The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About08-3651IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CINDY L. RYDER, Plaintiff NO. LV 441 V. STEPHANIE BAER, Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED NOTICE YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the Court without further notice for any money claimed in the Complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW. THIS OFFICE CAN PROVIDE YOU WITH INFORMATION ABOUT HIRING A LAWYER. IF YOU CANNOT AFFORD TO HIRE A LAWYER, THIS OFFICE MAY BE ABLE TO PROVIDE YOU WITH INFORMATION ABOUT AGENCIES THAT MAY OFFER LEGAL SERVICES TO ELIGIBLE PERSONS AT A REDUCED FEE OR NO FEE. CUMBERLAND COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION 32 South Bedford St. Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013-3302 717-249-3166 AVISO LISTED HA SIDO DEMANDADOIA EN CORTE. Si usted desea defenderse de las demandas que se presentan mas adelante en las siguientes p6ginas, debe tomar accion dentro de los proximos veinte (20) dias despues de la notificacibn de esta Demanda y Aviso radicando personalmente o por medio de un abogado una comparecencia escrita y radicando en la Corte por escrito sus defensas de, y objecciones a, las demandas presentadas aqui en contra suya. Se le advierte de que si usted falla de tomar accion como se describe anteriormente, el caso puede proceder sin usted y un fallo por cualquier suma de dinero reclamada en la demanda o cualquier otra reclamacion o remedio solicitado por el demandante puede ser dictado en contra suya por la Corte sin mks aviso adicional. Usted puede perder dinero o propiedad u otros derechos importantes para usted. USTED DEBE LLEVAR ESTE DOCUMENTO A SU ABOGADO INMEDIATAMENTE. SI USTED NO TIENE UN ABOGADO, LLAME O VAYA A LA SIGUIENTE OFICINA. ESTA OFICINA PUEDE PROVEERLE INFORMACION A CERCA DE COMO CONSEGUIR UN ABOGADO. SI LISTED NO PUEDE PAGAR POR LOS SERVICIOS DE UN ABOGADO, ES POSIBLE QUE ESTA OFICINA LE PUEDA PROVEER INFORMACION SOBRE AGENCIAS QUE OFREZCAN SERVICIOS LEGALES SIN CARGO O BAJO COSTO A PERSONAS QUE CUALIFICAN. CUMBERLAND COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION, 32 South Bedford St. Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013-3302 717-249-3166 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CINDY L. RYDER, Plaintiff NO. C"Vvo f c-ttt v. STEPHANIE BAER, Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION Plaintiff, Cindy L. Ryder, by and through her counsel, McCarthy Weisberg Cummings, P.C., hereby files the following Complaint in Civil Action (hereinafter, "Complaint") asserting a claim for damages against Defendant, Stephanie Baer, set forth herein, as follows: 1. Plaintiff, an adult individual, is a resident and citizen of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, residing at 334 East Garfield Street, Shippensburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17257. 2. Defendant Stephanie Baer, an adult individual, is a resident and citizen of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, residing at 337 East Garfield Street, Shippensburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17257. 3. At all times relevant and material hereto, Defendant was the owner, keeper and harborer of a dog, believed to be a golden retriever (hereinafter, the "Baer Dog"). 4. At all times relevant and material hereto, Plaintiff was the owner and keeper of a chihuahua breed of dog, named Pretzel (hereinafter, "Pretzel'). 5. On October 19, 2007, at approximately 4:15 p.m., Plaintiff was walking from her residence at 337 East Garfied Street, proceeding westward, with her dog, Pretzel, properly secured on a leash. 6. While Plaintiff was walking Pretzel, an unrestrained and unaccompanied golden retriever, later determined to be the Baer Dog, appeared from behind Plaintiff and violently, and without provocation attacked Pretzel. 7. Prior to the Baer Dog attacking Pretzel, Plaintiff had not walked in front of the Baer Dog's residence at 337 East Garfield Street; rather Plaintiff had left her own house and proceeded in the opposite direction. 8. While the Baer Dog was in the process of attacking Pretzel, and had Pretzel in its jaws, Plaintiff grabbed the Baer Dog by the collar to try to rescue Pretzel, and the Baer Dog let go of Pretzel. 9. Subsequently, the Baer Dog slipped out of its collar and attacked Pretzel again, grabbing Pretzel's entire body in its jaws. 10. Plaintiff was then able to kick the Baer Dog, which then dropped Pretzel, and Plaintiff was able to secure the collar back on the neck of the Baer Dog. 11. After Plaintiff secured the collar on the neck of the Baer Dog, the Baer Dog turned and bit Plaintiff three times on her right arm, just above her wrist, causing deep puncture wounds to Plaintiff's skin and causing her to bleed. 12. Immediately subsequent to the incident with the Baer Dog, Defendant advised Plaintiff that the Baer Dog had previously shown aggression towards other animals. 2 13. Upon information and belief, the Baer Dog had previously attacked another dog on at least one occasion. 14. Subsequent to the incident on October 19, 2007, Plaintiff has witnessed the Baer Dog roaming unaccompanied and unrestrained in the Plaintiffs neighborhood. 15. Subsequent to the incident on October 19, 2007, on February 26, 2008, Defendant was issued a warning by the Cumberland County Dog Warden for allowing the Baer Dog roaming unaccompanied and unrestrained in the Plaintiffs neighborhood. 16. Subsequent to the incident on October 19, 2007, on or about May 17, 2008, the Baer Dog attacked and bit another individual, Grace Russell, who resides next door to Defendant's residence. FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION: NEGLIGENCE, NEGLIGENCE PER SE. AND PUNITIVE DAMAGES 17. Plaintiff incorporates paragraphs 1-16 by reference as though fully set forth herein at length. 