The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About09-3772?r ? PAUL F. D'EMILIO, ESQUIRE ATTORNEY I.D. #16654 PAUL M. SCHOFIELD, JR., ESQUIRE ATTORNEY I.D. #81894 905 W SPROUL ROAD, SUITE 105 THIS IS ARBITRATION MATTER ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF SPRINGFIELD, PA 19064 (610) 338-0338 LIBERTY MUTUAL GROUP COMMON PLEAS COURT OF AS SUBROGEE OF JAMES FRALEY CUMBERLAND COUNTY 2501 WILMINGTON ROAD NEW CASTLE, PA 16105 VS. NO. cA- 377A 0,4q, l (en4 BENJAMIN BISHOP 1251 HUNTERS RIDGE DRIVE MECHANICSBURG, PA 17050 CIVIL ACTION NOTICE YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. IF YOU WISH TO DEFEND AGAINST THE CLAIMS SET FORTH IN THE FOLLOWING PAGES, YOU MUST TAKE ACTION WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS AFTER THIS COMPLAINT AND NOTICE ARE SERVED, BY ENTERING A WRITTEN APPEARANCE PERSONALLY OR BY ATTORNEY AND FILING IN WRITING WITH THE COURT YOUR DEFENSES OR OBJECTIONS TO THE CLAIMS SET FORTH AGAINST YOU. YOU ARE WARNED THAT IF YOU FAIL TO DO SO THE CASE MAY PROCEED WITHOUT YOU AND A JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU BY THE COURT WITHOUT FURTHER NOTICE FOR ANY MONEY CLAIMED IN THE COMPLAINT OR FOR ANY OTHER CLAIM OR RELIEF REQUESTED BY THE PLAINTIFF. YOU MAY LOSE MONEY OR PROPERTY OR OTHER RIGHTS IMPORTANT TO YOU. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER„ GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW. THIS OFFICE CAN PROVIDE YOU WITH INFORMATION ABOUT HIRING A LAWYER. IF YOU CANNOT AFFORD TO HIRE A LAWYER, THIS OFFICE MAY BE ABLE TO PROVIDE YOU WITH INFORMATION ABOUT AGENCIES THAT MAY OFFER LEGAL SERVICES TO ELIGIBLE PERSONS AT A REDUCED FEE OR NO FEE. Court Administrator 4th Floor, Cumberland County Courthouse Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 240-6200 Lawyer Referral Service 4th Floor, Cumberland County Courthouse Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 240-6200 AVISO Le han demandado a usted an la corte. Si usted quiere defenderse de estas demandas expuestas an las paginas siguientes, usted tiene (20) dies de plazo a partir de la fecha de Is demands y Is notificacion. Usted debe presenter una apariencia escrite o an persona o por abogado y archivar an la corte sus defenses o sus objeciones a las demandas encontra de su persona. Sea avisado qua si usted no se defiende, la corte tomara medidas y puede entrar una orden contra usted sin previo aviso o notificacion o por cualgier queja o alivio qua espedido an la petition de demanda. Usted puede perder dinero, sus propiedades o otros derechos importantes pare usted. LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO INMEDIATAMENTE. SI NO TIENE ABOGADO O SI NO TIENE EL DINERO SUFICIENTE PARA PAGAR TAL SERVICIO, VAYA EN PERSONA O LLAME POR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DIRECCION SE ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE USTED PUEDE CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEGAL. Court Administrator 4th Floor, Cumberland County Courthouse Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 240-6200 Lawyer Referral Service 4th Floor, Cumberland County Courthouse Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 240-6200 PAUL F. D'EMILIO, ESQUIRE ATTORNEY I.D. #16654 PAUL M. SCHOFIELD, JR., ESQUIRE ATTORNEY I.D. #81894 905 W. SPROUL