HomeMy WebLinkAbout01-5417
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
C'u~l ~~
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
NO. 0 l - .5"'117
NOTICE TO DEFEND
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you
must take action within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written
appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defenses or objections to the claims
set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment
may be entered against you by the Court without further notice for any money claimed in the Complaint or for any
other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A
LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO
FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
COURT ADMINISTRATOR
4th Fl., Cumberland County Courthouse
Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17101
(717) 240-6200
NOTICIA
Le han demandado a usted en la corte. Si usted quiere defenderse de estas demandas expuestas en las
paginas sugnuientes, usted liene viente (20) dias de plazo al partir de la fecha de la demanda y la notificacion. Usted
debe presentar una apariencia escrita 0 en persona 0 por abogado y archivar en la corte en forma escrita sus defensas
o sus objeciones alas demandas en contra de su persona. Sea avisado que si listed no se defiende, la corte tomara
medidas y puede entrar una orden contra listed sin previa aviso 0 notificacion y por cualquier queja 0 alivio que es
pedido en la peticion de demanda. Usted puede perder dinero 0 sus propiedades 0 otros derechos importantes para
usted.
LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO IMMEDIATEMENTE. SI NO TIENE ABOGADO 0 SI
NO TIENE EL DlNERO SUFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICIO, VAYA EN PERSONA 0 LLAME POR
TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DlRECCION SE ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR
DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEGAL.
COURT ADMINISTRATOR
4th Fl., Cumberland County Courthouse
Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17101
(717) 240-6200
ORIGINAL
235144.lIMTG\LC3
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 6/- .5''-1/7 e.u'<L ~~
mRY TRIAL DEMANDED
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
COMPLAINT
1. Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer is an adult individual and a citizen of the
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania who resides in Camp Hill, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
2. Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez is an adult individual who resides at 7004 Peters
Creek Road, No. 21, Roanoke, Virginia.
3. The facts and occurrences hereinafter related took place on or about July 14,
2001, at approximately 11: 18 p.m. at the intersection of South Third Street (SR 2035) and
Herman Avenue, Lemoyne, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
4. At that time and place, Mr. Wintermeyer was operating his 1983 Honda Shadow
750 motorcycle in a northbound direction on South Third Street approaching Herman Avenue.
5. At the same time, Defendant Salinas-Valdez was operating a 1984 Oldsmobile
Cutlass in a northbound direction on South Third Street.
6. The Defendant turned on his left turn signal and stopped in the intersection to turn
left onto Herman Avenue.
7. After seeing the Defendant's left turn signal, Mr. Wintermeyer slowed his
motorcycle and attempted to pass the Defendant's vehicle on the right in accordance with 75
Pa.C.SA 93304.
2351441IMTGILC3
8. Without warning, the Defendant suddenly accelerated and turned right, which
caused the right side of his vehicle to impact Mr. Wintermeyer and his motorcycle, causing an
accident.
9. The foregoing accident and all of the injuries and damages set forth hereinafter
sustained by Mr. Wintermeyer are the direct and proximate results of the negligent, careless,
wanton, and reckless manner in which Mr. Salinas- Valdez operated his motor vehicle as follows:
a) failure to keep alert and maintain a proper watch for the presence of other
motor vehicles on the highway;
b) failure to properly use turn signals;
c) failure to yield the right-of-way to Mr. Wintermeyer's vehicle; and
d) driving his vehicle upon the highway in a manner endangering persons
and property and in a reckless manner with careless disregard to the rights and
safety of others and in violation of the Motor Vehicle Code of the Commonwealth
of Pennsylvania.
CLAIM I
Dale Wintermever v. Josue Salinas-Valdez
10. Paragraphs I through 9 are incorporated herein by reference.
II. Mr. Wintermeyer sustained painful and severe injuries that include but are not
limited to a proximal left fibular fracture, a distal left fibular fracture, burns, and multiple
contusions and abrasions.
12. By reason of his aforesaid injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer was forced to incur liability
for medical treatment, medications, physical therapy, and similar miscellaneous expenses in an
effort to restore himself to health, and a claim is made therefor.
13. Because of the nature of his injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer has been advised, and
therefore avers, that he may be forced to incur similar medical expenses in the future, and a
claim is made therefor.
235144.I\MTG\LC3
2
14. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer has undergone and in
the future may undergo physical and mental suffering, inconvenience in carrying out his daily
activities, and loss oflife's pleasures and enjoyment, and a claim is made therefor.
15. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer has been and in the
future may be subject to embarrassment and humiliation, and a claim is made therefor.
16. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer has suffered work
loss, loss of opportunity, loss of frequent overtime pay, loss of daily piece rate bonus pay, and a
permanent diminution of his earning power and capacity, and a claim is made therefor.
17. Mr. Wintermeyer continues to be plagued by persistent pain and limitation and
therefore avers that his injuries may be of a permanent nature, causing residual problems and
permanent scarring for the remainder of his lifetime, and a claim is made therefor.
COUNT I
Dale Wintermever v. Josue Salinas-Valdez
18. Paragraphs I through 17 are incorporated herein by reference.
19. As a result the subject collision, Mr. Wintermeyer's motorcycle sustained
property damage, and a claim is made therefor in the amount of$I,993.18.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer demands judgment against Defendant Josue
Salinas-Valdez in an amount in excess of Twenty-Five Thousand ($25,000.00) Dollars,
235144.I\MTGILC3
3
exclusive of interest and costs and in excess of any jurisdictional amount requiring compulsory
arbitration.
ANGINa & ROVNER, P.c.
Date:
~"~
LD. No. 35956
4503 N. Front Street
Harrisburg, P A 1711 0
(717) 238-6791
Attorney for Plaintiff
235 144. I\MTGILC3
4
VERIFICATION
I, Dale Wintermeyer, Plaintiff, have read the foregoing COMPLAINT and do hereby
swear or affirm that the facts set forth in the foregoing are true and correct to the best of my
knowledge, information and belief. I understand that this Verification is made subject to the
penalties of 18 Pa.C.S.A. S 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
WITNESS:
~
J1LD. W:nt,erl'rlf\(f
Dale Wintermeyer
Dated: q 113/0 \
235144.I\MTG\LC3
(O~
J:#:. /:t.
.........1:::
~ ~
CI) C
~
CJ s~~
...." ~
~ .1I1 6
B8e
I I
~~
1
(')
c:
-.... tn
0ti.; 1"'1
Ill!,':' -.'0
-7 ~'~' I
~.~~." -
Ul,-- .-J
-<r,
f;~ 1..._.' -"0
:/'.Ci .-"
?I"I C..,).
;;> c:
-;r ,'""
~ ...J
:!
)~'B
.~., '^
'(-:, V)
:>1,
DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE
BY: RANDY C. GREENE, ESQUIRE
ATTORNEY LD. # 62692
1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard
14th Floor Attorney for Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez
Philadelphia, PA 19103
(215) 563-3500
Dale Wintermeyer
Plaintiff(s),
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
v.
Josue Salinas-Valdez
Defendant( s).
NO.: 01-5417
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
Kindly enter my appearance on behalf of Defendant, Josue Salinas-Valdez in the above-
captioned matter.
ENE, ESQUIRE
or Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez
d 0 n
"fl
0 ..,~i
n :::r..::...
-l :;T1~
..vr'n
0'> ".,0
~6 ,.'5(:
~ :_-1 :J
if'
i~ .~ :d
.::>~
I? ~
0 ~
(Xl
DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE
BY: RANDY C. GREENE, ESQUIRE
ATTORNEY J.D. # 62692
1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard
14th Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19103
(215) 563-3500
TO -"'/Q/n.J../~
You ARE HERE
TO THE ENCL~;E~01J~!JO :c;.A~
WITHIN TWENTY .a
JTH ER E HEREflWORJ OA YS FROM
N /.fA Y A f)[FAlIl T
ST Y U. BE ENTERED
.
Dale Wintermeyer
P1aintiff(s),
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
v.
Josue Salinas-Valdez
Defendant(s).
NO.: 01-5417
DEFENDANT JOSUE SALINAS- VALDEZ'S ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S
COMPLAINT WITH NEW MATTER
1. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph I and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial.
2. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph 2 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial.
3. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph 3 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial.
4. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph 4 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial.
5. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph 5 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial.
6. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph 6 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial.
7. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph 7 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial.
8. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph 8 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial.
9. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph 9 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time oftrial. By way of further answer, it is
specifically denied that answering defendant was negligent, careless, wanton and/or reckless in
the operation or control of any motor vehicle. By way of further answer, the specific averments
of paragraph 9 are denied as follows:
a. It is specifically denied that answering defendant failed to keep alert and
maintain a proper watch for the presence of other motor vehicles on the highway;
b. It is specifically denied that answering defendant failed to properly use
turn signals;
c. It is specifically denied that answering defendant failed to yield the right
of way to plaintiffs vehicle; and
d. It is specifically denied that answering defendant drove his vehicle upon
the highway in a matter endangering persons and property and in a reckless manner with careless
disregard to the rights and safety of others and in violation of the Motor Vehicle Code of the
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.
WHEREFORE, answering defendant demands judgment in his favor and against all
parties.
10. Answering defendant incorporates by reference paragraphs 1 through 9 of this
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint as though set forth at length herein.
."--'.----.-'..,--.., '--~-"",._......~~_..-_.,_..
II. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph II and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial.
12. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph 12 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial.
13. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph 13 and strict proofthereofis demanded at time of trial.
14. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph 14 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial.
15. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph 15 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial.
16. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph 16 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial.
17. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph 17 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial.
WHEREFORE, answering defendant demands judgment in his favor and against all
parties.
18. Answering defendant incorporates by reference paragraphs I through 17 of this
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint as though set forth at length herein.
19. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of any factual averments of
paragraph 19 and strict proof thereof is demanded at time of trial.
WHEREFORE, answering defendant demands judgment in his favor and against all
parties.
NEW MATTER
20. Answering defendant incorporates by reference paragraphs I through 19 of this
Answer to Plaintiff's Complaint as though set forth at length herein.
21. Plaintiff's Complaint fails to set forth a cause of action on which relief may be
granted.
22. Plaintiff's cause of action may be barred by the applicable statute of limitations.
23. Answering defendant asserts all of the defenses available under the Motor Vehicle
Financial Responsibility Law (75 Pa. C.S.A. S 1701).
24. The alleged injuries and damages complained of by plaintiff, if they are proven at
trial, may have been caused in whole or in part by the conduct of plaintiff in encountering the
risk which was or should have been obvious to them and therefore, recovery by the plaintiff is
barred by the doctrine of the assumption of the risk.
25. The alleged injuries and damages complained of by plaintiff, if they are proven at
trial, may have been caused in whole or in part by the negligence of others over whom answering
defendant had no control or for whom answering defendant is not responsible and, therefore, any
recovery on the part of plaintiff against answering defendant is barred.
26. Answering defendant exercised reasonable and prudent care with respect to the
operation of his vehicle and was at no time negligent, careless and/or reckless.
27. Plaintiff has failed to mitigate his damages.
28. Plaintiff's injuries and/or damages were not proximately caused by any act or
failure to act of answering defendants.
29. Plaintiff did not suffer any injuries as a result of the incident occurring on or about
the date alleged in plaintiff's Complaint.
30. Plaintiff has selected the limited tort threshold.
parties.
WHEREFORE, answering defendant demands judgment in his favor and against all
. REENE, ESQUIRE
r Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez
. .
VERIFICA nON
Josue Salinas-Valdez, avers that the allegations contained in the foregoing Answer to
Plaintiffs' Complaint With New Matter are true and correct to the best of his knowledge,
information and belief; and that the statements in said pleading are made subject to the penalties
of 18 Pa. C.S. 94904 relating to unsworn falsifications to authorities.
~~
-1OSue Salinas-Valdez
Verified this
Day
day of
,2001
&~tt; ,w
~~~)~
(')
~
~G.i
ZL:.;
0~;
~t-'
e'
L()
--c'
P-C:
Z
=<
,
C:)
;;,-
r:...)
'",'-
.,
I
U.
,
----1 ',~.1
~~C _it
'-:: -;::}
~, ',. )
UlTl
~
-<
2"~
_:;0.
,,)
\0
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
NO. 01-5417 Civil Term
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PLAINTIFF'S REPLY TO DEFENDANT'S NEW MATTER
21. through 30.
All of the allegations contained in the Defendant's New Matter are
conclusions of law to which no response is necessary. By way of further response, the factual
allegations contained in the Plaintiff's Complaint are incorporated herein by reference. By way
of further response, the Plaintiff was operating a motorcycle at the time of the subject motor
vehicle accident. Therefore, the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law is
inapplicable.
WHEREFORE, the Plaintiff respectfully requests that the Defendant's New Matter be
dismissed.
Date: \\~/\)\
~OVNER'P'C'
David L. Lutz
I.D. No. 35956
4503 N. Front Street
Harrisburg, P A 1711 0
(717) 238-6791
Attorney for Plaintiff
238315.1\DLLIMTG
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Mary T. Geraets, an employee of the law firm of Angino & Rovner, P.C., do hereby
certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the PLAINTIFF'S REPLY TO
DEFENDANT'S NEW MAITER upon defense counsel via postage prepaid first class United
States mail addressed as follows:
FUuldyC.Ckeene,Esqurre
1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Attorney for Defendant
Dated: \ \ ~S /\) \
238315.11DLLIMTG
't':> 0 0
C ."
$: z
""Del} ~ ,...
nlf'n .~n
Z:T._~ ... f'";:::
Z " I , m
(fj ~r: ,~
0'. ~
-< ,_:J ,
~C~ ......l ~~)
-0 ,
ZlJ :::!:: ~d ::J
C)
j>c, r:-? C) rn
C
~ w b!
::0
-<
_"":J",ll;Li~L~1 JI~:mltlllltf:iUj:~I[lk, '
,,'!' \J
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
NO. 01-5417 Civil Term
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE
I, Randy C. Greene, Esquire, counsel for Josue Salinas-Valdez, hereby accept service of
the Complaint filed in this action on behalf of the Defendant, and hereby verify that I am
authorized by my client to accept service of the Complai
ene, Esquire
1 JF Blvd., Suite 1400
Phil elphia, PA 19103
Attorney for Defendants
Date: 1)- 13 -D /
237530.1\DLLIMTG
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Mary T. Geraets, an employee of the law firm of Angino & Rovner, P.C., do hereby
certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE upon
defense counsel via postage prepaid first class United States mail addressed as follows:
Randy C. Greene, Esquire
I 800 JFK Blvd., Suite I400
Philadelphia, P A 19103
Attorney for Defendant
Dated: t\ ~ \ ~ ~ 0 \
236329.1IDLLIMTG
8 0 0
-n
s:: :z: ;:j~;;g
"Om <::>
!;2p, oc:::
.'-lrn
tJ55; .r:- '~i(:J
;:~')(Ll
~6 " ~-rl
6:;1
i8 ::Jl: .:::"..( )
N or",
~ .. ~
W
(.,) -<
,
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
NO. 01-5417 Civil Term
WRY TRIAL DEMANDED
PETITION FOR RULE TO SHOW CAUSE WHY THE COURT SHOULD NOT ORDER
THAT PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL BE PERMITTED TO FILE A PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW
HIS APPEARANCE
AND NOW COMES Angino & Rovner, P.C., and respectfully requests that Your
Honorable Court enter a Rule upon Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer to show cause why the Court
should not Order that Plaintiff s counsel be permitted to file a Praecipe to Withdraw His
Appearance. In support thereof, Angino & Rovner avers the following:
1. On July 14, 2001, Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer was injured in a motorcycle/motor
vehicle accident caused by Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez. See, Plaintiff's Complaint filed on
September 17,2001, attached as Exhibit A.
2. Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer retained Angino & Rovner and entered into a Power of
Attorney and Fee Agreement with regard to the July 14,2001, motor vehicle accident.
3. The insurer for the Defendant retained the services of Attorney Randy C. Greene and
counsel for the Defendant filed an Answer to the Complaint with New Matter.
4. Counsel for the Plaintiff and Defendant entered into discovery and the depositions of
the respective parties were scheduled for February 21,2002.
5. However, during discovery, Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer corresponded directly with
Attorney Randy Greene. Mr. Wintermeyer's letter dated December 3, 2001, is attached as
Exhibit B.
245515.l\DLLIMTG
"
6. Thereafter, Plaintiffs counsel advised Mr. Wintermeyer to not correspond with
defense counsel.
7. On February 20, 2002, two days before the aforementioned depositions of the parties,
Attorney Greene called Plaintiff s counsel. At that time, Attorney Greene indicated that he
would recommend to the Defendant's insurer that it should tender its policy limits of $25,000.00.
Therefore, in order to save both parties the cost of depositions, counsel agreed to cancel the
depositions.
8. On February 21, 2002, Mr. Wintermeyer met with Plaintiffs counsel and he provided
counsel with authority to accept a tender of policy limits of $25,000 with regard to the bodily
injury claim and to accept a property damage settlement offer of $976.50 for damage to his
motorcycle.
9. In a letter dated February 22, 2002, attached as Exhibit C, Attorney Greene
corresponded with Plaintiff s counsel and confirmed that the depositions were canceled in order
to provide additional time for the Defendant's insurer to evaluate the demand for policy limits.
10. In a letter dated February 25, 2002, attached as Exhibit D, Plaintiffs counsel advised
defense counsel that Mr. Wintermeyer and counsel met on February 21, 2002, and that Mr.
Wintermeyer provided counsel "with authority to accept a tender of policy limits of $25,000 with
regard to his bodily injury claim. Secondly, pursuant to Brian Yount's October 3, 2001, letter,
enclosed for your convenience, Mr. Wintermeyer has also provided me with authority to accept a
property damage [settlement] of $976.50."
11. Thereafter, in a letter dated March 27, 2002, attached as Exhibit E, Attorney Greene
corresponded with Plaintiffs counsel and advised that he had obtained authority to tender the
policy limits of $25,000 and to pay $976.50 for Mr. Wintermeyer's property damage claim.
245515.lIDLLIMTG
2
"
,
12. In a letter dated March 15, 2002, attached as Exhibit F, Mr. Wintermeyer again
corresponded directly with Attorney Greene.
13. Plaintiffs counsel has recommended that Mr. Wintermeyer accept the tender of limits
of $25,000 and the $976.50 property damage settlement, because to proceed further with the
litigation would not be economically feasible.
14. Plaintiffs counsel has also determined that Mr. Wintermeyer had rejected VIM
coverage covering his motorcycle. 75 Pa.C.S.A. ~ 1731( c.1).
15. Notwithstanding the tender of limits and property damage settlement offer, Mr.
Wintermeyer refuses to consummate the settlement.
16. Given Mr. Wintermeyer's refusal to cease corresponding directly with defense
counsel and refusal to settle his claims even though he had provided counsel with authority to do
so, Plaintiffs counsel has requested that Mr. Wintermeyer retain new counsel.
17. In fact, Plaintiffs counsel had provided Mr. Wintermeyer with a draft of the aforesaid
Petition and requested that Mr. Wintermeyer retain counsel so that the Petition could be served
upon Mr. Wintermeyer's new counsel.
18. To date, Plaintiffs counsel has not been contacted by Mr. Wintermeyer's
replacement counsel.
WHEREFORE, Angino & Rovner respectfully requests that Your Honorable Court enter
a Rule upon Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer to show cause why the Court should not Order that
245515.1\DLLIMTG
3
,
Plaintiff's counsel be permitted to file a Praecipe to Withdraw His Appearance and that any
settlement draft and/or draft to pay ajudgment include as a payee, Angino & Rovner, P.C.
Date' S ~ V () \:l
ANGINa & ROVNER, P.C.
~~
J.D. No. 35956
4503 N. Front Street
Harrisburg, P A 1711 0
(717) 238-6791
Attorney for Plaintiff
245515.l\DLLIMTG
4
Exhibit A
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
NO.
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
NOTICE TO DEFEND
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you
must take action within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written
appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defenses or objections to the claims
set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment
may be entered against you by the Court without further notice for any money claimed in the Complaint or for any
other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE TIllS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A
LA WYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE TIlE OFFICE SET FORTIl BELOW TO
FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
COURT ADMINISTRATOR
4th FL, Cumberland County Courthouse
Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17101
(717) 240-6200
NOTICIA
Le han demandado a usted en la corte. Si usted quiere defenderse de estas demandas expuestas en las
paginas sugnuientes, usted tiene viente (20) dias de plazo al partir de la fecha de la demanda y la notificacion. Usted
debe presentar una apariencia escrita 0 en persona 0 por abogado y archivar en la corte en forma escrita sus defensas
o sus objeciones a las demandas en contra de su persona. Sea avisado que si usted no se defiende, la corte tomara
medidas y puede entrar una orden contra usted sin previo aviso 0 notificacion y por cualquier queja 0 alivio que es
pedido en la peticion de demanda. Usted puede perder dinero 0 sus propiedades 0 otros derechos importantes para
usted.
LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO IMMEDIATEMENTE. SI NO TIENE ABOGADO 0 SI
NO TIENE EL DINERO SUFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICIO, VAYA EN PERSONA 0 LLAME POR
TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DIRECCION SE ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR
DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEGAL.
COURT ADMINISTRATOR
4th Fl., Cumberland County Courthouse
Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17101
(717) 240-6200
235144.1 IMTGILC3
Ghl'Pf1 fr
,
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, P A
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 01 -~'fJ7 ~LOlt I~
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
en
u\. ;-;,
Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer is an adult individual and a ~i~zen ~~~f the~:
..c:::... ~
U~ ..~ '. --1
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania who resides in Camp Hill, Cumberland County, ~h.nsylvania: c
~: f~':~ :J:~ : :~_
Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez is an adult individual who reside?ii~?OO<fi>et~}
, 'N ._,....,
=< .-.1 ::<
Creek Road, No. 21, Roanoke, Virginia.
n
C'
COMPLAINT
1.
2.
3. The facts and occurrences hereinafter related took place on or about July 14,
200 I, at approximately 11: 18 p.m. at the intersection of South Third Street (SR 2035) and
Herman Avenue, Lemoyne, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
4. At that time and place, Mr. Wintermeyer was operating his 1983 Honda Shadow
750 motorcycle in a northbound direction on South Third Street approaching Herman Avenue.
5. At the same time, Defendant Salinas-Valdez was operating a 1984 Oldsmobile
Cutlass in a northbound direction on South Third Street.
6. The Defendant turned on his left turn signal and stopped in the intersection to turn
left onto Herman Avenue.
7. After seeing the Defendant's left turn signal, Mr. Wintermeyer slowed his
motorcycle and attempted to pass the Defendant's vehicle on the right in accordance with 75
Pa.C.SA S3304.
235144.1 IMTGILC3
,
8. Without warning, the Defendant suddenly accelerated and turned right, which
caused the right side of his vehicle to impact Mr. Wintermeyer and his motorcycle, causing an
accident.
9. The foregoing accident and all of the injuries and damages set forth hereinafter
sustained by Mr. Wintermeyer are the direct and proximate results of the negligent, careless,
wanton, and reckless manner in which Mr. Salinas-Valdez operated his motor vehicle as follows:
a) failure to keep alert and maintain a proper watch for the presence of other
motor vehicles on the highway;
b) failure to properly use turn signals;
c) failure to yield the right-of-way to Mr. Wintermeyer's vehicle; and
d) driving his vehicle upon the highway in a manner endangering persons
and property and in a reckless manner with careless disregard to the rights and
safety of others and in violation of the Motor Vehicle Code of the Commonwealth
of Pennsylvania.
CLAIM I
Dale Wintermever v. Josue Salinas-Valdez
10. Paragraphs 1 through 9 are incorporated herein by reference.
11. Mr. Wintermeyer sustained painful and severe injuries that include but are not
limited to a proximal left fibular fracture, a distal left fibular fracture, burns, and multiple
contusions and abrasions.
12. By reason of his aforesaid injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer was forced to incur liability
for medical treatment, medications, physical therapy, and similar miscellaneous expenses in an
effort to restore himselfto health, and a claim is made therefor.
13. Because of the nature of his injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer has been advised, and
therefore avers, that he may be forced to incur similar medical expenses in the future, and a
claim is made therefor.
235144.1IMTG\LC3
2
14. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer has undergone and in
the future may undergo physical and mental suffering, inconvenience in carrying out his daily
activities, and loss oflife's pleasures and enjoyment, and a claim is made therefor.
15. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer has been and in the
future may be subject to embarrassment and humiliation, and a claim is made therefor.
16. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Mr. Wintermeyer has suffered work
loss, loss of opportunity, loss of frequent overtime pay, loss of daily piece rate bonus pay, and a
permanent diminution of his earning power and capacity, and a claim is made therefor.
17. Mr. Wintermeyer continues to be plagued by persistent pain and limitation and
therefore avers that his injuries may be of a permanent nature, causing residual problems and
permanent scarring for the remainder of his lifetime, and a claim is made therefor.
COUNT 1
Dale Wintermever v. Josue Salinas-Valdez
18. Paragraphs 1 through 17 are incorporated herein by reference.
19. As a result the subject collision, Mr. Wintermeyer's motorcycle sustained
property damage, and a claim is made therefor in the amount of$I,993.l8.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer demands judgment against Defendant Josue
Salinas-Valdez in an amount in excess of Twenty-Five Thousand ($25,000.00) Dollars,
235144.1IMTGILC3
...
.J
exclusive of interest and costs and in excess of any jurisdictional amount requiring compulsory
arbitration.
ANGINa & ROVNER, p.e.
~utt
J.D. No. 35956
4503 N. Front Street
Harrisburg, P A 1711 0
(717) 238-6791
Attorney for Plaintiff
Date:
235144.1IMTG\LC3
4
VERIFICATION
I, Dale Wintermeyer, Plaintiff, have read the foregoing COMPLAINT and do hereby
swear or affirm that the facts set forth in the foregoing are true and correct to the best of my
knowledge, information and belief. I understand that this Verification is made subject to the
penalties of 18 Pa.C.S.A. 9 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
WITNESS:
~
liLD. W~ntefrnf\1er
Dale Wintermeyer
Dated: q I \310 \
235144.1\MTG\LC3
Exhibit B
. .DellfMf., fant ...I~J3>/o I
. . . ..' llAmwrltin~in rtqc\r~S'Jomv-Jt~~1 dIsposition
. C\q,d nstJosl\ t ,S ql inC\s- ~1l~At2J ~h'6 is the.p irsQI1.p hilt.. y,cu.
_apf.re~re.s e 1\ t, flq. The. .fl V I \.A ctJoncC1J'.t. nu.m bd'.IS 01- SLJ n,
. ,Dlt\t.lo.GI. _Jl\tre vrk.wtt t tlsnt.[e~~iftlOtntIJLtblY\i tteJ.. the.
.!nt.e..t'[o:lntories .t.o.my 1(,<<1 repraelltitiv~ witho~tmakinq
~CG~ i eSll1'- i .\bcfOLC:LSIOiIl\! UcL!ttn<l~lu..h~J-s\tbmitti~
.,i. _Then. ~~. '.eru,1ht\a..J"bl't\ LttCJ J to_Dailu. t~ I WQS
.s.rn ta..-p L a cecA. _catv Jl.f-J till hie h . W Q S _1:y p C ~ Glnd,l.lI h iL h
w us.rrobo. b .v S tot ..6 .Vd.ua \,)'0. Thec~fyuHtKllt..Ld.wo.s.seJ\ t .
.. ba,k__con1.IH ~).r_o.'fe~,.~hJY)FJh~t~Jl.re- nOifl7rL~c~~G\flJ_or .
.'_~rt..not!u__:r.~<<J._JirJ jl nt\HyslA bJl),tteJ.r._hllvt .Lnc]OseJ. CoPtS
~.o.fdrrWtorrect,o nSd to anJ.df He..I n terrc qQtH~y.answerJ'_
.W'hiLKwCft inC41rfeci.r -vcfl....hi~,h~y..Vq'~ tht .importance
() "_Ltt,{, in _Jl)Jc!erGlI ktjQ .R, ht's ofconf,Jentialif
".i AI: t~!tfl~J!o J- h c.1lSLQ n"t .1 Ie . Sl\ftUlO;f -Illq Sod q LSJ'JIif i ~ Y
BtncfPts n~mber. CD nseql.\tntly.).L.haJ fI ttCJ\RJ eqal
.coJ't) lr\ent...D n ... ~my_or lq inh\ .J:rl!eI'Ioq o.t()r~_Jlflt.em en t.. ~tn!S.s:,
Jtis(~lllneolA-tl (/J)5ocJiG. \Sc(1\dtyJium.bs which was not-
.uinclude --on.__nt.-lJJ ~ et _(PP~_jh~t_~QS_.ttl~r1\fajo.rne..(o~.te. -
.q\.\co tl~..T.n Ave..cnle,q.qmn_Julae!mlY\t_Iorornen t IAn ~(t-.th, s
.4ffio.rtrn,en tjone!nSl(tii~.Dc _noi.JA1S;cJ,i.~i~d iSL!ose.1.tttql~.
jdtpflnt,Jcf fomFutcr,~t my (onfld{t\tl~LSOclCdj-J({l1ri~y
1\,.oYl~cSi.U.h,c.~ ...,s.pr{)~ufl'Jbr . FeJe.fql S;1~Ia. LS_(,(llrl~}Adp\1 h.
.lltw.Thc sO(l/d JtclAr,t y A(t..)"~cctlcn 1,os(c) (J..) IC)(vlf')
.rcqL\i res. thlA t See; ~I Je.cL~~mhersR~tt.e1o.teJ r-rrof4s that
.C\fC ohi~'n~"-, oLmalotcilncc\ bV CllAihcfLz.eApcfsons 'fl.\rSIHlnt
to cm~ provlsloncflaw tndctiJ c~or Qftcr Oct. ~ q~lbsh. all
h econ,f i Jen ti~~"hJno uGl.I.l thor! 2eAperso (\ shal\ d ise lOSe.
t\nl such ss~or rtlateJ recordS. I nave ~Iso fCfWctrJeJ
co ~.r.ct ~h;J' infcnno.ticn ~o Mr. Oa.viJ l"d2.rhercby deny ~ClA
alA ~Oflz..a.tlon to lAse my S,SN In noy Wfl.t " Mr.D.Wintenneyer
1408 Carlisle Rd.
CamP Hill. PA 17011
fY1 rOb, t b
Exhibit C
DUGAN BRINKMANN MAGINNIS AND PACE
New Jersey Office
Media Office
12 S. Monroe Street
Media, PA 19063
Attorneys at Law
1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard, Suite 1400
Philadelphia, pennsylvania 19103
16 Aberdeen Place
VVoodbur~ N)08096
(856) 251-9600
Facsimile: (856) 251-9602
(215) 563-3500
Facsimile: (215) 563-5610
www.dbmplaw.com
February 22, 2002
David L. Lutz, Esquire
4503 N. Front Street
Harrisburg, P A 1711 0
RE: Claimant: Dale Wintermeyer
Our Insured: Joseu Salinas-Valdez
D/L: 7/14/01
Claim #: 01-245468 MBS
DBMP File No. 2500
Dear Mr. Lutz:
This will confirm that we have canceled the depositions of the plaintiff and my client
scheduled for February 21, 2002 in order to provide additional time for my client to evaluate your
demand of the policy limits in this case.
I have advised you that we will have a response to your policy limits demand within thirty
days.
Tha..-llc you for your cou..--tesy.
Very truly yours,
RCG/ks
BY:
tfh1bff- L
Exhibit D
~GINO & Rc 1NER, P.C.
717/23%791
FAX 717/23&5610
RiCHARD C. ANGINO
NElLJ. RoVNER
JOSEPH M. MELILLO
TERRY S. HYMAN
DAVID 1.. LUIZ
MICHAEL E. KOSIK
RiCHARD A. SADLOCK
JOSEPH M. Dol\lA
JAMES DECINTI
JOAN 1.. STEHULAK
4503 NORTIi FRONT STREET
HARRISBURG, PA 171l<H70B
WWW.ANGIND-ROVNER.COM
E-MAILoDLUIZ@ANGJNO.ROVNER.COM
February 25, 2002
Randy C. Greene, Esquire
1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Re: Wintermeyer v. Salinas-Valdez
Dear Randy:
This letter will serve to confirm our telephone conversation of February 20, 2002, wherein we agreed to
suspend the depositions of our respective clients.
You indicated that you made a recommendation that there be a tender of limits of the $25,000, but that
there was no guarantee that the insurer would follow through with your recommendation. You also indicated
that you wanted to wait 30 days until a claims committee reviewed the file. If you require further information
and/or documentation, please advise.
I met with Mr. Wintermeyer on February 21, 2002, and he has provided me with authority to accept a
tender of policy limits of $25,000 with regard to his bodily injury claim. Secondly, pursuant to Brian Yount's
October 3,2001, letter, enclosed for your convenience, Mr. Wintermeyer has also provided me with authority to
accept a property damage of$976.50.
However, the property damage settlement is contingent upon a tender of the bodily injury policy limits.
Should you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me.
Very truly yours,
AvJtf1
David L. Lutz
DLL:mtg
Enclosure
237S08.1\DLLIMTG
f5A:b,t1
Exhibit E
Media Office
DUGAN BRINKMANN MAGINNIS AND PACE
New Jersey Office
12 S. Monroe Street
Media, PA 19063
(610) 891-8400
Attorneys at Law
16 Aberdeen Place
Woodbury, NJ 08096
(856) 251-9600
Facsimile: (856) 251-9602
1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard, Suite 1400
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103
(215) 563-3500
Facsimile: (215) 563-5610
www.dbmplaw.com
March 27,2002
Via Telecopv and Re~ular Mail
David L. Lutz, Esquire
4503 N. Front Street
Harrisburg, P A 17110
RE: Claimant: Dale Wintermeyer
Our Insured: Joseu Salinas-Valdez
D/L: 7/14/01
Claim #: 01-245468 MBS
DBMP File No. 2500
Dear Mr. Lutz:
This will follow-up my voice mail message to you on March 26, 2002 in which I advised
that I have authority to tender the policy limits of $25,000.00 and to pay $976.50 for Mr.
Wintermeyer's property damage.
I will forward a release for your client's signature in the near future.
Very truly yours,
RCG/ks
NN, MAGINNIS AND PACE
fjAf'brt- t .
Exhibit F
J 2002 16:10FR DUGAN BRINK MAG PACE15 563 5610 TO 7386~02500~17172 P.02/02
. r--..
:.
'"
To J'\.r. ~Qn&\J c.. Grant. March Ishco~
. /. I c.un writinq in frqQrds 10 Ot.lr
. .ml.\tlAo.\ \iti~tion aisposition. I ht1v~ ret(li~c~ Mr. Davic.lllAt-z.
of Anqino~..((QVncl)o rtprrsent "'v btst inttwts)lUhi<n I
h~Vt e~erfSSt'& to Mr. h.lAb... I ho.vl r((~ntl'f rf(ei~eJ (A ~
. letter.~fom Mr. kl\t~whkh ;J ._Jo,tt't M~tch IS~ooJ..l1r. j
. ~lAt2 ..HQs._informct! ~t ..in...t.ho.t..ltttcr th~t r .~avtpro\JiJe! i
. . :hlm wlth...tht. llo.thoflty to.Q(Ctpt.vOl{t prQpettY.,dqmaje ;
'.'" ':'::::.;: .:..:._.>:~::>:..:,;.., settlt.ffifl\t ~fer of .. ~f1~. 5()'y~nJJijCl~ .~c.. (amlnl/,u (o.tt! lhllt ~-..
.' . '. '..' ..:....settlttntl\t 0 ,fer...to. ~o.u. rho.! "of(tr.-'s .,.nQt..Qaevt(l.b.I.~. 0 mt'., ~.
. .L ha.ve. not Iqn(~ a.n 'np.trs. w..~l.ch sto.tc. th,t t \AI 1\\ i
~ (cept tha.! almcQnt. -f qn\/..(hfCtr..nr~ S Cl}t to f4\e fer thllt .i
.(uno\J.nt I wi \l not si qn it''" it will bt rctl(rnt~. Thai :
.a.mal4.J\f will ~l\IH ({)V-ef tht rtplqcemtnt' lab'I'.Jor fn,/ fafe.
fl\otor(~.(k OJltHGrhuthtfe. Weft cthd"_parts. tK..t wet! :
. d~m~dl. o~ It b._Mr. SQ\ino.s.r have. afro infotmeJ Mr. 1
.Dq\Jj h\\t"Z- that .I vJoulJ_be writin .toycu. to 'Inform :.
0\4 t a.t! (lIn not o.((e~f'f\ our 0 (reI have wr tten in :
t act in a((or&(l1\(~ to my best in tftstr Qn~as m
. ftprtsentitive o-f Ill\! beft il\ttt(stsb~ jnfOrminq M , :
. ().Y'c(n th4.t 1 wi Il/not Qcapt his most tn:ent -dff~t' Of ;
.... ....-.,. .' .....:.,.>-..,. J ql'. 50.:)).1 then CAlso UJr(}te. to nr, l.-lA.t2. "r QI\1 a.ls'o tlitcct- v
. '. i(\~ you to rf;f.USt to ({((ept Mr. Grt~ 0 f~f'."':r \.Uov.l~ ;
liltt to Know i ell. h~Vt ha.~ (o~les of rn n'\l'Ji((I1 ftcords
c. ter~riJ'~or by o.l\Hont ftom he. 14 firm of An inc" av"ef'.
It that hllJ' O((~tr{'~ plco.Jt lnf,()rm m.t Of t~e i J ntitl of -
tkt inJivi~lAo.l.f who ndVt pro~'jae~ Vou \Lith mlj meJiut\
rc(ord..sQ.f\J of the Mil\<'. Cf the. firm or hsinen,fcnterpriJ'{
which t~Cit pefsG')cr prrJ'ons wcrk's 10;, Tha.nt YCIJ..
J/(lcetel'P Mr.D. WiD~..
14M CUUoI.o lid. .
c...p Bill. PA 1'1011
c11~Ob,L(~.2 ..
. '
.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Mary T. Geraets, an employee of the law firm of Angino & Rovner, P.C., do hereby
certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the PETITION FOR RULE TO SHOW
CAUSE upon defense counsel and Mr. Dale Wintermeyer via postage prepaid first class United
States mail addressed as follows:
Randy C. Greene, Esquire
1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Attorney for Defendant
Mr. Dale Wintermeyer
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill, P A 17011
Dated: c:) -- I ~ DO-
245515.I\DLLIMTG
i::~U '
_"...._...."."H>..
i 'if, i;jfJhW1.' if1 iUt.1flMOlilUm.~''''''%~..
.
.
.
(') a 0
~ f'y -'n
~h. 3:
-oClf ~:' -.e... '::1
D)Ln -< r"...;
...::.....-.,.-. '1
...". ::/;;C[J
(?~ ~~;: ,h,-
-
r'(; '" ~._~~ ~::i~
?i~ _. I:;)t::j
~
e-_ ,........, N C:V"
Pc: -..;
Z ;p.:
=< t-v _D
-<
............
..
MAV~002
'\ f' ".#
v.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
NO. 01-5417 Civil Term
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
~
AND NOW, this ~ day of
, 2002, a Rule is hereby entered upon
Dale Wintermeyer to show cause why the Co
ould not permit Plaintiff s counsel to
withdraw his appearance and that any settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment not include
Angino & Rovner, P.C., as a payee.
Rule returnable within ~ days of service.
BY THE COURT:
1.
.
, ~
~r:-f(~g
t:6:
PLFt
o..ry G- R e e./Je
A~, 1-\0 ~ RovJer<..
245515.1IDLLIMTG
,li"lL,lidil;,U~"li''''''_''_''_''''"_._m''... ..
",... "
~
.
J;.' . ~
VIN\JJ\lASNN3d
A.LNnO:J (1\!'il!~jgVlJm
2S:\ Wd 91^~WZO
A1N10t.lOi-U.C:b jHl :10
3~)i:l;;iO--{j311:J
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
NO. 01-5417 Civil Term
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ORDER
AND NOW, this _ day of
, 2002, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED
that Plaintiffs counsel, David L. Lutz, Esquire, is permitted to withdraw his appearance on
behalf of Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer and that any settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment
in the above-captioned case must include Angino & Rovner, P.C., as a Payee.
BY THE COURT:
J.
247041.lIDLLIMTG
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
NO. 01-5417 Civil Term
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL'S PETITION TO MAKE RULE ABSOLUTE
1. On May 16, 2002, a Rule was entered upon Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer to show cause
why the Court should not permit Plaintiff's counsel to withdraw his appearance and that any
settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment not include Angino & Rovner, as a payee. The
Rule was returnable within 15 days of service and was executed by the Honorable George E.
Hoffer. Attached as Exhibit A is Judge Hoffer's Rule. Attached as Exhibit B is the referenced
Petition (without exhibits).
2. In a letter dated May 17,2002, attached as Exhibit C, Plaintiff's counsel sent to Mr.
Wintermeyer Judge Hoffer's May 16,2002, executed Rule.
3. Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer has not filed a response to the Petition. Therefore,
Plaintiff's counsel respectfully requests that Your Honorable Court issue a Rule Absolute and
24704LlIDLL\MTG
Order that Plaintiff's counsel be permitted to withdraw his appearance and that any settlement
draft and/or draft to pay a judgment in the above-captioned action include Angino & Rovner,
P.C., as a Payee.
ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C.
Date: ~ ___I L{ ---0 d
D~
LD. No. 35956
4503 N. Front Street
Harrisburg, P A 1711 0
(717) 238-6791
Attorney for Plaintiff
247041.1IDLLIMTG
Exhibit A
__',""'--"'-Lo"__"'._.",_"",-~........,...;,,._~.__.._,.;.,
~; 5 20D2
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT 0 COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLANDC UNTY,PA
AND NOW, this ~ day of .
CIVIL ACTION -
v.
