Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout99-01256 Defonclap\:a Donooclo li<lbility for 0I11.\13in9 \:hI3 110d,r\ent, al1r\ have <191'qecl Elmon9 \:hem~lelVes On apportj,onmenl: of any clam<1gel3 fOl.\nej, '1'hls will be a jllry trial in whioh,pl\!:l3ua\W to Eln agrElemenl: of oOlll1sed" Pl<lintHfs wUl huve I'm\!: paremp\:ory challenges, and Daf:anclants colleotiVely wUl helVe four peremptory oha11engc1s, for a total of eight, 'l'he Clstimatecl cll.\ration of trial is two dClYs, Defenclants have incHcated that they wUl be reql.\eating interrogatories to the jury on the iaaue of substantial faator (legal causation) <la well as damages, Counsel for Plaintiffs in the:lr pretrial memorandnm have raised the issue of the adm:i,ssibHHy of the test:i,mony of David Mataka, a nonparty who waa the driver of the truck owned by Donald Whitebread & SOI1rJ, on the ground that H had been indicated to him that Mr, Mataka could not be found, As of the present date, this remains the case, and in the event that any counsel should desire to have Mr, Mataka testify, he should so indicate to the trial judge so that a rUling on Plaintiffs' position oan be made by the \:1'ial jqdge as to tho admissibility of any suoh testimony, With rospect to settlement negotiations, Plaintiffs have 1110st recently demanded $125,000,00, Defendants' last offer collectively Was $30,000,00, Counsel have indicated that they do not expect the case to I, II" H. !t " .,. ~- ~. f:r ,,' ~n ..-~ i.:,~ '. " (!, I"~; , ("1 ,';1.\'f. 1),,' in)\';",) r.:-' r.q ,.~I,~e " 0.", L,: ' ') i~ ~ C) f,~ l-;-J ';,l~ l:!J il1 1"1, 1,:;J !.:J Ii I.. L~ Ulm " ,~. () r::l d Ii " " ;If . !d " 'I; " " " " '-" ;1 " " Ii " 'I " " H II '-J' " " !' , , " i! \, ,;"_,j,;_._,,,,_j,_J.1 "" "ii';;' ", " " " ",-lid ""d) GlZS " " '\ 'q, "" " " I.!lf \t,\HII hi 11,1 1,(1 '\<l'~l \\\ III 1111\ SV1 \1\1 1',0, Illl\. 1,'.Id" 1I,\1l11i'ililIl1i, Pl',',U'nl\\'i!\ 17111H l.!hH'!" I' (llll,llllrllCi, ""'P'.\I.'" t.. SIIII'~t,'Nt \llillJ1,1 I', \11.\\\ ,,:<:, " J/ tf no j' l..1 :J.flDy,e I' , I , , I; I I : 01; " .. I i! " \ 1\ " ,\ )) ); " I' " " " ';, ',"-'ll' ",,,,\,; '" , "" I' .' 1\ ,1."J,." ,V~,;~., 1,l\w OI'I'lqi \)" MICllAlil J, Hi\NI'T " 1\1' l'(lltN!,YS Sol t;:11\ iNSI;unIIS A'I' I,AIV ,1'1 111(( 1( I~\V"""^V II"'" Sill II IPIl I.'^I".I'I I" I'A l'IOI:I.1)1-I;! '/I'/,2'1')"S:I'/:1 '^X 71'/, ~'I'J,(l'I.S'1 \VIVW.IIM'II n ^\VIlItM,(:lIM OCT Jl201}b;. . JJ- 7 "I' 'I' " " ,," H " !i " H " " 'I' ",Iii' 'I I .\ " ^IlPI~I\Y M, yo\)N(IIl11\1 .'^MIiH YOUNo, PllIll1lll'1il I IN TllIi ('OUR'!' of COMMON PLI\Ml OF 1 ClJtvllH\R\.ANIl CollNTY, PHNNHYIN ANI^ ..1 I I 1'10,1)1)-125(1 CIVil, TI\HM v, WA YNIi Ii, IIOI,I.ANP 111111 lllClllWA Y T1~ANHPORT, 1NC'I l)ul'ol1dlll1l11 \" ,. DONI\W WIIITI\13HI\AD \'<; HONH nnd N II\. KI II llNClI , Addhlol1nl purundnnls ,JUHY TRIAL DI\MANDIiD I'IWTRIi\L MI\MORANDlJM.QE PEFENl2L\l'lTH WA YNE 1\, IIOLLAN1lnTllI HIClIIWi\ Y TRANHP()JIT.Jli~ I. FAeTH: Plnlnllrr Audro)' lvi, YOllngnllugus lhnl sho wns In.l\l1'ud Inllnnulomobllu nccldunl tl1nlocuulTCd onl-H Iln thc nron which Is throo Innos northbollnd Inlln111pdul] Townsl1lp ntnbout 7:50 n.n1. on Mnl'ch 12, 1997. Tho Whltobrond 11'110101' Il'nllol'lInd Il1u Ilonch nnlomobllo WOI'O Involved Illn oolllslollnhond or WIIYl10 Ifollnml. 110 swcl'vcd his Il'lICk to Iho right nlld collldod with tho IIlItomobllc opcl'lllod by Ml's, Yonl1g which hllll gllnl'llrnll. Tho Dol'ondllllls mu colluctlvolr IIlhl1lttlng IInblllty, !2AMACH\ti: Thu Dcl'ondnl1ts cOlllust Iho suvurlty orlho I'lnlnllf'l's nllugud bnck , ~, IIl.lur)', 3, 4, 5, IHHlJEH: Llmltud 10 dllll1l1guH, LEGAL IHHUEH: No prohlumH nl'c IInllolplllod. WITNEHHEH: DI', LIIIlCC YlII'llH, D,O, h)' dopoHltlon, 0111' 10 Hpll1l1l1l1oHI .1(11l dOmOUH hulill'u II olllllu 10 rUHlllllur 1i11l11111lhu glllll'lIrlll!. I'llIil1lll'l'H 1'111' II'IIH lollllull, 011 .Il1l1u 2,1, 21111(), l1ul'oIlIlIlIlIH WIIYllu 11011111111 1II1lllllghll'IIY 'I'l'Ill1HpOl'l, IIIU, .IolllUlI Alllllilol1l1l Dul'oI1I1I1I1IH 1101111111 Wl1liuhI'lJIIlI.'