The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About04-2397 . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA BRIAN NAILOR Plaintiff vs. No. 04-,;u91 Civil Term CIVIL ACTION-LAW DENISE KANELAS and JAMES KANELAS Defendants NOTICE TO DEFEND You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty days (20) days after this complaint and notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you by the court without further notice for any money c1airned in the cornplaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the plaintiff. You rnay lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. Cumberland County Bar Association 32 S. Bedford Street Carlisle, P A 17013 (717) 249-3166 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEASE OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA BRIAN NAILOR Plaintiff vs. : No. 04- J 397 Civil Term CIVIL ACTION - LA W DENISE KANELAS and JAMES KANELAS 6 Abbey Lane Camp Hill, PA 17011 Defendants COMPLAINT AND NOW, this 26th day of April, 2004, comes Plaintiff, by and through his attorney, Joseph D. Buckley, and cornplains of Defendants as follows: I. Plaintiff, Brian Nailor, is an adult United States citizen who current resides at 2030 Walnut Bottom Road, Carlisle, Cumberland County, P A. 2. Plaintiff, a finish carpenter and cabinet maker, owns and operates a business called Brian Nailor Carpentry, Etc. also from said 2030 Walnut Bottom Road, Carlisle, P A 17013 location. 3. Defendants, James and Denise Kanelas, are adult Unites States citizens, currently husband and wife, who own and reside in the property located at 6 Abbey Lane, Camp Hill, Cumberland County, P A 170 II. 4. On several occasions during the years 2000 through 2002 Defendant, Denise Kanelas, then Denise Romminger, employed Plaintiff for carpentry work and other jobs at her then residence. 5. During said time period all work completed for Defendant Denise Kanelas was performed on a time and material basis, all in a professional workmanlike manner and bills for work were presented at the end of the work completed. 6. At the end of said time period Plaintiff extended credit to Defendant Denise Kanelas, then Romminger, for work completed based on her statements that she was having marital difficulties and would have to make payments to Plaintiff over time. 7. Plaintiff permitted said Defendant to make time payments for work performed. 8. In July 2003, Defendant Denise Kanelas contacted Plaintiff and requested that he come to her new residence as she and her husband needed some work performed. 9. Plaintiff arrived at the Defendants' home and spoke with the Defendants regarding potential work. 10. Plaintiff was showed through the home and Defendants described in detail the various work they desired including, repair and replacement of a door, crown molding in a bedroom, cabinets and shelving in the nursery and shelves in many area and some other minor jobs. ' II. Defendants also specifically requested that Plaintiff build them a umque, custom buffet cabinet for the dining room made to a certain size and with specific dimensions. 12. Plaintiff asked if Defendant Denise Kanelas if she desired a written estimate for the work and she replied "No, I just want it done." 13. Defendants inquired whether the work could be completed by the end of October and Plaintiff told them of his existing commitments but promised he would begin as soon as openings permitted. Plaintiff estimated that he could not cornplete Defendants' work, especially the custom piece, until sometime in November 2003. 14. On August 8, 2003, Plaintiff installed the crown molding in Defendants' bedroom. 15. By late September, 2003, Plaintiff had replaced the back door, installed the crown molding and had made an example of the shelves for approval and received an installment payment of $1000.00 toward materials from Defendants. 16. On Septernber 26, 2003, Defendants approved the shelves and Defendant James Kanelas approved the height the shelving were to be placed on the wall. 17. On September 29, 2003, the nursery cabinets and shelving were delivered to Defendants' residence. 18. Defendants were to paint the shelves and cabinets prior to having Plaintiff install the same. 19. Prior to installation Defendant James Kanelas reiterated the desired height of the cabinets and shelves. 20. On October I, 2003, Plaintiff delivered to Defendants an invoice for time and materials to date in the amount of $3,709.20 less the deposit given Plaintiff of $1,000.00. (A copy of the Job Work Order is attached hereto, made a part hereto and marked Exhibit "A"). 21. At this time Plaintiff and another cabinet maker were crafting the custom buffet cabinet for the Defendants' dining roorn. 22. On October 11, 2003, Plaintiff spoke with Defendant Denise Kanelas regarding the custom mobile buffet cabinet. 23. During this conversation, said Defendant inquired as to the cost of the custom piece; Plaintiff advised Defendant that to date with the time and materials the cost was $3,000.00 - $4,000.00 and that upon completion the cost would be more. 24. On October 22, 2003, Plaintiff installed Defendants nursery shelves and cabinet. 25. On October 22, 2003, Plaintiff had completed the custom buffet cabinet and delivered a bill to Defendants in the amount of $6,201.95. (A copy of the Job Work Order is attached hereto, made a part hereto and marked Exhibit "8"). 26. On October 23, 2003, Plaintiff installed shelving in the Defendants' downstairs playroom. 