HomeMy WebLinkAbout01-2269ESTATE OF DONNA SNYDER ADAMS,: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
Plaintiff : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v. : NO.
JOHN P. SULLIVAN,
Defendant
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRAECIPE FOR WRIT OF SUMMONS
Please issue a Writ of Summons in the above case. Upon completion of same,
please forward the Writ of Summons to the Cumberland County Sheriff to deputize the
Lycoming County Sheriff to serve the Writ on Defendant, John P. Sullivan, who currently
resides at 84 Broad Street, Montgomery, PA 17752.
The address for Plaintiff, The Estate of Donna Snyder Adams, is c/o Billie Noctor,
Administratrix, 32 South Main Street, Marysville, PA 17053.
Respectfully Subbed,
WIX, WENGE~/~, WEIDNER
B,,~te~en/~. Williams, i.D~ ~62051
~/ 508 NOrth Second Street
P.O. Box 845
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0845
(717) 234-4182
Attorneys for Plaintiff
F:~srw\0085 (ADAMS, DONNA & JOHN)\1 t090 (V. SULLIVAN)\DOCUMENTS\WRIT OF SUMMONS.doc 4/17/01
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
County of Cumberland
ESTATE OF DONNA SNYDER ADAMS
c/o Billie Nocto~ Administratrix
32 South Main Street
MaIysville, PA 17053
JOHN P. SULLIVAN
84 Broad Street
Mostgomery, PA 17752
Court of Common Plea~
To ____J~n.v_ R.~__%uA!i_v_a.n_ ......................
You are hereby notified that
....... ~s_ _e _a_e_e_ _ ?_f_ _ _r~_ _np~ _ _S_ny_ct_e_ _r_ _ _~_ _ _mr? .........................................................
the Plaintiff has commenced an action in ........ C~-YiO--~cJ2J-~rl---~J-a'g--~- ........................
against you which you are required to defend or a default judgment may be entered against
(SEAL)
P
POST & SCHELL, P.C.
BY: AMY L. CORYER, ESQUIRE
I.D. # 82718
240 GRANDVIEW AVENUE
CAMP HILL, PA 17011
(717) 731-1970
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT
JOHN P. SULLIVAN
ESTATE OF DONNA SNYDER ADAMS
c/o Billie Noctor Administratrix
JOHN P. SULLIVAN
Plaintiff,
Defendant.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON
PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 01-2269
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
Kindly enter my appearance on behalf of Defendant, John P. Sullivan, in connection with the
above-referenced matter.
Respectfully submitted,
POST & SCHELL, P.C.
DATE:
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Kelley A. Spangler, an employee of Post & Schell, P.C. do hereby certify that on the date
listed below, I did serve a tree and correct copy of the foregoing document upon the following
person(s) at the following address(es) by sending same via United States mail, first-class, postage
prepaid:
Steven R. Williams, Esquire
508 North Second Street
P.O. Box 845
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0845
DATE:
Kelley A. Sl~angler-- E/
SHERIFF'S RETURN
CASE NO: 2001-02269 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
ADAMS DONNA SNYDER ESTATE OF
VS
SULLIVAN JOHN P
- OUT OF COUNTY
R. Thomas Kline ,
duly sworn according to law, says, that he made a diligent
and inquiry for the within named DEFENDANT , to wit:
SULLIVAN JOHN P
but was unable to locate Him in his bailiwick.
deputized the sheriff of MONTGOMERY County,
serve the within WRIT OF SUMMONS
Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff who being
search and
He therefore
Pennsylvania, to
On May
25th , 2001 , this office was in receipt of the
attached return from MONTGOMERY
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing
Out of County
Surcharge
Dep, Lycoming Co
9.00 ~
10.00 ~ R.
31.50 S~f of Cumberland County
,00
68.B0
o5/25/2ool
WIX, WENGER & WEIDNER
Sworn and subscribed to before me
this 7~ day of
...3~! A.D.
Prothonotary
~n The Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania
Estate of Donna Syder Adams et. al.
John P. Sullivan
N0.0]-2269 Civi]
NOW, 4/19/01
,20 O ~}, I, SHERIFF OF CUMBERLAND COLFNT¥, PA, do
hereby deputize the Sheriff of Lycoming
County to execute this Writ, this
deputation being made at the reque~ and risk of the Plaintiff.
Sheriff of Cumberiand Count'y, P A
Affidavit of Service
7Now, MAY 4, ,2001 , at 9:40 o'clock A. IV{. served the
within WRIT OF SUMMONS
%IpOI1 JOHN P. SULLIVAN
at 84 BROAD STREET, MONTGOMERY, LYCOMING COUNTY, PA.
by handing to MIKE FOUST,
a TRUE AND ATTESTED
and made known to HIM
Step Father,
copy of the original
WRIT OF SUMMONS
the contents t2aereof.
Sworn and subscribed before
inet;his 23 dayof MAy ,20 ol
31.50 PAID
43.50 REFUND
ESTATE OF DONNA
SNYDER ADAMS,
Plaintiff
JOHN P. SULLIVAN, :
Defendant :
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 01-2269 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 25th day of July, 2002, upon consideration of Plaintiff Billie J.
Noctor, Administratrix of the Estate of Donna Snyder Adams's Motion To compel
completion of Settlement, a Rule is hereby issued upon Donald Snyder to show cause
why the relief requested should not be granted.
RULE RETURNABLE at a hearing scheduled for Monday, October 14, 2002, at
9:30 a.m., in Courtroom No. 1, Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle, Pennsylvania
Steven R. Williams, Esq.
508 North Second Street
P.O. Box 845
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0845
Attorney for Plaintiff
Scott W. Morgan, Esq.
120 South Street
Harrisburg, PA 17101
Donald Snyder
341 W. 17th Avenue
Apache Junction, AZ 85220
BY THE COURT,
J~pgesley Oler~j,~ -- J.
'1-3o , o.~
ESTATE OF DONNA SNYDER ADAMS,: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
Plaintiff : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
JOHN P. SULLIVAN,
Defendant
: NO, 01-2269 CIVIL TERM
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
: JURYTRIAL DEMANDED
MOTION TO COMPEL COMPLETION OF SE'I-rLEMENT
AND NOW, comes Plaintiff, Billie J. Noctor, Administratrix of the Estate of Donna
Snyder Adams, by and through her attorneys, Wix, Wenger & Weidner, and files this
Motion to Compel Completion of Settlement, stating the following:
1. Plaintiff is Billie J. Noctor, who was appointed Administratrix of the Estate of Donna
Snyder Adams (herein, "Decedent") by the Registrar of Wills of Perry County,
Pennsylvania on January 17, 2001.
2. Decedent died on January 3, 2001 as the result of an automobile accident on
December 25, 2000 (herein, the "Accident").
3. In addition to the instant case, the case of Donald Snyder, individually and as
Parent and Guardian of Christopher Snyder, Ryan Snyder and Jessica Snyder,
Minors v. John P. Sullivan and Frank J. Sullivan, No. 01-3259 Civil Term (herein,
the "Donald Snyder Case") is pending in this Court. The Donald Snyder Case
involves claims of the minor children of Donna Snyder Adams (herein, the "Minor
Children") for injuries they sustained in the Accident.
4. The Minor Children are beneficiaries of the Estate and have an interest in the
settlement of this case separate and apart from their interest in the Donald Snyder
Case.
5. There are three insurance companies (herein collectively, the "Insurers") who are
responsible to provide coverage for the injuries and death resulting from the
Accident: USAA, Allstate Insurance and Motorists Insurance Companies (herein,
"Motorists"), Decedent's insurance carrier.
6. In or about November 2001, the parties in this and the Donald $nyder Case and
the Insurers all agreed to settle all claims related to the Accident. The agreed upon
settlement provided that the Insurers would pay the total amount of $120,000 to the
Estate of Donna Snyder in this case as follows:
USAA $100,000
Allstate $ 5,000
Motorists $15,000
Once the all parties and the Insurers agreed upon the settlement terms, the
undersigned prepared for filing with this Court a Petition for Approval of Settlement
of Wrongful Death and Survival Actions (herein, the "Petition") to obtain Court
approval of the Estate's settlement of this case. A true and correct copy of the
Petition (without exhibits) is attached hereto as Exhibit A and is incorporated herein
by reference as if fully set forth.
2
14. The Release is a standard Release, identical in terms to a release that Donald
Snyder has signed in order to obtain settlement funds from Motorists that are
payable directly to the Minor Children, outside of the Estate.
15. Plaintiff and John Adams have signed the Release, but Donald Snyder has refused
to sign and/or provide the signed Release to the undersigned. A true and correct
copy of the Release is attached hereto as Exhibit D and is incorporated herein by
reference as if fully set forth.
16. As a result, Motorists has not paid the $15,000 it is obligated to pay to the Estate.
17. Despite at least three (unanswered) letters to Nora F. Blair, Esquire, Donald
Snyder's current attorney, Donald Snyder has refused to sign and/or deliver the
signed Release because he now objects to the manner of distribution of the
settlement proceeds to the Estate.
18. Specifically, Donald Snyder objects to the Plaintiff, who is the Administratrix of the
Estate and the grandmother of the Minor Children, serving as the trustee of the
Minor Children's share of the settlement funds that are paid into, and become part
of, the Estate.
19. At no time prior to Motorists providing the Release (which was after the approval of
this settlement by this Court and after USAA and Allstate had already paid their
portions of the settlement funds to Plaintiff) did Donald Snyder object to any aspect
of this Settlement.
4
20. Donald Snyder's objection to the settlement and refusal to sign and/or deliver the
signed Release has no basis in fact or law, is not warranted and constitutes bad
faith.
