Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout99-01564 ~ .S ~'. ..t~, ~\ .~. J ~. ~ ... ~',' '1....'\' ~ . \ \ ,. " ~ ~ ":"" .. .~ .. ~ ~ ~. \0 ....... , ' " ,[./ ., " " ,. I' " .i" .. ,.' " ,. " ',' "I' ,. " ". I';' " !, ,. "J' .' , " , .' , , i' .' " .. .. 'f .. ,I " , , .i' , " " ;i " I , , , ., ,'i',; , "j ,. ,. . I' .. '1., " " ;i " " i' " !l ii ,:'j, !: 'i. " ;' ,\', 1"," " " " ii ,. q ,. :',Ii I' ",I ,;, " '1\ i! ,I' I' I, H Ii " " " j" " " I' I" I ',Ii' Ii I{ i ~ ' " ,Ii '1, ,j 'i' " " .,' " " " " '1,.\ ,..-I 'j, ;i " " il ,I' !' IJ " ., il " 'l; Ii " ';1 " 'J' -'.' " iii Ii " 'j. j. , i'-' "-\, ,; .. ;, " " ,. v, 1110 I IN 'J'lIm OOUIl'I' OF' COMMON PJ,Wf\S OU' I ctJMIJIi:IU,ANP COUN'I'Y,'vmNNSYI.vANIA' , I I , I CIVIl. AC'I'lON - J,AW I I I , I I NO, 99-1564"CIVrL ~mRM' PAlJJIINul 130GllAN Ilnd AJ,j3IuWI' IlOCWAN, Pln.l.nt.l.f fll COCA-COLA mNTmllPIlIsms, INC. t/d/b/n MIP-ATLANTIC cOCn-OOLA aOTTLINO cOMPANY and BRUNO D,tMnR'I' u,m, JH, / Pofendt\ntn !,IU1'1'I!l.AL COHU'IUHIilN_cm ANP NOW, this 12th day of JnnUlry, 2000, before mdgar a, Dayley, JUdgo, present: for the plaintiffs WIS Pnv.l.d B, Pawling, maguire, and for the defendnnts, stephen m, GeduId.lg, msgu,i.re, Thin .l.s I rear-end automobile aooident oase that oocurred on December 4, 199?, At th.l.s point defendant has not admitted liability, The pln.l.ntiff, PaulIne Bogdan, BUffered a b~ain lnj ul:Y for whioh she l\nderwen t an emel:genoy righ~. fron tal oraniotomy with evaouation of acute trnumatic right frontal subdural hematoma. She was released from the hospital on Pecember II, 1997, PIa.l.ntiff, who is in her mid to late60'u, olaims she suffers permanent m.l.ld to moderate cognitive defects IS n resl\lt of tl1.l.s injury, 8he was retJ.red nt. the U:me of the acoident and seeks generAl damages, There.l.s no claim for med.l.cnl expenlles, wage loss, or los t eal:ning capaci ty. At the time of tho protrial conference defendant increased its offer of settlement from $50,000.00 to $102,500,00, Plaintiff Will evaluate th.l.s offer, having previously clemnndod $,150,000.00 plus $50,000,00 In consort.i.um, Estimated time of trIal, two dnys, ,1, Il\lfondnlll, 111'\111\1 I llMlI1'I 110, .II'" IH 1I11l1lhllllndlvld\l1l1 who l'osldoHII12125 1'01ll1\y I ,Ino 1{111II1, YOl'k Hpl'hlllH, POlIlIHylvlIlIl1I 17~ 72, MC:l1!J\r. IIAClillRO.l!.Nj}, ,I. On Doool\1hor 4, 11)1)7, IIlnppro~hl1nloly (i: 15 P,Ill.. Pllullno UOll\lnn WIIH opol'J\thll1 11 19H7 II\Ilok C'unl\II'Y I.hnltod Illotlll' vohlolo on onlrnl1oo I'IIlllp "K" III Hllllo ROlllo 15 Holllh 11\ Lowor AllolI TownHhlp, ('\ll\1hol'llInd COlll1ty, PonnHylvlIl1ln, 5, Ml's, lIolldllll WIIH Sloppod ol1lho Onll'lll1CO I'lIlllp wlIllll1l1l\1l' Ihu honvy Irnfl1ulo UIIHU So 1111I1 Hho could HIlI'oly pruuood onto SllIlo ROl1tc 15 RO\lth, 6, AI tlw HIIIllO 1111l\l, ))ol'omllll1l, Ill'lIno tJlMlIl'lllu, .II'. ("tJofundnI11 tJIMIII'II1(,"), Wlla OpOl'lItll1g II VillI ownud hy Dol'omlllnl CoolI-CollI Enlol'pl'lHus, hlU, 1III/h/n Mld.Allllntlo Coon.Coln , 1l0Ullng COI\1PIlI1Y ("Dol'ondnnl Coon-Colli"), 7, Dol'ondllnt