The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About99-02664 -.' .... various schedules of the taking of these depositions. The Court feels that the case could be tried in two days with four challenges to each side; Mr. Keller is unavailable for jury selection on Monday, March 13, 2000, but is otherwise available for trial that week. Defense counsel raises a question as to the applicability of Section 1797(a) of the Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law, and how it should be applied in this trial. It is the Court's initial feeling that the gross amount of medicals should be submitted to the jury and the jury verdict subsequently molded in accordance with the insurance law; however, defense counsel has an opportunity to furnish a brief to the Court to determine what, if any, the jury may have involvement in this determination by way of a jury interrogatory. The Court directs that that brief be filed with the Court within seven days of today's date and defense counsel shall have seven days to respond. Each counsel relates to the Court that they are satisfied with the authenticity of the medical records in existence, but not necessarily their admissibility, including photocopies. Plaintiff's counsel indicates that there will be a revised vocational report forthcoming, and the Court directs that that be given to defense counsel by the - - ~g ~ v) 3:;r >- (") A ~ 0; C": j:: \.J) j::;, we) ., 7' cl:, u:;:: - ::3 .- ~ -...5 G u:c~' "1~ ~F:' :;:: ~>= <0 'C) c:.. :::l ~ (0 ~J~ C5 ~J~:;"- _-r :~~f2 Q it I - C:' ' , ^ '"" . ~; >- ~":- L: f':' oC( >:,~lJJ -Cl .'- :;:: :,,~.' u. :If:- u (,) 0"\ -~ ~ '/.J C"> ::.J u Cl._ -6 o!... SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 1999-02664 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND FOOR SAMUEL P VS. MUSSER BENJAMIN R ETAL ROBERT L. FINK CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania, to law, says, the within WRIT OF upon MUSSER BENJAMIN R defendant, at 12:15 HOURS, on the 12th day of May 1999 at 477 MCCULLOCK ROAD SHIPPENSBURG, PA 17257 ,CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania, by handing to BENJAMIN R. MUSSER a true and attested copy of the WRIT OF SUMMONS and at the same time directing His attention to the contents thereof. , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of who being duly sworn according SUMMONS was served the Sheriff's Costs: Docketing Service Affidavit Surcharge 18.00 13.02 .00 eo 00 $019. u;; So answ~/~~ K. Cas r,llne, 7;;herlff METTE, EVANS & WOODSIDE 05/13/1999 J- /1 - by -:)?;/~y ;;hed~5- Sworn and subscribed to before me this /J1!3: day Of"-nt., 19 '?r; A.D. n ." r:. ~ .0'~ ~ ~ioLnonoLary' 11. This paragraph of the Complaint is a conclusion of law to which no response is required. 12. Admitted. 13. It is admitted that The bus operated by Defendant Musser made contact with the rear of the vehicle operated by Plaintiff. 14. Denied in accordance with Pa.R.C.p. 1029(e). 15. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is the belief of the Defenciants that Defendant Musser was cited only for the CDL violation and not for the other violations alleged. The Defendants note that the allegation contained in paragraph 15 of the Complaint, even though accurate with regard to the allegation of citation for violation of requirement for Commercial Driver's License, is irrelevant and immaterial, and the fact of the alleged citation is inadmissible in this action. 16. - 22. Denied in accordan.ce with Pa.R.C.p. l029(e). -. SAMUEL P. FOOR, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO. 99-2664 BENJAMIN R. MUSSER, FORRESTER FARMS and DANIEL FORRESTER, Defendants JURY TRIAL DEMANDED PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT'S NEW MATTER 23-24. The averments in these paragraphs are legal conclusions to which no answer is required. If it is deemed that an answer is required, each and every allegation is hereby specifically denied. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff's demand judgement in their favor and against the Defendant and that the Defendant's New Matter be dismissed with prejudice. Respectfully submitted, METTE, EVANS & WOODSIDE ---~ - BY: ~---- - ~ ANDREW H. DOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Conrt LD. #39692 3401 North Front Street P.O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 (717) 232-5000 Attorney for Plaintiffs DATED: September 7 , 1999 , . " ~", ~, '/. w ;, I',~' , ~:' ,-. -7~~\~7'-. , " '.." ~,-:I,,',',' . >::'; ': ." ,'" -". :'fl;.' ,;.. ,:' ".', :~:,~~I,i '~'.":'\,.\:~. " ':,;":, " .r': :_, .'\:.", 0' :(-,~",.;,. :-:\ ".!"':',~' '"'" :': f . ,~~t.-: ,~.., , .,' ~~-"~: ,','.' .~" /N-"1~:';;":'i.~...,1'~,~.H~L'\"f#~;:t"""~.''.C"..,~~!,.... ,l.",.. .~, r"" " ,. " '. ,.' ,. ", \ ",v,.. "''<~;''_~_ .~."_. ,. \ " _~_~ .: ," t. ..; .. >>> LOCATION LIST <<< PAGE: 1 RECORDS REQUESTED LOCATION NAME MEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL AND HOSPITAL BILL H:.DICAL & BILLING MEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL AND HOSPITAL BILL RICHARD W. FIDELER, M.D. CU}ffiERLAND VALLEY ORTHOPEDIC ROBINWOOD.ORTHOPEDIC SPEC. CENTRAL PA. SPINAL ASSOCIATES CUMBERLAND VALLEY NEURO. ASSOC CHAMBERS BURG HOSPITAL PHYSICAL THERAPY ASSOCIATES REHAB MEDICINE ASSOCS., P.C. NORLAND FAMILY PP~CTICE, PoCo DAVID BAKER, M.D. ORTHOPAEDIC ASSOCITES CUMBERLAND VALLEY FAM. PHY. MILTON S. HERSHEY MEDICAL CTR. D=:02-1 u2LlY 0 a 626 -.C 0), : ~', ' . I ' .' " :."1::'. .< ,: : -', ' ,'.' ~ .;,' , .