HomeMy WebLinkAbout99-01591
,
~
...~
:
\,'.
V
~
~'
~
It),
......
,
.,~
~
\ \
,.
"
"
,
".
"
'j",
,.
"
\,j
.,
H
d'
;.
,.
,.
"
"I< \1
il
01'
'q.
1',
"',
;''1
,.
,,',
fI u
"
!! l!
,.
,.
/
Ii
....'-J- I
';~::r
"
"
....
I:, ,,'l
'I
q
.,'
,.
,.
_If
,.
,.
"
I'
'i
'I
h
;"
It
,
"j
fj
'I'
"
/i
"
i,'
" "
"
i,
"
j'!'
','
"
\,'
,
"
,I'
"
,.
"Ii
i.
"
"j.
..
,
.,
.,
."
I,
II
"
I,'
'II "
q
..
Ii
'I'
,.
if'
'I'
q
"
h,
""
'I,
I.!
i,.'l!
;'
,.1;
"
"
,.
I' ..
w
,.
i,'.1
ii
!!'
"
"
""
!!fl
II
"
"
,j i;
.}'
,.
"
'.
1\ I.'
,
,.
,H
"
, - ., ,,.
" ,
, , , , , ,
,.
"
"
f; Ii ,
, ,
.
q
,
, :
,
,
"
i
, ,
"
i,"
, ,
i
, , .-
...
I
,.
"
(l"
Ii
"
;1
.,
'Ii
'.i
H
,.
',',
.,
>if
,.
WIilNDY p, 131Jll."l'ZUlI~
plaintiff.
v,
XN 'l'/IIU COUR1' 01;\ COMMON l.'uVll\13
CUM131i11uJANP COUN'l'i', I?PlNNI3i'INl\NIl\
Np, 99-1691 Civil Term
CIVIl, Am'ION '" lJI\W
Rl\YMONP 1~U1PNIilR,
Pef.enc\tml:
DIiWillill1\N'l" 8 PRIU,JMIN1\RY OIl.n~C!I'.lillill
m..~ COMPl,l\JNT
ANP NOW comes the Defendant, Raymond Kapner, by anc\ l:hrol\gh
his attorney, William u, Adler, and respeotf.ully file~ the
following preliminary objeotionsl
I, prelinu..nau Db"lect:ion in the lI.ature of a Dem\ll;J;'ID;:
1, PlaintHf has filed a one-page, single-spaced complaint,
allegillg a ga1"den vad,ety of causes of aotionl
haral3sm8nt, a
Ii
violation of. the Fair Debt Colleotion Practices Aot (16 U,8,C, 99..
1692-16920, as amended), a violation of her right to privacy, libel
and defamation, unlawful wiretapping, deoeiving her as to the
"condition and amenities of property, oausing Plaintiff $180,00 in
electrical Work which defendant stated existed but did not[,]" lcst
wages as a result of "poor landlordship [, ]" and the l"eturl1 of a
seourity deposit,
2, Plaintiff' 8 complaint ;ls totally bereft of /lny factual
supporting allegations as to when, where and how Defendant is
liable under the aforesaid causel3 of actions, but rather sete forth
a series of legal oonCl1usions and demands for monetary damages!
. a) Plaintiff does not state when, where and how
1
Pefanc\an\: aUegsctl.Y' hAl'<\~",eq hel- at: hel' plOlCa of
empl.\?ymenl: I
b) Plaint:iff QOea not: II1lege the re:).at:ipnl3hip
between. her anq pefellQal1t: I
q) plaintiff does not qetail when, where anq what
ldnct of tlllegeQly false statements and allegaUons to
t:\1h'd paJ:t:ie~ were a l.Jegedly milde by Defendant t:hrough
the maUs I
q) Plaintiff does not aveJ: when, where and how
Defendan\: allegeqly libeled her OJ: defamed her Ol' to whom
she W&S Hbeled. or defl1med,
e) Plaintiff doea not allege when, where and how
Defenctant: allegedly admitted to ~er that he engaged in
the aommiasion of unlawful wh"etapping I
f) Plaintiff ctoee not state how Defendant suppoaedly
deaeived her ae to the "cond,i.t:ion and amenities of
property" and caul'!ed her to e:xpend $100 in aleatriaal
work "which defendant stAted eXJ.sted but did not; [] "I
g) Plaintif~ doee not aver when, where and how
Defendant allegedly demonetrated a "willful dieregard of
property" or how Ol' why ehe lost wages as a result: of
"poor landlol"dshiplll and
h) Plaintiff does not:. claim why ahe is entitled to
the return of a security deposit,
2
3 I l'l~~nt:!f.f' t3 CJol1lpl<\inl: I:q.tll'l \:0 aver oognht\ple 01llil1lEl 01:
oa\.\/3E1/3 of o\ol:!on whioh, H pr.oved, wo\.\lq en\:it:le h!3r to tIny 1-"elief I
a) \:he olail1l for t\ violt\tion of her right: to privaoy
oannot: IJe bt\l'leq on eending Pl\l"po.l:t:edly fa he I'lt:atement:13
\:h+-o\.\g)) (:he maUl'll
\;1) the allegu\::Lon that Mr, !(epner Ildeceivec\
l'l&intif:t: regarC\il1g cond.l tion and ameni tiell of propel:ty,
c&l\l3ing ('laintiff $100,00 in eleotl.'ic&l WOI~)t which
qefendant l3t:uted e:X.ll3l:ec\ but c\id not: (] II maltes no Ilenae
anc\ il'l not a legal grounds for reliefl
0) IIPOOl" landlorc\l3hipll is not a basifJ upon wh.i.oh the
Defendant may be founc\ oivilly oulpablel and.
c\) the boilerplate c\emanc\ for ret:urn of 13eourit:y
deposi t mUElt be c\il3n1il3l3ec\ ou\:right: beoause no reasone al:e
alleged to l3upport t:his demanc\.
1\, F'ul"ther, Plaintiff allegel3 that Defendant violated the
feder<\l F'air Debt Colleotion Practicel3 Act, whioh cause of action
muy not be brought: in a penneyl vania COUI:t and therefore mUl3t be
dil3mil3Eled. .
WI'(liJRliJlPOHE, Defendant respectfully al3ka that YOUl" 1I0norable
COUl"t !'lul3t:ain the preliminary obj ections in the nat:ltl:e of: a
demurrer (:0 all causeEl of action and dismiss Plaintiff' e Complaint,
3
I'
il. Pre1iminflr~_Qbieol:iQ.n in the l~ot'nl of. a Motion to Stroik€!
QQJnplaint for Nonoonf.onnanoe to RUles of. L'<lW anq Court.
5, First:, the oampl,dnt f:<lDa to Allege l:he time <lnd Pl<loe of
<lny of. the events aompla,ined of: or the ,items of speai<ll damage, <Ill
of. whiah .is odt:.ioal to <lny <If.f.irm<lt:ive ple<lding and required by
the rUles, "Averments of: time, plaae and items of speaial d<lmage
shall be speaifiaally stated," Pa,R,Civ.p, 1019(f).