DIMlIl'tllo WIIH prucoodlng IIp Iho HIIIllO onll'nnoe I'IImp Imlllodllltoly huhllld Mrs, Ilogdlln's vuhlolo, ll, Dofomlnnt DIMIIl'lllo nUllllllmllly nnd onrolo~sly Illilod 10 ohaol'vc thnt Mm, Ilogdlln's vllhlolo wns sloppod nnd WIIH unnhlo 10 ~Iup hlH vnn In limo to pl'ovonllt 11'11111 sll'lklnll Ml's, Ilogdnn's vohlolo, .. (), Dcf'olldllnt DIMllrtllll'H Vl1l\ vlolllntly Cl'lIHhod Into tho 1'(11\1' ond or Mrs, Uogdlln'H vohllllo, 10, tJcl'ondlll\t 1 llMmtllo wlla ollod hy Ihc Lowor AllolI 'I'ownHhlp Pollco Doplll'tl11ont 1\11' "f\lllowlnn 100 closoly" In vlollltlon or Roctlon 3310 A of lhe Molnl' Vchlolo Cmlll, 2 1t1 N' t')t) .), ' l:r, ,1,1 dll ,/ " '/' (i"I, , 1', 1,1, ,,/ C" ,..1 ,,) n. fL.: \.'. ';1-',,' ri/) f~11 " C:\J f1~ , i ct~1 f\., .. ,1'.'/ ':.;t-' \ l,/l';" '\.. ' " I ,:,1.: ,I " )\'1")' ,,:IIi._ /:.:' '. l,j' ..' .. " i( , " I', ,. H " " " " ;; I' Ii Ii. ,.' I: H, ,,"';, " ,;' I; ,. H,; ;j, 'i, ,. , " if " " " p,- "I t" ,I' ;; ,. 'I'. .;[, , .. .. tI Ii ,. f'. ,. ,. " (Ii .. I, 1\" 'i' , , " " ;; it /f" H ;; ,~ . " 1';, ,i';- ''i .. .. ". " " I' " " " " ii" "ll " " , " PAT~ [1~O~IV~I) PArr. Plloor.aaup SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT APAMS COUNTY, PJ:NNSVJ-.VANIA OOURTlloUau, GIlTTyanUAQ, PA l1~au - .-.'. . .....---.-.-- .. ....__.... ....u_._._._______.~__,_...__~_ ItfnTlUlOTlollQ, II"~ "1~IIT1HIOTIO~1I 1'011 8lHIVI01I ai' 1'1100111111 llY Till: 1l11r:tIIFF" 11I1 Ihll,pvpreu ollholPBI (No, 1l11;OIlV (11\111'10"". 1'1 POlO lwu ur 11I11l11uUlhl~1 11I1\ulnll ((lI\llnhllnV III ull copllll. On I1nltlulllr.!l nllV tUlllu.. 1\000 fmV,", ~..._.._....-...._~.-. "..---, ---...- I. I'lAIUTlFFIOI ---a~-(}'c]"ljnf~TiMIIf:.I'-...... .....-..- 'n ...__._._'_____n.p -3~,~~\I~lkl'Mto\\~~il~(:tlP~'~i~11~f~'f\ \\~fm~N IN(:,. tic Vb/li "N II )~8ili\NI'IX~ -(iK~~ ~;J;:~~}f&~:wI*i~,l~~(4~1~;\)'lhWl](Wi1- _J12LJ\liQ!'l'Ll NO., CC)!>l!'l\NYll1ld IHllINO,]l.1 ~VI!i'!" I-I':,,J Ii I u mu.. u..,___, u.>l ll~\IIl;\1l!L~__u, u_, __ _ ...."..____, 8IBnVIB 6. ~~Mli or 1~11IVmlJ~L COMI'~~Y. COIII'[JIIATlO~, liTO, lD lllOlIVICII Oil I1fillllllll'no~ ai' 1'II111'IHHY TO 11I11.Hvmn, AHAolllill OIlIlOl.P. ~ -'~I~~~~I)~~~l~:t~I~I..~I':. ,... ..,.. O. ~1101l.1I1i (1111..\ ",IWU, A".,I",o"l ~"., Oilv, 11<11", Tw"., 11I0'0 ~"II-ill;.r.cilll;1 m-_...___...'_.____,..'..'_____m ..u,. ..-.-.,---- AT 2J2'i C"IIi,ly 1.IIIlJ Hd, I York :-;l'lllJg~ I I'^ StiJ:RIfF SJ:IWIOJi PROCJ:BB AI:OJ:IPT, Ilnq AFFIDAVIT OF AJ:TLJf~N .-.-----_._h._._~_.___,_.._~_.__._n..._....___________~_,.. '"' '_'_.__~'_H'" .....0_______ -... .... -.----------~...--.---~___u_._._._.__~_________~__.___._.u ...._._____..H__._ -LLtillI0I\IE.!!!j!l~\IM0!JlHYIQlIiJll'mmf!NI\LiJJ'!Iflll9N IN9! 'AIICJE .1.1 !!I!I'I!I!?!!.U .QIl! \1 ,,~NI,_I1, HUfl!!IT!!!\U!!lltA!L,IJ.!'\'!II!l!!L! .PI! !!I!!...,___,.." ._ . _ ._"....,.. Now, ,--,--.,------ 10 _u..._..., ..., I, SIWRII'I' 01' ADAMS OOUNTY, PA'I do homhy ctol1l1llzo \']0 shorll' of . __.....'_..".._u_____..'_m..._..,__ Oounty 10 OXOOli\o thin Wrll ol1clmulm rotllrl1lhorof 1I0110rdlll(] 10 IllW, TIll c10fllHl1\1ol1 holll(] mllclo III the roquonl llncl rlok of tho flllllllllll, '__........ "m....... "u--_'_...'_.".____..'..m. ...___._____... -~apiliil~I,-II/BlliITo'Tio~1I -oiioTiii!niNI;i:ii1l,l~iioN' TIIAr WII,i: 'AllnioTIN IiXI;liiiITINClniiIlVloli... ----...",-----,-.-.,. .... -,--- -, -' .., ~'j~!1!rrQ!'~_'_'_~.,~Q9.~UI:L ___~___..._."..h._.______.._ ......_____._.... Non: ONI.Y APfll.IOAUll: ON WIlIT OF f:)WOlJTION' N.II. WAIVlifi OF WAlOllMAN-..Anv tlullUlV OliOfUllovylr1f1 UPOIlIll nllochlnu nfly PflJpurlV undor wllhln Will mnV Ipavu llluno wllhoul A walchmnn, In o\J8\mly 01 w!1nfllovor Is found In posolloohlll, uHlir nnlllylnu Ilorootlullovy Of ollllchmonl, wllhnlll UlIhllllV 0I1lho pml 01 uuch flOfluly 01 Iho 8110(111 to fillY plalnllll horoln rOf ally 1088, d(lll1ruclluIl or rumovnl nl oily our-h pro/lolly hololO RhOlll/'lI onlo 111010ul. , O. BIIINAnjiii!~i'ii TToi1ii~v;;;';;li;;~olljaiNIi-Toii;;;;I"~;II,,O;;;;v,c. '""II;;I;;ii';I~" h, ---- - '-Iii: 'T1H:liI'IioNii'Nlii.ilimi---' .....- -li:ii^i'~ "---,----,, K 1'1.^'~T"'r Duvlcl 1\, Dowling, I\uq, 1I1lt;1'r:1/1l~~T (7:17) 233-573:1 =---=~~::"~~SeAgfTil!;L9V{EQRIiSf;=QF.:sHgRjFf=QNLy.-=ij(fN'QT=WRIr':~1if;I.Q.W-=tHlfi-llJN-g_~=:=::::==-= ~~:l~~~~0~~'~I"I~.'r':~~\~:1 ~~~~~~__I_ _~~~:,:I:\!~'l_A":h":II.~I,~OOOI)O",':~ .01_C':'kO:TIII:..,. ..'______ ..._ ,_ ::', _OO'~::I:~i1.".,.~4_!i'''':::~~/~I~:~::'':,~ 16. I horllhv CenTlflV nnd nF.TUnN lhnt I ~ hovo pU/6tl1mlly sorl/od, n Ilovo BOIVocl pOlunn In r.IUH{lO, (1 hAva lounl oVld(l/lclI 01 sOlvlen no ohuwnln "rloronrkb" (on WVMSO) r-I havo 110001o<llho pbovo c10serlhud jlHlrHHIV willi lilt! WIll or GUlnploln! clDacIllIOll on 1110 InlllVlellInl, cumpnllY, corflorntltll1, 010" nllhp nddlpas ahown "llOVO ur un lho Individual, compAny, cU'l1OII\IIOI1, 010., 01 Iho Odel/DOIl hlllOf\UlI holow hy 11I1Ilflll1{Jlor !loaUnll n Tillie Mil ATTUSTlIl1 OOPV thorol. . .. '''--'~-___.m_''_'''''_'_'___~~"''''''','a_~_._..~_. . ... .____~.~____.__. '-"--'-~_____d_'__'.___"'n'_____~,_____,__"_,_,, , ..__ ___ . ....,.._._....._ ... _____.._. ...........__...___.___........_.._..._..._._____._....._._____.._____ -10ul.JulJ,!orohy r.0I11ly'.~~~1 ~f1JI!~~_~I?J fl()lJl~~J~(lr,~~ol Ol!' UI!uhlo.IO ~OOO'"lhtlItHIIV~fltlol, Cf/1Il!l(lIlY, ClllpOl!,!!,!n, 011., /lnm(l~I.~h!1'!'..o (!l..!lO }ml!n!~~~l.!l~'!~) . _ u _ _.__ 11. Noma and Ullo ollrltUvlllulll aorvocl 1'8 "(HiltOn oltUllthlu flgll ancl dltcllIUml I flood Ordor __J!.r:~_I},!.tt.!!!~~!!OL~~J,,'::~_J~'.'.~lC,'-I!!~Il\l,'Ll!OL~It:,' _, ,_ __ _" _ ,::i:~"'~!I'~~tr:~~~~,~d:I""'~:1 .., ,~~_,____ W Add/oaa 01 whmo lorvod (r.omn1olo only I' dlflorflnllhRll ehnwn Ilhnvo) (BtlOol UI IIrO, Apnrlmolll No, Oily, nom, Twp, t!t), Ooto (II Borvlco 21 limo Blnl~ ""I ZIP OOOU) 3/2~/99 6145~t -~g_ ~~:~~~~~J~~"l: I:';~,t:i;,iOl;- O;I~J M"~:lci.I;"~~'-I. II'I~,L~"~'~ 'li., "'hll:I::I;~~ 1~li::]~~I'Ill~,I_::~~~I~II:-~-,[H~:~~i~-= 23. ~"v."co 00'" 24. P.U. ~o HI. T.lnl en.!. 20. cll1l>'t~Kl6l\ nOFUlfll $75.,!~!.J~n,Sho'Z:IJ LH,?,/f()~)L_ _ _" _. _,____ __ ,i;2~). Iii _I~d! 3(2liLC)9 _ :i;IQ!..~~.._~J~dtJ.