Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
05-5888
PAGE 1 REPORT : ZDRDOCT First Judicial District RUN DATE 10/03/05 USER ID: JPM CIVIL DOCKET REPORT RUN TIME 01:49 PM CASE ID 050703379 --------------------------------------------------------- )Lv (7S _,? 1 d_J_ fit, CASE NUMBER CASE CAPTION 050703379 NEUBAUM VS DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORP FILING DATE COURT LOCATION JURY 29-JUL-2005 AR AC N CASE TYPE: CONTRACTS (GOODS), ENFORCE STATUS: ORDER/TRNSF OTHER JURISDICTION Seq # Assoc Expn Date Type ID 1 APLF A53084 Party Name / Address & Phone No. GORBERG, DAVID J 1234 MARKET ST SUITE 2040 PHILADELPHIA PA 19107 (000)563-7210 2 1 PLF @5261736 NEUBAUM, GARY 610 W SHADY LN SOUTH ENOLA PA 17025 3 4 DFT 112293 DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORP C/0 CT CORP 1650 MARKET ST PHILADELPHIA PA 19103 4 ADFT A66346 JOHNSON, JAMES L. 1845 WALNUT ST. MARSHALL,DENNEHEY, ETC.. PHILADELPHIA PA 19103 (000)575-2801 Filing Date / Time Docket Entry Date Entered 29-JUL-05 09:06:27 COMMENCEMENT OF CIVIL ACTION 03-AUG-05 29-JUL-05 09:06:27 SHERIFF'S SURCHARGE 1 DEFT 03-AUG-05 29-JUL-05 09:06:27 COMPLAINT FILED NOTICE GIVEN 03-AUG-05 COMPLAINT WITH NOTICE TO DEFEND WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 1018.1 FILED. ASSESSMENT OF DAMAGES HEARING IS REQUIRED 29-JUL-05 11:09:35 ACTIVE CASE 29-JUL-05 02-AUG-05 11:32:07 AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FILED 03-AUG-05 OF COMPLAINT BY PERSONAL SERVICE UPON DEFENDANT DAIMLERCHRYSLER ON 7/29/05. REPORT : ZDRDOCT First Judicial District USER ID: JPM CIVIL DOCKET REPORT CASE TO 050703379 Filing Date / Time Docket Ent 03-AUG-05 09:07:58 ARBITRATION HEARING SCHEDULED PAGE 2 RUN DATE 10/03/05 RUN TIME 01:49 PM Date Entered 03-AUG-O5 19-AUG-05 12:01:00 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED 22-AUG-05 JOHNSON, JAMES L. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF JAMES L JOHNSON ESQ FILED ON BEHALF OF DFT DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORP. 19-AUG-05 12:02:00 ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED 22-AUG-05 JOHNSON, JAMES L. ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT WITH NEW MATTER FILED BY DEFENDANT DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORP. 25-AUG-05 09:20:00 PLTF REPLY TO NEW MATTER FILED 26-AUG-05 PLAINTIFF(S) REPLY TO NEW MATTER OF DEFENDANT(S) FILED. 25-AUG-05 15:35:09 MOTION TO TRANSFER 25-AUG-05 DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORP, 23-05082123 RESPONSE DATE 9-14-05. 14-SEP-05 11:57:34 ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED 15-SEP-05 NEUBAUM, GARY 23-05082123 ANS FILED TO MOTION TO TRANSFER 16-SEP-05 10:56:27 MOTION ASSIGNED 16-SEP-05 23-05082123 MOTION TO TRANSFER ASSIGNED TO JUDGE ACKERMAN ON 9-19-05. 19-SEP-05 11:32:44 ORDER/TRNSF OTHER JURISDICTION 19-SEP-05 ACKERMAN, NORMAN 23-05082123 IT IS ORDERED THAT DEFT'S PETITION TO TRANSFER IS GRANTED AND THIS MATTER IS TRANSFERRED TO THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS FOR CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA. COSTS TO BE PAID BY DEFT. BY THE COURT ...ACKERMAN,J 9/19/05 29-SEP-05 11:48:00 PRAECIPE/TRNSFER OUT OF COUNTY 03-OCT-05 JOHNSON, JAMES L. PRAECIPE TO TRANSFER THE ABOVE CAPTIONED MATTER TO CUMBERLAND COUNTY FILED. * * * End of Docket * * * t,,-. sw r, NOV 2 2005 KISEP HL. \/-Ps Ps?t;'(N: O i ARY CF PHILADELPHIA COUNTY ra C7 c:> C] c: > cn -7 _ J ??' Ia ?' SV `I ... .°(1 f\i C? ?.? -? t J -ti >--'), aas'(!'L-PT.-.. COURT OF COMMON PLEAS PHILADELPHIA COUNTY PROTHONOTARY'S OFFICE Phila. Case Number: 3379 JULY 2005 Dear Sir/Madam: By order of the FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT, Philadelphia County, COURT OF COMMON PLEAS, the enclosed case(s) are transferred to the COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY. Accordingly, I am enclosing all related filings. I would appreciate the return of the attached green receipt addressed to the attention of: THE PROTHONOTARY'S OFFICE CERTIFICATION UNIT ROOM 266 CITY HALL PHILADELPHIA, PA 19107 ATTENTION: JOSEPH MANGINI If you have any questions, please call 215-686-6663. Very truly yours, Joseph Mangini 10-27M e931- sa s ctv°t .7L GARY NEUBAUM COURT OF COMMON PLEAS PHILADELPHIA COUNTY V. DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION JULY TERM, 2005 NO. 3379 ORDER QN2123 AND NOW, this / f 4ay of 51?1 2005, upon consideration of defendant DaimlerChrysler Corporation's Petition to Transfer Venue To Cumberland County based upon forum non conveniens and any response thereto, it is hereby ORDERED and DECREED that said Petition is GRANTED and the above-captioned matter is hereby transferred to the Court of Common Pleas for Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. The costs and fees for transfer and removal shall be paid by the Defendant pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1006(d)(3). The Philadelphia County Prothonotary is hereby directed to forward to Cumberland County Prothonotary certified copies of docket entries, proceed pleadings, depositions and all other papers filed in this action, pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1006(d)(3). COURT: J. COPIES SENT PURSUA"!TTO P:.R.CR 236(b) SEP 1 9 2005 FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT 01- PA USER I.D.: ti--..- DOCKETED COMPLEX LIT SEP I R 200 J. STEWART V01 21 ALIABUU\SLPGA517798V1AOJA03043V04274 MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & GOGGIN o ff' By: James L. Johnson, Esquire Attorney for Defendant, a(. Attorney I.D: 66346 DaimlerChrysler Corporation m U 1845 Walnut Street r\a ??. Philadelphia, PA 19103 °0) (215) 575-2801 n GARY NEUBAUM COURT OF COMMON PLEAS o o / PHILADELPHIA COUNTY V. JULY TERM, 2005 DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION NO. 3379 PRAECIPE TO TRANSFER MATTER TO CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Kindly transfer the above-referenced case, including certified copies of the docket entries, process, pleadings, and other papers filed in this action pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1006(d)(3) to the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania in accordance with the attached Court Order dated September 19, 2005 upon payment of the appropriate costs and fees for the transfer by Defendant. MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & GOGGIN By GARY NEUBAUM DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION COURT OF COMMON PLEA ??< PHILADELPHIA COUNTY ?l<, ?Ep 2 j Aj JULY TERM, 2005 %?. 2005 / r NO. 3379 /, IDS 1°17Y. ORDER AND NOW, this /r4y of 5/w , 2005, upon consideration of defendant DaimlerChrysler Corporation's Petition to Transfer Venue To Cumberland County based upon forum non conveniens and any response thereto, it is hereby ORDERED and DECREED that said Petition is GRANTED and the above-captioned matter is hereby transferred to the Court of Common Pleas for Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. The costs and fees for transfer and removal shall be paid by the Defendant pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1006(d)(3). The Philadelphia County Prothonotary is hereby directed to forward to Cumberland County Prothonotary certified copies of docket entries, proceed pleadings, depositions and all other papers filed in this action, pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1006(d)(3). COPIES SENT PURSUANT TO P..R.C.P.236(b) SEP 19 2005 FIRSTJUDICIA OISTRICTOFPA USER 1.0.- DOCKETED COMPLEX LIT r,E l ;- SEP 19 2005 J. STEWART I J. ' curt Of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County Fv Pmoauryu e o S fOwset N.mCerl Trial Division JULY 2005 Civil Cover Sheet PIANTIFF'S ILME IQEFENOMITSI E Gary Neubaum DaimlerChrysler Corporation CJy 3379 PLAINTIFF] ACORESS OEFENOMIrS AOORE_5 610 West Shady Lane C/O CT CORPORATION Enola, PA 17025 1515 Market St., Phila PA OEFE1,eA"T'51uME PLAUILF:'S .OGRESS pEFENOANiS A00RE°3 I I PLAINnFF-s N. M'e _ - --. I eEFENCANr5 NAPE I PCu.TIFF'S AOORE55 I CEFENOANTSACCRESS I ' TOTAL IIULI3 ER OF PLAINTIFFS TOLL NO. OF OEFEFIOwNTS COMMENCEMENT OF AC TION J Ca IN Plai., ? Pcoition AcliorT ? ;l.lin of Appnl 1 1 IPOL.M.M.sf ?TTL .. F.. Othcrl.,i sdicli.. MOUNT IN CONTROVER5Y COURT PROCMM5 550.000.00 or IaS Arhiu Bd.. ? M. Tort El C.. ? 5nllcmu¢ M.Tc Than 550.000.00 Jury ? 5a Ei.es Asian ? MIR.r Court Appcsl ? hfinurs ? Non-Jury ? ?.Uli.. ?" . Snmmry Appcals ? W,'0/S urn.'al ? Othm I CASE TYPE ANO O TOE (SEEE INSTRUCTIONS? - 1 C CONTRACT I SrANrORY 3A515 %CR CAUSE pF ACTION (SE31NSTRUCiIONS) N/A RELJTCO FENCING CASES ILIST BY C.:EE CAPTION ANO COCMEr NUMBER) IS USC BUT, EC T TO CCCRO IIUrIOII O ROERI I CS O ? ? NONE ? ? ? ? I TO THE P20TH0N0T.=.R`i r l.indly enee, my aooearance on behalCoCPlalntirirPedtion_:% noellanr. i I I aoe.E may se:vc? at ;he address set Conh be!o %,. .IACIE OF At AINTIFF"SIPETITIONER' EUPPELLAtirs ATTORNEY ...SEES ISEE lug TRVC:OUSI David J. Gorberg 1234 Market Street Phila., PA 19107 PI?.I,EI 563-7210 7210 X138 ' :UPgt Lic ?JVNr 'CEN LHCA TIJ" nt, c uul ACOFE=: 53084 DATE 7/11/05 IL,UI liic: :C'=J? ASSESSMENT OF DAMAGES IS1' ?F?I,1RE? DAVID J. GORBERG & ASSOCIATES. P.C. BY: DAVID 1, GORBERG IDENTIFICATION NO. SUITE 2040 qqqpp???? 1234 MARKESAW+T PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA 19107 (215) 563-7210 GARY NEUBAUM 610 West Shady Lane Enola, PA 17025 VS. DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORA* OjN ATTORNEY FOR c/o CT Corporation1515 Market Strl I' Philadelphia, PA 19103 1 THIS I8 Mt A,RB=AM"; 1880J1Ktlc IN rt, PF. ILADELt'IpKg 70; r: 5 rout wm' COURT OF COMMON PLEAS DIVISION :a JULY 2005 TERM, No.C{'0 e2379 CIVIL ACTION COMPLAINT IC CONTRACT NOTICE You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that it you tail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the court without further notice for any money claimed in the complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW. THIS OFFICE CAN PROVIDE YOU WITH INFORMATION ABOUT HIRING A LAWYER. IF YOU CANNOT AFFORD TO HIRE A LAWYER, THIS OFFICE MAY BE ABLE TO PROVIDE YOU WITH INFORMATION ABOUT AGENCIES THAT MAY OFFER LEGAL SERVICES TO ELIGIBLE PERSONS AT A REDUCED FEE OR NO FEE. LAWYER REFERENCE SERVICE One Reading Center 1101 Market Street Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19107 (215) 238-6333 AVISO Le ban demandado an corte. Si usted desen defender contra las demandas dispuestas an las p6ginas siguientes, usted debe turner Is accibn an el plazo de veins (20) dies despubs de esta queja y se save aviso, Incorporando on aspecto escrilo personalmente o y archivando an escribir can la corte sus defenses u objeciones a las demandas dispuestas contra usted el abogado le advierte qua at oared no puede facer asi qua el case poodle proceder sin ustetl y un juicio se puede incorporar contra usted compra la corte sin aviso adicional para cualquier dinero demandado an la queja o pare cualquier once demanda o relovacibn pedida per el demandante. Dated puede pander el dinero o to caracteristica de otra endereza importante a ustetl. LISTED DEBE LLEVAR ESTE PAPEL SID ABOGADO INMEDIATAMENTE. SI USTED NO FACE DUE UN ABOGADO VAYA A O LLAME POR TFLEFONO LA OFICINA DISPUESTA ABAJO. ESTA OFICINA PUEDE PROVEER DE USTED LA INFORMACi6N SOBRE EMPLEAR A UN ABOGADO. SI USTED NO PUEDE PERMITIRSE AL HIRE A UN ABOGADO, ESTA OFICINA PUEDE PODER PROVEER DE LISTED LA INFORMACION SOBRE LAS AGENCIAS DUE LOS SERVICIOS JURIDICOS DE LA OFERTA DE MAYO A LAS PERSONAS ELEGIBLES EN UN HONORARIO REDUCIDO 0 NINGUN HONORARIO. SERVICIO DE REFERENCIA LEGAL One Reading Center 1101 Market Street Filadelfia, Pennsylvania 19107 Toofono: (215) 238-6333 DAVID J. GORBERG & ASSOCIATES, P.C. By: DAVID J. GORBERG Attorney for Plaintiffs Identification No. 53084 1234 Market Street Suite 2040 Philadelphia, PA 19107 (215) 563-7210 GARY NEUBAUM 610 West Shady Lane Enola, PA 17025 vs. DAIMLER CHRYSLER CORPORATION c/o CT CORPORATION 1515 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 NO. TERM, 2005 COMPLAINT Plaintiff, Gary Neubaum, is an adult individual citizen and legal resident of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, residing at 610 West Shady Lane< Enola, PA 17025. 2. Defendant, Daimler Chrysler Corporation, is a business corporation qualified to do business and regularly conducts business in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania with its legal residence and principal place of business at P O Box 21-8004, Auburn Hills, Michigan 48321 COURT OF COMMON PLEAS PHILADELPHIA COUNTY and can be served at c/o CT Corporation, 1515 Market Street, Philadelphia, PA 19103. BACKGROUND 3. Plaintiff incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 and 2 as fully as if set forth here length. On or about March 31, 2003, Plaintiff purchased a 2003 Chrysler Sebring manufactured and warranted by Defendant bearing the Vehicle Identification Number 1 C3EL65R13N526172. The vehicle was purchased and registered in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. 5. The price of the vehicle, including registration charges, document fees, sales tax, but, excluding other collateral charges not specified, totaled more than $30,000.00. 6. Plaintiff avers that as a result of the ineffective repair attempts made by Defendant through its authorized dealer, the vehicle cannot be utilized for the purposes intended by Plaintiff at the time of acquisition and as such, the vehicle is worthless. In consideration of the purchase of the above vehicle, Defendant, issued to Plaintiff several warranties, fully outlined in the warranty booklet. 8. On or about March 31, 2003, Plaintiff took possession of the above mentioned vehicle and experienced nonconformities, which substantially impaired the use, value and/or safety of the vehicle. 4. Said nonconformities consisted of, but was not limited to, defective air bag and engine. Copies of repair receipts are attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "A". 10. The nonconformities violate the express written warranties issued to Plaintiff by Defendant. 11. Plaintiff avers the vehicle has been subject to repair more than two (2) times for the same nonconformity, and the nonconformity remains uncorrected. 11 Plaintiff has delivered the nonconforming vehicle to an authorized service and repair facility of the defendant on numerous occasions. After a reasonable number of attempts, Defendant was unable to repair the nonconformities. 13. In addition, the above vehicle has or will in the future be out of service by reason of the non-conformities complained of for a cumulative total of thirty (30) days or more. 14. The vehicle continues to exhibit defects and nonconformities which substantially impair it's use, value and/or safety. 15. Plaintiff avers the vehicle has been subject to additional repair attempts for defects and/or nonconformities and/or conditions for which the Defendant and or it's authorized service center, may not have maintained records. 16. Plaintiff has been and will continue to be financially damaged due to Defendant's intentional, reckless, wanton and negligent failure to comply with the provisions of its' warranty. 17. Plaintiff seeks relief for losses due to the nonconformities and defects in the above mentioned vehicle in addition to attorney fees and all court costs. COUNTI PENNSYLVANIA AUTOMOBILE LEMON LAW CLAIM 18. Plaintiff hereby incorporates all facts and allegations set forth in this Complaint by reference as if fully set forth at length herein. 19. Plaintiff is a "Purchaser" as defined by 73 P.S. §1952. 20. Defendant is a "Manufacturer" as defined by 73 P.S. § 1952. 21. Plaintiffs vehicle is a "New Motor Vehicle" as defined by 73 P. S. §1952. 22. Said vehicle experienced non conformities within the first year of purchase, which substantially impairs the use, value and safety of said vehicle. 11 23. Defendant failed to correct and or repair said nonconformities. 24. The vehicle continues to exhibit defects and nonconformities which substantially impair it's use, value and/or safety. 25. Defendant does not require participation in any informal dispute settlement program prior to filing suit. 26. As a direct and proximate result of Defendant's failure to repair the nonconformities, Plaintiff has suffered damages and, in accordance with 73 P.S. §1958, Plaintiff is entitled to bring suit for such damages and other legal and equitable relief. 27. Plaintiff avers that upon successfully prevailing upon the Lemon Law claim herein, all attorney fees are recoverable and are demanded against the Defendant. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully demands judgment in his favor and against the Defendant in an amount equal to three (3) times the purchase price of the subject vehicle, plus all available collateral changes and attorney fees. Amount not in excess of $50,000.00. COUNT It MAGNUSON-MOSS FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION IMPROVEMENT ACT 28. Plaintiff hereby incorporates all facts and allegations set forth in this Complaint by reference as if fully set forth at length herein. 29. Plaintiff is a "Consumer" as defined by 15 U.S.C. §2301(3). 30. Defendant is a "Warrantor" as defined by 15 U.S.C. §2301(5). 31. Plaintiff uses the subject product for personal, family and household purposes. 32. By the terms of the express written warranties referred to in this Complaint, Defendant agreed to perform effective warranty repairs at no charge for parts and/or labor. 33. Defendant failed to make effective repairs. 34. As a direct and proximate result of Defendant's failure to comply with the express written warranties, Plaintiff has suffered damages and, in accordance with 15 U.S.C. §2310(d) (1), Plaintiff is entitled to bring suit for such damages and other legal and equitable relief. 35. Section 15 U.S.C. §2310 (d) (1) provides: If a consumer finally prevails on an action brought under paragraph (1) of this subsection, he may be allowed by the Court to recover as part of the judgment a sum equal to the amount of aggregate amount of costs and expenses (including attorney fees based upon actual time expended), determined by the Court to have been reasonably incurred by the Plaintiff for, or in connection with the commencement and prosecution of such action, unless the Court, in its discretion shall determine that such an award of attorney's fees would be inappropriate. 36. Plaintiff avers that upon successfully prevailing upon the Magnuson-Moss claim herein, all attorney fees are recoverable and are demanded against the Defendant. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully demands judgment in his favor and against the Defendant in an amount equal to three (3) times the purchase price of the subject vehicle, plus all available collateral changes and attorney fees. Amount not in excess of $50,000.00. COUNT III UNIFORM COMMERCIAL CODE 37. Plaintiff hereby incorporates all the paragraphs of this Complaint by reference as if fully set forth at length herein. 38. The defects and nonconformities existing within the vehicle constitute a breach of contractual and statutory obligations of the Defendant, including but not limited to the following; a. Breach of Express Warranty b. Breach of Implied Warranty of Merchantability; C. Breach of Implied Warranty of Fitness For a Particular Purpose; Breach of Duty of Good Faith. 39. The purpose for which Plaintiff purchased the vehicle include but are not limited to his personal, family and household use. 40. At the time of this purchase and at all times subsequent thereto, Plaintiff has justifiably relied upon Defendant's express warranties and implied warranties of fitness for a particular purpose and implied warranty of merchantability. 41. At the time of the purchase and at all times subsequent thereto, Defendant was aware Plaintiff was relying upon Defendant's express and implied warranties, obligations, and representations with regard to the subject vehicle. 42. Plaintiff has incurred damages as a direct and proximate result of the breach and failure of Defendant to honor its express and implied warranties. 43. Such damages include, but are not limited to, the purchase price of the vehicle plus all collateral charges, including attorney fees and costs, as well as other expenses, the full extent of which are not yet known. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully demands judgment in his favor and against the Defendant in an amount equal to three (3) times the purchase price of the subject vehicle, plus all available collateral changes and attorney fees. Amount not in excess of $50,000.00. COUNT IV PENNSYLVANIA UNFAIR TRADE PRACTICES AND CONSUMER PROTECTION CLAIM 44. Plaintiff hereby incorporates all the paragraphs of this Complaint by reference as if set forth at length herein. 45. The Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law defines unfair methods of competition to include the following: (xiv). Failing to comply with the terms of any written guarantee or warranty given to the buyer at, prior to, or after a contract for the purchase of goods or services is made. 46. Plaintiff, as a Pennsylvania resident, believes, and therefore, avers the reckless, wanton and willful failure of Defendant to comply with the terms of the written warranty constitutes an unfair method of competition. 47. Section 201-9.2(a) of the Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law, authorizes the Court, in its discretion, to award up to three (3) times the actual damages sustained for violations of the Act. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully demands judgment in his favor and against the Defendant in an amount equal to three (3) times the purchase price of the subject vehicle, plus all available collateral changes and attorney fees. Amount not in excess of $50,000.00. DAVID J. GORBERG & ASSOCIATE BY:_ DA ESQUIRE Attorney for Plaintiff VERIFICATION The undersigned verifies that the Civil Action Complaint is based on information fumished to counsel in the preparation of his/her Lemon Law and/or Breach of Warranty lawsuit. The language of the Civil Action Complaint is that of counsel and not of signer. Signer verifies that the information supplied to counsel is true and correct to the best of his/her knowledge, information and belief. The contents of the Civil Action Complaint is that of counsel and not of signer. This verification is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to Date: Z v d s Cashier, 3 1 RYSIER CUSTOMER COPY 6 P.C. Box 120" BeaverSP639s, Fv 17872 (570) 658-0100 CUSTOMER Copy GARY/BETH NEUEAUM 610 W SHADY IN ENOLA PA 17025 0 A X.X ^^^ WCDRO CUSTOMER STATES WATER LEAK IN TRUNK 1 SM06VXLAB 1 SM07VXLAB 1 SLA9VYT.AP 31/2003 1028047 03/31/20031 03/31/2003 CARPET-WHEELHOU CARPET-WHEELHOU CARPET-LUGGAGE B X.X INDSV CUSTOMER STATES 40972 PASSENGER SEAT BOTTOM 1S LOOSE NC NC NC NC 0.4 Labor Op. 23002040 Failure Code?1E ADJUSTED HOOD NC Total Sublet 0.00 Total Deductible 0,.°00 Total Misc. 0.00 ;comer 1 .00 lature X M SOLUTIONS, INC. X888) 3A3-6806 1988 6199 Cashier-> 3 13? E' CUSTOMER COPY A.f rvQYG'A AYAC0?99A a'5. ., CP A&e.E P.O. Box 126 BeaverSprings, PA 17812 (570) 658-0100 CUSTOMER COPY CUSTOMER NO. LICENSE# STOCK ft DEALER# INVOICE DATE INVOICE# 526172 3299 68512 07/14/2003 029560 CUSTOMER NAME & ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT LOT #/HAT k COLOR DELIVERY DATE GARY NEUBAUM 3732M 3732M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 610 W SHADY'LN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L 017/14/2003 07/11/2003 VEHICLE ID # TECH & # P.O. # EN6LA PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. INT. EST. 6874 EXTENDED WARRANTY CO. POLICY# DEDUCTIBLE AUiHORIZATION# ADJUSTOR NONE 0.00 RESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY SIGNATURE QP smgq{aY, 11SA, dbC ` 'SCkbrc?aaWn sptEeac 95 vi .y.A jj. e'1 SI SMIb4f???{Lt i.. P S i6AII dODE \ GK"'3E. }waPp.. ? t . ? FdiirvNNBm ? ? .. a .ALm 06LRp+1(M4' :' Mp ?? ,+? A 0.5 CPDRO LUBE OIL FILTER 4350C gS ?` °L' O'I ' ` 17 ?^73i0 £? 0h AA BUL ' ' ?, { ., .'',w„ - 7 { P 7 S >D30 Shop Supplies x 0 60 _ OIL FILTER DISPOSAL 2.00 . Job A Total Parts & Labor 21.95 . k? I t T I Sates Tax , ., 1 36 A r I,a IR - ,.. ' .. .. .: 43500 . ... „ .... STATE INSPECTION,LF 10B, RR 6B, TIRES 8/32 19.95 STICKER #7769543 x K ? ?" ? . Job B Tota3 Parts & labor 19 95 + .? - s ? 4 Y4 4.. C ` `?+ A {.'S 3" Y x '{ ' ? t 3 ? _ S { t l t } It.l; F ju 3 S V E? TajL N! n f txS IvIn 0 a yIFS `# ? S "t p P " ; / '" ek { k 4 T F ? p E i y T _ j ; , ? y . a .t t # r 1 `5 " ' t x to ? c ? T t e a y 1 r ; j s sZ ,'a8' Yyr -' . \ s x ,. - x n d is x, ' y,*M ! 3 $ R J ?ci *E xr Y T } / y k t ? ( 'i '1 2 r x r `Rr 1 ;rfi 3 £ :. Total 4.abor = 33 §`0 \ Total Sublet 0.00 Total Deductible 0.00 Total Misc. 0.60 } _# a _ t w ' t{ r f '''. ' z ' Ha2ard Dth ,'0 goo >» W.kt x 9 t .v ;A T t l T =4 56 - e o a ax , x ., EXTENDED WARRANTY PAY EAOiORY WARRANTY PAY ALL LAfiOR CHARGES ARE 61lLFD ON FLAT ltP1E FINAL E6iIMA1E ' ' HOURS UNLESS OTHERWISE NOicD iOiAL CdSTOM eR PA\ 47.06 Signature X 'ORM SOLUTIONS, INO. 188813!3-6086 iM 3988 6/99 :ashier -> 3 1 :USTOMER COPY 526172 ISTOMER NAME & ADDRESS GARY NEU13AUM 610 W SHADY LN ENOLA PA 17025 P.O. Box 126 Beaver Springs, PA 17812 (570) 658-0100 3299 AGE IN MILEAGE OUT 3290M 3290M /MAKE/MODEL 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L :LE ID # 1C3EL65R13N526172 'RIDE SERVICE WRITE UP 6874 CUSTOMER COPY 68512 07/14/2003 1029396 /HAT# COLOR DELIVERY DATE STERL 03/11/2003 PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 07/14/2003 07/01/2003 0.00 A X.X INDSV CUSTOMER STATES AIR BAG LIGHT WAS ON 43501 B X.X WCDRO CUSTOMER STATES DRIVERS SEAT RECLINER IS INOP. 4350W - - - - 1.4 Labor Op. 23135502 Failure Code 51 Total Deductible Total Misc. 0.00 0.00 0.00 'Ustomer ignature X OEM SOLUTIONS, INC. 18881 343-6886 W 3988 6/99 CHRYSLER ,ashier-> 3 1 -X25^'USTOMER COPY L/ .l®L GARY NEU13AUM 610 W SHADY LN ENOLA PA 17025 P.O. Box 126 Beaver Springs, PA 17812 (570) 658-0100 CUSTOMER COPY 66512 07/14/2003 029561 HATrt COLOR DELIVERY DATE STERL 03/11/2003 PROD. DATE R.O. DATE _ 07/14/2003 07/11/2003 2 A X.X INDSV CUSTOMER STATES THROTTLE STICKS B X.X INDSV CUSTOMER STATES CONVERT.ABLE TOP SQUEAKS GOING UP A - 43501 PUT TOP UP AND DOWN RUES ON THE WAY NO ADJUSTMENT Total Sublet Total Deductible Total Misc. NO 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 -ustomer ignature X 'ORM SOLUTIONS, INC. (8881343-6005 W 3988 3/99 7325047 CARY NEUBAUM 610 W SHADY IN ENOLA, PA 17025 HOME: 732-5047 BUS: 772-6254 OPTIONS BRENNER 4 9 3 1 2 FAMILY OF DEALERSHIPS *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike CHRYSLER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep. ® (717) 766-7686 PAGE 1 Web Site: www.brennerchryslerjeep.com E-mail: brennercj@earthlink.net RVICE ADVISOR: 167 Rnl PARKER C3 DLR:685 MPI 003 LIST ON ALL THE.TIME .RUSE: LIGHT ON 23130104 REFASTEN SEAT BELT CONNNECTOR FC: UC PART#: COUNT: AUTH CODE: 6133 PARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE A: 0.00 CHRYSLER Jeep The factory warranty constitutes all of the warranties with respect to LABOR AMOUNT the sale of this Item/items. The PARTS AMOUNT Seller hereby expressly disclaims all warranties, either express or implied, including any implied GAS, OIL, LURE warranty of merchantability or fitness for a particular ur ose SUBLET AMOUNT p p . Seller neither assumes nor h i MISC. CHARGES aut or zes any other person to assume for it any liability in TOTAL CHARGES connection with the sale of this LESS INSURANCE item/items . SALES TAX CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY :ashier•> 7 09 1 1 c7a ? -USTnMER COPY •. occrvr? ?nu?u?a, mu. P.O. Box 126 Beaver Springs, PA 17812 (570) 658-0100 CUSTOMER COPY CUSTOMER NO. LICENSE # STOCK# DEALER # INVOICE DATE INVOICE # 14161 3299 68512 12/02/2003 031513 CUSTOMER NAME & ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT LOT#/HAT # COLOR DELIVERY DATE GARY/BETH NEUBAUM 7463M 7463M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 610 W SHADY LN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L 12/02/2003 12/02/2003 VEHICLE ID# TECH &# P,o.# ENOLA PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. INT. EST. 3102 EXTENDED WARRANTY CO. POLICY # DEDUCTIBLE AUHORILATION # ADJUSTOR NONE 0.00 RESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRIT ER DEUVERY SIGNATURE OP FRHWMC14'4Y95' ?ii 77, i.{ ? i t ::. . ••, ,, ><« . .'.„' , c..PA4Yaauxvx' S.t,? ..:"„ , `,,tti9[Hli,?e : .. :: ., maarCESC?akis3+ tf '. ; .' ? . t a:?? ..3 , A 0.5 CPDRO LUEE OIL FILTER 6745C 01 I r ' ^` E ? ??' bIF? RILT"EI? t ? Y 11 95 E # t Y { s t Vn ? Sk 1.Ft ; Yr?, Q i Y y Xfl }k T5 T#.f Y !? w. R t i tx a J t a3 Y1I3?7ItE?+ eT•? F.£?E'S#ST? .^..yt?? ALL SE?? ?ES F?`1*?t ?'3? IUD ut F E t .: ^ e F Z t E ;i`£.+ 3+ ?t t tS ?Y-? 3 E #, } t6 . ; fi t 4 S a l s # ? "? ` i ' i T , 3 ? " t 1ai"T3 i n ? :: _ x . T; t t#t a ?7I.i?Tk ,Re G LNP S 0 s 'S, iJ-F7 =' t : •, . ..,,,. <... ? ?_?.s'? `<?«t "` ' ' `? 10 OIL 1OW30 MOPAit B UL 5 00' °'° Shop Supplies 0.60 Job A Total Parts & Labor 21.95 r # k - 1 3k 24 Y£9 t4 a i t t' t "' 5d }' ^ t `• 1- 11 , ? t ] 5 S 5 M N . a } „T,r t Y 25 "rte ? DC rot LAY N x .x,* y q t §9'" JS i ' ( a ?* i '?£ ? t ' CP9'R£3 ?T E''TP R'9;S 4 ?' # 'O` f v+ t s q I f F ` , ? t„ 6745C 02 " "" ROTATED TIRES 14.95 Job B Total Parts & Labor 14.95 Sa3es fax a 90 rc £ bT k «t P 3 12 L 4 V' F ? I t' 4 4 '$ F E t F 4? :# S j 4Y Y .k "k k } t i y 4 3 ./t C "{ t fi fii it is T r 23 t Y "' t T , i t t .A` s TVQ 3 i 4 I Xk` 4 %1k 7 I yz i' 'H # ? 3 u 3 } g P y s r Sr L # n t 5Y 3 t '"t 3# ^£U t RQ ''?i FRD` TFryF'I3A i ; « I y n F .?< <.£,..' °,SP INSTALLED FRONT MUDFLAPS 0.00 1 82203871 GUARD KIT-SPLAS 1 0 .5 0 ^I / 1 8 ?. 'T t <Y jF t ? ? k 3^. ? t ? t 4 t 5 t ? £ it 1? ? (fi [?, # y 4 £ : 2JUJY "'? ?f'1. Y?1 t ??4 Wr. ?t«?Y+r. t [y.?.4]t 'yS V. t J u2 # « A 3 Sh. t' i t F q ; y 3 y$ I k Y S, ?A `Y [ `+ tT Ct ? S£ t t ? ? t £ ? -k ' ?# L £ t t ? , 'V 7J N i PR 5 * y i S Y ?21 5 y4 '^1X '?? N F ? -3 t> £ 3 t t t I ,iY Y S 3 y ,. j r: ? ,iY # fyit? «4 kG CC dY' 44 4 4 k i . M C F 1 E F f i f J I : # ?a4 Y`'} i'Yi{ ? C, ' 4b t ? S ? T t # . U t t « i u h: t 5 l S 9 S y { f t t# t t t" T I £T 5 }i t Y fi? f ? 4 ?? ? y `? i4 F t Et t S To`'? l b ; ? # ?? ' .a + 3. :p h .a -Y , ?, '?a t 5 4 4' L @?? S.t. rs'f6t i '`a t t ?TT ?: ? Y9 3T ??x1Y SAT , £ F E t j £ ? T . T, .a ? «? « ??? ?{?'?? Total Sublet 0. 00< ' Total Deductible 0.00 'Dotal Misc. 0.60 E Tt l ?'Oth t ?i AO ' Sad 'ard . y a r t # U s F s ttr w Tt J Y T t sY 9 F £ # : hi? } i' N x i 1 r Tpta TF L'x t] $? $? 5 ? t 1 S t ? . d #. 3 f ,: x 3 s; F iw EXTENDED WARRANN PAV FACTORY WARRANTY PAY IAB GES ARE BILLED ON FIAT RAZE FINAL ESTIMATE TOTAL CUSTOMER PAY H UNIO HOURS UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED 50.89 FUJI VI I ICI Signature X FORM SOLUTIONS, INC. 18881 343- 006 HM 3988 6/99 N :1Y K r Low- Mfy - q mcs IAA. C? 67"1 CHNSIER v~ P.O. Box 126 ,ash.ier-> 3 09 0 Beaver Springs, PA 17812 (570) 658-0100 'USTOMER COPY CUSTOMER COPY CUSTOMER NO. LICENSEk STOCK# DEALER# INVOICE DATE INVOICE# 033154 CU i3 AME & ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT LOT #/HAT # COLOR DELIVERY DATE GARY/BETH NEUPAUM m r 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD, DATE P.O. DATE 610 W SHADY LN n?rlwp= 7.P RP.RRTNr T, n4/19/')004 00 VEHICLE ID# TECH &# P.O.# ENOLA PA 17025 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. INT. EST. EXTENDED WARRANTY CO. POLICY# DEDUCTIBLE n nn AUTHORIZAT ION4 ADJUSTOR R E PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY SIGNATURE f4P. qq ={t t T?SfN##f 3RF C Fry 3 _ " iv (" x 5 " iA. tt S$ i`. A y } ? 3 C. , n ci . n $. row ,`i5. .. ,'cst a ? ? : h w ,,.., roERFODUtia?N ,: T7 '§ :'?z vM.aVaN-0azft p n s kpt»q^nwnoM A 0.5 CPDRO LUBE OIL FILTER F7&5C 01 z Y ' i r. t *+: ? T ?ZT 'r c % a as M Y :q e s s f f FTTER x?gY' s 4 1xt5?3?9?+' ? ff I Ifr Shop Supplies 0.60 -- - - - - -- -- Job A-Total - Parts & Labor 21.95 Sales Tax 1.36 _ ''h}Y [ d 3 "[ Y Sy fF RK fc ''y rYt + 1 ti ik dk '' S A Y' {? # t ? K kt? k"F s 4'x sz { ' 1xY+ f a ? r t*u' ?' 41 T t a " a ` ° z f } ?"? a & i dd??S 1 `I 4 .i 4 C A 1 S t C a T ° A = y "A$ T 3 i {t i..? 3 I t Y a = IS # "§ }`E m 'AY4; = t §L f s b i s 9 ti xf V #y^?T ,{ t x i #i'i°S t t % V k+ 4 T,ES ? ' .+' i.? 'H ; f i t 4 .. `' R y'( : +3.k X7" i L* S {R x x as ? 4 "? P k { { T ,p.. ?? T n > : ,{,- A2 tj kN x}. Y a ...? x ? ' ' _. • -:._. ,..; =6 i ..?.?.:,- =.,ku:,.?S,..,.!s.. „ ., t, -•<_ T45C. ,. of . .. - ROTATED TIRES TO HAVE EVEN TREAD ON FRONT OF VEHICLE 14.95 Job B Total Parts & Labor 14.95 Sales Tax 0.90 I t % 1 9 k y% 2 ?" 3} {54 T k ? ¢ t tY 1 ?N y .2 P $ Y ? Y YSY 4k.kfY t } `S # Y t f# t Y = k =$ ? ry ' t [ t $ , { q , y i3 r P i. i pn i ' 4N£` f ' k S btt N' SF + I t 's t $- 1 R i ? , % t x _ .y F ! k p' AG t . ,. t; ; i l S r :A. .? ac fi t R tx r a `" <. + z 3{i ? r U e-irV° iF . xx+ " ? a {t T{+{ g ILL C )R ,T S y k Jf xtti x # NT t IT R} ' y E ( ? 'e t34 { ! F t k Y tS i?T 3r t Rf .Y S i T 1 ?" + kr` T _ r Y i fq K t A i r' Y x + .. = h i r {i r p W} } Y{ t x} p 1-6 t 5t id v 3 Ld Kt } l i EL ",4 t e + s "k° 1 e T tt a? II-dh02' { a = ' 6 Q t i "r t ^ ? E 4 -. t ,f'=a,. ,. t 3 Total Sublet 0.00 Total Deductible 0.00 Total Misc 0.60 a a r / ' Pz tai Tam ' ' ` 2 2 ? s Rd ft .. 1i ?. .. .. EXIENOEG WARRANrv PAV FACTORY WARRANN PAY ALL LABOR CHARGES ARE ELIAS ON FLAT RATE FINAL ESTMAff TOTAL CUSTOMER PAY HOURS UNLE56 OTHERWISE NOTED 39.76 CUSTOrner Signature X FORM SOLUTIONS, INC. (888) 363-6006 HM 3998 6/99 lashier-> 3 09 5 O B :USTOMER COPY e LVu"C71 IVIVLVI.I1 ¦1I(I. P.O. Box 126 Beaver SPrinos, PA 17812 (570) 658-0100 CUSTOMER COPY CUSTOMER NO. LICENSE # STOCK # DEALER # INVOICE DATE INVOICE # 14161 3299 68512 04/19/2004 033155 CUSTOMER NAME&ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT LOT#/HAT# COLOR DELIVERY DATE GARY/BETH NEUBAUM 10416M- 10416M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 610 W SHADY LN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L 04/19/2004 04/19/2004 VEHICLE ID # TECH & # PO. # ENOLA PA 17025 1C3ELGSR13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. INT. EST. 6874 EXTENDED WARRANTY CO. POLICY # DEDUCTIBLE AUTHORIZATION # ADJUSTOR NONE 0.00 RESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY SIGNATURE ,:Es#"a?k?Wa ,.. (,5'l cooe .y„?iarrmrtiF ^'?z. ..,? ,,ma?y?awG°1??cyR€, . k a'x :si, .k s z .lia E'? ' t Customer Signature X FORM SOLUTIONS, INC. (8881343-6006 HM 3988 6/99 Total Deductible Total Misc. .ashier •> 3 09'C 7 B -USTOMER COPY '• a+ "vcl IIIVLV/JS ¦ffa . P.O. Box 126 Beaver Springs, PA 17812 (570) 658-0100 CUSTOMER COPY CUSTOMER NO. LICENSES STOCKS DEAIER# INVOICE DATE INVOICE# 14161 3299 68512 05/19/2004 033522 CUSTOMER NAME &ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT LOT#THAT} COLOR DELIVERY DATE GARY/BETH NEUBAUM 11763M 11763M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 610 W SHADY LN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L 05/19/2004 05/19/2004 VEHICLE ID # TECH & # P,O, # ENOLA PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S W. INT. EST. 6874 EMENDED WARRANTY CO. POLICY # DEDUCTIBLE AUTHORIZATION # ADJUSTOR NONE 0.00 RESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY SIGNATURE "O? ,y: #.R+YT?a. ,picccspe '.•. 