Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout13-1731 "1t6' c ouRr 41= coma/6k° PteA6 off Cur73ego9A,0 Could-CV, Peg s yc,vmi)/t9 C. 1 v't CVO - 1-1)10 71111 g0 1— r (\)o,a, 15 - 031 a-t\i-01Terell Petry ✓ inoibfl 1,1 co ,Z rn cJ)r' PRRCtI PC TO PROCEED 11V OR7Y)19. PAUPER I S - o i 13€ PRorNoriorfRq : -- • Kindly allow %eiiy Robe l- Roy64-er 1-c proceed ;n -Porir)a p4uperi Z, Teil Robes-4- Roysfer) hereby cer�jTv Mc41- L am unable, TO P4y •1-he (..05b 1ii11541-ion and 4-61- I ha e. tnclotc, h)e.. proper o►- -- J`ciavii- and col" 4 Order c i t`ec-i.ro3 3 / 3t 1 /3 7 J1y r?b6er / pro Se. 10 -nit. couK7" of cotomo•o PLE(t6 of CuW,4649G4ND COuAVT'/, Pei&& /I.VAN"/" C i J i F}C r10/0 r`~A(N `ally I6ysIr Pere" ibiArnblie{.6.I • AFNUHvi t �. L �m t•Mt plui,��,`�r� in #ht above rna44-er and bec44ye. o P �, Pinto c,'41 condi•/l on qm' unable h pc j t-he +eas and eo5f-s e' proseculin3 /-he c c d-ion And proceec405 1,• .L 4,1 „irmoe 10 4)14 In 'Cur►ds from anyone , includ%45 Mr fum,`Iy qSd 660c a0.41' o 17u1 4he. Cosf-t o� /4/34-Eicetn• (f t J 3, Z. re�?rc5en7- +4,4f- +he intorrnakon btlew relcAin3 4» na/ ability Tn pal M Pew S Aod eo5,45 is �ru� at,d coercc4- (4) rJc,1,e "reify Robe4 goyo?r Hddrt55` PO iboX AO 0 Camp Fill Pty 1 7001 Social Securil•y &umber: 16 S- 5g-51505 (b) ttvJpIoyment: X urn Aar employee/ (c) 0 k-her intone w;411 n +-he. p46+ wel c nronl-h 5 ; L am not- employed (.(1) b+her eonVribu, (ions To boctehold 6u,ppot+ : ,A)ort30' Cc.) Pfopet-ty owned c-heck'tns Mccou,nt ` n}one. 5 J+n5s 4ccoLo+. d'Jont eef4S►ce,i-es Oepo6d-; v)one G5k\-e n3QNG S+ochs ; l amts ; A,Ile (.c) c ncJ obli30-lon '. O+her: Metaic6,1 co-puy 1) Ptr6t,n5 dept nden l- upon you for 5uppor .; 4one `l, ancler61'411c1 f',f L h60e c can ir�viin� olofisc�l�,n lu in corn' +he Cour�•- o impvourmen - 'n rhy -tnancic,l circi,m5+c,nct5 wh;ch wowicl per m+ me 10 pay ,`Icurred hec� ►n 5, 3:- otr►Vy bklAtmen,'s 4.0, c4 tc viI- +aide ore lr'e anc coertc . vnlAer5}Gne }110. 5Wtrntn4 Ieftxn &lre m& C ukee} TO ie �n411.te oc 13 Pa CSbecd-lan `icibcl +t1441i05 1`0 uY�5Wwtt i•P(15icit4iDY) +0 0,4,44-kbr;fic6, Dc4e'. 3 Li$ii 3 it ko y6kr M. Supreme Co , i xis '_, nnsylvania 0 as Cou 6f(c nn l<10 'leas For Prothonotary Use Only: C i1'AY t Docket No: County 13 - j 731 UvifT€fl The information collected on this form is used solely for court administration purposes. This form does not supplement or replace the filing and service of'pleadings or other papers as required by law or rules of court. Commencement of Action: S .:a Complaint ❑ Writ of Summons ❑ Petition ❑ Transfer from Another Jurisdiction ❑ Declaration of Taking E C Lead Plaintiff's Name: Lead Defendant's Name: T 1—e1 Cy i<o f5‘-Pr fPekr 88/7;m Dollar Amount Requested: ❑within arbitration limits I Are money damages requested? I Yes ❑ No (check one) 53 outside arbitration limits U N Is this a Class Action Suit? ❑Yes :d No Is this an MDJAppeal? 0 Yes IN No A Name of Plaintiff/Appellant's Attorney: _ _ ® Check here ifvou have no attorney(are a Self-Represented [Pro Se] Litigant) Nature of the Case: Place an"X"to the left of the ONE case category that most accurately describes your PRIMARY CASE. If you are making more than one type of claim,check the one that you consider most important. TORT(do not include,Mass Tort) CONTRACT (do not include Judgments) CIVIL APPEALS • Intentional ❑ Buyer Plaintiff Administrative Agencies ❑ Malicious Prosecution ❑ Debt Collection: Credit Card ❑ Board of Assessment ❑ Motor Vehicle ❑ Debt Collection: Other Board of Elections ❑ Nuisance Dept.of Transportation • Premises Liability Statutory Appeal:Other S ❑ Product Liability (does not include _____ mass tort) ❑ Employment Dispute: E Discrimination Slander/Libel/Defamation C 0 Other: ❑ Employment Dispute: Other ❑ Zoning Board T _ — ❑ Other: — I I ❑ Other: --- g- MASS TORT ❑ Asbestos N 0 Tobacco ❑ Toxic Tort-DES ❑ Toxic Tort-Implant REAL PROPERTY MISCELLANEOUS Toxic Waste ❑ Ejectment ❑ Common Law/Statutory Arbitration 8 ❑ Other. ❑ Eminent Domain/Condemnation 0 Declaratory Judgment -- ❑ Ground Rent Mandamus -- - ❑ Landlord/Tenant Dispute DO Non-Domestic Relations ❑ Mortgage Foreclosure:Residential Restraining Order PROFESSIONAL LIABLITY ❑ Mortgage Foreclosure: Commercial ❑Quo Warranto ❑ Dental ❑ Partition ❑Replevin ❑ Legal ❑ Quiet Title ❑Other: IRI Medical 0 Other: __ __ ❑ Other Professional: _ Updated 1/1/2011 L70 i i4C COURT oP co,u"ON PcESgs of Cua1Stet_AaD cousry, PEA s1i.V94'IA gl(y gotpfer , j3 j73 i OlVtiriArt$1, ire)er -7 `�' inoio,, -e ) c,l Civil &lio/I �'w r--,_ NOT ICU 70 0Ef~exn° J 1 I J /C4 A4Nfe. bcen so,ed in CoUri-, 1 �' yba wish d*CfnO 45(4,061- -i-he e/41/116 Se/ Fe POI ;n 141e cd110wln5 ptige.s yoU i,N5f f'c■k& c,ci.ibn ' ; ).);,1 Twenty (2o) ciciy5 404r- ?-h■ 5 COraFkint' and n4i•iRe. are Served by v.nIerin5 a w r t -Ifin o,rpe4r4ncQ per5ov)c,1ll or- 1`)1 c0.\-C)rnY G11(.1 krj145 L^Ii" f--h& Court- yo,,r tensef, or objecI ons fh the CIA,n,S 5e1- Vor}h a3c4)01- yoN, You are iacrntd you ail W do 50 {-he Cost /ml frtrceed lajhoH� yott and c, JH4�lin� 0,1 ge enierd d�GiMS� you by Fht £o14- ijio4 +k'H,er NAVA NA-IC cor toy nnone-y ck'med in -h' COM p) i 69'1 c.c.,. cor Can o l4ier ClGem � �- (Ne)itc rere5 1-3e. Okin)1(N • 1/410u rylcY to5e moNI proferqy 01- aver° r i5h\5 i'mporkri >•,, you. '10-Lt 514ouis.) +Ak6 1-141 2 TO YouR Lfictriet2, t1- aNeti , tioa 00 N�z 1tAvC A �+�WyE2 c cANNoT i E ORD ofuE, Go To OR ECEP)}ouC fl+ tarries 66-'1 rber14 rEcow 1-o PJNO t ,14 LeE '!DU CAN GE Lei G f4t_ t- Et_ J Cvonberlcod C6uniy bar- 1i5ocia4ion 3a 60 ,14' ed rd 6f- )70 i 1 - 3 ©0-- ' O- 910 71.7- G2q e1- 31 64.6 y t3 I.n) 4c C (hN2c' DF cov►1rroN P(CA5 0 iI C urn6i�2 LA r�D Cdu+�ry , fc'ruiNSYL.✓gNin Binr or 10c:r tt� Dil4y54:,u+hcr'S, henty, t,aidi 51oeG z, Csc.tiaocr, K<::a,r (oak,Aireb, Plini',Scniutc; li J,^r:,, ti'u r1, {)r E}onr 131.1)9;u$iChc sigrs,06Ncin Ren aerlor, ih,rhiorribiuno;Harnav4 6,1.r's�, rJhanAyn r:Cam, oytti„/Ykilirldh, ✓,r' h, !i CTUny Lsvo. , Prvon Sainte, Cori 70/7 Iti{ry{PLO{ALJE Atgc Now, C.rne• 4-y0- �1,1i�+1�C'F, re t/ QmyS er and s,wers •I-he cr/lit)141 n , n S ,peer oC hi I. T"iiiy 0■410r1 ;s bro,; hi- fel 4I-he Courl-s aribincal jar c1(cl'►`cn, cancurre,%4- Iurr►‘dic∎-ior, t. h the Federc t Court .-or CiAinn and/er Scipplemenkl jur or U.S. Con ul-iorwl CjAirr7s. 2. Plain}icc relay .Roys+er is a pt'►soner pre.Sen+ty ancc rcerAfed o►1- 6C1 Camp /01,6 3. De:endaivi-s Peier i inniorr, £bcfor Vvor6J-kcf) T'e Y re Di1-i- , Richt(rd Sou•Mers; Y '170, i-lenry , 7 resa Legs) Ed Shoop Lt. Gardner) 1.4% I44z r, SS+. Cao k, 5 ,$irCs; 55-4. Flinn ; Co I Sc nfucci, COI (✓44,, Cbl Siun) CO) 8ril+ton, CO} 8r05;as, Chris C.hkrnbi'i's; Plelissa O? riarr j Mary 11cnderroni Daniel nlc GraMi 6herey 7lionlbIano, 3uJ, 144(ne✓i+zj Nhcc6e Lisa; AJ.rse 6h4nno' j nlurye Lriea) Aurbe toe d✓urbe l"laii,ndc,� N9,jcse t V`if` '4 tJur•5e ri4fany , Norbe Loiur,/j art- or i 4Ffe emplayecl by +he. ?ennsylvanic ten ri-met+ of Corr•ec+ion5 (Ooc) oliterfly er as canfrac t tootkers a'i SCi Camp hill dmria5 the. -titres. Ii'sied in +his eornplhirt#. o'. al,De ncic r f' Prism l�coil+h Cc..re5ervices (PHS) Ja r mown Gard zon was kilo mediciil prooicler Car 141e. DOC. dwrins 1"he, rimes I/6)-ei/ in I-his complain J-. 3.,v. EGON cliVenckryi' acted under +he color 61vivit law and are sited in fhe/r oC tie,i and indhlicimal Cc c1+y 6. PlAin4-i-'f has been dia osed ty 4 doctor as softerit From seJcre. pa;n re aiht' 7. Qluin�i••JJff receives ;Air:Ines o3' )eci5f I-hre.e ( ) 'iw ey per week And tech episode Lctin 14�- %rom v, tew hours lobo mot than (i7) hours each• S, Plaint■V tac,s prescribed by a dod-or F*'orice+ medreai-ion .4% pot,,ser-k„l pain rtlitsir or an c),s needed bu5i6 ho fie; +J en when pik;nf i14 has a rrii5rAine, tuhen pla+n44V tyferienct.s a migaine Ors 5ynpforrm6 t1t41- k4(/6 .gyp f» a rrlijf4lne he i s +6 r►oi-icy et 5+6A me; xr 1-h011- he, needs 11i5 Pled;ry4-iO4. rO. S44; M461- Nhen nofi f y medical 5+4 h t pkin Jif f is in need ©P reeditalicry. tl• f lecliec,l depwr}men-l' ,5 {-hen res i'bie cor delivt<ri49 the medir'c.ien .to plginf,� ' in a 46mely 'wooer, einywhcre ;tarn fen m,r»l-e s fa one. hour A* mo5l-• t`Z, ' e4ween March o%` aoii and Apt'i I of ?v i2 there were approximak J (vs) di3eren� 1-imes +hat p/Ain14f repe7�ede his mecicc-ien for- his mi5raine anc/ c✓'e/ nr.4 cv.ei4e. his medication cfir mare 'flan six holes a-P r making the >r'�iuest or ne4 cc+ ail cHHSr`n5 plar'nfM f e swA4er cram ex}r-eme fin air tit d.��•lr,��'c•i I. C' the mi3raioe episccle ar 4n ,l 4-he, rneclica-i•;'on Lrst,S is5 Lit rdd i3. OF 1-he (ri5) funs piciiribr-FP al-45 delayer/ r'n Petrivitij bets meir'c»dror or chi/011 c�� ►I � - all wce c{ resNlf oP k/ii'nR dePenclaanhs Chcm4eryi Gardner, I'Suaur, Coo (, Aires, Pl,°nn t 64n4-uicc;, IL reins, S.1-u,►Y, ;8ri//on, and fbresI ,4 O.c ;11'5 „wed / r fh.e rnedicc, ion and 1✓he clefend4nis delayed tAs. n5 fhe- me4c41 ehpar.i'merrit o 1 is need rar e„led fo inPorrrl /ie medi'ccl deparh enf 4-/- aif. it The a i►er kme`, p kin I•;f c cA.t45 delayed in jteibini his mec 4a ion i'S becaWS e ddc'endcoIs OQric:n, l..isc:, Shanivoi ( rico., I e#i rlali4c14) Evipial .sherry, 7'Ciany, Z"uJy, T.c3ory anal (lc ry iece r`espcns;bie for deliverin j /he mecI cal•iori APIer 4; I-inet7 ric ifieal oc' plat'+.)