HomeMy WebLinkAbout06-2737
Kelly Ray & Sandra Louise
Hockenberry, Administrator and
Administratrix of Estate of
Nathan M. Hockenberry,
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
: No. ()tJ~~731 cl,,;\--IerM
v.
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
: A.D.
AM General, LLC and General
Motors Corporation,
Defendant
PRAECIPE FOR WRIT OF SUMMONS
To the Prothonotary:
Please issue a writ of summons in the above captioned action.
Writ of Summons shall be issued and returned to Karl E. Rominger, Esquire at 155 South
Hanover Street, Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013 for private service on AM General, LLC and
General Motors Corporation.
Date:/lc,'j 12/2 oot
Respectfully submitted,
ROMINGER, BAYLEY & WHARE
/~ ~
Karl E. Rominger, Esquire
155 South Hanover Street
Carlisle, P A 17013
(717) 241-6070
Supreme Court ID #81924
Attorneys for Plaintiff
WRIT OF SUMMONS
To The Above Named Defendants: AM General, LLC
105 N. Niles Ave
P.O. Box 7025
South Bend, IN 46617
General Motors Corporation
100-400 Renaissance Center
East Jefferson Ave
Detroit, MI 48243
YOU ARE NOTIFIED THAT THE ABOVE-NAMED PLAINTIFF HAS
COMMENCED AN ACTION AGAINST YOU.
f~
Date: ?rl"(j 1r.2 ,c9. 00 6
By:
Deputy
l,\ e
s:
-- ~ -ui:n
f""'-J. ,...... ll'\. nlr;-j
\'l;. n- ~ ;;;~r'
"" . /~(
__ ~~c:
.J::: '" '< u
~ ....,,,,.,,
... .....s) ......, -;71,.,..
~ -.i ~-:z (_.i
..s:J \ "'<;) Jo'c:
- -.. ~ ~
~
.......
~
=
"""
:E
,...
--<
~
N~e
~:D
t;~
~
-0
::;J::
W
.,
c.n
c::>
.
LAVIN, 'NEIL, RICCI, CEDRONE & DiSIPIO
By: J seph E. O'Neil, Esquire
Identific ion No.: 29053
By: ary Grace Maley, Esquire
Identific ion No. 37610
By: R bert J. Martin, Esquire
Identific ion No. 45234
By: onica Proffitt Osborne, Esquire
Identific tion No. 56229
190 No Independence Mall West
Suite 50 , 6th and Race Streets
Philadel hia, PA 19106
(215) 62 -0303
Attorneys for Defendant,
General Motors Corporation
& Sandra Louise Hockenberry,
ator and Administratrix of Estate
M. Hockenberry,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON
PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
Plaintiff
NO. 06-2737
AM G ral, LLC and General Motors
Corpora ion,
Defendants
NOTICE OF FILING NOTICE OF REMOVAL
TO: arl E. Rominger, Esquire
ominger & Whare
55 South Hanover Street
arlisle, P A 17013
General, LLC
05 N. Niles Avenue
.0. Box 7025
outh Bend, IN 46617
LEASE TAKE NOTICE that on June 21, 2006, defendant, General Motors
Corpor tion, filed a Notice of Removal, a copy of which is attached hereto, of the
above- ptioned litigation to the United States District Court for the Middle District of
Pennsy ania
.
ou are also advised that General Motors Corporation, upon filing such Notice of
in the Office of the Clerk of the United States District Court for the Middle
District f Pennsylvania, also filed a copy thereof with the Prothonotary of the
d COWlty Court of Common Pleas to effect removal, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. S
1446(d).
DATE:
LAVIN, O'NEIL, RICCI, CEDRONE & DISIPIO
E23,2006
~1~A)~ ~
Jos hE. O'N ., Esquire
Mary Grace Maley, Esquire
Robert J. Martin, Esquire
Monica Proffitt Osborne, Esquire
Attorneys for defendant,
General Motors Corporation
BY
AM General, LLC
105 N. Niles Avenue
P.O. Box 7025
South Bend, IN 46617
'-
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
e undersigned hereby certifies that a true and correct copy of General Motors
Corporat on's Notice of Filing Notice of Removal was served on this 23rd day of June,
2006, vi U.S. Mail, postage pre-paid, on the following counsel of record.:
Karl E. Rominger, Esquire
Rominger & Whare
155 South Hanover Street
Carlisle, P A 17013
V. .OI<lGI~
SIt ~....
I'MoWIMI.r:
(PLACIi AN ,IN ON!! BOX OWI.Y)
e.w-t _ 01- l-..s.6 hTlll 0" .......vr
.t._....<:o.t &IoonIIII
T...rc..cd.ftvna
OJ __-.diKfiol
l..m&l
CCi M~lIidiRricl
t..ll__
1.ppl&l1e~
01 ./Idplunt
,....... .
e 1 :06-cv-01242-YK
Document 1
Filed 06/21/2006
Page 1 of 1
1544 (Rev. 031\l9) CIVIL OOVER 8HUT
Tbe.lS-4lI civil coveraheel KI ttw ~ cont8incrJ hcreI:n oehherreplaoenor IUppkmmt the tilhl'll'Id acrvtcea(pfcadmcs or 0Iher'PlOCl1" roquuw by laW,GC4\Illtll
_;.I.. bylo<al ruloo of 1111. fonn,appmYOd by ....ludiclolCnn_ of1llc1.hlir.dSwa on S"f*l1lbcr 1974, ~ 'OIl."od !brill, ....ofdlO CJm; of COUll for Ihe
~.iritjliai ,... civi do,l"uhcet INmliCTIONS ON THl! lUlVl!RSE OF THE FORM.
DIF&NDANTS
Ooncro] Mom Cor_lion.... AM Geo"..II..I.C
Mary~ Mal.,.. &qlJife
JWb,rt J. Martin, esquirr
MonlQ. Proffill OIbomc.
L&~in. O'N-,l. ~\;ci. C
]90N.lndopondmc,Moll
Phlladc.llplnl. PA 19106
(2IS) G27.0J03
lu~:nbeny, Adnrlnf&tnltor und Administtlx oflht
<''OutrTY OF RR.'lmENCE OP PJIlST lJSTIID DEFllNPANT fle"'"4 Ml
(IN \J.~. PI.AINTII'l' CASES 01'11. Y)
NOTE, IN LAND CONDliMNATION CASES. USE nIB LOCA TJON OF TIlE
71V.Cr OF LAND ltlVOI. VOD
ATTORNEYS (IP KNOWN)
.,
" P\.~ipio
W. SllilC 500. 6. .nd Race SlretQ
u. umq OF JUIUSDI ON (I'LA<:6-'N~)C"INOHBIQ"(Wl,Y)
DL crrlZltNSHlP OFPRlNroAL PARTIIlS (PLACliAN "X"lNOWE BOX
(por Di....Jly <.:ueo Only) ~QR PLAINTIFF ANDOllll FOP. Dlll'6NDANT
01 U.S.C",overnrnc'nt
J"l.-intit't
J Fode,,] Quem... pr~ Dll~
(U.s. Oov<mmcol NoUP>rty) m DllI'
Cltip.orThisStalo DI O. 1rn:OIJIII"leolIH'Prin<ipllP'- 0< 0<
of'BlWnss in 'I'his &I\c.
