HomeMy WebLinkAbout93-0021
AS OF }/- 011 ~ ).6ll (.,
CASE# I q q 3 - ~ I E'{u:+y
HAS BEEN SCANNED.
ALL EARLIER
FILINGS TO THIS
CASE HAVE BEEN
MICROFILMED.
.
'. .
Michael 1. Collins, Esquire
MARTSON DEARDORFF WILLIAMS & OTTO
PA ID. 200427; NJ 2620240
10 East High Street
Carlisle, PAl 7013
(717) 243-3341
mcollins@mdwo.com
Attorneys for Estate of Robert M Mumma
BARBARA McK. MUMMA and
LISA M. MORGAN,
Co-Executrices ofthe
Estate of Robert M. Mumma, Deceased,
Plaintiffs
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 21 EQUITY 1993
v.
Robert M. Mumma, II,
Defendant
IN EQUITY
STIPULATION OF THE PARTIES
The parties, by and through their respective attorneys, hereby agree and stipulate as
follows:
1. On May 27, 1993 , Judge Hess issued an order directing that the proceeds from the
sale of a piece of real estate, known as Lemoyne Square, be held in a certificate of deposit at
Dauphin Deposit Bank and Trust Company (which is now M&T Bank), and prohibiting
withdrawal from the certificate of deposit until authorized by further Court Order. A true and
accurate copy of this order is attached hereto as "Exhibit A" and is incorporated herein by
reference.
2. The certificate of deposit held by M&T Bank which is subject to the Cumberland
County Court of Common Pleas Order is certificate number 031003914025729 in the amount of
$857,918.16 (as of November 1,2006) with a maturity date of November 10,2006 (hereinafter
the "Certificate ofDeposit").
3. On June 18, 1993, in a related civil action pending in Florida ("the Florida
Action") Judge Mark Ciana issued an order acquiescing to Judge Hess's May 27, 1993 Order of
Court. Dauphin Deposit Bank and Trust Company (now M&T Bank) was not a party to the
630398.\
Florida Action. A true and accurate copy of this order is attached hereto as "Exhibit B" and is
incorporated herein by reference.
4. Subsequently, the Florida Action, Judge Mark Ciana issued an order on August 1,
] 994, directing that the funds in Dauphin Deposit Bank and Trust Company be released to the
parties in Florida. A true and accurate copy of this order is attached hereto as "Exhibit C" and is
incorporated herein by reference.
5. The Florida court has ordered that a receivership be set up to collect and distribute
High-Spec, Inc., assets pursuant to an Amended Final Judgment (which amended final judgment
remains the subject of a pending appeal).
6. The Florida Receiver, April Hicks, has attempted to collect the Certificate of
Deposit at M&T Bank, but the bank cannot to release those funds until this court issues an Order
directing that the funds be delivered to the Receiver.
7. The parties hereby agree that the funds currently held by M&T Bank in the
Certificate of Deposit pursuant to this Court's Order should be released to the Receiver, April
Hicks and delivered to her attorney, Kenneth A. Norman, Esquire, McCarthy, Summers, Bobko,
Wood, Sawyer, & Perry, P.A., 2400 S. E. Federal Highway, Fourth Floor, Stuart, Florida 34994.
WHEREFORE, the parties request that this Court issue an order directing that the funds
currently being held by M&T Bank in the Certificate of Deposit be delivered to the Florida
Receiver, in the form of an Order attached.
MARTS ON DEARDORFF
WILLIAMS & OTTO
BY~~
Michael J. Collins, Esquire
P A ill. 200427; NJ 2620240
10 East High Street
Carlisle,PA 17013
(717) 243-3341
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
C J. WIENER
By
Ericl
P A ill. 8046
2407 Park Drive
Harrisburg, PAl 711 0
(717) 657-7701
Attorneys for Defendant
ft
\., :~~~~:~LytnR
6<kMt- ,4
l..{~
B4WARA MeR. MUMMAanct
LISA. W. MORGAN,
O>beutrl". at the
&tah; otRoben M. Mumma.
~C64.ed.
c IN~ ~~t ,Q.' COM!dONP1.W 01"
t COMBBRLAND COtJNrY, PBNNS'YLV ANIA
P1aLndtfl
NO. 21 BQUlTY 1993
\/I.
RODBRTM.~lt
1)e.teJldant
. ..
