HomeMy WebLinkAbout05-23-11r.a
IN RE: : IN THE COURT OF COMMON AS ~ ~~
AN INCAPACITATED :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PE ~ VAIA ~'
PERSON, DERICK W. BOBB . . m c"` ~ ~ ~;
ORPHAN'S COURT DIVISION.-~c~ix W `- ~ '
cv - ,
C7 ~ l _T) -`~ - t j
f _""
PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT OF ~ ~ ~ ~~
GUARDIANS OF THE ESTATE
AND PERSON IN A CCORDANCE WITH 20 Pa. C S A ~ 5513
The petitioners, DAVID W. BOBB and TAMMY J. BOBB, by and through their
attorneys, Irwin & McKnight, P.C., respectfully represents the following:
1. Petitioners, David W. Bobb and Tammy J. Bobb, are adult individuals whose
principal residence is 10 Big Spring Terrace, Newville, Pennsylvania 17241.
2. Petitioners are the parents of Derick W. Bobb (hereinafter the "alleged
incapacitated person")
3. The alleged incapacitated person was born on October 10, 1992, is 1 ~ years of age
and currently resides with the Petitioners at 10 Big Spring Terrace, Newville. Pennsylvania
17241.
4. The alleged incapacitated person suffered a brain injury in infancy as a result of a
motor vehicle accident.
5. As a direct result of the brain injuries suffered in infancy, the alleged
incapacitated person continues to suffer significant mental impairment. A true and correct copy
j9
,~,
of a letter dated December 28, 2010 from the alleged incapacitated person's family doctor.
Jeanette C. Ramer, M.D., is attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibit "A."
6. As stated by the alleged incapacitated person's physician in Exhibit "A," because
of his impaired mental condition the alleged incapacitated person lacks the ability to effectively
make decisions regarding his health care, finances, and daily living situations.
7. As stated by his family doctor in Exhibit "A," the alleged incapacitated person
has poor understanding of day-to-day tasks, safety awareness, and managing his own personal
and financial affairs.
8. The alleged incapacitated person is unable to keep himself properly nourished and
hydrated, maintain adequate personal hygiene, make his own living arrangements, or seek
needed medical services.
9. Because of the severity of his mental condition, the alleged incapacitated person
lacks the capacity to make or communicate any responsible decisions concerning his person or
estate.
10. The severity of the alleged incapacitated person's mental condition and the lack of
viable, less restrictive alternatives necessitate that a plenary guardian of his person be appointed
to handle all issues relating to the person of the alleged incapacitated person, specifically
including, but not limited to: his living arrangements, his medical and psychiatric care, the
administration of medication to him, his education and schooling, and the employment and
discharge of physicians, psychiatrists, dentists, nurses, therapists and other professionals for his
physical and mental treatment and care.
2
1 1. The proposed plenary guardians of the person of the alleged incapacitated person
are the Petitioners, the natural parents of the alleged incapacitated person.
12. The proposed plenary guardians of the person of the alleged incapacitated person
have no interest adverse to the alleged incapacitated person.
13. The Petitioners are not aware that the alleged incapacitated person has signed any
powers of attorney or directives or in any other way designated anyone to serve as his agent over
any of his personal or financial affairs or as his surrogate over his medical care.
14. As a result of the motor vehicle accident that injured the alleged incapacitated
person, a lawsuit was commenced and subsequent financial settlement approved as more fully set
forth in that prior action filed in the Orphans' Court of Cumberland County. Pennsylvania. and
docketed at #21 - 95 - 0814.
15. Manufacturers and Traders Trust Company was most recently appointed Guardian
of the minor's estate in that prior action, which Guardian filed a First and Final Account current
through October 10, 2010.
16. At the effective date of the filed First and Final Account approved by this Court.
Manufacturers and Traders Trust Company reported a combined balance on hand of
X4,944,553.20 in the trust.
17. During the financial guardianship of the minor by Manufacturers and Traders
"Trust Company, the trust account was primarily managed by David C. Gority.
3
1 g. Mr. Gority has recently changed employment, and is currently a Vice President of
Investment and Trust Services with F&M Trust Company,
19. Mr. Gority has previously met with and is familiar with the alleged incapacitated
person, and it is the desire of the Petitioners that F&M Trust Company be appointed guardian of
the estate of their son.
20. The severity of the alleged incapacitated person's mental condition and the lack of
viable, less restrictive alternatives necessitate that a plenary guardian of his estate be appointed
to manage and handle all aspects of the alleged incapacitated person's estate, specifically
including, but not limited to: all issues relating to the trust established on his behalf: the annuity
contract currently held by Symetra Financial, his stocks and bonds, his real estate, his life and
other insurance of which he is the beneficiary, his entitlement to any governmental and
nongovernmental benefit plans, federal, state, and local taxes and the associated tax returns and
related filings, claims made or to be made on behalf of him or against him, and the payment of
reasonable compensation or costs to provide services for him.
21. Petitioners would further request, given the recent accounting provided by
Manufacturers and Traders Trust Company, that no further accounting be required to be
provided, but that the assets currently managed for the alleged incapacitated person be
transferred to F&M Trust Company upon appointment and approval by the Court in this matter.
22. The proposed plenary guardian of the estate of the alleged incapacitated person
has no interest adverse to the alleged incapacitated person.