4 Oivenit)' CltizIn .of Anotht" s.~ 1812 02 IlIc:orporalod aNi PrInolpol PW:c 0' ..
(lndil,;lltc <''hb:erWlip of ofBuaina. in AnodIcrSflrc
Parties in 1tm\ Ul)
CitiBn or!WbjecC of. DJ 03 PorciGR Nation O. [I'
F.,.; Coon
PUCE AN ,IN ONE !lOX ONL
D'2. U.S. Orwern~t
Oefcndmt
IV,. :-IATIJRF. OFSVIT
. ro
110 l...-re
[J IX! MeriM
[J150UiI'-rN:1
Cl.NelIlliIlil~~
[] 1:lO "'--YN"Ovtl1lf.l'WlCrII
.~~Q/
,-
CISl*di"",Mr.
tJ lJ2 a-....y of WoIY'"
III._LaInJ
1"'.VaCrMa)
C I" lIwM)'.r~
wiVtcWM'.B...su
C\M~s.iu
Ol911Oll..-(.:Qalrm:
CI9'CotIlnnI'Nllull.I.WllIir:,
~""'TY
D.l:IOWIII Ml&t\Grll"
C no rw.aww'
ODDItMtI.clK"'~1I
[J2"'"'nlDL.-I
(J 1A3 Tn11'rGdua U.\ihly
07W AlIOIIIIJI'RoIPPwIpm'J
:rv ...
. u.. NUIY I. ...- <lXl
C310Airplllll CJG ....1IiIIJ'- C.- 0lIIIf1fN1:Dq, 111USCI:Nl """W' J
O:JIJA\rpIIN~ "ICI~ CR5 ~adllW.~o/ Qw~, O"lO~
~ .u:,......,...,.- '~).IUSC..1 2IUSCJH D 4'" .............
C 320 At.lI. Libd .. C QO UlpIr ~ 0411 ~a..'1lC
.- ..........) 0'- La.*TnRIt om 0"'_
O]iG '~IiMp"ytn' C l6l ........ "'-" CtSClo\lTIiIMa.p O"'JO 1tIclc.uIr1ln--t1Nl
......, -...... CHO~" c-.CItIuita_
C~6I) !lIIrWa """" ......... e IliI 5&""" SaUl
0345 "'Pl'udlIct C"'_ IJISO~
LiNilcl' ~n.o,IUtTY 'Ill,., ......
o J'" Wo. vrllic:lc OnOOlllfrFr_ Orn ~0lI!1..
C3"NlltIIVIhlllt CDlT......Lnd.. 161 HIA l31 llUlC"..1.
...... ....., DUO OIberP,rMlIl IOJ.~r D'''_=I'''' OUI t\II'Ie'AldIAJu
lJ J60 UIk P-.I ............ Aa [lHJ D1WCJIH W(~ OI!llI&uaarak~IbII~
r~l')' CJI$~""'" C1lO_ O~ S3WTlIlIXV1 ""
-....., hI_ D IU .~ (<<n\sn []IlIJ"""'IIIAUIMi&Itm
C 1>> LIlMINpL CM4 Pnlrar4llua1iillAel
... -. FE L ,lXIU C."..........
510 .....IIJ .0 _Aa ~...Aa
-.. ClfO w...,LMNr . _rv.s.1'IUili OHa ,,"*lelFoc~
"" llr~O
-"""" om 0lIwr4bor 0171 IJIS-nmU.-tJ 1JIIlIII.,..Ae.-1O
0""_ ""*'
8'S)~ \)t8,.-, u_ )fUS(:')fIQl) 09SU CWlit~)'ot
015'1 EnpLlC4ln..
$40 ~aO*r -"" __a
0..._ o I'.IU 0rMrac...,.
A"
VIT. HEQUESTI: IN CHUCKrPTHlSLCA
(:OMrLAJN"f; C VKDII. '...c.p U
a.us ACTJOI';
PIMA"" $
CM<k rESooIyl/d<_ ",,,,_'m'
JURY DEMAND 0 va . NO
VIn.RILATIW CASF.(ll)
JFANY
{h-...,.;r,_~.
DOC'KET ~'?fUA
nA1'E. )\Ine21,20(l6
JI'OIl orne., USJ: ONLY.
RECBIPT ,
tDll1EDSTATESDISnuct IJRT
AMOUNT
APPI. VINe; tfP
IUOOE
Mh<.J.l=
FQR THE'BASTERN DIS
pttrpose of ~signment to ap
Address of Plaintiff:
Addr:ss of Defendant:
Address of Defendant:
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
CT OF PENNSYLV ANlA - DESIGNATION FORM to be used by counsel to indicate the category of the case for the
priate calendar.
Shi P n Ivania
Detroi 4 4
4
Place of Accident, Incident 0 Transaction:
West Pennsboro TownshiD. Cumberland County. Pennsylvania
(Use Reverse Side For Additional Space)
Does this civil action involve a nongovernmental corporate party with any parent corporation and any publicly held corporation owning 10% or more of its
stock? (Attach twocopi of the Disclosure StatementFonn in accordance with Fed.R.Civ.P. 7.1(a)) Yes 0 No 181
Does this case involve multi . strict litigation possibilities?
RELATED CASE,IF ANY:
Yes 0 No 181
Case Number:
Civil cases are deemed relate when yes is answered to any of the following questions:
Judge:
Date Tenninated:
1. Is this case relat to property included in an earlier numbered suit pending or within one year previously tenninated action in this court?
YesO Nol8I
2. Does this case in lve the same issue of fact or grow out of the same transaction as a prior suit pending or within one year previously temrinated
action in this cou ? Yes 0 No 181
3. Does this case in lve the validity or infringement of a patent already in suite or any earlier numbered case pending or within one year previously
tenninated action n this court? Yes 0 No 181
CIVIL: (place 181 in ONE C TEGQRY ONLY)
A. Federal Question
B. Diversity Jurisdiction Cases:
1. 0 Indemnity Con act, Marine Contract, and All Other
Contracts
2. 0 FELA
3. 0
4. 0 Antitrust
S. 0 Patent
6. 0 Labor-Manag
7. 0 Civil Rights
8. 0 Habeas Corpus
9. 0 Securities Act( ) Cases
10. 0 Social Securi Review Cases
II. 0 All other Fed 1 Question Cases
(Please specify
I. 0 Insurance Contract and Other Contracts
2. 0 Aitplane Personal Injury
3. 0 Assault, Defamation
4. 0 Marine Personal Injury
S. 0 Motor Vehicle Personal Injury
6. 0 Other Personal Injury (please specify): Negligence
7. 181 Products Liability
8. 0 Products Liability-Asbestos
9. 0 All other Diversity Cases
(Please specify)
I,
o Relief other
DATE: J ne21 2
ARBITRATION CERTIFICATION
(Check "PP,..pmte Caugory)
MI
counsel of record do hereby certify:
Civil Rule 53.2, Section 3(c)(2), that to the best of my knowledge and belief, the damages recoverable in this civil action case
exclusive of interest and costs.
monetary damages is sought.