JOSUE SALINAS- VALDEZ,
Defendant
NO. 01-5417 Civil
, 2002, a Ie is hereby entered upon
Dale Wintermeyer to show cause why the
should not pe it Plaintiff's counsel to
withdraw his appearance and that any settlement draft and/or draft to ay a judgment not include
Angino & Rovner, P.c., as a payee.
Rule returnable within J~5' days of service.
BY THE COURT
ri
245515.1IDLLIMTG
TRUE COpy FROM RECORD
In Testimony whercd, I here unto set my hand
and/t e seal o. f said'tOU, r at carl.is.,..e"., ,p.a.
JI.. 1 \ ) 'tJ-"
,... 0.
. .. ....L.f..J..(. ., ..,
...... .. (..... i, .~." /'--. ",
. ..". ' l.J-l.".jJ
_.~ P;~t notary / r'
~h~~1 ft-
Exhibit B
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT 0 COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLANDC UNTY,PA
,)
~~
"Oi-!
?~: ;~..,
':.:~ 1
v.
CIVIL ACTION -
i...
mRY TRIAL DE
r
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
NO. 01-5417 Civil
(j~, '.
.-',)
PETITION FOR RULE TO SHOW CAUSE WHY THE COURT
THAT PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL BE PERMITTED TO FILE A P
HIS APPEARANCE
1'.)
ORUER<,
THbRA Vi
AND NOW COMES Angino & Rovner, P.C., and respe tfully requests that Your
Honorable Court enter a Rule upon Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer to how cause why the Court
1. On July 14, 2001, Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer was inj ed in a motorcycle/motor
Withdraw His
should not Order that Plaintiff s counsel be permitted to file a
Appearance. In support thereof, Angino & Rovner avers the foIlowin :
vehicle accident caused by Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez.
September 17,2001, attached as Exhibit A.
2. Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer retained Angino & Rovner d entered into a Power of
Attorney and Fee Agreement with regard to the July 14,2001, motor hicle accident.
3. The insurer for the Defendant retained the services of Atto ey Randy C. Greene and
counsel for the Defendant filed an Answer to the Complaint with New Matter.
4. Counsel for the Plaintiff and Defendant entered into disco ery and the depositions of
the respective parties were scheduled for February 21, 2002.
5. However, during discovery, Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer orresponded directly with
Attorney Randy Greene. Mr. Wintermeyer's letter dated Decemb r 3, 2001, is attached as
Exhibit B.
245515.1IDLLIMTG
CthIV:+ b
6. Thereafter, Plaintiffs counsel advised Mr. Wintermey r to not correspond with
defense counsel.
7. On February 20, 2002, two days before the aforementione depositions of the parties,
Attorney Greene called Plaintiffs counsel. At that time, Attorne Greene indicated that he
would recommend to the Defendant's insurer that it should tender its olicy limits of $25,000.00.
Therefore, in order to save both parties the cost of depositions, co sel agreed to cancel the
depositions.
8. On February 21, 2002, Mr. Wintermeyer met with Plainti s counsel and he provided
counsel with authority to accept a tender of policy limits of $25,00 with regard to the bodily
injury claim and to accept a property damage settlement offer of 976.50 for damage to his
motorcycle.
9. In a letter dated February 22, 2002, attached as Ex ibit C, Attorney Greene
corresponded with Plaintiff s counsel and confirmed that the depositi ns were canceled in order
to provide additional time for the Defendant's insurer to evaluate the emand for policy limits.
10. In a letter dated February 25,2002, attached as Exhibit D, Plaintiffs counsel advised
defense counsel that Mr. Wintermeyer and counsel met on Febru 21, 2002, and that Mr.
Wintermeyer provided counsel "with authority to accept a tender of p licy limits of $25,000 with
regard to his bodily injury claim. Secondly, pursuant to Brian Yo's October 3,2001, letter,
enclosed for your convenience, Mr. Wintermeyer has also provided m with authority to accept a
property damage [settlement] of $976.50."
11. Thereafter, in a letter dated March 27, 2002, attached as
corresponded with Plaintiff s counsel and advised that he had obtai ed authority to tender the
policy limits of$25,000 and to pay $976.50 for Mr. Wintermeyer's pr perty damage claim.
245515.1IDLLIMTG
2
12. In a letter dated March 15, 2002, attached as Exhibit F, Mr. Wintermeyer again
corresponded directly with Attorney Greene.
13. Plaintiffs counsel has recommended that Mr. Wintermey r accept the tender of limits
of $25,000 and the $976.50 property damage settlement, because 0 proceed further with the
litigation would not be economically feasible.
14. Plaintiffs counsel has also determined that Mr.
coverage covering his motorcycle. 75 Pa.C.S.A. 9 1731( c.1).
15. Notwithstanding the tender of limits and property
age settlement offer, Mr.
Wintermeyer refuses to consummate the settlement.
16. Given Mr. Wintermeyer's refusal to cease correspond ng directly with defense
counsel and refusal to settle his claims even though he had provided c unsel with authority to do
so, Plaintiffs counsel has requested that Mr. Wintermeyer retain new
17. In fact, Plaintiffs counsel had provided Mr. Wintermeyer .th a draft of the aforesaid
Petition and requested that Mr. Wintermeyer retain counsel so that Petition could be served
upon Mr. Wintermeyer's new counsel.
18. To date, Plaintiffs counsel has not been contacted by Mr. Wintermeyer's
replacement counsel.
WHEREFORE, Angino & Rovner respectfully requests that Y ur Honorable Court enter
a Rule upon Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer to show cause why the Court s ould not Order that
245515.1IDLLIMTG
3
-"-'>~'-'--"~-~._'-'''-'''--''--'''-'--._..............-.-.....~".,.;,_... ~
Plaintiff's counsel be permitted to file a Praecipe to Withdraw Hi Appearance and that any
settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment include as a payee, An ino & Rovner, P.C.
ANGINO & RO ER, P.C.
'\j
Date: S/ \/\j
Davi L. Lutz
J.D. No. 35956
4503 N. Front S et
Harrisburg, PAl 110
(717) 238-6791
Attorney for Plai tiff
245515,1IDLLIMTG
4
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Mary T. Geraets, an employee of the law firm of Angino Rovner, P.c., do hereby
certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the PETITI N FOR RULE TO SHOW
CAUSE upon defense counsel and Mr. Dale Wintermeyer via postag prepaid first class United
States mail addressed as follows:
Randy C. Greene, Esquire
1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Attorney for Defendant
Mr. Dale Wintermeyer
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill, P A 17011
Dated: C) / )- t 0--
24S51S.1IDLLIMTG
--. ~-_._-_..-.---...__....._-~-_.._",.,
Exhibit C
ANGINO & R( VNER, P.C.
4503 NORlH FRONT SmEET
HAiUUSBURG, PA 17110-1708
717/23S6791
FAX 717/23&5610
WWW.ANGIND-ROVNER.COM
E-MAlli DLUI"Z@ANGIND-ROVNER.COM
May 17,2002
Mr. Dale Wintermeyer
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Dear Mr. Wintermeyer:
Enclosed please find Judge Hoffer's May 16,2002, executed Rule.
Very truly yours,
Da~
/mtg
Enclosure
234395.1IDLLIMTG
w.. "'_"_""~__'~_.-'-"'_"''''_~''"''
CHARD C. ANGINO
NEIlJ. ROVNER
OSEPH M. !fElIU.O
'nRRv s. HYMAN
DAVIDL Lurz
MICHAEL E. KOSIK
RICHARD A. SADlOCK
JOSEPH M. DoRIA
}AMEs DECINTI
JOAN L SInrulAK
~\;~'\+- ~
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Mary T. Geraets, an employee of the law firm of Angino Rovner, P.C., do hereby
certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the P AINTIFF'S COUNSEL'S
PETITION TO MAKE RULE ABSOLUTE upon defense counsel via postage prepaid first class
United States mail addressed as follows:
Randy C. Greene, Esquire
1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Attorney for Defendant
Mr. Dale Wintenneyer
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Dated: 0 --- f ~ -0 (J-
247041.1IDLLIMTG
(.-.
..;;..
:3
~
r-,:
o
-n
---4
.)"-
r-;1 :!J
r-
-::J fT1
;q?
'..,! ~
c;,JSJ
_L 'I
,.-}::-Q
;7(.1
cjrn
j;!
~O
-<
(:::
~
,",-
--.J
:-0
x-
s:'
'"\)
(0
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
v.
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
AND NOW,!hi' r'daY of
...
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 01-5417 Civil Term
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
, 2002, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED
that Plaintiff s counsel, David L. Lutz, Esquire,' permitted to withdraw his appearance on
behalf of Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer and that any settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment
in the above-captioned case must include Angino & Rovner, P.C., as a Payee.
~~~/CfIO:2- ;&/
-lb.__k. ~~.
i):J:. 1ffA) .
~~~PC.
247041.lIDLLIMTG ..,J, -(J.
BY THE COURT:
J.
.
...
\/\'~,\\'il'\~\}\Si\~N'~d
I \, \"" '
/\;.\'. \ ',:_,1
., 1Y.:,)"", iN nJ
i IJ :\:;
" ,
\;'\,ej
8- "\\'\f' ze
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
NO. 01-5417 Civil Term
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW APPEARANCE
To the Prothonotary of Cumberland County:
Pursuant to Judge Hoffer's Order dated July 8, 2002, attached hereto, David L. Lutz,
Esquire, hereby withdraws his appearance on behalf of Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer.
ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C.
Date: C\-)- \)'&--
~mz
J.D. No. 35956
4503 N. Front Street
Harrisburg, P A 1711 0
(717) 238-6791
Attorney for Plaintiff
236329.1\DLLIMTG
I
, )
}
JUN 1 B 200Z\f
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
JOSUE SALINAS- VALDEZ,
Defendant
NO. 01-5417 Civil Term
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ORDER
AND NOW, this ~~ay of ~, 2002, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED
that Plaintiff's counsel, David L. Lutz, Esquire, is permitted to withdraw his appearance on
behalf of Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer and that any settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment
in the above-captioned case must include Angino & Rovner, P.C., as a Payee.
BY THE COURT:
IS/~,,- E.. ~ Pl.
I
247041.1IDLLIMTG
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Mary T. Geraets, an employee of the law firm of Angino & Rovner, P.c., do hereby
certifY that I am this day serving a true and Correct copy of the PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW
APPEARANCE upon defense counsel via postage prepaid first class United States mail addressed
as follows:
Randy C. Greene, Esquire
1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Attorney for Defendant
Mr. Dale Wintermeyer
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill, PAl 70 II
Dated: C\/ J-- ~ )---
236329.1\DLLIMTG
JMurf-
o
c
~.
-oii"J
mp'
Z:Oc
zc:-
~~,
.~(~)
.;,;.... c-
.::.;;
~
'.
o
\"'.)
o
'n
en
r..-,
--0
I
:~~$
.~()
CJ
~.
~>t;,
:,-2<:')
<-~)rn
~'::I
55
-<
'"
DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE
BY: RANDY C. GREENE, ESQUIRE
ATTORNEY J.D. # 62692
1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard
14th Floor Attorney for Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez
Philadelphia, PA 19103
(215) 563-3500
Dale Wintermeyer
Plaintiff( s),
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
v.
Joseu Salinas-Valdez
Defendant(s).
NO.: 01-5417
DEFENDANT JOSEU SALINAS-V ALDEZS' MOTION TO
DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO PROSECUTE
Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez, by and through his counsel, Dugan, Brinkmann,
Maginnis and Pace, files this Motion to Dismiss for Failure to Prosecute and avers as follows:
I. Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer (hereinafter referred to as "Plaintiff'), filed a complaint
against Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez (hereinafter collectively referred to as "Defendant"), in
the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County on Septemb.:r 17,2001. (See Exhibit "A"
attached hereto and incorporated herein).
2. The Plaintiffs Complaint alleged physical injuries and property damage stemming
from a collision between Plaintiffs motorcycle and Defendant's automobile.
3. On September 3,2002, according to the docket in this matter, Plaintiffs Counsel
filed a Praecipe to Withdraw Appearance. ( See Exhibit B)
4. Since Plaintiffs Counsels' Praecipe to Withdraw Appearance on September 3, 2002,
Plaintiff has not filed any motion, petition or praecipe concerning this matter.
5. When a civil action has been commenced and the plaintiff fails to diligently
prosecute his or her case, a defendant may avail him or herself of a motion for judgment of non
pros in seeking a "reasonably prompt conclusion to a case." Shope v. Eagle, 710 A2d 1104,
1106 (Pa. 1998)
6. The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania has established a three part test to examine the
circumstances under which a dismissal for failure to prosecute is appropriate: I) A lack of due
diligence on the part of the plaintiff in failing to proceed with "reasonable promptitude"; 2) Lack
of a compelling reason for the delay; and, 3) Actual prejudice to the defendant. ShoDe v. Eagle,
710 A.2d 1107-1108
7. It is the plaintiff, not the defendant, who bears the burden of moving his case along
within a reasonable time. Id. citing to Pennridge Elec. v. Souderton School, 615 A.2d 95,99 (Pa.
Super. 1992)
8. A lengthy period of delay can be one reason for dismissal for inactivity. See. Metz
Contracting v. Riverwood Builders. Inc. 520 A.2d 891 (Pa. Super. 1987) appeal denied 531 A.2d
431 (Pa. 1987) (no activity taken for nearly three and one-half years); Cathcart v. Keene
Industrial Insulation, 471 A.2d 493 (Pa.Super 1984)(no activity taken for over four years).
9, The record reflects that Plaintiffs' cause of action was filed in September 200 I and
the last action taken by plaintiff was in September of 2002.
10. From September of 2002 to the present, there has been no activity of record.
II. Plaintiff ceased discovery and did not initiate settlement negotiations and Plaintiff,
from all indications, abandoned this matter as to Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez.
12. If Plaintiff truly believed that this matter was proceeding accordingly during the past
eighteen months, there would be some indication on the record.
13. If Plaintiff were awaiting discovery that was not being provided to them, there would
be some evidence of motions to compel or other indications that they were attempting to move
this matter forward.
14. Plaintiff has not proceeded with due diligence and reasonable promptitude in
proceeding with this action.
15. Plaintiff has not offered any reason, compelling or not, for his delay.
16. The passage oftime has certainly affected the ability of witnesses to recall the facts
and details ofthe subject matter ofthe claim thereby resulting in prejudice to Joseu Salinas-
Valdez
17. Given the Plaintiff's complete lack of diligence, the burden for which lies with him
and him alone, and the prejudice to Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez, which resulted therefrom,
this matter should be dismissed with prejudice for Plaintiff's failure to prosecute.
WHEREFORE, Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez respectfully request this Honorable
Court to Dismiss this Plaintiffs Complaint with Prejudice.
Respectfully submitted,
ANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE
~
DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE
BY: RANDY C. GREENE, ESQUIRE
ATTORNEY LD. # 62692
1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard
14'h Floor Attorney for Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez
Philadelphia, PA 19103
(215) 563-3500
Dale Wintermeyer
Plaintiff( s),
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
v.
Joseu Salinas-Valdez
Defendant(s).
NO.: 01-5417
DEFENDANT JOSEU SALINAS-V ALDEZS' BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF HIS MOTION
TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO PROSECUTE
Defendants Joseu Salinas-Valdez, by and through his counsel, Dugan, Brinkmann,
Maginnis and Pace, files this Brief in Support of his Motion to Dismiss for Failure to Prosecute
and states as follows:
I. STATEMENT OF THE QUESTION lNVOLVED
A. SHOULD PLAINTIFF'S CAUSE OF ACTION BE DISMISSED FOR PLAINTIFF'S
FAILURE TO PROSECUTE ITS ACTION IN A TIMELY MANNER?
Suggested Answer: Yes
II. STATEMENT OF THE CASE
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer (hereinafter referred to as "Plaintiff'), filed a complaint
against Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez (hereinafter collectively referred to as "Defendant"), in
the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County on September 17, 2001. (See Exhibit "A"
attached hereto and incorporated herein). The Plaintiffs Complaint alleged physical injuries and
property damage stemming from a collision between Plaintiffs motorcycle and Defendant's
automobile
On September 3,2002, according to the docket in this matter, Plaintiffs Counsel filed a
Praecipe to Witbdraw Appearance. (See Exhibit B) Since Plaintiffs Counsels' Praecipe to
Witbdraw Appearance on September 3, 2002, Plaintiff has not filed any motion, petition or
praecipe concerning tbis matter.
III. SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT
Plaintiffs have shown a want of due diligence in their failure to proceed with reasonable
promptness. Plaintiffs have not offered a compelling reason for their delay. It is the plaintiff, not
the defendant, who bears the burden of moving his case along within a reasonable time. A
lengthy period of delay can be one reason for dismissal for inactivity. If Plaintiff truly believed
that this matter was proceeding accordingly during the past eighteen (18) months, tbere would be
some indication on the record. The passage oftime has certainly affected the ability of witnesses
to recall the facts and details ofthe subject matter ofthe claim thereby resulting in prejudice to
Defendant. Joseu Salinas-Valdez
IV. ARGUMENT
A. PLAINTIFFS" CAUSE OF ACTION SHOULD BE DISMISSED FOR PLAINTIFF'S
F AlLURE TO PROSECUTE ITS ACTION IN A TIMELY MANNER.
When a civil action has been commenced and the plaintiff fails to diligently prosecute his
or her case, a defendant may avail him or herself of a motion for judgment of non pros in seeking
a "reasonablyprompt conclusion to a case." Shone v. Eagle, 710 A.2d 1104, 1106 (Pa. 1998). In
examining under what circumstances a court may dismiss an action for inactivity, the Supreme
Court, in Shone v. Eagle, 710 A.2d 1107-1108, has established 11 three part test:
I) A lack of due diligence on the part of the plaintiff in failing to proceed with
"reasonable promptitude"
2) Lack of a compelling reason for the delay
3) Actual prejudice to the defendant
It is tbe plaintiff, not the defendant, who bears tbe risk to move his case along within a
reasonable time. Id. citing to Pennridge Elec. v. Souderton School, 615 A.2d 95, 99 (Fa. Super.
1992). A lengthy period of delay can be one reason for dismissal for inactivity. See. Metz
Contracting v. Riverwood Builders. Inc., 520 A.2d 891 (Pa.Super. 1987) appeal denied 531 A.2d
431 (pa. 1987) (no activity taken for nearly three and one-half years); Cathcart v. Keene
Industrial Insulation,471 A.2d 493 (Pa.Super. 1984) (no activity taken for over four years).
If Plaintiff s truly believed that this matter was proceeding accordingly during the past
eighteen (18) months, there would be some indication on the record. If Plaintiff is awaiting
discovery that was not being provided to them, there would be some evidence of motions to
compel or other indication that they were attempting to move this matter forward. Plaintiff has
not proceeded with due diligence and reasonable promptitude in proceeding with this action.
Plaintiff has not offered any reason for her delay. The passage of time has certainly affected the
ability of witnesses to recall the facts and details ofthe subject matter ofthis claim.
Plaintiff bears the burden of moving her case along within a reasonable time and did not
do so; Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez should not now be prejudiced further by Plaintiffs' failure
to proceed in this matter. Because Plaintiff has failed to diligently prosecute his case, Defendant
Joseu Salinas- Valdez now avails himself of a motion for judgment of non pros so that he may
seek a "reasonably prompt conclusion to {this} case." Shone v. Eagle, 710 A.2d 1106.
V. CONCLUSION
Given the Plaintiffs' complete lack of diligence, the burden for which lies with him and
him alone, and the prejudice for Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez which resulted therefrom, the
Plaintiffs' cause of action should be dismissed with prejudice for his failure to prosecute.
Respectfully submitted,
VERIFICA nON
Randy C. Greene, Esquire, hereby states that he is counsel for the within and based on
other verified pleadings that the statements made in the foregoing Defendant's Motion to
Dismiss For Failure to Prosecute are true and correct to the best of his knowledge, information
and belief. The undersigned understands that the statements therein are made subject to the
penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. ~4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
BY:
ESQUIRE
t J oseu Salinas-Valdez
Dated: January 20,2004
DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE
BY: RANDY C. GREENE, ESQUlRE
ATTORNEY 1.D. # 62692
1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard
14th Floor Attorney for Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez
Philadelphia, PA 19103
(215) 563-3500
Dale Wintermeyer
Plaintiff{ s),
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
v.
Joseu Salinas-Valdez
Defendant(s).
NO.: 01-5417
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
Randy C. Greene, Esquire, hereby certifies t~~ a true and correct copy of Defendant's
Motion to Dismiss was transmitted on January ~ I ,2004 by first class mail to the following
parties or their counsel:
Dale Wintermeyer
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
OCT-09-01 09:12 FROM:The Har~rord-Omni
OCT e6-Gt 02:25 ~M
10,7709521115
PAGE
2/7
.v....
v.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNIY. PA
CMLAcnON -LAW
NO. OL-S:1l17 (?t-"ilY~
JURY TRIAl. D~ED
"
,
DALE WINTERMEYER.
Plalntiif
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
'NOnCE TO DEFEND
Yw bave been sued in CWlt- If you ",.10 de!el1<I apiD.sllbe chlinlS sct.forIh ill the 1i>UowiDi pap. yea
mwt take oi:licirrmtbin tWCIft)I (20) dJrys aftler thio Complaint lAd Noti",- ate ___ed, 1>).' enteriDg .. wnltal
appeoruce peN<lIU1IY or by ~ IlDd IiJiDg III writiDg with !be COUrt yo'" del'eose:s Of objectioos 1D ~ cloixDs
set Iilrth ogJiIIst you. v.., "'" wamcd lb:tt if yoa foiI1X> do s<> the ....., msy proceccI..;thoIII yoa aM · judgJDcal
IDlIY be aIIered ~ yea by \he Coart wilballl tunIIer nolice for mrr moa<:'Y ~d iD III.. ComplaiDl or for aay
ca.:. claim orIclid'~ byl1>c Plain6ff. y""mayl...._... prop<,rty orother rigl\l'l importoc't()you,
YOU SHOULD TAKE '!HIS pAPER TO YOUR LAWYER l\.T ONCE. IF yOU DO NOT HAve A
LAWVSll. OR c,\NNOT AFl'OJ\.l> ONE, 00 'TO OIl n!1J!P.!IONIl nm Ol1l'1CE SlOT POR'IH 'SJ;LOW TO
FIND ourWHEIU> YOU CAN OETLEGAL Rl!LP.
COURT AD)IINlS11tATOR
4th 1"1., CI>~ eou.y Courlbous.
CorIisIo.F, ~= 17101
(1t'7) .,
"~A.
Le lmadiall>a .....- a aswI... 10. corte. SI\IIIOld.qu.' JA "-- de _~ GJlUOlil'IS en II<
plI8iDasS>'P"~ usled<it;Oevalc (2O)'dloSdeplaDalportirclo;t.recb:J de 1&...... .. Y laDOliJi - U,...;.
Jdl. _ ~"'UIUi.. . ...t-eac:rba'o. _~r~ 0-,....... . 11 .lQ> y.~.a'lI\oorae.ea.'ffl8lLeaaa.oIX' c1 r
a S8S.;.lpc~1S ._.~Cl1 cx.crlr&.dc:.sn.persaIIL sea,-avisado.qDC!1i asted tlo-sc-dtA.Ac... Ja,cxric toman..
aoecIl6at.Y poIl!llIe,alIRr""" O!tb ocntr.I-"'''"hin~.Ylro OT..IIIP".rkII ypor ~quqa 0 alIoioquc I:S
pcclid.<>ea..pcticloDde tlea>omda. U.ledpuedopeodeS"'- 0 ..,. pl<lpiC<tadc:1 0 OU'08d...-.du>s impc<Nn"'" patS
uJIOd.
LLEVE 'ESTA DlOMAl'lDA A UN ABOOADO JMMEDIATEMI!ln1!.. SINO 11ENE AJ!OQADO 0 51
NO TIENE :e:L D1HERO SUFlCTP.NTl> DE PAGAR. TAl. SI'!RVlClO, VAYA.EN PERSONA 0 LLhME POll:
TELEJ'ONO A LA ol'1CtNA ClJVA DJRBCcrON SF. flNCUB}l'fll.A ESCIUTA AB~ p/"RA AVERlGUJ\!.
DONDE sa:; I'\JED[' CONSEOUlR ASISTENClA LEGAI-
COURT ADMINlS'lllA TOR
4<h Fl., eamberiDd COlIIll)' Co\I!1I>ou.!lo
Carliole, pCllllS}'lvmia l7l0t
(711) 24O.Q00
23SI44.1~!
TflUE eo?y FP:OMRECOFlO
I~T~mOOlJ <'!l',~;.el!f. ! 1l!1~ Ur.~ ~::17 !;~:.';!
~ tl1s m (If ~lIj~:;:::.' ~ t:l!.'I~'El' ~;a.
U>l$~~ ,",,' ,"~
_ __' ..=__.J.V~
OCT-09-01 09:13 FROM:The Har~ford-Omni
OCT-GG-.el 02:25 AM
10:71'09521115
PAGE
3/7
v.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO.
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
DALE WlNTERMBYER.
PlaiDliff
JOSUE SAUNAS-VALDEZ,
DefeDdant
COMPLAINJ:
1. Plail1liff Dale Winrermeyer is lID adult maividual and a citiun of the
Commonweal1b of pennsylvania who resides in Cmlp Hill. CumbsrllWl CoUll1y. Peunsyh-acia.
2. Def;:Ddant ]l)SUe Salinas-Valdez is an adult individ1.tal who residCll at 7004 Peters
C~I< Road, No. 21, :\W3DOke, Virginia.
3. ~ fllCtS and ~ I1creinafter reIa:Ied toOk place on or about July 14,
2001. at aw.oocimslcly 11: \8 p.m. at the iato;;Dection of South TIIitd Streel (SIt 2035) and
Haman Avenue, Lemoyne. Cu 1\ , lAnd County, Pennsylvama.
4. At that time and place. Mr. Wintcrmcyer was op=Dng hi:; 198'3 HeMa Sbadow
750-mOl.Orcyclein .. narthbollnd'd:Ucctioo on South Third Stttet'approaclrill1l Hetman Avenue.
S. At the same time, n..fI..,.d!mt SaliRas-Valde-,: was opetaling a 19&4 Oldsmobile
C~ ina uonhboUBd-dirootion on SoUlb Thitd Strecl.
6. The DefeDdant tumed on his left turn signal and Slopped in the ioterseetion to turn
left octo Herman Avenue.
7. After seeing the Defendant's lea tom signal, Mr. Wlnlelmeycr slowed his
motorc~lc: and attf:roptc:d t<> pass me Defendant's vehicle: en ~he right in lICCord;mce with 75
Pa.C.S.A. ~3304.
231144.I\!o!TGLC:\
OCT-09-01 09;13 FROM:The Har~ford-Omni
OCT-96-al 92:26 AM
10;7'709521115
PAGE
4/7
g. Without warning, the Def'endsnt suddenJy lKcclerated e.nci turned right. which
C<<USed the right side of bis vehitle!Xl impact Mr. WiJJl.enneyer llIId bis motorcycle. causing an
accident.
9. The foregoing acddent and all of tile injuries and "'"""F" set Colth bm:iDa&r '
sustained by Mr_ WUrtenneyer lIIC the direct and JmlXimate xesullS of the negligent, careless,
WlmtOD, and reckless manner in which MI. Salinas- V liMa operabod his motor vehicLe as follows:
a) failure !Xl keep alert and maintain a proper watcb for !he presence of other
. motor vehicles on the hjgh~~
b} failme to properly use tum signals;
c) failure to yield 1ha right-of-way to Mr. Wintcrmeyer's vehicle; and
d) driving his vehicle apoIl the highwa)' in a manner eodangering pmollS
and p>operty end in a xecklCllS manner with ClUeless disregard to the righls and
safety of others :md in viola1ion of the Motor V c:hicle Code of the Commonwealth
of Pe:onsylvania.
Ch'~II
maIe,~U" -- -ra.,v. J~SaliIMlS'-V~
10. Pamgm~s 1 tbro. 9 are iueo'I""..oo-herein by ref~
11. Mr. WrolJlllllEl)'et SllStai1Ied paini1l and sc:vere injllRes that inchKle but arc not
limited to a proximol left fibular fracll.lr.e, a disIlIl left fibul:\l' :fnIctore, bums, and lOlIIliple
contusions tmd abrasions.
12. By Iell50ll ot' his aforesaid injuries, Mr. W\ntemlf;yer was forced to incur liability
for medical trea.lmCDt, medications. physica11her.rpy, and similar miscellaneous ~ ill an
effilrt to ~ himself to Iu:alth,. and a claim is made tber.,{or.
13. BecaWlC of !he na1mC of his injuries, Mr. Winletmcycr has been advised, and
tbetcl"ore aver$, that he may be forced to incur similar medical ~penses in the future, and a
claim is made theIefor.
2)51~.11MI=
2
OCT-09-01 09: 13 FROM:The HarLrord-Omni
OCT-0G-81 e~:2r ~M
ID:7?1ZI=:l52111::'
r-......u.c.
~, ,
14. As a result of tP aforc:mentiODCd injurlll&, Mr. Wmtet\DCYe% bas uudergODe and in
!be future may 1UJdergo physical mi menml suffering, iDconvenienc:e in carrying out hi!> daily
adivities. and loss ofIife'lI p1casares 8Dd enjoyment, 8Dd a claim is made: therefor.
15. & a result of the afarc:md)tioncd iojuries, Mr. Wmtenneyer bas been and in the
future lIl:l)' be subject to emberrassmellllll1d hmniliatiOll. and Il claim is made tbctefor.
16. A$ a result of the ai'otemartioned iJ9uries, Mr. WinlcnnC)'er bas suff...red work
loss, loss of opportunity, loss offrequcnt overtime pay. loss of daily piece rete bonus pay, and a
pennaneat diminution of bis earning power and capacitY. and a claim is made tJ1erefor.
17. Mr. W"mtetmeyer continues tD be plagued try. persis!ellt pain and limitation and
therefure avers that his injuries may be of a ~ _c. causing residual problems and
perIIIaIlCtIt scaning fortbe f"t'I'Rin<ler orhis Iifutime. and a claim is made therefO(.
c~n"Ji[I
EWe ,- .
",_,}--- ~~ -_Ylll~-
18. F _. Ll tbroueh [7 are io. "'P'>.-.d.hc:R:iD'byr~rU:lIl~
19. At! a result me subject coUisiOll. Mr. W"unenneyer's motQIeyel" $\>!ltained
propcny damage, and a.claim!s made therefor in the amount.of.S1;99J.18.
'lWlERBFeRE, plBinliff'BaIt: W;.......-i.:t:de..-dsj\l '. t,lIgIIiBstn..fa1daot Jom:
SalInas-VtidD. in an lIIDQUD.tin c:w::ssof TweDly-F'lVe Thousand ($25,000.00) Dollars,
:m....IIMTOo1-C3
:;
OCT-09-01 09:14 FROM:The HarLford-Omni
OCT~a6-01 e~:~~ HI"'
10,7";'09521115
r'ALO~
UI
.
exclusive of inunst and IlO8ts and in excess of any ju:risdie1io,nal &mOunt requiring compulsory
ad>ifIatiOJ:l.
ANGINO &: R.oVNER,. P.c.
~~
LD. No. 35956
4503 N. Front Sucet
Hmisburg. PA 17110
(717) 138-6791
Anomey for Plaintiff
Dare;
l35l4\.I\MiCU!'s
4
OCT-09-01 09:13 FROM:The Har~roro-Omni
oCT-06 el ez:2( ~M
1 [): .(-'lD='~~ 11'1 ~
r-I""\I.:II~
g, ,
.
YE.&IFICATION
I, Dale 'Wintenueyer. PIa:iDnff, have read the furcgoing COMPLAINT lllId do hereby
swear or affirm thai the facts set forth in the fotegoing arc we and comet to the best of my
knowledge. informatiOP. and belief. I unde.tsland tbat 'this Verification is llllIde subject to the
penalties of! 8 Pa.e.s.A. ~ 4.904. rela1i:ag to UDSwom falsifica%lon to llllthorities.
WITNESS:
~
..lliJ). W :n-l;erll'\t~er
Dale W"mrermeycr
Dated: ~l 1"3/0 \
13S'.O.lIMTCJIl.c)
~
~ 7.--",p
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
v.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
NO. 01-5417 Civil Term
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW APPEARANCE
To the Prothonotary of Cumberland County:
Pursuant to Judge Hoffer's Order dated July 8, 2002, attached hereto, David L. Lutz,
Esquire, hereby withdraws his appearance on behalf of Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer.
ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C.
Date: C\~~/ \)~
OOu~
LD, No. 35956
4503 N. Front Street
Harrisburg, P A 1711 0
(717) 238-6791
Attorney for Plaintiff
236329,1IDLLIMTG
,Jl.lN 1 8 ~'Ij[}1 'Ii
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
v.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
'CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOSUE SALINAS- VALDEZ,
Defendant
NO. 01-5417 Civil Term
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ORDER
AND NOW, this ~:tt<aay Of~, 2002, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED
that Plaintiffs counsel, David L. Lutz, Esquire, is permitted to withdraw his appearance on
behalf of Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer and that any settlement draft and/or draft to pay a judgment
in the above-captioned case must include Angino & Rovner, P .C., as a Payee.
BY THE COURT:
15/ .J:k~,,-- t. . )/c#-J P J.
247041.l\DLL\MTG
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Mary T. Geraets, an employee of the law firm of Angino & Rovner, P.C., do hereby
certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW
APPEARANCE upon defense counsel via postage prepaid first class United States mail addressed
as follows:
Randy C. Greene, Esquire
1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Attorney for Defendant
Mr. Dale Wintermeyer
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill, P A 17011
~,,~-\) }--
Dated: 'v\. )
" J./lOti---
236329.1IDLL\MTG
()
c:
"""
-,.,..,
ri~ ?',;:~
-" 'OJ
;-2 r~
~.',~! :)~-
~\_")
).:,~ i-")
~~~~
Z
:<
......
<=>
~
....,
r<1
co
I
N
~
~~
:g
b
='-''''J
B::'.J
t5~
-'"
?
~
-0
:x
c.a
N
0"
..----l1l.le ~inter~:r~-llilnt1t--- rlAlI)btJ::Jan~ COlAnt~ Court
5 {~ (IJmrnol\ I:jea s
JOlue ,,"alinaI' Vu\.Jez. Ik..fendant (iv' ': -
~~ F.o~ ~~ear ~e70~.~[h\J court,In Order
. J st C J qu S 0 S I SGl lot '
IJ Mr. Dale Winttrmtytr- do heJtb~ contenJ and aVer
Hut the f:ollo\.lJi~q -tClcTs C\fc tr~t i.uhlch I QIn sUbmiN-
;n~ to th is COlAr! for JuJiclcd N~i:icf,
I. Afttr Dq,tnJo.nt JoS\At Salinas ~'o.)Jt2 r(cklus~
rcln Into rrYv r-rstvrtJ motorcyck i.\nA rn~ ltf-t Ie
which \.!JaJ b/roken in J.. plQCU dn J~ly lY 1001 I 51.{ -
t.ind . totol loss Of: ~y incoMe fOr seifer.1 Months.
l. si nCe: I coulJ n.ot u+forJ to pay 0. )tAwY\lj ClnJ I
no lonQer. hod arw Income. Jue. to my kq In 1urV I
]ookeJ)t~ro~qh tNf. Rhone: hook ctn~ J! CUlfY{ Q~ro(i:J
o.r1. a~\/lrtlS:JElY1er\t LX the law +-Ifrn Of" Anql/lo anJ
Rovner which stutes- lAn~ ftprJesentJ ~~BeI.ft kQw~
vefS.Ln Amerlco.."ancl "Fret consultatlon-)No Recovervl
Klc Fe(.~) /
3. AbOlAt 1.. weeks ctfter my It3 was broken 6, the.
ne q I j 3U\ Ce Of ,J OS~ t 5 Q\ IACls Vod cle2.vI CGt lie l Mr.
D alii J hutZ. t the law +- irm wh'l ell he. re.preje nt5
w,hlch is Anqino GIna Rovner.l eX,plC\,nel tllis C\cc-
i Vl.ttlt to DGivrJ LlAlz. vVtf tne phone. unA I tDIJ
him th&\t I wCtr\te, him to ItArcS'enf Yne. in Court.
I o.lso tol~ him thQt I w~~tf~ hllTl to colltct )OO/~
Ot the,)LU't Jl.lt compensoJlon O! the. JClIYlClja
{or /'f\( 'that Welft Ca~JlJ hX JOSIA1r.. Jalina-sunA
that this l~ompenScltionJor rryy rnotorctclc. damuqe.s
0JQJ mYf 'flf(\OJ't Corletr 0+ \ln~ortance. to sdtle
+lrstjbe Oft rrWj boJily inj~lry clcdm is sc.ttlecl.An
d+fiCt: C\ pointn1ent UJld He.n mo.de for me. to tQlk to
hl~ in person OYl AU3' ~1001.
(~y 1
--
..!j. On J\uj'~ 'J..OO~ my 11illfr oroVe me to Anjino (Al1d,
RovnffS o-ti'Ct to /nut with DGlv)J Luh tor the
+Irst timt, Dl.lrinq thC\t .medinq vJl\ICh I'f\y'Mother
~t1en~eclJI C\~G\lnJ IrLtCrlY1eJ DaJvj~ Lutz_. tth~t rn~
~rl mary concdrn waj' thClt I wanteJ hi rp to co lied
.full colnpenslAtion for rn,~ f,lot~r~ljcle cta~aj[s f'lfst
~ttor( colle.dlnq vrl mv ~oJ.ily ) n \~ry clal/"l\jJo that
I eOL(I~ qtl my --motordtclt fllxd '1lS ()ooY\ as p,ossiblc.
David. kut~ that tolJ IY\t 'YOlA sn9ulctril have o.nyhoLlhk
collectinq for ~our moRrcyck Jatn~Cje.s.~)t'\~ MotheT
then asktJ Davl~ Lutz. aboJt hIS +ftt anJ ht tcld her
that i + hc~..L~0 Jlut a fe coJrr.~l)1t aoun1t 9t!
pcdJ. ~ttofnry, Davi~ Lutz then o.qlt~~' to reprd-ent
-my Jtsirt .For him to co lIc.et thi +.IA II wwrnent for
rnt for T'n,v,rnotortC'\fc!e JQI'Mqer by JFro~ld;nq me. Jlifth
11 ~doJ .fcdth con ,net a,qrfeJr'f)tntf .for hIS r[l~reJ'trl -
Qtl~vS~hllch he Jilq(leJ~wMeh ddail~ his perCtntQqt
,f~cr J-f ht W oLd ~ mal\e. a. SVlCUSSflA' recovery on iny
b'fhal~whlch is to ~t in my bot ,detests, ABA tlo~ll
RlAk 1.1 stQtc'S"An Attorney is prohibiteJ from ossertln9
f'Q \sc or Jmls)tO-~1 n~"statelY1efliS)of Imp ,I ic-Qtiorls- Qbo~t the.
IA HOffl'(',VS sefV'Ct. !"Ir. lLtt~ thcY1 tclJ l'r'\e. to ~ct an
est i I'iIQt'~ -tor my /not ortyeiL damuol t-G etnd t~at ^ (
waul&. stat-tpreparinQ the cOlY\plC\~nt(
Sf A t[i.() w,ed.? )Qte~jI ,paid. HonJG1 l'1oto ~portJ B.1..0,35
i-pr Q~ est I/nate.. qf CI\e. iJ\umo.Qe.J to my Inot'orcycle
that were.. CalAse~ b.v ~JOfl,tL JSalinaJ:J1,nce m,y /notor-
tvck \,VQJ not iohlrecA mv hroth\.' rDdt ;t 10 the
s~or for thai esti/YlQt~wlhich totold lJIyO~S.8~(,tn~
I q.aVt/ C( cory ot that estilflatr. to my Itgetl reife-
sentit~vL ~V/~ LlAt2:Aho~t ct lY)on~ )at&j thl .
ltqa,\ comifa.,tlt \Vas ~Iqnet by DQVI~ huh,an, It
\jJ~S slAb md:td to H"sl court p,robab It by DavIt
l\ft2.jhut nD by mYJ'elf' Since it states on that
J
~~in~f l:~~I UIQ,f led t,
v . re sfntc& tha~ to me
a.l\~ to This COLtrt that ht woul& r[~reTer\t Me
Qn~ my b u-t 1 nb rests to Cl. "urv~ In this Court,
Mr. Oa.v',a L\At~ has +aile~ to iOtlOw('rhroLlih l.Uith
rt rClel\t;n m belt ,nterests to Q 'lAr in thiS
co~rt0wh;c~ ~ef rt~rerent~J to t~if ,t~u i and to
mv.sc./{ by de.I'f1QnGt1nQ C\ JU''I ttlct\.1. fEspectfully
SVlfbrnitt t~ thiS' CDLtrt that 'it IS' l1 vilOlution 0+.'
