Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout05-2264IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVAD CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogee of Edwin Ullom. CASE NO: Plaintiff, V. TYPE OF PLEADING: COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE Defendants. FILED ON BEHALF OF: Plaintiff COUNSEL OF RECORD OF THIS PARTY: MICHAEL J. DOUGHERTY, ESQ Pa. I.D. #76046 WELTMAN, WEINBERG & REIS 325 Chestnut Street Suite 1120 Philadelphia, PA 19106 (215) 599-1500 W WR #04141976 , L.P.A. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLV CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogee of Edwin Ullom Plaintiff, V. HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE Defendants. CASE NO: TYPE OF PLEADING: COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION NOTICE TO DEFEND NOTICE YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against the claim set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by an attorney in filing in writing with the Court your defenses or objections to to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the Court without further notice for money claimed in the Complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. AVISO LE HAN DEMANDADO A USTED EN LA CORTE. Si usted quiere defenderse de estas demanddeas expuestas en las paginas siguientes, usted tiene veinte (20) digs de plazo al partir de la fecha dela demands y la notificacion. Hace falta asentar una comparencia escrita o en persona o con un abogado y entregar a la corte en forma escrita sus defensas o sus objeciones a las demandas en contra de su persona. Sea avisado que si usted no se defiende, la corte tomara medidas y puede continuar la demanda en contra suya sin previo aviso o notificacion. Ademas, la corte puede decidir a favor del demandante y requiere que ustei cumpla con todas las provisioner de esta demanda. usted puede perder dinero o sus propiedadas u otros drechos importantes para usted. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP: LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO INMEDIATAMENTA. SI NO TIENE A O SINO TIENE EL DINERO SUFFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICO, VAYA EN PERSONA LLAME FOR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUY DIRECCION SE ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ADA. PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE SE PUEDE CON< ASISTENCIA LEGAL. LAWYER REFERRAL SERVICE CUMBERLAND COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION 32 SOUTH BEDFORD STREET CARLISLE, PA 17013 (717) 249-3166 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLV CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogee of Edwin Ullom n CASE NO: OS'- 22(,t{ l.?v 4lL?vt Plaintiff, V. TYPE OF PLEADING: COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE Defendants. COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION AND NOW COMES, Plaintiff by and through its counsel, WELTMAN, WEINBERG & IS, CO., L.P.A., and hereby files this Complaint against Defendants jointly and severally. In support thereof, Plaintiff avers as follows: 1. Plaintiff, Progressive Northern Insurance Company ("Progressive"), is a corporation with a registered office located at P.O. Box 43258, Richmond Heights, Ohio. 2. Defendant, Harris Marine, Inc., doing business as Harrisburg Seaplane Base, is a business organization licensed and authorized to conduct business in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and h Iving as one of its places of business 333 South Front Street, Wormleysburg, Pennsylvania 17043. 3. Progressive issued a policy of insurance where Progressive agreed to insure a 1199 Tracker Pontoon Boat ("Insured Boat"), owned by Plaintiff's insured. 4. On or about September 18, 2004 the Plaintiff Insured's boat was stored at Defendai's place of business and was at all times under the care, custody and/or control of Defendant. 5. While the Plaintiff Insured's boat was under the care, custody and/or control of Defendant, the Plaintiff Insured's boat was caused to be damaged. 6. Defendant is liable to Plaintiff for all damages sustained to the Plaintiff Insured's due to Defendant's negligence and/or carelessness which consisted, inter alia, of failing to have the boat properly secured; failing to take proper precautions to ensure the safety of the boat; failing to take proper precautions t ensure the safety of the boat based on the weather conditions which Defendant knew or should have known were occurring or were about to occur; failing to place the boat at a safe location under the circumstances; and, fa ling to act reasonably in the securing and protecting the boat. 7. As a direct and proximate result of Defendant's negligence, the Progressive's sured boat sustained property damage in the amount of $19,500.00. 8. Pursuant to the terms and conditions of the insurance policy, Progressive paid t e sum of $19,500.00. A true and correct copy of the payment and damage documentation is attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "I". 9. Pursuant to the insurance policy issued by Progressive and as a result of said Progressive became subrogated to the claim of its Insured against Defendant. 10. Pursuant to Progressive's right of subrogation, Progressive is presently due and Defendant the sum of $19,500.00. 12. Repeated demands have been made upon Defendants for payment of the aforesaid payment, from however, Defendant has willfully failed and refused to pay the sum due and owing to Progressive. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands Judgment against Defendant in the amount of $19,500.00 and costs. THIS IS AN ATTEMPT TO COLLECT A DEBT AND ANY INFORMATION OBTAINED USED FOR THAT PURPOSE. Respectfully Submitted: WELTMAN, WElN4Clq& REIS, CO., L.P.A. Michael J. oug erty, Esquire PA I.D. 6046 325 Chestnut S eet Suite 1120 Philadelphia, PA 19106 (215) 599-1500 WWR#04141976 interest BE Date: 10113/20 4 02:00 PM Estimate ID: 04-3847 62-01 Estimate Version: 0 Committed Profile ID: CUSTO [ZED Progressive Insurance 5053 Ritter Road Suite 101 Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 (717) 791.5178 Fax: (717) 697.6711 Damage Assessed By: LICENSE#273265 ANDREW DOLLMAN Claim Rep: ANDREW DOLLMAN (717) 791-5178 Product Type Boat Date of Loss: 09/1812004 Deductible: 250.00 Policy No: 42360716-000 Claim Number: 04.3847062-01 Insured: EDWIN ULLOM Address: 4423 AVON DRIVE HARRISBURG, PA 17112 Telephone: Home Phone: (717) 6524244 Mitchell Service: 911000 Description: 99 TRACKER PONTOON BOAT Vehicle Production Date: 00/00 VIN: BUJ27161D999 OEM/ALT: A Search Code: TRAIN/ Color: GRAY Line Entry Labor Line Item Part Type/ Do lar Labor Item Number Type Operation Description Part Number A ount Units 1 900500 MCH* REPAIR REPLACE RIGHT LOG New 4, 00.00- 8.0* 2 900500 MCH* REPAIR REPLACE LEFT LOG New 4, 00.00 * 8.0- 3 900500 MCH* REPAIR REPLACE RIGHT DECK EXTRUSION New 63.00 * 1.5* 4 900500 MCH* REPAIR REPLACE RIGHT SIDE RAIL COMPLETE New 72.16 * 2.5* 5 900500 MCH* REPAIR DECAL RT SIDE OF BOAT New 66.19 * 3.0* 6 900500 MCH* REPAIR REPLACE MARINE RADIO/CD PLAYER New 50.00 * 0.3* 7 900500 MCH* REMOVEIINSTALL REMOVE/INSTALL CABIN SIDES FOR ACCESS Existing 5.0* 8 900500 MCH* REPAIR WELDING FOR EXTRUSION Sublet 50.00 * 0.0* 9 900500 MCH* REPAIR DETAIL BOAT Existing 3.0* 10 900500 MCH* REPAIR REPAIR BIMINI TOP Sublet 55.00 * 0.0* 11 HARRISBURG SEAT COVER 717-238-9611 12 900500 BDY * REMOVE/REPLACE RECONDITIONED CAVITATION PLATE Sublet 00.00 * INC* 13 900500 MCH* REPAIR REPAIR CAVITATION PLATE Existing 3.0* 14 900500 MCH* REPAIR REMOVE/INSTALL PROP Existing 0.2* - Judgement Item ESTIMATE RECALL NUMBER: 1 011 3/2 0 04 1 4:00:34 04-3847062-01 UltraMate is a Trademark of Mitchell International Mitchell Data Version: OCT_04_A Copyright (C) 1994 - 2002 Mitchell International age 1 of 3 UltraMate Version: 4.8.014 All Rights Reserved Date: 10113 04 02:00 PM Estimate ID: 04-384 '062-01 Estimate Version: 0 Committed Profile ID: CUST MIZED Add'I Labor Sublet 1. Labor Subtotals Units Rate Amount Amount Totals II. Part Replacement Summary Amount Mechanical 34.5 65.00 0.00 205.00 2,447.50 T Taxable Parts 9,651.35 Sales Tax @ 7 000% 675.59 Taxable Labor 2,447.50 Labor Tax @ 7.000% 171.33 Total Replacement Parts Amount 10,326.94 Labor Summary 34.5 2,618.83 III. Additional Costs Amount IV. Adjustments Amount Total Additional Costs 0.00 Insurance Deductible 250.00. Customer Responsibility 250.00- 1. Total Labor: 2,618.83 Il. Total Replacement Parts: 10,326.94 III. Total Additional Costs: 0.00 Gross Total: 12,945.77 IV. Total Adjustments: 250.00- Net Total: 12,695.77 Inspection Site: CITY ISLAND HARRISBURG, PA Inspection Date: 09/27/2004 THE VEHICLE OWNER MAY BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ADDITIONAL COST ABOVE THE APPRAISED AMOUNT. THERE IS NO REQUIREMENT TO USE A SPECIFIC REPAIR SHOP, HOWEVER, THE INSURER CAN PROVIDE A LIST OF REPAIR SHOPS THAT WILL BE ABLE TO REPAIR THE VEHICLE TO ITS PRE-DAMAGE CONDITION. THIS APPRAISAL MAY INCLUDE AFTERMARKET CRASH PARTS AS REPLACEMENT PARTS. IF THE USE OF AN AFTERMARKET CRASH PART VOIDS THE EXISTING WARRANTY ON THE PART THAT IT REPLACES, OR ANY OTHER PART, THAN THE AFTERMARKET PART LISTED ON THIS ESTIMATE WILL HAVE A WARRANTY THAT MEETS OR EXCEEDS THE WARRANTY OF THE ORIGINAL MANUFACTURER. AFTERMARKET PART DESCRIPTIONS ON THIS APPRAISAL ARE PRECEEDED WITH A/M. AN AFTERMARKET CRASH PART IS A NON-ORIGINAL EQUIPMENT MANUFACTURER (NON-OEM) REPLACEMENT PART, EITHER NEW OR USED, FOR AN OF THE NON-MECHANICAL PARTS THAT GENERALLY CONSTITUTE THE EXTERIOR F THE MOTOR VEHICLE, INCLUDING INNER AND OUTER PANELS. LIFETIME GUARANTEE FOR SHEET METAL AND PLASTIC BODY PARTS The replacement parts written on the estimate are intended to return your vehicle to its pre-loss condition with proper installation. After pair, if any sheet metal or plastic body part included in the estimate fails to return your vehicle to its pre-loss condition (assuming proper installation), in terms ESTIMATE RECALL NUMBER: 10/13/200414:00:34 04-3847062-01 Ultra Mate is a Trademark of Mitchell International Mitchell Data Version: OCT_04_A Copyright (C) 1994 -2002 Mitchell International age 2 of 3 11 UltraMate Version: 4.8.014 All Rights Reserved Date: 10/1312004 02:00 PM Estimate ID: 04-384 062-01 Estimate Version: 0 Committed Profile ID: CUSTOMIZED of form, fit, finish, durability or functionality, Progressive will arrange and pay for the replacement of the part, to the extent not covered by a manufacturer's or other warranty. This service will be performed at no cost to you (including associated repair and rental car costs). To obtain s rvice under this Guarantee, call Progressive at 1-800-274-4641. This Guarantee applies as long as you own or lease the vehicle. This Guarantee is not transferable and terminates if you sell or otherwise transfe your vehicle. THIS GUARANTEE DOES NOT COVER NORMAL WEAR AND TEAR OR DAMAGE CAUSED BY IMPROPER MAINTENANCE, NEGLECT, ABUSE OR SUBSEQUENT ACCIDENT. THIS GUARANTEE IS LIMITED TO ARRANGING FOR THE SELECTION OF REPAIR ARTS THAT WILL RETURN YOUR VEHICLE TO ITS PRE-LOSS CONDITION. ACCORDINGLY, PR OGRESSIVE WILL NOT BE LIABLE FOR ANY INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAM AGES THAT RESULT FROM THE INSTALLATION OR USE OF THESE PARTS. ** PART TYPE TERMS A ND ABBREVIATIONS ** NEW AND OEM OR PART NUMBER DISPLAYED -- THESE REFER TO A NEW, ORIGINAL EQUIPMENT MANUFACTURER PART. NON-OEM AND A/M AND QUAL REPL -- THESE REFER TO AN AFTER-MARKET PAR , WHICH IS A NEW, NON-ORIGINAL EQUIPMENT MANUFACTURER PART. USED/RECYCLED AND LRQ -- THESE REFER TO A USED OEM PART. REMANUFACTURED AND RECOND. AND RECORE - - THESE REFER TO USED/RECYCL D OEM PARTS THAT HAVE BEEN REFURBISHED THIS ESTIMATE REPRESENTS AN AGREED PRICE BASED ON ALL KNOWN DAMAGES AT THIS TIME. THE REPAIRER AGREES TO COMPLETE AND GUARANTEE ALL LISTED REPAIRS, AND ALL TOWING AND STORAGE CHARGES INCLUDED IN THIS ESTIMATE. ***THIS IS NOT AN AUTHORIZATION OF REPAIR.*** ***NO SUPPLEMENTS WITHOUT PRIOR AUTHORIZATION OR REINSPECTION.*** PROGRESSIVE WILL ONLY BE RESPONSIBLE E?/FOOR77/ppy?{ryAADDITIONAL STORAGE OR MISC. L IN HANDLING BOTH EPAIRABLE AND TE TUP'OSTUATAYS IONSST THIS APPRAISAL DATE APPRAISER SIGNATURE REPAIR SHOP MANAGER'S SIGNATURE WARNING: Accidental air bag deployment is possible. Personal injury may result. Avoid area near steering wheel and instrument panel even if air bags have deployed. Dual-stage air bag modules may be present that could contain an undeployed stage. When disposing of a deployed dual-stage air bag, always treat it as a "live" module. See appropriate MITCHELLO AIR BAG SERVICE & REPAIR MANUAL, or OEM information. ESTIMATE RECALL NUMBER: 10113/200414:00:34 04-3847062-01 Ultra Mate is a Trademark of Mitchell International Mitchell Data Version: OCT_04_A Copyright (C) 1994.2002 Mitchell International age 3 of 3 Ultra Mate Version: 4.8.014 All Rights Reserved TOTAL LOSS vs. REPAIR ANALYSIS 1) COST TO REPAIR: Initial Cost of Repair (Initial Estimate) ................................. Documented Open Items (Anticipated Supplements)...... plus Rental Cost (Based on Formula: Total labor hours / 4) .. $?, $ 5bo . , T 0 L 77 vs. 2) COST TO TOTAL: Total Cost ACV (VAR Report incl taxes) ......................................... Rental cost ............................................................. plus Tow & Storage charges ......................................... plus Pool Fee ............................................................... Salvage bid ........................................................... $ $ ?L $ plus $ 125.00 minus $ 3 50 . ea als 3 i 6 *** All total losses must be reviewed by a team leader, manager, or trainer prior payment authority being granted. *** *** Granting of payment authority must include FSN documentation of photo *** A rep must consult with a team leader, manager, or pd trainer on any vehicle believe should be totaled notwithstanding the fact that the economic analysis indi otherwise. *** *** 2003 d5 1VIONWEALTH OF PENNSYL? ///?VANIA FISH AND BOAT CO CERTIFICATE OF TITLE TO A BOAS` of ' jp _p) 10 "EDWIN C ULLOM AND /, , JAN INE R ULLOM JTROS r? DR /h,j HARRISBURG PA 17112-1504 , ME, 14", (SEE REVERSE SIDE FOR LEGEND) x/07/2003 07112/1999 ham:/?//S % Trtl Nam ??? Dqe fLe.e Dae of Odgind W.e Title Brmde D.pliu pA Regll 19 9 BASST gK PARTY HUT BUJ27161D999 4 12 E3 / Y >if ,? fi}uo c %Modei Hog idenai mi.. Number e e /Yn (r ?_ rim?j/j,/?,'o//'// /%//p /i // //r ?% // ,i rO/p .. G+'sei/ /, ' y J ?? "r <Sen'.GNU ?? by af+eiuxer Han. Pow.. er I fi.g S.del Number tl4&etuttt, r rua d .? nerue f f. &a h.., '//,? ?/ ql epu T o a Ne Pe ugly Foh and Boa Cooonieauo ?r ? " 1st I,IhN f'yY,BA$BD //?// / ` U /G // 9i q Yij - ?r %?; Znd7d$N r ?p ?......................... MC? w / //,,' '/,/?i R 4, ' \ S ! e Y FY.AS OF TJiE ?k'AS?S r?7P ? yBmcp"S 4v mmBNNSyCC?.v t} 7n.eOa'x e,4 'mvSSION REFLECT T T THE OR C P S 4/1 v /, u wFrn ow m of a°Fy /C' i, mtB nlRYC?t4Y? ///,! r ', ' r //r/?/?