Marv Grace Malev
Attorney -at-Law
37610
Attorney 1.0. #
NO E: A trial de novo will be a trial by jury only ifthere has been compliance with F.R.C.P. 38.
I certify that, to my knowled e, the within case is not related to any case now pending or within one year previously terminated action in this court except as
noted above.
DATE: J
Mary Grace Malev. Esauire
Attorney -at-Law
37610
Atlomey 1.0. #
o Relief other t
Marv Grace Malev
Attorney -at.Law
37610
Attorney 1.0. #
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THB liASTERN DIST CT OF PENNSYLVANIA - DESIGNA nON FORM to be used by counsel to indicate the category of the case for the
pUrpose of assignment to a . ate calendar.
Address of Plaintiff:
hthadhi
b
vani
Addltss of Defendant
i MI4 4
Address of Defendant
105 N. Niles Aven e
Place of Accident, Incident Transaction:
West Pennsboro Townshin. Cumberland County. Pennsvlvania
(Use Reverse Side For Additional Space)
Does this civil action involv
stock?
(Attach two copi
a nongovernmental corporate party with any parent corporation and any publicly held cooporation owning lOOfo or more of its
of the Disclosure Statement Form in accordance with Fed.RCiv.P. 7.1(a)) Yes 0 No 181
Does this case involve multi istrict litigation possibilities?
RELATED CASE. IF ANY:
YesO Nol8I
Case Number:
Judge:
Date Terminated:
Civil cases are deemed reta when yes is answered to any of the following questions:
1. Is this case relate to property included in an earlier numbered suit pending or within one year previously terminated action in this court?
YesO Nol8I
2. Does this case in oIve the same issue of fact or grow out of the same transaction as a prior suit pending or within one year previously tenninated
action in this cou ? Yes 0 No 181
3. Does this case in olve the validity or infringement of a patent already in suite or any earlier numbered case pending or within one year previously
tenninated action in this court? Yes 0 No 181
CIVIL: (Place 181 in ONE C TEGORY ONLY)
A. Federal Question B. Diversity Jurisdiction Cases:
1. 0 ct, Marine Contract, and All Other 1. 0 Insurance Contract and Other Contracts
2. 0 Airplane Personal Injury
2. 0 FELA 3. 0 Assault, Defamation
3. 0 allnjury 4. 0 Marine Personal Injury
4. 0 Antitrust 5. 0 Motor Vehicle Personal Injury
5. 0 Patent 6. 0 Other Personal Injury (please specify): Negligence
6. 0 Labor.Manag 7. 181 Products Liability
7. 0 Civil Rights 8. 0 Products Liability-Asbestos
8. 0 Habeas Corpu 9. 0 All other Diversity Cases
9. 0 Securities Act( ) Cases (Please specify)
10. 0 Social Securi Review Cases
11. 0 1 Question Cases
ARBITRATION CERTIFICATION
(Check appropriate Category)
I,
eM 1
. counsel of record do hereby certifY:
. Pursuant to Loc Civil Rule 53.2, Section 3(c)(2), that to the best of my knowledge and belief, the damages recoverable in this civil action case
exceed the sum of $150,000. exclusive of interest and costs.
DATE: Jun 21 2
: A trial de novo will be a trial by jury only if there has been compliance with F.R.C.P. 38.
I certify that, to my knowled e, the within case is not related to any case now pending or within one year previously tenninated action in this court except as
noted above.
DATE: Jun
Marv Grace Malev. Esauire
Attorney -at-Law
37610
Attorney 1.0. #
.
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
KELLY Y & SANDRA LOUISE
HOCKE ERRY, Administrator and Administratrix
of the EST TE OF NATHAN M. HOCKENBERRY
AM GE
CORPO
v.
RAL LLC and GENERAL MOTORS
TION
CIVIL ACTION NO:
CAsE MANAGEMENT TRACK DESIGNATION FORM
In accordan with the Civil Justice Expense and Delay Reduction Plan of this court, counsel for plaintiff
shall comple e a Case Management Track Designation Form in all civil cases at the time of filing the
complaint serve a copy on all defendants. (See ~ 1:03 of the plan set forth on the reverse side of this
form.) In th event that a defendant does not agree with the plaintiff regarding said designation, that
defendant sh with its first appearance, submit to the clerk of court and serve on the plaintiff and all other
parties, a cas management track designation form specifying the track to which that defendant believes the
case should e assigned.
(Civ. 660)
E OF THE FOLLOWING CASE MANAGEMENT TRACKS:
(a)
Habeas Corpus --- Cases brought under 28 US.c.
~2241 through ~2255.
( )
(b)
Social Security - Cases requesting review of a decision
of the Secretary of Health and Human Services denying
plaintiff Social Security Benefits.
Arbitration --- Cases required to be designated for
arbitration under Local Civil Rule 8.
( )
( )
(c)
(d)
Asbestos --- Cases involving claims for personal injury
or property damage from exposure to asbestos.
( )
(e)
Special Management on Cases that do not fall into
tracks (a) through (d) that are commonly referred to as
complex and that need special or intense management
by the court. (See reverse side of this form for a
detailed explanation of special management cases.)
Standard Management --- Cases that do not fall into any
one of the other tracks.
( X )
( )
(f)
/Vt~~~
General Motors Corporation
MOTORS CORPORATION AND AM
LLC
CIVIL ACTION NO:
UNITED STATED DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
.
Y & SANDRA LOUISE
HOCKE ERRY, ADMINISTRATOR AND
ADMINIS RATRIX OF THE ESTATE OF
NATHAN . HOCKENBERRY
v.
DISCLOSURE STATEMENT FORM
Please che one box:
. The nongovernmental corporate party, General Motors Corporation, in the above
listed civil action does not have any parent corporation and publicly held
corporation that owns 10% or more of its stock.
o The nongovernmental corporate party, , in the above
listed civil action has the following parent corporation( s) and publicly held
corporation(s) that owns 10% or more of its stock:
/Y7(J' ~O-<A ~
Signature
Counsel for:
General Motors Corporation
Federal R Ie of Civil Procedure 7.1 Disclosure Statement
(a) WHO MUST FILE: NONGOVERNMENTAL CORPORA1E PARTY. A nongovernmental
corporate p y to an action or proceeding in a district court must file two copies of a statement
that identi es any parent corporation and any publicly held corporation that owns 10% or more
of its stock r states that there is no such corporation
(b) TIME FOR FILING; SUPPLEMENTAL FILING. A party must:
(I) file the Rule 7.I(a) statement with its first appearance, pleading, petition,
motion, response, or other request addressed to the court, and
(2) promptly file a supplemental statement upon any change in the
information that the statement requires.