A&A Mo~e\ RLtle g.~ to eJ\qaQt in c\ishcnestyanij,
J-r~Ll~ Qn~ rn'Jrt~rtJentQt'~njwhich [tft cons'iMere!
tlD he IrfO+t:fsional miscon~\Act.AnJ ABA MoJel
Rule. Y. i }tate-0"~~lsrtprLsentcd~ions mo..v C\lso
occur b,li f:l{ll~rt to act;~Ever since MV leCjQI
r-tpre.strlttit'Vt IY)Qild ct cop" ot' HaJ Complcdnt
t~ mt W I ch h ( i It!- or IA I tMltnde~ I llf tri 41
t is- Court to not1t t 0+ wIlen I woul bt
(\ 0 t; 1; j e! 0 f th t j't Q t 0 + J Ju ry s (: I t ct i 0 n.~~
__(l.rcHlJanet iLlb_L..t.tQrLSe~tlt1ion C~I1J demu.nCt: tor C\
Jury trial hY1DaviJ llAth Canons- Rult.l-IOI{A1r1}
sto-tesj"An ~ttornev I1\LU-r bi' \~lAY\ctl!~\ 10 +lAlf.illlnq
cdl ,priO+erJlDnf.l\ commitrY)t'nrJYAB~ ~1~~eV RJle: 3,'1.
s t c(r et ~, T h ~ a it 0 r n e V l\ ee pin q w it Y\ h (. c I ; en ts
beJ't Interest Must eX{'CLttt tCltJonable. attempts to
expeJit111t; ~(At;on;~)There.+or~,:1InY, best in!er~stJ'
wert 110 acte1J l,fP?11.J hfcause. VClV Ie{ ~utz- J10\ not
1~119W + rou~h wl'th rxpeJitlna thiJ liL,qation
I n thiS CvurV to ajlArlfjc{J he.JrepresentelJ to IY\c
ClI1~ t.o thiS' courtC'6nJlq~entlv~MI'1 lub- jQilcL\ to
p.rovidt me with 2.eo.lolAJ r(t>prefCntl1t,on b~y his her
1; q,Eni lrvulntr oJ JQ;linQ to pn:scrl rnv [7om~lrdnt
Gln-l!. J1rpos;tion tb Q Jl1fV in thiS Court witnout
procrasli nl\tlon.vwh i c~ ard v io 1 LltiDIH, Of C ano~s DR-
~-10\(A)(3),j"An attcrne~ rnQ~ not lAd: 111 Q r1tj)/~cnt
':J
mQ n n nJ and C (,\ n D n J 12JL1::l.Q.lJlU11l "
f\(,~ cQrLJ)J)t i ntl'ntionaJlk '~ c -
fe l:r1totion O.f the el; n1.')Also relavont to thac;dc
a.re ABA ModcH RLlIt 1.3 :Dili enu:) i. .'2t'd\OUS fc rc-
sent,tion oJ tie cll'nt" ""4 ~."No- prOrfQ,t:n,t;o or
lAnrcQsonaMIe. Jt)of"'cGnSC~LtLl\tl{, l. plc~qes OJ C\ laL\J-
~ er.J Pjd~( Of Pro 0 ,lianal i sm ~er( alSio Su~s(~u.entl'/
IIjolate~ 6 Nt. kill L which stl,(tt~61 will ~ (
matters (xpeJltioLtslyvand withOLlt' IAnnc:uss~ry L'X-
~ensc.')And "I will fAono, the S\'f'it anA If\te~t as
well ctS the Itfl1ir01\ents Of t c Qp'~)JcQb/( Wles
0* C~cte Of Protssiona\ Corlctuc. fO' my juris-
J fic t Ion .~, (
G.AiIth'"lh th~ frofcssionaly pre.~QrfJ utlmC\tc thC\t
was ~re;parc(j\or the Ja.maqts to ;rny motorcy.~1t by
He. ~on~C\ ShDp th~t I reqwlC\r\~ JelAI, uJ,Ith JhoW~
tAn LJtlma.tfJ Gu/)ou.nt o+, )J~Oe'5.0~lt is S-t4tCJ In
VIe. ComF-luint which DClvlH LlAb has siqnd anJ SLlb-
rDitte~ to HilS COlArt ~t Co~nt j:) Iq:J6'As G\ result
the. S'u~lt~t coll;sio~'lrl Wintermever}, motorcyclf
S lA stl\l h'e ~ rro,p crt! (;(.Qm Q q t an 0, I c I Oilfn I s !'Ii a(H
thcfC}Of(.in tA( ~!T1our\t JP4~qt3.13.')I re{,prct-
+l{II~ J-Llhmlt to this f()ur~ that I do hUVe. tJle IfjCd
rJ~:' htt to rt:~uirt an~ to Su:K Cl recovery p,<<yment
II IOO~o Of the. J(,(maqt est; mate. j niorlter1 to rt-
~ lau. the. JIAf(1Q3eJ arts O-t mv 1\10 ortcle tal
GU'~ as i' lAst,!to Co FtnJC\tioJ~AL(( an,J pa C(bl?,)QI1~
rtcover bit 11'1, ul comrensQllo~vJhlCH SilTl WIJh
to co lIecv~~X'c1lAs, e. OJ any other ~CH(ments or costs,
,hat ~1it1'1le. rar-C\qrap~ Il.> IAnJ~r [olunt .i !l.{rther
explcl/ns the. Q+~r~mel1tlOncJ Intent Ot mibft to collect
tho.t aMount {Or the. \ ust au~ comrlr1SQ ion of. my
motorcycle JJmaq,tS tlxcluJin~ costs)QS it is st4te~
&'l~htrc.~o rc ?let! tttifrJ DRlc;. \.J.lll1ttrm ~ VEl JtmanJs
jud~l'.In~nt ;f3iAinst Defen~clnt JOSU(~ J{o,11nas Valdez.
,-
"
~
Qt'lI0I1~t in f1cCSS 0 ~~e Tl,~f;;~
eVe e t nd I -
CtSS 0.+ <.\nv.;luri Jidior\a\ ClJf\O(H\t reql.(irjn~ com-
p\). Isot')y ~rfhl1rd Ion.!))
l.On ql~G)OljI lueivd G\ ktter iTam D(,(vi~ kUt2
~ h; ell hC\~ ,B un S tnt to hi /'1\ ~rom Brian Younb J~teJ
qho q~whleh st.\.te~/.It wouJ~ C\preal tho,J our In-
sure&. appears to he: l'lo.ble. in t~ls inciJent.The,c:-
JorSw( ~oulJ he. wlllinq to, p~y, ,1000/0 of tht:,dama,qt.
i!o ~our Clll'.llts mctofc{fle. /1\ t'hls IOSj~~Dc(VI~ kutlz.
alst Sent Ine: Q qpf, ol hi! r~p\~ !tHel thaJ he QdJ-
ruseJ ~D 1"\1. Youn!.whi)ck IS u\Oltd_Jt ~tember 2.S:
ADO I I.()hlch stC\tC'~.{, Dectf rIll YOUI'\t:..if; We orL un~k
to rto.ch CU\ olY\lcavlc r~~ol\Ation llJi,~h r~jar~ to,
the. B'gP~rtv dal'f\Qqe cl~'mf~oth dalrnr WI JI he ldq-
C\ate[.~lnCt Brlatil YOLlnt Qllt'~ tD pay mYJ'eI-f or
~r. D(.\VI~ klAt2 lOQ10 01 He JarnaqrJ' t1ho.t wele
calAJcJ to rn I'fwtD,(, tit. thltt reJ'tlltd in mlJ'rcprc-
senfl\tion. nr-1 kUt2 + lle1 to folloul thlOuqh wltN hLr
+lildlc;Clr~ Jlltv to cbllccf a JUCCfH.p,d rc{overx for
fht Jamgjt.J tro m~ motofcicle i n QchrJ~nce tD this
COlY)plalr11 that ht lfile~ Q fer- ht aqree~ to re~re-
sent. mv best 1 ntdr-nts 'f collt:ct;-n~ pr loo~l of
thf. Jama q e.f to my f1\otordyC'k.
8. SOIY'\e. ti~E httwetn Oct J 00 I C\n~ Jan. lOO~..J R4n~y
GrnYle. becQme. the. C\ttornr;v for JOJ'Ut Salinas Valdc2.
q,OQvia. LlAt2- sent C{ ldter to mt:. Jl.\te(i~ Novunber
~')1001 which statesJ"Deo.r Nf,kwinterN\eYfl:oefense.
(1)unstl hu scheault~ the tl,t\inq of ~oli, deposition
on Fcbrua.ry l)lOO~C\t 1;(~30 oJ mv Ot+.ict.Will you
~ I C'H thtrq: ore make uranreme/ntsl tD be in my
Office. at IP bo A.M. on Fe6fuar II ~OOl}'>
JO Dn Jo.n,t H01#cceived Cl._Ie:tler trom OClvid
kUt2 Which he. addfcfscJ to RC\lldl{ G flen a.J dateJ
Ja.r\u~rY1;Zool which .stl.ttt~/' Dt'/lJ' 'KanJ(wL UJould
r:,
iv,
I ~
er,rne yft' . :~~M=
c 0 \v,th ~
r~lav<<Ylt TO his bodilV i I)l\ry clalm.Fr-qnklyjwhcn
I 1'(\ t wit~ Mr. lJintrrme'1,tr qn Dectmber f;a ;(00 I
he v I S E J IY\ t th II i h e 4J 0 iA I d b t P 10 V ; a i n ~ f UJ iih
bfln\~ lk( to a\ rop rt,y, dama I:- cJalln 10 ap~rox-
i/'rlqtJelv B~O~3,1 .Alonq fhese Ii cswe will he ~ro-
Vii din9f, ('x~ert tCl'tim-bn( lUith reJarct to the cost
of rE~alrJ. ,
II. On ,Febrltur 1~:ZOOlJ II went tD mtd with D~viJ
to met t w IH the Deten dant attorn e _t1 . (rrte n.,
for He purrOSt of him to'ki,,~ my de oSit;on~ whJCt,
Dp.vi~ LC{t2 haJ repr~s-cY\tet to IYle as schc ltleJ.
Since. Randy, Giter\t +ade~ to ShOLtJ up tAt tha /nEet-
i nq that ha tl. be m ~rJ~ sche~~1 c J m ore. than 3 lY)onth
br+.o,~~I w.as once aqain JLl~,)ecte& to m,Sftrre.-
SErVtatron.s",c( Mr. Gften {-cured.. tQ) show UP+-Jlli/
C\ Horne ~ Da\Jid lut:L j nformec{ mt that rr. C'rceh
has ot~(rtlt to Stttk rr)V motorcycle amaqeS
claim ~oor "nG,5001o.nJ tWo.t It I fuJoulG accdp,t
thll.t 0 1tr I UJOUIi,\ Hen be: e Llr'le~ to a. him
ID"d L~12J :300 o~t Of H.t lor his .de Yconws-
ionjln contrG\o.,ction to COL\t\t ~J yaraq,rfaphJ jq o~
thh ComploJnt whkh Dav;~ LUJ2 ~) Iqne! anC\ +.ileR
to thiS' Cou.rt. Conseql.{(ntlvjI iniorrne~ David Lu./'b.
that 1 UJOL{I~ not a~ceFt IDtr sdtle ~~or bq(0.S0 {or
He da/na,qcJ Of u.~~rox/I"Y)Q ely J1~ood that WerE lin-
.f l/ct~~ ~o (f1,V lY\of~r~ycISna~l~ I lllJO in,forl:nd h, fYl
that It IS hlfS fU ICI&t'y -ifuJy to collec1! the +.L<Il
cJtib1ate~ mo~Y\ 0' jlAJt Jur, com ~(1s;atioJn in.
ac odance. to tht cllcnts' he t I ntef s-ts tor the
fcrre.StrltAt'lJY1 CtI1J jit'jut;on which has hdn COI1-
I
-t:f,~'~~;;r;~~-
clsian oncerninq A. R'prwntatiol(., on B.IlJr,th,r to
c\cu pt Ct settl(f~tY\t off:e'r'. At the. en~ of th<<t Il1te.t-
in,q uJlth DaviJ lUt2 I in-t-ormeJ him thdt still
norh;n~ has ban ~o.i~('~ trOm Imady' talking Llbo\.lt
thLI1+1qUer)C\nJ ~hlkt 1 wanteG\ him to mOVE this
Jispos(ition tnto the. Cotur tor a jury t~lqSa1 ,hI:
dLlY1anoe~ Qn~ re reStn c 0 /'Y1 ,SUrl f ClnJ to thiS
RIA\( 3.2. ExreJit(\C( i.statesc'Tnc: torne'0Keepin~
with He clients hest intt'rt:SP I'f\ltft execlAtt IeQsonaW!e.
atttffipts to exre~itt lit i qatiDn:)~)\nJ 2. 4qtes)"Thc
QUorntv Is proh,hitd from ~'runni~q ur tne it':fJ.')
Canons IDR l-)OI{A)(i)S'tiates'&An (d:tJorntv fY1~1"'t be..
~'p,L{Y\ctl.lcd in +u Lti!lina all Jf01t'SJiDMl tommitl1lentsy
Al1tholAqh Duv;)~ UUt2 jrnadt C\ rOfcssional commit-
ment V rnysdt lXnJ to this Curt hX hiT JerY)Qn~
fOr QlllAt.~/, trlC{II)~t Was not ~unctl(a \ in fUlfillinq
tiha.t CO'f'r1tnltrnenI:' In urr sort 0+ manner it he repr--t-
srnteJ,t9 IY1,Vse1t, an~ ~o th,sJ Court rela,tl'Vt tb, tht
COlY\plUlrlt,Atf no Ill'Ic Jurin3 fY\~ IY1cd,n~ With DQ'JI~
l~d2. ~iG~.I qivt hllf\ rrw ft miSSIOn to fACCLpt or
sdtlt to r- nn-t.So tor th alY\a~LS tho.t Wtrt
Cc\IAS('! to rnotoJrc tk /11 UTI, l,Uo vel" all or-
by IYI~ s;qna~Jre on a kcttleillent aqrltln1entn:k did
I 3 fa n t j)Ja v ; J L uJ 2 'rr\ 1 perm i s s ( c n' aut n 0 r1' 2. Q t ion
to collect thLtt CU'f)ounu at onv oth,er time which
vJvLlI~ have. bqn In contrqJlfction to C()~t ~rarq-
qraph Iq 0+ thIs [omr)"lnT which At iiJcJ.
I~, A+tel' I Inti wit Dav!~ LUt2 on Feb. 2b~OOlJ .I
rtctivc& Q ktter from Aim which 1.1 craJeJ Ftb-
fU IA.f\j ~s "002. TnQtJ Ittter rti-errect to my me-dIn q
with fDQvll L~t2. on Feb. ),~).do~ which Rlancly G-r-etne-
to.lle~ to a ~ peQlj-Ol.ln [hat Ie. Uer to me Jutec(
'~~ "~i; Jirin
telA J, 12. ,~ n ' 0 ~
tnLt\'11cQtt 0 ~1r. G-rrtnt hCAt if thtXf is (\ ten~er- '
Ot th~ iY).~ooo o+.,policy lilY)jtl) you. have ,~rovIJevl
1\1 e. yilth QlAthor/17y to CtCCEpl Q )lrornertv JCl.mo.,qe.
se.ttkment of lI~I{;.SO, r Qlso (lJvise~ td\l in tWir
re q ar~ then- uJ oulJ b t li\ r (\ttorpe~te. conCtSJ~1 on
O.fJQ30u.DO,~j Tn cd Ltn tr-ut. stf.lte.m ent'b DQvi cl kutz.
[S an~ \JJQS CU\ Qct ~ IAr\law~u\ rni rqrtJen1o.tlon
hteaLlSL.- I ~lcl1\ot iVt DQv\~ LlAtz- CU\ vex'bQ\ el-
m issqn to Q~ce-ft ~ ~ ,sO +oltrny InOh'CNCle dQ~qq0
/1Or-ltl~ I slqn a,nv sdtlerl\en ct,qlittmen1! -tOf th~-P
O-mo\.lY\t. COY\Jt~lAentllv T btlitveJ.. tJhC\t the cq:lOtLmmt-
ionecl rnf,orlllClt'lon o.y(o\. /y\,jrc~rtJO'\t()Jion whilh Dalilc\
k\Atz. in rmeulmc. O-f qfe(,ltIYl\top(tr~i2JJ. my ahiliTy
to co II< t jor 100/0 df '1L: ~'Mr J~( cOlllltnshtion +Ir
ih( Jamaqt tD my Irlotorc LI~ in accor&'a~ce. to 'ffIY
btst iY\t-trLstJ'!)VJhich..r r tGlinr~ DalliJ ~ut2. to
se~Vt and. ~o rep r,e.s-ent ,~lArJ[,(0nt to the: Cornplu,int
whu_'n ht sljneL.sI~CL this a~JltloY\ld Qct Of' miS-fer
feSu\tutioJ'\ co.V\seJ /1'\( to slAstlAln mort cmotiono.\
J istrel'sj l.\IlJ il nu Davi~ LlAb. nClS never shown mt
0.(\'1 aoclAmm trJ.. sdtleM((\t rlo pOJ'al -trom RClnqy Cl
Grb:,n anA since DaviJ luh c6ntinud( to fC\i\ 110
Z(qIOL(S~,y ..tLpre.ffnt my he\t inte,o-ts- bv VlAnctucdv
eX~EJittinq the. \v..ry triul in ClccorJqntt'to my Jij-
re'drvcj] hlit'\1cJ that I ha~ {\(), other altern~tlve
b~lt tD :lcnJ ct Idter to RClnJv c. HU:l\e whw I had
ha.n cont;n~t\llv f1 peri ~n cinq~ in eHc.ctiv( CounSt I.
Si I\~L the. U.S: (Jonst..itlAtiDn is Jthe "S~pr(/Y\e law oft the
)all~~l believed.. tho.t I haJ C\ ConstitlltionQl Rlq'ht to
COmTr\lAYllcG\tt with, RQnJy G-fttn).ufdch UJQ~ in a.cl:or~-
OJ\Ct to my best I nhr'tJ,tJ'j ts~eclal\y 51 net llothlnq
at QI\ uJar eveJ achieVE! hy ua.vl~ Li,(ti tpwC\rJ uc-J
overi nj 0.1'\ QrY\OlJ.t1t that wv~IJ bt Qcc-cptQblc to Il'lt for
t ' -~rD~~k dom'J'::::
13, Cons<:qllt~ntlv I mai\t~, fA ktter to Mr. Ran~y c.
Grten t, ori f1artt )~100:l. llJh'lch JtC\te)~'l, hiNt rclcent-
l\j HcclveJ a kttn '+-rorn Mr. LlAt2"wh,ch IS Ja.teJ
M1ar-ch Ijloo1.Mr.llAti has- i(\tQrrnt~ Inf in that kHer
th~t l I\QV( pr4JviJeJ him wi t h the ~ltthor,t~ to
acupt Y,OI),r pro~erty dCtmQq( sdt!rmettf/offer O{
'nb.t~QnJ .t~Qt he c.mm~ni,M,o\ H,t Df+d to Y, dIA,
T~at oTfe1 IS nA. QCCf~tabl( to meI ha~e not
slQ0e! 4nV PQrers which state that Il.Vil\ accept
thtft C{moLu~t. I have written In m\(. mOJ't rtCent
/tHer to DrwiJ LUt2)'11 am Jirec1linq, ~ou to act in
accorda.nce to m~ ~eJt intcro-t.r an~ o.r my rEp-
rEscntitive Of IY\ beft ,entere.st~~by in,wmrnq t1r.
GrurH. that 1 wi II not Qccept IS mort iecelnt
ot-fer at {{ nG.5D~)I then IAlro vJro e to 11r. l\At2-../~l
am alsd d;rectin~ you to Uf:LLf( tD accept ,Ir.
GrHn e S ()ffer.)) IJ a~JO stateA ;n m1t letter to III',
G-r-eenr}'l woulcllike, to KnqVJ If 'vou hdve haJ cop-leI
o 'In rn eJi co rt:cor(AS 0 the OrtlyopeJic Institute
o..nyotte rom the law 11m '+ Anqino\j-Rovne" If h<<t
has DC urreJ plcltse jntorm m-t 01 He ldmftity
Of the ;Y\~iv,~Jals who h Vt provl,~e~ you wiH my
mellca\ rcrprds)anJ OJ He n0me. Of the firm ort
bU51ntss eY\tcr~r;s( UJ~lch that person or persons
UJor~ for.') ~\rl ()-rea, ha-f {tA,lef to f(~lv to my
JeUtr to him Whlch pcrtCiins 0 Hir'Juit'lit\ltn
IAfter he \..Vas mCiJt QWlArt Of the t-Qct i:hGl:L DG\v'ld
lutz.. is no lonq,Er m,V Qttorne'y,l cbntenJ that Mr.
G-rcen has an tJthlcaV JLltv to rt.fpon~ to 'my leq,a\
JcthrsjQnA thCtf it IS' hiJ'/legQI duty to rupbnd to
TYlp co,mrnu.nlcal"Qy\s ~lS~~hkh, ~e has fClileJ to
~1~ holC\ pHrSIALnt to thiS ctlJrOsltlDn.
'"
v,
LQ
liver-fA,
2. ~ I
ltJ hi ch e fe prC'-Hnis ich i r the +i /'r\ of Anql 0 anJ
Rovne~. On pC(~t 1 0'1 thCtt let~tr t1hat I a4drJe.ssecl
tp Dav\cll~t2! 1 stlte! to hlm)"~Jin.ct ml~rcprr-
.r~ntatH~n IS lAYlltALlJfUI I QN\ herUlY In{onn/~q KOu..
t hat I f VOlA ru USr ~ifurs(l+ trOm fe p h~JentJjn~
/Y)( as vou. Qqr(f~ tD do wHw VOII slqntJ CJl,{t-
~qrL(mrnt toJ represent me. to/He c4tnp!ction 0+ IX
S-WCCCS,LLlA \ Iccovtry on Auq. 3,) ;z.oOIJ. then I Jtll1a~&.
to h t prJou;Jd~ with a.t1oHr~ Alia/no 't-Rovner Attorney
tll rt ph~J(nt m L in C ourtjP()~ ~lA,rtti I C<. JucCtSSfLd
recovLry' hQ-l' been obiainEbt anC\ ,~ompldeJ whVch
IS o..cce'pi4hlt to me. for my MoTorcycle. dQIl\Qges-.
TWD I.lJf~k{ af:ttr 1 [ ta!nec{ you)I mailc& fA P~tter
if Vou wfh'Ch IS J(JJe Fri. A~q'. 17/01, IJsia.te! U\
{rwt Id tr to YOiJ..JH 1 want L-tJ he pai~ tOr Hi:
It ~ laccmeY\! cdsts Ot lV(r~ t~ad tAat was Jarn~qtJ
on mv motorcv.cle. jncJh,{~inq tno-fc parts thC\t t,,*
(st;mC\tors dill n~ include) on tAeir e,rti/'1\ata- be.-
CaUSe it SaVtJ them tim(<l-rnonN h~ not Jolnq Cl COlll-
r )de. tstimcdc.;)I a Iso L()rott,-/fP),~asc rc~ly 1!o th Lr
Idter immeJIQtLlyr-'ctY1~ inform IT\t 0+ wuth.er you.
\AI i Il S L ~ k a n V far 0 r r. a I/.lnc n t J -I' rom lY\ f a -f. it; r 1. Ou..
wIll not rrrh: en! me. in [olArt~QrU Qftef~du.., hav,t
not t1\ de. a succtsJivtl fccolfYery to comr!d'0~ 1f1
Qccor OIlU Ito thai which is rt~,rtsentI"J o.n~
state on tl\( contract Q rLcmcnt Which ~u
sl ne while: OlA conl;nu tD dlJTC Ctr~ dlrect-
lv~s Po vou Jor my' bes int'restsiQn~ uJ ii, you
WIll not tH\J~~r rY\X wri ten le,qol ~-L(U'fions to
,\JOlA,I tnut thQi,Y'ou ~ill nDtHe clle.libertddv
Ifn h~J.,ereht to H 11' Idttr. uS ~ou. hqVtb un ttJ
mv dt1ith(f )dter!.)Jircci;vt{,ar1~ to /Yl~ documenteJ
~\A(fS- ions/)As LUlAQG DaviJ (lAt2 fRlldl to r-tr1y to
Lit' h'
I \' If ~O-
. .
i
~ i r I ejL\1 Jut to respond tD th rn c< Iso. ABA ~1ode I
Rul( 1.1 G 11 tutef "Even l\POI'\ termina.tion of' the ren-
re.sentClJloY\ the ClH#-net rrwst tqkt. all re,asonc<blf al1~
nCCtssC\tv rteEs- to protect tht cl,ents IntereJ'r S\ACh
as-but not limlteJ b bj Aetas attDrney vtntil the
cMwt can proc\Art CtnotAa- aJtorneYj ltnJ c)Surrrl1Jer
G\ll If~~d p.apers G\nt prortr'ty r~IClt;rlq to the repre-
senta.tl on J) J
IS. EVttl thou3h theft aTe cl.bout 10 lawxcrs- that also
UJork o.t th~ same. ){,(~ flJ'm Of Al\lllno<rRo\lnO' QJ D((\ll~
klAt~/An~ they alro specil\112t in ~cclJent in)Uf,y
] Iti ~QtiDrtn VQ~iJ ~\Atz_ nasV 10 IlAtd the Qforelt(en1!ione~
A~ A' ~Iod Rule. 1./ G becOJu~ he. ,hClJ not rrovl,JeJ me
WITh anot ef )C\wyer to fld JJI hiS' legal dlltltf to
t.b.LABA,-)o rnyseLfl." ,hLr COIAtt.
Thefc.-tof(J1 Cql\ new SH1tftt Ifa~van aQd by
no )o~,qtr 'havina an nttorJ1t 10 ~olloLU HrJouqh
With tHIS Jlsf.OJiition in ace r a~t( to whClt -Was
r(BrLsO\t('~ to rnvsclJ oncl to t is COlArt pLtrsuant
to this Com~IQif\t whicM DIAVI~ l~\:2 fild to this
Court uQC\Ir\st JOJl,{f SlAlinllS VClIJcz)J-if\u- I hClve.
not hid Ja. ~I ob nor an j r\CO me. si net A pri \ ,,-OOl. I
have. nrvtf' Ivell Davi ~ LVJ2 III ptrmifslon nor m
consent +0 h'II'1\ to d,scant/nlt '(p'resentin~ m'L f
TheH+ort 1 will citt Pa, JUptf 'Sl8 1\, ~d l(l~
lq~~>>asRsjQ{ VI'S, Scoville. Enhr-san~ thut Rul/n,q
U)a~D"A Jlscon inlAenct. entered b~ tor-mer counsd)
\.IJ itnout consen ~blrcLicl mlAJt be. stricken,"
IG, On June L~J.OO~~ I JlAbmitteJ leqol informa.tion to
this COlAtt wh,cf( was IU)~ is Jirfctll/ rtlQtrJ to
the. lif'3oJ;on ~f this leqld Jispositi(otl!J\Vh/ch WQS-
a ]elC<\ action. rhercf-ort I !4lJ'er t(J this- Court
thC\t He statute. Of Lrmiht,orlJ for thIS disposition
II
--.halnot toUeJ.
...Jl.LJe'(br aVer and (,llntf11d t~J1iJ tDU~ th~t
Do.vlct LvJ2-- JhOLlIA he hel~ )eqall accol.mta I~ anA
lejctllv rrspor'lsiblf fH' t.ol/ow'inc thrOU~h with rep-
reser1ttinq this Corn~l(]ir\tt whld hi: sl nr! un~
+-ileJ aawinst Josue. Sal,naS' VQ!HS 0.1' e f-eprc-
t(nt~~Jit Jo ,this C~lAitvin accor-Jonet: to his BfO-
+fsJ'/onal dutlo' which 7\( liftS sUJorn to uphol[.
t uLro cOr\ftn~ th~t th~ burden Of' J.ili qenCt to
Ii t; qG\tt thIs rrwtteJ' fats u ron D ilvi d L\it2 an~
his fcpresent,'tive law 1/rm o~ ~,ngino'l-~ovf\fr be
CaUjt DQvi~ LlAt?; unJertooK the 'le;qcd fcsnor\sl-
bilit~s of this c\ispositipn ,when)if... fl)f~ this
c olnpl~in uJhlc~ h,. fiRnrU<mo^tin~o. ,)4ry tri((1
and. when ~i: Sl neo... tHe. contr~ct a feehlcnT 0
Ani n 0 ~ R 0 v n eJ) Q r f ei n tor L ~ r t J,m t e.,. T h ( d t
s orn D Lip ol~ t!Ai ~tv to th( AB Jal1~ tJJ Heir
clients whic th(v u~rescmt
I O. At l~ unJer DfiLn~OJ\t JoSelA Jal,nlllJ Va.l ~e 2J
Motion 10 Disrnir F'Ol Fo..illA'L To. prorttcutl: which
has ban siQne~ h~ R~nJ~ C,ime it is r ute~
&'G-iven He- JYlaint\'f-fs c.ornpl~t( fti,cK o+' JI.l/~~C()
th( hlAr~eJ1 tor wnrch lu:s with hiM aM him Q/orrt
Qnd tKt r ~I LiJiCt to Dten~a It Josw SL\lin4
b( d.itmISs-ecllLli ,~na;lAd ce OJ' PlaIn it!J
-\,-c,ti lurL to proJLCIA~e. \A)HcrL~OrtJ Dtfcnd~nt U JelA
JQ!ino..l' Va.) del resp,cct+ull requeSt thiS HOI1/JfQhle
Coult to pism;.,fs tHIS }1)ain ,-ffr complaint with
Pre~\lAdlcc})l submit tD thiS' JHonoiahll Court that
thf il'fOft(Ylenti one! v~tCtttm~nt b v Ll ttoiney G-Itt'n
IS IlbeloUJ pro s-e)htcC\.lAsc J }wv~ not corl1l'nitteJ
any prd tud.icia! Qcts o..9Qi~st Joseu Sa.linu ValJl~
nor- Have.. '1. cOlnrnittd a.r1othtr tAn lo,lUfU.1 actS' a jain..lT
):1
, ,\,\ Ir,~"t AI I 'i
ChP. 'J L t d'~;~~'1 I I
,COU Q V I U 2 ,I( ...) . C c
O-t ff\al\ct.)an~ iY\timiJo. iotl a r al violQ Of\S f the
lalvJ .L conJI~tr I1r. G-rrene.s str.ttoncnt ancl de.Slff tOf
thl? I1)Qtter to be. qlsmlnei~, \,lJlthp',~J \l{!iCt..aq.~ir\,J.i..
Me to be. lAnConJclOna~\t bl(C~m(,dicloU'f~ Lt1tllntk
o.tiot:\. \Dhlch h~Vt causecllY\t to sustLtin aia;tionQ\
trnofiDna\ d i strtJ~ lYh\ck hru- been ddermineJ by the-
e ourts to b L Q ~\Anlshmel\t.
It l\llthol{qh it is an uttorntj,S p,rottsslona\ If,qa\
d\At,y to t'XreJi te. C\ sdtle.ment ag tement and:! I did
cOYlllacT RQnJy G-uene bV my ldt~" on MIA?ch IS~OO1.
hiS at-liberate. indi,ffer'cnct to IT\'{ letter has In
J-ctct l(slA1te~ in m;s JIJ~oJitiDnl bdn3 Imptdcl bv
lhnJy G-rtfnt since he. neVtT di& rtplL! to my kttet.
nor ['I ~ ht t~r s~ oJ. Q sdtkrntnt of-tler to fr\t e\Je~
o..,t tet' nt WQS matte. QWart 0+ the artlldu.ntr thot Qft
strAte~ -f-or COl'(\re~soJory, Jo.~Cta~S on the. COlY\~lalntj
lArd. I r\ l\\~~t oJ' he -fact[ thG\tJhe \AJQS informe~ Of:
tht tact thlltJ DaVI& hut2 wo.s no lonqer my attorn~y.
lO.l r(~ptct-tu\lv S~bmlt tD th\r C ot<,t that 1
shou.\J (lot bt feq~ire! t~o.n~ thQt I o.m not req~'IIe~
to file Q SUb~Ot~a tor Cl Tourt Ord,er To Res~OM'j to
MIl RunJv Greene. In QliAer tor hIm to rtpl to
mv )tthfth~t I SOlt to hi!"" ~m t1arch 1~~O.o~
'~I,IAllthnu3h 1 hQvt rnaJe. efforts to sdtlt thiS JISpO-
SI tion in o.CCOfaan(( to the r ~mplolnt the., ~ tto,urntF
the,I\IJtlvts art sok1v. responsible. +-01 +QIII~ to
~(~tlf thiS dispasltlion Qi\~ COlY\plltintn Jin Q exre~-
ItlOLlJ ~\anne~~as thej o.ft requ..lre~ to. 0"
1Z.In ~ht (fJ allo the a~r[mmtloneC\ acts
I hfrt~ res let u.11 fe lAaf thiS Honorable tourt
to Disml j' the PDe.y~Jant. t1~tion To Dismiss Fo\ FQIl\1re.
To PrOSEcLltt,
FdruCA.f( ~~OOL\ })cde. uJi"terlY\e~er-Plalntiff
(")
c-
?
CBn~
~f) >:~
~<(_5
~-~(')
'::~.CJ
......~c~
:7
~
-;-1
-
~' ,~
g '~
~ i~
~ 5~
am
~
~
<,y
""
0'
~:~;:~~ ~r~(o~
PROOF OF SERVICE
I, -D-a.k.-11.ini-e r-IY\ f ye r
I have this ~ day of
. .
the foregoing document(sJ,
Court In DI~ow Just ('aUje. To
fm.d.mkJ.Lif j ll~d 1 RiA)f,!
manner listed below.
, hereby certify that
WIUClr~ 'i~OY-, served
,I ft~ U;erj~~~~, ihi r
~UI'\SLfI,.r~ Sa C In
, upon the Person(s), and in the
S'N're by F;~t-C'~, M"~ 0
C l7~Jfnk
. ~; ~
n ..... ~
<::>
~ <::>
....
-c)cn ..... ~:!I
nln I'T1
Z:X~' CD ~~
ZC. I
~!~~; W
r::t-;
~. -0 ~~
..:::.(; ::II:
5>0 ~
c
~ N ~
lID
OCT-08-01 08:13 FROM.The HarLtord-Omni
OCT-e6--01 02:25 AM
ID: 7?0S52111~
f""I-\\.oe
~, ,
EXh:bit .1..
v.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 0 1-5''111
DALE WlNl'ERMB'YER,.
Plaintiff
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defel:Idant
JURY lRIAL DEMANDED
COMPLAINT
I. Plail1tiff' Dale Willlemle'yet is llI1 adult indiWlual mcI a c:iti2r:n of the
Commoaweallh ofpennsylv8llia who resides in Camp Hill. Cumberland CoUll1y, Peunsy1vama.
2. Def(:nd8:D1. Josue Salinas-Valdez is an adult individ1.llI1 who residcIl a17004 Peters
Creek Road, No. 21, Roanoke, Vilginia.
~. ~ fllCtS and oceurrenc:cs hcreiDaiIer .tda1ed tOOk plaee on or about July 14,
2001. at aflp.Ol<imsrcly 11: \8 p.m. ai the iDt=ection of South Third Stncl (SR 2035) and
Haman Avenue, Lemoyne, Cumbed8nd Co'll!lty, Pc:nnSylvacia.
4. At tbattime and place. Mr. Wimermcyer was .opel3l:ing his 1989' Heada Sbad&w
15lhnOlOrcyclcin a nonhbollnd'di.~tioD on Soutl1 Third Stte<~t-l\pprOllCbillg Herman Avenue.
S. At the same time, o..r.. .s....... SaJinas-Valde7. \>/as operalillg a 1~ Oldsmobile
Cutlass iD~ uorthboUlllidill:ction on SoUlh Thhd Street.
6. 'The DefeDdant tIlmed on his left turn signal and stOpped in the inaerseetion to tum
left onto Herman Avenue.
7. After seeing the: Defendant's lea turn signcl, Mr. Wln1ermeyer slowed his
IIIOtorc~le:: aDd attemptc::d to pass !be Defendant' $ vehie::le:: ('0 the right in ac::cordallce with 75
Pa.C.S.A. ~3304.
nS'44,I\MToo..o
OCT-09-01 09: 13 FROM:The Har~rord-Omni
OCT-06-0L e2:26 AM
10,7709521115
PAGE
4/7
&. Without wam\.og, the Defendsnt suddeD1y lItiCClerated and tumed right. which
C<<USed !be right side of his vchide 1ll1mpa.ct Mr. Wint=eyer aad his motorcycle. causing an
BCcident.
9. The Coregomg accident and all of tbt: injuries and d"'"~ set folth bt:ci:Ila&.r '
sustained by Mr. Wiatermeyer arc the direct end jllI:lXimate Jesuits of the negliSent, careless,
Wlmtol1, and reckless manner in which Mr, Salinas-Valdez operated bis motor vebide as follows:
8.) failure to keep alert and main13in a proper watch for !he presence of other
. molx>r vehicles on 1he high-.nr.y;
b) failure to properly usc tum signals;
c) failwe to yield 1bs righ~f'-WllY to Mr. Wintcrmeyer's vehicle; and
d) driving his vehicle gpon the highway in a manner eodangeriDg perso1lS
and I'.operty and in a reckless JIWU:Ier with careleSS disregllrd to the rigbIs and
saf"<::ty ofotheJ'S and in violation oftbe Mo~ V cl:W:Ie Code oftha Commonwealth
of Pe:mIsylvania.
Ch--'I
m..J~,""M. -
-oz.v.l
SaliI8S-V~ ,
1 O. Paragm~ 1 !broUllh gare j~hen:ia by refemllCe.
II. Mr. WmllilBBEl)'er suslaiIIed paini1l 8Dd sc:ve:re iDjllRes that include but ate not
limited to a proximal left fibullu: fiat.:tllr~ a disIal 1eft fibular fiaetore, bums, and JIMIIliple
colllusians I!IrId abrasioDS,
12. By IalSon of his ~.-.said injuries, Mr. WfDter1neyer was!orced to incur liability
for medi<-allrea!mCDt, medications. physicat 1hempy, and similar mistelIaneous e:xpcnges in an
efIi>r:t to restore himsclf to health,. and a claim is made therefor.
13. Because of !he na1xlre of his injuries. Mr. 'WIn1e=cycr has been advised, aDd
therefore aWf$, that be may be forced to incur similar medical eKpelISCS in the future, and a
cl.aim is made lhc%efor.
2ISI<t4.I>MIG\LC3
2
.I. U: ((l"::I::l~.l .l.l::l
OCT-08-01 08:13 FROM:The Har~rord-Omni
oCT-0~-el e~:2( ~M
r..........&;.
14. As a resul1 of the aforc:mentiouecl injurle&. Mr. Wurt~er bas llIJdera;one and in
the future may WIdergo physical md meIIl8l ~. inconvenience in carrying out his daily
ac:tMties. and loss of life' II plIlasures &lid enjoytllel1t, IIlId a claim is made tberefur.
15. & a result of the afDtClllClltioned iajuries, Mr. WmletJlle)'er bas been and in tJ.e
roture ma.y be: subject to emberJ:assmem lll1d humiliatioa. and a claim is made tbccefor.
16. As a result of the afutemeDtiolll!d u;unes, Mr. Wimcane:Yer bas suffeIed work
loss, loss: of opportunity, loss offrequcnt overtime pay, loss of daily piece rllte bonus pay. aIld a
pmnaueIlt diminution ofms eaming power llIJ.d capaciry. and a claim is made therefor.
17. Mr. W'mteEmeyer COIXlimIes to be p1agaed by pelSisteat pain 8Dd limitation aDd
therefore avec: that lW injuries may be of a p............"'llIllltUtC. causing residual pI'Oblems aDd
permanellt scarring forthe t'l'-ft'ftintler ofms liretime. and a cbim is made therefO!:,
C^,"'lirJ
n....l_~- .
:v..l--- ~~ - .~
18. l' _. . -1 tbroueh 17 ~ m. ...j,.>Ol'3Ied,hc&ein'byrefJI:1ll'"
19. As a result me subject collision, Mr. Wimenneyer's motorcycl<: S'.-;.-\
propertY damage, and a.c1aimis made thereforin!he llUlOuo.t,of.$1;993.lll.
'I\fl1ERI3FeRE, PlIIiIll!iff'D&Jc W',~..., ::r-cL.~j\l~1 t,lIlIIiDst~t Josue
Salinas- VIkIe? in an lIlD01D1t in cccess of Twemy.F'1Vt ThoUS8Dd ($25,000.00) Dollars.
ZJ'l#.nMTCol.CJ
:J
OCT-0S-01 08:14 FROM:The HaT~rord-Omni
" OCT~e6-91 e~:~~ HI"'
ID:77121S52111~
f""MuC.
" ,
.
exclusive of interest and IlOSts and in exeess of aar j1lI'isdietiol1ll1 amount requiring compulsory
atbittatiO,ll.
ANGINO &. ROVNER. P.c.
~~
LD. No. 35956
4503 N. Front Saeet
lImWlurg. PA 17110
(717) 238-6791
Anomey for Plaintiff
Dare;
235~1\MTQ\L('3
4
/
E xh /bit ?.
REPAIR ESTlMATE
NAME: 'b. ,WiYl:kM~""-- CUSTOMER CONTACTS:
PHONE: (W)
(II)
MODEL
R.O.
DATE .
1!f7S() C
~L( f/ c/
7/,1"0/0/
I .
Amount Parts
.:5,^"w
~1E -~
IS/nu./~~f
mota sports
GGS3 Carlisle Pite.
r'echctnicrht.tf9lQ, nosa
$~
To: -<'dC, , ,89
Total Now:
Complete Repair:
Adjusted Estimate:
fhone. 7/7 l~0-:JSd..3
QUote
-L_
. -g....
Part No.
Source
Description
Price
Qty
~.5500-ME~73
90545-300-000
61100-ME9-000
51~305
51447-463-003
__!!9
HO
HO
'4651 Q-MB1-406
219.10
1,88
134.03
20.18
2.47
WASHER, OIL BOLT
FENDER, FR.
SEAL SET, FR. FORK
3
,~
~.I
HO
2
HO CIRCLlP (INNER)
HO GASKET, FR.
Froot rum .tiqna I
HO rubblr IIImln:f;,[ STAY, FR.
HO LENS, TURN SIGNAL
TURN SIGNAL. R. RR.
TURN SIGNAL ASSY.