27. On October 23, 2003, Plaintiff telephoned Defendant Denise Kanelas and informed her that all work was completed, but that Plaintiff would not install the custorn buffet cabinet until he received payment. 28. Defendant telephoned Plaintiff and dernanded he cease all work being done for Defendants. 29. Plaintiff who had completed all work specifically requested by Defendants prior to having been instructed to cease all work, sent Defendants a final corrected bill for the work performed at their home and for the custom work they requested. (A copy of the invoice dated November 3, 2003 is attached hereto, made a part hereto and marked Exhibit "C"). 30. Plaintiff performed all work for Defendants in a professional workmanlike manner and followed their specific directions during his ernploy. 31. The custom buffet cabinet which Defendants specifically requested Plaintiff construct for them is a unique piece, custom built to Defendants' requirements and specifications. 32. Plaintiff has presented a bill for the services totaling $10,167.08 less $1,000.00 rendered at the specific request of Defendants and they have refused to pay the balance due of$9,167.08. 33. Defendants have breached their agreement with Plaintiff for work requested and performed. 34. Defendants have breached their agreement for the construction of a unique and custom piece of furniture designed and specified by Defendants. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requests this Honorable Court enter a judgrnent in his favor against Defendants in the amount of $9,167.04 plus interest, costs of this suit and any other amounts the Court deems fair and just. Jo h D. B Attorney for e Plaintiff Supreme Court LD. # 38444 1237 Holly Pike Carlisle, PA 17013-4435 (717) 249-2448 VERIFICATION I, Brian Nailor, the Plaintiff in this matter, hereby verify that I have read the foregoing Complaint and the statements made therein are true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief. I understand that statements made herein are subject to the penalties of Title 18 Section 4909 relating to unsworn falsifications to authorities. Date: April 26, 2004 ~~ BRIAN NAILOR EXHIBIT "A" . .__.~-,.._.~'".-..._..~..< , f' i (1 , BRIAN NAilOR CARPENTRY ETC. 2030 Walnut Bottom Road Carlisle, PA 17013 Phone:(717)243~6 JOB WORK ORDER e\O~O\.03 ), ""', ;1 'q j , ~ "J , .f . '.- , ~ .~ '""\ ,~ , ') Pt"rioci or ,1uiy 15 t"L- Cci I Sf Jobor:1 $\qSO.-i " t1:riod Df LTu\~ 15il1-CX't )st- ~X\tflft:AjaP1>: _'~ $r12Q,20 j ~si't- A'\Uuie~ ''tf2&> - ---:- lOOO. 9f!..1 To\ri 1 row"",^, C' 2c1QCI, 2S-1 JUt ~ WOfO."S1 ARE D1JE :iO OA YS FRQ"l THE LWOICE DATE. AU.l PAST 0['[ ~i'r;"VNJS ij7U. .j . JJF C;Ol1fCT TO 4 101'...""-...... 112'1 20 ! fINANCE r'i.4(t' J 0-: t.'.; : ..ll 'fONr,. lOTAL I.ABOR I<1W GO '. -1000.t!e -1000 00 .. lOTAL AMOUNT .2,0'1 '2.0 ~ o No """ _ 'ci T_ omwnl; duo 0 r_ billing to i 1"'-;;,: _ WG1l; or be moiIod _ " jab _. J ~ ('U ro \')eJ\I'Sf'. i. :1'i (Y\ Ka..ne la.s AIlIlRESS CIlY G, ~Y'l Loflt' C'.o..mp \-\ i \ ~ TIB -120 ~ I QDAYWORK JlllIMOIE"., lllCATlON Q CONTRACT Q EXTRA \.. I JOe PHONE /liE&CRPIIDN OF _ l>>o1l! CJlWPLEIED I - 0R<EREIl frt ,... 10 /01 /03 ~~-7 -,- /~~,(' EXHIBIT "B" -"'-<~'---"-",-, ,^, BRIAN NAILOR CARPENTRY ETC. 2030 Walnut Bottom Road Carlisle. PA 17013 Phone: (717) 243-6446 '~ 1 ;j :~l JOB WORK ORDER 1 ~ (bATE OF 0RIlEA ) I \.\0-2.\-,.>,') ..~ , .t , c1 .~ ('"UTO \)r1\\se I, ell ell KO,I\f' \Q S ADDRESS CITY (t' Ahhf'( I 0.($ {'11l'Y'\p I-i i \ \ 12B~ l&~ I ODAYWORK JOB MAlE ANJ LOCAllON $\\\" ()C~ I'OGrY\ t' ()(11JOB\~ \ \ "--- ('(\.\:) \ro( t '.::> . /fJEllCAI>nDN OF """" o ccwrRACT o EXTRA r;r; I . \ ,( l-.I\( i ""'>r ra - l".'..'I{ t )l/II " l.n 1:-/ J\ " \-,'," ""... lH T , (2. m("n/cf'II'''') '$ ~:':Jq S . - Pef iL)d J Del 2/\(.1- Or; 2cJ "- ,.iY\Li'if Y I cd".... \ 1= '2 PlOln, qs :f(/)?O\.QS lot-o..l riuL tD(~ .i\i\I's per, eri . All t~NOICfS ARE ellE 30 DAYS rKQN me INVOICE DAl to. AU. PA&T D(,[ N~n\t"l S \Hll. BE ~U;"tC I To" mw.cr (14Ah.. J~ t% ;:iJl 'fONnt Dfo1E CDIIUTED I """" 0fIDEAED IN ... \U no /o?J ,--...-- 0 No.... homo fI.............. WDI'L ~ ---.-'.---.......-...,-. j i ;j ;; ,~ 'J ,)j ..., ,~ l -il ,j .~ '1 j, , 1 1 1 lIlTAL....TERIAUl 2f'UiQ '15 :J TOTAL LABOR ?> "'A S u \:) ] 1 i 1 I TAX TOTALAMOONT I 4>201 '1~ ~ );zf Toto! omaunt due 0 T_ billing to 1"";; __:... be __ jab finiIhod. EXHIBIT "C" ~ Brian Nailor Carpentry Etc. 2030 Walnut Bottom Road Carlisle. PA 17013-9355 e-1WIiI: c.peuayEe.dClJlll (117) 243-6446 Fax (117) 24 3-6+t6 I STATEMENT J REMITTANCE copy SEND THIS copy ALONG WITH YOUR PAYMENT. AMOUNT OF REMTTANCE: TO: Jim and Denise Kanelas 6 Abbey Lane Camp Hill, PA 17011 I DAlE DESCRIF'TION/INVOICE NO. CHARGES (ACCOUNT NUMBeR] 717-728-1268 [PERIOD ENOING) 10123103 (DAlE J ( PAGE J 11103103 1 of 1 CREDITS BAlANCE I TEfUIS: Finance charge of 2% added to balances due after 30 days past invoice date BALANCE FORWARDED > W/22 7 Brian - install bookshelf" $280.00 $280.00 shelving cabine~ in bedroom 10/23 4 Brian - installed playroom shelving downstairs $160.00 $160.00 1~ Cost of operations charge $44.00 $44.00 *** This is for work cOIIpleted prior to notification of work stoppage by Mrs. Kanelas *** PAY AMOUNT SHOWN IN THIS BOX THANK YOUr $484.001 Brian Nailor Carpentry Etc. 2030 WaInul: Bottom Road CarlisIl:. PA 11013-93.55 e-md: c.pawyE@>aol.com mn 243-6+f6 Fax (7J7) 2..3-6446 T~ Jim ~nd Denise Kanelas 6 Abbey Lane Camp Hill, PA 17011 TEfUIS: Finance charge of 2% added to balances due after 30 days