3i?ex:[Mte h .°i ..,., ?rW,glp?rtDCiuFresl? ,... , n ,j% =L t: ., _,. ? . k t's4n+a9Eee^+, '....., t _ a !`.•1•• •j• :?•..' F` ;•;'RA9IYY341M4Y '*A'.iL ,...,`PPi&IA6H ?F°s9 ..." &4RIF%3?)FSIPIIGN A X.X WCDRO CUSTOMER STATES DRIVERS DOOR IS NOISEY WHEN OPENING 435OW L7f?32 T'- OtF ;EREiD NB : R I2T E 2S D HECFG 1' rC T ? T ± ?a.. Y r k t j ' ? EE ` N ' t Y ° 'k * , 3 $6 a Y .g 1 Fa' $ IE 01 9 s I k ° G 'tr $ s T b " S t a } t i ?t " 4 YO iY. i ii g § t t }} T S } zS { ? [* R } Y T T k "£E i * a ?Y k 6 i ,e r '4' 3L I4 X }1t K } }:"2, , : :, At Y , k s . ,. .. ... ...... t_. a w w ... i B X.X WCDRO CUSTOMER STATES REAR DEFROSTER IS INOP. AT THE BOTTOM 4350W_ FOUND GRID DID NOT HAVE CONTINUITY AT LOWER HALF, NC •'?`il'3?`HA 't 5? '5`' '. J1{4 9 Y t aJ I ? i ttt ; A $ { 3 1 r t 'S t u ; F {* :t #i ? ;,* .. ? 33 ..t fl ta .L {Y tix } 'i'{}i ¢.:Y{ Y,${ Y T tt?.y -ki {YT t!u t? j vLp` t j { ' f Rl?^:§ 61 a * ] "5{4S {'.?i'aC %it•4 3 ? dti.4} Y't ;ikL34; kY.^3 'l,'Gf{ i{th t a aMi{ t}VI'fFS YC } x 14y. Y Y{k i ? }*4 Ft { Y"t#k}S } t y?, C s{ .ei.4? 3 ? t I E`t? '4[ 4 Y a4 ? "• k ` ' ? } Ry Y S , , . ?; {3 ¢ y? i S t{! { Y Y } Sj 3 .j £ k . ,?+ 1 L {W rv3Y S+r { W #s4 i rt lYt k {f 4 rvi Y t tt [ v r i £ ..' Y 9}C"' ?t fi4S i T " ` ? t ? ' t } v ? .a: „e ,,. ., „?..., . }. 3 , t ! . F .a a . ,. . f.. .. `?:.: t.u.. . .... ..3.Y,.,.:;3+ .. 1 ': } I•rxa 1' .....x. i .. ,. ?. „ a , . iy Y i t . Yuk i t t f 1 t { y C 4 !? Y 5...i ? i ! t i x? L C } k } L' t a i k 3 t T Y Y ?; y t 2 ( A Y k. t } Y t. g f 4 i Y ? t S{0 ? ! S t Y{ } t t Y 4 aii 9jyik ?k{ S'a w ` Y t 4 5 4 rv *}s -5 ^k ?: Y 4,{ t } {S 4>w"{Y"" 4" a ! k t k 2 }4 T u. Y t IMA : i k y ay ? +s, Y t ? i }? Y L C 3 iY }? Y t t Y ? i Y. C nt a? r to t t? 4 j i FU 3 ? T i .{ T )4?3 Y i't ? i t 9 t ! q z`2 } a { 7 ts t? }a { 4 ' a ' ? ' ° t r ,;b, ?, s . '$ a Y T e ?a, ° k to > r t t t. S Y (? I i 't + Y t C !. , [ t YR S Y I Vl i d I t Y t t ..fi Iy f i i 3'IF I]f E;L Ft'{'R ". k4{}!tt-k Y5 Y TiDtHyJL71? .w a # r z,F>t T'„ { +t`YOta3- Parts t 0,0 ur D' { r? Y w' v . ,, p a 4, . a Total 6uble't 0:00•. Total Deductible 0.00 Total Misc. 0.00 x 1 F t o Hazard/Oth0. 4A a t a4, Y;i s x" "Y, it x t - `f? T`ttt al, TaX -0; 0A $ { t . Y i..E e F C J § ?? { •^ E Y t YR } 4 ' { . ? k SI Y% 4 S i , i EMENDED WARRANTY PAY FACTORY WARRANrv PAY All LABOR CHARGES BILLHD ON FlAi RATE FINAL ESTIMATE TOTAL CUSTOMER PAY HOURS UNLESS 0THERMSR,VI6E NOTED Customer Signature A FORM SOLUTIONS, INC. (888) 3636886 HM 3986 6199 Ocavci ivwwiay U?G. P.O. Box 126 -PRINT 3 10C L' 2 Beaver Springs, PA 17812 zE-PRINT # 1 (570) 658-0100 :USTOMER COPY • CUSTOMER COPY CUSTOMER NO. -LICENSE# STOCK# DEALER# INVOICE DATE INVOICE # 14161 3299 68512 08/21/2004 034850 CUSTOMER NAME &ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT LOT#/HAT# COLOR DELIVERY DATE GARY/BETH NEUEAUM 14327M 14327M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O DATE 610 W SELZ= LN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L 08/21/2004 08/21/2004 VEHICLE ID # TECH & # Pp. # ENOLA PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. IM. EST. 0925 EXTENDED WARRANTY CO. POUCY# DEDUCTIBLE AUTHQPIL5ION# ADJUSTOR NONE 0.00 RESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY SIGNATURE 6P Ssy "'R'5 2ti,f,?'}GfFhFpiR .. '( ... : . . .? PMCGk4NAh ._? 6' PMIfrytlEA9FR A , . s y ,, x .•, PARFRES[(eSIgH„ 4 A 0.5 CPDRO LUBE OIL FILTER 8226C 01 "" ? 3 S ? ? ? J?2V ,1?9? N ( S { S t ?. f"? £d. 5?,4?.7.1?ER'^ 1+`i? ?. p t ?^ £4 it iS R ¢ ? 3 ?? k{t t,,: ? c t . Y YI }. Y £ - $ k i f Shop Supplie's' b :`65 -- - Job A Total Parts -& -Labor 22.95 Sales Tax 1.42 R§4 3 4 f - y lit, I y Ht 3 £ F f i } £ } k , 'F'Y 3 ^'1 k P i d I 9 s F + ' rt a a Q (? C?DRO HTBaT 'Ex•.CruT ,a y a .?. { z a F : '4{ '&?."' -3 c l+ Y 3 4 ,F fF i * i # ?N T L, . S G t .•p i4 k fi Y Y{}. I •4 t „$ i .# 5 .5 ' Y } T h ??}? 5 S f C i © g? { 4 ! c nr R t , r : }:}x i t ?j F E 1 .,.i r....: „., ! n-k STATE INSPECTION VEHICLE NEEDS EMISSION STICkER" COULD NOT INSPECT AT THIS TIME Job B Total Parts & Labor 0.00 4 t ( E y p} t f { t v R ? T k s ? l s j0. 44x §r to (T# rt SN1 kntT l k'kT2s t} 3 S R TY 1 3 s y x .k t 4 £ ?yS S Sk • kf k 4 % I . 5 ? 4. 1 { 5 ?? 3f. i f fi . ,k " ? , . F S£tR ' i I . k H i H 2 Y . t Zvi § 5P A . 'Y Yi ? t ? S, ?a 4. 3 4 L ..i f i k • 3 , K ? £ € I x ? ? X. 9,ti t i t5 1 ?t b { 1 % 1 } 3 f I Y 4 £ y £ 4 (i { k k F tk A£ e 2 k ry ] % $} 1z , 1 .... t 1 t : f ?? r £ t kk st ? x ? F k ,i .., ,i b?a3 "Ysrts x© 24 . - Total' Sublet ,' 0 ' Total Deductible 0.00 Total Misc. 0.65 Huard/'9th 0yQO t x+ p } i. '? s ? - ` I ? ` ' R j T >t i a Toia 1 ^ ?ax ?+ ?5 .r z t 3 :'42 a E%IENDEOWARRANNPAY FAOTORYWAR'UNWPAY AI-LL A60R CHAR6E9 ARE &LtEOON MiRATE FlNAL ESTIMATE TOTAL CUSTOMcR PAY HCURS UNI K OTHERWISE NOTED I 1 - 25.02 customer signature A =ORM SOLUTIONS, INC. (868) 343-6806 -IM 3988 6199 BRENNER 7325047 6 4 0 0 8 FAMILY OF DF..A1, RSRWS *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike =ARY NEUBAUM CHRYSIER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 jeep. i10 W SHADY LN (717) 766-7686 :NOLA, PA 17025 PAGE 3 Web Site: www.brennerchrysierjeep.com iOME:732-5047 BUS:772-6254 E-mail: brennercj@earthlink.net 'ELL:372-9588 SERVICE ADVISOR: 167 ROGER PARKER 1721 GENBAN OPTIONS: DLR:68512 ENG:2.7 The factory warranty constitutes all of the warranties with resp.. to LABOR AMOUNT the sale this item/items. The Seller hereby expressly disclaims all PARTS AMOUNT , warranties, either express or Implied inclutl any implied GAS, OIL, LUBE me , warranty of merchantability or SUBLET AMOUNT CHRYSLER Jeep fitness tar a particular purpose. Seller neither assumes nor nor MISC. CHARGES authorizes any other parson to assume for it any liability in TOTAL CHARGES ® connection with the sale of this Item/items . LESS INSURANCE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY BRENNER 7325047 6 4 0 0 8 FAMILY OF DEALERSHIPS *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike 3ARY NEUBAUM CHRYSIER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep. i10 W SHADY LN (717) 766-7686 UTOLA, PA 17025 PAGE 2 Web Site: www.brennerchrysierjeep.com IOME:732-5047 BUS:772-6254 E-mail:brennercj@earthlink.net '_ELL:372-9588 SERVICE ADVISOR: 167 ROGER PARKER 6 LINE OPCODE TECH TYPE HOURS LIST NET TOTAL PARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE B: 0.00 7236****** VERIFIED PASS SIDE FRT WINDOW WILL SHAKE WHILE RASSING AND LOWERING REMOVED DOOR PANEL FOUND GLASS RETAINING NUT TO BE LOOSEI PIGHTEND NUT TO PROPER TORQUED VERIFEID GLASS GOES UP AND DOWN SMOTH :KNOW TECH98 VERIFIED REPAIRS -**.CUSTOMER STATES DRIVERS FRT SPEAKER IN DASH CRACKS AT TIMES NRM NO REPAIRS MADE 166 CC1 0.00 ! O. 00 PARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE C: 0.00 7236 ******* COULD NOT DUPLICATE SPEAKER CRACKING AT THIS TIME ilr D** CUSTOMER STTAES REAR WINDOW DEFROSTER INOP PART#: 5093179AA COUNT: I CLAIM TYPE: W AUTH CODE!: PARTS': ;0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE D: 0.00 7236 ******** VERIFIED REAR DEFROSTER TNOP CHECKED FOR POWER AT DEFROSTER FOUND WIRE CONNECTOR BROOKEN LOOSE FROM REAR WINDOW CHECKED STAR ONLINE FOR POSIBIZ E REPAIRS KITS FOUND.REPAIRS KIT SOLDERED TWO VEW CONNECTOR TO BACK GLASS VP,RTFTFT) OPFRATTON OP REAR WTNMW T)FPROSTFR The factory warranty constitutes all of the warranties with respect to ABOR AMOUNT the sale this item/items. The Seller hereby expressly disclaims all PARTS AMOUNT , warranties, either express or including any implied GAS, OIL, LURE warrant warranty of mer bpor lar ic artto fitness for a lar o SUBLET AMOUNT CHRYSLER Jeep u S ells, p u purp se Seller neither assumes nor MISC. CHARGES authorizes any other person to assume for it any liability in TOTAL CHARGES ® connection with the sale of this tem/nemms. i LESS INSURANCE SALES TAY CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY BRENNER 7325047 6 4 0 0 8 FAMMY OF DEALERSHIPS *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike 3ARY NEUBAUM CHMMER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 jeep. 510 W SHADY LN (717) 766-7686 3NOLA, PA 17025 PAGE 1 Web Site: www.brennerchryslerleep.com 40ME:732-5047 BUS:772-6254 E-mail:brennercj@earthllnk.net -'ELtL:372-9588 SERVICE ADVISOR: 167 ROGER PARKER T008 ENG:2.7 05 OUT 2AUSE: INTERNAL DEFECT 08191601 MODULE, SENTRY KEY 166 WC4 PC: 58 PARTi 5507054AA COUNT: 1 CLAIM TYPE: W AUTH CODE PARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE A: 0.00 The factory warranty constitutes all of the warranties with respect to LABOR AMOUNT the sale of this Item/items. The Seller hereby expressly disclaims all PARTS AMOUNT warranties, either express or i inclutl any implied GAS, OIL, LU BE ant m ,warranty of merchantability or fitness for a articular ur ose SUBLET AMOUNT Jeep CHRYSLER Jeep p p p . Sells, neither assumes nor h i MISC. CHARGES aut or zes any other person to assume for it any liability TOTAL CHARGES connection with the sale of this hem/items. i LESS INSURANCE SALES TAX CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY 7325047 6 5 5 9 1 *INVOICE* kRY NEUBAUM 510 W SHADY U7 VIOLA, PA 17025 PAGE 2 -IOME:732-5047 BUS:772-6254 OPTIONS: DLR: PIME CUSTOMER SHOULD GO ON RIDE WITH SHOP FOREMAN Liter MPI The factory wa ty nstitutes all of the warrants ith r to LABOR AMOUNT... L' 0. 00 the sale of this item/items. The Seller hereby expressly disclaims all PARTS AMOUNT 0. 00 warractes ethe express or implied including any Implied GAS, OIL, LUBE 00 warranty of merchantability or for a LC ur ose SUBLET AMOUNT - O.OO CHRYSLER Jeep p . a p Seller neither assumes nor Sal p h i MISC. CHARGES 0 • 00 aut or zes any other person to assume for it any liability in TOTAL CHARGES 0. 00 _ connection with the Sale of this item/hems . LESB INSURANCE 0 • OO SALES TAX 0. OO CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT n nri BRENNER FAMILY OF DEALERS1111"S ® 6039 Carlisle Pike CHRYSIPR Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep. _ (717) 766-7686 - Web Site: www.brennerchrysierjeep.com E-mail: brennercj@eanhlink.net SOR: 167 ROGER PARKER 72 CUSTOMER COPY ,ARY NEUBAUM 510 W SHADY IN ENOLA, PA 17025 30ME:732-5047 =L:372-9588 03 7325047 BUS:772-6254 OPTIONS: nT.R. 6R 512 RNC7e2 WORST WHEN COLD BRENNER FAMILY OF DEALERSHIPS ® 6039 Carlisle Pike CHRYSLER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeeps _ (717) 766-7686 Web Site: www.brennerchryslerjeep.com E-mail: brennercj@earthlink.net Liter MPI 166ISADC (N/C) CARTS: 0.04 'LABOR: 0_00 OTHER: D.00 TOTAL LINE A: 0-0i0 L8971 **** **** VERIFIED DRIVER SIDE DASH SPEAKER CRACKING INSPECTED SPEAKER INTERNAIL SHORT IN SPEAKER ORDERED NEW SPEAKER tx*??e.iE rv`**?**I***aY*Yr*iEt?x t+?*t+?r*****x?:E ?:#ye*?*tx?: t,r**? 3 CUSTOMER STATES THERE IS A FLUID LEAK FROM THE ENGINE AREA, CLEARISH LOOKING FLUID _'AUSE: LEAK 166 FC: 71 PART#s 5015646AC COUNT: 1 CLAIM TYPE: W AUTH CODE: PARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE B: 0.00 166ISADC The factory warranty constitutes all of the warranties with respect to LABOR AMOUNT the this Item/items. The Seller hereby expressly disclaims all PARTS AMOUNT warranties, , either express or w arranties, Inclu any implietl GAS, OIL, LUBE warrant me warranty of merchantability or ilmeaa for a particular ur ose SUBLET AMOUNT CHRYSLER Jeep p p . Seller neither assumes nor h MISC. CHARGES aut orizes any other person to assume for it any liability in TOTAL CHARGES ® ® connection with the sale of this i temftems. LESS INSURANCE SALES TAX CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY • 1 4 LARY NEUBAUM ;10 W SHADY LN ]NOLA, PA 17025 iOME: 732-5047 7325047 BUS:772-6254 BRENNER 6 6 1 5 7 FAMILY OF DEAL RSHWS *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike CHRYSLER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep, _ (717) 766-7686 PAGE 3 Web Site: www.brennerchryslerjeep.com E-mail: brennercj@earthlink.net SERVICE ADVISOR: 167 ROGER PARKFR CON _1 0.00 I CAS :2.7 Liter MPI INE OPCODE TECH TYPE SEALS. The factory warranty constitutes all of the warranties with respect to LABOR AMOUNT me sale this rte xs. The Seller hereby expressly disclaims all PARTS AMOUNT warranties, , either express or implied, influ any implied GAS, OIL, LUBE me warranty of merchantability or fitness for a articular ur ose SUBLET AMOUNT CHRYSLER Jeep p p p . Seller neither assumes nor MISC. CHARGES authorizes any other person to assume for it any liability in TOTAL CHARGES ® ® connection with the sale of this Rem4tams. LESS INSURANCE SALES TAX CUSTOMER SIGNATURE I PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY y , , J zARY NEUBAUM i10 W SHADY IN -MOLA, PA 17025 IOME:732-5047 '_ELL:372-9588 3LUE 1 03 DLR:68512 ENG:2.7 Liter MPI PIME 02F FULL SERVICE LUBE/OIL & FILTER CHANGE 1 5010042AA T636 19382', *+** **** VERIFIED F'Lt3II) LEAK LEAK COMING FROM;: TRANS AREA PLACEA DIE IN TRANS BLACK LIGHT TESTED FOUND SELONOID GASKET LEAKING REPLACED GASKET CLEANED OFF ALI 5T7AFACES ROAb TESTEI? m OK AT THIS T'IM E D FURHTER LEAKS PRESSENT AT THIS TIME The factory warranty constitutes all of [ arta i s with respect .................................. - LABOR AMOUNT n The the sale e item he this Seller hereby expressly disclaims all PARTS AMOUNT warranties, , either ezorei or express a including any implied GAS, OIL, LUKE warranty of me merchantability ty fitness fitness for a rt lar SUBLET AMOUNT CHRYSLER Jeep purpose, pa icu e. Seller neither assumes nor MISC. CHARGES authorizes any other person to assume for it any liability in TOTAL CHARGES ® connection with the sale of this temlrems. I LESS INSURANCE SALES TAX cusroMSa SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT BRENNER 7325047 6 6 1 5 7 FAWY OF DMERSIMS *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike CHRYSIHR Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep, (717) 766-7686 _ PAGE 2 Web Site: www.brennerchryslerjeep.com BUS : 772 - 62 54 E-mail: brennercj@earthlink.net SERVICE ADVISOR: i 67 ROGER PARKER CUSTOMER COPY • Y it ? BRENNER 7325047 6 6 1 5 7 FAMILY OF DEALERSHIPS *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike 1ARY NEU13ATJM CHRYSIER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep. 10 W SHADY LN (717) 766-7686 _ MIOLA, PA 17025 PAGE 1 IOME:732-5047 BUS:772-6254 Web Sae: www.brennerchrysierieep.com E-mail:brennercj@earthlink.net 'ELL:372-9588 SERVICE ADVISOR: 167 ROGER PARKER COLOR YEAR MAICEfMCTDEt :VIN 1.IGEN E % :MILEAGEIN{OUT TAG ILUE 03 CHRYSLER SEBRING CON 1C3EL65R13N526172 GENBAN 19382/19382 T636 DEL :ATE iN:SVGDATE : . PHOMIS EP PQ N0. RATE PAYMENT -: INV. DATE )8MAR03 IS 04SEP02 08MAR2006 17: 00 12APROS 0.00 CASH 14APRO5 R.O. OPEN ED'. READY t OPTIONS: DLR:68512 ENG:2 .7 Liter MPI 11APROS 14APRO5 ,INE OPCODE TECH TYPE HOURS LIST NET TOTAL 166 WC4 PC: 18 PART#= 5026094AA COUNT: 1 CLAIM TYPE: W 08600270 RADIO- FC: PART#: COUNT: CLAIM Ti NT AUTH CODE: PARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE B: 0.00 19382 ****** VERIFIED NOISE FROM SPEAKER INSPECTED SPEAKER FOUND CONE DAMAGED REPLACED SPEAKER NOISE FROM LEFT: DASH:::SPEAKERt GONE BUT STILL The factory warranty constitutes all of warranties with red to .................................. AMOUNT . he the sale this item/items. The Seller hereby expressly disclaim. all PARTS AMOUNT warranties, , either express or any implied implietl in GAS, OIL, LUBE , f me warranty of merchantability or fitness for a l rti ` SUBLET AMOUNT CHRYSLER Jeep pa ar purpose cu Seller neither assumes nor MISC. CHARGES authorizes any other person in assume for it any liability in TOTAL CHARGES ® ® connection with the sale of this temlitems. i LESS INSURANCE SALES TAX CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY - THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY ". BRENNER FAMMY OF DFAL. MUR"S ® 6039 Carlisle Pike CHUSUR Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 .Msp+ (717) 766-7686 _ Web Site: www.brennerchryslerjeep.com E-mail: brennercj@earthlink.net AMOUN'T' PAID BY COMMENT 35.35 CHECK 66157 GARY NEU13AUM '010 W SHADY IN ENOLA PA 7325047 154029 TOTAL RECEIVED: $35.35 DATE-TIME: 14APR2005 18:13 17025 CASHIER: STEPH LOCATION: CASH DRAWER: ACCOUNTING DISTRIBUTION CO JOURNAL CO ACCOUNT AMOUNT CONTROL 2 56 2 11700 35.35 66157 2 10400 -35.35 66157 CONTROL2 NEUBAUM NEUBAUM CUSTOMER COPY LO N* ca 3 s m a n? ?rt ? RETURN OF SERVICE PLAINTIFF(S) COURT TERM & NUMBER Gary Neubaum JULY TERM, 2005 NO 3379 DEFENDANT(S) DaimlerChrysler Corporation SERVE AT: C/o CT Corporation, 1515 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 Pte' ?p05 ATTORNEY'S NAME: DAVID J. GOR13ERG PVG p'3 ADDRESS: 1234 Market Street, Suite 2040 Philadelphia, PA 19107 NVS(0 TELEPHONE NO.: 215-563-7210 AFFIDAVIT OF SERVER On the Ql day of 2005 at(o'clock (?_. .m., St Illy 1/; Z'Z? served and made known to the defendant, FS?g" with the foregoing CIVIL ACTION COMPLAINT, at C, r4c.,, k V_j- S c Philadelphia, PA, in the manner described below. Defendant personally served. -Adult family member with whom said defendant resides. Relationship is ,. to Adult in charge of defendant's residence who refused to give name or ,j _-g relationship. -..? i -Manager/Clerk of place of lodging in which defendant resides. Agent or person in charge of defendant's office or usual place of business. an officer of said defendant company. NOT FOUND because: moved unknown no answer vacant I verify that the statements I understand that false statements Pa. C.S.A. Sec. 4904 Relating to u '4? DATE A_'C_..i SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED: BEFORE ME THIS ?, )DAY: OF 2005: in this return of service are true and correct. herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 sworn fal ificatio to authorities. Signature of Se. r I/ Pd6TAR1}U 7F AI, .kS?dIM? p[f k?f?llF.i ? ClIY Or F'1Hh,4N_ , 1)" MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & GOGGIN By: James L. Johnson, Esquire Attorney LD: 66346 1845 Walnut Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 575-2801 FILED PRO PROTHY AUG 2 2 2005 Attorney for Defendant, E. HUSTON DaimlerChrysler Corporation GARY NEUBAUM COURT OF COMMON PLEAS PHILADELPHIA COUNTY V. JULY TERM, 2005 DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION NO. 3379 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Kindly enter my appearance on behalf of DaimlerChrysler Corporation, in the above- captioned matter. MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & GOGGIN BY: -zn. zo.-?. AMES L. HNSON, ESQUIRE Attorney for Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation 5 Y. ? frJ C.7 iV f0 W . N (7 Pp :Y S ni -v oo o -12- FILED PRO PROTHY V01 21ALIAB\J UVLLPGA512525VLOJV03043V04274 MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & GOGGIN By: James L. Johnson, Esquire Attorney I.D: 66346 1845 Walnut Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 575-2801 AUG 2 2 2005 TO PLAINTIFF YOU NOTIFIED TO E E HVSTON PL EAD TO TH NCLOSED NEW MATTER WITHIN (20) DAYS FROM THE SERVICE HEREOF OR A DEFAULT JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU. rney for Defoffaant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation Attorney for Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation GARY NEUBAUM COURT OF COMMON PLEAS PHILADELPHIA COUNTY V. JULY TERM, 2005 DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION NO. 3379 ANSWER WITH NEW MATTER TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT OF DEFENDANT, DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation by and through its attorneys, Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin, hereby answers Plaintiffs Complaint and asserts new matter defenses as follows: Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of these averments and the same are therefore denied. Admitted in part; denied in part. It is admitted that DaimlerChrysler Corporation is a corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of Delaware with a principal place of business in Michigan. Inasmuch as the Plaintiff fails to define what is meant by "qualified to do and regularly conducts business in Pennsylvania", after reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the these averments and the same are therefore denied BACKGROUND 3. Defendant hereby incorporates its previous answers as though set forth herein at length. 4. Admitted in part; denied is part. It is admitted that plaintiff obtained a DaimlerChrysler Corporation vehicle in Pennsylvania that was manufactured and warranted by defendant bearing the vehicle identification number as alleged. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without information or knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the remaining averments and same are therefore denied. 5. Denied. It is denied that the price of the vehicle, including the charges and fees enumerated in Plaintiffs Complaint, total more than as alleged. On the contrary, the price and the alleged charges and fees do not total more than the sum alleged. 6. Denied. It is denied that the vehicle cannot be utilized for the purpose intended by the plaintiff. It is further denied that defendant or its dealership performed ineffective repairs on the vehicle. It is denied that the vehicle is worthless. On the contrary, all repairs on the vehicle have been effective and the vehicle performs as intended. Because plaintiff has failed to define the specifics of the alleged "several warranties", after reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without information or knowledge with regard to these averments and the same are therefore denied. -2- Denied. It is denied that the plaintiff experienced nonconformities. On the contrary, no such conditions or nonconformities existed that substantially impaired the use, value, and/or safety of the vehicle in question. 9. Denied. It is denied that the vehicle experienced any nonconformities that substantially impaired the use, value and/or safety of the vehicle. In addition any conditions that were covered were corrected within the terms of the express written warranty issued by DaimlerChrysler Corporation. 10. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. 11. Denied. It is denied that the vehicle experienced nonconformities or conditions that were not corrected within the terms of the express written warranty issued by DaimlerChrysler Corporation. 12. Denied. It is denied that the vehicle experienced nonconformities or conditions that were not corrected within the terms of the express written warranty issued by DaimlerChrysler Corporation. 13. Denied. It is denied that the Plaintiffs vehicle has or will be out of service by reason of a statutorily defined nonconformity for the number of days alleged. 14. Denied. It is denied that the vehicle experienced defects or nonconformities. It is further denied that any condition covered under the terms of DaimlerChrysler Corporation's express written warranty was not corrected within the terms of the warranty. 15. Denied. It is denied that the vehicle has been subject to additional repair attempts for any reason for which defendant or its authorized service center did not maintain records as required by law. -3- 16. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. 17. Admitted in part; denied in part. It is admitted that the plaintiff seeks relief for alleged losses. It is denied that the plaintiff is entitled to such relief pursuant to any statute, doctrine, law or regulation. COUNTI PENNSYLVANIA AUTOMOBILE LEMON LAW CLAIM 18. Defendant incorporates its previous answers to Plaintiffs Complaint as though the same were set forth herein at length. 19. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. 20. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. 21. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. 22. Denied. It is denied that the plaintiff experienced nonconformities. On the contrary, no such conditions or nonconformities existed that substantially impaired the use, value, and/or safety of the vehicle in question. 23. Denied. It is denied that the vehicle experienced nonconformities or conditions that were not corrected within the terms of the express written warranty issued by DaimlerChrysler Corporation. -4- 24. Denied. It is denied that the plaintiff experienced nonconformities. On the contrary, no such conditions or nonconformities existed that substantially impaired the use, value, and/or safety of the vehicle in question. 25. Denied as stated. This matter is subject to contractual binding arbitration. By agreement, no lawsuit is permitted with regard to warranty disputes. The plaintiff has failed to adhere to the terms of the contract and this lawsuit must be dismissed in favor of mandatory binding arbitration. 26. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. 27. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. WHEREFORE, defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, respectfully demands judgment in its favor and against the plaintiff together with costs. COUNT II MAGNUSON-MOSS FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION IMPROVEMENT ACT 28. Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, hereby incorporates its previous answers to Plaintiffs Complaint as though the same were set forth herein at length. 29. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. 30. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. -5- 31. Denied. After reasonable investigation answering defendant is without information or knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments contained in this paragraph and the same are therefore denied. 32. Denied. It is denied that defendant's authorized service facility has performed ineffective repairs. It is further denied that defendant has breached any warranty or is otherwise liable to plaintiff as a result of any action or inaction on the part of the answering defendant. 33. Denied. It is denied that defendant's authorized service facility has performed ineffective repairs. It is further denied that defendant has breached any warranty or is otherwise liable to plaintiff as a result of any action or inaction on the part of the answering defendant. 34. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. 35. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. 36. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. WHEREFORE, defendant, Daimler-Chrysler Corporation, respectfully demands judgment in its favor and against the plaintiff together with costs. COUNT III UNIFORM COMMERCIAL CODE 37. Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, hereby incorporates its previous answers to Plaintiffs Complaint as though the same were set forth herein at length. 38. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. -6- 39. Denied. After reasonable investigation answering defendant is without information or knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments contained in this paragraph and the same are therefore denied. 40. Denied. After reasonable investigation answering defendant is without information or knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments contained in this paragraph and the same are therefore denied. 41. Denied. It is denied that the defendant was aware of any reliance by the plaintiff. it is further denied that any representations were made with regard to the subject vehicle other than those contained in the express written warranty. 42. Denied. It is denied that plaintiff has suffered any damages as a result of any action or inaction on the part of answering defendant. On the contrary, no such damages were incurred as a result of defendant's conduct. 43. Denied. It is denied that plaintiff has suffered any damages as a result of any action or inaction on the part of answering defendant. On the contrary, no such damages were incurred as a result of defendant's conduct. WHEREFORE, defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, respectfully demands judgment in its favor and against the plaintiff together with costs. COUNT IV PENNSYLVANIA UNFAIR TRADE PRACTICES AND CONSUMER PROTECTION LAW 44. Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, hereby incorporates its previous answers to Plaintiffs Complaint as though the same were set forth herein at length. 45. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. -7- 46. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. 47. Denied. These averments constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required. WHEREFORE, defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, respectfully demands judgment in its favor against the plaintiff together with costs. NEW MATTER 48. Plaintiffs Complaint fails to state a claim for which relief may be granted against DaimlerChrysler Corporation. 49. Plaintiffs claims are barred and/or limited by the applicable disclaimers of warranty and limitations of damage provisions. 50. Plaintiffs claims are barred and/or limited by his neglect, misuse, abuse, modification, and/or alteration of the vehicle, which is the subject of this litigation. 51. Plaintiffs claims are barred and/or limited by his failure to mitigate damages. 52. If the plaintiff sustained any alleged injuries, damages or losses, those injuries, damages, or losses were caused by persons and/or entities over whom answering defendant had no control and for whom answering defendant is not responsible. 53. Plaintiffs alleged claims of nonconformity do not substantially impair the use, value, or safety of the vehicle. 54. Plaintiffs claims are or may be barred by the applicable doctrine of laches, estoppel or waiver. 55. Plaintiffs Complaint fails to state a claim for which any attorney fees may be awarded. -8- 56. Plaintiffs claims may be barred and/or limited by the Lemon Law, Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law, Uniform Commercial Code and the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act. 57. It is denied that plaintiff obtained the vehicle primarily or normally for personal, family or household purposes and plaintiff is not entitled to recovery under the Lemon Law, Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, or the Pennsylvania Unfair Trade Practices Act. 58. Plaintiffs Complaint may be barred by the applicable statute of limitations. 59. This matter should be transferred to Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, based upon forum non conveniens pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1006(d). WHEREFORE, defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, respectfully demands judgment in its favor and against the plaintiff, together with costs. MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & GOGGIN BY: `?-- JAMES. L. JOHNSON, ESQUIRE Attorneys for Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation -9- VERIFICATION James L. Johnson, Esquire, hereby states that he is the attorney for DaimlerChrysler Corporation, defendant herein, and verifies that the statements made in the foregoing Answer with New Matter of Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, to Plaintiffs Complaint, are true and correct to the best of his knowledge, information and belief. The undersigned understands that the statements therein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. §4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. ES L. JO ON, ESQUIRE -10- CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, James L. Johnson, Esquire, hereby certify that I am attorney for the defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, in the within action; that I am duly authorized to make this certification and that on the / 7 Pday of August, 2005, I did cause a true and correct copy of Answer and New Matter of Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, to Plaintiffs Complaint to be forwarded by first class, U.S. Mail to counsel below as follows: David J. Gorberg, Esquire David J. Gorberg & Associates, P.C. 1234 Market Street, Suite 2040 Philadelphia, PA 19107 MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & GOGGIN BY:" - _ 7 JAMES L. JOHNSON, ESQUIRE Attorneys for Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, 11- .? PHILADELPHIA COURT OF COMMON PLEAS PETITION/MOTION COVER SHEET FOR COURT USE ONLY ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: ANSWER/RE?PO NSE DATE: 'Njw,1M1v\1? ` ?\\\\\ Do not send Judge courtesy copy of Petition/Motion/Answer/Response. Status may be obtained online at http://courtslphila.gov GARYNEUBAUM vs. DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION INDICATE NATURE OF DOCUMENT FILED IN Petition (Attach Rule to Show Cause) ? Motion ? Answer to Petition ? Response to Motion CONTROL NUMBER: O N02.123 (RESPONDING PARTIES MUST INCLUDE THIS NUMBER ONALL FILINGS) JULY Term 2005 Month Year No. 3379 Name of Filing Party: DaimlerChrysler Corporation (Check one) L Plaintiff N Defendant (Check one) ® Movant ? Respondent Has another petition/motion been decided in this case? ? Yes ® No Is another petition/motion pending? ? Yes ® No If the answer to either question is yes, you must identify the judge(s): TYPE OF PETITION/MOTION (see list on reverse side) PETITION TO TRANSFER VENUE PETITION/MOTION CODE (see list on reverse side) MTTFR 1. CASE PROGRAM U. PARTIES Is this case in the (answer all questions): David J. Gorberg Esquire A. COMMERCE PROGRAM , Name of Judicial Team GORBERG & ZUBER Applicable Petition/Motion 1234 Market Street, Suite 2040 Has deadline been previously extended by the Court? Philadelphia, PA 19107 ? Yes ? No 215-563-7210 B. DAY FORWARD/MAJOR JURY PROGRAM - Name of Judicial Team James L. JOhrisOri, Esquire Applicable Petition/Motion Marshall, Dennehey Has deadline been previously extended by the 1845 Walnut Street 21st Floor ? Yes ? No , C. NON JURY PROGRAM Philadelphia, PA 19103 Date Listed: 215-575-2801 D. ARBITRATION PROGRAM Arbitration Date: 3/28/06 E. ARBITRATION APPEAL PROGRAM Date Listed: F. OTHER PROGRAM ?- i Date Listed' III. OTHER By filing this document and signing below, the moving party certifies that this motion, petition, answer or response along with all documents fii6d, will be served upon all counsel and unrepresented parties as required by rules of Court (see PA.R.C.P. Rule 206.6, Note to 208.2(a), and 440). Furthermore, moving party vef 8 that the answers ade herein are true and correct and understands that sanctions may be imposed for inaccurate or incomplete answers . . b, yl Or James L. Johnson, Esquire 66346 Attorney Signatt e/Unrepresented Party) (Dale) (Print Name) (Attorney I.D. No) The Petition, Motion and Answer or Response, if any, will be forwarded to the Court after the Answer/Response Date. No extension of the Answer/Response Date will be granted even if the parties so stipulate. 