The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About06-4900 OSBORNE & RETTIG, P.C. 126-128 Walnut Street Harrislwrg, PA 17101 Telephone:717-232-3046 Fax:717-232-3538 By: Jeffrey B. Rettig, Esquire Attorney for Defendant Supreme Ct. #19616 iretti¢(uhoalawoa.com LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS COMPANY Plaintiff ~. MAXIM DEMCHAK Defendant To: PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION -LAW Please issue a Writ of Summons on the below-named as defendant in this case: Mazim Demchak,180 SQrint?!view Road. Carlisle, PA 17015 Je g, Esquire S e . I.D. #19616 126-128 Walnut Street Harrisburg, PA 17101 (71?)232-3046 Attorney for P1ainHff ,. It k ~j ,1 "~ `S } ~Y ~dq, ~, ~„ ~ -~ W ~''i .,p 1 ~'I c ntr~ G~ ro ;: ~,..: : N W y~ ~J C ~ ; Wit- 'O t . C'>t '"" ~ ". fi ~ ~ Cr't J n t?, . W ' t =.C ~] LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY Plaintiff v. MAXIM DEMCHAK Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO:~=~QA~ C. ic~~C.,~~ CIVIL ACTION -LAW WRIT OF SUMMONS To: Maxim Demchak, 180 Springview Road Carlisle, PA 17015 You are hereby notified that Plaintiff, Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company has commenced an action in Civil Action-Law against you which you are required to defend or a default judgement maybe entered against you. Date: p(o Seal of Court ~yut g, Prothono By (Deputy) Attornev: Jeffrey B. Rettig, Esquire Supreme Ct. LD. #19616 126-128 Walnut Street Harrisburg, PA 17101 (717)232-3046 Attorney for Plaintiff OSBORNE & RETTIG, P.C. 126-128 Walnut Street Harrisburg, PA 17101 Telephone: 717-232-3046 Fax:717-232-3538 By: Jeffrey B. Rettig, Esquire Attorney for Defendant Supreme Ct. #19616 LIBERTY MUTUAL FIItE INSURANCE COMPANY Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. MAXIM DEMCHAK Defendant NO: 06 4900 CIVIL ACTION -LAW PETITION OF PLAINTIFF, LIBERTY MUTUAL FILE' INSURANCE COMPANY, FOR COURT ORDER COMPELLING PLAINTIFF TO APPOIIVT AN ARBITRATOR OR APPOINTING AN ARBITRATOR TTS SELF. AND NOW, comes the Plaintiff, Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company, by its attorneys, Osborne & Rettig, PC. and files the within Petition with your Honorable Court: Plaintiff, Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company, is a insurance company with its principal place of business in Boston, Massachusetts and which is authorized to do business in Pennsylvania. 2. Maxim Demchak is a resident of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania who resides at 180 Springview Road, Carlisle, PA. 3. On or about November 7, 1999, Maxim Demchak was the operator of a vehicle which was involved in automobile accident with Ms. Shook who was operating a separate vehicle. 4. At the time of this accident, Maxim Demchak was insured by Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company. A copy of the applicable declaration page is attached hereto marked Exhibit A. 5. At the time of said accident, Ms. Shook was insured by Erie Insurance Company with liability policy limits of $100,000. 1 6. As a result of the injures sustained in this accident, Mr. Demchak received the $100,000 policy limits of Erie Insurance Company. 7. On or about May 27, 2004, attorney David R. Thompson representing Mr. Demchak wrote a letter to Liberty Mutual requesting its consent to settle the claim against Ms. Shook and indicating the fact that his client intended to pursue an underinsured coverage claim against his own policy. A copy of that letter is attached hereto marked Exhibit B. 8. Since receipt of said letter putting Liberty Mutual on notice of Mr. Demchak's underinsured motorist claim, counsel for Liberty Mutual and Mr. Demchak have proceeded to engage in discovery including an examination under oath of Mr. Demchak on December 21, 2005 as well as the deposition of his treating phsycician Dr. Ross which took place on May 4, 2006. 