HomeMy WebLinkAbout99-01779
511,
The <1verments of p<1rElgrt1ph 52 <1re speolflot1I1Y cfenlecl purSWf1nt to PEl, R,O,P.
1029(0), l3y W<1Y of fwrther response, pefendElnt was ollllOflted lll1der Ihe oleElr and
",xpress Ifll"\gUElge of the MEIster Agreement (r::xhlplt A to Plalntlfrs oomplEllnt) to Eldvloe <1nd
dlreot Pllllntlff relative to the SOOPf! of the worl\ to pe aooompllshed,
53,
The averments oont<1lned within pElrt10mph 53 are oonoluslons of IElw to whloh no
response Is required, To tilE! extent thElt any reply Is deemed neoessflry, the <1verments
<1re admitted, l3y WilY of fllrther response, Plaintiff Inoorporates by referenoe f1l1d restfltes
the oomplalnt flied In this maller,
54,
Tho averments oontalned within parElorElph 54 are oonol\lslons of Illw to Wllloh no
response .Is required, To the extent that any reply Is deemed neoessalY, Plaintiff
InoorporEltes by referenoe and restateB the oomplalnt flied In thlB mEltter.
55,
The averments oontalned within paraoraph 65 Eire oonoluslons of law to whloh no
reBponse Is required, To the extent thflt any reply Is deemed neOeBBElry, the averments
are speolfloally denied aB statod. By way of further reBponse, Plaintiff Inoorporat~B by
referenoe and restates the oomplfllnt flied In this mailer.
5G,
The averments oontalned within paragmph 5G are oonoluBlonB of law to whloh no
reBponBe Is required, To the extent that any reply IB deemed neoessflry, Plaintiff
InoorporateB by referenoe and restateB the oomplalnt flied In this matter,
fi"f,
Tho UVlll'lllllntllllonlnhllHI within pUl'/IlJrnph 117 urll Clonolualonll of Inw to whloh no
I'eaponlle la rllqulr(l(l, Tn 11111 IIxtllnl Ihnt 'lilY ruply la deemed neOellaf.lry, Plnlntlff
II1!JOrporulllu hy rofmnnoll unci rlllltulllU Ihll Clompl<1lnl flied Inlhl8 malter. By way of furlher
roaponllo,lo thllllxtlll1l IImt It IlIllntnhllllhlld thnt Plulnllff Illude j,my repreaentallona relative
to thla Il1llttllr, thll 1111 III II waf(} prnllllulld lIolely upon Infol'l1111110n provided to Plalnllff by
l:lefendunt.
6U,
Tho uvormuntll oontulnml within pnraoruph 56 are oonolualonu of law 10 whlohno
reaponao III roqulrucl. To Iho oxtont thol any roplY la cleenwd neoeaualY, Plalnllff
Inoorporalea by II ,f, Irenoo and reatuleu Ihe oomplalnl flied In Ihl8 1llf.1l1er.
,
liD.
Ilia Q,hnlllad Ihal Plaintiff provided 10 pefendant "AB/400 RPG/400 Proorammlng
Qnd AnllIYlllu" durlnolhe porlml betwoen Deoember 31,1996 and January 31, 1997, By
woy of furthor rnuponlle, Plolnllff InoorporoloB by referenoa and reBtaleB the oomplalnl fIIod
Inlhla mnllor,
60,
Tho uvorrnonla oontulned within paragraph 60 arooonolualonll of law to whloh no
rOllponuo III roqulrod, To Iho exlenllhal any reply la doamed neoeBBary, IIIB avorrod that
tho uvormonlu oonlolnod within Ihla par<10raph 01'0 1I100n818tenl wllh and In oonfllot with the
tho oloor und oxprolla 10nou<1go of the "ABnlgnmenl Order" (Exhibit B 10 PlalnllffB
oomplolnl), By WilY of furthor reBponBe, II In averred IImt Plalnllff fulfilled all of liB
rOllpollnlbllllloB ond obllOlltlollB under Ihe "Maolor Agreolllonl" and "ABBlgllmelll Ordor".
61.
The averments oontalnecl wllhln pnragraph 61 are conoli~slons of law to whluh no
response Is rellulrerj, To the extent that any reply 18 cleemed neoesllary, the averrnentll
are speolflOl'1IlY denied, Sy way offurthar response, Plaintiff Inoorporate8 hy referenoe and
restatea the oomplalnt flied In this matter,
62.
Tho averments oontalned wllhln paragraph 62 are oonoll,1slons of law to whloh nq
response Is required, To the extent that any rerly Is doemed neoessary, the averments
are apeolfloally denied. l3y way offurtl16r response, Plaintiff Inoorporates hy referenoe and
restates the oomrlalnt flied In this math'!r.
63,
The averments oontalned within paragraph 63 are oonoluolon8 of law to whloh no
response Is required, To the extent that an~' reply Is doemed neoessary, the averments
are speolfloally denied, By way offurlher response, Plaintiff Inoorporates by referenoe and
restates the oomplalnt flied In this matler,
64,
The averments oontalned within paragraph 64 are oonoluslons of law to whloh no
response Is required. To tho extent that any reply Is deemed neoessary, Plaintiff
inoorporales by referenoe and restates the oomplalnt flied In this matter,
65.
The averments contalnod within paragraph 65 are oonoluslons of law to whloh no
response If! required. To the extent that any reply Is deemed neoesllary, Plaintiff
Inoorporates by referenoe and restates the complaint flied in this maUer.
60,
The avermenta oontalneQ within par~umph 66 ~re oonol\.lalona of I~w to whloh no
reaponae IfJ req\.llreQ, To the extent that ~ny reply III [leerned neOeaaElIY, PIEllntltf
InoorporEltea ~y referenoa f.1nd reatates the oomplEllnt fIIerl In this matter,
67.
Ilia Eldmltted thElt Plaintiff withdrew Ita employee fmm Defendant's premlae, The
olro\.lmatanoea of the withdrawal are Ret forth more fully In Plalntltra oomplalnt, whlohla
Inoorporated herein and restated In Ita entirety, 13y way of further reaponae, It la averred
that Plaintiff fLIIfllled all responal~llItles and obllgatlona owed to Defendant under the
"Maater AgreQmont" and "Asalgnment Order".
68,
The averments oontalned within pElragraph 68 are oonol\.lslona of IElw to Which no
responae la required, To the extent that any reply Is deemed neoessalY, rlEllntlff
Inoorporates by referenoe ancl restates the oomplEllnt flied In this matler,
70,
The averments oontalned within the IntroduotolY portion of paragrElph 70 are
oonoluslons of law to whloh no responae Is required, To the extent that Elny reply Is
deemed neoessalY, Plaintiff Inoorporates by referenoe and restates the oomplalnt flied in
this matter,
70(a),
The averments oontalned within subparagraph 70(1'.1) are oonoluslol1a of law to whioh
no response Is required. To the extent that Elny reply Is deemed neoeasary, Plaintiff
Incorporates by reference and reatatss the oornplEllnt flied In thla matter, By way of further
rOllpol11l0, In 11m oxtonl tl1al Pefol1dantl1aa flU ala In ad l1nY dwnaoell, wl1lol1 ara expreallly
denlerl, II10n 1110 Ilflnlll roaultocl from I1lu fl1l1ure 10 mlllOl1to, Improper manll0(lInenl of ilia
huulnouu or hlu own oondu!ll aa It rllll1loa to Ihe relullonal1lp helween Ihe pRrlleu l1erelo,
70(1.1),
The Ilvormenla oontalned within auhparllgmph70(h) aro oonoluslons of law 10 wl1lol1
no responae Is required, To tile extenl tl1l1t any reply 10 cleemed neoesuary,ll1e avermenls
are apeolflolllly denlecl, l3y Wl1Y of furll1er responso, to Il1e oxtenlll1l1l pefenclanll1as
sustained any clamagea, whloll are expreasly clenled, tl1en the same reslllted from his
failure to mitigate, Improper management of his buslnesa or hla own oon(luot as 1\ relales
to the relationship between tho partleahereto,
70(0),
The averments oontalned within Bubparagraph70(o) are oonoluslons of law to whloh
no response Is required, To Ihe extent thflt flny reply Is deemed neoessflry, Ihe averments
are speolfloally denied, By way of further response, to the extent that Defendant has
suetalned any damages, whloh are expressly denied, then the same resulted from hie
failure to mitigate, Improper management of his business or his own oonduot as It relates
to tho relallonshlp between the portles hemto.
70(d).
The avermonts oontolned within sUbparagl'l'lph 70(d) are oonoluslons of law to whloh
no response Is required. To the extent that any reply Is deemeclneoessary,the avermonts
are speolfloally denied, l3y way of further response, to the extent that Defendunt has
sustained any damages, whloh are expressly denied, then the same resulted from his
failure to mitigate, Improper management of his business or his own oonduot as It relates
to the relallonahlp Imtweon the pmtles Iwreto,
70(e),
The avermentQ contalnee.! within aupparEloraph 70(e) Elrl3 conolualons of lf1w to Whloh
no responsa Is roqulree.!, To the Ilxtent thut uny reply Is (jeemtle.! neOOSSElry, the averments
are llpeolflolllly danled, l3y way of further rellpOnse, to the extent that Defendant hElS
sustained IlI1Y darnaoes, whloh are expressly (jellied, then tho SElme reslllted from hl8
failure to mllloate, Improper manaoement of his plllllness or his own oonduot as It relates
to the relllllonshlp between the partlell hereto,
70(f),
The rlVennents oontalned within supparl:1oraph 70(f) are conolilslons of law to whloh
no response Is required, To the extent that uny reply Is deemed neoessary, the averments
are speolflcl:1l1Y denise.!, By way of further response, to the extent tlll:1t Pefendant has
sustained !lny dl:1mages, whloh are expre8sly denied, thon the same resulted from his
failure to mitigate, Improper management of his puslness or his own conduot as It relates
to the relationship between the parties hereto,
70(g).