~" f:"~~l~:,~.:'~-~':'':':\.,: ~"j<',:':~rr~'~ ~ ""~('J' :; '..',; ;~ :~' : "', ," ,,":1 '~~:'r' ';":,. .t ;:: ,', .:~~/:;;,_,' . \. :,' " '" ': ~, - EXPLANATION OF REQUIRED REG'ORDS .' TO: CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS FOR: CUMBERLAND VALLEY ORTHOPEDIC ASSN., INC. ] 20 NORTH SEVENTH ST CHAMBERSDlJRG.PA ]720] RE: 08626 SAMUEL 1'. FOOR INCLUDING CHARTS, REPORTS, TEST RESULTS, Any and all records, correspondence, files and memorandums, handwritten notes, billing and paymenl records, relating to any examination, consullation, care or treatment. Dates Requested: up to and including the present. Subject: SAMUEL P. FOOR 5024 WRIGHT ROAD, FAYEITEVILLE, PA 17222 Social Security #: 179-54-1498 Date of Birth: 06.12-74 >>> LOCATION LIST <<< RECORDS REQUESTED ~DICAL & BILLING ~DICAL & BILLING H::DICAL & BILLING H::DICAL & BILLING ~DICAL & BILLING ~DICAL AND HOSPITAL BILL ~DICAL & BILLING ~DICAL & BILLING ~DICAL & BILLING MEDICAL & BILLING ~DICAL & BILLING ~DICAL & BILLING MEDICAL AND HOSPITAL BILL PAGE: 1 LOCATION NAME RICHARD W. FIDELER, M.D. CUMBEP~AND VALLEY ORTHOPEDIC ROBINWOOD.ORTHOPEDIC SPEC. CENTRAL PA. SPINAL ASSOCIATES CUMBERLAND VALLEY NEURO. ASSOC CHAMBERS BURG HOSPITAL PHYSICAL THERAPY ASSOCIATES REHAB MEDICINE ASSOCS.. P.C. NOP~AND FAMILY P~~CTICE. PoCo DAVID BAl~R. M.D. ORTHOPAEDIC ASSOCITES CUMBERLAND VALLEY F AM. PHY. MILTON S. HERSHEY MEDICAL CTR. DE02-102219 08626-.COl , '1, " 'j " r ',-', "~I. ,...\,'.." .., :",'~-~: ~",,[\.,... ',,! ':'.,;', ",',t..:." \.:':Il:~-\.~~ "",':,.:;'Y :,1': :::_, ."1.'",., -.. r. ,l".,' '." '., ',~",\,'~' -I,I',~"'),., '~""'''' \"--'~'"'!i't"~":.,,,i'"N'!'~~/'\~'~_''''~!_'')o''''' ' l .\ ,'" , .' ""'" .,,..t...I/!.~"__.;J.~..., , '__L j , ", .J' ~ '" :' <nKHrI!!J.r.onr OIl' ~ 9Dll'r 01.' ~ SAMUEL P. FOOR Fi Ie No. II 99-2664 VS. BENJAMIN R. MUSSER, FORRESTER FARMS AND DANIEL FORRESTER SI.J6POEI.a TO Plllno: ~ ~~~~ FOR DI~ ~$UAHT TO E 2 CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS FOR: ROB INWOOD ORTHOPEDIC SPECIALISTS TO: (N.". of Person or Entity) . i Within l:Minty (20) daya after service of this '"'IbllCltllIll, vcu Ir"O Ol de. ed by the o:xrt t ~ the fOllowing doc::unents or things: SEE ATTACHED _t !HE MCS GROUP, INC., 1601 MARKET STREET STEU 800 PHIL (Ader-... ) iU 'feu msy deliver or msil leaible copi_ of the docunents or Pl"ocb:e things r~ested i this $llb~)Gn&, togethr with the ca-tifiC*te of CXJl1)lianee, to the PIll"ty making th' r~t at the adci-l':Sa 1 iated lIbave. You have the right to S8IIk in advlll"lCe the NIaSOnab' cost of Pl"'~ing the ecpies or Pl"'OCiJc:ing the things sought. I f YOU fai I to Pl"OC1Jce the doc:u!wlts cr thir,ga ~ired by thia ...~08l III within t--. (20} days after its service, the PlU"ty serv,ing thia '"'Opoena Il'llY sMlt a o:u-t ero c:al1)e 111r:9 you to CXI'/l) ly with it. . 'TliIS SUSPC:iEHA WAS 1SSla) AT 1lt! REa.1EST OF ~ FCUafrN3 ~: NAME: JOHN KELLER, ESQUIRE AOORESS:I00 WALNUT STREET WAYNESBORO,PA. 17268 TELEPH:llE : SlFR91: cx:urr "T1alIEY FOR: (215) 246-0900 10 " THE DEFENDANT DATE: ,/ t ~fi 'I ~wt. /.1 /'?'';'7 s.a I of the 0:x.r1: BY llE <XUrr: /H a-1~ r ~w,- Prothonot:ary/Clcrit, Civil Diviaion 'F;:.p(:~1/? k >>/t. /70:: y Deputy . " " \, ":, ":' ", :....\ ," ';:',',1,"",': ':~:,":' I:,' ':,':'\ ,: ", ,':,<~::,,~"':, ,.!:,;,,:'1,:'I.',,~ '.',:I'&,,~, ~',':,.,' " , ',' " ',l ," , . " I" J.;."jb:"'''''Il~';'~ ""'."J\l~~":1fl'r."'~' ""1'\ ,~. " , :'l ':. ," ., l" o ""," '..,' ", I'. ..'"..r." ,',' " ,....':...'_,,' ;~",~"J ")..J h ',~., "' "" , .., ~ I,' I " H ,\' ',-' , " . '., ~or~ CXll181Y or ~ SA.'lUEL P. FOOR File No. # 99-2664 VS. BENJAMIN R. MUSSER, FORRESTER FARMS AND DANIEL FORRESTER Sl.8PCEI.l TO PROOla: ~ ~i~!Q'i FOR DI~ FUl':'MNTTO RciE ~ TO: CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS FOR: CENTRAL PENNSYLVANIA SPINAL ASSOCIATES (NIInIJ of Prson or Ent i ty) Within twwaty (20) daya .ftr sllr"Vi~ 0' this ,.,"'~ ~ 11II Wi, you ".. 01 do. ed by the oocrt ~ the following docuntnta or things: SEE ATTACHED ~t JHE MCS GROUP, INC., 1601 MARKET STREET STE# 800 PHILADELP (Adcreu ) :liU 'feu ll1llY delivr or ll1lil legible c:cpi. of the doc:unent.s or PI"oQ.Ice things r~ested this s\Jbc:lQena. l:09ethr with the certificate of <:a!l)1fanc:e. to the party making th r~t at the adci-l':S. I fated lIbove. You have the right to :saek in 8dY1nea the I'8UClNIb <=Qat of pr'~ing the c:cpies or rrociJeing the thinga sought. If yeu fai I to Pl"OdJee tho doo..ments or things r~;,.ecI by this ...~ wit.'li" tw=. (20) days aftr its ~ie:, the pV"ty Sflr"Y.fng this 'J'iCpoena ny sNk a cart: 1:1' o::l'Il)G I ling you to cal1) Iy with it. ' 'lliIS SUlPCIeu. WAS 1SS1.eD AT nt! PS:IiEST a: 'TlE F<:U.artIlO ~: NAME: JOHN KELLER, ESOUIRE AOORESS:JOO WALNUT STREET W~YNESBORO.PA. 17268 1"EL.EPHC>>E: (2] 'i) 246-0900 S1..JlRaoE cn.RT 10 . 4~ ~: TH1=' nl-~FE\'nANT BY THE o::urr: /5/ 04TE: ,,/ J/. '/1 ("o"")/.r>.?r, /? /~"'/'!' s...: I 0 f tho Cl:u-t (/ . Civil Divi.ion r ,.y;~, CI- '" Oecluty ~, >>> LOCATION LIST <<< ?~CORDS ?~QUESTED XEDICAL & BILLING XEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL & BILLING !SDICAL & BILLING ISDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL .~D HOSPITAL BILL MEDICAL & BILLING HEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL & BILLING MEDICAL AND HOSPITAL BILL , v " PAGE: 1 LOCATION NAME RICHARD W. FIDELER, M.D. CUMBERLAND VALLEY ORTHOPEDIC ROBINWOOD.ORTHOPEDIC SPEC. CENTRAL PA. SPINAL ASSOCIATES CUMBERLAND VALLEY NEURO. ASSOC CHAMBERS BURG HOSPITAL PHYSICAL THERAPY ASSOCIATES REHAB MEDICINE ASSOCS., P.C. NORLAND FAMILY PRACTICE. PoCo DAVID BAKER, M.D. ORTHOPAEDIC ASSOCITES CUMBERLAND VALLEY FAM. PRY. MILTON S. HERSHEY MEDICAL CTR. DE02-102219 OB626-.COJ. ",,' ',~' ,,":\ '::~ :':' " :':(,,,::,,:,,'~'=::..i~~:::,;'.:::,'i:..\,,;.':g;::~~,<;,:,:: ::, :',,~:.-,;;; ',:, , ,':<",,,': :: ,,: :,", .,'" ,:' ',;: : ',",,, , I ' . ' ... .' \1, ..~ ~OI/f~ o ClXJN1Y OP ~ SAMUEL P. FOOR VS. File No. # 99-2664 BENJAMIN R. MUSSER, FORRESTER FARMS AND DANIEL FORRESTER TO: CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS FOR: REHAB. MEDICINE ASSOCIATES, P.C. SUlPCea TO PRMla:: ~ OR ~'~ F~ Ol~ ~c:':l).A;n: TO iM'E~ .22 (NImI of Person Of" Entft\r') Within twenty (20) daYI after sorvice of this ~, you r. orda, 6d by the cart to Pt'OClIee the following c:b::utwIts or things: SEE ATTACHED THE MCS GROUP, INC., 1601 MARKET STREET STEI 800 PHILADELP lot (Adc:rass ) 'fou rray deliver Of" mail legible copies of the cbc:unents Of" Pf'OCiJc:o thfngs requested b this sl.lboo<<\a, togother wfth the certfficate of CCIl1)1fance, to the prty making thl: request at the acldrt:Ss I fsted above. You have the right to seeK in 8dvtlnCe the re&sonabl, cost of prepv' i ng the cop f es 01' Pl"OaJeing the th fngs sought. ' If you fail to ~ the doc:unents cr thf~ r~ired by this ...