6. Second, the aomplaint fails to <lver them<lterial facts in
a conaise <lnd al.1111l11ary f:01."m aa required b}T P<I.R,CiV.p, 1019(<1) I
"~l'he mat:er~.al faat/Jon whiah a aause of aation or defense is bal3ed
I3h<ll1 be I3tated in a aona.iae and 13~lmm<1ry form," A aompl<1int mllst
be sUffiaiently spoaifia so <113 to enable the defend<1nt to prepare
<I response and to defend <1g<1inel: the aation, Material faate are
those wh,iah are essential to proving l:he alaim, Here, abeolutely
no material faats are alleged,
7, 'rhird, the aomplaint cloeo not aont!'lin sepnrate aounts for
the sep!'lrate aaUl3es of aat:ian !'Illeged. "UJ!'Ioh Oause of aotion shall
be st!'lted in a separate aount aontain,ing a demand for relief,"
Pn,R,civ,p, 1020(8), Several causes of action are set forth on one
page with no distinction made between them.
n, l~ourth, although Pla,int.lff makes referenoes to several
"
di,t:ferent W;t":Ltings, none are appended to the oompl<\int in violation
of Pa,R, Civ. P, 1019 (h) I "['1'] he pleader shall attach a aOI?Y of the
wri ting, 01." the mate1."ial part thereof, but if the wrHing 01: COP}'
4
i~ not &ooeQQible to him, it i~ Q~ffioient so to Q~~te, together
with ~he rea~on, ~"d to set for~h the ~~b~tanoe of the writing,"
9, l~.tfth, \:he oomplaint: is no\: verified by Pl~intiff in
Viol/1t.ion of H/1,n,civ,p, 10211(a) I "EJvery pleading oontaining an
avel:ment of flwt not E\ppear.ing of l:eoOl"d in the aotion or
oontaining a denial 01: 1;aot shall atate thaI: t.he averment or dcmial
.is true llpon the signer' ~1 p8r80n/11 knoWledge or inform~t.1.on and
belief and sh~ll be ved.fJ.ed, " No ved.HoElUon is attaohed \:0 the
oomplaint: .
10, The oOl11plEl.1.nt: flagrantly v.1.oll\teQ numerous Rules of C.1.vil
Prooedure Elnd thus mu~t IJe st:l"iolten for nonoonformanoE:,
WHlilRIWOREJ, Defendant re~peotj;ully Elsks that Your Honorable
Court su~tain the preliminElry objection Elnd grant the motion to
strilte Plaintiff's Complaint for nonoonformanoe to rules of law and
oourt ,
ill, Pl"eliminal"y -!2Q.1eoUon _in the Nature of. a Mot,1.on to Stdlte
ImlJert.1.nent MEltj:f.ll:
11 , PElrElgraph 4 of the oomplElint: avers as follows I "'1'he
Defendnnt, aEl deoreed by Distdot Justice Manlove, Cumbel"land
County, was awarded zero dollars for cOlmtel"-complaint filed
12/1/90. Defendant: thus must return a sum in the amount of
$460,00, as established in Court,"
12, '1'he instant aompla.1.nt established a de novo ~ction .1.n
Ii
",j"
I'
WlmRlilFORPl, pellendAl1l: ~ef.lj.Jeotf\.\llY l\l'lkll t:hl\t \,our IlonorAPle
com.'t: f.l\.If.ltOlin t:he j.Jrel:1.minAry objl'lotion <10cl Brant the mot:ton llo
Jtrike p~~intiff's Co~pldint far insuffioient: ej.Jeoifiaity or, in
the alternative, require th<1t <1n <1mencleCl,oomplain\: be filec\,
,
RPl8PJjJC'l'F'ULLY .8U13MI'l''l'IJlO I'
"
N ~
~ L, Ac\ I'll', squ
APLliln &. CLTlRAVlIL
125 LoaUet: street/P,O, Box't1933
Ii~rdaburg, 1'1\ 17100-1933
Phone I (717) ;l34.3;l09
D1\'l'IilO I
,'luna
d
-L
199~,
"
"
"
"
" "
,;1'
"
,
"
"
,
I,
, "
7
~ ("I
"'" ~
" I'
\_1 ~ r'ii
~.;) ~3:
J,' :r::
r'T' 1\.0 r'~Q
III l'l :1,' \@.
(~J: I ~ffi "'I
"\11 ,E!j
1- '
r.: &;'j
ll. m
.1
"
"
...---.....
I,
~
~ ~
;> ~ '
ct1 ~ W ~ ,~
~\:i~~IIV~':
S~~~~i.~~
P.1 eo~,]fdi
::I ~~n:~ c~
~ ' ~
"
, "
".,
"
.1"
"
"
.
.
1IP/lR'rMENT LEl/lSEl /lQREmNEN'I'
11reaahof lease shall. I>ll sllffioiunt in the event: th/lt the f.al1cUorcl shl\ll lmvs the right
to ccmnance /In 1\I11iC<\l>le I\otion pf mjaatment: far t:he prem1.ses tlesaribecl he1:ein, 4ncl
Tenant hereby a\1\:hor;l.zecl lInd E!lIWl'Grl'l An!!, at:torne~ 1:0 fl1,gn sAid /lmiC<\bla /lotion of
Ejectment of Tenant:' a lJeI\lIlf, It shl\ll bs laWful for the Protllonol:l\l1' of the Court
in \~hioh suoh notion is IJrought, nne'! he ill lJehlllf. It slmll be l<1Wflll for the
P~ot:llonQt:ary of \:he ~urt: in whioh suah nation ill bro\1gh\:, nne'! he is hereb~ requestecl
by the ,1J.'enant to enter saie'! /Il11iC<\ble oot:ion of InjsoLment, IIncl Also ta enter j\.1c'lgman\:for
the r;/\ncUorcl Py canfeallion against: the 'l'ennnt, w,1.thol.\t: any stay of Bllemltion, felr the
recove.ry of \.:lIe J:lOssession of the sa.id llpart:ment, wit:ll judgn~nt: also for all. unpail'l rant:,
13, Rules allq Re<Tulat.1.ons. Tenant agreell t:l1l\t he, his 1!amil~ ane'! gues\:s will CCl11J?ly \'11th
the rules and regulations perl:l\ining to oaoupanoy of tll13 apartment V~liah Sl.e &tt!1ched IlOre\:U
ane'! made II par.t of this lease,
14, SUbor.dinat.ion, 1J.1U.1l lease is subjeot: ane'! subordinate to the lien of aU mortgages
now or at: any t.ime hereafter. plaoecl upon Any parr. of Landlorcl' s whJ.oh inoludeB tlle
IIpartrnent, to elftenaions or renSll'als t11eroof, ane'! to all adv/lnoes now or hereafter f1\IIde
on the security t:lle.rof, Tenant Agrees, upon request:, to exsout:e such further instn1l1Pntfl
ev.idenoing suoh subordination as Landlord may request, anq i.f Tenant fll.t1s to do sa.
Lan<Uord is eI11l:lO\l'G.I."Ed to do sa in t:lle name of Tenant,
15. See I3elow*
, IN WITltNE:9S Wlrn:nmF, '.l'hs parl:J.es hereta have set t:lleir l1l\nda and seals the da!!, and year
fir~tabove written.
i U)~
,~~
1J.'ENlW1'
IJINDIDRo,
flY
~ ;;: Kef~e,.
OOMMONWi=Al,TH PF PF.NNSY~VANIA
. OOUNTY of cmmJ.U~t.MJD
l,IMIl.ljO,1
Q9-1-0;a
llJtl"l"IIIo~
nOBBlI.',J.1 V, HANLOVl{
~"I 19Q1 /J'l'A'.l'1$ 13'l'Rl$~'J)
~NJ.> nUf!, l,1~
T.kpl>lO" (717 )76:\.-Q5113
mvu. COMPl.AINT
~,AINTlFFI tll.MQ ,""~oonuQ
IlA '( KEl'NER
533 G~~t!nVIll\i 4\V\':
OlUll' IIIl.I. 1'4\ 1701.1
l-
'1
17Q11-0000
neFeNDANT;
r
VQ,
/l/J,lKlI1<l ~oonuq
.J
-,
AMOUNT pATa r~
FI~INCl OOSTB . JtL 50 '__-, 1
" ,SQAWIt:1 COBTe . .,'hOD .' I, I-=:..
lOTA~ , 53,50 1211 12.!!....
