Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout10-1500IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS (MMVv.C\n&a COUNTY COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA M AXPI DIVISION Case No.: \ VS. 02?t. t'? CoCC`3?a o? Q?•i Jt MI1?.cit.,?0a? ? C.DcfeL??ra? a?'?1 ? cP_C ? Sup?C . ?o?n Qo,\oltay ?C?n, Supe.e.r?ende?+?s IN FORMA PAUPERIS VERIFIED STATEMENT (? N 1 a M rrM r r v ??n;,p nQp\ a, n states under the penalties provided by 18 Pa C.S.A. § 4904 (unsworn falsification to authorities) that: 1. I am the Z\r j, a? in the above action and because of my financial condition am unable to pay the following fees and costs: PAP 2. My responses to the questions below relating to my ability to pay the required fees and costs are true and correct. (a) Are you presently employed? Yes No (1) If the answer is yes, state the amount of your salary or wages per month and give the name and address of your employer _eNZ:S - VN ? vw--? , jg' ?t ,max (2) If the answer is no, state the date of your last employment and the amount of the salary and wages per month which you received (b) Have you received within the past 12 months any income from a business, profession or other form of self-employment, or in the form of rent payments, interest, dividends, pensions, ann ' 'es, social security benefits, support payments or other source? Yes No If the answer is yes, describe each source of income, and state the.amount,received from each during the past 12 months. (c) Do you own any cash or checking or savings accounts? Yes No If the answer is yes, state the total amount of the items owned. (d) List the persons, if any, who are dependent upon you for support and state your relationship to those persons. ?Q\Qa,\r (e) List all your debts and obligations. M - D&-V QX ? 3. I understand that a false statement or answer to any question in this verified statement will subject me to the penalties provided by 18 Pa. C.S.A. §4904 (relating to unsworn falsification to authorities). Respectfully submitted, Dated V ? ?- name)Jk le.S 11?c= ?czdirla (Inmate No.)_)% State Correctional Institution at Forest P.O. Boa 945 Marienville, PA 16239 PA DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS INMATE ACCOUNTS SYSTEM RUN IAS365 BUREAU OF COMPUTER SERVICES PARTIAL ACCOUNT LISTING DATE 2/02/2010 REMOTE PRINT TIME 10:33 FROM PURGE FILE PAGE 1 INMATE NAME NUMBER LAST FIRST MI STARTING BALANCE HS0937 PALAD INO CHARLES 5.39 BATCH DATE TRANSACTION BALANCE AFTER # MO DY YEAR TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION AMOUNT TRANSACTION 2460 01-08-2009 41 MEDICAL 01/06/2009 -10.00 -4.61 9020 01-20-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT - CFRS Payroll 2008-12 Grp 3' 14.40 9.79 8021 01-21-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 1/21/2009 -2.45 7.34 2613 01-23-2009 13 PERSONAL GIFT FROM MRS. C J876270 25.00 32.34 2613 01-23-2009 50 ACT 84 TRANSACTION 0800542-2006 01/23/09 -5.00 27.34 2613 01-23-2009 60 VCF DEDUCTION 800542-06 01/23/09 -2.50 24.84 8028 01-28-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 1/28/2009 -7.17 17.67 8035 02-04-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 2/04/2009 -.18 17.49 8042 02-11-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 2/11/2009 -7.19 10.30 8049 02-18-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 2/18/2009 -.18 10.12 9049 02-18-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-01 Grp 3' 15.84 25.96 9049 02-18-2009 50 ACT 84 TRANSACTION 0800542-2006 02/18/09 -3.17 22.79 9049 02-18-2009 60 VCF DEDUCTION * 800542-06 02/18/09 -1.58 21.21 2890 02-23-2009 38 INSIDE PURCHASES 2 PHOTOS -4.00 17.21 8056 02-25-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 2/25/2009 -4.71 12.50 2946 02-27-2009 45 MISCELLANEOUS CLARK COLOR LAB -1.50 11.00 8063 03-04-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 3/04/2009 -10.56 .44 8065 03-06-2009 86 FRS COMMISSARY CR 32 FOR 3/06/2009 .67 1.11 8070 03-11-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 3/11/2009 -1.08 .03 3100 03-13-2009 37 POSTAGE -1.51 -1.48 9077 03-18-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-02 Grp 3' 13.68 12.20 9077 03-18-2009 50 ACT 84 TRANSACTION * 0800542-2006 03/18/09 -2.74 9.46 PA DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS INMATE ACCOUNTS SYSTEM RUN IAS365 BUREAU OF COMPUTER SERVICES PARTIAL ACCOUNT LISTING DATE 2/02/2010 REMOTE PRINT TIME 10:33 FROM PURGE FILE PAGE 2 INMATE NAME NUMBER LAST FIRST MI HS0937 PALADINO CHARLES BATCH DATE TRANSACTION BALANCE AFTER # MO DY YEAR TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION AMOUNT TRANSACTION 8084 03-25-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 3/25/2009 -7.59 1.87 BALANCE AFTER THESE TRANSACTIONS ------ > 1.87 PA DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS INMATE ACCOUNTS SYSTEM BUREAU OF COMPUTER SERVICES PARTIAL ACCOUNT LISTING REMOTE PRINT TIME 10:33 FROM PURGE FILE INMATE NAME NUMBER LAST FIRST MI HS0937 PALAD INO CHARLES BATCH DATE # MO DY YEAR TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION 8098 04-08-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 4/08/2009 9107 04-17-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-03 Grp 3' 9107 04-17-2009 50 ACT 84 TRANSACTION 0800542-2006 04/17/09 9107 04-17-2009 60 VCF DEDUCTION 800542-06 04/17/09 8119 04-29-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 4/29/2009 9139 05-19-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-04 Grp 3' 9139 05-19-2009 50 ACT 84 TRANSACTION 0800542-2006 05/19/09 8140 05-20-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 5/20/2009 8148 05-28-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 5/28/2009 9155 06-04-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-05 Grp 1' 9155 06-04-2009 50 ACT 84 TRANSACTION 0800542-2006 06/04/09 9155 06-04-2009 60 VCF DEDUCTION 800542-06 06/04/09 8161 06-10-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 6/10/2009 9169 06-18-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-05 Grp 3' 4039 06-19-2009 37 POSTAGE RUN IAS365 DATE 2/02/2010 PAGE 1 STARTING BALANCE 1.87 TRANSACTION BALANCE AFTER AMOUNT TRANSACTION -.18 12.96 -2.59 -1.30 -8.16 8.64 -1.73 -8.49 -.18 12.35 -2.47 -1.24 -3.88 1.44 -1.56 1.69 14.65 12.06 10.76 2.60 11.24 9.51 1.02 .84 13.19 10.72 9.48 5.60 7.04 5.48 5.48 BALANCE AFTER THESE TRANSACTIONS ------ > PA DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS INMATE ACCOUNTS SYSTEM RUN IAS365 BUREAU OF COMPUTER SERV ICES PARTIAL ACCOUNT LISTING DATE 2/02/2010 REMOTE PRINT TIME 10:33 FROM PURGE FILE PAGE 1 INMATE NAME NUMBER LAST FIRST MI STARTING BALANCE HS0937 PALAD INO CHARLES 5.48 BATCH DATE TRANSACTION BALANCE AFTER ## MO DY YEAR TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION AMOUNT TRANSACTION 8182 07-01-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 7/01/2009 -5.26 .22 8187 07-06-2009 86 FRS COMMISSARY CR 32 FOR 7/06/2009 1.04 1.26 8189 07-08-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 7/08/2009 -1.11 .15 9189 07-08-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-06 Grp 1' 21.00 21.15 9189 07-08-2009 50 ACT 84 TRANSACTION 0800542-2006 07/08/09 -4.20 16.95 9189 07-08-2009 60 VCF DEDUCTION 800542-06 07/08/09 -2.10 14.85 8203 07-22-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 7/22/2009 -11.39 3.46 4329 07-22-2009 37 POSTAGE -.44 3.02 8217 08-05-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 8/05/2009 -2.28 .74 9218 08-06-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-07 Grp 1' 25.13 25.87 9218 08-06-2009 50 ACT 84 TRANSACTION * 0800542-2006 08/06/09 -5.03 20.84 9218 08-06-2009 60 VCF DEDUCTION 800542-06 08/06/09 -2.51 18.33 8224 08-12-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 8/12/2009 -17.96 .37 9251 09-08-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-08 Grp 1' 27.30 27.67 9251 09-08-2009 50 ACT 84 TRANSACTION 0800542-2006 09/08/09 -5.46 22.21 9251 09-08-2009 60 VCF DEDUCTION 800542-06 09/08/09 -1.65 20.56 8252 09-09-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 9/09/2009 -15.96 4.60 4970 09-25-2009 37 POSTAGE -1.56 3.04 8273 09-30-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 9/30/2009 -.18 2.86 BALANCE AFTER THESE TRANSACTIONS ------ > 2.86 PA DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS INMATE ACCOUNTS SYSTEM RUN IAS365 BUREAU OF COMPUTER SERV ICES PARTIAL ACCOUNT LISTING DATE 2/02/2010 REMOTE PRINT TIME 10:33 FROM ACTIVE FILE PAGE 1 INMATE NAME NUMBER LAST FIRST MI STARTING BALANCE HS0937 PALAD INO CHARLES 2.86 BATCH DATE TRANSACTI ON BALANCE AFTER # MO DY YEAR TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION AMOUNT TRANSACTION 9279 10-06-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-09 Grp 1' 35.20 38.06 9279 10-06-2009 50 ACT 84 TRANSACTION 0800542-2006 10/06/09 -7.04 31.02 8280 10-07-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 10/07/2009 -4.20 26.82 8287 10-14-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 10/14/2009 -22.10 4.72 8292 10-19-2009 86 FRS COMMISSARY CR 32 FOR 10/19/2009 1.20 5.92 5270 10-26-2009 37 POSTAGE -1.39 4.53 8301 10-28-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 10/28/2009 -4.11 .42 8308 11-04-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 11/04/2009 -.18 .24 9309 11-05-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-10 Grp 1' 5.75 5.99 9309 11-05-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-10 Grp 1' 16.12 22.11 9309 11-05-2009 50 ACT 84 TRANSACTION 0800542-2006 11/05/09 -3.22 18.89 5415 11-09-2009 37 POSTAGE -.17 18.72 5415 11-09-2009 37 POSTAGE -.44 18.28 8314 11-10-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 11/10/2009 -7.02 11.26 9321 11-17-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-10 Grp 3' 1.50 12.76 9321 11-17-2009 50 ACT 84 TRANSACTION * 0800542-2006 11/17/09 -.30 12.46 5562 11-23-2009 37 POSTAGE -.95 11.51 8336 12-02-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 12/02/2009 -4.28 7.23 9344 12-10-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-11 Grp 2' 7.98 15.21 9344 12-10-2009 50 ACT 84 TRANSACTION * 0800542-2006 12/10/09 -1.60 13.61 9348 12-14-2009 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-11 Grp 3' 7.25 20.86 9348 12-14-2009 50 ACT 84 TRANSACTION * 0800542-2006 12/14/09 -1.45 19.41 PA DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS INMATE ACCOUNTS SYSTEM BUREAU OF COMPUTER SERVICES PARTIAL ACCOUNT LISTING REMOTE PRINT TIME 10:33 FROM ACTIVE FILE INMATE NAME NUMBER LAST FIRST MI HS0937 PALADINO CHARLES BATCH DATE # MO DY YEAR TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION 8350 12-16-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 12/16/2009 5812 12-17-2009 37 POSTAGE 8364 12-30-2009 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 12/30/2009 9013 01-13-2010 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-12 Grp 2' 9013 01-13-2010 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-12 Grp 2' 9013 01-13-2010 50 ACT 84 TRANSACTION 0800542-2006 01/13/10 8013 01-13-2010 32 FRS COMMISSARY FOR 1/13/2010 9014 01-14-2010 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2010-01 Grp 2' 9021 01-21-2010 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-12 Grp 3' 9021 01-21-2010 10 INMATE EMPLOYMENT CFRS Payroll 2009-12 Grp 3' 6187 01-27-2010 37 POSTAGE 6187 01-27-2010 37 POSTAGE 6187 01-27-2010 37 POSTAGE RUN IAS365 DATE 2/02/2010 PAGE 2 TRANSACTION BALANCE AFTER AMOUNT TRANSACTION -17.16 -.95 -.47 6.84 13.68 -2.74 -14.67 .75 .50 2.50 -.17 -1.39 -1.39 2.25 1.30 .83 7.67 21.35 18.61 3.94 4.69 5.19 7.69 7.52 6.13 4.74 4.74 BALANCE AFTER THESE TRANSACTIONS ------ > z? ?e Coilr o? Cbc(\mw\ Q\t .S Fnr ?r\e. Cn???eat??,. n? Perms \.aa??a ?i `3GT.Mac.??.1oa?, oe.?k: o? cocce???enS ??? Q2??c'k??t? For : _ SCZ Asais C"Maklrr. 59 B. SUP"C. ?as1\? l?.iaQ?oC `CoC \trc? ° -n i C?ne9 NDc.1'Che C?;i Chu?sLeS Qa. ono ?' ox- e&cceA,A-L. a\t e? -chi ?•. ArwePa'A cA:cr- t ce9s o? `Nti L\ wAa.v?xc Z9, SCZ: F?ces?,?bx qr?, Cos) tA& \e:av`%kkt. ,Pit klAsok . a.•• 1wiez dtz' . -vt. Vac wAa\k aA. %CAecy, WA h1e??o?eret.?e?c TMe. Skw\e-. tbm«u pn"k mx-8 F.moav-p- Secc?et??c C41dCS,s A`r? b vt???aC 7"pckc-% vt.-- w\.cc" xA Wkx\e tkAmul w6NN:.a 'iMe_ 4kZA?p-' a, WAS E a?,nncrk &A mm 'line o???cge. c? w"'b tJovemh?r 18toh, abbe ) Nk SCE c arnP??\\ Qc 3. d? No??rn'b?rt?ti,? ? a? caxc<r?a?\ NI A4P y ?.? eoecet?.o<w, o?:?.c s?co?e?? ?hliC?ci.n 1N'1oc_a?,o:.n Farc.?u\\y ??eve?'11n? C\oa?? Z.a. `inc. ?0?1?..?Fco? C???:.?. ?'Me_ C\ete?c?wc?? T? 'Cr•.e nv a. euC (.+?? S?r,F=h S\e{z c ;Me. "Co FoJ?\ oc? 1??? Le?? V1c`?g? oh? Le'.?? Kxe?.. . qq OA tldu?rn\?ez ??. a.n48 1?.\ ?,CY-.e bonptiiU?,v?ri9 auk-s.?e?ouri ?x.e?no? 1,y ?1(w a .?-vne, exoaera?c wr `tO.Ca Q`£t.(e.iD. %.ftA r?,'ta ?e_ Se?n?c ?Ski?lae_ za ??, -co Mea.?.d\ dot \?e??a? ?`.? Seuece_?Lt?k?S.cte loom f \gt;vxL Cxci "k 'W&)k \le. \Nor, -ca hiAn S nx\k `Cc? f??? 'She_ Ge t ob?c n lll?3 ?.. ` to % O"ml a?Cvc?cvs el? to M'vna?es \.LC -vte_ \a:.rnct?? 'p. t ?c e? ?ag?c • MaC?u .r D?a;. est?a?Tn lb"-. Mex\La-k ?? ?lb?rnwA? Wad To\? 1c, 1. "Me ugamftA w1n%N-%x 'Ce A N??r.a ?aC `(ham x?,C ic?ne_ d ,n ?C,:.? t?.?pcae es? u yk. Mnc uNao n) lac U ?,.10? Seh?t t'aacY. S? c??. D tett?cce?,. ??b Q?'e'S?•'^°?`C? Q? ? ,n? Xxe& QaA VSaga.t1? ?? o?:?e?cs tit `MQ: ?. ?dC 'Chi NttiC\ Five 'S ?com hlovernbe?c' 1l? ? n°?l ? ?. Mr?;r?wri.n R?r.??ta.Te Ltd 'M? C\oa?n?n? euV??? for Q,?C? •o? buC??nc?"(1?.? tc xa 66W%44 Xb• ar Nevtrnbt( k%)&oo',?Zhe. ?.\00..nnt ?c AAt&WNrtX lb (ao CIA ??ae %,.i W? &Ao?-tA "Al 95y Sgt. tvlr„r ?i?.sn:?n . ?Ch? Clc'.Me_?? ASV,t? ?Me. ray?? N?t.?...?o:?ri,Wby 1?.t?? ?nn? Mt.DU? . '1C `Zdu Lc? S9? • r?oxn s?o.?.,` ?tcnu?e., `tDa ca,.i©e.?, ?n Znt?nvcri?erc?.`C?.? aver ?' UOL- u"A tAft a `Ce st ?. vk"ultat\ y Ou ?6.1 ca Ac to V?wk Caere;\c?t r A? Zntrw?PS Mesta Nt,&:, tbs. -TALC Nu a x?i?an ? \9.. Nk the vcc-4 MntmQLn\- tea. c\nl?? a0Y.t=?? v?Secc?;s?l?.-CVCr V?.ccuAk ata .a?n? -rb wNK. °,• d ti 3ar.4We o, rhds?,?wc):.A ?'atc?o\\y S?nove?'M? k\oaMeir? "inn i??g X31. ?° V?e. En?tflsl"On? F.n?rdc e?.? (a.?lgulq'Z1R? t-\Q&ytx A\ ' & lul,e buts o-Faur Zrd? To ?a\\ M W?s LtSk KWM-E- o t& U CIAIN - \3. °Me. E.b;srnon? t, \tW.y C?e? ?,p a,? \?bb\e? asp `G.ut, V\i44s nsc 3 CK&Ob 1^ o,- beta CA Qe ir? AAc? Ike txr "Nw OvP. °?a . Mcs?at?03.? WpS 6 \(\C? \,m M?f? "Cho.c 4\ou q- W\W\ . 14. ?r.t c\ci,?crw.c?? t3,..i?Lv? W? To ?