HomeMy WebLinkAbout04-2239COZEN O'CONNOR
MATTHEW F. HENRY, ESQURIE
Atty. I.D. No.: 88364
1900 Market Street
Philadelphia, PA 19103
(215)665.7248
Attorneys for Defendants, AIU Insurance Company, American Home Assurance Company,
Birmingham Fire Insurance Company of Pennsylvania, Granite State Insurance Company,
Landmark Insurance Company, Lexington Insurance Company and National Union Fire
Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, Pa.
VIACOM INTERNATIONAL, 1NC.,
Plaintiff,
ADMIRAL INSURANCE CO., et al.,
Defendants.
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
MISCELLANEOUS ACTION NO.:
PETITION FOR ISSUANCE OF A SUBPOENA
AlU Insurance Company, American Home Assurance Company, Birmingham Fire
Insurance Company of Permsylvania, Granite State Insurance Company, Landmark Insurance
Company, Lexington Insurance Company and National Union Fire Insurance Company of
Pittsburgh, Pa. (hereinafter "Petitioners"), by and through their attorneys, Cozen O'Connor,
respectfully petitions this Court, pursuant to 42 Pa.C.S. § 5326, to issue a subpoena duces tecum
compelling Gannett Flemming, Inc. (f/k/a Gannett, Flemming, Corddry & Carpenter, Inc.) 207
Senate Avenue, Camp Hill, PA 17011, to (1) procure documents, on such a date as may be
agreed by the witness and all interested parties, but in any event, not more than two weeks after
the service of the subpoena, at a location in Cumberland County as may be agreed by the witness
and all interested parties, and (2) to have a representative with knowledge of those documents
appear for deposition on such a date as may be agreed by the witness and all interested parties, at
a location in Cumberland County as may be agrees by the witness and all interested parties, and
in support thereof asserts as follows:
1. This case involves an insurance coverage action venued in the Superior Court of
New Jersey, Somerset County, under docket number SOM-L-1739-99.
2. In this action, PlaintiffViacom International, Inc. seeks insurance coverage from
Defendants for certain environmental liabilities.
3. Upon information and belief, Gannett Flemming, Inc. (f/k/a Gannett, Flemming,
Corddry & Carpenter, Inc.) has knowledge and information regarding the matters of inquiry set
forth in Attachment "A" annexed hereto, and has possession, custody and control of the
documents and tangible things identified in said attachment, all of which are relevant to this
action.
4. The documents in the possession, custody and control of Gannett Flemming, Inc.
(f/k/a Gannett, Flemming, Corddry & Carpenter, Inc.), as well as the oral testimony ora
representative therefrom are necessary to the Petitioners' defense of this matter.
5. This subpoena is directed to Gannett Flemming, Inc. (f/k/a Gannett, Flemming,
Corddry & Carpenter, Inc.), a non-party witness, seeks the production of documents in the
possession of to Gannett Flemming, Inc. (f/k/a Gannett, Flemming, Corddry & Carpenter, Inc.
relating to the matters of inquiry set forth in Attachment "A" annexed hereto, and the oral
custodial deposition of a representative of Gannett Flenmfing, Inc. (f/k/a Gannett, Flemming,
Corddry & Carpenter, Inc.) with like knowledge and information. As a resident of Pennsylvania,
Gannett Flemming, Inc. (f/k/a Gannett, Flemming, Corddry & Carpenter, Inc.) is not subject to
the subpoena power of the courts of New Jersey.
6. Attached hereto as Exhibit "A" is a copy of the Order issued by the Superior
Court of New Jersey granting a Commission to take out-of-state depositions.
WHEREFORE, Petitioners, AlU Insurance Company, American Home Assurance
Company, Birmingham Fire Insurance Company of Pennsylvania, Granite State Insurance
Company, Landmark Insurance Company, Lexington Insurance Company and National Union
Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, Pa. respectfully request that this Court issue a subpoena
duces tecum in the form attached as Exhibit "B," compelling Gannett Flemming, Inc. (f/k/a
Gannett, Flemming, Corddry & Carpenter, Inc.) to produce documents designated therein on
such a date as may be agreed by all interested parties, but in any event not more than two weeks
after the service of the subpoena, at a location in Cumberland Connty as may be agreed by all
interested parties, and requiring a representative from Gannett Flemming, Inc. (f/k/a Gannett,
Flemming, Corddry & Carpenter, Inc.) with knowledge of those documents to appear for
deposition on such a date as may be agreed by all interested parties, at a location in Cumberland
County as may be agreed by all interested parties.
Respectfully submitted,
COZEN O'CONNOR
Attorney for Petitioners
1900 Market Street
Philadelphia, PA 19103
(215)665.7248
COZEN O'CONNOR
MATTHEW F. HENRY, ESQURIE
Atty. I.D. No.: 88364
1900 Market Street
Philadelphia, PA 19103
(215)665.7248
Attorneys for Defendants, AlU Insurance Company, American Home Assurance
Company, Birmingham Fire Insurance Company of Pennsylvania, Granite State
Insurance Company, Landmark Insurance Company, Lexington Insurance Company and
National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, Pa.
VIACOM INTERNATIONAL, INC.,
Plaintiff,
V,
ADMIRAL INSURANCE CO., et al.,
Defendants.
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
MISCELLANEOUS ACTION NO.:
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned certifies that true and correct copies of the foregoing Petition for
the Issuance of a Subpoena were served on all counsel of record, pursuant to the attached
Service List, via first class United States mail, postage pre-paid on this ]'~'L~day of
May, 2004.
Respectfully submitted,
BY: F~. , 1900 Market Street
Philadelphia, PA 19103
(215)665.7248
VIACOM INTERNATIONAL, INC. V. ADMIRAL INS. CO., ETAL.
Docket No. SOM-L-1739-99
All Counsel List
PLAINTIFF
Kevin J. Bruno, Esq.
Robertson, Freilich, Bruno & Cohen, LLC
One Riverfront Plaza, 4th Floor
Newark, NJ 07102
(973) 848-2100
(973) 848-2138 (fax)
Attorneys for Plaintiff,
Viacom International, Inc.
Leslie G. Fagen, Esq.
Allan Arfth, Esq.
Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison
1285 Avenue of the Americas
New York, NY 10019-6064
(212) 373-3231
(212) 373-2249 (fax)
Arffa fax (212)373-2116
Attorneys for Plaintiff,
Viacom International, Inc.
DEFENDANTS
Anthony P. LaRocco, Esq.