TANK, FUEL 'NH1Z'
PEDAL, RR. BRAKE
RUBBER
2
90543-273-000
33490-MBl-700
~3402-MB1-oo3
33600-MK3-405
~360Q-MG8-405
175A 1-ME9-02OZB
4650Q-ME9-000
24781-41S-0oo
5062Q-MES-670
1.20
2
:J..3.QQ to, 2
~.'lq 1
~ .Oq 1
ffiis price has '0\\1
hIm i n(rra.l'e~ 22.13
2 Thi.r yricl has l\DuJ
. b"n i Qiliililt 7.10
3ThiS Price ha.S no\/l
; hl"~n ~r'1(r"n...r,.i 42.72
, :5 44,09
/ ,2niS p,rj(l haJ' noW
',p,e" torr/dIe! 385.62
, 'l- 67.09
3.20
~
3nqQl
r(;
,5
.
~
i Sub Total: 1,098.78
~.
-::-9.1 ~ (!j ~~_
Qz-'\ -;q~qp
l~''11 '"\
~3iO,31)
1/ CJ~ ~
STEP ASSY., L MAIN
Outel' exnurt .rhi <14
PROTECTOR, EX. SUB
83.07
18413-MG8-000
15.16
1
2. (0""\ 0\ \
'1 sCf
po .4->'" (..1--,/,.5
f'.(( - 3-d- OvvJ..
;)51 ) 'J i7C>
I
V)/l I (( nv iZ..
...,
)1- (:;(..-1 '5
-
rt(
AY- ~8 _.28
" r~, l.
~rr'/20~i;Z~
I
pius .
( "c/ Jc,
fC{(/Lo' 1-- J
fa fl~l/
l 1 31!rJ"1t
t
.
C <.1 s..{.o>< 1Ja..,,{-
156.00
"
~
.':{::>." stvw
l.2Svo C(wa....e. ~C?~cJ
f~'~"Je"~-2/r' ,
_ 30.00 .f'cl"'d"'~:-J1J ..,> SIc.;
~ _ _ ~.--=---::....... ~ 1"- L I .
001 Bell & Howell Publishing SeNices
" ~--"""l':'",," ,~
1,\,,--..,-.: }- ",,)\"_,__:
;...~~-:...,.;. -:IJ;~\"-. ",~...-.
'-_J _.c_ ."_~,
'kr#-......... .,....., ,~.._1.'.{1".,
,,:.--/ ".'. {.:'''-<
','. :,-, rcj'" '.. ,
'-l:::'~_~ ?,' ..1 l~;~
',;~~~i\::;i ~,t~!
). ",~.': }'{J~~~.'."
"'-f""~.....;.-'" "'f ..f,"'j
jLf:;.---;......... ,_'1.;'. ,rt'.h'-{:~-;,
. , ;.' '{ ""-<
':-. -,- "'j''':-
, ., , .. L r- ':" '...
Jl 't:..-~ .......'.~.. "'! \ ~:..~
:;?r{~i~
;.. _'_~ -"--,,~ I, ~_j
il-(..-oO-l""9' ........ ...:).l(,...oO- r
:.~_, -.;"....~~.- {, .-;..:_i
'.....-.:-..~.._- ~., ~".', ~
'...." ,"r-- -.",. ,
'"
-I ::z -I ....,
c:I~:%>;II'3~r--o
-t~_~~6;~
:x>:= ~~~U:
". .....
~'"
.....
'"
c:
'"
'0
?O.......O .......
...;I ~:..... ?~O
U100Ulgg....)O
00
....
m
CO
I
Z
CO
>
z
en
:D
m
~
:D
^
m
:D
m
0'
~'
o
m
....
<
!'i
o
:D
o
m
:D
m
o
o
~:;:
o
",
n
".
'"
~
'"
~
.....
'"
'"
,.
""
,
On
<".
m:z
~"'"
0%
z-
m~
~
'0 ~ m
>
:D ."'" S
.... ~".
~ m
Z g
C
s:
~ m
:D
N
::::; ~
0
o
m
m
CO
:D
'0
.........
0""
zEl
'"
.....
...
'" E
~ ~~
~ ,,'"
CD m~
...
o
....
'!i'
""
o
r""
g; ?i::j
..... ~ <n
~ ~
.
c
z
::;
....
o
;;!
,-
...
,...
...
...
...
-
-
...
...
-
-
'"
..,
"'"
,.
I ~
~ 0 0 c
... C .... ~O ~
:D , ~
0 m '" ~....
'" ~J.
.... ,
~ m "" ~ ~'"f
..,0 c cO
",I
~ 0
~ ~
0 g 0 E
0
", ~ .... m
m , m ~
); m c ~
c '"
'" , m
0 e c
:D c
0 ~
0
0
m '"
..,
.....
::
~
0
0
",
'"
.....
-0
::
'"
.., 0
",m
.....m
-0
,~;!!
.....'0
.........
5
z
~ m ~
m ~
~
< " C
~ " m .
- m m
... ~ '" ~-
?' <0 ~
'"
0 ~'"
.... 0 m-"
~ - ~
x ...
> '" ...
-,- ...
.." :;:
;~
""
a
~
'"
. '"
.....
'"
c:
n
.....
'"
z
'"
-
~
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
~
-
m
;I'"
m
~
o
", lii
...... :-l
~ 0
g
m
<
z
'"
""
""
". <
>
~
<0
.....
....
""
o
n
~
m
a' ',,'
I',.'.'
'. "., ~..' '" ,
!.'I.' . 'i~i;~~.~.c;., '
~1J;,1fI""",~f"':':< .'
, ...." '.'
,31
t:'-o.. .
.11"".'
.:;.
.
3'~"'"
o ::c
i3' 0
",-z
-g ~m
"'....-
"'-.....
o~:::j
00-
3'....
~'"
~'"
...'"
'"
'"
'"
S:'"
m'"
a'"
::c'"
>~
~:D
~c
""en
c:~
:Dm
G)]!
- '"
~m
<
~
.....
o
~
....
~
<
c
c
~
. . .
-0 .
O~~s:
:iEO<~
mOcnO
:D-l :D
'Dm~ ,C'l
(j) ",,-(
c C'l
_ r
-0 m
s: (j)
m
Z
-l
~
8
i
~i;l~ g :f_"t1 1'<
<<g.lDllIlllCD:;r(DMO-
iB~~g"~;~'
n~~: H~~~~
5'~ :::r::r~ CD ~ '2"'" ::::I. g
8~~~i~~-<~~g
s;:r~CD5~&1ii!a!!l1>>
!2 i CD 2:.'~ c g. Q, ~
g.!:l-S i2"2 llCD ii! t:
'ifm---oa 3ii!l.
~....~' ;1l'il.Hitll
~ 0 CD" 3::f1Ei'
:fal)f 01 g:;!i 5.&~!rl
.a!!.!l.~-"iP' ~
~a~'5'e = oiii"~:E~
GllIliim~g- 6' (1-
ai !!,~!l.~~~h~
~,'il' ".i . ~ -.. ...
~.. lil.i. ,"
"'C~ ii &,30
ulh J if~l
!;t,. ,,;t.!,....
. CD CD !it Pi:r91oC! ~3
u~I-~.il:Il."
ii ~ !]' Ih d
~i!5.~ I~~
~!!. zit s,g:
. . ! .. d 0 '!i''2
H~ia ~p. ~ '"
ita" i "ffi.!
CD"!5 iJ 20 Ii
j p~l[i!l. 0
o~ ii! '2 n~
~. . " ~~iI"
. a:.:i! 0'; ~.
U !if~ ! ..
;:= 'ia ~!i
o!. _fldl ,iCDi:
~~ H~ ~~.
,,~::::I :10 i2-
o~ ['fill 'ii~
.., _ CD Q,_ ::lID
CD !il..Ul e
09/20/2001 14:14 FAX 770 952 1115
THE HARTFOI!J)
Exhibit 3
l(&IUUl
TMt HART~DID'S OMNI .AUTO PI.6N
P.o. lOX 10501'
...nANTA, SA 30348-5019
Re.... Service R~uestcd
ThE.
IIARTFORD
DATE: 09/20/01
OMNlAUTOMOBILE
ANGINa AND ROVNER LAW FIRM
ATTN; DAVID LUTZ-ATTORNEY AT LAW
4503 NORTH FRONT STREET
HARRISBURG PA 17110
RE:
CLAIM #: 01-245468 F11
INSURED; SALINAS. CARRIE M
DATE OF LOSS; 07/14/01
~/~....
.~~.
,.
;;: .;:;:r ..
)~~;;"t~t1"-4:""""
~i~JF~l ~
1.::;;~t1~""-. ':;~
PLEASE BE ADVISED, I HAVE BEEN ASSIGNED THE HANDLI~-~:'..
AFTER FURTHER REVIEW OF THIS LOSS AND LOOKING INTOllf!.
STATE STATUTES REGARDING THE RULES OF THE ROAD, IT ou"fo 1\!"
UR INS RED APPEARS TO BE LIABLE IN THIS INCIDEN. THE FO
R LI E J . _ .....", . ';<~>
LOSS AND I WOULD LIKE THE 0 Y TO EVALUATE YOUR CL. '. .~$}JJe::"f":"f"
CLAIM IF YOU WILL KINDLY PROVIDE ME A DEMAND PACKAGE WITH ~H$~~E
SPECIALS FOR REVIE~ LOOKING TOWARDS POSSIBLE SETTL.EMENT ON !fFlt~~d;
....1 .~~+_......~;....,~>.:
:# '~~~t-i...;;,t~:;:;,
AFTER SPEAKING TO YOUR ASSISTANT TODAY, SHE INDICATED THAT1~~;~D
SUIT, TO WHICH I REQUESTED YOUR OFFICE FAX ME A COURTESY C(-~~~lit.l~~h
SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT. HAS SERV ICE BEEN ATTEMPTED AND/OR:' ".'.. "!'~t
DO WE HAVE TIME TO TAKE ANOTHER L.OOK AT YOUR CLIENT'S IN ,;' -;;W
I NEED TO KNOW WHAT TIME CONSTRAINTS WE ARE DEALING WIT.".' ,.' ,.
WILL NEED TO REFER THIS TO OUR LEGAL DEPARTMENT OK_.lE;;1W... .',,,. '",,' x.'
FOR REVIEW OF THE SPECIALS AND DISCUSSION OFA~~~~~~:/?t;.:-m::*~~~'1!~$
...~4~ .......;:...~'4~<~._, ..~!. ~t<:~ "".a~'::'i~,,",,"'$~""_'$~'';;:::<<:::~'''~
.... _......~.... h..:tl....<~ ....:.... ~y .~." ,.....7 ~~.....:~$'l'....".:"'...t:...... .x;:.....:;;:;r:.:;~<.
~~;.~2~i~~~$~~;t~~;~~~~7;:.:.~~~:i~E~?;i:::~::;.-~t::~:~
,;..~:..';~.\~:}:~~~~":..~~~ ~:;;.:;'"'..>~....t~~{::~~~;;:;;~:::~;:;~=:::: ;;~;':';"~:%i'~;
.~:.::'.r~~;:-~'~>~!'~"~~~'+~;,::;~; .'t:<': ~~;t~~l'~~~~~t::.:e::~:~t:~~:;.'(..i' ~~.
..........,......;;.;;:: .........''''''- ~...:y~r... ~,....~..... ~~~~_i~ (...'"41...... ....,. ,,~~........>.+..t>.<.,
.t"~;:::! p ~ ~.~~;:' ,..;.t....~;::~~...':':.::. ~:t:,::~~:r.i... """'''''' ~.. ~~:~~~~~;:~t:..g:
BRIAN YOUNT ~;.<~.~;:':.:..,,:~:;" '~>,,::~" ~.:~';.~;,,;:,,"';:~dS"":~:?" ;:;~~~::::;:~:::;~
..... ~~.......- ~,-................................ .'5.,;.,............ -..\...........~~.u..... ~'<~""-'~"'%'<:~'.~:
OMN I I NSU RANCE COM PANY /CL A I M DE PA ~'~MJ' ""-oi.., : ~,..:;.~. ,,"~ ,1-.",.:; ;~::,:,.;:".;'''' . " -~,~'~:"'~"~.%'
ttr: I;:"f."(.'T:."I""'I" .... ...- -. ,~...-.......,..~,:;:.;;t:....",;:;==,..::~~:.~!."".:}"'.""'~"
:J~;.... """~.::''''~f~.;"i!l'''.~~...!(';A~~: .,l~,. ~'~'!'!Jl.*...t!Hl!l.;1i~~~):j~l'!I~i..~:""J__:~...'t;:i;' ."!..
~::~~l~~r.~.;:' .&.r;'~~~~~:..Q ~~~~"'~~~~:'::.!~r1~~!.i;~;t:-tH:~3:..~i~~f1tf~
PHONE 1-800-727-6664 EXT 29345 ~~M:l~.Fi:~:~Jl1$l~~~9~;~Em:5:~r:rr:r:0.,;?:
~.__.._...:<............~ :;-,..~..~~.....!.r.'~te:~~:::1f~~,l.:t..:2:~':'.:"':"'!~~~7"":< >7'
~~;"~~::Zi~~~~S;:~~~;~;:~~7~\~:;::"{~":;:::'::~"';,..:o...;~;;: :;:,...;. ~
':....>~;,.......-........:~..........""..,...:... .~~f<l:;..... ;;g;,::::,..':;.: :~..."':;:':;':';~t;::..~: :~::.'~~'
;:;;..<::.:::t::::;:~~~~::';::.~~:'::;~I""n;!I$~I<:o:>,.,,>>;...j~~~1~~i' _ ..i.",..,
'~"':..
YOUR CLIENT: DALE
DEAR MR. LUTZ:
WINTERMEYER
,':.
.""
."
if
{r!
~. ....
, , . ~,. .",. ~ .
ANGINa & ROVNER, P.C.
~hib;+ ~
4503 NORTII FRONT STREET
HARRIsBURG, PA 17110.1708
717123S6791
FAX 717/238-5610
RICHARD C. ANGINO
NEIL]. ROVNER
JOSEPH M. MELIllO
TERRY S. HYMAN
DAVlDL LUTZ
MICHAEL E. KOSIK
R1C1lARD A. SADLOCK
JOSEPH M. DORIA
JAMES DEClNn
WWWJ.NGINQ.ROVNER.COM
E-MAIL: DLUTl@ANGINOROVNER.COM
September 25, 2001
Mr. Brian Yount
The Hartford
P.O. Box 105019
!\tb..;."1ta, Or\. 303:12.-5019
Re:
Insured:
Driver:
Claimant:
Claim No.:
Date of Loss:
Carrie Salinas
Josue Salinas-Valdez
Dale Wintermeyer
01-245468 AI7
7-14-01
Dear Mr. Yount:
Receipt of your September 20, 2001, correspondence is acknowledged. With regard to Mr.
Wintermeyer's property damage claim, reference is made to the Complaint. If we are able to resolve the
property damage claim, we will then move on to the bodily injury claim.
If we are unable to reach an amicable resolution with regard to the property damage claim, both claims
will be litigated.
Very truly yours,
~
David 1. Lutz
DLL:mtg
bcc Dale Wintermeyer
2344 I 2.1 IDLLIMTG
ANGINa & ROVNER, P.C.
717/231><;791
FAX 717/238-5610
RiCHARD C. ANGINO
NEILJ. ROVNER
JOSEPH M. MEULLO
TERRYS. HYMAN
DAVlDL Llm
MICHAEL E. KOSIK
RiCHARD A. SADLOCK
JOSEPH M. DORIA
JAMES DECINTI
JOANL STEHUlAK
4503 NORnI FRONT STREET
!iARRJsBURG, PA 1711Q.170B
WWW.ANGINo-ROVNER.COM
E-MAlLzDL1JIZ@ANGINOROVNER..COM
Exhibit s-
November 6,2001
Mr. Dale Wintermeyer
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Dear Mr. Wintermeyer:
Defense counsel has scheduled the taking of your deposition on February 21, 2002, at 12:30 p.m. at my
office. Depositions are oral answers by you, under oath, to questions asked by defense counsel regarding the
accident, your injuries, treatment, present condition, etc. Enclosed is a. document entitled "Your Deposition" to
help you better understand the deposition process.
Naturally, I will attend the deposition with you, and I would like to review your entire case with you prior to
the deposition. Will you please, therefore, make arrangements to be in my office at 11:00 a.m. on February
21,2002.
Upon receipt of this letter, please call my secretary to confirm your availability for this date.
Thank you for your cooperation in this matter.
DLL:mtg
D
Enclosure
234395.1\DLLIMTG
J
ANGINa & ROVNER, P.C.
717/23S<;791
FAX 717/238-5610
RICHARD C. ANGINO
NEIL}. ROVNER
JOSEPH M. MEUllO
TERRYS. HYMAN
DAVID 1.. Lvrz
MICHAEL E. KosIK
RICHARD A. SADLOCK
JOSEPH M. DoRtA
JAMES DECINn
JOAN 1.. 8TEHuJ..AK
4503 NORm FRONT STREET
HARRISBURG, PA 17110.1708
WWW.ANGINQ.ROVNER.COM
E-MAIL: DLUI.Z@ANGINQ.ROVNER.COM
January 7, 2002
Exhibit G
Randy C. Greene, Esquire
1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 1400
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Re: Wintermeyer v. Salinas-Valdez
Dear Randy:
You recentlv requested that 1 Drovide YOU with a settlement proposal. However, we would prefer to
settle Mr. Wintermeyer's property damage claim before proceeding with a settlement demand relevant to his
bodily iniury claim.
II G9Q3.181Cnot corfect
The Complaint avers that Mr. Wintermeyer's damaged motorcycle repairs cost $1,193.111. Frankly,
when 1 met with Mr. Wintermeyer on December 28,2001, he advised me that he would be providing me with
another receipt of approximately $70.00, which would bring the total property damage claim to approximately
$2,063.18. Along these lines, we will be providing expert testimony with regard to the cost ofrepairs.
claim.
I await your response with regard to the property damage claim before discussing the bodily iniury
Very truly yours,
~
David 1. Lutz
DLL:mtg
bcc
Dale Wintermeyer
V'
237508,I\DLLIMTG
ANGINO & ROVNER, P.C.
717/238<;791
FAX 717/238-5610
RICHARD C. ANGINO
NEILJ. ROVNER
JOSEPH M. MELILLO
TERRY S. HYMAN
DAVID L LtITZ
MICHAEL E. KOSIK
RICHARD A. SADlOCK
JOSEPH M. DORIA
JAMES DEClNTI
JOAN L. STEHlfu\K
4503 NORTH FRONT STREET
HARR1SBURG, PA 17110-1708
WWW.ANGINOROVNER.COM
E-MAIL: DLUTl@ANGINOROVNER.COM
[xh:bit 7
February 25, 2002
Mr. Dale Wintermeyer
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Dear Mr. Wintermeyer:
During the time that you and I met on February 21, 2002, at 11:00 a.m., Mr. Frank Hopkins called my
office and indicated that he could not locate the letter I had sent him so my secretary faxed it to him. Mary, my
secretary, assures me that Mr. Hopkins was sincere. Therefore, upon receipt of a response from Mr. Hopkins, I
will send it to you immediately. Enclosed is a copy of my secretary's message from Mr. Hopkins.
Additionally, as we discussed during our meeting of February 21, 2002, Randy Greene, counsel for the
Defendant, advised me that he has recommended that the Defendant's :insurer tender policy limits of $25,000,
misf~ presen btion
Also during our meeting, I secured your authorization to communicate to Mr. Greene that if there is a
tender of the $25,000 of policy limits, you have provided me with authority to accept a property damage
settlement of $976.50. I also advised you that in this regard, there would be an attorney fee concession of
$300.00.
You also indicated that you would provide me with a copy of the rejection of underinsured motorist
coverage that you executed with your Progressive agent.
Lastly, you indicated that you would be discussing Jeff Conforti's outstanding physical therapy bill, and
that T was not to contact Mr. Conforti with regard to payment of the bill from your settlement proceeds.
As soon as I hear from Attorney Greene, I will advise you immediately,
Very truly yours,
c~
David L. Lutz
DLL:mtg
Enclosure
23439511DLL\MTG
Exhibit 8'
To nl. ~o.n&~ c.. Grrfnt Mo.rchI5J~OO:t
- ; I a.m writinq in rcqQrds TO O~I'
rYwh<d liti<uttion Jis~ositlon.l have rdai~c& Mr. Do.viet luh
of. Allqino'l---l{ovnesto reprt'sel\t my best Il\tel'ests)\Uhich I .
HVLr~~ressc& to Mr. kut2. I hll.vt recently recciveJ a
I ttter rom Mr. k t~which isda.td Mqtch IS~OO:J... Mr. '
klAt2 as Jr\formeJTrltJI\th<i.L Itthr th<\t lliavcproviJe~
" ., ',', him with the C\Ltthoritvto Q(Cfpt,y~~t propedy dqr\'\Oje
sdtle.ment j,fer Of l \~G.SO;>anJ tM he (Qm~~ni"t,J lh.t
settlel\'\{nt 0 pr to vou. Tho.toffer isJLUt Qcuptublt to me.,
.L na.ve. net lql\c~ o...n(y ~aperSuJ~',(h state. thd 1 will
(Accept tho.t a!ll\c~l\t.lt a.n\j checks Ilft sc~t to !,\t fOr tho.t
cunou.nt I wi 11 nDr si qfl itj1- it will be. r(1L(rne~. T~(,\l
lA.rY\wl\fw\11 Gl\lH .(0. v& the. rep)qccm. mt )ab~J'.. .-tor my lure.
motof(v,ck~o.lltH~r' - hu theft Weft other pads tK~t \AJclre
da.rno.gett.. 01\ It b __t1'f1 Ju\inCls. I ho.Vt afso in jOfmtJt\f.
Dt\V1J h\.\tZ. that J woulJ be writ:ln tD. vvu to ir\fo'nl
OIA lhl\t .I QIr) not o.((epf'f\ our 0 er.l ha.ve \AIr Hen in
tact in a((o,danct to my best j n eft'sh anA QS IY\'
repr-esentitive of rnt beft if\ttftst;Gb~ infol'minq M .
, ., ... C-.rccn thd 1 will not Qcapt hIS most Irrent -dffer Of.
. JJ n G. SO.$.I then Qlso wrete to 11f. k\.\t~"I o.m cdso Jircct-
i0~ you. to re5,UJ'e. to Q (apt Mr. ,G'i--edlS Offel'." t woul~
),}(e. to Know,~ you. nG.Vt ^Q~ (o~ieJ of. my ll1eJiad records
Of tht Ortho~e~ic InstitLtte. of ~(,\. +Ltrnish~J to ,OU bt thQt
e.hterFriJ'tJor by o.n,vont from the.. IQJJ firm Of An ino"RoVnel'.
If that no.s oc(~ne~ FIc<AJt lnf.orm fr\t o~ the ',J ntity Of
tht inJivid\Al,d.f who no.vt provlJeJ you. with m1. meJlc(a.1
ruord-so,nJ Of the name Of He. firm (fr hsinefJ' enterprise.
whICh thCit persolJcf persDns wor~Jf.o.ti ThQnt tGU"
J In (nel ~ Mr. D. Winlenneyer
1406 Carli!l1e Rd.
Camp Hill, FA 17011
l.xhihit q
, >"
Tv j\r.J)Q\1iJ ~lAt1.. .. ~e.livere~ on T\Aes. MQY It,OJ..
C om~u;;ic ~tlOl1lo~t~~Mlor;n~;t~t~~~~~~J::~hi~h.
rL-tl.r.ce.tJOs'l{QJ~LIllCO .. .....tv- o fithe. J(dl~ ~-.~'ch__Jl.(ke
~o ,,_ef. haS_.J nej__onMC\J::)~,IwouIJJJte.~ouj;o
c Ilf1i,biS Ru I.., ~S~J~VL ,net J.;sLhi:tqe<l YJtu--l'rom
lep1.M Jnq...JYlLJQ.lr\.~_h_fJ:tJnte.[L ts~ .... t{o.ur.cl:JtnJ
,th.at.this_liLe.._i nli c.Q:t1esj.Q~m{ .tho.t ~{)I,(_JALilh_to__.
, wjt.hI[l!W_~ttO~-X.f~LLe.otLnq,lnfLI__h n~b,r.f~~~tl.:L~
, JeLtI_~Ja:nlAt~ U~r~~_the.pClf1t .o-t .tha.t.Ru I ewRLc.h. ..,.,
~G ~tt fnt_Jl:Q.(L..dIJJJj)L_t!n\JttLDjl~Jt_..
I , . ':,,~q.. Fe! r ~
., ,untIl _not.-L LJ~_(lcAn roo_-R-W1\eS-- '",AS_ Il.p yee.
. Ve...L stile. _ _to_ LX ~I.te an .0_
41 /I,
'-.'
'_ ,c._
SnlA_ ,o.d._lnJho.L1te ~~-t~ _\A!c_Qtc no. t:.,
'- OJ..f.( _ ~a.(LJlmLCiLb~_Lej.!\~\A_Jo.nllJJih-'-tt~Q(d..iLth(
<UY1(tqL~L airniJ\1.ilur"b,a.n -~o.\J.r -tto,r vmeniDn ~
-o.LLt~ihLnt.elLsta.b:mtnt Je~JYKta , IJt .e_thQL~OlA
-.\.}lj)tAllLf.t.psfsentJ'QLtr, -~IOlA'ft..Jas --,l_tttfl'pfl )OlJ. to
_clOt "'"lnrp lY\"rfPOrfJfnlIlTloY1I,\ IAnl(wJ~'{\ T ~l'\'\ "',
hnr hIJ innrrnj,,'r IOU ,1hnt ~ "Inu ttr Sf \Jntlrlrl'
,rOM 're l(ftfn,;'Yl( lY\f a'l JI1U 'fr .'0 J{j 1.uIPt\ 11&
jnl1t' o~r (HrfPml"lni :() fY'OffJI"" ~ n,e to t.IP COMO-
IptJi~n 0 n ClJCCfSS.~\j t"f'rn 'rl Dr- AlAn ~ 2001 thfY\
T IplY\nn, ,0 bp :lfOt' :e) \11; r) i:lnl thl'fJAn/i'ino,-1{'ovner-
At--ornf"+ rnlrl'x",,,' Ill!" 'n (our"l;, and .urVt:i fJ.
,.ArUn 'I. -e~nve_IJ hn.'\ flfJ nbfaJnl"rJ... (lntl,[O')1-
.', l\ e1-."J h'lr is' (l(~ceJt( l?r' () rYlf .rJr h'lIJ IVlrJ":O,-
f-\I(!f 1l1Y\(j( P,\'. T\JJn u".pe ':"s 111'"i-rf' T "'daiAe," OU,
I ,mil; f (j I~ iff' to VVll III lith I S' J.a~r' l=ri, J,U -
il 01. I s-iutel in that' f+~fr' +Q IOU C'T \lIant. to 'f
fln,;rl .101 tne '1' ,laUrYlf~' (oS'~s- r--'~vtrv {) d that
WQ,\, ~ IY\nn,p,l\m IV\\)Qfc cle..if\f\jr!:rln' h~Sr
[AI S IUtJ e f.rlma~,r1r' (i-;'-A r\il" lt1rJlul f on
,e'lf ('J'~~mn'~esJecaL\se it SQVtS thef'l1 . ime ~
J
'J
'-.'
:3
, mo ntv-..bV-A.o-L Jo Ln.{,\__~_HCOl1\eJet t'. e sii mQtc~ i~lso
'. w cole.J1L.t..hfAtJttt&Ji1_~tJ.{_l1\-Qtor.~Vdc:S".D.lesJY\ I!tLll.t
-l-toncLL.Bl1WJ1oi.Qj"-wxts_J.n_~[Ih_eJ1YL{.. thqiQCLOrcli n.q
tD~Ls_ rJ CLJ/*--_O_O-SJn _hirci.s _.L\.tQdh _~~ ~SD..ACltt
\V 0 C .r vc.. uJ
r', Oc
... e c e 't. t. ve tct
, · ,S v . . n I ,
-" [ LllU---maV-fl _ILlS C ULI(,{ nu,... ..
-.J 1lun.~th~t-~_\!JHL-o.CLept_tL_p~JuXlLt_Q--f_}_ G laS~
~hf 0. a ,-~_tLm_y--m()f0~-(tcl~.oQn~_thqLL-
_dLqLso_u1\eep my. mDtorc~cLe.JSJnLJlho.snoL1.een
liu~eLto__.hav_eJu~Y\Joto Ie!" bY-!l1ysd.T'lQtbt m,,!.
- b (oJlleI~_wh(Lh~S_\&tJtienJJlfLr:e_ra.ILesrrmates .fA! _
th ernoio.tL c;Le_s:h:o~s.thllt--.h L hQSj,4J od:ut Qi
'-.~
Lj
I
Ll Wt \.lJ ('
, s ~l{laNOU ' eccl . e. to uJ thlr-c{\.()
t'rO~_Ltp'rUcn inq_Jnt witHolAt p rov\cJ.lnq IY\t with
~not.hf.t.AnqjnoJ RlYv_ner AHorniy" {U\~ then Wi,llchQ,q.< (
me. _or ;.~tte..-W1pt to cQ!le,ct any . lies 'ltqnv k !{\d yom
_P\t':_Q J~L_~_QU. -ho..v.c-ta.d,eJ tOnl~. rOJLI ,rne WI th
t e. UpLtStntQ.t}on an{)L.~ _..ruC( fS~fu I t'frov-
Dca. i eJL Imo.y', nQut:..to. reSf t
" I t' . t J ~ II th
,myQfJ~mQt-9-c\A..e!\ It 10.0__0 uu.~e. -fl:ff-es 0 . 't
~d.t-AYsOG1().tLoYbao cl-toafld~er lQtt O.JW ~ W~()l S-
Ie q u.icethVJo.\AJ.to rf.pon 0..0.0 tu'f_~-Cl.tio__ne.~J "
Jl\isse~ rcsd\ t<<t i D nSJ~nhtth" (Q\ ,~onduct.). QnJ.~ pee c h
or- JLl.tjes.ri-. you. W/S: tow,thJro..ww,thout
~. fd~l(GllAct'..:,c.t ~aLi(cjan! witho~t. ~ny.chQrje:bt-~e~
br-.ffi nttQr~dQlms ~m{ no\,U VI 11'\ the 1l.tlu.rej
t. hen i~fotmlY\ea.ccotctil\.9IV~SOb.bC\t 1: co.nJeceictt
_oI\Weu.t1ter- I mo.~ or met n'lit tfSlte this issue,
to -[hot 1)Q\" Ass oei 0. tion. t LV i 1\0
, e '. e e t
tel e
si r\ CeI'e I y-,
Mr. D. Wintenneyer
1406 Carlisle Rd.
Camp Hill. PA 1701 I
'.'
E )(h:b;t 10
"
~---..:...--
--.---- .._-.
We S
-~O;:~ts
Presented by Richard C. Anglno
-. ,tuom., .'UttI 1,
DAMAGE ASSESSMENT
In a civil suit, there. are categories of
damages upon which a recovery may
be based. Compensatory damages are
intended to make the person,"whole
again," mc;aning that the person is put
back in the 'position that existed before
the loss or harm. One subcatellorv of
comnensatorv damalle5 is llCneral
IiSlmllPCs. which is the amount needed
to restore fair market value of the
iniured Darty's nronertv, Special
damages. another subcategory, do not
arise as a result of the wrongful act or
omission itself, but arise due to the
circumstances after the loss or harm
lias occUlTed. Thus s~ia1 damaics
include out-of-pocket Items that can be
OOCumente<1. Consequential damages,
which flow from the loss or harm. are
s~~~-"s~illl damages. .
1,;
!fyou have b(en injured in'an accident
for which you think another person is
at fault, a call to your attorney is in
order for instructions about how to
document your losses in case you do
eventually need to seck compensation.
Remember;not all injuries are always
immediately apparent. For additional
informatioo about :recouping your
losses after a personal injury, call
ANGINO & ROVNER at (717) 238-
6791. The office is located at 4503
North Front Street.
HINT: Future ~es that are certaiu
to occur in the fu as a result of the
loss or harm caused bv the liable Dartv
are recoverable~ as 1002 as there is a
. satisfactory basis for them.
Visit Qur web site:
fwww.anglno-rovner.com I
F~ 0 3 2004
~
DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE
BY: RANDY C. GREENE, ESQUIRE
ATTORNEY LD. # 62692
1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard
14th Floor Attorney for Defendant J oseu Salinas- Valdez
Philadelphia, PA 19103
(215) 563-3500
Dale Wintermeyer
Plaintiff( s),
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
v.
Joseu Salinas-Valdez
Defendant( s).
NO.: 01-5417
RULE UPON PLAINTIFF TO SHOW CAUSE WHY HIS COMPLAINT SHOULD NOT
BE DIS~SED FO"~t7- OF PROSECUTION
AND NOW, this ~ day of YW , 2004, a RULE is hereby issued upon
Plaintiff, to show cause, if any there by, why Plaintiff's Complaint should not be dismissed for
lack of prosecution within twenty (20) days of the date ofthe Order to be entered by this Court,
or suffer appropriate sanctions to be imposed upon application to the Court.
RULE RETURNABLE: .1 ..l_ J _:' '" - JI' Xl:
., .AAur ~ ~O..t .
" () ~ BY THE COURT:
~ Tn Iq n-.
LC
J.
.
t &'
?D""~
l~
~t
t~
..r t"
,
~)\,
I ~
<:>
~
Vii\\i/ri.:
I !~"Ir"(>-'I ,':'
I\.~., ,. ,,_' '_,' '.
"..."r"
"'H Iv
1J2:IJHd 6-83.:i~aaZ
}.)MI(1'-i'l' "('" '-'U' '0
""\!~~:!'h....n~. '::i'::! .::.inl :J'
-OI:HO-O:JlIJ
_t1r, D,\Ji"terrflf~
vI' .
..Josue 'Illinns VaIJez.-~
c,,~~:~"ttJ;.Q~rL-
t;vi LAdion: ~o. ~l
PI.inUW~.l RfDf~~ ~r uJht C,,,,,I'i~t
S f DIJmlJfr J
\.1. ho..ve. the. leqa.\ stanJln,~ (And. G\ s~ff.ic'tnt
sta.Ke:. ~In IhLJ ors pOSlt'IOIl ro stt K MIlA. olbtQ.\n C\ non
bllA.se<li' \A \cia\ resol\At'lon Of this Compla'lnt in
e. \A.'lt or the. · \Ast ~1Ae. com enso.tio(\ 0 l'n loSSts.
~( s'% ,~\tion di l\1.ck~ l~\!.l Dicti,nor'i je'f~ k
.~In's ston~ln~ .s "st.n~ln~ m/Ons thll't Q p.tt~
HaS C\ SlA-t+\c ieJ'\t shKt 'trrJ OJ\ other-wise ~\l.{.stk'(a.bk
caY\hov(rs]~ to obto..ir\ CA \uJic'IGd resollArjon o+. that
cop troy'r{~1. The rci~ i [,NI'ent 0 t stonAi n is s. 'tis-
\e~ I' It ((.In kf. SO,Id.. th(l,t ~ht art naS 0\
.1, Jo 1(\ -ta.ct belve. a.. eqa\ ~rot~ctQblc: ana bwq-
'Ib\e. interest CAt stale. 'l..n is controversy \tlhkh-i
nO-ve. 0. ltQCA\ r-ijht to j)lArsl.tf,
... I h.ve :)Ilst caliSe to e~rHe m'l, entitltmept
to recover in tuH +or- a \l Of my losft waqe.S 0.1'\(\
tor \OO~O o-f t~t\~st .alAe compeDso.t\o~Jof a.ll Of
1!ne p'.rts aM i.\ror r(lmb~rJements Whl,h are
shqwn Of\. my motolc'lck rtpo,if tstimo..te..-, in
ora..tf to reJrtofc. It I bo.ck to the. SQll\t exc(lknt
cOY1~it'lon tho.t It WQ,S in be'fo,e JoSIAe. sa'i~QS
Vct\a(~)rcm i0to it an~ In" le.ft le<\jd\At to hIS
C lA I r a b L n e <\ ll(~ e n c L-' I J
3. I ho.v.e. thd c~0s.titu.tionrA\ .1 Qrtto . prtstnt tr'
cornplC\,nt C\"~ )It\q~tlon to Q -.uu!qt It'\ Wrson.
~ue.. P,OCtSS an~ , e~uQ\ pr-otecMoY)) a.nil I r<
a a l am irwokinq thIs 1~9o.l ri qh ·
5. I ae.sirt tOIf1esent Hi's l~q~1 dis~ositi{)n in per-
son in front 0 C1 J lAaqt Pendtnt( I i'te. anJ Nunc
pro tlAnsas.I ho-ve. tkt 1eqo.t r-ijht to do.
G. I hulle. not submitteJ C\ HlotiDn of Nolle. pros to
this Court.
1. Thi sCorn ~Iaint is still ,penJin~ CU)~ it is still
I t j C\ II v /Act Ion a b 10J plAlSlAClr\t to i~ as i ,t was sub m itteJ
to thi(r court hi UQvi! ~iAt~\JJho JtffictnJd 0. Ju.r,y Trio-I.
&. The. sta.tl.{te. 0 l'mitations Of\Artht'r and{ n:.sent
le~a\ Qction on IAni' of this dOlnpt'int QIl~ dls~ositjon
hc(S still not to II eVJ.
~. Si t'\Ci' I have ~ot rdrG\cte~ this o.ctiooqble COlY\plalr\'S
I hve continl,(eJ. to btlieve that thiS HOrlOfC\bk
court was ~oioj to 4ct on this' legal Complaint by
sCl'\~in.q mti IA notice. Of when thd irnp,enJin,q ,Ju.ry
se.lt.ct~on WOLl.I~ startj p<<rsuQnt to the ge.mMcV tor C\
Jurv, Trla.l I.lIhich was re~reset1tr! to this Honor bIt
COLlrt onJ to rnvsdJ hy DaviJ llAtz.,
10. I <Also contehl t1ha.t it uJo\AIJ be. uncons-ionable to
aLrmlSJ this vali~ an~ actlonabk leqa.\ complaintj
In llqht ot the.. ~ct HettI havy been slAbjtcte&
to Je!libcrJatt ',nJdlf-t-crence. by the. ctfiUiC\teJ
Attourne s who hqJd been hlre& in 6o~ lAith to
j k~),Ctfl~ rt.F tHntQtion~ i liqrt 0 tht tQct
t (.(t-Ihe.~ have.. itlilel to rtpl~ Jto m''j 1t~~Vly re.la.-
~~n-t Jstitrrfho.n qu~s~(ons u}hl~h p,crtiAinJto ,thIS
ck IspaSI tlo~ I.U ertQsl de.l, btrC\te. I naIJ[trenC't IS
lAJ~o.lI \j no rrna.lly frpw ne J [,{pon h y tK Co Ltl tSj
I \. In liI~ht of cdl Of the. a fo,e.mentililleJ rtlavant ctn~
By the Plainti ff
M,. D. Wintermeyer
By the. Cou.rt
()
c
~~2
~
.
~~g
:T
=2
....,
=>
c.:;)
.....
...,
f"T1
CD
N
W
o
-n
~
rn"
,-
"m
;:00
Qo
X'Ti
(:J 1l
;;:",0
7")m
~i
J>
.1J
.<
-0
::1::
<d
&'"
'"
IN ,FORMA PAUPERIS
AFFIDAVIT/PETITION
'\.\
MAR U 1 2004 ~.
~illt'rmfyer
W:Htf,~~:X ~~}
vrs.
DOCKET #J~1l
Josue .\u))na.f VajJerO!..yndant
STATEMENT OF THE PETITIONER
I hereby request that this Court permit me to proceed in forma pauperis (withoUt payment of the filing fee). In
support of this I state the following:
[gl I am the Petit ione.... in the above matter" and because "f my financial condition am
unab1-'l to pay the fe.e ,for ,filing Subpoenos Una or other +i linn feo that are tel(.\teJ
to thiS cuse. o.na l/tlqotlon. J J
I represent that the informatio~ below relating to my ability to pay the fees and costs is true and correct:
PRESENT EMPLOYER'S NAME AND ADDRESS
J illY) not f'mpJot'~.
~
~:~~~tJ:
CC\m~
SolL.AFlYORW.lGESF.,.~onf
3 0
SolL.AFlYORW.lGESFERMONTH, V~' :l~~
TVl'EO.v.<lRK 1 woo.!' deSOond .I ..a..mJjed .tar.J~fcifl(, ~.
OTHER INCOME RECEIVED WITHIN THE PAST ~VE MON~
BUSINESS OR F""'ESSION, Non r. I rY1 L< n f m ~ 0 Y f J . INTEREST, 8lt...
OT><ER SElF.EMF\.OYMENT, Non e OMOENOS, lio..n. f
FENSION....O ....NumJES' ~ Q n -e. SUF""R' FAYMENTS' 11 ~ n f
SOCl" SECURITY SENEFITS, ~ n e. OISASn.tN FAYMENTS' j 0 ~ f
WOPKMAN.S CCMP~NSJ.T10N: Non f P\JBUC ASSISTANCE'; .!J 01\ e
THE OATE OF MY VST EMp\'OYMENT WAS:
UNEMPlOYME!IlTCOMPENSATlON ANO SUPPl.,EMENTAI. BENEFITS:
PAGE 1 OF 2
PT "-
Docket Number:
~l
11
OTHER CONTRIBUTIONS TO HOUSEHOLD SUPPORT:
.....,lHUSSN<<l\ ~ ~) AD"" - 1>4US8AN0l IS ~ovm
~EIolI'l.Cl'tlA:
SAL.lAY OF! WAGES PEA MONT)ot:
CCN'I'7UtJT'ICNS FPlOM' "AFlENT!:
TYPE OF WCFIK:
to.
MORTGAGE:
LOANS:
.
PERSONS DEPENDENT UPON ME FOR SUPPORT-
USSANOI NAME;
o OillOFlEN. IF ~:
NAME:
AGE:
NAME:
AGE:
NAME:
AGE:
NAME;
o O'n-lER PC-RSONS. NAME:
AGE:
NAME:
AGE:
REl.ATIONSHlP:
NAME:
O~" ~O"""~ art< P.~ aJ:n:mf yet
AND now, this ~ day o~ ;l.OOLL. upon cor.,sideration of the above
petition. defendant's petition to proceed In Forma I'auperis is ~.