21. Notwithstanding his apparent objections, Donald Snyder has taken no action with
regard to the Order or this settlement, other than his unjustified refusal to sign and
deliver the Release to the undersigned.
22. Plaintiff seeks an order compelling Donald Snyder to sign and provide the Release
to the undersigned so the Estate can collect the remainder of the settlement
proceeds in this case from Motorists.
23. Based on prior discussions with Donald Snyder's attorneys, the undersigned
represents that Donald Snyder does not concur in this Motion.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests that this Honorable Court grant this
Motion and order Donald Snyder to sign and deliver the Release to the undersigned and
grant such other relief as this Court deems just and appropriate.
Respectfully S u b~;;~d,
WIX, WEN~ WEIDNER
508 North Second Street
P.O. Box 845
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0845
(717) 234-4182
~ll~,J0~_~, Attorneys for Plaintiff
Date:
F:',srw~0085 (ADAMS, DONNA & JOHN)\11090 (V. SULLIVAN) - GENERAL\DOCUMENTS~MOTION TO COMPELdoc
5
EXHIBIT A
JOHN P. SULLIVAN,
Defendant
ESTATE OF DONNA SNYDER ADAMS,: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
Plaintiff : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
:
: NO. 01-2269 CIVIL TERM
:
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ORDER
AND NOW, this__ day of ,2001, upon consideration of the
attached Petition for Approval of Settlement of Wrongful Death and Survival Actions, it
is hereby ORDERED and DECREED that Petitioner is authorized to enter into the
settlement set forth in the Petition in the gross amount of $120,000.00, and that the
settlement proceeds shall be distributed as follows:
To: Wix, Wenger & Weidner, attorneys at law,
for counsel fees $ 40,000.00
To: Wix, Wenger & Weidner, attorneys at law,
for reimbursement of costs $ 590.00
The balance of the settlement is apportioned as follows:
Wrongful Death Action: $19,852.50
Survival Action $59,557.50
The wrongful death action proceeds shall be paid as follows:
To: John Adams, spouse $ 9,926.25
To: Billie J. Noctor, grandmother,
as trustee for the minor
beneficiary, Christopher Snyder $ 3,308.75
To: Biliie J. Noctor, grandmother,
as trustee for the minor
beneficiary, Ryan Snyder $ 3,308.75
To: Billie J. Noctor, grandmother,
as trustee for the minor
beneficiary, Jessica Snyder $ 3,308.75
The survival action proceeds in the amount of $59,557.50
shall be paid to Billie J. Noctor, Administratrix of the Estate of Donna Snyder Adams,
deceased, and the net proceeds of the settlement to be distributed to the minor
beneficiaries from the Estate shaft be payable to Biilie J. Noctor, grandmother, as
trustee for the said minor beneficiaries. The Administratrix shall comply with 20 Pa.C.S.
§ 3323(b)(3).
Petitioner is authorized to execute the settlement agreements/releases
referenced in and attached to her Petition for Approval of Settlement of Wrongful Death
and Survival Actions.
By the Court:
ESTATE OF DONNA SNYDER ADAMS
Plaintiff
JOHN P. SULLIVAN,
Defendant
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 01-2269 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PETITION FOR APPROVAL OF SETTLEMENT OF
WRONGFUL DEATH AND SURVIVAL ACTIONS
AND NOW, comes Petitioner, Billie J. Noctor, Administratrix of the Estate of
Donna Snyder Adams, by and through her attorneys, Wix, Wenger & Weidner, and files
this Petition for Approval of Settlement of Wrongful Death and Survival Actions, stating
the following:
1. Petitioner is Biliie J. Ndctor, who was appointed Administratrix of the Estate of
Donna Snyder Adams (herein, "Decedent") by the Registrar of Wills of Perry
County, Pennsylvania on January 17, 2001. A Short Certificate, evidencing the
grant of Letters of Administration to her is attached hereto as Exhibit A and is
incorporated herein by reference.
2. Decedent died on January 3, 2001 as the result of an automobile accident on
December 25, 2000 (herein, the "Accident"). A true and correct copy of the police
report of the Accident is attached hereto as Exhibit B and is incorporated herein by
reference as if fully set forth. A true and correct copy of Decedent's death
certificate is attached hereto as Exhibit C and is incorporated herein by reference
as if fully set forth.
3. Decedent did not have a will.
4. From December 25, 2000 until her death on January 3, 2001, Decedent was in the
Hershey Medical Center intensive care unit. Until approximately three days before
her death, Decedent was in and out of consciousness and mostly aware of her
setting.
5. In addition to the instant case, the case of Donald Snyder, individually and as
Parent and Guardian of Christopher Snyder, Ryan Snyder and Jessica Snyder,
Minors v. John P. Sullivan and Frank J. Sullivan, No. 01-3259 Civil Term (herein,
the "Donald Snyder Case") is pending in this Court. The Donald Snyder Case
involves claims of the minor children of Donna Snyder Adams for injuries they
sustained in the Accident.
.6. There are three insurance companies (herein collectively, the "insurers") who have
been identified as being responsible to provide coverage for the injuries and death
resulting from the Accident: USAA, one of the Defendant's insurance carriers, has
tendered its policy limits of $100,000 per individual claim/S200,000 per aggregate
claim; Allstate Insurance, another of Defendant's insurance carriers, has tendered
its policy limits of $25,000 per individual claim/S50,000 per aggregate claim; and
Motorists Insurance Companies, Decedent's insurance carrier, has tendered its
underinsured motorists limits of $15,000 per individual claim/S30,000 per aggregate
claim. The cumulative proceeds available from the Insurers for the Accident is
$140,000 per individual claim/S280,000 per aggregate claim.
7. The following settlement has been agreed upon, subject to Court approval,
between the insurers, Defendants and Plaintiffs in the instant case and the Donald
2
SnyderCase: The Insurers will pay to the Estate of Donna Snyder the total amount
of $120,000.00. (The Insurers will pay to Donald Snyder, in trust for the minor
plaintiffs in the Donald Snyder Case the total amount of $160,000.)
8. Upon approval of this settlement, Petitioner will be required to execute settlement
agreements/releases discharging Defendant and his liability and under insured
motorists insurance carriers from any further liability relating to the Accident and
this case. True and correct copies of the settlement agreements/releases from tow
of the Insurers and a letter from the third Insurer are attached hereto as Exhibit D
and are incorporated herein by reference as if fully set forth.
9. The undersigned counsel for Petitioner is of the professional opinion that the
proposed settlement is reasonable and fair for the following reasons: First, the
settlement of Petitioner's claim and of the claims in the Donald Snyder Case will
exhaust the only insurance proceeds available to pay the claims. Second,
Defendant, John P. Sullivan does not appear to have any other assets sufficient to
pay a verdict over and above the available insurance proceeds. Third, this
settlement will result in payments to the Estate in excess of 85% of the maximum
amount of insurance proceeds that could be recovered by the Estate under any
circumstances. Fourth, absent this settlement, the claims of Petitioner and of the
three minor plaintiffs in the Donald SnyderCase would be interpleaded, possibly
resulting in a lesser amount being awarded to the Estate of Donna Snyder Adams
by the Insurers.
10. Petitioner is of the opinion that the settlement is reasonable and fair.
3
11. Counsel for Petitioner has incurred expenses in this case, for which reimbursement
is sought, in the total amount of $590.00 as set forth on Exhibit E hereof, which is
incorporated herein by reference as if fully set forth.
12. Counsel for Petitioner requests attorney's fees in the amount of $40,000.00, which
represents one-third (33 1/3%) of the gross proceeds of this settlement. A true and
correct copy of Counsel's Contingent Fee Agreement with the Estate of Donna
Snyder Adams is attached hereto as Exhibit F and is incorporated herein by
reference as if fully set forth.
13. Petitioner requests allocation of the net proceeds of the settlement, after deduction
of costs and attorney's fees, as follows:
Wrongful Death Action
Survival Action
$19,852.50, or 25%
$59,557.50, or 75%
14. The reasons for this suggested allocation are as follows: At the time of Decedent's
death, she was not working and was not contributing substantially to the income of
the income and household expenses of her spouse and children. It was not
expected that Decedent would substantially contribute financially to her family and
household expenses in the near future. In the Accident and throughout her care
until her death, Decedent experienced great pain and suffering. Thus, the greater
portion of this settlement is being allocated to the survival action to compensate for
Decedent's injuries, pain and suffering, and ultimate death.
1 5. Petitioner has sought and obtained approval of this settlement and the proposed
allocation from the Pennsylvania Department of Revenue. A true' and correct copy
4
of the Department of Revenue's correspondbnce is attached hereto as Exhibit G
and is incorporated herein by reference as if fully set forth.
16. Pursuant to 42 Pa.C.S. § 8301, the beneficiaries of the wrongful death action and
their respective interests are as follows:
NAME
John R. Adams
Christopher Snyder
Ryan Snyder
Jessica Snyder
RELATIONSHIP BIRTH DATE AMOUNT
TO DECEDENT OF MINORS
Husband 50%
Son 12/13/86 1/6
Son 5/1/90 1/6
Daughter 7/6/91 1/6
17. The pecuniary loss suffered by the wrongful death beneficiaries is recognizable and
is described as follows: The Decedent, although not gainfully employed at the time
of the Accident, nevertheless contributed to the financial well-being of her family by
virtue of her functions as a Wife and mother; further, there is a reasonable
expectation that the Decedent would have resumed gainful employment during her
marriage and the minority of her children, thereby contributing to their financial well-
being.