The averments contained within subparagrl:1ph.,O(g) l:1re oonollllllons of law to whloh
no response Is required, To the extent that any reply Is deemed neoessary, the avorments
are speolfloally denied, l3y way of further response, to the extent that Pefendl:1nt has
flustl:1lnsd any damages, whlohare expressly denied, then the sams resulted from hill
failure to mitigate, Improper management of his business or his own conduot as It rei lites
to the relationship between the parties hereto,
70(h),
The Avermenta oontalned within auppamorflpl, 70(h) Hre oonolualona of law to Whloh
no re~ponae la required, To the extent thai any reply la deemed neoeaaary, Ihe ayermen(a
are apeolflollllY elenled, ~~y WilY of further reaponae, 10 Ihe extenl thllt Defendllnt hEla
auatf.llned any damllgea, whloh are expreasly denied, then the Sllme resu/teel from hl8
fElllurEl to m/tlgate, Improper mfHlf\{Jemllnt of his Puslness or his own oon~luol as II relate8
to Ihe relflllonshlp belwflen Ihe parlieR hereto,
70(1),
The ayermenta oontEllned within subparagraph 70(1) are oonoluslons of law to whloh
no response Is required, To Ihe exlenllhlll any reply Is deemed neoessary,lhe Elvermenls
f.lre speolflOfllly cfenled, By WflY of further rORponse, to Ihe extenlll1flt Defendanl haa
suslalned Elny elElmageR, whloh fire expressly denied, Ihen Ihe Sflme resulted from his
fflllure 10 mltlOflle, Improper mflnagement of his business or his own conduot as It relales
10 Ihe relfltlonshlp belween llle parties herelo.
700),
The avermenls oonlf.llned wlIhln subparfloraph 70(J) EIre oonoluslons oflflw 10 whloh
no reaponse Is required, To Ihe exlenllhat flny reply Is deemed neoessary, Ihe avermenls
are speolfloally denied, By way of further response, 10 Ihe extenllhal Defendanl has
suslalneel any damages, whloh are expresaly denied, Ihen Ihe sElma resulted from his
failure 10 mitigate, Improper management of his buslnoss or hla own conduot as It relales
10 Ihe relationship belween the parties herelo,
\.
70(11),
Tlw ~vermenls oonlalnecl within slllJpamomph 70(11) me conoluslons of law 10 whloh
no rellponse Is required, To the extenl thaI ~ny reply Is deemed neoessary, tl1a averments
are speolflo~lIy denied, 13y way of furlher response, to tile extent that Pefendanthas
sustained any damages, whloh E1re expressly denied, then the Ilame resl-lIIad from his
failure 10 mltlg~te, Improper man~oement of his puslness or his own oonrJuot as It relates
to the relationship betwaen the parties hereto,
71,
The Introd,~otory portion of plwloraph 71 oontalns oonoluslons of law to whloh no
resflonse Is required, To the extent thflt flny replY Is deemed neoessflry, thl!! averments
are speolfloally denied pllrslllmt to PfI, R,O,P, 1029(0),
71 (a),
The averments of sUPpflraorflph 71 (a) oontaln oonoluslons of law to whloh no
response Is required, To the extent that any reply Is deemed neoessary, the averments
are (Ipeolfloally denied pursuant to Pa. R.C,P, 1029(0),
71(p),
The averments of subparagmph 71 (b) contain oonoluslons of law to which no
response Is required. To the extent that any reply Is deemed neoessary, the averments ,
are speclfloE\lIy danled pursuant to Pa, R.C,P. 1029(0),
71(0),
The averments of subparagraph "1 (0) contain conoluslons of law to whloh no
response Is required, To the extent that any reply Is deemed neoessary, tha aVfllments
are speolfloally denlad pursuant to Pa. R.C,P, 1029(0),
71(d),
The averments of sulJpElrflomph 71(d) oontl1ln oonoluelol1s of IElW to whloh no
reeponse /s requlrecl, To the extent thl1tany reply /a deemed neo8ssary, the averments
are 8peo/floElIlY clen/ed pur8uant to Pa, li,O,P, 10;10(0),
72,
The aVerl11anta oOl1tEllned within pEll"Eloraph n are oonoluslons of If.\w to whloh no
I'esponefl /s required, To the extent that any reply Is deemed neoessary, PIEllntlff
Inoorporatfls Ily referenoe and restates the oomplalnt flied In this matter,
73,
The averments oontalned within pl:lragraph 73 are oonoluslons of law to whloh no
rellpOnS(l Is requlrecl. To the extent that Elny reply /s deemed neoessflry, Plfllntlff
Inoorporates Ily referenoe and restates the oomplalnt flied In th/s mfltter.
WHEREFORE, Solution Teohnologles, Inc, rSllpeotfully requests thflt Defendants
New Mfllter and Countarolalm be dlsmlased with preJlldlce l:lnd thElt Judgment be entered
In Its favor as requested In the complaint.
ANSWER TO COUNTF.ROLAIM
74.
PIEllntlff IncorporElte8 by reference and restates Its complaint In Its entirety as well
as paragraphs 1 through 73 as set forth above,
75.
Defendant has failed to state a oallse of "lotion against Plaintiff for whloh .relief can
be granted In his oounterolalm.
76.
Tho avarments sot forth In [.lefendUl1t'll New MaUer and Oountorolulm are
Inoonalatent with and dlreotly oontrudlot the OIOtlr tlncJ expross lanOW'Ioe set forlh In tho
"Master Agreement" whloh oontroltedthe relatlonllhlp hotwoentho purl/es her~to,
77.
To the extent that tht! averments set forth In Pefendant'll New MEllieI' with
Oounterolalm l'Ire Inoonalstent wllhthe oleEll' an(I express terms of the "Mtlster Aoreemonl",
the samo are null, void, unenforoeable, violate the Parol Evldenoe rule I:\nd are therefore
Inadmissible and Irrelovant.
70.
The averments whloh purportedly sllpport Pefendl:\nt's QOllnterolalm are premlsEld
upon aelvloos whloll were not addressed In the "Ml'Ister Aoreoment", Oonsoqllently, there
Is no bl:\sls Inll:\w or In faot to support Defendant's oounterolalm,
79.
Defendant's oondllot as It pertl:\lns to his oounterolalm, whlohlacl(B a basis In law
or In fact, Is and has been arbllrl:\ry, vexatious and/or In bad fl:\Ith.
00.
Defendant's conduot as It pertains to his oounterolalm vloll:\tes the prOVisions of 42
pC!. O,S, g 2603 thus entitling Pll:\lntlff to an award of attorney's feos.
81.
To the extent thl:\t Defendant has Inourred dllmagos, whloh Is denled,then the same
resulted from his own oonduot, his fl:\lIure to mitigate or the mismanagement of his,
personnel or resouroes.
claniac\ \:11f1\: \:ha rla~n\:ifp, perfo\:maq on:\.y t:hopa \:A/ll~/l :\.\:emhacl :\.n
r<1~'f\gt'("ph 13,
14, The flVBrmen\:/l of PArAgrRph 14 fire deniecl All /l\:a\:ecl,
I\: :I./l ql;lnied \:hA\: the P1dntiff. h<1Q weel~l.y meating/l wHh t:he
IJefandAnt or .my flutho~'hed l'epra/lent<\Uva/l of: l:he pefandEmt:,
16, Theavermenta of ParAgraph :\.6 are deniecl aa /ltated,
It ip clenied that: the P:\.<\intiff At the diredtion of the
Defendflnt perfol'med the WOl:lt it:emhed .In PAragraph 16, find it ifl
f\\l:ther"qen.ied that any WOl'lt i\:embacl in Pal'agl:aph 16 wall worlt
authodl1ied by the Defendant,
:\.60 'rhe avermentp of Paragraph 16 are admitted in pflrt
and denied in part, It il3 admHted t:hat the Ume reoordl3 were
presented to D. Lynn l~isher, and it ia further adm.itted that Do
Lynn Fi/lher appl'oved t:hoae time reaordl3 aa aoaurate. It is
denied that D. Lynn Fisher approved the time reaards as being
properly bi1lab:t.e to the Defendant,
17, 'l'he avermente of Pa/.'agl'aph 17 are adm:l.t:ted :I.n part and
deniecl in part. It is adluitted that the ahm:ge13 whioh the
Plaintiff alaim13 for work from the pedod between January ~,
4
Ill., 'l'he IIvel"menl:p of l'Rl:Ug!:'~ph oil. of I:he lHf':I.Ilt:ife'!l
OOmpl.ailll: Rl"e cleniecj MJ at:Rt:ecj, It:l.p cjen:l.ocl that: p, r.ynn
Fi~ha~: "IPpmyeq t:ha I::\.me 1:0CQl:q fm" \:he PHl"pOf,le oe 1:d.1Hng \:he
Defenqflll\: or agree,1 \:hal: t:he Defenql\llt would PI\Y \:he f\\l1onnt:13
l1illod fOl' the t::\.me reool"d ending Fehnlllry 14, 1997,
42, ~~e averment:~ of Pf\!:'agraph 42 of the plaint:iff'f,l
ComPlaint: are denied ae at:at:eq, It: ie clenied thRt: the DefendRot:
hf\e clerived any economic beneUt h"ol1\ the worl~ perfol:med by t:he
PlainHff 0
430 '1'he averment a of Pf\ragraph 43 pf t:he Pl.aint:iff / e
Complaint: are denied ae et:ated, It: ie denied that: t:he Defendant.
l:eaeived any ueeful work or ally wor.k of fillY value fl.'om the
Plaintiff, It ie further denied that the Defenclant: aaaepted any
Heeful wot"lt from the Plaint:iff or hfHl ueEltj any work pel"formecl by
the Pla:l.ntHf, and :Lt ia furt:her denled t:hat any quaf.l:l.-aontraat
or aontl:aat impl:l.ed by law wae areated between the Pla:l.ntJ.ff: and
the Defendunt. '1'0 the extent Paragraph 43 aontainf.l f\ aonal.uaipn
of law, to Whiah no reapona:l.ve pleading ia neaeaaf\ry.
440 '1'he aVermellta of Paragraph 44 of the P1a:l.ntiff / e
Compla:Lnt are denied aa atated, It ie den:Led that II quaa:L-
10
mer.hod for the propofJeq oonvet'Il!011 of 11efonq.ml:' fl oompHter
pn)gt'umf:l ,
65, After Pluintiff oume to Defendunt'a pl~oe of PHflinepfl
in Deoember 1996, ut whioh d.me pefenelan\: gave Pla:l.ntifl' and
Pluintiff'p repreaentativef:l full aooepa to Defenelant'f:l oomputer
flyetem/ Plaintiff: macle oer\:ai.l1 l:eoommendal:i.one to Defenclc\l1\:
l'ogarcling I:he nul:ure, poope anel methocl of I:he propoJ'locl
convera.ion cmel pl:ef.lenl:erl Def,enelant w1t:h <I oontraot and
AJ'lJ'li.gnment OI:ellW wh:l.ch lu'e attuohecl 1:0 1'1<l:l.ntHf.' J'l comp],.dnl: Ole
r~)(hibitJ'l "A" l\l1cl "13" reflpoot:i.vely, anel whioh <It'e he1'ei\1
inoorpor<ltecl by refel:enoe <113 H ful.ly J'let f.orth,
56, 'rhe tel:ms of the oonl:raot ancl AJ'lsignment DreIer
referenced above,'whioh were prepared by Plai.ntHf after an on
ei.to inJ'lpeoti.on of Defenelanl:' F.l aystolll and the requi.rements of
the proposed oonverJ'lion, provided for an initi.al. term of two
weekJ'l to oomplete the projeot with a renewal option for an
addi.tionEll I:wo weelw.