18. The Pennsylvania Dog Law, 3 P.S. § 459-305, provides: It shall be unlawful for the owner or keeper of any dog to fail to keep at all times such dog either: (1) confined within the premises of the owner; (2) firmly secured by means of a collar and chain or other device so that it cannot stray beyond the premises on which it is secured; or (3) under the reasonable control of some person, or when engaged 3 in lawful hunting, exhibition or field training. 19. This Act dictates the duties of care required of someone in the same situation as Defendant. 20. Defendant's conduct as described was in contravention of this Act. 21. This Act was intended to protect people in the same circumstances as Plaintiff was in, and to prevent the kind of harm that Plaintiff and Pretzel incurred. 22. Accordingly, Defendant was negligent as a matter of law. 23. Defendant's negligence as aforesaid was a substantial factor in bringing about harm to Plaintiff and Pretzel, including the injuries and damages as herein described. 24. In addition or in the alternative, the Defendant knew or should have known that her dog was vicious and had a propensity to attack other animals and human beings without provocation, based on one or more of the following: (a) It is believed, and therefore averred, that the Baer Dog was previously known to be aggressive and demonstrate vicious tendencies towards other animals. (b) It is believed, and therefore averred, that the Baer Dog had previously attacked another dog on at least one occasion. (c) It is believed, and therefore averred, that the Baer Dog had previously been neutered in an attempt to make it friendlier, which was unsuccessful. (d) It is believed, and therefore averred, that the Baer Dog had previously, without provocation, growled at children in the neighborhood. 4 (e) It is believed, and therefore averred, that the Baer Dog had previously, without provocation, bared its teeth towards other people in the neighborhood. (f) It is believed, and therefore averred, that Defendant had previously given away the Baer Dog to another individual due to its aggressive nature, but later took back ownership and control of the Baer Dog. 25. Defendant was further careless, negligent, reckless and outrageous in allowing the Baer Dog to attack Plaintiff and Pretzel, despite all of the foregoing knowledge, by acting or failing to act in one or more of the following respects: (a) In keeping the Baer Dog on the subject premises when she knew or should have known that the dog was vicious, aggressive and dangerous, all in violation of the Dog Law and/or local regulations and ordinances; (b) In failing to properly and adequately confine and restrain the Baer Dog well away from Plaintiff and Pretzel while they were on a public walkway; (c) In failing to utilize proper and adequate materials to chain or otherwise restrain the Baer Dog well away from Plaintiff and Pretzel while they were on a public walkway; (d) In failing to properly restrain and/or muzzle the Baer Dog; (e) In failing to warn Plaintiff that the Baer Dog possessed known dangerous and vicious propensities; (f) In failing to warn Plaintiff that the Baer Dog was not restrained and/or otherwise could reach and attack the Plaintiff and Pretzel; 5 (g) In failing to take adequate precautions to ensure that the Baer Dog was properly secured and restrained, and could not break its restraints or otherwise reach Plaintiff and Pretzel; (h) In failing to supervise and maintain a close watch over the Baer Dog; (i) In failing to adequately, timely, and properly and completely inspect the premises where the Baer Dog was housed to ensure the Baer Dog could not escape; 0) in failing to care for and train the Baer Dog; (k) In failing to keep and maintain the Baer Dog in a safe place; (1) In causing and allowing a dangerous and hazardous situation to exist; (m) In failing to use the degree of care required of Defendant as an owner, controller, and/or possessor of the vicious dog under the circumstances then and there existing; (n) In violating various provisions of the Pennsylvania Dog Law; (o) In failing to have the Baer Dog properly licensed with the county; (p) In failing to have the Baer Dog vaccinated against rabies; (q) In failing to take remedial action subsequent to the Baer Dog attacking Plaintiff and Pretzel, such that the Baer Dog has been allowed to roam free in the neighborhood subsequent to the incident of October 19, 2007; 6 (r) In failing to take remedial action subsequent to the Baer Dog attacking Plaintiff and Pretzel, such that the Baer Dog was able to attack and bite another neighbor on or about May 17, 2008; (s) In being otherwise careless, reckless, negligent and wanton as may appear in the course of discovery and/or trial of this cause; and (t) In creating conditions or otherwise encouraging the Baer Dog to be aggressive toward human beings. 26. As a direct and proximate result of the carelessness, negligent, reckless and outrageous conduct of Defendant as aforesaid, Plaintiff has sustained the following damages and injuries, some of which may be continuing or permanent in nature or effect: (a) Animal bites creating puncture wounds to the right arm; (b) Scarring to the right arm; (c) Laceration to the right wrist; (d) Severe fright, anxiety, mental anguish, embarrassment and humiliation; (e) Severe pain and suffering; (f) Severe loss of the enjoyment of life and overall health and well being; (g) Plaintiff has been forced to spend large sums of money for doctors, medicines, hospitals, medical treatment and other medical expenses. (h) Plaintiff has been forced to spend large sums of money for veterinary care and treatment for Pretzel, including two surgical repairs of 7 abdominal hernias and a fracture to the back right ankle. 