18. The Department of Public Welfare has no lien against the Decedent or any of the
wrongful death beneficiaries. True and correct copies of DPW's correspondence
are attached hereto as Exhibit H and are incorporated herein by reference as if fully
set forth.
5
19. There are no ott~er liens or claims against the proceeds of this action or against the
Decedent's estate, other than the customary expenses of estate administration.
20. The wrongful death beneficiaries consent to the settlement and distribution set forth
herein. True and correct copies of the correspondence from Melissa Merritts
Rivera, counsel for the guardian of the minor beneficiaries, and John Snyder, a
beneficiary, are attached hereto as Exhibit I and incorporated herein by reference
as if fully set forth.
WHEREFORE, Petitioner respectfully requests that this Honorable Court
approve this Settlement and the allocation and distribution of the proceeds as set forth
herein.
DATE:
Respectfully S/~tted,
WIX, WEN,~//~ ~EIDNER
P.O. Box 845
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0845
(717) 234-4182
Attorneys for Petitioner
F:\sr-,v\0085 (ADAMS, DONNA & JOHN)\11090 (V. SULLIVAN)\DOCUMENTS\SE~f'LEMENT PETITION.doc
6
EXHIBIT B
Morgan Morgan, P.C,
AT TOI~ N ~ y S AT LAW
Scott W. Morgan*
Thomas A. Wilken
Melissa Merritts Rivera
120 South Street
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17101
(717) 236-7959
Fax (717) 231-7436
www. mm-pc-law, com
Direct e-mail: mrar~nun-pc-law.com
Chambersburg Office
Suite 309
14 N. Main Street
Chambersburg, PA 17201
(717) 263-5607
Lebanon: (717) 270-8827
Carlisle: (717) 258-4313
FACSIMILE NO.:234-4224
Steven Williams, Esquire
508 North Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17101
November 26, 2001
Re: Snyder v. Sullivan, et al.
Dear Steve:
This will confrrm receipt of your November 8, 2001 and November 21, 2001
correspondence regarding the above captioned matter. Enclosed please find a copy of our
Petition to Seek Court Approval of Minor's Settlement. As you can see, in paragraph 8
Plaintiffs state that they are in agreement with the proceeds being paid to the Estate. Please feel
free to attach our document to your petition.
Regarding the filing of each of our petitions, I am concerned about the lack of
correspondence from Motorist Mutual officially tendering the UIM limits. Further, Motorist
Mutual has never provided us with a definitive answer regarding storage fees, if any. I spoke
with Ms. Mugfidge prior to the Thanksgiving holiday, and she agreed to provide me with a letter
immediately, so that we may file our petitions. To date, I have not received a letter from her.
Please advise me if you have such a letter from Ms. Mugridge. Thank you.
Very truly yours,
Enclosure
3. At the time of the accident, Christopher Snyder was 14 years old, Ryan Snyder
was 10 years old, and Jessica Snyder was 9 years old.
4. As a result of the accident, Christopher Snyder suffered injuries in the nature
of a broken femur of the left leg and a broken thumb on the right hand, braised spleen, liver and
kidney.
5. Jessica sustained an injmy to her head which involved scalp repair and brain
damage. The right side motor skills were affected, as well as her speech. She also sustained a
broken left femur.
6. Ryan sustained a broken right clavicle and right wrist. He sustained a serious
injury to his head, including a shattered forehead and brain damage, which involved a partial
lobectomy. Attached to this petition are Exhibits A - I, medical reports outlining the diagnosis,
treatment and prognosis for each child.
7. Minor Plaintiffs Christopher Snyder, Jessica Snyder and Ryan Snyder have
substantially recovered from the above injuries.
8. Defendants, through their liability insurance companies, AllState and USAA,
have agreed to pay $145,000.00 to the three children in exchange for a general release. The
under insured motorist company, Motorist Mutual Insurance, has agreed to pay $ t 5,000.00 to the
children, in exchange for a general release, for a total of $160,000.00 to be divided among the
three minor children. The remaining $120,000.00 in policy limits is being paid to the Estate of
their mother, Diane Snyder Adams, who died as a result of this automobile accident. The
children will receive a portion of the proceeds which will go to the Estate. Plaintiffs are in
agreement with the funds .being paid to the Estate.
9. The settlement is beneficial to each Plaintiffbecause (1) most medical bills
EXHIBIT C
ESTATE OF DONNA SNYDER ADAMS,: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
Plaintiff : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
:
v. : NO. 01-2269 CIVIL TERM
JOHN P. SULLIVAN,
Defendant
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ORDER
AND NOW, this"'~,~.~ day of ~O'~LLG'.~ ~3"1-, upon consideration ofthe
attached Petition for Approval of Settlement of Wrongful Death and Survival Actions, it
is hereby ORDERED and DECREED that Petitioner is authorized to enter into the
settlement set forth in the Petition in the gross amount of $120,000.00, and that the
settlement proceeds shall be distributed as follows:
To: Wix, Wenger & Weidner, attorneys at law,
for counsel fees $ 40,000.00
To: Wix, Wenger & Weidner, attorneys at law,
for reimbursement of costs $ 590.00
The balance of the settlement is apportioned as follows:
Wrongful Death Action: $19,852.50
Survival Action $59,557.50
The wrongful death action proceeds shall be paid as follows:
To: John Adams, spouse $ 9,926.25
To: Billie J. Noctor, grandmother,
as trustee for the minor
beneficiary, Christopher Snyder $ 3,308.75
To: Billie J. Noctor, grandmother,
as trustee for the minor
beneficiary, Ryan Snyder $ 3,308.75
To: Billie J. Noctor, grandmother,
as trustee for the minor
beneficiary, Jessica Snyder $ 3,308.75
The survival action proceeds in the amount of $59,557.50
shall be paid to Billie J. Noctor, Administratrix of the Estate of Donna Snyder Adams,
deceased, and the net proceeds of the settlement to be distributed to the minor
beneficiaries from the Estate shall be payable to Billie J. Noctor, grandmother, as
trustee for the said minor beneficiaries. The Administratrix shall comply with 20 Pa.C.S.
§ 3323(b)(3).
Petitioner is authorized to execute the settlement agreements/releases
referenced in and attached to her Petition for Approval of Settlement of Wrongful Death
and Survival Actions.
~ ~.,~.~,~; COPY F~O~4 RECORD
In T~siimo~',/ ~,~'~:t~, ~ ' ' ~.'~t,o set my ha~
Jo
EXHIBIT D
WE warrant WE have fully disclosed and forwarded to Motorists Mutual Insurance
Company all papers and ~nfonnation relative to this claim. This includes without
limitation, all policies of liability insurance which might apply to this accident, the assets
liable for this accident, and all records and reports relative to OUR claim.
We have read this Underinsured Motorist Release, understand its contents, and sign it this
day of , .
Witnesses:
Billie $.dffoctor as Administratrix of the
Estate of Donna Snyder Adams and as
trustee for beneficiaries Christopher Snyder,
/sd Je~qca Snyder I ~
Donald Snyder as legal guardian of
Ryan Snyder, Jessica Snyder and
Christopher Snyder
Any person who knowingly and with intent to defraud any insurance company or other
person files an application for insurance or statement of claim containing any materially
false information or conceals for the purpose of misleading, information concerning any
fact material thereto commits a fraudulent insurance act, which is a crime and subjects
such person to criminal and civil penalties.
Page 2 of 2
ESTATE OF DONNA SNYDER ADAMS,
Plaintiff
V#
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
:
: NO. 01-2269 CIVIL TERM
JOHN P. SULLIVAN,
Defendant
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the foregoing Motion to Compel Completion of Settlement was mailed
via first class mail, postage prepaid, this day to the following:
Scott W. Morgan, Esquire
Morgan & Morgan
120 South Street
Harrisburg, PA 17101
Nora F. Blair, Esquire
5440 Jonestown Road
Harrisburg, PA 17112
Respectfully Submitted,
WIX, WENGER & WEIDNER
Date:
Alison Zortman, LegaDAssistant
508 North Second Street
P.O. Box 845
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0845
(717) 234-4182
Attorneys for Plaintiff
JOHN P. SULLIVAN,
Defendant
ESTATE OF DONNA SNYDER ADAMS,: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
Plaintiff : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
: NO. 01-2269 CIVIL TERM
:
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ORDER
~{~ Zoo7_
AND NOW, this. 7.. day of ~ Z. rt ~ z,-~ , ~, upon consideration of the
attached Petition for Approval of Settlement of Wrongful Death and Survival Actions, it
is hereby ORDERED and DECREED that Petitioner is authorized to enter into the
settlement set forth in the Petition in the gross amount of $120,000.00, and that the
settlement proceeds shall be distributed as follows:
To: Wix, Wenger & Weidner, attorneys at law,
for counsel fees $ 40,000.00
To: Wix, Wenger & Weidner, attorneys at law,
for reimbursement of costs $ 590.00
The balance of the settlement is apportioned as follows:
Wrongful Death Action: $19,852.50
Survival Action $59,557.50
The wrongful death action proceeds shall be paid as follows:
To: John Adams, spouse $ 9,926.25
To: Billie J. Noctor, grandmother,
as trustee for the minor
beneficiary, Christopher Snyder $ 3,308.75
To: Billie J. Noctor, grandmother,
as trustee for the minor
beneficiary, Ryan Snyder $ 3,308.75
To: Billie J. Noctor, grandmother,
as trustee for the minor
beneficiary, Jessica Snyder $ 3,308.75
The survival action proceeds in the amount of $59,557.50
shall be paid to Billie J. Noctor, Administratrix of the Estate of Donna Snyder Adams,
deceased, and the net proceeds of the settlement to be distributed to the minor
beneficiaries from the Estate shall be payable to Billie J. Noctor, grandmother, as
trustee for the said minor beneficiaries. The Administratrix shall comply with 20 Pa.C.S.