\iS C?\\ t?1b?. Q?-?a\l C?\dserl -C?r.c. ooec ta?n? t.a:•a eta 'Cd C.b1d F\tscsr `Ct, S?? ?,? g, 40ve t?e?S is g ?c. M&tLxMy. t\ tj l VVX4 Coc(-_ To VA CA'\ V nLLT C i\L` .-\, tS . IlL Evt?n\,ru??rleve?d+?.C \Ia,a bca) ' C „ ? Sobev:.??e?? Sack eb1.\ mac, mo.CY•? Was A°A. \-ktA) WA guts ?vcA- -1 c 0(?eA `<D \Z\g L.e.?kV AtAL ?ki.%Cv Wrvda\T -wa-,vo\\d.. w%%10 4 `ctie. tw"o.,&A ua&& Mt&to&) --L- e dytl w?Lct_ -%owtA tAtAlu t QomCC Skm**A -vWk "Wvc%a? wds \AcEvtt Vwm %61.).V409?1 \..oeV,e,a Lsp t^a betYO-c wtC Na `Me. -iog A 7 ?y ebiVkNe\ Q.epoCk -T* A- ?ac S\c.c? "-k =AxNi a\v eA e.kr% T?.e\eye?. M?.\e?? °?o?? \??? oc??.? 6 ?ueh ??. e.\a.?? Iroc Men, %im ? or tSe?tern\??C 13,30p??ih? eldrnnA S?bnri.e?. ct 1Lert?e ?r\EVc.?A `lam t? QLle:?it?0?'Mt. 1?.°?`? .?V? Qi? ?a9?. \v?n,C???oad1 • JOWL t'l. A {D7CGMb?tt1?y?S? F1V? pp g Lo`??C p.k4LC t4wle rnbEC \3,?AD6 ?11n? `L\a.Ma.,ti? te.u?wea r%Xt- A WiS Lt-\%apmt-e- "(,b SC.' ?p.+MPh.\\ NhcmucL m NNv? QC \. pwv V ?f5?c Wkkib MLt.\jWL \kae , ut V ti-wim\itd MA&r ZAVQgac.?„t?bv1 n•1 ?tdf?t?.cy 1??o9.,?t\. -lB. z'ae C?.?maA'C slow cxi??sr'? Fcbcn Cfi??a To 3evtc?. CMcoc??t_Q,?? rangy V.M.Q. Qe:.% aA 'i?n_c3 p?inCul TcouW? i.?k.? ta?`t a\??rs?s ?1?? 'M? LoeY:?ng uQ off. N?5 @bs1?. ?c1. ?,? a??.ors m? eeccei?ano\ o??;??r, sexye,i?? t?.e a,,,tion ? vlcce_ In?e.???ona,\ (Lb . k46 a. Q fta"I ac cx ThtiS mheLA ? uf, tew\-k Save a o? Ski\\ C- ?? t !N vt r-,m 1l?re? acv3 Q?ns? Qc:.n cum WA.e, Otr?crl QcoPec ?ceo,?Mt?c. a.\. "'Cht. Ck,.imnt?lr'iS 1??t?1nc:5V. NeoS? Q4?c?ex??c W??n a_ 'C1?.re1 O C4??.?.C?.Q,?„oE. e. an??QoC.e. Mch?,c Z4\A.Wo.S aA ?•OOIa. -,Z? \ cater n? ?a.?c lie. etx?\a ?1avt. ?e?? Mnc? S?vese\y S?c???ce.?s nC Qo\y u,\\.e?. ?' ... The C.\4? ?c WaS 9 ubJtAtx \X,I,d,L\iQ)1ea, ?l a?1e??i? Nne?,\?? , 'S.no.r?etoMc?l?en1, eue_ ?.3. ?? eos\:?\nreg A u&m,,.,N)e& Oaenoq?g Ace. ? ?o\\?.??a'. Me lu?.a\E?e?; '' : Pl cJaannc,,?1? Laos su\???t?C? -to ee,,? ?n? Meac,n\ c.a5?`s aC s3e.V.- et?\\ v `si?'S ???o?? anid. Mt?iCty?o? Fac TkeS? Y.h ut ?e:S . J ?l Goa?k Ma,E ? ?u?? Le,? }c?rrn t?e??, ? ?Mc 5? S.,c: oc?e9 fine M? ?. d ??gh QcoboJetl??y ? ?? Ulza ,&A- Mai tkeea\\ ` eaP ? zQ `. ,?e?:wJag?c cof?? PvrC?Cws? dncl MoJ.?n'te?srp a? M?.t,?, oc ?ne,,?a,?,ev?.e. ??prnex?? Sack o3 ?c,,ekQiC?S? W1nee1? l.?+ar I W?.r?le_ C.Mo;?r 115?\.?c? ? eoa? Me.?.Cta??a?n? ?.?? Q??\? ? ? tl T.?niea,.ce?.Ce???cnh c?i?rnr,,n?C ???h9 h.,n\iea?sci??.a. Q?t?uch??e?'Cb 'C?cc?c Qeo??O?or? v? ?ls Tb e? N.? u?c?able. Td mni\\y z c obj eA VS cL NAt:, Mlut*v?kc c\o,?t bel-uots , Do b ..'r ) T,Ot, Ao,\A&c A tw,& v 'Ay oo.?arjes Fac \o? Po?ter?w?'Eu?ace_ ?.cr??cj:?. 0 4 QCAV.' If lo?. ?l e\au?an? Su ecS KVL -co se rte dies 431t.. Uot t!n\ az?? Z ernes firms. ?..dGtu?? u Q o? ?,S Q:.??n?-S:ae_ `a,.,?e.C Q?a.?lt. c?an?. R?Sn tw:\? w?.? eo.?,,n e??:r?s???re? . t??en??o???? l?t?qu???o?.E1 ?i?a.o?.? o? stn Expe_r ?e?n? p a ?.ds? ? S\ ?Cen?.?o? -?,\ ? tht 15. -w+e, FMt vit%4,t, ar Mn Ret :%(*A Q]\? LL11.a? « lko . CAN one ?1?\?Fd'?, C\4rnc?o?n?c p?pee?c??\\ es1?, -S? erne?? p. oa?ns? one. b??tecc ? 'Ma??Swn? O?\\o« ? a.?D, ata . ors l ,o C 1airnn.A? , ?t fo ?,e . DdC V5? , \A!?:, boaq Sc'Z'Fare?lc, %x qyS 6 . C\t? cn^ IA-7 Ito c? ? Ph4 E*x1h o? c?. - cumeQ\ cf,?O? QAe OCit3?? `ClnceE'_ C??PS `fD : O??d o, ??e\\ 'Prd?r?no?n??4ry Ca?mb?C?ant? ?un?? CnrC?gll. ? t0.. t'?13 6ne k? a a? 9 CHARLES T. PALADINO, Plaintiff VS. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 10-1500 CIVIL DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, STATE: OF PA, SGT MACDWAIN, CORRECTIONAL OFFICER, SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, SUPERINTENDENT, Defendants ORDER AND NOW, this 9' day of March, 2010, the plaintiff is granted leave to proceed in forma pauperis with respect to filing and service fees. BY THE COURT, Kevin Hess, P. J. vU'harles T. Paladino, HS0937 SCI - Forest P. O. Box 945 Marienville, PA 6239 hn Palakovich, Superintendent Dept. of Corrections P. O. Box 598 Camp Hill, PA 17001-0598 :rlm 4 ,oa n C 5n iJ!t IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA Charles Paladino, Petitioner V. State of Pennsylvania, Department of Corrections, Respondent PER CURIAM O R D E R 0 d ? rn ?3 ?t No. 628 M.D. 2009 NOW, December 8, 2009, upon consideration of this matter, which sounds in the nature of a tort action and seeks money damages for injuries incurred at SCI Camp Hill in Cumberland County, in which venue may lie, this case is hereby transferred to the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County. See 42 Pa. C.S. §5103. The Chief Clerk shall certify a photocopy of the docket entries of the above matter and the record to the prothonotary of the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County. C40W from the Record DEC 0 9 2009 and Order Exit A .21 A.M. Miscellaneous Docket Sheet fiocket Number: 628 MD 2009 Page 1 of 2 December 30, 2009 Charles Paladino, Petitioner V. State of Pennsylvania, Department of Corrections, Respondent Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania CAPTION Certified from the Record CASE INFORMATION 3 2009 Initiating Document: Petition for Review and Order adt Case Status: Closed Case Processing Status: December 8, 2009 Journal Number: Case Category: Miscellaneous CONSOLIDATED CASES RELATED CASES COUNSEL INFORMATION - Petitioner Palladino, Charles = Pro Se: Yes IFP Status: Pro Se: Paladino, Charles Address: HS-0937, SCI-Forest ?`- ? .? Housing Unit F/A 1025 y P.O. Box 945 N Marienville, PA 16239 Phone No: Fax No: AGENCYITRIAL COURT INFORMATION Court Below: Department of Corrections County: Division: Department of Corrections Order Appealed From: Judicial District: Documents Received: November 30, 2009 Notice of Appeal Filed: Order Type: OTN(s): Lower Ct Docket No(s):HS-0937 Lower Ct Judge(s): ORIGINAL RECORD CONTENT Original Record Item Filed Date Content Description Date of Remand of Record: BRIEFING SCHEDULE Completed Case Type(s): Inmate Petition for Review Neither the Appellate Courts nor th* Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts assumes any liability for ina:curate or delayed data, errors or ornissions on the docket sheets. 11:27 A.M. Miscellaneous Docket Sheet docket Number: 628 MD 2009 Page 2 of 2 December 30, 2009 Transfer to Court of Common Pleas Commonwealth Court Filing Office Cumberland County. None DOCKET ENTRY Filed Date Docket Entry / Filer Representing Participant Type Exit Date November 24, 2009 Petition for Review Filed Paladino, Charles Petitioner December 8, 2009 Transfer 12/09/2009 Per Curiam Document Name: Upon consideration of this matter, which sounds in the nature of a tort action and seeks money Comment: damages for injuries incurred at SCI Camp Hill, in which venue may lie, this case is transferred to the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County. December 30, 2009 Document Name Final Disposition: Related Journal No: Category: Disposition: Yes None DISPOSITION INFORMATION Judgment Date: Disposed Before Decision Disposition Author: Transfer Disposition Date: Per Curiam December 8, 2009 Disposition Comment: damages for injuries incurred at SCI Camp Hill, in which venue may lie, this case is transferred to the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County. Dispositional Filing: Filing Author: Filed Date: Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania Neither the Appellate Courts nor the Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts assumes any liability for inaccurate or delayed data, errors or omissions on the docket sheets. 'Z(\ IN& Coilv\- C c(\mb \ ,A D,a For ?C?\C Co?c\?\r?c\?eQ\??. c? Pe ?\n?,,??va??a ?cat? a? pexc\??yvoari.ci, VA4\w\ Fdr : .x ? - ? ? 1 Cnmt3 t?? 'Mt C.?nno t?r? Gnus \eS Qa ?AO? P?pen r ??a, 2c o C-ow \6.kv6 c4 a4? " v J \. 'Mq.-, ?a A nkt:er- NA&e.,hs t9 C.N? e\o.\rndr? ISM SCZ Fbces?,?ox ?. c1yS? [fir env.\? IPk U6A3c1. I. lw%rm C?a.?n ZS qbc whe?aa\k W4- quAeCy I OA lie gio?@ne?.?c?c "'CM,- S?CO,?? Cam«v, es? IZa4 5.?8 'Ernp??ee. S?Ct?et\?c C?iil?iA /rr?ilbvt\?FaC '$??,?lf ?An?'C\ve_ C.\aarewt?? W?n?l? A `L?t\t? b.1i???n 'flnc l??g 'E lo??nnCt\ac era zip 'Me O??C?nC9? ??°? .Z\) \%-b ot\ Nov2rc?ber 18??, 8?$, P.k gC`I: C.arAQ?.\? Qc ??eri. 3. o\ t\la+?credotr la??y y Wt t pcox??.n.???.? N I NJP-.w. C?? f eC ?otwJ, o ?e?.C am qu*Ak - thw-b:\h I?.n ?occ.?u\ty S?nave?'?r?? k- .txm A Zacwte. Ttxe- C\o;\moikN 'Cn 'Cr \t o\vL---x o- (a.Naoo)? %u( CAN Zht-\\ skeo C VI%t \TC? iMe cxo:,-m&A Tv Fa\\ th^ wkA, t.e;k We \.g\- CLV\k Ltjtk V.er. +-1. 0A Nwexn\at-' b%N,,Ahb& v Apt tkWti ZrnA* N do., tLm,'Mt. C\oaa\ax? 0.? SCZ ?.b.?Mp??l\?l?P,? dui-??a,? C?OC ?? ?'Zp.C ? ?2C.C?0.1t\?A W?l?n 4a? ?pccMc???. Nlnc?o?\c\ ? iie W%0,1a 0e- Sex\?c ?S>!. ??1c1? to ?b '[d Me.a\?1? hoc ??..?oa \?oa.?\<\9 ?ea?ec?tL\ s . Le?,e.c t?,.?rl?ax\?Qa?+ng,???.ca?.\e..\??ocyl, S. Se??. MaCc??,?;u? a?r?\y 'Co.\a 'C\.? Cao?,?m?+n?r. ""fnp,?c V?? \?aa, •ca W?..? "?tiv??cy ia. Alf W?wf t?l Ua M\hu , \-ALC Nbp ,tm---w.e? Sa?? • tAbtXui&& ,.. 0.r ies .?Te Se ewa? 1? XAtIACL\ ,Inc e\o?\rnnt\? wn? ZD\L'ro, Wci\?c 'tom MaC?M\n?? . u&WNNA \AC\A s -K%A NC\r., FoC `M? S?1?c?.T?M? c.? A ar A?pc?clne,3 os?. W\&rAuh&:w\) wos s A ea?cx Z,r?S\a? 0 E.Vn?S ?ommn u? 'Me ??i?\?.? ?ChE C\cy:?rno x?? ABC C 'M? o ?Clz.C9 Q?k `MQ !At\?cco?ra.. Qle?\?. R?.?eg?w\y?o Qle Sc?\?'co Me.b,.e? ?k Wo.°s'CD\?hi? ??bee???c ?°?ieV? t.nl,\ • ?. Fbr -Ma,- NerCk Five cams Feorn *jovcrc\bec aj&bE3, Sys. Ma??,?c:.n R ugg"Vo kAQ C -%s-- Ck& i.Ma t ba !S-% hoc ?,&Lt t t w , 40"Ae ,Ch'?.? 1v X 2. 5h\4 . Xb. aA tu\lt-M)M t \'?,a DAB `che C.\o:..r.ax`?c A cs ?c.? "CD ?o a,1k %A Wr,? mac, e*A "N ?y Sgt. MnC.Ltilciit? . Zh?t ca,,o.?.? rsV.? `M!. ra9?• t?_?v?Aa+n ? Why ?cev?>c `??s ?.?tvnn? Me.. ??? ?g?C , t+1 o:..t\ s?d?e?; ?euu?e. `tua L &uNekt I can Z.,c tenvImkt \e.p- 4V\* -C V'" ; \\. °MV-I LU6.,AWA SXo." -Ce `:..IJ ?\1LS.l?bJC?.\A Ob `20.3 ?n\r? 't\n? Couek3 \1??\\ l'tae\4??al.C An 7?.anrr\a\4S Me?c.a1 Nl?S A? 'S.[\c.r?u ex?i?C? Nlomer?t -Mt C\a\max?? 'J(xs?f.L`MoS? Wec??\?tt. -t.1c r VcouAa. d?I \'d.. Ak Z1ne -J+-C'4 \t?iQtlt't To We\Vt, ? ?ol`? Zv?+??l?e ? °?\. MtaC???.?al\ F'ncC.?u\\y ra?noVea.?M? t\ca.MC,.r?'i.+n \??3 ?? V& Mt- rt-r tst2L"One_ E,n V&AeLe.I !a\??\?\y"CMe \o:?rne?c\?'fa -T \e eve n??aur T.rd? 3en?1P i? '6 VA\ On \k,& LC?k wne-- CL, Wc\4hX . \'?. "C1ne C.\ea rno?l\?c Ow?c?y Go?c uQ o ?b?a\e? u? `cu?c? ?\ie??n\S ?r °,.??oac? %.^ n- bca1\e. bed\ CA Qo irc\ o t &vens Tvt& l?t_°?a?c. McaCat?:??? WWg 6 \c\c? 'Co Mdce.?Cho.a ?r?lr\ove_ \\iM. \y. -,%,e Q\&xo ex& oatx\y \AtA-u% tae. S- %a.\) t\otw-.- & o?c No-I \a:,& bN 'Ce Cd?d F\oor Ze SoAN'. AA%6 Qa;????FenS?c\O? g c. T? u?at\ ltk&y Cbeu.-- -ems W%en, ua'lALSAC\:er Moce. 7?c:eA kS . Tft& ?vt?\\?ng\NeVerne c \,fh jAwf& I NC\ - txa+ %V.MA CL- U A\ S .c\n? \?t \n1orS A?Ao??\?ecl?a??c\a Ree.e\uc-L MAC a(\eA 'fin \\\I-bb Leck Wr d t p?\a ?ne.?. ih e'?d\1t i e\o?0?( 'Me_ C\d?r???t \WA gc ?? MA&O&? `? t a.?°? v1?.ce. Tcklt e?c\, Mcl3ien.\ ?? 5?.? -C1?? Nu?4:?? Wn.4, \?1t or?l? Evec\?c31? "h\? Go?,rr?wl\?S da?1l?. V.1eE? \.?e?e? ?? c?\? Qleh? e.?e.C -Co 'M?F?cyyn\c 9??? ? `C1r\d?c''Cr\ey e?i\?Nb? Q.epoCk-M?. M??' S\eve.e_zip znva\v e.?n `S.?.e\oye?. Mea'?en\ °?1co4 u?e? oc\\y b\\ItW -'Nn+L Wit\'t Mo?( :eN ?bC 1\i? Qeat\S . Ilo. or\ ti1a?lErn?Q C \'? ? ? ?'ilnc Cin;srncan?k Su?awv??Ce?L b. ?etNtes\ go) Re %eC k,,% n_ Grieva?n!!?. OJ.\t&& 4\b -40m, u J?`?e \, e by t-4. MoCe?u `i..A. VOL ?'1. plc ourno,?r+t\y (S> ?r i\Ie_ oea?? \.o.??.c ?c Ndver?\dec \'?, ?.?? ,?ne_ Gci..ruya?aC ?te?.e\?ea 'or\e_ ?Le leg 1 be ??vo nee_ QA-c vAW65 Tc n? ?ze3 TV e. &Wve. oAy . L1n@.. C\riwv.oank sk i\ V%X*A 11aS Gr \%m n nLp- -UN. SC'S- Ce \Ph.\\ 'Mc Mki C Vm Qc \??\S v R\ca#-Ih Mo:\\ %\\e. \\o,, %1 ? fie:\?t cc? d'?leS?e?.`[? °?.C1C?c.?vc?\CS? a\\y Qle?e\,??a ??.ce_ -cho.? ?c'c?c\? ?.? v.?? \?. 'Me C tL,,wm 4\n,, XADW S%-Aws Fcom XAA& To 'Ne- tse- U%cflt?\t- QVIM &A V.x oR'POLN n.%4 'CctaatL. wl. a \k V1Ah "Ck.p-. - up o'C \\t& 6Nm-. \°t. '%P_. M)?wt g d4 CoCCeS.?wno\ Ott;utz stsge A v\mt&LN %n ? VJLCe -lAkuN'%r t%A CLb . w . C,. 0.,?3?\ar cc -V*rito, U!?'bwAk I Soave tl S .\\ Su e?S 'fit rsrc? vlr e.? os,& Qna? 4a:.r " W? oer?ea& Qc ope c fat- MeA . a1.\. "C?C.e c .r?an1? Z3 ??.t?hc??V. \\wc\ Qo??etcx.?c W.?1t? o? T4..r O?ce? nS?c?e' ? a d? ?sr e\ostle?Qo?e-Mmv.s-?-r \Awh, .P\a,?nle? at\ t" AD .ODIC. ems,, ? cr?t\?Ce n? ?^o?? \\? a da\a Moen "Id yVtt-k bX Q o?\y V:?\\ e? . ate. . u\dtMcweX was &,tijqLpltr\ Nh,. pl Q13\0: d! \X.a ec?%VUL)t en, cbl??i? E1acaS?t , Cl A?\? ? ???y, ul Qd.,m "A %%ICed'Ac? i El ?c.?, ark Mc. Qa;?n o? 1??nyvig\., Gl Zr\aa?o?,.?\ea:.e,a\, en?? ?..3. ? eax\\?.,\oces o? cam, .?'!s IN!'- Vur-6 Acs 0,& ?:c\\oulla. Meate?lE,cp '' : Al C?.cv?an?c u.1ns Bloc e.?rftl\ -Co q" ?n? N`ea tnl cx6v9 6? lbkCV.- e?\\ b1 C\c axv .A M" .i 9u tS Lem ?Cc?rm t ee 'McS? S.x??uc.e3 tk4 zG d v 4N Qco\I0smA&4 TVIA -One Lko % D AA V101 Alta\??o?.\C,?tizn\c.or,°?ez Qvc C\nu9e-- c.%Rcl to c:LA t^t&? ek Me a t. of "Wa qicLv,e)sV,& me^\ %ank stma?A ) Whwa-, vq\ xr I W\.ec1? CMa?r Oteg60sa,\,X j ) Qca\A M?3.Ct? .a?c.?? e.\cc?.Q?.\?? ?\ \kv-% 9Ap--\mt3p- Lc c'Ear?t C1 C.\t?;scK?Cat\?c Nou ?tw? ?e?? cox. lei McClno .c P.1.\ ?1?3 L.?? Q *\ oC Z a W& 'yM.dtC?Cc>_t?d+n? C?:.r?.h?c \\ati?h 9 1C ?n?e.a. ?e it rat b 'Mc Q c .on `?P°t` WA F1L\e eloscrax??c?SZ+?jur.es \\na?ieuj 2,ee?c. c1 ?Le'u\k ?cucr. ?i4ith 's.,??.aex.\c °.x5 oS Zb S?extic3et 1X.?c..s l?\?. ?b Que. C-u?\t? i\\.? E. CAp\o jeA fo At. oatNNO, kt- C\a%& bar--il:el Ch &so) oob , 13IN \ otAte \ o mkV A\j 'C^&?Pic&a.0o\\eCa ?. 0 1 10 QeaA s c.?.9 01 tNbArULAM su eeg Nf?\? t? °?a1?c? \-Ma Q?eaek.. Qo:.? tm*-cy o13.-11 w\ . Ac "A ocTAkA 'C :MCS %rak; mok Ma--AN iKAAL V\eh?JE.v\A,w c.,,- G.,eces?c oml.oLC.e?C W?U . x ex?? o...a ^,.e.? ?.?c .nn? nand Qo.\,r. Mel Nbkll Fcbe k pe?ce?v? °?\ttl'SL C\c?:uha.??c Wt?n?e? N??u?S Qic??. ?en.??Nj ?Cnct2e.??nt?n1 a?:eePss e?. k\bP31 Esc? Qa?ub\??ity .lea ??na?. c?i?r`Z A?'C''?\i ?:.SMc??wt? Q?scS.sc?n?c'C?'M??\h??? Mtr??o? ?nca.? ?? l`.l?iC? ? I e?.rr? C?coac??cec? nt? ? ? a..bb°1. 15 . ,w%N oA&,a. 'TS F:\,?A. v ltWvn oC wn Rect?cea ?.? LAN.\ . UO. 14ARF bvL , C?;?nnax??c Qle_°?pee?c?.?\\ 3? rc???c kce pzxt\A ?. -M? mourn -c. ?unatex "rc ; o I Amarnbkr q• ?1'1? C?c\eg ?C . CdlO_C'?l?C? . ??rnnr`?c , `7 co Se . OdC ?1h ? 1? D°1'3'? SC'Z'F?e?1c, ?x AI- OAS \1c2,sok 0 . . w i-VI FIA?E OF S1E'Q?VTCF Z? e'..Qd?.n,??e?ee? c?c????y -c??'Zc?Q.. e.?i?e??c.?c?