/r?j r ,'//?,?y/???s'n ., elsoi a/,/ KIALTERATION OR ERASURE VOIDS THIS TIT //?' r r A ij'. NON j/ Page:'l Document Name: untitled CMSD2340 /CMSM2340 P A C M A N JAN 04 OPID: DCM0012 CLAIM PAYMENT INQUIRY TERMID: INSD: ULLOM, EDWIN C POL: 42 DOL : SEP 18 04 PA-MECHAN-BRN- CLM: 043847062 ACTIVE REP: A PAY TO THE ORDER OF: TOTAL DRAFT AMOUNT: 1 LINE 1: EDWIN C ULLOM, ONLY************************************* LINE 2: LINE 3: ADDRESS: 4423 AVON DRIVE CITY: HARRISBURG ST/PR* PA ZIP/CPC: 17112 IN PAYMENT OF: COLL, T/L TO 99 BOAT, PROG. OBTAINS SALVAGE 1099 ? N FEDERAL TAX ID: LAST UPDT REP: APD0003 CDS CODE * 12 PCL EFT TRACE #: ISSUING REP: A DOLLMAT BANK CODE* AS2 ISSUE DATE OCT 14 04 APPROVED BY: M MURRAY STATE * PA AREA * 252 REVIEW DATE: 00 0C STOP RSN * DRAFT # 436521301 REVIEWED BY: COMMAND: - 16:57 T690707 0716-0 ,500.00 *** CNTRY* USA Date: 01/04/2005 Time: 04:57:47 PM VERIFICATION I, Michael J. Dougherty, Esquire, attorney for the Plaintiff(s) do hereby swear affirm that the averments in the attached Complaint are true and correct to the best knowledge, information and/or belief. These averments are made subject to the of 18 Pa.C.S.A. §4904 relating to unworn falsification to authorities. Z/ A Mi ael . ou rty Date 0 o ? Ek (cam( SU Cy PL:: Q ° 7 T, 1t`? cn W "-< G SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 2005-02264 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INS CO VS HARRIS MARINE INC DBA HARRISBU GERALD WORTHINGTON Cumberland County,Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE was served upon HARRIS MARINE INC D/B/A HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE the DEFENDANT , at 1117:00 HOURS, on the 6th day of May 2005 at 333 SOUTH FRONT STREET WORMLEYSBURG, PA 17043 RON MOROZ, MANAGER , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of by handing to ADULT IN CHARGE a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE together with and at the same time directing His attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs Docketing 18.00 Service 11.84 Affidavit .00 Surcharge 10.00 .00 39.84 Sworn and Subscribed to before me this / day of A.D. prothonotar So Answers: j R. Thomas Kline 05/09/2005 WELTMAN WEINBERG REIS By: L?[I n,uW? r Deputy Sh ff I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION Plaintiff, IIARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE SEAPLANE BASE Defendant TYPE OF PLEADING: ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED ON BEHAL `OF DEFENDANT MAR INE PROPERTIES, INC d/b/a/ HARRISBURG SE APLANE BASE (improperly led as Harris Marine, Inc.) COUNSEL OF RF OF THIS PARTY: .JAMES W. JOHNSI PA lD# 23319 HOLLSTEIN, KEA' CATTELL, JOHNS GOLDSTEIN, P.C. 1628 JOHN F. KEN S U ITE 2000 PHILADELPHIA. F 215-320-3260 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY ubrogee of Edwin Ullom CASE NO: RD OF V. ESQUIRE NG, V& EDY BLVD. 19103 d/b/a Please enter my appearance on behalf of defendant Marine Properties, Harrisburg Seaplane Base (improperly plead as Harris Marine, Inc.). HOLLSTEIN KEATING CATTE JOHNSON & GOLDSTEIN, P.C. Bv: James W. J7, son Josette F. S k Attorney for Defendants 110247 00088'I'N4592J CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 1, Josette F. Spivak, Esquire do hereby certify that a copy of Defendant's Entry of Appearance was served on January 19, 2006, via U.S. first class mail upon the following: Michael J. Dougherty, Esquire W eltman, Weinberg & Reis Co. 325 Chestnut Street, Suite 1120 Philadelphia, PA 19106 Josette F. SlVak, Esquire t 10247.00088.. TN45921 (" p fQ J {Y? 0llt r1 ., ,;:Y 14aL-y IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND CO f PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY CASE NO: 05-2264 Subrogee of Edwin Ullom Plaintiff, HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE SEAPLANE BASE Defendant TYPE OF PLEADING: ANSWER TO COMPL/ FILED ON BEHALF O DEFENDANT MARIN PROPERTIES, INC. d/1 HARRISBURG SEAPL BASE (improperly pled Marine, Inc.) COUNSEL OF RECO OF THIS PARTY: JAMES W. JOHNSON, JOSETTE F. SPIVAK E PA ID# 233 19 / 82356 HOLLSTEIN, KEATINi CATTELL,JOHNSON. GOLDSTEIN, P.C. 1628 JOHN F. KENNEL SUITE 2000 PHILADELPHIA, PA 1 215-320-3260 ANSWER TO COMPLAINT WITH NEW MATTER Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, i Harris Marine, Inc., by and through its counsel Hollstein, Keating, Cartel[- Johnson Goldstein, P.C. responds to Plaintiffs Complaint and avers as follows: Harris OF BLVD. 103 pled as ,1024700098 FMi451 Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefore same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. 2. Denied in part, admitted in part. It is denied that Harris Marine, Inc. i a business organization licensed and authorized to conduct business in the Commonwealth of P nnsylvania. Marine Properties, Inc., improperly plead as Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a I larrisburg Seaplane Base, is a Pennsylvania corporation. It is admitted that 333 South Front Street, Wormleysborg, PA is the place of business of Marine Properties, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base. Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefor same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. 4. Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and thcrefor? same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefor same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. i 6. Denied. Answering Defendant specifically denies it was negligent or ?areless in its care of the boat. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks suf1 cient 10247 00088-TN45451 information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefore same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. 7. Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefor, same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. 8. Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefore same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. 9. Denied. This paragraph states a conclusion of law to which no respore is required. 10. Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefore same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. H. . There is no paragraph 11. 12. Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefor same is denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. 1024T00088'TN4545 1 WHEREFORE, Answering Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc., respectfully requests judgment in its against Plaintiff, together with the award of costs and attorney fees. NEW MATTER 1. Plaintiff's claim is barred by the common law defense of act of God. 3. This Complaint fails to set forth a cause of action for which relief 3. This Court lacks jurisdiction of the persons of Defendant Harris 4. Answering Defendant violated no legal duty to Plaintiff. 5. The action is barred by the applicable Statute of Limitations. 6. The plaintiff was guilty of the sole negligence which was the damages complained of. 7. The plaintiff was guilty of contributory negligence. 8. The plaintiff was guilty of comparative negligence of a greater degree negligence of the defendant, which negligence is denied. 9. The alleged damages sustained by the plaintiff are the proximate and/or omissions of parties over which defendants exercised no control. 10. Plaintiff is not the real party in interest. Seaplane and be granted. Inc. e cause of the t of the acts ( 10247.00098 TN4545} 1 1. Plaintiff lacks standing to bring this action. 12. Answering Defendant incorporates by reference the terms of the Dockage Lease Agreement, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "A", including, but not lim ted to Paragraph 10 which states: "Lessor is not responsible for any damage or loss caused y changes in water levels, storms, floods, vandalism, or other events beyond the control of the Lessor," and asserts same in defense of the action. 13. Answering Defendant incorporates by reference the terms of the Doc age Lease Agreement, including, but not limited to, Paragraph 12 which states: "Dockage of said vessel is at the risk of the Lessee and the Lessee expressly waives any claims or causes of action against the Lcssor on account of damage or loss regardless of how caused. It is understood etween the parties that this instrument is not a bailment or contract of wharfage," and asserts sal e in defense of the action. Exhibit "A." 14. Plaintiff's claim is barred by the terms, limitations and conditions set forth in the agreement. 15. Answering Defendant reserves the right to supplement its New Matte as indicated during discovery. 10247.00099'1 N4545 } Ii WHEREFORE, Answering Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc., respectfully requests Judgment in its fa?or and against Plaintiff, together with the award of costs and attorney fees. HOLLSTEIN KEATING CATTELL JOHNSON & GOLDSTTIN, P.C. By:( ! jAf James W. J Anson, Esquire PA LD. # 3319 Josette F. Spivak, Esquire PA I.D. # 82356 1628 John F. Kennedy Blvd. Suite 2000 Philadelphia, PA 19103 215-320-3260 10247.00088-'rN4545 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 1, Josette F. Spivak, Esquire do hereby certify that a copy of Defendant's Answer to the Complaint with New Matter was served on January 19, 2006, via U.S. first class mail upon the following: Michael J. Dougherty, Esquire Wellman, Weinberg & Reis Co. 325 Chestnut Street, Suite 1120 Philadelphia, PA 19106 Josette F. Spivak, Esquire 10247.00088 1 N4547 01/13/2006 FRI 15:40 FAX VERIFICATION U004/029 I, Michael Bowers, hereby state that I am President of Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc. and that I at authorized to make this Verification on its behalf I also state that the facts contained in the for going Answer with New Matter are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, informa on and 'belief This Verification is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C. S. § 4904 relat ng to unsworn falsification to authorities. / - Michael Bowers Dated: t 10247.000881N461 51 rn D ?? i ??? ? WORMLEYSBUAG RWERSIDE CITY ISLAND_X_ MAY IS THRU OCT- 1. 2004 MAY31 THRU OCT.1.2004 MAY 1 THRU OCT_ 15. 2004 DOCKAGE LEASE AGREEMENT All information must be filled out and lease must be signed or no slip will be given. Anyone caught in a slip without a signed lease, the boat will be pulled and you will not be allowed back in. This agreement made between B & B Holdings, Inc. and Harrisburg Seaplane Base hereinafter called Lessor, and named Lessee t`,'h ?r l???as9g Home Phone -sy.>?Y Work ?P/hone 'o7 -0 V? Emergency Phone Gyd'-=1A3s Address ¢ x.7 3 y,,,q () r T a,'',•51ll? 3 _ h'. 1,7?1,a ;lq Boat Registration# Boat Make Boat Year/Length 3c, Engine HP__Engme Year Engine Model _ Jet Ski Make Jet Sic Registration rr --- Providing for the rental of dock space for the berthing of a boat owned by the Lessee for the 2004 docking season commencing on or about the specified date at rile top of this contract, depending on weather and river conditions. If boat is in the Marina after the lease termination date, Lessee will be billed 510.00 per day as additional rental. Lessee agrees to pay unto the Lessor inconsideration of the dock space furnished, the total sum (2?S SLIP NUMBER - / io'/,- I. Lessor agrees to furnish space at its docks for berthing of the above vessel. 2_ Lessor shall retain the right to designate dock space. 3. All dock space rent shall be payable in advance. 4. Lessee agrees not to sell, transfer, assign or permit the use of his/her assigned dock space. Lessee warrants that be/she is the owner of the above-described boat. This contract becomes null and void if Lessee sells his/her vessel. We will not guarantee your spot to the new owners. 5. Lessee can only dock said vessel that is on this agreement. No other boat or PWC is permitted to be tied to vessel. 6. Lessee agrees to maintain his/her vessel in a safe and seaworthy condition, procure and keep in Force the policy of Marine insurance providing adequate coverage for hull protection and Indemnity, to moor and secure the vessel properly with a minimum of 318" nylon line, and to Operate the vessel, when in the vicinity of Lessor's docks and marina, in a competent and careful manner, avoiding wakes and damage to the docks or other vessels. If Lessor has to change any lines on your boat to meet the minimum standard in this contract, Lessee will be billed accordingly, 7. Lessee may work on his/her vessel in the marina as long as such work does not interfere with the rights or the right of way of other Lessees or the operation of the marina as long as the work is performed by the Lessee himself/herself. No work may be done by an outside contractor without written permission from the Lessor. 8. All pets shall be on a secured leash when at the marina. Further, it is the pet owner's obligation and responsibility to clean up mmcdiateiy and dispose of excrement of his/her pet as may occur on the Lessors property (including docks). 9. In an emergency situation. Lessor shall be permitted to move Lessee's boat. Lessee will be billed at the Lessor's prevailing rate for the services. 10. Lessor is not responsible for anv damage or loss caused by changes in water levels, storms, floods, vandalism, or other events beyond the control of the Lessor. No refunds will be given on dock space under any circumsances. I I- Water skiing or swimming from the dock or in the marina is expressly prohibited. Fire torches or such are prohibited also. 12. Dockage of said vessel is at the risk of. the Lessee and the Lessee expressly waives any claims or causes of action against the Lessor on account of damage or loss regardless of how caused. It is understood between the parties that this instrument is not a bailment or contract of wharfage. 13. No vessel shall be advertised for sale in the marina. 14. Lessee must display issued parking permit on vehicle when on marina property. Due to space limitation, only one vehicle per boat is allowed in Marina. One Primary Permit per vesseL' household will be issued. No trailers are permitted on parking lot. ,,offensive x`o others. 15. Lessor reserves the fight to exclude those whose actions are Lessor, B&B H Idm , ;nc. and Harrisburg Lessee Seaplane Base DATE: y?/S/c / DATE= r.ro ? a ?'1 WELTMAN, WEINBERG & REIS CO., L.P.A. BY: Michael J. Dougherty, Esquire Attorney for Plaintiff(s) I.D. No. 76046 325 Chestnut Street, Suite 1120 Philadelphia, PA 19106 Phone: 215.599.1500 Fax: 215.599.1505 File # 04141976 PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogee of Edwin Ullom vs. Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas No.052264 HARRIS MARINE, INC. dba HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE PLAINTIFF'S REPLY TO DEFENDANT'S NEW MATTER 1 - 15. Denied. Defendant's averment is a conclusion of law to which no responsive pleading is required. As way of further response, after reasonable investigation Plaintiff is without sufficient information to form a belief as to the truth or falsity of Defendant's averments. Strict proof of same is therefore required at time of trial. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands that judgment be entered in its favor and against Defendant, Harris Marine, Inc. dba Harrisburg Seaplane Base. WELTMAN, WEINB G & REIS CO., L.P.A. By Michael J. Dougherty, Esquire Attorney for Plaintiff VERIFICATION I, Michael J. Dougherty, Esquire, attorney for the Plaintiff(s) do hereby swear and affirm that the averments in the attached Reply to New Matter are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and/or belief. These averments are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S.A. §4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. Mi el . Dougherty Date / A 0 C r r 7 1 Q? HOLLSTEIN KEATING CATTELL JOHNSON & GOLDSTEIN P.C. ' BY: James W. Johnson / Josette F. Spivak IDENTIFICATION NO. 23319 / 82356 EIGHT PENN CENTER 1628 JOHN F. KENNEDY BLVD SUITE 2000 PHILADELPHIA, PA 19103 Phone: (215) 320-3260 Fax: (215) 320-3261 Attorneys for Defendant Marine Properties,, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc. PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY Subrogee of Edwin Ullom V. HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE SEAPLANE BASE IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY : CIVIL DIVISION CASE NO: 05-2264 DEFENDANT MARINE PROPERTIES, INC. d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE, improperly pled as HARRIS MARINE, INC.'S MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc., by and through its counsel Hollstein, Keating, Cattell, Johnson and Goldstein, P.C. hereby moves this Honorable Court to Consolidate the above -captioned actions for all purposes pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. 213(a). 1. Plaintiff Progressive Northern Insurance Company filed the above captioned action in the Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas on behalf of Subrogee Edwin Ullom. A true and correct copy of Plaintiff's Complaint is attached hereto as Exhibit "A." 2. Plaintiff and plaintiff- subrogee have alleged property damage to his boat allegedly docked at Defendant's Marina on or about September 18, 2004. Exhibit "A." 3. Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc., filed its Answer with New Matter on or about January 20, 2006. A true and correct copy of Defendant's Answer with New Matter is attached hereto as Exhibit "B." 4. Plaintiffs' complaint arises out of the same transactions or series of transactions as are alleged in the matters of: a. Progressive Northern Insurance Company, Subrogee of James Ford v. Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 05-3270. A true and correct copy of Plaintiff's Complaint is attached hereto as Exhibit "C." b. Progressive Northern Insurance Company, Subrogee of Raymond C. Santana, Jr. v. Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 05-2263. A true and correct copy of Plaintiff's Complaint is attached hereto as Exhibit «D C. Progressive Northern Insurance Company, Subrogee of Greg Sharrar v. Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 05-3271. A true and correct copy of Plaintiff's Complaint: is attached hereto as Exhibit "E." d. Progressive Northern Insurance Company, Subrogee of Jim Sauerwine v. Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 05-3932. A true and correct copy of Plaintiff's Complaint: is attached hereto as Exhibit "F." 5. Upon information and belief the Plaintiffs' claims relate to flooding which occurred in September 2004 as a result of the remnants of Hurricane Ivan. 6. All of the plaintiffs' seek to :recover in subrogation for property damage claims paid to their insureds for damage to the insureds' boats which were allegedly docked at Defendant's Marina in September 2004. { l 0247.00088:JFS 14371 2 7. Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 213(a) provides: In actions pending in a county which involve a common question of law or fact or which arise: from the same transaction or occurrence the court on its own motion or on the motion of any party may order a joint hearing or trial of any matter in issue in the actions, may order the actions consolidated, and may make orders that avoid unnecessary cost or delay. 8. These cases should be consolidated for purposes of discovery, arbitration and trial in order to avoid unnecessary costs to both the Court and the parties and because all of the aforementioned Complaints involve common questions of law and fact, and arise from the same transaction or occurrences. Rozonowski v. Penn. Nat'l Mutual Casualty Ins. Co., 343 Pa. Super 7 (1985); Lohmiller v. Weidenbaugh, 302 Pa. Super. 174 (1982), rev'd on other grounds, 503 Pa. 329 (1983). 9. Consolidation of these actions for discovery and trial will also avoid prejudice which could result from multiple hearings and inconsistent rulings. 10. Plaintiff's Counsel does not oppose this motion to consolidate. WHEREFORE, Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc., respectfully requests the Court grant its Motion to Consolidate the above captioned actions for all purposes under the caption and docket of (I 0247.00088:JFS 14371 Progressive Northern Insurance Company, Subrogee of Raymond C. Santana, Jr. v. Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 05-2263. HOLLSTEIN KEATING CATTELL JOHNSON & GOLDSTEIN, P.C. By: James W: John n, Esquire PA I.D. # 233 10 Josette F. Spivak, Esquire PA I.D. # 82356 { 10247.00088:JFS 1437) 4 Exhi b;+A IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, - Subrogee of Edwin UllonL - _ CASE NO: -- - -- -" --... Plaintiff. _ .. . _ _i.. . V. - TYPE OF PLEADING: - - - - = _ - COMPLAINT IN CIVIL AC'T'ION HARRIS KARINE, INC., d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE Defendants. FILED ON BEHALF OF: Plaintiff COUNSEL OF RECORD OF THIS PARTY. MICHAEL J. DOUGHERTY, ESQUIRE Pa. I.D. #76046 WELTMAN, WEINBERG & REIS CO., L.P.A. 325 Chestnut Street Suite 1120 Philadelphia, PA 19106 (215) 599-1500 WWR #04141976 r IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogee of Edwin Ullom CASE NO: Plaintiff, V. TYPE OF PLEADING: COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/Wa .- . = . _ •_ HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE _ .. :. - Defendants. _ NOTICE TO DEFEND NOTICE AVII YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to LE HAN DEMANDADO A USTED EN LA defend against the claim set forth in the following pages, CORTE. Si usted quiere defenderse de estas you must take action within twenty (20) days after this. _ demanddeas expuestas en las paginas siguieates, -- , complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written ustcd tieiii veinte (20) dias do plm al pwtir de la . _ - _ __ _ appearance personally or by an attorney in filing in": ' fecha dela demands y la notification. Hace falta writingwith the Court your defenses or objections.to asentar una comparencia escrita o en persona o coil. - ,: •,. - to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that un abogado y entregar a la torte en forma escrita if you fail to do so the case may proceed without yoU 'and---,-- sus defensas o sus objeciones a las demandas cn. a judgment may be entered against you by the Court:- contra de so persona. Sea avisado que si usted no:-.' _ • without finther notice for money claimed in the complaint se defiende, la cone tomara me didas y puede - :`: - ::F=? _: ? or for any other claim or relief requested by the,:-::: contiauar la demanda rn contra suya sin previo plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other- aviso o notification. Ademas, la torte puede - rights important to you. - - decidir a favor del demandante .y requiem que usted - cuumpla con todas las provisions de esta demanda. usted put& perder dmero o sus propmdadas u otros drecbos importantes para usted: YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP: LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO MIEDIATAMENTA. SI NO TZENE ABOGADO O SINO TIENE EL DINERO SUFFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICO, VAYA EN PERSONA O LLANE FOR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DMWCION SE ENCUENTRA ESCRTTA ADAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGUIR ASLSTENCIA LEGAL. LAWYER REFERRAL SERVICE CUMBERLAND COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION '32 SOUTH BEDFORD STREET CARLISLE, PA 17013 (717) 249-3166 4 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogee of Edwin Ullom CASE NO: Plaintiff, V. TYPE OF PLEADING: COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE .- .:Defendants: • - COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION - -, .:AND- NOW 'COMES, Plaintiff._W arid--through- its caunsef, WELTIyMA.N; _WEINBERG & REIS,, thereof, Plaintiff avers L.P?A., and hereby'fil'es this CoYnplairit against Defendants jointly and severally: In support . =, . ,, as:follows•_:- . - __ .. . _. -.- .:......:. - _-.....:: _... _ ._ _ •._ _...: - - - - ... .- - .•?_:: ji:::_ .: =:: -_ ' . • Y Y'1- . -1. • 1 •. % _ ..:, > : Plaintiff; Progressives-:Norther. Insurance :Zompanyi; !'Progressive"); is a: corporatign' with a rcgistered`office located at P.O_ Box 43258, Richmond Heights; Ohio:. - = - - ,.- Defendant, Harris. Marine, Inc,.; doing` 6siiiess- as : Harrisburg Seaplane Base, is a business organization licensed and authorized to cobduct 1uMness in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and having as one of its places of business 333 South Front Street, Wormleysburg, Pennsylvania 17043. 3. Progressive issued a policy of insurance where Progressive agreed to insure a 1999 Tracker Pontoon Boat {"Insured Boat'j, owned by Plaintiffs insured. 4. On or about September 18, 2004 the Plaintiff Insured's boat was stored at Defendant's place of business and was at all times under the care, custody and/or control of Defendant. 5. While the Plaintiff Insured's boat was under the care, custody and/or control of Defendant, the Plaintiff Insured's boat was caused to be damage& 6. Defendant is liable to Plaintiff for all damages sustained to the Plaintiff Insured's boat due to Defendant's negligence and/or carelessness which consisted, inter alia, of: failing to have the boat properly secured; failing to take proper precautions to ensure the safety of the boat; failing to take proper precautions to ensure the safety of the boat based on the weather condition: which Defendant knew or should have known were occurring or were about to occur, failing to place the boat at a safe location under the circumstances; and, failing to act reasonably in the securing and protecting the boat. 7. As a direct and proximate. result' of Defendant's..-negligence, the Progressive's Insured boat - sustained property damage in the amount of $19,500.00. . 8. Pursuant to the terms and conditions of the insurance policy, Progressive paid the sum of $19,500.00. A true and correct copy of the payment and damage documentation is attached hereto.and.marked as Exhibit "1". = - = - - - - -...... . - - 9. - Pursuant-to-the insurance policy issued by_-Progressive and as a result of said-aforesaid payment, Progressive became subrogated to the claim of its Insured against Defendant. - - 10. - Pursuant to Progressive's right. of subrogation, Progressive is presently due and owed from Defendant-the sum-of $19.500.00: _ , . .... _. r: - 12. Repeated demands-have been made upon Defendants for payment of the aforesaid sum; however, ..;:,. Defendant has willfully failed and:refused to pay The sum due and owing to Progressive. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands Judgment against Defendant in the amount of $19,500.00 plus interest and costs. THIS IS AN ATTEMPT TO COLLECT A DEBT AND ANY INFORMATION OBTAMED SHALL BE USED FOR THAT PURPOSE. Respectfully Submitted: WELTMAN, WE & REIS, CO., L.P.A. .. _ . ::. :......_ :. Michael erty, Esquire . VP, PA I D. 604 325 Chestnut S t Suite 1120 Philadelphia,'PA 19106 (215) 599-1500 V1WR#04141976..:_._:_i-_._.? r?. - :_.: E Date: 10!1312004 02:00 PM Estimate ID: 04-3847462-01 Estimate Version: 0 Committed Profile ID: CUSTOMIZED Progressive Insurance 5053 Rlder Road Suite 101 Mechanicsburg. PA 17055 1,717) 791-5178 Fax: (717) 697-0711 Damage Assessed By: UCENSE11273265 ANDREW DOLLMAN Claim Rep: ANDREW DOLLMAN (717) 791-5178 ProductType Boat Date of Loss: 09/1812004 ' Deductible: 250.00 - = Policy No: 42360718-000 Claim Number. 043647062-01 `. Insured: EDWIN ULLOM - Address: 4423 AVON DRIHE HARRISBURG. PA 17112 •J Telephone: . Home Phone: (717) 6524244 . _ _ Mitchell.Servlce: 911000 Description: 99 TRACKER PONTOON BOAT Vehicle Production Date: 00/00 VIN: BUd27161 D999 OEMIAL.T: A Search Code: TRAIN! Color: GRAY ?- •? Una Entry Labor Una Item Part Type/ Dollar Labor Item _ Number Type Operation Description Part Number -Amount_ ' bli is .:M 1 900500 MCH• REPAIR REPLACE RIGHT LOG New --- - _4.200.00'`= 8.0' ; 2 900500 MCH' REPAIR REPLACE LEFT LOG Now .4.200.00'''8.0' 3 900500 MCH• REPAIR - - -REPLACE RIGHT DECK EXTRUSION New 4 900500 MCH• REPAIR REPLACE RIGHT SIDE RAIL COMPLETE _ New 472:16 f 2.5* `' 5 900500- MCH• REPAIR DECAL RT SIDE OF BOAT New 288;19.' 3.0' - • 6 900500 MCH' REPAIR REPLACE MARINE RADIO/CD PLAYER New '' 250:00, ; 0.3' 7 900500 MCH' REMOVE/INSTALL REMOVEANSTALL CABIN SIDES FOR ACCESS Existing 0? r r_ ? ., 'I.*-.-'.-. _ 8 900500 MCH• REPAIR WELDING FOR EXTRUSION Sublet ' '•15:00' ;0.0' ; • r i ` 9 900500 MCH• REPAIR DETAIL BOAT Existing . ; " 310' 10 900500 MCH' REPAIR REPAIR BIMINI TOP Sublet 55.00' ' 0.0' ?. . 11 HARRISBURG SEAT COVER 717-238-9611 12 900500 BDY • REMOVEIREPLACE RECONDITIONED CAVITATION PLATE Sublet - 100.00' INC' 13 900500 MCH• REPAIR REPAIR CAVITATION PLATE -Existing 3.0• 14 900500 MCH' REPAIR REMOVE11NSTALL PROP Existing 0.2' ' - Judgement Item ESTIMATE RECALL NUMBER: il)M 200414:00:34 043647062-01 UltraMate Is a Trademark of Mitchell Intemational Mitchell Data Version: OCT 04 A Copyright (C)1994 - 2002 Mitchell International UNraMate Version: 4.8.014 All Rights Reserved Page 1 of 3 Add'1 Labor Sublet L Labor Subtotals Units Rate Amount Amount Totals Mechanical 34.5 65.00 0.00 205.00 2,447.50 T Taxable Labor Labor Tax Labor Summary 34.5 2.447.50 7.000% 171.33 2,618.83 Date: 1011312004 02:00 PM Estimate ID: 043847062-01 Estimate Version: 0 Committed Profile ID: CUSTOMIZED IL Part Replacement Summary Amount Taxable Parts 9,631.35 Sales Tax ® 7.000% 675.59 Total Replacement Parts Amount 10,326.94 Ill. Additional Costs Amount N. Adjustments Amount Total Additional Costa 0.00 Insurance Deductible 250.00 Customer Responsibility 250.00 1. Total Labor. $618.83 IL Total Replacement Parts: - - 10.326.94 IL Total Additional Costs: 0.00 Gross Total: 12,945.77 _ - - ` - - IV. Total Adjustments: 250.00 Net Total: 12.695.77 Inspection Site: CITY ISLAND HARRISBURG. PA Inspection Date: 09/2712004 - - VEHZCLE-OWNER. MAY BE - RESPONSIBLE., FOR- ADDITIONAL :CAST =:AHOVB.. THE... ., - THE -- :... APPRAISBD.;ALIN'r . TSERE I3 NO REQUIREMENT TO USE A!?'SPECIFIC 'REPAIR. A. LIST- OF REPAIR SHOPS:' THAT 3DE -_ SHOP, H0 3 R; := THH'.IINSURER: CAN. -PRQV - : : ' • ': WILL BE==ASI.E= •TO` REPAIR=•T8L-'VEHI ITS- PRE-D T- •- :.: _ C'LE TO AMAiGE""CONDITION. ==';1:: vri ' THIS APPRAISAL~'M1Yrs'INCLUDE - FTE T CRASH PARTS... A91 - REPLACEMENT - - ?,, PARTS. ;, _.IF, THL• :IISE; OE`; AIJ ?- T' CRASH PART VOIDS. THE'-EXISTING---- WARRANTYON THE PART THAT IT REPLACES; OR ANY OTHER PART THAN THE -. -- AFTERMARKET PART LISTED ON THIS ESTIMATE WILL HAVE* A- THAT _._?_.. ... ._ . . MEETS OR-EXCEEDS THE• WARRANTY •OF THE ORIGINAL K&NUFACTURER. ....... .t .,,:,. AFTERMARKET PART DESCRIPTIONS ON THIS APPRAISAL ARE PRECEEDED WITH A/M. AN AF'TMODU MT CRASH PART IS A NON-ORIGINAL EQUIPMENT MANUFACTURER (NON-OEM) REPLACEMENT PART, EITHER NEW OR USED, FOR ANY OF THE NON-MECHANICAL PARTS THAT GENERALLY CONSTITUTE THE EXTERIOR OF THE MOTOR VEHICLE, INCLUDING INNER AND OUTER PANELS. LIFETIME GUARANTEE FOR SHEET ANAL AND PLASTIC BODY PARTS The replacement parts written on the estimate are intended to return your vehicle to its pre-loss condition with proper installation. After repair, if any sheet metal or plastic body part included in the estimate fails to return your vehicle to its pre-loss condition (assuming proper installation), in terms ESTIMATE RECALL NUMBER: 1 011 312004 14:00:34 043847062-01 UltraKate Is a Trademark of Mitchell International Mitchell Data Version: OCT 04 A Copyright (C) 1994 - 2002 Mitchell International Page 2 of 3 UltraMate Version: 4.8.014 All Rights Reaervtrd Date: 10113r2004 02.00 PM Estimate tD: 04-3847062-01 Estimate Version: 0 Committed Profile ID: CUSTOMIZED of form, fit, finish, durability or functionality, Progressive will arrange and pay for the replacement of the part, to the extent not covered by a - manufacturer's or other warranty,. This service will be performed at no cost to you (including associated repair and rental car costs). To obtain service under this Guarantee, call Progressive at 1-800--274-4641. This Guarantee applies as long as you own or lease the vehicle. This Guarantee is not transferable and terminates if you sell or otherwise transfer your vehicle. THIS GUARANTEE DOES NOT COVER NORMAL WEAR AND TEAR OR DAMAGE CAUSED BY EMPROPER MAINTENANCE, NEGLECT., ABUSE OR SUBSEQUENT ACCIDENT. THIS GUARANTEE IS LIMITED TO ARRANGING FOR THE-SELECTION OF REPAIR PARTS THAT WILL RETURN YOUR VEHICLE TO ITS PRE--LOSS CONDITION. ACCORDINGLY, PROGRESSIVE WILL NOT BE LIABLE FOR ANY` INDIRECT;''INCIDENTAL OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGBS_T RESULT FROG THE INSTALLATION OR.- USE : OF :.THESE `PARTS-. H - ;s * * PART TYPE TERM11 AND ABBREVIATIONS NEW AND OEM OR PART NUMBER DISPLAYED--- THESE REFER TO A NEW, ORIGINAL EQUIPMENT MANUFACTURER- PART...... NON-OEM AND A/M AND QUAL REPL --- THESE REFER TO AN AFTER-MARKET PART,.: WHICH IS 'A NEW, NON-ORIGINAL EQUIPMENT MANUFACTURER PART. USED/RECYCLED AND LKQ -- _THESR:_. REFER T4 A USED OEM PART. REMANUFACTURED AND RECOND. AND RECORR'---- --THESE REFER TO USED/RECYCLED.. , _ __.. OEM PARTS THAT HAVE BEEN'REFURBISHED.' - =:DAI?iGE9i r _ - .;,• THIS ESTIki s REPRESENTS :J W?XGREEb PRICE"--BASED- ON- ALL KNOWN _ AT :THIS TIML: -TH_E`_REPAIRSR-?AGREE3 TO,'CCHPL_ETB=-AND GUARAtME, ALL--. - , AIM?