§ 3323(b)(3).
Petitioner is authorized to execute the settlement agreements/releases
referenced in and attached to her Petition for Approval of Settlement of Wrongful Death
and Survival Actions.
By the Court:
JOHN P. SULLIVAN,
Defendant
ESTATE OF DONNA SNYDER ADAMS,: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
Plaintiff : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
:
: NO. 01-2269 CIVIL TERM
:
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PETITION FOR APPROVAL OF SETTLEMENT OF
WRONGFUL DEATH AND SURVIVAL ACTIONS
AND NOW, comes Petitioner, Billie J. Noctor, Administratrix of the Estate of
Donna Snyder Adams, by and through her attorneys, Wix, Wenger & Weidner, and files
this Petition for Approval of Settlement of Wrongful Death and Survival Actions, stating
the following:
1. Petitioner is Billie J. Noctor, who was appointed Administratrix of the Estate of
Donna Snyder Adams (herein, "Decedent") by the Registrar of Wills of Perry
County, Pennsylvania on January 17, 2001. A Short Certificate, evidencing the
grant of Letters of Administration to her is attached hereto as Exhibit A and is
incorporated herein by reference.
2. Decedent died on January 3, 2001 as the result of an automobile accident on
December 25, 2000 (herein, the "Accident"). A true and correct copy of the police
report of the Accident is attached hereto as Exhibit B and is incorporated herein by
reference as if fully set forth. A true and correct copy of Decedent's death
certificate is attached hereto as Exhibit C and is incorporated herein by reference
as if fully set forth.
3. Decedent did not have a will.
4. From December 25, 2000 until her death on January 3, 2001, Decedent was in the
Hershey Medical Center intensive care unit. Until approximately three days before
her death, Decedent was in and out of consciousness and mostly aware of her
setting.
5. In addition to the instant case, the case of Donald Snyder, individually and as
Parent and Guardian of Christopher Snyder, Ryan Snyder and Jessica Snyder,
Minors v. John P. Sullivan and Frank J. Sullivan, No. 01-3259 Civil Term (herein,
the "Donald Snyder Case") is pending in this Court. The Donald Snyder Case
involves claims of the minor children of Donna Snyder Adams for injuries they
sustained in the Accident.
6. There are three insurance companies (herein collectively, the "insurers") who have
been identified as being responsible to provide coverage for the injuries and death
resulting from the Accident: USAA, one of the Defendant's insurance carriers, has
tendered its policy limits of $100,000 per individual claim/S200,000 per aggregate
claim; Allstate Insurance, another of Defendant's insurance carriers, has tendered
its policy limits of $25,000 per individual claim/S50,000 per aggregate claim; and
Motorists Insurance Companies, Decedent's insurance carrier, has tendered its
underinsured motorists limits of $15,000 per individual claim/S30,000 per aggregate
claim. The cumulative proceeds available from the Insurers for the Accident is
$140,000 per individual claim/S280,000 per aggregate claim.
7. The following settlement has been agreed upon, subject to Court approval,
between the Insurers, Defendants and Plaintiffs in the instant case and the Donald
2
SnyderCase: The Insurers will pay to the Estate of Donna Snyder the total amount
of $120,000.00. (The Insurers will pay to Donald Snyder, in trust for the minor
plaintiffs in the Donald Snyder Case the total amount of $160,000.)
8, Upon approval of this settlement, Petitioner will be required to execute settlement
agreements/releases discharging Defendant and his liability and under insured
motorists insurance carriers from any further liability relating to the Accident and
this case. True and correct copies of the settlement agreements/releases from tow
of the Insurers and a letter from the third Insurer are attached hereto as Exhibit D
and are incorporated herein by reference as if fully set forth.
9. The undersigned counsel for Petitioner is of the professional opinion that the
proposed settlement is reasonable and fair for the following reasons: First, the
settlement of Petitioner's claim and of the claims in the Donald Snyder Case will
exhaust the only insurance proceeds available to pay the claims. Second,
Defendant, John P. Sullivan does not appear to have any other assets sufficient to
pay a verdict over and above the available insurance proceeds. Third, this
settlement will result in payments to the Estate in excess of 85% of the maximum
amount of insurance proceeds that could be recovered by the Estate under any
cimumstances. Fourth, absent this settlement, the claims of Petitioner and of the
three minor plaintiffs in the Donald Snyder Case would be interpleaded, possibly
resulting in a lesser amount being awarded to the Estate of Donna Snyder Adams
by the Insurers.
10. Petitioner is of the opinion that the settlement is reasonable and fair.
3
11. Counsel for Petitioner has incurred expenses in this case, for which reimbursement
is sought, in the total amount of $590.00 as set forth on Exhibit E hereof, which is
incorporated herein by reference as if fully set forth.
12. Counsel for Petitioner requests attorney's fees in the amount of $40,000.00, which
represents one-third (33 1/3%) of the gross proceeds of this settlement. A true and
correct copy of Counsel's Contingent Fee Agreement with the Estate of Donna
Snyder Adams is attached hereto as Exhibit F and is incorporated herein by
reference as if fully set forth.
13. Petitioner requests allocation of the net proceeds of the settlement, after deduction
of costs and attorney's fees, as follows:
Wrongful Death Action $19,852.50, or 25%
Survival Action $59,557.50, or 75%
14. The reasons for this suggested allocation are as follows: At the time of Decedent's
death, she was not working and was not contributing substantially to the income of
the income and household expenses of her spouse and children. It was not
expected that Decedent would substantially contribute financially to her family and
household expenses in the near future. In the Accident and throughout her care
until her death, Decedent experienced great pain and suffering. Thus, the greater
portion of this settlement is being allocated to the survival action to compensate for
Decedent's injuries, pain and suffering, and ultimate death.
15. Petitioner has sought and obtained approval of this settlement and the proposed
allocation from the Pennsylvania Department of Revenue. A true and correct copy
4
of the Department of Revenue's correspondence is attached hereto as Exhibit G
and is incorporated herein by reference as if fully set forth.
16. Pursuant to 42 Pa.C.S. § 8301, the beneficiaries of the wrongful death action and
their respective interests are as follows:
NAME
John R. Adams
Christopher Snyder
Ryan Snyder
Jessica Snyder
RELATIONSHIP BIRTH DATE AMOUNT
TO DECEDENT OF MINORS
Husband 50%
Son 12/13/86 1/6
Son 5/1/90 1/6
Daughter 7/6/91 1/6
17. The pecuniary loss suffered by the wrongful death beneficiaries is recognizable and
is described as follows: The Decedent, although not gainfully employed at the time
of the Accident, nevertheless contributed to the financial well-being of her family by
virtue of her functions as a wife and mother; further, there is a reasonable
expectation that the Decedent would have resumed gainful employment during her
marriage and the minority of her children, thereby contributing to their financial well-
being.
18. The Department of Public Welfare has no lien against the Decedent or any of the
wrongful death beneficiaries. True and correct copies of DPW's correspondence
are attached hereto as Exhibit H and are incorporated herein by reference as if fully
set forth.
5
19. There are no other liens or claims against the proceeds of this action or against the
Decedent's estate, other than the customary expenses of estate administration.
20. The wrongful death beneficiaries consent to the settlement and distribution set forth
herein. True and correct copies of the correspondence from Melissa Merritts
Rivera, counsel for the guardian of the minor beneficiaries, and John Snyder, a
beneficiary, are attached hereto as Exhibit I and incorporated herein by reference
as if fully set forth.
WHEREFORE, Petitioner respectfully requests that this Honorable Court
approve this Settlement and the allocation and distribution of the proceeds as set forth
herein.
DATE:
Respectfully S/tted,
WIX, WEN/~ ~EIDNER
P.O. Box 845
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0845
(717) 234-4182
Attorneys for Petitioner
F:\srw\0085 (ADAMS, DONNA & JOHN)\11090 (v. SULLIVAN)\DOCUMENTS\SETTLEMENT PETITION.doc
6
EXHIBIT A
Short Certificate - Letters of Administration
SHORT CERTIFICATE--LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA :
:
COUNTY OF PERRY :
I, DAVID I. MAGEE, Register of Wills in and for the County of Perry in the
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, DO HEREBY CERTIFY that on the 17th day of
January, 2001, LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION on the estate of Donna M.
Snyder/Adams, deceased were granted to Billie J. Noctor Marysville, PA 17053, having
first been qualified well and truly to administer the same. And I further cex~'tfy that no
revocation of Letters appears of record in my office.
Date of Death January 3, 2001
Social Security No. 224-48-3814
NOT VAILD WITHOUT ORIGINAL SIGNATURE AND IMPRESSED SEAL
EXHIBIT B
Police Accident Report
~REFER TO OVERLAY SHEETS
POI,1 CR LNVO!IMA'ff['ON
· '[,"::~ .... '- ,,
2,AGENCY
NAME ~t ~ ~ ~li~ ~pt
4. PATROL ~
3.STATION/pRECiNCT ~1~, Pa ZONE ~
5. [NVEST I GATOR BADGE
6.APPROVED BY BADGE
NUMBER
8.ARRIVAL 2~30
~.t~o~,~ 12/25/2000 ~mt
'9.~DC:=E%? i2/25/2000
DATE
ll.TIME OF
DAY 2220
13.# [ILLED 14.# NJURED
0
16.DID VEHICLE NAVE TO SE
REMOVED FR~ THE SCENE?