I IN EQUITY
twMt ~Ql]QN ~plt P~"P.T ~~AR)' "{NJ'Q8CPQN
QBI>>ll\
ANn NOW, UUI i 1 ~ day of MAy, 1m, aft~t b~WlI\" ft. ,~ tbat tbI
ddcUl<1J1nf tw t.llod to ~ply with tho apcment of the partlcs date4 Noe-Jembor 25, 1991, &no
wat mo requlrtJIMU ot I prollmLaAq tajUl1'doll1uwc oUlcm.~ bccu mo'C, pcndlq dn&l
ruoludoQ of tbl JII.tt6t IGd wit&clit ptoJud!~ f.O either pany to be hCU4 III the coutU of
Plorld& on certain rclit~ liIu", It II ordered and. dirtcted:
1. 'That tho ~1dI of the ule of . p~l of rOIl mate In UIUO)'IlO SqUAre,
. .
Lem*c, P-cnnl1lYama., the '~COt of thtlC pl'OCttdlJagt, C1lrttnUy depolltcd. a=rdh1$ to Wi. .
de!end.\nt. in I certtbtt or dtpot,ft ,t the DI~phlXl Deposit >>aU. lhall be 'Ue! rcmall\ on
dtp081t with l81d Oauphin ~po.u. auk or any other bank whorG &aSd ium AUk' be 01\ cSopaait.
and Utit DO filtbdtawal of 'wy ~n!on thetaot .hall bo Uladc by &t1J partliltmo or tholr aaosu
unlCIS ~d untO htUO I. authari#d by . 00Qtt ot COm.~I~~ lurf.dlcdon.
2. 11\4& the <lclendarit f~cd1ately pWYid4 coda to the ,aid Dnuphlrz PcpOaIt
Bank. or gy blJUC where: .ald '\Un' may be on depo&lr. ot the aictcnco ot tbiI ordet IAct that.
within forty-elDM bobn. tho &f~d&nt provldc 10 lho ptalntffa the Identity of pid cc~care 01
dcpoa1t by fJrovtdlualts &CCO\l1U num~rt the wet ~O\)nt (Ill dopotlt. lod tho prtdlO bUdCudOII.
r
Exhibit "A"
P03094
: .. ;'~_'...' :,0...
of depolit. Nothlnl heteln JhaU prcclude tho plB1ntJff from makina bwnedtate JCMca, upon tho
MfcS Dwpruu Dcpol(~ Bank Of a.ny otbar appr()prlatc Wsut'UttQJ\ ot. copy or tb11 (Jrdtt.
BY THB COt1RT,
l.ou1d M. XaQmIXtt Ssquir~
For the PIalr1uftl
Aadtow I. Gordon. Eaqufro
'Por the Dc&adanl
#rlm
ft
'-, :~~~~APER
t:x~lbl+ B
.. .. ..... ;'. ... ...~:.:;:~:. :~.~~;~~~::~~ .:~':~:ji::;j:~;S:/it~:-~;'.=:~~;::;~:..~:~.~.~.::...~~. ;. .~~ ~.~~ > .::... ....
38
IN TBB CIRCUIT caua'!' FOR TSB
.NINiTB!N~BJUDICIALCIRCUIT,
IN . AHO !'OR. HAR'lfN .COomY ,
FLORIDA.. :
BARBARA MClC. MuMNA and LISA..".
MtJIIHA MORGAN, as Co-BxeautriX.a
. of the BSTATE OJ! ROBBRT M.. MOMMA,
and BI-SPBC, INC. ,. ,a .Florida
corporation,
Plaintiffs,
... .
CASK.NO. I 89~503 CA'
JUDGB I. CIUCA C.
;
.,
!
va.
ROBBR'!' MUMMA, II, and HI SPBC, IBC.,
PJ:RS'1' l'LORIDA DBVBLOPMB~, IHC.
Defendants.
I
ODS.
'. .
THIS CAOSB having come before the Court on the Plaintiff.'
Motion for ,the Imposition of SanctioDs or a Constructive T~.t,
and Motion ,for Contempt, and the Court having hear4 Argument. frODl
couDsel, finds that:
. 1. An Order with regard to MotioD for Pr~liminary
Injunction was .entered on May 27 i..1993~ in :the. Court of Common.
.. i.
Pieas of Cumberland .Count~, P.nnsylvani~, . :S~~d Ordez: shall be
\ . . . .. . .... ... ..;
recog~ized and aaqui.a.d to by. this Court~ ~n4:.~~e De.f.nda~t
. berein .~all comply "i th lIai~Ox:d.r. :~.... . '. . . I
2 .Th..;~:::~~d. .in the ~Unt of. $3i7,.60S.82..:"~h~~1.:;.r__iD. .