907189vl
cneral LLC and
al Motors Corporation
NO.
t 1 Fl'led 06/21/2006 Page 1 of 5
C se 1:06-cv-01242-YK Documen
.
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR TIfR MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYl.. VANIA
Kel Ray & Sandra Louise
Hoc enbeny, Administrator and
Ad inistratrix of Estate of
N an M. Hockenberry
CIVIL ACTION
ys.
NOTICE OF REMOV AL
THE HONORABLE CHmF JUDGE AND JUDGES OF THE UNITED STATES
DISTRICT COURT FOR THE MIDDLE DISTlUCT OF PENNSYLVANIA
General Motors Corporation, the defendant in the above-captioned action, hereby
files this Notice of Removal of this action from the Cumberland County Court of
on Pleas to the United StIll:ea District Court for the Middle District of
ylvania, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. ~ 1441 and, in support tnerl:Of, avers as folloWS:
A civil action Wall commenced by Writ of Summons filed in the Court of
on Pleas of Cumberland County, PCI1IlSylvanill, on or about May 12, 2006. KeJ1y
d Sandra Louise Hock.enberry, Administrator and Administratrix of Estate of
M. Hockenberry are the plaintiffs, and AM General LLC and General Mote\'ll
tion are tbc named defendants. A copy of (ne Praecipe for Writ of Summons is
c
attach d as Exhibit A.
2. The Writ of Summons was served on removing defendlll\t, General Motors
Corpo tion, on May 26, 2006.
.
This cause of action arises out of an automobile accident that allegedly
occurre on May 14, 2004 in West Pennsboro Township, Cumberland County,
Pennsyl ania.
The amount in controversy is in excess of $75,000. Upon information and
e Complaint, when filed, will allege claims under Pennsylvania's Wrongful
ct and the Survival Act on behalf ofthe Estate of Nathan M. Hockenberry.
At the commencement of this action, plaintiffs, Kelly Ray and Sandra
ockenberry, were Administrator and Administratrix, respectively, of the Estate
an M. Hockenberry, deceased. (See Order by the Register of Wills of
Cumb land County, Pennsylvania herewith as Exhibit B.)
According to plaintiffs' moving papers filed with the Register of Wills of
Cumbe land County on May 28, 2004, Kelly Ray and Sandra Louise Hockenberry are
adult i ividuals living and residing at 15 Rehobeth Road, Shippensburg, Cumberland
County Pennsylvania.
As of May 12, 2006, the date this civil action was commenced, Kelly Ray
dra Louise Hockenberry, were residents of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
of Exhibit C, Plaintiffs' Complaint against West Pennsboro Township and the
Dep ent of Transportation of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania which was filed in
of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania on May 12, 2006.)
Defendant, General Motors Corporation, is now and was at the
cement of this action, incorporated under the laws of the State of Delaware, and
maintai s its principal place of business in Detroit, Michigan.
O. This action is one over which the Court has original jurisdiction under the
provisi ns of 28 U.S.C. S 1332, and is one which may be removed to this Court pursuant
to 28 U S.C. sI441,etseq.
1. This Notice is filed within the time for removal set forth in 28 U.S.C.
), inasmuch as thirty (30) days have not passed since receipt by the noticing party
of a pIe ing from which it may first be ascertained that the case is one that is removable.
2. Written Notice of Removal has been given to opposing counsel and all
unrepre ented parties as required by 28 U.S.C. SI446(b).
3. A true and correct copy of this Notice will be promptly filed with the
otary of the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland, Pennsylvania, as provided
by 28 .S.C. SI446(d).
4. A true and correct copy of the State Court docket as well as all process,
pleadin s, and orders served upon defendant in this action are attached.
. EREFORE, defendant, General Motors Corporation, effects removal of this
case fr m the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, to the
United tates District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania.
i
.
Defendant, AM General LLC, is now, and was at the commencement of
this act' n, a limited liability company organized and existing under the laws of the State
are, and maintains its principal place of business in the State of Indiana. See
Exhibit
,
Date:
Lavin, O'Neil, Ricci, Cedrone & DiSipio
BY:
Mary
Joseph . O'Neil, Esquire
Robert J. Martin, Esquire
Monica Proffitt Osborne, Esquire
Attorneys for Defendant,
General Motors Corporation
BY:
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Monica Proffitt Osborne, Esquire, do hereby certify that I have served a true
ect copy of a Notice of Removal, upon all counsel of record and unrepresented
parties y United States Postal Service First Class Mail, postage prepaid, as follows:
Karl E. Rominger, Esquire
Rominger, Bayley & Whare
155 South Hanover Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Attorney for Plaintiff
AM General LLC
105 N. Niles Avenue
South Bend, Indiana 46617
Lavin, O'Neil, Ricci, Cedrone & DiSipio
Dated: une 21, 2006
.
Template: Civ I
Docket#
06-2737
Plaintiff
HOCKENBE RY KELLY RAY
Defendant
AM GENERA LLC
Term
Civil
Case Type
WRIT OF SU
Date
5/12/2006
Plaintiff2
HOCKENBE RY NATHAN M
ESTATE OF
Plaintiff3
Plaintiff4
Plaintiff5
Plaintiff6
Plaintiff7
Plaintiff8
Plaintiff9
Plaintiff10
Plaintiff11
Plaintiff12
Plaintiff13
Plaintiff14
Plaintiff15
Plaintiff16
Plaintiff17
Plaintiff18
Plaintiff19
Plaintiff20
Page 1 of 1
Help I logol
Iii page~ Of2.
I!I ~ 12 #; 0 Ii) 1~2~." Pages l~.....1 to[
ProthonotaryJ> Civil Dockets> 2006 Dockets> 06- 2701 thru 06- 2800 > 08-2737
Kolly Ray "Sanob Lou
Hocklmbotry, AdAlilll.....lOl'w1
AcImi~ "_"'.1
.NodIon M, H........,.,
I'loll1Ufr
: IN 'l'llECOURTOFOOMMON l'L
: CtlMBllllLAND COUNTY. P A
: ~O, {J"'~'Hi (:l~,l-
..
: CMLACI'lON. LAW
:A,D.
AMOmml,l.Lcand Gooeqj
M_ CoopoftllOll,
~
'PI! .l~PnIt W':ItTOIf .'l'LI"Lt'~
T.lIle~:
l'lwt II... . wrll of IUlllllIOllllrllJJe IIDove Q&l,ldD6 Ktlon.