~ZL _____ ,w,,::. ,""~:,:,:~~,,:.,:..::=~I~~_ .._ .-_ ~~~~.~"i:::, __,~.n= IIftV 01______,______ ____'.."__nJL._. n.__.._,__,_____ _ . n}111110UJv,..l:IIIUnL__,_._..______ ,_ .. _, .}/.!1.5L2.'L-.., _.m ''0' ,___.. j0W~,Nrj1t~'II_INI!~vt'1A.N_____ __n_, ,~ft':lm/99 __. BIIElllrr OF AIJ~MB OOUIITY ___'_~~_~___~_'U'. fi,.oii;onol..0tllPui)'7ijr.'ily-,i;;bila-..-------~.-- MYSQMMlBIIIQ!l, ~mWL.____ ,___" ".,. um_o. ______m __m__ I ACKlmWl.uOau I1EOUIi'1 Of' Till! BIIEIIIPP'II nOTUml BIQllATlJnU or AUTlI0I11Zr:O IBBUI~O AUTHOI1IlY A~1l 1111.11. ../..,. ,...,.u__,.,_____.______,__ 30. (Join flocnlvod ... ..._-_..--...__._._....~..._._..._............._~ 011 T~ fl~O~'V~P -~_.,._--_.. ~.._~-_.-.. .~______.u.. . SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT ADAMS COUNTY, P~NNSYI.VAN'A OOUATHllUIl~, QliTTYllllUAQ, PII rm" ll^'r~ PAOOliBB~P IN8TIIIIOIION81IJOO "INIJTlIIJOlIONtlI'OI\ IJlillVIl111 IW PI\OOIJUIJ llY nil: mum HtI Oil thu rQVOI~p ullho 1111.11 (No.5) CUllY ullhltlolln: Plpo,u Irlll! ur prjnlluOlhl~1 IllBUrlI1U 1U1IduhllUy ull1l1 cuplo.. 1)01101 dolnch IIny CUpIUII, ACAO PJW,f 1. OOlJlIl N\JMlllil\ P_..J.jl.~~~LLU_~.~.-~u.~U.!.....~lLl'_L..::.~U:~J_~L...L~~:.!_:~ "__m... ._. _"n L. -:L__._~ij.J..,_______. ......n._. ..._.....__~ 3. p~I'l:NPANTIIl/I ", 1,1 " I 01 ,i,.. .." , !,.\ , '" ' II . I , . ii' i ,1, ,T,Y,I'.IWI: Ytlll~ QI.I pq~II;\.AIN\q' \\\lj',InU"I,II' . ._-..!.'~~L~..!_!-'.ULJ:..:.__...:...J.._IL'__' _! - ~'U.'.... .m.l~~____.. !.:.______.~_.~_~I_,._..___.J.._.__.______., __._____ _..... _. "'_+n_.,. _L I.I,! '-j_L~,Ul.,-.,. "'_00'_" ""'__'_'H__M__~'__'___" _.._ li. NAMU 01' INIlIVIIlIIAI., OOMI'ANY, OOlH'llllAlIQN, lITO., TO BI"WIO~ Oil IlUUClIIII'T10N 01' I'l\nl'~I\1Y TO 1111 1.IIVlliIl, AlTAClllfill Oil BOI.!l. Sli~RIFF S~RVIOt: PROOF-sa R/,;Ot:IPTI ancJ AFFIPAVIT OF Rl:TlJAN , -i-'-riAiNTlff/li""m-"--"--n, "- 811llUE It AT '!"lliH'llii,li'lll JI-, '.iiAnpnFBB{Gln;oi'~;;-nii'(j~' Ailuiirnuiij"' Nj;:~-6Iiy; iic;ro: TWI~~: 8Iiill;l~iHj 'iii'l-cor>>:-l' h...__.__ ___.. h~~___.. ,.. '___._.__,. 'I" ['JlIlII'.' l.ill< :,,1 ,,' !'l ill " I '-~-_______'_U____"_'___~'___'__'_'" .--..----...._.___~____..__....u_____... .._.____ ....._....____..__.._. ......_.___.__.......___.._......~. "00_"__' _..._~.._..__._____.___._...___.__..._._ -LL"ill!P.!\I!L\L~V~l!!\bJlliflY1Q!!LUJ'li!mQJI!\L .UJ'm!flQii !NQI (@Q li. L'Qg!'.l!l!~li_'-' 9g!IHL!\!! '.!.!llilj!~I!'!mQMA.!b ~!'OBIE!U_LQII!g!L n'_________,_ NIlW, '_..___m....'..___'" 10 '_u ---,..., I, SHERIFF OF ADAMS OOUNTY, PA" C/o hufOPY C/uJllIlIlU tho Sllorlll of '__..u.n____,,,___,_._.~,..____,,,,.. OOllnly to OKoollto thlll Wrlllllld mnlm reHlm thoro! llooorC/lno 10 Inw, Thlu cloplllntlon belno 11111110 nt Iho roqllost 11m! rluk of tho plnlnllll, _'_'____u,,___u '_n__ .,.. u _.1. '..---'..,___"__'u,_,,,___, D:liFiiOiAI.ITiBTII\IOiiciii'iioll Oliif,ll-lllroli'~iAl;iciN'Ti-i" T W,I.i."iiRU-liIT ',N'uxl;UniTlNn6IiiivIOC" . . ..u__~.. .,-,-- u. ,-,--.J!!!~I!'!f..PL,AJ!~N! C""tl!L ---"--~--..-.----....-.~-.--~----.-.-.!I'!.- ..----..-. ...---- ....-..........