57. plaint.iff repreeenteel 1:6 the Defendant that the
propoJ'lsd oOllversion would take no longet', ,than the four weele
pedad apl30Hied in the initial AJ'lJ'lignment Order,
14
.1. I pefonr\~nl: W~fl l'e'l\l~.l'ec\ no el(.\wncl IH\pfltanl:ial.
f:l\.lmfJ of. money I:P PllY t:hah' ompl.oyeol3 \;0 ma;l.l1tl'lin t:wo pah'PHtlill:
I'IYfll:omfl 1n'I:l1e affiClel
j I PefenclAnt Wf\13 req\\i.l:ec1 \;0 puroh<\J'le ather
I'IoftWare to offlilCltHute the oonverflion of itl3 pamPHter programl3/
,
Ie, Defemlant <\ncl hifl employeelJ Wet'e l'equh'ed \;Q
e)tpenc1 oonl'licle1'aPl.e al110\\nte of acldi\::l.on<\l t:ime And money to
l'emedy t:he flituation oroatect by P1dnt:ir.f / fJ PI:eaoh I
71, AJ'la ref:lult of Plaintiff/fJprel'loh of the partiefJ'
Elgreement / DefElndfll1t hafJ been reqlli.red to e)tpend the following
l3umJ'l of money whioh it woulel not h<\vl~ otherw1ae h<\d to fJpend but
for Pl<\!ntiff'a bre<\oh,
a, Defend<\nt wal3 l'equired to e)tpend
appro;dmately $10,402 .in mdnt:enanae oOfJts to mainl:ain the S-3G'
Clotnputer I:1Yl3tem thl'ough February 1990/
b. Defendant inourred utility ooste to
,
operate t:he S-3G oompllter syet:em of $4,150 t\U'ough February
19901
19
~n~~F~f:l~ _ram p~p~m~~~ ~!, ~99~
,.
R~~p~PI:."ll.y ~\.lbm~bl:~~,
IiIilNRY,
'I
~Yl
COHOJilJ.,ItJI3, OIl'l'lilf'l, CUr...tl
\" S:'
opYu
""
PAyic\ 1\ I Q~y,
1\\;\:Ot'l1syI'I fa!:'
"
':, ,.
"
if
"
I';
I'
,.
."
d
';
/i
It
II!
'''i,
",.
;,
i'
"
I'
!'
q
"
.'
,.
I'
""
Ii/,
, : j ~
"
.'1
"
21
aOl.,UTION Tl:CHNOl.,OGII:S, INO"
Plnlntlff
VB,
IIN THg COURT OF COMMON PI.,~AS OF
I OUMl3gRI-ANP OOUNTY, Pl:NNSYl.,VANIA
I (;1 ". .-r-
I Nu, ., {(. I? 19.-(.I~,..(I U<~.
ROI3I:lRT 0, Cl.ARI< ~"p/n
ROJ:\t:RT p, CI-ARK ACOOUNTING,
Pllfllnflntll
.
,
I OIVlI. ACTIoN
I
I
I
I
OOMPLAINT
Solution Teohnologles, Inc. (Plaintiff) flies the within Cpmplalnt and In support
ther130f f.1vers as follows:
1.
Plaintiff Is a PennsYlvania oorporatlon whloh maintains Its prlnolpal plaoe of
~luslness at 7021..Isburn Road, Camp lilli, Cllmberlancl County, Pennsylvania 17011.7423.
2,
Raber! D. Clarl\ d/b/a Robert D, Clarl\ AocOllntlng (Defenclant) Is believed to be a
sale proprietorship with a prlnolpal place of business located at 511 Washington Street,
Huntingdon, Huntingdon County, Pennsylvania 16652.
3,
Plaintiff Is In the business of providing Professional Data Prooesslng Servloes,
Including but not IImlt!ld to consulting, contraot tlYblofns Elnd programming and teohnloal
personnel aSsignments.
4,
During the month of Deoember of 1996, Plalhtlff was contaoted by D. Lynn Fisher,
wllo at all times relevant to tills action acted as an allthorlzed agent, servant or employee
of pefendant, to detennlne whether It POI.lld provide certain teolmlpal sorvlceB 10 pefendE\nl
rall1tlve 10 Il1e oonverslon of a numper of oomputer proOI'E\lnS from a 8/39 opmp\jler syslem
10 a A8/400 compuler system.
5.
Plaintiff WE\S Informed py pefendE\nllllE\I tile following oorwerslon worll woulel neeel
10 pe E\coompIlBI18d:
"I). l~r1136 progrE\mS to be oonverted: 40
p). OC~ 10 CI programB to pe converted: 0
0). Numoer of dl'ltI'I flleB 10 pe oreE\ted externally: 0
d). Numper of datE\ flies 10 convert dE\tE\: 0
e), NUlnoer of El/36 menus to be convertfJd: 0
f). Numoer of converBlon progrE\ms Iwaded: 0
6.
On or aool~t Deoember 31, 1996, Plaintiff E\nd Defendant exaouted "I Master
Agreementl (Agreement) unr.ler which Plalnllff agreed to provide tile teol1nloal oonverslon
sfJrvlces (Worll) requesled by Defendant. The Agreement provides In pertinent part:
I, SCOPE OF SERVice
(Plaintiff] will prOVide qualified data proceBslng personnel to perform systems Elnd
programming taslls as required and directed by the Cllenl.
'" ,
IV TIME AND ACCOUNTING AND INVOiCeS
(Plalnllff's) personnel will complete weellly lime sheets for oolh management and
Client records.
A. RATES
1. Hourly rates are quoted on an Individual basis depending on Ihe scope of
1 A true and correct 'lOpy of the Agreement Is attaclled hereto as exhibit "A".
24.
On, a11(11H or ~lafore Fe~lruflry 1, 1007,' a flllpplemenllil AflalOllmant orr.lar wall
forwarr.leq to pefenclanl relative 10 tile oomplutlnn of tlla Worll,
20.
Defandant refljllecllO algn tile supplemental Allslonmont Order and attempteq to
renegotiate tile terms under Wlllcll Plaintiff WO\.lld oomplete tile Worll.
26.
As a measure of good faltll and because discussions batween tile parties were
oontlnulng regarding tlla terms under Wllloll tile Warll WOLlld be oompleted, Plaintiff
performed Worll on Ille following dates:
a). Woall enqlng Febl'ljary 7, '1997:
~l). Waell ending February 14, 1997:
27.
34 IlourS
30 IlourS
A lime reoord for tile Worll performed qLlrlng tile weell ending February 7, '1097 wan
presented to D. Lynn Flsller, Defendant's autllorlzed agant, Sel'VElIlt or .employaa, for
approval. Ms. Flaller approved and signed tile time reoord.o
20.
A time reoord for Ille Worle. performaq during 1118 weell ending February 14, 1097
was presented to D. Lynn Flaller, Defendant's autllorlzed agent, survent or amployee,for
approval. Ms. Flsl1er refLIRed to approve or sign tile lime recol'd.o
n A true and oorrect copy of Il1e lime reoord 18 attaclled Ilerelo a8 exlllbll"E".
o A true and correct copy of tile time record for Il1e weell ending otl February 14,
1997 Is attaol1ed Ilerelo as exlllblt "1'''.
COUNT I . !3Rt:AOH OF OONTRACT
36.
Plaintiff InoorporlllllS Py referenoe IInd restEltes 11l3reln pllrllgrllphs 1 throul'lh 34,
36.
Defendant hilS flllled 10 fulfill lis opllgatlons under the Aorel'lment py rafUlllnl'l to fully
PllY 1116 sum due IInd owing for /:Iervloes provlctatl 1I1ereunder lind/or undllr Involoe
# 14743,
37.
Defendeml 1111S prellol1Bcl the Agreement IInd Pllllnllff 1111S susllllned hllrm IInd
darnElges t11erepy.
30.
Pllllnllff Is entitled to IIquldflted dllmages In 1118 IImount of $ 6,526.00 plus 1116 .
oontraotual rate of IntereBt (1.5 % per month - 10 % per annum) from Maroh 17, 1997
fOlWard.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff Solullons Technologies Ino, respeotfullY requests that
Judgment IJe entered In liB favor and agalnBt Defendellll Ropert D. Clarl( diP/a Ropert D.
Clarl( Acoountlng In the amount of $ 6,625.00 plus the oontractual rate of Interest. The
requested dllmages 9Q I1Q1 exceed t!l11lnandatory arbltrallon threshold.
COUNT II . BREACH OF QUASI.CONTRACT . UNJUST ENRICHMENT
39.
Plaintiff Incorporates by referencll and restates 110reln paragraphs 1 through 38.
40.
The Worl( performed by Plaintiff between February 1, 1997 and February 14, 1997
was at tile speplflo dlrciotlon of Pafendant andlor Ilia aull10rljZeQ aoenta, Ilarvants pr
employees.
41.
Defl'lnclanl's €Iutllorlzed agent, serv€lnt or employee (p. ~ynn Fluller) Elpproved Ille
time reoord for Ille Weall enel!ng Febru€lry 14, 1007.
42,
Defendanl tlF.lS derlveel €Ind oontllllles 10 derive an eoonomlo bemefll from Ill!! Worll
. performed by PI€llntlff during IIHl period from Febrllary 1, 1 gO? to Febrll€lry 14, 1 gEl?
43.
1'116 perfonn€lnoe of tile Worll by Plaintiff from FebrLlary 1, 1007 to Fepruary 14,
1997 and IJefendant's repelpt, aooeptanoe €Ind use of tile same resulled In tile ore€ltlon
of €I quael-oontraot Emd/or a oontrElot Implied by law between Plaintiff and Defendanl.
44.
Under tile qllasl-oontraot andlor oontraot Implied by law, DE'fendant Is obligated 10
pEIY to Plaintiff tile Illlfn of III 2,BBO.00 piUS Interest at tile rate of (1.6 % pel'montll-1B %
per Elnnum) from Maroll 2B, 100? forwerd.
45.
The ollarges for the Worll, au outlined In Involoe # 14B44, were fall', reasonable,
Ollstomary and tile marllet prloe for tile servloes and Worll provided to Defendant by
Plaintiff.
46.
It would be llnoonsolonable for Defendant to retain tile benefit derived from tile
Worll performed from Fobruary 1, 190? to Fabruary 14, 1 OO? wltllout paying for tile aame.
.
IV, TIMIC ACCOllNTING I\NO INVOICI~S
IlTI pUI'~pnllul will uomplulll wuullly Ilmu shuuts for holh 11l1l1H11l1l1llU1l11111(1 C\illllt
rccorll~.
A, 1lt\'1't~8
l. HOll1'Iy mlo~ 111'0 lIll0le!l on 1I11lnIHvl(11l1l1 hllsls depOlldlnlJ on tho scope of 111\l "
IIss11l11mlllH 1II\lllho Indlvldll111 slll\1s rO\I\1lred 10 t\IUllllho SCOPH or SI1RVICH,
2. Hpllrly mlos Me lJ\lolod oxolllslvo of III1Y sill os 11Il!, AllY III1IOS lovlolllls II roslIlt of
STI's sOl'vluos 111'0 Ihe rllspo1161hllily of Ihll Cllellll1l\(l will hl1 sollldlollllHl ol1ll\1l
Involoe,
3, 1'hlrly (30) !IIIYs wrlllollllolloo wllllllllllveJll prior 10 IIny mle hlorollslls.
