Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout03-3115!A/ Tffh CoLJIZ-r OF COMMDAV /ALFAS ©F C'UAr AERLAMb C©LJAITY Ro\fA/svZi//4,k1/A -=s1jwcpw YAKS IauNDY ttv/LT:)RT AencuAIr LAAW FINIlml: Fr v DoelcEi' NC7_ a3.?3V-15 N t Rtr~zD SoUTI-lG.1ZS bP-FgM ,AAT- C Ono PLAI Kn - FA. PcLtrICgL Suf3DlVtstonl -rorcrLLA INN ACC I aAMMIIrd nP IneAl ALAL?IP IP IMMA nVt=F ro THE RonLCRAtaIE TULSES OF'SAtID r-aawr" : PLAINn FT MSHAi NGQ MtiKE ?au.NDV i?) ant aft s o1NA/ AW//A iF' W THE aBovE CA4P"ontmo es?usa n? wcrrou P-&sC1==er=ULLY 12E.PPSxSF--LtM on IR-t_,gNi /-T-1 nt'l TY CL XUAisOrcrtaa OFTNE c-CLJ YY' /s /4ASMO L14OA/ IVA Pk. de-5A. Swrn ou I gSO Apia o,L PA. vaL,r,cAL SL/66wl/ s, ou rmm- c-Lm w) 144-"r - I . PLAtM7-IFF SSHHN642MIM SAIMbY LAF?f1L37L?A?v/A/otanv,o?L^. CAPrYV6 Al- I-V?£ SrvWi-w Lc1rl2Af77OA,(AL /.VSTITLY7dA/ L.t-MO,tftLLLEEg?irv???fE1Z ?S..L.I.CAO?e., uA/>,EIZ Cavwcrro.v AeFS'LoM7?t/4s 1. AGF?AM?r' !!/cs/A41tD StafirffEAts l3 A? LcAnAA?'L _LEV?L•G9/???euASAL-Mm Lev L?tR?LlntC> lf,v0l=t?LIn1G nnao*.„owAS C \AntStitC2?_7?FT7A,C IPA. 6CAhRrx?s,a, t aF Goi2QE GT1ow/s,j6rWa1)J /v.at^rora? ?:D? Jnar,ova/? At S.c. /.CAM, SP711,t1L M./1N?.imM;c'xr LWtr? BU/lam/.tlG-?A^zt. ?fL/SiS OA?71r7CS'[?nlAt•L w?OtK ,4 cvtllVS?ItKG AiAtM AA/LcY/0AK6 CA.?LVVaA¢K SLo2V/A•sc 7'O PR/SSWSQ? TO A'I.fJ/Tr? r/BEM /N SOLViAlG Se9ClAL/ MgWAfeAI1Ct A? El/teD77oAG i- PRe ztr-n&,& rb ra/E AEX rMV7' aC /A/FLr/MSte-Mdo CMA MG&Mf it/ Awmmars- eff# "/oP- A-mo rn ciWVcLo.0 *-1*77LSE,OPb/6Ki7'V A-MA AAf-SPQA1S/AlLtTV ? Jt?,8 Dt5OZ o o I pu *?` /,f7St? . A4nt0 /Al Ef/s /AvviN/auAOL cAiMex& Ecm#%,nm-M AZ7S Awn coAOPawsrs AGMAM- PZ+//tf7rF:F- /K,//oLm-t'C,u OF LAw OA/.+B6[JT /e-/9-o/ ,yA{/-GeaAwl6. laEr-"DAAIT .IS A GtviG saoZ Kr EL 7je*,'Tb7 &/11A Vmm: vaMR A4 P99JAIS VLt ~O, M _Att' wty DIe&Wi2Lmf? UA&W4 T^'A& LA.W Or-rWO- COMA%DAOVVA--AD WOF- PpVbdSYLvA ikAi'AAVD CAM BE LscArG.o Ar t P. ©o epcK 9939 CAwlpwiLL, Pl?l-toctl?S21 Ll. 6jV OA. A 4-% yI L4 c7 UME: H.ao/ PLAiAVTt J=P WAS G I VtV ABM At/BCOAUO u,=- At]UA•ow - PA:)V, 6AM 6V OmPewD/4AM /,{/ 6" A9Vi714 1,3YLQrLLa6L htSLAWarl ear SoL.ef-v h:s /Z&7A-"O,v TS AtAiGA PLA/wmiP" t3coe r7m=w. G/rte S'ms7ls..t[GSC' 3,Y3 v3 /4KD CA 6 ,S S V?S N04 t eAatrr 4,,,F ArWA PLAtrm"A? to 000 ASb/r// Ct1Mv4ue,=_ ?* dtso ®/ . 5.Aj4-tAt"tRF A,1~ .A£mt /ILKtcmmls At[ T a 3Pic,,4? r,nAVAd?MQA? tiA Aa_oC.44M WtJW ^- ryA?-oF E,4RAf$7 9&e00 77MAL Lt.Fr a? UASdZ/t 3dLsTAAY .. .(?,vEi,?Fm>=nrT T?ST?4L ,s1xA?r o.i cc,.??,T oni5 Hvbr?57+grvd .4ri01c^RL_5TAfu4rbP?(?) LaAt& rW?1W W4&7W fF?- MUS7r SIOMV13 A.r L eWr- AMlvrA-,u.n df .2 AAoNT/4s av SALN AOAUA//srstAriVE cusrrr/.ayuc\ Pit.4sE A-Fr,r/t oor,Vc Vev4rl airAist4im o2V L11sT3BdiS6C)SAAJrnotJS,A,l,0aWi 5MMSAeRtaw4L~Nirf Aee&5TlASd7X_noA/, 1864LArUA&cHX2 6.MgfrCCxt9AtreoALS/ALLEgrw,Otus oCrAiseO,upuer- REPBlRS u owu4rrm 14esonntAWA_ JvAs'rAtAw, Yf R&Sutr-rty /AwMSO/ArE A6", t.FM PLAtwrrA" 57)eus` j=- a Abat Agr .l ouE PAeemss gjoD arm rS amLL), 1"A!/Ckl lb/o TAKE PLAeE krLF?I F? UJAf6T FLL?D A MtSGAAtA aer Irawa r TAt[GE AAAAt rwr- PLA,tvT PP B/ast2rs uPO U't H!_ taxA a-!C^ NE AOC-iba74r- P.E1Gwuafs 7Zo Aham!ru u"6me Atuo"AEx-4./nr.4v//vrEx&7c"rL dvt WA&euoas NA.twot 1.AFTE2TWOCA)AIALGouS o4 D wt tc t .arrCMPra ra CAu5j=- /SL.6. "rigs 41AtwARk4L1TeD . 