The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About05-15-15 Neil W.Yahn,Esquire Attorney LD.No. 82278 JSDC Law Offices P.O.Box 650 Hershey,PA 17033 � o � Attorneys for Petitioner c�' � -=� r-ri _�� Q � �'� c� ;-� -. � ''� c� 1N RE: CALENE M. CLOUSE, ) IN THE COURT OF COMMC��I�L�AS"� �' ;�? an alleged incapacitated person ) CUMBERLAND COLINTY, PE�N�YL�NI'A r:'� ) ORPHANS' COURT DIVISION r , On the Petition of ) � �, � � ' ��i J. Edward Clouse ) NO. 21-15-93 " W �?:.T �� . � G7 �, PETITIONER'S MOTION TO DISMISS OBJECTIONS TO SUBPOENAS AND NOW comes the Petitioner, J. Edward Clouse (herein "Edward" or"Petitioner"), by and through his attorney, Neil Warner Yahn, Esquire, of JSDC LAW OFFICES, who upon valid information and belief hereby submits the below Motion to Dismiss the Objections to Subpoenas as follows: Parties and Background 1. On or about January 27, 2015, Petitioner submitted a Fetition to Adjudicate Incapacitated and Appoint Plenary Guardian of the Person and Estate for the alleged incapacitated person, namely Calene M. Clouse (herein"Calene").1 2. Following submission of the Petition, the initial Plenary Guardianship Hearing was scheduled for March 3, 2015. 3. Calene is being represented by Robert C. Saidis, Esquire(herein"Attorney Saidis") of Saidis, Sullivan &Rogers located at 26�West High Street, Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013. 1 Petitioner hereby incorporates all facts,averments,references and exhibits from ltis Petition to Adjudicate Incapacitated and Appoint Plenary Guardian of the Person and Estate(herein the"Petition")submitted before this Honorable Court on or about January 27,2015 as if set forth in full herein. , � � 4. Attorney Saidis entered his appearance on behalf of Calene on or about February 24, 2015. 5. Following said entry, undersigned counsel and Attorney Saidis agreed to stay the Plenary Guardianship Hearing in attempt to resolve the matter and pr�vide the necessary protections for Calene without having to proceed with a formal adjudication of incapacity. 6. However, since the Hearing has been stayed, Calene's Uehavior has grown erratic and hostile including allegations of transferring assets to others in di:i•ect contravention to certain Family Partnership interest of which she is an interest owner thereof. 7. Despite Calene's outbursts, Attorney Saidis continues to maintain his position that Calene is not an incapacitated person (see attached correspondence and related notation from Jagadeesh K. Moola, MD dated April 9, 2015 marked collectively as Lxhibit"A") 8. Petitioner desires to resolve this matter amicably liowever based on the foregoing, Petitioner believes and therefore avers that this matter may not be resolved absent adjudication from this Honorable Court regarding Calene's capacity. 9. As a result, on or about April 28, 2015, Petitioner submitted a Motion for Status Conference before this Honorable Court to advance discussions on the need for rescheduling the Plenary Guardianship Hearing as well as ancillary discovery and capacity evaluation matters.2 10. This Honorable Court has scheduled the afarementioned Status Conference for May 27, 2015. 2 Petitioner hereby incorporates all facts,averments,references and exhibits from liis Motion for Status Conference submitted before this Honorable Court on or about Apri128,2015 as if set fc�rth in full herein. ,,i��r,cai ri,ur n i Subpoena Requests 11. On or about April 27, 2015, Petitioner issued two (2) Notices of Intent seeking to serve subpoenas upon the following hospitals: (1) Holy Spirit Hospital—Behavioral Health Services; and (2) Haven Behavioral Hospital (true and correct co��ies of the Notices of Intent are attached hereto and marked collectively as Exhibit`B"). 12. As outlined in each subpoena, Petitioner seeks copies of any and all documents related to Calene M. Clouse, including but not limited to, medical re�ords,medical charts, prescriptions, prognoses, diagnoses,physician referrals, specialist reports, nurses notes and capacity evaluations, for the time period from January of 2013 though the present date (herein the "Subpoenas" collectively or otherwise identified individually). 