HomeMy WebLinkAbout99-01308
...,
~
\
It .
~ "-...
~ "'\
\
I
}
,;
.I
/
/
I
~. r'~
;'
I,
Ii,
"
".
,/
H
'.
1\
"
.',;
I'
I(
"
,,"
/,
i'
"
'il
I, "
'i.
i,
i;
I'
II
"I'
"
I
;,
i'
,I
;'1,
j,H
I'
,.
H
f'
"
"
i!
,. i/
;j'
"
Ii
it
'"
q
"-1.
H'
I;
I. "
"
j.
"
i,"
H
ji
"
",
1\
"l
",~""'~'tWltt'Tl"
_n'H'l'_~\\"" 'H
,.
Ii
"
"
,
;,
'".
q'"
i!
!l.
"
"
h
H
" II
"
"
,.
"
"j,
',',1'
"
I'.
ii'
j,
'l
q
Ij'
Ii
"-j
ii
"Ii
Ii
.,
"
"
',I'
;;
"
II
"
"
I'
Ii
"
"
Ii
,Ii
"
I"
')!
,
i'
if
"
"
,.
H;
"
j,
i'I,I,
"
}! "\
<j,
j!
!I
I,
I'
(1
!!
I!
"
Ii
"
_n.._~_--................._".......~
-,",p,,,n_
;,
,.
"
j(
"
H
"
"
"
"
!,
'-b .(~
r'~
I::. l.-
s! ~
J ~
H: '-~. ~.
ct -j ~Q;
~- -It ~. \
~ 'q t
q"- ~ l-i J
i.I, ;
"
" " . ~ '
,
,.
,.
I' "
, I',
I", ,."
"
., i
"i'
q,
"
J
,
J
J
, j
I~ ' ~
. 1:1
J~,~
P iJ:
~~,
t'J."=:'t
~
,~ ' 2'~ ~
.1:1 ~ .~~R .
J "I I
8
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :@
~
~,~~~ ~
;.,
~
"
,. .i
,
,.
"
.,
I'
n
.... .'
"- ......'+.~.~.:_. ....". '''rr-T.-~___~," ".;.Il_o._. ,-..,,_,~ .__.._ .. _ _ ,~~'"." '_"n___
.1
1
I'
ClIllRTllH '/., 1I0/1I1A,
PlnlmllT
"
~- n'"-""~_h_"_""""",,,_
I IN TIIIl COUH'l' OF COMMON 111,IWI
: ClIMnll\ll,^NU ('()IIN'I'Y, PIlNNMYJ,y ANIA
y,
,
,
I NO,I 00-130!l
,
JONUR MOToH COMPANY, lNc:,
llofomlnnt
,
,
: CIVil, ACTION - I,A W
l!RAECIl'I~ TO lUCINS'I'I\.TlLWIU'I' Ol~ I'UMMONI.i
'1'0 Tim I'HO'I'IIONO'I'AltVt
I<lmlly rlllnstllto tho Wrllllf Summons Issuod on Mnrch S, 1000.
PU'I'mtS {It. w Mm,I1J1SKI
DlIlol r/$'11'
BYI _
/Jnmo. . GnrYol -Lsqulro,
UtI mIll)' J.D. 11711030
2031 North [11'0111 Strool
Hnl'l'lshurg, POlllls)'IYnllln 17110
717-2311.7SSS
Morlloy fill' Plnllltlff
,.
"
, il
"
"
"
"
.1'
!<,
;, --,
i.-'
r; Cf) t
~..; -it
" 1'\1, l~:i ~ .
r:'-' ('ll::L
'" i.~:) ::;, "
'\\< it I
C\ ;:1
1,;\ , 'I'to
r.el "t' )
(~L, I "II,(,
'-r. .....il
l~ 'I' r:':;; It) if!
1.;., (.L..
r ,? .
..... .',
IJ. (;1'\ :.J
.' tf1 (.l
I'
'I'
ldl
IJ I ~
~ ,} ~ E
III q II
HII.
"
,,"---..,.
~J
'1'"
II"
;",l
I,,;
("
t":' "
r1= I,'
c~~;
fl.".1.
nil
[,I, '
l-.
