HomeMy WebLinkAbout05-5791BURTON NEIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
By: Burton Neil, Esquire
Identification No. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
(610) 696-2120
Attorney for Plaintiff
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A.
701 East 60th Street North, Sioux Falls, SD
Plaintiff
V.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. OS - Sl?
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
850 Yverdon Drive
Camp Hill PA 17011-1850
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW"
COMPLAINT
NOTICE
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages,
you must take action within (20) days after this complaint and notice are served, by entering a written
appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the court your defenses or objections to
the claim set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so, the case may proceed without
you and a judgment may be entered against you by the court without further notice for any money
claimed in the complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the plaintiff. You may lose money
or property or other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE
A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET
FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. THIS OFFICE
CAN PROVIDE YOU WITH INFORMATION ABOUT HIRING A LAWYER.
IF YOU CANNOT AFFORD TO HIRE A LAWYER, THIS OFFICE MAY BE ABLE TO
PROVIDE YOU WITH INFORMATION ABOUT AGENCIES THAT MAY OFFER LEGAL
SERVICES TO ELIGIBLE PERSONS AT A REDUCED FEE OR NO FEE.
LAWYER REFERENCE AND
INFORMATION SERVICE
Cumberland County Bar Assoc.
32 South Bedford Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Telephone No. 717-249-3166 or 800-990-9108
C-8037
BURTON NEIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
By:Burton Neil, Esquire
Identification No. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
610-696-2120
Attorney for Plaintiff
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A.
701 East 60th Street North, Sioux Falls. SD
Plaintiff
V.
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
850 Yverdon Drive
Camp Hill PA 17011-1850
Defendant
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. OS -SW/ 7-I 1
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Complaint
1. The plaintiff is CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A., with place of business located at 701
East 60th Street North, Sioux Falls, South Dakota.
2. The defendant is Louise M Lamoreaux, who resides at 850 Yverdon Drive, Camp Hill,
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
3. Plaintiff, a national banking association, engages in various types of banking business
including consumer lending through the issuance of credit cards.
4. Plaintiff furnished consumer credit to the defendant by means of a credit card with account
number 5424180035318168 hereinafter referred to as the credit card account.
5. Plaintiff maintained an accurate and running record of all debits and credits to the credit card
account in its books of account.
6. Plaintiff mailed defendant a written statement each month which accurately stated the debits
and credits to the credit card account for the prior billing period.
7. Defendant received the monthly statements from plaintiff for the credit card account including
the statement attached hereto as Exhibit A statement without protest, dispute or objection.
8. Defendant in not protesting, disputing or objecting to the statements including the Exhibit A
statement thereby assented and agreed to the correctness of the balance due on the credit card account so
as to constitute an account stated.
9. The amount due plaintiff on the account stated, less credits, if any issued subsequent to the
Exhibit A statement, is $10,722.42.
Wherefore, plaintiff demands judgment against defendant for the sum of $10,722.42, and the
costs of this action.
BURTON NEIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
By:
Burton Neil,
Attorney for
The law firm of Burton Neil & Associates, P.C. is a debt collector.
• 08/05/05 $15632.42 $3389.32 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KCB7150
[=:vbi:':$>=aaE:>'- E:oifvi:>aaee>"::: A;A? 09/14/05 2 0: 40 : 3 7:
CITI CARDS
PO BOX 183058
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX COLUMBUS, OH
850 YVERDON DRIVE 43218-3058
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
Cities Driver's Edge
olrka,
Cltlm
Platinum Select Card-Charter Rbts
Account Number
5424 1800 3531 8168
Customer Sarviee:
1-SOO-866-9900 Total Credit Line Available Credit Line Cash Advance Limit Available Cash Limi t New 11alance
$13940 $0 $5600 $0 $15632.42
BOX 6500
Statement/ Amount Over
SIOUX FALLS. SD Closing Date Credit Llna Past Due Purch)Adv Minimum
Minimum Due Amount Due
57117 07/13/2005 $1692.42 + $1270.77 + $426.13 = $3389.32
SPie Data Post Date Reference Number Activity Since Last Statement Amount
Standard Purch
7/13 CREDITSHIELD PREMIUM 8.92
74 0000 0000000000
7/13 LATE FEE - JUN PAYMENT PAST DUE 39.00
66 0000 0000000000
6/20 6/20 X1TX5R00 AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE 58.79
61 N5969USA o r 75414915171
7/13 PURCHASES*FINANCE CHARGE*PERIODIC RATE 382.13
84 0000 0000000000
DRIVER'S EDGE REBATES SUMMARY
Purchase Rebates Earned
Ad7?ustments / Expired
NEW DRIVER'S EDGE REBATES
Activity This Period
1
-1
0
Purchase Rebates Earned
PREVIOUS DRIVER'S EDGE REBATES
Total Rebates Earned
Total Rebates Expired
Total Rebates Redeemed
Total Rebates Available
Previous Balance
150
Lifetime Activ303
153
0
150
Bonus Rebates may take one to two billing cycles
to appear on your statement. Please refer to the
specific terms and conditions pertaining to the
promotion for further details.
Citi Driver's Edge Charter Member rebates expire 3
years after they are earned. Expired rebates
will be deducted from your rebate account.
2.26 rebates will expire on AUGUST 11, 2005
Your late fee was based on your account balance
as of the payment due date (07/07/05), which was
$15,202.37.
Your account is seriously past due and your credit
privileges have been suspended. Please call the
toll-free number shown above to learn about our
special payment options. Call Monday - Friday,
7 am - 9 pm, or Saturday, 8 am - 5 pm,
Central Time.
EXHIBIT
Sale Date Post Date aeterence Number Activity Since Last Statement Amount
Account Summary Previous (+) Purchases (- Payments +) FINANCE (_) New
Balance &Advances &Credits CHARGE Balance
PURCHASES $15,143.58 $106.71 0.00 $382.13 $15,632.42
ALCES 0.00
4 0.
0
00 1 8 3
TOT $15,1
3
.58 $1
6. 0.00 $3
2.13 $15,6
2.42
Rate Summary
Sd Purch $15,374.40 0.08285%(D) 30.240% 30.240%
rd Adv $0.00 0.08285%(D) 30.240% 30.240%
Verification
6Y
Brit _ am an employee of Citicorp Credit
Services, Inc., (USA) which is by contract the service provider for plaintiff
Citibank (South Dakota) N.A. retained to perform services including but not
primarily limited to collecting delinquent debt. 1 am authorized to make this
verification as attorney-in-fact for plaintiff under powers of attorney from
plaintiff to Citicorp Credit Services, Inc. (USA) and to me. The foregoing
averments of fact in the within pleading are true and correct to the best of
my knowledge, information and belief. I understand that the statements
made herein are subject to the penalties of 18 P;
Section 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to
Date:_ "l J Signature:
i
z
,
ca
rT
.J GJ :{
SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR
CASE NO: 2005-05791 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N A
VS
LAMOREAUX LOUISE
SHANNON SHERTZER Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of
Cumberland County,Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law,
says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE was served upon
LAMOREAUX LOUISE M
the
DEFENDANT , at 1720:00 HOURS, on the 9th day of November
at 850 YVERDON DRIVE
CAMP HILL, PA 17011-1850
by handing to
ROBERT LAMREAUX, HUSBAND
2005
a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE together with
and at the same time directing His attention to the contents thereof.
Sheriff's Costs
Docketing 18.00
Service 13.44
Affidavit .00
Surcharge 10.00
.00
41.44
Sworn and Subscribed to before
me this !?'? day of
%VOVe,Mber ront5- A.D.
rot ary
So Answers
R. Thomas Kline
11/14/2005
BURTON NEIL & ASSOCIATES
By:
-Deputy Sher' f
CITIBANK (South Dakota) N.A.
Plaintiff,
V.
LOUISE M. LAMOREAUX,
Defendant.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
No. 05- 5791 Civil Term
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
ANSWER AND NEW MATTER
1. Admitted.
2. Admitted.
3. Admitted,
4. Admitted.
5. Denied. Proof is demanded.
6. Denied. Any statements did not accurately reflect debits or credits.
7. Denied. Objections have periodically been made concerning charges
for unauthorized debits for credit-shield programs, life insurance, late
fees, interest rate, etc.
8. Denied. Defendant has not assented to the correctness of any alleged
balance due to Plaintiff Citibank.
9. Denied. Proof is demanded.
NEW MATTER
1. Beginning August, 2005 sums totaling $5,410.00 have been remitted to
Plaintiff and should have been credited to Defendant's account. The
account is therefore not in arrears, nor is it a "bad debt."
t
2. This action may involve an attempt to obtain fees and costs or
otherwise may be in violation of the Fair Debt Collection Practices
Act.
WHEREFORE, Defendant demands a dismissal
of this action.
-
850 Y?erdon Drive
Cato Hill, PA 17011
(717) 379-8237
Pro Se
4A
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Louise Lamoreaux, Defendant in the matter docketed
to Civil Action 05-57919 hereby certify that I have, this day,
deposited a true and correct copy of Answer and New Matter
in the United States mail, postage prepaid, addressed to:
Burton Neil & Associates, P.C.
1060 Andrew Drive
Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
November 21, 2005
:?
'ii
,_
?; ?J_
co
__ t-_
BURTON NEIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
By: Burton Neil, Esquire
Identification No. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
610-696-2120
Attorney for Plaintiff
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Plaintiff
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
LOUISE LAMOREAUX
NO. 05-5791 Civil
Defendant : CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Plaintiff's Reply to New Matter
1. Denied. Defendant made payments totaling $4,910.00 since August 25, 2005 as
follows: plaintiff received a payment from defendant in the sum of $4,410.00 on August 25, 2005
and a payment in the sum of $500.00 on October 17, 2005. It is admitted that these sums were
credited to defendant's account. The account was in default prior to these payments and remains
in default.
2. Denied. There are no allegations of fact set forth in this averment. Pursuant to Pa.
R.C.P. 1029(d) no responsive pleading is required.
BURTQN.NEIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
By: - 7
Burton Nei T, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
In making this communication, we advise our firm is a debt collector.
Verification
Burton Neil, attorney for plaintiff Citibank (South Dakota) N.A. hereby verifies the
statements of fact in lieu of plaintiff as plaintiff is outside the jurisdiction of the court and the
verification of plaintiff can not be obtained within the time allowed for the pleading. The averments
of fact in the within pleading are true and correct upon information and belief based on information
provided to the undersigned verifier by plaintiff. The undersigned understands that the statements
made herein are subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C. S. Section 4904, relating to unworn falsification
to the authorities.
t
Burton Neil, Esquire
BURTON NEIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
By: Burton Neil, Esquire
Identification No. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
610-696-2120
ATTORNEY FOR: Plaintiff
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A. : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Plaintiff
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
VS.
NO. 05-5791 Civil
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
Defendant : CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Certificate of Service
I, BurtonNeil, Esquire, do hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of the within Plaintiff's
Reply to New Matter onpro se defendant, Louise M Lamoreaux, at her address of record via first class mail,
postage prepaid on the date set forth below.
BURTON NIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
Date: 1 + D BY.
Burton Neil, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
The law firm of Burton Neil & Associates is a debt collector.
C-8037
F.. M1
??
_+
4.
BURTON NEIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
By: Burton Neil, Esquire, Id. no. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
610-696-2120
Attomey for Plaintiff
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A. : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Plaintiff
:CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
LOUISE M. LAMOREAUX
NO. 05-5791 Civil
Defendant : CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Plaintiffs Motion For Sanctions
Plaintiff, Citibank (South Dakota) N.A. by and through counsel, Burton Neil, Esquire and
Burton Neil & Associates, P.C., moves the Court pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 4019 for sanctions
against defendant Louise M. Lamoreaux due to her failure to serve answers to interrogatories.
1. Plaintiff served defendant with interrogatories on December 17, 2005. A copy of the
interrogatories is attached as Exhibit A.
2. Defendant did not respond to the interrogatories.
3. On January 26, 2006, plaintiff s counsel wrote defendant requesting that she contact
plaintiffs counsel to confer regarding her failure to respond to the interrogatories.
4. Concurrence of opposing side was sought. On February 5, 2006 and February 15,
2006, voicemail messages were left for defendant to contact plaintiffs counsel.
5. To date of this motion, defendant did not answer the interrogatories.
WHEREFORE, plaintiff moves the Court to enter an Order compelling defendant to
serve full and complete response to plaintiff s interrogatories aspejfthe attached proposed Order.
BURTON NEIL &.ASSOCIATES, P.C.
By:
o Neil, Esquire
Attorn y for Plaintiff
In making this communication, we advise our firm is a debt collector.
BURTON NEIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
Burton Neil, Esquire, Id. no. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
610-696-2120
Attorney for Plaintiff
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Plaintiff
CUMBERLAND COLNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
NO. 05-5791
LOUISE LAMOREAUX
Defendant : CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories to Defendant
Plaintiff hereby serves these written interrogatories upon defendant who is to furnish
written answers within thirty (30) days after service of these interrogatories in accordance with
the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. The answers shall be inserted in the space provided
after each of the interrogatories; please attach additional pages if more space is needed for the
answers.
These interrogatories are continuing and demand is hereby made to amend or supplement
the answers as is required by the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. If the answering party is
a minor, a decedent's estate or an individual who is incompetent or under legal disability to
provide answers, the individual providing answers shall state his or her name and the authority
under which he or she is providing the answers. Full and complete answers the interrogatories
must be provided and signed by the party making the answers.
1. If you contend that any credits reflected in the monthly billing statements you received were
not accurate, explain in detail all reasons why you deny or dispute that the credits posted to the
account were inaccurate. Set forth the date and amount of each inaccurate credit, the amount you
believe is the correct credit and the date of the monthly billing statement in which the inaccurate
credit appeared.
EXHIBIT
2. To the extent you deny or dispute the accuracy of the credits posted in the monthly billing
statements, did you send a written billing error notice to Citibank (South Dakota) N.A. to dispute
or protest the credits you contend were not accurate?
3. If you contend that any debits reflected in the monthly billing statements you received were
not accurate, explain in detail all reasons why you deny or dispute that the debits posted to the
account were inaccurate. Set forth the date and amount of each inaccurate debit, the amount you
believe is the correct debit and the date of the monthly billing statement in which the inaccurate
debit appeared.
4. To the extent you deny or dispute the accuracy of the debits posted in the monthly billing
statements, did you send a written billing error notice to Citibank (South Dakota) N.A. to dispute
or protest the debits you contend were not accurate?
5. In paragraph 7 of the answer to the complaint, you alleged that objections were periodically
made concerning charges the account. When were these objections made and to whom were they
made?
6. With respect to objections periodically made, provide detail for each objection
a. Describe all reasons why you claimed a charge was not accurate.
b. If you wrote to Citibank (South Dakota) N.A. did you enclose any information such as
sales slips, payment records or other documents to support your position that the amount was not
accurate,
c. With respect to the disputes about billing errors do you contend there were any
unauthorized charges to the account?
d. Do your objections pertain to any charges that listed the wrong date or amount? If so,
describe any such charges.
7. With respect to objections periodically made, did you describe any failures to post payments
and other credits, such as returns?
8. With respect to objections periodically made, did you describe any failures to send bills to
your current address? If so, did you provide plaintiff with your change of address, in writing, at
least 20 days before the billing period ends?
9. With respect to objections periodically made, did you describe any charges for which you
asked for an explanation or written proof of purchase along with a claimed error or request for
clarification?
10. Provide the date and amount of each payment comprising the $5,410 in credits referenced in
paragraph 1 of defendant's new matter.
11. According to defendant's own records, what is the current balance owed to Citibank (South
Dakota) N.A. on the account?
Burton Neil & Associates, P.C.
By Burton Neil, Esquire
In making this communication, we advise our firm is a debt collector.