___._... .~--.._...._~__n...... ~_.__..__u_____.___....... _____ .....____~.__ -..._~____'~.n__~. NOH: ONI.Y APPI.IOAIlt.r: ON WRIT OF l:XI:CUTlON: "1.11. WAtWI1 0/1 WATOHMAN--A/lV dUllulV f1ho,lIllovv1nn UIIOIl or ullnchlnu (lnv Ilruporly wHlof wllhln wrul1lnv I(tAVO 8fHlIO wHtlottl n Wlllolunnll, In OUBlotlv of who!llllvor la found In pU811011U!OIl, nllor I1lltlfyln(J pOison alloyy or nllnclllilOlll. wllholtl UllhUit~' on lho PIlIl of Bueh (hlflUlv Of Ihu 8horllllo UIIV p181f\1II1 horoln 'or PIIV 10&8, doalHlllt!otl Uf IlIlIlovnt 01 oily Buell pi up oily holOlo IlhOfIlI'a 01110 Il10rool. -o:-iiiiiii^TUnU'~-A-TTonNiiv;;;~";;,;iiniQINA.TOii. ;~;I\lO"I.n'O~~I~;.~;;,,;'I';;h. "':.~;.'N~;I'~-'--'I"lii. i:U'l\ii"i~NiiNuMniir;"u---. ,. j""iTOiiTii-'--""""--- ll,'IVld iJ. j.p',dill.1 I',j;. . [JllI:Ff:Nt)ANT 1,/11! 'I '"I/I'd =--=---==~sel\QI;,-:-Ilg-LI:-5iLEQA-D:6ffQf:---S}jgAiEfQNLy:;;::[Q-..:NQiWRTI]'jrllr;bQ:w~tt:lle.-:-ILINIL~.:-~=:.:.:..._= ,12. Illllkl1o\\'lollgo fO~olplo' tho WIll SIONATUJlli at AulhOllzod ACall ()opuly or Work !HIll TllIo 13, Dolo ntlcii'lVod 14, (:lIplwlloll/lloPllnu dalo or cOll1lllalnl n8 ImUlllltod abovo. , . 1 ---~_..--_. ----------..- _.._~.- ..-.----.---. ...-.. --.-.. ... - ......---.-_..._. ,,_u___._.._.._ h.___________...___. _,_.. ___ __.__._.____~ ___. .._~___ .__ ._.. ~_~_..~..._~_.__..._____. . 16, I hnrohy OenTIFY nnll neTUnN lhal I ~{ hnvo porllollfllly 60lvod, ' I havo 80/'1011 pOtBOil In chnlllU, II Imvo lounl ovhlonc:o 01 sorvlc:o no 6hoWII In "flornnrkll" (on 10volao) (-J havo poalocllho ahovo dOBclillml ProllOlly wUh Iho will fir complnlnllloscr:tlOfl 0/1 Iho Inlllvlell/nl, c1.llllllnllY, corpOInU(lI!, 'Jlr..; allIIn oddroBB Bhown ohovo or olllho 11H1lVldunl, compAny, corpornUonl 010., nllhn ndel/oBa 1118(HlollhoroW hV hnrllltnu'Ol Poallnu II TIlUE And ATTESTlIll OOf1V Ihoflll. -~_._-----._--------_._-~-_. ...---.--....... ..-..----......,..--..---. . .... --+--....._~. _..~.__...__ ~.~_ ..u__.__. . ._.____.....____________~_. -1'L!2J_~,~.n~~~L~!!.-,lJ ~~~n~.!>,lJ~!lJ!!!~.!!....,O~!!I~!!....,O .!.~. .1!l__U~~~!!.I.ry.!e!.I.~.~fl_~~J!!~_.lr!(~!y!~I_~l!I~~_~~l.r.l_'!,I~~~L~~!111.0!nJ~,(I!~I-- ~!o:' .1l1~I!l,....Il...~t-~~y~:-(~-~~~~~n-"!..k.~E.~~~\.'!'L--.ul--.-.--~_R._ 17. Namo 11111' Ullo ollrllUvldunl8orvotJ 10, ^ porion 01 h/illlhlo ago mrld tlllc/otion nond Ordor . , 111ft" 101ldlnu In 1"0 dnlolltlllnl't u.ua' I '('I Ii,: i ,'i j I j I',. ; I 1 \ 'I " III I" 'II 'I j I j' 'I Illaco 0 ahode, ) i_I -lO.AddiORi. 01 whom 801vod (c(lrniiiOiooiiiYlliiiif~ton,tt;nn- ilil~wll-nhovoi(8i;OOl~1 ;1;:6:APMl'1l0-';I- N-;;~-ojly;-il~)f"~:Tw;: - ~ .--~~ np"O~'rl'\IO~'-RoiVico -21..-TlftlO-------- Olnlo and liP COD~' '/':"/ ill , ' .'1 )'11 _~,~' A,..~TiiM~~.~~e~..I. J.~,,:I~,-.',- j:~~~nl:, ~1.o:I:': J:'I~~I~~[~;~;J ~II"~ ~."~lliT:;:~ LM~~.' P.);PI:i"I:,I:~;:..l"M:~J ':" D:'I"I~~~ ~3. Ad"nco 00'1' ~1. ~6 ~o P.7 Inlnl On,l, P.O 008T aUK on nurUlI1l $7~,Jl() ""!!l!l~.dll ;,!,~~-,..--,- ____ _____, ______~. ..__.. __, ,_ __, : ,___u_____'-___,!..'-'_____.._ --..'-.---,-----,---..----...