~ within boent (20; days after its service, tho party serv,in; this "~'" II'IlY soak a cart Of"de c:arpe II ir:g you to COlt) Iy with it. TH I S Sl..ePCE:N.\ WAS I SSl.eD AT 'Ilt! Pe:J ll;ST a= 'Ilt! Fa./.Qfl N3 ~: NAME: JOHN KELLER, ESQUIRE ADCiRESS: 100 j,ALNUT STREET ~AYNESBORO,PA. 17268 l"El.EPtOE : Sl.PREJoE cn.RT 10 . A~ FOR: THE DEFEND~~T (215) 246-0900 DATE: ":5(,,..:1. /.3 /<;'~7" Sea I of the O::u-t BY llE <X:Urr: /.~I t4-1L; ~ ~",-," 'Prothonot.-y/Clri, Civil Diviaicn '-/8"" ;..," ..f-: A,;/~, fih;.? ;/ ~ 1/ ", \.' > .' ':" .,":' ~t': "':-,,',,'1:'1. ,.,' , .::, ,l:,~'~~';~-:~;~:";':{< I,,,",' ::~'::;':'I ~'~~~'~''':/:'', ",;<;. ,,~~',: ;~",~ ) I~\' :':" "~ ,'.. .,:' ~,~' ',.':' ',./,~,;:, ,\,..'~ .'" ' ' ,:. ": . , , ',. ' , EXPLANATION OF REQUIRED RECORDS TO: CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS FOR: NORLAND FAMILY PRI\c.."TICE, P.c. 3000 PHILADELPHIA AVE CHAM13ERS13URG, PA 17201 RE: 08626 SAMUEL 1'. FOOR INCLUDING CHARTS, REPORTS, AND TEST RESULTS, Any and all records, correspondence, files and memorandums, handwrillen notes, billing and payment records, relating to :lOy examination, consultation, care or treatment. Dales Requesled: up 10 and including Ihe presenl. SubJect: SAMUEL P. FOOR 5024 WRIGHT ROAD, FA YEITEVILLE, PA 17222 Social Secul'ity #: 179.54.1498 Date of Birth: 06.12.74 SUlO-211062 OB626-L09 :,,' :' '\" ,:,-.:,",,' :'" "c'::;.:..,~~::,:::}~;:,::,:~::~i::!':'~",~o!';:;::;;;~(:'~'/'"':,; ',:' :',: /:' i" :',~,:~ ''-;'' '; ":',: ;1': ,':", c',',,:' ,;,;" "'" :',' " , ' CERTIFICATE PREREQUISITE TO SERVICE OF A SUBPOENA PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.22 IN THE MATTER OF: COURT OF COMMON PLEAS SAMUEL P. FOOR TERM, 0000 -VS- CASE NO: 99-2664 BENJAMIN R. MUSSER. ET AL As a prerequisite to service of a subpoena for documents and things pursuant to Rule 4009.22 MCS on behalf of JOHN N. KELLER, ESQUIRE defendant certifies that (I) A notice of intent to serve the subpoena with a copy of the subpoena attached thereto was mailed or delivered to each party at least twenty days prior to the date on which the subpoena is sought to be served I (2) A copy of the notice of intent, including the proposed subpoena, is attached to the certificate, (3) No objection to the subpoena has been received, and (4) The subpoena which will be served is identical to the subpoena which is attached to the notice of intent to serve the subpoena. DATE: 10/06/99 JOHN N. KELLER. ESQUIRE Attorney for DEFENDANT DElJ-13I,28l 08626 -L10 , -, .' , : f ~OP~ <lXlNlY OP ~ I' ," SA.'1UEL P. FOOR VS. File No. # 99-2664 BENJAMIN R. MUSSER, FORRESTER FAP~S AND DANIEL FORRESTER SUlPCeHA TO PROa.ao [XX] t'EHTS ~ TH IIGS FOR 01!:i'r'M:Dv ptp~lANT TO flU.F. 4009.22 CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS FOR: TO: THE MILTON S. HERSHEY MEDICAL CENTER (Nsne of Prson Of" Entity) Within twmty (20) claya .ftr service of this "'~oetl4, YOU ... ordos. ad by the 0Cllrt Pt'Oduce the following doc:unt.nts or things: SEE ATTACHED Llll:. NLl:> liKUUl', iNt;.. ibUl /'lAM):;!' S'iK):;):;!, S!'):;11 !lOO PHiLADELPHiA,PA. i9103 lit _ (Adcreu) 'fou may delivr or mail legibhl COpies of the doeunents or Pt'OCtIce things rl!lQUestod this subooena. together- with the certificate of c::aTglianee. to the prty making thi request at the addrt:Sa 1 isted above. You have the right to seek in IIdvItlCS the r8UOnlbl cost of preparing the c:opies Of" P/"OdJeing the things soc.dlt. I f you fail to Pl"OCb:e ths cb<:unents or things re::;.:tr=d by tMs ...~ within twent (20} clays Ilftr its service, the party se/"v.ing this sl.tlpoer.. ny seek a o::xrt Ql' C01lJG 11 ;r:g you to c::aTg ly with it. ' 'THIS Sl..aPCEN4 WAS ISSleD AT '1lE ~ST Cf' 'TlE FOt..1.GWIN3 ~: JOHN KELLER, ESQUIRE 1W1E: 100 WALNUT STREET ACORESS : WAYNESBORO.PA. 17268 (215) 246-0900 TaEPH:NE: SlPReE o:urr ATTCREY FOR: 10. THE DEFENDANT CATE: '" <;..., ,/ . / 1 /f;;-//;:' Sea? of the o:u-t BY lliE CXJ..m': /;r Cr~X,-:; K M1{" . Prothonot.rv/Clri, Civil Division /7 /-". .k~ ,.[")? (~;/t/..<:;' /C, _ ==::. .7 .. '~,"<: >' ,; "'\ ~', I",: \,',:, ' ~ :/:'" , .:~"./,: X.:.~:~~:'j'\'~;\Y;:::!,\'; :(:,(:, ,~,'~~";' )" .': ~L:l:''''~:~: " ' ': ..: {.'. I' :; " :~, .": '''',> ,: ,~,' . I' "i :".";' ",;. '. -.. ',;:-,1_._,_ Word:\roxanne\misc\erie_forrester.pra IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA Samuel P. Foor, Plaintiff . . vs. . . No. 99-2664 Benjamin R. Musser, Forrester Farms and Daniel Forrester, Defendants : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED PRAECIPE TO FILE DISCOVERY MATERIAL PURSUANT TO PA. R.C.P. 40~ TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Please file the attached "Plaintiff's Answers to Defendant's Interrogatories Directed to the Plaintiff" and true copy of "Defendant's Answers to Interrogatories". KELLER, KELLER AND FREY 1 By elle a. upreme Court I.D. #25577 00 Walnut Street Waynesboro, PA 17268 (717) 762-3331 Attorneys for Defendants : ( "'; : "~. :~' ~, :,' :;,:' ; /. >, ' ;,'" , :,'.'~' '. ~:" '"I. . ~:.,,:~ .~ :':"~"/' :::~~~"'_,:;~ '.~" ,~1::,~ ;:~'..~:..::.1.J: "~~~ :,~.I:, ,~:'::;.;" ~f, ", <: ,~':.;" < ",,' \ ';- ~ ",',: \ .<, ,; , ' <", 't' _"', : .' ':,' d , ,. , " >. 3. With regard to each expert witness identified by you in response to the preceding interrogatory, state the substance cf the facts and opinions to which the expert is expected to testify and .......'11 .- . .... " I I a summary of the grounds for each opinion. See Answer to No 2, supra. 4. '. . :'., >'"C', ,.:'.'.",<:" :" ,,',',.t....,:'::~:,~,',.: .'i"::'\:.~.:;<:<: "'::,;~~).">",:';.>.' ':';, ~,,: : ,,~'./, .', '..' -:'..'.'