for the pl1ymen\: of Income loss henllflts, The court ruled thallho pllllntlff was ontltlod to I'ecovol' Inwrno loss boneflts from the elofendant without doductlon for slcl< pay Ilonoflts Ilnd Social Security boneflts he I'ocelved, The cOlll't I'ellsonodl "MI', Pllnlcholll has 'paid' for tho slcl< pay benllflto ami social sllcul'lty benefits he has recolved, The social socurlty boneflts come at tho exponso of n PflYl'oll tax deduction end slcl< pay Is a benefit employers factor In when settlno waOlls for employeos, Accol'dlnoly, any 'double clipping' 1111S come I1t the expense of some form of payment hy the claimant for ellch type of recovery," Id, at 296, 61\5 A,2d at 068, The Suprel11e COllrt reviewed the Panlchelll decision and affirmed, Pl1nlchelll v, I-IIJerty Mutual, Pn, , 6nO A,2d 930 [**"'6] (1996,) The Suprel11e Court concurred With [**1129] tllo Superior COl,ut's deterll1lna~lon that the receipt of both employer provided sick leave boneflts and social seclIl'lty disability benefits, as wolllls full Income loas ben~flts does not reslllt In "double dlpplno," td. (slip opinion at 5,) The cOllrt concllldlld that both slcl< PIlY and social secllrlty boneflts progrlllns I11l1st be constrlled as providing benllflts In excess of qnd not In dllpllcatlon of, Incol11e loss beneflto, Id, Because of the referenceln!l1722 to !l171!), the trial court detlll'lnlned that the Social Security disability pllyments received In this case were benefits lindeI' "qny program, group contract or other arrangell1ent fOI' the payment of benefits as defined In sElctlon 1719", Thus the court reasoned under !l1722 Appellnnt was pl'eclllded from rec\lverlno Incol11e loss benefits In that IlInOlll1t, The problem With the trial COIIl't's reasonlno Is lhat It does not look to other related sllctlons of the Motor Vehicle Hesponslblllty Law and does not consider the reasonlno behind the decisions In I'anlchelll, This sal11elangllaoe, concol'l1lng any "program, oroup contract 01' other arrangel11ent," [***7] Is also contained In 42 Pa,C,S,A, G 1720, Section 1720 eliminates sllbrogntlon and provides I In actions arising out of tho maintenance 01' use of a motor vehicle, there shall be no rloht of subrogation or relmbursoll1ent [*666] from a claimant's tort recovulY with rl1spect to workers' compensation benllflts, benefits available under section 1711 (I'elatlno to required benefits), 1112 (relatlno to availability of benefits) 01' 1715 (relating to availability of ndeqllate limits) 01' benefits paid 01' pllyable by a prOOl'am, group contract or other al'ranoement whether' primary 01' excess under sectlonl'l19 (relatlno to coordination of benefits), ~ 42 l'a,C,S,A, !llno, "Jrotrlol'o'l_,ll1~H74c522fTm2c5I1HcH7cc74()53 7()1)32 I &JlI'l1\l'scTYJlo~TEXTONL y &_flnlslI=F 9/21)/99 IOliIH,COl1l(SM) lOot II nOC\II\1CI\\ . hy Cilllllon . 441) /111, SIIPOI', filii 1I111l0 4 0 r 4 Soctlol\ 1720 clol'lfloo thot 1\0 slllJl'oootlon will 11\111'0 to poyol'a of hOl\aflla 51 miloI' 10 \hoso 110noma oVollolJlo lllHlal' mHo Insul'ol\co. Pl'lIVlollsly, IIl11plpyol's or II\Slll'Ol'S waro ontltle(1 \0 suhHlgolo thillI' cll111116 In lhll'(j pOl'ly tOl'tff.l0601' octlons, In slIch Instoneos gl'()llP hoolth Insul'ol's which Pl'oVldod honoflt>> wore pennlLtod to sf.lok 6llhl'ogotlol\ whon the In>>lll'od pl'ollght a thll'(' pmty tOl'tfoosol' octlon. Tho 10glslotlVo pl'OnollnCOl11ont In g 1720 ollllllnotos tho right of sllhl'ogo\lon. SoctlOI\ 1722, 11\ IIffect, COl11pol\slltes for this m!J\lstmont [~*"l<8] Py prohibiting thooo InJul'o(1 fl'OIl1 I'ocovorlng thoso SIlI110 Ilolloflls, Thus, wl10ro hOlloflts sll11l1al' to thoso fOlllld Innn allto Insul'llnco policy woro onco rocovomhlo Illl\ thonlotol' sUIJJoct to SllPl'ogo\lon, now lllHlul' fi 1722 they simply cllnnotllo 1'0COVol'od, thol'ohy ellmlnotlng tl10 1100(1 for sllhl'ogotlon, In Soc\lon 17;!;! tho 10glslntuI'0 IH1S pl'oclu(lo(' 1'0COVOl'y, whol'o In tho pl1st sllPl'ogl1tlon roslllto(, In 11 rodllctlon of tho I'ocovol'y Py 1'0flllll'Ing 0 poyhock hy tho InJul'or! party, Tho chllngos IJI'Ollohtnho\it In fi 1?;!0 1II1r! fi 1?;!2 hovo ZOI'O Ilat offor.t on tho InJurod party. r~ocouso 50clol Soclll'lty dlsahlllty bonaflts WOI'O nevol' sllhJoct to subrogation thoy do not fall within tllo purview of Sactlons 1 no and 1722. Hlstorlc~IIY thay hava not baol1 vlowod as 1lI1 Itol11 for which a traditional tort award WOlfld Ilal'oducod, 1'111(1 tho loglslatul'o wlsharlto Il1clll(lo soclol SocUl'lty dlsohlllty poymonts within tho preclUSions of fi 1?;!2 It could hovo specifically no mod theso poymonts, IlS WllS (Iono with workors' cOl11pansotlon ponams, Sactloll 1722 was oPVlously deslgnod to I'ofor to only those benoflts which 111'0 spoclflc<llly rocovol'llble <IS first 111Il'ty benoflts under the MVFf\I-, 75 [*667] Pa,C,S,A fi 1701 ot seq., 01' which hod ["*9] 11storlcally been subject \0 sUPl'ogatlon, Social Socul'lty dlsaplllty paYlnonts do not m within elthor cotegolY, Our concluslpn Is In kooplng with tho I'oasonlng bohlnd the decision In Panlcholll, It was noted that Soclol Socurlty disability po noms al'o bonoflts for which tho employoe has paid In tl1e f01'1n of payroll doductlons, Tho rocelpt of thaso boneflts by tho pllllntlff In Panlchelll, and their rocolpt In this case, do not constltuto "douplo dipping," Appolll1nt hilS paid for those benoflts tlll'OLlgholl~ his working CI1I'OOI' I1nd has paid a sopal'l1to pl'omlum to bo compensotod for all loss causod by I1n unlnsul'od motorist, Hecovory of both Is not dupllcatlVo, Hl1lhol' It Is filiI' and contompll1tod by tho tOl'lnS of tho MVI'HL, Accordingly wo concludo that tho Ilrpltl'otors did not 01'1' whon they I'ofllsad to II1l1ko ["1130] an offsot for Social Socurlty disability benoflts IIpald or peYl1blo," Tho trial court's rUling deducting thoso bonoflts Is rovorsad and tho court Is ordorad to 1'0lnstl1to the award of tho I1l'bltl'atol's, Judge S<lylor concLll'S In the rosult, HOlYloo: L1:Xlll:EiIll Ollollonl 074 02d 1127 Vlaw: Full Oolommal Wodnnsday, Soplomhnr 20, 1000.0:50 AM EDT A\lPIII WXle.NgXIIJ I TOIIIW Gml Q911<1II1PIIS Oopyrlohl "'1000 LEXIU.Nr:XIB 0'0"1', All rlohl' lo,orvoll, '. ...Irctrlcvc'l,..I1F'H74c522 f'IHl2c511HcH7cc7405J 70()J2 I &Jl1'll\1'6cTYjlc~TIJXT()NL y &_fll1lsll~=F 1)/2lJ/1)1) MIOHASI.. RAYSON Pllllntlff v, I IN THI3 OOURT OF COMMON PI..I:AB I OUMBI:RI..AND OOUNTY, PJ:NNSYI..VANIA I I OIVII.. AOTloN - I..AW I NO, 00-1105 I I I ARBITRATIoN ABJ3.IIBAIION..MEMORAtlIDUM PJ:TRA SHlflFJ:R, Pofond"nt ANP NOW, comes petra Sl1lffer by l1er llUOrneys, N~AI..ON & GOVEr~, ami fIIellll1e following Arbitration Memorandum, I, PROOEDURAI. HISTORY Plaintiff flied a Civil Compl<1lnt against tile Defendt1l1t on April 16, 1000, In tile Court of Oommon pleas, oumberland County, On May 10, 1000, tile Defendant flied a Notice to Plead and Answer wltl1 El New Matter, On May 14, '1000, Plaintiff flied a Reply to Defendant's New Maller, Depositions In tills m<1ller were Qonduoted on JUly 27, 1000. II, STATEMENT OF THE CASE On June 22, 1000, at approximately 7:10 AM, tile Defendant was attempting to merge onto Interstate 01 from I~ol.ltes 11/15, As tile Defendant merged onto Interstate 01, anotl1er automobile pulled Into tile lanG tile DefGndant WaB uttemptlng to enter, Due to tile presenoe of tills automobile, tile defendant was oaused to pull baol< onto tile Bntranoe mmp, and struol\ tile rear of tile Plaintiff's automohlle, Tile Defendant did apply l1er brakes upon sf.lelng tile Plalntlfrs Btopped automobile, end wae only traveling approximately 10 to 'I Ii miles per 1101.11', Neltl1er tile Plaintiff nor tile Defendant olalmad to l1ave suflored any InJurlea Immadlately after the aopldenl, The Pefendant'a hood and frant bumper were damaged in the accident, bll! the Plalntlfra vehicle auffered minimal clamage, Defendant oontenda thRt the Plaintiff la 110t enllllfld to reoover for wagea already paid by a separate dlllablllty In!lurer, The Defendant maintains that the Plalnllff 11a!l already I1een fully oompensated throlluh a groUp health dlaablllty prO(]l'am provided by his employer, thus mailing the Plfllnllff Inellgll1le to reoelve addlllonal oompenaatlon, III. QU~ST'ON PRE8~NTEP POES ~1722 OF THE PENNSYLVANIA MOTOR VEHIOLE FINANOIAL RESPONSII3IL TY ACT PREOLUPI~ THE PLAINTIFF FROM ANY ADDITIONAL RECOVERY WHEN HE HAS ALREADY REOEIVED COMPENSATION UNDER A DISABILITY POLICY THROUGH HIS P~ACE OF EMPLOYMENT? Suggested an!lwer In the affirmative. IV. ARGUM~NT In Carroll v. /(epllart, the appellflntln a !lult for Injurlea arising from a motor vehicle aooldent attempted to reoover wage losa from the appellesa In addition to slole pay benefits reoelved from her employer. In Oarro", the COUl'l stated thElt the Plaintiff, "'paldl for alole pay benefits she reoelvod from her employer In the form of lower Wllges, (ool1aequently) they are 110t bel1eflta within the purview of ~1722," 717 A,2d 554 (Pa. Super 1990), The Superior Court'a reaaol11119 111 Carrol! paralleled that uaed by the Supreme Court In Pan/challl v. Liberty Mutual Insuranoe Group, The Supreme Court noted that, "SoolElI 'I Seourlty dlaf.1plllty henema are Ileneflta fm whloh the employee hEls flEllcl In the form of payroll deqllotlona," 543 PEl, 114, GGO A,2d 030 (1 OOCi), The Oarroll Court oontlnues, "The reoelpt of these Ilenefltaln PIlII/ollelll, Elnd their reoelpt In (OllrI'DII), do not oonstltute 'douple cllpphlO'," Oa,.,.o/ll:1t 550, The InatElnt oaae differs from Otlrroll In tlll'lt the Plaintiff did not have a oontrElotuElI agreement with his employer to provlcle disability peneflta, nor did he malle payments or reoelve lower wages as a result of the employer's health care progmm, The Plalntlfrs employer simplY offered dlsaplllty coverage through a group health plan as a gratuitous heneflt to the employees, The Pennsylvania Motor Vehlole FlrlElI10lal Responsibility Act, 75 Pa,C,S,A. 91722, Indloates thf'lt, "In <lny €lotion for damages Elgalnst El tortfeasor, '''' a person who III eligible to reoelve benefits under the ooverage set forth In this supohapter '''' or any program, grouP r,ontraot or other arrangement for pElyment of peneflts '" shall be preoluded from recovering the I:1mount of peneflts paid or pc1YElble under this sUPohl:1pter, '." or any progralll, group oontraot or arrangement for payment of penaflta," At tho time of the acoldent, the Plaintiff was eligible to reoelve ooverage under a group disability program provided by his employer, Thill type of payment olearly falls within the gUidelines of 91722 as "any program, group contraot or othor arrangement for payment of benefits," Consequontly, pursuant to 91722, the Pllllntlff Is preoluded from recovering the amount of benefits already paid for disability by his omployer, IOl\ls.pol11(SM) lOot II PoclI\l1cnl. hy Cltlllloll' 54] PI\, 114 PlIun I off! I, I I 543 P,1, 114, "/ 66U A,2rl 93(1, "I 1906 I'll, ~(JX!5 13, ".. ANTHONY .1, pAN1CHt=I.I.l, Appellee v, 1.113I:Il'lY MUTUAl. lNSUIlANcE G'~OUp, AppellQll~ No, 21 WeNtorn Plotrlr.t Appnal pocl<ot 1905 SUI'IlI:MI= COUIlT OF I'ENNSYl-VAN1A 543 I'll, 1141 660 A,2d 03Q) 1096 I'u, I.EXIS 13 .1 Septemher 21l, 100!l, AIlGUI:D JnnuulY 10, 1006, DEClDrm PI\IOR HISTORY, [***1] Appoul from the ordor of ~ho 5\11)01'101' Comt I:ntored on July 20, 1004, ut No, 1036 pGH, 1093, Afflrmlno tho order oftho Court Common I'loos of Alleoheny County, Civil Division I:ntered on Octohor 25, 1003, ut No, [J20 of 1902, 435 I'n, super, 200, 645 A,2d 86S (1904). JUDGl:s 13r:I-OWI Hon, Il, Stunton WeHlcle, .11', (C,C,p,), I<I:I.I.Y, FOllD I:I.I,IOTI, BIlOGI<Y, 5,.1" .1.1, (super,), CORI! i'IlRMSI oross Intorno, social socllrlty, actuulloss, monthly, sick, Insurod, slcle louve, Inllurer, motor vehicle, first purty benuflts, salnry, disability, motor vehlelu acclclunt, untitled to receive, sllll1malY judoment, doublo, calculntlno, afflrnmnco, abuse ot cllscrotlon, doublo recovery, InjUry I1I'lslno, munlfest,.lssulnOr dl8ublllty benefits, dlssentlno opinion, benefits pllyahle, loss of Income, Injurod party, ca culutlon, dupllcetlon c:oUNSIll,l 1'01' 1.lherty Mutual, Apl'l:l-l-ANTI John p, 1300lnskl, I:squlre, .1, I:rlc I3nrchlosl, I:squlre, For A, Pnnlchelll, AI'PEI-LEI:I Michael E, I<ennedy, Esquire, stephon M, Groecher, .11'" I:squlre, Amicus Curiae, Fall APPELLeE, JUDGeSl Mil, CHIEF .JUsTICr: IlOBeRT N, c, NIX, m" FI,AHEIlTY, ZArrAI.A, CArry, CASTILLe, MONTI:MURO, JJ, Mr, Justice Montemuro, who WoS slttlno hy deslonatlon, did not participate In the decision of this case, Mr, Justice Castillo flies a dlssentlno opinion In which Mr, Justice Fluhorty joins, OPINIONllYI CArry OPINIONI [*115] [**931] OPINION MR. JUSTICa CAPrYI DeCIDeDl January 18, 1996 This uppeal presonts us with un 18suo of flr8t Ill1presolonl whether slele pay und social security benoflts I'acelved by un InsUl'od should hll deducted lJy un Insul'el' In culculatlno tho Insurod's "uclulIlloss of gl'OS9 Incomo" undor socllon1712(2) of tho Pennsylvania Motol' Vehlclo I'lnunclol Responsibility Low (MVI'RL), nl We concludo for tho r0080ns which follow, thut the Insurer muy not mnko such doductlon9 In calculatln\lll,e In9urod's uctuulloSD of gr09S Incomo, Accordingly, we afflrll1 tho doclslon of tho Superior Courl. ,_ _ . _ . - . . . . . . " - . " . .I'oolnotes" - . . . " . - - . . " . . " . . " .,,/rclrlcvc'I_lllc822I\b7cb2112c96ccc9655bfU 1 I 566ccO&JlrowBcTypccTIlXTONL Y &_0111811'=1' 9/29/99 IcxI8,CPI11(IlM) I nolI! \)pcIIl\lunl. hy Clllllion- !i4~ I'll, 114 (lllg\l2orCi nl Tl10 Act of I'ollf'llflry 12, 19(14, 1',1" 26, No, 11,75 I'n,C,S, 9 1701018oq, - . - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -r:ncl Foolnoli\s- - . . - - - - .. . . . . .. - - - [***2] Tl10 facls olvlno rlsolo tills I1ppoalarutl1nt Antl10ny J, Pl1nlcl1oll1 (Panlcl1elll) was Injllrodln a motpr vohlcloacclelonl on Pocomllor 2, 1 01l7, Pl1nlcl1olll was In811rocl I1t tho \lma UncleI'll IJOllcY1IssuoclllY 1.lborly 1'1l!lllllllnslll'l1nco GrPllp (1.lllOrty Mlltuul), wl1lcl1 Wus wrllton unci sSllee In /lcr,orclunco wltl1 tl10 provhllons of tile MVFRI., Tills policy provlclocl for Incomo loss honoflts lindoI' tl1u COl1'lblnntlon Flrsl I'nrty 130nllflts provision, I'lInlcl1ulll, who WI1S ronclorucl lln/lbll1to 1'101'1< I1S 11 roslllt of tl10 Injljrlolll1o sustalnoelln tl1ul1cclclont, fllucla claim wltl1l.lberty Mutlll1l for loss of InconwlJflnuflts, ()urlno tl10 purlod from POCOmllClr 3, 1907 tl1rouoh Auollst , 1, 1900, Pl1nlcl1oll1 roculvocl sick poy bonoflts from ilia employur Inl1n 1111l011ll10quol to ilia oross Incomu, I-Iborty ~'lul:lIl1l, tul<lno tl10 poal\lpn tl1l1tlt WIlS ontltloclto sol-off for l'anlcl1olll'a slcl< Pl1Y IJonaflt rocalvod by 111m, cllet not PI1Y /lny 1i1come loss bonoflts clurlno tl1la tlmo, 1,Iberty Mutuol beoon mol<lno Incomll loss beneflta to 1'0nlcl10111 of tor AlIOIIsl I, H>OO, but tool< a set. off In [*116] Iln umount oqllal to I'nnlcl1elll's montl1ly soclnl SOcl1rlty clls/lblllty bonom wl1lcl1 he was then recelvlno, n2 . - .. - - - . . - - . - - - - - - - -Footnotes- . . . . - . . .. - - - - .. . - - . n2 1'1'101' to Ills accldelit, l'anlcl1olll's oross montl1ly Incomo wns ~ 2,733,50, Liberty Mulllnl ruducocj tills amount by n 20% rlecluctlon pursuant to 9 1712(2) of tl10 MVFRI., for a resultlno amount of ~ 2,106,00, Tl1olnslll'or furtlw roc!\lcod tills nmount by Ills montl1ly $ 057,00 social security dlsoblllty benoflt, for anet monthly Income loss benefit eF $ 1,320,90, - - - - - . . . . . . . . . . . .r:ncl Footnotus- - - - - - - , - - - - - . . . - [***3] Ponlcl1ulllll1en flied \:110 Instant octlon uoalnst Liberty Mutual seel<lno tile full amount of Ills montl1ly solary less thu 20% statlll:ory deduction, for 0 pllyment I1mounl of $ 2,106,00, Tho trll1l court entered summalY judoment In fl1vor of l'unlcl1ulll, Tile Superior Court !1fflnnecl tills deciSion, !lncl allowance of !1ppel'11 was Ol'unted by this Court, In our review of a ol'l1nt of Sllml11UI'Y judOl11ent, we must detormlne whether thore wes an orror of 1111'1 01' a clel1r or l11!1nlfest allllSU of discretion. Lened 1'lol11e~ v, PopUl'tl11ent of I-Icenses und Inspections, ,306 Pu, 50, 123 ^,2d 406 (1956), After tllOl'ouohly revlewlno tho Issue beFore liS, we find no merit to I-Iberty Mutual's !1rOllment lhalthe MVFRI- must be construed to provont whut tile Insul'ol' Is closcrlbln9 I1S "cloUble 1'0covelY" by the Insured, I,e" l'ucovel'Y of slcl< pay 01' soclol security disability [**932] benuflts, 115 well 119 first party loss of Incomo benefits unclor tho policy, Section 1712(2) provides thut I1nlnSlll'el'lssulno motor vohlclollablllty policies sl1alll11alle avallablo for purcl1ase first party benefits wlll1l'espocl to Injury I1l'lslno oul of the l11ulntenance 01' use of!1 1110tol' vehicle, which benefits 111'0 to Include 1 (2) Income 10BB benoflt.-- [***'1] Includes the followlnOI ' (I) Elohty pOl'cent of I1ctlll1lloss of OI'OSS Incol11e, 75 flu,C.S, Ii ~712(2)(el11phl1sls adcled), Wo aOl'oe with tho 101'101' courts that Llborty Mutlll1l's I'ollunce 011 the discuss 1011 In Pel'sll< v, Nutlonwldu Mutul1l Ins, to" 302 Pa, Super, 29, 554 ^,2d 930 (1909), I1110c. denied, 522 fla, 613,563 ^,2d 499 (1909), of actuullo8s of ol'OSS IncOl11e undor tl111 MVI'HL us l'uqull'lng tho ,,;/l'u\I'IU\'u'/ _l\1"'H22I1h7uh2112ulJ6ccc%55hlU 11%6ucO&Jll'oll'suTypc=TUXTONL Y &,)1nI811'=1' 9/29/99 IOl\lu,ooll1(flM) I ClollI 1l111I\l\llClll . hy Cllllllo11 . 543 I'll, 114 I'lIgo 3 orfi losa ho "1'001" f llR oppo. Rod to tl1oorotlcf.1l, la I11Ir.plocod, TI10 Suporlol' COUl't'11 1'l11l110 111 POI'I1I1( die' not 1l~lctl'o~n tno CJuostlon of wl10t conl1W\ltul1o ["117] clo\I\Jlo rocovary of OI'OI1U Il1cul11o, I11Rtoocl/ It doolt with tho 11111\IU of Wl10tl1or Oil I1ccldont vlctll11 \'/110 wor. IInomployo(1 on tl10 doto of tl10 nccl(hlllt/ ond tlllls Wos not oUl'l1lno nnln(.ol11ll11t tl10 tlmo, 110s 1111(1 I1n nctllnllos6 of . 01'066 Incol11u \iI1dul' 6 171 ;1(2) of tl10 MVFRI" '1'110 lo\,/o\, cOllrlu/ In CtlnBtrulno tl1u pl11'II110 "octunllosu of 01'0116 Incomo"ln fi 1'11;1(2)/ np\ll'OPl'lntulY Ul1ClOIlV,l1I'Od to olvo offact to 1111 of tl10 provlslon5 of tl10 MVf'RI., t\ll'nlno fo\, OIl d/lnco to 61719, SUCl ZIIl1mOl'I11/1n v, O'11/1nnon, 497 Po, 55,\/'14;1 A,2d574 (19U2), Suction 1719 of tl10 MVF'~I. pl'ovlde5 I 6 1719, C(lDl'I"m~t'l.'lll of \Jonams(ll) lianol'llI [""*!j] I'ule,..lixcupt for \,/01'1(el"5 compen5otlon, II policy of In5111'0nCO IUl1ued 01' (Iollverod pur5ullnt to tills sullcl1llptor sl1l1U ho primary, Any prooram/ oroull contrllct 01' otl1er lH'ranOOment for pllymont of benefltu sUCl1l1s descrlhod In soclon 1711 (l'ellltln\J to reCJulro(1 hOIlt'lflls) 1712(1) IInd (;1) (relntlno to IIVllllahlllty of \Jenoflts) 01' soctlon 1715 (relllUno to IIvlllllllllllty of llcloCJUl1te IIl11lts) sl1ol1 be conuU'ued to contain 11 provlulon tl1llt lllllJeneflts provided tl1eroln sl1ol1 he In excess of and not In dupllclltlon of any vllllcland collectlllle first pllrtv Ilenoflls provlde(lln sectlCln1711, 171;1 or 171501' WOI'I(el's' cumpensntlon,(h) paflnttlon,--As useclln tills section, the term "prOOl'lIm/ OI'oUp contrnct ur otl1ol' nrrllnoemenV' Includes, hut Is not limited tOt benefits pllYllhle Ily n 110spltol pllln corporatlpn 01' Il profusslonal henlth service corporotlon subject to 40 Po,c,S, Ch, 61 (relotlno to hospital pion corporations) 01' 53 (rel<ltll1o to professlol1l11 heolth sorvlces plan corporations), The lower courtn reosonell that the reforence In !i 1719(0) to 9 1712(2) shol'ls on Intent on the pllrt of the Leolslature to 01101'1 excess recovery of 1'1000 benefits paY<llllo under ony proornl11/ oroup [***6] contrnct, 01' otl1er arrunoement. The lower COlll'ts reasoned tl1l1t slcl< poy and social security are "proorams" which prOVide poyment of benefits when thlil nblllty to elii'll Income Is Impaired, As tile trial court stoledln Its woll"reasoned [* 110] oplnlon, the terms In 61719(11), "anY proorllm" IInd"otl1er orr<lnoel11ont" for poyment of benefits, ore extremoly broad and easily encompas6 both slcl( loovo Ileneflts Ilnd SOCllll socllrlly benefits, I-Iberty Mutunl uroes thllt tho exampllls used In 9 1719(1l) show the Intent of the I.eolslnture to encompflSS only heolth cllre benefit plnns In tile definition of "IJrooroms" In !i 1719(0), Tills orgument, howuvol'/ falls to nddress tile "Includes, but Is not Imltod to" lonounoe In !l171lJ (Il). Moroovor, It flllls to tol<e Into conuldoratlon the rufel'onco mode In [j 1719(0) to!i 171;1(2), We aoree with tho lower courts that, bosod on the InnOW1oe of!i 1,719(0)/ slel( poy Ilnd social security Ileneflts proorams must Ile construed os providing benefits In excess oft IIndnot In duplication oft the Income loss Ileneflts payoblo under !i 1712(2), , Ponlchelll's receipt of Iloth ol11ployer provldocl slcl( leove boneflts ond SOCllll security dlseblllty Ileneflts, liS well os fulllncol11e loss bonoflts, [***7] does not result In "double dlpplno", Those lire benefits for wl1lch tho employee hos poldln tile form of lower wnoes for the sick leave Ileneflts ondln tile forl11 of poyroll deductions for tile soclnl security benefits, ThUS, In recelvlno his slcl< leovo poy/ I'lInlcl1elll wos exhoustlng his oomed employee benefit. slmllmly, Panlchelll hos paid for [**933] soclol security disability Ileneflts through pllyroll deductions, and he Is nol'l drowln\l on tl1ese Ileneflts Ilocouse his accident l1as rendered him unallle to work, Liberty Mutuol wouldl1ave liS loso Sight of the fnet that panlcllolll hos pold for his Incol11e loss Ileneflts through prel11lul11s he paid Uberty Mutuol with Ills own funds, He Is entitled to 1I1C0l110 loss benefits under his policy In tho full al110unt of his Income loss without any offset for sick pny 01' social security benoflts received by hll11, n3 . " " " . '" " . . . - . " . . " . 