27. All of the aforesaid injuries and damages have continued from October 19, 2007 to the present, and will continue into the future. 28. The aforesaid conduct of Defendant was outrageous, reckless, willful and malicious, and constituted deliberate acts and omissions having a high probability of harm with a reckless indifference to the consequences, by reason of which Plaintiff is entitled to punitive damages. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff claims damages against Defendant Baer in a compensatory and punitive sum both in excess of the arbitration limits of the court, plus interest and costs of suit. Submitted, Date: _V014- I ( I _'" ud' L4irry/AONeisberg, Esq. P.A. Bar ID # 83410 Derrek W. Cummings, Esq. P.A. Bar ID # 83286 2041 Herr St. Harrisburg, PA 17103-1624 (717) 238-5707 Fax: (717) 233-8133 E-mail: Iweisberg@mwcfirm.com 8 VERIFICATION I, Cindy L. Ryder, verify that I am the Plaintiff in the foregoing Complaint and that the facts set forth therein are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief; and that this verification is subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. § 4909 relative to unsworn falsification to authorities. 01 Dated: June, 2008. Cin y L. R er Q `1[ V "lJ V' 1\i" n ? 0 °n t --?? VT ,. -- C? n -n T L c{ "? co CD . wr IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CINDY L. RYDER, Plaintiff vs. STEPHANIE BAER, Defendant PRAECIPE FOR ENTRY OF APPEARANCE TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY: Please enter the appearance of Buzgon Davis Law Offices whose address is 525 South Eighth Street, P.O. Box 49, Lebanon, Pennsylvania 17042-0049, as attorneys for NO. 08-3651 CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED Stephanie Baer, the Defendant, in the above-captioned case. BUZGON DAVIS LAW OFFICES DATE: July 3, 2008 BY: S OTT GRENOBLE, ESQUIRE A ey I.D. #72808 525 South Eighth Street P.O. Box 49 Lebanon, PA 17042-0049 (717) 274-1421 (717) 274-1752 - facsimile Email: sgrenoble@buzgondavis.com w . I*- IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CINDY L. RYDER, Plaintiff NO. 08-3651 vs. CIVIL ACTION - LAW STEPHANIE BAER, JURY TRIAL DEMANDED Defendant AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA) ) ss: COUNTY OF LEBANON ) I, Janelle K. Worcester, an employee of the law firm of Buzgon Davis Law Offices, 525 South Eighth Street, Lebanon, Lebanon County, Pennsylvania, Attorneys for Defendant, being duly sworn according to law, depose and say that on July 3, 2008, I mailed to the Office of the Prothonotary of Cumberland County, the original PRAECIPE FOR ENTRY OF APPEARANCE and that I mailed, by First Class mail, in a postpaid envelope, a true and correct copy to Larry A. Weisberg, Esquire, 2041 Herr Street, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17103-1624, counsel for Plaintiff. Sworn to and subscribed before me this 3`d day of July, A.D., 2008. 14otary Public 20% OF PENNSYLVANIA Notarial Seal Undo 1.OWd Notary Public My Or Lebanon, Lebarm My Qwgy Oww"M Expi res July 3, 2011 Mlrnbar, P*n"$Y1V6n1* AsoccletWn of Nowlp ?t C Counsel for the Plaintiff McCarthy Webberg Cummings, P.C. 2041 Herr Street Harrisburg, PA 17103-1624 (717) 238-5707 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CINDY L. RYDER, NO. 08-3651 Civil Plaintiff V. CIVIL ACTION - LAW STEPHANIE BAER, JURY TRIAL DEMANDED Defendant ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE I accept service of Plaintiffs Complaint on behalf of myself, Defendant Stephanie Baer, and certify that I am authorized to do so. 7 i ?r Date 142 epha a Baer 337 East Garfield St. Shippensburg, PA 17257 IS" CD IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CINDY L. RYDER, Plaintiff NO. 08-3651 VS. CIVIL ACTION - LAW STEPHANIE BAER, JURY TRIAL DEMANDED Defendant AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA) ) ss: COUNTY OF LEBANON ) I, Janelle K. Worcester, an employee of the law firm of Buzgon Davis Law Offices, 525 South Eighth Street, Lebanon, Lebanon County, Pennsylvania, Attorneys for Defendant, being duly sworn according to law, depose and say that on August 1, 2008, I mailed the original and one copy of INTERROGATORIES and REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS OF DEFENDANT DIRECTED TO PLAINTIFF by First Class mail, in a postpaid envelope to Larry A. Weisberg, Esquire, 2041 Herr Street, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17103-1624, counsel for Plaintiff. Sworn to and subscribed before me this 1 st day of August, A.D., 2008. c Notary Public COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA Notarial Seal Linda i. (YNe#, Notary Public City Of Lebanon, Lebanon County W Co?mnission E)Vres July 3, 2011 Member, Pennsylvania Assoclatlon of Notaries v?r t, ,' . w <..x a ti s!?3a . ;1tls v?[ and NQw 9attcr.idix: -c)%?4i8 9 ,.S , 'I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CINDY L. RYDER, Plaintiff vs. STEPHANIE BAER, Defendant NO. 08-3651 CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED NOTICE TO PLEAD To Plaintiff: You are hereby notified to file a written response to the enclosed New Matter within twenty (20) days from service hereof or a judgment may be entered against you. ANSWER AND NEW MATTER AND NOW, comes the Defendant, Stephanie Baer, by her attorneys, Buzgon Davis Law Offices, and files this Answer and New Matter to Plaintiff's Complaint averring as follows: 1. ANSWER 1. Admitted upon information and belief. 2. Admitted. 3. Admitted. 4. Admitted. 5. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is admitted that Plaintiff was walking her dog at the referenced time. It is unknown as to whether the dog was "properly secured on a leash". 6. Denied. 7. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of paragraph 7, strict proof being demanded at trial. 8. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is denied that there was an "attack". It is admitted that Plaintiff grabbed the Baer Dog by the collar and thus removed it. By way of further response, upon information and belief, Plaintiff attempted to replace the collar on the Baer Dog. 9. Denied. 10. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is admitted that Plaintiff undertook to secure the collar back on the neck of the Baer Dog. 11. Denied. 12. Admitted upon information and belief. By way of further response, said allegations are denied. 13. Denied. 14. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to respond to the averments of paragraph 14, strict proof being demanded at trial. 15. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to respond to the averments of paragraph 15, strict proof being demanded at trial. -2- 16. Denied. FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION NEGLIGENCE, NEGLIGENCE PER SE, AND PUNITIVE DAMAGES 17. The answers to paragraphs 1 through 16 are incorporated herein by reference as if textually set forth at length. 18. Denied. The averments of paragraph 18 set forth conclusions of law to which no response is required. 19. Denied. The averments of paragraph 19 set forth conclusions of law to which no response is required. 20. Denied. The averments of paragraph 20 set forth conclusions of law to which no response is required. By way of further response, said allegations are denied, strict proof being demanded at trial. 21. Denied. The averments of paragraph 21 set forth conclusions of law to which no response is required. 22. Denied. The averments of paragraph 22 set forth conclusions of law to which no response is required. 23. Denied. The averments of paragraph 23 set forth conclusions of law to which no response is required. By way of further response, said allegations are denied, strict proof being demanded at trial. 24. (a)-(f). Denied. 25. Denied. The averments of paragraphs 25(a)-(t) set forth conclusions of law to which no response is required. By way of further response, said allegations are denied, strict proof being demanded at trial. -3- 26. Denied. The averments of paragraphs 26(a)-(h) set forth conclusions of law to which no response is required. By way of further response, said allegations are denied, strict proof being demanded at trial. 27. Denied. 28. Denied. The averments of paragraph 28 set forth conclusions of law to which no response is required. By way of further response, said allegations are denied, strict proof being demanded at trial. WHEREFORE, Defendant respectfully requests your Honorable Court to dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint with prejudice. II. NEW MATTER 29. The averments of paragraphs 1 through 28 are incorporated herein by reference as if textually set forth at length. 30. Defendant was not negligent, reckless, or careless with respect to any conduct regarding the injuries and damages alleged by Plaintiff. 31. Plaintiff's claims are barred or limited by the doctrine of assumption of the risk. 32. Plaintiff's claims are barred or limited by Plaintiff's own contributory negligence, including, but not limited to, attempting to re-collar Defendant's dog, which exacerbated the situation which directly resulted in Plaintiff's injuries, and failing to disengage from the situation. 33. Plaintiff's claims are barred or limited by Plaintiff's failure to use reasonable care. 34. Any acts or omissions of Defendant alleged to constitute negligence were not substantial causes and did not result in the injuries or losses alleged by Plaintiff. -4- VERIFICATION I, SCOTT L. GRENOBLE, do hereby verify that I am the attorney for Defendant, Stephanie Baer, in the within action. The facts set forth in the foregoing ANSWER AND NEW MATTER are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief, as conveyed to me by my client. My knowledge in this matter is based entirely on what has been passed to me by my client. I hereby further verify that I am signing this Verification on behalf of my client, pursuant to Rule 1024(c) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, because my client is unavailable to timely file this Verification within the time allowed for filing a pleading. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. §4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. Date: September 4, 2008 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CINDY L. RYDER, Plaintiff NO. 08-3651 vs. CIVIL ACTION - LAW STEPHANIE BAER, JURY TRIAL DEMANDED Defendant AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA) ) ss: COUNTY OF LEBANON ) I, Janelle K. Worcester, an employee of the law firm of Buzgon Davis Law Offices, 525 South Eighth Street, Lebanon, Lebanon County, Pennsylvania, Attorneys for Defendant, being duly sworn according to law, depose and say that on September 4, 2008, I mailed to the Office of the Prothonotary of Cumberland County, the original ANSWER AND NEW MATTER and that I mailed, by First Class mail, in a postpaid envelope, a true and correct copy to Larry A. Weisberg, Esquire, 2041 Herr Street, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17103-1624, counsel for Plaintiff. Sworn to and subscribed before me this 4`b day of September, A.D., 2008. &x, Notary P lic COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA Notarial Seal Amy HartranR, Notary Public City of Lebanon, Lebanon County IMy Commission Expires Sept. 19, 2010 Member, Pennsylvania Association of Notaries rn-i I F= Y i co .5 ?a . A McCarthy Weisberg Cummings, P.C. 2041 Herr Street Harrisburg, PA 17103-1624 (717) 238-5707 Attorneys for Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CINDY L. RYDER, NO. 08-3651 Plaintiff V. CIVIL ACTION - LAW STEPHANIE BAER, JURY TRIAL DEMANDED Defendant PLAINTIFF'S ANSWER TO DEFENDANT'S NEW MATTER The Plaintiff, Cindy L. Ryder, by and through her counsel, McCarthy Weisberg Cummings, P.C., files the following Answer to Defendant's New Matter, as follows: 29. No responsive pleading is required. 