\\
II' i1
I.
II.
(.\
C~l
"1'(
;l"~"
.,:
I....
\f.1
,
,.-
L'-,
l.O
g:)"
!I
,.
,.
\1"
I."
,-..
:--"'1"
":1.,
1',',);:1.
(\'/j
,(:,';;:';
H I f~ f:l
(ti~"1
'1-llrt;
/j
,
,,'
,!
"
';",
,;
"
Ii
"
"
I"
"
'"';,
'I
I
.'
"
"J"
"
."i
I;
'j;
.'
"
I' "
..
"
"j,
'!i
I;
..
"
"
H
,.
"
jj
"
"j I!
""
,,,
"
I'
"
"
"
,/
"
,.
,.
".
" , ,.
, ."
, n
"
, ;.,
,.
"
"
II
"
"
,.
"
,J
,I:
I!xhlbll A
r""'\
~
"
,.
'I'
"
,.
"
"
.' j,
"
"
,.
"
"
"
"q
'!,
"
,.
"
"I
..
"
"
"
II
"
H
"I'
',h
"
"
,Ji
"
,.
, ,,J r'
"
Ii
"
i.U'
ji
"
'f
"
Ch~llter !luson v, Jonos Motor Cll"lnc,
8,8, ) 1.\-J2-13511
Clllhn
111l1lo)
FINUINW, Oft' FACT:
I, PurulIlInl\o Iho stlpnllllion un Jurlu(lIollon (fl-I), tho p"rtlos litlpulllled thnllho olnll11l1l1l'a
ellllm pelitionls Ilovcmod by Iho prnvllllona of tho Pellllsylvllllln Workors' Componslllloll
Act, IIllllmendod,
2, 1'1Irsnllnllo tho slnlomOll1 of wlIgos (0, I), liS of Deeombor 2, 1996, tho olnlmun\ hlld nn
nvorllgo woekly WIIIlO of $677,)5, olltltllnll him to II lomporlll)' tollll dlsnbllhy mlo of
$45\.1 t.
), Tho olllhl1nll\ tostlfiod In support of tho olnll11 petition nl tho henrhlll before Ihls Judge on
July 29, 1997, Tho Olllll11l1n\ loslllled thlll on Deoel11bor 2, 1996, ho Willi InJurod whon n
4x4 Ulld tho wolght of n trnok 0111110 down Oil hill len 1'001, Tho ollllmnnt ollllod his
dlsput(lhel' IIl1d wus tllken 1\1 1111 IIl11bulllllCO In 13nlllll1oro, MD, '1110 olnhnnnt workod Ihlht
duty f1'o1l1 Deccmher 3, 1996 through Decembor 17, 1996, On Docembol' 18, 1996, the
clnln1Pllt slllrled drlvlllg IIgoln, The \3ll1ll11l1nt testWed thllt his fOOl hurt while driving,
4, Tho cllllmnn\ thrlher testllled thllt ho coni Inned 10 drlvo for the employer until he WIIS
tennlnntod effootlve Mllroh 10, 1997, The Olllhl1l1nl leslllled thllt he WIIS Ilred hy Jim
Rich on Muroh 12, 1997, The Clllhl1l1l1t tostlfied thol when he Wos fired ho oontlllued to
huvo nUlllbness III his foot, coldlless, 1\I1l1lnorellsed pllln with wlllklllllond 1I0tlvltles,
5, The olnhnnnt l\lrther tostllled thot ho heglln trelltlng with II Dr, Bolonkln on Morch 4,
1997, Clnhllllllllestlfied thot he continues to trellt with Dr, Ilolonkln lI!ld oontlnues to
huve problems wllh his foot, The ellllll\lInt testllled Ihllt Dr, Bl1lonldn ndvlsed him 10
\York III his own discretion,
6, The oluhnnl1t 1\II'Ihor testltled lhllt 011 April 18, 11)97, he I'Qtumed to work liS II tnlCk
drlvor, The olllll11l1nttostlnod thot he quit lhllt Joh so he oould go see II doctor, Instend of
Inking II lond to Colorndo,
7, The olllhnnntl\lIlher testltled thnt he obtlllned II new truok driving position with Templo
Trucking on MIIY 13, 1997, Tho elllhnllnltestlfied llllltthls pllld $485,00 per week, The
olull11l1nt testltled tlmt ho quit on June 25, 1997 becnuse the truck did not hllvc IIII'
condltloulng. The clnlmllnl testllled. thllt liS of the July 29, 1997 heuring, he \VIIS
cun'enlly unolllployed,
H, In Illrther supporlof the petltlou, the Olllll11l1nt presented the Mllrch 21, 1997 lenulnntlon
letter Ihlm the elnployel', Till! termlnlltlon lellor Indlcntes lhllt tho olull11l1nt \Vns
lennlnllled effective Mnrch 10, 1997, No rellson 1\11' lerrnlnlltlonls given in the Mllrch 21.