/ ttd need Hie' delayed iss�ain the rnccl'ccsfiir Icr se,tcra/ 1,,(41.6, Se+ween !")arch 2io1) w JiI pPee-o4- do l•e, pl c inli l:4 ho6 m&icle a norr,ber e c}'e,npk . *tsvl Phis Prablcm +0 no a,I6il by mc,l;in5 v'erbr,i and arii4en c,:mplainls }0 EnG1Oat MAI 5riesicinct i qit a i43Aich he. c?xhat46- ec all Temed,es 'Ailc,ble 7t! him• 16, At enu(?AI, Pi+51 Ntnry, 5h0-GP, Drt4/, ..4a-u}-hers; Chc. nbers, LAai 6ardner, JSazur, Look` (4 r ;re5, a»c>i rlinn i$e(e ec ch fed Aa;o.�^! e- t-I►e problem p1 Gin44C i d ,n rtte■4 A) hiS Meditc,}jen bit Tv.; ed '1U �"��Kt Pt46onab/e rtwioe I',e prebierr,. 1'? Sp ci�►c4ity inIermecl a cii c4 #406e. A/entrants c h;5 problem e.tl,er verbal iy Qt'- in unsS•i nb, Ar644r14 r4o.c6 or Ap-1l v acqa. ;'n re-talies i'ion �c r his compla.'nk rejeLed,'.g Woo cheo ecJ Peen." needed io day „H mtclicalIc-n Fieritcl ordrr 5ef +;mey h»O 43 Ple medcc,l-ion $e',lCI not be effed-hie o,dered h,s wet/. t9, otVend4n4-5 l3 no,00, Vccr54-64, Shoe'p and ,f . are responsible for i-he ehG05e., 24. Frcm (fora► cr April tcc Gala untii petsenf ch,le p14161, /iay ber`;) Arced fo �C�l0lyfit excr,46,:i n3a pair) c1. uQ h n honk's or) More_ 1'h»n (Z2) 5epcsrrje Cefc,y51.0ny becomoc ke t'5 arced fo }klce the rneclicat;on cJ sr!• limes., al, PHs hc. , ^eIu',ed to Provide plc,;nficc wf -h any redid• ' or etherwise en5ar•t tic:t p1 ,nl•iF is providecl i. 4, trec,t,nen+ c1. his 5erio;4y ,nedic-i nced5 . da. Decenckoi. I..c,ar cod amnion p1 nJi Cf thct- hr`s mediccd ic-n order voti7 c.hc;n ed #c yet t t5 to preve»-i- hi'vi rarn �1L 3 5rie✓c,nc.es concernins nL¢ ftceiv,r)3 4-he medico,i-ion, a3, Ali mooed olccenciccnb seroow5 rntckcc,i need: C ich ms Fur Relit} Oelibero,}e 4.0 sariou mee1:c41 needs 44, Defendants Chu,nber s, Gc isdner, jc,zir, Cock, fires, �l,irni Sy., acct', �'v'c,ns; t,rr»i tl't 'Iicn, 8ro.5i,46 re v,9c.i to nal: y medico, o4 p14411•itc6 need fer /it's mer/'cu•/.icrn in a +ienely manner and i ,'1.1.X6 ,o4- ek# ail con5114-(41•ec/ de lArraie in'ck tie:er7ce ,L0 Pla►r,-�i�fs 5erio41.5 medical neeck in vi'a1u140n ca. fhc Cr bfl, Aneadmea'k De6rmiad-t 06ti'c,» , L154 3hcnnor,, 'r,'ea, 6eth, 04nie1, tcvirlc„ Sherry; a• 71M01) J uclif ,a,g:'y and Mary re" ecg4 " c deliver (nedicalloa •,L p14,,241.11, in a 4-irnciy manner Nci'rr being ht needed del,`6erc,fe indif°Terence seric,.t rncdic4I needs in VioI41IO o +i,e Gi0113h Amenairi en i. 26. Oacndanl-s P H S j 6 ion id 1r'cc c1, /-40, Shoop, Henry, DiILI'y r je�thars fctZUr, Cic,anbers, Gardnery Ceoki Aires end 1i7 /-hei"r 3uperVtSor ccipcci¢y �iraJir� clirec'i hnGrvleChe 0c 1I4■tzficf s 5eriow5 mtGIJ`cc.S l needs land -Pe4;1"03 1-i 1-4ke 1'ec,sonc,ble slaps a ens.;rz f-C cece■i)E.• eyrry r;aie I'rea7'ri1e07 cons deI6erGI-e ,nd;i'Perence io f lainiii. s series medi(CI noels •n V"G14110-rs cc At e--6 Ameravw-/, dJ, Decendlints 15in/)tD )J Vcor6hd, 1,4t43 and Shoop acI/oi'i5 in ch4.A$/#,3 pI6in i�'}s rneci ca>Ita7 f0 5a. 4'iw►e5 preJe/il;nq pki)/11P trove, Peccia n5a rl'nie neec/fd n7ed,tai kree rrm4i Leh:ie :n pain Lon i4vLkd elel,berc 1e ins1cc t-ence f a �71k;n i t t5 Seriew5 Medical needs ,`n ✓ic/Ant:7 ;3 411 lmendineni• f cs, re54,ui- ok.c Sa: ,r , i(&iCJ dd erate r nel e tenee c ic,"tiit :raid nteus 5l Ai/ /«fined dttenC 'h p/A;nt;it 54rtered 3erere phricAt and eff7,1i064-1 174(4 aoli, ly . 1e kti a lion 9. gr'�rnclan�'3 ©innim Shoop And Li., changed ni,14c enedicab;or► tc 6ti- »es ay reswi} ac +ht �rINtabte6 c.iea re jarcLn3 11104 Peceivio5 hi4 medJca+ion n ei 1t;Jnclr rnCJncr w ►en ri uesled� Aid) cons4;iNk� tse+4liaiion tar pe3uWoriins redress of gricvc�,�ces »d -hereoce �i'oiaEicn .1-hc ArnenJmeiri P4 6t0,, Con51-4-Al.fen ttnc! cker PR SiAlt Ian, C... /litiynt /Medico,/ r?1k1prac1rc 36. nit de tndc:nis &Arne) ;n 44),"5 compiaie4 Ql,4ed pi4;nielf 0. duty of reAAy€ 461e care iA er►s.4re pc,;n medieo:l-ion Wc,S isswecl .0 him in A h*nei/ manner- ,.4raeo bei.,,) noiJied 14,6,3' he needed 31. Aii nswned dc1enc hits btect,heci #i t dal-y bl PL:;11'43 'lb ensat-e plAinit.cc received his mtditcti#ia:t �►en makin� a �`�,°kes� 'at- i4. 3a, 7—he brtc,d c duiy pi4;44-4 Sue eri,ns Se ere phrsicAi God emcticnAi pcin and +njurl 3b, the brta:cl) c' d441 prex m kIy cp,c45ed Maye cianae,eS piaini.aff Sa'i•"ferec 34 Ail cie�endanl� �4 led fo COrra414je col Gdc pf and encarce- a,derfaft rules ond pe lictcs 40 en`3,:,te 06:tji.1<y CAft r Plc 4 cf and GiileGf; Tp everSee 411 perbetls Jho pra,c"}rce. medicine 0_ JicArio45 1iybtti�}r / c spondea� S,,t�eri r Oe611.n1s PHS , Ainnionr Veer6faci 1.-coo) S"hoop) Henry) 011 ly, 50u01er.s, 1147urf 1.60:Jniier5t Gatelner i Cock, Aires Gnd Fiimi ,'n •jhei r Respbndeo.t' S yet orf syervisoV* uypnc► havih� 04ireci- l`norsieJe plainiilts derto45 mediccGl needs to.deJ to cii rp*ukk1 and s 6,c16p"F A»d �.r�ttt . c; er,;.}e "4te6 anJi pelicie5 enSyre tvithii y cvre. cor 1014;1,#ifT mnej taIlevl suede perscnj ,,rho pCe+ciice rnecLcrne 14h; ;45 watts," C resui� of +he, c4600,e tltnf•ion01 R. Def1120.c,3e. lncli'`f%re4te , 6. Rd-ALA-ion C. Nt511ynce./Medico! nud roc r ce, 0' V cc r ioras 1ìJ,1131 /Respon cdCN# Super/cr. 6f (a,ii Awned olec4ncig.oh Pe pectic(( I✓fs°red Severe. �hS;cc,1 cand emolienetl Pain cud s'boy • PER FOR fiEL lEF WHEP,EFc 6, )ain' i c re.vec o it prel5 4-haf fhis Court tryI-er j cd3med Plwi»1'i � ro,ni'in 3 3t7, A Gltci4r0,4-ion 1-ha at- eind dlecrried f:eretn Vis,fc,lrcl �(�14ip/f•i1�� i his: ` 8, C6rnpens44ar y p6Mcle �'► ikt- Amot40f e c tat')000, 00 c'i13C.c�intii' �G/�Cy, Lye/`teni air 31, Pan11c.+e dcuric e� ''A 11i aInadni a P $v6O 000, a A5alA5/' ee4ti, ckPend arrt. 16. .Ln„1AC4.f0n „elec. reviein3 oltVeno 4S 'fie ct.i eCt medicAl`ion craef 5, iil. A J'"t 1 f ria) or) ail 6/ j4417,qz. r iii.inittl`5 CC •/-h rst'# • �i3• Any Add/famed refieP MIS coarT eitenvs ji4sf wind erul'l.bIt. VVR I FI C flr1 o J 1,c ve_ :tc,c1 the ;g1.5.,165 Gccnf7)GihT Arid hereby %reri f7 f6i 141c. rr,413er , 4 Ik ed }4se,e�+n ore 'brae csnrl ca:tec+. .2 understood 4hot tulle 5h+ernen1.6 herein Dire nude i,ibjeeci. 4.o t11 e 9e,i,:;ITie6 GC I? Pc. C.. S, 3ec4i or) 70 Li, re lc,i n3 iv u nskao rr` -va51ticot-ior? It aw or,-1itS, ;e f a y5-ie r i2 /6- Pa ax goo CGmp IJril PA i7Oo1 OVA Cc,mpi}ili 03 8151 51.c,re, Rd PO rbbxaoo Philkdel, ic, n» Ii136- 1410 Cc,+no bill PA 17001 SOO �.►5�urn Rd © 110 l'rt�ress Or• �a iiJo.tre66.41,3 PA 15"370-• 80$2 C.s"r"P 04111 9011061 fro '7"4E couRr OI Commo ) PU,g6 dr CUw�36-124- 4n.D Cormry PEryosYi,VNruiA Roy6),er 13- 1731 a►vrl`�rr" 77.3 CT OEMANO POK ru,y -Rim— �?� c `.: A1ocs c yne."S p14i4; per Pennsyjoc►n;4 . 4- e rules }1,'" c� OerrtancI cos- jL4(7 1 CIC4 �n 1ht move capIionecI cc,5e• �`? t,wicREFc C plu;nk reftie64s 01411- cGSe proccec% iiC,I i� c;tbill- oc G Joey , Doe, 3)?1 )13 Respec{- u)/, s 6m1>��ecl f �e/ly Rays-kr` IN T/}6- CduRr O1 Co►riinOW PLEf}5 C14•0160U.4A)D coa, i y", PeAm6YLv/w,u9 71/Iy K'o/s�er 13 - 1731 01V.11.1-010 V PROOF of 6E CE ))ereby ceri.iP MAi- A /'rue And CdrfecJ- Copy of" p1GinirPP ' nlolice �o eleceod) Cer';ci'Cc, es O4 d7?efit and olem4od c r ., y / ' to epvzd on rl�Pendc,4 - by Pir51 Class tr9C � (WV' Chiec C'oun6 t1 2 . Pri,c r Heolh Sfrv,,ce 19AO lechnc103y Parkoc,y 3151 S Rif /YlechAn,c5bur5 P/4 /7050 Philadelphia P4 I9/36 - ?9io 3, Cori-Lon J69 �'ro 111-- 1'001 it e.5 I u r5 f 3 15 3'76 - ?0 3 2 r 0.) D . S/31//3 re y e0y3/ei- PG 60x a00 e' 19p ii;', Pf9 pool 7 It 40-ter- .r146 couRr oF convtiv Pdab oF V tonztaieLArvo coutvry itiOVI..valrott Peer Oionion 403 15- 1/31 0(vi Term Cc h irer14- lo 4-o 6e ck 11 Ted/ Po16kr ceriV +h& . 4,2 71,3 f)(pe rt it54i oiDny o q )1 Appropriak icen6e 4 rn rn /MCl/ 16 onntce5 -Ctr pf65eti4)--ico z-/-7, I 72'6 0 14) ci4;rnb 15Y i eie-PerS4/3 3h115 Roy4er- Po f3ogZO C4/01) 1/11/ /200/ /ft) -046- Coupr of conirion, Pi6S6 --i- ily koi64-er O F cotoeiegLatitvo cotinfril PagOVIVOW14 V Peler 127i Polon ti- ovi 731 i—,,,,,„„ 13 -1 aiva iciv- Cer+i-Nca ,i-e 0-P 'nen + A 6 4-0 .5' 4v7,96.9 r -Telly PD y54er cer li Cy 4h 4 -I- ! eXper 1- 1-e 6 )-//176 6/ v.1' 41 4 ci ffeeff/4 ic heeptoo/ --.. ,--, — proCe-55('on 61 lb otine0:554/N1 1 ,r pieeec /I on 0 xt_F-1 „r2 j--19 c /41/n5 0)iciin64- r' i6 de-ren hi) I- ■_,—. '— , • d .... '. . 47, e101==■,,, , efiY R076 kr PO 60)( 200 C47 Ilia pi) p /OD i t I(1) C 121- F Co A7A/204 P11-146 'try Ko54.er (641,11564-AND couivTi Povotitv1944,1 V Pe c- i /.7 I 11)/ e 13 - 1.731 CAvi Term Cer - cck ocrr,er, 'reit Po i5-ter / e/( 4- (no y 01 4 (A 1),Pr°el 1 6i 17 j pC) 'pr4e65( 0,4,11 iAon (Ld' r pi(3- 3eai I/ 642 0 - FIJ r _ C / /V) 1") tie Ci (A" (,) 3131115 • /141 , , c rry // .....r.° ' 1 e, I 1 k(V164?(-. i NI 70-c- co(ARI- oF cono90A) PaA5 of CumieRt_fiA)0 couriry Peri/NYL MN, 0 V 13 - i731 aohlTerol Pet-er ibtoion , { f 01 1 Cef-- ) ( 1,-t oC merit- 015 4- 0 Judi, 1)omovd-z. r : len / gou5I-fr ce4i . . / .1-h,.. i- : t exi)eid- 1-eJ1Plony 0-C. " CIPPr°r6lit 110605eal prOf t':),, 610441 1 5 t4 ece66c,f/ tor pro5ecr4 tioa 0 4' I-lie C14 . /o5 7.-7 :3 :j;-Jr] r ''' f.) i .......„ -Tri .. . - 1L'/ PO (3 ,y z a() 04",p Hili PA / 70 / goyoi-e ,A) cowzr of Cainiridiv PlE135 oF CumbeRt.AND coulary PerVioYLVfinn V 13 1,731 aoiliTe;(Ii" Peter ion , •41- cl I (7, rrl rel Cer4i C-Cjt Merit. A6 4-() 3Aet/I -rhion/- /eino rz,1 -71 I re I y 1O151-er 441 /)A1 t• experi- k6hoory o-P cu cippropriAle iice05edpro46idec/ Unnece66614/ T-or pro5eccikon 04‘ i-he c14 :/1 s }-h1 deVenc140 --b/31// 3 e/ty 076 TE r I'D 66y 2O )iiir P, /700 f fy goy-51er fit) rte 6 oarr o CoN02014) Pt1/33 OP V C640166'410)0 coLrry peN/V5yLvAIN/h ftier hino/Ion 13 . 1731 a',,-,\-reivv■ Cet-l-ifl cc. o c16 #0 Oa, 'ie ! 