HomeMy WebLinkAbout03-6368IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
STEVEN E. RATHGEBER and
GRACE D. RATHGEBER, as Parents
And Natural Guardians of
STEPHANIE E. RATHGEBER, a minor
vs.
JEAN TAYLOR
Claremont Nursing Home
A Wing
1000 Claremont Road
Carlisle, PA 17013
and
JOHN M. WHITTEN
630 Conodoguinet Avenue
Carlisle, PA 17013
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 2003-~- & 3~' ~-~
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRAECIPE FOR WRIT OF SUMMONS
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
Issue Writ of Summons in the above-captioned matter.
X
Writ of Summons shall be issued and forwarded to
Attorney/Sheriff.
Date: December ~, 2003
GRIEST, ~~0~UMANN LLP
By: /~~- ~
Christopher A. Ferro, Esquire
Sup. Ct. I.D. No. 85057
129 East Market Street
York PA 17401
(717) 846-8856
Attorney for Plaintiffs
SUMMONS IN CIVIL ACTION
TO: JEAN TAYLOR and JOHN M. WHITTEN
YOU ARE HEREBY
COMMENCED AN ACTION AGAINST YOU.
Date: ~ ~ 2003
NOTIFIED THAT THE ABOVE-NAMED PLAINTIFF (S) HAS/HAVE
Prot[/on~tary/~I~k,~vi 1
by:
Deputy
Division
SHERIFF'S RETURN -
CASE NO: 2003-06368 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLJtND
RATHGEBER STEVEN E ET AL
VS
TAYLOR JEAN ET AL
REGULAR
CPL. MICHAEL BARRICK
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania,
Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of
who being duly sworn according to law,
was served upon
the
llth day of December ,
by handing to
together with
says, the within WRIT OF SUMMONS
WHITTEN JOHN M
DEFENDANT at 1336:00 HOURS, on the
at 630 CONODOGUINET AVENUE
CARLISLE, PA 17013
JOHN M WHITTEN
a true and attested copy of WRIT OF SUMMONS
2003
and at the same time directing His attention to the contents thereof.
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing 6.00
Service .00
Affidavit .00
Surcharge 10.00
.00
16.00
Sworn and Subscribed to before
me .this ~ day of
So Answers:
R. Thomas Kline
12/12/2003 ,'7 /~
GRIEST HIMES HER~//~2~IAU~
Deputy Sheriff
SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR
CASE NO: 2003-06368 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
RATHGEBER STEVEN E ET AL
VS
TAYLOR JEAN ET AL
CPL. MICHAEL BARRICK
Cumberland County,Pennsylvania,
Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of
who being duly sworn according to law,
was served upon
the
on the llth day of December ,
by handing to
POA FOR JE~2q TAYLOR
WRIT OF SUMMONS together with
says, the within WRIT OF SUMMONS
TAYLOR JEAN
DEFENDANT at 1330:00 HOURS,
at 630 CONODOGUINET AVENUE
CARLISLE, PA 17013
JOHN M WHITTEN, HUSB OF TERRI WHITTEN,
a true and attested copy of
2003
and at the same time directing His attention to the
Additional Comments
NURSING HOME REQUESTED THAT TAYLOR'S POA BE SERVED.
contents thereof.
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing 18.00
Service 3.45
Affidavit .00
Surcharge 10.00
.00
31.45
Sworn and Subscribed to before
oth~: ' '
oth~no~ary ~
So Answers:
R. Thomas Kline
12/12/2003
GRIEST HIMES ~~~/~ ~-~
Deputy Sheriff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
STEVEN E. RATHGEBER and
GRACE D. RATHGEBER, as Parents
and Natural Guardians of
STEPHANIE E. RATHGEBER, a Minor
VS.
JEAN TAYLOR and
JOHN M. WHITTEN
No. 2003- 6368 Civil Term
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PETITION FOR APPROVAL OF A MINOR SEI-rLEMENT
AND NOW, to wit, this day of October, 2004, come the Petitioners,
Steven E. Rathgeber and Grace D. Rathgeber, parents and natural guardians of
Stephanie E. Rathgeber, a minor child, by their attorneys, Griest, Himes, Herrold,
Schaumann, LLP, by Christopher A. Ferro, Esquire, and file their Petition for
Approval of a Minor Settlement as follows:
1. Petitioners, Steven E. Rathgeber and Grace D. Rathgeber, are adult
individuals residing at 4 Edward Court, Ortanna, Pennsylvania 17353.
2. Stephanie E. Rathgeber, date of birth, August 9, 1996, is a minor child
residing with her parents and natural guardians, the Petitioners above.
3. Defendant, Jean Taylor, is an adult individual residing at Claremont
Nursing Home, 1000 Claremont Road, Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013.
4. Defendant, John M. Whitten, is an adult individual residing at 630
Conodoguinet Avenue, Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013.
5. On or about December 26, 2001, the minor Plaintiff was visiting her
grandmother's home located on Conodoguinet Avenue in North Middleton Township,
Carlisle, Pennsylvania.
6. While on her grandmother's property, the minor Plaintiff was attacked
by a dog cared for by Defendant, Taylor.
7. As a result of the attack, the minor Plaintiff received facial wounds and
lacerations to her face and head.