- -p _.~-
.. - ~ - - .- . ....... '
Chu81ur !lusull v, JUI1US Motor cu" Il1u,
S,S. 3 I 4-U-1 350
Clllhn
PIIg\l.1
1997 leller,
9. 111 I\lrthcf Sl1pporl of tlw pUllllol1, tho Ulllll1111111 presunled his WIIl!e doeunlllntllllol1 for his
purimls ofemploynwntsll1uu Mllreh 10,1997,
10, From April 17, 1997 IhnlUl!h April 23, 1997, the clllhnlllll WIIS employed by ItII1UM
Trlll1sport. Th\l elllhllll11\ worked two weuks, The ulnlollH\1 ullmud $200,00 Ihe Ilrst wuuk
IInd $406,15 thu seclll1d wuuk.
II, Frllm MIlY II, 1997 throul!h Juno 24, 1997, the 011llmll111 WIIS ell1ployed by Temple
Tnlllklng. Dllrlnglhe soven weeks of ull1ploymu11\. the ollllmllnl ellmud $270,00 Ihu Ilrst
weuk. $fI85.00 Ihu suo0l1d wuuk' $388,00 tho third WOllk, $485,00 tho fonrth woek.
$485,00 the noh week, $485,00 the slxlh week,lInd $194,00 tlllll1nlll week,
12. Froll1 Novemhur II, 1997 throul!h Deoemher 26, 1997, Ihe elllhlllll1t workell for COllst
Midwest Tnl11sporl, The ollllll1l1l1t eurnud u tollll of $3,351,1 H durll1g this Ih1\u period.
The olllhnllnl ellmed $478,110 the Ilrst week, $662,10 the soool1d week, $40H.48tho third
wcek. $680,30 the fOl1rth week, $601.10 tho fifth week, lIud $519,40 the Ilnn1 week,
13, In l\1rlher support of tho petltlOI1. the Olllhl1l1nt prescnted thc dcposltlol1tcstlmuny of Dr,
Bolonkln. Dr, Bolonkln tcstlllcd Ilmt he Ilrst IlXlIl11il1cd Ihe Olllhl1l1nton Muroh 4. 1991.
Dr, Bolonkln tcstllled Ihllt Ihc olnhlllllll eOll1pllllncd of perslslcl1t numbncss unll
dlscol11 1'011 In the forefoot IIrcllof thelcl\ lhol. Ills oXlIl11lnllllol1 rcvulllcd II 2 em bmlso 011
thu dorsul11 of tho 101\ Ihol. IIppllrel11 hCl1ll1lOl11uupproxhl1ulely 1/2 of tho Icft hullux 111111
oflho 101\ Ihol. IIl1d mild edelllU, Dr. Bolunkll1 testllied thllt ulherwlsc, his OXlIlI1ll1l1tlon of
the olulmnnt WIIS nonnul, Dr, Bolonkln oplncd thlltthe eluhnnllt \VIIS suffering Irom n soil
tlssuc Injury with probllhly cmsh Injury to pcrlphernlnervcs ofthclcll foot, Dr, Bolonkln
restrlctcd tllll olllhnllllt to nn driving, Ice, olevutinn. nnd rccommcllded tho usc of Z081rix
erCllm, On Mllrch 14, 1997, Ihe clnlmllllt hlld the SlImc l1ndlngs with n Iittlc hit of
Improvemont, The snmo restrlollons IIlld rcoollllncndntlolls \Vere lIludc, Dr, Ilolonkln
tcstll1ed thnt he exnmlnud thc ollllmnnt every two wceks, Dr, Ilolollkln IOstll1ed thllt he
IlIst CXIIIl1lned the ollllmllnl on Soptemher 19, 1997, AI thllt lime, the ollllmllllt \VIIS
compllllnlng of numhncss, ooldlloss. IInd pnln with Ilctlvlty III his lell foot, Dr, Ilolonkln
oplllcd thnt Iho olnhnnnt WIIS sul'liJrll1g from Ilcuwpnthy In Ihe dlstnl nspel:1 of the
sllperl1elnl pcrlphornl nnd perhllps plnn\l1r nerves of the lell tbo\, Dr, Bolonkll1tcstll1od
thllt the cluhnllnt hns not 1\1 II y recovorcd Ill' rcuolwd l11uxlmummedlollllll1pwvomcl1t, Dr.