UNIT 1 UNIT 2
y lN[]y l, []
.HAZASDOUS 19.PENNDOT
MATERIALS Y [] , [] PROPERTY
~E._E.C.A..Y Y N '37.RE~
PARKBD? [] [~ I PLAT~ ~5141
~9.PA TITLE OR
OUT-O~-STAT~ V[~ 43366333
~D~ESS 1718
4~.C[TY,STATE
& Z[PCO~E ~ ~, PA 17070
.YEA~ 1990
45.MODEL- (NOT
BODY TYPE)
~SPEC[AL
0
12.NUMBER
OF UNITS 2
15.PRIV.PROP. [] []
ACCIDENT Y N
I?.VEHICLE DAMAGE
O-NONE UNIT 11 ~ I
1-LIGHT
2-MODERATE ~
3-SEVESE UNIT 2
YE]NB]
~.~TRAVEL
SPEED 99
S~.DRIVBH Is~'s~ATE PA
NUMBBR 25443942
58.ORIVER
59.DRIVER
ADDRESS 84 BROAD ST.
60.~ITY,STATE
& ZtPCOCE ivey, PA 17752
77.RELEASE OF HAZ MAT
YE:] N [] UN~F1
61.SEX 16Z.DATE OF 163.PHONE
M [ BIRTH 10/15/1980
Y["~N~ CLASS
67.CARRIER
aS,CARRIER
69.CITY,STATE
& ZIPCOOE
7O.USDOT # [ ICC # PUC #
75.N0, OF AXLES
22,SOUTE NO.OR
STREET NAME
23.SPEED
LIMIT 45
SR 0011/i~. 11-15
LIMIT WAY L
IFNOTATZNTERSECTION:
SEGMEHT flARNER
31.DIRECTION~ ]~ W 32,DISTANCE
FROM SITE ~S FROM SITE 1740 FT.
.OISTA. E .AS
MEABURE~ [] EBTIMATEO []
PARKED?~ J PLATE B~8017 [3~,r~'
~9.pA TITLE OR
OUT-OF-STATE Vt~ 55197353
41,0~N~R
AO0RESS ~ 1 ~ 497A
&2.C[TY,STATE
& z[PcooE ~'~, PA 17062
&5.YEAR
1996 )44.~AKE ~,.
m
45,MODEL-(NOT
BODY TYPE)
~VEHICLE
NUMBER 22725249
58.0RIVER
' ~AME ~M.
59.DR~VER
A~D~SS~ 1 ~ 497A
60.CITY,STATE
& zIpcoo5 ~~, PA 17062
6~.~ATE 0F
F BIRIH 11/07/1968
MI.
INTERSECT I NG
63 .PHONE
717-438-3495
68.CARRIER
ADDRESS
70.USDOT # _} ICc # PU~ #
OvEN.co..o.
AXLES ~ MATERIALS Y[] N [] UNKel
G NAIVE ADDRESS
1 JCEIN P. SUf,T,TVAN, 84 ~%OAD ST., M~[qlIIb~RY, ~A 17752
1 ~ M. SN~DE~, RD 1 BC~ 497A, MTT,T,R~A%'IC~IN, PA 17062
i CHRIS SNYDER Sk~E ~
0 ~I~ ~ ~ ~
0
~WEATHER ~ ~' DIAG.:
85.DESCRIPTION OF DAMAGED PROPERTY
L~4CIDF2N*£' % :2000_12~_383
CCIDENT DATE: 12/25/2000
N I J K t M
2 3 6 C 8
2 2 9 C 6
2 3 6 C 6
2 2 2 C 6
2 2 2 C 6
OWNER ............................... : .............. :
PHOHE
87.NARRATIVE-IDENTIFY PRECIPITATING EVENTS, CAUSATION FACTORS, EEaUENCES OF EVENTS, NITNESE STATENENTS~ AND PROVIDE AODITIONAL
DETAILS, LIKE INSURANCE INFORMATION AND LOCATION OF TONED VEHICLES, IF ~NO~N.
BO!'H UN'tTS Pd~vIDVED FRC~ SCENE BY MAC.-Z~RO'S i~ff3TO .S~T,'~.q ~5~.ECKER, 732-6969.
i~J2CID~NT OCCIFRRED AS L~gTT 1 ~ TRAV~r,TNG SC~TH C~ 0011 AND CRC~s~JD INTO ~
NOR'I/-5~OLIND LANE OF 0011 I4FTIW,E NEG~/EIAT'fNG A CT~KVE /1% ~ l%OAIY~aff, gNIT 1 THEN
Wi'il{ T_T~.L'L' 2 ~ (/',T ~ ~ 2 ~ ni~RA'v~,TNC~ l'~Ol~'l/q ~ 0011.
OFFIL:~:~ ~S T.3X~'RT~ %0 ZI',rJ.'~-~.VJ.~SW DP~TVER 2 DUE TO HER INJURT~.q.
CHRIS SNYDE~, PASSSlklGE~ 11~ I1N.L'r 2 , WAS ALSO INi'.~a~vJ~WED BY THE O~'~'J. Ci~ AT THE
HOSPITAL. HE APPARENTLY ~AS ST.~.PING JUST PRIOR TO THE ACC]I~ENT ~ HAD ~ TO
UN/'i' 1 ~l~Ra~]/q~ D~{~:~:£'~,Y AT THEM. HE THEN EITH~ l~'~-~mTi ~ TO ~.~JD OR P~E~D C~T~ ]~JE TO
POLICY
UNIIT HO
11676166
B8 NAME
WITNESSES NAME
~[~f~9. VIOLATIOHS INDICATEO
UNiT 1 D~ ~ ~ S~E OF ~
:~*~ USE '~ST ~ RESULTS
0 O, 00~
COMPANY
FOIORISTS
POLICY NO
8305-06-584880-03A
PHONE
3301
REFUSE ~ D
k~ RESULT $ ~4. I HVEST ! GAT I C
__TYPE ~ NO TESTJ COMPLETE7
[~ REFUSE J
EST 0.0 ~6 ~
CENTER FOR ~IGBWAY SAF~
COMMO~TH
PA)~ CONiZNZrATION
~REFER TO OVERLAY SHEETS REPORT~BL~ ~ ~OS-R~PO~T~BL~ ~
INCIDENT I A~CIDENT COUNTY
2000-12-383 / 0ATE 12/25~2000 CODE.
~PERSON INFORMATION-USE OVER[A9 ~g S,~T FOR CODES
PENNDOT USE ONLY
MUNICIPAL
coo~ . 101
H I J K
L M
8t.'~ARR.~.T fYI:
INVES-riGATICN OF ~HIS ACtJJ3ENT LEADS ~gHIS OFFI~ TO R~,T~VE 5~AT DRIVER 1 MAY HAVE
~T,T,~ ]NqT,k~P CAUSIN~ }{IS ~ TO ]~IF]~ OUT OF i-TS LkN]E OF T~AVEL. ~ WERE NO ~
SKID MARF~ FRCM T/N-/T 1 OR SKID MARKS TO INDICATE T/N-IT 1 N~%S ~,TT~IN~ OEYf OF CC~T/RC~ PRIOR
PDSPi'rk5 IND!Ckr~23 A SUSPICIC~ OF HIS BEING %E~UER THE ~ OF ~ OR DRUGS.
UN±'r 2 ~ TO THE EXTR~V~ RIGHT SIDE OF THE NOIrH-5]CTCLN~D LANE (/qIO 5~E Rk~M INDICAT/1N~
AN Au.'i'.~VIPT TO AVOID THE COt~,ISIC~. DR/VER 2 APPAR~NTFLY OB~m<VED I]Ni'r 1 APPRO~/2FE[NG
DISTANCE A~AS{ TO ~,T,T ~ HER. TO TAKE AN EVASIVE Acr£C~ AND THE DIRSL'2T HEAD C~ IMPACT
INDICkr~u T. TN£,' 1 NAS TRA.V~T,TNC- ~'r~JNIGE{T AT I1N,'I' 2.
... :~.<. :.~ 9. VIOLATIONS iNDICATED
UNIT 1
UNIT 2
RESULlS
90. SECTION NUMBER~ (ONLY IF CHARGED) TC NTC
E~ NO TEST) ~]~f~" USE TEST ~ NO TEST COMPLETE?
EAST PE! iNS' ORO TOWhlSHIP
POLICE DEPARTMENT
98 South Enola Drive · Enola PA 17025-2796 · [717} 732-3633 · Fax [717) 732-3980
The following Fire and Ambulance services responded to the
accident.
SUMMERDALE FIRE CO. AND CITIZENS FIRE CO. OF EAST PENNSBORO TWP.
EAST PENNSBORO TWP. EMS
HAMPDEN TWP. EMS
CAMP HILL BOROUGH EMS
WEST ~HORE EMS
CAPITAL LIFE TEAM OF HBG. EMS
HERSHEY MEDICAL CENTER LIFE LION HELICOPTER
MARYSVILLE BOROUGH FIRE CO., EMS, AND POLICE DEPT.
N
+
co '
~).SEFER TO OVERLAY SHEETS REPORTABLE E]~ NON-REPORTABLE ~ PENNDOT USE ONLY
'.." ~I,ICF, INFONeT.ION .' ACCID~.L' 7'1~ ~ .
," ........· · ~,-= - "= .................................................. V~14~%5<:'-- %'--2'~ ;i~/l~ .... ~-~i~' "%~q9~ ~ --2'~3 ....