8. Immediately following the attack, the minor Plaintiff was treated at
Carlisle Regional Medical Center. A copy of the. hospital notes for the treatment the
minor Plaintiff received in the emergency room of the Carlisle Regional Medical
Center are attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibit "A".
9. After her emergency treatment at Carlisle Regional Medical Center, the
minor Plaintiff received follow-up treatment and plastic surgery evaluation from Dr.
Paul Manson of the Johns Hopkins Medical Center. A copy of Dr. Manson's clinic
notes for his treatment of the minor Plaintiff on February 13, 2002, May 15, 2002,
and November 6, 2002, are collectively attached hereto and incorporated herein as
Exhibit "B".
10. On November 6, 2002, Dr. Manson reported that the only permanent
scar on the minor Plaintiff's face is the one on her nose. Dr. Manson also indicated
that the minor Plaintiff's "improvement is sufficient that one could not offer her any
additional improvement by further surgery." SeE; Exhibit "B".
11. All of the medical expenses relative to the foregoing treatment have
been paid by the Defendant's insurance coverage.
12. A Writ of Summons was filed on December 9, 2003.
13. The Writ of Summons was served on the Defendants by the
Cumberland County Sheriff's Department on or about December 19, 2003.
14. The Defendants, through their insurance carrier, Evercash Mutual,
have proposed a settlement in the above-referenced matter whereby Defendants,
through Evercash Mutual, would pay the Petitioners the sum of Twelve Thousand
($12,000.00) Dollars.
15. Your Petitioners and counsel for the Petitioners recommend the
approval of the settlement with the insurance carrier for the Defendants on behalf of
the minor Plaintiff in the total sum of Twelve Thousand ($12,000.00) Dollars because
they consider it fair and reasonable and believe that it adequately compensates the
Plaintiff for the injuries sustained on December 26, 2001.
16. A copy of the proposed Order distributing the proceeds of the above-
referenced settlement is attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "C".
WHEREFORE, Petitioners move this Honorable Court to enter an Order
approving the compromised settlement and Order a distribution in accordance with
the proposed Order of Distribution attached hereto and incorporated herein.
IRespectfully submitted,
GRIEST, HIMES, HERROLD,
SCHAUMANN, LLP
IBY:~
Chr~ A: Ferro, Esquire
PA85057
129 East Market Street
York PA 17401
(717) 846-8856
FAX: (717) 845-3330
Cferro@ GHHSLaw.com
VERIFICATION
We, STEVEN E. RATHGEBER and GRACE D. RATHGEBER, hereby
verify that the facts set forth in the foregoing document are true and correct to the best
of our knowledge, information, and belief. We understand that false statements herein
are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. Sec. 4904, relating to unsworn fal-
sification to authorities.
Date: I0/~' ¢/o ~/
Steven E. Rathgeber
Grace ~ Rathgeb~r
Apr,j5. 2'003 11i25A1~ No,5498 P, 40/49
~,~,. ~,,,~,^ ,,o,~ ~,:7~.~.~,~ ..:.~:.i~:~:~::~!~:~.:.~'~...
......tit': ~~'.~.~.~.~.~:~?~,:~?':~: 777- 77 - 7777 CHILD
~ US .. (410) 836-8%82 FATHER
~TH~BB~2, SHIRLEY (717) 243-8830 G-MOT~ER
DOG ATTAC~D IN THE FAC~ ~v ~ ~RT
......., ............................... ~%~.,..,...,.z~:~ .................. ~ .......... ~ ............... . ..... ~..~.~: ................................................................................
:':::[::::: ~~T~--.,.---._....__~z~,s~c~ ~ ...............................
'?.'Z{:.' 104~S MILL R~ CIRCLE
· ,~',: OWINGS MILLS MD 21117
:::~:';~.:~:'. ( 800 ) 342 - 7287
I
=.....~ ........ ~.~ = ............................. ~ .................
..................... .~. .... ~ ............................... ~
~,,.,.,.~., .~ .............. ~,..~ .. ,,,,, ............... ~ ......................... ·
...................... ~....,~,'~.~ ~=.~,.{~:~5~5~v:z:'='.'~':..':~: - ...........................................................................................................
I
.'
.,:::::,.,:,::]
:~i"j~:~.~'.~::.,, '~ ~' '~'--' ~" ~"~'~"'
./.:.~::~ FALVO, THOMAS NONSTAFF, 0~ 0F TOW~
~I~L
~IT~ OTHER 12/26/200,1_
IIIIlllllllllJl IIIIlllllllllllll co ,¥ IJl llJJJlJJlJJJJJ
Apr.15. ~003 11:29AM
Carlisle Regional Medical Center
No.5498 P. 4]/49
mild ~ 1-10
florl8
~ld / ~amily ~t racoon gewr ~ ....
OTO
Un~b~lnabl~ Due Tot ~L.O~ In--on ~e'~fiS' ~
~:,~n ~ ............ ,~; ~ ~l~i~ ......
C,P. ~;~ DOE PND ;': .....
