Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout13-1118 A. TAYLOR WILLIAMS, ESQUIRE Attorney I.D. #33149 Supreme Court of Pennsylvania 813 MAR Administrative Office of PA Courts ♦' 4 26 P c�� C' 1515 Market Street, Suite 1414 8E R L A Mrs Philadelphia, PA 19102 PF tS Y LVA NIA Phone: (215) 560-6300 Fax:(215) 560-5486 RICKY TEJADA Plaintiff CIVIL ACTION - LAW V. NO. 13-1118 CIVIL TERM IRENE M. BIZZOSO, PROTHONOTARY PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT Defendant MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER FROM PRE-COMPLAINT DISCOVERY FILED ON BEHALF OF PROTHONOTARY IRENE M.BIZZOSO,OF THE PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT NOW COMES Irene M. Bizzoso, Prothonotary of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court,by and through undersigned counsel,who moves this Honorable Court to enter a Protective Order from pre-Complaint discovery in the above-captioned case and in support thereof avers as follows: 1. Plaintiff Ricky Tejada, acting pro se, commenced this action by filing and serving upon named Defendant Irene M. Bizzoso, Pennsylvania Supreme Court Prothonotary, a Notice to Defend and two documents entitled "PRE-COMPLAINT DISCOVERY WRITTEN INTERROGATORIES," attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and made a part hereof. 2. Plaintiff has failed to file or serve in this matter a Writ of Summons, Complaint or any document that sets forth a cause of action or any factual basis therefor. 3. The proposed Interrogatories,which are unnumbered and confusingly worded, contain questions such as whether Defendant has " a responsibility to make sure her staff and office of the Prothonotary for the PA. Supreme Court Middle District is in compliance with the PA. Rules of Court and applicable statute- and does compliance thereof render the defendant liable." 4. The said Interrogatories also inquire as to whether the Defendant is covered by insurance, and in how many actions of law or equity has the Prothonotary been involved. 5. The Interrogatories further ask the identity of the agent in the Prothonotary's Office who is "responsible for stulifying(sic)or impairing the procedural due process rights of the Plaintiff," and "how many times has this office stulified(sic) or impaired the Plaintiff efforts." 6. Although pre-Complaint discovery may be appropriate to obtain factual information to aid in the preparation of pleadings, such as the proper parties or the whereabouts of witnesses,it is not proper for"a fishing expedition" to determine whether a cause of action exists or whether a pleading shall be prepared in the first instance. See Luckett v. Blaine et al., 850 A.2d 811, 818 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2004) 7. In this case, Plaintiffs pre-Complaint Interrogatories do not target factual information such as names and addresses to aid in preparing pleadings,but are confusing, far- reaching,vague, irrelevant, and geared toward the proverbial "fishing expedition" which is disallowed under Pennsylvania law. 8. Pre-complaint discovery is proper if and only if a plaintiff has set forth a prima facia case, McNeil v. Jordan, 814 A.2d 234, 246 (Pa. Super. 2002),which has not been done in this case,particularly since Plaintiff has not filed either a Writ of Summons or a Complaint. 2 9. A Court is "authorized to enter discovery orders 'for the convenience of parties ... and in the interest of justice,"' neither of which would be served by requiring Prothonotary Bizzoso to respond to Plaintiffs Interrogatories in this case. Pa.R.C.P. 4007.3, Explanatory Comment. 10. Moreover,the Commonwealth Court has exclusive jurisdiction over actions against the Commonwealth and its officers, including prothonotaries to whom quasi-judicial immunity has been extended,under 42 Pa.C.S.A. § 761(a)(1); See also McKnight v. Baker, 415 F.Supp.2d 559, 563 (E.D. Pa. 2006), affd 244 Fed. Appx. 442 (3rd Cir. 2007); Leiber v. County of Alleghen y, 654 A.2d 11 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1994). 11. In this case,because Prothonotary Bizzoso is a state official,Plaintiffs claims against her, if any exist, are not properly raised in this Court,but rather jurisdiction lies in the Commonwealth Court. 12. Further, Courts apply the doctrine of judicial immunity to bar civil rights actions against clerks and prothonotaries, court reporters, and administrators. See Lockhart v. Hoenstine,411 F.2d 455, 460(3d Cir. 1969), cert. denied, 396 U.S. 941(1969; Davis v. Philadelphia County, et al., 195 F.Supp.2d 686, 689(E.D.Pa. 2002) (holding that quasi-judicial immunity applies to court staff, such as clerks of judicial records and court reporters, who are acting in their official capacities) 13. For these reasons, a strong likelihood exists that this Honorable Court will dispose of this case based upon Preliminary Objections, thus rendering discovery unnecessary. 14. Strong policy considerations protect Court personnel from burdensome,time- consuming discovery demands in lawsuits where a meritorious defense exists, with the goal of curtailing the deflection of public resources for unfounded claims. 3 WHEREFORE,Defendant Irene M. Bizzoso, Prothonotary of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court,requests that this Honorable Court enter an Order of Protection from Pre- Complaint Discovery in this matter. Respectfully submitted, ` ,— A. WILLIAMS, ESQUIRE ttorney 41.D.No. 33149 PA Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Administrative Office of PA Courts 1515 Market Street, Suite 1414 Philadelphia,PA 19102 legaldepartmentApacourts.us (215) 560-6300, Fax: (215) 560-5486 Attorney for Defendant, Irene M. Bizzoso,Prothonotary of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court 4 A. TAYLOR WILLIAMS, ESQUIRE Attorney I.D. #33149 Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Administrative Office of PA Courts 1515 Market Street, Suite 1414 Philadelphia, PA 19102 Phone: (215) 560-6300 Fax:(215) 560-5486 RICKY TEJADA Plaintiff CIVIL ACTION- LAW V. : NO. 13-1118 CIVIL TERM IRENE M. BIZZOSO, PROTHONOTARY PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT Defendant CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE The undersigned counsel hereby certifies that on March 25, 2013, she personally caused to be served upon the following a true and correct copy of the foregoing Motion for a Protective Order from Pre-Complaint Discovery and Memorandum of Law in Support of same filed on behalf of Irene M. Bizzoso, Prothonotary of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court,by mailing same first class, postage pre-paid, U.S. mail to: Ricky Tejada,EW-1339 SCI-Camp Hill P.O.Box 200 Camp Hill,PA 17001 Pro Se A. TAffLOR WILLIAMS, ESQUIRE Attorney I.D. No. PA33149 F Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Administrative Office of PA Courts 1515 Market Street, Suite 1414 Philadelphia, PA 19102 legaldepartment @pacourts.us (215) 560-6300, Fax: (215) 560-5486 Attorney for Defendant, Irene M. Bizzoso,Prothonotary of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court A. TAYLOR WILLIAMS, ESQUIRE GF THE Pljo Attorney I.D. #33149 THONO TAR Ir Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Z0134PR -9 AN11: 29 Administrative Office of PA Courts 1515 Market Street, Suite 1414 CUMERLAMO Philadelphia, PA 19102 PENNSyLVACOUNTY legalftartmentApacourts.us MIA Phone: (215) 560-6300 Fax:(215) 560-5486 RICKY TEJADA COURT OF COMMON PLEAS, CUMBELAND COUNTY Plaintiff CIVIL ACTION - LAW V. NO. 13-1118 CIVIL TERM IRENE M. BIZZOSO, PROTHONOTARY PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT Defendant RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO STRIKE MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER FROM PRE-COMPLAINT DISCOVERY FILED ON BEHALF OF IRENE M. BIZZOSO, PROTHONOTARY OF THE PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT NOW COMES Irene M. Bizzoso, Prothonotary of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court,by and through undersigned counsel, who responds as follows to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Defendant's Motion for a Protective Order from pre-Complaint Discovery: 1. Plaintiff Ricky Tej ada, acting pro se, commenced this action by filing and serving upon Defendant Irene M. Bizzoso, Pennsylvania Supreme Court Prothonotary, a Notice to Defend and two documents entitled "PRE-COMPLAINT DISCOVERY WRITTEN INTERROGATORIES." 