The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About06-3103 o . Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire Serratelli, Schiffman, Brown & Calhoon, P.C. 2080 Linglestown Road, Suite 201 Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717) 540-9170 Attorneys for Claimant MASS CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC., Claimant IN THE COURT 0 COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND C UNTY, PENNSYLVANIA t-.O -r......... v. NO.OI,.3JD3 MNR ENTERPRISES, INC. d/b/a, THE ORIGINAL SOUP MAN, CIVIL ACTION - ECHANICS' LIEN Owner or Reputed Owner MECHANICS' LIEN CLAIM 1. The name of the Claimant is Mass Construction Group, In . ("Claimant"), a Pennsylvania business corporation with its principle place of business 10 ated at P.O. Box 126337, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17112-6337 and it files this clai as contractor. 2. The name and address of the Owner or Reputed Owner (" wner") subject to the lien is MNR Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a The Original Soup Man, a Pe sylvania business corporation with a registered address of 1840 Sapling Co , Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. 3. The date on which Claimant completed the work for whic this claim is made is on or about February 3, 2006. 4. The Claimant contracted with the Owner to install a pre-as emb1ed restaurant kiosk known as "The Original Soup Man" which kiosk is known and numbered as Kiosk #1 and is located in the Capital City Mall Food Court, 3506 C pital City Mall Drive, Camp Hill, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. A copy of the 'tten contract is attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and is incorporated herein by refere ceo Copies of the accepted change orders to the contract are collectively attached her to as Exhibit "B" and are incorporated herein by reference. 5. The unpaid balance due Claimant on the contract and accejpted change orders is $19,000 , i plus interest at one and one-half percent (1.50%) monthly n the unpaid balance from the date of the completion of services. 6. The lien is claimed against the ownership interest of the 0 er or Reputed Owner in the aforesaid Kiosk #1,3506 Capital City Mall, Camp Hill, C berland County, Pennsylvania. WHEREFORE, Claimant, Mass Construction Group, Inc., claims to have a lien upon the premises hereinabove described in the amount of$19,000, plus interest a a rate of 1.50% per month, costs and other amounts permitted by law against Owners or Reputed 0 ers and the premises. Respectfully submitt d, Date: May 31, 2006 ~- ~~ Paige Macdonald-M tthes, Esquire Pa. Attorney l.D. No 66266 SERRATELLI, SC FFMAN, BROWN & CALHO N, P.C. 2080 Linglestown R ad, Suite 201 Harrisburg, P A 171 0 (717) 540-9170 Attorneys for Claim Mass Construction 05-31-'06 08:34 FROM- T-213 P001/001 F-591 VERJFICATJO~ I, George J. Sulzer, Sccret8l)'lfreasUl'ef of Mass CODS1ructiOl1 Group, Inc., hereby verify that the avermen18 of fact coDtained in the foregoing Mecbanic's Li Claim are tme and correct to the best of my Ienowledge, iDfonnatiOl1 and belief. I llIIderstand filIse $bllements herein are made subject to tho penalties of 18 Pa. C.S.A. V4904, relating to ultswom iIllsification to I I aulhorltiQ, MASS CONSTRUCTION OR; P, INC. reasurcr tKh-1b1t A- . 'AlA DocumentA101"-19 7. Standard Form of Agreement Between Owner and Cont where the basis of payment Is a STlPULA TED SUM AGREEMENT made 88 of tha 'Thlrtce.lllIt day of December in 1M year of Two Tho (In wonk /tt4JcaIe day, moll/llll1ld "41') BETWEEN 1M Owner: (NOlM. addre" and orIter /IlfOrmatlO1l) MNR &lerprises. b1e. 1840 Sapling Court M-h.nfcaborg. PA 11055 TelepboDe Number: S7().874-3002 Fax NI\JIIber: S7().874-2829 ADDI110IIS AHIlIlELE'l1ONS: ",.lWIhor 01 \hili doQIm..... IdtMd kif 01.._ n_forls cotnpIoIIon. Tho lIUlhor "'lIl' .... __lI1eleldolthe orIg.... AlA lllIndu1f form. Art AtIrI4'mt_~~ 1I1al noIIo addod Inlol1l1l111on.. WIll.. _10 1I1e otendoml form taxi fa 1IYlIIIabla!nlln the au1hOrand_ ba_ A WI!IaaI In. In the ItIt m_1lI _ doaImenllncl_ Where the au1hclr h.. addad -.ry InIonnllllol1l1l1d "",..the auIhor h.. addad to or dlI_trom the original AlA taxi. 1l1Is _ his Irnparlanl ItgllOOllHqutn__ ~on WIh an attorney 1a~v.<<hmpeatlO 1ta~1atIon or_OIL AlA Dollllllltlll A20t.188'7. ~ CandI\lons 0I111e ~ lor ConolrucIlon, III adClpWd In 1I1Ja doaumalllll' _.- 00 natUllllwllh_ gllll8llll~ lIIlIMthIa _Is modIllId. Thll dooumtnl has been appIwad and <<do,,"'" lll' The AlloaoIa*, GttltIllI Cot IlnIClOrt 01 Amtllaa. 8Dd tile Contractor: (NtJIM, addreu Il1Id oth4r /Ilformtll101l) Mass Colllln1clion Oroup, Inc. 681 KnlgM Roall Hmlsb1!r8, P A 17111 Telephone Number: 717-6$2-2230 Fax NlIlIIber: 717-652-8449 The Project Is: (NtJIM and locatio,,) Soup Man CapItal Clly Mall 3506 CapItal City Mall Olive Camp RiB,fA 17011 The ArchilcCl is; (NQIM, addrenll1ld other /IlfOl'llltlli01l) DaDie1 It MuIlln A1'Cblleetl, IDe. Arcbiteclure 8Dd PlallnllIg 512 112 South Main Street Moscow, Idaho 83843 Telephone Nllmber: 208-892-8433 Fax Number: ~92-8S33 The 0wIIeI: and CoDlractar 8gtcC as fonows. AIAll....."'IA101"'-lH7._ OI"5.1g18.1a5.'i$7.1il5~ 181e, 1il51. '*,1il57.1et'4," .1"", 18117.1"'ond lM7byThe __dA_ .vrtllllil",._I'I_,TbIJAIA DocumontlOpr"'_bJU.B.C Pf11lIhtLowond--.JonalTIUlle.. 1 UnauthOrlted reproduction or distribution 01 Ellis AJA' Docu..tpl, or _rry portion of It. tn.., ror:\Itt tn oWl and otImlnal p*'ha...., tnd Will ~ pr...._to lilt maxllnum _Ill po_ _ tho low. TIi. daau__.... P<<>doJood by AlA __ 01 3:01:10.. WI4I2OO5 uncIor Ordor No.lCOCI!fT418_1 _.....411712008, wl'notl..._ U... -., (m490289) ARTlCLE 1 TIlE CONTRACT DOCUMENTS The Contzact DOCUIIleIllI coDSi8t of this Acreemcnt. Collditiops of !be Contact ( Supplementary aDd other Condlllops), Drawings. SpocificatioDs, Addenda Inned prior to e=ntion ofthls otbel'documents HSled in thls Agrcemenland Modillc:allollS issned aftet e:recution of this Agreement; tbele !be Conlrecl, and are 1$ fully a part of tile Conlral:l 1$ It attacbed to IIU. Acreemem or repealed hereID. The nlr8Cl repte8eD1$!be wire and InlegrUed asreement betweeo !be parties bemo and super" prior Delotl represc:al8tloll$ or ~18, either written or oral. An enDlIICl'8l!on of !be Colllract Documents, other ban Modific.tions, sppears In Artide 8. ARTIClE 2 THE WORK OF 1lllS CONTRACT ihContraclOr shall fulIyex=te tbe Wolk de8crlbed In !be Colllr8Cl Doc\lrIlelIl8, lndlcelell ill tile Contract DoClllllellllto be !be resp<lllSibiIily of otbe:s. to the extent SpeCifically ARTIClE 3 DATE OF COMMENCEMENT AND SUBSTANTW. COIIPLETION 13.1 The date of Clm'Me-cemeat of tbe Work QlI be the date of lbIs Aplllellt below or provision is made for the d8le to be llxe41n . notice to proc:eed Issned by Owner. (ltlUrl Mil t/QIIl 0{ _nt if it tlif!erlfrom 1M date olrhl4 A,te8m8IIt or, If lIP. le, 8Idt1l thai rhIl tkuIl will bIl jlud /II a IKIIIce If) proc4Ild.) The co_nt date wlJJ be fixed in a notice to proceed. It, prior to the commencemCQ! oflbe Work, the Owner requires time to file mortgages mecbanic's liens and other secnrlty iIIt~ the Ow_'s time reqnlremeat shall be 1$ follows: N/A 1 U The Collll:act Time sball be measured from the date of co"'J"en_L 13.3 The CoDf:ractor shall acldeve Substanti~ CompJetion or!beelltlre Work notWN 15 da)'ll from the dale or COmmenceJllCllt, or 1$ follows: (ltlUrl ~r of calelldtzr dayl. A]l8l1l1l/ively, a calendar datI IIIIl)I be raid ",,/1m co Mud with tIrIl tkuIl of C()TtIIJl8h~. Unlllll Il4t8d el8twk" in ,'" Contract Docimttllll, inIm 411)' "fill. mmll /Or Id1'It4r SubltrJ1llial Completion ofcertainportiolUofthll Work.) ~rtI01l of WollI N1A Bubsblalill ConlplellOll Daft , subject to adjUltmenlll of this Contract Time 1$ provided In !be Contract Documents. (1_,., prt1I'/:/oTl8, if 411)'./01' Ii~d dQf/U/BU "lating If) frll/ure to comp/.llle on' or for bonu: pay1IIQIU for ,arty completion olth4 W"'*) No ~Damagea ARTICLE.. CONTRACT SUM H 1 The Owner shaI1 pay the Conlractor Ibe Contract Sum in CUIreIIt !ullds for Ibe Co tractor's performance of !be Coulract. The Conlnel SInn shaI1 be Twenty Nine Tbou8llld Eight Hundred and Fivellollm llDd Zero Cenll ($ 29,895.00). subject to additions and dednctioDS .. provided in the Conlract II. 1 U The Cot1tnct Sum it bued upon the followillg alternates, if InY, which are Documents alld are hereby accepted by the Owner: (S- thIlllUlllblln or tJ/kr Ulenti/iCQl/on of accepIld alu11fQl8l. II decllioTll on other rM Owner 811bH/{/lnlt to rhIl ,UCIltion olt1lilAgTtletMh~ attach a schtdllk of8lM:h 0 4111tJU1ltfQrtt>dllllld th4 dtJtIl when thai IIIlIOrmt ,1;p/m) I'IIi:ItIlI an /() be IIttlIk lTy r all8r1latellhawlng rM in Ibe Contract AIA_A101"-1"7.