Kirkpatrick & Lockhart, LLP
One Riverfront Plaza
Newark, NJ 07102
(973) 848-4000
(973) 848-4001 (fax)
and
David T. Case, Esq.
Jon Talotta, Esq.
Barry M. Hartman, Esq.
Kirkpatrick & Lockhart, LLP
1800 Massachusetts Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20036-1800
(202) 778-9000
(202) 778-9100 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendant,
Horsehead Industries, Inc.
Charles A. Jones, Esq. ("Tony")
Ross, Dixon & Bell, L.L.P.
2001 K Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20006
(202) 662-2000
direct dial (202) 662-2074
(202) 662-2190 (Fax)
email tjones~rdlaw.com
Attorneys for Defendants, Continental
Casualty Company, Firemen's Insurance
Company of Newark, New Jersey, Pacific
Insurance Company, Fidelity and Casualty
Insurance Company of New York and
The Continental Insurance Company
INSURER DEFENDANTS
Jonathan S. Reed, Esq.
Traub, Eglin, Lieberman, Straus
Metroplex Corporate Center I
100 Metroplex Drive, Suite 203
Edison, NJ 08817
(732) 985-1000
(732) 985-2000 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendant,
Associated International Insurance Company
Carolyn Bates Kelly, Esq.
Christie Pabarue Mortensen Young
1880 JFK Boulevard - l0th Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19103-7424
Attorneys for Defendant,
Republic Insurance Company
(215) 587-1600
James F. McNaboe, Esq.
Sepanik Conner McNaboe Colliau & Elenius
1100 Cornwall Road
First Floor South
Monmouth Junction, NJ 08852
(732) 398-5400
Direct dial (732) 398-5401
(732) 398-5414 (fax)
email j ames.mcnaboe~cna, com
Attorneys for Defendants, Continental
Casualty Company, Firemen's Insurance
Company of Newark, New Jersey, Pacific
Insurance Company, Fidelity and Casualty
Insurance Company of New York and
The Continental Insurance Company
Robert F. Priestley, Esq.
Adam M. Smith, Esq.
Mendes & Mount
One Newark Center
19th Floor
Newark, NJ 07102
(973) 639-7300
(973) 639-7350 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendant,
Certain Underwriters At Lloyds London
Douglas R. Kleinfeld, Esq.
Kleinfeld & Kleinfeld
219 South Street
New Providence, NJ 07974
(908) 508-0800
(908) 508-0555 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendants,
Westport Insurance Corporation,
St. Paul Surplus Lines Insurance Company,
Employers Reinsurance Corporation
James R. Greene, Esq.
Hardin, Kundla, McKeon, Poletto & Polifroni
673 Morris Avenue
P.O. Box 730
Springfield, NJ 07081-0730
(973) 912-5222
(973) 912-9212 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendant,
Royal Indemnity Company
John C. Sullivan, Esq.
Post & Schell, P.C.
Adams Place - Suite 3
701 White Horse Road
Voorhees, NJ 08043
(856) 627-8900
(856) 627-4451 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendant, Liberty Mutual
Insurance Company
Loren L. Pierce, Esq.
Robert J. Re, Esq.
McElroy, Deutsch & Mulvaney
1300 Mount Kemble Avenue
P.O. Box 2075
Morristown, NJ 07962-2075
(973) 993-8100
(973) 425-0161 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendant, Admiral
Insurance Company
Susan M. Chesler, Esq.
Melito & Adolfsen, P.C.
Woolworth Building
233 Broadway
New York, NY 10279-0118
(212) 238-8900
(212) 238-8999 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendants, First State
Insurance Company, Hartford Accident
& Indemnity Company, New England
Insurance Company, and Twin City Fire
Insurance Company
Donna Stephan-Nolan, Esq.
Purcell, Ries, Shannon, Mulcahy & O'Neill
One Pluckemin Way, Crossroads Business
Center, P.O. Box 754
Bedminster, NJ 07921
(908) 658-3800
(908) 658-4659 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendant, Old Republic
Insurance Company
Erik W. Drewniak, Esq.
Aidan M. McCormack, Esq.
Michael P. Murphy, Esq.
Hodgson Russ LLP
152 West 57th Street
New York, New York 10009
(212) 751-4300
(212) 751-0928 (fax)
email Edrewnia~hodgsonruss.com
AmcCormack~hodgsonruss.com
MMurphy~hodgsonruss.com
Attorneys for Defendants St. Paul Surplus
Lines Insurance
3
Kevin M. Haas, Esq.
Cozen O'Connor
Suite 1900
One Newark Center
Newark, NJ 07102
(973) 286-1200
(973) 242-2121 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendants, AIU Insurance
Company, American Home Assurance
Company, Birmingham Fire Insurance
Company of Pennsylvania, Granite State
Insurance Company, Landmark Insurance
Company, Lexington Insurance Company
and National Union Fire Insurance
Company of Pittsburgh, Pa.
Scott M. Seaman, Esq.
Jason R. Schulze, Esq.
Meckler, Bulger & Tilson
123 North Wacker Drive
Suite 1800
Chicago, IL 60606
(312) 474-7900
Seaman Direct dial (312) 474-7139
Schulze Direct dial (312) 474-4456
(312) 474-7898 (fax)
Email scott.seaman~mbtlaw.com
jason.schulze~mbtlaw.com
Attorneys for Defendants, Appalachian
Insurance Company and Affiliated FM
Insurance Company
M. Paul Gorfinkel, Esq.
Michael E. Buckley, Esq.
Rivkin, Radler & Kremer, LLP
EAB Plaza
Uniondale, NY 11556-0111
(516) 357-3000
(516) 357-3333 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendants, Allstate Insurance
Company (sued herein as Allstate Insurance
Company [formerly known as Northbrook
Excess & Surplus Insurance Company]) and
Dairyland Insurance Company
Ed Napierkowski, Esq.
Siegal & Napierkowski
220 Lake Drive East, Suite 304
Cherry Hill, NJ 08022
(856) 667-2080
(856) 667-2210 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendants, Century Indemnity
Company, Century Indemnity Company, as
successor to CCI Insurance Company, as
successor to Insurance Company of North
America (improperly designated "Insurance
Company of North America"), Century
Indemnity Company, as successor to CCI
Insurance Company, as successor to Insurance
Company of North America, as successor to
Indemnity Insurance Company of North
America (improperly designated "Indemnity
Insurance Company of North America'),
International Insurance Company and Motor
Vehicle Casualty Company, with respect to
policies issued by Cravens Dargan &
Company, Pacific Coast as Managing General
Agent (improperly designated "Motor Vehicle
Casualty Company (in liquidation)")
4
Gerald A. Huges, Esq.
