HomeMy WebLinkAbout01-6560INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT
SERVICES, INC.,
Plaintiff
ALBERT R. THOMAS, SHERI THOMAS
and HAYES, STOUDT & ASSOCIATES,
INC.,
Defendants
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO: 01-~,~'60 ~ '-7"'z..---.
EQUITY
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the
following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and notice are
served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and fihng in writing with the court
your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to
do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the court
without further notice for any money claimed in the complaint or for any other claim or relief
requested by the plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT
HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET
FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Cumberland County Bar Association
2 Liberty Avenue
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 249-3166
INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT
SERVICES, INC.,
Plaintiff
Vo
ALBERT R. THOMAS, SHERI THOMAS
and HAYES, STOUDT & ASSOCIATES,
INC.,
Defendants
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO:
EQUITY
COMPLAINT IN EQUITY
1. The Plaintifflnvestigative Consultant Services, Inc. (hereinafter "ICS") is a
corporation incorporated and doing business under the laws of the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania with its principal place of business located at 4004 Trindle Road, Camp Hill,
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17011.
2. Defendant Albert R. Thomas is an adult individual with a present address of 118
East Second Street, Mt. Carmel, Pennsylvania 17851.
3. Defendant Sheri Thomas is an adult individual with a present address of 118 East
Second Street, Mr. Carmel, Pennsylvania 17851.
4. Defendant Hayes, Stoudt & Associates, Inc. (hereinafter "Hayes Stoudt") is a
corporation incorporated and doing business under the laws of the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania with its principal place of business located at 328 West Broad Street, Suite 200,
Quakertown, Pennsylvania 18951.
COUNT !
Breach of Contract (Covenant Not to Compete)
ICS v. Albert IL Thomas and Hayes, Stoudt & Associates, Inc.
5. On December 1, 1995, Plaintiff ICS and Defendant Albert R. Thomas entered into
a valid written employment agreement under whose terms ICS hired Defendant Albert R.
Thomas as an investigator (hereinafter "employment contract"). A true and correct copy of the
aforesaid employment contract is attached hereto, made a part hereof and marked as Exhibit "A".
6. In accordance with the employment contract, Defendant Albert R. Thomas agreed,
in consideration of his employment, training and salary, that he would be prohibited for two (2)
years from the termination of his employment with ICS from doing any of the following:
a. Divulging the names or addresses of any of the clients or customers oflCS
to any party not employed by ICS; and
b. Calling on or marketing any current client of ICS on behalf of himself or
any other employer.
7. In addition, Defendant Albert R. Thomas agreed that if he violated the aforesaid
contractual provision and performed services for any client oflCS during the said two (2) year
period following his termination of employment with ICS either personally or on behalf of a new
employer he would pay ICS 100% of any fees paid by said client oflCS.
8. On October 30, 2000, Defendant Albert R. Thomas voluntarily terminated his
employment with ICS, subject to the terms and conditions of the employment contract attached
hereto as Exhibit "A".
9. Defendant Albert R. Thomas has become associated with Defendant Hayes
Stoudt, a direct competitor oflCS.
10. By way of a letter dated September 4, 2001, the attorneys for Plaintiff ICS
advised Defendant Hayes Stoudt that Defendants Albert and Shed Thomas were in violation of
the restrictive covenants contained in the employment contracts and that Defendant Hayes Stoudt
account for all fees received by it from the ICS clients identified above. In particular, ICS's
attorneys advised Defendant Hayes Stoudt that Defendant Albert Thomas had violated his
employment contract by contacting Travelers Investigative Services and Selective Insurance
Company. A true and correct copy of the aforesaid letter is attached hereto as Exhibit "B".
11. To date, Defendant Hayes Stoudt has failed and refused to account for the fees it
has received 15om ICS's clients, and in fact has refused to even respond to the aforesaid letter.
12. Defendant Albert R. Thomas has been contacting and soliciting existing and
former clients oflCS in an effort to have them shift work f~om ICS to his new employer,
Defendant Hayes Stoudt, in violation of the express terms and conditions of the employment
contract attached hereto as Exhibit "A".
13. The clients oflCS, which Defendant Albert R. Thomas has contacted and
solicited on behalf of his new employer include, but are not limited to, Inservco Insurance
Services, Inc. of Lawrenceville, New Jersey, Reading Anthrocite Company in Pottsville,
Pennsylvania, Travelers Investigative Services, in Reading, Pennsylvania and Selective
Insurance Company in Lehigh Valley, Pennsylvania.
14. The aforesaid actions of Defendant Albert R. Thomas constitute breaches of the
employment contract and in particular the covenant not to compete contained in the employment
contract.
15. The activities of Defendant Albert R. Thomas, as set forth above, and his
continuance of these activities, have caused and will continue to cause irreparable harm to ICS's
business and valuable goodwill in that:
a. ICS has lost and will continue to lose a substantial and indefinite number
of present and prospective customers; and
b. ICS has suffered and will continue to suffer a substantial and severe loss
of profits now and indefinitely into the future.
16. Defendant Hayes Stoudt is an indispensable party because it is believed and
therefore averred that it has received and retained fees and profits which were obtained as a result
of the actions, contacts and solicitations of Defendant Thomas that constitute violations of the
covenant not to compete contained in the employment agreement.
17. ICS has no adequate remedy at law to protect its business and property rights and
restraint by injunction is necessary to afford adequate relief.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, Investigative Consultant Services, Inc. respectfully requests this
Honorable Court to decree and enter an order directing as follows:
(1) That an injunction issue, preliminarily and for a period to continue until
October 31, 2002, enjoining Defendant Albert R. Thomas from contacting
any previous or current clients oflCS, and from divulging the names or
addresses of any oflCS's customers or clients;
(2) That Defendants Albert R. Thomas and Hayes Stoudt be required to
account to ICS for all fees and profits derived from Defendant Albert R.
Thomas' breach of the contract; and
(3) That ICS be granted such other relief as the Court may deem just and
appropriate.
Breach of Contract (Covenant not to Compete)
ICS v. Sheri Thomas and Hayes, Stoudt & Associates, Inc.
18. Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference the averments of paragraphs 1 through
17 above as if set forth fully.
19. On December 1, 1995, Plaintiff ICS and Defendant Shed Thomas entered into a
valid written employment agreement under whose terms ICS hired Defendant Shed Thomas as
an investigator (hereinafter "employment contract"). A true and correct copy of the aforesaid
employment contract is attached hereto, made a part hereof and marked as Exhibit "C".
20. In accordance with the employment contract, Defendant Shed Thomas agreed, in
consideration of her employment, training and salary, that he would be prohibited for two (2)
years from the termination of his employment with ICS from doing any of the following:
a. Divulging the names or addresses of any of the clients or customers oflCS
to any party not employed by ICS; and
b. Calling on or marketing any current client oflCS on behalf of himself or
any other employer.
21. In addition, Defendant Shed Thomas agreed that if she violated the aforesaid
contractual provision and performed services for any client oflCS during the said two (2) year
period following her termination of employment with ICS either personally or on behalf of a new
employer she would pay ICS 100% of any fees paid by said client oflCS.
22. On October 30, 2000, Defendant Sheri Thomas voluntarily terminated her
employment with ICS, subject to the terms and conditions of the employment contract attached
hereto as Exhibit "C".
23. Defendant Sheri Thomas has become associated with Defendant Hayes Stoudt, a
direct competitor of ICS.
24. By way of a letter dated September 4, 2001, the attorneys for PlaintifflCS
advised Defendant Hayes Stoudt that Defendants Albert and Shed Thomas were in violation of
the restrictive covenants contained in the employment contracts and that Defendant Hayes Stoudt
account for all fees received by it from the ICS clients identified above. A true and correct copy
of the aforesaid letter is attached hereto as Exhibit "B".
25. To date, Defendant Hayes Stoudt has failed and refused to account for the fees it
has received fiom ICS's clients, and in fact has refused to even respond to the aforesaid letter.
26. Defendant Shed Thomas has been contacting and soliciting existing and former
clients oflCS in an effort to have them shift works fiom ICS to her new employer, Defendant
Hayes Stoudt, in violation of the express terms and conditions of the employment contract
attached hereto as Exhibit "C".
27. The clients oflCS, which Defendant Shed Thomas has contacted and solicited on
behalf of her new employer include, but are not limited to, Inservco Insurance Services, Inc. of
Lawrenceville, New Jersey, Reading Anthrocite Company in Pottsville, Pennsylvania, Travelers
Investigative Services, in Reading, Pennsylvania and Selective Insurance Company in Lehigh
Valley, Pennsylvania.
28. The aforesaid actions of Defendant Shed Thomas constitute breaches of the
employment contract and in particular the covenant not to compete contained in the employment
contract.
29. The activities of Defendant Shed Thomas, as set forth above, and her continuance
of these activities, have caused and will continue to cause irreparable harm to ICS's business and
valuable goodwill in that:
a. ICS has lost and will continue to lose a substantial and indefinite number
of present and prospective customers; and
b. ICS has suffered and will continue to suffer a substantial and severe loss
of profits now and indefinitely into the future.
30. Defendant Hayes Stoudt is an indispensable party because it is believed and
therefore averred that it has received and retained fees and profits which were obtained as a result
of the actions, contacts and solicitations of Defendant Thomas that constitute violations of the
covenant not to compete contained in the employment agreement.
31. ICS has no adequate remedy at law to protect its business and property rights and
restraint by injunction is necessary to afford adequate relief.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, Investigative Consultant Services, Inc. respectfully requests this
Honorable Court to decree and enter an order directing as follows:
(1) That an injunction issue, preliminarily and for a period to continue until
October 31, 2002, enjoining Defendant Sheri Thomas from contacting any
previous or current clients of ICS, and from divulging the names or
addresses of any ofICS's customers or clients;
(2) That Defendants Shed Thomas and Hayes Stoudt be required to account to
ICS for all fees and profits derived from Defendant Sheri Thomas' breach
of the contract; and
(3) That ICS be granted such other relief as the Court may deem just and
appropriate.
