HomeMy WebLinkAbout99-02531
'f
,.~.
j
\
\
)
.....
I'(')
\t)
~
.
.
Timberle A.P. Cere,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON
PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND
COUNTY
Plaintiff
Barry Wagner and
Danielle Wise,
Defendants
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO: qq _ ;;)531
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
NOTICE TO DEFEND
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend, you must enter a written appearance
personally or by an attorney and file your defenses or objections in writing with the court. You
are warned that if you fail to do so, the case may proceed without you and a judgement may be
entered against you without further notice for the relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose
money or property or other rights important to you.
YOU MUST RESPOND BY FILING AN ANSWER WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS
FROM THE DATE OF RECEIPT OF THIS COMPLAINT.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS NOTICE TO YOUR LA WYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO
NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE
OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Cumberland County Bar Association
2 Liberty A venue
Carlisle, PA 17013
Telephone: (717) 249-3166
AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT OF 1990
The Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County is required by law to comply with
the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. For infonnation about accessible facilities and
reasonable accommodations available to disabled individuals having business before the Court.
please contact our office. All arrangments must be made at least 72 hours prior to any hearing or
business before the Court. You must attend the scheduled conference or hearing.
, .
answered, uy cs."
9. Mr. Marks also asked Defendant Wagner iflhere were any other problems with
the Mazda. Defendant Wagner said, "No."
10. About 8:00 P.M. Plaintiff, Mr. Marks and Defendant Wagner briefly test drove
the Mazda, which revealed no problems.
i I. The Pfainliffhad the Mazda inspected by a local mechanic who noted no major
mechanical problems and provided a list of minor repairs, which were made by
Plaintiff at a cost of $160. 77. A true and correct copy of the repair bill is attached
as Exhibit 1 and incorporated hereto.
12. On Wednesday, January 13, 1999, about 6:00 P.M. the Plaintiffpurchased the
Mazda from Defendant Wise in Mechanicsburg, Pa., for $2475.00. A true and
correct copy of a statement of the costs associated with the purchase is attached
as Exhibit 2 and incorporated herein.
13. On Thursday morning, January 14, 1999 Plaintiff drove the Mazda to her work in
Carlisle from her home in Mechanicsburg. The heater did not provide any heat
for the passenger compartment of the Mazda.
14. 011 or about January 26, 1999, Monroe Muffler/Brake and Service Company
attempted to repair the heater by flushing the heating system. The Plaintiffpaid
$54.06 for the service, which was ineffective. A true and correct copy of the
Monroe bill is attached as Exhibit 3 and incorporated herein.
15. Eventually Leininger's Automotive Garage diagnosed the heating problem as
being a defective heater core. On February 5, 1999, the heater core was replaced
at a cost to the Plaintiff of$233.15. A true and correct copy of the repair bill is
allached as Exhibit 4 and incorporated herein.
16.
On or about February IS, 1999, Plaintiff heard a knocking noise in the engine of
r
I
I
I
1
,
i
i
i'
,
!.',
i'
the Mazda as she drove home from work.
17.
Plainti ff discovered that the engine oil level was very low and she had over two
quarts of oil added to the engine oilleve!.
18.
The mechanic at Leininger's Garage concluded that the Mazda engine was
"smoking" and "burning oi!." The estimated cost of repairs is $1,500.00.
19. On or about February 28, 1999, Plaintiff checked the oil level and discovered that
the oil level was again one quart low. Accordingly, a quart of oil was added to the
engine oilleve!.
20. On or about Mareh IS, 1999, Plaintiff again checked the oil level in the engine
and discovered it was a quart low. A quart of oil was put into the engine.
21. The pattern of adding a quart of oil to the engine oil level about every two weeks
has continued to the date ofthis complaint.
COUNT ONE
(Fraud in the Inducement)
22. Paragraphs 1-21 are incorporated by reference.
23. Plainliffwould not have purchased an automobile in which the heater did not
work due to her ankle injury or whieh consumed oil due to a major mechanical
defect.
24. Defendant Wagner represented specifically that the heater worked and that there
were no other problems with the Mazda.
had no major mcchanical problcms.
3 I . Thc bricf test ridc and thc mcchanical inspcction would not havc rcvcalcd thc
major mcchanical problems.
32. Thc warranty was breached because thc Mazda was not in "very good condition"
as Dcfendant Wagncr had warranted.
33. Thc Plaintiff has been damaged in thc following amount:
a. Purchasc price................................................$2,475.00
b. Fees with purchase.........................................$ 203.00
c. Repairs made..................................................$ 160.77
d. Heatcr repair (ineffective)..............................$ 54.06
e. Heatcr repair...................................................$ 233.15
Total
$3,095.98
WHEREFORE. Plaintiff respectfully requests this Honorable Court to award her
damages in the amount of$2,965.21 togethcr with costs, attorneys fees and intercst.
Rcspectfully submitted,
~~t?~
Tirnberlc A.P. Cero
777 Old Silvcr Spring Road
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
(717) 697-5540
':,~;:' . ,~~,:","''':M2:;..\:h.id:i~:~;;;.::. MtW~~tFis "~;aRA'K~S €s+EE'fllNk~'su~~~g~S1oN' '::ALIGNM'ENT~v~~
'if!: '~";::i~i~iRES '~~f{CHAN~ES'~~O+.HEFj 'CAIL y ~MAINt"E~ANCESERV'fcES'~~~'
'to r.~J!!,.'.p' ...., "i.ll~'" "j\\"" " .., ','". "'" :om'L'e " 'D'r.~"'ro" '..... "."";~"'.''''
