HomeMy WebLinkAbout12-10-03IN RE: MILDRED J. GERBER : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
TRUST UNDER AGREEMENT :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
dated December 19, 1997 :ORPHAN'S COURT DIVISION
: NO: 21-2001-92
DECREE
The background of this Decree is as follows:
1. A First and Final Account of PNC Bank National Association, for the Estate of
Mildred J. Gerber, an Incapacitated Person ( the "Account") was filed with this Court on or about
October 24, 2003; and
2. Objections to the Account were filed by Marilyn Jo Gerber, on or about November
24, 2003; and
NOW, THEREFORE, by the Order of Court attached hereto as Exhibit "A", the said
William A. Duncan, Esquire was appointed the auditor and master (collectively "Auditor") in the
above-captioned proceeding.
The Auditor is specifically directed pursuant to 20 Pa. C.S.A. 751(1), to investigate all
issues of fact raised in and related to: Objections of Marilyn Jo Gerber, and to report finding of
fact, conclusions of law and recommendations to the Court with respect to Objections.
The Auditor is further directed, pursuant to 20 Pa. C.S.A. 751 (2), to examine and audit
the First and Final Account for the Estate of Mildred J. Gerber and to make recommendations to
the Court with respect thereto.
The Auditor is empowered to take such actions and shall follow such procedures as
provided for: (1) in the Probate, Estate and Fiduciaries Code, (2) in the Orphans Court Rules
adopted by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, and (3) in the Local Rules of this Court.
However, the Auditor shall file his report within two hundred seventy (270) days after
appointment (rather than within the ninety (90) days provided for in local rules) unless, upon
application, the time is extended by the Court.
The Auditor shall be entitled to reasonable compensation for his time and expenses.
Compensation for the Auditor shall be set at the rate of $150.00 per hour. Invoices shall be
rendered monthly and paid, initially, by the Estate of Mildred J. Gerber. Responsibility for
payment of the Auditor's compensation shall be subject to possible subsequent modification by the
Court.
The Auditor is direct to consult with counsel as soon as practicable and thereat~er
establish a case management schedule setting forth discovery deadlines, hearing dates, and other
case management directives as he deems appropriate. The case management schedule may be
changed by the Auditor on his own, or, in his discretion, upon application by any party.
The Auditor's authority is specifically subject to and limited by any retention of jurisdiction
held by the Superior Court of Pennsylvania.
BY THE COURT:
J/Wesley Ol~SJ~., J. ' /Z~
IN RE: MILDRED J. GERBER : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
TRUST UNDER AGREEMENT :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
dated December 19, 1997 :ORPHAN'S COURT DMSION
: NO: 21-2001-92
INTERESTED PARTIES..
Attorneys/Firms Who Are Represeming or
Direct Interest Have ,Represented Interested Parties
Marilyn Jo Gerber Marilyn Jo Gerber, Pro Se
Frederick E. Gerber Richard E. Rupp, Esquire
Rupp & Meikie
Joanne Christine, Esquire
PNC Bank Rhoades & Sinon
~l'itle o! O~cer.
ol tAe ~Ain ~smed Fa, ntoe it ~'~ti~~~~°st °J~ee a~dress
MADE, ~TH~, 29th dalt o! 3uly ~. ¼ th~ ~e
· Borough o~ New Cumberland, CunberXand Count~, 'Pennsylvania,
pa~Aea o~ tl~e secoo~ pa~t, ............... o -
G~n~¢e a
WIT1VE$$ETH, that i~ ~onsid~rat~m o! Thirty ~ ~~ ~
- - ......... - ...... - - -
and con~ ~'~s ~ gm~e~ ~, ~ ~ ~ al~l~ - ~ ....