past invoice date I DATE DESCRIf' noNllNVOICE NO. CHARGES I STATEMENT I RETAIN THIS COPY FOR YOUR RECORDS. (ACCOUNT NUMBER] l 717-728-1268 ( PJ1RIOD ENDING J 10101103 (DATE J [ PAGE J 11J03.1Oa 1 of 3 CREDITS BALANCE I BALANCE FORWARDED > 7/18 1.5 Looked at job $60.00 7/24 1.5 Dropped off crown lIIOuld $60.00 8/9 4 rnstalled crown $160.00 9/U 1.5 NO one ~/no key either $60.00 9/16 7 Back door/shelf prototype $280.00 9/17 1.5 pick-up Materials $60.00 9/29 12.5 Shelves IIiIde/dropped off $500.00 10/01 20 Build and drop off adjust- $800.00 able shelf cabinet . $60.00 $60.00 $160.00 $60.00 $280.00 $60.00 $500.00 $800.00 PAY AMOUNT SHOWN IN THIS BOX 1 THANK YOUI 11,980.001 Ned". Brian Nailor Carpentry Etc. 2030 WaIuut Bottom Road C AJ'IIsI- PA 17013.9355 e-1DIiI: 'CirpdwyE8>aaLcom (717)243-6+46 Fax (117) :M3-6+t6 I STATEMENT I REIIlrrANCE copy SEND THIS copy ALONG WITH YOUR PA YIIENT. AMClUNT OF REMITTANCE: TO: Jim and Denise Kanelas 6 Abbey Lane Camp Hill, PA 17011 r DATE DESCU 1I0NlltNOlCE NO. CHARGES (ACCOUNT NU_ER) l 717-728-1268 ( PERtOD ENDING J 10101/03 (DATE ) ( PAGE J 11J03103 2 cl3 CREDITS BALANCE I I~~ Finance charge of 2' added to balances due after 30 days past invoice date BAl.J.NCE FORWARDED > Sl.980.00 castle5 lIilteMals DOOr/plywood $580.65 $580.65 Misc. lIilteria15 $37.09 $37.09 Misc. lIilteria15 $21.09 $21.09 Crawn .wlding $90.00 $90.00 The LUllber Yard (Gable vents) $230.55 $230.55 COyle5 l.UlIber (poplar) $42.60 $42.60 POplar Sl4.84 Sl4.84 Eberly lUllber (bits) $50.78 $50.78 DOOr disposal $20.00 $20.00 Iri sc . shop supplies:sandpaper, $26.00 $26.00 glue, screws, nails,& biscuits PAY AIIOUNT SHOWN IN THIS BOX THANK YOUI U,Q92.iO~ Ned-... Brian Nailor Carpentry Etc. 2030 Walnut Bottom Road Carlisle, PA 17013-9355 e-DIIIiI: c.pmayEfi!aaLam ro1) 243-6446 tu (711) ~3-6446 II STATEMENT II RElllTTANCE copy SEND THIS copy ALONG WfTH YOUR PA VIIENT. AMOUNT OF RalTTANCE: TO: Jim and Denise Kanelas 6 Abbey Lane Cawp Hill, PA 17011 I DATE DESGR# 1I0NllNVOlCE NO. CHARGES (ACCOUNT NUMBER) L 717-728-1268 (PERIOD ENDING J 1Q{01/03 (DATE J ( PAGE ) 11103/03 3 of 3 CREDITS BALANCE I TERII8: Finance charge of 2% added to balances due after 30 days past invoice date BALANCE FORWARDED > 53,093.60 25" profit: (lIilt:erials only) 5278.40 5278.40 10S cost: of operat:ion charge 5337.20 $337.20 (lIilt:erials & labor) 9/26 Deposit: on work request:ed $1,000.00 $-1,000.00 . PAY AIICIUNT SHOWN IN THIS BOX(f' --$2.709. 2~~ THANK YOUI "-- ~ CUSTOMER Tho lumber y.,d of C.,lisle 450 eoot Nonh Stroot Coriisle PA 17013-2691 Phone 117-243-4140 f.... 111-243-11411 W_.: I s.M. _ lllClO988 .UHIA"v tv,\i,Ult 1111-243-6446 , : ...... __ 1__. 'IIIMN NA'IOII 2030 WALNUT BOTTOM ROAD CARLISLE PA 11013-0000 717.243.6446 ! , , I , j ; I , I o.Ivrt _1DlIIa 82939043 1 10/2212003 POJIlt.fh.wlllt6 no.JD.ae ICANELOS OCTAGON VENTS Oodw .....JDac. TypeI8ym. 2318959 I OR I COOKVG I 09118/2003 o.Ivrt ~ by: BARKUIf i OeU"ry note ...... I 01 , I, " T____ TlY~ Any Truck Tl Y AIY'f Truck Not~ Shipping '91_ .r..t.u. - 0eiwIy Tm. Item - Puulp.."" Oty o ~ 7).t;0 tl-'o- ??oo10 100038 NON-STOCK Venlllation _ Ext.Vendor With !he following conligurotion: TYPE Of VENTILATION PROOUCT OCTAGON VENTS VEHDOII fAIRWAY VEHDOIIITEM 10 fSKU) MIOAMERICA COLOR 21 DeSCRIPTION Of PRODUCT BURGUNOY REO GENERAL SIZE INfO 21" OCTAGON VENTS j;) 30. 5'S Colivered By Received By ...-,,,"'--...'.', 290 E, POMFRET SmEET CAAU~y=. PA1,7013, PH. (717) 243-~. FAX (717)243-9195 ~~ ES~bN~ " 4 """'J, T~Y,' ,,''"'" ~T~,~BER n-l 'n...... cA_ '~.,..,.",~ 000 0U27 ..JUI....UU. . 'IHVOlCE . ,..J'Hl 2~i6 07 ooa WAR.ER IItl PA TAt, '<<H'i..'U.", \ "','g"<:,,. ',-., '-'---'~,:.....:;''''':~''':'':'':- ~ -"'...",: " "'-"'-., "_e_ ...... "" ~ to AllDIJKf Cl1.\RGEl> "I'll Sl'llIlll ACCOOllT .. 21,89 TWBlJ: 19,89 1OlI- !AUBLE 0.80 S\lilTllTAL 19.8' TAX AftOUIT 1.28 TOTAL untili'" " ~ '. RECEIVED BY -." ~"-""'_"H .,,' - >~~-~~....'...,,- -'" ""C _._",....~..,.,~,."., _. 1liIIU illl) 24304124 Fq .. MIll (717) 243 9821 0flic8: (.717) 486-5535 SollHo p) i . il i'\ Nfl,!a{ ~ Millwortt -. ~ Coyle l.i.mber & M*-'< 231 E. Old _ Ad.. CaIIIsIe. ,.,. 17013 \,/ Mailing Acl<Ire P.O. Box I Mt. Holly Springe, Fl' 171ll _.coylelumber.co I:llIW8r To Data Ortler No. Orlvar III v , . %,0') A.M... '. v AMOUNT )4.00 . 'tq 14, I_F ');;. ,;' l~ /~(i DEIlCRIPTlON .(;. 2.,,"1/1 PRICE I. (j /j !(.;,( ''''- 14-. (6'(+ ,}W;;q 'IJ' " ..A' ~,~~" "" All irMIil:e& .. due on ~t AccxxI1ts 9StabIIshed by prior I I alllhorization aAI due under the tlIrms of that ~. . M\'MENT: I CASH J OBX I MCMSo\ I DI8COYER I_EXPRESS I ~ I~E~*,,.,F~~~IMCE - _e'l-l_ _......_ NZ tt98~ it' OIIIleC_.... ~.,.,tJ..JGMI.;. Mil & 'llW (717) 20..124 Fa II Mill (717) 2<G9821 Ollic8:'(717) ~ , 1/ Mailing Addn P.O. Box MI. Holly Springs, RI\ 17C _.coylelumber.c< ',' SoIdTo (~o! I A~I N I f\UI(l MRss ~To Coyle lumber & ~ 231 E. Old _ Rd.. CarlI8Ie, PA 17013 Dale In Order No, Driver I (/'I I t<.. DESCRIPTION PRICE AMOUNT I ('A"; [Ji F I..-J/\\ ?oP( f'il'l J/ .", 7 '~t,..ja() .. ,f~ ;;. ,1,.--" --' '-:e:. 15 ~~'1 -"._,_..~.. 11"./'-- 79I,'j\ n. '1'0 Sl't" Po L 6oR,6'l All imIoices - due on .-lpt Ac:counls estabIshed by prto'J I aullooi<.dlb. _ due under the terms oIlhat agreement PA\'MIWT: I CASH I CHECK I ~ I OISCO\IER I AM. EXPRESS I I CNERIlUE ACCOUNTS ARE SUBJECT TO 2'Ilo PER MONTH SERVICE . CHNlllE. THlS IS EQUAL TO 11_ _ PERCEIITIlBE IllITE. .... ,'.. . j' -CM....... ___ N~ 1J99( "'-'~'-'~-"-~""-- /~7 OIIM~L"IU"" ~"""eo".GoW _a _ (117j24a-4124 ,Fex at .. (717) 2<13-9821 ()Il"i:a: (117) ,48&-5535 , \....' MalllOg NJ P.O.B Mt. Holly Spri1ga, "" 1 www.coylelumbe, Sold To Bf,'L/V, N <4110 f Coyle WIIb6r & ~ 231 E. Old 'lbrlI Ad. . CerIl8Ie. ~ 17013 ~... DeIiwr To ]" 1;- 11'M) ~ 1.qif1 IlE8CRPJlON Date Order No. 0rIY8r ) 0 I 1:; I 0; PRICE AMOUNT Is BF 4.1' /) I /+ I d r .11 J. ~ t; 4)., } t::', ," i' ) j. d,'! /"'\" "- 40.