0hLAtb4E E.STM16E¢.w,0LT ktARtA DEFO,AAAAfr AMb Mts lhfMr=Wm-A5 bUPjF?P_` lSOR M2 5PMAL LN44WAGEYVN'FR utv,TLS Ur4\-% YV\vNr4 t ER CUan) (AlEtTETtdE 5AME_IAJUD9WTT RMDO&r AS A coAtrr,utlob Moaws of wtauu Bus AclS t.u P*n AA- rrr+. rt 2.bEPiat&Au7 A" a G w , r m Asi 4 dE9 ARE t4dso Pr:2?pd- Soc,.tiL lGtt ®LDS? 4. Ft-fE ktR177ALG tOF' etiteMAeAUeT ReAOAZS [5+4-10 wV.ocAITCE l iA1rt>rs /vsrAAtee=_oc r/fE PEtVrVS VL.VAAltr4 Dd+.42r7vt.F%tr- oP-e.zAAELTt oA.ls uPP-=&S5iOhJ&L-t;-? OF R- FIGS" AND Woe Pob" be-AOM 5rcct 3ZL (I)1,wNlcH STMT--s Iw PP kr-kk 6ILImop-E--- SMALL SE PuAns}+ab. RaTrtUATeD tc &AtA sl OR cmtA i t54 \-M.rtm o Fom Ceaob PAL-ves uSE aFTws Ga,,mjAAlem_ sggrEJYL,J, lO. T**i ITLESULr' OF T/tE Acrrotttr OM' 9&gBrAMtf- mint U° L1161-i &0> ALA-inmevc a45 &tar- Pm-E CAawcn J A&i - ien-? Rtc-ovB/L GEEMMtA1- DOAuLa-mou TTPMUI. AS /E RtzSu.l_T 9R.TUE PAC.ESG+CnGNSh 3¢T PaY D oA,a'r Au SNttL mFAct/AL..-rtpE UU6001(EW MESS"{( aT soar To 9TFArJZ SmutGuAkb STP&FF• r/. &l5P=JJ6ANr IS A PASS SARC.m r CouNLB RT Sa1 cAmOWLL / Kko st-ku_ MalA5 sw lAIPLyo(us< 64 1415 ALT10A15, ESPW-J Aly AC M Tt,*IJFTt'& F-1?'r¢.'OAl-IN CrG., L9 !N ALLthFE t4Povp- PU4j w71FF 4A-s 13F?u ,A/7u&tmD tN rNf_? A Kou,.rroFl?3l6-on,00 IfIRW-F,vc hluuBRE?D Dot1RTi7 MJtr ),JTs{X JAiy-ERCSr 10P /'vd?II127T N ?t'E)onl6 04OLLLAdZ. . w "- Eft FeR;c PLt4, w.T1 rP rAr n"bc t u DleM1u t G, n ATtou Suoc smE% T AC.ttl IJ5r wFEhIlAtTr ,u rut -"OU\Aar 041,731.03 ?rPAFF TAfouS.6U/?.SCVUV APLWDR>? Tw&&rY-aNE AeI?AUJ FtvE Ce-? AAIO F?S7' h 4TL? APei L Q_oo3 `??yL417 a I 1 u yl, Ro.8s1C aoo ^r?`.4F.3Vt3 (V\ e-v",litt t , AA,nooi Oa Co 2S/JA4vG© M1d6Ej5UW&Y Gta,tiriFF I?(--OA,[A SOvrmi- t DfiargAdwnr>- //v Ttsc L Of?RrcaF Cor?f,m,? PLrd4S of C t V, L 7" ,CT At ,V /MT L A-,. 2 L)OGK<-r No. /'vrAWJO1-„sr;C nF S'GVV//- - 2. ZSsfiY a,&v Lf/C? f3 e..veY?FSV,3? 1.,ey" 5t' Ce-77Ae r2po of 7K,e4e--AaA CL RRPZ.T oa PV mFTffE i477f9Cf,PEO ?E7rlG1o1B? /4, /OG.T7e,fL I'm A Ai rf/C/ef 7-0&7"CLA-1w A-c.T;OJJV LL,'4447, CL "em ^004 UtY L AA, GSA . S'oG. ES50A-"4 vAtif,wly IQG ,VWdsd Pto eCE76C oC coy 4-r ra t Cf,,4A3 .CG4x<A Cove rV Cd f+.r.on,r rkd% rs ?auv-f{oo.r?.. it t.L/SY Fi2sT cGris rv^^M••IL ?ALe"r, .. mA k Ic*T6fo RAvwA vI 43F-CA' % Aeorzcbt 7v AAP C.E? fps ?A!h A-/7RVA/1lS? ?I/T/Mv/TD,c 6(*f1 S RAfG ,O.QdI AO SEA Q/L0M (, AD /.SZL-A uA IE?Q/d?'SCS 1,6EPlCOOC?- QDvA-7- 2tcl*jo? Sores. 4,.= G?Cl sK/S ?7RGMrfA co c s rsr cb o&r%Ao ash R0.6mc 9-t-1-7 / C?uRYtFov sE SQUA-/tE c bK45t4tLL, OA , rZ oo 1-BS37 efthAL/ SLE, AA, /-7 0/3 PA, A- roRntc-Y Gf?).c-S OM c SraAVj(3arJI'( Sa &Ai ' l GrS???{L kb+Y?ALC1b PA. 1 '7/ za [Yt ?a?..rAwre '1? AaTrA lcTLt? daQ? ? (? / ?? ?FJV,J S Ca cr O C. c..? -. ?' r._ vt '? ntr s .., _ c' ? .. ? } _? . T 1 C_i .1 ?% y f:. tV ? P - G T„ T7.1 F. a4i,N+PRAt?,t.t 30NRIE0f SA IL> FnT,Tf;}.I?r?pL A1,/Ylar:' L.51i;-lNf3? Nr, KP f:waO%. _S'6.M:S LG AH ?, Tn FR!>tc C.C) ,. +-t A77'c2 /Al foAM# PAuJii A Cr r uU.'1 rE wtmi of rv-r5 THar /..l_ AAW Th' T %. TAM 1!?u jc=B ,e: Tslr i/stt e: ('?RRE.Crir),v.?l /-+ri?rrr/TI:)?r .rfi r'h,'r?'1- l_ .I+ 71 7r, .?. 2. AIAIYP t s-rfL f1Y tiaval r.S ...c, a,^r.f„^,7 -:F ern !+/CI a A9F .:.:: / PArCJ,C[/,'?1?7 /?J C7 N.L. .i t EwCr rf is 1 /??/lfJER J,n an .wars NAr'L E :44.1, T7 lA, G>..C A , t ,"A6f e `, PAY t HE Or ,;F 7 Ne St„ .090r C- tow G ?:., .!C rzr Se r . v{A.