Misappropriation of Trade Secrets
ICS v. Albert R. Thomas and Sheri Thomas
32. Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference the averments of paragraphs 1 through
31 above as if set forth fully.
33. ICS has, by the expenditure of considerable time, effort and money, developed the
following valuable proprietary information about its business and its customers, all of which
constitute trade secrets:
a. The names of its customers;
b. The identity of the individual or individuals within each customer's
organization who makes actual purchasing decisions;
c. Its customer's buying habits and preferences; and
d. Pricing and pricing strategies.
34. Defendants Albert R. Thomas and Sheri Thomas duties while employed with ICS
were in large part related to the sale of ICS's services to existing and prospective customers and
the maintenance of those customer accounts.
35. In their capacity as valued employees of ICS, Defendants Albert R. Thomas and
Sheri Thomas had access to and did learn virtually all of the trade secrets and valuable
proprietary information of ICS as referred to above.
36. Subsequent to terminating their employment with ICS, Defendants Albert R.
Thomas and Sheri Thomas have offered to perform virtually the same services to customers and
potential customers of ICS on behalf of Defendant Hayes Stoudt in direct competition with ICS
using the proprietary information and trade secrets of ICS.
37. It is believed and therefore averred that Defendants Albert R. Thomas and Sheri
Thomas have prepared and/or made proposals to ICS's customers and potential customers on
behalf of Defendant Hayes Stoudt using proprietary information and trade secrets leamed while
they were employees of ICS.
38. The trade secrets referred to in this action, which are in the possession of
Defendants Albert R. Thomas and Sheri Thomas, are being willfully and intentionally used by
Defendants to lure ICS's existing and potential customers for their own benefit and to establish
favorable relationships with ICS's customers and potential customers on behalf of Defendant
Hayes Stoudt.
39. The conduct of Defendants Albert R. Thomas and Shed Thomas, if permitted to
continue, will cause ICS to suffer immediate and irreparable harm, loss of business from existing
customers, loss of potential business, and loss of goodwill in the marketplace.
40. The monetary value of the harm to ICS cannot be definitely ascertained, nor is
there an adequate remedy at law to remedy the harm.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, Investigative Consultant Services, Inc. respectfully requests this
Honorable Court:
(a)
Co)
(c)
Date: November 20, 2001
To issue an Order enjoining Defendants Albert R. Thomas and Shed
Thomas from communicating with or soliciting any person, finn or
corporation which has been or is a customer or a potential customer oflCS
until October 31, 2002;
To issue an Order directing Defendants Albert R. Thomas, Shed Thomas,
and Hayes Stoudt to account to and pay over to ICS any fees and profits
the Defendants have received from the sale to any person, finn or
corporation which has been or is a customer of ICS;
Grant ICS such other relief as this Court shall deem proper.
Respectfully submitt, t.t.~d,
The~dor~ A. Adler, Esquire
Attorney I.D. No. 16267
Thomas O. Williams, Esquire
Attorney I.D. No. 67987
2331 Market Street
Camp Hill, PA 17011-464
Telephone: (717) 763-1383
Attorneys for Plaintiff
Exhibit A
INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT SERVICES, INC.
"Terms of Employment,, for Persons Employed
as Private Detectives/Investigators
Effective October 1, 1995
This agreement supersedes all other employment
agreements entered into by the employee
All persons now employed or who will be employed in the
future by Investigative Consultant Services, Inc. ("ICS"), a
Pennsylvania corporation with its corporate office located at
3109 North Front Street, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, as
Managers/Private Detectives/Investigators during the course of
his employment with ICS.
In consideration for the salary agreed upon at the time
of hiring each new employee, or for the salary currently being
earned by current employees, and subsequent salary evaluations
and increases and promotions, and in further consideration for
the additional benefits provided in accordance with current
company policy, each licensed Private Detective/Investigator and
Manager should read and acknowledge, with his signature,
intending to be legally bound, the following terms:
1. In addition to my salary, which is to be paid in equal
monthly installments payable on the last day of each
month, and subject to withholding of federal, state and
local taxes, etc., the following additional benefits of
my employment have been explained in detail to me by my
supervisor:
(a) Vacation policy and personal days;
(b) Sick leave policy;
(c) Paid holidays. Vacation days, personal days, sick
days and holidays will be credited as eight (8)
hour days for pay purposes;
(d) Medical benefits for myself and my family;
(e) 401K Savings Plan;
(f) Life and Disability Insurance;
(g)
Reimbursement for business mileage that I drive
while working for clients that are ordinarily
billable to clients at a reimbursement rate to be
set by ICS; and
(h) Reimbursement for business expenses that are
incurred while working for clients and are
ordinarily billable to clients.
I understand that the nature of my job will require
long hours and odd hours of work, depending on the
specific requirement of the cases assigned to me for
investigation. I understand this may require holiday
and weekend work on occasion. I acknowledge that there
are no minimum or maximum hours required on any given
day or assignment. I agree to do whatever is necessary
to ensure that each assignment I am given is
investigated thoroughly and professionally.
I understand that my performance will be compared to
other managers/investigators by my supervisor and that
sustained, superior performance will be rewarded
through quality pay increases and bonuses at the
discretion of my supervisor. I also understand that,
if my performance is lacking in any way, it will be
pointed out to me by my supervisor, and administrative
action may be taken by my supervisor.
I understand that my employment is "at will" and may be
terminated by ICS or me at any time.
I understand that, if I disagree in any way with my
supervisor's decisions and assignments, I may appeal
such decisions and/or assignments in writing to the
President of ICS.
I understand that ICS company policy forbids me to
carry firearms or other concealed weapons during the
course of my employment due to restrictions in the
corporate liability insurance policies.
I understand and have read the corporate policy
memorandum regarding part-time employment. I agree to
comply with the terms of that policy.
I understand that it is imperative that I hold a valid
driver's license. I affirm that the information
regarding my driver's history as presented in my
employment application is true and valid as stated. I
will report any loss or suspension of my driver's
license to ICS immediately. I also affix.:: that I have
not been convicted cf a felony or any offense involving
moral turpitude or any misdemeanor or offense ~ any
nature.
10.
11.
12.
I agree to sign a'receipt for all company property
issued to me by ICS, and to utilize care in handling
all company equipment, including company vehicles. I
understand I may be liable for repairs or replacement
of said equipment if the damage or loss of said
equipment is shown to be a result of negligent or
intentional misconduct on my part. After termination
of my employment for any reason, I agree to immediately
return all ICS property to ICS. I will also turn over
all documents, papers, files, records, manuals, or
other written or graphic material relating to ICS or
any client of ICS.
I understand and agree that if, after termination of my
employment with ICS, I am required to testify at a
hearing or other judicial proceeding regarding an
investigation or other administrative matter which
occurred during my employment with ICS, I will be
reimbursed according to the current rate for mileage
allowed by the Internal Revenue Service and at an
hourly rate I was earning at the time of termination.
This will be a fair and equitable amount for time and
service. I understand that I may request that a
subpoena be issued for my testimony.
I agree to keep an accurate record of my time and
mileage on a "Time and Mileage Record" in accordance
with ICS policy and further agree to keep a valid and
accurate record of reasonable expenses incurred in the
course of my employment with ICS supported by receipts,
for which I will be reimbursed bi-weekly upon
submission of my "Bi-weekly Expense Voucher." I also
understand that I will receive a cash advance which I
must account for by utilizing my "Bi-weekly Expense
Voucher.',
(a)
I understand and agree that, during the term of my
employment with ICS and within two (2) years after
termination of employment with ICS, I will not
divulge the names or addresses of any of the
clients or customers of ICS to any party not
employed by ICS, nor will I call on or market any
current client of ICS on behalf of myself or any
other employer, with the exception that the
identity of clients or customers may be provided
to future clients as references. I agree that, if
I violate this provision and perform services for
any client of ICS during said two (2) year period,
either personally or on behalf of a new employer,
I will pay ICS 100% of any fe~s paid by said
client of ICS as liquidated damages fnr the breach
of this provision. These fees shall be payable to
ICS, without demand by ICS, within 10 days of
payment by said client of ICS.
13.
14.
15.
16.
(b)
I also agree that I will not, during the term of
my employment and within said period of two (2)
years, induce or attempt to induce employees of
ICS to terminate their employment with ICS.
(c)
I further agree, during the term of my employment
and for a period of two (2) years after
termination of my employment with ICS, not to
divulge any information which I learned while in
the employ of ICS which could be construed as a
"trade secret". All such disclosures must be
approved, in advance, by ICS' Chief Executive
Officer.
(d)
I agree that the provisions of this paragraph 12
are reasonable. I understand that if I breach or
threaten to breach the provisions of this
paragraph, ICS shall be entitled to seek any
available remedy at law for damages or in equity,
including without limitation a preliminary and
permanent injunction preventing me from violating
its provisions. If a court determines any portion
of this paragraph to be unenforceable, this
paragraph shall not be rendered void, but shall be
deemed amended as a court may determine.
I agree to conduct myself at all times while an
employee of ICS in an ethical, moral and professional
manner.
I agree to provide two (2) weeks written notice in the
event that I desire to terminate my employment with
ICS. I understand that I will be paid at the time of
termination of my employment, at the end of the
calendar month following the date of termination, and
that my final paycheck will include payment for unused
annual leave in accordance with the current ICS policy.
I understand that, prior to the issuance of my final
paycheck, my equipment will be inspected for damages
and accounted for, and my expense voucher.reviewed and
settled. All damage to my equipment must be resolved,
and all costs incurred by ICS will either be paid for
or will be deducted from my final paycheck.
I understand that any violation of the "Terms of
Employment', may result in administrative or
disciplinary action being taken by ICS.
I understand and acknowledge that any use of the client
lists, prospective client material, price lists, report
formats and/or other confidential materi~l considered
as "trade secrets" after termination or my employment
with ICS may result i? legal action being taken against
me by ICS.
17.
18.