Wm ofSlllll_...hallllo.lloaed. IlllllIOCllOlllll t. x..tl. ~. Bolllll
iJalI....Slrt~ Culllle, p""",)'I\'IlI1& I'IOU lbr poMlo -*>> OIl AJot[[)ooorol, i
o..-l1'dol1llt Co<para.lbm,
0a"':/1~,/ Il/ 1. ('.lot
ltapeotilJJly..-~
JWJ.aNomt, BAnBY" \l
7- .
KId. II. ""'''''''r. lloq....
155_~5aut
CuIlIle, i'A 17013
('In) 241~70
SllJIl'O"" c"lUt II) 11181~
~ for PWlIIIft'
"'lTnIt.,~
1'bThoAlIaYfN~~": .....l.Hliillllll.u.c GononlMoto
lOSN,N'dOlA", .t~Jlmoj
p,O, 1m '/023 . II...'.......
SoulI& lIal4, IN 46611 DeIn!ll, MI41
YO'll ABN01:'U'IIIJ) THAT'lDABCJVB.NAMIlD P'lADmJ'PHAI
OO~DAN ACI'lON AOAINST.'\'cO'. A/)'
!!Il:l
0..." ?11~ /.J. ,Jdo'
Ily:
DIpUlf'
Powered by Laserflche WebLlnk version 7.0.4. Laserflche is a registered trademark of Compultnk Management Center, Inc.
This copy is registered to: County of Cumberland - Commissioners
http://records.cpa.net/we blink_ ext/ doc view .aspx?id=693 8 5
6/21/2006
To The ve Named Defendants: AM General, LLC
105 N. Niles Ave
P.O. Box 7025
South Bend, IN 46617
General Motors Corporation
.100400 Renaissance Center
East Jefferson Ave
Detroit, MI 48243
'.
& Sandra Louise
rry, Administrator and
trix of Estate of
. Hockenberry,
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
: No. () u ' J. 7"5 i Cl ,,;\ -Ie("N\
v.
: CIVIL ACTION - LA VI
: A.D.
AM 0 raI, LLC and General
Motors orporation,
Defendant
PRARC'IPR FOR WRIT OF SUMMONS
To the
ease issue a writ of summons in the above captioned action.
tit of Summons shall be issued and returned to Karl E. Rominger, Esquire at 155 South
Hanov Street, Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013 for private service on AM General, LLC and
General otors Cozporation.
Date) 4'1 12; 1. 00'
Respectfully submitted,
ROMINGER, BAYLEY & WHARE
;7~ ~
Karl E. RominSM'. Esquire
155 South Hanover Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 241.6(17O
Supreme CoUrt ID #81924
Attorneys for Plaintiff
WRIT OF SUMMONS
CO
OU ARE NOTIFIED THAT THE ABOVE-NAMED PLAINTIFF HAS
NCED AN ACTION AGAINST YOU.
(I~
"(j 1,.2 ,J.M6
By:
Date:
Deputy .
~ ~. ~
. ,~~
TO. ~ V\ ~1j...\... ~\ ~~. ~cP
~ ~ V\"'c -' -- .
-s ..t:. .v\ ~t r: 1
-.) -"" 0 ~(;: o;s:.
..D -\ '"'l:> "i-<~': 4? .
- -" "'- ~
_ r- c:::>
~
I
~Xklh'lt A-
.r
KeUy Ray
Hockenb
Admirli
.Nathan M.
Sandra Louise
, Adininisttator and
. ofBstate of
ockenbeay,
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS .
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
No. Of:,~ .1. 7!.. 7 CI,J, I +UfO\
v.
E.~
:J2~ 5!
~(;. -<
~~~ N
I': ~
~ ~.
:C
:A.
AM Gen , LLC and General
MotorS Co ration.
Defendant
To the Pro
issue a wtll: of sutnmOllS in the above captioned action
W:' of Summons shall be issued and returned to Karl B.ltoro.inger, Esquire at 155 South
Hanover S . C~l'tll$le, Pennsylvania 17013 for private service 011 AM. Genetal, LLC and
General M tors Corporation.
Date: i7.. .
I "-;.
(L,
/
. .
Z'.uO~
Respect:ft1lly submitted,
ROMINGER, BAYLEY & ~
.? ...:
Karl E. Romlnger, Esquire
155 South Hanover Street
Car.Iisle, PA 17013
(711) 241-6070
Suprem~ Court ID #81924
Attorneys for Plaintiff
L.J. H FFMAN
Authorize Agent For
Process-GM ~,O..Detroft
~y Usa offman
WRIT OF SUMMONS
To The Aba . Named Defendants: Al4 General, LLC
105 N..Niles Ave
P.O. Box 7025
South Bend, m 46617
General Motors ColpOl'ation
. 100-400 R""Alqance Center
East Jeffers'on Ave
Detroit, MI 48243
YO ARE NO'l:J1<mD THAT THE ABOVE.NAMED PLAlNTIFF HAS
COMldEN P AN Acn~ AGAINST YOU.
~
Deputy .
rfl
~iIJ
~~
g~
j
-<:
\
-
.
f~~\ b jt B
Petitio er_ after a proper search ha,S:...... ascertained that decedent left no will and was survived by
the folio 'ng spouse (if any) and heirs:
Name Relationship Residence
, A
_. ~ 17~V(
fl"r~ 17.r 1
r"
--
Jr, ..
ON FOR GRANT OF LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION
\\-OG~
No. ~ (>f) i -o{)l$"C> ~
To:
Register of Wijls for /-he J f.
County of (. "~~" In the
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
Social ecurity No.
etition of the undersigned respectfully represents that:
petitioner(s);jvho is/are lS-years-ofageotold"et,llllp11 ",I
R."r.... 4' . '"
(d.b .; pendente lite; durante absentia; durante minoritate)
the a e decedent.
Dece dent was domiciled at death in . ( .,~ l.~ . County, ,~ennsYlvania, with
last family or principal residence at ~ ~ ltI-J... re;f ~ .pIItAf;L. ~ 17d) 7
(lisl street. number and municipality)
I <r years of age, died /II{ A. '1 /e( ,>9- .)oo.f,
- for letters of adinlnistiition
on the estate of
Dece dent, then
at
t at death owned property with estimated values as folllows:
(If do . ed in Pa.) All personal property
(If not omiciled in Pa.) Personal property in Pennsylvania
(If not miciled in Pa.) Personal property in County
Value 0 reai estate in Pennsylvania
situated as follows:
c::.
$
$
$
$
"r ". ~ ,'"
THE ORE, petitioner(s) respectfully request(s) the grant of letters of administration in the
appropria form to the undersigned.
~
~
"'~
'il W
",{
].g
...'"
~"
~e:
ElO
~
<;;
~_ ;1 ~t1'hjyJ(J-
RD
In Testimony wherof, I hereunto
8et my hand and the eeal
...-',. ..