2. To date, Plaintiff has failed to file or serve in this matter a writ of summons, complaint or any document that sets forth a cause of action or any factual basis therefor. 3. The proposed Interrogatories are unnumbered, confusingly worded, and seek information that is not designed to obtain facts that would be proper for pre-complaint discovery to aid in the preparation of pleadings, such as the proper parties or the location of witnesses,but rather are vague, irrelevant and geared toward a far-reaching "fishing expedition" which is disallowed under Pennsylvania law. See, e.g., Luckett v. Blaine et al., 850 A.2d 811, 818 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2004) 4. Moreover,pre-complaint discovery is proper if and only if a plaintiff has set forth a prima facia case, McNeil v. Jordan, 814 A.2d 234, 246 (Pa. Super. 2002), which has not been done in this case, particularly since Plaintiff has not filed either a writ of summons or a complaint. 5. In addition, the Commonwealth Court has exclusive jurisdiction over actions against the Commonwealth and its officers, including prothonotaries,to whom quasi-judicial immunity has been extended,under 42 Pa.C.S.A. § 761(a)(1); See also McKnight v. Baker,415 F.Supp.2d 559, 563 (E.D. Pa. 2006), affd 244 Fed.Appx. 442 (3rd Cir. 2007); Leiber v. County of Alleghenv, 654 A.2d 11 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1994). 6. Thus, because Prothonotary Bizzoso is a state official, Plaintiffs claims against her, if any exist, are not properly raised in this Court,but rather jurisdiction lies in the Commonwealth Court. 7. Further, Courts apply the doctrine of judicial immunity to bar civil rights actions against clerks and prothonotaries, court reporters, and administrators. See Lockhart v. Hoenstine, 411 F.2d 455, 460 (3d Cir. 1969), cert. denied, 396 U.S. 941 (1969; Davis v. Philadelphia County, et al., 195 F.Supp.2d 686, 689 (E.D.Pa. 2002) (holding that quasi-judicial 2 immunity applies to court staff, such as clerks of judicial records and court reporters, who are acting in their official capacities) 8. Finally, strong policy considerations protect Court personnel from burdensome, time-consuming discovery demands in lawsuits where, as here, the above meritorious defenses exist. 9. For these reasons, Defendant filed a Motion for a Protective Order from the Pre- Complaint Discovery sought in this case, to which Plaintiff has now filed a Motion to Strike on the purported basis of"fraud." 10. Plaintiff has failed to specify or provide any details whatsoever as to alleged fraud except to claim that there is a "culture of corruption" and that undersigned counsel is without "privity of contract," and he has also failed to address or refute the legal defenses set forth above. 11. For all of these reasons, under Pennsylvania law, Plaintiffs Motion to Strike is properly denied. WHEREFORE,Defendant Irene M. Bizzoso, Prothonotary of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, requests that this Honorable Court deny Plaintiffs Motion to Strike and enter an Order of Protection from Pre-Complaint Discovery in this matter. Re tfully submitted, TA LOR WILLIAMS, ESQUIRE Attorney I.D. No. 33149 PA Attorney for Defendant, Irene M. Bizzoso,Prothonotary of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court 3 A. TAYLOR WILLIAMS, ESQUIRE OF rHE PRO r F0F'jC Attorney I.D. #33149 H�NO TAF J Supreme Court of Pennsylvania 2013 APR Administrative Office of PA Courts A��1. 29 1515 Market Street, Suite 1414 Ct SERLAN© Philadelphia, PA 19102 PE##SYLyA oUt'lY Phone: (215) 560-6300 Fax: (215) 560-5486 RICKY TEJADA COURT OF COMMON PLEAS, CUMBERLAND COUNTY Plaintiff CIVIL ACTION - LAW V. : NO. 13-1118 CIVIL TERM IRENE M. BIZZOSO, PROTHONOTARY PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT Defendant CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE The undersigned counsel hereby certifies that on April 8, 2013, she personally caused to be served upon the following a true and correct copy of the foregoing Response to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Motion for a Protective Order from Pre-Complaint Discovery and Memorandum of Law in Support of same filed on behalf of Irene M. Bizzoso, Prothonotary of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, by mailing same first class, postage pre-paid, U.S. mail to: Ricky Tejada,EW-1339 SCI-Camp Hill P.O. Box 200 Camp Hill,PA 17001 Pro Se A. AYLOR WILLIAMS, ESQUIRE Attorney I.D. No. PA33149 Attorney for Defendant, Irene M. Bizzoso, Prothonotary of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court k\ -rk z_nl_\127- 112L-C_Kc Z1: ZA__\ Znif\Tq e'r\ (-7(\t\. C) C22 Cci&ti -T-cr -rAnA CC) E,r;L . t2f_Aik_ R-r2-7 nco C:13 IZO-Ti■I OTA1(2q r- AefeArLit. A-T,J-crsc pegi_a_ktitAimz-fagnEx-ranoa Fit-ge.e wit mit,to ti tel T -rwc. jsUAiT etsPonict-,3 PuiMT1 m 'to _vr2fLtieg AgEhiunttf Artiytiemi -fink Pas-rErtnIE fetee tALICE -fratiO _AKLL AAA ep_ci%,c,661\ 1.112/WES +Le Pr2EhANIA0 nia3P,CA7B:Lc zc _ t_h9PLe-te44 +1,\E. Li A A P)( Arfc- AzA■Pr a.P..e.P.,\Ial/i) 4 __C.PPL-c(C_ (.12LJE AJPRIVA- PA,P_P_Pnillinq rc c fkICLIVOPCiteA lôH 4feRomtt 4o9et+f 42.et+, +Le zindOr_< Atter\iii0A1 t-n t. 12nLeeiLliati ALV P,2n1ESS eA.kr,gf\in_tica AdAER (41 nJrai6 +ke nr_E-TTILI.\ s 7_2_141.CL-1 4J keRebN-1 1-D +6 oleipAolov\t< ?Iv Lt1A6) 46P ?Riokkrkde gc_LAac -cAns CLignan tO RdTI4 4,‘? L_Ale AS 14P0 AS 2J Li .4: ral,(21 s cet cae+1, lea-1 JANP_ -EA4A:1\ oLc & NIQ_LACIP AJW- Nne,Jt_. .kpReid-A knotiereisl AAA nR?6eziteisl t&1 iiMeReabE ezA,R.e. 102,4,0( A, i611 tro fr) 11c)101,9,02/2) roL not n.ac Um (-F 11`il C-E)12+-L RERP Lk\ Z.1.K tIALRE GyaK flPiA n R_P-P mpAt- Jrn LITF.Cf\ CE LAA 4 t. ta_L ( l712.LnEt\IT.0 +La eLAL. ct,A,p.c,p.No_ion&Itc4 ,e1 .T2 LAlf. i1 e2i.r....c.z.Lic et _se.,fQ 'elflzte.01,n 6 -Ptak l7-1-4 t -ist2ACT. 2. .1u.P_ 4r 4-Le as.12,04.ixe RLezJtrf ,tei _d),?zA usi .ep7,:,Ads fc, ___<LALL rtrH nf Ave c '16 R_114-Ele Lccf kLii IN ' io is c.n _Af41) (32 b( ) A tet,,tAi zzAPm,t1 4'8 Lg-ikiN1 2aaTI--C LAS r\nT inecir.■ KROkINi 41AeRtA r.( 1141_ __SPLI`Tt r .ELA.1-2x1E1- Ad _Rf1i.A17 ecte,1 ante AAA iAlt_nP12.00nite.1 ,efa,Ca P Lt< 4iH SP i;604An kfitiEgEFORE knnuotAlt Nndst nAnicrT" LIRA OL- Lit. nitnuR +n __ctR ACE +Lf Qps/2.0,1se rt,eAt„1 Alnnv? 