~~.b """c..l~ ay the C,art
[~~ .o~ -t;.
o~.o~
J.
v/i\JV;\7,ISI\'I J?Jd
ll^lnn" il' '.~'" '_;'"'^<
/ "'1./_', !'/' "j',-;,,():)
?O:6 1111 8- i!VH ?OOl
},i:fVl0NOi'1101id ?JHl. :10
301::1010-0371;/
DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE
BY: RANDY C. GREENE, ESQUIRE
ATTORNEY J.D. # 62692
1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard
14th Floor Attorney for Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez
Philadelphia, PA 19103
(215) 563-3500
Dale Wintermeyer
Plaintif~ s),
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
v.
Josue Salinas-Valdez
Defendant( s).
NO.: 01-5417
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
I, Randy C. Greene, Esquire, attorney for defendant, Josue Salinas-Valdez, served upon
the plaintiff, Dale Wintermeyer, the following:
1. A letter dated February 13, 2004 enclosing a copy ofthe Court's February 9, 2004
Rule with regard to Defendant, Josue Salinas-Valdez's Motion to Dismiss for failure to
prosecute, via regular and certified mail, in the above-referenced matter;
2. The certified copy of the letter was refused; and the regular mail was not returned
and
3. The certified return receipt was received back on March 8, 2004.
Dated: March 16,2004
BY
ANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE
/'
DUGAN BRINKMANN MAGINNIS AND PACE
New Jersey Office
Media Office
12 S. Monroe Street
Media. PA 19063
(215) 563-3500
Attorneys at law
1880 John F. Kennedy 8oulevard, Suite 1400
Philadelphia. Pennsylvania 19103
16 Aberdeen Place
Woodbury. NJ 08096
(856) 251-9600
Facsimile: (856) 251-9602
February 13, 2004
D ~;~DW~,~
(215) 563-3S00
Facsimile: (215) 563-5610
www.dbmplaw.com
Via Rel!ular and Certified Mail
Dale Wintermeyer
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
RE: Dale Wintermeyer v. Josue Salinas-Valdez, Docket No. 01-5417
DBMP File No. 2500
Dear Mr. Wintermeyer:
Enclosed please find a copy oftbe Court's February 9,2004 Rule with regard to
Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez's Motion to Dismiss For Failure to Prosecute in the above-
referenced matter. Please note tbat you must show cause as to why your action should not be
dismissed within twenty days of service of this Rule.
Very truly yours,
DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNIS AND PACE
;faAl/1u L
BYV:'~YC
RCG/ks
Enclosure
- -
FEB 0 3 2004
DUGAN,B~ANN,MAG~SANDPACE
BY: RANDY C, GREENE, ESQUIRE
ATTORNEY I,D. # 62692
1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard
14th Floor Attorney for Defendant Joseu Salinas-Valdez
Philadelphia, PA 19103
(215) 563-3500
Dale Wintermeyer
Plaintiff(s),
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
v,
Joseu Salinas-Valdez
Defendant(s),
NO.: 01-5417
RULE UPON PLAINTIFF TO SHOW CAUSE WHY HIS COMPLAINT SHOULD NOT
BE DISMISSED FOR LACK OF PROSECUTION
AND NOW, this r;"':: day of J...J--. , 2004, a RULE IS hereby issued upon
Plaintiff, to show cause, if any there by, why Plaintiffs Complaint should not be dismissed for
lack of prosecution within twenty (20) days of the date of the Order to be entered by this Court,
or suffer appropriate sanctions to be imposed upon application to the Court.
RULE RETURNABLE: the dayef ,2991 at"
.2-0 ~ -a;w- ~.
BY THE COURT:
I
a.m.~.Hl.
/sf 11.'~r- E:. ~
' 'f],
TRUE COPY FROM RECORD
111 Tl8tlmony wlIereaI.1 here unto set my _
andthl ~ ., said ~ at CaIUaIe. PI.
fh" ! '~ ~ .{~'~ ~'j ~.1
. , .1 .. ~1 '
I .. ,
ProIhone&uf
I
I
I
I
\;,
;
:j
\1
i
i:
"
}?
o
];\
~
DODD
'z:z:=z
C::OQ...un
Z-4comc:
~c:lc.=R
~mn"a_
"'!:::Z::~~ ~~
d~i:8 ?f
""'&i_o~ ;1,'
C.-m-lCl
i;m.2!;lII;c:I
:Do=0=~
~,.;I.E=
elmZ
li!:l
m
5.
ell;;'
...
:0:
!ll
~
;:;
:-=;.
::!;
:3
"
'<
4
~
'"
'"
o
0-
-. =r
[::]
~ '"
-g:~
-, ~
~ ~
;,~
~-<
~ '"
a 0
-< C
~~
~ ~
ii' P.
;D~
8~
8
t'..}
t.n
t:) 2;:
c::
"
,;z
",tID
" ~
;,~,
~ ; I'
~ ~,;;"'"
~ ~"'
i ;",~,:;;,;\
ii"'''I''''f:i,''l
r',
fl&'::
'tI
>
"
,.,
-..J
CJ
CJ
I\l
I\l
.s::
.,...
CJ
CJ
CJ
CJ
.s::
UJ
..D
00
II'"
UJ
U1
CJ
00
",
"
"
."" .~t
,~\
-' ;~
" \". ....,...
"
,i~-
vrs,
IN.FORMA,PAUPERIS
AFFIDAVIT/PETITION
MAR u 1 2004 ~
~~t~ Court
Co . 0 \:leaS' '
OOCKE'I # () -
,
/
Uff;,t,cwr er
~e ,\I.lllno.r IlaJdn-lkfenJant
STATEMENT OF THE PETITIONER
I hereby request that this Court permit me to proceed In forma pauperis (withoUt payment of the flllng fee). In
support of this I state'the foRowlng:
I8J I am the Pttitioner- in the above matter, and because of my financial condition am
tUllab~ll to pay the J fe.e ,fort,filing S"b poenos o.nJ. or other .c.i lina tees tho.t are ttlute~
o th,S Co.$( a.n~ lit, qn Ion. J J
181 I represent that the informatlo", below relating to my ability to pay the fees and costs Is true and correct:
NAME AND ADDRESS PRESENT EMPLOYER'S NAME AND ADDRESS
~~.~~~t~ . J 0'" not Plnployea.
C(.\m~
....""""'w.........""""'" ~r"
VI
OTHER INCOME RECElVCD WITHIN THE PAST
=;=:N~;n.f In) I1nfm~'
==. f.~~
~:::~: "NMf
.~cooiPIHSAt1ON AN!) SUPPLE!oIENT.....ENEFm!: Nin f
~MO s:
IIIftlU1': 3J 4:
"""'"""': Moo.,
IUI'POIIT,.YMENTS: ij Q n f
llIIAIlUlY ,....ENlS: t!n.Q f
OURUCASSIST...a: ~Ol\e
11..."".,l3
~\"~
/ - ^' ~"-
t'a~f r/....
Docket Number:
QJ-Sill
\{
=E~ CONTRIBUTIONS TO HOUSEHOLD SUPPORT: ,
.. 'NIlIIWd:ti) A 0 II't - ...-. --.atml:
~~
.... .I.-W Oft WoUlD"" MONTHl
l'I'ClMP
..-nuaE:
lJ:lt-:
EL=S O:::ENT UPON ME FOR SUPPORT: ~f
__-:=-.~ NJ A
o .....-.. N<'f: NAME:
AGI:
.....:
_.
N",UC.
.lB&:'
.....-.
o fnHIII'~.tur-'
.taE:
HAUl:
"'I:
MA~
~~~;. . u ,', SionatUre llfthe pe~~. W \ ntmo.trr
I .u. ff\o.r:," '
AND now, this ~ day of ~, upon consideration of the above
petition, defendant's petition to pro,cead In Forma Pauperis is JeFi~~e.d. .
J5J ~~ll ~t
, ff"
()
c
~;::::
",~n
rpfil
~;;;;f..:
t71d"-
g,t.~
~(-~
tf::C)
>c
~
-<
. ~
....
=
e~
.<:"'
::II:
-
::;0
N
CT>
."
::II:
~
=t
rt1:Il
r
-um
~5~
. -r!
( --
zO
Om
~'-i
;:>.
,J:J
-<
Ul
V1
vs.
JOSi,Il'- '-lllinfH Valrlrz.-betendant
I'...!ll~
.WJLLL_b.f.~ .,
PROOF OF SERVICE
c c V, r ~~. 0 m rn.illL1.llitt.
flu I' \Ii!): () 1- S 411
Action
I, --1jr. D. \i.Jinterrneyef " hereby certify that
I have this :1.81:1- day of ~a~Llal-~ ,2nOS , served
the fO~egOing document(s), ~p\lel'\( {) P Od\.!.J':~CC\Alnfl\ts Or
~~ . ,_. ,pursuantto~
~~:~ ~i ~~~~e ~~~~1-;4~~ ,uponthePerson(s)~
.:.t . I i w' a e. oWn as lA.l<lJI'e..l'J'ecL.leJow.
Service by First-Class Mail to:
Hartt 01' d DlY'\n I r: I cd mS
{+~~ ~f; d~S30cii4 R
...
~0 :~i
\:,,:,':;
(
( :
COl.inh, of ClllllhH-lo.rlOl~
f
--.ljr. D. Wintermey('r-Plnint#-
I vs. . t
JOSUf SIl inas Y(lldt:~
ccurt 4 CI.l'f\rI1Gn PI el1s_
.GLD...Ji.Q.~_JI 1- S l{ Il
~f\ Action
PROOF OF SERVICE
I, t\.LJ). Win t e r m,y f r , hereby certify that
I have this ...J...a..:tL day of ~(J~6 ' .2 ooS , served
the foregoing document(s), mpornl1 0 C.LDocuments Dr
. S' , pursuant to ~
, upon the Person(s)~
It-IJr-e. rJ'f.d-'WDW.
Service by First-Class Mail to: l1f.j)(Hll ct L (A t z.
LJS03 N. Front st.
~PL\. 11/10
I
C
,---,
C~ r
~~!~~/~~~~ ~~:j~
(1 fLq\1~~I:J
r'~U I HlJl'jlj lAKY l.., LlJr',l\::l
r'At;:t. Ul!fj.:::
PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT
(Mu.st be typewritten and submitted in du.plicate)
TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY:
Please list the within matter for the next Argument Court.
_____w________________________________________________-~----------------------------------------------.--------------
CAPTION OF CASE
(e'ltir'e captioll musl be staled il1full)
Dale Wintermeyer
(plaintiff)
Ys.
Josue Salinas-Valdez
(Defendant)
No. 01-5417
,Civil Term
1. Stn1e matter to be argued (i.e., plaintiff, motion for new trinL defendant', demurrer to
complaint, etc.):
Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Pro~u~.~n~inn
2. Ide.1.ltify couns<1 who will argue cases:
(a) for pl>intiff..
David L. Lutz, Esquire
(N.me and Address)
4503 N. Front Street, Harrisbur2. FA 17110
(b) for defo:ndant:
Randy C. Greene. Esquire
(Na!lle and Address)
1880 John F. Kennedv Blvd.. Ste. 1400. Phila.. FA 19103
3. I will notify all partie. in writing WIthin two days that ~li. ca<e has been listed for argument.
(via first class mail)
4. Argument Cou.rt Date:
Si~e Nlo
O~
v
Randv C. Greene. Esauire
Print your name
Datc:
9/20/05
Josue Salinas-Valdez
,.....nomcy fc:r Defendant
(";>
c:::.
z..
"""CO
.tW'
~i~:i~;,',
f':'C
.L
',1.-'7< C'~
~Q
0:;;:,
:.t
~
-e-
%
-0
r-:>
r-:>
~
~-n
f\'\f"
-Qi'1J
-00
vb
-0 '~S~
,. -5\\'
~l
-:~
-
r-:>
o-
r-:>
0'
#2
DALE WINTERMEYER
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
JOSEU SALINAS- VALDEZ
: NO. 200]- 54]7 CIVIL TERM
IN RE: DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO
PROSECUTE
BEFORE BAYLEY, GUIDO, JJ.
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 29TH day of NOVEMBER, 2005, after review of the file, the
Defendant's Motion to Dismiss for Failure to Prosecute is DENIED. The Prothonotary is
directed to list this matter for trial.
Edward E. Guido, J.
Randy C. Greene, Esquire
1800 JFK Blvd., Suite 140
Phila., Pa. 19103
Dale Wintetmeyer
] 406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill, Pa. 170]]
j) . (- 0)
~I
~
j1f~
Court Administrator
:sld
,
.,
. ~
"
.
L
~~ml~~ commcpo.PieaS'
(;'0 Arti.n~;~
f\^c:lt^+ ~'- ~
--U.Jl.U~ _~__.
. .tlL~~~e P-k~~t J),cr r
\irs.
JDsllf_~n~\t-r\tRlde ~
---llif' --
~'\ctjcn FOI~ OrJer. T(), Represt:nt PICtIf1tiff' A~J CDmploJn~
PurslAunt To ~\A.CtS'1 Contrqct Ajfte/nl'ot Pot Tflld Repr-esenUIOn
I. SOOI~ 0.+ te.r JOSv..~ S'alino.S' ~r~ve.. in,to I my' lqt le~
anJ mV ~otorc y,c1S ~ fOun& CHI CAJVJI'tlsement o~.
the. lo.Ui t' rm o~ Anqjnc~ Rovl1tr reqQI'JIf1~ alAt01YH~i1(
relo.td p_ersoncd jnj~rit~j \.lJhicn Ji-&.te~'~1.Jo recovervl
~o Fe (,.'1) That ctdvrr,tife.rYH.(\t for le~Q.1 ,tp'resentoJi6n
)5 enttrl'~ as ~ w,th thrs' Mctlon For Orde,
To Re pre Se nt P) Qin ti ff'.. ,
J.. I then cOl\ta.('te~ me Io..w +11'/'11 Of Anqmo~ ROllfler
~nJ" I ~ons~eq\,t~ntlv then t41~e~ to attodrny D(Avif
llAt2) who, I~i Just! One of m4ny Qttoll.(,~Y~'" 'that h,~~al(
r~rsonnl I~\urr ~(AS~S OJ Itrresento.tlon QS Ut'fdlltteJ
WI H, that law J IflY).
~. ~rt~r 1 expl~ jne~ this situO,tlon ~f my losses <<oJ
I nJ~rltJ to Dt\\JtJ kl.\t~C\nJ 1. tol~ him that I wahte~
to be rerrefer\t~J bv qn attourfl~ in C~IAr't lif1J ill a
Tri cd who wClAl~ sue' +~or anJ ob'tltio 0, settle.lY\cnt pa.v-
IY)f.nt -for me. tor 1001;0 Of t^e. costs Of just JI.{~I
compehsationor the da.ma ~s tlwt .UJtre CCil.('se~ to
my vr..r'l fUIe tl\otofC'~cle},,, udG(,tlDn to CClltcttnCl
Jot- a/l other dctrnuqe.r iY\~rudinq liti,qqtiofl costs. J
Y. D4\Ji~ ~ut< then j,r+~rmfd me th<<t We has over ~o
tHS C ,ex per~ence 0 collettin COli') tnsation anJ
.to ICO'lv 0 the. 'a ajefor my lY1otorcycle. shOll
Jl\ot be. Q ro~lem4 I
~
, .lo.;J t.i/'TY) (~r~~1
c to' ., '! '0IJ..O ~
,. v s~'o e~.o.
s t r i c 1 : a j II t V s of,' C\ II o,f' tat t /) IAr n 1,1 Ro.. t a I e
lAndex. the. ~1\~ctiDn of tXe pri)p'~jetHh dlAt)tSlJ-re-
5 fllnslhle !J[(bd,ty.s 0f the Ia.UI -t1rms proprl(:ton-.
Tht~efilte. the. str,let liabIlity -fJor, provlcl'nq. (Y\~ with
l riA I tfltd :t'p, rO:f: e ss 1 0 na l fe.~re rhtc\ bn (\ otth'1 s; Com-
luint SlAi''t tlhot Dav;cl Lutz ha.s reprl:sef\tecSJiql1e~
nd stAbmitteGl to thi s Honoro.bl-e. Cou.rt wetS a[ce~teo..
b~')'tvJ(AJ ~lIJeda)(en b.y the. laVJ+-irm of Anf1lllo't-
Rb"Vf1(f anrt 6" DG\vi~ lZlAh. PUfSUa.1nt tl> i'hc st1;/1
Ie qedll- hioJil)/q R\.Io..Ji COl\t~ctf()f' ltq(\ I rtJlresent- ·
o.tjJoY\ that Do.vJiJ hlAtz has 5iq~t~'t~'~er(J: tD me
as M acti n a (]\t an~ rt re setYti t lve 01. tile. I ~ UJ
firm o-\, An1;n~ Rov ~tr.~, r<c'n~ <~i ion cf So'lent-
i nes lad; D:c~;onqI'V Jq:.il\ts ~~ brel.lch of contrdc-t to hS
"The f.Cl.j ll.\fe., O,t U Ratty to Q contra ~t to c,omp,ly wir/\
tht Julty, w~\lcH he. ~Cl{/ CtsJlune,l hy the obllqatldl\ Of
the. CCI\'tfClctor tht rJoin.q Of' Somt1hinq i(\c~nJL)'tedt
with ib' eXistef\ct TnC\V blt trt'a.te<.{ u.S' JA heo.c-h
th(r_toi'I').Thcr(.~orsa blruch 01' Jutl to repf,tJe~t me
in c.curt IlljfoM at 0. ,ji.(J~e Has b tn ccm/Y1lth(X
lKll\Sl me. hv .f-o.ilinq to' rc~reseJ'\t ,m~ b(j:t ;ntercsb-
COLlrt to '0. j/u.cceJssfu I concluslDrf,(htnbI ~n ClCC-
epta.ble o.mo\1f1t fer \J5t Jue cClYIpc/1slAtioo to me. has
~e{n (),htu.ir\e~ 'trecoVtr;eJ.. ccnsequehtlrJ I h,a.\Jt been S'u~-
J ect\~ to wI/It" ncqlJQ<)ic~c"/PQ~lc nlql'.l'ncs"nprc-
,te~~ ID{)(.(/ COI\J ctJa.FlJ ~ (u.I~a.blt ,/v\/J'conaJ,c't'.
II. ,S liKe L hLl.ve not f,reJ David hu.b:.. from represent-
i nQ me,:/\or- nO-s Da.vi~ ~\Atz.. Jeclard thir .CofY!'plaint<tJuit
fer Ja~(Ajt5 th~t ht h~s pre.scnteJ 10 thiS cou.rt. to be
"~II't VOI~'),cln~sll'\C( nedhtf myself nor the. Ia,w J.tfm
cf ~n~:n(jl Rovl)tr have JecluiecA OUT quasi Confract
9"
I II
. .~ ~
. VI e. VI" 'I L
~ s;vf:eiy t, ,
~-ft:1h f hi I J r e p reSf Y\ t..a:t.D e e'
rion thO,t 1 have- ,been subjest . to by Da,ViJ ~l.(tz.
[And. bv the llA,w -t-Ifm 0 t A:nqiflO't Rovntr ~t.tn
DQ,V( J I k \A t~ hi\J):V ith J~awn J his re p re fer/tat io," Df
rflYj'~l~ (,lllu\ the (olY\p)(uni1..heccau-e. ,the. law;\-lfT(1
o An if\o'r Rcvner ha.l1t nj)l. Rrol1l~ell e- yvitK
ct%other attoul'nv to \u)f i 1\ He I eJet\ du-tl es' an~ the.
I e qui I iubi I itic!. of ,bu.r (efitr.c! a tf'N\,^t for triol
reJf,esento.tjDn~'t u-httl (a SlACCeSSJIk recoverYl has
b:e.n IYIClGtttorlibtal,oet.\. OY\ tY) bfXo.l 61 the .Iaw
,-t.lrm Of A~qu10't--,Rov()ef. . ,', v..lt : .1.J..lJ~Lltej
'~AHctL.CJ1\' ,} J"'ub E.ct to IS~ c I t'J il
Ai jL\G IC\I . .') I now C\\i (', J-. L(HulArnys' th(\t art
L\Cju.lr\ft m:.)RClIlJ~ C-reen C\T\~ Juc(luel;ne CM.licl'YJcdl-
tMuqh I 411', noJl withOlAt'I(\AV. Irqcd r-~preSt'(\ttc. tiOI'.;
btctlus c I hCl.v( hecome. ,l,n#V'a~ta.q('A Jue L the
br-ee,ch q. ccntry\ct)1-clllt to th( brr~qh cf (,{(Aty to
prOViG\e. M~ Wltlt Iqcd rd.rer(,r\t~tlcnl
I~.~ T t ctdLsto.tes th~l~-
,toJIDr\ is to t 0110 c Hrou to 'ts COf)clJL.r~oo1>and.
C 0 llR G-IO I (A)(3) s o.tt~C ArLill..Q!bIlliL.l:nillL .
~i "cnto.ntr.)A ~I'~
it tS 'G Elft 0 er111oJ;on 0 ..D:ff"tfeatl.lrID(\
tle Q OUfn ~s Cl. e ,I ~t'~ o~~ 151 a~~ Le.sJary
t S 0 0 t'c C let ) nt e c ~
. no i j eo; Lea to _~J..
L CM If,fc~rt ef a ~'inc< DuvI
l~\t2 hQs fed Ie to continue to act Q,) rn.~ OJtOL{rrl:tJ
nor has hi vt' the llAW tir-l'!I ot An~i/10T RoVner ~fO-
vldeJ m,t wIth G\. ftpl(l.c!emtl1t,Qt1:uurnyy:sII1Ct DC\lIiJ
l...iAt2 ,tade.J to act after I JlftcteJ.. ",m to folloUl
throlA3K with hiS repr .rentl).tion Of this ccrn~laillt in
c
13, All c e C\ f-Hel(lcntione coaes-'t Rl{kr of Prilfess-
icnoJ Co altct have.. he~n misrepreref\te! 'l-br- hrhcheJ,
cdlthDU.~h Duvia kuJ~ has unJerto.ken the -Sworn oath
arJ PleMq~ Of Prof~.rJjoncdiS'm whkh is "'r will honor
thes.rlrt-'t o.ncllAte.n~o.S' well cU' the r~tAir-l':trle1\tr Of.
the '\f,P llc~able Ru)eJ bf Cvde 0+ Pf,o,f.e~sIDnoJ co()dd~j
a.nd.. ~.r \All/I resolve MCt.tterS' ex'fedltllousl_v unA
without IAnneCtSSfArlj expense!> hl)wtvef~ those.. a.
pleJ~es 0+ thC\t SWOrn oa.th were not cOlY\flieJ
with- a.fttr 1. feto.'lneJ.. Dal/id lutz. o.nJ He Io.w
4f.lnn ofJ- A1\qiflO't Rov,iitt' ro represel\t my best
I nit' r eJ' r)' ('{fl~ fr\ t d I fe ct llnf.
lL.j, Also in rt'~urJs to the mis-reprcsentation ana breech
of JL~ty that I hav~ been!ubJtcteJ to bv ~h~ Jis-
cbt\t'l\~e(ice.. Ot feprtSentoJIOtl dlltt to theJuJlth-
JrO,Ulin ~ rc: rerentifl, Ine is ,!he,fQct t.h~t ~
I I j S S VI" S J C1h/jJlf.~_S~L.JilK.
) was t ~~ A isconti (:(e Y\C~ ehte,rtJ.
~~ ~r co, sd ~ vJit DJli.. con leA Of h,s C 11e.n.t
IA srI C f Yl. )
)-5', TheY'€.~ofe in li1ht Of a II ~f tl1e cttoreme1\ticneJ fQC~
I here-b fts.~ect L( II~ OJk t'his Hon rable Court rb
e.lther 0 Ae.r tne ) UI f'lnY\ Ot Anjino't Rovner to provlde
In€.. with 4f\other aihlArn rom thQt Io..w . inn to
contil\lAe.. the contracteJ 1t re.s-entaiion) vJhJh .I most
Urq::tl:)or ~. a.sk for an OrJef', To com:,n\.te'tRentme
eprle.rtrlto.bon to gt Str1t by th,S Honof'1.t k It: Cou.rt to
)a.via Lu.t~whaet{)te Q Mohon f~f Hd.t QC t ion is h€re~y
'\ tt.rt.J. 'i-fe~u.esteJ, f
O~'yill1d mailed. Q le.tter to OQvid. kub.
\J 1 ha\JLJ.J:LL'J1L _L\ coPy Of my ktte.r to Mr. hl{B.
- L. I < t &
_\LIJUc.n I S t n en~
.
..-a.S .. .
.1.J-..el. f I I ' 00 2-
o..bolrt his IAn rOjfSSIDnal OndlActjt in reqQfJs b) hIs
\,(ndhlc~I)\'{J1IC\wfU.1 re,prfJentotions. I QYso once. qqain
lnJornltcA him of h,s proftSS'lonal j:qbilit,ts an&:'
Ie it! l:~~: IityJ'J WhIch he hQS ~a.ileJ to u.phold ano\
m ;ntLtln, I 6jo.; fl Ctske:.J OQllld LUJ2 q,uestions in Jnl
Je.thr to hi m,,'t I I 0. qUln intormecl ~;m that I wanie I
to \-eoGl Josue. _hl111l[J' Intthoqcttor,t:0) and. Of\Ce. a.qaJf1
my qlA'tstions'trny re1u.tsts fir In~onnat;on W~fC
mlt with dellbero.te. in&lfj€ tOet,,'" by' nore.rponse.. or-
QnSWtfS which waS tht:. amt indifferenc(. that /lr,
k\Atz sJi?jecte~ mt to throuqhout the. time af.ter I hQ~
hire.d. hl~ o.n~ He IctllJ f,rm-bf AnJino'tRoiJl1er 'to repre-
sent My hest interests blj ~c1inq~ (,{pon my dlrectil1t..i
tor lAnd / ot l:tlqatinq tAls CompJaitlt l(~tjll 6 5'ucceSSftd
and ffkli'lful recoiJery dor jiAst dut- cOlllw:nsatiorl nas
been QchieveJ to fY\V kQHj{aC't;D~,pursuant to th(
worJinqr our il1ul'lAcd qJusi confrasto.n~ pursuQnt.ta
t ht celn tnsatvfl{ CllY\ounts tho.t DavlC\ hUt2 has
srl:lteJ 0 tht: Cbl1\plalnt tha.t ht has sIJ(\t'~whlch Ae.
is r-eql,dreJ to.. ~(ftIiJ and represent QS q I€J.d l,ce
bilitv) as t~-e ,Irq,a Jl\t~ to r€fieS'tnt.
17. I (alsD stoJed -10 Dav\J Lv..t2. Ih tha.t letter thut 1.
lY1o.lletl to h,m 00 A~I'\1 ~S200~./t1..f 'Iou. withdraw
rfom rtpr'tSchtlll,q me'. befol'( you. Ho.Vt represented.
in.e.ln- Court~'t- 01 ~eforL Wt have reacheJ D. settlement
a qrec,ln(nt wn ,ch IS: QC,ce pto.b I~ to ms the.f\ I w((nt to
nLtve. an other A't-R C Anq Ino<t- Rovner) 0. ttofllt Y :re p,resent me.')
O~C( QQa,10 a,ftel I IVrbtt tjw.rJ I wctS sUbJ ecTeJ to de.-
Ilbtf'o.ti 111Jliferencc .
)g. 1. o.~Jtt,onallv wrote. it that ldter to rIfe k(,{~:::/'J.n
my t1urch l~~bo2. letter to you I wrot~/tlf Mr. G-reer'l
8 _
... irl not Ctj"'u ta ~ Stt:ilt.meY\~cr which I v
1J:fJ In wrltlnNh~nUL~~-_b
')s I lDl:. to MOVe. thlj" J ;sp,()sit;()f) into Cour~LlnJ..
once o.QIJln /'11'. ~uh JQ.ileJ to intiatlate. afly' ;11 Court
)itiqQ1:i--bn HeClrlnqs.)wHich reslAltect in contifll\eJ InIS-
feprltse.nto.tlons {}~ ArbA rledel Ruk '1.1 ~3~'Misfeprt-
s~l\t()t;ons may Qclcur by +l.\ilurt to act;) which LUUS
Ct Iso, another ,13l'euh of Du.ty uod '^ ~reech of Pro-
{eSSlono,( DLth eS.
~q, E v 01 thDl.tqh I i r1 formrJ DQv'l~ lv..tz that 1. w4nteJ
him to repre1ent my' htsf interats.ill Courttdl,4.ri00
H CCl.f': nqs- h tfore. iQ'f.ter he si.qneJ the. qu.az; COlltrac~
Ctqr'ttrr{ent urhich )e~ me. to ~tJJjeve tho.t h'G uJOL(ld tr~ly
r'ipres-ent my hst i nteiuts .lrL Court"'O,t Tried dL(t-
tD the wo~dl~q Of tht, CQY\tro.ct tor. re.pr:stnta.tion f~om
~h;lC\w tl rrnl,O f Al1Jlnot RO,vne~ he ~ontlnueJ to !cu I to
Jill.LLlil:;......JWyHL[Q..1uL.litillJn3s or Trial fepresentC\ilon
of my. Jlredivw-, ,In r'eqarJs to reprtsen~a.tlon O' m'f
best Interests: which "vendteJ In undh,cLdt-lW rO~1
e.Stnt((t;o~ Br-eec-n 0 fiduciary du.ty)C\nc{ Bru.c of
Contract,
J.()c Rt{er-rlnq huck to comme.nt lS) pursuant to my
reqyeslt -tor l~el representation hy a Co.r! OrdeSI
\.lJ,~1 be send i q SUbpOtflQ To A t'tend And. Represent
Complaint So 11 . David hLlt~uJhlch will re.~L{il( ~jm
to ClHea.r 1)1 the. Court of the Honorabk Ju.dge G-l.udll
on. JC\I1. Ll)~OOG,", pursl.{ant to thiS rlotion For Order To
Re..p resent PlaintIff And Complaint.
SilbmitteJ by. the. PlaIntiff
J'1 r. Dale 'Wi n ter me yef
Dt.c, 2~ZOOS
->
:c:,'~
c:C:)
0"
r"1
1~;\-1
"
",)
--.i
>--~
,,:)
'0
.-,
1:-n
1'\1r::
,7i'~:.}
: ('.:J
t-')
,;j
-:,'
C?
c~-: ",-.<.
0)
445-4541
921.2319
249-5338
243-2686
362.3132
533,7900
800 469-4663
i
J C Cobb Small Engine Repair
500 Stoner Dr Mlddletown---- 944-1197
Lawn Ornaments
SEE Garden Centers
Lawn & Garden Equip & Supplies
Statuary
Lawn Spraying
SEE Lawn Maintenance
Weed Control Service
Lawn Sprinklers & Sprinkling
Systems
SEE Irrigation Systems & Equip
Sprinklers-Garden & Lawn
Lawyer-Bar Associations
SEE Lawyers' Referral & Information Service
Lawyer Referral Service
SEE Lawyers' Referral & Information Service
(
JHLJ;,iH!
''''''j':'''',
. LA.WJ.rE1tS,:.. ': .)
"IO"!;,',:,'
A Mark Winter
310 W Chocolate Ave Hershey------- 533-4868
Abom John A
B south Hanover st Carllsle--------.. 249-0900
106 walnut St Harrlsburg---------- 232-9511
ABOM & KUTULAKIS
JOHN A. ABOM
(FORMER CUMBERLAND COUNTY
DISTRICT ATTORNEY)
JASON P. KUTULAKIS
(SOLICITOR DAUPHIN COUNTY
CHilDREN & YOUTH SERVICES)
. CRIMINAL DEFENSE
. FAMilY LAW
106 Walnut St Harrlsburg-....-..........232.9511
8 S Hanover 5t Carllsle....,-...--...-..249-Q900
Abom & Kutulakls
100 walnut St HarrlsbUrg.--------------- 232-9511
Abom & Kutulakls Carllsle-......-...-...-.-..232.9511
Abraham Law Offices
513 N 2 St Harrlsburg--------------------232-7825
Adler & Adler 125 locust 5t Harnsburg.-.... 234.3289
Ahmad Anser
servIng Harrisburg Area--------n----____ 909-4343
AHMAD & MIRIN
Serving Harrisburg Area..----------------909-4343
See IIIII' D/stIIIIv Ad ""tie 4J1J
Ahrens Thomas J
5521 Carlisle Pke Mechanlcsbrg...----697.1800
Alexander Jane M
14B S Baltimore Omsburg---..------- 452-4514
Allen Heath L 210 Walnut st Harrlsburg.--. 255.8011
Allen paul
4700 unton Deposit Rd SuIte 260
Harrlsburg.-----...-------------------651-0771
Alzamora John A
212 LOCUST ST Harrlsburg--------------- 255-7233
Anderson David C
3940 locust Ln HarrlSburg-------------...541-1194
Anderson Janice L
7105 Sliver Fox ct Hummelstown------566-0100
Andes samuel L 525 N 12 stlemovne.-......761.5361
Andrew W Barbin PC
123 State St HarrIsburg ----232-9200
Andrew's & Johnson
78 W Pomfret St carIl5Ie----...---._----..--243-0123
Andrlng WIlliam H
234 North North St Harrlsburg--------- 234-4728
CONTINUED NEXT COLUMN
LAWN-LAWYERS 407
LAWYERS
Angelo Peter G LaW Offices Of
2001 N North Front St HarriSburg- 232.1886
Angelos Peter 0
2001 N Front st Harr'sburg-~----23'2.18B6
ANGINO & ROVNER
Angino
-
& Rovner
SERVING CENTRAL PA
FOR OVER 70 YEARS
Recognized
Best Lawyers In Amarlca
Bar Register Of Preeminent Lawyers
Million Dollar Advocates Forum
AUTOMOBILE ACCIDENTS
MEDICAL MALPRACTICE
WORKPLACE INJURIES
PERSONAL INJURIES
FREE CONSULTATIONS
No RecovervlNo Fee
238-6791
(800) 648-2070
www.angino-rovner.com
4503 NORTH FRONT ST.
HARRISBURG, PA 1711 D
Anner Carolyn M
1300 Unglestown Rd Harrlsburg------238.2000
Anstine Timothy M
100 PIne st. Harrlsburg---......__._........- 221.1111
Aplcelll Samuel W
305 Front St N Harrlsburg----------.----- 237.5516
ArCher Thomas A HarrJsburg-------- 233-8676
Armstrong Patricia
212 locust st Harrlsburg----------- 255- 7627
Arosefl sarah W 305 N Front St Harrfsburg-2S5- n31
Art2 Charles I & Associates
207 State st HarrJSburg---..-..-------_. 238-9905
Aschlnger Jack F 212 Locust St Harrlsburg- 255-7609
Asmus Daniel G 212 locust st Harrisburg... 255-7624
CONTINUED NEXT PAGE
FIND IT HERE FIRST .. FAST.
r, .
t . :'i t' 11''':
.~'
,7,
PO~ROFATTORNEYANDFEEAGREEMENT
By SIGNn,G THIS AGREEMENT, I (WE) ACKNOWLEDGE THAT I (WE) HAVE ENGAGED THE LA W FI~LQJ'AJ'Gl]'!o _&. ROVNER,
P.e. (HEREINAITER A & R), TO REPRESENT ME (US) UNDER THE FOLLOWING TERMS AND CONDITIONS:
I. A & R may on my (our) behalf secure medical, work and other similar records, conduct an investigation, negotiate,
and if necessary start suit against anyone responsible for my (our) injuries and losses with respect to
MOTr)fDfe-le. Cl.CClaf",j- "1~ 1<./-01 ' with full power and authority to,appear on behalf of the
undersigned in any Court of record or in any administrative or other proceeding, to do and perform all and every act
and thing whatsoever that may be requisite and necessary to be done in connection with the above claim as fully as
the undersigned might or could do if personally present; hereby ratifYing and confirming all that said attorneys shall
lawfully do or cause to be done therein by virtUe of this power of attorney.
2. I (we) understand that so long as the case is handled by an A & R attorney, I (we) wilf not be responsible for any
fees and/or expenses unless a recovery or benefit is obtained,
3. If my (our) case is handled to a successful completion by an A & R attorney, I (we) agree to pay A & R all
reasonable out-of-pocket expenses without the payment of interest, plus a fee for time expended as follows:
loCZ
A&R ME (US)
a, SETTLEMENT PRIOR TO STARTING SUIT 30% 70%
b. SETTLEMENT FOLLOWING SUIT BUT PRIOR TO TRIAL OR
ARBITRATION 35% 65%
c. SETTLEMENT OR VERDICT AT TRIAL OR ARBITRATION, AFTER
TRIAL, ARBITRATION, OR APPEALS OR SHORTLY BEFORE
\ TRIAL AND AFTER CASE HAS BEEN TOT ALL Y PREPARED 40% 60%
d
d. IF NO-FAULT RECOVERY OR NON-MONETARY BENEFIT: RICHARD C. ANGlNO ($500); NEIL J. ROVNER ($450);
ASSOCIATES ($400) PER HOUR BUT NOT TO EXCEED 40% OF TOTAL RECOVERY OF VALUE OF BENEFIT
e. OTHER CASES
~~
~
4. If for any reason I (we) take my (our) case to another attorney or law firm including a fonner A & R attorney or
handle it myself (ourselves), I (we) recognize that A & R has, in good faith, expended money and time for my (our)
. benefit and 1 (we) therefore agree to pay, or have my (our) new attorney pay, immediately, upon severing the A & R
attorney/client relationship, all the out-of-pocket expenses incurred on my (our) case plus interest at the rate of 6%
per annum from the date of each expenditure. In addition, when the case is successfully concluded, I(we) agree to
payor to direct my (our) new allorney LO pay as a foc 20% ofthc gross recovery to A & R.
5. In the event that any settlement is made on a structured or deferred payment basis, A & R shall be entitled to receive
their percentage based on the present value of the structured settlement, if paid as a lump sum at the time of
settlement.
I (we) agree not to settle or discuss settlement of my (our) case without the written consent of A & R.
By SIGNING THIS AGREEMENT, THIS ~ DAY OF \\\vlf:...l. 20_, I (WE) ACKNOWLEDGE THAT I (WE) HAVE
READ, UNDERSTOOD, AND RECEIVED A COPY OF SAME AND ~ ITS TERMS AND CONDITIONS.
CLIENT(S):
x..tlr, h, Wint frmp~f.r
(SEAL)
(SEAL)
(OVER)
revised 2/00
t xh ; b ~ t 1
_To MIl, 'David liAt2
,
\,
}7 a. ( 2._
· 1 le,1 t.o Vrrz Iittl,.10
e.tte t whkhJ haVe retainr>J)Qf\J.
t A~I'JJ ~?OQ~)J:. wfote.j C~ If you
o r eJ' fJ\-Llef ore J/.niJ. MJLe.. re~~
re e t Geo rt<+o e or we-II e e Chp
the.n 1 want t have. Qnntbe .A<t- t rT\ cp \"' .
_Mc)).l Knew thCAt. iJwa~JJ llfhellft'cJal. tDJ~te.p_my
OI;j)n~.1 Ittiers to tOLL:otho:tlbavLJt'~~I.pLQ.l1..f
01 nOJlct q. MyJlfechve.;~Qr.JnY-i-UfJ;LOn~
sInce. ABA do d eLRiAit'..J.l-,~:irJb:
hy G C) ;e.l\ts dtc/sion C01lb..etl:' ft~H..
weat r to acce To. j tt ... L!a.l..u want
to r e.h1 i flJ you tL\tCg]m:t AJB CO C;G st e
"An o:ttorney, m\.tftlno.int()Jn~llmLcoJ1fiJinceJ' ellen..
'e tel". in '0.. e. .. cp.ct,relLtililUl}) Since. r've.
heen reaJiflj clkou.t corrtractj) I.wosjlaJ tD Jn~
OLd thut dreach oi eonkc . t 0 -
o.Y\C( OfrAl)t C01\tf(lC~uaL.o.blLa.Jl~YJhich mal syou
) e~ .I!~ iiablt to ~ piu>lJ.. r 'ft'ttentatian of tht contrnct
an'! the comp)uint i" Q Jur'y Tria~Qs y'OLt slAbmittevt
to He Co~rt by yO~f siqnatlitt. Acror<AUlj tD ABA .
tLWJ RlAle 8,~ C3~l1J i ffi' J' e re., e~
~ tJ' j' jOOtll tY1iJCOf\Jutt~l1L~lhc-_~11ill2l1ltr,r Of ma 1:-
VfQct\ce S\Aitsw~ichwC\rro.n. · 0. I' e. lX '-
wee b fco.ch oj' COl\tra.ct
~..~~ ~t W 0
\0 ~Pro -
'\
D. e.. 3
· *'np' :
.' . €rJ I I J
wit au e.ce.J'S r t: se..~j; r.G~ t;ll
.hMJ 0 I t e Supi r i lo,ollnte1LtJ III .w ~ LuU' He.
~femel1t~otjhe.._U, .. U . C
. eS cL~ 1 hopfulha ... m\;!
caLm is tlotJlstr1Lsse~J~e tQlnisrep,rcseah.tIQY)
. neq.l;3c:nc~ brfachof-t,J\Aciar~ Jutbbr-fQchDf
cof\ttlAcJ 111 (ff ect;VeCOUrlSt 1 or JLtt to ClfC\Uute..
~o uphotl. I e~al JiQbiltl7'~L~.l1ope th,t yC~QPPflC-
JoJ~thf..fAt that _IJuLJA.'fac/Y)xoLlof the
tact thafuI . stuJy JawwheOlt1rsL o,lkeJ .