I. .tf'~'~ ~""I:.i"I"'\' .'....M'~M. I'.,.' i'J'l:o\.Ii"\...", .. ." '\1")""'.11"1,4 'rf~. 0310~~~'li'i":
'~";{".~' ..~... !'l'i.:~,f.,.':jr.~:r', ., t~.;,..I"-~l! r."J".,,,'} ra....;) ...':1', \I~
~i, .. ','" Al'lS72~ ',.dhl~ll.:j:'''N. "j ~,... ~ li!l~. ,J.,l, I '. rJo..~~\\...~\ " _, :1S'_.tY~~J
:h!b....:t. :., Ait.),I~,dA "'l ';'1' 1C"~.r;'<~;'TlME.eRLE rr!M'~' R'iJ,f, 1".1:;': :1~~~~ ~ll": ','" '..' ',"_" " ~:?;~~ ' IlJl~,.l\Zi!a.:. ',~ :,' ,. .', t
:."~, v~,.,~,-6A't~. .~.t'A""",,"'"' .,........."... ~r.III,-ooa\"I'"
. 'f;fl.ti-.....,s ..:' " .... :l.:AU,.4'~;.. ;-~"'-" J,' ',':', 7n:CLD ~J..YE~RIM6. RD ',~l., '~~t~~.~;'!' ";";'}':"'.' '.1'l"'o~.":~ '~~~U,ii;!i!,~ ,'t'>:, .,: ~ 'V~~,r
,:W",cr.:,. ""I"'" '"''',-'--'' '....... ...' ' '. , ',' ,,,,,..",".. . '1 ''''''
' ""~:,:IU<RO SHCP I ,1~l:il~:"tJ ":~'''.~ IIECI'I1N1C".aURG .. eA. 17055 ,:.,;"< ",1/15/11 ":"':'"'13:33'''''''1''' ::: " ,'I,dT~n~",
.,':'" !,. . . '" -.. '. "'" . . ., 'I 'R" ,. "!;ij'" '. , , .,l"'.,{ ., "O:;"""l't~ IA '. -,. ,,~. '1Pt)l;'-ll
j'.:;.,de45 CJ;RL:SlE PIl\E,A.~EVIN RD. J,'.~,:,; t1 ~"...i.', ',;, '",,; ,.;.' ,,' ESTIMATE h ;", ,'5341l5 INVOICE I: 3%:2 :~k;,,::
.. " :':!~'t. "~~~'f:~':'~':;';, ':: . " J (7171175-9916 :i; ,~~': :,. YB'lR: B9 ,~r ~flE: AAZOIi :". ,r. Jl()tP.~:.!23 ,.::...~t~~,I~~'
'lEC:;;NIC:;.URG "Pii':170~S 17171\qi.~~"o:m. L:C::N5< 1;":JDX~s7 ST: ~~ :', ':,.."
Y;i17ls-me , " ' PO'i: ML<;'<;. IN:..,~"!:I ~lif"~ ,~T: 8251\ ';:':; l
:~ .
~ER: C:4<D 1l""IL1.E~ "
'TE, CH>IICI.i:~: CliA1l~A:~I'a,R &.,"/' ,
ALL CHAD A KlulR;.' / .
/\ I / / .'} I "1" '
( .. " " /'~I f/L-.,
l_._ W'_'.!I,
. ' MANAGER'S SIGNAT1.lRE
,. _ 2':':;~
'. "1. . bF(AAES
,t :',gXJ)IE~T
:\.l'.;.~,~':~;'~ .. ..':.~1'4';"'~ I,
e . ~!RME.DI:ct'Ufl"-::;.~..-.'NIJ-".~'''-.,'' !'~'!r,.25-
,'.' ..; "" ,.',.'..' ,p
.. 'BRf<(ES ";.
~ .
"
oi'ljsI4? I t(:.i,~ipl,(::J.:P~1:f '''ISF .a 2\.2S 2..23
'1."M0311 ,C'MEr~L!C BRl<RO'PIiS, , ~ i02'i.1;":.'''2~.15
,>...... ;.~ '. .. ~" (;i BRAV.ES - :', ' ':\~:;t;i~
:i';_ '" -,LI ,/:..:~~_:~
:.~ .". ~ . . ,"" &F.hk~3 T!jj;.L. ..'.::~'
. ...,..,.., ...'.'...'~ ,-
. ..~..-.r,.i,~._-..SE.\'JC,. ,'.., :", ~~ ..... --,;.~:.
__ .'. 1\ c: .:.~.:.->:,.;f:~ .' --.;~',:, ,.,1 "',:" :',.....
%/ie,,' ,C17.;JlA7STAlE"~IIPa1:~~!."':.~~.2'~,?f.i;,~011-:-'l:"::;~'" II
0;"','.: ," J '''r:uJtw...~.: :i:~"~_'.:d~~Jo':i""Y~~~OU~.It~ll~ i' "ll~~"~.!~.\
l'alJTC" .r 'SPINlllE..IIJT ,. '7~ ,.". ,.... ~' ~"
1 FF'< C~. IFLL~~.€::tf.a"fj,~'l..,<<~ '!!9:~9:~~ ~"p0
1 C'IT'ELT -''lio.... iUI:.Bal~'i'~~~;'~t:4fI'" ~ ~5."!\l'';:~~ '21100
'" .. "':)t" 'l~....... _ '. ~:.,., ~,l':1 ~~".:J..'t'" \ !J. dl~
C:;~ELT1 C ."~TSi.-:., ~-~fl~)"I7'48 ~,1 r.." ,J.~a-::~i';;. ~l
( SRD!SCct:NT. <~~~~"MfC:; OI5CllKl.l:":.}..;gt<<l~, .~JlI. ~"~S;llS~. .q~~~iOO-
'....1 iJl.~ EO 'gSERvICF~Al.':l p' fJ'~" R"2l.!l :"I.t'~~:' ,
:".1 ~'~~;'!.~ .;",;;". ~t~~ ,f,:, .e-;\~,!. ~,~ \'Ie '
_ J: "'otd'~.-..:,... :J v' :.(Ia.~~!I ~ ~.....~....., 1eH.~ 1M .
.~ ~.r~""ll.' ...... ...~," . , ,. I, ",~C'".1 i\, J ".J:"<;AV:1. -
'~','~W""~~- . ~;;",:,;;7lrmiF .,:'~~.:
.,..~~W - .-~"'--'''-'. ......,... "",,, .;.s~~'~
~'.....' ......'~. '~'~-il=:i'''1'''' 'i'-:;';"iU
.\ . ," 'Ot4r. '-:,,". 'O~:~~.;5t~
',' e.;;-6; . ' ~'~:'~"[.!
'-, ". ':' - ~"'i - "';,)~'~.-::~f~'f;; ~.; \",,\
:..-, .~e.u
,," "J~.,OO
i ..~: ;: .';.
;~,_f.' .~_''; '.
'....-., "~.
..t;:;\'.':':'.',;;~
:;!.'r;,.
"-, '..
.", .
. .~~ ~~ .~~
': ~ ~I ":
."~C"",_ ...
.
:,:.';,....:.:.~. ;,;.;
er~:..:~";'..:. '." .
.... ,
~. "; :'.' ~, ~ ,;
~... ,-"".'~
.!f;,-'....:l
.";' I
,,-,". J:
~.~ . n
;~f~,;i~,~
,;,.;,;:"
':':"';'
:d
":,.-.<:
.." ,".
'.,!~~:t .:
~ ';,
"
".':l
;:.~':::'5f ,;;.'