9. On or about May 8, 2006, the undersigned counsel wrote to Attorney Thompson requesting some tax records for Mr. Demchak and indicating his intention to appoint an azbitrator if those records were not timely received. 10. On May 15, 2006, the undersigned counsel again wrote to Attorney Thompson indicating that he had appointed an arbitrator and requesting Mr. Thompson to appoint an azbitrator as well. He was asked to do so within three weeks of the date of that letter. A redacted copy of that letter is attached hereto marked Exhibit C. 11. The undersigned counsel again wrote Mr. Thompson on May 23, 2006 asking him to appoint an azbitrator within the next 10 days. A copy of that letter is attached hereto marked exhibit D. 12. The undersigned counsel again wrote to Mr. Thompson on July 12, 2006, asking him to appoint an azbitrator within two weeks of the date of that letter. A copy of that letter is attached hereto marked Exhibit E. 2 13. Jn addition to the above referenced letters, the undersigned counsel has called and left messages with Attorney Thompson's office on three separate occasions since the July 12, 20061etter. 14. The undersigned counsel received a response on August 29, 2006 from Mr. Demchak's counsel in which he mentions the name of a potential azbitrator but does not indicate whether the potential azbitrator has agreed to serve. 15. As recently as July 5, 2006, the undersigned counsel received correspondence from Mr. Demchak expressing his frustration in trying to resolve this UIM claim against Liberty Mutual. 16. The undersigned counsel has no idea why Mr. Demchak or his counsel has refused to appoint an azbitrator for over three months but would like to move this matter along as readily as possible and for that reason is requesting that the Court enter an Order appointing Steve Greecher, Jr., Esquire, James Goldsmith, Esquire or Steven Finour, Esquire as Mr. Demchak's azbitrator in this matter. WHEREFORE, your Honorable Court is respectfully requested to enter an Order appointing an arbitrator for Mr. Demchak so that this matter can proceed. Respectfully submitted, OSBORNE & RETTTG, P.C. ~e ,Esquire Su a t.. . #19616 12 alnut Street Harrisburg, PA 17101 (717)232-3046 ., ,..u•:.'e. _. ... >x .': '. ~:..: .: .~ •. :....: .•.. .: :.,'; .:. ~.:.~.. .. .. ~ T.. vw'.'/.: i:.s ixJ.i~:. yLi:It~_1~[L~ :.-. w: - LI. a 'tTY MUTIIAL FIRE INSURANCE C~_dwNY LI'~ERTYGIIARD AIIZ'O POLICY DECLARATIONS BOSTON, MASSACHIISETTS ~ - '" FoLICTNtMBER ~ ... . .A 8 - THESEDECLARATIOtiSEFKEC7IYE~~ - ~ ' .. •...N~116DIV!4.A~55 FOR.. SERVICE CALL OR'._ W.4t7,TN: s.. ... .- __-- ---. _ .. MAXIM DEMCHAIC CHRIST R W .. .. - --- _. ...._ ...... ... 59k 1 GENEVA DR 2151 LINGLEBTOWl!]„RD, UNIT 150 _ MECHANICSBURG PA.,.17.055 HARRISBIIRG PA 17110 ' 717-545-4528/800=872=2568- "''"" "~""" ' CLAZMB:~ 800-3Sa^569'8"'- : --- ._ _-. . POLICY PERIOD: 06/15/99 TO 06/15/00 12:OlAM STANDARD TIME AT TFiE'P,DDRESS"OF-TFIB""" NAMHD INSIIRED. A3. STATED. IN. TBS. POLICX. T{iI3 POLTCY SHALL E%PIRE ON THE DATE SHOiPN BXCEPT TNAT IT MAY BE CONTINIISD IN FORCE FOR SUCC$SSIVS POLICY P$RIODS•~BY-""~ TB8 PAYMENT OP THE REQIIIRED RENEpPAL PREMIUM. EACH SIICH POLICY PERIOD SHALL BE FOR THE PERIOD SPECIFIED IN THS RENEWAL DECLARATIONS. ._ ... .. MATIIRE'DRIVER DISCOIILTP APPLIED FOR PRINCIPAL OPERATORS AGED 4D^64' - COVERAGES AND LIMIT6 IIAIDER YOUR AUTO POLICX: PART ..... A•.LIABILITY . .. .. .... BODILY .INKY $. ...PROPERTY-.DAMAGE.. $ • C.IIAITN$IIRSD MOTOR3STS BODILY YNJURY $ „UNRE~~?BD.. MOTQ•RT6TS .... ... HODILY..IN.7IIRY' .. $ $ FOLL TORT OPTION:SSLECTED - F33~ST-PARTY-$ENSBITS . 