~ 018115, 1818.11125, 1887, 19S~ 1951, lGeI. fllA, 1ll67.197.c.18 .198C.lll87.11181....19l17byTI1o _1ns111lA..,_ AlrIghIa"- WARNING: ThI.AUI Do.......I.pr...olOCl"'U.s. opyrlghlLaw.nd_notlonolTroatl... 2 UMUtborized.-.prodUCttOn or ClllU'lbutlan of thla AlA" Doc"mont. 01 any ponlon of It, ruy f.IUll in nv eMl NKI crtmlnal ptNIlh.. .mI WUt be p...........IIlIll. mllldm... _ pooolblo "".....lIl.l.w. Thi. <be_ -P!Od....b\' AJA -... 17:11:2Cl on 1211_ undor 0",", No.IOOO1S7418_1_~...on.,17~....is notfor.._, UIor - (548183836) 14.3 Unit prices, l! any, are as follows: Dlllcr1pUon NODe Units Price ($ .00) ARTICLES PAYIIENTS 15.1 PROGRESS PAYIIENTS 15.1.1 Based upon Applicatioll$ for Payment sublnitted to tho Architect by tho Contr and ~ for Payment issua4 by tile Architecl. tile OWDet shall mako progre$I paymenl8 on =llD of tho C.\)fttrat't Som to tho Contractor u provldecl below and elIewbm III tile Contract Oocumellts. 15.1.2 The perIocI covered by each Appllclltlon for Payment shall be one ca1endar mo the moDlh, or as follows: The period covered by each Application for PIlyment shall be from 4a~ of co colllpletion. t to clalc ofsubltantla1 15.1.3 Provlclecllbat an Application for PIlymem IIlllCdvec1 by tho OWner oot later the 'lbltty.first clay of a month, the OWner sh8l1 make payment to the Conlraclcr not later !ban ten (10) clays 0 recelpt of the Application for Payment. 15.1.4 EacIt Appllc4tion for Paymont shal1 be baso<I on tho molt teeeIlt acbedule of Conlractor In aocordanco wilb tlIo Contract Docwnoma. The scbe4ulo of WIle8 aba11 Sam I1llOng tho varloua portions of lbo Work. The scbo4ulo of YlI1uel aba11 be p by socb data to sub81antlalO lt$ accuracy III tho OWner may IeQIIlte. 'l'bls scbedule. un sh8l1 be used as a buis for leYiewing tho Contractor's Appllc41ions for PIlyment. sub~;tted by tho o !be eDlhe Contract in sllCb l'omI and SlIppOxtod objected to by the Owner, 15.1.5 AppllcallGns for Payment shalllndicale tho ~ge of complcllon of eaeh lion of the Wod: .. of the enc1 of the pllriocl cov=cl by the Appllcs.tlon for Payment 15.1.6 (Ptwgrtrp/ll dekted) ARTIClE 6 TERMINATION DR SUSPENSION 18.1 Tho CoDtracl may be letJIlinated by the 0_ or the Contractor as provided in A201.lm. 14 of AlA Docl.mtftl 18.2 Tho W 01'1;: may be suspended by the Owner u provlclecl in Article 14 of AlA ARllCLE 7 Ml8taLANEOUs PROVISIONS 17.1 Wheroref=la mallein thlJ Agreement to aprovlaionof AlA Document A20 .1997 oranolberContract Document, the tefemoce rofers to that provision as IlIDCIIded or supplemenlbd by other visloll$ of the Contract Doeumonts. Is due at tho rate staled where the Project is 17.2 Paymenlll due and unpaid under the CoIllracl shall bear Intercsl from the cIate pi below, or in the absence dIueof, at the legal rate prevailing from time III timo at tile pI located. (111$'" ~ oflnterut agreed uptm, i/arry.) One and oue-half percent ( 1.50%) monthly ,lIAllacum...A101"'-1K'. OoprrIght 0IDIS, lD1S, fm,IDS'. fD$~ lD58, 'DIll. IllS$, 1ll8'T,1814, lD . '8110, 1Il11',1nl orod IK1 by The Amorlcon_oI_ AllItMO.- WARNING: ThloAI" DooumontIa""*"....byUA opyrI8ht"'and~n.lTr_L 3 UhaUUtorlHd reproclUOtloft or distribUtIon or this AlA- Documllht. or .ny ponton at .. may rllllUll: in . cMlancf ctitnlNlI p.nIHJH..nd wDl bt pro.....led 10 Iha m_ ...... po..lIlIo undor tho 10". ThII doou...nc.... praducod by ~IA _ 13:01:18 on IW14J2005 under Order ""'-100016141S_1 whIch.,.,...on ....1712006. orodla not I."...... U... Noteo: (7a54l102tS) (UIIII"J /aWl and requirement.! under /hi Federal TnIlh In Lending Acl. slmilar.state local COMUmlr credir kIw, IlIId oIhIr regulalWns fJt the Qwner',llIId Co1lt1YJCtQ1"S principal pia,,, of buriMss. location olt/16 Projlct IlIId ellewhm may qJ1et:l/hl validity olthLt provilkm. Legal advllll'1roIdd be obtained Ilh mpect to deletions or modjficQtJolII, and allD ,.,garding 1'IIqtdremm1"uch <II written diIcIo&'UIY' or waive ) 17.3 The 0_', JepreSenrative is; (N-. address and other /1formIltIcn) Vinny Iohnson 1840 SaplInc Court MecbanlClburg, PA 17055 17.4 The Conlnctor', representative Is: (Name. addrm and orher btfonnatum) James Unn 681 IClligbt load Harrlaburg, PA 17111 17.J Neithllr the Owner's nor the Contractor's represelll8llve shatl be changed w1tlwu ten clays written nollee to tho other party. 17.& Other provl8lolll: Exclualon, pet Mus Collsttuclion Otoup. Inc. proposal and scope ofwodc lettet da December 13,2005 betein attacbed u E:dIibil 'A'. ARTIClE. ENUMmATION OF CONTAACT DOCUMENTS 1&.1 '!'be Conlract Documenta, except for ModIfIClltlons lssocd after =tfon of this grcemelll, lie eIlIlmrnted U foUows: 1l1.1 The Agreement lalhla exeewod 1997 edition of tho Stalldl1'll Form of A BetWeeD Owner and Contractor, AlA Doc_I Al0l.1997. 11.1.2 The Clclleral CondItions are the 1997 edition of the Oene:ral CondlllODl of the Doeumoat A201-1997. . 11.1.3 The SuppIemontuy and other Co:ndilions of file Contncl 8IIl tlwIe contained In Project MaDIW aate4 October 12, 2005 , and are as follows Daculll8nt None no. PIg" 11.1.4 '!'be Spedl'lcatlollJ are!bose oonlIIned In thel'roject Manual aate4 u in Soetlo 8.1.3, and are as follows: (EiJhor list /hi SpoctJicatlons 11m or reftr to an e:rIdblt a#llChod ro thLt AgrOOml/lt) Title of Spec:lfieatIona exblbit: Mus Construction Group, Inc. plOposaland SCOpe of Ieller dated December 13, 2005 herein llllaCbcd u Elblbil 'A'. 18.1.5 '!'be Drawings are as follows, and are aate4 October 12, 2005 unle... dlfferen date la abown below: (Eit/l6r CUt tM Dnrwlng' here or reftr to All ahibiJ altached ro thLt Ag,.,~) Number Al TltIt Cover Sheet Da" 1011 A1A_A101"' -t"7.COpyrIg~t 01.,5. 'a18. 1825. lQS7.1as~ 11158. 11KI1. Illa.laS7. 1Sl'-I. la . 11l8O. 11l87.1SllI and laS7by Th. _I_of_~ AlIl1G11loro_ WARNINQ, ThltAlA DocumenllOprotoOlldb)'U.s. ._tLawaml_,.natTrouJoe. 4 UnauthOllDd roPloduOll.. 01 CIlOlllGUIlon of Urio AlA" 0......111, or any porIlOft "'It...., r...n In cIvlfand _..oJ_hi... and wDl "" pnlIoclllod t. th. .._"'" ....... posiiblO under tIl...... TliI-....rt _ P!Od....d b)' AlA _.. 13:01:IS on 12f1412OO5111lCl0l' Ordet No.l000187418_' _~'on4l17Ji!006, andlsncclor..AI.. U- -= (7S541lO269) A2 A3 A4 Sl MEPI MEP2 Aoor & lighting Plan ud Schedules Bquipmont Plan SebeduIe B1evatloll8lSeclion Specifications Mllch./ Elect. Mech.I Elect. 1011 10/1 1011 1011 1011 1011 I 8.1.6 Tho Addenda, if any, are as follows: Number None Date Pages PortloIl8 of Addenda J:elaling to biddil>g ~u/remenlS lie not part of !be Conlract requlrememl are aleo 8D\lJIleQted ill tbia AztIc1e 8. 