Huges & Hendrix
850 Bear Tavern Road, Suite 304
West Trenton, NJ 08628
(609) 883-7100
(609) 883-9597 (fax)
And
Mary E. Borja, Esq.
Wiley, Rein & Fielding
1776 K Street, N.W.
Washington, DC 20006
(202) 719-4552
(202) 719-7049 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendants, Zurich Insurance
Company and Zurich International
Kenneth R. Rothschild
Golden, Rothschild, Spagnola, Lundell &
Levitt, P.C.
I011 Route 22 West, Suite 300
P.O. Box 6881
Bridgewater, NJ 08807-0881
(908) 722-6300
(908) 722-0029 (fax)
Local counsel for The Home Insurance
Company
Joseph M. Suarez, Esq.
Suarez & Suarez
2106 Kennedy Boulevard
Jersey City, NJ 07305
(201) 433-0778
(201) 433-4899
Attorneys for Defendant, Federal
Insurance Company, U.S. Guarantee
Insurance Company
Leanne Alsen, Esq.
Margolis Edelstein
216 Haddon Avenue
P.O. Box 2222
Westmont, NJ 08108-2886
(856) 858-7200
(856) 858-1017 (fax)
and
Elit R. Felix, II, Esq.
Margolis Edelstein
The Curtiss Center, 4th Floor
601 Walnut Street
Philadelphia, PA 19106-3304
(215) 931-5870
(215) 922-1772 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendant, Tudor
Insurance Company
Jeffrey S. Brenner, Esq.
Flaster, Greenberg
1810 Chapel Avenue West
Cherry Hill, NJ 08002
(856) 661-2275
(856) 661-1919
Attorneys for Defendant, Ranger
Insurance Company
Stephen J. Smirti, Jr., Esq.
Rivkin, Radler & Kremer, LLP
EAB Plaza
Uniondale, NY 11556-0111
(516) 357-3000
(516) 357-3333
Attorneys for Defendant, Houston General
Insurance Company
5
Michael E. Buckley, Esq.
Rivkin, Radler & Kremer, LLP
One Gateway Center, Suite 1226
Newark, NJ 07102-0111
(973) 622-0900
(973) 622-7878 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendants, Allstate Insurance
Company (sued herein as Allstate Insurance
Company [formerly known as Northbrook
Excess & Surplus Insurance Company])
Sheldon Karasik, Esq.
Robin Stone Einbinder, Esq.
Karasik & Einbinder, LLP
28 West 36th Street, Suite 901
New York, NY 10018-7911
(212) 244-6100
(212) 244-6110 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendant, National Union
Company of Omaha
Neil Walters, Esq.
Piper Rudnick
379 Thomall
Edison, New Jersey 08818
(732)-590-1850
(732)-590-1860 (fax)
Attorneys for Stonewall Insurance Co.
Daren S. McNally, Esq.
Connell, Foley & Geiser
85 Livingston Avenue
Roseland, NJ 07068
(973) 535-0500
(973) 535-9217 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendant, TIG Indemnity
Company (f/k/a Transamerica Insurance
Company)
6
Mark Tallmadge, Esq.
Bressler, Amery & Ross
P.O. Box 1980
Morristown, NJ 07962
(973) 514-1200
(973) 514-1660 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendants, New Jersey
Property-Liability Insurance Company
Association on behalf of Midland Insurance
Company and Integrity Insurance Company
Amy R. Paulus
Clausen Miller P.C.
10 S. LaSalle Street
Chicago, IL 60603
(312) 606-7848
(312) 606-7777 (fax)
And
Vincent Velardo, Esq.
Clausen Miller
One Gateway Center, Suite 2600
Newark, NJ 07102
(973) 645-0564
(973) 622-3423 (fax)
Attomeys for Defendant,
Cente~mial Insurance Company
And
One Chase Manhattan Plaza, 39th FI.
New York, NY 10005
(212) 805-3913
(212) 805-3939 (fax)
Charles Shimberg, Esq.
Litchfield Cavo
3 Haddon Avenue
Haddonfield, NJ 08033
(856) 428-6682
(856) 354-1656 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendants, Gibraltar Casualty
Company and Everest Reinsurance Company
f/k/a Prudential Reinsurance Company
-Remainin~ counsel-
Daniel G. Litchfield, Esq.
Dawn M. Gonzalez
Litchfield Cavo
303 West Madison Street, Suite 200
Chicago, IL 60606
(312) 781-6669(Litchfield)
(312) 781-6667 (Gonzalez)
(312) 781-6630(fax)
Antonio D. Favetta, Esq.
Gamty Graham and Favetta
1 Lackawanna Plaza
P.O. Box 4205
Montclair, NJ 07042
(973) 509-7500
(973) 509-0414 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendants
Allianz Insurance Company and Pennsylvania
Manufacturers Assoc.
Neil Glazer, Esq.
Frances Buckley
D'Amato & Lynch
70 Pine Street
New York, NY 10270
(212) 269-0927
(212) 269-3559 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendant,
Certain Underwriters At Lloyds London
Alexander J. Kovacs, Esq.
Caron, Constants & Wilson
201 Route 17 North, 2nd Floor
Rutherford, New Jersey 07070
(201) 507-3710
(201) 507-3706 (Direct)
(201) 507-3675 (Fax)
Attorneys for Fireman's Fund Insurance
Company
8
Scott J. Ryskoski, Esq.
Michael J. Steinlage, Esq.
Larson King, LLP
2800 Minnesota World Trade Center
30 East 7th Street
St. Paul, MN 55101
(651) 312-6500
(651) 312-6520 (Direct)
(651) 312-6618 (Fax)
Attorneys for Defendants, Employers
Insurance of Wausau a Mutual Company
and National Casualty Company
Richard Orr, Esq.
Dominick Cirelli, Esq.
Smith, Stratton, Wise,
Heher & Brennan
600 College Road East
Princeton, NJ 08540
(609) 924-6000
(609) 987-6651 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendants, American
Re-Insurance Company, Executive Risk
Indemnity, Inc. and Mutual Marine Office, Inc.
Vincent J. Proto, Esq.
Thomas M. Laudise, Esq.
Budd, Lamer, Gross Rosenbaum
150 John F. Kennedy Parkway, CN 1000
Short Hills, NJ 07078
(973) 379-4800
(973) 379-7734 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendant, General Reinsurance
Corp.