30-1061 (Rev, 4104) t , MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & GOGGIN BY: James L. Johnson, Esquire Attorney I.D. 66346 1845 Walnut Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 575-2801 GARY NEUBAUM V. DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION ON2A23 RULE TO SHOW CAUSE AND NOW, this day of COURT OF COMMON PLEAS PHILADELPHIA COUNTY JULY TERM, 2005 NO. 3379 , 2005, upon consideration of defendant's Petition to Transfer, and plaintiffs' response thereto, a Rule is hereby issued to show cause why the within request for relief should not be granted. This matter shall be heard in conjunction with the rule returnable already scheduled. RULE RETURNABLE the day of 2005 at o'clock, m., in Courtroom City Hall. Attorneys for Defendant DaimlerChrysler Corporation BY THE COURT: J. 4 V01 21 ALIAB\TKS\LLPGA512473\TKSV03043V04274 MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & GOGGIN By: James L. Johnson, Esquire Attorneys I.D.: 66346 1845 Walnut Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 575-2801 Attorneys for Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation GARY NEUBAUM COURT OF COMMON PLEAS PHILADELPHIA COUNTY V. JULY TERM, 2005 DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION NO. 3379 PETITION OF DEFENDANT, DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION, TO TRANSFER VENUE TO CUMBERLAND COUNTY BASED UPON FORUM NON CONVENIENS Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, by and through its attorneys, Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin, hereby petitions this Honorable Court for an Order transferring this matter based upon forum non conveniens to the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1006(d)(1), and avers as follows: 1. This civil action was commenced by the filing of a Complaint in the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County on or about July 29, 2005. A true and correct copy of plaintiffs Complaint is attached hereto as Exhibit "A". 2. The action alleges a violation of the Pennsylvania Automobile Lemon Law, 73 P.S. §1951 et. s.., the Magnuson-Moss Federal Trade Commission Improvement Act, 15 U.S.C. §2301 et. SeMc ., the Uniform Commercial Code, and the Pennsylvania Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law, 73 P.S. §201-1 et. sec.. as a result of the purchase of a 2003 Chrysler Sebring. I 3. This case has absolutely no relationship to any activities, events or transactions which occurred in Philadelphia County. 4. In the case of Dulaney v. Consolidated Rail Corporation 715 A.2d 1217 (Pa.Super. 1998), the Pennsylvania Superior Court upheld a transfer of a matter from Philadelphia to Butler County on facts essentially identical to the matter at hand. 5. The court in Dulaney had no difficulty readily deciding the inconvenience that was inherent in a Philadelphia County trial based on the fact that the plaintiff and all witness were located in Ohio, Western Virginia or Western Pennsylvania. The Superior Court made this decision in the light and guidance of Cheeseman v. Lethal Exterminator, Inc. et al, 549 Pa. 200 (Pa. 1997) which requires the defendant to show that the plaintiffs' forum is oppressive or vexatious to the defendant. 6. The filing in Philadelphia County of this and dozens of identical outside- Philadelphia County matters against the defendant, has proven to be vexatious and oppressive. 7. The convenience of all witnesses would be greatly enhanced if this matter were transferred to the Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas. 8. As reflected in the caption in the Complaint, the plaintiffs address is 610 West Shady Lane, Enola, PA 17025, located in Cumberland County. (See Exhibit "A"). 9. At all relevant times to this action, up until the present, the plaintiffs address has been at this Cumberland County address. (See Exhibit "A".) 10. The vehicle was purchased at Beaver Motors, Inc., RR 522, Beaver Springs, PA 17812, which is located in Snyder County. 11. The service and repairs to the plaintiffs vehicle occurred at Brenner Chrysler Jeep (a.k.a. Brenner Family of Dealerships), also located in Cumberland County, and Beaver Motors 2 Inc., located in Snyder County. (See the exhibits to plaintiffs Complaint attached hereto as Exhibit "A".) 12. The service manager, service advisors and/or service technicians who worked on the plaintiffs vehicle are important witnesses regarding the issue of whether the vehicle was repaired in accordance with the alleged terms of the warranty. These witnesses are employees of either Brenner Chrysler Jeep or Beaver Motors. To require their attendance at interviews, depositions, arbitration and/or trial in another county far removed from their place of employment would burden these independent franchise dealerships and damage their efforts to handle the service and repair needs of other customers. 13. All records, contracts, repair orders and technician's notes generated at the time of service of this vehicle are located at and are the property of either Brenner Chrysler Jeep or Beaver Motors. 14. Both Brenner Chrysler Jeep and Beaver Motors are independent franchise dealerships and their records and employees are not under the control of DaimlerChrysler Corporation. 15. Pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1006(d)(1), this Honorable Court may: For the convenience of parties and witnesses, the court upon petition of any party may transfer an action to the appropriate court of another county where the action could have originally been brought. Pa.R.C.P. 1006(d)(1). 16. Moreover, while the plaintiffs choice of forum is entitled to weight, a Petition to Transfer Venue may be granted if the plaintiff chosen forum is oppressive or vexatious to the defendant. Cheeseman v. Lethal Exterminator. Inc., et al., 701 A.2d 156 (Pa. 1997). 3 17. Moreover, pursuant to Cheeseman, a defendant is entitled to a transfer of venue by showing that "trial in another county would provide easier access to witnesses or other sources of proof, or the ability to conduct a view of the premises involved in the dispute." Id. 18. Trial of this matter in Philadelphia is inconvenient to all of the key fact witnesses as well as the defendant in this matter. Furthermore, the pattern of repeat filings in Philadelphia County of similar cases with no relationship to Philadelphia has proven to be oppressive and vexatious in its effect. 19. As set forth above, the arbitration and trial of this matter in Cumberland County would provide easier access to all the sources of proof both documentary and testimonial as contemplated by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in Cheeseman, Id. 20. There is no contact that this matter has with the City or County of Philadelphia. Given the absence of any important connection between the County of Philadelphia and the location of all relevant evidence and witnesses in Cumberland County or other such far removed counties, together with the burden that would be imposed on witnesses, the institution of this suit in Philadelphia County is vexatious, oppressive, prejudicial and unduly burdensome. WHEREFORE, petitioning defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, respectfully requests this Honorable Court to enter an Order in the form attached hereto and transfer the instant matter based upon forum non conveniens to the Court of Common Pleas for Cumberland County. MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN AND GOGGIN By: JAMES L. JOHNSON, ESQUIRE Attorney for Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation 4 i MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & GOGGIN By: James L. Johnson, Esquire Attorneys I.D.: 66346 1845 Walnut Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 575-2801 Attorneys for Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation GARY NEUBAUM COURT OF COMMON PLEAS PHILADELPHIA COUNTY V. JULY TERM, 2005 DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION NO. 3379 MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF PETITION OF DEFENDANT, DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION TO TRANSFER VENUE TO CUMBERLAND COUNTY BASED UPON FORUM NON CONVENIENS Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, by and through its attorneys, Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin, hereby petitions this Honorable Court for an Order transferring this matter based upon forum non conveniens to the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, and in support, submits this petition. 1. STATEMENT OF FACTS: This lawsuit was initiated by the plaintiff, who, at all times relevant to this action, had an address of 610 West Shady Lane, Enola, PA 17025, located in Cumberland County. This suit involves the purchase and repairs to a 2003 Chrysler Seabring at Beaver Motors, Inc., RR 522, Beaver Springs, PA 17812, which is located in Snyder County. This dealership is an independent franchise dealership' with no corporate financial, management or employee ties to DainalerChrysler Corporation. At issue in this case are repairs made to this vehicle by both Brenner Chrysler Jeep and Beaver Motors, allegedly under a warranty extended by DaimlerChrysler Corporation. This vehicle has been continuously maintained and operated in Cumberland County. DaimlerChrysler has no employees or representatives in Philadelphia that are familiar with the facts of this case. The documentary evidence with regard to the sale, service and repair of the vehicle is located in Cumberland or Snyder County, as are relevant witnesses. DaimlerChrysler Corporation does not maintain any documents, offices or employees in Philadelphia County. There is no relationship between the facts and allegations of this lawsuit and Philadelphia County. As set forth in Defendant's Petition, arbitration and trial of this matter would be extremely inconvenient to the material witnesses and is vexatious and oppressive to defendant. II. LEGAL ARGUMENT: Generally, although the right of a plaintiff to choose the forum in which he brings suit is accorded important consideration, it is not absolute. McReynolds v. Benner Township, 118 Pa. Cmwlth. 215, 544 A.2d 566, (1988); allocatur denied at 581 A.2d 575; See also Ernest v. Fox Pool Com., 341 Pa. Super. 71, 491 A.2d 154 (1985). In fact, the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure expressly permit a change in venue where venue is either technically improper in the county where suit is brought, or where it would be inconvenient to the parties, witnesses and the court, to try the case in plaintiffs choice of forum. Specifically, Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1006(d)(1) provides in pertinent part: "For the convenience of parties and witnesses, the court upon Petition of any party, may transfer an action to the appropriate court of any other county where the action could have originally been brought." Pa.R.C.P. 1006(d)(1). Therefore, under Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1006(d)(1), venue may, out of convenience to the litigants, be changed to a court located in another county, where venue is also proper. The Superior Court has recognized that the doctrine of forum non conveniens serves the essential purpose of "provid[ing] the court with a means of looking beyond technical considerations such as jurisdiction and venue to determine whether litigation in the plaintiffs' 2 chosen forum would serve the interest of justice under the particular circumstances." Alford v. Philadelphia Coca Cola Bottling, 366 Pa. Super. 510, 513, 531 A.2d 792, 794 (1987). In fact, the doctrine of forum non conveniens is necessary to counterbalance Pennsylvania's "liberalized venue rules," which enables a plaintiff to have a choice of more than one forum in which to bring suit. Vogel v. Nat'l R.R. Passenger Corp., 370 Pa. Super. 315, 536 A.2d 422, 425 (1988) (quoting Ernest v. Fox Pool Corp., 341 Pa. Super. 71, 75, 491 A.2d 154, 156 (1985)). Further, Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1006(d)(1) gives trial courts wide discretion in deciding "whether to grant the petition for change of venue." Brown v. Delaware Valley Transplant Program, 371 Pa. Super. 583, 586, 538 A.2d 889, 891 (1988) (quoting Fox v. Pennsylvania Power & Light Co., 315 Pa. Super. 79, 81, 461 A.2d 805, 806 (1983)); McReynolds v. Benner Township, 118 Pa. Commw. 215, 544 A.2d 566 (1988). The Pennsylvania Supreme Court recently addressed the issue of forum non conveniens in the matter of Cheeseman v. Lethal Exterminator, Inc., 701 A.2d 156 (Pa. 1997). In Cheeseman, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reiterated that the standard for a Petition to Transfer Venue based on the doctrine of forum non conveniens is that the instant forum is oppressive or vexatious. Id. The Supreme Court then stated, however, that the defendant could meet this burden by showing that another county "would provide easier access to witnesses or other sources of proof." Id. at page 213. In following the Cheeseman guidelines, the Superior Court, in Dulaney v. Consolidated Rail Corporation 715 A.2d 1217 (Pa.Super. 1998), granted a Petition to Transfer Venue from Philadelphia County to Butler County. The facts in Dulaney showed that an accident occurred in Ohio, and the plaintiff, all the witnesses and all the medical providers were located in Ohio, West Virginia or Western Pennsylvania, however, the plaintiff filed suit in Philadelphia County. The 3 court, citing Cheeseman, noted that a "petition to transfer venue will not be granted unless the defendant meets its burden of demonstrating, with detailed information on the record, that the plaintiffs chosen forum is oppressive or vexatious to the defendant." Dulanev at 1219 citin¢ Cheeseman at 213. However, the Superior Court held as follows: In its petition to transfer venue, Conrail presented facts showing that the accident occurred in Ohio and that the appellant and all of the witnesses lived in Ohio, West Virginia or Western Pennsylvania. Additionally, all of appellant's medical providers were located in Ohio, West Virginia or Western Pennsylvania. The only connection to Philadelphia County is that Conrail conducts businesses in Philadelphia County... Thus the facts show that Conrail has demonstrated that a trial in appellant's chosen forum would have been oppressive and that trial in Butler County would be more convenient because of easier access to all of the witnesses and other sources of proof. Dulanev at 1219. The court concluded: "[T]he trial court did not abuse its discretion when it granted Conrail's petition to transfer venue based on forum non conveniens." Id. The same situation exists in the instant case, trial in Philadelphia County would be oppressive and Cumberland County would be more convenient because of easier access to all the witnesses and all the sources of proof. Dulanev at 1219. As stated, the Delanev case is on point with the case at hand. The plaintiff in the instant matter is located in Cumberland County. The dealerships where the repairs were performed together with all the relevant witnesses are located in both Cumberland and Snyder County. To hold a trial in Philadelphia County when it bears no relationship whatsoever to the case at hand, would be vexatious and oppressive. A trial in Cumberland County however, would be more convenient because of easier access to all the witnesses and all the sources of proof. 4 DaimlerChrysler Corporation does not maintain any business offices, employees or records in Philadelphia County. All repairs were performed at dealerships located in either Cumberland or Snyder County. The service manager and technicians who performed the repairs and test drove the vehicle are dealership employees. To require them to unnecessarily travel to Philadelphia for pretrial interviews and depositions as well as arbitration and trial would be oppressive and inconvenient. In this case, the sales personnel who sold the vehicle to the plaintiffs are employees of an independently owned and operated franchise dealership located in Snyder County. These employees would have been responsible for explaining the terms and conditions of DaimlerChrysler's warranty at the time of sale, and assisting in the execution of sales and financing documentation, and most importantly, servicing the vehicle. Records involving the vehicle in this lawsuit including all sales and financing documents, warranty repair orders, and technician notes regarding repair procedures are generated, maintained and owned by dealerships located in Cumberland and Snyder County. This dealerships' documents are the primary documentary proof in warranty litigation such as this. These records and notes are not maintained, controlled or owned by DaimlerChrysler Corporation. Requiring DaimlerChrysler to defend this case in Philadelphia would have an adverse impact on both DaimlerChrysler Corporation's operations as well as the operation of the selling and servicing dealerships. Requiring Cumberland and Snyder County dealerships' sales and service personnel to attend depositions, arbitrations and trial, as well as to be interviewed by DaimlerChrysler's attorneys defending this case in Philadelphia, would have an adverse effect on customers that rely on these technicians and sales force at Brenner Chrysler Jeep and Beaver Motors. 5 In the recent Opinion of the Pennsylvania Superior Court in the case of Techtmann v. Howie, 1997 W.L. 194455 (Pa. Super.), the Superior Court upheld the trial court's grant of a change of venue based on forum non conveniens from Philadelphia County to Bucks County. The Techtmann case involved an accident that occurred in Bucks County, Pennsylvania. A review of the records informed the Superior Court that there were very few connections to Philadelphia County that justified the institution of the suit there. The Superior Court noted that the defendant, the operator of the hydraulic lift on the day of the accident, as well as one of the eyewitnesses to the accident, were Philadelphia residents. In addition, the plaintiff received some medical care at a Philadelphia hospital. Further, some of the defendants regularly conducted business in Philadelphia. Despite this information, however, the Superior Court held that these factors were not compelling in light of the significant amount of connections that the case had with Bucks County. By contrast, in the instant case, there are absolutely no connections whatsoever to Philadelphia County. Furthermore, in McReynolds v. Benner Township, 118 Pa. Cmwlth. 215, 454 A.2d 566 (1988); allocatur denied at 581 A.2d 575, the Commonwealth Court upheld a transfer from Philadelphia County to Centre County. The McReynolds court concluded that the fact that "practically all the sources of proof are located in Centre County" satisfy both the standard of oppressiveness and vexation that justified transfer, and the alternative standard of administrative and legal problems noted above. 544 A.2d at 567, 568. See also Fox v. Pennsylvania Power & Light Co., 315 Pa. Super. 79, 461 A.2d 805, 806 (1985) (only connection between case in Philadelphia County is location of one office of one defendant there, justifying transfer to Centre County.) 6 It is clear from the records set forth above that the trial of the instant matter in Philadelphia County is both oppressive and vexatious to petitioning defendant. This case is only one of many hundreds being brought in Philadelphia County by plaintiffs' law firm regarding allegations that have nothing to do with Philadelphia County and arise and exist completely in Cumberland County or other counties far removed from Philadelphia. The net, result both individually and taken as a whole, impacts negatively on defendant's corporate operations and its ability to defend individual lawsuits. DaimlerChrysler should not have to repeatedly chose between disrupting its operations or producing evidence and witnesses in Philadelphia that could be much more conveniently produced in the county where the incident in question occurred. Given the fact that this case is being pursued in Philadelphia at what must clearly be an inconvenience to this Cumberland County plaintiff, the conclusion that the litigation is vexatious is clear. As stated by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania in the Cheeseman decision, "...the defendant may meet its burden of showing that the plaintiffs' choice of forum is vexatious to him by establishing facts on the record that the plaintiffs' choice of forum was designed to harass the defendant, even at some inconvenience to the plaintiff himself" Cheeseman, supra, 549 Pa. 200 at p. 213. For the plaintiff to travel over two and a half hours to pursue litigation in an unrelated county which is clearly burdensome to the defendant is a precise ground that the Supreme Court has approved as a basis for transfer. The Supreme Court in Cheeseman also stated that "Alternatively, the defendant may meet his burden by establishing on the record that trial in the chosen forum is oppressive to him; for instance, that trial in another county would provide easier access to witnesses or other sources of proof, or the ability to conduct a view of the premises involved in the dispute. Cheeseman, Id. at p. 213. 7 It is clear that trial in Philadelphia is not only inconvenient but it is ultimately oppressive to DaimlerChrysler's defense as well as its operations. To require witnesses, personnel and documents, to be transported over two hours by car for depositions, arbitrations, and/or trial, is a clear burden which has become oppressive. To require dealership and DaimlerChrysler personnel to be away from their responsibilities for extended periods of time directly impacts on the ability of DaimlerChrysler and the dealership to sell, service and repair vehicles. While adjudicating one customer's complaint other customers unnecessarily go unattended. The easier access to witnesses and sources of proof that exist in Cumberland County or other counties far away from Philadelphia County, as well as the ability to conduct a view/inspection of the vehicle in question, clearly militates in favor of transfer of this matter to Cumberland County. In addition, the issue of convenience, as established in this case, is the second alternative ground set forth by the Supreme Court in Cheeseman as justification for transfer. Pursuant to the standard set forth by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in Cheeseman, Petitioning Defendant has established that the trial of this matter in Cumberland County would provide easier access to sources of proof and witnesses. Moreover, Philadelphia County has no relevant connections to the resolution in the instant matter. 8 WHEREFORE, Petitioning Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, respectfully requests this Honorable Court to enter an Order in the form attached hereto and transfer this matter to the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County. MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN AND GOGGIN By: ? >? J ES L. JO SON, ESQUIRE Attorney for Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation 9 R f VERIFICATION I hereby state that I am attorney for DaimlerChrysler Corporation, defendant herein, and verifies that the statements made in the foregoing Petition of Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, to Transfer Venue based upon forum non conveniens are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief. The undersigned understands that the statements therein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. section 4904 relating to unworn falsification to authorities. J ES L. JOH ON, ESQUIRE CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am attorney for the defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, in the within action; that I am duly authorized to make this certification; and that on the.2 `f-YL day of ? ` 2005, I did cause a true and correct copy of Petition of Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, to Transfer Venue based upon forum non conveniens pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1006(d)(1) to be forwarded by first-class U.S. Mail to counsel, addressed as follows: David J. Gorberg, Esquire David J. Gorberg & Associates, P.C. 1234 Market Street Suite 2040 Philadelphia, PA 19107 MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN AND GOGGIN By. AMES L. JO ON, ESQUIRE Attorney for Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation ?? ,???, h. -curt of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County ILLI Trial Di on I Civil Cover Sheet Dory (Di,L 'I MJTIFP'E NAME CEFEHOANiS NAME Gary Neubaum DaimlerChrysler Corporation pLAINiIF/'] AGOFEES 610 West Shady Lane Enola, PA 17025 OEFEHOANTS AOONESS C/O CT CORPORATION 1515 Market St., Phila PA OEFEIIO.T'S NAPE PLmm?FF'E AoaNEEs 1EFE.01IT-5100-ES'+ .a PLVNTIF r"5 ADDRESS I CEF-ENOANTS A000.E55 i 1 TOTAL INLIa ER OF PL INTIFFS TOT.L NO. OF DEFENDANTS 0 AMEN CEMENT OF AC ION J CampW.1 ? Pctiuon Acdoa ? ;lolicc or Appccl 1 1 WmafSammons ? T.fc. Fmm Olhcr Jurisdiniona MOUNT IN CONTPOVEFSY CCUR'pFOGF"MS 550.000.00 or 1. Arbi.6. ? N(=T.. El 5=11..Ullt M.' Ihan 550.000.00 Jury ? 5a Eines Action ? Minor Caan Appccl .? Mmura ? Non-Jur ? Portion Snralary Appeals ? rn.a1 ? W,-D/5, y , ? Othc- CASE TYPE Ali0 UOOE ISEE IIISTn NCT ONSI IC CONTRACT l i SrAFUTOnY BASIS :C0. CAUSE OF AGI0PI (SE°_ IfISTPUCTIONSI j N/A BELATED FS.NOING CAUE5 MIST BY aSZ CAPTION ANO OOCn ST "UN S ERI IS Ca SE SUBJECT ro COaNCM+TIOH On OEA] Yc5 i4c ? NONE ? ? ? ? TO THE P40 T HONOT:.RY: Kindly e.^.[e., my aooearanac on benalfoFPlaintiriiP^ieione: P.ppellanc Pacts may 'ot ser• ce- ac ;ht a6dress 5er foeh below. u 6I[ OF 11 IN IIP F']FPETItIONEWSIAPPELIIII r2 ArTO.NE1 '+a CnESS ISEE IuS iPVC:On it David 1. Gorberg 1234 Mar t`Street PLDIILI ULIBP F3 Phila A 19107 563E -7210 , PA?blAb?8 jj GUP'n cL« ]CV0.i G EU r:NGilUlr ril. 53084 = uIL ACCaEiS .mnnruaE o. r-< 7/11/05 I CT CORPORATION Service of Process A Wolterskluwer Company Transmittal 07/29/2005 Log Number 510420805 RECEIVED TO: Richard D Houtman DaimlerChrysler Corporation Office Of General Counsel, 1000 Chrysler Drive ?' I r C 4 ?005 CIMS 485-14-78 Auburn Hills, MI, 48326-2766 WARRANTY GROUP RE: Process Served In Pennsylvania OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL FOR: DaimlerChrysler Corporation (Domestic State: DE) DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION ENCLOSED ARE COPIES OF LEGAL PROCESS RECEIVED BY THE STATUTORY AGENT OF THE ABOVE COMPANY AS FOLLOWS: TITLE OF ACTION: Gary Neubaum, PIT vs. DaimlerChrysler Corporation, Dft. DOCUMENT(S) SERVED: Cover Sheet, Notice, Complaint, Verification, Attachments COURTIAGENCY: Court of Common of Pleas, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania, PA Case # 003379 NATURE OF ACTION: Product Liability Litigation - Lemon Law ,t ON WHOM PROCESS WAS SERVED: C T Corporation System, Philadelphia, PA ?('? ...(((\\\(((\\\ q?.,, DATE AND HOUR OF SERVICE: By Process Server on 07/2912005 at 11:29 ?y \Wr?„4j / .''y APPEARANCE OR ANSWER DUE: Within 20 days ATTORNEY(S) I SENDER(S): David J. GOrberg, Esquire 8/p David J. Gorberg &AssoAssociates, P.C. P?G A 1234 Market rkei Street Suite 2040 r' ctJ Philadelphia, PA, 19107 >iy^uY1`" 215.563.7210 ACTION ITEMS: SOP Papers with Transmittal, via Fed Ex 2 Day, 79059374772 ,gaG Email Notification, Richard D Houtman sprooess@dcc.com SIGNED: C T Corporation System PER: Sandra Solomon ADDRESS: 1515 Market Street Suite 1210 Philadelphia, PA, 19102 o ''t" if TELEPHONE: 215-563-7750 J(j? ur ?t'a C .y G3 3iy;W. t® Page 1 of 1 / NA Information displayed on this transmittal is for CT Corporation's recent keeping purposes only and is provided to the recipient for quick reference. This information does not constitute a legal opinion es to the nature of action, the amount of damages, the enavver date, or any information contained In the documents themselves. Recipient is responsible for Interpreting said documents and for taking appropriate action. ...AS c .+L ?.. ?LUUSU II A s?...., vA L slLLauL.s?F l+su ?. sluuL) Trial Di, on j Civil Cover Sheet = 11111Y90OF PLAINTIFF'S NAME DEFENDANT-5 NAME Gary Neubaum DaimIerChrysler Corporation PLAIII TIFFS ACORESS DEFENDANTS AOORESS 610 West Shady Lane C/O CT CORPORATION Enola, PA 17025 1515 Market St., Phila PA PUW rIFFS NAME CEFENO+NrS NAME PUUITIFF'S ACORESS DEFevO+N i'S AOOREES I I ' I PLAINTIFF'S NAVE I I GEFENOANTS NAME I PL INTU'rS AOORE55 I OEPSNOANTSACORESS ' TOTAL NULISER OF PI+INTIFFS 1 TOTAL NO. OF DEFE11OA14TS 1 COMMENCEMENT OF ACTION CDmplsial ? Pcsioan Anion ? Writ DlSummDlu ??runic: From Olhcr lsuisdiniuv Nolir a(Appeal 1 AMOUNT IN CONTROVERSY SSD.DDp.aO or los COURT PROCMMS Ar6isnsion ? hlm Ton ? Curmcc ? Scnlcmun ( M1lDrc Ihsn SSO.Dan.00 ' Jury ? Nan•Jurv ? ? S.,ines Acsian Pcl Dion ? Minor CDan Appcsl ?', Sumlory Appcnls .? wi-- ? WMISurvl Val I ? aLh cT. _ CASE TY15 110 GOOE ISEE INSTROCTIONSI 1C CONTRACT 54rUrORx 3AS15 FOR GUSE OF ACTION 152E IIISTRUCTIONST N/A '. RELATED PENDING CASSE ILIST EY GSE CAPTIOII AND DOCKET NUMSERI 15 CASE 51E1ECT TO COORDINATIOII CROERT C5 i'0 ? 11 NONE ? ? 0 1 I TO THE PcW T HOMO T:.RY: Kindly tn[er my appearance on behalFof PlaineiriiPc:i[ione %Anoellanr. i I Papers rnav be served al [be. address Se: Corn oe!pw. AME OF PLAINTIFF' 91PETITI00ER'EIAPPELLANrs ArTORrIEY +IIDREES (SEE IN5}RVCION5) David J. Gorberg 1234 Mar treet ! RrvG„[I MMSER iF. r R Phila A 19107 563-7210 S?6II??/38 5VPR2ME -CURT I:n IC+fION nO 53084 i SlCUnrVRE MuL ACORE3S DArE 7/11/05 11-:UIIRCt :_131 ASSESSMENT OF DAMAGES S PEWRFD 4 DAVID J. GORBERG & ASSOCIATES, P.C. BY: DAVID J. GORBERG TNI9 IS IM ARSIIM"( ." : . LAIIIIN TA ORDENADO CT IONCHEARING LVD 5TH FL -,1D3 j (? JUL 9g" 006 5111 L COMPLY L AUFlA?A0t* OTICE 6ELOIAr DAVIA ppEBE O ?ELAVISO IDENTIFICATION NO. SUITE 2040 11nnoo 1234 MARKE?8V? +T PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA 19107 (21 S) 563-7210 ATTORNEY FOR Plaintiff GARY NEUBAUM 610 West Shady Lane Enola, PA 17025 ct. VS. AT a1_... SS t:. DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORAT1170'Ni c/o CT Corporation1515 Marke t Stre&A c, r ' PhiladelPhie PA 19103 t ,..r,....,. u CIVIL ACTION COMPLAINT 1C CONTRACT NOTICE You have been sued In court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that It you tall to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the court without further notice for any money claimed in the complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW. THIS OFFICE CAN PROVIDE YOU WITH INFORMATION ABOUT HIRING A LAWYER. IF YOU CANNOT AFFORD TO HIRE A LAWYER, THIS OFFICE MAY BE ABLE TO PROVIDE YOU WITH INFORMATION ABOUT AGENCIES THAT MAY OFFER LEGAL SERVICES TO ELIGIBLE PERSONS AT A REDUCED FEE OR NO FEE. LAWYER REFERENCE SERVICE One Reeding Center 1101 Market Street Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19107 (215) 236-6333 COURT OF COMMON PLEAS DIVISION JULY 2005 TERM, 0033'79 No. AVISO Le han demandado an torte. SI usted desen defender contra las demandas dispuestas an las pdginas siguientes, usted debe tomar is acci6n an at plazo de veinte (20) dies despubs de esta queja y as sirve avlso, incorporando un aspecto escrito personalmente o y archivando an escribir con Is corte sus defenses u objeclones a las demandas dispuestas contra usted el abogado Is advlerte qua at usted no puetle hater asi qua el caso puede procader sin usted y un juicio as puetle incorporar contra usted compra Is corte sin aviso adicional pars cualquier dinero demandado an Is queja o para cualquier otro demands o relovaci6n pedida pot eI demandante. Usted puetle perder el dinero o la caracteristica de otra,endereza Importante a usted. USTED DEBE LLEVAR ESTE PAPEL SU ABOGADO INMEDIATAMENTE. SI LISTED NO HACE OUE UN ABOGADO VAYA A O LLAME POP TELEFONO LA OFICINA DISPUESTA ABAJO. ESTA OFICINA PUEDE PROVEER DE USTED LA INFORMAC16N SOBRE EMPLEAR A UN ABOGADO. SI USTED NO PUEDE PERMITIRSE AL HIRE A UN ABOGADO, ESTA OFICINA PUEDE RODER PROVEER DE USTED LA INFORMAC16N SOBRE LAS AGENCIAS DUE LOS SERVICIOS JURIDICOS DE LA OFERTA DE MAYO A LAS PERSONAS ELEGIBLES EN UN HONORARIO REDUCIDO O NINGUN HONORARIO. SERVICIO DE REFERENCIA LEGAL One Reading Center 1101 Market Street Filadelfia, Pennsylvania 19107 Tel&tono:(215) 236-5333 A, DAVID J. GOR13ERG & ASSOCIATES, P.C. By: DAVID J. GORBERG Attorney for Plaintiffs Identification No. 53084 1234 Market Street Suite 2040 Philadelphia, PA 19107 (215) 563-7210 GARY NEUBAUM COURT OF COMMON PLEAS 610 West Shady Lane Enola, PA 17025 PHILADELPHIA COUNTY vs. TERM, 2005 DAIMLER CHRYSLER CORPORATION c/o CT CORPORATION 1515 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 : NO. COMPLAINT 1. Plaintiff, Gary Neubauin, is an adult individual citizen and legal resident of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, residing at 610 West Shady Lane< Enola, PA 17025. 2. Defendant, Daimler Chrysler Corporation, is a business corporation qualified to do business and regularly conducts business in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania with its legal residence and principal place of business at P 0 Box 21-8004, Auburn Hills, Michigan 48321 and can be served at c/o CT Corporation, 1515 Market Street, Philadelphia, PA 19103. BACKGROUND 3. Plaintiff incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 and 2 as fully as if set forth here length. 4. On or about March 31, 2003, Plaintiff purchased a 2003 Chrysler Sebring manufactured and warranted by Defendant bearing the Vehicle Identification Number 1C3EL65R13N526172. The vehicle was purchased and registered in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. The price of the vehicle, including registration charges, document fees, sales tax, but, excludine other collateral charges not specified, totaled more than $30,000.00. 6. Plaintiff avers that as a result of the ineffective repair attempts made by Defendant through its authorized dealer, the vehicle cannot be utilized for the purposes intended by Plaintiff at the time of acquisition and as such, the vehicle is worthless. In consideration of the purchase of the above vehicle, Defendant, issued to Plaintiff several warranties, fully outlined in the warranty booklet. On or about March 31, 2003, Plaintiff took possession of the above mentioned vehicle and experienced nonconformities, which substantially impaired the use, value and/or safety of the vehicle. 9. Said nonconformities consisted of, but was not limited to, defective air bag and engine. Copies of repair receipts are attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "A" 10. The nonconformities violate the express written warranties issued to Plaintiff by Defendant. 11. Plaintiff avers the vehicle has been subject to repair more than two (2) times for the same nonconformity, and the nonconformity remains uncorrected. 12. Plaintiff has delivered the nonconforming vehicle to an authorized service and repair facility of the defendant on numerous occasions. After a reasonable number of attempts, Defendant was unable to repair the nonconfonnities. 13. In addition, the above vehicle has or will in the future be out of service by reason of the non-conformities complained of for a cumulative total of thirty (30) days or more. 14. The vehicle continues to exhibit defects and nonconfonnities which substantially impair it's use, value and/or safety. 15. Plaintiff avers the vehicle has been subject to additional repair attempts for defects and/or nonconfonnities and/or conditions for which the Defendant and or it's authorized service center, may not have maintained records. 16. Plaintiff has been and will continue to be financially damaged due to Defendant's intentional, reckless, wanton and negligent failure to comply with the provisions of its' warranty. 