HomeMy WebLinkAbout12-23-14 RHOADS & SINON LLP
By Scott Alan Mitchell
Attorney ID No. 76124
One S. Market Square, 12`h Fl,
P.O. Box 1146
Harrisburg,PA 17108-1146 Cl>
C=
(717)231-6602
rn
nuM
Fax: (717)260-4402
Email: smitchell@rhoads-sinon.com C,,�, --0
Cn —D
4
IN RE:
IN THE COURT OF COMMON`P'-E-AS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENTqSYLVIA-NLAf—
KATHLEEN M. KNISELY
ORPHANS' COURT DIVISION .
An Incapacitated Person
No, 21-12-946
PETITION FOR APPROVAL TO EXPEND PRINCIPAL
BY PLENARY GUARDIAN OF ESTATE
TO THE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF THE SAID COURT:
The Petition of The Bryn Mawr Trust Company, by and through its counsel, Scott Alan
Mitchell, Rhoads & Sinon LLP, respectfully represents the following:
1. The Petitioner is The Bryn Mawr Trust Company, with a principal place of
business at One West Chocolate Ave., Suite 200, Hershey, PA 1,7033.
2. This Court has jurisdiction over this matter pursuant to 20 Pa.C.S.A. § 711(10) in
that this matter involves the administration and distribution of the real and personal property of
the estate of an incapacitated person.
3. The Incapacitated Person is Kathleen M. Knisely ("Mrs. Knisely") who resides at
23 W. Lawn Circle, Wormleysburg, PA 17043.
4. By Order of this Court dated November 15, 2012, a copy of which is attached
hereto as Exhibit A and incorporated herein by reference, Petitioner was appointed plenary
1
974432.1
guardian of the estate of Mrs. Knisely. Additionally, under the said Order of Court, James G.
Knisely and Barbara Knisely were appointed co-guardians of the person of Mrs. Knisely.
5. Mrs. Knisely is 81 years of age, having been born on February 11, 1933.
6. Matters involving Mrs. Knisely's person and estate have been the subject of
numerous petitions filed with this Court resulting in various Orders of Court issued by the Court,
and such procedural history will not be reiterated in this Petition.
7. Petitioner has recently been made aware of a life insurance policy on Mrs.
Knisely's life that was purchased by Mrs. Knisely in or around the 1990's. Petitioner
understands from discussions with the family (and in light of Mrs. Knisely's assets) that the
policy was obtained by Mrs. Knisely for purposes of payment of federal estate tax at her death.
8. Approximately 2-3 years ago, prior to Petitioner being appointed as guardian,
Mrs. Knisely transferred ownership of the policy to all five (5) of her children, Lee Ann Knisely,
Barbara L. Knisely, James G. Knisely, Kathleen L. Knisely, and Samuel Scott Knisely,
whereupon she has continued to pay the annual premiums for the policy.
9. Attached hereto as Exhibit B and incorporated herein by reference is an
Accelerated Payment Anniversary Statement of MetLife, which has been provided to Petitioner
by Mrs. Knisely's children.
10. As noted in the Statement, the life insurance policy is on Mrs. Knisely's life and
bears a face amount of$3 million, and the policy includes additional paid-up insurance and
dividends earned.
11. As also noted in the Statement, the current annual premium payment for the
policy is $81,490.00, which is due January 1, 2015. However, because of accrued dividends in
2
the policy, the dividends may be applied to the premium under option 2 in the statement, leaving
a net premium due in the amount of approximately $34,000.
12. Petitioner also has confirmed that although the Statement reflects a due date of
January 1, 2015 for the annual premium, the premium can be paid within thirty (30) days after
the due date without any lapse in coverage or policy forfeiture.
13. In discussing the premium payment options with Mrs. Knisely and her children,
Petitioner understands that the family desires to proceed under option 2 in the attached Exhibit B
by allowing 2015 dividends to be applied towards the premium and Mrs. Knisely paying the
remaining premium balance (approximately $34,000, as noted above).
14. As of December 22, 2014, Petitioner is managing approximately $6.5 million of
Mrs. Knisely's assets under the guardianship. Additionally, pursuant to this Court's Order of
Court of December 20, 2012, Petitioner, as trustee, is managing approximately $4 million of
Mrs. Knisely's assets under a Declaration of Trust, dated December 28, 2012. Finally, Mrs.
Knisely's house at 23 W. Lawn Circle, Wormleysburg, PA 17043 is owned by a Qualified
Personal Residence Trust, dated June 5, 2012,
15. Mrs. Knisely's current income consists of the following:
a. Social Security—approximately $1,150 per month;
b. BNY Mellon trust established by husband—approximately $2,000 to
$3,000 semi-annually; and
C. Guardianship account—approximately $168,000 per year, the majority of
which is expended each year for Mrs. Knisely's health, support, maintenance, and welfare.