BURTON NEIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
By: Burton Neil, Esquire, Id. no. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
610-696-2120
Attorney for Plaintiff
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Plaintiff
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
LOUISE M. LAMOREAUX
NO. 05-5791 Civil
Defendant : CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Plaintiffs Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion For Sanctions
Plaintiff, Citibank (South Dakota) N.A. filed suit against defendant to recover the balance
owed on a credit card. Defendant filed an answer to the complaint. Plaintiff served defendant
with interrogatories which are attached to plaintiff s motion. Defendant failed to respond to
plaintiffs discovery. Pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. 4109 seeks the Court to enter an order compelling
defendant to respond to plaintiff s discovery. Pa R.C.P. 4019(a)(1)(i) provides "The court may,
upon motion, make an appropriate order if a party fails to serve answers... to written
interrogatories under Rule 4005." An appropriate order would be one pursuant to Rule
4019(c)(5), that is, "such order with regard to the failure to make discovery as is just " Under the
circumstances, plaintiff requests that an order be enter compelling defendant to answer plaintiff s
interrogatories.
BURTON NEIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
BY:
Burton Neil, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
In making this communication, we advise our firm is a debt collector.
BURTON NEIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
By: Burton Neil, Esquire
Identification No. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
610-696-2120
ATTORNEY FOR: Plaintiff
CITIBANK SOUTH DAKOTA N.A. : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Plaintiff : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
vs.
NO. 05-5791 Civil
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
Defendant : CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Certificate of Service
I, Burton Neil, Esquire do hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of the within
Motion for Sanctions, proposed Order and supporting Memorandum of Law onpro se defendant, Louise
M Lamoreaux at his/her address of record via first class mail, postage prepaid on the date set forth
below.
BURTON NEIk'& ASSOCIATES, P.C
r
Date: G BY:
uon eil, Esquire
Atton for Plaintiff
The law firm of Burton Neil & Associates is a debt collector.
C-8037
,
?
'?
?-
'
,
L
a
t FEB 0 9 2007,F/
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Plaintiff
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
NO. 05-5791 Civil
LOUISE M. LAMOREAUX
Defendant : CIVIL ACTION - LAW
ORDER
AND NOW, this day of wry , 2006 on consideration of
Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Answers to Interrogatories, it is hereby Ordered that the Defendant
Louise M. Lamoreaux is directed to answer Plaintiff's interrogatories within 20 days of the date
SX,V "46. -1
of this Order.
A
BY THE COURT:
e
o`%
9 1 .g WV £ 1933 LQQI
kViO NOHIOdd 3HI 30
Burton Neil & Associates, P.C.
By: Burton Neil, Esquire ID. NO. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
610-696-2120
Attorney for Plaintiff
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A.
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
Defendant
NO. 05-5791 Civil
: CIVIL ACTION -LAW
Certificate of Service
I, Burton Neil, Esquire, do hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of the Court's
February 12, 2007 Order on pro se defendant, Louise M Lamoreaux, at her address of record via first
class mail, postage prepaid on the date set forth below.
Date: f 0
Burton Nei'-& AAsociates, P.C.
Burton Neil, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
The law firm of Burton Neil & Associates is a debt collector.
C-8037
1
-L?1
',? ? ?;r?I
?..ry
?
..
i
r
?
.
r 4
M
J
.? -..
i ?.
y
-
_,L
?, ??? ?
?
{
-? +
?{
i ? ?
f
?"'yj
?
t
=?4
?? G..7
V
i
BURTON NEIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
By: Burton Neil, Esquire, Id. No. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
(610) 696-2120
Attorney for Plaintiff
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Plaintiff
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
: NO. 05-5791 Civil
Defendant : CIVIL ACTION -LAW
Plaintiffs Motion for Summary Judgment
Plaintiff, Citibank (South Dakota) N.A., hereby moves under Pa R.C.P. 1035.2 for
summary judgment against defendant in the sum of $9,222.42 for the following reasons:
1. The pleadings, which consist of the complaint and answer, are closed.
2. Plaintiff served defendant with requests for admission which defendant failed to
answer. A copy of plaintiff s requests and proof of mailing are attached hereto as Exhibit A.
3. Plaintiff s affidavit in support of the motion is attached as Exhibit B. As reflected in
the affidavit, subsequent to the filing of the lawsuit defendant paid $1,500.00 which reduced the
lawsuit balance from $10,722.42 to $9,222.42.
4. There is no genuine issue of material fact which will require a trial. Therefore,
plaintiff is entitled to summary judgment.
J
WHEREFORE, plaintiff Citibank (South Dakota) N.A. moves the Court enter summary
judgment pursuant to Pa R.C.P. 1035.2 for it and against defendant in the sum of $9,222.42 plus
record costs of $96.94 for a total judgment of $9,319.36.
BURTON N & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
By:
Attorney for Pl ntiff
In making this communication, we advise our firm is a debt
9
LAW OFFICES
Burton Neil BURTON NEIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
Edward J. O'Brien 1060 ANDREW DRIVE, SUITE 170
Yale D. Weinstein WEST CHESTER, PENNSYLVANIA 19380
Derek C, Blasker 610-696-2120
Brit L suttell Facsimile 610-696-4111
Neil Sarker Email: Burton.neil@burt-law.com Refer to File #
April 23, 2007 C-8037
Louise M Lamoreaux
850 Yverdon Drive
Camp Hill PA 17011-1850
RE: Citibank South Dakota, NA
Account with Louise M Lamoreaux
Dear Ms. Lamoreaux:
I herewith serve upon you Plaintiffs Request for Admissions.
Very truly yours,
Burton Neil
BN/sb
In making this communication, we advise that this firm is a debt collector.
U.S . P ost al Se rvice
CE R TIF IED MAIL RE CEI PT
= (Dom
For d esti
elive c M
rv ini ail Only
on.,ar ; No Ins urance Cover age Pr ovided)
fu
V7
a
N
W7
M
C7
Q
0
Q
rq
t3
r
Ca
r`
EXHIBIT_ A __
t
¦ Complete Items 1, 2; and 3. Also complete
item 4 If Restricted DsINwy Is desired.
¦ Print your nerve and address on the reverse
so that we can return the card to you.
¦ Attach this card to the beck of the mailpieoe,
or on the front If space permits.
1../ Ar icis Addressed to
F-ouiSG Ls'"O?'ea4d?C
A. S%F%d re
E3
Agent
X
li3?e
A-4-41
B. llecelred by (Prh J MW* C. Dame, of DWtMY
?TC1ftn Y-24-2
0. Is delrsry address dnlere A from asm 1 T MY"
it Yes, errter delivery address below. 0 No
?So yyshi'e?1 Q??dG ? (?- ?03?
Pfl /-?.Oft a servic.lyps
Certified Mal ? Mel
D Reylstensd R'Retrxn Reoelpm for Merdumdiae
E3 knumd mom 0 C.O.R.
4. Restricted DelvsryR X%VS FON 13 Yee
z Article Number 7006 0100 0005 5052 0975
(Th new from service
Ps Form 3811, February 2004 Domestic Rerun Reoelpt 1025,540
Burton Neil & Associates, P.C.
By: Burton Neil, Esquire ID. No. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
610-696-2120
Attorney for Plaintiff
CITIBANK SOUTH DAKOTA N.A.
Plaintiff
V.
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
Defendant
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
: NO.05-5791 Civil
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Plaintiffs First Set of Requests for Admission to Defendant
Plaintiff, by its undersigned attorney, hereby serves upon defendant the within Request
for Admissions pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. No. 4014. Your attention is called to Rule 4014(b) which
provides:
Each matter of which an admission is requested shall be separately set forth.
The matter is admitted unless, within thirty days after service of the request, or within
such shorter or longer time as the court may allow, the party to whom the request is directed
serves upon the party requesting the admission an answer verified by the party or an objection,
signed by the party or by the party's attorney; but, unless the court shortens the time, a defendant
shall not be required to serve answers or objections before the expiration of forty-five days after
service of the original process upon him or her.
If objection is made, the reasons therefore shall be stated. The answer shall admit or deny
the matter or set forth in detail the reasons why the answering party cannot truthfully do so.
A denial shall fairly meet the substance of the requested admission, and when good faith
requires that a party qualify the answer or deny only a part of the matter of which an admission is
requested, the party shall specify so much of it as is true and qualify or deny the remainder.
An answering party may not give lack of information or knowledge as a reason for failure
to admit or deny unless the answering party states that he or she has made reasonable inquiry and
that the information known or readily obtainable by him or her is insufficient to enable him or
her to admit or deny. A party who considers that a matter of which an admission has been
requested presents a genuine issue for trial may not, on that ground alone, object to the request.
That party may, subject to the provisions of Rule 4019(d), deny the matter or set forth reasons
why he or she cannot admit or deny it.
Requests for Admission
1. With reference to the monthly billing statements for defendant's credit card account
with plaintiff copies of which are attached hereto as requests for admissions exhibits 1 through
25:
a. Defendant admits that the detail set forth in each monthly billing statement accurately
reflected for the monthly billing period defendant's use of the account and accurately reflected all
charges and credits to the account.
b. Within 60 days after defendant's receipt of each monthly billing statement defendant
admits that no writing or other communication disputing, protesting or objecting to any of the
charges or credits appearing in the monthly billing statements was sent by defendant to plaintiff.
c. Defendant admits that with respect to each monthly billing statement, a written billing
error notice was not sent to plaintiff.
2. Defendant admits that after receipt of the monthly billing statements marked exhibits
1-4,6-8,10-12,14-17,19,21 defendant made a payment which was reflected as a credit in the
following month's statement.
3. Defendant admits that after receipt of the monthly billing statements marked exhibits
5,9,13,18,20,22-25 defendant did not send a payment to plaintiff.
4. Subsequent to receiving billing statement 25, defendant admits that the following
payments were applied to her account:
a. $4,410.00
b. $500.00
c. $500.00
d. $1,000.00
5. Defendant admits that the last payment made on the account was posted by plaintiff on
August 25, 2005.
6. Defendant admits that balance owed on the account is $9,319.36.
Burton Neil & Associates, P.C.
By:
Burton Neil, Esquire
In making this communication, we advise that this office is a debt collector.
C-8037
Verification
1, Louise M Lamoreaux, defendant in the within action, hereby verify that the statements of fact
made in the foregoing Requests for Admission are true and correct to the best of the undersigned
my knowledge and belief. The undersigned understands that the statements made herein are
subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. Section 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to
authorities.
Date: d - -
Louise M Lamoreaux
08/07/03 $9747.36 3203.00 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KCB5076
$-i_ ° M OWN. W. 1 12/09/05 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
P.O. SOX 8108
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX S HACKENSACK, NJ
850 YVERDON DRIVE 07606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
rcr a ? OO °`N .
Citl' Driver's Edge*
Platinum Select Card-Charter Rbts
Account Number n^r?+r~ wan.,rea BOX 6500
5424 1800 3531 8168 SIOUX FALLS, SO
PAYMENT MOST ME RECEIVE@ BY 2.00 PM LOCAL TIME On 00/07/2003 mtpra vwff Wa 57117
Wenwr4ft- I ; Oats Total Cndit Lin. Avaiabk CrWR Lim Cash Adva * LkMi Avalabl. Cash Lbws Now parano.
07/14/2003 $25000 $152p5v?2 $5600 !$5/600 $9747.36
crWt iJaa ` Past OWN klNnaie Du. Mlr*mm Armad Ow
$0.00 ; $0.00 f $203.00 a $203.00
..n..,.. ,www ... P.-W-Y aiaw ?fc ac.ww AMMwat
6/30
7205
Be
Pa nts Credits A Adjustments
62
25 PO ME
NOHANK YOU -200.00
0000
7/14 CREDITSHIELD PREMIUM
6.13
6/24
6/24
SV7LTTLS 74 0000
UNITED 0167512510367 MANKATO MM 0000000000
269,00
6124
6/24
2W?LTTLS 61 E3000US 1019
UNITED 0167512510368 MANKATO MN 93410193176
269.00
6/24
6/24
CXQORS30 6L E3000US 1019
Orbitz • Service Fees WWWORBITZCOM IL 93410193176
10.00
6/24
6/24
9MPS1.OO 61 A4722US 1065
AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE 88541863176
37.42
7/14 61 M5969USA 2019
PURCHASESOFINANCE CHARGE•PERIODIC RATE 75414913175
118.19
84 0000 OOOOOODOOD
CASH WHEN YOU NEED IT - It's easier than ever to
get cash up to your available CasA Advance
Limit. Vear off the attached check, deposit it
into your bank account, or use it like any
personal check. Convenience Checks access the
cash advance portion of your credit line. Refer
to your Citibank Card Agreement for specific
finance charges.
• CITI DRIVER'S EDGE CHARTER MEMBER REBATES *TOTAL
Last Month's Balance 174.71
Earned this Month 11.71
Redeemed/Expired 0.00
Current Balance 186.42
Citi Driver's Edge Charter Member rebates expire 3
years after they are earned. Expired rebates
will be'deducted from your rebate account.
23.42 rebates will expire on DECEMBER 31, 2003
Please see the enclosed privacy notice for important
information.
EXHIBIT I
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
beY DOW PWt Date ntalirews Number Aetblq slaw Last Sta wont Am=M
Account Summary
PURCHASES
ADVANCES
TOTAL
Rata Swmnary
PURCHASES
Standard Purch
ADVANCES
Standard Adv
$9,237.62
=0.00
$9,237.62
=9,575.90
MOD
551.55 $2 00.00
$59/.55 5200.00
Periodic
Rate
0.03740X(0)
0.05477%(D)
$1 8.19 $9,747.36
1
$18.9 $9,747.36
Da s ThiS 9pM PDttod: 33
Nominal ANNUAL
APR p g0J ff r RATE
13.650% 13.650%
19.990% 19.990%
09/08/03 $9691.50 ;201.00 SITE:KC-CL TM:CD-5000 ACID;KC85076
# N a w.1_ v 12/09/05 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX P.O. BOX 8108
850 YVERDON DRIVE S HACKENSACK, NJ
CAMP HILL PA 07606-8108
17011-1850000
Citi Driver's Ed
e' rorcusbamar=??o??
g
Platinum Select Card-Charter Rbts 1-800-967-8500
A=ount Number
5424 1800 3531 8168 To am mom avem a,Ma BOX 650D
4100 - 0011041M
PATMES7 MafT RE RECEIVED BY 1:00 PM LOCAL TIME ON 09/06/100 SIOUX FALLS, SD
57117
snab"Wr tXbow; Date TOUT CredR LW Available Croft Line Cash Advance Lkn t Avaaabla Caah Limn Now Balance
08/13/2003 $25D00 $
1
5
308 $5600
$5600 $9691.50
m
ou
M
Credt Lit r
$0
00 Part Ow MWMI-W
. Ad
CZ. MlnNwm Amouaa ow
. $0.00 + $201.00 - $201.001
6/06 43731122
8/13
7/21 7/21 3D33HT00
8/13
PATMENTsfHANK YOU R Adiustnaents
70 0000 0000 -220.00
Standard Pureh
C
74 0000 REDITSHIELD PREMIUM 6.26
AI 0000000000
AIG LIFE FE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE 37.42
61 N5969USA 2019 75414913202
PURCHASES•FINANCE CNARGE•PERIODIC RATE 120.46
84 0000 0000000000
CASH WHEN YOU NEED IT - It's easier than ever to
get cash up to your available Cash Advance
Limit. tear off the attached check deposit it
into your bank account, or use it Tike any
personal check. Convenience Checks access the
cash advance portion of your credit line. Refer
to your Citibank Card Agreement for specific
finance charges.