Employee shall not divulge any information acquired by
employees of Ice to anyone and further shall not make a
false report to ICS. To divulge information is a
violation' of Section 14 of the Private Detective Act.
This agreement is to be governed and construed in
accordance with the laws of the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania. The corporate headquarters of Ice are in
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. Any disputes or litigation
concerning the terms of this document or the breach of
any terms hereof shall be resolved by the courts in
Dauphin County, Pennsylvania, and I consent to the
venue and jurisdiction of said courts.
I, the undersigned, acknowledge that I have read and
understand the above "Terms of Employment."
Signature
ICSEMPL2.AGR DRG19
Exhibit B
REAGER & ADLER, PC
ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELORS AT LAW
THEODORE a. ADLER +
DAVID W. REAGER
CHARLES E. ZALESKI
LINUS E. FENICLE
DEBRA DENISON CANTOR
Wdter's E-Mail Address: taadler@epix.net
2331 MARKET STREET *'
CAMP HILL, PENNSYLVANIA 17011-4642
717-763-1383
TELEFAX 717-730-7366
WEBSITE: ReagerAdlerPC.com
September 4, 2001
THOMAS O. WILLIAMS
SUSAN H. CONFAIR
JOANNE H. CLOUGH
+ Cedified Civil THai Specialist
Tom Hayes
Jeff Stoudt
Hayes, Stoudt & Associates, Inc.
Professional Investigations
328 W. Broad Street, Suite 200
Quakertown, PA 18951
Re~
Albert Thomas; Sheri Thomas
Our File No.: 00-871.000
Gentlemen:
We represent Investigative Consultant Services, Inc. (ICS).
Albert and Shed Thomas were employees oflCS until October 31, 2000. As part of their
employment, the Thomases signed an employment agreement with ICS. The agreement
contained a restrictive covenant that prevents the Thomases from calling on or marketing to any
clients of ICS for a period of two (2) years following their termination of employment.
Recently, it has come to ICS's attention that the Thomases have been employed by your
company. Indeed, Albert Thomas is holding himself out as your company's Manager of
Investigations. In that capacity he has solicited business from a number of companies which
were clients oflCS's at the time the Thomases terminated their employment with ICS. These
clients include, but are not limited to:
(a) Inserveco Insurance Services, Inc., Lawrensville, NJ;
(b) Reading Anthracite Company, Pottsville, PA;
(c) Travelers Investigative Services, Reading, PA; and
(d) Selective Insurance Company, Lehigh Valley, PA.
ICS has confirmed that Al Thomas has been in contact with each of these companies and perhaps
other ICS c~ients.
Tom Hayes
Jeff Stoudt
Hayes, Stoudt & Associates, Inc.
September 4, 2001
Page 2
The employment agreement signed by the Thomases provides that ICS shall be paid, as
liquidated damages, 100% of the fees received from any client oflCS with whom the Thomases
may have dealt with in violation of the employment agreement. We are requesting that you
provide us with the following information:
(a)
(b)
Confirmation that Sheri Thomas is employed by your company; and
An accounting of all fees received by your company from the ICS clients
identified above since November 1, 2000.
We are also demanding that your company agree that the Thomases will not have any
dealings with present or former ICS clients until November 1, 2002, and that your company will
ensure compliance with this agreement. Since both of you previously worked for ICS, we
assume that you have knowledge oflCS's client base. However, if you need a list of clients with
whom the Thomases may have no contact, ICS will provide it to you.
By copy of this letter, we are demanding that the Thomases have no dealings with any
present or former ICS clients until November 1, 2002.
We can resolve the issue set forth in this letter the easy way or the hard way. It is your
choice. If we do not hear from you within ten (10) days of the date of this letter that you have
agreed to all of the provisions contained herein, we will assume that you have chosen the hard
way and we will commence litigation.
We look forward to your response.
TAA/cmc
cc: Albert and Sheri Thomas
Carl Schleicher
Investigative Consultant Services, Inc.
~re ~A. Adler
Exhibit C
Employee's Name:... ~t-~ ~-~. ~ ~
INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTA/~T SERVlCESt INC.
"Terms of Employment', for Persons Employed
as Private Detectives/Investigators
Effective October 1, 1995
This agreement supersedes all other employment
agreements entered into by the employee
Ail persons now employed or who will be employed in the
future by Investigative Consultant Services, Inc. ("ICS"), a
Pennsylvania corporation with its corporate office located at
3109 North Front Street, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, as Private
Detectives/Investigators during the course of his employment with
ICS. '
In consideration of the hourly wage agreed upon at the
time of hiring each new employee, or for the hourly wage
currently being earned by current employees, and subsequent
hourly wage evaluations and increases and promotions, and in
further consideration of the additional benefits provided in
accordance with current ICS policy, each licensed Private
Detective/Investigator should read and acknowledge, with his
signature, intending to be legally bound, the following terms:
1. I will receive an hourly ~age which is to be paid in
monthly installments, payable on the last day of each
month, and subject to withholding of federal, state and
local taxes, etc. I will record all hours worked on
time sheets to be reviewed by my supervisor. I
understand that I will be paid for a minimum of forty
(40) hours a week. In addition to this hourly wage,
the following additional benefits of my employment have
been explained in detail to me by my supervisor:
(a) Vacation policy and personal days;
(b) Sick leave policy;
(c) Paid holidays. Vacation days, personal days, sick
days and holidals will be credited as eight (8)
hour days for pay purposes;
(d) ~[ed[cal benefits for myself and my family;
(e) 401K Saving-: Plan;
(f) Life and Disability Insurance;
4 o
(g)
Overtime pay for hours worked in e~cess of forty
(40) hours a week. Overtime pay will be paid on
the next payday after the month in which it is
worked (i.e., October overtime will be paid in
November); and
(h)
Reimbursement for business mileage that I drive
while working for clients that are ordinarily
billable to clients at a reimbursement rate to be
set by ICS; and
(i)
Reimbursement for business expenses that are
incurred while working for clients and are
ordinarily billable to clients.
I understand that the nature of my job will require
long hours and odd hours of work, depending on the
specific requirement of the cases assigned to me for
investigation. I understand this may require holiday
and weekend work on occasion. I acknowledge that there
are no minimum or maximum hours required on any given
day or assignment. ! agree to do whatever is necessary
to ensure that each assignment I am given is
investigated thoroughly and professionally.
I understand that my performance will be compared to
other investigators by my supervisor and that
sustained, superiqr performance will be rewarded
through quality pay increases and bonuses at the
discretion of my supervisor. ! also understand that,
if my performance is lacking in any way, it will be
pointed out to me by my supervisor, and administrative
action may be taken by my supervisor.
I understand that my emplo~.ent is "at will" and may be
terminated by ICS or me at any time.
I understand that, if I disagree in any way with my
supervisor's decisions and assignments, I may appeal
such decisions and/or assignments in writing to the
President of ICS.
I understand that ICS company policy forbids me to
carry firearms or other concealed weapons during the
course of my employment due to restrictions in the
corporate liability insurance policies.
I understand and have read the corporate policy
memorandum regarding part-time employment. I agree to
comply with the ter~5 of that policy.
I un~.~'~stand that it is imperative that I hold a valid
driveri ~ license. I affirm that the information
regarding my driver's history as presented in my
employment application is true and valid as stated. I
9 o
10.
11.
12.
13.
will report any loss or suspension of my driver's
license to ICS immediately. I also affirm that I have
not been convicted of a felony or any offense involving
moral turpitude or any misdemeanor or offense of any
nature.
I understand that I must supply my own vehicle that is
suitable for investigative and surveillance work. The
vehicle must be approved by my regional manager. I
will not perform maintenance of or repairs to my
vehicle on ICS' time. I further understand that I must
carry my own vehicle insurance and agree to provide ICS
with a current certificate of insurance upon renewal,
or at least annually. In addition, I will report any
cancellation of my automobile policy to ICS
immediately.
I agree to sign a receipt for all company property
issued to me by ICS and to utilize care in handling all
ICS equipment. I understand that I may be liable for
repairs or replacement of said equipment if the damage
or loss of said equipment is shown to be a result of
negligent or intentional misconduct on my part. After
termination of my employment for any reason, I agree to
immediately return all ICS property to ICS. I will
also turn over all documents, papers, files, records,
manuals, or other written or graphic material relating
to ICS or any client of ICS.
I understand and agree that if, after termination of my
employ~ent with ICS, I am required to testify at a
hearing or other judicial proceeding regarding an
investigation or other administrative matter which
occurred during my employment with ICe, I will be
reimbursed according to the current rate for mileage
allowed by the Internal Revenue Service and at an
hourly rate set by ICS and advertised to all employees
by a policy memorandum. This rate will be revised
annually by ICS and will be a fair and equitable amount
for time and service. I understand that I may request
that a subpoena be issued for my testimony.
I agree to keep an accurate record of my time and
mileage on a "Time and Mileage Record" in accordance
with ICS policy and further agree to keep a valid and
accurate record of reasonable expenses incurred in the
course of my employment with ICS supported by receipts,
for which I will be reimbursed bi-weekly upon
submission of my "Bi-weekly Expense Voucher." I also
understand that 1%~ill receive a cash advance which I
must account for by utilizing my "Bi-weekly Expense
Voucile~. ~t
(a) I unc=ustand and agree that, during the term of my
employmen% -,Tith ICe and within two (2) years after
14.
15.
termination of employment with ICS, I will not
divulge the names or addresses of any of the~
clients or customers of ICS to any party not~
employed by ICS, nor will I call on or market any
current client of ICS on behalf of myself or any
other employer, with the exception t~at the
identity of clients or customers may be provided
to future clients as references. I agree that, if
I violate this provision and perform services for
any client of ICS during said two (2) year period,
either personally or on behalf of a new employer,
I will pay ICS 100% of any fees paid by said
client of ICS as liquidated damages for the breach
of this provision. These fees shall be payable to
ICS, without demand by ICS, within 10 days of
payment by said client of ICS.