. ',::,,',(., ,.,' "".: . ,~ ' ~ , ' " 4. Set forth the name and address of each provider of health care services, including but not limited to hospitals, imaging facilities, pain clinics, physicians, chiropractors, and physical therapists, which or who has rendered care and/or examination services to you as the result of injuries which you contend resulted from the accident in question in this case. See Plaintiff's Demand package dated February 16, 1999. a. With regard to each provider identified by you, set forth the date of each instance of care and/or examination service rendered, a brief description of the service rendered and the charge for each such service. See Plaintiff's Dcmand package datcd l{:'.bruary 16, 1999. '. ,". ',' '<, "'>:~; . .:.: .::, ': .':.>~./.,~::.,':,:..,,:;.:i~'~:~~''''~''':' ,;);', ~. :..','.:::: ':;':':".<;.,.":': :;,. '(; "" .,.'.'... . "':.~: " " I..", . '.' b. With regard to each charge for health care services which you contend were rendered for examination and/or treatment of injuries sustained in the accident in question in this case, set forth the amount which has been paid, the name and address of the entity who has made payment and any amount which continues to be claimed by the health care provider. See Plaintiff's Demand package dated February 16, 1999. 6. ,~' ',: : ',~' " ','., ~\ i.~;,.' ./; " ' ..:-" "I'~' ,,', ,",," , \~I"" ~~.t::~I'''::III:::~' )f~,~,~~.~,+...~t. ..:.,;;'~~;':.: _.::." ,', '~,::\"I ,',~ ,:,i :~: ,~:.:.<:.. (' ',':, ,,{_ll'" ;', ':\ I'~ ' ,': . " ',' ' 5. With regard to your claim for Workers' Compensation arising '. from an alleged work related injury on or about September 3, 1995, identify all dates through the present for which you have received Workers' Compensation, and set forth the name and address of each health care provider who or which has been paid pursuant to your Workers' Compensation claim for health care services rendered to you. See separate package included with Plaintiff's Demand package dated February 16, 1999. See also correspondence dated April 27, 1999 addressed to Douglas H. Reinhardt, Claims Adjuster, Erie Insurance Group and attachments thereto. 7. " :' ',',:, \' ,,~~~., ".: . ',;; ,"" "t ;. ',',:,~~' ")':':~~'f,'~~')';."~" ~;...': 'c:"::..'..:";~~':"'l::~: :','~ ,~. I : .<:t ': -,' ',/ ':' " ,:-,',',"';'~'. :::.,,: I'"~ ',; \.; ~:,' >, 1 ~',' "'.:,1,::: < '~.' CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, John N. Keller, Esquire, attorney for Defendants, certify that I served the foregoing Defendants' Interrogatories upon the following person at the following address, by depositing same in the United States mail, First Class postage prepaid: Andrew H. Dowling, Esquire MET1~, EVANS & WOODSIDE 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 Date: ~/g/71' KELLER, KELLER AND FREY h By ~ N. KeXler Supreme Ct. I.D. #25577 100 Walnut Street Waynesboro, PA 17268 (717) 762-3331 Attorneys for Defendants 12. 6, Statclllcnts If you know ofanyonc that has given .my statcmcnt (as dclincd hy thc Rulcs of Civill'roccdurc) conccrning this action or its subjcctmallcr, statc: (a) Thc idcntity of such pcrson; (1.1) Whcn, whcre, by whom, and to whom cach statclllcnt was madc, alllt whcthcr it was reduced 10 wriling or othcrwisc rccordcd; and (c) Thc idcntity of any pcrson who has custody of any such statcmcntthat was reduced to writing or othcrwisc rccordcd. See transcripts and summaries of recorded statements which are being produced. \ II \ 8, l.iccnsurc If you wcrc rcquircd hy luw or rcgulalionto hc liccnscd fi,l' thc activity in which you wcrc cngagcd ullhc limc of lhc incidcut, statc: (a) Thc typc of Iiccnsc rcquircd; (h) Thc ualc you lirsl ohlaincd such u liccnsc; (c) Thc dalcs of issuuncc :Ind cxpiraliou of your currcntliccnsc(s); (d) Thc idcnlily oflhe authorily Ihal issucd your liccnsc(s); (e) The numbcr of your Iiccnse(s); (I) The nulurc and dural ion of any revocation or suspcnsion of your liccnsc(s); 1.' (g) Thc spcciul rcslricliuns, if any, imposcu on yonI' liccnsc. Ben; amin..1L Musser (a-b) The defendant has been advised that he was required to have a commercial driver's license. He did not have one at the time of the accident. (c-g) license No. his license The defendant has current Pennsylvania operator's 17092851. lie has had no revocations or suspension of and there are no special restrictions imposed. , " - '-~ "-:"''--~~~.--._",' 12. Trial witncsscs lucntify cach pcrson YOll intcnd to call as a non-expcrt witncss allhe trial oflhis easc, anu for cach pcrson idcnlilicd slatc your rc.lalionship wilh lhe witncss amI the slIhslance of the facls 10 which lhc wilncss is cxpccted to lcslify. Aside from the defendants themselves, no decision has been made about non-expert witnesses who will be called to testify at trial. Objection to the request for statement of the substance of facts to which non-expert witnesses are expected to testify as defense evidence will necessarily, at least in part, be dependent upon evidence offered by the plaintiff and, furthermore, such request exce'Tds the scope of permissible discovery and, in effect, seeks to e~i~it the defendants' script for trial. 17. Substance inllminnent If yo II consumed any nlcnllolic heverage, sedative, lnll1<luili7.cr, 11Iarijuanl1, cocaillc, hashish, or olhcr drug, mcdicinc or pill <.luring the cight hours immediately prcceding thc inci<.lcnl, slalc: (a) The nature, amount, nmllypc of item consumcd; (b) The amo\lnt of limc over which eonsumcd; (c) Thc idcntity of any ami all persllIls who have any knowledge as to the consumption orthose items; and (d) The identity of the physician or mcdical practitioner or olher person who gave, purchased or prcscribed any of said items, if any. , I' n/a 20. Motor vchiclc damagc With rcspcct 10 any vchidc you owncd that was involvcd inthc incidcnt, state: (a) Thc natnrc of any damagc cxisting prior to thc inddcnt; (h) Thc idcntity uf any pcrsun who (lcrlilrlllcd rcpairs to thc vchiclc Iilllowing thc incidcnt; (c) Thc total amount of the repair bill(s), ur ifnut yct rcpaircd, the total estimated cost of repairing thl~ vchiclc or thc cstinlated valuc oflhc damages to the vehicle (include thc idcntity of thc pcrson lilrnishing any such estimatc); (d) Thc datc and plac'~ of the last state inspcction prior to thc incidcnt and identify thc person making said inspcction; and I I (c) fhc naturc of any defcct in or problcm with the vchiclc and thc lcngth of timc such dcfcct or problcm cxistcd. .' Daniel Forrester (a) None. (b,c) Not applicable. (d) This information is heing sought. The inspection for the bus was current. (e) None known. ~ , '. I veri fy that the facts set fOl:th i.n the foregoing document are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. Section 4904, relati.ng to unsworn falsification to authorities. Date: 9- :3 -5'9 , .