4, Any overtlmo IIl1lhodzed hy Ihe Cllell1 wl\1 he illvolood III Ihe SlImo hOlll'ly mlo liS
I'llglllm' tlmo. . .
S. In Ihll ovonl Ihlll 8'1'1 pOl'solmlllllrrlvo IIllhll CIiI111t's ~ito 10 hogln II sohedllllld
1I~611lnntOllllllld 11nd Ihlll work 11I61,s hllvo heon clInoollod or dolllyed, STll'oservos
the r1~hllo hlVolou tho C\iunl Ulllhl (II) holll's showllp thno for olloh porson_
60hodllled; To I'csohmllllc 1I11l1sslllntnelll dllY, STII'Il'llllrus 411 hOlll's notioe,
n. EXPI~NSI~S
1. Expenses IlS dellllled below will bo reoorded dlllly hy 81'1 pUl'sonnclllnd Inolndell
with sllIlcnlllnts for services.
2. If 1'1'00 pllrking is nolllvllllllhlo, Ihe Cliont wlIl bo ohlll'gud lit II monthly 01' dlllly
1'1110, whlohevol' is IIppllcllble, '
3. STI's stllndlll'd polloy Is to bill 101' mllelllJo only whon tho mllollge betwoon the
oOl1sultllilt's home III\lI the Cliont's slto oxoeods. Ihe mllulIge between tho.oonsultllnl's
homo IInd STl's olososl offioo. Thon, only tho oxooss will bo hilled. Tlllllllilt~llge is
blllllbllllll tho mte nllowcd by Iho U,S. Intel'l1nl RevenUe Sorvict"
.
4. AllY other oxpenses lIulhorlzcd by lhe client to completo the l\:isignmelllllre
blllnblo, .
.
C. PA YMENT TImMS
1. STI wtll suhmlt, on n weekly bnsis, invoioes for services rondered. The Client
should pny such invoices within ftftuOIl (15) dnys of I'eoelpt.
V. I>UnAl'lON OF SI~IWICIC
The dlll'nlion of STI's involvel1\ellt will be dotennlned by Ihe Client's requiroments.
Eneh work nssignment mnde will SIJl~oify II period of IInenl perfonnnncll Ibr enoh
Indlvidulll to bu provided by STI. Thul1\inlmutn period of'lhwlI\ pel'fonnnnce till'
ench Illdividunl will be one (I) cnlcndnr Illonth IInless otherwise spoclned In writing
nlld IIcceptnhle to bOlh Plll'lieu.
.
VI, CONTINUATION ew SICnVICE~
Upon notHillllllon of Ilxtol1slon hy Ihu Cllonllo 8'1'1 nllollst thlrly (30) dnys prior In
Ihullllpll'llllon of nn n99h~'lInllllt of nny hllllvldllnl, flTl will Ilontlnllu IhulIssIgmnont
of tlllll Illlllvllhllll to Ihu CIIllnt Iill' n porintllo he nBl'oOllllpou. Tho Ilmu shnll hu
uxtlllHlull for 1\ mlnhmlln of ono (I) olllomllll' month 01' nny mnlllplo of onlundnl'
luonths, ,
VII. lucnucTloN ()II srmVlcrcs
upon wrllleu notlfionliou hy tho Cllont 10 S'Pllt lonst Ihlrty (30) dnys prior 10
lloslr(llllormlnllllon llllto, thu ClloullllllY roqnest II rodll\ltlon in tho spoolfioll perioll
of IhlOlIl pllrformllnoo. SlIoh n fodllolion will 1101 rudlloll speolfioll Pllrlor! of IInonl
purfnnnllnoll 10 loss thlln uno (I) monlh.
VIII, lU~cIPnOCltl'Y ()II CONSUI:rANTS
I. The Clhmt nBroos lhllt It wlllllotllotlvoly sollolt for hire tho oonsllltllnts ofS'I'1
while slloh 001l9111llml9 IIruporformlng work for tho Cllcllt IIl1dllr IIUY worll
IIsslgnlllent nor for ninety (90) dnys nfler IIsslUl1meut completion, IInloss RT[
lllonllgement hilS IIdvlsOlI the Clientlu writing thllt oortoln Indlvldllllls mllY he
oxtondod Joh offill'S. . .
2, STlllgroos lholit will not IIctlvoly sollolt for hll'o the omplpyoos of the CHont for
n pCl'lod of ninety (90) dnys nfter oompletlou of tho work osslgnment, nnlcss wrllten
IIpprovlIlls ohtlllnod from tho Cllonl, .
3. The Client IIgrons uolto rotlllnthll servloes of on ox,8T[ consllltont nsslgned to
the Client's work offol'ls, nnder !lnothol' oontl'llot work ordor for n pcrlod of ninoty
(90) dllYs fro III thnt Indlvldnnl's I/lst dllY of IIsslgnmont lit the Cllent's envll'Onmont,
IX, PATENTS ANn INVICNTIONS
It) tho evellt !IllY plltollt or lllvontion reslllts frolll tho (lcrformonoo of sorvloc
rendored by Its porsollllol, ST[ IIgroes thllt snoh plltont 01' Invontlon thorofl'Om will he
tho Cliellt's solo property, nnloss otherwlso speolliod In writing.
x. CONFIDENTIAL INI!OUl\/ATlON
STlnlld its oOllsllltlll1ts willlrellt oil illfol'llllltlollllnd work produots rellltlngto
lIilslglllllellts liS Sllomt IInd conlidentilll when so Idolltllicd by the CIIIlIIt.
XI. Imoc
STI pledges to strive to olimillllte dlsorlminntion In clIlployment. Asslglllllents will
be mllde solely 011 the hllsls of qUllllfiolltlons wlthoutrogllrd t() moo, color, oreed,
nntlollllt origin, IIgo 01' sex.
XII. INSUUANCE
STI Illlllntnlns IIdoqunlo worklllolls oompelisntloll fbr ench stllff momber In
lIecllrdllnce with stllte roquirelllents. STIIIIsll cnlTlcs clllllprehenslvclinbillly 1'01'
ollch porson.
XIII, IHWLr\.Clel\1ENT
STlll1l1Y rcphwc hll\lvhhllll atnff 1110mllClra n8aiBI10lllo 'thc Cliol1tllpol1 Cllellt
IIgroomont.ollly, Whr.n rcplnoun1Cl1tia ngrccclllpon hy IlOth pnnloa, tho mtu will
rOll1l1lnthu anmu 1lI111 nn uqllnlly l\lIl1l1lluII atllffmolnhur will bo allhathntud. STI will
reqlluat of Cllcllt alloh rophloumont, n11l1 CIiOl1tnHlIlllllolllOllt olll1lntervlow fbI'
qllllllllclltllons, If II anitllhlu roplnou1l1unt annnol ho hlell\il1ud withlnlhlrlY (30) IIIIY6,
tlw Cllunt hns thu oplion of IIn nltul'l\lItu IlIhol' 80n1'00. .
XIV, IUi;COIU>1'J
STllIlll'cos to mnlntllln rcoorlla l\llll othor ovlljunuo (1OrlllinlnB to tho ooats IInd
ClIpOn60S nssoollltoll with tho IIgl'OOll\lllltto tho olltonl IIlld In snoh dotlllllla will
propol'ly relloot 1111 diroct 1I1111111111ruct ooats 1'01' which ruhnbllrsclI\ontis ollllll1uII
nndcl' tho provlalona of thla nBrOIlIl\UIl\,
XV, CIII\NOICS OF I\MICNnMICN'I'
Thu torma IInd \1onllltlons of Ihls IIl!rOOnlClllnHlY nol hu vlldcd 01' mnondud 01100(11 by
l\nInatt'lnHentIn wrltinl! Olloonlllll oonoun'ontly wllh or snbacquentto tho 01lllontion
. of Ihia IIllroOll\ontlllHI slgnod on bohlllf of Ihu Cllonlllnd S1'I by dnly lluthol'lzocl
porsons ro~pootivllly Ihorounto,
XVI, TEUMINI\'I'ION
ElIhol' pllrly olin Illnnlnl\to thifll\groomcnll\t lIuylln,,' prlOI' to tho speoified porlod of
Iinelll(lorfol'lnlll1oo. Snch tonnlulllionls to tlll(c cffuel slllt}' (60) dllYs following
written rooeipt of lonuluntion notice.
XVII, RIGIITS/REMEnmS
All rlghls IInd t'OlI\cdies herellndcl' lire onlllullltlvo nnd nOI cllo1usivo.
XVIII, CONFLICT
If nny provlsloll horeln is III connlol with nny stlltllto 01' \'lIlo of IIIW, Iholl suoh
provislou will bo doomod Ino)lol'ntlvo 10 Ihe extent thlllltlllny cOlltllot thorewith nnd
will be deell\ed 10 be modll1ed so liS to oonform with III1Y stlltule'o\, mle of IIIW, .
XIX. SICVlmAUlLITY
I I' IIny term or oondltlon ofthls ngreement 01' 1I111111ollllon the roof 10 III1Y lIerson 01'
Oll'CUlllstlllloe is huld IIIVIl11d, suoh Invll11dlty shll11 nolllffec\ olhor terms, oondltlo'ls,
o\' IIPllliclltlons of this IIgrOemenl' (
XX. WAIVEIl
No term C)r oondltlon of this IIgreel11elll w111 he modlned or deleted oxoept by n
written Instrllment signed by Ihe pllrlles hereto. Wnlver or IIny hronch of IIny lorm
01' condition of this IIgreOmenl will 1101 be deemed II wnlvor or nny lIr10r 01'
suhsequent hrellch.
lHE SOLUTION CENTER
( 'll-l-If\11
~..
r1 ~ 1.1I0"'j nnllllV^lU
.l\k,MmHI lltllf II
1"\1 11M"'''''', I'''' 16r"1II
'1'111"\"1111 nH/UH.Q.111l
f""'MILI' UI,W""'llor,
ASSIGNMENT ORDER
CIIlln!! IlOhtl"! n. Chu'lI, AlllllHmtlllll JI,O, NIllllhtlrl SOI"H --,'
fill WIIshlnlJlnn RI. . .',,,.---
""nllnlJdoll, lit\. 16652 A,O, Numhcl'! SI0"8'
..
\Jill 'I'm Ilnhlll'l 0, Clul'll Allllnlln!llIlJ AUenllnlll Ms. l.ynll Flshtll'
511 WIIshlnlJinn Sit
Ihlllillllldlln, IlA 1/1652 Jlhnncl (Ill I\) 643-0430
Jlrnjellt Nnmcl
. .