+Ar l,c'F /AW,S rAAr(i,ac casT) !'r r", r` Fr Are I'c1OFSD NH rur5 r.rarre: R It"AiA,.,A r"AUPEf;u-5 AIto ..rnurhlrpAvn,FK4- oAaVA,) 1 F /r" rME GUY/RT pi ('- shFlJ10" YLEAS. SS NG,.?:S A':a 1:,11Kt N-li 0FC11416Ef,i AAj0 {. DUAITY PE. AwlT, PG CGI wr...- Tc i A,--r. ..,.i M t.-i/ V. DOCKET N.?. ,/s!d"dd rvs. SEtc;rl Ta lR. b6=K`c ra?n?? -.:.,r M r / r.. F !'t 1 An F.SERC.A1 Arn _. tHFi>nvt rb+ArfEr"^,y,? I;E2 a?. 6I2t ='M/ x ..,sac ..,•I JVI r'r 7+,r le AAA COST- W O t.CrrW", rail GF. FF.IV!G rkf.. Amy ?., or OR.,QP ?....^ , M d T'a is<?T ?1N F 1,'^•.,/ 5 P'krYv A.- 01 / IG rprN G' M4 FY, ,r11 ,•'^r a ! a" t'ST ro ?w , G_o51 :. !.1 I SAT! Wit _ ',y: e 'I i•/,J E`r"t .a vv i<Er ATI •7-..:? •"71 ABrr.rTYI PA'j-f;' rej r+Nt' ISr IJ ix 'S. i. I'tr.: /`IYE SC:R7 I-:ik7 i /•,r ..v r.•=+ k .i R rtn r.rNfr?n PL c.Yr ", A, D LA'., WW`e.6 Ia, f ri.;T,Lr C; Joe&Are^+w:.:. MF v".1 .?,++ t;•-IC LA S'I TwlE-. '. F_. .n„?r'r -, .y 'V i•t?fc"'..f(•`F>rF N<f>CC:tt?h21r3'. rF ...a.,y T?s r•t aia}tI'e:., :it. i... t.^,: t'r'i (y .?. n.. ni sfT ®....nA Ara `? t:?AS1i ,_slL G9+E CKt V^`r ui, -?*?,•,?l-sS racc.?t +nr TS uR ^. r?.a1. St ?=?? 5-r -; 1. ; t. .+, ... -; c :: yry? Il.!- i.,in, ,. A}YC_.i r"1-11{.J2 ' 1 X `10 141 (' F- v ()U . TNa=i7F.- fi 1:k l r Of S,W rl?PT I)r ^,_..? th,/ rat: Fli ?' . SS clvr'?3i:7. .:.'/IVpr "r,"O T. I/a Yr_'.AC',-mlrr nrr n/.? Ay"'" 5 rn'Arrr"AL. c.rKG•.r rotiS'Aa16f-.s cl-,.,A aIr.r. +^KMl/r a o-r;,, ,! 4 v/' ,zn,n- IQJ117 7rIE r s.': -c Cu RRrC. ?, ..? Y(? iIFY 74;kT YF/C S`YAa"rr to F >: r:; Mi•. •^,? Vd nr-,. •E ,.+.:nE. :3d.FE: ,' f._. 7"._. . r ..r, ?";, e., <?C' i'b d _. .. St. i' ?..nr al 9Ci1/ rPr-.^'li n.:< r? r„ .?.,:'. FA,• (•'f E; v. s 7? n,rzr Ti a, ,1 r r c, CD c C- GO -- Z C'. -rn Y C. N GNAAfGO ItA1IC? 7U 11.,`/ PL A,., r, Cf U. I'?ICHARD SDUT +eaS bU FfirkmA T /A! f4E, C,-D1/f) % OF Cc7"MO n/ r)kA.V CF OU)"AfPL<n16 C°ov vTV tMFk40,PAA4Ar1nA V)F /Au/ THE coafr uF Cv,-r,aoA1 A(cAs OF CU, al5,,eCA?a COU1v7-V DeN//Sr!?,tmNA , d•S,A. UL/SD/cnO1v O EnrTER 7741? THIS C014AA1A17 CAvdnO, D/i77C4L AA T SUAAI?/S/ojJ 70177 C/AjA4 ACCT L/ot 1)A.C,S,A .SEC. ?FSscD INd/G//MNr0A/I)l/!T _ /A/ Amy ACITON Ar.A/NsT A• .., , , „ fMOlr7YFF TNERtOi i.-a? 1)Aw4016ES Ow Arr OVdT OF AN /NchVRY C.41ASEn F,Y THE AC7-c]r r hle r-MPLO VCE 1v ,NF//CH /T/S c%UbOALLV IAL'TEPM/NE/O 71-/AT THE AC7 Oc THE EMDLovE-e CAU.Set 7f/,E /N7ulaV AA/4-Jo -/AT SUcH ,AFT'CU.VS7'TTUT,F?6 A CRIME, AcTi,(Ao )eALLD, AO"uAL A4,AMee OA W/ U-k UL M1SC0A1&jc7- - 7-A4E A?o VISIONS OG 5EC776a/ k'SY.3-?i E[Ar1„,6 Tb or=f/c?ArLg Lin ?3, [,ry FILMEWU-Z1 T-TI4 C-a/0"?TIAIG 7'o DEFENSE OF®P"P/C/AL r„uM ?wir?i Lc(SL/$'L(SE4HTING TO /Nt?EA9w ?,.?A'S1171.L.SE1/71NCa TO On, i?AA1A 3HALL NOTAPPL`! . VVILLFUL MISGOwAtAC7" NO2 LJ141cl4 OFFICE& Is uvr 11UINUAIL= uuDrA2?cNe,SH1JAN,A3 POL/TICAL S u4bbWiSIONA TDie CLAIM ACT Ig Uar guess-eAT? IU01 Ff'EIZtNCE.. IT 1ZEQulnEs pESIRE Tn APbour T,iE. 2?SULT OR AT LEM r-rh4E AWARENESS T/-)RT /T /5 SV41SrY1107A/LY CBRTA/N To F16L L okAj, C>,IEN V. CrrY orOAMAMLAIJA. 6,D, DA,lAK G f. c vASP_ 2d 373, AwAR& OF Pua1 -7 iVa AAsUACArrs A6A11vs - Notice oGG/cie-12 111 AcTiow A3/h7U&47- 13V AR/7ESTfE fan ASSAULT AA10 6ATrE V AND CALsE /ArARlSOevMEn,- 1 ?.1s wdT SUF1'ir1E'nrr- r-O E srA alfSa-/ "WIIJI,?t ?Lt1st'?11Di.rT 7-h1,AF I,va.tA Aftkibc AoL,CE 0i4EX FROM 0877gl NIAiG A"br= MITI FROM r-'rV uar5E2 POLI'CAL 4iu6bjgI Io AI TORT CLAIM A[T FOR 'Tu-S6?ME.T EN?