James Pabame, Esq.
Carolyn Bates Kelly, Esq.
Christie, Pabame, Mortensen & Young
(215) 587-1600
(215) 587-1699 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendants, Government
Employers Insurance Company ("GEICO")
and Unigard Security Insurance Company
(f/k/a Unigard Mutual Insurance Company)
Kevin C. Gmbb, Esq.
The Concourse at Beaver Brook
1465 Route 31, P.O. Box 546
Annandale, NJ 08801
(908) 238-9400
(908) 238-9401 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendant, Michigan Mutual Ins.
Co.
Mitchell A. Steam, Esq.
Kevin M. Grace, Esq.
Porter Wright Morris & Arthur, LLP
1919 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W., Suite 500
Washington, D.C. 20006
(202) 778-3000
(202) 778-3063 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendant, The Home Insurance
Company
William P. Krauss, Esq.
Wilson, Elser, Moskowitz,
Edelman & Dicker, LLP
33 Washington Street, 18 Fl.
Newark, NJ 07102-5003
(973) 624-0800
(973) 624-0808 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendant, MidStates
Reinsurance Corporation (f/k/a Mead
Reinsurance Corporation)
Michael L. Gioia, Esq.
Landman, Corsi, Ballaine, & Ford P.C.
120 Broadway, 27th Floor
New York, NY 10271-0079
(212) 238-4800
(212) 238-4848 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendants, Government
Employers Insurance Company ("GEICO")and
Unigard Security Insurance Company (f/k/a
Unigard Mutual Insurance Company)
Ira Bergman, Esq.
Duane Morris
380 Lexington Avenue
New York, NY 10168
(212) 692-1000
(212) 692-1009 (fax)
Attorneys for Defendants, Westport and ERC
Shawn L. Kelly, Esq.
Thomas J. Castano, Esq.
Mary Ellen Scalera, Esq.
Ellen M. Christoffersen, Esq.
Riker Danzig Scherer Hyland
Perretti, LLP
One Speedwell Avenue
Morristown, NJ 07962
(973) 538-0800
(973) 538-1984 (fax)
Attorneys for Highlands Insurance Company
9
Patrick Dwyer, Esq.
Polstein, Fen'ara, Dwyer & Speed
83 Maiden Lane
New York, New York 10038
(212) 344-3339
(212)-344-3635 (fax)
Attorneys for Affiliated FM Insurance
Company
C:lDocuments and SettingslmJhenrylLocal SettingslTemporary lnternet FileslOLK81 Viacom - All Counsel List (use this one)_vl.DOC
10
COZEN O'CONNOR
One Newark Center,
Suite 1900
Newark, NJ 07102
973-286-1200
Attorneys for Defendants, AlU Insurance Company, American Home Assurance Company,
Birmingham Fire Insurance Company of Pennsylvania, Granite State Insurance Company,
Landmark Insurance Company, Lexington Insurance Company and National Union Fire
Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, Pa.
VIACOM INTERNATIONAL INC.,
Plaintiff,
V.
ADMIRAL INSURANCE CO., et al.,
Defendants.
Superior Court of New Jersey
Law Division: Somerset County
Docket No. SOM~L4739-99
COMMISSION
TO THE HONORABLE JUDGES OF THE COURT
OF COMMON PLEAS, CUMBERLAND COUNTY
The Superior Court of New Jersey, Law Division, Somerset County, hereby requests your
assistance to procure the deposition of, and production of documents and tangible things from
Gannett Fleming, Inc. (ffk/a Gannett, Fleming, Corddry & Carpenter, Inc.), which is believed to
be a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, County of Cumberland. This Court believes that
Gannett Fleming, Inc. has knowledge and information regarding the matters of inquiry set forth
in Attachment "A" annexed hereto, and has possession, custody and control of the documents
and tangible things identified in said attachment, all of which this Court believes is relevant to
this action.
Having confidence in your prudence and fidelity, we request your assistance and have
appointed you, and by these presents do give you full power and authority, in pursuance of an
Order issued in the Superior Court of New Jersey, Law Division, Somerset County, in this
action, to issue a subpoena to these persons or entities to appear for a deposition and give
testimony in the cause, and to produce documents and tangible things for inspection and copying,
in accordance with the New Jersey Rules of Court and applicable Rules of the Court of Common
Pleas, Cumberland County.
Dated thi~ day of
,20
BY THE COLIRT: /, ./fi']
Judge of the Superior Court of
The State of New Jersey
-2-
ATTACHMENT "A"
A. DEFINITIONS AND INSTRUCTIONS
1. These requests refer to all responsive documents in your possession, custody or
control which were prepared, created, examined, sent, delivered or received by you during the
time period from 1899 to the present, inclusive, unless otherwise stated.
2. All responsive documents within your possession, custody, or control shall be
produced, including all responsive documents which were prepared, created, examined, sent,
delivered or received by you, and all responsive documents available to you or any of your
predecessors, successors, agents, employees, attorneys, accountants, representatives, independent
contractors, or others from whom you are capable of deriving documents or information.
3. Any request for any document shall be deemed to request a copy of the document
(without abbreviation or redaction) whenever the original is unavailable or whenever the copy
has written matter on it not present in the original, including alternations, notes, comments, or
other material not appearing on the original, or whenever a copy has attached to it any
alternations, revisions, drafts or other preliminary material. Any request for a document shall
also include drafts, revisions of drafts and other preliminary material, from whatever source,
underlying, supporting, or used in the preparation of any document.
4. The terms "you" and "your," unless otherwise specified, shall mean Gannett
Fleming, Inc., its corporate predecessors, successors, subsidiaries, parents, affiliates, offices,
branches, departments, bureaus and divisions, and all present and former employees, agents,
officers, directors, attorneys or representatives of that company.
5. The term "document" is used in the broadest sense permissible under applicable
New Jersey law and rules governing the scope of discovery to encompass any written,
typewritten, printed, or graphic matter of any kind or character, including, but not limited to,
correspondence, notations, papers, books, agreements, applications, forms, telegrams and
telefaxes, contracts, reports, minutes and records from any meetings, memoranda, notes, e-mails,
e-mail attachments, diary enthes, telephone slips or logs, calendars, bills, invoices, charts,
studies, graphs, summaries of investigations, calculations, analyses, drawings, photographs,
maps, transcripts and affidavits, and also including films and videotapes, other tapes or
recordings, transcripts, computer printouts and information stored in computers or other data
storage or processing equipment.
