The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About08-6175IN THE COTTRT OF COT'?TTO'T PLEAS J TTESi ' A. PALUGH, JR., P1 -in ti:Cf CO R TIONS , ET AL . , en T(Tq JUDGE : Sect- n. III b lo,1 ire beinC, ;:ae c , - Xi- fie .. ---- - hEntZ. Aat? ?,. P? 4 9 nn A 41 cLtP, ties, o IE' fici.rl?.l cap a- :ruaisb1CTP0N P3 10VOKEb citi.- , aaL/cr. bot' ._s C" [,Cr • • _I! - t e U. S. @121 10r?`:"{ §610- o i' C. J:aris. jic_t on. tnxid. Authori.t T li s civil ".Ctioll `?t 1a`::r is Ta-de pllY'ssu,-nt to 11io,, la-!,s of the Co P nt? zrr,n, :^-? F'' • Cl. Fl. Z Y A.s o o ly,....9A - - ??5..?1) 3- 532-0) thf-- of l c l !! its?. 3 1. t re ( ller.1 C3, (C 2 r T.T. S. (',.A. 1925 , e, t, re(1. °;-? T . 5. C. A. L 1 7,31(,-,) , 134-3 ; 412 IT. S. C. A. §1907, et, seq.). The Co .trtl s ^. athoritlr to this tIl of PenrA Yrly n.ia (1968 Art,. V. Sec. 10),-, _ P. C.S.A. et seq. ; the Penns„rlw ni ( "PA") Rules o-f Court,, Rules 10?J1, e -seq. ; as °ael? ,,ny o cr .rin_sc- i_1 Px oce lare, Rule 1.n1' cl,,.i-ls hereiil. J• *-*e fort /aw app//ex, 3 T11is is civil ricl tFn action piled by Jr -:Zes A. P^111cr, Jr• Vil ( IT1,1 1 iti : /Pltf. ate pri --loner under the care (gin-tl/or l__ ch r er 9- cii fio czr, gin:. co a rte -n - trz., .. :. _ -; -co12 elz = ? tiol <. t ?i<' 1n T] _]_ ("5 CI-?i 1.17 ?illt7) nrPSP11tly 1 J1C r C ' ::,tE t_ in the St'l.'l e Co r l Institution q,t Fayette (11SCI-Fayett,et1) in L<.-.Belle, PA, uction . -for __ ??unc ive re e ae -777Cfi1- f -M.L19 -, ^ c ux u gn__ta__ L, e a, a r ; ??c_ i o :_=n c utho r i. fi,r evi o??a :71 a n- vo?te ITl P^rt I 1aove, asserting <^n 0- n,verrin.c, civil ri -' is ra+'_ otl!nr r' ,:,t? toa° r vi ol Lions ruc}z r s '? z.r ,s=s lent, e ru l lv,,rnssr^ent, rc i= - •_ ___mm_ _ _ -1,011' , nap- , T75 `? c ^}^Cr :.boll GOnc?IY CCr tQ ?e G Zr ?r 7 1 i C_ 811Ge, T'-li.l y-e to intervene -?s 1 superviSOr, to !'?rotect, V «:_._.4 '. '.?.. Q}1 :7r ?17 ti71.Qli., A'J ple C ss,: , itq b-,ttery, 11 nr, 571 op1 tv, ?•l.t .••. •...-___.._.., _.___-__?L..?-•'1-... 1.._._..y?l,•_.L. l..._.. _.iJ . _,... _•?,.yy?."j" I...,..,?. .?.?....lii.l. ,.., rytl!i.!_':_f:..ir .u Ili . 9 L 0 v 0 9 7 9 • vi Sit E` incre?sc i vi sitin, t ico, rLiss ary 'no('., r:,dio, ?c. nC2'S9 television, etc. fefas e!t ??l s• i?: c ??.? T r? _e I1.t.5_1.11?"at?a?t?r 7 r. . a_h .:11. c nr e j ?.1 n C! Plt ?° in , Cif <.-. S C•r" o t1 e cJ.i"r, es in A CJ '4-80 n t,,, .1.C . ,_? it 111.(_','''_ hirl bot.;l (`,:uc process t,1171 tm mmat I,, _L -"L _L L _,. C, te, 1 1 0 Ya I!. a ,rr I t ts _Q C e?_Y_, r i fr0i:1 iii l (I r to the Pi_t . Plt"^. ; o die' _ flo s.vc(.is it„T co,:'a.corn by rtteilntin` to see the of ITrpic..er s:'_rlo ?. _ _? gun ^ -7 ?i ffr--t-?- • 0 r Sent(mnber 24, 2006, P 1 t L . V''IRS ,4iVC11 nronortyT n,?C i '" rt,e 7.1 soo v'ere 1. ??uriil,rr this time that three ( 3) 35 i.?_?_i ?^t^Y rilO to- C3r,7.hh,? "J oh ?e,i cte? t1,-:ro youns7 r,.c?_ult fe;zples 1 s.?,?s.n< -m1 per or. ir-` v)rohi_'.,ited by, P ? PoC Policy, `sere Ill sin`; froT`1 1i ' y U1erty• . 45. m'ins('t;hree {3) rho to S `:`:'ere to be ret_irneCT to t1le llinsb-InO_ r ? of orl.e off' w1c e r7l=les r1_enic ec? _J.n. x1e n 10 o,1. ._. __ ___ _____ _ ??Y---?;:l??-aT--?e---a??-c?????.-e--_-nrs-???:_?? .?.?-?];?:,?-e-,---??i.e.c7.-l,n • _ _ ___? _nythin,,,, ,bou.t the 1111SS111;?; ,photos. 7. Kline -,Onittecl thrlt the only stq,if ,,',-o have .r1ccess to the ST'L? _Rro er TRoo' :re 1??nr. 1.1.;... TTul er _ ?nct-Z-6u !7,rf CCrn1.l1"' the SS111 ` Y)lotos. -?-. I"11 Ti-I-P-rt, t11(, F cilit`,T Gri-:v,7.nce Coo_ . in,- for q.t S!U- _ Tip --..r e e'?0_:-_r e? c J ??r*"r+ r pf1.S? :: - FsT?? gC ?- _.- ?.:.Lli:_:.t?.? 50b T°re n?lotos the >10 -aSs n t , i...,.,_, ??rere in t .Cl m,.,?.?io 1 or ri'ic.e ALl^;'l;,t 1,, 20,06 ,.,,en they ivere conrisc?tec' by est'.er T"line or !Tuber. T1r,t_ r V. ^_F n ,gin(? Plt` if :1e tr :Y1t? to LI ili?e the ST `.T? ll..ii.i.-l r 1 i i?r^.ry ?":ill") Pltf 11V e r rr _ , 52. S.l nson re T?:?n -e d, "Get n-.1_ecl.." P1tf. er_ onio,' "c,'.-,e nor- ..! - , ?? t »?-n-e.rch.,1?i- }n:--e -bene aver -t>e -rv?1_:---?t-tT to >.e se -un.l noise... "Uh, ah, o'v -,,,h! t11? ,,, ?;? • ? ,? ?, (?LL^i , '-;-. of P no t „ c.?~ ? ? tit^ t -v,.11 -ottl a e r. so 1, c^ll1 1;'" hi-1 5 ,Af l k-, C,n 1 ? 1.n " dressed, P1t1 • 71 Ce('_ 1 ; 1C?, ou.i- of, the r ?- 11- o re 1 ?n c?:cu ".Ire .• iio evc_ , Si ,o i ?(?. ,_ 1 0-- e L - Plt . to J ,Z 11?,.nds b.?-.c __ into the cell. Sirli-)son clornr'_ the t .r e;, Ciesi. tc)1-.. Plt:., "You h-r7(. so^:n on your hrncs." 55. Pltf. azserts that he cid not_ _hmv-e__an soo.o on hi. haaLls. ?r_r, the it Sign;"?5=on frbricq.ted this clni.m to denj hir^ ??ccess to the Collrtol a.p, r2 ^rls of h^r.ssrlent rind retrali.tion for the Pltf_.' s oocl _:, i_x ^- '? ,j'1r' .__;r.LevrlriCeS l,(c1111r tl1? S'?fi st-irf on the' • ?.'-?::..-•--=t;tJ-_-??'.?-Q._..p...i: - ?-:',lt t .7?._d.1'].?'?.,. O Y e11fc?•E} g.1.i1f in O t ?Y' ;ai a ";T i 0 l? ,:?? ,r -• t1{?1n 1,1 so believe,'- 1-h?. Sim, ,,on i.n- ?: r1?erF to er14r tile: Pltf. hip, mll time becn.use Plt-f. hr-.d :i'il-eJ ri.ev- C , sD1 -r c` ,')- P1_ti.._.-fell; 1, r,!iIiat, D;L ? .I s,onls s-extu-1 hpr-salient !hen noises -^s Pit'. ','1,'..S ni^.%ie(. ben`Tinr- O res t0 - - ------ ------ ?'.i?!'.Yl S1.^1n?:011 gently tOU.C.t1P,'_ '1;18 1n- f -P1t`f:?^ - -,?rr? ..-.__. t f-- i:e r? - ,33? ? Si an., - -,et:s a f se ti l ejat 2 r e._r. 0 _ t lz_`? I _ 1_I' '1t? rr-'.10 _ z?11 ? .1 j3ffjjMM ?,rlv''i1CeS G?1 P1_t • 1e_ 1. On. Ott o er 2 1 2 006 P1 t fIf e-,_ Gri e v-.ncF o. for T'1^ i Dv nee s ,Le lied , ,oe lle(!, rs1 es?1':un ec'i ?t ^.rl,linl S r?tsve 1 evel??. - !1?r?roy±.tlry1(1 ,TF, reslll'fp ,. .... ,..._...._.. V 7-.....J•vyl i '?f? ? ---Y"7?-.? • -?? ?? l...LL,L'.-<. L.'L t.--F?-_??1C. 1: 3. T?'?J fJ V C4...-4?'?-_-"V-S" ?7pZ:.??..C'.?.?.. Y, 1 'l M:-• .___...___._ ba ult^r, ')?7 o't;iler ST-M pl lsoners wl-jen he opo17 ,r spo1•_e bout Pl t_-f. • s C^.<<e°, by r7enyin;- Pltf. ?. i1erl cr-,. 1 '1 ; 111P1 to sl..lffer ht1r'' Ter lo,?S O-HnL?1 r1 10Y1 r. _. _.c _-0 J-441 l?.d cte- 11 '^_ ?'.te 1nC?i.?`? eyence. 5?. As f 1..Yeci. nnC ny0. 1. l ,te resl-3 t of -fore..enti.oned ..^ct s ll, o of B3 1 0. , P? fi :_ . u'f ?,.C 3zrrl^ ]- ?... _ _ e :_._ r CY __ nf ; 7 i nrp _*Fa > ev fir. cF? `,,a, n ,,-,t Si^ -)son f7n l o ''ley _:._ . ._ _ . __- .___.._____ KIT # f ', ?l? ^.s nsjTc'lolo?? c ?l ^b???e. 0 r r Y, ,,a t o tile- n 6 . A,, ,lirect rand pro > .11. to re, al fo__ lentionecl c s __ ] 'LL. __ 4) s1'l___. onertir c ?ec1 ? _i c 11v t :tree ?5rrl ;1101.0fi;r?Yp11ti. i !Tl DoC it t uf._t foi not, h.^vin.; noli Giesnrocerttre.; in l ce c Ce. ] d the 10 i , t11eft, Or rlc tyl?.C 1.1.OYl. 01 1eY .OYl.^1 -)1,0 ?(3r^fi f Ico 2..1 ? Ur- PA - - to f F... s x,r z?R ?}mil F t, , P? s--,%WT G-ra.f-?' d--ao _i ver tor?;_Pl_tf.' 1n his pi e,wnce con... ?cec.L. ?l. As _, ^. G', r?.; ,roxl.al^? e rc,11T?-_ of ?. rr:lrl.io?ie '- t. ?f ._;?kt ?^t-?_-?-??_,?.??-_„„„1?_.c?ts>:`Lr_Cr?.._-?3r3-i%3---'r}?-;?_?-'?l-k E3 _??'-0-0•??-.?-a•,l.^'' ?_..:11?_._Z.]._ .;?'_-Yr his 1 en he f^1 ec to P_ tr. to ? r, " ' o 1 t0 GOxlt Gt IrelCl?n°Y li 0' 1 . r] _ __ Yo Ln- :-,s .. "1 to s s ".. ? ._ ^ 8 G ! 1 r d i Q f f 1. G 8 to (Ie t e ri"x1111 e r e ^ f?ji r ?t*- `*1'r•±? i 3i33 P,--i? ?*t?€i._.??..-a -1 @1_L:L1}.._._C'.11, 1L'1.,._p? . ^ a 0_ l?:`'1E;:C i1Y1r'':] ?^ aY] efi ^!'T.111;LOC1`'.l EC time in-the.-SIT, `i1 ^ rr1?1C l_ "..nd -r 1. c - n i.l'? r 11i. i7 62. As 1Y C"F l.nCt ?Y O. i`1< l F J1r: for C1 - t.5 e' 'Cotl -'IIi.n-; 90 (I.-,jS (•;11icn 1:1e se2'17ec? i..1 full), (-c?nlrin,-; 'iir1 the o ? D 01,r, tl,'1 _1 'G ?T T O be %" E' _. e aS e ('_ fr 0 ' .i . ^1 :' S,. T, ^-:C]. -n" . _ 1 C <^ i1 i1 .1 C ?13 p2 T:7l?)r -1A:'.1`" of 'lt?.1^£?S Sri E'11t ; w11Y C' ? 1 _LOn, 0J':1C1...2 Olllir es `"?.OYIp -------.. to !D'T Ayer s, .c' f o , .l-I 1-r < . Y en{,? ? ? 'r L1 ?.0,f"i?r.?.f.i.es• d?Fwta?d " li-.c , _ T'L7LI)' , n ?. __S zaaa -,o oia.a_ 2-tf_.. au y or_e rl_ psi 0_F i'eCi;1.0]1 (fU?r?i.nteed to him. .,,.T .elti SpUf]1?!'.p ?rri^C'i"? 11?T. ?'EZCi1nC,r i.l c fi o - 1l'J.ff°YVC'i1e x(70 Cer'.Se1P.Se 1TJt1C S r0'1 C011t j_l1.'.'111 ,I _..... ,-'•-,..?-..,- ....c...T,.C_ _CS.?__•ti i1 ?'I__'f':I:?"IZ'.__„?91.^ __,r.?^.?e..__.,,.?.?,1 _ __ _ _ . _ _ __ .,_____ --__ _-___ I r- ? be, "o, 2006, r s e?lle,?- to PItf• 1c±._, cell. Af1c,e r c,',o' ri I that. PI f. 1nteJ t-o cne L ..T?'. 1 111.1?1 Co,10.oYiIiD. ? 10, c _C11 r JUrt' 110t',v CY ATP. TJi.r G'1 to %0 ?.n?? STTTT f COUNT I _ (Dei:s. I T?• ?'. C• @l n2" - 1FAIIITTLIB, TO PTIOT- "CT, FATLUTRE TO INTERT.TTE --kS _-SZ7P7VISCT -- , T ?O??"'?FI--?C-Ti_ .??T ? O PP RBIFi S IO NT p yt w?????77TTT? ?y t . y,.. .._!',•!.I:??Y' ?J r _.i:i 373 -- 17t- v?.• ,.•,n _...r_..0?,5..,;?....- u1 r -in 1? , ? - C1 r CO1.?i1 ,'? l,2?_- r- n t1..--- t0 nr0 pl (-.'°. .?... 1'1 -? - ._. _ _ •._ '?oc'f; c o... no:r,,,-J-`fig !??r Pe_i-, 4 ors, ? -- ,_ p v _ _ It 0 7':I J. t -. 3 r7 1,. c; Z i"" ?''t? Ct 10 i_- 1..:1 :i i ;1 ; Pl'i , C. ,• T Lf '..? ttn'.'1? 1ri ;11°??;> to i-n .? ?7f 1e ^?, ?'_I_tf. Oil. '1' Den-,on-11 lovel.`LC'11 ,^C'Iio.1a7..C) Y?? irr i' , C t7 :l i _L 't" i' !% e YZ C ,° l 1. r =?. C C 1 C'•_ i' 1. !. ? I t? i °1 r' l _ 5 . ZT ?1 C '_ E'. 1 ? }^ t C - --------- -------- n1, C!7.Ce . _.... __ ._.._ ,-,c?._ ._ __.-.ur<?,,,- _ }°r 1-,,.,- r1.c',?.f'7"??`?`?--`?-O?i?t`3i`i-?--fly- -.??`? F'..--T??:+?--?f r----? f-? ?:'•a-3--f?..._.?i1=)-??k?:?:- _ .._______ ... _-___? _, 12c?,i;erl,_? icotiffss_.1:Y?-en.io'"??...rec ess, ?1 ;re - r 1, cDI 21 r, C,, 0-:.1 :rF, ?r' ?e11T)er^.t e i.nJifference t-o t3:1E, Plt -Yl_ _ 117,73 FORE, ur.z?u' c t e(7, , Pl tt i . r-7 m_.r>n (ls Ile folio . 'in r relief: I -? C --,-a 1r•,i-ory nzlc? t1L1i11.'F Ve Vie Def-. in i frOIa _ zT ' y o it ,r , or r r_ V 0 ^ ' ? l Jr in "n "? 10'1101.'1- il_. ?_rll- 1Yl ?. 1 'tlC.] tr 1 r-? 0? y1.i1?' G TTO 'J Tip. LIICt 1 Jr relief 1.11 File f Or"[1 0 einta.Yl, _ n!i :?_? 0 Pl'1', ' • ? c ?'? i^ i ?:0 n. r e C 0 r C?. S ; c Relen,2,- "'"0'.'1 se`,-rex .11011 FO 'nr rll.er ,l +?O?i.zl<::F1Or 1 rF`r w? 7 e11"orcin,m new PA DoC Policy or rterron,--?! 1)1- 22- ii. C ,o i1 al l o Ply f. 1'',. 0 i ;"ler 1171 O''1P1 r 1:11.1 ?r? ;r l 1l- ?pl Fo e ii rye, n'c cluri.iElie ,c11?.1 ?1. 111.7__. r1. n,, ?:. e) }p.-?,y for nv Coin t_ coy hr- or fines; _ lncLq Deis-, 11?_r t; rc1.'-1burse Ili r'oi" coat , of li,lF1 tion lie 1..11- ., tr _...-... , ._ ----'?-,._'-_ c e c , --,-_^-_. (T r'"r 1: - fio, fi=f,nea 70 Tpri T' EFT OF PROPERTY, FAILURE TO I AVE 1.401-,ICS ; Dt.tE ral - - _ Lp" CESS, LIT3ERT r INTERT.STS, CI`TIL RICTTTS, l,',-T'-'L 1rTErT DTTTa ,T T - DUE PROCESS CLAUSE, PROPERTY ITT TERES TS ---0LAI S._.___ ._ _ 3E' @E CL ; E -3-? T-99 (PA COTTST.) LOSS OF PFRSOTTAL PTC'ERTY, EGI,I(7,M E Ok r , a ^ " one e,-v Y- . \ v7? re 1Y1rOr Oi Fe( I Y^?rc-ace, ..Ull 2" 1, 1-.11 e'2. .n F _ _ _ _ _ - _ ? a .i- --- X33 e-t ? • -. ?.?re-d .._?_ _?-? ??-- ?a-t...- ??-??1;?::,i-l ?--=?=?-?-?.-???---? e ..__la ?'?a- fi.-e.:::.- - Plfi" nr.,r on i Y_lronerfiy leil Ile Mlf1 eref' F'P loss o'" _rE?e ? j) X1101 t)- !i_' '.i.,'_E' PI_'F • ? _ no" bI'?ein,,, n lit, (?.a a':! ?.n.c' __-_ ' J ..',1%• [YT T•i.. 27 1 7 TT 711. ^1.11 O:!: I11.^: F ]' .On 12 t]jja A 1 _?:+..__^ X Z o PA ?/ ! i" 07111 i. l l': - 0 0 1 1. cur ?_ n l .. V i_..1,11l!J' .. ?? l r Y1 e r 'F t r 1 11 'F O r . , 1 • S u d e?? ,. 1 ^t e,rr L_,.l o , _ 0' ?c';; r ac't' ion, ot"` o•F' er IoSS; b,v fl-_ 1..1t 0,7 1011., ',l i 1]E'?, p }??_ i n ?r0 r l?r T.r O ll?T. 37"S1.11E , ^ ; _, =ISYI- _-173-- lief' (III c- §1983 ?:TEREFORE, pa--- a-nLat to 4-2- TT. S. C.A ^n' P'.. C. S. E3? ?Ol, et, sec;-. , cc I1S^t Y (I-,u ?eS ?,°;?,1Y1St 11 t1,1e DefS. 1n t, hi, Ci0unt jointl7, or severz lly in -n ^.l'iount to be ---------- c e e-r.ciiner by a fury, a riot mess thr.0.M; 'ur,lljT, jointl,r, or s°.ver' ily in ?.n f oLuit to be cleterllinecl by j ur?r; 17 nor any uou-rr, a.lnes or cos-r•c; Inc c) u^ :s. ;:ltitrl MR ' 9 .in ?r 'CT curc,.cluding bit, not lir-dte? ll_ to, - " ttornc,tT fees, ?'..el"l v etc. .? TT. S. C. §10-/33 - CONSPIRACY TO DEnT" CIVIL RIGI7TS 1 OFFICIAL SIFICATION OF AN OFFICIAL REPORT . RETALIATION (GEI'TERAL) , ':tETALIA.TIO T FOR r 1-,TTT?Tlff? TO j HAW AND 1`'TAIIIFEST HARM A T SI - m ra m e r,, arr r?r?r o fUU j ST ATE CLAIMS - RETALIATION (r 7?I`11LRAL) , M.,TSr'.)OTU FALSIFICATION Fup )----_.w rnn nttmrrnrrrmrr+a ?la-?? --- Sr'.r..T?T, RrTALIATION FOR PAST OF717ICIAL ACTION 4-nln-e-4- 9 re _i:neorno'rP.treJ hero-LO'l Dy reference, -as thott7h en.ch 'Jere fall,T S,-..t !-ortl1 herein ^.' l en tl ?t,?_? _ _..75 f. - ri iec i _.tli1 ?ourl iai?1 ?_CLi7_I r f :lecl to , r'otec_t P'T_ti'.rs -'-lets, k)y 'ai con tact resort .<-;',4 ia'st . Pl l' C I"1e-.,nS O h r ,SSI?P,nt ^ncl ret li^-tion for _,ttP.rgptinrp to re- J! i')Ort jt3_l_e ,"?t1.On of nbtl^e fel_lO''!' CO-- 'Orl e to SLaper?Tlsor, nces. As _f_.Y_0au2! f:l' fl i P11.f. : li ~_ creel servim -in ur1 1?a.rraalted an cil,i on^1 ni.netir _(90_)__._ _ t' t"L.S "?..1 Cl lie served in fall in -0 _ lOSS of ire a.?1(":lorir..?_"o??.??er c,11r.1??Yl. ae ,V;li_-,.o ,_, Count 7-.,eye 7 '!.1P "'.JOV^ CL (?.~'c cibe(_ '.CtiOi1 ', of file Def. iT1 t"-is so intention 1 +f C , ,31, ?1 "trP,cl c'.tch 'V l.'ll: J. y t'.,_ . ..r C-i UJtj 'i')l.,-t."J '. 1V.111 1 e- _..-- . -_ a L0_LIrlt to be f-etermined by bud not less t11-.n °OO.QQ; 9 ;FORE nur?u^i1t to ? TT. S. C. §lc6 ^Il r P r. S.?EOl, et. ''? , serv. Pltf. ,e ,^ .('_; t'1e follo.-dn, relief: b) Pt>_Zi.tiv ct rn des ^inst Def. s ohri i.!1 t}iis Count in rn. jury -dth Pltf. ?L,^ Meson .loon, to be cletPr._Zi..necl by sanctd.on o 310,000-.-T) _or e_17c 31v1l -- c) Doclatortr relief in the ort-i1 thrl.t Pltf. is L-u,,.ocr-nt of this l7i.scon.(lact Report, No. A834302 ^n, -.nor o' lcr ?ncl°:>tor re- -- 1 1. C 1 111o t r a n -? o r j lle Pi . U c"' ,; Ti tr?tir?:lt: f in f ? -Po :nn o f rnl i TTh o n Av -nn? beinC; exnun -ecl irorl Pltf. ' s, nri son. -cc (-orcl, e) Rele.-,,re from Ce,t~reg.ti.on to n,r oner 1. no,?>_ ^tion• S`) Dpi . 1o1,ha ust T)-y for any VOULTJ, CO;? Lim UI L l-L1C ;? _Yl Pi rn ?iir-,P i rac _rs, i._-l.cIur1 , b It not lii t0'' to, r,- o:_; 1 c,rzen,:c :, St to 1. }-•? fee ::i (l_el!?'CT !7??rr1 !', r;eF 11.'I er°`, l? ?teo , u QQaT T IV T 1 T" CIO once, ?-.s t'laoll"?T.:_._n?..cal_?°ter "cat forth eYO.M t lgn,m h. rT% De r. nalecl in tlds Count nnln•:ITT'tlly .C^i-lec tO pro?;ect 3-1 ^ =:i1ec ,o Pltf. to c, ? I_ Def. oIl i +ness to 'til conce_rni.n.,? Pl'i._',« CJ11'l,:.Ct 13."1'11] %Or Tliscon(l:uct Yo • 8 1 -v?2 9 Or ^? i ,n m 0 1.nc• lL1 Y e llfJ.,;.TOrn., _ l,1 r r t ti 10_"?.r .'711-ch T?, `TsO ! _y • o 1'-_} +_ ._ ?lCs,1C ] , P, f'... _1: f- r--ElC0T J;4 V 4t 1eo c I1 (71.oiioa E?-x1 stec7, 1oY os- oy nO'. Plt-°e oj'?t. of ?,?. :,ll? P7J '1 .:no-, ?.1 t P1_tf. ? s 1.i1C? 'C T(? ^.?. ?'n1l_'?._1 •'1OCi c7f 11..6- ^i1(` _'l''_rl (2 . Piff, calf l_li1C': , o r•ns n?t.1.. .. iC7 C?.tr o Dir. Y- 1.(.'^r .. :L1. 1 __.._ -_. _ r•• -- - 1iJ _._____._ .__ „ ,7 J tl1 r - 171' 0., ,ec_ P 7f, Yl1r 1"OCR '?.."a ll ? ?1- lzy La' ?_-i ???-{-'-7-c_r-_'_-^t•_..r ??-.??.r>--?6?-.In - ....-_?1.??r-.?iL'__ .L ? ?_.. ? _ .......? __ , :I'? n 1 n ,?.!1 u a% 11 . .':.? I P( _. J i P t ?) (? (T 1 I 1 011.' l .) C T : e c <. O n 1 p i :..?t7 bl ??..1_. e ,. '. ,._ t .ii G. .1? lZ .i 0-L7 of? L. 'h 1( ' ' 1 l !to incUf! erence t") --fie P'l-'r .C o ? ij ci ":Til l L1 7 '.1'_ 0 2..? 011 of ?? i.l..Ci1, t?. v e '''Irv' "11? 'V'.."J ti:?!'l.I SLS, x11:1.1 ,:?1.L ?: ',.L1 ?? isv ?,_ ..:e »•s• r P l r c -1- .._?of r co _ ._ t ^,11 ?? 7 L1 t11,. 1 V e l^ v i z c.' t it 'i ; De f. r. T E __._ _ 1 , n ?.•____ _._- (D a v v l LC.L 1, a ! Yl `? t l_ :?' O LL1 i' J eterrdjao L1rsr r_ • _L i 11, fi .1 S 00 n. e r) TT 0 ?02,? o'r' O court, u1c? ?-' 1 E, o 1.O r1 O l r , ner i no ~u - , l Oil _ e -T) f TT r C c - t__`-. ___ vT u Vii. ' COQ 7. 1?1n??, ,n0g T rv y 1 La ry ! r e T 1 !? ur s e fl Or c0,:! i; _= l_1 1 1 C, x'1011 1e t l 1 e c s, rl el -r f" -I 1 rf p i 1,{, 1 er e t, ., ' _ ,iL1e rT. a. C. R1c?33-_ -')72,TIAL OF D?7E PR0CI;SS 1TTrT G , rm - S '? Rl'T TIJS TI OrTY, IITdES IL?7R ' SES g F. Tn PROTTVV T, DRMI BT)ATE 5 7' 7 ...., ?J1 'TIS? ITT - ( 'B, AS 17-30 JL') s, , - OT ATE CLA.II'TS - AT 711 IS A, 0VE) f PILL OF ,! RTf"r=TS (UL) i COMTT v "• Tr 1r'11?c r, PA D o C I ^x5, rE31.c,Pyf a j_L? ', 11?crp A 1-? - LST .'p _r. „. r Tr r r +--------- _- (U• S. UO 71 LITtJTION) f 73. P , ,r. ,j1s one (1) fi o is mj1 ?r^.n fi _ ? ern + 4 (75) n .or or ?.1 erel_. ?;r r?'_ ?ncc; _- _ r .i1o i1,r;_1 ^".cl 1 er 0 L r r^ I - 'tip, r--- 77. P? - 1 7,01 R he De__ . nr 1 in i'jj . Oouni, it constil - fi1 .) fj ------------ y; 11 1-'f0 1'he ...._.._... _ _--- ??•. ?.?-_ , ?n??.- ?_n ? ?.? ??_ ice- _.s??`?'e-?°?1 _ r???--??-?-r- _ - E; r C TT1 ?? n '? i C i1»? l1_Ln? 11or, 18 PI'f'f• 0 ,1. e Uu1l l17L PC i;=1c Citizen r,,r wet s r0,2i ? en or it c, rO i.,? t 1 1 on,l ,_n1 to I fr,- from Oil, g 1 O O ?1 ??:C'-e -SS S 1O -n j O1'renCe, Y).n r-'T j-%'PI1C8, b ;3s of ,11e process ri uhf V jt 1???' { t1e DP ^.n i 1 ol].e" Le Co._1t?]_ • r !,. .'1'31'll7 -_OLlr au -tea 7T1e 12 Po.1r Ft:t 1 -11 .Arlen!t,,,ents to the Unite. Stites Con ; a i -,uvw,ion, Pltf• cle_ CO ' l E it ; Pt.0fy ?Yl r t? U_ai i- e C ? 1< , e S 1...Y1 ,n in excess of ?i li?t.lc11 O _?r` f ?YUS 1o1et.lyci. ov. ?? 1 :,r ,,? (1) thro?z~' r ?eve?lt?r-nJ'n,e (7one .? .r ?' .f' ?; • ?r ? 1. ? i 1. t' zl ? 1. : 1 c? .Ce"'.1c?.t]. Ca• e 7^1J e r ----- f i. l in p .r?. -L 1?1 J 111 L) ^;:?rse _ iron i11., 'neci_?i.c Co1n? 1., 1.L e1n. F1-o.l herein. V3. 1)E-.Z nic ii'1. P'?Y,^,• ti 11?rel?? '.1.•,i11.rSer 1rOi1 1! ?' ?C1._L t,c C0 l!11711i1t -herein-. rr1---Trt9--"s^Pi4-f+--+a-wire CO,-. . C:. t, a_rtiu l0 33 lc' 11 ; Fe (I i, 7 R Pr 5. P1tf, ,, . . o C. ---- c o c i b : ; __ . nn or 1 0 ; 11 r __ _, 1CCe >s7-ull r r d . ? e,,erve c"''A- 'Oe J',r^.ntec • Uv• Pl_t1`• asserts Varlt. 11e '.1s ?^ i 1??1iE3' Vie gjirCAcmts U l S J 1 CL S 7 <'' n ------- -LOil vi, S' ? ':1 1 r 1 FT FI t , . 1 ?o ? sen rnc? ,-_ P. St? In C- $tt.i.. 1.:.-c i:. ?. 1,a.._.__.ci- i,Gt-vl1-_..ii..L..-.-- .?W..__.Li-C,'...?,^;,n I, :a?.4.. ..lam. L_.n-.? .bd.Jr nPY-T iF.•u ` IT V1 ?i 1;'1 0_? lace by rr1 'Orl Oi f1 Ci`,, _s in t7.'1e PA DOC :3'Or OZ7E?7^ 1°.Otlr (?r) 17 ` oli t ry. --con:'1.ne, ? ent ?? c',?flrlntlill 11 c? tt1 nnt till t-J, 11 nr?. n c n L r_ ,*} hQr) C1 a, C 1 1.?1. C? 7.I o.• -Lo, ^t 1 this (', r1.1 lit f'. 1i1c.?. 11 _ 0 ?1?71 eS- », 1orsx 1-101; '`'O sec.'iumili-'lion nor r°ven'-, 'ill! tCi re?,tOr,C ?11ct1.Ce _°Or S } f P 11_. ,. _5 , S r Ml CT77,1-j -171-0.C`2 VII. De 'I c Lion tY??FRFIORF Pl^,intif re 1)ec?;_.u7L »- -.--,_ .11.5 ?n )ren Or '??0 aLl CCOrr11 t0 t'1e l2l'r9S 0 -IC' 'i:hi S COUr i; -^11 r1 nn•", er Or 1.1 e s vi o _ , Y-- onr ec1 in Sente fiber 2_ , 2008 77, t? c1, tj r SCI-FnYette LrBe7_le, PA 15450-1050 I1 i T77E COiTT.T PLA r0i7RT O F (TU)'TBFRLWTD COUTq,\Ty, PEPTI`TSYLVASTIA GT.._ A. P-.ltzch, Jr, , IDe.1 Ln "r-hr. Pl ^int f"1 t, c 1 e ?_, - - e at cllec' CO:?1rr'.o hereby Jec?l_^.re o --..t-,- _ -- lL -r-1o_,'1 0e, 1n or'?^ti.on end belief. n0, Y ff-',ls? tit L. eraents lerei. r1 `r b e F,, L,17') j cct, t0 r,en 1fi, ?? . for L,-. O C? t'',.C. 0 COI1G°111.Y1.? fI c 7 y'; i?^1?1i`_C< 1?;1.or]? - ?_,iai,. _ - •• - - - ?> 1711, T: O _ a1 7 ?E 3eiF 9rr ?f 3F # CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE - T bn1 n?° ??he P? i.11(-1 ":r O" i 11c , 'F'F, checl o1nF, P?.__11c11 v. PA Deg.rfi leni; o? Co rrec•t;ion et ^.l. (C.se ve sErve.n or1 1riI conJ off' T ?- ^ ,L,'?p-?nua4..j,.1 r s pT ? ?I,/? .__ h-c/? w-.. Ja- ?] -riz'. 1 "a=00-Z Rulce 1V' it into the hl.n(rs ? P9 DoC F?uil,` r - -- ? of t st-ff at S CT ?- F,'r . c serV e s IDn'- e Vi f1- "t- U. 9 oz, r^P.-nr i^1.t tin'1?' X10 Ilm C?u?lberl,?.nrl. Cot711?;;;r Cour?;houee Ooze ??titlra z o _ nn:r e _ PA 17013-33<7 J ies A. P?lu.c'-, Jl-., Pro Se 3 -3-g`, cc: rI F^ --_- _ L ?Re1i PA 15,1-50-1050 Sef?i e:?ther 23 2008 -- c -n t s ile rt? r... _ ----- --- i, ITT r'?I COT?RT p' rp'rt;p1;T PI,TJ.:?.J OF 0 j!l.H aRL TTTD Ir"OUITITY, P7T1_` MMV;1NIA U .'?T r J:.r1 `'f • PAL U CH, JR. CIVIL ACTIOTT - A.T. LAW PENNOt CTS, 76 • ? LV D NI +` ' A A EPARTMENT OF RR t2C1 TIONS; ETAAZ-, E'erard A,r,, M -tthf?t;r VO, 1, Eric ; 11 D1 of»4 SoL1i 1(`:r s , Roberf T3obl) jn 1] ( ; _ T _ _ - lp'y y.?Gt C' 1`? l )-TTI? n i Don,i;? . 9 ?. L. ITn?_c'.'1-more o JUTff TRIAL D T.11`TDED: y ry ----- --------------- NN 0 T I C E ------------------------ YOU I VTR BF? T SUED IN COURT. If Jyou. ;rids to de:i encl ,iT r l; kite .. . . i-,"10 ?- ? ,: r• ?. m c? l1 111 'f-•' ? f''?' 1 1 •.? '_?Z - G11 1 1 i1 ?. . `r^ -fter this rf (;Or:111,".1_n? r .1 (20) Notice y re ,erve;?:?, by en- t nr,r<^on,i, l ;r O -r ID7 " t t n C 7.;ti?;w te ot1rt roar cie cx?sc or of}jectio-a;, .o'l.e c__?,ir e.t s F r„ .. o_ J e ou. Dti f, rp t ,,?; it drnLt_ir_,i?-c ? ? _ ..? t7(?F?(>'(9 1..1 c. Ltt1 =(?:'i. _ `7rr {.) e.t.d. ,)l-e.. fl,"ls...)?s - `` 7 ? r? r- C o a by ?- 1n (I tI:r j I,. LOUl" fLl 1-. ,,, r. ?nctdon or n-oti.ce i o?npr c'1?^.i ?e i L 'th (D. I ? t,l? or fo r i1 J o', f?r c'l ',1iR or .r elt of r(o0 Llo i e ? ;??r the p? ,111 li:a'. Yoa - - --_ ---- - , . PrT? Ol^ O? 'n ? c 1r? 1?r( 110hfZ 01 22r02 T rO l? I ' Taq m0 ,rO iT? T1 i?rT'iTR ,.',m 07 T Trt Tn• j )o ?T ?. ,. Tr11 f' _ _ T, A `.:v?r"7 1 T T m 1 '7 TT?J 9 T .?? IJ J T"OTT 1J rR ,,? TE 'T ,_4 O2 .<? TT 0. TY? ,?1 C? CO TO 0 :J ? IC, . r nm 7?T _ T{ aT,O ! rn? T OUT iJTT;'R-F YOTT C?iT (* f1 LT;(•T,aL TTY (1 11 i IT • 1 ---'?_ n 2 .1.7613_ ........ ..._ .n v- 4 l r t? y ---- --- - -. _... - i - - -? - f ?j 1 I IN THE COTT`2T OF C017,,TOTT PLEAS J n,TIBS'+ A. PALUCH, JR., Plaintiff CIVIL AVTION' - AT_LA` __._-_____.----__.. _ YRNNS''XLVANIA--DEPAItMENT -0B .__ CASE _TTO_. -- CORggTIONS, ET AL. , (F J,l ,Tofe[?druzs 1 i.,-l.ecl--iu -. JUDGE Section. III bnlovi nre being; _sue4 fan._ei_titer.__.eir._aariv?t?__ - .-.-- ---_._..__P.EdDE?1S_Aatl?_S?r??&?ffNZ?- Cv,'o dltios, o fi ci.nl C;tp<a- SuR1SDICTk0a T,5 1AV0KHb citeAy?j,_ :.1(':fo r . bo_tL as _ 1a_ i-_ `©WArDED!- ca t. e c? C O M P L A I N T Cons U. S. ?1^1 @6u0: or c _ _ ?lal e This civil -,ctiosi rt lq.,m is rv,.cle pursuant to the loss of the .t-a.ti.on or hr, Conrabna,,e .lth of Pennsylv:^ni (-2 Pa. C. S. A. X931Y--__-__-- C. Li-ter" S 1.+ t c r of A .er z.ca (42 U. S. C. A. 9§1? 63,. 193591=nc^,6.;..._42 A. P§1331(x.) , 1343; 42 U. S. C. A. §1997, et, seq. ; anc? 12 U. S. C. A. - --- et; seq.). TIC Court's .uti,oritl% to he,a.r _h is civil c1.c-,.l-on ?r..;,3-q:int--l, a.lth of Penagrly ni (1966, Art V., SEC. 10); A-2 Pn,.C.S.A. et: seq. ; tho Ponnryl vani ("PA") Stq.tn Rules of Coart, Rules rIf— P ocE'_1zre, R z?_ lObl, et seq. as voll x.:..?ny ofisL?r"___?nnl.1C?_.__ :.nl C1 i 1, '_irrnin. Jica4e 4orf law a /yes. This is a civil ri.frh.t; action ii(-,CL by Jrvies .9. Pa1uCh, Jr. ( "PlM.atiff/Pltf. ") , - stgte pri soncr LL-Ider the Care ('.11(!/o1' l< Cii - ther f), Casto('t(r,_ n': co tr51..o€' t C PA DerctrtT1m7.t-of-Corner.--ions----- --(YDa ?)-,- -a-x:..er1 y--confined__in..tille-St'_ a+_E__CQrr_e.ct: a c_ia7 In_s.ti t :zt_ioil at C .rtp T_tll_ ("`iCJ-C in T'il..l"), -m-1 pre:sentl,y i-rlc rcer ,tE('. in thn Str.te Corr ,Ctionnl last,it ai-.i.on `1t Fayette ("SCI Fa.yet:tc") in. Lca.T3elle, PA, -fo:r ?i;ju_tcfi;:iv? reTie?' ????--.????..1 -?r--f?--c-o-zn-ens?i-or•?---;?,n:??--rc?x?i?re----- ------- _ r?,.. ^ r?aur_< _LAn._t;---to-._111.eju.xQfii_s2?? cxld putliori1,uryrevioiisly in- ,hts, rn(1. other Voice P^rt I ',bOVE, L SErti11 ^:nO_ 13VErr1nA; C1.V11 r i g `3 .t ,r.tion., . .-n.n.r:`a3•.1 end:, re[l_ia- si.. ?_ tT ziol _. c ?iItch ?.s _t 1a.r< ? lcfnl iA ..nt, se-Mal il 1011 di.C offs 1 - - ._. --ni i °etee, f:ailurc to intervene 'IS i supervir,or, f;!.ilunr to protect, al or, ,r E,»i.on, i :? le :.s ,pu1t, bpttcry, property, r?.e- ttn ------- cf rte:'i c^1-se:rzrl:ces, ^TM;on7';1--._0.-ther _nnn(?:en.t ,.n,-=fo,•-^ ?_en..r?:h. 1 ;t<a.i e. a 1,I e eral__ J.u =i a?lic ioi?.3.1_ clains under 23 U. S. 0-:1. §1376 for V.'.O? O :L 'k:llo F, rL k , I''i ft]1, El 'ltl1, L11C1, I''OLlr k:e ?rit11 lit ?nc?_,!1P.!1t of the TTY S. Con,.^t to ioa hi cli ^rr U•-,.YLLn'ccecl ",n(' r,Lie to ldm. The Pltf ?_co ?_1r r, Ac,,- mence. III. 1 P^rti es -A . --Paluch, Jr; , _ p1 r11 ±-imm's relcvm-ii --k•tr-- i ' 1c_ c r,?tc d t_SCI-Crnl, IIi.?? ill 1; le rci.l rT- n lent Unit ("SrrU") cinrinthe events ,lo scribed herein.. :'is ire c ' i lrea„ .1,-, 50 Overlooi; Driv,., L-,Belle, PA 151°50-1050. )_..PA_._DOC', i r, -n1-cm r ,_. O.'. le CO lU;ul_ o lth O Penn :;'r1 v.°111 G1, ntl o-rersees the r1`n r e_ i ?.?ni 1 1 i ^P ?,l O Ce !SO Pre in Cll ?1 of 1h^ ca to(lvt, 0orltrol, ?211' C re f 'k_Ir Pitf. ;,n for t22e hLL"1?.ne i:re Ltment of _.,.31 a -•,+e nr.c;?ner,?q s:ne?LLi?i:in??; ?tt4. /zo+ ?_?rs-t-e z--tea-- ?;1*_s-a;s-kr?l?-l-i:?k-__-__-- --- "o1L i is _oI i^ie , nrocl?rte rllleW, r??u1_?kioi2't ''Slc' 'ircctlvCO. Eic PI. DoC ir, being, s"Uec.'•_ in offici^1 c^nacit17 ,,n,'. i.s loc,,te 7, < t: - 520 i,° l ur l .Ron(!-, ..P 0. Iio 5?u"; C?mn T1112_Pl? y 3. -- 9 ??QQ Eric II-lac Ac';. -n ' ubrr ("IlUbOr"), TTP,V Si,lhson ("Si n or1"), 6 - - - r. rc col?Yecti.ons 0-ff cers-_._..-------___-.. i.llr c p;er . three 0537 C1,0 1M 11,;.,: Co 1pL i.r11, P.nc. -their law-,,n r.l(Tress i. ,-, 2500 Lisburn Ro,°d., Cp?ip ?'ill, P9 17001 8037. ---- - - _,f• B'ex'-"-'F7. -??4}9?bE# -.P6'9`PC3` -1,'?'E3fltt-T-•?^'-9 n 5. 'r7^.:?_. Roo^3rc Robber ?rr_z:L'.er-..(_'irrerr?er }--?.?? n r .{;r,?n'r1s su;?cx-risorf- tofi_ic De-'P. li` ^ci in ( 3) _ ^oux (^) ,'1i)oif e, r11Y_loyc,l - t SCI-C^.r_1n iii.11 in. the Sr ITT ki.ies relevr it to t!ds, Connl ilia, ,vd 11 J -no.:'1 e, cadrenF, is isburn-Ron 37,--Gc nri-Hi?_l?-P --17941- 37. ------ _O. _D-,°F R].-------- "Dic1111 j0"ut?1(?rs ("SoLtllBrs") 1.S 1?1. 1ll11t r?1^:?Yl`1.- -- '_ ?l2 oYVi£iOYt 'ar?J`;1.111.^tr?.TO1" to the Deis. lir.tccl. in np.r'arrvc nhs - 0), n ?1. - 1- ' f oar (`-) 4, ive (5) TTi 1 ?o Te, erlplo?re?1 -^ t SCI-C• rip _ s-_.1 2500 Li-r1 urr_ Ro d_, P.O. T'ox u337, C?rl7 if11_1, PA 2.700?_- 7. Del. Z?.C ,a.Y';7 TTO1?1'. _(_ttr?TO, 1_r.'," 1S ?. ilCc'.Y'1n;?" eX'lil i for >>ri tuners ^ent sect of kL bronj.ln." 1c, 'fe i besuet in both hi; of i ci.;,1 nc Triv<.te •ti.e3, r l?, 1?_i i_no n . (11reos is 2500 Lisburn. Ro-, ?L, P.O. 13o, Cn n ."_fi.1?_2_ P9 __...9700'1-_88-3`7?--- - tip w .. r • 'I 4,4 ; 4 A r, t E,vF4ft = nn•,l L,Z Kn]S1-in prnhn pr"l ".11 C'_/O ". 1: ^.C1. }_iTJ' c:_l(,)-,.. -er of SCI-0,1.1n I'111, em n]_O tr-n,'- b' ,r the PA. DOC, -rA :, al t1?1c„ rclc.vmf, to this Collr,l,int; the 3cnior Sllpervi,:Or Of _ otr7h C1.-Nh1; J, - hc?a---*rrr. xvm-e-r--in-ri=, 7 rr s •_ . (3) thr Ce cJan.?: it _b^'n rug?.. in both his nrivate P,11( officiRl c pn:- ci ,i c- his cno:nl P?,'revs is 2500 hi, i)urn. Ro..?., P.O. Bo-. -Dr- isrr---trya,? -.phrr- three--{ 3}--?h, opt ]1-i Pn-(10}- qulb Ci'l i zeii of '1!'Un tcr' S 1_o£_L bel i evcP 1-0 bn re d(7: Y1.1 of ti-.Le --------- 0 ° Pcn.. *1_vni. 0 _-- -- 1' OOC11111L1G o ^,C1 , L122 rr c.7l_O r ? Ct;? C T ? ]? 7 l ? _. , . . . _ . -Si wre a•- iefi e1e r a ?i.t? r)? 1171.E bO1 1 y)r!_V Ar, ol?kr Ylr? O t11F-C17-T021C, 01 1 .1--fort-:^ o1 the F._" DoC. 1 I". At -1I y M", 111100, h rni rr]c, n i ,I C LL r Wes-0 1n'iv1 :'101 >lil Fh?rs r21 Sol r . , _ , , , 0 J -r 1-11.0- al :1,bou i-he 1-3s of i-'._., COill'l.n c`.l1ll O -F es Cb ?:i?11? tr -- 'I:J,;t.,'i... n., ? 1..c roc, ';1^oil,,io-i r9.O7.°.',. ,. i ti .17t? _.1 _, ,? "? ,'?•i...n 7 1.r',1 !. "r'01a r'r. Jr.. 1.?. 1]".. 4o u .__.___.. _ - _.^;'_ . . 1 ?.?", f ;11_?7l^(-d `'I"i)'rC_,.....7_t?..'?'_'•_-TJTfT1?IT*',.,<';_j77 ?'C?__-<x1 ;TT?_-x'.' c : ,> i,,`?_'.?..__.. _______. £Li'r In iia? _ t Tl_ F 'i1 ( 1 n?J ^Y a. Y) _ i.l0i) l v0'i'1-. 1 ?. OJ 7,0-, ?_L., 0709, Y-1. il_n" C1crn1 L7 ?- Cnr,rt { p?? -a ri --PA Ilonor ble Ec?.C_ B. Br-y_ley. i1 `tr::ri (15) '?'r:11'OU,,;"_l 1' O ?111:,i E:?' O] t r , O -.----- T PA no Cy }_. (or -1-035 ritril Tc,rr_l' .re .l.rlcor„or- 7 1 - - -- - o P- " _ ----- - • . -?