Bolol1kln tcstil1cd thlll the olnhnnnt's oomplllll1ts ns of Septcmbcr 19, 1997 wcre
subJcotivc. Dr, Bolonldn toslllled 1111\1 tho c1l1lrnllnt's Ilollvitles should continuc to be
reslrlctcd, Dr, llolonkln lIl:knowledgcd thul liS of I\prll II, 1997, he Indlcutcd In his
modlclIll'ecords tlllltlhc clultullnt should soon be IIblclo rctumto work liS n truck driver,
..--...--.. .~~
CI\U~lur Iln~ulI v, .hmos MOlor en" Ino,
S,S, .114.)2.1350
Clllh11
PlIlIU 5
14, In nppnsillon tn tho potitlnn, thu elllplnyer presented the te~tllHol1Y of Sootl FlsllUr, Mr,
Fisher WI1~ the clllhnnlll's 1HIII1I1g11r, Mr, Fisher testltllld thllt hu oOlltllcled thu clnlll1l1n\ on
Of IIhnll! Mnrch Ill, 1 <J97 nnd IIsked Ihe IIlnh11l1nl to Il\ko II Inlld Irom Ll\nonHtor, Ohio to
Mcohnnlosburg, Pn, Mr, Flshor loslltlod thnllho Cllllmnl1\ WIIS rulllctnnt 10 luke the lond
slncc It did not olTer enO\wh IHllengu, Mr, Fisher teatltlod thn! the olllltnllnt did lnke the
lond IInd bring tho InOlI Ihll11 LIIIH1n~tuI, oh, to Meohnlllcabnrg, Pn. Upon nrrlvnl In
Meohnnloshurg, PII., the olnlmllnt's tn,ok Wus In for survlolng, Mr, Flshor liS lIed Ihe
olnlmllnt to slip aontlnto IInnll\Ur IInit 1III\III\ke II 10lld to Mnrylund. Mr, Fhlhor testified
thnt the olullHullt rot\tsod to slip seut und tuku tho loud In Mllrylnnd, Mr. Fisher lestlfied
Ihul he dl111S nnl know If the olllllnnnl evnr took thu 10lld tn Mllryllln(l, Mr, Flaher testlfind
tlmt on Muroh II, 1997, the elulmnntlldvl~cd him tllllt hl~ Ibot wns II 1It110 sore, Mr,
Fisher teatified thnlthe events on Mureh 10, 1997 nr Mnreh II, 1997 hlld 110thlll(J to do
wllh the olulmnnt's Icnnlnlltlon,
15, In l\lrther opposition to the pelitlon, the elHployer presented Ihe deposition tesllmony of
PI', I.evlne, PI'. Levine testified tlllll he eOllld not give nn opinion to II reusonnhle degree
of medloul e(lrtulnlY ns to the olult11ui1l'S condition prior 10 Septemher 22, 1997, Dr,
Levine tesllficd thnt the olulmnnt cornpllllnod ofpnlnund discomfort mdlutlng Ihrollgh his
len forelllllt, Dr, Levine tC~llflcd Ihut his oxnl11lnntlon of thu ellllll1l1l1t reveulcd II tlnullng
~enSllllol1 whcn ho compressed the eOlllmon dlgltul nerve npon p"lpllllon of the left
1'01'01'001 bet\Veen tho third IInd forth too, Dr, Levine opined thllt the olnlmunt \Vns
slIITerlng f)'om u stntlls pOSI lIellle cnl~h h\llIl)' or n plnuhcd nerve, nellrollln, conalstent.