1.nndeA4 Lau1t2t Pc_R e_r PA46_2_51ci_ 2 C6 22i +n itsfiPose SAr J ku-rJecoc ._so1LTA16 ri- L31,2 Wr,i-t) tnetAA,43 2__Nno2LIPQR Etc e1c. ha +.6 PcPCTITIfiti PA,P.0(kko 1323_4 Re___(?ectfLit-1 R_S f214. Af2,1 2_113 kactN-rc-c An A LLi T ni\ n11L £f r 7 y ?` L. ;N- 1-C <-17/-V j d7-C_nJ n.L<>il L i.LA ntT --r17 ALA cif t,try _ �c2i.Jk n1.. c232Z�SD PIZo-rN f1n113-Ter2-1 _ ete do 15. 11Li, 'C Pa.RLP.4&1h t sevael t hicharlsitEAJERtnerr PaRgc.P t m_ rnrol cn�ep�� (J3 nnLR.P +mod vtticAzA1/41s“ is i_SU -1 to Jae +L.Q. Q2, J L 4LAL Lt_(P " tin:te_ st rags J, k c b_cb 2.cz1 ._ca tlA k.P,AL &.Pti e zxAel csvetizA s∎lnnd;tdRe_„ 44\ t fiolio LA ,izt,ctS znRP. Lo eta& n1Qt nneanit ►. -r IAZA At c- _11 to nn Petp,\'r .srAt +G,k tVRK' rnictU61 (NI + ;S 4ePIZteL k:ON __) eADLIIre. La DC +Le fieda +.o t-LP >1s eAnkvA(P +I,,e _0-LI#k'a. uk c NAAR i -Lc Afr rlAJ,k. 19A_P.( f\1.0,--do aR.s` /JoRRet.17_ ii- (\noLet_ Am\ ktot coR foLdQ ittIJ16 ?uPPoie1.. 2_ -12e k nnQ.}Jr/Y11©e Pu_S6R2e0f -LiRt Li) ,,s6,\i(le 330H9 AS .6It1-n21\L"1 viz ?A_ cn2,2521 f 2 22 c:u)(PR.S Pie- zt, e tke CnIILLTi1 r7rt_P_c_?_N1a.110 CTTnn) uc set fn /I U2T 1,1k,cin cnakale_ tl,LeRe. e;WOe_RS the <AIZTin N I < eleSZA A +6 t9t D i42 2,-T-r pia. _c. NJ D_ 023 .3_N. ALcils T i\T Lv..1 /02 l_l' NI- A3._1e ;?S.Ent e CD u(4s E IT 2s/J2:2s21 c22 IA o PI,PA L I 4 kB %eto2e, t.14. rOUR4,- AI‘ suAA �, 1���`Td1nlC �Q SCltnl`� � ;s 64t-.,6T cad .s4,c1 PLeitjl „166) ARE _i\11t n i. bi),nln 01ATJ k fiK\ran n� Jse r (Al ;e:C Lio_ I nn i _ATT=nl ( __A‹<L1/4119. --7- ed:. LE bPnAL^. _A H e_c A CAL ACT3D� i.ik;clA .n2.1 1 A L7gL a.. Pil.R_C-P.AL A,J n4k._7 O ki ucln 1,1,6t.c 7 r n A -ft) iv~1 +t re' P-L1 C �a.�_�_��,fl no APT 7.2,a 7. R As e_,n, 11((eiQi1\ lP' AL i\ ezue r_e.. nlo_�oo� tb) ic) cu,A l A. LtLe. -19oIAr_6,1 k2z1 Ala 2t ?.,4 A.e.ALA Ps _t rA.Q_C..-e,it. 7_►1.> et-_s2(: LwIr.LokaDRGiiv..el .et.c s®C ; ale ,"neleafiDAlS 2.1tk-iPS eP_IRAQ �4,Itl� t1A.c oR_ -C-(-rL2T AK berm 2dQL N ktJ- A PA:tQ,cs.ran_ 131 AS P.0 e2 ^12_ ra_ 2S-401 Qi-� � r�uk �s 41,e_ PL AC 4-LE D YcC,6R RCNI .. CC — RIn1.(1C''Tnal nl hi t\A k_ike 11 S S L LI L _PAL _ F211"CTZ r- is b _2_ to kiivP —Ti 1��S� t�f. 1� �o Peni2Cie �,� 1,s,►\ ,J.o nl`p_A1,\ `-2 C C La . nk;Anc.Dn11,11tH Cc\ M e. WA;u1 JL iA PLeAtn62, 11(}C J 1-o z_M.oCsil ¢o 2L o 11cZT ioPiGfau S2 7--E P_zI d.k18 31 L'A\ t "KJ S— S �r k e C APTc P d.PPeR4Ls,N;n6 to i2I (LKIPLLitr PCM +o �1)n L;:11 t d oral 47.44ii..er_P r.16.; `o\�nc oe�( {723LvPA(ni M2 la_c ls.L`1.r92 t)Rca.LInt ;.1 /��(\L `I l_�i1VC/T r�Q.R_r_P__ i ,nnt itlniCh (S lJt�� � 1 •1'n I-LE p.Ll_eJL{�S tit c) t �0 1 J L !as �i1L 1\ I �L 1/ 1��1\�' rS td T e:4_12_L.SD1 tJ1 �s > LCD IA T ezt,2_e_P,rJak-ton2.1 to +1AP _SLAC&IE INCIATT .te ._r1'J© A.CTaDr. PA_la nl0_iani LAs etltieP it reelGita tte r L LAC LA. ok: Rif-L—D72— +I,,e _ _C-r G.,lE nt A LA ICE anrk o:,J Lf ('KTT(1 arm AN? 1soC6n(lc!\ST OR o-fN-r r;1CaZlLi-- =CO c Lou PIRA LJA 4L LAPAIt:t`\ ►nrikAiLai .intf, Lk 4E_ „ep p__l_p_e. P_ to. k1ton3.1 ulAILL A1-C_P s s h-1 \fl e:2oc- ai,�6,L _b F72ntfSS +. uQt ar S\1(0 +4,th Lul rJ .c.-..17P7 r\h iSS r to LQ r'11.P. .�{ 1 r 1� Il� r O Re_s c�2 _tire/ 6 S u c In .N7 « n_CJRE ALPrA a� .n 9_ rJ D� C��7 '�1(TZD ;>J\lnw,/16 a rr oR _1PP13CAT i \ r7-{' [_..�t� �-a 't-JA,.LT r�Li_R.r.P c,_W L;D3.1 (A\ (lo� LU N�nJ ,t TT- -r LLATI r\ ,9.e P 47.A. _r_49.ti p_it 0 3 _ — t-r +I,t.L> ( CP/11 M. IAA a rd J L- a cu-r I o JfA to 06, 12.0 ahL e- aL1.1 s L -rePN11` ,„.„J c nAL17 1 ONIK _ NH LlA Aff ^T „ AL.Q ocoRes.s PI(e� E`LZ�tr r�lC) arl Dgl (nATIU(.S J T1L n.S .-P_N10,ioci i? JLA€rT NUTT'S .&2/18,_ ‘-.4 i\AL■ek e-1 P;tL.eR T 1AT At,H t -LeP Psi Rt,)l ( c +L,att kJLc tc,vQ s:LNel 40 s AA i949Al DR APi22okrea) hilAtCL Ms ,,.Q s fl "aa-i-J R kLe T1.h3rJ OZd lkq no( L f Fn }S.e �"Cr oC _SuLI� c_a Ci_ VQ_nToU TA 2-i' ►'a_R A. ,31i�{.3ll�t�l�3ti2i�,3iit r�.3(DI(c� moo\ `T in X T J D i c p e k a IQ_e,Q.f\10 M L%_k t ki 4„c t\CLM6, C sJLL 1\7 S t MSL1R . tainEARA b IN I l\ ; J oetAe_9Q fn a .1Ai�L€ cie r 32�L�> exP(\ne , LRafizi EnNAPL�T �d:.R_r_Q�ra_ioo1 AS oiT. J. L .. }I,Q -Pu t)../5 m&L\LIA c� nkt cs,+IL ia. _r..P`n1O_±1 D Inc �►I�c In C L- ��L 1 ?2e2JtiAPs f..o2 __C 1�. 1 21C _iPt.1•B.� 'L aDk �o +I�.k 1�1 I rIvA.Q.c.�X10_13si De c_ic. 1Pt_ SST �ra..R_e_ rv�_t��"l pots1 I Zr.(12Tk( 4-,c, +Le -PLARI2n11 4 pe P.d nib 2 (A n,01 '1 0 2.1 A �n J l c, 56_,\J 1-1-40 tiL t1.2 di7A ie*'4 ;S a `17i_Y)`' 1 C ©!Q R _1k I, L 3 R C6 RA tl Ot rI(1!7l IL t 1 P._nl 0.2tiol AR A 11 s P ;PA_ '_rI rio_ -2J3n or a “Dfalt,Del VA,P:r,P k10_2sro 0- s0...6 -i2-Ci? nn_2_Le,,;\10_4v0._ Y222 z,n;_ Set ct.ite,1 ct 2 ssPrGt VIA,s -fu.R—CA.0? , ;sPeA1SPA WAA t ke TQ LIOA_N-T`77,0ALc e,S L k_ LC)I_J P-1' Ni ki 12 ilveL knee _3n\Cd\RPArr T 7. R X10_ t22D.,(21 r, (211, 3 L3,, ,11 +r, [AA 1 -PA S 021A , D2E ,„1 10`1 CkO73t3 ri-r-T 1f\\ tl.Dt Gv_ % dS 3i1 I At T L.DidsLoke,„1 ae _ATTigle C +0 L1�itiJ L� �4 t•ke 19.z112 _<. ,eJ.otki,AL .i1-SD Lac ,,J oRAzA kn am3 tie �Nit_Q.R L�TI� dJt� L „Duo, c -T-Elr t_Sni \ l S C\116'6VrC6 P�ujSPc - � R f'1,e.GteL F'Gt,R,.r,P r\I O.239 I_ it\(c) t vnl fg\ 1.4eNADLtPLikt r_n►fl P -:EAT - Ni ioprfl g 4-Lc knt.1 oRAinLe 4i2t hlc .1LLL1 ,1\tCCLL_SJuE'_-E ;_s �r'�tsC7 �L ANiN1.3-1/1 NI Le_: ILI P( €1\1.C131\C)E NAjoil ReziLiSNI,eA t o,C QPPR,c c-i JC take e L is 4,2 C R2`t REI set - fA, kv( i.I(4) ri3Jt ?LA,R r_P_N cab +- � �T CCSJW 4 _i�L f�S ��R i7nC PS ---- i)Te ee'1 nnA +LP Si o Pe nif Istikki?-1 1Ye 'eOuSP : \-,loa t ni,1 P-ti C 1,9A.o_c.?P, o. H n t r i\nAtEk116 r 'tre t- ,,se nQAel2 f\LATLS AAA a\11 OPC2 e--i ,t•s uN1C�1° i\>J dAtl ,s -?Ls Ong 4LjLL--( La. n61 Lei . P12e icH 1 P RIA\ 6 tLk PD 1T Iry s a 2 _S i�L 1 hecLiil.irt? CaAA2LL( t-Le 11c_-11.0 Sat .ioRtL, > 1/4,1 0,c t 0_ i tlivA 1132/0 tiA r�1 ndeA- X11 n-Tan\l t� _ � K 2gal t PRA LOJAAP ,Al APIA 1.13 6,e St01\.SZd r_QN10.;o21 - LVe t04 0, l ti a.►LI i1 L0� L~f P/_Q,c..0.k10 rnz ID L-2, tke C-C C i -1 LOjns t rim A.?A ^. l.) C N\ ,A.1„R,tt.nk kALrc uu. f +Le_g.PA.tJ Cnno-hD:) +n g'LL.A 1■ • Nth' -r-?[CT_CALtq L.Er R_AL_L`( .Aen:Pz1 (.4212 ek ,r,f:Al 10 —AAA re sc9n;3Sule c7Lel rNjD ctrl thk 1.11,A0N\ houl N NJntae LeC_ KID_ ni),i ic021 , 0201 cS ApPAAPA I� s -�[ lrs la ODitt Lo SR 2 �lZ krJ i eft �. _r32:io(,) ,A,Linto _ LA`? 14RPu\i (.11 r-• sei SEA L InfAeeUrP-1 pcce / \ NfL6.4,ai \ sULl„ P ;SLAG, < e-/l LLSns-Pi "2, tz a_1 ti`\3A.r\VT ��_P.E µo1 �s �� y (\1C_ v‘RI:p_i0-1 €.1\)Pfl1,,1 nl1 tams 1--1.011OR P--eR PA_e_ L'�_�( \i n. 2_``19:/SL ) ,A zAAA 1�2 .3 , ien r_S.S i1`e c A t T_JDN K�1 pk t n 1 � t�u Nc e 1 c 1.I _gi t`1 A U 1 1 n' I `(N I .c 7 11_2 L DR_ .1N i, 7CLA 6 tke 19.A._ZAL c _AUSt1`-1 ezi_2.r.Qn10_ ;2tc,„i21112h [022.s;Ir0231'1 ti� _S"Ci23k " 3 LawASP _ANn oeRe c,P 1 212_ 4-112au PaP I 47�°� ooJaNlY +Ir„t? -Ck 17r L c AK.snr;AJ t.I:+b1 StJ L A din LD.L��J__� r_,t1A ke122,1"1 N1 +n � f T L 4-1nP _soi\Ae i o\r, Nnalm,11- co e \b 1 Kla 10J1 9_k-?r , T k�eR Vti _P 3 Jsi 2 LADS€ 1J_ra 4zA,-i ?11 2r_P_ ester in, t2 .1-LE t\ 1 T tlY ?Z,Q_C_.P NJ a_ i o2.. J TD iU_1� ass c5�n� LcJAse I A eicaRsslt,L 4\(l D` LLN\ ST'st L- tf (Lie e(20- 'rf `F2 JC P.AJI LAS U -PQ_ . . 0I6I Lab(kI n N I\ ca0I eY .sue A r nJnSer Fa_e c_,P, 14f_ .1 cc\ ri. +ke LA,A.Sktakke,1 1 JR rrL_nl �t `N LLIIU L] Oro IMP e T J Ir,.Li K 1Vl,\ to N M tAueAt\ 4LL s b1 (d\ --rl,.f' c i Q zit PA..R,' 2,39).t eY .saa L-1 et t\fl T1t\\ 1M.R_i s to- /JD ti3uA d A ake�t'r--^ttse nealp ' %ice �.i� .