YES (d~a)
H1M [DDM / NIDDM
none Appy C~oly H)~t~-
Animal / Human Bite. Page 1 of 2
Apr.!5. 200,3 ]l':30A~I N0.5498 P, ~2/49
~ , Carllslo R~gional Modical ¢~nter
EKO: NSR no ~ di~ase IMF. Da: D.T. ,5 cc IM
DIFF $ B L
X-Rayt
I~T/Pi-r: INR: ..... ~ulae ox:
L'=T~: SGOT SGPT RA O2:
UA: ~lG prot EBCa WBC~ AllO:
UCa: + I -
% NL / hyp~
~ human'b~" dog bite
Ot]leC.
Mtb~ ~lulffis
puncture wound
]VF:
I~:~,EY:
I~
S~me
YIN
Pro- MED Maximus
MD/DO
Animal / Human Bite. Page 2 of 2
Apr.lS, 2~0,3 11i30AM No.5498 P, 43/49
Carlisle Regional Medical Center
flap ste~late avulsion
foreign body
digital block } Z.), oc's ~lJ~) 2% lido .5% man,'alne
~ .~T'~r-'-'~7'~_ ~,~T..7"-'--'- ' -'":7.~.._.
........... ,~ubcutaneo~*, .......... # - 0 vl~/~
simple !ntaf~...p~l running mattman horlz / ve~t
. .. fascia / muscle / tendon # - 0 vl=.ryl'
simple inter.m, pted running mat~eas horlz/yen
~...o~ ' ~ .1~,~!~ YIN Other;
~i tendon functl°~"nta= vascular intact
superficlel" subcutaneouS' ' mu~e tendon ~'o~e
linear irregular flap s~late avulsion
~:~ ~' fore~ ~o~
~.hi~,'! Io.~,.. digital ~=g ~ .. 1% lldo 2% lido
w/epi w / btcarb
~l~a~T~-'-~etadlne ' ~JbJclene saline ~'rigation debridamant
,~a'~ skin # - 0 prolene nylo_n..., staples
simple I.n~r~upted runqir)g..._metlmss harlz / vat
~ensaflen intact
,5% marcaine
Dermabond
subcutaneous # ~ 0 vk~ auk
slmRt.e !ntenuptad rennin9 mattress ho~ / vart
fascia / muscle / tendon #
simpl~.interrup~ed running mattre.~s horiz/vett
Other.
Pro-MED Maxlmus
YIN
Oote Jn: 12/2B/01
Carlisle Reg~onm MeO~ca; (;enter
NammRATHGABER, STEPHANIE E 1=~9214741
DOB: 08/09/1996 Age: 5YR$ Sec F MRR0001006832
EDP;FALVO,THOMAS PCP:' NON.STAFF, OUT OF TOWN
CMP
.... D.._~ Same~ (Urine). (Serum)
UA
Bel~ HOG
Lactic Aclcl
s~x~ Cur~r~ x¢ t
wound Cullum
ABG
[] KVO De, vim
r'llv
[] (;ardlsc IV~IW'
~ NIBP Monitor
[] Pulse Ox/meb7
[] Warming/Cc~ling Blanke~ ~i~
~:] Irrigation ONound),
r'i NGT Inser~on
I~ Ur~ary Catheter Insertion
rt Central Une Placement
~ Sp[Ir~ng/lmmobl~zatJon
[] CPR
r~ Endos~olo P~edure
[] Notir~a~n of Pml~r AgenoT(s)
[] L~cera[on Re. Ir
r~ F~g~ ~ocly Removal
E~;r.]5. 2i0~ lli32AM
I~u=w~fD~u,A~(;'MENT No,5498 P. 45/4.9
Carlisle Regional Medical Center
ONGOIN(; NURSIN~ ASSE,~SMENT ~r~ ~THG~;E~ ;TEPH~IE E ~ 9214741
~e: 5Y~ DO~:08~/1996 ;~: F M~:0001006~2
~: 1~26/01 ~P:F~VO,THO~ PCP: ' NON~T~F, OUT OF TOV
Airway Gearenee, Ineffective Communication Impaired Info,on, PoMntJal Self Cam Defl~
~An~y '~Coplng, Ineffe~ve '-~nJury, Potm~ '--"SXIn INegff~' Iml~rment
~erea~ing Pattem~, Ine~ ~'~""Fluid Volume, Aitem~n in ~"~'~o~edge Oef~t ~---'rheught Pr~asses, Impaired
__C~'dlao Oulput, Oeoteased ~Gaa Excflange, Irnpai~ld .~Mo~l~[y Impaired __~ought Pm,'*,.--,,.,/,Jt~mi~m in
Cemfort. Altem~on in ~Hype~em~ia (Fever) ~Hon-Compllanm ~'ri~u; Pen'udon, Ntma~on in
~O'~er Other
[] Pll la~_MOVAL [] Ib~MOBILIZATION I PROPER AUGNMENTi D IMPROV~.NT OF BREATHING
n PAIN CONTROL o MNNTAIN STABLE HOI~TA~I$ 0 r~ ENt/IR~NMENTAL NEEO$
~ DECREASE AN~ETY I [] IR6JNTAIN I iMPROVE CIRCULAllON [] ~ EDUCATIONN. NEED6
...... "--
.. D/C I/mtTuc~ne gt;n to~~/'J~ = Verbalized ',J~demtandln,
0 Treated & Relea~ecl []Admit. ~ t .~o Dr,
...... i-j Ttan~. to D L~t without ~eaf~tent o Left NdA
RelXat mired at __ and given to
..... Pain; SevedtyScall: '~/ _ Dlmprovecl ~Un~llanged ~Wora~
D/C VRaW; T. P, R BP ,. J
Apr,J5. 2'00,3 I1':32AM
. EMEI~GENCY DEPARTMENT
MUSCULOSKELETAL NURSING ASSESSMENT
Su~e N~:
-No,5498.. P, ¢6/49
Carlisle ~e~,~,,,=, Me~;<,~ ~**~J~r
Namet~G~ S~H~IE E ~ 92~4741
Age: ~RS ~a:O8/O9/1996 8~ F ~ ~01008832
EDP:FALVO,~O~ PCP[" NON-~AFF, O~ OF
LocaUon'. Quail~g.B~llat'p oDull nCramping ogurrdng hACking Sevedlysmle; Oreet:.