- W?.ce°_??? v.ciF??? e\,oPA one (\ o c : ? cu.? -c?.c Qe,(.31 c,o?,? C1?ezN& fir! My og aC?,kt-2 cue l\ t&" *rot On?ct.t?levemde? AA- j 41bk da,,L cv?61131?- U%nx \eL°s 'T . Q ,XaA c, 'vice. wt- . 0 'fines muck eornmbr P\e For -?1ne com.on?er?.\?Ck o& Penc?lvar??o. C1nnr\e? `r. Pa??n?, .t, l' iV t\ NCvt w\ tmsp-- t?o . WM) - tA.b . &bbi . "ro 'C4.e- ckqrV, .? & u, oC k P\tnSe V:eA akk6-kAa ?????o e? E,?1r"b? s enorv.?? Cox:A2f X21 FoC W%YV? Zr? -tvA10-1 WM dV e C aQ? t oy,\ Cie . ' NNf-- acay-,\CL : F't?C??n2C GvmtA. 'wtrn t6u v Z ktVto^ v.1&-,Oh Lion -ct,.? b??? ?k d? oete .bar ??1, a v r? Qc sb,c\&, vice t t-\ Mea` stc\j nAe- . tree e?beC a3 rA,) Amq , \4.vj sib e.a Ga?rnr?t , `?('o der ? C1???,-??©c? of V\-'aw't ) a' S? h ?1 ?? ?n?C.e fie( fib. 1? 5 q ff r hc?e?C,y Ste- v ?ze? 0\10 , Y\.) &+CkNe, o?- 2CSaty k""O'X i?,G Ov, (Wvecv? ,\ Q , a00 W4?+1e b?. n? le-t ?? oc o. `?ZC cv r. yace (AS CO A'V'C c e-5 t ??j?- • ?Q?,???-x.?n ?fo?e? C?^cr.(\t,5 ?eC Yvo 6e?,.Son. ??ncc l c-,c5 I?St oo+ IV- ?coc T AAne p See- 0,?C kl C5 wu$ qo;n' 11s5'Ic?e Ca?? ?? (?eSSe.? ?Y+c sy?, ?v ? 0-,,kmkv-S Ccw)s "y 1^+ ?a ???? ©n 1??5 kafv-?s cnn4- ?ree5 , 1'?om W ecc. j? Wc,,S 47L Cov? `neuc U?? ?rQ. ?J?o1e. 5????:un Una root 5,j an y 4v,?n4,c? 3Fo vo tCe 3e? ny ??,Shc?. ?U?e ` Nov??c ?3 aoo? v m.w?k\r? -?%Q m?,e 6e c \A 5cl ?(o f( Form DC-135A Commonwealth of Pennsylvania INMATE'S REQUEST TO STAFF MEMBER Department of Corrections INSTRUCTIONS Complete items number 1-8. If you follow instructions in preparing your request, it can be responded to more promptly and intelligently. 1. To: (Name and Title of Officer) 2. Date: 1 ? ?\ ? 3. By: (Print Inmate Name and Number) 4. Counselor's Name ?c? ?c?.\[?.c1?t nn 11? c'xl3'1 b p? 5. Unit Manager's Name Inmate Si nature 6. Work Assignment 7. Housing Assignment -22 8. Subject: State your request completely but briefly. Give details. 'v , M t&f -x 44 E To DC-14 CAR only ? To DC-14 CAR and DC-15 IRS ? Staff Member Name / Date Print Sign Revised July 2000 Form DC-135A INMATE'S REQUEST TO STAFF MEMBER `t - A P od Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Corrections INSTRUCTIONS Complete items number 1-8. If you follow instructions in preparing your request, it ca"baL4;1% ,tR*,(WCA promptly and intelligently. 1. To: (Name and Title of Officer) 2 hkffi?yl) 2. Date: 2008 u-,31- 08 -. 3. By: (Print Inmate Name and Number) 0ncack4- At, og3?F 4. Counselor's Name ellAe& Inmate Signature 5. Unit Manager's Name 6. Work Assignment t4 01 e 7. Housing Assignment - - As 8. Subject: State your request completely but briefly. Give details. tkxk M \ L% S-•C v CL QZ1 A -e 61 c v.?--! n. L11A "-,AIX C, G -? ` J To DC-14 CAR only ? To DC-14 CAR and DC-15 IRS ? Staff Member Name Revised July 2000 Prin???? Sign Form DC-135A INMATE'S REQUEST TO STAFF MEMBER F Unit - A Pod Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Corrections mo ", i". 1. To: (Name and Title of Officer) ) 2. Date: 1--,7- 3. By: (Print Inmate Name and Number) clr.ar\eg a No- d uVn O [tiA 4. Counselor's Name: /CJs., -, ?-- L. "Z(IQ 5. Unit Manager's Name: Inmate Signature / 6. Work Assignment:,: 7. Housing Assignment: 8. Subject: State our request com letel but briefly. Give details. - M C' :Z ?Le ?- . , r S q 9 Z 5 CU462d&I -r-,l . c s? To DC-14 CAR only ? To DC-14 CAR and DC-15 IRS ? STAFF MEMBER NAME J< DATES Print Signature 7.2.1, Counseling Services Procedures Manual - Section 3, Request Slips Attachment 3-A Form DC-135A Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Corrections INMATE'S REQUEST TO STAFF MEMBER INSTRUCTIONS F Unit 1 w A Pod Complete items number 1-8. If you follow instructions in preparing your request, it can be responded to more promptly and intelligently. 1. To: (Name and Title of Officer) 2. Date: / 110 -toe > _ 3. By: (Print Inmate Name and Number) 4. Counselor's Name: 5. Unit Manager's Name: Inmate Signature 6. Work Assignment: Housing Assignment: 8. Subject: State our request completely but briefly. Give details. 1:1 avt- Givela A cllka- T& l"? 1AA 1 I - AI / I I --N. S I _ / /f/1 - '_ AA_-/1- - [ v I I To DC-14 CAR only ? To DC-14 CAR and DC-15 IRS ?/ STAFF MEMBER NAME l Sle4,- -(, DATE ` Print Signature 7.2.1, Counseling Services Procedures Manual - Section 3, Request Slips Attachment 3-A Form DC-135A INMATE'S REQUEST TO STAFF MEMBER F Unit - A /'-\ PO i Pod Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Corrections INSTRUCTIONS Complete items number 1-8. If you follow instructions in preparing your request, it can be responded to more promptly and intelligently. 1. To: (Name and Title of Officer) • 2. Date: 3. By: (Print Inmate Name and Number) V^&.6e-A Pa\nb«?o Wt 801 4. Counselor's Name: L Inmate S' nature 5. Unit Manager's Name: lud, , CHCA JAN 6. Work Assignment: 7. Housing Assignment: 8. Subject: State our request completely but briefly. Give details. ) ail P") C j?k e&'11 ! ' T M 7-A M e - Cla d rmg 146A(41 Abg,j :Me A41?n rd Me A - 4. *14-11 kz 1;2k L - - ZZ& Z o / ZZI M16 G Il t.v rte- S o ?. / ?y o?S To DC-14 CAR only ? To DC-14 CAR and DC-15 IRS ? STAFF MEMBER NAME ?:c lJ? ice"-ATE Prlnt Signature 7.2.1, Counseling Services Procedures Manual - Section 3, Request Slips Attachment 3-A DC-ADM 804, Inmate Grievance System DC-804 Part 2 COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS Attachment 8 P.O. BOX 598 OFFICIAL INMATE GRIEVANCE CAMP HILL, PA 17001 DC-804 COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Part 1 DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS P. O. BOX 598 CAMP HILL, PA 17001-0598 GRIEVANCE NUMBER OFFICIAL INMATE GRIEVANCE TO: FACILITY GRIEVANCE COORDINATOR FACILITY: __ [6ATE. FROM: (INMATE NAME & NUMBER) SIGNATURE of INMATE: WORK ASSIGNMENT: HOUSING ASSIGNMENT: INSTRUCTIONS:' 1. Refer to the DC-ADM 804 for procedures on the inmate grievance system. 2. State your grievance in Block A in a brief and understandable manner. 3. List in Block B any actions you may have taken to resolve this matter. Be sure to include the identity of staff members- you have contacted. A. Provide a brief, clear statement of your grievance. Additional paper may be used, maximum two pages (one DC-804 form and one one-sided 8 /2" x 11" page). State all relief that you are seeking. B. List actions taken and staff you have contacted, before submitting this grievance. t Your grievance has been received and will be processed in accordance with DC-ADM 804. Signature of Facility Grievance Coordinator Date WHITE - Facility Grievance Coordinator Copy CANARY - File Copy PINK - Action Return Copy GOLDENROD - Inmate Copy Revised April 2005 - _.-DC-004 Part 1 COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS 1 ` C P.O. BOX W& l'i 8 GRIEVANCE NUMBER FFICIALINMATE GRIEVANCE ------?- TO: FACILITY GRIEVANCE COORDINATOR } FACILITY: DATE: FROM: (INMATE NAME & NUMBER) SIGNATURE of INMATE: WORK ASSIGNMENT: A/6 AIL HOUSING ASSIGNMENT: INSTRUCTIONS: 1 Refer to the DC-ADM 804 for procedures on the inmate grievance system. 2. State your grievance in Block A in a brief and understandable manner. 3. List in Block B any actions you may have taken to resolve this matter. Be sure to include the identity of staff members you have contacted. A. Provide a brief, dear statement off your. grievance. Additional paper may b e used,, maximum two pages. s / Ari i? /" _61 X f'1''?.R?'ved A fAf'_(tie- i Kf_-2 x'!r`!ee rt,,3,-y) Qf.]YII?F"t ) / r7Uptom' ifdS!?r i '`?f?1? ,,a / -L ( 1 / ,y r ? T?xT f4Gt1f;?, SVdT Rr:?C?(+t?'.c! 1 41 ?.. C. A M? -, r l! . d? s e1r`?t'l. ?,+I ? i .7C~>??2nY t' }} t rt r - -.1 4M I L.I C.RI.'? ?^ _ ' • y 7?F' i T;.:..f? rA7 x f flog: T.-. %% - B. List actions taken and staff you have ContaCtetl, before submitting, this grievance. ?"'# i I"I ... 4 ,?-71ri j '? .L. n , T tl a.YI H' d?.e..J..t? e N' ?J .?? y ]I `3Gt Jr d]t tf :::..T rif^I.?r,- i` t; f!•" ( - ,?i•'..?V,-t j' Your grievance has been received and will be processed in accordance with DC-ADM 804. I f Signature of acility Grievance Coordinator Date WHITE -Facility Grievance Coordinator Copy CANARY - File Copy PINK -Action Return Copy GOLDENROD -Inmate Copy Revised December 2000 Form DC-135A INMATE'S REQUEST TO STAFF MEMBER F Unit - p Pod Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Corrections 1. To: (Name and Title of Officer) C > 2. Date: ?' o 3. By: (Print Inmate Name and Number) OYNC-lc k6 ate. \C, d ok n o ? ca:,w 4. Counselor's Name: mg . e 4.?Z1I4??C ? ? 1i/' Inmate Signature 5. Unit Manager's Name: 6. Work Assignment: 7. Housing Assignment: 8. Subject: State our request completely but briefly. Give details. 'all il 7- qPe.,l - N! r? r r 7-A VI/ r S Ale A/,3 9( Ise'./ d fYV 'Y -?vu -Z7 cy 7 ;v cv^-0,46)z -Ell 4-62 44,k- LT-4' To DC-14 CAR only ? To DC-14 CAR and DC-15 IRS ? STAFF MEMBER NAME Shy DATES l ? Print Signature 7.2.1, Counseling Services Procedures Manual - Section 3, Request Slips Attachment 3-A COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA Department of Corrections State Correctional Institution at Camp Hill Superintendent's Office February 18, 2009 SUBJECT: hnnate's Request to Staff Member TO: Charles Paladino HS-0937 SCI-Forest FROM: John A. Palakovich Superintendent You will receive a response once the investigation is completed by the Security Office. JAP/hf cc: File 1 r ?..? -%r. Cauc \- a? c?c?ncnon Q\ wm?z\Oa u-1vAy NJ ,SGT. MaCAL. a,%c' j of A. caaot- t\n. \b- \Stb MbA IDN FbCZ AQPbS1JTM `C bF cwtysla Cc?Mes r1oL.1 "i1r,? e\ci,+n?c,??, C?r•os\?S Qa?eu\??d, S.e. -?c,:g M?r?r For "C1ne. P\n,,A'VI A co -orn i? c:) ?\O, A XU F\cc? t-,CAa\- to c.bPZ bus A c ?.?ys ( e ,?ncj 4. cege??n?i? or an No, ccac\Vnc? AA c ?g, \\OLLs %tk.,\ '3. -chi Q\ci,c,t, YS IAA 0.,e, 'AAtcv*\, N<A \4,\\ ?a1c Qi? a?\? Ze W6d ,tt\y \A'. ?CY?t com4\?x??y as `cht- enfv-l. Cacon\-a Z.r. FarcY,a_ Q?Pec1? a?dO . WlaEt,V--VO V. ,-n.? \kL..W l Qcnls -vy\r&- "t\wv cc Aqn tiNosk Rc om Mo ?a?n NSA e(Aeec` i??.r acrr,e?n? oJ? cz.Lsq\ -Kt:, G, c a k\ d"'Au C)Y, G?a?a2,n? C\e,o.C\e? ?C • Qn?.?c? 0 11 CE.?Z ?S.'? SCP.T dF stvv T r.. 'I., e?.e.n?to.? Q[?YddtiM.tS, eS????y -cw,?c 'Ct?1? en?e.?a ??cea? \n1cCe. Berk u ?o. F:cs? C1a? rba\ To ?n?2 Go\1nc?i??no' on MnCC1? tr) ? d?\A ? one-.0 ocic3?no\ 11nce?l3> c??es -tn eleS K e? 'cMe C CA t ? ,c,ak CS Comrc\em Q\eb9 ??? (? N \c??n?us2 Seem Pk. knelks Da?1e : Mace 15 1 AmF? . dAI& & 0 Daniel R. Goodemote Senior Deputy Attorney General Office of Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 Direct Dial: 717-783-3147 E-Mail: d~oodem~~te'uiattornevgeneral.gov ,, _ , ;_. CUt~ ' ~'~~1 ~'t ;:, , ,:- ...1~':i:FA PALADINO, CHARLES, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA Plaintiff v. SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, SCI -Camp Hill, 2520 Lisburn Rd., Box 598, Camp Hill, PA 17001 Defendant No. 2010-1500 CIVIL NOTICE TO PLEAD TO ALL PARTIES: YOU ARE HEREBY REQUIRED to respond to the within New Matter and New Matter Crossclaims Pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 2252(d) within twenty (20) days of the date of service hereof or a default judgment may be entered against you. Respectfully submitted, Thomas W. Corbett, Jr. Attorney General By: D niel R. Goo ote Senior Deputy Attorney General DATED: May 14, 2008 Daniel R. Goodemote Senior Deputy Attorney General Office of Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 Direct Dial: 717-783-3147 E-Mail: d~oodemoteaiattorneygeneral. ov PALADINO, CHARLES, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA Plaintiff v. SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, SCI -Camp Hill, 2520 Lisburn Rd., Box 598, Camp Hill, PA 17001 Defendant No. 2010-1500 CIVIL ANSWER AND NEW MATTER OF THE COMMONWEALTH DEFENDANT This Answer and New Mater is filed by Defendant Supt. John Palkovich of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Department of Corrections: 1. Admitted. 2. Answering Defendant does not have sufficient knowledge or information to either admit or deny this allegation. Based on the informa±ion in Plaintiff's Complain±, Answering Defendant is unable to determine which employee of the Department Plaintiff is claiming caused his alleged injuries. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are denied generally pursuant to Rule 1029(e) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. 3. Answering Defendant does not have sufficient knowledge or information to either admit or deny this allegation. Based on the information in Plaintiffs Complaint, Answering Defendant is unable to determine which employee of the Department Plaintiff is claiming caused his alleged injuries. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are denied generally pursuant to Rule 1029(e) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. 4. Answering Defendant does not have sufficient knowledge or information to either admit or deny this allegation. Based on the information in Plaintiff's Complaint, Answering Defendant is unable to determine which employee of the Department Plaintiff is claiming caused his alleged injuries. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are denied generally pursuant to Rule 1029(e) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. 5. Answering Defendant does not have sufficient knowledge or information to either admit or deny this allegation. Based on the information in Plaintiff s Complaint, Answering Defendant is unable to determine which employee of the Department Plaintiff is claiming caused his alleged injuries. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are denied generally pursuant to Rule 1029(e) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. 6. Answering Defendant does not have sufficient knowledge or information to either admit or deny this allegation. Based on the information in Plaintiff's Complaint, Answering Defendant is unable to determine which employee of the Department Plaintiff is claiming caused his alleged injuries. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are denied generally pursuant to Rule 1029(e) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. 7. Answering Defendant does not have sufficient knowledge or information to either admit or deny this allegation. Based on the information in Plaintiff's Complaint, Answering Defendant is unable to determine which employee of the Department Plaintiff is claiming caused his alleged injuries. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are denied generally pursuant to Rule 1029(e) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. Answering Defendant does not have sufficient knowledge or information to either admit or deny this allegation. Based on the information in Plaintiff's Complaint, Answering Defendant is unable to determine which employee of the Department Plaintiff is claiming caused his alleged injuries. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are denied generally pursuant to Rule 1029(e) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. 9. Answering Defendant does not have sufficient knowledge or information to either admit or deny this allegation. Based on the information in Plaintiff's Complaint, Answering Defendant is unable to determine which employee of the Department Plaintiff is claiming caused his alleged injuries. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are denied generally pursuant to Rule 1029(e) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. 10. Answering Defendant does not have sufficient knowledge or information to either admit or deny this allegation. Based on the information in Plaintiff's Complaint, Answering Defendant is unable to determine which employee of the Department Plaintiff is claiming caused his alleged injuries. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are denied generally pursuant to Rule 1029(e) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. 11. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Defendant PennDOT does not have sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to the truth of the averments. 12. Answering Defendant does not have sufficient knowledge or information to either admit or deny this allegation. Based on the information in Plaintiff's Complaint, Answering Defendant is unable to determine which employee of the Department Plaintiff is claiming caused his alleged injuries. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are denied generally pursuant to Rule 1029(e) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. 13. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Defendant PennDOT does not have sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to the truth of the averments. 14. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Defendant PennDOT does not have sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to the truth of the averments. 15. Denied generally, there was no sick call on November 13, 2008. 16. Denied generally. 17. Admitted that Plaintiff filed a grievance and Plaintiff was transferred. The remaining allegations are denied generally. 18. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Defendant PennDOT does not have sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to the truth of the averments. 19. The allegations of this paragraph are denied generally pursuant to Rule 1029(e) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. 20. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Defendant PennDOT does not have sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to the truth of the averments. 21. The allegations of this paragraph are denied generally pursuant to Rule 1029(e) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. 22. The allegations of this paragraph are denied generally pursuant to Rule 1029(e) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. 23. The allegations of this paragraph are denied generally pursuant to Rule 1029(e) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. 24. No. 24 is blacked-out and illegible; Answering Defendant is unable to respond. 25. Denied as a conclusion of law to which no response is required. WHEREFORE, Defendant Palakovich demands judgment in his favor and against the Plaintiff. NEW MATTER 26. This action is not within any of the exceptions to immunity as set forth in 42 Pa. C.S. §8522, and therefore is barred. 27. All affirmative defenses under Pa. R.C.P. § 1030 are asserted and incorporated by reference as if set forth herein at length. 28. Employees of an agency of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania cannot be vicariously liable for the acts of others lower in the chain of command of the agency. 29. The Commonwealth Defendant is immune from claims grounded upon negligent supervision or employment. Respectfully submitted, Thomas W. Corbett, Jr. Attorney General By: D iel R. Goo ote enior Deputy Attorney General Supreme Court No. 30986 VERIFICATION The facts set forth in this Answer and New Matter of the Commonwealth Defendant are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. This statement is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. §4904 relating to unsworn falsifications to authorities. D iel R. Go e ote Dated: May 4, 2010 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving the foregoing document(s) upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below: SERVICE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL POSTAGE PREPAID ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS: Charles Paladino (Pro Se Plaintiff) SCI-Forest Box No. 945 Marienville, PA 16239 By: aniel R. oodemote Supreme Court No. 30986 Senior Deputy Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 717-783-3147 -Direct Dial DATED: May 4, 2010 CHARLES T. PALADINO, Plaintiff vs. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION -LAW NO. 10-1500 CIVIL DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, STATE: OF PA, SGT MACDWAIN, CORRECTIONAL OFFICER, SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, SUPERINTENDENT, Defendants ~' = ; c. ' ; `'; ~ ~ r {: ~, , ~; , -~ ~x: rt~ ~-" ~. IN RE: MOTION FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS ORDER ~J day of June, 2010, upon consideration of the foregoing AND NOW, this s petition, it is hereby ordered and decreed as follows: 1. A rule is issued upon the plaintiff to show cause why the petitioner is not entitled to the relief requested; 2. the respondent shall file an answer to the petition within twenty (20) days of service; 3. the petition shall be decided under Pa. R.C.P. No. 206.7; 4. argument is set for Thursday, August 19, 2010, at 1:30 p.m. in Courtroom Number 4, Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle, PA; and BY THE COURT, /~h ~ el ~oDc~E'i'xal~, Kevin .Hess, P. J. ~~4liv ~~ Charles T. Paladino, HS0937 SCI -Forest P. O. Box 945 Marienville, PA 6239 Daniel Goodemote, Esquire Senior Deputy Attorney General Office of the Attorney General Strawberry Square, 15~' Floor Harrisburg, PA 17120 :rlm CHARLES T. PALADINO, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF Plaintiff CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA vs. DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, STATE: OF PA, SGT MACDWAIN, CORRECTIONAL OFFICER, SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, SUPERINTENDENT, : Defendants CIVIL ACTION -LAW NO. 10-1500 CIVIL IN RE: PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO ISSUE SANCTIONS AGAINST DEFENDANTS ORDER AND NOW, this Z S ~ day of June, 2010, the plaintiff's motion to issue sanctions against the defendants is DENIED inasmuch as defendants have been forthcoming in the production of records which clarify any prior representations. BY THE COURT, Charles T. Pal din H a o, 50937 SCI -Forest P. O. Box 945 M~arienville, PA 6239 ~ Daniel Goodemote, Esquire Senior Deputy Attorney General Office of the Attorney General Strawberry Square, 15th Floor Harrisburg, PA 17120 :rlm Cod ~ ~~ .~,~.~ l~C., ~/as/iv ~rr~ l.~ -~.~ es- r-~ ~, '` ~r .~'~ {~, ~'; N O n ~J -~, ~~ ` , t~'; '-; ~- =, -c C~,.o.C\es T . Qo\da~tw D . v. c. n1~. ~1S o°~3~ Se.I~ ~nte~ ~x #= qy~ JUN 2 4 2010 Sung 14, a.Dll1 . Oov ~ c1 ~ve~l~ C\e,.r~C . Mr. ~~e1\, p\e~se. F:~ ~,,,r~~\ose~ t~ N~~.n~ Fnc ~:\:~y ~ acdes . F~r4~nec',c,ndr~, s a.gce~ ~1~~~. ~.~. oc~ex~ c\os~~ Nldtanr~ Td o~SM:~ My N1o~~~oh ~n~ Pc~uc~~ ~ oac~mtc~~ ~, Mme awl Ac~ce~ \n1~~~. c~ o~s~n:ssol, ~~ Z -C~,z~1h ydu I~ A~~d,n~~ Fnc ~o~ i~~en~~. ~~ree~e_\~~ c~l~ -~. Pa1~.a;no ~• Daniel R. Goodemote Senior Deputy Attorney General Office of Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 Direct Dial: 717-783-3147 E-Mail: ~oodemote~attorneygeneral. 2~ 10 .~ ~Ji.. ! 3 ~,~ ! I ~ u ~:3 PALADINO, CHARLES, Plaintiff v. SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, SCI -Camp Hill, 2520 Lisburn Rd., Box 598, Camp Hill, PA 17001 Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA No. 2010-1500 CIVIL COMMONWEALTH DEFENDANT'S RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR AN ORDER COMPELLING DISCOVERY This Response to Plaintiff's Motion for an Order Compelling Discovery is filed by Defendant John Palakovich (Commonwealth Defendant): 1. Plaintiff s motion to compel the documents described in Paragraph 1 is untimely, as Plaintiff has not previously requested the logs described in Paragraph 1. 2. Plaintiff s motion to compel the documents described in Paragraph 1 is untimely, as Plaintiff has not previously requested the discipline records described in Paragraph 2. 3. Plaintiff s motion to compel the documents described in Paragraph 1 is untimely, as Plaintiff has not previously requested the written reports described in Paragraph 3. 4. Plaintiff s motion to compel the documents described in Paragraph 1 is untimely, as Plaintiff has not previously requested the photos described in Paragraph 4. 5. Plaintiff s motion to compel the documents described in Paragraph 1 is untimely, as Plaintiff has not previously requested the address described in Paragraph 5. The Commonwealth Defendant further asserts that the motion, as it relates to Plaintiff's Interrogatories is untimely, as the Interrogatories were mailed June 9, 2010, received by the Commonwealth Defendant's counsel on June 14, 2010. Plaintiff's motion. is dated June 31, 2010 (which we note is not an actual date on the calendar). WHEREFORE, the Commonwealth Defendant respectfully requests this Honorable Court to deny Plaintiff s motion as untimely. Respectfully submitted, Thomas W. Corbett, Jr. A rney Ge 1 r By: iel R. oo m Supreme Court No. 30986 2 VERIFICATION The facts set forth in this Commonwealth Defendant's Response to Plaintiff s Motion for an Order compelling Discovery are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. This statement is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. §4904 relating to unsworn falsifications to authorities. D iel R. o0 o e July 9, 2010 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving the foregoing document(s) upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below: SERVICE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL POSTAGE PREPAID ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS: Charles Paladino SCI-Forest Box No. 945 Marienville, PA 16239 By: Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 717-783-3147 -Direct Dial DATED: July 9, 2010 4 Senior Deputy Attorney General i J ~ 'M2 ('c~,C~ ~r ~~m~1t~~ Q1e1~ 7 hoc ~.~ e~rrbeslt~na. cc~~-~.,~ c~ 4~~~1,r~n,a, AUG a 3~ 201u ~.c~.r\e~ ~c ~ Qd.~.c~c~."c~d Cave` Ae_.~,c5~,n ~. `3c~nr Qd.\c~.a..~ ~er~C., ~~~ . ~~~~ c.~~ ~. ar>>e- tea p.~ CJ.d1ts , ~:.~ bc~;.~ ,c~ ~as~` ,~1~1t~,~n~. Q'~e.~~n~~~~ ion ~aC de~~~~~d~ ~~ ~~\ci~x~ (~e~~c~, sS ~ %"' W / ~ OY ~ p I'!~ / bI~ ~ 4~` ~ ~., ~ /~J ~s j /~j ~ .r l1'Yt .~iw O~ +j' iK ryM Q~.+ `Che. C~~C~ ~~`!~,-ics Pajaaf;~,a +/ ,EXIn i r ~ C-~a~l~°,i.~o ~° SSG ~ sG r tKa~ ~c~.w ~'BPi~S /Ka•t~ ~f9IlD r ~c~ .-, ~_ -~; ~. s ~ ~~- .,p .- .© .~ ~ =~: __~ ~.., • ~ -~ - b ~-:.; W ~Me_ c~r~ ~ e~.rc~~ Q~~ ~~~ ~~ C4.at1e~ -c , Qo.~,~,n ~ v. ~'~E~ AUG 2 g 2010 e:~.~,~ ~.or e~ ~1n . ao~~ ~~ ~- r ~z Q~Ci~,,~, t~4.o~ Tv ~o, a. "cc`.d1, ~~~ S~ are. ~ `_.~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~: dP ~ , ~y fie. ~ h~C~ _~ qtr ~'O ~-~''~ Ma -?.e_ tc?t rk a? c??nn n? Q?e1?S Cumb??s?c? C1`.vt??y OVaE\k C-N."i.\ NA,k i--n cn?c? °1 c.?ti I Ct? wh -5 -Df N i IF- -P C':) f C- ca .zn I CQ t'?,s rylaL LCL alt s f to SEP 14 2010 ?D 'C?? Tfrit???es ?iZ.?s''?the11? h\1.1c? -Me_ Q\?.?:?? "??:? l?Cc:?,c?\Ce•..??.e?:.?e.-c? Q??e..? Zv??r?C??t?. . kAa?nt.? ?t ?S t vCCc?i1 ti; 'S?MY,\n-j +A b tY FnCtmt>d ??nc?C t?_Cz ? F?cct?c?a? o? .\ . bC rtne -- P\ ir\?.? ??erc e 'c '\\nc.? CV ?rcI1P, ?eC In?? -Mt- IEY\C'?L Se`S: ?=dte.?+? 't+n C.??mbe?\ori? e..c.i?s??y Cr?uC?L,n?t?? Ta Q?z 4c,??k ?nC 'M+? ,,rJN?'?.E?GC?. ,`tv? ?lri???r`?c? \?urn??? er ?y ?l"1nr?? "Crn\g ?ael?c?cr?b\e_ r_e,Uc ?3sc:A . , - C-1 c .1 ., 6- t' P?ac\.?c ?CL9?E'_ ?? S?.C V \ Cam. r'??c Cui°? Me??\ 'fry \ln 3rd cne: t..\ 1 Cf? c3 Cpt?C? ?c C.L?miY\C1?1 ?\?a CLiM?Qi?S\d[\a. C?y??4ti??? t11i'-',U? Cc??k -,? Cs . Qoriie? ?r?P_+Mta?? th e if, f- t? -,c1r.4--, - ?kA . tne? . pa 4?-- .Pke bps ra faLkb . uv.cxMem? ?. Qe-A"% n c - -Me car c er_,.?,ru ?\e?? tA) D vll SEP 2 4 2010 to":-,e hl? • X18 _ 1 c5a?n.c? ND S\ ?a Y t 4?? Z1?d (7) t- C.Il ?., f\7 "? iJ ` ?CD ^ f43 f-rI q), tnoOc . T V,& ul-xk ink comma, Pka ulmmer\hAa mts \N cw'Arkwa, -c. VCAE,&(V?, V. 644 NA.6k,\ r..Aa tom. \6Ib- AL16 M?TS?\F?P.P'P?ZNZ'N\E?\?C ®F TN\°??L ;?? =?-?, N...?MPS win.. "thy.. @1d?e??????c?.or\es Q?n?.(???`.G,n ?c?n.S N1??r?uA Far A?,.,n?c?c? ?? µ, OS . -ctn? Q?os n R r?na?dca roSe? . .± a . -%%C- L6 l lnul c?\\ cs? t: \J i1 CLS5 Cox kk\,\VN CC4,? lS t? L. e" 5tx QCo--VXA tl\a kk\tb\\0 . A. MAs c ?5 h1e? L:? Fdr?camrc?P\e?_ c?uC? -c ks\t.?& . . Zn 11n? V--VeA C5,- z e=? \F± a. Furs?»A `co p0...?.L` iQ. .L\g. Aj-dL.13 • ) rne.\( rMsg?c Qcese -wo- cureA WAf ?.cne Kro?1s To P c?.r, \?f -:=)r?\ '?? perrn? -rb Tr.? 'tYv2_ Cam. ''11n? Q\c?vc??? O?e? ?\n? 1h?i1? A.r? p.f c?? Ta K*&I\A Nis Wt-A %cL` Cot???ce?eQ Lo.I:n'th?E-.1eA a 'Trio1 S1no\\ tnm,,ek Cl??-?c??('n:ra??ong Anc\ P\0?????- c.ant?n? Cro??-EY.circti??? t?imge?.rr. ?c?-Exa?«c?c?? :Qa ???\ kINE @\C Akt Qco.s'Cha?rCkics??n?t?\? Cnurk C,ccsn? Mo\.c?n Ark Q?\Ck-r 3rck db\D . -I Alm ?7r cv...t\e-jt, --r- ?jnAad'tnn, o" tom. WS oar Moxtr???\\e,Q A . \ to?L3q 0 L '(?+ h A II n? ?y r? fi?i?.? ? ?t c ?2 ec yes v,1tSe_ sew v'O. V i Ze)t b N\OA wN tileuem?,PS 3c&fvAo on?.??lar?9,?nol -AO Qrd rw?ar.l my 60r, 4 irk o? emmmm P\tn6 c,%mh*-'AW cl ca?n?y caw-- C ?iiC? It lhf?? e. \Gb ulrvksNa- , PAb ?