$ic?E?1 AOAI,w<r PQ0te oF?,cE? I,u l"HAT Acr,0?4 S/NCE /ZL?c,&E Ss c.71sAU?Y "t&,Nr AF TuPTJC,V:NT 7--tD SVPPOIrT AwAfim of nUN1rINE 17AAVA6E5, ltFN/! V. CITYOFO/M:S/bLASH, by A,-'a :2ff°h537 an,SvV, 99V, -ze J7;10 -S ? T-- T7 CT r z cn ` -- r i`` l D ISHANGO MIKE BUNDY, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF PLAINTIFF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. RICHARD SOUTHERS, DEFENDANT 03-3115 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this -V day of July, 2003, IT IS ORDERED that plaintiff may proceed in forma pauperis without paying a filing fee or ser By?he Court, Edgar Ishango Mike Bundy, AF 5413, Pro se SCI Camp Hill P.O. Box 200 C Will PA 17001 0200 amp , - ^ :sal ?e ` >- t, ? ?? ?,. -= r -, CJ? e 3 ? " lJ .--, r` ' u t ?.:aZ ; ? 1 ?.':-. .j ?t1 <% O U SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 2003-03115 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND BUNDY ISHANGO MIKE VS SOUTHERS RICHARD GERALD WORTHINGTON , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County,Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE SOUTHERS RICHARD DEFENDANT at SCI CAMP HILL 2520 LISBURN ROAD CAMP HILL, PA 17001-8837 by handing to IAN TAGGART, SUPERINTENDENT ASSISTANT a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE together with and at the same time directing His attention to the contents thereof. Sheriffs Costs Docketing 18.00 Service 10.35 Affidavit .00 Surcharge 10.00 .00 38.35 Sworn and Subscribed to before me this o2( 1 day of o7Q7V A. D. prothonotary the at 1444:00 HOURS, on the 15th day of January , 2004 So Answers R. Thomas Kline 00/00/0000 By a t Deputy y She She ff was served upon Office of Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 151" Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 ISHANGO MIKE BUNDY, Plaintiff V. RICHARD SOUTHERS, Defendant Daniel R. Goodemote Senior Deputy Attorney General IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 2003-3111) DEFENDANT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT Richard Southers, by and through his attorney, the Office of Attorney General, preliminarily objects to Plaintiff's Complaint pursuant to Fla. R.C.P. 1028(a)(1). 1. Ishango Mike Bundy (hereinafter, "Plaintiff") commenced this action by filing the Complaint on or about July, 1 2003. (See Docket Sheet; attached as Exhibit A). 2. The return of service indicates the Complaint was served by handing a copy to Ian Taggert, Superintendent Assistant at the State Correction Institution at Camp Hill (SCI - Camp Hill) on January 15, 2004. 3. The Complaint was not reinstated prior to service. 4. It is unclear whether Plaintiff seeks to sue Defendant Southers in his individual capacity or as an employee of SCI-Camp Hill. 5. If Defendant Souther is sued in his individual capacity, service on an employee of SCI-Camp Hill is defective as service at Plaintiff's place of employment does not constitute service on the Defendant individually. 6. If Defendant Souther is sued as an employee of SCI-Camp Hill, service is improper as Plaintiff failed to serve the Office of Attorney General as required by Rule 322 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. 