TO THF. PEI=i=NPANTI Tile alJove named plalnll"(s) esl<e Judgment agEllnal you for $169, on .togeiiiB'rW1I11
789 00 oasIs uponll1e following olall11 (Olvllllnes mustlnoll.lda ollallon olll1e stalule or oraJmll1oe
53' 50 008'1'S' vlolated)1 _____--~ .
, at . 50 . " 'l'IlNAN'r nl~lIAOIln::LANIl LORD' tl.. l'I\Ol'lmTY llY I'I,ACING DllCALS PN
, 12, TOTAl. \1111' 1l001lS 1UI\1 IN Tl\E IIATIlROOH. l'Eil~IISSIaN WAS NEVER GllAN'rED FOR
'l'ENAN'l' '1'0 I'AIN1~ Oll..1\EDECORATIl,'rO ItIlR llEflIl\E, IIEll I'WI' oNr
RIIINlW I,IVING ROO~I CARI'E'l' Am I'ADDING WHICII IIAD TO liE
1\lll'I.AOED,
WIlNDY Il, 1l1~1"1'~lnl
27 S, 24TH WI'
1- CMII' IIILL I'A 17011 .J
IJoollet NO~...pqrrr:cT~ .'
Pale Flledl 12~1~98 .. '
.--- -
,
.... /'
,,'
EX H-16 1"- 10
"
I, RAY KIlPl>Illli. verify Il1alll1e faols sel lorlhln 1I11a oomplalnt aro IruB And
correot 10 the beal of my Imowledge, Inlormallon, and belief, This atatemenlls Illade aUbJaollo 1110 ponallles of
8801l0n4904 of tile Crl[nes Code (10 r~(I, S,OA, 9 4904) relaleello unsworn falslfloat/on 10 authorllles,
~. ',/,'
e.
una UfO 0 an
Plalnllfts
A tOrRSVI
AdtlrosBI
T.l.ph~nnl
,l-- -
If: YOU INTEND TO ENTER A DEFENSE TO THIS OOMPLAINT, NOTIFY THIS OFFIOE IMMEDIATELY AT THE ABOV!:: .
TELEPHONE NUMBER, yOU MUST APPEAR AT THE HEARING AND PRESENT YOUR DEFENSE, UNLESS YOU DO,
JUDGMENT WIl.L BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU BY DEFAULT,
,
If YOIJ I1l\ve Q oluhll agalnslll1e plaint/II wl1loh Is wllhln c1letrlol!Ust/lle ,urloellot/on and whloh you Intend
10 aseort at the hearing, you musl fila It on a oomplalnt 10rll1 0 Ihls 0 IIoe at laast five (5j days belore
1110 dalll eot for Ihe hoarlng, If you hnve a olahn against the plalr"'" whloh Is not wllliln dlslrlot jus lies '
lutledlot/on, YOIJ lI1ay roquosllnlotmallon Itoll111110 oflloe as 10 Ihe prooedures you may follow, II you
ato disabled and require aeslstnnoo, plenoo oontaot tho Mngletal'Inl Dlslrlot ollloe at the nddross
obove.
~
Aore aOQA.94
, ' ." '. '" ,., .'..., f ".,
NOTIO!: OF Oi~~~~TrrRAN~PR(~t:.
r,J.AINTlFF: / NAMU ,n<l ~IIV~U60 ' ':,,"'"
Ind'>lflu~, UY " ,. . .". ..'J.
5~3 GN~NDVIKW ~~ .
CAM~ flIItI., ~.lI. 17111:1.
l-.
" . vs, .
,12.IlFIlNDANT: ' NAMU 'n<lAUuHU66
~RI.TZRN, WHWPY 0
27 a ~14'l'H a'l'RER'l1
CAMP HJ;I~II, VA 170:1.1
1-
Docllal No,: OV- 0000,",,93 - 90
Dalo Flied: 12/01/!l0
OOMMONWi:At,TH OF r~i:NNSYl..VAN'A
OOUNTY OF\.-.. OUMJlBRI.A~ . r
~~i, (1'11./10.1 . .
. ll9-blll!
PJt~ll1\'1 Ilon,
ROHBR'll V. ~NI.OVR
tI<kJI.." lUlll IlTM!U ll'l'R.BB'l'
'.';",."i'>'~"'I,."..,,~HI.', J.;rI~J,1 V,l\ "I'''' ,
' I', I ': ,\ .~ , ' ::: ~,'_ . ;' .. /,' , , 1,:" '. t,. -: ' .' '. . . -:' .
.; " T,ilPltollil'17;1.7)' 761-115113 . l'/01;L,llOOll
'.'1' .
',' -,------
~DY D. IlUI.TZBR
27 a 24TH I'I':\,'RBR'l'
CAMP UIr~I., PA 17011
,"
,1~\1
, ".. '. .,.THIS IB TP NOTIFY you THATI -', '~""', ....... ':"_~" ,I,'''. ,.". ._,.. _. .,.._
Juclomanl: E'P\I PI.ATNlJ.IID'D'
IXJ Judomanl waa anlarac! for: (Nama) -lt1!lJ!.NlUl..--llA:'L-
iii Judomant waS ontorad aoall1al: (Nl1mo) -BRLlJ.!ZEI4_I'/RNDV n
In llla amount of $ no.. on: (Dala of Judoment)
!l/:l~ Il}g
, .
o Potondllnla IUO jointly and aevorelly liable,
0' Damagea will be aasaased on:
(Dalo & Time)
;\
Amcunl 01 ,Judgment
Judomant Ooala
Inlereal on JUdument
Attorney Faea
Total
, ,
,
o Tllla oase dlem/aeed wltl10ul prejudice, ., '
','.
, '
O Amount 01 ,Judomenl Sllbject 10
Altaol1msnVAcl 5 of 1996 $,_. e'
o Levy Is slayed for days or 0 generally slays,d,
Post Jlldoment Credits
Poal Judoment Cosls
, "
Cerllfled Judoment Total $.
". .0 Ob!SOllO!lto levy haa been!lIed anc~ Ile,mlno will bellol?:.
Dille;
Time:
- PI""" 6Xf118rr
H .'.."......_...............,..._.\'-_.,...,.......
.J
.l
.J
.
. . ~ '.', ..,. , -. ., 11, . r-' '... . ..... . ..
----
'.,...--
$,
$
$
$
$
.ill)
-t.!lll
.OQ
.00
.00
$
$--,--
==== =RCU:lI:U:U~R
. ~. ,"
1/
ANY PAnTY HAS TIll! RIGHT 1'0 APPI!AL WlnllN 30 OA YB Af'TF.f1 TIll! I!NTRY OF JUDGMI!NT BY "ILING A NOTloll
01' APpeAl.. WITH THe pR01l10
MUST INOLUDI! A OOl'Y OF THI
~~~ Dale
I corllfy Illat Il1ls Is a Irue and
Qf;;JJQ9- Dote .~
My commission explrss flrsl Monday of Jnnuary,
AOI'C 3' 6.ge
, :1000
v.. .,W
I:
'1/;
" I'll'; "
.-"
l','
r:'cl .