\: SOI1H 111111 Nlkklllulwh IIl1ulIlllg Ihlllll1ull' l1ugllgol1oo l'uHlllioll Il1lhu l)[1IIIHlolI holwoolI IloIIIIIIII'H II'I\l1k 111111 MI'H, YOlll1g'HUIII', Hpoollh1lllly, .Il1HllllWlI1I or MI'H, YOlllllllllld 1101'o11l111111110111lIld, MH, IlolI~h II'IIH oporllllllg 1111 1I\11011l0hllo III Iho rlghl-hlllld 111110 or HIIlI'hlllJ 1111'111'101' I I'll 11 Ul' opOl'lIlo11 hy 1111llllld Whllohl'ollll & Snl1H II'IIH prn\lUodll111 Il1lho loll-hlllllllllno nl' loB I, 'I'l1u WhllohrOlld Il'IIull IIwllho Ilol1uh II\IIn11lnhllo onlllllod nr IIhllnHI onlllllcd 111 l)'nl11 nl' Dol'oIlIlIlI1IH'lrllck IIllI'hloh 111110 Dol'olllllll1lllnllllllll onllhlod II'lih 1'11111111 I'l'H vllhlolo, Nnnolholollll, Iho IIl1hlllly orulloh Dol'ol1dllnl hllH hool1 HlIPllllllod, Soo 101101' or WIIIIIII11 Alldlll119dlllod Soplolllhor 211, 21111I,lIl1l1cl1od IwrolnllH I!xl1lhli "A", ", S'I'ATI~MI~NT OF BASIC FACt'S AS TO J)AI\IAm~S All II rUHlI1I nf'lho IIcoldol1l, MrH, YOllllg Rnl'l'orod IIn 1I01llU oorvlolIl HIl'lIln, HOVOI'O pili II In Iho Ion OOI'VIOllll'oglnl1, loll illg 111111 nook, hCl'lllllllnn or IlIl11hlll' dlHO III 1.5-S I, pnRlorlol' Ihool HII'IIII1, ROVOI'O hllnhlll' plIllI with 1'1111101111\\' plIllI, hlllllol'1I1 Hhollldol' pili II, IInll IIl1xloly IInll 1I0pl'OHHIIln IIH II1'0Hnll ol'hor I 11.1 I1I'loH, Sho hllH IIIHn HIII'I'ol'oll, 111111 11'111 ollllilnllo 10 HUI'l'oI', pllln IInll HIII'l'orlllg, IlIonllvolllollou, olllhlllTlIlIHIllOl1l, IllCl1ll1ll1l1glllHh IInll InHH ol'ul\lnynwlIl nl' 111'0. III pl\\'llolIllII', MI'H, YOlll1g WIIH l\1rcod Inlll1111pono hol' 0lllplnYlllUI11 plllnH IIlld 1I'1I111\1l'cod (n onpo wllh HOVOI'O pili 11 111 hol' Inll'ol' hllok dllrlllg hor pl'ogllll110Y wllh 111'111 hnYH hnl'llllll (MohoI'I H, 2()()() IIH II1'0Hlllloflhu 1I0cldol1L 1'111111111'1' ,111111011 Ynung hllH IIHHOl'lolI II e11111ll 1\11' IlllIlI nl' \:0111101'11\1111, 2 , " , j.t " " I 'Ii' !:xhllJlI A " '\ " II " " j. I) " " " 1',' ii' " " .' " " "i' " " " " " " '.' " " " jI ,. " !.j '11' Hi "I' (! " d " Ii i Ii (._t\ 1111">1>1 1111'11 tl,~'ill~'. 'tlllhllil" III , r~' " I.. Elchlblt A I, exhibit A ';"1111'''''\ .. ('I' I';" ", " ii' ;1' " iI' ,< " ,-,1, ,-p " ;i I, ;-,1' " " " " " " .( " " " '1\ "I' " " " ".'I " " " " " H , " '", " " (i' " f; (':, .'11 IJ'; r'J,::1 ~.'Ilr ,:,i:" ~ t'; .'1" fL. (Iii ] I' (T) fj" r jJ, ("oi lili' I" t 'I" ,... II, I, ,\ (..J (J-, I, :>' " l ]', J I " I \'l! .. " :-') C.,) ," " j." 'I j' .-1' I, " i, H I"~ If II '1, " ,I II' " Ii !'. " " " " " (:i " " \( " I" .. " " " " " " " " " .I, ,,' 5, AI.lho SIlI11U 111110, Dolomllll1l WIIYl1U I!. Ilollllml, WIIS <lrlI'II1UII 11)1).1 Frolul1ll1l1ol' 11'110101' 1I11111owII1uII 11I111iOl' 11'1I1101' Illl1Tyll1ullqllll1 plllsllo, whloh WOI'O 0\1'011 l1y Dol'ol1<1l1l1l IlIuhWII)' Tl'lll1spnrl, 1110" 1111110 pOllIoI' 110rlhI101111<1 1I11l\l01' 1I110rsllllu HI, 10 Iho lun or 1'11111111''1', h, \10/011<111111, WIIYl10 1I01l1ll1d Illll'olossly 1III'I10d 1I110lhUl'Igl11 111110 10WIII'II PIIlII1I!lf 111111 HIl'\lok hol' I'ohlolo, Ihl'oll11\ 1101' 01'1' Ihul'olllllll)d 01110 Iho h01'l11 whol'o slw onllldml wllh II u1lllr<lrnll. Tho pnlllslol1 ollllsed 1'11I11111f1's Vlll1lulo 10 spll1l1ll1loSI :lflO <lOgI'OllS hol\1l'o II UllIllUlo 1'0SIIIl\01' hluhw 1110 glll\l'lll'lIll, 7, As II <lll'oollll1d Pl'OXll111110 1'0sIIIl ol'lho oolllHlol1,lIl1<1 1101'0111111111'H 110gllgul100, 1'IIIII1tllT ^"<1l'oy YOlll1!! slllTol'u<l physlullllll1d pUI'SOll1llll\ll1l'lus, COUNT I A!ll.l1:Q.LYlll1l1l1 v, WIIl'110 1I0llnllllllnd lII11hwlIV TI'nIlHIIlI1'I. IlIe, riJ!Jl.lluulluu 8, Thu II1'orl1l0111s llOl1ll1ll1Ulll11 pll1'lIgrllphs I Ihrollgh 7 111'0 II1uorpol'1I1u<l hUl'ol11 hy 1'01'01'01100 liS II' I\llIy suI Ihrlh