• CITI DRIVER'S EDGE CHARTER MEMBER REBATES *TOTAL
Last Month's Balance 1a6.42
Earned this Month 0.75
Redeemed/Expired 0.00
Current Balance 187.17
Account SLnmary revious + ur s -
ants (+) FINAKU =
r-T
PURCHASES
ADVANCES
Beane &
$9,747.36
$0
00
Advances & Cyr dit
s
t<43.68
$210.00
0
00
0
0
CHARGE
z
$1
00 e w
.
9,6
TOTAL 59.7
. .
.
0
.68 $
543
5220.00 $0.
$120
46 0.00
. $9,691.50
Rites Summary
SuWact
o
c
Periodic Da This BRII Period: 30
h- 0
Finan
e C Rate APMai ANNUAL
PURCHASES P ERCENTASE TE
Standard Purch
ADVANCES $9,776.96
0.04107%(D)
14.990%
14.990%
Standard Adv $0.00 0.05477%(D) 19
990%
. 19.990%
EXHIBIT
10/OT/03 $9995.48 $208.00 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KC85076
".$ 12/09/05 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX P.O. BOX 8108
850 YVERDON DRIVE S NACKENSACK. NJ
CAMP HILL 07606-8108
PA
17011-1850000
Citi Driver's Edge' 1 -60D Fer?,?te.e.r=. ,?aerWF"
Platinum Select Card-Charter Rbts -967-8500
Account Number Tar-taaryn..eR.,b BOX 6500
5424 1800 3531 8168 to#6brtaagaaagalli SIOUX FALLS, 5D
PAYrENT MoS1 It RECEIVED NY 1:00 ?n LOCAL TIME on 10/07/2003 nrtre.ws.T«el.yb 57117
Sfatem KICW" Date Total Cra lk Line Avail" Ceadt tine CashA&are Lbntf Available Cash LNaa New Balance
09/12/2003 $25000 $15004 $5600 $5600 $9995.48
Amount Over A?
Credit Llno Past DUO M11 DW Lnnlnum Aneoud Duo
$0.00 + $0.00 + $208.00 = $208.00
e ?
6/19
8/28
8/28
8/28
9/02
9/06
9/12
8/19
8/28
8/28
8/28
9/02
9/12
42903199
OZ0e9000
3CDZ266S
ML4BK4DC
ML4BK4DC
OID2163G
Pa wants. Credits ii Adfrstfnents
70 PAYMENT 0000 THANK YOU 0000
AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE
61 N5969USA 2019
ONLIKENOTEL RESERVATIO 8002569089 TX
61 A4722US 1141
US AIRWA03774556812165 ARLINGTON YA
61 E3063US 1141
US AIRWA03774556812176 ARLINGTON VA
61 E3063US 1141
URBAN NUTRITION INC. TEL2018762570 NJ
61 A5499U5
PURCHASES'FINANCE CHARGE•PERIODIC RATE
CASH WHEN YOU NEED IT - It's easier than ever to
get cash up to your available Cash Advanca
limit. tear off the attached check deposit it
into your bank account, or use t l(ke any
personal check. Convenience Checks access the
cash advance portion of your credit line. Refer
to your Citibank Card Agreement for specific
finance charges.
• CITI DRIVER'S EDGE CHARTER MEMBER REBATES 'TOTAL
Last Month's Balance 187.17
Earned this Month 7.91
Redeemed/Expired
Current Balance 195.08
Remember. every time you use your Driver's Edge Card
for ppurchases, you earn Driver's Edge Rebates that
can be used towards the purchase or lease of a new
or used vehicle. See your Driver's Edge Directory
of Services for complete details.
-220.00
00000000006.35
754149132317 42
785059432419.89
934507932419 00
119.00
93450793241
39
98450963246 .99
122.33
0000000000
EXHIBIT 3
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
3010 Dab Post Data astsnaa nlaaraf Actift Slats Lad Uataawat Aawuat
Account Summary
PURCHASES
ADVANCES $9,6 1.50
0.00 $4 1.65 $2 0.00
10
00 il $122.33 Ce
=9.9
TOTAL
$9,6 1.50 .
0.00
$401.65 $220.00 0.00
$112.33 $s0.
$9,945.48
0a Thk aMMa Period: 30
Rate Summary Balance Subject Periodic om ,
Finance Charge
Rate
APR ANNUAL
PURCHASES
Standard Purch
ADVANCES $9,928.83 0.04107%(D) 14.990% 14.990%
Standard Adv $0.00 0.05477%(D) 19.990% 19.990%
11/06/03 $10889.91 $226.00 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KC85076
12/09/05 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
P.O. BOX 8108
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX S HACKENSACK, NJ
850 YVERDON DRIVE OT606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
17DIl-1850000
Citi' Driver's Ed
e' ForCustoanrBar&*,calorvIF"
g
Platinum Select Card- Charter Rbts 1-800-967-6500
Ac:couatHumber
5424 1800 3531 6168 110"c"600"Mmkoft,
ftme r.wtel" "
t BOX 6500
SIOUX FALLS
SD
PAYMENT MIST It VICEIYED BY 1900 PM LOCAL 719E 01 11/06/2003 ru
R-"-y-dor? ,
57117
stale" WIC"Ag ode Total C99d* LIM
10/14/2003 $25000 AvaNaBY Cmdk Uro Cash AdvocA Undl AraNable Caab Unit Maw eaNnce
4
0
$1
1
1
$5600 $5500
A
eu
?t
p
?
r
C9Mt Uw
Pad Due $10889.91
WAd
M1=.
CZ. Nh*num AwmrA gut
$0.00 + $0.00 + $226.00 = $226.00
10/06 41976525
10/14
9/18 9118 TRX2Y400
10/01 10101 R5ZQXIRL
10/14
PAYMENTsTHANKaYOU >i Adjustments
70 0000 0000 -250.00
Standard Purch
REDIT5
HIELD PREMIUM 6
68
?
74
AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE .
0000400000
37
42
61 M5969USA 2019 .
75414913261
NCL-RESERVATIONS MIAMI FL 963
08
61 A4411US 1065
PURCHASES*FINANCE CHARGEOPERIODIC RATE .
97499673274
137
25
84 0000 .
0000000000
" CITI DRIVER'S EDGE CHARTER MEMBER REBATES *TOTAL
Last Month's Balance 195.08
Earned t is Month 20.01
RedeemedLExpired 0.00
Current BBBBalance 215.09
Citi Driver's Edge Charter Member rebates expire 3
years after they are earned. Expired rebates
will be deducted from your rebate account.
23.42 rebates will expire on DECEMBER 31. 2003
Our records show hone phone 717-761-8236 and
business phone 717-238-6715. Please update above
coupon if incorrect.
The Bose Nave radio/CD delivers lifelike sound. Yet
it'
s small and si"lle to use. Your satisfaction is
qq
. To
u8
00-249-
673 Ext
his
r
r
1
8
2
brought to
79. T
. TO
after
is
you by Media Syndication Global.
an
k
to rent a car from
He
o
nd enjo
d
a
r
Y
g
rti
vin4
reat
a
the world! Call 1-800-654-2200 and mention
s
s
your
Citibank Hertz COP number 160005.
L?
EXHIBIT
R
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
Sob Daft Pat We Weraw wmNr wdm sine ud usblant Abrm*
Account Summary Previous M Purchases "an s + FINANCE :) ew
Balance 6 Advanegs s Credits CHARGE Balance
PURCHASES
ADVANCES $9,995.48 $1,097.18
10.00 $0
00 $2 0.00
0
00
11 $117.25 $10.889.91
TOTAL .
$9,995.48 $1,007.18 .
0.00
$2 60.00
$137.25 0.00
$10.89.91
0a This BRR Padit 32
Rate Suamary a ante Sub)ecf to
Finance Charge Periodic
Rat Nominal ANNUAL
Dnoruacrc e APR P ERCENTAGE RATE
Sd Porch $10,443.16 0.04107%(D) 14.990% 14.990%
rd Adv $0.00 0.05477%(0) 19.990% 19.990%
M
12/08/03 $11720.93 $244.00 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KC65076
12/09/05 18:52:55:
ism
CITI CARDS
P.O. BOX 8108
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX S HACKENSACK, NJ
850 YVERDON DRIVE 07606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
Citi' Driver's Edge" rsm•rS.rYk.,a0orwtxo
Platinum Select Card-Charter Rbts ?
Account
5424 1800 3531 8168 Tar+uthma.a-ML MR.
t BOX 6500
SIOUX FALLS
SD
PAYMENT MOST RE RECEIVED IT 1:00 Pa LOCAL TIME OR 12/OS/ZO03 as
poonve" r4ftL ,
57117
St;absmant/Cb" Cabo TOW C"dR Lim
11/12/2003 $25000 AVallaW Crack Use CashA 4 , Limit AaaNabla Cash umR Mar ealsapa
$1
32
7
9 $5600 $56
0
0
$11720.93
?'?f
13
Q
?""" "
`
d
?
MMlmun ADua Mlrkmm Amw t Duo
$0.00 + $0 00 + $244.00 = $244
00
Sak b f. P-6 B.&. - ----- ..??. ..??..--- • --- -• - - .
10/31
4174IZ31 Psrrments Credits A AdfustRUnts
PATMENT fzK YOU
10/22 10/22 •S3VOV3o CARNIVALOCRUISE/MANUAL0MIAMI FL
71 4411U5 1065
11/12 CREQITSHIEL.ELD rcPREMIUM
10/20 10/20 OYTC•V30 74
CARNIVALLOCRUISE TKT/RE MIAMI FL
10/20 10/20 Y2KL3R30 61
EXPEDIA SERVICE FEE 10 SOO-EXPEDIA wA
10/20
10/20
L7V4OXYG 61 A4722US 1065
DELTA 00675274278243 ATLANTA GA
10/20
10120
6eV40XYG 61 E305SUS 1734
DELTA 00675274278254 ATLANTA GA
10121
10/21
GP632200 OUS
AIG LIFE - TERM INS 173301300075620 DE
30/27
10/27
RD219R30 61 N5969USA 2019
EXPEDIA CORPORATE TRAV 888-249-3978 wA
11/12 PURCHO FINANCE CMARGEOPERIODIC RATE
• CITI ORIVER'S EDGE CHARTER MEMBER REBATES •TOTAL
Last Month's Balance 215.09
Earned t11??is Month 18.41
Redeemed[ Expired 0.00
Current ggalance 233.50
Your Citi MasterCard could turn your holiday shop-
fin9 into something stupendowsl ften was the last
time you enjoyed a vacation filled with lauahter and
fun with friends or family? 11/1 through 12/3172003.
For details visit https://www.Mastercard.com
Get $5 Statement Credit. Sign up for All Electronic.
You'll have instant access to your statement online,
without that pile of paper. Get an a-mail notice
when your statement is ready. Register or sign-on to
citicards.con and choose Manage My Account.
-235.00
975418632970.00
00000000007.37
501.96
9TS41863294
29.99
88541863295
934173432948??
934173432948.00
37 4Z
75414913294
15.00
88541863302
0000000000 .28
EXHIBIT_ 5
a
LOUISE M LAHOREAUX
Sata Dab Past Dab 11191mm" iMo?lor AetMtr NM L" Steb Mat Aa t
Account Summary rrwious
B (t) Purchases aym s + FINANCE (:) Now
alance i Advances i Credits CHARGE Bal
PURCHASES
ADVANCES
$10,g¢9.91
00
10
$9¢7.74 =275.00
00
60
$1 8.28 ance
=11,
0.93
TOTAL .
;10,889.91 .
0.00
;967.74 $215.00 518.28 70
$11,720.93
B
l D This BIN Parkxt 29
Rata Sumtaary a
ance ec t o Periodic Nominal
PURCHASES
Finance Charge
Rate
PR ANNUAL
CEN GE RATE
Standard Purch
ADVANCES $11,610.28 0.04107%(D) 14.990% 14.990%
Standard Adv $0.00 0.05477%(D) 19.990% 19.990%
01/06/04 $12853.85 $510.59 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KC85076
swap= 12/09/05 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
lOUISE M LAMOREAdX P.O. BOX 8108
5
850 YVERDON DRIVE SACK, Ni
CAMP HILL 07660606--818108
PA
17011-1850000
Citi Driver's Edge' PorCus4sbwrSarrke aMar-.
Platinum Select Card-Charter Rbts 1-600-967-8500
Account Number To?eertM"ana,a-aa BOX 6500
5424 1800 3531 8169 to'Z -=- SIOUX FALLS, SD
PATMENT MOST NE RECEIVED BY 1:00 PE LOCAL TIME ON 01/06/ZO04 ?'? ' ` 57117
Sdtan@i/cW np Dab Total Credt Line AVaNMM Croft Line Cash ACranc• LbWt Aralf"k Cab Umlt new 84110p
12/12/2003 $25000 $?1g221p4Va6 $5600 $5600 $12853.85
CC $0.00r + Part Due YM1?mWn?Dw YlMmuia Amotnt Duo
=243.59 + $267.00 = $510.59
Sob Date Poet Dab Adwomca NuWAff AdM q Shoe Last Stabmaat ._?.
12/01 88988888
12/12
12/12
12/12
11/13 11/13 VD3X8T00
11/13 11/13 5CH74YVD
11/13 11/13 DGM74YVO
11/18 11/18 C•LY9P00
12/04 12104 VK9MMND3
12/05 12/05 KXCFN7MM
12/09 12/09 XHJK"P30
12/09 12109 HDJK•P30
12/12
CR
SN nARTZ SETTLEMENT AR NND 800 558-5854
72 0000 9999
i P FEE DEC 03-MOV 04
ELD PREMIUM
- NOY PAYMENT PAST DUE
AIR
ffM INS
OKS 201
TION
:SSA TX
K YORK TX
Y YORK TX
,300075620 DE
x-8309532 CA
NORTH TX
-845-8856 FL
-B45-8856 FL
ERIODIC RATE
• CITI DRIVER'S EDGE CHARTER MEMBER REBATES *TOTAL
Last Month's Balance 233.50
Earned this Month 18.70
Redeemed/Expired
Current Balance 252.20
ofithetsettiemedtclndtheaSchwartz lawsuit Portion
The Annual Percentage Rate on your account is
subject to increase and Your ability to redeem
or earn Citi Driver's Edge Card rebates may be
suspended when you fail to make a payment to us
or any other creditor when due, exceed your
credit limit, or make a payment to us that is not
honored by your bank.
-.41
00000000000.00
00000000007.97
00000000005.00
785003733182.00
854386433193.44
654386433193.44
754149133228.79
784507833388
784101933432'34
88541863344 '50
885 41863344 '00
154.80
0000000000
EXHIBIT 6
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
Bob Dots Post Date Retemrn NwAar Ac"My State List Stalawwr t MaMt
Your current nominal annual percentage rate for
purchases may vary W thly and is based on the
(fall Street Journal Priam Rate plus 10.990%.
However if you default on any card Agreement,
our ra{e may increase. The new rate will be the
rime Rate pus up to 23.990%, based on the
nature of defaults and performance indications.
These rates apply to your account at the time this
statement was priinted.
Please see the enclosed Notice of Change in Terms to
Your Card Agreement for important information
regarding changes to your card Agreement.
Get rewarded for paying your taxes!
Charge yyour taxes on your Driver's Edge Card.
Call 1-B00-2PAY-TAX for more information.
Account Summary
Balanea (+
c aces
MA
& Advances
Credits
FINANCE
"CHARGE
Do=
PURCHASES $11,720
.93 MOM 0
41 54.80
$1 $12,8 3.85
TOTALCES 0
00
$11
720
93 $918. 00 10
:
4/ s
00
4. 83
85
.
. 0. $15
8
0 $12,
.