-"AT•T• TpWING?AND- -STORAGE--CHARGES:,.INCI.UQFDr'._ N:.THI ?.,?r ;, _ s_• Y"- .`• :LISTLD"REPAT*S= - - " _ ' c: •°_ ? -- "**.THIS IS~'NOT 'AN"_AU'rH_ORIZATiON° OFREPAIR: ** - - .,?•;.-':::??• •?: ' AUTHORIZATION' OR "REINSPECTION . tpp--SUPPhF S%WITHOUT PRIOR' PROGRESSIVE WILL ONLY BE RESPONSIBLE FOR?ADDITIONAL STORAGE OR MISC.: HANDLING=CHARGES WHEN-WARRANTE "'UP AYS POST. THIS APPRAISAL - DATE IN BOTH REPAIRABLE AND TUATIONS. APPRAISER SIGNATURE REPAIR SHOP MANAGER'S SIGNATURE WARNING: Accidental air bag deployment is possible. Personal Injury may result. Avoid area near steering wheel and Instrument panel even If air bags have deployed. Dual-stage air bag modules may be present that could contain an undeployed stage. When disposing of a deployed duaktage air bag, always treat it as a "Ilve" module. See appropriate MITCHELLO AIR BAG SERVICE & REPAIR MANUAL, or OEM loft.. ation. ESTIMATE RECALL NUMBER: 1011312004 14:00:34 04-3347052-01 UltralMate Is a Trademark of Mitchell hdornational Mitchell Data Version: OCT at A Copyright (C) 1994 - 2002 Mitchell International Page 3 of 3 UltraMate Version: 4.8.014 All Rights Reserved TOTAL. LOSS vs, REPAIR ANALYSIS WORKSHEET .. I) COST TO REPAIR: . Initial Cost of Repair (Itutlal Estimate) ................................. 77 Documented Open Items (Anticipated Supplements)...... plus $ 500 . Rental Cost (Based on Formula: Total labor hours / 4) .. plus yys. 7? -.- _.. ..:y _.? +=_ . - 2)_:COST TO TOM _ _ __ -Z M: ? Z .:_...._Jr •i????iOtaaY?o.7i _?-..?_' .._..' =-?•-'?'`-'?" .-.?-..L c?T:. ? - 1 . _ -_CV [] rt- lta s .............. sr.?.?......... • ALr (Y pO ?r ?? ........ _ ? _ _ , • It7 l s Rental cost:. :..........::.......... .?..: p u Tow & Storage. charges.. .............. ............. ....... plus ....:r ..-• •- - ;y ._.... .F??•l`Y'-7? -?..?!q ?. ..il y' _ _. . .7'-fir ..M.rr' 'T ..a I- L_ .0. ?_'.t_ - .: -. . .. . ..• t.. . 'T_4• :,.,? i t . ::`•?yl1??L_ -•JI?_ ..•.`r ?? ? r:.: ..:ter. _i ..:??.. ' •. si, .... .; -'._?__ :•.?.._ - _ --. ?: ,c-t^ .?-.-'-•:r *7 f7 O - :'_•r1_ .S'?- : ?: ....._. -.:- '.. ..•... .a.a J.i .:.....:.. ._ .... ..__. ...... .... .. .:phis- , $-J25;00-'t :y ;•ti ? ?R ... ..- -- - N................... ?1...1.i...1.............N ti a.+? ?1 .?• . o1 . W. _. • ........... ? V •- L .• . ?W.Lj a•?•I-/?•?Ti i. r-r_'?•?Y? jr• -_ _ __'_ ?•Yr_M'?4R'r??_-145?_Jar _fnr.?•?•^ r...... r?...•+? ?7 ?..• _.,17-.if..i?:i -1 &! I._a__ .?.r d?•. ???^3 ._; =_ ..... : :: . ..:: . . . . e bid y SSalva _ minzig: .... ....... .... .. . ........................... .. . . g *** All total losses must be reviewed by a team leader, manager, or trainer prior to any payment authority being granted. *** ** Granting of payment authority must include FSN documentation of photo review *** *** A rep must consult with a team leader, manager, or pd trainer on any vehicle they believe should be totaled notwithstanding the fact that the economic analysis indicates otherwise. *** Sept 2003 Document Imaging Service Center has added this page to your original document to alert you of special circumstances regarding your document. PLACARD This is to notify you that the following page(s) are: Black/White Photos Original RECEIVED is a Photo Copy of; Check-(! itle - Certificate f Registration This is to notify you that the following item(s) were removed from this document: Non-Scanned Item- SENT INTEROFFICE Description: Nan-Scanned Item- NOT SENT INTEROFFICE Description: Diskette or, CD ROM - SENT INTEROFFICE Video - SENT INTEROFFICE Audio Recording -NOT SENT INTEROFFICE Revision 4/2005 ` T OF PENNS IA. FIS:?-I AND BOAT' C ?, .. 7s' OF TrrLE TO A.-B h ?•.. .:•i is •.. -- ?ti ., ? • ??`St. a ? EDWIN C ULLOM AND ?? ' '+;.ra : j JAN INE R ULL014 JTROS ^s 4423 AVON DR HARRISBURG PA 17112-1504 k?ir'r f • ?`'?:' Sie REVE M SUM POP. LEGk?ID) :q,? t:• 1999 3' Tr .7 Lar• Tub ar m& t .•. • :YA' ?. ?? -. s - - HUT B .?. _+ .. .? ?•:? .? IJ•atfA?Jmo ?• [ Hal • t. ;?'1 - -y _- _ .. .•a+y.? . Vie, ? Z ??• r • Haim ?>dft S?1.1 Nansbr «, ?• ? •?a ? _ - - - -- _ .his.- ' yq , a' • . a(** Aug sea. . _ , . ? .. ? j ?•• ? Medea . '" =1bi!!mt!71wda Fdl eoA Dw? C.? --. r -•? w:aw 3 .+ ? ? :?' . "^'?. S• .rem' - .?li/i`T a?`: ?'- - - - - -....._-- --?".??it'?i,? .• - .L•A ,•: • A .4 s ti iE • A - '? it ? = ",i .s AN, ?age: 1 Document.Name: untitled CMSD2340 /CMSM2340 Pik C M A N JAN 04 05 - 16:57 OPID: DC40012 CLAIM PAYMENT INQUIRY TERMID: VT690707 ;INSD: ULLOM, EDWIN C _ POL:-42360716-0_ ' DOL SEP- 18 ' 04- - PA-MECRAN-BRN-.- -== +=-M- =--043847.062•* ACTIVE =REP:.:: A r DOLI;MAN PAY TO THE ORDER OF: TOTAL DRAFT AMOUNT: 19,500.00 LINE 1: EDWIN C ULLOM, ONLY***************************************** LINE 2: , LINE 3: ADDRESS: 4423 AVON DRIVE CITY: HARRISBURG ST/PR*.•.PA: ZIP/CPC:- 17112-1:.-.,•_ CNTRY*. U; ..OF: COLL,: T/.L TO 99= PAYMENT BOAT,: PROD _ OBTAINS SALVAGE , i699 - '?- "N- FEDERAL' TAX ID: LAST: LJPDT--. REP:. -'APD0003 mS. .CODE =* ° 12- PCL - _ --.; A•'DO? SS.3ING -REP EFT T-RACE= -; - • : : . _ _ .: . :: _ _ _ , _ _ -. - iii ? = ::' ?: CODE* AS2 BANK- ISSUE DATE .. .. ? .. .... Q4.=:`APPRQVEI).BY:c M. OCT:-14; . . ?3'TATE' ?,.*• -PA=: " AREB?: * •252 RMEW -DATE STOP RSN * . DRAFT # 4365-21J61- REVIEWED- -BY : , _ ?• ?'? If ??w . i-?^i - ? 1 - :• ? ' -L1S ? { ' • t • ? L? ?* F + - • ? .. _ - _ _ s .: ': ... . . - L ? -I wS:: r- . .. . +._ r ' . i..•r ? - s.:+Rkw ?• 4 ;Ti f' - .i.: 1_~ . •?t M\i• ?i':•.1. - . _.. _ .•7 ?A? • - - • _ .. ..+ - ? w?l.,^ t-• • ?•?«1-.lT?? rC.• ?4.: :?. - •• - .. - .?f... ;.• -1i+•v_• ?•ri' ~.?- t • _ ... '1y'??s1.S „"•, r!i.i/?: :.?f.OR l:;'?r. (•16r•-i -i.:r • - •7 . - ? .:-i . -b.L'a:r.::= n•+c' - '_,•_-, - d:• '°. ;': y?•-•:",•i•-^:•-_.!•• s.S.:!^?-.a' ec_:: ._?.r ter:: •: ?]?-'•• •.• ? ,?/f7, r -. ?.: _..:.??? - . •?M..t ?I-?- .N..?..w-rw? • y 'j.' -• - w' : r ' L•1' A??' * ? ? .: _ r ..•?• - - ._ - .. _ .. . ? . • Tr w : ? .K i-i _. _ _ .-. '_'?'••. ?. - .-._ r , .yam - _. gate: 01/04/2005 Time: 04:57:47 PM - • VERIFICATION I, Michael J. Dougherty, Esquire, attorney for the Plaintiff(s) do hereby swear and affirm that the averments in the attached Complaint are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and/or belief.. These averments are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S.A. §4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. - -.Mi ael ou rty - ...: ._ Date - - .j: •?j ?. ?==?=`= -• _:-?.:..:.:= .: -- =??=ire=?;_. _.. --,-- ? ?.. - •.. :. - - .... ?. - s._ - -. .•? •a-•. r -??7:-:?-:•.. __ :?yy,;.il'-?.?.. ??..n.• _j.:?.:w::-?.:: •'. .y-r.: ?:i??•il.-.-. -•v ? ..?1.'??.: i.. .. - ?.. _. r . ?.X?'?bit B qTO r. rot gloa iGl IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNIx PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN r---3 l-? cn INSURANCE COMPANY CASE NO: 05-2264 Subrogee of Edwin Ullom : TYPE OF PLEADING: Plaintiff, ANSWER TO COMPLAINT HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE FILED ON BEHALF OF SEAPLANE BASE DEFENDANT MARINE PROPERTIES, INC. d/b/a/ HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE (improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc.) Defendant COUNSEL OF RECORD OF OF THIS PARTY: JAMES W. JOHNSON, ESQUIRE JOSETTE F. SPIVAK ESQUIRE PA ID# 23319 / 82356 HOLLSTEIN, KEATING, CATTELL, JOHNSON & GOLDSTEIN, P.C. 1628 JOHN F. KENNEDY BLVD. SUITE 2000 PHILADELPHIA, PA 19103 215-320-3260 ANSWER TO COMPLAINT WITH NEW MATTER Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc., by and through its counsel Hollstein, Keating, Cattell, Johnson and Goldstein, P.C. responds to Plaintiff's Complaint and avers as follows: `f7 n Iii t"J ?7 --i (10247"00088:TN4545 ) I . Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks sufficient information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefore same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. 2. Denied in part, admitted in part. It is denied that Harris Marine, Inc. is a business organization licensed and authorized to conduct business in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Marine Properties, Inc., improperly plead as Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, is a Pennsylvania corporation. It is admitted that 333 South Front Street, Wormleysburg, PA is the place of business of Marine Properties, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base. 3. Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks sufficient information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefore same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. 4. Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks sufficient information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefore same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. 5. Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks sufficient information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefore same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded al. trial if deemed material thereto. b. Denied. Answering Defendant specifically denies it was negligent or careless in its care of the boat. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks sufficient { 10247.00088:'CN4545 } information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefore same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. 7. Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks sufficient information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefore same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. 8. Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks sufficient information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefore same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. 9. Denied. This paragraph states a conclusion of law to which no response is required. 10. Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks sufficient information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefore same are denied with strict proof thereof demanded at trial if deemed material thereto. 11. There is no paragraph 11. 12. Denied. Despite reasonable investigation answering Defendant lacks sufficient information to admit or deny the remaining averments of this paragraph, and therefore same is denied with strict proof thereof demanded al. trial if deemed material thereto. (I0247.00088:TN4545) WHEREFORE, Answering Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc., respectfully requests judgment in its favor and against Plaintiff, together with the award of costs and attorney fees. NENV MATTER 1. Plaintiff's claim is barred by the common law defense of act of God. 2. This Complaint fails to set forth a cause of action for which relief may be granted. 3. This Court lacks jurisdiction of the persons of Defendant Harris Marine, Inc. 4. Answering Defendant violated no legal duty to Plaintiff. 5. The action is barred by the applicable Statute of Limitations. 6. The plaintiff was guilty of the sole negligence which was the proximate cause of damages complained of. 7. The plaintiff was guilty of contributory negligence. 8. The plaintiff was guilty of comparative negligence of a greater degree that the negligence of the defendant, which negligence is denied. 9. The alleged damages sustained by the plaintiff are the proximate result of the acts and/or omissions of parties over which defendants exercised no control. 10. Plaintiff is not the real party in interest. (10247.00088:TN4545 ) 11. Plaintiff lacks standing to bring this action. 12. Answering Defendant incorporates by reference the terms of the Dockage Lease Agreement, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "A", including, but not limited to Paragraph 10 which states: "Lessor is not responsible for any damage or loss caused by changes in water levels, storms, floods, vandalism, or other events beyond the control of the Lessor," and asserts same in defense of the action. 13. Answering Defendant incorporates by reference the terms of the Dockage Lease Agreement, including, but not limited to, Paragraph 12 which states: "Dockage of said vessel is at the risk of the Lessee and the Lessee expressly waives any claims or causes of action against the Lessor on account of damage or loss regardless of how caused. It is understood between the parties that this instrument is not a bailment or contract of wharfage," and asserts same in defense of the action. Exhibit "A." 14. Plaintiff's claim is barred by the terms, limitations and conditions set forth in the agreement. 15. Answering Defendant reserves the right to supplement its New Matter as indicated during discovery. (10247.GW88:TN4545 ) WHEREFORE, Answering Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc., respectfully requests judgment in its favor and against Plaintiff, together with the award of costs and attorney fees. HOLLSTEIN KEATING CATTELL JOHNSON & GOLDST,EIN, P.C. By: 4. James W. J son, Esquire PA I.D. 3319 Josette F. Spivak, Esquire PA I.D. # 82356 1628 John F. Kennedy Blvd. Suite 2000 Philadelphia, PA 19103 215-320-3260 ( t 0247.00088:TN4545 ) CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Josette F. Spivak, Esquire do hereby certify that a copy of Defendant's Answer to the Complaint with New Matter was served on January 19, 2006, via U.S. first class mail upon the following: Michael J. Dougherty, Esquire Weltman, Weinberg & Reis Co. 325 Chestnut Street, Suite 1120 Philadelphia, PA 19106 Josette F. Spi , Esquire J { 10247.00088:TN4547) 4 i VA004/029 r V'149- 1 . - - - WORMLEYSBURG RIVERSIDE MAY 15 THRL' OCT. 1. 2004 MAY 31 THRU OCT. 1, 2004 DOCKAGE LEASE AGREEMENT CITY ISLAND_X MAY I THRU OCT. 15, 2004 All information must be filled out and lease must be signed or no slip will be given. Anyone caught in a slip without a signed lease, the boat x;rill be pulled and you will not be allowed back in. This agreement made between B & B Holdings; Inc. and Harrisburg Seaplane Base hereinafter called Lessor, and named Lessee ??u?,•h e- Mf?aZ22 Home Phone 6 5 =; - X01 AAVork Phone 19? -vv-,/F Emergency Phone ,/ y.f - 415r3s Address -1 41.2 1, r HlLti":'S Boat Registration# Boat Make Boat Year /y? Length ,, ' Engine HP Engine Year Engine Modeli Jet Ski Make Jet Ski Registration #_ Providing for the rental of dock space for the berthing of a boat owned by the Lessee for the 2004 docking season commencing on or about the specified date at the top of this contract, depending on weather and river conditions. If boat is in the marina after the lease termination date, Lessee will be billed $10.00 per day as additional rental. Lessee agrees to pay unto the Lessor inconsideration of the dock space furnished, the total sum $ kj c,,v SLIP NUMBER - / 1. Lessor agrees to furnish space at its docks for berthing of the above vessel. 2. Lessor shall retain the right to designate dock space. 1 All dock space rent shall be payable in advance. 4. Lessee agrees not to sell, transfer, assign or permit the use of his/her assigned dock space. Lessee warrants that he/she is the owner of the above-described boat. This contract becomes null and void if Lessee sells his/her vessel. We will not guarantee your spot to the new owners. 5. Lessee can only dock said vessel that is on this agreement. No other boat or PWC is permitted to be tied to vessel. 6. Lessee agrees to maintain his/her vessel in a safe and seaworthy condition, procure and keep in Force the policy of Marine Insurance providing adequate coverage for hull protection and Indemnity; to moor and secure the vessel properly with a minimum of 3/8" nylon line, and to Operate the vessel, when in the vicinity of Lessor's docks and marina, in a competent and careful manner, avoiding wakes and damage to the docks or other vessels. If Lessor has to change any lines on your boat to meet the minimum standard in this contract, Lessee will be billed accordingly. 