6. "Person" or "persons" means all natural mad legal persons, including, without
limitation, individuals, corporations, joint ventures, partnerships, trusts, sole proprietorships,
tmincorporated associations and any agency, division, subdivision, branch or department of any
local, state or federal government.
7. "Relating to" or "relate to" means to consist of, refer to, pertain to, reflect,
discuss, describe, cite, evidence, concern, summarize, analyze or be in any way logically or
factually connected (directly or indirectly) with the matter discussed.
8. All references to the singular include the plural and all references to the plural
include the singular, as necessary, to produce the most inclusive response.
9. The term "or" shall mean "and/or;" the term "and" shall mean "and/or." Both
terms shall be construed broadly to produce the most inclusive response.
10. The term "each" shall mean "each and every;" the term "every" shall mean "each
and every." Both terms shall be construed broadly to produce the most inclusive response.
11. For any document requested herein that was at one time in your possession,
custody or control but is no longer so, the request shall be deemed to include all documents
reflecting or relating to the disposition or current location of the original and each copy of each
such document.
12. "Viacom" shall mean Viacom International, Inc., and any corporate predecessors,
successors, parents, subsidiaries, partners, affiliates, divisions, members, other entities under
common control, offices, branches, departments, bureaus and divisions, including but not limited
to, Viacom, Inc., Viacom International Inc., Paramount Communications, Inc., Viacom
2
International Services, Inc., Gulf & Western Corporation, Gulf + Western Inc., The New Jersey
Zinc Company, Zinminco, Inc., E.W. Bliss Company and Universal American Corporation and
all present or former employees, agents, officers, and directors thereof.
13. "Mobil" shall mean Exxon Mobil Corporation, and any corporate predecessors,
successors, parents, subsidiaries, partners, affiliates, divisions, members, other entities under
common control, offices, branches, departments, bureaus and divisions, including but not limited
to, Mobil Oil Company, and all present or former employees, agents, officers, and directors
thereof.
14. "Horsehead" shall mean Horsehead Industries, Inc., and any corporate
predecessors, successors, parents, subsidiaries, affiliates, offices, branches, departments, bureaus
and divisions, and all present or former employees, agents, officers, and directors thereof.
15. The "DePue Site" shall mean the: a) property and facilities located in and around
DePue, Illinois which were owned and operated by Viacom upon which, or with respect to
which, you performed environmental investigation and/or remediation; b) the site identified by
the United States Environmental Protection Agency as CERCLIS No. ILD062340641 (64 Fed.
Reg. 24949, May 10, 1999), as same may be enlarged from time to time by any Government
Entity; and c) all land, air, water (including surface water and ground water), atmosphere, natural
resources, disposed or other wastes, abandoned property and real or personal property, which has
been alleged to have been affected, directly or indirectly, by the operations, acts or omissions of
Viacom, Horsehead or Mobil in and around DePue, Illinois.
16. The "Palmerton Site" shall mean a) property and facilities located in and around
Palmerton, Pennsylvania which were owned and operated by Viacom upon which, or with
respect to which, you performed environmental investigation and/or remediation; b) the site
identified by the United States Environmental Protection Agency as CERCLIS No.
PAD002395887 (48 Fed. Reg. 40658, September 30, 1983), as same may be enlarged from time
to time by any Government Entity; and c) all land, air, water (including surface water and ground
3
water), atmosphere, natural resources, disposed or other wastes, abandoned property and real or
personal property, which has been alleged to have been affected, directly or indirectly, by the
operations, acts or omissions of Viacom, Horsehead or Mobil in and around Palmerton,
Pennsylvania.
17. "Environmental contamination" shall mean the actual, alleged, potential or
threatened contamination of, or injury or damage to air, environment, atmosphere, land, soil,
sediments, property, water (including groundwater and surface water), natural resources, plant
life, animal life or any natural person or class or group of natural persons, by or arising from the
presence, existence, movement, emission, discharge, seepage, release, dispersal, disposal,
dumping, or escape of, or exposure to, hazardous substances, hazardous wastes, fertilizers,
irritants, contamination, pollutants, toxins, vapors, fumes, methane gas, acids, alkalis, metals,
chemicals, energy, radiation, oil, polychlorinated biphenyls, petroleum, petroleum derivatives,
silica, benzene, contaminating liquids or gases, waste materials of any type or any other material,
substance or cansative agent alleged by any person in the past, now or in the future to be
(whether before or after its or their presence, existence, movement, emission, discharge, seepage,
release, dispersal, disposal, dumping, or escape) detrimental, harmful, injurious, hazardous,
noxious, nuisance-causing or toxic.
18. If any objection is made to any numbered or lettered paragraph or subparagraph,
or any portion thereof, of any request herein, documents shall be produced as to any and all
portions thereof, as to which no objection is made.
19. Within 30 days after service of the attached subpoena, you shall serve upon the
requesting parties or their designee(s) a log which (i) identifies each responsive document that
has been withheld or redacted for any reason or has been destroyed or is otherwise no longer in
your custody or possession or subject to your control and (ii) provides the following information
with respect to each such document:
f.
g.
h.
The nature of the document (i.e. letter, memorandum, etc.);
The date of the document;
The author of the document;
The subject matter of the document;
The addressees of the document;
The recipients of copies;
The document request to which the document is
responsive;
If known, the positions and/or affiliations of the
author, addressees and recipients at the time of the
date of the document; and
The legal basis for withholding or redacting the
document, if any.
20. These Requests shall be deemed to be continuing so as to require further and
supplemental responses as you obtain additional information between the time of responding
hereunder and the trial of this action.
21. All documents shall be produced in an orderly manner with appropriate markings
or other identification to allow identification of the source of the document, the file in which it
was maintained, and the person to whom such file belongs.
22. All indices or similar doctanents that list, classify, organize, record, explain or
enumerate responsive documents shall be produced along with the responsive documents.
23. If a document requested no longer exists or has otherwise been disposed of,
identify each such document and state the date of, circumstances surrounding, and reasons for its
disposal; identify the person responsible for and the persons who have knowledge of the disposal
and provide all other information that would be of use in obtaining the document, a copy of it, or
the information contained in it.
5
B. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
You are hereby required to identify and produce for deposition, at the time and place
designated in the accompanying subpoena, one or more officers, directors, managing agents, or
other agents and employees with the most knowledge concerning the DePue and/or Palmerton
Sites.