7. It is well established that the rules governing the service of process set forth in the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure must be strictly followed. Township of Lycoming v. Shannon, 780 A.2d 835, 838 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2001). 8. Because the Complaint was served more than 30 days after its filing and was not reinstated, service of the Complaint is improper under Pa. R.C.P. 401. WHEREFORE, Defendant Souther respectfully requests that this Honorable Court dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint based on lack of jurisdiction over the person of Defendant Southers, due to defective service. RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED: GERALDJ.PAPPERT ATTORNEY GENERAL BY:. DANIEL R. GOODEMOTE Sr. Deputy Attorney General #30986 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day sending a copy of the foregoing document to all persons and in the manner indicated below. SERVICE MADE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS: Ishango Mike Bundy #AF5413 P.O. Box 200 Camp Hill, PA 17001-0200 :.L9 6L,r, DANIEL 11 GOODEMOTE Senior Deputy Attorney General #30986 Office of Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15th Fl., Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 (717) 783-31 7 / DATED: ptoC- IC`I' I-D ?:1 v -h C /Sf/AAt&(D M11(F_ f3UNDY t7LA/Nr)FF fttC//hRD S ou n4RItS DEFENDANT iiv COURT OF QE)MMW PLEAS CL//NBERLANCI COUAR_Y, REMNS-YL.VANJA OW14 ro,rr Acnon: T LAW DKr. r40_ N O. 03 - 3 1 / 7 -/?"41- 6YJt12Y RLAIMY'/FGS XESPONST-- 7-0 P, --Um,tv4aV OAJZFerPO" 6`I JUEFEuOAA7T p/Arnrr/PF SSiIAUC?C? MtK£ ?IJNOY F.St{/? TNiriAT? 1?// ya 9tA•, c.s,.A . ? 8S?© ?ciiiJFt ? .v.s? a?.c??, a- -_ aoAOLAI/VT LIAAAE2 8Y D>=FEJ?ID" /. P1_A1N77or- b1h NoT comN?/? 77,PS AC77ON A:!5 c-/rEb r ANT, 11v A7TA PREL/m/,uAAV 0Li6_MC77O,us "ou oR AiSaLrr' TULY h &W:3" T,U/S /fKL> tlEJZ /?RELM,.vA2Y O.QTECri OAr.S /tllE /> /?/FIwoots, PLACaD, /N THE RErO/zb !O clout, rffE AcmoOj. 5EE oArm om OAtatNAL/ flApmokicoptED GOMPL Almrr" ETA 2. P Lkl/?rtFF /aAWLI?V -5Edt'tE5?-_'/ INGMNIG ????? JtcEG3t.• CA.) L3ai ?,Vn4 7- AIA.< VO7- :AIIQil ? / ?E eJ?FFis d77o FGva-Y aorRec ,o AAW ?PLt4/v7XAG'%fAs n/-T R_ Fs?'/r??r '? OFDEFOfD,4rrTs gc-a IES`C To T/fE couer7v /4/A:vE Yf/E A7to2vE`/ G>?8E+lis0f?icE IZG-PRESCVT F{1J?7 rJ t/DSR Th4S A c?O (l CQL[RT B'L . \ --/?ESC..uAc?t aabv/aCJI->r2? rr:FE G9C/FL 21LL-ES C%3) U VDT:a 714E L.ocAi 2uLc3 F Ga?i1,QT irJS > -?f ?tSS/!??alE? J dJ.fAEJes 7-mac dg7qSMa4APr ?62?tt? CINdC?2 775L/S 7YOE 4 E7701? ' JunGE ^f O uiFJLA-no:J p4z--71Q/901rnG,v AJ<?/L.4 ca[Lvt?L nrSA+ TFF?E i Ss N o OF 7fWg AcTr m v hhSZaO use/ A< AEL??a 4+v ? Mr.UM/WA&V oFst77vrv Mori oA/ . /T' / S T/t/o:EF02E 77AE C "I<n LC-Cv/ct? /ZESp?AtSi 61 LJ 7+/ 7-0 RGrvs 774-T 6=_:' ?rc2v/ o SVJULY?9.YS iFT1fRt' j6`i fF= cAS<?- %1 !r '3 41-41 n -r7 PiL_ i S J1zgZ?r,u Af OV/K"6 :tea= c4xm7-Ta 2E-/.us'Y71-T1=' "rot sf,Qv,zg,7 4{ . G oNTR/t/ Y' Tv Y-r/E 577¢7E?i>=^tT v c Q1;=/1 6&F25V1VV%d7-k P1ZEij M1 tvAAY @B" C"ri mM5 unrdE,*- IJc1nnAFJ2 FouRCy3,GLk/nir7FF Gl-E5PCnLY S77f7'ES IA/ 7-fE LAST SEN?CE of TKr oAe&iAMf- COMOCh/NT 70 71415 Acti Q 1.1 cAU oeJL N o.v1 774AT I>EFJrDA r? •...... /N l<JS rJ1la1 t!!h(l tL c"AL/rY colrfm trrm> ACTS ANA OFFt:NSA25' AGAllv57- ",L"r-F..!` n<o wfFeE?/LE &-(-sm l` rl*E coJ4t,LArnlr Aor_-sAT snt-rt= o7WiEX 1,5E. S. pLAf mm opC Zvi praT' .