I .'''I.rA.'''\....._ I .'{""'-r
._~'::-- !.L..:~~.)_~',:.~__-'~', ~..,":.~.0
crECX
':~;('_l~;.) ;, :;.:;-: - .. '8
'"~ . . ..- ,.~-
19'. ,I)j l..--;gi;1 - J:=J
'j.J;'lr:; n'~_ .. u
'L~ nt'd ,;~ ~~h - i::i
;'2~1."} !,.::-J .- r' ,
~....
~;!i.,;C. H:~:":~ - C';:j
+--
SIUS .~l
GAAND-1Wt.
l.a, 77
SI.lHOTi'(
_." V J:, C,i: .5I:CP.Hl,
", -d-":"I~'j'~'~,-I ,\~... ";.'.:
,~- '-;'i.
~ . J \ ..~. ';-)',"
CUSTOMER COpy
.'
::z.~!
5~.~~
: ';':~.).~~:':
:~The undersigned. having .Iendered . payment of It
mvolca by chock; cledlt cara, or olhar charge, 'Igree
pay MONRO MUFFLERlBRAKE a ,um "eQual 10
chargos and expenses. InCluding reasonable .allorfl
loes and relurnea check chargoll incurred bV MONF.
in the 'Ivenl :hat lor any reason said ChUck or charge
nol 3CCOplOd lor collecUon and p3ia 10 MONRO,"
Your dmployoesma'l'"operale Ihis vohl=ta for inSPeCli',
10911ng, J,ndfor dOli...erYat my risk, You will not ~e_ r
sponSlble 10' ordamaga' the v~'e ~nlc!
left,lnll. ,4 'l'~" "
~'~."i~~""/"?'c" ,'"''
, -,;::?.AV< . ~
TOMER' SIGNATURE.l.'~:~r":~~!:;,,
In addition to 00'': iilatime ";.;iirraiii1eson'iTiulller~~ sticc~
brakO pads and snoas, and cenam suspension pllr1S (I
.....OICh you Will recel...e a soparalo wnllen warranty),
olher seNlcas pertormea and pans Installed are ;Ul1
anleed dgainst delecls In malotlals and workmanship j
a minimum ?orlod 01 90 days or 4,000 mllas. whlche...,
comes Ilrst. Should any pan Installed or service pe
lormed become delectlve during It's warranty pene
MONRO MUFFLER/BRAKE does hereby agruslo rep;
or replaco said pan or re.pal1_orm said sarvice at r
charge upon the praaent~tlon or thll Involc.. ,','
~ :;:~'"'~~:'~,REMIT TO:. .' <''''::''':'1 .,
,~ 2DO'HOlLEDER PARKWAY :J;;;,:"
, ROCHESTER, NY ,14615 i:;~
'J~l :"~~',..~. ,.~ :'..... .~::;.;..!.,,_::_:
~:!. OIAGiiOS'lS fAECi CdCES"'..!~~~~~;:.
,:A . Component REQUIRED bec3use It Is out
,. of manufacturer~s specilicatlon'or.no y-::":;.~
. longer pettonns Intended lunctlon,"l~'b'::r
'. ~ . Componenl or servIce SUGGEEiT.ED..pe.r,,:
h,' . industry standards or In advance qt.:,jof 1'~
" component lailurs.. '. lI.Y !.":
:,p.;. Component or service RECOMMENDED, ~or
,7., Improved vehicle performance. ~"l'jl$,-~~.~.'
. C . Component or service requasted .~y ~:d~~
. customer or, cnrryout transactlon...7";( ..,.:;5i
WARRANTY lWARR' COCES . "X?
, 0 . Liletlme on parts & labor _.,. ~<~.c;
.20 . Liletlme 01"1 parts & one (1) year_on,:,,5
labor, . _I'~~;; . \.::':;RJ:?'4~,1
30 . Five (5) years or SO,ODO miles on ,.,;..',{;~
part:l&Iabor;" ""i
:40 . One 1'1 year on parts & labor ~-
'.~ . 5, 0 . One' year or 12,000 miles on .:1.
parts&lo.bor,',:, '. r.
::60 . Ninety (gO) days or 4,000 miles
on parts & labor .
70 . Sae manulacturers written warranty
NO. NO WARRANTY
5f;1l't:'1Kll'1f;.t'i .
"'
~,...;: .;
27. ;5- ,
\2.18
;.-.:3
6.39" ,;;
<;.4j","';"
19.91 ..
jo.2e, _1 :'
J::. sa ~~' '1'\
..29:e5ci ;~
. 8i..14 "":':'~'_;'l:
~,'"
:~~:,<.7~
".,.'
,t.,,'.;
, "r ~SEE'AEYEBSE F.QIllOC~T10N (LOCI CODES ANt
151.67 . hl.tW(Ll!IICOllJl>W_Il<lIlllRV1CECENTERS
.: ~q':IE'Arlqj~ A~
~.l~ .'; mt41m:D; TO'~OING
160. 77 <1I11ll TIE.HIGIlESl1UVEl
CliSTfJlER"'5ERVlCE"iF ~"
HIlVE ~'mTl0t6 OR
,.:;cWteir5.iuASEtA.L
VINCENT'~RA 2!i-I',Z
EXHlsr
J
1
1 ~~Y ~~...~I C~"E~..I":
~f",~ -.Ij:\
MUFFLERS - BRAKES - STEERING - SUSPENSION ;_,;( _~..
. ALIGNMENTS. TIRES" OILi::HANGEs'~~f;:di:t.:;; -Qnal:l~~
' OTHER DAILY MAINTENANCE SERVICES" '1;"".' ~...~~~~tt..~e~#l1ii..
AI~J~727.r . ~
~ TIIII!I:RlE Cl:J<ll , ,. .,
"'" ~ .....~- ,..77J lL? SILVEilSllRI!<<; RD. . ,I. ' :',.....
IQRO Sli(Jl1~ll~t~ .~~~~' ';.~IE.9t!1!.~J<ll ~ ~17f15,' ~' ~~S3 ~}2~/'.'; I
6(l\5 CSlR(l~ PlliE ~YI.~ RD.~. '~i..;r t~~!'7t . .;1' ~h. , .".
"':\:~f~~ ~,1i,,:l"',~;;,~,: ~>\;,t7l7)9~-~e16';':"",,~ ",I.'''i'',~ R:tl9, , '/IiKE:' '".
1lE~~ICSauJ<ll.""PA 17Q5'5, ""., . '." 1717Im-:!;CQ.ElT. '~l ; 1,;' '\L/C9G;'lr'CjoX957 ,.1;
17171m-9220 j:<J I: ~ILE""E IN: lil.i<:;S
/~
.,' . ~..' ~'.", "The unce~r9ned, having-tendered lIaymem 01 :hr$
inVOIce by check, cradil card, or other Chan;e. a~ree I
;lay MCNAOMUFFLERi8RAKE or SPEEDY AUTO
SERVICE .1 sum sQual 10 all charges and OlClJenSos,
inclUding reasonable anorney lees and r"turned ct1ec:
charges :ncurrod by MONRO or SPEEDY, in Ihe evan"
that for anYJeascn said eneck or chargo l.!l nOI
accepted for collection and paid 10 MONRO or
SPEEDY." \"' .,.. " , '.