�3�C k rGunip1 ._�S�T.kLL LQ,NIi %1�{'Tb n.L�F�1 i�11c-r !C.PJ1I S 11UnSf.l �Lfl t2t,e�dtC L'�tN J W 1 _cie� Off( SCJL.II�'l(ACT emoel, O f EA PA LirT `{ +„ ®iZirr 7 �u �QyCP.nt� 10143(' )L55 CC k ,alei r bb LikAA 101 __SucL ITT L'Lna1 h ,vP fc1.e.e\1 i -1:3zinrt...L ®K ;oc-12 1e- M2t �1 c ._r_e tuD_2o _f e-t .sew TL \ rn K\LtJI 1 kiT 71\1 42 at U ethsp�,s ii\zke L-1 1,\ Fi?li wt3 t,,Nrsp <2n (i� no∎NI,N1� +�`�_i . C-T�.�,\ Prt_�..c_P Na. z) 6L7,tit �iInSel -c-A-t t 11K 4 rnin� o-P1, "� k o i._12t,\.! t a_i?_r. N (21 te) NIA ,L.eR Jrn _Abf -' nQ 142,611111i tl~e`"1 ARE .(\c)i). tZ"- acie R t„ LAW g J71^Q.C.-P.r\lBA 021 156 1,340,n6 ( +.a LLB P✓1_R n18 to-)IA eatkl t ,A&E (Enda NYC vac Pla,iaol riAti (1T2- �C'T oe A , 6 I,e f\M,tkplt ,u mekoN\-_Lif), a D.Pmrr S r_nA .ORnn �J SIC hi11P2,1 o,\ + z,1„,1 +\a. kp_8r, 02 ;s N „ht\J„(tt`i ro72 off. tLe AE(PAnnt _SU e ;_s CL = PA-ELK.S ,i-LA,Dnl aRtt (9\ _SkilkJMN L\ JeiRA IIIJLL - Pn IAIcRS tIN.e to as 4(3 +,3 kILI tkek - 'te 112 ta_2,id,RR I D3 2Alift_912,93 L c2D2 Li( Lw.J.) tie r2Ll.rc_Ll. 22I srJOt2n1 fi0 N l __ ubsotzbe_pl tlA.LS Ini3 aS tgul as JeP,cet e�.RtP, o. io`4 Lana{ AAA SP_tALS eAAZ_ (ei)/ia) ,nl ref-GRNIVANI aR.t,g03 Anel acefnit.0,1 41A,(?(1 roal rlE Re di= AEtAaktisl LINA& i29 PLl.0 :U_^1c1 D"t �� / c-' � �a ZS14 PIe,�.1.44, �° c i- ''*Au.i g • t —r h► n' rend\Nil inl P TULL �agk L -f tJc_ .z22O\1 ►4). SD eR(1-To 3(.1D-TAIL ne -e_Aclak A . tEitCCfirt A-fr „elSfr2dit.r > �1 LP_RirT-1 \f\A,t s i fl Awl toa_ zA tart AAA cnr2/22,et" ca-)1 4- ' 40 R JL DL( 6 ,f,n ck(ARL,{ oL\PCt_0, LIALI rIt A c P e d-frALt\I tLE t 3,1t-\ . Alm rn iA Ni f P9 anmlfLci L2.(fli,J, >AAn S.dkt.c eS 4-49 ut Me kc o A_2C_P.NiO,ktitD Cad/ . Li ,tint 1u CL\ (u 12/211,,W_, Pd 'ant tD (?) eA- c.S,z5,_Kko\D a,01 Jcw.sr-Litt S P yet' cOu_P crP.n(D tlA iai( ok <n S,■ s _f EAU' Vii_2i_ 992 10\ 90v {Gv(c. (Cy r(.0 zif Rtaal o,1 �a � c, P. N13_11.. riv\E A.12.z_ (Doi Aleppot — f as0Ni -10 R41 i is st.J Po.StA Q.,JceAr/P1 LizA9A.r.„a, /r.o2 sari rR.St L /Acc NO Lid co(\o►�S= i\n.,Q_ cv c. &.1,e,[\ p_Rf i u & iJkk &se. OAP Ln,IR.t 4� e s R� Q__A c,i,\ o.c 1 eS Q escs gnARtefi si-�5� �WGtit louni cr9getYliAM fittknl.t eRpitAi&L -7 "2S.I.E /-r�,cse2T.v ` PnvJlal'nL Pk_.-BLS OF- C-UO-AcgL.b&ILN zn(JAI q C3 _L N-a P:�r lkk- Lid.n.L� £���3'Cf113n5{131�t 1> �y cD >,= G5 r� A� � �2 S��C t �l n)`oL ,as - aP lots voD of &Ww— zbu Ri- ,rn jrAvt'. dA PG& Lfp. MQI��iA�`DiC"�.1U° IOAC r nhte- 4- {�e 4-008dtAlo 4aettr A4_; cj a r4ndtt?,k d LLNLi 'SP.j c(sLW (�ki --<u is_AA,LP-1 42e"Ad p_f OWL) P"r-P.Ab,2;tq,.. rMl Af� t aLOUL r�iPi�a� +tJ���1 L�5 �a��lS eD +�s�ar� �o � �l�tsk`��i t�iPeli�ticttGfL`'� �blect��GsS !Ft)P- AA(R-. t o� k{ E ReAI, t +4 LS-We ac /j PWte-k ctDLJJc§e 2_C-Ci/C ��t.aE'.c ?rf lld t c�,a la n�e er �nfi 30 ,IA-4-< kn I (sue. LJ1 16 kn J)8JAAt .1-sAfnSek-i eimIulEct AAA � Prnokat�ctid -CuW oR tq&�Ee� to dsup --<LiLL d-f I�Ityp t� t�e Aoc4�O-k t�p Ao&-,cAp L 4)Atto'k Yi.SR A�Ll i, LIU nSL I fD J�C, +V E AP&A.Q, FLU W -�?A ze e&-Cast to M,f-i 'Op znfzep-r-t- A2,Sl&n A Al f&dLRJ 6'1 PA,P-0 ,10,1023.16) tO bkJ& &dN-QA J Pi ,.��is� r,� r��tP[�u► 6� I , R +�� &J-1OR ZORREALo a,� t.8 sek+�? l,sracem FZeDAeff LDJ)tV-tLfl� V VR dtkA IMA "I �UW OR &Ct1A to PVA, tlAACIA- iL32� r1t114�_[t� to �Ae \JU&,S,�r ?Akr,4 dLLkm ItiSlAoi tsS t dd,, �fl7loaj W N.f-&-.f 7D 1*r'- p 1 Atht,-Kle Maw lee t6- P& -aA� kA & Va-PSs oA r.DsP-T- cam` PeR aR�na�lce 6� ,��_�Q_t�_P,Ja to3w �n� .3rlav,:,euen{J &'OU(PIAL ZOIJ»Wt to aPreuk ��_R.e.P.nV1�t2. ,2�tq��32��� IeFDQ tie L►JA VIIAOP-JQ.L0�0 to - ePVOP. fL AAAA.LP-S DJ &elAff- af its cf re4 .LxA LaKP4 cod f�ti -ie-iAoW-Af &J JOSUP2 4rJIle La 1• sZi -n tt'C,E -A& A(SfaO-O hfdt � a� ;�1 >�e dMLdt k 4- aon-aR <Ar C OA At 2 s,JPlel A t.PAMA tL 14S 16 '&sdkt-, WA 1C�SPEcT�FfU�1 uRS -rfA li� Z-LOP7 nf CnO&)J PULLS nf rJn»dPLAN16 Z-ntA&H LT-aL -ta� <:r.l-)tA fti��-q Luarda A f +ka+ ,ke AJ , +�ql . Aa later +,o hP -Mf- lA 4-euLeZYJ rAeP-- wt +E P(.PAJtd�S Jo +kP f8lln; AL A - soil AJ t� t�P n(1.&n dj& 14caW JAfa,l , wkA s�a egi-l;jAw-As n' Pli<- ,J88 nL AS d i+At-(SJ PJaAE 9,03 ion king . 41,0,JLA6 k&l tJ \'Iq) -A L.Alti 1-12 �IJP.d./, IbOl _t.ANIP fi& nice Znjp-t kLp- 1 QUA cu�[tst� PGI cm t3 AAte; Lao Dui 2c3 see+k�Sti� ��J THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY RICKY TEJADA Plaintiff CIVIL ACTION- LAW C_- V. NO. 13-1118 CIVIL II r IRENE M. BIZZOSO, PROTHONOTARY OF THE PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT Defendant ORDER AND NOW, this day of ?,el-I 2013,upon consideration of the Motion for Protective Order from Pre-Complaint Discovery filed on behalf of Irene M. Bizzoso, Prothonotary of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, and Plaintiffs response thereto, it is ORDERED and DECREED that said Motion is hereby GRANTED. BY THE COURT: C4 /71_e?j J. 1A)tib S11411t 2 A. TAYLOR WILLIAMS, ESQUIRE Attorney I.D. #33149 Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Administrative Office of PA Courts 1515 Market Street, Suite 1414 Philadelphia, PA 19102 Phone: (215) 560-6300 Fax:(215) 560-5486 RICKY TEJADA Plaintiff CIVIL ACTION - LAW V. NO. 13-1118 CIVIL TERM IRENE M. BIZZOSO, PROTHONOTARY PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT Defendant MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF THE MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER FILED ON BEHALF OF IRENE M. BIZZOSO, PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT PROTHONOTARY I. INTRODUCTION Plaintiff Ricky Tejada commenced this action by filing and serving upon named Defendant Irene M. Bizzoso, Pennsylvania Supreme Court Prothonotary, a Notice to Defend and two documents entitled "PRE-COMPLAINT DISCOVERY WRITTEN INTERROGATORIES," attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and made a part hereof. Plaintiff has failed to file or serve a Writ of Summons, Complaint or any document that sets forth a cause of action or any factual basis therefor. S S The proposed Interrogatories, which are unnumbered and difficult to decipher because they are confusingly worded, contain questions such as whether Defendant has " a responsibility to make sure her staff and office of the Prothonotary for the PA. Supreme Court Middle District is in compliance with the PA. Rules of Court and applicable statute - and does compliance thereof render the defendant liable." The Interrogatories also inquire as to whether the Defendant is covered by insurance, and in how many actions of law or equity has the Prothonotary been involved. They further ask the identity of the agent in the Prothonotary's Office who is "responsible for stulifying(sic) or impairing the procedural due process rights of the Plaintiff," and "how many times has this office stulified(sic) or impaired the Plaintiff efforts." In response to Plaintiffs Interrogatories, Defendant files this Motion for a Protective Order on the ground that the questions posed are vague, overly-broad, and fail to target basic factual information to aid in the preparation of a Complaint,but extend far afield into the impermissible territory known as a "fishing expedition" that is prohibited under Pennsylvania law. II. ARGUMENT Although pre-Complaint discovery may be appropriate in rare cases to obtain information to aid in the preparation of pleadings, such as the proper parties or the whereabouts of witnesses, it is not proper for a "fishing expedition" to determine whether a cause of action exists or whether a pleading shall be prepared in the first instance. See Luckett v. Blaine et al., 850 A.2d 811, 818 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2004) In this case, Plaintiff does not merely seek factual information as to names and addresses,but rather has geared his discovery toward a fishing expedition, which is not permissible under the law in this Commonwealth. This is particularly true because Plaintiff 2 in this case has in no way identified what rights he claims have been violated. In that regard,pre-Complaint discovery is proper if and only if a plaintiff has set forth a prima facia case. McNeil v. Jordan, 814 A.2d 234, 246 (Pa. Super. 