~ that ce~t~a ~ ~ t~t ~ ~nd ~tuate ~ t~ ~~ ~ N~ ~-
l~d, Co~ty ~ C~erland'~ S~te o~ ~n~lv~a,:mon ~c~ly
b~d ~d ~ocr~d u foXl~s, to
B~~ at a ~lnt ~ t~ easterly line o~ ~lltop ~i~,
comer ~ the s~tberll Antersec~on o~ ~lltop DrAve ~d H~As~
thence northw~dX~ ~ong a~d e~terly ll~ ~ ~lltop Drive b~ a
the left ~vi~ a ra~s of 1~ teet ~ ~c ~et~ce ~f 25.~ ~eet to a
o~ taugeucy; ~e IRll n~th~y ~9 s~d ~ne ~ ~Htop ~ive ~.56
· ~t to a ~Ant; then~ easily at ri~t ~gles, ~ ~
XA~' o~ ~t ~o. 19, nX~ -~, ~ feet' to a ~t; t~nce by ~ u~ or
· ~rly of ~r S. ~mr~u S~th 19 ~greeo X7 ~utes ~st
to a ~intt t~uce ~otw~y ~g t~ n~rn ~M ~ ~t Ho,
watery X23.~ ~eet to t~ ~ace ~ B~~G.
Plan ~ng re~r~ In P~ ~ ~, Page 1, ~rl~ ~ty
~V~ ~e~ e~cted a ~ story brAck a~ ~nn ~i~
atta~d ~ ~ g~age ~m as ~ u~~ 623 ~lXt~ DrAve.
BK~ ~e o~e p~s ~ ~ ~ot~ction, lnG. by ira
~guot 19, X~3 ~ ncord~ An the ~rX~ ~ty Rec~der'o Office
~e able deocrA~ ~~s ~e c~ey~ ~ ~ ~Ject to a ~tga~
to FArot P~aX SavAugo ~d ~ ~s~AatAon, ~rA~,
Lng b~d.. -
BILLING SUMMARY - TOTALS
HOURS AMOUNT
APRIL 11.3 $1,695.00
MAY 3.4 510.00
JUNE 7.5 1,125.00
JULY 7.3 1,095.00
AUGUST 1.4 180.00
SEPTEMBER .6 90.00
OCTOBER 6.3 945.00
TOTAL $5,670.00
CALDWELL & KEARNS
3631 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110-1533
TAX I.D. #23-2015480
(717) 232-7661
'INVOICE #33623
MONTHLY BILLING
Nov 13 2002
Marilyn Jo Gerber
42 Drexel Place
New Cumberland PA 17070
MATTER 01607
Guardianship Contest
FEES HOURS
,.I ..... ll~ .......... L ii
Oct 09/2002 Research Review Hearing Issues - 0.80
Entitlement and Appeal
Oct 11/2002 Research Appeal of Guardian 0.80
Appointment as Basis for Deferral
Oct 17/2002 Draft Motion 0.70
Oct 18/2002 Draft Motion -.Review Client Faxes 0.40
II
Complete Draft. of Petition for 1.70
Review Hearing
I 1
Oct 24/2002 Revise, Edit Motion for Review 1.10
Hearing
Telephone Call from J. O'Halleran 0.80 ~
and with Client RE: Illinois Order
TOTAL FEES AT $150 PER HR.
Photocopies
Telephone charge long distance
Fax charges
Sep-30-02 Lexis Charges month of September, 2002
FEEES AND COSTS
OUTSTANDING BALANCE
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE .................................
SAL:slb
CALDWELL & KEARNS
3631 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110-1533
TAX I.D. #23-2015480
(717) 232-7661
INVOICE ~33357
MONTHLY BILLING
Oct 10 2002
Marilyn Jo Gerber
42 Drexel Place
New Cumberland PA 17070
MATTER 01607
Guardianship Contest
FEES HOURS
Telephone Conference with Client 0.60
RE: Rupp Letter of 9/26; Petition
for Review Hearing
Page 2
TOTAL FEES AT $150 PER HR.
Copies
Telephone charges - long distance
Fax charges
FEES AND COSTS
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE ..........................................
SAL;slb
CALDWELL & KEARNS
3631 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110-1533
TAX I.D. #23-2015480
(717) 232-7661
INVOICE #33166
MONTHLY BILLING
Sep 20 2002
Marilyn Jo Gerber
42 Drexel Place
New Cumberland PA 17070
MATTER 01607
Guardianship Contest
FEES HOURS
Review Rupp Letter 8/7/02 RE: 0.20
Visits
Aug 08/20'02 Telephone Call from Client RE: ~ 0.30
on Visit
Aug 20/2002 Telephone Call from J. O'Halloran - 0.90
RE: Visitation Issues,
Proc Enforcement of Order
Page 2
FEES HOURS
TOTAL FEES $150 PER HR.