13. On or about May 11, 2015, Calene objected to the foregoing subpoenas premised upon 42 Pa.C.S.A. § 5944 (regarding the Holy Spirit Subpoena) and 50 P.S. § 7111 (regarding the Haven Behavioral Hospital Subpoena) (herein the "Objections" to which true and correct copies thereof are attached hereto and marked collectively as Ehhibit "C"). 14. Petitioner hereby submits the within Motion to Dismiss respectfully requesting that this Honorable Court enter an Order denying and dismissing Calene's Objections to the Subpoenas with prejudice and allowing the afarementioned Subpoenas to be issued consistent with the Notices of Intent as presented herein. � ,,�,�,��, ,�.,.� , 42 Pa.C.S.A. � 5944 15. 42 Pa.C.S.A. § 5944 provides "[n]o psychiatrist or•person who has been licensed under the act of March 23, 1972 (P.L.136,No.52), to practice psychology shall be, without the written consent of his client, examined in any civil or criminal matter as to any information acquired in the course of his professional services in behalf of such client. The confidential relations and communications between a psychologist or psychiatrist �nd his client shall be on the same basis as those provided or prescribed by law between an attc�rney and client." 16. Calene's Objection to the Holy Spirit Subpoena premised upon 42 Pa.C.S.A. § 5944 is misguided as said statute concerns confidential commu�zications to psychiatrists or licensed psychologists (emphasis added). 17. The Holy Spirit Subpoena herein simply requests Calene's medical records and related data, including records from Dr. Jagadeesh K. Moola, M.D., which is wholly appropriate for discovery. 18. The psychiatrist-patient privilege is designed to p�-otect.disclosures made by the client and does not protect the opinions, observations, diagnosis, and treatment alternatives of the professionals. See Commonwealth v. Carter, 2003 PA Super 131, 821 A.2d 601, 2003 Pa. Super. LEXIS 530 (Pa. Super. Ct. 2003). 19. Moreover, assuming this matter proceeds to a fonnal Guardianship hearing, Calene's previous medical history will naturally be relevant (and necessary) for adjudication by this Honorable Court and for proper assessment.3 3 In addition,Petitioner believes that the opinion expressed by Dr.Moola in liis correspondence dated Apri19,2015 attached Exhibit"A"herein is not consistent with Calene's prior medical history. Moreover,Dr. Moola is not a geriatric psychiatrist and therefore not qualified to issue opinions on issues of'incapacity.Petitioner avers a review of the medical records by an independent geriatric physician is appropriate. �„„ri iiirrr,ur�r � 20. As a result, Petitioner respectfully requests that tYiis Honorable Court enter an Order denying and dismissing Calene's Objections to the Subpoenas with prejudice and authorizing the Holy Spirit Subpoena to be issued. 50 P.S. & 7111 21. 50 P.S. § 7111(a) provides "[a]11 documents concerning persons in treatment shall be kept confidential and, without the person's written consent, may not be released or their contents disclosed to anyone except: (1) those engaged in providing treatment for the person; (2) the county administrator, pursuant to section 110; (3) a court in the course of legal proceedings authorized by this act; and (4)pursuant to Federal rules, statutes and regulations governing disclosure of patient information where treatment is undertaken in a Federal agency." 22. Petitioner hereby requests authorization for release of Calene's records from Haven Behavioral Hospital pursuant to 50 P.S. § 7111(a)(3). 23. By way of background, Calene was involuntarily committed at Haven Behavioral Hospital in or about August of 2014 as a result of an incident at a theatre in which Calene made dangerous threats towards other individuals. 