Provocation: [] Other:. Aggrava6ng factor:
R~dlmtng: ~3NOI3Yes ~ ......................... DConstanl nlntarmltt~t IR~evf~gfa~3t~;
~~!1 ~~t~.~,
Caregivec El]elf nFamltymember Dslgal~ca~tother Qgrouphoma
Employmaat: g3Fullfime QPafffime ~3 Unampioyad
ACIM[yIQVeI: oAmb~late~tnde~eradenlly OReo~b'es~tance nNon-am~lo~y
oPerfom~s ADL's Inde~ndently DRe~ulre~ ae~i~tance w~ ADL's
En,~ronmenu aNomps aPewste~s aMany~teps
NulriUana] ~ ~,NmTnal [] Cache~ ~ Obese
Yes
What waa felt or ~emd up~ InJu'~.
Pm-hospital tmab'nent; Q Full spinal Immobllzdon 13 C-Cotla' OSpllnt
i:]Pmmumdre~slng QIc~ 13Heat QAcam-ap
PMH fi'em tttelie: NONE
Previous Sx i~volvtng mu~culo~keletal w~tem and dmz:
~Diabetes aA..thdl~ oOsteopame~ oHemc~hlUag~Cancm':
~lty A~eument
RUE Pulses:.DYe~ r-INO Cap. Ref.: r'l<2s. []>2s.
LUE Pul~e~:r'lYe~ []No Cap. RE.:
RLE Pulses:r-/Yes E]No Cap, Raf,: [~<Zs. r-1>2s.
ii1= pulsas:i"lyea r'lNo Cap. Re[: r-l<21. I-1>2a.
lvlo~,ion: DYes rlNo
Uotkm: OY~ r'lNo
MotJ~:/'1Y~s ["iN{3
Senaalion~ []Ye~ [] No
~l~lj~:: [] Yes [::] No
Temp. l-lW DC C~or
T~I:),~3W I-lC Ca{or
Temp.[]W []C Color
Temp,~ w r'Ic
Apr.~5. 200,3 lli33AM
,INITIAL ASSESSMENT FORM
PRIONITY: 3
Urgent
DATE; 12/26/2001
Presentation'rime: 14;18
Hel~c
Chief
Complaint:
N0.5498 P. 47/49
Carlisle Regional Medical Center
PaUen~ RATHGABER, STEPHANIE E
DOB: 08/0911998 ACE: 5YR$
;DP: FALVO,THOMAS
PCP: * NON-STAFF, OUT OF TOWN PHY"
T~ge Time: 14:19 Atfl~ll Mode: CARRIED
· Weight: 40,0 lbs, 18.2 kgs. LM~ La~tTatanu:;; unk~m~n
ANIMAL BITE
Brle{ DOG BiTE TO FACE FROM NEIGHBORHOOD DOG ABOUT 45 MiN AGO.
Assessment:
HEMOFTYSI$ NO
FEVER NO
NIGHT SWEATS NO
WEIGHT LOSS NO
ANOREXJA NO
KNOW THE ANIMAl. YES
KNOW THE ANIMAL'S LOCATIOYES
I:~: 9214741
Sex: F MR#: 0001006832
W~s
.Emp. R~:
Vital Sluns
T: 98.9 T
P: 120 Regular
R: 20 Unlabored
BP: 000/'000
o~: % RA
P~ln Int~n~ty $=~e: / '10
Pain Lo~J~o~: Unable ~ ~
Pre..Hosplta!