'I'ootnotes" " " . " " " . . " . . . - . " . " "Jl'olrlovo'l_111"'822I\h7oh21\2ul)(iooc9fl55hlU I 1566ocO&JJI'lllvucTypo=TEXTONL Y &..fintRII=F 9/29/99 10~ls,colll(SM) I CM II 1)110111110111" hy Clllltll1l1" 543 I'll, 114 l'lIlJO 4nf6 113 f.10C/Hlao 1'10 Ilolloyo Ihnl Iho MV/'Hl. nllo\,/u tho InBlll'Oclln rocoVllr IJlllIOnlS for which 110 hOH flolcl 01' onl'l1ocllhrolluh hla 0l11ploYl110111, liS 1'1011 ns Il1col11o 11ll1B bOl1oflls, 1'10 cnnnolllorao wllh \hu ellssonVa poaltlol11hol PnnlchulllIII I'flcolVll1u 0 wlndfnll horu which Is conlrnry 10 Iho Inlonl ,,, of Iho MVFRI-, Tho e1lsllol1l's posltlol1 WOlllel \lClllnlly sorvo to 1'01'111 I'd I1n Insllroel 1'1110 has ullhol' ClxhIH10lud 01' Is npl Clllolblo fOI' sick lonvo bUl10flls or aoclnl socurlly cllslllJllIlY nllho tlmn of tho ncclelol1tlJY flnclll10 nil octllnllpsa of orpSH II1CCll110 to Ihl11 porson, whllo p\II1IHhI110 1111 Insurod Whol /1t tho tlmu of thol1ccldol11, IUI6 I1Cc\ll11ull1locllllck lonvo 01' ollolhllllY for BPCI'lI socllrlly ells'lllllty, lly flnelll1U rocolpt pf Ihoso bUl10flls 10 IlUnr llpOlllll1l ollolblllty for Il1como Ipss Ilul1Clflts cpvornon ul1elor his Insul'<1nco ppllcy, , . . " . . . " . " . " " " . . "J:nd Fooll)olos" " .. . . " . . , " " . . " . "" [***0] [* 119] As 1'10 porcolve no 01'1'01' of Il1w PI' 11111111fost nbuso of cllscrotlpl1ln tho lower CPllrts' eloc:lslons, tho Suporlor COllrlls Orelor nfflrl11ll1o entry of HUl1111111ry juelOl11on\ In fnvor of I'nnlcholllls horeby nfflrmed, ' MI', Justice Montomuro, who wns altllno by eloslon'ltlol1, cllelnol flnrllclpnlo Inlhe decision of this cnse, Mr, Justice Casllllo flle~ n ellssen\ll1o pplnlon In which Mr, Juutlco Flohprly Joins, PI/iSI:lNTIIYI CASTII-I-!: PI/iSf;lNTI ,PISSI:lNTING OPINION MR. JUSTIcl:l CASTII.I.I:l PI:lCIPI:lP, JanulIrv 10, 1996 The effllct of the majorltv pplnlon essenllally allows a party who Islnjurlld In n 1110tor vehicle acclclent to monetarily profit from their Injury, and In SPl11e casos reap boneflts thatwoulelln effect double his 01' her salalY, The purpose of tho Motor Vahlcle Flnanclall~esponslblllty I.aw Is simply to 11101<e an Injured pnlty wholelnot to bostow upon an Injured party n windfall. Accordlnoly, I musl dlssont os I dlsaoree with the Superior COllrt's holding and this COlll't's affirmance thereof, following appellee's motor vehicle accident In Decomber of 1907, allpollee rocelved slcl( loave benefits that were e'llllValent tp his monlhly gross Incol11e for 11 pel' od of apPf'Qxlmntely eight mCll1ths, At Ihe [***9] time of his accident, uppollee's monthly oross Incol11e Was $ 2,733,50, Accordltlo to the majority, appellee WOllld bo entitled to receive this $ 2,7.33,50 pel' month In addition to his Income I-oss l3011eflts plll'suant 75 1'0, C,S, fi 1712(2)(1) of tho Motor Vehicle financial Responsibility Law which perl11lts the InSUI'ecJ to receive 00% of his ar.tualloss of gross Income, nl Thus, appolloo would be entitled to receive ['~120] 00% of$ 2,733,5001' $ 2,106,00 pel' 1110nl:I1 plus $ 2,733,50 pel' 1110nth In slcl< pay benefits, Appalleo's total benefits for this eight month period (slcl( pay pillS Income loss benefits) would equal approximately $ 39,362,40, Had appellee not boen Injured during this some Period he would have recelvod $ 21,060,00, Thus, the Superior Court's ruling allows llPpelloe to nearly e10llblethe 1110nthly Incol11e he would havo received had he not been Injured, " . . . " .. . . . . " . " . " . 'Footnotes. " . " . . " " " . . " . . . " . . nl Section 1712(2)(1) states In relevant pal'll ., ./rolrlovo'l_Ill"'R22nb7cb2n2olJ6ccolJ65 5h III 115Ci6ccO& JlI'll\VsoTYJlo~TIJXTONl. y &,_ fmtsll=11 9129199 10~ls.coll1(SM) I GUlli 1)0011I1101\\' hy CI\II\1ol\- 543 Pu, 114 PUIlO 5 nf(i , , An Inl>\1I'or Issulno 01' dollvurlno IInhlllty Insurunca policies cpverlno any 1110\01' vel1lcle of tile type roqlllro(1 to Ile roolsturoelllnder \1115 tl\lu, '" sl1ull rrmleu aVi!lIable fpr [lurcl1aso first flarly Il\lneflts wlll1respucl 10 InJ\If'Y orlslno aliI of tl10 11111lntenunco 01' uso of a motor vol1lclo 05 follows 1 (2) Xnlllll11e 10118 Ileneflk-Inclucles tile followlll01 (I) t:lol1ty parcont of uctuolloss of oross Income, 75 Pa, C,S, ij 1712(2)(1) (ern pilosis l1ddaet), - - . - . . - - - . - - - - - - -t:nd Footnotes- - - - . . . - - . - - - . - - - [***10] At tho and of thu aloht montl1 period, In Auoust of l\lOO, llppellea's slcll pay bunaflts ' tormlnatacl at wl1lch time 110 baoan to racCllve $ 057,90 In social security penaflts per montl1 as llresult of Ills Inl.urles, Tile Supurlor COllrt l1eldtl101 appellee wouldll!! entitled to rucelve tills $ 867,00 In lulclltlon /'0 $ 2,106,00 (00% of appellae's forl11er montl1ly gross Income), The 511111 of tl1a social secllrlty heneflts piUS 00% of his 1110ntl11y gross Incoma amounts to $ 3,044,70 Ilar month, Tl1us, 1111(101' this scanarlo, lIpPllllee WOlllcll11alee$ 311,20 pel' 1110ntl1mOI'e tl1l1n hu wouldhava [**934] racelVlld were hu stili worklno ($ 3,044,70 - monthly sulmy of $ 2,733,50 .. $ 311,20), I believe these raslllts fue controry to tl1a purposa of the Motor Vehlcla Flnanclllll~esponslblllty ~llW which was anllctad to curb tile rising costs of alltomobllalnsurllnce, See I-llmhert v, McClllre, 407 Pa, SupaI', 2~i', 262, 595 A,2d 629, 631 (1991)1 Parslk v, NlItlonwlde Mutulll Insumnce Co" 302 Pa, SupaI', 29, 36, 554 A,2c1 930, 934 (1009) (pmpose of tile MVFRI- was to reduce the escalatlno costs of purchaslno Cllr Insul'llnce llnd to confront tl1a prohlams cQllsecl by tha hloh numhars of unlnsllradmotorlsts), The ooal of the Motor Vahlcla [***11J Financial Responsibility I.aw should be to mnlce tha party whola In the event of an acclclent and should not put II party In II better posltlol\than he or she was had the accident not occurred, Profiting from car acclclents fosters fraudnnd encourages mnllngorlno, therehy dofeatlng tho purpose of the Motor Vehicle Flnanr.lall'\osponslblllty Law, This should not be pormltted, Accor(lIng to the plain lanouage of 75 Pa, C,S, Ii 1712(2)(1), all Insured Is entitled to recover only 80% of his 01' hel' Ilc/ul11 loss In gross Incol11e, Haro, nppelloe dlcl not suffer any actunl [*121J economic loss durlno tile first elohtmonths of his Injury becllllse horecelved slcle PllY benefits that were equal to his oross Income, Therofore, pursuant to !i 1712(2)(1) llppellee should bo procluded frol11 rocelvlng any Income loss benoflts durlno the eloht month perllld since appellee did not llctually RUffer a loss In his gross Incomo, With respect to the period following the flight month period, appellee recelvod social security Ileneflts as n dlroct result of the accident, Thus, appellee's nctualloss of gross Income was actufllly helng reduced In part by his social security benefits, Therefore, Llbarty Mutufll should bo permlttecl [***12] to deduct llpplllloe's Socllllsecurlty heneflts from his monthly gross Income before calculating nppallee's actual loss In oross Income ($ 2,733,50 (oross Incomo) $ 057.90 (soclalsocurlty benefits) x 00% .. $ 1,500.40), n2 . . - . . - - . - . - - - - .. - - -Footnotes- - - .. - . - - . .. - . - - - . . . n2 Uberty Mutual argues that Its liability to appellee should be cnlculated hY multiplying his nonnolmonthly solary by 00% and thon subtrllclln\l the social security honeFlts from the 00%, If this calculation were perfonned, Uborty Mutuol would thenllll required to poy nppellee only $ 1,320,90 pOI' month ($ 2,733,50 (gross Incomo) x 00% . $ 057,90 (soclalsocurlty benefits) .. $ 1,320,(0), Were this scennrlo accepted, I.lborty Mutuol would then be pnyln\l less than 00% of appellee's actual loss of oross Income, This assertion Is Incorrect as It also serves to circumvent thelluhlllty Imposed undor!i 1712(2)(1). .,.lrolrluvu'l_m=822nh7ch2n2096cco9655hfU 1 1 566ccO&Jll'llwscTypo"'TEXTONLY &)lntstr=F 9/29/99 A, NON-li(,ONOMlc..n(lMAOEH I , dl!.l!il.ilUlllil1l!Jl~ Mr, Itllys1ll1 did n\l\ IhinK hu wns IlIlurud III Ihu IIcuidunt S(l\lIlU, Allur \l~(llllln!lln!l Infilrmn\lolI with III1l D\lIiJlldllnt. Mr, !tllyson \l'IIvulud npproxlmlltuly threu mllus 1\'\1111 lI\(l IIcehlulll SUUIIU 10 hltl .Ioh, Mr, Itllyson Is umployud liS II douk WOrKul' III HI(lhlhlHlH, hWllled Oil North Indnslrllllltollllllllllln'iHllllll\ (neilI' Wildwood PllrK). Ilowevcr, olleu MI', !tllYSOII lII'rlvud III !tlehlilllds. hu IlIliln)1cd his supurvlsor II1IIt his IIcull nnd shoulders wuru sllll' IIl1d soru 11I1\1 he '!ld nol Ihlnk hu wns ullp1lhlu of pUl'lhl'mllll! his .Ioh 1'0'lull'h11l hOllvy II\lInunllll1101', MI', !tIlYSOII l\lll HlohlbOlls IIl1d WOlllllOlIl\l to Mifflin Coullly IIl1d \lnllo(1 his fhmlly physl\llnll. Dr, Todd A, TllylOl', 11r. Tllylol' UVlIlUlllod MI'. !tllysolllhnl nl\urnooll. 1 ~, llrJml,1 A. Tllylor DI'. Tllylor 1I010dlhlll Mr, Hllyson wns oxporlullclllj! oUl'vlonl plllll IIl1d II dcol'unsod rnn!lU of molloll of his oOl'vlulI1 SpIIlO, Dr. Tllylor onlorod x-l'IIys of his CCl'vloll1 splnu, Thuru WUI'O 110 1l'lIulul'us, Dr, Tllylor mlldu II dhlllllosls or eUl'vlulI1 sll'lllll/Spl'IIlll, MI" HnysolI WIIS phlco(1 on 111111- 1IIIlllll1mlltol'Ios IIl1d musclo-l'ulllxul's whluh Included Motrln HOD Illll, 10 he IIIKUII dlllly IIml Nnrllex 100 Illg. two II1ll0s pOI' dllY, Dr. Tnylol' IlIsll'uulod MI', Huysouto I'umnln 011' worK, Mr, HllysOllluluphollod Dr. Tllylol"s oftloo 011 Juno 26. 199H 10 IIdvlsu Ihnl his nook pnhl IIl1d stltlhoss hmlllot I'usolved. Alllrsl. Dr. Tllylor plnood him on II work I'ostrlclloll of' IIl\lng uo gronler IImll 25 Ihs, Mr, !tuysoll IIdvlscd Dr. Tllylol' IhuI he is I'oquil'cd lolln mol'u limn 25 illS, 011 n rC!lIlIIll' hllSls, DI', Tuylol' pllleed MI'. !tllYSOIl OU II "uo work" sllllus uutll Jllly 4. 199H. On .Iuty 7. 199H MI'. Rllysonl'ctl\l'nod to Dr. Tllylor with Illcl'ollsed lIeek sllmlOSH IIl1d Pili II , lli'. Tllylol' proserlhcd IIOIV IIllII-lnIlIlUlllll1lol'lus, When Mr, HIIYsou rcllll'lIod to Dr, Tllylol' Ihe 203124,1 \UI,I,\f1C 2 tilllnwllll! wuuk, Iw hHlluu\ud 11\111 hu full nil I)' u HlIlJhl hnprnVClnUIl\, Ill', Tu)'lnr pnJsurlhollu unurHU nf physluullhunlPY ullluullhHnu\h. Mr, HlIyHnl1 'VCI1\ III HUU Ill'. TlIylnl' upprn~lmlltul)' uwr)'lwn wOUKS Ihr Ihu lluXI \wn IlInl1\hH, 011 HoPlulllhul' 14, 199H, Ill', Tu)'lnr UXlIlI\lllull Mr, ItllYHOI1 ulld hu IlldlulItolllhut hu WuH o~purlolluhm HUII\U hnprnvclI\ol1l, I\ucunlhmly, Dr, Tu)'lnr porll1l1tod Mr. HlIYllnll III rll\\lI'nln WUl'k. I\\lnuhcd UH ICxhlhll n UI'U Dr. Tu)'lul"H ropnl'l duloll Muroh III, 1999, ICxhlhl1 C 11I'0 nl11cu Iln\uH fl'nm Mmmluln Vlow MUlllolll CUl1lu\, ulld ICxhlhll n nl'O Curlll1clltuH nf DIHlIhlllt)' IHHuollln MI'. HU)'HUI1 h)' Ill'. 'I'uylllI' dutoll7/2/IJH, 7/71911, 7/1 :WII. 7/27/IJIl,1I/14/911 und 9/1/1J11, 3. I IOIlIt hfullilh_:Eh.\'llUlU I thol'nllX I\H Indil1l1\cd, DI', 'I'lIylnl' prcHcl'lhcd phYHicullhul'llpy. MI', Itu)'snlllnllllllcd ph)'slcul thol'uPY on .In I)' 14, 19911 ut IlclllthHnulh. Ilu Ilndorwullt thompy HUHHlnns Ihroo thnuH pOI' wook. IIIH tl'lllllmolll Inoludcd mniHt hout, ultruHuund, Hnn \IIIHUo I11nhllll~Itlnn, 110xl\\I1II>" Htl'otohlng line! HlI'onlJlhonlng, Mr, Rnyunn ropol'lod tn HculthHl1uth fill' hlH I1nul thompy HUHHlon nn Sllptcmhor 14, 19911 IInd WIIH dlHohlll'gcd fhun phYHlcnl thomp)', Attuohod UII ICxhlhll IC 111'0 1I0ulthSnuth'H phYHlcul tlll1l'l1p), l'ouol'llH. Il, ECONOMIC DAMAClHH MI', RU)'Hl1n WUH dlHI\hlod from .Iune 22, 19911, until Septumhol' 15. 19911, All indlcutcd, he is II dock workcr ut RlchfhllllH IIllllllttuchcd IIH ICxhlhll 11111 u cnpy of hili .Inh description, Mr. Ruyson's grnHs wurk lOllS (nut Including 10111 ovcl'limu) WUII $7,637.30. 110 rccelved $3,461.20 limn his I1rHt-purly benefltH ClIl'r1cr, Nlltlonwlde (Soe Exhlhlt G) IIIllI Ihcrofhrc, Hllld 203124.1\tll,I,\9C 3 lII11mmlls IlUllWOVCrnhlu, 75 l'u.C,S,A, ~ 1722, Aeu(1I'l1lIlgl)', Mr, HnYNlll11s uI1l1l1\l(1 10 $:1,(1011,70 hi reeovurnhlu wllgu 10NH, 1101 hwhldlllll uvul1lmu, Moruover, Mr, HIlYSlllllllHO 10HI ellmpul1sllllulllhr tlw ovurtlllw Ihnl hu WOllld hl\V\l worke(1 (1Ilrll111 his (lIsl\hllily, Mr, HII)'Hon wUllld hl\vo hl\(1 thu OppOl111llh)' to wor" 14 <Inys of ovurthnu <I\1rlng his dIHl\hllh)', IIIH overtlmo mlu or pny wns $21,62 pur ho\ll'. Aeuonllngl)', Mr, Hn)'sol1 SCU"H $3,026,110 In nvurtlmo WIlIlIJ 10HH, AUlwhed ns ICxhlhl1 II Is un omployor's roport (Inlell Fohrllnr)' 10, IlJ99 IInd suhe(hlllnll shculH which deplcllhe reg\llllr wor" dnYN nll<llhe ovurtlmlJ worll <Inys fhr clIch emplo)'co, I'lense nOlu IImt !lel1 !llltlnll, thu umploymJ lIstud hulow MI', RIIYHOI1, wnr"ml14 dnys ovurthnu dlll'lnllthu tlmc porlod tlml Mr, HI\)'son wnH dlHnhlc(l. Mr, HlIyson WOllld hllVO niNo wllr"ed thoso dn)'s heellllHu hu Ims l11oro sunlnrll)', C, Antlclpnted Dol'onHcl\rl\umont~ It IN nntlelpllled tlmt tho Dol'ondllnt wlllllrguu thl\t sho IH unlltled to II oredh or n "sot-on" of tho eollntoml HOlll'ee pn)'l11ont Mr. RIlYHlllI rue\llved In thu limn 01' dlHnhllh)' honcllts, Th\l Jdentlell\ IHHlle Willi rlllHed h)' tho dolb11Hu 111 DeCceeo v, TI\!LllJJrehoh'oluLillrnklnu co" 146 I',L.J. 243 (1997) (nUnohl)d liS ICxhlhlt I), Relylngllnthll SlIpreme COllrl's deelHlonln .I3u1l.9helll v, Llllill:lx M.llI.JJnllnslll'llnee Group, 5431'11. 114,669 A.2d 930 (1996) IInd the Superior Court's dcolslonln BI'ownQ, v. Nntlllnwldo InHul'l\neo Co" 674 A,2d 1127 (I'n. Supor, 19%), nlloe, d!lll.lillJ, 545 I'll, 674, 6112 A,2d 306 (191)6), I!le Courl held 111111 tho 1'IIIIntlfl's I'ecolpt 01' dlsllhlllly honol1ts could l1!ll he Het-on' fhun tho .Iul'Y verdlot: DolimdlllllH nlHo clllhnthlltlhc Ihllnro 01' this COliI'I to Hct on'lhe .Inr)' verdict by the nlnount or tho dlHnhlllty policy hCllcl1ts pllld nr pnynhlo to 1'IIIIntll'I' hnH ontltlcd 1'llIlntll1' tll 1\IIIko n douhlc rccovcry. Ilowcver, Iho Supromo C'onrllll &lJ.jQlI.\lJll fhllnd no modt totll\l lusuror'H IIl'gumcnt thul tho MYFRL mUHI ho conHtrued 10 prevent n "douhle rccovery." JjmJehclll, 6(jl) A,2d lit l)l! I. Rllthcr, the COlii'I dclcl'lulncd thnl theHo bOllontH "I11UHt ho ~O] 1 ~1 , 1 \IlI,I,\OC 4 CUIlHlfIICl\ IIH prnvlllhm bCIlCt1IH III e~ceHH uf 1I1ll! 1101 III l!llpllclllloll 01; the IllcllIlle hlHH bellelllH p"Yl\hle Illlller ~ 1712(2). . .. The He me hellollllllhr whleh Iho empluyee hllH pllllllll 1IIll1\1\'Ill III' IlIwer WlIgeH thr Ihe Hleli 10llVO bel1elllH 1I11l! Illlhe Ihnll uf pllyrnll1lell\lc1IullH I'll\' the Soollll Scc\lrlly bCllelllH," ilL III OJ2, ThlH IH Ihe e~lIlll HII\lIIII\111 with PIIIIIlIlI1' peCecou, 11111111111'1' pllld 11]0 prel11hll11H Ihr hor lllHllblllty polley IhrulIglllllil her ClIl'eer by 1I1llllllH of II pllyrolllled\lelloll. Therelhre, recovery of bolh hor dlHllhlllly bellell\H IIl1lllhe venllet IH lint 'luplle1lllve, HIIII]el'. IIIH liIll' 11111\ elllllemplllled hy Ihe \ermH Ill' the MYFHL. /ful.lll1ill'llllt 674 A.2d III 1129. TlllIH. IhlH ('o\lI'I'H deelHloll In prcehlde 10HIII1101l)' l'elllllVlllo PIIIII1III1'H I'ccelp\ of dlHllhlllly belle 11tH WIIH llolTCel. peCceeo. 14(i 1'.1,,,1. III 244. Llliewllle, III Cunnll v. Kephlll'l. 717 A.2d 554 (I'll. S\lper, 11)1J7).II\\lIchcIIIIH ICxhlhlt ". the Hllpel'lll\' CO\lI'\ held Ihlllll Delulldlllll III IIlhll'd-PIII'IY ellHe could 110\ "Hel-ol1" Hlok PIlY hellclllH Ihull lhe PIIlIIlIII1'H elllhll 11111 Ihlnl-plIl'(y Olllle, III !.:llfrull...Y..KIlllllll11, II rCIII'-elld molol' vehicle IIceldell\. tho ollly iHlIllO for tho Jury 10 rellolve Willi dll\11l1g0H. Ilelhl'o\rllll. \he 11'1111 cO\l1'1 preoludell MI'H, CIII'rnll'H wlIgo 10llH ellllm, The cOlln l'ellllOllcd Ihlll hoellUHe Mrll, ClIl'mll Willi "ellglhle" 10 h\lY work 10HII hellonlll, Hhe cOllld 1101 Hcek work 111111111\ Ihe thlnl-pllrlY ellllo, Adlllllolllllly, IIlld l'eleVlIll1 10 Ihe prlJllelllllelloo. MI'H, ClIl'rolll'cclllvcd Hlek PIlY hOllel1111 Ihun her employer, The 11'1111 courl held Ihlll Hhe would he "douhle dlpplllg" If pennllled 10 I'ccover' work 10HII III her Ihlrd.pnl'ly elnllll. The Superior CourlreverHcd, FII'III, Iho Superior COlii'I l'eJccted the lrlnl eOlll'('1I delennlllnll(~1l IIml heenllHe MI'II. Cnrrnll wnH "ollglhle" 10 hllY work 10llH hellel1lH, IIhe could 1101 IIcok work 10HII COlllpllllHlllloll III Il'lnl. Secolldly. the Superior COUl'l held lhnt Hlcll pny doeH nol filII withlnlhe purview of ~ I 722. AH In DeCcccn, lhe Superior Courl citcd III lenglh Ihe I'cnllolllllg nml I'l\llolllllo III holh .&nleholll nlld 11I1lIYJ1Q. holdlllg Ihllllho pl'lllelplcH nl'lleulnlcd III IhoHe Iwo (llIl1ell wero nppllenble. The Superior Courl concluded 111111 MrH. Cnll'oll wns nol preelnded fi'oll1l'ceoverlnl! wnge 10HII Ihull lholorllunHol'. oVlln Ihongh IIhe received collnlcl'lll HOlll'ce IIlck pny hellel1ll1 t\'OIl1 her ell1ployor. ) a03l2.I, 1\111.1.\1'" I" .1 I ;\" :1 .....I,J,...,..,,,.,,!i!' " 11" " ;, !l i' ',; " " ." q " \1' l' ,- ", ,"I' " .. .1 " " \i 11 \ j'i i.1 . V \J u \..) "(.1 L' ,,,(... v " To\III A. TllYlor, p.o. Bponoor A. Ilopnor, I'A'o .f., (i, Gufscr, .'111,'1)" (P,C, 1.,lHIII/nur, M.P, I1I111wn MulllnllUhlln, M,P. (llllhorlnll M, Mlohnoln, PA,O 4lrllllllllr/1I1 Pllrilllol1ll P.O.llo~ HlIl Mlllllnlown, I'A :t70UO Tulophonol(71'() 4,1{J.82113 MlIl'ph 18, 1999 Puvhll" l.lllz AIIBlllo ulld Ilovllur 4503 Norlh Frolll Sll'uul IlurrlshllrB'!'A 171\0 1101 Mlohuol Jl, IluysoII D.O,Il.; <I/3/li9 ~8flllil-58-32'10 1'1l~1 (7:L7) 436'UUfJ4 Ileur Allol'lIoy IAilz; This INlor Is rOBllrlllllB Mluhnol p, llUYSOil,1I IWelllY-lIll1o youl' 0111 mule who wus Involvod In u molor vehlolu ueeldolllon 1i/22/98. Mr. IluysolI Wus soollol'iOllllllly hy me on 6/22/98 the dill' of his uooldolll. '.rhe pullonl WIIS III slllhle oOlldllloll nnd oomplnlned ofeurvlculllOok 11nlll nnd dcoreused runoe of molloll of his oOl'vloulllplno. Plulll X-rnys were Inkoll nnd wore lIo0nllvo, My I IIIOllosls nl 1I111l lime wus oel'vlOll1 sll'ulll/sprulll slullls posl vohlclllllr noolllolll. I'nllelll wus olverl u 11'1111 of nlllHnflmnl1lulorlos nlld mllsolo roluxors whloh IlIollldod MOII'III BOOmo TID wllh fond ulld Norflox 100mOlwloe n dny. fie IVns olven nil off work uXCllSO for 6/22/98 1I11l16l23/911, A folloW-III) oull IVns rooolved 0116/26/98. Atlhul lime lhe pllllelll oomplnlllod ofsllll huvlllllllock pnln nnrl sl101lOss.le wns pluoed 011 work l'eslrlollollS ('I' 1In1110 110 81'0nler limn 251h9, 110 slnled Ihlll hu wns III1Sme It'he IVollhl ho nhle 10 work dlle 10 Ihu fuollhlll he hll9 10 110 n 101 hOllvlel' welohls nl his 1I0nnlllJnh. ThIlS, he WIIS olvenlln exellse 0'0111 6/22/98 10 714/98. Mluhnel \lrOSelllod 7/7/98 for follnw-lIp oomplnlnlllO of IlIorensed neek stllll\ess nnll pnln, lie slnled Ihnl he hnd leenllOln8 nl work nlld he slnrled 10 hllve hlOl'enso\1 Plllll. 1I1s eX1l1l1 wns essenllnlly IInohnllBol1 nlld I slnrlcd him on somo IIOW IInll-lllflllmll1nlol'los. 110 wns seen In follOW-lip In one week. lie slnled nllhnlllme Ihnl ho hnd sll8hlly Improved. Allhls 11II1e 18nvu hlll1 n pl'esurlpllolI for physlellllhel'lIpy OV"IIIAllon nlld tl'enlmOll1 Ihnl wns 10 IAko pllloe for two weeks nlllollllhSolllh, Mlohnel IVns Ihell soon nppl'oxlllmloly OVel)' two woeks IInl1l9/1 /1/911. Throll8hollllhnltlmo hu oonllllllud physlonl thel'npy ns woll ns nllll-lllflnmmnlol'lcs mill mllsole rolnxllrs. 011 9/141911, I SIlW the him for tho Inslllme 1'081ll'dl1l8 this neeldUIlI, I lu slntcd Ihnt ho fell mlluh bUller nllll Wllllled 10 relllrlllo l'e8111111' work, lie wns alvolI n rolollsu 10 rell1rn 10 l'e811111r work 011 9/19/9R. I hnvo lull seclllhu plltlclIl reBnl'dl1l81hls 11I0101' vohlellllll' uooldolll sllleu 9/14/98. ThIlS, I hnvo 10 nSSllme IIml ho hns fillly reeovcled fi'om his 11I0101' vehlclllm' neohlolll, I do nol nnllclpllle Ihnl he will need Illly filrther Il'cnllnelll for Ihls IIl1less hu hilS exncerhlllloll of Ihe symploms bl'oll8ht Oil by some olhcl' hUllry. I hope thnllhls 1111'0111I1111011 Is IIsofill reonl'dl1l8 Mlohnulllnyson's OIlSO. If yo II hnve nllY filrlher qllesllollS plonso do nol hesllnlo to COlllllolmu, Slncorol ,-; ) MOlllltnln VloW Motllonl Contor ........., 'f'''''' '~~ILftt:""""""""""~'."'-'u--L""''''~'''''.''l'''''''''''''''-_'1,.....~"..4.~~.t::: ""~'" O;"~' ,', ~.j . .. .yr''':''' I, I'. ,f,':" ..["'\,;->- li~t\"'\': IT/'H{ 'I,' , ,.' " "~I "'~".H,.....,.,.I__~~ .. ') " I', t.1JCH"1T g \ " " /'( ., " "I' " "" " ,I. 'I, " " " " .. .. I' '. oJ \....1 u l.) \/ I' ,,V '-- i:..j,.., " '.""}' \ 'f, NIIIIIO: \<'(.l.'1,$(Jn ( rn \ c.hn ('.,1 I ('~ I .I11",ll,1 "'I ( .11', ',1, I;,',. I' i 'it I. :(1'1 '.!/Iir,r' "1.,"\'.1",1'-'1'.; 1-- __ __ n 0 _, CI!Iv.!. C(]II~!lnll1l ,__ '111I11 & oulon 10118 --'- "---'--' ...'-..--...--..----...-.-...--.-.-.-...-.,--..-..- .b!e . --Is;" t,l AIY) _ ..J~('t.,I.~.l~L_-.._ CC'..m.:,\::..nj-L.l..~.V__.__.:j~~L___.._______.__ I.L.kL_:J ___ ------....-. -\.Cl.~.e.c.-bO'c.IC._.I-f::L":l.._._, .J:.\LLI:tl.CLI. . -LL.811~ -\:l.:l~..lt.~U....l:I_ --I-;--lqQfl---GLT-l.r...:l::c:id_..,_. ---:. _ '. ' :u,Lllhcf ,\I.\.1:I:~J:L\_..__ .L...---IC\\A./.e,r_I::;ac..K__,........ .bdJ: .l:L t' 1:h:.l'.'l '- I_lJ.J.1L~_._ -r.U:.\-Lo-.-Q::b-__Lucu::.IC._._. ."'_... _ CL_ r :) "'- L'10 ---Cl.CI 1="'~-1-..)-1E)~f'1____ -;-j;.l LIXLO 1.()8--L~.. ill' .l~_lz..-..___..__.aLa ~.--Q...IO:I::........().r=:___._._.___ _"__"_, t3..w....(il:....,,:1. (~e_J..!E.I.:2D . J.U?..:I::\qg-.(kI:::_LL')C.t:Y::'IS.~__ _ t:''1~ OQ..~_\..lc.s -QL.cl--c\d\.,_i.l_~1::_____ -b.lcu:,::;.i.C\9~_~ -:::.......... ~ _.wa.c.o:)._-r.D.tl.l.8:I::.__b.eC!.:k"':'-U,lt'l:~'L1 e.f'\,\~...-1IL-LLf"\ ""- -!:...........ru'D:)e...._v:;~LI-"e.k.,_L --..l:ll,1,r-Ao.I.09___...J;'\ LI_ ---:----:: ~z l' -----:---=-I~r~~= ._H";."",,-,os-- "" LC. I ----=-.(,~rL(\ -L.r,\~~. l~t~ ""("1'\ "-~(l l..I ' ' - --t'~~'r"X::j -l~(\T'L-- '1 .L\~. '~l' .1':'- --'-">Ilj\ -;:~'l'l' 00 II C1 ~ I ------- ~= ;c:: " L.-~~~.- ([Ld::S~-= - =_1.W~ ':J' . I , l..._. ~J7 I k, _ -l~.lL\::...w6):1~3~ ... I l -....\. c: '- I ... \: ~f:: "1'\-""'\ ." j'4\ L~ I ,L . 'I =---:= =-~'QS~~:tL-t[.;LfJ c' . ::;;;:':;;;;.J';9=-~ :~=" ' ---- =--,.tL~\. .1 ~~~)~ ;,- ;c-.... ~~.l:\1.l...Lr.DCL\~_---=-1..Jd_Ii! .--,..-..L....'t:--? ). ~J- -M.eJ:L_~Q.._LI ..-- ------- ---LJ~~'-:~J ;::~~~~I~'t= ~ J:lu.ma..I.O!j--.L\ u cerv', I -- ----- --".Jt-I--J.\.t::: ~- ~(' J l-.... - -- t.' t~~...~.. ~D..1Z..._ ---.J,J.. ...' ,1....:.r..1C:.~'. t-l ,. .'\ "I', ) '-..