Da This Biting Period 30
Rate Summary Balance iac to Periodic Nominal AIINUAL
Finance Charg e Rate APR PERCEMTAGE RATE
Purch $12,564.02 0.04107%(0) 14.990% 14.990%
Adv $0.00 0.05477%(D) 19.990% 19.990%
0205104 $12632.10 $263.00 SITE:KC-CL TM:C0-5000 ACID:KC65076
010, 12/09/05 18:52:55:
ERNME INANOW INN M-1
CITI CARDS
P.O. BOX 8108
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX S HACKENSACK. NJ
850 YYERDON DRIVE 07606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
Citi' Driver's Ed
e' or *oft
g
Platinum Select Card-Charter Rbts
AccountNombar
5424 1800 3531 8168 rra.irr?oiW a? BOX 6500
SIOUX FALLS
5D
PATtaENT MIST DE RECEIVED eT 1:00 PU LOCAL TIDE ON 02105/1604 ?w....eTRrtow. ,
57117
Stats.aent/CkainO Csta Total CredR Lb* AvaeaNe Cron Line Cash AWanCs Licit AvaRahls Cash LIm1t Him 831sew
01/13/2004 $25000 $123
6
7 $5600 $5600 $12632.10
p
?r?
Anount
Crad6l0» r
Put Due
Y1i1 L Mtnhnum AwmW on
$0.00 + $0.00 + $263.00 = 3263.00
12/15
97679245 Pa mots Credits A Adjustments
PAYMENT fHANK YOU
70 0000 0000
c
1/13 PREMIUM
CREDITSHIELD
12/15 12/15 ESZ00000 SPEEDPAYOSERVICE FEE
12/17 12/17 96RNGVFP CUSTOM WOOLEN MILLS O?CARSTAIRS CAN
35.75 CANADIAN DOLLAR =
12/18
12/IB
07336SOD 61 B5699CA 9385
AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE
1/09
1/09
VNOWK500 61 X5969USA 2019
BLAIR * 800-458-6057 PA
1/13 PURCHASES`FINANCE CMARRGGEE`PERIODIC RATE
84 0000
* CITI DRIVER'S EDGE CHARTER MEMBER REBATES *TOTAL
Last Month's Balance 252,20
Earned this mouth 2.03
Redeemed/Expired 23.42
Current Balance 230.81
Citi Driver's Edge Charter Member rebates expire 3
years after they are earned. Expired rebates
will be deducted from your rebate account.
23.42 rebates expired on DECEMBER 31 2003
35.76 rebates will expire on DECEMRU 31. 2004
Your Citibank credit card provides the convenience
of transacting in foreign currencies worldwide
wherever MasterCard is accepted without having to
exchange and carry more foreign currency than you
need for your transaction. Your transaction is
converted into U.S. dollars based on a wholesale
market rate or a government-mandated rate.
MasterCard increases that rate by 1%, and Citibank
increases the rate provided to i by MasterCard
by 2%.
-511.00
7.99
0000000000
000000000004.95
27.67
75186893352
58.79
7541491335Z
14.98
78432864009
00000000004.87
.r
EXHIBIT
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
sw ode put Doh netereece number Acthal Siece Last Statement Ameuet
Account Summary Previous +) ure aces (- Payments + FINANCE N Now
balance & Advances & Credits CHARGE Balance
PURCHASES
CES $12.8130: 85 $1$24.38 $511.00 4.87
$1 $12,? 2.10
TOTAL $12,.85 $124.38 $511.00 0
$164.87 $12,632.10
Days This exx Perhrt 32
RNte Summary Balance SuWect t
Finance Charge o Periodic
Rate Nominal
APR ANNUAL
'
PURCHASES pE R
CENTA RATE
Standard Purch
ADVANCES $12.544.74 0.04107%(D) 14.990% 14.990%
Standard Adv $0.00 0.05477%(D) 19.990% 19.990%
t
03/05/04 $12991.04 $270.00 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KC85076
IN 12/09/05 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX P.O. BOX 8108
850 YVEROON DRIVE S SACK. NJ
CAMP HILL PA 0766D606--818108
17011-1850000
Citr Driver's Edge' F?t ??.«•
1-800-967-8500
Platinum Select Card-Charter Rbts
5424 AM' Number 3531
8268
[ 601'"
"Oft Fm 1 "P""
"1M Box 65.00
SIOUX FALLS
SD
PATN
n1 RNST SE NECUVEO By 1:00 PM LOCAL TIME ON 01/05/2004 ,
57117
sh** ant/Ciasinq Date Taal Crudlt Line AveliAleCradn Line CwhAdvwe Limit AwOabb Cash UMN New oweaa
02/11/2004 $25000
$1122008 $5600
$5600 $12991.04
A
cradt, , Pat Due N VUL Mtlmum Amawl Ow
$0.00 + $0.00 + $270.00 = $270.00
Sub Date, Pant OVA ftgfw== Num ber Aetk*W Sloe. L.d st.e.....r
2111 61705587 PAYMEENNTsIHANKdYOU J~ A/justttents
70 0000 0000
2/11 CREDITSHIE PREMIUM
2/11 74 0000
LATE FEE - JAN PAYMENT PAST DUE
1/15 1/15 Lk5T6P30 IMAGINATION SAIL 6 SIG MIAMI FL
1/18
1/18
1Y4C8D39 61 D4411US 1065
WAL MART MECHANICSBURG PA
1/22 1122 GQZZRXOO AIG LIFE - TERM INS 106301300075620 DE
2111 61 N5969USA 2019
PURCHASES+FINANCE CHARGE+PERIODIC RATE
84 0000
When you pay your bill by check. you authorize us
to electronically process your payment. If your
check is processed electronically, your checking
account may be debited on the sane day we receive
the check and it will not be returned with your
checking account statewent. Yf someone other than
you ora bill paying service pays your bill, you
:lust give a copy of this notice to them before the
payment is sent to as.
e CITI DRIVER'S EDGE CHARTER MEMBER REBATES *TOTAL
Last Month's Balance 230.81
Earned thhis Month 8.69
Redeemed Expired 0.00
Current 999alance 239.50
IMPORTANT PROGRAM INFORMATION:
MasterCard renewed their insurance coverage with
Virginia Surety Company, extendingq Purchase
Assurance, Extended Warranty and MasterRental
through January 31, 2005.
-275.00
00000000008.33
35.00
0000000000
705418640 64.80
141.13
70483824018
58.79
75414914022
000000001005.89
EXHIBIT U
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
Sate Do. Pmt tiek newam a!wib.r Activity Stew Lost Staftmat Amount
Account SimTary B
l y ens
s (-s
PU
ADVAKES RCHASE
TOTAL a
ance 6
$12,6:232.10
.1 Advancer
Credits
$4
8
0.05 $270.00
15 CHARGE
$1
0.00 Balance
$12,991.04
$12.63
0 $
8
.
$Z75.00 5
S1 .89 $12,991.04
Rate Su.nmary
° Ge ec o
Periodic
Days TAIL
8NI Period; 29
o
Finance Char a
Rate m n
APR ANNUAL
PURCHASES C _RTE
Standard Purch
ADVANCES $13,088.50 0.04107%(0) 1{,990%
14.990%
Standard Adv $0.00 0.05477%(D) 19.990% 19.990%
04/05/04 $12949.10 $269.00 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KCB5076
9 ( MIN " ? 12/09/05 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
P.O. BOX 8108
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX S HACKENSACK, NJ
850 7YERDON DRIVE 07606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
Citi' Driver's Edges Cltie
Pla lnum Select Card-Charter Rbts
5424 1600 3531 8168
Cttatotaer serYlca:
1-800-!67-8500 Total t
25000
Line Available CmM Line Cath Advance, umlt Available Cash Limit
$12050 $5600 $5600
New Balance
Box 6500 $12949.10
SIOUX FALLS, SO
ST117 03/1
c=, h A r`A0°nMt p
t z: Past Vale
1/2004 0
00 + M
+ Parch/Adv
'mom Dee mwmvm
Amount Daa
.
OO 269.00 = $269.00
sob Deft Post Date l1werem Num ber Activity Sine Lot statement
Amami
3/10
61850269 Parnests Credits 6 Adjest?attts
AYM
ANK YOU
PO
?D00
0000 -340.00
Standard Purch
3111 CREDITSHIELD PREMIUM 8.34
3/11 74TE F?- FEB PAYMENT PAST DUE 0000000000
35
00
2/18 2/18 9wNBNMoO 66 0000
AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE .
0000000000
58
79
3/11 61 M5969USA 2019
PURCHASES*FINANCE CHARGE*PERIODIC RATE .
7541441 55
93
84 0000 .
0000000000
* CITI DRIVER'S EDGE CHARTER MEMBER REBATES *TOTAL
Last Month's Balance 239.50
Earned this Month 1.19
Redeemed/Expired 0.00
Current Balance 240.69
Accent Staatnwy Previous + urc ases (-) synlen s (4) FINANCE : ew
Balance & Advances & Credits CHARGE Balance
PURCHASES
ADVANCES
TOTAL $12,991.04
60.00 $102.13 $300.00
$0.00
60.00 ;
10.00 $12.949.10
$12,941.04 $102.13 #300.00 3155.93 $12,949.20
0e, s This Nang Period; 29
Rata Summary Balance Subject to
Finance Charge erro Ic
Rate om?na ANNtiU1l
FuRCNASES APR PER CEyiTAG TE
Standard Purch
ADVANCES $13,092.16 0.04107%(0)
14.940%
14.990%
Standard Adv $0.00 0.05477%(D) 19.990% 19.990%
EXHIBIT
05/06/04 $13568.46 $600.90 SITE:KC-CL TM:C0-5000 ACID:KC85076
12/09/05 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
P.O. BOX 8108
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX S HACKENSACK. NJ
850 YVERDON DRIVE 07606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
r
Citi Driver's Edge' CI 1
Pla inum Select Card-Charter Rbts
5424 1800 3531 6168
Customer servh:e•
i-800-96T-6500•
TOW Credt LMe
$25000
AvWl" Cmdt LMa Cash Adveoce Urtk
$11431 $5600
Available Case LWW
$5600
New valance
$13568.46
00
BOX 65
SIOUX FALLS, SD
cfselData
2
A'nd"Min: Pest Due
r? .1. D
?
90 =
e sw
t
90
600
ST117 04
04/12/ 0.00 + 5269.00 + 1331. .
Sala Deft Pod Date OWWWRoe Raba Adh'tt/ WW8 tat sNtenwt Atemot
Standard Pureh
4/12 CREDITSHIELD PREMIUM
T4 0000
4/12 LATE FEE - MAR PAYMENT PAST DUE
66 0000
3/15 3/15 2NGNTOF* WM SUPERCEHTER SE2 MECHANICSBURG PA
61 A5411US 1065
3/17 3/17 CG4T3C2G LensCrafters 10004950 CAMP HILL PA
61 A8043US 1019
3/16 3/18 VMFPGJOO AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE
61 N5969USA 2019
4/12 PURCHASES*FINANCE CHARGE•PERIODIC RATE
84 0000
* CITI DRIVER'S EDGE CHARTER MEMBER REBATES *TOTAL
Last Month's Balance 240.69
Earned this Month 4.98
Redeemed/Expired 0.00
Current Balance 245.67
Citi Driver's Edge Charter member rebates expire 3
y4ors after they are earned. Expired rebates
will be deducted from your rebate account.
35.76 rebates will expire on DECEMBER 31. 2004
The Annual Percentage Rate on your account has
been increased due to one of the following reasons
stated in your Card Agreement with us: you failed
to wake a payment to as or any other creditor when
due. you exceeded your credit line or you made
a payment to us that was not honored by your bank.
Additionally. Your ability to redeem or earn
Citi Driver's Edge Card rebates may have been
suspended. Please call our toil-free number
above to learn about special yment options.
Call Monday through Frtda1:7:8a
0 a.m. to 9:00 p.m.
or Saturday 8:00 a.m. to 00 p.m. CST.
Our records show home phone 717-761-8236 and
business phone 717-238-6715. Please update
coupon if incorrect.
8.42
0000000000
35.00
0000000000
126.25
71483824076
64.00
70410194077
58.79
75414914076
326.90
0000000000
EXHIBIT /0
}
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
Sob Date Pact ab mtm.n 1MmMr Adirft $Mce Led $t•t~ Affmat
Accowt Strnmmry
PURCHASES
ADVANCES $12,949.10 $2 2.46
00
$0
00
;326.90 $13
5 8
46
TOTAL .
0.00 00
$12,949.10 :2 2.46 100.00 ,
.
10.
=36.90
A
$13,56
8
Rate Summary
• nee e to Periodic Da This BaM Perfo& 32
omins
eae,u ? rrr
Finance Charge Rate ANNUAL
APR arnr-vi rae a n.n
Parch $13,322.61 0.07668%(D) 27.990% 27.990%
Adv $0.00 0.07668%(D) 27.990% 27.990%
06/04/04 $13079.51 $314.72 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KC85076
---------- L. 12/09105 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
P.O. BOX 8108
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX S HACKENSACK, NJ
850 YVEROON DRIVE 07606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
Citi Driver's Edge'
Pla inum Select Card-Charter Rbts
5424 1800 3531 6168
0=M?W iota! Credlt UM AvaigbM CredN t.lae
$11920 Cast, Adraaae Llfnlt
$5600 Available Cash t,1mn
$5600
$25000
BOX 6500
FALLS,
? tstatement!
b%
i Amfeaat Over
0
0
00
call
+ 314 72
a7
i ?l
05/1M +
0
_ i
4/19 ` 44407414
5/10 162898369
4/20
5/12
5/12
4/20 VRG71NOO
5/12
CIT, 0
Now "Macy
$13079.51
Mdnwn+
Watt Due
1314
.72
PP>?YMEIiTTHANK Y011 I Adjustments
70 000 0000
TONOOOONANK YOU 0000
Standard Purch
CREDIOSOHOIOELO PREMIUM
LATE FEE - APR PAYMENT PAST DUE
66 AIG 5? TERM INS 201901300075620 DE
61 969USA PURCNASES•FINANCE CHARGE-PERIODIC RATE
84 0000
0 CITI DRIVER'S EDGE CHARTER MEMBER REBATES 2 5767
Last Month's Balance 1.18
Earned this Month 0 18
Redeemed/Expired 246.85
Current alance
Please note that payments must be received by
1:00 p.m., local time, on a bank business day at
the payment processing facility :bat handles your
payments, in order to be credited to your account
as of that day, and payments must conform to
the payment instructions set forth on the reverse
ssido. All conforming ppaayments received at the
beyacreditedcassofgthe followingebankabusinessill
day.
Notice of Change in Driver's Edge Rebate Program
Terms. You will have 90 days from your vehicle
Yur lhase Redemption a date nto complete and return the
ehicle Notice of Change in Driver's Edge Rebate Program
Terms. we pay change Program rules, restrictions or
benefits. in whole or in part, with 30 days prior
written notice. We way also terminate the Program or
portions thereof with 30 days prior written notice.
Want to receive your billing statement in Spanish?
Prefiere recibir su estado de cuenta en espanol?
Llamenos al 1.800-947-9100 Para elegir recibir su
estado de cuenta y las cartas de Servicio al
Cliente ea el idioms espanol.