hel'ull1, I), Tholluoi<lol11 WIIS PI'OXhllllloly OllllSu<l hy Ihol1ogllgol1oo 01' 1101011<111111, WllYl10 E, Holllll1d, liS 1\1l1ows: ,,(II) Il1ll'1l\'L1l1l1g 11111 sPoo<l gl'Olltol' Ihlll1l1'lIS 1'0llsol1nhlo 111111 PI'IIdol11 11111101' Iho 1l0l1dltl0l1s 1I1\1111'IIh dllo 1'0glll'II 10 Iho 110111111111111 polUl1llll1 hllzlIl'Ils oxlHlIl1g 1111'10111\101101'75 I'll, C,S,^, * :l:lfll; (h) 1I111l0vll1g his I'Ohlolo 11'111110110 Il'lIf1lc 111110 101l1l0lhol' whol1lho 111111'U11lUl1l cOllld 1101 ho 11111110 II'llh 1'0llsol111hlo slIloly 111 vlolllllol1 01'75 I'll, C,S,A, * :l7:l4(II)i 2 II " \i\'ll nTH:! (I.: 'i' ' :,,'" ',', ':'JfNIY " " , , , " " "'; ';, " " '.' , " Ii " " " " , , .. " , " ,,';! " " " " " /; "I' II d' "J I , , , . , " j , ) i' " j; H " , "II)' ril)' i'dl _I, \, ',"'1''/ '\!I,'ll, " I,' " Ii I! ", ., " ;, I ~ i; I, i, ,. ,I II' " 1.1, " " ,1, Actcti~ional DefBndan~ Nikki Henah ill an a~ult inctiyidUal rel3icj,j,ng at (.3 Biroh Strool:, MBohan:lrJllburg, CUmber]lInd OOllnt:y, 1'1\ 170lil; , G, '1'he 1'1aiutHfa hAve f:Ued ,1 oOl\1plaint Qgainl'll:. t.he DefendQntl'l nlleg.ing thAI: I\lIdrey Young wns :Injllrec\ .in a oolU,J3ion be\:ween her v~h.iole and Dot:FJIldantl3' I:]:notol: trQU,er, 1\ oopy of: the oompl,dnt. il3 Qt.tQohed I\S InxhibH "1\," 'I, '1'h8 Defendc\l\I:13 fUed an alwwor ,,11egin9 that I:he oollis1.on was oauaecl ,py the ool1iaion of: a traatOt" tl:aUer tlnd a oou: liirectly in front of: t:he Defendants' trual~, 1\ copy of the anawer .i.s attQohed as Inxhib.i.t "fl," ,0, The tractor trQiler 1.nvolved in said ooll1.aion Was owned by1\dditJ,onal pefendQnt DOIlQld Whitebread & Sona Qnd opm:c\ted by ita Qgant, servant and employee, David L, Mataka in the course of hia employment by 1\dtl.l tionul Defendant, !), 'l'he aLlt.omobile involved .in SQ1.d oo11:l.sion wal3 owned and operated by Additional Defendant N.i.kki Hench, lO, Sa.i.d co11il3ion occurr.ed as the Whitebread truck was traveling North on Interatat:e 01 at about 8tQtion Marker GO .in the left of three lanes, 'rhe Hench automobile was all30 tl:aveling North ,in the dght lane, Both drivers negl.igently and oarelessly attempted to enter the cent:er lane di.rectly in ft'ont of the Defendants' truck, A colliaion between the WhitebreQd truck and the Hanch Clutomobile caused Defendant Holland to take evasive aotion resulting in a collision with the PlaintJ.ffl3' vehicle, "'!T' I ~ I'. ..''P<. .~ .~ ! 'i \ " ii 'O, 101' ,,"i;dth!iifH,'''''';~~t!""_ " , ~ ~IlH~,.'T A \1 I, ,.'" <\"..'fhM,;, ',I ,;11 'i:~',IiH;,I-il4i:ii#-m-'M\!."t-\';l-i.t(Wi'Mi.~!!'\~if;f>-H"IM."fJ,~\~l)!';'A-f)H\I'.,tn;it~ii"~l~~"!"" .:"'.1",-"..', ---_ _ -,--.., _,-_ iP'II,"-i,"-! I j , ~ !j;IHti. '.~j;_'.-l= lil''',';'',i~ :" .",-,,-itL "~--"lt"-"''''; , -;-"=,.y~ '~I-'\"~"'- ,I' " " .' , .. " " <; " " '!' .IIi ,lI " ,V \I., " " ~ ,. , ;d' .' " ,I " 1-, " ,; " \1 " 0" Ii ", 01' ',-" ", " " " I' ;'- ,- ill; ,I " " I' ,-'; Ii' I' I' ", H I, ,I'" " " " 11, " II I'll " 'I ',!'-;';< " l' " ,,'\ ii .' Jj! , " oj " " i\ " " " '.' " " jl ;l H " , ", iii' I'i ,. d' " " .H 'I' II " 1< ,; " Ii i' " " " 1I " " '..,.. . "-.'t....... -..:,.' , " "" i i!j \,' L~ ,10 h" ,.1, "'1 " Ii ]', !j " , , .KH"'T' " \. , . '1.1."1 -j...,....'.i'I,..,'m......t'itM~i\on"fl(;,,'t'W;.-,w-~t;~.f "." " ,-, ii.... ' , "'",.v~"w,""'....,~ "-T" ~", -.,....',.....'-. ~,~"w_, ".,i'i<"",.'r_,C-. ,_, ",F, -H""~ ""..."""'" .-,' I 'l\ _Plr;,w'lrH~~;.i'" " " " 'j. " Ii " " " ", " " 1,1i " ,I' " 1.1 ',I " II " " !' " ;" "if, " 10 " 10 q, " " I, ,,' " ,,' 'i Ci <1:, " , If, " !, ,II " H I, " 'I ii " j! 'I, ;1; Ii' ,I" i< 'I' , to '~- . I ,- ti'l I ., " " , ~":J ,),,. , d f"I::_,j ,'" t,:I'" (1,; "f~ 'I. . t')~1 i j , . ,',., "':'r./i . !::~ , ! . , IUr.;,' f'-:J ~1 ' , -, ~,--. I' C'] i!'