L, I, ,1.1"
'/: I In
i.J II
,/ , I
Ii IIi ! r h
"f : ',.J
"'-1.
L" 1'-:",
') O~
"
I'
'J;
,I>,
~.
I
"
II'}
,'1,
'....f,
\\ ~ '.j,
~ C"J
1\";
! l:iJ
'I, ,l~
j.,:
,:)
U
,';
"
,
'j,
i\
;,
I'
"
"
i!
i'
"
q
"
"
I
h(
i'
I'
"
"
i;
11 "
;11
"
"
H
II
"
"
"
,',I"
"
" ""
IL
,n
.i'
i".
;,
";,
ii
'Ii 1\
i\
"
h
"
'.
,,'
':
1,1
If,.
!\
I",;
;,
'I
.'
,t;
,
';
r" ,
, ,
'"
'i,
'j.
"
!'I
"
" ,
" ,
,
'i.-
I';.
,
,i! , , ,
H
;';
"
. ,
" , , ,
i,
it;
,
;, I , " ,
,
H
.,
;'."
/I
I
I
,
,
I
I
"
,I'.
~! CI\ '~ "
..:t
.. ~;l"1t
;;: H~
~W if5i .. ~
I\~;:
. 1", ~~ :;;5ai
~r N I~ "'''''
.I~ ~ Cd fp.
~:l.
F' ell
l5 m u
t\J
<i'
"
il,
"
'. "
;,
I'
Ii
"
,',
,',
"
\\
;d
,I
"
"
ii
i,'
;'
;,
>!
"
I"
""
"
!!
,,'
j,
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
'i, I,
.I \
I'
"
,,"
"
".1'
i',
"
"11
",.j,
..
"
Ii
"
"
Ii" "
n
H
,i'
'.\
""
i!
!'.
"
"
Ij
,.
~~~~~I~'~l!r~-'!l_Ii!!'~~.~IA .... .
COUAT or COMMON NIAI
NOTlCII 0' APPIIA~
fROM
____~._..___._.._..____..h_..__.....___......_ __...
PIITIIICT JUITlCII JLlIlUMIINT
u, call1MOIi rUAI N~nCH~.J5qLCl\ttJ..TemL
NOTlcll Of APPIlA~ 3, 18'- qq
Nolle. I, ~IVIln Ihollho I1l'pollonllll1l fIIod In Ih. "boyo C,lU" of Comn1<ln "1011, (1I1ul'pool from Iho II,dumonl ,o'i1ler,,! by Iho Pb"I'I Ju.llco OI1lh.
dc,I. llIl<lllllh. co,. monllon.d bol,lVtI
JUnlCIAI PI,,"I"
1UA1I'~'V~te~;(1-\--1)~--~~~I"l---;'; .n---.........--(;.i)-,~(.~mlli.i.. i.....-------[Mi?)rll\-~iM~O/o;;.=-------
-OOfl"o/.if1f/oNf'--~'-""'-;:)"q'CF--';: :.~.:.-.-._.....--.. ......-rllv----.--..-----.--.-..-J1A11------.--:''Cil
~II.,,- v J.-.:---'="-:-nl~l~flU0/7",.,,~ij-~......:~,-:;-----.~-...-..n-...-.-...-n..-,('")-.__.__..f.., .:1'-~i" ./1 (\
( ':J'~ (]>(I\ ,:I'Qf.\cL ~,t' \ L: ((I '-I"(~~, k t' '-)(\r.:' ('
. ..z,..'oL ..::L-----.-.-.;.l..r;-~~J~~~;.-......\..--....---........--. l;;..HAuflMIO '''1il~1-IfJ>1mn!f~. , -.nfllr'....-------
CV lP.__":'L.:L..---1.lo1__,.. / )"~,.., " ...,
( )
1~~~~ek wllft1 :~;~f"ONLy~~~'jj~I~';~;IQth,i; fi;;;q,ii,j,(fUnJ.,-jlu"it,p.Jp;cNn, . ;If-,~~"was "0 ~ IMANT(siiirii,-ii,c,PJ,P,"No.-
Thl, Nolle. pf AI~lO"', whon reeolVlld I>y Ihe Dlllrlcl JUlllee, will opo",Ie "'" ,,1001 (6) 111 uel/oll 10m (Jls/rlot Just/eo, 110 MUST
SUP~RseDEAS 10 Iho judu,,,e,,I 10/ I'o"e,,'on In Ihl, CmB FILE A COMPLAllfl, wlI/lllI ,wollty (20) (/U)11I Ill/or
--.-----..---sliiiliii'iiii"mciilliliiiiljiiVi~-lliit,'ry...-u.--n..-.--- fI/lm} Ills NOTICE 01 APPEAL.
...,.---.----.---.-.---------___.___._.._____..._n_.___.~_h..___________
------.--..--.-.----PRAi-i,jpft"OENTEil.'itULlfTO-,-ji,jj-COMPLAINT ANPRULif"OflLr------
(TIlls Sor.l/OII ollCHIII/olllJ 115afl ONl,y W/I011 /IlVlllllnlllwns OIII'I,NOIiNT Isoo I~I, /1.0./',,/,1', No, tOOl(7) III 1/GlloII voloro IJ/ulrlnl Jusllao,
IF NOT IJSIIIJ, rlo/IHlIi I/(~II orv,y 01 111111011 01 fl/VlOnlln 1m S(l/vorl"I)(~1 IIp/lIJllml},
PRAIlCIPE, To "rolhO/lIIlory
~nl.r lulo upon _.___________.
M~IIO 01 lI/yHllk](l(a'
) within IWll"Iy (20) d"y" nffol I.,vlce of ,ulo or lulfol ontry of Judomonl of nen pro.
-- , "1'1'0110.(1), 10 fIIo " eOlllplolnl In Ihllul'l'o(~
ICO/11rnon Pion, No. ____________,
S/(1llltlro oIlV,>oII..~11 (II IIJs attornoy LV riU<<i
RULI, To _.___.___..___________, "1~lolloo(I),
Mwno 01 f'IY'JO/loof' J
(1) You om "ollnod IIl111 II lulo II homby o"le,od upon ynu 10 11I00 eOl11pl"lnlln Ihllul'!,enl within lWOI"Y 120) doy. nff", Iho duI. "f
IIlYIc. of Ihlllulo upo" you by po"onol.o"lc. '" by eo,lInod or ,oohlo,od "",II,
(2)11 you do "01 fIIo " <.or"p'"lnl within Ihll 11m., " JUDGMENT OF NON pnos WILL DE ENTEReD AGAINST yOU,
(3) Th. d"III 01 .."ko of Ihl"ulo II lOIVleo 1\'<1' hy m,,1I11 Iho dolo of 111011lno,
Dote:
__,1\'.__,
ll'llll.hm 0/ 1luI/""_r or /JopIIy
NJf'C1tIl.lJ4
COURT FILE TO DE PILEb WITH I'ROTliONOTARY
j
~
"', ~ lf)
0~~~~
... i:: , ~ ~
N .. ~
.. rt) .
- "." -,-j [? t"'
.\';' C,):OI,.!
(1".',
,1.: ~;I. ~ 3
' t I,);;.) '\1
'. fi ",
'o.. . ~jl: co .,j'in c:x
,.- j';;.
f.''': P' "., 1(}
fJ..lU 1','iJ
-1: Ink
f..: ~.:
~ ,.