2002). Plaintiff in the instant case has failed to do so, and has not even filed or served upon Defendant a Writ of Summons, Complaint or any other document that sets forth a cause of action or any right that Defendant has allegedly violated. Further, the Commonwealth Court has exclusive jurisdiction over actions against the Commonwealth and its officers, including prothonotaries to whom quasi-judicial immunity has been extended, under 42 Pa.C.S.A. § 761(a)(1); See also McKnight v. Baker, 415 F.Supp.2d 559, 563 (E.D. Pa. 2006), affd 244 Fed. Appx. 442 (3rd Cir. 2007); Leiber v. County o Allegheny, 654 A.2d 11 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1994). For this reason, in this case,because Prothonotary Bizzoso is a state official, Plaintiffs claims against her, if any exist, are not properly raised in this Court,but rather jurisdiction lies in the Commonwealth Court. Courts apply the doctrine of judicial immunity to bar civil rights actions against clerks and prothonotaries, court reporters, and administrators. See Lockhart v. Hoenstine, 411 F.2d 455, 460 (3d Cir. 1969), cert. denied, 396 U.S. 941 (1969); Ginsburg v. Stern, 125 F. Supp 596 (W.D. Pa. 1954), affd per curiam on others, 225 F.2d 245 (3d Cir. 1955). See also, Marcedes v. Barrett, 453 F.2d 391, (3d Cir. 1971) (holding that judicial or quasi-judicial immunity applied to clerk of courts, a supervisor on the staff of the clerk of courts, an administrative assistant to the president judge and a court reporter); Davis v. Philadelphia County, et al., 195 F.Supp.2d 686, 689 (E.D.Pa. 2002) (holding that quasi-judicial immunity applies to court staff, such as clerks of judicial records and court reporters, who are acting in their official capacities) (citation omitted); DeFerro v. Coco, 719 F.Supp. 379, 381 (E.D.Pa. 1989) (court held that defendant Coco, a court 3 clerk who was carrying out his normal duties, was entitled to absolute immunity against civil rights action filed by plaintiff). In Guarrasi v. Scott, 25 A.3d 394, 405 n.1 l (Pa. Cmwlth. Ct. 2011), the Commonwealth Court found that"a court administrator acting under direction of a common pleas judge in a Bucks Common Pleas proceeding has quasi-judicial immunity from Plaintiffs constitutional and civil rights claims." One reason for extending the judicial immunity doctrine to those who perform a quasi-judicial function is to prevent litigants who cannot sue a judge directly from"vent[ing] their wrath on clerks, court reporters, and other judicial adjuncts." Gallas v. The Supreme Court of PA, 211 F.3d 760, 763 (3d Cir. 2000). A Court is "authorized to enter discovery orders 'for the convenience of parties ... and in the interest of justice." Pa.R.C.P. 4007.3, Explanatory Comment. The grant of protective order is fully within the discretion of this Court and is especially advised where, as here, time- consuming Court resources are involved. Strong policy considerations protect Court personnel from burdensome discovery demands in lawsuits where a meritorious defense exists in order to curtail the deflection of public resources from unfounded claims. "Pretrial matters [such] as discovery are to be avoided if possible,because '[i]nquiries of this kind can be peculiarly disruptive of effective government."' Mitchell v. Forsyth, 472 U.S. 511 (1985), quoting Harlow v. Fitzgerald, 457 U.S. 800, 817, (1982). Courts have repeatedly recognized the propriety of staying discovery. Compelling Prothonotary Bizzoso to participate in discovery at this stage of the proceeding would undoubtedly amount to no more than a meaningless exercise,particularly in light of the immunity defense to which she is entitled. Thus, public policy is served by preventing burdensome and time-consuming discovery in this instance. In fact, even if Prothonotary Bizzoso were not afforded judicial immunity, it is clear that Plaintiffs proposed Interrogatories 4 do not target basic factual information to aid in the preparation of his Complaint,but extend into far-reaching,prohibited territory under the law in this Commonwealth. III. CONCLUSION Because Plaintiffs proposed Interrogatories are improper under Pennsylvania law, Pennsylvania Supreme Court Prothonotary Irene M. Bizzoso respectfully requests that this Honorable Court grant her Motion for a Protective Order to preclude Plaintiffs Pre-Complaint Discovery. Respectfully submi ted, ,w A. Y R WILLIAMS, ESQUIRE _ Attorney I.D.No. 33149 PA Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Administrative Office of PA Courts 1515 Market Street, Suite 1414 Philadelphia, PA 19102 legaldepartment@pacourts.us (215) 560-6300, Fax: (215) 560-5486 Attorney for Defendant, Irene M. Bizzoso,Prothonotary of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court 5 Exhibit A _ ,. Tr4-C C-06RT nNe CDhflpCiDt\l ,FLOC dam- c-L ��S£f.LL�' CZ`12L - ra xj-rc-r n r� IBC -r:c-TA aA JS_ ��Lr�-C tip. �:ZZ20So I I A?-F- [aVt.:A:bft A-ISCO1tEV I WRIT?-go-4 =Ad-n-:Z36ATO R±£S IN �.ccl�2elv1�►L,� c�11►�n Pu.R_C.P. Rio_ �0�3_���to�3 � f,�, �1��3_M rd �to03_S Gv �i�05 1� , 2 v�P C;C,nP� tJl t�v`P1 `�DV f1� PLEJ- - [Cillf H P�o;S 1�i n� k1�,e Jaen o!,� �P�.Q SS a�I f�S�o , To ►.S�� Pe�� M2 �a.cs.u. 2�or et se4Q cn] &L C_P_ r3 8_131 1(33 c(Ji t-ot,.\I,) 1 PQ.C,S.A. tq of J Pd.��.Q. 10� 2�C�c�p�f 6RUi ZA t ltv ap.- �_P. 3�It1���2�a1 ,31�3f� SP�n1S.b;�ft� fp Mac4� 1�1 �21Q �.SiDt�f' GIC� 04t'Ce Uk �6 PP-D4 LtLlkl cop- +Lt PQ. _SJP�H/IP' Lnil!�� Mii��� LS11STiSII�., lS IN G�rS�Pllu�iLA f�Il�n TV�C I'�d. iC�L�'_� el 18Jkl and �PPIiLQb�e 1kAt — -- doe_S �o LDMP{IGln;i� eRP�t &Agel t�e nlJ - PAAnt J ILAD,e i ISPeef+\1 LSA AAt l� ku►( ; �ll�ea t6 Plra;�ts AS LdANav- CJ120-.� TJ2SdnAt to 123 '6� Io3 cd Mavgs A%e LL L�P,t _M ,1fn( :tin t�P oF�;&P- J , an! AN " 1ccZit;Drq 1�7a_�2.�. P. .D2_ rS � oFr►Le [rtP� �� �� �o eniLtQ PJQS:lallt �o PQ_ R: .?_ Esc �z Ira.cS.a_ sco3 ��- sLlil f,6\6 CbKAoO�K W,�A 0,S + a of-ReE (A t ot,�P-A :::C P2DLVAJPun f�li� 1'RocE'SS Kf�ln� �� b"i +�P. LkMdZ;&A ArA �rnt d �o t(�dNS P� CSc�P�{ JI IJ:�N D Plfmd) +L` wc�d Q tkE ~S occI. Al eribE �Q.�.S.U_ IgSlJ ✓ 7 +o In2 C6SP r4D_ 0110 NIAL 20t2 ANA N-1 MdP 2Dt2 H2 i'L1.C .SIIt. no 1 '0� _S P Q nA eo�e .C-F- Ln3,o t'a.O_..d. 31 I I Q+_Sp-a exPk&sS* D Q i tp fc zl;jnl h,pnset; ,c i�E ��dp± _Set foR+� iH K2 t�Lt_C_S_�. 2'}3"?13�. kotj mnr - I tttApl �X�, tk �, "Ltp t� stuk,W no ��e P[6,N4tK (d zit Sul 4-oP- CA Ye rJD l'S)-M nh7 niI '1 2-001 fill ZDrz ; TSB P41T 2Di2-; 2�1"l n11.f�.2o�1 ; StM nft'T sIs Nnr 2fl,1 NNA Ss' 04120(L tr �WP A4A, CKPerP W,�A ( u� ssYS efc etc b� \tt)QtuQ Df _Sdl ItAili l , V.nW t\AZAP "i &C tbNs A+ 10c OP AQ- u.H etc. -�2 ALPA� ctW .-�c JkA " 1a� ��tS 0� Lp zLf i4al{ IL( Lie ep 11O, 1�at t�kRP-Of , �OeZAJ kN'J8\A t Pr�.k�_ �sl�to t�lto� t� : , e6,a& kO 41� .a(jo- to ip-AA-cfe 2 Gs. .