.:1 U (.;,,1 (,,', ,. " ,. II I' n ,. L ,. !i " i! " j, Ii .. " I' ,. ii " " it i! ,. I' " ,. ;, j);, " !1(1;' ,- !j" ;'. " ,- " !, " " I; H d! .. i ~ !; i; '. ,- ,- H ,. it -, " !' If! ','Il , , ". i'; -~ r";' " , .' ,. " l! i' " , , ,. , , ,. (V, ,,-; " (\.) ;;., 1,-; t,-; ] i:.~_:; , " ') r;': i l::., , ',~ ,"ill ,.,;;(t '(il",I, "J .l" :,~J (.,'J "I <'l; :") " I.,! I~ ;j i'OJ I::' " H J'I' " II i! " " '';' " , , i' " " .' II' I,P i< " !' t. ,- " " ".. 'i ,n ,',If,; ,- i; " J, !' " " ,- " " j; " ,,, ",Ii " (',I " .'- I' ,. " Hi I! 1,\' " " '\ i\ L " , \. ., ,- ,. ,1;:' , , ;;1' , " " ,I' " i" II ,I' ,. " I', ,. . ,.. " ,. " j! ., In tl: fl' (. ~ , .1 )' " ,. t;( , 1,1; ;'1(; I 111_ " ,Ii ,. it 'I I; " " " (( I; ill J; ;' 'j, " ,. II \ , '_,I I. ,II I ;' I' ';F , " ,. '1'" " " ,j ,,' ,. " !, " " ,. " '1'" '\ ,. !f " I'il " " I' H ~ \31 ~ r", ". "'i t1-, th,b (1'1 .~:J e;1': I' C) =l;; i' 1~ll '." aq t.):-._ Ft, '," u.. n~:! '" "I' f, ;:' 'J'i' r,r.) ," if q" .. . I ,J,-=1J t}111~! H' q'.IfE .. I .....l, bJ. ,:.. ;..;t I!r~ II. l~ (,) .~ C..:l l; ., .(' ,. ,. \,' " " HI! ,. j; ,. j, /, " I, " Ii (I " ,. .. 'Ii " ,,( ,. " H Ii " 'j d! " t," " " ;," " ,. ,. ,. I.), " " nl H,ll, 112, H\lgnl'lonl; I 'Il~.cnw CUllnly, I'ennsylvnlllll 1"1)42, Allolhel' IIvermunts 01' Ihls plIl'lIgrnph nl'e dun led, 5, penled, Allel' I'ensunllhle InvcsIlgnllon, Answering Ilelblldnnlls wlthollt s\lll1clenllnlhnnnllonlll' knowledgc with whleh 10 Ibnn II hellel'lIs tu Ihe Imth oftho IIvcrments lll'thls pnrngrnph lI\1d they 111'0 lIucunllngly denied, 6, Admitted, 7, Admit led In pllrl1l11l1 dUllled h) pnr\. Ills IIdl11l11ud Ihllt Iho dolbndllnts 1lI0d nn Anslvcl' IIl1egll1g lhlll tho eolllslon WIIS oll\lsed hy tlweulllslon 1ll'II1rnetol' tl'nller nnd enr dll'eelly In fl'unlol'lhe dolimdnnt's trllek; howevcl', It Is denle" thllt IIny oolllslon helweonnlrnotol' trnllol' nnd n 1lI11' onllsed nny other collision, fl, Admltlod, I), Admitted, HI, ^chnltled In plll'lnnd dunled In pnrt, Ills ndl11ltted Ihllt sllld collision between tho Irnclor trnller owned by Ilonllld Whltehl'clld &, Hons IInd the em'ownod IInd opernled by Nikki Ilonch oco\llTed ns tho snld trllelor trnller wns tmvcllng norlh onlntel'Hlllte flint IIbollt stlltlon Illnrker 60 In the lell of'three IlInes IInd lho Ilendllllltomohlle WIIS tmvullllg norlh In the right 111110, Ills denied Ilmt IInswerlng dclcmlllllt neted negligently 01' eurolessly InllllY I11l1nnel' whntsoeVCI', On Ihe eontrnry, IInswerlug defcndunt uetcd rcnsonuhly 1I0d Jll'lldL.nlly lindeI' Ihe eh'elllllslunees, Ills I\lrther denied Ihulnny collision helwecnlheunswerlng IIddltlonul dellllldunl's lrllek IInd the Ileneh nutolllohlle L'IIIlSed uny olhel' vehicle 10 luke eVIIslvc lIetlon, I', Denied, Ills donled unswerlng IIddltlolllll delcndnnl WIIS negligent or ellreless In uny Illllllllel' whuIs(l\)vcr, Onlho conll'l1l'Y, nnswerlng IIddlllonnl delcndunlueted reusonuhly IInd prlldently lindeI' Ihe eh'Clll11stlllloes, (1I)"(ll), DIJllled, On the conlrm'y, IInswcrltlg dcfcndllnt lIeled I'lJIIHonubly IInd pl'lldonlly lindeI' Ihe Oh'Clllllslllncl'H, 12. pOl1led, AIIIII' 1'0l1HIlIHlhlo Il1voHlllIl1lllll1, AI1Hworlllll llofcI1dll111 IH Wllhllll\ Hllmolol1t Il1lh\'l11l111111101' kl1llwlodl1o wllh whloh tll Ihl'l11 II hollol'lIH tn tlw 11'IIIh ol'tho I\VOn1\Ol1tH nl'lhlH plll'II111'1\ph III1lI Ihoy 111'0 1I001ll'dll1gly dOlllod, (lI).(oj, pOI1IO(I, ()Iltho cOllll'lIl'Y, III1HWOl'll1g dol~l1dllllt 1I0tolll'0llHOllllhly IIl1d pi'lIdlllllly 111\11,,1' Iho UII'CIII1\HIIIIlIJOH, WllHHHFOIW, pclcl1dlll1l dUllloH IIHlI PIIlII1I11I' IH ulllillcd 10.llldlll11UllIIIgllll1Hllhu l)ulcl1dl1l1tll1 thu 1111111111\1 Hpcclllllll, nt' 101l1\Y HI1I11lll'1110l1uy WI\lIIHOUVUI" 01' tollllul'uslol' CIlHtH IIl1d pl'llYH Ihlll.lllllumol11 he el1lol'ed 10 1l0lCIldl11ll'H lill'lll' IIlld I1gllllls1 Ihu 1'1111111111' IInd fhl' hlH oosls IIl1d IbuH IIl1d fhr HIICIt othor 1'0llul'IIH Ihu Clllll'l d00l11S IIpproprllllo, PIWIlND^N'I' PHMANDH TRIAl, I\Y .I\IRY, .NI~W MA'J''J'lm 13. Dululldllnl rusorV"H Ihu rlghllll ehllllongu III1Y IIwIIl'llol' llelllY dllll1l1gos 111 (his eIlHO. 