\ _.., A U n 'c;j-., ~~ .L~ s: -:"3:\...h"I~t's -.-'->.17'c-,f,>.!..r:--:- ~'~l' -r=- m - ---:~)'r(S:: (y..~~'(--fl-fe-;- -7\b~t)j;,~-=-", \r ~- -~ \-Lnl~"---~l0-~1 --._E\.t:I_U\~c~...l_. ___ -- ,_.--t'~:f$-~,:;r~:l) J~-1~ "-~::l- ~=~~ ~ .- ------- -- '-J'l,~ ~ ~F <:.-:'p:=;)_. --T'II:L.~- _0.1 .~ \.1,..., h7 _. --- ~~~I\ r'1z.! d:............. '5 ~ ~~,t:J.'" ---:-J =----::-- -:-~..~.~~,'th~~('1~~\:0=J c-{--- =--(~t=,_bt '~~~_ r~tf\~~ - -~"-1~~r1~r~_'~~'"l:;- -_..n_.~\ "'t ~ "__p__~ - ~-- r-~ 7\,;-:~p~~r3';;"~ ~_~= '-'lj~~~':'~C'7 t J / ~~L/l C:tlJ~"'l-L)~~~~.:;,-- - -~I ~ -:)..--' -]}.-d~I""~'!'__~Ll\__.... -t-:~ -:s~-:'00 l' ~~..-;-- --'t=~ -- ---.--. --7- ,-~'--'-.:r-- --P-1 :-_n--~_T\~~\,.':.'I?--;,-;o\. --l'fr -- ~,L'!'.. '1', I~r: ~':._\.L_ L..... _ '1,,-'1 \ "n /-, - <it . _, . Allofulnn: N\(.,A. r' 'of CompluI111 PIUIIH & Moclllllillul1u -p.I(' I!.llc '~ I~ I (~(.;J:JJULt.L:...f:1 c.{).J~2L illW')l (\'-l!/l/'-;P /.1\(.) -I)f.lL1.:..~ Wi 1'4fi! '. ) . .__...__.~._-~---_.._-. " ' . f1A'\ I!!NT'S NAMI: -L:L~..Lr..JL.(.WJ._~C~lCl.IL..._u_._ \ 'I I PAW J.:..!.L'.l!'.! NAMH -.----.......-.---.-._____,... I'IIOI~I!: 1I..__u____._.u u..__u_. W ___._.____ ,___. nn _,_________.__m.___.__ M(;SSACl(; TMf'N IlY .(.:::..o.~A!.:.t~'i....._._,....__ _ 11M!! ._._IV.:~____...... l'lr:ASON FOil OALI. ---:r;-'~l~~"'-';--'---:----;-'''-'::~;~~~''- ---..........- \,~u"J,.~~I-;-j~',-:':~.i t--;-:' SYMPTOMS .._.([~_I.!...l!..IL\lL\..Lt,"-_Ll...J........_.LJ'...n_....___. .._l~~LI,,_Hul, (.:\,ll' .L'1 'll VJ K 'y) "1 1')tL 'i ( l I.. .'. --~---,--==,.,,~ \..""hlt\--fl:':"'-- ....l_............___ . _..:.}., 1..11.__ 1ll1L,_ll.E.- Pl'l'Il. APVlor: ---.----.-__._.______.....___._ l, II n d.J.~_LL1(:1].!......-..--.. ,J.lll\J'L1lL.G.l'l.J..lkl{(JLL':'L~L.IL . (.::,LlJ..1"'-'---~l.n-~t.. ...._ . LI.I..,.'U\ l .\.1\., ,~~-;\;:T'Lt: p'~-t:\('~-I~~-t'l1 \'I:~{'-\\TiIt"-f1v:'H"r.-?"'-rr:.m----- l'lF-f'lll, , '-<:~-""nl-:::() . ~--'_'_~PIIA.1MACY. "---"~---b l!.~t!'1 . ___uu_... ---:-:'--'~'-'-rn I ; --- . -: .., ]1~fl~~.~.~\(IN ----=:---- -----... TIMEi/PATI: INI'ORMr:n I'ATmNT ___no - 'L6(~~' .c= rA T1liNT INPOl'lMI:P flY --..-----l~ -_ . . _I.I.....~_.._______ _ ,._.. 1110 I.,i'. '1(7 rAT'''''.. NAM' iD~C'-J'''''L:::'?n ,="'~_____ I .:J ~' ,/r' U . . PATE':.1:._',j NAME --...-_.____.._____,_ f'IIONj!: II . _._._._, W ____ S .. () II nn, .____'".-f!::L..____..____ MfiSSACl(; TAI\EN flY ..._.\.';,~\ Mlli"___,_._ TIMli __L:'_____ . :~~~~~~:~~ CAL.I. -'--(i)'i~Ql,."~~:ti.L~_;2.=~=--=~==--=L~~(1 ~,Z~c/ \1'~.L~~ . ---. L?I-..lLLc..hLU.LL-_____..___-W1.l.LL)L.l:.:.\lCCU:LL- on'!!, APVlcli ____.____. ..LJUl.d .._--------....!-_--_._.__..-----_._-~- ---_._------..__._----~._- -. n1:FII.I, -- ~'~12IJ1 I'IIAflMACY. __ -- ------------------ "MI OAl_"" "' '"-a - TIMI:IPAn, INFOflMED f'ATI(;NT _______.._______.___. ~: f'ATIliNT INf'ORMIW IlY ----,--_. .--'.-..-------. - d \. ~ , . .u~.. (' \\~) Il . \:{.\.l"':)t.1 0 .' .' \ (),' \ '" 110 (.;UI",ullvIO.I'C ,IIIU)'.J;,H/!fllIW/l<liC'i\() h)1I0'(1O!, t.l'ffllllld',\'ll rnJfl'ill\,M,I,\ Illl'l1 Allornlou: ", r '::' ,.- Numo: .. Polo . r'" Ohl~f oomp 1I '1111 B & ad 011 0 0 '-LLJ.d.:j 8 ..__._ 112JP' Cl t\h ~,I PiLi.Il___._.._ _L~ ._llil.1' '-..,\{I, j!i I.!..JLL!.l.._\-= ( 1\ '.11 .' '\ :.1 .", 1'/\ I PIn ~ --,U.l.rnr-- .--------.-l..J.I.,\.LL\.sLLq.i,.l.Ltll.c1.cL7 -iJ"----------- -,TII'f ....JJl~L_ - .~-C!l.l.:LdQ.Jl-t~~ ~:LLL.,m.1L~'1 (~---k'd.J.L~iW:L-f--- -~ jo :~5tq'g'~~Ut~-- ==---.'ir .==-L1 t=:'ll~___ I~~" . t&'^' ~J) ( /.--..---; \~, '-1(.111' ( I' r; .':! I" ( !.\ ""1 --1 ','or' .. . v..... ::t:...1_v_ - L:L._. ~" ""-<--~=_..-'-'- --t--- iJll ~11'i -11: ~- ~- -. -1..J '; ('((I '~iwr Cl ( .'.> J .u 1\. ) I ".1 1'.,\ Y I _._ . . ... __ ~~.~ ~- .~~ ~~:::)'wl': I r)-..--~~~~;~~- l",,,t - -- ~~----,---.....-...-.._~ :u....,,~_-----m--.__. .~: ---'-=--= =~~ -(!\'t -=e--Ee-I~r-t ~==-'~vtre\;~--.: -- _.-t.(k~;6/bt --~\- - -f -=10-1V\"~-'~\fk~\~--.._----------- ,.... :::;-~--,- -~ 9-.--------- W1~J4-\-\L\L::~\-~~ -;- _ -a<{tr~r\7V'c::"-. ________ ---- -t/V m~~tt ~--- -. ~~~) C~l~-~iJrtt = - - W-~~\~=-~__ -rlX-:iTI---r-i', rtfNA- ----.- . , - -V:-~~~~V=-~~ --- fti-f-f: 6t-Cp ~ .-- --I#--~ ------ --- :;' - . __ ----,,-- ---D'~ -------- ~-~1t! _~_-r' ------= =--\-ITil'-m -. ." 8 ~\~ - . ---\,~-\-\I.~- I../~b\- -.1- -'\V~j,~-~ - .____m _.r.. -, - "'Ip'-~:. ~e~=tV~-~:==~.. __ --------.-,.- -~ .----.,;----_....._--~- -----....--.- I"'~ Polo ) :"9-II-I,((~ L,lj' t- ("/ fb-. ' ...L ' lr B ., ..:p ( \ "'/'1 T .- ~\\ ~. \ (, . .J2,P /,3 "Ill L> . c:tl\,a- ,~j - - l'It'...,f' - _ Pinna & Morllon\lona ~o.l_:l:.)..~_uu y. fJ P 1" -- ".)111< I q,y pin U . .. ',;(~ .s,:;r ,__ Nrll l,UIL.::-.. h u__ \,\ (n \ nIL) U-'1,_.k.n I'll ) \ .HIt /~ () _ _\ _ .1. I rlJ ,~ ~ ,L~-t-Ie~;p ~ - . , v/' - ~L:iW~ 0!1t.ll.J:d.uJ I. ,~ , .2~\{- ~^t'i: I&-:- ( L ':.1 l. 1._. ,\) 11 \ I _j~:esJ ~( ~~_~\1fu lli~ .J:S lL ',4"\~~11- -C~(~~f-L{-(:clL-..c1-~f) I 1\-1 /'" 1 il.ot)!' -(l}-F-E.V€VC ',( "\1\1 "..L',It~ I') 1I ll~ 1\1 If? ~ 1:'1 I.' I'll"! ~~t):~ . -:fv~?~ (""" V\I\\\1}?=1ll~tr-\7,V::~- Wr:A'vrjcteWv-~f ~'ffi-;Vf 'I ' . V\l\Vl\f(~f-\"v'v J~~,E {, ~'l~ttf~~ ' f1/V-~ - @-fF2C vA - - l~~ ci1f4j-{ -[- ~~-W-i7v\v'Vf-'-(+V!l \lV\-\-j-\rv . A ElT-~€' h\<<-(--L.:5 VI-h-~1~,A---. ~(f') (J'VAl, ~nl7\~ ,.Iv ~~~~'1\-lYF - - ittx'-t(C ~~~ Ae:--Y+(.q+~f-= ~~fW-11J? .rt-7() (fe L,;/ r-r ' . . ;./') V/l --. ~ - J~// r-,' / J "" ". //'f.-, V Ii // / '-1 'II' / / 7 ""Iof OOl11plnll1\ I ), J\.r Lh.....<_~,. ~\. It Q,.U, " \., "t"l' ) \,.-'1_11L.. LA..... ~ \ \\ \"l,1 , ' .Jv'~ )!\ Nmno: \ 'e ~ C' \ Pnlo .J I G C.tJl~;Hll"l 0, PC 111N['\,:,UlllIlI'MII' ,;("!AU t'(lll;")~Wl r.Hr\U1I0,l,'tI /ltrl~I:i'TIVI\I'I" 1105'J Alloroloa: O!!!l!LQ2mllllllnl . -I 1,,11/) , . Plnl]B & llfodlolllloilB - - I'AllfNT'S NAMI: '___h.____ "'. . -. ---.... --_._---.__._._-----_.~-_._.. llATI: --'-. NAMF II - ..-'-.-......_.h_____________._.___.__ I IONr:: II _h___m_.___ W pn, -------------- ------ --on M~S2ACH: TAI<r:N UY -:--- _ '---------- m:AsoN. Fon OALI. ,=/YlL6J1(hJ'__ .lLtA(}DJl~-.._~:~:~~~~-=~=_-_~~~~=---' ~IMr: '-----,--_ SYMPTOM LJ ---..-------------,- _, S ----lQ"U(1:t{). II - /I-f)ly\ri---J7,)----f.-;\l(-(.,l\Ii--,---M-~-:17:",..l/ll\ -~,J---J----- --W---L.l.f"-''i-.--u.ti (.1":: .,1.lI/.x., I..) i< ..Il. J'~/:'11 1_ '- __~~~~lVIOl: '-1~[b. -0-Jt)f!f~ l!q~ltr~~ti~~/t\---:~=~'==~=~~':=Z-~"-!fl~rk?/fi...---= ~ --- --~. .-----._?((j .-'\ on. ~ -.-- . ~ 7"7-J -.. -----.'1/14 ~ - '-:::-::-c=n r' "'" --..--.----C. .1~'L -- C' ?Ia~~C?-)'- H1:I'111 " . """ . ~ ___~~""'"-- . ~\;~ - '.:' --'- --; l?"" -.~--,-,- III IiMIIIW':::.- =...... , -'-- . (~--(:.../[ ":... .c:. rll,{:I:...).:_..__ T!~~_llAI'~lin ~lX ~ -'(..iI?~17--I- I lIMElllAT!, INFOIlMr:1l r~1! I ___~,.-J-~ , ..-l-~~J..--lli.~~~. ~~ ,\..-. -- --'I . PATIENT INFonMEllav-:.m~R~.u.~. Ar- ~_..::...__._ < ..' (j, l (77 I ~17t:(rT'-- 'f' ~b1 ;r(~- 7 Ul-..,-----l7\-fU-LJ!t _.I-~--- \>' .- ------ - /'" _i:l~~ [2 I..A~ " ILl (Ik. >.....lLt.C".l. ( '-I .) ~:L.Lln_u..Jl~~_/:~_-'-__ \o/iV 'it <; ~e~[,tf~{-~~ N ~,-6 " \f,~:"" -I-c= Tl~'( v. .. "--- LlLLI'n'). ~II _ (, . -== - --:'IT\r~ S~\"Y '_'LLLU:ru.1l.u&_ ";IL, LIi;Alll (. ~.:I _, {_ :Oa~ _~_ fU-1'-~-<Ad- _ _.___.!..J.-'.J l.l (\n __ ,liP I'd. _ _ -nfA: _ rl-~. 1~1'1.1 ...1.12,6w,'I",_.L .....i:.l (;) f . q ([Jlill_ . V\' If\ ~ _ _. _ I ]_!:~~ PIn \ '" ~ ,.1 ) - ~V =\-r&\.--tff1> ___..'. \.'h.l,J II' . -- -. -- (J tt~~ ~ ~<<lt\V\"+:rn~\~'tv~- - (;W!lJJL_ -\t~~ \ ~VS~ - .. ----- d6~t\~\\rb~~l~t~ .Iq.b __.----- __ tmtm. ~-~-~\:~~ iff. -~-p_4~~ .. .. -S-.ID-~W~: l~-'----.._- ~~tkvt{-~te-)\~-wflf. \ --~@f~il-"lL~ ~~~ [I)~_ ~~ ~\7(~. ~{ .-----.-- -:- ~~A-'vf-[--'---_.-iiiJ~- (L _0:t1J_______.__ _ --------.-- - ' ,.,~ -~", ./ 1'/..-0/;'<"'- - .~J~.A .//~4 lllllo ' . 'ul Ollll1ulnllll Plnllll 1\ Mmllon\lollu c?'h - .. _KICJ . 'T?J _CC.l__ r ..--I.e.'l./ ____ ,.ff'--"~~. ,J' _ .ItIdt. 7' _____'-~:b-' .22 /. (w(()dL~tt-L . ~~_, SG2:Ji!..a,.;t85 ,_ _~L&'/ ( .:0.~...., a.;;Q . _ "/~d'1:L-.--4~-Gb'\1':-r~~h') /..S?r/)?~ "'.7b-r..-?L-___ f/I,. @~ ~C!J::n ,\-:-'x:, I, r-fc~4V.~~' 6~JL ,.': ~~-~C t:---~~~ /,~~,P~. .- r: ~L.' V?(-t.L .::@f:r\Ll,\ .a..( /l/i:1...-v iUl>'~.~U5J _ . ...?rl/./;S' \ J' J.~' )tL/, , . ..11./ -""""''::1'-2>, ~-..:I Q.)yJ -, /.f \f1 Y..I_,\-::; ;JJ'\tvv-' pI6).( ny;>, !??~__~ . __ ~~)I \~~_ ~ _ \\-- ~ C' -....,. r,l\_ ~~-L3""'AA ,v )r 1~..r"" _ !1..I.1/&.t'4--....u.... V-~-"""K ~_' ='{(~ 1~~/I~(l=L;!; .5~/~.r/"-4 ~~-~' --~-q3 -J'VBt11iP7-'tvrr- _ G~ ' ~~~ -\7ffl--.C1~ -- \lV\\,{S12~J~~~~ .\-~.dt~ (~~ttF ('tV, ~\ \ 0....~ . ~~~~-q7'i111 C (J\^,:~\:.*" ,/l--t:L ':.( . ~ /' nIl ~.. A ,'... V'1r- - -I~ ,. I If\' A,/ " .II (J\7V~~--e>~ -fNfL ~ J AVJ /.1/ _, ;"/.. ::@t(C~ . ~/<wr"( v~ I (.~ UIII~,I:li.lvtl1.l'C: .11t,1(l\.J:,H/'....lIWIKI,'(),hO 1'0 nOo: '(I~ NfllllO: ~)?,. 4/t(:"''::?;;;; II '" ',"Y^"', "AllorUloo: !?,t(pf )1\ 0 )110 00 11\1 1\110 & oc 0 n 0 -2'. f. 'C.._ _ " ~~ . -1IV7Jil!L----rr- -e- '-(z\Q')-,-G' -.-...- -{; . _..Ctyt:2~t.'t'd~)'_--:-________,_ _ul!...ftf~__ ~,L~, -x:r,=-v..::.\.._-.:[~'ll:=_ -r.~.-,- ~~~ 0 -T;I--fl-. ~-- - ~-~~ -t _.jS-kLctoJ /'Z~ -P-i ~-- :3:1~ -~7(1ZtCuid.O=(r~. --: .~~ ,...-;;--- 4-!l(s-- ~'t- -(-t-(=-i:-64~-(I\i'\(~ Wa~ ~ ~~.L. -.J ~jlttp-- ---'--, '-~'I7J- -'~-ITri''i70;---- _r.Jt.eCL_~~71__ , .. -~Cll~- -':"IA.' -:- . V-I..L.v.Lr___ ~~f.lLi'121_~7.u ~2.1 . - -f'/-1v17)-P+ ,.~ -_ _i:-/~~#'~, . ----,--- - _LL_~(---Y.... ___,_L_.__ --Ls:.(.L.L1Z2..1---L~G1. -------f 7')\l7t\ '---' -IL.aL~:i!A~~1lO'.2 -\;: g;-v-.,z..r. '-4ItLL-e,(~.r =- -==jj~~a:~:~-~,,-@F-- . . .--- ---r~tazr~-~~c~-'(7~ k--- -.-- . -5-(J~L-)(ttit-f-I,~-~~@~ t[(~G{-r-~Tt~ '=l/T(l' ~v.c~~ -,~__~__. --- l41b1+r::-fs2--)-I~\fr.I4j'II\,.- _,Cv"'--- . =------- -~!1~fJL:-:(!uvrJ?:A~w~= ---- - ~--==--~ I faf(rf(fJ-7)?f0tfu" -fj/l!!1rt'1 --- -- ~Q}r-Ltv:".d,\~.\tr- . - . {("t4-l7lf~L=rf?L -:~ - -~~~. :jJg~ff7lJ- fltJ41~_ --;J~vtJA;~rA.c~~-(A/d, .~ -fiJllI/'r~-(-7t--l"-7~,.. ~.W-\l--\:]L(,Ll,.~~._-.- ~-- ;(J1t/4 ~- \ --.--- ---.--..... ~ NI11l101 0010. \.(:1 (:illl~il:I~, !vln,p(; ,IUI[)\J~WI'\I.IWlr:ri\',\[) PO 111.)( I~!.> ,{~r5 0/1 r r)1';i~(/~'M~VM'''' ":.\1I01010Bl OhloLOlltllplnlnl 11 (C.'/!' . -ElanB & MOtlIOlill~I1B ...... ',;AAlll,~:Ni~~~~~W"I~M'i:_-/!!'~~~~<.~I!!~:~l~'-_'I'llnNI:; II _./I.S.(e::(i2IJ~ ~ _,_________ : - .((!:ull:u , . t., /'_ !In, '-//MA/Wt<.. .--.-'-.":'1.-".. MIHlSAOI, TAI\I'~ I}Y ...---..--..-......---,...--., TIM" ._.___!'t21l._ . ImASoN FO~ CAI.! .-.-._-JV7LLf1-jI.Ltd()..'..-jltlYYl..f.t1;~t.$-lln-.ua..:)!t.-.... /IZ.-----... , BYMPloMS __..___,.._.._.ArS__11Ut._Sf-ar.leiL. f.IIM~t/.~.n.iL/!.J,.~~~----.--,-~ ' .. ..-.-.-.--...-..--..-----.-.:ii1J,~Jt.lJtd"--:f,( ...4~t!-.--(]'J11t'!/ /(L --., 1~5-.WaLi. . IlIl'S AilVIOI:_.-__.-...:<. . _ _'-__()f'._SilO(l(Lr..Vf.jJ.L/IJ,1-__(Jr-t__((.f. ,'(.6:aL1__ . ~ '2 . _ _ ..__.__ ____._._ .IJL..____.____,_ _, _ __ ___ __ - - .....-.-.-..--.;-..,--~...-O'C_- :.' .-; " a I rllu!l~ ~I{.t_ ry;? ~ ~7!J/ ..-.-....-J;-)- -( .!:(--.~h-(-C--(!\&\ (l(fq---1--- --M;V;r~, tm:oA-u'-C-7tUI~ 111:1'11.1, -~'7!~-\~t~1: ..~t\tC<;,2 W~qt\~:IIA:\MAOY,) '~5P~-1~Y-- F.. ._C1!s._.___.__._____ _H' _____.J___._\_.__._ 11~ ,CAI,I_"I ~_._ . lIMI:!IJAT" INr:onlv\l:IlI'ATII:N.,Q. ~:-(0J,.- c~-V\1:V::e=-~._~ - - , (-' -- . =:;;1 PAT"'NT INI'OITMHIJ flY ____..___.__...,._.__...______._____ ". . - --.- -''2&98 ~ ,~ta..s-o/!-L1e.ct5..- I?te4-.' CWQli'K..D\i6~ _Wl'-OlL__ f}d:/11J!tlc~(.iJi>l ,. ~._(!<l .'!)/fW '>=r;.S M(h --'ilf;l.L~/1V - _-1 -~~,!-~;):;&I.I..~(~.~lJ~(&~!'elY; -')5..tL4::m /7 UeaL_____ !11!...eL.-- -- am",,~lMe.-t[.lL1il4,,~r.l.:r,p._..dillil'.._ J.:U~hlf3~{(J:J .. -1Jll_dQ&tt_ Jel.&C'-iI..MLM!il:t;(i&(nL~,_ _d!..aL/:nL_.Lt:1 tLv",m -1.:-8.:.!- .. --(}Ia.fX~dQ.LUr:. J"IL,<k:...Sl.'J.Eid.iL ___ ~(}N..:::JAlOlUU f!: 1(/ (.:/.1 diP . l'E~,,~'(lJ.IiJ.L,;I.;-::jlj)W hCU,\~ ~LdSu.Jib -11'L' .lfJl-r<.: /,J I, ;-, ~ ' ~), "'(' ('<to,l. 'lL:- U .A~~l /"7 h .,.. ----'l'llJ-~1 -p<_ ~1<l!.Cflli LillL:L'k'L\~--:~_t:4l_.___ _tZ!~_!JL{ _~-:-{._ur..L'/11 ',_ cp ,(; ~I()C~ ~.>I..t?-4'J;'_j~3.iJ;.i.l(lla{),o:: _ -6 Ull1 . ~~1:.L\~_ ~(\.IWt~?& LJ5..t.f.:f/:D:J-f.3...(.,{1.!lt_ .k~~(1~i:UJ!!:JJ~CA.i.~/'J:f!t.io/:"""' )(",sL __ ~Llc::1f~~Ul\~t~dU:....2f:':...&& Li?l!T NA f-). '.e.!21JA~ ;-l(:/:'/J1LI.1.-1L'Us...d., V7 :d..;._&l"l'''' .L."I'w",T (!,fal,lt/ ,_ 1?1~tr-: C!.2ci",d .!r..J (/I) .'Id.. 0ill{(.[ Q(l(LLWJi/'1' /P.; +.I:?(.>..J.~,....fi!rltJ ;('()1l7 ____ LiJ.L/JG.s.' (ITA /9,~I.(,d_. .. ____ ____ " I~f.' !..R. ~ I 'I' ,~-,9Inll1n1l.(,! II... 2 ; .. 1!-.L&ZJJ2fJ ). -~. VQ . ~t'~/I.f_:Y#y'-~~~(r~ =[liv __~' 'm t..<"'w-A-I;i.:h.-!4,~j-~J-~_G -07Jf;--- , W _,LJ 't':.i:l f-'r.'l-0 'tlY,wC.uf.(kLY(t1.<-'L71.?' /(l1!.tL~_________,__ . Jl1/JIl)___________ ,_____ =-=~- (E~-0-~r7&~~h"J."Ni\{'{)-?:i~~*~+- ~ - ~ "'.( _. ,/'Plllew JLt.!:,'.:._~y'--IO.jLVX:...t( a:(~ ,.. --.- " , ----\!-V~ _H(-.0Jj~~'s:.!;i..._~<::LvO...:l- _ :t______l/l.Kf!!~cl.I-1?4,,! -- -.- I h C',lIl\ill{ !vlll P{: ,IIII{"I',!(<I'\II'^lh: IiI lAP t'(I\I'."lll!1 Nmno: l(t~r~;t)>11 ;11,(t't~:eel\l'I\""M'" "Allnrulon: II//tA. I )11 0 _ 0110 00 I " ' '\ n !.f;1Yd~~lIol1n ' \, __ '21 ..(>~__ _,<::~~ ~~J/- ---2l,(!(.t.!"...J(!t-1 1~_.__j21c.r:.t_?,. c-w4/1.-) ! _1.V'~_.1I2-,_ ____.__._.__-1!/U5J.ULL__....__....._. __iJ.t'II.JI.5ZU!..(.!2__-!,g...Ii~(J1i( \ _/.(c-c.&.'!!L __li'-k!\?"..L.(}.t!CL-----.-.--...... -'.. ./..5~t.CLll?"" ..L' .~L:.~n --,- i 'l"' ()'7 J?' ,'" "1' /oJ.",,'. ......1.' ., ~~ pO 2'"i() I __' l-4'1r.-~ _,__Lf.(._(..c:.'-r~.dLL_...---;:':~.- -=7".1.. ... ~L .,fJ.'L~__ i __/J;_.l (J l~l~.2- ____...____.___.___.______...('l;'..L _.....1:, ltlJ(.?{i:t;4.:./!l.!!...--------- i I: 1I2.~_ -71-.---\----"..---".- ........,..__..;1cllllfi..:...._.f..2.' J_t...t':!/.l1.............._ , Jtj ;:;\ ~,/ ., I'll () Ir /.~..'" - .. "",)( ..." I _L\ r . -::-;:-i; ~_....LL -'--'--: .. ::..-.----;-----.---:i--.-,--.-~-.;-:T7'r'LlIiv-=--:- I \ ..qfJ'-' 'y6.- __<:~~-,.d&:~:.~~,~,,".<. ..'7_1:~~~~:~r__At.[~'i'.~~Jt.l~l)tl..tt'rL---~a~~:LL!.j~~ _'___ _ 4. /d'&< a:A!-;e. r~u.~:(~J.:'L.1L~-'-_.. _nd.i!(..{Lll7L-._LL'Ltlll.-.~ " (y" I Y . (, __ ~'Z".-.::;~:,~r';'- {1TrY"'-7i -r...!fSl.I:y,-: ~.L'l15.{:L:.t2.1._--__--_.._ ~__._____~ ~~Vl(JJ~;~.'-!};] .I~,lf.~.' ,~.._~~lz't'/ ____:(,::J..C.Ll.?lh.-----;r ____ _,_~ ~~:;~7p)~;~~'Z?I~~~2~~ ~~:~:='i?-RY~~().:Cv~ '__-,-_ ___,_ ___'.tj)__(i;;)_.K<rY~f!:': :fl!.~_'-- -.....--~..-----.-.--_..--.---.. , -- ",- - -H-U\C-~=k---~- .- ----f k-~------- ----- __ -r- ,1./~__~_L.l.L ..--..--- --,-----,--------- . ---.t-.!:::rL@1\- --:;7 ~;\'-\ .. t'lS-\~--.-_=-..---..-..---' .. - ~@~~~iLLL~-~r~5t1~ ~ ... ~-rnspp7~.:' , I ~ ~ -- fi_~~;J1JJi --:-li~1tlti:-=--'. . =--=~---:=fi1TJV\, ~~--- - ,'t-... -rtrzc:~~'~'~--= . -~~\ (A,J ~~l4=- =CC[fd--__ -==-:---- 1 ~..---.----.----..--- ----.-~. - 1A - -- ==~==-= =-~---~(*--- ---- . -tf - - . -- ------.-.-.--..-- ----~-- ------ - ----- ____..___4._~_ ... - -- .- .------- --~--_._--~----~-----. ----------_._---_._~..._....._~---- ------.-.. .-- '" . ...---..---- -------.-----.---- -----_...,_._.-_...._._.--~.._.._---_.- .._-~-_.,.._.---_..__.------_..__._~.--- -.----- -_.---~._-------,._-_..~._.._-~_.._--_... _...~_...-.--_...~--_.--_.~_._..~-~_-. ._~ -----.-.._--.._..-------~_.._._~_.-_._. --------..-..-------.----.-------.-----.-- \)nlo T' _ '01 cOl11philnl I I'hll1n,~ MlllJI~.!IJln'w. ( . "I' n'\) " PAlIr:Nl'A NAMn _ .I\.~L ..UL~....l!.Ic~.\.{In_......._.... I" 'v.. (Vi II' ')'1 (>i I ' . I>ATlillJ.:.\~\.(I::'NAM" ............. ...._..._..__........._..__.m P'ION!': II __: ~~~ (-:'Q'n.!l, w.....____.___.__.... t. I,' f" 'f"'-,,- .' 1>11, .....n_.n........n_...._ -.. ...--_. MI:llEW'l!: "AIII:N IIY n' .. "-(J~M., b.L~,"_._._..... .......IIMI: L.,J-'---~~2___..__.n 1Ir:^!:n~';DllcAI~:.;(\;;~-.--,.-::;-- ---r'\(;'--:(C!; .. ;:'l\ ,-)u~'~-(':I-;T ..).(-..~l--.--xr-c.-..., - !I,MI I' ~A,\ \'.._n--LIL).}jJY..,.\.-\L.___) ",..L....-- ...n......_..l... !L_i\..~_J~~,Jl.. _ ..l,tL.nc,.-.\,J~_"ij.\)Llt -fJt~\Ltj:)l1.bLi._.. ',-'\\.1.). X\lr_Ir;.,_.. !..1 l~.~l:.U1:}~J-----..-.- \lll 'II , AI>VIGl; J~tl '''l ,._-1) L\~\. _ hL.\.ldl'. p,~.. L ~:i.Llcl...\'\~,.... L ~.Ltlll!L:_1\~'L~(k___ : ..._ _(>-:\:__Qc~'L.:.\.~ tJu_L~JtIl.YL,. ,_ ._.~.US~, -~~::>\''\,,\.JIXucl~:jcl.J ,:J:!..L,'(~cJ~...:LI.L__.._\l _ ~ \. Ie. ' c. \ I ' .r (. , \ - . '-'lJut~_~..____O'(\..~::::.LI,: Vl\'(},Q..lCl"-"'--"-"-7T.-\'^P'([}\JJ\~:j-:,-\'(~~l::-"''''-'''---ljj,d - fllJl'lIl, ---Mu-,t'A~' . --~l~'~. ...!~~~~_--\)...\1IiiAYIM~CY ,---~Q'5:-1'}---~-~\"'Tl;f\)2-,:.,:;:~clJ~il- . ,...IJ__ ~ f~--' . - -- .;- '2.___._...:.__ liME C^\.\.EP IlX IN ------lr.tItl.J;J~IJ1V Ilr)~' il\.~ :'.":"''' ',~'Op, , '''''"h~__IL'f['Ftt'. -~,I(f'r*\'f'?1 ,"-e \i'\'~~ ~J"L: j~~~~ IlY ---\J.\J- wV"-elA-"l\~.'M.L~S\~ly_..------._:T~lj;(h~~~," c .. 1~ , -------. (~' .L~nl\lL........~u\.t.:\1 .Jf' ~ oct. '~!-,J " PATlr:Nl'lI NAMI, ,_JY~lCL'(lt~__L~L~.\rl\{)_.._.~_. .-..-..... . , (JATI, ___..._.___, NAMI: ______._______.._..._____...____.._____~_ PIIONE: 'I __________..~___, W -----... !l11, ._____..........______.____,_____ MEABAOE 1AI<I:N IIY _________~~___.._.._.____.n__ llMIi ..----- - I mASON FOil GA\.\. _.___n......_.._._,________~___.~______ -..--......------------..-.-----....... ------...---- BYMPTOMB ._\,U'1\ll~t_,llv,LJ.._~Q.y,~~IJl'__'___lhrL\_~l:'.:.2.2.:jt{ _~_'--_.":'?,:Y_:.1.j(_,____ - -- -, , : ',,;;:_~;,~:-= ' ,_=- ,=:~, ~eT'=01j~~~01YctLlf==-=~~-~ : -';;~-';III, ~==~~:=~~:.~=~~----.-----=::...-;01] ..' " 1~;~~ -:=====::=.:=--=-~~~=~~ ,.1- ,______........._............._____.____.____4().Jf-..._.11 ,l ^\.I.I] IlX IN .._____,_.uu...._____ ~ 'lIMEIIMlI: INFOIlMlJP I'ATII'.I~' ......--....----....-------..... . -------~----...-.....------..------.---- ... PA Tlt:'~ 1 INF(JflMlil) ny _ .......__...______~__._~.__.__....".........._.~_.__. ---~.-.~...--..---........ ----..-.-~~-.---....--.. .._.~_._-..- " ......,'- Il .,,~ Il Il I' I, " ' ""~'\"(lji'Wi;H'('i;_ \, ii' I I fUCUIPITD ~ , . ~ , ""'., ~,~ -- i',,;!' "<___,~.,,..,, .h'l.-.........~ .'..,..r~..r......--...',_.h.__" '<, Il I'd I: " "I i,1 " " ,. I .' " ..!~I . .. , .. ~ , MOllNr^IN VI~W M~OIC^~ CliNT~R rOlll1 IN~ll1l1l^l. "^R~ ~O^P po~o~ Ifl MII'fll/HOWN, M I7tlU ('/11)\16.1211 ,tj.^MP )11~;;:;; TO I\PI'l1~N To WO~K/SCllool, "^,~~PNIINPeRMrC^~p/noh'__ l~.!121f{L__TO ' 7. '4.?i' MiD \V1~L ~P ^P~STO IIIiT1IRN TO WORK oN --,- 7' (j/ 9!? . . I'Mnll'e op ''''./'I1!Sl o~ INJ"~ r COMhllflru . p~-'k-~rfor / I11r/~ttfJ(lMnui_ p^n_~ ,__ " . -"""-- - DA.TEI '1- .a.q ~ NO, or MOES (Nor INCLUDING FRONT 1'1\013) MESSA-OB, d " .:! ..,... i' ,. ! ". ,.,'J'''\'''''''.' .~. " . " ','., ' ,,/ 1!!)(I1I..n' .. 1', . . ';l" =;.. -i -"""M."~"l>i,,.,e .."':"""'4J";' ~'.\ \;,_..~t"#''''''l~'B;''.\ -.:. .4 ,,,~, \ 'tl ..;. '>'.'-1' i .,.; \ \ "li " ':i. ~ :'1'. -.. L., , ,. " .\ Ii I'" " ,. ,. .. ,. I' " " , " '\' ,. ,. .j ,,'"-.1 u u v v (.' i. e ') e ~ e PATI: J:AOti I3NTfW MlJST flt: SI~Nt:P _3/&t/iL 'I'Ll JIt1(( (L.Ld{(LIuL~t1::J4\UJ.Ji~II""A''?J' ,~\- :/Jq ,.#at ..1' . (J) " (/ {/ :;~:/;;;/ ~1:(L~~I/u..t'ttJC~U~~I( ,- - ~--- ~J:.a.lbtJ.t.J~~IL-'t~~t..s+(i2JlL~t/J1/'14 h...t., .dU<<~ - 4a... "I'H...111~J..L.(ltlI4w...:..s;.il.lJ.....t/..! ,'J",,", 1., .r t,.. 1ia.J.-rt.i'~~ ' _ r!;-.tQ.l\:Llau.L,_:Z~j~"!; N Ii, .---::---.... K. ~U.kL("er/..Ji1W' IItl/r ~,~,l.~.;?" , _.__ o,I~/H):.I.'" I 'fvlllM,t 7...ti~.:. N' /'1C....4~.w::U,-A.,'tl1.I. M',"'/~' 1,_ Ao '$.I'{~ ___ -C4;,tLL), t .[1t..!ii:.J!,y/,OIt.. t'1lM V II?' .;;;.- {(JIb 1....,( 1~..,1. A:/I, )IJ~~a.~-t'h7 ".I-"';-IL.~... N"/~ .- t L'//,! 1.--~7 / 1 In'lf)' I),,, , -, . . -,,- ...:-LhJlj".., ~v' I),) AlnU-I.HI.t.. I' /~""I" J hJ.. :~'A::'A /./ /Gl ......:n~ . _11/ .,t,.{w,~ ",~....'^... ~ -----~.u. 61? ~WtY:b:znR r .l/.!iLj:1iL- 6: "L( (i,I~-' 1,,(.,1'1 .,..,,1 Lj-iJwoL.....LI.!.'tJ.J....illi l' ..fNi q~" 'iu.. ,.." /(r...cl , " . , I, ,1 . '. tw'll n--f1;l.~lII."I4_.1J./.'f7'u:c.LI~" fY II;I,i~ I ;::., tJ./ .6(4' .ifL:--&..&Ll~.td.(". /';:j~ . f,t /;,,{( I/'d........f 4<'>'1"",,. ~"',Mty /~t 1;/,1, , t..' N <I".i Mf) ,1.tI'1...J,~~,rv/.),Ir.tt~ 6.E!.T(I.4Wttldlvrr ~/.1I<J,f EL- ..~/Y )"'.""')" "'~ ""~/.(,;'I /!.-\'. /,;, JlUt:L~':>'7,i r Ut~'d,.J.,'b'~ f: ',{.,""~~II ~"111/, PI. (,dId IMd" """";':' ,-~# ".,L.L1~~11 ,4 , .f7l1l/ol It.In...ftJ.b 1i....dJd.iu~ ~~,,{il&f;!..z:;Lttll(j(J/12/l1pr C--~< . -- J' \"/'" ','-,'1 ., I'" ,1'(1 ! . '. 1'; 1 - ) , .. ).' I. r ILL (' .1 Ie) I '" /.1 (I J~)121) l!jl~o,J~,IO HEAI.THSOIlTH NITTANY VALLEY /lEI/AIIILITA TlON IIO~PITAL 660 Woal 0011000 Avonuo Ploneonl Clap, PA 10U23.0000 PHYSIOAL THERAPY OUTPATIENT PROGRESS NOTES 0-41 .'~. ' ".\" .' '" .. ,")'. ," . ....1..' ',;......_.1 ,_. PATI: t:AOI-! I:NTRY MlJST 131= 8IClNt:!P --._---------~-_._~._--. . ~- !l.~i.:(.-:..]I,;.idtd..,*l:-:,!':uj;liL;U.z.,dh.;n::d_l/Jfd4.I-.&;w!I/L;&,.-'0jll~ /t(' I Gr.D1. . ., 1;{~ '13'. )llziu.cLJ..~Ld~l'&l 11!;r:>/~.., Ii' /v/ILI...JJTIfI. ( . .. / I / ' ,- ~~IIt1LlL..L.-1.1ll1IIJ 1l1--kr.r!~'~G.L....l__ ~~-L~~ ~I 61-:;;/,;(pq.;;:cr-- .%IL7-)2I- J. /'1. .1f1'd:..lrl.d~~d:r-A!ttL_tlYd'jJ-{..:(~~tL tit" ,.~1Jf.r-c------'-' -- .&A'# JjtJ.'Uhr ,Llt.L-BiLLrzY'-f!-..I(';( A'f.u~,k!.; JI/J :rlVL4:~ . ~nUr.ll~' .:? /Jl&U-.uJ.i:L.,,'; ,t<o> "/',,,,Ir.m14 .. / i2.~' 7-'11V F ~.~,..:,. /1U':..<;~~l!..tL~_.Lf!J.(',it> I (ml -/. fiJ..JLE 4-.~ /:?,I 'd.'d. 11'~ A'lJ1'1 -eM,,:,.} .IiWLL#'-illl -".",LJ..:Lk./ 4<,<t1 . ''LLdUd-I,l AkRI,o..;. I rt!al:.U.>l.d""-. / t..' cf!.4t(~";.,, E Md .r's7;J1, ./~'----:-" AI'. Jf.&..leLG.J!r:/-)iW.;.;~/MP 1~1/Jl- s: "J,;", !,.<lL.du:..uL i~, ""<1""'7 II :/.(,i,/L {,v1'P'_L<.!t.r...LdItlD; (J "...,.,jI l ," _ f2.:.../&_L.ld1.w~-' lOll",. "....t.. .~t .577'-( .<, Cl:2. u.,-' JIl1WuLL~:"ta.~'L4UJ'~t'. _ /1-, ,h!~1'llA~ M(,UlIm:.",...lJJI A~(J>.' (0 :h ,.'W-.""J. .r,(,,,~,~. _ (I I ~ 'llLJl 'd),l, ~:)r-;n:,,'lll,t-,""ldkL~iL~-"r:""'II....-t"l"_~~_ ~JJJ,UJ'da.JhL~I)r m""~r"---' ,\~ ~~r.It.(J.i.JJru J77.,(V-1.1.fL M1.:I: I. &;6Nf R-1~,-~.JtJ.;;:;1W1YI2I11;Jf th:.J1. /11' 10" dt1DL;:JLllill~-/(}LL.r..tfCLIui.t....Llitl/ll'fl( l'A.1f' ','(.,..) . 60'11 /'1 ('1(r.~..,.J. ... Q;Jjf/ t /5 I 7n C ~J.'