HomeMy WebLinkAbout03-3385JULIE ARMAND, INDIVIDUALLY
AND AS LEGAL TUTRIX OF THE
MINOR CHILD, HARRY LANCLOS, III
VERSUS
USAA CASUALTY INSURANCE
COMPANY and GEORGE S.
BOURGEOIS, JR.
27TM JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT
DOCKET NO.: 02-0-1046-0
ST. LANDRY PARISH, LOUISIANA
PETITION FOR LETTERS ROGATORY II
The petition of United Services Automobile Association, defendant in
the above numbered and captioned matter, with respect represent that:
1.
Highmark Blue Shield, as insurer of Harry Lanclos, III on whose behalf a
claim has been brought in the above referenced matter by his mother, plaintiff,
Julie Martin Armand, has information which is relevant to the above captioned
matter.
2.
Highmark Blue Shield has an office in Camp Hill, Pennsylvania which
contains medical records regarding Harry Lanclos, III.
3.
The deposition of, Highmark Blue Shield through its corporate
representative(s) and human resource records custodian, has been noticed for
Monday, July 21, 2003 at 10:00 a.m., for the production of records on the
attached Notice of 1442 Deposition.
WHEREFORE, defendant, United Services Automobile Association,
prays that Letters Rogatory be issued to the appropriate authority in the County of
Cumberland, Pennsylvania, commissioning him/her to require the appearance of
corporate representative(s) of Highmark Blue Shield through its custodian of
records to produce certified copies of the records listed on the attached Notice of
1442 Deposition, in this cause.
Respectfully submitted:
SWIFT & RHOADES
RHOADES (Bar #1557)
930 Coolidge Boulevard
Post Office Box 53107
Lafayette, Louisiana 70505
(337) 572-9877
A'I-rORNEY FOR DEFENDANTS
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a copy of the above and foregoing has this day
been forwarded to all known counsel of record by depositing same in the United
States Mail, postage prepaid and properly addressed.
Lafayette, Louisiana, this _~/'day of ~ ,2003.
JEFFR A~. RHOADES
JULIE ARMAND, INDIVIDUALLY
AND AS LEGAL TUTRIX OF THE
MINOR CHILD, HARRY LANCLOS, III
27TM JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT
VERSUS
DOCKET NO.: 02-C-1046-C
USAA CASUALTY INSURANCE S~LANDRYPARISH, LOUISIANA
COMPANYand GEORGES.
BOURGEOIS, JR.
LE'I'FERS ROGATORY
TO:
Cumberland County District Court
Prothonotary's Office
1 Courthouse Square
Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013
in the 27"~ Judicial Court for the Parish of St. Landry, State of Louisiana,
there is pending a case entitled Julie Armand, Individually and as Legal Tutrix
of the Minor Child, Harry Lanclos, III v. USAA Casualty Insurance Company
and George S. Bourgeois, Jr., Docket No.: 02-C-1046-C, and it appears to this
Court that the just determination of the issues therein presented requires records
be provided from the Custodian of Human Resources of Highmark Blue Shield
whose business address is 1800 Center Street 1AL4, Camp Hill, Pennsylvania
17089.
It is therefore requested that in order to assist this Court and to serve the
interest of justice, you cause the foregoing witness to be served with a valid
subpoena duces tecum through a competent officer authorized by you, requiring
that the Human Resource Records Custodian of Highmark Blue Shield appear
and produce certified copies of the documents as outlined in the attached Notice
of 1442 Deposition on Monday July 21, 2003, at 10:00 a.m., as filed with this
Court, or as soon thereafter as practical.
It is requested that you cause these documents to be returned to counsel
for the defendant United Services Automobile Association, Jeffrey A. Rhoades,
Swift & Rhoades, 930 Coolidge Boulevard, Post Office Box 53107, Lafayette,
Louisiana 70503.
This Court is ready and willing to extend the same courtesies to you in a
similar case when required.
Lafayette, Louisiana, this 3 day of~_~, 2003.
St. Landry~a,~sh ,.,,,~r~, of C.,tJ,~ o Office
~ ' D.~.~. lerk
JULIE ARMAND, INDIVIDUALLY
AND AS LEGAL TUTRIX OF THE
MINOR CHILD, HARRY LANCLOS, III
VERSUS
USAA CASUALTY INSURANCE
COMPANY and GEORGE S.
BOURGEOIS, JR.