NAME East Permsboro Township Police Dept
4.PATROL
3.STATION/PRECiNCT EI1Oi~, ~ ZONE 2
5.INVESTIGATOR BADGE
CPL, P, OB~L, P]lNmJ]I 1606
6.APPROVED BY BADGE
11.TIME OF 12.NUMBER
DAY 2220 OF UNITS 2
XILLED 1 4.# NJURBD S.PRIV.PROP.[]
0 ACCIDENT y N
20.COUNTY CODE
Cumberland 21
Zl'MU~ICIPALITYEast Pennsboro Twp E°D~iO1
UNIT ~: 02 - COMPLETE ONLY INFORMATION THAT F~S CHANGED SINCE ORIGINAL REPORT
56.LEGALLY Y N 5F.REG. )SB.S~ATE
PARKED?~[~ PLATE
39.PA TITLE OR
OUT-DF-STATE VIN
40.OYNER
SS,DRIVER
NAME
59.DRIVEN
ADDRESS
60.CITY,STATE
& ZIPCODE
61.SEX 62,DATE OF
BIRTH
. O M.VEN aS.DRIVER
67,CARRIER
68.CARRIES
ADDRESS
69.CITY,STATE
& ZIPCODE
70,UBDOT #
~VEH.
CONFIG.
41,OWNER
ADDRESS
42.CITY,STATE
& ZIPCODE
43.YEAR ] 4~.MAKE
45 .MODEL-(NOT 146.1~S~
BOOY TYPE) N)'-)UHX[]
O~NERSHIP
/ / J63.PHONE
66.DRIVER
SS#
ICC # PUC #
~CASGO 74.DV~R
BODY TYPE
75.N0.
OF
~AZARDOUS 77.RELEASE OF HAZ MAT
AXLES MATERIALS Y[-] N [] UHK[~
SEQUENCE OF EVENTS, WITNESS STATEMENTS, AND PROVIDE AODITIONAL
56.0RIVERNuMBER [57.STATE
8~,NARRATIVE - IDENTIFY PRECIPITATING EVENTS, CAUSATION FACTORS,
DETAILS
DRIVE~ OF IIN-~T 2 DIED IN THE HERS~-~ MEDICAL CENJ.'J~F,. SEVERAL DAYS AL,'.I:~< THIS CRAS~ A~ A
RESULT OF 31qJUP~IES SU.~'~'.'~q.ED IN THE CRASH.
AN AEDITIC~A~ Sb/~4ARY ~IOLATIC[q OF CA~P~ ~-qS DR1-V3/~ HAS BEEN F~,'~h ~S"~ DP~VER OF UNIT
1.
INSURANCE
INFORMATION
UNIT
NO
COMPANY
POLICY
NO
EXHIBIT C
Death Certificate
WARNING: IT IS ILLEGAL TO ALTER THIS COPY OR
TO t" '~LICATE BY PHOTOSTAT OR PHOTO' ~.PH.
CO,~ONWEALTH OF PENHSYLVANIA
LOCAL ~ST~,%R'S CE. RT~F~CAT~O~k~ OF D~ATM~
1-06-2001
hb. rn~-', d Decedent Donne Snyder-Adams
Se:,: Female Soci~l Security No. 222-48-3814
Dateo~Desth_ 1-03-2001
Race White Occupation Nursing Assistant Armed Forces? No
tDecedect's
Marital St~,tus Married Ma]ih'~D Address R, R, #1, Box 497A Millerstown
tn~on'nan~ John Adams Funera~Director Douglas T. Boyer
Neme and Address of
FuneraiEstablishnqent B~ye= Fune=a/ HOme, P,0, Box ~1, New BloomfieLd,
Nov
7
1968
DEL
Date c4 '~"' · , .~m~uw~on,
P}~ce of Death Hershey Mad Center ___ Dauphin Derry Twp.
<Yes or No)
a" Sepsis
Mu[t±p[e ~rauma
(~) ........
(c) M V A
Pad U: Otiqer Signi~ican~ Conditions
PA 1708:
PA 17068
in'ien'eI Between
Onset end Death
f.taha-e,I ~ Homicide
i!~,cciden~ ~X Pending investigation
Suicide ~_] Could not be Determined
Describe how inju~7 ~ ....
Vehicle vs. vehicle
:[271 S. 28th St.,
Graham S.
H3_~isbur§,
Hetrick
PA 17111
Coroner
(M.D., '3 0 Coroner,
455
EXHIBIT D
Settlement Agreements/Releases
Motorists Insura
Companies'
~' x \ ~INSU~NCEGROUP ·
2674 Monmeville Blvd., Monroeville, PA 15146-2344 412.856-0740 800-876-7488
NOVEMBER 26, 2001
MORGAN & MORGAN
MELISSA MERPffrTS RIVERA
120 SOUTH ST
HARRISBURG PA 17101
Claim nnmber: 3-530895
Insured: John R. Adams
Claimants: Donald Snyder, Parent of
Jessie Snyder, Ryan Snyder and Christopher Snyder
Date of loss: 12-25-2000
This letter is to confirm that Motorists Insurance offers the underinsured policy limits of
$30,000.00 in settlement of the claims of your clients Donald Snyder, Parent of
· Jessie Snyder, Ryan Snyder and Christopher Snyder and the clients of
Steven R. Williams, John R. Adams and the Estate of Donna M. Snyder Adams.
I understand that you have reached an agreement with Steven R. Williams for the distribution of
these funds and that you will provide me with the breakdown in funds so that I may prepare the
appropriate releases for your presentation to the courts.
In regard to the outstanding storage charges for the 1996 Ford Windstar, Central Penn Sales
advises that there are no storage charges for the first 60 days storage. After the first 60 days, the
storage charges are $1.00 per day. In addition, there is a $80.00 charge for the vehicle wrap.
Today I have notified Central Penn that the vehicle may be placed up for sale and I have sent the
vehicle title to Central Penn,
Upon receipt of the stmage and wrap charge statement from Central Penn, I will send you a copy.
Please keep il-, mind that Motorist would not have Incun'ed the storagc charges and/or the ;-','rap
Motorists Insurance Companies
Christine Mugridge
CSR Specialist
Piltsburgh Branch Office
800-876-7488 extension 1128
cc: ~Steven R. Williams
0-153 (%97) http://www.youknowus.com
RELEASE
KNOW ALL THESE MEN THAT BILLIE NOCTOR, as Administratrix of the Estate of
DONNA SNYDER ADAMS, Deceased, (HEREINAFTER REFERRED TO AS THE
"Releasor(s)"), for and in sole consideration of ONE HUNDRED FIVE THOUSAND AND 00/100
($105,000.00) DOLLARS, the receipt and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, do/does
hereby remise, release, and discharge JOHN P. SULLIVAN, FRANK J. SULLIVAN, UNITED
SERVICES AUTOMOBILE ASSOCIATION and ALLSTATE (HEREINAFTER REFERRED TO
AS THE "Releasee(s)"), their heirs, executors, administrators, insurers, employees, successors, and
assigns of and from all, and all manner of, actions and causes of action, suits, debts, hens, dues,
accounts, bonds, covenants, contracts, agreements, judgments, cia/ms, and demands whatsoever in
law or equity presently existing or subsequently discovered by BILLIE NOCTOR, as Administratrix
of the ESTATE OF DONNA SNYDER ADAMS, resulting from a pedestrian/motor vehicle accident
that occurred on December 25, 2000, which against the said Releasees//we ever had, now have, or
which my/our heirs, executors, administrators, successors, or assigns or any one of them hereafter
shall, er may have for or by reason of any cause, matter, or thing whatsoever. Releasor(s)
specifically and expressly reserve all rights to pursue any and all claims against any person(s) or
entity(les) responsible for the medical treatment of Decedent, Donna Snyder Adams.
Vwe understand said Releasees, by reason of agreeing to this compromise payment, neither
admit liability hut all expressly deny liability of any sort, and said Releasees have made no
agreement or promise to do or omit to do any act or thing not herein set forth, and//we further
understand that this Release is made as a compromise to avoid expense to terminate all controversy
and/or claims for injuries or damages of whatsoever nature, known or unknown, including future
developments thereof, in any way growing out of or connected with said incident.
I/we admit that no representation of fact or opinion has been made by the said Releases or
anyone on his, her, or their belief to induce this compromise and that the sum paid is solely by way
of compromise ora disputed claim. It is specifically agreed that this Release shall be a complete bar
to all claims or suits for damages of whatsoever nature resulting or to result from said incident.
It is further understood and agreed and made a part hereof that neither I/we, nor my/our heirs,
executors, administrators, successors, or assigns nor our Attorneys or other representatives will, in
any way, publicize in any news or commun/cations media including, but not limited to, newspapers,
magazines, radio, or television, the facts or terms and conditions of the settlement. All parties to this
agreement expressly agree to decline comment on any aspect of this settlement to any member of
the news media. This paragraph is intended to become part of the consideration for settlement of
this claim.
Releasors specifically reserve the fight to make claims, actions, and causes of action arising
out of the above-referenced incident against every other person or other entity, other than Releasees,
who may be responsible for the injuries sustained by the Releasors, together with the right to make
the claim that such other persons and entities, and not the Releasees, are solely liable to the Releasors
herein for any injuries, losses, and damages sustained by Releasors.
It is further agreed that in the event that Releasees are also found by judicial determination
to be a joint tortfeasor with any person or entity in causing injury or damage to the Releasors, the
Releasors hereby release that port/on or share of the cause of action which the Releasors have against
the Releasees and discharge any and all damages attributable to the Releasees in such cause of
2
action, without in any way discharging or releasing the portion of the cause of action attributable to
the non-settling tortfeasors who have caused injury to the Releasors herein. The Releasors do hereby
credit and satisfy that portion of the total mount of dmuages to the Releasors which has been caused
by the negligence, breach of duty, breach of warranty, or other liability causing conduct, if any, on
the part of Releasees as hereinafter may be determined in future trial, and the Releasors do release
and discharge that portion and percentage of the total cause of action and claim for damages against
the Releasees which shall hereinafter, by future trial be determined to be the sum of that fraction or
percentage of causal negligence or other liability causing conduct, as determined pursuant to the
Comparative Negligence Act of Pennsylvania (42 Pa. C.S. Section 7102(b)), if applicable, or any
other law found to be applicable, for which the Releasees are found to be liable.