10,000 MEDICAL S%PENSE 2,500 FUNERAL.BXPENSE 5,000 INCOME LOSS 0 ACCIDENTAL DEATH 1.00,000 EACH PERSON 300;000 EACFI ACCIDENT 50,000 EACH ACCIDENT 100,000 EACH PERSON 300,000 BACH ACCIDENT XU 0,000• EACfi PERSON 300,000 EACH ACCIDENT '~. COVERAGE IS PROVIDED"WHERE A . PREMIUM IS SHOWN FOR TIffi COVERAGE VEH 1 VEH 2 VEH 3' VEH 4 $ X61 164. :147; "' ' ' ' . 31. ' ": 31 31~ . ' $ 90' ?' 90 90 ~ . $ 40 49 44 . .... ..... - .. D.COVERAGE FOR DAMAGE TO YOIIR AUTO .... _ .off TAAN, Cozr.ISxoN $ a6 as ' 141: aa. ACTUAL CASH vaI,IIE LESS DEDIICTIBLE SHOWN: -'- - - VEH.1 $.100 VEH 2 $ 100 - VEH 3 $ .100. VSH 4 $ 50 COLLISION.. 80 71 197 ~ ~ 34 ~ ~~ $ . ACTIIAL CASH VALIIE LESS DEDUCTIBLE .... .... 3BOWN: VSH 1 $ 500 VEH a $ 5DD . VEH 3 $ 500 VEH 4 $ 100 TRI9 POLICY' COVERS COLLISION DAMAGE TO RENTAL VEHT~CLE9. nu, v MI eoe~! or a •e p M e.n a 114 n u u OMM n• ~ • Is• M ' 365 3116 a 79 10 0 OS 11 9 00 00 R 1 Ol 0000 000 4 0 1 00 N SACKET 3075 1389 2 01 0000 000 4 8 0 1 00 N 3 01 0000 000 4 NO 5 1 00 N 4 05 000 000 0 0 0 00 N xasrx~s~.rir ZO'd 8071 9002 s:: .~ •`i:-+8'::C=.:.;~.;:'^.ixt:,9 G::".:-a:: `C'i::h.:': ~'. ,:: _:.,. j,. ..~.: a'.. ....~ .:. •. '.- .'; <a;{__.. .i`-. ~SiSi.:`4'3.L"1:::?'.gF::~`,v ~~'.'~1.::$t'$.Y24?~ L~ 2TY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE CC._dANY.. ... PAGE..D2 LIBERTXGUARD AUTO POLICY DECLARATIONS BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS ~vNUre~t ' - - TF1ESEDECV~RA71oNSeFFECrnE 06 15 NAINEp915URED~AIID WILIMO 71~S3 FOR SERVICE CALL OR WRITE: ~-~ .. .. _ ....' MA%IM DEMC(lAK.. :. C.BRIST .R. 4i.. ... ........ _ ..... ...__.......... 591 1 GENEVA,DR_... 2151 I;INGI,ESTONN_RD; ITNIT.150....._;.__.,._.... ':' '. .MECAANICSBIJRG' FA', 1705'5 ' HARRISBDR73`k'71 ':1711b. ::.` - _ _ _ ' 717-545'=4528/80:0-872-2568 - --~~- CLAIMt{: 800-362-5698 ' (CONTINUED FltOl~f kREV.IOII$. PAGE] _... OPTIONAL COVERAGE TOWING 'AND LABOR CAST - $50 EAC& DISABLEMENT $ 6 6 6 ERTENDED TRANSPORTATION EXPENSES $15/$950 ~ la la 12 ANNUAL PREMIUM PSR VEHTCLEz $ 446 448 668 SAFE DRIVER"INSURANCE PLAN CREDIT: A9 A RESULT OF: VIOLATION 3C0 NO SIIRC#iARGE Accxn$NT sco No svRCaARGg . TOTAL" "ANNUAL" POIiICY 'RREMIUM:. $ 1:616. o o' _ . _ .... .. _ ENDORSEMENTS ATTACBED TO YOUR POLICYs 56 2330 .., , , ,. CdiANGE OF ,FACSIMILE. SIGNATURE .. a3a3. ~NNCiAL MEETING DATE CHANGE .... . . PB 05 51 li 92 PElII1SYLVANIA FIRST PARTY BENEFITS COVERAGE ENDORS~Q8DP1' ' PP '0'4"Z2';07 9'0' 'SPLIT UNINSURED ~MOTO&igT9 LIDQITS PENNS~'I.V1s2iIA ~ LSTACREDj '. AS20'49 02 96 IININSURBD MOTOItIST9 COVERAGE - PENNSYI'YVANIA•(STACKED)'.: AS2067 08 97 AMffi7DMSNT OF POLICY PROVISIONS - PENN6'YLVANIlC ' PP 04 18 07 90 SPLIT UNDERINSVItRD MOTORISTS LIMITS PENNSYLVANIA (STACRSp AS2051 12 98 IIDIDERINBURED MOTORIST COVERAfb$(STACRED)-PENNSYLVANIA .. _. '" PP"U3"03''03L''86 ';COWING 'AND LABOR COST COVERAGE ' PP '03 ' 09" 04' 86 SPLIT LIABILITY LIMITS • AS1046 la 89 AUTOMATIC TERMINATION SNDORSEt~GTP PP 03 02 12 89 ERTENDED TRANSPORTATION E%PENSES COVffitACiE _ . _ .', , PP 03, O8 '04: 8'6..: CO'VAj2AGE FOR. DAMAGE TO YOUR AUTO _ ,Y .. . ) ,.:. VEBICLSB COVERE D BY XOIIR POLICY: RATING.... _ ..RATING...... . VEH . ~ ~SODEL IDENTIFICATION # CT,ABS BTATE .TERRITORY _SYIABOL,.. . "1 " 90 "' VOLV 2'4 D' YV1AA8857L1858445 07 PA 37 ~ U27 , OS Z 85 CHEV CAV TYP 1G1JE67W4F7214338 27 PA 37 027 10 3' 83 MRBZ" 380 WDBHA45A7DB026246 4$ PA 37 027 71 .. ... , 4' 79 "BOLE 725153 Op PA 37 .. ~ ,__, AU XOIIR PREMIUM REFLECTS THE FOLLOWING. IF INCORRECT,-CONTACT YOUR SERVICE OFFICE. . CLASS 00 VEHICLE TYPE INELIGIBLE FOR CLASS ASSIGNMENT. Off R M1 1• 000( RYOYY 1 f VY11 Y Y Rb. Y Y T 1 O b11Y• bb 10 YR/111 l { IM Y 36 2 79 10 0 OS 11 9 00 00 R 1 O1 00 0 000 4 8 0 1 00 N JACKET 3075 1289 2 O1 0000 000 4 8 0 1 0 N 3 01 0000 000 4 NO 5 0 1 00 N 4 OS 000 000 0 0 0 1 00 N scats l'1CfyilNl' 6.777 eo'd 80~O1 soot to ~nr LIBL...i'Y ML1TllAL FIRE, INSURANCE COMa.aT1Y PAGE 03 LIBERTYGUARD AUTO POLICY DECLARATYONS BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS Pouc'rNU~x - - - 9 nR.'SEDEttAftAT10N9EFFEe7rvE . ............ ... ~NIIAIEDY~gIRZEDAND W~RRIG ADDRESS ~' ~ FOR 3SRVICE r+.nT,r, Olt ~PRITB.: ~ ... .. .:. .... - 1`F]k7[IDS • DSMCIrAK CHRIST R W 591' 1"'GENSVA DR 2151 f,INGLBSTOWN RD UNIT 150 MECHANICSBURG PA 17055 HARRI$HURG PA 17110 717-545-4528/800-872-3568 . CLAIMS: 800-363-8698' - _ .. - ._ .. _.... .... ... . - .. (CONTINUED. FROM...PRF~IIOUB-SAGE) .-:- CLASS 07"PREFERRED RAT$ - PLEASURE USS - NO YOUTHL'UL OPBFtATORS - COMMUTING LESS TARN 3 MILES ONE WAY - PRINCIPAL OPERATOR AGS 40-64. CLASS 37 PREFERRED RATS .- NO YOUTHFUL OPERATORS . - ,COMMUTING LFlB^9,,; ~'N ;3,•. _.. .. .. "' "" -" ` ' MILES 'DNS"WAY - US88 ADTO LESS THAN 7500 .MILER ANNUALLY - .NO PRIN1GrTPAL OPERATOR AGE 40 OR OVER. """'°CLA98 4'8'PREFERRSO RATE = NO YOUTHFUL OPERATOR§ -.COMMUTING LESS.. THAN 3 MILES ON8 WAY - USES AUTO LESS TITAN 7500 MILES'ANNUALLX - PRINCIPAL OPERATOR AGE 40-64. VEH 1,3,3,4 f3ARAGED AT NAMED IN'SURED'8 ADDRESS TH8 FOLLOWING DISCOUNTS DISPLAYED WITH "YES" HAVE ' E APPLIED TO. YOUR .' .. '•. POLICY. 'Tli$ DIS'COUNT¢ INDICATED AS • "NO" HAYS NOT SEEN 'APPLIED: TO YOUR .. . POLICY. IB YOU HELYSVE THAT YOU MAY BE BLIGIBLE FOR ANY'DISCOUNT(9). _ - T,IST$D~AS~, "NO",'PLSASE'CONTACT 7COUR'LOCA L SALES OR SERVICE.•.RSPRESENTATIV$'.. ~ , SHOWN'ON' THS~'FIRST PAClB OF YOUR' POLI^_7t DECLARATION^.h. . ' ~ .. _..... ;' .._', .. ; . _. . . .;.,. • -. . -- ' . ..: ... c: .' ' ~ . • •• •• .: VSH .S' Eli :~., ~VLH..3' ., VI;H 4. - - • ANTI-LOCK BRAKES NO NO NO NO ANTI-THEFT DEVSCE(S) NO NO NO NO " DEFENSIVE DRIVER'COURSE NO , NO NO „ NO DRIVER TRAINING NO NO. ....NO ..._ . ...NO. ... .-- -...........-- 000D" 'STUDENT NO NO NO .. NO MULTI-CAR YES. .YES YES . NO- . PASSIVE RESTRAINT YES .NO NO NC: - ... . (AUTC4lQ-TIC SEAT BELT AND/OR AIR B!l,GS) _ .. _....... OPERATOR INFORMATION: NO. NAME DATE OF HIRTIi 1 MAXIM DBMCHAK OS/31/36 SPECIAL STATE PRQVISIONSs _ ANY-' PERSON WHO' IONOWINGLY, AND WITH INTENT TO DEFRAUD. ANY INSURANCE COMPANY OR OTBSR PERSON FILES AN APPLICATION FOR INSURANCE OR .STATBlU'.l71' OF CLAIM CONTAINING ANY MATERYALLY FALSE INFORMATION OR CANCEALS FOR THE PURPOSE OF MISLEADING, INFORMATION CONCERNING ANY FACT MATERIAL THERETO COMMITS A FRAUDULENT INBT7RANCE ACT, WHICH IS A CRIME AND SIIHJECTS .SUCH .PERSON TO.: - ' 'CRIMINAL AND CIVIL PEY~ALI'1~I$S. 6sTiC[ w v rw ly r at wowa roYwi lyyy p rwl a r y wy rywy 10 rG a wi p[! oyw 365 3 6 2 79 10 0 OS 1 9 0 00 R 1 0 0000 00 4 B 1 00 N JACKET 3075 1289 2 O1 000 D00 4 8 D 1 00 N 3 O1 0000 ODO 4 NO 5 0 1 00 N aa~~.,__-~ ^~~~ 4 05 ODO 000 0 0 0 1 00 N YO'd 60~b1 9t)OZ l6 Inf •. .r.____._.-_.____~...__.-_._ ___--._ .. . ._ lit` .-2TY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE Ctti MANY . . LISERTYOUARD AUTO POLICY DECLARATIONS BOSTON, MASSACH[JSETTS "" '" ' ' rwacr~eER' ,, - - - n~seoecuw,no-r.~~ecrnre 6~ NANF,Dp-61ipEDAlI~W~A.RIO ADDRESS ' FOR SERVICE CALL OR WRITES MAXIM DEMCSAIt CHRIST R W 591 1 GENEVA DR 2151,LINGLBSTOiPN RD UNIT 150 MECAANICSBIIRG PA 17055 HARRISBURG.PA. 17110 - - --- ""'"" 717-~45-4528!800-872-2568 CLA~M3: 8.0.0-362-5698. -. .. :-'.