17. Plaintiff seeks relief for losses due to the nonconfonnities and defects in the above mentioned vehicle in addition to attorney fees and all court costs. COUNTI PENNSYLVANIA AUTOMOBILE LEMON LAW CLAIM 18. Plaintiff hereby incorporates all facts and allegations set forth in this Complaint by reference as if fully set forth at length herein. 19. Plaintiff is a "Purchaser" as defined by 73 P. S. § 1952. 20. Defendant is a "Manufacturer" as defined by 73 P.S. § 1952. 21. Plaintiffs vehicle is a "New Motor Vehicle" as defined by 73 P.S. §1952. 22. Said vehicle experienced non conformities within the first year of purchase, which substantially impairs the use, value and safety of said vehicle. C T CORP. 215 563 7771 P.02/02 23. Deliendant failed to correct and or repair said nonconformities. 24. The vehicle continues to exhibit defects and nonconformities which substantially impair it's use, value and/or safety. 25. De{'endant does not require participation in any informal dispute settlement program prior to filing suit. 26. Asia direct and proximate result of Defendant's failure to repair the nonconformities , Plaintiff has suffered damages and, in accordance with 73 P.S. § 1958, Plaintiff is entitled to bring suit for such damages and other legal and equitable relief. 27. Plaintiff avers that upon successfully prevailing upon the Lemon Law claim herein, all attorney fees are recoverable and are demanded against the Defendant. WHER2FORE, Plaintiff respectfully demands judgment in his favor and against the Defendant in an amount equal to three (3) times the purchase price of the subject vehicle, plus all available collateral changes and attorney fees. Amount not in excess of $50,000.00. COUNTII MAGNUSON-MOSS FEDERAI?'1'I2ADE COMMISSION IMPROVEMENT AC? 28. Plaintiff hereby incorporates all facts and allegations set forth in this Complaint by reference as if Fully set forth at length herein- 29. Pliintiffis a"Consumer" as defined by 15 U.S.C. §2301(3). 30. Defendant is a "warrantor" as defined by 15 U.S.C. §2301(5). 31. Plaintiff uses the subject product for personal, family and household purposes. 32. 13M the terms of the express written warranties referred to in this Complaint, Defendant agreeti<to perform effective warranty repairs at no charge for parts and/or labor. TnTAI P OP TOTAL P.02 33. Defendant failed to make effective repairs. 34. As a direct and proximate result of Defendant's failure to comply with the express written warranties, Plaintiff has suffered damages and, in accordance with 15 U.S.C. §2310(d) (1), Plaintiff is entitled to bring suit for such damages and other legal and equitable relief. 35. Section 15 U.S.C. §2310 (d) (1) provides: If a consumer finally prevails on an action brought under paragraph (1) of this subsection, he may be allowed by the Court to recover as part of the judgment a sum equal to the amount of aggregate amount of costs and expenses (including attorney fees based upon actual time expended), determined by the Court to have been reasonably incurred by the Plaintiff for, or in connection with the commencement and prosecution of such action, unless the Court, in its discretion shall determine that such an award of attorney's fees would be inappropriate. 36. Plaintiff avers that upon successfully prevailing upon the Magnuson-Moss claim herein, all attorney fees are recoverable and are demanded against the Defendant. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully demands judgment in his favor and against the Defendant in an amount equal to three (3) times the purchase price of the subject vehicle, plus all available collateral changes and attorney fees. Amount not in excess of $50,000.00. COUNT III UNIFORM COMMERCIAL CODE 37. Plaintiff hereby incorporates all the paragraphs of this Complaint by reference as if fully set forth at length herein. 38. The defects and nonconfonnities existing within the vehicle constitute a breach of contractual and statutory obligations of the Defendant, including but not limited to the following; a. Breach of Express Warranty b. Breach of Implied Warranty of Merchantability; C. Breach of Implied Warranty of Fitness For a Particular Purpose; d. Breach of Duty of Good Faith. 39. The purpose for which Plaintiff purchased the vehicle include but are not limited to his personal, family and household use. 40. At the time of this purchase and at all times subsequent thereto, Plaintiff has justifiably relied upon Defendant's express warranties and implied warranties of fitness for a particular purpose and implied warranty of merchantability. 41. At the time of the purchase and at all times subsequent thereto, Defendant was aware Plaintiff was relying upon Defendant's express and implied warranties, obligations, and representations with regard to the subject vehicle. 42. Plaintiff has incurred damages as a direct and proximate result of the breach and failure of Defendant to honor its express and implied warranties. 43. Such damages include, but are not limited to, the purchase price of the vehicle plus all collateral charges, including attorney fees and costs, as well as other expenses, the full extent of which are not yet known. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully demands judgment in his favor and against the Defendant in an amount equal to three (3) times the purchase price of the subject vehicle, plus all available collateral changes and attorney fees. Amount not in excess of $50,000.00. COUNT IV PENNSYLVANIA UNFAIR TRADE PRACTICES AND CONSUMER PROTECTION CLAIM 44. Plaintiff hereby incorporates all the paragraphs of this Complaint by reference as if set forth at length herein. 45. The Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law defines unfair methods of competition to include the following: (xiv). Failing to comply with the terms of any written guarantee or warranty given to the buyer at, prior to, or after a contract for the purchase of goods or services is made. 46. Plaintiff, as a Pennsylvania resident, believes, and therefore, avers the reckless, wanton and willful failure of Defendant to comply with the tenns of the written warranty constitutes an unfair method of competition. 47. Section 201-9.2(a) of the Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law, authorizes the Court, in its discretion, to award up to three (3) times the actual damages sustained for violations of the Act. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully demands judgment in his favor and against the Defendant in an amount equal to three (3) tunes the purchase price of the subject vehicle, plus all available collateral changes and attorney fees. Amount not in excess of $50,000.00. DAVID J. GORB&RG & ASSOCIATES. P.C. BY: DAVID J. ORBERG, ESQUIRE Attorney for Plaintiff Cashier-.- 3 1 CUSTOMER COPYnfuRtA P.O.'Box 126 Beaver Springs, PA 17812 (570) 658-0100 CUSTOMER COPY CUSTOMER NO. UCENSEB STOCKR DEALER# INVOICE DATE INVOICEk CUSTOMER NAME & ADDRESS MILEAGE IN 526172 MILEAGE OUT 68512 LOTS/HAi M 03/31/2003 COLOR 028047 DELVERY DAIS GARY/BETH NEUBP.UM 723 M 727M RUE YEAR/MAKE,/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 610 W SHADY IN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING 03/31/2003 03/31/2003 VEHICLE ID A TECH & H P.O. B ENOLA PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. INT. EST. 687a EXTENDED WARRANTY CO. POUCY 8 DEDUCTIBLE AUTHORIZATION k ADJUSTOR 2107 0.00 RESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY SIGNATURE Yi`Tk YJS t+?'t? 4?A?i' ? ' dr s '# s rd4m X _ Y'u. Y'h A1,11 ' .:. ? x? ? v - , w r ?-' ° ,R7ge? terra ??.?rYYr??r?GWY?"!'+t ? sYry b'A n& Swi -'!. '^NC. v? u'v.: ,J} n ?T N?432 w ? f ? .k 6 ?eogyn ",tf ys4l IF) x ytF ?til; 4 a j?.?`P?h?`b br CJ TEA. '1'7•VC J L- . c.p 1',y L 3 . ^ S. FEH+RCMUR6M, R cY'f+s 1: 1 a . Al16?, k .-r . ".i e a _ x :! r' i F ? A i °i. T Y ` fi? ii^r, G, kF1rTx'.i n "^ •..I',. A X.X WCDRO CUSTOMER STATES WATER LEAK IN TRUNK 4097W t? cx Mel aJ? 3? REr L s?wx r• h *, 4w o 'a " s w ,s.. ;{r 1, - r 1 r m- Y ad *ryx :' e IR r..... 1 SM06VXLAB CARPET-WHEELHOU NC 1 SM07VXLAS CARPET-WHEELHOU NC 1 SL89VXLAC CP.RPET LUGGAGE NC t r? a ; ? 'a, v ^ 4 a" '~ a -.cc I a t i ? 'r nm _ M?v.?ra?: ?m?,=,-r x?ly? rtm' ?a ov'? ., uk T'is-v T+'E. t.v. 15 `..? P GS,34 k3 ai v -,a..; •YSn? ??.£ 1 M1F ?y tF `srk. P{S N?M E t m m I 6Fi11?1'h??leS?Sx..?tr_y` L.n4?M1iw.? m mm?4 m'- sm; B X.X INDSV CUSTOMER STATES PASSENGER SEAT BOTTOM IS LOOSE 40971 gg ORDERED RECLINER MECHANISM NC ,u- W 3 ? ai? ?' ? 'Yx h a. Syr '' S?Z91??,ntt'd4 P'tWl?q ?'{i . e ?F+f4?2.L { ?:1 ^" T 46? $d ? ?'2'[ P'f ' ? • j?? ? ?' ?i R 3 l???r ' ?fl N ? . _ .. . ? k5 1 .td. ?? y?:, 1- t WR.n .? .v J ?f ?"v ?-e. S _ }H'4 4 ? ?T 0.4 Labor Op 23002040 Failure Code lE ADTUSTED HOOD NC N. ?.S s?ns9 m ry.:•.PS ,n {r^ r? e r r.' a'SI a r ?nxr +'>f?. rr ? ?'qy 5' , ? 4',?IYj ? >S?'?,xL+ ?e ? ?`?"?„?r-; ry?.r'3 ?';, p» N `?.+'? ,y.k ??C?d?'A ?' k?`?it j?' ?l?i? a ? ?+r?;? ? w.?'`?"h'^. {I Y T fi 4f m.F 41T+ti.4' t? t en u t Y P ; S 4 4 '. A ?Pt eh';. "F''p k_•, ?` ? 3P ?m ? ???k`°`{"i ?b TR TAi? .1y?1n ?rEyy?i 'Jw1?E 6 i° ?T Y IPA C.#a 0? F??V.? y "r^°.'SCC? kp ( y }y>?°?'S"2"..A.yaY ? ??Y? IhR}j .^ s' Ny?.3 L.p ? ? {("?? T3 , ? , '.. d 4+yg y..M. Rv' Yi.['?pft?? Y't '[ i# }Ix?h1%rw,^.* °NiHwv .J;+Ln4'rk?hll !) "Hr?l.'I pd'f a ,?'?' ! `M`A 'LY 41YNY+ Vqq°::'' tlW `i 3t Tel. i ?. I i ^L? Y '+m Y la?..i ? X nl ?}Y'?? y, ?1 'tyhrv A •° PFIN"^Y ??^45 L?? V I ? * ?N4??f ri 5 ?? ?y pp 1 ,7 r e? ? I Y r• nrl } n A q e 9 apt "P „ ? ty5'.y" r?r;,12?H''?' YXT?? "?tt dr Jt.> A 9?}'F 3 ,} fF? t?+y,, { ? f .y? ? 6? ."JSoHI.. I.dYlb(gMa•k$: M?dSSf .T_.9v A 5 YpIL.. * g?.k4F$ ..i?uEF j 'I _}'se . A'. _ Total Sublet 00 Total Deductible G?'Q amt}n , rG?r, T, ?,. ?, q q Total Misc 0-00 a.,,1 iF'. „'.¢ ,M .rs a 3" .4a3 raS'?'i`'",yI 'Rt Jrc> }+'?''tu ut. rz +.ra '+ a G$.i'E•t"Tt ar:? eb ..AT a r p ?. rk v, ?,,??4 -. wv t•? 1 r?' , t +fd?"?. Pk ? * 's la I Ji, '' Y?9°` ' '?^' ? k "6 s tom' `?i' :huh, a ,r ?` a ? ? fi 5 x n ; a 4 1. dib} ?84? '4H'fL V ?i? e?P f ?n ? a 4?? MtYni ;? ? . E%TEVJOED WMRPNN PAY FACfOM WARRANtt PAV AlA TABOR CHARGES ARE BILLED ON FIAT RgiE NNgL E511MA1E TOTAL CUSTOMER PAY - HOURS UNlE530TSERWISE NOTED .00 Ttomer lature X M SOLUTIONS, INC. 188813436996 3989 8(99 Cashier-.> 3 13v uo>Ln CUSTOMER COPY ' ' • Beaver Spq,ngs, PA 17812 (570) 658-0100 CUSTOMER COPY CUSTOMER NO. LICENSE# STOCK# DEALER# INVOICE DATE INVOICE# 526172 3299 68512 07/14/2003 029560 'CUSTOMER NAME &ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT LOT#/HAT# COLOR DEUVERY DATE GARY NEUBAUM 3732M 3732M STERL 03.11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 610,W SHADY LN 03CHRYS1,ER SEBRING L 017/14/2003 07/11/2003 VEHICLE ID # TECH & # P.O. # ENOLA PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 • ° OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. IM. EST. 1 6874 EXTENDED WARRANTY CO. POLICY# DEDUCTIBLE AUTHORILATION# ADJUSTOR NONE 0.00 RESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE E WRIER DELIVERY SIGNATURE VIIC SEE RR y ? [[nn ?:{qq ? d`.in.%n ^ < +,?a A#,n?).9 e S.sX L'aR'k?l+.l.`R^.? .s ??? hhi.FL?.ri^,r 3Y3.'?f+ i Y4 ., ).:b 1i{iF"i-Y v a%r- d.d'Ja Y4 i.ek.vW n?.11[ "y. _vl?k M x { x :l.. `)M.".'edtroet"'Fk,'r?v*ry?'R,iIu",.`'t,.ro..x4`Ydm`T:.i`,?.`?fs-."A.stF A D.5 CPDRO LUBE OIL FILTER 4350C r ">A' c v w-. MI 'q't, r ?{,^, o ms n ,r a, , 1x " '' wf 9 "i 9 4 aP3kx.E?sr'? i? s+ tl a Y+N ,3ui? 5.tieRy 5 4-a .y F?1 1Y}1td ..."" iP...F '?44:w e R k11Q 7t 11 d,u"?:? "'; 4 5p pS v 4?"` r w M1 ''[ 3"' t U F w" 5? "M %T. f'yY?i'91P?4f-L f 3 M" i !5 E' i w tt"r 4 i Ri.r r '11r$'S'J?,iy,l?' ,p q7 '47)fJ?'A v f a`?ra+v$? : 'YI°t?5 r?,I a N' yip , e y? i?i. p1? ? iS d HIV' SLn•. y,"T N' I ?[?v S ,T t Y ' M lT il,,yi W ` t?{` . i „ ?l, yy?` µi 4' fy°P/?Y y 4 qM n R r Y ??M I rS',J o f h4 . pv { ?r jNN P V ` 'srs,??{,,. `q k {tC t IBS '334 55f??f 2 ? `Yifibr+}H %? "y' Y An ?, C f Siff mat:' 1 {>N )Li t 4 I?p * '' ? i ' ?? Y ?rI M ,2,..m? s{? $? . .. v l„.v. '.- i i fe, i? .Y..i vl ? ?,u .? . • YS., T.. Ye .k•+ Shop Suppfies '0.60 - --- - - --- -- - - - OIL-FILTER-DISPOSAL -- 2.00 Job A Total Parts & Labor 21.95 R 41 IMF, ! ' QT? S ty+ fv{1" ( ,.?,*i.'?..y,utfy STIv .:' ,I >^r 11, a'B § xp d r A°w.?`+'F'.?Tgg! tS'r,R 4,. y?' iex'%,ki ; • ft l ??P ?` RNMN"T %k??? f1 '^FS ' 'S n ' ' a -u is ,.F. eek.«.1{>r ? T .?`?C°ie£_fd'. 1?4It?u` , aw 3. 4350C STATE INSPECTION,LF 10B, RR 6B, TIRES 8/32 19.95 STICKER #7769543 'i77. T 4nP" ., R' a'F 'r [ rf+S' 'nv13"a'mTV '°':5 .w OF 3.1 r F a'b i- r a• 3 r ?;? "' tE a ,« X49 +• a h' ob?• r"I?'Dtaa3 HP3'r .?s ` ' o'k'r `'` r +.; 'o-, M1L 1 M1 )? 1'$P ?y +E. i a `} W " M1' h h 'S G l f' rz Y! ,E? 1' P 44 1 { ?? Y,!.n, "?'1•'¢a?k 1.°201p•1'}?..`"?,.y, 3't *?• 3f r`{'f ? 'wi ? 1- an.4Ra } ?+wl:?ya s'? v7'<Y tFi H'6 ^5 ?I{, a LT,rs ? ? ' SY?^y? S "A, ?' M1T??- i"h ,?"g ak•. v? '} ?y??°B')rh'„y??c d #r .xk ?r?k? "? q, I Fe'6 ? t N a pp??,"?ii? ?'°?,*,,,?4>?:.a&{`x'`$ .,'. @, i'.'3.k?.''s ?g ;k"i,"k 'Mt j`hrx>,ao?, b`Y'L{; .$?j????u,?^t`"? w?m-Fr,., N?`?S? ), '?.a?`st.' w: .. ; a. a_L.` F',?2?rr? Imo, ,?_a,,?sr,r x. d•? ?+U?- '?c?t ,?* 'r, ''r.,t . fAr Ar?s?iuF'r-.?/,y?}+rg ak ref TV tLksp -aL"s? ?,u-? u:.v.rS '?-?<1"f?.LrT ?-'..?maswv a• [ a.Yx v«.h .-tx :, V „1? .p,?ATf N}Ia? v?M h ? M1 3 °f.i.SE,ia,?.,} ?ykry .`? f' '? r v n 6Sjay, ? p+{ a 1^P ?{,pp ?a xn, fi s rd Vtpn 'iu`Ymg d.. hW '?t4{'" ?.Fi2 x ??I ?{?{ 11-R'Y'Z''k?"ii'??''vs'1?y'ul3T.?.J Tµ.,O"-? ,?}"Atl}ty?glTdS?'?` `E Xr E,x.F •4arkT?S?Td A.?.{ov j?P (,°?t.F`?j.?s?` '?T?, as??+l>1st Dk S'4y ?3 d?*T?(%?)_ '?' .mt°e 'x ('E?pYv!fF ii r ?e ??}T •."v x tl f ta'tf 4acaI. ?Y13`, 1+,,,n,?F rT}y r' ? L .y., Ii ^n F x{ysy', EA Yn VI,11 7;il N'S'A4F dT'?M R4'..miY kf fG'.?yf"'v+j W MI'I°L1}¢.,yl'jy 41fif ?Iu,V P" 1fl !i f'i. FK p.?l , I?L?.\r7Fry 4 5,"y?',N!?K1` j..tiF/k 'il r)M1'jvY? 2'\ y FY'd {}1 s?+1"..' R Y ?' rt ? ? 44M1 .T{{' ?Y nk ?'if .lid f ? k ? p . pl 2u ?.YJy ?+ a' '#iW?? L ?+tT+'i:i r? " 2Mi u f FIB t?' V? F ? ! IX? fIz 'R i }} 3 t f ?1 I ?ry slk Ik AiL 91 V'+x y r d ,py,N,y 1 tr4. °w)y, nl'j Total Sublet 0.00 Total Deductible 0.00 Total Misc. 0.60 tld!R3r'S P "^y U" Y ] T I nF.lc V 1 5 '?7^ I ,. x 9 'Nn rc ?,.,? y a .irv A a +` {7 'f ?? Aap F??yp, Yfn;y 7 ? ?'.. b<?+}e A'{tik 11F?.1'3?3'F`?, ?A.d'I?gk?i?9'?T/'9.•M e>¢?{ tl4 4 5'.?$,,.? "7' ? ?'? 13511 oY¢i?S-j ?i Y'4? r'%L A. ? X ?? ?i.:??? ?ISRf?'t v a k r *??? Wg?S}?N'?"'?H 'I ty ??ll;ti5? kf6 ? Y+? iP 1; PF yxI Y6i191 -+R.'. Nh" ?„'`k }'l,'f ! 9 L.... t uY ? m `?' ' I t}Sh ?+9s 'xir v k + ??w ? ?`? "t ?Z? I 4 0 t " ' £ ? ~ ? '?1 ° ? dH a ? ? ? ) M '4 ? ? . y cl r . l Fdy? , pp ?? , >W .Tx. ? k ? ry? ' p t 1 y N 4t"ga?•g°a' ?'' ' iu'? . ih ?' Pi'?'Fi??i} a"T ?,? dn y ?tFa`i??"I ''2?5 ?ir'ij, '1 '''yy??4,j???7?p}{4??° Ik t4ly?° ?$i'!A: rAr?9p'5? " ?tr? kelT' f? ° - ?' ' T ` i ? ? ? r c r w r W h ror. L i5, r tA41Nd,1t ) t• - ii i 91 9 ?,. Iw. 11, Ywh tM1eNY.h rvh ii+rnr d1a W'SP9 w"ar,.aa F1:?', , n ?Q .., Y°hA i p.v ? F%{ENDED WARRANIV PAY FACTORY WARRANTY PAY ALL IABDR CFwPGE6 PRE B61ED ON FUT f141E FIVAL ESIMAIE lOTP1 CUSTOMER PA1' HWR66NlE4 OiIiERM6F NOTED 47.06 ?Ustomer Signature A =ORM SOLUTIONS, INC. (696) 3!3-6006 {M 3996 sin .ashier-> 3 106dael :USTOMER COPY Beaver Springs, PA 17812 (570) •658-0 t 00 CUSTOMER COPY CUSTOMER NO. UCENSE # STOCK # DEALER # INVOICE DATE INVOICE # 526172 3299 68512 07/14/2003 029396 CUSTOMER NAME & ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT LOT #/HAT # COLOR DELIVERY DATE GARY NEUBA"UM 3290M 3290M STEAL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE 770 . DATE 610 W SHADY LN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L 07/14/2003 07/01/2003 VEHICLE ID # TECH & # P.O. # ENOLA PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. IM. EST. 6874 EXTENDED WARRANTY CO. POUCY# DEDUCTIBLE AUTHORLATON# ADJUSTOR NONE 0.00 RESIDENCE PHONE BU6INESSPHONE SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY SIGNATURE IIid3'R 1 FL .L ` }, t IK ,.., .+xf,.,lil4 "I TTN 'S>'PiS. rapt wd r'i .- + - 'F. . °Rk Y$ ..'w S?.?iY??F r.M r ,f ,. arv IW?i W ?L^w?,, .. mE,?F"'za. ff, ?I WHl i?i`??ffl,CT:yw??$.bE?I, dY1f,.f lv :BF,vFziSs44rYgMJM"F4 y" TFN?f YBW ^>?IN I{:T ?;rt?i?'?';...t dt ?t4ii '?P N...r ?f it ..o b+i (_ K ..{ f ?^I?WN? I' -.-y{HRPtf. ..bv' fAA8E11 N, rl Y IPAP}S 1)lp e };,:. Rat` A X.X INDSV CUSTOMER STATES AIR BAG LIGHT WAS ON 43501 '?it'ivty +lya? ??a r`:"`= ; r T 'i" Y^w iy.?'x'+k'''Oa ",E" 3 ?C L31E'F'tiS3Q?E," aANl3 .LsH3.' , - T -Ze'-' erC, { 4 p " ? t S`qa? 'v. rq1,. 6u F .g 6 '#r1 !; ? ra 9_c9 Yu '? c' *N ,:mv t??? .E °k'R? 1 1 ?:c' YZ i H Fa k r}, , ?A +.Y'4 t: 4 ' ? # r 7t* ?I? Fk $ Y L k ? A ` ? ' `N Y ;. z ? ? .+ T,* (. 1 r A 'Ct if T}i? {t ? 1('M , 3 re i,,: Y h ?CR+D' D 3?AR'TE iN Yh, d 1._ s T`s j '? u?I$i l 1'7 F e J k,c 3 Y'" ?? ? + `C l?? r , E !N '? 1 (? r y ? ib j # T ? T J?? Al Tt ? ? ? ? ??? S ? ' ? l * ? ? ? IT ? %, p 4 j' p ' + ^'4 C? t HT ? f ! t T L' ? € A 4 ? ? >l hF 9 I .? l AXY T }F:!Bdl fA,Y Pv T? iT Y' .xY+§dt SF i't! td rG iy- ATP af?Y rl 1 F4 1r C 1,, µ I?, p !? q ?'.5 >t ?1 {AW }?? ? ? ; L N Il .v?x B . WCDRO CUSTOMER STATES DRIVERS SEAT RECLINER IS INOP. X X 43BOW 1.4 Labor Op. 23135502 Failure Code 51 N w mGR "m Ia" . ? 1`S y5 £•' ? ???yy fT'G? ??? fya??Yyy4Yi 'k ? { t?P ?'}, 4'?ti??"'k1 ?ry n Y ? i ?l t?m.?{ ! ??°??a 4 ?' t.??y???'?"?Y'"4t°'?i?"'Cti ?F:rt ? ryR 1 ?p9@9@ ? ?r *f"*I En i? ?.` ? tk? fT1A r.{'I?k"k L "?PTrfLa k !Y'[a IA?y Mr NI h?9h1 ?!?.?'/??n ' L p ? ? :V?tt ?t?i' ?ryW... Y?$ r 3 ,T1 S I Z4 y ? d 'Y? ?` 1 ? ' i ? ? ? ? y ; 1 ? . 4 } . q ak { ?N! ?2U l 3'' '?d{ ?y?$$ T$1 y`"?. ff 11i y. 1S? ? ??i? E?1"?y J:J+'i FR?2 '?•l(•d Vk ? 5, r (/ I 3.;J?S 1M Y' FRY F jI? y lSr .hh? flL4.3T'? ?F??fES`?4?{T?? T31? JL.d??{-4 lY'p v'If 1y l{ w ? TB, 1-'W4??'S l'"?ttFlia"]`rR J iT 11 ?J?31u'ddd... ].ft... ?Ytfi ?'??l?tk ?'!„ {'a5"HS"",?? ,RS'L .F l Ai:V YI JL .f ? Y twfrL & ?? Y? h 5 ? ? 4'? L? n :"? k l ?' ' ; ? . . , rl ± t , a A 2 V .W v t v. ii tt ? . . ??DI Ry??iP ?' 'L tLk $ µ?µ ? "'Y k'?C x Y ?'k F m-'?.,f Y rS?MU `"",F8{" d, JJ r Y lal I'?y?j 9frd 1 ?lkkT? C ?,^? 4 ? ??:YUi`r 1' ?JI d} .: 1bytW l7?Afy I1R?,j?y 4? lFti?j• ?T py'[T111.k? .rftys ilk, AI Py ??>` 9 rt ."PY rrfi1 .:??1?1(tfl?? . ' ,4.AN.r +?? r?, J 40 M fI1iWB i .Yf?, rgt ,1u>? Y'i,(J I:'f?,. Nii. M vi ` 00 Total STiblet : Total Deductible 0.00 Misc. 0.00 Total X.# T1-itc?Jy?? :ij3C`' F y 1 S s r,.. t'q': r '' `1qt 1 * . fl m ?w 3{- rl f .9` G I " y 1*r ry, $ v7 M irT}m?.Rr'k All « afll a" r,Y. k ,?3 ? ., ??I?°I ? d? ? r " ? ? y?e{ nl tl .Rt,iosc,"s1?Y4"Yk' 'F43 r'.,? t•xh rT7 F} eiNe;4 K b.Rt ? 51n Y {L?"Y3",? a as , v:') ., afx s ':zrlrrV :' x? al ;+F ' P v ?' d ti{ a .. , . ?, e . , , ._. n, o .., . - a ? , ?. r4t Lr r EXIENCFDVJARRPNIYPAY FACiORV WAfNAN1Y PAY ALL LABOR CHARGES ME BILLED ON FLAT RATE FINAL FSTMAIE TOTAL CUSTOMER PAY HOURS UNLES5 OTHERN NOTED 1 0.00 ;ustomer ;Ignature A ORM SOLUTIONS, INC. (888) 363.6006 1M 3986 6/99 ;ashier.> 3 1 '_U1TOMER COPY Beaver Springs, PA 17812 (570).656-0100 CUSTOMER COPY CUSTOMER NO. LICENSE # STOCK # DEALEP. # INVOICE DATE INVOICE,# C;? 61 7 3299 68512 07/14/2003 029561 CUSTOMER NAME & ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT LOT#/HAT # COLOR DELIVERY DATE GARY NEUBAUM 3742M 3742M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD, DATE R.O. DATE 610 W SHADY IN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L 07/14/2003 07/11/2003 VEHICLE ID # TECH & # P.O. # ENOLA PA 17025 1C3ELG5R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S W. INT. EST. 6874 EXTENDED WARRANTY CO. POLICY# DEDUCTIBLE AUTHORRATION4 ADJUSTOR wwlz 0.00 RESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DELVERY SIGNATURE ._,. .... ., PA#.....N" ..ar nI Rr?iaE.a T'7a"?.?'bn?P:i`'»1.??di?':?vw"'f€,?N#r4i+F t .n,,, ,YtY, k??in .Jt'3t ,"x"'vpF. -dr t~?RR14wM#Y kaAJ,w l,rv,;<?r n. ?, ..-ia?1NA51bBE?R.:? '7P. 4 d+?.?'.,T. N3 x in': D.ARr6®C5m>w`NVE: ?" i rt}. .5 m t T .?rS 'G RSV SF?T z, A X.X INDSV CUSTOMER STATES THROTTLE STICKS 43501 i -*r?L ?-t^ m'y5? i3+s'°+?` ax -r a? 9 ^r a r r n r- Fa \+, ?a r.Ki & x4p? 3 „r ?' six ? na: ny.r r _ w A v 3+xs .i a -V fti ¢ .?. 7 lee ?Hl( i "" J 'f 'sY J lt? ai z UV i "e A" >•,-ie *4 14a #tJ '?.. ?1k t' b"r]? '4j rms:? R +JJ4? 6??]j € 3"?d?q'R3' T? ['?'tt yt,j R t ?A- Pi .w+?x ?,x?''\ ?' 'FS r / i, n. r rv 7 ^yd s i yy.. 5 tl § G n 'E `? Y" tl & z e'6?'A c•t.` iAtR'rlY"?,' -q .f ,A5 arm. p r i,a Wk''-0v?iSjNY `r a.?d?y„ y+i'?S4 ?Y? "rv?HM v ?3{#?'E iY? ?4 xv la' ? j[ r d,A @A m nl ?'F7id5 v 4. 9 tti mm 11m, B X.X INDSV CUSTOMER STATES CONVERTABLE TOP SQUEP.KS GOING UP AND DOWN - .. 43501 . PUT TOP UP AND DOWN RUBS ON THE WAY NO ADJUSTMENT NC W1,y,m }'w,7arL.x'v +r,r uy ?ar?R'T `'st"9,_df ei n'Rx'5w' xi4`,? t^` a i??.a4` Aq??rE..p.+ ^'grli .r _.? .:vZ xel?.Ye ,b.. .;. ? i ? -... 'hri`5.. ... u'..l,F?i Ea ry'3 - i. .. {F?.3. x. fd ? u VkU ? v }-.? : x.. n ?.?nX..3_ `. urmu ,4 5wy, h 4 "{''> ?1'?+' '??, ? ¢ vy E T rd 1.;, i v yE '?i ?vr 4 `4 4 d. .d^ i'?{?#'akA?'`,.N IC„{,?'7A•?.y L'?F'JS f{,S.?JFyJ,4?'jio-v?y? .u "tinily R'{?5???+r ?7"t ? "' "ct'h'3.?2 GI fl i llf l.. ,!F' ?Ai \?^s s t? F;"f'?"AAv =+?:,' {,I??xasrµV ???4NY°' ? Y v i iT??nRtTiS LY fi"h'!'d??i1 €.& y ? a# ,-{? fi3?`L'?? re 'r le V k C '?,".s ,Tt il„Yw.Orj,t ??yr r+- t 1 L S`"I'° E3X."'' 'e ma } a.'? + t`R Nh:w w Y i w r ?" zx "r `` A.4" 6PS "°U EFH?4:Lb"4x ?r ??,3 ' It y?' f"ysr ,?a'?Fxy",?ra„?? n'+3' a V p ?^? 3`5 fJ?`1,ys,yr rr. FFervo? -?3 ' IN'ra!H?iTfF "1? !yn-s?# F v I r .li,vr^xc ?1 S r 7t 4^T^IRe^ L . ? h tipixe>u'Ax. "i ?1,xw'E ? t i R T+',r w;t ?Tai?1'r`£- ? r4 +R9? t +5r?ji m?N u? ?`# h w'nq ,??, ??{?4q F as r Tr • I?' 4 m1 ? F '" x'?rF s? ai t 3" r ui '? ? v 't? utt ??1 R..a d S4?m'd?9 eR" l.u+.'L e+J k, 5?? 1A,ri ,Aa!?+LviR C#J ?R+, r' h?-C'ry4?'R lyu l+{+£.vI "t .t,3 n ? "'T 7 Q ? s !} it?w ? 111 r+?'a i u? 11Pf ?S'j,( d! Y yr,?. A vi x 4 A ??v 1k1f r r ?A,4'NTll?fi}S td t9k` ?1 Bfb d 'Sx.?7A 1 l gU'Y ]Try Yi Ir n,'Y.'?IFt,??M- 4.r17 I T G F 5? a+ tl !" `#.??V y.m?.Rd 3 .4{66 tJ F .F 3 nif' i 4?1? .t' J? ?l{ 3?AF iF wV rvl ?.! tf k r Yn Y d 56 FJS n r i^F k ?I o y} ?x #? Sry'? 5'! j`a">ffk'?',?"e-n ? ?4 Ir diA,BFF..???Dq Hn ??}k'ja??"1"y IL A4?Ix; ypR a$§ n?A? I -y ++ a \ ?i ? r YT FS'w , rx it Yv"VA`'t?i ?lRk lu}i p'?H, v .,ya ? . ,,. _ ??''? , i.?-at.2 >i. iii?Y? y}?.1 S64i {t ?^fiS .?3 $ 1f ,iP:F{ (? j?' ?91y3vIY?i x? !E yP ?l1P`??.? .?iil? 1dl$y1?RryM:1'?? YI 4" '„?'? •' a Wt 1+1. 91' fir' 1? ??III '?' F 6?F ?{ -i6?Pli?i 1?y? i'.'' ?? L 5i S T?fl?'?-t?? ARgfi J?A C I?}}Xl?N frR3? lydt i 0?{!M ?. R ?'? ?LL ? SIq 9 `*f A 1 .uA J V 1S. ?iM l7 IY ,F ? l 0 "W S'?.{?°sn ?b ?I?e ?. ?.Tp ?y p pn ? ?4 p ?13? . x?'.?tr't.ai4^. x,','PM1^?,U3at,^.Y?:s= ?`'?}5.,i,t?-?,.rT?r a t?o1Y.4 nG.`TjY ni?'?A ,ti a•''9?,"'t Pd, ."Ae'r?'F?O? Ixtl t .' 4 +,v i'{ w ?R'3? ?3 .t 9?`it d i"i h? F ?Ir r; Total Sublet 0.00 Total Deductible 0.00 {1 .N Vy? 4[*e _ Total Misc. 0.00 ?ff xy?JJ?V 6 i? F ? t4? FVjF j?'.il^pq ?] Yi" t 1 1 }n hf .e 1"y?X>hi ?4J4.1e(447'9k't'f" ?i[? T'Rr+rAh?'W' k. ?,nr?,? xRfiC F 3" Y 'Y i 1 A ?l - F e"r} v?H -,ry Y` S !? IS ]^ r?M "t .r?s T "U r?i,`'afrR^ha?v z?(-t?Y 3. 5x?i ?? z?°Ljj,w?+a,6'?? of ;,! is ,y fY??aY "?a-di pd `r #'I?a ??? It L. `at ?k`?t1?, ?I }32 "??Y ^'` h °? R?^@I 'fi t !s JK`iP r}: @ ? ? ki l??" v d v ?. .P $?? 5t kr (??9 0?7,. 'P A ?+w IXIENDED WMRANIV PAY FACTORY WMRANIY PAY ALL WBOR CHARGES ARE 31LIEp ON RAI RATE HNAL ESTINAiE TOTAL CI6TOMER PAY HOURS UNLE40THERWRE NOTED o.oo .ustomer dgnature A 'ORM SOLUTIONS, INC. 10881 343-6006 iM 3988 6199 GARY NEUBAUM 610 W SHADY IN ENOLA, PA 17025 HOME: 732-5047 4U-0 1`7GI r0VGI"1111i 7325047 4 9'3 3.2 _ANUY OF DRATi ,RRSt"S *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike CHRYSLER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep. [717) 765-7686 PAGE 1 Web Site: www.brennerchryslerjeep.com BUS: 772-6254 E-mail: brennercj@earthlink.net SERVICE ADVISOR: 1f;7 Rnr,RR PARTr:R 6791 ENG:2.7 Liter MPI 23130104 FC: CONNNECTOR PARTS: 0-00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE A: 0.00 ** VERIFIED ASR BAG TO CHECK THE C302 WENT AWAY. aZll CHRYSLER Jeep -FACTORY PART Thefamor y warrentry constitutes all - of the warranties ties with respect to LABOR AMOUNT the sale this Item/Items. The PARTS AMOUNT n Seller hereby expressly. tlisclaims ell warranties, either express or GAS OIL LUBE impllad, including any Impliad , , warranty of merchantability or fitness for a rno l SUBLET AMOUNT pa v er purpose. Seller neither assumes nor h i MISC. CHARGES aut or zes any other parson to assume for it any liability in TOTAL CHARGE: connection with the sale of this LESS INSURANCE Itemgtems . - SALES TAX CUSTOMER SIGNATURE I PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY aghier-? 7 09 i 1 O Lij 'USTOMER COPY e r.v. oux rco Beaver Springs, PA 17812 (570)'658-0100 CUSTOMER COPY CUSTOMER NO. LICENSE # STOCKS DEALER k INVOICE DATE INVOICE # 14161 3299 68512 12/02/2003 031513 'CUSTOMER NAME & ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT LOT #/HAT # COLOR DEWERY DATE GARY/BETH NEUBAUM 7463M 7463M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD, DATE R.O. DATE 610 W SHADY LN 03CHRYSLEP, SEBRING L 12/02/2003 12/02/2003 VEHICLE ID# TECH &# P.O.# ENOLA PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. INT. EST. 3102 EXTENDED WARRANTY CO. POUCY # DEDUCTIBLE AUTHORIZATION # ADJUSTOR NONE 0.00 RESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DEUVERY SIGNATURE 7- 4 rr;•Ai."r...: '.. , owE+Fi .,.'>'L?."T?i7 t"3a' ?t, A. ' 'LF r y m. vx .n yry,,,,?., raw ,p(` ...1? ,,t 1 x Y f y? x iip?at wv u5? IT I - u .'R„x r W YSS-`.WJ6:i? ?r.. .et iVe.."v? 4rt a:,N ..: Y,a ,3W' as .. Lb .. .sY a"`9.M [?'?i "S?a"";i5 P ?a F',g'6e e!R!krd. it c. el t LY.k: %'j" z A 0.5 CPDRO LUBE OIL FILTER 6745C 01 ??`p?? EN (1'? r c1? ft e???''k? .Y3AT vb ?T??n Yy±?i I '! 1 L?`Tr+s: T {uf Mw S? qA-v I'?"?P C "a.. ? R Y ?' Y t K -k, La -?•y !) 4`t` § sw i?` Y r ^?jd ? r r?q ?x(j",, 1' A I T ? ,? e ? Y a rt'^I1nY ;?h rv s Fclt 'r t w E T s?a? ? A t '? '? fi V d `? ` d a - P x g . y ^ : w? . I x. > .,r Y 4 P ? a >., t t n} z•3'r'??L$ a R ,?a`Y7?'1 ?p??§ ??"4i'ao .?A?A?si ?r?s 'bs? T? }?4F4A??Y?t?'??Gy?H'???4+?_Z?$?i-'i? +''?';;'"{4?A ?4 ?+ °?' '?'aSh?? " k?i ' z , .fi . 4 . S .._?_ "? ?> w " " ' " ? 0 5. D 10 OIL lOW3b MOpAR $UL ShopSuppiies -- - ---- 0:60 Job A Total Parts & Labor 21.95 :i?'"'. a` d ,5,.'?. v?fi}t '•,• a , ;,.= 8 r ?1? , rAif wy"?'r- r^. s i `v4 T;1'''z.' '? t'.a tT sP a4r,;. ,G «+'??f 4 A'?'''">-?'aies 'T"ay yi,'r R, - , ra t9 fn r- ,,. I I Ia.1 TS,L?''4v 4a t'2F r.3'. .'Y'??"3".T'?+1 A'*.?yf?b?3d ei"y. ?CLS T:" }??Y f 4". ?s?5 h'.T???? i <wt W+i?'?? ,` t ?sf y,. ARk+'^ 4v"??i`SP ?ry4 Rte{, aft ku? 0 h7 ??r r? tl"°'?4Y? *'?7@ m f?? 4?(?r ^?al a rv' " w "rar ? e A ? ? . I "' nw, 6745C 02 ROTATED TIRES 14.95 Job B Total Parts & Labor 14.95 w 9712C INSTALLED FRONT MUDFLA.PS 0.00 1 82203871 GUARD KIT-SPLAS 10.50 y ?b+w lr 5yk ?, yM3 SiM1F d? h ` ?yTS iL $ q? '" ? i*!'{TX ? `I '1-14 3' /' ?I y ?'? ?Er k-? qq 'I 'f? (L i ! ? S '? ?f )- ? .f yy. . ry i . F ? ! , r § i. £ f S A .Y , $ 3 I 1. 1 P? ?? 4 f1A3 Y-4h4 5 k?4 X .N ?YIf I :?.Y/l 1,y „? "u F 'FL # Iv •1 ?.ryfj+TA'Y'?Ih tl YI l 1' Y yy?.. 1 I?,? }.Mr "f SM1 ? C I a`{ +,. '° b $^I. 1 t 5.. ' FY?4 Yn v M ),? ?"?A"F L°,I ?j 9yi (R PF 41'Ju { 1 n"'A 't Y. ?'??I "??,nf.`?(D'???? ?{?M?`? ?N'???? "N,{ ?d'?xk Ftx?Y?FS' rl fhry.l°&? 'rh V?rv}i '{!N+?:t[It ^?(rf. ? 5Y? 4 Y' M%.Yfi.?C ?k1 ?""f<I ? ? /???itxit$@ly?L` 1 y ? ? w1 . l M1 - r r a ?4n: ?Y % ? S M1 0.11 .? ?kFy^ pi4 !: q?'!{}1+4 ^t1;fYsFi n( ? 3 Af3 ymy F'r.. 'f R T In ?f E'M ??LSC ?}i?H"T?ia4lN q "?+AIIY Vti'?.'F?$` fi z?)!$,?4Y Y M1i??. ?"N! 'S" i..R'(,k \ ? er?n5{ I?R?{k ??.?1 S??Si?SE'YErf? ?"2YV fYP t:4 YI"?I?'?' f yi? V1. ?e 1A+Id' 1 ! V P5^'M ?L?wlf ? ?,1?9 IX.1?}? L S 3a3 ?.fh?? AP [4?J I A?Xf E.IY EI VII f[y S yp .R (If S1Mk I11.??[, I?A ? tl? d "ml W ?y' P P f jY 5? R' ?'yI?M1H?,?1?L?4?' 5r E) R'?{ Fkr. 'J'i N.Y ?fY4y1'•? 3?'F.h 1a '4` R 1 '"tr?p A ???9R-1?1.. f y YI ? ?Pd4( }^u`i'P'?"?R5>?p?' k+l??'f sk?' ?ar7??tl1?'?'.1??= I'R"??1?? F? I ? ?1>? y? ?b???• .:?17 (??I ??RTy ?$>?? T p,?'?' Y? N ?M p ' ? r ? ? ? ? A 1 aA i i ^iI ^p e YkM ?? t :? tl? ?,Y? t r•• r6T'e 1 l5$?.or'Byy ' T?7 { t?F N a I `YMr d ? i a . !d`?Fn 6 °R ?. °. L.. ?e >*?Si:K.§1 '? d '?v?d`" a ? Ti??S?.e filh ?e"'??"iN!Iwr1? 9a vsh9 tt ?k =Y'TI0.z; +C`h ?u k[ k:u +h Y f t?'d 'kl L' % f? . „ :. ? . f . I L 151 IMYwRx.rl34 r , . -. I ft, l SEE: t ? (5?' l u ? . Tota S e ' Total Deductible 0.00 Total Misc. 0.60 ' y:Ti,',J+tTITY'rw 5' 5. ? i FItT +15.7,151 + iflr i ? e`1'.T7' i In. ug ^ ~} w 19 ?!???, (?"F >" T a b3 TM.rr v n # O k d i? I rl :: ? 2' ' 4l "ff 1 i ' ?I SxN. 4 'R" ? ??5? 3w n? F . h'hT E ?+i ?Si?j?}§kR ? ?^M?`,'?I t fM ?YY '4dIV u ? § # i^ k1 f4 r?']] F i. L14 5E?a ,?5Y4iup+'Wx''?'4 } ?. ? w? ^^ 0. {?- m i 4 ' ' ' ? At +^ H [ V ? .14 g v 3 L R i F ?f5S at Y ? f r M E +v ai S 1?xa'9?if YR d' fI5'w}k? : { ?J E i ?1 E A '7 ? ^ ' mm + " + .. nx . . , : x e, ,, u.hM> v g a. eE 471 m:e"!., f , ?r a,.? e4 Y .! Y EXIENBED WARRANTY PAY FACTORYWARRAN7YPAY All LAIR CHARGES ARE BLUED ON FLAT RATE FINAL ESIIMAX TOTAL CUSTOMER PAY HOURS UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED 50.89 Ustomer 3ignoture X FORM SOLUTIONS, INC. ISM) 343$806 HM 3988 6/99 f, I n? q t Loo`s mf-T - q 0'„Os Pd ckG791 U1lll1JLLll as`hier->,3 09 0 USTOMER COPY Beaver Springs, PA 17812 (570)'658-0100 CUSTOMER COPY CUSTOMERNO. LICENSE: STOCKA DEALER# INVOICE DATE INVOICE qq F 5 CUBTO AME&ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE CUT IOT#/HAT# COLOR DEUVERYDATE I nl 9M A qTWRL /11 / 0 03203- GARY/]BETH NEUBA-UM YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE v T.' 1/19/2004 0. 04/19/2004 610 W SHADY IN _ VEHIC IDH 1ECH& P.OA 7 25 T ENOLA PA 1 0 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP I S. W. IM. EST. d EXTENDED WARRANTY CO. POLICY # DEDUCTIBL ALBHORIZATION # ADJUSTOR R ENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRRER DELIVERY SIGNATURE ° S e"r 'k h b °*k7tT ?2'€xN'h i?V hhy!, VNN aNl.It x *1RF hri End 5 ' '0 ¢N r t - 9 a d: Yfl i x k#v vt5 N f".? d m <ri a a{ ?x , ?{ 5e b " r'. 'b t'M}a ,J .Y. .`k .^R BU'.. ":.n r7..?F{fNfl'?4.r3umi n 4dL e2. ae`M aw'?`w?$-1M$1 v'",!".: ! , F?<'Y5.YFT10+Yh1.M ,.a LTfi'^i? la kJ .ro lr ASi-9 :v14: t??,..d:. 1 ll, bFa ?? A 0.5 CPDRO LURE OIL FILTER ®n y». 6_4.SC R O1 a r - ' 4 t m tit iri t i rt°41e 4 " kLL'` 's?-: RniY ? i ? m ? ? ?<r1-31 f. .... ..._ ... ... A Shop Supplies 0.60 Job --A-'Total-Parts- &--Labor - --21.95 Sales Tax 1.36 ^ f ja }? ?"nNor a L`"`"? *, IN 4 ? [ a?. ROTATED TIRES TO HAVE EVEN TREAD ON FRONT OF VEHICLE 14.95 Job B Total Parts & Labor 14.95 Sales Tax 0 90 r a T"y' a ,: ? Gn". ?, x1""k+. x r d`F ?' SuC; T *"I? F . g- y°^':. wF C V 4 H h L 1 { 5?? ? ""?'? riIP a 4' ? wjt? h 1? ',n 3 x ?N r w M1 u+ 1 ( *W ar aK ^a" ? ? n ?? A :? N? t 4 Fs ?? ? S tY -0V ? a yg t ? 61 ? $ t d 'ar•4?,?1T'.,rftry'" s.:k , %"+a, o-, r"n? 'a3?>7.?PafY" o . A„?..- Y? V Pa YRd>9R f)Yp?Y f F £ersr LLFt 9l R??` ?T 3'! R h6?dp../i {"!Fny} Sk sY v {Y?47ti3 ri?{i40 yYtSP"+ A TX?"YV vtdT 9v? °I. t l.yi 'Y4 `ridr '".* 1Hm'?i ?4 ? ,m TES a., .p 4' +q 1 rMz, ['^[-k''?3: 11, , tti T' '' I Kr "jl4 4'Y,II .3 ,' r$P... A yy NEWS G yr r '`' dk.e+'f l Y tEM1'?y rv.: J??gg??yc6a? tte1l '?? {???4 1 Y $:'t" !?'ykMAYAr3 tj5.i AA 41+ ?.1 t !y?^`%!'Li §a ?k `?I'}'dY^\Rp 5- ?}h,"'?VJy.?tt 3 '' ri'`?. ? ianltn?.ku??i`jt3"h-tps'?e"' - ?¢ wyu2fy ,T "y"'s,r.,2' S<.^4 't'' yrstq?, rlr; d"`i`T "'s}'aSYYPte+U tr k' g 7"0 r'f"V"?''?4?M 't^g} tx `hdT {4.C' }.` jr'v NA" y?'tlt p'r?7TV sji FSNUNN Irt ,fir +cr? .; Y-4 w r '4? kJ Y t 4P i? "d#5'f V?' v,.r ' 9 - 2 a? ?FV(ds'p?y r IM I??r !5n}?Ty?Y )V?*,?f-1R'W £Eryf ydkrpa"Yyyl,,i f^ Q? ? .. .. tY . 1 a . J Total Sublet 0.00 Deductible 0.00 Total } 0 6 i:.yaR'Y'xy?-" a ?ezt ,ry'cvty t?P #-!,? T rt, s.r x?5-m`gr i^ikpt,. .'as a??l{"m?d3V a{F.S' x `f tnPY'v;Y :T "15C akR y 71-0m0 A., I=:'F }j T'???k iYl Gnty q Y t >?.li Qe t Ri.lcd - dr Rho k? } '!? _Tb 1 R ,fNI} F" II 6E}' ! IV ?`Y SpT>Jf fl 1. vy?luais#}1t,? 'fir + fi",WID'?4S'p u?aYi tx rr''? gge, 0, N1? ..+ w) +?'.s h, Lwe i ri M' 9 ?A' 2 fr 1 a 4 r r? r9 7K?k'?` 1icf. h r?t?r r p I3 }d r I !'# f Yn1 n J d r' Art;r nVF w £^n h y t? f ?A l? 6>?P+a'?"n f?"d F 4 dN 4+ 1 i!/y m"1 A q 6fVr^ v r'` ? ? M ? ? ? i _ 5 ji-'i'}.. "'{ tC rA W `,J' a F °.F r1lfr ?i? y ?il b l w,u? S{I hT .IY us r °. Vv p y IT„„>?4r„P'a'' k `P Nn'4 =yr to 'k ,+°."A^ ayJe „---- AP {'Yr .R` h F,?94'cYn t.a4v ;. , " A : xa . xn EXIEI'DEGWMRPMYPBY FACTOM WARRANTY PAY ALL LABOR CHARGES ARE IALLLiI ON RLXT RATE FlNAL ESTIMATE TOTAL Cu TOMER PAY HOURS UNIE6.4 OTHE?NOTED 39.76 Customer Signature X FORM SOLUTIONS, INC. 18881 343-BOOB HM 3980 6/99 !as-hier 3 09 5 7USTGMER COPY f .L).,97OX 120 BeaverSpi,ngs, PA 17812 (570) 658-0100 CUSTOMER COPY CUSTOMER NO. LICENSE# STOCK# DEALER: INVOICE DATE INVOICE9 14161 3299 68512 04/19/2004 033155 CUSTOMER NAIVE &ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT LOT#/HAT# COLOR DELIVERY DATE GARY/BETH NEUBAUM 10416M 10416M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O, DATE 610 W SHADY IN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L 04/19/2004 04/19/2004 - _ VEHICLE ID # TECH & # _. 7 o* ENOLA PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. IM. EST. 6874 EXTENDED WARRANTY CO. POLICY # DEDUCTIBLE AUTHORIZATION # ADJUSTOR NONE 0.00 RESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY SIGNATURE f k "? . tad A Yi "I?:??' A i?Tw s + t - r c ^. 'T 3wf g aY Y Net 4 ??t'tt§x i ?u a P9?L .?Irh9RY'$ a ' e.C '.? ?'E n r "4 A Ivy I TR'?- ^ ' r ' F r R ? " }$' ? i qY ? ??e? m i T r u ix a ?r+ ?T y 5 1tEF,. Yp 'tk°+ . G S 4 Suy N } e k ' ? '? ? 1 ? ????T .b x"+ .FlTi"` rt ,: 556 c e a ,a 4 1, n s a .?An A X.X WCDRO CUSTOMER STATES REAR DEFROSTER DOESN'T WORK 6745W _ Mq, •q? A TYq S pF ° ! M }r 'SB.° V1 '? `i? I4"v( 4 L4 PY S f 1 1 yY#?j T 14A..?. iFi•' h ^l 1?. .. gPl? a .k) Tr 14 ?i' P.Y ?I! ?iry? 4..' , I aM k a w 4 ? 3& ?' LY?I4D?'? a•t :? t ? P y# , ''? •MM.?, `, t 3 ?Z 4 "'' f t i! ?Y a S? S K.EA r ?s7'. i4_ Y ?RF` 17.1 ? rf,?, ".nlxtr.??,?7"i"'?=a?'.. ?..d'L?.....s.???e?,tt?_..?,}:"?'???9??#`U6??r`}?..?k????}a ?..,_ n? y ?' e Sy 1 Y ",}r, ?:??. w a ,?:.?».?S 'v?a' ?53 au fr'i ? , ? _ - .._ . .r_.. .. . B ?X.X WCDRO CUSTOMER STATES DRIVERS DOOR MAKES NOISE WHEN OPENING NC HAD TO ORDER DRIVERS SIDE DOOR CHECK x" fia rry k? ?,. rrvm^ cP- ?.y';?°"# m .I x r '? P _ Vva? w T?Lae ; z aw ? K ?xN. % 4?f - n A vv a{# 3 ti "x ?3 r?J s'"! s?Y, 017 4,11-1 + ' ` . r 1 :..,q`x? + ? w A Sr 1 rkW.... l .-... ?'ak i, a v N HAD CODE FOR PASSENGER SIDE TERMINAL OPEN, CHECKED CONNECTOR UNDER SEAT AND MADE SURE TERMINALS WERE TIGHT, CLEARED CODES AND ROAD TESTED CODE DID NOT RESET w"°mcs A.. sY.n< '$ ° '" i. k?p> e'lz .'.M Will! f aF4C/ "?a } n>r[•F e 4 S4 y"4 ?y mft?il?L,? ry. F y{{yam m'kC'? ?,i i Y t33.:?59°hpkN $k. Y°`S4 N3 w q £.AJ)?+'S ?TCjR?%2 xdyd5'.'bhYd ?"YI I117.,'?fY'.C``?iF {1yj *F?? ,y4yY??'4,St?sf Kj?' Il .r"!d WC<•. I??.yy?{??FL?Ti Y?1,. `x?m??"f f fi i" 1 3.yPNe ACy F".f. S 3 { ilkg ? Nll w e '' i ` ?? W S u y I 1 P P, % IV2': a $ ' L fe { , 4 ? 1 . Y a' N?YInli?'?.Ffy? a. r ,1 Mrf#}?(? iY w g ? Ed= p ran` ?'dtl?.?? ?y} . h ?Y'S"' ? a' I? r[n u4 ! % i i *T I,. . ?Gr .r=.kJ ? •. f f s t Y # . ?'y xptw vra? 1s t u4?u „?'rf4:i t ' ' ? 4L??? „?.< . . .w.,,. .r 3....,.w ....,ss ... ..,. . ??....H ? E'?,r;{.MM4 }?&h??-yA1 iF?C.y?I N°y,,???'?Yfi?rc+S?3 ?` ?:¢?n:IC4y't?'`?'Sh -I S Jfl 2''Y"rM?4"h L }F''?1x9 . p? Ly,+l?.S?`zg; k;:iV y'4i" I E 7 F J, 01110 m[r ne ''u ?RE 'd i'le "xk$Ni$T:%Y '4+ ll , o. . . _ . igg- p ! 