Pl'n,lellt Mlln/llJellltlntlClltlntl X. 8Th
SlI'tlSpCI'SOIH .'Otl MCI'III1
Slllllll\1cnt nfWnl'lH ASI41111 IlI'G/4011 1)I'olJl'lImmlng /lnd Anlllysls
Consultlllltl Mlehllcl NltlllI
TllIel Sr, III'ogl'lIlllllllll'/AlIlllyst
HOllI'ly Illltcl
$45.00
EXpllllSlis \Jlllllhlcl
NOllc
Stlll'IDlltcl .'111111111')' J, 1997
i \,J. 'f
I
Elld Dutel
STI Aplll'ovllh
sJ.rM
1I'l:1lI~ Il:ltka
r~ I Aahar~ ~ clJrk
. ,
,
'tall nnh
I'I\UM l> II 1JA1'l-'I111-I- '/1'( ?CiJ 4JIH 1',4
00 ~ 'l'17'130a03\1 at 01/14/97 10 I 0.811I pg O\t~/003
PHcn: I{l, I llIl~t\~~a414. JJn, 14 1991 lUllJF/'1 PI
~.,~tll"1"4.)~4a 01 "","~\If/n ~a,~.p ~",,100~/OClIl.
~~U8U PA'NT
.
5()LUTIl)N lnr.HNQ~OGmS, INC,
IIHI''''~
1...1111\'...."."'"11,'11I
...... 11/'1""1'
,1<....',.,/11,.11
OONS\.l~ TANT
TfM/:T~Ul!ljaT
'lAMli ~N/UI.
, ..--
J~fl~P'(1l1i NUMPflR..1.mHlr., ,_,., . W~\!I\ llNPINB n"Tft ,MM7
OI.Jt:NT .-~~~J!I!~_ ,,' llUPV/MBR I ,,~I.."UU'l9.fIr!fr
PflQJIlQTPPIlQ\',IPTION, NOM~..ar~1lI1 ___.~_
__[eAT~'IL___ ''''t~''JHU
1961u..I__ _.. _JlL --tIf _ _'11,_
UJ.M..6llli!-l.-. . ~ II . !,
-,...,.--
.......
---~. ....-._~- NON~l!IU.'Il~1l ,----
IVA(,l^TION
, ....", ~-- ,-
-
.liQbPm. " ~, ,~ ..--
810K/IIIlHS
" ... -,
JI\^ININ<J - -" " -
TfWJ.!L. , .
.....,. ,- - -
Q~NOH -" -,' -,-
,02IAP .... _.. , " -- "
OTHeR ~II , .i2.- '
I'A_., .."
NUMPRR O~ IlI~LM~\l OVIlRTIMIl HOUR~ TO fill elAV1!O AS CCMP C~
I, rlM~ IIft~oMeo MU8TTQYIo~Al ~'A~T4QO flClu", PUll WIIIIK
a AU. moll ~"Q"T~I'I aHOUl.ll DI TO fliP NI^"tllT 'I11l111 (Ill U),
0, OAl~ TltIl AoooUNnNU Q'~^/lTI,l'NT (f1Y.fU-44Ul QII t.lPNDAIIMOflNINQ ANo nVDl1't VOU" HUURY WIlRWMO,
.1I11'IJ~UTH^raOTIlVOU ANClll' C1Ulrrr810N M T1MeIUUT,
g, lAAl~ YOlm 'I1MlIHlnT TO Till O~'iC' 'VI~II MOIlPl\Y,
I. VMlATION llUtT .1 Al'PIIOVII'IIN AOIIANOI,
y, FDII TIM& "II/IOI\TIOIII Till 'OTllln' "lLtl, [l~' ft~P,,^N^IION, ,:t(f)ubllUlhllfll" a~ ~ ".IIJlllttntlo-
--'
AppqOVB~,J~ d( d~,_
,
''''M
I","\"..a-Hr/~('a ~'""lQI,l.\'YI rl'\wM tal ~ \",A(\'t+UI-I-. III (l;)..:t t4.~1
,.IyI.\l-.....I"""~~\'I."IfII"If.t.YI'.~YI""..,\r.,.,"""'I, 1\,....,\'1..."....
'~I.."\ '.......f ~1l.,,1 !'~IIl_'" _" "., I,. ." '_,'I
FROM I llllb.r~ PC, ~,'I'
I _ ~ '
"n<<1 nj I:""
PHlJIl ~p, I 1l'~i~~W4 .Tlll'l, 14 1,.1 I~' 1:54'\11 PI
~~,.~nl""""4U4,4 ., W"'~U/'7 la I ~'il f$l,lOO)/OOQ
OONDUI,T^NT
TIMIIl'~~UII!IT
.
SO~U'ItON 1Iir.:HNOI.Q(JI~~1 1~1C;,
~"I'.""""
:,!.i,"" tlhtjI"rf" 1If\\hl.lt
v<t""lll't . '\'
'~''''''''(I\''' ,
~IRAU f"lNT
'lAM" "'"hHlHJ//Il/
.t,tp~o;;;MiW1 fN~I}TI _ WMIlll ~Nn'N" t)^TP.JJ1J1if!r.
OI-l~NT ~flpU,CHIII""~, ~I .IlIJPV/Mi'lR 11,~\IIIIIF~-"~ ---,. ,.-.
/!"lM10TDllI\O""PTION~r81/(j" , '''-, ..-
~J~::!i! ~ON .....1I1L wen~-TH~ ~ ~
llWllll ... "- .~-,- ~ItO:lA .. ,.11 --., - TII~ I
I "~~.bft~q J 0 111 ,
__ t "'..--- "_., --....,
~T~O~
H 0
--''''
a 0(1____
IHlNB
.!l.~_
,!l!NOH_
Jl~"
OT R
(I
o ~
,--
~...-~.
-,
...~,
...--
-'
. -,
.......
,.,
~-
," "',.......
"
-
---."..,.
I~--
--"
-......-
-
-
..--
NUMIII1R OP PMIIIlLll O\lIiATIMIi 110UA8 TO as 1U\\If.!I'l All t'lOMI' \....,-." 1
1, TIIAIIUlPQATrO Mvn T!ITA~AT ~llIn~o 0 HIlLI~' ~QA VVUK
II. AL~ TlM8I1~PO~nD "lO\JUlllR TO 1111 fllAnlaT 111lTII (11\ I 01,
0, nllu 1111 AllOOUNTINtl OWI'AR1MaNY (1H.lf"4IH1 ~N Il.,NPIIV ~pnNINGANO ~.~om tOUR I.oullli 1'f1lNK'PI
4, fta BUns lllAT 00111 YOU ANDTHft OllUIUKlN lHI TllAlaH8Br.
I, !MIL vou~ 1lM18HIIT TOTH! O'Plr:of IVIlAV '"'OUtlAY,
8, ~Nl^TI(lN MUIT.. APpno~.o IN IIOVAIIOB,
y, pun TIM. nlll'lIl\no IN YIIK 'OTHI"' '1"1,0, ClI>'llKPLANlI1 'ON ..fl'jWblMAool & ,,!,ul(jl"''Utf ..../l,1n ~I.utt
....---
~OV.P~~~'~ of( )4~,_
,,\,".'
, ,
t " ~ f'
ClD~8UI..T^Nr
TfM,..HI!I!T
.
SO~LJTlON l~CHNOLOOI~I INC,
11.'*"".....
r;::.:.~ Irnl~I~I'" 1'14'1
""-"l1m'lllI
P~^UR P"INT
N^Ml!-dt;Wt*~.
IM"~OYj;1i NVMlIflR.. l'lEl ;~ 2~ ""'1"\ Wl1iiKIiNPING PMR
'Q~II!Nl' ' =':. RlJflVlM(1R~
11 · '
PflQJIIO'f tll'CRIP'I1CN_~' :110 .I l u.~tI-,...... "'r
---
~
fiAT
au
.....M9ti._ u
~U
........._~#
1(1
TOT l
.!I"L
0,4; &11
lSll.LABIJl
NQN...UILI.AlllL'l
YACA'IlO'" - ~
~fOLlOAY .
------.- -"'-- -- - 'f- - i..?
SIOK/Pllns oJ I , "
.,.-, -
TIlAININI) ~ -
.!Wb. - , -
RIINCH
- -- .. -
OOMP "
mll!It
"OTAL
NUMBeR 01' BII.LABL& OVIlRlfMII HOU/lU TO aa SAVitt) AB OOMP r 4-Cl -J
Ii
t. nmllW~OIlTlln MuaT T\~T^lA'l' IJlA1I1' 40,0 IIQUIII ~1I" waf(.
a, AIJ. TIMf ABI'OMlID aftou~D 01 'l'0 THI NlAAllllnONTtI (lIG 1.1),
~,OAll. Till AOOOUNTINO nlPARTMBNT (T'?~1"~~IAlI/ ON MONn^V MOnNING ANti fIll~O"T YOUII ~IOlll\bWOnKllD,
4, De aURII TIiAT 80TH YOU ANDTHF DLlllNT 8/0N Tlil!TI/IIOUlflllr,
I, toIAII. YOIIA TIMIlOtlllllT 'l'Q "11 O~"'IOllMlnv MONDAY,
f. VADATlON MUlIT III API'I\OVftD IN AOVANQIi.
r, ~a" T1to1l! IUll'OPlT1!lO IN THIl'UTHRR' ""ILe, CliVi B~I'LANATION,
GMPLOYl!l!a'QNAT\J~110VItD
.........
~{}A~",:,<< . )....c.-
,.v./AG
" I II ","""""" I"'''. W1 ,,.,.. I
"".......t>nhTM , ',...1'........;
"',fP'''' f1 1./Aan'W t 1,IrI~hl
, ,
,
, .
INVOIOIa
flROMI
liOL.\JTION Tj::OHNoj.,OQII!It, INr:;,
roa 1,IflillURN RQAP
ClAMI' 111~~, I'A 17Q11 '7~~1
'11717ea'l\Cl11
-
..
SOI.UTION, TP.CI-INOl,OGI~S,INC,
INVOIPP N\JMU~f11 \ !\1~'j
PATl!' iWlI71'>\~
T~11Mfll Nl! I II', \)A'(ii
TQ;
(;\"I\III\ 1',I:C\1I,JNT I\N'r ,;.
~Il WA~HINftTDN RTR~~T
~)NT'NqDON, PA ]6!~~
ATTPNTIONl p, 1.'11'11'1 n Sllr,"
OI\OI3R O\.I~NT P,O, INVolOti NAME HOi,JRfl HOURLY eXTl:NOaO
NUMaER N\JMagri DATf:13 RAn:; OHf\Al1ll!
"-- -
AOf.\061,) l,:U:i:U"O\/I);) M \l';11(1~~1- Nll'll?\ ~l (j~, ,Ill) 40lj,OO
"IObOI,!! 01/04-01110 M1Ctif~F.1. 1'1111\11 ,~O 11l\ ,00 1 ')60,1)0
AOflO!>O 01/\ 1-0'1 iP M1CHA"l. 1'1 IT II'A '10 4F.>,OO l:,l~,O ,0\)
/\Of"OMl ()l/l!H:n/~I\ "I);f,:11An, Nl'TI~~\ ,~(l {JF, ,(/0 WOO,OO
AnIIO"'(; Ot/~(,'I-: /:ll. ~1r.l\I1Af:l. NITI\A ~I:, 'IF, ,00 t r.,,~() .00
.