\ "t,,, 1.'1 4-1. b All irMIices ... due on AIC8Iipt. Al:c:ouIls ~ by prior I I aUlt~, arB due IM1der Ihe terms of !hat agreemenl "WIIENT: I CASH I CfEClC I MCMIIA I OISCO\IER I 11M. EXPfIESS I ~ I OlIEAIllIE ACCClUHTlI AIlE SUBJECT TO "" PER MONTH SERVICE X CHMGE. THIS 18 ECIllo1ll. 10/4"" _ PERCENTAGE RATE. IC'lI . _c.,,_ ____ N2 1.1 98' . ., ... (.4.. .... r U ....., C4J ... .~ ... . ~ ii, .~ ~i ;! ,~~,5.:3+,!Jli," ' -'8.i1" ~'~ ,. ';:. :,',~,!S" ..,.,. <<: l-;:;;::~ i:'~'" ~lS;- ~ as;!::..;! lll'~' .:.. !a ~"~ ~ ',~.'~ .....~.., OC'.:/iia I :O"'~.' ! ~l::!"''::''. ... r;"" ...~ ~ i ~ !i1.,_.~ ... ~-_. -~~j . =_! - ;Es;~~~s~ il~ ;~~ . >- Ar- ~ P :;) o ~ CIi .... ~ 'i;~t!:~ [~;:2t , "'''':j .....i.,.:.,./ff. ,. ~"" . "1"'- ~ .. ... . f:1,." : : . ... . . Co.) .. - ......"".. III Q... :.f; :- ~ '."".. :-":-';': .. ...... I~g ;,w~ .;r- 1 ,!! :is s ar: r" Jm 'i-;;;-~'-ll - =-~ ~ llIi... 'i "'... ~ a'J"" III 2::1 -.\.,; -. '''l%~ , ,,'" <' .'~ ',"',""".'" r . ",...... , ' II> CD - CD Iii !, ~fW"t')..-...:......' :-a:-', .:: ';:'H1?:.~ CIJ~:~ Iii!~' .--,...-y' ,..,~,tEw-..;1': :E-'CD o!!Z~ ',Q,;:,~,-C?;.::,.,.,- ,w~~ 00'<11' (J) '~ t\I .... 'E. :r ~ '~1 r ,- .1~ . ~> :JIl ... i:i ... ~-'--_...-.,..,-", ~ s $18. ~f:i~ ... ... ..; ... ... ~Cl':tt: ~t-i.n ... t:I t:lt:Ii:! .... i:!.-:li:! .. - ......, Ie - - - s:: lSlioilIJ ... S::~!Q ... ... 'N ..; .nM ... ... ~ CQ~'~ ... "''''l!l ~s:/ ,i!j ..... ... 1 .~~~ r... ~,t:t~ f:l&l m ~ ~ :J <:I. i:i i:i i:I <:I ^"" \. I--- \_____ .f.:t co~~ ... -....FI I ~ ~z~ ~.~ ,,"') .W') ~ :;JE~ ....,J::: E l,fA --, >n '" ~ . . "..",,<v..~',"' . ~ o w ~ ~ '" ;:j \-\'\ I.' ,~ ... ~ \\. \' \ '\...." > .. o ~ W o w a: ::u :'l 1ft <' l!l 'I! \ \ "< \ " \\ !=i 31 .. II~ . .. p;~! ! ! J i> . J .... 'i' ~ .... ,.., , IIi '" . ~ J a,..., ia ~j - . ... .. ... w - ... t I " . ?i a 'T.I. tl ~.". I ! C! '" j f "' .' . .... ;t :i ~ ~,.:t' :sa:s ~ ':S ,';,. n I ~ ~ ~iY!!l -:::~ "'0 -- ~",m II> !!l ~ co - III .-. a;:;; .... "w:a~ ...~ ... :<1 - ;1 ~ i ;:::: III [ "'" ~. ~ . -. ....~ . . ...... . . .. ...... ... ... . i! . .... .'. . .. ans'" ... .... .... .. . .... Brian Nailor Carpentry Etc. 2030 WaIaut Iloa:om Road ("'-"~ PA 11013-9355 e-1IIlIiI: QqxuayE@laoi.com. ffi7) 243-6+46 tu (717) 243-6+46 I STATEMENT I REIII1TANCE copy SEND THIS copy ALONG wrrH YOUR PA VIIENT. AMOUNT CF REMITTANCE: TO: Jim and Denise Kanelas 6 Abbey Lane Camp Hill, fA 17011 DESCRIP11ON/INV NO. (ACCOUNT NUMBER) 717-728-1268 (PERIOD ENDING J 10120t'03 (DATE J ( PAGE J 11103103 1 of 3 CREDITS BALANCE 1 ~: Finance charge of 2% added to balances due after 30 days past invoice date 1 DATE W/07 10/08 W/09 W/W 10/13 W/14 10/15 CHARGES BALANCE FORWARDED > 1 pick up .aterials $35.00 535.00 5 Brian - dining cabinets $175.00 $175.00 5 Darb - dining cabinets $175.00 $175.00 7 Brian - dining cabinets $245.00 $245.00 6 Darb - dining cabinets $210.00 $210.00 7 Brian - dining cabinets $245.00 $245.00 6 Darb - dining cabinets $210.00 $210.00 6 Brian - sand out cabinets $210.00 $210.00 5 Darb - sand out cabi nets $175.00 $175.00 8 Brian - drawers and doors $280.00 $280.00 7 Darb - drawers and doors $245.00 $245.00 8 Brian - door parts/glue up $280.00 $280.00 8 Darb - door parts/glue up $280.00 $280.00 PAY AMOUNT SHOWN IN 1HIS BOX 1 $2.765.001 THANK YOUI Brian Nailor Carpentry Etc. 2030 Walnut Bottom Road C-"iIlsdr PA li\l.l3-9355 e-IIIIiI: Q.pauryE@ldaxp ID1)243-6<<6 Fax (7l1) 243-6<<6 I STATEMENT I REMITTANCE copy $END THIS copy ALONG WI7H YOUR PA'tIIENT'. AMOUNT OF REMITTANCE: TO: Jim and Denise Kanelas 6 Abbey Lane Camp Hill, PA 17011 r DATE DEKIUP.kONIINVOICE NO. CHARGES (ACCfOUNT NUMBER] L 717.728-1268 ( PEIqOO ~DfNG) 1Q1'2(1103 ( DA~'] ( PAGE ] 11J03103 2 d 3 CREDITS BALANCE I TERMS: F1nance charge ot 2' added to balances due atter 30 days past invoice date BALANCE FORWARDED > $2,765.00 10/16 4 Irian - sand out doors 2 oarb - sand out doors $140.00 570.00 $140.00 $70.00 cayles LuMber (poplar) $108.89 $308.89 castles Ulllber (plywood) $679.27 5679.27 castles Lu.ber (.ise supplies) 522.64 $22.64 castles Lu.ber (shiMS) 54.87 54.87 Eberly l~r(pocketscrew jig) $164.20 $164.20 Eberly LuMber (.isc. supplies) $62.64 562.64 ROCkler (cabinet hardware) 5552.00 $552.00 ** estillilted cost for Roekler, it815 not ordered yet ** PAY AMOUNT SHOWN IN THIS BOX I THANK YOUI $4,769.511 Brian Nailor Ca1pentry Etc. 2030 Wakwt Bottom Rold Carlisk, PA 17013-9355 e-mail: c.peuayEeaal.c:om (717) 2.H.6446 Fu (7J7) 2>f3-t1+f6 II STATEMENT I RETAIN THIS COPY FOR YOCMf RECORDS. TO: Jim and Denise Kanelas 6 Abbey L.1Lne Camp lUll, PA 17011 (ACCOUNT NUMBER) 717-n&-1268 ( p~ ENDING) 1~03 (DATE J ( PAGE ) 11J0:W3 3 d 3 CREDITS BALANCE I TEllIS: Finance charge of 2\ added to balances due after 30 days past invoice date r DATE DE8CRIP1IONIINVOICE NO. CHARGES BALANCE FORWARDED > $4,769.51 25" profit (IIilterials only) $448.63 $448.63 1ml Cost of operations charge $521.81 $521.81 (IIilterials and labor) **Original billing invoice was for $6201.95, however, upon careful review,an error in the hours worked was found. T1Ii s then credited 13 hours back to the custoMr. our apologies. . PAY AMOUNT SHOWN IN THIS BOX L THANK YOUI $5,739.951 ,"'-": /-"""'\ ........