..L:&.!aJLLI~-1d2I.!:L.jl...fJ!/PM" Z'. "1'J1:tik{~-1li1r4- : . ,:ilL? :;:'r''Z,',i'''I''U- '. <IP.'.- 0'f.J"'c.. .AM...n> ';'(,~n.tL. ':)':6h, . '7 ' --- e.:-(!n, ?f'"u~"'-- ---- ,~LtLJ2FII',,7lJUJ?,tl/ll)J?f .J!Ji/21- :" W;a't-J.~.Ill,//t'.IV JJU/l1C'11 Vi.! l4.iell_LJ.'''' /' A ~~ .&. L\IL.!:...}J./J Iv ['(/'.!J:( I &J/l!.b!tJ1' ylf~I' <<</~nL M, '~~'~4j~""d.~"Jj4t::..t1.2.uz: ~fj.7E. ~..J...J.t.~:d...",dl /,/))'11"",-,- - .~"/; ,;,~ '''7''.~ ""~':~:tr,; r.e ~-,r//tr PHYSICAL THERAPY OUTPATIErh~ROGREBS NOTES -_.__._.-.----._~_._----- "J,. , . . ,"-"". . "'il;) . ~ ,.. ',' .' -..." .11,.tot..,. " . . . It ,., 8 " e PATI'l I:AOH aNTAY M\JaT aa SIGNap ..i:::1::1I__ ~'7dJ.1'~' ,,{.. ftL;!iL.~J~"7': JJ{..-n,;.. ,Jf lLllh0i. !2:...41dxl1..L..f~U"';"7~:....t.!~J:"L1I:,/..:&dll:.!.tuLA4~..;L~ ,JJ.I" ,..1 J..~' I {,I .J'", -j!i!l.~I--" N.',LUL_{)(/,, ___ U~:t.LiU.lLY~:1~',," "'~r11L....dkiKL(?P (LT:-b, ~~J'M~d' 1,;, . t~, AJ~/ ",a'! I f~~~j,(I'rJ4 ~ 4., l''''"^ " ~_~i!"';,'"~"z'd:-,l, ~t . . ' --- --_______...1._ ~:~....--- -"-l~{{tl!tLfi" fIJulaJ.i:JI17PC .$:Jt!::.!1.I- i).' lIJt.L211LL/J!Jd,';', _ _ .... __ a.~CflL4(:dttL4.4.L::i'I/.1tj;,,,,:~((r.tLEL--..a}2L4';1'I! 1r;1Lt-aat.'1 ~;A .121)1\) 'lJ.f./ ,.:tJ,) ...Efi...1ldui.uL " ~4L!ra" i' J:ff- ~~-t . , ?) ..:k~~_.E!.cIL..4L'LllfJI )/1(} .<l//:".L.l!C'" Y' j lJ.~.iiaJ.UO P t~. , e: (7",-&,,, ~~tf; r-- J', ",iLL61'r.lliiu~ Il'mt?L #J.._.JLfJl. ",/,,/)'1/,1 &)."-""") I~ - · ~"",-L'''''.1;-.i.L~:....i~~/'~,{ __ ~'_A/4~~ ~:I, t~,. 1:Y",Cr, 7" ,fl.... -,:/.'~/pl kJv,., ,,,...1....,&; ",7l W ~(JLtJ.J.u. \.' - -at l- t): 1'1. nJ>,-h~/"hl ..Mt!-'~'"''.:.J-?,*>'' /1/"',.,,(. iI .J .r.(, :A)",. ~,(Jj) ~~! I / / 1./' f/' I t?' . m /<?,I.,;,L(f'," /.1'( r ~ ,<,..,/ ;,{,. .'> , , .4.' j ~I'" j~UJJ.l4J.p.. I l 4P1''/'_M4d, 1'''-<; -"';:f.al~'UM f1""',I ~'II~t.~ ;1 fI..t/"'/- ::i Iv!. ,I kd." , ' /: 11ut"Jt LfiLr. ,/--'---- ;( )l{tIt(.l ("pj /-1rl-Ualf.J IIII' T 1/tI/tL-~Lu;m1~' hll:'1~11, '/1., l(l.'''-' :" ~fU() (h";''''''v',/!'d..,b';'~.~1Y . . /UuG , dr c1I:.1.u.L:aft. .~ /)I"'W.ill...dI..IM""'r.. ;.). , 74&i. J'h ~i,:.. ,',~ t_.'I;"'.-- {f,? .,. . ,(: u.ii..:" ..,,,"" 'd1<hL 4J.,"" I' ___ ..---- r ,ilJj(.1f::,~' ."?/~ ~<';'/' ArlEN,. / "{~- HEAI.THSDUTH N/ITANY VAWiY IlEI/A/J/LITM/ON I/OSP/TAL 660 Weal OoUooo Avonuo Ploo..nl Oop,f'A 10023,0000 -.~.. :' ~;I,(/(/" ;t{1 if ,,{il~ I ~ \ \' ~, I "I ~, 'r L f'. I', I. \ . - I ','" r 1 r. L " . I. 'f'4 . C,I/I) l/~I ,\' ('I 3CJI215 161)3)240 PHYBIOAL THERAPY OUTPATIENT PIlOGREBB NOTES 0-41 ., , , ,~', .f ,f '/ ' . , ,., t'(, ) ".:'; I It,' ," , -.. .'. t \, . I, "".' r ~\ '. ", '.. \ '-.,' , e ~ flEAL THS((:>>aJJllf'# Rt:HAal~ITATION OI'iNTt:R P..ATI.eNI.RB~Sf.QBI e ~ e QINITIAI.. '::>la:t:lEClEEHI FIOATION q I)ISOHAR!lt:1 f'I1I1Bnl'o Nllmlll -.4{( 'It '(~.f.!l-J . F'l1yololllnl -~.l..'1'- _ PIIIOl1oolQI -SpLflL(..t.l:UaI:,'.t'_'-U11IJd....--__,_,_______, PI1IB of 11111111111VBIi _?-LIl/ I fJ:._ Froq\lonoYI L.13 .lImoo/wl< TollIl P\lfl\lIonl...s.iI~"'~'!-. AIIBlldllllOBI _btrznL .Cl.\.UlfilllJ:rllll1manll - 7md,nt./,f -' 1?(~V'Y"'I'I,'~ -t,'(M'?'~......, ~/iA7 ?lo{/-(,1:WI .trlt(".yh.",,~ (( c?f'{/1'n'4-'" ,o?it -h/..~'f:- Q.urrfJJ1Lfl1atus.: ..n.: PI, Z"!: .~>V4,...uc"",,-~, (ffi ~~, ........ " JV, lid (Ji7 rJW/La,' ((oJ.. F I1Ul:)"j-~-4tJt.;LLJd--4:J:IL. ' , (1'" A"t --dll&.t.-e;L.'.tL...&zitL1fI.tM . _ 0.' ,1. (1'"'":21 ,t!a1d:.JneL.t~ ~- .?~-/ pi' Mk;'/- ~ A.tad...j/JA tJ:.-. /7) , ~I.d$_ ~a ~~'~~w, , II',.PI. ,~ Z M!.It..dJ. rilLLf.M d~):'t.M.l1.:L;;- /~<I<;n'~+K~.L:-_ -'-0.1'1,,"1- hAl' , L~~ili'!:lL;-~" P/~J'JL /'''M /')).'?:..-o/t :lo--J_ ._.:LM <<J;j tXL ([,7, /I~ f ('_.Ir, IIJ .cJ!L;zI. AIIiJYJu.d.,Aahl /"/',,h! /..j . ..J 1/.)' 61) I 11II1!L~(2~IU'tt,.Ji!~&L~H....7 1V'.1';" r-l' )(.(lj ./~, , ' 1It:::P - - -. TI1!.llilplal's ReQ.Qlllmenclallons.; 'hNm?l. ?F k ;2111fr.t-' I(.J/;,. A, t ~1" l.e?1((,,'I"'//.111 (.(, - Eb~olan'B Orclel'Sl CUV\,\--' }A.tALQ.. P, ~() f'~VZW\~ Thoraplsl SlgnaturBI ~ll!L('P7'!~.1AJ..tJt/2.mft ' 1bdaY'B PRIBI -f.-LL!I---1Jl_ Physlolan 8!9~'I(o; . Oale~' (i(-l:'~- Rolur OOfflOBI _ , tPloL) ,ollm, while (or'gln.') cOJ)Y. 1<'-(1 y.,IoIY fo yom "oonl,. CJlO1111ll1lt1g,nltlgll..OJlY.D,JIulllLtoQ.Jl.11I1a41l1IQUD.~P.AJ.llDo.ulllillJlalNlljDo...EiulL(D.I~1JlaJC.1101 Q.lj~WlIBLOllIlll.gD.lwll\uQ..EIlIIID.nl\Ll3IlJl,l'lL1Jlll2a..lD.\.!I)Jl5.lha1aLEoxI_ll11illnWOD ^1JntlUD.lrlnLP...nrkllQntl..MillIIll1QWJ],J~AjlQJlo.(7J1l~D.:lI:mLfJ\KL(Z1.7j.Aall!Jla.ttl I,;U!a.UlQnllILUQulD.~nttl,.MIIWlllI...ElLm.ll1-lZ.11lJlllihfiDQO_r:l\l(L(ZiZ1JlOihllD.Ofl lJ..ll.Il.JllIJJnlnJllrul"LllWlaIQWil,.EA..1.ZQM.,(Z.1llJl1.ltll.~llLEnKLlZ1Z1.2.42::M1l1 G:.li1lQ PATt:! f.AOI~ ENTRY MUST I3fl SI~NEP ..-.-- .:1.=:;>>0-'\:t -8.1. 'T (:} LJ..1.A'h.~ I\'~ y. (<\"\,<;_,, \~_:'_"__,.-USl.... <:'J,.M.'j u-S> ~ Cl:....... r.._ c.~, \ ._ o,~ '-'-\.~~<U. '-:,....} . -2~~.l:t: ~Q,Mn~"""~ -VJi/JL- 6.~...At;UXt.L.Ju..A.uL.._.2.~~ld; , IU;"'jlJ..~Jr .h.,L.t?t-(.'''7 .t1~t-,/ n:t'~- ...A,... tL~I!.j-'tp~_ ,____ .0' OJt..Af.w'dLiJJ1I.Ut/, A, c :r..,J},L (rfjJuT._iK.z'iL/>.<..""".,(.,r,;,(,LJ,(U<<:.II-1 hl..v- ~I I '/ /" , ,LUt.(X.t!.. ' 1-I~.._Iu.L.adM /-~: (?~j<lduu...1' h...: ~111LJ.M. ' _ 0' I' I' ' (j f ' , r - ~mrltv "uta.l.ttL.d.'h'3' c:_a.y-!t2I{, ,rv.. "~....:. ("I/t,~,t- ./~__ 5.~rr 21) .1l,u. "...--- ~ /Lt-,I!Ir.l'.IL.6I!f-/.J111J.11i.h !Jll? ~ .k/I! JLtL...Attdi ~?I'~II'dLL" c:1:-5-11'1. cN(.,- ~/., fD(LL,~ 7i. ~a21"? /lAt.), _dzZ1~1 ..lp ...:.. ..z':7-~ .' ..A...~-4l11'V:~' &~4.,L4d.. .h'~:.:,,,, -~ A of, ,). ~('... L.r/J)L')"~-1 ....., I,., IJ , . ~ _ , .1'" . -- ~/J,J )'./)'; 1>,1 /i~"""ln("'.,{2:~ ,r"..,"'C,l'A/r'l.!,YANm/ cL./!:. ,dJ.i!Lt.1~~llttl. \'0"tt' lLL.6.b:/4lI?M /:i .. rr <lvw.t~ ~&1_d6_~ ,IX, Ii"';;M1 ,~,a."..ct, t..:....Jd11iu.~l,tu,vA(/."'p. r"'--- !'..A(~&c..prr-'I A 1!/f,of.mPi-' , , l#YJ:..j!t,...dpIL.~ /u IvA./r... '~~l"'/!-? &l. ,~AY;l;..<... Lc'EJp'~' , a:..&-7~~;'-'d)"/&:""~ I~ or" ~'~/,{.dt~ ;,,.,.J/1. ~k,.~", ./4-/""'" .f' ...... ~dS.?o{!l"..l.)!.;J~t;1 7V/"',/~~....dI&d-.L. () '. f?I. )/11I'.1 'h/ut.-ISO In AL 'F61!UL.a1h:.u..~",-_. I~< .-1ddl !il tftOI.l''''' L6.~~"L..tf.LJL.d;dnU.t ;, )Of!- jWii_td A/~7 ~ JLC ___,~~MLL...~~rll' "1'/ f.' l' 11'"" i III/U..J ._ t.p-t.. ~~ JL..tf.(,,cc'( r;1.rr,! 111Ati41lm/11 17 ~ ~/"='-- ~ ------ ---~. PHYSIOAL THriRAPV OUTPATIENT PROGRESS NOTES ,.. . . ~ i .j ,t r' ~. . .;. ,:,,' ~." : . . 'l " ~,\ _, .: .... " e , H EAL TH~fJJ(OV7ll# At=HASIl-ITATloN Ot=NTf=A EAtLgN_'[J~BQGags.s..agP.QflI 1'11110111'0 Nama, -1:ltclJtt1..L-IlcIJ:MlL______ PI\yolollll1i r iifLrr:::. _~ 011101100101 ~yr:-LLWL(:c:.,:dc.il_4lu.ul1---,___.__,__ Pnlo of 111111111 aVail _iLL/v 121'_ FroflllonoYi -.l~--lImoa/WI( Tolal DlIl'IllIOI1l JUJ.j(LJ Al\lll1dal1ool ~_ e ~ e q !NITIAl. ~i=Ot:ATIFloATION . q PISPI'IAr~~~ .QlJ[l1lnLTililllmflUU IlIl?jr/l<'(l-T-J 'I;(~,V' ~;iJ ;~~ 1)C.tj'.,{;~1' -(<<r .~t:'f~~ .e.1. - ... t- Ql.IlliillL6-Uilua: . o :.- PJ.-LI.lztt.r-Ae..jlfla..ll7':t~L~(21~,t1JLzf.m:,...~h.l.bJd(a...A" J,'r ,rJi{ly . _-L-~i/.tu.'ll"-4"'aC7-1M["~._.J:Wl~f-..I.LLrIf~~~iJ.!"_~ _ -~c..!..~Lil~ ,4?()-)(t lL..tl~~IJ..,-fllitLL'j-11d-4af.dt.(luL~J'.t.U'-.aa.J61:Lni!e hl'Hd~r:Jl\'r.._... .. ./l;J!l..-;u~0t-I<I('II-'--.L'YI,jL/Ja.LtL..eLJclr/dtt141.u:...._ r /, Y'~7 ,)< ~ '-'USl:1 r. -------.-- -- - :rharaplst's RaQQJllrrumclnllQQlll , C'I,A'/WI! -Jr.. .51'.<! !' /, .;;~"' .:? -..3 (,.J,(\J 117 1,)<</(. (:II? ~fl{li'ril{lnu. I !tilt,/! /7(.:kvl'-!1~S , ... - Pby.mg!mlll...Qr.cIe.rlll Theraplat SIOl1aluro: L_JiIc./a'-6Prl!Jza{t.f(.l Today'a Dole: ...2.1.1/.-----1_'l( 'PIOlJ,f) folll'" while {ollglnlll} copy, Keep ysllow 10; your ;.carr/.. ~LBDlUnuJ]ldgIl.OtiYJI,JllllllLIJlO,_1l11lIQ.QQIIQgQ~PAJnOl-<ll1.!\l2aD.:o.liOILr:m<L(IlI.!l1.2alc1Zo1 g_nnO_WQRI.QDIIQgQll1'.QnuQ.-'~101lRnlllJ.1nn,_PA..lnn2(l(l1lAl:.afiD.:a.!l2-LJ:lIKUIl1.!\laUD.:5ll1l.O ~lnlJualrjllLf?mk..BDml,_MIlfIlIlIDI'II1._PA.lZ.OfiD_(U7J.~aD.:n~aLEnKL(HZL4aa,UfiUl Q.2a!UJDgm1.11DUlo.VlluJ.-MIILlInll.-'~t\.117.li.t(Ull.nO:halllllL.r:nKL(7.lZlJll!(t.JjOOfi LUlL/unlnlllJlIClIQ],.!.owlaIDl'lllcRlL17.0.!l4..(7J Z1,2~2,ll4111LEnl(Lt7_11.ll1.4M1Jl.4 G:IlO.ll f.AOH f.NTAY MUST 13f. SIQNf.P ----- .!J.::2J.:.e[~, J1 PI. ~~ ,/aLM(.~a....~li, Il't~ f!4Jnv:t(' .4At'I~,(, -'4/l -u.aL7-rJr;J1 J _L,IL (/'h I." I 1'41/, ,;.'. , -- --'!..ZLU:( '_40kU{-1 tJ,(..d _.,1" f.. httt!:'-1~~t!.LL_/t_l.," L ,~""dt'I.Q ,~t:U~ ----. / , I 0.' !~;( ~?tiUl..i'.-&1iLiL..G~u., I~, (}1:ru.'y-1a....l'I~', ~.&~L4./-#!!~"'- tf:.L4tLlCCd.1:..J.Ilu!.-~uJ.dd(:it'aI,d-,-- _ , 'V., i-J A~'1.Ltt:uut..rr-lJ.i /Jete;". M-t1>4:W!k:t.'.j/l/ ;f'.!1'~'~/A.1 ..&4L ' Xlt.1!.~.Jcll:JJdu( /1,,, J,w /"'~AI, f),' ALd '-/- ("tL~'(! 7\,.,,;' ., " 't!-~tll~ll:llJ.e..J!L,-'cLL1..J{2l.I'.~_Ifi~~ d,r~,. ''-, L ../J.6. ., """/- ".It) i:L.f~()-/2 ..A'41.~,^",r It~~~,- J? ~ PI ,(JIt~, ,ll/J IcJd~t:Lf~ IN" ." /1. L i. II Mod .p"-i4~~ .'\"\'J', fl' J.:u:.Lf-:iLAu(.'uk.&...~Gl&la.1 l:-~fl:iLLili,k,. . " L&-- 6P~11,Vltlhmflr -in/91 <)' f'l ,?""t- AI(Ld~l~.",.f .1,\, tf, "p.,{,,,.,, i(, Myl,~1LiA-Itp"lt. -~.lIll ~/"" /. er I,: t .'~, .<d, ;,-, ~/.... /,n 0lft ~_ir, rl) (Jr (/~/" "tl.u.:-1"'LJ~U{lLi~~,:" 7':& )"m) " .-- . _II ,. 1'-',' II ~ldf-I') '(,,,-,,, ,., I,.~ (Ill 4..L...l'I'''I' (!' / , 'f/,'" -r ,(1)1.(/5- t ,<~",:., .1L02..L.;z:::Lc-+!!t~7/; ,rl-d,,,,(.,1 (It.:J!.(~UlW~'''<!''lrl 1/' Pl. ,I;(."diL'!f~a'b,:I.;:r .dd6.~J A." ',/L~:",T'~- ,/1. ...."" /"'A':4"f"'~f C -J"';.r t"',{.v },.{ ",Ill ~,/",/,..,I. ""'<';1.' , . J. t"yl.'''r-lf/.i' ,I...T.",!:., , ".-- ,(.)/,-,&, GI'T ~/ltZjl/JJJ1ff' 'I- :ao~~~ So\ ""\"'''1 ,,~~r. \o(Y\Q~""I1.~-; 2. W ",\-..L~= (\lIC't "-\~~'-f-1\ --5:.~ ~ ~--__Q~J_'!;\. ~\-'.. 'r; 1:5\ r\:) c.-.",~~... U--"T....' '-\. \..q ~ '~M ~ "'" ,.J- PATr: -~- e ~ e ~ e ~ ~I\"'~ ,,<,' <:tN. W\~ , ~~~".j....~f.\ HEAI.THSOUTH NIlTANY VALI,EY REIIAB/LlTA TIDN I/DSI'IrAL 660 W.b! 001100. Avonu. PI...nnl Gop, PA 100Q3'OOOO ATIf.NT '.' 'j", \, 1 "i,' t, ('. 1a(~P;l' ;; itti.t4-, I C l. f. \1t."I~1 l')l)'~J~,I:.) G.41 ~\ PHYSICAL TueRAPY OUTPATieNT PROGReSS NOTES -------- PAT!: aAo~, aNTRY MUST aa 81GNF-P ---.--. ? -/1, ~ ?!- ~~!~(ii.dJ~(11:tLll..tJa.llLt:'4l1-.<l~4uI..u.L.A,:, J.'(\.~/7/!:!-...- . -- -..P.L..iAluLl!2t:L_ldl ,~/.IL.~UL'l~l!"1-(~~~_tiLl;~t_:?L_ -4Lfa./td il.k.~_'IA''v ""XLu!IJW--(5.~k.J1i::7'.J~laJl .!I.II! 'I,,'IL :N-<- ___ _ . 'aL~ld'a-Jfc.k' d . (j v . .fl~ ~~._.i1ILz!wuUi...L.<!tII;tL.~~/'~'-' 7~r2.Llub..fll~- ,'l1Y!u.tlI.UCJ:au:n.._..:L-7~= -~'I41'f..,LJf'-.tkt,- tUr'sY^",I ~t(.MU"" ~ / V I , . (1: 1~~_(.f:tl1}o _. ';~'a{1~~4fu.ffL'(I ."J'_, ,t ....:I'':".(:d.&.'''1;...ct!.tb:fuedh",pJ UJlII.d1M (J.t~ .( :i(J.1L~~.6..1Litd_L,w,L~~~ ;1MM.~-==-- .-lAn_, 11> llWl.'41kL..W~,J~/ 761~~jdt;- n/.A..aiA< __, tJcI(Lill.tI .,4, <1./"-r-t:i~.....6M..J'. )'//,~-'...LvML'<L~L.:iP~lft "~IVI~.I'.~/l"lL~LL.~Jc;",r:<? h.~~-->- ..' .. IU...l!6 _111M ,"'.:4 11.",";.. /";:;:-- (.>,/)o./>-,,{.;'-1 aJ. t:r (' "'\~<1-Adr...I..l.L--' l4.1J,~,.t.- /.~M"'" ~ 1/7,1 di..1LL_/~('-- , .. P,' t~2J.tuu..J4I' .1 Sn.\~J- &!I..I^'(.'7",iJ,~ <1)~-~, z" ~//;'" ./ . -;d~ ~tk'V. ,/ ( / /~v (. )(d4'GP~4r?{)tlrlliVr' _1J-l,b::1L .I,'?J. Apu:b....M.tA.AI>jJlL/:~1".1 b"r'-1~.6./tln~~~. , -1.i1~M~-AL-AJnl 7'1. Ml',(, .. 0: b ~'rh..t;, t!(//.,{, C' ~~""/1J:'" >< ltl ",,:/- , 1:!I....:Ii.t:UL..M.(~_ "'.....1" ,.6'\ . 'r I.JJ...t..... ",I- ,:. "II /n,!~Al rkr >4, .." I{,J,e& . 11/. _~'~L-~ I. I r Itk/YI)YM,I .<1lvl,i., .r '(."~~"':;'" -A"~ ~IL('ldl.. 1-1. ;{ Ir( ~ /Ii. '7"',,_____ / /'~' __c1i:!lLklL:b..;7 0;". 7'\:I1~L..r.,.{, C.J;'u.., rle}' ,'" 1L!'d..ll,~~-,-__. Ll?4m~ilill tj~ "1,'l!i"/~~iArM(d:. . . r.' ~/(, < Wtf "I rd.,,,j L.~ ./nL;Jl:., / .t:fI1'T1~ c, AL<J:iL6fN/ bttall}~ -6., ~"---;"". ~.-~ -_______.____. -.-"-- "'"-- ..- '--.---- .- .. PHYSIOAL THERAPY OUTPATIENT PI'lOGI'1E9S NOTES e ~ e ~ e . . (") - ..... '. ~TIi f:AOH !!NTRV MuaT In; al~N!=p , . ~~~"-L.. r_~.>~~; ,..y r ,~~ /.?~k ~ c:::$.... " -r--...:r,..,.,-....-?-? ~) ,_ ~"';::>,...,;r- 7I'r...s ":><"1 ~..G:::2_6'-- -r ~"'~~~__"'~c~'!.-...A~ --=r ',. .-" f' ~ ~/ -- ~. .-r.ry.:...:::'d, h;-:"" t:"'~, ~-L:2~l=ft-r d- . ~-.P''?l?d./ 5"' ~~ r~ ~..,..-~ ____ ,.--__~_ ..:::-/: ""-;:--... c~_ t.#.e: .::;.::.- "'i'''''~..r- .-' 5-7 ".-? ._~- ,~~o4jje-~-- ,~ ~~. ~,~"'-....." ~~~~f>d":A.~ _. , -~~- ~!J:1Jf_;LlL~I"'I'1.J .~ ';Al"}',;:dr~ A"/,Iab::".t~ Il,:' 1// .ml.',-.fdok> , . qu.l.:.:d.~j.::......:z7~~.dJUcJJl.J.L,Li.l,i'J A;t'" " ../. w/' ~&...&..4'''' " I ~ If "'<Jf,"</J ,~. . ~ , ;/-/ .on? I> ,~L2Ll-.J/~'/fl"'_.. I. fi..:J , ,/ , ;I h' c' II II -,4, (.a;cJ;~, I ,I' :II) ,.., f." ~~1!tn.tc'L.4 577-t ~ (ffJ..--t7 A')o;-' a.~ PI. l,1.1':U;,.(~'l,{.,I/lrt( l.... I./T /,-h.~lfl~/ ,!I"t.I0.l:::-d.:tr>,A _r1,f,l.~-Llt:,()'f ('~ r ?,u.1L.-1..&.b<.~' ,'\'&M", ~"f,/ .:~O (/" , -:];1 /,.--;?.< d."I' Llflt1'lJL.2.C2J5. .AU"d. '.><-..1'/1'" 2 K ,4S' ' I -; / / I / --.!l IJrtd ('..,,:k..d~D.l::J't'.,- ,c"'1K, /1rI2ltU~ A: jJl. ~/~~dl. II. I<H1f1,,1f~'~.rJ.d2.t:,if /1. Mf~~cLlLuia:.I'" :/ /?,...M-:;~" t~ ce'1'u(""...0''''-Ilul- Ll<11-b'&J~h:.. /1'1.'''....... , , / / ' __ Lldh-h:", ,,0 it< rI t c' ~""'(;'IP e'~I~('~ "''' 7'1l/e.~"d.... _ ~ _', _ / d!u;,....- C 11c&--6..E.'I,/J.JJJ..hyJ.,1111'( ------ .. - ----...'----- " , .:. .'. . (l n 1;,1 u \,~I PATIENT &ij'~;?' '. y1--&/~(?, / \~,I~! )"i', fie L C j I ' ),1 I, I " ,'I )~)I(,) lbl):;)2~O HEALTHSOUTH NI1TANY VALLEY REHABILITATION HOSPITAL 660 WOII ColI.g. Avonu. Plo...,,1 o.p, rA 10023,0006 PHYSIOAL THERAf'Y OUTPATIENT PROGRESS NOTES 0-41 , ;1' I' P 'CAL TIlEMIJY CAR1~ I'LAN. 'NE - Inlllall'la" _~ 30 Day I'lo~lcsl SUlllmary I'I!Ul1CI Chall #1 Dal<ll PhYllolalll_ ._ 000upal1on: Worldl\81 YCI No Evalllalloll dt\\e: __ Dla8nollal lC'D.~ oodol IIlrCllllllCl11S sll\oo IIl$\ ~lInuna\r: ___ COlllpltauool__~_ Addltlollal vlslls reqllesto<ll_ I'Honj.J1.lY( J.IST - Objectlvo alll~qual\llOablo I) I'IIS\U,a! deviations of: ~ '.>".:s"'../ / c/ -:- 11) Abuol1llal body lllechallloslpos\lIml aWar~l\el& . - .. 2) Dt<ll'ell1o IJ1 CervrrhorfLlIlIlbar AROM~Jt....,.,.?> _6t'_-. --!!"r?pC J'-(1'd!-." c..$" , v , 3) Sofi Ilalllo dYIf{l~llon of; .?1-,.J.'/r,-' @'? __ ...~,,?~- ZZJr..P 4) '1;lc~rtJlllty ,eSlrfcrlofta of: - l'llllclloua! Aetlvillel (\sseS&lllell\: JIO Stabllltatlon Lcvelll'oll\tsl _~.__ (FOSE) 12) Redllced balallOO alld I'roprfnoeptlol\; 5) Dccrcaso In nluiole strcngth of; 13) )ollll hyPonlo\llllfY of; 14) Jolt\\ hYPtITooblllty of; 15) Neuro!ogloalllcl1clll, 16) 1'\lncllol1alllcl1clll_ 17) Decrcosed l,os!tiol1allnleralloes: _. 6) Ahl10rmal response 10 vel1lcal oom\,reSslou; 7) LIlInbar I'rotecllvo Meohanlsm gm< 0 of; _ -. 8) I'aill scale ralltlg of: 9) Work statILS~~ (( 10) API. Lhnltallol\s: '~ ~ \ 8) NeuronlllSO\llar oOllllOl dofiolt;__ -- - 1 ~) Other; _ - 7) Inlprovo L\I1l1bar Proteotivo Meohalllsml -.--- GOALS. ObJeollve alld q\lalllltlablo - _ wk 9) Improve halalloe alld proprIOOOl'llolI: , 10) Incroll1o JollI\ mobility: 2) R~sloro AROMI (~ t(//1/~ ,,(//;,,~?J;b 1- _wk 11) Promotejolnl Slablllty: 3) Improvo soflllsSllo mobIU\yI----, 1.T-:7, _wk 12) Improvo nonrolllusolllar 001\11'011 4) Improve 110xlblll\y: ~~,!q~:"", 4'~_WI: 5) Improve musolo Strel1gllll wk 13) Inorease I'osltlonaltolemlloes! _, _wk 6) Itllllrovo venloal ooml'resslon response; _wk 14) Improve ADL'sl_ _ _w\; 15) Ind"".'lIdenl Wllh hOll\o excrclse program;:JZ: Z,wk _wk 16) Improvo nemologloal statnsl _,.wk 17) Il1d""endenVAcllv~ahlmanag~IOl1t s;ratcgleSI 'Zwk _wk 18) Retum 10 wOlkl,~.t..... rr"_'" 2'1:lc.r,4 ,,/.>.... z..w\; I~) Other: ' _wk, 1) De<rrell1e postural dovl~tlonsl _wk ._wk _wk _wk 8) Inlprovo bO<ly meohanlos oml ploleollon of spine; F\lnollonal Aatlvltlos Assessmenl: 11 0 Stablllzatlol1 LcvoVI'olntsl _ (FOSE) ASSESSlYlENT - MAJOR FUNCTIONAL LIMITATIONS 1'REAThlENT PLAN ,~ostunl excrclsesllnSlmctlOl1: _ 9) Nourolltusonlnr reeduoatlon __ 10) I'\lnollonal stablUzallol\ tralnlnR _2) Dodymeohanloslnstluotlon _11) CardlovasonlarreoolldhlonlnB .~rsofltlssuo mobOlzatlol1 _ 12) ADUFnnollor,al training _!I) Jolntllloblllz~llonli'ROM _13) PoshlonalToleranooaollvhles ~5) F1exlbllllY oxerolsc __ 14) \'\lnotlonal Basellnc Eval\1~lIon . - 6) Man\lal rosistlvo exercise d7.~"Work oondlllonlng alld shu\lIMlon - 7l...Dnok ed\lcatlo\l and tmlnlng __ 16) Modalllles as Indloaled ..k::::::1l} Strengthening I,rogram ~_ 17) Othorl._ Treatment FreqUellcy:~yt(/~. Treatmenl Duratioll;S N;{<?, I oel111'y that tho I'rogram outUned abovo Is being Ilrovided undor my s\ll'elvlslon and Is reqnlred for the p"tlent, 1111s oarc 1,Ion Wll$ dovetoped b le'tl mplst and will be rev lowed every 30 days. This plan has bccn dlsonssed with IIle pat Ion!. ~~ ~, ?~7-~~- 0W' /" ~hysloa Therapist ~ patlenl -- Physician - ate . , . PIJleptlvll J;valuatlon . apaelfl~ lallna ~aSOQ en pallonl pr,osenlallol1. . with a reaspn {lIven fOf nollesllna. ....,Gllllo~urvnllo~ Alllalale R ~_ \r1I~1 Oomprosolenl , . S\f\IP!l1rMI p~aorvllllenl . /;t'J I? Occlpl1l '7...4-+----- Sh.oUlder~. B~pUlal..~~_ Olnvlclns A&IS PSIS lIIae Oresl. Trochnnloro _ GIUleal telde ~na ~snalh. Sacrnl SUlclls _ IIA 0' flncfllm ~olarnl Shirt _ ' , OarvlOllllordosls .~ ThoIllOI\lI<yphoala ':?"" ~um~sr ~llrdosle. ~ poatijre/o~vloua1Ti.9cJJon enl alrau polnts:_ ~-+",.".,..-~~. ,- -- /,~t _ Ronae ot Mallon . ~uenllty as <~o,r,r!fl[.f\lU"r.nc~ <- 'f1~r " AHOM JP" PRO Ill'-', OA _ I'D . Fa M FB ..2.e.. BB LE-_ Sill, SF.lL 2b- ( BaR _~ Aotellon L RL Rolatlon R ~~~A' IlO Illl ~~~~?:;~~ " JOJalerlor QeaQranl Toel: l ~9 -"1. R ~I!-..__ ~'I_ ' Ver1e~raIArleryTeet: ~ +/- R___+/- f'raIRlbPeelllon/Mo~IIIlY: L ~/ _ R~ Thoroclo Oullet Sorunl Adeon -:=:_ + I -. MlIllery -- -... I _ Pecloralls Minor ~ _ TMJ soraon,~;:r- Nouro Sora on: ~ U lfu! Loft ~ hi S.ltiOllUl Floxlon In Mod Svr ,NL MI Mcd Svr Ohln Tuok (01.2) Exlonelon NL In Mod svr WNL MI Mod svr Peeh Ohln Up (01-2) AdQuctlon I NI. In Mod svr 'WNL M n Mod Svr Sldolmnd Head (03) Abduction WNL In Mod SVr WNL M Il Mod svr UpperTraps (04) Exl Rol 'WNL Mln Mod SVr WNL II< In Mod svr Deltoid (OS) Int Rol WN Mln MOQ svr WNL In'Mod Svr Bloope (C5-6) ABC Diagonal WNI Mln Mod SVr WNL In Mod svr Wrlel Exlenelon (00) ADD Diagonal WN . Mln Mod svr WN Mill Mod SVr Trloepe (07) SOIIpulohllmer I W Mln Mod svr WN Mln Mod Svr !:x1.Polllole Lonaus (C8) Rhythm , Lumbrlcale (T1) PALpATION \. ~ SOf.tTlSellllAesoeemon~)1~~__ .~k'p !7tP'..?~~ '~~,b../""""";J' ;;"" n L, ~.~.Y_ -. Noma: It an Ih, .e not lealod. II mual ~e marked accordingly A~~~ ~' - - SIlf1. SIlI~ ~J- ~__ Funotlonal Activities -~ _~ Slllo StQnd 51110 Supine Supine 10 Side Overheed Reaoh Slend 10 Squet Soore -~- - , -- . - --- 1'olel 0- cennol per/orm oorrectly 2- able In pSlloml oorr~ctly , I '\egmenlal Mnblllly/Posltlonol Faulle Sealo a-Dnkyklse<! a-lInDlahle ument, Hypoll1oblle Hypermoblle Posltlonel Faull Polnrul ~ -----~-"". Thoroplel Slgneluro AeeesSll\entlMejor Functional LIrT1I1Q\lone:~~ ,A? 11':9 ~. tf~ .....-.-~.. 0n.I..r ,~ ~~~, r/'" "'1'lc:Lf_~_.... ct&,.~ HE:TH~oCrN · ~N1T1". Rpl~AJ3I/..ITATION O~NTt::A ;:g.=.~T~~~AT,aN , eATJJlliI...ffiOORSSUlJ;emrr PaUanl's Namal -l.('0{c.-E~..s.t'-) '_ Physlolan: ...1~b.!:--_____ Plaonoslsl ~\ ~f~"l':~) MIILL Palo of Inlllalllvall -1.,~_L!lL Fraqullnoy; -~, Umos/wlt Tolnl PllraUnnl .11421tUu/l/.,GAIIllnclnnoal .JJ~ QJJ[WnLtre.alr.ne.ntl 4Ai;; N'Ii ((.sTief I'M ';;"'w..tf .,(}~'".tI(./..( 'd OUrrenta!w\Jat ..<11 :'1 j~~ "' <c~&...;s~", " ;<, "-~1/ f t:r?i (9.' , ' -:till ttJtU.a1 A""L ..2/JliL ~)~ 'If( ( ( ~u,,L .:.-t ,.{t(< ,( L,,"""-I JI2Li . I, .i}";jV. .'l~JIilI ~.1~~I:" iT .1f;-6.(4LLl.J:s";1 / "-(l.~_~~. _ . t/GP ... Il1emplst's RaaomlJ1endati.Qnsl {~,(i1~u~ ,Pi A"/" I J /~I fr'.L; /tXt/? h 1 !:/j" . ~~ $';7 .?nc/..wA""1<.t> t)I'/ fAt/v tf * MY,( ( !113iJ~ Thoraplst Slonaturol.LJj~J.P-r I&Wo..l-/2J1JIJT .Y 12 t(f~" lbdny's Palol _(LL.af_ _1__ .1 -. ~olan'B Ordm:m p lefl ~ ("'" \1)1 V\'<:', , ~(r fo(" ().-. V\l\.we W'- ~I,~J Ie) l' fVto1vl~ClI't~~ ttk\A Wd-/\c.. \r\G(V(I{.tvt(l"r Physlolan BIOflalurll1 Palol..1,.L1.J..1f'RalurIl 10 011I001 I 'PftMIO lo/utr1whll. (ollglnal) cOllY. K80{l Ydl/OlV for your 'BOOrdl. !;Llio.Lflll!llnal31dDfLUIIVQ.JlllIIQJ.oQ,lUnlllC.QIIQDD..I1\.Hlllo.1.~/l1.4l.JlalhIlIl.OtLEllKL(1I11l.1!aa,1,ZLlt ~aLO.cIlQDQ_AVQnUQ..ehll\6nntJ.inll..eA.tllllaa.ln.Lll.llliI8l.4aLEilKL(/l1.4IJlliQ,llnllII ualrJnU!l\tk.l1llJld,.MJlfUnlllwn;J?Al7.011.11.(7JZL4llll:llaa(Lf:nKL(Z17L411lhll.11111 UJI.a.4.1IllDnn.D.o.ulllwll~MIILI:lnll~MlWiL{7.mJlllIl:JlOo.Lf:nKL(illlJlI!:l:Il.OOll UJlll.Jul\lntnllltQQUowlalawlI..P.A.11111.'l(7.t7.1ll..4M.411lL.f:nKL(illL2.4M.401 !l,ljllll 1-.. e - . ~ e ..~-------._-- '.-'---'__ _._..r____..__.~_ ---..---.,...-----.-. ----.---- - fOil TII~~IMf.NT IIEOOIIII PII Oala Ilala f' IIlla A lIall A Oala IImld Unll II Harvill -1.1 ,.~ Nr _:d/ll ~ -~ 1?}f_JkI9f Jhll/d' 'fj;/i;tylJ.L..._ II UIIII ~ 15111111.) , ,.'- REJ~~I~1 EV~~lI~TloNH my OOIlE my OollE lilY COilE lilY OOUE nTY OOPE lilY COPE -- --- -- -- --, '-- --- -- - 437,001 11111111 Eval. """our Addlllollal~Vli:-' --..-- ---. --.-- --- ---~_. --...-- ___h.~_ ----- -- ----- 437.002 v,lIour --- ----- ------ ....-.-.. ----.- ---- .-- ----- --. -- -- 437,00.1 CVblKlKlllcorll -- - , - --- -_. 1-- _t!.100E~ _..L _1t.__: ~~: --- _(cJ If.Jd~ _lP. - L8JL 437.004 l!!!!!J!!!'Ilo Ewc!!!.... /1t-::__ ._s:...._ -~ .Ll~, Jt.1-::.... 43/.605 Thlllllaullo f,o,TX ---- -- --- -- --- ------- .-- '-- -- -- -....-. 437,006 NIUlomuiClIlarllo'Ed ----- .-- -- --- -- --- --- ---. .--- ---- .--- '- 437,007 fllllcl Aollvlllal -.----- -- --.-_.~- ---- .---.- --- -- --- -.._- -- ---- 437.000 0111 Tllllllno E,SlIm (MarllI1il-- ---- --- -- .-- -- ----- --- --- --- 437,OIl1l -. -- ---- -- --- --- --- -, -.--- -- -, -- -- 437,010 lonlollhorosla -. "-- -_. - --_. -- 437,011 TracllonlMallll!11 ~- ,-- -- -- ---- -- ---- -- "-- -- -- 437,012 Mamga _L J'(1::,_ ,_L__ .1K'b.._ .-.1.- jK1-- _L_ 182.-_ -- "---. -- 43/.013 ConlrlslOnllla -- -- --- -- -- -- - -- 437,614 UIII/lolllld .---. Unllllld proCoiiure- -- --- --- --- --- --- ---.--- -.- - 43/.010 - -- '--- -- --- ---.... 43/.010 Orou~ -- -- -- 4370617 Toalllll'a.'!ll1y/Conl --- . - MOOAlITlEH /8 /-. /J'JJ 43/.0\0 IloVCold f.acks -'- _Il.