24. Petitioner avers the records from Calene's stay at Ha��en Behavioral Hospital are relevant and necessary to an ultimate determination of Calene's capacity(or lack thereo�. 25. As a result, Petitioner respectfully requests that this Honorable Court enter an Order denying and dismissing Calene's Objections to the Subpoenas with prejudice and authorizing the Haven Behavioral Hospital Subpoena to be issucd. 26. Petitioner has provided a true and correct copy of the Mation contained herein, as well as a copy of the Proposed Order,to Attorney Saidis who has indicated his non-concurrence in Petitioner's Motion to Dismiss the Objections to Subpoenas. WHEREFORE, Petitioner respectfully requests that this Honc�rable Court enter an Order denying and dismissing Calene's Objections to Subpoenas with prejudice and allowing the , aforementioned subpoenas to be issued consistent with the Notices of Intent as presented herein. Respectfully submitted, JSD LAW OFFICES � ,� ,, . ��'� ._ Date: •-; a "�, + > By. ( 1 .- Neil W. Yal�ri, squire Attorney�T.D. N�. 8227� 134 S3pe Avenu� Hummelstown, �A 17036 (7k7) 533-3280 A orney for Pe itioi�er ._ ��,i.irrrrr urn.. � VERIFICATION I verify that the statements made in this Petition are true and con�ect. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. � 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. -�' � � � � ,� �� . Edward Clouse r Date: ��' �C� J ""1�kl��lll"I�I'f�lllf7C� � Neil W.Yahn,Esquire Attorney I.D.No. 82278 • JSDC Law Offices P.O.Box 650 Hershey,PA 17033 Attorneys for Petitioner IN RE: CALENE M. CLOUSE, ) IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS an alleged incapacitated person ) CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA ) ORPHANS' COLJRT DIVISION On the Petition of ) J. Edward Clouse ) NO. 21-15-93 CERTIFICATE OF NON-CONCURRENCE Pursuant to the Cumberland County Local Rules,the undcrsigned hereby certifies that counsel for the alleged incapacitated person, Robert C. Saidis, Esquire,has been provided a true and correct copy of the Motion contained herein, as well as a copy of t}ie Proposed Order, and said counsel does not concur in Petitioner's Motion to Dismiss the Objections to Subpoenas. Respectfully submitted, JSDC LAW OFFICES .�—._ Date: � � '� 1 � BY� _ Nei W. hn, Esc�uire Attorney I:�D. No. �227$ 134 Sipe A}venue Humn�elst � n, PA 17036 (717 533-3 80 Att rney fo Petitic�ner ,�.,,,,�:,�� ,�...� � -°��i��i�rrrrnir-�r� � Lnw Oilices oY SAIDIS, SULLIVAN & ROGERS A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION 26 WEST HIGH STREET R�RBRT C.SltIDIS CARLISI.E,PENN5YLVANIA 1"7013 LEMOYNE OFFICE pANIeL L.SULL[VftN 'i'�LEPHONE:(7l�243-62Z2—FACSIMILI;:(71'�243-6486 635 NORTH 12TH STREET,S7'E,400 ELYSE E.ROG4RS EIVIAIL: attorney@ssr-attarneys.com f.EMOYN�,PA]7043 ]OHN A.PGICHTEL www.ssr-attorneys.com TELEPHONE:(717)612-5804 MARYWCJ MATAS FACSIMILE: (717}b12-SSDS ANNA DORRO I-IAYS pEAN E.REYNOSA OfCounsel TODI�F.TRUN'1"L STEPHEN L.GROSE $EAN M.3HUL'fZ HANN�H WFIITE-GIBSON REPLY TO CARLISLE Email:rsaidis a�ssr-attorneys,com April 22,201 S Va E-matl nyahn(.jsdc.co�n . Neil W. Yahn, Esq. rSDC Law O�f'xce P. O. Bax 650 Hershey,PA 17433-0650 Re: Calene Clouse/Edward Clouse Deaz Neil: ' Pursuant to your recent request,enclosed please find a copy of thc letter I received from Dr. . Moola. You will note his opiruon is that Calene is capable of determining the disposition af her estate � and making other financial decisions and that Calene is not incapacitated. If you have any questions,please do not hesitate to contact me. � `J'ery trul yours, ,SULLIVAN&ROGERS � � obert C. idis � RCS/pm Enclosure �c: Calene Clouse SEY2VINC YOUR Bl1SINT�SS,REAL F.SI'AT�L�',ESTATE PLANMNG,LI'i'1GA'TION AND FAMII.Y LAW NE�DS '""I'�I'I�TI I1 111"If' � ' � I�C�LY SP��.IT A GEISINGER AFFILIATE � � I f I i � April 9,2Q15 � � Rnbert C.Saidis, �squlre �� Saldls,Sullivan, and Rogers 2s W. Migh st, . Carllsl�, PA 97033 � � ��; Calene M.Clous� � DQB; 12/29/39 � � Dea�Mr,Saidis: i � I had a regularly sch�ciul�d appointment wi�h Calsne M.Clause an AprN 3,2D�5 for a