7. Lessee may work on his/her vessel in the marina as long as such work does not interfere with the rights or the right of way of other Lessees or the operation of the marina as long as the work is performed by the Lessee himself/herself. No work may be done by an outside contractor without written permission from the Lessor. 8. All pets shall be on a secured leash when at the marina. Further, it is the pet owner's obligation and responsibility to clean up immediately and dispose of excrement of his/her pet as may occur on the Lessors property (including docks). 9. In an emergency situation, Lessor shall be permitted to move Lessee's boat. Lessee will be billed at the Lessor's prevailing rate for the services. 10. Lessor is not responsible for any damage or loss caused by changes in water levels, storms, floods, vandalism, or other events beyond the control of the Lessor. No refunds will be given on dock space under any circumstances. 1 l . Water skiing or swimming from the dock or in the marina is expressly prohibited. Fire torches or such are prohibited also. 12. Dockage of said vessel is at the risk of. the Lessee and the Lessee expressly waives any claims or causes of action against the Lessor on account of damage or loss regardless of how caused. It is understood between the-'pa'rties that this instrument is not a bailment or contract of wharfage. 13. No vessel shall be advertised for sale in the marina. 14. Lessee must display issued parking permit on vehicle when on marina property. Due to space limitation, only one vehicle per boat is allowed in Marina. One Primary Permit per vessel/ household will be issued. No trailers are permitted on parking lot 15. Lessor reserves the right to exclude those whose actions arepffensive/o others. Lessor, BM3 H din , nc. and Harrisburg Lessee Seaplane Base DATE:/ Sfn DATE. EXHIBIT ?n?b?+c D ? J IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY,- Subrogee of James Ford d2a{? ?- L-7 4 CASE NO: - :v. OF PLEADING: . :COMPLAINT IN CWM AC'I'ION_ HARRIS MARINE, INC., d!b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE Defendants. FILED ON BEHALF OF: Plaintiff' COUNSEL QF RECORD OF :- THIS PARTY: MICHAEL J. DOUGHERTY, ESQUIRE Pa. I.D. #76046 WELTMAN, WEINBERG & REIS CO., L.P.A. 325 Chestnut Street Suits 1120 Philadelphia, PA 19106 (215) 599-1500 WWR #04276307 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA ?CIM DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogee of James Ford. Plaintiff, V. HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE CASE NO: TYPE OF PLEADING: COMPLAINT IN CIVEL ACTION _ Defendants.". NOTICE TO DEFEND NOTICE AVISO- YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to LE HAN DEMANDADO A USTED EN LA - defend against the claim set forth in the following pages, CORTE. Si usted quiere defenderse de estas you must take action within twenty (20) days.after.dh ;j-..- demanddeas expuestas en In paginas siguientes, complaint and Notice are served, by entering a wri?tert usted tiene veinte (20) dins de plazo al partir de la _ appearance personally or by an attorney in filii g'fi fecba dela demanda y la notification. Hace falta writing with the Court your defenses or objections to asentar una comparencia escrita o en persona o con,- the claims set forth against you. You•a_ re warned that un abogado y entregar a la torte en forma escrita. to if you fail to do so the case way proceed without-yod-ijid' : sds defensas-a sus objeciones a las demandas en - a judgment may be entered against you by the Court : _ contra de su persona. Sea avisado que si usted no .... ., without further notice for money claimed in the Complaint se defiende, la torte tomara medidas y puede or for any other claim or relief requested by the continuar l &nkuida en contra suya sin previo plaintiff. You may lose money or property or otlier aviso o notificacion. Ademas, la torte puede _ rights important to you. _ decidir a favor del deumdante y requiere que usted _ ci xVla con todas las provisions de esta demaada. usted puede. perder dinero o sus propiedadas u otros drechos itnportantes para usted. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO To OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP: LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO INMEDIATAMEWA. SI NO TMNE ABOGADO O SINO THWE EL DINERO SUFFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICO, VAYA EN PERSONA O LLAME FOR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DIRECCION SE ENCUENTR.A ESCRITA ADAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEGAL. LAWYER REFERRAL SERVICE CUMBERLAND COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION 32 SOUTH BEDFORD STREET CARLISLE, PA 17013 (717) 249-3166 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogee of James Ford CASE NO: Plaintiff, V. HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE TYPE OF PLEADING: = COM PLAINT IN CIVIC. ACTION _ :- Defendants. ::. COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION AIVD ' COMES, Plaintiff-15y-and hugh its -counsel, WELTMAN, WEINBERG . &-IZEIS;•?C0_ :NOW arid,hcreby files this Coriiplaint'agairis 'Defendants jointly. and severally. In support thereof,,. Plaintiff aavcrs--- • ?, C-t-:i:i?7 .?t??_ `:-? ._,:.=' %-.,i?F`i::::G.:";` .: `.: .:?:::_.:::= •d•::L"i^_? 3!' .-'': •_ '_C?: ?'.:.ae: ' •.. •e'--. .. _....-._.• •. ._ ?, Progressive a Northern-_ Insurance. _Company.: •Progressive"),. is a corporation_ with' a -:l•; :Flanitiff,: .a _ 't t' registcied office located at P.O. Box 4325 8, Richmond Heights, Ohio. - 2. befe' d&nt, Harris Marina Inc., doing' business'--as'-Harrisburg Seaplane Base, is a business - - organization licensed and authorized to conduct business in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and having as one of its places of business 333 South Front Street, NVormleysburg, Pennsylvania 17043. 3. Progressive issued a policy of insurance where Progressive agreed to insure a 2000 Starcraft Pontoon Boat ("Insured Boat'j, owned by Plaintiff s insured. 4. On or about September 11, 2004 the Plaintiff Insured's boat was stored at Defendant's place of business and was at all times under the care, custody and/or control of Defendant. 5. While the Plaintiff Insured's boat was under the care, custody and/or control of Defendant, the Plaintiff' Insured's boat was caused to be damaged. 6. Defendant is liable to Plaintiff for all damages sustained to the Plaintiff Insured's boat due to Defendant's negligence and/or carelessness which consisted, inter alia, of: failing to have the boat properly secured; failing to take proper precautions to ensure the safety of the boat; failing to take proper precautions to ensure the safety of the boat based on *the weather conditions which Defendant knew or should have known were occurring or were about to occur, failing to place the boat at a safe location under the circumstances; and, failing to act reasonably in the securing and protecting the boat- 7. As a direct- and proximate result of Defendant's negligence, the Progressive's Insured boat - sustained property damage in the amount of $2,723.09. - F ` .. 8. Pursuant to the terms and conditions of the insurance policy, Progressive paid the sum of $2;473.09: A true and correct copy of the payment and damage documentation is attached hereto and .marred Exhibit "1 addition, :the Plaintiff's -Insured also sustained damages in the amount of $250.00 rep-resenting his deductible. • 10. Pursuant to the insurance policy issued by Progressive and as a result of said aforesaid payment, ; ?.. Progressive became.subrogated to the.elaim of its Insured against Defendant: 11. Pursuant to Progressive's right of subrogation, Progressive, is presently due and owed Arom Defendant thc'sum of $2,723.09. = _.,..-;; • :t,:.: ,:-- 12. ' Repeated demands have been made upon Defendants for payment of the aforesaid sum; however, Defendants have willfully failed and refused to pay the sum due and owing to Progressive. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands Judgrnent against Defendant in the amount of $2,723.09 plus interest and costs. THIS IS AN ATTEMPT TO COLLECT A DEBT AND ANY INFORMATION OBTAMED SHALL BE USED FOR THAT PURPOSE. Respectfully Submitted::: j 'wELTMAN, ERG & REIS, CO., L.P.A. J: Dougherty, Esquire - PA LD. # 76046 325 Chestnut Street _ Suite 1120 A. Philadelphia---PA -19106 (215) 599-1500 "'''. _. :.. ,:.-. - _ _........:;. : ?+..•. -_ -WWR#04276307.-;x--;• 7-1 :. E t0i08a0p41 DOW. 04.386-16094 Eslmc?te I' 0 r:sttmate version • Date: 10/08/2004 12. Estimate IM 043867609-01 Estimate Version: 0 Committed Profile ID: CUSTOMIZED Progressive Insurance 5053 Ritter Road Suite 101 Mechanicsburg. PA 17055 (717) 791-5178 Fan: (717) 697-6711 Damage Assessed By: LICENSESV3265 ANDREW DOLLMAN Claim Rep: ANDREW DOLLMAN `<{:• ? (717) 791 5178 Product Type Boat Date of Loss: 0911112am4 _rr Deductible:"-- 250.00" ' -Policy No: 41567436-001 Claim Number: 04-3867609-01 insured: JAMES FORD- Address:: 409 SYLVAN STREET MARYSVILLE, PA 17053 - - ?. Telephony " Work Phone: (717) 834-3515 Home Phone: (717) 957-2458 ,::,_ -• . Mitchell Service: 911000 Description: 00 STARCRAFT PONTOON BOAT Vehicle Production Date: 00100 VIN: STR50699K900 OEMIALT. A Search Code: MECHANICSI Color. BLUE)TAN • _ ": ?':•5?:3 .,. _ -- mac'-7+. Une Entry Labor Line iter6 Part Type/ Dollar Labor Item Number Type Operation Description - Part Number Amount Units 1 900300- MCH• " REMOVEIREPLACE REPLACE LEFT REAR"FENCE New - 9M.90'- . 1.0' •- •::.• 2 900500 MCH'. REMOVE)REPLACE: - REPLACE RIGHT REAR FENCE New s 38340 ' 0.5- 3 900500 MCH'•-. REMOVE&EPLACE REPLACE LEFT FRONT FENCE Now 1.0' : - 4-. 900500 MCH' REMOVEIREPLACE INSTALL DECALS ON ENTIRE BOAT New 58.00 * 3.0' S SHIPPING PRICE INCLUDED IN PARTS PRICES 8- CRATE CHARGE ALSO INCLUDED IN PARTS PRICES 7 900500 MCH' REMOVIVREPLACE REPLACE MAXXIMA DOCKING LIGHTS New 36.85 ` 0.0' 8 WWW.PARTSSYSTEMS.COM 9 900500 MCH' REPAIR REPAIR RIGHT PONTOON Existing 1.5' ` - Judgement Item AdcM Labor Sublet bor Subtotals Units Rate Amount Amount Mechanical 7.0 65.00 0.00 0.00 Taxable Labor Labor Tax @ 6.000% Total* K Part Replacement Summary 435.00 T Taxable Parts Sales Tax 455.00 27.30 Total Replacement Parts Amount Amount 2.113.95 6.000% 126.84 2,240.79 r Summary 7.0 482.30 rE RECALL NUMBER: 10108)'200412:42:02 04-3867609-01 UltraMate Is a Trams .. ?aster?°u A?,man tan m •; clacastemo int'1r`8d ne p8:50 AO 1010?04A potima?Q?C?s?e.com To. drew P_ CC arits Sutie ,Ct - the for PTicing of the Ady breaXdown pa'?ts • . 44.90 9 have - $ ar fence re _ $38340 ieces Left ?portl face • 1Q cement P ing - 2., Ri9ht r iad3e Fence $ 0 , g05- a a g0 and other reel and guested ghipp 3 . Ryght f;ont fence ht front f,ene ndes °;sting 4. Left l klt for rig The emote inol 5 DeCa rra plug tax • : ?: . 4.4 The ve' 1te .._? .. _ .... . s _ cost8:s. _ ....: .. - - -. Dale Marine. Ccunty 2,12 . '7503 21 59-13. C www • lancagt - • . -Wf r Page: 1 Document Name: untitled CMSD2340 /CMSM2340 P A C M A N MAR 04 05 - 12:42 OPID: JES0018 CLAIM PAYMENT INQUIRY TERMID: VT650190 INSD: FORD, JAMES G -II-: POL:..41567436-1 DOL i- SEP 11 04 PA-MECHAN--BRN- CLM: 043867609 ACTIVE REP:--A DOLLMAN PAY TO THE ORDER OF: TOTAL DRAFT AMOUNT: 2,473.09 LINE 1: JAMES G FORD II, ONLY**?*****************'***** ************ LINE 2: LINE 3: ADDRESS: 408 SYLVAN STREET -CITY:' MARYSVILLE ST/PR* PA ZIP/CPC: 17053. :.-.-CNTRY* U ' IN PAYMENT OF:- CALL DMG TO 00 STARCR.AFT,. LESS $250 DEDUCTIBLE' 1099 ? N FEDERAL TAX ID: LAST UPDT REP: APD0003 3 7 CDS CODE * 12 PCL EFT TRACE #: ISSUING REP : ' A DOLLMAt! --, ;. - BANK CODE * - AS 2 ISSUE DATE OCT 0 8 0 4 -APPROVED BY : - : t :- - ?- = •- _ . STATE * PA AREA * 2 52 - REVIEW DATE _ ' 0 0 - 0 0 STOP RSN-* DRAFT # 436399936 REVIEWED BY: "COMMAND : - - '_ -'= - - ?'--' Date: 03/04/2005 Time: 12:42:27 PM s VERIFICATION L Michael J. Dougherty, Esquire, attorney for the Plaintiff(s) do hereby swear and affirm that the averments in the attached Complaint are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and/or belief: These averments are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S.A. §4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. _fA - =Date Michael . Dou - erty IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogcc of Raymond C. Santana, Jr. V - -.-? . CASE NO: . Plaintiff, V_ TYPE OF PLEADING: _COWLA_ INT IN CIVEL ACTION HARRIS MAri Nt, INC., d/b/a :.. _ . HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE - - : T Defendants... _ FILED ON BEHALF OF: _ .. 1: - . Plaintiff _ :. ' - •_ COUNSEL*OF RECORD OF " - THIS PARTY: MICHAEL J. DOUGHERTY, ESQUIRE Pa: I.D. #76046 WELTMAN, WEINBERG & REIS CO., L.P.A. 325 Chestnut Street Suite 1120 Philadelphia, PA 19106 (215) 599-1500 WWR #04179550 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogee of Raymond C. Santana, Jr. CASE NO: Plaintiff, V. TYPE OF PLEADING: ' COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION.- HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE Defendants..- NU'TICE TO DEFEND NOTICE AVISO .. . - :: - YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish it -LE IRAN DEMANDADO A USTED EN LA defend against the claim set forth in the following pages, CORTE. Si usted quiere defenderse de estas - - You must take action within twenty (20) days after-this. demanadeas expuestas cn las pagai w siguientes, complaint and Notice are served, by entering a wiiitca ?... usted tienc veintc (20) dias de plazo al partir de la appearance personally or by an attorney' in filing in --, fecha dela-demanda y 1a notificaeion. Race falls'.'. writing with the Court your defenses or dtijectiohs to - asentar nna compareneia escrita o en persona o con.: to the claims set forth against-you. -You a :warned that :_ . un abogsdo _y_cnt nar a In. torte en forma escrita if you fail to do so the case may proceed;withouf you-arid sirs defenses o sus objecioner alas demandas en a judgment maybe entered against you by d16 Court . • - - contra de su persona. Sea avisado que si usted no _ : without further notice for money claimed in the Complaint se defiende, la eorte tomara medidas y puede or for any other claim or relief requested by the_ = continnai la dcmanda ca'contra suya sin previo plaintiff. You may lose money or property or othd aviso o notification. Ademas, la torte puedc :. . , rights important to you. .. decidir a favor del demandante y requiere que usted , - cunWla con todas Ins provisioner de esta demanda. usted puede perder dinero o sus propiedadas u otros drechos irrrportantes pare usted. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORn[ BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP: LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO I MEDIATAN ENTA. SI NO TIENE ABOGADO O SINO TIENE EL DINERO SUFFICIE TTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICO, VAYA IN PERSONA O LLAME FOR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DIRECCION SE ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ADAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEGAL. LAWYER REFERRAL SERVICE CLINSERLAND COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION 32 SOUTH BEDFORD STREET CARLISLE, PA 17013 (717) 249-3166 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogee of Raymond C. Santana, Jr. CASE NO: Plaintiff, V. TYPE OF PLEADING: `- •_ :'- .' ' COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE • _ _ .:.._ .... -?.. - - . - . ' ? Defendants: - _ . ' - .. ' - : . . - --- -~ J COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION - AND' NUW'f:OMES, Plaintiff by'and'througli its courisel;:.WELTMAN,_ WEINB* RG '& REISf,%;. L.P..; aiideretiy ;files this Coriip7airit against I)cfeiidants jointly. and severally. In support thereof,. Plaintiff avers: - ; as follows-; f yeti ?:?•; :i' _ _ :i_y ^?t:? L - :.. _. Ott .- _ _ :i:Y?t ..'.•?+a:.:? ?". :;i. r.?_.. i. .?"w?r•;7???:t'.?`•.••• __.n __YJ=v?.t ?. _' ••. ?'•?.T..._,.t? ... .. •:e:t.:f ?7??