~ -L_ L!..2::._ _/- L~ / -1- ---- 437.020 Tnollon Mochanlcal --. --- --- __N_ -'--. --. -- -- --- 43/,021 E,SlIm (Unollondad) .-- 4370622 VasollnoulIlollo Oovlco '-- -._. --. --- -- --- 437.02~ I'arallln Oolh -- --- --- --, - --- -- -- --- ~24 Whlr1llool ..--. -- --- .----- -- --- -- 43/.026 Olalhermv ..~ --- -- -- -- --- "- 437,620 Inlrarad --- -- ---- --- 437,627 Ullravlolol - Unllslod MOdolllV -- '--" .----. -- -- -- _h. <137,020 .-- -_. -,- -- 437<629 lIubbard Tank -- -----. -- -- -- -- -- 437.031 6wlrno, -- -- ---._- -.- - -.. --- -- 437,633 Prosllrallo Tralnlnu __ "---- -.- -- -'~--.- 43'7.035 --- ._-~ Klnollo Aollvlllos --- -.- -.--- --- -......-. .- -- ---- ------ -- -- -- 4370630 Wo,k1lardonlng ~~m7 PLtirurmn- .-. -- .-- -.--- ---..- -- -.--- ---- --- 1111 i.l__._ ~._-_. --._- -- ---- ---- '-- -- .----. --.- -- ---- ---- .. MllIOd Traalmonls - .--'--- - l1 Olllpollolll MIFFLINTOWN OLINIO IIEALTIISOUTlI NITIANV VALLEY nellAOILI1M'lON 1I0SPITAL Phvslool Thororx JnEATMENT nEDOnO/of nDE SLIP ... ,,, t:, . , ;' ~ ~ r?otino T(1010pl51(5) SIOllolllro/Cor 0 . . \., I..: , . , I I t: I. I. -LML r.6/!L/J'J=_ ____.________ , i.- ~ 1'.'1.' /1,' I >~ ,1.1 , -......-- .----.-...-..---------. JU Ii'i) 1~"Hn40 --='- .. - ..-- ---::--=-...""::::'=:::::- ---------------.--.--- .- ,~ I I tit -. . e m r---____ -~---~_..-.~~- --....--..---.-...-..-....-. '______n__.~__ _~.~__.~._~__ ____~___. _.___........,-__.. fOil TnIATMiNT lIiP01I11 "II' 1111, 11111 1"11 ""0 0111 IImr~ IInll 01 S"vl" (1~mln,1 7 - 3<.\::!L (J,.;Hf 12 (/! J~'Ji :2L j'I~?-7J ' i'~N"7i --. -- - ---~- 8i'~VI01 iVA~UAlInNs IITY Colli lilY coni lilY 00111 IITY Doni IITV POOi lilY o III COPI ------ ---- _._- -- - -- _. --, ~- m'OOI Inlllll iv,l, \'! 1I0ur eddlllOnlllVlI. .. -.-- ---.,-.- ,...........- ._-.--- ----.-- ---- -'--- -_..~ -~- -~~--- --- .---- 437,002 ,1I0ur ____ --.-- ---- --.--- ------ ----..- -.-..-- ---- -- ---- --- m.003 CyboxlKlneom - -- --.... - - -- PIIOCiOUlIlB -- -- pC -_. --~ --'- -,- Jl2:~ ' J~'.1-, _ -~ .Ilk .437~ l!!!!!J1.!!!!!p',Eiar!l!L _tL.. ..L?&... Jj{f.L 1k.'kL _.l<L__ -.iL 431,005 Tllmpaullo Co.TX -'- --- ----. - ---- --- "-'- -- ,- --- ~.o8 Nluramuleillor lIa.Ed funel Aollvllin ----~- '- -- --- ----- - -- 431,001 -- -_. -- -- --- -- -- '-- --- -- 431,000 Olll,!rllnlnp -- -. ---- -- -- -- -- 431'009 i.Bllm IMlnilal) , - -- --- ~_. - -"- --- -- -.- 43/,010 lonlorhorell~_. ~" -- --- - -- -- - 437,011 Traollon IManual) , - - - -- - 431.012 Mllllpa '-- -, --. . --- - m,013 Conlrasl Oallll -'-c. '-' '- . - - -- 431<014 Ullrllound - Unllllld ProeldulI --- '-- 431,016 - -- '-- -- -- -- -_. ~ Group -.-- -' -- -.- - -, 431.611 raanVfamllylconl 1-- - - -- -- -- --- - MOOAUTlEB 7 ~ '/-- - -, ~ HoVCcld Paoka L_ .1!LL. ---'- ._1- JrL 431.620 Traollon Maellanloal -- - 431-02 I E.BIIIIIIUna\landadl -- -- -- -- - 431.622 Vuopn~umalle Oavlea -- -- --- -- --- -- --, -- 431-623 Paraflln Oalll --- -- -- -- - 437.624 WIII/lpool --- -- --. -- 431,625 Olllllarmy , ,-- '-- --- 431<020 Inlrarad .. - .- m'~21 Ullllvlolal . - 1TnlIiliil1JOiJ'ilrry- -- ---~ -_. -- '- 431,026 --- -- -- -. -,- 437,020 lIubbard Tank -..-- '- ---- . ------ --- -_. --- 437-631 Bwlmax ----..- -_. -----. -- --- ---- .-.- ----.... ---- '- --- -- 437-033 ~roBlllalio Tralnlno _ -'-. ---- --- --- -- -- ---- -- ----- 431,035 Klnallo Aellvltlaa ---- --~.. --- ----.- ---- -- --.-- ---- -- 437,030 Woiklla/llanlnu 4~1W r~tluallon~' --. -- --. -.- --.--- --- .- --~ --.- n1L~ 1.iL.._._ ---- ..-.- ---- "---- -- -~-- -._- .--- -- -- Mllsa" Traalrnanll ~---_. '-- - o Oulpntlonl MIFnINTOWN OllNIO IlEAlTIlSOUTH NllTANV VALl[Y HEIIAOILlTATlON HOSPITAL , ' , f'hvalonl Thorn~v I:.\ll" 11.1:' t'1(:t. I', TnEATMENT HEOOnOtOI An(lE Sll" " .' . , J. u ( Trontlno Prap/SI(S S/onsluro/Codo 1., I ., ~,~, t / 1,\ fie L . II I , ',! .{':' L ~ 1t.l2/?L.J . . ..:... __. '. r. ~ /(' \ I ~ y I~ H ' , ,/1, . J , ""'fL- ~~o.\..."Q-\\1 ~() _______~ '~d I j' I) ItlHH'\l . .:, , .~\'\ v!J,.' . . " ~ f~, l' ) , , . , (II. I'.'i\' , , '" ':\ij; ':,1i).' ,. , . - .- --- . .' ',~~ - " I ~-~" D 'en \':le to \~ ~6 ~S.2S ~ <57'::\8 & ;1~/~I3L~ '. ......' ~,.... ... ~;.> \.)'?;':; ~q; 9?G-gRft/' ~:t6 601 Jf'f 1tt''fd,- 6",\ ~'~, 6'8y.- ?30? /ILLk eCL~1t:,ll nppq111\:mel1t;(n) un Han ~ TIII>>....J.'1.4-we Thurn _ 1i'rJ. ~ ~-_ If 14--. ~"--- -- UE1ALTIISOUTU REHABILITATION CE1N'1'lilR - MIl!'l!'LINTOWt - Xli' YOU AlUi1 Uijl\llI.~ TO Jqim;-~XIl A\'l'OXijMNT, l'I.1U\sm 0l\.LI,\~~233. ., .......,.......................,.....................................................,...,...........,..........,",; flat/ent Name ,_ u "nTURN INI _ D/lVa rLf.V q {( (a - WEE/I a v- .--- -_ MONTI a __ _ AaNEEP - RETURN TO WaR/I APPOINTMENT WITH ---- RETURN Fon ov PX f'X & PM' LADS ONI.Y X.flAY ON~Y 'i " __, " ,.,.. " " '", " " '>1' f \;r, ,'1' -~, ~t ti ~t'';: f t,-t t't1'{f t \.~ ~ i~ I J .XHIJIT " Wi~\"MM\""Af!'il\"fflJ;';\~'\l-I,\.tW~Mi.f.''' " " I. I I " " ,: 'I U.; " I' .' "I; " ',. " Ii " 'I " " ., j" " I.i .1 l'j -Ii I" v v 'J ,-J '-' \j \,., l.J ,. r ), l! f hI p,~ ,." l't " ''''1-' ..,,,,',!,,<, .XHI"IT Q .... ~ ._oii/f'l I-.t!\ I"!y.'\'!~ 'I ''-'-'-'-'"''''-''''--''''' ,\ ,--~, "', --'.' -._,", .. :" ,,";,~~~, -.'.-j ",;,;,. ~_~r,.",'"" '''''1 ". " '-., " .. ... ',,; .. ,,'/; 1i ':, " (~~r r,\ ,e " " Ii " "t I,; /' ,. " '" ,'< iI 'L v ,_/ v u u v v I.i 11 I I i (,.,' H\, j "~'I' ',\', ,*\;>;",,_,;t '~_- ;,.\'.;,.T:," -,~,J'-;:"L- (i.I'eUli,',U.:j';'\'i'; I . . I~""", . .--,. .,'--. .--.,.-.- ;~-;\,;i;HiI/HH!iK'r-rt"M'!'1i1\!Wt-I,~i\Y1\ll~ '). "IeHI.IT H ,. il' " ,. .. " .' ';I " ,. ,\ " en ';" .' Ii, ".P " " L 'OJ ':t " " " '"~, " .' " " " d' ','" \'f .' q ,) i..~) .;.) u '-' v 1" n I I , . I I I I"'" , ! to -;.J I Tt) ~ -. j' ) l:JISNIORITY ~ISTING" .-<l-PA _ NAMf: 131030 Sf:NIORITI.. _ a ..JL -.-L_ w _ _.1__ J_ S - ~ I.Q8QJ3..R~_l1oolf -- ~_. ------ -- --- ~ ._2L;}.;L~__dlt .;l\_~,..1LL -1.. RtlYl5.lhhltiGSR 10/6/66 X X X X 2 sTeVfl JON~___ ._1/10/66 - --- N txf 1-_ x .- _ x --- _ 3 EBffi!.1:l~GY __ __1/20ffi!L_ __ __ ___ -1L _>1- --1L.. _>1-__ _1_ PAVIP STI~SS 3/26/60 X X X X 6 JSFF oARNSs. _-.!!!J;!!80 .- ,- -- =. x _X_ - x- -. x = 8 aRIAN BI3N~L.___ _.__0/11160__ __ - _.L _.1L_ -1L _.L 7 JIM I(F-Y 1P/20/80 X X ,X x 8 ROBflRHININGt:R ' - iO/3WL -------::::=.-:.00_ aD ~(5b ~28L ==- o JflFF BOYSR ___12/31/80 ~__~__li._____....1<_-1L_ l!!. ~ ROPE _ ' 1/30/00 --1L.. -L _lL ,_JL .. ___ J1.Q.~veWINGlEB1-_ 5/13/00 ___L~_2__.JL_____.. ~ GTIM! OA6SEI..,.__ _ 1/20/0.1__ --1L.. -L -L...JL 1:1 PAVSWISt.:ANP _ 0/10/01 _______ X X X __~_ 14 MloHMI.VYoOP 10/1:1/91 _-=_____...JL2_-K.._.-l<_ J.! BEN Gl.lYls0N . 5/30/03 ..3_ --1L.. _lL .~ 16 OLAUP!: PIEf.lI.ER __.~/'\l0..:!_ -1L -1L...JL x J1 gP 6TUl.l. 8/0/04 _ ...JL _lL_,lL --1L.. .1!!.. !!,IM PEP~aR _.~JJ!!.1-. JL _>1- .....L_ _1<_ 3_ 10 MII<ERAysot-t 12/3/05 _.__--1L.. X -1L______J_ no Bt;N ElITTING --1L2.1/0l!-. __ -8..- -L -L x _,_ __ x .M. tMTT GI:RHART 3/3/08 _(& ~_ -1L --1L.. 22 PWA YNI: GI.MSON 7/0/06 ._8- __ _ ,....K_ x -1L _JL E_ AR_T WHITAI<F.L_, __ 0/1/06 . _L -1L _ __ _ -L X 24 Wl.l:!.IAM THoMPSON . %/.!I~_ _. ~_ -L_...:::::= _ _L --L --=-- 26 MII<E PIVITTORS 0/10/06 __ _L -L --1L..~_ ~_ AI.E1( WSlsS _ ~/10/06 __ _L -L....JL ~- 27 OI.IVER al.LIS 0/23/06 I I I - -- , .,.gy. GARY I(ITNI:R-- 1/20/97 x_ X -- b.VA _JL X .g,1!. f.RI:P PAr~'<S"_~/1Q/07 _ -,-,- 4- JJx ,-1L..L -- _--1L.. 30 ,,101:1. WH!SI.ER 10/6/07 __ ~_ _ ~ - -I- _ _L--1L.. 31 !:STSflAN VIDOT 4/6/00 X cl X X 32 RYAN BAI<SR --, 4/10;'io- -x -xu -,,")(-X- -33 M. PAUGlI'lI:R'i'Y"- --liiT7ioo'- -X- X- -x .-- -0 X- 34 ,.1, KINr:R" -6/177~ x--X- 0 )(X- 36 J, MOOAOS 6/17100 -X -X)( -....GL-X 30 S, sMITH =~!J7/90 _~ =:-X =-~ x - -g- -*-. 37 a. BSgGS 6/24/90 X x 0 X 1\ 3"8 alP _=____ ~_ x 1L- L- 30 40 ------- -..--------------.--- ~~ ------------------ -.-.---- ---- Ie. -y;- / ,\:--!JiJ- Ir;- i 9 -::-')"""'5:" L/ :l , .. to - d~ 'f(J I-Lf El~NIORITY l-IElTING" " ,r.._~~__~-lP.~O _ ll~N!QRI:rv ~_ B --~-J- _.1L, -L J...._ B 1M '''TOAP!!!!8 ..= ill~.Q_...__ "-- ~2E ~.i.L ~3 j;j -L=....L :3 i' l( , . Y KIl-l-!t:!GJ:R _____ ,..__J916/06 _ ....JL -15_...JL. _1L /J 1.. sT~ve JQN~s_,._._ ..__...1t.l.!!I!!.!L_ __. __ ~_ _~__ _JL _L il ____ --1.. EBl=.O HeAGY , .....__1!~Qi!!.IL.__,_.__ _..Q.... ~JL _L .-.....1L.. _1<- ...1_ PAVIO m~__._ _~/2~!OO_ _,.._ _.0..::. ...QQ_ ~ J(1_.->1Q.. , !nOABrJ1!~ . ~11'.O _ r--1L -1<_ J._ ..JL ...i.. !3RIAN aeN~gf:L._,_. ....__~I.r"~J!_ ,__ _CL _lS...... .,....>L _.JL_ _,.JL 7 JIM Key _._jo/~%o ____ ......Q... _~_ _L -L _,-1L o fiQl3F.RT 1.IN!t:!Q~__ ._._151/31/00 __.~ _-=.. J........JL -L -L. ___ o JEFF soyeR , __ ._~/31/00 . ,-f~ _JL ---,~_ __lS._ -L - .1Q.. ~L~...Bope ____ . ....._1/30/00 _ ~;P ,m_..QQ...~-- 11 OAVE WIN13I3RT 6/13/00 X X X X 0 . 12 BTJ:ve OASSSl- _ 1/2.QL!!L__ __ -""x -x --X._ ::...,x = 0 == = .1!~9HaAbWC?OD 10/13/01 __ --=-.::., . - _1L......lL_.....1L~L 14 saN Gl-eA60N 6/30103 0 X X X x -1I1..Q~upaPI~al.eB.._~=6/1/03 -----__ x x ~ x- 1)- ... X 16 RIOH TliOMPS~!'l_ _ Ont04 __ ....lL_ _..J5...._ ___ _~ _>L _ L_ 17 eo STUl-1. 0/0/04 0 X X X x 10 JIM Or3DNeR ... 0/27/04 - t) --- --- x''''''''x --X c&-') "Ill 1illKE RAY~ '1213/06 X x7 _L.......1L -- - -L 10: !1mfmtTING __. ~~/06 ,_ X X....JL.. _,_ _._IL _>5__ & M6 TT GeRHART 3/3/06 __. x :......lL_ x __ __ _CL-L_ 22 pWAYNIH31.I:!ASON __ 7/0/06 I _.JL -L -L_>L 23 Wll.l.IAM TlioMpsON 0/0/06 .....J_.......L::: - --- =--L -L_ - 24 Al.ex WeiSS _ 0/18/06 -L.....JL.. __ -L ._.Q_ _._ x JJL OI.IV!:!R 131.1.16 0/23/00 _ ......!..... .......L_ -L_ - --='- 26 GARY l<jTN13r~ __ 1/28/07_ u _><-: -)(~ ......:.\..-.::-X-. 27 p, :zeRsY 2/0/07 P X X X X -20 FReD PARI<S-- ---3/1Ciio:r- -X- x. x - -O----X- 20- JOEL WHISLF.R 10/6/07 ----x- ----x- - 0' --X----X- 3D ESTeBAN VIDOT 4/6/00 ----x-)( -0-)( X- ------- ---- ..~'I-~--- 31 RYAN BAI<SR --.1/.10/00 X X .........Q x x 32 M."OAOGFiffRTY 6;; 7/0~ ----x- ')()( - ---O-----X- '33 H. KINliR 6/17I0U --X- -x - -'-j- )(----x- "30-:MQOABS 6/17/00 -x -x - lL --- --.t2. X- 36 s, sMl'fFi .__,__ 6/177~ - x - _.1$.= x _ ~ X 36 B, 1lI:t:SS 6/24/00 x X 0 . x x 37 OPEN 1/ MIQ(\.A(! --- --r IJ (I) - .- - ---"'110 t'- r:.;::r-- ~ 9PliN &il&~,,'" bid ~ -- .,,-: L- L~ L) ,.- r~ 30 40 -~ ~I /T~~I')- 't -;>0 4T ---. _L~ -":r ----::-:- -{- 7iF -- Il} .)'.<0 JD ~;L. ~ ~- 0" ,,: J , \_'-"'1"'" " ,i -1,',<'" " .._ '-'.~f~ ... ._t., ~_",._..._. ,"1fI~f' L."J'. _ _ n t1t.......__~_..... .~_ , oJ rl:\OUNP . 1 S~NIORI1Y 1.ISTINQ" RIOHPoopa - FA , I ,-. _~~"'< Ti'\ -)..../ -- .t':!t\MI? B1039.. seNIORITY _ _.. s .....!L _.1...- ....~ -L. _L s ---- ~- L-oAtftiRB ,~..1 (000_--':-"-'_' "'-.~:;' ~- -2....... -8 ..9.. -- LU _-'-.L.. -L MY~II.LINGER (v.., __lo/6/!!L_ ...JL -1i_ _L _L 0' 2 sTeVIHoNES ..---.1!10/8~ __L...JL _....lL. 1_ 0 ,~ PRep ~j!:AGY ,. .__lL~0/8L_ n__ .,___ _Q~ -L -.1L _L -L ___ _1.. PAVIO STlLEIL_.__3/26/8L.... __ _oX- -1L -1_ -L -L -_ _J!... JI:!F/.:, O&jNI:!,L,___ _..!l/13/8L_ ~ ....lL.. _>L...lL _JL_ .. L~RIAN I3IiiNN~R _._ _.0/17/00 ' ...:::.?/ -1<_,_ --~-..JL......li.... ....._ .~~~~~~ L.~INOI:R .-- =~'6f~~~~ ~ ~3~ , ~- --~ ~ __ ~- ~IJel~F floYI:R ' '12131/80 X ....lL -~-..JL......1<_ .1.Q.. ill~ ROPE "_ . 1/30/00 ......&l-1_ __L -1L-'LIL ..11 DAVp...'NINGl:R.L__ 5/13/00 -L-JL_L-1L_C2L JThTEVI: oAssat.. -.,_1!20/01 _>i.._ X _ -L --2i_..iL. __ .1! Mla~II:AL WQO!L___ _..,JW13/0J_._. ~"r2i.__ ..JL.. .....?<_ _x_ -1L" ..1.1- );lE!N GL~SON ._ __ 5/30/{l3 _ _..9_ -1L _L -L ....lL ~9I-AUPI:OI@3LER .. 8/1/03 -L.....K.-_?L-1L_.__--2L .1.6.. RIOH Tl'loMPsON om04 -L x _. __ ~_ -L._2- ,..11.. 1:.0 S'fULL 0/0/04 _ ~VY- -1_ ..JL.. _>5.._ ....lL J.!l..!!lM DBPNER _ 0/27/.!!L..... ::.(;- ~L -1-I-X_ -L-1L '10 MIt<ERAVSON __ 1213/05, _J<_~_..JL.. ),/ -1L 20 ~ llITTINl3 2124/06 _ _LL X X -.lL __ _.... __>L 21 MATT G~RHART 3/3/06 _JL X _1<_ _ _ n 0-/ -1L 22 DWAVNI: GLI:ASON 7/0/06 ......Q_ _L _>L -~_....1L 23 WILl..IAM THOMP.,aON__r---.!l/0/08 _ _ --1..... _...L_ - -- --L --.L -, 24 ALEX WEISO. 0/16/06 X X X 0.,1 X 25 OI.IVER BLLIS - 9/23/06 -'1- ,- -== =~ ~ 26 GARY I<ITNI:R . 1/20/97 .- -- X- ---x- - ----x - -7)-x _27 D. ZERflV -'-2/0/07 -- . ~ -' .-. ex)- J'() aD' CXJ 20 r.figQJ.W~I<S 3/10/07,....lL.. _lL.. ....lL D -1L 20 JOEl.. WHIBl.lm j 0/6/97 X X 0/ x x 30 ~an:aAN VIDOT 4/5/08 "X ~ X _ - OJ x X 31 RYAN aARER . 4/10/08 X X D X x 32 M. DAUGHERTY 5/17/00- ---x -x "X- t.>r =-;:;--x 33 H, l(fNeR'- 5/17/00 _x X" .) -::..x >:.<- 34 J, MOOAlle 5/17100 X X)(....J.2. X 36" ~. SMITH 6/17/08...._::"X ~ ~ x ___ ~ _'_ -x 38 fl, BEt:SE 5/24/90 X X ) _ x x 3';'OPEN VM~(Ue - ,--,---- _=I--L_ 300/"r:N RJI/6."""" 6,J ._==__1--.1 I 1_ j~- ,..1!!.. --_.. .----- --- I.) _ ..2.;.... '-jO' ..) () I ~- ./r- -L~ I 4f ------- - Y - '1 0 / "j<) I ,.)/ J I .)c> ) I f, I,'" ....11 .)j ~I . '. . , ",' J ".':' ,;,,'. ,,>.~ ,'} (,1 '.'::' '...., ,. . ',' "'(~)~,' . ,,; '~ 'j~'~~Jtl~,I,i"'. I '. ','~ " ~ ..'IIl......:.L....._.'...,. __' -_.._.<04.,.#.,..,..U_..._.......~....,........... ", 'iI'", '., iJJ"" I ,_,., .. .~ ___--;_ .. , ... . I, ,,~';"\i _ _.,. ,. . , ,.t 'fIOUNP.l i~IO~fFOQPS - f'A SIlNIORITY (.ISTING" "'" -- - r-i...:- _I~~ME a'D~9 _~!1NIQR'~, ___ ~ ~ J_ W _ J_ ,L,...JL -- -,- 1..0~PIlRB .. it!@! -, -= _I L 7] M" ..!.s" ':LL " ) __ --; f-' _.L f1.AY KILLINClIlR __._l%/ii~ --'r--" -15__ --X.... __.l.L_ ...lL _L ~ ..L STIlVIl JflliES ._11.t!!106 _ 15- _,x __ _..K_ ._1t_ -li:_ -L 3 FREP f"EAClY -~P.ffi!._ __ ___ -LeT'- ...".lL__ ~ -&_ -1__ _.::::..... .. DAVIQ..STI~IlS ,-- 3/26/8L -_ __::: ==-----_. (,~..uk. .!....'1l. -ll&L ~ 5 J!EEF OABN~___._ 0113/110 _'___ -Lr!,"- -..lS___L _>L ,-_>L ___ ~RIAN allNNIlR . ..J!117100 _._ __'_ -!:--~.--lL _~_ -fL_.L _7..~!MJ~~ -y_.._,__.._~lOl2.9i" - _1_"_ - _lL._L.:..K_ --1<-_L -ILIRo.I:!~Rr ,.INI~GIlR 1 0/31l~L __. _fL_.. :: -~- ~EFF 130YSR -.--, ---12/31/00 .. -_ ---=-. :x~ ~ l'-~~ J_. }- _~. J9_~M RQQE. ---.----,-...11!~00 .__ __ --X.... ..JL -L ---X.-_lL .JL_ __ .11 PAVE WINClI3fIT..._--,..._. 5/13/00 ---L -15.... -_>L ._J.l.. ..fr.. '" j;2 I~ STaVE OASSEL' 1/20/01 X >L -1i_/-L, -..ELI_'f.:' __ ::-~~~:~~6~~;--~1 ~~~6%~1 --=-~~-- :?2.,_ ~._- ~ _~__,_~_ ~ Ji 9LAUpa PII3BlER_. -- 6/1/.!!L_.-== -. 5'- X x' x-- = -Ii:':' *"_ 16 ~-'CH T/jOMPSON 8m04 _ -2L ..lL __ -L -L ->L-12..... 17 1:0 ~ui.~_ - ---..!!/6/04 - -._ -F :...__ ~::.. --1<~__'L. _~_ _L_ \.J 18 dIM OEPNaR 0/27104 --.,., x x x x ~...- 10 Mlfca RAYSON '- --12i'3iii6---::: =-= ~ x _ X _ -, x c -;;--- =---= _*- ..~ 8EN BITTJNCL 2124/00 -2... X x x ~ _ X I 21 MATT GF.RHART 3/3/06 - ~r-x- X '";;- -- - E - X 22UWAYNEGLI3ASON --718ioo -_ILf=_->< ' -1S..._-K..., x ,/ ~ WILLIAM T~tOMPSOti_ _ 0/0/00 _ _. __ --.3_' _ _ I I _ 24 ALEX wg~ . 0/1':"&0 --K_ X = X ~ _E...= X ,/ 25 OLIVeR ELLIS 0/23/08 ---1- 1 ,_ _"_ _, I 26GARYi<ITNER 1/26/07 --...JL.. X _E. ., X_~-u..~~ v 2" 0, Zl:RBY .. 21010t._ __ ---.:: == =-_ C.i(.:> __ Jt> _JP _dP.... 26 FREO PARlcs _ 3/10/07 -.lL X X <..) X ,/ 20 1QEbWHlsLa~ 10/5/0L-_-L_X'- E' =~-=- x_ x - ....- 3ll aSTEf3AN VIOOT 415/06 _ __, __~ L ----E- _ -.:L. x -L 31 RYANaAI<eR 4/19/06 x -L_e___~!_)( ~_ '32 M, OAUGHeRTY - "'"-B/17/06 -x X X fG;') X 33 H. KINaR -5/17roO')( x- -- &.- -;-)( X-- '34 J.MOOA8E ~17/08 )()(x:--E'------'-----~:-x- - x x -"';-- -- ---y-)( 36 S,SMITH - 5/17/00.. + _____.,.g:.________ 36 8, BeaOE 5/24100 -15 _,,_ -E __ -L _~_ _~__ ~ OpaN v ~tOl"#t - ,- I I I "~PPEiN &116~,':2 b,d--------=====I _.i-- ,__, _ 39 ',___________ 40 -__--- '~ ""7 ' _, " ,,, :1 ' "-::.1-., -":'>1- _~ ~ '41 ,\ --::::- .; 2.. ,. , ' 9 ,~ ~ ;-., .) .) oJ ; I ,j I I , I i - . ;,.~:".j._,'_":"'. j _~.~~"__"'_~''''.'''_''''''T . ,. . .,.-. , Bt:NIORITY hIBTING" I . ~.PA -)..../ q -rO '''") ," ~,.;5 . . flJAMI: BI031) Sj:NIORITY S M T W T F S .~~~;~~tt~~~B"-~:= ~~~.~:~:-- -.' ~~~~~ ~~I~:L ~i.~: ~~~~=i~~ ~:'x ~ jt'I~~L. ~ . ~~:6t:H~~~B ~= =--'i7J.~:.: --= .~ ~:':h :-:-~ _1= -.~ r." ~-.. 4 PAVIP STlbas _ __.~!.?~jno __ - .-- - _.1<__ _~_. __./.i.._ --1L....:2... 6 Jar:r:. OARNI3S ._.._~{1~L~~____.. .__~__ --1i- ...JL. __>L ._52_ _fL !!BIAN al:,N~l:R ,Q{1Jj!!L_ '--- 1.1$L. <.:.>Q_ _~_ ~l(:~ +-- 7 .JIM I<I:Y .1'~i,~JO/?~~__ ....-- ..--.,, X ~,__. _:lS.:.._._J<~_ ~, o RoaaRHININGaR 10/31/00.. _ _ X X x. -.1<_......L- o ~SFll9XE!.l___ ~/31/01L_ . X_1L _..JL. _>L __LL- JJL ~IM ROPI3 _, __.JL~Qf.!!Q...._ ___ J.__ _1L ._1L _-1<_ _ ..-?_ ____ .1L PAVa WINGaRT 6/13/00 X X X X .:. 1? !!JEya OASSSI. - 1/20/01 )("X- _ X . ---X' ----=..') __ 13 ,MloHt:AL WOOD 10/13/0'1 ... X X X Xl 141aat-! GLEASON - _~30t!l.L___ ---;c- ___L..JL.=~_ -X . .1fj..lo\:6PPS PISBLI3R 6/1/03 _S:...... .~>L--1L J..,... ... X ~RI9JiIttoMPSON 0/7/04 _1L. ~ ______JL..JL..Y_ J1-1 SP STULL _ . 0/0/04 __ ___ -".., ----L. ~._ _>L _L 161~~HNPEPNaR ___~?7/o.L_____~L.____ X X. X --1L 10 M I<e RAYSON .Ti'rj 12/3/0f!._ ____ X ~X_1 -....... -L 20 laSN BITTING 2/24/06 (X X X .. X :iiJMATr GaRHART -- -3/3/06 - -.- ....1L _1L --1L ___= ---. G . =:&I ~PWAYNEGLI:!ASON 'TlO/06 ____ 0 ___----L.J.__~_. X .2:lIALEX WI:!ISS 0/16/06 ___._.K. X C X D -__15... 24 :CiIAIW 1<ITNIER 1/26/07 X X X:);), X 25]0. ZERBY 2/0/oi-___ = - - _ X )( X X 2flIFRI:!D PARI<s ;1/10/07 X X X 0.) X :. 27 JOF.LWHISLJ:R 10/6/07 ='-X. x_ ""I ___-2- -- X . X_ ~ M, FTZWE!ILI:!R _, 07112/21- _ __ 0 ...2_ __ ....1<_ ..JL. -L. X :l0 ESTEBAN VIPOT ':1:~ 4/6/00 ...Ji!....1, , ,-..-- ". '.X. ---:x;- 30 RYAN BAI~BH ,-- --<l/f%n-- -- X X-',) -- --:;, -X X- l.t M. DAUGHP-RTY ____-.!IJ7IOO__ == X X X --:7-:--- -'t1- -'X 32 IH.I<INBR _ 5/17/00 .!~jL..k._ff _;L__.......2...._-X~ lJ.tl ~J. MOOABE ___~{m~O. X X X,;J ..: X__ .M..h~' SMITH .____ 6117L~~ ___ _X __ ....1L ....1<_ --='-- - . <{'.,.. -XX 36B.BI:!BSr: 6/24100 X X!J ': x _~ 36 ;1311) 1---' - .---- X X . -- _________I~!L..____ X - 37 ,13IP 1 - -- =r=-_1L- ..__ XL_ 30 'H, SHUR!3ART? - ___.___ __'_ __ X X ~_. 15__ 30' ....__________.'__________,._ ..1!l____ 1--.----- -,..-- --.I 1--7--.---1' '1- 41 I 1__ ..' " :,,), '" " 1 " 'If ., I[ ". t.," , "" !) , 'I :.) .j , .' .. " -- , ,. --~. .,..._,..~ OUTaoUNP' 1 S~NIORITY I.ISTING.. ({t :::::blL4, Ii', Cl - I __-:INAM~L 13103~__ J~.E~J9B!TY- __.__ __~.... ,j~L __1_ .... w__ ___L.. ..J;:~~~. -._~ ':~I~:'~=~~bQ8TIfjRB ~=.~ Il~Q:C'::::'~':::':'::: :== :-1-:i:;-:M: 1"'i<C -j4- =~. -TC 'T- ..L ft6YJSlbh\NG13R __,_.__...1!1!~L~L_ ---~ :::::::: :::oe:= = _::~ l{:: C>B-=::' . ~;::" --- ,L !?TeVe JONeS .... ___~.Lt~I.~!_~. __....._ ____ ...:If.::::' .:=:~ J:: =..' . == ::-.-:--=:: _.!_ FRellliE..i\.~___.._ _,_1@Q/08..._ __,_,_ ___ ....9.... ...11..._ __>L _JL. ...1<_ ---- ~,.. ~YIP sTI~e~_,_._ __~/28i!li!- ___ _,_._ __.9_,_ __X.__ ...JL- _._lL --.~_.. ._'- 6 JeFF oARNelL___ 0/13/00 ___ _______ 0 .__~._ ___>L__.~_ ...~- 8 13I1IAN at:llNelL_ __Jl1.l?l~L-__ -. ___1<_ ..._.K_.. ,_x..___~_.. ...Q-.- ,J JIM I<BY __1QL29/0\l._ ._C2_. _..JL. ...~_,_: --~.-. _.._>L_ a ROBeBI ~INING13R _ ..--1Q!311l!L.._ __ ____ _,__.... ....1<_ ..-.1L. ....1S__ _L -Q- J!_ ~EFF BOYF.R 12/31/00 _ _.___ ____ ...,.!L_ __~_......Q.... ~_ _ x_ -- ~ ~~ ~~O~I~~!!T ~~~~~~~ -- --- - ~ - =~~..- =_ ~= :~}-. =&. -.------...- 1 ~ ~T~Vt: OASf.lF.\..__ 1/20/01 _. ...__ x _~_.. __JL ~_..x_ ___ _ ..D__ .ll.IMIOHeAl. WOOD ,_......1Q/13/01__ ...,,_ b X _ X X X 11\ II-UII'IURGART _..J131/03-_ ,., x.. X __x... x 16-[j3I:N GbSABoN ,____ __~/30/O3 _ ,,- .......- "<,-'" -~: ..(~). ::(~ -G0= JQ..~,=^Uf)t: DIt:BI.aR _ ___8/1!1!~_- __~__ ..J.S.___>S..__ -- __L 17 IRIOH THOMPSOI'!.,_--- __---.!I/7/04 __ ._JL x ...-'- _JL -X._ -...Q.- I Jlt'ep STU~l. ___ _..l!/a/oL- _J2..._ _L _JL ...1<__ X _ J.!!JJOHN Dep~t:R ___'_ 0/27/04 __0- _.JL _.JL -~- ~ .gQ.,!MII<E HA:@~__ 12/3/05 ..J<....... 2_ .....K._ u' 2..._ ,RL!Bt:N aiDING :1/24/08 __ 0 _JL..J<....... ...1<...._ ___ ,__ .,...L, ~ATT GERHAHT ..........1L~/08 ___ ___ __JL _,~ ...JL _,____ __u () --~- E..[R.WA YNE G~F.ASON _...71.0/06 _.D_ ......1$.__ --~.- ...1<__ ...1<_ 24 'A~ex weiss 0/16/08 x x X D, X 26 IGAIW 1<ITNt:H . r--1726107- - ...,-x-- ---x- -- - x - ---'0 )( . I ------ --- _...______1____________.___ .26 ~~;mHI1Y _ 2/0/07 ....9._________ x x --~. _?<- {:t~~~E:i~ :;::, -= ~ _~___X-= ~--~=tt 30_\.eSTEaAN VIPOT 4/6100 - 3- x _ -x-=. c:-- 1--_ _ - -=- -rr -g-.:::.: 31R'@lf3AI<ER 4/19/90 x x . 0 D)( x i~ t~tl?I~~~Ht:RTY -- ~~1 ~~~f- -+ ='I~:=JL (") - ?-'- ~.~- _.~-, . ___p__ . _____ .__. __. __._._ ____...sL-. ___, --- 34 .J, MooABe 5/17/06 X X X 0 0 __x .~_l!...i 6, eMITH _ 6/m06 ,- lS._ =-..~= =:.x ....tL.... -;-~_... ~:JI ....=-x .~~_~l_lL~eF. ___ 6/24/00 x <T x__ v D IV II X X 37 BIP 1 R. 4 (\!.'.. I.!.'.. L_ 30 ,alP 1 - X X X x '3l!.~.1W ...- ----.--- == =- ~ = = ~ '--.i. .. I. . =~-= 40 /) I d '. ~ ~ Ii if...llm =~=--==---1l -0/ '1f~ -~. (~~~-.it +\ RICI'II'oope . PA . T S4 ~fi '.J .",,.~~f~11't" I ~__""'-4<<...~.... ... __ . '. - ...-" , OUT130(JNP , 1 A/CI'I/:ooPS ' P~\ aSNIORITY liSTING" CO-~ - ~ -~. --- 'u_, Nt'-M!;____~!Q~O__ .-~-~~!QBlty_~. s. -_I\L _L _W _ --L .._F_.__~__ "--'~~~~=bQ~Q!!B!L~-= .u~QlL~=~= .,--. _1~= ~_= ~ ~__~ _ S __ ~~.:::.~ 2= ~~= ._1. Ri\~ldt!NQE1L___ __JO/6/1!.L..... __,_ - _~_, .-1.<__ _>5.__ _.~__ __(_ ___ --g,- flTf.VE ~l&s_ -Jml!..~ ____ -=- _>L -..1L_.X__ __lL _L_ __'_ ._~-- FRF.P HeAGY - 1I2U/60 _. ___ ---L ....lL __ X__ __~_ -_>L. __ _1.. QAVIO JIT1!:g~______ .,-- 3/2~/69 . .. ____ -P._ ...1L --X-r4.- _IL '___ ..A- ,II=FF C6BNF.S___ __~13/~ __ _. -15._ _>S_. _IL -JL_ _!LI3AIAI'I seNNr:fL_____ --.Jl.Lm~ --- ___ __Q_ -..fu- ->1-- ~,_ -->L. _ _L .IIM 1<r:L_,.____ __....19L2.11/80 _ _ c.1L ,X), -1$2.. --'.~!.._ =-_ -!. !!.J!oYI:lR .___tg/31/oL,. ___ ___ -L -1<_ ~_ -L _lL._ .JL1& llNlI'LGER __--E@1I00 _ _ __ ~-J2.....lL -1L....lL -IL__ ...111. JIM ROPt: ~'_ 1/30/00 _ __ ....lL _..Q._ () x ~_ _~ .11 pt\Ye WINGF.AL__ ---...!!/13/00 _ _'L -L ...lL -L. ___ _ y__ J.! S'Tj:VF. OASSr:l - --.1~g!.~ __ -lL.. ...1L. __l<__ ,_>L., __ -------2.. 13 MIOHf.Al WOOp 10/13/01 0 X X....lL _X_ 14 H. ,m:!~r~QNU-=---= :---1i~1/03-- ~= = == __CL _ x_ X_ -.IL-L ~ l3eN Gj.eAsoN _..A!.~~ _,::-.=:: === ==- -L x ?L ._>L_ 10 CLAUDf. DleSleR 0/1/03 .. X X X D ____~_ IiI RI9tt THOMPSON --- 0/7/04_.. '- x - ~ x -. --- == -IL x b 'I ~ iIJ'STUI.l _ --. 8/8/04 -.-D. -R ~x ~ . 10 JOHN Pf.DNI:R - _!!/27/04_ _ _Q__ __ .....K_ -L .-.lL. ....lL ~ .lQ. Mlt<e AAY!!ON ---------1?