A TRUE COpy FROM RECORD
In Testimony wherot, I hereunto
set my hand and the seal
ot said Court at Carlisle, PA
This \3~ay
CIe\'k of the Orphans Court
Cumberland CoUn
Cumberland County - Register Of Wills ~'~~/200~
PA File No 2104-00508
13411106132006
ROW621
File No 2004-00508
Decedent HO KENBERRY NATHAN RAY
DIE Date
No. Filed
001 OS/28/04
002 OS/28/04
003 09/01/04
Docket Entries
TITION FOR GRANT OF LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION
TH OF PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE
TH CERTIFICATE
T OF LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION
REMINDER LETTER MAILED TO PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE
004 09/20/04 C RTIFICATION OF NOTICE UNDER RULE 5.6(A)
005 12/09/04 P TITION FOR APPROVAL OF SETTLEMENT
006 12/20/04
007 01/10/05
008 01/10/05
009 01/19/05
010 03/31/06
:>11 04/17/06
ER OF COURT - DATED 12-16-04 IN RE: PETITION FOR APPROVAL OF
TTLEMENT A HEARING IS SCHEDULED FOR 1-5-05 @ 11:00 AM IN COURT-
OM NO.5. BY THE COURT - EDWARD E GUIDO JUDGE
F NAL ORDER AND NOW THIS 10TH DAY OF JANUARY 2005 IT IS HEREBY
o ERED AND DECREED THAT THE SETTLEMENT IN THE AMOUNT OF ONE
RED FIFTY FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS IS GRANTED SEE FINAL ORDER TO
T SEE DISTRIBUTION-SIGNED
REMINDER LETTER MAILED TO ATTY & PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE
INCOMPLETE FILED
.--
1=-K~'\l h~ t L
Pennsboto Township and
ent of Transportation of the
onwealth of Pennsylvania,
Defendant
: A.D.
Kel y Ray & Sandla Louise
H enberry, Administrator and
A .. stratrix of Estate of
Na M. Hockenberry,
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
; CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
: rh. Oil - ~1 11 Col.:.1 + crl'<
v.
: CML ACTION. LAW
NOTICE
YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against the claims set
. forth in the following Complaint, you must take adion within twenty (20) days after this
Com laint and Notice are served, by enterillg a written appeamnce pmonaUy or by attorney
and . in writing with.theCourt your defenses or objeclioDs to the clainis set forth against
you. You are warned that if you l3il to do so. the case may proceed without you and a
j ent may be entered against you by the Court without tiuther notice for any money
in the Complaint or for any other claim Ol: relief requested by the PlaintitT. You
money'or property or other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE TInS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU
DO OT HA VB A LAWYER, GO TO OR TELEPHONE TIlE OFFICE SET FORTH
BEL W. THIS OFFICE CAN PROVIDE YOU WITH INFORMATION ABOUT
G A LAWYER. IF YOU CANNOT AFFORD TO HIRE A LAWYER, TInS
MAY BE ABLE TO PROVIDE YOU WITH INFORMATION ABOUT
cms THAT MAY OFFER LEGAL SERVICES TO ELIGIBLE PERSONS AT A
CED FEE OR NO FEE.
Cumberland County Bar Association
32 South Bedford Street
Carlisle. PA 17013
Phone: (717) 249-3166
AMERICANS WITH DISABn.lTIES ACT OF 1990
urt of Common Pless ofCumber1and COllJlty is required by law 10 comply witbthe
. with Disabilities Act of 1990. For information about accessible &riljties and
. Ie acoommodations available to disabled individuals havinl business before the
co , please contact Ollr Office. Alllll'tllJlgtD1CllS must be made at lease 72 hours prior to
any hearing or business before Ihe court. You must attend Ihe schedukd conference or
hearing.
Kel y Ray & Sandra Louise
Ho kenberry, Administrator and
A, ., stIatrlx of Estate of
N M. Hockenberry,
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PA
v.
: ~.tJr. ~ .;.711 ~ -r;;;....,..
: CML ACTION - LAW
: A.D.
Pennsboro Township and
ent ofTransportation of the
onwealth of Pennsylvania,
Defendant
COMPLAINT
AND NOW comes the Plaintiff, KeUy Ray & Sandra Louise Hockenberry,
A r and Administratrix of the Estate of Nathan M. Hockenberry, deceased,
thro their attorney, Karl E. Rominger, Esquire, and for cause action against the
1. The P1aintiffs are Kelly Ray and Sandra Louise Hockenberry,
Administrates of the Estate of Nathan M. Hockenberry, deceased, duly
appointed by the Register of Wills of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania
on May 28, 2004, and they bring these actions under and by virtue of
Section 8301 (Wrongful Death) and 8302 (Survival Action) of the Judicial
Code, 42 Pa. C.S.A. Section 101 et seq.
2. Plaintiffs are adult individuals living and relliding at IS Rehobeth Road,
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17257.
3. Defendant, West Pennsboro Borough Township is a municipal entity in
the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and maintains an office at 2150
. Newville Road, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17241.
'.
4. Defendant, Department of Transportation of the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania (hereinafter referred to as "PennDOT") is an agency of the
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and IIllIintains an office at the Keystone
Building, 400 North Street, 91b Floor, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17101.
5. The decedent Nathan M. Hockenberry was, at all times relevant to this
action, a resident of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, residing at 15
Rehobeth Road, Sbippensburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17257
with his parents, Plaintiffs, Kelly Ray and SandIa Louise Hockenberry.
6. At. the time of his death on May 14, 2004, decendent, Nathan M.
Hockenberry, was nineteen, having been born on February 22,1985.
7. Decedent did not, in his lifetime, bring an action against the Defendants
for the injuries causing his death.
8. On May 14, 2004, at approximately 1:56 p.m., the decendent was
operating a 2001 Chevrolet Blazer automobile owned by Barbara
McMullen.
9. On said date and time, the said vehicle was being operated in a southerly
direction on State Route 11 in West Pennsboro Township, Cumberland
County, Pennsylvania, with the vehicle following the flow of traffic.
10. On said date and time, Darlene Hall was operating a 2003 Hummer H2
automobile in a westerly direction on State Route 233 in West Pennsboro
Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, near its intersection with
State Route 11
a. In failing to place a traffic light at said in~tion;
COUNT ONE-WRONGFUL DEATH ACTION
Ray &. Sandra Louise
enberry, Administrator and
. . stratrix of Estate of
M. Hockenberry,
Plaintiff
v.
We Pennsboro Township,
Defendant
IS. Paragraphs 1 through 14 of Plaintiffs Complaint are incorporated by
reference herein as if set forth in full.
16. The intersection of State Routes 11 and 233 bas been the site of numerous
acCidents prior to the HockenberrylHall accident and had been the subject
of traffic and/or engineering studies by Defendant, West Pennsboro
Township, prior said accident.
17. Said intersection constitutes a dangerous and hazardous roadway of which
Defendant, West Pennsboro Township, knew or had reason to know of
prior to the occurrence of the accident which is the subject of this action.