. .....<.>.:~~..~~~:..~.<...~,~.:.:~_;.,::,..~~:-.. .... .....:....... ..~..~..._ :','- ". ... '......,.........:....... ". i"'
intact as a .oertifio'ate. of. d~pol!lit: ~~~:'liic.Jl\. Spec',: Ino.., with
Dauphin. neposi t. Ba~k... :.~~t~l: th~;:.~'~.,~~~~~;~ri/:.~f:...t~. .actl~n' ~d
~ I, .' '. "..':." '. .;...... .:; '", ..-.:..'.?~.:.":.....:.~~..-:......r..,:;..,..,.....~'.~.:.:.-:;... ....
. further Order of the Court... . .." '.. ',. .. L
. .
3. The Defendant shall ~o~ply with this Order and the Order
ExhibitltB"
P03088
'. .
. -.
. ..'.. ~. .~., ~.::: ..,. :~ '~;::C:::::7:J.r:;::'J:T(:'':~::::.~~:~'" .-:'~ .:.... ~'.~ ".::~f.:: -~:: .''- ..... '..,
of the Court of Co~n Pleas of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania,
Bo. 21 Bquity 1993.
4. The Motion insofar as 4 construative trust is Bloot a8 a
result of said fore!gn court order.
~.
.
5. Plaintiffs~ Motion :for Sanc~ion. and Conteii~t is hereby
denied without prejudice in the event the Defendant fail. to
comply with this Order or the Order of, t.he ..C~urt of C~n .Pleas
. .
of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, Ho. 21 Bquity 1993. ..
~NB and ORDERED, this I~ day of \rune, 1993, ,in S~uart,
. '., . I
Martin County, Plorida. .._},?':;.:<~.~~ :' ./ .../ " , .
" . ...... J ...~"... .' ....... ......>
.>,;>:::.~... :..:.:;'~ ..' . '... .
CUNCA, CIRCUIT JUDGE
Copies furnished to:
Jordan Pields, Bsq.
Paul R., Regenadorf, Esq.
. .
.....,_...1:10&. ON
: .
.~::~~.::Y.J/\.:.:..,
. t.........'.. 1 ~
.. .
,.
- .
t .
P03089
ft
'-, :~~~~~~PtR
t:xh.J bit L
,'IH (-~l,-"",",I\~.~ 1'" ;.1'" HI'I FIJ;;;:LDS I-IIL.KIHSOH
4a.i";<:t;$I;j! . ",,1;1
1-'.(;14
yo
........"
~"
..
'.,
IN THI CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 19TH
JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND POR
MAR~IN COUNTY, FLO~IDA
CASE NO. 89-503 CA (Clanoa)
BARJARA MCK, MUMMA, at al.,
PlaintiffS,
v.
R081RT HUHKA, II, at &1.,
netendarats.
I
BJPULJ.TIQlI
The parties hereto, by and through the under.lqned coun~el,
her.by stipulate and aqree as follows&
1. pur.uant to the flnaljudgment the parties were under an
ob119&tion to complete a tinal aeoountinq by April 29, 1994.
2. The parties have llgreed, in ord6t" to .ave tlJt\e and
additional aooountlnC) feea, to attempt to resolve the tln~l
aocounting by authorhdn9 Geot"q6 Hadley, CPA on behalf ot the
plaintiff., and 8ruoe Brown, C~A on behalf ot the detendant, to
reach a joint an4 agreed upon final accountinq for the wind up of
H:1qh Spec, 1no.
). This stipulAtion shall effect a stay of the order of this
Court requirinq an acoounting by April ~9, 1994.
4. Eaoh party will bear the co~ts ot their own accountant.
5. The services ot any third party accountant will be stayed
pen41ng th. possible aqr..4 to final accountin9~
6. In the event tbe above referenced aooountants are unable
to a9rQe to a final accountinq, this stipUlation shall terminate
upon notiee from one party to the other that a tinal aoaountinq
~
~
If
If
~
W
\"'
Exhibit "e"
MAY 27 · 94 1 1 : 35
P00014
4072881728 PAGE.002
~
'"'
~TIH Q~~CUIT QOUa~ Ca.. ~o. 8~-S03-CA
oannot. be agreed upon. The aocountantll shall render a final
aooounting no later than 45 days trom the date ot thl- stipulat.ion.
I
It the agreed to accounting 1. not completed ~1thin 45 dAYS, this
stipulation 1. aut.omatically termlnataa. It thia stipulation is
t.r.tnated the third party aocountant shall complet. the flnal
aoaoun~lnq within thr.. (3) ~.ekB fro~ the date this .tipulation ia
terainated. Upon the termination ot this stipulation the parties
are subject to all previous orders of court.