= r, r-' .-- ~ "* r,''-:' i-- '= ". 1"""\ ;~ ..... r. .: ,-.. ~., - ,....., , r.. ,'"\ ,J it I.. Ij l ' ~l!t i-:. :! I ;)J, <-r:: cr-'F ~' . '..... -;t;;' <f\,QU"J':;'li'l1,:;;'11->- . :e:,...... ,....'1'}' , ,. ""-""ii-;':' ~ '(!- ""'i;j .,..'''''1. ;: ,0 ~.; .;"', >J, ~,~ ~2" :;,111;,:: III . . f' ,,,' iI1 > ", ~ 'v' ':..:, ~ f;"';.-.:,ru -',- ~,+ ',:})-,_; ;,,::,t,;,:;: r.>fi' :, .~" ..',^,,",C,.., 'Cj' ;"""iI~f'''' ~i' ...:7 e;\ ~ b;M 1...." ~ -:'pr',:i{,', :r, "::,r<:~; Itf;-:--~I;~':' "''''i'~;? c. . !!!;.,,., . ~">1, '; ':'~~: "~'';':;'i:,.~t'__ "IIIl.": .,,,~,.' ....,-." ;r-_ C ,,"~j::,._ ;"1?.a\,,:';j_ l ! I 11~.i I! ~1 !r ! ~ ill! .1. ~I" l~' :hh , , ~ 1:11 ! i . u!i i i. \~ Un! !l"t\ itu I ~! ~ ilfll g " ll" I, rn '''. !.! i 't iU I i Iii! ! I r! 'I)i~~ i , 'r~i .I~ ! "" - i I!! ..h i ... """.n ~I'" .' <-'\ ,.l ;;= >- D. o U o a: ~ .... >- II: .... ~ ~ I~ ~i ~ ~;:: f "'... :[ "!I~jiJ ~~ Ji.:.! j=f~1 ~, i '~I';':""':" n'_ ~r,%:;\ r);'[: ~: .-~ ,";4~~'- ~~ 2~ .... ~,~~J 8:';:' v , .C',;; tdi fif': [.i "" Q" "~ '1;''' ~' u ~ .: - "'. ~ ~ a:: r-- J" 0~':b' ; e w ,...., :;: ?"~"~"'i}. . , ",- -;.C <t: l:o:: '" h;'. z.... . :",Ii!, J ''';~Jo',,;o<'._-'':'~-:_:''' '"~" ',' ,'--' . ", ;'-,' , ' ~ ;t' 'ir": ':h, lj ,. '" r ,1'"'50/' ~" r -' .. ;---, ~ .,-.. ',~, - 1'"', I'"' :-. :i:i'-', - - ,'''-'''' J'-', \ :i it U ll'~ . Ji!~;;G:,Lj~~~:~,. . 'i1( !:i"~:':::;"';<1C:;:" " -;: . _'-' . ,.'i-~ " - . > IL o OC'.> ,,'r; "'",,,:.:,,;., ';;;>':i;JJ~,:";)_,.:::, .,..\ II: ~ .... > II: W > ~ I!i'" , !~ ~t: .; \ ;;?~.L:.~ ~g ~ !",^,,!i'L:, .,. ;~tii ~!ii~~I~ <:,l:~:~ 'A~ ' !: .lI11J: ".;. ., h' . ~~' >>.~1 ,:':;F; ~r'. ~ .~,:;;~(~~:~i: EI~:::~~ ,"i.X,...:;j:!j;.~ :'1'"~-~;)4-'.:';' :.~):51~ :~l:~~~rti~": ',,::, ,-' <J i&:j! ~!'\':~ 41 'fui~: '1~, ,'. Ilt:t ~~ ~,_:, c~:- :-:," .".tn9.";'O-~-.o . ,- ... . ". -', .... ~~..I:~ ' 0' '-,:, 1\ ' 1\ - --,;";~'-" . " '*''''', .,/. _ " , ".- -"';--e;. _,' ':' A:lt~:"'r",;:,r-'I'"' "'" '~I\ ,-.' .' . .,,:'.,', ,,:_.,_ _",~..,,:...;,:J"""-, ' " ',~', ,__:,.., __....~"_~_:,.."y"'" "". ,-,- 'iI...rt,.,-~..~..,~",.~~,:"...:~..:zw -.'~ __ , .,'''' . ....~....,.^'. ~"-'<- .....,."c'....-- ~,..~.J:,.:~.i;..;~ ',''1 ". "'>/" l .J .'~"';' ,-:r ,.,,,,,,,,,,,'. >- G;- o Q., tE' ~ e- (I) :;) u .~?--. !II ~ /jj ~ UI~;;::- ~;;- 0!5e /jj!(~ a:a:u: U.wo ;<-.10> oral G.if. 1U:{;1 O~'" 0> ;::: '" - .... - r~ flJl ~I "'j fIJ ~ ~ :?! i 'i :::: ~ ~ ~ ~(':"i:~ :_~";; ,c, i (, 1;.',.-.... ., ;~q:;-~;J.~~ ('S : .. ~:tj - . - . Q . ... . -. ....- ~ : . I ei f!:i", ;:~ "'... a... &.i ~ .. ~~ "'>-- ~l ,'. ii ",,,,, i1/ '1;jI :/' '" J _0"" -, ~l?;fJ~ I ~') -: x<i -.: - f i---__'___,_,___________, ,,~! L" .,~--- ~f , .it iff " .,.. ..;., . ~ ~ ~. ~ =tjt!~ ~'.;) ., -.c S . ,. '" m ~:n.. ;9i~~,- , d ~tJ!:;, t,o.l~C:.Q.. ~~~~- i;_," '$r' ,&, ~ f,t!," fJ t; ~ t*lJ - %r~~g; J:..'_ __________._ · -,~ ""..~ ""'<: "'J.:: i~<J~~~t.....l P J ~._------------ ;'1': ,(--., t "-._-" , i .~ ~ ' -- ------- ~q~ :.q ....; ~J_; ~.., t""'4 ;j "" ...~ ~ ~;! i5~i2 ~"'.. -r C,I:;. (- =- (,('1 ... '" c~ n, : ~ <.> ... ~ ." i2 i e -- ~ ir! -, ~ Ci; " >- <II o ~ iU ~ )0( >- Q,. I I!' Y r m-,' - ... J;j , ~, ;'11I.., '" fref Jui~ II:'U: g'~': a.!12 '.11:'''' 11I<13 ~o~ - t:. r"'"' l "fijI' ;.}' ,.,2 " "" 'H'. ~:_, '....,.."~..., , '" - ,., "t'a ;=i.' , "::<;~"'il} , ,~ 81 ,... ~ 'i ;;::: J '. tc; ,: -. .. '. e;:l:'J . "':f: '"..... :"-": 3:......: S...,'" ... ;.-:.:: , 'H ti~ :-;g~ !!:'i '. ',~ Jg' ~-:, '" Ii s~.: , II I' 8iS ml , . :.. -J r :2 J .... , . . .f;j - u::au:: ..,I.. ~i~ tlil' !;) . >- lD & ,. ijj o i# "....'.,."._~:~l ~i71i)4ll&'SS35 MaulflgAQll e '..,....... .,_,::'J'J~.;~ Mt. Holly Sprlnge,A'.17 WlWtcoy/8l~.C SoldTo 6<i 1 tl ^ / j\l1 ,\{ ("-,(/ AddIws c.lhwTo Corle Wnber&~ 231 E. Cl!d ~ Rd.' Carlisle.~ 17013 tlElICRtI>noN Date V I ""7 I (", ,?, Older No. Drivw Plllce ~,e Ie."". fBr:: .../ "I ::>1 ' ,<, i e', .. " f,t'. '-"'11 .1/ -:)1"1 75 ....~ .""'>t~V':'_ OJ ~ .5~j~ i5 '<)'( . "'.'"'~.-....\"................. . "T ~:;_ l' 791."11 1'7. (\6 r"",. <"/ \, '> ~ l,~,) t"f. \"..' ~ ""608 ,8'1 =.":.~.:..-t=~~ I I I .""It J~ r- f -I - f "'..,. ~.f --1~'f.;;~J::"" " ." .......- --.tit Ull$ ',...;::(~~.:., :i:;':~':~~.,,, ."". "".::'~..,...:. :.".., ,,~"'<\""'~'"'''''~ " " ~.~.~ .".={~.'1;<~:~t~.:;:~~~; :. L.. ;,...,... . o(Q. ~~ ~ - .t: B ~~~ C>' ~ --.r ..\; o ~ ~T\ c~ ~ ~ (~- __'~ -'f'" -j\ '3:. ~~,'l~; c~ '"" ,),'-, 1(11" -.J .:..~ _:~_\ :~ ;--::f~ - x- c; ----- --- --_.~ .-~--"- ..-..."~ SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 2004-02397 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND NAILOR BRIAN VS KANELAS DENISE ET AL SHANNON SHERTZER Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE KANELAS DENISE was served upon the DEFENDANT at 1545:00 HOURS, on the 10th day of June 2004 at 6 ABBEY LANE CAMP HILL, PA 17011 JAMES KANELAS, ADULT IN CHARGE by handing to a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE together with and at the same time directing His attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing Service Affidavit Surcharge 18.00 10.35 .00 10.00 .00 38.35 Sworn and Subscribed to before me this .2.2.......