16. Because Mrs. Knisely's income and personal assets (outside of the guardianship
and trusts) are insufficient to pay the above-referenced life insurance premium, Petitioner seeks
3
approval from this Court to expend principal of Mrs. Knisely's estate hereafter in an amount not
to exceed $34,000 to pay for the annual premium due January 1, 2015 in the above-referenced
policy.
17. Additionally, because the life insurance policy will continue to have an annual
premium of approximately $85,000, which, as demonstrated in Exhibit B, may be offset in whole
or in part by each year's dividends within the policy, which are impacted by current interest
rates, Petitioner seeks approval from this Court to expend principal of Mrs. Knisely's estate
hereafter in an amount necessary to pay the ongoing annual premium for the above-referenced
policy, in addition to the January 1, 2015 premium.
18. By Order of Court dated March 14, 2013, this Court decreed, "None of Mrs.
Knisely's children may accept any money from Mrs. Knisely without express permission of this
Court."
19. 20 Pa. C.S.A. §5536(a) provides, in part, "The court, for cause shown and with
only such notice as it considers appropriate in the circumstances, may authorize or direct the
payment or application of any or all of the income or principal of the estate of an incapacitated
person for the care, maintenance or education of the incapacitated person, his spouse, children or
those for whom he was making such provision before his incapacity. . . ." (emphasis added).
20. 20 Pa.C.S.A. §5521(a) provides, "Expressed wishes and preferences of the
incapacitated person shall be respected to the greatest possible extent."
21. "20 Pa.C.S.A. §5536(b)provides that this Court, for good cause shown, shall have
the power to substitute its judgment for that of the incapacitated person with respect to the estate
and affairs of the incapacitated person for the benefit of the incapacitated person, her family,
4
members of her household, her friends and charities in which she is interested, such power
including the power to make gifts outright or in trust.
22. In light of the foregoing, whereas (1) Mrs. Knisely has expressed her wish to
continue to pay for the annual life insurance premium; (2) Mrs. Knisely has paid the annual life
insurance premium in the past, both when she owned the policy and after she transferred
ownership to her children; (3) Mrs. Knisely's assets will result in federal estate tax liability at her
death, thus underscoring the importance of maintaining the insurance policy; and (4) Mrs.
Knisely's assets (including the guardianship and trust assets) are of a sufficient amount that
Petitioner distributing principal for the payment of the life insurance premium will not in any
way jeopardize ongoing future funds being available for Petitioner to pay for the ongoing health,
maintenance, support, and welfare of Mrs. Knisely, Petitioner submits that the above-referenced
statutes warrant this Court approving principal expenditures for the payment of the life insurance
premium.
23. Mrs. Knisely's next of kin consists of her five children, who are the current
owners of the life insurance policy on Mrs. Knisely's life. As the Court is aware, one of Mrs.
Knisely's children, Samuel Scott Knisely, is not a named beneficiary under Mrs. Knisely's Will
nor under the Qualified Personal Residence Trust, which has resulted in prior Orders of Court
often containing the following provision: "We will decide at a later date whether or not it would
be appropriate to seek reimbursement from the remaindermen from the real estate trust for these
charges."
24. In the instant petition, funds distributed from the guardianship decrease funds
otherwise passing to four of the five children under Mrs. Knisely's Will, and they benefit all five
of the children as the beneficiaries under the life insurance policy. As a result, Petitioner
5
requests that any Order of Court in the instant petition, confirm that the Court will decide at a
later date whether it would be appropriate to seek reimbursement from Samuel Scott Knisely for
his pro rata share of any life insurance premiums paid out of the guardianship funds.
25. As evidenced by the attached Certificate of Service, notice of the filing of this
Petition has been provided to Mark F. Bayley, Esquire, guardian ad litem for Mrs. Knisely;
Anthony L. DeLuca, Esquire, counsel to Barbara L. Knisely and James G. Knisely; Delano M.
Lantz, Esquire, counsel to Samuel Scott Knisely; Lee Ann Knisely; and Kathleen L. Knisely.
26. Whereas all five of Mrs. Knisely's children are owners of the life insurance
policy, Petitioner believes that all five children would consent to the relief requested in this
Petition, and Petitioner shall hereafter file with the Court any consents that are executed by the
children.
27. As a result of filing this Petition, Petitioner has occurred and will incur legal fees
and Court costs.
28. Specifically, Petitioner have incurred legal fees and costs of$1,595.00 through
and including December 23, 2014, as evidenced by the itemization attached hereto as Exhibit C
and incorporated herein by reference.
29. Petitioner anticipates additional legal fees and costs of up to $1,500.00 being
incurred in the matter after December 23, 2014 in concluding this matter, including a possible
hearing before the Court regarding this Petition.