18.1.7 Other docuJ>le1lt8, if any, fotmlngpatlof!be Conlmt Docomcnbl lie as folio (U# h4n ""1 tuldJUonaJ tfocImtnttI dud "" lmended to form pan oft'he ContrQCt D 1Wl provldu that blddlng nq.,lrtme/JU oSUCh /II adwrttMment Ot irlvItr#iDn to bid, ~ 10rml /IIld the Conttv.crot', bid an 110/ pan oft1I4 Contract Docwnenrs rmJel8 enume .should M //sled h4te only II Intended to M part olth4 Contract Docllll'Unrs.) Mus CollStrUClion Group, Inc. proposal and &copO of wolle Iett:et dated December 13 200S heIein attached as Bxbibit . A'. Is unleas lIlll biddlllg IIU. AlA DOCII/I\QltA201- toBUItkn. sampW dill thl$ Ag.-.ement. ThIy Tbi8 A&reement fa enteftld Into as of Ihe day ud year first written above and is copies, of which one is to bo delivered to!be trlCtor, one to the Arehi Z~andlbe~Z!~. ..~ ~ OWNER. (9 ) I ViDny Jobnton (Ptlnud 7Ifl1M /IIld tiIk) in at JOISt three original the admlulsttation of !be CONTRACTOR (9Ig_rt:) Made D. Ptcsldcllt (Printed ntunutrd t4le) A1AD-",onIA1D1--1_.COp,nglll 0 1915. 1918, Illl!lI.ln7. JeS~ 1958, lllS1. 1963. 11167. 1974. 10 . 19811, 19&7. 19111 and 1987b, Tho AIMrioonln_"_ AUlIh\Ora...- WARNINO,TIII.AIA Do_I.pr_byU.s. pytlghrL...nd_lonolTrHllH. 5 UDlUlhortad re~cdan or ......budon Of tht. AlA. DoCUll'l8m. or.ny panlcm at It, mlt)' 'HIIIt In IW oMl ani cr1mInad .."...... ,00 wfn be pro.."- t. the m.xl...._ _110 _r lho I.... Thlado......... _ produoed by AlA.- at 18:01,,8on Iil/1L'2OC1S onder Order No.l000I67418_' wnlcl1 """""....11712008, IlnCllsnollotra-. U_l\Iow., (73~2lllIl I . fxhi bIt 3 n.rnbDUlII. ,n I' I l~ Ph, 7.)7-652.2230 Change Request ~ To: MNfl. ENTERPRISES, INC 1840 Sapling Court Ma""anlC8burg, PA 17055 Ph: (570)87HOlIl Far. (51O)G7+Z829 Numblr: 2 O.hI: 12121105 Job: 02-80.0050 Soup Mon. I .r.n Klosk PhOft.: 510-87+-300Z Dt..r1pdon: I.mnallon 01 TranSfOrmer and "'.no1 \No aro ~d to oller lh. /olll>win9 .po.lratlo". and prielng to make tll. /otowing (:I\anolOO: In....natiOn or. (1lNew 100 amp 3 ph_ 12D12OBV 12 .,.-pa.... in I;lodrioRoornwllh II 70 limp b,eaker 10 feed loot<. 210 THHN wire from panel In ElecIrical Room 10 Kiosk Wire recder uplllzed lor .urrenl108dlng 88 pe' NEC I The rotal amOllntto pnMdelhiJ WOrk is ........................ ............................"......................................... $9,300.00 II yoU "eve onyq....:lIiona, pl..." oonlllOl me 81717.662-2230. S\Jbm~"'d by; JlIITlII. R. lonn MASS Con,.,utlion Group, In.. Appmwed bi': Dale; ; LW..<.A'* \;\.\rt2\.J..,......... ./-....:L1.i -i'lt r \.1 Peg. I of I MASS CONSTRUCTlON GROUP I" P a.llO( 120331 \ l"I.rtit.~rg. PA 171'~ Ph : 't1f-$:l!-a~ao I Change Request I To, MNR ENTERPRISES,INC 1840 S8II1;"0 Coull Mechan'<sburg. PA 17055 Ph: (570)87<1-3002 Fa.' (1l70)87c-2W Number: 3 Dote: 11201D1l Job: 02-80.0050 $()up Man. "tall Kiosk Ph......, 570.874.3002 oeaOriplilln: Eloc(rlCoI Changes & IJnd8fslab Plumbing We are pleased 10 offer Ihl following sp6eif1cation. and Iltioirlg to makalha f<>llowing changeo: Add"~ional aleottlcal rtams . $7,050.30 Fur';'" and intalllabor and materials lOr undargrounll- $1 ,c7e.00 FUllllah labor and equipmel1llo (;Il\ ftoot slab ror IIIldergr()Ufld plumbing, $1.400.00 Labor and material. 10 pour eoncrete for undetgrounQ plumbing. $1,387,00 AddItionall9bor hOutS for unforseon condil!onllnll items oUl of our oonlrol- $1.445,00 Thololal ","OUllt \0 """,,,,'hl. _ki. ..................................... . ......................... .............. ............." ff you hllVe anvqueBliorls, please COOlao! m. 11717-852..2230. Submllted by; Jlrnea R. Linn MASS C....u..etion G"",P. (rlQ. ";Ad wJ-;!/J't/2"",,--- J - ,~'2i..~ 'JiJ, } Approved by: Dale; $12,738,30 Page 1 of 1 "" 0 = C~',> -n IT' ~ ::'1.: --I ::r:..,., Fi- '1:,.... rnp r . -: -a1n ~ c..,) :::;Jf~ e ~ (~l~ ,( ....I ::t:"" "- ::::: '" ~ 0<) ... lI-, .... "' ~ ~ ~ '" <C"J %. C'\ :< 4,...-'" ~.. Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire Serratelli, Schiffman, Brown & Calhoon, P.C. 2080 Linglestown Road, Suite 201 Harrisburg, PAl 7110 (717) 540-9170 Attorneys for Claimant MASS CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC., Claimant v. MNR ENTERPRISES, INC. d/b/a, THE ORIGINAL SOUP MAN, Owner or Reputed Owner IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 06-3103 MLD Term CIVIL ACTION - MECHANICS' LIEN PRAECIPE TO SUBSTITUTE ORIGINAL SIGNATURE VERIFICATION TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Please substitute the attached original Verification for the copy of the Verification that was attached to the Claimant's Mechanics' Lien previously filed with the Court on or about May 31, 2006, in regard to the above captioned matter. Date: June 1, 2006 Respectfully submitted, ~~~~.~ Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire Pa. Attorney J.D. No. 66266 SERRA TELLI, SCHIFFMAN, BROWN & CALHOON, P.C. 2080 Linglestown Road, Suite 201 Harrisburg, P A 17110 (717) 540-9170 Attorneys for Claimant, Mass Construction Group, Inc. t.' .~.", VERIFICATION I, George J. Sulzer. Secretaryffreasurer of Mass Construction Group. Inc.. hereby verify that the avennents of fact contained in the foregoing Mechanicts Lien Claim are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S.A. ~904. relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. MASS CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC. BY:~ George J. S , t ITreasurer '" " ~" ..,# '- ",.1 o ~~~ "'<..,... -',< 1'-) = = c:;r. <...- c::: ::~.l~ o -Tl -l I-n nlp n~ r;,' ~> I Ul -1'1 :::: ..;- (') ::-')rT1 ~::t ~~ in :< 9 c e.... IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION MASS CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC., NO.: 06-3103 MLD TERM Claimant, Mechanics' Lien vs. MNR ENTERPRISES, INC., d/b/a, THE ORIGINAL SOUP MAN, Owner or Reputed Owner OWNER'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS AND DEMURRER TO CLAIMANT'S MECHANICS' LIEN AND NOW, comes the Owner, MNR Enterprises, Inc., d/b/a, The Original Soup Man, and does file these Preliminary Objections to Mechanic's Lien, and in support thereof avers as follows: FAILURE TO IDENTIFY OWNER I. Owners are the alleged owners of a moveable kiosk at an enclosed mall called the Capital City Mall (hereinafter "Mall"), owned by the Capital City Limited Partnership Pennsylvania Real Estate Investment Trust. 2. The Defendant alleges to have perfonned certain work in that it assembled a moveable kiosk in the Mall. 3. On or about May 31,2006, the Claimant filed a Mechanic's Lien against the Owners. A true and correct copy is attached hereto as Exhibit "A". 4. However, the Claimant has failed altogether to properly identify the owner of the land, i.e, the Capital City Mall. Further, the Claimant has failed to allege that notice was provided to the owner of the Mall. 5. Failure to correctly identify the owner of property is a fatal defect and renders mechanics' lien invalid. Delmont Mechanical Services. Inc.. v. Kenver C011>.. 450 Pa.Super. 666, 677 A.2d 1241 (1996). 6. Further, Under 49 P.S. ~1303(d), no lien maybe had against the owner ofland for work performed on behalf of a tenant unless it can be shown that the construction, erection, alteration or repair is for the immediate use and benefit of the owner. Chambers v. Todd Steel Picklin~. Inc. 323 Pa.Super. 119,470 A.2d 159 (1982). 7. Clearly, the Mall is owned by another party and the Claimant has not alleged that the work was for the immediate benefit of the Capital City Limited Partnership Pennsylvania Real Estate Investment Trust. OBJECT IS NOT PROPERTY UNDER THE THE MECHANIC'S LIEN LAW, 49 P.S. ~ 1502 8. Plaintiff incorporates by reference hereto the allegations of paragraphs I through 7 as if the same were more fully set forth here at length. 