}.-??-.1..7._.:.x_1.....----------- I„ i ,r.. ij rn l)f.i.;? refcrollec" 111 ;-_t01-,IT 0111_r_iJl'-------.._.. D l,nc it 0 " tc ,.,, 12 ° it a cl'21is "f1r i fol o r' --- Pair. i. e%n-r crcor'c'-"`arr- S >, ^ , ,er n, 2006 O 1 , , n 5• I? ii 110ii ,J y P .1 1Ci1 1 - CO h1i; oat of i11.r cell Ct Hel > not even Of i-i e. Y0Llf10 tcl" i-n .; ; e0nlc th'"'t `0Ufre •S c-,-T01'. ir'1(7,, .:0 'r-?her r0U C0 lil.O , -'GO._l oC.'p i11., 4i.L...'?...i1GC'._:L.:L0.,1 l'Li_. _ 17. A)cr:5 COil l.f1uO?'( his verl'),il Irlsi -ult: 11011 f**k ii Ou.y n44Nc;j7-; YOII d f,_'1f "h ;;O „C"Ye 1. '11011 you .,n1.Oed th^t oui- o- 1.11- __...?? A ? lrl, tP'.`_^,YCSICC to Pill f. convicti oil for '"P 'ti3f Y ,i;?'tr1.? ''..3u_..111.t..ei1::?.L--_1.o__1G1_'?L'. SPtt1 to h,r nss ?n? ,?o? rel ] i rl ;.^iilst i' c Pill-P. nlr'ce(I into cell, +?, ers i-oo_> "+itrI_Lll_!T _._.----- {:i7_._w .4z:1 C 1G-ca--PLW-:>i-0 a! iLii1._:_'.i1_ j19. Ai:l",er 11:nc11 tz,".rt; ;ere pi.c?•ce,9 Lip, Ajrer:, th:m).teiec, Pltr. bjr i '.t 111, y aDC NYC; i.tf ^11 0-ver, goalrr Oi1Y1 c o-r fN#1'-ecl up! 11 _... - ?C -Orl:-Scl -1 26 .-._PE3'36-_ A-rr--1re:?^n ?rirrn?n_;,-`*rlc? trtitj;, ti^._ 1. C k: rr- r 0i?'''illf l l_. ll r• '--"l nl i -'0-10 -1e _..---- STTtT 21. Pll _ . r(r J t0 CC (. 1111"1 t0 "'0 011 A 0r ,?e 9 ??8 ;? - ,+ka?az_e b'P-ck tc _ ' 0 AIr--ee-11.-1-. P I ;; .- ?aF-_x.0-t-uy Qd to -- - ---- - ---------------- - 22. Pll . e11 hi,, nei,:,abor in. .^D-06, Ric-Iy m,j•? ?, i lle ]I.-.(?" ! i;a f: sii C;r P_i 1? 11?pne1le(.i, tw'?, t ..r _`1 ,•,r `rOtlr _._ '... ' n.T YOill1 re^nOr1r'.el? Syr t 0 o.,1-,E' lit Frn . r; ----- ------------ CC'l.y 11TH;:, ^;.l,vi l.^ ou `- (11.rec'f or!'_er t0 v';et off ?To'.lr' :e. Lt. - _.-- r + + -- tor1n.yVI Plilf. tol('. Yohn. ..> ???.Y.l t to t ?.1i - to miners C-01-1--- s _'-o OT -^111 e.o r eason l=o or er T? lr o' L 6 ?, _ . 1ii + Ac 11 i:Olle -!lYi}tZ_1Ioa'11_tL,1ll .':U-Id- r ?,,l?f tin t< in, l; Plt _ r n lice No. 52^ 1 7 1651,23) "3- y `Y011i1?---? 1,....i17f'P. __-TIie. ^•l err, ?-n,-f-IBC .'.y -"`nom"rs'-.11.C'?'-9--- -.nT._c7h-iii n 'h-?t1:-_----- PI lr. rec,ue,- tecl SCI-C^,nn T-,ill l'- i c 1e'ner to nre serve [ Zd ?1". ?, c; V'1' O 1rJ^i.l_1"111.00 h1Ci1 rCCO]"rie('L the inciclent. COi t,l_ _11CU_ - - -- - --- -5 ----.)i?_c? llze 2s'z.a- 20Q6¢_Yolul i s sucO P! i,; . =,.1>2 i c '.1 P<< 11.f 1(7;U.Ct "i'1?C11) ]-cr)ort (PTO. A"34 02) 1'IY 'l1 r7t?-; ".'>Cl^1 Te, 0 _CP.ney oa^ i nr07r1.,te 1"i1?u.'.F C (??tJAOII,?? 1L(!_ _07 ref urizi ' to oueir an l F-?-lnr?- his Request for Reprer3enl ^tio z -n l 4Yi •ns es Pt. 2A") Form requesting as .%,itnes ses: es,) Vi-('co C -men-i, F.vi.'cilce 1'o3- T;D Q'L1 .C?9 :-m( Def. Yolln. T11P. JiC'_P,0 CVl(?2riCC l'JOt?1 l i1 e ----_ --- -sl? ?5'. ..__1-i1,?-l?P-l t-P, - .,.?,^--rroi--?reNti?r1-?-o t? t,-li-?--?'toa-r!! -<-?s•-?+3?--??1-:e1_y--"-- _ --------- On October , 2006, Morlrh Coa1laGte+ h(-.rii1(-° for l,,/c i' NO. q ?0?. Pio 10 +i 1 tlYe' the -Pl1-r.._. i i n. i'LC SP4tT, beirYLr i --._. - - - - _ une 7P -w. altiyric`I. „1. ,ri1LJ C L1 h^.rdship, (Zeni E ,_1 Pltr. Iris c'_ue nro- Coss i-71it b;r lei. rin r lira flhe requested 28. Moa19k-. reli ef-l- on -tne- seeon«i_iiQrYr? r?:fo-r r?_ .or or (ler _ 00 who '." li ,te, by Yol-La as ritness in A834302, tla,.t no video evi!,encc i.s ^ it bl_e for tlYr ilearin F,: r ine,r' s "HEX") ( revie , Wtio'eL wat aIS o 2(. -Pi ti. j "clot uilt?rn io T(AOiI ?.,.?.'. R't'60. -_unswcrn_ eS$Vmor?r, 30 . lw {) r lk;_ --ai s ai->ad--t 31 ra c:lfsae e IiAA I? -a-ate,a E? -R?4. .-ui t ,? of R NO. Pl t r?.s anctionec , 90-r1?I,;rs consecu-five d RTr_> disci pJ in^r;;r custc 'y (ADC") 5t, ru by MoslaL , --- __-_-- ,? r n t , n ??_c rr?nn, r?r? Plt,f ,,,jilt. .o .. __RTQO_ _]?,y_--_? __prep.nncleranca_n _.?,ic_euiuence__ _ by t?. ? DC-ADP? ('301, 6.5.1 Policies, !nc? lass. - 32. Pl'r -,)ne, lIc _ A334302 f'n(, it o (eai.e,- nr? eylmustcd ,t '?1i1i. 'fir-tiv',- le-velo. 33. PI4_ 1c_.f.-.il ,r... Lo__ n?uire ? t ic._Secur {.y -Of -ice. - -- ^.r ,Let Yer t_,.(, _^^eon eJ vi( eo evi.:?ence of RD Qu:,,c.O, for Sen` nl.:er ? ? ?005. ?l;e.v,dev e? d'tn" ?,icuid-VvavQ. l?ovJK+k L4 was not Comm' +48n K any m1 Stc•'dut 34- Rath' a.he- Securi-tr.i-e- -r,-,,l finer-?--re ac?ces,? ho_.--lhe- rcoo e_:_ vi loo urveil l_q.ice from H-Unit _(SP'TJ) ,trpl._`_re bl to ANINUM ------------- do:: ocl '1-.]e 2,ecorr'_el surveillance to a. '_l.arddrive. 35. Pitt. bol ieves t,LIt l tlc viJoo Slirvei.linnce recorCda , oysl em at 8f „:.(f.'nn hi 1-1 p-7- I:vy i-cY3. 15-1Yk81'ttl_le( nY3: ?i'-??Yi?fi i'l Ff}1PT -1 5- 1 Y20 ?n . - .. li,rit?.l vi,-I.co_recorder "DVR") ,,stein. -- - Th DVR r r, to i .t SrI-Cnll, Bill recycle,? itself every five (5) 37. ]?i t ?,,?ea ..s ?1:? a 3--Mo -,1.-a1y_...cnulri. lr€.v.e- calt:a.o I ?1 cl?ra?x--- ------ '111i.'i? r 'ia.le CCClrit?7 Offi_Ce to inquire if tho reco- ec'L vi(I(,o F-mrv(:',illnnce for on Sc7,te bcr 216, 2006 (,1 -,te:l.. .--- _. ' - ....._.-.._ ._..-___. nSt_ert^.; i•h^t--i1e rl^C J"1r,it t0 C..^Il 33_.__ !: -__ --r - S e a.T . Et+a? r .'6, _ ?DQu'__a?acJ,_ Ll?? t __ he_ y y:elliri? LL-1, _o.f -Ili Coll loor. - -- 39. Yohn is,, ,ae . A331.302 <;. a l2e<laz(?i 'i".o ofiici -ll,i, onnress, ?i -'et , I I -lirltc ._" 1nr,t 1=. i PIt-f. 'f'or tILc-- 'i.I n7 o- es 7r__Ue ; -n: , rat - -- --- ---_--5mv__ •tafz Oa.-the _.6:_00_ to._.2:._00 -p?as? ui-,1.:fQr__sx? etiz*;-tie;. 4.0. As i rppul.t of Yolual s f lbricrite l reror. :,nil. Mo._1, IC's Fn.i_lure _ - s:ul% r_e3_._th°-_ co.2ss >iennP lclition ll disci Alin,-ry conri zc , eni in the - - ---------- SMU, thus his -r bili.ty to -prof ress through the STITT Foi^ r,,ri.vile fes m even a l release i.o n y ,?enerr,l Honor^.tion ???r further un.conslitu- _ cres l i of Yom's i',.rri.ca.ted 'renort Pa,T Moolrlc'= f;>.ilurc to n otect. rot 1,;;iur, process, ri ,1, , ." _t7 ,l,_. ib=.r'F„ es , ,.CCess to rw.rc?vlse 1"r:7-l.eLlic st.uIn ie-, nersc'n^l- (5) V?r'1?', i11CY"' V1 1t.L"1 tl'Ir CO1LiSS:1Yt" a j 0O r' Z10 1 c,levi„ion, etc. r"nri.i_,;l,.r;-,r;fue1 to <ccet the ;•ffir'",i:+, of 1;io 4^) S CC1Cr tp t;_1Ci Cii in A33.C02, r1l:L thi.O nYcjL1I'Jc0!T Pl1-f. in,- ii C:r 111ri ''Dotal !Llr? 'nrocesS "XI C4 TYL1t1 ?.0, tP1!1-1i11n.?; hC _ri.nLI;. thr7t..,,.ohr_ t-e-?)rerr6tv r, t,_ ass; n.5?l __(ID or - on,] ihc;.t hie:, c1i,Oxr°erc hn.rr :i.n? to PJtf. PJtf. no aec. no CCLli .;jr collccrn !r ^tteilr,ting to ,see tl,e .smi „t :alce of T reider llo -.- ,. .,...,: .... ., .._.. .. .. ..v , i.,iii, •. 1. i_L V LG1 .JI^LlJ ,..L t.l-t_L'wi. - _._. ___._ _.._ -?c. ---O11_-sentoinbor 2A 2006, -Pitt. wng rriye11 r)-on(;r IT e c`,jr11!-'e `?:tv',L '.. lcoverc(I rlurinl,t1li s time that three (3) 35 1i11.?_l_1. C? 0,r n loto- `.r.t.n1 1 C1? --- ----- - i: e rl . t,, r c .O rOLlllm ^c?.LLlt ferl les erfon:-ink, ctin l' : ngu-ri on_c ?. Y,rohi ited by' P1 DOC Policy, vere nixing frorl ht nrol.erttr. 5. m,lc three ( 3) photos v7ere to be ret?.li"nec, to (].lc 1w s?r?nc Of of of 1'r1O $ei1^ies r1..!-)1cter? 1r]. the ,__ p.?lo t o ,? . v . :.n1 l. 1 rl ; +bOL1t the mi.s^ihlt; Photos. - --- ------ --- - , 7. I lnc , r;11'i'tC l th^.t 1;110, only tqff "110 1l ..Ve "",Cris to the - ry1??i'/?,eFr'? anc?S(oYuthe?';:?;-----?_T,,-----/----/-? --n--??-------_____. rl.L1..__..L?1SZ:1...yr:?17..?i.n.._'rti-.._.1-V_1..? car 17 the ]ri1S51n" photos. 49. I^n T? ,rt, the F<aci.li tf Griev,ince Coor( liaatcr ^.t SCI- C L;. ?i17? re?ecte? Th0,._r ject om 7se rrer' ens e ? - ? ----- _ _ __e???.? te?_?.1:._aL_°r? „ni.ut?.tiTz??_eve??w_•-------__--------___-_ 50. Th; ire photos .sere in the nos._•essi_on of SCI-Csay.n %_i l1 ri_1oe -- Aa!?u : 1,r, 2006 ?ten they e!ere confiscates' by I?.1i_ne Or "caber. -- 5? , - - ?1'I f? ci-o?ser•_?;._?00. ? -Si?;n;?l-?<,?.?T--to- I-'lt-f:-'-?-c??_-?--,r,,i; ---____------ _._ "'s ed- Pltf. i - i .le ,,<,llter? to u1-i7_ize the S-",-L ! '_11.i-1?_1."a li.ora.ry Pltf -,a.id, Yes. 52. Sii,pron "e„r p0n!1eC.y "fret ,1 1.aC3." P1.t n r10]Tl(?, the nOY- - --- ---m 1- ri:P- ^ 0,r rcir-ro L?ti n0, - - , s-die Ply, 0,c --oar--tom - =pal i F, bAA k - se:_Lhl_ S1 .gip ?. > n. to noise... "Uh, Llh, o' y era.h:" ---ir°lick:lna; 1:1?0,14.; tyrlty tyre of riC1.Ses t11^t, ,. X1%1].'1 ;.Ollll' ?Il 1?6 ?'U1"ih1., C1':" of s x. sori1 C7l 1 ] iii-i. :) "'il0 10 >ey:u%l" Lll('. n n F ;rOt". ^ S nL. ,?lICY ;';C1.t1J.1`? L?r2:>>.>Ot'-y Plti. Y1l.:-1CBC. ;LJ _5 IL .lC:_s O'lla, of "he -' P. "i it l]l"C', t0 ZlC' ?`_i 1 ^ti" r c-.- r?--- - J_ _ ?1! c charo 0,v , , Si. 1p, on be j"I-11;.0, # 1_ --- -- --?:i-ale--,x PIt,f to )1,J1(1ts b?.c« into the cell. 'Si ipson cloe,e('. _ the `),,erR- tura the i tol-rl Pltf. , "You 111a Tc r_oftn On «oar 11;lYl S." --- --_____-- -4-64 i 55. Pltf. :asserts that lie. dial not have any- -soap ul his h-1ds.. anr7_ t: ht Simpson f.^brica.ted this clr=i.m to cleny hirm access to the Court; s m as of hr rass,:lent ^nd retnli.a.t:ion for tho Pitf.'s goocl i<:'i:tL the S''TtJ -,t^fi' on spumm-- Ql<:P_ ? r ._.._ (?._flQ _' ?) w. 1. -.``hi + and foT e-ao- .rillg in 0t1102: plc-vaoum 1e.nti Berl. l :,,+:iul ?,Ct:i.T.-it:ics. It its ,lsc believe,l ih'!,i; Simpson in- tcnrl.e to (IC11r file Pltf. his roll tirle l?PC^urr, Pltf. hid "filed ??,,riev- lrinr-on Toy . St11?57'r':0't;-n-- d-1 11;7: Z'T7-ri'riT2 (3r ? ? h?.T^ GCn t i1M n0i.,Ses •.^s Pit,. Over t0 sP= it bi ttoc -,!ell s Lr-;n St+lpson gently T hoIL e _ the in O-f--Prig :_' -7, -11--n p}{ - mli Silgrf-, ' s P; -9 o f se a-l -= i1,e11t _'C_? 6 ^.C t:17 , 11: hOmo se, ll: l ? r177^ iC2 1i C11 P1t fii?7.du C'_15tLLrbin?;• . .--__- -'__ ... Griev°'.nce _To. lO n77 Plt% file 2006 On OCtol )er 21 57 ' , . , . t?t"?. r S1 gr-SOrl -for the- rlenl..p:?.-fit N:11Z-?.C1+_1- F38?k?Fbl_ R,r,sr- ea.t,..__L't_C: Th^ 1 C'7 °1CC S dC 11 8 , nC 1leCl, L:i e x1'";tl^?eCl it °l ] C11;1i 111rt,r +tive levP]_. . 5". 1=; (i_.iroct nn'1 pro,umr,.ie, resul o_. '110 r be emu, t c - l1w ot•_Ler STITT pri loners ;c1 Len I c ope_Zl r spa:l_c bout PI fin's ?tP cri ;i -1 C?.se, by (lenyin? IMPltf. a deal es:u,,ily him to ,puffer h n,-er -•r)+' to , ; of n?tl.firi:i Lori erin,-- i:e cfa1? ,~t?n?:.r -C-,_o . _?rTlJEl m1.C::11 al]1L fl,.__.S11a1.E? S: L11?, b-^t?_.7?rf Yl:y_^ - e.-kat'-1,1A4) lilJciE .te in(li-fferrance. 59. As it .ct. ^ni nro..i l",t e ro'-'al'. Of he cTorc :?nti.onecl ^ct,r of Sire) son nr'. of ;yen SIT ^f f, S 'r-'.ll_ ,?.<3 nr~YCh010:7i Crll Pluse. -- --- ------ - --- - --- nCl pr0 X1.1: C'.? C re ult O the fJ Lc1-ti.ono-l C 1rPCt 2 tip qS C1 - - . - r?rl? #13A-P,? ?oC, t1Le ??1t F??.exc. _----trle-__ "2? i.l i.cally tl-ircc '15rrz ploto?repl s. T;, -- i DoO i.e .,t fu,,LLt for not h^vin.r r,olicies ?.YLrI procedures in r1r ce 'co the c, theft, or Clr::2tl'uction. of Ur,ron. l ?ro5?er •y -- a- 1w P 0 r S t f . A r! -ttr X71 n?j ` 3 s- #> 4 ,, ,, .ta_fi ;; 0 ul a. not nronP.r'f r : il'o in hi .r , Y e "ens ;'ilf)rL i t. Coaf -,Cft0(l. -__.-- r]_. 'l.i x cct; uv praxi. i lte re.au7_ ?"? ZO c'i ent tone-? 1_e ij-, h I/c he r1n.;, ,,)Fit he f-ilei;_ to Pit"". to es- i to cone Ct I'elc}'?izer J./or _ tl 'ecu i1- Offi.cr, 'o .termmine ?. re„ore e ,-; ,, co iii 9> __ ice- --- _ _--._._?\-- i7,.:L ': 4y' iaY7 ">1`rilCli 8(_ f, ,1 j j71O11`?.l DO time, 1.17. rhr; SIM, -ui 1;+7111 C ?_ Ilrl As - '' 62. 1rr.. of re,=ui_t 01 1 ,1:. ^...OI .;T1c,11.1: i0,.1 Cr' ".Ct of Y 7n, Pl_•i;f. .a u:r r';i1a m1A ret,:li,;I.ory rtul_i S1*.l•1ea; -of ?(1.<Ti tir 1 a?_...DC ti,a. 1o1,^11in nO ,1-.ys ( 11ich hP, Served ill ?'t111), (?r11_1*ln,^ 11111 the . _ - _ - - __ 1 -1- - _. _ - - ---- 0-n 0i?i; _i_, T 'f0 be 'F 1°,<l. F (_ 1'j"0 ? _7':; Srr, n• - tLr ? :"LT, Ci i,?rnl_C'^l •,n.' t,:.Cl.iflr,„-?li• y1L 11, 1??T `',1P 't1 0 f" it?.r S18J1 111 1" i`?1 , .,ti 017, LCli31 o [?rE s :1.011, - -- lclwl,i?3r.%1/c rupovt ;FIO?,_ far_..,?al?ill„ La._.raparl .ta--I:xei e •tklc- in o t •^, 1 1 ; r L'r) j eci e: to biT Ayers, n ioY hu11 en a 1 ,.'_ r__. rt(- ^ . c t 1 ? 11.1_ es ------ ata and _ 63, Ar ^,ro lih t reuizit Q. i??e Sorel nom{ ct ^ch,5 0? Tlrr f i lZ1141 r1!:1Gy iiL1T)8ry_. 11.1.-_51;4p 0i1y 1_'..ZUffCT_eC 'tr.1^ ? lnS«a _-----_---_- of 4'rec l-don U r .1Uter..d t0 11irY1 `:'11811 50L1t11erE p i'rGir_8r , ''.nCT. Kc)loi' 1aer 1.1 II> to hltrl ,Irme to ce Se t iC e 'tbL cs fra%l co"1t11o1n? rt(i -1t1; #7: ?'e of -the-1 ti.-1e 1-1-me 7 in. - rLv.^?_ N Kxe? c'eY fin 11 ,r lkeci b ' 'l ^z?' 1,,. Tn coi Taber '? '_'6, ,:.OOG, c 11.8x'. i;a Yl_tf.'s cell. h'-per re??ol°•i:in.? 1;118i; t0 u,e?:i 111ra Conoor1111'1:- the :? lu-'O 3-n-c-r, :, ---n -ers??_ _r?-i(?er....re;?„on_r?e,y-•i;o -P?±?- y __n?'??t, r?nl,r _e_ irn? a: ,:, -A- _X11 OUr llothcl ^.V bi.rtil to on." TIl 11".1 9TTTT 1);, 1T1SlYlsT - V. H Cl-,i1n1S S al e. . Y ,'.L fi e- =777 1 17 "' 1 SLR' 7"_ COUIITT I ?oG (?c Kn1 chiarr, Soni',.c rs, an'! Krel('er) s"190 i - P_'1IIATTON TO PROTECT, ?'ATT,TTRE TO SnTTER?T?TE __ _- - --_--- AS-STTPT;?tVIS(TRS---P7sL'L'3ER?1TF-1TTDI?'7+'^. , ., - _.. _ OTFTCTAT, OPPEMSSION T_ _ Uq'.WTFT TT T _>` 7'71Tr. rr F-, -rTrr'rIr trE- a s SnPr711TTSO R ---- -- (TT. >. r. A. ) rr-'---- _ UG r [siL1 31CC3, . iS_' 10_x^.1__( Cll_ ':IuY^v?-?.L._1r r_i.7 ._:1Ci_G1L _- '--? (?f Y -----_-_-_._. 0 ! rOt^, pl _ . 0 J, 1 l ;1e;7. 11:, _1C no-1, U1.1 _,,`, .i,o `-.brl: e c;o u_i i,•i ley I)eJ s ?•, ?r ;, Yo1Ll, ? 1' ;: r -Pr 1. i7i7 j,7 { nrzjc ? r r t, n? nll _ __. -IT 1711 r1(= y Y1i. 1 'uber _'roS(1 0.0lati111111.1,vr to 11?i" ,SS I r',i,'i,11- Pli:r. , e. ,. Thci i u _. dlllnoss to lntcrverle 1-n -±.nt- nit 1 n oorrl?: frirr.^ rh r-v r -oi z c?„?-e? }1? - rt roJ J-7 P1h_?._oa Such .^c" i.orl, o r,'r':1er L-i- C1.-,, to t'.le 1.^..,17cl 01' 't;li.!.J(?1:;:•,,•i;C ------------ t???1:---------- ID.._`iOfl l --lit,-_'1 7 1 cl0l,1S7_ 1Y,tr?,atio'l.^1 rec!:less, 1 nl(.?terl Y r 0 '_1 eS 2,'_ il+°11T`. On'-, to 1n(Ti f f (?rence to the I It .' i right:, "11rl i ': _ 1,I1- a ?;:.! _ 11x' 1 '1 J_Q l.t.lt7il_ 2 _ :y1llL 1 ?; 1 sL_....C? 1'.,5'ti_ 1?...`_:I l] Y 11"?B i• e ^n P2 1T r _?1ou3_, -6 !f', .,?., - .,, _ -4_ .:< S. X001, rR?]+'ORF r t ^ ? _ Plt... relief: '+„7 ].r?. nL]i11'rjV 1 > >['re,? ',^:!'.117 -,11 tile Dcf?'_ 4:1 (,'0'-,r aL I 7,.,15,0 _ t'li {i0U1'i: lY1-1 i u1 or n,tT y?11 r iri .^n ?Oltn.1 ?O_. ?j-r,_ rl:r?'?"f'.1'!'!ti:I1P•??. ?j?_`?,__?Tt?'?f.•y.-?7T?'l':_Z1D'?` 1_F?S.F_'1'.I?'.1;t'?j???.??.?-...--, ,b) 1z).jurr`11 Jc. ro lief ill t'_ln form of O` Ux1 02 _°roa Pli:''.' c rri.,_oli rocorcl_ ; „E ll?r no i ,)_ :11011; C) r 7 r ,r P, :,11 011 to 'In y ___.- r - , - - - TT3-;JLj:i`l@3-.-v ?-r e3-ter-Win.--i; A--???!r-o-? -- - ?x].??. enforc?nrr ?. ne':a PA DOC Policy- 'or „er:;oiv:1 r,r P 1 , 1 i-t P..1.0.: 'r.'oU.l,' Plt_. (,la1c? 01;:18r r)]"1 - - tcl to 17^, j? ^ecCYl"i: (lU] ln," r? -O ,C1:1.11? ]a '_ 1,11Vet X07^1n , e) 'Opf'l. pn,J for -u-I"r Capri, coat " Or L'i_0.0,0; f) De.-Tr. -riliburoo PltL, foi- coils of Ile hi- curs ih:clu+i;.n xi not Fo, fees,, c?c7 (D?? ••:--S?[i?'"?:?7 >; '?.'rS"ne; ??.r?1?['i"?Yr - - •.y-.qT _. _ r. _. Ta+tS?7fiT t' . `Pfd , I1Tfr`P ,T2`Irf- ----- - - TIIEFT OF PROPERTY, FAILURE TO IIAVE POTICY LESS, LIBERTY INTERESTS, CIV_TL RITITS, ??F;^TTFI ITT - DUN PROOESS CLAUSE, PROPERTY ITTTETiFSTS ` ( M? S; ---- ---?3I'{#'PF _ff;AlauS __-- -DtJ7;--PRE?CFSS_f.'TJflr; -11.0 R F7*-I-i'?fiFjR-FS-PI ... . (PA COTTST.) I,OSS OF PERSOTTAL PRPRR`PT, rTrCrT,ICTF?TCE Q?I° lrou =h ,..even (67) z'.r0 illcor1,0] e o I. z> n Al) c, =Cr.,_ 1 •gAre fLL-l r Y't prtil L eYt i.:l :'t- . 1. - ' 4 • T? 8 t . 12c1•t2 r--i.11 ''sii ?a?Lt31.-k?±1-1 ,1 fa3,.l.r3ti:-4 -{3rd4 ri .. _ - - ... -- Pltf nc roon^1 nro•,er'tf 'alien lie caf]: erec' i;}ie loss of three (3) ''?Floto- - . 1 r,' ?. , (1ue to i he. P11:•1., ,? no'i hei.n ?roceiit c'L1 r1n. > r+;_e _ -- -, ? ,., nl n-r,? ? 1 ? •;;'. P1'i ?..?.; 10 _c) nfOpCY t,Y' ''t -_.--------@:1-?=-'tl -=;,?-=-E?-1; -•3-f--3?. , ;? ' ,`;4}.3{ ?-.a111---3'•?,.?--.!'a.^.??-- t?-f-.-.?:'1?--?-Z1A..?i--?1r-?,^,,.11111r?r--?'A __ ____ _._. ' r,?v0 I oc?r Sr fe Th ,rd.in0 Plti.'s pronertu interests from theft, ?. ^. ('.C:-t_rli.ction., Or OC,er 1osYs; or by the inteatiorl"11 theft of , . Ply" , - -- - -a * " ? ?ronert-;r Tyr S-?uiTl,,rs,T?i.nc7-^,1,,/oi-FIiit)er9 I; -i _1 no..?1-1-iSY? - -'---_ --o? -c ???aY?s.-,-l:p? u_._•???:?__a.Lina.-?.a._u.c__a.._...?..,Te...> a?rani,..cu.,__ "i Plfi_ iFREFORE, pL a .et to t,.1 tT. S. C.A ^n 9 T'?.. C. S. i3 5 i01, e4' se . , (9) Co.ml^asntory ra^ni yes C?.in,st n'11 the Da-F's in thi, Count _ --inn;?ivi?'-un117, jointly, or sevonl ly in ,r.n r>-.tount-• to be (l, ni rl.prl )ir to 111-rir- n . n,'1 roc d-1•,n /l) n --- -- ---- _u?-^11;r, jointl?, or s?vCro.lly in ..^n Ylot?Yii: to be <'eter.ainecl -?-- - I} Vr r t jury; c)73e?_s ;•zu.r , .-or 'any out-T-In(? Or Cos •F; ?,izn -- ? °__---- 1I)_.?x?L° nn 1 railnhllrca P1+-P- fns nnot ^-+ :?-.,a- -) 1 r 1l 1-, _1 ,..2"?,t,LtaY1 11(a i n --- jl C'urS, inclll'.ing but not 1_i,n _ .1litei?. to, ;'ttol'nPy'S fees, c'.e1a?r 42 U.S.C. §1933 - COTTSPIRACY TO DENY CIVIL TtIGHTS OFFICIAL , -- SIFICATION OF SAN OFFICIAL' REPORT RETALIATION (GEDTERAL), UTALIATIOI1' FOR PAST J ACTION, r_\ 1 y y V 1 HARGT AND MANIFEST IIARM ST. TE CLAIMS - 'T;TALIATION (T T,fERAL), U?TS"IORN FALSIFICATION STIMTT, RrTALIATION FOR PAST OFFICIAL ACTION c-?-E?G?--y?3?2- lYnE:4ri?31'?t?'freC? --- horr ? ijy reference, thoumli coach were fLftl?1 sr t, _-ort,h herein €I.t -Def. n^ ;.ecZ i? tliir Count L11l!1 ViLIlr f i:1C? to protect P1t.i'.'s - ci.v _2 4- -i_• ;I?t:s by_inters.i.-.iexi.ally-._f?^lcityiY1p__,1..:ljSC0Sic not _report;._.again. _t PIi-,f o : nr4 retn.l.intion for r?t.tpmpting, to re- ?ort• 1 ?_ _e •^,tions 01 ' nbuse fe_l 1.0 •, co- ror <_er to sup e1 vi „or, for rerciCS.ri;m Prot^cteT tec seec' _ fi ^.a f6 r o . ri ezi noes. As_-_a F.:;:alt _ of _ Yoiu2!. a. _01i'icial_-0 .?pLes: airl__uncna: i it<rz_uian^1 clCerl P7_11U e7Pc1 e=i1?' In wil. rrnntcr? <ric .( 1tl.onil ninety (90 do.ys C st tus dc. i he served in fL11 in „oli_.tary confinement, loss of i._ f ire ,( ' „ 'ion '; T - -•., ^.. - 7?1ti..:ae'f??- _7 to luc 72 Th b ib d ti f t ' t C ' ' - • e '. ov^ C lescr e - ",c onc o uit ; he Def. in his /ere ot so n' ' lLc;enty ri^.1i.Cious, intention.^l, reckless, nac? c'ri. shl^yeu such r,_.------ -__r o :, i'S7T Zs9 i-h?Y 7 ` PS'tII(t I'f`P'BP?ITCZ'-t'J T'-P C f ?`? c -CS ?TT? ?'I_.` L f .5."? _1 i1; f ---- --_--- ,1 n, I s2f 1 'aye 7 , 1 r d7mrFSeg i.s ;y 1 ranf,ed 'T,13;'rEFORFJ, nurFnir^nt to 4? U. S. C. 91903 '-si0, 42 Pry-. C. S. 60601, et. eo j Plt r l-e n r .• t le foll0 T1r1 7"?a 1 P C; ; ?I2-?--fiOt?3`LtT--??i-fr23--•---•- to be,_',eterr,iiranr3 by_.^ jurL, but not _less t}?n.n 6900.008 ---------------------------- ----------------------------- '" 11 b) P,-u itive Def. Yohn in •t}?i.i s Count: in ri.n lOltC7t to be deterili.necl by a jury with Pltf. ,u-ertinm --- } ? ---- S L? 0 r r - - . for ef-:.Ch C't1011 0" paT1 . , c) Decle.tory relief in the form th-l.t Pli.f. is innocent of 'this "i rcon(loot ReY)ort No. A834802' ^.n' t'.Plut n L ,cl: rlccl--,tort' re- I ? 1-i: o ,11-1011-?Faz -Co u r ur?r c_e-T ei 1 s- j u, ! , _xc;l i f in k?, -Pnrii? of NTjs,-a„r?„nh Repart Tines-- - Au? ^.C0? hei }a. ; expanmecl from P1tf..' s prison recorcl; e) Rel e-? from : e ,re g-:tion to any C;ener. 1 no nil^tion; Or 111,xlr OcYUI 't'-S- ST IS or PI , Fnr cn tc)° liti ma 'on IZe -- 1-nc`,lrs, i..c?.Ll'1nM bui' not. lini`;e1?_ to, Yln,;>011?l eracn, e, y -;t.f-0~r?c r'r fec. , coja,i (1,1 :rnames, i.nteres,t, etc. -- ---- 1- ---- - -- -- CO I T 1 V - L ?-- _ (Def._I_h??lj _ (Comal:c. li_s i;ec9_ belovl) ? eference. ;-),s thou, h e?.cl1 were full;7 set, forth Herein 71. D(,f- naaiecl in this Count Lml.-.v:vfully frl.lecl to pros ect 1 f -Pl •_ . _ .> CSVI'l Ti ?h+ S 1.rirl cor_;s+7rtrttiiIangl -3?1 l9 4 t2@ -fCA, }le0 i,0 - _? l to Pltf. _ to c 1 Def. "olui -s n , tness to cxc- dnE hi'm concorn.mp Pli iircoll,lc ct 111- for Miccon?uct No. A831,11 :ror Ilo;; ins ^rj 1 i:iol ;T :: 1 c r -ISO Gris:rorn, to :nc e c etc, if _°ecorf1,4(.?ri;leo- c v.i clenc,k, . ex1 . ,l for llos-. , - ,s n,OllJi1 o.li' 01'11-. r 01 ,11 010010, c?° , ??c ?? ?•.ZCr 0_? 110Plt ' 0 _ ?1, T'TJ J^' ri^ i'^i; Pl_tf. ?S it1C`?]'0?7 t U.t1 1 COx,',.1"1Ori;; Of 1 „f,crnt l: Ili_I") ^ ho _ ----°N_ P .n: yl' , H1 i:ne.t5es. ?-- ?e?u:n? .??1... i:lzt 'Lo a?c.?;??u _------- i a cl? 1 „t o T , n D /o -C l0 'I: n, "S ) U n I' I , r ? _ ....,_ 1.c of , - „o',i 1,.e :r,,,.ar i . _,t1.'1o ,r of Dc,°, F", fi r er CCr1_(?r 0a h, ? 7.10T: {;cTP7=i uc pro .e -------._...?,?t,Q q-F?d <.-s,?f,e.e? _I:,.?? 1-k?..;;-, <??_ ?..i.:::..1ih=.r t?,T_._uzt•_.?_t:s.._ ? ?_ e, 01 le ,:ua tL?'a,.s_:n1-er1 rMinty (pp) ? yr, „,;'.i?•ionra.l DC v 00 afil,^'i.ont 1i c, o bleriI 11 r '. 1 , i o i i -re c0-j. 1i ter-y - -- -'--*i ]"?' 3 ?`7 l u - i'f t }21'; °?C7'tYl1? - " fi?F r3 I) .SAS.-b.'j,;.-_.;il:::.6lQLlk?•}-..L.17? '-ni" 1 ? ?'? _1 ,e' j_P nivil th c rec: e yen - o . _ : ? • titi?_: c>?_tD,_ 1 n( _ f i:.1e 'ClOl'! Of L-U-Ii five ^'es i!?. ????rr„?11 c, ..-?''r?T?'?'? ,?-•?'•tt?-1#---t?,-y--?-G--i-f?S-{`:--§??c,-?---^m?- P?-?:-1;:---i-r0l-r-a-'c., - y 1 --------- - --- - - -------- co -" ,11 . Do f. ..o- ,, 1.11 COU_1i- in ?rT -'1Ow1fi' to be defi.err>i-nc,l b? jary; , j ins J , v i ..r. ?.6' 1'1n.OCex'f- Of i-his TTis(,onr- act T?o,)Ort TTO. A071,,'002 _ -iIt'i-2 i(0. .tOY 7^ i e( "i11.CiL tiai COla.rt `l.nC'y/O- ?tl'."f ('0 01_,, jars t? Jl Iil jLLQCtl. 70 Yel1.e 1.n l'hi'. `oyi1 OJ ."1 '' CO11'.iLCT RE "Ot { T'TO. e) Def. ,111.1rli rOl' "IIV OoLTrt co?'1 s O'r _rineS cLnd, Plt.:;% '°or co,.'crl c) ?.iT1ti0n _ie -'------- _ :. n -I int, cr e u?lg c, . -I r-- T bf i11m "me, "I for v, o i_oxis oar: D-7TTAL OF DTTT; PROOE-,,,-3 TPYS',CTrT TE917I701'T`i', _,.T: _ ., _F`"?AT_'TT__TO ALLOW ^^- "UrITESSES, FAILTJ>3F TO PT'tOTT,,(1,T, DT;LIRPTI'ATE ) 5TT" AT'MTDTTP, !TT - (S'1T"73 AS ABOVE) --- -- .- _-_.__ -.- -r ?7? -- - i '. J. 1 - ( fi7 }IE- 3 AB O VS) j STATE CLAITTS - ( AT47ir AS APOVE), rII,I, 0-17 RIGHTS (rill) -- - 1 V 7fT m ( l;". Yr, killer, PA Do C, SOUthers, Kreider, I'line, Tlaber, Ayrrr, - - - l I zST !iTM'TTI,r?T?--??a*.Ti"?^IfiI»T?l,TTT? ITT?MFJ'""7?,tT`t'?_1 TI1";9.?'"_'T?Trr?T _ (U. S. 00?STI'_T'[TTION) 1 - - ? %u. P".a ^;Y^.';-)},,,, O4C' (l_) f ?rOl7'?'ii rOV(?rit,r-f1Vo (75) ,'re 1110,02-?OI ''i?e ? - ---------- - - {i : l" : 1i1 i?J rG ?e1 H11C'E?, , . , '{ 10 1,-,='1 ?',? C1 Mere i (,L_l;r Ct _:07"tTl _lerBl.n --. ... ? I. PI. {?"1 r,r 111 "??ln c.-> 1) l ;01 7 1 1. J1] of N le Do's rl,^ in thl.: COLInt ,x cT. con tit Ll- i 3.O..1 r'.n'{ „r tO ?T1I a(, no,! 1'1 1 O i-i,n -,). ti l_t??LxY'3 f?H .YfA . ESlt1''.?P.Y•9f? i};;F--?T1P.1r1"__lltl}:"fa'"a--tja-'`a'C', 9:01`3?`? -_____. }Fc , l - i;,l ?rxln fro ii The Pi tf. 4 x I 1l e.i.r ?cOx1 11 Or ?„.;c _ '.o-:i... 'arc ?u?l•, _ ui_._ 'ic:?.rccrr'tc0_ cii-i_Zell "r "Iel_ s rceident O" Or i-o l c fyc-"? ZrOrl C1 O;-Inre??r,l.On, r ---- = ': 3 = "v= -? 11 + } ti t.St}}}':? 1-t}c>t3C3 V - 3#43-?G1? $-11 t-dl F -? i t='1c s of h1 _U. nrocesr, Y1?nt?;, _i'ti'_ Ot'n.r T, 1F 'i.:'1rJ, ir-juries C'.',ll by "le D ^. P' Of c' i_'i t,;,_ CO lnl Yl.ni t" ? FOUr r-entil 9,.en7:len.'f; to the Unite,' St;d-,es Constitution, PItf: de- 1`',£1C1.f COilnC,-1s^t0r r n y-jwil ti1Je ?<1 QC;, eS in ?11 piaount in P_XcesFS of "!_Uli 1110 UL? IULOL 1JJ-L-L:.7 ci \ vP!_U, UVV. UVJ, ")!u3 'aUa1 C'"G [2,rJ- G0117snrjaT1..On ..COr ---- 1i 1-44ita- nrr erln,p? suclh •I- n>rr?n^l ?••n?Il°O:? 1 L'C61"6` G ', CO?t?y -_ ..;.tonne=r'r ee?, n_i?' !1.eln? r?;a;lL;es. u0 P_'.1' .I''1;" one, (1) 1;117"011,'Tr1 SBVP,nty-f1i_ne (70 ..^,rC 1.YlCortOr- • ., _ • 1. -:.: 1.. CS -',1; e''.?i'.C?'C? ,";.?T O'-(????EZ,Z -?? `-. it , J: _, ?l. De:??s. ,Gri i1;}t, Zi:11 e'tl't1C.Y., Gerber, ^rlrl Brit ??e11 in P-r^.. lernllv fro-,n 1111. sncci_Cic Co:ap) .i..lii Herein. - -- - - j r'.?}e f ... D r n *c r-?*rrd -c erg ?n Para`- ?r-r2??.* i ?e-- :f'ro: cci is Cott L lint her in, ??. Del. Wi ;h ,a11i in P. r > iS llr'rebV 173 21:1i?lsed- f7"O11 thiS ?ncl. lc CiOianl.!'111.{ herein. {-a.?._1"5i.---7T'TTTr-2+fl--?. s--r-e? r-v _ Co, 1 _ IrLit to 12 81033 ^nc' the Feca.R. Civ.P?^oc. 5. ?1J . P1.._ rts `ver c nn_. !'.ecl^rea that he }» est,bliller'_ c ---- e Of action fOr 7.11 Of hi9 clnillu . n' 11P, uccc 7°LLlly nr e ervecl _^---'_'f•U.t3 ?".- .-!i A-.,. .7.?i`-?icTL?^A:fT?_-1_'S'_?: eM; 4-,e _ I 1.1 rcli_01 c d1 ?c r n1 e(3. n - U0. Pit f • 1e )1 .. sr ti ;fief, t'Le le ^?_ renui.ra-ionts o_c i YL??-PA -p1i,_oneri?i., ,f.io1` l'-Porn 9c i VI . Stun it ry )o?:r;: ? Tifi^sincFiisen •,n?-u 1 ? c pp re yA T •? ?+ -bee .. _ vic rti'.'1 Of n1>1-1,ce bu nris?oz of fici-ils1 in t}1e PA Don for over 'Our (4) r nx1 e1,- in.. i.:z ;Oli 1, ry con.'inonent - 1 ,^llt l t' i1L7 i 1"1`1 1i; f o ' -t'1C l ?S:iC?Z Ct1?i] ties 11-1]:11. 1'1. 017' i. maLI 0-1 emrain,- r. ins-.in (110 rrt 0:,7 T ie 1) :'^i11?9 1 .o 0 1 °•,h t, hi Ci. V i ? sui t ,. ..in s t X11 0 '? 7_ 1 'I^ I _ ,? ; ,s- ;o r„ 1,10 to se .,_ ..!11.1.1i`Ado11 nor r Vengo, burr to rc2tore j'uH.ice for ?'?IPl.? - •- , .?11-, ? _ 7?57i:1",,.> f?Y'-,, i7 O C".I .. .?r, --- ._ ------- - --__ _ _ -- VII. J Dec7_ic,,,,tion i.:z Co.. n it i. cat ,.. -in +hc r2o 9-i;- to rT1 ^rerlo;-?r f.- A--I--'. -.-_-L_. pt , 11Ch 1 L C-7n - --- (00.8)._ -_- i 4YjTFgFF?T3F, Pl^.i.ntiff ctfully ter ys:s 1,11-•1lydc:, 0rpl c m,;Or , be . stte3 l.ccorli,,; ll; to tlle 11ras of his Court nnci n.mver for the cririec F r a C,1)_ -7 i i 1;_ ?i - - --- -- " ,_ V1p1t311pris .:alley e(1_ 1n tl'11fJ ori- -171 11 i t'1 11r1r!11e S s , SOT-;'Fayette ------59??,$--- .- 050 J) el fl: Scnte" ibnr 23. 2003 LnBoIle, :A 151-5'0-1 (l3) l l T?_.R COIirRO'd PI, EA?; COURT OF liUf"'.nl;(t1,8i`;.u V1tu:L';'li, r.Cull`!a.LLVtLL+1ts -- 7 1 V- t T)TiMT- 1 i trn T c. r R A 2 -- TT? , , ----- ----- Alt--AT i Jr., bei.n,r, the Plaintiff in the !l.bove cii:e c .se nc' at.t !.che:'._ Coi;lnlrint, <lo hereby tleel_,^re th^.t rill of the ---i crr? f' rr!i-de e1 r`a i>i orsf,;q, -lc? e? ? rrect to the b c:-,t of ;-ay l.novtler': e, iruroniw-.ti.oa, -ncl belief; Prl - t ln,t y fnlce ct<,,tcrzentc lade therci.n m ,-.y be subject to nen1-1tie;s for perju.rt y pursu^z+ to 1 P,^.. C. S. ?n90n conCerni.n ; "ru1-1721 porn f?Icifi.cr tion. -- CTRTIFICATE 0'a' SFRVICF 1i I, J^Jles A. P"'ILLC11, Jr., bei.*, ; the Pl;duti.ff o--f- ,he rtt-checl - Co '. t] 1111 , P acli z? PA Dc n .r1; 1( Yl1 oz COr3 (G I%1 ono, 1 • r' ?? 9.. ----- -__._ - - - :sJ le 1C Orl- t1 Ihn.l COtI T Of ?]cLVC Y V0C1 ,3.x1 Orl ,r; uy CC'l i'1 ._ J 1.3.t ---- r tir nor- -MAI; -Co(.k t' , E'.o? nt- ,akin s, Va.?_ }ie_PriN,?uer.' . Pwi7 Un r Rule, by t?e??o:itll??-; it irn.to the han(ls of PA DoC Facility st.-tif -d-, SCI F .rct1 e, nn i th r oo vise is belfi r-vl.do vi fii.r 1 cl U.9. TR^ 1,? , re ?.^ t (7. 0t1 t.1P -f0'T:7_-0-. 1r~---;je774101111. ?0 ^ t mC-p _ Ourt Lon - Prorhorrnt T:ry---- _. Ctuabc-rl-?,.nd Cotuatg Cour-L- ioLise -One. CouYthonoc-Sopo.re ? ; C Zli.cle, FA 17013-3307 ? IY1 ? ? ?'1C11° .,, Y-d - L - i i 4 r I />/ J acs A. P lacll, Jr. qf?l$ ---- J<,. ics A. P?.ILICn, Jr., Pro Se --- - 3 T69 SCI-F(m,yette Lr%Relle, PA 154.50-7_050 R,A-,o Sept,er?lber 2008 Att. cc: cile . y i. ._.? I mTr CCU-iT 0 ' r;p?'m''z0?T P?I?r 'j. RALUC? , J-R a _ p?n ; 0,IVIL ACTIOI? - IT L-Vil • r ^ Q_ • C?SaJ nT0 ? ?n JUDGE '?E?fcnC `?Y1 ,c, " PI .i.n.fiiff's Mo-rion for Le.ve to Proceed. S7f27 © F77 C-Y In %r --, -; rr Forma auner1s _._._. nre, .,??, ? fih? fit?? 1 n???i n cf• hl_? ?• 'a.f':S ?re ll.ot7?;1;? .Ll.let_ C1"•l1l x11.1'1 in this, Cov.rt on 77 _, 2?Oo, ?'ocreet?_ P,1uc1' v P_-? DoC. Cd; I'l (ntt _ ?. _ of - 26 7c ?zr? e 77^ t-O ?-t " Gee( in i 4 w- L7L T 1)7 x'. 008. • T. _ C 1. ` ?.,_ ?. l- J P tr l E l ? L TT ( V ,- i- n -•+-,•--• ono Ter 1 n 0 1-`,7 rt? ... Civil suits. He I1er,-tl_v nee-,,,- to :7, i .1 F t ???' J #1 1tC ?t<'.t Lt°, O:' c _23?'. necl O on CT13??: 1 i( O1 G SD ec".' .11 - f w , ti „c ?.on. aae incor?or;ite V O Z_` 0Z P`?l 1 'r1 5`.fiL1S x11. L c.l le Cot1_r"? 011 1 ?C3 tjr ?_ is - --i txll?r-sue T _ c? ii n? c, 1 Pnn h h& i n f `:o?Lr#' ,- cv, o P1 i . u l I0 al-, fi i?"Ie oGaly.1i.1 n r.?f:e 1l Z 0 r.., i,'1r^ Li r, e ti,. it n 3-07,_ 1._ _ ???r?r ??' ,?i1"? ?'