(b)
I also agree that I will not, during the term of
my employment and within said period of two (2)
years, induce or attempt to induce employees of
ICS to terminate their employment with ICS.
(c)
i further agree, during the term of my employment
and for a period of two (2) years after
termination of my employment with ICS, not to
divulge any information which I learned while in
the employ of ICS which could be construed as a
"trade secret". Ail such disclosures must be
approved, in advance, by ICS' Chief Executive
Officer.
(d)
I agree that the provisions of this paragraph 13
are reasonable. I understand that if I breach or
threaten to breach the provisions of this
paragraph, ICS shall be entitled to seek any
available remedy at law for damages or in equity,
including without limitation a preliminary and
permanent injunction preventing me from violating
its provisions. If a court determines any portion
of this paragraph to be unenforceable, this
paragraph shall not be rendered void, but shall be
deemed amended as a court may determine.
I agree to conduct myself at all times while an
employee of ICS in an ethical, moral and professional
manner.
I agree to provide two (2) weeks written notice in the
event that I desire to terminate my emplcvment with
ICS. I understand that I will be paid at-the time of
termination of my employment, at the end of the
cale~.iar month following the date of termination, and
that m~ final paycheck will include payment for unused
annual leaYe in accordance with ~ke current ICS policy.
I understand that, prior to the issuanc~ of my final
paycheck, my equipment will be inspected for damages
and accounted for, and my expense voucher reviewed an~
settled. All damage to my equipment must be resolved,
and all costs incurred by ICS will either be paid for
or will be deducted from my final paycheck.
16.
I understand that any violation of the "Terms of
Emp!oy~ent" may result in administrative or
disciplinary action being taken by Ica.
17.
I understand and acknowledge that any use of the client
lists, prospective client material, price lists, report
formats and/or other confidential material considered
as "trade secrets" after termination or my employment
with ICS may result in legal action being taken against
me by ICS.
18.
Employee shall not divulge any info:'~ation acquired
employees of ICS to anyone and further shall not make a
false report to ICa. To divulge information is a
violation of Section 14 of the Private Detective Act.
19.
This agreement is to be governed and construed in
accordance with the laws of the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania. The corporate headquarters of ICS are in
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. Any disputes or litigation
concerning the terms of this document or the breach of
any terms hereof shall be resolved by the courts in
Dauphin County, Pennsylvania, and I consent to the
venue and jurisdiction of said courts.
I, the undersigned, acknowledqe that I have read and
understand the above "Terms~of ~zp!oyment.,,
Signature '~~/~r / //~/~///ff~-~ Date !i,.~7'/'-
[CSEMPLY.AGR ORG19
I, Carl Schleicher, verify the averments of the foregoing Complaint in Equity are tree
and correct to my personal knowledge, information and belief. I understand that false statements
herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. §4904, relating to unswom falsification to
authorities.
~--~ L ~t
1~8£ L-£gL (LLL)
~'~J'~-L LOLL Ycl "1"11FI
.L:::I :II:I.I.S .L::I)tI:Iy~
N~Y-I .L¥ SA3NI:IOJ_I.Y
INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT
SERVICES, INC.,
Plaintiff
Vo
ALBERT R. THOMAS, SHERI THOMAS
and HAYES, STOUDT & ASSOCIATES,
INC.,
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
.
: NO: C~/~ (, ~'6c~ ~ ~
:
: EQUITY
:
Defendants :
MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION
AND NOW, comes Plaintiff, Investigative Consultant Services, Inc. by and through its
attorneys, Reager & Adler, P.C. and respectfully moves this Court for a preliminary injunction
pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1531, and in support thereof avers as follows:
1. Plaintiff Investigative Consultant Services, Inc.'s (hereinafter "ICS") Complaint
in Equity is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety as if fully set forth herein at length. A
true and correct copy of Plaintiff's Complaint is attached hereto and made a part hereof and
marked as Exhibit "A".
2. Defendants Albert R. Thomas and Sheri Thomas have refused and continue to
refuse to cease their contact and solicitation of Plaintiff ICS's clients and customers, which
contact and solicitation is in direct violation of the restrictive covenants contained in the
Employment Agreement of December 1, 1995, between Plaintiff ICS and Defendants Albert R.
Thomas and Shed Thomas. (See Exhibit "A" attached to Plaintiff's Complaint in Equity)
3. Defendants Albert R. Thomas and Shed Thomas have been soliciting and
contacting ICS's customers and clients in violation of the covenant not to compete contained in
the agreement.
4. Unless such improper conduct of the Defendants is immediately enjoined and ICS
is granted relief as requested, ICS will be irreparably injured in that:
a. ICS will continue to lose a substantial and indefinite number of present
and prospective customers;
b. ICS will continue to suffer a substantial and severe loss of profits now and
indefinitely into the future; and
c. ICS will continue to suffer irreparable harm to its reputation in the eyes of
its former and current customers and clients.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, Investigative Consultant Services, Inc. requests this Honorable
Court to enter an Order pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. 1531 as follows:
(1) That all Defendants be ordered to appear, following due notice, and show cause
why a preliminary injunction should not be issued during the pendency of this
action according to the relief requested in the Complaint oflCS and the requested
injunctive relief;
(2) That an injunction shall issue, preliminarily until final heating, and for a period to
extend to October 31, 2002, enjoining Defendants from soliciting or contacting
the former or current customers oflCS, and enjoining the Defendants from
utilizing, divulging, or otherwise disseminating any proprietary or confidential
information acquired during Defendants time of employment with the Plaintiff;
(3)
That the Court's Order shall remain in full rome and effect until such time as this
Court specifically orders otherwise.
Date:
November 20, 2001
Respectfully submitte~l~
Theodolte A. Adler, Esquire
Attorney I.D. No. 16267
Thomas O. Williams, Esquire
Attorney I.D. No. 67987
2331 Market Street
Camp Hill, PA 17011-464
Telephone: (717) 763-1383
Attorneys for Plaintiff
Exhibit A
INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT
SERVICES, INC.,
Plaintiff
Vo
ALBERT R. THOMAS, SHERI THOMAS
and HAYES, STOUDT & ASSOCIATES,
INC.,
Defendants
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO:
EQUITY
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend aga'mst the claims set forth in the
following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and notice are
served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the court
your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to
do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the court
without further notice for any money claimed in the complaint or for any other claim or relief
requested by the plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT
HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET
FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Cumberland County Bar Association
2 Liberty Avenue
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 249-3166
INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT
SERVICES, INC.,
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
:
: NO:
ALBERT R. THOMAS, SHERI THOMAS EQUITY
and HAYES, STOUDT & ASSOCIATES,
INC., :
Defendants :
COMPLAINT IN EQUITY
1. The Pla'mtiff Investigative Consultant Services, Inc. (hereinafter "ICS") is a
corporation incorporated and doing business under the laws of the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania with its principal place of business located at 4004 Trindle Road, Camp Hill,
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17011.
2. Defendant Albert R. Thomas is an adult individual with a present address of 118
East Second Street, Mt. Carmel, Pennsylvania 17851.
3. Defendant Sheri Thomas is an adult individual with a present address of 118 East
Second Street, Mr. Carmel, Pennsylvania 17851.
4. Defendant Hayes, Stoudt & Associates, Inc. (hereinafter "Hayes Stoudt") is a
corporation incorporated and doing business under the laws of the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania with its principal place of business located at 328 West Broad Street, Suite 200,
Quakertown, Pennsylvaxfia 18951.
Breach of Contract (Covenant Not to Compete)
ICS v. Albert R. Thomas and Hayes, Stoudt & Associates, Inc.
5. On December 1, 1995, Plaintiff ICS and Defendant Albert R. Thomas entered into
a valid written employment agreement under whose terms ICS hired Defendant Albert R.
Thomas as an investigator (hereinafter "employment contract"). A true and correct copy of the
aforesaid employment contract is attached hereto, made a part hereof and marked as Exhibit "A".
6. In accordance with the employment contract, Defendant Albert R. Thomas agreed,
in consideration of his employment, training and salary, that he would be prohibited for two (2)
years fi:om the termination of his employment with ICS from doing any of the following:
a. Divulging the names or addresses of any of the clients or customers of ICS
to any party not employed by ICS; and
b. Calling on or marketing any current client oflCS on behalf of himself or
any other employer.
7. In addition, Defendant Albert R. Thomas agreed that if he violated the aforesaid
contractual provision and perfomxed services for any client oflCS during the said two (2) year
period following his termination of employment with ICS either personally or on behalf of a new
employer he would pay ICS 100% of any fees paid by said client oflCS.
8. On October 30, 2000, Defendant Albert R. Thomas voluntarily terminated his
employment with ICS, subject to the terms and conditions of the employment contract attached
hereto as Exhibit "A".
9. Defendant Albert R. Thomas has become associated with Defendant Hayes
Stoudt, a direct competitor oflCS.
10. By way of a letter dated September 4, 2001, the attorneys for Plaintiff ICS
advised Defendant Hayes Stoudt that Defendants Albert and Sheri Thomas were in violation of
the restrictive covenants contained in the employment contracts and that Defendant Hayes Stoudt
account for all fees received by it fi:om the ICS clients identified above. In particular, ICS's
attorneys advised Defendant Hayes Stoudt that Defendant Albert Thomas had violated his
employment contract by contacting Travelers Investigative Services and Selective Insurance
Company. A tree and correct copy of the aforesaid letter is attached hereto as Exhibit "B".
11. To date, Defendant Hayes Stoudt has failed and refused to account for the fees it
has received from ICS's clients, and in fact has refused to even respond to the aforesaid letter.
12. Defendant Albert R. Thomas has been contacting and soliciting existing and
former clients oflCS in an effort to have them shif~ work from ICS to his new employer,
Defendant Hayes Stoudt, in violation of the express terms and conditions of the employment
contract attached hereto as Exhibit "A".