C. DOCUMENTS REQUESTED
All documents in your possession, custody or control relating to the investigation
of environmental contamination at the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
2. All documents relating to hydrogeologic, geologic, surface water, soil and
engineering evaluations, testing, experiments, investigations, reports, studies or analyses of the
DePue and Palmerton Sites.
3. All documents used or reviewed by you in connection with any evaluations,
testing, experiments, reports, studies or analyses of the DePue and Palmerton Sites prepared by
you for, or on behalf of, Viacom.
4. All documents relating to your work at the DePue and Palmerton Sites, including,
but not limited to, remediation, disposal, storage, treatment, mitigation, reduction or elimination
of environmental contamination at the Sites.
5. All documents relating to any steps taken by you for, or on behalf of, Viacom in
response to any directive, order or other instructions from a local, state or federal governmental
(or quasi-govermnental) authority or agency relating to the DePue or Palmerton Sites.
6. All documents relating to any steps taken by you for, or on behalf of, Mobil in
response to any directive, order or other instructions from a local, state or federal governmental
(or quasi-governmental) authority or agency relating to the DePue or Pahnerton Sites.
7. All documents relating to any steps taken by you for, or on behalf of, Horsehead
in response to any directive, order or other instructions from a local, state or federal
govenunental (or quasi-governmental) authority or agency relating to the DePue or Palmerton
Sites.
8. All documents or communications by or between you and any members of the
public, including homeowners, community members, or civic groups, relating to the DePue and
Palmerton Sites, or any documents relating to comments or complaints or investigations into
comments or complaints made by members of the public.
9. All work proposals, scope of work and contracts relating to any work performed
by you at the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
10. All field notes associated with any work performed by you at the DePue and
Palmerton Sites.
11. All memoranda prepared in connection with any work performed by you at the
DePue and Palmerton Sites.
12. All correspondence prepared or received by you in connection with any work
performed by you at the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
13. All internal work papers prepared and retained by you in connection with any
work performed by you at the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
14. All drafts of reports prepared in connection with any work performed by you at
the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
15. All final reports prepared in connection with any work performed by you at the
DePue and Palmerton Sites.
16. Any photographs (including aerial photographs), maps, drawing, diagrams and
videotapes of the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
17. All documents and communications by or between Viacom, or any representative
thereof, and you relating to or regarding any work performed for Viacom relating to the DePue
and Palmerton Sites.
18. All documents and communications by or between Mobil, or any representative
thereof, and you relating to or regarding any work performed for Mobil relating to the DePue and
Palmerton Sites.
19. All documents and communications by or between Horsehead, or any
representative thereof, and you relating to or regarding any work performed for Horsehead
relating to the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
20. All documents and communications by or between you and any federal, state or
local governmental (or quasi-governmental) authority or agency relating to the DePue and
Palmerton Sites.
21. All documents and communications by or between any other person or entity and
you relating to or regarding the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
22. All documents relating to the location, layout, design or methods of operation at
the DePue and Palmerton sites.
23. All charts, studies, reports, maps, drawings or documents setting forth, describing
or discussing the soil characteristics, surface water configuration, geology, hydrogeological
characteristics or subsurface characteristics at the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
24. All documents or information that Viacom, Horsehead or Mobil supplied to you
regarding environmental contamination at or fi:om the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
25. All documents relating to historical waste disposal practices at the DePue and
Palmerton Sites.
26. All documents relating to the maintenance and housekeeping of the DePue and
Palmerton Sites, including, but not limited to, any interview or inquiry of past or present
employees as to the historic maintenance, disposal and/or waste handling practices at the Sites.
27. All documents relating to costs incurred and costs to be incurred at the DePue and
Palmerton Sites as a result of work conducted, proposed or recommended by you at the DePue or
Palmerton Sites for, or on behalf of Viacom.
28. All documents relating to costs incurred and costs to be incurred at the DePue and
Palmerton Sites as a result of work conducted, proposed or recommended by you at the DePue or
Palmerton Sites for, or on behalf of Mobil.
29. All documents relating to costs incurred and costs to be incurred at the DePue and
Palmerton Sites as a result of work conducted, proposed or recommended by you at the DePue or
Palmerton Sites for, or on behalf of Horsehead.
30. All documents referring or relating to any current or past corporate document
retention and/or destruction policy, practice, procedure or program implemented by you and
applicable to any documents responsive to any of the foregoing requests and/or having any
impact on your ability to fully and completely respond thereto.
NEWARKI\14948\1 088309.000
ATTACHMENT "A"
A. DEFINITIONS AND INSTRUCTIONS
1. These requests refer to all responsive documents in your possession, custody or
control which were prepared, created, examined, sent, delivered or received by you during the
time period from 1899 to the present, inclusive, unless otherwise stated.
2. All responsive documents within your possession, custody, or control shall be
produced, including all responsive documents which were prepared, created, examined, sent,
delivered or received by you, and all respunsivc documents available to you or any of your
predecessors, successors, agents, employees, attorneys, accountants, representatives, independent
contractors, or others from whom you are capable of deriving documents or information.
3. Any request for any document shall bc deemed to request a copy of the document
(without abbreviation or redaction) whenever the original is unavailable or whenever the copy
has written matter on it not present in the original, including alternations, notes, comments, or
other material not appearing on the original, or whenever a copy has attached to it any
alternations, revisions, drafts or other preliminary material. Any request for a document shall
also include drafts, revisions of drafts and other preliminary material, from whatever source,
underlying, supporting, or used in thc preparation of any document.
4. The terms "you" and "your," unless otherwise specified, shall mean BCM
Engineers, its corporate predecessors (including but not limited to Betz Environmental
Engineers), successors, subsidiaries, parents, affiliates, offices, branches, departments, bureaus
and divisions, and all present and former employees, agents, officers, directors, attorneys or
representatives of that company.
5. The term "document" is used in the broadest sense permissible under applicable
New Jersey law and rules governing the scope of discovery to encompass any written,
typewritten, printed, or graphic matter of any kind or character, including, but not limited to,
correspondence, notations, papers, books, agreements, applications, forms, telegrams and
telefaxes, contracts, reports, minutes and records from any meetings, memoranda, notes, e-mails,
e-mail attachments, diary entries, telephone slips or logs, calendars, bills, invoices, charts,
studies, graphs, summaries of investigations, calculations, analyses, drawings, photographs,
maps, transcripts and affidavits, and also including films and videotapes, other tapes or
recordings, transcripts, computer printouts and information stored in computers or other data
storage or processing equipment.