30. Therefore, in addition to the above-referenced requested principal expenditures
for payment of the life insurance premiums, Petitioner requests approval to expend principal of
Mrs. Knisely's estate for legal fees and costs in an amount not to exceed $3,095.00, to Rhoads &
6
Sinon LLP, subject to such firm providing Petitioner with satisfactory evidence of actual legal
time and costs incurred.
WHEREFORE, Petitioner, The Bryn Mawr Trust Company, respectfully requests that
this Honorable Court enter the proposed Decree attached hereto, authorizing The Bryn Mawr
Trust Company, Guardian of the Estate of Kathleen M. Knisely, (1)to expend up to $34,000 of
the principal of the Estate of Kathleen M. Knisely for payment of the life insurance premium due
January 1, 2015, as outlined further in the Petition; (2) to expend principal of the Estate of
Kathleen M. Knisely for payment of the ongoing annual life insurance premiums, subject to any
dividend reduction in the premium that Petitioner so elects; and (3) up to $3,095.00 for payment
legal fees and Court costs involving the filing of this Petition.
Respectfully submitted,
RHOADS & SINON LLP
Dated: bd x3( �� By:
Scott Alan Mitchell
Attorneys for Petitioner
One S. Market Square, 12'h Fl.
P.O. Box 1146
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1146
(717) 231-6602 �.
Sup. Ct. Attorney ID #76124
7
Exhibit A
11/21/2012 11:48 FAX 1a002/002
IN RE: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
KATHLEEN M. KNISEL , CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
an alleg d incapacitated ;
person ORPHANS ' COURT DIVISION
NO. 21-12-946
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this (15th--day pf November,_2012y after
hearing, we are satisfied by clear and convincing evidence that
Kathleen M. Knisely meets the definition of incapacitated person
under the statute. CHryn .Mawr.Trust-is appointers permanent
pl er3�ry- and an _a
her--.estate #ames C;,-Knisely,and=-Barbara
jtnise,ly_ re. appoin ed co-_guardians of her peisori:
The fees of the Petitioner's counsel and Mr.
Bayley a e author' ed to be paid by the guardian of the estate,
as are . e fees of Dr. Hume.
All powers of attorney executed before this date
are deemed to bei valid and revoked.
By the Court,
Edward E. Gui o, J.
Anthony DeLuca, Es ire
For the Petitioner
Mark F. Bayley, Esquire
For Kathleen M. Kn' sely C) -,-, ;
Thomas R . Flower, Esquire rT1 - < e.710
For Sam el Scott Knisely 4 �0-
srs A TRUE COPY FROM RECORD Q;=-'
In Testimony whomf, I hereunto Q rr;
set my hand and the seal v -' Z6 Q
St laid court at Carkle,PA
az
L
`'� � Cummbeftnd ccumv
Exhibit B
O ..
1VIetLifQuestions?
METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY Contact your MetLife
Reresentative:
101 ERFORD ROAD SUITE 200 $ 717-724-9700
CAMP HILL PA 17011 fi A
ales
7 5/163�3gency
Accelerated Payment Anniversary Statement Amount Due
$81,490.00
J,B,S,K, & L KNISELY Date Due
23 W LAWN CIR January 1, 2015
WORMLEYSBURG PA 17043-1142
P9 iic44y 1816Obet 570 PR
Face Amount
UUOf insurance
$3,000,000
Payment Mode
Nameof KATHLEEN MANN KNISELY Annual
inmued
Plan LIFE PAID—UP AT AGE 98 �y ---_AmountYaid/DatePwo
Dividend Summary
Ylatseryy, Fo. Your 2015 dividend will be used to buy Additional Paid-up Insurance if premiums are paid to January 1,2015.
. platelh(.s Fi
; n 2015 Dividend: $47,550.00
�,tnc)t,ysijr .
�Y zi Additional Paid-Up Insurance
Prior Balance: 127,614.07
Additional Insurance Earned on Prior Balance: 1,722,79
Amount Purchased b
y Current Dividend: 61,339.50
Total Additional Paid-Up Insurance(Al): 190,676.36
<= ww;= ; Payment Information
Amount Due(Premium): $81,490.00
As requested,the amount due will be paid by the Accelerated Payment(AP)arrangement,if you do not pay it
alher
out-of-pocket See ) y y
sfde:faYF�g:-:.cs P ( Option 3.However,you should be aware that based on MetLife's current dividend scale, our
dividends will not be sufficient to pay all future premiums.You may want to consider the following payment options
a f3rmahon i shown below.