1.1, Delul\lllln( donHllldH Ihllt IIpprnprllltc hCllrllIgH ho eomhlulcd ill this ellso prior to III1Y IIwllrd 01' de IllY dllll1l1l1eH, 15, Rlllo 2311ol'thu I'cnnHylvlIlIl1I l{uleH IlI'Clvlll'rnelllllll'c, ol111H Ihcc, IIl1d IIH IIpplled Is vlolllllvu of'the Dlle I'roeeHH IInd HquII\l'l'oleelloll elllUHeH ol'llto Fourleenth AIl10l1dll1el11 to Ihe ConHtltutlol1 ol'lhe Unlled HtllteH, * IlJll3 01''1'11104201' (ho !Jnlled HllItOH Clldo IInd Mllelu I, * I, 6, lll1nd 26 IInd Mllele V, * I O(e) ol'tho l'ennsylVlIlll1I CnnHtllutlnlllll\l1 hnpllsoH II ehllllllg ellcel olllhe exercise hy Delcndlln( ol'lIs eOllHlllullonll\ right H, 1 Ii. Home 01' 1111111'plll1Ulill'H elllhnH Il1I1Y he hl\l"red or 11111 II cd hy pllllntlll's selection ol'lltnlled tol'l optll111 lll'thelr IlIsUl'llnee eovorllge purHullnl (ll l'ellllsylvlIllllI MIltOI' Vohlele Flllllnellll ReHpollslhlllly J.IIW, 75 I'll, C,SA * 170 \ et Heq, 17, Addlllonlll dclclldllnt IIHHerls IIl1lhe delcnHeH. IhulllltlonH IInd exeluHlolIH ol'lhe l'ellnHylvlIlIl1I Mottll' Vehicle Fltulllellll ReHpnnHlhlllly I,IIW, 75 I'll, C,H.A, * 170 I et suq, IIl1d IIVerH lhllt pll1lntll1'I1I11Y nol pluml, provo, Il1lmduee 11110 evldellee or rceovcl' IIny hellellts pllld or plI~nblolll1l\O\' Iho 1'0nl1s~lvnl1lu Molo\' Vehlclo Fll1ullolnl Hcspol1slhlllly Lnw, Ills 1I1\'lhc\' nvorrod hy IIIldltllll1nl \lclcl1dlll1llhllt lhc plulllllll's CllllsC of'ncllol1ls bu\,\,od liS ulJulllsllllldl\lolllIl dclol1dullt pc\' IhoUppl'uprlUlO slUlulo ot'lhnhutlol1s ul1d tll\'lho\' Ihlll dolcl1dlll1l's cnusc nf'nctlllll 1lIJIlll1s1 nl\lIltlnl1lll Ilolol1l1ul1t hi hn1'l'cd h)' IhollPl'l"Ol'l'luto sllltlllo nl'lhnllullol1s liS woll, I H, I f' Ills doto\'l1lll1od Ihllllhoullswcrll1l1l1ddlllollul dclulldllllt Is IIl1hlo olllho 1'IIIII1\11l's Clll1S0 of'lIollull, tho uI1SWO\,11I1l uddhlulllll dolbl1dulll nvol's Ihut Iho plullllll1's \'l~COVLl\'y shul1ld hcclhllhllltod UI' I'odllcod Il1llocunlul1011 whh lho l'ulll1sylVlll1lu CUII1Plll'lltlve NOIJlhwl1uO Acl, 421'11, C,S,A, ~7102, 10, It Is 1Ill'lho\' uvo1'l'od Ihullt'lhol'lull1llll'slIllcl'od UI1~ Il\lurloshllllllullos UH ullolJcd, Ihoy WUl'oolll1suII suloly und p\'hnurlly hy thu 1'lllll1tll1's oWl1oUl'olussl1oss 111111 1l01J111Ju1WO, 20, It Is IIlrthc\' uvol'l'od hy thollnswo\'1111l dolclldlll1t lhllt If'plull1llll'HlIl1crmluI1Y 11\11Il'ios/dulllUlJllS us ullollod. suld plullllll1; hy lholr oUllduulllSSlll1llld tho r1s~ uf'lhosu IIl.lllrlowdul1llllJuS, WIIEIWFOHE, DulcIlduI11 dUlllos thull'llIll1llll'ls onllllod lu.ludlllllOl1ll1lJlllnsl tho . Dctcndul1l111 lhu 1I11l00\llt spooll1od, 111' IUIIIlY SIl\lluf'IllUIlOY WhlltHooVOI'. or In Illtorost Ill' oosts IIl1d p\'IIYS 1I1II1.ludlJl1lol1l ho ol1lo\'od 1I1IJ0lcIllllll11's IhvOI' lIud 1IIJIIII1sllho 1'11I111111l'lIlllllh\' his oosls IIl1d Icos IIlld Ihr SllOh ulhor rollot'us tho CUlIrl doo\lls uPI'I'Oprllllo, DEFENDANT DHMANDS TRIAL BY ,IlJRY, Nlm' MATTEHj'lIllSIIANT TO I'A, 1!J!"I', 2252((11 nJlmC'l'Im TO OIUGlNIlL I)Ji;FI';NJ)AN'J'S ANI) CO-AIlI>I'I'IONAI( IHWI':NI>AN'I' 21, l'urSlIlIll1 to tho provlslulls 01" I'll, ItC,I', 2252(d), IIllswol'lllllUddhlolllll dotcndullt IlSHOl'ls lhllt nrlgllllll dolulldullls uud/nr oU-llddhlulllIl dolclldullls 1\1'0 IIIUI10 IIl1hlo or .Iollltly IIl1d Hovcl'l\lIy IIlIhlo or IIlIhlo ovel'lo UIlSWOl'llllluddltlulllI1 dolclldullt UI1 tho OIlIlHO ol'uotloll doolurod 1I1'ollllllho C0ll1plllll11 hy plllll1tlllil, .. " " .. ,. ii' " II' " ,J1 .. .. q," " ,. ,i 'I' '!' ., " j, " ~.,,; ("1) .,.. /'1: lr;.. I" It F~: . (l~ j.. ... .. " '.' (:Jt;, " ( ii , C)!:t: e,',I! L't.. \:J ;;", If) "-~' {IJ " Ii ! .,Ii). I" "I' i ~,i' ',! fD " , ..,1; I , C:'J d t.J r":J " " ,. 