7)2e 6r6 co :73:173--T1 rri r n r- 7:1:31 r , 7lly Roy64-r. ; e)(Pe 4 1-e6finlOny tic Ai) appropt144e ficensed ProCC5SiGncli 1.6 linfieCte34, p r pro6eca /ion or 1-he thiitno A3ciir764 de-rend4ni 3131 I) elly koyt kr PO 66.1/zoo e4prip /1/1/ Pn 1700/ /r1) T C ouen OF Cotnn2671 ' P114 O1" C U rrl i3CRCAN D Coo Alit/ y / �ENNS Z09/1 r3 ti . !-E'r j//)/2 t or) L A 13 - )1 31 �iiVi l�2im'� Cerk - cc, \-e o rV?erJ- Go 1'/e)i &5G Otri 1Pf r rr crr 3 ' 1 koy± t � � 1 4-h4 ; �1 _ r e ype { '5 ifYnny oc ppr(yr' Ale /icrnse6/ -`_' }„ a" 1-he c14 n5 a54,,75-1 �� , `7 o% r(',y.)0/44 313/ / ; 5 e//y 1!G y5 / r� PO /( ZGo CGnp /1/ 1/ Pn TIIsj 5ker rfic co(or or aromaio /DEI1 OF Curatowkvo cocoury Peivivvhoirtio. Peter c\l ;t. 15- 1131 O'") CT: Tevfl 7;1--r1 MC° - C 4-1 CIA te- 0Q Mef if ao it 6'd shoOp . r-- ‘rel(i )?6 y6ler Cer'Vy 11/ eXperf h5firnbi/1 Oc aein 4102rOpi4 ifeelfied proce564,60.1 15 (444ete ,547 f ,r ppo5ecti7Li64 typ +))e c14;ini 013604 this decenclod, I rb eh/ 415.1er Po 60x ZOO atenp Nit I i700 I fr.) Mc Cooler OF coal/7164 3Y-65 oF T11 Roti54'r- CUO)641149A10 Couvry pew/15W.11/111M (3 - (TN 0;04 Ere-rm Pr 15(nAiOniei- PtCC Cj'e• 09 merli- 01 i117 knder-30- U rn - rn 173 2), Z77) r. ) y6le r cerOly -r-- - ta)(pff Sc./mon' P c.‘ n g qropt, 4 / Cet7519/ prOce56104G. 1 1.5 on acce547 r plo5ecc 0.)e 1 Otyi 4 s+ t/ 6 dePen Jan 3 1 )1111D elf y 1<cl 51pr- P o 1.30)( 200 Cc,„,t) 11,11 17001 IA) rrn .oaffi" OF coo/1010,u pL6-45 op -re/(1 R6kr cou,vry pouiv3yzimioN _ 1131 ee kr 61'nel,on ,c 41 ;-1 eQr4' L Cs 0 er I Cj5 ) 6 rere 5c, L-) -r-7 r ri r7-1 cc) , 1=7'. (A) ib15ler Crj 3-h : An pproptic,te b'crimodpilece55;5.71-;/ 5 10,0 Ce.55c,ri c‘br pr6 sce4 I on 01) f-A e ett; i415 A5414 57/ dpeociA \ rctil 1?0,154r poot ' .• I. . COMGERLI9(1.10 • • 15- 1'13\ v■1-renh . e r 44i0 rn m P t 7.) r- 7.r Cr'i , . : Cr'• - ° - A H j ,16 F7 -A fry ic3 +t— on ,1 i 6. ,,Ar;; • • • -; r) f \ • # SI 3 0/ IN.,- • (Y),J P// RelsVe r MG' CeaRr 017commona Kr/4i OF C'cimag600 COUNTY, Pn\415YLVAi1hA r id- )3 -113 m rrl C.erkiCAte. o i 7.77: .r., 're tv Rocibitr, Cery WON 7, experl- (my oc An apror`tite ihensed proces6ione1! 14nnece664ry c.or ro6ectAt-ion DV- 4-1.yR ciciier)6 ov:sloof 1-4;5 cle, encicinb Ock:. 3)31i efiv Ro ys.if r- Oox Aoa CAtrip /RI PA 1700/ i fli 1 74(77 Co a R :- d r: cop9,41 Ai pa.--,1-_, ,,,( co_,A) r/ V 13 -- ir 1 i i`4 Term r 194)r , )ii)(710i) er •:, i 1 t...4 f I-4 ' fi:' (6‘ 1-e, 0 C mei , -1. -;., L ilallop 3 'fi'5 6t) 1c (41 5erVICe -r .7.'' .1 q / L.p r' r . , ( . 1 --11.." / 14)47'- iLt-.° ti ''i --- c() — ---,L,-, it i , d) / 0 f' 4 -4 i 1 3 tir)e(e5c;I/ e• -"-/ I pre) 5e Co I/ .04 , pile ,- 3) i i 79_0, -7. -//7 ,e()Iltr PL) / 6x 26o Comp /1/40/ ..)4 J (../(..), Js) Ts- burr op conieetv ( 73-6 Te.,1 IL/ 12 b1/4/4er OF CPI/Opathil,0 6 coy rY Peitd04.4/19/0/0- V \3- 1131 &III-Term k r 6i60;on ek i eNct-e 0C meril a, "1-16 011.11. Cori zoc.,0 ,, if, rric3 ,'• -T:#::9 --r: rt / gbC14er CeitSy 4761- -r•:-"j ,../ —.a ,, ---,c- - - e)(p (t t. le4iirMny o-E am Ai)?Cri 4Ie prei -e56104A1 +5 140fiece550 y T...0 r p r 0 ,5e co H on 0 T )-Ihe C1411 Inb Asc, iol- A i 6 de-reoh4 f 3) 31 I i 3 -f--eili R67&jer P box ZOO' C4mp 11/i/ m ) 7601 -- 7t .i \ , ()i.: ,-') r- iiv roc CO,4j27 OF cofeifiloiv Pl-tA`f7 ° T.'" c-LA Al lb(P-AN 0 OA 0 TV eq."11.104 IMO 6 15 -n31 av, i-Ter' C) r---, rn CL1 m a r V■(--. \ C ‘\-e 0 )(Y)e r # -- r---- _ 11 i k,<,,,r) --er co .. .. . .. , . ei-- \,-- rz.5 1-kvv7 0 0 I C3 C r> A q ppro pi 1 c,-.4,. Iirerpvi proVi.,5'710lic., 1 (Ann ece54 r`i Co r 1)("04.2en,i i-1 ot) 1 \-1„ „:, c 1 c, , ni .5 Asc., #.0 1; . 5 ....._... i 7.-e. oy Roy514ar Po / (,;)‹ 7O CAM? 1--101 P1312601 1-5e11,1 R096ker 10 TOE' coaRr oF CoolMON PLE136 OP ctAritb6Rowo cowry 1010YLAINO 13 awn-ern/1 f)4er Oinr)101) e-A-‘ 0%1 _ rnc..0 — r Cefl C, Ve ax, tb / (Tfly -<> Cr 4 T__, -reit/ RorVer 7.) e3p-erS A 91)1.1pel'CA-k I'Cf WV/ Fr`be56 itIn 0,1 t nnete54cirti c-or 0,042a:0404 \-\yz, ct 61 ;1116 oisAi 04' fh I' de T-crl 41.- 3 Ki 11 I'll I Ruysler po /box 2 (20 6(41 wivi P617001 i. etiv R014#.: 1-Pr— IN r Or Cot.4a7 01-: C 61 V I); i/l P,461)-6 OP C OLVVF 1 , '-Itht6W-VfiAn/9 Poi r 0) ). . , 1_ , I a i 0 I !(1) E ' L,' 13 -\i3( iv i Term ,-- -c---- ' -;.--t) 0 ....<,,› caa ._...) I It rt I ) 151-er c ( i c1 --A----, ''''-::i"-•' I.,. 7":- ' re7, 1 I cil)prop , i‘e/75,6'.., 4? , 1 pro \--03,5( 0 1)G,i i 5 k noecec,(/ co r prt6e(e„4 )" 7) Olt'. t-h t Cico 05 656, ,n ir) '. 4 i 5 de Cedi7 :1 I , 3 / 1 i 1 /-)) 1/4';‘ ...........................,_____ (74,...4114 .. - 1--_..., 127=1:1■ '1'4'1 I 117 1 ,-- Pc 72,tx 200 C 40)p 11/// PA i20/ I `T"" o r- j N r fic' Cb un'r a F core/v64 P�15I s aF �c�y Rey P�'n�IO51VA1 W A � CGt�,�eL�r�Q C64t��'y Pel-ec /3rnnibn et-61 13 - 1x11 QTr © feeI . A3 I-o P26/i C -n _.$ ieily try, r ce14 �� o t� G n a f D r iA� �i'cehSPG� .. _., �yP��+ 5��n7 r ?PoeSir)41 i 5 cin, ece5A(f Or yroecU)-ion o 1-he Cicogin6 45.c,ini A i 5 dePehn7t i- 31311 l , � , rm..'- et-1y govi_lor. P o 200 C kmv h1,// pA i26ol ■ IN 114, co 4 1-• r OF comific.,,,,, 1tio: 0 F L Ai 6 jt.-.:2L(-4/t.)0 c ,vr/ pi,itim5vi.vyvv//)- n, , 1 13 - \131 L;tv I irer6/1 7' € 0 -c= k... r .Ct..‘, 1,,, 1.. , E --- , m --t7 , •F.: --..,-_-; 37.1 --‹1> co fp i ) T 1/ii i ':i q .-, ef'• cer1- 1C1 I-h6) 4- ". _..„ f-,--- ---i c--; I 1 <7c-J, r,A_ i .'r• :'.r.! e r r tt--,)1 i/. 7 t f) / O c q o ce iy(4,pr .1 6.4 :.1 /i(e-nt-, 47 •;./.' 'i, “.--'fy) for)(4/ ; i/if)i)(ce 5 .)4 -' v/ k c i- pc oect,,i 1/ o/ 1 re f 1 / i(i oy )11,0 r i ‘0 /3 a x -0 0 Lt.) C4frip ili'd tii) 00(:)/ TELLY ROYSTER, • IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF PLAINTIFF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. • PETER BINNION, ET AL DEFENDANTS • NO. 13-1731 CIVIL IN RE: PETITION TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 18th day of April, 2013, upon consideration of Telly Royster's Pro Se Petition to Proceed In Forma Pauperis, and it appearing that Royster is currently serving a life sentence following his conviction for first degree murder and having no income, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DIRECTED that Telly Royster's Petition to Proceed In Forma Pauperis is GRANTED. By the Court, \I\NCta M. L. Ebert, Jr., /I. ✓ Telly Royster, Pro Se Plaintiff ✓ Office of Chief Counsel 1920 Technology Parkway �f Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 e--1 ✓ Corizon D 6 169 Progress Drive k 4-0 =pi -a • Waynesburg, PA 15370-8082 S �' � Prison Health Services '� ' / LL= 8151 State Road = -- - Philadelphia, PA 19136-2910 bas IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA TELLY ROYSTER � CD Plaintiff, z c:) -� v. No. 13-1731 PETER BINNION, et al., Defendants Civil Action PRAECIPE FOR ENTRY OF APPEARANCE TO THE PROTHONOTARY; Please enter my appearance for Corrections Defendants in the above- captioned matter.' Respectfully submitted, Office of General Counsel, oseph Fu ssistant Counsel Attorney ID No.: 208039 Pennsylvania Department of Corrections 1920 Technology Parkway Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Phone No.: (717) 728-7763 Fax No.: (717) 728-0307 E-mail: josfulgini @pa.gov Date: May 8, 2013 1 As counsel for the Department of Corrections, the undersigned counsel is not entering his appearance on behalf of Prison Health Services or Corizon. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA TELLY ROYSTER Plaintiff, V. No. 13-1731 PETER BINNION, et al., Defendants Civil Action CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am depositing in the U.S. mail a true and correct copy of the foregoing Entry of Appearance to be served upon the following person(s) in the manner indicated below. Service by first-class mail addressed as follows: Telly Royster, EL-2245 SCI-Camp Hill PO Box 200 Camp Hill, PA 17001 Renee J. Ro4ts Legal Assistant PA Department of Corrections 1920 Technology Parkway Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Ph: 717-728-7763 Fax: 717-728-0312 Date: May 8, 2013 r r a IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF � CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA c. r TELLY ROYSTER Cn + ° Plaintiff, p� � .C:) , V. No. 13-1731 PETER BINNION, et al., Defendants Civil Action DEFENDANTS' PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT Defendants, by and through their counsel, Joseph G. Fulginiti, Esquire, Assistant Counsel, Pennsylvania Department of Corrections, hereby file the following Preliminary Objections to the Plaintiff's Complaint. Parties and Procedural History: 1. This is a civil action filed pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983 by Plaintiff, Telly Royster, an inmate presently incarcerated by the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Department of Corrections ("the Department") at the State Correctional Institution at Camp Hill ("SCI-Camp Hill") for 1St Degree Murder. 2. The named Defendants are Sgt. Edward Ayers; CO John Britton; CO Clint Brosius; Unit Manager Chris Chambers; Sgt. Thomas Cook; Retired Superintendent Jeffrey Ditty; LPN Lisa Duncan; RN Evirta Gadsden; Lt. Brian Gardner; LPN Erica Gipe; RN Judith Hamovitz; LPN Mary Henderson; Deputy Superintendent Timothy Henry; RN Beth Herb; Lt. Martin Kuzar; Retired CHCA Teresa Law; LPN Lori Liddick; former LPN Danielle McGrath; LPN Melissa O'Brien; RN Shannon Quigley; LPN Melinda Radle-Barrett; CO Matthew Santucci; Acting CHCA Edwin Shoop; Retired Superintendent Richard Southers; CO Jesse Stum; and LPN Sherry Thiombiano.1 . 