ROAD, SUITE 105 SPRINGFIELD, PA 19064 (610) 338-0338 THIS IS ARBITRATION MATTER LIBERTY MUTUAL GROUP AS SUBROGEE OF JAMES FRALEY 2501 WILMINGTON ROAD NEW CASTLE, PA 16105 VS. BENJAMIN BISHOP 1251 HUNTERS RIDGE DRIVE MECHANICSBURG, PA 17050 ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF COMMON PLEAS COURT OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY NO. CA- 377 Civ;LTerfn CIVIL ACTION NOTICE UNDER THE FAIR DEBT COLLECTION PRACTICES ACT, 15 U.S.C. §1601 (AS AMENDED) THE PENNSYLVANIA UNFAIR TRADE PRACTICES ACT AND CONSUMER PROTECTION LAW, 73 PA.CON.STAT.ANN. §201, ET. SEQ. ("THE ACTS") INASMUCH AS THE ACTS MAY APPLY, PLEASE BE ADVISED THAT THIS COMMUNICATION IS FROM A DEBT COLLECTOR. THIS IS AN ATTEMPT TO COLLECT A DEBT AND ANY INFORMATION OBTAINED WILL BE USED FOR THAT PURPOSE. COMPLAINT The Plaintiff, Liberty Mutual Group, by its attorney Paul F. D'Emilio, Esquire, bring this action upon a cause whereof the following is a statement: The Plaintiff, Liberty Mutual Group ("Plaintiff'), is a Corporation authorized to do business in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, having an address of 2501 Wilmington Road, New Castle, PA 16105. Plaintiff brings this action as subrogee of James Fraley (herein the "Insured") under a policy of insurance issued by Plaintiff. 2. The Defendant, Benjamin Bishop is an individual residing at 1251 Hunters Ridge Drive, Mechanicsburg, PA 17050. 3. On or about August 19, 2007 the Defendant did unlawfully vandalized Plaintiff's _V Insured' vehicle on Kingsbridge Road, Rehoboth Beach, Delaware, causing the damages hereinafter set forth. 4. As a result of the conduct of Defendant, the Plaintiff paid pursuit to its policy of the Insured the sum of Three Thousand Eight Hundred Ninety Six and 641100 ($3,896.64) Dollars plus the insured's deductible of Two Hundred Fifty and 00/100 Dollars ($250.00) for a total of Four Thousand One Hundred Forty Six and 64/100 ($4,146.64) Dollars. A true and correct copy of the estimate is attached hereto, made part hereof and marked Exhibit "A." Count I Liberty Mutual Group v. Benjamin Bishop Intentional Acts 5. Plaintiff, incorporates by reference all of the allegations contained in paragraphs 1 through 4 inclusive of this Complaint as fully as though same were herein and set forth at length. 6. At all times herein mentioned, Defendant acted intentionally, consciously, deliberately and with malice toward Plaintiffs insured. 7. At all times herein mentioned, Defendants intentionally, carelessly, and recklessly. 8. As a direct and proximate result of the conduct of the Defendant Plaintiffs insured sustained damages and incurred the above expenses. Count II Liberty Mutual Group v. Benjamin Bishop Negligence 9. Plaintiff, incorporates by reference all of the allegations contained in paragraphs 1 through 8 inclusive of this Complaint as fully as though same were herein and set forth at length. 10. The said occurrence was due to the negligence of the Defendant in that he: a. did vandalized Plaintiffs Insured's vehicle without due regard for the rights, 2 I and safety of the insured's property, and b. acted intentionally, consciously, deliberately and with malice toward Plaintiffs insured. 11. As a direct and proximate result of the conduct of the Defendant Plaintiffs insured sustained damages and incurred the above loss. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against the Defendants upon each count in an amount not in excess of Fifty Thousand and 00/100 ($50,000.00) dollars together with costs of suit. Date: Paul F. D Emilio, Esquire Identification No.: 16654 e-mail address: pauld@demiliolaw.com Paul M. Schofield, Jr., Esquire Identification No.: 81894 e-mail address: pauls@demiliolaw.com 905 W. Sproul Road, Suite 105 Springfield, PA 19064 Telephone No.: 610-338-0338 Fax No.: 610-338-0303 3 VERIFICATION 01JP111 , Subrogation. Representative with liberty Mutual Group in the above captioned matter verifies that the facts contained in the foregoing Complaint are true and correct. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. Section 4904 relating to unswom falsification to authorities. John O'Neill Maims manager DATE: Su rogation Representative . r MUTUAL GROUP vV. TILGHMAN STREET SUITE 200 ALLENTOWN, PA 18104 n co u? r.? t: COMMONWEALTH OFF PENNBYLVAM NeMrW SeN Keay venrwce, Noisy Public soulh VAOMMN TMip.,,Lehiph cou*' My CWWJ Mls Do& 31, 2 Member, Pen OUNOW 4 Exhibit "A" • 0 AUTO APPRAISAL. REPORT LIBERTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY EXECUTIVE PLAZA IV 11350 MCCORMICK ROAD, SUITE 301 HUNT VALLEY, MD 21031 •" ESTIMATE "" 08127!2007 pMmsr. JAMES FRALEY Address: 7 THE MEAD City gee Zip: HOUSTON, DE 19954.9631 WowlDay: Homdpsy: (302)4242422 FAX: Infionnation Claim 8: 008646619.01 Loss DateiTlme: 08118/2007 08:00 PM DeductlbN: $250.00 Fps /: 11879 Ins. Company: LIBERTY MUTUAL Address: ExemWe Plow IV SUitd 301 11350 McCormick Rd. City State Zip: Hurd Valley, MD 21031 Agent: SHIRLEY HOHENWARTER Insured, JAMES FRALEY Claim Rep: SHIRLEY. HOHENWARTER Inspection Date: 08/2412007 10:04 AM Inspection Location: 7 The Mead City Stab Zip: Milford, DE 19963 pdnry pnpwA: Non-Collision Drlveeble: Yes Assigned Da W171ms: 08/22!200710:07 AM Fket Contact DaWTlms: 08/2312007 10:07 AM insured Policy d: PD332 Loss Type: Comp?ehenalva Accovnting 0: Worklosy: (410)771-8012 FAX: FAX: (410)783-0883 Inspection Type: Field Contact: Secondary knpact: Renal Assisted: RsoaWed DaW11me: 081271200710:04 AM Appolntmant DaWTlms: 06124200710:07 AM Appraiser Name: John Ckunobell Address: P.O. BOX 5244 City State Zip: WILMINGTON. DE 19808 Repow: R&D RESTORATION Address: 201 $.REHOBOTH BLVD City Stab Zlp: MILFORD; OE 19983 Terget Complete DateMme: Appraiser Lioense fi: WorWDay: (302)89"195 FAX: (302)999'0416 Conuct DONNY WodujW: (302)422.8664 FAX: (302)422-8873 Days To Repair. 8 08271200710:18 AM Page 1 of 4 0 0 2004 Acura TL STD 4 DR Sedan Claim 000114861"1 08/27/2007 LKO NOT LOCATED DRIVEABLE PRODUCTION DATE NOT READABLE. SUPPLEMENTS MUST BE INSPECTED PRIOR TO REPAIR FAILURE TO NOTIFY LIBERTY MUTUAL COULD RESULT IN NON PAYMENT OF SUPPLEMENT ALL REOUESTS FOR SUPPLEMENTS MUST BE DIRECTED TO (800) 241-3238 EXT 42224 Vehicle 2004 Acura TL STO 4 DR Sedan 6cyl Gasoline 3.2 5 Speed Automatic Lk.Plats: 41029 Lic stab: DE Llc Expire: VIN: 19UUA61=0035148 Prod Dab: Mlo ps: D Veh (naps: Mesa" Type: Non Readable Condition: Code: 81633A Ext. Color: dark grey Int. Color: Ext. Reanleh: Two-sbge Int. RMnlsh: Options AlrConditioning Alarm System Aluminum/Alloy Wheals Anti-lock Brakes Automatic Dimming Mirror Boae Sound System Center Console Cruise Cor*ol Digital Signal Processor Dual Airbags