(r, ~~j
LT, (..)
"_____11I '......_."'m".:.~~_....'-_'''''i!_..~' U01;lIlldwIWIUI.IUJlIlIIiI ^I'l
. --- -,............_---., .,. -.-- .... ...._---~.~.-
IIIIWllI/HUI/II
1)III1IU ~'IIM IMVf1!JjI,/IIlIII(\\ UIOII)(/ H'P'J/(ljlllllll/UIII,/S'
. -. ---+-~-~..... .._. ~"_r"___'_',_,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,_,___,~,_~__~___,___~",,_,,,_,_,_
/11U1/I1I/U Olll/lllill,S
...........lll '...m.. ' .......-..-... ell) ,1.Vf.1 flll II
,W-I :1I11):mn n'lIl1l1DiJlll1l: "IN (U,II"1l1UIV) '-IIIOMlJ
'ujnHll1 PnlPlJlllJ IdJu;l/u {j,H1pIHl~1 III 1/11 I ,
(1'''11I1''111''') (pOIIIIHlo) ~'! (J "'*'''R l'lIHlfllOcJ Aq [] .. -''''''lll I............ ........'...............-.-...: ......... Il" P"Rt.lUPflll SliM IJI"lJ "'II
''''''1M UI (O)II(JII",I,lu nqllH)iJll I"!H'r1V 10 illJlI"N 'IM''!1I 0'11 nIlIAllI/r1I1HHH/j, IIII"IIII""D "nllJ "I nl"l1 \I'll P'MJIln IIUlII JlJlIPIlI 1'''" U
'olnHlq poq""IIUldlOllllJ 11,1111'111111 'ill/III ("nWIOIU,U) (1'"1111.1<)0) ~II [IIHl'^H\lIfllll"I'Hllf Aq r:J ...'......(;1 ' "'...
Ill" ,.....-.._.._................_.........__........._,........__............~-_..."....... ........ (/JlfllI,ii 'OOIlUlld" (IIi1ll1l1ll1 pllll 'UIIIIIIII 111'11"111111 IllfUWll
II,II)PIIIIII '1I1l111 (pOllllollllll) (110111111I0) ~II 'r.J UOI^Ill11IUIII)lllnd ~II [I ,.......'.........",.......-cc-'........... ...........'.. '(/JIIIA""II" "'lll)}
IIn llldllHIl pOj\llJfllliUp, I1Ullllnf' IOIJlfllU 0111 undll1 ._...~~.---.. ._..'....h.~ 'ON, IJlHlld llnlllUlO:) '1lImlclv 10 IHlIIIlN lllll II") Adoo II Ll
PO^'Ul1lll1llll\lIIlIIJ lO ,1Il1lMU Aql1wq I :.LI^VOlcldV
"I
,IOAHmoo
,I
\fINV^'AUNNUd dO 1l.l.1V,lMNOI~I~OO
(S,JWO'/ Ofll,,,,!!,I'/1I ;PIlll:) 'fuoddu I" /JIIIIOIl'"IIIiIlIlIlIl.'/,ldV f,',\ WI (0/) N'/./ NII/1 1M unfd:/fI ./ i,'I1IV '/tlI"'''''/IIIC11J/tll!llfI.I
"
J..NIV1dWOO ::111d 01 31nu ONV 1VtJddV dO 3:lI.iON :10 EJOIAlHlS:lO "OOUll
--
.,
--------.,---.-,'T1"'"_...___.....
"
if, '. oJ
,
QOMMONWf:AI.TlI OF Pf:NNHYI.VANIA
OOUNTY OFL_'?I~l.l~I!!,Mm
MiU.~:---t::==:.:.:.~----";"~;":=;;,::,c:-~~'~;:;:;-..::;.;.;.=.:;:;-=.;.._---_.t:.:.:.+_.~
, 09-1-02
HOORRT V. ~~N~oV~
~l<J,,,,, 1901 1l'1'A'1'~ rN'R~W1'
~HP 111M;. l''''
T'''rl~n" (717) 761- 0503
17011- 0000
~o'n.oJ: OF Oi~~'W(JiTITRAN60R'PT
'!,A'N11I"', lii.M"'""^llIIlI"1I11
rIlR~11'klRn, WFfNPY P -I
:17 a :14'1'11 aI1'R~R'1'
OAfofl' un;r;, Ph 1711U
L
VS,
PI:FgNOANr: fj^~\I! "'''^IJIIIIli61l
rjbm~Rn, n...y
533 GRANPVIRW ~VR
OAfofP llIr,r" PA 17011
1-
.J
1J.INo1In9: !lull
---.-----.-
I
WENDY D. IlUr.TklRR
:17 a l\4'1'1I ll'l'ltnR'l'
OAMP III~L, 1'.1\. 1'1011
IJool\ot No,: av- 0000493 -!lll
Polo Flloel: 1/07/99
Of~OS8 .9.QMI:'.[.AINJ:_..!!Q.L._...
_J
'*
THIS IS TO NOTII'Y yOU TliAl"
,Juclomol1l: -J!.OlLDBU.RNIlAN!C__,
IXl Juclomol1t woo 011101'0(1101': (Nomo) -1CJUlNER,-lU\.Y--___
[i] JuelOlllol1t woo ol1lorocl uooll1at: (Namo) --flli1L'l!Z1ill.__WENDLD__._________.
111 tho amoul11 01 $ ---~n 0_ 011: (lJolo 01 Judomol1l) _21-l\3,LnlL___
o Dolol1dol1ts oro Joll1t1y omJ sovomlly 1I0blo, (Dolo & l'lmo) ___~.___u____.
r.:J Dmlluoos will bo ossosuocl 011: Amoul1l of Judomol1t $__-&0
JUdomont Oosts $_---L{U)
O Illtorost 011 Judomol1l $ .00
This oouo dlsmlsuod without projudloo, A I' $ n.o
1I0rnoy '000 ,,___U!
TOlol $__-&0
O AmoUl1t of Judornol11 SulJjoollo
AlloolllllOl1l1Aol Ii of 1000 $___ __________
o Lovy Is stayod for doya or [J OOl1erally stoyod,
Posl .lmlomol1l erudlts
Po at ,JudOlllOI1I Oosta
$---
$
== tltmtu::;=tlt:= =
o Ob/uollon to levy has buon fIIod anelhoarlng Will bo hold:
Dolo: ._________..__11 Plaon:
Tlmo:
- -.I.: -
Oerllfled JUdgment Totel $
]
ANV PARTV HAS Tlil! RIGHT TO AI' 'AL
01' APPEAl. WITt, Tlill PROTtlo TA
MUST INOLUOfl A OOPV OF THI I
ala3ICl~L_ Do to _u_
I oortlfy lhollhls 10 nlruo on
;;JJr2t3f-rJ-" Duln _.__
-f'l-!-
, Dlstrlot .Jualloo
110 proooO(II110s oOl1lalnln[J 1110 judgll1onl.
( ___._, IJlslrlol Juslloo
My cOl11l11lsslOI1 oxplrus llral Monday 01 Jnnunry,
AOPO 31 o.on
:.1000
SEAL
''11>..""
COMMONW'^\TIt 0' p'NNn\V^NIA
---.----Cliiilif p~QNPi'M
NOTlC" of APP~A~
fROM
PIST"ICT Jl.lliTlC;~ JIJPOM~NT
-==~:::===-=::--=:=:=.::.=:::-:':::~::::::~'-'::':.:"~::'-........,.- _..h______..nc~~~~.\!~.~':,{:IJ:.J1i~}LJ~.l 'Li.LJ~~.