'OJ' Ii " 'I " " ,. ;I> ",; " ;if " .. , ., " " 'I' " " " I'" 'i , " " ,., , I AUDRllY M, YOUNG I1IHl.It\Mlit'l YOUNG, PIII/11II f/a : IN TIIn COllRTOF COMMON PI,Ms . I CUrvWIlIU,ANI) COUNTY, PBNNSYLV ANIA 1', , , I CIVIL DIVISION WA YNIl 11, IIOI.LAND II III I HIGHWAY 1'RANRPORT, INo" , , I No, 99- 1256 I Dufol1dlll1ls , , I JURY TRIAL nliMANDIJD 1', DONAL\) WIIlTEllIWAf) & SONs, IIl1d NIKKI HENCH, Addlllolllll Dofol1dll111s, PLAINTIFFS' IUCSI'ONSIC '1'0 IHWICNUAN'J' . . ~LI> WIII'I'ICIllmAn & SONS.INC.'S /SICW MA'I"l'RL~ NOW COMES PIIIIIlIIf/ll Audroy M, Youllg IIl1d ,'mllos Youllg, hy IIl1d Ihrough thoh' nltornoys, Buehnl1l1l1ll1gorsoll I'rofosslol1l1l CorpOrllllol1, IIlld /ile lho wlthll1 Rospol1so 10 Now Mu110r liS follows: 13, No respollso Is requlrod ns nil IIwllrd ofdelny dlllllllgos hns 110t hoolll11l1do to dlllo Inlhls 111111101', 14, No l'OSI)(1I1S0 lorcqulrod liS 1111 IIwlIl'll of do IllY dnlllngcs hns 1101 hool1llllldo 10 dlllo Inthls I111111el', 15, Dellled, Tho IIVOrl110111s C0l111111led 111 Pnrllgl'llph 15 cOllslIIIllo oOl1oluslons of IlIw 10 whloh 110 rospollso Is rcqulrcd, To lho oXlolltll rospol1so Is roquh'cd. Iho 1I1'01'l1l0l1ts o0l11nlllod lnl'nrngrllph 15 nro donled, l.l'97.1 " 1 Cl, PUlllud, Thu III'Ol'lllUlllH \'n111111110d 1Ill'1I1'111lrllph I Cl cOIlHllil1lo cOlwhlHlllllH or IIIW III whlph IlO I'OHIH1llHU IH ruqlllrud, Tolhu \Jxlul1ll1 rUHI1I1llHU IH ruqlllrud, IIIH Hpuellhllll1Y dOlllul1 Ihlll "HoIlW nl' IIl1nl' 1'IIIIIllllrH OlllllllH I1HI~ Iw hlllTUlI or Ilmllud h)' 1'llIlllllff'lllliJlepllnllIll' lilllilud Inrt opllol1nl' Ihelr IIlHIII'I\IWU 11oVol'IIgo pllrHlIlIllllo l'ullllllyll'lIllll1 Mnlol' Vuhlelu Fllllll1ullIl ltoHpol1slhllllY I,IIW, 75 I'II,C,S,A, ~ 1'101 !!1 Hllil'" 1'/, pOlllod, Thu IIvunllUlllH Onl1tllllled 1Ill'IIrllgrllph I () eOllsll\lllo \lolwhlHlollH of IIIW 10 whloh 1l01'0llpOllSO ISl'uqHll'ud, Tolhu UXIUIlIII rOHllllllHe IH I'eqlllrod, 11I1(1111011111 f)ul'ol1dIl111 f)ol1l1ld Whltohrolld &. 1>0116, IIlC, 1'II11H 10 hlplllll'y which "dcl'oIlSUH, 1I111lilllloll6 IIlld oxulHsloll1l of tho 1'01l1lllylvIIIlIII Molor Vuhldu Flllllllellll HOHpllllHlhlllty Lllw" It IIIlHUrlH, 1'11I111t1rtiJ 111'0 IIllllhlo to IIS001'11I11lllllhls tlmo whllt hOllcl1tH 111'0 pllYllhlo Hllllor Iho 1'0111lHylvIIIlIII Molol' Vohlclo HospollslhllltV LIIW 1I11\IIhol'oforo dOily tho IIl1egllllollrollllcd thorolD, Ills Hpoolfioll\ly dOlllcd Ihllt Pl1111lllflH CIIUSO ol'lIotiolllH hlllTollllglIlllsllld\\Il1olllll dorul1\hml hy tho stlltUto or IIl11ltllllol1s, 1 R, Donloll. Thc IIvennonlll contnlncd In I'nrllgrllph 1 R COIlHlltulo cOl1olUslolls 01' Inw 10 \~hlch 110 I'CHpOnSO IH I'cqull'ed, To Ihc cXlcnln I'CHp0l1S0 iH l'eqHll'od, It IH spooll1clI\ly dOl1lod Ihllll'llIlntlrfs' 1'000 very shoHld he "olhnlnlllollol' I'Ullucod Innoool'lllllleo with tho l'el1nsylvllnlll COI1lPlIl'lIlll'o Nogllgellco Aet, 42 I'n, C,S,A, ~ 7102", 19, Donlod, Tho IIVOl'monts conllllned Inl'lIl'11gmph 10 constltule oonchllllonll orlllw to whleh nOl'esponlle ISl'oqull'od, Tolhe exlcnt III'OHpOnSe IH roqull'od, It IH spooll1clI\ly dOlllcd thllt 1'llIlnllff8' InJurlos woro "enusod solely IInd prllllllrlly hy tho 1'IIIIntirrs own 11lIrolessnosH IInd llCgllgcncc," :7.0, Denim\. Thc l\Vonnonts contlllnod in Plll'ng1'llph 20 oOllslllllto oOllolllSlollS or IIIW 10 which no I'OllpOllSC ISl'oqllll'cd, To Iho oxtont n I'osponso iSl'oquil'od, It Is Hpoolfloll\ly dOllied Ihut !'llIlnUrfs UHHIIlllel1 the r1Hk 01'111011' IqlmleH/dnll1l1goH, 2 H 'j; '" c' I ',. (I' ('"j (", d' .' , t,'}) 'I .'1" " , , , i'!,ll .~ , , if : l. ) :;,.I~ : , f.l. , I ") ;~'_', " , , , , , (1;1' '.; ~~.~~ 1,'-,; j'!;L.. ! '. 1,1(1,)' , ; , "! ,(l. " I ".i ~'~i , , I .i II, , , 1::/ () j:' '" Ii q " "' ,: " 11' II " ., I'; " j' .. , " " " 1/ " j; L ,. ,/. " j, " ,(, " " I' '1 \, ,. 