9. The Claimant alleges that he assembled a restaurant kiosk on behalf of the Owners. However, such activity is not considered an improvement and/or alteration to land. 10. The Claimant has not identified the work performed as erection, construction, alteration or repair ofland. 11. It is essential for a Mechanic's Lien claim, that the work performed consist of either erection/construction and/or alteration/repair to land. Here, the Claimant simply assembled a moveable kiosk in the Mall. MECHANIC'S LIEN NOT PERMITTED UNDER CONTRACT 12. Plaintiff incorporates by reference hereto the allegations of paragraphs I through II as if the same were more fully set forth here at length. 13. The Claimant attaches to the Mechanic's Lien a copy of the contract allegedly entered into between the Owner and Claimant. 14. However, Claimant only attached portions of the Contract in question. Specifically, the contract references and makes part the General Terms of AIA 1997 edition ofthe Standard Form of Agreement Between Owner and Contractor, AIA Document AIOI- 1997 and A-201-1997. 15. Specifically, Section 4.5 "MEDIATION", 4.5.1., states "Any claim arising out of or related to the Contract, except Claims related to aesthetic effect and except those waived as provided for in Subparagraphs 4.3.10,9.10.4 and 9.10.5, shall, after initial decision by the Architect or 30 days after submission of the claim to the Architect, be subject as a condition precedent to arbitration or the institution oflegal or equitable proceedings by either party." 16. The Contract continues by stating under Section 4.6 "ARBITRATION", 4.6.1, "Any Claim arising out of or related to the Contract, except Claims relating to aesthetic effect and except those waived as provided for in Subparagraphs 4.3.10,9.10.4 and 9.10.5, shall, after decision by the Architect or 30 days after submission of the Claim to the Architect, be subject to arbitration. Prior to arbitration, the parties shall endeavor to resolve disputes by mediation in accordance with the provisions of Paragraph 4.5. 17. Finally, Section 4.6.6., "Judgment on Final Award", states, "The award rendered by the arbitrator or arbitrators shall be final, and judgment may be entered upon it in accordance with applicable law in any court having jurisdiction thereof. 18. It is clear that the Contract at issue call for and mandates all disputes to be fIrst sent to mediation and then fInally decided by arbitration. It is essential therefore that the parties be bound by the tenns of the Contract. As a result, the mechanic's lien, must be dismissed with prejudice. WHEREFORE, Claimant's Mechanic's Lien should be dismissed. Date: Au~st 29. 2006 JiYru-z STEPHEN T. CARPENITO, ESQUIRE I.D.68860 ATTORNEY FOR OWNER 615 Center Street Ashland, P A 17921 Tele: (570)875-3500 Fax: (570)875-0699 fx~)blf 4- " Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire Serratelli, Schiffman, Brown & Calhoon, P.C. 2080 Linglestown Road, Suite 201 Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717) 540-9170 Attorneys for Claimant 'lRVE COPY FROM fiECORO '1' T.>~"~"C...".. """"1'"." I hA!'a u-o ..... _ "'a" .q ''-''-"..OWh, -.>:.,,' .,1....1. ,,g V fH. ~ "'.1 h,-",,,",,,, .'~ me :_ \It!.illd Coon .l\t CanislI. !Ill. fillS, 3t;u "Q. "'~d~ I~~- J ' , . ...~ MASS CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC., Claimant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO ". 0 , "" WI L_.D '1,,- . v \4> - ~-.., "" _.J . MNR ENTERPRISES, INC. d/b/a, THE ORIGINAL SOUP MAN, CIVIL ACTION - MECHANICS' LIEN Owner or Reputed Owner MECHANICS' LIEN CLAIM 1. The name of the Claimant is Mass Construction Group, Inc. ("Claimant"), a Pennsylvania business corporation with its principle place of business located at P.O. Box 126337, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17112-6337 and it files this claim as contractor. 2. The name and address of the Owner or Reputed Owner ("Owner") subject to the lien is MNR Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a The Original Soup Man, a Pennsylvania business corporation with a registered address of 1840 Sapling Court, Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 3. The date on which Claimant completed the work for which this claim is made is on or about February 3, 2006. 4. The Claimant contracted with the Owner to install a pre-assembled restaurant kiosk known as "The Original Soup Man" which kiosk is known and numbered as Kiosk #1 and is located in the Capital City Mall Food Court, 3506 Capital City Mall Drive, Camp Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire Serratelli, Schiffman, Brown & Calhoon, P.C. 2080 Linglestown Road, Suite 201 Harrisburg, P A 1711 0 (717) 540-9170 Attorneys for Claimant rRUE COPY FROM RECORD mfesllm,;,"ly''\l;'';!':;!, I M!e mite seI "'Y 112/'" .~ me ., ,JI:lald Court ;tl: caniSle. ,.., rl1is h~ ~ Ilf.~":.' . JttG_ , ' ,AI Jh-I(~ ~ ,,~ MASS CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC., Claimant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO.Oi., , J' " ':t ~,.'I Lfl '-r;_ .~ v_~ ~"L MNR ENTERPRISES, INC. d/b/a, THE ORIGINAL SOUP MAN, CIVIL ACTION - MECHANICS' LIEN Owner or Reputed Owner MECHANICS' LIEN CLAIM I. The name of the Claimant is Mass Construction Group, Inc. ("Claimant"), a Pennsylvania business corporation with its principle place of business located at P.O. Box 126337, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17112-6337 and it files this claim as contractor. 2. The name and address of the Owner or Reputed Owner ("Owner") subject to the lien is .MNR Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a The Original Soup Man, a Pennsylvania business corporation with a registered address of 1840 Sapling Court, Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 3. The date on which Claimant completed the work for which this claim is made is on or about February 3, 2006. 4. The Claimant contracted with the Owner to install a pre-assembled restaurant kiosk known as "The Original Soup Man" which kiosk is known and numbered as Kiosk #1 and is located in the Capital City Mall Food Court, 3506 Capital City Mall Drive, Camp Hill, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania A copy of the written contract is attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and is incorporated herein by reference. Copies of the accepted change orders to the contract are collectively attached hereto as Exhibit "B" and are incorporated herein by reference. 5. The unpaid balance due Claimant on the contract and accepted change orders is $19,000 plus interest at one and one-half percent (1.50%) monthly on the unpaid balance from the date of the completion of services. 6. The lien is claimed against the ownership interest of the Owner or Reputed Owner in the aforesaid Kiosk #1,3506 Capital City Mall, Camp Hill, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania WHEREFORE, Claimant, Mass Construction Group, Inc., claims to have a lien upon the premises hereinabove described in the amount of $19,000, plus interest at a rate of 1.50% per month, costs and other amounts permitted by law against Owners or Reputed Owners and the premises. Respectfully submitted, Date: May 31, 2006 ~ ~~ ~,~ Jv..