13. The clients oflCS, which Defendant Albert R. Thomas has contacted and
solicited on behalf of his new employer include, but are not limited to, Inservco Insurance
Services, Inc. of Lawrenceville, New Jersey, Reading Anthrocite Company in Pottsville,
Pennsylvania, Travelers Investigative Services, in Reading, Pennsylvania and Selective
Insurance Company in Lehigh Valley, Pennsylvania.
14. The aforesaid actions of Defendant Albert R. Thomas constitute breaches of the
employment contract and in particular the covenant not to compete contained in the employment
contract.
15. The activities of Defendant Albert R. Thomas, as set forfla above, and his
continuance of these activities, have caused and will continue to cause irreparable harm to ICS's
business and valuable goodwill in that:
a. ICS has lost and will continue to lose a substantial and indefinite number
of present and prospective customers; and
b. ICS has suffered and will continue to suffer a substantial and severe loss
of profits now and indefinitely into the future.
16. Defendant Hayes Stoudt is an indispensable party because it is believed and
therefore averred that it has received and reta'med fees and profits which were obtained as a result
of the actions, contacts and solicitations of Defendant Thomas that constitute violations of the
covenant not to compete contained in the employment agreement.
17. ICS has no adequate remedy at law to protect its business and property rights and
restraint by injunction is necessary to afford adequate relief.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, Investigative Consultant Services, Inc. respectfully requests this
Honorable Court to decree and enter an order directing as follows:
(1) That an injunction issue, preliminarily and for a period to continue until
October 31, 2002, enjoining Defendant Albert R. Thomas from contacting
any previous or current clients oflCS, and from divulging the names or
addresses of any of ICS's customers or clients;
(2) That Defendants Albert R. Thomas and Hayes Stoudt be required to
account to ICS for all fees and profits derived from Defendant Albert R.
Thomas' breach of the contract; and
(3) That ICS be granted such other relief as the Court may deem just and
appropriate.
Breach of Contract (Covenant not to Compete)
ICS v. Sheri Thomas and Hayes, Stoudt & Associates, Inc.
18. Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference the averments of paragraphs 1 through
17 above as if set forth fully.
19. On December 1, 1995, Plaintiff ICS and Defendant Sheri Thomas entered into a
valid written employment agreement under whose temps ICS hired Defendant Sheri Thomas as
an investigator (hereinafter "employment contract"). A true and correct copy of the aforesaid
employment contract is attached hereto, made a part hereof and marked as Exhibit "C".
20. In accordance with the employment contract, Defendant Shed Thomas agreed, in
consideration of her employment, training and salary, that he would be prohibited for two (2)
years from the termination of his employment with ICS from doing any of the following:
a. Divulging the names or addresses of any of the clients or customers of ICS
to any party not employed by ICS; and
b. Calling on or marketing any current client of ICS on behalf of himself or
any other employer.
21. In addition, Defendant Shed Thomas agreed that if she violated the aforesaid
contractual provision and performed services for any client of ICS during the said two (2) year
period following her ten;fination of employment with ICS either personally or on behalf of a new
employer she would pay ICS 100% of any fees paid by said client of ICS.
22. On October 30, 2000, Defendant Shed Thomas voluntarily tenidnated her
employment with ICS, subject to the terms and conditions of the employment contract attached
hereto as Exhibit "C".
23. Defendant Shed Thomas has become associated with Defendant Hayes Stoudt, a
direct competitor of ICS.
24. By way of a letter dated September 4, 2001, the attorneys for PlaintiffICS
advised Defendant Hayes Stoudt that Defendants Albert and Shed Thomas were in violation of
the restrictive covenants contained in the employment contracts and that Defendant Hayes Stoudt
account for all fees received by it 15om the ICS clients identified above. A tree and correct copy
of the aforesaid letter is attached hereto as Exhibit "B".
25. To date, Defendant Hayes Stoudt has failed and refused to account for the fees it
has received from ICS's clients, and in fact has refused to even respond to the aforesaid letter.
26. Defendant Shed Thomas has been contacting and soliciting existing and former
clients oflCS in an effort to have them shift works from ICS to her new employer, Defendant
Hayes Stoudt, in violation of the express terms and conditions of the employment contract
attached hereto as Exhibit "C".
27. The clients oflCS, which Defendant Shed Thomas has contacted and solicited on
behalf of her new employer include, but are not limited to, Inservco Insurance Services, Inc. of
Lawrenceville, New Jersey, Reading Anthrocite Company in Pottsville, Pennsylvania, Travelers
Investigative Services, in Reading, Pennsylvania and Selective Insurance Company in Lehigh
Valley, Pennsylvania. '
28. The aforesaid actions of Defendant Sheri Thomas constitute breaches of the
employment contract and in particular the covenant not to compete contained in the employment
contract.
29. The activities of Defendant Shed Thomas, as set forth above, and her continuance
of these activities, have caused and will continue to cause irreparable harm to ICS's business and
valuable goodwill in that:
a. ICS has lost and will continue to lose a substantial and indefinite number
of present and prospective customers; and
b. ICS has suffered and will continue to suffer a substantial and severe loss
of profits now and indefinitely into the furore.
30. Defendant Hayes Stoudt is an indispensable party because it is believed and
therefore averred that it has received and retained fees and profits which were obtained as a result
of the actions, contacts and solicitations of Defendant Thomas that constitute violations of the
covenant not to compete contained in the employment agreement.
31. ICS has no adequate remedy at law to protect its business and property rights and
restraint by injunction is necessary to afford adequate relief.
WHEREFORE, Pla'tariff, Investigative Consultant Services, Inc. respectfully requests this
Honorable Court to decree and enter an order directing as follows:
(1) That an injunction issue, preliminarily and for a period to continue until
October 31, 2002, enjoining Defendant Sheri Thomas from contacting any
previous or current clients of ICS, and from divulging the names or
addresses of any ofICS's customers or clients;
(2) That Defendants Sheri Thomas and Hayes Stoudt be required to account to
ICS for all fees and profits derived from Defendant Sheri Thomas' breach
of the contract; and
(3) That ICS be granted such other relief as the Court may deem just and
appropriate.
Misappropriation of Trade Secrets
ICS v. Albert R. Thomas and Sheri Thomas
32. Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference the averments of paragraphs 1 through
31 above as if set forth fully.
33. ICS has, by the expenditure of considerable time, effort and money, developed the
following valuable proprietary information about its business and its customers, all of which
constitute trade secrets:
a. The names of its customers;
b. The identity of the individual or individuals within each customer's
organization who makes actual purchasing decisions;
c. Its customer's buying habits and preferences; and
d. Pricing and pricing strategies.
34. Defendants Albert R. Thomas and Sheri Thomas duties while employed with ICS
were in large part related to the sale oflCS's services to existing and prospective customers and
the maintenance of those customer accounts.
35. In their capacity as valued employees oflCS, Defendants Albert R. Thomas and
Sheri Thomas had access to and did learn virtually all of the trade secrets and valuable
proprietary information oflCS as referred to above.
36. Subsequent to terminating their employment with ICS, Defendants Albert R.
Thomas and Sheri Thomas have offered to perform virtually the same services to customers and
potential customers oflCS on behalf of Defendant Hayes Stoudt in direct competition with ICS
using the proprietary information and trade secrets oflCS.
37. It is believed and therefore averred that Defendants Albert R. Thomas and Sheri
Thomas have prepared and/or made proposals to ICS's customers and potential customers on
behalf of Defendant Hayes Stoudt using proprietary information and trade secrets learned while
they were employees oflCS.
38. The trade secrets referred to in this action, which are in the possession of
Defendants Albert R. Thomas and Sheri Thomas, are being willfully and intentionally used by
Defendants to lure ICS's existing and potential customers for their own benefit and to establish
favorable relationships with ICS's customers and potential customers on behalf of Defendant
Hayes Stoudt.
39. The conduct of Defendants Albert R. Thomas and Sheri Thomas, if permitted to
continue, will cause ICS to suffer immediate and irreparable haun, loss of business from existing
customers, loss of potential business, and loss of goodwill in the marketplace.
40. The monetary value of the harm to ICS cannot be definitely ascertained, nor is
there an adequate remedy at law to remedy the harm.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, Investigative Consultant Services, Inc. respectfully requests this
Honorable Court:
(a)
(c)
Date: November 20, 2001
To issue an Order enjoining Defendants Albert R. Thomas and Sheri
Thomas from communicating with or soliciting any person, finn or
corporation which has been or is a customer or a potential customer oflCS
until October 31, 2002;
To issue an Order directing Defendants Albert R. Thomas, Sheri Thomas,
and Hayes Stoudt to account to and pay over to ICS any fees and profits
the Defendants have received from the sale to any person, finn or
corporation which has been or is a customer oflCS;
Grant ICS such other relief as this Court shall deem proper.
Respectfully submi~.~.~,d,
- /
Th~dore A. Adler, Esquire
Attorney I.D. No. 16267
Thomas O. Williams, Esquire
Attorney I.D. No. 67987
2331 Market Street
Camp Hill, PA 17011-464
Telephone: (717) 763-1383
Attorneys for Plaintiff
EXHIBIT "A"
EmploYee's Name:
POSITION: ~.-~ f~
Dated:
INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT SERVICES, INC.
"Terms of Employment" for Persons Employed
as Private Detectives/Investigators
Effective October 1, 1995
This agreement supersedes all other employment
agreements entered into by the employee
Ail persons now employed or who will be employed in the
future by Investigative Consultant Services, Inc. ("ICS"), a
Pennsylvania corporation with its corporate office located at
3109 North Front Street, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, as
Managers/Private Detectives/Investigators during the course of
his employment with ICS.