`?0?3 ?aCci3b?Cc? j PA. 1'?1?d of'.. NNvem?.r !Ira, aL\o Ll/F e? G A- -f- 7L PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL (Must be typewritten and submitted in triplicate) TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY Please list t e Mowing case: for JURY trial at the next term of civil court. ? for trial without a jury. CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be stated in full) L`lnrit'1l!S 'T. Qa.?1il? VS. 'SnMr Qn1n1?n??e)<.,ooc_.. KLviA MCK?n ) Qu. LA. SCZ .\\ Qc ?Sdh 45 Gis ucn (td. ?Qo .6nx Sqg Coc??n?\\ ? Pa. \?db\ vs. (Plaintiff) (Defendant) OF THE FILED-OFFICE PROTHONOTARY 2010 NOY 12 Pff 12: 34 CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA (c ck one) Civil Action - Law ? Appeal from arbitration (other) The trial list will be called on and Trials commence on 1\2AW% Pretrials will be held on t, tq n (Briefs are due S days before pretrials No. \r-?,Ne , NtN Term Indicate the attorney who will try case for the party who files this praecipe: Indicate trial counsel for other parties if known: r-%wi Q\S-'1LL^-- nfth&P 4. ?Z&0?rst to rncc tip %rCA• /? This case is ready for trial. Signed: am" . (94Ld Print Name: P -C. Q r l nn Date: ?o?? lpp? q ?,2611N Attorney for: O . L-z6At mA k, ES?, IA 7\ve_ tmwc? of CjNmc(t,R P1eos C?m1c?rlt? r ?,?R?Ca( nar lea 'C . Po.\n.c?,unn Gv ?\ Ac.? ? en v. ic??ntti Po1aK??v?r ln,??ra1. Ml?arvDR -CO ,?? Ski\EmPs??t ` ]nV?Nbc?'MC P?;.?n????,t?nc?t\PS Pesl,tu??tv?,,QC? S?,'zn 'M?g Mt?lr?nt? Tb "S.4?U2 ?2?1?M?c . -caeA txcxm o& Nahwkk 1Q?c3?eC.?. 3 ? 'Chips r ??c.?. \kne5 O?S.?L. -a:?? CnuC? Nit?c? ?R1 hAot?4iPs ?'Tk? Q?ti?n'?[? ? F y 1ec? C.I?,cc?S N1o??ca?a m boa n v. \ rx ?. N?SmQ.['i, t?r tint, Q\nan?a tS ?r?\??95 1tl?Ce C?e1??esi aC Q?t?tX D Ta ?1i? ECfc?C? air 'Me. Q1a?e????c ? Wiri?eh !\e. CaC CP.L?ei\. Ane> (?? \\? . cue Pear. ?? Wttk4 L&Akt,$Vie, - PCa1orwt A?,wi\?t??n -\?Q. Q\c?aC?..??. \\a.?eves?'Me_P\aay.?a? :+? Q?.c? Pco\ \?i?e? ??9ti? Ta 4cb?eu? 1?it?a A? ? R?s?v? ??:.bt? Gnc ?1?g-zs???C?es. i1?. t'\cat A %2&tbjeg vrA cx- PIP- \e mtA \Am,kl%eA ge & -vm? tt"Ot % ontu AC ».? e t?_?tt=t?c? to QceueR& Ark F,ac? s csvt\ L?n?e?n?PA ? g OVA Quk cb, WWV%Ot EYAa%r?Yo mn? c &-e-pue- Zo Z1ne. T?er?e C??a?tYl?kit,+n Ancl mnc.nrN\jP_Rcy e.?e6h. ,A1M.Tc.ywL J-%*- %aA'A serpwCg WA -cr:ve?, Ct g1, t ZWAme_ aL ecomi? tAts Aekf-%-C'y &--aA\exheA\ ` Wkuw. -i\ 'Me Q\"t 4.? 'C??Ce?c?ttitac lEcK -Wi-t S.ACeghc t& A\\. -c . ?a1nAk-nb a n r -urn -„ s o =C:) - ZIC z ? Dz tv osn CCW-MU IAML dF 5P-MILE ea,,e,,.P?,s.P?.??•??/?,c.?s?i?Cy -n.n.?. -'Ccu?c.c?ie? U1Q.CC. Sink v??E?G6? C\c.?'NV???t`Co 1Me. frolla?alidlt? NVN ntcmtxAt)o+-r 8M. , "kt . bn? L1? CD?,? 'C D C.au?? o? Cbmmction Q?eoS Lilrr?lca?t lnr?. C.r?c?? \Du62 e% . ?D0 mot- C.ak C-arki&v-., eA. 1 013 ©nt- W "\( -ro '. 1?ciA??` C??rne? Sex??nr c? • wk? . Cy?.r? . 1?1c?[rigbucg QA. 1?13n Zc\ `Chi Cbi``3r\\\A Cpmcn%t\ P\to5 C_?lcc??0l.C?ot? CC»??? Choxtps 'C . Qe.\?c?.ttCs Me Cav',\ a t_\\D,n cns? t.1d . kst - abtb Q\o. ,??'s Q-te+a. tf-I t'"tAAM.I.Ns ?spance_;co e\o.? ,r?s Q fnv,u V ,%\es wo1 - @.? cn o2re?nc\a?is 0.e_5?tw,eti jC d P\ci?c?\\??s Mc??t,t?? ?Fdc Dt?09,&tw\ uPnr tti\r'A \. X.A D??erc?at s °Y`? Td @\o:,?t,? 6 v tr,?e,n tl?, ?c s? L1wQCm?r,\c 'l??g\ca S 'Mn? C\n? Q\cau? ,r? Lt.Ul? Mc r?a?e„c S.r? QuPS?'?ntt nCSJ.?ce.? n?c, oe?. \?, 3t?, O?rc??n? `nn? ? tD 5????,A,na L? .Me.E\?.ic?vn WnS ntd? Woctc??a? TVA hem Av?'(?m2 . Tm- to Awv\ IS C\enr\y, A?c?cemEs??h9 To ml%eAe -Me C??r? Amr? -SA ae-bx\y C Nf&,?*A. -cMe_ @\ci r\ , C?EAF?`( Spa\e c?1x? V?,s l"?.e:vL\ tt"M?x&'A :T -vv*Maces y% [?u wr C?Ci`.Jce? cA ahm. t%Ahc\B, o?cc:r?j`Me to-? Stier \ toucc?nr?k31 &.Z.f, DPS?ec?pret QlE'l nY?tSt Td %C;?A k ko&, \AtY, aL1?12S ,dI1°???AUISMIr,?C ??,rJ?td\eS ` tA. Mt \,ilcii \A?t).5 tJDt Wnr Vat19 an \lrte Oa f ?r,a -('% me?'Me. Q\ccxftvA visAA A 'Mt l` oAcc MA Da?P6?k??h pCC11Ce? . \a(3WEVEF?... ?, oe.?extaan?s ?e.Sfeevee_w P1a,,ni,??5 (?? lac Qcac?uc?an o? oe??cre?nn\S?AVecme?'ll T1n? t? ?? skoke? ?c.? t_\ . McE.\?aar, W A? W?\1\lZl?1G tin t?1?v . \3,?D8, duc e\ne3 Y1n? le- r1 S\.\?ac, fie- ?T?? t?dS ?? Utn,['ty Mdrv,Mll?t,p QQ.fi ?,)Cy. J. In t&?L-Aoft p Q\flaA?\1 WCI?lY1( aQ ?b(,?s,tA?llSm [ I!Y\A2S -rnA TV*-%C Y.A- t'h U-V ? rGc IN*- b? _ _?2 M t_? . tE\?n ?V,? Phor o.se,rE y ?, t.1n? t,W?\y Ze en.?? Zd "?nz ??ScnVP_t y llrr 1 Re\ea?o?nac aC A?,rri, 1o\c E\AA*Ac?. T? %c 9lp AJM tr A\ea6 Ik W.\\ try ?t< a Qca ec? Qc i?c ?•r b s \??ary sea?k',ne? o ne\ /&c Qc gar \ su. Irw,o. Ma,? \1&%& V:\*A Mf..Xc& Lk - t1kova S&A ana =S A. Zn mkkn" %$t.&M.C -%t?, P\c?AAg \n e;,k*. , k1wtsVf& k 'v- S1) S\Am -M&c T,k Q\ft,M\ C vao6 Seomc\ ??y M?\t&\ or t4mv. \?\,ZCcA. "Nkt-- 'h&A%0 v.\o.,\lk LAX -N s tA&%&-M?r CAar Vac Me Cnuc\ t4MA "WA Q\mr?,?l' S?b.r,?\? N:s S,e?c.- cn1\ ?on a\ev, t3,,1t?B; (Pc\sex. Qs\tc,,? ? onH,8?1 CS?eE; `'Znu ?a?\\ fie. ?Ll?r, sr Z1nl. Ntt??C Su:X C:?v?e ? '??3t\1efT?Kt:.,`Me Q?lrnle.?s NQ,c? SttK-Lt? Ft'om t?1dV . 13,a?8,\,? 4\?L\e1 cn w1e?t. t?,1?, P\a??.\\?? Wcac?t.D NAT ?v? C\e Seen or mu-J. tylawai-T . ?E Gm? t4ca M&\k \3 ?et3, ?AmA -vv g c-st ke-o" 'SS wte-m.od, -Kv\o Cbac\ w.kL. "ltris t?\\zga?',?.n. 'Me vkt14AV," 6?\i?\y Aar \aa -wA \\t_ QitQLw.%A Qh?s m\'Mecapy LPOOtrlsti*, \Ae S.Aesp. ECbw\ Nb& th%Aln Qd,? %ke S\r o,?s\?i,? Wsb?q.Q,%*A, OPT Aed mjt\ "Mru- 'E?cs\ Q\oea \\ave_ `%& tan Amy ?xcesllA?`. ta?Ll t.1evQm*s c?0 ? jQ L+- © V Z O N tu Q O ti O U l./ 4Lac?w\\? Su\or?n,? C`-1nac-1QS T • ?Qa?i n d I Y ??:(2d?tY0.?C9'V?K6,CPS??.? Mn? `tc?? Cte6 WElCiL Sln? ?t:?. ?:C?C Go?6Mc:?\ Ze Mt ?Fn\\au?? bn c?c k ? e.?mman Q\'P?6 hI& erALl?? t6" -% . boe??e\ ???fYld?lce. S?run? bA. . . 5?tc??sey sQ.,?s?F\. bd . ??v?rnbec C\V?v AtAb daLW 1 . u az\eg -C. Qc..k&A%%, %6 v. Sin'smr, @c. a itsw C a, I wz? NCA -Vwtg /f4 -X-n I\At- tbork c.,& Cbmnnbh Pleas NOV 15 2010 Cif ?\ M? ien cue.. X10 ? t? - do1? . , °o,,E o? t`loverv?er, a,.ou?, u? c.ar?;?c?eSd??bn,-nrt? ?- f a . pew#-% cr >- N 2 uj vQ -x _: ?a a _ a i U- w oy ocl, ttJ? J ? JCn Cr Z _ ? ? uj:c J 1 .. d CL CS C-.) A4A& y A• Jde4 /Y4-1 Ysy -Me'_ eo?r? .1 /,?--/ \k %r t,. - \Ateih, Q S Co ES rrta Lf crnrkeg -N. Qo"v\m v. s?h? Po1aKc?+;cy.,Ek?1. 61'.i?\ O&V,,b ? co" 141. \Sm- 3btb Coa*r.NiDcL1T1f\t t'\o?n?i.??',C t\t?, Qalne??r?u?Qcn se,z?. -M.? c?nnk.nc.-cn ? lesner?r. -Me T\O! t,? sus a? c?c l: 1. on d.?. ?oT?.? Q1ca+?\c? F?\P.e?o.Q?????nFdc - to tX&M o& psf )ww Ae? C.t. 8... Eat\.;M? Qlo?sn ??'? ??? "taerc?r?r? ri:\el? C6C,.t4, 7s-k, ?oc.on. task \k s irk wmestk1 N ft&?hI Me_ v\&Au ooaFat,,r c??us Mn??nc?6 lA. tusw*&6L)3 e& m Q\o,,n?k, s ft95 oeri e?\ br QV4- Lwaout To F;V;fus srcoc9 6-W& Es. TV*- Q\??n?c? ' h:.?i.\y r?n? 'C?no?'?inc acS?eY.aat r \`AC3at\ r;.. A. t.1 XACA t, z Pco\? ??g?n?lr To Pc?3et?u?2 P?citl\?C? !?'M?? Q\n :pct .?? . t s??vec ?'M? ?tia?.?? ???Li ?ov1 Qc-. W Q. \??S 4?a? \o? Ae? ?V2.. C?m?e?P?n?:.dt? GaC 1P1?g z.ri??C'??.3. La. Twc T\&A,i&c Q?1alafeS'c c. Cl.. rte- RAtm\tA \n MA%eA 3??t 'ham. tt"Ck,Quit-.c Nrl b"tA" Rmu" ttulAvufy%tke? I?, PA AAR14LCiQcmtrk splmgTo -w%% a c1??oue.'cm A,A ?AC?hV4<tB+Maelb. l??1!\E'F??R?.,?ne Q\oiaAt;t-t ??' ?? ?:? r n.?r? Yee. c?. Qc Mdne?cy ??\exr?en? QA-\u!ie&n Tv\t-. tvickA W4 ? e For `Ont c A NA, C. oxt:. Vex ? ?j ?c?? . Q C??cv\\y? S?brM' l?? C o '21 'p3 0 -i xm C n r, O M = . -< c> - Z r ?C3 -p =q Z A Z c -w't ??' Z N °r 9) J- ?.vi a guL1.? ? QCb?nD?tt?,C? ?uC?r o? ?mrclan Q1?S ts?mb?t 1a,n? C.c:?w.k.? &AC one Cpl "\, -to '. 1aaCf?gbuCG3 ? QA. 1?-t3b t o cam, k1 ` &`.Iblb -C . ?c.,k&Al na CHARLES T. PALADINO, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF Plaintiff CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA VS. CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 10-1500 CIVIL DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, STATE: OF PA, SGT MACDWAIN, CORRECTIONAL OFFICER, SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, SUPERINTENDENT, Defendants IN RE: PLAINTIFF'S REOUEST FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT ORDER AND NOW, this day of December, 2010, a rule is issued on the defendants to show cause why the relief requested in the within Request for leave to Amend Complaint ought not to be granted. This rule returnable twenty (20) days after service. Charles T. Paladino, HS0937 SCI - Forest P. O. Box 945 Marienville, PA 6239 aniel Goodemote, Esquire Senior Deputy Attorney General Office of the Attorney General Strawberry Square, 15'h Floor Harrisburg, PA 17120 :rlm Cop iF.c' in? L?:L BY THE COURT, 14 4ix, --?1 Kevin ess, P. J. c ? 0 -?? III, O , -° a c-s rY'1 - -? r` te c.) r - ? -.r C ) ,?. CD ?o .. _-?, oo z n -? CO I C??b,C?eg 'C. Qo c r\-,arn es?.Ct?1? C1?u+c??cy SEP 2 8 LUAU e \J A AC''?t ?h" catle_ ,.1N . 40\6-- \sW S.?r Q o\a?Y.bV ??1c? ? ?c.? d\ . MOK U?," LA e?,??? I ?-C c \ A(I-& is An)neS 1u1 e ?? ie cam(\?tSM `? •\" k. t1 I Q. ?. R44,1 0 z?8 /to :::Z1 C o ;? =- c rn FILED-OFFICE OF THE PROTHONOTARY Daniel R. Goodemote Senior Deputy Attorney General Office of Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15`h Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 Direct Dial: 717-783-3147 E-Mail: dyoodemote'a.attorney eng eral.gov 2610 DEC 29 AM d' j 1 f,-UMBERLAND COUNTY P PALADINO, CHARLES, Plaintiff V. SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, SCI - Camp Hill, 2520 Lisburn Rd., Box 598, Camp Hill, PA 17001 Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA No. 2010-1500 CIVIL DEFENDANT PALAKOVICH'S RESPONSE TO RULE TO SHOW CAUSE Defendant John Palakovich files this Response to the Rule to Show Cause issued by this Honorable Court dated 7 December 2010 regarding Plaintiff's Request for leave to amend his Complaint. Defendant Palakovich responds as follows: 1. Plaintiff filed a Complaint filed March 3, 2010. Defendant Palkovich avers that only he and Sgt. Macdwain are named defendants in this action. I 2. Defendant Palakovich was served on March 18, 2010. Undersigned counsel entered his appearance for Defendant Palakovich and an Answer and New Matter was filed on behalf of Defendant Palakovich on or about May 5, 2010. 1 The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Department of Corrections appears in some of the captions of documents filed in this case, although not in the Complaint. 3. Defendant Macwain/Macdwain was not served and the return of service by the Sheriff s Office of Cumberland County indicates he was not found. The Sheriff's Return is dated March 19, 2010. 4. There is no return of service for the Department of Corrections. 5. Plaintiff filed Request for Leave to Amend Complaint was filed December 2, 2010. 6. The incident giving rise to Plaintiff s claims arises from an incident which occurred November 13, 2008. On that date, Sgt. McElwain allegedly intentionally pushed Plaintiff in the back, causing him injury. 7. Defendant Palakovich opposes Plaintiff s Amended Complaint because Plaintiff s Amended Complaint presents Eighth Amendment violations. These claims were not in Plaintiff s original Complaint and the Statute of Limitations has expired for Eighth Amendment claim. 8. Additionally, any amendment beyond the correction of the name of the party is untimely. Plaintiff has indicated the case is ready for trial and Defendant Palakovich has filed a Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings. '` This is the spelling from Plaintiff's proposed Amended Complaint. 2 9. Defendant Palakovich does not oppose Plaintiff amending his complaint to correct the name of Lt. McElwain. Defendant Palakovich does oppose any other amendments on the grounds set forth herein. Respectfully submitted, Thomas W. Corbett, Jr. Attorney Genera By: aniel R. emote Supreme Court No. 30986 VERIFICATION The facts set forth in this Defendant Palakovich's Response to Rule to Show Cause are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. This statement is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. §4904 relating to unsworn falsifications to authorities. aniel 4e.te December 21, 2010 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving the foregoing document upon the person and in the manner indicated below: SERVICE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL POSTAGE PREPAID ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS: Charles Paladino SCI-Forest Box No. 945 Marienville, PA 16239 By: C niel R. Goodemote Supreme Court No. 30986 Senior Deputy Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 717-783-3147 - Direct Dial DATED: December 21, 2010 5 CHARLES T. PALADINO, Plaintiff vs. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION -LAW `' -s NO 10-1500 CIVIL - =- -?' . c? DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, STATE: OF PA, SGT MACDWAIN, CORRECTIONAL OFFICER, SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, SUPERINTENDENT, Defendants IN RE: PLAINTIFF'S REQUEST FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT ORDER AND NOW, this -S 4 day of January, 2011, the request of the plaintiff to amend his complaint with respect to the name of a defendant is GRANTED. The pleadings and caption of this case should henceforth reflect that Sgt. Macdwain is instead Lt. Kevin McElwain. The remainder of the plaintiff's request for leave to amend his complaint is DENIED. BY THE COURT, -"/ 4 1?4 Kevin . Hess, P. J. /Charles T. Paladino, HS0937 SCI - Forest P. O. Box 945 Marienville, PA 6239 /Daniel Goodemote, Esquire Senior Deputy Attorney General Office of the Attorney General Strawberry Square, 15'' Floor Harrisburg, PA 17120 00?ud &P 'e V 1 Am CHARLES T. PALADINO, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF Plaintiff CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v CIVIL ACTION - LAW JOHN PALAKOVICH, DOC., SUPT, KEVIN MCELWAIN, DOC,: LT., SCI-CAMP HILL PRISON,: Defendant 10-1500 CIVIL TERM IN RE: CASE STRICKEN FROM LIST ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 4th day of January, 2011, upon consideration of the call of the civil trial list, and no person having appeared to call the above-captioned case for trial, it is stricken from the trial list. By the Court, /Charles Paladino SCI-Forest Box No. 945 Marienville, PA 16239 Plaintiff, pro se Daniel R. Goodemote, Esquire Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 For Defendants Court Administrator bit) :mae lY' lJ"?' ??(pIu<<Q m . CA) V.... C) L"o\b,--.c\w,A Ca%ir?tI v. Sn\nr? Qd\aV.?vl? E d\ t e_t4t . \St? - az,% MC kbd\ FbC ??[\?\eleS \et\ Foe ??c ?Cy.2x?vnq C1]r? ?Cou?n Tc i ti\ ?is? C1yme0 l.\?,..? C\?.e_Q?a?