1"1 ,. "d. i' ;,' '., " j. ", \1, , ); ,. " " I (I, l1ul1l1)(1. TIWII\'UI"IllUI1IA uOl1ll1lncd III i'l1rllgmph I h lJonAlltnlc lillllChlAlnnA or IlIw In which no rCApnl1AU IA rCIIlIlrcd, Tnlllu u~IUI11 II ruspnl1AIJ IA ruql1lrud, II IA Apccllkl1lly llunlul\ Ihlll "AOl1lU 01'1111 ol'l'll1l11III'1'A cllll1nA 11111Y hu hmru\lor Ihnltud hy 1'I111nlll'l'A Aultlcllol1 pl'lhnltcl\ Inrlopllnn or Ihulr InA\lrIlI1CC 11lll'pr11gu p\ll'AI1 II 11 I In i'UI1I1Aylvllnlll Molor VPhlclo Flnllnullll H\lsponAlhlllty I,IIW, 75 1'11,( ',fI,^, ~ 17ll I ~l H~H," 17, punlml. Thu IIl'u1'l11\111IA unl1ll1lncl\ III I'lImgmph I () 110nslltllto conchlAlnnA or IlIw 10 whluh no rOApOnAC IA ruqlllrud, Tnlho uxlllnlll rUApOI1AO IA rcqulrod, 1\III\Itlol1111 D\ll\Jl1dllnl Pnlll1ld WhltohrulIl\ & flOI1A, hlll, 1\1118 101dUI1III'y whluh "dcI'0I18C8, 111111111110118 I1l1d cxuluAl0118 or Iho I'Pl1nHylvllnl1l Molor Vuhlclu 1>'I\1I\1IcIIII HUHplll1AlhllllY LIIW"I1I1HAllrI8, 1'IIIInlll"lil IIrc IInllhlu 10 IIHcurllllllll1 this 111110 whllt hUl1ulitA IIru pllYllhlu IIl1dcr Ihu 1'011118ylvllnll\ Molor Vohlclu l{cspol1Hlhlllty Lnw 1111\1 thcrclhrc dUllY Ihu IIl1ugllilol1 rcllltcd \l1\Irulo, It IH Hpocll1clllly l\ol1lud Ihnll'lnll1til"l'H cnllRU ol'lIlJtiol1ls bnrrud I1gnll1st mldl\llll1nl dlll\J1\I11I111 by Ihll Alnluto ol'lIl11lln\lol1A, I R, DUl11ml. Tho nVUnl1Ul1tA cOl1lnll1od 111 i'lImgrllph 1 R cOI1A\lllIlo c0l1chl8111I1A or IIIW tn which 110 rOSpOI1AC IA roqlllrcd, To Ihu uxlul1ln 1'l1Hplll1AC IA rcqulrod, IliA ApOc\liClllly dCl1lcII Ihnl 1'IIlII1tll"l'H' rccol'ury Ahould hc "11lhllhullllll or rcduccd Il1l1CCo\'lllll1CU with Iho l'ul\l1Hylvnl1ln Clll11pllrlltivc Nogllgul1cu ^Ct, 42 I'll, C,fl,^, Ii 7102", 19, DOl1lod, Thc nl'orlllCl1tA c0l1lnll1mll11 I'lIrllgrllph 1\) cOI1Alltlllo COI1CllIHlOI1A or Inw 10 whhlh 110 rCAplll1HO IA rcqlllrcd, To tho uxlUl1l11 r08pol1AO IA rcqlllrod, It IH Apocll1olllly dCl1lO1I thllll'lllll1til"l'H' II1.1l1r1oH wcrc "olluHml Hololy IIl1d prlll1nrlly hy Ihu 1'IIIIulllrn OWI1 cmcloHHI108R IIl1d l1ogllgol1co, " 20, DUl11cd, Tho II1'0n1\c111H C0l11111l1cd 111 i'lImgml'h 2ll C0l181111110 C0l10hlHlol1A Ill' Inw III whloh uo rOHpnl180 18 requlrod, To Iho oxt0l1l11 rCHpOI1AO IH requlrcd, It Is 8pccll1clllly dOl1lod Ihnll'llIll1lll"1il lI8H\1Illcd Iho r18k orlholr lu.lllrlc8/dlll1l11gcA, 2 W'lfrl~IW()IW, PIIIII1II nil rp~llOPlnlllY rUIIlluSllllls CI1\11'I Pll1ur .I11\1~I1WI1II1I.lI1II1~1 f)pl\Jll1ll1l1t<< 1Il11lll1lh\'Pr Ilf' PllIll1linll 11I111g1'11l11 ~lIuh I\lrllwl' rl'lluf' liS II Iloum~ nppmpl'llIlp, IHJCIIANt\N INClI1HSOIA.. IWJFI.!SSIONA I, COHPOHt\TIClN ~~ ~\;'I;:'~~;~~~ ,/ ,I,ll h2076 . flluplwl1 Mlll1lnk. Esqllll'u . f,p, II!lOO:l5 . ~ 1:1 Mnl'kul S\1'90\. .1,<1 Floor Ilnl'l'ish\ll'g, PA 17101 '(717) 237.4800 Allo\'lloys (hI' Plllln\ll'l's Alldroy 111111 ,Inmos YQllng AIIgIIs('Z, ~ 2000 " I." " t. rl' I! , " " ;. " I' " ,. ,. ,; :1 !J)MM1?N\:\'!itll:1'! L!lFJ'ENN1iYLYi\NL'\ (VPNTYPH;VM III iBL A.N l~ A 1I1l l\IIY N, YO\lNll VB I I HAYNll l~ t 1I01,1.ANll ~ IIHllI\vAY 'l'I\ANfJl'lll\'l' Ii'\' A'. I'lIn ~r,,__jl9" l~ 56_......_~.._....,_ SL'IlI'OENA TO ~BODUCH,POCUMnNTS OR 11'1IN.r.ili FO lLI2I S CO.Yli R Y I' U I\S tJllliT_TO IW IJi.'!QQ.?,172 TOI .. ClIS'l'OlllAN Oll l\liCOIlIlB lI01l1 S'l'UAl\'I' A, lIAl\'\'NAN, Il,O, o-------~..-.------.--..---(N"lllr!lf ";';;',, (II Enlllr) .._-~---- ~~'i~;II:: 'wonl)' pOI '~'YI ~h.r '::~C~~I,~I~..~~~!:'~~~iili'~_Nr'I~~~Ht~,~~~.'~~"-~:~~'~:~"dll~~ Ilw (nllowlng dl1l!1l1no",. ul ------_._----~_._-_._-~ _.__._-~+_.