NOTlCIl Of APPIlAJ, 3, m.. (1(7 .
Nallcq II olVlln IhuI Ih. uPf'.lklnl 11<11 fU.,lln Ih. ,,!>avo Cau'I 01 Call1ll1a', rl.," "" opp.nl fr<ll1' Ih. ludomonl ,oncl...cl hy Ih. PIIl,lcI J,lllk. a" Ih.
dole "nd In Ih. CUll monllanocl b.I"",
l~PICIA\ PlmlCT
'OO\f'Nv~rl~ f \ I, t \ . \'~;~~I-I~~:~n___--('~~-~i-I'ii--"-"--J'!C~T~~OAjMl~N~~ l) ---
-;mm~r---;-:-I--"~~--i\-\----::-'----'----'--fi1'Y--"--'--"- --"t~rr-----------W~l5lif-
'li\ltCll"', ,q,' Jr-----:..:...-J~~l\m1,1 'm71l"""r" \_-~:-:-:------,-_.._....._._-;~-iJ---'7~"hi"idiiJ----o,1 --.1l~~
':1,(1,'\'\ \JI"I"I ;\,11,'11 /(\1/ ",'j,.ll'h..,I.I,."I.I')
1UbrnIr'- --- 1-\ \ \ -;-,-~I-~:"-' .-----.- ~J./A/iilf\"m~rpJ1ln;ffOllf:<l,r,j nllf1\f ------
CV1~ ',' i__..II,,'I. I'\)l ,{} ,(.". ..\',,"~
Thllplcck wnrt~ :1:I;;d ONLY ;~I~~I~Ilo;;"t;;c,ui'.d'i;-"'I.r\r"i:R-:-C-:-r:J.i\~"- /ff 1I1~~ltiih\vii~{c7.~'IMANT(seii I'll. {~~:r,J,p, No.
100011. '',,/'\\'" " "',,''',,\'''' ( \
Thll Nallc. of Ap".al, wh.n I.c.lv.cl by Ih. DI,Irlcl JUllle., W111'~)."II. ,,' <I 1001(6NI~ootlonl>i'O(O (JIStr{Qtl'~f/JtI(Je, 110 MUST
SUraRSEDEAS 10 tho Judomonl far pano"lanln Ihll ema . FIL/: A COMPLAINT' wlt/l/n twenty (20) clays aller
_" (~ ,~=-=>-=''''_.__.___'_' fI/llla Ills NOTICe 01 APpeAL,
"'_\-- . ... lJ'Ollll/I/{(J Or r1rop0l1otflfY 01 IJO{JHIY
l1-cc,,' -A CI~ii ~~t-it~1~1.~ ';'~-fl;;~~~;~~INT ANDRUI.Il TO flU -----
{Tills soot/all ollm\)/ll /.Ie IIsed ONLY w)~e~IIH)O/l1l1l1 WIIS PliFf;NIJANT Isoo I'n. RpP.,I./'. No, 100/(7)11/ (WI/Oil /.laiD/(! IJ/slrlol ,/IISI/oo,
IF NOT USEIJ, 'If,oo'\'rortl oCV'Y of Ilot/no r{llt~)OIlIIO /Jo sOlyad IlpOll IIHJO/loO),
PJlAIlClPIl, T" prolho""IulY ,,)
Enl.r rul. ul'en
N~,IO vlllry-;;;iiOo(s)--"--- .
, "1'1'.11..111, 10 fll. U eompkllnt In Ihh app.ul
ICommon rl.", No.
) wllhln lwenly (20) d"YI 1f1)I'Xl~..~,~71:,or IIlff.r .nlry of ludom."t of Il<lI1 f>'"
I S~I<l'I4'a tl1 lIIyHiiiiViliir IliS alttlmcy 01 ft(JOflf
RUU, To,
NNIW ollll''1OIIoc(sJ
-__,01'1'011..11),
(11 You 01. nollfl.d 111<11 "rul. II h.l.by ."I.I.d upon you I" fII. u campl"I"I In Ihll ul'f'.,,1 wllhln twenly 120) d"YI "tI.r Ih. d"I. "f
'Ofvle. of Ihl. nil. upor, you by fltIllanal,.rvk. C/ hy c.,IIf1.d 01 l.o1'I.r.d ,""II.
(2111 you dll nol fII. u eC/,'plulnt wllhln Ihll lime, " JUDGMENT OF NON 1'1105 WILL liE ENTEflf,D AGAINST YOU,
,ii
(3) Th. cl"l. Ilf ..rvlc. ollhl, lul. If '.,vl,. wa. by ,"ull II Ih. d"Ie of I11<llllng.
',.)ltel_.
,19_.
&\111II>.. oIl\t>UIWoury .. l>Iputy
I:
N>ro 3U.(\4
COUIlT PILE
~.--......_._.._~.--._.._._..._-......--_._..
-----...~--~.-..-...~_._--_.._-_..-._---_.-
PROOF Of Sf:RVloa: or NOTICE Of APPI:Al AND nUI.a: TO Fll.I!COMPI.AINT
(1/1/', /1111111 III !illll'I"" AlP,'; I III 1-11 ill WIIIIIN II:N I 'O! 1M \'.'1 A/ I UIIillllll111(1 1111""" ", "1'1'''''/, r:III",h ",.,.Ii,o<"'flllll!\".)
(:OMMllllWI'AI111 1l11'/iNNfi),;.:ANIA
(,ClIJNH Of-, ~I,\\"l\ htl' ~_\.
;111
AFFIDAVIT: 111I""hy f'IVtl/IIIl: /lllilllllllllll "OIVIII' (" . I
" /,q I S'l .
lJ 1\ ('opy (11 II III Nlllllil) (I,,^PIHI'~' 1'''''"111111 1'111,\11 1>111 '.. ..- , _ I '"II1"\tlllll)llI~il~I.IWllh:\1 dtl!illJlllllo(llllUltllll on
I \ llllll11 1"'1,," 1'1"") . ,,;) I ,;1.;) I'},. .., .., . H "I' PI" "111111' ",""il" I U..lI1'fl(:1I111111111i 1IIIIIISIllllIIU /111111, ~lIll1lcl'fi
1111""/11 !'l'ad~lIllll1l1l1ll1, 1I11t1l1i:III'1I1\1 "/1/1111""" 1/1111/1,,) . 1"~l'r'I'\\P.' ~ . .r,k-'~f'ly.I~_."..- ,.._ ... .."., ""
~l' ..1.. '.n I HI q _ L. 1.1 by PIII'IHIII/lIIIlIlVlcl(~Y (c(1flllllltfl (fllIlIBlulfld) 11111111 tluncltll'h ItHlulpt l\ttlwllnd tUlluln.
IJ 11IHllmllulIlIwllul1l vpd Ihl1l11llo1o I'lhlll CII,,,plullll jll~ld,rnptlll'ldllll Ihl' nlHlv(1 NlIlll,tl of ^PJlHfllllpon tho IIPpnlllltl(nl to WIHlItl
, lIullhllo WII!i IHll"tlH~\tlllllll . , 111__.... ,1.I!ly I'tll'liOllUllllllVlt:o 1llIY (I.llllltiud) '(/tIl1lnltllll(l)
fllIIl!. 1"'lIdol':1 rut nll't nllnt:lH'd 11\Iw\l! ,", ( ;.