\&?, Cy\of\es Qa?o.r?ir\?,Ln \\\ra Mo??e.?n Foc ?L?Y\S\teS?.\?Y\. Q\dr?,?? S?o`?c? as f?cbur? . \. on Sc?,n,Aftry \o, a.nA 't\nt p\daYt A Rat-eive.c\k K^ acAts FCorn\\ovn. W?-.\ey d\ec Sc., t AtA Sonunsy -\ %\\TV\* move."I"A Fcom'Me_?c:?\L:?? ??co.???r\LjT+na?f tAN PeSSee\ N*txatA To cm\\cA Tt*- ua&t- Fox -v c ?UA . '± ?..or. ?e texvdtt An,, V dDle,'c\?e Q\o,,, A F:\!? dQer?..MI\ 'EMC \Aet tA vwsk tbc?i o.e\'CeS?t,Cill?n?.uM, ?l uQ?i?rw,'Co ?t Q]fout?h rflc?? IC&C %. bh t?an?rn\?!f ''\, a&,\6 •'Mt Q\ din t,?! QsLlrGV ? 0?x? ?Cae [ ChM V?on . \k13AY\ A . \\!?•Q . S • s?co\t?+l? ?nDL? Woh Fdc \Wmtb6 Coc?,? v.1,\\ @? Cav?S Sea WM?n't?Mc? zS L??ke? Foc T r ict\ . '-\.TC\r -Q"oNva emXeme\w Prole-A NVA At- \i.\dra\c1 Nom %exx\ N\ i\eL -,a Nmr.L eC tak AA %man vct&t k -a \A?e: usml\?- %ek-y\ mbar eve ww%fA&r -cd %e-.-c\ntm Eoc 'MtL e.o,\ . Vucv?*xrnoCeLP\a,??. Ac ea 'C\nak \?e_ `?1a \?t 45e Qce?,?:ce? Ar??loc Q?e?:?7 A w\ Fbc aoh 6?\ng A??Cae:el \XXT'xtS& 'ce %e PCP-&terk V&c -\M*- ebrkg -ccie.\ CAI\ ?; • Q\d\Y?k. ? zs WIAUkEVaE Wa A A \\IswAb\,?Q'Cogel -T" t1r:?a u?nrwcalAS- Caut\ Q?t?rP??C l 4b bt?&r g?,c\cY&riiA fin! Q\oar\vtA Gcorrn I.V& Tc?d\ L\b\c . ?P?u\\? St?brr?•?td r-V, e?4,\alw\a c 7-- CcJ -n O --+ c::, D '-C v ? C.Q<(!?Q thr-sl?,SVil`A' -X. ?,?e?,y ?zt???.? `cvw?'Cc?? ?,e°?'r1?r?S \c?ece_ ??.:?? ???eL F':r?? L1d?..?Mc.????fin? Fo\\???;n? ©dl??1) tn?" TQ s o? d 1c Pcd?nc? C,r? r??ck t, c?rnb?. P\Pn?. OL --v ?7 DN the C©t1C' `` Dk CDmmDV1 P\eb9 G]mbtS\D,.nr? Cd?1r?y c?r.arlcS 'C. Qa?.ca??D, L?v?\ S?\(1t? Qca.?aY.a????1r. s??r? t\\?lX\., ? ? Q? ? ?or Vox "rA ok No cnrnes tAt La P\oar ? Rcl??r?tl? O??en??.?5 ? Q.a. Sa?b?es z.Y, Porgy To ?.i''2'M2 NrF.?`5 a? 'Ck?e S..mp\??a.?r?er c? 'CY?e_ Te??a e? `(?;?? \n\c?? ?. t?? ??lacle.,crdes \°5"t?e.,dD?B,?n? Q\oan??C? W? QMya?ca\\y A?o.?i\\? 6y 'Me O?cGnaar.?r t?a.,enl?.1???c?.?i Lne c ek-\.ura\ L\ , w?u?r M,?E\U%c an. ?ane? ?n? P\oan ? 6 A?n,?\\ t\? S e cg ?com c1?\c, C, Sevect- barn. N.,n& 1l new Qoan o& o,. U&\,\\ W.6os\ttk, I ?,. The\n:?r? IS M^" aG d Me?:?en\ Spec?ta\;u?\c Cnce: Enr \1?s 61L Zrrsoc?w . 3, The Q\baf&kgg ies?ts en?c\r Td a .c.4 ci Mc?,,en\ Ex fslc? -co 4? a a, -creci)& 11r.C P\n:.nl.?? For \\?5 ?ncV? Z??ae??.s, Tb Qe?vev??t. Anf c?n?\\e? d? T.,n?{'e??c oc ?e??c??'•ans Fx? ?h'c.G PcX43CVNS \lenl, n ?e?csS\ea?c?c??Oe_?a n\cs Q.nA the Q\e;?n\c:??, ?. e\tittl, Zs yne?,o?r? P.c?a, c.at r?(.,)L A oCa M? a n? MeA% a?e?mn IFnC a%C? Qd n ?1ec US'A 'C%A-h Pc??t? @co i,?C M .es?\ E4v r\S Tn Cceb?'?r? Q\cvt?NA Fac W%6 6 WNE'?'??'?., P\o:,n?,??r ????c '?rv?c ^M? ?.?e.Y.?nZs ems- 'C\,e Ct?e ? ecdv,?,n?-ctir,? Q\d.???,?c- W1t? CL lAt-kktoil E?er\ b;A M? ces? OR -",At- b ,[mac. bp N-V TNu"\O, l` r C??. ?o?i\vory a.\??? a.la\\, t=C - Foces&, Q- tom, %nx C\As P'1ar?--mf R . \t,A9 ? v rrl o _ ter,, Wta c.? S?cv%ee Z, P n" Qo ? ; e?ck. ? ?c?e_ C°P'`? W?s? se \ ?[. n. F csk c?o? Mo a? ?d Fo.\\o??%%\cj oh bv\v-lx-? mm 'baai?? 13?e?,\, Qco??C.e?cw?c?V c?i?? o? eamm?m Pens cin?.l\? ". -vb.. mom. `SuNviont al6k, v-"\t r3,? ,Ge cp (. 6)aPA, 1 CHAI T. PALADINO, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF laintiff CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. CIVIL ACTION - LAW JOHN ? ALAKOVICH, et al., Defendant NO. 10-1500 CIVIL TERM I ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 21St day of January, 2011, upon consideration of Plaintiff's "Motion for Reconsideration for Strickening Case from Trial List," the motion is denied, withou? prejudice to the right of either party to relist the case for the next succeeding trial term a?d without prejudice to Plaintiff's right to file a motion requesting that he be excuse from appearing at the Call of the Civil Trial List for purposes of calling the case for trial. SCI F P.O. F Daniel TortsI 15"' Fl, Harris] BY THE COURT, Paladino, #HS-0937 Y. 945 ille, PA 16239 , pro Se Goodemote, Esq. gation Section Strawberry Square g, PA 17120 for Defendant oppie:& ?la`??"ate C -?3 rnw =rn ?w CA r-= a n 2 p z L .F` -v s w CD O --t rn 'urn ?-a p ?p o-n =n -ern :rc Daniel R. Goodemote Senior, Deputy Attorney General Officelof Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15`h Fl or, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 Direct Dial: 717-783-3147 E-Mai : d?,'oodemotc'attornevgeneral.Gov OF, THE PROTH©MOTARy Z01I JAM 24 pM 3: QQ CU lBERL HQ COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA PALADINO, CHARLES, Plaintiff V. SGT. MACDWAIN, DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, SCI - CAMP HILL; SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, SCI - CAMP HILL, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA Defendants : No. 2010-1500 CIVIL ,NT PALAKOVICH'S RESPONSE TO MOTION TO COMPEL DE. ANSWER PLAINTIFF'S SECOND SET OF INTERROGATORIES Defendant, John Palakovich, files this Response to Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Defendant to Answer Plaintiff s Second Set of Interrogatories: 1. After reasonable investigation, Defendant Palakovich does not have sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to Plaintiffs allegation. Plaintiffs counsel did not receive a second set of interrogatories from the Plaintiff. After reasonable investigation, Defendant Palakovich does not have sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to Plaintiffs allegation. Plaintiffs counsel did not receive a second set of interrogatories from the Plaintiff. 3. After reasonable investigation, Defendant Palakovich does not have sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to Plaintiff's allegation. Plaintiff's counsel did not receive a second set of interrogatories from the Plaintiff. Respectfully submitted, WILLIAM H. RYAN, JR. Acting Attorney General By: Attorney for Defendant Palakovich Supreme Court No. 30986 VERIFICATION ,The facts set forth in this Defendant Palakovich's Response to Motion to Compel Defendant Answer Plaintiff's Second Set of Interrogatories are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. This statement is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. §4904 elating to unsworn falsifications to authorities. Danie de Dated: January 19, 2011 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving the foregoing document(s) upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below: Char14 Paladino (Pro S Plaintiff) SCI-F rest Box No. 945 Marienville, PA 16239 Torts L itigation Section 15th Fl or, Strawberry Square Harris urg, PA 17120 717-78 3-3147 - Direct Dial SERVICE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL POSTAGE PREPAID ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS: r By: 1 4?, Daniel o e Supreme Court No. 30986 Senior Deputy Attorney General DATED: January 19, 2011 Daniel R. Goodemote Senior Deputy Attorney General Office of Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15`h Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 Direct Dial: 717-783-3147 E-Mail: d<,oodemote!u?attornevUeneral, PALADINO, CHARLES, Plaintiff V. SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, SCI - Camp Hill, 2520 Lisburn Rd., Box 598, Camp Hill, PA 17001 Defendant FILED-OFFICE 2011 JAN 31 PM 2: 0.14 CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA : No. 2010-1500 CIVIL RESPONSE OF DEFENDANT PALAKOVICH TO EXPEDITED PETITION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS This Response to Plaintiffs Expedited Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus is filed by Defendant John Palakovich: 1. Denied. After reasonable investigation. Defendant Palakovich does not have sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to the truth of the averments. 2. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Defendant Palakovich does not have sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to the truth of the averments. 3. The Defendant opposes Plaintiffs request and is unaware of the existence of any conflicts of interest or conspirations between the Prison's Health Department, the Defendant and the Plaintiff. 4. Defendant Palakovich admits that the prison will not provide a medical expert for the Plaintiff. After reasonable investigation, Defendant Palakovich does not have sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to whether Plaintiff is indigent and cannot afford medication for his pain. WHEREFORE, Defendant Palakovich requests this Honorable Court to deny Plaintiff's petition. Respectfully submitted, Acting Attorney General William H. Ryan, Jr. By: aniel Goo e Supreme Court No. 30986 VERIFICATION The facts set forth in this Response of Defendant Palakovich to Expedited Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief This statement is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. §4904 relating to unsworn falsifications to authorities. aniel Good Dated: January 28, 2011 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving the foregoing document(s) upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below: SERVICE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL POSTAGE PREPAID ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS: Charles Paladino (Pro Se Plaintiff) SCI-Forest Box No. 945 Marienville, PA 16239 By: 1) iel R. Goo e Supreme Court No. 30986 Senior Deputy Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 717-783-3147 - Direct Dial DATED: January 28, 2011 .1? ?n? CD?C? t? Cdre?r(??h ??eL?6 ?a?r\r Qd\o.?lt?v ?e?. , ?\o\ . 4 nz s h }+?+ is ha r , ? ?c ?, .c tv?K. -? H 2?cs,a Ca,??o ? a"? r*'1 "t3 fTk C7Q i`T1 t""' 3 " ?.. f ? ? ?J O? T' N t r-T] C,3 Cn Chess T Rtkdlno, Pt f' ?ie I G c odemvte , F.? les Mjiod ? 3 II a? 'orB PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL (Must be typewritten and submitted in triplicate) TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY Please list the following case: ? for JURY trial at the next term of civil court. for trial without a jury. ------------------- CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be stated in full) Cdr\LS `Tinorna& Po.\o.A.no vs. Sotin Pa.1nLC?,?c1?, E?a .\ ?, occQQ?. o? e?cc Sc? C..arc?ti?\l Pr?gnn Asa.n G6bucn or, La-M riiW , PA. 1-4166\ vs. (Plaintiff) (Defendant) n1.?- c C= -O3 = rn 03 cn CD t-G- Z v --------- -- •-- w (,cl eck one) Civil Action - Law Appeal from arbitration (other) The trial list will be called on and Trials commence on Pretrials will be held on (Briefs are due S days before pretrials No.',-7)QQ_ &OLL Term Indicate the attorney who will try case for the party who files this praecipe: Indicate trial counsel for other parties if known: This case is ready for trial. Signed: Print Name: ??.5 Date:/ / Attorney for: CI 'J ?o a r:r? CV A- PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT (Must be typewritten and submitted in triplicate) TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY: (Liszt the within matter for the next Argument Court.) -- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be stated in full) G -? -- -*? _- CHARLES PALADINO, Plaintiff - rr fit" N ;O C VS. <C7 SGT. MACDWAIN, DEPT. CORRECTIONS AND SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, DErfflp "ra CD-1j OF CORRECTIONS, ors, No. 1500 2010 mir- 1. . State matter to be argued (i.e., plaintiffs motion for new trial, defendant' s demurrer to complaint, etc.): Defendant Palakovich's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings 2. Identify all counsel who will argue cases: (a) for plaintiffs: Charles T. Paladino, Pro Se, SCI-Forest, P.O. Box 945, ar envi e, (Name and Address) (b) for defendants: Daniel R. Goodemote, Office of Attorney General, 15th Floor, (Name and Address) Strawberry Square, Harrisburg, PA 17120 3. 1 will notify all parties in writing within two days that this case has been listed for argument. 4. Argument Court Date: March 25, 2011 ?ature " `?? " ARN17 ?oo0?k Print your name Date: February 14, 2011 Attorney for Defendant John Palakovich INSTRUCTIONS: 1. Original and two copies of all briefs must be filed with the COURT ADMINISTRATOR (not the Prothonotary) before argument. 2. The moving party shall file and serve their brief 12 days prior to argument. 3. The responding party shall file their brief 5 days prior to argument. 4. If argument is continued new briefs must be filed with the COURT ADMINISTRATOR (not the Prothonotary) after the case is relisted. -in -ry\e_ c??c\ ok cor?cnon P\PnA v. r nc.Q k. ksoo- Sohh Qom.\d?loV ??h, ?? a\,, oe?otnc &A . r \,b-\lC.E Tts "?WE Usulva uW\ Fe?rL.1Os' orneIj var t?el\c\nn sI me ,koa Cnmc\erc??e Fi\ed Qfo,.2C.pe_ For L??\??9 Cl,?- '-ov mcr kN v--A FoN 3\25\??. ?.? P\d?? ??? F?\ec\ c? Mo ?on Foy N..p kAw\" D? e-vso?-\ Wh,,Lh NAe ?e ?eve? SS S?C?\\ Qe?na??n? Zr\ Avg \abrocc?l?\? er-,ur\ . \-uV b\A e ' -ne_ ccs.?r t !\or\cr NHS Mrs vn? Fir A?c»??Crne??t L? Cc?%N<e_\ S??C? MeSe_ -S? An kc%pV\er\ o??e_ Sep For 3\a5\??, Q\ W1rkkC\ \ inc. P\C XXA A Re\"e?teen At- Wk1\ tl\c ?QO- NAIL'_ Tcb Arlel?i?e??r\? ?e c?ser? Avmp, e\? , k\??\nou? ctv?:e\ QctveA c o LLJ cv v LLJ L.a -? F?e?e??cu\\? subrci.?\ C?.xte5 T. po\cLCl?no Dr?C ND . 1r\S L??'?`? SCI: FoCes?, Q.o. ?oXq'?S Mor?e?v?\\t? , PA. \t?.35 CHARLES T. PALADINO, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF Plaintiff CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA vs. CIVIL ACTION - LAW -1 77 , NO. 10-1500 CIVIL I r DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, STATE: OF PA, SGT MACDWAIN, -- CORRECTIONAL OFFICER, -o $UPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, ?SUPERINTENDENT, Defendants IN RE: MOTION FOR APPOINTMENT OF COUNSEL ORDER AND NOW, this day of March, 2011, it appearing that the captioned matter is a civil case and that the plaintiff is not entitled to court-appointed counsel, his request for same is DENIED. ? Charles T. Paladin, HS0937 SCI - Forest P. O. Box 945 Marienville, PA 6239 ? Daniel Goodemote, Esquire Senior Deputy Attorney General (Office of the Attorney General Strawberry Square, 15th Floor Harrisburg, PA 17120 3 V Qx& :rlm BY THE COURT, ti Daniel R. Goodemote Senior Deputy Attorney General Office of Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 Direct Dial: 717-783-3147 E-Mail: dgoodemotena attorney eg neral.gov r tt T, 21 P' X14 ?., ?a?i SI PALADINO, CHARLES, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA V. SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, SCI - Camp Hill, 2520 Lisburn Rd., Box 598, Camp Hill, PA 17001 Defendant No. 2010-1500 CIVIL COMMONWEALTH'S RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORIES 1. Please refer to the Commonwealth Defendant's Response to Request for Production of Documents #1. The Commonwealth Defendant is providing the most accurate responses as possible to Plaintiffs questions. 