~..._----------- " .. HQS..J.llilll1P....JJ'IQ.LL.l.f!.O 1 flAIU{E'l' !ll~lIili'\', /I BOO, I'IIlLt\llIiLl'lIlA I I'A 1910J IAcldrcul )'011 In')' ,1'"\"1 or 111.1I1."blo cupl.. of Iho doclIl11o"l. UI pludllCO IhII1U' roqllC5,.d 11)' Ihls '11111'0'''', 10g.'h.r wllh Iho "111(1",. of cOll1pll.nco, 10 Iho 1'''1)' 111"Klng Ihl. roqllC51 ,11 tho "ddro", Ilfi1o,l .hUI", )'uu h.l'o Iho rluhl 10 ,o.k, I" .,I\"nco, Iholo..nn."lo ro'l o( ploparlng Ih. coplo. ur I'luduclng Iho Ihlnu. .uughl, I( )'nu (.1110 produce Ih~ dO~\lmon'. or Ihll1g. roqulr.d by Ihl. ,"l1l'oona, II'lIhln 111'0111)' (;!O) d.)', '(10' lIS 'Cll'lro, Ih. 1"''')' '''I'lng Ihl. .ul1l'uon. In')" ...k. rour' ordol cOl11l'olllnn )'l1\llu cOI11I'I)' wllh II, THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT nlE HEQUEST OF THH FOLLO\\l~G I'ERSO~I NAMH: ~J(\lltLA~'ITATLEIh...lli~L-_ ADDltHSSI J~O Nt\HKI,T S'l'l\lili'l', 1'0 1l0X.._I2C~, -1IAIUU!lIl.lllillLflLll!9lL,_~--,-._ TELHpHONEI (215) 2110.,0900 .........,_,___ 5Ul'IlEMH COUnT ID ~I A1TOllNEY Fon: ""IILDlillEN.llI\ltC DATE: 09/16/2000 41' .;J,5 ~~~- Ill' T1~CoJ.1nTI J.'~( '1&A' R: ~~" r~'I1..u'uy/C1 .C'I'II Oll'hl.. - ~;'~t:L /~ ~A~ .f}~ ~' Dtpllly Senl of Iho Court (El(, 7/97) !< ',. If' ~ " n: '~'( ,,' ri~ I~" " U., r.~ ~... (',i ;-S \'.':,', :,\,: (.)~~ <I,.; I'. t: .:, ~ C!~:.. .. (,~;, I" I /. ", ,.,. "'1'[/ I:" N "'{JII I' . IJI 1 PI ~. f"l', (i. f ,~; 'I ,J1U~ .., l''' c':,,! ,- J t!.~ Q ,. I, " I," " H " " q Ii ,. " 1-'" Ii " If, " I' ii " ,. i, " " II' " d,', " I,~ I j "i, '" It II /! I' " I' " '1' " i!\ !< hjf " " , I; i< " .1 ., Ii " " ,. " i' r I' ;,", " H \! il! " ',; d' Ii " !I ;! " Ii " ','.I' \l ,,, " , ., dH' " ,.' ii' ,. ,II " ''! I' II' ,. ,. " I'" " ;.- ,I'; ,I' I, '., I' Hj q " .' " II ," 'I,' Ii ,. I , I I i I I I , " i ,. " ,. I, " I" " , ('; \ I . , . , if (', I:" " ,~ , , . , ,'1: :,;! ,"\ .. .' I),. ~ I; I ,I'IP 'I , fjl I.", , :'" I'J " '-f j' "" f! " " "q " ;. ;' " 01 " I.. " I. " '1 .," il< "~II' If , . ." .. " " H ,. I' 'L ,. I, " ;! " I' ,," II. I' \, " ,. , , ," , " " " ",. I' ,.1 I;, " , . , ,i f~1 ,. " ,.' " I' ;j' " (" i' ,) ,!' " , ,. " ,:' "ii'.-1!;;"""-''-' , .. ,-, ,,1'; .' ;' I' " I' ,. " M;d I),w OI'l'Il:1' UI' IvIll:IIt\I\lI, IIAN!'T ^rIUIINI'~'~ I" C",UNSI'I.I.11IIS M I.AW 1'\ Illill,'lI;Wllll!> I\VINIII sl"d Illll C"'II"I, 1'^ 17111:l.I)H~ 71',,~II',,~:I?\ 1 ,IX 'II.,,;M",(N~'I WWW.IIMIIII.III.IJIlM.l:m... I' " 4~.;r_,-., "":'!dl,,,' ;' " " " I' "L ,. , .. " " " ,. 'j; " I' I; ji " ;; ,. ''-' " " .\ " fi " It" , i', '.:~,: ','.I " l"!! 1,,( (1 ' '" ".":',1 '~'-/'>' !1:;,;; ;)1'1:1 if+. I'" .~'~ C,.> ,I i'tl , ;r, Ii', .\,1, ',-' .I' !! \, " " " HII' II " ". i' " , ,. " I' ";I' " " " ,- !' ".'11 " ,. w I'" ii' ,. , , " , , '" ., I' " " ;1 ,. I, ,. :, '\ , , n " I,' H ~,. - (f'; j'" ,,' , , 'I: I {II: 1\ 11\ I, '. ' ,. (', " \.(" ~',' II' t ,< , J.r ( 'J~) ,01".-" 'I:'" ''','I;Li i' ~'. ,/, ,"I>~j i("'-' '.Il!'l) :ho:. cI o (".1 'f:11 .-.' 4..,~ C,) " " " j I' 'I '; " ;i ,_"\ (Ii " I." " " " , ." " " " ..,< " " ,. 'I " I,' c I'll " I, " , ,. ,. I " '1\ '; " " ,. ',i .. ~)JI)It'I'II"ICA'I'IO ()Ii' HI'lHY.I(!IG . I, JnY"l1n H, WolfiJIlIllJ, HSlllllro, oorllly lhnll nllllhlH IIny "OrVlllllll pnllY nftlw fnrpllllhlll 111l1llllllllnl \1111111 tlw pprsllns 111l1l0nlo Iwlnw hy I1nlloll 8111los Mnll, pnsllIllo Pl'oplIlll, Ora! IlhlSS, 'yhloh "orvlpo slIlisOos Iho rOll\llronWnlB nl'lho ponnsylvnnln R\llos nfClvl1 PIOPOll\lrll1 ,John A, Slnlior, 11"'1\1110 anhlhol!!, KIII~lllnn &. Shlpnllln ~;w Hn"l Mnrkol Slront Sll'I\whol'l'y'Sllnnl'o IlnlTlshm!!, PA 17101 Hownnl'), Kn\lmllnn, ESlllllro Jnhn aornld I)ovlln &. ASBnolnto", 1',0, 1 DO PI no Slroot, Snllo 260 . Hnrr/shlll'l!, PA 17101 WIIIlllmA, Addnills, JJslllllrp . '"lilY Oflloo" nfMI\lhnol.l, 11111I0 19 Urnokwotlll A WI1\lP, 8111\0 106 Cnrllalo, JlA 11013 '. ,. DA TEl Novomhor 29, 2001 1. " , I .. " " " 'I, '., fr; "; 11,1'i t.'!" ., . L " I.' , ( r ,\ '.. ! ". C/ I. if" " ,..., \'" I,t!, ..... ~!~ ~1... ~.. h ,'i.. 'I"II,:~ I",.,;." l.,)p: I~~)~i ;:",(;~ ,1 :~i;, Ifil':)' 111ft; , ;j r.~? C::;:t ("" ~.... "':..1 -" ... c;:, .. 'j, '" i' " H " " I' " " , .. " ,,, i' " II q, 'j, it' .,' " H ,. J' '.i 1,1' " H ,. " 'j; " ,. " H " " ,. H " 1'1i " II; " ,. ;" ,. .. H p iI " " , ,H " j) ! ~ j; I'. ii' ,. ,. ,. H " 1\ H ,'" ;I' Ii " i,j Ii ,. " " ii' I! Ii it, f' 1\ " " " I' " I; ,. !' il ;, " " If lj " " 1 , , , , " ,. II' i< ,. ., ,. " , -.~