30. The averments of Paragraph 30 are a conclusion of law to which no responsive pleading is required. To the extent that a responsive pleading is required, the averments of Paragraph 30 are denied. 1 V Y 31. The averments of Paragraph 31 are a conclusion of law to which no responsive pleading is required. To the extent that a responsive pleading is required, the averments of Paragraph 31 are denied. 32. The averments, of Paragraph 32 are a conclusion of law to which no responsive pleading is required. To the extent that a responsive pleading is required, the averments of Paragraph 32 are denied. By way of further response, Plaintiff specifically denies that she attempted to re-collar Defendant's dog or the she failed to avail herself of any reasonable opportunity to disengage from the situation. 33. The averments of Paragraph 33 are a conclusion of law to which no responsive pleading is required. To the extent that a responsive pleading is required, the averments of Paragraph 33 are denied. 34. The averments of Paragraph 34 are a conclusion of law to which no responsive pleading is required. To the extent that a responsive pleading is required, the averments of Paragraph 34 are denied. Respectfully Submitted, Date: //- o(? Larry A. Weisberg, Esq. P.A. Bar ID # 83410 Derrek W. Cummings, Esq. P.A. Bar ID # 83286 2041 Herr St. Harrisburg, PA 17103-1624 (717) 238-5707 Fax: (717) 233-8133 E-mail: Iweisberg@mwcfirm.com 2 } VERIFICATION I, Cindy L. Ryder, verify that I am the Plaintiff in the foregoing Answer to Defendant's New Matter and that the facts set forth therein are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief; and that this verification is subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. § 4909 relative to unsworn falsification to authorities. Dated: September 2008. Cin y L. yder CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving a copy of the foregoing Answer to Defendant's New Matter upon the person and in the manner indicated below, which service satisfies the requirements of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, by depositing a copy of the same in the United States Mail, first-class postage prepaid, addressed as follows: Scott L. Grenoble, Esq. Buzgon Davis Law Offices 525 South Eighth Street P.O. Box 49 Lebanon, PA 17042-0049 (Counsel for Defendant) qDate McCarthy Weisberg Cummings, P.C. Larry"A. Weisberg, Esquire Sup. Ct. I.D. #83410 2041 Herr Street Harrisburg, PA 17103-1624 (717) 238-5707 (717) 233-8133 (FAX) Attorney for Plaintiff °sr ° q r;jGr ? 2.f v Zr r9 r„ C,ri ' C IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY RYDER Vs.. NO. 08365 1 BAER CERTIFICATE PREREQUISITE TO SERVICE OF A SUBPOENA PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.22 As a prerequisite to service of a subpoena(s) for documents and things pursuant to Rule 4009.22 SCOTT L GRENOBLE, ESQUIRE certifies that: 1. A Notice of Intent to Serve the Subpoena(s) with a copy of the subpoena(s) attached thereto was mailed or delivered to each party at least twenty days prior to the date on which the subpoena(s) is sought to be served, 2. A copy of the Notice of Intent, including the proposed subpoena(s) is attached to this certificate, 3. No objection to the subpoena(s) has been received, and 4. The subpoena(s) which will be served is identical to the subpoena(s) which is attached to the Notice of Intent to Serve the Subpoena(s). Date: 09/17/08 File #: M355716 SCOTT L GRENOBLE, ESQUIRE 525 S 8TH ST PO BOX 49 LEBANON, PA 17042 717-274-1421 ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT INQUIRIES SHOULD BE ADDRESSED TO: MEDICAL LEGAL REPRODUCTIONS, INC. 4940 DISSTON STREET PHILADELPHIA PA 19135 (215) 335-4907 By: Jamie Kendorski IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY RYDER Vs. BAER No. 083651 TO: LARRY WEISBERG, ESQ (PLAINTIFF) NOTICE OF INTENT TO SERVE A SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS AND THINGS FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.21 DEFENDANT intends to serve a subpoena(s) identical to the one(s) attached to this notice. You have twenty (20) days from the date listed below in which to file of record and serve upon the undersigned an objection to the subpoena. If no objection is made the subpoena may be served. Date:, 08/26/08 SCOTT L GRENOBLE, ESQUIRE 525 S 8TH ST PO BOX 49 LEBANON, PA 17042 ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT INQUIRIES SHOULD BE ADDRESSED TO: MEDICAL LEGAL REPRODUCTIONS, INC. 4940 DISSTON STREET PHILADELPHIA, PA 19135 (215) 335-4907 By: Jamie Kendorski Enc(s): Copy of subpoena(s) Counsel return card File #: M355716 9TLSS£R :# 6TTd papo u.znga.z Tasunoo (s) -euaodgrns go Adoo : (s) ous Txsaopuax aTwpf :As L06t,-S££ (STZ) S£T61 Xd 'VIHdrISGVgIHd ISHNIS NOI M OV6:V ' ONI ' smi mfiaoudau TibarI Tio ida ni os asss$saair as aznoHs s$i aoxi ILNVC[Nagaa do.3 71abrdOSS'd Z 3 O L T va ' NONVsH'S 6v XOS Od IS H18 S SZS a-difinsa ' Hriaom-dff) Z &LOOS 80/9Z/80 :a-4,ea •pat.aas aq A-em Pusodgns aTgq appw sT uoTgoa[go ou 3I •suaodgns aqj oq uoTgoalgo up pauBTs.aaptzn aqq uodn at?..zas pup p.aoo9a go 9ITI oq uoTUM ui MoTaq pagsTT agpp aqq woa; SAPP (0Z) A-4uaM-4 aAPq nod • aoTgou sTgq of pauoplgp (s)quo aqq oq TvoT-4uapT (s)-euaodgns v w aas oq spuaquT jNvaNsasa TV600i, 99nH OZ .LNVf1S2IfId AHaA03SIQ 2103 S`9NIRL C N V SJ-K3WaJ0G a3I1(l02Id OZ VKa0dffaS V aAHaS OZ JNaJM 90 931LON T99£80 'ON (daI,LNIK'Id) OSH 'DUESSIaM )MUVI :01 •sn M UN A LNnoa (INV I2I9Swaa 3o Svarld NOW N03 90 lHa0z) aHL NI 9TLSSER papo uangaa Tasuno0 (s)puaodgns go !LdoO TXSaopuaX aTwPf :A9 L06:V-SEE (STZ) SET6T Vd 'VIHdrIEC[V'IIHd SSS2i.LS NOIL SIQ OV6V 0NI ' SNOII,0IIQ0ddMl 'I` E)H'I TVDIQSW Os asssamay as agnoRs smiumaHI JN CIMH 3SQ Wa TiSN-d0IIV Z