-' PENNSYLVANIA MINIMUM QIIOTB LAWS ' OF THE' 'CONJM - . TFiE ONWEAIlPH OF PENNSYLVANIA, AS ENACTED SY TBE GBZIBRAL . ONLY'RBQUIRB ASSEND3LY, THAT YOU PURCHA98 LIABILITY AND FIRST-PARTY MEDICAL , BENEFITS COVffitA138S. ANY ADDITIONAL COVERAt+E5 OR COVERAGES IN E7CCSSS OB THS LIMITS REQUIRED. RY LAW ARE PROVIDED ONLY AT YOTJR REQUEST A$_..CB7!'~5--•~-.... .._.. $ABIC COVPRAGES: •- I VEA 1 .. VE8 3 VEH 2 VSH .4 LIABILITY $ 89 . 91 62 0 BODILY'INJURX $ 15,000 EACH PL'RSON ' . $ 30,000 EACH ACCIDENT . PROPERTY 'DAbIAf38 $ 5, 000 EACH ACCIDENT .FIRST PARTY BENEFITS ~ ~ 11. 14 12 0 . 5i 000 MEDICAL 9EN88ITS: ._ _ .. _: .:..:: ~:.... _ ..c:.'::.:.:':`_:`:•~`.:' . .8.:..-aoNBF ~ .-.BaN~~TS ::.. .. _. _ ter' .. •v _ ._ !' - , ..._,...; .:::...,, . v .us ... w~.r.: r._a, u...viv` -.::...,:p '.. .. .. .. - .. ' - :.. i • .. ::.; ..n.~.., .y ~x :JrtY '.1tra5: "ap1~e .Y : ~:::-::=::.PER:~-Vi_ ' , , .. .;, ~,. • _ .., ,. $ .100. ..'..105.__ '. ._..:94: ._... ..• 0.. , , _ ....:TOTXI, .~REMIIIM9 ., ~ .. -_ ~. ~ 299- :. ... . . r~ sea • u ues us • • .• •x ~• r • rn • :n 3 5 311 2 79 10 OS 11 9 0 0 R 1 O1 D000 000 8 0 1 00 N JACKET 3075 289 2 O1 0000 D00 4 8 0 1 DO N 3 01 0000 000 4 ND 5 0 1 00 N 4 OS 000 000 0 0 0 1 DO N ECLS J.'RAldT "L75~ Sp'd 60~Y1 9002 tE InP DAVlD R. THOMPSON Attorrt2y at Law 308 Walton Street, Suite 4 P.O. Box 587 Philipsburg, PA 16866-0587 May 27, 2004 Liberty Mutual Attn: Sharon Bruno 18 Sentry Park West, Suite 200 P.O. box 3051 Blue Ball, PA 19422 Phone: (814) 342-4100 Fax: (8141342-7081 Emait: drtlaafnlhotmail.com Re: Maxim Demchak vs. Liberty Mutual/Maxim Demchak et al vs. Delores Shook No. 01-1817-CD Dear Ms. Bruno: Please be advised that I re erfnchak regarding a automobile accident that occurred bac November of 1999. ns you may or may not know, Mr. Demchak has initiated and been pursu ng an action against the tortfeaser Delores Shook. Recently, we received an offer to settle in that case for the policy limits of $100,000.00 on behalf of Maxim Demchak. For your information, there are four passengers, who are Mr. Demchak's immediate family, who also have claims against Delores Shook. The policy of insurance is through Erie Insurance Company. The policy limits aze $100,000.00 per person/$300,000.00 per accident. As you may or may not be awaze, Mr. Demchak sustained serious bodily injuries and damages that greatly exceed the policy limits of $100,000.00. Through his policy with Liberty Mutual, he does have underinsured motorist coverage. We do intend to pursue a claim against Liberty Mutual for that underinsured motorist coverage. It is necessary that we obtain consent from Liberty Mutual to settle the claim with Delores Shook/Erie Insurance Company for the policy limits of $100,000.00. It would be appreciated if you could contact me regazding this matter and inform me as to any further information you will need from me to process this consent. As you know, consent is required prior to us agreeing to settle the matter for the policy limits due to the fact that we intend to pursue an underinsured coverage against our own policy. RECEIVED JUN 0 12004 BLUE BELL Liberty Mutual May 13, 2004 Page Two If I have directed this letter to you in error, and it needs to be referred to another claims adjuster or department within Liberty Mutual, it would be appreciated if you could either contact me with that information or forward the letter to that person. I look forward to hearing back from you. Should you have any questions or wish to discuss this matter, please feel free to contact me. Very truly yours, ~~~~ David R. Thompson, Esquire THOMPSON LAW OFFICE DRT:jt cc: Maxim Demchak Lee Anderson, Esquire Robert Mix, Esquire RECEIVED JUN 01 2(!d4 BLUE BELL OSBORNE & RETTIG, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 