18. Defendant, West Pennsboro Township, WlIS negligent in its ownership,
custody, control and maintenance of the intersection of State Routes 11
and 233 in one or more of the following particulars:
,
b. In failing to properly and adequately design and maintain
said intersection so as to assure that it was safe for
motorists traveling thereon and
c. In failing to warn motorists of the dangerous condition of
said intersection.
d. In removing or allowing to be removed rumble strips which
guarded the entrance to the intersection and which would
have warned Hall as she approached, that a dangerous
intersection was ahead.
19. The negligence, carelessness and recklessness of Defendant, West
Pennsboro Township, as described created a dangerous condition of
Municipal-owned real estate and highways within purview of 45
Pa.C.S.A. 8522(4), at said intersection of which West Pennsboro
Township had knowledge and/or notice prior to this accident.
20. Notice of this action, pursuant to statute, was timely provided to
Defendant, West Pennsboro Township. (Attached lIS Exhibit "A")
21. As a result of the decedent's death, West Pennsboro Township, is liable
for the following damages:
a. Funeral expenses for decedent;
b. Expenses of Administration relating to decedent's injuries;
,
c. Loss of the support, consortium, comfort, counsel, aid,
association, care and services of the decedent sustained by
his parerits, Kelly Ray and Sandra Louise Hockenberry and
his daughter, Lariah-Ann Marie Wilson; and
d. Such other damages as are permissible in a wrongful death
action.
Plaintiffs, Kelly Ray and Sandra Louise, Administrator and
A . of the Estate of Nathan M. Hockenberry, demands judgment againsl the
dant, West Pennsboro ToWnship, in an amount excess of the mandatory arbitration
and costs of suit.
'.
COUNT TWG-SURVIV AL ACTION
Kell Ray &. Sandra Louise
Hoc enberry, Administrator and
A 'x of Estate of
N M. Hockenberry,
Plaintiff
immediately before the collision and the time of death;
v.
West Pennsboro Township,
Defendant
22. Paragraphs I through 21 of the Plaintiffs Complaint are incorporated by
reference herein as if set forth in full.
23. As a direct and proximate result of the aforesaid collision, Defendant,
West Pennsboro Township, is liable to the Plaintiff for the following
damages:
a. Decedent's emotional distress between the time
b. Decedent's pain and suffering from the ofhis injuries and
the time of death;
c. Decedent's future earnings and earning capacity during the
period of his work life expectancy;
d. Decedent's other financial losses suffered as a result of
death; and
e. Decedent's loss of enjoyment of life.
v.
REFORE, Plaintiffs, Kelly Ray and Sandra Louise, Administrator and
. . stram of the Estate of Nathan M. Hockenberry, demands judgment against the
Defi dant, West Pennsboro Township, in an amount excess of the mandatory arbitration
Iimi and costs of suit.
COUNT THREE-WRONGFUL DEATH ACTION
Ray & Sandra Louise
nberry, Administrator and
'x of Estate of
M. Hockenberry,
Plaintiff
Dep ent ofTl'IIDllportation of the
Co onwea1th of Pennsylvania,
DefendaJ;rt
24. Paragraphs 1 through 23 of Plaintiffs Complaint are incorporated by
reference herein as if set forth in full.
. 25.. The intersection of State Routes II and 233 has been the site of numerous
accidents prior to the Hockenberry/Ha1l accident and bad been the subject
of traffic and/or engineering studies by Defendant, Department of
Transportation of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, prior said accident.
26. Said intersection constitutes a dangerous and hazardous roadway of which
Defendant, Department of Transportation of the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania, knew or bad reason to know of prior to the occurrence of
the accident 'Which is the subject of this action.
27. Defendant, Department of Transportation of the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania, was negligent in its ownership, custody, control and
maintenance of the intersection of State Routes 11 and 233 in one or more
of the following particulars:
a. In failing to place a traffic light at said intersection;
b. In failing to properly and adequately design and maintain
said intersection so as to assure that it was safe for
motorists traveling thereon and
c. In failing to warn motorists of the dangerous condition of
said intersection.
28. The negligence, carelessness and recklessness of Defendant, Department
. of Transportation of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, as described
created a dangerous condition of Commonwea1th-owned real estate and
highways within purview of 45 Pa-C.S.A. 8522(4), at said intersection of
which Department of Transportation of the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania had knowledge and/or notice prior to this accident.
29. Notice of this action, pursuant to statute, was timely provided to
Defendant, Department of Transportation of the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania. (Exhibit "A")
30. As a result of the decedent's death~ Department of Transportation of the
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, is liable for the following damages:
e. Funeral expenses for decedent;
f. Expenses of Administration relating to decedent's injuries;
g. Loss of the support, consortium, comfort, counsel, aid,
llSSOCiation. care and services of the decedent sustained by
his parents, Kelly Ray and Sandra Louise Hockenberry and
his daughter, Lariah.Ann Marie Wilson; and
h. Such other damages as are permissible in a wrongful death
action.
FORE, Plaintiffs, Kelly Ray and Sandra Louise, Administrator and
. stratrix of the Estate of Nathan M. Hockenberry, demands judgment against the
t, West Pennsboro Township, in an amount excess of the mandatory arbitration
COUNT FOUR-SURVIVAL ACTION
Ray & Sandra Louise
nberry, Administrator and
.stratrix of Estate of
M. Hockenberry,
Plaintiff
v.
o ent of Transportation of the
Co onwealth of Pennsylvania,
Defendant
31. Paragraphs 1 through 30 of the Plaintiffs Complaint are incorporated by
reference herein as if set forth in full.
32. As a direct and proximate result of the aforesaid collision, Department of
Transportation of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, is liable to the
Plaintiff for the following damages:
f. Decedent's emotional distress between the time
immediately before the collision and the time of death;
g. Decedent's pain and suffering from the ofhis injuries and
the time of death;
h. . Decedent's future earnings and earning capacity during the
period ofbis work life expectancy;
i. Decedent's other financial losses suffe.red as a result of
death; and
j. Decedent's loss of enjoyment of life.
Date: N~1 /21 ZdOt
BY:
7
,
.'
"
Defe dant, West Pennsboro Township, in an amount excess of the mandatory arbitration
trix of the Estate of Nathan M. Hockenberry, demands jijdgment against the
REFORE, Plaintiffs, Ke1\y Ray and Satldnt Louise, Administrator and
Respectfully Submitted,
ROMINGER &; WHARE
Karl E. Rominger, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiffs
Attorney 1.0. #81924
1 SS South Hanover Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 241-6070
Date. L1
. ('f/2{ 2066
7
.-
. Karl E. Rominger, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
.,
, "
Kell Ray &. Sandra Louise
Hoc enbe1Ty, Administrator and
A nistra1rix of Estate of
Na M. Hockenberry,
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
v.