with the Pecemher 2, 1996 Injury, Dr, Llwlne testlf1ed thllt tho clnll11nnt hilS renehcll
I11l1xlmllll1 mcdlclIl hllprOVOIl111nt nnd the elnhnunt's hllUl)' dnes not ohllnge his IIhllllY to
fnnctlon hilt mcrely prodllcos n tingling sllnslltlon, Dr, Levine opined thnt the elnlll1l1nt
could return to work with no hnpnlrmont nnd 1\111 cU(lnbllltlcs,
16, Thc clnll110nl hilS n 20% lbe ngrcel11cnl with the Inw 111'111 of (leters & Wnsllcfakt.
17, Thc eluil11nnt hilS Incurred Iltlgl\tlon costs In the IImounlof $256,90,
\ H, The elnlll1nnlnnd/or cluhnnnl's counsel did not snhmlt n 'lunntnmmenllt exhibit,
II), I IIcee(l1 liS persuuslvo, the testll110ny of thc clnlmlln\' Tho cllllmllnt's testllllony, thnt he
sulfcred IIn InJUI)' to his Icn Ibol on Deeemher 2, 1996, WIIS term hInted by tho el1lployer
effective Mllreh Ill, 1997, lInd contlnucd to hnve pl'Ohlellla IInd restrict lOlls liS n resull of
his Icn font In.lmy liS of Mnrch \ 0, \9971s supported by nil of tll(l evidence nnd testimony
of record, Mr, Flslwr IIcknowledged thlltthe clllhnllnt eOl1lpllllned of problems with hla
len IIllJ\' MI', Fisher lIeknowledged thlll thc Incldenl he tostllled to hlld nOlhlng to do with
wh\' Ihe dnlml1lll WllS tennlnllted, Both doelors, Dr, 1l11lonkln lInd Dr, Levlue, testltled
Ihllllhe Olllll1lllnt slIstulned IIU luJmy on Deccmber 2. I'JI)(i lIud contlnucs tll hllve
. . : ~ ~ : ~~; .;:-:- ~ ++-
Chester Ilosen v, .Iolles Mntnr Cn" Iiw.
S,S, 3 I +32.135ll
CIII\In
PlIge Ii
prohlems us II resullof thlll 1I\I\I1'y,
20, Inooopt us crodlhle, hili not pors\lllslve, the lestll11\lny of Mr, Fisher, Mr, Flshor tostlfioll
tn OOrlllln nctlvlllos whloh poo\lrred Oil Mnroh 10, 191)" nnd/or Muroh II, 11)97. However,
Mr, Flshe\, tostlfied l\Int he Wus not sme If tho clnll11unt OWl' tonk lho IOlld to MllrylU1111 ns
req\losted 1\1111 tostltlod lhlll lho Inolllonls he tesllfied 10 hlld nOlhlnll to du wllh lho
fJluhnnl1t's tonnlnntlllll. Therofore, ullhuugh credible, the tosllmony of Mr. flshor Is nol
persulIslvo. Mr, Fisher's testhllllny docs not support II finding IlllIt tlw clull11ullt WIIS
tenlllnlltod for eUIlSI"
21. I 1I0oept liS porsllllslvo, III purl, Iho nwelleul opinions of Dr, Bnlnllkln, Dr, llnlonkln's
oplllloll \llllt tho oluhlll1nt suffered un Injury Us 11 roaullof Ihe Decemher 2, 19% h\oldenl
III work Is s\lpported by Ihe pers\lnslvu opinion of Dr, Levllle, Dr, fJolonkln's \!lsthnony
Ihlltlhe oll\lmunl hns ongoing reslriotlons liS u roslllt of tho Injury Is not pers\lnslve, Tho
olllhnlllll's own notions, IIlloeptlng seveml dlfferenl tr\lcklng positions, supports Dr,
Levlne's opinions thllt tho olall1lllnt's Injllry no longer reslllls In a dlsllblllty or f\lnotlonnl
hnpnlnnont,