/3/06_ ]V- _' if ~1{) '-0,..,- -==-~---1C ~-~i:~~~~~Rl-==-- ~~;~~O__ -- - X..' ~ -~ ~=. -::.__ 0(: _.. ~_ '2'3 DWAYNS GLFAS.ON, 7/8/06 _ ,_" _ ..:....>.<:,1 ~p ~ ...:.}{)_ -~ Al/:X Wr:I~s -- 0/16{QL_ __ -L....JL ___ _X_ ___ __2~ _lL . 2/i GARY I<ITNI:R --, ---.1t.~~_ r-L _L_ _ _L D J_ ~ 0, ZSRBY - __2/0107 -_ __ _,9_ '__ __ ._~_ -1L -.lL...lL_ 27 FReD PARI<S 3/10/07 X X x I.-i-..+-~..- -.::..... --JL :: ~~:~:~:,~~ -- _,i~~;' - _~:",-:=- -Ui-~+- 30 aSTel3AN VIOOT . -1!.M!!!._ _X__ -lL __ ---......!2..... -X- -x- l 31 BYAN I3AI<SR 4/10/08 x X Q X- -x. 32 M.DAUGlil;RTY ----ri!17100= ::-x ~-X=--'--fj--x-- ~: I~'~~~e ---- ,-g~Ji:~- ~- --~ .. x- --_. ....0_ _..~ __ ~- ----r-----,---- ---- -- -- ---.- -- --c;--x--- 36 s. flMlTH -_ _--p!17/f!..L _ _>L._ _~_ _L ___ __A __ __ ___ I~~SE .--- ",==n!~4'--9A__ _~. .=~~ '1\->5.._- x:---- .. x-..lrl. X_no ...J5._ 301rnot'- --'---.-,- ---..X------X---X.=K== ~~LL_.. ----=--_________,_ .=r='== {- :_K___L_ ,*iJiuL-__._..______,__ /t---:f~ /T-:EJ=:!-;;L7r ;J -- '4:f . '---,---- J -:? :5- i--i)-- -~':..~)_= ' - --- J~<< ;.' - -- .. -,' ...." I II I I ~i&4_" oj.. _.,'6014..........4.....,_._...... .. ...~-..._-. ,.. ~....._., ((..- 9' TD ~-15 ..,~p. 1 sl3NIORITY I.ISTING" , ,,'oops. PA . y -~ NAMa al030 _~!!N!9RITY_ B _M_ ___:L w ___.L _-.P__ s ---- . 'M_~__'_~_~________ '-- .--- .-.-- -. l-OAPI!RB l1!!QL~== :T-~ ---~-~ ..t!.!?___ __LL _.L?:_, 1;'L I tL L'.t:: ...L BAY,I<II.llNGm:L____ 1016/115 -~.- -L x _>L _fL --..............---- -- ----- --.- -- _1!_ SIE.~N~__ 1/10/86 --_.. --- _2L. _L _.L ._lL.. ._t9_ ,-- 3 fRI:P HeAGY 1/2Ql!!!L.. ~- _L -L .-1L - ---- - ..!- PAVill..sTILI:~__._ _~!~8/80_ 0 X -2<_ ...1<_ _JL 5 JIEFF OAr~NI3S _ _~13/89_ _>L X --~-- --~.-- _A_ -. -~ Mlt\1:! SIENNIER __J!L17/8L.., ---- ---- ~,- _..lL _>L ._>L -A,- 7 JIMI(IEY )0/211/80 " .i,_ I , -L_ __L -.- 8 ,I, SaYlER 12/31/80 -~- ___lL -r---- _1L. ...1<_ - -,- 0 R, llNINGI3R 12131/80 ~ -L -~_. __lL -li.._ ~ --- Oc ,~ illM RO[:lli..___ ' 1/30/00 --- -1<~_ ...lL --- _.~- ....lL 11 PAVl3lNlliG13RT _ ,__6/13/00 __ -L -2L 2_ _lL - -- _P.lL. J! sTIEV@..Q!\SS13l 1/20/01 _L .___?i__ -1<_ x -. -2-',- --- :---- _1!. MIQ_l:!ELIl WOop 10/~/OL .;> x __>L __!L_ x -- -- (&) J1. Ii, SHURGART' 1/31/03 0._. X -L ...1<__ -- J! SI3N- Gl~bN 6/30/03 C) X X x -L - -- ---- 1---. 16 Ol-/lUDIE,DI813llER 8/1/93 _l<_ _!L. x '_ c.. _ .~ -L . '-- -~- !-- 17 RloH THOMPSON 8/7/04 ,__JL. -1S__ X _lL 0 10 lED STUl.l 8/8/04 ~ - I-- _>L_ -1<_ __,X X . 10 JO~IN DEDNER 6/27/04 -- ~!... .~ _L -X... _>L J.Q. Mll(8 RAYSON. 12131.~ _..L -'---- _.L -- -L_ _~l I3I=N SITTING 2/24/08 _.1L X X X -_.. -L ----- 22 MA IT Gl:RHART 3/3/06 _!L.. _L ____>L '- _c",__. _L -.-. --, 23 DWA YNIE GlEASON 7/8/06 '- -- - -!L___ X X _..lL - - -- 24 Alf:X Wl:ISS 0/16/06 ....lL ~ _,X_. " __1L__ - -- I~ GAR'flliTNIER 1/26/07 _L X x --"--- -L - 20 D,Z8R13Y 2/0/07 0 .-L -L --.1<_ _>L - -- --- 27 FReD PARI(B 3/10/07 ....lL X .1_ 0 -L ~,- ---- I~ ~oEl WHISlF.R 10/5/07 _lS.__ X 0 X X ~- '- ,- -- -- -- -- -_. 20 M, ETZWF.ILER --E/1f21 -- -&- x ...lL X X IESTEI3AN \iIDOT72~ m= -~- ~ ~ lID 1'1 4/6 08 _. 3f RYAN DAI<8R 4/111/0iJ- -x-- X -V'. --i:'?..... 32 M:Oi\UGlI'll:HTY 5/17/90 -x-- ---x- :-x ---c"'- -x- 33" J-t. KINER 5/17/00 x- ---x- c? -x- -'x -34' J, MOOAiill -'5/17/08 - )( ---x- x'-- --Ct,,- )( 35 8, SMITH - 6/ft/06 )( --x- x u -x- 36 D,I3F.Esi: '5/24/06 )( x- - c X -)( ---- ...__,'1:1I 37 ---- ---- -- - -)( --- x-- .x--. .-x- 36 1310-1-' .. .. ---- -- x- '- - _x- )( ---x- -- 30 DID 1 .. --- li. ---x- -- --- )( - x ---- 40 DID 1 4T - .)u 3. .)1 = i~ ~}- d. () 4'2- -._- ---,--- .i '" If ::> " ,. l~ _OJ ,. f If )~ ;j' -:lS.)y .... I 'u.~. I~!,~..I",/ ..". 1_.. ,. ,'", . ., ) ""::', ,,( c~_ l!n Ir-\ ('{'-' ;;'\r:1 " ,- ,~,._ aIP3.!L _~.~NloRl1Y, _,_.__ ___,~... ~_rL __1- w ...5_ i_ S ,__'~o8Q!!l!!!'__ I1!l!!!L:"--=~-= ---- ]~ :"72..= I~_--= ::l!L.: -sO'- .a:L ._~ _<,YJ5lb.ldtl9lliL__- __1.Q{6/t!L- ___ _....____ _lL_ ..:.1<_ .-1<_ ._~_. _.g____ \ __ !lJFV.gjQtl~s 1/1 0/06_____.1\._ ...1<_ - ks-X" -7.:-- _L .EBap Ht:AGY 11e.Q/8L..... ~ (}Q -~.. -~.:=;.... __1_ PA'llQ.!Ul~____ _._ 3/2~!!L- ,_2_ -K_. __lL __X_, __lL. a .,J(:Ff.9.8BM13S _._ 0/1~!00 _ _.__ __ r.> _ ____. _L ...JL ,_X__ -K_ _,_ _!L @.B!61.'l~al'!Nt:R _,__..._ 0/17100 _..____ _JL __lL, _~_ -L _JL .--, .L ~LM.l~__._ _..1.QI.2.!!/DO __ ___ - - ......L_ _L_ _L_....L.. - o ~-,--aoVgR____ __.12/31/60 _____ ___.___ _,~.._ ._1S_ _~ ~ ~_ .1.. B.,,\.ININGr:R __ ___w.~1!.!!L_. ____ ~ _L ....1L_ _L -'2- J.!L ,11M ROOr: 1/30/00 _ ____ ___ ___ ....l5.____ ~ _ ~ _lL_Q..... 11 OAV~ wINGeRT 6/13/00 __ m -x_ x x - ~ sTr:ve oAsseL 1/20/01 __ --1L.., ~_ _~_ .-.-?L..____tL.. .1! MloHeAL WOOD __ __.J.!lJ.1~/OL_ ... __ __CL -_'_ ....l5._ ---~-4-_ ~ 14 ~1.stlURGART 1/31LQ.~ --..----... ..:.~i~ (XI ~ 15 ~eN GLl:ASON " _ 5/30/03 __ .__..."-2- )( X ~_ _,.1L ) ~mI-AUOt: DleB~eR __' 6/1/03 X X X 0 x -H-i~IOI.t THOMPSON 017104 _..15_ ..-X._ V)L x -12..... J.!l,[BO SIULL 0/0/04 . _ ~ ,__ __. _L ..JL _L ~ 10 MII(e RAysoN 12/3/05 __ -'- ....l,_ ....l_ _..c:=: ::::......_ -==- .2._ . 20J aeN BITTING 2/24/06 _ __ .> _>L _>L.. _.JL __,_ ____.1L 21 !MATT GSRHA~T __ 3/3/0lL-1-__ _~_ _.JL X '-_..!:._...JL 22 !PWAVNEl GLSASON 7/0/06 0 X' X..L x 23~CLiXWI3ISS 0/16/06 = ~~__X-'= x ,=-~ c.'" >5.:= 24 ,GlARY f(ITNI3R 1/20/97 II X X X x !i!..lD.ZaR!!Y . --'2/0/07 --- () -- --- J'- - x - -'x ~ 2\\ FRSO PARKS 3/10/07 X X X P "X 27 M. ETZWEILER --li7i12i21'--~ I) =~~-- l5 ~_) _>L~ X 26 RYAN BAI(I3R 4/10/00 X X X X :> 20 M, DAUGHERTY 6/177iio-- -x --5(- -X- -t::;- ---- -x ~~ H.I<It-lER .. ~/f7/0(\_ :::><--;'X_= _a.... '"1f'=' X: 31 .1, MOOAaa 6/17/00 X X X 0 X -3fs, SMIT~I __' 6/17/06 ~ X X-- x __~O--X 33 B, BEr:SI3 ,~/24/06 x X -D-' x x J{i,\, RIOLSY , _...!l.!g~/9~_ ..;..1:1 _ -L~~ ~__ 1O ~ ~rr ----- ------ :J1 -- _.ll.U[::: ..J.~ -q,- ,1.'2- I" _~o _ _____ . J_ ~ -L. 3 't....L. -~ 39 i .____ _______ ..L'l.. _.) ..L_ _o1..L_ .~--~ 40 , ' m--'-- ---....--.-- ~- -::+iF ':i-4-= ....:tll_.- 4V-- :':;l<>- -:t--:rc:: , ' . SI!NIORITY LISTING.. \lIt ), j':"l .' ", ' ,.1 ',' .,' , ' ,',,'. '. " ~ _1; " \' . ,.. J' " " / , I :,: ~. --$-,... . .2--......-,.. _._,,~-.....,;l-'~'~'r" .<, X' '( )(' l( <(' ,I( *' ..-;........""Nrfm'or.:.......... ~,.. ......... fl'" .......- ......._-~..... ,. -....... ............ , 1 -....--..... \ "i'130UNp.1 RIO~IFoopa . fA cz; -H:3 -r 0 (6 ,.; :J. Q ~OAP~RS I Jl ( I 1 ~ .... :=~~:~~~-='f-= la~P3~__I- s~~~q~!g: ---.---. .~ 5 --..~= :=I~=-.~: _.!- '=i~~k~- ____bf.A!!ID!!_____]l1__._.._____' _~.J..;'_li_ ....lL .~~. ._~_ _2- _L RIDghbIMGeli___ __J.!lJ!I!86._ _._ __ X__ _li.__ ,...1<___ _-1< ._~tsTf:~t:.Jg.tles _____ ____1!J.~!~L ,_ ..___ ~___....lL _~.. ~....: ==--= ::..-=-~ a .FReo tl!:AQL......-:.... __jl~Ql86 _._ __.__ -- -_lL _K_ _K__....JL. ___ _"-/PAVIP STIl.~S _,_____ __,__~~~l~R._ ,___ ______ _~__ ....lL _.L __~_ _?L.. _._ ~FF oARt@s _.. 8/P/60' ___ _____ 0 _~~_ ___L _L __>5..__ __,__ _~aRIAN s!:NNeR . -1lLJ7100__ __v'_ ,_..L _~__ __~___JL~__ . I -L~M I<ey 10120/80. _L.....l_ _L __L .0 IJ, sayeR. __1!ya1/8o__ x _lL..--=- ~_L __?L.. JL.It. ~ININGeR .J~/31/!!.L- _ _ -E- _lL....JL_ -1S._ _lL_ .1Q.. illM ROOF. 1/30/00 _ . x ....lL ~_....lL..:->L_J.L.. jiDAVeWINGern _~/1~/00_. '>:o...W $'_~ ---- 12 .sTeve oAssel. 1/20/01 _.lL _>L. _ .j{) ..J2_ 'Ia MIOHeAl. WOOD __ _...J..Q!1~/OL..___, ./ __K_ ....K._ _~_ ._~._ J!. H. SI-jURGART . ,_1mI0a __ _ _ := __ -- x __ x _ ....JL. .___~, 16 13eN Gl.eASON 6130/03 _~, -- __ x x X X J6 Ol.AUPEJ?lesl.~R .~11/0~__.____ x X _lL~2......___....lL 17 RloH THOMPSON 8/7/04 x 2_ __IL. x ~_.....2...... 18 ~O STUl.l. ~18/~_ __..2.._ ,__ __ 2___ x ....lL_lL 10 MII<e RAYSON 0- 12/3/05 _ , I , I .b.\I_ DeN ElITTIN~ _ 2/24/08 ..Q..... _1L __>.L_ -A._ __ __,....lL J!1 MATT GeRHART __~13/06 __, X ....lL x - ____.~_L ,ROWAY1'lI:~l.l:AsqN__ 710106 _c.)__ --_l<_--.L-J<R-L ~~ Al.I=X walss 0/16/08 __ ___ X X ._~ 0 __ ....lL 24 GARY I<ITNER 1/26/07 _..2_ -X._ ....lL _>L_ _,?L.. 26 0, ZERsY 2/fJ107 - C x x x X 26 FRliO-PARI<S 3/10/07 -1<_ x. -1<_ ~ , . r--x 27 M. ETZwell.ER 97/12/21 D X X X X J.!!..RYANsAI<GR 4/10/08 _~---x__-=:=- x - x _ x,-.:-) ~_M,OAUGHERTY _ 6117/~L_ __L X ___~.______ ...Q___L 30 H,I<INGR 6/17/00 x x t> __, X X a1 J, MooAe!: 5117iiia- X--5(-X- -----o-x.- 32 s, E!~J.ItL ___ __I!I.17/08 _ __ -X._ _ x ~_ ____ _..J2._ _lL_ 33 e. eliEBE! 5124/08 x X 0 X X 34 A, RIPl.IW -----0720/00- -x- -5( ----)f- x- (5- 35 --- -- -.-- -- 3iit-------------.-- _,__ __ __ 38i_ .-:,-----------.-----..-- T-z.. - ...L? I") ,~ -"";)0--)0-+- 30 _______ .__.__.._ __.__ ._L_ ;:,L_ _-' .. ,... __fL.___ ..1Q.L-____ ____._______ ' ;' ___.?__ _._:JL J), .....d..!L ..L-L.. 41 " ' ',' ~~'oIU~l.ti~.t~ I.~ I I"; '. . ' 'r&,..I.J..:":':.I..'J.'~.L.Li...aI.~l..,- .:"'~."..nt'~iU"'.,~"" " ,., .,. ., . ,(1l0UNP' 1 AIOI1FOOPS . ~A p ~OAPf:!RS Cb - 3\J 70 9-:J 3lJ !II I !> :? ~, .- '__:I~_~~~=:.:::-_ a'o~~--:~~~~9R.l~: ------ 8__~-- .._1,__ W __1._ ,_,L_ 8 ,___.-___b.oAPIiRS ._ 11oQQ,_________. ..iJl. _ __:2;.:- .....:.L _).L';._:~.._ __~__ ',' I _.1- Bt.lll~~INGf:!R___ ____J9Lf!l!!.!!._ ____ ____ _L __L _-~-- ,___1L. -~--. __un> ~_ .l!@va ,ION!!~__.__ .__.-1Ll0/~L-.,,--~- __~____JL___X._._ .fL-- 3 eEB.EQJ:!EAGY , 1/20/88, _ .__. _~ __..1<_ ".-~-- ---~-- ..1.... PAVIP ...!IT1~f:!B____ ___ 3/~~L!!P,_ _____ ,--,.Q- _?5__ ~JL_ nJL____~.._ 8 J!:FF OARNt:B ..-f!l.19/8~__,. 0___ __Q_ ~__ 2..__ _,JL x 6 l3RI~l~Jlf:!!'!tf~~___ __!llill!!L.... _____ ____ __ nuL _-~.___ __JL_ _...K_ _.12.._ _L JI~,I~~ 10/20/80 . __'_ ._,__ _..L _L __L __L___ 8 J. t10Yf:!R _ 12/31/60 ,_ _ 2__JS_ -..:::-- -{<..- -~-- ------- o R, ~ININc:JaR ~/31/!!!!..- _:2_ ___ X__X_.. _.-lL X JJ!. ~LM ROPE. --.1L30/00__ - X__ 2__. -.,__ _iLL _!L. 11 PAY\':! ~f:!RT __ ___ 8/13/00 __lL_ ---1L.-1L -K_ _ _...fL J~ amF- OAASf:!L 1/211/(Jl .....1<_.-1L .-1L _~__ -,--- ---- -1L__ ~ MIOHEA~ WOOP 10/13/01 _ __ __ ~"L __~__ --~- __1<_ _X_ Ji.H,al'~G~,RT _1/31/~_._______Q...__n-1L, X _L2_ ilL l3t:N GLeASOL__ 6/30/03 ___ _'.2_ _ ____ ~_ X X...lL_ . ~~ obt,UPf:! DI~~LF-R 6!1/03 ..___ __>L __L _!i.,_...!!..._ ___...1<__ 1, RI~11 THOMPBOli._ 8/7/04 _ __" _JL1.- _r__ 2__ __IL-IL '18 I:DSTUL~ __...!!!6/04 _______CL____ X, ~_---1L' X 11l MIKF- RAYSON ____t2/3/06____....-L.--L---L - ~ ____L 20 SF-N l3ITTINL___ _~2124/0~_ _ _12-.-L- X _-1L __ - _15..._ ,.gt MA TT GF.I~HART __ 3/3/06 __ _,..K.._ _-L .....1<_ ___ ___ :J.-1L A PWA YNf:! GLEASON _ 7/6/06 .JL._ __ ___..-L X X X !l!;l AL!:X WSISS . 0/16/06 __.-L- 2_ __ _1L_ __ 0 ~- 24 GARYI<ITNSR .1/26/07 __L2..___-.1S-- X X...JL. 26 p, Z!:R13Y _ 2/0/07 _0_ _____ ~ ::_:15::.:. 'X' ~ 26 FRep PARI<B 3/10/97 __....lL X .-1L...l..- __ __...JL. 27 M, F-TZWSILF.R ()7/12/21 U X X X X 28- RYAN aAKf:!R 4/10/06 -)( -X ----x-)( ---0- :jt M, D.AUGHf:!RTY 6/17.LOil__ - __ X -X= __ X - S..:: )L~ 30 H. KINf:!R 6/17/06 X X ::> X X 3ftJ. MOoAOa 6/17/06 -,-,'-r- -' ,,, - -------r 32 ia, aMITH _._6/17106- X - X ~ X ___ -L_~""': 33 'B. OIiBBF. 5/24/06 X X :) X X -30, RIPLF.Y .. 6/26/06 - X -1L X .-L_ ~~p . 35 .eL~Ae~!::~\!,!.Ll...L "t ..l.J:.fL __ _-"L ~ __ -- _!L. --~ -.}<- 36 ~.' 1"'\" ""'n 1(" . I \.- ~_t:__ ctV-t r~.- ,__ __'L:_1.~L- ___ --'-'-- ---~:.-- .--- - --- ~---t-.~- _3"IL I U_ .- -- _I .-----:--- ~~ r------- ---- ~ -;---1-8 -ji)-!- ;Ju-n-rT-~ i J - 4T'----=~~----------.u-- ----- ---;f-'I-~--:JT- - Y--i/T1.liLil.::f= NEWIN,XLS " i I I :1 I I ~ ,,- _,___t-ljV,t~_ f3103~_ pr:~J.oR1IY_ s _M_ .__J_ -I_._ __E__. _..J!_ .-..--- . ...~- ..---~ ,Il!!!1Q._._= - ~-- __1:::= r~ 9.-- :JL i?_ .-..~. 1.0AOIlR,B _A. - _.il.. _L ft..t\t.lSlI.I.INGEfl _JQi~/8~,_ ._~- _.1<__ ..-!'L. x -- -,- --..!~.- --- .--- ..~u ~IsY.!i~QNg~_...._.__._ _ ...J{lll!!!.~._,__ __.1$.... .._IL. ",XU ..,_,x___ . --.-..-.. "'_'H_."" ..-.-----. -.-.-.,.-.- 3 Em;p.JJt:A~L___ _,...J!~O/~.Q_.___ ....1.S.__ ..1<.___ _ .lS..__ _,..L ..,___un.' --- -. ------ ...1_ PA\ilQ,!!III.t:L__. __._~!g~l!!L__ 0 ___.lL __X- .-..1<_ ~- 5 JpFE.OARNEa ___...__._ __,_~Ll~/OO __ (l _L __K_, _"'>L X ._~- -------- _c:&. JL !'!flLAN f:!t:NNE.B__._. _..,..~/17/8L_ _.1<__ .....L ,_X... :.~.'!. _1.. JIMJ5E.~L______ __ 10/29/.!!L- ___L _L -.L __L 0 ~ a9.Y.FJL_,._____.__ ._..__.1 2l~.1i!!L..._ ,_JL _,JL - __.L -~- -.-....-- .-- - 9 ~.l..l:lliINGrili.. . __..t~!~11!!L.... _tL, ._1.S.__. .....!L_ _>L._ --~-,- - -- - J.!!. ~JlQQt: ._, ___,1/3Q!!lL.. --.- ----," -~--- _1.<___ __0_ _.1\__ --~::::', ----- .11. PAV~ W[NGERL____ ___6/13/00 -. ----- ___>$..__ _._.K_.. ---1<_ -L ._- 0 -- J~ .!ITE.'tE CASsel. --- ...........1l2o/01__ -- ____>$.__, 1_ __..x .__ _.JL. -"----. ---- _.0- J!. Mlc~If:AI.. wooP _ . __.1QLL~/01___ D __..1.S._ _1<._,. _,...>L -..-.L .-- -~_. - J.i. tiL!JtJblRGAr~T ___.1!~1/03 ___ -. -_.._-.- -~.__. ___12...... _-1<_ -..-.L _.15...._ __L J!. aeN ~l..eAsoJ'L......__ .__JiJ~.QLoa.,_ QEi_ - Q...- --.-- -- -~.'-- _.JL __>L ......1.S._ __1!!. cl-Aupe PIEID-,gB.__ __.......!!!1/0L- _.~- _>L __.1L .....!L_ - -..-.L -.- .--- 17 RICH nloMPSoN 0/7/04 _ X' ....JL ~ ~- -X._ 0 - -- -7) --- _J.! t:P~TUI_1.. 0/0/04 ~- _L -2.<~ -..-.L J.!!. MII<t: RAYSON . __ 12/3/06 _ .__..L ~- I I --- ]j~- =(~= R' 20 f!~N aITTlN~ _ _.JI141oL_ .---=. - 21 MATI GeHHJill.T 3/3/00 x X x 0 x . -_.,---- - "---- ---- ..-- -- --. ,~ --- 22 PWAYNt: GLeASoN ._ ....._710/00 -- ....f2_. __n -- ....lL .....!L_ .J2Q.. _~>L 23 AI.t:X WJ:ISf! _-11L10/1l!L__ _.L -2.<_ .....!L... 0 ...lS_ - -- -- -- 24 GARY 1(ITNeR ._ 1/20/07 ~ ~- x x _>L I~ O,~BY _ 2/0/Q.'L__ -~ __JL ...JL J&:: ...JL 26 FHf!P"pARKS 3/10/07 X X , X --- :) _1<_ 27 M, F.TZweU..eR 117/12/21 _C- _IL_ x )( x -..-.L 20 RYAN EiAT<ER-.- --;j/f%a- --- _x _ X : -X- X :;) . :!O_ M, pi\uS3HeR1Y ,'--- '-l( -X _ x 0- -)( 6/1'1100 - 6ifr7Oil-' --x -----x --~- ---- J..!!. .!;hJ$!NER -- ........!2. x ~3J. J. MCCAa!: 6/{7/0--O--- I I ,- .....L. -r- 32 S, SMITH 6/17/00 -----x x- .. 1< - 0__ .,-x -- ~-- -33 a, agasr: 6/24106 - X X _.2._ X x 34 A, RIOI..F.Y --- -il/20/9~ )( , x -.- _lL -----x 7) 36 M, l.eVANOWeTZ - 4/13/06 X ..-x ..? -X -x- ~S, MCCl.eARY --O/16/1la- x-- x ~ - )( -X- 30 IE!, JACI(SON _ . 0/30/00____ -I.)Q-= ()V_ --2__ _.x (]) 30 . ------- -- -Lt---~:- -- .. .-~ . . , - ~ ,'...:: _.~- 40 -~--- ./~L ~}-I-~ -"f'---------- '-;- i .s ;::>.;-' 9- b /'0 9-/;) NGWIN,Xl.S , . r ., ~ ,\ O\JTI30UNP - 1 ~OAP!:Rs ;) ~ I' :~FOOPB . PA C\ .... 1'\ If) Cj,., I q, 5/ -- Jf\lAM!L..------1!!P39.. _SJ:;NIORITY. _ _~_ _~_ =,l~ __'!L. -. _L.J:,_~_ =.::~:~-- l.OAOI:RS-- moo _____ _ :LJ_~ _/-'L.. :*-:~ :&-:: L2_ LL z~-- _1. .M.Y.JSI!:bIN~!lli ___JQ!'!!~__._____ __~ _1L__ -,,1;...':::' :~_2L_n.1L _ ___ 2 l!lJWE.~9NE!L.u.., __ 1(l~/~~h___._ ..._..., .._x ,Xv' _..><X..___..._1., 3 fRF.D HF.AGY _____ ._J!'?'Qi~!!..___ ___ _,J,'L _L. __~nh__L __.L _______ -.1.. DAVID s'f1l.es 3/26/60 ___ __ __'2- x _X__ __1<_ __lL _:1._ 6 JElFF OARNEl6 _.!!i13/80 _ __ -12_ -A- n_X_ .~L -lk--- 6 13RIAN 13flNjJ...@R____.!l!17/80 ____ OI~ ~ lx) C82.. _.:1Q.. _dQ_..:.::::_ _LillM I<EY _______10/20/60 . -L__L__L--1_.-__ 6 J, BOyeR 12/31/80 x x ..e- x x o B. l.ININGF.R ______.12/31/80 __- =.-.- DO J",ID i!Loo..- .1Q.ill.~ROPF. _~Q/OO _>i_...JS.._ 0 -1L~_ .11.l?&'ffi WINGF.RT __ _6/13/~L. ___ _lL __lS.,- ..~_ _..l5.__ __ __ ..Q.._ ..1~ .~m:Vi: OASSF.l. --.1/:l0/0L- -1L _.JL ....li_ _.JL c) j!, MICI-Ir:Al.WOOP ___ __JO/13/01 _ 0 _1<...._ _L, _L...1<_ J_4 I~, SHURGART "1/31/03. _ . () __~_ _L _>i__..CZL J~, ~~F.ASON o. 6/30/03 __ rP x ...JS.._ _.JL X tl!.Q~!: PIF.~l.gR ' __ __6/1/03__ _ __15__L _L _ 0 __ c: (x") j7 RICH m?MP~ON 8/7/04 _ ~_ ...1<____ v -1L. ~__n Q .18 eDsTUl.~ , 8/8/04 _\L _l<__~__L__L J!. MII<r: RAY~~___ 12/3/05 -L ....L-L_ -' , 20 ~F.N 1311l"1NG 2/24/08 ___ - x x x _9__ x 111 MATT G[=RHART . __ 3/3/06 _ _lL .-1<___ x L...lL ~~ QWAYNF.ql.F.ASON .__ 7/8/06 __.__ 0 ___L-1L~__.l<__ 23 Al.r:XWF.ISS_ 0/16/06 -1L-1L_____L 0 x 24 f-"!~RY I<ITNF.R 1120/07 _ 0 __ ..lL_ ___ _>L_ _~__ x 26 D. ZJ:RBY 2/0/0'/ 0 I--- X x -.1.... x . 26 FRJ:D PARI<S 3/10/07 X -X- X~ -- -- "(" ;-----X- 2';- M, F.TZWI:Ij.J:R . 07/12/21 ,.- _~___ x __L.K_~ x _ 20 RYAN BAI<F.R 4/10/00 -1L__ x x TX)- 0_ 20 M, DAUGHF.RTY 6/17I00...lL -1L ~_,__ __ -R........L 30 H, KINF.R 1i/1~/00_ ~__l<__~_____,:L-1L_.1<"_ 31 J, MOOABI: __ _ 1i/17I00 -L,_ -.J~ _L. -Jr-- 32 S, SMITH 6/17/00 _~_ _~_1_ ._____ _ ---1L~_ 33nr:F.SI: 1i/24/00-.1L__1<_______f-.;.~ x _~_ -:i4A, RIDl.I:Y 6/26/00 X X 0 X ~ (.) 36 :M, l.~YANOWF.TZ . 4/13/00 - . )'_ X-.=-- =..:.-::: _...2.. '8L~,- ;~ :~: '~A~OKl.:~Y -- ~~}~~~ - _~ - ~I_.J'-- -,~) --~. +IL~ ~ . 30 ' j~-------,- ------- ..l_~; -2?'-rl IlL'.J.~(t--r.L~--1~-Q-t.1P 41 ',.. 0 :l 0/ I" " S" S- NI:WIN.XI.S (~).' . ~-' )) ,y:( \) ~" \\1 ~;' ._..,1 ,~, ' ", tl'. Jill 4'..,' .' ~~ ii" ~~;: ',', '" .' 't~. .. '~ri' 'iJ' '11~. f ~.. ): .' i\ \~, 'II, r. ~ 'i, ,; .... I" 1"-'~ /', 1ft I I,. .'1; < I' R J' f j J W!'ltl I~, I., J ~l , J .~ ~ '11 ! ~ I l:~~ I~' .] ~l ~. J u,. f~JJ ' ' , ~ fl.R f I 'ft' ~ JI Jl r' 1 ~I; :n " '~ ~I ,.n '~ ~ ' ~ J ,~ ~~, ~ I ~Mt a ,~. 'J ~ ~ ~ ~ fr RK , 'Ii: . .11 I: H M.r.-fi,. " ti '~H .fl,. Ill' :~ ' . ' , ~ 'ft 11 I ~ I~ 8 H ~ ~ l' 1/ "R P ~ "II j . .,j Jf :IHi ,J!I"jl f [,II g I~MJ ~ ~ ~ . ~.~~ ,~~,~~] i ~..~ I ~ .thJ . , , '~I ' I ' . I i i ~ H n~ ij~jli~~IJ1lf;J :[~l~fJ ~ '", P. a-fu'n 'U]h ~~ ,~~ij'l '~, ~~ Ii .1 f u ,~ : · S .id1;~1 l 'I" ',) r' ~ ~ ~ if ' ]~". ] ~,u ~ i . ~ ' ~.: ' ,]",, .~' ~~ ': " ~. i p I K~J':~~li~ t~ I: t H~ti~ ,iJ~ l ~~I . ,U~J~.~~il, ' / ,~u r!l' {,J II ~ ~'H ~ ~ ' v . \'4J . ~ ii' 1" ,1~lf Id,d1 hi I~~ ,Iii . ~. ,f:,'I'I~1 jfhUI J dfWUd~ fr: ,~~ t] ,~ .lHRhhl~ uMj h~~ 1 " .' ., '.(""~ "fJ'iJf, ': f1fWI./]u, ~l mijf""i~:~!IU1!MJj;\ I ," J.",:! ~ ~JII' ',j Jln ~d !l~: ]f"~] ~) lif:ltJ/i JfMUJ f~i: '!Jf~iib' ,: !:IJd J \' d P-eQ1 It'M! ~ if ,i~, Ill: ~~ Ii : ~>fU .. ',' M ll!'lh g M J. 'i",IHUj'jillllfl"I.'~~J Jl'/WI'/i,i ill · :, ~ ~~Jt.~~ ~ uJ~dJl~H tqGff~JU ~J l~ ~BlhJU Ikijx , ~'", "1 '. , ,I, ',II;.],I\!,.,. ~I1WIIW - JI'I ., "' ,J'fTl., '.." \", ' '. ""j'l1l'\"'1W"i.llll "'IIIil\\~'~\'i!!<<ItS;/IIM:V' ',nf!~Nl '':0' ,"r,'rJ ,"," .'.,;,Ift.\., ,'n tll'.', doil- If .', ," .. I, '~j,.Jf"', \~')n . l'n~1J'!>lf'.~,tH~~~111Ir,' · ;', ~',. I' t,", 't I." I, t. ' . "', j+ \ '''. I , t , , <"f ': f mmm!J~;Ul! lmfumi~~lil~ ' ~u'm t~ti · >\ J tmmtrni!B1JHJtmUf~l~ir JUi~j."iJ::1 ' , iii, 9' H. 1~I,ti. ,I] I .UHf 'il , Ii~' JJ'il 'u Udl' Ifr . t, I r d~ ~~ 1!'jd II l'l,,~g I. \ ~ll. d~ 'lIdIIS\" ~:gm yi:H 1 . ~ .t,' I n ,I ~,l~ jhl. h ll~) IJ4'/ Bd ~~ l~~ 1'1 ~Hlll ' II ..U N, II', '.., J~~ ~~~. ;~ uK,~ Jj ~~i.Qf.ll\~P.ll~ i ..~IJ HatJ. , : ~ If: ~n! .IJ fJ ; !~lm ,I~t S't III :;." ',~ x~ . ~i', "~a' .....d, \I ~.aL: "." \.;; . ..t .. , ,.. ,. . , "'~Nl '," I t ~\ ,t:' . .r', ' .; · "p, <.r ' , " i , ,,~ I " '. ,i'~,(\11 ~~ru'. ,uflu '1t'~~'iJJjnf'{ c~lR,.~ ~liIll"~1 1I11,1t~:D.n", ]', t" '~,~~ II ltil'I)',Uf~,i' 'lu 'f fa,. ~~I ~f~ 1 ~ I; r J1!:,i,yJJ; I1Hu'I :1'1: df,H'iJ'j f 'M'~ i ' f1~' 1.' .~~ i ~~ 'iJ ,~~. J ~" M, I' ~r .u. ~'" ~ .1 4' i' ; ~I:ll~~lh, :~,"..' "NJ~~l~' 'ld'~~ll~I.~l~~1 ":~".~ ,~~~ :" & ~ "U d ~ ,~ ., . ~ Jl'~ III .II. I ~' . ~ u.o ' j H I, ,"~ 'K f'{ 1'1 R ~ ,U .~ .8 p JI , , ~ r ' ..Q ~ " .ff ~ ..,.... ~""_.ff".'ff'~_ , ---. ;t".:nr.~W"r--r.. :rcu:a.....-__ - ~ , ';i ~ UU'h ~,ILJJl~.~~~H'i ,~~~ ~"j IJU ';~~'~~~]~,~ n~~~:~J~UI]f'~ IfJ ~ . ~ ~ ~ y 1\ ~ :~, ~ ~. U U. ~ l' I ~ t'l n U ~ .!J ill ;// 'U .h ~l ~ "lr.J~ Jj G ," .u " < 1,'~' Jl,; ~~ {I]~n' .;, u, [~'~~ '~~h~'] ~'R P.ll'l\.'lJj~, j lJ! . , [:. Wi :,I~ljl r II u ' ;, alU I ,J,! I), If., 11 . ,~, . cl ] ~ ,; " n n .'l ~ ~ 1. U' ~ . ' '.'l . 11'" 1,' n,,~ :~~, I"~'b~,',~"r' "1 '.U'; '4~ ~I'" h ~! " " 'Q I . fA · Ii' , I] 'n 11 n'N~' Ji '; .It ~ 'U tl I ,n 11 . ,I"~I "1"''', .",-", ., " '. " w." '" l~,""""","", , "II"'" ,'.",..' . "', ,"" , . ."".n'.fIU{'ll1'liM.....,..,'.""Ijl>;>,.,., , . ., jlQ(Hfl1T " .,......,";- "-'I. " H,! .' " " ,- " " " ;1', " " " " " 11, " " Ii' tJi.i , " .. n: I; " 1_.; ';.01; il " " Ii i' " \' ,I ,) I,) () u \,) \- c ,r iI,' 717 A,~,I 5~4 1I~1I~ IISI 717 A,1(1 fiS4) MIllwn'~1 CI\IIIUII.I., .IlIlInl\, CIII'I'III1, hlw IIml 111'\1111 CIIITIII" AIIIIUlIlIl1lS, V, "HlIUi'II/, lII1IIIII1SIIIIIlI';, 1~IWIII\IIT, ^l1l1ulIlles, SIIpul'lllr ClI\lI'llIf l'ullI1sylvllIIIIl, Arullull JIlIIU 23, 19011, 11111111 AIIU, 31, 199H, I\llllr'llll!lllll ullr Ilrlvor 111111 llllssolluor hl'ollglll PUI'NIIIIIII lI\111fY llullolI IIgll1lls1 nlhor Ilrlvor, Tho COIII'I III' CII1I11111l11 I'IOIIS, pohlwlIro CI1III1IY, civil IllvlsllIlI, Nil. 95.273, llnlllluy, J" Olllol'ull jllllullwnl 1111 jllfY Vurtlllll for plllhlllffs, wlIl1 IIppulIlull, Tho SlIpul'lllr CIIIII'I, Nil, 1211K I'hlhlllolphlll 1997, PllpllVlch, J" lIuhllhlll: (IlrulIr,olllllld llrlvor sIIII1I111 11111 hllvo 111I011 \ll'llllhlllllll frllll1 rccnvorlllU WIIUO \1m fmll1 nlhcr dl'vcr, IInd (2) vonllcl nf $fi,SlKl In PIlNsuIIuur whn slrllck his homlllll IlllShhlllll'llwlIS nlll sn 1II1111c111I1l10 liS In Cllll1pOlllWlIl'd nf 1I0W Irllll. Mfll'll1ollln pllrl, VIlCIIIOII hI PIII'I, IIlId ,'oll1llllllcll. 111 AU'I'OMOUlJ.I<:!l ~251,17 4HAk25 I. 17 llollr-olldcd drlvor WIIS IInl "eIlUlhlo" In rccolvo IlIenlllo Inss hCllonls l\IIllor Mnlnr Vohlclo 111111111cllll 1l08pllllslhlll1y 1.llw (MVPIlL), IIl1d Ihlls WIl8 IInl prochllllld frn1l1 rocnvorlllg WlIllO Ins8 1'1'11111 nlhor drlvor, IlS hor ll\!1nll1nhllo IlIslIl'IInce pnllcy Ilhl nnl prnvhlo fnr hlCllIlIO Inss hOllofl1s, I1l1hnllllh sho cnllhl hllvo pllrchll8Cd Ihlll IlIsurllllco cnvorllll~, 'IS PIl,C,S,A, ftft 11lll, 1712.1722, [2] IlAMAm:S ~S9 115k59 Slok PIlY recolvell frnll1 c1l1plnyor hy rOlll',ondClI drlvllr 11111 IInl prlllllllllo drlvor frnm rccnvllrlllg WlIllo Ins8 frnll1l1Hlllll1drlVllr, 118 rClIr-ondlld drlvcr "pllhl" fill' 81ck PIlY hCllonls III fnrll1 nf Inwer WIlgll8, 'IS "",C.S.A. ft~ \'119, 1'/22, [3] llAMAlHlS c%;:;>22\(1) 1151172 \(7) Jury vollllcl III po 1'.8(111111 h\lmy Ilclllln WIlS 1101 IlIeolllllRlolII ollgrl1l\lld Ihlll jlllY IIwllrded pllllllllff Iho filII 1l1l11111111 (If $ t:I, '/25 1'111' his \IIedlclll OXpOIlNCS hili nWlll'llctI hlll1nllly $fi,4lHl fnr pllln IlIllI sllffcrlllll' I'"uc 2S HI NI':W TlllAl, ~fi 2'/Skfl IJllclslnll wholhor In UI'IIIII " ncw Iflll\ Ii wl\hh\ tho Slllllullllslln.llllll I'f Iho Irllll cnllll. (fit J\\'I'to:Al. ANUI':1\1Um ~mm 311k971( I) Appolllllc llllllfl wlllllllllllsllll'h Irllll clllII'l's Ilcclslnll llll wholhor III urllnlllOW Irlllllllllc88 Cllllfl 11I\11'"h1Y IIh11SI,,1118 (lIscrcllllllllr cnlllllllllol\1I11 onnr llf IIIW, Ifi1 AI'l'IIAI, ANIlI~ll1lOlI ~ 11104(5) 30kI<Hl<\(5) JIII'Y vonllcl Is scl IIsllIll 118 hlllllolllllllO whCII II "l'pcllrs In hllvc hcolI Ihll prnllllol nf pll8sIoII, proj\!lllco, Pllfll,1111Y, llr Cll1T1111111l1I, llr whcro II clollrly IIppcllrs frnm llllClllllllllllclcd ovhlollco 111111 Iho 1I111111l1l1 nf lho vonllc\ hCnrs IIn rOll8nllllhlll rulllllnll \lllho Inss 8\1ffcrc(1 hy Iho \1111111111'1'. 