6. "Person" or "persons" means all natural and legal persons, including, without
limitation, individuals, corporations, joint ventures, partnerships, trusts, sole proprietorships,
unincorporated associations and any agency, division, subdivision, branch or department of any
local, state or federal government.
7. "Relating to" or "relate to" means to consist of, refer to, pertain to, reflect,
discuss, describe, cite, evidence, concern, summarize, analyze or be in any way logically or
factually connected (directly or indirectly) with the matter discussed.
8. All references to the singular include the plural and all references to the plural
include the singular, as necessary, to produce the most inclusive response·
9. The term "or" shall mean "and/or;" the term "and" shall mean "and/or." Both
terms shall be construed broadly to produce the most inclusive response·
10. The term "each" shall mean "each and every;" the term "every" shall mean "each
and every." Both terms shall be construed broadly to produce the most inclusive response.
11. For any document requested herein that was at one time in your possession,
custody or control but is no longer so, the request shall be deemed to include all documents
reflecting or relating to the disposition or current location of the original and each copy of each
such document.
12. "Viacom" shall mean Viacom International, Inc., and any corporate predecessors,
successors, parents, subsidiaries, partners, affiliates, divisions, members, other entities under
common control, offices, branches, departments, bureaus and divisions, including but not limited
2
to, Viacom, Inc., Viacom International Inc., Paramount Communications, Inc., Viacom
International Services, Inc., Gulf & Western Corporation, Gulf + Western Inc., The New Jersey
Zinc Company, Zinminco, Inc., E.W. Bliss Company and Universal American Corporation and
all present or former employees, agents, officers, and directors thereof.
13. "Mobil" shall mean Exxon Mobil Corporation, and any corporate predecessors,
successors, parents, subsidiaries, partners, affiliates, divisions, members, other entities under
common control, offices, branches, departments, bureaus and divisions, including but not limited
to, Mobil Oil Company, and all present or former ~anployees, agents, officers, and directors
thereof.
14. "Horsehead" shall mean Horsehead Industries, Inc., and any corporate
predecessors, successors, parents, subsidiaries, affiliates, offices, branches, departments, bureaus
and divisions, and all present or former employees, agents, officers, and directors thereof.
15. The "DePue Site" shall mean the: a) property and facilities located in and around
DePue, Illinois which were owned and operated by Viacom upon which, or with respect to
which, you performed environmental investigation and/or remediation; b) the site identified by
the United States Environmental Protection Agency as CERCLIS No. ILD062340641 (64 Fed.
Reg. 24949, May I0, 1999), as same may be enlarged from time to time by any Government
Entity; and c) all land, ai~:, water (including surface water and ground water), atmosphere, natural
resources, disposed or other wastes, abandoned property and real or personal property, which has
been alleged to have been affected, directly or indirectly, by the operations, acts or omissions of
Viacom, Horsehead or Mobil in and around DePue, Illinois.
16. The "Palmerton Site" shall mean a) property and facilities located in and arotmd
Palmerton, Pennsylvania which were owned and operated by Viacom upon which, or with
respect to which, you performed environmental investigation and/or remediation; b) the site
identified by the United States Environmental Protection Agency as CERCLIS No.
PAD002395887 (48 Fed. Reg. 40658, September 30, 1983), as same may be enlarged from time
3
to time by any Government Entity; and c) all land, air, water (including surface water and ground
water), atmosphere, natural resources, disposed or other wastes, abandoned property and real or
personal property, which has been alleged to have been affected, directly or indirectly, by the
operations, acts or omissions of Viacom, Horsehead or Mobil in and around Palmerton,
Pennsylvania.
17. "Environmental contamination" shall mean the actual, alleged, potential or
threatened contamination of, or injury or damage to air, environment, atmosphere, land, soil,
sediments, property, water (including groundwater and surface water), natural resources, plant
life, animal life or any natural person or class or group of natural persons, by or arising fxom the
presence, existence, movement, emission, discharge, seepage, release, dispersal, disposal,
dumping, or escape of, or exposure to, hazardous substances, hazardous wastes, fertilizers,
irritants, contamination, pollutants, toxins, vapors, fumes, methane gas, acids, alkalis, metals,
chemicals, energy, radiation, oil, polychlorinated biphenyls, petroleum, petroleum derivatives,
silica, benzene, contaminating liquids or gases, waste materials of any type or any other material,
substance or causative agent alleged by any person in the past, now or in the future to be
(whether before or after its or their presence, existence, movement, emission, discharge, seepage,
release, dispersal, disposal, dumping, or escape) detrimental, harmful, injurious, hazardous,
noxious, nuisance-causing or toxic.
18. If any objection is made to any numbered or lettered paragraph or subparagraph,
or any portion thereof, of any request herein, documents shall be produced as to any and all
portions thereof, as to which no objection is made.
19. Within 30 days after service of the attached subpoena, you shall serve upon the
requesting parties or their designee(s) a log which (i) identifies each responsive document that
has been withheld or redacted for any reason or has been destroyed or is otherwise no longer in
your custody or possession or subject to your control and (ii) provides the following information
with respect to each such document:
4
f~
g.
h~
The nature of the document (i.e. letter, memorandum, etc.);
The date of the document;
The author of the document;
The subject matter of the document;
The addressees of the document;
The recipients of copies;
The document request to which the document is
responsive;
If known, the positions andIor affiliations of the
author, addressees and recipients at the time of the
date of the document; and
The legal basis for withhold'mg or redacting the
document, if any.
20. These Requests shall be deemed to be cont'muing so as to require further and
supplemental responses as you obtain additional information between the time of responding
hereunder and the trial of this action.
21. All documents shall be produced in an orderly manner with appropriate markings
or other identification to allow identification of the source of'the document, the file in which it
was maintained, and the person to whom such file belongs.
22. All indices or similar documents that list, classify, organize, record, explain or
enumerate responsive documents shall be produced along with the responsive documents.
23. If a document requested no longer exists or has otherwise been disposed Of,
identify each such document and state the date of, circumstances surrounding, and reasons for its
disposal; identify the person responsible for and the persons who have knowledge of the disposal
and provide all other information that would be of use in obtaining the document, a copy of it, or
the information contained in it.
B. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
You are hereby required to identify and produce for deposition, at the time and place
designated in the accompanying subpoena, one or more officers, directors, managing agents, or
other agents and employees with the most knowledge concerning the DePue and/or Palmerton
Sites.