m�dication � -� �ch�ckup�isit. Her currer�t di�gnosis is�ip�lac I Disor�er,mast racent episade depressed, Based on rriy examination an April 3,20�.5,ii is my opinipn that Calene M. Clouse is not in a�anic state ! and when nat in a manlc s�tate she ls capable af mak�ng decisions afFecting t�er everyday life fnc�udtng i f�nancial matters, ; � Upon examination,s�he had a clear knvwiedge of the gen�ral compositian of the properCies she owns � and discussed Ch�flnancial�r�angements being made,including the trusts. � At the ttme of rn�+A�rll,3�,2015 examination, Calene was,In my opfniAn,capable of determining the ' i dispnsitian of her estate�nd making other�nancia�declsians, � , i If yau need addCtional infc�rmatian,please da not.hesit�te to contacY me. i SinCerely, r � � Ja$adeesh K. Moola,M,p. Psychlatrist . � �ehavioral Hea(th Servi�es: � , . .. , : . � • . � .. �:�_.. . . . . k�� .l - ' � � . � . i f. ' . . . 1 ... � ' ��' � . .. . � - �. . . : . . . t .. . � . . ., ' . . • . � ... • � . . .� .� . . � . . �. . ' ' . � ' .. . ' . . ' _ . . I . � . 5Q3 Nor�th �I st Street,Camp Hill, ('A I?U I I-2�88 � '�17�763_2100 � www,hsh.o_rg �,i rrrrr�r°nrn , -,�qi.�.�„�,I.��.,llf'If � Neil W.Yahn,Esquire Attorney I.D.No.82278 ]SDC Law Offices P.O.Box b50 Hershey,PA 17033 Attomeys for Petitioner 1N RE:CALENE M. CLOUSE, ) IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS an alleged incapacitated person ) CUMBERLAND COUNTY,PENNSYLVANIA ) ORPHANS'COURT DMSION On the Petition of ) J.Edward Clouse ) NO. 21-15-93 NOTICE OF INTENT TQ SERVE A SUBP4ENA TO PRODUCE DQCUMENTS UR THINGS F4R DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4Q09.22 Neil W. Yahn,Esquire intends to serve a subpoena identical to the one that is attached to this notice. You have twenty(20) days from the date listed below in which to file of record and serve upon the undersigned an objection to the subpoena. If no objection is made the subpoena may be served. Respe�tfiilly submztted, JS CLAW OFFICES .i -- Date• -�f j a.7 ( �"� By: Nei1'Warn Yahn, Esquire At�orney I. .No. 8227$ .O. Box 6 0 Hershey,P 17033 {717} 53 -3280 tto ey for Petitioner ��r,r��rirnir-�r 9 COMMO�NWEALTH OF PBNN$YLVAN'Z,� COUN7'Y OF CCJMBBRLAND In R�: ' CAI,� M. CI,OIISB, ' an alleged incapacitated person ' ��a1-15-93 On the Petition of t J. Edward Clouse = i , SUBPOENA T�O PRODUCE DOG[JMENTS+��. T.�INGS FOR DISC4VERY PURSUANT TO RU�:;,� q[,,�pg,Zz 'j'Q;Haven Behavioral Hospital 145 N. 6th St. Reading, PA 1g601 {�1/Q10 8f Peff01 Oi[$1�� V1��t�1IL tW0i1�'��8�$�(�Ct$!d'YICtl O��BU�r}�OL�dfC�'D4`t�}�r 1hE t'A17f'f t0 pl+Q��iC fb1ZOWU��YtI1COt8 Oc�t1f�,Y: 3ee Attached Exhibit ■A� 8t the below referenced addrese (Addt+ea&} You may daliver or mail kgiblo copies of the documenls ar prodnce tivngs requ�tod hy this subpoane,togcther with ihe oertificate of c�pliaoce,ta t6e p.�rty m�king tk�is neque��s lisced abova You havc the ri�t ta�e,elc ia advars�e d�e raesanable c�ast of pnepsring�h��,��.��g�e rhir��s saugitt. If you fa7 ta prodvice the docutaente or tbinga xe.quirod by t8ie aubpoer,a within tvreaty(2p)dsYs at3sr its serviec,tbv Rarty sa'�'ing thar subp�may ceak a court ordar aompelling you ta comply witk�it THIS SUBPQEI�IA WAS 73SUED AT Ti�ELBQUEST OF THE FbLLpyV�[W(`,p�RSpN. ��q�;; Neil warner Yahn, Esquire ADDRES$; P.O. Box 650 Hershey, P 170 TL�PI�NE; 717-533-3280 SLlPR8M8 COi7RT ID# 82278 A7�UR]VEY FOR• J. sdwar ouee BY 7�CQURZ; � Regietec of Wit}siCla�#pf t�prp�• D�ee: sat of fhe c�o�at � .�:i��rrrrir�nrii ° EXHIBIT"A" SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS QR THINGS FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.22 TO: Haven Behavioral Hospital 145 N 6th St Reading,PA 19b01 Copies of any and all docurnents related to Calene M. Clouse, including but not limited to,medical records,medical charts,prescriptions,prognoses, diagnoses,physician referrals,specialist reports,nurses notes and capacity evaluations, for the time period from January of 2013 though the date of this Subpoena. .