'(our empfoyees operale this vehicl r inspec,liC:
test/ng,~nt1for~ve my {',YO 'W' 01 be ,-
raspon , '9"" ~ iii :0 lie rllel!;
I ~l<l?~ '..-,,_
. . CUSTOMCR'S SIGNAruRE.
In addition :0 our life lime .....arrantles on mufflers, shocl<
,'brako pads 3nd shoes, and certain Suspension parts (I
:which you .....111 receive a separate'wnlten warranty), all
olher services performed and parts installed ate
guaranteed Jgalnst defec1s in matanars and workman.
ship for a miMlmum period 0'.90 days or 4,000 miles,
wnlchever comes firsl. Should any part installed or
ser...ice performed become dalec1ive during ii's warrant
penod, MONRO MUFFI.ER/BRAKE or SPEEDY AUTO
SERVICE does "hereby agree to repair or replace said
part or re.perlorm said service at no charge upon the
presentallon ot this Involcl!!. '. ~..'; .
REMIT TO:
200 HOLLEDER PARKWAY
ROCHESTER, NY 14615
DIAGNO~p ~REC' CODES
Componenl AEbulAED because it IS out of
manufacturer's specilication or no longer
perlorms intended lunelion, .
5 : CompoJnenl or service SUGGESTED per
6- industry standards or in advanr.:e 01
componenllailure.
P .. Componenl or service RECOMMENDED lor
improved vehicle performance.
Component or service requested by Cuslomer
or carrycul transactlon.
WARRANTY /WARFU CODES
Lfelime on paris 5. labor
Lifetime on parts" one (1) year on
labor
Five (5) years or 50,000 miles on pans
&. labor
.so .. One (1) year on parts & labor
SO ';';" One (1l year or 12,000 miles "n pans &
. labor ....
60:<>' Ninety (90) days or 4,000 miles on parts
& labor ., . ~,.J
70 . See manulacturers wnnen warranty
NO c NO WARRANTY .' .
51. Ill! , .' \'W FOIl:STIJlPING AT . "'.
1lO:-IiE.lif~ ~Loc.nON (LOCI fOOfS I
ClJIIITTED'TO PROVIDING Y
WITH ~ Hl~S! LEVa
lllSTOIEJl SCRV ICE. IF YOO
: -', "" .: ~~ 'I,
'4~~U :I
rotENTS' PLEilSE'CSU.
VINCENT DASTRA 233-9~9Z
\.
lII'.Nr.ciR: ARTHUR L FR!T1
TEC:'NICIhN: llARTlN IL
ALL ,'~RTIN P L
.~..- ~ .. ,,....
'<,~jl'
~',IJ;.:t
;.~,):.
toEJlT"
'.' ~.;' ". ,'~,
. ,
. ,~.
...:~'
.':...
. :'~'.,;. :;~>,:~>,.\.
f~t::~:~G,
.-: '
'. ,.':~.,."
>.<- :
M,,~eQi;.'l' SlOi'l"TURE
..~ -~.:....
.....,.
-
::~',';::
." ..~....,.."",.
"'.-:
.~_~,f.'"
~~-'-
1 13
1 13
C MISC. SERVICE
C MISC. SERVICE
, ' , ,$<RVIC< TOTAL
:~~~i ..Lff~:\.'.",.
ia
,a
SIC
SiC
.5.~
;.il\!
4~.00
&.00
51.1le.
\',-
:.~,
';,....
. ~~' I
:.....'.
'.
.. ~',
.. .
, -'.
.- ,.... ~. ...
'.J :':,.-:. . ",
,... ,-'
..)/.
""-'.
. --1
' ..,6.17'
.:? I .
~ .::
2:t.;
j'.' ~~; 'I
. .'~', ,
~ ',.; -' .~.
,
~cn ..~.., -., ~- -.
. .... ,.. "~:. "-
, . '1~"C(
'"!,7Y
'''l ....
,..."r'
.'
a-I"' ' 'jeil (."
j/J
o
?I-<
I
,
,,'
CHEC{
54.06
SUB-TOTl'(
srHS TAX
SRrJ/D- TOTAl
3.06
S4.0b
c
-,
INVOICE
SlilJPl\1
CUSTOMER COpy
. -. -..-.-- --. --~,- --. -- - -.--.. -.--
.-...-...------
~,
.
.\
.' .:~,.... ,....,:~,)."..,"~::)~~~':;'i,',,:..
;' ...'r.o.. ~t,',
,..",>,,',t) ~
~ II m .-r.i' '1;0 ~~;J
PIlDEi. J2J.' :.., ': , ':!
ST ~:i"~ l,#~; .", " .
MUDGE OUT: ~
1ol( 7l'O
,/':~.": '. 'OJ '~"~I"'''''~'' \\';:'~,~~I~::i:ri71~~i.S
"..~I,~,. _,'1"" r~~"lf~T'-':_':j~".
.. ," ; '. l ,1 :',' ~ ,,' l\,,:t:>.r f, 7{ ~,"~ t-:
":"6 '!~'" .... ,','"~f'j~I~.~.'::..'~A~'f..
'.. - _. '. '.'\':1'J.'L,.~~...t.. ~'.,
(.'-:-':1,- .:"Jr .,,~..~-t; ~\;-:";;,rl:H~o!.~.,~:~,:..
,;.. -:~ '. -', .,,",. ,'~."I.n."~ "....,..
.....;;-:.\~. .' .......,.. ..u..... ..'~...,"_.,
. "~,;;:,1.":. -I ~.;.1:'f.,.~.~~~~:Xt<l:.'......~..:
...
_..
'"
D
'0
20
'0
EXHlsr
J
.3
0926168
...-.'-..-------- .___.......~...Jf't.-._.:
". .
(".'
.. ..,
.....
. ~'.{. './ .
";'.'~l' .;
....1. .
'::~";-"" --........ --..-.
" ",.....1.:
-j:) 'o..(
..,I.
.'