Dual Power Seats Dual Zone Auto ANC Fog Lights Garage Door Opener Heed Airbags Heated Front Seats Heated Power Mirrors In-Dash CD Changer &Tape Intermittent Wipers Keyless Entry System Leather Seats Leather Steering Wheel Lighted Entry System Ovedwo Console Power Brakes Power Door Locks Power Moonroof Power Steering Power Windows Rear Whdow Defroster Rem Trunk-UGate Release Side Airbags Stability Cntrl Suspenan Strg Wheel Radio Control Tachometer Telescopi : Steering WN Tile Steering Wheel Tinted Glass Traction Control System Trip Computer XM Satellite Radio Xenon Headtsmps Dernapss Line Op Guide MC Description MFR.Part No. Prke ADJ% 8% Hours R I N 6 Front Bumper Cover R&1 Additional Labor 1.7 SM 2 RI 41 Headlamp Assy,Xenon LT R & I Assembly 0.4 SM 3 RI 42 Headlamp Msy,Xw*n RT R & I Assembly 0.4 SM 4 RI 52 Lamp,Slde Marker LT R & I Assembly 0.7 SM 5 RI 53 Lamp,Skle Marker RT R & I Assembly 0.7 SM 6 E 83 46 Panel,Hood 50100GEPA90ZZ $516.58 1.3 SM 7 L 63 13 Panel,Hood Refinish 5.1 RF 2.8 Surface 1.1 Edge 0.6 Two-stage setup 0.6 Two-stage 8 E 10 Let1el,Hood 60050SR31-100 $1.50 0.1 SM 9 E 78 Label,Hood 77871SDAA90 53,58 0.1 SM. 10 1 103 Fender.Front LT Repair 110' SM 11 L 103 Fender,Front LT Reflnlssh 2.3 RF 1.9 Surface 0.4 Two4loge 12 BR 104 Fender.Front RT Biand Re"h 1.2 RF 08/27/200710:18 AM Page 2 of 4 2004 Aura TL STD 4 DR Sedan palm o: 00864881"1 08127/2007 Line Op Guide MC Description MFR.Part No. Price ADJ% B% flours R 0.8 Blend 0.4 Tyro-stage 13 EP 143 Windshield,Sheded QUALITY REPL. PART $314.50 3.7 SM 14 E 145 Arm,Vlfiper Blade LT 78800$EPA01 $57.17 0.1 SM 15 1 135 Panei,Bodyalde Otr Upr LT Repair 3.0' SM 16 L 135 PenslAodyaids Otr Upr LT Refinish 1.4 RF 1.2 Surface 0,2 TWo-stage 17 E 1883 Bezel,Console LT 7729MPA02ZA 570.85 0.3 SM 18 1 209 Pnl,Fmnt Door Outer LT Repair 2.0' SM 19 L 209 Pni,Front Door Outer LT Refinish 2.3 RF 2.0 Surface 0.3 Two-stage 20 RI 270 PH, Inner Door Trim LT R & 1 Assembty INC SM 21 E 280 MIdg,Front Door Scalp LT 72465SEPAOIZA $28.18 0.2 SM 22 E 241 MIdg,Front Door W LT 72450SEPA0IZA $43.13 0.2 SM 23 E 307 Appique,Frt Door Fram LT 72470SEPA0IZA $27.80 0.2 SM 24 E 229 01 Mirror,Outer RIC LT 76250SEPAOIZA $234.22 0.5 SM 25 EP 215 Glass,Frorlt DoorT LT QUALITY REPL. PART $71.86 1.0 SM 26 RI 253 Chonnel,Front Glass Ru LT R & I Assembly 0.3 SM 27 RI 227 Handle, FroO Door Otr LT R & i Assembly 0.5 SM 28 1 289 Pnl,Rear Door Outer LT Repair 2.0 SM 29 L 289 Pnl,Row Door Outer LT ReNsh 1.9 RF 1.9 Surface INC Two-stage 30 RI 333 Mldg,Ror Door Bert LT R & I Assembly INC SM 31 RI 276 Applique Assy,Rear Or LT R & 1 Assembly 0.8 SM 32 RI 344 Pnl,inner Door Trim LT R & 1 Assembly INC SM 33 EP 295 Glasa,Rear Door T LT QUALITY REPL. PART $70.08 0.8 SM 34 RI 305 Handle,RR Door Outer LT R & I Assembly 0.5 SM 35 1 341 Penel,Roof, Repair 3.0' SM 36 L 341 Panel,Roof Refinish 2.9 RF 2.9 Surface INC Two-stage 37 RI 343 Glass Panel,Roof R & I Assembly 0.5 SM 38 E 351 MM9,Roof Drip LT 73163SEPAOI $40.07 INC SIA 39 BR 389 Pnl Assembly,Quartsr LT Bland Refinish 1.1 RF 1.1 Blend INC Two-stage 40 RI 533 Tallamp Assembly LT R & I Assembly 2.0 SM 41 E 525 Lamp,License 34511SEPAOI $242.52 0.6 SM 42 N 566 Rear Bumper Cover R&I Additional Labor INC SM 43 N COLOR SAND & BUFF ++ Additional Labor 1.5' SM 44 L COLOR TINT Refinish 0.5' SM 44 Items PAC Ilssseos 01 CALL DEALER FOR