C. DOCUMENTS REQUESTED
1. All documents in your possession, custody or control relating to the investigation
of environmental contamination at the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
2. All documents relating to hydrogeologic, geologic, surface water, soil and
engineering evaluations, testing, experiments, investigations, reports, studies or analyses of the
DePue and Palmerton Sites.
3. All documents used or reviewed by you in connection with any evaluations,
testing, experiments, reports, studies or analyses of the DePue and Palmerton Sites prepared by
you for, or on behalf of, Viacom.
4. All documents relating to your work at the DePue and Palmerton Sites, including,
but not limited to, remediation, disposal, storage, treatment, mitigation, reduction or elimination
of environmental contamination at the Sites.
5. All documents relating to any steps taken by you for, or on behalf of, Viacom in
response to any directive, order or other instructions from a local, state or federal governmental
(or quasi-governmental) authority or agency relating to the DePue or Palmerton Sites.
6. All documents relating to any steps taken by you for, or on behalf of, Mobil in
response to any directive, order or other instructions from a local, state or federal governmental
(or quasi-governmental) authority or agency relating to the DePue or Palmerton Sites.
7. All documents relating to any steps taken by you for, or on behalf of, Horsehead
in response to any directive, order or other instructions from a local, state or federal
governmental (or quasi-governmental) authority or agency relating to the DePue or Palmerton
Sites.
8. All documents or communications by or between you and any members of the
public, including homeowners, community members, or civic groups, relating to the DePue and
Palmerton Sites, or any documents relating to comments or complaints or investigations into
comments or complaints made by members of the public.
9. All work proposals, scope of work and contracts relating to any work performed
by you at the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
10. All field notes associated with any work performed by you at the DePue and
Palmerton Sites.
11. All memoranda prepared in connection with any work performed by you at the
DePue and Palmerton Sites.
12. All correspondence prepared or received by you in connection with any work
performed by you at the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
13. All internal work papers prepared and retained by you in connection with any
work performed by you at the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
14. All drafts of reports prepared in connection with any work performed by you at
the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
15. All final reports prepared in connection with any work performed by you at the
DePue and Palmerton Sites.
16. Any photographs 0ncluding aerial photographs), maps, drawing, diagrams and
videotapes of the DePue and Palmertun Sites.
17. All documents and COn~l~lIJ~l'lcatiorls by or between Viacom, or any representative
thereof, and you relating to or regarding any work performed for Viacom relating to the DePue
and Palmerton Sites.
18. All documents and communications by or between Mobil, or any representative
thereof, and you relating to or regarding any work performed for Mobil relating to the DePue and
Palmerton Sites.
19. All documents and communications by or between Horsehead, or any
representative thereof, and you relating to or regarding any work performed for Horsehead
relating to the DePue and Pahnerton Sites.
20. All documents and communications by or between you and any federal, state or
local governmental (or quasi-governmental) authority or agency relating to the DePue and
Palmerton Sites.
21. All documents and communications by or between any other person or entity and
you relating to or regarding the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
22. All documents relating to the location, layout, design or methods of operation at
the DePue and Palmerton sites.
23. All charts, studies, reports, maps, drawings or documents setting forth, describing
or discussing the soil characteristics, surface water configuration, geology, hydrogeological
characteristics or subsurface characteristics at the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
24. All documents or information that Viacom, Horsehead or Mobil supplied to you
regarding environmental contamination at or from the DePue and Palmerton Sites.
25. All documents relating to historical waste disposal practices at the DePue and
Palmerton Sites.
26. All documents relating to the maintenance and housekeeping of the DePue and
Palmerton Sites, including, but not limited to, any interview or inquiry of past or present
employees as to the historic maintenance, disposal and/or waste handling practices at the Sites.
27. All documents relating to costs incurred and costs to be incurred at the DePue and
Palmerton Sites as a result of work conducted, proposed or recommended by you at the DePue or
Palmerton Sites for, or on behalf of Viacom.
28. All documents relating to costs incurred and costs to be incurred at the DePue and
Palmerton Sites as a result of work conducted, proposed or recommended by you at the DePue or
Palmerton Sites for, or on behalf of Mobil.
29. All documents relating to costs incurred and costs to be incurred at the DePue and
Palmerton Sites as a result of work conducted, proposed or recommended by you at the DePue or
Palmerton Sites for, or on behalf of Horsehead.
30. All documents referring or relating to any current or past corporate document
retention and/or destruction policy, practice, procedure or program implemented by you and
applicable to any documents responsive to any of the foregoing requests and/or having any
impact on your ability to fully and completely respond thereto.
NEWARKI\I4948\l 088309.000
COZEN O'CONNOR
MATTHEW F. HENRY, ESQURIE
Atty. I.D. No.: 88364
1900 Market Street
Philadelphia, PA 19103
(215)665.7248
NAY 1 9 2004
Attorneys for Defendants, AIU Insurance Company, American Home Assurance Company,
Birmingham Fire Insurance Company of Pennsylvania, Granite State Insurance Company,
Landmark Insurance Company, Lexington Insurance Company and National Union Fire
Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, Pa.
VIACOM INTERNATIONAL, INC.,
Plaintiff,
V.
COURT O'F COMMON PLEAS
CUMBER/LAND COUNTY
MISCELLANEOUS ACTION NO.:
ADMIRAL INSURANCE CO., et al.,
Defendants.
ORDER
AND NOW, this z/~' day of /~ ,2004, upnn consideration of the petition
of AlU Insurance Company, American Home Assurance Company, Birmingham Fire Insurance
Company of Pennsylvania, Granite State Insurance Company, Landmark Insurance Company,
Lexington Insurance Company and National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, Pa.
for the issuance of a subpoena pursuant to 42 Pa.C.S. § 5326, it is ORDERED and DECREED
that the petition is GRANTED.
It is further ORDERED that the Cumberland County Prothonotary shall issue a subpoena
duces tecum in the form attached hereto, compelling Gannett Flemming, Inc. (f/Wa Gannett,
Flemming, Corddry & Carpenter, Inc.) 207 Senate Avenue, Camp Hill, PA 17011 to (1) produce
the documents designated in the schedule thereto on such a date as may be agreed by the witness
O~ ... F,~LED-OFF'iCE
, ~hc PROT,~!C, NOyAq¥
and all interested parties, but in any event, not mom than two weeks after the service of the
subpoena, at a location in Cumberland County that shall be agreed by the witness and all
interested parties, and (2) to have a representative with knowledge of those documents appear for
deposition on such a date as may be agreed by the witness and all interested parties, at a location
in Cumberland County that shall be agreed by the witness and all interested parties.
2