" .'. fIi...,........A
..~.;..,.,...~~\,.,t:..7'"
.... 't.~::,~:.j[[.,!,;. :,:. . ~:' .
r~"''''''''''7:':-~~''\.~~'_--;''!'7''I''J.I~,;-r:-'''R -""~~-~-;"'-:--~~"l"\tJ..~ ,I:
-. ~1' -" ......~MJ';' ...... '.~"""';j{fJl;.......:. '.'"Il'l::~!r','!''' "\J -A.f..L1.,:z,.1:\.'."",......,. . ',',' 0/,... ")'. /I
},:'; '," ~'.~~:;;r'(EiN~G~Rs:~uf5MO~IVE:.?_..;7.' -..\'.;,J '. .. . , -"f: "}'l:\. ,. ,t:: .
- , :J ~:-.\,- :'6384 Brandy Lane" ..REPAIR ORDER' .,. -----.
t Mechanlcsburg. PA 17055 " ' '
1 ., (717) 766a1414
FAX (717) 796-0760
,"
j i
. t,
i.r
'"
,
.
i
I
i
i
.I
,
i
.1.... r'.,
j r
I (
I .'
(
',I [.
,',.
l
. !
,
t..
I I
.._Ll
! .
,
(
~ '.'
." .!
,',
.
,
i
I
..I:
I
L
I
",,",
llAT1!:I'AOlol13fC
NI:Q4AHCIT1!:Cl-W1CWol
...,-
...........
UC<NC< ""-
.......
CESCRIPTlON OF 'M:lAK
AMOUNT
o CHANGE OIL
o TUNE,UP
DLUBE
o OIL FILTER
:'
,
~
I
!
;',
I
.",'~'-~--'
....,.
er<
PART NO. AND CESCRIPTlON
(
\
-
..:
..."
'.~ .......
Cl CHECK
Clc.osH
I:lJac
TOTAL PARTS
TOTAL LABOR
EPA I WASTE
DISPOSAL
I '*-by autt'IorIm thI abcMllWpait wort( 10 . ak)ng
with the nec:unry rT'IlIr.riall. You and your emploY'"' may
Opol'lll the vehicle tor purpoHI of telting, Inspection. or
cMlMir M my fiak. M elprtll meehanica lien II
aeknowledgecf on above vehicle to HCure the emount of
I1Ipall'l therellO. tl is understood thai you win not be held
I'lllpeMible lor Iou Of d."..ge to the w.hicl. Of" article. left
In vet'liCle In cue of tire, theft or &ny other cauaea b-vond
yourOQon1rol.
.-....
SUB-TOTAL
TAX
TOTAL
x
L
~.~ RfI...(to.&9707Ut;l
r~:..~~;:.;.~:_~~_ "
EXHIBIT
Y
I
I
I
I
,
,
I
i
I
I
I
I
I
i
,
,
,
I
I
f
..
..
C.f!MMON.WIALTH 0' PINNIYLVANIA
COUI' O' COMMON PUA5
NOTICE OF APPEAL
fROM
JUDICIAL DISYIICY
DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT
COMMON ...", No. qg. ;}S3/ ('.~~ I Ttrm
NOTICE OF APPEAL L/ In Iqq
Nolie. i. givon that tho appellant has Hied in tho above Court of Camman PIoa. an appeal lrom tho judgment r.ndered by tho Di.trict Ju.tic. an tho
date and in tho case mentianod balow.
c..edW
~~_"'o7aJ
(OlJfmc1.nJ
t D.4>.J/Ei..U;
l':i(;~
0wE~Fk Cern
117 DLO 5llVEl<SPI?.D/G R I
J./. J
"
TIMP.>EQ.Le.
WISE.
Signarure of Prothonotary Of Deputy
If appellant was CLAIMANT (see Fa. R.C.P.J.P. No.
1001 (6) in action belore District Justice, he MUST
FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty /20) days alter
filing his NOTICE 01 APPEAL.
i
I
I
i
CV 19. q'l - 00" no 7 '1
LT 19
This black will be signed ONLY when thi. notaHan i. required uncle< Po. R.cP.JP. No.
l008B.
This Notice of Appeal, when received by the District Justice. will operate as a
SUPERSEDEAS ta tho judgment lor posse.sian in this ca...
PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE
/7his section oIlonn to be used ONLY when appellant was OEFENDANT (see Pa, R.C.P.J.P. No. loo1l7) in action before O;stliet Justice.
tF NOT USED. detach from copy of notice of appeal to be served upon appellee}.
PRAECIPE, To Prothonotary
Enter rul. upon
. appell..(.). to Hie a complaint in this appooI
Name 01 appcllec(sJ
(Common PIoa. No.
) within twenty (20) day. after service 01 rule or .ullor entry 01 juclgmont 01 non pos.
SJg1atlle of a(.JJeIIwJf Of his attomey or ~
RULE, To
. appelloo(.).
Name 0I8f.P01lOe(s,
(1) You "'" noHfied that a rule i. hereby entered upan you ta file a camploint in this appeal within twenty (20) day. aIt., tho date of
service of this rule upon you by p."anal ..,vic. or by certified or rogi.terod mail
(2111 you do not file a complaint within this Hmo, a JUDGMENT OF NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU.
(3) Tho date of servic. of this rule ~ ..,vice was by moil i. tho date of mamng.
Date:
,19_.
Sig1aUe rI Po.AJ.o.,*, rx 0IIpJty
lOPe 311.61
COURT FILE TO BE FILED WITH PROTHONOTARY
c" -..
COM\.10NWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
(This proof of ~orvico MUST BE FILED WJ7HIN TEN (10) DAYS AFTER filing the nor/ce of appoal. Chock applicablo boxes)
PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT
COUNTY OF ; ""
AFFIDAVIT: Illoroby swear or affirm that I servoej
o a copy of the Notice of Apponl, Cl)rnlTlOn PIl'il5 No. _ , upon the District Juslic;c designated therein on
(date of 5o"vice) ___ , 0 by personal serv'ce 0 by (cerliliedj (registered) mall, sender's
receipt attached hereto. and upon lhe appellee, (nama) , an
, 19_ 0 by personal servicQ 0 by (certified) (registered) mail, sender's receIpt attached hereto.
0, and further that I served thl' Rule to Filo a Complaint accompanying the above Notice of Appeal upon the appellee(s) to whom
the Rule was addressed on __ I 19_-.0 by personal service 0 by (certified) (registered)
mail, sender's receipt atlache,j tifHctO"
SWORN (AFFIRMED) AND SUBSCRIBED ElEFOF1E ME
THIS _____ DAY OF ___ , 18_._,
Signature of affiant
SianllluflI 01 Off/C/ill twforo whom rdflli,l~lt WilS /f'O:~tl
~._---~---
Titlll ofofllCi:t1
My cOrnnlj~l\i(.Ifl ()}(pil('s 0'1
"1~1__
() ,.0 Ii
L;- "II
~,'- -:;-..