-300.00
-601.00
8.54
0000000000
00000000005.00
58.79
75414914111
309.72
0000000000
EXHIBIT
LOWSE M LAMOREAUX
etaaissnt AAw?Ad
Bob Deto post not* uslwomm w4mber Amoy Slaps LW
Axcow* Sianmary Previous + ure ases .Payments
di (MINANICE
CHARGE m New
@alanee & Advances & Cre
ts Balance
PURCHASES
CES 613,5 p.46 $1$02.33 5?1.00 $3 .72
00 $13,079.51
TOTAL $13
568.46 $102.33 $900 00 $309.72 019.51
$13
, ,
Da This 8M Perlod• 30
'
Rah Summary • nce Su-blect to en a ammo ANNUAL
Finance Charge Rate APR P ERCENTAGE ATE
5d Purch $13,463.59 0.07666%(D) 27.990% 27.990%
rd Adv $0.00 0.07668%(D) 27.990% 27.990%
07/05/04 $13631.07 $302.01 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KC65076
12/09/05 18:52:55:
-
MENE
CITI CARDS
P.O. BOX 8108
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX S HACKENSACK, NJ
850 YVERDON DRIVE OT606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
Citl* Driver's Edge'
Platinum Select Card-Charter Rbts
CI vl+
Aosataa WNW
5424 1800 3531 8168
Custorow Satr 1=
1-800-967-8500 total credit Line AYSsabte eredk Lin. Cash Aevaaw UmH
$25000 $11368. $5600
Box 6500 stdoa ti Amaont over
SIOUX FALLS, SO ct n Date
0 nOtLine M
57117
06/1
004
10.00 + OO
$0.00 +
Awnabte Cast, Limn H" aia.a
$5600 $13631.07
.O1 a $302.01
nts Cradits E Adjustaents
Pagqtr
6/01 42084663 ?
PAAYME
NTT ANK YOU -320.00
O
0000
70
Standard Parch
6/10
5/19 5/19 80211YJ00 01300075620 DE
G LIFE
- TERM INS .79
9
2019
61 75414414140
5/28 5/28 M331WPJN ALAND RENT-A-CAR WARWICK RI 171.67
61 A338TUS 1065 78453264150
6/01 6/D1 ZLS'TYN3 ROYAL PLAZA HOTEL MIDDLETOWN RI 335.64
61 A7011US 1065 78547534154
6/10 PURCHASES•FINANCE CHARGE;PERIODIC RATE 297.01
84 0000 0000000000
e CITI DRIVER'S EDGE CHARTER MEMBER REBATES *TOTAL
Last Month's Balance 246.65
Earned this Month 11.32
Redeeteed Expired 0.00
Current alance 258.17
Kant to receive your billing statesrents in Spanish?
Prefiere recibir ss estado de cuenta en espanol?
Llamenes al 1-800-947-9100 pare elegir recibir su
estado de cuenta ]as cartas de Servicio al
Client0 an el idiy om espanol.
Account Summary Previous
541mce (+ Purchases
A Advances - Payments
& Cr*dls +
CHARGE Now
Balance
PURCHASES
ADVANCES $13.0 9.51
0
00 $574.55
$0
00 $3 0.00
50
00 =297.01
00 $13.6 1.07
TOTAL .
$13.0 9.51 .
$574.55 .
$320.00 .
$2107.01 0.00
$13,631.OT
Days Thb 8a Permd: 29
Rate Stanntary Be kame Subject
Finance Charg to
e Periodic
Rate Nominal ANNUAL
APR pERCENTAGE RATE
Purch $13,356.62 0.07668%(D) 27.990% 27.990%
Adv $0.00 0.07668%(D) 27.990% 27.990% EXHIBIT o?
08/06/04 $13761.52 $357.92 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KCB5076
NINOW 12/09/05 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
P.O. BOX 8108
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX S HACKENSACK, NJ
850 YVERDON DRIVE 07606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
Citr Driver's Edge" /1a
ati
Pla i,,,,num Select Card-Charter Rbts
ACCOURt
5424 1800 3531 8168
Customer Service:
1-800-967-8500 Tetal CredltLine Arailahle Credit Line Cash Advance Unit AvaRa ble cash Limit New Balance
$25000 $11238 $5600 $5600 $13761.52
agx 6500
Sbtemeat/ Amount W.
. post Dee
SIOUX FALLS, SD Cbair? Date W PaF04Ade
uMnww Due MMlmual
t Due
57117 07/13 /2004 10.00 + $0.00 +
OO 337.92 = 357.92
Sall ode Post Date Refs voce Num lar AeUeay Since Let Statement at
PBrrsiettts Credits i Adjustments
E
T
O
00
-325
7/12 61525347 U
AYM
N
N NK Y
? .
O
0000
Standard Purch
7/13
ELD PREMIUM
C
REDIT?I
8.74
O
74 ?00??0
T/13 LATE FEE - JUN PAYMENT PAST DUE 3
5.00
0000 000
0000000
6/21 6/21 BYHXJL00 AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE 58.79
61 R5969USA 2019 75414914173
7/13 RCNA5
8
•FINANCE CHARGE'PERIOOIC RATE 0 .92
0
4
0 0000000
0
* CITI DRIVER'S EDGE CHARTER MEMBER REBATES *TOTAL
Last Month's Balance 258.17
Earned this Month 1.18
Redeemed/Expired 0.00
Current 9Balance 259.35
Citi Driver's Edge Charter Member rebates expire 3
years after they are earned. Expired rebates
wilt be deducted from your rebate account.
35.76 rebates will expire on DECEMBER 31, 2004
Please see the enclosed privacy notice for important
information.
Fast Online Card Payments with Click-to-Pay
Pay your Citi card bill online anytime, day or night
Payments received by 1 p.m; EST will post that same
business day: Sign-on to citicards.com and choose
the Make a Payment menu.
Aced Summary Previous
Bal +1 Purchases
A Adv (- Payments
dit
& C [+) FINANCE (=) Now
CKARGE
ance ances re
s Balance
PURCHASES
ADVANCES $13,611 .07
0
00 $1p2.53
$0
00 $325.00
0
00 2 .92 $13,7 1.52
$3
0
TOTAL ,
07
631
$13 .
53
$102 .
$315
00 1
.00 $0.00
$3 2
92
,
. . . .
$13,761.52
Days This 81111in Period: 33
Rate Summary Balance Subject
Fi
Ch er ie
t om na ANNUAL
arg
nance e Ra
e APR PERCENTAGE RATE
rVRLnRaCa
Standard Purch $13,822.79 0.07737%(D) 28.240% 28.240%
ADVANCES
Standard Adv $0.00 0EXHIBIT l
.07737%(D) 28.240% 28.240%
09/06/04 $14188.28 $687.05 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KC85076
w it/09/03 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
P.O. BOX 8108
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX S HACKENSACK, NJ
850 YVERDON DRIVE 07606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
Cltl' Drivers Edge0
Platinum inum Select Card Charter Rbts NU~
5424 1800 3531 8168
Custonwr Swvloe:
1-800-967-8500 Toth CrodltUna Avall" Credk Llna Cash Advanu Limit Awallabee Cash Link
BOX 6500 $25000 $1081p1? $5600 $5600
SIOUX FALLS, SD C D N A 4n /M Line Past two A
57117 08/12/204 10.00 + $357.92 + 329.13 a
ab
New Meow
$14188.28
amt Due
687.05
8/12 CREDITSHIELD ePREMIUM
74 GOOD
8112 LATE 0000 AL PAYMENT PAST DUE
7/20 7/20 GY03RHOO AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE
61 U5969USA 2019
8/12 PURCMAS?ES*FINAMCE CHARGE*PERIODIC RATE
64 • CITI DRIVER'S EDGE CHARTER MEMBER REBATES *TOTAL
Last Month's Balance 259.35
Earned this Month 1.18
Redeemed/Expired 0.00
Current Balance 260.53
Want to receive your billingy statements in Spanish?
Pretiere recibir su estado de cuenta en espalol7
Llamnos al 1-800-947-9100 pare elegir recibr su
estado de cuenta y las cartes de Servicio al
Cliente.en el idioms espanol.
8.84
0000000000
35.00
0000000000
58.79
75414914202
00000000004.13
Accoutt Summary revious t
Balance 6 Purchases Payments
Advances 8 Credits +
CHARGE = Now
Balance
PURCHASES 313,7¢1.5Z $1 2.63 0.00 $3 4.13 $14,188.28
ADVANCES 10.00 0.00 0.00
1 0.00
1 $0.00
TOTAL $13,761.52 $
2.63 0.00 $3
4.13 314,1b8.28
Dr Thhi 8 Parlat 30
Rate Summary Be ones Subject to Wi is Nominal ANNUAL
Finance Charge Rate APR pERCENTAGE RATE
PURCHASES
Standard Purch $13,964.48 0.07737%(D) 26.240% 28.240%
ADVANCES
Standard Adv $0.00 0.07737%(D) 28.240% 28.240%
EXHIBIT
10/OT/04 $13918.00 $354.13 SITE:KC-CL T12/09/OSO ACID:18g52?55:
I
CITI CARDS
P.O. BOX 8108
LOUISE M LAMOR£AUX S HACKENSACK, NJ
850 VVERDON DRIVE 07606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
11011-1850000
' Clt!
s Edg
Driver
Citi
,
Rbts
Platinum Select Card-Charter
5424 1800 3531 8158
T*t*I Credit Una Aralle0k Credit Una Cash Aewnca itmlt Arallaele Cest+ UisR
1C-M. -n r967-8500 Services
$25000 $11082 $5600 $5600
New ealeece
=13918.00
BOX 6500
statemati A,must Over
SIOUX FALLS, SO t:lgat Dow 4r+slt Una Pset ae
00 +
+ $0
2
1?WAM¦N
13
1354 Mkdrwm
n1O?
13
= 354
.
04 10.00
57117 09/13/ . .
sob Doh Meet Data RNenwo RLmYer Activity dace L=t statomest Amaret
Par?rslents Credits i Adjustetents
HANK YOU
W
T -687,05
8/25 43426017 70Y
0000
00
00
Standard Purch
9/13 CREDITSHIELD PREMIUM
8.85
74 0000 0000000000
On 8/18 F9VSRG00 AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE
S969USA 2019
1 58.79
75414914231
I
6
9113 PU AS 0 •FINANCE CHARGE*PERIODIC RATE 349.13
84 000 ??
***Driver's Edge Charter Member Rebate Sumwary***
Previous Statement Rebates Total 260.53
Base Rebates Earned 1.18
Total Rebates Earned This Period 1.15
Total Rebates Available 261.71
Lifetime Rebates Earned 395.42
Bonus Rebates may take one to two billing cycles
to alpptar on your statement. Please refer to the
spec c terms and conditions pertaining to the
promotion for further details-
IMPORTANT INFORMATION ABOUT CREDIT REPORTING:
WE MAY REPORT INFORMATION ABOUT YOUR ACCOUNT TO
CREDIT BUREAUS. LATE PAYMENTS MISSED PAYMENTS OR
OTHERCDEFAULTS REPORTON "UR ACCOUR MAY BE REFLECTE6 IN
YOUR .
FREE SERVICES FOR CITI CARDMEMBERS
Manage your Citi Card account online securely,
c
bal
see
t t
k
h
your
e,
ec
an
o c
anytime-whether you wan
if a payment was received or pay your bill.
Register now at www.citicards.com
Account Summary rwLous + Purchased; eym (+) FINAW-E
Balance & Advances .& Credits CHARGE ¦ Now
Balance
PURCHASES
ES $14,188.28 $67.64 $687.05 $349.13
00 $0
00
00 $0
00 $0
$0 $13,916.00
$0.00
ADVANC
TOTAL .
.
.
.
$14,188.28 $67.64 $687.05 $349.13 $13,918.00
Rats Surnmary
Purch $13,978.78 0.07805%(D) 28.490% 28.490% `
Adv $0.00 D.07805%(D) 28.490% 28.490% EXHIBIT
11/04/04 $13651.09 $328.99 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KC95076
No-ow "rA , .? 12/09/05 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
P.O. 80X 8108
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX S HACKENSACK. NJ
850 YVERDON DRIVE 07606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
C it i' driver's Edge`
Pla inum Select Card-Charter Rbts
5424 1800 3531 8168
Servica:
ideffl rnr
8500
800
i^
--96967-
Total credit Une
Maltabk Credit line Cash Advance Umlt
$288 $5600
$13940
6
BOX
SIOUX FALLS, stateme"
d
e Amourd K
+
OsR
o
f 0 00 +
57117 10/13 4
/ D
sale ante F=d Deb aelereece Ilme ber Aadeef awe Lwt statement
Psyytaents Credits E
ANK YOU Adjustmmnts
9/15 43224659 POY 0 0000
19/08 42153139 AYME??HANK YOU
7 0000
Standard Purch
10/13 CREDITSHIELD PREMIUM
O
9/20 9/20 9SP26MOO - TERM INS
AIG LIIFFE 301300075620 DE
61 K5969USA 2019
9/29 9/29 FGP1T800 BARNES & NOBLE.COM 800-843-2665 NJ
61 A5192US 2222
9/30 9/30 LTN05C6S BOOK CLEARINGHOUSE INC HARRISON NY
6
05942US 2222
10/05 10/05 SBF5CM00 BARNES & NOBLE.COM 800-843-2665 NJ
61 A5192US 2222
10/09 10/09 YQ53TXOO BARNES&NOBLE BOOKQU EST 866-257-7723 NJ
61 A5192US 2222
10/13 PURCHASES*FINANCE CHARGE+PERIODIC RA TE
84 0000
***Driver's Edge Charter Member Rebate Summary***
Previous Statement Rebates Total 261.71
Base Rebates Earned 2.61
Total Rebates Earned This Period 2.61
Total Rebates Available 264.32
Lifetime Rebates Earned 396.03
Bonus Rebates may take one to two billing cycles
to apppear on your statement. Please refer to the
speclfic terms and conditions pertaining to the
promotion for further details.
Citi Driver's Edge Charter Member rebates expire 3
willsbeafter
deducted from yourdrebate account.
35.76 rebates will expire an DECEMBER 31, 2004
Our records show home phone 717-761-8236 and
business phone 717-238-6715. Please update
coupon if incorrect.
dtl'
Amiable Ceeh WnR
$288 New Calance
$13651.09
per.,
99 =
328 ?u_3a2'8 0
1328.99
. Annual;
-375.00
-355.00
8.69
00000000058.79
75414914264
18.69
78432864273
21.45
85505944275
22.74
55432864279
8.74
55432864283
323.99
0000000000
EXHIBIT 16
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
s210 Dab Pat Dab LLNa?a aembar Aet WY Sian Left Statamant Aagaat
Account Summary PrevkKn +) Purchases - Payments 01 FlMWF P) ew
Balance b Advances b Credits CHARGE Balance
PURCHASES $13,918.00 39.10
$1 $730.00 $3 3.99 $13
651
09
ADVANCES 00
:13,918.00 $s
$139.10
00
$710.00
$323.99 ,
.
$13,651.09
Da TW O11 PerW 30
Rata Summary
y Balance asuWact to
cl......? f-1- .? Periodic
._L_ amna ANNUAL
Purch $13.715.64 0.07874%(D) 28.740% 28.740%
Adv $0.00 0.07874%(D) 28.740% 28.740%
12/06/04 $13941.93 $314.46 SITE:KC-CL TMI:CO-5000 ACID:KC05076
WOMM Mona RAVOW 12109/05 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
P.O. BOX 8108
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX S HACKENSACK. NJ
850 YVERDON DRIVE 07606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
Citr Driver's Edge' e
CI
Pla inum Select Card-Charter Rbts
5424 1800 3531 8168
tlRtotbK Service:
1-500-967-6500 Total Cre011
Lbea Avaiable Cred1t Live Cash Advance Umlt
Available Cash L" Now Balance
$13940 $0 $5600 s0 $13941.93
SOX 6500
SIOUX FALLS. SD MW o Am40°I,l IV,i, Pat Dw
I pw Due
57117 11/10/2004 11.93 + s0.00 + 312.5 3 = 314.46
Sala Dub Pot Date RatwRix= Mah er ActWity 61.ea Led swat Aamant
11/08
62743505 Payyments credits it Adjustments
PAYMENT THANK YOU
-340.00
TO 0000
0000
Standard Parch
11/10
HO LD PREMIUM
C
REDIO
8.83
S
74 0000000000
11/10 A
TE Fes- OCT PAYMENT PAST DUE
L 339.00
A
L ????