11b-128 WAINIJf S7RBB7'. FIARit1SBVRG, PA 17101 •7ffiFPIiONB (717) 232-3016 • FACSIMIIF (717) 2323538 JEFFREY B. REl'I'IG, ESQUIRE May 15, 2006 David R Thompson, Esquire 308 Walton St., Suite 4 Phillipsburg, PA 16866 RE: Demcbak v. Liberty Matwl Dear Dave: WRTI'ER'S E7CT_: 106 WRT1Elt'S EMAII. ADDRESS: Jreltiefo~LOSlawoa.com 63asmuch as your cheat is asserting siJIIvl claim in this matter and we have boen unable to agree to a resolution of that claim, I have appoimed Jim Nealon, Esquire as an arbitrator. Please appoint an arbitrator on behalf ofMr. Demchak at your earliest conveaieace so that these gentlemen can select a third arbitrator. I will then approach the arbitration paced with a request that it order Mr. I)wnchakto sign offon a release which w371 authorize us to obtain copies ofhis full and complete income tax rdurns. If you are Wlable to appoint an arbitrator within three wades of the date of this letter, I will proceed to file a Petition with the Court asking the Court to appoint an arbitrator on your behalf. We do not want to delay this case any further. Thus, eves though we have made an offer, l swi expect to hear from you within three weeks either accepting the offs or appointing an arbitrator. Thank Y~• Very truly Yours. g JBR/jec OSBORNE & RETTIG, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 126.128 WAINUI' S31tBE1', FIARRLSBURl3, PA 17101 •7EIl+PElONB (717)232-3046 • FACSA4QE (ill) 2323538 JEFFREY B. RETfIG, ESQL3IRE May 23, 2006 David R. Thompson, Esquire 308 Walton St., Suite 4 Phillipsburg, PA 16866 1RE: Demchak v. Liberty Matual Dear Dave: WRITER'S EXT.: 106 WRITER'S EMAIL, ADDRESS: hettig~a.hoslavp~ Thanks for your recent ldter. I do not believe my client is intemsted in paying Mr. Demchalc to obtain copies of his records. If Mr. Demehak is willing to sign the Authorizations that I previously forwarded, we will then obtain and pay for the records. I have appointed Jim Nealon as our arbitrator I would ask that you appoint an arbitrator within the next 10 days. I do intend to approach the arbitration panel to request an order compelling your client to sign off on the Authorizations. Best regards. JBR/jec OSBORNE & RETTIG, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 126128 WAINIrT STREET. HARRLSBURG, PA I7I01 • TEIBPHONE (71'n 232-3046 • FACS1MnF (71n 212-3538 JEFFREY B. RETI'IG, ESQUIRE July 12, 2006 David R. Thompson, Esquire 308 Walton St., Suite 4 Phillipsburg, PA 16866 RE: Demchak v. Ir`berty Mrtual Dear Dave: WR1T'Elt'S EXT.: 106 WRITER'S EMAII, ADDRESS: Jrettie(a~hoslawpacom Last week your client dropped off at my office a copy of his 1999 Schedule C and D. I had understood that he was not going to obtain these but I am glad we now have them. Several weeks ago, I advised you that I had appointed an arbitrator, Jim Nealon. I had asked you to appoint an arbitrator promptly. As of this point in time, I have not received word of your appointment of an arbitrator, We remain anxious to move this case forward. Please appoint an arbitrator within two weeks of the date of this letter. Thank you. ~y ~YYo~ e B. Rettig JBR/jec CERTIFICATE' OF SERVICE I, Jeffrey B. Rettig, Esquire, hereby certify that I am this day serving a copy of the foregoing document upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below, which service satisfies the requirements of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, by depositing a copy of same in the United States mail, first-class postage prepaid, as follows: David R. Thompson, Esquire 308 Walton St., Suite 4 Philipsburg, PA 16866 OSBORNE & RETTIG, P.C. Date: ~~ Harrisburg, PA 17101 (717) 232-3046 ~~ ? L+ T C.. " c o-. _ a~ <.