Treatment:
Peclla~t¢
Pa~
Niacin: N~
G&D Apl3, for Age - NO, Immunization UTD - YES, Height ~t. i~.. Head ~ · Grad,=-, with GRANDPARENT~
NONE
Medicines: NONE
Addition~ NO~;
cm-a~lApr. 1.5. 200~3n.I 1..:'33A. M~:~I~a,t
~ Pa.<er St, Ca~ll~la, PA ,17013 - (717) 2.,45-r~00
DI~ PosrrloN SUMMARY
.~ATHC~,a~. S'r~lo' 54,98~
'12/~/0t 4-"41 pm
P. 48/49
Patient: RATHGABER. STEPHANIE
SS ·
CURRENT Address;
City:
Current
_ Zip:
Age/DOB:
Medical Record:
Arrival:
Disc, h: 12/26/01 4:49pm
Disposition:
MD ED: Donne Fehmr~bach, D,O,
Res/PA/NP: ~J. pa¥ L. Wiener, PA..C
Dx #1: Doe Bite
lCD-9 #1:E906.0
Dx//2: Laceration. Face (Unsoecifled Slte~
ICD-g #2:873.40
PMD:
PMD
#1 Dx Engl: ~
~2'Dx Engl: ~
Mad th~ Auamen§n (Amoxioillin & Clavulanic acid1
Mad #1 Engl; AMOXlClL.EDP
Follow-up: YOUR FAMILY I~OCTOR
#1 Dx Span: ANIMALBT.SSW
~ Dx Span: LACERATS.SSW
FlU MD Ph:: _
F/U D/T:
Other In~tr. RETURN IF ANY SIGNS OF INFECTION. KEEP CLEAN AND DRY AND FOI,~Ow VP W~TH
THE QUARANTINE OF THE DOG AS WE DISCU.S,.~ED OR YOU NEED TO RETURN FOR
RABIES IMMUNIZATIONS. IBUPROFEN A~ DIRECT£r) FOR DISCOMFORTl
MY SIGNATURE EELOW INDICATES:
> I have re~v~:~ and understood the or~J instructions r~arding my ~urrent
medical 13roblem.
> I will arrange follow-up care as instructed abOve.
> I acknowledge receipt of the written instructions as outlined on this and
any pm,/ie, u= pag~..~ I ',~J,' I read and review these inetru~ons.
x
Patient (or Legal ~uardi~) Signature
St=ff (V~tness)Signature
Apr,15. 2003 11!33AM
No.5495 P. ~9/49
CONDITIONS OF TREATMENT AND ADMI8810H
Accoum No. 9214741 DATE & TIME OF ADMII;$10N 12/26/2001 14:18
~ONTAININ~ FA~, INCOM~ ~ ~N~ IN~RMAT ~ ~Y BE ~ TO ~EC~ON UNDER ~BLE LAW,
~VAN~ ~R~ I~R ~ON TO ~AL O~Y~
:arlisle Hospi:tal -- Emergency Department
40 Parker St. Carlisle, PA 17013 - (717) 245-5500
Patient: RATHGABER, STEPHANIE Disch: 12/26/01 4:49pm
MD ED: Donna Fehranbach, D.C. Medical Record:
Res/PNNP: Joey L. Wisher, PA-C
AFTERCARE INSTRUCTIONS
We are pleased to have been abte to provide you with emergency care. Please review these instructions when you return
~ome in order to better understand your diagnosis and the necessary further treatment and precautions related to your
.~ondition. Your diagnoses/prescriptions today are:
Dx #1: Dod Bite
Dx #2: Laceration, Face (Unspecified Site)
Med Instr #1: Auqmentin (Amoxicillin & Clavulanic acid)
;:G~neral: lnfo~tion :on 7ANIMAL BITE':iWOUN DS
An "animal bite wound" is any injury that results from contact with the mouth of an animal. Most animal bite
wounds result from being bitten by a dog or cat. Depending on the circumstances, there may be a bruise, a cut or
both. Bruises do not ordinarily require any special treatment. Cuts, on the other hand, need to be thoroughly
washed with lots of water and may need to be stitched. This almost always requires a visit to the emergency room.
What are the dsks?
Most animal bite wounds heal in s week or two, and do not produce any sedous medical problems. There are,
however, some dsks:
1. By far, the largest risk is that of infection. An infected animal bite is usually red, warm swollen and tender. It
results from small germs (from the animals mouth) that get into the wound and start to grow and multiply. Even
small, seemingly insignificant bites often get infected. If not treated dght away, these infecfions can become
very serious. Because of the risk of infection, animal bite wounds are sometimes not stitched.
2. Deep cuts sometimes injure blood vessels, tendons or nerves.
3. Depending on the circumstances there nffay be a small dsk of rabies. If there is a significant risk, the
emergency room doctor will recommend rabies vaccination (shots).
) If you have a cut or scratch, you should keep the wound clean, dry and bandaged. If the bandage gets dirty or
wet, change it right away. Otherwise, you should change the bandage oncE; a day. To change the bandage you
should:
A) take off the old bandage,
B) gently wash the area with a soap and water,
C) if you are not allergic to it, using a Q-tip, gently apply a thin layer of antibiotic ointment and
D) put on a fresh bandage.
2) If you are not allergic to it, acetaminophen (Tylenol) may help ease the pain. Stronger pain medications are not
usually necessary.
3) Tetanus shots are good for 5 to 10 years, provided you have had all your "baby shots" as a child.
4) SEEK IMMEDIATE MEDICAL ATTENTION if:.
A) you develop a fever, persistent bleeding, vomiting or
B) the wound gets red, warm, swollen or tender or
C) you develop red streaks on the skin around the wound or
D) you notice a creamy liquid (pus) draining from the wound.
5) If you had stitches, have them taken out in days.