10/21 10121 3GFVRHMB RIANDE CONTINENTAL MIA MIAMI FL 77.97
61 B7011US 2222 55499674297
10/21 10/21 PMBPGP00 AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE 58.79
61 M5969USA 2019 75414914295
10/25 10/25 YR4B•Y30 IMAGINATION SAIL i SIG MIAMI FL 138.72
61 E4411US 2222 55541864300
11/10 PURCHASES•FINANCE CHARGE•PERIODIC RATE 307.53
84 0000 0000000000
***Driver's Edge Charter Member Rebate Summary*
Previous Statement Rebates Total 264.32
Base Rebates Earned 5.51
Total Rebates Earned This Period 5.51
Total Rebates Available 269.83
Lifetime Rebates Earned 403.54
Bonus Rebates may take one to two billing cycles
to appear on your statement. Please refer to the
specific terms and conditions pertaining to the
promotion for further details.
Your late fee was based on your account balance
as of the payment due date (11/04/04). which was
$13,926.57.
COMPLIMENTARY TIRE CHANGE.
Don't be stranded on the road with a flat! Call
1-800-670-6406 to request a wallet card for a tire
change --at no cost to you.
Don't target you can redeem your rebates toward the
purchase or lease of a new or used car..
EXHIBIT /7
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
salt Data Pest Dab nmwvww *mmr Adtra/ flee Lot StMs ent Amood
Account summary previous {+) c sa symen t FINANCE = New
Baianee Advaacee S Credits CHARGE Balance
PURCHASES $13.611.09 $323.31 $340.00 $307.53 $13
941.93
ADVANCES
TOTAL 0.00 0.00
1 $0.00 ,
$0.00 $D.00
$13,651.09 $3
3.31 $340.00 $301.53 $13,941.93
Days This BDIt Period 28
Rabe Summary Balance Subject to
Finance Charee Periodic
Rate Nominal ANNUAL
APR eenerru-rA -e• e.t.
Purch $13,944.87 0.07874%(D) 28.740% 28.740%
Adv $0.00 0.07874%(D) 28.740% 28.740%
Y
01/06/05 $14069.67 $505.70 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KCB5076
r oc? H ,, ... 12/09/05 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
P.O. BOX 8108
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX S HACKENSACK. NJ
850 YVERDON DRIVE 07606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
Citie' Drivers Edge' ati?
PlAcc„a inum Select Card-Charter Rbts
"Wow
5424 1800 3531 8168
M1kMer S6mft
C
_
1-600-967-8500 16tH Credit Una Avalhble Clod Line Cash Advance Umlt Avama ble Cash Lbnn Now Balance
$13940 s0 $5600 t0 $14069.67
BOX 6500
statanane/ Amovat Ow
SIOUX FALLS. SD C1gs?y Date Crodlt Une Past Dw Pa A;1.,, tfMhtam
Mlntaeem Dee at Dw
5T117 12/13/20 04 6129.67 + $0.00 + 5376.03 : 505.70
Sub Deb Peat Data Referents Number Activity Slag Last Statement Aanuat
PayYments Credits E Adjustments
12/13 61881623 P
riENNTTHANK YOU -350.00
O
0000
E
P
E
E
12/13 RSNI
DEC 04-MOY 05
B
FE
M 0.00
T4 0000 0000000000
12/13 ELD PREMIUM
CRREDITTS
H
I .92
O
O
O 0000000000
12/13 LATE FEE - NOV PAYMENT PAST DUE 39.00
0 0000
00000
11/18 11/18 3GRXSM00 AIG LIFFEE
- TERM INS 301300075620 DE 58.79
61 N5969USA 2019 75414914323
12/13 PURCHASES+FINANCE CHARGE'PERIODIC RATE 371.03
84 0000 0000000000
***Driver's Edge Charter Member Rebate Sumfm;iry«ss
Previous Statement Rebates Total 269.83
Base Rebates Earned 1.18
Total Rebates Earned This Period 1.18
Total Rebates Available 271.01
Lifetime Rebates Earned 404.72
Bonus Rebates nay take one to two billing cycles
to appear on your statement. Please refer to the
specific terms and conditions pertaining to the
promotion for further details.
Your late fee was based on our account balance
as of the payment due date (12/06/04). which was
$14.000.72.
HAPPY HOLIDAYS FROM ALL OF US AT CITI!
We'd like to take a moment to thank you for being
a Citi Card member and let you know that we
appreciate your business. warmest wishes for the
upcoming year.
EXHIBIT ??
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
s k into Wet Dab aelena a ".. a r Adhar:lee Let stebiasat AlesYMt
A«??
Summary rvvous t)
Balance S Purchases
Advances Payments
& Credits (+) FIKANCE
CHARGE a) New
Balance
PURCHASES $13,941.93
00
$0 $1 6.71
00
10 $350.00
$0
00 $3 1.03
0
00 $14,069.67
0
ADVANCES
TOTAL .
$13.941.93 .
$106.71 .
$350.00 1
.
$371.03 $0.0
$14r069.67
Da This BMan Perladt 33
Rate Summary Balance ec er c mnna ANNUAL
Finance Charge Rate APR PERCENTAGE RATE
Punch $14,156.73 0.07942%(D) 28-990% 28.990%
Adv $0.00 0.07942%(D) 28.990% 28.990%
t
h
02/04/05 :14554.47 $1338.89 SITE:KC-CL T12/09/050 ACID•18B52755:
CITI CARDS
P-0. BOX 8108
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX S HACKENSACK. NJ
850 YVERDON DRIVE OT606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
'
'
i
a' ?\a
atl
s Ede
ver
Dr
Citi
Platinum Select' Card-Charter Rbts
5424 1800 3531 8168
Castolnar Swvlea:
1-000-967-8500 Total Credn Llna
40
Av*Mab* C-* Line cash Advance Unit
$0 $5600
Available Cash Umit
$0
New aalanee
$14554.4T
$139
BOX a50o
tt6st?isg1nnone/
K.;OU; FALLS. SD 01/12/21805 Amount Over
$6114.47 t+ $376 t03 VareMAdv
+ 13413.09 Minlmam
$13315.59
Standard Parch 92
8
1/12 74EDIOO? LD PREMIUM .
0000000000
1/12 LATE FEE - DEC PAYMENT PAST DUE 39.00
O 0000000000
12/23 12/23 G5.lOX800 - TERM INS 301300075620 DE
AIG LIFE
61 M5969USA 2019 58.79
754149143
1/12
DIT LIMIT FEE
E
OVER C
R 35.00
OO
O
O 0000000000
1/12 •FINANCE CHARGE;PERIODIC RATE
SEES
RC 343.09
O
84
O ? X
***Driver's Edge Charter member Rebate Summary** *
Previous Statement Rebates Total 271.01
Base Rebates Earned 1.18
Total Rebates Earned This Period 1.18
Total Rebates Expired 35.76
Total. Rebates Available 236.43
Bonus Rebates may take one to two billing cycles
to appppeear on your statement. Please refer to the
on
and conditions pertaining to the
specific ,
promotion for further details.
Citi Driver's Edge Charter Member rebates expire 3
years after they are earned. Expired rebates
will be deducted from your rebate account.
35.76 rebates expired on DECEMBER 31 2004
5
R 3
2
1,
00
106.26 rebates will expire on DECEMBE
Your late fee was based on your account balance
s of the payment due date (01/06/05), which was
114,128.46.
Your account is past due and your balance is
over the credit line. To ensure you continue
to receive the many benefits of Your
cardmembership, please send the inimum Amount Due
shown. If you have already sent us this payment,
thank you.
We are pleased to inform you that the current base
benefits on your MasterCard(R) have been extended
through September 1, 2005. For further information
on the benefits you can access as a cardholder,
please call 1-600-MC-ASSIST.
EXHIBIT r
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
lab Date Post Mb PAWSaoe NumMr AetMtr New Last Stdomat Amamt
Rack up your rebates! Use your Drivers Edge Card for
all purehases and watch your rebates quickly add up.
Your rebates can be redeemed toward the purchase or
lease of a new or used qualifying vehicle.
FREE SERVICES FOR CITI CARDMEMBERS
Manage your Citi Card account online securely,
anytime - whether you want to check your balance,
see it a payment was received or pay your bill.
Register now at citicards.com
Save Time. Save Paper. Sign up for All Electronic.
Yau'il have instant access to your statement online,
without that pile of paper. Get an a-rail notice
when your statement is ready. Register or sign-on
to citicards.com and choose Manage My Account.
Rant to receive your billing statement in Spanish?
Prefiere recibir su estado de cuenta en Espanol?
Llamenos al 1-800-947-9100, o elija su idiom de
ppreferencia en www.tarjetsciti.com, modificando su
Perfil Personal en )a section Administrar all Cuenta.
Fast Online Card Payments with Click-t*-Pay
Pay your Citi Card bill online anytime day or
night. Payments received by Ipm EST will post that
same business day! Sign-on to citicards_com and
choose the Make a Payment menu.
Aeeolat Summary r•vious +)
Balance & ur ases ayme s
Advances .6 Credits + FININCE
CHARGE (7-) Now
Balance
PURCHASES $14.069.67 $141.71 $0.00 $343.09 $14,554.47
ALCES 0
9
61 1
71 fl
00 43
0 4
5
TOT $14,
6
. .
.
$14 $3
.
9 5 .
$14,
Da TMs BS11 Period: 30
Rate Summary c• Subject o
Finance Charge Periodic
Rate Nominal
APR PERC ANNUAL
ENTAGE RATE
PURCHASES
Standard Purch $14,275.82 0.08011%(D) 29.240% 29.240%
ADVANCES
Standard Adv 0.00 0.08011%(D) 29.240% 29.240%
F0
03/07/05 $14536.06 $1165.06 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KCB5076
t 12109/05 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
P.O. BOX 8108
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX 5 HACKENSACK, NJ
850 YVERDON DRIVE 07606-8108
CAMP HILL PA
1TOIl-1850000
Citr Driver's Edoeo
Platinum Select Card-Charter Rbts
A=OW* 141011W
5424 1800 3531 8168
Gustemer serreue:
1-800-967-8500 Toth Credit Una Available Cramp Line Ceah Advisee Limit
$13940 $0 $5600
ROX 6500 statam"t/ Amaest pwr
I
t D
P
SIOUX FALLS. SD c?I ate
2 CrNit l
na an
ue
571f.7 05
02/10/ $596.06 + $216.42 +
Debt
1/19
at1e
Available Cash Limn Now Balance
so $14536.06
50.58 = $
Payments, Credits i Adjustments
2/10 61616365 PAYMENNO ANK YOU
0000
Standard Purch
2/10 CREDITSNIELD PREMIUM
74 0000
2/10 LATE FEE- JAN PAYMENT PAST DUE
00
1/19 JY9PK500 AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE
61 H5969USA 2019
2/10 OVER CREDIT LIMIT FEE
62 0000
2/10 S FINANCE CHARGE*PERIODIC RATE
RCHA
8
4
0
000
-Driver's Edge Charter Member Rebate Sunanaryee
Previous Statement Rebates Total 236.43
Base Rebates Earned 1.18
Total Rebates Earned This Period 1.18
Total Rebates Available 237.61
Bonus Rebates may take one to two billing cycles
to appppeear on your statement. Please refer to the
spec: ific terms and conditions pertaining to the
promotion for further details.
Your late fee was based on your account balance
as of the payment due date (02/04/05), which was
$14,613.26.
Your ccount is past due and your balance is
over a the credit line. To ensure you continue
to receive the many benefits of your
cardmembership, please send the Minimum Amount Due
shown. If you have already sent us this payment,
thank you.
Please see the enclosed Notice of Change in Terms to
Your Card Agreement for important information
regarding changes to your Card Agreement.
-505.70
8.92
0000000000
39.00
0000000000
58.79
75414915019
35.00
0000000000
345.58
0000000000
EXHIBIT C
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
Sale tab Pad Date IINiraap tMAa,ler AdMt?slap Last Statenast /laairt
Account Summary Previous
Balance + ure ses
& Advances Payments
& C edits (4) F11MCE
CHARGE = Now
Balance
PURCHASES $14,554.47 $141.71 $505.70 $345.58 $14. 36.06
CES
A 5 5
5 3 0
TOT
I $14.554.47 $1
41.71 0
$
70 45 58
$ $14,536.
6
Dan This ellum Perloa 29
Rate Summery
Purch $14,749.90 0.08079%(D) 29.490% 29.490%
Rdv f0.00 0.08079%(D) 29.490% 29.490%
04/05/05 $15023.27 $2002.77 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KC05076
..?IN 12/09/05 18:52:55:
gow CITI CARDS
PO BOX 183058
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX COLUMBUS. OH
650 YVERDON DRIVE 43218-3058
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
Citi` Driver's Edge' •
CI IT,
Plainum Select Card -Charter Rbts
5424 1800 3531 8168
CrntottNr S"I"
1-800-967-8500 Total Credk Llaa
$13940
Awaabk Credit Line Case Advano Limit
0 $5600
$
Available Cash Lbnk
$0
lkw aalance
$15023.27
BOX 6500
SIOUX FALLS. SO ceseg?ta to
57117 03/!1/2105 p
FA
C?rediit L Past Ow
$1083.27 + $569.00
Pore
W Da.
+ 1350.50 = Amovat dpi
$2002.77
Standard Parch
3/11 74EDITS ELD PREMIUM .92
00 0000000000
3/11
TE FEE FEB PAYMENT PAST DUE
LA
9.00
66 DOW 0000000000
2/18 2/18 VOZX7600 AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE 58.79
61 N5969USA a r 75414915049
3111 OVER CREDIT LIMIT FEE 35.00
0?0
3/11 PURCHASES*FIKANCE CHARGE*PERIODIC RATE 345.50
B4 0000 0000000000
***Driver's Edge Charter Member Rebate Summary***
Previous Statement Rebates Total 237.61
Base Rebates Earned 1.18
Total Rebates Earned This Period 1.18
Total Rebates Available 238.79
Bonus Rebates may take one to two billing cycles
to appear on your statement. Please refer to the
specific terms and conditions pertaining to the
promotion for further details.
Your late fee was based an our account balance
as of the paylaent due date (03/07105), which was
$14.594.85.
Your account is past due and your balance is
aver the credit line. To ensure you continue
to receive the many benefits of your
cardmembership, please send the Minimum Amount Due
shown.- If you have already sent us this payment,
thank you.
Important information: Please see the enclosed
Notice of Change in Rebate Terms and Conditions for
changes to the Driver's Edge Charter Member Rebate
Program.
EXHIBIT
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
sar Dea Pmt Deb Ralmsm NaeMr Admty Since Last gateau t AnwUnt
Account Summary revwus t
Balance 6 urc aces -
Advances & Payments
Credks (4) FINIMEE = Now
CHARGE B3 ante
PURCHASES $14,5 6.06
10
00 $141.71
$0
00 0.00
0
00 $345.50 $15.0,?3 27
00
0.00
$0
ADVANCES
TOTAL .
$14,536.06 .
$141.71 .
0.00 .
6
$345.50 $15,023.27
Days This Billing PKW 29
Rata Summary Balance • o
Finance Charge Periodic
Rate Nominal ANNUAL
APR_ PERCENTAGE RATE
d Purch $14,746.65 0.08079%(D) 29.490% 29.490%
d Ady $0.00 0.08079%(D) 29.490% 29.490%
05/05/05 $14183.88 $680.37 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5 0050 ACID:18852T55:
CITI CARDS
PO Bolt 183058
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX COLUMBUS. OM
850 YYERDON DRIVE 43218-3058
CAMP HILL PA
ITOII-1850000
Citl' Driver's Edge'
Platinum inum Select Card Charter Rbts NUMber
5424 1800 3531 8168
CuSbww sert4tMc
2-600-W-8500 Total Credit Line AVOW* Lfedk Line Cash Advance Unit Available Cash Limit
8oX 6500 $13940 $0 $5600 $0
IsttssaIttieg?ment! Amos "t over t? ?arch/Adv
SIOUX 57117 FALLS. SD 04/12/ I?2005e $243.88 + F^s.00 + 1436 49
sat: Dab Peat Gabe Rdaraaes btamber Aetivky NOW Last 90661000t /"?41
ati
ew eaaaee
$14183.88
bunlaan
= 6Amount Do*
80.37
It
Pil ya>tnts Credits it Adjustments
AYtMFVa RK YOU
4108 43174415
-1,338.59
70
0000
Standard Parch
REDIO?ELD PREMIUM
4112
8.92
T4 0 0??