�.i��i�,rrrr,ur.n , Neil W.Yahn,Esquire Attorney I.D.No.82278 JSDC Law Offices P.�.Box 654 Hershey,PA 17033 Attorneys for Petitioner IN RE: CALENE M. CLOUSE, ) IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS an alleged incapacitated person ) C[JMBERLANI7 COLTNTY,PENNSYLVANIA ) OR�'HANS'COURT DIVISION On the Petition of ) J. Edward Clouse ) NO. 21-15-93 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE AND NOW,this�Z-�day of April,2015,I,Neil W.Yahn,Esquire,do hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of the foregoing Notice of Intent to Serve a Sub�ena upon the following below-named individuals by depositing the same in the U.S. 11�iai1,postage pre-paid at Hershey,Dauphin County,Pennsylvania: SERVED UPON: Robert C. Saidis, Esquire Saidis, Sullivan&Rogers 26 West High Street Carlisle, PA 17013 Attorney for Calene ouse NEIL WAR]�,.V'E�YAHN,ESQUIRE Attorney I . #8 278 � ��°� ,�.i,�r��rir�iir�ii.. , Neil W.Yahn,Esquire Attomey I.D.No.82278 JSDC Law Offices P.O.Box 650 Hershey,PA 17433 Attorneys for Petitioner IN RE: CALENE M. CLOUSE, } IN THE COURT C?F COMMON PLEAS an allegad incapacitated person ) CUMBERLAND COUNTY,PENNSYLVANIA ) ORPHANS'COURT I)NISION On the Petition of ) J. Edward Clouse ) NO.21-IS-93 NOTICE OF INTENT TO SERVE A SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OR THINGS F�R DYSCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.22 Neil W. Yahn,Esquire intends to serve a subpoena identical to the one that is attached to this notice. You have twenty(20)days from the date liste�below iri which to file of record and serve upon the undersigned an objection to the subpoena. If na ohjection is made the subpoena may be served. Respectfiilly subrnitted, JSDC LAW OFFIC;'ES _,,� Date: �/z�+ � By: Neil W Yahn,Esquire Atto ey I.D No. $2278 P. . Box b5 H hey,P 17033 { 17) 533- 80 A for Petition+er ..��,�r�rrrr,,vr�r , COMMONV4'�ALTH OF PBNNSYLVANI� CUUNTY aF CUMBE,RI.AND In Re: ' ['nr•� M. czovss, � 21-15-93 an alZeged incapacitated peraon ' ��NO. On the Petition of � J. Edward Clouse ` SIJ$PQENA TQ FRUDUCL�'DUCIJMENT��Do�", 'd'BINGS FOYt I3IStY?V�RY PURSUANT�RU�.�E �.�Q9.Z2 TQ; Hol S irit Hospital Behavioral Health ServiCes 5p3 N. 21st St. Camp Hill, PA 17011 (Neme af Peraon oar Entitlr} "� Within 1w�ntY(7A)dsys af�er eea�vice oftbte subpoeaa,you ane nm�n•.ci by ti�e oourt to praduce tl�e followit�g docsumeuts pr tbi�s: See AtGached Exhibit °A° at the below referenced address (Addross) Yoa may dcIiver or mait )egible cnpies of the documaits or praduce thir�gs t�equestad by tbiis su6poena,togcther with the certificate of c�pliancx,to t!x party mRking this roquest Bt thc addrass fisled abova You have the right to aeek in advance the�easonabls eost of prepaain.g the oapies or producmg tht d�i�rgs sought. If you flail to ptoduce tlu documenffi or things required hy thia subpoen�within twenty(20)days �fter its servicx.the peRy sa�ving thiY subpae�a mey reek a oourt ordor campelling yau to r„omp�with it Tx1s sUBroEt�rA wAs rssc�A��t�atxvuEsr o��Fazr.�wnvc r�xsox_ NAME: Neil warner Yahn, Esquire Ap�RE$$• P.O. Box 650 • Hershey, PA 170 TELEPHONE: 717-53 3-32 8 0 SIJPREMF CO[iRT ID# e22�s ATPORNEY FOR' J. 8dwar C ouee �Y'Ti�COUItT: �� Reg�er of Wills/Clerk of�p�pbe�t Datr: Sesi of the Ca�ut �y -��,vi�r�,rrr.,ur.n... , EXHIBIT��A" SUBPOENA TO PRUDUCE DOCUMENTS UR THINGS FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT T4 RULE 4009.22 TO: Holy Spirit Hospital Behavioral Health Services 503 Norkh 21 st Street Camp Hill,PA 17011 Copies of any and all documents related to Calene M. Clouse,including but not limited to,medical records,medical charts,prescriptions,prognoses,diagnoses,physician referrals,specialist reports,nurses notes and capacity evaluations, for the fime period from January of 2013 though the date of this Subpoena,including��11 aforementioned records from Jagadeesh K. Moola,MD. ..�-,��,,,,�„ „r.