<-iJow /J &9c25LrL?AJW3 AApQESS, J•uCY Trfr= P theE aF4x ?M®LOYF1 01kCrlN0CEAE77fEC014,Jt /A 66 0vC'*C7"S.4AMA @19 cc YSS iFMKPtAeF, 7'A M; z5 ur-- /SAMArM e 00C.-3 JAiciAe /2j; & PvNT,,,q &rc/ s e 4 ACoREST? Y- (?cxOD?l 642? n. OA , I aq.%) -7 9 7 F S'UM. n' Q4 4 6.. raPEUbXMT 1S NOT SLAB ASAAI J-.-!'N PLOYS OiF S C l C -MAH,r.c DrIL SE . i avdca rA&5 AEnr/ctSYLrl,?vrA4 POL,rrcA•L -CUAAi vision! 'TO/r CLAIM AcT f 42-60A•G SA 4 P351 gR! A r A r)4= Av EMPLOY2e Qc An! A46;?MCY E77--. CAAS 66=- SUEE /At r# & 1At6ivinc1AL. CslOAc/7Y Amt3 5E2r/cE O? Su^Aowo„cr ,s a",acl2 v1`SYi 17-M %OR•>"LAv%c OROCE2NUAoENtr/FS Cil-c-- A60VEt. AAIA17-1,=??- Poe-Se, /_5 /u©T• /:S.7ur/?.?2iYLA-1r?tT0 SE?vC- ?v/?7' n?o2T/l,?A?t'ik?i?c?/ CF?tIOU! os ? rSU WA40nis . AA,17% rA,-.EAV,4'E CA}wct 0-7- /_iE 4&WAfez9!S6 /3! N Fog sug:'A6' 6 upaAv A%e A-4 a4MS De1=15CV o14- sC14-H 3'aFlevX?1SE: . 7, : • A-41AMP F/L&O I-M4S7 COMPLh/ILC7- A-S A Sc??tz,wt! fditN`r U&P.EW OS-1VMSYL?i44WIA &L/770t(- SUA0i %JISiCKt 7-0&r C:L4lrN Acr.1 f 1 P14, L" CA SGC. S-.SSO Wu '4i NdIC-OALA /r:, , Antb /73 PR?L DtmL?s, 14 o vtA i-C 7l"'tI?E GfJCL/tT ^qSeaF7/-C Yb c zxW-ECA' T"L? A4-LL?6PC'f'CQnLS CA Mf4 77fc-- A-rro21vzrY Cdr%tEmf1s ojilrCE i c.• 2cyjct'Ro,cc'7? S?YL?![c o?Su K Vtsrts oi. TtPcS C O1KPLA4/"-T-. AAx-6 7Z ),4e-404,1 P/ZowiRr ?/Loc_r?u?? Ta ??/'?t1 ?E ter. ALAtAerv/- TD Aeaocapr nDTxA-e-?'T? L lz?o?r, ALAI Arn A: At -rAez?tLY /es2 Limn- TEFAr- -rhKs f- OIVORAALa< G6Uf'r GGl¢QECT 77,-A ALL€GE2?S E_/{A& • a,C .4F7'LVCGjl- E)F- SCLALAAd,VA&S "AM L72WS' IfC77t31V , A^,re) A'F"DVtc- ACA/ovTiFF TO PAPO.- A 5 ,TUrt1SBIcr7bvdL L?F rn4nn- : v nrC©citL A-esz=-XfCM E,?r /?Li>?EE LOSBES 7WZ--(t /KMUKITY dE?$LS tr , F rc* s? Atl70NCS 0-C.")ArS`r7TV7-A-= AC7Z1stL ,?iCA4UL>: ,4Grv.fL -i r+LlcE. orL wt",cuL Mise4K.rAcAC ' /J4-F24v/liC v MiilLtcf{, G,/PAI.,Ld //5/S", ,Sa AA. cmwL'r4, lLLcA4u L-r!. q q 9?...... , r s ^E7jSem ( emt> rLy ,AI A - ce>u r-op LAtw, • CG (J-1). Z LIO-E2,ELSY C rIR77,c y 9r-ACA-7-Z 1%-A4 r44 S /JAY s 95-"A / n!G iE "101 (D/= r'4-FiE-- F077-,erC0/,t" A0c1w,,.tAma •Tri ALL O?XsoctS A AAA -,Lt rt /-l A,i i vE 2 IA16i c_AI"E/J /UaLcx,n S ?2v/c? i t A-be_ J2)Y Gi2si class et'1 , ?? t7/L?sS?!>Lcl S 45 AA /? . Cu 2Yf S La)cCG, PAOT9a),v.¢ 7*#-Y oGF/ C?- OA^ T7-FE ea=-Vl< C_u,uRc2l.?k-u? L'txlntrs Coc?n`TJ-k?t1s? / COURY7-(orLSE. SQI1?6P?' L?t2usL?-' ?A . / 7e7/ 3 A4 , ,4YlbkAfM--e 6? t?'rtLs Ct cOE- Tb/tn: LT176A77cx? SEG'770f o' /,5-7-,4 G16."C"_?2. 5MALV AMiNt y&LjA2i7=- /`f1Fi?1?rS"I3CJA'G, PA• /712C) 66:K 4 q 4 9FSc(7-3 ,iZ_ 4o-a, A is-L1rs-c)-©qv4 fc C- ? ^? 0 C7 r t? -- _ ?- JJ co 1S 4AMC-,o rllt Ki= t3U r.?? ' I'e'?i ar?e? vs -? • L? , S7 1 GERyJ?1(T T E OE R _ yy PA,?D -JTCf4L Si1Bl7 ?ti? To f2T C ?-1 N`S Case NA) O_ 3-3116 ; v3-31 t b o3-.ctrl Statement of Intention to Proceed To the Court: intends to proceed with the above captioned matter. u[ i 3 pal 1+?7 Print Name T-s m,lg Buwb)JSign Nam =-M,Z3ANr. ?? a?wby t,^ :s e6N5 Date: aG ob?r ago1 Attorney for ?c5ht,4XC t3 f)Uk,.lr bu N by Explanatory Comment The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania has promulgated new Rule of Civil Procedure 230.2 governing the termination of inactive cases and amended Rule of Judicial Administration 1901. Two aspects of the recommendation merit comment. 