111 NI';W '.1'111 A! , c%;:;>fiH 215kriH Whcrll Iho jlll'Y's vcrdlcl Is sn cnll\rllry III Iho CyllIcllco liS In shnck nno'S scn811 of jllsllco II \lOW trllll sho\lhl ho IIwlIl'dcll. III] AI'I'I~AI, ANlllmllOlI ~I004(4) 3llkIlXJ4(4) (lcllcrlllly, II vcrlllol will nlll \10 1I1sIIII'bcll mcroly nil "CClllIlIl nf Iho 81nllllnoss nf Iho dllmllgc8 Ilwllnlcd nr bCCII\ISO Iho roYlowlnu (lOllrl wll\lhl hllvo IIwllnlcd mnrc, 19] AI'I'I':AI, ^NlllllUlOII @,:;o101I4(13) 311kl(x)4(13) WhclI Iho trllll cnllfl rcflluos rolloI' IlUIII1I81 1lI1 IIl1cllcdly Inmlelllllllc vonlllll, lho Ilppolllllo ellllrl will cxcrolso ovollllrclllcr Olllllllllllll rcvlcwlllU lis Ilclllln, (1ll1 llAMAm:S ~1311,3 115k\30,) JIII'Y vonllcl llf $6,SIHI \n rCllr-cllllcd ellr P1l8801luor, Whll Nlrllck his h01ll1 n\l 1I1l8hhllllnl, WIIS IInl so 1IIII1IcllIIlll0 liS In cnmpolllwllrll nf ncw Irllll, IlIlIllhl llf cnlll1lollllll I\Icllhllll loslhllllllY IlS III OXIC\lI nf hllurlcsl llcfollllllll1'S 1I01ll'1llnuIsI 10811nell Ihlll pllRSO\lUOr shn\lhl hnvo flllly rCCllvorClI frnm nllY h\lurlcs, Ihlll 1I1l1gll11sllc Mulllos porfllrmcll Oil Pll8S0llucr wcro lI11rmlll, l\1ul ovlllcllco wns IIIR\lfnch.1II III 110,0\'1\11110 If IIcclllolll ClI\lRCll pllllr Ilcmlcmlc IIchlovcmcn\. Cnpr. <D Wcsl1999 Nn Cllllmlll Orlll. !l.H. (IllY\' Wnrks '.} 717 A,211 554 (UII~ 11~1 717 A,21' ~M) 1111 '1'llIAI. Q';.:;o3'~ 3Kllk315 "Cnl1lpln11\l~u vul'lIlul" I~ nl\ll whul'u Ih~ jlll'Y, 111 llnlllll II~ In Ihu Ilufumllll1l'III1UIIIIIIIIIIOU nr plllll\III'['1I onl1lrlhlllmy IIUlllllluI11:n, rUlllrnK II vunllol IiII' Ihu plllhlllff hili hi IIlullllor lI11\nlllll Ihlln h wnllhl hllVlllf Ihusu I\ll\ISllol1S hllll houn fl'uu fl'nIl11Inl1\ll, Sou pllh\loll\lnl1 Wnnlll 111111 phmsus fnl' IlIhul' .11111101111 unl1sll'lIUllnns 111111 Ilu(ll1lllnl1s, . ! P2111AMMll\S .g;;;.221l7) 115k22' (7) Vurl\lcI IIwllnlll1l1 nl1ly $6,51111 In r~lIr-ul1'lu'l 11111' PlIlISCl1l1Ur WIIS I1nl onll1prnll1lsu vunlllll, ullpuulnllY 111 IIghl nf llUlUnl1ll1",lnn Ihlll Vlln\lul WIIK llllullllnlu, W1WfU jl1ry Willi I1nl In 1IIII1hl ilK In l1uIIlIgUI1CU nr onl1lrllllllnl'Y I1UIIIIIIOI1CO, lIS uvlllcllocll hy spuullll hlloHlllllllnrlus, P21 'l'mAl. ~31li 311t1k315 Vonllol 1I\Vllnllllll nnlY $6,5(111 In rOllr-ul\IlUII eliI' \lIISSCI1t1ur \VIIS 1H11 cnmprllll1lso vunllcl, ospeolllllY 111 IlIhl nf 11ulufllllllllll1l11 1\1111 vunllcl WllS lI<1ullllIIlO, whoro jllry WIIS I1nl III llnlllll 1111 In 1101lllgullco nr cnlllrlhlllnl'Y Ilug\lIlOI1CO, liS uvlllullcuII hy 6poelll\ hllurrnlllllnrlos. .li55 S, Allol1 NIlClllc1l\lIn, I'hlhlllulphlll, fnr IIppcllllnts, JIIIIIUIII', llrmlloy, MolIllI, fnr IIppollous, llllfnro 1'0pOVICH, ollln Mm.vIN IIl1d SCIIII~Lm\, JJ, 1'0pOVICIl, Jmlgol This Is 1111 IIppolll frnm Iho jl1llg1l\ol\l 01\101'01111\ Iho Cnl11'1 of Cnlll\llol1 I'lolls of DollI\Vllro CIlIIl1IY III fllvor nf IIppolllll1lS, Mllrgllrol .556 Cllrrnll, Jllhllll, Cllrro\l 111111 111'11111 Cllrrllll, III1lI IIglllnsl IIppolloOR, 1I0rhorl 0, Kophlll'l 111111 f\ollll\lll n. Kopllllll, 011 111'1'0111, 1I1'1'01l1\1\IR prollolll Iho fnllo\Vlnll II"usllonll fnr nnr rovlOWI I. Wholhor Iho lrllll onlll'l 01'1'011 III I'lcoll1l1ll1g IIppollllntR frn\ll IInrl1llllellll\ ovldonce nf Mlllllllrcl Cllrrnll'R InRR nf Incn\llu for IlIu jllry'R cnl1Rldornllnn hllRell 111'011 1110 CIlIII'I'1I \Illllll1lorprulllllol1 of Secilnll 1722 Ill' Ihe 1'0nl1sylVlll1111 Mo\Ur Vohlolo 1'IIIIII1cllll l\uIIl'ol1l1ll1l1l1y Lllw ("MVl'1\L"), 75 I'II,C,S,^, fi 17111 01 lIeq:/ l'llll" 26 }" Wl1ulhor lI\u jllfY vuflllul 1I\Vllnlhlll IIfhln 1'111'1'1111 $(,,51~1 fllr pllll1 11111\ IIl1ffurhm \Villi Ufllllsly ill1\llolllllllu 111111 1I1111illlll Iho Iwlghl IIf Ilw uvllluncu'/ :1. Whulhuf Ihu .I11fY vVflllol WIIS IIlclIl1l1ll1lol1l w\wru Il1u .Iury I1WllfllLll 111'11111 ClInllll Ihu f\lll 1111\111111I Ill' $\3,725 fill' hili \IIVIIICII\ OXpllllSOIl IlIlIlI\VlIflloll hl\ll IIl1ly $(,,5lXl I' Of 1'11111 111111 IIl1fful'll1l1" 4, Whlllhur Iho .II1fY VUflllcl IIWllflllllg 111'11111 CIIHIIII ol1ly $(,,5(111 for 1'11111 1II111 lI\1ffllrhlg C0l1111 \10 UXC111101\ 1111 II cOl11prl1l1\lsll VOflllcl \Vlwro I1UIIIIIlUI1CU WIIIII\lIIl\I\lell'/ Upol1 rovlll\V, wu lIff1fll\ll1 pllll, Vlllilllu 111 pllll, \l1111 fUl1\111111 for prouuollll1l111 eOl1sllIlUl1lWlIh Ihls 01'1111011. Thu rlllOVIIIII fllCl1l 111111 pfl1collllflll hlslory IIru 1111 followlI: 011 ()clohor :llI, 1993, III IIppfoxll11l1ll1ly 91(111 110111.. MlIrllllfOI 111\11 IIrllln CIIHolI \vulu Il1volvoll 1\1 II Iwo,vllhlulll llcoldo111 wllh I\ollllllu 1<0phllll, Tho cllllllllon OIlUI1HOII \Vilul1 1\01111110 I';uphllrl IIrnvu hor vuhlulu I1lln Ihu 1'11111' ul1ll nf Ihu CIIHolIlI' vohlulo, whloh Willi IldvuII hy Mllrllllrel CIIHIIII, ^II 11 rCSl111 IIf Iho cnlllllllll1, 1Ir11111 cIIHolI stnlUk hili hUIIII 1111 Ihu dllllhllollfll, reql1lrll1g s11ll1fuS ovor his lofl oyu. Mllrgllrol CIIHIIII hll hor hllllll 1111 Il1u hUllllruS\ IIl1d 11I1111111nOll II \VhllllllRh Il1jllfY, MlIrgllrol 1111(1 111'111\1 Cmnll \VOfO Irlllllll'oflcll 1'1'0\11 Il1u IIcOIIU 10 1\lIldlo Mull\orllll 1\011111111\, wlwfo Ihoy wuru Irulllod 1II11111110f rulollllud, Ti1u UXIOIII nf Ihu 1111111'1011 sl1l1ll1lnOll hy IIrllln CIIHIII\ 1111 11 rUIl11\1 Ill' Ihu IIcolllull\ Willi IlIlllllplllu, 011 JIIIIIIlIry 6, 1995, IIppulllll1l11 l1IuII II civil c0l\1pllllll1 IIl1l1hlll\ IlppulloOIl 10 roollvor IIl1mllllOIl for Iholr hllmlos IIrlsllIll from Iho 1I11101\10hllo IIculllolll. ^, Iho c0l\111\OIICII1\10111 of 11'1111, l\nslIl\o Kuphllrl IIll1l1l\1uII IIl1hll\ly for Iho IIccldol1l, Thu ol1\Y IIIIIIIU for Iho jllfY 10 rOllolvu III 11'1111 \VIIS IIl1mlllloll. 111 rOSPOl1l1U 10 Rlluollll hlluHolllllnrlulI, Ihu jury l1olo1'111lnoll Ihl\l 1\11111\\10 I<ophllrl' a l1ullllllolleu Willi 1\ IIl1l1sllIlI\11I1 fllolor 111 hrlllllll111 IIhOll1 11111101111\1111' hllllrloll. Thu jllfY Ihul1 rOlllrnod II vonl\cl IIwllnlll1ll 111'11111 CIII'fIlIl $13,725 for modlclIl OXpCIIIIOS nl1d $6,5(111 fill' pllh\ 111111 IIl1rrorlllll. 111 IIddllloll, lhu jury IIwol'llod Morllllrol CIIHolI $7,500 IIIllI John CUHol\ $1,111111 111 111111'OCOII0ll11o d1l1l1111101l, ^1'1101\1I11111 mod II 1'01l1-lr11l11\1011nll for II 110W Itllll, whloh WIIS dOl1lod. Tllurollflut'; .111111111\0111 Willi olllorml iiI fllvnr of IIPllol\lIl1ll1. Thill Ih11uly IIPI'OIlI fn\lnwell. ^pPIIIIIIIIIII 111'11I oOlllllll1llhll1 Iho 11'11111'0111'1 01'1'011 In I'roullldlllll Ihol\1 ffllll1 IlIlrlllhlell1u uvlllllllCO nf Mllrgllrol CIIHnll'1I loa II nf IIICnll1C for Ihe jury'lI Cnl'r, ~, WOSI 1999 Nn CllIllI1lo Drill, V,S, C1nv\, Work II I \ I \ I \ I t" 717 1\,2d 55., (CII~ II~I 7171\,2,1 55'1. '5~fi) cUllshl~rllllulI hllscd 1I1'01l Ih~ COIII'!'s mlsllllcrl'relllilun of!i 1722 uf Ihe MY!'lll.. AI Ihe lime uf Ihe IIcchlelll, Ihe Illll'!hnru Ilor~hllln Sehuol Dlslrlcl ~mploycll MIIl'lllIr~1 ('111'1'011 II~ II l'"rHlmo schuIII IlIls Ilrlv~r, pnc III her h\lurlcs, MllrOllrel cllrrull mlssc(ll~n wceks III' wurk, which she reCelvcll sick I'll)' from her omplllyer, PrillI' 10 Iho 1I001lle11l, MIII'OIIl'O\ ('111'1'011 111111 uplell nUl lu pllrehllse 1I0-fllII!1 Incllllle luss ooVel'lloe wllh hor 1I1110mohlle Inslll'llnoe Ollml'"I1Y, III First, the 11'1111 oom! conohHlcll Ihlll hOOllllSO MlIl'SlIrel Cmoll WIIS "ellolhle" 10 rccelvo InoUllle 11Iss hOllol1\s II1111er !i 1712(2) of Ihe MVPIU., lllHI hoollllse sheohuso lIut III plll'OhllSc IIHII IlIsIII'1I1100 OoverllllO, she WIIS I'rcol\lllol\ from roCOWrllll\ wlloe loss fromlll'l'ullcos, (I'N II Scetlon 1722 sillies: I'NI. SooilnIl1712(2) I'rnVhl,", 1III'0rlhlollll'II1'11 ~ 1712, I\vullllhlllly '" hOllorll. 1\111111111'01' 15\lIll1u ur dOllvorlll" lIuhllllY 111"11'11000 1'"110101 onvorlllU ullY 11I"lur vohlolo Ill' 1110 tyl'o 10'llllrod In ho rnul'lorClllllldor Ihls llilo ", shullllluko IIvllllnhlo fur I'mohnso rlrs\-illlllY hOlloflls wllh 1'0'1'01'1 In 1IIIIIry IIrl.llI" 1111I Ill' Iho 1I1111111ullulloO III' 11.0 Ill' II 1II11111r vuhlolo II' fllllllw., . . . (2) 1110"11I0 IIISS hOllorlk'llIulllllos Iho fnllmvlllll' (i) IlIUIIlY 1'0rcoIII Ill' RCI"nllll88 III' urll88 IIICIIIIIII, 75 I'R.C,S,^, * 17\2(2), '557 !i 1722, I'rcelosllIlI of recovorlllll 1'0111111'011 hOllol1ls III III1Y 1I0lluII fill' 1I1111111lles 1I1\II111S1 1I10l'lfellslIr, or III IIOY IIlIllISlII'ed or 1I11110rlllsmed l11(lInrlsl proooedlllo, IIrlsloll ollt of Iho 111111111eOlllloe or oso uf II 1110lur vohlole, II porson who Is olll\lhle !II reoolvo hOllol1ls Illlllor the oovornoos SOl thrth III "lhls suhchllplor, ur wnrkors' Oll111pOIlSllllulI, lIr III1Y prOlll'll111, llrullP oUlltrnol or other IIrrnlloo111elll fur PllYl1101l1 of hOllol1ts liS dol1lled III seotlulI 17\!l (rolllllllll lu ollurdllllllloll of hOllcflls) shllll ho Plwlllded frolll rooovorlllll Ihe 11111(111111 of hOllonts plIlll or plIYllhlo IIlldor Ihls sllhohllptor, ur workors' CUI1lPOIlSllllol1, ur nny pruorllm, I\l'OlIp cUlltrllcl ur ulhor lIITlIlIllol11onl for pnymenl uf hellenls ns 1I0nlll'd In soollun 171!l, 75 I'n.C,S.^, !i 1722 (omphllsls IIMclI) , Tho cllIn'l rOllsollell lhnl Ihe 1'1101 Ihlll Mnrl\lIrel ('nrroll olllllll hllve (lllrchnselllllcumo 11Iss covorngo l11ellnllhlll she 1'11"0 ~7 wns "01l1\Ih10" III rcoelve IhcNe hone fils, We flml Iho cUlln's oUllohlNlul1 Ihlll Mllrll!lrOI Cnrrlll\ WIIS "ollglhle" 10 rocolVil IIICIlIllO luNS hOlllll1ls lIIull'r !i \712(2), oWII Ihllllll\1 hor 1IIIIIll11uhllo hlslll'lll\oe pullo~ lllll 1I0t I'rOVlllO for ilwso hellel'lIs, Is orrOnCIlIIS, AI tllO Olllsll!, we nUlo Ihll\ Ihe pllrohllslI uf IlIculI\o Illss IlIsllrnnoo Is ul'lIonnl. Soo 75 PII.C,S.I\. !i!i 1711, 171'2, MlIl'llllrol Cllrrull Ilhl nol vlullllo III1Y pruvlsllll1 of tho MYPlll. when she lIPlo(1 11111 lu (lmchllso 11111\ ouvorngo, If wo wore 10 111101'1 the lrlnl CUUn'n rllllonlllo Ihlll IIny 1'0rs0l1 Whu. oonlll hnvo \1\lr0\1nsoll Incol11o Illss ouvcrnllO WUIIIl! ho "ollglh 0" 10 rooolvo thuse hOIlOnls, II 11'011111 prll(luco 1111 IIhsllnlur UI1rOllsOllnll\o reslIll, which wo I1111s1 proslll11o the luglslnlllre IIIlI lIullntollll, Soe I I'\I.C.S,A. ~ 1!l22(1); 1.lnlll1ol'v. Mullnn, 544 I'n, 4117, 67'7 1\,2d IIU4 (I!lUli), I' Aocllrdlnll 10 Iho Irlnl CUlln's Inlerl'rolntlun, nllloo ovory vohlolo oWllur In 1'01lllsylvlll11\1 InllY (lIll'Chllse IlIcolno Illss oovornlle, OVOrY vohlelo OWnor or Insmod driver In 1'0nnsylvllIIIII wonlll ho "Olllllhlo" III rocolvo IIIClllllll luss honoflls, As II rOlmll, tho ulIl~ porsons who ooulll SilO turtfollsors for luss of 111001110 woulll ho uUl-of-stnlo OWllllrs IInllllporlltors of vohloh's, Wn do 1101 hollnvo Ihl' 10lllslllluro IlIloluled slIoh II rosnll. Thns, wo 111'0 Ilnnhlo 10 IIcenl'l Iho 11'1111 CIlIII'I's IIrllnl11ol1l thn! Mnrllllrot Cnrrllll WIIS "ollnlhlo" 10 rooolvo 11101ll11e loss henol1ls 1I1lll0r !i 1712(2), Illllhor, wo 111111 Ihlll II porsun Is "Olllllhlo" lu rcoolvo Incomo loss hononls 11111101' Ihe MVPllL when ho hilS notlllllly I'lIrehllscll sneh honenlS, 121 Socullll, Iho Irlnl COlin lIulorllllnelllhnl Iho slok I'ny rocolved hy Mllrllllrol Cnrroll \Vns II hononl \Vllhlll Iho pnrvlew or !i 1722 of Iho MVFIU.. Tho OUllrt ronsunoll Ihlll If Mllrllnret Cllrroll wns nol proollldod frul11 rcouvorlllg he I' WIIOO loss frum Ihe lor!fonsor, sho wUllld he "lIollhle 1lIl'l'lng" hy reeelvlnll slek PIlY hllnonls I' Will hor lllupluyer IInll Ihell rocoverlng Ihe snl11e IIInullnl In 1IIIIIIngos 1'1'0111 IIppullccs, Inllolol'lulnlnll whollwr slok PIlY hcnonls nro within Ihe purview or ~ 1722, wo l11usllook 10 Iho Innl\lInllO or ~ 1719, SOllllunl719l'rovlllos, In porllllonl (lnrll !i 171\1, Cuordllllllloll of honunls (II) (Jeoernl 1'1110, . Bxoopl for workers' CUl11pOOSlllluo, II polloy 01 10s\lrllocO Issllell or Copr,~' Wosll!l!l9 No Clnlu110 Orin, lJ,S, (Jovl. Wurks '11'/ 1\,211 554 (CIlI11I~' 717 1\,2(1554, +S57) 11~lIv~r~11 pllrSlllll1l III IlIlij ~lIhollllplor ijllllll hu prlllllll")', AllY prllgrlllll, >>rullp OUIIII'IIOI ur 1111101' IIIT1I1Ig11mo1l1 fur PIIYlllolII IIf hOllofllij 1111011 1111 Iloijol'1l10(1 III 11110111111 1711 (rolllllllg III 1'0111111'011 \1ol1ollls) 1712(1) IIml (2) (1'\lllllllIg IlInvllllllhlllly Ill' hOllonlij) Ill' 1715 (lollIIllIg Iu IIV"lIl1hIlIIY Ill' mlolllllllO IImlls) sllllll he Ollllijll'lIo11 III 01111111111 II IlrllvlslulI 111111 1111 hOIlOllls plllvlllolllIlOl'ol1l ijllllll ho II O~OOSij Ill' IIml nul III llllplll'lllllllluf III1Y vlllhlllllll cllllo"llhlo nrsl pnny \>Ollonlli prllvhloll IIl1dor socllun 1711, 1712 ur 1715 Ill' WUl'kolij' cUlllpOIlSllllun, 75 I'n,O,8,1\, ~ 1719(11). I\ppolllllllij IIrgllo 111111 1110 111111 CIIIII'I 1IIIIIIIIIorpll'IolI ~ 1722, I\ppollllnlij IIvor 1IIIIIlilck PIlY dllos 11111 fnll Wllhlll Iho pllrvlow uf ~ 1722, hili, rlllhor, lij II honolll III 0~008S uf, IIml nlll III tlllpllollllulI uf, II Ihlrll-pllny pnymolll fur IUIIII uf WlIgOij, I\ppollllllls roly ulllho doollllull8 In 1'111110110111 v, 1.lhony MIIIIIIII 11I81111111cO (1I'III1P, 543 I'll, 114, M9 1\,211 93ll (l99fi) nl111 1I1'llWI10 v, Nnllullwhlo MIIIIIIII +SSH 11111\11'111100 Ou" 449 1'1I.8I1pOr. MI, fiN 1\.211 1127 (199M, IIl1uCIIIUI 110111011, 545 I'll, 674, fiH2 1\,2tl 3llfi (l99fi), III lillppUnuf Iholr IIrglllllolll. 111 1'II1110holll, III1PIll, UIII SlIpromo CUllrl 1I0hlllllll 1110 III11UIIIIIS rocolvoll hy 111111\1111'011 olllpluyoo 1111 ijlok PIlY IIl1d suolllllloom'lIy h0l1011l11 wero 1101 tlotluollhlo hy IIn 11111\1101' IlIlIolormllllllg 1110 Inonrl1o l(lijij hOIlOlllij 11110 III 1110 omplllYoo 1I11dol 1110 MVI1IlI.. '1'110 SlIprOIllO COlin OXpllllllotll 1'II1110holll's 1000lplllf hulh ompluyol' pluvldotl ijlok 10llvo h01l1l1l11l IIl1tl suollll 1I0cllrlly tllijllhlllty houolIlS, liS 11'0111111 fllllllloumo 10sII hOIlOflI8, 1111011 11111 1'0111111 In "IIOllhlo tllpplllg", Th080 111'0 hOllolllij fur wlllch Iho olllplllYoo 111111 pllltl III Iho limn uf luwor WlIgolI fUI Iho slok 10llvo hCl1ofll8 IIl1d III 1110 form uf p"Ylull dotl110111l1l11 fur IIUCIIII licol1l'liy bOIlOfllll, Th1l8, III 10colvlllB hili IIlck 10llve PIlY, 1'II111cholll Willi OXhllllSIIIIg hl8 ollrnoll omplllYoo hOlloll1. Slmlllllly. 1'11111011011I hllll pllhl fur 811cllll 80cllrliy 1I11111hllllY h0l1olll11 Ihl'llllgh pllYlull IIcllllCllulIlI, IInd 110 III IIUW (1lIIwllIll UII Ih080 hOl1ofll1l hOCIII1110 hili IIco11l0111 hll8 1'0111101011 111m 111111\>10 lu WUlk, I.lhol'ly MIIIlIIII WUIIIII lll1ve Ilij IUllo IIlghl uf Iho fllcl 111111 1'II111cholll hllll plIlll fur hili II10umo lUllS hOlloflllllhl'l1l1g11 PI'VI11II1I11S ho plIlll L1hol'lY MIIIIIIII wllh hili OWII fOlllls. 110 Is 0111111011 Iu IIICUI110 IUN8 hOIlOfllN IIl1l1cr hlij pulloy 111 Iho filII III11UIlI1I of hili Il1cl1l11o 101111 wlihulIl III1Y uff801 for 81ck PIlY ur MlClnl IIcelll'lly hCI1ortl8 rocolvoll hy I'nllo 1" hll11, 1'II111cl1olll, 5.13 1'11, UI 1111, M,9 1\,211 nl 932-933 (Ol11pIIlIHIH mlllol\), III IIruwllo, Mlprll, Il1lij 1'"111'1 1'011011 nil 1110 Iloclijll1l1 III 1'1I1110holll, 811pl'lI, 111111 Cl1l1olllllcll Ihlll 81101111 8cI>IIrlly 11l811hllllY IIllYl1101llij 11'01'0 11111 IIIol111101111llho Olllogul'Y uf Ilollofllll pIIlll ur pllYllhlo 1I111111r "lIny pruIIl'lIm, !1I'unp oUlIlI'nol ur lllhol' IIf1'III1BOllllll1t" fur WI1I11h 1111 llff8111 1111181 ho I11l1dll 111 118001'11l111111g Iho hOll01118 nVllllllhlc 11111101' 1110 MVflIU.. Soo 75 I'n,C,S,I\, ~~ 1719, 1722, Thill CUlln 111111011; 0111' eUllClllijlUII 18 III koollll1B wllh 1110 1'01l8uI1111B hohlmlll1o IIocl8111111111'1I11 oholll. II Wllij lIulol1 lhlll SUllllI1 Scellrlty 11l811hlllly IWllonls 111'0 hOllllfll8 fur whllll1lho ol11pluyoo hll8 pllllllll Iho fU111I uf pllyrulI IIcIIIIOl1l1l111, Tl10 roeolpl Ill' 1I10Se hOIlOfllN IlY Iho plll111llff III I'lllllcllolll, IIml Iholl' I'ooolpl In Ihls 01l8e, 1111 1101 Cl1l1ijllllllo "lIl1l1hlo (lIppll111." Appolllllll III1S plllll for Ihollo hOllol1l11 Ihl'UlIllhnl1l hl8 wUl'klllU CIIl'Oor 111111 111111 plllll 1\ 80pllrlllo PI'Ol1lll1l1llo ho OUIllPOIISlllolllilr II111us8 Clll18ClI hy II IIl1hll1l1l'ol1 mlllol'181, 1l0cllvol'Y of hOlh 18 IInl IllIpllollllvo. llnlhol' 1118 1'1111' IIml cU1I10lllp11l1C11 hy Iho 101'IIIH uf Iho MVflUl" 111'011'110,6"" 1\,211111 1129. Wo nllll Iho Pl'IIIOlploN 111'110111111011 III 1'1I1110holl\, 811PI'II, 111111 III'UWIIO, 811prll, "Pllllollhlo Iu Iho 111'011(1111 011110. We fmlhor OUIIOlllllo Ihlll lho Irlnl ollllrl mlllllllorprolol1 Iho IlIl1gllngll uf ~ 1722 uf Ihe MVFllL lmll fllllolllll cUlIslllol Iho rOllllolllllg hohlllll 1110 IIcol81ul18 III 1'1I1111'holl\, III1PI'll, IIl1d lIrnWllo, IIl1prn, III I'lInloholll, 811pl'lI, 0111' SlIpl'omo CUIII'I Illllphlllllzclllho fllol Ihlll IIlck PIlY nml soollllllecllrlly hOl1ol1ls WCl'e hOl1olllH fill whloh 1111 omployoo hllll plllll fill' 111 Iho f01'1II uf 11111'01' WI1l\eij IIml pllyroll dolll1l11111118, Wholl l'eoolvll1g IIlck pny, 1111 ompluyoo Willi 0~h1l1l81111g hili Olll'llcll omplllYoo hOl1elll, IImllho 1'000lpI uf 8110h 11111 lIul 1'081111 111 "l1ullhlo IIlppll111," Thllll, Nick PIlY hOllofllS CIIIIIlll1ul ho 1I801llu 1'0111100 1111 ompluyeo'8 rocllVol'Y hOOllllllO ho pII1l1 fur thollo h('l1ol1ll1, 1'lIl1loholll, SlipI'll, 111111 111'1111'110, SlipI'll, 1101 fUl'lh dol1l1ll1vo o~lIl11plos of Iho Iypu uf hOl1oflts Ihlll 111'0 IIUI Il1clllllcl1 111 Iho CllloglIl'Y III' hOl1oflls plllll III' p"Yllhlc IIl1l1er ~ 1722 n8 III pl'ol>llIlIo recovory. I\ol>onllllll III Ihollo doollllll1l8, hOIlOfll1l for whloh II plllhlllff hllN p,,'1I fur ur olll'l1clI IhrulIgh his CliPI', <t, WOIII 1999 Nil Clnlmtll Drill, U,S, (luv!. Wurks ., 17 A.211 ~~'I (Clip IISI 717 1\,2(1 55'1, .55H) Ol\lplpYIIIPIII 111'0 1101 Wllhlll Iho p"rvlow of ~ 1722 1111I11110 rooolpl of Ih\INO hOllonlN 110 1101 OOllNllllllo II (10111110 rooovory, III Iho prosPIli OllsO, shll:O Mllruurol Curroll "plllll" for Ihp slok pllY hOllonls Nho 1'00011'011 frulll hor olllployor III Iho 1'01'111 of lowor WIIUPN, Ihuy IIrll nol 110110 fils Wllhlll Iho I'lIrvlow of ~ 1722, TIIIlN, MllrUllrol CIII'I'oll Is 1101 pl'ollhllloll frolll rooolvhlll slok P"y, liS woll 118 rocOvOrhl11 WIIUO loss 1'1'11111 "l'pollcON, Wo (10 1I0111111111IlIIl'I'lIf 1111' 11'1111 oOlln's III'lllllllOllis sO cOlllpolllng ns 10 proohlllp MIII'lllll'ol ~~lIl'roll fronl rooovorlllllwllgo loss frolllllppollllos, ConNllllllollily, wo cOlll'hlllo Ihlll lho 11'1111 oonn 01'1'011 In pl'oohlllhlll IIpplllllllllS fl'l'l11 InlrmlllcllIll ovlllollou nf Mllrglll'ol Corroll's .559 loss of III00I1111 for Iho Jllry's oonshlorollon, Thol'oll1ro, wo 111'0 001111'011011 10 Vllolllo Iho JllilOlllonl, III plln, 111111 1'0111111111 for II II0W Irlllllhllllolllll MnrUIIl'ol Cllrl'llll's IIIIIIIIIOOS for IllSS of Inolllllo, 131 Appolllll\ls' sooonll OOIliOlllllln Is Ihlll Iho Jllry VOl'lllol IIWlIl'llhlllllrllln Cllrrllll only $(i,~(X) 1'111' pllln IInll snrforlllu WIIS llrossly Inllllollnlllll IIl1l1l1UllhlSllho wolllhl Ill' Iho ovhlonoo, Thns, IIppolllllllS olnllll Ihlll Ihoy 111'0 onllilolllOll nllW 11'1111. IPN21 I'N2, ^1'1'01l1l1l1' 111'" ClllllolIIllIlI1I Iho vonllol WII. 1001111'18101\1 hooll\l8o Iho JIlIY IIwllrlloll 111'11111 ClltlUlI (ho 1\111 1111I111111I 1'111' hlN 1\101110111 081'01l'OS 11111 IIwllnloll hll1l loss Ihnn Iho 1\IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIi,r 1'1I111111111 sllfforlllU, Wo l11111 Ihlll Iho vorlllol WIIS 11111 11I011I1SI'lolIl. Soo UOllorally chlllvorllll v, Sowlokloy VlIlluy IIl1sl'.. .109 1'1I.SUl'or, (,]0, ~9H A,211 1021 (1991) (jlllY vonllol WlI' III0lllI,I'101\I whoro Iho JlllY lillll\ll 111111 IlololllllIlIl's 11011111101100 W1I8 1101 II 'lIh.11I1II11I1 Ii'ollll' In I>rllIlIllIlI I1hlllll 1'111111111'1'8 hllnll h\ll 1I0vorllll'Ioss IIwllr.lo" I'llIhllll'l' 111111111110' "' II 10s\l1I Ill' Iho 11101110111). Illllhol, 111'1101111111' IIro IIIlIklllll IIstollslhly Iho SlIl1Io 111111111I0111 liS In Is,"o IWI1, Ihlll Iho vonllol WIIS 11111110'1111110 111111 111111111'1 Iho WOlllhl Ill' Iho ovhlolloO, Th1l8. WO wlIllIIIIIl'oss hl1l1ll,slIo, shll\llllllloou.ly, 141(51(61(711111191 Tho deolsllllI wholhor lu grlllll II /lOW 11'1111 Is wlthlll Iho sUlllld IlIsorollull ur Ihll Irllll CUIII'I. Mlloholl v, Orllvuly 1/11'1, 6911 A,2d 6111, 619 (1'0,SlIflor.199'1), Wo will Ilul dlslmh Iho 11'1111 oUllrl's dool8111llllllloss Iho OUIIII flulpllhly IIhllscd 118 dlsorellul\ ur cummlllcdllll orrur ur Illw. hi. A JIllY vonllol Is SOl 1181110 118 hlllllolllllllO wholl It IIppOlll'S lu hllve hoc II Ihe fll'mluol III' PIIS8111U, I'IIIIol9 proJlIllko, pllnllllllY, III' 01l1T1I11111l1I, III' whoro 11 olollrly IIppOllrs frum IlIlolllltrlllli'lod oVhlollco 111111 Iho 111111111111 uf Iho \'01'11101 hours IIU 1'0llSllllllhlo rolllllulI III Iho IUS8 8111'1'01'011 hy Iho plllhillff. Whol'o Iho JIllY"; VOl'lllol I' su oUl\lrury lu Iho ovlllolWo us lu "'hllok Ullo'S SOIlSO uf Jllsllco" II110W 11'1111 shllllhl ho IIwllnlcll, II Is Ihu pruvlllou ur Iho .Il1ry III llSSOS8 Iho WlIl'lh uf Iho 10sIImuny III1lI lu IICOllpl Ill' 1'0.1001 Iho oSIhlllllu8 IIlvon IlY Iho Wllllussos. If Ihu vor(lIel hOllrs II rOll8ullllhlo rosolllhlllllOO lu tho pruvulI dllmlloos, II Is lIul Iho flmolloll uf Iho OUIII'IIIl sIIhSIIIIIIO lis .I111111Il\OI\l 1'111' Ihll Jllry's, I!I1\Vovor, whllrll IIIP h\hlslloo ur Ihl! vonllol "s11I11I1181 lill'lh IIko /I hUIIOun", II 011111'1 shulIIII nul hoslllllu III 1111l11i IlIlIdollnlllo 111111 ordor /I IIUW 11'1111, I<lsor v, SOhlllio, ~]II I'll, 219, 225-2(" MH A.2111, 4 (1994) (0111111011' umlllull). "(Junurnlly, II VOl'dl", will nul ho IlIslllrholl moroly un lIooullnl Ill' Iho 811\1I11110SS uf Iho IllIIlIlIlIoS IIwllnloll or hUOllllsO Iho rovluwllIg Ollllll WUllhl hllVo IIWIIl'llod moro," Nllllolmlln v, (1Ilhl'hlo, 436 I'II.SlIpur, '1<1, 647 1\.211 233, 236 (199'IJ, (11Wllllg 22 Am,Jllr.2(I, Illlmllllos, * 1029 (1922). "Whon tho 11'1111 01111I'1 rOflls08 1'01101' IIllllhlSlllllllllooodly hlndulllllllo VOI'lIlOI, Iho IIppOllll\O CU\II'I will oxol'ulso OVOII grolllor Ollllllunln l'I'vlowlug lis 1\OlllllI." Nlldolmllll, 647 A.211111 237, (11IUllllll Mllllllor v, I1rnlldun, 2112 I'II,SlIpor, 37, 422 A.Jd 664 (19110) (IImphllsl8 III\lrlglnlll). 