EXACT PART 8/ PRICE 13 INCLUDES 0.6 HOURS FIRST PANEL TWO-STAGE ALLOWANCE 46 PRINTABLE ALTERNATE PARTS COMPARE ES600% Tobsi r& Enlirlss I Gross Parts Other Parts Paint Materials Parts & Material Total $1.265.60 $456,44 $375.001' $2.097.04 08/27/2007 10:18 AM Page 3 of 4 • • 2004 AcM TL STD 4 DR Sedan 0612712007 e; 006846810-01 Replace Repair Total Raw Hrs Hrs HM Lim - sheet Now (8M) $42.00 16A 14.2 30.0 $1,285.20 Mccivow (ME) $85.00 Prone (FR) $47.00 Refinish (RF) $42.00 16.2 18.2 $764.40 Paint Materials $22.00 Laker Total Gross Total lave: Doduct8+le Hot Total 48.8 Hours $2,049.60 $4,140.64 $250.00- 53.006.84 Altemete parts Y/041031D0101/01 CUM 04103100101/01 Zip Code: 21031 Geo 21031 Rasyded Parts Y1010 Zip Code: 21031 Audaga Estknating dA.11S ES 0012712007 10:18 AM REL 5.0.113 DT 0010112007 DS 0011612007 CopyApht (C) 2007 Andsax NorM America, Inc, UBER.ESTASL ISHED THRESHOLD FOR PAINT MATERIALS HAS SEEN REACHED AND CALCULATED IN THIS EST 2.S HRB WERE ADDED TO THIS ESTIMATE BASED ON AUDATEWS TWO-STAGE RIFT MN FORMULA. ESTIMATE CALCULATED USING THE 2.6 HOUR MAMMUM ALLOWANCE FOR TWO-STAGE REFINISH OF NON-PLE THIS IS NOT AN AUTHORIZATION TO REPAIR ATTENTION: PRESENT THIS APPRAISAL TO THE REPAIRING GARAGE BEFORE REPAIRS BEGIN. WE RESERVE THE RIGHT TO INSPECT ADDITIONAL DAMAGE BEFORE PAYMENT OF SUPPLEMENTAL CHARGES. NUMBER OF DAYS TO REPAIR........ ,g ........................................... COVERAGE TO LIBERTY MUTUAL CJJSTOMER IS UNDER THE COLLISION, COMPREHENSIVE, OR UNINSURED MOTORIST PART OF THE POLICY. Op Codes = UW4F-rntered Value E = Replace OEM NO EP = RapMce NAGS PART = QUALITY REFL EC = QUALITY REPL. PART IND & QUALITY ET TE = Partial Replace Labor = Partial Replace Price PM . ¦ Replace PXN Reman/RdA EU UM = LIKE K = NEW DISCOUNT OEM PRT L = Refinish PC Replace PXN Reconditioned UC - Replace Reoondi ionad TT Two-Tone SS = Sublet Repair N = Additional Labor BR = Blend Refinish I Repair IT = Partial Repair CG AA = Chipguard = Appearance Allowance RI RP = R 3 I Assembly Related Prior Damage P = Check This report cont8ft proprietary inftxrnation of Auds*x and may not be dieobsad to anY ,?r^ ONrd party (other than the insured, claimant and others on a need to know basis in order f ? oteX? to aflectuate the dams process) wMxYA Audatex's Prior written consent. CoPYNBht (C) 200T Audaga North Amarlca, Inc, Audatex Esdmathg is a trademark of Audetax North America. Inc. Pape 4 of 4 06127/2007 10:18 AM -? o FILED-O ICE OF THE f RUW . DNOTARY 2009 JUN -8 PM 1: 11 CIOUNlY !YLVAiNIA , 4'18.50 P-D ATT14 co 80'9lo Sheriffs Office of Cumberland County R Thomas Kline ??yyttr pt Climub' lire Edward L Schorpp Sheri f Solicitor Ronny R Anderson " Jody S Smith Chief Deputy oFFtCE OF THE SHERIFF Civil Process Sergeant SHERIFF'S RETURN OF SERVICE 06/10/2009 07:42 PM - Amanda Cobaugh, Deputy Sheriff, who being duly sworn according to law, states that on June 10, 2009 at 1942 hours, she served a true copy of the within Complaint and Notice, upon the within namec defendant, to wit: Benjamin Bishop, by making known unto himself personally, defendant at 1251 Hunters Ridge Drive Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17050 its contents and at the same time handing to him personally the said true and correct copy of the same. SHERIFF COST: $37.00 SO ANSWERS, June 11, 2009 R THOMAS