( day of ~ r10/J'( A.D. fl. L r2 )]",..1#,., AO~ '-r-'t';:;,thonotary , T7 So Answers: r~~ R. Thomas Kline 06/14/2004 JOSEPH BUCKLEY W! By: n/ J '&'~ - Deputy Sher ff - SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 2004-02397 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND NAILOR BRIAN VS KANELAS DENISE ET AL SHANNON SHERTZER , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE KANELAS JAMES was served upon the DEFENDANT at 1545:00 HOURS, on the 10th day of June 2004 at 6 ABBEY LANE CAMP HILL, PA 17011 JAMES KANELAS by handing to a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE together with and at the same time directing His attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing Service Affidavit Surcharge 6.00 .00 .00 10.00 .00 16.00 Sworn and Subscribed to before me this ,;), ;;J."...J.., day of ~d.IJVl.-J A.D. . {2 Jh,-€t7,.. A OLJC P othonotary I~' So Answers: ~/;)./;<P' // .r'~~J"~f'~ R. Thomas Kline 06/14/2004 JOSEPH BUCKLEYp" By: ~~J ~./ Deputy Sherlf II' '\ ! BRIAN NAILOR, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiff vs. CIVIL ACTION - LAW DENISE KANELOS and JAMES KANELOS, NO. 04-2397 Civil Term Defendants NOTICE TO PLAINTIFF NAMED HEREIN: YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED TO RESPOND TO THE ENCLOSED ANSWER AND NEW MATTER COUNTERCLAIM WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS FROM SERVICE HEREOF OR A DEFAULT JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU. Date: to.. Au..~u s+ :lDl)~ Sam I L. Andes Attorney for Defendants Supreme Court ID 17225 525 North 12th Street Lemoyne, PA 17043 (717) 761-5361 II Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA BRIAN NAILOR, vs. CIVIL ACTION - LAW DENISE KANELOS and JAMES KANELOS, NO. 04-2397 Civil Term Defendants DEFENDANTS' ANSWER WITH NEW MATTER AND NOW comes the above-named Defendants, by their attorney, Samuel L. Andes, and make the following Answer, with New Matter, to Plaintiff's Complaint: 1 through 8. Admitted. 9. Denied. Defendant Denise Kanelos handled the discussions and negotiations with Plaintiff. 10. Denied. Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New Matter. . 11. Denied. Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New Matter. 12. Denied. Denise Kanelos made no such statement. To the contrary, Plaintiff advised her that the total cost of the project would be a "couple" thousand dollars and that he would later supply a more detailed proposal. Plaintiff never provided such a proposal. 13. Denied. Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New Matter. 14. Denied. Matter. 15. Denied. Matter. 16. Denied. Matter. 17. Denied. Matter. Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New II 'I 18. Denied. Matter. 19. Denied. Matter. 20. Denied. Matter. Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New 21. Denied. Defendants have no knowledge as to arrangements Plaintiff made with another party to construct cabinets for him because that information is within the exclusive possession and control of Plaintiff and so Defendants deny the averments in Paragraph 21 and demand proof thereof at trial. 22. Denied. Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New Matter. 23. Denied. At no time did Plaintiff advise Defendants that the cost of any of the work would be $3,000.00 to $4,000.00 in addition to what they had already paid. The averments set out in Defendants' New Matter are incorporated herein. 24. Denied. Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New Matter. 25. Denied. Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New Matter. 26. Denied. Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New Matter. 27. Denied. Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New Matter. 28. Admitted. Defendants incorporate herein by reference the averments set out in their New Matter. 29. Denied. Defendants incorporate herein the averments set out in their New Matter. 30, Denied, Plaintiff's work was incomplete, unworkmanlike, and unsatisfactory. The averments set out in Defendants' New Matter are incorporated herein. 31. Denied. The agreement between the parties was that Plaintiff would construct cabinets in Defendants' dining room. Plaintiff never presented a plan or other data from which Defendants could approve such cabinets, the cabinets were never designed to Defendants' knowledge or satisfaction, and Defendants do not believe there was anything II unique or unusual about the cabinets. The cabinets have never been installed in or delivered to Defendants' home. 32. Defendants admit that Plaintiff has submitted a statement and made such a demand but denies that any further payment to Plaintiff is due for the reasons set forth in their New Matter, the averments of which are incorporated herein by reference. 33, Denied. Plaintiff is the party that breached the oral agreement between the parties for the reasons and in the manner set forth in Defendants' New Matter, the averments of which are incorporated herein. 34, Denied for the reasons set forth in the answer to Paragraph 31 above and for the reasons set forth in Defendants' New Matter, the averments of which are incorporated herein. WHEREFORE. Defendants demand that Plaintiff's Complaint in this matter be dismissed. NEW MATTER In addition to the foregoing averments, Defendants set forth the following New Matter in response to Plaintiff's claim: 35. At all times relevant to this action, Plaintiff held himself out to Defendants as an expert in cabinetry and carpentry. 