10 uyo~UJh1chis why LJecfiJe!~() reJcdn fA
JawyerwhoworksnA t{ . comml~S'IQ.nPftcc:niQge.
hctsr S)be,Co.LLfe. 1 h:nowUClLltJS_Vtry har~'t
..Q IL~oJ'tlrQP!)SSLhle to tot_ce.a?lnJlvldu.oJ1-or
arl!I\ ,tL{ranc~ companX-Q__~l!Y. JlAJ'L!H; .corr:pe.n~
SatlonJt~e. ... Ire !Ar[ e.... . Losts: _of the.. J/ hqai: Ion
wh I chuQ lso S'lloul&__Loc-lude.pur1 ;iLvt _ Jan1Q~ e.S 1-
I j~lA i !(A i eJ-.J Clm ays,
Si n cere I v..'>
~!.__P_.__Wi~~~r~~~____ l
Exh'lbit Y
'"
...
,
Dear )'1,. ~ut-z-, April lGjiOO.1
,. , ,.t sh.rt{~ I'll( Oct. 1~)O.l IttteJ to 'yOl).
by wf I t I nib 'I ltst'('J'Jq~ CI.f-td.n001.,.oJ. .3.3 ~ 1 .lAtttllwteJ to
ltu.ch VOl}' ~r ~olAr.sLcr'(foJ~ b V ~hone b~t 1 LULlS not Q~le
to aOfq'lSIr\U ne,thtt at vou WtU ()(JuUIl\blt.Allth~L(3h 1
Was' tolr that 1 coulJ klAvrQ IY\ eSSctqt- on ~OUJ VQ I C(
l'f)ui~l chose 110t tv Jill sobecQUS{ Jl believe th14t It
IS best tD talK to Q ptfso~peI'SoMl\YJ QnJ thtlt written
cOfl~spon~Clf\a 'IS the btst VJctv to S~bstC\~tsjattmy
O~I(\}Ol'\S;'DI CtISD wrots"YoL( m~y aJvlSt Br-ICln Yount .th~t
l' will UCCfpt u ~~yme.l1t of ~b~),S fQr the. J/ol1.a.qa to
my motorcyc\tJQn~ th4 1 \iIl',1l LtlH kte.~ my mo'tor-
~vck..')I d\so wrDti)~tlf Bnf.\.fI YOlAnt wll\ rlot conc,eJe.
fJ mV qtntIO},lS. Off..ex'io. stt.tlfHus J,Qmo.qeJ. claim
thQt t ~rn W! Ilmq ~o Qccfp~),tho1 l u: dlUfftr' ,one:.
oUel' alterndl\/f lrlo\' to a. [{)\Al't A ~i:IOl'l. I:t Bna.Y1 ~
YOLlnt COon IDCa.tt-. Qr\othtr.,lq~3, H6n~C\ ShQID.'~ vnsoc
th<.tt loob as qooJ O,S I11lnedlJ. befHe. this Q.C(-
i ae~t o([~rre"lJhel1 I wi 1\ Q((.ept Rnoth,r .qWly.... 'I. .
JIJ).QJ Iq[3 Ho.~Aa...Shajow tv-stomas ~ tr<<Jf.,f~: I
MTrit.~' hIlt ncl()Sdu(o~o J~;A~lOO\
htier whlc nttome:.' ~tt~
. 0 . hat ..t hI' au wrot. HOt . ~~
1!.J'e. un~h.l.L.b r-tQch iCe( I eSO ' .
r Ctr- a . t .~ 'e\'. . . CLq,LLulimyvJul,cLctLffi.,t
, e j<.. Yo QXtb~unct hv your dhicaJ
1.\. V to ~r VI clY1c.with tfffctiIYf rerfese~tation
which IS- ~D h tolloUJ~J t0ro<<ql'~Y1t; I .Q ntccesJf.'ul
fecovf.lV IS ma~~ whch 'J~cceptQbk to ..m.sctnd
whl [~ t, hctVt u,qtuJ to pay you. +~r do;n~. BaseJ yn
~OUJ' wpttefl unAJ \/crb.al. rt:prts(t1tC(~lon~I ~Q& confi-
dfnu. 10 ~O\! that ~ou wOiAlJ be. ft:vretentlr1q m,t. in
ml h-e$t intfusts hy liti~L\tin~rny motorcycle dam-
! J)
I
Feb.!natinq I WDlllJ have SljneJ Gl Se.ttle.lYle.nt
A fument ~~ 1 J;~ rt0tSlj/' one. t h~ve. inclose& Q.
c~~'t '.f\.fAt. to.rney.. s. JIA,titSRoA IIC\~.i,litys Which.s.h.ow
that 1 mav rv. (. tOr co nS'equ.ent; cd Jet mil q ~Jj Uf\rt C 9vefea
lY\vn.efJrn;sffpr,(HnhtiD~')Brte(h of contr'dctjBfeec.h Of
D\.ltY~AJ,~Ht lcqo.lfftJ'thQtl mav have to \.lnJ~rtale.
in ro~JtrJo SlAtltil ideHedivcQttcrn\v.I. nQve myoJi~jnCl.l
ltttersiAnct m~ cDfI'ohofoJinq mctoCLtWHto:tllot\\ On \),hJ. 4ffer-
I\Qon.jApril the IOth...I. fctlA~nd ~QLtr ~hone call. 0 nce
o.q4;~Iwas toldth,,} Vo.u..were not 1~Q.ncl thcd YOiJ.. WOl(U
n~t be If\ on ,Th~rs. ,0 I"' 'Fri. titheI'. When I I.I.JKeJ your
phone. r tee pb Onlsrl f she wou.ld b. b. Cl/YI fJSQ~ e for
vou.tish 11,(ickly ha the voice mail'uorJinq Cl3C\irr. I
ta.~"1' ask hpe recordtt'S' leqal intOflYlQtiorr CU\~ L
Ji ~nlt retcdn C\1l. a.nswa'i~q inQchiht to rt~ftSertt lne..
buCl.u{e. thiV ~ri I nttf.f(tlIVt~ Q.nc~ theYfctil to froviJe.
i1'\t. wdh +h~ 11'1 fcrmClbon thct1 r WClTit ~oQbtQin. Since.
thtlt He. 10 uttnntKS' at A'i-R,)my call shoulJ bi iInm-
~!~';~ trwferreJ h qnother atlornty qnJ Q fe;l
t s 01'\. Oct. 30J:2.DO:" \/0\.\ se.nt.:th-e. Interro9Cltories to be
Tille~ O\AtjC\"~ yov i nst.r~ctcJ mt: to tdurn them to you
, \AJ iUin ,one. Wit\\. which L corn~lieJ wi th.After M<<ry
· G-C\ra.~.t..s tvpe~. rhtn~)She Stilt me. Q coPy 0 f her ,typed
Vt,SIO~') Qrf~ 4 copy WetS Stnt to. RanJ( Gnen. Tr1tre.
W(\()- pa~e.s CJ Kaf)\S t.y'pe~ vtfsion thLit wefe not
COl'lfct as r hQ~ sltbmitltt'~ thtrn,Ot ,rimC\,y import-
Qna WQj' item 55 t SociC\\ St.cl-ll'ity J1\l.mbt.f'.Sinct::t
hQv(.ln.t~,me~ YOIJ in writint Ctn~.vt,baly' about fr)Y I
hot wCll\tlnq to ~C\ve my fonfIJentll~\ 50C10.\ Senility
Btncfitr ft'umht.l' ~isclbJd fo ClnyonSl hq~ written
Q ~iJcl(\imtJ' on my or;~lna.t InterrOjL\tvrie. 4S I
rtCGtI~which did riot ClPlwlf on the. cop~ thCLt MaJY
~
p
S~l\t b me. Qf\~ h f'llr G,rttn.Jo since. I re:h;n the:.
~iqht Of. cli,tilt conJiJence) client (~nt;~entlality')ctn~
1 11o.v'L ~ht II qht, to ~Qve. my CD. mrrllm I ct\.t I OM cOlwcyeJ
in a. COff-ectJo.nJ ,protfSsrdna.\ mLtnnf.t, 1 :orfectc~
M.o.r.vs errors Of In C fftctly t'(pl'tStnle!lnfOT'.mQbnn.
I tH.l en. il\vokd m. 11eqQl ft. med" by Stn~. inq [ppks
of my corf'uJeJ po..qtf t~ Mr., Grterscl,llthdu4h I
w OL!.IJ'./lot.ho.V.t ha..~.t..if rlO]th't..lf ln~ 0 fljH\Q.lJrl\t-efr-
oq~iVfifsba.JbHn hp('c( correc~l QS':t h(t~.S~b-
liT I ttc~ thon. ~ 0 Cl lack' 0 f. prQfUJ' 0 ~I ism ,eH\,\\ IC L
mtb Clct ~lluckll,:/^I\J In -!!T b'ut I fiteresrSt r W(Ult
to .piCKLlp my. oriln(t! puge:. o.t the. In!erroJttflfit.
\V n f c h .1 s u brrf I tt t' to VOlA W hIe II h C\ S I h 11\ S Son Ii,
&. it.hef.. Il1Qi./it to, Int ,ot (.,11 )qn~ I"v~ ' ~t:f';(o~
o ' whtn I CC\r\ piCk. It \.(p J Vi- cdsQ I nfor
,'oDeo e.t t J' h t 1 wJo.-I: tl.l~ JosuC,.
isLe ro . otles Qn ; 0 ~Atter
~O\A hQ~,St(\t Me: youtJe.t ef' which is JlAteJ,FeV:.z~
'1001 which s-h.ta thli.t VOlA suufeJ my Ci.uthorl2.'lt,on I
t. oco!p1Y\IAY1t CLltt ~onr: Hunt thltt I ndvc provide!
VOU" WJJho.ld:hol'lrY,toac.cept Q propat:r JQmQ~t.
.set,tltmt,n! () f ~qlG. s~ 1:. Stl\t you. q 1 eHero0 311s1 OJ..
whIch; ~Irtcte& vou. to HfvUC thett Offtr, SlhU
~ ktter to tIt. Crlu:t1 ~i{()ot ft ri:te~
ill,: {wE,.) f . Jece. i.\..\ ~~l i rint;' q'l\ mi;-
ef r I IH 1\ os ,0 D Cl J' tr-e ' b
~~I~.l~tm~nt.tflc G-r~i7G.,SO /S J,tll
o ct ub [[sn't liA~ll..l~
~lflw~uIJ hfl.Vt Qqt'u~ to' Qccept thQt
~IY1VUl\tQt olAr mfeti~J inJFeb. 1 urn suJe. Hat vvu,
woulthavt s((li\re~ m/n autno'lz.eol Q(aptunawith
QI1J by mys't'Jnctht'coY\ C'{ settltll1ent l\~rf(mfl\t.
0#)
OlAr IAnJtrstL\nJinq tlnJ out ct~rler\1e~t \.UC\S o-nl still
js QS rJvt. eXr,rtf-sl.'J. it to 'u Initictll)QI1~Qs ot.(
hQVt r'epr-uer\tf& m1 intenti n to Stttl~ lY11. mob1c~cI{
JQ/1Wlt c1QI,m tLn~. We ~o CDurt. ~Ol{ fepfeS~t\te!
thaJ 11\ ~tl\ t Ion UI1 J t:S I fe, ,'f 1Y\ Y htS~ I nt tl't.Jts- in yv.u.t'
Se.pt, is lOOI /titer io 8r1Q~ You.nt ~ hlCh .sto.tes '.If Wf
aft una.b1ttQ UQch G\n cuy\ico.bk r'tso llAtiol1 wiB, rtjltfJ
toHe.prog-edy dllma,qe. clrdilbboth c/ClilYl5' will bt
. , tc 'It /lot AotloreJ hv y'1l~th<.\.t st<ttelY1'tl\t mq1
be c nJ't\'l-te! to ht tlfl act df m;sre~,estnta.tio~.I
apect VCIJ to)qncll want,yoLl. to follow _~hro~~hllJith
whoJ you hctve. rep/(Jtnte~ to me., 1 Jot\t thl'nk thr([,
I C\m ,expfctif\9 G\.nythif1j ~(nfe4JOnablt, Fom yo~ hv
e)(~-ectl nq YOlLtO~~hol~' you.rprottSSlohct[ Jit I e.S (an~
~ICl~ilit)'is, to obtQin a jLlcaJq:~lJy comp/ttet recovery
10 inybtst Inrertsts;)ClS 1 ho.Vt htuine~ y'o~ to do
~f (ct"VelV.lr\/):~rch lS'jlO.O~ ltHl'f to you 1 wrot
", Mr. Grtd) Wr 141~,,_~~(lf(~ ~Q 'I si~tl(rne":~
\.U Vt S e~ Inj\lX~ t <:1\ Lsldcl s:
· " +:IT ( 't l ~ ,._,l..C f'..~.j.. ~)
, (J I S I 0 C V 1:. . (,h l_~~ I ' 0 S.L.LJ[LlLJJ.&-1..~,l<l.L.h .
On Th\,\fS, N~\I. ~O\ 1. cuUrt.sse~ C\ It. te, t~ you..Dnce
fA G~i(\il txplcd nr~ U~ proplon oi n~t bejn~ ~h'( to. comm- i
LU'( I (ll-[e with C\ !tfsonb ohtrUI1 IHtOrora.t,on. I wrote
in thA,t Ic.tte~>, 1 hClLcul.\cA to tQlk ~o p(~Hy on TueJ',
LIft. 6uJ she \NUS nut o.vculll.blc..lo.qcun co-IIeJ bQct
h ask hersomr informe<tion C\t 3:lg't-3~30 Wd. Clfter-
l1oo~')'l-r l\/IWClfS,qe.t0\ r.~corJinF .t'veJ'j. c~r +fo,nt ~esk
hti"J'Qrl, It.rfsont tOOl JUiCe. 1 caf\)ifI 4nJwttS
r. . '/ tIt L ,)
fO m C\V (J ICe. lIIo.l s'v,s e.1Yb t JLtS, /i '\1 Vip. ~p my, .
tItter- toQLL\AL~Ii:hLJS Uk& Moflt0 rl . 0
WI' " or L Crr t ~L lno'
.p.r any a.motA lJaJl~~glS_fLm.y_m.Q.tQrcyd~
dl\mC!r-SClf\d thlAt Usa st('k~.lJJl.tl'Ci\1r~
Q~}/{ \ :~ockeLwnLte~ haVt him
f (tlfTC' t~rtH!\tlilY\t-l ClT1cL~_~~~
illls:w hidt may bt,neCfS,) f . Ide D ob ·
e. C e. silo ". l't.a S I will
. Qwa.i :Y,OUJ replt',) tn rnt OHf.f I n~ Idtef thQt I wrnte.
to Y,OU: Dn Aprd ~ I re.fe.rr('~ bucK to my MoJen I.~
~oo~l,ttterjQ(\~ 1 wrots"'t QJy\ QIJ'o cUffcti,~ you.
to rttlAJe. to (Acce~t 11r. GrtEnJ' Offtl.)) TheY\ 1
a.skd~C6HQve. VOlA. eXfCLtteJ my Jirective to rv\\,G-rw1
t Y\ thortmQJllI tr~)) I \AJ~\.d~ I j ~( an CU\SWtT to IY\V ql-lcst-
ion, withou.t txpe.fl,tY\cinq the. S&J)'\( I((c.k of. (~n\m\Al)i-
coJlot'l thi\t r e.xpe.f,ltI'\Ce. r.uhe.n I ca.ll, ~DUr off( ct~ I
o..lso wTott_/'.r.f. 8rlC\n YOlJ.1\t thtl\ dtce.'deJ to not
honarinls ftBrtSented.. sta.temel\t vf be.i~q willinqto
~Cly' Jillffi 0 + my /Ylotofevcle. JQMaqe~ He.n tfle. ke~tt\
i\t+initiDI1 ~ ' tniSleprtScntlltiol1is applictthk Qn~
invokable. a o.lnst BrlC!Yl Yount.>> Ccnsq\.ltnt'y,j I believe
thttt s.i 11 a " lA ar t 4WQfe. Of Bri OJl Younts m;,srepre.scnt-
~tl~n which t h~Vt, inclosd IX cOPL oft \1: am rC1}.H.Jt- ,
Inq {l.nJ rtcornmenJln~ thQt yo~ report ~'S une.thwd
coi\~\A.c.t to the. B~rJ in liqht of the. tact tho.t ram
ordy s-eekinq ltJ)8'lS tor th~ JQmb~tJ' t mv mfjtorcy'cI~
rtotf the. +ulf bock vul e. Of It C\ni}! no! as much QJ t)H.
Hcn~G\shop tstimctte! th J~m~:y-s to bt. I am ve.rL
we.1( ~l.Uo..re. 0+ the. fuct thQt it IS ihe. cl1tniS' deciJ;nn
o -t wNen to rdtk for (,\ ,eu~onC\b Ie. .Q;cepTuh Ie.
ftcOVttr,v a,moLlnt.By th; WQY)IY\ uJJltlon to sb,(Jyln~
]C\WJI! I{a,ve. QIS'o stu.Jiea. pfycholoqv which IS Cl .
V t r V, ~ 0 0 J Cl.. SSe. t to h a. Ve.l n lY\ V f-d, 1\/-b I w h (' n 0 th if s
wdnjlV, thinK thll.t I am ~pLr~ol\ thfAt thtV CQ~
tC\ke. io'Rv(;mtay~ Ol' ~Js to \,uhat ~
lLI)
[Sf
ClAmhITlanJ eDIAnt COl1rL_
~~~s
. ,0 - l ~l -
" l" .
, n
if IS,
_Joswe Sa!;I1ClS VCt~ehdani
~o..", l'iunL.J>lLlill1.L.. Answer To Frue.cipe. For
~,stln9 Co.se rOf ArqlA1Y)ent PursuC\nt To Motion To O)s/11is..r
For l:u c k Of Pl01~cuilon
1.. I hC\Vt previouslv. n:sp()n~e~ to this Lrn,(e 0+ o.tt-
em.1;in~ to c.ir:cu1Y1uen.'t or ~uash my Ie, qui Rfo' ht td liti~(,ltc
this 'CompJLUnt~-;,s-l,dt 'for comfp,en.fCAtor otamCtq~s~
p\Jr.s-LiCtnt t@ Plr)(ltiffrs Answer- I-\nd Rea ons FOrJlNhy
Comp,laint shou/fA Not Be D;.rrnisS'e~wh Ich I submitte'~
tD t~i.f Honorable Court pefsono.ly on Feh. l3 ~OO~OJ1J
1 also. m(.\jle~ 4 Copy. ot ~he a+oftlne,ntioneJ P141Y1t"{fS
Arsw~r to the Detet\~ nts a ttornev) Rand.y c, Greene 00
thCl.t Jate, r
~. I QIl1 i 1\vokinq OJIJ. o.vai I inq mysd+ of aJl ot my
l,al Rj~htS' pdrsuant tf) Me ~{,J. ton.rtitutivn dnJ
R ruan I to t~t Po"tcpnrtitutLon th'~l1jhout cmj Jut)nq
t e. J.t:n InQ d'SpOSl Ion an~ 1. fdcun the I'ey(d R/qht
1:9 tile- C\. JMotiorl For Re~reSf Of' G-rieVctnceJ -b.t Qrrv
t Ill, e. f
3,:r. bd;fVe. that It is the leqcd Jut\{ Of- Ct profe.cdinq
(Attorney to eroJec\Ale crlffi1ntAl 4ct;onS aM vlolat,005
anA Hlk complaInt is 0 CIvil Action,
Y. Soon CI.{ter mx o.~kl~ leh4nJ mv mptorctcle, were. dam-
Q,qe~ bV Oosu~ Sal,nas Vot'o..e~l.. tea~ Clfl oJ In the
pNone. b~ok+or leqcd represen,to.t/on hv the lenA) firm
bt: AnQ/no'flRilVnet Tho.t o.Jlllrt,semdntdatu' QnJ
rlp!erknts...)" No, R~CO\J~fY INo Fa.~
Y,slnce I waS In\~{feJ 'a.I1r.t I cOiAlcl f\ut: work Juc~ to
rny jnjlAfie{)IAT1J'I. JiJ /lot have. [(flY income)I JeceiJeJ
Po.~t- 2
Ya j (, 3
it j A ~ <j- v
Do.vid ~lAt a.n~ he I W firm thai I Qve contract
I.lIlihfor feprestntinq my c)uim 'for just Jue. com-
f,t(\s-altion.f-br rpy dcPmllqls an~ ifll~uri't~~~c I,eqally
I ,able. anJ Are d~ty hou~~ to l,fphoW. the +1<AUCIGt'~11
Ju.ty of l11o.inta.inihq. zcalous repreJentatibn Ot In ndf
anA ()t the. complQiFtt) \Anti II CI. s4cces-sp.d rebov ~y
hQS been obtaineJ .bt either D((IIIC~ ~~h. or by anotHer
lawyer of the: ^Ylj1flO't Rovner- lavJ fIrm ~L{rtuQnt to
our' sti II b i nJi nq centrad o.qrament for re.prefe~tatio'J
anA p~{r sl.\ant to' the. Com plaMt that ufos prep,art'c\ b
a. e.nts 0 the. lavJ ,rm 0' An 100"" RDvner,Accor i
~Ct hreac O' n r c an rea.ch 0 Id1uJJL
iJ,.,ul\'-.Q I f--- 0 A i sc i i n e I .W.L
he : '0 · e " ~SJJ!c!:~~ ~ .. iDLJ~ f;]Hts
s ~ S re(\.c ~ con rae-Jail r_fa.cl..of.tf-flC:'
-I. DC\vid hl.\t2 leJ me. to believe HlAt he. wcu.l~ he
fe~resentinq me an~ the comp)Q;,nt th(~t ht siqnd an~
rIA bmitte. Jin u Ju Tritl\ which h f( re1s-enteJ
~,t hus not I,\cte in ccor ance. to..1ili represent-
e ernanJor 0.. J(.(f TriaSABA f10del Rule Y.1 (3)
by 0.' l.\re. to act; is applico.hle QnJ relavGlr\t.
~, T ere.f~re.~I absolve mv-relt frollljqnJ I h~feby
J.I,fQVOW fY\X elf; 0+ o.n~ ()11~ cdl culp~ble fltql,qtrke.-S
rnlJfeprese" at,onf,brrtch o+.. EfOre.ss-I()I\QI JLttyf,\
hreeches 0+ ABA RUTes of. COI1~uct anol Of o.,~y. bteQches-
Of CanonS- CoAes whic'h C\re. tht. '('ged lIalfi IitYJ Of
OuJ foS () W s
Otll of the JlAtyS ClctlonJjneqliqence~un~rote.[JiollC\1
. c{Jn~urt~i"o.ctidl'\~ leYld profft{urt~QIlJ k,q I +ilinqJ'
· which (Are. conJuctcR unO. uyw.edaken hy tHe la'wytr-Js
i Ctn~s-tQ+t th",t work oS o'AeV\ts of- H~t law f,i'rm,
. q.AlIthw'qh .I o.m the. iX' ur~ .~enon, I no.ve. no't yet
, he,en ~rdyl&et with ~n trurt+Lt\,1e(l~iclol r-e~r'eser\t-
i aT/on which h s, cOt\bn ~Gl to .Su ~eci ,t to IAfaLl~
monc1lary har~;'h,~s (,\j\~ ~' nUJTan~ ~Jl)O lonal JlstftSS,
i Q.. .t.h. 1. have.nqfereu\. Q los-~ 0+ Jncomsaoc I ha.G\
V.i pOty -tor Jhe. tfcunaqe. repcursJ ot my motorc-yc/e..
10,.I't Y5' sta.te L{r'\Jcr n!. statement Of The. Cas.t:./r6ce~-
lAra. I History in the notion To Di-tffiISJ' For' Failure. To
,! ProJecut~c"Plqif1tlff Dede. WinterlYleyer +iltJ ~ CO/Ylpl(dflt
U,ritlst De.fen~a.nt Josue Sa.)'04r V6.!L\fZ..:> in tAc. court
I 0 ,co1Y1mon Ple~s of ~\All1ber)anJ c~Ltntv 01'1 ~Jept. ':vioO,
LV Ich IS an IAntrUt mlJ're,pftsefltatlon.I bel,eve tho..T
1-ra~aJI~;nq'l'tmj'ffepreSe,f\taticn art, all e~~l\IIV, i Iltqa!,ABA
flo~tjl lile~. Y D. .states th(j:t",CG It IS p/'Otfs1/of\!llin,r-
concl,u.c : i, To \liD la.le. Ht. ~u I~s of Profe SS/llf1lAt COI1Jl.tct;
3., EOjllqlnj in &jshDnestYjt.-ra~a)Jecejtof m;sfepreS'el\t~-
bon. I-f ~ql1Jt C-reen woi/IJ 0~Lle checkecl HI:: Pf~t~~nlt-
o.'r~S ddcketecofJ a I J,ct, ht WtOI.(I~ have VtT,;eJ
thdt v'J klA · e n SU · lof
, s r f ' , i.1lL
oJ \ef 0 'e. ''\- e Ther-etofs
I ~n ru. e .ulL Ie a. Ija i/it sa ac ions tor GInA of
thiJ' complalflf to . avid k~t2 nd to the laUl firm 0+
An~lno't-. Rovner-') ElI.r-Sl.(cmt to the. siill binJjf1 cont,mct
G\ -tee/Y1ent or representation that 1 waf 0 eted\.
Ouv;til l z re.t o-cte is rep e.fen at; ~Rana Green
.
.s 0. r e
with.oLt! procrastInation Of \AnfeasOnctbl~ }elqy,.flntcet
RCln'J~ G-,un was aware of 'the Complain!; tuJMicn S AA eJ
lY\()ntra.ty {\/noLlJlts-fof t' ~st due. coMpenso.. Ion Randy
G-reen shb\Al~ not have. . o.lIeJ to se.nJ '^ JdfPtmetvt
PfDfoSQI to me. ABA M del Rule. 1.3 Diliqcnce. requireS'
thil. there. is to be..) i. ZealoUS' repres-entoJltYll of the
cl;el'\t)o.fl& z. No procrastinaTion or- unr!"aSDn 6 e. delay.
It Lr 0. lo.vJve.rr dut,y to IApholo.. the kawYtfJ PleJ,qe. Of
PfrD '~sri.onCllllrm llJ~lcM, Jltate~)('I will resolve. /'()at1t~rtl
-eX e&it,ous)y o.~a Wltnout unntcerSal'l t'x~enJ'JJlaf)G\
{,~ will h~ndr the spirit anJ intcr'\t Q.s! wefl QS Tfie.
re~\Al~tlne(\ts oJ th; Cf p~)ico11e. RlAl~} of Code at Pro-
+e!Jlonal conauct.!> In iijht of. the. fact tho.t Rar\Jy
lJ.r-een has -sri II neqlecteJ to rend meczfe.ttlonent Pro-
POHtG Canon Direct Rulc. G-IOI (pJ{J) siatesJAn o.ttorlHY
ma~ not act in a. IItjllqent maTlrler~
11, On }1~,ch IS ,~OO~ T }Stf\! ,Q C,ertitie~ )e.tter-to Ri1fl&Y
G-ree.n, In re.q,~(clJ' ~li th.IIS l/t;go.tlon dnJ JlsLo\JerY)LOhlc~
\AJas met wfth Jel,bera.!e. ;ncA~f1er-e()ceo.nJ 00 rep'lv.Aqt.dn
I will cIte. ABA ~1oJel RlAlc. Y. c3.t~ffLfreprtJeI\Ho.tj~1\J
/no.'1 pCClA.f ~~ jlAilure to acT?) Ulmch mIL alyo be.
co.l!eGt CIA. po.lile. neqliCjt(\c(.~er s-ha be. t.)(hlhitL
13,0 n Dec, 1~,/ooY 11 r-kc(:iveJ <:\ e.t er -from RlAsse II
Johnso~)\,tJho is, q );tiqation reprefert!ltive. 0+' the..
H G\rttor~ Omnl ,nsur-tince (0. whIch IS JuteJ Dec.
.~~~ 1.0Dij., Mr Johnson wrot~ Dea.r Hr. D. Wi(\ter{Y)~ver-: Please
b~~ QJv/J'('c t},<<f I o.m the. new o.J'llAJtfr hanJII/~q th,s
lo\.ss, Al( +lAt~rc. co{reJponae~cie.~~~qntinq Hir "tl~im
Sf\DuIJ bd d,r~ctecJ.. to my at ~nt/011. Onc.e. cxqcun In an
~~f.~rt to initiate. aisco~e\~'l~nJ In an o.ttbnpt to .
IrlittaTe. Cl sdtlemtntJI mQl'ttcX 0. reply to fir, JohnJon. III
e.
I su p1it e 0. CQfY Of mv kiter into t {. Doc et
~ (Cord. ~ i Ie. Alltho~~'h 1 rho.i bl Cl Sl,d1Roe.no. To ProJl.I.cc
Domme./'lts Or Thi n :.r- to Mr. Russe.l I ~ohnson whlch
is (A c.O\,u..t Or ex', 0 reply to ,my lttter)whic-h hits
been slqneJ un ~Qte& hy C\Artls R. ~on, ory dJ..8Jo~
tho. t coiArt Or er<l- S~bp'deno. We.fe. both a.~Qj() m e.t
with Je.I;bero. e in&'fftrtnce.:;hy no rep from
R\.~sse.ll Johnson.
I Y. Tht:. Cou~t Docket record. does. s~ouJ Hot ther,e., ~C\S
b~e.n contI0~(e~ fntrys anJ uct/vdy Of tht Id'Jl\-
riJJf\ 0 f thIS cusc,
lS, U,S. constitLtt/D1tll Amwclrne.nt 1 stoJer H,tu.ln
Suits oJ C'o'/YH'110n QLV Wntrt the. volue ill controver7
~t1Cdl e)(cte~twtllfy dollurs",He Rjqht Of tried b
. \l(rV shaJl 0 e rfts'trvct J
I'C. rill ) i q,h.t Of 'tht u+o~elr1ef1tj()neJ {Q.ct:, this C0fY1l1ialllt
shoul A nflt h-e.. ~i.smjJ-t~c;\ for the. 10. tk o~ proJ'e.cJtlo[0
If heftaS the ,}{" rr:oX'7t lSSl.l t of concern JiJ' ct c:oil~cbnq
.l1l...1Jill .for the J iA. t JLte compenS'abon +0, the. dafn{qcS'
thall wde. CctuJe~ to "HI very rGlre mctJrc~dtjI cds'o
uJClnt to bt reimburse! lor c0rise~l.t(t1tiq l da.rlw.qes 4110\
t~f. f\A.~Urc: J,uma.,q,tS' U)tn~h shall inc/t.ule ill (~,S'ts Of
I j t,3utJn~ th IS &ISposlt1on. .
~;l.(1h11 tte! hy th~ Plaintiff on
r~/;)Jlos J1t-. Do. Ie tJilltenMyer
~?
._" co
,->
c:~)
if;
a
}'+'I
,.:-)
r',)
-..J
-)
>il
-~
;;~:;~
, ,
'"1'1
f~)
(:,
-~
)
:'1
"':,.
~'5~
-;-~
... w JwA' 100I
LAVIN JlOlfllRS
. 1PtACl! C81TRE, ,
, lea AndS~Mce For
'" Boy, RY~;',& Ryobi
.""CImIlHIR 761.1617
lAWIlI CARDEN TRACTORS-
SALES & SERVICE
uYWION
IlROS J(1JBOTA R~ 7 Lebanon
,... 800363.2767
445.4541
921.2319
249.5338
243.2686
-896.3414
I
362-3132
533.7900
. ~ MOWBRs:::s1IARPEN &:
,,"<"'\~'REPA1R' .
,.'>.1'-".":;' ."e".
.,
Mower Repair Service
ArIentown Blvd Harrlsburg--.---....540-9272
!urns Small Engine Service
C!ttVSlXIrO I?CI (lower Allen SnOPl}lng
'JDmpHJII---.-.737.8648
'&mIll Engine Repair
Ban Lake Rd Ettel"S--------938-6463
I LAWN SERVICE INC
MOWER ~ \.. R~
:j ~~~'R g
Makes & Models. Blade Sharpening
E1lowers.Trlmmers.Snowblowers.Chainsaw
lip And Delivery Available
rlQ-lafld.scape Maintenance-Tanbark
'Bl & Senior Citizen Discounts
C:ett\'Sburg.O MetlJanJcsburg -- 761.7975
MObile Mower Service
U>CUSl Way DJIIsburg-----_....._. 432.0912
ROEBUCK AND CO
leWis R~ Han1sburg
Fre. .800 469,4663
Mower SVc
!<mJlburg Mlddletown--...--.._.. 944.9839
I !eQUipment Maintenance
RI~g..~ DJIIsburg---.-..._..432.4374
-'-'~lHE. YELLOW BOOK WAY.
Exh',b';t J\
. . LAWNMO
'~~'i':;';r~;J'~
J C CObb Small Engine Repair
500 stoner Dr Mlddletown-------- 944-1197
Lawn Ornaments
SEE Garden Centers
Lawn & Garden l<~quip & Supplies
Statuary
Lawn Spraying
SEE Lawn Maintenance
Weed Control Service
Lawn Sprinklers & Sprinkling
Systems
SEE Irrigation Systems & Equip
Sprinklers-Garden & Lawn
Lawyer-Bar Associations
SEE Lawyers' Referral & Information Service
Lawyer Referral Service
SEE Lawyers' Referral & Information Service
Qi111!!1mmw-~~:I!:,f::i}i!1' ...;,.@
A Mark Winter
310 W ChOcolate Ave HerslWv------ 533-4868
Abom John A
8 South Hanover St Carllsle---.----- 249-0900
106 Walnut St Harrlsburg-.-.----.-- 232-9511
ABOM & KUTULAKIS
JOHN A. ABOM
(FORMER CUMBERLAND COUNTY
DISTRICT ATTORNEY)
JASON P. KUTULAKIS
(SOLICITOR DAUPHIN COUNTY
CHILDREN & YOUTH SERVICES)
. CRIMINAL OEFENSE
. FAMILY LAW
106 Walnut St Harrlsburg.--..._.._--. 232-9511
B S Hanover st Carlisle.. -------.--...-249-0900
Abom & Kutulakls
106 Walnut St Harrlsburg..----...--...---_-- 232-9511
Abom & Kutulakls Carllsle......-.-.-.-.-.....232.9511
Abraham law Offices
513 N 2 st HarrlsbUrg.-----..---.-.---.----232-7825
Adler & Adler 125 locuS! 5t HarrlSburg.-.... 234.3289
Ahmad Anser
serving Harrisburg Area---.-.---------.--.._ 909.4343
AHMAD & MIRIN
SelVlng Harrisburg Area-------.-..----..909.4343
see_'II./llllrIfJlPIIIIB.oO
Ahrens Thomas J
5521 Carlisle Pke Mechanlcsbrg...--.--.697-1800
Alexander Jane M
148 S Baltimore olllsburg------.---432-4514
Allen Heath l210 walnut St Harrlsbur9...... 255.8011
Allen Paul
4700 UnIon Deposit Rd Suite 260
Harrlsburg--..------------..--...___._651_0771
Alzamora John A
212 LOCUST ST Harrlsburg---.-----.----.. 255-7233
Anderson DaVid C
3940 locust In Harrlsburg-.----------.---541-1194
Anderson Janice l
7105 Silver Fox Ct HummeJstown.------.-566.0100
Andes Samuell 52S N 12 st lemovn'.-.-...761.5361
Andrew W Barbin PC
123 State St Harrisburg--_____.______._____. 232-9200
Andrew's & Johnson
78 W Pomfret St carllsle----------...----....--243.0123
Andrlng William H
234 North North St Harrlsburg-----...--. 234-4728
CONTINUED NEXT COLUMN
LAWN-LAWYERS 407
LAWYERS
Angelo peter G Law Offices Of
2001 N North Front StHarrlsburg--232.1886
AngelOS Peter G
2001 N Front st HarrlSburg.----.232.1886
ANGINO & ROVNER
Angino
-
& Rovner
~
SERVING CENTRAL PA
FOR OVER 70 YEARS
Recognized
Best Lawyers In America
Bar Register Of Preeminent Lawyers
Million Dollar Advocates Forum
AUTOMOBILE ACCIDENTS
MEDICAL MALPRACTICE
WORKPLACE INJURIES
PERSONAL INJURIES
FREE CONSULTATIONS
No Recovery/No Fee
238-6791
(800) 648-2070
www.angino-rovner.com
4503 NORTH FRONT ST.
HARRISBURG. PA 17110
Anner carolvn M
1300 llnglestown Rd Harrlsburg-___ 238.2000
Anstine Timothy M
100 Pine St. Harrlsburg...--....-------._ 221-1111
Aplcelll Samuel W
305 Front st N Harrlsburg-------....----237.S516
Archer Thomas A HarrJSburg.----.-.-------- 233.8676
Armstrong Patricia
212 locust St Harrlsburg.-----------.-255.7627
Arosell Sarah W 305 N Front St Harrisburg-25S. 7231
Artz Charles I & AssOciates
207 State St Harrlsburg-------..____...__ 238.9905
Aschlnger Jack F 212 locust St HarriSburg. 255.7609
Asmus Daniel G 212 Locust st Harrlsburg.-- 255.7624
CONTINUED NEXT PAGE
FIND IT HERE FIRST .- fAST.
\
Ex:t~i hit
1.
To J\r. Ran&~ c. Greent Murch 151~oo~
I Qm LUlltinq In rcqQl'ds to our-
n'W.t~Q\ ,litlQ,\ltioYl Ji.r~osit,on.l ho.ve reta!~cJ I\\". Duvi~ huh
c.} !\nqino'l--\\ovnel~}O fepresfl\t lfIV best I r\terests)\Uhi c.h I
hAve. e~eressc& to t1'r. kllh.l hC\v( r((ent'~ received C\
letter Jro~ 1"Ir. ~\,(t~~hich is clatcJ Mqtch IJ~OOJ.,~f.
\"'v.t1 Has ir\folrnd lYit 11\ th~t ItHcr th~t 1 nllv( prO\lldeA
him with the LltAthority to Qcu~t youX' property dCHna~e .
s, ,ttltffient o~fef of ~ \~ G. 50"anJ tk,t \, (0 m"~n i "t,J. th, t
settleMent 0 ,fer to vou. ThQ.! Off,er I.Ln.ut. (,t((evtQbl~to me.
1. hllVe. Mt Iqt\eJ 0..11./'1 ~npelS W~I(h sio.t( that 1 wl\l
Cl,curt tho.1: ~f\'\ou.t\t.1:+ O,n\j checks nre. SCrll to jnt f~r thCl.t
oi.lncu,nt I will nat siqh itj"t- it will btrt1l,(rr\fLtT~o:t '
, vdY\Gu.n.fwlll GI\IH (.0\1& t~( feplC\cemcnt )ab~f ,~Of ml{ fafe
'1lotof(~"ck./),.lltH~l{ h thert weft other parts tK~t w&e
da.mu c[ 01'\ It 6\ 1'\1\ .s~\i(\Cl5',I h!Wt ctl'so in ofmeJ Mr.
~N th"lt I Cl.m not o.cceV Inq \four 0 ~Cf. h~Vt WI' Hen In
m~ mOST reunt letter to DC\vJicU klAt~~ .t t\1YI cUri'(ti~ ~ou.
to act in,Df(or&ana to my, best if\Hlt'~tr anJ, as m'
fepr-eserd:,tlve of mt heft Ifd(ftst~)~ il'ltCrffitnq M ,
C'-\"u:n tht\t 1 \,vi It not Cl(apt hIS most lrrent ~ffer ~+
11 n~. SO.,'DI thrn QISf; wrote to Mr. h~t~"I ~\m cIlro &ifrct-
i0~ you. TIl re;fufe. to Q (( ept Mr. preens Offel'.:l~ 1 WOI.\'~
ll~e. to Kno\,u 'f: 10U. na,vc: hQ~ corles of, my, meJlcal rnords
O{ the. O,rtho~eJlc Inst,tLttt of ~C\,+UJ01she<t to lOU bZ thClt
~hter~rlj'Sor by (u\yont ro~ the- IQw firm Of ~n il\~l-Ro\lnef.
.Lf ~hQt, h~J' o(c~rreJ{J plc(,\Jt Inf.orm me. Of. the I J ntlty oJ
tht 'I1Alvl~l.\L\ls who nctve. proviJeJ you with ml. mdic1cd
fUOI'J-SO,nJ Of the f\U1l1e. Of He. flfm Vf Cltsin tJT enterpriJ (
WhIch that persofjor persons work's {o:f'. n~nk you..
:s In(€tdy~
,..., Mr. D. \Vintenneyel' I
1406 Ctrllsle Rd.
CamI\ Rill, FA 17011
"
: Letter to R(\(\d Greent.
ReInQ,\le~ en TI,(e.S. A ri\ d... D:J...
CAMP HILL POST OFFICE
CAMP HILL, Pennsylvania
170113717
04/02/2002 (717)737-1461 03:04:06 PM
Sales ReceiPt
Sale Unit
Qty Price
Product
Descr i pt I on
Final
Price
PHILADELPHIA PA 19103
Flrst-Class
Return Receipt
Certified
Lebel Serial #:
Customer Postege .
Subtotal:
$0.34
$1. 50
$2.10
70011940000587089171
-$0.34
$3.60
Issue PVI: $3.60
Total:
$3.60
Paid by:
Cash
Change Due:
$4.00
-$0.40
BIII#; 1000400650304
Clerk; 06
Refunds only per OMM P014
- Thank you for your business -
Customer Copy
U.S. Postal Service
CERTIFIED MAIL RECEIPT
(Domestic Mail Only: No Insurance Coverage ProvIded)
.-'l
r'-
""
IT"
'"
CJ
r'-
'"
Postage $
$0.34
Cert\ffedFee
Return Recelpt Fee
{En<Iorsemerotflequl1'ed)
Restrlcted Denvery Fee
(Endorsement, Required)
o Total PQstage & Fee8
:!'