22, ( lIoccpt liS pors\lllslvo tho 1110dlcIII opinions of Dr, l.ovlnc, Dr, Lovlno's opinions lIto
SUPPlll10d by the ollllnlllnt's own IIctlons, and Pllrtllllly S\lpported by the oplnlolls of Dr,
Uolonkln. The Olllll11l1ut's own nctions ludlcllte Ihlll he hilS retllrned 10 three dlfferel11
truck driving positions since Mllrch 10, 11)!l7, This certainly docs not support Dr,
Bolonkln's testllllony thlltthe clnhnlllll's lIetlvitles should be restricted, Furtherlllore, Dr,
Bolonkln tcstlOcd lhal ns of Soptcmber 19, 1997, the clllhnlllll only hnd sul\leelivo
findings, Dr, Levine's opinion thllt the ellllmullt's Injury has rcnched mnxhnulllmcdlcnl
hnprovemellt and It docs not resull III III1Y 1\ll1ctlonllllmpulnnem or physlculrostrlotlons
Is supported by Dr. Levine's September 22, 1997 exnmlnntlon of Ihe cluhnllnt and tho
clnhnllnl's retUl'lllo work on three sepllrntc oecuslons liS a tfllek drive,..
23, BlIsed on tho IIbove eredlbillty delel'lnlnlltlons, I \lud thnl the elnhnnul sustnlnClI n
plnohed nervo, nel\l'OI11I1, of the len foot while luthe course nnd scope or his ()Illploymellt
with the omploycr 011 December 2, 11)96, TIll) clllllllllnt wus tennlnnted while slillundor
restrictions us n resull of the work.relnled Injury on MlIl'fJh 10, 191)7, The employer did
Ilot presellt uny evidence Ihllt the terlnlnntloll on March Ill, 191)7 WIIS for cnuse, Tho
clnlmllnl should be puld lempornry tollll dlsnblilty benelltslnlhe nmollllt 01'$451.11, with
stntulory Illtcrenl from Mllrch II, 1997 lhrough und Including September 21, 1997, except
for Ihe periods when he wns employed with (1lncs Trnnsport IIlld Tel11ple Tmeklng,
During the periods lhe clnlmnnl WIIS elllployed with Hines Trnllsporl nnd TCll1plc
Trucking, the elnlll1nllt should rceelve telllpornry pnrtlnl dlsllbillty benellts, with stntutory
Intcrest bnscd on his IIctuul ellrnlngs. Thc cllllmllnt's workers' compellsnllou b,:nellts me
tCl1l11nlltcd ns of Seplel11ber 22, 11)1J7 bnscd upon the credible nnd flersulIslve Illcdlcnl
. -~---: . .~~ ;,r.:,.:....:,;.jo .,;
0, Jones Is wllllOll! Bpeolfio knowledge E1U to the remaining avermenls of
Paraoraph 9, therefore Ihe SElma Is denied Elnd strict proof thereof Is demendee! E1tthe
time oftrll'1l,
. 10,-11, Jones denies any avermenlll1at Plaintiff WE1S physloally unE1ble 10
perform Ills duties as EI consequence of the afpremenlionecl olalmed Job- relE1ted Injury
of Iha Plaintiff, Tha remaining averments of paragraphs 10-11 are denleq,
12, PE1ragrapl112 of tile OomplEllnt Is l:1dmllled,
13,.113, Paraorapl1s 13-10 of the Oomplalnt oontaln oonoluslons of IE1W to whloh
no responsive pleading Is required, To th\'! extent Ihat E1 response Is required Ihe same
aro denied and strict proof thereof Is demanned at the lime of trial.