In further consideration of the aforesaid payment to the Releasors by the Releasees for
damages, injuries, and claims of the Releasors, the Releasors agree to satisfy any claim or judgment
of award, ultimately recovered by the Releasors or by any person or entity against the Releasees for
contribution or otherwise by satisfying such percentage of any claim or judgment against the
Releasees as the negligence, breach of duty, breach of warranty, or liability causing conduct of the
Releasees bears to all the causal negligence, breach of duty, breach of warranty, or liability causing
conduct of all tortfeasors having liability by reason of this incidents and to that end the Releasors
agree to indemnify and save harmless the Releasees herein from all liability and damage of every
kind and nature from further liability to the Releasors or any other person or entity having a claim
for contribution or indemnity. The Releasors further agree that, in the event that they settle any or
all of their claims arising out of the incident hereinbefore mentioned against any or all other
tortfeasors, the Releasors shall include in all other releases that it executed a provision that states that
3
any other tortfeasor it releases shall not seek any contribution and/or indemnity from the Releasees
herein released. It is the intent of the parties to this Release that this Release shall be construed so
that the Releasees herein released shall not be liable to any other tortfeasor for contribution and/or
indemnity.
INWITNESSWHEREOF, Fwehavehereunto setmy/ourhand(s)and seal(s)tkis
of ,200__.
SIGNED, SEALED, ANDDELIVERED
in the presence of
day
DATE
BILLIE NOCTOR
as Administratrix of the Estate of
Donna Snyder Adams
SWORN to and SUBSCRIBED before me this
day of 200__.
NOTARY PUBLIC
4
EXHIBIT E
Counsel's Expenses
DATE
DESCRIPTION OF CHARGE
CHARGE
1/3/01
1/30/01
2/1/01
2/27/01
3/21/01
4/19/01
4/24/01
4/30/01
5/2/01
5/31/01
6/11/01
6/14/01
7/31/01
8/1/01
East Pennsboro Township Police Report
Photocopy Charge - Coudhouse/Library
East Pennsboro Township Police Report (Related
Accident)
Photocopy Charge
Summerdale Fire Company
Hampden Township Ambulance
Westlaw Computer Research
Westlaw Computer Research
Medical Records Services
Photocopy Charge
Prothonotary- Filing Fee
Sheriff - Service Charge
Photocopy Charge
Telephone Charges
Telephone Charges
Family Medical Center
Capital Copy Service
Police Report
Telephone Charges
Travel
TOTAL
$ 15.00
$ 1.o5
$ 15.00
$ 3.15
$ 15.00
$ 18.48
$ 22.80
$ 10.00
$175.95
$ o.go
$ 45.5O
$175.00
$ o.45
$ O.53
$ 3.15
$ 27.23
$ 26.90
$ 2O.OO
$ 1.13
$ 12.77
$59o.oo
F:/SRW/ADAMS, DONNA & JOHN/v. SULLIVAN/EXPENSES EXHIBIT.doc
EXHIBIT F
Contingent Fee Agreement
CONTINGENT FEE AGREEMENT AND
AUTHORIZATION TO REPRESENT
Eml~lovment of Attorneys, Billie Jean Noctor, as representative/administratrix
of the Estate of Donna M. Snyder/Adams (referred to in this Agreement as
"Client"), employ Wix, Wenger & Weidner, a Professional Corporation (referred to
in this Agreement as "Attorneys") to represent Client and Client's best interests in
any legal action brought against John Sullivan and any others, as a result of an
automobile accident that occurred on December 25, 2000 on Route 11/15 in or
about East Pennsboro Township (referred to in this Agreement as the "Matter").
Attornevs' Powers. Attorneys are authorized to take whatever action they deem
necessary against any persons, firms, associations or corporations arising out of
the Matter. Attorneys have full power to make any inquiries, to negotiate or
settle, bring, conduct, prosecute, sue and/or comprise the Matter with Client's
consent. Attorneys also have the power to sign any documents, checks or
orders on Client's behalf in connection with the Matter.
Client's Obli.clations. Client agrees that during the course of Attorneys'
representation of Client in the Matter, Client will, at its own expense, do each of
the following:
a. Supply to Attorneys all documents and other things requested by
Attorneys related to the Matter and that Attorneys tell Client they need in
order to handle the Matter; and
b. Attend all depositions, hearings, trials, meetings, and other
conferences related to the Matter that Attorneys believe C~ient should
attend; and
c. Generally cooperate with Attorneys in all respects of the Matter.
Amount of Attorneys' Fees, Client agrees to pay to Attorneys, as their fee, a
sum equal to the following:
a. thirty-three and one-third pement (33 1/3%) of the gross amount
recovered, if the Matter is settled before a trial or hearing begins; or
b, forty percent (40%) of the gross amount recovered, if a trial or hearing
has begun.
Gross amount recovered is referred to in this Agreement as the "Recovered
Funds".
Payment of Attornevs' Fees. Attorneys' fees will be calculated and paid out of
the Recovered Funds before payment, credit or deduction of any expenses or
costs incurred in the Matter.
Client assigns to Attorneys out of the Recovered Funds an amount equal
to the fees, plus the expenses and costs to which Attorneys are entitled.
Attorneys may direct any person(s) paying the Recovered Funds to make
the payment payable to Attorneys, as attorneys for Client. Attorneys may pay the
fees and the expenses and costs to which Attorneys are entitled out of the
Recovered Funds and pay the remaining portion of the Recovered Funds to
Client.
Attornevs' Lien. Client grants to Attorneys a lien on the Recovered Funds in an
amount equal to the fees plus the expenses and costs to which Attorneys are
entitled.
Appeals. Attorneys are under no obligation to file any appeal from any judgment
or order obtained in the Matter. If Client requests that Attorneys file an appeal
from any judgment or order, Attorneys' fees will be subject to renegotiation. If the
person against whom the Matter was filed appeals from any judgment or order,
Attorneys' fees will remain as agreed upon in this Agreement.
-2-
10.
11.
Other Leqal Matters, The employment of Attorneys by this Agreement covers
this Matter only. Attorneys are not required to provide legal services to Client
that are not directly related to this Matter. If Client wants Attorneys to provide
legal services on other legal matters, Client and Attorneys will enter into a
separate agreement to cover the other legal matters.
Expenses and Costs. Client understands that Attorneys may be required to pay
sums of money for investigation and other expenses incurred in the handling of
the Matter. Client agrees to reimburse Attorneys for these expenses, in addition
to paying Attorneys' fees.
Expenses may include filing fees, charges for depositions, photocopies,
cellular and long distance telephone calls, telecopies (faxes), travel, computer
research, and other items related to the Matter,
Attorneys may send to Client monthly invoices of the expenses and costs
incurred. Client agrees to pay the invoices within thirty (30) after receipt. Client
agrees to pay interest on the unpaid invoices at the rate of one percent (1%) per
month.
Settlement of the Matter. Attorneys will not settle the Matter or release any
person from the Matter without Client's prior approval.
Termination of Attornevs' Employment. If Client fires Attorneys, or if
Attorneys resign from the Matter because of Client's failure to fully cooperate in
the pursuing of the Matter, Client agrees that Attorneys will be entitled to a fee.
Attorneys' fee will be calculated by multiplying the amount of any settlement offer
outstanding at the time of the firing or resignation by the applicable percentage in
Paragraph 4 of this Agreement. Client also agrees to reimburse Attorneys for all
expenses and costs Attorneys have incurred in the Matter.
-3-
if there is no outstanding settlement offer when Attorneys' employment is
terminated or Attorneys resign, Client agrees that Attorneys will be entitled to a
reasonable fee for the services provided.
If Client fires Attorneys, or if Attorneys resign from the Matter, Client
agrees to sign any necessary documents confirming that Client consents to
Attorneys' formal withdrawal from the Matter.
Notification of the termination of Attorneys' employment will not be
effective unless it is in writing.
12. No Recovery No Fee. If Attorneys obtain no recovery for Client in the Matter,
Attorneys will not be entitled to any fees. However, Client agrees to reimburse
Attorneys for the expenses and costs paid or incurred by Attorneys in the
handling of the Matter.
13. Fleceil~t of Aclreement. Client acknowledges receipt of a copy of this
Agreement.
Client and Attorneys intend to be legally bound to the terms of this Agreement
and execute this Agreement on the !l~. day of January, 2001.
WITNESS/ATTEST:
Billie Jea~Noctor, representative/
administratrix of the Estate of
Donna M. Snyder/Adams
By. L/
Tf
;nger & Weidner
i~s L Weng"er
F:\srw\----- (ADAMS, DONNA & JOHN)\----- (V. SULLIVAN)\DOCUMENTS\CONTFEEAGMTI.doc
-4-
EXHIBIT G
Department of Revenue Approval Letter
12/4/2001
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
BUREAU OFINDIVIDUALTAXES
DEPARTMENT280601
HARRISBURG, PA 17128-0601
Telephone
717-783-0972
Steven R Williams, Esquire
Wix, Wenger & Weidner
PO Box 845
Harrisburg, Pa 17108-0845
Re: Estate of Donna Snyder Adams
File Number: None Listed
Com~ Number: Cumberland CCP-Civil- 01-2269
Dear Mr. Williams:
The Department of Revenue has received the Petition for Approval of Settlement Claim to be filed on
behalf of the above-referenced Estate in regard to a wrongful death and survival action. It has been forwarded to
this Bureau for the Commonwealth's approval of the allocation of the proceeds paid to settle the actions.