3. Plaintiffs Complaint appears to have been filed on April 3, 2013 and served by Sheriff on April 19, 2013. Factual Allegations 4. Plaintiff alleges that he has been diagnosed as suffering from severe migraines at least three times per week, lasting for several hours. See Complaint, T 6, 7. 5. When Plaintiff experiences a migraine, he avers that the established procedure is for him to notify a staff member, who then relays the information to the medical staff, who then delivers Plaintiff s migraine medication. Id. at TT 8-11. 6. Plaintiff contends that between March of 2011 and April of 2012 there were approximately 45 separate instances in which Plaintiff requested his migraine medication but did not receive it. Id. at 12. Plaintiff also seeks to name Prison Health Services and Corizon as Defendants in this action, though their inclusion as "people" is likely improper under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and they are not represented by the undersigned DOC counsel. 2 7. Plaintiff further alleges that in April of 2012 Plaintiffs migraine medication order was modified— from "as needed" to "twice daily" — in retaliation for his complaints regarding undelivered medication. Id. at T 18. 8. Plaintiff additionally avers that the Defendants have been negligent towards his medical needs and have committed medical malpractice. Id. at T¶ 30- 34. 9. Plaintiff further contends that several Defendants are liable for damages pursuant to theories of respondeat superior or vicarious liability due to the supervisory nature of their positions. M. at¶ 35. Relief Requested 10. As relief, Plaintiff has requested declaratory relief, compensatory damages, punitive damages and an injunction. Id. at¶¶ 37-43. Demurrer 11. Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure No. 1028(a)(4) provides that a preliminary objection may be filed for legal insufficiency of a pleading, i.e. demurrer. " 12. When ruling on a demurrer, a court may sustain the objections and dismiss the case only when such relief is clear and no doubt exists that the law will not permit a recovery. See Stone and Edwards Insurance Agency, Inc. v. Department of Insurance, 616 A.2d 1060, 1063 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1992). 3 13. A demurrer will not be sustained unless the face of the complaint shows that the law will not permit recovery, and any doubts should be resolved against sustaining the demurrer. Id. 14. In coming to such determination, the court must accept as true all well-pled allegations in the complaint and all inferences reasonably deduced therefrom. See Doxsey v. Commonwealth, 674 A.2d 1173, 1174 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1996). Preliminary Objection: Eighth Amendment Deliberate Indifference 15. To establish an Eighth Amendment claim for a denial of adequate medical care, an inmate must demonstrate deliberate indifference to a serious medical need on the part of the prison officials. Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97, 104-106 (1976) ("It is only such indifference that can offend 'evolving standards of decency' in violation of the Eighth Amendment."). 16. Deliberate indifference exists "where the prison official: (1) knows of a prisoner's need for medical treatment but intentionally refuses to provide it; (2) delays necessary medical treatment based on a non-medical reason; or (3) prevents a prisoner from receiving needed or recommended medical treatment." Rouse v, Plantier, 182 F.3d 192.7 197 (3d Cir. 1999). 17. A mere difference of opinion between the prison's medical staff and the inmate as to the diagnosis and subsequent treatment that the inmate receives 4 does not establish a claim of deliberate indifference. Kretchmar v. Com., 831 A.2d 793 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2003); Farmer v. Carlson, 685 F. Supp. 1335, 1339 (M.D. Pa. 1988). Further, neither negligent misdiagnosis nor an inadvertent failure to provide care establishes a claim of deliberate indifference. Estelle, 429 U.S. at 105-106. 18. When assessing the sufficiency of an Eighth Amendment deliberate medical indifference claim, "[t]he key question . . . is whether [the defendant] provided plaintiff with some type of treatment, regardless of whether it is what plaintiff desires." Farmer v. Carlson, 685 F. Supp. 1335, 1339 (M.D. Pa. 1988) (quoting Lamb v. Maschner, 633 F. Supp. 351, 353 (D. Kan. 1986)). 19. Moreover, the Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit in Durmer v. O'Carroll, 991 F.2d 64, 69 (3d Cir. 1993), established that a non-physician defendant cannot be considered deliberately indifferent for failing to respond to an inmate's medical complaints when he is receiving treatment by the prison's medical staff. 20. The reasoning of Durmer is simple: if differences in opinion between two medical professionals cannot be a basis for an Eighth Amendment claim, then a medically, untrained corrections official cannot be found liable if he relies on the opinions of a medical professional. Id. at 69. 21. Likewise,, in Spruill v. Gillis, 372 F.3d 218, 236 (3d Cir. 2004), the court explained, "[i]f a prisoner is under the care of medical experts . . . a non- 5 medical prison official will generally be justified in believing that the prisoner is in capable hands." The court further concluded in Spruill that "absent a reason to believe (or actual knowledge) that prison doctors or their assistants are mistreating (or not treating) a prisoner, a non-medical prison official . . . will not be chargeable with the Eighth Amendment scienter requirement of deliberate indifference." Id. at 236. 22. Plaintiff alleges only that on approximately 45 dates during a time span of more than a year, his migraine medication was unusually delayed or not delivered. 23. Plaintiffs allegations amount to nothing more than a simple difference of opinion between the type of treatment he wished to receive, the and type and frequency of treatment that was offered by the prison medical staff; this is exactly the difference of opinion that fails to state a claim for an Eighth Amendment violation in Durmer. 24. Plaintiffs Complaint essentially admits that, but for the approximately 45 days within a year that his migraine medication was unusually delayed he typically received treatment as offered by the prison medical staff. 25. As such, Plaintiffs' allegations —that the treatment he was offered was not to his satisfaction — does not rise to the level of an Eighth Amendment violation and should be dismissed accordingly. 6 26. Additionally, many of the individuals named as Defendants in Plaintiffs Complaint, including Defendants Ayer, Britton, Brosius, Chambers, Cook, Ditty, Gardner, Henry, Kuzar, Law, Santucci, Shoop, Southers and Stum, are not medical professionals, and under Spruhill cannot be liable for an Eighth Amendment violation relative to deliberate medical indifference. Preliminary Objection; Retaliation 27. To prevail on a claim of retaliation, Plaintiffs must first prove that his conduct leading to the alleged retaliation was constitutionally protected. Rauser v. Horn, 241 F.3d330, 333 (3dCir. 2001). 28. Next, they must show that they suffered some adverse action from the prison officials. Id. Specifically, they must show that the adverse action which they allegedly suffered was "sufficient to deter a person of ordinary firmness from exercising his First Amendment rights." Allah v. Seiverling, 229 F.3d 220, 224-25 (3d Cir. 2000) (internal quotation and citation omitted). Finally, Plaintiffs must prove that there is a causal relationship between the exercise of their rights and the adverse action taken against them. Rauser, 214 F.3d at 333-334. 29. With regard to the third prong of the Rauser test, the Rauser court adopted the burden-shifting analysis as set forth in Mount Healthy Bd. of Ed. v. Doyle, 429 U.S. 274, 287 (1977), where the Supreme Court held that "the plaintiff bore the initial burden of proving that his constitutionally protected conduct was 'a 7 substantial or motivating factor' in the decision to discipline him. The burden then shifted to the defendant to prove by a preponderance of the evidence that it would have taken the same disciplinary action even in the absence of the protected activity."Rauser, 214 F.3d at 333. 30. In other words, Rauser held, that as to the third prong of the retaliation claim, "once a prisoner demonstrates that his exercise of a constitutional right was a substantial or motivating factor in the challenged decision, the prison officials may still prevail by proving that they would have made the same decision absent the protected conduct for reasons reasonably related to a legitimate penological interest." Id. at 334. 31. In establishing those elements of a retaliation claim, a plaintiff must produce more than "general attacks" upon the defendant's motivations. A plaintiff must produce "affirmative evidence" of retaliation from which a jury could find that he carried his burden of proving the requisite motive. See Crawford-El v. Britton, 523 U.S. 574, 600 (1998) (internal citations omitted). Because many inmates have a tendency to raise retaliation claims when they are confronted with disciplinary action, courts must examine prisoners' retaliation claims skeptically to avoid becoming entangled in every disciplinary action taken against an inmate. Cochran v. Morris, 73 F.3d 1310, 1317 (4h Cir. 1996). 