~ '- /1;<1 /~~-v1~.' ~ ,...<"'t' Benja~in R. Musser II' , ,- lot) ~h (1: '-- ..:--.,: , j'.-::.. ~'.'- (....., ,.~ " ~: , f~'?F: . i , , . , '1.:(' r..:... . " J 9<.:- ,- C"'J C' I 'J '. L: , r ',' :,.;H~ I"';"') r::' C; u. r, - , U C"l ,. .. .. ,>,' ,.' ,'.'," :~'.. ':1; . '\, :~:;: : "::>:'-\'\ ~,': '-:.: ",!,,: :>";:1>::,;:: ': :,:. \:i': "";\:;~"~': ~'\,:~}~,:.:, ',~.:i I 1,>::;~, ":~":.'i" ~ ":. ',::,~;. ",~',,:(:_',':':"~::>: ~,:~,',; V,,: '.: <~', ,",," '1,' :' " 'I: ,,:' " ", ,i ',", .w Word:\roxanne\misc\erie_forrester.mot IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA Samuel P. Foor, Plaintiff vs. . . No. 99-2664 Benjamin R. Musser, Forrester Farms and Daniel Forrester, Defendants . . . . JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ORDER OF COURT , 1999, upon consideration of the motion for summary judgment of Defendants Forrester Farms and Daniel Forrester, it is hereby ordered that the said motion is granted, judgment is entered in favor of Defendants Forrester Farms and Daniel Forrester, and the said Defendants are dismissed from this action. By the Court, J. " , IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA Samuel P. Foor, Plaintiff vs. No. 99-2664 Benjamin R. Musser, Forrester Farms and Daniel Forrester, Defendants : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED MOTION OF DEFENDANTS FORRESTER F~S AND DANIEL FORRESTER FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT NOW come Defendants Forrester Farms and Daniel Forrester and, pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of civil Procedure 1035.1 et seg, move Your Honorable Court for entry of summary judgment in their favor dismissing them from this case for the following reasons: 1. This case arises from a motor vehicle collision which occurred on June 4, 1997, when a car operated by the Plaintiff was struck by a bus driven by Defendant Benjamin R. Musser. 2. The said bus was owned and registered by Defendant Forrester Farms, the trade name of the farming business operated by Defendant Daniel Forrester as a sole proprietorship. OOOO~OG...cJ~ n,' If;!",.. ;f..."'''.J' COMMONWEAl.. TH OF PENNSYLVANIA POUCE ACCIDENT REPORT RfPORIAlIU: IlOH."!POA'....[~ I PCUCEINFORMATION ACCIDENT LOCATION ';r 'I",~~::'.'::.:~ , 1O COlHTY A .-,~-I13:.'U~Zt. . . 2 ~_ t.\~~ (0 ., .. .~""""~_.. ... d.~l'~ 1.......11Cf'/UTY ""-'UI: I S:-=, _ at~.;;_j'.~~IlOL 'Z'i PR,~ptt~OA~AY iNFORMAfj~~- - ~. M.e.,,,,,,,,, _. :" 1<>11 :=~ '~~'~I~~~='_~~ ~OA;h-.~--V:':N.-~:.,f". Lom .4$_!~N~~'T~Nd RO~6'r~ .~ :~~~ -. ACClDEHT INFORMATION 26 :~~:,~R .oa::UH1 I I'll '.,DAY WUK " SPE'O -r..'jlYl'E" m '@i:)Iii:a..---'-. -!!tTE (,. Lj '-'U'I Wl2:wp;.M-\ ,..~ r," ,!~AY, _I ':'_~, _ I "'DA"': 01 Z I 1.0 I '2=~ 3 'F NOT A TlNTcRScCTlON: 1,:(.tc1..im t..tUURf.D .. '-its. PAN. PROP' " ~ 30 CROSSS1RE.ETOR ".. ...--. -. . _. "---pp-.. _ .. 0 /, ACClDEKT Y~..J'!__ SlGlA["'MNlI<[R.J',AW_""," ,",..e-I"', ~. . _....__.. I 'I. DOVViCUKAVEYOBf !11VEHlClE~[ 3t.OUU:CTIOH ~l>>.OLSU.NCE ,,, REaQVEO fRO" THE SCENE~ O. NONE UHII 't FROY SIlE N S _g~ _ _ t~.~.~~, .pfl ~ !~ ,WI. I IHT' IHT 2 '1 .,1G1I1 " DISTANCE WAS I -I - M IV :f.UOO(AAIE lIf.ASl.RED -_ UfNf.lfD t V I J H V" Y ~ N I ,3'SEVE_W-: UtllT2. z...: )4 CIOO!~~lHUCTK)'" (:J.5.) TfWftC f,'R.~!AL I "L I ^ I - CONIROL I j II HAZAROOus ' .'; u l\I. i'i, PlNNlJO r I'. \r1 .... 2- ""ERlALS vL ~!.W~_ __ ; .... DEVCE ... :.;~;''';'' UNIU1' UNlTt2". ..UUAUY Y H 17,fU:G 'JI stAl[ )6 l[Go\llY Y H 31,RfO, ,''!'''EO' UL.;,-, flAIE "13~l:i9'i I I'A 'ARKCD" 'IU, ".ATE, ~D8'l", ..'''TmlM 1$BQ 3g f'''IlIL[OR Z""""\'- ~ IU'l'.,), "'n,[ H~ ~ '-'1 Z. ,U\.I 0 I r40:c::MNER f":'""1., "'" -~ .0 OWNER ~ " , , , ~ ~~ ~Tl>~a. PLoAG~.. I 41:()MoER .1 OMi[Ft /i._"!""'ESS ..lCO r:q..; . Wl.4 I2.D _SS 10 ~tT' c, Q. CtTY, sun n eny, sr.lE r ._',~ ,_S\AIi'f'f~ I PII nz., &llPCDD< ~ANlaCJ4a....U; PA, n.~J,_ '_' , .. ,..... '14 .:.. ..... M:> tp " Y[AH I..,..... ... UOOEl . (l<<lT '.. ... >! '''''OD<, ~~,' ~ ./.....' ~. . -- 1-.,~:-,!YPl). f(oMjii~l..,t r;..-',';HICI,H "'z.t4~ -"',ooOOo"yYlWE) ~..~ ~~Y_..'h'~O ~~";'I. tm=.AJ\" oSPtcw. I" ".. - r' p$P(.cw. 0 U.,VOUC&.f ..., I . T'I'f"l ~ 'USAGE 0 OWH[RSUP _ ~ 1VPE ~ USACt - O'M'IRSiP &". ~NTW.-"..a' -~-1~',y[HCl[ (:'1,lItAVEl r- ~,lNlllA.1. IUP.lCl ~1~!VEHr:::lE""- i:jnu.-rLL--'--. . . 1'0" IZ- $lATUS 0 S'UD Z... . .''0'''1 If>' S1MUS 0 . 6PELO " ::~f\'ll"" [lfOOMR r'D,llAMR I ss ,VElIlClI I ,llIiMR H!OONfR'-'.-',-. - - CA.A1 '1/1 I 'PRESCNCE COHQrtlCt4 ORAOIfNI PRfSHCE .. COhOllOH I ".OR....;P ~, SIAlf ~ DRN'(R ~r.'JAlE " .~.""". 11o<tt-e,51 I=A """"'" ~"'''.I;~ " __, __ _,. N,OIWEIl '" llIlMR s; t "NAIJ!. ~^"'I"" ilII-I MiU5a. NAM' ~~UEl.. .~,t...fD::t..___.__ " llf\IvTR " ORMH I I . AlXR!H~'ll MumcU:. e{) AOOflUl 41{~~,~..-...I) <;:c_ _,,_ _. 10 CITY. saT[ 60 Cny, SlAt[ U..=O<1, . $'~I'!r:..So.l!G. fA Illl'COOC CHA",~j1...~, "II .I!!:~__ "~9- Q.04TEO/- 11 S( (;10"'Eor In.1iti:Jti.; BIRTH 8~lH (, I '1 .. ~ VlH 6.$ CRMH , M COloW ':fl.' .(.) OOMR , 't' f1I; aoUS "'"' "N ClASS I" E:A" (;1 C"HRII - , fU.w:,n;r... 0, tM~ ! II CARRIER , .,~ Ie:> r<)f< j('~~ IU> I...em', su.rr :. &.lIPCOCX S'lo(lI'(...,..~u.-..L"- ~ p,-. I "7:,~"7 : TO ti:.Doi. :cc , ~.A:: " z.k>o<C " "0", i#'l~. fU'CAroRCO . cor:_:. I p?Ol'lYP!. I ~ r~ NO Of . ~ 3 yr, KU AROOUS I AJCl.ts ; ......t[AiAl.6. 00 M..u("~1 ~\I< ~ I Ai )AUfA TO O\UCUY IHEET& ._....J~~.:: P'lNClO1 UII. DN.Y WI C.vtRI( lot ALlOf'"tlss. (,\1 en... ~1"" '-U"COUl 'OU~l' ice. 1.1 r3't:.A.H.CO I f;ourl'rt'l I:'i'\/w AROOUl. . ""llRW$ O. f"l..A:,. . ~~ " G\'V.