?? :11.i111.?e-?• _ _ - J J. cllaao, - Yl?o O 1?. nlly) t Oconies, of t e ? richer" _Z Co 1nl- i Y1t, 0t (=.C,'1..1P11?? t0 ft?r''^.r ?i1C3i to S, r af r- 11..Ce c i^rr fL111r's t0 "C11C ?ilcil rJ" ' P?^t7 ?,? ?r 9 i u. I'7_ ,,. y1CY (??sr -t7 (? ^1 pS i.t?cts ?1't?i 1.'.1 ili S !lon `1,e ,~•"L1? o "uns':rorn l ifii c<-tion ?o uYorii-es,??. .?;REFORE, F? i i. r?r ( 11t in leuve to proceed ?-?•?-?-- •??...?.«?e.?-?_T _- ., 0 o f ?- i.C.?e Co, i ,.1.-? i 11.,....tt ci 01- rrn,, -0 IN THE COURT OF COK1ION PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA 61U7ES A. R LUCH, JR., ; Plaintiff CIVIL ACTION - AT LA/W? V. CASE NO. _ Q • LRL.L? PA DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, ET AL., ? JUDGE: Defendants n"??? o PLAINTIFF'S AFFIliaJIT OF WAGES C- I, Jai-,es A. Paluch, Jr., do hereby declare as follA- a 1. That I am the Plaintiff in this case as well as Pa£ach-*v. PA DoC, Civil Term 08-4835 (Case 41) ; 2. That the Honorable Edgar B. Bayley did grant me leave to proceed in forma pauoeris in 08-4835 on August 21, 2008; 3. That I remain indigent and unable to pay for the filing fees or any over costs associated with litigating 08-4835 as well as the attached Complaint (Case #2) being filed today and herein as attached; 4. That my prisoner account balance is presently $7.55; 5. That my only income at this time is PA DoC "idle pay" for which my account is credited approximately $10.00 per raonth anal that this ias approved because I am r?iedically unable to be employed while in solitary confinement; 6. That montly allowances are used for purchases of station- ery supplies, postage, and other as-needed services which are required for three (3) civil cases I ,gym litigating. I also attest that this presents a serious hardship and burden to me be- cause not only are the supplies at times insufficient, but I often must forfeit the purchase of hygiene supplies to manage my budget; 7. That I own no real estate, financial accounts, or other significant assets; nor do I have any dependents. liabilities, or debts. I am a dependent of the PA Do C; and, 40 8. That I mailed this civil suit (#2) to the Cumberland County Prothonotary on September 239 2008 in order to meet the September 24, 2008 filing deadline. I represented in my Motion for Leave to Proceed In Forma Pauperis that I incorporated by reference the Affidavit of.In Forma Pauperis Status which I filed with this Court on July 319 2008, as though it was fully set _forth at length for this Court's review. I did this because I was in a stranglehold for time so I could mail the Complaint (#2) and its related documents on September 23, 2008 before the mail was picked up. Therefore, I made a "good faith" judgement call to do this instead of having to file a separate "Affidavit of Wages". I suffer from chronic and acute carpel tunnel syndrome. There was no possible way I could have filed a separate "Affidavit of Wages" in time to meet the filing deadline. The Prothonotary has refused to file Complaint #2 because an "Affidavit of 'Nages" ?1,ias not attached and I assert and aver that the Prothonotary erred in iAys judgement, having no right to reject or deny the filing of this Complaint, esp. since the Prothonotary knew that I was indigent and was petitioning the Court to proceed in for- ma Pauperis. I affirm that all information contained herein is both true and correct to the best of my knowledge and that any false statements knowingly made can subject me to the penalties for perjury pursuant to 18 Pa.C.S. 94904 concerning "unsworn falsification to authorities". In kindness, /s/ Janes A. Paluch, Jr. iel?e?pS James A. Palia.cL,., Jr., Pro Se BQ-376' SCI-Fayette 50 Overloo,? Drive LaBelle, PA 15456-1050 Dated: October 10, 2008 cc: file CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, James A. Paluch, Jr., hereby certify that the attached Complaint (Paluch v. PA Dept. of Corrections - Case #2) along c7ith its Sumr7ons, Pltf.'s Motion for Leave to Proceed In Forma Pa:uperis, and C.O.S./Declaration were originally mailed on September 23, 2008 as indicated in the enclosed original C.O.S. and that the Prothono- tary refused to file this Complaint on September 30, 2008. I fur- ther certify that all of the above mentioned documents including an "Affidavit of 'Wages" is being served upon the person below, via first-class U.S.P.S. postaige prepaid mail: Curtis R. Long, Prothonotary Cumberland County Prothonotary Office One Courthouse Square Carlisle, PA 17013 on this 14th day of October, 2008. Service has been made, by hand- ing it to R TJ prison officials at SCI-Fayette on this date, pursuant to the "Prisoner's 51ailbox Rule" (Houston v. Lack., 108 S.Ct. 2379 (1988) Comm. v. Jones, 700 A.2d 423).* In ici2clness, /s/ Ja:_-,es A. Paluch, Jr. James A. Paluch, Jr., Fro Se BQ-3769 SCI-Fayette "pt log 50 Overlook Drive LaBelle, PA 15456-1050 *PS-173 cc: file ( 2) 50 Overlook Drive La73elle, PA 15456-1050 October 10, 2008 vurtis a. Long, vro-tnonosary Cumberland County Pro thono to Une Courthouse Square Carlisle, PA 17013 Dear Mr. Long; Please find enclosed my civil Complaint, Paluch v. PA Dept. _ orrec ions, et al. - ase , ong ?,-ii its Summons, 4otion for Leave to Proceed In Forma Pauperis, -Affidavit `6-ages, e c ar o n ., an anew e a s e at i lfile it and process it for service by the Sheriff. !It is my understanding, that you erred in your judgment not t'u-f'i j e ancr pro ss tnis Complaint wen origina y mai e it to you on September 23, 2008. I believe that you had a date anct m e stamp as Being e You co _. 'have easily notified me of any discrepancies, whereupon I ?__cis -l you f"eed"6 _`T pT?n Ito take this matter up with the Court if the Defendants ob- A? I ?tr`#Yrd??mt : From noV7 on , -If`?r`? Yiave c r e= - panci.es, kindly notify me without having to send the legal to remail these documents back to you. linien you do this, QU pl a -a- aigni-f`t as upon cannot--du (this as a courtesy, let me know, and I'll motion the Court r fir -rthvrxti? ir: Please --Sinat !allowance of onl;r U10.00 a month and I'm litigating; three { _ rrtirer cvi?-- ers. Thil, know. I remain; In kindness, /s/ James A. Palu Is Office P " Jr. ,James A. Paluch, Jr. „„ 1-/-- SCI-Fa;rette ,:Enclosures cc: file ? a e '+ 1.:)7 S PA I !'l ('Y 'f71 1A I'ft PA i? : _1 ...J l e 1? lwC....1.......... _.,..._. - ..?.... ,.__....? u _ J I 1) (7-E! ._ -._....[f.l..?_?...r-,..w1.l.J...al..±-_-::.r .1...-...ai,y,{.?-.?..__.e.. _... _-... .. - .C?w_..-.:131..............1..-2 ?- _.... ? ?_. I1' it Pi r rnM 77 T_ ? T Jr S: 7 rr j n AN D n f7 a ^^a, - , +Y• ^'lr ;. -... f, ., "` _....i ,..',..- r+.., _.. - _?', _.' ,?. ?-?- ?.•r?,'? r ? ' - ': ? ,D r-) ice.?.. .... ter... .. ..... : ??.x';'9'.rZ '?.''-..._i? ; ., a?.. f{1.?..,+..-, ?_. _.,,,1 -.a .1-_?'1 ."•,.. ..^...?-r..,, .J._;.?.., T Tr..T.M .,., .F,,.•, l-?-1 ,? .-_" r•., ?^.`.. '?a.a ....,.. - -. (, ^ r7- ._... ... -- ...._.._...?_... . , ?. ?. j P1 a J . ; r1 t a ? ?'? I-. .^ ? ?.. y, tirwn .a= .Z +? -. :-r ?^ 1 ^ }'1,'lq !_ ',.?. : s.l W.. ?.,..1 . .. /rl-.ys..-. -.I1 ?:. .. ..•......... . 1 •. V S. i _- ?y 1? _.,.. T ..-: ,C'rj -• ''-tl , `_ 1. 1 c. -. ril` ,_ -. i. .._ t __ .. -- 9 i ? e j- 1 o - ..... .', ,1. .. ,?.. _ .. . ,ri ,,rte., 1 nl c-.,? ?:+ . r... _._ ._ _ -. j - r _•_ _ .... _ l??__. L ? ? '?:? '?, ,',_?? •-fin.;"iyn'. O._ ?j?_._, ? °- ?'? - - _? ail'!. ?? ._1' 7) 71-1 07-7 ,rA-4? 1.. .{,s ??' .`- +: +-- l ?..nl^ .t CJ..l. ...?„ .?..rl-l.+`i.'.. ..,. .4?.?. .. .. ..L..+ ?.. G-?. ._.. . ...._.., ___, _ ._. .__ ....,. .__ 71- . JAMES A. PALUCH, JR., IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF PLAINTIFF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. PA. DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, ET AL., DEFENDANTS 08-6175 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this day of October, 2008, the motion of plaintiff to proceed in forma pauperis, IS GRANTED. The Sheriff is directed to serve the complaint without cost to plaintiff. B, Edgar B. Bayley, J. \ ,"J'ames Paluch, Jr, BQ 3769, Pro se SCI Fayette 50 Overlook Drive LaBelle, PA 15450 --"Sheriff - A IY I :sal t r- Co cxm 4. ;? ? c\i C -) CZ) .. U- C c y cl-n y C4 ?, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION-LAW JAMES A. PALUCH, JR. ; Plaintiff, : No. 08-6175 V. PA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, et al., Defendants. PRAECIPE FOR ENTRY OF APPEARANCE AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Please enter my appearance as counsel on behalf of Defendants Pennsylvania Department of Corrections, Edward Ayers, Matthew Yohn, Adam Huber, Mark Simpson, Eric Kline, Robert Krieder, Richard Southers, Zachary Moslak, and Donald Kelchner in the above-captioned case. The Defendants also demand a jury trial on all issues. Respectfully submitted, Office of Chief Counsel By: 1[6 m d W. Dorian Assistant Counsel Attorney I.D. No. PA-48148 Pennsylvania Department of Corrections 55 Utley Drive Camp Hill, PA 17011 (717) 731-0444 Dated: November 10, 2008 2 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION-LAW JAMES A. PALUCH, JR. Plaintiff, : No. 08-6175 V. PA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, et al., Defendants. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day depositing in the U.S. mail a true and correct copy of the foregoing Praecipe for Entry of Appearance upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below. Service by first-class mail addressed as follows: James Paluch, Jr., BQ-3769 SCI-Smithfield P.O. Box 999 Huntingdon, PA 16652 k5_j Shelly Holle Clerk Typist Pennsylvania Department of Corrections 55 Utley Drive Camp Hill, PA 17011 (717) 731-0444 Dated: November 10, 2008 ??r E' ; ??- ?, .?- IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS FOR FAYETTE COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION-LAW JAMES PALUCH, ; Plaintiff, No. 08-6175 V. PA. DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, et al. ; Defendants. DEFENDANTS' PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT AND NOW, come the Defendants, Pa. Department of Corrections, et. al., by and through their attorney, Raymond W. Dorian, Assistant Counsel, and pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1028, object as follows: 1. This Civil Rights action was initiated by Plaintiff James Paluch, Jr. ("Plaintiff'), an inmate formerly incarcerated at the State Correctional Institution at Camp Hill ("SCI-Camp Hill"). 2. The Corrections Defendants include the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections, a Commonwealth agency, and past and present employees of the Department at SCI-Camp Hill. 3. On October 16, 2008, the Plaintiff's initiated his action by filing a Complaint. In his Complaint, the Plaintiff alleges that he was issued a false misconduct report and was later found guilty of some of the charges by Hearing Examiner Moslak. Complaint at ¶¶ 25-38. He also asserts that Hearing Examiner Moslak denied him due process in connection with the misconduct hearing. Id. at ¶¶ 27, 31, 40-2, 61. The Plaintiff also claims that Defendants Yohn and Ayers yelled at him. Id. at ¶T 15-17, 19, 22. In addition, Defendants Kline or Huber allegedly confiscated three pornographic photos from his personal property. Id. at ¶¶ 44-50. Finally, he alleges that Officer Simpson make sexual noises and caressed his hands during a strip search in his cell. Id. at ¶¶ 52-56. A true and correct copy of the Plaintiff's Complaint is attached and marked Exhibit "A." 4. The Defendants demur to the Plaintiff's Complaint for the following reasons: (a) The Defendants are entitled to sovereign immunity with respect to any state law claims; (b) The Plaintiff has not alleged personal involvement on the part of all of the Defendants; (c) The Plaintiff has improperly sued the supervisory Defendants, based on their supervisory positions only; (d) Defendant Kelchner cannot be liable, based merely upon his processing of the Plaintiff's grievances and appeals; 2 (e) Hearing Examiner Moslak is entitled to quasi-judicial immunity as a hearing examiner for the Department of Corrections; (f) Mere verbal harassment and threats do not constitute a violation of the Plaintiff's civil rights; (g) The Plaintiff received all the due process to which he was entitled in the context of an inmate misconduct proceeding; and (h) The confiscation of three pornographic photos from the Plaintiff's property constitutes a de minimis injury in the context of the Civil Rights Act. WHEREFORE, the Defendants request that their Preliminary Objections be granted and the Plaintiff's Complaint be dismissed with prejudice. Respectfully submitted, Office of General Counsel Raynr End W. Dorian Assistant Counsel Attorney I.D. No. 48148 Pennsylvania Department of Corrections Office of Chief Counsel 55 Utley Drive Camp Hill, PA 17011 (717) 731-0444 Dated: November 17, 2008 3 TTl,n - - - ry nl TTT) ry()Tr l.nY jrrT;T' IT T Pi ?o PALUCH, CiT`rrT Jul",' rJl PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTj':ZENT OF _CO RRE CTIOI•TS --r T . AL : y -E Tva r.d ------ - - , _ rr 73 - 7 Dc)"! :" l P? 'I i l r 1 o Lr rlJiLTr TPT ^T NN PL T. , ----' :?,.. ?"% L._S.._ L 1! ? i. 1 ? ? ...__c.? 1 _L7..: r ? Y ? ?l m o ?• I . 7 , r ' , l 9 1 l 1 1? . ?? ? (? , f I i , ? J C ^ - r i J I I C I - - _ - - rn(- ,- Z if !,- T ,f rlo T-,l1 - T) - r (I n , TTn in. r)rn T,? Fl, -tin i n,; CI rT':T) C)TT rn ';?tl, lro T r l -j ( r, Tj"I'V71 j'r -7a , a % ber?4x??.C0u64T Bar. A5500-n - s ry 77 re Ii 013 .249-3iJ:1. 7 9? ) 'c?.0 i yr Q - V . r EXHIBIT _---- __-------- __.----_-----_..__.._.__ !IT THE, rv? iT1i , OF COT O4 Pi-T ,?5 CT1i;'TTi^RI„9'?'D rOTTp,,•f PgiT.?S7V;':Td?A T Ia. PALUCIi, J12, CO ( r:.tl- E: C' "i; ,jL:C0 ct 11-- Ca ? V. VANIA DEPARMENT OF GTIONS, ET AL., TIT ol j, f: 1 ,X01" Ui) C. 111 L1 - CIVIL AUTLION - AT I hv'? C.9,ST` TTO. l1_.F _L7 . ail:?DGI? o PCWbC-Wr_AND _Si.61',P6F_M6NTh2_ S?R1sDlcrl'o/J ps 114VOKEb . JITR`' T722.1?L DT'!'":/11`r')l,l)1 C 0 M P L A I AT T _ I. JL., tg!lt.r.f.1.0i?. nnr,, n , 1, 1'_,r1r t7L1,:mr'nt to .I!C 1.i. O_ 1:j'!n r%O n ',1 i G1 n 1 Of o Pen Tl wmi • A2 ., . /l So- i S. 55313•._-5 3.253Oi=-?'i,i:1C; riOlr?l_l?'i'l?- 1:011-0?- ti '??• n T i 1 1 I . .. T1 , C.A. n j. 1 art i r:U ? y LT 4.') U. S. C. ?,. 1O(?`7_, .lc(,,l ,?On° C.._i.._. T.7 r; (i01l'ii).ui1;, i!u =1 '%il ( .i.0:- 1 z... ? i •, rrT?(;u 7 P ' r' r 1. 11 ul r, C, 111,>i.?- p: pr __ ?) t L 'r'll ?, 7tr OI r]^ ni,l_1.C-. !n)_itt i T ? ul t)ll'Yr)u r_„ 0=._CC'ive, Ll. 1, ::i:1U11 0*1 1 !E _.,r.J-_1D.. J4-c--fe -fort law- u b ' S. -_-- T t i t n - _ ( 1;1.OIi i_r J, P-1 l, n, a TJ T -? P1 P1 I{{I , ?-!.C?1''l7-), !'h.?`I•C'''„'v ':1.; C0A17-1 0.' Ply Dc'.n?-J1 1^i1: of C07rf',C1'.1Crn,^-_... Do Of') , 10 ]".;;GT-1,y cU1::xl1Ci' _1ii J11G .5' 1!r1 C`C'1.1 C?T17.; I ! I .? 1 t Ott ?.T C;;; a t.__l ._.--C'': n, ,.1 l ;?) (:'.t11'1 )_v i J•tr rr_.r. ?.r r, i ,I c? . co_ ,, 1:.1011^ . arti i'.l:-i on n'i P @1: j;c. -rr n - ("SOT ;yei:i,c. ) JA LcJ3e17_e, PA, ro_ I jCilr:i i V 1,c1J C I. ,Ir foi CO'Tl' ns,,- on, inrl ,t)r11-1i1:if0 _r?-;.:;, i;0 1611C jL_1E.; Ii r:"17LU t .t.- TO 111 P^.7^i7 i i,'C, Z1. 0 !^ I1 ,., ,.LJ,Y .,17f3r1^1.71;' civil 1-^l'I? n ]-;' 1710 I_, .I1O.C1•, MC I ] I(.-nI:? r^LL_?_ C:i).17y ]'C:,•' 1.oi:1 r,nC i,]'OC`('>'-, y _'l:^,?7"F;?,^t017.G-C:01'?Cr-'.rYt1p1:,,,.COlt.?1.,,-?t„t@12'lt _d-rl-_.rl.-i.?£?C1- .1.1??- tTJ1`1 !'."'.7C:".? ^f`•?^vtCn.,? ^•".x117.^P1' na',??r t?.O.?.G!".l ilr-?/nr -^:1tn71r,.t'.nl.-,l_ ... _.. _. n TT ` . . ll J TTJ il -1 J. C Tr 11 I(J11: TTJ, ' II„ r rll\ flo? !T' . ' !:T ;. ;: n l .l ,., 1).;"1 •"" y TrnP,r T", r, ^ P n„7 r^!1?1; ? n 7) n... ? n ? PA DO C .,1, CC), `7^.;i, :L? I r7-?_-rr C..r j?rC? •?l ,.(,_.. U r, i i)]_ 17 rl -,i 1 1 I r .1 •) ;- of _ '1.!.. `' Yi)_ 'i _ •Lii. J'l r.o 1]r; ?T'1, r.'.1. _._ ,.I??,Ir „r1 rin^.. Y' ? 1.J)r Illrlill ? 7C J7.0i l1 U'I? 1:, (I1 r ,'l i.7 , - I _1 ? n nC .I (f: ? ]`ltl o? ? 7 r •+lll .i. i r)i ? .,IJ ' i r( C',_j zT TC' Tr 1)OC C^?1 i P.O. Bo C rn?? C .!'') ll Ur? /Crli l )- -J.1n l i In T' (?r ?Il;ll,'!7n;.u17 ,4 ,7 ?,,:1pOO1J ?I151 II?: 1 '.' `? "q! _.._.._ ,. __ .. _ .... " .. _II - - - G I .. 1 c) -C^..fi_.Irill 1A a11C.-S11U. at L11 _1-line.:, T.taG-.. l J , V <I. 1'b l s_ f is r 1? - - ."- _ - t - --.7 :..:10 '7i1 (, .]"(..?.> t... :.,1)!) l r,Jl."-- Pli - ,l T'i17 y I i? r? Illy. ? IIT?•)!),. II 7 ^,, 1C (; _" (I?? nILI , ^..?'..T ? I fD .`. 5l:T-C :.ln ,l'I 1,1 t11( ST;TT ro 500 171'1)1 .ill.] 22 R o P O PO , i C .IV•. T , I Pal 7. i _V 11? R.I ( I J "Di r,; II +O_,' i i r`J-L> II 7t..I I, r.1 ."n) i t. .1 i ?:1 1`I-..._..__...... 7."..ills O i.nc 1) cf t-, TJ in -_ , 1Irr r) '-1w.re? rl: ',l_u?(''.,.?- F; CT C"1?1i-1 r. Vii- _, rYlrg?;.7,r-a_eV:-r,!t.i: TZOn11 P. C), T107 ..'P:il 1 70 / 1)r 7r,r TTO^I ?. IIT.n l "'I),, j- J)c,Cl i:. i)r I f; i,rln 's.1l l_. C 1 ; .li.,l.? fi)17 Gull r. 'ilr I , 1 -C1 111.1""_ r)n.!'1 1 1. UT !7. 1 .U,,r 1 ('I l (`. U i)T(` I 1 1;, ... . . i_u l?l.t r r, n . _ , • r'^--?t•o I (' v^ ,Du_1"?>w_L..__1_=.i:1G?!i14i ?"r I ?jli?.,-,.,(I? ?; i"'1? 1?• ?-i i,;r t.?., - o f S (?T-Q 1 In -ill, "?_-Il " r. i?C; l' 7 -? - ?. k C, J_.r, nay <7.^tlr:' iii^?r !ail Ih:'(C ?') k „"Oh rn_ rj ^ _,(?.,i 1 ,:__r'.:t :.; t il•'.J:1 'r,' 1.[). a o'II).. eta; -1:'1./.,•i:r 11_c' 'O_,':'i r,i l p, 1_ CI TI? nrTr:, r,.. nJ i:f7rne (?? 'ri!' n- {l 10. 1117 7)? ' J -o r J u is _0 r f-, I. J7 1TJ-!..]'I; (;' c i.;.a 7 J?.,'I i f•Zr C, r, ?;,_) i!.., :!-(. ?'?;,: iJ."i C? of illy nl .'0 t ^ 1 11 •-:?l :;-? :. 1_ "ILQ?;,, 1)C ?1':'I;', '.ri,i l'..T,.li?i,.? lii,^ _ _ _ c S 0 n 1 '. 7 j i ; 'I !r? 7 'p ), J) h y. i... l ?1 - l _r - I , C) IViL TETP4) C.1 Ir 0il0T^ltl c, E( 1._R D^?rl 1 ?'?:.. .. 1. m:,._ :.. !'•'n' ;?: '-: 1., :-? . I. rn r.;.lr n 2005 1 it r! !r r - r.. Out i 0- Ll (m 1- 1? ?) I I ? :E3i r 1 fl 1 li ._ . I'I ...:.11? .. .'(' _ _. •11. ..i!1 :,', ,. "??.?i, ?.;_?.,.C!.: .: CJ"-?'J? t)I'i tlj ) .. . 1(r 1:?:) PD (-.j -V •_?I?I, Ir. '?'-111r.. , l?. 'til.ll (?r'.{'-. n'a 'hn fii? C^l, f-C P?Ii: ', __. 17!:! 111' ? 1 1?? lIn t 1-(u:wr' ]'J_1:.. tt q ;. t , ,., 1 1.1 j.1t 11 ??. On. anaa ""^T ?)^ •',1! .rr i.nn YI n` -1 IrT 9, 'IT 5 r: 1 __1 o11. A,,'f?_ .tlo:. to f, n T' i c- T ': ?.' i:1n .?. ,•1 -.'. 1rr_i.? 1r?tljl l"r i??.., , ; 11h 1, C, 11T 1 e C, Tt ? ? 1 )l e Ir.. < ? 1 it is . Tr ° 7 ._. .____ 1':CO? 'C?•?_ L;"L^ 1 7.C1:. .__ C?? rlc.,' n, C, 0 "di C1• u'I T.",'p fir; ):'.? )` II; 1: "r !'s ii}f ^(,1?^? 0T 1 ,1.,,CI._)TJ (nTTAOTI-r") ".J.' i'r:..«';S:.i, 11??111 _ Too ° fill_•?-lir- t T.? P, -vi ,(.,.1CC (?_ ED ))cf. `rO:.l1e The 'r1!'^1) n'?i''C1.7.Ci± OIL_1' itr'zIC ...11nT• ,;r(;].:!.1,rp" OR'i; -111 ?. '-IAt9]"11 FLF v0)11J. J.? ?„E31•%. _.... _- C1 • .T(-)0011 ,11C.i:F.-' ,rr,: rig (n) ),T a. C: i fq/ O ' l' { CC ' i:i I T.,'1 q..' .i)V i.. (r-, ) T .`.ox . i_::)7: g '-, ?" i t rl S1 rlr 1) -' is i r?nrlj -c cl- VCY ?!.l Srn?)?1,,'-i)•??•1.(1 1.Yl. j: ,??`.,,,. i, ,--, ,.;:: i (i of I IAt.C_ ')7. .1. no E'.'V 1 1 `, •! - _07 ?,,. „E . _.; ,., . . Y i.;-, j - . en n11C i ,lilt: ,rr 6ln5Wcrn test Moray. ,.{, Tf. e (01 i;M)IL,c:,_ r'VI::iil. J i' 90 Nos t..o2,`.'r;cvvj, e m- i ) r?n?lr _ ?il? _1.'.. pl 1•_.. . n._^.i i)]'!-^ t. NOU T riJ, l ,, i).(1i .k'. _1_ _ 1^17., 16„•1 1-j,.1 _ _ .,ib li ,•!L'I: U__'iTDC) iii, I1i71"?1]O!1LGYLL''1(_ O th _C JidCA1CCn I ,C v t^`') 1- __ ! ? f ' r . .1]. „ , t0 Of ., „ ., . ?_,. r1E?es.rc o:; ? c?_Cl.u.I.C; O- l .1 C. . e ^t 1 r "" 'Ti ISO (-,A ei)CC. of BD ?LL 1? J 1 i r r •1',)n}' ??J 7 ;1,'x!1.;;, 76 vNeo chhnee. wzu A HAVE 5?1ou1n •1•?ov1 ?I+•f • was Y1C} .- ?Omm,+•-'I,n? nvLy rnlSe.cr,?la,?t•h• -';. Both _r r'cu:rtt.; c! 0--- rj CC T' (CL , Fl Cl -ner .a.. Tr-; ..,, .. 1:(1 .lt(' -n v j ,1 ,,0 3.1r r'i l.lmo row E-Unit (577) lull '11- _ 61 '40 51- FecorW Farwillpace to 35. PUT. b] _r?y`3,_ thAt Mw WOO r_"l, - j l _ !?C(: rem l" j.i QUO& Amp ill or 1.1•" T _ ----- i 1,1 ?.}) 1t> 1i?,_1:-l_C,.' or), .4--TJ']!.1:_l.f is i._i7n .r11 Could 17.:-;S e_ (=01^i:•.c'.'1.-? r -, .I. + ?;C _. (•.. rC i/ i.11rv 11' -1 1-- ''1)r- ! ,,:,- -r i. :p °ti i.•i.t r.-•C Urn 0A WKWwr 20, 2006 qMKICA " hl -r.. ._ r,. i. r tr,. ,,•- ., ,'1 _"•I-. t:0 C^l_l -^n _i" --T 0_ O!7 ...-....... 110'1', fl' jll •11 oat Of LiE }l '_1 .'!7.•.. `.'i:'lj_1'l1 C 'i.'7. 1: Ii I:i.LP 'r•il_111.;. O ^11c,r^,1 CCC f, ^in.,':T SMU __ l o 1. S 11c U: 'Do -u DO D.A. SLIM. if is o:. `r0!11t t Li 17"j/WOO 7" 't07" I' J:).1 R'TO, 1 'J ' , i. .. . ..l_ h7- e to M-;P& both slit O '-OC^,,A -,-,-- ^ q77?' l_jhC7 ^A ?1' _ iall;n; C,. 'I;,^>Y »l.T _ :JL!1i'luu. Conceo(t0J:ee of ;Wi'I;j..oma r1,1 C1.Dl11!•.ry_.('•011)°]..1 ,:'Ci: t in the SWU7 9:,111; .1i'; cbjl_iQ to i, UrC,.,l 'i:},rOtl^;i 'I;li.r. SMT :"o privYl_e ,' _ ijj ' - ;'t ,an l r.i: i p't "n r ftli..M7^ LL't - o:L;'. J. i:'Cl-- 1:1.011 .l l <r T?t'^l r'nf', 41. n '. ' ,. t.1t T! t t r.. .. i.hd 1^f?n0'1"9: ^., •' r•T,l .'l -r -?`• j ? .. ji ws'- s ' aw ' . .. c DIM. I .? n 'r'j I-u 1? 01 1 t l I. t l- ? 'il' T t r a t n L. cL?rlrl ,t"oh ;11 Y . C J I C, I C::,-. h. { , 1 11 PI K ar r, 0-t )rah '!^rr no -l-(, ta1tc--)o110!.r) r'i r. 71 -iri? i! iti ri.i lrl' to Pitt. nr ra A: r: volrrt?-_..,,.,r-n1-le iii; T1 t ? 1 _ CO ( C 111 i t i'1 in 111 i i:' CU ?? ?r l'I , r' , t! c:"i.. i _ r,L 1I. ;r) rO( "1 r' -, rhl_1: I r ,-?1 es ;_i 1 _1.Jlgar on-c`.,0h O'i';"er, f:rj_lwl ,rj. 1:1•.,.•tiirn lr1.r1- ,:':rl.)ILr•j.nA, bu.t not. _ -j_ys f7"Cr.l iii:- r,'-vn.,_ i.v° -- (i) i?hO"t•Or? E;Y(3 "i:0 1)!1 '1 U •?1(? .L.._:.';'J' ?lr' •-;,). - i<l _11le '+-id0- oxylaZCt.C3( Ti1F1_.nY(JP.('!.1:1;._.exc11.:.age, Dg oL ;a'1c tit (sct'L , t,l1t? or:, _ r. i',.1' 7 r.lin O-.;/-'!.., !O Il..,,t(= ccc,?;• to 1-11c) U C i'.'• T Old ]" _lit. i . Ul . Raber, _ cr _ On 0)ci:ot!Cl. 6y 2OQUy Pit f. }11cV 21.C.G No. 166220 ?. ._1_t? ro.a- 33 __ -? ? Q WAY G?" t l? _i1C(i (7,. t :11 Till -?!jvctej V5220. , - •.-•n ... .. ! C'7. Ct_ 1.... c,-?, 11 `i_ fit- r'U:L i " I e On C^;n ^ -T t1 c.,l l- -.-t ilt I ^? ? :: ;.;? ' I a,r' r,? 'i .. t 11njt, -i- ?• i-it tt l i l j Pitt. i "Yen." -., S 'j n!-lor!. ttrT,^i: I4060 TWA p- cwch ro: i Inc p''• :,n -he i)E._! e,: over 1:0 1iks i:i) _ _.r; ll_1; ay,',c'. !" t j 1.im n;'; _. ,t'•ir; i-r, r?L' o.l. noj'-,cL 'i .tl•, •i; 1,1!:1 -•,'- O J? -A tiqo g1^. t)( 1,1.1'L - '., 'ch1"1.,., „,-OLZ 'i:et ;:.l.i_CicU.:iiJ _.-_u_s1:1p-_ PUT. A^c!'- ;i,: j. .I Q On of ,__..- U _..- o p- i ? _ I' ''' it c .. into 3w ae7_l.. W t,';o.- r•.].n;'.r• _! ur' -- 'i:.. I _lr T., 1. Si f .{^, C-00 No .,. c in it to am", low '.C'C'r',,_ to ]1 n il.--.,.iil? _.'?1.- Oi .!1 ] •'r_:?i; '.ilr'. i"?,i,.,l i, .l.?O!:1 - 'I_-_e t-..+:.. L) D i. t. J i u_ c 1 1 _ _ ;1, 1STOP _._l_ uj - C' i i - . Has. as. It 1MYOWNP 1 1 1 l i L.. iii. i!1]_l_ live l i nom. l.:.f'r M h, 1jr- IN 1 . -.I( 1,'r 1 t1Jnn '17!]. ?-OI Oj i; F • ll 1-,.? , i :? l 11 l 11 '), -- P Y r- ?' lJr 1'i O,ruY i•O , 1:11o ij.j- ..- -C' ;?O'f -Ttl:?. •. ? ?. .?, n?.'? ? _}rr,l ?:.?7f.'.,. ial•.LJi S!r.lr, l)?l+u ,Ci,;; ?- ?I 1 c 17I ` C"/C •' i l l 1 10 iF, .It.,? ,j.- C'C c h Pity. CJ: ? .1 j (r7 n. .1-77 ?t Wnn" ,• :Oft .' n, the r1F, r!t nl of-Mil z trl SWUM I ', z;,f 1P 1t•; C'I C. T _11-, ]1]( rep, l_l_ ^'] C'_l Qi(: i 1.!_ ^ 17'V£ 57- Y O ArrQ W l r:. , x:111 ;-11 I Cf. C I t I„S l U^7 ST 'T1 _ 1 1)i1r:_ 1P JO qn 1 5n^:. UOU I Pit + Pl i;= n l C It 11:1, .tl. l O C, r ] _. -.I,1.'i:]i}jbl"1 (x-,j- ,... it C:1,0 091.0. )_ O:- SI' _ 17J_ -Pi 'i:_.. ' Wulf -'Ll^l 1 a_l .7 s,se '?.' scd `f1C' r ,jt',l_-i _' i l ian V o -'. S1 '-TT ? 1 ,r I nil firart an 0 -_ n T 1. 17 ?_Z -,rl Lfl ? .. , lA l ) n ,7 L)l.. ? : 0 f !.l.li I 1^'., t n ?? :., I r, • " r ..l - ):0 , .?:.t.C:, ? •. ], f'; t ho l_')PF , they, KTVO. _r-Lt.('410h. of n"7" ol')."_I. ?:' on(:yhv i •:.t-"; tit, ,,n T) C+ ca r. nrr, ,1lTLtpt .. ., iav al (;OTC, p is f. , L D r ... •n. "l. 'iYgP t t r -nil- in hi r 4 UM10C 'P i' 0000 hontrd. ,Jl :j r. ': ?',.-,-r• :.1 r.' )--1.. L t C ? r?, ll ) I O C .. Oi -F t }rl "'l.. _ dud 00 loth 1!15. %(-4 I)i"i)( (:f.,. i _..- l _;1 Ilrr 1.1:1.: .lL.ll _I, .__.'i tic to Pilo- j'_M'i 1:0 r?- '- t (1 rlt _11u •.u lt•]• i0 ?'OJa T. ??t,il r 1 C11 Off! M It i!`i"1G_ie _l. _;]" 7"r'.1] r,: ItI i.l_._, - r C'.Ti •-: .: .. •' d n.r.r r ... ,-• ?$? _ "Ex +_o 'L.Y -- 1<1:' pl 1 ' 'i-.O U 1i ' . _ " U `•?c , L, 1 _P j on 7 7 _ C 1 . I I t)i: 1 . . ? U i_ i A 1 (1 . j,j ( JI . r d , f..wt (Arv4 Li G("(`,' ?i) llil 1 ,11 5'.) ittL.. i?_y. 1 t; ? 1^. ?. _t ..]? a t ?C •-. ,l - a-i to .? 11, .. _.. 111'._ 11 tPL` c (' 1 rat r707• rn.?+,??. n .._.?:_? Tl' usn,. ° PD ?• ,?•. ,Jt /T;' i,, „J• It T yt •.t IT. n i .. ' 1 COUNT I _ II ?b a aC ( r -1. I I I TT. S3° C ?n ^ __ FiI TT,TT,T,T, m,l 1 TO O _. (:T H AT TTT2Y' qtn T Ttn, P RTr ;I,sT, 1 S STTTj-'-?VT ,O_Rc T Mi7r77> TE, TITDTT,'ll n ,r..,? 1 C'"'T'AT '1 O1'?'R',,.:;TnPT + I T `T T:rT T): TprtT _ T•.rT nT,TC r"CIT T•T_Rr-j Tr,"DTrT 1;c% 9TTj'T-jr- ( I ) , r ?r t n F., ': T7 'C7? e, TT`?f] _ l `t F (. e 't ill :K, t TJ" II ?... .. a ?.. - v I -.. 17 1-77' ,,2 . -- ?i t'. -:i)Cl l 1,.1 .. ."'t. !.U;J•.,7^pl.! r'tl.ai i J?V_J LL' 'i: i)11 t - ?_. ? .. . ... .. '. Lli"ri1 111E-•11. C;,,,_ I?Q .l ]. ).,r r:_1.P .. - __.---._. - U .1 ," ?- ?•r;1?- r? CC;-'?"1? -I'T?1tt.," T ?,,, C ? c ."? trt, i t 1 1, l 1. f .... t r-.?).. .. o - - _ _... .. _. - •?'i .. In'-, ^ Itn,?,. A,. ,. r, 1 t.7, nri , 1?-f i{t?-L.. Q _'.. i;.:, N- T ` t , 1 , Co i'u , r: i1r'.1 ( n {? _._ .1 e i ,',I 1I TT, . n -. .. _.... - ?.I n - e . e ?? I _. ..1 I 111: „ ?it _ ..1. `?' j•tl: ?. i.', ^l.y i. t. il'tr t. '?'P I ,. i "? 1 .I{.. 1 ,)' 1_l.,•, J-'I t.) _. .. r, .. ...1 ., i , ___.__ - , ;J-, ,-,r.,T?7"i`!1,YIr•-' h"? -., ;1,rT*. ?T?i: )lOa" l •?'• (? ?r-1 .._----__. '). ?:'I' 1 l .- _';•'t-, ?__7. ll:'° 11' 't:_! i....'?O Y?lU f)!? _.p.L. ?..-', •']: ..- 11 r, ., ..1.:, ?,,., .1 -f - "(,r l'I YrL.?.. __ .7 .. ?.,, _ ?! t t J.;'ir' 1'ln T?la T1oC V - .;i" __i:.. ?^•.L; ?,'l r?7` r'?_. ,.;G':I C7"?_ , i,l_ rl li- - _. r: y'? - ?? •?.1:)T-1').1 1..17 1 1 n.G. 1)11;.,..1 t)_.L I _? n 11 r ;t.) + Ir f,( MTP`TT 17- TT lI +TT;TT177;-!!C)..._TR(1TI (T^.._pn fS?jTPTf 1?} T PT' ,,?/ Tr T'nT OF PROPPT?TY, 1. TTITTZL IfY1 ; (1T,T (I r 11I !TTJ r) T" )T-rTCr -PTWF,?T•r . r,r m PLTN _'S , DTTT' 9A P•- CESS, T,TTP131Zrmr 1TTrrTI?P?,r('ci CM71 I?T( ...mS. PT,R501 r r?T TT• jT-TTZI.•(, r. gi'Tr ,7rp, 111 _ TT? -y C ,r n .. T) T) T r PROCPSS SIT 11T Ii TU'Ro p 1?In T rnT'T?re Pr (11LATT 8 - -DUE, PROCESS CT:4T.79F ),'V'9RIT --T1,rm1MESTS; Li p nrT.9T 1 I.C,^,5 Or nT ln` OTT AT PTV:T'S'Rm',, TT-!7T,TM',?.`(lL+r Q1? T) i 17 CILl."ll. -.C,). .. 'l n. ,ll.cl_ r 'PI 17 .e7..i.!.+.-+: I)!.)..T•_L._-11....1'=i; U!_ PA Di-)C _J_0.;.. y11.111ii'_; to, v (. r l 1 ,, e f i, Or,':: 1.!.il i 1..> _."l f? i i1V.'11 ozi. •' ?r - I J?i? 1 - by I )_C' .111 J.O!'1 of J:rl•i 1 r'77'i),-,n •;. i:'-'- Ci,. _".. 'T' // - .. .. ?) :. Llr_ •?.]..11.I ,.. .71!Tir. j'p ? V.L".i. .1,1 '.. 11:'+'1O G A 011) .1" ..,.,.. Zp.l. 1.17 ii ....L..f..n:... i ...,., .,.. .? . ?. ._ _.._... CC'?7---L!Ll.C1,(t? r.??..._ _i t 'I ltl §1983 PD r, elf, tr7?- " .. -vY),1 r 1, r.. i_ _... Ju: , )L . ]]01: 1. cc 11 ' '?! .ru00.00r _t..y....(int1 iLE'-t , )_1_- l _U.• ?? , _1 l _ -- . , . i) r zrr l l c? 1 ._ 1 •,,,16Li11' 1,0 1) r 1 01::11;1 o T) .1 Z3 0 f. 0 ,- . l.:)_.._?- _....---ALL. L. _ __ _ ---•-- '' °' L - ?_.._. .l. _..,., • nr:a i'I r, _ if " I j i , r'0 llr('TIT!]' , 'PIG' .rm5 O FFT I . -CTA L ------ --- IFI^,nTIOM Or AN OFPIrl REPORT - -- -- l..?T .A, =T Il) rurm _ _-1ZT?!T';?T?T:;"`IE}1`T lY P ?TT9 tr.`_1?]) -TP7?nP,_c] n?:CI7 _.. - - ----- RETALI,ATIO11 (GPI?ER_ATI), I!BTnT,IATIOi IN) P, :,xmrpT.rplf)?!?-TO--I?d?j'I?I'Ct^-._..---- 1TAW! AND 1`Ai'1IhL5T .[ARP4 ST. T}'^.T, TI1S ----- -U.-t (r r , - 1?7,,T , I"TTOT, (r '" '??nT.) jP?ti''OR?'? 9T:SIPIC!!"'IO1 - 5:- X11 UO•',) : NAF 1S_ _ ,S'TT1FT P'-'T.jj;IIPTO', 1Y11Z 11:1ST O?„',,"CIAL '1CTTOAT O-..e __. ]7?. _1'? -1.1`1. 