Photocopies
Telephone expense
Fax Expense
FEES AND COSTS
OUTSTANDING BALANCE FROM PREVIOUS INVOICES
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE ......................................
SAL:slb
CALDWELL & KEARNS
3631 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110-1533
TAX I.D. #23-2015480
(717) 232-7661
INVOICE #32901
MONTHLY BILLING
Aug 15 2002
Marilyn Jo Gerber
42 Drexel Place
New Cumberland PA 17070
MATTER 01607
GuardianshiP Contest
FEES HOURS
Jul 08/2002 Review Letter of Client to F.E.G. 0.20
& R. Rupp
Complete & Revise Motion 2.00
Jul 09/2002 Proof Petition,. Final Revisions 1.10
Filing 0.40
Telephone Call from Client and 0.20
Call to R. Rupp
Telephone Call from Ro Rupp and 0.40
with Client RE: 7/10 Visit
Jul 15/2002 Telephone Call from Client RE: 0.40
'Visitation
Review J. Baylay er; Letter 0.30
from Rupp and Telephone Call from
Client
Jul 19/2002 Telephone Call from Client RE: 0.40
Visitation
Jul 29/2002 Telephone Call from Client RE: 0.70
ermlna~e
Visits
Review Motion to Suspend Visits 0.30
Page 2
FEES HOURS
Jul 30/2002 Review Judge Bayleys' Order and 0.60
Telephone Call with Client RE:
Visitations
Letter to RupP RE: August 0.30
Visits
TOTAL FEES AT '$150 PER HR.
Photocopies
Fax charge
FEES AND COSTS .....................................
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE .....................................
SAL:slb
CALDWELL & KEARNS
3631 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110-1533
TAX I.D. ~23~2015480
(717) 232-7661
INVOICE #32716
MONTHLY BILLING
Jul 25 2002
Marilyn Jo Gerber
42 Drexel Place
New Cumberland PA 17070
MATTER 01607
Guardianship Contest
FEES HOURS
Jun 04/2002 L'etter to R. Rupp RE: Visits , 0.20
Jun 07/2002 Telephone Call'from Client RE: 0.50
Visitation Today;
Jun 12/2002 Telephone Call R. Rupp 0.40
Telephone Call Client 0.30
Jun 13/2002 Review Letter of R. Rupp and 0.80
Prepare Reply
Telephone Call from R. Rupp RE: 0.50
-Visit
Telephone Call to Client RE: 6/14 0.30
Visit
Jun 17/2002 Letter to R. Rupp 0.20
0.00
Jun 19/2002 Letter to Rupp 0.20
Jun 21/2002 Prepare & Revise Petition for 2.80
Review Hearing
Conference with Client RE: Hearing 0.70
issues
Jun 2'7/2002 Telephone Call from Marilyn 0.20
Letter to Rupp 0.20
Page 2
FEES HOURS
Telephone Call to Rupp 0.20
TOTAL FEES AT $150 PER HR.
Photocopies
Fax charge
FEES AND COSTS
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE
SAL:slb
CALDWELL & KEARNS
3631 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110-1533
TAX I.D. #23-2015480
(717) 232-7661
INVOICE #32576
MONTHLY BILLING
Marilyn Jo Gerber Jun 28 2002
42~Drexel Place
New Cumberland PA 17070
MATTER 01607
re: Guardianship Contest
FEES HOURS
May 03/2002 Prepare Letter to R. Rupp & Review 0.50
Correspondence for Rupp
May 06/2002 Review R. Rupp Letter 0.10
Telephone Call from Client Re: Reply 0.40
Prepare Reply Letter to R. Rupp 0.30
May 07/2002 Telephone Call from Client Re: Visit 0.10
Review Letter from R. Rupp 0.20
Page 2
FEES HOURS
Ma~ 13/2002 Letter to R. Rupp 0.20 ~
Telephone Call from Client RE: 0.50
Visitation, ~ Review Hearing
Issues
Letter to R. Rupp RE: 5/21 Visit 0.20
May 21/2002 Telephone Call to R. Rupp and 0.20
Review Letter Received by Fax
Telephone Call to Client RE: 0.20
Todays Visit
May 30/2002 Telephone Call with Client 0.20
Telephone Call with R. Rupp RE: 0.30
Visits
TOTAL FEES AT $150 PER HR.