IT"
"".
U"J
CJ
. CJ
CJ
""
CJ
CJ
,.<;- f"-
$
entTof -
..m.._J:1t....RQll~.._C.....G.L:r;.CJ1~.._.._....,........._.._m......
st_t, Apt. No.; QI"I S '+-- 0
~_~.~~~J~.a .EK.illlIJl":::__Ull.L.lY.D: .__......,..
CIty, State, ZlP+ 4 ,
'II
;.,.~
Exh ;h;t 1.
. , '
..JU' (AJ ilL J ohn.scl1: H c\ iled ciuJJill..3..La.s.._'_._.
., . ~ am ;rep)y~ in ffjofclLto He ___
...lrl.kf:th.J yo Ll h IlV e. c\ d...dli j'.Lb /lJ e. w.l1ktLLJ~__
-..(k if ( , " D e L~1 ~ 00 LITkUJ~rt i CUIU__1.fLJnVSllLLi1Llul.nst
JO l\T ) J\l)\ If Cj J O.N: ~[Sl\ Ii nC\S Vn IJ t ~. -,A} IthoHfjh ,cr(, hClv't
l'~t' ","'ec( In your Jdt" Hot 1 ",OI.lIe\ cn}( v," In
telCH-oCr to -c:hiJ iflC[ttt'~)l helVe clde.,{f);ntL~ HClt In
o ef to yrotect Trl}, re~l Rlqhts so thoJ I 'maY
re..tcdn doclA.ll)tnte roo' 0 '11l COIn unicC\t,onslto
~'I ~QrtjtS..llncl"i; ~, t < t~erl.n~, co.nty co,rt
..L vJill cor1TIOU-t to f,{ISC\ASS thIs penalnq SlA~t bl
WIAV 0+ wriite.f) co mml.<n ico.t ions. sinc't comYlAte.rs ufe
o.qlcdntrt 4P:Y tthnlc re.ll~io\.u he.\!e..tS,J I Jo not comm-
lA1T\elAtt b/, E mall.., nor comjutets be.cau.J'f corn-
J.iAters mo:.V b-e. )JrOA,rCl.lY\ J to li~')?J' they ~o.Thtr~-
Ole.,) 0 1m conrlnu( to CO/n/n/;H11 cate.. WI th IYI t In
e.qOtrJs ~o HIls 1nC4.ner in the st-\mr: manner C(S ,voLtf
rtc>'tnt lttter to me. Sjna you (He. novJ the most
recent clcdms ~J\L{Sr(f Cl.nJ lit;'qC4.tion re.pre..sentit-
ive. tor this le.10l'1 Jispositjo~I' ~oulJ Yike. tD
ct,r k XOVt. 0.. ft\.U .~u(J'tionJ. Do YVlA, have. 0\ cavy Pi
mv Com'P)ql~i Suit wh.ich has' been fIled in! th
Cuf/l')berlfAnA COLH1t~ COlAdhOIASf in carlislS Pq. which
is still (0 in .: ~o..V( ,ou been ' rovl~cJ wit .C\n~
i clu inq the. X ro.ys OJ my hroKtn Ie in~lArles
which wiYfe. cUlueJ by JOStUl So.\lnas Va. Jcz J Art
tov.. Cl bona. flJe. lC\.wv.el~ If ~ou.. ate Ct bo(\(\ .f; e.
!",w er ctre. lOIA C\~thor'j2eJ Q.n~ Ie cdl permitted to
II ii ;~te. HiJ' leqo.l Jisposition ~th;~) al1J or throuqh
the venLle. 0+ thi clAmberla.l)~ COlAn~t CVllft~Ful tel
to asK me a~y ~u.estJonJ thfAt .you. IT)C\ hlA.ve. toS o.n~ 1.
tV i JI IAnJlAler tHe.m /AS yroficicntry as. GIll) o.ble. to,
Slnctre:lYJ
Mr. D. Wintermeyer
1406 Carlisle Rd.
Camp Hill, PA 17011
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOSEU SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
01-5417 CIVIL TERM
IN RE: CASE STRICKEN FROM TRIAL LIST
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW. this 27th day of December, 2005, upon
consideration of the call of the civil trial list in the
above-captioned matter, and neither party nor counsel having
appeared at the call of the civil list, but it appearing that
this matter was listed by direction of the Court on December 1,
2005, the case will not be stricken from the trial list, and
further action, if any, by the Court is deferred to the pretrial
conference.
By the Court,
J.
~le
1406
Camp
Wintermeyer
Carlisle Road
Hill, PA 17011
,BAndy C, Greene, Esquire \
~880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard
14th Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19103
For Defendant
Court Administrator
:mae
<'.::
~?
';-.:~,
t;2~\
'..\,;-"'::.
C)'(-,'
.1.,"
t:i~L:,,-
~~~:~
1"':
D_
C')
r;:T"
~:~::>
.,
C'..J
c..
CJ"
{,'.J
<,,)
u..J
Q
,,.,,
(:".:'J
C:~.:)
<-'
')
()
~~~::~nt~~~"rt
, t
vs.
Josue. .\llI1nllJ' Valdtz:-Detendani.
PROOF OF SERVICE
I, tlL..-D, W~~r~If.;; , hereby certify that
I have this ~ day of ' C 4:1 , a.OOS , served
the foregoing document(s), .M.poe.na~uct' DOClHY'l{'nt\' Or
. · , pursuant to ~
, upon the Person(s)~
Service by First-Class Mail to:
"'>
':~:;:~
c...;'\
C:::J
r\-~
C'
CJ
-'n
.-'
(,.)
C)
"'>lPf
i:.c.:
CJ
'~if~
net
c..)
(...-")
v)
CQMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTYOF CIANIlERlAN.Q..
-1Jr. D. Wi OtfPy\fy,rr'- e.Ja1ntitf
~rs. J
JoSur Snlinns VnJdr . - J)efell. qn+
Pleas
TO: l1.L-Oavld
SUBPOENATOATTENDAND I(EPRESiNT f'Ot1PLArNT
b1Ltz- Attorl1e~ouJ firm of Anj1no1Rovntt
1. You are ordered by the court to come to ikJIonofClble JIAd:1r Gl.IiJoJ' Courtroom
in thil' tar IlIj r' COlAft),oUSt'
(Specify courtrofm or other place)
,LlAl'i'lber-lal"lo. County, Pennsylvania, on Jan. ~ ,100(,'
at~f \cheJl.Il..e.r.Ltime ,to ~IJ \Jour ,worn oath and...dIAtie.r
t . "e" Iv) 'e ·
'I-
e.
2.
l
If you fail to attend or to produce the documents or things re uired by this sub oena, you may be subject to
the sanctions authorized'by Rule 234.5 of the Pennsylvania Ruies of Civil Procedure, including but not
limited to costs, attorney fees and imprisonment.
Date:
A!<.t m.. ~.. , J. 7. ;ltV!
Seai of the Court
Deputy
Official Note: This form of subpoena shall be used whenever a subpoena is issuable, including hearings in
connection with depositions and before arbitrators, masters, commissioners, etc. in compliance with Pa. R. C.
P. No. 234.1. If a subpoena for a production of documents, records or things Is desired, complete paragraph
~ .
(Elf. 7/97)
()
c
r--'
C_~)
c:::"!
<:,,;'1
CJ
fi-"\
n
G)
o
()
-n
-..:1
(..:"l~
~--', \;'~"
I
,
-(',\
(,.)
c.)
~"~
vs.
Cum b.c.d.Md Count y COUl't
Of Common I?1I'A.,J
_JOSIAt Slllinas \/aIJe.z-DejtnQllnt
PROOF OF SERVICE
I have
. hereby certify that
, J OOS, served
e e
Hi' '/ :+.fr,"Tlnn
, pursuant to ~
, upon the Person(s) an,l or
S.N;'. b, F;,,,-CI.,, M." to'~n~T.
~::-~;
C::::.J
~;-)
CJ
, .
C")
CJ
o
-0
(,-"'>
C')
'::)
'n
.--1
-r
hi~
r-'
C:'
,
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
JOSEU SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
NO. 01-5417 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 4th day of January, :200~, we have
explained to the Plaintiff that the issue with ~egard to
representation of him by the Angino law firm ha$ previously
been settled by order of Judge Hoffer. We will not
readdress that issue in this case.
We have further advised the Plaintiff that he has
three options facing him at the current time:
1. Obtain new counsel to represent him.
2. Represent himself.
3. Accept the policy limits that hav$ been
tendered by the Defendant to settle this case.
We advise Plaintiff to seek other counsel
immediately to at least review this matter on his behalf.
We have further advised Plaintiff that this ~atter is to be
relisted by the Prothonotary for the next civil term which
occurs during the week of March 13, 2006. The Prothonotary
is directed to relist
this mattel>~i"-_that term of Court.
/..-'" "'-
. \
~/
Edward E. Guido, J.
.~
~CV~
~ rY;:. C~
L/ Ole
~.
I'\.D
'L)
Z~; :E 1:d
('\ - f JI"f' frJ.J"7
:; 1.1 ;"\,;
At.fi/J~.ii'
:':'. ~ i
.....,......
1'-\
:JU
~
Dale Wintermeyer
Pro Se
Randy C. Green. Esquire
For the Defendant
Court Administrator
:lfh
.
DALE WINTERMEYER
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA
V.
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ
: NO. 2001 - 54] 7 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 3RD day of JANUARY, 2006, it appearing to the court that
Plaintiffs former counsel David Lutz, Esquire, was granted pf,rmission to withdraw his
appearance by the Honorable George E. Hoffer after adequate notice to Plaintiff,
Plaintiffs current "Motion for Order to Represent Plaintiff and Complaint Pursuant to
Quasi Contract Agreement for Trial Representation" is DENIED.
Edward E. Guido, J.
Dale Wintermeyer
] 406 Carlis]e Road
Camp Hill, Pa. 170 II
4~
~ v,'d Lut:z. lst91A./IZi..
~
/YM..~
I_/'~ O{..
9~
, !
/d_"",
6S :G
^ 'I' 'f 'n' Z
t)- '" l,;1
!.i! JrJ'..
15465801032006
PYS510
Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office
Civil Case Print
Page
1
. ~
2001-05417 WINTERMEYER DALE (vs) SALINAS-VALDEZ JOSUE
,-
Ref'erence No. . :
Ca~e Type.....: COMPLAINT
Judgment. ..... .00
Judge Assigned: HOFFER GEORGE E PJ
Disposed Desc. :
------------ Case Comments -------------
Filed....,... :
Time,. . . , . ." :
Execution Date
Jury Trial. . , .
Disposed Date.
Higher Crt 1.:
Higher Crt 2.:
9/17 /2001
3:27
0/00/0000
0/00/0000
****************************************************,****************************
General Index Attorney Info
PLAINTIFF
WINTERMEYER DALE
CAMP HILL PA
SALINAS-VALDEZ JOSUE
7004 PETERS CREEK ROAD
NO 21
ROANOKE VA
DEFENDANT
********************************************************************************
* Date Entries *
********************************************************************************
9/17/2001
11/05/2001
11/06/2001
11/14/2001
11/14/2001
5/14/2002
5/16/2002
6/17/2002
6/25/2002
7/08/2002
9/04/2002
2/02/2004
2/03/2004
2/03/2004
FIRST ENTRY - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
COMPLAINT - CIVIL ACTION
-----------------------------------------------------------------~-
DEFENDANT JOSUE SALINAS VALDEZ'S ANSWER TO PLFF'S COMPLAINT WITH
NEW MATTER - BY RANDY C GREENE ESQ FOR DEFT
-------------------------------------------------------------------
PLAINTIFF'S REPLY TO DEFENDANT'S NEW MATTER - BY DAVID L LUTZ ESQ
FOR PLFF
ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE OF THE COMPLAINT BY RANDY C GREEN ATTY FOR
DEFTS
ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE - BY RANDY C GREENE ESQ FOR DEFTS
----------------------------------------.---------------------------
PETITION FOR RULE TO SHOW CAUSE WHY THE COURT SHOULD NOT ORDER
THAT PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL BE PERMITTED TO FILE A PRAECIPE TO
WITHDRAW HIS APPEARANCE BY DAVID L LUTZ ATTY FOR PLFF
--------------------------------------------------------------------
RULE - DATED 5/16/02 - IN RE PETITION FOR RULE TO SHOW CAUSE WHY
THE COURT SHouLD NOT ORDER THAT PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL BE PERMITTED
TO FILE A PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW HIS APPEAEANCE - RULE IS ENTERED
UPON DALE WINTERMEYER TO SHOW CAUSE - RULE RETURNABLE WITHIN 15
DAYS OF SERVICE - BY GEORGE E HOFFPER PJ - COPIES MAILED 5/16/02
--------------------------------------------------------------------
PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL'S PETITION TO MAKE RULE ABSOLUTE - BY DAVID L
LUTZ ESQ FOR PLFF
----------------------------------------~---------------------------
PETITION TO APPEAL AND SUSPEND JUDGMENT ORDER OF RULE - BY DALE
WINTERMEYER PLFF
-----------------------------------------.--------------------------
ORDER - DATED 7/8/02 - IN RE PLFFS COUNSEL'S PETITION TO MAKE RULE
ABSOLUTE - IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT PLFF'S COUNEL DAVID L LUTZ
ESQ IS PERMITTED TO WITHDRAW HIS APPEARANCE ON BEHALF OF PLFF DALE
WINTERMEYER AND THAT ANY SETTLEMENT DRAFT AND OR DRAFT TO PAY A
JUDGMENT IN THE ABOVE CAPTIONED CASE MUST INCLUDE ANGINO & ROVNER
PC AS A PAYEE - BY THE COURT GEORGE E HOFFER PJ COPIES MAILED
7/9/02
PRAECIPE FOR WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE OF PLFF PURSUANT TO COURT'S
ORDER FOR DAVID L LUTZ ESQ
-------------------------------------------------------------------
DEFENDANT'S JOSEU SALINAS-VALEZS' MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO
PROSECUTE - BY RANDY C GREENE ESQ FOR DEFT
-------------------------------------------------------------------
PROOF OF SERVICE FOR PETITION FOR RULE TO APPEAR
-------------------------------------------------------------------
PETITION FOR RULE TO APPEAR IN PERSON IN THIS COURT IN ORDER TO
SHOW JUST CAUSE TO QUASH DISMISSAL OF COMPLAINT PENTENTE LITE - BY
DALE WINTERMEYER PLFF
15465801032006
PYS510
Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office
Civil Case Print
Page
2
- , .
2001-05417 WINTERMEYER DALE (vs) SALINAS-VALDEZ JOSUE
~
Ref'=>rence No. , :
Ca~e Type.. , . .: COMPLAINT
Judgment...... ,00
Judge Assigned: HOFFER GEORGE E PJ
Disposed Desc. :
------------ Case Comments -------------
2/09/2004
2/23/2004
3/08/2004
3/26/2004
2/08/2005
2/08/2005
9/22/2005
12/01/2005
12/27/2005
12/27/2005
12/30/2005
Filed....,...:
Time.,. . . . . . . :
9/17/2001
3:27
0/00/0000
0/00/0000
Execution Date
Jury Trial. . . ,
Disposed Date.
Higher Crt 1.:
Higher Crt 2.:
RULE UPON PLFF TO SHOW CAUSE WHY HIS COt'IPLAINT SHOULD NOT BE
DISMISSED FOR LACE OF PROSECUTION - A RULE US ISSUED UPON PLFF TO
SHOW CAUSE IF ANY THERE BY WHY PLFF'S COMPLAINT SHOULD NOT BE
DISMISSED FOR LACK OF PROSECUTION WITHI11 20 DAYS OF THE DATE OF
THE ORDER ENTERED BY THIS COURT OR SUFFER APPROPRIATE SANCTIONS TO
BE OMPOSED UPON APPLICATION TO THE COURT - RULE RETURNABLE 20 DAYS
AFTER SERVICE - BY THE COURT GEORGE E HOFFER PJ COPIES MAILED
PLAINTIFF'S ANSWER AND REASONS FOR WHY COMPLAINT SHOULD NOT BE
DISMISSED - DALE WINTERMEYER
--------------------------------------------------------------------
RULE - DATED 3/6/04 - UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE PETITION
DEFENDANT'S PETITION TO PROCEED IN FORM], PAUPERIS IS REFUSED - BY
GEORGE E HOFFER PJ - COPIES MAILED 3/8/04
---------------------------------------~.---------------------------
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE - BY RANDY C GREENE ESQ FOR DEFT
--------------------------------------------------------------------
PROOF OF SERVICE - TO MR RUSSELL JOHNSON
--------------------------------------------------------------------
PROOF OF SERVICE TO MR. DAVID LUTZ
PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT .. BY RANDY C GREENE ESQ FOR
DEFT
---------------------------------------,----------------------------
ORDER OF COURT - DATED 11/29/05 - IN RE DEFT'S MOTION TO DISMISS
FOR FAILURE TO PROCECUTE - AFTER REVIEW OF THE FILE THE DEFT'S
MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO PROCECUTE IS DENIED THE
PROTHONOTARY IS DIRECTED TO LIST MATTER FOR TRIAL - BY THE COURT
EDWARD E GUIDO J COPIES MAILED 12/01/05
-------------------------------------------------------------------
MOTION FOR ORDER TO REPRESENT PLFF AND COMPLAINT PURSUANT TO QUASI
CONTRACT AGREEMENT FOR TRIAL REPRESENTATION - BY DALE WINTERMEYER
-------------------------------------------------------------------
NUNC PRO TUNC ANSWER TO PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT
PURSUANT TO MOTION TO DISMISS FOR LACK OF PROSECUTION - BY DALE
WINTERMEYER PLFF
PROOF OF SERVICE FOR SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OF THINGS - TO
MR RANDY GREEN
12/30/2005 PROOF OF SERVICE FOR SUBPOENA TO ATTEND AND REPRESENT COMPLAINT -
TO DAVID LUTZ ESQ
-------------------------------------------------------------------
12/30/2005 ORDER OF COURT - DATED 12/27/05 - IN RE CASE STRICKEN FROM TRIAL
LIST - THE CASE WILL NOT BE STRICKEN FROM THE TRIAL LIST AND
FURTHER ACTION IF ANY BY THE COURT IS DEFERRED TO PRETRAIL
CONFERENCE - BY THE COURT J WESLEY OLER JR J COPIES MAILED
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - LAST ENTRY - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
********************************************************************************
* Escrow Information *
* Fees & Debits Beq Bal Pvmts/Adl End Bal *
********************************~********~**************************************
COMPLAINT
TAX ON CMPLT
SETTLEMENT
JCP FEE
35.00
.50
5.00
5.00
35.00
,50
5.00
5,DO
.00
,00
.00
.00
45.50
45.50
.00
**************************************************~.*****************************
* End of Case Information *
**************************************************~~*****************************
--,
DALE WINTERMEYER
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
VI.
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ
: NO. 2001- 5417 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 4TH day of JANUARY, 2006, after review of the Plaintiffs
"Nunc Pro Tunc Answer to Praecipe for Listing the case for Argument, Pursuant to
Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Prosecution", we note that the matter was previously
resolved by our order of November 29,2005.
l:>P. v/ d. Lu.7z E~ t9 U4'/f.~
1. .I
Da e Wmtermeyer
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill, Pa. 17011
Edward E. Guido, J.
~CL'~
~tu( /-/D 6&
/l
''-ro-o
:sld
~'''\n,)
01"1 :5 ~rl 6- t\~\T SJr;Z
Mt., \J}m-term~f~~-f~
hliU....S' C i v i lAc lli.rL
P dit"Ofl To Ruo,! COlArt Procee.! i nr
I. On Jctn, aSJ,ONj I submitteJ a. J OClAment title"
Req\Aest J=or Court Tra.n~'crlpt'ons. 0[\ th,C\t document
I req~esteJ ()., JOCLtmentecA co pV of tht e"tife Trans:-
cribIM communi cQt',ons th~t dls~e~ dIAling mv COlArt
Cl. ~~,e~\o.nce.. 01[ Ja.n. ~sao~G.,j which I O,m en1!erirlj ClS
exHib,t i with this Pet,tion,
J. On Jan. ?-sao00.> I r-ecei \Ie! rnv Rt1L(est For COi,lrt
TfCllUcri fit; 0 ns In tht /'loJ \. At I th~ ~ottom of ~tlt
is sto.te~J.'~ Prttr'laln con-he\e.n~e.s ,Llft not tuKW
down on ~ht recor6\~) all [ IT IS sljne~ hCAlArC\
HQf)Jle~ C ourt ~~porter. .
3. -lr, tKe. pasty I ha.ve. a.ttendeJ. C\ J~dic\ctl pro-
ctt~ ln3 on behalf O~ m? brothe.~ wh.lch WQ.f helJ
in the. Cumbel)cu)J.! CollAnt [olAd Oi Ju~qt Thumas
FIC\ceYjG\t h'ls COlAd l~ Qtion on S'pcrtirlq H;ll RJ)
i1echarticshltf'j'ThrotAghcu.t that pfoccevl.;nlq,l vJlt-
IItSseJ tht tact t410.t J\AJ~e Plate'! o-ll{ll,/J'eJ m~
br()theX' to th e. reco,J.. tlk ntirt focee.din.
~,A\s~ in th< ~asLI. att,nJeJ a Judi~ial pm d-
I n~ thC,t wa,s he~ In tn€. York COl.lf'tty Co~rt of
JlA t Scott Gross a.t hiS' (oud loc t;~h 0 . G8G
YO\' to\!J0 R~ hcwijltrry. 1: q p.peareJ In t~at coyrt
to testq.y ltS (A charedtof' wltne.sS tOt my frIend,
who is tlra.iJ 0; 1I~r. ThrouqholAt that leqQI ~roceeJ::'
j n~ th~t, r atttl()d.e~) JlAJq~ Scott Grorl' ctllowed
m +T Itnet (raJQ Drllertto to pe. record the
entire. ,JuJ1cicdJ prDceeQinj' .
r-:> Q
C.;> T"i1.
<'::J
.-;'\
f""
,,:)
,
c:;
-(\
-"...
--
~
~-~.
r-"
.
.
~(.. cOl.lr~ common ~leas
. o. 0 - 1
Clvi I Action
Exhibit 1
v IS.
JoSue VI.II.de.z.-Dr!..fenJant<-
~uest EOI COlArLTransrrip..tions
flAtSlAMt,_lo.lhe. CO\Att~reClta.nCJ thCAt wetS helcl
in th{.Honoc(;\kl:ecJlA~~tHE~u Qt~ G-lALOJ' courtroom
....onJ(ln.l~}QO~pJ~proxjf()cttel~ ,. ~:oo A. M) larn
h eTth~ .T,eql(tsiLn,C-'\lXaocl,unwlefA co F..v. Of the. ,
.. ...1..ntitt.tronscdi:H:d..,coJumlAnicCl.tioos !hCl ttnSL(e~
, +- t c t J. t,. t'
....lAclng, .,. ..,k" .CI.. ,_uoJA.tuap~. ea.ta.nc~ peflCA /Dynol t I co. Ion
o+J-fLe cilsts..peLaqe.Qnd: the. oto I c hatjt
+hr th t.tniiteJllA rhe.nt~J trQnscri p tlofls bl
twJfLom J:too.jW . Of th IS coLtfth 0 lASe..
. tf~tt"'~41 cpl""\{e.r~nC::4!$ c::tre not ~-I<en
.dt.::>lND.ot""\ .., the. ""~C.~r:c=:l,1h e. ~ou'rt
Qrde-r th~t_lN4..StLa.OS~'-:J ~~ frQrY"'\
fuQ-"'t,~Ql'J#re-~e.. YQ~ . bave... .a.l read y
rec-eJ"e.dJ n . .... ~ D:\~ I L
.RecdILtdon.,ltsloG
.~~~R~~Z"y
(',
(~ ~:
r-...:.
Cj
"-;'1
-11
r-,!
C']
I
0.)
--:"1
..tic uJinttflneyrr- PJ(ji[lt'tft
vs.
J()SlAt s. Va.IJez.-De.-ye.nJClnt_
t ~~fO, c~,~l4flf c ommOl1 !:hlL.
Cl\Ji I Af'tion
PROOF OF SERVICE
I, _Mf, Dak \J In t e.!'Tr)e~fr
I have this J&nth.... day of Fe. b IJ a r l
the foregoing document(s), -.&tit10n UL..R 'cord c
, pursuant to
!:luJ nLrC.l2V e.rJj.. , upon the Person s) (.lod or
IOl'lltions which are. shown as utlJI'e..Ll'f.t:Lhlow.
, hereby certify that
J..ODG
i.L the l\~e1ICY
'.wi" " Fi~l-CI.~ M.i1lo mf"p:~circ
. I C~~3
~_._..------_..
c:;.
"j
.......J
1.
DALE WINTERMEYER
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
lOSEU SALINAS-VALDEZ
: NO. 01-5417 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, February 14,2006, the above-captioned case having not been
called for trial at the call of the trial list on today's date, the case is stricken from the list
of cases to be tried during the trial term beginning March 13,2006. Counsel are
requested to relist the case for trial at such time as they deem appropriate.
By the Court,
Dale Wintermeyer, Pro Se
Plaintiff
Wi~
Randy C. Green, Esquire
For the Defendant
)-)3tJC, ~ ~L
-yt;
Court Administrator
:ssg
o '1), 'tz \.nJ
--
DALE WINTERMEYER
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
JOSUE S. VALDEZ
: NO. 200i - 5417 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 23RD day of FEBRUARY, 2006, Plaintiff's request to tape
record proceedings is DENIED.
>..-'-~
./;r'>'//' __-'- )
By the Court, f
L/,~"..-..<,' .~-
~,
Edward E. Guido, J.
Dale Wintermeyer
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill, Pa. 17011
})3-tJ~ C~~~
.J%
Randy Greene, Esquire
1880 JFK Blvd.
14th Floor
Phila" Pa. 19103
:sld
nt'
\} ::.'
': !
s;:~ "~~?3
.Ii
--" L~.
-
PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL
(Must be typewritten and submitted in duplicate)
TO THE PROTHONJTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
Please list the following case:
(Check one)
(XX) for JURY trial at the next term of civil court.
for trial without a jury.
-----------------------------------------
CAPTION OF CASE
(entire caption must be stated in full)
(check one)
Pale Wintermeyer
( XX) Civil Action - Law
Appeal from Arbitration
(other)
(Plaintiff)
vs.
Josue Salinas-Valdez
The trial list will be called on 5/16/06
and
Trials commence on
6/12/06
(Defendant)
Pretrials will be held on 5/24/06
(Briefs are due 5 days before pretrials.)
vs.
(The party listing this case for trial shall
provide forthwith a copy of the praecipe to
all counsel, pursuant to local Rule 214.1.)
No. 5417
Civil
lOO. 2001
Indicate the attorney who will try case for the party who files this praecipe:
Randy C. Greene, Esquire, Dugan, Brinkmann, Maginnis and Pace
Indicate trial counsel for other parties if known: Dale Wintermeyer, Pro Se
This case is ready for trial.
Print
Esquire
Date: March 13, 2006
Attorney for: Defendant Josue Salinas-Valdez
,,~
=
C';:)
C'"
o
-n
::t
~ri1""
~,
_{'" t,
:1')0
:.?~S;
i~(~
,;':"~rn
~j
~}~
.n
-<
::r:.
-.
So
N
~
.....
-
.-
,-
o
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
vs.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 01-5417 CIVIL
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
IN RE: PRETRIAL CONFERENCE
Present at a pretrial conference held May 24, 2006, was Jackie Cassidy, Esquire, attorney
for the defendant. The pro se plaintiff did not appear.
This case arises out of an automobile/motorcycle accident which occurred on July 14,
200 1. The defendant is ready, willing and able to either try or settle the case. The intentions of
the plaintiff are currently unknown. He is warned, however, that if he fails to appear for trial or
is unprepared to proceed, the court may issue a non pros.
May 24, 2006
Dale Wintermeyer, Pro Se
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Plaintiff
Jackie Cassidy, Esquire
For the Defendant
Court Administrator
:rlm
't/iN'di\lAsr\iN~ld
"",{"-,..-"," ,"-.' r; ,.", '--''-'''''.n''
1\4I\j) ~I r : ", j ,""-:<':;y"~ IV
L 2 :OllrlV S2 A VI~ 900Z
AtlV1C;\G,'.UUd 3Hl :l0
::D'l:(';-O?nl:J
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
CIVIL ACTION ~ LAW
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Defendant
01-5417 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 12th day of June, 2006, upon
consideration of the Defiendant's oral motion for Judgment of Non
Pros made in open court, and based upon the Plaintiff's failure to
appear for trial as scheduled on this date, the Defendant's motion
for Judgment of Non Pros is granted, and the Plaintiff's complaint
is dismissed with prejudice.
By the Court,
~le Wintermeyer, Plaintiff
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill PA 17011
~ndY C. Greene, Esquire
1800 JFK Blvd.
14th Floor
Philadelphia 19103
For the Defendant
pcb
~~
~
)',.r UJ lJI,
v (, .. i~:' _,.]
GN
~ l", ,Jv
J:".LL
~erlY)e.rr-: Plaintlff-
~~~~;:;~f~
jLi-k~~fL~vl~~S:li-~-~f~IeJ.-In-yJr-ifins. that -1- am-in-
\1Qkj~_aJL_Dt.nffi~C~llS1itlA-til)nQI R~~lhts in t(qa.t<ll ...
..ic-..ooS".. Ol.J_:i'iilDn..Ihe.f'e.+'! .t.J::- OJ"Q 1'fivokln,(t
..~~Mr-llj _my..J at R'lllhtJofb.ir an& tqu.~\. treu::e'-
fY) enl.-Ln--ft.JL4..COI c'~--Jtu-thc.~Mo.L.. PtoJ'e C'tUln___..
_cJ a !AS ~_.Q s,-culUtalltio.rs-!-lJhL hls. ConsttllA.UOll
.~ I \J S tC~,~___.__.~_n__...____.,.~__
-U~ r o! e, I .~~~ S.-e..c.l_l.~l.._.d..o.tcS:,-'illMLtle...litl:e-
--O+~tprL\Lat1.QfLJL[t J' if1C;;f-o.t }(lW)?J1nf.~.et
.u1~.cQkL.o.~__~.. .. DJ<.~., Ln.dllLe...,.L.~tUI
cdo~ '~~jLli{Qrr'_in~,-
. thi_,. I V I 0 li~t:ny- i11h~sa~~~~~<c_
_l1nJn.llllJ ..tl........ll~\AI. ... o.r:. 'ff...o t~~. hV, tltlan.s.ttt:-
\l1~lltlJQWS.4+- .JAnile.! .Slilis-liaJL be...+nLn
,jA-n.d.e.t..ttltS"_Jl}l~.oL.JjnfLI Sont!-nutma.[~- tb.aILL._
.'1.4- t.aLrQL...h.o:th;---------. ..,..--- ...--.----..'-...--...-.....---. .-
3L~QillL.JL; t t. ..JiL~1k.....S JlM......L-:.V...a.l.Ju_
C. fir, e less, "P.'f w~a~ i I\tO'IIDf-J?-Ut~~'1ck.-A~~/MJelt.: L~.tr~
~f~Jd~"-Cf~i~~~fnJ1Jl~~~~n:~~1 ~'~~I.s 0-
. I W' ] 'J ~ 1 · I I
_ __ tI V I .h.IA...k.~W 0 I J ...alL_S -:
)("1\ttt.1v.e._o,iht~._p:t-fk.-~Q'tRo.v 't1JH.\2. firm... .
- Afttt'-D~vt<i Jut__1 Arf).fln.ecL 11.. m.o.thtLI thd.-he-. h
-..,.......,.....,'""'....1
, ....'^_.,,_c
,
j
I
i
+.-
!'
i
I
j
I
I
,
wo
.enL1llit--ht.sLlili.Ce.rt.L.L(l..Cill.Il'.nLi1L_f e f S 0 ~!Le.~'-!l-n-'
Jul~it..,dIJ-fA..Q.~tIrkh-OJU!.o. ft.er-. DQVILL ut2;leJL
':to_.h~llJ~-.U.e..lh(J.t-hc..w---'ll! 1J.'s.l!c:cess{,I.A.1ft_ohbuo .. .....
, J_c.o.l1e.Qt_f,~OL1n'f..j.u'L.Qm.alillt.tkt. WJJ~_e.jn.m.~-
.. i j ll~t.r;.eJll .McL.a..cl.eLnlliJL l~J..l! t~Je...;ltLL.tf)..bdj'tv
LJl.t.J AU'. . f- f\ot.lhJo..\'()_+-Lt.m..~.~~(LtR.D.\l.
". ~~.. ~r/}\U: n J~JU-r ,.ot..chcU=~i ::tl~VutlIul-
~b.LP. . --.tlrllL_~t- l1LQ_.~qYn'eL~
lL.L-o '. cO~~4l-cLtb:L L._wi:tlLQ.-l1J.tlt-.
.JJ._CUJll;f,e.t..fl k,..pit..t+uan!~..tk.j1n-c:.Lirr.a.nt _.-~
j t~ov _.~l1.bllL_b.QQL"tQJ j cita.tjon.a.d.\Il.Ltj~e.-
w.h1C--t~I'~:;t_.tecoJLtr JJi~ Fu~~(Ef hilJ i L 11
tlwLf. f d-- ua}lv.. · f . M,+.tUt~.q!AJlt!--
ntnci 4--taJA.ct T.fJ.iL.t.~ft.esmt~
. _!an.M tk~~1f1!l I t Rn~t~--
otjlL~t(lJ LWLldu_-{ff n I an.. h Y_D.itotnr-'t-.
a.vitLL\.l., ~.1!lh.o..sl .......L <;:O.I\. 1J.c! n.a.f'ttll1tl\t uJhf .
x:Jse.tfe ~fntr LOll11in. ULLtdJ.Ltl.on.Jo bf'ee .
's' _.\..' 1(>(10.11 b'] I
.L.t.tn ~ . L-DJ. ::r;;' lnQLn~Lfll1-
c ee JY\ent wi t.t.h.e.. 1.41_ f ...An. . Q!Ro.\l.n
lLs--ittJn ,Ll&Elq_ctno....l~4-,jt ..C E), "
Q, V.L~(~ -~_kw~+.I.tllLebA1t'1J11lQ-ct_.R1)\I~C
I:tttd~ft-f-~~tn--~cls:tntJfe~an,^lt J.s.stattrL....,
t...L.D.n ,..this---Q.\liUl. LOl\~tD.-ct .r;-Jr la.L(J.nc1.~J 111 nCfft.umt-
ilun.ihoi~'-LC w d.w11Ln.ol.b'f;..u~s:1hl.c .illlJ{.-f.t.C
.or fX~fnsrT un k" (.l recollr'f'1: or --6 , . _Js.~ta.i.n
kL-"!LO.f, · d -1nLJltto.--helli~\lj.l,D.a~ iJLltiti:
t... aJLju.tl nue llnJ.1--p<< b[~ ...an.cIf.lL -
fTeed
---- j
I
of
-!
+--
i
,-
I
..-r
+
f.
I
r
.j
I
I
,
I
-I.
i
.... i
,
I
r ..
j" ..--
--
,
----1
,
--I
.... t
i..
.-.....,- r
I
I
,
.!
+
L
I
1--
.
,l
f
~
.
---I
,
!
t
. I
'... t
,
,
-I
+...
.--l
j
I
I
I
;
.
.~, ---..j,~
-..j-
I
I
.,
L
I
i
I.
I
,
,
f
!
j
'~-""-'-""'-------'-'-'--~-----"-- -"-.~---_._- ---.------.-.. - --'-."------...---.-.---.,.
,
--~
--,- -... j
.-.------ .....1 . .-'- ..
.L
I
I
I
I
t
i
1
J
\
I
i
j
+
,
j,.
.... .--.--+-, ----_._-----~. .-.---.--.--.-......--.
..__.....+-.._.~-~.__.__._..,_.. .. ,.,----.- -. .,-....-..-
,
i---
.~-j.-
I
- -~ .--..---".-- T'- -----".-----------,,,-
\.
. ~'
e..
_G:t.feIL_h eC' --'lllJ S ~ e I t.Lt I' I
--tkis-ll .OJJL C olkrLft4.C 01np1lt1Ll.bs.wJt1dts:JitiliA...
H , JO.ieU j'n11.n.ds---V~tlf.u-Bti~f~1l-Jl!wrt---
_D_'n J~tlo.t i D 11 J~D i . rm i s S-E.o.tJh1lu..tn_.r~LJ?r-D-~tC.l.t ~
. 4 cLll.!l!le.r: > ro Ce lA'rGl..Ll:LLtttt-Lt.JX----
" I. f\ \\',.1-__ ' rI\MI'II,,:~t
S- -. , ..J1 ..WJ.l\-l.<L!.:mLvtr'nf I J1 _~
~r-i11 _ J OSr ~ ~aJ i nasJ Vo,~1n....ikCl)j.tl:t~.
-~1~-'i1 f'illlt C 11 m1 tr1wLco..u.ak.."OrL~te.mbtt....~
.JJ4-4.f2D.1~2Th . ..rlateLYwttJs_.noi1r1AL-h.e.c.a u.u...l
-dntt~w..i n!-~~ J.....a...t~Jlt' ..D1JJJ.l.J...uk-.n
...a J ~:: I k....cOIJrtfAn.cL-4\--~LOntObn
.1.L ' ._J).ll'J.l --llAh..k..L tt'llIltJLAIlot..sPnnpl
"/lh'llllln\ L.... ~' , J'
- ~-~tU-e I\t' ~ ..-tn....blti~itJ.. --
In-f:J=u . JUlALfo~A-
---~ eUki . .t!..._.._
E · i~' · '>~
_.lL ,~ . .j.. s.
-a~~JjjsUktt.. '.-tn, ..JnLt1ll'..lce..Si!lt____
..G:U1u-Sla.tul..lla..L'..L.Jw..e...-ti-t LL-tLt-_
~1 I '...-i- htW" ~'
-t ' . . -J.U /' WLDf:r ----JE .....J1J.O...
-FLD, f!"_~OJ: <tel:'~ f.Je7,thaL_a6;~t., s,. ..
-1lJll-Lr...o._. ..OS"f,tC-[.tllfiJ) fy ; C!LB Jo. c KS lo..L!.L.JJ.CtlOLt"
....Q..tv.T#-ft.-lle-~~J ,...a!c:t--ILf.ln-ij'..te..Pi~u..e.JLkt1~~
ttLl_t2 S.~.IhL-...tWemeAt,...SjL ..1nJUlS-.hU-.tLfS...cri1alL ilit- .
net (Accord.. wJth He .ta.cis.!J) 1 .tt.thmito.hlhit...!:1)which
Lr..Q letter ftom-..the..- ttn..t1\ty t1lJ.tI. hb,veh1t&Lto
~.. _.- -... -.-. --~ .__...:----+--
..-----t--.
+Qc_ttL-.lu..tz1a-s__ ~r~are(l.o.ll.JctQ(l qe.l the..-
te con .. nt+t_Qf.-,the_C~~ ~M,L.h ISJ'_oIe'lO tntD.t~_n
.. "I. \.lJ.ULWtldtL. clltl i C21l~)has-Je!..1r\.ttD6l1jf.1k
..Jhat~ -U.' I · Lw1ldi..-kJll.ts
_.tS.fritl~ a~ ~~ %'-_~~._ I I1!o-\LOtfJltW ~J[Jn#-
--1.--~. - tl=4&_COJA.ttt atI._
.holu _unLllrtlAKmn:h.e.-.-J l!LJ I · a4J1A-o.t-the-- "
1 _I r+._ I I ~i I
-~~ . ~
h 1I V e hit " ..a.nJ- lie. !l\AL-tlDn
't.Rov 1~es~otJnLJ1L,.caurtLh4 .
· · ~l-a1I_~Jlni.QJ!r
- '.t J J:f- Oii~t\lllih.Lc:h..l..hillLL_.u-
I .' An' '}- v
- DliecLt n~~L-'Lcunk4c~nttQct.
-L-kv.L-nol~ ~1lli~-ftUMt~-_C.durt+O-t__u
..Em Sesktu ~~ na ve.~_qtp.l~M.1hALLs.6lll!Lk .
_._u qtQ.nWlr.Q, r 1~..44l~t-4i:t.ll.tnf.~-f-f.,SlnCL-
_..~-Qf(LtJL..,.1e.--fUV~!_\-lJ.J.W.+~-(!Mcf.(w.a.Lt[mbn
-AJLtfs~niu~~t,__E~~If!rDtJeclLnA.Lait;e...Jlt' }~LeT
. LL.SL -- Llils.tltJitLD.n~Mun1LccLha.ve..bf~(LJ1L U.e. LA
u.t~,JL_ ~t.'f.chOf- c:llntr Jl: t anL.-hrw:,h ~ t-t-"llr e.r~~nt-
- aJOfL_rrte.tu..r--~e.J~L~A,- .s.eUft1!t Julltl ~alLta~ . L.
Sw]a"j efrJ..!Lw'th. 2-. MW'-ttOJJLt L-.
. Lilt _ Jr. IlLC01lti(1c.tc_LU.tth1ku~~Wli
~~ti;fn 1rl1,coJrlf l.illt a.q oj nsE:i-p~Of.u.riilll'
',1A.tt.-OtllfJt!1U_JllL.t4JA.it.a.1 J .e,. u.Jn.GlMet...... Aal\ ..fit,.. .LB'.al
t ~ cq J . s' [SlAb.' - - +- +- J : r'n VI 1 ~ e..' +.1 I
.--r. R"'& tr~a1J ~, ~=-""-""'""FlLi-.l.LC
fi~~~ the e+~lI11t CLll.\sel J..m"jrS ~t;-;;'y I ;,OJI
to my mot~tcyde.JI. halle. tili-nbeenfLmLS1d.hr.th
m--....,~
I ~::.:.\...}..)
f...
-,. t-
.. ,~, .. ~.~. . ~- ..1
t
j
.-.---.-
-!