� Neil W.Yahn,Esquire Attorney I.D.No.8227$ JSDC Law Off ces P.O.Box 650 Hershey,PA 17033 Attorneys for Petitioner IN RE: CALENE M. CLOUSE, } IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS an alleged incapacitated person ) CLTMBERLAND COUNTY,PENNSYLVANIA ) ORYHANS'COURT DNISI(3N On the Petidon of ) J. Edward Clouse ) NO. 21-15-93 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE AND NOW,this�day of April,2015,I,Neil W.Yahn,�squire,do hereby certify that I served a true and coirect copy of the foregoing Notice of Intent to Serve a Subpoena upon the following below-named individuals by depositing the same in the U.S. lviail,postage pr�paid at Hershey,Dauphin County,Pennsylvania: SERVED UPON: Robert C. Saidis, Esquire Saidis, Sullivan&Rogers 26 West High Street Carlisle,PA 17413 Attorney for Calene ouse p./�-_ � .��.. NEI. AR�TER YAHN, ESQUIRE A mey I.D�i #82278 �,,,��,�,�, ,�� .—r��l nll..�k,�.I.��.,�iR`�I'- f IN RE: CALENE M.CLOUSE, . IN THE COURT C}F COMMON PLEAS an al�eged incapacitated person , OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, . PENNSYLVANIA . ORPHANS' CQURT DIVISION On the Petition of . No. 21-20I5-Qq93 J. Edward Clouse . OBJECTIUN TO SUBPOENA PURSUANT TtJ�RiCII.,E 4009.2 Calene M. Clouse objects#o the proposed subpoena directed tc�]-Iaven BehavioraI Hospitai that is attactted as Exhibit A to this objection far the follawing reason: The records sought to be produced are,upon information and belief,records relating to treatment under Pennsylvania's Mental Health Procedures Act, 54 P.S. §7101 et seq., and are confdential and not subject ta discovery pursuant to 50 P.S. §711 l. Respectfiilly submitted, SAIDIS SULLI`'AN&ROGERS . Dated:May 1 l,2U15 BY: i�-1 �.- �. Daniel L. Sullivan,Esquire Id.No. 34548 2b West High Strest � crs Carlisle,PA 17U 13 �' `'; �� (717)243-6222 �'; � ' M Attorneys for Calene M. Clouse �',- : � t'. , � Q_ ' - t, . . , � i,:, ; . � i.i C;: g . v -I'. C2- i.`� :S— 1:. i'.0 t'�. �':s �.L,� �ir f„/`) O �� C�� '•-1 P�'Pi�1.f�.,111'•�I " Exhibit A x�w.y�,�� Attaraey I.D.Na.82278 JSDC Iaw O�cee P.O.Bauc 650 Fitrshey,PA I7Q33 Attaaaoys far Petitioner IN RE:CALPNE M. GLOUSE, ) IN THE C�URT OF COMMON PLEAS an ailcgcd incapacitatcd gexson ) CIJNIDERLAND COUN'I'y,PENNSYLVANTA ) OitPHANS'COURT Z7IyISION On the Petition of ) J.Edwsrd Clouse ) NO.21-15-93 NOTICE OF INTENT TO�ERVE A SUBPp��j, TO PRODUCE DUCIIMENTS OR�ffi�YGS FUR gySCOVERY PURSUANT TU RIII,E 4(1Q9.2Z Neil W.Yahn,Esquire inteads to servc a subpoea�a identical ta the onc that is attachcd to this notice. Yau}�a.ve twenty(20)days frosn the date listed.below ia�vhieh to file of record and serve upon the undersigned an objectioa to the sabpoena. Tf na abjectian is znade the subpocna may bc served, Respectfully submitted, JS LAW OFFIG`ES --�. Date: �)z�r 1 s"s By: N�i1$'�Varn Yahn,Esquirc A�orney L .No. 82278 .O.Box b 0 ershey,P 17033 (717j 53 328Q tto ey for Petti�vn�r � ��"',i R.t �1 � �� ..��+wr+�'�i��'�.P.�,I.��..,�alf`�Y-� Y co�aa�ro�wau�x o��s�.v,�.,,� �OUN7'Y OF CUM�tI,AND In Ro; % CALffiQ8 H. CLODSB� i Fj�CI��I-I5-93 aa a2leged incapaci.tated persan r On the Patition of � �T. SChrard Clauee ' i t su�ro�A ro raa�,�nt�c�rrrs o�. �r� k�(?R DI�CO�RY�'UBSUANT Tt?RULE 4-�p9.2x TQ:Havea Seh�vior+sl Sospi.tal 145 S. bth St. Readix�g, PA �g6�1 foltc�riag do�g��P�bpoot�.�ecs bY tbe c�at&t °�Od pracAwo d�e Ses Attached F�chibit ■A" at the below retezenced addresa Yoa may +�.o�ivcr a�aa3J legble m��eya��ar sR��+�'widi tIx r�S�e a�comp�anc�,y�'t�p�ty ruaking�� by tbis ebove. Yon hava tbe tight tn s�ee3c ra advmsce 6�ceraanabk oost of �C°t At tbc sddce�a!'i�ted �+SS�L �the coplas pr pro�jag thc !f ypt�$7 ��dq�ar thi�s t�u�by thie aubpoet��a t"2ntY{�d�Y$ afix ita sarvia�,t� sat�ocaa meY�C a cotct ardet °°mpe1�$You to eoa�y y�it �IiS SUBPt)&�IA WAS 7SSUEb AT 1�FtBQiJ�ST OF THg Fpl,i,p,WiNG P&R�� hj� Ne11 waraer Yahn, Esquixe ADDR6SS� P.O. Bqx 650 8er�hey, P �.@F�1NS� 717-533-328Q SUPREM�COT.TRT Il�# 8zz 76 ATY'iDR]YR'Y FOR; �• e $Y Tf�C4t�II'tT� � �4f�1(�GF�E� L)Y11� �eal offfiti ibeart �Y =*'."1 1fl'1'�.1'I'I'I"�11f`�I.