• ~ -{ T nib J "U ~ T~ ~x _. I ')~ ~_ .~, ~ ~ >(-, , : ~.~~ ~. _i -J ~ `J =-~ LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF COMPANY, :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA PLAINTIFF V. MAXIM DEMCHAK, DEFENDANT 06-4900 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 12 day of September, 2006, a Rule is entered against defendant to show cause why the relief requested herein should not be granted. Rule returnable seven (7) days after service. By the Edgar B. Bayley, J. Jeffrey B. Rettig, Esquire For Plaintiff ~vid R. Thompson, Esquire For Defendant :sal J ~d~ .~- ~~ _, ~I , i _ _ . ~. ~~ ~~ ~; ~ ~ ~ ~ r ~.ts t:: ~ ~r'_(: ~' IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY, * Plaintiff * No. 06-4900 * vs. * MAXIM DEMCHAK, * TYPE OF CASE: * Civil Matter Defendant * * * * TYPE OF PLEADING: * Certificate of Service ~, * '~ * * !, * FILED ON BEHALF OF: * Defendant * * * COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR * THIS PARTY: * David R. Thompson, Esq. * Attorney at Law * Supreme Court LD. 73053 * P.O. Box 587 '~, * 308 Walton Street, Suite 4 '~ * Philipsburg PA 16866 * (814) 342-4100 * .' IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE, COMPANY, Plaintiff vs. MAXIM DEMCHAK, Defendant * * * No. 06-4900 * * CIVIL ACTION -LAW * * * CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, DAVID R. THOMP~ON, Esquire, do hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of the NOTICE OF DEPOSITION of Robert M. Stein, Ph.D., in the above captioned matter on the following by! placing the same in the United States mail, postage pre-paid, and addressed as follows: Liberty Mutual Fire nsurance Company c/o Jeffrey B. Retti ,Esquire c/o OSBORNE & R G, P.C. 126-128 Walnut Street Harrisburg, PA 17101 GEIGER & LORIA REPORTING SVC 8 N. Queen St. Lancaster, PA 17603 Robert M. Stein, Ph.D. Center for Neurobehavioral Health, Ltd. Regency Executive Offices 2173 Embassy Drive Lancaster, PA 17603 Maxim Demchak 125 Clay Road Carlisle, PA 17013-7404 DATED: ~j--js' D G BY: Davi ompson, Esq. Attorney for Plaintiff ~ b ~ ~' -u {~'. ~' ` ~ T "°' ~ ,~ rya ~ "~ C ..~ _ ~` ~'~ Y~ ~7 LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY Plaintiff v. MAXIM DEMCHAK Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO: 06-4900 CIVIL ACTION -LAW ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE. I, David R. Thompson, Esquire, Counsel for Defendant, Maxim Demchak, hereby accept service of the Writ of Summons filed by Plaintiff, Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company on August 23, 2006. By: wire 308 Walton St., Suite 4 Phillipsburg, PA 16866 Attorney for Defendant ~ ~ c ~~~ ~ ~~ m r.~., -- -c~ ~,~: ~ _ :.. ..~ ;~-~'s1 ~~ ~ w IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION -LAW LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE, COMPANY, * Plaintiff * * No.06-4900-CD * * TYPE OF CASE: vs. ~ * Civil Matter * MAXIM DEMCHAK, * TYPE OF PLEADING: Defendant * Certificate of Service * * * * FILED ON BEHALF OF: * Defendant * * * COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR * THIS PARTY: * David R. Thompson, Esq. * Attorney at Law * Supreme Court I.D. 73053 * P.O. Box 587 * 308 Walton Street, Suite 4 * Philipsburg PA 16866 * (814) 342-4100 * ~ w IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE, COMPANY, Plaintiff vs. * MAXIM DEMCHAK, * Defendant No. 06-4900 CIVIL ACTION -LAW CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, DAVID R. THOMPSON, Esquire, do hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of the AMENDED NOTICE OF DEPOSITION of Robert M. Stein, Ph.D., in the above captioned matter on the following by placing the same in the United States mail, postage pre-paid, and addressed as follows: Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company c/o Jeffrey B. Rettig, Esquire c/o OSBORNE & RETTIG, P.C. 126-128 Walnut Street Harrisburg, PA 17101 GEIGER & LORIA REPORTING SVC 8 N. Queen St. Lancaster, PA 17603 Robert M. Stein, Ph.D. Center for Neurobehavioral Health, Ltd. Regency Executive Offices 2173 Embassy Drive Lancaster, PA 17603 Maxim Demchak 125 Clay Road Carlisle, PA 17013-7404 DATED: ~ ~~~ ~~~ BY: D id . Thomp on, Esq. Attorney for Defendant ~ ~' C U^ .