1117 ^-,,"n?• 1 _CG; u1?1!^11 n .C7_ .,r _ c l a i; r'i'_1 hr'-,, 'nin 71. -1) r. _Lj f 7o Civil I- i ,J."i.,, :.11, C i7 iJ. ,1C'6 1`6110"?: ,.1_]-is '.I'ig!t:? t ,11 i. i U<"]f- O "IM.1-0 -y C) T. C 01 to y '-'ef'C n' '?Or i i r,., 6= u-iiui:?l I- of Y,?a l? I ;16.1 1!' L?1CO.l;.t11 i L_ ,LCLl!.? f?.r,f rl I' .r:? 1 ' 11-. ??r ! t 1_i.i!YI l 1']1 n (n( ) 1 1 ?) r IDC _ L0.1 i..IJ.,01.1 1 rt01111 _f' )r{ 0`.,? o l 1 ! I' 11 1 ! ? 7 t n •1 1 _.. ----- ------ - - - ------------------ ---- -- - - ----------- -- T'r m i)Zr NCB: i 17 r' c t i-OIIC 0 ylt` De-f. 1.111 , Count .,c.- c - ? o ul?l, t r ?1 , I t n nlt, J']1 r ' 1 ! OL)'', rn, C1 ,.,,s , `U:Lr' r :c ?",. L!I- (T11 ; r 1 n -.. r P 1•.r+, ?.r 1 rr on. r. r t1? -I1T n, ` rrri-l 1 _i m? 1',r t.,T.,.'F l,._]-lc---.;'1?>,:1.U.LI ?i1:0i..! U'?_!Jilill_%:1_Zrr` c,,:;2 I ,.-r_.] r?11j•Pl-. ?, T,._.f, ('e _•l rl? t _ 1 _-- -,? _..._{/. c> __--- - .._.._.---._.__. 601 ,C'1 ' ,1?OTZ''s, '?ll_ LJ'111: to 7 !.'., i.1r- 01 -.0 .,t. _n t r)r Yohn ,.::n 1'11: Cou.I ,i'1--1 i?' ".11 !:lC'r. LL?r .i! pD_i-... L 7 ,, J. 11^ !_ u 94? 0 000, ?? r' - -- ._. y ..J7 (-.".. I nJ.?,]l T1 r.1 .,•t i ,.1p fo C) n ?Il^ u r -iL1 7. r;nQrrl - ? 00 l'_ --'J ( w C .,: L1 :!! l.C,`.: i J' L1llhL! l ;L . }?? i' L.e 'P0 -' l i Ii -- ---- -- CC'TTI?T-TV- - I' : I Orr / : n(:-?r. 11(1 t-(1 i!, i_!1 (: ?'OLiiJ.I LL.II n ?'i.L_?? -'J.] P(? TO n7"iti•CCi% 47 - - .. :, •!.n" CQ"rP'i:J is ,•r- t nr, l ? .a, '- i _y? i l-pr.''. i 0 _ )'... u -.0 Idyl - __ le_ ... _:. ^i: ;' t ??!. °a':' TI1 ^na. .. r'1 i''TOe ?f •^??.? .._ ._.??.. ... .. J').o:.. ?. r'Ji'i•?Y ."n'•e -- (:., !(l•., l .J ?.?,: _ P1 1-7. it ...st yr..., Tl_i-,...e ..•,f'. 1 .'.n _ i r , ;' n 9 t !r J pitp, ANK , ,...:. _., ..1 I )i l?0 a 1.?.., n •l ? - ;1 p1 '-„ l _ _ ---- _ 1 ? , Il i I r 1 ?. ?• r'.J1 :. 1.1:L' 1 ".IJ . U ??? _t (:.:.:, L_' Oil. .I .. - _ _... _. _ . _._.... _.___.._.. ... 1?.rr ! :.r t 0 -•S • P-11- L i -• 1 C - ..:. :-. .. . :? r I 1 t l T:.) _.:.,-t Y1 J -`r „ -1 1) LIT I e -o o r_ - -.Ir.`I t-.j. j ,,...r:.-?i'U ?'-?rrf-` •:',9 •r ...'1 r...,.,..,-r. , n y__--__-_. -___ -. : ,.i /r i ^ 7 1)ipri1T I, T, (? TI 1)TTT T?1ZCl':T;i, i ?. r,rr)r _, - Pr*r? nT, CYr MM. PROrr5 ; r rT T? TT' 7p, ., T?n'[T.TTI 1, 'L'() T+'?(1 m•?;,rym y rT Tn? ,? 1 mF - - _fTrDTTrrT?T;f`T?r- rTrrrrrrT„•-rr - ---- =--- - - -- __ __ _ rr r 1.''`7 P' rar?rp _ ?ci:7l,rr _1 ?rCT71?) gmrr-fir {, n*rrm -_ (S.JT'.1 9Sl99(1VT;1--- - BT TRI, . (T T 9T ,S - ?' !1r?T nr: :1'3C1V7,) P,TT.Tr (t n r Tv (11OUT'"T V P'J ))U?:y i701 ti2?^?,y zr _•_ =U;_?_ __y.-i:1`tD..'_OSly ilrl ?O11i ___ _ _. ?rr 1 ,, y 5'9-T n, nrn r n.r . ro (F1e i. Co 'S"TTTTTTOTT) -1.. (771 rG'(' X18 , ?.' c ) . r I. . i. i.?..aJp-aa, r.I:F: Cta,)?C] {:.? __,-F;? i 1.1 r, IT. 17- :1 Oi'1 •'i? ''..1 _1.11.-1 0.1 r„-1.n : v'/ TT;I?T;It(1P'',y .. T.1 .r! I -.7r] :••,i", -Ti -^ .i _. ., .. . 11i.i. I. - - - _-- - r Dell (V;?r ??): -71 r.? o I / r 'T a "I 17 - _ )(: , •, -I,' P ,.l 1. r? l i _ _-- Cc. _ -r;°a 1)r.j •.? _))...,,rlt!' nr-n:nr-);L..C' 1 1? - V :It t ^:tnr t °iC ?'7'I, I it ? T) ttrI I IJ r. 1 t ]? i -P _ .ta - ? c ;: ? I -`I,i) It lr' 1; n. . -rl.rr._--,C) _r•y`1'C 7 - -i F - rt? lf't I" '11t tt t T,„ r? c _ 1-,? I.. ._ _ .-__. -..-.--- - .:.__ °• `l i:]I _ fPnrl,T-? r1. fi' ?• ''7r't`. 1 rrl•-? I tt u r 0 - - It01. r, ," .J(tr`p Q. tl l v ) 1 ,1 - -- 1 et. tier. r:)L!: , ?fr>.:t f-t A (.'.. Tl - t l - -- - - -- - ----- r? 11 '_ -? t' -- VT. 5v yr ( pnn E - ;(3r t 11, -1 7,7 Do;' V: - _ _ ... ,1.1? i• t._Wv 11-1 it t t,- c t °. V.T 71 T -- '?' '.1. rr ?. .? j rt ; rt In 10 t _ 's') n An T y 1, i t C) ,', o u r. _j J- 1 1 -:; 1 l t 'i'1j; t t ,ll .1 1 Oll. l n i 'Nl i t , it rl t f fir/ J e. 1 r^11.? ';0_(117:) l_,)T D.7 j -'-V 0. r. 4 _I r c,:i--l r)rr CIP'll RTiXT)) C'C'TT'C! P T.A _.-{_ngr)r `'? ET -11h. J V C: r?.I no, be l7'l 0?. r., q''?.7r,. _1 ---- I .. 'U T7fl _.- e-S. T ---------?-- r .,TimTl'IC??,Tr Ctr' ST';i?1rrC? I . rl -. A 0 co 17 ?- 1 T T( ?..:)?:•!- ,+i J. p! rrF,? r'0 l'?1--.-- - Rll A li Y" DoC 17alcai l-i - i l Toil. .p+-.,?^rr l .. _ Co i1Jitr' CiJi_l-'i?!10(!?:f: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION-LAW JAMES A. PALUCH, JR. Plaintiff, : No. 08-6175 V. PA DEPARTMENT OF : CORRECTIONS, et al., : Defendants. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day depositing in the U.S. mail a true and correct copy of the foregoing Defendants' Preliminary Objections to Plaintiff's Complaint upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below. Service by first-class mail addressed as follows: James Paluch, Jr., BQ-3769 SCI-Smithfield P.O. Box 999 Huntingdon, PA 16652 - AL Shelly Holl Clerk Typist II Pennsylvania Department of Corrections 55 Utley Drive Camp Hill, PA 17011 (717) 731-0444 Dated: November 17, 2008 ?? '"? = ,?-; ; ....- ?'?t"1 ? .+ PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT (Must be typewritten and submitted in duplicate) TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY: Please list the within matter for the next Argument Court. CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be state in full) JAMES PALUCH, JR . , (Plaintiff) VS. PA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, et al. (Defendant) No. 08-6175 Civil 1. State matter to be argued (i.e., plaintiff's motion for new trial, defendant's demurrer to complaint, etc.): Defendants' Preliminary Objections to Plaintiff's Complaint 2. Identify counsel who will argue case: (a) for plaintiff: James Paluch, Jr., BQ-3769 (Pro Se) Address: SCI-Fayette 50 Overlook Drive LaBelle, PA 15450-1050 (b) for defendant: Raymond W. Dorian, Assistant Counsel Address: PA Dept. of Corrections Office of Chief Counsel 55 Utley Drive Camp Hill, PA 17011 3. I will notify all parties in writing within two days that this case has been listed for argument." 4. Argument Court Date: Oral argument is not requested. Dated: November 17, 2008 "J-/? At o ey for Defendants Raymond W. Dorian Attorney ID No. 48148 00 .. T.. J/ J f,Ya =L7 SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 2008-06175 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND PALUCH JAMES A JR VS PENNSYLVANIA DEPT OF CORRECTIO GERALD WORTHINGTON , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County,Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE was served upon PENNSYVLANIA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS the DEFENDANT , at 1555:00 HOURS, on the 29th day of October , 2008 at 55 UTLEY DRIVE CAMP HILL, PA 17011 by handing to ROBERT J VOLCIAK, ASSISTANT SUPERINTENDANT a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE together with and at the same time directing His attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing 18.00 Service 14.00 Affidavit .00 Surcharge 10.00 .00 1a2?GS??g 42.00 Sworn and Subscibed to before me this day of , So Answers: R. THomas Kline 00/00/0000 B J A.D SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 2008-06175 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND PALUCH JAMES A JR VS PENNSYLVANIA DEPT OF CORRECTIO GERALD WORTHINGTON , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County,Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE was served upon TWD'00 VnTA17VDn the DEFENDANT , at 1550:00 HOURS, on the 29th day of October 2008 at SCI CAMP HILL 2500 LISBURN ROAD CAMP HILL, PA 17001-8837 by handing to STACY SENTZ, ADMIN OFFICER, ADULT IN CHARGE a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE together with and at the same time directing Her attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing 6.00 Service 14.00 Affidavit .00 Surcharge 10.00 .00 i ;-/05A t 30.00 Sworn and Subscibed to before me this day of So Answers: R. Thomas Kline 00/00/0000 By: A. D. SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 2008-06175 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND PALUCH JAMES A JR VS PENNSYLVANIA DEPT OF CORRECTIO GERALD WORTHINGTON , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County,Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE was served upon YOHN MATTHEW the DEFENDANT , at 1550:00 HOURS, on the 29th day of October , 2008 at SCI CAMP HILL 2500 LISBURN ROAD CAMP HILL, PA 17001-8837 by handing to STACY SENTZ, ADMIN OFFICER, ADULT IN CHARGE a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE together with and at the same time directing Her attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing 6.00 Service .00 Affidavit .00 Surcharge 10.00 l jU5/D 8 9?^- .00 ? 16. 00 So Answers: R. Thomas Kline 00/00/0000 Sworn and Subscibed to By before me this day of A.D. SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 2008-06175 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND PALUCH JAMES A JR VS PENNSYLVANIA DEPT OF CORRECTIO GERALD WORTHINGTON , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County,Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE was served upon KLINE ERIC the DEFENDANT , at 1550:00 HOURS, on the 29th day of October , 2008 at SCI CAMP HILL 2500 LISBURN ROAD CAMP HILL, PA 17001-8837 by handing to STACY SENTZ, ADMIN OFFICER, ADULT IN CHARGE a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE together with and at the same time directing Her attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing 6.00 Service .00 Affidavit .00 Surcharge 10.00 .00 / /tJJ?b& ?. ?' 16.00 Sworn and Subscibed to before me this day of , So Answers: R. Thomas Kline 00/00/0000 By A. D. SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 2008-06175 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND PALUCH JAMES A JR VS PENNSYLVANIA DEPT OF CORRECTIO GERALD WORTHINGTON , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County,Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE was served upon HUBER ADAMS the DEFENDANT , at 1550:00 HOURS, on the 29th day of October , 2008 at SCI CAMP HILL 2500 LISBURN ROAD CAMP HILL, PA 17001-8837 by handing to STACY SENTZ, ADMIN OFFICER, ADULT IN CHARGE a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE together with and at the same time directing Her attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing Service Affidavit Surcharge 6.00 .00 .00 10.00 .00 i/ 16.00 So Answers: R. Thomas Kline 00/00/0000 Sworn and Subscibed to By: before me this day of A.D. SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 2008-06175 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND PALUCH JAMES A JR VS PENNSYLVANIA DEPT OF CORRECTIO GERALD WORTHINGTON , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County,Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE was served upon SIMPSON MARK the DEFENDANT , at 1550:00 HOURS, on the 29th day of October , 2008 at SCI CAMP HILL 2500 I,TSRURN R(AT) CAMP HILL, PA 17001-8837 by handing to STACY SENTZ, ADMIN OFFICER, ADULT IN CHARGE a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE together with and at the same time directing Her attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing 6.00 Service .00 Affidavit .00 Surcharge 10.00 .00 /a?6 s ?U 8 ? 16.00 Sworn and Subscibed to before me this day of , So Answers: R. Thomas Kline 00/00/0000 By: A. D. CASE NO: 2008-06175 P SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND PALUCH JAMES A JR VS PENNSYLVANIA DEPT OF CORRECTIO GERALD WORTHINGTON , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County,Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE was served upon KREIDER ROBERT the DEFENDANT , at 1550:00 HOURS, on the 29th day of October , 2008 at SCI CAMP HILL 2500 LISBURN ROAD CAMP HILL, PA 17001-8837 STACY SENTZ, ADMIN OFFICER by handing to ADULT IN CHARGE a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE together with and at the same time directing Her attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing 6.00 Service .00 Affidavit .00 Surcharge 10.00 .00 ia?vsw? 16.00 Sworn and Subscibed to before me this day of , So Answers: R. Thomas Kline 00/00/0000 By: A. D. CASE NO: 2008-06175 P SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND PALUCH JAMES A JR VS PENNSYLVANIA DEPT OF CORRECTIO GERALD WORTHINGTON , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County,Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE was served upon SnUTHRRS RICHARD the DEFENDANT , at 1550:00 HOURS, on the 29th day of October , 2008 at SCI CAMP HILL 2500 LIS13URN ROAD CAMP HILL, PA 17001-8837 by handing to STACY SENTZ, ADMIN OFFICER, ADULT IN CHARGE a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE together with and at the same time directing Her attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing 6.00 Service .00 Affidavit .00 Surcharge 10.00 /,2/0y-/o r q.,. .00- v1 l Sworn and Subscibed to before me this day of , So Answers: R. Thomas Kline 00/00/0000 By A. D. SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 2008-06175 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND PALUCH JAMES A JR VS PENNSYLVANIA DEPT OF CORRECTIO GERLAD WORTHINGTON , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County,Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE was served upon MOSLAK ZACHARY the DEFENDANT at 1555:00 HOURS, on the 29th day of October , 2008 at 55 UTLEY DRIVE CAMP HILL, PA 17011 by handing to ROBERT J VOLCIAK, ASSISTANT SUPERINTENDENT a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE together with and at the same time directing His attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing 6.00 Service .00 Affidavit .00 Surcharge 10.00 .00 16.00 Sworn and Subscibed to before me this day of So Answers: .0 R. Thomas Kline 00/00/0000 By A. D. SHERIFF'S RETURN - NOT FOUND CASE NO: 2008-06175 P COMMONTWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND PALUCH JAMES A JR VS PENNSYLVANIA DEPT OF CORRECTIO R. Thomas Kline Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff, who being duly sworn according to law, says, that he made a diligent search and inquiry for the within named DEFENDANT KELCHNER DONALD L but was unable to locate Him in his bailiwick. He therefore returns the ('nMT)T T TTTM f_ T nrr T rlV the within named DEFENDANT SCI CAMP HILL 2500 LISBURN ROAD CAMP HILL, PA 17001-8837 DEFENDANT IS RETIRED. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing 6.00 Service .00 Affidavit .00 Surcharge 10.00 00 /zIG??68 16.00 So NOT FOUND , as to KELCHNER DONALD L . -f homas Ki lne ff of Cumberland County 00/00/0000 Sworn and Subscribed to before me this day of A. D. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLMD COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA • JAXI S A. PALUCH, JR., : Plaintiff ; CIVIL ACTION s V. NOS. ; 08-6175 s PA OWT. OF CORRECTIONS, Z? AL. 9 s 410N. EDGAR I„ BAYLEY) PLAINTIFRI S MOTION TO STRIKE CORRECTIONS ?DELWANTS . PRELIMINARY OBJSCTIONS AND NOW9 comes the Plaintiff, James A. Paluch, Jr., pre se, and-pArsuant to Pa.R.Cis.Proc. Rule 1028, et al. to strike the Corrections Defendants' preliminary objections as follows: 1. This civil action at law was intiated by the Plain- tifi, James A. Palueh, Jr. ("Pltf."), a state prisoner former- ly ?oufinod in the Special Management Unit ("SMU") at the • Sta e -@orr.ectional. Institution at Camp Hill ("SCI-CanP gill" )q purist to 42 USC 111983, Pennsylvania state tort law (Pa.B. Civ? Proc. Rule 1001, et seq., and other applicable laws of the Constitutions of the United States and the Commonwealth of P sylvania. 2. The Corrections Defendants ("Defs.") include the Pe sylvania Department of Corrections ('"PA D60"), a Common- we -th carporation, bureau, and agency; as well'as employees of he PA DoC at SCI-Camp Hill. 3. On July 31, 2008, pursuant to the Prisoner's Mail- bs? Rule, the Pltf. initiated Cieil Action No. 08-4835 by and threatening Lim. Id. at paras. 36-42, 91-969 100-112, 119- 1219 126-1399 142-1521, 165-1719 209-2169 57-59• In addition, Defs. Huber and Kline confiscated Pltf.'s personal property as a means to harass him. Id. at 86-899 165-170. Personal prop- erty was not returned to Pltf. or lost or destroyed. Id. at paras. 171-177. 4. On September 23, 20089 pursuant to the Prisoner's l[ailbox Rule, the Pltf. initiated Civil Action No. 08-6175 bar fil*g a Complaint. In summary, Pltf. asserts and avers that Def. Ayers continued to verbally harass him. 08-6175 at paras. 15- 8, 20. Ayers' harassment turned to threats. Ide at paras. 19. Ayers battered the Pltf. by gripping and pushing him ex- tre ely roughly. Id. at paras. 20-21. Def. Yohn joined in on ver1 a,Iay harassisg7Pltf. Id. at para. 22. Yohn issued Pltf. a fab Bated misconduct report to Pltf. Id. at para. 25. Def. l[os ak denied Pltf, due process protections during his miscon- duc- hearing which harmed Pltf.'s liberty interests in not be- ingiconfined to disciplinary ststus in the SMU. Ian. at paras. 27-?3. Pltf. discovered that personal property was missing from hislatored property. Id. at paras. 44-50. Def. Simpson sex- ually harassed Pltf. in the presence of other SMU prisoners. Id.lat paras. 51-56. Defs. Ayers and Yohn created a danger to P1t?. to be assaulted by other prisoners when they openly spoke abo*t Pltf.' s criminal caso in an effort to incite "black" prisoners in the SMU. Id. at para. 58. 5. The PA DoC Defse have attached what appears to be a true and correct copy of Pltf.'s Complaint which is marked as Exhibit "A". For all intents and purposes, Pltf. refers to Exhibit "A" as attached to Defs.' Preliminary Objections for thin Courtfs review. 6. Pltf. is having problems comprehending what the word "demur" means as it cannot be found in the Black's Law Diction- ary because that particular page is missing. At the present, Pltf* is awaiting approval to use the facility's law library. • (2) To this extent, Pltf. is without sufficient knowledge to formu- late a belief or opinion as to how to respond to to the Defs.' demur pleadings on page two (2) of their Preliminary Objections to Plaintiff's Complaints. He is requesting the Court, if ne- cessary, to allow him an :additional thirty (30) days to compre- hend the meaning of demur to provide a more informed response. However, for purposes of the Defs.' demur Id. at para. 4 (a)- (h) Ein both 08-4835 and 08--6175, Pltf. responds as follows: (a) The PA DoC is not entitled to sovreign immunity with respect to any state law claims. To the extent { that the PA DoC Defs. are entitled to sovereign immuni- ty, it only applies to money damages.. The remaining Defs. who are persons have been sued in both their pri- vate and official capacities. To the extent that the persons named as Defs. have been sued in their private capacities, they are directly liable for any state law and tort claims; (b) The Pltfo has indeed alleged personal involve- sent on the part of all the Defs. named in the Complaints. To the extent that any "specific" involvement was inad- vertently left out of the Complaints, it is likened to minor, excusable neglect, and Pltf:'s Complaints along with their Facts and Declarations should be liberally construed as prisoner pro se pleadings for the effective litigations thereof; (c) The PA DoC is being sued in its official capacity and any supervisory Defs. are sued in both their private and official capacities. Respondeat superior is not an absolute immunity and supervisory Defs. can be held di- redly liable for either their personal involvement or when there is a sufficient casual connection between supervisor's conduct and constitutional violation, which Pltf. asserts that certain supervisory Defs. in Rltf.'s Complaints are prima facie liable for; • (d) Def. Selchner was responsible for the care, cus- (3) tody, and control of the Pltf. Selchner is being sued because he failed miserably in his legal obligations to intervene and protect the Pltf. from the ongoing harass- ment and retaliation and other forms of official oppres- sion that he was being subjected to by the S1 staff he supervises. S elchner failed to intervene and protect the Pltf. and is therefore directly liable pursuant to the Civil Rights Act as well as state law claims; (e) Def. Yoslak is not entitled to quasi-judicial immunity as a hearing examiner for the PA DoC; (f) Verbal harassment-, sexual harassment, threats, batten, loss of personal property, and being subject to receiving false misconduct reports as well as the in- tentional infliction of emotional and psychological dis- tress amounts to a "campaign of harassment" and collec- tively add up to create an overall effect that is uncon- stitutiomal; (g) The Pltf. did not receive all of the due process • protections which are guaranteed to his and to which he is entitled to in the context of a prisoner misconduct hearing proceeding as well as on appeal with respect to his liberty interests while housed in an.atypical and significant hardship (SKU) ; and, (h) The denial and loss of meal trays, personal pro- perty, legal materials, etc. does not constitute a de minimis injury in the context-of the Civil Rights Act because multiple losses in addition to the campaign of ! harassment that Pltf. was subjected to by the Defs. add up to create a single, identifiable harm. 7. Pltf. also asserts that the PA DoC Defs. have not included an affidavit verifying the statements made in their respective Preliminary Objections and Memorandums of haw for o8-4835 and 486175 which are not part of the record. Unveri- fieo statements not part of the record must be disregarded and str cken. Pltf.eraquests the Court to disregard and strike all • sta. ements made in ? the Defs.' Preliminary Objections as i (4) unverifiable and thus prejudicial to Pltf. An OBJECTION is be- ing made and preserved that ? all statements made in the PA DoC Defs.' Preliminary Objections (Id.), and those specifi- cally detailed in Pltf.'s attached supporting brief are not verified by law and Court rule (Pa.R.Civ.Proc. Rule 206.3). 8. Pursuant to law and Pa.R.Civ.Proc. Rule 1028(b), all preliminary, objections not raised by the PA DoO Defs. in bath 08-4835 and 08-6175 are deemed WAIVED. Pltf.'s Complaints and their respective Facts and Declarations are thereby deemed as une,posed and should be accepted as true by the Court and/or other factfinder. WHBRE1 VB, the Pltf. respeefully requests this Honorable Cou t to grant his Notion to Strike Corrections Defs.' Prelimi- nark Objections with respect to Civil Actions Nos. 08-4835 and 08-4175, further granting the relief Pltf. requests therein/ heroin, and enter an Order for the same. • aP E In kindness, /s/ Janes A. Paluch, Jr. James A. Paluch, Jr., Pro Be BQ-3769 SCI-Smithfield 1120 Pike Street P.O. 10ox 999 Huntingdon, PA 16652-0999 Pro Be Plaintiff Cc: ' Raymond W. Dorian, Eel. (w/encls.) (PA DoC Defs. ) Alan Gold, Esq. (w/encls.) ( Def. Barbacci) file Dated: December 319 2008 satt4ckments (5) IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OIL CUMBERLAND COUNTY 0,, PENNSYLVANIA JAMES A. PALUCK 9 J R. , Plaintiff : CIVIL ACTION' : V. NOS. 08-4835, 08-6175 (HON. EDGAR B. BAYLEY) PA OPT. OF CORRECTIONS, ET AL., Defendants PLAINTIFF'S BRIEF AND NEMORANDUK OF LAZY IN SUPPORT OF NOTION TO STRIKE CORRECTION DEFENDANTS' PWILIIMiINARYT OBJECTIONS I. STATEMENT OF THE CASH' Plaintiff, James A. Paluch, Jr. ("Pltf. ") is a state pri- senor, formerly confined at SCI-Camp Mill in the Special Manage- memj Unit ("SaMIU"), and presently confined at SCI-Smithfield in Kun?ingd n, PA. Pltf. brought this action against numerous on- plo*ees at SCI-Camp Hill pursuant to 42 USC 819639 Rule 10019 at seq of the PA R.Civ.Proc., and all laws and rights under the i Con titutions of the United States of America and the Common- we th of Pennsylvania. In Pltf.'s Complaint, he asserts and ave?s that the Defendants ("Defs. ") have violated zany righto secured to him in violation of the Civil Rights Act of 1983 as well as applicable tort laws of Pennsylvania such as the trans- gression of due precossf, retaliation, harassment, the loss: of per onal property, and other cognizable claims. Pltf. is seek- ing the Court's intervention for tke restoration of justice in the!form of commpensatory, punitive, declatory, and injunctive rel?ef"amongst other remedies available at law. II.I QUESTIONS INVOLVXD. 1. SHOULD THE COURT STRIKE THE CORRECTIONS DEPENDANTS' PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS AS BEING FRIVOLOUS FOR EACH OF THEIR STATEMENT OF ISSUES PRESENTEN Suggested, Answer: Too. 2. AS TO EACH OF TAE STATEMENT OF ISSUES PRESENTED` BY THE CORRECTIONS DEFENDANTS IN THEIR SUPPORTING ME- MORANDUM OF LAW FOR 08-4835 AND 08-6175 THE PLAIN- TIFF ANSWERS IN THE NEGATIVES III. HISTORY . • This is Pitf.'s first state civil suit since Paluck v. Beard, et al._ (Civil No. 830) was filed in Somerset County in 20079 Per Order of the Court, this responsive pleading in the ford of a Notion to Strike the Corrections Defendants' Prelim- ina4y Objections, is due on January 3, 2009, or thereabout. a This Motion (id.) is a consolidated response of lath 08- 483J and 08-6175 for all intents and purposes of good faith lit4gation of the claims therein. A third Complaint will be filed (Writ of Summons issued per Order of Court on November 14, 2009) and Pltfe will thereafter move to consolidate all three (3) civil actions to ease related difficulties. On December 18, 2008, after serving four (4) years, six (6) months, and twenty-two (22) days in solitary confinement undir official oppression of the Pennsylvania Dept. of Correc- tio*s ("PA DoC"), Pltf'. was released to general population. He has since been waiting to be placed on an approved "Call-Out" • to tilise the law library and has been denied meaningful time to prepare this Motion. Pltf. will attempt to address only the claims and issues which the Defs. raise in their Preliminary Objections as they opp?y to both 08-4835 and 08-6175 in similarity. Pltf. suffers from acute carpel tunnel syndrome and complications from what ke believes are brain-related injuries which interferes with his ability to concentrate. I V. ARGUMENT/FACTS 1. The Court should strike the PA DoC Defs.' Prelimi- nary Objections as being frivolous for each of their statement of issues presented in both 08-4835 and 08-6175. Pltf. will attopt to address the issues in the order as the PA DoC Defs. present them. A. KELCHNER/SUPERVISORY DEFENDANTS Pltfo concedes that Defs. Branni.gan and Patton . sho4d be dismissed from 08-4835. See: 08-4835 Para. 267. As (2) to Defs. Kelchner, Southers, and Kreider who act under color of . state law, Pltf. has properly alleged facts to establish a pri- ma facie that their "lack of care" towards Pltf. still readers th subject to direct liability, even if not subject to respen- dea superior. Pltf. isn't suing Kelckner for failing to pro- coo prisoner grievances or misconduct appeals as the.Defs. ab- sur y claim. For example, in Count III of 08-4835 (p• 30)9 Plt . properly raises that Kelchner violated' Pltf.'s rights by failing to preserve and protect video surveillance evidence for a misconduct hearing proceeding which would leave proved his i eence and would have substantially prevented his from losing rights and privileges he had while on Phase Two (2) ("P2") and being subject to disciplinary custody status on Phase Fire (5) ("P5") while in the SMUt an atypical and significant hardship in elation to the ordinary incidents of prison life. Kelchner had a duty to protect Pltf.'s civil rights by allowing kin to call witnesses on his behalf which Sandin v, Conner (S.Ct. 199) in support of Wolff V. McDonnell, 418 U. S. 539 (1974) was • designed to protect. Even if negligence is not cognizable under 42 USC 41983, Kel*hner is also being sued pursuant to state tort laws as pro- perly raised by the Pltf. See: 08-4835 Count III (p. 30) , 004t IT (p. 31) ; 08-6175 Count I (p. 8), and Count v (p. 12). Personal involvement is not only properly alleged in the Pltf'.'s Facts and Declarations, but more specifically in 08-4835 Paras. 