"7;f "~:J -;1
?~ ~. ~:;.J -" ~
~ ,'V l"li-n
n ~:.- ;"jl=.t
if (J! --.1 ,~"~ (~J
~ -, B
J:) ~~~: -n ..
,~C~ -~-~ ~~.~ fq
llo 'I.J ~;~:; l::.jl'fl ,
(J1 -4 IU
..;) "S.- .'" )> U'l
:.:1 j.J
-0 (]'I -< ().)
-0 ~
~ p
-rj .,.
~
3
. .
.. "':';
..
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF: CUMBERLAND
,
NOTICE OF cI~ItGC~~~T/TRANSCRIPT
PLAINTIFF: NAMEandADDRE&S
fCERO, TIHBERLE '-,
777 OLD SILVER SPRING RD,
MECHANICSBORG, PA 17055
Mil). 0111. No.:
09-3-04
OJNIlTlt: lion.
THOMAS A. PLACEY
-.." 104 S. SPORTING HILL RD.
MECHANI:CSBORG, PA
\
" L
,
-..l
VS.
NM4E and ADDRESS
rwAGNER, BARRY, ET AL.
3118 HARVARD AVE.
CAMP HILL, PA 17011
L
Docket No.: CV- 0000079 -99
Date Filed: 2/23/99
i
I
I
I
,
I
I'
I
I
,
,
I
I
"
I
I
TI_""': (717) 761-8230
OEFENOANT:
17055
-,
TIMBERLB.CERO
777 OLD, SILVER SPRING RD.
MECHANICSBORG, PA 17055
',/\0'\ /
, ./ ..~/
, THIS IS.TO NOTIFY YOU THAT:
. Judgmeni: . '
[i] Judgment was entered for: (Name)
, [i] Judgment was entered against: (Name)
'."
. .FOR PI.II '"N'I'TFF
. .~ I.C~.." .~,
~llRn. '1"TM'RRRT.R
WT!=:R "ANT'Rr.r.'R
In the amount of $
(Date of Judgment)
(Date & Time)
~l;~ ~1 on:
4/01/</Q
.
o Defendants are jointly and severally liable.
o Damages will be assessed on:
Amount of Judgment $ 287.21
Judgment Costs $ 66.00
Interest on Judgment $ .00
Attorney Fees $ .00
Total $ 353.21
Post Judgment Credits $
Post Judgment Costs $
o This case dismissed without prejudice.
O Amount of Judgment Subject to
AllachmenVActS of 1996 $
o Levy is stayed for _days or 0 generally stayed.
------------
------------
o Objection to levy has been filed and hearing will be held:
. . \ . I . . .;
Dale: Place:
Certified Judgment Total $
Time:
ANY PARTY HAS THE RIGHT TO APPEAL WITHIN 30 DAYS AFTER THE ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BY FILING A NOTICE
OF APPEAL WITH THE PROTHONOTARY/CLERK OF THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS. CIVIL DIVISION. YOU
MUST INCLUDE A CO~r I Ii' N ICE OF JUDGME!!!P'RANSCRIPT FORM WITH YOUR NOTICE OF APPEAL.
1-' I_a a --=
~ Date ,District Justice
I certify that this Is a true and corre t copy of
~Date
g the judgment.
. District Justice
My commission expires first Monday of January,
AOPC 3 t 5.99
SEAL
:...)
I ,
I
, ,
0: ..
..
,
I
cJ i;; 0
-
..: w ;:::
a:
a: >- -
III <i a;
III W >-
w Z Z Z ...
U ~ 0 Z "'
u: a: w cD
u. a: u. .. M
0 ci N
~ oil J: ;:::
>- a:
0 a: ::> C
-' 0 '"
Z Z III
Ci M a:
0 a:
Z on '"
<l: 'It J:
TIMBERLE A.P. CERO,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
BARRY WAGNER and
DANIELLE WISE,
Defendant
NO. 99-2531
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
TO: PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY:
Please enter the appearance of James DeCinti, Esquire of
Angino & Rovner, P.C. as counsel for Defendants.
Respectfully submitted,
James DeCinti, Esquire
I.D. #77421
4503 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
Attorneys for Angino & Rovner, P.C.
Dated: 11-f/1'7
.{\?;
,
~...._...I.""''''--''''''-,----"
".
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Megan A. Reinard, an employee of AIlgino & Rovner, P.C.,
hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the ENTRY OF
APPEARANCE was served by United States first-class mail, postage
prepaid, upon the following:
Timberle A.P. Cero
777 Old Silver Spring Road
Mechaniscburg, PA 17055
~O~'1Q-~~
Megan ' Reinard
Dated: 5/d.S/QQ
'>- tn ,"
, '.
".
(.',
,J
,
)
U I- ~
w
a: w ;::
0:
ri. I-
'" .. ;;;
'" W I-
w Z z Z r-
U Ei 0 z '"
u: 0: w '"
"- u. 0- M
00: :J: ci '"
:s;oll I- 0: r::
:5 0 0: ::> E
0 '"
z z '"
8 M ii:
0 0:
Z on ..
~ '" :I:
'.
'.
9. Denied as stated. It is admitted that Plaintiff's friend, Mr.
Marks, asked if there were any problems with the car. It is denied that
Defendant Wagner stated "no." Rather, Defendant Wagner stated as far
as he knew everything worked and the car ran well.
10. Denied as stated. It is denied that Plaintiff "briefly test
drove" the car. Rather, Plaintiff test drove the car for approximately
20 to 30 minutes both on the interstate and throughout the Camp Hill
area. It is admitted that the test drive revealed no problems because
there were no problems wi th the car. Moreover, during the test drive the
heater was on and functioning properly.
11. Denied as stated. It is admitted that the Plaintiff had the
car inspected by a local mechanic of her choosing. It is further
admitted that Plaintiff's mechanic noted no major mechanical problems.
It is specifically denied that Plaintiff paid fer all of the costs of the
minor repairs which were noted by the Plaintiff's mechanic. Rather, Mr.
Marks, contacted Defendant Wagner indicating that the repair costs would
amount to $255.00. Defendant Wagner suggested that the parties split the
cost and in doing so, Defendant Wagner reduced the sale price of the
Mazda by $125.00 from $2,600 to $2,475.
12. Admitted.
13. After a reasonable investigation, Defendants are without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of
the averment contained in this paragraph. Therefore it is denied and
strict proof will be demanded at trial.
14. Admitted in part. Denied in part. It is admitted that
Plaintiff took the automobile to Monro Muffler and Brake on or about
2
"
January 26, 1999 and had some service performed on the car in the amount
of $54.06. The remainder of the paragraph is specifically denied and
strict proof is demanded at trial.