� "t t P,- rvrE' `cS�'e�S�S Pd.C.SlI. iQ2�1 t.� t� t�Q.C'S.%1. IDl �i'� r + t�flen;''i�1I Glrv'1t11At.f l -o tl .t WSONS llUDL tt� tklt caFRtF' 0( -' flenLA�ObO 'EY-AM A-A %)? 1AVIA is t&i)Ljtp-j fi� L;S c��P��-a,t� y�te. �1�-�.�,�� �-E�..� �r�.�.c.P,�D. �toc D ��tn�� c�,� �. c�R�;rt�.a..� �o cn.S�n.�.�I•S eA4&,0a tkRe-O -tt� knM 91PLaRLL At.DV GP. 0��1o1"I.i K�JI") coil ► KDl(L to, k01S 1� gklt� Will W- e44 i-nrt t;Ctej b� 16 tS11Pl- ` .S�Lvn 1 G:t: "mo Lis.6U& (� CZARi P IVA, �� I1 00l Ltd' a ktM,l? ol\A AAe znt-3Jatjtp.n 4'6 40 PARi(PS 20 aV-A�S ak"-- PgkItl�' a +�l9 'Jlt.LIP (�,t0{�� OhPt'?p bP�IJIflr(S &-Vl LnAJtP.A� jr)n1.1 F,1A.R..C.P_rJD, ;`tDD3.1 ,-Ctrl lo.Q 'I'GtPri AS Set- CoRtc u4 i7/A,- jb, i.DD2 J i�L. I PS as Rrza j" fn q 6"( PA,f.t~"p.,j D. Koni .I ?JR-waAt +D 142 r.S_�. sS.3,ss"Lt�t _ ss25 wteP 4lizA -T i "1 Coc�i�C nF cf1,J!Dr� S,c z���E2L�n(�� L1n1T`( dS_ 12En1E r fi. r(,2,1 S� PP-(-)-rw ono-r-&Q--( PR cD o`((1 P U nIt - S�rvs � ;,v t�nL nl1GlN�l1� C/1�rCf.�� JO-��ac.� � �J�ntCln SP�JI(�_C�tt�S��?S �ln� :CP1,lcSt�e — me.,i t tPSt- a rip's ot(�c�tn� f�c;Mlr serfs t�I �� R�nuto�S AAA MMOCDN � Q = t'RtSfl�l SIP ;3� cen.s�SL;P fob r'a.stG� P�c[�P.aJC4n� `12 �a..C,S,I��l�(�2 SG1nd�P. Qst C (da MALI al o(IotiJs r-drP aRLAPi0 Z,:iU; l+q ,-'n J + L-ndSp- D� �,CQ C�f tf,p- Fkn4NbNo 1p2H St��d�k11P �JQF nk- r�nlnlG 1,, LCA !1)MV DAiVJO-A(4\ -AJQ 1St1t1C 4SGD f?o_ 2,0 S( 62515 f-�G1R�rSbcJR6, 9G n;o�- 2-s�s' (l s ko UA �-lA :fi CJrt�J� epe]LJrLo — -riAr- znj3,,Z P z);�- cnv,,W&� fLEL of i'eJ. Cf\iSkPLa� 6AU '`tL�D -AP AAPZA rt rj1.M L)- +to,. (� A Y'!!1ICXAD,il�i i�!3td As Qel1 a� r�Gl, _�. 111f_3112t�� X11 t�1-��i�t� 1J✓ co`� ��Jt � f? AE(-eJ�,AI\t � kffv\L a �'�S c�?uS���IC� 1 t� n{1r�« SJ��L ►��r� ��dK� �� i����� D� r� C29 D f, LLRt,r.�tr n11�' �tst�2tC �, sS � tv�t�tsdiJf� ��� t 1'LI. Y�tl iLLRLoC"— t d a-�k LDAAAAI - t P('D4,OADIG1P'I LJJdS-J X5-1 tr �L!rZAI'Lo MUJ,32 ; +n vi�� -ltAA t �C} L1. �.�_ t"L r�lta� t L�3 t� rf,J�i t �� SE � ti ©F ► Ant AO( It C -any Pu,ul to is kg ckKt,.tp- C,'stA A P\P-4n me� �'D 2t1 6e �iS;�S,��n k-D rlk-V IS( Alj 13t .BUILD Prz-D- c�JPJA� t�tii cI? s_c JUTA� to L4 6Mla,"It.eh 1W S tti CAARA +LD ieAILct�.� � 1,�� Isiu�� OZD toL ,2L L &t�A, M'1 tJ 2-D(2 s i ���I���O c> rn(tQGtr rn I1e c'i�oL� icP�' � U2. aocaS ttLLL �� ��>k cWAtkrt r""nf - LA bD-tL �ta kltp. 41 ("u, Eam Aj r?3iP_ Df Lb6)Ll1' �PGt f,-1,f. S It! F-� -vo- fKpi.xS( 9" ) /Z)k riJ1�k� (tll�Otl�•�'•'� .i (9Lur�TV ziti ti kdr�- PPaD GPA 0 F2 U+' la'� 142 1'L(,C-S G(..n TO(11, 2')51�2) ZAJ_ hD W 00 n l rtr S .LLL� h.,r�L� kkd i`,�L2 S ir'APA �IA L 0--�FI+6 At --SCJLL fDK ,(-gse rJ Q.L O [Dq MT ur2 OT LD t 2 J Z41 A,O,2D t Z i S-01 c.1 tJt� 1-D(Z/ S-t 5 i a-r 2D C-L h�tLC-�. �v�� �a?�,r1��t0�;".rS�l �.5 ��•�r� �J�2�t 'Alt's yo ..Surf i-L2 t _T a (eRx�t 4Le aAtdi LTA J Ut C CAl kt-D tf O iSM GtS it L VWU- "IP NJ t���lv1i �G,ti i!/tiu Sl4il bt f-AC- b-i tfi kL4 ©FJL� ILIA UM--, �,DIJ NAA.41 i'�✓,° ,OAS ai tAd 0.) adl-H �1.Q.5 � � C lx LeAi 1d ����/DFct1^rS OfCLL,� a.s wP[W At 02.01l.,DAOUk,f W"'�.M St�J()tjd wJ 4 0(o c f I a t>� tJ 1 kln t E'6 A ( to k -A(I d q +d) 't D tk ,I,P A KLD tt z POD` lD'! Cc� 1 tlnL nrV�ntGtl ><rrn!',�r ��U� ; ' Y� Snu� 'ti�ii� ( L�.0 DEirE' i,'t�U1i.CiLiF � PXPSJ AA la E tn(19 It rs . ' Jt T'u CSt�RlAinl � ' i�C- C� k'd,Q<L.P,4p,gj)Co A( 6 tt1^ Of -eApairnL ?Lj� eosr-.s Z dAjv s (it.£,Ctdo- 10,011 0C"DII A�.0 -I,Atk At 00 DN kA nt-)i �o(�,�r fit~;�� AA Olt � -taW A: 2-S�D lfsL LA P,-� LAM RM U rat A fU3-0 ,I k'JQ: J&A� �U '1L. t�.L^S,LI ��S�L�7:��1 IV k-LLLKL 'n y 711IT7 vuulclelt, � f71 . T/9 ILI V� 1 e�l n Q 7 - " P T 117,1 f- -6)5- d-!Tlyl�F,97 )70111'j- 17, IN74 3-Ti7l--3 yr t7F 7Q-17 5N 5-0'31+-d ap jv rp cj'j '�w)o, �-Vv Ti `TY 1T if TJ 61 c4l \J� C7 I �VVPT ? -MgPq rJApTFV- r� vw�i- -CT, JC/ 3M+ yjl�Y14 F�F- �4 ANA �f y NUT I Ti I A ai� (71 i F C,7+ 7P,-P fV7 J7 5T RICKY TEJADA, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF Plaintiff CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. CIVIL ACTION—LAW IRENE M. BIZZOSO, PROTHONOTARY OF THE PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT, Defendant NO. 13-1118 CIVIL TERM IN RE: PLAINTIFF'S MOTION Pa. R.C.P. NO. 1017 TO STRIKE DEFENDANTS PETITION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER DUE TO FRAUD ON THE COURT 1 ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 13th day of May, 2013, upon consideration of the above- captioned motion of Plaintiff, and upon consideration of Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Motion To Strike Motion for Protective Order from Pre-Complaint Discovery, Plaintiff's Motion is denied. BY THE COURT, Christylie L. Peck, J. Ricky Tejada, EW-1339 SCI-Camp Hill P.O. Box 200 OJ(i d Camp Hill, PA 17001 CO i� 01 3 Plaintiff, pro Se A. Taylor Williams, Esq. Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Administrative Office of PA Courts 1515 Market Street, Suite 1414 Philadelphia, PA 19102 Attorney for Defendant :rc 74 Lc L T L LL fl fin\ cli .QLdnl1 r-T , 0 r L , N-7 ■ hr Cr r- , P rJNLc L L AS-r A t2IE4t( d I also_ 1,10. 13-t l l22 kis - I (Mel estnPPe1 t0 PRocee 11 tnit �. R-rz-)n CO tc l sec. oink. cnr- f� _: •.I T c: c. MaTILW P4 CPn10.239.k,ttil R (54.1D CV!I T Pa_Q.r_? No_raet i:: co.! ?h4E PlkAisaAtES A t2 74€ i.4fitiR-E of ARt►E,ibT,J4 Pitet.gata33 1f4 AV31 l P.A,CCf.46.tool To CA AeFoRA 10: THE PLEADIA �S - RAAsAc.-rin,iI ne accdtuNCES PaittNa.1033 .1141S c.oukrc- 41 PQ.,c.bb►®ioar PzittP,140 04 panii-r-rEe Pa.e.- c! nt o s o3D , Jf( k1 ca\ fat,n-tifc r c Rps,2ect I;i'1 rJth cirJ/ +Le knNioeildotp t )Likri 1b .Iu items a{ irkP -roi1,Dt.3t.AL rtGticts +off tLe /Mao VQ-raP4& I Spa+tPi2 a1R.St.Ltnnt- t.n, 112 et sSokt, caI2eI ALLE tJltL (d\ orJ the tR.et.n►S`PS" t-7A.-e.r.1 too. ;11 _I cJ'P_. 1, ti 2 Pli.e c.-e(\J o, 2_023.11 ��J a f�cn In CL crAf.1 be KeAleJeateAl fra.R.C..P.n1,o.2Mq 101 JRty £c (J)c+Loll Pd,R e.PA(1 231.1) mAttP.P a(S LAP-tU-sriazi i-In tke ,elGPC" LoLiPt c AStStR t a pltSPa<kt.onl ohulE PR_ac1r,ti) Pa,Q.r. toy tLe s,s Ker,ne cndkt 17.a,R.,c.P,niD_12 /J 1.22) A, tz ►�� I bl zitnA 23°; L1.0) I2\ t\L {,tie NUAL I P I +Ratnls6tr_tL oN rs\ cake 10, ►3--iliv 212,4T t22, t'a:r.z,G.scogi Lx- Rif I,ttfedt,on, 14+s ice 2+J - IJ1STt 1) 6PDni P lain trit- suzi -f�c�/�I �►� Ian 142_1_Lf6 L nnaSEAR.NLlTr Bi_S iO MP A:1-A-I t n e hJ t i It a tflS act tn Re-1 AP.nA C uI t�Dn1 33\41 IS c,'tezi h.P1ge(o"1 -1,6P ci2ci YC PCAE5 ©f nuAsoi tn1 ( /��ZL��T`� I7ra.:12_c.P IJ6_t,o23..t (c\ al A Ti4J j) t?altC, )Qi 1,ft'3.103tJ ICAzolJ (26 ,41 O( ,V Na -("Too_ pA_R.e.P.IJO,tn3nJ in cal so codAs"el A 10-1 oee_ Pettor ref 19126t.eeli)RP hnLiSt c..Adce. t74,R.r.P,n0.1 023.32Db.H ,43 k1P-( I\ CST iae held 3.11 �r�Tt I�fI�T LaifT f0 APP 6 Ahl - nIQRCs\ CL]AL S-r r T 4 cLKLIL 1�►( het- ut /12 .-0212 cfl L.av,Ato al LiYat 1 T-? tkEIZ.eto 1\1\1] +k() RJR& �I1e awed PER,_m.LA t L2R`1 4A R key.cfl J/Li Lac ta,J A Ghl +Le_ 1.12 0.8 ' a pa_pcpP 140.1023.1 sULL LAPkAMR`( J .NTLAT321 Iltlfadtl f\\ NnaJucnt t P a,c.s.U,s S t t c I i t o n h n\ r t a R .s nat. ►h i Jrieve aloes - ctt k O,,1 nna t te12 u t tPanl.sac' cod N0. 13-Ic(b -- c- gQ.R,c,91.110,t433 _103i Inn ►t,tefak1 A .foR ok,,do.f1Plre. 4i gARRI - K l AAA\ _Li -1119 knL 4 EtiR ,tse i)r ni rAL' te<E La ■ Q 4-- 72 19i PPPc S ac H2 a_l.CS,A.. 2So2,2S22 s0\te.44 ‘.1►tl„ tLe aiat� t� r Phi +o N?ou,nk tine LaJRt' ►J++t -F.orPt,e. ezLet.e,Nicoact taR i7feC 'T `T7t\E De . e.61-AA PA c.P 1•10.4i6161.I 22 ,A, i2L ¶2q LA AAA c©3 �� tAicL �S -n2At.n EhlteR z /A\ - - P1.P.r.P, hica. roan Au/N11 eiatnt,.rc (c U C( . Jk3 „dam! ~ST s,,LL 4 PA 11\ It ;oec&fl t +LA. S.ethe,l ilfe loRce e,esPPflnlS,bl,e ,nl fSJ1Td ? AN' �YU� I.L.U1t! c0R +L\.s +?,A. P./1.P...c,e hil Ti 1 ! I yUN\--c le 1✓LA 1J V f Pllts�.C.i .