~ 17,oVI "~lll""~( OrJl~t.U,J . fJ lllAJ llf.kn .J'1-Vlft COI"'I'';' 1:1 NO 01 ,.....H!. 14 CVWf\ 2349251 ra.c.[ U.hlH.AW.of fWWAl Y l.1 ~ q lHll.J I "......00'. e"$1[ OoomJ08 ; ",,,!~-~,~""'!.-,~~~ &MS - , !t:lC!~i:l-!T,~: .'l.\.1-=,'~'3~,'l1,.1~~' : to """"'" 'ACUTV r .. ACCIDENT OA TE: r': r~ Te ;_P."_~ ~ -,-Q-!-~-, , .. ADOOf.. . H " 1'" RK'f.l . ,.... . l.q..lj'~,J~I"~ _e~o~_m>&-.I ',C p ,~- .~ -~r~- I.J+~IJrl~rC:> ,Cj'!O/A1r.6.\o.j~ "7~'\ 1'l,""",""~I..Il'~I'AI'~"1 ,O,,!, .. '''' _'j__ : -q-~ . f I!)..j ~ -ql <>.,lot't ,"II'iMI1Lfll. ~ ....~"I ~l"" to !"~_.9t\. ..~ '~~_'I' ~_ ~~ _r?... ~+~t:-~":-;:l':l~~I'l<Jln:;-~.a<;~ .1!t'l'l ~laD,Co s""~~'~'_ : ':'I'-~ ~ I~i-~~ IT'] ;'..jll i~. ~'O'''"fAlM (""':'," - h~'WOU'N) Lu S>H11l'liItl;~_,____, -.-: '0- 0-' -, -0-1-:' "I. .. CLt') M,:'\.....IIIL- . _ ill~u~,1OH i3'~~.'!.2j MATHER/"a.. j 10. ~u r^,w~..t"I".~ to )-.M ~ ~ ~tlllol(,. klr" I .'r; ~"''''''lla,h'1,," ~ ....... ~ !"~JOO.wawACE: I I , 1._.._' F~~nvAl4~scitooi- OlSTRCT-- IF AI'PlI::IaE) ....-orsawli}J~ OAMAGfDPAOIUIY f i'~OuE tA:X'ilf~'''' I '/ ---l <> ; ,. ~ T"'If+ J.....'" I "4 <> I -..., "-illl .wrr..7lt9wR I \...tCJ!n GtoUto.(..,.- T. 'ntll~.. . NoT~rt." E . elP. NAAAATM .IOEHUFY PRiClPrrATINO EVENT', C"'USATION FACTORS, SECUENCE Of EVEN'll. WITHE" STATUlIEHTB. AND PROVIDE ADOItow. .-!!!.A!~,UQ: ~_E_IHt~!~ AHDlOCATlOfot OFTO'h't:D VEHICLES, U:KN9~,.. ... _.....~.__. _, .._......___..~_" S'~ '2b ~. L0 , tv,.r.,&.c.\r" M"'If'_I- t..(f1,,~p...=toff'" .,. '.'''' r "...,r.. t.:, , """ref' '''''''... " ....-"...., r"""'''J ... """" Lot hr..AnE.~ ""I....."rl) AS~.a::~...L_.w~_...]1;!~~LA..tC6t:.__t... rut! 1..fTa"'~o.u'\ l~~ c::J' c..u. .. A .. Ol_AJ': ~-~'f y.l<....c_~JI<c .~am: A...."'- s.......;oc. 0... ",,_ A...u..t 'IILto.lL A..t")) ^\ ~rr.._~__i\fr"""" AO)..ruC._~.ooWll="J tJII# ~ I u,t (lUU~ .~ ~ MT"E....x- l1>_'}!!ef._~I~,I!ClllC...c,._.?<<~~S~ Ii> I....n> ~ ,1.1""- ~.t4"'U'C....!'.L-::-._~I."k. """,,&r:~.l--_.J'I.:L..")"~U14 ~n ItIlfW: "3~....Mj1"':.~-1_ CA,.." _ ilL. a.e~ ^L..M""~f. .l~m1!.t"'L1" AFrp.. I.... "....,T', (.0.1. rr~,- "'Hr" [)~t'CL."'I' AE1n~. S'~.D.I~"-:'\&.'"j",..rL..~~_~' DL4w.., IIlI'Tb , ....... , ;...", :n~(" 1_., --I "",' '"- UNrl ) " ''HOb,lA L .. UM" ol~ ~~~~~_ W~~,:~~~~=',"__' =t ,..".....C, . CO",PANY ----~~-- -,- - -, ...., ,Ma~.u= CO""ANY . _-j lNFlJAIlIATIONI.. e:t-tC f"""....LA",,....(: o.',..Aut.E: ,INrORIr,(A1l0~. S'T~rc rooo\--tM r."'~ r~t..n~o ; UNIT r POLICY. UNIT POliCY "0 ND C;'1c,,"l1'1 :;~c:. 'Jy,~ A ~~ pt1;J~ NCo'..c: N.U.4E AUDH[!>~ PUONE, I'. N ~ ~1.C;l.(Jt4NlJtAU[RSION~Ylf CHAHCflll ~ .1 '1': I till I Ii.:' : :i; I i1 PHOb"'~ll 1/1 TYrol jiJ .FclSUlTS. ~t~1U'IWtlJ\<ESTICA11ON I' U~I TlST ; I nHu:.[ CO"'Jll[T[ , o 0 0___'1,.; ""KI'l~ DcfNO(.:i: ~DC'.. OllSTf ll> M"u:...,Ail",{;. .,.. Q2 1YPe HSl '!'II' D c:..::> . U Jo\t~iJll~ "l.'1'lO 1(5,1 /" Il( f U!,( 0__ _% l.t~K U' lll'~1 2:-149248 '^Cl O~ "'-0:.,.__..--,__",_ _. _'.".'_.._.._,-,-,.,..,.,... + ._'. ....... ,._~ .-..~- ,..~""'_.,. ~,~."..,,~_.. \:J~ @ 000090~ COMMONWEAL TH OF PENNSYLVANIA PAR CONTINUA nON SHEET fD)RERA TOOYEIUY DErrs REPCRTADlE l2ll' _IlEPCR'....E 0 fll(JrH)()T US( CH..... .....c. IH .- 4. _ " I.~::'''r III" Jq;'- "M. I~~'" ?AU ~IIION INfOIaIATNJN. U5E OVI:RlAY, 2 StEEl fOft cx:xa:.s ICDEFGNAIoE ADDRESS ' " I J . L .. , L/ r: 11 0 () 0 ,~U'" '''~oJ OJ_ au UA- h ..~" 4. p"", 0 0 0 fl " 0 , 1(, p I~ 0 0 () iUV"" 1... . -- ." ... " 0 0 If C> ~ 1 Co M 6 0 c:> c:> "'<J ~.. ,^" .-- A"" ,,~V ~< 0 0 0 & 0 '" I ~ 1;- 18 () 0 0 ~'--oJ "-'<""," d.' b.~, ..., R< () 0 0 B 0 0 , (~ /tI 13 0 0 0 , ~tH,J. ~A-1LL a- Q.,fflo04iL"'L A4 0 (;) (;) l1 0 "" ~ M 17 0 0 0 .. ... - "., <::> 0 "" 8 "" c:::> 1M 113 0 , }.M"~.. d..u-. Lt} " ."", 0 a M () I::> .,... n- o 0 '" "" I 11./ .01 It; 0 0 (;) ~, <,- ""-IN '....... ~ C","""Nflf....., "" 0 "" 0 fj 0 I::> I 1.1 1,:- It. 0 '" 0 .~~..... ~."' -',. . . ~. 0 0 0 a 0 ~ J '" '" ,,</ () 0 0 E7\ M, - 7Jt- -,' A P"" " 0 0 B 0 .. I 0/ r ill " 0 () , ,..,. ,. . '^ N-,' I- 0 0 '" B 0 0 I 'I p I~ 0 0 0 JI,Y:,,_ -. :;'c;;~ 6U.'", ~ 'J> w p" 0 0 0 13 0 '" J Go (:' I~ 0 0 0 I...... n.. "'u..._u L. 'w" "" 0 0 0 6 0 0 I " t: 18 0 0 0 '.b~, "1' , h - '" 0 0 0 ,.; 0 co I 4 f 10:. 0 0 c.:> ......... ,a., ^. .., a........ t.D PA 0 0 0 B 0 0 I U '3 /lk(n.. Of",1i ..., oJlhL ... B !IT ;) <1 0 '" 0 () 0 0 , (p Ie 13 " " () ,~C~ ,.....c.. ... ,<, """,OA~ ,,~ 0 0 0 (J <=> <:> I 'I '" ,7 0 <:> 0 ,.~ -, ... I.., 1"A..1l:...,-:.-4...,. Dl. ..... 0 c> 0 B (;) 0 c'..u.AM - I 4 r 1'7 0 " 0 ...- ,~n.. "'A'I'\. ...~ ,",.... ,...,. ... ...,..., .~ ,,~ ., ~ 0 B 0 ... I " J: I~ n ~ 0 1...k3C,cA "-.. . ^. ..l>ltd.!< ~, ... "... ". <=> 0 c:) B .. " J " ~ I~ 0 0 " S~"'\Ao"''' 'I"lu-.""I\\, ~., Du. . - .-.."" ~.,.. ~ (;> 0 0 13 '" '" J LI ,., 11- 0 " 0 ...~ ",,', ^M -. . -.....r_ "^ ,..AU' P... () 0 (;) 'R '" 0 J (,. '" 10 0 0 '" ,n.,... t'1 ~n. "1':~l."l_.E.J2. Q~.,._....;...._,. - (;) 0 .:> G 0 0 o. J 'l r= '''' 0 0 C' ~'1.:11..-~.~'...l.LAr.. ~U!"L'~n...~ '" <:> 0 0 IS 0 !!... I 4 ,. ,8 0 " 0 ~ t.;;A..DCX1 "c.-(o,J ...u..(.OJ....!a~~~ -..,r.h ~ 0 &> 0 _lL 2..- 0 1- ..':.jM 11 0 " U ~ALr ~~~ (.........oc!..!-~~n-11O=:X-!:J..'l$.J ~. 0 c:- o ,iL c (;) " II' 10/ ... <> ,) ~~C1~Jjl1~~~--.i')t-..!L-'D.. JJ.,..E.,......r..L.~.. ~ p I!!... 0 i? C> 0 f.:- -'., , - - -- ,- -L :1.) 5-; D " a ~.tl OI:A't" 'l1~""'-J,'"'A.i._~1LS"-1ijal1!:::!i..,'~ ,... p "" 0 B .. .~ ...L .. ,( '1 0 oJ '" ,,"'..,.., (1[A\.~.J~.~,i-.......~-.-!i)_S!f~~~-L f'^ "" C' '" B 0 0 - I " :~ III 0 " <:> I"l~. "'... ::L~~I....~~~~._.&.tf.--I.~A..~'.L.LL PI' '" 0 D Ii. ,0 0 , ....nrr: - ~OI."""'l/.V....,"'S .. ______...,.lM.l ~lCT~NUtr.<<.llHSI()Nl.....,.CtV.HGlOI rc Hie - -;-:-j t:' ~I;'~. '.;';'Y'ii.Jiii.:iili 'E'Y" - t,..-..c US! '""') 0 0 M..:.c(I~ -'-------..-j-------,---__.._ 0 rJ I ';;-U .".. ------- ~'~ .,,'.. '''-li'-''~. , ..y-- -'-- [] 0 ~...J,I~'.IIn ):a",J11 !.1 .. ~)'II;)lJ"Ull ~In'l ~U!.UllS C'JtCTH1 ~'M$'UlKN 'ClIV1lJ!,( I.J...L lUt 0 K.fLrA.- ~nt , O-__"'~D l~1( ll~!j.. 0'___-;.0 LMl: '1:$ ~H.JO - -------;;G{ 0'-/ Ci.Nl{R'~A I(ICHW"'"" S.f-fTY (iI)_lDoYPuYllfiTl IIiPClllTA8I.E fill f<ON.AEPClIlTAIU 0 rvtCJOTUIf.: CN.'f ~ U1.