2. The initial response was the result of a misunderstanding of the records by Defendant's counsel. Department medical records indicate that the Plaintiff was seen by P.A. Newfield on 11/14/08. A sick call request would have had to be submitted sometime prior to the 10 in order for the Plaintiff to have been seen by P.A. Newfield. After reasonable investigation by the Commonwealth Defendant, the exact date of the request is unknown at this time. 3. Yes, based on Department Policy 13.2.1, "Access to Health Care." By way of further response, the Plaintiff was seen by medical on 11/14/2008. Plaintiff submitted a request at some point prior to being seen on 11/14/2008. 4. The Commonwealth Defendant is not refusing to disclose the prior discipline history of Sgt. McElwain. As stated in the Commonwealth's response to Plaintiff s Request for Production of Documents #6, the answer is none. 5. The Commonwealth Defendant does not release diagrams of "Bravo Block" yards, entrance/exit and two flight stairwells" as this would be a security risk. 6. Defendant denies that any representative of the Defendant has mislead the Court. The Commonwealth Defendant was referring to the date of 12/17/08 as the date the statement by the Plaintiff was given in case no. IAK163-08. Also the 2x10 shift was being referred to as it was referenced in the Investigative Summary for case IAL-163-08. Respectfully submitted, WILLIAM H. RYAN, JR. Acting Attorney General By: iel R. Goo e Senior Deputy .Attorney General Supreme Court No. 30986 VERIFICATION I, _Ian W. Taggart , VERIFY THAT THE FOREGOING STATEMENTS ARE TRUE AND CORRECT TO THE BEST OF MY INFORMATION, KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF, AND ARE MADE SUBJECT TO THE PENALTIES OF 18 Pa. C.S.§4904 RELATING TO UNSWORN FALSIFICATION TO AUTHORITIES. Date: March 11, 2011 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving the foregoing document(s) upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below: SERVICE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL POSTAGE PREPAID ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS: Charles Paladino (Pro Se Plaintiff) SCI-Forest Box No. 945 Marienville, PA 16239 By: D 'el R. Goo emote upreme Court No. 30986 Senior Deputy Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 717-783-3147 - Direct Dial DATED: March 15, 2011 Lhn.C \tS T. Qcr\o.AC O, n M. ?\cat\vg . I za?A Qo..\o?NloV'1(?n, Eft ca., mr\ Tne umxk aF cnrr\(Y\ar\ P\P ^ e?mbec\at\a Ca?t\A.? Lw\\ kk\mb ^ c ^ c.e_ \.\b . ks bt- Um b WV)A \ `C S? c\QC11@t1'C Dt\ 'M? P\e?\ro? C.L\m%rm UIOLAIN lM- Q\blAcA Lv,.[\tS Qu%)M^ 11nieh \v\A"Qf\ Vmc S.%15"* 1c w\ - e\ena\A y we Aft tlt-ktAAC,A\ t_k . V-,P-v m iMQE JL;t . U Qd\l tb )Ote. Nh. \kca cA%%,s5 we c eAkI M^tri'csscltl tai SCI- ?oCes\r?Q. . ?x ?\?\S, mar:zc\vi\\t, PA. '.?..o??e?an?,\=?w??nc-?c 1Ctu:r, Mc?\?a?a,?t\ ?W1no I6 'E?\o?es? a? scZ-?c?cc??n?\\?P. ? . Q?ax S°?8, 3.Q1o?,,c\??r G:\e? ?:? c..a?\o\A? uc\ oc 1?\?nu\ Marclcy3 ?n\n. ?l. L1r e S E"\\eA T.-&\C M&iwes M,\A t1p_? wkaAkes b^ ec a =J? "mom " S aAm b . I ?. Q1ai+r!\\ geel/.s oam es ci\n?k o??e'x\?act\ ? o:c\ iFoc Pfau\k Q?.?A?es.t ? yne\iceed M p1oc,` ? o???? EmP\oy.r,?c,? or ??1nv?rcb? \'?,?. U. k)A mk 'C:me:e, ti`lcle??cyn?,Zlnt Qi?\A1:4?g MltbsA,.bAr. be Z-tA^a? M\uQ61aAs, Mt?u\k- A.\d Q5MAO ry LAP. \rnt. %mialeM \n\nsz?\ %Aq%?borcdrAtA wwa Auko ?cn\\y v:o\d\eA Qtnat\)t.&ft tltt-t " NrA -4 .OkSerAnn)e. AONe_ Q\!bA \VIA t??%tA\ "? \nlocwvAt) ak\ 'CY\e'C.me A?\? OoAe -a-e- tAmAt r 'ir\ D. e v, ^ Coh6o,.%I* Ark ?. esyl ^c Q\e?? . L3. C1??r2?f\ ?ioa?e. Q\? Dnc? Q\ri1?t\\r: t e0 \d\p 5 itsw-" \trA F \? W-A MeX\eo.\ Q?P?C ii1J` FoC LAS 'Mcrn°.?2ave9? =ih?°Ncb FoAd t>dr???\nt\'Ce'Me p.\\e a?C?ac?S\e6, P\nac&A at ? \??t\ Q?eu?w e? Rkt cc a?W?mg aryucA taA auk%s or\ic\t- 'CMra 'l?_ 0.e6 u. ,M(V1 Atl %Nj r*-t-t rc 3tAL -kL.1nnt\ Wese ?1??\?exac\.? Ir\Zet\?\onol A? .x\u?c.?ece?.A?. W\AE'Q?E.FbR?.,?\?,?n????e_hc?e\ta Nuwh*ky P e "e, -w..ak 'Zhu AA<\ord\o\c. tt Qc)* Xfa6u - ow%)L oeAEz C?cac\??x\tjsu?rn?A AA'Me_Q\ec?\AC? dA tl1i? 6?\nnk? 0.ge.\c\6A o??s\an,nlr V.tv:t\ Mc..E\c,.?naa\. ?PS?'?Ct?\\\? Su?C]rM?IP?] Chc?.r\eg T. pcs..\?\t\b lbC tJd , "Es oc\3tA c7 ? 0 ?? CD C) i Q D A' D x'n pc7 c o rrI -t W -C -mot A ? e?r?\??cn?? b? S?CV1C'L -(M -Teo C.a?.w?.. W?ce ;.,tA mCs F t ce?t a acLai?:, Mda 'co -rt\L Vo\\ow:ncj ott M&Kux aa, a oil : ?t????lnc:?.n?\ bxv,.&-K iola)- C me,.-Te, Do?vic? Qiue?.\ , QCa?t?rwt??Cnr\t r o ,r)?- 6t C-,ommntl P\P LN ?uMbtc\c.? r?..?A?V ht\rL C?ucklnous? ?.t?, '?c.1DG ?r?is\? PA . ??D \3 owe c \l cry To'. Otih\??.\ C?DbC??Mo???E?L\ . Seu:iaC ?? t??cc??..y Cye?c\eca.\ 5?co.??btcc.? sbt??z , ?skh F\ooc 1?oCc:Sb?c? , P A . \-I-1Ab Uc\eLC'\egh "C . Pa.\ac?idlD 0 Daniel R. Goodemote Senior Deputy Attorney General Office of Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15'' Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 Direct Dial: 717-783-3147 E-Mail: dgoodemotena,attorneygeneral.gov PALADINO, CHARLES, Plaintiff V. SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, SCI - Camp Hill, 2520 Lisburn Rd., Box 598, Camp Hill, PA 17001 Defendant FILED-OFFICE OF THE PROTHONOTARY TOi I APR 11 AM 11 * 31 CUMBERLAND COUNT'S PENNSYLVANIA IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA : No. 2010-1500 CIVIL RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS 1 - 9. Defendant, Lt. Kevin McElwain, acting by and through his counsel, the Office of Attorney General, makes this limited appearance for the sole purpose of opposing this motion. Lt. Kevin McElwain was never served by Plaintiff, nor did he accept service in this matter, as did co-Defendant, John Palakovich. Any and all previous responses in this litigation have been filed by co-Defendant, John Palakovich. Plaintiffs motion should be denied as this Honorable Court has no jurisdiction over a Defendant who has not been served. Respectfully submitted, William H. Ryan, Jr. Acting Attoyaey Ger By: Senior Depufyrney General Supreme Court No. 30986 VERIFICATION The facts set forth in this Response to Plaintiffs Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. This statement is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. §4904 relating to unsworn falsifications to authorities. el R. 00 o e Dated: April 6, 2011 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving the foregoing document(s) upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below: SERVICE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL POSTAGE PREPAID ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS: Charles Paladino (Pro Se Plaintiff) SCI-Forest Box No. 945 Marienville, PA 16239 By: . 1 ""7' 10 . - .' r -,4 4ieDZl R. Go to Supreme Court No. 30986 Senior Deputy Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 717-783-3147 - Direct Dial DATED: April 6, 2011 CHARLES T. PALADINO IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF) Plaintiff, CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVt1IA° ---? zM -0 ' F=- vs. CIVIL ACTION - LAW X: -urn NO. 10-1500 CIVIL -n SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, r ET AL., ' ' Defendants -? IN RE: DEFFENDANT' S MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS BEFORE HESS, P.J. ORDER AND NOW, this f 9 day of April, 2011, upon consideration of Defendant's d Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings, and the briefs submitted by the parties, Plaintiff having alleged no cause of action for which sovereign immunity has been waived, Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings is GRANTED. `/Charles Paladino, SCI-forest P. O. Box 945 1 Woodland Drive Marienville, PA 16239 Daniel R. Goodemote, Esquire For the Defendants p41 Am BY THE COURT, CHARLES T. PALADINO Plaintiff, VS. SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, ET AL., Defendants IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 10-1500 CIVIL IN RE: DEFFENDANT' S MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS BEFORE HESS. P.J. HESS, P.J., April , 2011 OPINION AND ORDER For consideration at this time is Defendant Palakovich's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings. (Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings, filed Nov. 22, 2010). The parties have submitted briefs. (Defendant's Brief in Support of Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings of Defendant John Palakovich, filed Mar. 8, 2010; Plaintiff's Brief in Opposition to Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings, filed Mar. 7, 2011). The facts of the case may be summarized as follows. The Complaint in this matter was filed on March 3, 2010. Plaintiff is an inmate currently incarcerated at the State Correctional Institution - Forest (SCI - Forest), located in Marienville, Pennsylvania. At all times relevant to the complaint, however, Plaintiff was incarcerated at the State Correctional Institution - Camp Hill (SCI- Camp Hill), and Defendant, John Palakovich, was the Superintendent of that facility at the time when the events described in Plaintiff's complaint allegedly occurred. On May 5, 2010, Defendant filed his Answer and New Matter. (Answer and New Matter of the Commonwealth Defendant, filed May 5, 2010). 2 Plaintiff's complaint seeks damages from Defendant for injuries resulting from an alleged assault and battery of Plaintiff by one Lt. Kevin McElwain. Plaintiff alleges that, on November 13, 2008, at SCI - Camp Hill, Lt. McElwain "injur[ed] the claimant while acting within the scope of his employment and in the discharge of his duties...." (Complaint, ¶ 2). Plaintiff's complaint states that Lt. McElwain "forcefully shoved the claimant in the back, from behind, causing the claimant to trip over a (about) four (4) inch step causing, the claimant to fall on his left wrist and left knee." (Complaint, ¶ 3). Plaintiff further alleges that "[t]he actions of the correctional officer, sergent [sic] Macdwain,i were intentional and unwarranted." (Complaint, ¶ 19). Plaintiff labels his claims as "assault and battery, and negligence." (Complaint, ¶ 2). As a result of the injuries sustained from these alleged events, Plaintiff seeks damages. (Complaint, ¶ 23). Defendant has filed the motion sub judice asserting that, as a Commonwealth employee, the Superintendent has sovereign immunity. (Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings, ¶ 9). A Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings under Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1034 may properly be granted in cases so free and clear of doubt that a "trial would be a fruitless exercise." Bata v. Central-Penn Nat. Bank of Philadelphia, 423 Pa. 373, 378, 224 A.2d 174, 178 (1966). In ruling on such motions, a court must consider only the pleadings and any documents properly attached thereto. Id. at 179. Judgment on the pleadings may not be entered where material issues of fact are in dispute. Miami National Bank v. Willens, 410 Pa. 505, 507-08, 190 A.2d 438, 439 (1963). The trial court must accept as true "all well pleaded statements of fact, admissions, and any documents properly attached to the pleadings presented by the party against whom the motion is filed, considering only those facts which were specifically admitted." ' The complaint has since been amended to reflect the proper rank and name - Lt. McElwain. 3 Delaware River Preservation Co., Inc. v. Miskin, 2007 Pa. Super. 113, ¶ 10, 923 A.2d 1177, 1180. In Pennsylvania, the Commonwealth and its officials and employees, acting within the scope of their duties, are protected from civil suit by sovereign immunity, except as otherwise provided by the Legislature. 1 Pa. C.S.A. § 2310. It is well settled that the sovereign immunity protections "were enacted to insulate the Commonwealth and its agencies from liability except in certain specified circumstances so that state governmental assets are not subject to depletion through multiple lawsuits." James J. Gory Mechanical Contracting, Inc. v. Philadelphia Housing Authority, 579 Pa. 26, 39, 855 A.2d 669, 677 (2004). Sovereign immunity acts to "[preclude] a litigant from asserting an otherwise meritorious cause of action against a sovereign agency or a party with sovereign attributes unless consent to suit exists." State Workmen's Ins. Fund, Com., Dept. of Labor and Industry v. Caparo Real Estate Inc., 160 Pa. Commw. 581, 586, 635 A.2d 705, 707 (1993). Sovereign immunity is codified at 1 Pa. C.S.A. § 2310 as follows: Pursuant to section 11 of Article 1 of the Constitution of Pennsylvania, it is hereby declared to be the intent of the General Assembly that the Commonwealth, and its officials and employees acting within the scope of their duties, shall continue to enjoy sovereign immunity and official immunity and remain immune from suit except as the General Assembly shall specifically waive the immunity. When the General Assembly specifically waives sovereign immunity, a claim against the Commonwealth and its officials and employees shall be brought only in such manner and in such courts and in such cases as directed by the provisions of Title 42 (relating to judiciary and judicial procedure) or 62 (relating to procurement) unless otherwise specifically authorized by statute. 1 Pa. C.S.A. § 2310. The Legislature has also enacted exceptions, or waivers, to the general sovereign immunity provisions. Those exceptions are contained in 42 Pa. C.S.A. § 8522, which provides as follows: 4 (a) Liability imposed.--The General Assembly, pursuant to section 11 of Article I of the Constitution of Pennsylvania, does hereby waive, in the instances set forth in subsection (b) only and only to the extent set forth in this subchapter and within the limits set forth in section 8528 (relating to limitations on damages), sovereign immunity as a bar to an action against Commonwealth parties, for damages arising out of a negligent act where the damages would be recoverable under the common law or a statute creating a cause of action if the injury were caused by a person not having available the defense of sovereign immunity. 