1. The parties further agree an~ stipulate to transfer the
fu~d. ourrently held pursuant to oour~ order in 'ennsylvania to
Florida.
8. The parti.. will exeoute and dubmit a stipulation and
order ~h.reon to ~h. appropriate co~rt in Pennsylvania to release
the funds pursuant to th6 tollowlnq t.rma and Qonditions:
A. ~h. money will be delivered ~o Gary sweet, Esq.,
1100 South Federal HighWa.y, stuart, Florida. as
esorow aqent.
B. The ..crow agent will he instruot@d to plaoe said
tu~d. in an interest bearlng aCQount at a federally
I
insured lending institution as agreed upon by both
parties.
c. The ..crow a9ant shall hold the money oUbject to a
final jUdqment entered in thi8 caUse and ,ubject to
2
MAY 27 '94 11 :36
P00015
4072881728 PRGE.003
w
--
HARTIN alRCUIT OOUR~ c... .0. e'.603-CA
any fu~~her order of th1. oourt O~
stipUlation ot the parties.
WHIRSFORE, the parties submit the abOVe at1pulat1on.
turther
BY
BUCHANAN INQERSOLL, P.c.
Attorneys ear Defendants
One Turnbarry PlaCe
19495 11soayn. Blvd.
Suite 606
North Miaml Beaoh, Fla. 33180
()OS) 93) 54 ~
BY.
J Esq. .
F 612900
fIBLDS , WILKINSON, P.A.
Attorney. tor plaintiffs
42' corte. Avenue
stuart, rlorida 34994
(407) 286-0890
.
ONo.
Datad. . Hay {ft., 1994
ORD2R ADO>>TX.G 8~I'D~ATIO~
1994
~he Court beinq advised of a stipulation betw..n the parties,
having reviewed the file and beinq otherwise tUlly advl.ed in the
pre.d..., it is
OanERID AND ~bJUDQ.Dt
1. Th$ te~ms ot the Stipulation tor Settl*mtnt entered into
betw.en the parties i. adopted by the Court and inoorporated into
tbi. Order.
0011. DD ORDERBD in Chambers., at,' stuart, Martin County,
F1D~id. tbi. ~~aYDt.~, 1994.
~~a~
CIRCUIT ~OU~T JUDGE
Copi.. turnl.had to;
Jord.n Field_, Bsq.
Joro.y A. KO.., Esq,
3
MAY 27 '94 11:38
4072881728 PAGE .F~Q16
j
-
I - '., c,' _. . .' ~ ..v -<' 1 ' ~ , ..1 . 0
-~~.'--
. ., '..,' . . ....~:.::: ::.::,.~..:::~:t. j~:~~;~L;:7::{t:::~:;t~;:;.~;~~:.'2;~~':~:'.'~~... ;'.:;;~:-~::.':::" ........:3 8
IN TQ CIRCUIT COURT FOR '.rBB
.NIIUiDJS.'rB JU1)ICIALCIRCUl't,
IB ..uO l'OR MARTXH ..COUNTY ,
FL9ftIDA. . :
BARBARA Melt. MuMHA and LISA.....
NUMHA MORGAN, as Co-!xeoutrbC.s
. of the BSTAR OJ! RO_aT H.. IWMMA,.
and BI-SPBC, INC. ,. .a Florida
corporation,
Plaintiffs,
. .. .
CASK.RO.I 89~503 CA'
JUDGB I. CIAHCA. (.
.,
I
va.
ROBDRT MUMMA, II, and HI SPBC, INC.,
FIRST FLORIDA DBVBLOPMB~, IHe.
Defendant..
/
ODB.
THIS CAUSB having come before the Court on the Plaintiffs'
Motion for the Imposition of Sanctions or a Construct.ive TJ;"U8t,
, .
'. .
and Motion .for contempt, and the Court having "heart! argwnent. from
counsel, finds that.
. .1. An Order with regard to Hotiol1 fo~ Preliminary
Injunotion waa .entered on May 27 ;;.1993~ in 'the. Court of COlDlDOn.
. 1-
.pieas of Cumberland .County, Penn8ylvani~, .Said.Order Ihall be
. . . ,,' . .
. .
r.~og~zed and acquie..d to by. this cOu.rt~' ~D4:.~~~. D~f.Dda~t
.berain .~11. coaply with .ai~.OJ:d.r.
.'.
'~'.
. .
. .' ,
,.
.
.... . ..... 1"...\, . ' .:. .:
2 .Th.;;?~Wad. .in the amoUnt. of. $3i7,.60S .82.. ..aball ;rema!n. ..