Photocopies
FEES AND COSTS
TOTAL ~OUNT DUE
SAL:slb
CALDWELL & KEA3~NS
3631 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110-1533
TADX I.D. #23-2015480
(717) 232-7661
.INVOICE #32236
MONTHLY BILLING
May 14 2002
Marilyn Jo Gerber
42 Drexel Place
New Cumberland PA 17070
MATTER 01607
RE: Guardianship Contest
Outstanding balance ..........................................
FEES HOURS
Apr 03/2002 Telephone Call with R. Rupp 0.70
Telephone Call with. Client RE: 0.70
Visitation & Order Compliance with
R. Rupp
Review Letter from R. Rupp 0.20
Apr 04/2002 Telephone Call with Client, 1.30
Discuss Response to 4/7 Visit -
Possible Contempt/Enforcement
Proceeding
Prepare Letter'to R. Rupp 0.70
Begin Outline of Petition to 0.40
Enfcrce Order
Apr 05/2002
Prepare Letter to R. Rupp RE: 1.60
Visitation
Apr 09/2002 Review Client Phone Messages & 0.30
Comments RE: Visitation
Apr 10/2002 Telephone Call & Message from 0.30
Client
Apr 11/2002 Telephone Call from Client 0.20
Apr 12/2002 Review Correspondence from R. Rupp 0.20
& Prepare Fax to Client
Apr 15/2002 Messages from Client; Telephone 0.30
Call to Client
Prepare Letter to R. Rupp 0.40
Review Letter of 4/12/02 & Case 0.80
Page 2
FEES HOURS
Evaluation for Further Motion
Apr 16/2002 Telephone Call from Client 0.20
Review Letter from R. Rupp; '0.20-
Telephone Call to Client
Draft Reply Letter RE: 4/17 0.20
Telephone Call with H. Rupp 0.30
Conference with Client 0.30
Apr 17/2002 Review Fax from R. Rupp and 0.40
Telephone Call from Client
Apr 18/2002 Prepare Letter to R. Rupp & Review 0.40
Letter of 4/17
Apr 22/2002
Telephone Call with Client RE: 0.20
4/24 Visit
Apr 24/2002
Telephone Call from Client RE: 0.30
Visit
Apr 30/2002
Telephone Ca E: 5/1 0.20
Visit
Prepare Letter to R. Rupp & 0.30
Telephone Call to Office
Review Reply from R. Rupp 0.20
Page 3
TOTAL FEES AT $150 PER HR.
Photocopies
Fax
FEES AND COSTS
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE ...................................
SAL:slb
1, 2, and 3. Also complete A. Received
/~.u' t is desired. !~t~o~D
r name and address on the reverse
/fat..w.e can return the card to you. C. Signature
/'ach..this card to the back of the mailpiece,
on the front if space permits. I-1 Ager
[] Addr
.Article Addressed to: item 17 [] Yes
[] No
47 lb',-e,.zel. Plac'.e
Ne'~ Cumhe:r_!ancl, PA 1
J -_s R~iste, w '-' R,,tur. R~,,ipt for M~har
_ [] Insurad Mail [] O.O.D.
[ 4. Restricted Deliver/? (Extra Fee) [] Ye~
PS Form 3811, July 1999 Domestic Return Receipt
102595-00-M.0
OC? 3 0
MILDRED J. GERBER, : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Plaintiff/Petitioner : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
:
v. : NO. 98-4120 EQUITY TERM
MARILYN JO GERBER, : CIVIL ACTION EQUITY
And now the ]$"[ day of ~ 2000, Petitioner Mildred J. Gerber's
.... - ..... petifion:to:x, aeate order is hereby GRANTED and this c6iart~ prior order in this case of'-
December 28, 1998 is hereby vacated.
BY THE COURT,
MILDRED J. GERBER, : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Plaintiff/Petitioner · CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
:
v. : NO. 98-4120 EQUITY TERM
MARILYN JO GERBER, : CIVIL ACTION EQUITY
And now this ~ day of ,2000, it is hereby ordered that a hearing
by held on the petition of Mildred J. Gerber to vacate this courts prior~orde~ dated .
December 28, 1998 at ~ on ,2000 in courtroom g___.
BY THE COURT,