15. Admitted in part. Denied in part. It is admitted that on or
about February 5, 1999, Plaintiff had the heater coil replaced in the
1989 Mazda. It is specifically denied that the heating coil was
defective at the time of the sale or that Defendant Wagner or Defendant
Wise are any way responsible for the heating coil.
16. After a reasonable investigation, Defendants are without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of
the averment contained in this paragraph. Therefore it is denied and
strict proof will be demanded at trial.
17. After a reasonable investigation, Defendants are without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of
the averment contained in this paragraph. Therefore it is denied and
strict proof will be demanded at trial.
18. After a reasonable investigation, Defendants are without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of
the averment contained in this paragraph. Therefore it is denied and
strict proof will be demanded at trial.
19. After a reasonable investigation, Defendants are without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of
the averment contained in this paragraph. Therefore it is denied and
strict proof will be demanded at trial.
20. After a reasonable investigation, Defendants are without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of
3
the averment contained in this paragraph. Therefore it is denied and
strict proof will be demanded at trial.
21. After a reasonable investigation, Defendants are without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of
the averment contained in this paragraph. Therefore it is denied and
strict proof will be demanded at trial.
COUNT ONE
.(FRAUD lN THE INDUCEMENT)
22. No response required.
23. The averment in this paragraph is a conclusion of fact and of
law to which no responsive pleading is required. To the extent that a
response is required the averments contained in this paragraph are
specifically denied. At the time Plaintiff purchased the vehicle, the
heater worked properly and there were no major mechanical defects in the
automobile. Strict proof of Plaintiff's claims are demanded at trial.
24.
Denied.
It is specifically denied that Defendant Wagner
represented that the heater worked.
By way of further response,
Plaintiff test drove the vehicle for more than 20 minutes, with the
heater on, and then later took the vehicle to a mechanic of their
choosing for an inspection, which revealed to Plaintiff's satisfaction
that there were no problems with the car. By way of further response,
from the time Plaintiff took the vehicle to their mechanic to the time
of the final transaction, Plaintiff was in sole and exclusive possession
of the vehicle for more than five hours.
25. Denied. It is specifically denied that the heater in the
Mazda would not function properly and that the Mazda "consumed major
4
amounts of oil due to a major mechanical problem." On the contrary,
Plaintiff took the car to a mechanic of her choosing which revealed no
major mechanical problems. Strict proof is demanded at trial.
26. (a) - (e) Denied. It is specifically denied that Defendant Wagner
made any fraudulent misrepresentations. Therefore, Plaintiff has not
been damaged by any action of Defendant Wagner.
By way of further
response the dollar amounts listed in subparagraphs a-e do not add up to
the total damages as stated in paragraph 26.
COUNT TWO
(BREACH OF WARRANTY)
27. No response required.
28. Admitted in part. Denied in part. It is admitted that
Defendant Wagner advertised the sale of a 1989 Mazda in the newspaper as
in very good condition. It is specifically denied that the advertisement
in any way mentioned anything about the presence or absence of major
mechanical defects.
29.
Denied.
It is specifically denied that Defendal1t Wagner
represented that the heater in the Mazda worked. It is further denied
that neither Plaintiff, nor her friend Mr. Marks, specifically asked
whether the heater worked. Rather, Plaintiff and her friend test drove
the vehicle for more than 20 minutes with the heater on, and
additionally, took the automobile to a mechanic of their choosing for an
inspection prior to purchase. Thereafter, and prior to the final sale,
Plaintiff and her friend were in sole and exclusive custody of the
automobile for more than five hours.
5
30. The averments contained in this paragraph are conclusion of
law to which no response is required. To the extent that a response is
deemed required it is specifically denied that Defendant Wagner warranted
a 1989 Mazda with 82,000 miles on it.
31. The averments contained in this paragraph are conclusions of
law to which no response is required. To the extent that a response is
deemed required it is specifically denied. The Plaintiff and her friend
test drove the vehicle for more than 20 minutes and hired a mechanic to
inspect the vehicle prior to sale. In addition, Plaintiff and her friend
were in sole and exclusive possession of the vehicle for more than five
hours between the time of the inspection and the time of the fin,a1
transaction.
32. The averments contained in this paragraph are conclusions of
law to which no response is required. To the extent that a response is
deemed required it is specifically denied. Strict proof is demanded at
trial.
33. Denied. It is specifically denied that the Plaintiff has been
damaged. By way of further response the dollar amounts listed in
subparagraphs a-e do not add up to the total damages listed in paragraph
33.
WHEREFORE, Defendants request Judgment in their favor and that
Plaintiff's complaint be dismissed with prejudice.
NEW MATTER
34. Defendants incorporate and assert each and every defense as
contained in Rule 1030 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure.
6
35. Plaintiff has failed to state a cause of action against
Defendants upon which relief can be granted as a matter of law.
36. Plaintiff's claims may be barred and/or limited by Plaintiff's
own comparative and/or contributory negligence.
37. Plaintiff's claims may be barred and/or limited by Plaintiff's
assumption of the risk.
38. No act or omission on the part of either Defendant whether
negligent or otherwise, and all such acts and/or omissions being
specifically denied, directly or proximately caused any damages allegedly
sustained by Plaintiff.
39. Plaintiff had the opportunity to and in fact did, test all
major interior functions of the car such as the heater, the windshield
wipers, the turn signals, and the air conditioning.
40. Plaintiff hired a mechanic of her own choosing to inspect the
vehicle and after said inspection Plaintiff determined that the car was
worth purchasing.
41. The automobile in question, a 1989 Mazda, is 10 years old and
has 82,000 miles.
42. Prior to sale, Defendants never had to add oil between oil
changes.
43. Plaintiff bought the vehicle "as is."
44. Defendants bel ieve and therefore aver that the actions of the
Plaintiff, Mr. Marks, and their mechanic's may have caused the problems
as alleged in the complaint.
45. Defendants assert. the affirmative defense of estoppel.
46. Defendants assert the affirmative defense of waiver.
7
WHEREFORE, Defendants demand judgment in their favor and request
that this honorable Court dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint with prejudice.
Respectfully submitted,
Dated:5/~1/71
ANGINa & ROVNER, P.C.
~
L .. .
James DeC~nt~, Esqu~re
LD. #77421
4503 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
Attorneys for Angino & Rovner, P.C.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Megan A. Reinard, an employee of Angino & Rovner, P.C., hereby
certify that a true and correct copy of the ENTRY OF APPEARANCE was
served by United States first-class mail, postage prepaid, upon the
following:
Timberle A.P. Cero
777 Old Silver Spring Road
Mechaniscburg, PA 17055
51a11q:?