~"\ll.1 Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire Pa Attorney 1.0. No. 66266 SERRATELLI, SCHIFFMAN, BROWN & CALHOON, P.C. 2080 Linglestown Road, Suite 201 Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717) 540-9170 Attorneys for Claimant, Mass Construction Group, Inc. 05-31-'06 08:34 FROM- T-213 P001/001 F-591 . . VERJIl'ICATION I, George J. Sulzer. SccrelarytrrellSUrel of Mass ConsttuctiOl1 Group, Inc., hereby veritY that the averments of fact colltained in the fbregoing Mechanic's Lien Cllim are tnIC IlId correct to the best of my knowledge. information and belief. I llIldetstand that 1lIlse lltllIements IIerein are made snbject to the pena1ties of 18 Pa. C.S.A. ~4904. relating to unsworn tlIlsificalion to authorities. MASS CONSTRUCTION GROUP, me. By:L~ George J., er Claimant's Exhibit "A" .AIA DocumentA101"-1997 Standard Form of Agreement Between Ownet and Contractor where the basis of payment Is 8 STlPULA TED SUM AGREEMENT made as of tII& TIlirt=nth day of December illlhe year of Two Thousand and Five (Tn wordl. /JtdlcaI4 day. IMIIlh and Ytf.I1') BE1WEEH !be Owner: (NQIM, addn8land other brformatJon) MNR l!nrerpriIes. be. 1840 SapllDa Comt Mech..i.....borg, PA 17055 TelepboDc Number: 570-874-3002 Fax N\lIIlber: 570-874.2829 and tII& Contractor: (NaN. addreu and other illfbml4liOll) Mass CoDBtntctlon GrollP, Inc. 681l<nlgm Road Bmlsbll1'8,PA 17lll Telephone N\Jmber: 717-652-2230 Fax NIJmber: 717-652-8449 ADDI110NI AND DELETlON8: The lWlhor 01 thIa cIcIl:uMnt Ita added InIolIna1Ion n_lorb compI<lIlon. The IlAIIor IIIlll' ... haw rwvIIod tMlttxl a11he origIr1II AlA slWIdIRI form. An AdrIIf1t1MIIlId ~ RIlpott 1I111l_added ~~.l'"'atj..... ....au _Ill the_rd form text Is IIYIIIIabIt lllllillht au1hor and 11II0'*1 t.._ A wrtleII ....In the 18ft m-uJn 01 !hI<< docImtnt ~-.. theaulhorhlllddtd --r irrf<IIlnatlan IRI_ the auIhor hallddtd III or da_ tnlm tile OIlgNIl>JA text. ThIs dOcaMnl has Important 1ogoI......- ~_an atIamoy I<< -.uraged'Mth I'MptCt III Ita oompr.tloft or m..-n. AlA 00clInInl A201-1WT, GeI** CondIIons 0I1ha ConIro<ll for ConItn.dIon, I<< adopled in thIa ctloumtIIl by _ 00 nolusewith_ D-'COl1IlIIIclmtn-lI'/$ dooumenl is modIfIod. Thil ~hu """ IPflltlYed and.....- by The ANOOfa'-" Gonorat ~l't aI AlMlic& The Project is: (Nam4 a1td ltJcation) Soup Man Capital City Mall 3506 Capital City Ma1I Drive Camp Hill, PA 17011 The Archilect is: (NanN, addnll and otMr brformaticm) Danie1 K. Mul1ln ArcbiIectl, !Jlc. An:bilecture aIld Planning 512 112 South Main Street Moscow, Idaho 83843 Te1ephone Nwnber: 208-892-8433 Fax NIJmber: 208-892.8533 The Owner and ComraClOt asree as follows. AlA _Al.l'" -ln1. COpy/IfIIl "'015. 10t8, 11125.'1031, 1l1S~ 10", lSS1, I. IM1, leT'" 1871. IS8O, 1881. 11181 and 1981b\' rhe __oIA_ AIl"""",--, wARNtNG;m.A1A O......OlIllOproteOlWClbyU.S.OopyllghlL....mlr__mIlT"'.,I... 1 UnautbOrl2:ld reproduotton or distribution 01 this AJA- Document, Qf any ponton of it. m.y 'N\JIt in uvt:ft olYl and otImtnal ptnII.....lncI WIll be pr.lOOutecltolhO mOXlmum _ po_IO uncI8r lh. I... Thi. <f<Ic:unlo<1t.... ~ by AlA _ at 13:01:1. on 1211_ under Onlot No.loooI87418_. which .lCplr.. on 41.712OOlI. and Is no! Ior_, uoor _: (7354_) AR11CI.E 1 THE CONTRACT DOCUMENTS The Collll8d Docwnenta COllSist of thla Agreement, CondltiollS of the CoDlEacl (CJene.W, Supplementary and other ColldIlloIlS). Qrawinsa, Specl1icaliOllS, Addenda isslled prior to e=:llt:ion oftbis Agreement. other documents fisted in thla Agreement and Modl1lcal!ons Issued aftet WlCUlion oflbls Agreement; thele form the Conlrlct, IDd are as 1Wly . part oftbo.Conlr8l:l as if all8Cllod to lid. Acreemem or repoated boteln. The en......... ~ lbo eIllire and lnloarated agreement b~een tII& parties boreto and supersedell prior DeloliatlollS, ~'" or ~lS, either wrIIlen or onl. An eDlllIIC:IlIon of tbo Contract 00cliIlwnts, other tban Modiftealions. appears in Article 8. ARTIClE 2 THE WORK OF l1IIS CONTRACT 'l'be CoDltaClOr ahall tIJlIy =tc the Wolk deacrlbed In !be COIlUlCt Doc\lmenlI, except to tbo cxlcntapeci1ically lncllcaled in the Contract DooUIDCIllI to be the reapons!biJity of otllm. ARTICLE 3 DATE OF COMMENCEMENT AND SUBSTAN11AL COMPlETION 13.1 The date of """""'enctm-.11l of the Worlc sball be the date of thla Agreement anleaa a dltreRnt date is stated below or provision la made for !be date to be fixed in a notice to proceed lssned by the Owner. (Tnurt th. d4te 01 ~ if it differ: from the dare ofrAu Atree_t or, If applicable. l1tlfe that thIr d4te wiU be jlud /JJ a /IOIJce 10 proceed.) The colDlIlellCelnent da~ will be fixed in a notice to proceed. If. prior to the commolleemeDl of!he Wodc, the Owner requires time to file mortgagca, mechanic's liens and other security inlOraSlS, the Owner's time requirement shall be as follows: N/A 13.2 The Conlnet Time shall be measured tiom !he dare of co_t 13.3 The Contractor ahall achieve Sllbstandal Completion or the entlre Worlc notlar<< lban IS clays liom !be date o( commencemelll, or .. (ollows: (l_rtlllllftber of cale1Jdar day:. AJlematlvely. a calendar dare may H u:ed whm coordJnated wtlh the dt:W of C01/lI1Itft~ Unl4M IlaUd elsewhere in the Clmrraa Documentl, Wm arry reqttlTf_tlfor etJrli4r Sulmatrtial Qlmpletlon of certain portiOIfl tJfthe Wor.t.J Portlon of Wolle N1A Subatantlll ComplellOll DIIt . eubjoct to adjustmanta of thla ContQct Time as provided in the Contract DoCllDlellll. (Trlletf pruvisIolfI, if atry.ftJr Iiquidakd damagu relallng I<I/al,",", I'() complm an tirM Or for btmu: ptr11IICIU ItJr early campktJOI'I oftM Wont) No Liqllidattd Damagca ARTIClE 4 CONTRACT SUM f 4.1 The Owner shall pay [be Contractor lbe Contract Sllm in current (unds for lire Con1r8Clor' a performance or the CoDtnct. The Contract Sllm shall be TweIlty Nine Thouaand Eight Hundred and Nlnet)' FiveDolIm and Zero Cents ($ 29,895.00), subject to additlons and deductlollS as provided in lire Contract Doonmonts. 1 U Tho Contract Sum ia based upon the following alternataB, if any, which are doscribed ilIlbe Conaact Doc\llDeDls and are hacby acccpled by the Owner: (9_ thIr numbers tJr other itkllZjficatiall of accepted altemates. Tf tkcUltJl'II 0tI other alurnatu are /() be mode l1y the Owrter IIlbset{llera to thIr .UCIItlon tJfrhil Ag,.,e"",n; !i/ltQCh a scheduk of such other alternate. shtnving rile a_for eacfI and the dat4 whe1l that amtJWIl e"!'irtls) AIA_entA1Cl,"-'It'.C.pyr1gtR Cl'9'tl, '9'9.1925, '937.'9S~ 1959,19111, f963,'Il67,'974,'977,'9Sll.1ll97,'Il9,...I9ll7byThe ~ NtItAt d AT'ChItectI. AD rtghta ~ WARNING: ThIs AlA: DOCUMent I. prottotOd by u.s. eopynGht Law and In....MUOnlll Treatl... 2 UMUtborized ~ or CIIltlibt4lan of data AlA- I)oc",mont" or M)' ponlon of It, mlJ rnurt in Qvw. clYlt IlnCf cl'Imlnal ptnalU... .,d wut be ~ to "'" mllllmlll1l UW1lpoulblo....... Ill. law. TMi. cloc:IJnmt.....!>Tllducod by AlA 30_ ol'7:1':2O on lV14'2OllS"nOer Order No.laao'17418-' whICh....... oUl7lllOOll, ondis not tor_, u.r_ (S49llB:l33S) 1 U unit prices, it any. are a& follows: Ottc11pUon None Units Price{$ D.lI8) ARTICLE 5 PAYMENTS 111PROOREBBPAYIENTS 15.1.1 Baaed llpOn Applicallons for Payment $llbrnitled to tho Atc:bitect by !be Contracto: and Cc:rtlficItea for PaymeDt i8$lle4 by the Architect, tile Owner sball mako progress paymenta on 3C(:()lIIlt oflhe ro"l"'''' S\Jm to tile Contractor u pxoVided below and elIewheze In !be Collltact Doc\ImenIs. 15.1.2 The period covered by each Application for Payment shall be one calendar month ending on !be last day of !be month, or as follows: The perlo4 covered by each Application for Payment IhaI1 be from da~ of commencement to dare of au!latantW coBlp1etion. 15.1.3 Provided !bat an Application for Payment is received by the Owner not later than !be Thirty-first day of a m>nth, Ihe Owner shall make payment to Ihe Contractor not Iatet than ten (10) days of recelpt of the Application for Payment. 