These calculations are based on the current dividend scale which is not guaranteed and are therefore subject to
change in the future.
j lu
if ! 1. Pay this year's premium out-of-pocket.The AP arrangement would pay premiums until the year 2025.
c
2. Use the 2015 dividend of$47,550.00 plus$33,940.00 out-of-pocket to pay this year's premium.Your
c total AI would be reduced to$129,336.86.The AP arrangement would pay premiums until the year 2020.
J. Allow the premium to be paid by the AP arrangement.The premium would be withdrawn from the total
o'I; Al reducing it to$86,050.53.The AP arrangement would pay premiums until the year 2018.
Your MetLife Representative may be able to offer additional payment options.For questions or service,please
73 abto t `. contact your MetLife Representative or call 1-800-MET-5000(1-800-638-5000).Our busiest day is Monday,so it is
xfini£4s-y€ best to call Tuesday through Friday,if possible.
<t
wnGl>,
v'j?o`hila:
----------- --------------,___.___-------.------- .-.----_----__•---------. -•
MePLefe° Accelerated Payment — Type 4 A Detach here and return
with our payment
Folicy No. Frenuum vivrdena
934900570 PR 343 1 000 81490.00 47550.00
SalesOffice/Agy, Nameefinsured - Date Due
C75/633 KATHLEEN MANN KNISELY January 1, 2015
J B S K & L KNISELY Amount Due
211 * LA*N CIR $81,490.00
WORMLEYSBURG PA 17043-1142
Unscheduled Payment
Please make check or money order payable to MetLife $
Mail to: METROPOLITAN Amount Enclosed
P 0 BOX 371310
PITTSBURGH PA 15250-7310 $
X11-1.111i1111111ifHIIIIII 11IT,1.1rvr1111+1 1
NYH6HX830A
Exhibit C
BIM300T R2 BIM RHOADS & SINON LLP BIM RUN# . . . 0023072 Page . . . . . . . . . . 1
Date . . . . . . . . . . 12/23/14 BILLING INFORMATION MEMO
Requ Attorney. . 801 Roteman, Cinda L. 13696 000 Bryn Mawr Trust CO BIM#: 00382998
N Orig Attorney 603 MITCHELL/SCOTT A 3 Kathleen Knisely Guardianship Time: 12/19/2014 12/23/2014
N Bill Attorney 603 MITCHELL/SCOTT A Opened Date. . . . 12/01/2014 Cost: 12/19/2014 12/23/2014
N Resp Attorney 603 MITCHELL/SCOTT A BILL MONTHLY Estate-Planning, Wills & Trusts
N Rept Attorney 9999 9999 STDO1 Time by Prd/Year: N
N Othr Attorney 9999 9999 Cost by Prd/Year: N
Bryn Mawr Trust CO
Wealth Management Division
10 South Bryn Mawr Avenue
Bryn Mawr, PA 19010
Susan W O'Donnel, Sr VP
T I M E
Wkng Actv Billable
- Date - Atty Task Code Description Hours Rate Value Non-Chrg. Group# /Item#
12/19/2014 SAM E-mails from/to client; review file; .70 290.00 203.00 91531 7
teleconference with client and Tony
Deluca; teleconference with James
Knisely
12/22/2014 SAM Review file; draft petition to expend 3.30 290.00 957.00 91550 1
principal for payment of life insurance
premium; e-mails to/from client
12/23/2014 SAM Review file; review/edit petition; 1.50 290.00 435.00 91550 2
teleconference with client;
teleconference with James Knisely;
review/edit petition
----------- -------------- ------------
Unbilled Time 5.50 1,595.00 .00
No costs advanced recorded for this matter through 12/23/2014
No unapplied credits for this matter
No trust activity balance for this matter
VERIFICATION
The Undersigned hereby verifies that the statements made in the foregoing document are
true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. I understand that false
statements herein are made subject to penalties of 18 Pa.C.S.A. Section 4904, relating to
unsworn falsification to authorities.
THE BRYN MA TRUST COMPANY
Dated: �Z 7� o�v1 By: ff
eo e . George, Vice President
6
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that I have this 23'( day of 4OVW - , 2014,
served the foregoing Petition upon the person and in the manner indicated below. Service by
first-class mail, addressed as follows:
Mark F. Bayley, Esquire Anthony L. DeLuca, Esquire
17 West South Street 113 Front Street
Carlisle, PA 17013 P.O. Box 358
Boiling Springs, PA 17007
Delano M. Lantz, Esquire Lee Ann Knisely
4 North Hanover Street 485 Front Street
Carlisle, PA 17013 Louisville, CO 80027
Kathleen L. Knisely
9008 Avis Court
Vienne, VA 22182
RHOADS & SINON LLP
By:
Scott Alan M ti c e
Attorneys for Petitioner
One S. Market Square, 12`x' Fl.
P.O. Box 1146
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1146
(717) 231-6602
Sup. Ct. Attorney ID #76124
9