247f 250, 253-54, 259, and 256; 08-6175 Paras. 66, and 77-79. The.; same., as likewise, applies to Defs. Southers and Kreider. Geitel v. PA State Board of Funeral Direct_orssp 755 A.2d 7509 755+56 (Pa. Cmmwlth. 2000)(Defs. negligent or at fault because of ?is "failure to supervise properly" his employee). The staii4ards for "negligence" can be found at Geisel at 756 f. 41, quoting, Colston v. Southeastern. PA Transp. Authority, 679 A.2d.299 (Pa. Cawlth. 1996). Pltf. has properly shown that K elchner, Southers, and Kreider were made aware of the harass- ment and retaliation he was being subjected to by SW guards i (3) and yet failed to intervene to prevent these abuses, thus in • both their private and official capacities are liable for the claims being made against them. Also, Pltf. is not an attorney and should not be held to any strict rules which require every Court rule and procedure to be followed. Requiring that the Plt4 indicate if K elchner, Southers, and Kreider were present at a time of the violations when they occurred is not wholly" nee sary because Pltf. properly asserts their involvement in the ievances (DC-804s) and misconduct (DC-141) as well as their appeals. Because the Pltf. has properly identified these documents in his Complaints, the Court should consider them as suppiorting evidence. After all, they will be considered by a fac?,findesr in determining whether or not liability exists. Pltf. asks the Court to excuse such a minor technicality, ex- cusable neglect, and in the kindness of liberal construity.. LikOwise, this should apply to any claims of the Defs. that the Plt?. doesn•t indicate how they would be aware of the actions of ?ke other Defs* which Pltf. asserts is frivolous. • B. PA DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS Pltf. is very much confused as to why or how the Defs. raised this as an issue. The Defso apparently either did not road the Complaints or are attempting to manipulate tke tru-tth-determing process of this Court. The PA DoC is being sued in its "official" capacity. (08-4835 at para. 2; 08-6175 at Tara. 2.) The remaining Defs. as persons are being sued in either their "official" and "Private" capacities, or both. In 08-4835 Counts III, IV VIII, and 08-6175 Counts I and V, Pltf. is Tither requesting punitive, declatory, or injunctive relief forwhich the PA DoC can be held accountable for. Therefore, thin issue as presented by the Defs. is frivolous. i What's more, the PA DoC as a Def. is not entitled to any Sletenth Amendment immunity. They waive such immunity because thePA DoC is a state agency which receives and accepts Federal fun4s. See: filler v. Texas Tech Univ. Health Sciences Center, • 421; F.3d 342 (C.A. 5-Tex.-2005) . The Defs. claim is frivolous. (4) C. M4SLAK/QUASI-JUDICIAL IMUNITY • The United States Supreme Court has clearly ruled in Cleavingor vI. Saxner, 106 S.Ct. 496, 474 U.S. 193 (U.S.Ind. 1965) that disciplinary hearing officers in prisons are not quash-judicial officers whom are entitled to absolute immunity. Def.':Noslak is a hearing examiner of the PA D®C and whom is em- ployed by that state agency. Moslak began his employment in the PA boC as a guard and was eventually promoted to the position of inteILligence captain whose assignment was to oversee institution see' ity. He enjoys a special relationship with the other Defs. named in these Complaints as "co-workers". Any credibility de- tersiinations Moslak makes with regards to the misconduct charges broght against i'ltf. by his fellow co-workers were all exclus- ively in favor of the SNU staff named in these Complaints. As the Supreme Court ruled, Moslak's position is rather akin to that of abi "adjudicator in the school disciplinary process" whose re- spoosibilities.were to "judge whether there have been violations of kekool regulations and, if so, the appropriate sanctions for the violations," Id, at 502, quoting, Wood v. Strickland, 420 U.S. 3081, 95 S.Ct. 992 (1975). Moslak is not licensed to practice law nor are his respon- sibiiities to decide constitutional matters for which he has no trained experience. He is not an "officer of the Court" by any meai%s and presents no evidences that he is. Moslak' s ability to serve as a prison hearing examiner cannot be equated to service upon a traditional parole board. The (parole) board is a "neu- tral; and detached" hearing body. Morrissey v. Brewer, 408 U.S. 4719! 489 (1972)• The parole board member has been described as an *partial professional serving essentially "'as an arm of'the sentencing judge.'" Cleavinger at 502, quoting, Sellars v. Pro- c er, 641 F.2d at 1302, n. 15. See also: Wolff, supra. at 561.; Cleavinger and Ponte v. Real, 471 U.S. 491 (1985) remain as precedent cases of the Supreme Court. The Defs. present no • pereiasive authority arguing otherwise. They simply try to de- (5) ceive the Court by attempting to manipulate the language of the law. Defs. are hanging on the word "hearing examiner" which is and can be a term used to for both the PA DoC and the Parole Board. Upon closer inspection, the Third Circuit cases which the Defs. rely upon are only applicable to the Parole Board, and those rulings are not extended to the PA DoC, regretably for %osl*. The Defs. merely try to persuade the Court that the PA DoC and the Parole Board are "administrative cousins," but once agait fail to present any evidence to the same. To equate that Moslak is situated very similarly to an "administrative law judge" is ridiculous. The Defs. claim that Nosl?k does not "work with the fellow employees who lodges the charge against the inmate (sic) upon whom they sit in judgment" is w?iolly debatable. Again, Moslak presents no evidence in sup- port4of his claims. Mosl ak is not entitled to quasi-judicial immu#ity by law. It has also been alleged by the Pltf. in his Complaints that Moslak had the opportunity to review valuable video evidence which would have favored the Pltf. If Moslak in- deedwas a quasi-judicial officer, he would not have relied on the unsworn second-hand testimony of Def. Kreider and since the spoliation of the video surveillance was a key factor, Pltf. more; likely than not would have been exonerated of the charges against him-. Instead, Moslak conspired with "s is co-worker (ea- Defs ) employees by choosing to disregard due process pro- tections thereby causing Pltfo to suffer the loss of privileges and being subject to atypical disciplinary status in the SMU. Xosl?k's attempts to present himself as a quasi-judicial officer is Y&o ly frivolous. D. DUB PROCESS/MISCONDUCT PROCEEDINGS Pltf., while at SCI-Camp Hill, was confined in the SMU, where the prison conditions are designed to oppress prisoners whom the PA DoC and its prison officials deem as dan- get t6, either physically or intelligently: utilizing the con trol'mechanism of solitary confinement. Prisoners in the state prison general population and the Restricted Housing Units • ("RXUs") are not subject to the atypical and significant hard- ships that the SMU presents. The SWU can best be described as a daffy-by-day assault on a prisoners' physical and mental well- bei#g. It is a place where most prisoners and guards exchange crux4 games of intimidation, threats, and violence, although the latter has a much greater force of resources to oppress the pri ' ners in their (lack of) care, custody, and control. It is a p ee where guards steal, damage, alter, destroy, and lose pris ners' personal property. It is a place that the good people of sylvania need to close down in order to reduce the danger of re "revolving door of victimization" which awaits them. The Defs. quote the Wolff case, but forgot to mention the Sandlin v. Conner case (115 S. Ct. 2293) which applies to Wolff as it 4plies to the Pltf. In this case, Pltf. was denied both his ri to call witnesses (who were of no danger or consequence to either Pltf., Moslak, or SMU staff) and to present documentary evi ce (video surveillance, etc.) in his defense. Also, as Plt i. intends to shcaw the factfinder, Moslak also failed to pro- vide! Pltf. with a written statement (or rationale) by Moslak of the evidence relied upon and the reasons for the disciplinary action. At best Moslak's rationale was ambiguous. Pursuant to the PA DoC Policy DC-ALK801, Moslak was in- deed required to determine a finding of guilt in the context of prisoner misconduct based upon a "preponderance of the evidence" (DC-iUX 801 SVI.I.1, effect. December 140 2006). Moslak' s argu mentjthat he was free to base his decision on other evidence be- sideb the video surveillance is also frivolous. The eye of the caae}a is impartial to both parties and both the Third Circuit and the PA Courts have ruled that when video surveillance is available as evidence., it is relevant, even inside the prisons. By way of further argument, the video surveillance used by *e SCI--Camp Rill facility is believed to be recorded on a digi}al video recorder system which recycles itself every five ( 7) (5) days. Def. Southers was not the only person who had access • to the video surveillance evidence being called as a witness in the respective misconduct hearing proceedings. Pltf. asserts and vers that both the Security Office and Def. B elchner had acce s as well. The misconduct hearings were either held before the five (5) day recycling period or on the fifth (5th) day be- fore it was in danger of being recycled. Moslak made no effort 01 to c ntact either the Security Office W or S elchner to ensure that the video surveillance in question 'would be preserved and downloaded onto a disc# per the Pltf.'s request at the hearinggs. P1tf also requested Selchaer to preserve the video evidence in ques ion through the use of an "Inmate's Request to Staff Member" (DC 35A) fora separately, but his request was denied. So much for a so-called uasi-judicial officer, eh Pltf. doesat t expect a fall panoply of rights to which a criminal defendant is entitled to, but he does have a constitu4 tionlal right to the basic protections and safeguards of due pro- "'I when charged with a misconduct report, esp. when he is • elai. ing actual innocence, and Moslak and his co-workers were fully aware of the consequences Pltf. would be subjected to upon a finding of guilt. Moslak, B elchner and other Defs. violated Plti,.'s due process rights, that is, by law. Therefore, Defs.' clams that they did not violate Pltf.'s due process rights is frivolous. E. HARASSMENT, THREATS, & PERSONAL PROPERTY The Defs. claim that their use of offensive and racist language towers-':him as well as other verbal taunts such as Oussing and other inappropriate: language is deainimis.' They claim that Simpson's sexual harassment of Pltf. is de minimis. They claim that the loss of Pltf.'s photographs (which he was giv4n permission to possess but did not own) is de minimis. The3t further claim that such actions do not violate the Civil Rights Act. Pltf. has been unable to research the cases that the{Defis, cite. Even if these forms of harassment, threats, and (8) loss or destruction of Pltf.'s personal property does not con- stitute a Civil Eights Act violation, they still violate the laws of the Commonwealth Qf Pennsylvania by statute and the Deft. have been sued according to tort law claims. However, Pltf. assents that the respective Defs. can be sued on a "totality of conditions" theory pursuant to the Eighth (8th) Amendment. Collectively, Pltf. has established that the Defs. have acted in a; "campaign of harassment" against him. Ewen if these viola- tioujs may not be unconstitutional on their own, they add up to create an overall effect that is unconstitutional. See: Palmer v.. J3 ohnson, 193 F. 3d 356 (5th Cir. 1999). The U. S. Supreme Gout has also recognized that multiple conditions add up to create a single, identifiable hart. Wilson v. Seiter, 501 U.S. at 3,105 (1991). Both 08-4835 and 08-6175 substantiate the "to- tal. ty of conditions" theory with precendential law. Therefore, the jDefs. claim is frivolous. e ? e V. OTHER SUPPORTING FACTS "It is not necessary that Complaint(s) identify the spe cif4c legal theory of the,.,underlying claim, but rather it must apr se the defendant of the claim being asserted and summarize the essential facts to support that claim." Grossman v. Barke, 868!A.2d 5619 568 (Pa. Super. 2005). Pltf. asserts that if azq spe ific information was not included with his legal theories in. he Complaints, it was not intentional. Interestingly, the Def . never argued as to how they were prejudiced by Pltf.'s ne4ect. The Complaints are pro se filings by a prisoner and sho?l.d be liberally construed as such., It is well known that state prisoners have a liberty in- terist protected by the Fourteenth (14th) Amendment's Due Pro- cess Clause in avoiding assignment to (a.) state's supermax pri'os, as such assignment imposes an atypical and significant kar hip on a prisoner in relation to ordinary incidents of pri?on life. See: Williamson v. Austin,, 125 S.Ct. 23849 2394 i (9) (2005). Pltf. asserts for the record and avers that if William- son applies to prisoners who may be considered for supermax placement, such as the SKU9 the ruling should also apply when prisoners housed in and under such atypical and significant harsitips are being considered in misconduct hearing and demotion proceedings since the conseWuene.m of a prisoner being sent back to P5 involves a more severe sanction than a general population or V?M prisoner would normally receive. When Pltf. lost his P2 stat#s and was sent back to P5, he just didn't suffer being sane- tion d to 60 days of disciplinary program, but an additional 180 tys in solitary confinement (minimum) since Pltf. would be also be required to serve a minimum of 60 days.on Phase Four ("PO) t 60 days on Phase Three ("P3"), and 60 days on P2 before, bei4 considered for release from the SKU. Prison officials are eing given too much authority by the Courts to abuse the unbr dled discretion in determining the fate of prisoners i^ the 01U. Without more appropriate safeguards and protections, these abuses will continue much to the detriment of not only • pris?ners, but to the staff who work in the SMU, and society. "In a 81963 action, Pltf. must prove two (2) essential elemien.tss (1) that conduct complained of was committed by per- son ,iacting under color of state law, and (2) that conduct de- priued party of rights, privileges, or immunities secured by the Constitution or laws of the U.S." Atwell v. Lavan., 2008WL822110, 200*L822110e4 (M.D.Pa. 2008), quoting, Parratt v. Taylorp 101 S. Ct. 1908 (1981) ; Kost v. Kozakiewicz, 1 F. 3d 176, 184 (3rd Cir.?l 1993). See also: Oatess v. Morris, 637 A.2d 627, 629 (Pa. Super. 1994)(seeks injunctive relief). Also: Johnston v. Leh- =an 609 A.24 880 (Pa. Cawlth. 1992)(,prisoner may properly state 819 3 claim if such discretionary decision was made by reason of prisoner's exercise of his constitutional rights). State law retaliation claims are also cognizable for cause of action and for punitive damages. Maylie v. National 8aikoad Passenger Corp.,, 601 A. 2d 308 (Pa. Super. 1991) (alle- (10) gation of systematic retaliation constitutes "prima facie tort" in state court). See also: Field v. Phila. Elea* Co., 565 A.2d 1170 (Pa. Super.)(ye.ar unknown). Preliminary objections should only be sustained when it is certain that the law will not permit recovery. Harris t. Nit 747 A. 2d 1251 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2000). When ruling upon preliminary objections in, the nature of a de*urrer, the Court must accept as true all well-pleaded alle- gations of material fact as well as all reasonable inferences dedu6Cible therefrom. Yount v. PA DoC, 886 A.2d 1163, 1167 (Pa. Cmwl?h. 2005). Personal injury Pltfs. have right to file preliminary ob- ject?ons raising any appropriate defense or objections Pltfo may haverjhad to Defs.' preliminary objections. Ambrose v. Cross. MrS4 Condominiums, 602 A.2d 864, 866 (Pa. Super. 1992); Gale v. Were Catholic Medical Center Ba_stwick, Inc. Fitzgerald Mercy LV. 698 .2d 647, 649 (Pa. Super. .19 _A_merican Fume SYs- tens, Inc.. vim, 872 A.2d 12029 1215 (Pa. Super. 2005). "Supervisor may be held liable under §1983 only upon shoving either that supervisor personally was involved in con- stitutional violation or that there is sufficient casual connec- tia2l between supervisor's conduct and constitutional violation." Bveiit v. DBTNTIF'F, 330 F. 3d 681, 689 (C.A..5-Tex.-2003) , quoting, Tholppkkins v. Belt, 828 F.2d 298, 303-04 (5th Cir. 1987). (Em- phais nine.) Pltf. has established a prima facie for both a Civil Rights Act and state tort law violation with regard to Def. Kelchner, Southers, and Kreider and will further be sub- sta4tiated through discovery proceedings, should the Court allow. Pltf. also OBJECTS to the PA DoC Defs.' failure to verify fa0s that are not part of the record. No affidavit is attached to ihe preliminary objections asserting that statements were mad4 under penalty of perjury, thus they are unverified and must be Otricken. Fltf. requests that the Court all statements made in heir preliminary objections to 08-4835 and 08-6175, but • (11) fically and especially in their Supporting Memorandum of s follows: A. 0,_.8-_4835.. 1. "As a Department hearing examiner, Def. Moslak's position is relatively independent and impartial...". (p. 5); 2. "In this case, the Department's hearing examiners are not part-time adjudicators and they do not hold any other positions." (p. 7) ; 3. "While (hearing examiners) are employees of the (PA) DoC, their sole right function is to hear testimony and ad- judicate inmate disciplinary charges." (p. 7) ; 4• "(Hearing examiners) are not subordinates of the Sup4rintendent of the institution. Rather, they report to the Chiof Hearing Examiner in Camp Hill." (P. 7); 50 "(Hearing examiners) (Moslak) do not (does not) 'work with the fellow employee who lodges the charge against the inmate (sic) upon whom they sit. in Judgnent.011 (P. 7); ?. "Pennsylvania's hearing examiners are "profession- al hearing officers' and are situated very similarly to admini- strative law judges." (p. 7); "...hearing examiners perform a similar function 70 to that of their administrative cousins on the Board of Probation and Parole." (p. 7) ; 8. "Further, a finding of guilt in the context of an inmate (sic) misconduct need not be based on a preponderance of theevidence, but merely on some evidence." (p. 8); and, 9. "...Moslak is free to base his decisions on the misconduct reports or any other evidence, so as long as there is som6 evidence to support his findings of guilt." (p. 9). B. 08-6175 1. "Yoslak is immune from suit with respect to any decision he made in the context of an inmate (sic) misconduct hearing." (p. 6) ; 2. (same as Sec. V.A.l above) (p. 6) ; (12) • 3. "In this case, the Departments hearing examiners are not part-time adjudicators and they do not hold any other posit ions." (p. 7) ; 4. (same as Sec. V. A. 3 above) (p. 7) ; 5. (same as Sec. V.A.4 above) (p. 7) ; 6. (same as Sec. V. A. 5 above) (p. 7-8) ; 7. (same as Sec. V. A.6 above) (p. 8) ; 8. (same as Sec, Y.A.7 above) (P• 8) ; 9. (same as Sec. V. A. 8 above) (p. 9) ; and, 10. (same as Sec. V. A. 9 above) (p. 9). Since none of these statements are go included as part of t?e record, an affidavit asserting that these statements must be Bade under penalty of perjury. Qallman v. Martin., 889 A.2d 6499i652 (Pa. Cawlth. 2005). (Defs. need a verification for facts that do not appear in the record). The PA DoC Defs. have also waived their preliminary ob- jections to any claims, issues, facts, and declarations made by • the?Pltf. in his Complainta which were not properly raised in botls their Preliminary Objections and Memorandum of Law. Be- caule Pltf, verified the Facts and Declarations of both 08-4835 and 08-6175 the Court should accept then as being true. I VI. VSB.I FI CATION Pltf. verifies that all statements, facts, and informa- tio> contained herein are both true and correct to the best of his knowledge and that any falsehooda may subject me to the d pene?lties for perjury, pursuant to 18 Pa. C. S. 04904 concerning "unoworn falsification to authorities". VII« CONCLUSION WSMBMFORB, for all the above reasons, Pltf. respectfully re"osts this Honorable Court to grant his Motion to Strike the Cor*ections' Defendants' Preliminary Objections, and enter an Order for the same. (13) .7 • C7 Dat.0: December 31, 2008 a tta?Clsment s cc: I maymond W. Alas Gold, fil e In kindness, ? 65 qQlal /s/ James A. Paluch, Jr. James A. Paluch, BQ-3769 SCI-Sa:ithfi eld 1120 Pike Street P.O. Box 999 Huntingdon, PA Dorian, Esq. (w/encls.) (PA D©C Defs. ) Esq. (w/encls.) ( Def. Barbacci) (14) Jr., Pro Se 16652-0999 . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OT CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA JAMES A. PALUCH, JR., Plaintiff CIVIL ACTION s V. (NOS. 08-4835 & 08-6175) PA DOT. OF CORRECTIONS, ET AL. 9 (HON. EDGAR B. BAYLB?) Defendants a j PLAINTIFF'S VERIFICATION FOR MOTION AND SUPPORTING BRIEF TO STRIKE CORRECTIONS DEP'ENDANTS' PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS I, James A. Paluch, Jr., being the Plaintiff, do hereby veri'y that all statements, facts, and information contained'in the Itforenentioned and attached documents are both true and cor- rect; to the best of -my knowledge; that I an, due to my indigency, unab} a to attach any documents in support of the aforementioned. and attached documents unless the Court provides me an alterna- tiv? means to; and that any falsehoods may subject me to the Zp ties for perjury, pursuant to 18 Pa.C.S. 84904 concerning lnworn falsification to authorities". So verified, on this 31st day of December 2008, in the City of Huntingdon, Huntingdon County, Pennsylvania, as executed ley: i /s/ James A. Paluch, Jr. Jam s A. Paluch, Jr. BQ- 769 SCI-Saithfield 112 Pike Street, P.O. Box 999 Hun ingdon, PA 16652-0999 ProlSe Plaintiff at4chments cc:! Raymond W. Dorian, Esq. (w/encls.) (PA DoC Defs. ) Alan Gold, Esq. (w/encls.) ( Def. Barbacci) file 0 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE • I. Janes A. Paluch, Jr., hereby certify that I an this 31st day of December 2008, pursuant to the Prisoner's'Mailbox Rule (Thomas v. Slash, 781 A.2d 170, 176 (Pa.Super. 2001) and _Beic#ard-Copestakes, 925 A.2d 8749 875 (Pa.Super. 2007), depos- itink into the prison mailbox, via first-class postage prepaid mails the following legal documents with the Cumberland County Protonotary, to the persons so named below: Plaintiff's Praecipe for Signature Authorization; Plain- tiff a Answer and Motion to Strike Def. Blarbacci's New Matter; Plai?itiff's Motion to Strike Corrections Defendarnts* Preliminary Abje''p?tions with Brief and Memorandum of Law; Proposed Orders; and Yerifi4at on. Raymond W. Dorian, Esq. Alan Gold, Esq. Asst. Counsel - PA DoC Gold & Ferrante, P.C. 55 Utley Drive 261 Old York Road Camp Hill, PA 17011-8028 Suite 526 Jenkintown, PA 19046 In kindness, • /s/ James A. Paluch, Jr. James A. Paluch, Jr. BQ-3769 SCI-Smithfield 1120 Pike Street P.O. Box 999 Huntingdon, PA 16652-0999 cc: R. Dorian, Esq. (w/encls) (PA DoC Defs. ) A. Gold, Esq. (w/encls) ( Def. Barbacci) fil e E e? r? cz-n IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF f 1 • MBEBLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA JANES A. PALUCH, JR. , Plaintiff CIVIL ACTION V. ; NOS. _ 013-6175 s PA DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, ET AL, : (HON. EDGAR B. BAYLEY) Defendants PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR ENLARGEMENT Or TIRE . TO FILE SUPPORTING DOCOYENTS AND NOW, comes the Plaintiff, James A. Paluch, Jr., pro se, and moves the Court pursuant to Pa.R.CiV.Proc. Rule 248, re- questing an extension of time to file photocopies of documents in support of his Answer and Motion to Strike Def. Barbacci's New Matter as well as his Motion to Strike Corrections Defs.' Preliminary Objections, and presents the following in support thereof: 1. Pltf. filed 08-4835 and 08-6175 pursuant to 42 USC 61983, Pa.R. Civ.Proc. Rule 1001, st seq. for state tort claims, and the U.S. and Pennsylvania Constitutions and their laws. 2. Pltf. is a former state prisoner confined in the Special Management Unit in SCI-Camp Rill. Pltf. is now confined in SCI-Smithfield. The PA DoC Defs. are both a PA state bureau and agency; the remaining Defs. are persons employed at SCI- Camp Hill. 3. By order of this Court dated November 3, 2008, Pltf. was granted sixty (60) days to file his response to Defs.' pre- liminary objections in the Judge's Chambers (Hon. Bsyley). 4. Pltf. was released from long-term solitary confinement on Deeember.18, 2008. No has attempted to secure photocopiers of legal exhibits is support of his Answer and Motion to Strike Def. Darbacci' s Now latter as well as his Motion to Strike Corrections Defs.' Preliminary Objections to no avail. For example, Pltf. wanted to attack a copy of !the Sheriff's Return, a grievance ford, etc. 5. Pltf. is uncertain of whether supporting documents are absolutely necessary, but if so, at the discretion of the Court, Pltf. requests ?fifte*n (15) days to make photocopies and file then with this Court in support of the aforementioned Motions. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF • CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA J AM?S A. PALUCH, J R. , Plaintiff CIVIL ACTION. V. : NOS. 08-6175 s PA DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, ET AL, (HON. EDGAR B. BAYLEY) s Defendants. PLAINTIFF'S AFFIDAVIT OF INCAPACITY Plaintiff, Janes A. Paluch, Jr., hereby declares and re- pre?exts that he: 1. Made several attempts to secure photocopies of sup- porliug documents for both his Answer and Motion to Strife De- feniant Barbacci•s New Matter as well as Motion to Strike Cor- reciians Defendants, Preliminary Objections with accompanying Brief and Memorandum of Law from the facility library; and, 20 That the facility library to date has denied his re- pealed requests to use the leisure library for photocopies; and, • 3. That he has been waiting to be approved to be placed on scheduled Call-Out to utilize the facility's main law li- brazty for photocopies to no avail; and, 4. That the facility, as of the morning of December 31, 2000, has been under an "emergency lockdown," further incapaci- tating the Plaintiff from securing photocopies of his supporting do eUments. This affidavit is both true and correct to the best of Pl tiff's knowledge, subject to penalty.of perjury for any fal ehoodi, pursuant to 18 Pa$.C.S. 84904, concerning "unsworn i t C7/ IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA J AMTS A. PALUCH, JR., Plaintiff : CIVIL ACTION V. ; i Nos. ?- 08-61759 & PA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, ET ?., ; (HON. EDGAR B. BAYLEY) Defendants PLAINTIFF'S PRAECIPE FOR NOTICE OP CHANGE OF ADDRESS, TO ITHE PROTHONOTARY OF THIS COURT; I, James A. Paluch, Jr., being the Plaintiff in the abode captioned matter concerning Civil Actions Nos. 08-4835, 08-Z759 and 08-6588, hereby notify this Honorable Court of mar new change of address from SCI-Fayette, 50 Overlook Drive, La- Bel, e, PA 15450-1050 to the following: James A. Paluch, Jrc BQ-3769 = SCI-Smithfield 1120 Pike Street P. o. Box 999 Huntingdon, PA 16652 Be advised that when the Court communicates with the Plaintiff, the Court ]MST' mark the outside of the envelope "Legal Mail" to ensure that it is treated as privileged com mun;i.cation. Thank you for respecting my privacy. Counsel for the Defendants have been advised of the new c*ge of address under separate cover. Thank you for your asg I istance in this matter. i In kindness, 44& 14.1 #7 /s/ James A. Paluch, Jr. James A. Paluch, Jr., Pro Se BQ-3769 SCI-Smithfield 1120 Pike Street Dated: December 299 2008 Huntingdon PA 16652-0999 c c:1 file ;rva9 j" 7 Pry yDp' JAMES A. PALUCH, JR., PLAINTIFF V. PA. DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND NOW, this defendants, ARE SUST AIM' es Paluch, Jr., BQ 3 SCI Smithfield 1120 Pike Street Huntingdon, PA 16652-1 aymond W. Dorian, Es, For Defendants IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA 08-6175 CIVIL TERM TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT ORDER OF COURT day of April, 2009, the preliminary objections of all :D. The complaint against all defendants, IS DISMISSED. Pro se By th u Edgar B. ley J. ,D 0 :sal =ILI 0 °' V JAMES A. PALUCH, JR., PLAINTIFF V. PA. DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, ET AL., DEFENDANTS Bayley, April 9, 2009:-- Plaintiff, James A. Pennsylvania Department defendants, PA Departme Correctional Institution at Southers, Unit Manager, Mark Simpson, Adam Officers, and Zachary Mos complaint can be summE was later found guilty of Examiner Moslak denied ' Paragraphs 25-38. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA 08-6175 CIVIL TERM TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT luch, Jr., an inmate under the jurisdiction of the Corrections, instituted this civil rights action against of Corrections, and the following employees at the State mp Hill: Donald L. Kelchner, Superintendent, Richard Bert Kreider, Lieutenant and Supervisory Administrator, , Eric Kline, Matthew Yohn and Edward Ayers, Correction k, Hearing Examiner. The allegations in plaintiff's as follows. He was issued a false misconduct report and of the charges by Hearing Examiner Moslak.' Hearing due process in connection with a misconduct hearing.2 2 Paragraphs 27, 31, 41, 42 and 61. 08-6175 CIVIL TERM Yohn and Ayers have yelled, sworn and threatened him.3 Ayers once took plaintiff's handcuffs and "spitefully pulled them up causing him to experience physical pain and red marks on his wrists."4 yers once "gripped and pushed him extremely roughly" while he was attempting t go to yard,5 and Ayers once denied him a meal.' Kline and Huber confiscated three o his photographs depicting "two young adult females kissing and performing cunnilingu on each other."' Simpson made sexual noises and caressed his hands during a strip search of his cell.8 Kelchner, Southers and Kreider failed to protect him from this alleged abuse committed by the other defendants. The complaint against the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections must be dismissed because it is no a person subject to suit under the Civil Rights Act. Warren v. Pennsylvania Department of Corrections, 616 A.2d 140 (Pa. Commw. 1992). The complaint against Kelchne , Southers and Kreider must be dismissed because the allegations against them a based solely on their supervisory capacity. The doctrine of respondeat superior does of apply to causes of action brought for a violation of civil rights. Wilson v. Horn, 97 F.Supp. 943 (E.D. Pa. 1997), aff d 142 F.2d 430 (3d Cir. s Paragraphs 15, 16, 17, 1 ? and 22. 4 Paragraph 18. 5 Paragraph 20. 8 Paragraph 58. ' Paragraphs 44-50. 8 Paragraphs 52-56. -2- • 08-6175 CIVIL TERM 1998). The complaint against the Hearing Examiner Moslak must be dismissed because he has immunity in the performance of his adjudicative duties. Harper v. Jeffries, 808 F.2d 281 (31. Cir. 1986). A civil rights action is not a forum to relitigate the validity of misconduct Deports. The allegations set forth in the complaint whereby plaintiff alleges that correction officers Yohn and Ayers yelled and swore and threatened him do not give rise to a cognizable claim of violati n of civil rights. Wilson v. Horn, supra. The allegations against Ayers regarding his once using handcuffs causing him pain and red marks, and pushing him extremely roughly on one occasion, and denying him a meal on one occasion do not give rise t a cognizable civil rights action. Hudson v. McMillian, 503 U.S. 1 (1992). These alle ations are legally de minimis. Id. Nor does the allegation against Simpson involving exual noises and caressing his hands. Id. We are not prepare to say that there is a cognizable civil right action against Kline and Huber based on heir confiscation of three photographs depicting two young adult females kissing and AND NOW, this defendants, ARE SUST erforming cunnilingus on each other. ORDER OF COURT day of April, 2009, the preliminary objections of all IED. The complaint against all defendants, ISMISSED. By the o t Edgar B. ay ley, J. -3- 08-6175 CIVIL TERM James Paluch, Jr., BQ 37 9, Pro se SCI Smithfield 1120 Pike Street Huntingdon, PA 16652-0999 Raymond W. Dorian, Esquire For Defendants :sal -4- A i 7 ,- ALED- f .i E '-A ?HE PIROMI! CNOWY 2010 MAR -4 R« 4: 20 Buell, David D. Prothonotary Cumberland County Courthouse 1 Courthouse Square Carlisle, PA 17013 - - - - -- ---- ---------- AOPC 1013 Rev.03/03/2010 6uperfor Court of flenn-5ptbania Karen Reid Bramblett, Esq. Middle District Prothonotary Milan K. Mrkobrad, Esq. Deputy Prothonotary March 3, 2010 RE: Paluch v. PaDoc No. 9 MDM 2010 Trial Court Docket No: CV-4835 and CV-6175 Dear James Paluch Pennsylvania Judicial Center P.O. Box 62435 601 Commonwealth Avenue, Suite 1600 Harrisburg, PA 17106-2435 (717) 772-1294 www. superior. court. state. Pa. us Enclosed please find a copy of an order dated March 3, 2010 entered in the above-captioned matter. Respectfully, C: ??< cu?? Milan K. Mrkobrad, Esq. Deputy Prothonotary /tp Enclosure cc: The Honorable Edgar B. Bayley, President Judge Buell, David D., Prothonotary Raymond W. Dorian, Esq. James Paluch . V. Pennsylvania Dept. of Corrections ORDER IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA (C.P. Cumberland County Nos. CV-4835; CV-6175) No. 9 MDM 2010 Filed: March ? d , 2010 Petitioner has filed an application for relief in this Court describing (without documentation) his attempts to file a notice of appeal from the dismissal orders of April 16, 2009. Petitioner asserts that the trial court refused to docket his notice of appeal and returned that document to him un-filed. Petitioner's application for relief is GRANTED to the following extent: To the extent the petitioner has been attempting to file a notice of appeal, the trial court is DIRECTED to accept and docket such document if submitted to the Cumberland County prothonotary for filing. The trial court shall then transmit any such notice of appeal to this Court, which will ultimately make a determination as to the validity of the appeal. See Pa.R.A.P. 902. Per Curiam 7 ?j H.-ate , 7'q _r Grr, -%, ?/N ?fE 6OU4T O? e.©/Ylra?JON PGE/fs FC74 /- ; / T/0 1,1 1R 1J0 i ,c L U Al B E2 L 4 i?%b G'0 U?1Ty/ l?E Ns?S?/L VA IU-r,4 /VOJA// GO:v;F.sl'LR1,-Jrl r'J ?i1 s ?i1?ucJJ, TR.,'?'i°GTf, " . P/ n. -SF_ ; l'G(/ suA O >rJ/F /CR L ?'.S' i C(T? > P /'1l//l. 1?n/b h'PGc L.I_A : ?c OnCjC?, ?' 1L.F_S / 7`F;flJ?f'/?L/: /1/AC y/FcZT OF 1:9 L//- /X ST J?? F,O6f,- 7'H rI/i)eA,,6 +.rF_.A17S/ GJ?li ?:n u, ff; C s4 /.;7 /J E.T 5'?1?, /:ff nr?f'. 6?lT zJN1J?C. -7-1 /-7- (woi?.v r/ 1A1T£,c, VzF /7-/eJn/ YOB %-'/ , c TO ?gLy i-FA4.SUa?Q '%?i?iJ'GH ?J t?G'/J ci?L?k' A ?r BTC -? T!!? / /',J1!/7C?' L r !//S CO.?.C/SCx7Tct Ft.?D ti%Gk? . ?%?C?.,???{CTJ"V!-Lc?'f;'L L'/ZGF?/'r`/,??, /?.^-?lJ f'/FSF_NT_si/-tG rOLLOC.?In/(r /r?.S/iF'/-Ali' °/rJ T Ji .fir' 0/<' !!i _ .CUs _S /JF T Z ,A4.77, 77 E 7) ;X _ L PL- «v c?UU 1 a Sf',Ec/IL ,? l J c F/ SON= _ O4'/r? _ , />; /,ff'/''l?JJT/C-?i?/T ?';'J1Yir.t' ??/,'/JTI ?OGS=Q t . PL ?F, CJli/i)f'i.F?Ji??.e9 ;>F ?fiJF!UUS GJVi1-. /?i C"G!.icTi. /G/.!'7L /Z/?=//7? V/D,L ?T/UN-` i/V/L :/CL{TS Coln A4 / n?:rdTi'OlIr /rJt'n / S-.art FGCy<ES <1T C/,4';-7 .SO AIWIn4o yS..4 ;1Ci=crJli,vJ?/ ;A,? /<<?lSi:?`.?1??'3yC-?_' e CJr Pk`!_SG?rJ f/tJ;[. T ? S?:r??!CES., //'f,.' ,`is /,t;?,kJ.?5T 1/'.E = :? UrSC'. / Ef'Jl` iJ%(r !; [- ;7 1! T T??F j'L7 %,OL'.:???5,_ 'GEp ?'?<i Jr?JJ?/?1`' y U/3? ce r/0 r W 7,q T/f _G L k n :G c TF. f- mF/ 7 -4 Tri[ c^Cl-?AT ss'. ,T?- 'S J /?Ui JC.? 1_' j j' - t)" /-. / / /? ? / / f?FlrpL 1V.'%.1,.?L /.... T//:?dVv ?l/?.?'?.? /'?cf ?'?.'i`/C/? L. _?7 ./?.i r?l/i'? .? /?/? lJ dC??J aL. >C .5...4%' /t/ : %-f l i/ !•; L' -i . C i ; 1? f y? '?. ' S ?v!? 7'1 ',E O /= /? /f C /h L ?1; G ?'Gd G / G / U G! S - yr -- - - _>,a f _s_.. c. ___, . _t/ _ r_.: z 6J? _"u F= /•. /,-?!? Fs Z; h> r -/z r',i I_ GrJG G_" /fF .>71Y /,):3 h :f,'?f.! /71? ?-jG?'?K ?'i?P?/Oi7'IS /.9? ?.. _. • '? ?r`rR:i i!-//{ > 'yC JCgf sE f'-/r'J.A? -T64Z 5 + ?.'t9°7r J?`U..:n,y /<.%;?'c/Yli ,r ?'. f'//'/Tr!??.cf ,'?-. /?G L '!' /Y'•:; \..r'%/i J?f'Tr?/,?i %0 C.u fL!J?1JC/ j%J V. ' XZ- 7T (7121 prt?C ??N ./J f/? 1//77 IAA-5'7`1 i UTJQ/ /.. ?'`_.;Fr:., % ? r?i:cS??',`G. !n1CJ7 Z?.;r-!"•vTc /J?/ Tits Sr'f'T.= "'l.< -.: O 1.. .+ ?1. a• 'Y_ }T ?JV JTKJ=/F_ti%U i,? *:r `?/NGtjCJJJ Jam,4 ;7 7o Hr ' / N '', ?''a?.SU/-,'J?f` TO f^/ ?1GC ,F'G?LL/?% ?J'? fi !- i<. i"UA,'AL INf^('`?EJI %?Y>,. .?L Ti=. !S (711,x:. ?/ :?? T.??? _ '? Ci'n,r? i ' G_SS/OJ/ L/' Tll ,'O //f f GDi CS v^F ?c "SD ! /%2GPF_ CT u?AJ/ ,E /A/ t'E/JE?AL Ot'<rLFtT1G/? rs1F//i.L 'Gr.?/ ?1) %C %1?E C:; Tr J?Tcil iru /?/n/(r v'NI.- ?"f J/u")f_f?t%? /S Oti/t y t' ) ? of F'F.t'SOn!gL FND?E/27y /T?r,7.?; ? X;'E_SE ,?CTJ v% ._,!'C/JL •"Y /rTEP, J,qL s J FLT/ ff T Ti-//- t' 0 Al-l 717-1-, /r /ec y^ OE n16- %" /?9 YE R Cc'e JS 7'J T^/ES"E / uG { S, IJE.I; Cqr, ?x?? / ?6 TF. r}{/S"S r•?.eS l?r?oi'F?-? JaS A ??:-E/r?,v/,JT. 'T i'J,4'?.= !i!'C,E?S /-!/S""" LE"_°i;G J7'/?.;?=",?'/%r1.? „?! ,L/.f r=.HSc= /%i.?'z? .'-r .:?'J? y^rr07? S/='E :J'!:: D/lTc'S. ? ARE PG A' I - O IV 7-0 _ -rOPf7 E. :L--X?f 4=-S5 LCFf-j 1- Jar 7-Zl(-l',7Z j,* C -,/V im 0 /J?/1CT/vr e E CG?f' /- ]?. 2/J JaCtJ? ,G,I .t t4-1 -Z 009, -S`Jil c ?,?J:;,JG'R7EG ?ctJp ('? J c i) E.S'- Cj/-' 4CC7-/ Ve? ? X- r ;y rio ' L'bUF•'.[i r'!' YitlJCJ JI/_?[-.c:A.S? (i/?r L/.%717, ?. /? /? ?/?!?'I ?.SS F[ /.r G_4,("/? l{?j.r-Rr./l??ti'`_.??,/-Y'?Gf1J..: ?°:'tsl/L../fit.: _.., /}L TF ?! t1.E A Ttt?!t L jt r bTIGE Gf' RFF ESL ?bfrl Tfr'! D/Srr. 1"SS,4 OAZ J' ,?5RS OF f?OS Q Q L..;r O . ry.J/,/0 t ? f?cTURti/EL u? C#Fp?/?Z. TL "J-?G7F, G''r?/F/Gft1 LEC4uS.6"f{/T 17fPc'AL ct/ S rl,!i tEO /n/ ' `?,0 _S4EPAR-9Tf ?NV?dGJPS ?1/ of Tk-4ctC/f /;iF,/L£[? f7T TL/F .S •4mE /Z?? t? r_ L% yt rf -? ! , Iqi[ <G %fi E 7'11,E 17//461...7 6 C',orf TU t'L rF- ffrn -Es<l?rG? y L y Cr - `L rF: j? -fr J/? lc?i,4-6h-7773 /va JC 6 , ti / ( A 4 1116L) " ,, {? r Urnrj /r 4/ rrtf0 SF_Pn/4xTc' t??/VC-LdF?$ frr Tir`E >lrty7c '/Iki?• 1 D,"r'/-/l7N0 c ._ s A /4 C c / FTuP r /-f .._. 7'/ < IN1071di- c. r- it r r upJG/L E b - ?r 7-F/f?T Tj{: /1R .Sr?P6+?JOh° /??o T f/Dn/U Tr!R? .G?/rFS ?Fus/NC,- ??l F/L E /? /S Ivry i /?L I ?= F l/G--Z ' /- 7-0 _ Cocm,T it 71-1,q7- TsfE P!r'r'tNL jS .L>Gc/:iLu ,-11_ED ?1N'T /c. J (G y;?xr l,G/r h:r aR'/ rtt ,SO.L v .,D ? 7 Id ^, vr_SL41 F' ?6C .IJ FS, '/-?F?7 J f it G y , 1' !,' N' U15TF z? TJUIlS, TU Sk K J c Tti` m ; ca JJ /rn ,- vl 7"! 6 i r , cNQ.icriDtlS -o l` _,"'c,5-filJ7lC. 7W,4 '77 /-//S 'O 7-/C e G = /} Oi rim /. A%G_? r G , 5 fif - L• ) L.? _ 5 t r,,G ?/ 14 1 ? ! du/7?r?+ s ?Gax.7 PI-71! r t / r7 ??!?/L !?/CL >? 7f!__n f.%-r-Gi v. /: <tCr* j / .?. 6-l : S. l? . ? . ! 1,4 l Li , r) ! S T. 0 a-° PA =I ; _. ,.1 .. L /?S-/ -II /La ?1\ ! t/vt / ur-h ?r ?. U. t I-L '? L :fj `? ! F.. .? , ' kC:,c:..iS r r--,}? /r' /:' J,'C, ??, . I, :...C .: LCti?/ t.G ?'?/ _ r r.. ,'1 .=4•/? ` 2f' -,[ i ,? , !:`....• 7" ?r.?7 :e., (? `/-//C. r` -T..=/c C,;2 Lu ;/OJ? ?f 7-AG /A/dr_-AJTO /6b STGX" I) .EY °_? _. L?c?fi 's J?f h'7-)/ 0/? 7.7 :1/. f, /11 a r, r.w77 /-:rtu? A r . ----.4L.Lt,r,u </-/Tlr J!!%F.:'L7-_ Y'.--?, .?- ,-? _.,-?rf? r-,',' .-.,S6.h.'-S.T? ENScreZ,w ?Tr/yp7- -,"q /.,E j _r,- - • H 1-5 f h ! i' 'Qt'1C/ trNB .GJ L/'Otlc U ril1?1? Lr A. : . r ? t! ".? :? _. _ V r" ?.?•....-...?. ! A ..: ?,C _ fJ j" S % fi L . t'-r?J /C E. J fY ..`?. y L.? U .FJ-!?t t_ 'U /`. = i ..? /C t?l GlE S'j T U /%fUt///??I + Ity; (tl,7Ff t?1 yhL i iFr G,?' J CF+rcG /7/r: S r 777F ;?7 /- ?LCI ( uIJXC_ J p i Z 0 % 1 ? f ,? L ..> J L.. ir t . . v ? :1 /-? T ^{ !/ !- f' ; i ::. i i r (?' ?!l J / ` ! ??- /•.. = i /-? ?: i L? Ll n. , _5 44 j = >7 LA 7- 7) .. , 77,77/-0? 4 T s z-? ?F ?/? 1 j.Y 7, D hrJ? .? f-ioL.l, .? !,/,;J: j .71c lr?./ ,.F_ T ?iu?:-1' rUr. J i?f- D I.'-i?'` f'.:r;'r•',1.Sr_ 1rr/ir /? 'fj•? tc. - ._ ... r; ? - ,-,c-tck=/-rcco a? cuc-G.6, 7-l G Gr,< r?s :j</li?c !4: l5f c o,.= /'Z.?F,!s 4. e6 7-11ir47'c' ?rR1ZV,4,,i"=S F rk- 41 Lo s ??fcIPf CCJG<RT Etc/ ESC-D ?iN RD /i' 7SJ/ /,lJ /a. o;o / _1-L 7rz. ` S All-rle- ©E-' Ira 14 ? -UF" /?C7 d 8 ° f ? JS IT n I.' .'- S a . i? t' ? //? r?/J ?7z,CG1? :.3;..'+ . EGi. C'/CCr?l;: T /c5 «-Rbr,l /'? (? / ,2 GO y, <7', OP? Crf !J/ ?'Ji0r 1047- . W4-5 47 5 OATcc? TD _.5 -r 5 A!'q 1-14IrrK'lnl? IlOGM, SSG . (.?LJ / 7,6 , ?/f ?? rr ?f.J%; . I `' :ic/cf,' C -T i-t Ft? -.S? iS .? a i!t?G Trf'C ..`cAG.S v;.'kc' Sr'G¢NL7 '?/.li /Y?-h:'F',fi?• Gtr t/!'•.C.-i' /Nif ENTOQ y/ 94w7' X q %/VS r' I L i ST / Al i/f 1V ?G /Q ? fY / Z a A2 11 1 WNl?H ?f ?7 - !?DE? Ar/ !J?(:f3EIl7 /i? w1vICr1 l L '"F .? T TF/?t!}TED 7-0 ,A?E7 I EL/ G ors ti: S S/f)- A / 07iG' 0A 4 P/ ?ItL 5- ?Ca 0J-.' ? 3 ? Anl- O `? / / =¢ s I$ ;?/oG?L`U?"P, T`ii {yDx r r?RkrD ''SrJ?TE'! LVIllaH ?on/"l<7/NS TIDE CFISE? Fall /vl?S/ ?, _?» _.,.- . ?... :: • ?„?, ?-- y:?iD" f! °:G "! J _ 1,t.?/[: ?/ wA 5 -/? L ?` ?<ibY AP.EidE.1l' , T /_:' ?vrlS C.?P?Y,_ ? ?/% ??? ?.? n J ?+ ?f. O .FGy/? rr."/,?F?'C'Ff /+J/ ?'CO/D. %/iE TJ?7P.? SL-,trLS ??.::k r= ??Ol?r"?.° L /?jGln/ ?! ? ,1 , s/?? Uf L0577, ;%IE LoI2?' OF Z- r/--, "S i)<?uclrt; n/; u'??cc K??/Y)G?/?L Rf? /l' . / _ - ? ' - ' I ` < i; ?. J f _ .. l. L ? r7 • - u i,:_, /! / ' %O c (._ /- /r`f ?O X ? ; r= 7"<f //? ! '- U r- ? C ULI D /!G i ?ou?lD. HEM F'cJ S? P4 Ti , sG4Eti?EO Jon ?' f ?''? %t' U u Ear ?' G;= H/S F'E,E Y', GC•A4 ? E?? STu/:'?G f'/?.Gr°c% ?.1' rG? LvJ.+??s? /?., ? "r" !S" fit//1>c.?1- Y t ?^ ( r /r j? .,-.? 1 //?, ,l,?,.. / -'lr ?/( , f`/ IL- .?.'./". !._7 ?•a ^/?GN.G..l /r NIA SL: VA4C 4 6IE 4:`?t/ EFIc E, f'L'TF. J3" JTOrcc?J EX- -5S L?=r. "Wuf' a'TI?-sL'O/VTf? ? lr`, C.n/Fll? NT1L?,L-.- . /Jl'Nc fr -L'=LrLnl1--['..G:V7iYrLCI`/ri.h /Cti/ ,/, -)•CJ?-,.-.''-?L/?../J., Lt/c7,E>.K f'/c'C'L'uL.J? j-'?:,USc ?t/Gr',?, rL'L'% `- U7/CAI E,6 it/_`.". /A !!>'IC !,!r5?j /f [J "7-0 in -,,c 11 .t/G 7,0 OF.'.f ?G FC'C' -,WJS -3-r G /.?`S /ir/i.? , L,/-Drte/ GT. .. 7?0 !/`/v'L?3?'? ? G/: ?.` ?" /.? _ 1 ?. j.! / L r?' y? /i fv ? ?? --. -' r /i ,G ?'?„ i ?N` ii-r ? ' /Y.- ? / /C•f f r _ i? x.? r'? _ _ _ '-?C 6, a J 7!{c U, .;,r>; v'clL c=c /14 ??t (> /?f_!!%r1J rLTI=,':s o"v7077ON rr7/ SSE O f! tiF?GRL Ji? %>? tui ON (SLJFr'A ;i.9 cFDu/vvj?: ) G° ECON- '/ /? +- /• .fJ 7' / ?1 LU i 7' ,y ,;.! L U v , L ? O N r?: f fr' ?' H ! ?{ L_G' . - tR,? .f 4 .T r- /t'?G ==.-,i ,: ""?J' /!S ri <? M1! (! Ir: h .,, r _. ? O i.? fc T 7'6) f.` C T ? 7 I / ? = D /? -S ! 'L! 7/ /? -r: ?:'%r. /' '??i v?i'1 P.i ,? ? :% j`./f`s ?:f->%- li,.'.:: iJ _.- ?/1:?/.rr7 G.r.. F, •:l L,:_.i? j ,.ate i?/-?? .ter. S. -L.:-: f?%'?? ?%T".`.(^ /!•.' f / -: t c97 4E'-, rf C / G}L / 4 / /. / v ry `?._/ / L 1 / / T Jl._t{ .,/_ / ? :?, G_/,? ? ./?. ?/: ?'} l:l ?? U:- .T/i cT"- l-(J-?:)iJf•r6L/,?Lll. ?i? r?C'/?'././_) v4. \?ff?%/j 70 UG A/7- /r."J? ?" 'C' l; r2 nl r....7 Vv'Y"[.i L ..?t' 'i /.- C !?f <s h /1!U ? .4 ! Lr C' .£. 3 CJ t? f•,'/ / .i S:TUIc, i. L' L' A"1- U /v - s) //L!F:.?/!?i. /:_TJ; TO C/:v/'y'ttiJTOi?y! f L C7i-.H./S _S7J?`?a? ?X -CSS 4- CJ-AL - 1 ?r_ /=/ crr_:?/O ?f-.ti / G'fi? 7G: J! ` r`-"kr i:Nd !//?j? ?c',aJ37c ,!?y AE/JG-a mAy!??.IWISS/iO?', 44-ir7, V?liYiFr??1J/ fLi 2?D! ETG. j -14 Z /1%11 J;Kc? iTGRNG Y-e- l,F.ilT G0,--/, GL- 7 LV E!?E E'•FUK??!: 15 AI X L' O ': ,E 5 (1 F fi' `? 77 L' F c E is xi ? s MA 7-.Z /44. f1/?? 6111 0tV Z71", TO M/7RA' T,r/E .SCi /--5- iA.1iTH A /S S'/ONF<7 /A//T/q?S A/„l?rC%% 1ji17? FJ/ ?: ? ?i?f/s?/IL/N? IJnD GfL?XLHPnj?ES; f .- ?• n / T J 4 e &4; 71n , n/Q A-f 1v %1 = 7- " L / ,rc' !! r'7 - = ft(I f!_L- ` S _ An/? •d...__ b =-_-.- ? . r? SF. ?! SE.< Vt ; ??? ;Gfr CAN ?J ? 2 c `D 7`6) { i r,- !, ?ILFi,'JJ7/F/= '7C t, ._ n; '" 7 f - 4J ELF' /inP?/'T/E lnli /-?,p.h/= GLR/?%r5 f' sun/RG .ScCYES, C!F/-,L f_GG xi L_ ?Ol.!ri SC?T,d n??nnr nf'EES /i',7 f A107- CFEnrr?Il? "J¢Pc-ScflLS [I ,- ?Lf1//?7i.Fr /S a"7?kclJ ; !. ',-iC l?:uxrS uGCi-S:f/L h!!S /?kESE/??°C L'!"'HOLtT ff ??in Ok?.El? ,G'J • ,i?-'Hc"/7; L G7';'. !? f ??' ? STS ,4 j ?_ ,ry:ff=0r,!'?,*? ? j Tf y J? TtfL?P? S'cr//CR/CrP ?GiarCT's' lT N -'4: C a JL T 27 TT,'S ? 7?d. ? L E K 'S:?/IAL ?FC°rr_ :i:v'c/JTGR 'GIST. ? r !< o N<U :,i .5.c y Lt ! .5 m ' SSE<7 ='G : F. J S' ,41r'E R i .S?c" ? .?L uG':,•' r/, _G !? wSD/?./J S=J: /? .?1 ,c? r` _ - illy. Gl!GEr, flri S F/? D /? /071!)^J rV ScT .,_ /.i.'-E ] ?t J 1 i 1 i i'EQ.?c^iT/D+t?-_./tS-f'c {)Pfi_cn. !/? lo/?r1<1 °G? h RC{D?c'. .5 LtPO/? T!•/E CGGt,Q7/.f ORl3-4 GQfiNT%?(r (aL7F iS !',gOro.S£A //1 c` ?'?c n/T/,> f L%? Fuf; E? K,594,-r-sTS 7-,,/ NaGE Cou,< r ?a .D/2EC7 r/( P.4 ?aG .bZF,,EAvf?Al?T. 4t1lb 7W -C/,c C•0-,Ehlr/'Lvi?FE-S' 7'-0 lr?///?E l/?Irrf4r Jl/A7?' q?r.?1/?CE??rENTS ?O/c ?I?`? /n(???IT?kY./'/G Qr? (?'Lir", ?.' STl?,4F-.A EXGESS' .LEG/rL f'?t,^,F'E?f"T/?S SO 7"//ffi %?E /??/? Ll)?+4T"E IJISNdT/L'E, b?' !it'F??FL .fr'N'lj Su(3/?? ? ? i T ta/! ? r/ Tl-f,Z: ,i!?u6. . ' D. ?YG S.F?_S />ir+1D G0' 'n / fem. G>.GtrnB?RLfIn/v ?CU!?Ty' Cio /YIIYIOi? PLEA_5- . (.'r7 u C 3" H l r. r<Iy U / fU/r /O 81,4 k 4446 u:/1G/ IG? f'GTI ,S ?Ey^,>rCZ7- /,?tl7r`.-/.,E "J Y ^ ? -?•`?f 'F-=' I _A b 7r=1?`S ?%?^/':? G%i..G-" fr/:? ?%?i i!-iir.: i/FE .:emu/;'/? lylCilL'?/.:?f=. ??/y ?/r?.r?r>k',t(;rz?.E.`OL!?"7". L q =r: jY ! i': 7G"?7Ci? / > r'r/{ % / / OGD , ?! /: /7 T:/ PR 0iEC7- L'G7r?S ; /71- / D /IJA ?/' j i/<(e +? ?; _'-I--r7':5 O 7-,, O rJ t?/i >. G i >`/ n?O lnlq '' T",G' ?-Tu D ?, C E i/aE %?c-r`6 F?n.%rS T"L;'G-//::.'.D-c.`rir"La?'.E?=_?, U,?G GOrr;/?.?D,?-;/_s..= i.?? P?../a!_UC-/r'??-G fl?T?R=:STS . Qr-°/ iSG , PEE/?/At 5, FJU i rFr rJ7: l<v? .?#-E ??!0?:A%:/_ 17t(I'?E," i.?Ciofd,Li _?`,ERtG=Gf?TG_ EA P4, 4) 1G '"JO ./.i144:tSE 1 //! i/?` ff r'I J<I^/7 /'i //} Q/t ft?Jir?/?, %? I-115 f_ J >4? U??s?L .fjs 1'-6. 1400 -Hi ,; TD i'Eto c%"?-E ` LE r~N4 O R r/•-..5 Fq 7- /2/SV 6!c 4-G S-S -- TL, - 1 i N!s /17,i i :'on/ r? JN7lff/ 'S /{; % i N NE=' ` s<tK'y' /N/ vF,n?/Tr%sf?/ rNHlc /{ Tr//?' -72 Hold o/ 14.64 - C Gi/?T IJE ? ?S FC; 4 AZ ?f£-rte! t>'? c Fo.c'c, .? /?sh :Tr%r a,cls%E-K A 7-1 6,&?4 PL A/D i is % / )Cr !J /? lL? /? li • ?Irif'rti ?// = : 7777"1 f? L. /; 710, Ar= / Zc-Zi r : ,zZ vvr C ?J 7;4 7-Eb lnJl? LG.?(c.: / ;G T?dc Lug_?_rrr?f>/--?-?e-n.10u1?Eu':rc A'/J,4A-1,/y_F1-I4 /` ' U; ,E"A?r +?l' C-L ? [=/ t!E/t7 %E 7 fI /jam? Tc7 <<rJ L %?/ ?4? ??t=Y ? .?fC' S1 /'t !T SL.s q 7 i cJ p z-, L`rc. .G, ' F r Y y HM ?/?? 01¢E /jL 7-,', i??_T?G??L j ltrl': S Tr;=%i% %%7< GN<iK x?L. E i!floff? 7" % r A t,• Zvi r?o?iL? c'?6 b4 !/ ? ? r"%;?G a A h x .ter - ; ? ?" /, ?' x y y /=Ka -c N`O'TE: O.{'l?!/?f1L /lNd AtdPL/C'/1T'?-t'L'P!£SI??P?" ??ol"C?c'?1??, _ - till hi y _ l--.---....--- _-.--__ .. _.. _ C- e)F ,5.E y. N. __ 7764- Sr-_</b _©?` ?4P.Q/G ?b/©, /f rh ,3 ?°cs`r r?i?c?- r.+f?""? ?-r1f? ?sl- ?ccNrT f-'?<sd.? ?/.??' ' ?'" LORE?r?lNCr "/?GAls?7tFi°'S /i 7G?%CN F?'? /N%E.e v?'NrrCi? ??v'/ r!f __ ,4 e do mA ??h j%/Y!G??!7 .??__? ARV; fk??_r__?:-s, c?. ? ._ _ __ 21 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION-LAW JAMES A. PALUCH, JR Plaintiff, ; No. 08-6175 V. C-7 PA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, et al. , Defendants. ' DEFENDANTS' ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR INTERVENTION AND NOW, come the Defendants, Pennsylvania Department of Corrections, et al., by and through their attorney, Raymond W. Dorian, Assistant Counsel, and answer as follows: 1. BRIEF HISTORY OF THE CASES ADMITTED in part; DENIED in part. ADMITTED that the Plaintiff was formerly incarcerated at the State Correctional Institution at Camp Hill ("SCI- Camp Hill"). It was also ADMITTED that Plaintiff filed Civil Rights actions in the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, which actions were dismissed by the Court. The rest of this statement is DENIED and proof thereof is demanded. II. OTHER HISTORY DENIED. Proof thereof is demanded. It is specifically DENIED that the Plaintiff is disabled. III. MOTION 1. ADMITTED that the Plaintiff is currently incarcerated at SCI- Smithfield in Huntingdon, Pennsylvania. 2. ADMITTED that under Department Policy DC-ADM 815, inmates in the Restricted Housing Unit ("RHU") are only allowed to have one records box of personal property in their cells. Any excess material is kept in storage. It is also ADMITTED that inmates in general population are permitted to have four records center boxes of personal property in their cell at any one time. By way of further answer, RHU inmates can request to have additional boxes in their cell. In June of 2009, the Plaintiff was permitted to have one extra box of material in his cell after he returned to general population. 3. DENIED. Proof thereof is demanded. By way of further answer, the Plaintiff had many property exchanges, including on August 24, 2009 and August 27, 2009. 4. ADMITTED that on April 16, 2009, Judge Bayley dismissed the actions filed in the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County at docket nos. 08-4835 and 08-6175. 2 5. ADMITTED only that the Plaintiff filed Notices of Appeals in the actions at docket nos. 08-4835 and 08-6175. The rest of this averment is DENIED and proof thereof is demanded. 6. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a reasonable believe as to the truth or accuracy of this averment and proof thereof is demanded. 7. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a reasonable believe as to the truth or accuracy of this averment and proof thereof is demanded. 8. ADMITTED that the Defendants did not file any documents in response to the Plaintiff's respective Notices of Appeal. 9. ADMITTED that on October 26-27, 2009, a jury trial was conducted before Judge Rambo in the Federal Court matter of Paluch v. Dawson, et al. at docket no. 06-cv-1751. 10. ADMITTED that on November 6, 2009, the Plaintiff's personal property was inventoried by staff at SCI-Smithfield. 11. ADMITTED in part; DENIED in part. ADMITTED that the Plaintiff asked to sign the tape seals on the boxes of his personal property, which request was denied. The rest of this averment is DENIED. Proof thereof is demanded. 3 12. ADMITTED in part; DENIED in part. ADMITTED that the Plaintiff asked to sign the tape seals on the boxes of his personal property, which request was denied. The rest of this averment is DENIED. Proof thereof is demanded. By way of further answer, the Plaintiff was not entitled to sign the tape seals. The Plaintiff also refused to sign the personal property inventory sheet. 13. ADMITTED in part; DENIED in part. ADMITTED that the Plaintiff filed inmate grievance no. 298211-09 concerning his personal property. The rest of this averment is DENIED and proof thereof is demanded. By way of further answer, the Plaintiff's final appeal of this grievance was denied. 14. ADMITTED in part; DENIED in part. ADMITTED that the Department's Central Office denied the Plaintiff's appeal of grievance no. 298211- 09. The rest of this averment is DENIED. Proof thereof is demanded. 15. ADMITTED that the Superior Court issued an Order on March 3, 2010, directing that the lower Court accept and docket the Plaintiff's Notices of Appeal. 16. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a reasonable belief as to the truth or accuracy of this averment and proof thereof is demanded. 17. DENIED. Proof thereof is demanded. By way of further answer, the Plaintiff had a property exchange on March 24, 2010. 4 18. DENIED. Proof thereof is demanded. 19. DENIED. Proof thereof is demanded. 20. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a reasonable belief as to the truth or accuracy of this averment. Proof thereof is demanded. 21. ADMITTED that the Plaintiff filed a Motion for Court Intervention with Judge Rambo in the Federal case of Paluch vs. Dawson, et al. 22. ADMITTED that on February 22, 2010, Judge Rambo denied the Plaintiff's Motion for Court Intervention, except that she ordered that the Plaintiff would be permitted to go through one box of legal materials at a time in order to pull any medical documents to support his upcoming trial against Defendant Smith. It is also ADMITTED that the Plaintiff filed a Motion for Reconsideration of Judge Rambo's Order. 23. DENIED. Proof thereof is demanded. By way of further answer, the Plaintiff is permitted to keep one extra box of legal material in his cell. The request to re-inventory his property and to tape seal any boxes is unnecessary and excessive. 24. This is a conclusion of law to which no response is necessary. 25. This is a conclusion of law to which no response is necessary. 26. This is a conclusion of law to which no response is necessary. 5 27. DENIED. Proof thereof is demanded. 28. DENIED. Proof thereof is demanded. 29. No response is necessary. WHEREFORE, the Defendants request that the Plaintiff's Motion for Intervention be denied. Respectfully submitted, Office of Chief Counsel B y Raymo d W. Dorian Assistant Counsel Attorney I.D. No. 48148 PA Department of Corrections Office of Chief Counsel 55 Utley Drive Camp Hill, PA 17011 (717) 731-0444 Dated: May 20, 2010 Fax No. (717) 975-2217 6 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION-LAW JAMES A. PALUCH, JR. ; Plaintiff, No. 08-6175 V. PA DEPARTMENT OF : CORRECTIONS, et al., Defendants. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day depositing in the U.S. mail a true and correct copy of the foregoing Defendants' Answer to Plaintiff's Motion for Intervention upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below. Service by first-class mail addressed as follows: James Paluch, Jr., BQ-3769 SCI-Smithfield P.O. Box 666, 1120 Pike St. Huntingdon, PA 16652 s/ Shelly R. Holley Shelly R. Holley Legal Assistant 1 Pennsylvania Department of Corrections 55 Utley Drive Camp Hill, PA 17011 Dated: May 20, 2010 XA/ - T,ri- 6fJUat T _OF "dtm ON *vL &* s )wVA 0_44A16-EX LA'NY ?,au ?•ry, PFN/vSYL.vANSA Ps. rf. OS A.4 6 - PLA Ar 'A A"& o ?.r .. Tli/S 6OU9 URsuoNTTo RuL(r /033 OA ZAW .04-4, ci?. Agoe- To +WRAIO M/S P"OrioN Aoo;' //VT I AVENT'/opv *-r FoI-1-0 /s: n F T V- IN" T i - C7« pp p liG St/17G ?ronn t' t Or?;ina./ ?/?r,'S NJO?+'en Tpr ?o,.a•rf' Sn}?CrNtn?/on w.f f{e e..q?i t it T ' aA j be invty?+o I lea( CLhcl Processed W,+L " 7-a1 {•?owrs upor+ (?;s recep4ior, in4-o t 4e- Rids.(. 32. T e - pYVI Irls- o 7 eyan rote •yeres Manwa s4oL s +/nov+ a_ wr?'sov?tr `a i O e- 1 12 #-A e i lr i r n -?O ?? a R. 0 u , I, 33 , PA DOG > 1 aCi l ? y eeu?-+ y ' o ? ey ar. roc tyros wrt?? 1 ec on., -pa r- PC n So ` o f ? 0. ?? -+ ?'o ?e ` ven?e 'c -26:kZA rOGtSSGd l+ ?? ?+ ?!? y?o wrs t?pv4 jt 1'5 reCe f +l on 'K'+- - ke- R14u , 33 S Z !i 14U o i'ders c(d - nod- rnven+cry n.er process .'s en -SOMCO or ' ? ' a er 17` .s tccpfion in?-o l-!+t R14U). S. T moty 9, o20 /O ?nvtnfory o 41',AvO, eJe? ProPtrffy, y Al¢/trs . Betrm?-7?? ' a ua/ D t?I a?CO i'? ?O r? / 1+4nd- hG/a r'? l"lAx"Ce ca.nernt.., 3lv. Was A-0eo/Permiss/on 1? f t Pro iavr? av"ew apwo", Vc V"R ae ?wt?r t /lea R ?ranCi or e-d'p*" A. Liecvt fwo ) (saxes o-.0 ae fi ve 1 Jw / Inw.?Criw,/s r`rs !i is Ce //, On r,&braa4-y 11, Z0/O, Od't "A*Vu d,, i I'Ou/?/?L ! TGMS" in his Gel/ pGr /OGst- 3p, d ,21 ? ,'ter a,rne -.4? a A -AA P/ o l1 P/ 4? A 440,1( , 'S net you le of ale yQNL! a., a fuse PR c' d , I c3 q. CF .?p AkC +?r+?e PRC era?tr ..?r?tt. 844"_6 do&& Ad d?SG+?'+/ -f' i ? . /oRN•?s or' f'a.e/+!I ?y ?Q-n?er ?,s @or?stn'?. y0. PI 10 X4 r`s c +?,+ p re vt ., f mac,( a a ees s to !t 1: s 4ceesr Lo. ro?er + es Se. ?r + AA J4 A6wA,./,o d 7"ir?ae? orr nR.! Gef?ie,S & PC .Mere/ ?ivr s t.lpekee/r/n? tece?asa Pr/:as, evo a/n.?s 'o--f Smz ,. L e S/NtZ e[+'-t dtrrYI'.j Rn1? wro-n ado la / ltewcver p?,f,f. /sRs ?r?ae ' o,i fo s•?l.xi Vf? s Ckc+^t, At wok!d irre fs cr.?1?r a&v" t Iis's 0-/dt/mx 4.0 44'0 1.2AIaa &PAPI-c vl I rieJ 60*14 09"4n1 fJ,e ?! sae r lrw &X /on 0%e Ise s I eJ?! r?