1101 III Iho pl'o'om 01180, Iho oXlom or 111'1111\ Cllrrull's h\ll\rlu8 WII8 IlIllIsplllo, 1I11lllhu .Il1ry WIIS prosoliloll wllh cOlll1lollllg 1I\011l01l11uSlh1\01lY. \I WIIS rur Iho .Il1ry lu IISS0S8 Iho ovlllolloo lIIullll lIooopl ur roJool Iho Ollllnlollllll 10sIImullY or Iho wllllossos. CllrlsulI v, I1l1hll8h, 432 I'II,SlIpor, ~14, 639 A.2d 't~lI, .\fiO (1994), III111clllllr (Ionlod, ~'IO I'll, 592, 6~5 A.2d 9112 (1995), Applllllllllll urroroll Iho oXPolI 10RllmollY ur Ill'. IIlIhol'l LlohlllOI' IIl1d Ill', Johl\ TllWIISllnd III Iho rurlll ur vldoOlllpod dop08111u1l8, Dr. TUWIISOlld, II hUllrd oOI'lIl1od\lourulolllsl, uplllod Ihlll I1rllln f~lIrroll '1\8111111Cd II mild 11'1I1\11111110 hllllll h\ll\ry ollllsllIll dlzzll\css, VOlllllu, loss Ill' momury, IlIok ur CUllool\lrllllul\, pruocsshlll dOllclolloles, 1'001' 1I01l1l0ml0 lIohlovol1101l1, liS woll liS pUSl'oOIlOllsslvo hCllllllohos. Ill'. TllWlIsolld oUl\codod Ihlll 111'1111\ Cnrrull did IIUI oumplllln ur II hOlld IIIJllry III Iho hllsplllll rullowlIlll Iho lIccldolll. Dr, L1ohlllor, II chlrnpl'lIolur. llplllCd 111111 111'11111 Cllrrull IIlsu sll81111110d 1I Millin ur Ihc IIcok, rlllhl shullhlor IIl1d lowol' hllck liS II 1'081111 uf Iho IIl1lumohllo 1I0eldol\l. Ill'. I.lchlllor 10sIII1011 Ihlll I1rlllll Cllrrull IlIdlolllcd Cupr. [) WOSI 1999 Nu Cllllmlu Orin, U.S, Ouv!. Wurks ) 7i7 1\ ,211 55,1 (c1I~ II~I 717 1\,211 554, .559) Ihlll hu hlill ~1I~llIh1UII wlIlllllIsh hllllrl~s or Ih~ lI~uk Iillll IlIllIk Oil I'Ivu prior o\'ullsloIIS whll~ ~1;1I1111, liS willi II~ sll'IIllIull his lowul' IlI1llk III Jllly of I OO~, II rew mOlllh~ I>ul'oru IhIlIlC~lIlolll, I\ppolloos offur~1I Iho 10,llmollY of PI" 1111'11111'11 M. 1<1I1~, II h01l1'11 oOrllflullllullI'ololll~I, wllo ~xllmlllllll IIrllll1 Cllrroll 111111 rovlewull Ih~ l1IulllulIl r~porl~ or 1110 olll~r Irulllloll pllysl~llIlI~ IIIllI 1110 0111OrllOllOY 1'0011I rucol'Il of Hllhllu Momorllll II08plllll, Pro '<III~ 10sllfluII Ihlll 111'11111 ellrrnll 11111 1101 1I'8U .5fill cOII~~IIlIIsllm followllIll Iho 1I11~III~III, wlll~h 11I1I1~1I1~lllhlil h~ ~1I~11I11I~lllImll1or h~1I11 1111 lI1'y , 1\1 1lIlIlllllllrllllll~y rOOIll, 111'11111 ClIlToll (11111101 Compllllll of Imy prnhl01ll8 willi Ills llllll, hllIIlIlC~, hOIll'II111 01' 8Plleoh, ot COllf1181011, Ill', I<III~ IlplllOlllhll1 IIrlllll Clltroll s\lsllllllolI 11 11I1111 1'1101111 h\~ornllol1, soflllsfil1o filtllll1 of Iho 1100k III1lI hlluk 1111111111111101' 1101111 hllllry, Jlll1'llIor, Pt, KIII~ 81111011lhlll IIrllll1 cllrroll 8hOlllll III1VI' I\llIy r~oovoroll 1'1'0111 III1Y 1I\lurlofi 1111\1 he 8111'1'orollllfi II rOfill1l of 1110 1I11101ll0hll~ 1I0~1I101l1, II, ~lIppOrl'ol' hl8 Opllllollfi, !Jr, 1'"I~ 108111'1011 Ihlll Iho (1I11111108110 81111lles plll'l'orllloll <111 111'11111 Cllrroll, COll8181hlll of IWo Mill SCII1I8 of Iho hrlllll, II CI\T 8~1I11 of Ihu 11[11111111111 x-rill' films of 1110 Skllll, proV~ll 10 he 1I0rmll!. !Jr. KIII~ 81111~lllhlll ho l1l81111l'llCII wllh Ill', TOWllfillllll's COllollI~lolI Ihlll IItlllll Cllrroll'8 Ollllolllll COlllpllllll18 wero rellllull 111 II olosoll h01l11 1l1ll1ry. !Jr, KIII~ 11180 81111011 Ihlll Ihoro Wll8 111811rrtololll 1111111 10 1I010rmlllo If Iho 1I1110mohllo lIoolllent' ollllsell Ilrlllll Cllrrnll'~ poor 1101111011\10 lIohlovOIIIOlI1 III MOllllllllllory COllllly COlllmlllllly colIOllO, 08peolllll)' III 1I111l1 of tho 1'1101 Ihm ho hllll poor llrnlle8 prior 10 Iho IIcolllolll. Dt, KIII~ oplllcll Ihlllllrlllll Clltrnll's 11I111101l11lskolutllllypo cOlllpllllll18 WlltI'II111011 1118I1hllll)' of 11 fow wooks IIl1d Ihlll II fow Illlllllhs of dlsllhlllly WOIIIII ho uxoosslvo. Fllrlhorll1oro, IIccorllllllllolho roCord8 of II11ok81110nt I'hY81cIII 'I'horlll'Y, Ilrlllll Cllrroll Wll8 (hlsorlhod liS hlllopol1dOll1 111111081 lIollvlll08 hy Fohl'llllry 15, 100.\, I\flot II 1I1lll'Ollllh rovlew of Iho rocord, wu 011111101 cOllohllle Ihllllho wrlllcl WIIS IlIlIdolllllllO IIl1d 1I11llhlSI Iho welllht of Iho ovldollCO, II Is nppllronl 1'1'\1111 Iho vordlol Ihlll Iho Jury fonnd !Jr, 1<1117.'8 108\1111ony etodlhlo IIml dlshollevoll Iho ovlllolUlO of dllllllll\OS pre80nted hy IIppollllnls In oxcoss of lis IIwllnl of $6,500 for 11I1Inllnd sUfforllll\. Tho Jury did hellovo Ihlll Ilrllln Cllrroll's 11101110111 OXp011s0S woro Inol1fI'ClI liS II rosull of t1w IIcclllonl, III1lI IIwllnlod hllll .' !'nl\o 311 dllllllll\OS 1111110 fllllnlll\IUnlof $13,725, Ills 1101 for Ihls l,o\l1'1 10 111011110 10 1110 .I\11'y Iho ovlllolloo 1\ II1l1sl hollovo, Cllllllllllo v, IIlllllk, 537 I'll, 155, 161,6012 A.211 "'la, 451 (I OO'\) , Wo 110 11111 1111I11ho .Inry vc1'lllul sn shook hIll 10 OIlO'fi 80nsO of .In81100 liS In oOlllpol Iho IIWIII'lI \11' II now Irlll\. Thorofnro, wu 011110111110 Ihlll Iho trllll 0111111 11111 11111 IIhn80 lis IlIsorullol1 or onll1mllllll 01'1'01' nf IlIw hI IOr1lS1116 10 llrllnl II IIOW 11'1111 Oil Iho Ilrolllllls Ihllllho vordllll WIIS hlllllolllllllo lnllllllllllllSllho wollllll of Iho ovlllolloo. I11I Flnlllly, IIppollll1llfi onlllonlllhlll Iho .Il1ry vor<lIol IIwlI1'llhlll llrllll1 Cllrroll 0111)' $6,50(l for 1'11111 11I111 slIfforlllll 11\111011108 11111\ Iho, ,hll'y OlllorUl\ II cOll1promlso vordlol, wliloh h 1I111'0rll118sllll0 hoclln80 IloslIlIo I<uphlll'l 11l1111111cll IIl1hlll\y, "1\ Clllllprllllllso VOl'lllol Is Onl) whore 1110 .Il1ry, 111 dOllhl liS III Ihe liofol1l1llnl'8 1I0111l110IlCO ot pllllnllff'8 oonltlhlllory 1I0UllllOIUlO, rollll'lls n vol'lllol for Iho plllhlllff hili 11111 lossor IIl11nlllll Ihlll1 II won III hllVo If Ihoso IIn081111ns 111111 hoon 1'1'00 frnll1 (Ionht." Kisor, 531\ I'll, III 233, 60111 1\.2d III a, 1121 IIoroln, Iho .Imy WIIS IIl1l In (IOllhl liS 10 IIppollo08' nOllllgolloo or liS 10 IIPPUIlIlI1lS' oOlllrlhlllOr)' nOllllllulICO, 111 re8pollsO In 8poollll hllorrlllllllorlos, Iho .Illry f0ll11111hllllln811110 I<ophlll'l'fi neullllo\lCO WIIS II 811h8111ntllll 1'1101111' In hrlnllhl11llhlllll IIppollll1ll8' 1Illl1rlos. The .Il1ry WIIS 1101 118ked 10 dolorllllno If IIppollllll\8' woro clInlrllllllorlly nOllllllonl, Slnco Iho VOI'IIlUI, 118 ovhloncod hy 1110 spoollll IIIIUITOlllllorles, WII8 "1'1'00 1'1'0111 liollhl," wo cllllnnl conellldo 111111 Iho vordlcl WII8 II c0ll1prlllll180 vordlul, ospoolllll)' In lI11hl nf nnr fllldlng Ihllt Ihe rosnlllnll vol'lllcl WIIS ndolllllllo, In snlll, wo find thlll Iho trllll Ollnl'l orrod In proclulllng IIPpollllnl~ 1'1'0111 proSlIlltllIll ovlllcncu lIf Mllrllllrol Cnrrnll's loss of IIICOIIIO, FlIl'Ihcrllloro, wo onnolndo Ihlll Ihu .Il1ry vOl'lllol WII8 nlhorwI80 llliollnlllo IInd nnt 1I11llhl81lho wolllhl of Iho oVlllonoo, For Iheso rUIISOIl8, wo IIIl1sllIrrtrlll III plln, Vllonlu III PIII'I, nnd l'onun1l1 fill' 1I110W 11'11111111111011 In Mllrllnl'ol CIII'l'll1l 's 111I1II1I1l1l8 for loss nf Inoollw. Jlldlllllonl IIf11nueli, Inpllrli Vllolltod, InpII1'1. CII80 r0l11l1mlcl1 for procoolllnlls conslslolII wllh Ihl8 opinion, Jllrlsdlcllon rollllllnlshod. EN!) 01' DOCUMENT ./ Copr, 10 W0811099 No Clnllulo Orlll, U,S. (JOVI. Works .lPJ1,DIno " ~ ~ !"\ C".I 1.-0 ("' ~ C' IfJ j ..;:.~ 'II 'II" h, ~, ~ 1'1)\<: !,-.~ ., " L', ,,'j i I ,~J \ """ ;j ~ l~;':i {, , I ,i'/ ~ i->; , (~ '.-' :,1\.. , .\,... I.-I ;},,! .,'1.) ~ ~ ;H , I,;) I ~ .,:fl:, "I~; c./ ' ~,'-\ .'c-' 1..1 ~J'\I/ -:1 .. c~ :t\ ", (.q ".;, " . .. -, 'l I' 'ilINV/iIA~;I:lINW'.II"lr'\';) AINI"C\'I U"'.! :"",. , .; 1'1~. - ~lI\V IiC, l) '111; '" 1,11 ." ,\,.. ,I , (\" '1,) I .JCi I' 'II' J)l ",\\il ,',,\ . . " " ",: dll\1 (J\l ~\ln -G Iii :\lll~ "U' . >:\ 1"1) (:uUHI'I \, !"\;i';I~I'\I\YLYIJ,!1/"" I' .' ,,' ";.-. In " I fi:; I~: "'-' (t:. ~ J,q(; " :,'~~i . ~ , ~ .) ;;'1 ;:1; /, . , 1 "l.. ' '", ~ AA (';/ 1.\" '. lJ,1 , i ..) ~_:~j ~ 1 ' ~ ("'1 '1") ..~. II ,:/ , ,; ;?;~l ~ " :.'.', , r Ii 'JQ 11_1 ';liI) i ,..,1 h.-~ t'),"'I. '-'i t II, n, ~~i ~ () Ci") t'_) \V' ~ I ~ OUJGJlilVr "I ;, '-2. wanton auc:\ reol<lelJlJ manna}: :\.1\ vlld.oh Dc,fBl1clilnt: l3\1iHm: opof.'ilted hor motor vehiolo a~ followsl ii, fai lUl:l'l \:0 hAve hor vehicle IIndel' slwh oontrol as to be able to atop within the ilssured olear distance ahoac:\, b, l:ai.lll1:e \:0 apply hEll.' bnll<B1'I in l'IuJ:f.:\.cient \:ime to uvo:\.d striking the roar or Plaintif.fs' ve\liole, .0, failure to keep pl.'Opnr and adequate control over her vehiclel anc:\ d. driving hel: vehicle upon the hiUhwcW in a manner endangering persons and property and in a reck lese manner with careless disregard to the rights and saf.ety of others and in violal:ion of I:he Motor Vehicle Code of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, o. plaintiff Michael nayeon sust.d.ned Painful and severa injuries which inclllde but are not Hmited to cerviqal sl:rain, $I. By l:eason of the af.oresaid inj uries sustained by Mr, Rayson, he was forced to incur liability for medical treatment, medi.cat.l.qns, therapy and l3imi.lar miacellaneotls expenae/3 in an effort to reatore himself to health, and claim is made therefor, 10, Because of tho nature of hia injuries, Mr. Rayson has been advised and, therefol'e, avel'a that he may be fOl'ced to incur similar expenses in the futm'e, anc:\ claim is made therefor. 11, As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Ml'. Rayson has undel:gone and in the future may undergo physical and mental auffering, inoonvenience i.n carrying out hia daily activities I loss of life' a pleasures and enjoyment, and ola,1.m is made therefor. 2 MWHAliJl, nAYSON, Plilil\l::I./:1: Vf3, IN '1'1114 COUR'!' Oli' COMMON Pl,liJAS CUMBr4HLAND COUN'l'Y, PI;:N1~SYl.vANIA CIVIl, AC'I'ION - I,I\W NO, 'Ir. I/Pf(ll,,,:t"'-;",._ .JURY 1'IUA1, DlilMANDliJtl COMPI,AIN1' PliJ'I'RA SHI[i'[i'l4i<, Defendant: 1, Plaint:it:f: Miohael Rayson ia an c~clult individual Who resides in Mifflintown, Juniata County, Pennaylvnnia, 2, Del:enc1ant Petra ShUfer is an nclult; inclivic1ual who reaides at R, n, 1, Box: 53A, Mi.lleratown, Party County, Pennsylvania, , 3, 'l'he I:aots and OCOll):rences hereinal:ter related took place on or about June 22, 199B at i\Pproximately 7 a,m, on Route 11/15 before the I-B1 briqge, Cumberlnnd County, Pennsylvaniil, 4, At that time and place, Mr, RaYSon was operating his motor vehicle, a 19$14 Dodge Dakota, in a southern direction on Route 11/15, '" ::>, At the same time that Mr, Rayson was travel:l.ng north Dn Route 11/15, Defendant Shiffer was operating a [i'ord Probe also traveling south on Route 11/15, G, AI: that time and plnoH, tlw front pOl' I;:\. on of Defendant Shiffer's veh.i.ole oolli.ded with the rear porUoll of Mr. Rayson's vehicle, '7, The foregoing acoiclent and all of the injuries and damages set forth hereinafter suatained by Plaintiff Michoel Rayson are the d.i.rect and proximate result of the negligent, oarel.ess, 1 wqnton flnel l:ncll(JoUfI 11I1\1\1)01: I.n whl.oh I)of'ondilllt ,Yld.J:f:Cl):, oporat:oel hill: motor yohialo flU followul n, f:n:lllll:O to hfwe he!.' vehl.alo nndtU' Sllah CJontrol ns to bo flblo to ~Itop w.i.thl.n the f1SlI\l!.'oc:l ChHU: diut:Ance clhenc:\/ b, f:n.i.lure to apply her brnltos in sut:fiaiont ti.me to avoid striking the rear of Plal.ntl.ifs' vehicle, 0, f:ailul'e to keep propel' nnd adeqnf1t:e aontrol oyer her vehl.ale, and d, ddvi.ng her vehicd.e upon' the highway in a manner endfll1gedng perSOnfJ nnd property and in a l'eokless lIIanner with CAreless dis.l:egnl:d to the dghts and safety of othera and in violat:i.on of: the Motor Veh.i.cle Code of the conunonwealth of: pennsylvanl.n, 0, Pla.i.nl:Hf: Mi.ahael Rayson slH3tained pai.l1ful and severe injud.Be wh.i.ah .i.nclude but m:e not Hmited to cervical strain, 9, By reaaon of the aforesaid .i.nj uries sustained by Mr, Rayson, he was iQrcsd to l.ndu~' li.abil.i.ty j;or med.i.cal tl'eatment, medicat:l.ons, therAPY C\nd sim.i.lm: miaaellaneous expenses in un effort to restore himself to health, and claim is made therefor, 10, BeaaUas of: the nature of his :l.njuries, Mr, nayson has been advised and, therefore, avera that he may be forced to incur siml.lar expanses in the future, and alaim is m~de therefor, 11, As a result of the aforemBntioned injuries, Mr, nayson has undergone and in the future may undergo ~hysiaal and mentnl suffering, inaonvenience in aarrying out his daily act:l.vities, losa of life's pleasures and enjoyment, and claim is made therefor, ;< " 'I, ~ C~) ;,.. 'i' (",.~ I.. . ~,; ,'- " tub " l~l;;) .~ ~llt'_i ~ 1.,)~r IJ:r"', n... HI..j I jp t~.. ~]r:' l.rl i'\rJ Ii i. I I"I,~ fUI' >... ,lip I; ill !}J . ' I..: ~.;5 l5 c..., '1'1 Ci ;'" i' ,I II ',; " "\1 ~.- ell ." tf; I:'. 1."< ~J/., ,l"j' ~II ~ , ,. , I, .f 1::1 .1 I, , ,.. (__II ! I , L'.I , 1'1 [,:, I. 1\1 I' . I. :. -.<II'IJ , L~~ 1 .. '.~rL l" [I) .J ,J 01 U .. . , ,. - ~!l ! I 8~~ ~~I ~~~I~H il~ !ll ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t\..: I'" '" "'. ll~ r,,, I... .. L;i..,(' Ill!") (\.J I.,J:';J I,... !'r: 1..1::'- .;:./ , 1"', (.l. ".J>j '-( . ']1\. "..., J,'.. (\~ 1:.-';,: 1M" " .-1\ l',. ; 't j i1~: lJ.. J .. :nn! I ~. .. l,'~ 0'1 It; C,J (;1') ~) ,. ,1'", " ;, MIOHAl;1. RA V80l'l Plalnmf v, I IN THl; OOURT OF oOMMON PI..f=AS I OUMI3J:RI.ANP OOUNTY, Pl;NN8VI..VANIA I I CIVIl.. ACTIoN - I.AW I NO, 00-11 ou I I I JURY TRI~1.. PI:MANPI:P Pl;TRA SHIFFI:R, Pefllmlllnt flUBPOaNAJQ.PRoouca POOUMt:lNTfl OB..Itlltmfl EQB.QlflOOVfilW PURSUANT TO RUbIL4nnn,2~ Tal Mounlaln Vlaw Mollloal Oonlor W11111n twenty (20) deyo aftor sorvloe of this Subpoene, you are orderecj 11Y Ihe Oowl to produoe Ihe fOllOWing cjooull1enls or things: lilllLAnMlI:llill al the offloes of Nealon & Gover, 301 Market SIreet, 0"' floor, Harrlsburo, PA 17101. You ll1ay [Iellver or 1l111111oglble ooples of 1I1e dooull1onts or produoe \hlngs requealed 11Y thla SUbpOal1ll, together wllh the Oarllnoale of OOll1pllence, to the pl1rty ll1aklng Ihls raquaat I1llhe addreas IIsled above. You hl1ve the right \0 aeek In I1dV8nCe the re~aonable coal of preparing tho ooples or producing Ihlllhlngn aollght. If you fell to produoe the docUll1enls or things required by Ihla Subpollna wllhln twenty (20) daya after lIa servloe, the party .~elvlng thla Subpoena ll1ay seek 11 Oourt Order oOll1pelllno you to cOll1ply with It, Thla Subpoena Was Isaued at the requeat of Ihe followlno person: Matthew R, Govor, Eaqlllro 301 Marllol Stroel, O'h Floor Harrisburg, PA 17101 717-232-0000 Attorney for Oofendanl BY TI'II: OOURT: DATI:D: (p -- ,I f' 11 . J-' (e e u' h.'J 1\ ,Io'/'Jc PRoTHONOTA'RYl jr )' ;. ~JtJ'J" a.R/,c ;/ .,(,,{A~, . '-~~i~ Seal of the OOllrt MIOHAIEI- RAysON PIl\lntlff I IN THt:! OOURT OF OOMMoN PI-lEAS I OUMa~RI-ANP COUNTY, P~NNsYI-VAN'A , I CIVIl.. ACTIoN. I-AW I NO, 1111-1106 I I I JURY TRIAl. PI:MANP tiQILqg TOI Mountl\ln View Meetlnal Center v, paTRA SHIFFi:R, Pefenctl:lnt You are re9ulred to oomplete the fOllowing Oertlflo!1te of Compll!1noe when procluolng doouments or things purSuant to the Subpoena, QSBTIFIOATE! OF OOM~I.IAN08 WlIl:t aUElP08NA TO PRODU08 DOCUMeNTS OR THINGS fY.Bm,!ANT TO RUJ.1L4009.~3 I, Reoords Custodl!1n for Mountain View Medloal Oenter, oertlfy to the best of my knowledge, Information ancl belief that all clooul11ents Qr things requlrecl to be produoed pursuant to the Subpoena lasuecl on have been procluoed, DATE; Reoords Oustadlan \1 ,-, . ", MIOHAI:I. RA VaoN Phlll1tlff v, I IN THe OOURT OF OOMMoN PI-I:AS I CUMaaRI-ANP IJOUNTY, paNNSy~.vANIA I I OIVII- ACTIoN . ~.AW I NO, 90-11115 I I I .JURY TRIM, OI:MANOap PI:TRA SI-IIFFaR, Oofol1(llInt aUBPOIlNA TO PRODUOE DOQYMlllillLOR ntltillIl ~QVIlRV~URaUANlTQRUl~~~ TO, Nallonwhlo 'nsllranoo Oompany Within twenty (20) days after sarvlce of Ihls Subpoenl'!, yml ore orderecl by the COllrt to produoe the following doouments or thlnos: llF.E A TIAQ1IIiQII\ the omces of Nealon 8. Gover, 301 Morke\ Streel, Dill Floor, Herrlshurg, PA 17101. You may deliver or mollleglhle ooples of the dOOlunents or procluoe things requsstecj by this SUhpOl1nll, togethsr with the Oertlrloate of Compllanoe, 10 tha party mal<lng thlo requeatllt the aclclresll listed ehove, You heve the right to seek In aclVl'!nce the reosonl'!blll oosl of proparlng the copies or produolng the things soughl. If you fall 10 produce the clooumen\s or things required by this SUhpoena within tWanty (20) cleys efter Its servlco, the party serving this Subpoene may seel\ a Courl Order oompelllng you to comply with n. This Subpoene was Issueel at Ihe request of the following person: Mftllhew R, Govor, 60111llro . 301 Markol 81rool Bill 1'1001' . I Harrlsburo, PA 17101 717-232-0000 Attorney for Defondanl IW THE COURT: DATED: (p. /8 "10 , (!/J..- ~) _ .A.t{ttJ '.' "':;Cj PROTHON RY ~ ,..~4 Sllol of the Court :q I' " " , I , I , (,,' , II I L " t , , ~ ~ ~~~ ~ 6 &~~ ~~~ ~~~I~~~ o P ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~ Z ( g ~ I II Mfc~'Agl.. RAYSON Pllllntlff v. i IN THg COURT OF COMMoN PI..t:AS I cUMagRI.ANP COUNTY, Pt:NN5YI..VANfA . , i CIVIl.. ACTIoN" I.AW I NO. 01).1105 I I I ,JURY TRIAl.. Pt=MANOI:D P~TRA SHIFFt:R, Pf)fol1chmt flUa~aNAJ:llI!BQllliClIUJQJlUMIUiTJiClBJJIINllli EQaDllio.a.\lallY.J~llllll.UANU.Q.BULl.i!Illnll,"a TOI Rlohfollcl Within twonty (20) clays after SOl viae of this Suhpoena, YOII ArO orclerod by tho Oourllll produoo the followlno eloaulT1ents or thlnos: Sr;;ILAUAQl:laD ot 1110 of/laos of Noalon & GQvor, 301 Marllol Htreot, 0'" Floor, '-Iorrlshuro, PA 17101, You may deliver or mallloolblo ooplos of tho (Iooumonts or prodlloo thlnos roquosterl bl' this Suhpoena, touelhor with tho Oorllflooto of OOlT1pllanao, to tho pmly maklno 1I11s roquosl et 1110 adrlress listed ahovo, You havo tho rlollt to seok In advenao the roesoneble oost of preparlno the ooplos or produolno the thlnos souoht, If you full to produGo thu doelllTIClI1ls or Ihlnos requlrod hy Ihls Suhpoena within twonly (20) dnys oftar lis servloo, tho party sorvlno Ihls Suhpoona mey SBol( a OOIlrI Orelor oOl11polllno you to oOlT1plYWlthlt. This Subpoona WllS IBsued ot tile raquost of tho followlno peroon: Motthow R, Govor, ESl]lIlro 301 MMlwl Slroot, Oil' Ploor Harrisburg, PA 17101 717.232-0000 Attorney for Osfondanl BY THE COUHT: DATEO:__~~'- I J-1 'l ('(' I )" _LL~'LCLU .IS, - {)1tt \:J,",-, I-- l" l (, -:a. ' c.) I 01// Soal of tho Courl , " 10 i:: " " , ,>. iI , r , I , I, ,I i ': . , , ll" , t...' !,J I t:l if! I', , p"", I , ! i.! , '{[' " II ~ ," I , '" \ l.'J 0, (,J ~ ~.l; ~I ~ ~ ~ ~ I o 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ( I, 1~'t110'''b"II~''IUIIO.tHtI/O ItJlft'lWOI '/)ijl"rIrolIVUWIlU.U.VU'm K111<':'1,waV 'tytlllllVlI1TV ~ ~ ~ 5 ~. $ ~ I!l ~ ~ ; i ! ~ ~ ., m ~ ~ 1. ,. - -"1- ) I ) J~ Th. Co"r~ I' C~A '1... of Qumb.rland CDUQ~1, "nDly~v.n" ".- MJCIlAu:r, I~AYSONI V. I'Ii1l'IlA Slfll'V'p:R "11,99 ,HOB " qq ~ - OA.Tll W. do .olamal)' ~~'r (or .fft~) tha~ ~I ~ill '"ppllr~, oblY .nd dl'lnd UI Con.C;I.~"Ull~ of tll' UJlil:.~ 1I~,tll nd tlll CIIDlU~1It"~" of tllb Colamon.. w.dth pd thl~ WI "Ul 4hphul' th. duf;111 of our pfUPI with Ud.lt~y. ..-:-' ) , /J /J . l."'~ VI!~~. , ~ __e - -f.{i ~qm~~ ~~+r.man ...... e -- 'II"'" ,.-.'- _...~ ,./' (; ...-::..--~~' --'- , . ,~l~~_ ~.1~~il mlire - Arbltl:/ltor e'{ .'-"(t.. I J.& . Miohael J. I'Ykoallt ~aCJuil:e - ArbJ.tr!ltor AWARD W'. the und.r.tgn.d .rbitratorl. having b..n duly .ppoint.d .nd 1U0rD (or :afUr:lII.d), uk. the followiog .ward, (Not., If damal" for d.l.y are ,wMrd.d, th.y .~all ba ..parlluly .tatad.) ".). . A ' '0 u..J , \}; L f.... \ -'\ ;...,. ""D C-\J N "1, <tIN ckatt... ~ !" .:.:1 ~ I o-vWf, it? J:A~ 1 ILl f').MYI u..q '1 !'! Ii" I 4 cl c', 4'j. - '1 app1!Qabla. ) . Arbitrator, dia..nta. (Insart name if >>at. of H.ar:Lng! DecJIll]1ber 2, 19~ nata of Award, _'/).t..:. 2 / ~ '1 '9 .>"!JJi~ .' '.J.~ Ge ,-- 1 /-YVt'~ r~ , MIo laa J. 'yk NO'l'ICF. OF ENTRY OF AWARD Now. the ) day of fu<,.tiYl'l_2.oJ . 19 q ?' at 1()''',9 JJ:..tt.. the above award va. entered upon the docket and notice the eof given by mail to the parti.. Dr thaiI' attornny.. ' -.. .'-_e..... ~Chd1ffilll!\ -- , Eaqu re - Arbitrator , IIrbi trlltor Arbitratora' compBnaattoo to be paid f50n ~peall $:<'~ .()OXI<. nYl 'IN i 11,1.-\-1"'\ ~ ' Q'>"" '1 I 0 M t.\ \..u rt- C!l ,\'~ I~()J h, ~ .SA~/! Ie /J/! ( '. I PCI<-! '(b NIC~(U~ ~/c'cJsh ' Ilr(J-S'(~"c,?15' ,. n w ..r~lW I /a ta (/fJ r # c5/(t2./'! tPP/~ 1 1/;(.(4..( {~. /.,JI(>(./'('? r;:, -0 ~3- (:, -.t:: (Ll d) r:> [) :3 ~\ P , .::c.. -1- (b P ..~) () ;3 D ~ 0 ' ,g, p ~, (D ~ ~ -0 oJ ~ c;: d (6 0::... ~. P (j) Ul 0%:'.:1." (b Ulo ::-. ;X - &-' - I (Uj" .....!-' Q.,\ :::::- e.,,1 (t) Jr p . ::t=:.' ". W 1;) r -\'1 -0 ';:.. c7 ( , c,-' ''""0 I--g-~" P lP :p L}-. [J> :. ""C)c.q"", LD(T P_ ;::p \:A.. -I- ~l fu_ 6- .... () GL-, ;0 7'.. ...J CPo ~ (;.J (jI- I -- C) -1- -I r -- D<l -P (ll - ..., .." l!> -.J C\;) '"D \) ~r G} f1> ,.q D. '::' /1\ VI (Cl -VI '"' O~?';:. rr:- -. - CP (0 t.. 3 -....j(.)~. ':;1 a a ~ r6\Y) (fJ ~ C5 (II ~c2 ~ ff.. .;J<::::. Fl' -t- - . r\~ o ff2 (''.1 'l() l\ G ll)' ('~ '.if:I'('1 C) -, ..J{''i 1'1 "'J c~ r (e) ;1I:u "/., I 1)),1 ""1'1 f~( ,,\ 1'1 - ,", t ,'" ., .,() ., 't" ,.;';'c-~ :';,i I.:~' S';;r~' L::i (,a;. J -,- .. t-,'fl ::') ..:1 U} 'J -<; \./.) ~l'; -<; -I) 11 .. Q:. t() " I: I I, ~ , 1:1 I '~ 11' I ('" I (.l, , " " 0 l;,l ~ " ~ , I () , a ~ ~ ( I 0;:; r.i I) -err - ~ P.i ~ ~ ~ ~q~ ~ E &~~ ~~I ~~~I~!~ ~~~ r~ ~ ( g ~ ~ :t ., . .. . .. . IV'" """O' Hl hllO' 11 UIIO, 10 UtlO ;!Hj hVOj :)I/I',,,IIOII"III/'JIII,II"" llyjulIOl$lAAly'nouu..'lt'1'f