tIO L T Vd ' NONXSHrI 6f, XOS Od IS H18 S SZS MdifloSS 'S'IgONHUE) Z S.100s :# aTTa (s) OTIS 80/9Z/80 :a-4'eci • paaaas aq Apm Puaodgns attq apvm sz uoTgoaCgo ou 3I -puaodgns qqq oq uozgoaCgo up pauBTsaapun atgq uodn aAaas put paooaa 90 9IT9 oq uoTgm ui MoTaq pagsTT 942p aqq tuna; sApp (0 Z) Aquamq aAPu no7, • aozgou STgq oq pGgDPgqP (s) auo atjg oq TPaiquapT (s)Euaodgns 2 aAaas oq spuaquz iNvcNS3SQ . IZ'6W =,a OZ jwvf1S2 j xHaAOaSI(i 2IOd SOAIIH.L cNv S.I.IlIm IMoQ aZ)f1Q02Id 01 VKHOdRaS V aAHaS OZ .LI HJM JO a3IZON TS9E80 'oN - SA (aaiiNIvga) OSS 'J2ISHSISM mduva :OZ UavEl URCUli AJLNaOJ UNVrIHHZWfI3 10 SV2[rld NOWN03 30 JM03 3M NI 3Dodd SIHl Nsnn'm (INV NDIS TO-9TLSSEN C[Rv -dHElKn3 SWH HUGHS SSSM aoj aanIeu6TS pazTaoggn? aged oaAoagsap uaaq aneq S7,VdX / SGUODaU ( ) S7?xx-X ( ) romiq is INSIZFid ( ) SGUODau ( ) (XOS aIVIUd0HddV SHZ X3aH3) paqeooT uaaq aneq squaiunoop 6uzMOTTo; aqq ;o paooaa ou gegq pup appw uaaq seq goaeas g6noaogq e gegq A;Tgaao Aqaaaq I :g7SV7IVAV SI)Vg11 ajoa OAT [ 1 paonpoad uaaq anew pauO.TquaW anoge sbuTgq JO squawnoop TTe jaTTaq pup uoTgvwao;ui '96p9TMOUx Aw jo gsaq aqq oq 'gegq spaooaa ;o uetpojsno se Ajzgaao Aqaaaq I :O.L",yH agHOV.L,LV gyV SQ?10jgy I I\12117AA (I NV 313ldWOD ° NVI aois nD GA OD311 'a3KVUVHddV rIVNOSH3d HaoA 30 il3I'I NJ Q3Zd3j3V 39 'I HM SHM0301011d GHIMIUK)` totlEXXXXX =NvSS o-9/9Z/ZT :H,L'dIS d0 HIVCl Vd UnSSNHddIHS is aaaij vD H iEE : ssadcia6' URCUld rI AQNIO : aWVN OZ JNINIVIU3d *Vd 'DWnSSNHddIHS 'ZS aagIdUVO S :EE IV ?8 OIQHW - L0/6T/0T 30 IU0dSNKdZ d0 SCM00HU TTV SW2[ 3HOHS lSaM ='dOd SCrd00H'H 30 NVIQOISfID TS9E80 'ON Uavq - SA 2iSa.I2i viviOd ua s of ma aNgaav (L6/1. '433) A4ndap 1 ,--(UOtsLnLp L4At0 ° tO/A-ml40uo4goud s F -0 : i2i= 3H1 AS _ -4u? 044 10 l aS a-7 :31VCf - ZO-9TLS?Ew IINVCIN535Q : a0j A3NUO.UV ZTZ£-S££-9TZ # 01 lli W 3W01&S Z:?0 L T Kd ' MONVga I :3NOHd3l31 OSS ' SZ :3WVN : NOS83d ON I MOl10d 3HL JO 1S3r O32i 3H1 1V a WW I SVM VN30daM S I RL '4? 44?M A1cl, o4 noA 6uL1todu= apjo aUnoo a Baas Aew eueodgns (ALA. 6u? nJas A:I and a4,4 ' ao; A.MS sq ? jo;lB sABp (OZ) ?4uaMj uiy-4tM eueodgns st44 Aq peiLrbau SSUL4'4 ao squaunoop 941 aonpoUd oq jte3 noA .41 •446nos s6u «{j 944 6uLOnpoUd uo saLdoo 944 6ulJedaJd 30 4sOO a?gEUOt?eaU a4- aOUenps UL 4995 04 446?u 944 aAB4 noA °anogn pagsit sseippe 941 qv 4senbaa ..,yp But Aq-xed aqq oq 'aOUVLLd = 30 0-4eOL41-4UaO 944 L14lM ua4-4960-4 'euaodgns siy-4 1,,i pa 4sanbau sbu L 44 oonpoid .ao squeumop e4q 40 sa L dOO a l %6a t t ? ew JO .pan L l op Alu m k did ''viva ° *.is xoLssIa 0V6Vs )'sKoILonaovdx'a 7yeari 'IYOIam -- mi.crvamy Qmayssu aas • s u PA Jo uWOH OW 6u t Mo l t o4 94; aonpoid oq lino o4g Aq pejapio eiv noA 'euscdgns slyq 40 aOLn.aas .JajJe sAtp (0z) A4uaM4 uL44?M (A-4tIu3 JO uosJad Jo QMN) : 0J. LSZLT add EMUSNSddIHS '69 XOS Od ' SWH VaUV E)UfISSNSddIHS Z ' 6004 3Y12i 01 1NW)SUnd A83AOOS I 0 iiOd SON I HL 80 SIN3?C= 3Of1 Md Ol VN TS9E80 'ON SLtA i a-- rho A. AIM VIM-LXSNRaa ao RITtamoMm Idava SA HaCU i 4 -v 4 3Ddd SIHl X1snild alb Y MD IS U-9TLSSEW QNVrI2I39WIID SWS VHUV 0Un9SNHddIHS aog aangvubzs pazzaogq pafoagsap uaaq aAPq S)?VdX / SGUOOS2I ( ) omIggIg INHIlvd ( ) age0 SIRVa-X ( ) SGWDS2l ( ) (X08 HlVIUd0HddV SHI XDHHD) PaIPOOT uaaq GA-12q SgU9 naop BUTMOTTO; agq go paooaa ou g2gq pup appw uaaq sug goavas gbnoaogq P gvgq AJTgJao Aga-lag I :g7SV7IVAV S.LAT3KI2000 OAT [ 1 •paonpoad uaaq aAPq pauOTgUGW GAOgp sbuTgq ao squawnoop Ilp jaTTaq pup uOT4PwaOJuz ' abpaTMOu3{ Aui go gsaq agq oq ' lpgq spaooaa go upzpogsno sv Ajzgaao Agaaaq I :O.LgyYH ajHOVJKLV 3IIV SQ2IOO [ Iv[-mild a»d 313ldWOD ® NVIaoisnD (TODD H 'UJNVUV2[ddV 'IVNOS?Iad IMOA AO flalrl NI QalAaDDY ag TILU SaId030Z0Hd (1211) LU20 ?v0:?£XXXXX :NKSS 09/9Z/ZT :H,LUIg 30 HSKQ rdd `NMRSNHddIHS IS CYIHId2IXO H tU : SS?16CCIi USCU'd rI )?QNID : HWKN 01 ONINIVIdad E L O Z HONE gnEWK 90 lU0d SNVHl QNK grI'dD ONI MIVOE d SCINODS'd rI'IV SY?I? V V O?Il1SSl?I?ddIHS ' 2I03 SaHoDad do NVICloJ s la TS9E80 'ON iIHva sly ldscUli vNjoju a S ®.i iva aNgaav U611. '3d3) A4ndao :- UOLSLAL0 L ?At0 ' lO/A-anouogjoud Fig 3unoO 844 30 L MS -: 31VCI E 0- 9 T L S S. EA . iWM 3H1 AS ZNKQN333Q UOd A3NHOIL ` ZTZE-SEE-STZ # a1 1kV= 3J323dns Z v 0 L'T vd ' NONKS3'I :3NOHd3l31 EBB iiS O_ C ["7[" J :SS3bOClV 0SH 'a : NOSH3d DN1MOTIOd 3H1 30 1S3M38 3H1 lb a3nSSI SbM VN30d9M SIHi '41 44?M Aid, o-4 noA 6uLlladu= _,epjo 4Jnoo e moos ALxu euaodgns e i 4a. 6U L AJOS 44jed 941 ' eo; AJOS s'4t aa438 sAEp (¢Z ) 44UZAI uL44?M sueodgns sL4p Aq pauinbei s6uL41 jo squauracp a4laonpoid oa Ltvj noA j1 •-446nos s6uL4-4 944 6uLonpoid JO saLdoo 0414 6uL..mcioid ;o 4soo 3lgsuoseau ay; aousnps ut A90S 04 g46?u a4q an84 noA 'anogs p94SLL ssaJpps a44 Iv 4senbaj t y,4 6u ? ?vw A4..MCI a4-4 04 ' aoue L L duoo 10 9-4so t d ? J Sao a4q qq t m ja4-496oq 'suaodgns s L 4-4 cq PalsanbaJ sbuL44 sonpoad ao squeunoop a4,4 40 SaLdoo alq?6al Lew JO JaALlep Astu noA va ° ° rd'IIHd "Is KolsSIa o v4f S' )' sxoiSOnaoxa3u 7yo3z 'z iam 4-8 wriaK may aaHay jL v 2tas :s6uL44 JO SIuallnOop 6uLMoll04 aye aonpoi oq lino aqj Aq poiepio eje noA 'suaodgns sL44 40 aoLAJas -1014s sAg p (OZ) AquaM4 uL44tM (A,4tIu3 Jo UOSJad 10 QMN) TOZLT Vd -dfl9MM9WVH0 'ZS HZL N ZTT 'dSOH DIdENISIla9 WHO -Ol Z? 6001V?pM Ol 1NYMUnd Add I a a0d a3SsanOwd JtIIZ`II?aB -1N31?b00 356WHd Ol VNM@W Nava TS9E80 'ON eL ?d -SA USCUU auinoDw ao xamm YllqVAa Jo £0-9TLSS£W aN'dTdaaWnJ dSOH DUn9SUH9WVH0 ao; aangeuBTs pazzaougn*d paAoagsap uaaq aAPq S2iVUX / SCrdoDaU ( ) ONIggIH ZNHIlVd ( ) a-4-a S7,VU - X ( ) Sa-doDS I ( ) (X09 RIVIUdO-dddK alll NDaHO) pagpooT uaaq aAPq squawnoop SuTMOTTo3 auq jo paooaa ou gpu-q pup appw uaaq spq goapas gBnoaoq L gpgq A;zgaao Agoaaq I :,V7gV7IVAV SLAIgW,2joa oV paonpoad uaaq 9APq p9uoz4u9tu anogv s5uzuq ao squaiunoop TTP jaiTaq pup uozgpuiaojui 'abpaTMouN Aw jo gsaq auq oq 'gpuq spaooaa jo uprpoqsno sp Aizgaao Agaaau I ?O.L?H Q?H??'.L.L?'