1 '? C TL? ; „j? h Wg t!' yr-'4T>' ?' F 1 f M JA w ? J L tl1 ?jyla"$ A*p . Il A ' `hN Ia , { 4?i k ' `' `' r -..+ ? . , -Total Sublet 0.00 Total Deductible 0.00 Total Misc. 0.00 n Y'',y d 4L 'ia'"?'r ???ryryrtu''pkGeA'?Wa? f "?1rTt +ar< 3 I ?yy? r wT?Sf"T-nA'^{, syr ?a r :k" ^r? I Ei '.yi•IFya iES5 'S... ^by i, . Sw41 ' r " ? , 1pg '?rl it Y v9' ° ''?"GF"?e"r'R?m T+ Vn pl £t"i, ,,tM7 5uW` m'1 d' YI+, ? Cy 1 rt r u ? ?; t ' k' E r «,I' ' N , , ., ft rv t' W 1 SKiENOED WARRANTYPAY FACTORYWARRANIYPAY Al LIBOR CHARGES ARE BILLED ON FLAT RATE FINALESTMATE TOTAL CIAfOMER PAY HOURS UNIESS OTHERWISE NOTED 0.00 Customer Signature X FORM SOLUTIONS, INC. ISB91 343-6896 HM 3938 6/99 :a shier ;? 3 09 a L27 'USTOMER COPY Beaver Springs, PA 17612 (570).658-0100 CUSTOMER COPY CUSTOMER NO. LICENSE' STOCK # DEALER # INVOICE DATE INVOICE # 14161 3299 66512 05/19/2004 033522 'CUSTOMER NAME & ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT LOT #/HAT # COLOR DELIVERY DATE GARY/BETH NEUBAUM 11763M 11763M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 610 W SHADY LN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L 05/19/2004 05/19/2004 VEHICLE ID# TECH &# P.O.# ENOLA PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. IM. EST, 6874 EXTENDED WARRANTY CO. POUCY# DEDUCTIBLE AUIHORIZATION# ADJUSTOR NONE 0.00 RESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY SIGNATURE a N y a.?? Y < J 1I11AE 'Sm` ?J' I - u ! 'ii ;??' 'WIW . :? Vi}JA[rCC ?. Tf ?2LrY 0.' ? M IP - - a : 1 uI".rv ., rY n . .:bC Rb$ :. va J L ;?K?.uf' >eJ aiCrv-y?.w v 0 01101 6!, .. pica y?.v.. ,. .v cVti .. 'le. to . [ ?I?. a tt Vn;I :hT?v,:y3M°Y. i?t'Lku, hi'#9 mJ 'p °31;3 n F`i A X.X WCDRO CUSTOMER STATES DRIVERS DOOR IS NOISEY WHEN OPENING ' 4350 W 'y? !! b i ??q tai H, JL` I' .'r I Y F"? f"('?I? I°y J?v R D V ? -. ^ " !l?A,?[ {D $ ---- M f ,%.\a( F !` T µr4 pWJ { T?MSe'1 Lry F}t i l'i p?J i 5"T. FES3l?.'.5}Y M a"i sGlr A'e15 J^ fS''%f}n"Y"?u ". 'Ad#YAM'('"'^Y"+?+•L5b% I ?k f'Yfi-A IFlM`.fix J^}?LL+L '?i'tl5 Yi 'i }4 vo-Ser'ld '? ? 3 1 V ( ? ? ? '. A g .' Y -rs L, f4.k1 ti .r.?h-F'IY r i .yv, A.Yy,,,X C+'F'A r+ 13 ^HE fie h $ L?kk I h .AA AI +? - `M^.. `?3 e!.?}1nJ ikkdfi( f'4 i"yi f*?.i §.'M,n14'C? Pt Y u:i!^r LYt: ?I}?,R6k k! } tl5. ?y t 91 Y-s4'? Eilr#y.^y 1 J4'h La S '?w tl'V'??J l1bi? a+ly ' .° #}' I 1 g? q: J 4 m r Af 4? ?' r i! t1U 4r I ?F ? ) DEFROSTER IS INOP. AT THE BOTTOM B X.X WCDRO CUSTOMER STATES REAR -_4350W----- .. OT HAVE CONTINUITY AT LOWER HALF, NC GRID DID N j j `( i}:9 '.CT f"Y1. -?Ni 3?u? %£ i v1° t F iii f{':sn ?r,( Kr 4' 4*?'1 4A'5?11 -yT SR ;A ry? T 14 rP tl} ? "H ? V J - Ye ,v . 410' 1"N,C, .B"? §, A , a,d???ir.s" ' d G? LY° ' . ?k:f'!_'?` + 5. 4a . n '. 7 6 Y M q h ?TJ9 ?Prc']T f+Y}..? 4L1'.r " I-?j?," 1? 'l k??' TFV M "k-?'[ 31?r IR t CROW a k, i t1 ysx M R E t- U.`'' °5 i I '`Y+ n '' £ F ?'a € 4 T I vr"':L` , i ? y FNV Fa 'f'"'iE11 Rag' ?, .if TN4F '€ ^'G?,RL,*?lT41Y6 "W. Is y, L .?F By & !?%»t.F{??iR 9? a?kr95? y? 3+?°? 2b"^M=•,µ?? }K`T ',,??'r„l fdATrTF?M. X^ro I$ 3@ Au /x Y ?f ]{P d?ln'a' }f" dl i,u F ??k 5 M1T ` i YL 3i Jlw µ. Gf KAW h ?"Y' ?i. YP ' ? ' F pp T'k. , rPjj t? L3°' d T b'"nit a, h}yI r V$ ????W@sr? u A7"ISat RIO 31 ?V Fi ,? a y? s EPA f rJ a "' ' S : Y '" i TI` T" ° ag-pgt •' g ; h gYl s , J. ' .J", !¢ k wf: -e r ". 3.. as rr , , `a+i IS Ha- ' yrSVd4"r'".5'+ ,dFC-?'I L`, L'uh '4 #" 6[f Ta,'n `r"'J'rsr n s 'I- 'hYJ t a "h' L.,7 a '£' rz s d r i 4 t_wa Yr14 r PTT O .a-nx 77 y ti r 'aarsike4 SK aA ?5 E R4 sA 'ls. 'k9'd''G.t G14 m?al',?Jds.YL. y1? ° Ldx y gg ??t^'f ,x?' a >{` I ' J k'?"'`'` v 4'nr w^5?c '.. i' u t / Y ry??,M' o JV„ - _ . 'X?}?JprY( ???y?r tE TYm? TSr P 4j J'11?5"Ip,A`Y .: N 4 .{}. "E 4 ?I},?AJ}T ,YTS 3'Slntt'?"4 !.,?` WJ I3 S`pk° y "?T3P4StIR: }W ? fl' B ? ?F'4 .0.`.JF 14 ?.?'nV??,g;t?a14??."h*al hd?IS $?d ?, a.?;J`?? MIF M.i ? Itii?r- "`F.? Jf ?-*E ?"? *??d$1i1.€ ?#i`"FIY?£??Y??T??Y{'J ? , ?H y y y , . dY t a v ? I - k s^{4a'µ J k k?il f h ?,"f ?3 h V 4 '? S Y : 'V a ) ?+ , r , . ,3. , q . • n E ,• ..? : ;-? 4''?9 i# SPY AS^,('?,ryr^tafilf.'?'rY/ l"T?^"i'rl?piM1K EiJf??a ?4 hY:ixlc`nk LiF 4"BY F.PT?jb xSiy'rv Jliu`^'u-sa.?'tn ^??'S"i C' '4#, ?ayR :, SPIRY; T 1TL § Jg V4g d f'P 1 1' r R 4 ri1}eE N'J?' rF^r. 1 Lldf 4. ?I V11 eiY b I ; P11 1 j?4?yJ 6 44 A? I e Ski ,#I'F@1`_ 4 A9J`n.Yyy?' S „W, YJ S' 44{'F tVl ? } y A{I ( t L a e ? 1 r j 1 ' ? t ? J . , p , 1, ., 3 A e . a )? n + N k ?'{j a f ? M1f tA? 'y rF? A,.,rvrvk,r,. ryTyty,?'d ,??4 NJ ?" 4??1 IK',Z 'y'?' 1??4 *W",???Wy ey?JN (t l{ 9iy1CUy.Y Z 0?J?4 Y ? tlYk' J. I x ? ?Fl??i t 1? ? Zin r ? ? ? ? 1 ? ab ? u... tn Y -? 't.?&'..ra ,3.0 3n5. 14 P„bs,. FJ k.''] ? T Y'?OnFa? ?`YL?r ,. ?I L l ?4? Tr" le l Total 5 V Total Deductible 0.00 Total Misc. 0.00 si...'7"„ 9 "'•`E J arT rT..br a 1 fI L k ?{, rru..4#s?t tart,r? 4N I"kW "'T'N , r f z gay f 4 a DR ?1 a .atx { v <' t' I I" It E 5tl rt ?t V? g YY' ? y ,G is J ! JNN t . t 5. ITV S.P fl f,ry9 A(! yI Ps J f ?" , T i R`PtJMLC I'C N b Y iiV L.J iy.(`P (nE'PY 1 tl y3^A? 1., YI yy J F y{ 'T" pA p '?"? r S? r , ? 9 ? P a t+}?' r" T ?, v ?a? ?i I w G bA't h rz I {'? ? 5 ? ? ? J v t L p?? ( . ? ir7 I t '1 'If. 4} 14^Y',y'1 iL d?'r41 k 1 4 A h`,4W 1 ` t RA ??A{I?!I ow, Y? e ,;???bJi+W r?s. K? ?aJfru+Sl MVA'IP9'NN pWt?.d.ukJkK xr r'L} ?'A'.. rl"Y?i5 [?'L{., 't4°r.i ,P S` V+"' b,. 0 JY rF 1?S4JT '3jd1fG l,t?l ? P V'jk r 4 f? ) h WENq WMRAWPAY FACTORY WARRANTY PAY ALL LABOR CHARGES ARE Bh1ID ONFIAT FAZE gNAIESTIMATE TOTAL CUSTOMER PAY HOURS UNLESS 07HERM9E NOTH) 0.00 Customer Signature X FORM SOLUTIONS, INC. 18881 343-SOBS HM 3989 6/99 ,srier'a 3 10 Y? 2 2EPRINT # 1 :-USTPMER COPY r. L"', tiox 7Yti Beaver Springs, PA 17812 (570) 658-0100 CUSTOMER COPY CUSTOMER NO. - - LICENSE# S70CK# - DEALER# INVOICE DATE INVOICE# ' 14161 3.2 68512 06/21:/2004 034850 CUSTOMER NAME & ADDRESS .. MILEAGE IN MILEAGEOUi LOT#/HAT# COLOR DELIVER -DATE GARY/SETH NEUBAUM 14327M 14327M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 610 W SHADY LN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L 08/21/2004 08/21/2004 VEHICLE ID # TECH & # P,O. # ENOLA PA 1702.5 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W, INT. EST, 0925 EXTENDED WARRANTY CO. POLICY # DEDUCTIRLE AUTHORQAPON # ADJUSTOR NONE '0.00 RESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE - SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY SIGNATURE ^ - Ogg g? '4 ti4 kW5 d? 4 Yd 5' .d Y d h'k M+, rail' F? ykvL, € r ,p7 z,*4+reLfr? j ?rc aEk..+'+?u?.# ?? '? ,;y -vTl T?+1PCti S'T?Vf^'..:t.r r '? r ?,s »T``i^h43"" a. `.»LT"n gin ru`c?r r'^?a,tamEM1dl rvd"t ``r+?J ?T.'E?? m. 9fri'L "d'U9 ??" r ?I?Adc?a . ,k a"+!T• My,'?4;s..v,-... ,4. Y,. trff ,./AT':4PNkdAI?IM, C,FkA14?.a:} v . ?S`fx?{}?.M- d'.kMf.N1MR69rw 4... r,..i .,tr yF eR4`'",r ?.e +Y; piA?YOCJAP?IfMtl'G ,y:.r .for., k.,e'HLS xY,x-?. 4,')1vµ o-Y ..rv CPDRO LUBE OIL FILTER 01 ?wlul utlf Signature X 'ORM SOLUPONS, INC. (BOB) 3636006 iM 39BO 6/06 COULD NOT INSPECT AT THIS TIME Job- A Total Parts -&--Labor - Sales'.Tax Job A Tntal PA r1-c .G T.vIhnr Total Deductible Tnt,vl Miar. 3ARY NEUBAUM 310 W SHADY LN 2-40LA, PA 17025 TOME:732-5047 "=IMI=IVIVCIVI 7325047 6 4 0 0 8 ANUY OF DEALERSHWS *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike CHRYSLER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep. ® (717) 766-7686 PAGE 1 Web Site: www.brennerchrysierjeep.com BUS:772-6254 .E-mail: brennercj@earthlink.net SERVICE ADVISOR: 167 ROGER PARKER S: DLR:68512 ENG:2.7 Liter 1 OUT AUS: INTERS DEFECT 08191601 MODULE, SENTRY KEY 166 WC4 FC: 58 PART: SI07054AA COUNT: 1 CTTM TYPE; W AUTH CODE: „ - PARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE A: 0.00 7236 ******** VERIFIED CAR WON'T START DRB TESTED FOUND CODE PRESSENT Et7R NO SKIM:' MESSA43E5 RE:IEUED PERFORMS D DI00 fl3TICiTEST CEiECKED FOR POWER AND GROUND AT SKIM MODULE HAD BOTH CHECKED BUS CIRRCUIT BUS PROGRAMMED VERIFIED CA R STARTS AND RUNS FINE AT THIS TIME RAOD TESTE D The factory warranty constitutes all of the warranties with to LABOR AMOUNT . Me sale of this s diem.ems. The Seller hereby expressly sly disclaims all PARTS AMOUNT warranties, either express or an i includin im ad GAS, OIL, LUSE - y g ,warranty of merchantability ty or or SUBLET AMOUN' CHRYSLER Jeep fitness to a Particular compels. Seller neither assn assumes nor nor MISC. CHARGES authoress any other person assume for it any liability in m TOTAL CHARGE connection with the sale of this kem0tems. LESS INSURANC SALES TAX CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY 7325047 6 4 0 0 8 A11IILY OF DEALERSftlPS *INVOICE* 6039 Carlisle Pike 4ARY NEUBAUM CHRYSLER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep, ?10 W SHADY IN (717) 766-7686 VIOLA, PA 17025 PAGE 2 Web Site: www.brennerchrysierjeep.com [OME:732-5047 BUS:772-6254 E-mail:brennercj@earthlink.net 'FT.T.-17')-area SERVICE ADVISOR: 167 ROGER PARKER ENG:2.7 Liter MPI ?ARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE B. 0.00 7236****** VERIFIED PASS SIDE FRT WINDOW WILL SHAKE WHILE RASSING AND rIGHTEND NUT TO PROPER TORQUED VERIFEID GLASS GOES UP AND DOWN SMOTH IOW 'TECH95 'VEi?SFTED RTaPAI ,. 3516 GLASS. HEATED WINDOW-Test and 1 5093179AA CLIP PART#: 5093179AA COO CLAIM TYPE: W AtS iv: cob (?STS: 0-0D FOR: i; Qi ON p 3EP„ O.LI I "TGTAI IINE'7D. D-i?'0 723 6 1; * * * * *+ ?7ER ET D REAR D 13Z S 1 17'N ?FTEC,I?ED ? p?2 SOW R A x DEFROSTER FOUND WIRE CONNECTOR BROOKEN LOOSE FROM REAR WINDOW CHECKED 31 'i7ATLSNE FOR PtST$L E:$T2EPT12R TLI S ''POUNT3 AtPATRS IC T SC?TD RED 7t^7Q factory warranty constitutes ell of the warranties with res raspem to LABOR AMOUNT the 'sale of this itemAtems. The Seiler hereby expressly disclaims all PARTS AMOUNT waned Including ehher express or any impilrd Implied GAS, OIL, LUBE , , me or fm of merchantability or SUBLET AMOUNT CHRYSLER Jeep aes f purpose. Solar for a a ... mes nor or ssu neither a pa Seller MISC. CHARGES any authorizes any other person to assume for It any liability in TOTAL CHARGES csnneotlon with the sale of this Item/hems. LESS INSURANCE SALES TAY, CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY ,,. .a "=IMIS =INN INN GIV5 ;. 7325047 6 4 0 0 8 vAMILY OF DEALS iSWS *INVOICE* ? 6039 Carlisle Pike Z NEUBAL]M q{MSIEg Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep, 10 W SHADY IN (717) 766-7686 NOLA, PA 17025 PAGE 3 Web Site: www.brennerchrysierjeep.com iOME:732-5047 BUS' 772-6254 E-mail: brennercj@eerthlink.net DLR 7 Liter MPI ** 4'OSTOMEFL STATES i?7HIL? DRI37II?lG,FRT EL?7D ?.r''EL5 R(]IIGIi NRM NO REPAIRS MADE 3 66 0 01 PARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE E: 0.00 723.6 ******* ROAD TESTED CAR WITH SHOP FOREMAN CAR SEEMS TO BE DRIVING PO SHOW HIM CONCERN '?r**.ar dt 9;*iz?'at it*sFak'Yz-fr?N: ?k lr+kky: !r'.t*ft•#:?!E'Hr sr is*tA'v;A'4t**,?le;>; 9bfz**«c....... ' <i .. .:. aZ" INDICATES NON-FACTORY PART. The tamory warranty constitutes respect all of the e .. warren5es wim th respect to ............... .............. LABOR AMOUNT the sale of this ItemAtems. The disclaims all Seller hereb ex ressl PARTS AMOUNT ® p y y warranties, either express or I im li d d GAS, OIL, LURE n any p e implie , warranty of f merchantability SUBLET AMOUNT CHRYSLER Jeep . fitness for a particular purpose. Seller neither assumes no: MISC. CHARGES authorizes any xher person to assume far If any liability in TOTAL CHARGES connexion with the sale of this hemftems LESS INSURANCE . SALES TAX CUSTOMEfl SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY +. 1. 7325047 3ARY NEUBAUM 510 W SHADY IN -NOLA, PA 17025 30ME:732-5047 BUS:772-6254 f:;RF.I TIME" 65591 IFti ILYOFD' RSUff"IS *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike CHRYSIER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep (717) 766-7686 PAGE 1 Web Site: www.brennerchrysterleep.com E-mail: brennercj@earthhnk.net SERVICE ADVISOR: 167 ROGER PARKER 16: ONS: DLR:68512 ENG:2.7 WHEN COLD 8577 ********* V FtIFIE1J.D UEi?;S Y3E 0ASH"Sov, CtAC NO;INSPEC EJ SPEAKER INTERNAIL SHORT IN SPEAKER ORDERED NEW SPEAKER *?*F.*+k :catxt St.* ; *+***:t-*?t<x #y: et*at*#*** 3 CUSTOMER STATES THERE IS A FLUID LEAK FROM THE ENGINE AREA, CLEARISH ZOQK-I "FIi JSD 2RUSE: LEAK 166 WC4 FC: 71 pATZT#:' SD15646AC COUNT: 1 PARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE B: 0.00 ********** VERIFIED FLUID LEAK -BEAKS FOUND AT THIS TIME tt**-ir*,t4ic*h?*#sk*hac*-it;r:#*ac**3r:sEi:+kis**hk.SNMr*ksy'*'5C ie3r+lr3r+r 01 M CUSTOMER STATES THE CAR SEEMS TO RIDE ROUGH IN THE FRONT The factory constitutes all of the war warranties with th es respect to ................................ LABOR AMOUNT the sale of this expressly ternfitems. The Seller hereby disclaims e PARTS AMOUNT ® warranties, either express or implied inclutl an Implied s including GAS, OIL, LUBE , warrant y warranty of merchantability or fi f SUBLET AMOUN' CHRYSLER Jeep tness or d particular purpose. Seller nelnmes nor assu MISC. CHARGES authorizes any y other parson to assume for it any liability in TOTAL CHARGE connection with the sale of this item/items. LESS INSURANCI SALES TAX CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY 3ARY NEUBAUM 510 W SHADY LET BOLA, PA 17025 30ME:732-5047 7325047 BUS:772-6254 6 5 5 9 1 *INVOICE* PAGE 2 x{)"MY OF DFAU SWS ® 6039 Carlisle Pike CHRYSLER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep, (717) 766-7686 Web Site: www.brennerchryslerleep.com E-mail: brennercj@earthlink.net GENBAN HUH DLR:68512 2.7 Liter MPI km'i The factory warranty constitutes ell -"--"'" LABOR AMOUNT of the warranties with respect to the sale of this hernifterns. The PARTS AMOUNT Seller hereby expressly disclaims ell ® warranties, either express s or including any implied implied , LUSE GAS, OIL, LUBE , warranty of merchantability or f fi ti l SUBLET AMOUNT CHRYSLER Jeep tness or a Par cu ar purpose. Seller neither assumes nor MISC. CHARGES authorizes any other person to assume for it any liability In TOTAL CHARGES connection with the sale of this LESS INSURANCE hem/hems. SALES TAX CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY I IVillCIVIVCII 7325047 6 6 1 5 7 j LY OF D ,ERSMPS *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike ;ARY NEUBAUM CHOLER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep, i10 W SHADY LN ® (717) 766-7686 NOLA, PA 17025 PAGE 3 Web Site: www.brennerchrysieriesp.com iOME:732-5047 BUS:772-6254 E-mail:brennerci@eerthiink.net CON 11C3EL65R13N526172 :68512 ENG:2.7 Liter 1 The factory warranty consttwtes all of the wenanties with reapers to LABOR AMOUNT the sale this. itemxs The Sailer hereby expressly disclaims all PARTS AMOUNT warranties, afther express s or r including tlinp an implied implied GAS, OIL, LURE , y warranty of mer y or fit f i l SUBLET AMOUN" CHRYSLER Jeep ness or a partass pose. part cu ar Purpose. Seller neither sesames s nor MISC. CHARGES - authorizes any other person to assume for it any liability in TOTAL CHARGE: connection n with the sale o of this kemltema . LESS INSURANCI SALES TAX CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY " 7325047 6 6 1 5 7 FA Iff OF DFAU St"S .u *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike ARY NEUBAUM CHRYSLER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 jeep. 10 W SHADY LN 17 1 71 766-7686 NOLA, PA 17025 PAGE 1 Web She: www.brannerchrysierieep.com OME:732-5047 BUS:772-6254 E-mail:brennercj@earthlink.net ELL:372-9588 SERVICE ADVISOR: 167 ROGER PARKER 9382 05 1 1 0.00 1 CAS DLR:68512 ENG:2.7 Liter MPI CARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE A: 0.00 3382 ********* VERIFIED CEL ON DRB TESTED FOUND CODE PRESSENT FOR T EUAP,L A7C Pt1456. G£ B77a C;?S S TRSP PR SSENI. R992T3 T S C1AR ?ASSED TEST NO LEAKS PRESSENT AT THIS TIME yk#+yk#*vF9c*4de?1:***yk 9eHk ai`#**?^7ek;*dr*d-******#&at b, V* A, .. 3 CUSTOMER STTAES NOISE FROM SPEAKER INSTALLS-0 PARTS 08607003 SPEAKER, SOUND SYSTEM-Test 166 WC4 FC: 18 PA{tT#.' SC1603§! COUNT: 1 08600270 RADIO FC: C I X: PARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE B: 0-00 19382 ****** The factory warranty constitutes all of the warranties with respect to LA BOR AMOUNT the sale of this Item/hem.. The Seller hereby expressly disclaims all PARTS AMOUNT warranties, anther express or Implied Including any Implied GAS, OIL, LUBE , warranty r ness for merchantability or rticul r for a SUBLET AMOUNI CHRYSLER Jeep a pa pose. Seller neither assupu assumes no, S.R.r nor MISC. CHARGES authorizes any other parson to assume for it any lability in TOTAL CHARGE: connection with the sale of this item/items. LESS INSURANCE SALES TAX - CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY •. ,. 1?.1`1G1V?VG?? 7325047 ''6 6 1 5 7 FA , LY OF DEALERSMPS *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike i.ARY NEUBAUM CHRYSIER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep, ;10 W SHADY IN (717) 766-7686 !NOLA, PA 17025 PAGE 2 web Site: www.brennerchrysierjeep.com IOME:732-5047 BUS:772-6254 E-mail:brennercj@eerthlink.net 17T.T..'t'7)-asRA SERVICE ADVISOR: 167 ROGER PARKER 6 2 rIME :68512 ENG:2.7 Liter MPI CUSTOMER STTAES FRT PASS WINDOW WILL NOT GO DOWN AUTO MATICLLY ALL THE krAY WHEN .I"UT"I INO'O I?£T, NRM NO REPAIRS MADE 00 LABOR: 19382 ******** COULD TIME **************************************************** 02F FULL 1 528 19382 ******* COMPLETED LOF 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 16.20 OTHER: 0.00 6.70 0. .70 33. E CUSTOMER STATES THERE IS STILL A FLUID LEAK FROM THE ENGINE, SEEMS 1 5010042AA *DYES-LEAK - DIE IN TRANS BLACK LIGHT CHRYSLER Jeep. The factory warranty constitutes all of the warrentles with respect to the sale of this hem/Items. The Seller hereby expressly disclaims all warranties, either express or Implied, Including any Implied warranty of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. Seller neither assumes nor authorizes any other person to assume for It any liability in .nnection with the sale of this itemhtems. REPLACED I PARTS AMOUNT I LESS INSURANC SALES TAX PLEASE PAY THISAMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY 14 'UWRY OF OFAURSW -S 6039 Carlisle Pike • cHxvs?rt Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 J"P• (7.17) 766-7686 Web Site: www.brannerchrysierjeep.co m E-mail: brennercj@earthlink.net AMOUNT PAID BY 35.35 CHECK GARY NEUBAUM 0'10 W SHADY LN ENOLA 7325047 COMMENT 66157 154029 TOTAL RECEIVED: $35.35 DATE-TIME: 14APR2005 18:13 PA 17025 CASHIER: STEPH LOCATION: CASH DRAWER: ACCOUNTING DISTRIBUTION CO JOURNAL CO ACCOUNT AMOUNT CONTROL 2 56 2 11700 35.35 66157 2 10400 -35.35 66157 i N CONTROL2 NEUBAUM NEUBAUM CUSTOMER COPY I DAVID J. GORBERG & ASSOCIATES, P.C. By: DAVID J. GORBERG Identification No. 53084 Suite 2040 1234 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19107 (215) 563-7210 R. WEISS w ::ry GARY NEUBAUM vs. DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION O PROTHY Attorney for Plaintiff PR AUG 2 B 2005 r? rr :n zb c rn COURT OF COMMON PLEAS C- N cn - o JULY TERM, 2005 NO 3379 . C".) v: PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT'S NEW MATTER Plaintiff, Gary Neubaum, through his attorney, DAVID J. GORBERG, hereby responds to defendant's New Matter as follows: 48 - 59. Denied. The allegations contained in paragraphs 48 through 59, inclusive, of defendant's New Matter are conclusions of law to which no specific response is required under the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment in his favor and i DAVID J. G?RBERG, ESQ. Attorney for P intiff t VERIFICATION I, DAVID J. GORBERG, verify that I am the attorney for the Plaintiff and that the statements made in the attached ANSWER TO NEW MATTER is based on information furnished to counsel, which information has been gathered by counsel in the course of this lawsuit; and that the language of this pleading is that of counsel. Signer verifies that he has read the within pleading and that it is true and correct to the best of his knowledge, information and belief. This verification is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to DAVID J. DATE: August 23, 2005 CERTIFICATION OF SERVICE 1, DAVID J. GORBERG, ESQUIRE, do hereby certify that service of a true and correct copy of the within ANSWER TO NEW MATTER was made on August 23, 2005 all interested parties by Regular First Class Mail. J INTERESTED COUNSEL: James L. Johnson, Esquire MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & GOGGIN 1845 Walnut Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 PHILADELPHIA COURT OF COMMON PLEAS PETITION/MOTION COVER SHEET I ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: ANSI PONSEDATE: I DonotsendJudge courtesy copy of Petition/Motion/AnswerlResponse. I Status may be obtained online at hitp.Ilcourts.pliila.gov Neubaum VS. INDICATENATURE OFDOCUMENTFILED: Q Petition (Attach Rude to Show Cause) ? Motion ? Answer to Petition ? Response to Motion CONTROL NUMBER: Q7aIL?3 (RESPONDING PARTIES MUST INCL UDE THIS NUMBER ON ALL FILINGS) No. 3379 Name of Filing Party: F Gary Neubaum r BOO (Check one) I] Plaintiff ? Defendant sl (Check one) ? Movant v? Respondent Has ati6t%r petition/motion been decided in this case? ? Yes I] No Is anuthe 4tition/motion pending? ? Yes ? No If the answer to either question is' yes, You muse identify the judge(s): TYPE OF PETITION/MOTION (see list on reverse side) PETITION/MOTION CODE (see list on reverse side) Response to Petition to Tranfer Venue MTTFR ANSWER/RESPONSE FILED TO (Please insert the title of the corresponding pefitlon/motion to which you are responding): 1. CASE PROGRAM II. PARTIES (required for proof of service) Is this case in the (wuwer all questions): (Name, address and telephone number of all counsel of record and unrepresented parties. Attach a stamped addressed envelope for each A. COMMERCE PROGRAM attorney of record and unrepresented party.) Name of Judicial Team Leader: David J. GOrberg, Esquire Applicable Petition/Motion Deadline: David J. GOrberg & Associates, P.C. Has deadline been previously extended by the Court? ?Yes ?No 1234 Market Street, Suite 2040 B. DAY FORWARD/MAJOR JURY PROGRAM - Year Philadelphia, PA 19107 Name of Judicial Team Leader: (215) 563-7210 Applicable Pedtion/Motion Deadline: Has deadline been previously extended by the Court? James L. Johnson, Esquire ?Yes ?No Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin C. NON JURY PROGRAM 1845 Walnut Street, 21St Floor Date Listed: Philadelphia, PA 19103 D. ARBITRATION PROGRAM (215) 575-2801 Arbitration Date: 3/28/06 E ARBITRATION APPEAL PROGRAM Date Listed: F. OTHER PROGRAM: Date Listed: III. OTHER By filing this document and signing below, the moving party certifies that this motion, petition, answer or response along with all documents filed, will be served upon all counsel and unrepresented parties as required by rules of Court (see PA. R.C.P. 206.6, Note to 208.2(a), and 440). Furthermore, moving party verifies that the answers made herein are true and con' et an understands that sanctions may be imposed for inaccurate or incomplete answ rs. / ?y d 7 Kimberly Hoehing, Esq. 92973 (Anorney Sign uere/Uniepresenled Pat, y) ( me) (Print Name) (Attorney J.D. No.) The Petition, Mot nandAnswerorResponse,ifany, will beforwarded totheCourt after theAnswer/Response Date. No extension of the Answer/Response Date will be granted even if the parties so stipulate. Month Term, 2005 Year W-106113 Instructions for Completing Petition/Motion Cover Sheet A Petition/Motion Cover Sheet must be attached to all Petitions, Motions, Answers or Responses filed, except for Discovery Motions and Motions for Extraordinary Relief. Sanctions will be imposed if the Cover Sheet is inaccurately completed. Please Note the following: 1. ANSWER or RESPONSE DATE. The Motion Clerk shall enter the "Answer" or "Response" Date on the Cover Sheet. All Responses to Motions and Answers to Petitions must be filed with the Prothonotary and submitted to the Motion Clerk on or before the Response Date. Note: Summary Judgment Motions have a 30 day Response period. Except for those Motions identified in Phila.Civ.R. '208.3(a) and (b), all other Motions have a 20 day Response period. 2. ARGUMENT DATE. The Motion Clerk shall enter the Argument Date and location on the Cover Sheet, as appropriate. 3. CONTROL NUMBER. The Motion Clerk shall assign a Control Number to all Petitions and Motions. The Responding parties must enter this Control Number on the Cover Sheet accompanying their Answer or Response. 4. NATURE OF DOCUMENT FILED. The filing party must check whether the document being filed is a Petition (in which case a Rule to Show Cause Order must be attached), a Motion, an Answer to a Petition, or a Response to a Motion. The parties must indicate whether another Petition or Motion is outstanding or has been decided and, it so, must identify the Judge(s) to whom such prior Petitions or Motions had been assigned. 5. PETITION OR MOTION TYPES. The parties must utilize the following Petition or Motion Codes and Types (and the Motion Clerk is authorized to change a filing party's designation to reflect the correct Petition or Motion Code and Type): CODE MOTIONS MTSAL Motion for Additional Distribution of Sale Proceeds MTPHV Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice MTSVR Motion for Alternative Service MTAMJ Motion to Amend Judgment MTADD Motion to Amend Pleading MTGAL Motion to Appoint Guardian Ad Utem MTAPC Motion for Appointment of a Conservator MrMCF Motion for Approval and Distribution of Minor's Compromise MIWRD Motion for Approval & Distribution of Wrongful Death & Survival Action MrAPS Motion to Approve Transfer of Structured Settlement MTADH Motion for Assessment of Damages Hearings MTAMV Motion to Auction Motor Vehicles MTBIF Motion to Bifurcate MTCIA Motion to Gently order for interlocutory Appeal MTCNM Motion to Change Name MTCLC Motion for Class Action Certification MTCMP Motion to Compel Discovery MTCPS Motion to Compel Payment of Settlement MTCOM Motion to Complete Terms of Sheriff's Sale MrCST Motion to Confirm Settlement MTCNS Motion to Consolidate Actions MTCON Motion for Continuance MTCOR Motion for Coordination of Actions MTCRT Motion to Correct Record MTCNF Motion for Counsel Fees PTDOM Motion for Delay Damages MTDJT Motion to Demand Jury Trial DPROB Motion to Determine Preliminary Ob)actions MTDSC Motion to Discontinue Case MTDIS Motion to Dismiss for Forum Non Conveniens MTDCN Motion to Disqualify Counsel MTEMG Emergency Motion MTSTT Motion to Enforce Settlement MTSDG Motion for Entry of Default Judgment CODE MOTIONS MTJNP Motion for Entry of Judgment of Non Pros MTSUP Motion for Entry of Supersedeas MTEXP Motion for Expungsment of Record MTECT Motion for Extension of Time to file Certificate of Merit MTEXT Motion for Extension of Time to answer/ respond) PTEXR Motion for Extraordinary Relief MTNPr Motion to File Nunc Pro Tunc MTFUS Motion to File Under Seal FTFM V Motion to Fix Fair Market Value MTINT Motion for Interpleader MTINV Motion to Intervene MTIOP Motion to Invalidate Opt-Outs (Class Action cases) MTJAD Motion to Join Additional Defendant MTJPL Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings MTJUR Motion for Jury Out of Time MTUM Motion in Limine MTMJS Motion to Mark Judgment Satisfied MTMVR Motion to Obtain Motor Vehicle Records MTOPN Motion to Open/Strike Confessed Judgment MTSAR Motion for Partition MTPIC Motion for Payment into Court MTPRE Motion to Pay Rent into Escrow Account MTSYS Motion to Postpone Sheriff's Sale FMW Motion for Post Trial Relief MTPCD Motion for Pre-Complaint Discovery PRINJ Motion for Preliminary Injunction MTPPA Motion for Preliminary Settlement Approval (Class Action Cases) MTPDE Motion to Preserve Documents and Evidence MTIFP Motion to Proceed In Forma Pauperis MTPRO Motion for Protective Order MTQSH Motion to Quash MTRCS Motion for Reconsideration MTRPR Motion to Redeem Premises NITREF Motion to Release Escrow Funds MTOPT Motion to Remove Opt-Out of the Proposed Settlement Agreement (Class Action Cases) CODE MOTIONS MTRWT Motion to Return Writ of Possession or Execution NiTSAN Motion for Sanctions MT229 Motion for Sanctions for Failure to Deliver Settlement Funds MESAS Motion to Set Aside Sheriff's Sale MTSAA Motion to Set Aside Award MTIPP Motion to Settle IncompetenV Incapacitated Person's Estate MTSPR Motion to Stay Proceedings MTV40F Motion to Stay Writ of Execution MTSTK Motion to Strike Pleading MTSJD Motion for Summary Judgment (30 day hold) MTRAE Motion for Supplementary Relief In Aid of Execution MTRDM Motion to Reassess Damages MTREF Motion for Reimbursement of Fees MTREL Motion to Release Bond MTRCS Motion to Remove Case from Deferred Status MTSRC Motion to Seal Record MTSEV Motion to Sever Cases MTSPP Motion for Specific Performance NI Motion to Transfer MTTRJ Motion to Transfer Judgment MTFTV Motion for Title to Vehicle MPNDA Motion to Withdraw Appearance MTCPS Motion for Writ of Possession MTRRS Motion for Writ of Seizure MTMIS Miscellaneous Motion CODE PErMCNS FTARR Petition to Appoint Common Law Arbitrator FTARC Petition to Appoint a Receiver PTCAR Petition to Compel Arbitration PTCAW Petition to Confirm Arbitration Award PTCST Petition to Confirm Settlement PTCCT Petition for Contempt PTOJD Petition to Open Default Judgment PTSNP Petition to Open Judgment of Non Pros FTEMG Emergency Petition 6. CASE PROGRAM. The party shall check the program to which the case is assigned and provide the requested program data. '. PARTIES. The filing parties shall set forth the name, address and telephone number of all counsel of record and unrepresented parties, and must attach a stamped addressed envelope for each attorney of record and unrepresented party. 8. OTHER. The parties shall enter other relevant important information in this box - such as request for stay, emergency designation etc. - placing the Motion Clerk on notice of special handling or request. 9. SIGNATURE LINE. The Cover Sheet must be signed, dated and, if applicable, the attorney ID number must be provided. 10. SERVICE. A copy of the file-stamped Petition, Motion, Answer, Response and attachments must be served on all parties of record immediately after filing as required by Pa.R.C.P. 206.6, and Pa.R.C.P. 440. The Current Version of the Petition/Motion Cover Sheet May Be Downloaded From The First Judicial District's Website: hitp:f/courts.phila.gov. GARY NEUBAUM vs. COURT OF COMMON PLEAS JULY TERM, 2005 DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION : NO. 3379 ORDER AND NOW, this Day of 2005, upon consideration of Defendant DaimlerChrysler's Motion to Transfer Venue and Plaintiffs' response thereto, it is hereby ORDERED and DECREED that Defendant's Motion is DENIED. BY THE COURT: J. DAVID J. GORBERG & ASSOCIATES BY: Kimberly A. Hoehing, Esquire I.D. No: 92973 Kim@mylemon.com Suite 2040 1234 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19107 (215) 563-7210 Attorney for Plaintiff GARY NEUBAUM : COURT OF COMMON PLEAS VS. : JULY TERM, 2005 DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION : NO. 3379 PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO TRANSFER VENUE PURSUANT TO PA. R.C.P. 1006(d) Plaintiff, Gary Neubaum, by counsel, hereby respectfully request this Honorable Court to issue the attached Order denying Defendant DaimlerChrysler Corporation's Motion to Transfer Venue, and in response thereto, aver as follows: Admitted. By way of further answer, it should be noted that Defendant DaimlerChrysler Corporation filed an Answer and New Matter to Plaintiffs' Complaint but did not raise improper venue as a preliminary objection as required by Pa. R.C.P. 1006(e). Therefore, Defendant has waived its right to assert improper venue. Admitted. Denied. It is specifically denied that this case has absolutely no relationship to any activities, events or transactions which occurred in Philadelphia County. By way of further response, Defendant DaimlerChrysler Corporation has its registered office in Philadelphia County (in accordance with Pa. R.C.P. 2179(a)(1)), and Defendant regularly conducts business in Philadelphia County (in accordance with Pa. R.C.P. 2179(a)(2)). Furthermore, Defendant conducts business in Philadelphia County through its authorized dealerships in Philadelphia County. Therefore, there are facts connected to Philadelphia County, and all things considered, it is the most convenient county for all concerned. 4. Denied. This is a legal conclusion requiring no response. 5. Denied. This is a legal conclusion requiring no response. 6. Denied. It is specifically denied that the filing of this matter in Philadelphia County against the defendant has proven to be vexatious and oppressive. By way of further answer, Defendant has failed to demonstrate any facts which show that Plaintiffs' chosen forum is oppressive or vexatious to the defendant. Denied. The convenience of the witnesses would not be enhanced if this matter were transferred to Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, because Plaintiff will not, nor it is routine to, call any salesmen, or repairmen as witnesses in arbitration or at trial. Cases which are based on breach of warranty theories may be proven by the testimony of Plaintiff and the documented service history of the subject vehicle. 8. Denied as stated. This averment is denied insofar as it attempts to characterize allegations contained in Plaintiff's complaint, which speaks for itself. (See Plaintiff's complaint attached as Exhibit "A.") It is further denied that Plaintiffs' residence has any bearing on Defendant's Motion to Transfer. On the contrary, under Cheeseman v. Leathal Exterminator, 549 Pa. 200, 701 A.2d 156, 162 (1997) (emphasis added), "a petition to transfer should not be granted, unless the defendant meets its burden of demonstrating, with detailed information on the record, that the plaintiff s chosen forum is oppressive or vexatious to the defendant" 9. Denied as stated. This averment is denied insofar as it attempts to characterize allegations contained in Plaintiffs complaint, which speaks for itself. (See Plaintiff s complaint attached as Exhibit "A.") It is further denied that Plaintiffs' residence has any bearing on Defendant's Motion to Transfer. On the contrary, under Cheeseman v. Leathal Exterminator, 549 Pa. 200, 701 A.2d 156, 162 (1997) (emphasis added), "a petition to transfer should not be granted, unless the defendant meets its burden of demonstrating, with detailed information on the record, that the plaintiff s chosen forum is oppressive or vexatious to the defendant." 10. Admitted. By way of further answer, the fact that the vehicle was purchased in Beaver Motors, Pennsylvania has no bearing on the issue of venue. Plaintiffs will not, nor is it routine to, call any salesmen as witnesses in arbitration or at trial. 11. Admitted. By way of further answer, the fact that the vehicle was serviced in Snyder County has no bearing on the issue of venue. Plaintiff will not, nor is it routine to, call any servicemen or repairmen as witnesses in arbitration or at trial. All service records and repair orders are acquired via first class mail as per subpoena. 