KLINE, SHERIFF M 1) O&A APO I I De h i 2009-3772 Liberty Mutual V Benjamin Bishop ? O C" 3 -77 IN THE COMMON PLEAS COURT OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA LIBERTY MUTUAL GROUP AS SUBROGEE OF JAMES FRALEY 2501 WILMINGTON ROAD NEW CASTLE, PA 16105 V. CAUSE NO. 09-3772 BENJAMIN BISHOP 1251 HUNTERS RIDGE DRIVE MECHANICSBURG, PA 17050 ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES Comes now Benjamin Bishop, Defendant herein, and submits his answer and affirmative defenses to the allegations contained in the Complaint filed against him herein. FIRST DEFENSE Defendant would show that the Complaint fails to state a claim or cause of action against him upon which any relief can be granted. SECOND DEFENSE Defendant has not performed all of the acts accused of him under which the Plaintiff claimed that Defendant has acted negligently; also, the insured's property was deliberately and maliciously violated by James Fraley with the intent of concealing the true nature of the night's events from his father. Defendant disagrees with the claim in the amount of 4,146.64 for damages listed for the insured's property. THIRD DEFENSE And now, answering the allegations of the Complaint filed against him, paragraph by paragraph, Defendant would show the following: 1. Defendant admits the allegations of Paragraph I of the Complaint that I, Benjamin Bishop am an adult resident citizen of 1251 Hunters Ridge Drive, Mechanicsburg, PA, 17050. II. Defendant admits the allegations of Paragraph II of the Complaint that the Plaintiff, Liberty Mutual Group, is a Corporation authorized to do business in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, having an address of 2501 Wilmington Road, New Castle, PA 16105. III. Defendant denies the allegations of Paragraph III of the Complaint. IV. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge or information at this time to admit or deny the allegations of Paragraph IV of the Complaint and therefore denies same. WHEREFORE, now having fully answered said Complaint, Defendant requests that said Complaint be dismissed with prejudice and that Defendant be awarded costs of this suit from Plaintiff. Respectfully submitted, DEFE T CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Benjamin Bishop, do hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the above and foregoing Answer and Affirmative Defenses has been sent, via first class mail, postage prepaid, to Liberty Mutual Group at 2501 Wilmington Road, New Castle, PA 16105. So certified, this the 24! day of June, 2009. DEFE AN OF TITE 2019€1a 2 4 ii i 'It al= i1 PAUL F. D'EMILIO, ESQUIRE ATTORNEY I.D. #16654 PAUL M. SCHOFIELD, JR., ESQUIRE ATTORNEY I.D. #81894 905 W. SPROUL ROAD, SUITE 105 SPRINGFIELD, PA 19064 (610) 338-0338 THIS IS ARBITRATION MATTER ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF LIBERTY MUTUAL GROUP COMMON PLEAS COURT OF AS SUBROGEE OF JAMES FRALEY CUMBERLAND COUNTY 2501 WILMINGTON ROAD NEW CASTLE, PA 16105 VS. NO. 09-3772-CIVIL TERM BENJAMIN BISHOP 1251 HUNTERS RIDGE DRIVE CIVIL ACTION MECHANICSBURG. PA 17050 ORDER TO SETTLE. DISCONTINUE AND END TO THE PROTHONOTARY, P.C.: Kindly mark the above entitled matter settled, discontinued and ended upon payment of your cost only. Paul F. D'Emilio, Esquire Attorney for Plaintiff ~L~Cj- 2C~9 OCT 14 A~ 1 ~~ ~ ~