In consideration for the salary agreed upon at the time
of hiring each new employee, or for the salary currently being
earned by current employees, and subsequent salary evaluations
and increases and promotions, and in further consideration for
the additional benefits provided in accordance with current
company policy, each licensed Private Detective/Investigator and
Manager should read and acknowledge, with his signature,
intending to be legally bound, the following terms:
In addition to my salary, which is to be paid in equal
monthly installments payable on the last day of each
month, and subject to withholding of federal, state and
local taxes, etc., the following additional benefits of
my employment have been explained in detail to me by my
supervisor:
(a) Vacation policy and personal days;
(b) Sick leave policy;
(c)
Paid holidays. Vacation days, personal days, sick
days and holidays will be credited as eight (8)
hour days for pay purposes;
(d) Medical benefits for myself and my family;
(e) 401K Savings Plan;
(f) Life and Disability Insurance;
6e
(g)
Reimbursement for business mileage that I drive
while working for clients that are ordinarily
billable to clients at a reimbursement rate to be
set by ICS; and
(h)
Reimbursement for business expenses that are
incurred while working for clients and are
ordinarily billable to clients.
I understand that the nature of my job will require
long hours and odd hours of work, depending on the
specific requirement of the cases assigned to me for
investigation. I understand this may require holiday
and weekend work on occasion. I acknowledge that there
are no minimum or maximum hours required on any given
day or assignment. I agree to do whatever is necessary
to ensure that each assignment I am given is
investigated thoroughly and professionally.
I understand that my performance will be compared to
other managers/investigators by my supervisor and that
sustained, superior performance will be rewarded
through quality pay increases and bonuses at the
discretion of my supervisor. I also understand that,
if my performance is lacking in any way, it will be
pointed out to me by my supervisor, and administrative
action may be taken by my supervisor.
I understand that my employment is "at will" and may be
terminated by ICS or me at any time.
I understand that, if I disagree in any way with my
supervisor's decisions and assignments, I may appeal
such decisions and/or assignments in writing to the
President of ICS.
I understand that ICS company policy forbids me to
carry firearms or other concealed weapons during the
course of my employment due to restrictions in the
corporate liability insurance policies.
I understand and have read the corporate policy
memorandum regarding part-time employment. I agree to
comply with the terms of that policy.
I understand that it is imperative that I hold a valid
driver's license. I affirm that the information
regarding my driver's history as presented in my
employment application is true and valid as stated. I
will report any loss or suspension of my driver's
license to ICS immediately. I also affirm: that I have
not been convicted of a felony or any offense involving
moral turpitude or any misdemeanor or offense e~ any
nature.
10.
11.
12.
I agree to sign' a'receipt for all company property
issued to me by ICS, and to utilize care in handling
all company equipment, including company vehicles. I
understand I may be liable for repairs or replacement
of said equipment if the damage or loss of said
equipment is shown to be a result of negligent or
intentional misconduct on my part. After termination
of my employment for any reason, I agree to immediately
return all ICS property to ICS. I will also turn over
all documents, papers, files, records, manuals, or
other written or graphic material'relating to ICS or
any client of ICS.
I understand and agree that if, after termination of my
employment with ICS, I am required to testify at a
hearing or other judicial proceeding regarding an
investigation or other administrative matter which
occurred during my employment with ICS, I will be
reimbursed according to the current rate for mileage
allowed by the Internal Revenue Service and at an
hourly rate I was earning at the time of termination.
This will be a fair and equitable amount for time and
service. I understand that I may request that a
subpoena be issued for my testimony.
I agree to keep an accurate record of my time and
mileage on a "Time and Mileage Record" in accordance
with ICS policy and further agree to keep a valid and
accurate record of reasonable expenses incurred in the
course of my employment with ICS supported by receipts,
for which I will be reimbursed bi-weekly upon
submission of my "Bi-weekly Expense Voucher." I also
understand that I will receive a cash advance which I
must account for by utilizing my "Bi-weekly Expense
Voucher."
(a)
I understand and agree that, during the term of my
employment with ICS and within two (2) years after
termination of employment with ICS, I will not
divulge the names or addresses of any of the
clients or customers of ICS to any party not
employed by ICS, nor will I call on or market any
current client of ICS on behalf of myself or any
other employer, with the exception that the
identity of clients or customers may be provided
to future clients as references. I agree that, if
I violate this provision and perform services for
any client of ICS during said two (2) year period,
either personally or on behalf of a new employer,
I will pay ICS 100% of any fees paid by said
client of ICS as liquidated damages fqr the breach
of this provision. These fees shall be payable to
ICS, without demand by ICS, within 10 days of
payment by said client of ICS.
13.
14.
15.
16.
(b)
I also agree that I will not, during the term of
my employment and within said period of two (2)
years, induce or attempt to induce employees of
ICS .to terminate their employment with ICS.
(c)
I further agree, during the term of my employment
and for a period of two (2) years after
termination of my employment with ICS, not to
divulge any information which I learned while in
the employ of Ica which could be construed as a
"trade secret". All such disclosures must be
approved, in advance, by ICS' Chief Executive
Officer.
(d)
I agree that the provisions of this paragraph 12
are reasonable. I understand that if I breach or
threaten to breach the provisions of this
paragraph, Ica shall be entitled to seek any
available remedy at law for damages or in equity,
including without limitation a preliminary and
permanent injunction preventing me from violating
its provisions. If a court determines any portion
of this paragraph to be unenforceable, this
paragraph shall not be rendered void, but shall be
deemed amended as a court may determine.
I agree to conduct myself at all times while an
employee of ICS in an ethical, moral and professional
manner.
I agree to provide two (2) weeks written notice in the
event that I desire to terminate my employment with
ICS. I understand that I will be paid at the time of
termination of my employment, at the end of the
calendar month following the date of termination, and
that my final paycheck will include payment for unused
annual leave in accordance with the current Ica policy.
I understand that, prior to the issuance of my final
paycheck, my equipment will be inspected for damages
and accounted for, and my expense voucher'reviewed and
settled. All damage to my equipment must be resolved,
and all costs incurred by Ica will either be paid for
or will be deducted from my final paycheck.
I understand that any violation of the "Terms of
Employment" may result in administrative or
disciplinary action being taken by Ica.
I understand and acknowledge that any use of .the client
lists, prospective client material, price lists, report
formats and/or other confidential material considered
as "trade secrets" after termination or my employment
with ICS may result i~ legal action being taken against
me by ICS.
17.
Employee shall not divulge any information acquired by
employees of Ice toanyone and further Shall not make a
false report to ICS. To divulge information is a
violation-of Section 14 of the Private Detective Act.
18.
Th~s agreement is to be governed and construed in
accordance with the laws of the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania. The corporate headquarters of ICS are in
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. Any disputes or litigation
concerning the terms of this document or the breach of
any terms hereof shall be resolved by the courts in
Dauphin County, Pennsylvania, and I consent to the
venue and jurisdiction of said courts.
I, the undersigned, acknowledge that I have read and
understand the above "Terms of Employment."
Signature ~~ Date /c~ /( / q ~~'
I CS£MPL2.AGR DRG19
EXHIBIT "B"
REAGER & ADLER, PC
ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELORS AT LAW
THEODORE A. ADLER+
DAVID W. REAGER
CHARLES E. ZALESKI
LINUS E. FENICLE
DEBRADENISON CANTOR
Writer's E.Mail Address: taadler@epix.net
Tom Hayes
Jeff Stoudt
Hayes, Stoudt & Associates, Inc.
Professional Investigations
328 W. Broad Street, Suite 200
Quakertown, PA 18951
2331 MARKET STREET ;
CAMP HILL, PENNSYLVANIA 17011-4642
717-763-1383
TELEFAX 717-730-7366
WEBSITE: ReagerAdlerPC.com
September 4, 2001
THOMAS O. WILLIAMS
SUSAN H. CONFAIR
JOANNE H. CLOUGH
+ Certified C/vll THai Specialist
Re;
Albert Thomas; Sheri Thomas
Our File No.: 00-871.000
Gentlemen:
We represent Investigative Consultant Services, Inc. (ICS).
Albert and Shed Thomas were employees of ICS until October 31, 2000. As part of their
employment, the Thomases signed an employment agreement with ICS. The agreement
contained a restrictive covenant that prevents the Thomases from calling on or marketing to any
clients of ICS for a period of two (2) years following their termination of employment.
Recently, it has come to ICS's attention that the Thomases have been employed by your
company. Indeed, Albert Thomas is holding himself out as your company's Manager of
Investigations. In that capacity he has solicited business from a number of companies which
were clients of ICS's at the time the Thomases terminated their employment with ICS. These
clients include, but are not limited to:
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
Inserveco Insurance Services, Inc., Lawrensville, NJ;
Reading Anthracite Company, Pottsville, PA;
Travelers Investigative Services, Reading, PA; and
Selective Insurance Company, Lehigh Valley, PA.
ICS has confirmed that A1 Thomas has been in contact with each of these companies and perhaps
other ICS cqents.
Tom Hayes
Jeff Stoudt
Hayes, Stoudt & Associates, Inc.
Sep,tember 4, 2001
Page 2
The employment agreement signed by the Thomases provides that ICS shall be paid, as
liquidated damages, 100% of the fees received fi.om any client oflCS with whom the Thomases
may have dealt with in violation of the employment agreement. We are requesting that you
provide us with the following information:
(a)
(b)
Confirmation that Sheri Thomas is employed by your company; and
An accounting of all fees received by your company from the ICS clients
identified above since November 1, 2000.
We are also demanding that your company agree that the Thomases will not have any
dealings with present or former ICS clients until November 1, 2002, and that your company will
ensure compliance with this agreement. Since both of you previously worked for ICS, we
assume that you have knowledge oflCS's client base. However, if you need a list of clients with
whom the Thomases may have no contact, ICS will provide it to you.
By copy of this letter, we are demanding that the Thomases have no dealings with any
present or former ICS clients until November 1, 2002.
We can resolve the issue set forth in this letter the easy way or the hard way. It is your
choice. If we do not hear fi.om you within ten (10) days of the date of this letter that you have
agreed to all of the provisions contained herein, we will assume that you have chosen the hard
way and we will commence litigation.
We look forward to your response.
A. Adler
TAA/cmc
cc: Albert and Sheri Thomas
Carl Schleicher
Investigative Consultant Services, Inc.
EXHIBIT "C"
Employee's Name: ~-l~ ~------~'.
POSITION:
Dated:
INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT SERVICES~ INC.