-.. "'-- ____'_m_._~____.._ ..-....-,-- -... ,---..,-----,.- -,,,,- -jjl:IANBwajj;'" , . ..-_____...___''',,_..__,__ A"f:lnMf!U 11M .ublellhocl to ho'oro mo Ihll____. .---..-1. -.. . ~ - -- - .-.-- -_ ._ .---J-------..--.---r~..____.~ .t-1 /~ ,J(fV.J/.,itfr'! _<- .... _jl :-_ ___ ___~'_'_----" lIy /~h.IlII' lIa" Elhorlrf) (l'1~h~'o' P/nr"N, f{~1 (Jnln ,~ I "J I" I ' , "oy 0'--__,__.._,____.., ..,~-- -- !L, " ---...., --..---..., - "'--'~,;II:~;"O__;,(~~~~.II. ,~ - - ,'~:~----- o,;;;'....yL,,----- , . .-1JJ t--- \1 ' 1 _ ~_ _ ..! .__. ___ ~ _2____.__ --- ---.--j'lOii;on~llly/lloriiTriHoi.ivl;ljiliic-. - --. - -- --- - -+ - -- Bllp.nlr:r ~FIAIJ~Mg COU'4TV ;... MY CO_~Ml!!91~N EKf'J!!~,1L_..____"_._,..,__,__..,,'___,,.,______""'" . _....,." '_n ..., I ACIlNOWl.liIlGE nllOUlPT 01' Tim BIIEnIFP'B nUTunn BlnNATUIlU or AUTIIOnlZIIO mSUINn AUTlfOlUlY ANIJ TITLE. --_._-----_.__._-~-_.-..--_.__.._--~---_....,..._~-._"._-.-...-.--- . ....-""..-.-'.T~........ -.-"/'.."..-------... "'--"""--'''---'''- . ,3,u, l>nln Ilocnlvod .;.;. ~:-:; f,- ~. ..:... ~,--,~"-,-~,, .._______n__.__._~. , , III Till' Coul'f of' CllIlIlIHIIl PIUIIH of Cllmhul'llHlIl Cl1l1l1fy, PUJlIIHylvnnln 1'01111110 130UelUl1, ut, lll, vs, CnOI1-Cplu 1':nl:orprIuull, 1110" tiel/hill M.icl-Mll,"t.lo Upol1-Cpln I3pl:t:l.lnu CompAny N 00-18fi4 CIVIl u, ,~- Null', :I/Ill/OO ..J2ill.l p 111n - 1 D_, r Hlllilllfo'F fWClJiI'IlIIiIH,^Nll CflPNTY, 1'1\ 1111 hmh)' IluPIIII~o"IQ,Hhurlffllr Cnlllll)' In P~pOI!lu thl~ 'Vt'II,lh'~ Ilo11l11111h1ll1101l," 1I\!lIlo III tlIO l'ull"o41 lillI' l'llil nrlhe l'lnlnllff, /' p/4 ~~~<:1~~~ Shorlrr uf OIl"'hUI'hl1l1l CUIlllly, I'n,. A.f'fidnvlt of SUI'vlco Nnw, wllhlll__ II I'u II III I hy hlllllllno lu, !lffostod CIl!'Y Ilfthu ul'l"lnlll Iho cUlltonfs (/'CI'Pllr, 19__,111 u'Cluol! /H,4ur\'011Iho ---.~ " i'--.. __ II frllc IInd 111111 1I\IIIIp ImowlIIII SII'lInsll'ol's, Shol'lrr uf CIIIIIIly,l'i" i' COSTS SWUI'II IIlId sllhsOI'lhcd hcfilrc. mo Ihls dll)' uf _19_ - slmVICIi . MILICAGIC AFIIIUA VIT s s 7, Punloet "" "InlllCt, II In ndl111111ll11l1nl l)ullll1l'"nl PIMnrt1lo'1l vohlolfl Willi hflhlnr' Plnlntlll'6 vohlolo huloro llnel 011110 111110 01 Ihu IllHlhlonl, 13, Alhnllllllllhlll PnlundonllQ fllHIHlnlllhlo 10 ~ornn eluoro" for Iho hllPPllnlno 01 Iho 1I011ldllnl, IlnWlIvuf, hy wny nl hltlhur rnopOnllll, Plolntlfl uloo IllUY hour rflllponlllhllllY lor otllrllnlllu lInlllr 1I1l1hllll1wny IInll lI\11n IIlupplno wllholll ooor' OQlIIIO, ll, lJul1ll1llll11 n IlIlInl uUllnhlQlnn ll/llf IlllrQunnt to pll,n,C,p, 10291fl), 10, Alhllllllld, 11, llullllllllIII nlUlIlIIllUl1nlllHIUI1 onel purlluullt 10 Pn,n,c,p, 10291fll, 1;1, 111111"1(1 fllItlllllIlll Iu PlI,ll,c,J', 10291nl, WltllIwpnlll" 1l1lluI11111nlll Conn.Culll I:nlorprllloll, Ino, unrl aruno PIMul'llIo, rUlllwlllfully In!fllnu' VUllr I hlllnrnhlll COllrt 10 rlllll1llll11 Plalntlffll' Complaint wllhollt OO/lt or Iltlfurnnl11 tn 1\, OOUNT! 