~' {.,,, 1_4 ~' 2'" I COOl' Zou . C D E ';"7."".:::;" ADORE.. " I J K L .. I " 1M H 0 0 D "VA" _...'" ~" ... ~ ",. 0 .,. ., '(1! 0 ~ , &/ Ie 3 0 " ., c... :r.... ...,. A Aft e. .... <> <:> '" l> 0 co , il (! 1/3 D 0 " MO..,.,.. "~._ '~_7 r~\ ^' 0 " C> (3. " C> , .r- M II! l> <> <> .k>r ......... K....A ......... ,.~.._ ~ no <> .:> C> g C> C> , I " M /(.. 0 0 .., - "..~ ~ ..,... .,,~. u., ~, ... <> 0 0 R 0 0 / II F /3 0 0 .:> ... o,n.. ~ c" D- o 0 0 12 0 0 ~~W~/t: : , , '0,0 :5 :0'0 :u': :1 '0 '0'0:"". 1.-"'-= ~- Q, DA ,0 .t: I : "" :8: ~: I : 2) --..;7. 'U :'1 :1./ ,g:o: I . , . , . .", , . , , z. : 3 'AI :&4 '3' I 'l.'~... ......~, I, o.J~" A.., ......",. ~.ut... ,., ,,~ :0 :0 'o'a :0 :0 :;: I: At : &It, ':l' I . 0: ol1rY,1#7 : ",.., '0:8 '''' :.:> 3,:S f,1<h 'I '() ~ h,"_, II 'N,-l, d. .~, ~~, .ft..... ~Q:o : Q ,~ '0 : C> : : : . : ft ....."'V"r r : : ..,..." 0'..<' :,..... -"'I : , '. ~ IUI~-z.. , ..... ~ 'Ir-,- ~D ^'-,u........ .", -~ :~:'JJ~ lM~C .... '(./III"" "'Z- .~.,. : It.: 'r"; ft ~:r ,. :_,,; M " C-,_. ...., "/"/" _ ~~ 7,"" <7'....,. ~. .or~' ,"" : : , '- . :" "u rLOhd - ~.,. oIr ,,;.......' "'df' ~:~ .""" - ~, ".- H' _."'~ '.1 ,~, .".' ..... M., ...... 'ArUUNC MuIr Kn4 &'Dt kilN fUN: !..; J . ,.,...,. II' "'..".""" " hUH U.. ... ",.. ...." ",,' no" "..;. 0_- ~,~ -... ~~ If' ....., n :AIT A..~ ur I "" r.2. :... ~ .\ ~r : -- ~.,~ , "'...-~ J,.ff.t ru'~lrn Nl'l1 ""*,o>,r V",") Lr,.1,.. ......... ,...,.<;, , ..k? .;?_, '."'.!.~Ill"m At" t"~I~1N1fI-LJ &,~ J.i9!6J,lJt- ~ C.1'i./~7 A.,. M'.' J'tlnnl _'We urLJtil-'~ ..... f)([ u~r ,At" 'nfr t"'~ Lirf'T'?t """,l) IUAS".,. rCAu.'r ATIAlI:. Arrr","~. , ..... "-t ". '.~'''''d, - n4.w' ,.{r ,., ..or .Ihcu _ A;.<tl'''''^ :n. n,r' "",; : . uour"*". ,"" ~'''Lb I~ 14t: <---..a 'A-"~ NU ~.;n...........~. I~.,.... . - MoLL --- - 18 Ol.!:.CAIUE. VIOLA1~S YO :!olCID~HUtr.lW..IiStC>>o4lYi#-CHAHGlOI Ie HIe IHT' 0 0 -- It <NT. f!!J~"'-[Vlr"'J'" 0""'''' ." ,V"cii....il-Fn~-v;'''''''' DI<l1[s. 0 ~= [ ~ iE'W usr D Jt:Jl.U t~ USE 1UT 0 ft:f~ COt.II , <NT. O___~/. 0 ~I( UNIT: O'___./~ 0 l.N( \'[$ tOO I...... .. ...~. v.~ 0000910 COMMONWEAL TH OF PENNSYLVANIA PAR CONTlNUATlONSHEl:r ~ M.st: CIW) rAa~ CI ttl[R roM. HIGH~"Y ,,,rrTY ,...._~ +~ @ ~ "~, . '.'''~~'I\,..." .,;;.,....,..,""....1'''''''',\ 0000911 . '. ; <,' COMMONWEAL. TH OF PCNNSYI.VANIA PAR CONTINUA T10N SHEET ~lfJOWIU'.uT. AfICATAlU !Xl' NQH.""I'ClRTAlU !:l JIVrHJ01 U. Ot.'f ut - g~.,Z-/ (,hh7 ~. ,/3 I~'" Zo~ """""'1n:=~~wl/t,""'..1 ,~. AIlllAESS H , J K L .. ICD 'OKUE ! G,MMlAA1M: : M:"_""'.1:: 1W <2f". ^,j J..I.. ... ..",~ :2,0. ...,...~, ;",_: :,oor 1lA" uuw ...... "'... ' , ' ,- '-' U,rrD _,'7 UA,~ ~ ~ - ......, u" LN&, ",. ..or <>-J '" eJ. DY ,~. , : ....;~ - ..~ ,....."" ~. IILWin Mil .."",,'-~ .... JUr ~^ ~ : I . 4.< """r :,. ... ..,," Au,," .... ...,. ". 1M. L,.." .,: " : : : : : 1--- ..... " A.... o/t7L; I : "~J. r.. \, ., c.- r.,.. 1"'.' , DIJ", ""- "Flu" At- ~ "...,.. _~ (~\{>l ^ " v "'~,. "LP.... LK..,rf' Il~ lttJILr I",,""'-i~:~.., . , , .. ru,,", "." ur,,-JI ",. ^' P,,, ~ "" ."r ;, n. - : -.., ..'.., "';"'~I: ., ...... .Ad ...... .R:+t~1. n.tmu ,,_Au:....t.l .~/]) '..In. "-'_ . "-1."",,; , (tr. ,,.., ", .", ",., . . '"~<C.''' .~ ..,.. . .. . , ---- . : , a:l ~C11ONN.Jt.Q{RSICH.'t"CH4HGE.OJ lC Hie '--'["':]5"- \lJ u~;.Y1t'-+Ci~I~' tJ:S,[ ---"'($' Drt.fl.~.r LNl,1 0 "'-0 '''' I __ -' -- """"'::(11IiZ) v' 'j~Ooitil-f '1 if"( US,( U5>1 liIJ -suu DNJHS1 o...n"" 0'__".0 '"' o 0 o 0 --------~- - UN" I p,,"*--. Cft>;TfR ro~ HIGHWAY UHf" " .;- " :>- ,.... >.. (~ .., I- i>:: ~< I;,) ~ (,~ ;3~~ ':.} , t",': " .'1::', , _. ", ;~ T( , (::,1 " (.') ~ I. I , ~\,! ,I ,- '-'/, , .,'., ..;':; '..IU . ''..:';J.... I '. C-;, .:) CO C:> () , -" r- ',- r.:.. .;~ c': I:: , c <: c.. I,~ , , " , , '. , L'-" , , ~_l r ( () ," J / ..;.' , 'j iii . ., , .' " ("':') :'j 1_:"'1 f..:'. C) ,. ; ',,'" .' : ,:";:' ::': "l:.:~:, '.,,;,' '<"::<:':'''''''~;':'~'~~;:"'1;:~~.I;:,:,I:.,:..:~~,.:;~;~,~~:",::",:-",:,:,'<."~:,,:,2'<:":,<~<,: ":.' ;.:.:"~'..:,." , , IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Samuel P. Foor, Plaintiff Civil Action - Law vs. No. 99-2664 Benjamin R. Musser, Forrester Farms, and Daniel Forrester, Defendants JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ORDER OF COURT February , 2000, upon consideration of the within Motion of the Defendants for continuance of trial from the March 2000 term of Court, it is hereby ordered that the case is continued from the term of Court beginning March 13, 2000 to the next term of Court beginning May 1, 2000. By the Court, J. r ( ~ . ~~4 @cr r~~~~) .. -1\ J \ c~'" \'-'c \\$\ \ l$\-' ." . 'I, '. '':'''~':';' ::':, :, '; ,:;~;;;~(,::::';. ,/,>;', ',<:,: _~;;", i;~,::~:::;::,::\:)::~_':~,::~,;',:,,~,>, "c", "'/;,':-;:,',::,::,.:',',:: :,:.';~..),,:',', ',: ,>,.', . ::,.:.",' :,i :,.',:' '" ',' .',1 , . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Samuel P. Foor, Plaintiff Civil Action - Law vs. No. 99-2664 Benjamin R. Musser, Forrester Farms, and Daniel Forrester, Defendants JURY TRIAL DEMANDED DEFENDANTS' MOTrON FOR CONTINUANCE FROM MARCH 2000 TRIAL TERM Now come the Defendants, by their attorney, John N. Keller, and move your Honorable Court for entry of an Order continuing this case from the March 2000 trial term which begins on March 13, 2000, for the following reasons: 1. Counsel for the Defendants is lead counsel for the Plaintiffs in a Franklin County civil action, Buchanan v. Shank and Morgan Drive Awav. Inc~, No. A.D. 1993-125, in which a Scheduling Conference Order was entered by the Honorable Richard J. Walsh on August 30, 1999, several months before this case was listed for trial, fixing jury selection for Monday, March 13, 2000, beginning at 9:30 a.m. Attached hereto and marked "Exhibit A" is a true copy of the said Scheduling Conference Order. 2. A summary judgment motion filed by the Defendants on December 9, 1999, seeking dismissal of Defendants Forrester Farms and Daniel Forrester from this action, remains pending, In response to the motion, the Plaintiff took the deposition of Defendant Daniel Forrester on February 8, 2000, however, the Plaintiff has not yet filed a response to the motion. 