-t .~ ; n,~` , t ~Ci ? ~, ~ ,~,t ,-t ~: .. _,.., ;. ,. : ; C ^_ ` ~ ~~ Y -~ t't~ IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE, COMPANY, * * Plaintiff * No. 06-4900 * * * TYPE OF CASE: vs. * Civil Matter * MAXIM DEMCHAK, * * TYPE OF PLEADING: Defendant * Certificate of Service * * * * FILED ON BEHALF OF: * Defendant * * * COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR * THIS PARTY: * David R. Thompson, Esq. * Attorney at Law * Supreme Caurt I.D. 73053 * P.O. Box 587 * 308 Walton Street, Suite 4 * Philipsburg PA 16866 * (814) 342-4100 * M IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE, COMPANY, * No. 06-4900 Plaintiff vs. * CIVIL ACTION -LAW * MAXIM DEMCHAK, * Defendant CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, DAVID R. THOMPSON, Esquire, do hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of the NOTICE OF DEPOSITION of Carl Ellenberger, M.D., in the above captioned matter on the following by placing the same in the United States mail, postage pre-paid, and addressed as follows: Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company c/o Jeffrey B. Rettig, Esquire c/o OSBORNE & RETTIG, P.C. 126-128 Walnut Street Harrisburg, PA 17101 GEIGER & LORIA REPORTING SVC 2408 Park Drive Suite B Harrisburg, PA 17110 Carl Ellenberger, M.D. 96 Birch Street Lebanon, PA 17046-9360 Maxim Demchak 125 Clay Road Carlisle, PA 17013-7404 DATED: ~ a' ~ ~D ~ BY: avi .Thompson, Esq. Attorney for Defendant ~' T ~ o ~ ~ ~z ~ ~ ' --- ~ -_~,-r, ~ ;`; ~ ~r, ~ ~ I ~_ ~ ~ ~°~ ~.~ r ~ - ~_a rn _..~ ." ~ Johnson, Duffle, Stewart & Weidner By: JEFFREY B. RETTIG, ESQUIRE I.D. No. 19616 301 Market Street P. O. Box 109 Lemoyne, Pennsylvania 17043-0109 (717) 761-4540 jbr@jdsw.com Attorneys for Plaintiff Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF COMPANY, CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiff NO. 06-4900 v. CIVIL ACTION -LAW MAXIM DEMCHAK, JURY TRIAL DEMANDED Defendant PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW APPEARANCE THE PROTHONOTARY, Please withdraw the appearance of Jeffrey B. Rettig, Esquire and Osborne & Rettig, P.C., on behalf of Plaintiff, Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company, in the above- captioned action. OSBORNE &RETTIG, P.C. Jeffrey B. Retti squire PRAECIPE TO ENTER APPEARANCE THE PROTHONOTARY, Please enter the appearance of Jeffrey B. Rettig, Esquire and Johnson, Duffle, Stewart & Weidner, on behalf of Plaintiff, Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company, in the above-captioned action. JOHNSON, DUFFIE, STEWART & WEIDNER By. rey B. Rettig, Es ire t CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that a copy of the foregoing document has been duly served upon the following counsel of record, by depositing the same in the United States Mail, postage prepaid, in Lemoyne, Pennsylvania, on the ~ day of 2007: David R. Thompson, Esquire 308 Walton Street, Suite 4 Phillipsburg, PA 16866 (Attorney for Defendant) JOHNSON, DUFFIE, STEWART & WEIDNER By e ey B. Rettig, Esq ' e :295243.1 n c _.~- ,.,,,, ~ ~ r~.~~, ~ ; ~ Ri ~ , _ :r '~~ ~ ? .~ - w : ~ ~~~ :y,- .'_• ' r r W ~ p GD