4/12 LATE FEE - MAR PAYMENT PAST DUE 39.00
0000 0000000000
3/18 3/18 ZTW44000 AIG LIFE TERM INS 301300075620 DE 58.79
61 N5969USA o r 75414915077
RC ASES*FINANCE CHARGE•PERIODIC RATE
4/12 33992.49
84
0000 ????
00
***Driver's Edge Charter Member Rebate Summarye•
Previous Statement Rebates Total 238.79
Base Rebates Earned 1.18
Total Rebates Earned This Period 1.18
Total Rebates Available 239.97
Bonus Rebates may take one to two billing cycles
to appear on your statement. Please refer to the
t
in
to th
i
iti
g
e
ons per
a
n
specific terms and cond
promotion for further details.
Citi Driver's Edge Charter Member rebates expire 3
years after they are earned. Expired rebates
will be deducted from your rebate account.
106.26 rebates will expire on DECEMBER 31. 2005
Your late fee was based on your account balance
Is of the payment due date (04105/05), which was
15.082.06.
Our records show home phone 717-761-8236 and
business phone 717-238-6715. Please update
coupon if incorrect.
EXHIBIT
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
s.r mm.ta Pont oet. rAlw*aca l4tmbw AethAty Wm Lot Stat w mt Aeoret
Account Summary rewaus
Balance + ure aces
1G Advances aymen
.& Credhs +IFINAWE
CHAR3E (a New
Balance
PURCHASES ;15,0 3.27 $196.71
0
0 $1,338.59
$0
00 $392.49
00
$0 $14,163.88
0
00
ADVANCES 0.00 .0
$ . . .
TOTAL $15,0 3.27 $106.71 ;1,338.59 $392.49 $14,1 3.88
Rate Sumnnnry
Purch $15,053.32 0.08148%(D) 29.740% 29.740%
Adv $0.00 0.08148%(D) 29.740% 29.740%
06/06/05 $14633.55 $1517.06 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KC55016
: ,.. 12/09/05 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
PO BOX 183058
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX COLUMBUS, OH
850 YVERDOli DRIVE 43218-3058
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
Driver's Edged'
Citi' CTa
,
Pia inum Select Card Charter Rbts
5424 1800 3531 8168
Custanwr Service:
1-800-967-8500 Tetal Credit Une Avenaalo Cm* Lim Cash Advance Clink AvaVable Cash LYnk New Balance
$13940 $0 $5600 $0 $14633.58
dOX 6500
SIOUX FALLS, $D clIqq..ww??yy Dattee A Crash Over Past Dw INIWAM
l1 n?Dw A*euat fte
57117 05/11/Z0 05 $693.58 t $436.49 t 1386.99 = $1517.06
Sala Dote Past Bete Reweave Maai sr Acttft Sines Lot Statement M?aunt
I
EL
5/11 CRED
TSKI
E
LD PREMIUM ? .92
O ?
5/11 LA
TE FEE APR PAYMENT PAST DUE X9.00
A
6 0000 O0QW
4/19 4/19 K3D33000 AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE 58.79
61 M5969USA o r 75414915109
5/11 4RCN?ES*FINANCE CHARGE*PERIODIC RATE
P 3442.99
B ???
***Driver's Edge Charter Member Rebate Summary***
Previous Statement Rebates Total 239.97
Base Rebates Earned 1.18
Total Rebates Earned This Period 1.18
Total Rebates Available 241.15
bonus Rebates may take one to two billing cycles
to a ppeear on your statement. Please refer to the
specTlic terms and conditions pertaining to the
promotion for further details.
Please note that payments must be received by
1:00 p.m., local time, on a bank business day at
the payment processing facility that handles your
payments, in order to be credited to your account
as of that day, and payments must conform to
the payment instructions set forth on the reverse
side. All conforming payments received at the
ppayment processing facility after that time will
be credited as of the following bank business
day.
Your late fee was based on your account balance
D1s4of the payment due date (05/05/05), which was
Your account is pa*t due. In order to redeem or
continue earning Csti Driver's Edge Card rebates,
pplease send the Minimum Amount Due shown.
If you have already sent your payment, thank you.
Save Time. Save Paper. Sign up for All Electronic.
You'll have instant access to your statement online,
without that pile of paper. Get an e-mail notice
when your statement is ready. Register or sign-on
to citicards.com and choose Manage My Account.
EXHIBIT d3
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
Sub Dats Pant beta aalnesm Nwsher AdMtr Owe I st Stab~ Aemwet
FREE SERVICES FOR CITI CARDMEMBERS.
Manage your Citi card account online securely,
anytime - whether you rant to check your balance,
see if a payment was received or pay your bill.
Register now at www.citicards.con
Account summary revious
BsIlglCe + Purchases
& Advances Payments
& Credits (+ FINANCE
CHARGE M New
Balance
PURCHASES $14,183.88 $1Qb.71 ,2 $342.99 $14,633.58
ADVANCES X
0.
00 1000 10
0 $0.00 $0.00
TOTAL 33
.
:14,18188 5106.71 0.00 $342.99 $14.633.58
Rate Sumateuy oaunce auopect TO
Finance Charge vernocic
Rate namnai ANNUAL
APR PEgrEWAGE RATI
>URCHASES
Standard Porch
IDVANCES $14.395.29 0.08216%(0) 29.990% 29.990%
Standard Adv $0.00 0.08216%(D) 29.990% 29.990%
OT/07/05 $15143.58 $24T4.35 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KCB5076
12/09/D5 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
PO BOX 183058
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX COLUMBUS, ON
850 YVERDON DRIVE 43218-3058
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
Citi' Driver's Edge'
Platinum Select Card-Charter Rbts
5424 1600 3531 8168
Cusbomw SarWkW
1-800-398-2200 Tettt Cr"It Line AvelhWe CreNt Line Cesb Advance UfMt Available Cash Limit
Box 6500 $13940 $0 $5600 50
SIOUX FALLS, SD e e Date A creed L?1 a lest nw FAMM Due
57117 06/13/2 05 S 1 Z03.58 + $823.48 + b?I 1447.29 Cltl
ew Balance
$15143.58
mew* pw
= $2474.35
Sob Date Past Dabs nefereae number AetWy line Last stabment Aanoaat
e
PREMIUM
6/13 CREDITSHIELD 8.92
74 0000 0000000000
6/13 LATE FEE - MAY PAYMENT PAST DUE 39.00
66
IFEO 0
000000000
5/19 5/19 R6Y2Ze00 AIG L
- TERM INS 301300075620 DE 58.79
61 N5969USA o r 75414915139
6/13 PPURCN??•FINANCE CHARGE•PERIODIC RATE 403.29
84 000000000
DRIVER'S EDGE REBATES SUMMARY
Activity This Period
Purchase Rebates Earned 1
HE uDRIVER'S/EDGQQEiREB
TES 9
A -
1
Previous Balance
Purchase Rebates Earned 241
PREVIOUS DRIVER'S EDGE REBATES 241
Lifetime Activity
Total Rebates Earned 302
Total Rebates Expired 151
Total Rebates Redeemed 0
Total Rebates Available 150
Bonus Rebates clay take one to two billing cycles
to appear on your statement. Please refer to the
specific terms and conditions pertaining to the
promotion for further details.
Citt Driver's Edge Charter Member rebates expire 3
years after they are earned. Expired rebates
will be deducted from your rebate account.
1.12 rebates will expire on JULY 13, 2005
Your late fee was based on your account balance
Is of the ppayment due date (06/06/05), which was
14,692.37.
Your account is past due and your credit
privileges are suspended. In order to redeem or
continue earning Citi Driver's Edge Card rebates,
please pay the Minimum Amount Due shown. If you
have already sent us this payment, thank you.
Important Information: Please see enclosed insert
for discounts and offers from Hertz especially for
Driver's Edge(R) Cardwembers. EXHIBIT
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
aer wt. Pmt bete Refs w. Mumaw ACtftl steae Liffilt 5- Amount
t Summary
Aocot
at Previous
Bolanc + Purchases
& Ad antes aym s
r. CredRs + FINANCE
CHARGE = Now
Balance
_
PURCHASES
tCES
f
A $14,633.58 $1:06.71 0.00 $403.29
03 $15,143.58
58
1
3
L
A
TOT 514 ,63.58 5146.71 0.00 29
$4 4
$15,
.
Rate Summary ?Fieaace Charae Rate APR PERCENTAGE RATE_
rd Purch $14.874.39 0.08216%(D) 29.990% 29.990%
rd Adv $0.00 0.08216%(D) 29.9901(7 29.990%
08/05/05 $15632.42 :3389.32 SITE:XC-CL TM:CO-5000 ACID:KC85OT6
----- .---. - - .............. 1.?., Xl 12109105 15:52:55:
CITI CARDS
PO BOX 163058
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX COLUMBUS, OH
850 YVERDON DRIVE 43218-3058
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
Citi' Driver's Edge'
Pfau inum Select Card-Charter Rbts
5424 1800 3531 8168
ontoolff sa -yom
^&an" urmt
1-600-B66-9900 Tow Credn Llne AvAnble Credit Lkw
$0 can
$5600
$13940
BOx 6500
SIOUX FALLS. SD
X7117 Ci?11 De :
O7/13/2?05 ct
Aasit `m
:1692.42 + Past D"'
$1270.77 +
C! ?1'
A%Wlasie Cash Lhnn flew aalamce
$0 $15632.42
i?IM . Dw A?sunt Oue
1426.13 = $3389.32
A Standard Purch
7/13 CREDITSHIELD PREMIUM
74 0
O
7/13 - JUN PAYMENT PAST DUE
LATE FFEE
6/20
6/20
X1Tx5RO0 66 0000
AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE
7/13 61 N5969USA o r
'FINANCE CHARGE-PERIODIC RATE
ES
OURCHO
O
S
84 DRIVER'S EDGE REBATES SUMMARY Activity This Period
Purchase Rebates Earned 2
Ad ustments / Expired .1
HE DRIVER'S EDGE REBATES 0
Previous Balance
Purchase Rebates Earned 150
PREVIOUS DRIVER'S EDGE REBATES 150
Lifetime Activity
Total Rebates Earned 303
Total Rebates Expired 150
Total Rebates Redeemed
Total Rebates Available 150
Bonus Rebates my take one to two billing cycles
to a ar on your statement. Please refer to the
specific terms and conditions pertaining to the
promotion for further details.
Citi Driver's Edge Charter Member rebates expire 3
wilisbefdeducted fronyourdrebateiaccountates
2.26 rebates wilt expire on AUGUST 11, 2005
Your late fee was based an your account balance
!15 of the payment due date (07/07/05). which was
.202.37.
Your account is seriously past due and your credit
privileges have been suspended. Please call the
toll-free number shown above to learn about our
special payment options. Call Monday - Friday,
7 am - 9 pm, or Saturday, 8 an - 5 pm,
Central Time.
8.92
000000000 9.00
0000000000
58.79
75414915171
382.13
0000000000
EXHIBIT
'15
LOUISE It LANOREAUX
so* M!a Pat Dote aNgmm Nulobw AetMtr Sims Let asomew Ammmt
Accowt Stanmary rw ous +)
Balance 6 Purchases
Advances aym s
b Credits C+) ri
CHARGE = New
Balance
PURCUA5E5 515,143.5fl
$000 S1Q6.T1
WOO
JOHN, 53 2.13
0.00 515,632.42
¢0.00
ADVANCES
TOTAL :15,143.58 $106.71 0.00 53 2.13 515,632.42
Da Thlt 5 n Period: 30
ante Subjtct to Periodic Nominal ANNUAL
Rate Summary Finance Cfiarpe Rate APR P ERCENTAGE RATE
Purch $15.374.40 0.08285%(D) 30.240% 30.240%
Ady $0.00 0.08205%(D) 30.240% 30.240%
. V
L
BURTON NEIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
By: Burton Neil, Esquire, Id. No. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
610-696-2120
Attorney for Plaintiff
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Plaintiff
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
: NO. 05-5791 Civil
Defendant : CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Affidavit of Citibank (South Dakota) N.A.
in Support of Plaintiffs Summary Judgment Motion
I, ERICKA SMITH , am competent and make this affidavit
based upon personal knowledge and review of business records described herein. 1 am employed
by Citicorp Credit Services, Inc. (USA), a servicing company for Citibank (South Dakota) N.A.
("Citibank"). I am authorized to make this affidavit on behalf of Citibank in support of its
motion for summary judgment. I share custodianship and have access to all of the documents in
the possession of plaintiff that are germane to this case. The following statement is true and
correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. I understand that this statement
made is subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. Section 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to
the authorities.
Citibank is a national bank located at 701 East 60th Street North, Sioux Falls, South
Dakota. Citibank engages in various types of banking business including consumer lending
through the issuance of credit cards including the credit card issued to defendant with account
number 5424180035318168.
In the regular course of its business, Citibank maintains as a regular business practice
accurate and running computer records of the activity on credit card accounts, including
defendant's account. These records reflect the purchases made, payments received, amounts
owing, and credits and debits. It was the regular practice of Citibank to send monthly billing
statements to defendant. These monthly billing statements reflect the account activity including
EXHIBIT -?
charges for any purchases, cash advances, finance charges, late fees and over the limit fees,
payments and other credits, the balance due, and the minimum payment amount. Plaintiff mailed
monthly billing statements for the account each month to defendant. The monthly billing
statements were sent to defendant at the address of record, beginning the month after the credit
card was issued. All the charges on the monthly billing statements sent to defendant were
correctly calculated.
The last monthly billing statement Citibank mailed to defendant was dated July 13, 2005
and set forth a new balance due in the sum of $15,632.42. A copy of this billing statement is
attached hereto as Affidavit Exhibit 1.
Subsequent to the date of the Exhibit 1 statement, defendant made payments totaling
$6,410.00. These payments reduced the balance due on the account to $9,222.42. As of the date
of this affidavit the amount due Citibank on the account is $9,222.42.
`cam
Date S '-?, i O
08/05/05 $15632.42 $3389.32 SITE:KC-CL TM:CO-5000 AC1D:KCB5076
,, Y.. 12/09/05 18:52:55:
CITI CARDS
PO BOX 183058
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX COLUMBUS, OH
850 YVERDON DRIVE 43218-3058
CAMP HILL PA
17011-1850000
Citi' Driver's Edge"
Platinum inum Select Card-Charter Rbts
5424 1800 3531 8168
C..ftb tr Sarvkw
1-800-866-9900 Total Credit Line Available Credit Line
$0 cash Advance Limit
$5600 Available Cash Limit
$0
$13940
BOX 6500
SIOUX 7117 FALLS, SD
5 statement/
07/1372005a Amovnl r
$1692.42a+
$1270a.77a PurlNA4V
+ 1426.13
C tl?
Now 0alanco
$15632.42
13389.
Standard Purch
7/13 CREDITSHIELD PREMIUM
74 0000
7/13 LATE FEE - JUN PAYMENT PAST DUE
66 0000
6/20 6/20 X1TX5R00 AIG LIFE - TERM INS 301300075620 DE
61 W5969USA o r
7/13 PURCHASES+FINANCE CHARGE•PERIODIC RATE
84 0000
DRIVER'S EDGE REBATES SUMMARY Activity This Period
Purchase Rebates Earned i
Adjustments / Expired .