12. Denied. The fact that service of Plaintiffs' vehicle was performed in Snyder County has no bearing on the issue of venue. Plaintiffs will not, nor is it routine to call any service manager or service technician as witnesses in arbitration or at 1? trial. Furthermore, defendant failed to provide affidavits showing that requiring their attendance would be far removed from their place of employment and would burden these independent franchise dealerships, as required under Cheeseman v. Leathal Extenninator, 549 Pa. 200, 701 A.2d 156, 162 (1997). All invoices are acquired via first class mail. Further, Plaintiffs chose to litigate this action in Philadelphia County, which coincidentally is also the most convenient County to DaimlerChrysler Corporation. Defendant obviously filed this motion in an attempt to strip the Plaintiff of his right to chose venue. 13. Denied. All records, contracts, repair orders and technician's notes are also held by DaimlerChrysler Corporation. 14. Denied. DaimlerChrysler, the manufacturer sells vehicles to authorized dealers who are also agents of the manufacturer for warranty purposes. Furthermore, all records, contracts, repair orders and technician's notes are also held by DaimlerChrysler Corporation. Lastly, Plaintiffs will not, nor is it routine to, call any salesmen as witnesses in arbitration or at trial. 15. Denied. This is a legal conclusion requiring no response. By way of further response, Defendant has failed to demonstrate any facts which show that Plaintiffs' chosen forum is oppressive or vexatious to the defendant. Plaintiffs have agreed to travel to Philadelphia County and Defendant's counsel and all experts are in or near Philadelphia County and routinely litigate in Philadelphia County. 16. Denied. This is a legal conclusion requiring no response. By way of further response, Defendant has failed to demonstrate any facts which show that Plaintiffs' chosen forum is oppressive or vexatious to the defendant. Plaintiffs have agreed to travel to Philadelphia County and Defendant's counsel and all experts are in or near Philadelphia County and routinely litigate in Philadelphia County. 17. Denied. This is a legal conclusion requiring no response. By way of further response, Defendant has failed to demonstrate any facts which show that Plaintiffs' chosen forum is oppressive or vexatious to the defendant. Furthermore, the transfer of venue to Cumberland County would not provide easier access to all documentary and testimonial sources of proof. Plaintiff already has documentary proof or can obtain access to documentary proof by subpoena. Both counsels for Gary Neubaum and DaimlerChrysler Corporation, as well as their respective experts, are located and/or primarily practice in Philadelphia County in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Lastly, the cost to both Plaintiffs' and Defendant's counsels to pursue this case if transferred to Cumberland County would treble. 18. Denied. It is denied that trial of this matter in Philadelphia is inconvenient or burdensome to all of the key fact witnesses as well as the defendant in this matter and defendant did not provide affidavits stating same as required under Cheeseman v. Leathal Exterminator, 549 Pa. 200, 701 A.2d 156, 162 (1997). Again, Plaintiff will not, nor is it routine to, call any servicemen or repairmen as witnesses in arbitration or at trial. All service records and repair orders are acquired via first class mail as per subpoena. Furthermore, both counsels for Gary Neubaum and DaimlerChrysler Corporation, as well as their respective experts, are located and/or primarily practice in Philadelphia County in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Lastly, it is denied that filings in Philadelphia County has proven to be oppressive and vexatious. 19. Denied. It is denied that the arbitration and trial of this matter in Cumberland County would provide easier access to all the sources of proof both documentary and testimonial. By way of further answer, again, Plaintiff will not, nor is it routine to, call any servicemen or repairmen as witnesses in arbitration or at trial, All service records and repair orders are acquired via first class mail as per subpoena. Furthermore, both counsels for Gary Neubaum and DaimlerChrysler Corporation, as well as their respective experts, are located and/or primarily practice in Philadelphia County in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. 20. Denied. It is specifically denied that this matter has no contact with Philadelphia. Defendant DaimlerChrysler Corporation has its registered office in Philadelphia County (in accordance with Pa. R. Civ. Proc. 2179(a)(1)), and Defendant regularly conducts business in Philadelphia County (in accordance with Pa. R. Civ. Proc. 2179(a)(2)). By way of further response, Defendant conducts business in Philadelphia County through its authorized dealerships in Philadelphia County. Therefore, there are facts connected to Philadelphia County, and all things considered, it is the most convenient county for all concerned. Furthermore, Defendant has failed to demonstrate any facts which show that Plaintiffs' chosen forum is oppressive or vexatious to the defendant. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests this Honorable Court to enter the proposed Order denying Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation's Petition to Transfer Venue to Cumberland County. Respectfully Submitted, DAVID J. GORBERG & ASSOCIATES By: Kimberly A. Hoehing, Esquire Attorney for the Plaintiff Dated: September 14, 2005 DAVID J. GORBERG & ASSOCIATES BY: Kimberly A. Hoehing, Esquire I.D. No: 92973 Attorney for Plaintiff Kim@mylemon.com Suite 2040 1234 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19107 (215) 563-7210 GARY NEUBAUM VS. DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION COURT OF COMMON PLEAS JULY TERM, 2005 NO. 3379 MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS' OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT'S PETITION TO TRANSFER VENUE 1. MATTER BEFORE THE COURT Before this Court is Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendant's Motion to transfer venue. Plaintiffs request that this Honorable Court deny Defendant's Motion to Transfer Venue. 2. STATEMENT OF QUESTION INVOLVED Has Defendant met its burden under Cheeseman to prove with evidence in the record that Plaintiffs' chosen forum is oppressive and/or vexatious? Suggested Answer: No. 3. STATEMENT OF FACTS This is an action against defendant DaimlerChrysler Corporation for sale of a defective automobile. On or about March 31, 2003, Plaintiff purchased a 2003 Chrysler Seabring, purchased and registered in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. As a result of the defects, this vehicle cannot be utilized for the purposes intended by Plaintiff at the time of acquisition. (See Plaintiffs' Complaint, attached as Exhibit 'W ). Defendant's Motion to Transfer Venue to Cumberland County is essentially based on its claim that this case has no connection to Philadelphia. Moving Defendant completely fails to meet its burden of proof under the law of Pennsylvania. For the reasons set forth herein, Defendant's Motion must be denied, and this case should remain in Philadelphia County. Although the Pennsylvania Supreme Court has repeatedly stated that a plaintiff's choice of forum is given great weight and a defendant has a heavy burden in asserting a challenge to the plaintiff's choice of venue, Defendant has completely failed, in any way, to meet that burden. Cheeseman v. Lethal Exterminator, 549 Pa. 200, 701 A.2d 156 (1997). Specifically, Defendant has failed to meet its burden of showing that Plaintiffs' choice of forum is vexatious by establishing with detailed facts on the record that Plaintiffs' choice of forum was designed to harass Defendant, even at some inconvenience to Plaintiffs themselves. Secondly, Defendant has failed to meet its burden of establishing with detailed information on the record that trial in Philadelphia County would be oppressive. Defendant can point to no detailed information of record showing that Plaintiffs' choice of forum will be oppressive to it, in the sense of imposing an unreasonable burden. Defendant merely contends that a change of venue would be less inconvenient to the Plaintiff. Plaintiffs' convenience is not a consideration, under Cheeseman, and showing that Defendant will travel further to attend trial in Philadelphia does not constitute a showing of oppressiveness. More importantly, defendant failed to supply any affidavits listing the alleged counties of residence of alleged witnesses, and does not even allege that these witnesses will be oppressed by trial in Philadelphia. Moreover, Defendant fails to establish on the record what the anticipated content of these witnesses' testimony is or why their presence at trial is even needed, as it is required to do under Cheeseman, supra. Defendant attaches no affidavits or other record !I a evidence showing the alleged oppressiveness of Philadelphia to these alleged witnesses. Motions to Transfer Venue cannot be granted on the basis of geography alone. See Cheeseman, supra Defendant has failed to produce sufficient evidence to support transferring this case to Cumberland County. All Defendant has done, in essence, is repeat the tired refrain, explicitly rejected in Cheeseman, that this case has no connection to Philadelphia County. Defendant's claim is untrue, and was rejected by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court as a basis for transfer. Defendant has failed to make required averments; Defendant has failed to meet the burden set forth in its own motion; and because Defendant has failed to meet its heavy burden, its motion must be denied. 4. ARGUMENT A. Petitioner Has Not Met its Burden For A Motion To Transfer Under Pa. R.C.P. 2179(a)(2), a civil action may be brought against a corporation in any county where it regularly conducts business. Venue is proper in this forum under Pa. R.C.P. 2179(a)(2) and Pa. R.C.P. 1006©, and Moving Defendant does not challenge venue here as improper. Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1006(d)(1) provides: For the convenience of parties and witnesses the court upon petition of any party may transfer an action to the appropriate court of any other county where the action could originally have been brought. In deciding requests for transfer, Pennsylvania courts have historically consistently sought to insure that plaintiff's choice of forum was honored and not disturbed. In particular, it is well established in this Commonwealth that parties seeking a transfer must demonstrate compelling reasons which justify the requested transfer. As the Pennsylvania Supreme Court stated in Walker v. Ohio River Co., 416 Pa. 149, 205 A.2d 43 (1964), the plaintiffs' choice of forum must be respected, honored and should be rarely disturbed. See also, Koster v. Lumbermens' Mutual Casualty Companv, 330 U.S. 518, 524 (1947); Gulf Oil v. Gilbert, 300 U.S. 501 (1974). Pennsylvania Courts have consistently applied this standard to find that a plaintiffs choice of forum is "of paramount consideration" when reviewing petitions to transfer. Petty v. Suburban General Hospital, 363 Pa. Super. 277, 280, 525 A.2d 1230, 1233 (1987); Kom v. Marvin Fives Food Equip., 362 Pa. Super. 559, 524 A.2d 1380, 1382 (1987). More recently, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in Cheeseman v. Lethal Exterminator, 549 Pa. 200, 701 A.2d 156 (1997), definitively established the legal standard to be applied by trial courts in deciding motions to transfer venue. The court ruled that transfer of venue is only appropriate where the defendant establishes with detailed information on the record that plaintiff s choice of forum is vexatious or oppressive to defendant. fAJ petition to transfer should not be granted unless the defendant meets its burden of demonstrating, with detailed information on the record, that the plaintiff's chosen forum is oppressive or vexatious to the defendant. Id 701 A.2d at 162 (emphasis added). In order to prove "vexatiousness", the defendant must show that the plaintiff s choice was intended to harass the defendant. Id. In order to prove "oppressiveness", the defendant must show that the plaintiffs chosen venue imposes an unreasonable burden on the defendant. Id. Further, the defendant has not met its burden if it merely avers, as moving defendant does here, that no significant aspect of the case involves plaintiff s chosen forum or that litigation in another forum would be more convenient. As the Pennsylvania Supreme Court succinctly stated in Cheeseman: Claims by the defendant in its petition that no significant aspect of the case involves the chosen forum, and that litigating in another forum would be more convenient ... do not amount to a showing that the chosen forum is oppressive or vexatious. Nor does the assertion ... that the trial court in plaintiffs chosen forum is congested ... amount to a showing that the chosen forum is oppressive or vexatious to the defendant. Id. (emphasis added). Rather, "a party seeking a change of venue must demonstrate, on the record, any hardships that will result from the plaintiff's choice of venue. The defendant must clearly adduce facts that establish oppressiveness or vexation that are out of proportion to the plaintiff's convenience." Keuther v. Snyder, 444 Pa. Super. 468, 664 A.2d 168, 170 (1995) (citations omitted). In order to meet its burden of proof, the defendant "must clearly specify the key witnesses to be called and must make a general statement of what their testimony will cover." Petty v. Suburban General Hospital, 363 Pa. Super. 277, 285, 525 A.2d 1230, 1234 (1987). A petition to transfer must be denied if the moving party merely makes general allegations regarding witnesses without identifying them or indicating what their testimony will be. Id. In Cheeseman, the court further emphasized that considerations of the trial court's congestion must not enter into its decision whether to transfer venue. If such considerations were allowed, the result would almost always be to transfer to another venue, and this would frustrate the court's intent that plaintiff's choice of forum should rarely be disturbed. Id. 701 A.2d at 161- 62. The court stated that "a trial court, even if congested, must give deference to the plaintiff's choice of forum in ruling on a petition to transfer venue." Id. at 162 (reversing transfer of case from Philadelphia County to Bucks County even though all the parties, fact witnesses and treating physicians resided in Bucks County and none of the tortuous acts happened in Philadelphia County.) The Cheeseman court also noted that the trial court must not afford any weight to the fact that a plaintiff is a non-resident of the forum she has chosen since "the issue of residency is irrelevant" to a petition to change venue. Cheeseman, supra., 701 A.2d at 162 n.6. In Cheeseman, as in this case, since there was no testimony or evidence presented to show that plaintiffs' choice of forum in Philadelphia was vexatious or oppressive, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that, based on such facts, a transfer of venue was an abuse of discretion. The case was remanded to the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas. In the wake of the Cheeseman decision, the following Superior Court decisions upholding transfer of venue were reversed and remanded to the trial court for further proceedings consistent with Cheeseman: Noll v. Keagy, 549 Pa. 591, 702 A.2d 362 (1997); Hoffman v. Acme Markets, 549 Pa. 582, 702 A.2d 357 (1997); Godshall v. Blatt, 549 Pa. 583, 702 A.2d 357 (1997); Leiser v. Atlantic Ref. & Mktg. Corp., 549 Pa. 594,702 A.2d 358 (1997); Green v. Valarie, 549 Pa. 580, 702 A.2d 356 (1997); Kolbe v. Gratch, 549 Pa. 588, 702 A.2d 360 (1997); Minio v. Gratch, 549 Pa. 588, 702 A.2d 360 (1997); Arnold v. Fraider, 549 Pa. 587, 702 A.2d 359 (1997); Boarsts v. Silver, 549 Pa. 589,702 A.2d 360 (1997); Ferst v. Raider, 549 Pa. 590, 702 A.2d 361(1997); Evoli v. Rosenfeld, 549 Pa. 586, 702 A.2d 359 (1997); Lamar v. Fraider, 549 Pa. 586, 702 A.2d 359 (1997); Porcellini v. International Mgmt. Consultants, 549 Pa. 581, 702 A.2d 357 (1997); Seidman v. Michitti, 549 Pa. 585, 702 A.2d 358 (1997); Hunsincker v. R.D. Werner Co., 549 Pa. 544, 701 A.2d 1343 (1997); Krausz v. Fine Hotels CoM., 549 Pa. 543, 701 A.2d 1342 (1997); Techtmann v. Roy J. Howie & Robert Gray's Sons, 548 Pa. 567, 699 A.2d 729 (1997); Beard v. Rite-Aid of Pa. Inc., 548 Pa. 564, 699 A.2d 728 (1997); Rodriguez v. Lehman Equip. Sales, 548 Pa. 567, 699 A.2d 729 (1997); Hansford v. Valley Forge Ctr. Assocs., 548 Pa. 570, 699 A.2d 730 (1997); Hunt v. Philadelphia Electric Co., 548 Pa. 569, 699 A.2d 730 (1997). In light of Cheeseman, the Superior Court has repeatedly vacated lower court opinions, concluding that the petitioners failed to demonstrate on the record the level of oppressiveness needed to disturb a plaintiff's choice of forum. See, e.g., Johns v. First Union Com., 777 A.2d 489 (Pa. Super. 2001) (transfer should not have been granted because defendant failed to demonstrate detailed information on the record that chosen forum was oppressive and vexatious); Cooper v. Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co., 761 A.2d 162 (Pa. Super. 2000) (error to transfer case from Philadelphia to Pike County where Nationwide failed to demonstrate on the record vexation or oppressiveness to witnesses, and mere inconvenience did not justify transfer); and Hoose v. Jefferson Home Health Care, 754 A.2d I (Pa. Super. 2000) (abuse of discretion for trial court to transfer venue from Philadelphia County to Delaware County where defendant claimed only that various witnesses would suffer hardship, noting "a vast difference between a finding of inconvenience and one of oppressiveness"). Lastly, as recently as June 30, 2005, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court found that the trial court abused its discretion in granting a Motion to Transfer without holding defendant to its burden of showing that trial in Philadelphia County would be oppressive as opposed to merely inconvenient. In Raymond v. Park Terrace Agartrnent, Inc, et al. No 3461, EDA 2004, Plaintiff brought suit in Philadelphia County for a personal injury claim against his landlord. Defendant filed a Motion to Transfer Venue to Delaware County based on Forum Non Conveniens. Defendant's motion was based on the facts that the accident took place in Chester, Delaware County; the plaintiff still lived in the same apartment in Delaware County; an eye witness lived in Delaware County; the maintenance worker at the apartment complex lived in Delaware County; and after the incident, plaintiff received emergency care at Crozer Chester Medical Center in Chester, Delaware County, as well as follow-up treatment in Delaware County. Defendant attached affidavits from three different employees who were witnesses in the case that alleged that it would be "burdensome" for them to travel to Philadelphia County to testify and that this burden would be alleviated if the trial took place in Delaware County. Furthermore, the defendant alleged that only two of its four expert witnesses had offices in Philadelphia County. The trial court in this case granted defendant's Motion to Transfer Venue stating that Delaware County had a greater connection to this case than Philadelphia County. However, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court rejected the trial court's conclusion that trial in Philadelphia was vexatious and oppressive to the defendants. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court felt that the trial court "improperly applied a balancing test and failed to hold Appellee to its burden of demonstrating that trial in Philadelphia County would be oppressive, rather than merely inconvenient." In coming to this conclusion the Pennsylvania Supreme Court quoted Wood v. E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Co., 829 A. 2d 707, 709 (Pa. Super. 2003) (en banc), appeal denied, 860 A. 2d 124 (Pa. 2004): Indeed, the Cheeseman standard presupposes that the plaintiff's choice of forum is more convenient... [and] will prevail even if it is inconvenient to the defendants. The defendant will be able to transfer the case only if it carries its heavy burden of proof that the forum is oppressive to him. Because the Cheeseman standard already tips the scales heavily in the plaintiff's favor, the court need not expressly weight the relative convenience of the forum to both sides. Rather the proper focus of the inquiry "is whether the choice of forum is oppressive or vexatious to the defendant." Cheeseman, 701 A. 2d at 162 n.6 Consequently, a court must not apply its own balancing test in determining whether venue should be transferred, the court must focus on the burden that the defendant must meet and must assure that defendant meet that burden. Furthermore, the trial court cannot base its decision to transfer on the fact that the Philadelphia Courts are congested. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court stated in its decision that "despite the fact that the burden on the already congested Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas to resolve cases that have a tenuous connection to the city is quite real, the Supreme Court has made clear that court congestion in the chosen venue is not a proper consideration in a forum non conveniens determination." As a result, the trial court can not transfer a case from the chosen forum of the plaintiff unless defendant meets its burden in proving that trial in Philadelphia County is oppressive and vexatious. Defendant in the instant case has not met its burden and consequently, its Motion to Transfer should be denied. B. Defendant Has Not Established Its Entitlement to Transfer As in Cheeseman, Johns, Cooper, and Hoose, Defendant here is unable to meet its heavy burden of showing that Philadelphia County is vexatious to it. There is literally no evidence, and indeed no claim, that Plaintiffs' choice of forum was designed to harass the Defendant. By identifying Plaintiffs' residence as in Snyder County, and then identifying Plaintiffs as witnesses with knowledge about the incident, Defendant implies that this action should be transferred to Cumberland County in part because Philadelphia County is inconvenient to Plaintiffs. However, Plaintiffs' alleged convenience is totally irrelevant to this Motion. See Cheeseman, su ra, 701 A.2d at 162 n.6. The principal basis of Defendant's Motion is its claim that Plaintiffs' case has no connection to Philadelphia County. "Claims by the defendant in its petition that no significant aspect of the case involves the chosen forum, and that litigating in another forum would be more convenient.... do not amount to a showing that the chosen forum is oppressive or vexatious." Cheeseman, 701 A.2d at 162. Such contention by Defendant does not amount to oppressiveness or vexatiousness, and is thus insufficient to support transfer, as a matter of law. In contrast, Defendant has completely failed to provide detailed evidence of record that witnesses in this case will be oppressed by having the trial in Philadelphia County. In Johnson v. Henkels & McCoy, 707 A.2d 237 (Pa. Super. 1997), the Superior Court held that the defendant must provide the trial court with the names of witnesses who would suffer hardship and their affidavits attesting to the same. Johnson, 707 A.2d at 240. See also Cooper, supra; Hoose, supra. Defendant does not supply any affidavits from the actual witnesses, testimony or any other form of proof that the listed witnesses actually live where Defendant asserts they do. Defendant does not describe the anticipated content of any of these witnesses' testimony, nor whether they will in fact be needed to testify at trial. This is required by Johnson v. Henkels & McCoy, 707 A.2d 237 (Pa. Super. 1997), to give the Court the necessary basis for evaluating the claim of oppressiveness. To the extent Defendant argues that holding the trial in Philadelphia County will increase the distance certain witnesses will have to travel, Defendant also fails to meet its burden to prove that Philadelphia County is in fact an oppressive forum. Defendant does not identify a single individual who may actually testify or who would be oppressed by a trial in Philadelphia. Defendant does not provide any affidavits stating that traveling to Philadelphia County would cause a hardship for any witness. The distance that a witness must travel to appear at trial is clearly insignificant absent proof that such distance creates an inconvenience to said witness. See Cheeseman, supra. Defendant is now simply seeking to shop for a more strategic venue for trial. Such an attempt to change to a venue contrary to policies respecting Plaintiffs' original choice of forum should not be tolerated by this Court. Defendant has utterly failed to meet its heavy burden of demonstrating on the record that Plaintiffs' original choice of forum is vexatious or oppressive. Cheeseman, supra; Cooper, su ra; Hoose, supra. Furthermore, this court has denied numerous motions under similar circumstances: M. Katherine Wahl and John C. Wahl, No. 2275 July Tenn, 2003 (Philadelphia Co. December 16, 2003); Thomas Aleck and Pamela Aleck v. Daimler Chrysler Corporation, No. 2888 April Term, 2003 (Philadelphia Co. October 28, 2003); Nathaniel and Michelle Hite v. Daimler C sler Corporation, No. 1675 May Term, 2003 (Philadelphia Co. September 28, 2003); Shawn Iloshwav v. Daimler Chrysler Corporation, No. 0497 April Term, 2003 (Philadelphia Co. September 22, 2003); Lisa Rimby v. Daimler Chrysler Corporation, No. 0995 July Term, 2002 (Philadelphia Co. May 5, 2003); Curtis Todd Loose v. Daimler Chrysler Corporation, No. 001661 August Term, 2002 (Philadelphia Co. March 5, 2003). See copies of Orders attached as Exhibit "B". Moving Defendant does not support its Motion with any affidavits alleging that Philadelphia County would be an oppressive venue. Defendant does not provide a single shred of detail concerning the anticipated content of the testimony of any witnesses who will allegedly be oppressed by trial in Philadelphia County. Defendant makes cursory, unsupported and non- specific assertions in its brief regarding the witnesses who will allegedly be inconvenienced by trial in Philadelphia County. The case law makes clear why detailed proof in the form of affidavits or deposition testimony is necessary, and why Defendant's Motion is inadequate: the court has no factual basis to evaluate the claim of oppressiveness without detailed information on the record concerning the identity of each witness and the content of his or her testimony. Petty v. Suburban General Hospital, 363 Pa. Super. 277, 285, 525 A.2d 1230, 1234 (1987). Defendant has simply failed to supply such information. 5. RELIEF REQUESTED Defendant has not shown with detailed information on the record that Philadelphia County would be an oppressive venue for it. Counterposed against this is the fact that Philadelphia County is the choice of the Plaintiffs. Defendant's claim that this case has no connection to Philadelphia County is exactly the claim rejected by the Supreme Court in Cheeseman, supra. Accordingly, Defendant's motion must be denied. By: Respectfully Submitted, DAVID J. GORBERG & ASSOCIATES Kimberly A. Hoehing, Esquire Attorney for the Plaintiff Dated: September 14, 2005 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Kimberly A. Hoehing, do hereby certify that service of a true and correct copy of the within Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Motion to Transfer Venue was made on the 11t° day of July, 2005 to counsel listed below by first class mail. To: James Johnson, Esquire MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & GOGGIN 1845 Walnut Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 DAVID J. GORBERG & ASSOCIATES By: Kimberly A. Hoehing, Esquire Attorney for the Plaintiff Dated: September 14, 2005 cx?,b,+ A ooel Number ..__--.?-.. u.. uti0.LLCIlJ1114 LULLACy U. cloy l 1 Trial Division I l _ Civil Cover Sheet I : Judy pUWtIFF'S NAME OEFEHOANrs HAVE Gary Neubaum I DaimlerChrysler Corporation PLAIPTIFCB ADDRESS OEFENOA,,rS ADDRESS 610 West Shady Lane C/O CT CORPORATION Enola, PA 17025 1515 Market St., Phila PA p4MFlf%'S NANE I DEFENDANrs'I.WE i4Ntlf.-'S ADDRESS DEFENnuITSAODREES I I I PlAtnilFr 5 NAM£ 1 i CEFENDANTS WNE I i PtAlNTIFF'S ADDRESS i IOE£ENCAIITS ADDRESS ' TOTAL NUMBER OF Ft-AINSIFFB TOTAL NO. OF DEFENDANTS ' COIAMENC£MENT Of ACTION CamPlaivT ? Pctidon Action ? llutir ar Appol 1 1 1 Wrilarsumm.m ? Transfer Fmm Dlhcr Jurisdimiam AMOUNT IN C@NRONERsY I CDURT PROORAMs 559.000.00 or Ins Mwv than 550,000.40 Arbitmdan Jury ? ? hl savings Action =Ton ? td inor Coup Appeal .? M1Jmu1T 1 Smtuio7 APPcalf Nvn•Jury Pclltlon Wi W]ur+'IVV i 1 ^ ? n0 1e. . _ CASE TYPE ANO JOE ISEE INSTRUCTIONSI I ] C CONTRACT I SrArUrORY BASIS ;OR LAUSE OF ACTION (Sc NISTRUCTIONSI N/A RELATED PENOINO CASES (LIST BY CA.EE CAPTIOA M40 DOCKET NUMBER) I IS CASE SuOJECT TO 0000.01NAT OROERT I i10 ? ? NONE ? I ? ? I 1 TO THE PROTH0M0 T.;R" l.indly enter my aooear_nce cn behalf of PlaintitiiPe:itionz:iA.ppzllanc i- t Paoe:E- maybe served at :he address se: Foes below. uME DF a1 AIN i1F P]IPETI TIDIIEWSUPPBLL/N ra ArT Ofl NET ADDRESS IEEE IIISTR'JC IOICI David J. Gorberg 1234 Market Street Phila., PA 19107 P,.Gn E.IOMBEn- I F. I IA R 563-7210 LUFNFIAe COUFT -CEN CnC.11ON nG = ul DRE 53084 +'ID NA NRE DATE 7/11/05 JL:UI IRS-.::'831 ASSESSMENT OF DAMAGES BS1??' n PEQ0lRE+! DAVID J. GORBERG & ASSOCIATES, P. BY: DAVID J. GORBERG IDENTIFICATION NO. SUITE 2040 1234 MARKES 9T PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA 19107 (215) 563-7210 FT is ?It u?amut r Plaintiff ATTEST JUL 2 9 20U5 LAURAPAONE GARY NEUBAUM 610 Rest Shady Lane Enola, PA 17025 xr t f ,. ? DAIMLERCFIRYSLER CORPORAWI bO . . c/o CT Corporation1515 Market Street ... r PA 19103 Phil del hia p , a A t I ItT_iT t `itT? .. FF201Lf r.. , , t,.T?r?;; CIVIL ACTION COMPLAINT 1C CONTRACT NOTICE You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth In the following pages, you must lake action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that If you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the court without further notice for any money claimed In the complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the plaintiff. You may lose money or properly or other rights Important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW. THIS OFFICE CAN PROVIDE YOU WITH INFORMATION ABOUT HIRING A LAWYER. IF YOU CANNOT AFFORD TO HIRE A LAWYER, THIS OFFICE MAY BE ABLE TO PROVIDE YOU WITH INFORMATION ABOUT AGENCIES THAT MAY OFFER LEGAL SERVICES TO ELIGIBLE PERSONS AT A REDUCED FEE OR NO FEE. LAWYER REFERENCE SERVICE One Reading Center 1101 Market Street Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19107 (215) 238-6333 COURT OF COMMON PLEAS DIVISION JULY 20??M' No. 003,379 AVISO Le han demandado an torte. Si ustetl desen defender contra las demandas dispuestas an las paginas siguientes, ustetl dabs tomar Is acc16n an at piazo de veinte (20) dias despubs de safe queja y se sirve aviso, incorporando un aspecto escrito personalmenta o y amhlvando an escdbir con Is torte sus defenses u objeciones a [as demandas dispuestas contra usted el abogado Is advierte qua of usted no puede hater asi qua el caso puede proceder sin usted It un juicio se puede incorporar contra ustetl compra to torte sin aviso adicional pare cualquier dinero demandado an Is queja o pars cualquier olro demands o relovacidn pedida par of demandante. Listed puede perder el dinero o Is caracterlstlca de Otte endereza importante a usted. LISTED DEBE LLEVAR ESTE PAPEL SU ABOGADO INMEDIATAMENTE. St LISTED NO HACE DUE UN ABOGADO VAYA A O LLAME POR TELEFONO LA OFICINA DISPUESTA ABAJO. ESTA OFICINA PUEDE PROVEER DE LISTED LA INFORMACi6N SOBRE EMPLEAR A UN ABOGADO. SI USTED NO PUEDE PERMITIRSE AL HIRE A UN ABOGADO, ESTA OFICINA PUEDE PODER PROVEER DE LISTED LA INFORMACION SOBRE LAS AGENCIAS DUE LOS SERVICIOS JURIDICOS DE LA OFERTA DE MAYO A LAS PERSONAS ELEGIBLES EN UN HONORARIO REDUCIDO 0 NINGUN HONORARIO. SERVICIO DE REFERENCIA LEGAL One Reading Center 1101 Market Street Filadeifla, Pennsylvania 19107 Tel6fono:(215) 236-6333 DAVID J. GORBERG & ASSOCIATES, P.C. By: DAVID J. GOR13ERG Attorney for Plaintiffs Identification No. 53084 1234 Market Street Suite 2040 Philadelphia, PA 19107 (215) 563-7210 GARY NEUBAUM COURT OF COMMON PLEAS 610 West Shady Lane Enola, PA 17025 PHILADELPHIA COUNTY vs. TERM, 2005 DAIMLER CHRYSLER CORPORATION c/o CT CORPORATION 1515 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 : NO. COMPLAINT 1. Plaintiff, Gary Neubaurrr, is an adult individual citizen and legal resident of the Commonwealth of Pen isylvania, residing at 610 West Shady Lane< Enola, PA 17025. 2. Defendant, Daimler Chrysler Corporation, is a business corporation qualified to do business and regularly conducts business in the Conunonwealth of Pennsylvania with its legal residence and principal place of business at P O Box 21-8004, Auburn Hills, Michigan 48321 and can be served at c/o CT Corporation, 1515 Market Street, Philadelphia, PA 19103. BACKGROUND 3. Plaintiff incorporates by reference paragraphs I and 2 as fully as if set forth here length. 4. On or about March 31, 2003, Plaintiff purchased a 2003 Chrysler Sebring manufactured and warranted by Defendant bearing the Vehicle Identification Number 1C3EL65R13N526172. The vehicle was purchased and registered in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. The price of the vehicle, including registration charges, document fees, sales tax, but, excludine other collateral charges not specified, totaled more than $30,000.00. 6. Plaintiff avers that as a result of the ineffective repair attempts made by Defendant through its authorized dealer, the vehicle cannot be utilized for the purposes intended by Plaintiff at the time of acquisition and as such, the vehicle is worthless. In consideration of the purchase of the above vehicle, Defendant, issued to Plaintiff several warranties, fully outlined in the warranty booklet. On or about March 31, 2003, Plaintiff took possession of the above mentioned vehicle and experienced nonconformities, which substantially impaired the use, value and/or safety of the vehicle. Said nonconformities consisted of, but was not limited to, defective air bag and engine. Copies of repair receipts are attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "A". 10. The nonconformities violate the express written warranties issued to Plaintiff by Defendant. 11. Plaintiff avers the vehicle has been subject to repair more than two (2) times for the same nonconformity, and the nonconformity remains uncorrected. 12. Plaintiff has delivered the nonconforming vehicle to an authorized service and repair facility of the defendant on numerous occasions. After a reasonable number of attempts, Defendant was unable to repair the nonconfonmities. 13. In addition, the above vehicle has or will in the future be out of service by reason of the non-conformities complained of for a cumulative total of thirty (30) days or more. 14. The vehicle continues to exhibit defects and nonconforn-ities which substantially impair it's use, value and/or safety. 15. Plaintiff avers the vehicle has been subject to additional repair attempts for defects and/or nonconfonnities and/or conditions for which the Defendant and or it's authorized service center, may not have maintained records. 