4
23. Petitioners would further request that an attorney be appointed to represent the
interests of the alleged incapacitated person, and would respectfully request the appointment of
Jacqueline M. Verney, Esquire because of her prior experience as a guardian ad litem, with her
costs to be paid from the trust of the alleged incapacitated person,
24. No other court has ever assumed jurisdiction in any proceeding to determine the
capacity of the alleged incapacitated person.
25. Other than those identified herein, no other guardian or guardians have been
appointed for the estate or person of the alleged incapacitated person,
WHEREFORE, Petitioners respectfully request that this Court award a citation directed
to Derick W. Bobb, the alleged incapacitated person, and the Petitioners, with at least twenty
(20) days notice and service thereof to be given to them, to show cause why Derick W. Bobb
should not be adjusted a fully incapacitated person, why Petitioners should not be appointed
guardian of Derick W. Bobb's person, and why F & M Trust Company should not be appointed
guardian of the estate of Derick W. Bobb, and that a trust be established and continued to care
for his future needs and estate.
Respectfully Submitted,
IRWIN & McKNIGHT, P.C.
Douglas .Miller, Esquire
Supreme Court I.D. No. 83776
60 West Pomfret Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 249-2353
Date: May 19, 2011 Attorney for Petitioners
5
VERIFICATION
The foregoing document is based upon information which has been gathered by my
counsel and myself in the preparation of this action. I have read the statements made in this
document and they are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. I
understand that false statements herein made are subject to the penalties of 1$ Pa.C.S.A. Section
4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
l
VID W. BOBB
I~YI /71l ~ , ~~ ~.~;,
TAMMY J. B BB
Dates May 19. , 2011
IN RE: : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
AN INCAPACITATED :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
PERSON, DERICK W. BOBB .
: ORPHAN'S COURT DIVISION
. NO.
CONSENT OF GUARDIAN
F ~ M Trust Company hereby consents to serve as guardian of the Estate of Derick W.
Bobb. F & M Trust Company has no interest adverse to Derick W. Bobb or to any estate in
which he is interested.
F & M TRUST COMPANY
'~ ,.
Dated: May 19, 2011
Da id C. Gority, V~e Pr ident and
Trust Officer
PEN N STATE
~, Children's Hospital
Roger L. Ladda, NID Department of Pediatrics Penn State Children's Hospital Tel: (7171 531-8414
David S and Am) S Goldbere Division of Human Genetics. Penn State Mil[on S. Hershey Medical Center Fax; (717) X31-0276
Professor of Genetics Growth & Development Department of Pediatrics. H085
and Pediatrics 500 Universit Drive. P.O. Box 850 `~~`r~~-'~''~~ ~ ~`,~;'~
)'
Chief. Division of Human Hershey, PA 17033-0850
Genetics, Grov~4n and December 2 8 , 2 010
Development :. -
gg Ede
Patricia L. Gordon, A1D Mr . and Mrs . David Bobb
Assistant Professor 333 Oak Flat Road iKi"Jil''~:ltli(;{i111iG~'?
of Pediatrics Newvi l 1 e , PA 17 2 41 r",5' f}` ri%`~``
.Icanette C. Ramer, NID
Professor of Pediatrics RE: BOBB Derick W. MSHMC #589757
~
Director. Medical Pediatric
Rehabilitation Birthdate - 10 /10 / 92
Developmental Pediatrician
Cheryl D. Tierney, MD, MPH TO Whom It May Concern
Assistant Professor of Pediatrics
Developmental Pediatrician I have been asked to write a letter regarding Derick Bobb' s
Nlarl;Dontoto,MGd current judgment, cognitive skills and ability to manage
Developmental Specialist his own interests as well as his day to day care.
717 531 7776 Tel
Susan L.SeII,n1S,CGC Derick is an 18-year-old young man who sustained a very
Certified Genetic Counselor severe brain injury in infancy as the result of a motor
vehicle accident. I have been treating him for the last
ten years in follow-up of this injury. His last visit to
me was on October 25, 2010. In addition, I have had the
opportunity to review his school records, including
cognitive evaluations along with information front his
family over the years to better understand his skill
development.
Unfortunately, Derick's brain injury has severely impaired
his learning potential, social skills and judgment. He
functions in the moderately cognitively impaired range and
attends a life skills classroom placement. They are
struggling to teach him daily living skills. He has
problems with memory dysfunction, very poor time sense, and
does not know what step comes next even in simplF> tasks.
Hygiene remains of concern as well. He frequently fails to
wash his hair and is oblivious to the effect of poor
hygiene on others.
The greatest functional deficit remains in language skills.
He takes a very long time to retrieve essential
information, including his own phone number and address.
He becomes frustrated when he cannot express himself.
Derick has very limited understanding of money; he may
count it accurately, but is unaware of how much items cost
or what he would need to buy to sustain himself. Safety
awareness is at about a 5-6 year level, requiring that he
be supervised at all times outside the home and at home
An f-.goal Oppurwnig~ Uni~~crsilV
RE: BOBB, Derick
Page Two
December 28, 2010
when he is preparing food or, at times, during showering
and self care.
Overall, although Derick is a pleasant young man who wants
to please, his overall skills currently approximate early
first grade for academics and perhaps age 8-9 years for
social skills. Therefore, he has very poor understanding
of even day-to-day tasks, safety awareness and, certainly,
managing his own affairs. He would not be competent to
make decisions regarding health care, finances ar:d daily
living situations.
I am available for further discussion (717 531-8414) if
greater detail is needed.
Sincerely,
~'~Jeanette C. Ramer, M.D.
Developmental Pediatrician