NEW DRIVER'S EDGE REBATES 0
Previous Balance
Purchase Rebates Earned 150
PREVIOUS DRIVER'S EDGE REBATES 150
Lifetime Activity
Total Rebates Earned 303
Total Rebates Expired 153
Total Rebates Redeemed 0
Total Rebates Available 150
Bonus Rebates may take one to two billing cycles
to apppear on your statement. Please refer to the
specific terms and conditions pertaining to the
promotion for further details.
Citi Driver's Edge Charter Member rebates expire 3
years after they are earned. Expired rebates
will be deducted from your rebate account.
2.26 rebates will expire on AUGUST 11, 2005
Your late fee was based on your account balance
as of the payment due date (07/07/05), which was
515.202.37.
Your account is seriously past due and your credit
privileges have been suspended. Please call the
toll-free number shown above to learn about our
special payment options. Call Monday - Friday,
7 am - 9 pm, or Saturday, 8 am - 5 pm,
Central Time.
8.92
0000000000
39.00
0000000000
58.79
75414915171
382.13
0000000000
EXH I B IT_______t
BURTON NEIL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
By: Burton Neil, Esquire, Id. No. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
(610) 696-2120
Attorney for Plaintiff
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Plaintiff
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
NO. 05-5791 Civil
Defendant : CIVIL ACTION -LAW
Plaintiffs Brief in Support of Summary Judgment Motion
A. History of the Case
Plaintiff sued defendant to recover the past due balance owed on a credit card account in
the sum of $10,722.42. Defendant filed an answer with new matter to which plaintiff filed a
reply thereby closing the pleadings. Subsequent to the filing of the lawsuit, defendant made
payments which reduced the balance to $9,222.42. Plaintiff served defendant requests for
admission which defendant failed to answer. Plaintiff filed a motion for summary judgment
because there is no genuine issue of material fact. The pleadings and matters admitted from the
requests for admission constitute the record for purposes of this motion. Plaintiff's motion is
before the Court for disposition.
B. Issue
Whether there exists a genuine issue of material fact which will require a trial?
C. Argument
There is no genuine issue of material fact which will require a trial. This is because of
two reasons: (1) defendant admitted all of the allegations in the complaint and (2) all matters in
the requests for admission were admitted.
The answer to the complaint admitted all the allegations either directly or because of
denials which had the effect of an admission. Defendant directly admitted complaint paragraphs
1 through 4. Answer paragraphs 5 and 9 were stated "Denied. Proof is demand." A demand for
proof except as set forth in Rule 1029(c) has the effect of an admission. See Pa R.C.P. 1029(b)'.
Therefore, defendant admitted complaint paragraphs 5 and 9.
Answer paragraph 6 also had the effect of an admission. Defendant did admit that
plaintiff mailed a billing statement each month because there was no response to the allegation.
The denial "any statements did not accurately reflect debits or credits" is an admission.
"Although no fixed rule can be stated for determining whether a denial is specific, generally for a
denial to be specific, it must deny what is averred and then must affirmatively aver what did
occur in place of the facts as averred." 5 Standard Pennsylvania Practice 2d Section 26:40 and
the cases cited therein. See also Acme Cotton Products Co. V. Michael McDonou h Inc., 61 Pa.
D. & C.2d 608 (1972); affirmed, per curiam, 225 Pa. Super. 701, 306 A.2d 351 (1973).2 In other
'Pa. R.C. P. 1029(b) provides :Averments in a pleading to which a responsive pleading is required are
admitted when not denied specifically or by necessary implication. A general denial or a demand for proof, except as
provided by subdivisions (c) and (e) of this rule, shall have the effect of an admission."
2The denial was an admission also because it is in haec verba. "Any form of general denial is an admission,
including a denial which merely repeats allegations almost verbatim in the negative..." 3 Goodrich - Amram 2d §
1029(b):4. The rule cited in the treatise has been the law in Pennsylvania for many years and has periodically served
as the basis for grant of a motion for judgment on the pleadings. See Hoffman v. Bozitsko, 198 Pa. Super. 553, 182
words, debtor was required to aver facts which stated the reasons that the debits and credits in the
statements were not accurate. Therefore, defendant admitted complaint paragraph 6.
In paragraph 7 of the answer, defendant alleged objections to the statements were made
periodically. For the reasons noted above and on the same grounds as in the Acme case, this is a
general denial because not a single fact was alleged in support of the averment.
Complaint paragraph 8 alleged defendant did not dispute, object or protest any of the
billing statements to which defendant merely stated she did not assent to the correctness of the
balance. Here, too, defendant alleged no facts why the balance is not correct. Although this is
not a Rule 1029(c) denial, the logic of the Cercone3 case would apply. This is because defendant
would be in a singular position to possess information which would enable her to respond
specifically to the paragraph's allegations. She is the one who used the credit card, received the
billing statements, reviewed them, made payments, had the opportunity to determine whether the
statements were correct or not and as such could respond specifically. Had a notice of billing
error been sent to plaintiff, she could respond specifically with the date it was sent and
summarize its material facts. She did none of this. Therefore, paragraph 8 was admitted.
The new matter alleged defendant made payments on the account. Plaintiff's reply and
affidavit reflect defendant was given credit for all payments she made. The matters admitted in
the requests establish the payments she made which left a balance due on the account in the sum
of $9,222.42.
Defendant did not answer the requests for admission. Pursuant to Pa R.C.P. 4014(a) and
(b), each matter sought to be admitted in the requests was admitted and conclusively established
for the purpose of this case. These admissions are sufficient for the Court to grant the motion4
A.2d 113 (1962); Noll v. Hamil, 72 Pa. D. & C.2d 177 (1975); Martin v. Barfield, 66 Pa. D. & C. 321 (1948);
Sheppard v. Stubbs, 19 D & C 215 (1910).
3In Cercone v. Cercone, 254 Pa..Super. 381, 386 A.2d 1 (1978), the Superior Court held that a defendant
may not rely upon Rule 1029(c)(1) to excuse a failure to make a specific denial of factual allegations contained in a
complaint when it is clear that the defendant must know whether a particular allegation is true or false.
4The failure to answer request for admissions was the basis for summary judgment in whole or in part in the
following cases: Borough of Mifflinburg v. Heim, et al., 1997 Pa. Super. LEXIS 4020, 705 A.2d 456, 466 (1997);
Bvmes, Inc. v. Buss Automation, Inc., 415 Pa. Super. 549, 609 A.2d 1360 (1992); Innovate Incorporated v. United
._, : #
because they confirm there is no genuine issue of material fact which will require a trial.
Finally, defendant's new matter paragraph 2 raised no genuine issue of material fact.
This is clear because no facts were alleged to support the bald averment. Further, there is no
provision within the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, 15 U.S.C. 1692 which would provide a
defense to a creditor's action to recover a debt.
D. Conclusion
The judicial admissions5 in defendant's answer and the matters admitted in the requests
for admission are binding and conclusive on defendant. They establish proof of plaintiff's
account stated cause of action.b Because there exists no genuine issue of material fact, trial is
unnecessary. Therefore, summary judgment should be entered under Pa. R.C.P. 1035.2 for
plaintiff and against defendant plus the costs of this action.
BURTON NEIL 8/ASSOCIATES, P.C.
Attorney for Plaintiff
In making this communication, we advise our firm is a debt collector.
Parcel Service, Inc., 275 Pa. Super, 276, 418 A.2d 720, 723 (1980); Bamebei v. Hauf, et al. 116 Dauph. 215 (1996);
Carter v. Harrisburg Motel Enterprises, Inc., 113 Dauph. 479 (1993).
5A judicial admission is an express waiver made in court or preparatory to trial by a party or his attorney,
conceding for the purposes of the trial, the truth of the admission. It has the effect of a confessory pleading, in that
the fact is thereafter to be taken for granted, so that the opposing party need offer no evidence to prove it and the
party by whom the statement was made is not allowed to disprove it. See 9 Wigmore, Evidence Section 2588
(Chadbourne Rev. 1981). It is axiomatic that a judicial admission cannot be contradicted by the party that made it.
See Tops Apparel Mfg. Co. v. Rothman, 430 Pa. 583, 244 A.2d 436 (1968). Jewelcor Jewelers & Distributors v.
Corr, 373 Pa. Super 536, 542 A.2d 72 (1988)
6The Second Restatement of Contracts defines and states the legal effect of an "account stated" at Section
282 as follows "(1) An account stated is a manifestation of assent by a debtor and creditor to a stated sum as an
accurate computation of an amount due the creditor. A party's retention without objection for an unreasonably
long time of a statement of account rendered by the other party is a manifestation of assent."(Emphasis added)
Under Pennsylvania law, "...the essence of a common law action for an account stated is an agreement,
either express or implied, based upon prior transactions, between two parties as to the correctness of an amount
due.." Connolly Epstein Chicco Foxman Engelmyer & Ewing v. Fanslow, 1995 WL 686045 at *5 (E.D.Pa.1995)
(applying Pennsylvania law).
Burton Neil & Associates, P.C.
By: Burton Neil, Esquire ID. NO. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
610-696-2120
Attorney for Plaintiff
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A.
Plaintiff
V.
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
Defendant
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
: NO. 05-5791 Civil
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Certificate of Service
I, Burton Neil, Esquire do hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of the within
Plaintiff s Motion for Summary Judgment, Brief in Support, proposed Order and Praecipe for Listing
Case for Argument on pro se defendant, Louise M Lamoreaux, at her address of record via first class
mail, postage prepaid on the date set forth below.
Burton Neil & A ociates, P.C.
R
Date: By:
B
(Lwff Ne quir
Attorney for Plaintif
The law firm of Burton Neil & Associates is a debt collector.
C-8037
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Plaintiff
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
NO. 05-5791 Civil
Defendant : CIVIL ACTION -LAW
ORDER
AND NOW, this day of , 20, plaintiff s motion for
summary judgment is GRANTED. Judgment is entered for plaintiff Citibank (South Dakota) N.A.
and against the defendant Louise M. Lamoreaux in the sum of $9,222.42 plus record costs of $96.94
for a total judgment of $9,319.36.
BY THE COURT:
J.
63 _Z Wd 61 AON LOOZ
3HI Jo
?.'U?Cg4&Ij
Praecipe for Listing Case for Argument
(Must be typewritten and submitted in duplicate)
TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY:
Please list the within matter for the next Argument Court.
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA) N.A.
Plaintiff
V.
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
Defendant NO. 05-5791 Civil
1. State matter to be argued (i.e., plaintiffs motion for new trial, defendant's demurrer to
complaint, etc.): Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment
2. Identify counsel who will argue case:
(a) for plaintiff: Burton Neil, Esquire c/o Burton Neil & Associates, P.C.
address: 1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170, West Chester, PA 19380
b) for defendant: Louise M Lamoreaux, Pro Se
address: 850 Yverdon Drive Camp Hill PA 17011-1850
3. I will notify all parties in writing within two days that this case has been listed for
argument.
4. Argument Court Date: January 23, 2008
Attorney for the
The law firm of Burton Neil & Associates is a debt collector.
E'7
C ev
c=a
Q
7_7
1i{;:
CJ
-n
'_ .qC T
0 0
N
CITIBANK (South Dakota) N.A., IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
PLAINITFF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
LOUISE M. LAMOREAUX
DEFENDANT NO. 05-5791 CIVIL
IN RE: PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
BEFORE BAYLEY, J. AND EBERT, J.
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 25th day of January, 2008, after consideration of the
Plaintiffs Motion for Summary Judgment and the Court noting that the Defendant
did not file a brief in opposition to the Plaintiff's Motion nor appear for argument,
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DIRECTED that the Plaintiff's Motion for
Summary Judgment is GRANTED.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED AND DIRECTED that Judgment be entered
in favor of the Plaintiff, Citibank (South Dakota) N.A., and against the Defendant,
Louise M. Lamoreaux, in the amount of $9,222.42 plus record costs of $96.94 for
a total Judgment of $9,319.36.
By the Court,
Burton Neil, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
M. L. Ebert, Jr.,
J.
120P 1?-v rnv?LLQ
Louise M. Lamoreaux, Pro Se
Defendant
bas
f,i ..may ¢' G
] •?? 1. ai ?? d?^
Burton Neil & Associates, P.C.
By: Burton Neil, Esquire ID. NO. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
610-696-2120
Attorney for Plaintiff
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA), N.A.
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
Defendant
: NO. 05-5791 Civil
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Praecipe for Entry of Judgment on Court Order
To the Prothonotary:
Enter judgment on behalf of the plaintiff, CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA), N.A., and
against the defendant, LOUISE M LAMOREAUX, as per the Court's Order dated January 25,
2008 and assess damages in the sum of $93fr
Burton N ' &
By
P.C.
Neil, Esquire
And now, this 0(#k,
day of
judgment is entered on
behalf of the plaintiff, CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA), N.A.' and against the defendant,
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX, in the sum of-S9,9 t . 9, •y?
Prothonotary of Cum rland County
- /Y&gwi?w -
In making this communication, we advise that this office is a d 4t collector.
CITIBANK (South Dakota) N.A., IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
PLAINITFF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
LOUISE M. LAMOREAUX
DEFENDANT NO. 05-5791 CIVIL
IN RE: PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
BEFORE BAYLEY, J. AND EBERT, J.
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 25"' day of January, 2008, after consideration of the
Plaintiffs Motion for Summary Judgment and the Court noting that the Defendant
did not file a brief in opposition to the Plaintiff's Motion nor appear for argument,
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DIRECTED that the Plaintiffs Motion for
Summary Judgment is GRANTED.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED AND DIRECTED that Judgment be entered
in favor of the Plaintiff, Citibank (South Dakota) N.A., and against the Defendant,
Louise M. Lamoreaux, in the amount of $9,222.42 plus record costs of $96.94 for
a total Judgment of $9,319.36.
By the Court,
M. L. Ebert, Jr., - ( \ J.
Burton Neil, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
Louise M. Lamoreaux, Pro Se
Defendant
bas
Burton Neil & Associates, P.C.
By: Burton Neil, Esquire ID. NO. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
610-696-2120
Attorney for Plaintiff
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA), N.A.
701 East 60th Street N
Sioux Falls, SD 57117
Plaintiff
V.
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
850 Yverdon Drive
Camp Hill PA 17011-1850
Defendant
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 05-5791 Civil
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Certification of Address and
Affidavit of Non-Military
Understanding that false statements herein are subject to penalty under 18 Pa. C.S. Section
4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities, I verify that:
1. The above are the precise last-known addresses of the judgment creditor and debtor.
2. Pursuant to Section 201(b)(1)(A) of the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act of 2003 (SCRA)
the defendant is not in the military service of the United States based on information received from
the defendant and/or the Department of Defense website.
Burton Neil Associates, P.C.
Burton Neil, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
In making this communication, we advise that this office is a debt collector.
rv ? W
O
LA?
Cam- ° -n
t c -*i
rT'? n1
rv ?
Cf)
7jj
rY C: N rn
?-
?ca
r
S
Burton Neil & Associates, P.C.
By: Burton Neil, Esquire ID. NO. 11348
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
610-696-2120
Attorney for Plaintiff
CITIBANK (SOUTH DAKOTA), N.A. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
V.
LOUISE M LAMOREAUX
Plaintiff : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 05-5791 Civil
Defendant : CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Rule of Civil Procedure No. 236 (Revised)
Notice is given that a JUDGMENT in the above captioned matter has been entered
against you on q- aw
Prothonotary of Cumberland County
If you have any questions concerning the above, please contact:
Burton Neil, Esquire
Attorney for Party Filing
1060 Andrew Drive, Suite 170
West Chester, PA 19380
Phone: 610-696-2120
In making this communication, we advise that this office is a debt collector.