111.4 Eld1 App&.tion for Payment 8haI1 be based on tho most teC$lI schec1ll1e of values 8IIbmilled by !be Contractor In accordanco with tho Contract DocwnentI. The scbedule of values abaII allocate !be entbe CoJllract Sum among !be various pottjons of the Work. Tho scllocIuIe of val11Cll 8haI1 be prepaled In such form and Sllpported by such daIa to $llbSlanllate its accuracy as !be Owner 11lIY require. This sc:bedule, uuleas objected to by !be Owner. sball be llsed 1I5 a basis Ibrreviewlng!be Contractor's Applications for Payment. f5.1.5 Appl!catlGns for Payment sball indlcate!be pctCeDtage ofcomplelion ofeachportionofthe W~.. oftbe end of tbe paiod coveted by !be Application for Payment f 5.1.6 (paragl'fJP/ll deleted) ARTIClE S TERMINATION OR SlJIPENSIOH 18.1 The Contract may be temllnated by the Owner Or the Contractor as provided in Article 14 of AlA Document A201-1997. f 8.2 The Work lIlaY be suapended by the Owner as provided in Article 14 of AlA Document AWl-1m. ARTICLE 7 Ml8CEU..AIIEOUS PROVISIONS 1 7.1 Wbm ref_fa IIlIde in tbla AgrcemcntlD a provision of AlA Doc_t A201.lm or another ContrlCl Document, tile reference refers to that provision as amended or Sllpplemented by other provisiOJll of the COll1%&ct Documents. 17.z Paymonls due and llI1plid IIllder the Contract sball bear interest from !be date payment Is due at the rate statecI below, or in die absence thereof, at the legBl rate prevailing from time lD time at !be place wheze the Project is located. (/1I3<Tf ~ o{intere$l ag1Vltd upon, ifarry.) One and one-half percent ( 1.50% ) ID()DlbIy AlA Oacum....A1Q1'" -10ll? CopyrIght .. 15'5, 1518, 1ll2S, '13'1', 11lS~ IllS" IllSl, ,_ 1981, 18T.. fST1,Ieea, ,.,, Illll' 0Ild IIlOTbyTho Am.ncan lhatlut. d Atchhct5. AlrIIIdJ rt8IIWd. WARNING: This AlA Oooument II; praleCted by US Copyright Law and 11,b..,..ti...,. Tr~s. 3 UnaUlhorllCtJ reproclUCtlon OJ distribUtIon Of tNs AlA- Dooument, or any ponIan of .. eM)' rNuh in...,.,. civ'8 and criminal t>>naHfn. and wnl be prosecuted to Ihl maxknum extent posalbll LInder Ebelaw. Till. cbcl.Irn.rt WlI prodUCfld by AlA software at 13:01:1$ on 1 ~4I2aos under Ordar No.l000t61...'8_' wNch. uptrn.on JJ17/2OO8, ard ia notfotl\ll....~ U... Nolo" (73li4!102G9) (U8I/l'Y laws and ,.,qutr_nu under ~ Federal Truth /If Lendlnt Act. simikJr #ate and local COMIIPIIIr credillaw' and tJwr IVgulalicns III ~ Owner's and Cc/ll1YJC1Qr's pri1fcipal p/au, of husIMn, 1M ltJcatImI of the Pro}8ct and e~ may ~ W Wllldlty oftltU provilit1ll. Legal adviclshovld hI tJbt4ined with "''P'ct to tkl4t1on8 or 1tItJt!llla;ltkml, and aw ""ardin, nqttir4Jne1lU suclt <II wrltnm dI8cIolll1YI tJr 11Iaiv8n.) .7.3TbeO_'s~veis; (NQIM, addTm and OIher brfonnatlon) VIOllY Iohnson 1840 Sap1Inc Court MccbanlcsburS. P A 1705S 17.4 Tbe Conlnclor's represelltatlv. is: (NaIM, adrm8laM other iIlformawn) lames LInn 681 tmgbt Road Harrlaburg, PA 1711l . U Neither the Owner's nor the Contractor's teprelClll8tIve shall be changed witheut ten days written notice IXl the oll\er pllrly. . 1.1 Other provWoIIJ: Exclu&ions pet Mass Construction Grollp. Inc. proposal and scope of worlc Ietler dated December 13, 200S herein attached as Elhibit . A'. ARTICLE. ENUMERATION OF CONTRACT DOCUMENTS '1.1 The Contract Docmnenrs, except for Modllicslions lssoed after exccntlon of this A~ are enlllllctSted as follows: .8.1.1 The AgreemeJlt is this execUled 1997 edition oftbe Staodarcl Form of Agtcemenl Between Owner and ContraCtor. AlA Doc_t AI01.19ln, f 1.1.2 TIle Gencnl Condltion6 are the 1997 edition of the General CondlllOIll oftbe Contract for Construcllon. AIA Doc:1lmelIt A201.1997, . . 1.1.3 The Supplemontsry and other Condilions of the Contract III'O those contained in the Project Manual dated October 12, 2DOS, and are as follows DacuIll8lll None TItIt Psg.. '1.1.4 The Speciflcstions are these contained in the Project Manual dated as in Section 8.\.3, and are as follows: (Either Utt 1M Sptei/iMtit>tu heTI tJr refer to an cJdbit attacMd to /hit A.gree/lt4/1t,) Tille of Spoc;fi~ns exbibil: Mass Constrllction Grollp, 1Ilc. proposal and scope or work letter dated December 13, zoos herein attacbed as Exbibit' A', .8.1.5 The Drswings are Sf follows, and are dated October 12, 200S llDIesa a diffeten[ dale is shown below: (EitherUtt th4 Drawingt here Or reterto "" exhibit tJJtached to tltUAgre_.) NUlllbtr Al TItI, Cover Sheet Dale 10/12/2005 AUoO_A1D1"' -1161. CopyrIgIIt C ISI8. Ig18. 11128. 1!lS7. Ig51. 1058. IllSl, 1ll63, !M7. 11l7<l. Ig77, Ill8O. 11l81, llll1llnd 1997by The AmlrIcan Ins1ttute c:A ArchAeotL AI naMe rnlfWd. WARNINO: TNt AlA. DocumNlt It pr**d Dy U.s. COpyrtght Law and lnlPrnl:tlOMt Tro.tIN. 4 U"""'orlDd ,._on or ",.tribtlllon of lhiol>.lA" Oocumom. CI( any ponlOll of I~ may r...~ In ..... elvll and crI_ ponoIlI... ood will be pm;.c:uCwd to tht maximum extlnt poAibll under tn. law, lNI doc\ment wu prodtmld by AlA .CIftware at 13:01:16 on f2l14J2005 undw Order Na.l000187418_'_"""....on4l171ll106, and 10 notlor_., Uoor _" (135<0025I>) A2 A3 A4 81 MEPl MEP2 Floor & Ughllng Plan aud Scbedu1cs Equipment Plan ~Ie B1evatlonslSectlon SpeclficatiollC Mecb. I Elect. ~ Elect. 10/1212OOS 10/1212OOS 10/1212OOS 10/1212OOS 10/1212005 10/1212OOS I L 1.6 The Addtnd,. it any, Il1'8 3$ CoIlows: Number None Date Pili" Po<tions of Addenda relating to biddiPg Iequhemen18 ~ not pitt of !be Contract Docllmenls un1e8s tile biddillg reqlliremenls are alaa en_red llIlbi1 ArtIc\t; 8. S U.7 Other doell_ilia, if any, tonning part of !be Conttact DocumenII ~ as follows: (lkt hertI any tuIdIliOflaJ dtJcuntmll that cut i1l1lnlled to form part of the Ctmtract D0C1l1M1IU. AlA DtJcument Al01- 1997 providu thal bidding ~nu.ruch 01 advertl8e_ tJr invitofiDn to /)/d, l'n8trrIclitm8 to BitJden, ~ fOl71lland the Ccntrrlaqr's bid are nor part oflhe CtJlItracI Dot:turwnu II1Ilen t1IUIIlemud ill dlis Agr.61Ile1ll. They .sIIoAJd be luted Mre only if inunded /() be part of 1M Cbntracr DOCIIl1I4ntL) Man ConstrUCtion Q:oup, lIlc. proposal and seopo of wade letter dated December 13. 200S beIein attacl1ed as Exhibit 'A'. This Agreement Is ente:ed into U of tho day and year lint written above and is e:recured ill at least tbree original copies. of which one is fa be deliverea to tho Cqntraclor, onegztO!be Arehi albeadminlatratlon of tII& eoptrac~ and Ihe remai~ Owner. ~ . ~f'.~f~ F!R.(S~trf:!) CONTRACJ'OR(SigllQ/JI~)- Villny Jobnlon Made D. Cbrys\er,l'Iesldent (Prinud rutmlaM titk) (Printed 1IIJJ1JII and tide) AlA o....montA'''''-lttT. COp,ngnt 018'5.1918, 1m, 1937, 'll$~ 185ll, 1981, nl63. 1967. 1974. 1977, 1980, 1!la7. ,., ond le87by Tho AIllIlioorl_cl_ Aftrlghts.......... WARNING, TbioAlA O._ltpr._byU.S.CopyrightL..OlldJnto_noIT....'... 5 Unauthortrcd ~))tOductlan or dldrlbutlon Of thI. AlA. Dooument, ot il'l1)' portion of It. may 'Nllft In SWtr. oMI and criminal pwtaIdn, and WI. b8 prosOCllllld ,. lb. mexlmu.. _ _1Il1. Undo1lhollW. Thia document _ produced by AlA ,,,,,,,"," 0118:01:'8 all 12/10008 urd<< Older No.IOOO187418_' _ upiM .M/f712OO8, aMI, not"" ..aIo. u_ rt>_ (72Wlll26e) Claimant's Exhibit "B" "~DWr".'t"t .tl'e Iit\: 7..11-65Z.2230 Change Request ~ To: MNR ENTERPRISES, INe 1840 Sapling CotIIt M8cnaniCSburg, PA 17QS5 Ph: (570)874-~002 Foot. (570~7+.2ll29 Number::!' Oel.: 1~'21105 Jail: 02-!O.QIJGO Soup 1.1". . Install1<losk Ph...,,, 570-87+3002 llncrlptlon: In&tallallon of TranSfOrmer Rnd Panol ~ are p'o....d to oller the folklwing sJ!ecill<:ations at>d priGing to make the folowi/lg Q/\qll$: 'n"",UallCnOf! (1) New 100 amp 3 p""'. 