(a,Q PLt.2 1210-12LaL t22),L 133►e ii\( 44,.e C.L CIS te r P hill 119_bAAK1 ALe ttk,s tiN 17 \S 4A L-E C.nn\7 .L.T 1'eiAAc.TZ 17n1 ®cr,L t!c t , ,e,1 niuRess ALLA k'zA.P_e.P4o.102 ►s , Cwt- AA LTILAi..aL-E erkt t> eiA.RQ-C.N.01,1uL,1 irL1.163 LA h2RPI31 — AAA ln1 Oee-R1&k 01 of MZ �Gt.C'S./(_3�ZSa2,25 vac LLOHIlI►_Lnyto el4So►,Jkn tint S tf2aAISU,t4,01\ a_N 1 ATRit t-1e NJ >ot �Tlln�T �eRnf1.S �f�� z,,,hAl:lohl.f c, Vk 62.4 a t►tP.a) �P trc�✓ .-TAUS, PeR VG1,P c,P 40.E 03►j tke elu►NItA' aid +1,,s Iati.i'01 nlennanel -1aP eelveP I,`1 sLIn() L.eig_tuttJ Ut _r \totAo'1 (a)rc .CaR aPPeA►P ►�1 sflknt nAuNJni.eRlS� rv�i1 .S3 S-T� -t2 ae,K:GI, 2SDZ,2c22 to L t9gLit irtb8 ►JIn1cIn 1,ziS t tal-r N IZILi-cr }o aLim tLe cx:41,kr. / de k7ROcess AS ctttel ankt 1'o 1.11CIA L1� S.e\ LAS u o J 4T +o S C,bJSeC sulk„ etezu,nla.( tJeRe LYT illnPRA,P.f etc Inn�oREOz le L at to LLCM £a._S 4 LoJt'ke,a .oRAeR -o SdAbhl czitsse inS\C21 ski LLtLiSe hp iS hi( 12.0_12134-1 EIkTt`1 a,zl ..( ,e0PLo crC NiO-TpkettApil cdeDAn eAl_lotAb +lie t -SGc��D,J uk NILL11-100 AS wet‘aS NiatlraLit As A tl.lfZ,l PQRrii deft_. ,n1• ‘6R._ 12a-TO aAl-ce..A6) to CL meek olowlJ w Z:zt t ek0Le s AILOztcs.usidi Nntike. Aid > ,,I,rt� pu,R.r.P.,vu7,23�.b lmodiateH -able ?aAf AA),d0_1401 AS INtteRior,XkoM AS Set fvRtl �nl '►2t'A_C,S,�A.� �o2,�G�/o ,ee cPeiettJ M 'J es St\1 121-1k1k_ 11,L3+P [- L G_Ov nnn r r I Z L , ►v°r k 1Z c r (J R n1nIS-i LLLA.n17 A r21c -71-77 Al1A ( t-as2 I.J. 13 ti1Q) 1'iatntt fir, _hitliccai i M ce lemultaleal Js. &RE.=Cal Cbl6,11 zR£n1-E (41_ arY7 ns� Pt24?N onlo�r�R`} sue■l.rr QtR_c.P No_ L. of's x i _dJ£R s cM r ea.f c.P Ma.Iaiq 1/A nl© nn 3R2 #L 1A- tz J. ( � I.S r j ca RA, o dial 1'Ce ee,n11 Gi kLtG+E LASE u unttif State 16s -F: S3L cI12. tgg1\% L.3 ?ie.\ Reim arr c lat L ?a:�.� c,P,Ni8,2D33 loptnL 1es - cUH s1-JDiE'n1 t'�t.t� �'.'102i' n14i/ e-e.PPSe t94,R:C.too1 M2 ,1 6I2,r1a ,P P,L ()Dr stlanui-JRL I)u,P.t. P.,J0,1L i.tea+ 1611olttltlo ckets RP rnRRect chitl (\rot nn,eanit +a is 1 L; 1. --rinokt_, Ur c^at t LS Loa\Peke to st'a c tlne ni 111 t k e.R S (N CLAW c nl t•.■S Altr iA 4\i ...(n o11 VAOt.. 4 �/cam tl�e �t,t*ts,AAA olP.0\AREA k n 4,L) IaeSt .n 4Le s1'QP+Af_Aq MAP r n1 1ln+s a1 t t��101 t� �' d ke tieue u)R RLt i- nn P GEte 002 A ziatt nbt f„:312 1411.1 terARIAL 12Jk?CLIPS 47a,R,.t.ga1 (al 1"1\ 11cA..1902c42-.l L 2. s conk V .kfcciP. keRelo-1 kat .DA i wio 42.4.P.e.4?rJUat03 stateNl.2.A.'1' OR cnt.c1LisLo,,1 J -eXPI e.ccatl oR ski +Le foRem,n runt;o,J -Cod' JLii6PnMA1• o,J 144 Pleat. /404 h.( ,of AMert;rtin +he Qct.cm) Air NIL). c_n1i(oPiI1 +o tlne Pt.eAnh. iletdn1SD►.Ct,o,JS ok. or,C69PPJt c b-1 -foRe(otn( (LIM-PP ziau,n c1t;iV ,J2ki maitd _, cLR ,- t_. RPtaS S rvlli 156A -e\nEA CkS cciunsei 1 R T a„.1% , N LATEki b�l t�nowLn't ,+\ten\t as hied aS C AdO AAA _iAb P e)c,-° .0n1/cR tnnPitQA R�LARa1;46 t2A4_SA2t,Dnis Air NO.t �tic� t J tL ,J(jte.4 .su4 trLA,1 Skite,n `12 AAA LL eket1AnL;n6 cnrlPRnPe cnit'tcrenll,QS t eAel eRc ta\nsel 3 .A TA' -1 D2 aki.o7ne-'► IAI #33M L7a. .6:S IA .ruka\ at ivi /eke nt b'1 'AAA tRAAIStatt,an13 tits raAAtRIAL a>r-66.6v\ LAa12 �neR�b,�7.�r�JReIS clnal e�c��Rk�®nt staff lt� ate }s u�`�,e�.e b`1 tl.e sa;a ' owtl�i glk_s�Ckarentikto,is ci k1.� tJIAtek A\ .( a� tAIG.teatS P..Llo�i&I b`1 r_o LA-P l tts\j Ai Ra.RC.PAID:go ko S3loSrAbeti 12A.R,f,,tooi +In,S i"t fi� � tnal 2_thl AS +t A takRket beIAL tiekpal tied PL i -P.N10 ib LINALK [l) act taik-Lktn Ceti 1,1 tlt,e {attdt.0t6 twnif ruul_Seat i.S atf Rnlkttani cvIal L xec ltll 4.PsRfLor' Pd.R,��Vo�at\AACAf cod icalt)lgllso)tiiicvi:�1.1ousA ...� sJ. �4 /5/. _� . sn1 -rt C. -(714-l S cil, -TCL Lad A\"C`i e1 1.10_ t3- 13° s(tom rn cn :J.:: r. AAAK LJ l cc heReIM 4L t\.,1 S EAtk`l L.4LCP e n 1 ' S4\t_ SPR\Jt lk FQ3ce-_ ageL o tsnAW.D -0IL azinkktAgRoltnn u12t 4 Pve ,n1.1 6AA ,no- hDA -11R LiJr\ .eaet +\' 11LOJ RP DC. a MeA E`1 (\e>a Nna ft AAA L8k..iq4 L o tLt Af. 4 oLNke dVIt kAA iou htL s ec +Gke e- �,R�rae�;ts Pz{.t? t a.No2 (A\(-2r& kti4o LI\ — REA\/.1 _, -FLIRSLUIAt to e) c'ArsiA 40\311 .JePfte ?A,R,c,Qpin. 4;, AS 10 iu v�an!s Li Se ,IS (o\(k"\ (;:.)1_0 rd ,1,1 atf-R;,nz1k,o Rt-P o,ih &NA Exer ik 01 A. 2.i. 10 3( t 1\,2RLA: }-&sal -1,0R0 L X 13 cc t�.s tyl o eA,14.PAVAS M Q_r,S,d,L( 2 .Snore. cJcsnioetzv1A L,At1 c, uPt[oZL ,nne LaSRic lwilsp n ��� 13 � e �t �tl�1 -1,06)k Pais:4'R .ey Ait1i t 4;3 (11) Cpl.; {i' �j'tt1(NotV- �A3-,t i cLQ �T 1 1 -rum _SL\aiTZTIOR zrAtier . f Ai -q L LAA I.N2a L =T1.2/07° PiA,� ,- �1S_ -vim zz ; rrtzcorn 6—_APPatAila &Min 4®R ILEAVE ILEA TO PROMO iiJ FoRR!!A MAC( cad zttowe c PriO,kl i&ifiteQ de�i1PPS� ? Rsjti►nfi t� 4' e€JLIL\ktPS k It 6.C.S.a.'109 +limit k2 is +I,,.e d e19 1 \'r - PtmtAtLc 0k 4 o.n6t 'te3 J LAiP41Nl -sdeebt 4 AUL \n,_( L,ARR1M -CALtAt a r01\th`,on\ 6,1t oie +o A /.2_ rnct �� coA Ape-EA P (k iJRL I,\kc ) 1,31\\ ReciStt< ti _said 60_0- ,,l\nk W lae ; , aP kIAJ niok PEcenirt-1 ,in iQ t,,AS L82.1 0n1 13 -tezti2S L ot-L2aILSE acpaes rJ3 cnjCO( 3_ AnetInA- t h,e,kkr R LL,,, tJ aR 42ien irhrr L +tai- NiNr3122 A AS A APia OR_J iS itNek gAl D Jii&t L oL A.Peettmnl- N A C ga'AS G�►��dn�T Zn, cow aN ,coR CAP O∎\ �l1���Ci✓ Pi9,e(Lv\t- Lni 4-AA1 h,_( -GAzaLi Lol LU1,L1 Il\O c - J e NIUSI I.nnTY1 AAA LL3d t FaiNA l YIJ zteRP\\LAM a\So k_SA6 -Arvin kLatir 41\1`1 r�Ll� skA ACZ r ke Je nl .s s te_t os,A)`I fir -19tn,6\ki P_ _21,1 TH-E _sOZtqa3Q Cali r ii Qr L\i _ sr -T CasP ►Ja. 13- ili8 1_0 12 moRT .nick r h(0. ,t1 r14 z�k . 2?DS a �,Z w -¢ PRn 14 fDfT?JS VCZi m -Nt'fentlet -<D c CD P5 rift'1 aritt Of _APPEAL _c-c-pc4 i4i1Z Lzke6'1 a.p?ellant- PI LILAC( (AP SdPRIA t7eALC Pli_CA " Its ir 4,,e ss2.eRt.iR Le)JP* w2 Pi. r,s.4. It,541, h2 Lyf- P.-ins-t iZri IA Jnc,fel ;. Atta\ Pa.r.s.1 11 1)12n1,221,22. zt,1ab� sots364,s2 s3a'7 cam.C1 4e ktnLl oR Pat.R._A.P,L®2 tab (A\ cif 441,& rUNNaeRlaArel Lauf kkA P i e€f 41_1 PA.c,s A i!'i e 1 J4113 AA t&i +kI1S 13 �, k'I ac MA-1 131 2 ,e1ADI a k tike keRe 1-L PQ.R E . 9 o r tAN lb)l a (1) rid) ctoznA kft(i.nei9Deol ti_al M la _Reuel r/. LU.. a,:&YYC 2_0/0 eA t\N +1,11 '7.4 (loot A"CTAtFddlEAITS ►�I fLR& (IdP,eRLc P-e_tktun& R.Q.P. ssi RpieR e2e nciut2 +LE LMd Fittke Ig21 P2a©c c (L s\toe P.a.12.0 t2J L n 6 2T I L P L L t-' ^T Lase kin._ 15- i t tB t'I�i�nSi-� r�1 LOti.I � «�t,eT ilLcicET NIL t�f2o�h1O1.f,n- At-2`1 ��'SLI JIG1L'A1 1�. z r C �w. rn A -- CD C) z cD A ► 0111C-E _Aeekit PA.RA.P gal et set i $Dpe irL,6. Li loam- cdet,cn1 Noilt Pa.& P.02_, +Le. of c►ri( codtgzi- ,q.e..eoRtER file t.,J beR1M A rodr k'1 LDU Rt k)\LIE ;s kthe i-1 o eRzal C ANN C£ N eel t►k_ . � i' CDIZ\ Pa-RI int fo . 04-tree cd►e)rucA-.1342a ,Ai 1ov4IPILLit tie ti,1,�4L Pit R A. t o3 et- Jaen, -PvtieS,lDU1'r k-U PA,R d.P t4 1 44. a�R'r S r2Pl anestp_el 4' Kk Tic-/ A?Pff.tlanrt I +■42. niptuaifAL yQ,cer<.'f_\6Ut.k i\ s o 41, tSe,(2 ce-1 R RierwOha L3R wzajCcAt 3t1.1 - i7iJe t.161YC ,JltA-'1 tae coR41,‘LO"11,4 .