"Terms of Employment" for Persons Employed
as Private Detectives/Investigators
Effective October 1, 1995
This agreement supersedes all other employment
agreements entered into by the employee
Ail persons now employed or who will be employed in the
future by Investigative Consultant Services, Inc. ("ICS"), a
Pennsylvania corporation with its corporate office located at
3109 North Front Street, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, as Private
Detectives/Investigators during the course of his employment with
ICS.
In consideration of the hourly wage agreed upon at the
time of hiring each new employee, or for the hourly wage
currently being earned by current employees, and subsequent
hourly wage evaluations and increases and promotions, and in
further consideration of the additional benefits provided in
accordance with current ICS policy, each licensed Private
Detective/Investigator should read and acknowledge, with his
signature, intending to be legally bound, the following terms:
I will receive an hourly wage which is to be paid in
monthly installments, payable on the last day of each
month, and subject to withholding of federal, state and
local taxes, etc. I will record all hours worked on
time sheets to be reviewed by my supervisor. I
understand that I will be paid for a minimum of forty
(40) hours a week. In addition to this hourly wage,
the following additional benefits of my employment have
been explained in detail to me by my supervisor:
(a) Vacation policy and personal days;~
(b) Sick leave policy;
(c)
Paid holidays. Vacation days, personal days, sick
days and holidays will be credited as eight (8)
hour days for pay purposes;
(d) b[edical benefits for myself and my family;
(e) 401K Savin~ Plan;
(f) Life and Disability Insurance;
6 o
(g) Overtime pay for hours worked in e~cess of forty
(40) hours a week. Overtime pay will be pa~d on
the next payday after the month in which it is
worked (i.e., October overtime will be paid in
November); and
(h) Reimbursement for business mileage that t drive
while working for clients that are ordinarily
billable to clients at a reimbursement rate to be
set by ICS; and
(i)
Reimbursement for business expenses that are
incurred while working for clients and are
ordinarily billable to clients.
I understand that the nature of my job will require
long hours and odd hours of work, depending on the
specific requirement of the cases assigned to me for
investigation. I understand this may require holiday
and weekend work on occasion. I acknowledge that there
are no minimum or maximum hours required on any given
day or assignment. I agree to do whatever is necessary
to ensure that each assignment I am given is
investigated thoroughly and professionally.
I understand that my performance will be compared to
other investigators by my supervisor and that
sustained, superiqr performance will be rewarded
through quality pay increases and bonuses at the
discretion of my supervisor. I also understand that,
if my performance is lacking in any way, it will be
pointed out to me by my supervisor, and administrative
action may be taken by my supervisor.
I understand that my emplo~-ment is "at will" and may be
terminated by ICS or me at any time.
I understand that, if I disagree in any way with my
supervi$or's decisions and assignments, I may appeal
such decisions and/or assignments in writing to the
President of ICS.
I understand that ICS company policy forbids me to
carry firearms or other concealed weapons during the
course of my employment due to restrictions in the
corporate liability insurance policies.
I understand and have read the corporate policy
memorandum regarding part-time employment. I agree to
comply with the term~ of that policy.
I understand that it is imperative that I hold a valid
driver~ ~ license. I affirm that the information
regarding mf driver's history as presented in my
employment application is true and valid as stated. I
10.
11.
12.
13.
will report any loss or suspension of my driver's
license to ICS immediately. I also affirm that ~ have
not been convicted of a felony or any offense involving
moral turpitude or any misdemeanor or offense of any
nature.
I understand that I must supply my own vehicle that is
suitable for investigative and surveillance work. The
vehicle must be approved by my regional manager. I
will not perform maintenance of or repairs to my
vehicle on ICS' time. I further understand that I must
carry my own vehicle insurance and agree to provide ICS
with a current certificate of insurance upon renewal,
or at least annually. In addition, I will report any
cancellation of my automobile policy to ICS
immediately.
I agree to sign a receipt for all company property
issued to me by ICS and to utilize care in handling all
ICS equipment. I understand that I may be liable for
repairs or replacement of said equipment if the damage
or loss of said equipment is shown to be a result of
negligent or intentional misconduct on my part. After
termination of my employment for any reason, I agree to
immediately return all !CS property to ICS. I will
also turn over all documents, papers, files, records,
manuals, or other written or graphic material relating
to ICS or any client of ICS.
I understand and agree that if, after termination of my
employment with ICS, I am reauired to testify at a
hearing or other judicial proceeding regarding an
investigation or other administrative matter which
occurred during my employment with ICS, I will be
reimbursed according to the current rate for mileage
allowed by the Internal Revenue Service and at an
hourly rate set by ICS and advertised to all employees
by a policy memorandum. This rate will be revised
annually by ICS and will be a fair and equitable amount
for time and service. I understand that I may request
that a subpoena be issued for my testimony.
I agree to keep an accurate record of my time and
mileage on a "Time and Mileage Record" in accordance
with !CS policy and further agree to keep a valid and
accurate record of reasonable expenses incurred in the
course of my employment with ICS supported by receipts,
for which I will be reimbursed bi-weekly upon
submission of my "Bi-weekly Expense Voucher." I also
understand that I will receive a cash advan~a which I
must account for by utilizing my "Bi-weekly Expense
Vouc~e~.~
(a) I unmarstand and agree that, during the term of my
employment ~ith ~CS and within twc (2) years after
14.
15.
termination of employment with ICS, I will not
divulge the names or addresses of any of the,,
clients or customers of ICS to any party not
employed by ICS, nor will I call on or market any
current client of ICS on behalf of myself or any
other employer, with the exception t~at the
identity of clients or customers may be provided
to future clients as references. I agree that, if
I violate this provision and perform services for
any client of ICS during said two (2) year period,
either personally or on behalf of a new employer,
I will pay ICS 100% of any fees paid by said
client of ICS as liquidated damages for the breach
of this provision. These fees shall be payable to
ICS, without demand by ICS, within 10 days of
payment by said client of ICS.
(b)
I also agree that I will not, during the term of
my employment and within said period of two (2)
years, induce or attempt to induce employees of
iCS to terminate their employment with ICS.
I further agree, during the term of my employment
and for a period of two (2) years after
termination of my employment with ICS, not to
divulge any information which I learned while in
the employ of ICS which could be construed as a
"trade secret", k!l such disclosures must be
approved, in advance, by ICS' Chief Executive
Officer.
(d)
I agree that the provisions of this paragraph 13
are reasonable. I understand that if I breach or
threaten to breach the provisions of this
paragraph, ICS shall be entitled to seek any
available remedy at law for damages or in equity,
including without limitation a preliminary and
permanent injunction preventing me from violating
its provisions. If a court determines any portion
of this paragraph to be unenforceable, this
paragraph shall not be rendered void, but shall be
deemed amended as a court may determine.
I agree to conduct myself at all times while an
employee of ICS in an ethical, moral and professional
manner.
I agree to provide two (2) weeks written notice in the
event that I desire to terminate my employment with
ICS. I understand that I will be paid at tP~e time of
termination of my employment, at the end of the
cale~.~ar month following the date of termination, and
that m!' final paycheck will include payment for unused
annual leaYe in accordance with L~e current ICS policy.
I understand that, prior to the issuance of my final
paycheck, my equipment will be inspected for damages
and accounted for, and my expense voucher reviewed an~
settled. All damage to my equipment must be resolved,
and all costs incurred by ICS will either be paid for
or will be deducted from my final paycheck.
16.
I understand that any violation of the "Terms of
Employment" may result in administrative or
disciplinary action being taken by ICS.
17.
I understand and acknowledge that any use of the client
lists, prospective client material, price lists, report
formats and/or other confidential material considered
as "trade secrets" after termination or my employment
with ICS may result in legal action being taken against
me by ICS.
18.
Employee shall not divulge any information acquired by'.
employees of ICS to anyone and further shall not make a
false report to ICS. To divulge information is a
violation of Section 14 of the Private Detective Act.
19.
This agreement is to be governed and construed in
accordance with the laws of the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania. The corporate headquarters of ICS are in
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. Any disputes or litigation
concerning the terms of this document or the breach of
any terms hereof shall be resolved by the courts in
Dauphin County, Pennsylvania, and I consent to the
venue and jurisdiction of said courts.
I, the undersigned, acknowledge that I have read and
understand the above "Terms/~of ~mployment."
Signature ~--~ Date /~.~.7 . /'__ l 3'
~ CSEMPL¥.Ar-R ORG19
5
I, Carl Schleicher, verify the averments of the foregoing Complaint in Equity are tree
and correct to my personal knowledge, information and belief. I understand that false statements
herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. §4904, relating to unswom falsification to
authorities.
Date: /'/-~ -~ t By:
I, Carl Schleicher, verify the averments of the foregoing Motion for Preliminary
Injunction are true and correct to my personal knowledge, information and belief. I understand
that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. §4904, relating to
unswom falsification to authorities.
Date: //' ,~- (? [ By:
Carl
INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT
SERVICES, INC.,
Plaintiff
ALBERT R. THOMAS, SI-IERI THOMAS
and HAYES, STOUDT & ASSOCIATES,
INC.,
Defendants
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO: O!- (.a-~.o ~ ~
EQUITY
RULE
AND NOW, this ~ day of ~'~-d~, 2001, in consideration of the within
Motion for Preliminary Injunction, a Rule is hereby entered upon the Defendants to show cause
why the preliminary injunction should not be granted as prayed for in the within motion. Rule
returnable the /~V_,~ dayof ~rn~t~,,~,2001, at 6)5~0 .~_.m. in court room ¢ ,
Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle, Pennsylvania.