'-/'Y\OJ\11l V'\ f). '1?(~l1a.Lt'i
~Reinard
I
9
RLED-OrTiCE
OF 1''': ! ' ,Y;I'::'i"ClTMW
99 SEP 30 Ai; 10: 35
CUM8i:fiu,,'iu CCUi\'1Y
PENNSYLWNIA
~ ..:r ~ t ~
.;: c::
:::: r:..: ?~ 0
UJ_..
<"J (~~, .~ (3~; ~
tti:' ,,- :> ~
0(:, .=i);:::
0(' - :::. ~l.~
WCL N ._J'-:'<_ ~J@
~LI; Cl.. ,:r:2~
i!.: u, "s'U
cr- ,;. Cl-
} u_ CT'l ::;
0 (j~1 0
rl
iT. Lt) ~
~ CO':
.. ~~~
wS -
Ui.5 -
~:;- c:: ,') ~:J
)1" ?~~
~. ('")
(~~ I !L:;~
_.J" : Z "':..!U.J
U:jE ::.:> i:Jc...
-, ~
l.L 0'\ :.:J
0 en ()
PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT
(This proof of servico MUST BE FILED WITHIN TEN (0) VA YS AFTER filing IIw lJotico of appoal. C/lock applicablu boxos)
COMMONWEAL]OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF_ umbe:/Q.Dd
._ ; SI
AFFIDAVIT: II1ereby swear 01 offll rT> tbal I"erved
~ u copy of the Noltce of JPP1:J.'. COlTllllGfl pJp,as No _GG-=-..Q.5_(J_J_ upon tt~.:> District Justice dusignntcd therein on
(data of "arvl""1 _).j,.,~.r!. _q9_____ . W by pN50"O' servlca [] by (cerlilled) (regislered) mail. sender's
receipt ~lIache(ll1elcto, al1ltlJl 011 t1w appell,,,,, ! """"'.I6jl"I~J"WA~_ ,Alo1n__U,flh.U~~-' , an
_Ll/_.'3a_ . 19_~___ 0 by personal s(lrvicoM by (certifiod) (registered) mail, sonder's receipt attached herelo,
o and further th("!l I served tlllo Rule 10 File a Compl;'jinl accomprmyill9 thp,1bove Nolice of APPCllllJpon theappcltee(s) towhom
the Huh.: W,loS addressed an ___._.h_______, 1~_--. 0 by personnl service 0 by (certified) (registered)
mail, sendpr's rcc(~ipt nttached I~er('lo
__s~ ~tf a fj~~;9q
~ Signatllreaf affillnt
_~____._ l~j___
'101MIAI 8fAt ...:
~'CCAR1~.llolltrH't!~rIC '
. IIrllbP~oM'(l en""'"t
l..~~j,.r.;rc
(") U) ~
~ u::>
~oo ::I: :y:l:n
:>
I{' -<
_.l ,:;~
6j~ I
W :..]
~., ':.;'(
:,.,-c .....' ;i!jJ
~0 ::r ',h~
Zc ,"'
7Pc! Of
~ 'j;!
-< C'\ ~
. ,
TIMBERLE A.P. CERO,
Plaintiff
v.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 99-2531
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
BARRY WAGNER and
DANIELLE WISE,
Defendants
k. ORDER
AND NOW, this " day of ~ ' 1999. It Is hereby ORDERED and DIRECTED that
Kelrsten W. Davidson, Esquire Is removed from the Panel of Arbitrators assigned to the above refsrenced
case. Lisa M. Coyne, Esquire shall be appointed to serve on the Arbitration Panel.
: 128943
F:t r:D-O::FiCE
cr 'I'~ '....,r"..":CJi/il1Y
59 flfC -7 iii 'I fl: 1,5
CUt,.;:;j::-'~/'I: '.!> CC'UJ\!TY
FENNSYL\i::\,~\)!.,\
. -
Till ,j ( (? LL:
fJ CO.?C )
fL/I,i .1/:( ('(' )
>.
)
)
)
)
A
'13/1 (c (<' '( I- 0''1/ G ,"I "'-Ie
.1//11/ (. L ~ Li:' t>i/,. ..1.<.'
Oc'o:j,I/J,i../in,
"r-
We do solemnly swear (or affirm)
the Constitution of the United States
wealth and that we will discharge the
In The Court of Cornmon Pleas of
Cumberland
:olo. qL(
County, Pennsylvania
--2 -.] <.; .I 19
-
/
OATH /.
that we~~~ sUPl'prt,. ~ObeY/and defend
and the f~ s~2iZ01l.A'f i--5 C01Dl!l0n-
duties 11l1~:; it';/; fidelity.
. '7 lhair:nan ,
.fJ(~i {.....{vi II /;(,.vrrryn"v/-.-1.-~
/;-:j~'r7h~ S'
AWARiJ'
We, the unde~sigued arbitrators, having been duly appointed and sworn
(or affirmed), make the following award:
(Note: If damages for delay a~e awa~~ed, they shall be
separately stated.)
hAJ,) /N ~A-1Ioa r,F bE FC-:'/'\,.I,")"n-/rs- /J-tV.'") .46AI/U":,
&c. "'''''''''1t.fllt-:
? ), ;7 ~ Chair:nan
L.'{i ~ /'\~[{,~.t'-d{A/t.. !!::7:..-J?'1'1'-h"-)/J.~l.-~'----
:4n,~~'!L/ (:1_ _
:-lOnCE OF ENTRY(~{WARD I
Now, the .I.(,,4l.eray of J':;;~"'-l ,l'9)()6r) aw:S-O, E.:l., the above
award was entered upon the docket and notice thereof given by mail to the
pa~~ias or their attorneys.
applicable,)
Dace of Rearing:'1/i ILl "2.t;
Date of Award: :]"/1 ,.~ ;Z ~
Arbitrators' compensation to be
paid upon appeal:
$ :?S'()-f) /"')
Pi.. hII\J7:1=',::
#4-
~("
ary
/ -
//'
~l W~8~- ~cL
n Ci
F~ '_::;J
r lJ'" -
r-'!i': "
;;~ i-::' ....
0..,
~?:' c ,
2:~
~ ':;':,,-' :~
}:-; E~~ ~:)
-<; 00-'-.
. -:i 01
-< (:J
-;:.
~
~
:.i.:
~
I..rS/1 mar'" '(" [,,>fl-i'
S$N' {"t/- {rb-e"l~Z
;? e/tl/~/z. I ?tIJ1/11 (?nr~~n ,;-r c
J:>.r YI.. .:U ~ J}. r!...-.'f' 11de, ~.17""