-c ►,f iS dtt 9tk i, ta1rtd1; r_Ogleiet2 tqetoRel ir.AA oc &1 P4,kA.P, 1921 r k, iethon1 PA +R-E ,Los ,s avot14,41 ILeRto f ILAL b.e■AI i,IAtA zxS LeRt�tfitOti-LDn1 tAlLe iri 1 AtuS GAs k A u.nel Re LLA ktNto Niotre, of Aee i 211 ana ....Bok 9ni.D CA\O P i-LtL 17A IloD( THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY RICKY TEJADA • Plaintiff • CIVIL ACTION - LAW v. • • NO. 13-1118 CIVIL TERM IRENE M. BIZZOSO, PROTHONOTARY • OF THE PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT : `= _ rri Defendant -< -t C'= --�C--=. '? ORDER1_ AND NOW, this /3' • day of 1' ' 'f , 2013, upon consideration of the Motion for Protective Order from Pre-Complaint Discovery filed on behalf of Irene M. Bizzoso, Prothonotary of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, and Plaintiff's response thereto, it is ORDERED and DECREED that said Motion is hereby GRANTED. BY THE COURT: TRUE COPY FROM RECORa / • In Testimony whereof,I here una'is e,Pa hand ' J and the se of said Court at ,20 This ay of" —Prothonotary . 621Z I F.5-- • RICKY TEJADA, : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF Plaintiff : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. : CIVIL ACTION–LAW IRENE M. BIZZOSO, PROTHONOTARY OF THE : PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME : COURT, Defendant : NO. 13-1118 CIVIL TERM - IN RE: PLAINTIFF'S MOTION Pa. R.C.P. NO. 1017 TO STRIKE DEFENDANTS PETITION FOR PRO i'ECTIVE ORDER DUE TO FRAUD ON THE COURT ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 13th day of May, 2013, upon consideration of the above- captioned motion of Plaintiff, and upon consideration of Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Motion To Strike Motion for Protective Order from Pre-Complaint Discovery, Plaintiff's Motion is denied. BY THE COURT, 7 ' f 9 Christylde L. Peck, J. 26cky Tejada, EW-1339 SCI-Camp Hill , P.O. Box 200 Camp Hill, PA 17001 ``�, ` Plaintiff, pro Se — A. Taylor Williams, Esq. y 7. fL, Supreme Court of Pennsylvania _^ Administrative Office of PA Courts �= 1515 Market Street, Suite 1414 Philadelphia, PA 19102 Attorney for Defendant :rc SuazI3+ LL1 cs T z I LA& Nia_. 13- tUU$ ela,nt,c s LD1,1t,t2 C��1RT�(MCKCT J�_ 2C1k3- iLt.Q 2_Z-En1C rfU, P 3-7143nldTelq-1 _tQf a t C-£t ttEtcATE of sEtkVIC-€ ontI i/onzal t°PRt,CPc k Reile)`1 .1-\ALtt 1 �� tLS tia`1 .3 CALCE to �e sP��'1S�R�►�r,L L t'RDLEL- EA' tine., cnReIn[n‘ NJ CA 4- aPPPAc LSPDNI 4e. -Cpsibi CS) z JANe age -NitJ (nairAtibi k Je i.L .ik►cLweek►, satisC,p_r ,aL nests err X21, d�- dkit\is iU SLI. nfi to Li+knpcc fil,R,EA 13 LA r -EcAoUSil1� �✓ -► Anfl seAtts P4.Rt.10i CA A\ 1n1 .01-tiff TWN LA,R-Es Rol NA, lot Cal fbl Ai 601 +A ex ,o,\ Pikt.lebtr laat eA fasL:, At,►34 1 ez.s1/1 .11,f ,G7e -La 42 PA. sane C, r.., f aqS'r CltlLc nnav\ is -CLI O&IS: -0 3 171 CD Ka Rem -R 2Ri,.f6iett gRm-LOAIDtAN "' =-Ft �. Pk,\ , ('La 19(OL E T? c U al(o2.1 l L1A1 LnLiAH L JRt ., Plc 4143, 8til2� and. rIALWt 6,olLik S QJLXR2 Caf21s(,8 ( z f"l0 (. .Iereenr2 2.+?1 nSt3 LEA coN1+�nL� t�2l�tlk��A:l� AketibJ riwb to e' 1.1s4 Oa-1 2811 ' se-ec 6‘\-1 oALIA. AJo ' 133 6 tJ,Nut eReS;iAtc t401,06t meJ 'Ge RICKY TEJADA, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF Plaintiff, : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. : CIVIL ACTION - LAW IRENE M. BIZZOSO, PROTHONOTARY OF THE PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT Defendant. NO. 13-1118 CIVIL TERM IN RE: MOTION PA.R.0 P NO 239 6 FOR JUDGEMENT (sic) ON THE PLEADINGS PA.R.C.P.NO 1034 ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 19th day of July, 2013, upon consideration of Plaintiff's "Motion Pa.R.C.P.NO.239.6 for Judgement (sic) on the Pleadings Pa.R.C.P.NO.1034" it is hereby ordered that Plaintiff's motion is DENIED. BY THE COURT, Christy ee L. Peck, J. Acky Tejada, EW-1339 SCI-Camp Hill P.O. Box 200 Camp Hill, PA 17001 . _ . Pro Se Plaintiff � WMa ./A. Taylor Williams, Esq. Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Administrative Office of PA Courts F— W. 1515 Market Street, Suite 1414 " Philadelphia, PA 19102 `D-`'. Attorney for Defendant `° RICKY TEJADA, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF Plaintiff, : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA c-a E, V. CIVIL ACTION - LAW IRENE M. BIZZOSO, -- PROTHONOTARY OF THE r-X` ° {'> PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME ?3(-) COURT r - Defendant. NO. 13-1118 CIVIL TERM _< Cc) , IN RE: MOTION PA.R.C.P.NO.239.6.249.D FOR JUDGEMENT (sic) PA.R.C.P.NO.126 ON THE PLEADINGS PA.R.C.P.NO.1034 IN THE NATURE OF AMENDING PA.R.C.P.NO.1033 THE ACTION PA.R.C.P.NO.100 1 TO CONFORM TO THE PLEADINGS TRANSACTIONS OR OCCURENCES (sic) PA R C P NO 1033 BY THIS COUNTER-CLAIM PA.R.C.P.NO.1031 AVERING (sic) PA R C P NO 1019 NEW MATTER PA.R.C.P.NO.1030 ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 19`1' day of July, 2013, upon consideration of Plaintiff's "Motion Pa.R.C.P.NO.239.6.249.d for Judgement (sic) Pa.R.C.P.NO.126 on the Pleadings Pa.R.C.P.NO.1034 in the Nature of Amending Pa.R.C.P.NO.1033 the Action Pa.R.C.P.NO.1001 to Conform to the Pleadings Transactions or Occurences (sic) Pa.R.C.P.NO.1033 by this Counter-claim Pa.R.C.P.NO.1031 Avering (sic) Pa.R.C.P.NO.10 19 New Matter Pa.R.C.P.NO.1030" it is hereby ordered that Plaintiff's motion is DENIED. BY THE COURT, / Christyl L. Peck, J. Ricky Tejada, EW-1339 SCI-Camp Hill P.O. BOX 200 Camp Hill, PA 17001 Pro Se Plaintiff 0� 0 VA" . Taylor Williams, Esq. Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Administrative Office of PA Courts 1515 Market Street, Suite 1414 Philadelphia, PA 19102 Attorney for Defendant 2 RICKY TEJADA, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF Plaintiff, : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. CIVIL ACTION - LAW IRENE M. BIZZOSO, PROTHONOTARY OF THE PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT cD Defendant. NO. 13-1118 CIVIL TERM IN RE: APPLICATION PA.R.C.P.NO.102 FOR LEAVE TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS, ORDER TO REPRODUCE ORIGINAL RECORD, NOTICE OF APPEAL, AND CONCISE STATEMENT OF ERROR(S) COMPLAINED OF ON APPEAL ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 19'h day of July, 2013, upon consideration of Plaintiffs Second "Application Pa.R.C.P.NO.102 for Leave to Proceed In Forma Pauperis," Plaintiff's "Order to Reproduce Original Record," Plaintiff's "Notice of Appeal," and Plaintiff's "Concise Statement of Error(s) Complained of on Appeal," AND upon .further consideration of this Court's Order dated May 131h 2013, granting Defendant's "Motion for Protective Order from Pre-complaint Discovery Filed on Behalf of Prothonotary Irene M. Bizzoso, of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court" and this Court's Order dated May 13th, 2013, denying Plaintiff's "Motion Pa.R.C.P.NO.1017 to Strike Defendants (sic) Petition for Protective Order Due to Fraud on the Court," which do not dispose of the litigation, AND upon further consideration that an appeal may only be taken from an interlocutory order as of right (Pa.R.A.P. 311), from a final order (Pa.R.A.P. 341), from a collateral order (Pa.R.A.P. 313), or from an interlocutory order by permission (Pa.R.A.P. 312, 1311, 42 Pa.C.S.A. § 702(b)), it is hereby ordered that Defendant's appeal is procedurally improper no further action shall be taken by the Court on this matter. BY THE COURT, Chrispi lee L. Peck, J. cky Tejada, EW-1339 SCI-Camp Hill P.O. Box 200 Camp Hill, PA 17001 Pro Se Plaintiff t A. Taylor Williams, Esq. Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Administrative Office of PA Courts �� i 1515 Market Street, Suite 1414 Philadelphia, PA 19102 f� Attorney for Defendant 2