;;W[\III~Ii\II'I~~1I11)i\NI\:;lIII:l(,1I1111111111('1l1 MI . (,~: /""",,1) </,'j
""', Q~:; :~ '" q9_____.~_ ~I'~) {-,,:', ""'''';'' ",,,,.,,,,
"'V""'"''''''''If'''''I'''~''''''''''''' .(,.'
NOT^I"UAI, BEAt. Z 76 2 .'
... .,. .. 'Qt!^RI.EO ^,tW"lClW, Noln'Y l'ubllo . It . '156 ],0,
/,"" "',, " " Camp 111\1, CumhnllnlKI COlln\y liS 1'1,,'nl !JIlIVIr:II
I,', """" ,. ,C ml l'!l EK '~B 0611, 30 2002 . '" Rooolpllor Cortlflod Moll
NIIIIlIIUlnlU:n CllVlIrRfllIl1lflviilnd,
1.!~mLH!!.l!.!i!L~ltl!!.H.rrHI!D.{!LMnlU{!~~i~~I!!!H~.
&lnlln .J-) l j
Sttoii1A'-j.i;di~~J/-._l_~. L~!\~~.!~~._ _.~. .-.-
-.1J ~;;"'_!!.'([(!.r;_'-L.~_"'L..8.J~
P?fl Orllco, 'lIIl10:1111 C(~lll r 1\ \
_\:.Il.'/'I\.f'--_llL _1__ .JL.. _LIIIJ.__,
~~o~~~~..__..___..__._._. .~_.___~.~2_.2_.._
~~'~~~__..._~_ _.n .~_.J _(.__~l_~2_~_..
lJpnlllllllohVnlvFIIO
~ <'01 .".
C:::' [..
t:) 0' "I
~~: -. ',1 1,-
'It. \..12,
/fL,' ;'.1:
r n_ 1.')'<:11
). IJ2;'i
G -i' 0' :~;z3
~ 'C I jr~
~lll f~
rl" 1. UjR!
oq
l"i m ,...-:
,I "1
0
,
,
I
flROTltONOTMY
CUMIll:RIAt-lD COUNTY COURl'HOU.
ONE COlJllilIOIJSr: SOlJ^RE
CAIlLISLE, P^ 11013-3387
.. . .!
I\PI\R'l'MEN'l' Ttlm8~ MlIIRRMEN'l'
{mr.I~8 IINP R~(]Ul.l\'l'IONS
1, lJ.'enl\n~, htll fAlllU.y, Anel j\lastll Ilhllll nol~ A~ Any time malce ~n~' noise,
or clQ anyt\1in\J or coneluot thet1\llelVllll in /lny ~y whioh dillt:urp8 any other
rasiclant or intarfDl:fla with tl10 rilJht.ll, CQf\fort Ct' conveniences pf IIn1
o\:her reQidant, MuaiCU\l or aound~roproC\\.\oing inlltumen\:l1 or dn\Jing w thin
the /lpar1:l1\01\t Petwoon 11.00 P,11, tll\ch night /lncl 0, 00 lI,~l, ~he f.ol1~in9
morning,
:2, /'lQ pat of any lcincl Ilhall pe Ilro~h1; or !coj.Jt in \:11e apartment Ot' 131sew\)ere
(:In Lnncllord'll property. N tf 'f''(:,.
3, Xn \:hI! event aclditional. person sha~,l live with lJ.'e, nant in \:he aparl:mentr
a cost of ~aoo,oo par J;l8t'llon J?Br n~Jl)t:h far l!aoh such addit:ional perllOn sllll 1
pe J?lIicl Py 'l'eJ)ant,
4, UalJ.ways, wal1\Wl\ya, stairs, Il\:oraga areas, landings and entrywllYll shall
Ile "aed onJ.y for accesn \:0 IInd fran \:11e apati"~~nt, shall not be UlleQ for
storllge areas/ and sl\llll b(3 llep\: olear of bicyolell, WlIste rBceptaoloa, And
/lny 0\:11er srtiololl at /Ill tin~8,
5, WlI\:ering of lawns or oar vlash.l.ng by \lB.1.ng flloilitios of the splUi:lnent ill
prahibited,
6, 1\.11 trash and rubp.l.sh is to PB plAced in plastio bags inside a;lntainera
provided by LAndlord, All debrif.l, ntbbish, and traah must lJe plAced in
pr.ope.r containers,
7. Tenant al\ll1l lceep the apartmellt in gaoc'\ And s<1nitary conclitiofl.
O. TenAnt sl\llll not ohanga J.ooIls or install additional lookll, W.t\:1\Ollt the
written cansent of Landlord.
9. Tenant agrees \:1\l1t LundlorCI may oI\l1nge \:11ese re<;/Ubt:ions and required to
protect \:11e apart:ment or Landlord I a 0\:11er propa.rt:y, or add to the conveniences
of 0\:1161' acaupanta of \:11e apartment a;l1lj?lex. 'lhasa regulations are made a
part of this lease alJreement: and failure ta cct11Ply wi\:11 same shall be cause
for termination by LAndlord.
fli\1l1ed this clay. 22. of -A~tJsr
_ 199'C
.
, ils2~_
Tenant
witness
~ ;:~ I{ em"er- _
Landl.or.d T
WI:NPY p, 81:1.. Tt:F-R,
Plaintiff
: IN THI: COURT OF COMMON Pl-I=A8 OF
: OUMI3f.:Rl-ANP OOUNTY, PI:NNsYl-VANIA
,
,
: NO, 99-1691
RA YMONP I<I:PNI=R :
PefEmclant : OIVIl- ACTION
UWiLME&~MlMA~
;rQ.EbAlNT~UiI "
~
v,
QBQE.B
. ANP NOW, ,J;Jr "J-..~ , 2000, after conslcleratlon of tile pleacllngs ancl the
objections thereto, clefendant's preliminary ol)ject/on to plaintiff's Fair Pebt
Collect/on Practices claim Is grQnted on the grouncts tllat defenctant's actions
were not within the scope of the Act, pefendant's preliminary Object/on
pertaining to plaintiff's reference In the complaint to the prior cteclslon of the
District Just/ce Is granted, In actctlt/on, plalnt/ff Is Instructect to amenct her
complaint In conformance with the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Prooecture, as
explalneclln the opinion below, within twenty (20) days of this Order,
By the Court,
eorge E, Hoffer, P;J,
MfU.WJ muUlul
fi .j.!/OO
RHrB
Wr:NDY p, Sr:~ TZr:R,
PllllnUff
: IN Tl-lr: COURT OF COMMON P~r:AS OF
; OUMI3r:R~AND COUNTY, PJ:NNSY\..VANIA
v,
,
,
: NO, 9~.1691
,
,
RAYMONP 1<r:PNI:R
D~fenelllnt
: OIVIL AOTION
~
Q.flNtQ.M
PIEllntiff Wendy Seltzer, of 2" South 241h St" OElmp Hili, PennsylvElnla, flied
a oamplEllnt on April 9, 1999 ElgEllnst elefendElnt RElymand I<epner, of 633
GrElnelvlew Avenue, OElmp Hili, PennsylvElnlEl, Plalntl.ff has alleged, Inter alia,
hElrElssment, vlolEltians of the Fair Debt Oalleotlon Praotioes Aot, and defarnlltion
o/alms against defendant, Defendant has ralseel several preliminary objeotlons to
the oomplalnt, anelhEls Elsl(eel this oourt to oreler thElt the oomplEllnt be strloken or
amendecl,
DefenelElnt has rEllseel the follOWing preliminary objeotions: (1) laok of
jurlscllotlon over subjeot matter of the Elotlon In regard to the Fair Debt Colleotlon
Practioes olalm: Elncl (2) Inoluslon of Impertinent matter In regarcl to the prior
. cleolslon of the Dlstrlot Justloe, The basis of defenclant's first objeotlon Is the
premise that this oourt laoks jurlsdlotlon to hear "'. olEllm uncler the Fair Debt
Colleotion Praotloes Aot, a federal statute, Oonversely, oase law states that this
oourt may hear suoh a olalm, In Itrl v. Equlbank, 318 Pa,Super, 268, 464 A.2d
.'