36. In July of 2003, Plaintiff and Defendants entered into an oral agreement whereby Plaintiff promised to construct and install in Defendants' home at 6 Abbey Lane the following items: A. A new door for the back sunroom; and B. Crown molding in a small bedroom for their daughter; and C. A built in cabinet in the daughter's bedroom measuring approximately six feet high, thirty inches wide and sixteen to twenty inches deep; and D. Install four shelves approximately four feet long in the daughter's bedroom; and E. Install three triangular shelves in the corner of the child's playroom; and II 'I F. Build and install in the dining room cabinets which were to be designed by Plaintiff and approved by Defendants before they were installed. All of this work was to be completed by the end of August 2003 and Defendants made known clearly to Plaintiff the requirement that the work be completed by that date. 37. At the time the parties entered into the oral agreement described in the foregoing paragraph, Plaintiff advised Defendants that the total cost of the work he was to do would be a "couple" grand, Plaintiff also agreed to prepare and submit to Defendants a detailed proposal outlining the work to be done and the cost for such work. In reliance upon these representations by Plaintiff, Defendants authorized Plaintiff to commence the work. 38. Plaintiff did not complete the work as promised in his agreement with Defendants. He did not complete the installation of the crown molding, the built in cabinet and shelves in the daughter's bedroom, the shelves in the play room, or the cabinet in the dining room. 39. Plaintiff did not perform his work in a good and workmanlike fashion, as required by the agreement between the parties. Much of his work was shoddy and incomplete and contained latent defects. 40. Plaintiff did not complete the work he did by the end of August 2003 as required by the agreement between the parties and as promised by Plaintiff. Much of the work he did was not done until October of 2003 and he has still not completed all of the work required by the agreement between the parties. 41. Plaintiff breached the contract between the parties. Specifically: A. He never provided the detailed estimate or proposal to outline and describe the work he was going to do; and B. He never prepared or presented to Defendants the details of the cabinetry he claimed he would install in their dining room; and C. He failed to complete the work under the agreement as he promised; and D. He did not complete what work he did in accordance with the time schedule he promised; and E. The work that Plaintiff did for Defendants was not workmanlike or of good quality and was not in the workmanlike and quality fashion as required by the agreement between the parties or as promised by Plaintiff. II \ 42. Defendants believe that Plaintiff has overcharged them by claiming payment for work which he did not do or materials which he did not use in the work he claims to have done for them, The prices that Plaintiff now seeks to charge Defendants for the work he claims to have done for them are excessive and unreasonable. WHEREFORE, Defendants demand that Plaintiff's Complaint be dismissed and that judgment be entered in their favor in this matter. L. Andes Attorney for Defendants Supreme Court 10 # 17225 525 North 12th Street Lemoyne, Pa 1 7043 (717) 761-5361 " . I verify that the statements made in this document are true and correct. I understand that any false statements in this document are subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C,S. 4904 (unsworn falsification to authorities). D'tefJ7~/tJor tl21':J€. 6~ 4dM DENISE~. KANELOS II CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I served a copy of the foregoing document upon counsel for the Plaintiff by regular mail, postage prepaid, addressed as follows: Joseph D. Buckley, Esquire 1237 Holly Pike Carlisle, Pa 17013 Date: 2 August 2004 A~~S'~ Secretary for Samuel L. Andes ( r-' - " , , ;1 -,-'~ " C.-~ r"..) ~, C.'-, ;;. BRIAN NAILOR, Plaintiff : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA vs. : CIVIL ACTION - LA W DENISE KANELOS and JAMES KANELOS, Defendants : NO. 04-2397 CIVIL TERM REPL Y TO NEW MATTER, AND NOW, this 27th day of August, 2004, comes Plaintiff, by and through his attorney, Joseph D. Buckley, Esquire and replies to Defendaat's New Matter as follows: 35. Adrnitted. 36. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is admitted that Plaintiff and Defendants entered into an agreement for work to be perfomled at Defendants' home; it is denied that the work was to be finished by the end of August, 2003. To the contrary it was that the work would not be able to begin until August, 2003, with completion by December, 2003. By way offurther explanation, Plaintiff not only installed the stated items, but also custom manufactured the items to be installed. 37. Denied. The work was to be completed on a timf' and material basis as had been the custom of prior work performed. By further explanation, Plaintiff stated that he would need a couple of grand prior to beginning the work in order to purchase materials. 38. Denied. Plaintiff completed the work but Defendants refused to pay for the custom work, thus only the custom cabinets were not delivered. 39. Denied. Plaintiffs work was performed in a workmanlike quality. 40. Admitted in part. Plaintiff specifically stated the work could not be performed and completed until December, 2003. 41. These averments are legal conclusions to which no response is necessary. If it is determined that there are factual matters contained therein, specific proof thereof is requested. 