•. P EXHIBIT"A" SIIBP4EIITA TO PR4DUCE DOG`IIIV�NTS OR T'gIl�iGS FOR DTSCOVERY PIIRSUANT T�RULE 4009.22 TO: Haven Beba�vi�oral Hosgital 145 N 6th St Reading,PA 19b01 Capxas af any and all do�cirments relate�to Calene M.Cfouse,ineiuding but nat limited to,Iaedical records,medical c2:arts,PrescriPiians,prognoses,diagnases,physician refexrals,specialist rep�arts,n�ses notes and capacity cvaluations,fos the tim.c period from 7anuary of 2013 though the d�te of this Snbpocna. �-n ui i�rrrr�nr�r � Ncil W.Yahq Fsqirire Attomey I.D,Nt�.82278 JSDC Law Officea P.O.Box 650 Hersl�oy,PA 17033 Atroa�nays for P�er Il�T RE:CALENE M.CLOUSE, ) IN THE COURT C}F �OMMON PLEAS an alleged incapacitated persoa ) C�3MBERLAND C0ICTNI'Y,PENNSYLVANIA ) ORPHANS'CQURT DIVISIDN On the Petition of } J.Edward Clousc } NO.21-IS-93 C:`ERTIFICATE OF SERVICE AND NOW,this'Z�day of April,2015,I,Neit W.Yahn,F.s9.�,��Y�fY that I senred a true and carrect capy of the foregoing Notice of Iatent tfl Serve�Subpocna uprm the followiug below named iudividuals by dcpositing the same in the U.S. hiat�,postage Pre-�aid at H�hey,Dauphin County,PeansyIvauia: SERVED UPON: Robert C.Saidis,Esquire Saidis,Sul3ivan&Rogers 25 V�est Flig�Street Carlisle,PA I7013 r_ Attomey for Calene nse NEIL�V Y'Ai�T,ESQUIRE Attaa�ncy I � . 278 �-�i�i r�rrrr°urn- R CERTIFICATE OF SER�ICE The undersigned hereby certifies that I have served the foregaing document upon counsel of record this date by depositing a true and correct copy of the same in the United States mail, first-class pastage prepaid, addressed as follows: Neil W. Yahn,Esq. JSDC Law Office P. O.Box 650 Hershey,PA 17033-OG50 Attorney for J. Edward Clouse SAIDIS,SULLIVAN& ROGERS Dated: May 1 l, 2015 BY: , � d-'��`�''"`� Daniel L. Sullivan,Esquire Id.No. 34548 26 West High Street Carlisle, PA I7013 {71'�243-6222 Atforneys for Calene M. Clouse ��.,-i,�r,fl�i.i.i�i.��ir��r� � IN RE: CALENE M. CLOUSE, . IN THE COU�.T QF COMMON PLEAS an alieged incapacitated person . OF CUMBERL�ND COUNTY, : PENNSYLVAle�IA . ORPHANS' C+�URT DIVISION On the Petition of . No. 21-2015-0�93 J. Edward Clouse . OBJECTION TO SUBPOENA PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.2 Galene M.Clouse objects to the proposet!subpoena directed to Holy Spirit Hospital Behaviorat Health Services that is attached as E�chibit A to this objection for the following reason: The records sought to be produced represent records of Calen.e Clouse's psychiatric caze under her psychiatrist,Jagadeesh K.Moola,M.D.,and are privileged a.nd not subject to discovery pursuant to 42 Pa. C.S.A. §5944. Respectfully subrnitted, SAIDIS SULLIV'AN &ROGERS c,_ c.:, v: �.�., . 1a..� _� � -, �='I�'ated•�'R1ay 11,2015 BY: � . ;:. . :>_ r., � Daniel L. Sullivan,Esquire . Q__ �� 'y. ; Td.No. 34548 �'r ' �--r � 26 West High Street ��: �.� � v' <- � : Cazlisle,PA 17013 t.i r� � i:�'' ' � (71�243-6222 ta.! t:,� �„ �;: ;.�: � � � cti � Attorneys far Calene M. Clouse n� f„� �"1 Vl'll1�l"I'I�'llf ll ` Eghibit A ��"ll`I'�11�1'I'"11f"If'� ' xe�w.Y�,� Attoracy LD.No.82278 7SDC I,aw Offices P.O.Box 650 Fiesslx�y,PA 17033 Attnrncys Far Pe6tio� IN RE.CALENE M.CLOUSE, ) IlV THE COURT pF' COMMON PLEAS aa allsged incapacitatcd person ) CUMBE.RLAND COUNTy,l°ENNSYLVAIVIA ) ORPHANS'CIJLTRT D1yTSION On the Petihon of ) J.Edward Clouse ) NQ.21-15-93 NOTICE UF IlYTENT TO SERVE A SUBpp�A TO PRQDUCE DOCdME1�iTS OR THIl�iGS FUR bISCOVERY PURSUANT Tp RtiLE 4009.22 Nei1 V{T.Yahn,Esquire intends to serve a subpoena ide�tit,a� to the onc that is attached to this notioa You liarrc twenty(2p}days fram the date listed belaw in which bo fi�e of record and serve uprna the undersigned an abjection to the snbpoena. Tf no abjection is made the subpoena mgy be served Respectfulty sabmitted, dSD I�AW OFFICES Date: H �� f By: Neil W Yaha,Esquix� A ey I,D No.822'78 P. Box bS H hey,P 17033 ( �533- SO A Petitionex �-i rrr�irir°rir�r , co�oxw��t o�r�txs�.v�xA GOIJIVTX�3F QJMSARLA3�ilD In ge. a c�c�ras r�. ci.ovss, : an alleged incapaci.tated perHam = � 1��5 93 Ox� Yhe P8tltiCm o£ r �' J. Edxard Clouse ' i