1. Rule of civil Procedure New Rule of Civil Procedure 230.2 has been promulgated to govern the termination of inactive cases within the scope of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. The termination of these cases for inactivity was previously governed by Rule of Judicial Administration 1901 and local rules promulgated pursuant to it. New Rule 230.2 is tailored to the needs of civil actions. It provides a complete procedure and a uniform statewide practice, preempting local rules. This rule was promulgated in response to the decision of the Supreme Court in Shop v. Eagle, 551 Pa. 360,710 A.2d 1104 (1998) in which the court held that "prejudice to the defendant as a result of delay in prosecution is required before a case may be dismissed pursuant to local rules implementing Rule of Judicial Administration 1901." Rule of Judicial Administration 1901(b) has been amended to accommodate the new rule of civil procedure. The general policy of the prompt disposition of matters set forth in subdivision (a) of that rule continues to be applicable. II Inactive Cases The purpose of Rule 230.2 is to eliminate inactive cases from the judicial system. The process is initiated by the court. After giving notice of intent to terminate an action for inactivity, the course of the procedure is with the parties. If the parties do not wish to pursue the case, they will take no action and "the Prothonotary shall enter an order as of course terminating the matter with prejudice for failure to prosecute." If a party wishes to pursue the matter, he or she will file a notice of intention to proceed and the action shall continue. a. Where the action has been terminated If the action is terminated when a party believes that it should not have been terminated, that party may proceed under Rule230(d) for relief from the order of termination. An example of such an occurrence might be the termination of a viable action when the aggrieved party did not receive the notice of intent to terminate and thus did not timely file the notice of intention to proceed. The timing of the filing of the petition to reinstate the action is important. If the petition is filed within thirty days of the entry of the order of termination on the docket, subdivision (d)(2) provides that the court must grant the petition and reinstate the action. If the petition is filed later than the thirty-day period, subdivision (d)(3) requires that the plaintiff must make a show in to the court that the petition was promptly filed and that there is a reasonable explanation or legitimate excuse both for the failure to file the notice of intention to proceed prior to the entry of the order of termination on the docket and for the failure to file the petition within the thirty-day period under subdivision (d)(2). B. Where the action has not been terminated An action which has not been terminated but which continues upon the filing of a notice of intention to proceed may have been the subject of inordinate delay. In such an instance, the aggrieved party may pursue the remedy of a common law non pros which exits independently of termination under Rule 230.2. I . a PA/Zri Gs Guri,s i? • onq C*me5 r,o,? . f?1icanA?? [July`)/3ec1-4rBdparl,.x., /rQ???"?l1'y ..C r- + ??.r ?"I +rr ?? a / c.?v i 7'?t oa/?' Id r e,J •f/ ?,C.G rA.s r/7 a & Rvid. ?4 f /I) Av?T vF Tit urn,/ Cja, gf a h.?v . :wA,i A", , d o-srsrG,/nrsr-4• 4aH cam` f?rr Z4a w_,L ?..,..Lf'f ciC or$ S frr? G? j,? 