I
I
i
I
I
j
j
i
I
~
4-
.j
i
-..........--....-
. z.
e.c
\AJ
~Lol1", j~~p,scl:l: fJll ,nt j.lJ <nttt --1lIe
_,.......~LJlfi.JL.J!LIQO'lo e.LLJ:a.t j~:l::~&1 LIlA, Mill IU ;.ne...i,tk n
'J 1..+_ +1 . If' 1. - I 'f- L .v
., .(tVL~~-'iLOl'---14f.-_ JAL:M -J"UL~- e.t.J..\.W-L---.
n-#~f~ al)J .~~tN-Atj~f---
--bW.k-}L-dDSe.- tJL. Q_lY1olAntt.:tk:L ,'(l.rL-Wi---
_sb.tuLllo.GLl Jnkj:kL_c~Wnt J1a.t1L ~a s
=E~f~~;t?~,~~:'"li1i-~~Mf~irm;JbC
J1Lls "'fx!' aod .>inet tk'-D<i~~
.,.Li.nl~-'r~DJ.d'n-tk-~aJtl.Jnellcal.hULr-~~--
..tt.p-ottUJo- A-_ttelfilthrl"iin.Q a.qellcl{'lwkiCA- ho...r - n
_LaJ!sdJ1LC tQ.-b.e.-Il.LUlls,-tll-'AhWtLnt'11-yhdll q c hatw~a
_-IDj)r.e".-J:Dt~..c:1AtJ1irl!ta. n c: e-. J.lJ1m_l_.hauf!_llnJ:t'alS:Q.naI.~.
~~~~~'~~J~~c:~e~~~S~~~ctt~ 1l\L
10 .-AUth~t.~~UlttckLUo.vJtil. ~to--D..Lm-JI\c)uik---
__llt~__l1 d.o.ntU ;s~t'a,(\Ct'c~~..l1Lt!>,JkD1rqp'la.1Jli~
-JJA1-L.-+-- I1JL~aJ.fIl'fiUx~~--d.'Ittd::
tCULd~~ , '..... ~fDJ1. 'n ~_~LmltwJt[j!t l(SLto.t-
J..lfe~ilft~l ~~hj~sltflr'1t~JuJJth-" motot v~h:cle is
AnT IM\ a rf~laC't w lrh JotS wo.rrClnr both 0. ch,,-rq-t
Otn1iLlt~lI}lf , lllhLJlet MLtLld Inm~~J.tl-
.-TILIl.--lL~t .. , c..w~Jn.l/-,o.ttnr1Wf.-_Da.v i ~
.l w'L-- JA,Lj - lLlll ,.Jhe.u_dkt fcLQoti.colllftQ . ...._
.. a.sJ"'QLd . wLth..JLft\-QtDl:_lILhj c1f.tfi~campk1nL~ikh.,
.h~e~.te",.l1.a-e ,o:S ~ wa:..~q.'-S.libfe,. ~~tc__
oilln1l..\. f' c ~~!IDL1JL-1..1 8)
tili1\!.te.-JLllit.!>) COI\Se1-JA~lL ~.fi-n'
fT'\::ad
-<
i'
<
....
--t."
j--
,;
I
I
I
I
'Ve-
, 11
(t~AJ~~1r~~~fii~h'::Jj~t;;;J~nts ~tTliiM1<I hi~k
'fctlAreil-mv.J-4f-'ll _se.vtd 1f-I1a.JbJtfl-t~ JY\1,Lffiof e'r c~de.J-
t 't~o \1c~}-ff:ittt~~-4lLPea.r.f.ct _d_,thcj:<;fllLa. ti1ut' m.. .",'
t l-.. n~Uli!a.t'LllrmLe...l1lI'i>_' 1h.:tJs.sJA.tJiD.-mdtnL.-'-
. vLnJdl-_.cliaiLan-J-Lilc.O ,)\M~~\J_ll1zs~tlllil
. Ik---~ttlctQ nomf ls'.Rn1.e-c~j.e,J.rre.C.._.citatLQf\-___
.Jl~_S~eJLa:~L/l) 0 n e.~-f.WlW:un.e.n.ts.:._vJ1lcJull.~Ju1le
_h(). . 1! f Ule. a 11 ~ CDS' ts,' 0 11 ik...t'-f.a.LQ.f--.lkL1f.1dJ.th~-
_.cJ.~ W" e .h1Ld_w. ;liet i ~ SLl..eiL
.J.k~~ Lt e ~Ut~frR1ht.\ AnL.o.h~tJ
-ih.d~t ....wJl.~_[~.Lr.t(L.tQ.,~~~.se vao..\. cost! ...
--~~~~J)n JO-1Al,L.f.oJ' n\f-LrS'lA.ance--of u~t CitD.t;Oy\ ;ai
f :.f.4..0-L_CU1l!.e.nll;..G..ll1i-QJLtLthu,.th. tht- . De..;f.flltkntdl
~1L~W ~ tlth:tcl..tk....JJ.t ft_CDsts_tha.t Wet.f,
, j Y\ L.~' ~_. ---Liiulln1LJJ..t.sto.tf~t ~it~_
, ~ - ~h~y..~JillLOli1.ij-t~~ J1i..
-!11VJ.ll~itd~~---Leaim.e.ni-c cfu_
.lL3' _o~li '.teC-L.L_~.tiL mi .IA A..L
--'\!lll J.it d --'.n! I' j~ lhc <ft! ~nLt 0- J'{l~- t A-
.Dlt-~C-JAD\..fiJAnk_t --oJ'es.hte.Jo.JLCo.mp.oont_____
:I~e:~t-P as \ ;~~;f;~af~~lr1 ;;:-B ~ il=.~
ACt '~~ili f) ct UC.o.ILth-a+f1E1J.tMUJ!-La.S.__
.-sclloe . lA Ie tk'h.e..-JJ11jQttJ... - il)- -tk.-LQ~rt 0 -f.~ Dlr~cict
_tif!. La. ~Rn.htti .~tlrAnJQllL..I a kl tilt _liLlh_L
...s ' l:I
'1 ........ ·
+.lA.lltJ...- --l_
~.cf~~~~\II<<s ~.LwomlJ.. ....
-J1M1e..nltnt tIltD.-bkJ1Wt-I..c.t..Jl!d.1~--Ro.1f r t .
!l"'ea-...rJ
r--'-"'~
,,- ,.,. ...-- --.....1. - ..
,
.,.
i
r'
I
I
I
I
I
I
'i-
I
!
. ......... J
. ..- -- I..
---... ---.... t-
-- r
u .
JI o.t.lL__(\-t,---------'-----. ,. _m .... ....__~____m.._ ... ..m__.__
IIJ.Q1L I::ie1LJ~il~...r.tC~j.uul.~J?Q,ttcoJ'rl-w.hi ch.. j L._
_J!fiitclJ.~L~ G ill hich._4_illJtil__QUl.u.,OE.Pr.o.~_
.thanotat _illlLwhkh--.-Ls.-sl .-1_CI.Joij,rR. ton L
.u....t.X;i1....s~..c.a. ~_nQiLf.i .JJ1~-~-
~jt~lhll~~tf~k.Lilltj~t~~t-!n'Jfj)t: -=
. " . lOll......f.1.lll..a..L.ttfAI L lQU.s~
. P'" '_h onOf'a bJL~c.olcl.--tfLL~~Lln.Lssi.o.(l.-to-
c ( ~Qu.e.!'~%~.YLh.kh. LsoJl~weA.. Ln..----
. .1 ,.$: \ frict_JI.l .t.heQm~tmLuiOJ'L._
~I!!QS 'tlli e 1TrtflJklu f'ia~.au t~l:LIlJtfo t
I · ~h.h t~.-f.L~.- -
in Court as sc 'f t _
.h.LO.~. o.)' ~.JJl'
t~ -'\~_J1L. C.o-ut_.tkt._
Jle.,.t.ro t 1l1~-f1U.e.s'
II~~ u-
i.e.n:kt · _AlIL.ln rutJ!'
..tkEtW._f.tfu I QJLL1.Qk!J~ U.L.c s '. ·
-'loil L -".ltl t1'~T;~~;tr~~flMlOll ~La-R"-liL!~- -
~.1Lt~Jo;tt -.Jl ~---.llimLliO-~JJA1lS-fu-
_'e.. _ltClo_....JI\ '( 0 n J Cl. W t!-t-C. In f I t\ tAt.S
_ . I kbJe....11+A1lhfX'--tkt-Dtrlr-lcL ., , tlCU1Jo v e_. bu._
.tLLQ.. f.a..L_J coud_'__~VJt4'tLrJv.ts:~t~lb _hLL
le. fi\-\~.1.nililv~_.L...IlVt.tLt.rlLe...L-a.m....r~''Jllct -+ JL'f----
1l ." · .l.llLs:--h.o.n.o.to1k-j:ILU.tt-..1~Lj~e..-.AA.-.-O.tld.trl--
rJ_ . .Q-'J~f11i'l~~ rQll-rnif-hf..ho.~~.:>\&hLC ~ wi! i.
.clired.-tbillf..tgn ._fAllclJlt_1'\ lso..1tdtne.ys-to.-fWt-
r\""lr~cd
.-j
...~~_.. .. ~-t
,
,
'-.~ '-"1'\..
'.n.. f--
_..!-:..
,
,
,
t
i-
...J-
I
I
,
.. i.
,
. --I
j
~.-
t
t
I
_.. -.. I
+
.f
.---i----- ---
, -......._-........-
- --..--.."---..-.-...- --......-..-
1
,.
.
n
~..,~
-(
"'--'
'=--:.:>
C)
-:0
-<
I'"'""Tl
rn~
;'"1'
-c:-"
c_
I',)
Q-~l
1';'..:>
0<
.,
0;=:.' l \\ t.l
,,-X('iIl~II, ~
LAWN-LAWYERS
Cl'i")itt<lo~'~'i"; "
~, "l" "';.i:.~.,!v,i;' . J C Cobb small E1\llIMR8lla1r . W, , '
l~~}f\n .,dr;X~"iY:$","!/,500stonerDrMldd_ ' ," ,::944:1197
I rrSo"IIl)'M Y'bbl ' '1"';",1;- """'La'\\fn."'.Oril~elitil'.."'"''
J' .. ',,' ',' , ",','_ ','." ,";<': ,",_ _:'.'
4303~C3r1I~~i:amP tll\r*' 'Q~JlJ. "" 7814617 . ,;'.J,:.SEE Garden., Cei\~.', ,',::~?,-;:'''i'Lf;~'_iL~;.',' 'r.',;,;. ,'.<....::..\i.it,.:;
" "" I,.' .., ,Lawn" G8rdeltEquip '" Suppueo:,:" ,,: 'I
BOTA LAWN.lOARDENlllACTORS", 'i';., "'Statuary. ,',',,', ':3 :, ',' ,
':'''.'''' ~~""\~..,..".........;it...),I~Wtri,,,,,,,";,r,. ".,,1:,'_,"",:_.', "" I' IT',..;., orS '~:;l;;;; t~< ',.' J
i;"(,,,,~~,,;'t~'t1i!J1UIVfCB',::\;~X;" ;, ~wn pra,y......g' .', "
:J1',. '~~';,.." .,,;,',;,;,,,:-1\1.,,,;,;,4'" :.'1.';.';- "~""',; {';'f'-; , , j," r < "
V'~:'....~~;:~;~1~1:;i;\'.l4ilJNVur-::"~::'~:,:;:':;',v~,":>":,,,:-:"" _ SEE Lawn M.mttmanee, "': ;:","", '" "
f BROSWBOTA R(U,~n.' . ::" .. Weed Control ~ce;",../. ,: "",l, i;,,'r;
1741tTOllFree. ..... .', ' 8OO363'2767.I.awn Sprbooeri(&SpriDklliig
wn'Clre EQUipment center UJ>',':, ;,.:. . .' .". Systems ;"'T . ,,;),;, ,.
n!1sIInII1Rd_al. .,..,. ...... MS"*". . SEE !rriptiOiiSys_'ltEqUip' '''''','ii '.",,: "
, n'Malntl!"anCe'~lt4,~I:';'::":";' "~;l"h" ",If; . ,. SprinkJ~anIen'''Lawn ;:, ;, ;"",',, I.,:,
mt\'ir~":u~i~;i;i;lf~:~~~" . l.awyer-:-BarAssoCiatIoWl"-I'
". drkRil eaiiISIiI.' "".",",,' "';"249'5338 \ SEE Lawyers' Referral "InfunnilOonSem.. . ,
'~";~nt,"..j,~";"1""""""\"""L ' .. 'U';'..--II ""--"",,,,,; A "-rOLaWOIIIcesOO' i'< ';" q
lss~~'St~~:-VJM~~"i!1;f2~0~j!~r.a':!.~~(~;"=::~ ""n~~~.~rtIIFflll\t,St~,.;:\'~~':'"
~M<M~~~~':'ir,;'I'~:5~i .' ",'. .' "'.' 'Ang::0l,.~~~~~L"/;\I.,.:~,r,F;.:75if11'
seMce.321 Rul1lllh,oil1lsl""'t249-7833'., , " '. ,.,,'w,. "'.' .,;..",c,..... . . .
era..s.I.... ;,."!";Me.',~., '!~'l' "'.,1",,,; 'Li .. 1." '.' '. . . ..' . '. '" ANOIN ,lI ROVNER".,."",.,..,...",,,, '...,M."
=,.t;;'RlI'ii~}jlil".t";"'896:M14.' AMarkWlnter\,"): . .' ,..... .
".' '. . "'dO; _:"'C:"'.. ,. J" ", . 31OWtIIocoIatOAvtH.nhey 533.48611.
1': -""''';:7f!::.,:..,'','Ol';c< !'".,.,','" I ", '..'...A.be mJOh.nA. ".
'-L"'III'111'~'~j"I.Zuf~545.2051"'::."" " '''''i'''';'., ,,-," ."';>"~"
I."~,,,,~,,~~ .'. ......~st"'.~"..__ft.,;....","'8sout11Hanoverstca~I.I.' :!49.090li : i
~n.,.~!!...re."n'~""".~"'"'7~~,:>'''l06walnutttHarn'b111l1 . 232-9511 Ui"
.~=:,~C&~#iI'; ""ffi;:"\{!'36i.~';ABOU ~~NA;'ABOM .... ," ....'i$lJWijjj;~csmWj:i:.~AI'., \,l,~.i
Orl'Olfl'AllA ',W iiJ "," ...;:> .', ':'FOR'ovER70'(EARS<\,:i,'.~..
~~::I~~~~J:'~B1,;, ':,. ,:~~~M~~V~~~~~~~UI.~:,t .'.....,.;C:,:i~j'RlIc'~~1{i:)y'1;~,.,:l..:!
I . '~li.'TUrf,l1C,!l',f"'Jo!lII""'~~i.",."i!:~;7'eJi '. i;'.".... ' "", JASON,P,KUTULAK S\ "i'.' ...."" Beat~\!IAliillltCllt!i"'l.:"
. .fA: ~~Rt22S 1IaUftX!l.~~H;::"'~~2'3132"" 'i" '/SOUCITOR.DAUPHINCOUN1Y'!;,., BilrRjgWOf...IiI'gj;I!~'
7~~=':~M..R'";:1~!,i'!S3H~ CHIU:R;~":I~~~:~~~~)~!:<~~~~~~~~;=~~~' ';'
_,t",,; l06V1a1riut~~~~W ~~1 AurOMOiiLE'ACc1DENTS' '
8SHanoverstcarJIsle .' . 249-0900 MEDICAL MALPRAcT1CE;,
Abol~ ~~I:~rn'bUIlI 232.9511 WORKPLACE INJURIES';
Abem , Kutulakls ca~I.I' 232.9511 PERSONAl.: INJURIES
Abraham laW OIIIces , "
m~ ':iF~:=~H_=::, '~~:O~7;J;1g~S
'StlvlngHarn.b11Il1Aiil. 90904!43 '(800)..648-207,0"'"
--....,......-. . ".' '. . .
Ahrens ThomasJ. .' , >,' , . ;WwW.anglno-rovner.com .
5521 carJl~e PIce MeChanICSblll ,,", 697.1800 4503 NORTlf FRONT $1: "
AlexanderJaneM .' .,' " . . HARRISBURG'PA'17110'
148S8altlmoreOIll.b11Il1'" , "'432-4514'" ", . .
. ZI:~~~L210walnutstHa~'lS5'~1'<'AnnerClroIYnM, '. .. ".'." .
47l1O Union OeposUd SUItli 260 .', . .. ., llOOungJestownRd~238
H_1lI lisl.omAnstlnenmotl1yM ,,' 'I
Alzamora John A ,.11. 00 Plne.st H.rnsllu.1lI 221-1111
212LOCUsrsrHin1.bullI- . 255-7233,:. AlllcelUSamueIW.. .,.
. Anderson DaVId C .. J '. 305 Front 51 N Hatr1.bUIlI
..3940lOC1J$tLnHarn'burg ..... 541.1194. ArcherThomasAHarnsblll1l
432-ll1l32 AndersonJanlceL' 'i'< " .,.,;.,""'"'''''''' AnnstrongPalr1cla,. .,.'" .
, 711lS5lIverFoxClHOmm.ISlO~S66.mOO',:.. 212lOCuStstHaITllbllrg: 255-7621
Andes Samuel L 325 N 12 51 LemOVlle--761-5361 \ ArosellSarah W 305 N Frontst ~25H231
AndreWWBaI1lInPC, '. ,.",;;,.ArtzCharlesI&ASSOCIates.. ',.'""
123 stalt 51 Harrisburg .... 232.9201)'''' 207stal11stHarnsbuIlI . . 23S-990S
Andrew'U Johnson. . ',,, , ASchInger Jack F 212 Locust 51_rg. 255-7609
,> .78WPomlrtlstca~(~. . . .. 2A300123. ASmUSDanleI021Z~stHaIT1$blJrg-0255'7624
'.. AndrlngWlUlamH ',i';.,r,~<.,.t,;.i'./:";,, "',.. ,.~f' .' CONTINUEDNEXTPAOE' .
~32..4374 '." 234Nort11Nort1151H_blltg. . '234-.,..,. "'''''..
. . OONTINUEONEXTCOLUMN .. ,..." l,. .FlNOITHEREFlRST-FAST..' >""."
Angi~
& Rovner
"j; '!',
POWER OF ATI'ORNEY AND FEE AGREEMENT f)( h:l1 ~ t A.'
By SIGNING THIS AGREEMENT, I (WE) ACKNOWLEDGE lHAT 1 (WE) HAVE ENGAGED THE LAW FUw OF ANGINO & ROVNEl,
P.C. (HEREINAFTER A & R), TO REPRESENT ME (US) UNDER THE FOLLOWING TERMS AND CONDITIONS:
1. A & R may on my (our) behalf secure medical, work and other similar records, conduct an investigation, negotiate,
and if necessary start suit against anyone responsible for my (our) injuries and .losses with respect to
~e Clcc.llhl'll- 1- 11./-01 ' with full power and authority to, appear on behalf of the
undersigned in any Court of record or in any administrative or other proceeding, to do and perform all and every act
and thing whatsoever that may be requisite and necessary to be done in connection with the above claim as fully as
the undersigned might or could do if personally present; hereby ratifying and confirming all that said attorneys shall
lawfully do or cause to be done therein by virtue of this power of attorney.
,
2. 1 (we) understand that so long as the case is handled by an A & R attorney, I (we) will not be responsible for any
fees and/or expenses unless a recovery or benefit is obtained.
3. If my (our) case is handled to a successful completion by an A & R attorney, I (we) agree to pay A & R all
reasonable out-of-pocket expenses without the payment of interest, plus a fee for time expended as follows;
/cCZ
A&R ME (US)
a. SElTLEMENT PRIOR TO STARTING SUIT 30% 70%
b. SElTLEMENT FOLLOWING SUIT BUT PRIOR TO TRIAL OR
ARBITRATION 35% , 65%
c. SETTLEMENT OR VERDICT AT TRIAL OR ARBITRATION, AFTER
TRIAL, ARBITRATION, OR APPEALS OR SHORTLY BEFORE
{ TRIAL AND AFTER CASE H~EEN TOT ALL Y PREPARED 40% 60%
d. IF NO-FAULT RECOVERY OR NON-MONETARY BENEFIT: RICHARD C. ANGlNO ($500); NEIL J. ROVNER ($450);
ASSOCIATES ($400) PER HOUR BUT NOT TO EXCEED 40% OF TOTAL RECOVERY OF VALUE OF BENEFIT ,
e. OTHER CASES
~
~
4. If for any reason I (we) take my (our) case to another attorney or law firm including a former A & R attorney or
handle it myself (ourselves), I (we) recognize that A & R has, in good faith, expended money and time for my (our)
benefit and I (we) therefore agree to pay, or have my (our) new attorney pay, immediately, upon severing the A & R
attorney/client relationship, all the out-of-pocket expenses incurred on my (our) case plus interest at the rate of 6%
per annum from the date of each expenditure. In addition, when the case is successfully concluded, I(we) agree to
pay or to direct my (our) new at\Orney .0 pay as a fee 20% ofthc gross recovery to A & R.
5. In the event that any settlement is made on a structured or deferred payment basis, A & R shall be entitled to receive
their percentage based on the present value of the structured settlement, if paid as a lump sum at the time 01
settlement.
,I (we) agree not to settle or discuss settlement of my (our) case without the written consent of A & R.
By SIGNING TIllS AGREEMENT, THIS ~ DAY OF ~u~ , 20-, I (WE) ACKNOWLEDGE THAT I (WE) HAVE
READ, UNDERSTOOD, AND RECEIVED A COPY OF SAME AND ~ ITS TERMS AND CONDITIONS.
WIINES ES
CLIENT(S):
Xli.!:.}). Wil\terme1er
(SEAL)
(SEAL)
(OVER)
revised 2100
-'
i)
RECEIVED
NOV 1 5 2005
BY:
t
DUGAN, BRINKMANN, MAGINNSAND PACE
BY: RANDY C. GREENE, ESQ'UJIRE
ATTORNEY LD, # 62692
1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard
14m Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19103
(215) 563-3500
-*1-
Atto>rney for Defendant J oseu S alinas- Valdez
Dale Wintermeyer
Plaintiff(s),
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
v.
J oseu Salinas-Valdez
Defendant(s).
NO.: 01-5417
:: Exhihlt 3
DEFENDANT JOSEU SALINM':V ALDEZS' BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF HIS MOTION
TO DlSMIS ,$ FOR FAILURE TO PROSECUTE
Defendant Joseu Salinas-ValLeJ:2, by and through his counsel, Dugan, Brinkmann,
Maginnis and Pace, files this Briefi m SDJlport of his Motion to Dismiss for Failure to Prosecute
and states as follows:
I. STATEMELff OF THE QUESTION INVOLVED
A. SHOULD PLAINTIFF'S iC'AUSE OF ACTION BE DISMISSED FOR PLAINTIFF'S
FAILURE TO PROSECUTIf.:nS ACTION IN A TIMELY MANNER?
Suggested Answer: Yeso
II. SJ'A'ITEMENT OF THE CASE
P1tOCEDURAL HISTORY
Plaintiff Dale Wintermeyer (lIie,reanafter referred to as "Plaintiff'), filed a complaint
against Defendant Joseu Salinas- V aJdet (hereinafter collectively referred to as "Defendant"), in
the Court of Common Pleas of CllI1Jiberlland County on Seplember 17, 200 L The Plaintiffs
Complaint alleged physical injuries and jproperty damage stemming from a collision between
Plaintiffs motorcycle and Defendanli's ;automobile
ANGINa & ROVNER, P.C.
,
717/23&6791
FAX 717/238-5610
RICHARD C. ANGINO
NEIL J. ROVNER
JOSEPH M. MELILLO
TERRY S, HYMAN
DAVID L. LUTZ
MICHAEL E. KOSIK
RICHARD A. SADWCK
JOSEPH M. DORIA
JAMES DECINTI
4503 NORTH FRONT STREET
HARRISBURG, PA 1711().170B
WWW.ANGlNQ-ROVNER.COM
E-MAILsDLUTZ@ANGINQ-ROVNER.COM
exhibit 1..1
August 30, 2001
Mr. Dale Wintermeyer
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
I)l.,;ar wIi. \ViliLCf.llir;:y(;f,
Enclosed is a second draft of the Complaip.t. Please note that we have made cha.'1ges to paragraph 8, 12,
13, and 16,
Based on our meeting of August 28, 2001, I understand that you will complete paragraph 9, listing, in
detail, the parts that were damaged and the cost oflabor.
Once you obtain the information to complete paragraph 9, send the Complaint and executed Verification
back to my office, and I will initiate the litigation,
Secondly, enclosed are the records we recently received from the Holy Spirit HospitaL
Very truly yours,
~
DLL:mtg
Enclosure
234395,lIDLL\MTG
,
Exhihit s
OFFICE OF PROTHONOTARY
Cumberland County
CARLISLE. fA. 17013
)' J.L 1..1"....
,I rel'ri uljr iJn .2.1~ DATE p~. /7c2CiOt..
This is to nottfy you that
{1ft tJ4rf~J-( ,:" ()YrJiUA c~ A"A/M.- ;)~
No. CJ/ - 5~ &Ld 19 _ has bean
R.Ii.t.d for Trial at the /JIhA/L /3 ola?&Term 19_
of Court. Pre-Trial date
. 19
,-
W
rOe. e e..
~j~,~~cl lIJ tr lA1a~ ,s~rLLJLA T:?. v' . n
nBrlatL~lll\JL_s i~ lLiLlLL~J&t,Ljll~m-Y-tCctD..in!Ac- ~~_
by-.cJ)nt~fl.ct-o.tt~rnJlo.vi4--1JJ~'~1ledr'-ltrL Ll! t2: ..-
... L't.illQU.jl_~.-, OJLt_.LlLS.JAt.a~.I.Jn bt.~
JkhJL.Jn._tliJ.s _i 11 c1 ~1~~w.t,1'J.QllkLk'f._Will::
__.,j.Jl tL_p_~,..lD.O ~r~i ll1l.r(L_~__.cJ,.lf.,tlt, -L_____'.
c c' I s..l;,~ J' t . tn
- ~ r I 1 --QJ1~ L ~ in ,_lI--..-
.~
,S' . \ ~ 'h jt(~ a,nJ, con ha (1 e! ~ ii{=nAj.dL_lIJz.~_
__a.lli1.~j .. -_t1.e._J~.-~'#pr~qlW- ~biuL"S whlcl.o v'
utz. i,s:_~n -'it~) i - siJdWJl~~,~ lk___-,.
~ I . W ' t t . c it} ant .L '.'
~ V '__Ln"J1\-__ OJ..'.,l.lIUl._ltllU_
. ~l ^' + · ·
r.q.rj ....JdlL~.u---U--.~--ctln .
iwlLJ-fcovtri ,.J12.Qi'o~lk-~l1st d1le.1 -
n~_~ L~amou~tilltQtJlo.lIJcL_1tl2..
_j_nLkh!Jin '_\!1Jlic.h_lt_hns.~tfcL__
lI.1Ld..~ I liLk._lUlL.J: \AL ,I
, '\- recoviffJ OL,EJJ.. t
In't,-i~!f ~.a.ilDn_iLiLL.tl1!.. ------
o\K:t . -JU.~fr~i;-D.~.t<pfa t.b .IlJlL"-f"I"tL
t'lL,.,l!p1clJ~ ',ruL1_~dJ.ttp-whlc:b_aLe._lf:t'edles
,-t~s~iaJ 'a". .__~'_.___,'_"'_._.,_.,.;-- ..."..'..__-;-__._'_
~.L'"le,Ltl~..J:.-...1!l.\LLJ.ttn_-sill1;Jtdf.J.-j12, LIlt.-t1'LCD\.Ie..._____
,. . LQLtns.t..b-jll~ff..e.c tlvLJeqa.Lttp reS eniAriD13> b r:e ie:ho +. .dl.l tjes,
l! nJ.b[:e.c.e:H,..af-.c.ani t1l.ct.}p.rin . C.ou.tt .QI\tlltJ.rILrf~~_
te.senloil~_lUU---tJLllln.LttJfj-_~~iliil,lliitL
jh.l~l\.\L~t.m.entJ_xhl~tL.l_i ""~_~NL~OJ: · C
dQ..tfl..,.ttQ~.l ~100m~4Jhklt IS a.ISO_QlL Avev-men+ solicitati.ol1
VJ hJC h WGt.t ~['e.sffited._k/attor ne yR JcaarJ c A~ n~! i:J elk
! !z-~'C:'-..J
4 &
tht.;- QHlUheJ'_M-w I ~(.-~...a.s'e,.tom~~o J>tcd,J.'
..w h LC'Lwo.l.l'Hl e.- ~ .e.! f ffifJ\- t Q.1n'.!A tlte u.nt
Lin':Llrls~~:~_tntks Qcc'f,~ ~,OI'i~~'. 'I 't ,.h4u.e-.-
.1ee~ tlLll v I c"kro' l.1a.\Lc,.1h L\C~ t _ LwHL
.,1l\Ifl.luloM ~t~~inP.UUSdt-1- Qyj~ .
~Ll'iJ1L .' In 0 LVVI~{~~~~~t4 .0.. ._.~
__LdL.L.t. fr_.UllU .. 0 --llUt-"J!t
o I ~ ,,,f.L,
,.UlSJAto.n.c ., ncr.ta.J:.l,. (/. V t .uL...
J~~t~,rl , Iml2-t.-ln-c1~,~-_s-n-t' TL.C"'-ttr-'
J~ . IeL. lUs:..tilJ.d'l S:~.QnJfU QI-~JLI\.-
11JL ex: 0 t "~~~E~kJ~Ult4...L NuLe...
fLSe.a.S L-fUl_\Le t.. .... 'L.QnJ~
JuL.D~_~I,SU Ii~ <i~s i~Jl~At:,j~~tin cl.
tll}Di1dn~LJJili~~ lo.w+1tL.kt1L~[~~esslao~\ -Cl ttn'~~~'/U_
_Inti tdiA.Jl;?{' ~Ull.}-JhtS'~~\ufn-l.lf'..t,.mJ 1', #'
. e- L_~LI~:U11UlL-MtiLs~ckLtD._tHl~_.
f , · 'nal ~?r. ~l I fJillltCL.a-t .fj~r~J
,~ ~.u.er-::~,J!t, v ltM nV...&.lL,Q, llrAffl-1hta..-
JD.'\'~L~r.rtt-1h4~lJ- JJLJ1C~vltl.LJnLwJ i~:thci/t_. '.
.Cil,urltraJ)oLTr.l41J' e r.tSfAf!l-t LO n .llall~ nrlVt,ContrQC
:i1ftU . 111 s Otcle!lL.J.I[: es.DQIl<<L timer
JL e e \J k..tr~rne
. '~11tU4M · ~J.fL.hL_~
.~J, ,flL,.slA1s" ~41lte..t1Jsl I1btJr ..LO'~_L~n_Qr~et.w_h1-n ".,
sluJL tf~Lf.e.tl1R.t._l_.Sl1Q IL..!. .,- ,.~- J1ts:L.1UL,_.,
'~ '1~ .j. c s ·
~mf', ens _ '!Ii . nv.Q ...tit L <4-_~,U4-_ -
n~tt-a.fJJ e~ I ~ ..1~tJJ,_11h.e,Wlu...o1ml' ..
.t _&2:J f' n .te. LiLs:~~tk,..t~ '
. pJ:P_ J~_h1t~r:i~Jd~ lbuJ1b1l1-~~~
(Thad
e
~~n i;~ L t~'. · n.'u~~ID,l:erL!:. i=!Jtl,:J ~=
1 ~'11 ~~. i~t'-1X-:.~ l~t-,-;'El11ltJ.~ftki1,c.S~1~e,L-.,---
utD .. )olnLtip..io?tt'lI~...~tr~o,:~ifL-
_w11c vJJL.LnnL,{ 'tf~J'\t QJlJ{LL~.t~.,_.,
I '~uJ uJ' I ra
-tILe Q \fout cllnitL.rno.:tor: ckltL '5-.10. :>?-
-LW-UL. ''D:"J1J.C~AJlflc. ,. J _ rL1)le~tLILt-_hJ ,S'--__,
inf.,LS~rcl' c 0.1~J" 'U Dll-ClJln-
,., Al4-tS.kM~11LtS. :f.!.fl.tD..f;tftS t Jt.1 IUtS
_ltls_tlw,n-.:thlt..~LSen. .,-'tuan.ti~.. ,Q{-~If CQ/'flCQJl -.
i t~_ptQ~t\Ljc.c,;~LiktHr:latLJ'o. tjjtbLlto.rt
_o.~.In,mr.JULCL.__~..Qt_t(LiLt Lf~hll:t_,.,.
."! I .-mLtf.tJ1Lo1_Lo_t~t_~~~~ (1~taJlli).~J2r:-
. u.o. ~-!~t~th.~t~:t Li~~L.~~~t.~Ou
. t1tb~.~ ~_S' 121L~LlLt2_~t~SWt ,--
,J.tU.-1.ah1l1 . ~!Jlb::l;~ mtilLn1,uul bldL,s.tQ,te~--'_J1.tt1=--
, _ItkLJ}e :tt1n.+atmeJ.._.h'un tbA.tI .' wlm
. _h t1iLL_t_L~tse.A-tIDf.- ,ULCJltltt ,in .,. +!O ~i -Ot' -.Q., . J~ J ~t .
OJ.)d..l-if\.uo.JJ.lf'.-vr Ir:t~<illd.L&a.S_.Jnl,ild~ t d_h~ I it,vt . ,-"
'1111l_.hLuliJJJ.t1c~d'd.L _In.~_wjth,, ,tJtt_[t~tcsf.nt~_ '_m_
",se.t.IJjc_~-Q4-iln+--o.1.U:"LM.Ji_lclcJ_",_r-l.Jlt~j'tn,ta..i.i~~i.~"
'.G.ote.mul11io1Lt.cl ilitJitL o_._clec p LV~ .. IASJT\1.ss
ti. .,
CIAI: -.J1w i.c1-w:tt'~t!eJ!ltll{ntl lficaJio.n..s' ,(If sc f Ltl~--
._c ~ IAIT .Q,P-fltM'U 1\ C esJkt,.J1.,-was.-'Stnt.Jt, .a.nd.'fJlltLthls-
\T'ead
-,
'1 0 G S'
o ..j..1 T Dee [ t oC ~ W I I I
.,."m~..H. 1 ,lDn.-L.D- "" j)[j. aut ... L te UlF-.'flLlllnl<'^-,
.,.c\.. .trnI_la.cl_sLkLiha.tDLittlctJ~- ThIHl'\fLS PLo.c(r
{t r~ cntrP'JcLlid.J1t_SkJltiG:~DrJet~o~ t " QUO-~ct. 11f.-
__.l)__-te.d.lO-J.l~FLC ~~~_t1L-___,
j!q,tt_-ttlv. .,.at t.E_A-1 ..uUih..JliL,' t_lh-t- { 0 \A tt_J.1p.p=--
..fI!.tWd!..c l,l).{W!i... olh-Jn'l
.,.be :tAtt,- tAv~t!lt_Jn_tk_., ,().MWIL-----
_J :." . 0 ltL--U~utki_cia.t~tillft,..ik_.
_D t._Mt-.e-lllit~~-l:Js-1.---Dli:M"~f.ar~~L--
_t(l_f1LsetliDt-~-t1i~..~SS~U1~di,_I,l,la.s~-{tn a eL
~Q-tJ1LC-Q1!, JL~t1U-V\ tl1m",LlilR..JniSt*f., sent..Q~_,
~..ioJll~~n 0 sJ{~\Al~UAI1UlLfyIU1Lkk_WM'~-
CI, I\lllAL~tLIu.n.L11~ ~l{oJLt:_ Pt
"l!.J' hr' J:, j' .
...~L O,/l') e" -5:., me.
1 "r ' 1 · c'v'l 11 t'
" . .~ ~~ WJl UllLH< .jILQ._~J';IT, n."c,'.LOn...-
L~ L r:-OIA,ft~ UA.tan~ !&a.s_IT:ll.MlUd..lJl.
h m._ . c J.(('t }~ Jlis tcictJ<ulaLR<kfd.-.ll
, 11 .u.!.+.I_ t.0L --lh~ts.C:h. il.le1,Hear-lll .-
.l .,-1 ':en ..bL .,.. ~ eat"Qlls.e.qJ.{J.. tJ%_
.. I ,,' ,w as__ t f,n VDf.Qh.S, nt~b.m.aJ1fl- ,
. i~at1-~;~~~rlt.JPff.Dlt1'j" .. fv;~~:- --
~t!f_pnil~..wu-ftt~Ltr~()IJJm'-+~l ,Q,J,ll-t-, tlLLpre
s~~L Hut1~J:Jl.rwf~~"~JUnI--.
111110' 04, ' ' ~,iJ,r:jriJQ._~_lttalr.
_LIjIL ..Jl.i~ _Illl _' ~rfrl. lln _CQn~tIl\Jl na to
thle E u.d L Prlotedlon(ll1~ t~Lud t t'to.tfutn tel a.tLs f._ Of
m:::(::d
,
(:1
,
h:,
~"~-)
(-)
--q
:::1
c
j'
C ~.J
()
(.'.)
Cl:.
09/20/2001 14:14 FAX 770 952 1115
TN! HAflT'OAD'S OMU/ .AlSt'D PUll(
p.o. lax lOSGl:l
..a.nA,.rA, SA 3lJ3~It-!ia{!
Return Sctvi-:e fleqll~
DATE: 09/20/01
ANGINO AND ROVNER LAW FIRM
ATTN: DAVID LUTZ-ATTORNEY AT
4503 NORTH FRONT STREET
HARRISBURG PA 17110
RE; CLAIM #: 01-245468 F11
INSURED: SALINAS, CARRIE M
DATE OF LOSS: 07/14/01
YOUR CLIENT: DALE WINTERMEYER
DEAR MR. LUTZ;
E UN
AN
CLAIM IF
SPECIALS
BRIAN YOUNT
OMNI INSURANCE COMPANY/CLAIM DEPA
PHONE '-800-727-6664 EXT 29345
.
THE HilKH'UKlJ
Ie;J lJlJl
Exhibit 1
ThE.
Iilj{TFORD
OMNlAUTOMOBILE
LAW
"
'~:"':,.....
Exhihit l.
.
Your
Legal Rights
Presented by Richard C. Anglno
AltoNUfJ' lit ltIfI1
CONTINGENT UPON WINNING
Attorney, usually take on personal
injury ca5m1 on a Contingent fee
basis. The lawyer' g fee is a
percentage of my'-money IetOVeted
on the clie1lt's behalf.\Geue:rsllv. if
no money is recovered.. the client is
. Dot resoonsible for any attorney
ree,. Contingent fee arrangements
-.;;:;moit beneficial to those injured
parties ~ho could not otherwise
affqrd an attorney to protect their
legal intereSts. No one wh.o is .
injured as a result of another
person's negligence need feel that
he or she is Dot able to file a $Uit in
civil court to-recover damages for
the injuries suffered. .
f
,
Providing individualized service ap.d
meeting lhepersonal and profes~onal
legal needs of our clients is our goal
atANGINO & ROVNER. When you
have a Pressing legal matter at ham!,
let our experience go to work for you.
Call our office at (717) 238-6'19110
schedule a consultation. We are
conveniently located at 4503 North
Front Street. For' a list of our servi~.
visit wwW.angino~rovner.com.
rVisit our ~'b sits: . I
www.anglno-rovner.com
t.
..
.
--
OFFICE OF PROTHONOTARY
Camberland Count,
CARLISLI. rA. 17013
DATE iJIlr ' ,-j .;:za;JS
Exhibit 3>
.
This Is to notify you that
J.:1jJ /JL-k.'""1p-i, , n. -9"JrJPJ.L 6~/7LJ - d~
No. tJl-.5C//7 CWJ
Relisted for Trial at tha VM, Cl? daJ(;' Term 19 -
, '-/
19 _ has been
of Court.
Pre-Trial date
OFFICE OF PROTHONOTARY
Cumberland COUft',
CARLISLE. rA. 17013
J: rf(2J tJ,is- iJn .zholc~ DATE ~ /7 d,Q1<;:-,_
This Is to not!fy you that
{M tJ~J-( ,- ~s. (}:Jvau54A"/J",,~~
No. cJ /- $'-,--- _ (.<LJ 19 ___ has been
Relisted for Trial at the /l1aA./..J /3 .;.7CI:J!c T.rm 19 _
of c..m. ~~"'.'''h eM,. J~~~~?tr
'"OfHO~"' ;-
<,
I
,
o
~
.
/
.
/
/
~
!
"
~,
~,~
;',
,-~
"
~'r'
.-,
;~~E
M~! '
-\'i'
-
o
\:-~)
\..iJ
~
DALE WINTERMEYER,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOSUE SALINAS-VALDEZ,
Defendant
NO. 01-5417 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 19th day of July, 2006, upon consideration of Plaintiffs
"Affidavit and Nunc pro Tunc Response to Letter Titled 'IN RE: Pretrial Conference,'"
filed June 26 2006, and of Plaintiff's "Nunc pro Tunc Averment and Motion for Order,"
filed July 10, 2006, which appear to be an attempt to assert a claim against Defendant
following the entry of judgment against Plaintiff and in favor of Defendant, I Plaintiff's
motions are denied.
BY THE COURT,
v1'S'ale Wintermeyer,
1406 Carlisle Road
Camp HilI, PA 17011
Plaintiff pro Se
~
~andy C. Greene, Esquire
1800 JFK Blvd.
14th Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Attorney for Defendant
,\)\.9
o
r\
o
I See Order of Court, June 12,2006,
\
\
\'-,
\\-'
(" \
""1 il",j ,-'
\ \ ',(I ',-, ,
~'.,'\ i
:;' 1\)\3''''
\::>,\\i.
'-:;~~~\~")