C f~NOI OIIAAOlI Of' I,BM'tllOfl'h,_' Gro.. ~1Kl "" F".',JlQ
t'\trr,flH.II1.wtfJA~P6 to\GBflAfa iIll. ,7'7 ,/11
Of' j J!. bt 'fllu..J to all 111'0.... "'""' U\III LftN Oolla
!O t\oV1 ' BAlaS -
TBMfthle BIIVloo ~oo "'(l,nnl
TN< sllea Ta" flft\1 (,1/
CALCULATION Sllel TIM 0111
me, ,on
ToCAf InvlIloo Amount q,/, I r;,?~) ,1)0
OOMMIiNTElI
Pl1g~, t
10!-1d>l~11jIt.lU W, ~IAI'1
I'IM! ~Il CI\I'PH1I_L 717 .,a:~ 436"
P,6
"
~ ,
,
.
.INVOICJ:
FROMI
I$OI.,U'rION TI!GHNOl.,0!3I11~, INC.
top ~IaIllU"N l'lO!'>P
OAMP 1111,1.. PA I7Q\ loT4a5
11 Tl1n.'.~11
-~.
.
-
SmUTloN lkHNOI.oGWS,INC,
INVOIO~ NUM~Ii~1 \ ''''H.t
DATIII ()2/~1Il/(.t7
TIlRMBNliT ~ ~ Ilf\'{~l
TO'OL.f'''''; , A'::\)\llJNTM~lTEi
~;ll HFlI3Hm':(i'i'l'N f.lTJI:firn
HIJ"I'I'1 Ni'1Il0N, I'f' l.(tllr.I~~
';'TTIlNTIO~\, l,YI'IN F'\I3Hf;1H
-
OI~OER OI,IIlNT P,Q, INVOIOIl NAMf: I'IOl.lR~ IIOlJR~Y aXTI!NDfiD
NlJMElllR NUMIlf:R OAras RATR OHARe>i=
-- -
f.rJ~,:,sa I ~/OI"'O:<:/Q" ! ,~h/'\..l Nitlill 1;,-\. -1 Ej. fJI~ 11~1~'~. CIO
f oeN~ro r. :~/l)"I,(,l~'1 ,\11 , I ',~ 1'11\11I1 N. bl(i,\ :00 '\1' ,1'/1', J St'lo.oo
,
- -
^ FtlAllUQ VHAl\O~ OF Ul\ s: month, "'lkl! am.. ".. , "t trU!H\ ,.
10 '1"~lonllo In ~1IAl. Pt!II eNTAlIII fV\Ta r;~ , Oa2 II :;:'~l
OF . ..~ bo 'fll>1Iod ,. II ~n"'" m... Ih.., LAlli 00",
&Oem..., SAlons
Ta.abltlitrvkle "... -mu.J)",
TAX
Sa"'. ,... Rata f.,'X
OAlOUVlTION -
Oalt, TalC DIIa .". ,,'
Tal.llnvo~. Amolinl 12,t!ln':,,':I()
CClMMfiNTSI
"C\(JIil 1
"
.~ en f:;,:
N
r cI~ ('-~
t., J
l~'~! ....- I L~I
0-"-1 , ',,'
{,I.; ~ ,-
In , .1
~'.; C'J ; "
-'I' ,.i'
p" If':'
f-' 1"; 111"<
;r {nUl
/:':' ,',' 'I~
'l n~ ~'j
U'l U
"
.
. ,
"
d'
,.-
.~"
~~
~
(~
.......
,
,.
"
"
"
.'
Ii;
~.
,.1,"-
"
I'
r-
r
'-
~
II'
~
~
f"
y
ri
~~J~'
"
Ii
'I
I;
I.
.1
,;
;I'
.1 I.
'j,
t; I'
"
'I;
I'
,,'
I'
IJ.
;'
i'
"
"
"
r\~
i'.i
I,.",:.!
, ':1"
I "'.'
.1,>.,
I,.
(!i'l
(.~"
;1 \'-'
,:.1\-1
3-. ~.i ,
I"
H\
I.'
,A
"
,'j"
:,r'
"
T"'"
"l~
,~
(.~~
,'".
:p..:1':
1,)1)
i) ;;r
")"\
"_,,,:
~~_. rj
. "\.)
I 'r j~,~
\' 111..1
h~H~..
t1~
.,1
\..,l
'.'~: '
i.l..
;,11\
-
~...
~, t,
~i..~
r.r,
en
"
I"~
,
,
"
, .
,.
";J
"
"
!.
I.
'II
"
,
"
".
il
"
',,';
"
Ji"
,.
"
!J
"
"
"
I'
,"
J\
"
J..
"
,
,
, , "
"
1 , , "
,.
,.
n
"
"
"
,.t "
/' Ii
"
/, ..
,
,
,n
i":
,.
"
"
,
" j "
"
"
"
;;
( H
'.Hi
"
'j,
"
'I
1\
,.j.
;,'1'
ii
j!
to, The Ayermentf:l o~ rArAgraph to <Ire, denied 1'If:l atate~,
It is deniecl that the Pl.aintiff brought the airol1matanoe
ol1l:l:\.ned in !?<lI:agl'Aph 9 1:0 I;he Pe,fenc:lAnl:'1l <lttention,
ll, 'I'he <lvermentl'l of, Pa1'<lgl:<lph 11 <Ire c1en.i.ecl AI'l f:lta\:ed,
It ill ~enied thaI; the De~endant <luthori~ed the P1Elintiff 1:0
prooeed with the worle after peing ac'\v:lf:led al3 l:;() the
oi.t'oul11f:ltElnoel3 ou\:lined i,n Parolgraph 9, On the oont:t'f\l'Y I the
Defend<lnt: expected t:he WOl:lt ta be oompleted AJ'l it: hEld been
I:epl'el'lented to the Defendant :I.n the time frame within whioh the
l'laint:lff told the Defend<lnt that: the Plaintiff oould oompl.ete
t:he worle,
12, 'rhe avermen\:e of Paragr<lph 1.2are denied af:l atated,
It ia denied that the Defendant DElve the Plaintiff direotion afJ
pled in thi!'l Complaint, and it i!'l further denied that the
P1Elinti,ff l'elied upon the al.leged direotionfJ. averl,,,1 .I n Lite
Complaint in beg1l1ning to perfOl:m worle on the oonvereion,
13, 'I'he avermentl'l of Paragraph 13 are denied <113 I'ltated,
It is denied thElt the itemized t<lska set forth in Paragraph 13
are the task!'l Whioh the Plaintiff performed, It ifJ further
3
qenieQ t.1I11\: I:h~ l'lAi.nt~ff perfot'meq onl~' \:hOlle \:l'\llltf:l :\.I:amilleq in
l'llragp<lph 13,
l.<.\ , '!'he f\ve,l:ment:1l of Pf\ragnlph 11 are den:l.ec\ ElS Il\:ateq 0
It: ~,fJ clenied that: the l'lf\intiff. h<\c\ weeltly meet;ingf:l wi\:h the
PefenQan\: or <lny <1\1thori.li:ed raprefJental:ivel3 of. the Defenq<lI1t.,
15, 'l'!le avet'l11enl:l3 af. Paragt'aph lli are den:l,ed. <la statec\,
It: :\.fJ denied tl1<1t the Plain\:iff at the direotion of the
Defendal1t performed the worlt itemized in l'arElgrapl~ 15, and 1t h
further denied that f\ny worle itemi.:z;ed in Parflgl:aph 15 waf:l work
authori:z:ed bl' the Def.endant t
16, The avermentl3 of Paragraph 16 are admitted in par\:
and denied in pat't, It: is actlld.tted I:hat the time reoordl3 wel:e
preesnted to Do l,ynn F.isher, and it is further admitted that 0,
Lynn Fi.eher appl:oved those t.ime reoorde al3 aooural:e, It i,e
denied that D, Lynn l~isher approved I:he time reoorde as being
properly billable to the Defendant,
170 'l'he averments of Paragraph 17 are admitted in pElr\: and
denied in part, It: ie admitted thaI: the oh<lrgea Whiah the
Plaintiff olaims for work ft'om the period bel:weel1 January 3,
4
~4, Mmi\:t:ecl,
25, 'l'he f\vennf,lnt~ of ['<lI:uornph 25 of \:he t'lf\il1tHll'fJ
Complld.nt Ilt'e dan:I,ed I'HI fJI:I.\\:ed, It ill denied t:hnt: tha Deff,lndl.\l1l:
~'efnl3ect \:0 l3ign t:he Iluppl.ementfll, 1\1l1l,ign1l1en\: Ot'der beOflllfJe \:he
llefend<ln\~ wanl:eCl to renegoti.ate \:he \:er1l113 with the pldnt.iff,
On the oon\:t'ary, \:ha Dafelldlmt l:elluF.led \:0 !'lign I:he aupplemen\:l.\l
AfJf:lignmenl: Order beoause the Plfli~tiff failed to perform under
the Defendant' 13 agreement: wit.h the Pllduti.ff <Iud bepauae the
PIElint!ff CaUed \:0 perform ita wOl:I~ i,n fI WOrle1l1flnlil~e <lnd
oompetenl: mflnner,
26, ~~e averment a Of PflragrElph 26 of the Plaintiff'll
Complaint are denied ae al:ated, It is denied that <luy worl~
performed by the Pldnti.ff as Ilet forth in Paragraph, 26 was
p.rformed all a meaaure of good faith and/or performed beaaufJe of
ongoingdiaollaaions between the parties,
2'/, 'l'he avermenta of Paragraph 27 of the Plflintiff' s
Compl<lint are admitted in p<lrt and denied in 'part, It ill
admJtted that D. Lynn Fisher wall pref:lented with a time reoord
and it ill admitted that she signed the time record, It ill
6
3~, Mmit:teq,
34, The. avet'menl:p of P.WAgt'Aph 34 of the P11'Ii11tHt:' f:l
ComplAint <l1'e c1eni.\3d .w I'ltated, It ifJ qaniec\ thAt the Pldn\:iff
w~thdl'ew itf:l COl1l'lll1l:Ant from t:he Pt1f'ellc\ant' 13 WOt'!e pl<lce pecO\Hl'le
cf the PefelldAn\: I p l:efl-ll'lAl. to fJign \:he I'Iupplement J\fJPignlllent .