Pursuant to the Petition, the decedent died as a result of a motor vehicle accident. Decedent is survived by
the decedenfs husband, John R Adams, and three minor children by a prior marriage..
Please be advised that, based upon these facts and for inheritance tax purposes only, this Department has no
objection to the proposed allocation of the net proceeds of this action, $19,852.50 to the wrongful death claim and $
59,557.50 to the survival claim. Proceeds ora survival action are an asset included in the decedent's estate and are
subject to the imposition of Pennsylvania inheritance tax. 42 Pa.C.S.A. §8302; 72 P.S. §§9106, 9107. Costs and
fees must be deducted in the same percentages as the proceeds are allocated. In re Estate of Merrvman, 669 A.2d
1059 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1995).
I trust that this letter is a sufficient representation of the Depar/ment's position on this matter. As the
Department has no objections to the Petition, an attorney from the Department of Revenue will not be at~ending any
hearing regarding it. Please contact me if you or the Court has any questions or requires anything additional from
this Bureau. Finally, the approval of this allocation is limited to this estate and does not reflect the position that the
Department may take in any other proposed distribution of proceeds of a wrongful death / survival action,
cc: Cumberland County Clerk of Courts
f ?,r)- Paul Dibert
Inheritance Tax Division
Bureau of Individual Taxes
EXHIBIT H
Department of Public Welfare Lien Letter
WIX WENGER & WEIDNER
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
508 NORTH SECOND STREET
POST OFFICE BOX 845
}L~RISBURG PA 17108-0845
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WELFARE
BUREAU OF FINANCIAL OPEP. ATIONS
ESTATE RECOVERY PROGRAM
PO BOX 8486
HARRISBURG, PA 17105-848S
Noven~er 14, 2001
Re: DONNA SNYDER-ADAMS
SSN: 222-48-3814
Dear Attorney Williams:
Pursuant to your letter dated November 09, 2001, the Department of
Public Welfare (DPW), Third Party Liability (TPL) - Casualty Unit, has
reviewed the information you provided regarding the above-referenced
individual.
DPW has determined this individual stopped receiving medical assistance
on August 31, 1998. Therefore, the Department's TPL - Casualty Unit has no
claim on this individual.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me.
Sincerely,
Ronald D. Hill, Manager
TPL - Casualty Unit
(717)772-6604
(717)772-6553 FAX
WIX W~NG~ & WSIDN~
DENISE B WI~.LI~J~SON LBGAL ASST
508 NORTH SECOND STreET
~OST 0FPICE BOX 8A5
~ZS~L~G PA 17108-0845
Jan%xary 10, 2002
Re: JOHN AD~I~
~SN: 210-40-3942
Dear Ms. Williamson:
Pureuant ~o ~our leccer dated Noven~ber 28, 2001, nhe Depar~menc o~
Publiu well&re (D~W), Thira Party Liability {TPL) - Casualty Uni=, has
reviewed th~ information you provided re~ar~ing the above-refer~nce~
individual.
has been ~etermine~ that DPW has no lien againa~ ~hfs individ~l.
If you have any questions, please feel free to co~tact
Sincerely,
Ronal~ D. Hill, Manager
TPL - Casualty Unit
(717)772-6~0A
(717)772-~S~ FAX
§ '~__.6~O~'ON __O~8§OLL~L AIlIlSVI1 AI~Vd 0~ ......... ~:~ ~O0~*ll'NV?
W~X ~E~ & ~EIDI~T~R
;a~ua~ 10~ 2002
C"~ZSTO~]~;, 5~DER
175-68-7686
· ursua~t tO your letter dated November 2B, 2001, the Department o~
Public Welfare (DPW), Third Party Liabillty {TPL) - Casual=y Unit, has
reviewed the ingo~atton you provided regarding the above-referenced
individual.
It has bee~ determined that DPW has no Xten against this individual.
If ~u have an~ questions, please feel ~rss to contact me.
Sincerely,
Ronald D. Hill, Manager
T~L - Casualty Unit
(71T)?72-~604
(71~)?~2-$~3 FAX
DEPARTM~qT OF PUBLI~ WEt,PARE
BUREAU OP F[NN~;~ OPERATIONS
ESTATE RECOVERY PROGRAM
PO ~OX~8
~anuary' 10, 2002
WIX WENG~R & WEZDN~R
DENISE B WILLIAMSON LEGAL ASST
508 NORTH SECOND STREET
~057 OPFIC~ BOX 845
~IS~G PA 17108-084~
JESSICA SNYDER
201-72-4565
Dear Ms. William~on:
~ure~anc to your letter dated November 28, 2001, the Department of
~ublic Welfare (D~W), Third Pa=ty Liability (TPL) - Casualty Unit, has
reviewed the information you provided regardln~ the above-referenced
It has been determined that D~W has no 1fen against this indivi4ual.
Zf you have any c$/estions, ~lease feel free to contact me.
Sincerely,
Roneld D. ~i11, Manager
TPL - Casualty Unit
(717}772-~553
E '~ 6~OE'ON O§ISGOLLIL A£I]I8¥[~ ^±~Vd ONE ~a[~:~ ~OOg'tt'NVP
January lo, 2002
WIX WENGER & WEZDNER
DENISE B WILLIAMSON L~GAL A~ST
508 NOR~ SE~ S~ET
~0ST OFFIC~ BOX 8%~
167-72-1582
Dear Ms. Williamson:
Pursuant to ~our letter ~ated November 28, 2D01, the Departmen= o5
Publi= Welfare (DPW), Third Party Liability (TPL) - Casualty U~it, has
reviewed the informatiOn ~o~ 9rovided regardi~ the above-re~ereneed
individual.
has been determined that DPW has no lie~ against chis individual.
If you have any questione, please feel free to con,eot me.
Sincerely,
Rommld D. ~ill, Manager
TPL - casual=yUnit
(717}772-6;04
(717)772-E553
EXHIBIT I
Beneficiary Consent Letters
John Adams
664 Camberia Avenue
Harrisburg, PA 17111
November 10, 2001
Steven R. Williams, Esquire
Wix, Wenger & Weidner
508 North Second Street
P.O. Box 845
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0845
Re: Estate of Donna Snyder Adams v. Sullivan
Dear Mr. Williams:
I have read the Petition for Approval of Settlement of Wrongful Death and
Survival Actions that you sent. I consent to the settlement and to the proposed
distribution that are contained in the Petition.
Morgan &: Morgan, P.C.
Scott W. Morgan*
Thomas A. Wilken
Melissa Merrirts Rivera
120 South Street
Harrisburg, Pen~ylvania 17101
(717) 236-7959
Fax (717) 231-7436
www. mm-pc-law, com
Dire~t e-mail: mmr~mm-pc-law.com
Chambersburg Office
Suite 309
14 N, Main Street
Chambersburg, PA 17201
(717) 263-5607
Lebanon: (717) 270-8827
Cadisle: (717) 258-4313
FACSIMILE NO,:234-4224
Steven Williams, Esquire
508 Noah Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17101
November 26, 2001
Re: Snyder v, Sullivan, et al.
D~ar Steve:
This will confirm receipt of your November 8, 2001 and November 21,2001
correspondence regarding the above captioned matter. Enclosed please find a copy of our
Petition to Seek Court Approval of M/nor's Settlement. As you can see, in paragraph 8
Plaimiffs state that they are in agreement with the proceeds being paid to the Estate. Please feel
free to attach our document to your petition.
Regarding the filing of each of our petitions, I ara concerned about the lack of
correspondence from Motorist Mutual officially tendering the UIM 1/mits. Further, Motorist
Mutual has never provided us with a definitive answer regarding storage fees, if any. I spoke
with Ms. Mugridge prior to the Thanksgiving holiday, and she agreed to provide me w/th a letter
immediately, so that we may file our petitions. To date, I have not received a letter from her.
Please advise me if you have such a letter from Ms. Mugridge. Thank yom
Very truly yours,
Enclosure
VERIFICATION
I, Billie J. Noctor, Administratrix of the Estate of Donna Snyder Adams, have read
the foregoing Petition and hereby affirm and verify that it is true and correct to the best
of my personal knowledge, information and belief. I verify that all of the statements
made in the foregoing Petition are true and correct and that false statements made
therein may subject me to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S.A. Section 4904, relati~lg to
unsworn falsification to authorities.
ESTATE OF DONNA SNYDER ADAMS
Date:
Billie J. No, tar
ESTATE OF DONNA
SNYDER ADAMS,
Plaintiff
JOHN P. SULLIVAN,
Defendant
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 01-2269 CIVIL TERM
IN RE: PLAINTIFF BILLIE J. NOCTOR, ADM1NISTRATRIX OF THE
ESTATE OF DONNA SNYDER ADAM'S MOTION TO COMPEL COMPLETION
OF SETTLEMENT
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 14th day of October, 2002, upon consideration of the attached
letters from Thomas L. Wenger, Esq., and Nora F. Blair, Esq., the hearing previously
scheduled in the above matter for October 14, 2002, is continued generally.
COUNSEL ARE requested to notify the court if they desire a hearing in this
matter or if the matter is settled.
Thomas L. Wenger, Esq.
508 North Second Street
P.O. Box 845
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0845
Attorney for Plaintiff
Nora F. Blair, Esq.
5440 Jonestown Road
Harrisburg, PA 17112
Attorney for Defendant
BY THE COURT,
Ji Wesley Olcrrtr., J.
:rc