13, lluIlIIulnntn Inullrporllto horoln by faloronoo, as If flllly sot forth at lanOlh, Pnrll{lrnpl111 1 - 12 01 Iho Anllwof to Pllllnlllls' Complnlnt, 14.lnl ... (h) 1)lIlnnrlllnlll Ildmlt that thoy lire to 1I0mo dooreo responslblo for the lIooldunl ol1d PlnlntlllH' Injllrlnll nnd rJlIl1111[lOS, If any, However, by way of fllrlhor responso, Pllllnllll 111110 Illny hour rUII/lon'jlhlllly lor Htnrtlno to ontor thn hlohwllY cmd thol1 Htopplno wltholll (lood nnllllu, 11l,(1I1 "f/1 DUI11l1d pllflll1l1l11 tel Pll,R,C,P, 1020(0), 11\, DUI11nd till nlullnl nonohllllon IInd pllrllllont to Pll.R,C,P, 1029(el. 1'1, 1l11l11nd 11111 IIllnl1t 10 I'n.I1,C,I'. 1020101. 111, Ilul1lnrllln n IUrlnl oonolunlol1 ond pursunnt to PII,R,C,I', 1029(e), 111, f)ullIllrlulIlllut/nl oonuluHlon nnd purnuont to 1'0.t~,C.p, 1029(0), ~(), DUlllllrl nn II 10rlol oonoluHlon and pursunnt to Pa.R,c,r. 10291nl. ... WI'I~Rj:FORj:, pefonc1qnto Cooq-Colq F.ntllrprlslls, Ino, qml anmq PIMllrlllll, rllopllotfully roq~lool your !-Ionorllplll CO~lrt 10 c1lsmlso I'lolnlllfo' COmpllllnt WllllO\.ll 00111 or juc10mlllll 10 II, OOUNT II 21, Dllfonrjl1nto Inoorpofnlo horoln hy rllferenoo, 110 If fully 001 fOri 11 III IllnOll1, I'llrll0l'llPhs.1 - 20 of Ihll Answllr 10 I'lulntlffo' Complolnt, 22, Mmlllecl, 23, II 10 Ildl1lllloc1 thllt Defendont DIMllrllle WIlS oporatlno 11 ven ownocl by Defllnclllnt Oooll-Coll1 F.nterprlsos, Ino, end thllt Defendent DIMortlle, while ootlno wllhln Ihe oourse Ilnd soopo of his omployment, WllS to 001110 dOOl'ell rooponolblo for tho oooldent whlohls the subJllot of I'lolnllffs' Compllllnt, However, Py WI1Y of furlhor rosponU\l, 1'IIllntiff aleo mllY boor rooponslblllty for otllrtino to ontoI' tho hlohway Ilnd Ihen otopplno without good OUlIDO, 24, Denied pllroullnt to 1'0,R,0,1', 1029(0), WHF.RF.FORE, Dofondants Coon-Oola Enterprl080, Ino, Ilndl3runo PIMartilll, reopeotflllly rllqullst your Honorl1ble OOllrt to dlomlos 1'IIllntlffs' Oompllllnt without oost or Judgment to It. COUNT III 21i, Dllfllndllnts Inoorporlltll huroln by rllferonoo, os If fully Silt forlh Ilt lenoth, Porllgrephs 1 - 24 of tho Answor I1ncl Now Motter to I'lalnllffs' Oompllllnt, 26, Donled pllrSUl1nt to I'Il,R,O,I', 102010), WHERF.FORE, IJofondonts Cooo-Ooll1 Entl1rprlsos, Ino, I1nd Brllno DIMllrtlle, rllspllotfully roquost your I-Ionorllblo COllrt to dismiss Plolntlffs' Compllllnt wlthoul ooot or Jlldgment to It, New MATTaR '1.'/, 1lllluIlllllnlll Incorporl1lu l1aroln hy rolorunoo, os If fully sat forth ql 10nOll1, Pnrnllrllphll 1 .:W IIf Ihu Anuwur 10 Plnlntlffs' OOll1plnlnt, :m, Plnll1tlffll' IlIlurlllo nl1lt domooos, If OilY, may nol hllVl1 hoon oal.1sod ~lY !lny IInls, 1I111111111011s, 01' hl'unnhus of duty 01 Pofflnlhmt, 20, l)flllIIlIlnl1lll' oonchllJt 11111Y nol hav!! Iwon 0 1I11hlltan\11I1 faotor In ofll.1slno Plnll1l1ffn' II1)urlllu lIl' clnmn()1I0, If IIny, 30, 1'llIll1llffo' olnllno mny hn hnrrud 111 wholo or In pnrl hy thnlr oomparallvo I1l1ullunI1011, 31, I'lnll1llffo' olnllno mny hfl hmrocl hy tho provlnlono of tho MOlor Vohlolo , I'll1nl1oll1l flllnpul10lhlllly AoI, whloh 11I'0 plOllllocl hy roforenoo llnd Inoorporlltod horoln 1111 If fully sat forlh nt 101101h, 32, I'lnll1tlffu' Il1I1Y hovo fnllod 10 mlllonta