+-slvcr re s, I i ay? , AOlO, if dots r.of eve- aL y mess a .s re ? o-r- o ?+?•- /ret,1E o-' A/s /t?e/ Yj S Af" 4, IN1101 )oli-001 ott not 41Y-C any aee.Css fo any s-4 /$ -KC4/Ve_ 'Vf - - 316 Joao ge c swm as Am #oJ &r Jen "141 ton le j-90 MAJFCr1els, whe.. 101 ;1#1 is in +-4-L Jkel 4"J /4L Yy. _ s or ' 04-Ate- doeuwpe,"fs A-c Piece& qfa,- *r/R/ exA161, s Ar*v, Ao.0 Seboxca in - + ©i-d c.6, de. or rtZwes is . It ld ewKS -6 wCee" ?Wl Ifu 4AIS A4 e., f"#-Jlk?M^4 4-0 a o , MC.S t Marie a:,t„ P, a1r, J?T_ A. EX p?ts.e it" Awls x v, /t?rwd,"Al, PA t r.GSZ RA O Adr is n ` attee:s {pis It a/ w,etrfer/w1s /h f!,/s eese , See ; 91 vs. V Est 1 .0/6,01rtoA/ :r, ?i A?1ES .?. MA"d#, Ole., #,eg Y V-"Cloy R"R'f'4*dr 7r'O /Q/.ttE IO&V OJW T,f/E pA, R, C/?, ivae-. #nM if PA, e.,s. 1119oS/ 77mr roe ?FOR?'IrtEN?'/Ort/RO pi.Al^!r/fe/s A~**" AW7.0N ~ Lltsrtr ivrmvoo-trtoi/ /s ,6#-r / TAME *,WO -Co+t,tKa 7r0 rAV QESVOR Altx llN-o+?t toO-ff MAtiXW 1vXgwj itry AF A=KTa,Q y, ?ERT<i/GAFTE O? 3fR'V/CE ?C', ?A?tn Fs A?. Pat ?c?, ?iP., /,fExiAly vFa y an? rals "rM a*l of MOVE .10 to., filcRJcrx,vr To pa.?, aw, PA'oe, Rrst.E'VYo 44A4 -mz "I°C1s#A& mAfkiISox RtKtE, ?? = A>» DEQas /r/NO- /wra rmc m*Ajbs Of PktsoN oFoia/A?fs of sdz- s^'J,7wF1Et.O TMF ,Aftx'F - A490ftoNt,D bpe4t*tEµr.S wt-r&k Pko-Pos" o",w a o,c1 TIKE 1RCCt.owta6 p?ERso? ?Ltow I NI 'r*t p4RMN61t 30 J0D few-rho FIRS4=CLASS U. S. MA! L PCSTA?.rrZc PRhP?l11! "3Z"^4 #n?b boRi.4,i l 6sq, A.ss,r, eO"#r.SFZ- P-4.boc Ss ur4.t y bA, Q„A,M P M 1 L4, PA 6'+o t t- T O 2-W 1>??d : 3?'u? t1, ?o?v EM L, u : Imax Sr.t KJabrJ6 ss / Zk"".gs 4. t'?Ka6t, ??e. aR 3 ??9 SC.z-Sh,t?4't+RIELA I l s.o ?c rt,F sv--, l?ua?=rrs?,?a.r ? P a ? Lb say PL:rr;./ PPo S= JAMES A. PALUCH, JR., IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF Plaintiff CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA vs. CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 08-4835 CIVIL / NO. 08-6175 CIVIL PA. DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, ET AL., Defendants IN RE: PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED MOTION FOR COURT INTERVENTION ORDER AND NOW, this Z8' day of June, 2010, the Court being satisfied that the plaintiff's complaints concerning a violation of the order of the Honorable Sylvia H. Rambo are more properly directed towards the federal court, his amended motion for court intervention is DENIED. ./ saes A. Paluch, Jr. BQ3769 SCI-Smithfield 1120 Pike Street Huntingdon, PA 16652 Plaintiff aymond Dorian, Esquire Assistant Counsel - PA DOC 55 Utley Drive Camp Hill, PA 17011-8028 Am BY THE COURT, 4 .,."q A Kevin . Hess, P. J. C '-1 . 111 ? ? f t III ZN rMR /Tourer OA GOA*0&-oN PPLEAS io,R tRR6pNO doit.?lry, PE1JNSy?V/tutA ?; Z V 2JA'?-? 8 N ?-r t. I LJ ?i1FM!rf A. PALKGI, Tit., pL^AWIPP pros, o f- yd9s, o t- `rays V. PA Me, CrAL., M&R[?AA>ffS 1 N4n,Pj• 1465-5) P, -Y,) m m r.. t GOP ? " ©y i A ON A1JQ uNRat-oTl s, gRl &FS, AND r;?'OS'TSJ flttA/0 OF k4 OTIIFrt Pfi&5 lp.rl Fis MOTto/u pop LEi1ve -m pgotE't b oAI APp*AL isi FOAA4^ PAuft P1.AtNTIt'tr, -S--% A&J A, PA,.,aM, T4, ("Ptu/. "?, PRo SE, fillvirrt} Ntrlilai? rIF4 Cowtr mo ym OF Ptrv,?J m&woet Foot ItrrsaevON97oI/ t;©N6940106 YOU 6"491jf o1¢DAt kN of Tutsa 2,0101 MOVES -Mg CO"T Pu A414NT 7o PA. 0- APP,?A-06. RU LAS S3Z, i ftitttf ?O /AD4L&FA /N FAtMA PA&WARIS, *,.O SirATOS 7116 Fbt,{,owrat; LI,wrDEM TN-6 P + #! PA.C.S. ¢ygoy ("t/WsMre/trt FAj-stFtekT)o?ITO ^wWvAlTlAs t) TWAT: '= Aa1 T06 Pt.rF. t J ttlL AG*%/o AdTION A.-,* AgitOAM-90 OP My 60#,J pAy -rI?A FoLLooji $ F"x A&0 Corm: IrtLtrts• Paes; avows oP PttooµEtNf- At:t OTO*A COCNA,ttt-Trf; W1TNEfS *A/D/OR MiZEAOC FOaTS; S141COIRF'.t Sfs wtCE F&&-As SuPaRSEOFassFCcuctry Is IRAIPAAASLA 1449M WectD A5StWf (F MOT wAIVfnt oR Cdrrf OF YIitS elvag'T,' OTC, :2• My AFfPONSOJ 7o ALL. QUISTIOms REL,*T/a14 7o Awy 4601.4Ty TO la*y rI1& t PROSEC ATI WQr Ad APPEAL A46 U14E AIJO a; VAAteT : A) I AM NOT 5W"yfrD; 8) T NR ASsirrNMlcNr stow MAy 1, ZOOq (Z AM uNAER OFF/OIAL OPPAasstON ty 9'149 pA DO d7tiElt joa&1$ vA 861JEF1r'S vJtTW 'rili exisP7Yorl oil Alit-r bAy 41Prs (usuALiy 42.0 OwN No SAVIN4s OA 41SIC c 109 Ad""P TS ; A) Z DQ Nov OWN QarY XI-At ESTAYE, NOT&Sj A& ros. OA or#sg VALNALiLF PROPAA'.TY Ott ASSETS (arm" Titali PlaswA TFLEV/Statd, & PEW ROCKS, A SAOKEA3>yOSWAIralt, A^tb A 4SAOk*r.JkAD/O be .*r'lolu JOUAPOSSS)? t) `Z MMAV0 NO ©9Pr.,Drjjrrs; 14tib, tlr? r 0"Jw .40000-Y. befin ro -rMA, U.s, a/srt,tr ONO >W/RD dixtuir Cowers. ?. S ?DR1tSTtOdO >1?FAr A I?,aLSG s1'iV>•1E?ett?ts' eE; A-NSw?'4 7a grJy tQt,?ES9 F!!cA SyRrrrluFNT' ++?/lt?t Stt6.Tt e? Alt To VW4f l09dI 4f riss J040VIo EA d y 4'4 w (Ir ?diE d'FC4,40 Ae&991E) . .fO Ve/t *wX&A Ps4FSu.4.-Jr 7*o R&tLL /02?/ (R4.A', ?!?, A.Pat) APAD It P,O, t°. S /Vl,v jT uLy/ts?D14v /QELS BFI l.Ar! oat''r0 ,Ft t ti(tO,Q<7'1 rE.s rJ AN 7,VAS NO !N a Ay OF A6" IrAW ""Y OF #UPJr/A1*d40A6 Af4w, /fuArr/A,liDOA7 ""Arty, PE'lAA1J /Lt/.fAJ?,r 1 S. fS AArD COSTS OF Na4' MAD A PttnsoAt C) I Ase&Iv& My 0 OR LESS); D) s rocks, BOIJDS, STOMS SW4A AS A r0 IroA; 114"it eAre - t /, rl0. 00 !N I00 ,'AJ rw4f th ,Q/- r Apst'O"OP of '; f y9oi/ ,CsAI?,t- wsr Zo/o IN 8`j.3o/o DA-r?e : ,41.ca?urr ,?o, i.ola lAje s, de-: R. Do,efhAI E-seQ, 1AEA.s,) AIL- E 8g3?-6 9 SGZ-swlr PItKE ST,fEG"T' Also J A0ff1A 4-V0A4 P,4 t i A,! Y1011 PRo .Std 0014f 4.6 o, eox 4s9 .,r'Z-0919? lrooF p4A-lAJTtFG, zzk44E3,4. p'AG"ew, TQ .? ox o S4, 'ArRa 4 y ?46Fk r1,liES ©N THIS 3arm zky a u61tSy?- zoio 714.4,' Ak4 is SEikill ?l- 4 1,9149 N-r,D 6"-ox-4;r 6&p y oc-- 7,*E Aox-o "l e NO>/QE Q-r 4-PPZ-41- !v&Ala ARa ru1?6 ` e- CBU47 OR.D,Ex .74[r/E 28, 24ld) AAJa PG4rNTl?i?S/f'107/O? la" L1-AvE TO AkodEj;;-o ow /iv -ocx4.q MPOAv -r#E AM- ,S"OA/ 4AID /A/ TldE /P74A 6R . VO AW4D1 U Y',D b ELO W ^'X S 6cAA1r 74 7#k ??1S0N£'?215 IV7411-13OX RUI:E ?'S!!ir¢Orn??f !/, FLRSR? -?f/ 1?0.1 /76 to.4,.S'w", 200/) By bEPos1Y'1,vd-1,vro 7W ?42ANDJ Olc ^Ier ,v OAA14I,44S wNIc# so S&,ev1d9 S??rF1ES ?, e? 14&?1,?eR?n??i?S of P • ?. ??P. PRad, X"I-E /-2i 1 L AS 57-, cou,'sZ- /- - )r-? o c. S:5- U7-4E?y 254/vE, d,4 yip /j /L G ? 0 //- ?4 Z 8 -pt4,0o') Ar- 30, Zo l o VNe4- s, FILE R, DociRN " ?µ ars A . w, S,Q,., ?Q3?-b9' Sc°a-S?a+r?d-F??4D t 12, o PVKE S-rg- & FT P.O. Boy, 9 a 9 j4U x) -n m -D o .#J, -T>A 10 1--rF. , pp- o SA 1-,? r?? Go u,cr 0s ?.o,?,•?oa vs?s 1coe r..a -ct 1iE,yrgS i4 BKLKdAG Tyr!. A/0, or- A/pis, V 4 rycN. NE ss, P ?;; C N ?? Isle C F 9 A PP O i4 L• /vutJo PR0 rcc^rG 'POASU* Or ro ?t? ,, . a4pjgc * -73 / A, Zo d z 9l 6 jr o S"PoQ. /NOTICE /S IfERl,sy 6jvEi? r//e-' rAFs oaovA ?ret?voc Pi,?:,?s?a1=, 3',rt ss A. to.. 149RkDy "PE4cs 71.0 TNK s&4v,*,v@ t e.s"Ar o,v PjEAt?SyLVA?/A -air ?+ tiNE Oabsx FNrGRBG /AI ?-#,g A4*7wiEQ OF ?La?»vtrtots Mos'?o1? ?a,t 6ouRT ,T.??aJOr?y'ionl O? f#A 28r// Dar eF ?k?o ZOlO• 71fj b6Pwry f?aortfonloTi?ay mr, ?a -rq& da:attrrZo COP1Es /A1To THE ho-wer ot? -rllf/de RksPESSivE h*'rgJ dY Co"Ar S a?• nLAtsJT/ Q WAS No XOJOw44oe-E 1P #Aty rJeAAtCee1Prs 0#4 Goucr Axotew"A16s .e L .oyo?11?+aLE. P6aJ^171f i aPfjAl-.f 1.1e, v oo opr/ftTNt ???TN X000 L?RtcSJE t ANA ?NsLt P1C PENT QYSOEN3? -r#Ar ?'uobi AlwssI AFoKf? A, -/o^/EO d?tDOR (ZD.) IS tR/VoLdu ;t /?d,4Std,fL O? .y'ttOtC/AL. D1.rdRE>/oAJ? 14^/E.?RJr.7'trDtC/AL TD P?As?v>'?FF`s SrvrFr ?D ?GDi•?CgL Co ^/sb-t ?ru r 1 e,?1,v L As WAC4 t AS f ?-,w7-" ro Rey FOA-tMCF,C, PL.?/.rrtaF /+F.as ??F.? baaNf?o /k ?o?¢?rrw P,eu via srv4us eY 7'Jf1t Co&AT- ANO /QG1vtAt.?1 A PACCAE.[, Pu,¢s.cA?rr 7e ZS u.J.e, fifr ;? A-> .5". 7rK/S /?PIpF?t• /S PKESEN>Ee So AS To PRES44VO *44. 69-^JFO #'s, Rl#*rr f/?F4f1^!, /i?ERGt1?, ?4n/? TffeFRETO puRSte,p?tr fa I?PPte`Is©L.? L.1L?t -4iva e-O"AT Rut AS. So A-PP4f,*'L bA.fkb ; roue u.$r 301 1010 be : R- DoRjaESQ. (b &r-s,) ¢tL.E i,Joav ss, ?n ?EL1> 5e, SAA rOP1 11 zo P1140 srRt?r ?, p, ,gpR 949 j. j t.?i?Ti•v 6-D o? i 7?:4. 16 `?f'Z-? !.O'! 9 9 piA1J11V W,l Pleo s? 1 ptplNT!`FSthFiERB'A R SritoKE O^! Alciat7r t!, ,Z0/0 j4tl4 w* Ar ?AtrrtTrEO 7"b a'Trt,BLAh[ QN 4,,4, ;jr auo w.sf ,I?pZ.o ^00 ?pF NosPi>,ss /N PA. A44F W" R&16 / PRtrOtl+s MEotdl?t OAPs. ?itrtlTlL Astir :2 s, PYS511 Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Page 1 Civil Case Print 2008-04835 PALUCH JAMES A JR (vs) PA DEPT OF CORRECTIONS ET AL Reference No... Filed......... 8/12/2008 Case Ty e..... . COMPLAINT Judgment......: .00 Time. ... Execution'Date 8.55 0/00/0000 Judge Assigned: HESS KEVIN A Jury Tria Disposed Desc.: Disposed ate. i 0/00/0000 ------------ Case Comments ------------- gher Cr l.: H Higher Cr 2.. l I G d Attorne Info enera n ex y PALUCH JAMES A JR PLAINTIFF 1120 PIKE STREET P 0 BOX 999 HUNTINGDON PA 16652 PA DEPT OF CORRECTIONS DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W 2520 LISBURN ROAD CAMP HILL PA 17001 ZIMMERMAN DEREK DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W SCI-CAM 2500 LISBURN ROAD P 0 BOX 200 CAMP HILL PA 17001 0200 SIMPSON MARK DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W SCI-CAM 2500 LISBURN ROAD PO BOX 200 CAMP HILL PA 17001 0200 AYERS EDWARD DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W SCI-CAM 2500 LISBURN ROAD PO BOX 200 CAMP HILL PA 17001 0200 YOHN MATTHEW DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMO?DD W SCI-CAM 2500 LISBURN ROAD PO BOX 200 CAMP HILL PA 17001 0200 HUBER ADAM DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W SCI-CAM 2500 LISBURN ROAD PO BOX 200 CAMP HILL PA 17001 0200 KLEIN COL DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W SCI-CAM 2500 LISBURN ROAD PO BOX 200 CAMP HILL PA 17001 0200 KREIDER ROBERT DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W SCI-CAM 2500 LISBURN ROAD PO BOX 200 CAMP HILL PA 17001 0200 SOUTHERS DICK DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W SCI-CAM 2500 LISBURN ROAD PO BOX 200 CAMP HILL PA 17001 0200 BRANNIGAN EUGENE DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W SCI-CAM 2500 LISBURN ROAD PO BOX 200 CAMP HILL PA 17001 0200 PATTON DAVID DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W SCI-CAM 2500 LISBURN ROAD PO BOX 200 CAMP HILL PA 17001 0200 MOSLAK ZACHARY DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W SCI-CAM 2500 LISBURN ROAD PO BOX 200 CAMP HILL PA 17001 0200 PYS511 Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Civil Case Print 2008-04835 PALUCH JAMES A JR (vs) PA DEPT OF CORRECTIONS ET AL Reference No..: Case Tyyppe..... . COMPLAINT Judgment..... .00 Judge Assigned: HESS KEVIN A Disposed Desc.: ------------ Case Comments ------------- BARBACCI KRISTIN DEFENDANT SCI-CAM 2500 LISBURN ROAD PO BOX 200 CAMP HILL PA 17001 0200 LAW THERESA DEFENDANT SCI-CAM 2500 LISBURN ROAD PO BOX 200 CAMP HILL PA 17001 0200 KELCHNER DONALD L DEFENDANT SCI-CAM 2500 LISBURN ROAD PO BOX 200 CAMP HILL PA 17001 0200 Filed......... Time. .. Execution Date Jury Tria Disposed 'ate. Higher Cr 1.: Higher Cr 2.: DORIAN RAYMO D W GOLD ALAN S DORIAN RAYM07D W II DORIAN RAYMOND W **************************************************************7 * Date Entries 8/12/2008 OMPLAINT C FIRST ENTRY - - - - - - FILED BY JAMES A PALUCH JR PLFF PRO SE i 8/12/2008 --------- AFFIDAVIT -- -- ----- -------- ------ - -- OF IN FORMA PAUPERIS STATUS - BY ----- - i JAMES AI , 8/21/2008 ------------------------------------------ ORDER OF COURT - 8/21/08 - THE PETITION OF -------- PLFF TO FORMA PAUPERIS IS GRANTED - THE COMPLAINT SHALL BE FILING FEE PLFF - BY AND THE SHERIFF IS DIRECTED TO EDGAR B BAYLEY J - COPIES MAILED SERVE IT 8/21/08 8/27/2008 ---------- SHERIFF'S -------------------------------- FILE RETURNED FILED. -------- Li ytigant.: Address..: NDEPARTMENTOTICE 55 UTLEY DRIVE gg Cty/St/Zp: CAMP HILL, PA 17011 Hnd To: RANDELL SEARS ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/D ty.: ROBERT BITNER Date/ Time: Costs _____ 08/26/2008 0930:00 -$42_00-Pd-By_-00/00/0000- - 8/27/2008 SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. ? Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: Regular' Litigant.: ZIMMERMAN DEREK Address..: 2500 LISBURN ROAD Ctyy/St/Z • CAMP HILL, PA 17011 Hnd To: BOB VOLCCAK, ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/D ty.: Date/ Time: Costs_____ ROBERT BITNER 08/26/2008 1000:00 -$30_00 -Pd -By_-00/00/0000-- - - ? 8/27/2008 SHERIFF'S Case Type: Litigant.: Address..: - - - FILE RETURNED FILED. COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: SIMPSON MARK 2500 LISBURN ROAD -------- Regular Cty/St/Z • CAMP HILL, PA 17011 Hnd To: BOB VOLCCAK, ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/D ty.: ROBERT BITNER Date/ Time: 08/26/2008 1000:00 Costs....: $16.00 Pd By: 00/00/0000------- -------- 8/27/2008 SHERIFF'S Case Type: Litigant.: Address..: Cty/St : Hnd To: BO Shf/Dpty.: FILE RETURNED FILED. COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: AYERS EDWARD 2500 LISBURN ROAD CAMP HILL, PA 17011 B VOLCCAK, ADULT IN CHARGE ROBERT BITNER Regular) Page 2 8/12/2008 8:55 0/00/0000 0/00/0000 * ***************** - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - PALUCH JR PRO ----------------- PROCEED IN ,FFILED WITHOUT A ?f?IITHOUT COST TO PYS511 Cumberland County Prothonotary's Civil Case Print Office Page 3 2008-04835 PALUCH JAMES A JR (vs) PA DEPT OF CORRECT IONS ET AL Reference No... Case Ty e..... . COMPLAINT Judgment.. .00 Judge Assigned: HESS KEVIN A Disposed Desc.: ------------ Case Comments ------------- Filed......... Time. ... Execution Date Jury Tria , Disposed ate. Higher Cr 1.: Higher Cr.2.: 8/12/2008 8.55 0/00/0000 0/00/0000 Date/Time: 08/26/2008 1000:00 Costs....:-$16.00 Pd By: 00/00/0000 ---------- ----------------------------- ---------±---------------- 8/27/2008 SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type. Litigant.: YOHN MATTHEW Address..: 2500 LISBURN ROAD Q /St/Zp• CAMP HILL, PA 17011 To: BOB VOLCCAK ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/D ty.: ROBERT BITNER Date/ Time: 08/26/2008 1000:00 Costs....: $16.00 Pd By: 00/00/0000 : Regular 8/27/2008 27/2008 -------------------------------------------------- ---------------- SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: Regular) Litigant.: HUBER ADAM Address..: 2500 LISBURN ROAD /St/Zp• CAMP HILL, PA 17011 Q To: BBOB VOLCCAK, ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/D ty.: ROBERT BITNER Date/ Time: 08/26/2008 1000:00 Costs....: $16.00 Pd By: 00/00/0000 -------------------------------------------------- ---------------- SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: Regular) Litigant.: KLEIN COL Address..: 2500 LISBURN ROAD /St/Z • CAMP HILL, PA 17011 RTo: BOB VOLCCAK, ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/D ty.: ROBERT BITNER Date/Time: 08/26/2008 1000:00 Costs....: $16.00 Pd By: 00/00/0000---------------II ------------ ----------------- 8/27/2008 ----------------------- SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: Regular) Litigant.: KREIDER ROBERT Address..: 2500 LISBURN ROAD Cty/St/Z • CAMP HILL, PA 17011 Hnd To: BOB VOLCCAK, ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/D ty.: ROBERT BITNER Date/ Time: 08/26/2008 1000:00 Costs....: $16.00 Pd By: 00/00/0000 ------- ----- --------- ----- ---------- 8/27/2008 -------------------- SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type Litigant.: SOUTHERS DICK Address..: 2500 LISBURN ROAD Ctyy/St/Z • CAMP HILL, PA 17011 Hni To: BOB VOLCCAK, ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/D ty.: ROBERT BITNER Date/ Time: 08/26/2008 1000:00 $16.00 Pd By: 00/00/0000 Costs....: .: Regular) -- ------ --------- 8/27/2008 - - ---------- ------------------------ SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type Litigant.: PATTON DAVID --- .: Regula, Address..: 2500 LISBURN ROAD Cty/St/Z . CAMP HILL, PA 17011 Hnd To: BOB VOLCCAK, ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/D Tim Costs Date/e: 08/6/2008 1000:00 ate/ ty.: $016200 008 By: 00/00/0000 - -------- -----_.----- --------- 8/27/2008 --------------------------------------- --y------------------------------ SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type Litigant.: MOSLAK ZACHARY Address..: 55 UTLEY DRIVE Cty/St/Zp: CAMP HILL, PA 17011 .: Regular N N N III PYS511 Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Page 4 Civil Case Print 2008-04835 PALUCH JAMES A JR (vs) PA DEPT OF CORRECTIONS ET AL Reference No... Filed......... 8/12/2008 Case Type ..... : COMPLAINT Time. 8.55 Judgment..... .00 Execution Date 0/00/0000 Judge Assigned: HESS KEVIN A Jury Trial .... Disposed Desc.: Disposed ate. 0/00/0000 ------------ Case Comments - - - - - - - - - - - - - Higher Cr l.: Higher Cr 2.: Hnd To: RANDELL SEARS, ADULT IN CHARGE N Shf/D ty.: ROBERT BITNER N Date/Time: 08/26/2008 0930:00 N Costs....: $16.00 Pd By: 00/00/0000 N -------------------------------------------------- fi---------------- N 8/27/2008 SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: Regular) Litigant.: BARBACCI KRISTIN Address..: 2500 LISBURN ROAD Cty/St/Zp• CAMP HILL, PA 17011 Hnd To: BOB VOLCCAK, ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/D ty.: ROBERT BITNER Date/ Time: 08/26/2008 1000:00 Costs....: $16.00 Pd By: 00/00/0000 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8/27/2008 SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. Case Type; COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: Regular; Litigant.: LAW THERESA Address..: 2500 LISBURN ROAD Cty/St/Z • CAMP HILL, PA 17011 Hnd To: BOB VOLCCAK, ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/D ty.: ROBERT BITNER Date/ Time: 08/26/2008 1000:00 Costs....: $16.00 Pd By: 00/00/0000 ----------------------------------------- 8/27/2008 SHERIFFFS FILE RETURNED FILED. Cas Case T 'S COMPLAINT & NOTICE -Ret-Type.: Regular - Litigant.: KELCHNER DONALD L Address..: 2500 LISBURN ROAD Cty/St/Zp• CAMP HILL, PA 17011 Hnd To: BOB VOLCCAK ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/D ty.: ROBERT BIITNER Date/ Time: 08/26/2008 1000:00 Costs....: $16.00 Pd By: 00/00/0000 ------------------------------------------------------------------- 8/27/2008 SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: Regular) Litigant.: BRANNIGAN EUGENE Address..: 2500 LISBURN ROAD Cty_/St/Zp• CAMP HILL, PA 17011 Hnd To: BBOB VOLCCAK, ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/D ty.: ROBERT BITNER Date/ Time: 08/26/2008 1000:00 Costs....: $16.00 Pd By: 00/00/0000 ----------------------------------------------------- --------------- 9/16/2008 DORIANPESFOR ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FOR ALL DEFTS - Y RAYMOND W ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9/16/2008 DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL - BY RAYMOND W DORIAN ATTY OR DEFTS ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9/16/2008 PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT - DEFTS MO tON FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO RESPOND - BY RAYMOND W DORI ATTY FOR DEFTS ------------------------------------------------- +-- 9/16/2008 CORRECTIONS DEFTS MOTION FOR EXTENSION TO TIME TO RESPOND TO PLFFS COMPLAINT - BY RAYMOND W DORIAN ATTY FOR ALL DEFT ------------------------------------------------- ----------------- 10/02/2008 PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT - DEFTS PR 'IMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT - BY RAYMOND W DORI ATTY FOR DEFTS -------------- i----------------------------------- ,----------_------ 10/02/2008 CORRECTIONS DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT BY RAYMOND W DORIAN ATTY FOR DEFTS 10/27/2008 PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR ENLARGEMENT OF TIME TO-FIL 'RESPONSE BRIEF TO DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS - BY JAMES A PALU k JR PLFF PRO SE --------------------------------------------------- ',----------------- 10/27/2008 ORDER OF COURT - 10/24108 - DEFTS ARE GRANTED UNT L 12/1/08 TO PLEAD TO PLFFS COMPLAINT - BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J PIES MAILED 10/27/08 PYS511 Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Civil Case Print 2008-04835 PALUCH JAMES A JR (vs) PA DEPT OF CORRECTIONS ET AL Reference No..: Filed.... Case Ty e..... . COMPLAINT Time. ... Judgmen?...... : .00 Execution Judge Assigned: HESS KEVIN A Jury Tria Disposed Desc.: Disposed ------------ Case Comments ------------- Higher Cr Higher Cr -------------------------------------------------- 10/30/2008 ANSWER AND NEW MATTER OF KRISTEN BARBACCI TO THE C, JAMES A PALUCH - BY ALAN S GOLD ATTY FOR DEFT KRIS' ---------------------------------------------- 10/30/2008 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FOR DEFT KRISTEN BARBACCI - BY -------------------------------------------------- 10/30/2008 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED - BY ALAN S GOLD ATTY FOR DEFT BARBACCI -------------------------------------------------- 11/03/2008 ORDER OF COURT - 11/3/08 - THE ORDER ENTERED ON 10 DEFTS UNTIL 12/1/08 TO PLEAD TO PLFFS COMPLAINT IS IMPROVIDENTLY ENTERED - DEFTS FILED PRELIMINARY OB PLFFS MAILEDCO1/4 DINT ON 10/2/08 - BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J - -------------------------------------------------- 11/03/2008 ORDER OF COURT - 11/3/08 IN RE: PRELIMINARY OBJECT COMPLAINT - DEFTS HAVING FILED A BRIEF ON THEIR PR OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT - PLFF IS ALLOWED 60 FROM THIS DATE TO FILE A RESPONSE BRIEF IN THIS JU THE PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS WILL THEN BE DECIDED ON EDGAR B BAYLEY J - COPIES MAILED 11/4/08 -------------------------------------------------- 12/11/2008 NOTICE OF INTENT TO SERVE A SUBPOENA PURSUANT TO P. BY ALAN S GOLD ATTY FOR DEFT KRISTEN BARBACCI -------------------------------------------------- 12/12/2008 PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR ENLARGEMENT OF TIME TO RESP BARBACCIS NEW MATTER - BY PLFF -------------------------------------------------- 12/16/2008 ORDER - 12/16/08 IN RE: PLFFS MOTION FOR ENLARGEME RESPOND TO DEFT BARBACCIS NEW MATTER - IT IS ORDER MOTION IS GRNATED - BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J - COPIES M -------------------------------------------------- 1/07/2009 PLAINTIFF'S ANSWER AND MOTION TO STRIKE DEFT BARBA - BY PLFF -------------------------------------------------- 1/07/2009 PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO STRIKE CORRECTIONS DEFTS PRE OBJECTIONS - BY PLFF -------------------------------------------------- 1/07/2009 PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR ENLARGEMENT OF TIME TO FILE DOCUMENTS - BY PLFF ------------------------------------------------ 1/07/2009 PLAINTIFF'S PRACIPE FOR NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRES -------------------------------------------------- 1/22/2009 ORDER OF COURT - 1/21/09 - IT IS ORDERED THAT DEFT OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT SHALL BE DECIDED BY BRIEFS ONLY - BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J - COPIES MAILED -------------------------------------------------- 1/28/2009 PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR ENLARGEMNET OF TIME TO FILE DEFT BARBACCIS NOTICE OF SUBPOENA NUNC PRO TUNC - -------------------------------------------------- 1/30/2009 RESPONSE OF KRISTEN BARBACCI TO PLFFS MOTION TO ST GOLD ATTY FOR DEFT BARBACCI -------------------------------------------------- 2/02/2009 ORDER - 1/30/09 IN RE: PLFFS MOTION FOR ENLARGEMEN FILE OBJECTIONS TO DEFT BARBACCIS NOTICE OF SUBPOE - PLFFS MOTION IS GRANTED - BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J - 2/2/09 -------------------------------------------------- 2/11/2009 RESPONSE TO PLFS REQUEST FOR ENLARGEMENT OF TIME T BARBACCIS SUBPOENA FOR MEDICAL RECORDS - BY ALAN S DEFT BARBACCI -------------------------------------------------- 3/09/2009 PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS TO DEFT BARBACCIS SUBPOENA PROTECTIVE ORDER - BY PLFF -------------------------------------------------- 4/16/2009 ORDER OF COURT - 16/09 - IN RE: PRELIMINARY OBJE DEFTS ARE SUSTAINED - COMPLAINT AGAINST ALL DEFTS BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J - COPIES MAILED 4/16/09 Date Date. t 2.. Page 5 8/12/2008 0/00/0000 0/00/0000 ---------------- MPLAINT OF ?EN BARBACCI ---------------- ALAN S GOLD ESQ ---------------- KRISTEN ---------------- ;24/08 GRANTING VACATED AS ECTIONS TO COPIES ---------------- ONS TO PLFFS LIMINARY ADDITIONAL DAYS GES CHAMBERS - THE BRIEFS - BY ---------------- RCP 4009.22 - ---------------- ND TO DEFT ---------------- T OF TIME TO D THAT PLFFS ILED 12/16/08 ---------------- CIS NEW MATTER ---------------- IMINARY .