8 32. In the instant matter, Plaintiff has produced only "general attacks" upon the Defendants' motivations with regard to the modification of his medication frequency. 33. Plaintiff alleges that Defendants retaliatorily modified his medication scheduled based upon his complaints regarding the delivery of his migraine medication, but Plaintiff has not established the third element of the Rauser test — that the alleged retaliatory conduct was motivated by his exercise of a constitutional right. 34. Plaintiff does not allege and cannot show that the modification of his medication frequency was motivated by anything other than the interest of his medical care. 35. As such, Plaintiffs claim of retaliation should be dismissed accordingly. Preliminary Objection: NeWhzence/Medical Malpractice 36. The Commonwealth and its employees acting within the scope of their duties enjoy sovereign and official immunity and are immune from suit except where the legislature specifically provides otherwise. See I Pa.C.S. § 2310. 37. The affirmative defense of sovereign immunity may be raised by preliminary objection in the nature of a demurrer where such defense "is apparent 9 on the face of the pleading..." Wurth v. City of Philadelphia, 584 A.2d 403, 407 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1990). 38. In other words, it must be apparent that the cause of action does not fall within one of the statutorily defined exceptions to immunity. Id. See also State Workman's Ins. Fund v. Caparo Real Estate Inc., 635 A.2d 705, 706 n. 2 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1993). 39. At 42 Pa.C.S. § 8522(b), the legislature specifically waived sovereign immunity for negligence claims in nine areas: (1) operation of any motor vehicle in the possession or control of a Commonwealth party; (2) acts of health care employees of Commonwealth agency medical facilities or institutions; (3) care, custody or control of personal property in the possession or control of Commonwealth parties; (4) dangerous condition of Commonwealth agency.real estate and sidewalks; (5) dangerous condition of highways under the jurisdiction of Commonwealth agency created by potholes or sinkholes or other similar conditions created by natural elements; (6) care, custody, or control of animals in the possession or control of a Commonwealth party; (7) sale of liquor at Pennsylvania Liquor stores; (8) acts of a member of the Pennsylvania military forces; and (9) administration, manufacture and use of toxoid or vaccine. See 42 Pa.C.S. § 8522(b). See also Faust v. Commonwealth Dept. of Revenue, 592 A.2d 835, 840, n. 7 (1991). 10 40. Plaintiff alleges that the named Defendants were negligent with regard to his medical care, and that medical malpractice was committed. 41. The closest exception which applies to Petitioner's claim is the exception relating to medical professional liability. See 42 Pa.C.S § 8522(b)(2). But, the medical professional liability exception to sovereign immunity only applies in cases where a medical professional causes the Petitioner's injuries. 42. In this case, with respect to many of the aforementioned non-medical Defendants, these individuals are not medical professionals, and the negligence claim against them should be dismissed. See Williams v. Syed, 782 A.2d 1090 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2001) (inmate failed to allege medical malpractice claim against prison superintendent). 43. With respect to the Defendants who are medical professionals, to the extent that they are medical professionals and the medical professional exception applies, Plaintiff still fails to state a claim of negligence against them. See id. at 1096 (prison health care administrator is properly classified as a health care employee within the meaning of the medical professional liability exception to sovereign immunity). 44. "[T]o state a prima facie cause of action for negligence, a plaintiff must allege (1) a legal duty or obligation to conform to a certain standard of conduct; (2) a failure to conform to that standard; (3) a reasonably close causal 11 connection between the conduct and resulting injury; and (4) actual damage or loss." See Id. at 1093-1094 (citing Wareham v. Jefifes, 564 A.2d 1314 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1989)). 45. Pro se litigants who choose to litigate in state court must adhere to Pennsylvania's "fact-pleading system of jurisprudence." Cimaszewski v. Board of Probation and Parole, 868 A.2d 416, 422 (Pa. 2005). 46. Petitioner's allegations are insufficient to state a claim of negligence by the medical professional Defendants particularly because Plaintiff fails to allege how they breached any duty owed to Plaintiff where he was being treated, albeit not to his satisfaction, and accordingly, any purported negligence claim against those Defendants should be dismissed. Preliminary Objection: Vicarious Liability/Respondeat Superior 47. To state a prima facie claim under the Civil Rights Statute, 42 U.S.C. § 1983, a plaintiff must allege a violation of rights secured by the United States Constitution and the laws of the United States, and he must show that the alleged deprivation was committed by a person acting under the color of state law. West v. Atkins, 487 U.S. 42, 48-57 (1988). 48. For Section 1983 claims, the allegations in the complaint must demonstrate that the defendant was personally involved in the conduct of which the plaintiff complains or that the defendant had actual knowledge of or acquiesced 12 in the commission of the wrong. See Rizzo v. Goode, 423 U.S. 362 (1976); Rode v. Dellarciprete, 845 F.2d 1195, 1207 (3d Cir. 1988); Hampton v. Holmesburg Prison Officials, 546 F.2d 1077, 1082 (3d Cir. 1976). 49, Liability cannot be premised on a theory of respondeat superior. Hampton, 546 F.2d at 1082. 50. Because the language of 42 U.S.C. § 1983 requires a causal relation between the conduct of the defendant and the plaintiffs constitutional deprivation, the doctrine of respondeat superior may not be used to impose liability against a government or supervisor solely by virtue of his position. Monell v. Department Of Social Services, 436 U.S. 658, 690-695 (1978). 51. Thus, to state a cause of action against a defendant in a civil rights action, a plaintiff must make some showing of personal involvement by the supervisory personnel. See Rizzo v. Goode, 423 U.S. 362 (1976). 52. The supervising official's misconduct cannot have been simply a failure to act, but the official must have played an "affirmative part" in the alleged misconduct. Chinchello, v. Fenton, 805 F.2d 126, 133 (3d Cir. 1986). 53. However,, the mere allegation that an official ignored a prisoner's letter of protest and request for an investigation of allegations made in the letter is insufficient to hold that official liable for the alleged violations. See, e.g., Garrido v. Coughlin, 716 F. Supp. 98, 100 (S.D.N.Y. June 27, 1989). 13 54. Likewise, a Defendant cannot be considered to have personal involvement in any alleged wrongdoing by virtue of upholding an appeal. See, e.g., Bey v. Pennsylvania Dept. of Corrections, 98 F.Supp.2d 650, 664 (E.D. Pa. 2000) (official who upheld decisions with respect to misconduct charges against a prisoner was not liable under Section 1983). 55. Plaintiff attempts to hold many of the Defendants liable based upon a theory of respondeat superior•, however, based upon the above-cited cases, such a theory of liability is prohibited in actions brought pursuant to Section 1983. 56. As such, Plaintiff's claims should be dismissed accordingly. Preliminary Obiection: Statute of Limitations 57. The Third Circuit held that Section 1983 actions brought in Pennsylvania are subject to Pennsylvania's two-year statute of limitations for personal injury actions. See 42 Pa. C.S. § 5524. 58. The statute of limitations begins to run when the cause of action accrues, and accrual of Section 1983 claims is governed by federal law. Long v. Board of Educ. of Philadelphia, 812 F. Supp. 525, 530 (E.D. Pa. 1993). 59. A civil rights action accrues when the plaintiff"knew or had reason to know of the injury that constitutes the basis of [the] action." Id. (quoting Sandutch v. Muroski, 684 F.2d 252, 254 (3d Cir. 1982)). 14 60. Plaintiff alleges violations beginning in March of 2011 and ending in April of 2012. See Complaint, 61. However, Plaintiff's Complaint was not filed until April of 2013. Id. 62. As such, any violations occurring beyond the two-year statute of limitations — that is, those violations alleged to have occurred between March of 2011 and April 3, 2011, should be dismissed as barred by the statute of limitations. 15 WHEREFORE, for the reasons cited above, the Defendants respectfully request that this Honorable Court dismiss the Plaintiff's complaint accordingly. Respectfully submitted, Office of General Counsel, ul ssistant Counsel Attorney ID No.: 208039 Pennsylvania Department of Corrections 1920 Technology Parkway Mechanicsburg, PA, 17050 Phone No.: (717) 728-7763 Fax No.: (717) 728-0307 E-mail: josfulgini @pa.gov Date: May 8, 2013 16 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA TELLY ROYSTER Plaintiff, ; V. No. 13-1731 PETER BINNION, et al., ; Defendants Civil Action CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day depositing in the U.S. mail a true and correct copy of Defendants' Preliminary Objections to Plaintiff's Complaint in the above-referenced matter. Service by first-class mail addressed as follows: Telly Royster, EL-2245 SCI-Camp Hill PO Box 200 Camp Hill, PA 17001 Renee J. R �es Legal Assistant PA Department of Corrections 1920 Technology Parkway Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Ph: 7 1 7-728-7763 Fax: 717-728-0312 Date:. May 8, 2013 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA TELLY ROYSTER Plaintiff, V. No. 13-1731 PETER BINNION, et al., Defendants Civil Action PROPOSED ORDER NOW, this day of 2013, upon consideration of the Defendants ' Preliminary Objections to Plaintiff's Complaint, it is hereby ORDERED that the Demurrer is GRANTED. Plaintiff's Complaint is hereby DISISSED. BY THE COURT: J. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA TELLY ROYSTER, a pro se plaintiff ) V. ) CORIZON; ) PETER BINNION, MD; ) No. 13—1731 C THEODOOR VOORSTAD, MD; et al. ) c Cn CD -< W _ rat Praecipe for Notice of Removal to the United States District Court F To: The Prothonotary of the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1446(d),the above-captioned defendants enclose herewith as an attached exhibit a true and correct copy of the Notice of Removal filed on May 30, 2013 in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania. By: John . Ha zell,Jr., Esquire Attorn f r Defendants Corizon, Peter Binnion, MD, and Theodoor Voorstad, MD PA I.D.#38548 STRACHAN&HATZELL One Liberty Place—Suite 3800 1650 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 Phone: (215) 255-6400 Fax: (215) 933-3207 e-mail:John.Hatzell @AIG.com IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA TELLY ROYSTER, a pro se plaintiff ) V. ) CORIZON; ) PETER BINNION, MD; ) No. 13—1731 THEODOOR VOORSTAD, MD; et al. ) Certificate of Service I hereby certify that a true copy of the attached Notice of Removal was mailed/e-mailed this 30th day of May, 2013, via electronic mail to the following.parties of record: Joseph Fulginiti, Esquire Telly Royster, EL-2245 for the PA Dept. of Corrections SCI—Camp Hill Office of General Counsel P.O. Box 200 Via E-mail:josfulgini @pa.gov Camp Hill, PA 17001 By: Joh J. atzell,Jr., Es uire Attor for Defendants Corizon, Peter Binnion, MD, and Theodoor Voorstad, MD PA L D.#38548 STRACHAN&HATZELL One Liberty Place—Suite 3800 1650 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 Phone: (215) 255-6400 Fax: (215) 933-3207 e-mail:John.Hatzell @AIG.com 2 Exhibit to Praecipe for Notice of Removal to the U.S.D.C. for the Middle District of PA JS 44 (Rev.12/12) CIVIL COVER SHEET The JS 44 civil cover sheet and the information contained herein neither replace nor supplement the filing and service of pleadings or other papers as required by law, except as provided b local rules of court. This form,approved by the Judicial Conference of the United States in September 1974,is required for the use of the Clerk of Court for the purpose of by the civil docket sheet. (SEE INSTRUC27ONSONNEXT PACE OF THIS FORM.) I. (a) PLAINTIFFS DEFENDANTS TELLY ROYSTER CORIZON; PETER BINNION,MD; THEODOOR VOORSTAD,MD;et al. (b) County of Residence of First Listed Plaintiff CUMBERLAND County.PA County of Residence of First Listed Defendant WILLIAMSON County,TN (EXCEPTIN U.S.PLAINTIFF CASES) (IN U.S.PLAINTIFFCASES ONLY) NOTE: IN LAND CONDEMNATION CASES,USE THE LOCATION OF THE TRACT OF LAND INVOLVED. (C) Attomeys(lSrni Name,Addrerr,and 7clepphone Number) Attorneys(If rcnounr) TELLY ROYSTER,a Pro Se Plaintiff John J.Hatzell Jr.,Esquire Phone:215-255-6400 EL-2245 STRACHAN&HATZELL SCI-CAMP HILL,P.O.Box 200,CAMP HILL,PA 17001 Suite 3800, One Liberty Place 1650 Market Street (This is an inmate of the State Correctional Institution at Camp Hill,PA) Philadelphia,PA 19103 II. BASIS OF JURISDICTION(Place an"X"in One Box Only) III. CITIZENSHIP OF PRINCIPAL PARTIES(Place an"X"in One BoxforPlaimifJ (For Diversity Cases Only) and One Box for Defendant) ❑I U.S.Government ®3 Federal Question PTF DEF PTF DF,F Plaintiff (U.S.Government Not a Party) Citizen of This State ❑ 1 ❑ 1 Incorporated or Principal Place ❑ 4 ❑4 of Business In This State ❑2 U.S.Government ❑4 Diversity Citizen of Another State ❑2 ❑ 2 Incorporated and Principal Place ❑ 5 135 Defendant (Indicate Citizenvhip of Parties in Item 111) of Business In Another State Citizen or Subject of a ❑3 ❑ 3 Foreign Nation ❑ 6 ❑6 Foreign Country IV. NATURE OF SUIT (Place an"X"in One Box Only) CONTRACT TORTS FORFEITURF✓PENALTY BANKRUPTCY OTHERSTATUTES ❑110 Insurance PERSONAL INJURY PERSONAL INJURY ❑625 Drug Related Seizure [:1422 A cal 28 USC 158 Appeal ❑ 375 False Claims Act ❑120 Marine ❑ 310 Airplane ❑ 365 Personal Injury - of Property 21 USC 881 [:1423 Withdrawal ❑ 400 State Reapportionment ❑130 Miller Act ❑ 315 Airplane Product Product Liability ❑690 Other 28 USC 157 ❑ 410 Antitrust ❑140 Negotiable Instrument Liability ❑ 367 Health Care/ ❑ 430 Banks and Banking ❑150 Recovery of Overpayment ❑ 320 Assault,Libel& Pharmaceutical PROPERTY RIGHTS ❑ 450 Commerce &Enforcement of Judgment Slander Personal Injury ❑820 Copyrights ❑ 460 Deportation ❑151 Medicare Act ❑ 330 Federal Employers' Product Liability ❑830 Patent ❑ 470 Racketeer Influenced and ❑152 Recovery of Defaulted Liability ❑ 368 Asbestos Personal ❑840 Trademark Corrupt Organizations Student Loans ❑ 340 Marine Injury Product ❑ 480 Consumer Credit (Excludes Veterans) ❑ 345 Marine Product Liability LABOR SOCIAL SECURITY ❑ 490 Cable/Sat TV ❑153 Recovery of Overpayment Liability PERSONAL PROPERTY ❑710 Fair Labor Standards ❑861 HIA(I395ff) ❑ 850 Securities/Commodities/ of Veteran's Benefits ❑ 350 Motor Vehicle ❑ 370 Other Fraud Act ❑862 Black Lung(923) Exchange ❑160 Stockholders'Suits ❑ 355 Motor Vehicle ❑ 371 Truth in Lending ❑720 Labor/Management ❑863 DIWC/DIW W(405(8)) ❑ 890 Other Statutory Actions ❑190 Other Contract Product Liability ❑ 380 Other Personal Relations ❑864 SSID Title XVI ❑ 891 Agricultural Acts ❑195 Contract Product Liability ❑ 360 Other Personal Property Damage ❑740 Railway Labor Act ❑865 RSI(405(8)) ❑ 893 Environmental Matters ❑196 Franchise Injury ❑ 385 Property Damage ❑751 Family and Medical ❑ 895 Freedom of Information ❑ 362 Personal Injury- Product Liability Leave Act Act Medical Malpractice ❑790 Other Labor Litigation ❑ 896 Arbitration REAL PROPERTY CIVIL RIGHTS PRISONER PETITIONS ❑791 Employee Retirement FEDERAL TAX SUITS El 899 Administrative Procedure 210 Land Condemnation 440 Other Civil Rights Habeas Corpus: Income Security Act Ll 870 Taxes(U.S.Plaintiff Act/Review or Appeal of ❑220 Foreclosure ❑ 441 Voting ❑ 463 Alien Detainee or Defendant) Agency Decision ❑230 Rent Lease&Ejectment ❑ 442 Employment ❑ 510 Motions to Vacate ❑871 IRS—Third Party ❑ 950 Constitutionality of ❑240 Torts to Land ❑ 443 Housing/ Sentence 26 USC 7609 State Statutes ❑245 Tort Product Liability Accommodations ❑ 530 General ❑290 All Other Real Property ❑ 445 Amer.w/Disabilities ❑ 535 Death Penalty .IMMIGRATION Employment Other: E]462 Naturalizatio-n-A-p-pTi—catton ❑ 446 Amer.w/Disabilities ❑ 0 Mandamus&Other [1465 Other Immigration Other 550 Civil Rights Actions O M ❑ 448 Education ❑ 555 Prison Condition O �' ❑ 560 Civil Detainee- LJ Conditions of Confinement V. ORIGIN(Place m 'in One Box Only) ❑ 1 Original 2 Removed from ❑ 3 Remanded from ❑4 Reinstated or ❑ 5 Transferred from ❑ 6 Multidistrict Proceeding State Court Appellate Court Reopened Another District Litigation (specify) Cite the U.S.Civil Statute under which you are filing (Do not citejurisdictional statutes unless diversity): VI. CAUSE OF 42 U.S.C.1983 and the 8t°Amendment to the U.S.Constitution ACTION Brief description of cause: Plaintiff claims defendants were deliberately indifferent to his need for Inedical treatment. VII. REQUESTED IN ❑ CHECK IF THIS IS A CLASS ACTION DEMAND$ 0 d ) CHECK YES only if demanded in compl ' t. COMPLAINT' UNDER RULE 23,F.R.Cv.P. a `i( a �iG -� E JURY DEMAND: ❑Yes No VIII. RELATED CASE(S) IF ANY (See instructions): JUDGE DOCKET NUMBER DATE SIGNATURE OF ATTORNEY OF RECORD 05/30/2013 John J.Hatzell,Jr.,Esquire/s/ 410 FOR OFFICE USE ONLY RECEIPT tl AMOUNT APPLYING IFP JUDGE MAG.JUDGE IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA TELLY ROYSTER ) Plaintiff(s), ) V. ) ) CORIZON; ) Civil Action No. 02 -6000 PETER BMMON,MD; ) THEODOOR VOORSTAD, MD. ) Defendant(s)/ ) Third-Party Plaintiff(s), ) V. ) Third-Party Defendant(s). ) DISCLOSURE STATEMENT PURSUANT TO Fed.R.Civ.P. 7.1 (Civil Action) Pursuant to Rule 7.1 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure,the Defendant CORIZON (type of party) who is , makes the following disclosure: (name of party) Page 1 of 2 1. Is the party a non-governmental corporate party? ,Vl YES ❑ NO 2. If the answer to Number 1 is"yes,"list below any parent corporation or state that there is no such corporation: There is no parent corporation. 