Or-del' ,
313, 'rhe f.lVet'men\:fJ c;if the Pefend<lllt 113 Tlnl3werp, Pat'agrAPhf:l 1
"
thl'Ol\gh 34 <lboVe, at'e inoorpo1'ated herein Py ref,e1'ence <lfJ i.f f:let
fort:h fully,
36, 'l'he .:Jvet'mentfJ pf ParagraPh 36 of the Plaintiff I e
Complai.nt aredeniecl ap stElted, It is denied lhat the PIElintfff
hAa fulfilled itfJ obligat:ion under ita agl'ElGment with the
Defellctant, It is furthBl: deni,ed thaI: the Defend<lnt W<lf:l
oblif,1ated to pay any sumEI of money \:0 the. Plaintiff,
37, 'rhe avermen\:a of Pa1'agraph 37 of the PIElintiff'13
Complaint Elrfj denied al3 atated, It: is den~ed thaI: the Defendant
hafJ preached ita agreement with the Plaintiff, and it: ia further
deniect that the'Plaintiff has auatained harm ar d<lmagep,
o
41, 't'\Ia ElV\H'l\lenl:fJ of. P<ll'ftUt'flph 4J.. of I:he Pl.lin\:J!;f.'ll
cPlnplt\i.nt fire c1elli.~q ap fJtat:ec1, II: ia !.\en:l.ac\ I:h<lt p, r,ynn
l~i,phel: appl:ovacl \:he t,tl\le t'eoQrcl for \:ha purpope of p.iU:l.ng the
Pef.eudan\: 01: agl:eect thfll: t:he Dafendanl: would PAY I:he ElI\lQ\\!1tl3
p,Ulect fat' t:he t::l.me reoon'! encl:l.nu 11eprlUlI:y J..4, 199'1,
4;:j, 't'ha avennenl:p of, Pal'Elgraph 42 of. the PIEl,intiff.' 13
Compl<linl: Ell'e denied al3 I3tElt:ecl, It i,fJ cleniecl that the Defenclflnt
Ilal3 ded,vecl any eoonomio benefi.t h"om the Worl~ perf:ormecl Py the
Pl/.dnti,ff,
43, 'I'he <lvet'l\lenna of. PElrf\gt'<lph 43 of the Plf\,int.iff's
Complaint are clenied as stated, It il3 deniecl t:hflt the Pefenclant
reoeived any llseful. worle or any worle of any value from the
Pla:l.ntiff, It if:l further denied that the Defendant I\ooeptec\ any
usefUl worle from the Pl<linU,f:f or hal3 used any worlt parformacl by
the Plaintiff I and it :1.13 furthel: clenied that allY quaai. -oontract
or contraot implied by law was created between the Pla:\,nt iff and
the Defendant, '1'0 the e:Ktent Paragr<lph 43 conta.ins a oonoluai,on
of law, to which no reaponJ'live pleadi,ng is neoeaaary,
44, The avermonta of Paragraph 44 of the Plaintiff's
Complaint at'e den.ied as stated, It is denied that a quaa:l.-
10
51, ~n de\:ermining whet:l1at' c\' nOt: ;l,t WO\llc\ be Able to
Pl:oviqa the f:let'vice~ ~'eqnefl\;eq by Defendflnt, Plai,nti,ff reql-lefJl:ecl
And W<l13 given aocef:l13 to Defenc\<lnt' fJ off.icea find aompntet' aYf:l\:emlJ
f:lO thl\t it could betl:el: eVElluate the nfll:ut'e of I'lr~rvicefJ +'Ejquired
by Pefend<lnl: t:c effectuate the oonverai.on which DefendElnt wal3
t'eqneating,
5;1, Defendant i.13 in l;he budnef:lfJ of <lcm)l1ntil1g Elr!d hall no
e)tpertiae in mattel'l3 concerni,ng computet' hl'lrdW<ll'e Ot' 1l01:twal'e
<lnd f:lpecif.ici!uy hal'l no e)tperl:ifJe with reepect to the ielJue of
canverting compllter 130ftwal:e from cne syetem to ano\:hel',
53, P1Elintiff il3 in the buainefJe of providingprofeaeicnal
datEl proceee,1.ng servlcee, including, Imt not limi ted to,
aaneult:Lng, contract aYl3teme, programming and technical
personnel ael3.i.gnmente, and held i,teelf out to the Defendant and
to the publ.i.c at large as hav.i.ng expertiee i.n the field of
computer and teahnical coneultinH, pro!jrammi.ng, and aeeoci,ated
eervices, inclUding the converfJi.cn of fJoftwarB from cne system
to another,
54, At all ti.l1\ee mentioned herein, Defendant l'elied upon
the e)tpel,tiee of Pla.int:iff .in determining the nature, scope and
13
J, Pef.encl<\llt Wl'\fl t'e'lnirec\ to e~panq IIUPlJtAnt~'A+
f:lll11la of mpney to Pl'ly 1:l1ai,t' al\1ployaef:l l:p mdnl:nin two C0l\1pl\\:13r
I3YfJt.13I11f.l ,i,n \:1113 offi.C131
j , Defe\1cl<lnt wafJ reqnh'eli I:p PIn'oh<lf.le other
fJoft.WA:l:'fl to eff.ectUAte the ccnV~t'f:li,on of i\:f,I complltet' );lrogr<lIl1El/
Ie, Defend.lllt I'\nd hil3 employeefJ wet'e t'eqlli!.'ed 1:0
expBnq cplwi,qet'able amount a of acldil:ional \:ime f\lId' money to
l.'emedy I:he f:lil:ual:ion creElI:ed by Plaintiff' f:l bl:Bf.\ch,
;1'
/,
'!:a, As a result of Plaintiff's bre<lch, DefendElnt haa
'Buffered damagel3 in I'In amount in eXCefJB cf $35,000,
WHERDllrORli1, Defendant, Robert 0, Cl<lrk, cl/b/a Robe1.'t n,
Cl<l1."k Accounting clemanda judgment in itl3 hvor and against
!>lail1t:iff in,an amount in e)tceafl of $35,000, plUfl costfJ <lnd
19
.' Ii
.,.
YIllR:tIl'~aATIQN
I VI!#fy .~hA\l \lhe IltAtem~nl:f'1 I11l'1c\e in ,thif'l ^nnw~l' ,
<Ire true An~ por~eO\l, I underlltand thl'lt eAlfJa f:lt~tel11l!ntf:l h~rein
<I~e mAde eupjeat \lP penAltief:l cf. la p~, Q,a, Q4a04 r,elA\l:\.l1a to
I-lnfJwprn ~A:t./.lif:\.q~tion to AlIthQ,!:'i\:1el3, . . '
l~~\J_~
Panial' M, ClArle
DA'l'1ll1 6./:;1I)/!lP
..
'j ~
, ,
"
" "
if "
,.
, ,
,
" . ,
'I
"
" I
.,
" , i'
"
"
.;" 'i
,..J'.
"
,,"
.,
"
,
"
,
':"
"
"
fI;
'"
'\ ;/'
1,1 "
" I'
(!
," "
"
" "'i H
I,
"
q
.,
" "
;, it.
i(
" , "
J',
" !I
,.
"
/'
itJ ,.." ~
e( N
g~ ~ ~ ~rl
.~) ~t
'(;5 ( l'ij "
~ J':'ir,~' I, ,.1'
.. 'J A-; I'
1'1 " ,.. " .,
'.'.'; s;
~[f: l() 'lP(/~1 if
r-. ''')t~ 'I<
'(; L,u ..'/ Ihtil I'
F/ 1;0) U}u, .'
I '. '
~ ~ ~ !o
'"
,. " " ;. ,,0'
"
p "
,
Ii,
" "
" IIj
" "
"
n. "
.i'
"
"
"
"
Ii
"
i<
"
Ii
i ~
" ,. 'i'
"
"
I'
if
q
"
I,
"
"
.'
" ,
"
",
'I; j;
'\ "
"
"
"
"
~ C) ~ I'
..:l
~ ,-.
~~ f! '8~
I r', ~ cli~ 'I; .'
, ""
1,[ (;Ji
n"
"/ > 0 f1~m
(.]1\:" N /' .'
I'll Ui
;:i; IJ~" ~ " ,1,-
." "
Ll, ."
() el1 () ''; 'i
" Ii
" "
.' "
"j ,
I'
.'
,f-"
"
.'
"
"
,! " " 'I
.'
j\
flOl-l,.ITION TI":lOHNOI-OGIJ:S, INO"
Pllllnllff
I IN TI11= COURT OF COMMoN PI.E1AS OF
I OUMBE1RI.ANP COUNTY, PJ:NNSYI-VANIA
I
I No, QO -1770 Olvll
I
I OIVII.. ACTION
I
va,
ROf:lI:R'l' p, al-ARI( cl/lJ/ll
" ROf:lI:RT p, OI..ARI( AOOOlJNTIN13,
PIlf1mclllnl
QRQim
ANP NOW, this
clay of
,199f), upon aonslclemllpn
of PlalnUff's Mot/on to Oompel Pefendant's An!lwers tQ P1alrtlfrs Oomblnecl
Interrogatories ancl Request for PrQclllQtlon of PQQunients Plreated to Defenclant, It Is
hereby ORDERED that Pefenclant shall answer (jlalntlrt's OQmblnecllnterrogatorles and
Request for ProdyatlQn of Poaumente within ten (10) days of servloe Qf this Order or
suffer SElnotlons as provided by Pa,R,O,p, 4019,
1\ ,
I3Y THE OOURT,
. J,
if
I',
;, I'
. ..
,;'
II
",
d I;
"
"
'.I'
.,'"
..
"
,.