---------------- SUPPORTING BY PLFF PRELIMINARY HIS JUDGE ON /22/09 ---------------- OBJECTIONS TO Y PLFF IKE - BY ALAN S ---------------- OF TIME TO A NUNC PRO TUNC OPIES MAILED ---------------- OBJECT TO GOLD ATTY FOR ---------------- ND MOTION FOR ---------------- TIONS OF ALL S DISMISSED - PYS511 Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Civil Case Print 2008-04835 PALUCH JAMES A JR (vs) PA DEPT OF CORRECTIONS ET AL Reference No..: Filed.... Case Tyyppe..... . COMPLAINT Time. ... Jud ment...... : .00 Execution Judge Assigned: HESS KEVIN A Jury Tria. Disposed Desc.: Disposed ------------ Case Comments ------------- Higher Cr Higher Cr -------------------------------------------------- 5/08/2009 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON BEHALF OF KRISTIAN ALAN S GOLD ATTY FOR DEFT KRISTIAN BARBACCI -------------------------------------------------- 3/04/2010 ORDER - PETITIONER HAS FILED AN APPLICATION FOR RE; COURT DESCRIBING (WITHOUT DOCUMENTATION) HIS ATTEM NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM THE DISMISSAL ORDERS OF APRI, PETITONER ASSERTS THAT THE TRIAL COURT REFUSED TO NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RETURNED THAT DOCUMENT TO HIM PETITIONER'S APPLICATION FOR RELIEFF IS GRANTED TO EXTENT: TO THE EXTENT THE PETITIONER HAS BEEN ATTE: NOTICE OF APPEAL THE TRIAL COURT IS DIRECTED TO AC SUCH DOCUMENT IF SUBMITTED TO THE CUMBERLAND COUNT FOR FILING - THE TRIAL COURT SHALL THE TRANSMIT AN APPEAL TO THIS COURT WHICH WILL ULTIMATELY MAKE A TO THE VALIDITY OF THE APPEAL - SEE PA RAP 902 - P -------------------------------------------------- 4/28/2010 PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR INTERVENTION - BY JAMES A P -------------------------------------------------- 5/21/2010 DEFENDANTS ANSWER TO PLFFS MOTION FOR INTERVENTION DORIAN ATTY FOR DEFTS -------------------------------------------------- 6/17/2010 PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED MOTION FOR COURT INTERVENTION PALUCH JR PLFF PRO SE -------------------------------------------------- 7/01/2010 ORDER - DATED 06-28-10 - IN RE: PLAINTIFFS AMENDED COURT INTERVENTION - THE COURT BEING SATISFIED THA COMPLAINTS CONCERNING A VIOLATION OF THE ORDER OF SYLVIA H RAMBO ARE MORE PROPERLY DIRECTED TOWARDS COURT, HIS AMENDED MOTION FOR COURT INTERVENTION I KEVIN A HESS J - COPIES MAILED - - - - - - - - - - - - - - LAST ENTRY - - - - - 'Date ate. 2.. Page 6 8/12/2008 8:55 0/00/0000 0/00/0000 ---------------- ARBACCI - BY ---------------- `IEF IN THIS TS TO FILE A 16, 2009 - bCKET HIS UN-FILED - THE FOLLOWING PTING TO FILE A EAND DOCKET PROTHONOTARY SUCH NOTICE OF DETERMINATION AS ,R CURIAM ,LUCH JR BY RAYMOND W ---------------- BY JAMES A ---------------- MOTION FOR THE PLAINTIFFS HE HONORABLE HE FEDERAL DENIED - BY * Escrow Information * Fees & Debits Be *Bal***Pymts/Ad' End Bal ******************************** **** ****** ******************************* SUBPOENA 3.00 3.00 .00 ------------------------ ------------ 3.00 3.00 .00 * End of Case Information TRUE COPY FR RECORD In TeMk=W wl MA I ka" wNo sa aw pond .nWw..,IN.?wtP& 16 w i k i $ t1?M1U 1'yiN1 t ? k?y6 tMt ?,f iy+.::+.:. oil .icy ,t1MMti11?lMIM3M?sMIrN sd? Orr! tr'? Karen Reid Bramblett, Esq. Prothonotary Milan K. Mrkobrad, Esq. Deputy Prothonotary RE: James Paluch Appellant Middle District November 24, 2010 Pennsylvania Judicial Center P.O. Box 62435 601 Commonwealth Avenue, Suite 1600 Harrisburg, PA 17106-2435 (717) 772-1294 www, superior. court. state. pa. us v. Pennsylvania Department of Corrections, Edward Ayers, Matthew Yohn, Eric Kline, Adam Huber, Mark Simpson, Robert Kreider, Richard Southers, Zachary Moslak, Donald Kelchner 1909 MDA 2010 Trial Court Docket No: 2008-6175 Dear James Paluch Enclosed please find a copy of the docket for the above appeal that was recently filed in the Superior Court. Kindly review the information on this docket and notify this office in writing if you believe any corrections are required. Appellant's counsel is also being sent a Docketing Statement, pursuant to Pa.R.A.P. 3517, for completion and filing. Please note that Superior Court Dockets are available on the Internet at the Web site address printed at the top of this page. Thank you. Respectfully, Milan K. Mrkobrad, Esq. Deputy Prothonotary /bg Enclosure cc: Buell, David D., Prothonotary Court Reporter c' Raymond W. Dorian, Esq. c The Honorable Kevin A. Hess, President Judge a) -rn rn zm rn C' rn? -v r ? A Iv rn CD -- c:) <c7 =C 2 O ? N Cl a CO A W 4:18 P.M. Appeal Docket Sheet Docket Number: 1909 MDA 2010 Page 1 of 5 November 24, 2010 CAPTION James Paluch Appellant Superior Court of Pennsylvania Secure v. Pennsylvania Department of Corrections, Edward Ayers, Matthew Yohn, Eric Kline, Adam Huber, Mark Simpson, Robert Kreider, Richard Southers, Zachary Moslak, Donald Kelchner CASE INFORMATION Initiating Document: Notice of Appeal IFP Case Status: Case Processing Status: Journal Number: Case Category: Active November 24, 2010 Civil CONSOLIDATED CASES Awaiting Original Record Case Type(s): Docket No / Reason 1910 MDA 2010 Similar Issue(s) SCHEDULED EVENT Next Event Type: Original Record Received Next Event Type: Receive Docketing Statement Next Event Type: Receive Docketing Statement COUNSEL INFORMATION Appellant Paluch, James Pro Se: Yes Appoint Counsel Status: Not Represented IFP Status: Yes Pro Se: Paluch, James Address: BQ 3769, SCI Smithfield 1120 Pike St. PO Box 999 Huntingdon, PA 16652--0999 Phone No: Fax No: Receive Mail: Yes Receive EMail: No Civil Action Law RELATED CASES Related Next Event Due Date: November 8, 2010 Next Event Due Date: December 8, 2010 Next Event Due Date: December 8, 2010 4:18 P.M. Appeal Docket Sheet Docket Number: 1909 MDA 2010 Page 2 of 5 November 24, 2010 COUNSEL INFORMATION Appellee Yohn, Matthew Pro Se: No IFP Status: No Attorney: Bar No: Law Firm: Address: Appoint Counsel Status: Represented Dorian, Raymond W. 048148 PA Department of Corrections PA Dept of Corrections 1920 Technology Pkwy Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Phone No: (717) 728-7763 Fax No: Receive Mail: No Receive EMail: No Superior Court of Pennsylvania Secure Appellee Simpson, Mark Pro Se: No Appoint Counsel Status: Represented IFP Status: No Attorney: Dorian, Raymond W. Bar No: 048148 Law Firm: PA Department of Corrections Address: PA Dept of Corrections 1920 Technology Pkwy Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Phone No: (717) 728-7763 Fax No: Receive Mail: No Receive EMail: No Appellee Ribchard, Southers Pro Se: No Appoint Counsel Status: Represented IFP Status: No Attorney: Dorian, Raymond W. Bar No: 048148 Law Firm: PA Department of Corrections Address: PA Dept of Corrections 1920 Technology Pkwy Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Phone No: (717) 728-7763 Fax No: Receive Mail: No Receive EMail: No 4:18 RK Appeal Docket Sheet Superior Court of Pennsylvania Docket Number: 1909 MDA 2010 Page 3 of 5 Secure November 24, 2010 COUNSEL INFORMATION Appellee Moslak, Zachary Pro Se: No Appoint Counsel Status: Represented IFP Status: No Attorney: Dorian, Raymond W. Bar No: 048148 Law Firm: PA Department of Corrections Address: PA Dept of Corrections 1920 Technology Pkwy Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Phone No: (717) 728-7763 Fax No: Receive Mail: No Receive EMail: No Appellee Kreider, Robert Pro Se: No Appoint Counsel Status: Represented IFP Status: No Attorney: Dorian, Raymond W. Bar No: 048148 Law Firm: PA Department of Corrections Address: PA Dept of Corrections 1920 Technology Pkwy Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Phone No: (717) 728-7763 Fax No: Receive Mail: No Receive EMail: No Appellee Kline, Eric Pro Se: No IFP Status: No Attorney: Bar No: Law Firm: Address: Appoint Counsel Status: Represented Dorian, Raymond W. 048148 PA Department of Corrections PA Dept of Corrections 1920 Technology Pkwy Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Phone No: (717) 728-7763 Fax No: Receive Mail: No Receive Entail: No 4:18 PA Appeal Docket Sheet Docket Number: 1909 MDA 2010 Page 4 of 5 November 24, 2010 Appellee Kel Pro Se: No IFP Status: No Attorney: Bar No: Law Firm: Address: Superior Court of Pennsylvania Secure COUNSEL INFORMATION chner, Donald Appoint Counsel Status: Represented Dorian, Raymond W. 048148 PA Department of Corrections PA Dept of Corrections 1920 Technology Pkwy Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Phone No: (717) 728-7763 Fax No: Receive Mail: No Receive EMail: No Appellee Department of Corrections Pro Se: No Appoint Counsel Status: Represented IFP Status: Attorney: Dorian, Raymond W. Bar No: 048148 Law Firm: PA Department of Corrections Address: PA Dept of Corrections 1920 Technology Pkwy Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Phone No: (717) 728-7763 Fax No: Receive Mail: Yes Receive EMail: No Appellee Ayers, Edaward Pro Se: No Appoint Counsel Status: Represented IFP Status: No Attorney: Dorian, Raymond W. Bar No: 048148 Law Firm: PA Department of Corrections Address: PA Dept of Corrections 1920 Technology Pkwy Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Phone No: (717) 728-7763 Fax No: Receive Mail: No Receive EMail: No 4:18 P.M. Appeal Docket Sheet Docket Number: 1909 MDA 2010 Page 5 of 5 November 24, 2010 Appellee Adams, Huber COUNSEL INFORMATION Pro Se: No IFP Status: No Attorney: Bar No: Law Firm: Address: 1920 Technology Pkwy Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Phone No: (717) 728-7763 Fax No: Receive Mail: No Receive EMail: No Superior Court of Pennsylvania Secure AGENCYITRIAL COURT INFORMATION Court Below: Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas County: Cumberland Division: Order Appealed From: Judicial District: Documents Received: November 24, 2010 Notice of Appeal Filed: Order Type: OTN(s): Lower Ct Docket No(s):2008-6175 Lower Ct Judge(s): Hess, Kevin A. President Judge ORIGINAL RECORD CONTENT Original Record Item Filed Date Date of Remand of Record: Appoint Counsel Status: Represented Dorian, Raymond W. 048148 PA Department of Corrections PA Dept of Corrections BRIEFING SCHEDULE None Cumberland County Civil Division 09 September 7, 2010 Content None DOCKET ENTRY Filed Date Docket Entry / Representing Participant Type Filed By November 24, 2010 Notice of Appeal IFP Docketed Appellant Paluch, James Comment: Awaiting proof of service of appeal upon t/c judge, crt reporter, crt admin & opposing counsel November 24, 2010 Docketing Statement Exited (Civil) Middle District Filing Office November 24, 2010 Application for Relief Comment: and appointment of counsel. Appellant Paluch, James November 24, 2010 Docketing Statement Exited (Civil) Middle District Filing Office JAMES A. PALUCH, JR., Plaintiff VS. PA. DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, ET AL., : Defendants IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 08-6175 CIVIL IN RE: APPEAL OF PLAINTIFF M, &,i ORDER ?'eco?rn?,?.Gn. AND NOW, Nwamffbm 3, 2010, in accordance with Rule 1925 of the Rules of Appellate Procedure, the Plaintiff having filed a notice of appeal, the appellant is directed to file of record, within twenty-one (21) days hereof, and serve upon the undersigned a concise statement of the matters complained of on the appeal. Any issue not properly included in the concise statement timely filed and served pursuant to Rule 1925(b) shall be deemed waived. BY THE COURT, /?Ix Kevin . Hess, P. J. ?es A. Paluch, Jr. BQ3769 SCI-Smithfield 1120 Pike Street Huntingdon, PA 16652 Plaintiff aymond Dorian, Esquire Assistant Counsel - PA DOC 55 Utley Drive Camp Hill, PA 17011-8028 Arn cz?' Z) es mat LL /.L 3!!O c q c? ?r -0m ?a --< '*> w o ro ? : M -? o n CERTIFICATE AND TRANSMITTAL OF RECORDS UNDER PENNSYLVANIA RULE OF APPELLATE PROCEDURE 1931_(C) To the Prothonotary of the Apellate Court to which the within matter has been appealed: Superior Court of Pennsylvania The undersigned, Prothonotary of the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, the said court being a court of record, do hereby certify that annexed hereto is a true and correct copy of the whole and entire record, including an opinion of the court as required by PA R.A.P. 1925, the original papers and exhibits, if any on file, the transcript of the proceedings, if any, and the docket entries in the following matter: James A. Paluch, Jr. Vs. PA Department of Corrections Et. al. 2008-6175 Civil 1909 MDA 2010 The documents comprising the record have been numbered from No.l to 130, and attached hereto as Exhibit A is a list of the documents correspondingly numbered and identified with reasonable definiteness, including with respect to each document, the number of pages comprising the document. The date on which the record has been transmitted to the Appellate Court is 01/11/2011 -A 1) L?j D uell, rothonotary Regina Lebo, Deputy An additional cony of this certificate is enclosed. Please sign and date copy, thereby acknowledging receipt of this record. Date Signature & Title Commonwealth of Pennsylvania County of Cumberland ss: I, David D. Buell , Prothonotary of the Court of Common Pleas in and for said County, do hereby certify that the foregoing is a full, true and correct copy of the whole record of the case therein stated, wherein James A. Paluch, Jr. Plaintiff, and PA Deparment of Corrections et.al. Defendant, as the same remains of record before the said Court at No. 2008-6175 of Civil Term. In 'TESTIMONY WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the seal of said Court this 11 day of r--4nuaXy A. D., 2011 Prothonotary I, Kevin A. Hess President Judge of the Judicial District, composed of the County of Cumberland, do certify that Ninth David D. Buell , by whom the annexed record, certificate and attestation were made and given, and who, in his own proper handwriting, thereunto subscribed his name and affixed the seal of the Court of Common Pleas of said County, was, at the time of so doing, and now is Prothonotary in and for said County of Cumberland in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, duty commissioned and qualified to all of whose acts as such full faith and credit are and ought to be given as well in Courts of judicature as elsewhere, and that the said record, certificate and attestation are in due form of law and =3??7 er. f 0? Pre sident Judge Commonwealth of Pennsylvania County of Cumberland ss: I David D. Buell , Prothonotary bf the Court of Common Pleas in and for the said County, do certify that the Honorable Kevin A. Hess by whom the foregoing attestation was made, and who has thereunto subscribed his name, was, at the time of making thereof, and still is President Judge of the Court of Common Pleas, Orphan' Court and Court of Quarter Sessions of the Peace in and for said County, duly Commissioned and qualified; to all whose acts as such full faith and credit are and ought to be given, as well in Courts of judicature as elsewhere. IN TESTIMONY WHEREOF, I have hereunto setlmy hand and affixed the seat of said Court this y f January A. D. 2011 Prothonotary No. Term l9 No. 2008-6175 Civil Term 1909 MDA 2010 James A. Paluch, Jr. Versus PA Department of Corrections et. al. EXEMPLIFIED RECORD From Cumberland County Debt; . . . $ Int. from Costs Entered and Filed Prothonotary. Among the Records and Proceedings enrolled in the court of Common Pleas in and for the Cumberland county c° 2008-6175 in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania to No. 1909 MDA 2010 Term, 19 is contained the following: COPY OF Appearance DOCKET ENTRY James A. Paluch, Jr. vs. PA Department of Corrections et. al. **SEE CERTIFIED COPY OF DOCKET ENTERIES** rz551s uumneriana youn.zy ?,rornonozary,s urrice Civil Case Print rage 1 2008-06175 PALUCH JAMES A JR (vs) PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF COR Reference No ... Case TTyyp?e..... COMPLAINT Jud ment Filed. Time. .... 10/16/2008 11.23 g . Judge Assigned: .00 Execution Date 0/00/0000 Disposed Desc.: DISMISSED Jury Trial.... ------------ Case Comments ------------- Disposed Date. Higher Crt 1 4/092009 1909 .: Higher Crt 2.: M A2010 *************************** ********************* *********************** General Index Attorney Info ********* PALUCH JAMES A JR SCI SMITHFIELD PLAINTIFF PRO SE 1120 PIKE STREET PO BOX 999 HUNTINGTON PA 16652 PENNSYVLANIA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W 2520 LISBURN ROAD P 0 BOX 598 CAMP HILL PA 17001 0598 AYERS EDWARD SCI 2500 LISBURN ROAD DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W P 0 BOX 8837 CAMP HILL PA 17001 8837 YOHN MATTHEW SCI 2500 LISBURN ROAD DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W P 0 BOX 8837 CAMP HILL PA 17001 8837 KLINE ERIC SCI 2500 LISBURN ROAD DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W P 0 BOX 8837 CAMP HILL PA 17001 8837 HUBER ADAMS SCI 2500 LISBURN ROAD DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W P 0 BOX 8837 CAMP HILL PA 17001 8837 SIMPSON MARK SCI 2500 LISBURN ROAD DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W P 0 BOX 8837 CAMP HILL PA 17001 8837 KREIDER ROBERT DEFENDANT SCI 2500 LISBURN ROAD P 0 BOX 8837 CAMP HILL PA 17001 8837 SOUTHERS RIBCHARD SCI 2500 LISBURN ROAD DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W P 0 BOX 8837 CAMP HILL PA 17001 8837 MOSLAK ZACHARY SCI 2500 LISBURN ROAD DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W P 0 BOX 8837 CAMP HILL PA 17001 8837 KELCHNER DONALD L SCI 2500 LISBURN ROAD DEFENDANT DORIAN RAYMOND W P 0 BOX 8837 CAMP HILL PA 17001 8837 ******************************************************************************** * Date Entries ******************************************************************************** - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 10/16/2008 COMPLAINT - CIVIL ACTION FILEDSBYEPLFF ---------------------------------------------- cumber_Lana county ?rotnonot.ary's ottice Page 2 Civil Case Print 2008-06175 PALUCH JAMES A JR (vs) PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF COR Reference No..: Case Type... COMPLAINT Judgment. Judge Assigned: Disposed Desc.: DISMISSED ------------ Case Comments a-7 10/16/2008 10/27/2008 a 3 10/31/2008 j[,? 10/31/2008 05 10/31/2008 c?& 10/31/2008 a -? 10/31/2008 oZ? 10/31/2008 J? 10/31/2008 Filed......... 10/16/2008 00 Time. 11 23 Execution Date 0/00/0000 Jury Trial.... - - - - - - Disposed Date. 4/09/2009 Higggher Crt 1.: 1909 MDA2010 H 2.: PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO PROCEED IN 1FORMACPAUPERIS - BY JAMES PALUCH R PLFF PRO SE ------------------------------------------------------------------- ORDER OF COURT - 10/24/08 IN RE: MOTION OF PLFF TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS - MOTION IS GRANTED - BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J - COPIES MAILED 10/24/08 ------------------------------------------------------------------- SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. Case TTyyppe: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret T e.: Reggular Litigant.: PENNSYVLANIA DEPARTMENT OF ORRECTIONS Address..: 55 UTLEY DRIVE Q /St/Z • CAMP HILL, PA 17011 To: ROBERT J VOLCIAK, ASSISTANT SUPERINTENDANT, Shf/D ty.: GERALD WORTHINGTON Date/ Time: 10/29/2008 1555:00 Costs ..___-$42_00-Pd-By: 00/00/0000 ------- --------- SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. - - -- --- _ _ _ Case TTyyppe: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: Regular Litigant.: AYERS EDWARD Add ess..: SCI CAMP HILL 2500 LISBURN ROAD Cty/St/Zg• CAMP HILL, PA 17001-8837 Shfdd/Too: TACY SENTZ ADMIN OFFICER, ADULT IN CHARGE DateDTity.: GERALD 10/29/2008 1550:00 Costs ....:$30.00 Pd By: 00/00/0000 --------- --------- SHERIFF'S FILE-RETURNED FILED. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ---------- Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: Regular Litigant.: YOHN MATTHEW Address..: SCI CAMP HILL 2500 LISBURN ROAD Ctyy/St/Zp • CAMP HILL, PA 17001-8837 Hnd To: BTACY SENTZ, ADMIN OFFICER, ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/Dp ty.: GERALD WORTHINGTON ime: $16.0010/29/2008 Pd 8By: 00/00/0000 ----------------------------------- ------------------------------ SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. -- Case TTyyppe: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: Regular Litigant.: KLINE ERIC Address..: SCI CAMP HILL 2500 LISBURN ROAD Q/ T To: To: ACYMSENTZ, ADMIN7OFFICER, ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/Dpty.: GERALD WORTHINGTON Date/ im Costs.... $16.0010/29/2008 Pd 8By: 00/00/0000 -------------- __ --------------------------------------- SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. ----------- Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: Regular Litigant.: HUBER ADAMS Address..: SCI CAMP HILL 2500 LISBURN ROAD CtdHnd/ 88 To: To: TACYMSENTZ, ADMIN7OFFICER, ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/D ty.: GERALD WORTHINGTON Date/Time: 10/29/2008 1550:00 Costs ..__,-$16.00 Pd By: 00/00/0000 ------- ------- ____________________ _____ SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. - Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: Regular Litigant.: SIMPSON MARK Address..: SCI CAMP HILL 2500 LISBURN ROAD Q/ T To: ACCYSENTZL' ADMIN 17001-8837 ADULT IN CHARGE Shf/D ty.: GERALD WORTHINGTON Date/ ime: Costs .... : $16.0010/29/2008 Pd 8By: 00/00/0000 -- --- ________________________ SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. ---- Cumberland. County Frotnonotaryls Ottice Pa e .j Civil Case Print g 2008-06175 PALUCH JAMES A JR (vs) PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF COR Reference No..: Filed........: 10/16/2008 Case Type ..... COMPLAINT Time. Judgment. .00 Execution Date 0 11.23 Judge Assigned: Jury Trial.... /00/0000 Disposed Desc.: DISMISSED ------------ Case Comments -------- ----- Crt 1Date. 4/09/20 D2 09 --'-- Higher .: 19009 9 MA2010 Case Ty? COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type Higher Crt 2.: Litigant.: KREIDER ROBERT Regular Address..: SCI CAMP HILL 2500 LISBURN ROAD Cty/: CAMP HILL/ PA Hn To 17001-8837 dd To: ADULT IN CHARGE S Date/ hf/Dpty.: GERALD WORTHINGTON Costs .... : $16.0010/29/2008 Pd By: 00/00/0000 ------------------------------------------------------- 30 10/31/2008 SHERIFF'S FILE RETURNED FILED. ---------- ' - Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: Regular Litigant.: SOUTHERS RICHARD Address..: SCI CAMP HILL 2500 LISBURN ROAD Cty/To: TACCYSENTZ, ADMIN7OFFICER, ADULT IN CHARGE Shf /Dpt Date/ Time: 10/29/2008 1550:00 Costs....: $16.00 Pd By: 00/00/0000 --------------------------- .3f 10/31/2008 SHERIFF'S-FILE-RETURNED- -FILED. _ _ _ _ _ _ ---------- Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: Regular Litigant.: MOSLAK ZACHARY Address..: 55 UTLEY DRIVE Hn To: R Hn To : OBECR PJHVOLCIAK,lASSISTANT SUPERINTENDENT Shf/Dp ty.: GERALD WORTHINGTON Costs Time: $16.001029/2008 Pd 8By: 00/00/0000 ------------ -------------- ,3a 10/31/2008 SHERIFF'S FILE-RETURNED- -FILED. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Case Type: COMPLAINT & NOTICE Ret Type.: Not Found Litigant.: KELCHNER DONALD L Address..: SCI CAMP HILL 2500 LISBURN ROAD Costs .... : $16.00 Pd?By: 00/00/0000 Service Attempts: 1st: 0/00/0000 2nd: 0/00/0000 DEFENDANT IS RETIRED. ------------------------- _ _ _ ___ ----------------- 3 3-,3V,4 11/12/2008 ERAEECIPE FOR ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FOR DEFTS - BY RAYMOND W DORIAN ----------------------------- _ _________ -------------------- 33-3yA 11 12/2008 DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL - BY RAYMOND W DORIAN ATTY FOR DEFTS ------------------------------------ __________ 11/18/2008 DEFENDANT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS - BY RAYMOND W DORIAN ATTYF OR DEFT PA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS S(o 11/18/2008 PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT - DEFTS PRELIMINARY ------------------------------------------------------------------- OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT - BY RAYMOND W DORIAN ATTY FOR DEFT PA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS --------- ----------- 57- 1/07/2009 PLAINTIFF'S-MOTION-TO-STRIKE CORRECTIONS DEFTS _ PRELIMINARY --------- OBJECTIONS - BY PLFF --------- --------------------------- 510- 1/07/2009 PLAINTIFF'S-MOTION FOR-ENLARGMENT OF TIME - TO - FILE _ SUPPORTING ------- DOCUMENTS - BY PLFF 1/07/2009 P LAINTIFF'S PRAECIPE FOR NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS - BY PLFF ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4/09/2009 OPINION AND ORDER OF COURT - 4/9/09 IN RE: PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ------------------------------------------------------------------- OF DEFTS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT - PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS AR SUSTAINED AND THE COMPLAINT IS DISMISSED - BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J - COPIES MAILED 4/9/09 3/04/2010 ORDER - PETITIONER HAS FILED AN APPLICATION FOR RELIEF IN THIS ------------------------------------------------------------------- COURT DESCRIBING (WITHOUT DOCUMENTATION) HIS ATTEMPTS TO FILE A NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM THE DISMISSAL ORDERS OF APRIL 16 2009 - PETITONER ASSERTS THAT THE TRIAL COURT REFUSED TO DOCKkT HIS NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RETURNED THAT DOCUMENT TO HIM UN-FILED - Cumberland County Prothonotary's Ottice Page 4 Civil Case Print 2008-06175 PALUCH JAMES A JR (vs) PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF COR Reference No... Filed. 10/16/2008 Case TTyyppe. COMPLAINT Time. 11:23 Judgment. .00 Execution Date 0/00/0000 Judge Assigned: Jury Trial.... Disposed Desc.: DISMISSED Disposed Date. 4/09/2009 Case Comments ------------- Higher Crt 1.: 1909 MDA2010 PETITIONER'S APPLICATION FOR RELIEFF IS GRANTED TOtTHE FOLLOWING EXTENT: TO THE EXTENT THE PETITIONER HAS BEEN ATTEMPTING TO FILE A NOTICE OF APPEAL THE TRIAL COURT IS DIRECTED TO ACCEPT AND DOCKET SUCH DOCUMENT IF SUBMITTED TO THE CUMBERLAND COUNTY PROTHONOTARY FOR FILING - THE TRIAL COURT SHALL THE TRANSMIT ANY SUCH NOTICE OF APPEAL TO THIS COURT WHICH WILL ULTIMATELY MAKE A DETERMINATION AS TO THE VALIDITY OF THE APPEAL - SEE PA RAP 902 - PER CURIAM ------------------------- _ _ _ _________ ------------ -143 4/28/2010 PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR INTERVENTION - BY JAMES A PALUCH JR --------------------- ______ 5/21/2010 DEFENDANTS ANSWER TO PLFFS MOTION FOR INTERVENTION - BY RAYMOND W DORIAN ATTY FOR DEFTS ------------------------ i/3 6/17/2010 PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED MOTION FOR COURT INTERVENTION - BY JAMES A PALUCH JR PLFF PRO SE Ily 7/01/2010 O RDER - DATED 06-28-10 - IN RE: PLAINTIFFS AMENDED MOTION FOR ------------------------------------------------------------------- COURT INTERVENTION - THE COURT BEING SATISFIED THAT THE PLAINTIFFS COMPLAINTS CONCERNING A VIOLATION OF THE ORDER OF THE HONORABLE SYLVIA H RAMBO ARE MORE PROPERLY DIRECTED TOWARDS THE FEDERAL COURT, HIS AMENDED MOTION FOR COURT INTERVENTION IS DENIED - BY KEVIN A HESS J - COPIES MAILED ------------------------------- IISS 9/07/2010 PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO PROCEED ON APPEAL IN FORMA PAUPERIS - BY JAMES A PALUCH JR PLFF PRO SE ---------------------------------------- --------------------------- I/6-/?2D 9/07/2010 NOTICE OF APPEAL TO SUPERIOR COURT - NUNC PRO TUNC - BY JAMES A PALUCH JR PLFF PRO SE ----------------------------- __ ----------------------------------- 12/02/2010 SUPERIOR COURT OF PA NOTICE OF APPEAL DOCKETING TO #1909 MDA 2010 ---------------------- _ -------------- 12/03/2010 ORDER - 12 3/10 IN RE: APPEAL OF PLAINTIFF - BY KEVIN A HESS PJ - COPIES MAI ED 12/3/10 ----------------------- _ _ _ __ -------------------------------- lag-I3o 1 05/2011 IN RE: OPINION PURSUANT TO RULE 1925 - 1/5/11 BY KEVIN A HESS PJ COPIES MAILED 1/5/11 ------------------------ _ _ _ __ ------------------------- _ 1 11/2011 NOTICE OF DOCKET ENTRIES MAILED TO RAYMOND DORIAN ESQ AND JAMES A PALUCH JR - - - - - - - - - - - - - - LAST ENTRY - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ------------------------ ------------ .00 .00 .00 ******************************************************************************** * End of Case Information ******************************************************************************** TRUE COPY FROM RECORD In and the sW of am Y w ,1 here unto set my hand at Caakae, Pa. ThW -. / day Of Rn. 20 Protho • CERTIFICATE AND TRANSMITTAL OF RECORDS UNDER PENNSYLVANIA RULE OF APPELLATE PROCEDURE 1931 (C) To the Prothonotary of the Apellate Court to which the within matter has been appealed: Superior Court of Pennsylvania The undersigned, Prothonotary of the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, the said court being a court of record, do hereby certify that annexed hereto is a true and correct copy of the whole and entire record, including an opinion of the court as required by PA R.A.P. 1925, the original papers and exhibits, if any on file, the transcript of the proceedings, if any, and the docket entries in the following matter: James A. Paluch, Jr. Vs. Received in Superior Court PA Department of Corrections Et. al. JAN 112011 2008-6175 Civil 1909 MDA 2010 The documents comprising the record have been numbered from No.1 to 130, and attached hereto as Exhibit A is a list of the documents correspondingly numbered and identified with reasonable definiteness, including with respect to each document, the number of pages comprising the document. The date on which the record has been transmitted to the Appellate Court is 01/11/2011 sz?)Yi David D. Buell, Prothonotary Regina Lebo, Deputy An additional cony of this certificate is enclosed. Please sian and date copy, thereby acknowledaina receipt of this record. Date Signature & Title CERTIFICATE AND TRANSMITTAL OF RECORDS UNDER PENNSYLVANIA RULE OF APPELLATE PROCEDURE 1931 (C) To the Prothonotary of the Apellate Court to which the within matter has been appealed: Superior Court of Pennsylvania The undersigned, Prothonotary of the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, the said court being a court of record, do hereby certify that annexed hereto is a true and correct copy of the whole and entire record, including an opinion of the court as required by PA R.A.P. 1925, the original papers and exhibits, if any on file, the transcript of the proceedings, if any, and the docket entries in the following matter: James A. Paluch, Jr. Vs. PA Department of Corrections Et. al. 2008-6175 Civil 1909 MDA 2010 The documents attached hereto identified with comprising the record have been numbered from_ No.1 t- "I" as Exhibit A is a list of the -+-- YPQ avid D. Buell Prothonotary Cumberland county Suite 100 One Courthouse Sq. Carlisle, PA 17013 RP ?- -, ?4 o a,'a +O A P J James: A. Paluch, Jr. BQ3'769 igmr POSTQ?® l Z hh[Y°iSOWE+s' 4 2 1 1?V 26 I Qb F RIM ZI ODE 17( T T- r13 C mac: 1 00 0-1112C RETURN - RE:F"L1 F lJT3A?l..E TO FORWARD *0419-09470-1 EsC ?/ ? r. 4 /l '