SUBPf?L1Y1�1'O PRQI�LT�Dfl�[jMEt►T'TS p�,�.HINGS FUR IZISC`OMYffitY�(TANT�RI1I,�'Lr 4!l09.22 �: Holy irit Hospital 8ehavioral Health 8ntvi.cea 503 �t, Zlst gt, Ca�p gill, PA 17011 ��+tY Q�d4Y�lflamvli�O�fmtt ��) foflawiag�!s o�r� �•Y�aee ortieread by�e coar!on Jx�ua 9�tr See Attached Sxhibit ■A" at r�he b�iov, referenced addzess Yc�mey aeWer or mair {�b") s�+bpoen8,'Ra�tlur wit�the c�zti5�pf �of t��ts or Ptodu�i��sy thia a6ovG. Yan have the ' ��'t0��'��eat�t�e addra�a fiskd thir� scw �, "�ta see�C ia advaa�e ti�a c�abie cost of preP�g tha aopiea or grad�ayg g1e 8s 8b a�r ita I�erriGe.t�o parpry seivin t�s��6y thi�aubPneaa wlthin tweacy(1p)d�ys 8 �o�a�'ueJc a oauct or�or cornpctling ycu to oo�pa,wltlt�t TI31S SUHPDENA WA�I38UED AT THB 1tBQ�ISSt'OF TI�FQLLp'�rINO PER,S07�I: H��; Neil Wazner Yahu, Heguire ADDRES$' P•0. Sox 650 � Her Y, FA �.EPHQNL;'719-533-338D ... .... .__ _. SiJPREt��COtTiLTiD# 82a�a A'!'T�DRIVEY�OR; s. vtar ou BYTHB COURT, �� R�Oer of W9li�rf�aoFdu Olph�' Da�e: Scsl of fEte Ca�crt � `""'111'1'il1�l'I'']If'll , EXffiBIT«A,� SUBPC?ENA TO PRUDUC DOCUMENT Ol�T'SINGS _FOR DISCOyERY PURSIIANT Tp RULE 4009.22 TO: Holy Spirit Hospitat Behavioral HeaIth Services 503 NarFh 21 st Street Camp H�1,PA 1'7411 Copies of aay and all documents r+elsted to Calenc M.C'lonse,in cluding but not Iimited to,mcdical r�corris,medic�l aherts,PrescriPtians,ProSnoses,diagnvses,physici$n rcf�als,specialist reports,nurses notes aud c�pacity evaluations,for tha time period frozn January uf ZOI3 thaugh t�e date of this Subpoena,including r.�l aforementioned records from Jaga.deesh K.Moola,NID. ��rm��rr.nrn � x�w.Y�,� au�Iaa.xo.s2z�a JSDC I+awflffices P.O.Box b50 Hesrsbey,PA 17033 Attorncys for Petitioaer 1N RE:CALENE M.CLOUSE, ) IlV'I'fIE C�URT OF COMMON PLBAS an alltged incapacitated pers�n ) CUMBERLAND CQUNTY,PENNSYI.VANIA ) CfRPHANS'COURT"DIVISION C}n the Petibi�on of } r•��'�� ) NO.21-15-93 CERTI�ICATE UF SERVICE �ND NOW,ttus�day of April,201 S,�Nei�V4�.Yahn,Esquire,do hereby certify thad I served a txue$ad correct copy of the frn cg�oing Natice af Iatert to Serve s Suhpoena�pon the followiz�g below-na�aed individuats by depasiting tha same in the U..S. 12ei1,Pos�gC P�P�d af Hershey,Davphin County,Pent�sylva�ia: SERVED UP�N: Robert C.Saidis,Esquire Saidis,Sullivan&Rogers 26 West HigI�Sireet Carlisle�PA I7413 Attom�y for CaIene ouse � i ��Y��it7Q��i A ey I #8227g ��.� ri i�i7.ii.iirir P CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE The undersigned hereby certifies that I have served the foregoing document upon counsel of record this date by depositing a true and correct copy of the same iri the United States mail, fust-class postage prepaid, addressed as follows: NeiZ W. Ya.hn,Esq. JSDC Law Office P. O. Box 65Q Hershey,PA 17033-0650 Attorney for J. Edward Clouse SAIDIS,SULLIVAII�'& ROGERS Dated: May 1 l,2015 BY: i�.-� �- �..,�,�--- Daniel L. Sullivan,Esquire Id.No. 34548 26 West High Street Cazlisle,PA 17013 {717}243-6222 Attarneys for Calene M. Clouse "'"1 fI'�11"I'I`illf°If ` Neil W.Yahn,Esquire Attorney I.D.No. 82278 JSDC Law Offices P.O.Box 650 Hershey,PA 17033 Attorneys for Petitioner IN RE: CALENE M. CLOUSE, ) IN THE COURT OF C'OMMON PLEAS an alleged incapacitated person ) CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA ) ORPHANS' COURT DIVISION On the Petition of ) J. Edward Clouse ) NO. 21-15-93 �'". CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE AND NOW, this �h' day of May, 2015, I,Neil W. Yahn, �squire, do hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of the foregoing Motion to Dismiss Objections to the Subpoenas upon the following below-named individuals by depositing the same in the U.S. Mail,postage pre- paid at Hershey, Dauphin County, Pennsylvania: SERVED UPON: Robert C. Saidis, Esquire Daniel L. Sullivan, Esquire Saidis, Sullivan & Rogers 26 West High Street Carlisle, PA 17013 Attorneys for Calene Clouse �,� �. ; � �. --�--'""-�... R YAHN ES U IRE i � NEIL WAR ,� , Q Attorney I:D�h#82278 i, ,' � ,� ��___.�--�. f,.