"
I;,
SOI..UTION TI:CHNOI..OG I I":lS, 'NC"
Plaintiff
VR,
fiN THI: COURT OF COMMON PI-J:AS. OF
I PUMI3J:RI..ANP COUNTY, PI:NNSYhVANIA
I
f No, 00 -1770 Civil
I
I CIVIl.. ACTION
I
I
ROBI:RT p, CI..A'~I( d/b/a
ROBF.RT 0, al..ARK ACCOUNTING,
Defundanl
fl..AINTIFF..!1iMOIlQtLtOJ!Q1JlPF-l.. DF-FENQANT'S ANSWgBlUJJ PLAINTIFF.!.fi
Q..,Q.M~lNI'illlNIE.BBQ.qAIQRlIDlAN 0 RF-Ql1stITE.QB..ffiQDUCTIO N OF:
DOCUMgNTIiQIRgQI~IQ.Qlm;NgANI
1. The Instl'lnt oase arises out of a Iluslness relationship between the pmtles
under which Plaintiff agreed to proVide consulting anel/or technical services to
Defendant relative ,to the conversion of certain computer programs at pefendant's place
of business from one system to another,
2, On Aupust 18, 1999, Plaintiff served Combined Interrogatories and
Requests for Produotlon of Documents, a copy of Wlllcllls attached hereto, marlled
Exhibit "A" and Incorporated herein by reference I1S If set forth atl€lngth, upon
Defendant's counsel,
3. On that same date, Plaintiff's counsel sent a letter to the Cumberland
County Prothonotary's office, with notice of service of the aforementioned combined
Interrogatories jlnd requests for production of documents upon Defendant's counsel as
of Augllst18, 1999 attached, A copy of the letter and nollce of service are attached
hereto, marked Exhibit "B," and IncorpOrAted hl~roln by reference as If set forth at
lenglh,
4. As of September 30, 1990, Defendantl1ad not responded to Plalnllff's
dl!lcovery requests, Accordingly, on sunil c1ate, Plaintiff's counsel sent Defendant's
counsel a le\\er Informing Defendant's counsel \l1at the cllscQvery f:1nSwers were
overdue f:lnd aslllno Defendant to file Ills answers wltlltl1e next ten (10) dEWS, A copy
of such le\\er Is a\\acl1ed l1ereto, marked I:xlllblt "0," and Incorporated l1el'eln by
reference as If set fortl1 at lengtl1,
6, As of tile present date, I)efendant has failed to proVlcle both anSWflrS to
the aforementioned Interrogatories find responsas to the requests for production of
doclln18nts,
6, A par\y In a civil action may ohtaln discovery of any malter, not priVileged,
which Is relevant to the subJeot matter of tile acllon, Pu,R,C,P 4003,1 (a),
7, A party may serve lIpon any otller party written Interrogatories, Pa,R,C,P,
4005(a), and a request for producllon of c1acuments, Pa,R,C,P, 4000,1 and 4009,11 (a),
to be answered by tile party served,
0, Uncler the Pennsylvania r~ules of Civil Procedure a party served with
wrl\\en Interrogatories and a reqllest for production of documents shall serve an answer
to suclllnterrogatorles and reqllest within tlllrty (30) days of service, Pa,R,C,P,
4006(a)(2) and 4000,12(a),
0, Tile caul" may, upon motion, malle an appropriate order If a party falls to
serve answers to written Interrogatories, Pa,R,C,P, 4010(a)(1 )(1), or to respond to a
reqllest for prodllctlon of documents, See Pa,R,C,P, 4010(a)(1 )(vlI),
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, Solullon Technologies, Ino" respeotfully requests your
Honorable Court to enter an Order compelling Defendant Robert 0, CiaI'll d/b/a Robert
2
, fo7U:n'Olr~).)[:
(IF 1IIh' I'/lm/ () 'IOT,\flY
D~ Dnr? I AN Inl 1/
Ii.
C()I~Wl:FIINi() COUNTY
, . ~NNEiYt.\W'il'\
H "
" "
,;, "
!' " II
i\,.
"
,. " "
1':'
I." i'. !\
;,
" I:;
"
;;
,. it; j',
L .,
if
" "
,. ",.
" Ii I'
i, ,'I.
" "
"
" "
i', '\ '.",
" " "
fl" ;;
II
" ,j' "
!f ,.
\i
" ..
!;
,.
iI .;.- " ,.
I;
,. ;,
.,. .,
I. " I' II
" .,. " II
i!
j' "
." ;, If
"
"
"
" 'i I, "
.. ,
"
i; ,. .,
, .il
"
"
" ;;
'" "
"
,. 'J,
,-;;-
".1 ,.
H
"
"
"
j.
.,
"
.. ,
...
,.
..
,. "
, " H:
I. "
.j'. 'I
" "
,. /,
"
" i'
I , I ,
!>
" " , "
,
Ii
'I;
I' ,l
"
" ,. I ,
" , ~
i!
, , ,.
,
I' " ,i'
"
,. ",
.. , , ,.
" " "
d " "
, I' ,.
j; "
,.' ,. II
!i;i ,.
" ,.
"
'1 H
i
, .. .' "
II
I'
"
1j
, , " "
1,1 ,.
" " ;I
.. 'I
,. " ..
" ,
,'.
Ii'
, "
" /{f
, ,
I' :11 .,
Ii
,. 'I
d "
i,
"
, , \.
\ I Ii .1.
"
..
, " '1
i' liiXlIII3I'l' 11 "
"
, ,
" ..
"
"
SOl-UTI ON TI:OHNOf.,OQI1:8, INO"
PIAlnllff
;IN T1113 OOURT OF COMMON Pl..aAs OF
: OUMJ:lI=Rf.,ANP COUNTY, PI:NNSYI-VANIA
VII,
.
.
; No, 00.1771)
;
; 01Vl1- ACTION
ROJ:lI:RT p, cl-ARK ~/b/A
ROI3f:RT p, CLARK AOOOUNTIN13,
Dofen~Anl
OOMJ:lINI:P INT13RROGATORI1:8 ANP
REQU13STB FOR PRODUOTION OF POCUM13NTS
Tal PQfon~l\nt Robort p, Olnrk d/b/~ Roport 0, 011\1'11 AlloountlnOl
INSTRUCTIONS AND Of:FINITlONS
Pursuant to Pennsylvanl/:1 Hules of ClvllProoedurfl4001 et seq" please respond to
the within Interrogatories/Requests for Produotlon of poouments within thirty days of the
date of servloe,
In answering these Interrogatories, ple/:1ee furnish alllnformaUon /:1vallable to the
Plaintiff or within your poesosslon, oustody or oontrol, or In the possession, oustodyor
oClntrol of any person aotlng or purporUng to aot on your behalf.
Please answereaoh Interrogatory sepamtely and as aompletely /:1S pOBslble, If your
InvestlgaUon Is oontlnulng, please answer eaoh Interrogatory based upon Information
presently Imown to you, If additional Information IB obtained 01' COmeB within your oontrol
or ImoWledge, please provide supplemental answers to these Interrogatories as required
by the Rules of Civil Prooedure,
If a privilege Is olalmed as to any of the requested Information, pleaBe provide a
privilege log whloh IdonUfies the Information subJeotto the priVilege,
If any Interrogatory or RequoBt for Produotlon of DoclImonts 18 obJeoted to, please
stl1te t1111 ohJectlon "'ncltho Ilaals \lpon whlph th\'l ohjllollon lamado,
l=lhotoooples of 1116 roquoatod domlmllnta I11f1Y hll provlctocl. If oopylnu the
dooumantll would oausf) InoonVflnlanoe or \Indue hardship, pleclso ao stElta In the
IIPprOllrlate answer flnd a mutufllly oonvanlentlllnu amI plaoa will he Elrrunoecl to faollltClte
11113 oopylng of the requested dooumenta,
Ooflnltlonll
Aa uaed In these Interrooatorllls, the following terlna I1re Intended tt\ have the
followlno meanings:
"Pefandrmt", "you" ol'''Defendant's oompany" shall mean Defendant Rohart p, Olarl<
d/b/a Hobert p, Olarl< Aocountlng, his Elgents, servanta, employees, representatives,
Insurers, allorneys and any other peraona undor her dlreotlon or oontrol or purporting to
repreaent the SElme,
Unleua otherwise Indloated In theBe Interrogatories, the torm"wrltlng" Inoludes the
original or oopy of doo\lment whether handwrlllen, typewritten, printed, photostatlo oopy,
photograph and every other meana of reoordlng upon any tangible thing, any form of
oommunlaatlon or representatlon,lnoludlng lett~rs, words, plotures, lJr oomblnatlon of them,
Information being requested Inoludes Information In possession of the answering
party, the answering party's attorneys and agents and the answering party's flrat party
Insuranoe oarrler,
, Intorrogatory t~ 1 r Please Identify the Individual (by name, address and position
within Defendant's aompany) providing answers to these Interrogutorles,
ANSWERI
~ .
hltarrpoRtory # 211 Ple/:1se pmvlqe a full anel oomplete IIsl of eaoh employee Ihat
10 referenoed In ~ 70(1) of ypur answer with new mailer anel oounterclahn. In adel!Uon,
please proVide the followlno Informatlolll
R), Ihe Job title for eaoh employeel
1>), their rate of pay (please Identify whether !laoh employee Is sall1rled 01' paid by
tho hour):
c), the eXE!ot Bum palel to eaoh employee l'Ia a reault of Plalnllffs alleged oonduot:
anel
d), the nature of the work requlreel by eaoh employee whlah Jusllneel addlllonal PIW,
ANBWI:Rr
Roqunat for ProductIon of Documontol For eaoh employee referenoed In ~ 70(1)
of your I:1nswerwlth new ml'ltler and oounterolalm pleaae produoe full emd oomplete copies
of 1116 followlno dooumenta:
n), any Ilnd l'IlI time reaorda/aheeta/cards for eaoh auch employee for the follOWing
oalender years: 1996 & 1907: and
b), an~, and l'IlI dooumonts or reoords of any nature or form whloh relate to
additional payments made to these employees aa a result of Plalntlfra l'IlIaged
conduot.
I'
!\
,I.
"
"
.,.
I'
Ii
j, !~ di
"1.,"
',.
d
"
,
"
I'
I'
I'
1'-
!' ./
"
.'
,
.!;. " \\ ,. ,.
,. f{
" "
,. ,. ,
"
I ,. I'
I'
,.
"
" i/. ,
Ii,
,. , ,
" Ii I'
" I
n
n " I'
:il!,
, "
,. Ii
"
I' H, 'I;
"
,.
I' ,
I'
"
"
Il:XlIIOH'l3
FIWr>.OltFIOF.
or 11.1F rI1('ITlIOI>!QTARY
$V nOHI
MIIOI II
CUMEI:IIII\)!U COIJN1Y
, .. PENNOYW/\NIA
,"
H
,.
Ii
,.
"
.."
Ii
,.
"
/,
,.
,.
\f'
..
,.
,~ "
,.
;;
"
.
. .
,.
;,
"
"
"
,!'
"
>- f'" ~
Ir r:; E"
-ii'
,..: " ~:;= ,
", ,Ii 'H)'~
'~Ij'!tj " ';:,)~; ,
) "tc' ,'~t:~
1'(.\ ), \_lrJ:
,. i.: ,:1':' "l';~l
11
?," j II:.
")1.1, llt{!~
1.;;1'" ,:~J t~;.:
Lt::P,! m ii"'"
rL !- ! all,
lS 81 "5 " ..
(.1
H
'Ii
"
"
.,
i!
Ii
;,
"
iI !',
"
.'
II'
k-
"
i
/,
I! ,I
/""",
"
" "
" ,
I'
I'
;i
"
,II i!
"
,.
Ie
,t'
,,Ii
/.
1'.
Ho'
II
,
" I . ,
II "
,I' I' , i'
, ,
" ,.
'I'
,. Ii
"
"
"
"
'll
"
,.
Ii
;,
I;
,."
,,"',
"
I,
i!
" l'
j;
!
~"
ii,
,.
,.
,-"
.,.. (,0 ,-
VI' (...
~l\ C
-, ....
t" If'; .,. "
"'1 :;1';'(1"
}.I'l;;' C.h,~
~; '. r ", ;,,:: ();.:-ct ;11
I" ..
.1-.1 <1., I_,!::l
(.('l"_) ,.\..... {~:
hllL ~ 'tt@ !\
1.\' i'iJ l~.n \1
t\' II.; i 11ft)
, ;1 ~ (:'1 If..) ~.
"'. (t~ " " I "
lIl, r", ...) ..
CI 1:::1 (..)
.;;J
II'
.,
"
"
,,,
" .. 11
" "
"
"IJ'
-,:1
"
.1
,.
il
"
.
'I
."
"
";t "
"
"
i"
"
"
L
;.
"
;i
I'"