27T' JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT
DOCKET NO.: 02-C-1046-C
ST. LANDRY PARISH, LOUISIANA
I ORDER II
Considering the foregoing Petition for Letters Rogatory:
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the defendant's Petition for Letters Rogatory be and
is hereby granted and that the Letters Rogatory, Notice of 1442 Deposition, and Subpoena
Duces Tecum be transmitted directly to the appropriate authority of Cumberland County
District Court, Prothonota~/s Office, 1 Court House Square, Carlisle, Pennsylvania, 17013
SIGNED this '*o~0
__day of "~'~/~y , 2003, at ~)~,· ~ Louisiana.
JULIE ARMAND, INDIVIDUALLY
AND AS LEGAL TUTRIX OF THE
MINOR CHILD, HARRY LANCLOS, III
27TM JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT
VERSUS
DOCKET NO.: 02-C-1046-C
USAA CASUALTY INSURANCE S%LANDRY PARISH, LOUISIANA
COMPANYandGEORGES.
BOURGEOIS, JR.
NOTICE OF 1442 DEPOSITION
TO:
JULIE ARMAND, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS LEGAL TUTRIX OF
HARRY LANCLOS, III
Through their attorney of record
G. Douglas Dean
504 S. Main Street
P. O. Drawer 280
Opelousas, Louisiana 70571-0272
YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED that UNITED SERVICES AUTOMOBILE
ASSOCIATION (USAA), defendant herein, through undersigned counsel, will take the
testimony on oral examination of the following persons, pursuant to Rule 1448 of the
Louisiana Code of Civil Procedure, before a duly authorized officer, on the day and the
time and location indicated below, and continuing thereafter from day to day until the
taking of said deposition may be adjourned at which time and place you are hereby
invited to attend and take such part as you may deem fit and proper.
Highmark Blue Shield
Claims Department
1800 Center Street, 1AL4
Camphill, Pennsylvania 17089
Monday
July 21, 2003
@ 10:00 a.m.
Swift & Rhoades
930 Coolidge Boulevard
Post Office Box 53107
Lafayette, LA 70505
RE:
Policy Holder: Julie Martin Armand
Group # 028835-000
Policy # ZAR435294698
Copies of your entire medical claim records on Harry Lanclos, III (DOB:
7/9/85; SSl/433 61 5229), including, but not limited to, all notes,
correspondence, narrative reports, test results, hospital records, lab
results, patient admission sheets, discharge summaries, consultation
reports, physical therapist reports, billing records, progress notes,
handwritten notes, nurses' notes, records of prescriptions, patient orders,
emergency room records, insurance claim forms, correspondence sent or
received by you relating to Harry Lanclos, III and any and all documents
listing or summarizing claims made and paid, and any and all other
records compiled by you or in your possession pertaining directly or
indirectly to the above-named claimant.
NOTE: THIS IS A RETURN ON DUCES TECUM ONLY:
NO ORAL TESTIMONY IS REQUIRED IF DOCUMENTS ARE PRODUCED
I hereby certify that a copy of the above and foregoing has this day been
forwarded to all known counsel of record by depositing same in the United States Mail,
postage prepaid and properly addres..se~
Lafayette. Louisiana, this ~ day of "~/),,~- ,2003.
JEFFRA.~RHOADES
JULIE ARMAND, INDIVIDUALLY
AND AS LEGAL TUTRIX OF THE
MINOR CHILD, HARRY LANCLOS, III
VERSUS
USAA CASUALTY INSURANCE
COMPANYand GEORGES.
BOURGEOIS, JR.
27TM JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT
DOCKET NO.: 02-C-1046-C
ST. LANDRY PARISH, LOUISIANA
STATE OF LOUISIANA
PARISH OF LAFAYETTE
AFFIDAVIT
BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, Notary Public in and for the
aforesaid parish and state, did personally come and appear:
Jeffrey A. Rhoade$
who after being duly sworn, did say unto me:
That he is the attorney of record for USAA, defendant in the above captioned
suit. That he does hereby certify that the subpoena request to Highmark Blue Shield is for
medical records relating to the plaintiff in this case. That a copy of the Letters Rogatory,
deposition notice and subpoena request we re sent by certified mail to counsel representing
the plaintiff by certified mail on June 27, 2003.
WITNESSES:
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me on
~-¢..,vy_ ,2003, Lafayette,
in
Louisiana.
JenA. Rhoades
Attorney for USAA
this__ ~''7 day of
CUMBERLAND COUNTY DISTRICT COURT
STATE OF PENNSYLVANIA
JULIE ARMAND, INDIVIDUALLY
AND AS LEGAL TUTRIX OF THE
MINOR CHILD, HARRY LANCLOS, III
VERSUS
27TM JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT
DOCKET NO.: 02-C-1046-C
USAA CASUALTY INSURANCE ST. LANDRY PARISH, LOUISIANA
COMPANY and GEORGE S.
BOURGEOIS, JR.
SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM
TO:
RECORDS CUSTODIAN - CLAIMS DEPARTMENT
Highmark Blue Shield
1800 Center Street, 1AL4
Camphill, Pennsylvania 17089
YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED in the name of the State of Pennsylvania
and of this Honorable Court to provide via U. S. Mail. certified copies of the following
documents, papers and/or records:
RE:
Policy Holder: Julie Martin Armand
Group # 028835-000
Policy # ZAR435294698
Copies of your entire medical claim records on Hetty Lan¢los, III (DOB:
7/~/85; $$# 455 81 $228), including, but not limited to, all notes,
correspondence, narrative reports, test results, hospital records, lab
results, patient admission sheets, discharge summaries, consultation
reports, physical therapist reports, billing records, progress notes,
handwritten notes, nurses' notes, records of prescriptions, patient orders,
emergency room records, insurance claim forms, correspondence sent or
received by you relating to Harry I.~n¢los, III and any and all documents
listing or summarizing claims made and paid, and any and all other
records compiled by you or in your possession pertaining directly or
indirectly to the above-named claimant.
On:
Monday July 21, 2003 AT 10:00 A.M.
at the offices of:
SWIFT & RHOADES
930 Coolidge Boulevard
Post Office Box 53107
Lafayette, Louisiana 70505
(337) 572-9877
NOTE: THIS IS A RETURN ON DUCES TECUM ONLY:
NO ORAL TESTIMONY IS REQUIRED IF DOCUMENTS ARE PRODUCED
E!LE Na.559 07/15 '03 13:59
ID:Swift ~ Rhoades
FAX:33? 5?2 9?37
CUMBERLAND COUNTY DISTRICT COURT
STATE OF PENNSYLVANIA
PAGE 3
'-. JUL 1 5 003
JULIE ARMAND, INDIVIDUALLY
AND A8 LEGAL TUTRIX OF THE
MINOR CHILD, HARRY LANCLOS, III
VERSUS
USAA CASUALTY INSURANCE
COMPANY end GEORGE S.
BOURGEOIS, JR.
27TM JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT
DOCKET NO.: 02-C-1046-C
ST. LANDRY PARISH, LOUISIANA
ORDER
CONSIDERING THE FOREGOING Application to Take Deposition of Hlghmark
Blue Shield;
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that defendant's Application be and is hereby granted
and defendant Is authorized to taka the 1442 Deposition of Highmark Blue Shield and
the Clerk of this Court is hereby authorized and directed to issue e subpoena to the
following:
RECORDS CUSTODIAN - CLAIMS DEPARTMENT
Hlghmark Blue Shield
1800 Center Street, '1 AL4
Camphill, Pennsylvania 17089
and a subpoena duces tecum to produce at the aforesaid deposition the originals of the
following records:
RE: Policy Holder, Julia Martin Armand
Group # 028835-000
Policy # ZAR435294698
~IL~ N9.559 07/15 '03 14:00 ID:Swift E Rhoade$ FAX:337 572 9737 PRGE 4
2003,
Copies of your entire medical claim records on Harry Lancloe, III (DOB:
7/9/85; SS# 433 81 5229), Including, but not limited to, all notes,
correspondence, nerratlve reports, test results, hospital records, lab
results, patient admission sheets, discharge summaries, consultation
reports, physical therapist reports, billing records, progress notes,
handwritten notes, nurses' notes, records of prescriptions, patient orders,
emergency room records, Insurance claim forms, correspondence sent or
received by you relating to Harry Lencloe, III and any and all documents
listing or summarizing claims made end paid, and any and all other
records compiled by you or in your possession pertaining directly or
indirectly to the ebove-nemed claimant.
_~~ , P. nrtsylveni', this~--~day °f ~'
SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULJtR
CASE NO: 2003-03385 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
ARMAND JULIE ET AL
VS
USAA CASUALTY INSUPJkNCE CO ET
SHAWN HARRISON ,
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania,
says, the within SUBPOENA
Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of
who being duly sworn according to law,
was served upon
HIGHMARK BLUE SHIELD RECORDS CUSTODIAN-CLAIMS DEPT
WITNESS , at 1615:00 HOURS, on the 16th day of
at 1800 CENTER STREET 1AL4
CAMP HILL, PA 17011
SALLY MCCOY, PARALEGAL,
a true and attested copy of SUBPOENA
the
July , 2003
by handing to
ADULT IN CHARGE
together with
and at the same time directing Her attention to the contents thereof.
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing 18.00
Service 10.35
Affidavit .00
Surcharge 10.00
.00
38.35
Sworn and Subscribed to before
me this ~ day of
notary
So Answers:
R. Thomas Kline
07/17/2003
swiFT RHO S/ LP
By:
/Z-~De~u~ S~eriff