•- _ ... _. - '?' •r?r_... -?1:r ?_aK:Plaintiff;= Progreasi, e:.Noithem=_Insurance- Company-: (`.'Progressive");' is. a corporafion;_vin = registir ddoffiee located at-P.O. Box 4325% Ricbnwnd•Heights; Ohio. - - 2. Defendant,--Harris' 14416nt,' Inc., 'doing- itsiriess ' as Harrisburg Seaplane Base, is a - -business- •_ = • organization licensed and authorized to conduct business in. the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and having as one of its places of business 333 South Front Street, Worinleysburg, Pennsylvania 17043. 3. Progressive issued a policy of insurance where Progressive agreed to insure a 2000 Lowe Malibu 200 ("Insured Boat'), owned by Plaintiff s insured. 4. On or about September 18, 2004 the Plaintiff Insured's boat was stored at Defendant's place of business and was at all times under the care, custody and/or control of Defendant. 5. While the Plaintiff' Insured's boat was under the care, custody and/or control of Defendant, the Plaintiff Insured's boat was caused to be damage3. b. Defendant is liable to Plaintiff for all damages sustained to the Plaintiff Insured's boat due to Defendant's negligence and/or carelessness whichi consisted, inter alia, of: failing to have the boat properly secured; failing to take proper precautions to ensure the safety of the boat; failing to take proper precautions to ensure the safety of the boat based on the weather conditions which Defendant knew or should have known were occurring or. were about to occur; failing to place the boat at a safe location under the circumstances; and, failing to act reasonably in the securing and protecting the boat. 7. As ' a - direct and proximate result - of - Defendant's negligence, the Progressive's Insured boat :.. sustained property damage in the amount of $2,158.14. - - - 8. Pursuant to the terms and conditions of the insurance policy, Progressive paid the sum of 51,658.14. A true-and correct copy of the payment and damage documentation is attached hereto and.x ked as . . Exhibit "Ito. 9,-- -•. In additionAhe.Plaintiffs. Insured also sustained damages in the amount of $500.00 representing- _ ?•.4' .?.. ~• ,tee' ._ .:• _.. - ...,•. ...:.. ..._.. _ .. .. •`.?_.. _.._ _ .. ..__.. _i: •. -_-- ! _1 .'i:t _ ..._. -his deductibk_ _ _... _ .. _ _ :. =.: • _" • -- Lam: 21 _ ... • .si.'.l:__-. V?:.:.::?.••J-_::. •.: •' .:.. ,.d; .t'_. I:.:_:_._• _ ..; ••?? -_'. •: -•.r. .? .:--. ??'.. t:•: '. _-_ --• - .: ?:..:",. ?- 10._:_.. - Pursuant to the insurance, policy. issued by Progressive and as a result of said -aforesaid payme t, ` ,_ . • . -- r,:: i ; ;•;?Progressive became subrogated to the claim of it_rAnsured against Defendant: :. •- - =1'1: Pursuant tol. Progressive's -right -of subrogation, Progressive is :pn tly ;due and owed ;from: ,`t* Defendaiit-thc'sum"of 51158:_14. 12. Repeated demands have been made upon Defendants for payment of the aforesaid sum; however, Defendants have willfully failed and refused to pay the sum due and owing to Progressive. _ WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands Judgment against Defendant in the amount of $2,158.14 plus interest and costs. . . THIS IS AN ATTEMPT TO COLLECT A DEBT AND ANY INFORMATION OBTAINED SHALL BE USED FOR THAT PURPOSE. Respectfully Submitted: `VELTMAN, WE[N G & REIS, CO., L.P•A. Michael ughcrty; Esquire . •::. PA 1. 76046 .... r . = = -... 3 estnat Street ; cite 1120:-. - Philadelphia;-PA=-1.9106 (215) 599-1500 • -> +. _,._ .._ -.._ ;.:: : - __._ ....__.?_.. -WWR#04179550:.•, ...w-- •- .• . - . • . ?? .. ;? ?. ir"L: _..?.._?. •' ._ .. --- ems.. .- - ??`? ..... ... .. .. _ __ -.'....-_____• ---. _.? ^-`. .. .. .. ._..._?:.. , .i: L_ .?. ....i 4?w 1i ii. -,. - -.-? •"--- _ - - - - ". _' ;'i. ... :4'i :?=_.-.' - :?:.wt'?':•. ?c'- .-? :a _?:rl:;•?-._ _ --:aft.: s.- 1 El ff 11 Date: 11117!2004 02:21 PM Estimate ID: 043907050-01 Estimate Version-. 0 Committed Profile ID: CUSTOMIZED poose?asmE 3053 RITTER ROAD SUITE 101 MECHANICSBURG. PA 17055 (717) 791-5178 Fax: (717) 697-6711 Damage Assessed By. LICENSE#273265 ANDREW DOLL MAN Claim Rep: ANDREW DOLLMAN (717) 791-5178 "Product Type Boat Date at Loss: 091t87004 • Deductible: 500.00 _ Policy No: 39039012-002 'Claim Number: 043907050-01 insured: RAYMOND SANTANNA Address: 102 THISTLETOWN DR.IiUMMELSTOWN* IDA 17036 Telephone: Work Phone: {717j 238-832fi Horne Phone: (717) 566-2571 Mitchell Service: 911000 Description: 00 LOWE MALIBU 200 VWde Production Date: 00100 VIN: OMCS63361900 OEWALT: A Search Code: MECHANICSI Color. BLUE Line Entry Labor Line Item Part Type! Item Number Type Operation Description Part Number MANUAL ENTRIES 1 900500 MCH' REPAIR" - PORT PONTOON Existing 2 900500 MCH' REPAIR STARBOARD PONTOON Existing 3 900500 MCH• REPAIR REPLACE PORT REAR FENCE New 4 900500 MCH' - REPAIR ` REPLACE PORT FRONT FENCE - Flew. - _- 5 W0500 MCH' - REPAIR REPLACE STAR86ARD REAR CORNER New 6 900500 MCH• REPAIR - REPLACE MOORING COVER. New - 7 AMERICAN CANVAS 419-382-8450 8 900500 MCH' REPAIR REPLACE ENGINE COWL New 9 JIM'S ANCHORAGE 814-658.3464 10 900500 MCH' REPAIR REPLACE NAVY STYLE ANCHOR (2) New 11 BASS PRO SHOPS 28 LBS_ 12 900500 MCH' REPAIR FREIGHT AND PROP Existing 13 900500 MCH' REPAIR PRICE HANDLED AS SUPPLEMENT Existing - Judgement Item ESTIMATE RECALL NUMBER: 11117120041421:23 04-3907050-01 Ultr"te is a Trademark of Mitchell lntemallonai Mitchell Data Version: OCTI04 A Copyright (C) 1994 - 2004 Utdwil International UltraMate Version: 5.5.008 All Rights Reserved Dollar Labor Amount -= Units 1 A• 173.00 - 2.'`'=or - `409:29' ' 0.0'• ??=` 570.09' _ 0.5• 69.98 ' 0.0' 0.0• 00 Page 1 of 4 Date. 1111 MOW 02:21 PM Estimate ID: 04-3907050-01 Estimate Version: 0 Committed Profile ID: CUSTOMIZED ** PART TYPE TERMS AND ABBREVIATIONS ** . NEW OR OEM OR-PARTv NUMBER DISPLkYED--THESE REFER TO A NEW ORIGINAL EQUIPMENT MANUFACTURER PART. NON-OEM, A/M AND QUAL REPL--THESE REFER " TO AN AFTERMARKET PART, WHICH IS A NEW, NON-ORIGINAL EQUIPMENT MANUFACTURER PART. USED/RECYCLED AND LKQ--THESE REFER TO A USED/RECYCLED OEM PARTS THAT HAVE BEEN REFURBISHED. BDY=BODY, BDS=BODY STRUCTURE, REF=REFINISH, GLS=GLASS, FRM=FRAME,MCH=MECHANICAL, ADD'L C ST=ADDITIONAL COST, ADD'L OPR--ADDITIONAL OPERATION, FRT=FRONT, RR=REAR, L=LEFT, R=RIGHT, UPR=UPPER, LWR =LOWER, OTR--OUTER, INR=INNER, ASSY=ASSEMBLY, SUSP=SUSPENSION, EXT=EXTENSION, BRK=BRACKET, INST INSTRUMENT, ATG=ASSEMBLY TIME- GUIDE . Addl Labor Subket - -- :1. tabor Subbi als _ : Un is :: f Rata- : Arnount Arnormt Totals Mechanical 5.7 65.00 0.00 0.00 370-50 T Taxable tabor 370.50 tabor Tex @ 6.000% 2223 -- -- labor Summary 5.7 Ili. Additional Costs Total Additional Costs _ .C•5...:ice-.... ._.. ?-, _ _ ___r_ 11. Part Replacement Summary Amount -Taxable Parts ?:?_------ 1,665A Sales Tax 6.000%--c'., 99.9 Total Replacement Parts Amount 'r 1,765.4 39273 u n t A no IV. Adjustments Amount / y ? O.DO - Insurance Deducb'We ' Customer Responsibility --'500.0 -.st 1. Total Labor - . = • -.:.. - :._ :_392:7 • = ' 11. Tdcd Replacer rent parts:: -. • ._ ,„ t:7S.? 4 111. Total'AtldiSlonal 0sts: '• •.. O.t? rose Total: C 2158.1 _ • IV. Total-Adjustments: 500.0 Net;Total:. _ :1:658A Inspection Site: CITY ISLAND HARRISBURG. PA inspection Dane: 10/20/2004 ESTIMATE RECALL NUMBER: 11117,2004 1421:23 04-3907050-01 UltraMate is a Trademark of Mitchell International Mltdhell Data Version: OCT 04 A Copyrot (C) 1994 - 2004 Mitchell International UltraMate Version: 5.5.008 All Rights Reserved Page 2 of 4 Date: Estimate lD: Estimate Version: Committed Profile ID: 191172004 02:21 PM 04-3907050-01 0 CUSTOMIZED THE VEHICLE OWNER MAY BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ADDITIONAL COST ABOVE THE -APPRAISED AMOUNT. • 'THERE: IS NO. -REQUIREMENT--TO- USE A SPECIFIC REPAIR SHOP, HOWEVER, THE INSURER CAN PROVIDE A LIST OF REPAIR SHOPS THAT ' WILL BE ABLE TO REPAIR THE VEHICLE TO ITS PRE-DAMAGE CONDITION. THIS APPRAISAL MAY INCLUDE AFTERMARKET CRASH PARTS AS REPLACEMENT PARTS. IF THE USE OF AN AFTERMARKET CRASH PART VOIDS THE EXISTING WARRANTY ON THE PART THAT IT REPLACES, OR ANY OTHER PART, THAN THE , AFTERMARKET PART LISTED ON THIS ESTIMATE WILL HAVE A WARRANTY THAT MEETS OR EXCEEDS THE WARRANTY OF THE ORIGINAL MANUFACTURER. AFTERMiARKET PART DESCRIPTIONS ON THIS.APPRAISAL ARE PRECEDED WITH A/M. AN AFTERMARKET CRASH PART' IS A NON-ORIGINAL EQUIPMENT MANUFACTURER (NON-OEM) REPLACEMENT PART, EITHER NEW OR USED, FOR ANY OF THE NON-MECHANICAL PARTS THAT GENERALLY CONSTITUTE THE EXT£RIOR.OF THE MOTOR VEHICLE, INCLUDING INNER AND OUTER PANELS. IF FRAME OR UNIBODY REPAIR IS INCLUDED ON THIS ESTIMATE,- THE AMOUNT- _ SHOWN INCLUDES- TIME OR ALLOWANCE FOR MEASURING BEFORE,-DURING AND AFTER' THOSE '_ ?RJEFAIRS -LIFETIME•..GUARANTEE FOR-SHEET METAL:AND PLASTIC BODY PARTS The replacement parts written on the* estimate are intended to return_:_ your vehicle to its pre-loss condition with proper installation. After - repair, if any sheet=.metal- or. plastic body part included in the estimate fails to return your-vehicle to:its.?pre-loss condition, (assuming proper-"'- =_ installation) , in terms of form, fit, finish, durabihtyor functionality; Progressive will arrange and pay for" the-•replacement of the' part, ta;he"exten_ :not covered- by a manufacturer' S: 6r.-other ' warranty. This-.service- wi-il:-be" "- :,performed - at no' cost to you (including as scciated-=itiepa r='and rental car.:?costs)"1T6ZM ak . _ , service under this Guarantee, c:a31":Progressive at 1-800-274''4641. .This.-Guarantee applies as long as you `own or"rease the vehicle .- -This: - ?_. - .:. ..Guarantee is not transferable and terminates if you sell or oth -rwise transfer your vehicle. THIS GUARANTEE DOES NOT COVER NORMAL WEAR AND TEAR OR DAMAGE CAUSED: BY:•IMPROPEi _ MAINTENANCE, NEGLECT, ABUSE OR SUBSEQUENT ACCIDENT. THIS GUARANTEE IS--LIMITED-.' -ARRANGING FOR THE SELECTION OF REPAIR PARTS THAT WILL RETURN YOUR VEHICL£;TO._I' PRE-LOSS CONDITION. ACCORDINGLY, PROGRESSIVE WILL NOT BE LIABLE FOR.ANY INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES THAT RESULT FROM THE INSTALLATION OR USE 0: THESE PARTS. THIS ESTIMATE REPRESENTS AN AGREED PRICE BASED ON ALL KNOWN DAMAGES AT THIS TIME. THE REPAIRER AGREES TO COMPLETE AND GUARANTEE ALL LISTED REPAIRS, AND ALL TOWING AND STORAGE CHARGES INCLUDED IN THIS ESTIMATE. ***THIS IS NOT AN AUTHORIZATION OF REPAIR."** ***NO SUPPLEMENTS WITHOUT PRIOR AUTHORIZATION OR REINSPECTION.*** ESTIMATE RECALL NUMBER 11/172004 1421:23 04-MNY.10-01 Ub*Aate is a Trademark of Lfilk alt Intemational Mlicheil Data Version: OCT?.oa A CopyrlgM (C) 1994 - 2004 Mttdteg tntemational UltraMate Version: 5.5.008 all Rights Reserved Page 3 of 4 Date: 11/17/200402:21 PM Estimate ID: 04-3907050.01 Estimate Version: 0 Committed Profile ID: CUSTOMIZED PROGRESSIVE WILL ONLY BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ADDITIONAL STORAGE OR MISC. HANDLING CHARGES WHEN - WARRANTED UP-• TO:-TW6. -DAYS POST - THIS APPRAiSAL•-DATE -IN BOTH-REPAIRABLE AND .TOTAL., LOSS SITUATIONS. ANY PERSON WHO KNOWINGLY AND WITH INTENT TO DEFRAUD ANY INSURANCE COMPANY OR OTHER PERSON FILES AW APPLICATION FOR INSURANCE OR STATEMENT OF CLAIM! CONTAINING ANY MATERIALLY FALSE INFORMATION OR CONCEALS FOR THE PURPOSE OF MISLEADING, INFORMATION CONCERNING ANY FACT AND SUBJECMATERIAL S THE PERS??TCo II? "D FRAUDULENT CIVIL PENALTTIIES. ACT, WHICH IS A RIME APPRAISER SIGNATURE J_- _ REPAIR SHOP MANAGER'S SIGNATURE - -- - - - - -Event Log -11/17/2004 01:4727 PM - _ 'r' - = -Estimate Started: 111178004'01:49:09 PM - = Estimate Printed: - - - Estl6ate Committed: -1 ViV204 -02-.21:23 PM ?'- Estlrrwte Uploaded: Estimate not uploaded' ESTIMATE RECALL NUMBER. 11/17/200414:21:23 043907050-01 UltraMate is a Trademark of Mitchell Inter wOonal Mitchell Data Version: OCT 04 A Copyright (C) 19% - 2004 Mitchell tntemational UltraMate Version: 5.5106 AN Rights Reserved Page 4 of 4 Page: 1 Document Name: untitled CMSD2340 /CMSM2340 PA C M A N FEB 08 05 - 13:39 OPID: DAW0025 CLAIM PAYMENT INQUIRY TERMID: VT680494 INSD: SANTANNA, RAYMOND C JR POL: 39039012-2 DOL. ::: SEP- 18 -04- PA-MECHAN-BRN- ' _CLM:.:. 043907050 -:_ ACTIVE - - REP: ;_A _ DOLLMAN :, •. PAY TO THE ORDER OF: TOTAL DRAFT AMOUNT: 1,658-14- - LINE 1: RAYMOND C-SANTANNA JR., ONLY*********'?*****t**************** LINE 2: LINE 3.- ADDRESS: 102 THISTLETOWN DR CITY: HUMMELSTOWN ST/PR* PA ZIP/CPC: 17036 - CNTRY* U. IN PAYMENT OF: COLL. DAMAGE TO 00 LOWE, LESS. DED. 1099 ? N - FEDERAL -TAX ID : - ^ ` LAST UPDT REP : APD0003:. CDS CODE * 12 PCL EFT . TRACE - # : -ISSUING REP:. A DOLLMAN.:: BANK CODE* AS2 ISSUE DATE NOV 17 04 APPROVED BY: STATE_ _PA AREA * 252 REVIEW DATE: 00 :00_ STOP RSN * DRAFT # 437038303 REVIEWED BY: COMMAND :. :. r:..- - .. _ : - __ _.. .. Date: 02/08/2005 Time: 01:39:11 PM VERIFICATION I, Michael J. Dougherty, Esquire, attorney for the Plaintiff(s) do hereby swear and affimn that the averments in the attached Complaint are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and/or belief.. These averments are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S.A. §4944 relating to unswom falsification to autho ' 'es. ...? - : - / . :. Nfi el J. Do 46erty - - -- .? Date F..A,ibit E IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogee of Greg Shang Plaintiff, V. - HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE Defendants. l: CAS E NO 00.x- 0.3 v2 -7 ?. : TYPE OF PLEADING: -COMPLAINT IN-C[ViL ACTION FILED ON BEHALF OF: Plaintiff COUNSEL OF RECORD OF .:THIS PARTY: _ MICHAEL J. DQUGHERTY, ESQUIRE Pa. I.D. #76046 WELTMAN, WEINBERG & REIS CO., L.P.A. 325 Chestnut Street Suite 1120 Philadelphia, PA 19106 (215) 599-1500 WWR #04276311 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUN'T'Y, PENNSYLVANIA CIVII, DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogee of Greg Sharrar Plaintiff, CASE NO: V. TYPE OF PLEADING: COWLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION - HARRIS MARINE, INC., dtb/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE - -- Defendants. NOTICE TO DEFEND NOTICE AVISO - YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you -wish to LE HAN DEMANDADO A USTED EN LA - _ ? - - - defend against the claim set forth in the following pages, CORTE. Si usted quieroe defenderse de ester _ you must take action within twenty (20) days after this-- - Y; denwMeas expuestas en las paginas siguientes, . _ _ • "..• complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written - arced time veinte (2D) dias de plazo al partir de 1a appearance personally or by an attorney in-filirig in fecha dela demmnda y la notificacion. Hace falta ... _ writing with the Court your defenses or objections to asentar una comparencia escrita o en persona o con:;,.: to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that= _ up,abogado_y entregar a la Corte en forma escrita, if you fail to do so the case may proceed without yori and 'sus defich Mi a sus obji6bncs a las demandas en:-..- judgment may be entered against you by the-Court='- a contra de su persona Sea avisado que si usttd no: _ :. ......, ,,.: _ _ • _ without further notice for money claimed in the Complaint _ _ se defiende, la Corte toinara medidas y puede _.~. or for any other claim or relief requested by tfie'_ ` coritirniar la deinanda en contra suya sin pw1no plaintifE You may lose money or property or other ` -' aviso o notificacion. Adensas, la Corte puede - rights important to you. decidir a favor del demandante y requiere que usted. cumpla con todas las provisioner de esta demanda. usted puede perder dinero o sus propiedadas u otros drechos importantes para usted. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP: LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO INM[EDIATAMENTA. SI NO TIENE ABOGADO O SINO TIENE EL DINERO SUFFICTENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICO, VAYA EN PERSONA O LLAME FOR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DIRECCION SE ENCUENTRA ESCRTTA ADAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEGAL. LAWYER REFERRAL SERVICE CUMBERLAND COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION 32 SOUTH BEDFORD STREET CARLISLE, PA 17013 (717) 249-3166 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogee of Greg Sharrar Plaintiff, V. CASE NO: TYPE OF PLEADING: COMPLAIlf IN CIVIL ACTION HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a -- - HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE - " Defendants. COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION -AND NOW 'COMES, Plaintiffby and iliroug}i_ its: counsel;.-WELTMAN; WEINBERG & REIS. _CO., L.P.A., and_hercby file's this Coriiplaint agai]ist_Dafcridants jointly andscverally. In support thereof; Plaintiff' avers asfollows:. ?1. .. • . -Plainti -Progressive . Northern:Ariisurance: Company :;?.(' ogressive'),.. is a corporation with:: a • ,,.: registered office located It- P.O. Box 43258, Richmond-Heiglits; Ohio.: - ?;•>,__ 2. Defendant, Harris~ Marine; Inc.; doing' business "•as * Harrisburg Seaplane Base, is- a business - organization licensed and authorized th conduct business in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and having as one of its places of business 333 South Front Street, wormleysburg, Pennsylvania 17043. 3. Progressive issued a policy of insurance where Progressive agreed to insure a 2003 Sun Tracker ("Insured Boat'J, owned by Plaintiff's insured. 4. On or about September 19, 2044 the Plaintiff Insured's boat was stored at Defendant's place of business and was at all times under the care, custody and/or control of Defendant. 5. While the Plaintiff Insured's boat was under the cart, custody and/or control of Defendant, the Plaintiff Insured's boat was caused to be damaged. 6. Defendant is liable to Plaintiff for all damages sustained to the Plaintiff Insured's boat due to Defendant's negligence and/or carelessness which consisted, inter alia, of failing to have the boat properly secured; failing to take proper precautions to ensure the safety of the boat; failing to take proper precautions to ensure the safety of the boat based on the weather conditions which Defendant knew or should have known were occurring or were about to occur; failing to place the boat at a safe location under the circumstances; and, failing to act reasonably in the securing and protecting the boat_ 7. - As a: direct and proximate` `resu3t?'of =Defendant's. negligence, the Progressive's Insured boat. . sustained property damage in the amount of $7,449.15. 8. Pursuant to the terms and conditions of the insurance policy, Progressive paid the sum of $6,949:15. ' k true and "correct copy of the payment and damage documentation is attached hereto and marked as r - - _...:..: - - . - _ .... _ _ - Exhibit "I". - - - - - : 9: -:In- addition Plaintifr-s-Insured also sustained damages in the amount of $250.00_re_prespnting.; , his deductible. 10. Pursuant to the insurance policy_ issued by Progressive and as a result of said aforesaid payment, - -Progressive became subrogated to.th_e claim of its-.Ins&ed'against Defendant, Pursuant to= Progressive's right of subrogation, Progressive is presently due. and owed-,from Defendant the sum "of $,449.15. : - -, _ • _ : . 12. Repeated demands Have bedri made upon Defendants for payment of the aforesaid sum; however, Defendants have willfully failed and refused to pay the sum due and owing to Progressive. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands Judgment against Defendant in the amount of $7,449.15 plus interest and costs. THIS IS AN ATTEMPT TO COLLECT A DEBT AND ANY INFORMA'T'ION OBTAINED SHALL BE USED FOR THAT PURPOSE. Respectfully Subnfitted: WELTMAN ERG & REIS, CO., L.P.A. :Michael J: Dougherty; Esquire- PA I.D. # 76046 l ; - 325 Chestnut Street_ . - Suite 1120 -- . - -= = - = Philadelphia, PA..19106 : . (215) 599-1500 - - - :.... - - - _... WWR#04276307:,::?,:s .• ..... - •!' ??. - -._ - -,7_ _ ._ ... _. . . _ ... _.. _ .. .. • _ _ ... _.--. _ _? -. -?• _ is •.. a - ... _ ' ?.. EXMI T 1 Date. 01/18200510:25 AM Estimate ID: 04-380985901 Estimate Version: 1 Supplement: 1(F) 01118/200510:18:15 P Profile ID: CUSTOMIZED 5053 RITTER ROAD SUITE 101 MECHANICSBURG. PA 17055 (717) 791-5178 Fax: (717) 697-0711 Damage Assessed By. LICENSE#273265 ANDREW DOLLMAN Claim Rep: ANDREW DOLLMAN (717) 791-5178 Supplemented By: LICENSE#273265 ANDREW DOLLMAN - Product Type Boat ' Date of Loss: 0911912004 • Deductible: 500.00 Policy No: 35294164-001 ' Claim Number. 043809859-01 Insured: GREG SHARRAR =_-" Address: 0815 ENGLISH AVE MECHANICSBURG, PA 17055 Telephone: Work Phone: -'(717) 545-3758 Home Phone: (717) 795-8895 *- - ' --Mitchell Service: 911000 Description: Vehicle Production Date: 00100 VIN: OT685144 OEM/ALT. A Search Code: MECHANICSI - - - Color. IVORY Entry Labor Line Item Part Type/ Dollar Labor Number Type Operation Description Part Number Amount Units MANUAL ENTRIES - - - - 900500 MCH- REPAIR REPLACE STARBOARD LOG New 3,490.00 ` 8.0' 900500 MCH• REPAIR REPLACE STARBOARD DECK EXTRUSION 3 PIECINew 150.00.5• _ 900500 MCH• REPAIR REMOVE INSTALL RIGHT FENCING 2.0• PARTS AVAILABLE FROM RYAN VYGAS = - .. .1. _ AT BASS PRO SHOPS- 410489-2500 EXT 4480 900500 MCH- REPAIR HAULING CHARGES Sublet 413.00 0A• INCLUDES HAULING, TRAILER FEE, 2ND MAN FEE 900500 MCH' REPAIR DETAIL BOAT INTERIOR Existing 2;0' 900500 MCH" REPAIR SHOP SUPPLIES Sublet 900500 MCH' REPAIR WELDING SUBLET TO Bf HANDLED AS SUPPLEMISublet 375.00' 0.0- 900500 MCH' REPAIR FREIGHT CHARGES HANDLED AS A SUPPLEMENZublet 625.00' 0.0• - Judgement Item ESTIMATE RECALL NUMBER: 1011342004 10:47:08 043809859-01 UttraMate is a Trademark of WAchell International Mb&tell Data Version: DEC 04 A Copyriot (C) 1994 - 2004 Mitchell International UltraMate Version: 5.5.008 All Rights Reserved Page 1 of 4 Date: 011181200510:25 AM Estimate ID: 043809859-01 Estimate Version: 1 Supplement 1(F) 0111&200510:18:15A Profile ID: CUSTOMIZED Add1 Labor Sublet 1. Labor Subtotals Units Rate Amount Amount Totals 11. Part Replacement Summary Mechanical 13.5 65.00 0.00 1.428.00 2.305.50 T Taxable Parts Sales Tax Taxable Labor 2.305.50 Labor Tax @ 6.000% 136.33 Total Replacement Parts Amount Labor Summary 13.5 2.443.83 Ill. Additional Costs Amount W. Adjustments Total Additional Costs 0.00 insurance Deductible Customer Responsibility 1. Total Labor IL Total Replacement Pests. ' III. Total Additional Costs: Gross Total: 3.858.40 Amount 500.01 500.0( . 2.443.8: - 3.85.8.4( 0.0( 6.302.2: IV. Total Adjustments: 500.0( ` - Net Total: 5.8022: Less Original Net Total: 4.742.2: - - Net Supplement Amount 1.060.0( S1: LICENSE0273265 ANDREW DOLLMA1.060.0( '.... - Inspection Site. BIG BEE BOATS - - - - , - -- _ _ MARYS%4LLE Inspection Date: 09f27r2004 ' THE VEHICLE. Oi??tER-?' -Y E RESPONSIBLk"FOR AD_ DITIONAL -COST_,3ABOVE THE _APPRAISED-.'AMOUNT'' ' TfiERE . IS. NO REQUIREMENT TO USE A SPECIFIC REPAIR- 4--' -'j- SHOP, HOWEVE t a~::T) F .INSURER CAN PROVIDE A LIST OF REPAIR SHOPS THAT _ WILL BE.•ABLE_TO:REPAIR THE VEHICLE TO ITS PRE-DAMAGE CONDITION. THIS APPRAISAL MAY';INCLUDE AFTERMARKET CRASH PARTS AS REPLACEMENT ' PARTS.--IF-THE•USE--OF AN AFTERMARKET CRASH PART VOIDS THE EXISTING _- WARRANTY-ON'THE PART THAT IT REPLACES, OR ANY OTHER PART;_THAN THE :_. AFTERMARKET PART LISTED ON THIS ESTIMATE WILL HAVE A WARRANTY THAT - MEETS OR EXCEEDS'THE WARRANTY OF THE ORIGINAL MANUFACTURER. AFTERMARKET PART DESCRIPTIONS ON THIS APPRAISAL ARE PRECEEDED WITH A/M. AN AFTERMARKET CRASH PART IS A NON-ORIGINAL EQUIPMENT MANUFACTURER (NON-OEM) REPLACEMENT PART, EITHER NEW OR USED, FOR ANY OF THE NON-MECHANICAL PARTS•THAT GENERALLY CONSTITUTE THE EXTERIOR OF THE MOTOR VEHICLE, INCLUDING INNER AND OUTER PANELS. IF FRAME OR UNIBODY REPAIR IS INCLUDED ON THIS ESTIMATE, THE AMOUNT SHOWN INCLUDES TIME OR ALLOWANCE FOR MEASURING BEFORE, DURING AND AFTER THOSE REPAIRS. LIFETIME GUARANTEE FOR SHEET METAL AND PLASTIC BODY PARTS ESTIMATE RECALL NUMBER: 10113r2004 10A7.05 043805859-01 UltraMate is a Trademark of Mitchell International Mitchell Data Version: DEC 04 A Copyright (C) 1994 - 2004 Wdchell International I IltmMatw Vwrsian- 5.S.OOS Ali Rights Reserved Amount 3,640.00 6.000% 218.40 Page 2 of 4 Date: 01!18200510-25 AM Estimate ID: 04-3809859-01 Estimate Version: i Supplement: 1 (F) 01/18200510:18:151 Profile la: CUSTOMIZED The replacement parts written on the estimate are intended to return y our vehicle to its pre-loss condition with proper installation. After = -- repair, if any sheet metal or plastic body part included in the estim ate fails to return your vehicle to its pre-loss condition (assuming p roper installation), in terms of form, fit, finish, durability or func tionality, Progressive will arrange and pay for the replacement of the part, to the extent not covered by a manufacturer's or other warranty This service will be performed at no cost to you (including associat ed repair and rental car costs). To obtain service under this Guarante e, call Progressive at 1-800-274-4641. This Guarantee applies as long as you own or lease the vehicle. This G uarantee is not transferable and terminates..if you sell or. otherwise t ransfer your vehicle. THIS GUARANTEE DOES NOT COVER NORMAL-WEAR AND TEAR OR DAMAGE CAUSED BY IMPROPER MAINTENANCE, NEGLECT, ABUSE_.OR SUBSEQUENT ACCIDENT. THIS.GUARANTEE IS LIMITED TO ARRANGING FOR THE SELECTION OF REPAIR PAR TS THAT WILL RETURN YOUR VEHICLE TO ITS PRE-LOSS CONDITION. -ACCORDING- LY, PROGRESSIVE WILL NOT BE LIABLE FOR-ANY INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL OR CO_N:4-* SEQUENTIAL. DAMAGES THAT RESULT FROM THE INSTALLATION OR USE OF THESE P ARTS. .. - ._ . = = - * * PART TYPE TERMS. AND.-ABBREVIATIONS- . * * ... NEW AND OEM OR PART NUMBER DISPLAYED -- THESE REFER TO.'A NEW, ORIGINAL EQUIPMENT MANUFACTURER PART. NON-OEM AND A/M AND QUAL REPT,:=- THESE-REFER TO AN AFTER-MARKET PART, _ '':: WHICH IS A NEW, NON-ORIGINAL;.EQUIPMENT:.MANUFACTURER..PART. USED/RECYCLED AND LKQ -- THESE REFER TO A USED OEM PART.. r _ :-? :REMANUFACTtIRED: ANp?`'AECONQ.-„ND'.RECORE. --'THESE -REFER- TO USED/RECYCLEU:- :-- -OEM ::PARTS.- THAT:HAE. ?BEEN* REFURBISHED-. :. THIS.. ESTIMATE- REPRESENTS AN•-AGREED- PRICE :BASED ON ALI; -KNOWN- DAMAGES-. -= _ - ---AT THIS TIME. THE REPAIRER AGREES TO COMPLETE AND GUARANTEE ALL -:-: ` ==LISTED=:REPAIRS,::--AND' ALL 'TOWING. _AND:=STORAGE- CHARGES -INCLUDED IN • THIS ' - " '--' ESTIMATE. ***THIS IS NOT AN AUTHORIZATION OF REPAIR-.***-- ***NO SUPPLEMENTS WITHOUT PRIOR AUTHORIZATION OR REINSPECTION.*** PROGRESSIVE WILL ONLY BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ADDITIONAL STORAGE OR MISC. EN WAR DATELINGBOTHRREPAIHRABLE AN?T,? I,,. TO I ATiONSST THIS APPRAISAL APPRAISER SIGNATURE REPAIR SHOP MANAGER'S SIGNATURE ESTIMATE RECALL NUMBER: 10113/2004 10:47:08 04380ga59-01 UltraMate is a Trademark of Mitchell International Mitchell Data Version: DEC 04 A Copyright (C)1994.2004 Mitchell International ultraMate version: 5,5.008 All Rights Reserved Page 3 of 4 Event Log File Created: Estimate Started: Estimate Printed: Estimate Committed: Estimate Uploaded: 10/132004 08:39:09 AM 01118200510:1727 AM 01118200510:20-28 AM 01118120051025:29 AM Estimate not uploaded Date: 01!18200510:25 AM Estimate ID: 043809859.01 Estimate Version: 1 Supplement: 1 (F) 01118200510.18:15 f Profile ID: CUSTOMIZED ESTIMATE RECALL NUMBER 10113200410:47.08 04-3809859-01 UltraMate Is a Trademark of Mitchell Intemationm Mitchell Data Version: DEC 04 A Copyright (C) 1994 - 2004 MitdwH fnternational UlfraMafe Version: 5.5.008 AN Rights Reserved Page 4 of 4 ?ages 1 Document Name: untitled CMSD2340 /CMSM2340 P A C M A N MAR 04 05 - 14:24 OPID: JES0018 CLAIM PAYMEN'T' INQUIRY TERMID: V6010477 INSD: SHARRAR, GREG POL.: 35294164-1 DOL SEP 19 04 PA-MBCHAN-BRN- CLM: 043809859 ACTIVE REPi A DOLLMAN PAY TO THE ORDER OF: TOTAL DRAFT AMOUNT: 4,742.23 LINE 1: GREG SHARRAR AND************t************t********#**** LINE 2• GREAT SOUTHERN BANK, ONLY**************:***}**************** LINE 3: Q ADDRESS: 1815 ENGLISH DRIVE CITY: MECHANICSBURG* ST/PR* PA ZIP/CPC: 17055 CNTRY*._t IN PAYMENT OF: COLL DAMAGE TO .03 SUN.TRACKER, LESS. DED. 1099 ? N FEDERAL TAX ID: LAST UPDT REP: APDO003 CDS CODE * 12 PCL = -EFT• TRACE #: ISSUING REP: A DOLIAJAN; ., .. :- -BANR CODE* AS2 ISSUE-DATE OCT -13 - 04 . APPROVED BY: 21 STATE * PA -AREA *-252 - - - REVIEW DATE: ~ _ - ?` '? _ STOP RSN'* DRAFT # 436520246 REVIEWED BY: r C014MAND ate: 03/04/2005 Time: 02:24:27 PM Page: 1 Document Name: untitled CMSD2340 /CMSM2340 P A C M A N MAR 04 05 - 14:25 OPID: JES0018 CLAIM PAYMENT INQUIRY TF"ID: V6010477 INSD • SHARRAR_ , GREG POL _.:3 5294164 -1 DOL : SEP 19 04 PA-MECHAN-BRN CLM: 043809859 ACTIVE REP':'-*A-.DoLLMAN-_ PAY TO THE ORDER OF: TOTAL DRAFT AMOUNT: 1,060.00 LINE 1: GREG SHARRAR AND************************'****************#* LINE 2• GREAT SOUTHERN BANK, ONLY*******************#**##***:******'` LINE 3: ADDRESS: 1815 ENGLISH AVE - CNTRY* I CITY: MBCHANICSBURG ST/PR* PA ZIP/CPC: 17055..- IN- PAYMENT=-OF:-COLL. SUPPLEMENTAL CHARGES FOR PONTOON BOAT 1099"• FEDERAL TAX ID:- LAST UPDT REP: APD0003.--" - I1?!?AN CDS CODB' -* -T2 -PCL EFT TRACE 4: . - = ISSUING' REP .. A D04 'AS2 - -ISSUE ?DAYS 'JAl?F id. " 0 5 APPROVED - -BY: BANK t'ODE STATE= = * PA '7-AREA REVIEW -=DATE :: STOP • ESN- * DRAFT.# 437991349 REVIEWED BY:.- CO MMAND Date: 03/04/2005 Time: 02:25:36 PM VERIFICATION 1, Michael J. Dougherty, Esquire, attorney for the Plaintiff(s) do hereby swear and affirm that the averments in the attached Complaint are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and/or belief. These averments are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S.A. §4904 relating to unsworn falsification t authorities. Michael . D gherty ?.: .. - ' -Date= --. - - - '` '. - .. -..... .:-:"••"ii:,-- - - - - _ - Y - - Ale- F d a. Z V 7 O O o. U O IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogee of Jim Sauerwine _ CASE NO: ??? .3 9 3 Z Plaintiff, - - V _ _ -•-TYPE OF PLEADING: - COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a .? . HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE - t: Defendants. - - FILED ON BEHALF OF: Plaintiff - COUNSEL OF RECORD OF THIS PARTY: - MICHAEL J. DOUGHERTY, ESQUIRE Pa. ED. #76046 WELTMAN, WEINBERG & REIS CO., L.P.A. 325 Chestnut Street Suite 1120 Philadelphia, PA 19106 (215) 599-1500 WWR #04352149 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CfVDL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTFIERN INSURANCE COMPANY, Subrogee of James Ford. Plaintiff, V. HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE Defendants: : }- r , - - CASE NO: TYPE OF PLEADING: COMPLAINT IN CIVIL AMON NOTICE TO DEFEND - NOTICE AESO - YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to LE HAN DEMANDADO A USTED EN LA defend against the claim set forth in the following pages, CORTE. Si usted quiere defenderse de estas - :...:.. you must take action within twenty (20) days _after this demanddeas expuestas en las paginas siguientes, . complaint and Notice are served, by entering a wriften usted tiene veinte (20) dias de plazo al partir de ]a appearance personally or by an attorney iri filing iS - fecha dela demanda y la notification. Hace falta ... _ writing with the Codit your defenses or objections to*_ asentar una comparencia escrita o en persona o con. to the claims act forth against you. You eie.warned that un abogado.y entregar a Is torte en fornua escrita if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you aiid'? = `sus defensas'o sus objeciones a las denaandas en a judgment may be entered against you by".the Court.. _ . contra de su persona. Sea avisado que si usted no..::, _ without further notice for money claimed-in the Complaint se defiende, la torte tomara medidas y puede or for any other claim or relief requested by the-': - ' . . contiR uar la demanda en contra suya sin previo _ plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other. aviso o notification. Ademas, la torte puede . ...,- rights important to you. _decidir a favor del demandante y requiere que usted cumpla con today las provisions de ests. demanda-. - ' iuted puede perder dinero o sus propiedadas u otros drechos importantes para usted. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP: LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO IIOAMIATAMENTA. SI NO TIENE ABOGADO O S1NO TIENE EL DINERO SUFFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICO, VAYA EN PERSONA O LLAME FOR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DIRECCION SE ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ADAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEGAL. LAWYER REFERRAL SERVICE CUMBERLAND COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION 32 SOUTH BEDFORD STREET CARLISLE, PA 17013 (717) 249-3166 ' THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY, - Subrogee of James Ford CASE NO: Plaintiff, V. TYPE OF PLEADING: • COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION HARRIS MARINE; INC., d/b/a =- HAgMVIURG SEAPLANE BASE _ • Defendants _.....---__.___. ___..• - ' -- COMPLAINT IN CIVIL AMON NOW =COMES, Plaintiff .by, and through its counsel'; WELTMAN a WEINBERG `& REIS • !QP;, • ?• ' .. _ L.P.A., and herby f des this Complaint against Defendants jointly and severally. In support thereof Plaintiff avers.,;. . .as,follows:_::,.:? :_ :: _ - • ; - ..:t .. - K :: ,:;:: - :?._:?: ,:.?P:Iaintifl?::?Progressive-'Noithem. Insurance" Company.("Progressivc'J,• .is _a..c_orporabon. with'. a-' registered-offce'located at P.O. Box43258; Richmond-Hdights,"Ohio. • :;- - 2: • '' .Defendant, 'Harris - MaiiriE; e:, 'doing -business as= Harrisburg Seaplanet Base, is !:a business" :... organization licensed and authorized to conduct business in the Commonwcalth of Pennsylvania and having as one of its places of business 333 South Front Street, Wormleysburg, Pennsylvania 17043. 3. Progressive issued a policy of insurance where Progressive agreed to insure a 2000 Starcmft Pontoon Boat {"Insured Boat'), owned by Plaintiff's insured. 4. On or about September 23, 2004 the Plaintiff Insured's boat was stored at Defendant's place of business and was at all times under the care, custody and/or control of Defendant. 5. While the Plaintiff Insured's boat was under the care, custody and/or control of Defendant, the Plaintiff Innsured's boat was caused to be damaged. 6. Defendant is liable to Plaintiff for all damages sustained to the Plaintiff Insured's boat due to Defendant's negligence and/or carelessness which'consisted, inter-alia, of: failing to have the boat properly secured; .- - - failing to take proper precautions to ensure the safety of the boat; failing to take proper precautions to ensure the safety of the boat based on the weather conditions which Defendant knew or should have known were occurring or were about to occur, failing to place the boat at a safe location under the circumstances; and, failing to act reasonably in the securing and protecting the boat- 7. As a direct and proximate result of Defendant's negligence, the Progressive's Insured boat .. - sustained property damage in the amount of $21,494.40. 8. Pursuant to the terms and conditions of the insurance policy, Prog essive paid the sum of _ $21,244.40. A .true and correct copy of the payment and damage documentation is attached hereto and marked as :- Exhibit "I .. :..: . _ . _9...-_- _ In_additioh, the Plaintiffs Insured also sustained damages in the amount of $250.00 representing i his deductible. - : • - • .;;i% ., 10.. Pursuant to the insurance policy issued by Progressive and as a'result•(if said aforesaid payment, . _ Frogressive.bt_ came sub_rogated_ to the cl_ai_m_ of its Insured against Defendant. -ti 11. Pursuant to Progressive's right of subrogation, Progressive. is ?prestntly due and owsd from- :•,: z 7- Defendant the sum of $21,494.40. . :?:a._. -. ?i• ..? l.: .._- -.'r_ _. _?,.,:?? - . - -• :' ._ .. ,_ -;•'__ _ -?a --mot- '':: + :"•i`i:.. _. ,: a +i _ _ .r 12. Repeated demands have been made upon Defendants for payment of the aforesaid sum; however, M: Defendants have willfully failed and refused to pay the sum due and owing to Progressive. _ WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands Judgment against Defendant in the amount of $21,494.40 plus interest and°costs. . • • _. . • - r • _ - . . .. . . .. .. .._ .' i•- r. ":t-.: . - . . + : : -' .r.- : . . - _. . ` THIS IS AN ATTEMPT TO COLLECT A DEBT AND ANY INFORMATION OBTAINED SHALL BE USED FOR THAT PURPOSE. Respectfully Submi WELTMAN G & REIS, CO., L.P.A. -Michael L ougberty, Esquire PA I.D. # 76046 - : - 325 Chestnut Street . Suite 1120 Philadelphia,-PA 19106 = . • (215) 599-1500 :- -WR#04352149:.. - - :. - . . . -- W __........_ -- _ E_??IZ.1 - NADAguides.com - New Car Prices, Used Car Values Used Values: Result Wecwine. Boats and Personal Watercraft ;,.. 1994 TRACKER MARINE SUN TRACKER SERIES PARTY CRUISER(*) October 25, 2004 @ print thi- page Used Average High = - Trade-In Retail Retail Base Price. - ` .. - - S13,300 $15,850 $17,900 _ .. - ; Options -Power Boat: ENTERTAINMENT T. V. 13" Color: $80 $95 $105 Power Boat: GALLEY Range - Electric: $390 $455 $505 Refrigerator - AC/DC - $350 $410 $455 6 ciL ft.: Power Boat: MISCELLANEOUS OPTIONAL EQUIPMENT :- Air Conditioning/'. _ Heating System - $760 $885 $980 12,000btu: - - - Generator /-5- KW - $1,765 050 $21 $2 275 Gas:. P 0 Hardtop 16' - 20'.Boat: $855 $995 $1,105 .-TOTAL PRICE 517,500 520,740 $23,325 Notes (*)INCLUDES THE VALUE OF THE OUTBOARD MOTOR. (")INCLUDES THE VALUE OF THE OUTBOARD MOTOR AND TRAILER. (***)INCLUDES THE VALUE OF THE TRAILER. Page 1 of 3 NADAguides.com - New Car Prices, Used Car Values Next Steps Get another_price Vehicle Specifications Length: Model Name/Description: Boat Type: Hull Material: Beam: Engine: Net Weight: 32' PARTY CRUISER(*) Pontoon Boats Aluminum 816'1 1 90 HP Gasoline 5,200 $ack tp Top.• • - :; Value Explanations - " - .. Manufacturers Suggested List Pricing(January and May Y) We have included manufacturers suggested tions DNL _ _ retail pricing to assist 'in'the financing, insuring and appraising ... ;t = ; ;1;.L: i. ;• of vessels.-, This pricing .All appear in the High Retail column for the current year only, if available. The value listed ._ ; ; ,:• ::::.: ,?:: reflects the approximate price of the boat when it is brand , new. The MSRP prices. W furnished by the manufacturer and • ? are assumed to be correct. :_ ?::_ _ t.} _. Value Range'*- The values listed are derived from the :market place.. These values are based on the boats overall ,- condition. Used Trade-In (Low Book) - This column reflects the average trade-in value of a clean used boat "ready for resale". This may also be considered the low book value. Average Retail - The average retail column reflects those boats in clean condition with no visible damage or defects. This boat will show some moderate wear and tear and will be in running condition. The buyer may need to invest in either minor cosmetic or mechanical work. High Retail -Me high retail column reflects those boats in excellent condition- Like new! ! This boat will show very little wear and tear and all equipment will be functioning, and the engine(s) are in good running condition. This boat has been meticulously maintained or restored and will not require any reconditioning. Page 2 of 3 • NADAguides.com - New Car Prices, Used Car Values Loan Value Explanation - This guide -does not have an established "Loan Value" designation. Lenders will use a percentage of either the Average Trade-In, Average Retail, or High Retail values. The determination of which column valuation is used is based on the lending institutions own internal policies and guidelines. Back to Top.& CCopvrighf 104 NADA Appraisal Guido. lne. AU Righa Reaawd ONADASC 1004. All Rijhis Reser?ad. .=:3? .. ... ?.: ice-' _ t• ?.. . -•' Page 3- of 3 :age: 1 Document Name: untitled CMSD2340 /CMSM2340 P A C M A N MAR 04 05 - 14:13 OPID: JES0018 CLAIM PAYMENT INQUIRY TERMID: V6010477 INSD: SAUERWINE, JIM POL: 39099080-3 DOL : SEP -23 44 ' PA-MECHAN--BRN= CLM: 043833649 ACTIVE REP.-_A. DOLLMAN. PAY TO THE ORDER-OF: TOTAL DRAFT AMOUNT: 21,204.40- LINE 1: JIM SAUERWINE, ONLY *****************?******************** LINE 2: LINE 3: ADDRESS: 217 ALLENDALE WAY CITY: CAMP HILL ST/PR* PA ZIP/CPC: 17011 CNTRY*. C IN PAYMENT OF: FULL AND FINAL SETTLEMENT TOTAL LOSS TO 94 TRACKER--250 DED 1099 ? N FEDERAL TAX ID: LAST UPDT REP: SSS0009 CDS CODE * 12 PCL EFT TRACE #: ISSUING REP: S SCHEIFELE:;:_ BANK CODE* AS2 ISSUE DATE NOV 02 04 APPROVED BY : M MURRZiY- :'_. -; _ STATE * PA AREA * 252 REVIEW DATE: 00-00 STOP RSN * DRAFT # 436779.121 REVIEWED BY: - _• Date: 03/04/2005 Time: 02:13:58-PM VERIFICATION L Michael J. Dougherty, Esquire, attorney for the Plaintiff(s) do hereby swear and affirm that the averments in the attached Complaint are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and/or belief. These averments ar ade subject to the penalties 1 of 18 Pa.C.S.A. §4904 relating to unsworn falsification to ?u orities. Date-_ Michael V.Dou erty HOLLSTEIN KEATING CATTELL JOHNSON & GOLDSTEIN P.C. BY: James W. Johnson / Josette F. Spivak IDENTIFICATION NO. 23319 / 82356 EIGHT PENN CENTER 1628 JOHN F. KENNEDY BLVD SUITE 2000 PHILADELPHIA, PA 19103 Phone: (215) 320-3260 Fax: (215) 320-3261 Attorneys for Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc. PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS INSURANCE COMPANY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY Subrogee of Edwin Ullom CIVIL DIVISION V. HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a CASE NO: 05-2264 HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE SEAPLANE BASE MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT MARINE PROPERTIES, INC. d/b/a HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE, improperly pled as HARRIS MARINE, INC.'S MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc., by and through its counsel Hollstein, Keating, Cattell, Johnson and Goldstein, P.C. hereby moves this Honorable Court to Consolidate the above -captioned actions for all purposes pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. 213(a). Plaintiff Progressive Northern Insurance Company filed the above captioned action in the Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas on behalf of Subrogee Edwin Ullom. Exhibit "A." Plaintiff and plaintiff-subrogee have alleged property damage to his boat allegedly docked at Defendant's Marina on or about September 18, 2004. Exhibit "A." Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc., filed its Answer with New Matter on or about January 20, 2006. Exhibit "B." Plaintiffs' complaint arises out of the same transactions or series of transactions as are alleged in the matters of- 0 Progressive Northern Insurance Company, Subrogee of James Ford v. Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 05-3270. Exhibit "C." • Progressive Northern Insurance Company Subrogee of Raymond C. Santana, Jr. v. Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg plane Base, Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 05-2263. Exhibit "D." • Progressive Northern Insurance Company, Subrogee of Greg Sharrar v. Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 05-3271. Exhibit "E." • Progressive Northern Insurance Company, Subrogee of Jim Sauerwine v. Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg plane Base, Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 05-3932. Exhibit "F." Upon information and belief the Plaintiffs' claims relate to flooding which occurred in September 2004 as a result of the remnants of Hurricane Ivan. All of the plaintiffs' seek to recover in subrogation for property damage claims paid to their insureds for damage to the insureds' boats which were allegedly docked at Defendant's Marina in September 2004. Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 213(a) provides: In actions pending in a county which involve a common question of law or fact or which arise from the same transaction or occurrence the court on its own motion or on the motion of any party may order a joint hearing or trial of any matter in issue in the actions, may order the actions consolidated, and may make orders that avoid unnecessary cost or delay. These cases should be consolidated for purposes of discovery, arbitration and trial in order to avoid unnecessary costs to both the Court and the parties and because all of the aforementioned Complaints involve common questions of law and fact, and arise from the same transaction or occurrences. Rozonowski v. Penn. Nat'l Mutual Casualty Ins. Co., 343 Pa. Super 7 (1985); Lohmiller v. Weidenbaugh, 302 Pa. Super. 174 (1982), rev'd on other grounds, 503 Pa. 110247.00088:JFS14371 2 329 (1983). Consolidation of these actions for discovery and trial will also avoid prejudice which could result from multiple hearings and inconsistent rulings. Plaintiff's counsel does not oppose this motion to consolidate. WHEREFORE, Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc., respectfully requests the Court grant its Motion to Consolidate the above captioned actions for all purposes under the caption and docket of Prop-ressive Northern Insurance Company, Subrogee of Raymond C Santana, Jr v Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 05-2263. HOLLSTEIN KEATING CATTELL JOHNSON & GOLDSTEIN, P.C. By: J`afnes W. Johnso , Esquire PA I.D. # 2331 Josette F. Spivak, Esquire PA I.D. # 82356 {I 0247.00089:JFS 14371 3 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Josette F. Spivak, Esquire, do hereby certify that a copy of Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc.'s Motion to Consolidate and Memorandum of Law has been served on plaintiff s counsel listed below by first class mail, postage pre-paid on this day of , 2006: Samantha Tran Estevez, Esquire Weltman, Weinberg, and Reis Co. 325 Chestnut Street, Sutie 1120 Philadelphia, PA 19106 C? f 5 NOV 0 20?1a d PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS INSURANCE COMPANY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY Subrogee of Edwin Ullom CIVIL DIVISION V. HARRIS MARINE, INC., d/b/a CASE NO: 05-2264 HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE SEAPLANE BASE ORDER AND NOW this dayof b t c."te 2006, upon consideration of 5 Defendant Marine Properties, Inc. d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, improperly pled as Harris Marine, Inc.'s Motion to Consolidate and any opposition thereto: I,S It is hereby ORDERED that Defendant's Motion to Consolidate4GRANTED; and It is further ORDERED that the following actions: Progressive Northern Insurance Company, Subrogee of Edwin Ullom v. Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 05-2264; Progressive Northern Insurance Company, Subro??ee of James Ford v. Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 05-3270; Progressive Northern Insurance Company, Subrogee of Greg Sharrar v. Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 05-3271; and, Progressive Northern Insurance Company, Subrogee of Jim Sauerwine v. Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 05-3932, will be consolidated for purposes of discovery and trial under the lead case of Progressive Northern Insurance Companv, Subrogee of Ravmond C. Santana, Jr. v. Harris Marine, Inc., d/b/a Harrisburg Seaplane Base, Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 05-2263. L :F htIV 9-- ;t D Z a._. M j4 cy WELTMAN, WEINBERG & REIS CO., L.P.A. BY: August J. Ober, Esquire Attorney for Plaintiff(s) I. D. No. 94701 325 Chestnut Street, Suite 501 Philadelphia, PA 19106 Phone: 215.599.1500 Fax: 215.599.1505 File # 04141976 PROGRESSIVE INSURANCE COMPANY As Subrogee of EDWIN C ULLOM CUMBERLAND County Court of Common Pleas vs. HARRIS MARINE, INC. DBA HARRISBURG SEAPLANE BASE NO. 05 2264 ORDER TO SETTLE, DISCONTINUE AND END TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Kindly marked the above matter settled, discontinued, and ended . WELTMAN, WEINBERG & REIS CO., L.P.A. By August er, IV, Attorn v fo Plaintiff 2699 DEC -4 Frl G: 19