. ......,.~..~.~~~.~~~::..~,..;.P~.~.:.:._:,::,..~~.... '. ......>....- . ..:.:....':,-'~._........., "'-"'l'~""'::"" .. j"
intact as a .cert.ttic'ate,ot .d.po.i~: ~O~:n'Bi~~.:.Sp8c'/ Inc., with
Dauphin Deposit. Sank . .:.i~~til th~;-.'d~.~~.~f.~~~~;::.of 't~. action: and
~ '. .' '. ....:.. -. .;.'...~.:..; . ". ":::'-:',:\f:."-'-:"~~:~~:'~';'.:.'::':~',:;..:_.-;.''..:;<.:,.::... .~. .j....
. further Ord~r oft~e CoUrt..: '. .: _r:;.... '. ":,.' .,,':- 1. .
. .
...
3. The Defendant shall ~o~ly ~ith t~i. Order and the Order
P03088
~. , . ", ". '.
. ,.. ..:. .:.. ...:::.... ~:':~:~~:~:.:~::3.:If"r"';rt::~.:J:'2:'~~~-:;"".~::'",:'.'... .'.~"::~(' :::..,. ..... ....
of the Court of Co~n Pleas of Cumberland' COunty,. Pennsylvania,
No. 21 Bquity 1993.
4. The Motion insofar as.4 constructive trust i. BlOot as a
result of said foreign court Qrder.
..~ .
5. Plaintiff.~ Motion for Sanctions and Cont..pt i. hereby
denied without prejudioe in th& event the Detendant fails to
comply with this Order or the Order of the .C~urt of Couaon . Pleas
of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, Ho. 21 Equity 1993.
~NB and ORDERED. this J~daY of Junot1993, ,in s~uart,
, .~! .,';; ,;'., ,,' . J
Martin County, Plorida. . .....;:,?..'.::,.!: .f :'/" .
.>~:.~.;:4".."....~. :..:,:;~:'''. . ,..' '.::..
I CIRCUIT JUDGE
Copi.s furnished to:
Jordan Fields, Bag.
Paul R.. Regen.dorf, Saq.
I .
*-a\...atJ.oa.o&'lll
: .
,. .
.; ::~;::.:::'!</\:.:.:: . .
t.'. ",',' . I ~
- .
t .
P03089
, .
F:IFILESIDA T AFILEIMumma 5844.1 (estate) 8747 (Kim)\5844.I.Mumma Estate\5844.I.equity21 .cert.setvice
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Jacqueline A. Decker, an authorized agent of Marts on Deardorff Williams & Otto, hereby certifY that
a copy of the foregoing Stipulation of the Parties was served this date by depositing same in the Post Office at
Carlisle, P A, first class mail, postage prepaid, addressed as follows:
Mr. Robert M. Mumma, II
Box 58
Bowmansdale, P A 17008
Eric J. Wiener, Esquire
LAW OFFICES OF ERIC 1. WIENER
2407 Park Drive
Harrisburg, PAl 711 0
MARTSON DEARDORFF WILLIAMS & OTTO
B~(khJ
c II e A. Decker
10 liSt High Street
Carlisle, P A 17013
(717) 243-3341
Dated: November 27,2006
';:; SA
.. -::")
~ .-\
""1:4\
r1 i ~:,
1'.')
_J
~
_.'~
---
{ ."
r'~.)
r\
,
NOV t 8 ZOD6IY'/
BARBARA McK. MUMMA and
LISA M. MORGAN,
Co-Executrices of the
Estate of Robert M. Mumma, Deceased,
Plaintiffs
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 21 EQUITY 1993
v.
Robert M. Mumma, II,
Defendant
IN EQUITY
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, after consideration of the joint stipulation of the parties, this court directs
that the funds currently held by M&T Bank in Certificate of Deposit Number 031003914025729
in the amount of$857,918.16 (as of November 1, 2006) and any interest subsequently accrued,
be released and delivered to the receiver, April Hicks and sent to her attorney, Kenneth A.
Norman, Esquire, McCarthy, Summers, Bobko, Wood, Sawyer & Perry, P.A., 2400 S.E. Federal
Highway, Fourth Floor, Stuart, Florida 34994.
A / . J oJ _ 2.--1 Z--6 D (...
/I((I~
BY THE COURT, /
Bv--/ /l- /L
J.
...~
~
~~-
.~
~
'"
~-
co
::c
aa:
~
z
:~ <:t:
~~~~
~]?j
.,.;... ....,.-
;;~~;!Q
;"J.-~2
:,~jW
.,1.1 a..
:::E
-.::J
U
o
M
>-
o
z
u:;J
c::::>
c::::>
C'-oI