42. These averments are legal conclusions to which no response is necessary. If it is determined that there are factual matters contained therein, specific proof thereof is requested. VERIFICATION The undersigned, Brian Nailor, hereby certifies that the statements made in the foregoing Reply to New Matter are true and correct to the best of his knowledge, information and belief. It is understood that statements made herein are subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. Section 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. Date: j - 1..7 - (:)<( 4;~ rian Nailor/" CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing Reply to New Matter was duly served by prepaid first class United States Mail on the following person: Samuel 1. Andes, Esquire 525 North 12th Street Lemoyne, PA 17043 Date: ~. 0l1,U>>r g ; '\~ ""Q .~ rnr'\'\ h'3:"~ zr,_ (j~ ~,.:,.. :i:: ....~,. GO I<:: jE ~ ~ q, ~ ~ \\ -Q ~~ :s; (51'<' t'> ,..' .;;. !Ji -1 BRIAN NAILOR Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. : NO. 04-2397 CIVIL TERM DENISE KANELOS and JAMES KANELOS, Defendants PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS TO THE HONORABLE JUDGES OF SAID COURT: Joseph D. Buckley, Esquire, counsel for the plaintiff in the above action, respectfully represents that: 1. The above-captioned action is at issue. 2. The claim of the plaintiffs in the action is $9,167.04 plus costs of$55.50 and interest. 3. The claim of the defendants in the action is -0-. The following attorney is interested in the case or is otherwise disqualified to sit as arbitrator: Samuel L. Andes, Esquire. WHEREFORE, your petitioner prays your Honorable Court to appoint three (3) arbitrators to whom the case shall be submitted. Date: November 4, 2004 ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, ~~(.,U/ ~ ,2004, in consideration of the foregoing petition, ~ ~ , Esquire, yll.~ ~~, Esquire, . '" .1 /1 and .~ ~ (vft~, Esquire, are appointed arbitrators in the above captiO'ned action as pra~~d for~ BYfue?!~//r PJ. '1;f~\/h:;:\Si\j~~'~d llt'("~'- h, ,.-,-",-,1"\ ^J.. ''i, ;\_ I.} .' ~~: ,"~~-!~l"tJi k) 98 :01 WI 8- nON ~DOZ l\ti'vl()r~Jf{LCdd ~ril :fa 38!~:!'o--Q31~j CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE It is hereby certified that a true and correct copy of the foregoing Petition was served via first class mail, postage prepaid, addressed as follows: Samuel L. Andes, Esquire 525 North Twelfth Street P.O. Box 168 Lemoyne, P A 17043 (Attorney for Defendants) Date: /1'" dY-(),/ At ney for Plain Iff Supreme Court J.D. #38444 1237 Holly Pike Carlisle, P A 17013 (717) 249-2448 tf ~ ~ ~ ...... "- <?\ '- ~ & t ~ ~ J o r: ""tJ ,~;: nJ ~ 7" ~';'.,," r, I ...."'t.,-' (it '1 - '''<:-' I :,"S~ :::J ~ c '\ ~ g; 0 .....- -1'1 ~:n ::.0 r;; ,.;>.10. :-)l :-rJ~/ ('''j ,4 >>(=5 t'jrn j;! ~;n -< ::;e o "<.: I .:;:- -v -,.. --. N .. '-0 BRIAN NAILOR V. : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : CIVIL ACTION - LAW : NO. 04-2397 CIVIL TERM DENISE KANELOS and JAMES KANELOS IN RE: ARBITRATION PANEL ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, February 15, 2005, the Court having been informed that Sharon Clark, Esquire, is unavailable for the above-Gaptioned arbitration hearing, Austin Grogan, Esquire, is appointed in her stead. By the Court, WI Georg E. Hoffl3r, P.J. David Baric, Esquire Chairman of the Arbitration Panel ~.~ d. ./f-O'; c)-, I Court Administrator 1\ " r'.:" ,',)j " '";:'";J LL ~ .I3~/~NN~/L~R Plaintiff In The Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania No.Dt/ - ;}37(j Dr,:cIvI~L::' ki<JNb-UIS .J/fm/!I?c, k/QNb"LfJS Defendant Civil Action - Law. Oath We do solemnly swear (or affirm) that we will support, obey and defend the Constitution of the United ~~~~~n~ion of this Commonwealth and that we will discharge the duties of our o~ce 'r2i-'~. (d~ (LL J~ ' (! . Signature fl Signature ( /)Nl/,.c! ;J [)4tf/~ .4"~17,J f &lkJeM .&tLIl\:tJ C:-. Name (Chairman) Name Name f)' L? I (' ~,"I:/ D IS' <:;tf. tJFF Ft-DwGZ O'D/(/f:,N; D/lR f~' {ULf./&-t-t;.R L0-/r.!C t, CoiNr: f- ('. k L-IA.J/)~IIY , Law Firm Law Finn Law Firm ILl iN Su./# 57, !,Ci/.)I MMI<CiJ 5: r '2(9 W. {-f--rr;;{1.- ST-. Address Address Address CoP.L.I~U;'1 /70/3 ~p N.dl vA 170 /( C//-;t-l--(5l-G. fit-liDO City, Zip City, Zip City, Zip Award We, the lL.'1dersigned arbitrators, having been duly appointed and sworn (or affirmed), make the following award: (Note: If damages for delay are awarded, they shall be separately stated.) t::c;-;:? Pi- At N-f i r:-t: !1Dt>iTl,J/'J 7?J 7NG - (N Tf,fG,' /, J1I7), lit) I . So,... C.D~TS /tJ 0/ 6'A/ bXlNT<;; . Date of Hearing: (} / I <::; I c5::;- Date of Award: ,;:)/;'5'10<:;7 I l (Chairman) Notice of Entry of Award Now,the J~dayof ~L."t.<.)~20t1o\ ,at /;;;:6(. , J:> .M., the above award was entered upon the docket and notice thereof give by mail to the parties or their attorneys. Arbitrators' compensation to be paid upon appeal: $ .;('90.0(1 (3"~,,".,,oo"ry By Deputy Co /",)'/ ---/0 C. IJ , Co f)l U rrl'a.:L'l..<. L -/0 Ii ,f ~.H'1 J. ~i::J,,-y .ve:..wISC. c:L Jd .......r.; /6,.:,e..L'a.S ~._.. '., ,\ ---', -r,\ ..~.. r;-::'- C,' II I I' BRIAN NAILOR, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF DAUPHIN COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiff vs. CIVIL ACTION - LAW II II Ii II Ii II I I I II II I' I' II Ii II II Ii I 'I I DENISE KANELAS and JAMES KANELAS, NO. 04.2397 CIVIL TERM Defendants PRAECIPE TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Please satisfy the award of the arbitrators in this matter and then mark this case "settled and discontinued." I I, Ii " il I II I: I , , ! II C) ro_ , c.,-~ "-' <::~:) ~;;'~ ~ C) -q -<