12Jl/2OBV 12 _ p'ne1 in l:lecll1o Room wlllla 70 amp broakor to feocl KJoil<. 2IQ THHN wire from canol in Eledrical Room ID KIosk Wire r.."", ~P_d lor ourrent lOading as pet Nee Thatclaf amountf. pnMde IhIa W<lrk is ........................ ...........................................................,(........... $9,300.00 lIyo~ have Myq",,:llions, 010_ contact me at 717-852-2230. . SUbmijk>d bY: JIIlTl.. R. Linn MAllS Co.s'ruction Group, Ino. t..L. ' /') App",""" by: ~,' ,\.\I....(,...~ h'ortr"i \..J.."'- Oale; i -1.(,1 -('\(; Page 1 0/ I .;' , IIllASS CONSTRUCTION GROU' p o. Bo~ 120331 H....risbutg.!=lA. t"11~ Ph ; rI7-~~2230 Change Request I To: Mi'IR ENTERPRISES.INC 1840 Sall~ng Court Mechanlcsbur~. PA 17055 Ph; (510IB14-30aa. Fa.. (!;70)8N-2829 Number: 3 Datv: 112010B Job: 02.80.0050 SouP Man. Install Kiosk Phone: 570.874.3002 OeSerlplilln; eloc(lif::aI Changes & Underolab Plumllll\ll We .r. pl..seo 10 orfor tha r_n9 specifications OlIO oricmq to m8ke the 101_; ell...: AdlfllionalllroOltJCaJ items. $7,050.30 Furnifh and inlalllabor aM ma_.1or unoergrounrl- $1,474.00 Furnish lobo< and equipmentlo cui tloor _lOr underground plll'ftbll\ll - $1.4QD.DO Labol.nIl materials to paur concrele for und8'l11"Oun<l plumbing - $1,361.00 AddItiotlllllilbor hO.... for unforseen condWons OlIO item. oul of our control - $1,0145.00 The total amount toptO\(id~ this w~'lcii ........,."...................,..... $12,738.30 II you have any questions. please contact m. aI717-652.-2230- Submilterl by: James R. Linn MASS Consttuel;on G"",p, l~ Approv~:: . :~~ ~~t!,tc~e~..- Page 1 of 1 . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION MASS CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC., Claimant, NO.: 06-3103 MLD TERM Mechanics' Lien vs. MNR ENTERPRISES, INC., d/b/a, THE ORIGINAL SOUP MAN, Owner or Reputed Owner ~nfifh:llte of'setUire I, Kelly J. Klusman, Secretary to Stephen T. Carpenito, Esquire, hereby certify that, on this date, I caused a true and correct copy of the foregoing document pursuant to Rule 2252(d), to be served via first class, U.S. Mail, postage prepaid upon the following: COUNSEL FOR CLAIMANT Paige MacDonald-Matthes, Esquire SERRATEUI, SCHIFFMAN, BROWN & CALHOON, P. C. 2080 Linglestown Road, Suite 201 Harrisburg, P A 1711 0 DATED: 't~"1 ha:J~ I f ~~~~~~~ KELLY. USMAN (") f-; .--' < _:~) 'C__::.] Cf' :to;;: -\ .-- (^, c::> <;;fi ::;J G'i:D r-. -,.-,rn ~_,-)O ;-,1. :.::.jC) .~,.... "1, :~? ~i~ [~;n -..\ )--". :..\J -< -0 c~) C:) N <::) Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire Serratelli, Schiffman, Brown & Calhoon, P.C. 2080 Linglestown Road, Suite 201 Harrisburg, PAl 711 0 (717) 540-9170 Attorneys for Claimant MASS CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC., Claimant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO. 0(, - 3103 IvtLD CIVIL ACTION - MECHANICS' LIEN MNR ENTERPRISES, INe. d/b/a, THE ORIGINAL SOUP MAN, Owner or Reputed Owner NOTICE TO PLEAD To: MNR Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a The Original Soup Man c/o Stephen T. Carpenito, Esquire 615 Centre Street Ashland, PAl 7921 You are hereby notified to file a written response to the enclosed Preliminary Objections to Owner's Preliminary Objections within twenty (20) days from service hereof or a judgment may be entered against you. Respectfully submitted, ~~,-,~.-d,,~~ Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire Attorney ID No. 66266 SERRA TELLI, SCHIFFMAN, BROWN & CALHOON, P.e. 2080 Linglestown Road, Suite 201 Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717) 540-9170 Date: September 7,2006 ^' Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire Serratelli, Schiffman, Brown & Calhoon, P .C. 2080 Linglestown Road, Suite 201 Harrisburg, PAl 711 0 (717) 540-9170 Attorneys for Claimant MASS CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC., Claimant v. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 0"''' 5103 UIJ) MNR ENTERPRISES, INC. d/b/a, THE ORIGINAL SOUP MAN, CIVIL ACTION - MECHANICS' LIEN Owner or Reputed Owner CLAIMANT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS AND DEMURRER TO OWNER'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO MECHANICS' LIEN CLAIM AND NOW, comes Claimant, Mass Construction Group, Inc. (hereinafter "Claimant"), by and through its counsel, Serratelli, Schiffman, Brown & Calhoon, P. c., and files its Preliminary Objections to the Preliminary Objections filed by Owner or Reputed Owner, MNR Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a The Original Soup Man (hereinafter "Owner"), and in support thereof aver as follows: PRELIMINARY OBJECTION TO OWNER'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTION TO CLAIMANT'S MECHANICS' LIEN CLAIM- FAILURE OF PLEADING TO CONFORM TO LAW OR RULE OF COURT Pa. R. Civ. P. l028(a)(2) 1. Claimant filed its Mechanics Lien against Owner on May 31, 2006 against Owner's property known as Kiosk #1 which is located in the Capital City Mall Food Court, 3506 Capital City Mall Drive, Camp Hill, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania (hereinafter the "Premises"). .. 2. Owner was served with Claimant's Mechanics' Lien Claim by the Cumberland County Sheriff on June 6, 2006. 3. On or about August 30, 2006 Owner filed its preliminary objections and demurrer to claimant's mechanics' lien. 4. Pennsylvania law is clear that preliminary objections must be filed within twenty (20) days after service of the preceding pleading. Pa. RCiv. P. l026(a). 5. Owner filed its preliminary objections 84 days after Owner was served with the Claimant's Mechanics' Lien. 6. Owner's preliminary objections were untimely and consequently were filed in direct contravention of the Rules of Civil Procedure. 7. Pa. RCiv. P. 1028 provides that preliminary objections may be filed by any party to any pleading. (Emphasis added). 8. The Rules of Civil Procedure limit the pleadings in an action to a complaint, an answer thereto, a reply if the answer contains a new matter or a counterclaim, a counter reply if the reply to a counterclaim contains a new matter, a preliminary objection and an answer thereto. See Pa. RCiv. P. 1017(a). 9. Claimant filed a Mechanics' Lien. Claimant did not file a Complaint to Enforce Mechanics' Lien. 10. A Mechanics' Lien is not a pleading. Consequently, Owner cannot file preliminary objections to Claimant's Mechanics' Lien. WHEREFORE, Claimant respectfully requests that this Honorable Court dismiss Owner's Preliminary Objections to Claimant's Mechanics' Lien with prejudice, uphold the validity of Claimant's .. lien upon the Premises hereinabove described in the amount of$19,000, plus interest at a rate of 1.50% per month, costs and other amounts permitted by law against Owners or Reputed Owners and the premises, and further award Owner all such other relief as is proper and just. Respectfully submitted, Date: September 7, 2006 ~~ ~IA~-./~~-d> Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire Pa. Attorney I.D. No. 66266 SERRA TELLI, SCHIFFMAN, BROWN & CALHOON, P.c. 2080 Linglestown Road, Suite 201 Harrisburg, P A 17110 (717) 540-9170 Attorneys for Claimant, Mass Construction Group, Inc. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire, do hereby certify that on this 7th day of September, 2006, I served a copy of Claimant's Preliminary Objections to Owners Preliminary Objections to Mechanics" Lien by United States Mail, First Class, postage pre-paid, to the following person(s): Stephen T. Carpenito, Esquire 615 Centre Street Ashland, Pennsylvania 17921 ~ \ .^\.,...-.......