1T$r '0 odt ?7 i?Csf 46 T r evAA,•eS I?.eru.IfA' i de / A iS 411 I c O r dc. a5 t 5 /ie.a'l li?K,9 he 4),r to 1?4 P C' ,.?,•.oh /?/.?c?S rl;)LX. ?" O /' e",,.t htr/A A4. Al C.o ur, )?( 440 3 -- YI17 t1 ??/ 9 9i hoe- i tF forfr veS o f ,4t aYd ro s /°- 0 • /Sa Ic L. a b,e/(e. , OA • J -f t.i 5-v -- C 94 9 . . G? o e crh a v f S c p 't.•r ? ?v . ?'' 7 u :- >Li ?s ?i -c r-Zr,? r a.?. t? fwf W QYQ r,At" ? ?e ?;x i-C, ? of 1 d r?.7.?-rs= r ?.??vl ? 3 ?(?1'1 ,a .:a 14 y a ? a Lam/ Zif /.toyi c.t 7OV07t At / )td Oe A, rlrvy.s era C a s.t # ?spT - 3 /.) ; O3/`3N6 ,' a -Z (2 3 '51/7 wog-`iAlGlc!.lst ?ie t. 4,,-~&rl go/ llo d?it-s;sHs loJ^l-3G wjor- A t..&Aa, _ o t A 111, ?t ufr ! / /v W., "er Dc ,emu, /40 .1).Q . !7 r/ / ."f t.?. G s 1 t'Jrt o ??d rv S c•u fi i c /'1 7e4 2 1--r' IW44Pr s11 PPfe Ira- r- e?e 1/e dr ?4'A4 9 At o,,>7 e e s Aoh S,?e- q, T? ?s r`esDe?'+5t r s `i Cast 'A/npp Y.t f, ,. c.u /? ,e .ur /i ??,? ?r CD M S. I A is rP5/IaJ? 51. ? /? +r?- , ? Y 3 alp .0. d , 9 -/,nr r?vr - 3 v o'*e 6 f Y /f Al S !rr lei If ? ar j&c ?t,?,h a ?? r?o C 4-0-4- X ew ! N ?? 0..•. d 1o iM t- i'/ t-. U tI P Y tc,-,C-p..s S, r2-e- !Jf i..7 c)o - 9 or* 9` `y / c...? 5 r1c?,r !? y ?,?!' 1?t t? / ?? $ y?r a ??y a iar,.? i a Cas e...s ye?c - 1?/grQr; PC t ttl t. / raw s hra .a .e 00 MaX? a•.• ? t (AlAo " 7 I? i5 i H 3 ?r• u .,-+ ?.., ?' ,r?? S ? i ? ,",? G s ? ??t,?1rt.? l? c.s?r ?vr+???'J,?sp/t ??- ?? S N- i,t ,4+ x. K (,t G G 3 ~ l { • A., • ? rT ?"? s /I 0 i-?, n D.;+oV ?- S Phi 1 Q ?'1` a tt d 4t /! v? T,J/1.jme?A G $.. C r a t r '? 2- ft d ry v N I r1 /r+ 4 t G,+?L es TI+ C.?n 1??LrTt g rr G.I /%N d > c.c`r?Cesi4.=.td va?tR s w n 1?ac e-1 ?-?-c •? s?.e 3 7?',f' , S Gf r?•t #,V 0 f ? 4-4 )'-t C h i rater- ?-u?/ d/ s c/,.> 5-Lo r4,r o ??fl?o7? vadGr /, ere.o?rtn u 6 ova. • ? / ?° K/, m i s A wo ? e o/ 74,t S /.sr+? T /? Ic? .+ d tl G S ! ?.t N t?, 'v- ervt? 700 / 0 3.t=o D QD3 M13/7"o Our' ,s /<• L ai?' ca?f4I j/ C v rs..,had G.. / Cv L/ m f-V 194 v rI ?'.l c 1,jt t / c? Oj A-P)o7 .6 1'6,x f +W !Z r z . ,j jAj a a j t3 ti i d J Sweat a,,fd a l'T! rnn iV t.f' /,A4 A v ro , r? 0 ac f Touc an Co c . C-t ase'd oA -.9 P-ersamR Yraw/else su-ijar'k- ,sdo.rt-, Q?vyor. ?, !s1 r cv ?n 7f'.7 a =,7?or.?+"? S .ice PA, G..S. q#av A.rd SVl?sect,.A /d.L W:ft.u or 6j pct 13 i'A1d07 2c+ rd, sue/ 2!' t /?',.1°y-`.21?5???tY? ?+?' .(r??/C{`?'.?? i? t/li/1,5?f/115L+t?? CC. C 12. ?. Prk `? 5le %A V 3--?qp ttt L.1rTJS r Ld Ng ?A,ro A004 p? r9 t. o"ruoh IBS cawrt CumderlaKd ny Cot Aousf- N L Cccs? 5s u a?? La rliste- PA;, t -7 3 -"sA6otwa A'fiKL6 kti &Y Aff Al fai4,wrf rYvd , 4r-, VLr {rte k v /ft ©A < ! 1 A Sr Ac*- Ioo7 ear Lu r?rS /Q? Lo.+? AoA o ;,ta4 ryr ;: CJo se-d h erewi M f i it d- "'.,K y "r-,(CF- To Pf?o crceI?, ? "Oe??n?+Q fiver c QPoo1 Cast Pt u 0,/?Y w r? ? 5? cJ'I.A-d A Ac'/- r o ? rnu7-?--f . ? ? 4.•t-r ? ?r u er r rt y -?h? ?if rM ?' /?/7? G t ?f ?"'O ?•?? ? 1 ?? aw Mt C &Vee ALA.: Cases-. ?1 n 3i c5u /a/ A y/ 5 cs:)A S A r 7`1?1e4L4^ Z-P-/ AY Lk„n tl Q d JA e r Za Czz f ?o.aS L4 H A own AIJJ n. , A" 4t 1 ? r ?? h s??ro aC?d ?0l ? s L. Pvm,,%cA1* r'm 4 t^04 WA- b y la ?•?- t.", a 0 ri J c?-?.e? /? o w /V O ?4, CO lie' - 41:- 7q Q n A-L l' Xall L- Tr T e e. Ale.- CD T_-n -) t1r- ice,.. cn W