42 Pa. C.S.A. § 8522(a). Thus, Section 8522(a) requires Plaintiff to show that Defendant committed a negligent act resulting in harm to him in order for there to exist a waiver of sovereign immunity. The statute also provides certain other acts and exceptions which may also impose liability, including the following: vehicle liability; medical-professional liability; care, custody, or control of personal property; Commonwealth real estate, highways and sidewalks; Potholes and other dangerous conditions; Care, custody or control of animals; Liquor store sales; National Guard Activities; and Toxoids and vaccines. 42 Pa. C.S.A. § 8522(b). A plain reading of Section 8522, however, reveals that a necessary precondition to the application of any of the aforementioned exceptions is a "negligent act." 42 Pa. C.S.A. § 8522(a) (emphasis added). Actions against the State or its employees involving intentional torts are not within the scope of exceptions set out in 42 Pa. C.S.A. § 8522(a). Faust v. Com. Dept. of Revenue, 140 Pa. Commw. 389, 398, 592 A.2d 835, 839 (1991) ("Further, intentional tort claims and civil rights actions are not within the narrow exceptions set forth in 42 Pa.C.S. § 8522(b)."). Lastly, exceptions to sovereign immunity are to be strictly construed. Dean v. Com., Dept. of Transp., 561 Pa. 503, 508, 751 A.2d 1130, 1132 (2000). In the case sub judice, Plaintiff alleged that "[t]he actions of the correctional officer, sergent [sic] Macdwain, were intentional and unwarranted." (Complaint, ¶ 19). Accepting as true the facts contained in Plaintiff's complaint, Plaintiff has alleged the intentional torts of 5 assault and battery. Despite his listing of "negligence" as a claim, Plaintiff has alleged no negligent acts. He has alleged facts which sound in the nature of assault and battery. As a result, the action is not within the scope of exceptions to the general sovereign immunity provision which bars actions against the State or its employees acting within the scope of their duties. Plaintiff has, therefore, failed to state a cause of action for which sovereign immunity has been waived. For the foregoing reasons, the Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings will be granted. ORDER AND NOW, this I9' day of April, 2011, upon consideration of Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings, and the briefs submitted by the parties, Plaintiff having alleged no cause of action for which sovereign immunity has been waived, Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings is GRANTED. BY THE COURT, Kevi A. Hess, P.J. 6 1 n -Alf\ C r??r ?F ec?mc?n? Pte Cumber?a?a ???? v. D??r2r?C?[1Y1?t- + MM-MR -co usVAR 1. COMES NC?W, M?E'`n?r? ?k?,C1lRQ?1 ? '?NL-whmmt') Qcn ??sn_ N? N?4:a c?v%\ M?kdn 4= im `? .. xx' mot" c? -Um ":;O v --4° c C> M 1 • %Cc Ah\A P.er??.? or c?e_r ??? -c?n:s Cry \C?f to" p t r 1 1c&) &I \m CMc nAk Moxkton F©r QAtPl, &n !4 1,NS zo t ?ts.& aA Q\Da n? ?? ?Ltg cap--A ''i1n?-- Cdur A NtA 1 uc t, (b ? ?1erC?, n? ?r4 \ Gcc?n?,e? ???e ai??tS `5":Ao \ Nk "M? F'A2?\qfp, V-?: k TAR,- c n?P M&m ? V r% ?c,c?? \"t- 'Z w\t'\ (?ec?? sc?1 S?eh order w . Pin . Cry mpe?i5 -?r::5 c??? zo Qcoc 1 ` ??? -cy,e'_ ' ?or= N kri:Ah cL 'ckcu)\ p?rtnt \n11??'?1C?aR? , @r???:? ??u? ?ua. ???r -cc?. ??s '???e?-? I ?1??C ? e? b? -i1n seS- FoceSi Q o . Qax q?? ov .,C??i]?J ._:':iJ 4? f? : vat: j ar k'. r?? -orril; : c.s e ?e?3 ??arrS? S ?; rh,? r_tc kmil"N n:Nurk aA CnrnMCf\ Q\N? ook: 0 k ktk4 aak . I 1.L e?l?t??g Y . Pi\IAO?t?r? ck4?R?S T . P A,Lt?I1?1? c?u\ 4.???or v5 , L n4QL- VAL. \? ?1b\d SLSNt? Pta\.._p.?v`SS? ; Ear o.\ . WIN Xlib\A MA-%5 Z H a- <.a.l a."S ?"' ?w over, 1 /4? zo it w? a ,?? ' pr C Ord -•r? rf? 3 -+ rrnw rrl 3 . a) -4rrl m r c o© o orn % KC?vvSN AwWF?S,Q. S• _4 Daniel R. Goodemote Senior Deputy Attorney General Office of Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 Direct Dial: 717-783-3147 E-Mail: d?zoodemotegattomey eng eral.yov PALADINO, CHARLES, Plaintiff V. SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, SCI - Camp Hill, 2520 Lisburn Rd., Box 598, Camp Hill, PA 17001 Defendant -j "L i 0 TA , ', 7iKi\ 2"] 12 JA 2'13 A I i 1UM8ERLAt J 1?; Sri§; FEN* S "-!MANIA IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA : No. 2010-1500 CIVIL ANSWER OF COMMONWEALTH DEFENDANT TO PLAINTIFF'S BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF APPEAL This Answer is filed by the Commonwealth Defendant Superintendent John Palakovich: Plaintiff filed a Complaint against Defendant John Palakovich and Sgt. Macdwain on March 3, 2010. The Department of Corrections is not included as a party in the Complaint, nor are there any allegations against the Department in the Complaint. The Department does appear in the caption in some of Plaintiff's filings, but the Department has not been served with original process. Sgt. Macdwain has not been served and undersigned counsel has not entered his appearance on behalf of Sgt. Macdwain. A copy of the Sheriff's return of service is attached as Exhibit A. Plaintiff was informed that he had not served Sgt. Macdwain, not only by the Sheriff's Return of Service, but by the Response of the Commonwealth Defendant to Plaintiff's ' Although Plaintiff entitles his latest pleading as "Plaintiff s Brief in Support of Appeal," it appears to be in the nature of a Petition, the Court having issued a Rule to Show Cause. Therefore, the Commonwealth Defendants are treating the same as a Petition and are filing this Answer in response. Motion to Order Defendant's [sic] to Respond to Complaint. A copy of this document is attached as Exhibit B. All subsequent filings, including the Commonwealth Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings have been filed on behalf of Superintendent John Palakovich only. Defendant Palakovich's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings was granted on April 19, 2011. 2. Admitted that the Order of this Court dated April 19, 2011, did not specifically state that the case was dismissed or that Plaintiff had thirty days to appeal. Defendant Palakovich knows of no rule or decision requiring the Court to include such language in its order. 3. Admitted only that Plaintiff filed a Notice of Appeal dated October 7, 2011. After reasonable investigation, Defendant Palakovich does not have sufficient knowledge or information as to the extent of the personal knowledge of the Plaintiff. 4. Because Plaintiff failed to serve Defendant Macdwain and proceeded with his action against Defendant Palakovich, Defendant Palakovich contends that the Order of this Court dated April 19, 2011 is a final order. By rule of court, Plaintiff is permitted thirty days after the entry of a final order in which to file a Notice of Appeal. He failed to do so. WHEREFORE, Defendant Palokovich respectfully requests this Honorable Court to deny Plaintiff's petition to have his appeal rights reinstated nunc pro tunc. Respectfully submitted, Linda L. Kelly Attorney General By: D iel R. Goodioode?mo`ft' Senior Deputy Attorney General Supreme Court No. 30986 EXHIBIT "A" SHERIFF'S OFFICE OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY LED-GpICE Ronny R Anderson ()F ?HE PP07j^.?,)Tgg1f Sheriff 0? Ot C?NfibTf/Qry ?titr Jody S smith 2310 MM 23 M;; $ ! 4 Chief Deputy ,wF ri Edward L Schorpp .n. cullv? Solicitor OFFICE OF THE SHERIFF i Charles T. Paladino vs. Sergeant Macdwain (et al.) Case Number 2010-1500 RETURN OF SERVICE 03/18/2010 03:38 PM - Michelle Gutsha I, Deputy Sheriff, who being duly sworn according to law, states that on Mara 18, 2010 at 1515 hours, she served a true copy of the within Complaint and Notice, upon the within named defendant, to wit, John A. P lakovich, by making known unto Bill Fairall, Deputy Chief Counsel for SCI Camp Hill, 55 Utley Drive, Camp Hill, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17011 its contents and at the same time handing to him pBrsonally the said true and correct copy of s 1 . ICH DEPUTY 03/19/2010 Ronny R. Anderson, Sheriff who being duly sworn according to law, states that he made a diligent search and inquiry for the within named aefendant to wit: Sergeant Macdwain, but was unable to locate him in hit bailiwick. He therefore returns the within Complaint and Notice as not found as to the defendant Sergeant Macdwain. The Pennsylvania Department of Corrections does not have any record of a Sergeant Macdwain being employed 'In any of their offices. March 19, 2010 SO ANSWERS, FON R ANDERSON, SHERIFF (r; CouotySuae Jner`t le'eosott. hl.• . EXHIBIT "B" Daniel R. Goodemote Senior Deputy Attorney General Office of Attorney General Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 Direct Dial: 717-783-3147 E-Mail: dyoodemoteLa?attorneygeneral.gov PALADINO, CHARLES, Plaintiff V. SUPT. JOHN PALAKOVICH, DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS, SCI - Camp Hill, 2520 Lisburn Rd., Box 598, Camp Hill, PA 17001 Defendant RLEO-Di FJSE ?T T! c P." GARY 2010 APR 23 PM 3: 26 CUMP } ::_-` ;"';l?ylY PE tce&U1XM IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA No. 2010-1500 CIVIL RESPONSE OF COMMONWEALTH DEFENDANT TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO ORDER DEFENDANT'S /SIC1 TO RESPOND TO COMPLAINT Defendant Supt. John Palakovich (Commonwealth Defendant) files this response to Plaintiff's Motion to Order D ''? [sic] to Respond to Complaint: 11 1. Admitted. 2. Admitted the Defendant Palakovich was served. Defendant Macdwain has not been served. 3. The relief requested by Plaintiff is improper and not authorized by the Pennsylvania Rules q ivil Pr ? , , ,dare. WHEREFORE, the Commonwealth Defendant, Palakovich respectfully requests this Honorable Court to deny Plaintiffs motion. Respectfully submitted, Thomas W. Corbett, Jr. Attorney General By aniel Goode _o Senior Deputy Attorney General Supreme Court No. 30986 VERIFICATION The facts set forth in this Response of Commonwealth Defendant to Plaintiff's Motion to Order Defendant's [SIC] To Respond to Complaint are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. This statement is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. §4904 relating to unsworn falsifications to aniel R. iooi Dated: April 20, 2010 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving the foregoing document(s) upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below: SERVICE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL POSTAGE PREPAID ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS: Charles Paladino (Pro Se Plaintiff) SCI-Forest Box No. 945 Marienville, PA 16239 B) Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 717-783-3147 - Direct Dial DATED: April 20, 2010 Supreme Court No. 30986 Senior Deputy Attorney General VERIFICATION The facts set forth in this Answer of Commonwealth Defendant to Plaintiff's Brief in Support ol'Appeal are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. This statement is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. §4904 relating to unworn falsifications to authorities. Respectfully submitted, LINDA L. KELLY Attorney General By: Daniel R. Goodemote Senior Deputy Attorney General Supreme Court No. 30986 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving the foregoing document(s) upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below: SERVICE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL POSTAGE PREPAID ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS: Charles Paladino (Pro Se Plaintiff) SCI-Forest Box No. 945 Marienville, PA 16239 By: Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 717-783-3147 - Direct Dial Daniel R. Goodemote Supreme Court No. 30986 Senior Deputy Attorney General DATED: November 17, 2011 VERIFICATION The facts set forth in this Answer of Commonwealth Defendant to Plaintiff's Brief in Support of Appeal are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. This statement is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. §4904 relating to unsworn falsifications to authorities. aniel R. Goodemo Senior Deputy Attorney General Supreme Court No. 30986 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving the foregoing document(s) upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below: SERVICE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL POSTAGE PREPAID ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS: Charles Paladino (Pro Se Plaintiff) SCI-Forest Box No. 945 Marienville, PA 16239 Torts Litigation Section 15th Floor, Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 717-783-3147 - Direct Dial DATED: November 17, 2011 Senior Deputy Attorney General C') N r? ?r Cis C.1 N ?l . yb?N ??c?t?Cs? rrl cil c " ?- H?l ZorZ f czM? v?p? pt?zs..rC+ ?D R Z s, M"g© t UN\ .tom ? ?N D • t 04 r't ?i.\('? t? ? ???1c.?DR F' iCiC 13? ? a Q:` s''y? . G `'•.` A ,? (? . Gocaern©4el T% -\k? t. OW\ nF Li?rht?FWJ?a,Yp C.LivN`S `t ?Nt?fS 'C . PP?\AbT.N?, cSvZ\.. ?ti??? V. U Sk tk6, VSbb- ab\D MD,CS?bN F0?1, o'E'Ew??-c' -S ?Of?M?rt P\r????,?'; C.?.??.0.1?5 Q?pbil?s,???e?a.Z oec\nceS :i a?n ?r\,?.. P.\a,,rit.LL \ne,.cc.?r.. "MC ?..DM?s??A?c h?.CZ.?R uJcaS F?\P? ?t? 'Mc?.YC? '?cA?c?\b• n? . zotsot c kLiscd ?nece.? ShD%LN \-\\a ?t.Q. 4.ocwc 1c?\e. -s., lost- Cur , &tc &O?t%A 4tNt rOw a kJah \ , ar htj v?9 Mott Sr\nat\ Ab baais \^wit- ?\c.J?St.a s.c?ea '+cv+- aoke on u?vi?c? \4.t. AtAtAaa As ?-atst. ?%t mes e_c\ -k-a C' A %r t, So.?c\. e A?v . ?]\cficr?t `_? rn? ,aR ?rca ce??n rs ? 4??5 n. \ c,L BAs Nom Pcb'i? .? cc ?rvz n ct y pF p _. uec\ns? uROGC Qe?%1 oX pe c icy ??•c?.? W* ?bc ,Ay ? s J&lt CoA Mb kt \c ? Es\v?r??t?,?eS o.??l.,ta1 t LQ?n?t`a bt Ce,??,p?tt.? ?1Ut?` eco'Cur?C ?ec?c ?.??c?.r.?e'a ?va'iuf? 1r? :P„???h?. Ocr &- t,?ONcM[secc A'&; 3D\\ . flo C tai . KS pQ13? Sc3: foCts\ , Q, h , QSnx qy? Meati.enV ?\1.P. , QA . \1a 2?.??j 0 S4 S ecv i LP-- ac 'Cc?? c.?v? ???ceu? ??cc? Sew v?ci ?'.cS?k c?raS3 Mca? ?'c? ?:'?? ?t Q??OLU?h? O?'? `??CaV?t11?C1?? d.'6*, t ALA\ • c-3c\ t c.fIkt C..tan~ E'\ ur= nm,%Ct- ok she i u?c`rono'ta??? IL w"mss\ck ull"It wur ?,se b,(\e. CDUrtlrwvSti. S?c?Xt- ? 5\t. \m C rm.'s-; t --? C1at ?fiM? a1' s ua?'C?cs1 c.?nasrbtr5 L t??xt\4?'? Pry. , 1 c), \'As Sergi\ac o?a?c•k a?oM?.y Cae?Ccat ytCca?,i??o?CC.y ?r?u,.c? 1Sa?. E\ot?c 11oSC??;?oucy, Cott. \°}?d.,t? takt-, v\hm--matr aB4, aa11. 6 ;?