thaiI' damllgou, 33, If thin Was II worl(-rollllod aoolclal11 Involvlno tills l'lalnllll, Plaintiffs' olqllns mny ho hnrroeJ or limited hy oollateral eSloflpol, WHliflIiFOfl!:, Polondonts Coon,Col1I Iil1torprlsos, Ino. and Bruno DIMartlle, rospeutfully rOl1Uoal your Honomblo Court to dismiss Plaintiffs' Complaint without oost or ludoment to It, ~ l 'lJvW, r -- --{-- THOMA ,~~~B & HAFF.R 'U~J) ~ .' STIlP'/ N E. GIlDULDIG, ES~ ATTORNBV 1.0. #32574 ATToRNIlY FOR DBflaNDANTS ,QIm'UF..lilAU.JlF-Dlll{i.V;J:Qlll 1)/ ;,lIl /~ A')' " l: hr;q:eby rmrt~.i.t'y \:11<1\: on \:hi~1 JaIL... rlAY of: .kS. '.,_......,_, 1999j f\ \:nIP E\Ilrl. ClO),'I.'oot: ClOPY of: t:h f:progo',tno, ~W~t,L"I"It.:~I..C..._..:;.~.__ WI1fl um'vocl II\, lIIemw of. Un;l.I~(3q 1'11:<\\:\38 Ii1il:\.l, f:i:r.fJ\~ olf\aP, L10atnqo pl'epfl.l.cI, npon \:11\3 f.ollowi.ng I ataphon ~, Oeclulclig, Qsqnire 'i'IIOM1\s, 'l'IlOMAS & 'IMwg 1 1,1.,1' .'306 North li'ront: ,gt:roet 1",0, 13011 999 'Ilf\l:'ri/3p\\r9, 1'1\ 17100 /1.. . ~ C:? ?II!~-4~ ~~UUfJ ~'i" L, Zll +C ..,'. '. " ,. " t,,, " " " " ,. ,,~ " i " l " Ii I' , ;( '," C-:l , ly; ~'l (" ,. i. ,\l~ , , Ii ) ~; :. " , I;. ('It'l Wi , ", ,I" I ~' J I',.' ., ;"_:1 ( )' '1 j..} ,... ",!i:J r ' ('. IiI 1_ l;:~ I (" t;'ii.'1 11'.':' . . (:1.. I U l~ I .,., :':1 .. " nl tJ CJ\ L n " j.' ,. " j; " d: " , " " ,. ,. " " iJ" " !'i; ,. '(; " " iI "" .1' 'I (', 'il " '. " " ..~. -. .,., l'i 4:'''. f.o! ". ..:l:, 'If- , " I'" c:I-~ "3~ ,. \11';:1 c_. l,. 1"', ~:i u,,~ ,I. ,..." ,,(1... .. ~:: '! H _.\~ r! I;.) ~;j " e.l,(;\ ''''' ';i' f/,} '. \" I ,,1...,. h:, l~\ ;'''' U'fe 11.1)! ,rJ; I' I,,' ,;I.: Ill: 1,\, m d ~) p..., .... , ..,..,.", ,; ,. " " , ,. " " 11' ". II;';' i' ,. .. " " " " . d' " " ,I' 'J' ':';1 ", ,;1 ,. .' ,," ; Ii " li ',i', " " 'I, " " " ",! " if " ',' " f\; \~l '" [roo tJ ~ ,; ::_~i '-',I' " Ii, .'J l'.~ (> ) ~ .~, )f' ~'j ., ( ;) ,~'t~ 1:/;,' ".j (I.. ;,0} ;~;J ('II., ";'/,i,j J \'. <;7\ 'I" I .~, b' ,.,~ "t""" ~.:} l J I ['i !',)U\ "'1:"',: "']P. " I. ..,.. ~'~~ ,. II.. ,n <! " L;I en. I,) ,j' .. .. .. 'I, " Ii , " 0", " " it H '" I' "ri Ii ;, ;; ';,1\'.1' " i' , H " I' '10 " i, 10 j, ., " " " " " I' i! ili , ,. I' f'" ,. Ilf ;; ,i' '1 " III " Ij .' " " I' " Ii , " " " J' d' 'i " j; ~. " i< [I' 1~1 ..... " ..:, I'" I, ;; " I,,' (~ .f:,! 'L {'c: . _ 1 ~,. " " 1\ .,~ (1 I (.,1 It;; ,i; f ~ ,} ,~I' '; (_J ~\r Ii ',' " [,I.,., r;\,;/ !j "j'. 1"( ,,'.~ ." ~ ~ " . t'{!a \' (, I ~ , ....<I) ,\ " ," ' {1)ot,.1 /:',..1_ T.~ 'i/IF' f' '.'f." 't:', Ii! ,... " U .1. (I 1~;-'1 '~ .,' 0', '(I...) ,. " " " " " "i " " " i! " " ;1 " ij ,. ,I ~ .. " j; " " " " Ii " ,I; ,. " " " " , ., j , , , " Ij !i I, ,. .". " I;. j. " " " " " 'I., " " "~I ,. ,. " 'I" "I! " ", i: " ':" " " ',. " " /' " i' I; " I' " '~ t:.l . b:~ ; (:: " ',. .~, ",,' <;\') ..:., ;, I,,\.I 'I' :;;)..,'(: ./ I (') .~: f..;J!;'il r~ I " ;,:t~ ,{..,1t.'i: "it ;; /oj II'; 1'\1" ,q.. ,'")1''.1 ~i'O' to.. :.;tJt~ Ilj" IN ;-'iJI~; I, " j"" WJ j, }fl~ l. I' 'J /I "'J c,jl . " II, 0, i!.:] c.:.\ (I'; 0 ,/ " il' I: " 'i ," " ", 'J 'j. - " " /I I' " I', ,. " .,'