General Information on LACERATIONS (CUTS)
The word "laceration" is the medical term for an accidental cut in the skin. Lacerations often result from auto
accidents, falls or contact with broken glass or other sharp objects. Although .'some lacerations are very large, most
are only one to two inches long and can be easily repaired in the emergency (department. Treatment usually
consists of:
1. a shot of numbing medication to deaden the area around the wound,
2. opening up the wound and cleaning it with lots of water and
3. stitching the wound back together with special thread. St;'tching the wound usually results in less scarring and
quicker healing.
What are the risks?
Most lacerations heal in about two weeks and do not produce any serious medical problems. There are,
however, some risks:
1. When the skin is disrupted by a laceration, germs sometimes get into the wound and start to grow and multiply,
producing an infection. These wound infections occur in roughly 1% to 3% of ali lacerations and can result in
serious problems.
2. Most lacerations do leave some form of a permanent scar, although it may not be very noticeable. Many scars
gradually improve for the first 6 to 12 months after the initial injury.
3. Deep lacerations sometimes go into the blood vessels, tendons, nerves or bone. This can be sedous.
1) Keep the wound CLEAN and dry. Cover it with a plastic bag when bathing.
2) If the bandage gets dirty or wet, change it right away. Otherwise, you should change the bandage once a day,
starting the second day after the injury. To change the bandage you should: A) remove the old bandage,
B) gently wash the area with soap and water,
C) if you are not allergic to it, using a Q-tip, gently apply a thin layer of antibiotic ointment and
D) put on a fresh bandage.
3) Most lacerations ars not painful once they have been cleaned, stitched and bandaged. Pain medications are not
usually necessary.
4) Tetanus shots are good for 5 to 10 years, provided you have had alt your childhood immunizations ("baby
shots").
5) SEEK IMMEDIATE MEDICAL A'~'ENTION if:
A) you develop a fever, persistent bleeding, vomiting or
B) the wound gets warm, rsd, swollen or tender or
C) you develop rsd streaks on the skin near the wound or
D) you notice a crsamy liquid (pus) draining from the wound.
6) Be extra careful if you have a very large laceration, an animal bite, a small puncture wound or a human bite
wound. These types of injuries tend to get infected more often.
7) Have the stitches rsmoved in days by a nurse or doctor.
Pg 2
Drug Information on AMOXlCILLIN
BRAND AND GENERIC NAMES - Amoxil, Apo-Amcxi, Augmentin, Clavuiin, Larotid, Moxilean, Novamoxin,
Penamox, Polymox, VWmox.
:.i~;i~),~.~'~?~AGE:I~FORMA TION
Habit forming? No
Prescription needed? Yes
Available as generic? Yes
Drug class: Antibiotic (penicillin)
Treatment of bacterial infections that ars susceptible to amoxiciIiin.
How to take:
* Tablet or capsule - Swallow with liquid on an empty stomach 1 hour before or 2 hours after eating.
* Chewable tablets - Chew well befors swallowing.
* Liquid - Take with cold beverage. Liquid form is perishable and effective for only 7 days at room temperature.
Effective for 14 days if stored in refrigerator. Don't freeze.
When to take: Follow instructions on prescription label or side of package. Doses should be evenly spaced. For
example, 4 times a day means before meals and bedtime.
If you forget a dose: Take as soon as you remember. Continue regular schedule.
VVhat drug does: Destroys susceptible bacteria. Does not kill viruses.
Time lapse before drug works: May be several days befors medicine affects infection.
; WARNiNGS:&?RECAUTiONS iI. -
Don't take if:. You are allergic to amoxicillin, cephaiosporin antfbiotics, other penicillins. Life threatening reaction
may occur.
Before you start, consult your doctor:
* If you are taking beta-btockere (high blood pressure/other), chloramphenicoi, erythromycins, Ioperamide,
paromomycin, tetrecyclines or troleandomycin.
* if you are allergic to any substance or drug.
Over age 60: You may have skin reactions, particularly around genitals and anus.
Pregnancy: Studies inconclusive on harm to unborn child. Animal studies show fetal abnormalities. Decide with
your doctor whether drug benefits justify risk to unborn child.
Breast-feeding: Drug passes into milk. Child may become sensitive to penicillins and have allergic reactions to
penicillin drugs. Avoid amoxicillin or discontinue nursing until you finish medicine. Consult doctor for advice on
maintaining milk supply.
Prolonged use: You may become more susceptible to infections caused by germs not responsive to amoxicillin.
Super infection also a potential.
Driving, piloting or hazardous work: Usually not dangerous. Most hazardous reactions likely to occur a few minutes
after taking amoxicillin.
Discontinuing: Don't discontinue without doctor's advice until you complete pn~scribed dose, even though
sYmPtoms diminish or disappear.
~ PO~IBL~'E~-=F~AC~IONiWITH OTHEIR:iSUBSTANCES (Combined Effect)
* Alcohol: Occasional stomach irritation.
Pg 3
Follow-up: YOUR FAMILY DOCTOR
FlU MD Ph:
F/U D/T:
Other Instr. RETURN IF ANY SIGNS OF INFECTION, KEEP CLE-'AN AND DRY AND FOLLOW UP VVITH
THE QUARANTINE OF THE DOG AS WE DISCUSSED OR YOU NEED TO RETURN FOR
RABIES IMMUNIZATIONS. IBUPROFEN AS DIREC'rED FOR DISCOMFORT.