By the Court,
V~NVA"]ASNNB<J
A.LNNO9 FP,%q U,:],~ F~NO
AI:IViONON, Ci:; 2 {J. JO
SHERIFF'S RETURN - OUT OF COUNTY
CASE NO: 2001-06560 p
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT SERV
VS
THOMAS ALBERT R ET AL
R. Thomas Kline , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff who being
duly sworn according to law, says, that he made a diligent search and
and inquiry for the within named DEFENDANT , to wit:
THOMAS ALBERT R
but was unable to locate Him in his bailiwick. He therefore
deputized the sheriff of NORTHUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania, to
serve the within COMPLAINT - EQUITY
On February 27th , 2002 , this office was in receipt of the
attached return from NORTHUMBERLAND
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing 18.00
Out of County 9.00
Surcharge 10.00
Dep Northumberland 90.24
.00
127.24
02/27/2002
So answers~3- . ~ ~
R/ Thomas Kline
Sheriff of Cumberland County
REAGER ADLER COGNETTI
Sworn and subscribed to before me
this 73 ~ day of ~
~0~2~ A.D.
SHERIFF'S RETURN - OUT OF COUNTY
CASE NO: 2001-06560 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT SERV
VS
THOMAS ALBERT R ET AL
R. Thomas Kline , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff who being
duly sworn according to law, says, that he made a diligent search and
and inquiry for the within named DEFENDANT , to wit:
THOMAS SHERI
but was unable to locate Her in his bailiwick. He therefore
deputized the sheriff of NORTHUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania, to
serve the within COMPLAINT - EQUITY
On February 27th , 2002 , this office was in receipt of the
attached return from NORTHUMBERLAND
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing
Out of County
Surcharge
6.00
.00
10.00
.00
.00
16.00
02/27/2002
So answ~rs~.
R./Thomas Kline
Sheriff of Cumberland County
REAGER ADLER COGNETTI
Sworn and subscribed to before me
this /B ~ day of ~
A.D.
SHERIFF'S RETURN - OUT OF COUNTY
CASE NO: 2001-06560 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT SERV
VS
THOMAS ALBERT R ET AL
R. Thomas Kline , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff who being
duly sworn according to law, says, that he made a diligent search and
and inquiry for the within named DEFENDANT , to wit:
HAYES STOUDT & ASSOCIATES INC
but was unable to locate Them
deputized the sheriff of BUCKS
in his bailiwick. He therefore
County, Pennsylvania, to
serve the within COMPLAINT - EQUITY
On February 27th , 2002 , this office was in receipt of the
attached return from BUCKS
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing 6.00
Out of County· 9.00
Surcharge 10.00
Dep Bucks County 48.00
.00
73.00
So answer~:
Rf Thomas Kline
Sheriff of Cumberland County
02/27/2002
REAGER ADLER COGNETTI
Sworn and subscribed to before me
this /3 ~ day of ~
~ &v32~ A.D.
! ! Prothonotary ' /- ~
PLAINTIFF: INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT SERVICES, INC.CASE #: 01 EQ 6560
VS:
DEFENDANT: THOMAS, ALBERT R. &
D: THOMAS, SHERI
D: 118 EAST SECOND STREET
D: MT. CARMEL,~PA 17851
D:
SHERIFF'S RETURN
CTY FILED: CUMBERLAND
FILE DATE: 01/11/20
DATE RECEIVED: 01/12/10
ASSIGNED TO: 2 DEF
LAW FIRM: CUMBERLAND
EXPIRES: 2001/12/20
I HEREBY CERTIFY AND RETURN I SERVED: ALBERT R. THOMAS
BY H~NDING A TRUE AND ATTESTED COPY OF THE WITHIN: NOTICE, COMPLAINT IN
EQUITY & MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION
PERSON SERVED: ALBERT R. THOMAS
DATE SERVED: 2001/12/12
CAPACITY: PERSONALLY
TIME: 3:20 PM :
PLACE SERVED: 118 EAST SECOND STREET MT CARMEL PA
COUNTY OF NORTHUMBERLAND AND STATE OF PENNA,, MAKING KNOWN UNTO : HIM
CONTENTS THEREOF. SO ANSWERS: CM3LRLES S. BERKOSKI, SHERIFF
BY DEPUTY: MORACK, ANDREW
BY:
THE
I HEREBY CERTIFY AND RETURN THAT I SERVED: SHERI THOMAS
BY HANDING A TRUE AND ATTESTED COPY OF THE WITHIN: NOTICE, COMPLAINT IN EQUITY
& MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION
PERSON SERVED: SHERI THOMAS
DATE SERVED: 2001/12/12
CAPACITY : PERSONALLY
TIME: 3:20 PM :
PLACE SERVED: 118 EAST SECOND STREET MT CARMEL PA
COUNTY OF NORTHUMBERLAND AND STATE OF PENNA., MAKING KNOWN UNTO : HER
CONTENTS THEREOF.
SO ANSWERS: CHARLES S~ BERKOSKI, SHERIFF
THE
BY DEPUTY: MORACK, ANDREW
BY:
DOCKET PAGE #: 01 CV 0813
SHERIFF'S COSTS: $ 90.24
REC #: 19340
NO. OF ATTEMPTS: 3
me '[his /f/ day of ~
A.D. 200% . ,q , ,-- . _
....... ~J~RO]=HONOTAFJy
~¥ Comm. Exp. 1st Mon. Jan. 2006
SERVE:
In The Cour. t.of ommon Pleas of Cumberland'County, Pennsylvania
Invest&gative Consultant Services Inc
VS.
Albert R. Thcmas et al
NO. 01 6560 civil
Sheri Thcmas
NOW, Dec~mber 5 , 20 01 ., I, SHERIFF OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA, do
hereby deputize the Sheriff of Northumberland County to execute this Writ, this
deputation being made at the request and risk of the Plaintiff.
Sheriff of Cumberland County, PA
Affidavit of Service
$ow~
within
,20 , at o'clock
M. served the
upon
by handing to
and made known to
copy of the original
So answers~
the contents thereof.
Sworn and subscribed before
me this ~ day of
., 20
Sheriff of
COSTS
SERVICE
MILEAGE
AFFIDAVIT
County, PA
SERVE:
In The Court of'Common Pleas of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania
Investigative Consultant Services Inc
VS.
Albert R. Thcmas et al
No. 01 6560 civil ~
Albert R. Thomas
Now, Decamber 5 ,20 01 , I, SHERIFF OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA, do
hereby deputize the Sheriff of Northtanberland County to execute this Writ, this
deputation being made at the request and risk of the Plaintiff.
Sheriff of Cumberland County, PA
NOW,
'within
Affidavit of Service
,20 ,at
o'clock M. served the
upon
by handing to
and made known to
copy of the original
So answers,
the contents thereof.
Sworn and subscribed before
me this day of
,20
Sheriff of
COSTS
SERVICE
MILEAGE
AFFIDAVIT
County, PA
:'UFK; ~'tSSC D']CK:T ~ ,:,.~u.~ 3336] LgCATZg~I: OUT OF CgUHTY
CLASS: ASSUMPSZT
~',",'",.'..- SHERIFF" S R~.TURN OF SERVICE-.--~w;X:".~;.-,..
SHERIFF'S OFFICE
CUPS~RL ~NE: COUNTY
1 COURTHOUSE SQUARE
C A RLI SL ~,! P~ ~7013
ATTN:SHERIF~,S CUMBERLAND CT¥.
PLAINTIFF DEFENDANT
ZNVESTIGATIV~ CONSULT~INT SERV VS. ~AYES, STOUDT ~ ASSOCIATES
/
IZi~SZO01 R~C~IVE~D ~/SH~RIF~IS OFFICE ~q SErVICe. TR~NSACTZ~]N ~0i-1-~416
A~OUNT Pll~
]iilZCOi SHERIFF' RJTURN. UNDER OATH, NOT FOUND BY DEPUTY P~AK AS TD
D~rEND~NT PAY~S~ STOUDT ~ ~SSCCZ&T~S. D~PUTY
K~iV~D A~T~R EXPIRA-
TiON D~T~. 3Ci D~YS RAN OUT.
Z~,VOICbl NA]Li~D TO CUMBERLAND CCUNTY SHERIFF'S
JO N
dON
JON
JO N
dON
~ERVE:
In The Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania
Investigative Consultant Services Inc
VS.
Albert R. Thomas et al
No. 01 6560 civil
Hayes, Stoudt & Associates, Inc.
Now, Dec~mber 5 ,20 01 , I, SHERIFF OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA, do
hereby deputize the Sheriff of Bucks County to execute this Writ, this
deputation being made at the request and risk of the Plaintiff.
Sheriff of Cumberland County, PA
Now,
within
Affidavit of Service
,20 ,at
o'clock ~ M. served the
upon
by handing to
and made known to
copy of the original
So answers ~
the contents thereof.
Sworn and subscribed before
me this ~ day of
,20,
Sheriff of
COSTS
SERVICE
MILEAGE
AFFIDAVIT
County, PA
BUCKS COU NTY-zof '--
SHERIFF'S RETURN
Special Instructions-
· C~v~ - ltant SerV.
Action ~ T~xr~ f~ze COtRSU __
plaintiff ~
vs ~ As s~iiateS--
Defendant
Address Served if Different
Served under pa.R.C.P. #402
___/A) {i) Defendant personally served
_ JlA) (2) (i) Family Member
_~_~A) (2) (i) Adult in Charge of Residence
__ J.A) (2) (ii) Manager/Clerk at Defts. Lodging
.____{A) (2) (iii) Person in Charge of Business
By Handing to
~ By Posting
~s Ran Out
~ Defendant Moved
~ Def. Unknown
~ Checked post Office _ _ No Forwarding
Twp.,~
By Deputy
At ~ ~ ....... v._~/.~d on trte
ment was serVeu ~_
The above docu ...... ~=, ~bove in the County
defendant as pert~ntorm, a.t~u-,' ed rani
~ ~ .... ,,~ ,,f Bucks County
Lawrence R. [~tchaels, on=H., v
Affir~d ~ubscribed before me on this day /~
Prothonotary
~ Affirmed and subscribed before me on this
Notary P~blic
~ Com. Exp.
Defendant Not Home
Address Vacant
~Dep. Needs Better Add.
Invoice to be rnai~e~ to
-- Cumberland County
Attn. of - -- "~-- Sheriff's Office
or