NE.W..MAI.IIm
By way of further answer to tile Complaint Jones pleElds the following New
MEllieI':
19, Plaintiffs complalnlls barred by 1I1e employer Il11munlty provllllons of the
Worl<er's Compensation Aot, 77 p,S, Seo, 401-
20, Plaintiffs oomplE1lnt fEllIs to state a claim upon relief may be granted by this
Court,
21, Plaintiffs claims are raised In anll11proper venue,
22, Plaintiffs clE1l1ns ere bare by the Dootrlne of Clean I-lands
23, Plaintiffs olE1lms are barred by National Labor Rellltlons Act ancllla
progeny federal statutes,
24, Plaintiffs claims are barred by the Dootrlne of Failure to Exhallst
Administrative remedies,
",-
II;
':1.
1111
{; ,-I ~
It.,
""1
'-Ill'
1:'\
l\!'
"
I ~", -_I '
I".
II.'
(.,)
",
,.
I,,',
("
..
>-: . .'
l-:"",<
ri\j 1.(
C.lL-_J
I. ,\ :"~:.I
C') ~:~I"
ir'l~~
"J. r ~
," J ;1j~
\fJfi~
~l'J
w
'\ Ii
..~
'I"
IL;
1:'".1
.~.
f;i
I,.,J
0'
in
I',
"
"
" d'
if
,.
,.
i'
,.
./<
;,
J;'
i'
"
If
"/,
"
"
I'
"
" "
;)'
!'I
H
"
I"
"
"
,I'
,.
jI
,I,
,~ '
,.
"
,.
,.
H
j;
"
i'
j!
,
I'
1'<
i.'
Ii
,I'
"
"I'
'\-,1,
,Ii
"
,
,i'
"
ii"
,.
'i
,. "
,.
,.
,
., ." "
, " , "
H
"
"
, 'I
1 , II
"
,.
"
,,] "
,.
" j'
"
I.
U'
, "
iJ(
'I'
II,' j] H
,
II ruply I~ rcq\ilru\I, II I~ ~pcell'lclliIY \IUlllulllhlll Ihu pru~el\l IIcIIll1\ I~ hlllTell h)' Ihu "lIlWII'II\U or
elelll\ hll1\II~,"
2~, PUI1IUl!. PIIIII\IIIT I~ Illll'l~UII hy cll\ll1SUllllHllhurul\1ru III'uI'S Ihlll Iho IIl1u!\lIlhll1~
COllllllllulll1l Plll'lIl11'lIph 23 ~\illu eOl1cll\~lol1s Ill' IIIII' III which I1llruply Is I'uq\llrull, Tlllhu uXlell1
II ruply Is nllllllrcd, 11 is spucll'lellllY lIelllellthlll Ilw prusulll lIellllll Is hlllTud hy thu NllllolllIl
tllhllr Hulllllol\~ A\lllInd/lll' lis prllgull)' rudul'lIl slllllllus,
24, PUll led , PllllntllT Is 1Illl'lsl'd h)' ClllIllsullll\d thul'lll\1l'u IlI'UI'S Ihlll the IIlIu!\lItlolls
eOlllllll1clll1I plllllllrllph 2'1 ~tlllc cllllcllISlollS Ill' IIIII' III which nil rupl)' Is l'uqllll'lIl!. Tlllhu uXlUllt
II I'upl)' Is I'equll'ud, It I~ spcclnclllly lIulllud Ihll\ Ihu Pl'uSUllllICllll1l Is hlll'l'Cllhy Ihu "lIllctl'lllu Ill'
Ihlllll'u to uxhllu~tlldmllllsl1'lIlll'c rumedles:"
25. DUlllud, PllllnlllT Is 1I111'Ised hy cOllnsulllnd thul'el\1ru III'Ul's Ihlll Ihu IIl1ullllllollS
eOllllllllelll1l plll'lIl1rnph 25 slllte ClllldllslollS or IIIII' 10 which Illll'uply Is I'eqnll'ud, Tllthu uXlullt
II I'uply Is ruqull'ed, it Is speelnclllly dun led thlll thu prusent lIutlllll Is hll1'l'ud hy Ihu IIppllellhle
sllllnlu or Ihllltllllolls, To Ihu collI 1'111')' , Ihe pl'eSelllllctlll1l WIlS Ilmuly fIIudll'llhllllho IIllpllellhlu
sllllnlu or IImltlltlolls.
"
I;"
\
2 I,
!,.