?' SQ?IO? [ J mnlU U NY 313IMOD - NVIaois ID ®21OD3A •aHCrdV iHOd -9AIIM SQHOJaH Os HOiHd GaAOHdJV 39 iSAW SHHA rIrTV aassanoald JNI'I'IIS 'IKOIasw tl0 :?£XXXXX : NvSS 09/9Z/ZT :HJHIEI 30 HJVCI Vd 02In$SNSddIHS IS arISDDI E) a t££ : SSa2IQQFi 'daCX I rI XQNI o : SWKN Os `JNINIviuad ' ,LN3 SS2id HHI OZ LO/6T/OT WOHa S'IrII S aNV SCMDaH WOO'd &DNaf)-dHWa aNV ZNEIS,KdS,nO ',LNSIJVdNl 'I'IV (INV XW dSOH -91MHSH2[RWVHJ :'dOd SaxOOSx 30 NXIaOSSna TS9£80 'ON 'davEl - SA x?a?x U61L '433) A-4ndaO uo t S L n L o I f A LO ' "1 O/Ajvgouo44oad 'id= 3H1 AB 3unO0 944 ;o I R PS Me ? 31Va ,LNKQN33SQ 2103 k3NW1 LV ZTZ£-S££-STZ # a1 L8rK)o 3438dns ZtoLT `'a'd 'NONE 2Hq VO-9TLSS£l? 3NOHd3l3.L ?S-?Z O--S S7 5 SS3800V OSS ' Sr! :3 VN sNOS213d JNIMOIIOd 3Hi 3O 1S3M31 3Hi lb 03nSSI SVM VN30dgM SIH! • 4t 44t m A tel l oq noA SU L L I aducxa . +apio 4inoo a Baas ABw Buaodgns i 4q. 6u t Ajas A4.md a4-4 ' ao; AJas s j ? ja4}8 sA2p (oz) A4uaMj ULgj?m Euaodgns SLg4 Aq pauinbau s6ui4-4 jo s,4uaurcop a4g aonpoid oq ILE3 noA 31 •j46nos s6UL41 944 6utonpoud uo satdoo 944 BUL.eoaud 40 4so0 3?g2uosaau a4; QOUBAp8 ut Maas 04 446tu 244 aAE4 nOA •anoge p94SL1 ssaupps a44 38 4sanbal 4 j 6u L pis A4..md a44 oq ' aoLML I dui 40 G J VO L 4 t 4,rao 944 Li4 t M ..i94'49603 ' Euaodgns s i 4j ,i palsenbau SBu L 43 eonpoid jo s3uaunoop 943 40sa L doo a 1 q L 6a 1 I V ew Jo aan LI ap Agw noA Yd ' Y IIHd -is Zs mo.LsSIa 0$6VSa )'sxoi.LOnaoxaSx riveaI 'IYOIQam 48 11trlQNWRIV Q3JVJLJL ' MIS -- as6u 43 ,ao s3 op 6ua IIo_4 943 sorpoid o4 4 unoo a43 Aq pajap.,io am noA ' eueodgns s t 43 40 BOLA-MS jai}B s4ep (OZ) A4mm4 u t 43 ? M (A3 t 3u3 JO uos.aad do GMN) TOZLT Vd E IISSHEMWHO 'ZS HZL N ZTT 'X-dSOH 0-dn9S-dH9IKHO 'Ol ZZ • 600V 3W Ol 1NVMWd ktl3AOOS 10 2103 SON 1 HL 210 S1.N3 rooo 30rM8d Ol VN3odens a$ssanbau sayx-x zyHlo=xo TSMO 'ON al ?3 -SA xSQA2i clrfidam?m Jo MUM vINFIA d 3o ULTI VKMWM 3 DYd S 11•°1.1, N,*d n13'd CI NY del J d S :?0-9TLSS£W aN'dri=lWno X - d SOH DUn9SUH9WVHO .70; aan-4Pubts pazzaOT4-4 agaa paAoagsap uaaq aAPq S) FVHX / Sa2I0092i ( ) S7,vu-X ( ) JNI'IZIS INailvd ( ) scuoDaH ( ) (XOS SSKIHdO-dddX SHI ?IOSHO) pagPooT uaaq aAvq squauinoop buTmoTToI auq jo paooaa ou gp-gq puv apEui uaaq sPLj goapas gbnoaogl p gpuq Ajzgaao Agaaaq I -a75v7ivA 6' S.LAtamlljoa av [ J • paonpoad uaaq aAPq pauotquaW 9Aogp sbuzuq aO squauinoop TTP 49TTaq PUP uolgPulaoguz ' abpaTmOU'X Aui ;o gsaq auq oq ' jetiq spaooa.a _40 u-2zpogsno sv AiT-4zao Agaaaq I :O,LgggH aVHJVL.LV gyV 5QZ10a? [ l 1°121111321 GMY 3i3ldWOD ° NVIaoisnD (IAOD3A aS J,SRIk saga 'I'II' °(Iac[u muoa -9slilS S(mooa 101.2IORId Qa-AOuddv , aSSSanbsx s7,ya-x gvmisiuo bot£xxxxx :NKSS 09/9Z/ZT =HI'dIg ,30 aJVCI pfd ounasNSddIHS IS CIrISIdUV5 S K£ : SSS2taaII uaci7lu Z )?aNIO : aWVN OZ ONINIVIUSd INSSHEd OZ L0/6T/OT WOUa SWgIa Z'IV aNX A-NV X-dSOH -Dj0ffS?I3ffVJVHJ :'dO3 SCMODS-d aO NVIQO,LSnO TS9£80 ON 'sn -d ava URCIA'd vivjoasn s of mn aNjaav (Wi. •433) AgrdaQ 7Vr!7-r7 r) - ", f u uo L S L A L Q J l A LO '± l 0/A.,rQ?v? ---? 7 S '4.rro00 94-4 }o eaS -_? :31VG SO-9TLS9E-14 : i.8n00 3H.1 AS INKQNS3SQ : d03 A3Nd011V ZTZC-SEE-STZ # QI I&= 343ddM Z V 0 L T Kd ' NONVUHa : 3NOHd3'13J. -fig S S qzS : SS3dOQv OSE ' SZgOR -ffL I : N NOS83d JN I MOll03 3KL 30 1SW038 3H1 l t d a3ftSS I SVM VN3OdW S S I t U 4 ? 44 tM A l dui 04 not 6u L l l actin, !apio I,lnoo a ? oos Aew euaodgn, U i yg. 6u1 Auas Aq-md ayq ' ao; AJOS s4 ?. J94 _4V sAteP (OZ : ri4uaMa u 414 M Euaodgns st4,4 ,tq pa tnbau s6ut4,4 .so squaunoop a44 a0npoud 0-4 l 93 not I 446nos s6u t 41 9L44 6u L onPOJCI uo sa t doO 941 6u L , mdeud 4o 4soo a geuoseaJ ay r aOUenpe u L )Iaas o3 I4s ? u a4q aney noA • anoqR p814s L l ssa.ippe a4n -4e -senba.j t yq 6u i >Mw A,4-md e4q o4 ' Q*UV t l d LM 40 G jRO c 4 14J90 944 LI4 t M J9419601 ' euaodgns s c y- +y Pa-}sanba u s6u y4 aOnpo.ad JO s4uaur?op aye 10 sa LdoO a l q t Se j l ? Ew JO MA L Lop Asw noA Yd ° ,YgiHd ° *is KoissIQ OV66,5So)ffVrsxoiionaoudzu gvez'I gyoiaam ;e lya(I H(I([ ' (l HjyjUv Has -- -- :s6uL4-4 JO s4uaunoop 6uLMoll04 94; oonpoict oq unoo aye Aq pa, rap.ao aie not ' suaodgns s . y 4 Jo aO t A„ tas .J3q j8 sAvp (OZ) A4uaM4 u t 44 ? M (Aqq IU3 JO uos.aad 10 QMN) T O Z L T Kd ` 7dflE[S'da9 IKHO ' T alS aAV aNAKM S E O T ' SOOS SV OIQSdOHIE0 :Q.- ZZ•600q rnu Oi 1NVMdnd A83AOOSIQ W: SON I H1 80 SJN3WX= 30C100ad Ol VN IS9ESO *ON al tj • SA 2IHQA.'d CNVTSHEKD ao AjArm VIMgASNNM 30 HZ'IFI0N[1Q @W 3DVd SIHI oe1MIRI (INN NOIS SO-9TLSSEW QNV IusSbQIIO SOOSSV OIGHWH.INO log aangpubzs paZT.zoTq-q paAOagsap uaaq aAPq S-YYUX / Sa2i0OaH ( ) ONIggIS INailvd ( ) a-3 aa S)?K2I - X ( ) Sa?IODau ( ) (XOS HIVINdOUddK SHI XOSHO) palpooT uaaq GAPq squaUinoop SUTMOTTO; auq go paooax ou gvuq pup appiu uaaq spq goaaas ubnoaogq P gpuq A;Tgaao Agaxaq I :a7ffv-ii Av S,L)vgwnj6a om [ J paonpoid uaaq 9AVq paUOTquaW aAoge sbuTgq ao squawnoop TTP ;aTTaq puv uozgvuaOJuz 'abpaTMOUX Aw go gsaq aqq oq `gptjq spaooaa go uPip046no SP A itlaao Xgaaau I :O.L3mvH agH36'.uv "v SQ?IOD3?t [ ) N-sn.BA GNV U31dWOD - NviaO.LSn:) GSOD3A 'H3NVHVHdJV 'IVNOSH2[d IHaOA AO r19I1 NI (13"333V 39 'I'IIM SdIdO:)O.LOHd (IdIdLLUT) V0T7£XXXXX :NKSs 09/9Z/ZT :HLdIS aO SJVCI Kd 02InsSNSddIHS IS a'IHIAUVE) S IiE£ : SSaNaaV xaaAx rl AaNIO : awvx OZ ONINIVIUSd ' INSSHUd 01 LO/6T/OT WOUa SCINODTH rIrIK QNK ANV SDOSSV DIaHdOHZIIO : uOd Sax0321x aO NVIaOJ SnO '[59£80 'ON IdavEl • SA USCUU vAijoju l S of iva aNjaav N611. '143) Rgndaa :- ? u0 L s L^ L a I? A `O 'jig i O/A„aegouO4l0ud :ian00 3Hl R9 ZNWINUSQ 90-9TLSSic"A : UOA k3NUO.U ' ZTZE-SEE-STZ al ldf= XMdnS Z V 0 L T Kd ' NObrVgZ'I : 3NOHd3131 1s RI-2 S-SZS SS3b'<XN osa 'sgeonam-i amono :3WVN :NOS83d JNIMO-1103 3H1 30 1S3n036 3H1 1V aWWI SVM VN3odSM SIHl. •4? 44tm ALCM 0,4 noR 6utlladUM ap.jo 4unoo v Baas AvLu euaodgnfs L 44 6u i n.aas A14.aed aye as ; A. ias s? t „+x448 sAep (()Z) A4ua.;j u t 44 ? M euaodgns Slop Aq Pay l nbau sSu t 41 jo s4usuroop 94-4 QOnpOUd of I ? v4 not 41' •446nos s6ut44 944 6uionpo-:d uo satdOO ay4 SUL.MCiQ Jd 40 4sao alg2uo_R9J ayT aOUBnpe ul Maas o-4 '446iJ a4-4 anE4 noA °anogR pa4s?1 ssa-Jpp8 944 '4v -4sanbau ? yq 6u i ?