16. Plaintiff has been and will continue to be financially damaged due to Defendant's intentional, reckless, wanton and negligent failure to comply with the provisions of its' warranty. 17. Plaintiff seeks relief for losses due to the nonconfonnities and defects in the above mentioned vehicle in addition to attorney fees and all court costs. COUNTI PENNSYLVANIA AUTOMOBILE LEMON LAW CLAIM 18. Plaintiff hereby incorporates all facts and allegations set forth in this Complaint by reference as if fully set forth at length herein. 19. Plaintiff is a "Purchaser" as defined by 73 P.S. § 1952. 20. Defendant is a "Manufacturer" as defined by 73 P.S. §1952. 21. Plaintiffs vehicle is a "New Motor Vehicle" as defined by 73 P.S. §1952. 22. Said vehicle experienced non conformities within the first year of purchase, which substantially impairs the use, value and safety of said vehicle. 23. Defendant failed to correct and or repair said nonconformities. 24. The vehicle continues to exhibit defects and nonconformities which substantially impair it's use, value and/or safety. 25. Defendant does not require participation in any informal dispute settlement program prior to filing suit. 26. As a direct and proximate result of Defendant's failure to repair the nonconformities , Plaintiff has suffered damages and, in accordance with 73 P.S. §1959, Plaintiff is entitled to bring suit for such damages and other legal and equitable relief. 27. Plaintiff avers that upon successfully prevailing upon the Lemon Law claim herein, all attorney fees are recoverable and are demanded against the Defendant. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully demands judgment in his favor and against the Defendant in an amount equal to three (3) times the purchase price of the subject vehicle, plus all available collateral changes and attorney fees. Amount not in excess of $50,000.00. COUNT II MAGNUSON-MOSS FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION IMPROVEMENT ACT 28. Plaintiff hereby incorporates all facts and allegations set forth in this Complaint by reference as if fully set forth at length herein. 29. Plaintiff is a "Consumer" as defined by 15 U.S.C. §2301(3). 30. Defendant is a "Warrantor" as defined by 15 U.S.C. §2301(5). 31. Plaintiff uses the subject product for personal, family and household purposes. 32. By the terms of the express written warranties referred to in this Complaint, Defendant agreed to perform effective warranty repairs at no charge for parts and/or labor. 33. Defendant failed to make effective repairs. 34. As a direct and proximate result of Defendant's failure to comply with the express written warranties, Plaintiff has suffered damages and, in accordance with 15 U.S.C. §2310(d) (1), Plaintiff is entitled to bring suit for such damages and other legal and equitable relief. 35. Section 15 U.S.C. §2310 (d) (1) provides: If a consumer finally prevails on an action brought under paragraph (1) of this subsection, he may be allowed by the Court to recover as part of the judgment a sum equal to the amount of aggregate amount of costs and expenses (including attorney fees based upon actual time expended), determined by the Court to have been reasonably incurred by the Plaintiff for, or in connection with the commencement and prosecution of such action, unless the Court, in its discretion shall determine that such an award of attorney's fees would be inappropriate. 36. Plaintiff avers that upon successfully prevailing upon the Magnuson-Moss claim herein, all attorney fees are recoverable and are demanded against the Defendant. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully demands judgment in his favor and against the Defendant in an amount equal to three (3) times the purchase price of the subject vehicle, plus all available collateral changes and attorney fees. Amount not in excess of $50,000.00. COUNT III UNIFORM COMMERCIAL CODE 37. Plaintiff hereby incorporates all the paragraphs of this Complaint by reference as if fully set forth at length herein. 38. The defects and nonconfonnities existing within the vehicle constitute a breach of contractual and statutory obligations of the Defendant, including but not limited to the following; a. Breach of Express Warranty Breach of Implied Warranty of Merchantability; C. Breach of Implied Warranty of Fitness For a Particular Purpose; d. Breach of Duty of Good Faith. 39. The purpose for which Plaintiff purchased the vehicle include but are not limited to his personal, family and household use. 40. At the time of this purchase and at all times subsequent thereto, Plaintiff has justifiably relied upon Defendant's express warranties and implied warranties of fitness for a particular purpose and implied warranty of merchantability. 41. At the time of the purchase and at all times subsequent thereto, Defendant was aware Plaintiff was relying upon Defendant's express and implied warranties, obligations, and representations with regard to the subject vehicle. 42. Plaintiff has incurred damages as a direct and proximate result of the breach and failure of Defendant to honor its express and implied warranties. 43. Such damages include, but are not limited to, the purchase price of the vehicle plus all collateral charges, including attorney fees and costs, as well as other expenses, the full extent of which are not yet known. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully demands judgment in his favor and against the Defendant in an amount equal to three (3) times the purchase price of the subject vehicle, plus all available collateral changes and attorney fees. Amount not in excess of $50,000.00. COUNT IV PENNSYLVANIA UNFAIR TRADE PRACTICES AND CONSUMER PROTECTION CLAIM 44. Plaintiff hereby incorporates all the paragraphs of this Complaint by reference as if set forth at length herein. 45. The Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law defines unfair methods of competition to include the following: (xiv). Failing to comply with the terms of any written guarantee or warranty given to the buyer at, prior to, or after a contract for the purchase of goods or services is made. 46. Plaintiff, as a Pennsylvania resident, believes, and therefore, avers the reckless, wanton and willful failure of Defendant to comply with the terns of the written warranty constitutes an unfair method of competition. 47. Section 201-9.2(a) of the Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law, authorizes the Court, in its discretion, to award up to three (3) times the actual damages sustained for violations of the Act. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully demands judgment in his favor and against the Defendant in an amount equal to three (3) times the purchase price of the subject vehicle, plus all available collateral changes and attorney fees. Amount not in excess of $50,000.00. DAVID J. GORBIrRG & ASSOCIATES, P.C. ', BY: ,` DAV? J. RBERG, ESQUIRE Atto ey for Plaintiff VERIFICATION The undersigned verifies that the Civil Action Complaint is based on information furnished to counsel in the preparation of his/her Lemon Law and/or Breach of Warranty lawsuit. The language of the Civil Action Complaint is that of counsel and not of signer. Signer verifies that the information supplied to counsel is true and correct to the best of his/her knowledge, information and belief. The contents of the Civil Action Complaint is that of counsel and not of signer. This verification is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to Date: ZJ as LSLhq er-y 3 1 m TSTOMER COPT r.u. Dull 1-10 Beaver Springs, ,°A 17812 (570) 658-0700 CUSTOMER COPY GARY/SETH NEUHAUM 610 W SIiaDY LN ENOLA PA 17025 0 A X.X WCDRO CUSTOMER. STATES WATER. LEAK IN TRUNK 1 SM06VXLAB 1 SM07VXLAB 1 SL89VXLAC 03/31/2003 1 028047 R DELIVERY DATE BLUE DATE D R.O. DATE 03/31/2003 03/31/2003 CARPET- WHEELHOU CARPET-WHEELHOU CARPET-LUGGAGE B X.X INDSV CUSTOMER STASES PASSENGER SEAT BOTTOM IS LOOSE 40972 NC NC NC 0.4 Labor Op. 23002040 Failure Code lE ADJUSTED HOOD NC Total Sublet 0-.00 Total Deductible 14=_:=00 Total Misc. 0-.00 >mer '0.00 Iture X SOLUTIONS, INC. MGM 343.0006 M 6/93 a3hier,-T 3 13v 1 UOLLI UETOMER COPY o Beaver Springs, PA 17612 570) 656-0100 CUSTOMER COPY cullumtIHNU, UCENSE# 5TOCK# _DEALER NVOICE DATE INVOICE# 526172 3299 68512 07/14/2003 02°560 CUSTOMER NAME &ADDRESS MILEAGE IN 71 AG GOUT LOT#/HAT# COLOR DELIVERY DATE CARY NEUBAUM 3732M 3732M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 61.0 W SHADY L14 03CHRYSLPR SEBRING L 07/14/2003 07/11/2003 VEHICLE ID# TECH &# P, 0.A ENODLA, PA 17025 I 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. IM. EST. 6874 I EXTENDED WARRANTY CO. POLICY# DEDUCTIBLE AUTHORIZATION4 ADJUSTOR NONE 0.00 RESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DEUVERY SIGNAIURE + 4'„?A s? ''`? hAHIT° 'x4 k {'N,b?ht` '?+` x'Y ? ?' Whu I x a 7 i*k fi• .t 1 S ?? ? } } { ? 6`?ds+ EL faY MbM1 5? 11PI?w"T^'°+°i. v° ?'X'C _ r ,?y? r?4.1}m".a''EI??yy A X _}" $" )I L Yi M A ; C "?h ? t Kt "? 4 pX A i'r T4 v ? 41 1 ? 9 l-n$1{ )•xlk rv.? .. r . @FHCPA f1?M9H1'"k§ F .. I b a b i . r:Vit_7 F. (M'.AICW , *" "'-' + Y A 0.5 CPDRO LUBE OIL FILTER 4350C ,rc r x ^xTR x r TL + 4*+Yt 1fi` N ?' " fi sA s SAN f#iJk{yt a r,,'xr SEUr sa+i ?7 jv3. 7as sr„?iPl xkr i`'} isC'. w"Iffi.1 r9 1 r .s; ? e"v ,?-1'A Y r a ax t4 ' ' 11?Y ` 3? ' ' I ? a . yf rf'=`j x5?'t T p,f W i E{BiQ ?` ? 'e $ A .? ? T, M y, T iw . x ?, „f`+`,b.?°? p $ V ' yt# ym , yF t Y 'id' ,glx 'R ?t-w"r. i' f AiR 5 c r 3V #'P RH y4 y A` ?i rtstpE ? 7 f dx. a 7 h xM I r + 0 ' ? T"x- r A _fM1? J. 9 ? n ?p ? '"t' . , . ,. S Shop p Supplies OIL-KILTER-'DISPOSAL 2.00 Job A Total Parts & Labor 21.95 ?p % ?r'kyunl 'rm`gg n'fi? I S" } * y +" , ;?` m as ar & } ,a TMr R' C? ??`° r : 'F3 pof yy ???? x - ,- ?^ 'S' .1 4 ? S -tk ! :" G mt FS y r I V4iisM 4??t^ a?. x' Rv ,,A 'S1J ? ? J ? iX +6a .- , h`^,3a',,ria s,..y'crY 4?w '.L'T'1-rnx F 1 P Y ;..r 3 '°M gr .k Yj x `tN . Tx ' L t J r j4' '' ? ? „yil . T ,, . r s } Y ? F' yT IP % 4 N A n-'9 If} y? yy??'?Pir? 1 N" '8 "?qp• ?i tY '9V x y,,¢. y Fr4 ??/? # y +1? -g M yi A4 3 i1` x51Yi? ?1 i`..`.. wY P)7rh 044 3 Y Jx'?r? d4' M1.RL "5° v 13A5'„ ippt.. P d D,q'Ap }d f. h H Fn K ! ? `" . .. dx, E k J' fr-0 'r. r v?'.kiiA.b"3"yk 4{R' .}ay ,4 abut^[ { 4350C STATE INSPECTION,LF LOB, RR 6B, TIRES 6/32 19.95 STICKER #7769543 " w}A tl n?,ns`u 3' i f?ry a --7,' `.'r 0-no, a°T rl it o "r r n r , nv6 n w #etf y }p 1R, Tb a3M"art F2FSa 1¢a?7 A {` WON nt'+! N *apY'Ik ilyyl• J k. J Fp S'" > F 13 t{ 1 f M" t k.. -? a?'?S :74 ? " ? r ? { .¢ . r w,. 5t:f 'Q-^?`^f"1 ? ??1 t f "'``'htr ttIQM} FlR"11 t '??k` p {`-rn, ?°I': i„ > T £ `t ?3 N 7 k "3 1 ' `f"' ' A 't^ ` - _ ? ? _ ? ?V : ,M. ., 4.n - t ; .. .. >, .? t t ?a ... ,. t ..,I ; i ?'?' c_I •ry .? xvu ?+., r'?m C ^!xes,".I. +f, V? YT p1 "'Z'.u #"F ,k'W; m ja 'm°x "'+1] x, tie +'%ex i k 4A vk +i h i3L t Yr., s kM a A; !ra4 Ai??fa€'d "'M'St? ? Pi' '.xi<^+s?"eyca4 -"t ?5 x ? y?M1 ik Tt4ki '?? 4? s .P ? t$" 4 , }k? x`^A' ?+ti s y?2 F ?,.?: r Y{7? ?? ?, ? ? n ?" t + } ye :. irr t 45'P 4 Sr ? + Ys Y 'p " -Y "? 4q, a i -"+ ; ,B + Y "? Par ° ?"•?"`- r:?,",.?7 ?Ye??3r f ? .?41 ?Lr ? r ? ?k"81l 4 , ??t k r s t 'z y ? ' ` fi` ? ? *' ? ?? ? ? ? , , ?4 r i ? v1 ,?? ' rr hd fi. a pr ^^c L a #? ice' r ,+4- ?. ?x d+? +?a1" ,S? vj 7# t l f„ & ? ,s+ d' k S. yy.. ` y! ? 1'F '*rP 1. { 94 d % ^. i? ? - ^k 4. hix R tl >kR?. i P t F ? s Ai '? 't , ? -? „ „ _ y d A,I :..N Tt^ s?„t ?'$?'F'?AV§'?,pS-a a- „. 1@i , t Y dr.mi?A ??? }x.(.!rty? t °"+'zp,'T'tp u d f t`y 3 k ,"t f.".".1 f?4 ? + ?. z' W= 4 ? T S ?3, Y s i 'R R ' r u ?t ?r r / .. 5 A?$Ty§ ? ? aw °?+' ? #,1'w's+Aik r9. rv`'i£„??'rjf•? ?YyV p#'i x ?{ a #*u ?' e 3A ,a ? { V"k T""'3 r I Y y? I F r # 3, i r 'V I?SfP'' ', ' A 3< L t ;T( 1F t lkd?t +, y3 R 4 M 1;S'iF. ?S x 's n r *rk d E d NO < u`?"B''§,.,?^y? A 1Y ; ,k rv:YZ £ a f4 ?' +. z,H.#a JS IA Sa. tr7 fi x"t 1Y'` ,,, fr myl1 ' E"' § ? '8 ' l ' k T ' ?' ' V .. : a. ! :: xk dU . E? y 1,3 +a .2 yrLS S?., i:= . . t a Is h :.. ?.I'e' `:?? Y.d `fYa Rt." fe.u,Y t `'. x ,. ^Ye`Y 1 ' x 1 art } ,_f. Y `60 Total Sublet 0.00-rv Total Deductible 0.00 Total Misc 0.60 'a"a","t'"`?#,#'?tr Y +1 "ir t k ? V i NS? '? Rtt??wl ?d V ?. ?} *T },N Y'Y' ? J } i "?' J"o- Y 5- ^s+t SS) Yri 1 Y 7 , ? EXIWDED WARRANN PAV FACTORY WARRANIV PAY [y1 L46DR C`IARG"cE APE 9o icn ON FIAT MiE FINAL E9IIMAlE TOTAL GrSrOINER PAY ?? HIXJR3IlN1E4 OMEkMEE NDTER 47.06 :ustomer Ignature R ORM SOLUTIONS, INC. 18881363-8886 M 3988 6199 o L fc.TOMER COPY ' ' Beaver Springs, PA 17812 (570) 658-0100 CUSTOMER COPY UWUMh NU UCENSE# STOCK# DEALER: INMOICEDATE INVOICE# 526172 3299 68512 07/14/2003 029396 USTOMER NAME &ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGEOLA LOT#/HAT# COLOR DELIVERY DATE GARY NEUBAUM 3290M 3290M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 610 W SHADY IN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L 07./14/2003 0 7/01/2 003 VEHICLE ID # TECH & # P.O. # ENOLA PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. INT. EST. 6874 (TENDED WARRANTY CO. POLICY9 DEDUWBLE AUTHORRATION# ADJUSTOR NONE 0.00 ESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY OGNAIDRE y DPI Ti M„r"dbaobF 1 TY >r{kME -A, m "°re*i a'..etii iu&'iwH M1S? TY.! F n a y, %2 f ?-vfl7 LIJ F 'Y fJdtGG bk i':, f D f& T"` a,'G' e. ty ! 4s x') ?vy.,,XIR?T„ a s 'eAs F !w s°a 'U'+ 3f di3' s d e`T'" ,Ma , =rvls F s>n-p,d ;,? 41 ?a+'k"f 1 #va,Fisrtrlrt'8uwmn:vt'. - ?.. mlaratltt'zw ,r F K". xs Pa TDVA PnC'. I A X.X INDSV CUSTOMER STATES AIR BAG LIGHT WAS ON 43501 r e ?'h.Vi"„' r,?{Eai ash iC;IEI,t,'? `'p +b33S 3'i+?f2j.3'1"ER. L,'Ai2ED ,CODE AND aLtIGHT o ,NfC ?ss al aV n ° "Li- ! ,I k;??t d a 9eW K s ft{ kJ T: F4 a r p ?? t ,S' r w p rT'4 a rA "t Y-y,,, 1 r r' 1 e 't .?:es t +, o y xm ? f f xe+,?9m 'f`' t a r,C?';+Ga' 7 ? Imo) i'?'_.u'R?. ?Y a>? ?' ? 4''4?y,,? d,.T ?gf ?,. ?, f u6v",fi,( +t 91?d' sy ?p A t?a+s 3'"Ta"? ° f Ft"s? ? . w t a d tr r ?is? y? n`? r .. B X.X WCDRO CUSTOMEP, STATES DRIVEPS SEAT RECLINER IS INOP. -- _. 4350W. 1.4 Labor Op 23135502 Failure Code 51 NC" kr 7,TL 5i' '-'&R #-,?t",-.5 3 a Y §§Mt ] 4` x5, `k% F iu. "'a g fi Ei § a<F i?, v ^^J ,.s, 5.^? d r sf i a w 's4r"? &x{ ; M1 h EiRS p4 Yom' t'Fk''4 .,?.uLx''aw:;?'apD.?kVa'1 ?FJe e a'a + °'"` t % FFs ,4x#1JL ?, ? 0' +x,'13 'w y 1 = ryd u4 SI T' al e l`p?"U+Trp aL ifs' bA ^a r rv,? ! " ;S tl;^r1?{Rr k-TV -TMd?63?'WCSNER, 4Y.5, s ax 4 M? •y.'.r. a . v k' kx g`+'1&T?rY? 1 Lx `'rr?.:, d?}.:,r}`R"a a :?r.4,vr7.f N° I?s.'k }e ?;` I ' j,? Syr z '-+r .? s^v :#s., f Sr ?Ylr ?? T 3u Gl rv' Ti, B"1 'f"P )L FK i -fi IYy 'try fisk' T ,t n r_-dr ' 4. x ' x11 .:x r. r It s rd u i g°"No ?OJ+'}?U g w [y 7 4 q, ev+ sr 3 ?,.`f S r +"? -{. u h Fla P T ref ? r. _.R"'T 3,?"%1 v r c a ? s SA? 0 Eve ztJr I 's ?y,y3'm?nV'? x xr im- ? i t ??'y???i ^1 %^+h $t f?"YitT.i ?i ?, y?,ay 1{}^? a ;. ; i vN1 . a A.t ° '? E r E ;?! t +a ? d. r,{ .. S?,µ ? r 'T 3 1?? krv ? 3'A+a YfA'tt!1 x_ ^fi %Cr?? ? 4'd is F? '.is'y- F "il) p a? e r r K ?e ? lG `.. 'Cy'' !"?. b?`}?,?, Y e ?' n ?. d a ? 'I ? 3; rP . 33Y'vtSV" ! yl r ? L a '2? J t rv ? f s l ? ! E fa f f; i ? F ?, >T^Y. ?" e 4 S 1! I 1 3.P f ?K51 Ff 1S4?j ? 'r 1S'?i f'k? ??.+`),- 'S?4 g" il"5 !¢y /? XiF F y, 3 i ? d; 1 k ?y s +Y d ~f RI x r *.,',?, '3 3x t },?? ? s. x v f 60 ? ^FK pln6e a§!? tim;? fr - .. ?T i. ey1 ? a v ?Y&a H rT "'' x '?T d q x # r '15 Tn gat i s?alJt 3i ! r y L 1 N w .3. s,TV U? T°l d.?TM r! C°L 11 ) j'ff i3 kFUE 6 T., ££ r ?: 44 r w .i/` xY! >U P 5 a .4,.. .?f ;r lL a. en,Y:. "? x(x1jL r,.. ec4?s 'a3 2 } k:: 'Gaax.P-aY•?T5 ate- t{Q -z Total t+ Sublet F.".,, ye 1a s'p w b A ah'Tt Total Deductible 0.00 F ? a wr NI, as T fi Q,P C'r Y hr r Total Misc 0.00 a a !d h -'? V i9ei4 1 A s 3 'A n i rf Y s r +' r G X'"' ?IAis !6 wa?.,'s t sN Au ?*' s.?3 e?. E'k ?`a ?u ? sfi t T a er C r ? T, I t? ? T,-?r s' f n. EMENDED WAARANN PAY FACTORY WMRANTY PAV ALL LABOR CHARGE ARE BILLID ON FLAT RATE RNAL ESTIMATE TOTAL Ct15TOINER PAV - HOIlRS UN ESS OhIERf415E NO1ED 0.00 JJ I V l l ltll mature h IRM SOLUTIONS, INC. ISSSI 343. 16 439SE 6/99 .SICII CI- J 1 4/LJ • FSTOMER COPY oddvur oprings, I,-A 11612 (570) 656-0100 CUSTOMER COPY JSTOMER NO. LICENSE# STOCK# DEALER# INVOICE DATE INVOICE0 S? T 79 - 3299 66512 07/14/2003 029561 JSTOMER NAME & ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MI LEAGE OUT 207 #/HAi # COLOR DELIVERY DATE GARY NEUBAUM 3742M 3742M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 610 W SHADY LN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L 07/14/2003 07/11/2003 VEHICLE ID O TECH & # P.O. # ENOLA PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. INT. EST, 6974 aEiHDED WARRANTY CG POUCY# DEDUCTIBLE AUTHORIZATION# ADJUSTOR 0.00 ESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY SIGNANRE DPk r pwR n + 11 1" kr 5 pF?i Is F *kss ^:, Trt HI , I t 10, +?rty i G}pdCE Y ? u'"" f$F'x J kpTml '4?v ?p ".vT„ 9x 'co1g .,'e.? N ?,"M1?Sa :F " V`?? . ?+ C; trY,,">Fikf S!?? "vfi n: Y "i ?m', .el w Yll .? ? nn? n u rr?r ?4i ?i P34? . r v v ? t k , p WMMm, .', uy _ . YNbNFikB6[I':, S wg °. »Abpcg?dM - , xir t +? ? , z '? ?, „ A X.X INDSV CUSTOMER STATES THROTTLE STICKS 43501 F 6 `+ F 3 P'3 k 4 tiJ -ry.L C YTS ?n M A[ R ?' 9 Y 1 61 " ? ? i ? ? 4 F ? k ,.?F +} 9 { * M 4 ? k p¢{?T } A,rtp, .?? ! ht 3 YF §f IF 3 YWp'?. +. } fe°'vsl?rv +??? ? d {?Y G ?" ? +: ?i` ?%? x- G ^ f J ! ?jh? 3 + j'Y+. ??M3y{F i ?wY` 1Y=3? +" "+ ""AF S ?? Y`"'f4 j' fi r ?yY " # ` *9?* F^'? pl ?? M1 ? Y ?' T "°" I V' ? Yf?? k ° '? k ?? ? ?t` ?' y, ; ? . ? . ? i {uY .? 4 ., .?5 r d } ? Y ' M{f t JI ? { ,SJ?F' ? ?f ? N? qq 6 ??????? B X.X INDSV CUSTOMER STATES CONVERTABLE TOP SQUEAKS GOING UP AND DOWN - .._..._. 43501 PUT TOP UP AND DOWN RUBS ON THE WAY NO ADJUSTMENT NO i i°$ ' a ' niS?A''i 3T?sdGMA3a STS zGYlu yONRfi?18ZE I r 32 S f'. d e v ve s i J' T$? ' s e .A + eR 3 y- a d"L x k x$b Y N i A p"f EtA'tt ]'Ca 1k 'k4 „ Y 1 St 5 p # Y kTS'a b a'Tk'A T d eM1 -. f r? x r a ' J '+'?P dt M1 } T? 2: sk yy' ep, M1 f y? el i{.`hY}3", z `fi '{^ 4R '?' KS1.+t is C, +Y 4', , i Nay 19k >•,d ,L"MY' 1v, 0401 `f4' i r P! '. {tF x + . {.."711y.1 b^E h F 'd \k F?'i{4 $?.`4a' ? ? X Y+ ? J' i ,j' 1.,? S `T a'" 9 ` 'Y' [ 4 + f t > 4Fi?y?MM1?+t t? a k '"v5"? i i '?$ rE+ ?l5't' Lktx ???. r.na 2 ix r rx ! m *}?n -I 'i r? rz i :' x ?7$x ?4 ?frt Y ?yry W ? fF' ? :Y NSF d"t F }? ?? fi l 'aY"?s 4l "A$?M ti "' #Y t?, I F ? °Y" '??? $yy?0. ' £'¢ iY ? 3 M Y ? T N„ ? r h .¢ i i F ui.M1Y d i 4I 1 + Y » N?I ?. iX ? ? 1Fk4 dv'`YyNt??'"?d+'?P3? ?f.? .y ?? '71'??r }'i ????'1Yl ?Yrv?' Yty"Y?Y ?[?yL?t??, ?n r "?4? .?A1 ? ? k ?i $$ 4 ? ? 1k?C ? r ? A h ? y t ^1' 4 1 M! I A & Y ? 3? Y a'N b ?t Tlt ?,r :r T? ?# F ?4Rr$tt????Cili(? ?}"u` '"` l r ? ?x'I?? rhlit ' ?d4? y ,y } Y J 4 ,. ( S? AFW 9' t w?Ga'!¢.? i? r d ? a '? x- PI'i ?'? N d ?'?` Y 3 fIf ?,'^Fr,., ? T x ? r ?? ? w N I N! M1 s1s "f x M., t I ft D ?,A ?„ Ff?i ;?`>3'' ?t(? }:! Yi6!° f ?ai? S ? I? T ?* ?? ? " ??i'I T [' ? 1 ? ?' 33i + ¢ x K ? N 3 r i .(y yy?? ^b { Y \t Y ' ! "3 m .k p Wair lsdr,??+ 9 3?' £ 't sPx4x ?. * `Mr`S r ? S k R -0 J Y i. Y + + tl rt 1I.?311 r?k .t i{ r. n £r F .], $ , FCe t '.. + .a w.. e, r _ .. .. ,. .. ... rv. .. i i'i Y R . .. ,- . .. -, om. . .P g } ki+vy'.h ?Yi 4.Ra:? J"If?A "??Lw w"ttiF'YU{ajH,riP4T e x TP SS •#, " i d Sr >n'eJ< t t. 1k y Ys}v i f-- -:. 1f : A y i 1 ? p ??„y .?f i FyM yY 3 ,{ dt ? i ?i a. I? 4F+ t L Y e4 t JY' H ?y' ?w ti ? t? KL ? V A g 1?} k i14 ? l ,?' T ? Qh + it p ^? wI t [ } ? 9 ' ' ? ? ' Y . k # _ l t W r Y ry Fd Yw ,Y ." ETI P x , ?11 a?. 3.0' box € r, ?, ? n 0 0 71? ? 11 AN ot Y T f ?N i x z? ?* ? '? "i r t + a ?` ?< s ,r- d ??, : ?E x u? r , ? ? pk r Ae? . 4 + `§ S f{ kz! rk 4 i '1e Ak d 1 J D r a k ; p+ x M?i `z x."+ f # f, , ' '?'Pd To?a 1 TtS Total Sublet 0.00 Total Deductible 0.00 Total Misc 0.00 I P T J 51{ 'k- b il! k Y '? Y f yMkl ?k #' 1- 4 y MY 5 yJ /w? . ia?c?iiLy-Wt i Q r s` Yx V P ' "F ' ? Y y l }- k ,? 1?: k F o !1 ] ,4 '& - p i' 4 >iP z-s 5l. YSkt Y kluY' i ic a f ^ k T P ' 3 ? ?? {{ k? ?p3'f ?C7?t ?? .+ I ?A ? ^i. Y "a ?y flu ? a ?. f' a y gy ' x q?4 ? P ? i? ?'? M1 % ? ? t, Y b& , ? :+S a yL } • n v e m 1 ..- '°5'6" .y _ . .,M1 4tre ; 3 . EMENDED WARRANtt PAV iACTORY WARRPNtt PAY ALL LA80R CHgRGEB ARE B l l cn ON FIAT RAZE RNAL ESTIMATE TOTAL OfSijm?H PAV T + HOUR3lAVLESS OTHBnMSE NOTED 0.00 JStOfI'19f )nature A RM SOLUTIONS, INC. (889) 343.5888 13989 8/99 7325047 IAR.Y NEU13AUM 10 W SHADY IN NOLA, PA 17025 [OME: 732-5047 3 BUS: 772-6254 72 1 GENBAN 1 6791/6792 r cw nznur UPTIONS: DLR:68512 ENG:2.7_Liter_MPI 150CT03 160CT03 ALL THE, REFASTEN 4 9 3 1 2 FAARLY OF DFAURSfffS *INVOICE* NM 6039 Carlisle Pike CHRYSLER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep, (717) 766-7686 PAGE 1 Web Site: www.brennerchryslerjeep.com E-mail: brennercj@earthlink.net SERVICE ADVISOR: 1 r,7 Prv PA nnnrrt,n CONNNECTOR 'RTS: 0.00 LABOR 0.00+ OTHER. 0.00 TOTAL LINE A 0.00 *** VERIFIED AIR ?u11rA1 f3ETsTENST HECK THE C302 CO 1'i3 B?A?.'3?1B ?t0`f7D TOR SECURELY AND 6788.: The Factory warranty constitutes ell of the warranties with respect to LABORAMOUNT ® the sale of this harrifitions. The Seller hereby expressly disclaims all PARTS A T IVI warranties, either express or implied, ina.ding any implied , LUBE GAS, OIL, LUKE warranty of merchentablllty or fitness for a particular purpose SUBLET AMOUNT CHRYSLER Jeep . Seller neither assu mes nor assu authorizes h MISC. CHARGES an, any ot er person m assume for it any liability in FIG ES TOTAL CHA ® ® connection with the sale of this tern/Items. I LESS INSURANCE SALES TAX CUSTOMER SIGNFTURE I PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT BAG LIGHT ON. CUSTOMER COPY sneer-T / Dye L O e ?STOMER COPY • - Beaver Springs, PA 17812 ,570) 658-0700 CUSTOMER COPY :USTOMER NO. - - LICENSE# STOCK# DEALER# INVOICE DATE INVOICE# 14161 3299 68512 12/02/2003 031513 :USTOMER NAME &ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT -LOT #/HAT# COLOR DELIVERYDATE GARY/BETH NEUBAUM 7463M 7463M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 610 W SHADY LN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L 12/02/2003 12/02/2003 VEHICLE ID# TECH &# P.O.# ENOLA PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP 5. W. IM. EST. 1 3102 VENDED WARRANTY CO. POUCY # DEDUCTIBLE AUTHORIZATION # ADJUSTOR NONE 0.00 ESIDENCE PH O N E BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY SIGNATURE 71 7 C; Q4 7 ? ? y ? ${ ,t yry? ?'li MwtRl*^„!!P ?"}?TI ?Ia.TM/ANtd.e}41?"'Y'i:.Sf.T?iTh,Y Y ,b '??.B?fb?'£y ?#aMa'?.ve'<..?e't '! {Xr.?.'-i.0c[;Y ?a' .w FI ?:._f.?'1T"1? I{ `?aj:,. q .1 ..11T'..f?}, uuY : ladh Mrd{z.'??`:# w'?c rY+».-x:;'14 `Mgre'?.iyifi I'P1:.d SS: 1 e [n Y'r?.Jw.'_Iw.!_R K '4?d4RCak.?'?.1' t4fi tRt.A a1. '?I•:j?,,,,. 5"'t r'?2 : ( 1 I' E z ,? •:rLw? I" i.'?r'iT"?r"'? _ '?^? . zd )emu _=eq xs•. z.i `'F t a s A 0.5 CPDRO LUBE OIL FILTER 6745C 01 r`'a g'` `3iktrq+@!t< rtt }`fir rtr? tt "t x {u¢dur,'?``,R?u 7?bO .LLL'a a,.nu'sf. R,..+o `3i y2 {5.k ???sh( Y4' r !} a.1'35. '.. t A{' 4d ?h`i F(£Yxi}ii? ? t( Jn$ -?V+ M1 (? 4?''t, diU' to ?{ 31, ?o6'' 'J O8h'rvY '„ 1i?i i ? R 5-Fe S '.w4- ';"? 1n4'? -]rry. I?Idf A f ) 1 t .,p h^i d ^ ? ? a k .? ? .yif . g d$ Y p i F uxt Al{IS}x'r {? rho>+ft'r.? /` ''' `?'+y*''I'i?Yl ????'=lr..? .?"?a`°r{'u -wv AY?L k r-r p 4" ar t " (kY??Sh`tl?7y?k"? yyr a? P ?e?? ? ??? p ??a"IF?EL ??? $ ? ?xd L' ?'§? q!f ''s{{ 'd LT + ? ` ' F ? . r V6 f 4 y SFa i A % ? t} 'TM 'H"' f" h W e; x Sv S r.i ul µ a rtM 4 W yyy.T ?e? $'((,,,, <Y ( 9 i R + _ a£ ,,. .. _L.iM1 "'n YLiT. .,!.,: •u_N.u?a,{ e i?'=L ...r?nt,Z ..k... aP :-0m.Y r:l I fv^Y i % ShopSupples -- ? -- 0:60 Job A Total Parts & Labor 21.95 wJ 3 { E:'??} i R aW" 4r,47 ?tt+l'43 "S aE. rT d t s` nP a lr u a R4a?"d ?Ti -[ht I >l1 u _ Yi '"'.'#_y?.?! lb'" C' may. did' +d ?-.? ToM1l?ti ? =4t >,?"? y ^4 T?k '{ Nr= hl'LyIF "J?Ea°.t ?. vt43{ NYFVEi?? R 5? {# pr t Ya`S ?y?y ? YNh 1 - 4? ? "A.1= rr? r5 yf?.p,. ? /A£ '4 ? 3; $ Y_1G d-0,.)ftif .rf l E? +r. T' Y :.. dT C " TTyR1 ?. Q. '? 'i , HiSr t E £ 'P W' fihT 21 N ?` al M1 Y ? ?t ?? ` ? ? . .I Li to P ?. ..d E, 4 ? :; r d 5..u ? ?T%rv.r.'?.? ? as Gm >R ?'; "?.5 C ! rv } d-t>pE >w Y owv k aFY?}'Y nr Rt +'&l "kz I.:M1 #. "" - 6745C 02 ROTATED TIRES 14.95 - Job B Total Parts & Labor 14.95 I$ ??` tw ?iftryt.?a ??'t k ?3T'tJLa sY. k.,: ,. ? K: ,y,,T'f ?+u AkeE; -?xiyr -uR?x i.i ? atvY v'?'F r 1'FFF ru d.?? 'IT Y'?I is f i'-?/ - ><: C3 p s k n 5i L "' FT:' ?akliq'! 4 ) a tl 'd' Yry k?r'P ,} 5{' 4 Ais 'yy ,{ ,p KY °k f f=.?` 41, 1 ,Y'` TMi ku EGt.itl 4.d?d'*? S uX ieY 4•Yn Y A 1§.+ '$ a R b 3 a8yr An 13 e a ?}? ? ?#?` :u;, T =' yk s'? + ? ?`i {C°f aC ? ?? 44 ? ? ? ' " ' ? ? i iy'ATMer n 0 t ri 3€IS >< vFi v a ff? '??k+? ?}: r t t & ^ " , . ..c_ .. _ ,.,. .ae. na L m ..fki ... v.+tt.Ner §. >.ia x.T_ 2{Y"g ar , t X vxa? ? , ,....,,µ l?,y? rua a ! +?+m .. 9712C INSTALLED FRONT MUDFLAPS 0.00 1 82203671 GUARD KIT-SPLAS 10.50 d: M1 ArT? y`?4 r '?9I 44`'RuFr"° E .'".'II aCT u? d h 'diet I I,Y.R ^?t.L'? 05S 't.k ? L Fri f r r'Etw T„ '? at ",.3 „"n ,A P,b ft z?`,?" ?r?. `1 iP .4iw?YW i -?" 4-43! Y " `SS,,r?,y' r.l''4)tZ. "t aOS'ury f 51F.d. ?'G1 ri e { p rva 9 9Y ? y?, 4S .?4E V? iY ??id ^y ^s } 9? ?! ?k`a q ??R. t p;^'R 1?'d }'?y ?'? IH 1 d? ? ' ` d M" ' L u i. ` ? k 4A(?" 4' Y P- f 1?? ?£L uag a Y `? ? 4 ? ?A . ? ? ?, t q ? ? ?n -p? i ? . > tr . rv 16 W . ' t Nk ?S"'P dr i .L ^ry^tfd 9e-1 +: 46} }4,fY}R4 g i ?Ft; ? ?2ry d,.?X;4y §rv*b i.y?r?Tl ?.d:a'2'4`:?S„ Pt'"i[??'£S9Pri??jy. ?F`Mg?a r''??'?ff"?A4Y-A 2 f y ?S'd? >Np 8 d f e.'"fM1"?a n ?- 3x r? +ytt` 4 ik '$f q ar : (s i I t rd t II ! F"'7 [£ ;: Yc m f k .?T _. }+ ir# <AJ, 9'h ;Y '9R?t''?q . ttr Yd.£3hn' 'i` e€`u.S ?ytr, 3 'g. <.r.A n dyr'' nit 4 uu +i KN: T Y y 'Yr i } !" yy ,y?i'RS +' Rf fi. Y'a k'?dL.d `T?1 { S LIM 4fl ?Y',{P J£4 s"x1 ? ?' m` Y t N. 1.-1 `i '.F .,?` I ? ivra'.{ ">'? ,' ri y:?5 frl d'Jd )?t} pk !. d( ry. 'x 'h? 13;,{ £ `??? {"T IN'x'vT ,+:, tN' ? ? I ?¢ 1 I' qi ?I 3??R rNi''d a€"" s 5 r h { .t Ry Total Su?1et? ? 0.00 ` - Total Deductible 0.00 Total Misc. 0.60 ^?J "" ald Ta ?j rL {Y ?"13 ?'j{ m^+-y ro "r^'x 5°`:i i a ? T:.b '!i . bl r -5rt zF std +4"r ?U`?# x 4 t<k S,d rrr: a a?",vt&F'?r-"' ?.. Isr.?" Y se ?'?? a f t4 N ytrtyzar i 53.???G???*T i s t +Q a?`? t A[ "Y? + }[?' Y d 'r X V y "M1 A 'i C J('i h. tit y'Eµ k ! S f N k T H 1 d? ? 1 ?Y ? !?? i F 1 tp iF S " I ( 1 t d 1 EXTENDED WARRANTY PAY FACTORY Wg9RgNiV PAY ALL LABOR CHARGES PRE 61L1FD ON FLAT RATE RNAL MMAM iOTP1 UUSTOMER PAY HWRS UNLESS OTHERW e- N= 50.89 ustomer 3nature X )RM SDLUTIDNS, INC. 15881343- 086 N 3988 6/99 4 ) Low -?' Mfq r q rius Pd ck G7?? BYtier->! 3 09 0 9TOMER COPY leaver Springs, rA 7 /67Z (570) 658.0100 CUSTOMER COPY USTOMER NO. LICENSE# STOCK# DEALER# INVOICE DATE INVOICE '3?G4 S 7 G U O NAME&ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT LOT.#/HAT# COLOR DELIVERY DATE GARY'/BETH NEUPAUM e T: T. 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 610 W SHADY LN T.' n4/1 a 0 - VEHICLE # TECH & # P.O. # ENOLA PA 17025 T S OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. INT. EST, 76 MENDED WARRANTY CO. POLICY # DEDUCTIBLE AUTHORIZATION # ADJUSTOR tJ1UtIV t YMuNt, Shop Supplies ---------?? Jnb A -Total-- Part s- &-Labor ROTATED TIRES TO HAVE EVEN TREAD ON FRONT OF VEHICLE Job B Total Parts & Labor Total Sublet 0.00 Total Deductible 0.00 39.76 CPDRO LUBE OIL FILTER 'Ustomer lianoture X °ORM SOLUTIONS, INC. (8881 363-6009 iM 2988 6/99 s7aier->, 3 LULAL&WLIPL114 .`11 5 STOM$R COPY Cam Beaver Springs, PA 17812 (570) 658.0100 CUSTOMER COPY USTOMER NO. UCENSE# STOCK# DEALER# INVOICE DATE INVOICE# 14161 3299 68512 04/19/2004 033155 IUSTOMER NAME &ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT LOT WHAT# COLOR DELIVERY DATE GARY/BETH NEUBAUM 10416M- 10416M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 610 W SHADY LN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L 04/19/2004 04/19/2004 _ VEHICLE ID# TECH &# _ P.O.# ENOLA PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. IM. EST. 6674 1 XTENDED WARRANT/ CO. POLICY # DEDUCTIBLE AUTHORIZATION # ADJUSTOR NONE 0.00 IESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY SIGNATURE u s...,: .. .. ._v..,. ...=za, e. nu ..::u . ,i __.n :. .• .o,'.--: ..., _,am> ..r. at. ..G r v..r r xxr r?._.,a.ae2,. .,x... .-i,.n riJ WCDRO CUSTOMER STATES REAR DEFROSTER DOESN'T WORK HAD CODE FOR PASSENGER SIDE TERMINAL OPEN, ctxECntiJ CONNECTOR UNDER SEAT AND MADE SURE TERMINALS WERE TIGHT, CLEARED CODES AND ROAD TESTED-CODE DID NOT RESET Total Deductible Total Misc. 0.00 0.00 D.00 0.00 WCDRO CUSTOMER STATES DRIVERS DOOR MAKES NO HAD TO ORDER DRIVERS SIDE DOOR CHECK Customer Signature x FORM SOLUTIONS, INC. IBM) 34346806 HM 39M 6/99 E;Si3.er->, s uv STOMER COPY heaver springs, t-A 7/d72 (570) 658-0100 CUSTOMER COPY USTOMER NO. LICENSE# STOCK# DEALER# INVOICE DATE INVOICE * 14161 3299 68512 05/19/2004 033522 USTOMER NAME&ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGE OUT LOT#/HAT# COLOR DELIVERY DATE GARY/BETH NEUBAUM 11763M 11763M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 610 W SHADY LN _ 03CFRYSLER SEBRING L 05/19/2004 05/19/2004 VEHICLE ID# TECH &# P.O.# ENOLA PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. INT. EST. 1 6874 KrENDED WARRANTY CO. POLICY# DEDUCTIBLE AUTHORIZATION4 ADJUSTOR NOISE 0.00 ESIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY SIGNATURE ?YY P,AR?. ?,+P.GTk2AfE.;'f' ?[?WMAT??.., 4'>u1 n z; 4Y,MRWpI(bt?A.Vy?gf".. ?hx; a'. u ."s1. 4kti?..atA?.} rcAS?'i's? uAf?kk7?,. ?,Y,t rt„r,? dM''z4. ':.i? T. nT'`d?e9, £ .:. z'kY C. ;1AfnCh.?knCttmlR ?.? „4 ? .A. V. x. '?' _. M9 . x tafEr v4'? h.+rl"?4{ i'HA(>? ..,?'l . L% 2 a A X.X WCORO CUSTOMER STATES DRIVERS DOOR IS NOISEY WHEN OPENING 435OW .. .. " i "r} 5f' t.x,W 1@.A'.G U?Y "@ I V"' $','?'IF+k Yr:... "14 fT Y @ j4 Yri {'^J? t ! 4-?( .{? ???I }{ 1 ;?: ?R?y?t+b # tIJi ?}y3 JT ?>j? IA 1 „yn1 ,. Ty*t aM ii'?? N?rv++t wl?+^N%# @YR, 3`i?:@ 4, Jk n# xY 4a V' } al ?F"? `Y ? ? ?? d ,'? 'E kK ,? ? ? , s+tdl'E"Y?a 3 i <4 ?" 2Ng `?F t ?' 1&yai??•? 3 . ?t[? t t" rJ '' ` hrI L q' ,?. ,y 'S atk_ _ia`fi1x'r dtw.,e".nN""oJ„a.''A'?xef.,F Y ' 4 k.i B X.X WCDRO CUSTOMER STATES REAR DEFROSTER IS INOP. AT THE BOTTOM ----4350W------.-_ FOUND GRID DID NOT HAVE CONTINUITY AT LOWER HALF, NC $.?',? ??,R?v-. I??r vsnr-i?^ ????v IT:?. .'?I*%??I"?a„ "*?'? w??"? '?.?'.'? ? "'*!?'fia ?k.?# +? rGm' r r^w S,i ?+ i' s wK e f r'k ., .. i -ki "# .• # ?'i 444 ?. ,?R 4 t`?"`"?y'" ?1 ?'et ???'th ? P S3 IN, F1.fL.Yk.i ??{{?s's'yg?,.{.i:??14 kaiFi?'Syi ?'l"3t???T.?. ?'p6'`?- ci`E `3G'.?F '?'?q?.? ?-?+T i 10 F 5 ?v "^YU "C g,. + '." ? l?f'+{F it ? r ?. k B'i?'iYY?Ey ?Yq?Y,ir?!"'x"`r #? ? "AAN ,+ ,y ? h d ` I T !R 1 ? !T Y , n ,, ,r q w_z t k R i .. is . f r F r ? 1 k 0. 1 I `$ x "R { ?'P3 ? h ? "'Y? *1?@. k?vl A„ ?^ # ; }P B'YF• 4 i•T•^rf T?.T? $? ? i f .. i iY'.- T d %@ zX P fi + d Y !_ ?$ ? d S? H+ ? ? 'C Fi?Ma ?JF?LK }?''i?,rv?"C1 F ?. -4 }c M ? ?? Y6 4-' ?? r AA ?i' -yh 4?e4 ? ?`b ?? ??Iv ?? F ! r 1] S. f£i 2 :, ,?5„"Np ? Y ? iW'' ,.:.ik V ^? q'.#yro??l?y?i. 'b?t,V N 1 Yit[`N!ypp. 6 y k ? ) r?ii ?i( ?, In 4 '? 'kt sSS4 'nz, it .?}y?.r ?%A'" * ' T A u i tt -b' $ a p y#? e c x 4 i uYE. d ?L ujt? r. x p ?+ y P-r t v a y rc $ 4? $ 'q" V x r h+ t & ? a .x $`.0 1 }r' 9.1"'h v ?a ( fii t% ?? t R y Sii i 'P ki ?1i ? ? ? ? N ? `Y . , . ? v1 j.?0 " ? Y 4 .T"'i%i u, 4rwNJ@???niFn ,?i,. ra v„.aP { . + L3?. Y, .$'.3:k?.?( ?' •'. -.L °.Y'? ,n%?vk,..i?'.Lll ,: Y£??S R4?`'a ?P1 i? u . .. ?{ ?r+k A`?Y!F" it`M+f,? 2v??'{='><#S F3.4::? y"'>J?_. ,='+`11A.l.rxi y Ff f?' t3G „@4$n?i? ir'?VY .?.? "fpR l? I di a k€"t A+tY,. T [e R'1 t4 a ' » 1 +a ? ?' r ' ? ? " 4'4"rc Ir E ,Y " !Y t. y t wJ# E. [ 4 I t ) k C ?`} ,iY f?.Njt 1 t6 ?Y { A rz?g$?? 3 f ? 4"x:`"?b ?Y Y .@? ?7??yy?? d N Fr rvt+"i g? W ? a'?' II?C .Yry.y 4" (?i k i 3a ?I s-i. F P? dV4. t r ?x } !Y h ,4 4'"Rii } Ct' I $? } 0 JkRpLp?, k£ ? . ? ? `,TaT -u? {?i v# Y,ii tb ;6,'£t" F C' kY Y i d + ? ?? ? ? ? ? ? A n .r+r q y., y .. n ?'( Fi` a 4T ># , Y < x W , ,H k hy@ %: A?'?YFl" S Lll ? `?31yY' .pr 'S4ri" r a+? intl. ':L+ + i w ? ? ? : A H f?? h ? d4 -y 3G. ? A m r Vt rv Ao "h a ""J(5y yY,YW S 2'at ?sli-`y[Ch? ? ?L 'f` "1! tt S p? ?7Y U S ? } x T J ?1??. ? 1Jh YY FG' °d It F`it' {Q(.? { , ? n ? - Total Sublet 0.0 Total Deductible 0.00 Total Misc. 0.00 ??.r yrx fp 3w ?e4?t. ? f,: r -4?e2E, Y4.'x?''Ax ?": 'w"? #r l '4 ?T, r PT # Ts isrt ?d ?¢?d +15"t. T' ?" ??' ,' .n i .@I£ A SI 3iY`' ?4'# Y drCl 4 i 5 k tLA} Pkra` y '3,' .S I j+<S.gY 9y1 iy? i } 4 1FF 1 5 Q X Y °1 ' ? I F' 1' l? M " " rc ? ? ? ? + Y A" !L? . f Y :.M [ . 41+ IYt Y;.'. W 1- f Y j. ( + ?! r u 'tw '?, k `t t{° I ..z: i ?".h7+L4x'.tal 'Ak w?aa?." na'ir a '? Y` It tr. H,F ra t# I x . 7 ? r '?"?. ar a ?%. ,?" V 7 ?ivv?"f?95Ad+ r,Vx p S? >, "`s ,=iK ? S 4 I ,,. +u 1 r? s?= M * 'I' ? ' ? ? ? ?- . , . ? s s t -1 [SX. ; ,4Jw.+. }I, h n . h'A .Si. « ?iv.. A. bS .,i? .., 1 ? W o .. 'S?4 Y5 ?Y n..}S S .ro-e ,M x, n.v " M . ?? 7 AL EXTENDED WARRANIYPAY FACTORY WARR4Nrv PAV ALL LABOR CHPRGR PRF BLLIED OIJ FIAT RAZE FlNALRTIMAIE iOTgL CU6fOMER PAY HOUR3 UNLESS OIHERWi9E NOTED 0.00 :ustomer ignoture X ORM SOLUTIONS, INC. (888) 3636006 IM 3988 6199 s;iier->? 3 10" 2 PRINT # 1 0 LM STOMEP. COPY Beaver Springs, PA 17812 (570) 658-0100 CUSTOMER COPY JSTOMER NO. UCENS-e# STOCK4 DEALER# INVOICE DATE INVOICE# 14161 32.99 68512 08/21./2004 034850 JSTOMER NAME &ADDRESS MILEAGE IN MILEAGEOUT -COT #/HAT# COLOR DELVERY DATE GARY/BETH NEUBP_UM 14327M 14327M STERL 03/11/2003 YEAR/MAKE/MODEL PROD. DATE R.O. DATE 610 W Saz0Y LN 03CHRYSLER SEBRING L s 08/21/2004 08/21/2004 . VEHICLE ID # TECH & # P.O. % ENOL.A PA 17025 1C3EL65R13N526172 OVERRIDE SERVICE WRITE UP S. W. IM. EST. 1 0925 RENDED WARRANTY CO. POLICV% DEDUCTIBLE AUTHORIZATION# ADJUSTOR NONE 0.00 :SIDENCE PHONE BUSINESS PHONE SERVICE WRITER DELIVERY SIGNATURE { w e o6 ?tw +.xr r { ? b, 4 c z{e a ,_ ,., .+, cww F,}T., a 4 y¢I '). L'J a"?aBH xl ft kCf??{??}} •' 1 ;p b ? +, 4 `r?rs?a rrv `'s?H? ++"s°>•?`I ., YIFk?.4X'bB:TU? "' 4i 4rv rz ,u tt' i._`?i?. rFf 4£4"4?.. 2IS e??"? ?uA°v. ?7 s 0 . . k-? s r ?.,8 x .'>•' ",Fri'A?ifP,Kf Y, W, -s3 .' MpSrdrke66 i^;c r £ ? fl 5 r {. "?f JAIixOtlPJ1?Ory x 1 ! - T ??.}., A 0.5 CPDRO LUBE OIL FILTER 01 8226C i?cyy pp'?? Styr (3?5 ? .a'dA'?.?'' ?t Y4 3 x M IfFM1.fe7r?j '^1'?? 7^n'A '?' ?Jd 1 ?''?* k ?? {'? ?.: Ji? L J? ^GMA}, M~ Y Y?r +.Y' 1 f Zxir Y f.- ??i FS?.J l•; r ?f F"}h i' a"?jWj F xi r"W }' s ffryl' YVp,F 4?a{' S-s .t b/ tmY^ESA il r. ?wc;`>t}e v -E?i1T2 w?' 4 Y n t 15 y4C} f`'x' & %i, Tr,,$,?, a C y y k tJj t( a?g= %M "fx iI ( ` ? VF ? ? R ? gu 1 ?1 x" .u f r 3i i! A IF `f' - '..ry 4 -N T[$ I;+ T} IraNx? iii?n g? yn3? k ,T ?.?dE?-0 E E" .;1 es.w ' .6 Shop Supph b Job A Total -Parts &--Labor - 22.95 Sales-.Tax 1.42 y +':+ tom, rJ y 1 „ y- w'F ?v. h -.-rl'em ,a- .I` p TM1 J }T 1 lN.b 6 'S iR + -'i -:' m-{ F? *y,.? (F I'{}yF } 1 ' 11 '"P v ?yq?FY 9: iT y '?Ar ?? i Vq R j4k' ?iyy LY +n'£ { i 1 £° ?h3?'{,.) ?! v,? ? nw4xvp i r a't3?kkF ? ? ' « ?Yx ?Y,R,?FY'i` -M1_ ? 'F , ?'i 4 r? 5'?. }rM1 lyp.!?' kti?'e ? q d ?V'?h? kk d A V ?v y"?iY ?'^F 1 v h+d ? f bi-'k?'4p?li, F ?tV?v? ?.1t.'6 ? S r i ?Y b E " aY ?5 S id? ? ' x - 1?$ F'iJ3T+ ri Q ?` ? ' Y I? ?? ¢ ? y fi i? sa yp w ; ?5, 1, i ? "ta3"? `gy??? #R y {ME?pj, ,?J?k`t SrS ".? ? r °? iJ,3 ;+ ^dJdy;a ?y try pp `.,{? C A g STP_TE INSPECTION VEHICLE NEEDS EMISSION STICT??'R i. V V"' 4 O - COULD NOT INSPECT AT THIS TIME - Job B Total Parts & Labor 0.00 („ q{.xa€ 4ry'31 {T"`" }?„. y€{ { 5?y$P,? N"lPF J?