3. At the request of counsel for the Plaintiff on January 11, 2000, deposition of the Plaintiff scheduled for January 13, 2000, was continued and was rescheduled for February 8, 2000. 4. At his deposition on February 8, 2000, the Plaintiff denied certain statements attributed to him by his treating health care providers in their records and contended that his health care providers had provided certain advice to him not documented in their records. 5. For reasons which include the aforementioned deposition testimony of the Plaintiff given on February 8, 2000, the Defendants now intend to schedule and are in the process of attempting to schedule depositions of some of the Plaintiff's health care providers who are not expected to testify for the Plaintiff, however, defense counsel believes that it may not be possible to schedule these depositions prior to March 13, 2000. 6. Defense counsel has consulted with an independent physician who has agreed to review the health care records of the Plaintiff in this case and who may be asked by the Defendants to provide trial testimony. Defense counsel is concerned, however, given the voluminous records which have been generated, that it may not be possible to provide the Plaintiff with expert discovery prior to any scheduled deposition or trial testimony of such reviewing CERTIFICATE OF NONCONCURRENCE I certify that, on February 10, 2000, I telephoned counsel for the Plaintiff, Andrew H. Dowling, Esq., and advised that I would be filing this motion for continuance. Mr. Dowling instructed me to note that he does not concur in the motion. By J n K 1 ~ preme Court I.D.#2577 100 Walnut Street Waynesboro, PA 17268 (717) 762-3331 Actorney for Defendants Date: February 10, 2000 '{:" :;r ',',<', ", ':~~~'" :~';:"\1'~ ,,;',<,:'~':}'.;,:~::=":J~I;;i;>~~:,::",~~~<;4',~~,~;~~~,',~:':,:\.,'~ > ~:; "..,:~: ",<, ",.><:,<',r,"\:'.,r,i, .:, :'. -'~':,:.: \'.j" <', ~',... ~ " Buchonnn v. Shank, et 01. No. A.D. 1993-125 Schedllling Conference Order Page:! 4. I>cndline for I>ispositivc Molio~: Dispositive motions, if any, shall be filed lIot later tlrall Wedmsday, December 15, /999 and any argument thereon, if necessary, shall lake place on Tlrursday, lallllary 6, 2000 at 9:30 a,lII. with Driefs to be submitted to the Courl in a timely fashion pursuant to the Court's 1999/2000 calendar. 5, Su\:\:cstion of Death: Counsel for the Defendants will file as reasonably soon as possible a Suggestion of Death with respect to Defendant Frederick L. Shank along wilh any supporting document or instrument. 6. Pre-Trial Conference: It is anticipated that matters normally dealt with at Pre-Trial Conference pursuant to 39th Jud. Dist. C.R. 39-212 will be addressed by the Court at the Pre- Trial Conference and addressed by the parties in their Pre-Trial Conference memoranda to be submitted in advance of the February 28, 2000 Pre-Trial Conference, 7. Modification of this Order: This Order shall be a final Order unless suggestions for correction, amendment, or other change arc made to the Court in writing within seven (7) days of the date of this Order. By the Court, ~~~( J. c: David C. Cleaver, Esquire, Counsel for Plaintiffs John N. Keller, Esquire, Counsel for Plaintiffs F. Lee Shipman, Esquire, Counsel for Defendanls John R. Ninosky, Esquire, Counsel for Defendants Timothy J, Abcel, Esquire, Counsel for Defendants Louise D. Hayne, Esquire, Counsel for Defendants .flu.qlLSt ~I .1999, A copy of the within Order has been,mailed by regular mail to counsel above named, ~lru. /: /' I~LU1UJJ1\...,. Secretary /lCD SfP 02 1999 , ~ KELLER, KELLER AND FREy Attorneys 01 Low 100 Walnut Slrert Waynesbora. PA 17268.1646 . ~EB } 5 ?n{/~) " . ij . , " "'-. ,..... ~.. .. : r KELLER. KELLER AND FREY Attorneys at Law 100 Walnut Slreet Wayneshoro. PA I 726R. I 646 " ANDREW H, DOWLING, ESQ, METTE, EVANS & WOODSIDE 3401 NORTH FRONT STREET HARRISBURG, PA 17110.0950 ] , , ,; ,;::,:, ',' . ~: '"i', ,'/, '.", ',' :'>' ""/;'" ' 1',; .,:.' ~ ':,l:~"~,.~~:~;'\:~,~~f'~l~:~~;~":"':' ~;; ~~~~:' ~,:::: ;::~,.~,,~~:' i.:', ':~ >\:',. \ :~:'~,~~'~~:' : ,',:,' ~", ,,': :,,'-',' <7\ '-,' :>:: ' : >\ ::' ' ..' ':, '~~\ ::~ , ~ '. ~ i '. , KELLER. KELLER AND FREY Attorneys at Law 100 W"lnUl Slreel Wayne,holO. PA 1726X.I646 . ~ KELLER KELLER AND FREY 100 WALNUT STREET WAYNESBORO PA 17268 ?' various schedules of the taking of these depositions. The Court feels that the case could be tried in two days with four challenges to each side; Mr. Keller is unavailable for jury selection on Monday, March 13, 2000, but is otherwise available for trial that week. Defense counsel raises a question as to the applicability of Section 1797(a) of the Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law, and how it should be applied in this trial. It is the Court's initial feeling that the gross amount of medicals should be submitted to the jury and the jury verdict subsequently molded in accordance with the insurance law; however, defense counsel has an opportunity to furnish a brief to the Court to determine what, if any, the jury may have involvement in this determination by way of a jury interrogatory. The Court directs that that brief be filed with the Court within seven days of today's date and defense counsel shall have seven days to respond. Each counsel relates to the Court that they are satisfied with the authenticity of the medical records in existence, but not necessarily their admissibility, including photocopies. Plaintiff's counsel indicates that there will be a revised vocational report forthcoming, and the Court directs that that be given to defense counsel by the ,'" , , '. "", \ "" - '. ,.',' , ,\ I , .',' ' , , " 'I,. ' , ,'.' ......'., , '" , . ,,' "'I~: I,' ". ,,' ' I,., ""..' , ,', ' . I'- close of business on Tuesday, February 29, 2000. By the Court, Andrew II, Dowling, Esqui re For the Plaintiff John N. Kell er, Esquire For the Defendants Prothonotol:y / Court Administrator :mtf ~~ ~l