EKGs and X-Rays: If you had an EKG or X-Ray today, it will be formally reviewed by a specialist tomorrow. If there is any
change from today's Emergency Department reading, you will be notified.
IMPORTANT NOTICE TO ALL PATIENTS: The examination and treatment you have received in our Emergency
Department have been rendered on an emergency basis only and will not substitute for definitive and ongoing evaluation
and medical care. A follow-up physician has been designated for you. It is essential that you make arrangements for
follow-up care with that physician as instructed. Report any new or remaining problems at that time, because it is
impossible to recognize and treat all elements of injury or disease in a single Emergency Department visit. Significant
changes or worsening in your condition may require more immediate attention. 'The Emergency Department is always
open and available if this becomes necessary.
Johns Hopkins Medicine
CL IN! C NO TE
Name: Rathgeber, Stephanle
History: 2-345-67-54
Address: 1912 Bowen Way
: Forrest Hill MI) 21050 Visit Date: 02/13/2002
Phone: (410)836-8482
Dob: 08/09/1996
Race: Unknown Location: 31 gA
Sex: Female Document No: 91751310030
Primary Provider: Man,on, Paul N
Other Provider:
Reason for Visit:
History of Present Illness:
This patient is seen for the residual ora dog bite sustained at Christm~ time when a neighbor's German Shepherd
mixed-breed dog from the neighborhood bit her at least 2 t~mes in the face. She sustained lacemtious to the bridge of
the nose and the left cheek and the scalp. The scalp has healed the best with a barely perceptible scar. In the cheeks,
she had quite a black eye and had a bump in her cheek as well. They have checked with Dr. Kurgansky, and he wished
to have her seen for scar revision.
She has previously been otherwise healthy. They have been puttiug vitamin E on the area and massaging.
Medications:
She takes no medications.
Allergies:
She has no allergies.
Major Findings:
On exammation, she has a periorbital hemaroma that has been slightly pigmented~ A I -cra laceration is present over
the bridge of thc nose and over the left cheek. She has some induration present. The scars are slightly spread.
Assessments:
April 11, 2003
F~3VAL DOCUMENT
Patient: Rathgeber, Stephanie
ProblemsfDiagnosis:
History # 2-345-67-54
Procedures and Immuni~t. iOIlS:
Plans:
I provided her a prescription to use for CicaCare, and she is to continue vitamin E massage. She may need a scar
revision in the future. I discussed that in detail with the parents. They will let us know their plans.
Medication Changes:
CC List:
DICTATED BY: MANSON, PAUL N, M.D./906/917 D: 02/13/2002 T: 02/:[5/2002
Provider MANSON, PAUL 02/25/2002
'r~LtS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN ELECTRONICALLY SIGNED
April 11, 2003 FINAL DOCUMENT
Johns Hopkins Medicine
CLINIC NOTE
Name:
Address:
Phone:
Rathgebcr, Stcphunie
1912 Bowen Way
Forrest Hill MI) 21050
(410)836-8482
H/story: 2-345-67-54
Visit Date: 05/15/2002
Dob: 08/09/1996 Location: 318A
Race: Unknown Docma~ent No: 55799310030
Sex: Female
Primary Provider: Manson,Paul N
Other Provider:
Reason for Visit:
History of Present Hiness:
The patient is seen for observation. The scars are fading. The scalp is not pexceptible. The ones over the nose and
cheek are receding. It is my opinion that they will recede sufficiently that the2), do not requixe any surgery, but I will
see her aga/n in 6 months to 1 year. Thexe is no evidence of any subcutaneou,,~ induration or of any growth restriction.
Medications:
Allergies:
Major Findings:
Problems/Diagnosis:
Procedures and Imm~mi~aliOUS:
April 11, 2003 FIN~IL DOCUMENT
Patient: Rathgeber, Stephanie 2 History # 2-345-67-54
Plans:
I should see her again in 6 months.
Medication Changes:
CC List:
DICTATED BY: MANSON, PAUL N, M.D./005 D: 05/16/2002 T: 05/17/2002
Provider MANSON, PAUL 05/22/2002
THIS D OCT, IM~NT HAS BE~EN ELECTRONICALLy SIGNED
April 11, 2003 FINAL DOCUMENT
Johns Hopkins Medicine
CLINIC NOTE
Name: Rathgeber, 8tephanie ltistory: 2-345-67-54
Address: 1912 Bowen Way Visit Date: 11/06/2002
: Forrest Hill IvlD 21050
Phone: (410)836-8482
Dob: 08/09/1996
Race: Unknovra Lo,cation: 318A
Sex: Female Document No: 92857510030
Primary Provider: Manson,Panl N
Other Provider:
Reason for Visit:
The patient is seen again. This is a followup for considered scar revision.
History of Present Illness:
The only scar that is really prominemt is the one on the nose. The cheek scars while still red and barely perceptible are
fiat and one would not thi~lc that any of these scars could predictably be improved.
Medications:
Major Findings:
Problems/Diagnosis:
April 11, 2003 F2NAL DOCUMENT
patient: Rathgeber, Stepbanie 2 History # 2-345-67-54
Plans: I *hink that her degree of
I discussed this with him ia detail. I will see them once more for a final evaluation,
iraprovemant is sufficient that one could not offe~ her any ad6itional improvemant by further surgery.