1336 (1983), the Superior Court hel(:l Ull'lt CoUtia of common Plel'la hElve subject
m~Uer jurladlotlon to heE1r olalma under U16 Aot, 11:1, I-lowaver, we note Ulat the
Aot does not apply to person II or bualnesaes oolleotlng del~ts an their own behl'llf,
16 U,S,Q,A, g16921'l(4), RE1ther,lt Is directed to those persons who are engaged
/n bUlllness for tI1e principal purpose of oolleotlng debts, lel, I'lt 916921'l(6), As the
complEllnt dOElIl not Ellleoe thElt Mr, I<epner WI'lS altemptlno to oollect for anyone
other thl'ln hlmaelf, the demurrer la austalned Eln,l this oount Is <llsmlsaed,
PefendElnt's aeoond objection relates to plE1lntlff's Inoluslon of the prior
deolslon of the P/strlot JllaUoe, PII'llnUff mE1Y not Inolude referenoes to the prior
deolslon of the Platrlot Jllstlce In her oomplE1lnt beoause In Elppel'lllno the Plstrlot
Justloe's deolalon, she hl'ls Instituted a de novo review of this Ofllle, Therefore,
defendElnt's objeotlon Is oranted pursuant to P""R,Q,P, 102B(a)(2),
Pefendant has also asl<ed this oourt to either strll<e the oomplalnt or, /n the
altern",tlve, order that It be amended for failure to oonform to the PennSYlvania
Rules of Civil Prooedure, Plaintiff's oomplfllnt oonslsts of one page of ShOli,
someUmes fragmented sentences that do not Sllfflclently describe the facts
surrounding eaoh of her claims, Rather, plaintiff's complaint Is a list of legal
oonclus/ons, A complaint must state the material facts upon whloh the claim Is
based, Pa,R,C,P, 1019(a), Pennsylvania employs a system of "fact pleading I"
whereby the plaintiff Is required to set forth the fflcta of the oase with speolflolty,
A oomplalnt must apprise the defendant of the nature and extent of the plaintiff's
claim so the defendant has notloe of what the plaintiff Intends to prove at trial and
WOIHly p, Hollz\,1'
I'lullllllr
IN '1'1 iii COUIf!' OF COMMON I'I.IIAH
OF CIJMIlI\HI,ANIl C01JNTY,
1'1 iNNIWI, VANIA
CIVIL ACT/ON - LA W
y~,
1~"YIl1PIHI I\oPIlOI'
Po f\llllhl11 I
No, 1)1)-151)1 CIVIL TI\ltM
COMPLAINT IN CIVIL LA W
Amlllow UPlllO~ Iho nhoVO-llllnlOd 1'llIlntln; WOlld)' D, Hultzol', IIlld IlHlko~ tho
fhl/owlllg COll1plnlllt~ 111 Civil' ,lIlVi.
I, Thu I)of\llldllllt I~ MI', HnYllllll1d Kopnol',lIll ndlllt Illlllvld\lnl who o\ll'l'ol1l1y 1'0~ldo~ lit
C1l'11lldvlow AVOIlIIO, clImp 11111, I'A 17011.
2, Tho 1'IIIInlln'l~ M~, Wendy D, Holtzer, nn mlnllllldlvldnnl who elll'l'olllly l'osldes lit 27
H!)lIlh 24111 HIl'uol, CIII11I1 lilli, I'A 17011,
:l. Uoth tho 1'IIIIntlfl'lI1ld tho Dulolldont hili'll heell hOlln lido I'esldollts ol'tho
COl11ll1Ollwulllth oj' l'ollnsylvlIlIllIlhl' the podod oOWl'od hy this not 1011,
4, Tho Dolondlllll, liS deol'll\~d hy Dlstl'lel .hlslleo Mllnlovo, Cnmhol'llIlld cOllnty, wns
IIWlll'ded zel'O dol/III'S Ihl' oO\lntOI'-elll11l'llIllIt filed 12/1/')H, Delondllntlh\ls mllst l'etlll'll
n S\lmlll tho III110llnt of $i!tiO.OO, liS estnhllshl1d 111 COIlI'I.
5, D\lfolldllnl hlll'lISSed I'lnlntll'J'1I1 plllee oj' ol11ploymont IIlld vlolnll1d FiliI' pebt '
Colleelion I'l'lIullues Aot (15 lJ,H,C, !i!i I G1J2-1(1)20, liS IIIl1Onded). 1'IIIIIlllIT soeklllg
1l101l0t!l1')' dllll1l1gos oj' $250,00,
6, Dolhlldllllt vlolllted 1'llIlnllff's Hight to I'l'lvlley hy elll1l111lttlng oJ'tlJllSOS throllgh the
Ullllod Htlltes I'ostlll Hervleo In the 11111111101' oj' selldlllg Ihlso sIIIt0l110llts IIlld nl/oglltlonR
10 third Pllrtlos, This Illlhn11l11loll WIlS In dlroel eOllfllot with truo nnd.lllst roolll'ds
Dolillldllllt posscssos. 1'IIIInlllTsucklng 11101111tllry dllmllgos oj' $1 ,SOO,OO,
7, Dololldllllt eOlll1l11tted Llbelolls Auts, wrlttcll dolhl11l1tlon Inlll'ctolllltory Illllllllel' IInd
sent this to nnlnvolvod third plll'ly, 1'IlIInlll'f seeklllg mOllolllry dlll11l1gus 01$1,500,00,
H, Dol'cndllllt IIdmllled 10, by 101le,,, the eonllnlsslon of 1I1llllIVlhl wlrelllpplllg, In wllll\,1
dlsl'ogllnllhr slllto IIlld J'OdOI'IIIII1W, 1'IIIInlllT soeles mOllolnry dnmllgeR of $1,500,00,
9, Dol'clldllnt douolvod 1'1111 ntl 1'1' I'ogllrdlng oondltlonllnd '1Ill1ollltios 01' pl'oporly, enuslng
. 1'IIIIntifl' $ I HO.OO In olcotrlolll work which dol\.1ndllnl stlllod oxlHlcd hut did not,
1'IIIIIItll'I' soeklng $1 HO,OO to recoup those oxpendltlll'es,
10, Duo to 1J0l'endllnl's wllllhl dlsl'llglll'd ol'pl'llpOI'IY, Plllin\lfl'losl $12H.H5In wllges liS 11
I'osult ol'pool'll1ndlonlshlp. Pllllntll'l'seuldllg to I'eeoup dn)"s los\ wilgus ol'$12!l,HS,
II, 1'IIIIIltifl' sculdnb\ ol'lgll1nl $4(iO,O(} (I'olul'n socul'lty doposlt) Inllddltloll to the nhovu
ollloullllod Sll11l of'$S,05!1,RS,
12, Tho PIIIIIlIIfT requos\s this Courl to entel' lulhvol' of' sllld lilli'S.
Wondy D, Seltzol'