3. If the answer to Number 1 is"yes,"list below any publicly-held corporation that owns 10%or more of the party's stock or state that there is no such corporation: There is no such corporation. The undersigned party understands that under Rule 7.1 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure,it must promptly file a supplemental statement upon any change in the information that this statement requires. John J. Hatzell,Jr., Esquire/s/ Signature of Counsel for Party Date: 5/30/2013 Page 2 of 2 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA TELLY ROYSTER, a prose plaintiff ) V. ) CORIZON; ) PETER BINNION, MD; ) No. 02—6000 THEODOOR VOORSTAD, MD; et al. ) NOTICE OF REMOVAL To The United States District Court For The Middle District Of Pennsylvania: The defendants, CORIZON, Peter Binnion, MD, and Theodoor Voorstad, MD, by and through the undersigned counsel, hereby files this notice of removal of the above-captioned action from the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, No. 13—1731, where it is now pending, to the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1331, §1441 and other applicable laws. In support of this removal, the defendants aver the following: 1. Attached as Exhibit "A" is a copy of the pro se complaint in this action, which originated in the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, PA where the Plaintiff resides imprisoned as an inmate of the State Correctional Institution at Camp Hill (a/k/a SCI —Camp Hill). 2. Docket no. 13- 1731 reveals that plaintiff commenced this action in the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County against numerous defendants on or about April 3, 2013; however, proper service upon the moving defendants herein was never made. 3. The Plaintiffs certificate of service of the complaint in this matter is attached as Exhibit"B." 4. The defendant therefore avers that service of original process was not properly effected under the PA Rules of Civil Procedure'within the previous thirty (30) days or otherwise. 5. Pursuant to the provisions of 28 U.S.C. §1331, the United States district courts shall have original jurisdiction of all civil actions arising under the Constitution, laws, or treaties of the United States. 6. In his complaint (Exhibit "A"),the Plaintiff asserts that during his present incarceration he has been intentionally denied adequate and proper medical care, which is a claim sounding in a violation of his Eighth Amendment rights (the states may not subject a person to cruel and unusual punishment). 7. Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1441,this civil action is properly removable to the Middle District of Pennsylvania, which has jurisdiction over actions filed in the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, PA, where such actions involve federal laws and questions. 8. All other parties (represented by Joseph Fulginiti, Esquire)consent to the removal of this civil action to the United States District Court. 9. Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1446(d),the moving defendant will promptly file a copy of this notice of removal with the Clerk of Courts of the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, and will serve a copy of same on counsel all adverse parties. 1 PA Rule of Civil Procedure no.402 holds that original service of process within the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania must be made by the Sheriff by hand delivering the complaint to an authorized representative of the defendant. Service of original process cannot be made by U.S. Mail. 2 WHEREFORE,the Defendants, Corizon, Peter Binnion, MD, and Theodoor Voorstad, MD, hereby removes this action to the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania. By: John J. Hatzell,Jr.. Esquire /s/ John J. Hatzell,Jr., Esquire Attorney for Defendants PA I.D.#38548 STRACHAN&HATZELL One Liberty Place—Suite 3800 1650 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 Phone: (215) 255-6400 Fax: (215) 933-3207 e-mail: John.Hatzell@AIG.com 3 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA TELLY ROYSTER, a pro se plaintiff ) V. ) CORIZON; ) PETER BINNION, MD; ) No. 02—6000 THEODOOR VOORSTAD, MD; et al. ) Certificate of Service •I hereby certify that a true copy of the attached Notice of Removal was mailed/e-mailed this 30th day of May, 2013, via electronic mail to the following parties of record: Joseph Fulginiti, Esquire Telly Royster, EL-2245 for the PA Dept. of Corrections SCI —Camp Hill Office of General Counsel P.O. Box 200 Via E-mail:josfuleini@r)a.goy Camp Hill, PA 17001 By: John J. Hatzell, Jr.. Esquire /s/ John J. Hatzell,Jr., Esquire Attorney for Defendants PA I.D.#38548 STRACHAN&HATZELL One Liberty Place—Suite 3800 1650 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 Phone: (215) 255-6400 Fax: (215) 933-3207 e-mail: John.Hatzell(a)AIG.com Date: 5/30/2013 EXHIBIT "A" Supreme Co- . nnsylvania Cou f Cti t>! leas For Prothonotary Use Only: C t t Docket No:�yr County j 1 .,31 01V If Tarr The information collecled on this,form is used solely.for court administration purposes. This firm does not supplement or replace the filing and service qfpleadings or other papers as required by law or rules of court. Commencement of Action: IM Complaint 0 Writ of Summons ❑ Petition ❑ Transfer from Another Jurisdiction Declaration of Taking & Lead Plaintiff's Name: Lead Defendant's Name: T" -Telly )?n s('r" Pe-kr 8 Dollar Amount Requested: Owithin arbitration limits lC Are money damages requested? M Yes 0 No (check one) 12outside arbitration limits 0 N Is this a Class Action Suit? ❑Yes 0 No Is this an MDJAppeal? [] Yes C7 No A Name of Plaintiff/Appellant's Attorney: ® Check here if you have no attorney(area Self-Represented (Pro Sej Litigant) Nature of the Case: Place an"X"to the left of the ONE case category that most accurately describes your PRIMARY CASE. If you are making more than one type of claim,check the one that you consider most important. TORT(do not include Aloss Tort) CONTRACT(do not include Judgments) CIVIL APPEALS ❑ Intentional ❑Buyer Plaintiff Administrative Agencies ❑ Malicious Prosecution ❑Debt Collection:Credit Card Q Board of Assessment ❑Motor Vehicle Q Debt Collection:Other O Board of Elections Q Nuisance Dept.of Transportation © Premises Liability B Statutory Appeal:Other S ❑ Product Liability(does not include El�+ Employment Dispute: mass tort} Q Slander/Libel/Defamation Discrimination C! ❑ Other: Q Employment Dispute:Other ❑ Zoning Board T _ 0 Other: Q Other: Q MASS TORT ❑ Asbestos N Q Tobacco ❑ Toxic Tort-DES ❑ Toxic Tort-Implant REAL PROPERTY MISCELLANEOUS Toxic Waste [,� Other: 0 Ejectment ❑Common Law/Statutory Arbitration 0 Eminent Domain/Condemnation ❑Declaratory Judgment Q Ground Rent Mandamus ❑ Landlord/Tenant Dispute Non-Domestic Relations ®Mortgage Foreclosure:Residential Restraining Order PROFESSIONAL LIABLITY ❑Mortgage Foreclosure:Commercial Q Quo Warranto 0 Dental © Partition 0 Replevin Q Legal Q Quiet Title Q Other: W Medical n Other: Q Other Professional: Updated 11112011 -Eli 1-Ir Coc+RT of corr»6N PLEA'S OP CuolSeOLAND Cou10Ty, P6AIA yY4V&1119 Q�tY RoyS�tT 3 1 1131 - , tie�e(, , (3'176oA,c 1 a,? Civil Ac�ie�I -rTl 71 Op r-- w c r-= —+c NOTICE TO DE-FE >c /OG been 514 d /R C-14, I Ybu Wi6h d4ed O.QGt1/l6T 4-/+P SIG+MS S�� �br�h ;n the vllow;n3 g ige,s , you m tsf f4kk GcVlon &,J ;An +-wPA� 00 days cAr cw4Ai,,� and notsa are 5et'ved I by tnlerrr75 o, wrlt4n &,ppearRncv ej,5onctll Cr by oArrney and X11;05 +n �r� 4g wl'" 1he Court' Yogr de�Pn560 or objecf tons is Eh'. Cla;MS Sep' �- orEh 013ri*5 ' YOA, Yoa are W4rned AcJ ;� 11"14 �A;f �a 90 50 fk C09 MAI proceed w4komf You and a j%#45menl w-I 32 enkrtJ aowml ' you Al +hL &,44 oiAo4 �,,r6er tlotit$ far anI lVentl c�uimecf in �� Coro��G��} or �ot` Gn� 0 1Pr GC14;n� or- PdA reIkeska hY tyke Pl�,tn�i�� . `lou �,uy fo5e money! ar prb�e��y a� o ►Pr f j5hVs irnpar-144� W yoa. ycU GI{out,U +AKe r rots POW TO YouR LRW`Jea 9i aNC_.0 , jj i-toa Oo 1 gFFORO ON6+ (70 tO OR ELGPiiovG Na"C ,Ave A AWyiR p(Z CRNNnT T7+t; d�r'c� s�; t=eLert{ r�ELOw ro rtN9 wµE�E YDU CAN Ge AFLP C�Mbe�►G^d Cn�y P��,r g55ocia�ton 314 6..4 r3ed +rd 5I. Cacli5k P(4 l7c 115 1 - 00-- q`10- 910 3 _71'7- THE C oNer or con►omoti Ptffit o e v �nr•,or., da•c's1r�� C.usmf��2tAND fiau,vTy, pr,Vt'�SYt,Vt}Nit� B d, 0144y:5aAhers, Nenty, l,c,w, C-araoel.,K�::Kr, (oA,Ajre5j xtin+s,�y,t�urci Edar:e, 5-wog, 6e,46t),$rO5iuy1 than, trs��rian i4ender.).4,A%,nth;T"h;e►rib+ lhunntih, &.ca, �yr#i,,m tndi,,a�t,r`#�, ij Stany t,a„r PPv)t,n ak:Ah frrvice, Corgi zon �om ? AeJC NOW, L%vAvb 4i,a pj,,iA%C'�r', TIMI Qbyskr and a%vtrs the Vnl{owt 05 i A Sypper� m hi t, tb+np�4i r� �, ��� t�t.�'ion �s bro��- iri the Coati's ori�irYal �i+tri3r�te�`at2r conzurP�n-� urisafic�';on oo,�h +he Federal Ceu4 4er u,b� 441m9, one;//er SaQplcmtn`i Ai jarisdi4ion �tr U,S, COs�4si r`ohU de-ims. -2. pka nVj�� Telly & s}er- is & ptisoner prt6Cnft;1 rncarsemted a� 5C) c4.p bill. ;. 3, Da�enjCA+s leer 6innron, Aidvr Voar6+(;d) 'Tj Frey Dr 4 y, Ri ch4,,d SaciAtrsl T.0. i4enry , 7-tre5r, "t-A j 6d Shoop L+.Gardner-, IJ. Kt,zar, 564-, Cook, s .A;rCS� F1'nn j Col SanfwCc.'t, C41 6"vavnel; 01 Sfu:5+"*)., C��lB640n; Col &0;14as, Chris UWAMbtM.) Miissc, 0bri(An) M Dot ary Hcadtfsonj w) t•,f✓CGI'aAj She-toy nov6iano,, 14d; 14omeb1+zy AhAr6e. Li t e j V-4me 6han^onr Al"rse Erieal Nurse tbeAj ,'t1W(.66 t"lal+ndat A) rse C-V1f C4) fjuroa T'440.ny , Almfl a I.o,uIftelf are. or we-t•e employed 6Y +6e Penmgl vanic. De�,ar men+ o� Corfie4ion s 00c) or as conkraJ weekers a+ Set Camp hill d&4r;AS Ae, 44te. l*6he/ in +his cotwp kin�. 0 q,De�tndar& Prison ffmRh Cary Services, 006) 101hr known c,� C662.0n wat, Ae t»tt icui prautckr for At 70C olurin5 #-hc. kMe,-5 1161rd t'n �-1 is to.