Medication Changes:
CC List:
Dennis KurganSky, M.D.; 2 Nog Avenue, Suite 100; Bel Air, MI) 21014;
DICTATED BY: MANSON, PAULN, M.D./005 D: 11/10/2002 T: 11/12/2002
11/15/2002
Provider MANSON, PAUL
TH~ DOCUMENT HAS BEEN ELECTRONICALLY SIGNED
FINAL DOCUMENT
April I 1, 2003
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
STEVEN E. RATHGEBER and
GRACE D. RATHGEBER, as Parents
and Natural Guardians of
STEPHANIE E. RATHGEBER, a Minor
VS.
JEAN TAYLOR and
JOHN M. WHI'I-rEN
No. 2003- 6368 Civil Term
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PROPOSED ORDER
AND NOW, to wit, this day of _ ,2004, upon
consideration of the Petition of Steven E. Rathgeber and Grace D. Rathgeber, as
parents and natural guardians of Stephanie E. Rathgeber, a minor, and after a
hearing thereon, the court hereby approves the ,compromise and settlement of the
minor's action for the total sum of Twelve Thousand ($12,000.00) Dollars.
It is further ORDERED and directed that ~[he sum of Twelve Thousand
($12,000.00) Dollars received in settlement of the claim of Stephanie E. Rathgeber,
a minor, shall be distributed as follows:
a. To Griest, Himes, Herrold, Schaumann,
LLP, for counsel fees in representing the minor $ 3,000.00
b. To Griest, Himes, Herrold, Schaumnan,
LLP, for costs advanced to obtain medical
records, colored copies, and Accurint location
information 36.87
c. To Stephanie E. Rathgeber, rninor Plainitff $ 8,961.13
It is further ORDERED and directed that the sum awarded to the minor
Plaintiff shall be deposited in an account insured by the federal government agency.
The account established on behalf of the minor shall contain a provision that no
withdrawal can be made from the account until the minor attains her majority, except
as authorized by a prior court Order.
It is further ORDERED and directed that Plaintiffs shall mark the suit settled
and satisfied of record and that they shall execute and deliver to the Defendants and
their insurance carrier a proper release acquitting and discharging the Defendants of
and from all further payments, claims, suits or demands, by reason of the incident
which occurred on December 26, 2001.
It is further ORDERED and directed that r)efendants shall reimburse Plaintiffs
for all docket and court costs, in the amount of $102.95, incurred in the above
referenced matter.
BY THE COURT,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
STEVEN E. RATHGEBER and
GRACE D. RATHGEBER, as Parents
and Natural Guardians of
STEPHANIE E. RATHGEBER, a Minor
VS.
JEAN TAYLOR and
JOHN M. WHITTEN
No. 2003- 6368 Civil Term
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ORDER
AND NOW, to wit, this ._~ day of ~~ ,2004, a
hearing on the within Petition for Approval of a Minor Settlement is fixed for the
day of ~ ,2004, at ~'" ~ 4 o'clock~r .M. before the
undersigned Judge in courtroom number ~ of the Cumberland County
Courthouse. Both the minor Plaintiff and her guardians shall be present at the time of
the hearing.
Jo
Au,'/LOi~,COHj,.Ou,:t :BFLL .40
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
STEVEN E. RATHGEBER and
GRACE D. RATHGEBER, as Parents
and Natural Guardians of
STEPHANIE E. RATHGEBER, a Minor
VS.
JEAN TAYLOR and
JOHN M. WHITTEN
No. 2003- 6368 Civil Term
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PROPOSED ORDER
· day of
AND NOW, to wit, this ,2004, upon
consideration of the Petition of Steven E. Rathgeber and Grace D. Rathgeber, as
parents and natural guardians of Stephanie E..Rathgeber, a minor, and after a
hearing thereon, the court hereby approves the compromise and settlement of the
minor's action for the total sum of Twelve Thousand ($12,000.00) Dollars.
It is further ORDERED and directed that the sum of Twelve Thousand
($12,000.00) Dollars received in settlement of the claim of Stephanie E. Rathgeber,
a minor, shall be distributed as follows:
a. To Griest, Himes, Herrold, Schaumann,
LLP, for counsel fees in representing the minor $ 3,000.00
b. To Griest, Himes, Herrold, Schaumnan,
LLP, for costs advanced to obtain medical
records, colored copies, and Accurint location
information 38.87
c. To Stephanie E. Rathgeber, minor Plainitff $ 8,961.13
It is further ORDERED and directed that the sum awarded to the minor
Plaintiff shall be deposited in an account insured by the federal government agency.
The account established on behalf of the minor shall contain a provision that no
withdrawal can be made from the account until the minor attains her majority, except
as authorized by a prior court Order.
It is further ORDERED and directed that Plaintiffs shall mark the suit settled
and satisfied of record and that they shall execute and deliver to the Defendants and
their insurance carrier a proper release acquitting and discharging the Defendants of
and from all further payments, claims, suits or demands, by reason of the incident
which occurred on December 26, 2001.
It is further ORDERED and directed that Defendants shall reimburse Plaintiffs
for all docket and court costs, in the amount of $102.95, incurred in the above
referenced matter.
J=