{ew A,4jed 944 04 ` anus L I cb= 40 ajso t 3 ? j..rao 9414 LI4 t M J944960-4 ' 8uaodgns s i 4-4 ti Palsonbau SBu t 44 sonpoud jo s4ueur oop 944 j4o so L doo a I q b SO L L I Btu JO JOA L Lop Am nok yd ' *YgiHd -is is Koissia OV6OS9MVr sxoISonaoudx-d ZYOSZ 'IYOIQaw 48 I)Va N21(lay (l Ha`dsZv Has : s6u L 44 Jo s4uaur$OOp 6u LmO H 04 944 oonpoad 04 4 Jnoo 044 Aq pejapio eiv nog( ' 8ueodgns s L 44 40 ao t AJas .1aq j8 sAvp (OZ) A;uaM4 u L 43 W (Aq?qua ao uos and do MMN) LSZLT Vd DHfISSN3ddIHS 'Qx W01109 InN?NI E6 'dSOH 'I'aWINK J2iIISSNSddIHS 01 Woof 37% Ol Imnsand Ad3AOOS I a ao3 crais$nna-d )tar ZISS a-%s-LN 30no0ad Ol VN30a 'davEl "ON a1?3 .SA 'daa72I cmwDmEn-o rho Amnoo VItWA'IXSNNaa JO HIM4324NOWWo° 4 4 4 3DVd SIH1 N'dn13? GNV MIDIS 90-9TLSSEW cluv I2iSSWIIO dSOH gVWINV Dda9SNSddIHS log aangpuBTS pazzaougn? agaa paRozgsap uaaq aApq S7,VHX / Sa2I00SU ( ) SRVU-X ( ) ONIUgIS SN3ILVd ( ) Sa2I00S2I ( } (XOS aIVIHd0UddK SHZ XDSHO) pagpooT uaaq 9n2Lj SgU9=00p buTmOTT09 9ql ;o paooaa ou gPuq put apeui uaaq sPq goavas gBnoaogq L 4vgl AJTIaao Agaaaq I :g?gd7IVAV SjjVgI4llI000 OAI t 'paonpoad uaaq aAPq pauozgUgW aAOgL sbuTgq ao squawnoop TTP ;azTag puL UOTgP iaOJUT ' abpaTMouX Aui ;o gsaq eqq oq ' gpgq spaooaa ;o uprpoqsno sp A iTgaao Agaaau I .01",VH ajHjV.L,LV ,VSQ?IOO t i 1\I?lmu (IMd 3131dWOD ° NVIaoisnD adoDu °a3NvHvaddv 'IvN0SH2[d HaOA d0 n317 NI amLda3jv ag ' mm saido3oloxd GMAI.LHa3 aalssaoa i ONI'Ir is rrvDIGHN fl0 : E XXXXX : Nvs S 09/9Z/ZT :HJUIS 30 HJVCI Vd )UfI8SNSddIHS IS a'ISI3UV5 S fii E £ : SSS?3aaII 2tSaFi2[ Z 7saNIO : SWVN OZ ONINIVI USd (VnHVnHIHO) ZSZSS2id 30 ZNaKLVaUl HOd SggIS aNV Sa2i00sU 'I'II' dsoH 'Ivwimv oHnasNaddIHs : -dO3 SaxoDS-d dO NVIaOSSnD TS9E8o 'ON Uava . SA URCUN vNgod Sa s 01 Ka aNgQav (L6/L '433) A4ndaQ ,r-tiO L S L n t a Lt A LO ° t o/A, mjouoy4oud ?p s :.L8nM 3H1 AS r 4urJ 944 10 l v ?S 3 z s 3.LVG ZNVCINHdS(i LO-9TLSSi'W 80,1 A3N2 OA-LV ZTZ£-S££-STZ # Oi 12if m 3,m" Z V 0 L T Vd ' NOXVUH'I > 3NOHd3'Y l ?a HZ8 ?S7S - :SS3 bSEl 'SZ ;3WVN : NOSH3d ON I MO IOd ALL' d0 ISW038 3H1 lb a3nSS I SLIM VN30dg)S S I Hl °4L 44Lm Aldw? oq noA SULlladu= .-ap-jo lino a Baas AEw eueodgns; s L t4q 6UL AJOs Alied ay,4 ' aa; AJOS sat as}3e s?tsp (07, ) A4uaMj uL44LM eueodgns sLyp Aq pa.?inbau s6uLyl jo squounoop ayq aonpo.id oq 1Lea not }I • -4y6nos s6u L y4 at;q 6u L onpo.;d uo sa L doo ayq 6u L ieaajd 4o 4soo algeuoseaJ ayT aouenpe ut X2es 04 4y6Lu 941 ansy noA °anoge pagsil ssauppe ayq 4e 4sanbal a ? yq 6u L dew A4 .ted ay-4 o-4 ' aoue L l d = 40 a jgo c 4 L jJao 9144 t114t M u9449601 ' euewgns s L yj ?q pa,4sanbau s6uL4,4 eonpoid jo s-4usunoop ayq 4o soLdoo algL69l Hlew uo JanLtap Am noA Yd ' *VglHa `IS KOISSIa Ot6V drsxolionaoxazx 'IKJ3z 'IyoIazx Is ----- 14MG IAG(W QHHaVssV MIS --- : s6u L 44 ao s4ua UlOW 6u L Iwo l l o4 ayq oonpoid 0-4 -4unoo ayq Aq paiepio ejo noA 'eueodgns sLy }o asLA,tas .rah}a sAep (OZ) A uaM-4 utyaLM _ (AILqu3 Jo uosaad do SMN) ,Uduu Su i %L :o ZOZLT did DdflElS'da9WiHO 's 7,'dM NgOONIU 0:£T 'dSOH gVWINV DUnES2IaeNVHO l ZZ ' 600q 31M Ol 1NbYt 8nd AU3AOOS I O a04 azsssna$x JxIgaias% aWAS1N3 i=O 3XM8d Ol tM xsva M,TE .ON al ?d ' SA UR(Uul I affTROaHm SO A.NI[l0U ADDENDUM TO SUBPOENA RYDER Vs. BAER No. 083651 CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS FOR: CHAMBERSBURG ANIMAL HOSP ALL RECORDS AND BILLS FOR TREATMENT OF PRETZEL (CHIHUAHUA). PERTAINING TO: NAME: CINDY L RYDER ADDRESS: 334 E GARFIELD ST SHIPPENSBURG PA DATE OF BIRTH: 12/26/60 SSAN: XXXXX3404 MEDICAL BILLING REQUESTED CERTIFIED PHOTOCOPIES WILL BE ACCEPTED IN LIEU OF YOUR PERSONAL APPEARANCE. RECORD CUSTODIAN a COMPLETE AND RETURN [ ] RECORDS ARE ATTACHED HERETO. I hereby certify as custodian of records that, to the best of my knowledge, information and belief all documents or things above mentioned have been produced. [ ] NO DOCUMENTS AVAILABLE. I hereby certify that a thorough search has been made and that no record of the following documents have been located (CHECK THE APPROPRIATE BOX): ( ) RECORDS ( ) PATIENT BILLING ( ) X-RAYS ( ) RECORDS / XRAYS have been destroyed Date Authorized signature for CHAMBERSBURG ANIMAL HOSP CUMBERLAND M355716-07 * * * SIGN AND RETURN THIS PACE ?."' ? a Y ' ae C./'? '?^'?? ??.. : ` ' ?? ^?t ...r ?.?w ?fy 1 " r.? ? ?? . ?,, ..l I .4% Counsel for Plaintiff McCarthy Weisberg Cummings, P.C. 2041 Herr St. Harrisburg, PA 17103-1624 (717) 238-5707 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CINDY L. RYDER, NO. 08-3651 Plaintiff V. CIVIL ACTION - LAW STEPHANIE BAER, Defendant PRAECIPE TO DISCONTINUE ACTION Pursuant to Rule 229 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, Plaintiff Cindy L. Ryder, hereby files this Praecipe to discontinue the above captioned matter against all named defendants. Respectfully submitted, Date: //,- y oop McCarthy Weisberg Cummings, P.C. 2041 Herr St. Harrisburg, PA 17103-1624 (717) 238-5707 Fax: (717) 233-8133 Email: Iweisberg@mwcfirm.com Attorney for Plaintiff By 1/ 14 L-/ Larryeisberg, Esq.,PA I.D. #83410 ,, . ?% CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving a copy of the foregoing Praecipe to Discontinue Action upon the person and in the manner indicated below, which service satisfies the requirements of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, by depositing a copy of the same in the United States Mail, first-class postage prepaid, addressed as follows: Scott L. Grenoble, Esq. Buzgon Davis Law Offices 525 South Eighth Street P.O. Box 49 Lebanon, PA 17042-0049 (Counsel for Defendant) /I- Date McCarthy Weisberg Cummings, P.C. Larry A. Weisberg, Esquire Sup. Ct. I.D. #83410 2041 Herr Street Harrisburg, PA 17103-1624 (717) 238-5707 (717) 233-8133 (FAX) Attorney for Plaintiff C5 ra I r\D