-1. ~,~ ~o<","\oJLt>' ~\ V'UJ..., Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire , Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire Serratelli, Schiffman, Brown & Calhoon, P.C. 2080 Linglestown Road, Suite 201 Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717) 540-9170 Attorneys for Claimant MASS CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC., Claimant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO. D~- 3lb3 M LD MNR ENTERPRISES, INC. d/b/a, THE ORIGINAL SOUP MAN, CIVIL ACTION - MECHANICS' LIEN Owner or Reputed Owner NOTICE TO PLEAD To: MNR Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a The Original Soup Man c/o Stephen T. Carpenito, Esquire 615 Centre Street AsWand, P A 17921 You are hereby notified to file a written response to the enclosed Preliminary Objections to Owner's Preliminary Objections within twenty (20) days from service hereof or a judgment may be entered against you. Respectfully submitted, ~~ '-'~ vv....c,~-d~'1 Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire Attorney ID No. 66266 SERRA TELLI, SCHIFFMAN, BROWN & CALHOON, P.C. 2080 Linglestown Road, Suite 201 Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717) 540-9170 Date: September 7, 2006 \ Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire Serratelli, Schiffman, Brown & Calhoon, P.C. 2080 Linglestown Road, Suite 201 Harrisburg, P A 17110 (717) 540-9170 Attorneys for Claimant MASS CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC., Claimant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO. MNR ENTERPRISES, INe. d/b/a, THE ORIGINAL SOUP MAN, CIVIL ACTION - MECHANICS' LIEN Owner or Reputed Owner CLAIMANT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS AND DEMURRER TO OWNER'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO MECHANICS' LIEN CLAIM AND NOW, comes Claimant, Mass Construction Group, Inc. (hereinafter "Claimant"), by and through its counsel, Serratelli, Schiffman, Brown & Calhoon, P. c., and files its Preliminary Objections to the Preliminary Objections filed by Owner or Reputed Owner, MNR Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a The Original Soup Man (hereinafter "Owner"), and in support thereof aver as follows: PRELIMINARY OBJECTION TO OWNER'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTION TO CLAIMANT'S MECHANICS' LIEN CLAIM- FAILURE OF PLEADING TO CONFORM TO LAW OR RULE OF COURT Pa. R. Civ. P. l028(a)(2) 1. Claimant filed its Mechanics Lien against Owner on May 31, 2006 against Owner's property known as Kiosk #1 which is located in the Capital City Mall Food Court, 3506 Capital City Mall Drive, Camp Hill, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania (hereinafter the "Premises") . , 2. Owner was served with Claimant's Mechanics' Lien Claim by the Cumberland County Sheriff on June 6, 2006. 3. On or about August 30,2006 Owner filed its preliminary objections and demurrer to claimant's mechanics' lien. 4. Pennsylvania law is clear that preliminary objections must be filed within twenty (20) days after service of the preceding pleading. Pa. RCiv. P. 1026(a). 5. Owner filed its preliminary objections 84 days after Owner was served with the Claimant's Mechanics' Lien. 6. Owner's preliminary objections were untimely and consequently were filed in direct contravention of the Rules of Civil Procedure. 7. Pa. RCiv. P. 1028 provides that preliminary objections may be filed by any party to any pleading. (Emphasis added). 8. The Rules of Civil Procedure limit the pleadings in an action to a complaint, an answer thereto, a reply if the answer contains a new matter or a counterclaim, a counter reply if the reply to a counterclaim contains a new matter, a preliminary objection and an answer thereto. See Pa. RCiv. P. 1017(a). 9. Claimant filed a Mechanics' Lien. Claimant did not file a Complaint to Enforce Mechanics' Lien. 10. A Mechanics' Lien is not a pleading. Consequently, Owner cannot file preliminary objections to Claimant's Mechanics' Lien. WHEREFORE, Claimant respectfully requests that this Honorable Court dismiss Owner's Preliminary Objections to Claimant's Mechanics' Lien with prejudice, uphold the validity of Claimant's \ lien upon the Premises hereinabove described in the amount of $19,000, plus interest at a rate of 1.50% per month, costs and other amounts permitted by law against Owners or Reputed Owners and the premises, and further award Owner all such other relief as is proper and just. Respectfully submitted, Date: September 7, 2006 ~~ J.M.-~o.~ ___~~d> Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire Pa. Attorney J.D. No. 66266 SERRA TELL!, SCHIFFMAN, BROWN & CALHOON, P.C. 2080 Linglestown Road, Suite 201 Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717) 540-9170 Attorneys for Claimant, Mass Construction Group, Inc. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire, do hereby certify that on this ih day of September, 2006, I served a copy of Claimant's Preliminary Objections to Owners Preliminary Objections to Mechanics" Lien by United States Mail, First Class, postage pre-paid, to the following person(s): Stephen T. Carpenito, Esquire 615 Centre Street Ashland, Pennsylvania 17921 ~ \ ^\ ... ~. ~c~ '-~'" .1;\C..kd ~ \ V\{)-1 Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire ..'_'i '0 ,.-, ,.-4 ,~- -, , .) C"~) c;... SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 2006-03103 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND MASS CONSTRUCTION GROUP INC VS MNR ENTERPRISES INC D/B/A THE MICHAEL BARRICK , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within MECHANICS LIEN CLAIM was served upon MNR ENTERPRISES INC D/B/A THE ORIGINAL SOUP MAN the OWNER , at 1510:00 HOURS, on the 6th day of June , 2006 at 3506 CAPITAL CITY MALL DRIVE CAMP HILL, PA 17011 by handing to JESSE MCKINNEY, EMPLOYEE, ADULT IN CHARGE a true and attested copy of MECHANICS LIEN CLAIM together with and at the same time directing His attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing Service Affidavit Surcharge So Answers: c+ Sworn and Subscibed to 18.00 12.32 .00 10.00 .00 40.32./ 1111/ex,. ~g~~ R. Thomas Kline day 06/07/2006 SERRATEKL~ROWN CA By,. _ ~~ Depu y &H€riff before me this of A.D. PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT (Must be typewritten and submitted in duplicate) TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY: Please list the within matter for the next Argument Court. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be stated infull) MASS mNS'IRucrION GROUP, INC., (Plaintiff) VS. MNR ENTERPRISES, INC. d/b/a THE ORIGINAL SOUP MAN, (Defendant) No. 06-3103 MLD Term 1. State matter to be argued (i.e., plaintiffs motion for new trial, defendant's demurrer to comolaint. etc.): Preliminary Objectionf? filed by Defendant to Plaintiff's Mechanic's Lien Claim and Plaintiff's Preliminary Objections to Defendant's Preliminary 2. Identify counsel who will argue cases: Objections. (a) for plaintiff: Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esquire (Name and Address) 2080 Linqlestown Road, Suie 201, Harrisburq, PA 17110 (b) for defendant: Stephen T. Carpenito, Esquire (Name and Address) 615 Centre Street, Ashland, PA 17921 3. I will notify all parties in writing within two days that this case has been listed for argument. 4. Argument Court Date: February 28, 2007 ~-e ,UUAio.t-i v~'Vti' d. Jkl.A'>. :Lit 1..1 ~ Signature . Paige Macdonald-Matthes, Esqui:ee Print your name Date January 10, 2007 Attorney for P lalntltt D r- ~ :$.. J..{> "-,) = <:::::::> -.,., k ~ s;; ::;:1 rfj :n r- \""Ji"11 ;r?y 2!@ S:! :0 -< N -0 -",,-... ....... S' c Ol