{?Y y,i J lm'"? .1'4D 'Y y T•r-'. -AS `4 Ei [ _:. tiu E ,_ i ,4 F 5 k 3~ ( Im Pi M +1 R:4J?{ ?rk'x YP'?i H l a.W [i ?r ?a y?.. .?{F hyS { ] ? t? '?t'c y \ } ?p ¢': 'vat6.111nYW4i{k SZ_ yA'rT.$ '{c v5 F ?JFSg R4? xl t 4x ?£' Md1J. { pp r 3Scx36 Ay Acrv`tik" {uta x.;"{ , F ' A E dk1+} e aF PT 4 °?-I'Ni< x i. ,a, 4Td' tie a ry> *(Gc x d ar ,r}v 4 ? Pd -A-rs 2 P x a$ io e {IL'Y `' -s'"4?' *uR,,, { +'„ ?r"" n.»Tyz ,w"'"ii t' slag "'S* d I t'«+ka?r '? ` x J v' Y T? 3 k ?m w ..3 P,e A { L ... _ Y.? )- t ' ?tl ? ba L4. ?v r: T=>_F ?w?6 ? ur?z:t.. Til ?`.. , 3k, c, .?a ,i.-. 3 < Y. 1 ) •. _ , ....F Y l?'i wk I1 3 a - ? y , , _."? . ?.. ... .. . J Iiy.T' `^ Sr}Sry I "ht4 k { 4 r h''b r Vi`A' R3{y i..'NY.. }Y'.... Y m CA '` f I r+ rk Y Y 5 ^.G 1. y I "' ?k5-W' 't5 1: 1N X' ?,4" Pl {#,?!rr V' f J 4,Tif r +,F}'Tr hM? tt a e y nAA €` a e fl..? b+ T { n1 dd T w } } s' 'i H p y y%M1 S P tb' 1 5 {i AC la"r "._ h4 3 4 } i C Y{ k jrA f k i'}t iY -6 a { ! I X Y` ^ ° ? 4 ? k y T } . ?, i" m"y b ? "i ? Y M Y 6 S 4l 1 `. SA'J' S 4a ?? g rtv F hLp ( ! }.u lP ?.tN hY k.,. 1 T r? J4`Fbd ?"i ' lr`i ?y?.e) -'1 ? G? ?J ? I'i ? ,{Id„ J R'*?i ? ???} AYE ? ? ? iH?'.a T. j x `{ yR H4 ik 1- `,,FyyS a t{4.K T (tea r. '.. i A 'Ta L I 4r '. 1 T?`f t s P,.''. ydE' { I A ^ a F <?Y a Hgo W 3 ". i l s rr`? S- sX- AF yd?, N l6. i'.'„?AL°'.?',:4 t4 ?tx t Ym 2 n 7 Y u° `R1P a f,yyl,} } y'''6d 2 4,i;. y.? -P Y"ra?a +U tit `„5"fi[ slx tr r `Y}. UT 1JIt ?vabt7 4y ?A{ J ' ? "? ' k E ? a Y ,"+ `IA ?F er d; CU, .' G.N^ YaH *a j d ,xE..ai{+zN yt i5 ?f t 44 ?' N ka't1 a A- s} iC4 1: Ft"it',}F,¢rq'+4 x?PY'EAs" A?ydY?$i Tota`1 Sublet " ' ' " 0:60"""` Total Deductible 0.00 Total Misc. 0.65 fe'i ?n ;,R'yz9f i'reT{ '' { .`.' I r "'rf{:'.. t ? d kc> r s a'1??aY?CId't'14 ' T3,0 ., ''' T x+?, +dk 1 ?j ed Y a3.v ?. N?3 }S?TnIk ?rfi? ry 2:s: T£a rfiMT'• '3.+ykv ?.6,,y YYa 4 r a bfi 3} t ' EXTENDED WARRANtt Pq1' .FACTORY WARRANM1'PAV P11lABOR CHARuE3 ARE BILLED qV RAi RATE FlNAL E9RMATE TOTPL N6TOMER PAY HOURS LM4E66 OIHERWl3E NOIED 25.02 Ustomer gnature X )RIM SOLUTIONS, INC. 16681 343,6006 M 3966 6199 2Y NEUBAUM ) W SHADY LN DLA, PA 17025 vIE: 732-5047 LL:372-9588 7325047 BUS:772-6254 64008 *INVOICE* PAGE 3 SERVICE FA1!'MY OF DEALERS Fiff S, ® 6039 Carlisle Pike CHUSIER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep, ® (717) 766-7686 Web Site: www.brennerchryslerjeep.com E-mail: brennercj@earthlink.net TO 68512 MPI ************************************************ ** *C7SZ()MR S3ATES Y3ILE DIIWING '1 RT ENDk'EEi S 'fOIIGH !:. W ARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE E: 0 00 ******* ROAD TESTED CAR WITH SHOP FOREMAN CAR SEEMS To BE SHOW HIM CONCERN *t#+k*4t**Yc fr ?s sF*&iE44 a,#at*rE?:#ak#*#*'1c?rdEF*Ue*dE#?k?#'7e#Mt Y: ik *ytynk "Z" INDICATES NON-FACTORY PART. The faCtDry warranty ell war mrstiltutbS of the with th respect respect LABOR AMOUNT a of this the sale hiss t[e s. The he t expressly disclaims all Seller hereb FARTS AMOUNT ® ® y either express or warranties, i li GAS, OIL, LURE mp ed implied, i nclutlmerchantability any warranty of or SUBLET AMOUNT CHRYSLER Jeep fitness for a particular icular purpose' Setter neither assumes nor MISC. CHARGES eumorizes any other person to assume for it an)' IiabllkV in TOTAL CHARGE: ® ® connection with the sale of this Itemlitems LESS INSURANCI . SALES TAX CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY --- --- -- - - 7325047 6 4 0 0 8 FANUY OF DFAURSRWS *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike RY NEUBAUM CHRYSLER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 JBepe 0 W SHADY LN ® (717) 766-7666 OLA, PA 17025 PAGE 2 web Site: www.brennerchryslerjeep.com ME:732-5047 BUS:772-6254 E-mail:brennercj@earthlink.net T.T.•772-9SAR SERVICE ADVISOR: 167 ROGER PARKER NS DLR:68512 ENG:2.7 ARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 6.6o OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE B: 0.00 336 ****** VERIFIED PASS SIDE FRT WINDOW WILL SHAKE WHILE RASSING AND CGHTEND NUT TO PROPER TORQUED VERIFEED GLASS GOES UP AND DOWN SMOTE HEATED WINDOW-Te 1 5093179AA CLIP PKG-HEATED REAR WIND (N PART#: 5093179AA C{3UNT f: 1 .. CLAIM TYPE: W ?1UTH C`ODEs ....................... ARTS: 0.ifl(3 LA130R: U.QO' OTHER. U 00 TOTAT IEE D:S 3?.0t1 236 ** ***** VERTFI O R D'SPROSTEl TN PI: MEMO: F P., EFROSTER FOUND WIRE CONNECTOR BROOKEN LOOSE FROM REAR WINDOW CHECKED TAR ON ,INE FOR POSI:sL E REPAIRS KITS FO[lkD REtP TRS KIT SOLD8pED TW6 The tacmry warranty constitutes all of the warramles with respect to LABOR AMOUNT the sale this item/items. The Seller hereby expressly disclaims ell PARTS AMOUNT ® warranties, either express or i nfNd an im lied lied im GAS, OIL, LUBE y p p , , y of or merchantability SUBLET AMOUNT CHRYSLER Jeep fitness for a particular icular purpose. fitness Seller neither assumes nor MISC. CHARGES authorizes any other person in assume for it any liability in TOTAL CHARGES ® ® connection with me sale of this Itam(rtems. LESS INSURANCE SALES TAY, CUSTOMER SIGNATURE I PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY ¦ Wi M '7 m mm 0 ? ml m _N 7325047 6 4 0 0 8 FM LY OF DEALERSHIPS *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike tY NEUBAUM CHRYSIER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep. ) W SHADY LN ® (717) 766-7686 )LA, PA 17025 PAGE 1 Web site: www,brennerchryslerieep.com 4E:732-5047 BUS:772-6254 E-mail:brennercj@earthlink.net -oCtoa SERVICE ADVISOR: 167 ROGER PARKER OPTIONS: DLR:68512 ENG:2.7 Liter I OUT IZITEFNAf DEFECT USE. 08191601 MODULE,SENTRY.KEY. 166 FC: 58 PARIS iI 57 070,54AA COUNT: 1 CLAIM <;'I`3LF!E:` t"1 AUTH CODE: 1RTS: 0.00 ******** VERIFIED AND GROUND AT : COUNT: 00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL 00 DRB TESTED HAD BOTH PRESSENT BUS AUTH CODE: The factory warranty constitutes all the warranties with respect to LABOR AMOUNT thth the sale this items The Seller hereby expressly disclaims all PARTS AMOUNT warranties, , either express s or li i d GAS, OIL, LU BE mp e implied, InclutlinB any warranty of merchantability or SUBLET AMOUNT CHRYSLER Jeep fitness ,pr a particular rpo Seller neither assumes s nor nor MISC. CHARGES authorizes any other person to assume for it any liability in TOTAL CHARGES ® ® connection with the sale of this kam 'hems LESS INSURANCE , . SALES TAX CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY GO ON RIDE WITH SHOP "Z" INDICATES NON- A- A W The factory warranty constitutes all of the warranties with reaped to LABOR AMOUNT 0, the sale this res. The Soler hereby expressly disclaims all PARTS AMOUNT O warranties, , either express or In any i implied, GAS, OIL, LURE 0 . warrant at warranty of merchantability ty or fitness for a articuier ur ose SUBLET AMOUNT O CHRYSLER Jeep p p p . Seller na@har assumes nor MISC. CHARGES . authorizes any other person to assume for it any liability in TOTAL CHARGES O. ® ® connection with the sale of this hem/hems. LESS INSURANCE 0. SALES TAX 0 CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT .... ...__.."_n CUSTOMER COPY COLD 66ISADC S 8371 ******# T I ETJ D E S 3 E TiAS ! E'EAI RCA t NG T SPECTED PEAKER INTERNAIL SHORT IN SPEAKER ORDERED NEW SPEAKER A-:etrr #**'#**k 9e*3F yra4#+et#&*,F4##ft;*#?r***+c>k.kfl?*+Y*+,k;tF irk CUSTOMER STATES THERE IS A FLUID LEAK FROM THE ENGINE AREA, CLEARISH ---- -LOOKINGFIiUZD 166 WC4 FC: 71 - PART#:: 50156?6AC . ;° COUNT: 1 CLATM:tTYPEr.W AUTH CODE: ARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER 0.00 The factory warranty constitutes all of the warranties with respect to the sale of this its ® Seller hereby expressly disclaims all © warranties, ether express s or express or implied, including any implied CHRYSLER Jeep warranty of mh. ror titles for a particular l=pear purpose. Seller neither assumes nor nor authorizes any other person to assume for it any liability in ® CDOneRIOn with the bale of this item/barns. B: SELONOID 0 LABOR AMOUNT PARTS AMOUNT _ GAS, OIL, LUBE SUBLET AMOUNT LESS INSURANC SALES TAX PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY 7325047 6 6 1 5 7 FAMII,Y OF DEALERSHWS *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike CRY NEUBAUM CHRYSH:R Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep. -0 W SHADY LN ® (717) 766-7686 IOLA,- PA 17025 PAGE 3 )ME:732-5047 BUS:772-6254 Web Site: www.brennerchr?sierieep.com E-mail:brennercj@eart Xlink.net 3LL:372-9588 SERVICE ADVISOR: 167 ROGER PARKER Coto fl YEAR : ia1AKElM130E1::: #1N <; 3.IC6,,:;5£ ;fV11LEA0l= INit? TA SUE 03 CHRYSLER SEBRING CON 1C3EL65R13N526172 GENBAN 19382/19382 T636 OPTIONS: DLR:68512 ENG:2.7 Liter MPI SEALS. ':4 4:r e Ix I I W, The factory warranty constitutes all of the winsmies with respect to the sale this. Item/Items. The Seller hereby expressly tllaclaims ell PARTS AMOUNT i , warre either express m i dnclutl any I GAS, OIL, LURE i ran, t war warranty or or l merchantability i or fitness f r i l SUBLET AMOUNT CHRYSLER Jeep cu ar o a part cu ar purpose. purpose. Seller neither assumes nor MISC. CHARGES - ,, assume es any piker person to assume for it any liability in TOTAL CHARGES ® connection with the sale of this kam/Hams . LESS INSURANCE SALES TAX CUSTOMER SIGNATURE PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY RY NEUBAUM 0 W SHADY LN OLA, PA 17025 ME:732-5047 T.T.. "1'7r)-q r RR 7325047 BUS:772-6254 IS ? as -- as - --- - 6 6 1 5 7 EMMY OF DEAURSNiPS *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike IM CHRYSIEK Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep, (717) 766-7686 PAGE 2 Web Site: www.brennerGhryslerjeep.com E-mail: brennercj@earthlink.net SERVICE ADVISOR: 167 ROGER PARKER 1 DLR:68512 ENG:2.7 Liter MPI [ME * ai#ak**k r***>t 4r `X anyr ?..... it+#**^k?r k#*y!Et titi::'k?Fak#*+1e9k 9eaA`:k 9r**a¢*** CUSTOMER STTAES FRT PASS WINDOW WILL NOT GO DOWN AUTO MATICLLY ALL NRM NO REPAIRS MADE ARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0. 0. 11 9382 ******** COULD NOT DUPLICATE CUSTOMER CONCERNA THIS TIME OPERATED ONVERTZBLE`TOP SEUE PTI4L? WORKER FINE '??'.RY. TIC ???FI ?5 ??ERIFZE#9 . **************************************************** 02F FULL 17.15 93B2 ******* OTHER: 0.00 70 6.70 D: CUSTOMER STATES THERE IS STILL A FLUID LEAK FROM THE ENGINE, SEEMS YEL7TSHN fiaLOR 1 5010042AA *DYES )IE IN TRANS BLACK LIGHT ?URHTER LEAKS PRESSENT CHRYSLER 90BA FILTER Jeep_ The factory warranty constitutes all of the warranties with respect to the sale of this ftemfltems. The seller hereby ezpresely dlsclaims all warranties, either express or implied, Inducing any implietl warranty of memhantabil@y or fitness for a particular purpose. Seller neither assumes nor authorizes any other person to assume for It any Iiabliity, in connection with the sale of this Itemfltems. REPLACED AMOUNT LESS INSURANC SALES TAX PLEASE PAY THIS AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY ¦ men -1 N .N m 0 ohms -a 7325047 6 6 1 5 7 FAMMY OF DEALE,RSIf'S *INVOICE* ® 6039 Carlisle Pike 2Y NEUBAUM CHRYSIER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Jeep, D W SHADY IN (717) 766-7686 DLAr PA 17025 PAGE 1 Web Site: www.brennerchryelerjeep.com )4E:732-5047 BUS:772-6254 E-mail:brennercj@earthlink.net r,T,:472-asRR SERVICE ADVISOR: 16,7 ROGER PARKER OPTIONS: DLR:68512 ENG:2.7 Liter MPI NRM NO REPAIRS MADE 1s's CC1 a.; n `n a RRTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE A: 0.00 ********* VERIFIED CEL ON DRB SSED TEST NO LEAKS PRESSENT AT THIS TIME it rt+b*'k 7k dr# pr*tF ?4...?4?rYSeExvF ?c4<Yk?*ae dYC*k&Ie tFvk:k!.k'ab`kd-#ie s4?*3r*&9. +k:9t k* _ .. CUSTOMER STTAES NOISE FROM SPEAKER INSTALL S-O PARTS 03 166 WC4 FC 18 PARI# 56 66.5 AA COUNT: 1 CLALM;TYPE: AT 08600270 RADIO-Test and replace (C AUTH CODE: ARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE B: 0.00 ****** VERIFIED NOISE FROM factory ..rwarranty constitutes act all warranties with th respect to .................................. LABOR AMOUNT the the ante this rte s. The Seller hereby expressly blsvlelme all PARTS AMOUNT wied pl express of as, includin n an Im lied GAS, OIL, LUKE warrant f me g y p , warranty of mrti p or l i l fi f SUBLET AMOUNT CHRYSLER Jeep cu ar or a part cu ar purpose. tness Seller neither assumes nor MISC. CHARGES authorizes any v other parson no assume for a liability In TOTAL CHARGES ® ® connection mute with me e W. of this item/items. . LESS INSURANCE PLEASEPAY - THIS -AMOUNT CUSTOMER COPY FAMILY OF DF.AURSHWS ® 6039 Carlisle Pike CHMER Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 J"P. (717) 766-7686 Web Site: www.brennerchrysierieep.com E-mail: brennerci@eerthiink.net AMOUNT PAID BY COMMENT 35.35 CHECK 66157 154029 TOTAL RECEIVED: $35.35 GARY NEUBAUM 610 W SHADY LN DATE-TIME: 14APR2005 16:13 ENOLA PA 17025 CASHIER: STEPH LOCATION: 7325047 CASH DRAWER: ACCOUNTING DISTRIBUTION CO JOURNAL CO ACCOUNT AMOUNT CONTROL 2 56 2 11700 35.35 66157 2 10400 -35.35 66157 CONTROL2 NEU13AUM NEU13AUM CUSTOMER COPY ?? 13 Sep 14. 05 03:45p Kimberly Hoehing Esq 8565963350 p.2 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF PIULADELPHIA FIRST JUDICLAL DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL. TRIAL DIVISION SHIRLEY SOLCH and JOHN M. SOLCH Vs. KIA MOTORS AMERICA COURT OF COMMON PLEAS PHILADEL..PMA COUNTY NOVEMBER TERM, 2004 NO. 004625 ORDER AND NOW, this l?day of2005, upon consideration of the Motion to- Transfer Venue of Defendant, Kia Motors America, Inc., and Plaintiffs' response thereto, it is hereby ORDERED and DECREED that Defendant's Motion is DENIED. THE C T: COPIES S?Nr P 2361b1 PIlRSUA°n ? .? . APR 1 `?'ZU05 FIRSZ JUDiClAL015SRICT Ot:FA OSERIA:.???- DOCKETED COMPLEX LIT CENTER -ArH 1 S 2005 - J. STEWARF __.nc2QFn P.BERG .?g,?SQ?' 82?eit ?G,Ga . 0a 1)O11No. 89?? . me9 fosPl' went suit 204a VA 191x7 RN PLgAS phyla g6 210 : COL31?T OF CRS (215? IRS C. ySLF.RCRgpRB?TLON NO.22'f5 opofDefcn t-,.?1a63,?*g°" won ((pfo^ and WOOS ' SOW, flu`s ? l Non Comen,?na. for of yr a- or ka n id Q oa'sD D. 014 Nidd? to atydA?? ?, it'sab?°y RBV rbURT= y FP a R p. 238(b) PURSUNW DEC 17 ZO03 fs4wul s?CICA M Ub`Ct)•VNIYGS? ?! Sep 14 05 03:45p Kimberly Hoehing Esq 8565963350 p.4 GORBERG, GORBERG AND ZUBER By. D03MMQUE GRENMR, ESQUIRE Idendflication No- S9227 1234 Market Street Suite 2040 Philadelphia, PA 19107 (215) 563-7210 POCKETED CpMpLHX LIT CEM ER OCT 'G 9 2003 J. STMA9T, y attorney for Plaintiff THOMAS ALECK COURT OF COMMON PLEAS and P.A4MFJ A. ALECK PETILADEL.PHIA COUNTY Plaintiff V. APRIL TERM, 2003 DAEALERCHRYSLER CORPORATION Defendant AND NOW, thisy.olt X O"? 2003, upon consideration of Defendant's Motion to Transfer of Venue for Forum Non Conveniew, and Plaintiffs Opposition thereto, it is hereby ORDERED and DECREED that said Motion is DENIF_D? ?y[J?-lt.??t onoa- A,? :e5ZVA cam. 1? w&/-,/.4P6BY T1JE COURT' CAproPSe"T ISW ?'?' PCT 2 9 2DD3 dPa Fits Sep 14 05 03:46p Kimberly Hoehing Esq 8565963350 p.5 GORBERG, 00"ERG AM ZMER By: DOMMQUE GRENMR, ESQUIRE IdenfftWonNo. 89227 1234 Market Street Suite 2040 Philadelphia, PA 19107 (215)563-7210 Attorney for Plainti$ NATHANIEL AND MICELLE HTTE COURT OF COhMON PLEAS PHILADELPHIA COUN'T'Y Plaintiff V. MAY TLzRM, 2003 DOCKETED DADUARCSRYSLER COMPLEX LIT CENTER CORPORATION NO. 1675 SEP Z 5 2003 Defendant J. STEWAR7 AND NOW, tWs y ofV.4i , 2003, upon consideration of Defendants Motion to Transfer of Venue for Forum Non Conmiens, and Plaintiffs Opposition thereto, it is hereby ORDERED and DECREED that said Motion is Dmajj /x - ` Z`y 6i:' BY 0 CUPIESSErRT PiiRSUW T4 Ps. R,CP. MN) SEP `L 5 203 RM ?orcrauu traosPa User Sep 10 05 03:46p Kimberly Hoehing 5Sq 8565963350 P.6 liltC SAY p ??? B Do11?ItvI. QVE GRENIER, _QUIRE CN/4gp?j??isTcZ,?43 Identification No. 89227 ANY 1234 Market Street Suite 2040 Philadelphia, PA 19-07- "? - - (215) 563-7210 ,Attorney for Plaintiff USA RIMBY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS P$IL.ADELPMA COTJN' y Plaintiff' v. JULY TERM, 2002 DAIMLERCEfRYSLER CORPORATION( NO. 0995 Defendant AND NOW, ftis-day of, 2003, upon consideration' of Defendant's Motion to Traw:Fer of Veaue for Forum Non Conveniew, and Plaintiffs apposition thereto, it is hereby ORDERED and DECREED that said Madan is I)E1TM. BY THE COURT- COPIES POgSUgEl?17' 7D Pa. A:C.P. s MAY 0 B 3 First j Ad d iJSea/,p,; 8- .Sep 14 05 03:47p Attorney-fbr-laintiff - p.7 CURTTS TODD LOOSE Plaintiff Kimberly Hoehing Esq 8565963350 GOP.BBRG, GORBBRG AND ZUBER By: DAB J. GORBERG,.ESQUIRE Identification No. 53084 1234 Market Street Suite 2040 Philadelphia, PA 19107 (215)'563-7210 DAIM ERCHRYSLER CORPOR_4T1ON Defendant COURT-OF COMMON PLUS PHIT.ADELPWA COUNTY AUGUST TERM, 2002 NO. 061661 ORDER AND NOW, this'J day of 2003, upon consideration: of Defendant's Motion' in Transfer of Venue for Forum. Non Com+eniens, and PLlimtiffs opposition thereto, it is hereby ORDERED and DHCRBED that said Moiioii is DBNIM. BY TFIE MURT: curs POR5LJAIViTO Pa.FL.RCP cp RECEIVED r?jb) NIAR 0 MAR 0 6 2003 User tD CIVILADWNISTRATION u, 'p n mberly Hbehing Esq 8565963350 P.8 GORBERG, GORBERG AND ZEMER Hy: DOMINIQUE GRENIER, ESQUIRE Idmtification No. 89227 1234 Market Street Suite 2040 Philadelphia, PA 19107 0215} 563-7210 DOCKETED CoMPLEx uT CENTER SEp x 3 2003 J. STENWART Attorney for Plaintiff SHAWN ILOSHWAY COURT or COMMON PLEAS PHILADELPHIA COUNTY Plaintiff V. APRIL TERM, 2003 s DMWERCHRYSLER CORPORATION NO. 4497 Defendant I AND NOW, tt c2le--day o , 2003, upon consideration of Defendant's Motion to Transfer of Venue for Fonun Non Conventaw, -and Plaintiffs opposition thereto, it is bereby ORDERED and DECREED that said Motion is DPNks'D? y BY THE COURT; ???? S 2043 SEP 2 . Ff awox? met 3 0:•? %mm 'Sep 14 05 03:47p Kimberly Hoehing Esq 8565963350 p,9 ti 2A170 . 2W05 plus 40 as.1/11(It, MW-PPACNIDWOMAL W!CWON - SEE OUPMOR COURT 1.4.10.65„37 149MAEL RAYMOND AND BERNADEM RAYMONDr Hf W Appellant 4. PAWL TDiRACE APAR71MENfS, INC. AMD WntgEr CORPOPATION AND 2014-20" E 177 CORA0RKrION AND BRADFORD WHIM CORPMTMN IN THE M PEAIOR COU Y OF PENNSYLVANIA Appellee No. 3151 EDA 2009 Appel from the Order entered November 23, 2004 in the Court of Common Pleea of Philadelphia County CMI No. 3uly Term 21003, No. 3287 _$EFORt«•^FORi3-EIJ.t?,-.tOY?C>:ate-MON781gtJRA;17_.._.__.._... _. _... ..._ ....... ___ •MEM0RIN9Dt A: FUJW JUNE 31116 2009 Thia in Art appeal from the Order dodoathed November 23, 20W4, In the Phlladelphte Cauety Court of Common Pleas, granting the paddtion of Appellee Bradford WhRe Corporation to transfer venue to Delaware County on the basis of foram non convendens.3 For the reaaona not forth below, we reverse and harrnand the matter to Philadelphia County. On 3arnuery 4, 2009, Appellant Michael Raymond fail Mho a.baditb M" With ttraldlRg water In his apartment at 1023 Ward Street in Cheater, DelaW&m Ootlnty. Although h(s nkca Deslres 5tep14s PURad him from tot An appeal from ¦ pretrial ardor "nsfarMli vemre is pomissibla under PS.RA.P. 311(4). 'Redred Jh§dm aseasrod to Superlar Carat .Sep 14 05 03:48p Kimberly Hoehing Esq 8565963350 p.10 J. A17025/03 tub almost 6nrs iy, App elil It suffarad sawrid and thkd degree bwm to his head, tom and arms. On July 26, 2003, Appellants flied a ne;gifgenm wMan in the I'Miedelphla County Court of Common Pleea against then landlord, delmhV that the water tainpareture on the bona was sat too high? On DWArnbar 15, Appellants filed an amended complaint Ir ing the mantuft brow of the bolter, Appellee aradford White Corporation, as a defendant The emended complaint iodudes addRtOnal dalma of negna"ce, stall LabNRy, and breach of warranty against AppeYec In 3anuarY of 20040 both Appellee and the landlord dWwdanta filed praliminary oWattom Challenohvg venue in phNadeipttla. The ametetions were ovamsted try Order detrtl,Manch 18, 2004, and dbooveey continued In Phllade tilt County. On Setotember 20, 2004; Appellee fled a motlcn to tsar afbr the relater M Delaware County on the basis of Imam lion ronvenkm.s Appellee also Ned s mutton for at MINlry Judgment a Itw days lobar. By order dodcec lls fiovernbar 23; 2004, the tail court granted Appelte/e's forum non cw"okns madan and trans%rred tab case, as well on the wd_saWine mothm far summary judgment, to Delaware Comity. AppWal moved for Z M tact Reymandfs who Bernadette, seeks damages for loss of eorssomum. The Landlord defendants - park Terrace Apartments, brr., 1120 Shard Street Corporation, and 2414-3044 V. 177 Corporation - did not Join In Appelses motion. itovrso r, they have flied a brie' In wppgrt of the trial caw ; rvlingr arid, in Tact, still contend that they arc ran suldim t to venue in PhNadelphlo county. -2- •Sep 14 05 03:48p Kimberly Hoehing Esq 8565963350 P.11 ?. u7oxsfcs reowk9lderation which the Court pramptly denied, and thte tlrnsty appeai fotlaws. Appelftnt rafses one Ime an appeal: Wimton the T1tal Court abused Rs dLv*Uon end/or roisappilad the law in transferring venue of thfs case to Delaware County when the record darnonaeub s that Appellee Bradford Whine Coop. provided no evidence that trot In Phiadelphle Is vexetloue or oppressive bo Appellee. (AROdl IWML Brdaf at 4). Penncyhrerra Rule of burl Procedure 1006(d3(1) pamtlrs the transfer of a came from ono county to another `tflar the eohvenfence of paWes and vritnesses.' This Court will not rev ma a trim court's dedalorl to transfer venue absent an oboes of dletradon. MmW v. E4 der Pent do Naenotl u :i asd Cls., 1138 A.24 707, 709 (P%.• Sow 1009) emn banc)? sPP?f"dented. 660 A.2d 124 (Pe. 2004). As our Supreme Court vVeined In C6seoereean v. L&MW el9s9eM11sa0ar, ice, 701 A.2d 156, 162 (Pa. 1997), the doctrine of Ibrurn ran converAws Is aetuelly a nftomer, indeed, `!fie defendant nvx* show mare than *at the chosen oxwn k mereW 6toonvenlent to him' to juewfy the tseoslier of a cm tt rn the plaintiffs chosen venue. Under Cfleeownee, `a p Wton to transfer rescue should not be gramed aMess the ddondent need Its burdon of de"lleftting, with detailed a0brmn& n on the record, that the plaingR's chosen Pomm Is oppreealve or vexatious ba the dWW%Mnt." !dL The Court explained trot the burden rmy be met by esWh0ahlrg with Oct* on the record that the pialntifrs choice of farnm was designed to harass the dafbndarit, even at same -3- Cep 14.05 03;49p Kimberly Hoshing Esq 3. A17026m5 8565963350 p.12 luVOneramm to the plaint fr hirmelf ... tar] by establlehing stn Civa record that trial In the chuaeri ftsmm to oPpramlve t O Nm; for Inetance, alai hu in another cmity wotdd pmvlds pier acoess to witramsas or dlNar somem of proud`, or Co the ablgty m madwa a view of premises invdved In Ilm dispute. id. Morcwep Ow c an Caurt disregarded Balms ths'no sgnN4cant aspect at slim ease hwotues the chosen thrum, and that litigating In another fbnren would be more ®rwenteot.' " An this Court declared In VAwd, wpm, a eaiarec*V of the dman and proposed forums is not appropriate: Indeed, the Clleassrnan standard premMpmm that lfte plak"193 dtolae or foram is more owive lent ... tom] wig {iraval even V It is raeorNeRMM to the .dellandwts. 'the dedandant will bd able to transrer the Cage only If It canim AS heavy burden at pruvf that the laruffi IS oaPreaslre to him. Bemuse uw C7rsa wmw standard already tips the smd4w _ _---heavily In tlte..plairOft favor, this court need not a lY Aa{Yta Y,d ,WY?Y wgwr ?,Y..M w r.r w.w.o w .???r-+.rrw•_._ .. _.._. - RatireM *a proper Podia ar the Inquiry ^1s whether the dwAm of form Is oppresalve or vmratIous to tio derv dent.' Chaassms,% 781 A.2d at 162 n. 6. M at 715. With this sterdard in mhd, we review the trial courCs dedsbn in the present cage. As the want nebes in Its Cptnlon, oelawara t.,atfMW dearly h" a fear greater Connection to ft case than Prodelphla Courtly. Indeed, ap or the GMnk ve tads *=Xnd in Delaware Caursty, Appe0ants and their niece All Ave t1we, and almost alt of mho medical treatment and therapy was adminlobn*d these. The court than conduced that `haylMg the trial In Miladelphta was oppreeelva and veua*us to [Appelleal ea well as to the Apartment Ddendarsts." {Mal CG Op, at 7). ttowww, we find that the -4- ,Sep 14 05 03:49p Kimberly Hoehing Esq 1. AVOWS 8565963350 court pnpcopwV app4d a belencing tact and faked to hold APPPJite to Ill burden of dernRnstmUng that trial in Phdadeiphla Connty would be oppressive, radw than merely Inconveniaft Indeed, wee mndude that we p.13 are berond by , MVMf snd Its pmgwy,to rsaver3e the tr rwftr order In the present ease. glace iht cAnatareran deddoll was itled, tuft Court has been retuetIM to ttana%r eases *Mn PMladeliphis the s ursoundirrg esuntiee based on Ji vom non corwenirirt:. See Ce mamas v. AMoft le J6ema'se o Cef„ 954 A.2d 1259 (Pa. Super. 2Ca4) (dsdlntng to trarrefer cast trorn P'hPwbtpfNa to a4dar county); .7ahm w. Ffrs!'.flriftn G nr-, 777 A.Zd 499 (Pt. Super. i=) {dedlning to-tnWwase.torn Philadelphla_ttp !lodes 0ourrty)i_ laerAw P. ltffwmnr lbnm Healitit Carrsst, Ater„ 754 A.2d 1 (Pa. super. 2000), apspeesf danilisd, 766 A-d 1249 (Pa. 2001) (dedlnbg to Canslar aria Pram Phiiada%" to Detewwa County). Asa no MWwa v. Sftw, S19 A.2d S$S (Pe. Super. 2003) (aMn%g transfer of case from Ptdledithie to DOMart County). Is reaft, trovet"a from Detaware, Bucks, Mant gonrrsy or Chester County tta Phladelphis is not parthwlerly onerous. And, despRa the fact that the burden on the airaady congested Ph9adeiphia County Court of Common Pleas to rraolve. cases that have a tenuous eonnsesimt W the dty Is quft real, the Suplsma Court has made dear drat murt congestion In tuna &.0sen veram is not it proper consideration In a foftm non nonvenlens deterrabbat IM. Sas ChOWR nan, MtWv at 162. Therefore, Appellee here -5- *Sep 14 05 03'49p Kimberly Hoehing Esq I. A],702"S 8565963350 p.14 seed a "ry heavy ixrrden to dernanstrate wHh deMled'Recta on the r8mrd •appaeesioh and v"s*asnees, not mere Inconvenience." WWd, wpef at 715. We eld that it Called to dd no- TA Its transfer madon, Appellee Ileted several Chas Co7wee 9 the case to laeiwwsm county: the aedderrt occurred In Chester, Delaware CorxrtY and the wager heater at leaue remains there, Appellants still live In the same aparenerdy Appelort r niece, who Wrolo &ed the Taal leM Hues In Woodiyn, Delaweira Counter; The mahfamnce parson at Appellants' apartment complex Hv4s in Cheabar, Delaware County; aM aMw the *Wdww, Mr. Raymond reoeNad enlefgeney Gate at Cram Cheater Medical Center In Chestier, -Delaware-Coin,-as-well-asIlobw-up-atedleal treetrtwnt arld,thtrapy from seven pmvldera In Deleytar6 Lratifit* In 'addkSon, Appel" nate4 that ifs peAdpal place of bush-am la'ln Ambler, MenVomwy County. It attached aMdevits *wn there employae,Iwifrtesaas who We fn Mawark, Delaware, Monn. Ctresber County, Pennayhranle, and FreEerldc. Maryland nwpectNaMr whldr aH aver *wt It would be -turdanwme" far them to travel to AhHadelphla to tkCN and that the burden would be smwwahat allavlated If this maaw wore bW In a court in Media, Delaware CourOW (Motion to Trandbr venue, Exhblt E, Affidavit of Herb Faetar st 1-2} IMd" F. Affidavit of Robert 1 Hunts,, at 1, f?xhihit G, M111davlt of Theodora 1 Slkorskl at 1). Moreover, Appel** robed that only bwo of Appelienle' four wed expetta have offtoae M Phlladeiphle. -a- ;Sep 14 05 03:50p Kimberly Hoehing Esq J. A1702WOS 8565963350 Appeeants Mad it response to the motion dla Uft Appallea's condudon that trial in Delaware County would be more con"Went for their awn wanes es. Indeed, Appellants attached an aMdsvrt }Item M. Staples averting that archough she Was In Delaware County, Mal in Philadetphla would he-move cenvenlunt for her bacouse or public transportation issues.' Moreover, Appellants disputed rice offdavtts provided by ApMACet amply/eealwRnesses as dislegwwotrs Once .they travel Farther than Phdadelpela, tlae by to Ambler, Montgomery County, lbr work each day. As this Court olatad In CoUgnos, swprb, •[tVw location and convowancet of the plawNf's witnesses Is oeneralfy immahw1ai to trove centaai p.15 _ yueattw arwhether t to forum is loppreselve-to OwdefbndanW". JkLimt-1260 indeed, Appellants came Philadelphia as their fdeurn. 'Prewinebty, they wilt ensure Hrat PttUadeiphle is awwanlent for their own woes, whether feet- bead or mgwn. 'Thus, the onty relevant facts bmrkM on the oppressiveness of trial in Phtledelphle Is that dw accident occ+md in Delaware County and the bollar In quastlon ramalrra them, Appellee's prinegW place of buskrss ft M MoDtgomely County, and three or Appellee's vMpkgoWwt jhvsses have everrad that trial th Philadelphia would be -burdwoome." 'These flida, we find, are InsuftMMt to derrtortstmta shat Dial in Philadelphia Is more than merely inconvenlent to Appellee. c COladdeft Ms, Staples Ie an ayaWWvM to Me accdent as well as Cie. nieoe of Appellants, we doubt thst her bvnsportadon leaves are as dtra as Mike avers. indeed, we avowne Chas Appellants' mmweel would PMvlde Ma. Staples with cab fare Ethe trial wane held In Media, Daiaw ors County, -7- Sep V 05 03:50p Kimberly Hoehing Esq J. A17025/i05 8565963350 P.16 Appellees reliance on NOW, copra, lei m€5plecad, aHhovo Malfewly, fella falls seem very oknher to those pesarraw here. In l/atrerr, the appelfiartt, a resident of Delaware County, lftd suit against the appetiser, one of whom also resided In Unworn County, as a result of an automobie accident that accurrod In D41mare County. in a rnodon to traveler venue, the appellees avafred that trial In Delaware County would provide ender acvess to sources of proof slnc:e In addafon is being the slius of the coillelon, two of the Partlbe resided to Delewore County and aQ of the appellentle medical Disobneflt was rendered there. Moreover, OR of the parties, as well as the Identfied fact witnesses, were lomeed oumtds of _Phdatlatptrla. -tn-her mspwvw, the aPPellar?t-dld--not-apaallmlh'-deny_the .. ... -oveemeirbs, but rattreP etssetted that the appellees rafted to provide a'dabWe;d record. The appellees' cioderferidant, American Insurance Company, also filed a respar". admMKng all of the avermantf In the madam The trial court granted the petition and transfntted the matter to Delaware Covrey. on appeal, this Court afBhrn.finding that the Well court's transfer or dte an won rerasgrrebia. Spedfkaliy, we noted that , , . the record is devold of wq dfepi fre as to the factors the trial court relied upon In faultnq that 90gadon of the acUtin In ftladeiWa county would be apprMPM. Appellant Slitter admlla the fads of record, namely, the facts cDftlmed withht Appatlee'a petition, or flbfis to dlepuea those facts. AppedGwrt simply assert. that the Wdonce is hrofAderrt to astabilah tick PlWdelphta County would be oppressive tea Appellee. Abeent a dolial of the tads of retard by Appaflar4 we M991: accept do facts as Mrs. These facto establish that all of the perUM as wnfl as the Identified tact witnasess, reside ornstds tit Phkdefphla .g. Sep 1t 05 03:51p Kimberly Hoehing Esq 8565963350 p.17 ). A17625/El5 County. In addttton, AppellaWs madleal wlllneas Is located within Delaware County and alt of her nxdlcal nutrient was rendered in Delaware County. dlr. at 567. TherelDre, In Mohm, this Court relied heavily an the fact that the platnW/aMmUnt essentially admitted that Delaware County would provide easier aoaess b0 ail the SoUrom of proof. Here, there I6 no such adrnteclan. Indeed, Appel[ents have gone out of their way to demonstrate that trial In Philadelphia would not be Oppressive to any or this parties or waft asm. Aceor4in91y,1Mateu is not eontronln0 s Weesum we and that the trial murt abused its dlaxstion In trarefrrruhp tits Case to Delaware County, WM revere the court's November 23, 20114, __. order, and._rsmtaid..the_.case. _to_PhHadetphls..CaUrYW br coitelderatbut__Ar Appaliee's outstanding summary judgment motion. Order neversed and case semaMod. jurisdiction rahnqubt". S we note with dtapleasura that one of tho cases upon *fth Appellee rifts, Itrmnr w v. Sat. Snarphis IEspltonnfMIsn i ffMw edr, X001 Pa. Super. 165 (Pa. Super. 2001), was withdrawn by this Court alter pwW m=rwidaradon was 9ranard, said aWnequently tiled as an unpublished mmnoripedwn. Also Kmw e w w. NIL JARMAir AWBlorre? Meaft Notwe rI4 791 A, 2d 1294 Ms. Super. 2901) (unpublished memarsndum). Thus, any reliance on or citmen to this case Is Improper. -9- -LO- r C Ci V ? ?1 V M ? J F Zsr' J I r-, ( 1 O t_ - TI -7 1 t J r.z w MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER COLEMAN & GOGGIN BY: Matthew L. Owens, Esquire Attorney I.D: 76080 4200 Crams Mill Road Harrisburg, PA 17112 (717) 651-3501 GARY NEUBAUM, Plaintiff Attorney for Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION Defendant NO. 05-5888 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Kindly enter the appearance of the undersigned on behalf of Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, in the above captioned case. DATE: 3 / 2-3 / () `0 BY: MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER COLEMAN & GOGGIN BY: Matthew L. Owens, Esquire Attorney LD: 76080 4200 Crums Mill Road Harrisburg, PA 17112 (717) 651-3501 GARY NEUBAUM, Plaintiff V. DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION Defendant Attorney for Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Angela Zilla, an employee of Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin, do hereby certify that on this. *)'?k Xday of ffl , 2006, I served a copy of the foregoing document via First Class United States mail, postage prepaid as follows: David J. Gorberg, Esquire Gorberg & Zuber 1234 Market Street, Suite 2040 Philadelphia, PA 19107 Angela la -?, .? _+l ?` _ ,,+ ', :.? ;?_ _??, 2'- 't n. % ':?G _. MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER COLEMAN & GOGGIN BY: Matthew L. Owens, Esquire Attorney I.D: 76080 4200 Crums Mill Road Harrisburg, PA 17112 (717) 651-3501 GARY NE,UBAUM, V. Attorney for Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiff NO. 05-5888 DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION Defendant WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Kindly withdraw the appearance of the undersigned on behalf of Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation, in the above captioned case. DATE: .3 ( Z3 f a MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER COLEMAN & GOGGIN BY: Matthew L. Owens, Esquire Attorney LD: 76080 4200 Crums Mill Road Harrisburg, PA 17112 (717) 651-3501 GARY NEUBAUM, Plaintiff V. DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORPORATION Defendant Attorney for Defendant, DaimlerChrysler Corporation IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 05-5888 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Angela Zilla, an employee of Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin, do hereby certify that on this 3a k day of I P/ 14, F i. ?t , 2006, 1 served a copy of the foregoing document via First Class United States mail, postage prepaid as follows: David J. Gorberg, Esquire Gorberg & Zuber 1234 Market Street, Suite 2040 Philadelphia, PA 19107 Angela Zil 74 DAVID J. GORBERG & ASSOCIATES, P.C. By: DAVID J. GORBERG Attorney for Plaintiff IDENTIFICATION NO. 53084 Suite 2040 1234 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19107 (215) 563-7210 Gary Neubaum : Court of Common Pleas vs. Cumberland County DaimlerChrysler Corporation : No. 05-5888 PRAECIPE TO SETTLE DISCONTINUE AND END TO THE PROTHONOTARY. Kindly mark the above-captioned matter Settled, Discontinued and Ended upon payment of your costs only. q"ID T GORBERG, ESQUIRE Attorney for Plaintiff My, 3:.? t == C= 33 c.a ci? co co