: CIVIL ACTION. LAW
West Pennsboro Township and
ent ofTransportation of the
Co onwealth of Pennsylvania,
Defendant
: A.D.
ATIORNEY VERIFICATION
KARL E. ROMINGER., ESQUIRE, states that he is the attorney for the Plaintiffs
in thi action; that he makes this affidavit as attorney because he has sufficient knowledge
or inf1 rmation and belief, based upon his investigation of the matters averred or denied in
the fo going document; and that this statement is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.
C.S. e.s. ~4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
.
.
"
.'
,~g~
LAW OFFICES
lawtlromingerl .com
www.romlngerl.com
1 SS SOU11-t HANOVER STREET
CARLISLE. PENNSYLVANIA 17013
TEL: 717.241.6070
FAX: 717.241.6876
KARL E. ROMI GER, ESQ.
MARK F. BAYl ,ESQ.
MICHAEL J. W ARE, ESQ.
July 26, 2004
FILE COpy
W t PeMsboro Township
of Supevisors
21 0 Newville Road
C lisle, PA 17013
P ylvania Department of Transportation
De ty Secretary for Highway Administration
Ke stone Building, 400 North Street
H 'sburg, PA 17120
RE: NATHAN HOCKENBERRRY
DATE OF DEAm: MAY 14. %004
Board of Supervisors:
This letter is to infonn you that we are representing the Estate of Nathan
Hoc enberry who was tragically killed in a motor vehicle accident on May 14,2004, on
the 'tner Highway in West PeMSboro Township in Cwnber1and County. We intend to
nam all responsible parties in a lawsuit, and hereby give you notice that we believe you
may an appropriate defendant.
Therefore, consider this letter our six (6) month notice of our intent to bring any
and I applicable causes of action in a Court of competent jurisdiction.
Sincerely,
--j
./
~
Karl E. Rominger, Esquire
KE
cc. e of Nathan Hockenberry
EXHIBIT "A"
ADVOCACY - ADVICE - ANSWERS
(') ~ ~
~ ~ .,..
"'"
-1.'\'1':'1 ~ ~~
T"oo ~ ~ rtH1't ~
.......".
~ ofor.+;'
~\ /' -
~ <1',."" r-> ~~~
...<':~'
~ V\ c;:cJ
- - ;;; ..- ,.,. %~~
'e ~ ..J ..t.. c ~)..~ -:;:.
~ Yt::' -
.,C) - =-I
\. ..... '? .' ~
~ ~ ~ ~ -
~ C"' C1'
-Q ~
{ :I:..
-4
~
l
-
~
"
'"\
.
,"
THOMAS W. CORBETI. JR.
Attorney General
.'
... i
.-
.'
Steven . Gould
Senior eputy Attorney General
Office f Attorney General
Torts L tigation Section
15tl1 Fl r, StrawbelT)' Square
Harris . PA 17120
Direct ial: 717-783-3105
E-Mail: s2ould.@.attomeYieneral.l!ov
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
Plaintiff
CIVIL LAW
v.
WEST ENNSBORO TOWNSHIP and
DEPAR NT OF TRANSPORTATION
OF COMMONWEALTH OF
PENNS LV ANIA
NO. 06-2717
Defendants
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
P ease enter my appearance on behalf of Defendant. Department of Transportation of the
Commo ealth of Pennsylvania, in the above-captioned matter.
Respectfully submitted.
By:
DATED: ay 24,2006
To Litigation Section
15th Floor, Strawberry Square
H burg, PA 17120
717- 83-8035 - Direct Dial
A~~
By'
. STEVEN C. GOULD . #80156
Senior Peputy.Attomey General
..
.~/ ..,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that I am this day serving the Commonwealth Defendant'.
En of Appearance upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below;
SERVICE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL
POSTAGE PREPAID
ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS:
W Pennsboro Borough Township
215 Newville Road
Carl Ie, PA 17013
..'"'
.
.'
(") ~ q.
c ~
~. ~~
"",,0" :l!:
fi,r' :.>'
........,:, ...:
~r ~ :-(; J
;l,~~" ,." I
':7tt;f~
....., :.'):1)
:P.;; :;!l; ,~.n
,<he .~n:i
PI';: r:-? 9
~ :- ~
.r;;- ;;<.
-
"
,
,
.
.
Steven . Gould
Senior puty Attorney General
Office 0 Attorney General
Torts Li gation Section
15m Flo , Strawberry Square
Harrisb g, PA 17120
DirectDal: 717-783-3105
E-Mail: ould ttorne eneral. ov
Y & SANDRA LOUISE
ERRY, Administrator and
atrix of ESTATE OF
M.HOCKENBERRY
Plaintiff
v.
SBORO TOWNSHIP and
DEPAR ENT OF TRANSPORTATION
OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF
PENNS VANIA
Defendants
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
CIVIL LAW
NO. 06-2717
NOTICE TO PLEAD
By:
DATED: June 8, 2006
IFFS:
OU ARE HEREBY REQUIRED to respond to the within Preliminary Objections within
twenty ( 0) days of the date of service hereof or a default judgment may be entered against you.
Respectfu1ly submitted,
THOMAS W. CORBETI, JR.
Attorney General
.
.
t'
,
.
[xl-tl b;+ D
..."
. '
,
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
Kelly Ray & Sandra Louise
Hockenbe , Administrator and
Administr trix of Estate of
Nathan M Hockenberry
CIVIL ACTION
vs
AM Gene al LLC and
GENE MOTORS CORPORATION
NO.
AFFIDAVIT OF AM GENERAL LLC
IN SUPPORT OF GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION'S
. PETITION FOR REMOVAL
I, Kevin . O'Rear, being first duly sworn on oath, hereby depose and state:
1. I have personal knowledge of the facts contained in this Affidavit and could
competently testify to these facts if called upon to do so in Court.
2. I am the Vice President and General Counsel of AM General LLC ("AM
General"). I have held this position since November 2001. I am also the
Secretary of AM General and am authorized to make this Affidavit on behalf
of AM General.
3. AM General is a limited liability company organized and existing under the
laws of Delaware, with its principal place of business in South Bend, Indiana.
Further, affiant sayeth not.
/4j~
Kevin D. O'Rear
AM General LLC
BY:
State of diana )
)
County 0 St. Joseph )
Before m , the undersigned, appeared Kevin D. O'Rear, and he, being frrst duly sworn upon his oath,
stated th the foregoing was true.
~/v1111L--
Erin M. Villeneuve, Notary Public
Residing in St. Joseph County, Indiana
~\U.. 2-0 I "'2.-Qo (p
~
My comission expires:
October :>, 2006
.
.
>:
0:,
I
C
uJ
(--'~
(p
\j
(=-,.,
I
E-."~ 'c~
cri;~J
o
u-
o
~'" ;:-,
c'-'
c")
(,.;,~
~_,o
c
:....")
,,-.':)
,
'i~
.