�pl t„f-, 3.,v. -;*Eozl 4ii tndani" ore4ed under +he coler 4 s6 a Aw etnd are 6wed in Asir OMtic'i �. ant indtvi aal CaPAC4 Pl4W F hi bh fiA " r r ol y -"ftef! n rl ,5�carn VY11l�t'C+►1neS= 7. Pi(Ain4j;' rectives mjjujnes %V 3e4s+ �hrte C3) 44Mes ptr a,eek a WJ r,4ch tp�Sode U-4 las} from N tew loours wpfc Mort i4xn 07) fours Bach, Z Pla;ntj�� wc,b prescribed by a,, oloc+or F orice+ mediaa- m .oti powc4mj pa;n Mlitkr on on As needed basis 1'0 4 44en (A)m pla;4A has a rn; tai»a= `l, When ��ai»�;�� tjYfer1tnOf,5 a rM1. rAi/)e of- 6yrdp+0076 thy,#' kook :4p f» G MifQ;ne ht i s r a y a SU 4 mt1"bxr f-holf lie needs hie, med3 cc, 104. +o. S+DA mw6� Then n4lV y meditaf s+aA Ph f-pkWiTT is in nee4l a-' Ai.-, merIve-r.A"an- il Ihedic6i depc,4okn+ is }den r,e5por�,'bit V6r delivering Hhe. MediC4ie,'t -FO p14;n4i fp u 4h- ,n a #+meaty rtvnoerr, 4rt-� w)wre ;row ¢en trliaaki fo one. hour- a-f mot4-• Ez. 'b4nen March of 200 and RE)'S) O� ea012 there wire opproximckly (y5) 44erenf #Mmes +haf` P/441*4 r ues+ed his med caAm tat- his mi mine anel ckc/ no+ 4`ttebx his r»edKo4lon -6 more fhan six havers tvNer rwh; � Ae truest or n a+ Aa caHgrn w V t4141 -) ,5 V � � onp ' N -A /4 ' c� fix Ml�t'"d!�ine eptscrle c,t- �+��i� �� mt�tta�i'an lest�5 rss�tda 13, OF ,fit ((/s) �im$s pl-ir)-P;;P wo,s 01E14yed in Peteioinj his r t J o4 ail wus a tt6i.14- dePendanfs 4h"rs, Gardner, AArar,# Cook, Aires) p runt 5t,Autcj, Cvfns, S u,�, t8r:f d:n, c, d l3tost'+es o f�, need fir` the TnediCA-611 (nnd -'die dtAndrnis Alartd ,;�fermin Me mtyr+cal depar4menil- o r'o WJ or �c,iltd h ih 'ot-r» h 111d cd deparl-mili a-� 001. 144 The oAtr 1-rme-) p6inkff we4t, delayer! ;A C*'1J kiS M W,;:4 'ro#? j5 6eaw, "tndaah 0&1'vni kisa, 6heumenj f.rica, &A, 1►?0r4ala) Dnr'elj Zv;4gi she.nry# r,Apanyi Tudy, 14-mry an;��+ 1"w6yj rr t.re ftsp .-wait for/ c4hjerin j f v Me4A�:or) b,4 aP er 6e1 �'iMaff f'litd Pt pioinT/tT0 /3Etd 1G?I dLlGytf! #55Nin fhc ancAmi%dn Per setet,41 ijou�S. IS. Sweet March o� 2011 uAW prttpea� fait, pkinh;P leas 1"Ade a /s~ber- o A44tr p+-. +v "t4kre (hit. proQcoi fb no Adc�il by makin3 t trbeJ " wr114en cc�xplcaak '}a ieulade mcmi yit.tc,nces, oM a; whic� he exltu, 6Jed all Ttmpd rs a✓adcble Ao rim. 16. 0,4enkn6 P1#5t ifenry, 5hoap) Dd4p Szru hers, G'h4wibers) 14,4, 6okt^dntrj jk,4%&r, Gooks Ruts, and Minn ,^sere a ch persena,tly acaare OT' i-1+0 problt,rr Y�ecc;�tin� his r»ecl,cw 'ian b:, 4;{td 'lv #i, a t`tayonr.We steps 4D rtioJ'se fbe prob-er". t'r tP10.4 A sfaci�icaily Armed each a; fbrse dtfendaf4f> a� his prowe" e;}her vtt•aAIly or ,n wt•i�inJ. ig, Atra, ,d f4aeeh o:- AP-1 &JV �Ot d in Walic on Par h,s compJa:,4i rtjard;,15 hit, Meoitakic-y, p1a,41iR' F;ahtcl ordtr wky tCAC,%ecp! -Frain as necdico� fd wJ`ce u G/A af 5C+ 4;fnt5 �7ypr3 45 fist MediC444 00-1JdI a4 bt: effective ordered Mis WAY,# j9. Werxdan� f3innt'ob# vocr4cd, vhovp and kaij are tvspan"Je por 1-he etia,,,$e , Z'Oo frcra parch or 13pri1 a� X61a u4;1 ptoenf duce plai.j T- has bee;, �erctol fo t44ft e)(Crt4L4;Aj {eta;ire ;or Ap h +tn )ai=rs at) Mort f#s»„ i 2Z� stpc,ruFe ccru�sron� buaKoe 6 i s �c rc O 7o -KW At mtcJ:c,�}i 0A riJ se J hme s a ai, PH5 hc;s i4woed fa 1it'avi a plc,;,4;;; w,lA any rehe� or o4)ert4,ye enfa re- 4hc,>�- 04"41;� is provided WJs -rta+t»enf Var his wiowi ,tit-AO neec{s: 41O,- D4tnd,»n+a i..ciw o,00l Ginnion 44cl PW*4i ft fhci-- his medliccken Order, &V416 c.6wjol 4t se+ fime-a 4-a p,reve»4` hive 6rfn ;;I;n.3 grie#AMCts can4ern,n,5 nUf ftceiJ,ng �ht med cc,6en• a3. l it n,,aserl ate endanF3 hne-11 0� �4ir141 $ .scetov,s mtcl,'cai needs: Clooffis Per Rebev A• Uei;berR„k Ihc+�;UC16,ente Jo aerlous Med'caj needts ;Z�t. ngtt�ry�s Cha nb,ers# Gapdaier, 8.r4z,4r, Coe-,,j1 ins# FLOn i � San KrCi, 6r46n, $rotiA6 re�abcd k mb y medical a� plal»Pif;s need- A, Isis me it rn a +imtly magnet` And j,+me 4;wses5 /*+ A-- All cons�i+uh4d a/t It-trace rock f f v rr tce iLo plairrk s 6cfiovt9 medicAl ncedi, in v,o)Jion oY the 6�AA Anead atv-k As. De�'enrc-Ce+,�s Ogc;4», I•is4) jhanoon f L-'Pica, &A, f*al;ndl4, Daniel, 4✓fr ia, 54errp . w d� ,i UJV, -aw-y and Mrry rcVc;yc+) -c dtjiocr medica•ker) -fb p144:44J; in a •,melt' mknnrr o,$••4tr be;nD n.JiPcJ -AJ he needed /4 com:q-Mu ied 4,140r41e I`t%ht�-c(wCe .}a p seeicws medico,l needs in vioktlo» o; tl,e Ci j6A '947,1041e,4. 26. P14s) 81117nior'1j Vocre4ad, IL4wj Shoop) Henry, D,'fly r•jo�rtlrers, Xazur, Chambers, Car ,4aer, Ceok j Aims and Ram 47 er•hei r 3upery+sot' eaPcw,�y Aa,))4,3 tired k„o;,,;Icc19e o� P14,n�;4 s serious med;m! needs and f6;i;n3 P" ><uke t'ek5onr�ble s ees �o ens.;rei p1m,�i<0 receives cyproplr;aje Acca�m&,4 ca,74 Jed cklib ra4e Plainl•r•�•F S serloys medical netd5 /a ✓r•o/ATia-n c; At it'hlh ay, Devendr,nts I&Imlior), Vcvr4fad, 14w and Shoop actions ;n chan�/�S /°/yi„fiF�'s Mrc�ia></an +o "4 �irmts preve/,ling P14i�7irt' trowi receiu;nj kha neec/toI• n'ftdr(d �rrct�,,-,end ashrle :n pain Cons•�i-66d ak ibercfe ;ndiMttnre �c ply;a fps uria".5 Altd;ca/ needs :n ✓iclalien a� l'ht �i�rfh /�mendir�enE• dS• As a res�i�• e� fbc a6oJe .►renfionrd del,�era�e indi•��erti,ue he Pl4il)T;�+s ser,`otss /rfrd;rtl nttJ-. 5)I q01 n.•med dtPendaahj pkI'elf;ft S►rl•feerd .4-were physical tta,.l c&7r-Ii'onaJ p4;6 401/1,,1 4e�, M. Oe&nd4R+3 Wn4,vo , ✓oer-.tkd) Shoop and l-Uw ck kyd �o,41WS rnedi,o4ian +c 4 �iyJlS �S aF the, 3rieaantec. pic-413; �Aed rvj4rdin3 r,o+ PeueircinS �is merlieafion in a >�i�nclr MAnner W1tn t"Tt tdr Kil$ Lon4;446j M1410lion tar Pe4; 10I)ins redrew e� grievcnces r nd 4sert"re violob6on Ae- Atmn&/Men+) P14 6•Wt ConsW4ian cod clear PA t4t-,it kj cJa►ms t r rGWia�ien. C-. nle5l i9enee/f''')t4W rhkl prat tr`ce 36. ali dtVtAj c:n'i<s A.;% d 4"A )•h;s eoMplr inj *,Jed plk►njiff a army o•� reasank6k Care >� enscsre tykt hr's ac„r► intdicafion etras ;65-fed +0 MM !n A b'"eir P"A,mer- iipv-7 Aein9 rnal'Aed •61 . he needed ;•l-. 3i. Aii tmfntd c0cnAnk 61`eo►Aed A4+ dall &j Fail,tl �b ensare ply+/��/ rece;�c�l his medirc,�io:► •Ohen ,making a retests#- Vor ;t, 3a. 7/,e brtaLh o� olu�y re•;ailto/ in P1a;r�'�-; � suSfrr-i/es sescre phrsilyd and eme4icnal pcin and injutt u3. -/-be 6fuch o� dair ptexi'mizidy caiaeJ fho,�e dae?ages 1�ltiinr��� 6xf;ereal 34 Ail deVendanFs ;ailed -to j6rm`,4lk-e a, daelepf amd CnPor•'ce. adetctak. rule5 and pclicres iv err�vte Z""1 3y Cart. Yoe' pj&i414; cnp �a;jed to aver6ee Ail Fer5ons iiho Prac4lce- MediCl4e wails. D. ViLAr WAA2 l i%6 444 CRcz ro,)a6+ SHperiv l- i�e�endan�s PHS, rs:nnionj Voors+Ad, l.aus y shoot) Nenry) Oilh/1 so wMe.rs� 947sir, Li,gon6ers, GArdretr i Cath, Ai its and Fl%.,n .'A J6 r Remelt a capes►f/ hav1,,)5 aIiret+ knowle4e a'F plain4rtta 6erio i6 medicut needs hailed h -t:V 3ulkre j ancy C%JOFV An �M rt c+vVr k "4Iei Ald POIiGes 16 e04ft t4oJI�r Cc,*t V e r I,31Aig7 ir Anc t .ltd 10 ooertee c,U Per6t,0 ,4l0 PrrkcAice feditlne :A646 ;�5 walls, 3�. Ai o. resui} cif +he c, owc men4livar d Deliberti}e iodAreote, 6. ReIAWSiOQ C. N�o�igeoc��i�9tdieal melprkctice. 0. Vico,rious iiabdi4l IRe,6p6adtc, - Saje(-ior' by c1.11 na,ntd dt�endAnfa itSped"Cir Severe fphysil and ea"o-hoo"! Pain Anj inyuty. PROt:t2 FOP, fiGl..t&'t= WHERE'PM6 }ain}J mmpc4,• -mllr ,rays 4-h,4 Phis Cou4 e_n,).sr ,jWCfjMra 37. A dtclaro' ion -'-6k• I ht U6 and ami"lens elteri6ecl herein violc'.lecl rbii,ol T5, '68, C6mpet)644ory dam ty �,i r•" cmwoof P $900 Doo, j o5aiaek o4,.4 de-Pen4ll,4 39. Panik,,t damrgc5 l he an+aun a F $401000,eo a9ai s6-k each, dtFenalanl 10. Inj:, t4lon ftliat Mt!it;n3 fo ccrrtcf pic-"4jfpI mtdio;han craters. 4l A otl pf rtal on 0411 by pop, I2. 6 CO*k i4 A;7 ;6614. `t3, Any addikmel rcheP phis coar� ekems JW4 and v4Able. V159 1-Ft CWrl0M .- h"ve. -tad 4-6,t 64-yie#5 ecinpletin4 oancl htrtby vrr;�j t6 f he rvma-gers ml,%ec/ •}hcre:n Ure 'brae c,nc1 co:rcc+- •1- t,nderbfand 464 Wlt ShjeMe✓,Is hertiir, arc S,A6jec+ +o The e� I? Pa C:S, Sct4ioo g9Qy, re14lin5 is u)sWorn - �.15;�icabion +b aN�f��it6, 71e l r64er C,k a29V Po Z oX aoa CQmP 14W AA 170ol Q Sci Cc,�,p k4it 1 QQ 8151 S�a� Rd Po tbaxaoo f2n 19t36-a9ro Ca+np 14111 PA 1700 I (�jdSDO L.isburn Rd .� 16 q Prtres5 Or. Camp Nill WQYSA"rg PA )S3lU- 80$2 PA 110(31 jN 7'06 couR'r cP comaom) Pjw6 op CUM/3eeLiJAJO Coc�,�ry, P6'Nj)Sy,L.VANf/� goys�er fT1 DEmANO FOR 3-14Ry !A1ow cones p141444 per Annsylvan;c, 5�tjje rules o; cour c� Demand for fury �cf(,J ;n A-t aho„e captioned case• LJJiEREfi©RED plt�;n�i � reties s lh�,}- Phit, Caoe procceeto A lei �tt,4 a ,.'ry. �"e/ly Rays-kr 05/02/2013 07:51 7246274280 PHS SCI GREENE PAGE 01/07 ' ' '� aKfe�rd Health F" COVER SHEET DATE: `� j 1-3 PAGES: including corer TO. -7z/M .5ir't l7tif FROM: PHONE. PHONE: FAX: jr /.� a q efo FAX: E-MAIL,. E-MAIL; CC: 7t(E _Sty ,tvC-115.D QN f CFFICC- This communkution is intended only fa the use of ft indroidual or m ty to whits if Is addressed and may cv4Mn Information that is prin1eged,conildentiat,and exempt Iran disd=ffQ under ap 1=)e taw. O the wdt t ur tires umilmunlradon is not ft handed mdplenL you hat:homby noHod that any diecofffmSon,dtatftMon,or ooPyclg Of INS communieaflon is SM prohibited. If you have received this communtation in error,plt notify the sealer. Thank you. SCI GREENE) 169 PROGR SS ORM I WAYNESBURG,PA 15320 i P.724627.4281 I F:724,6274280 I WVVW.WEVORRHEALTH.COM 1 . EXHIBIT "B" 1N 'i/}�' COURT' 0� CornMOw F4695 OF C'y.oltltRcR�uD CouN7'y, oeNNSy4VgV/q �/ly A'oyS�Pr Vo, 1 3 _ 1-131 01 vil P_L Oct 6F 66AWCE hereby cv4S �hA� A 11r'ue Anc/ �o1q�i�/rF�'S /q CeriSi-cAfes 0f g7eri4 4*70l ojema,)d ea.nP ;.,{�,r 'was g��ved on t-he oj��'enC�a��a by �irs� c/ass p-J� , /, 3`'`'y �rlc./ 1• ���i c� Chi2p ceun5 el 2, f rr'San > �lfh Sgrurce Rd Mechan,'esburg A14 l70fiv l�tiilaolelP�ia ��} l9l36- 2g,o 3, Cor�zon ti a —' �e55 prl 'UQ�j �• 'r"_r� �7ay �e5�yrg �� 15376~ �vg•z cn y(7, eoYs PO 13OX Roo