HomeMy WebLinkAbout94-00111
;i j
':J
,
,
il
,
"
I ,
I,
I
"
,
, I I
I
f ;:
I d ,
,
-
-
. ...
(..!):
,
,'f
'"
,
"
'"
i'
i
~
, \
\
\
"
"
"
"
I
Ii r
,
"
i
'I'
I'.,
"
H
\
i
,
I
','j"
I!i;
" ,
II,
"
1
1 '
,
;\
,
I"~
t
"
:i ',i
,
',II
"
I
I,
"
I,
.~
'11
,"
'1' i
"
."
.,'i 1_,
,Ii \
"
.1
"
J
, '
, ,
';;1
. :~
, "
l';
I,
"
~OAAIT P. OI~LAUOH, a.
parent and natural guardian of
ORIOO I. OILLAUOH, a minor and
~OARIT GILLAUOH,
IndividuaUy,
P1aintiffa
v.
MICHAI~ P. MCGXNLIY and AUTH
ANNI MCOXNLIY, a. parent. and
natural guardian. of MICHAEL
MtOIHtIY, JR., a minor,
Defendanta
. IN THI COURT or COMMON PLIA.
. CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
.
.
. ClVIL ACTION . LAW
.
.
. No. 111 CIVIL 1994
.
.
.
.
.
.
H011C1 or ARalTRATION BlARING
TOI ~aren S. coate., Eaqu1re
THOMAS, THOMAS' HArER
305 North Front Street
sixth Floor
P.O. Sox 999
Harrieburg, PA 17108
Marcu. A. McRn1ght, III, l.qu1ra
IRWIN MCRNIGHT , HUGHES
60 weet pomfret Street
Car1i.1e, PA 17013
P~IASI TA~I NOTICI that the Arbitration Hearing in the above. .
captioned matter haa been aet for wedne.day, Augu.t 23, 1995, et
9130 a.m. in the Law Office. of COSTOPOULOS, FOSTiR . rIILDS, 831
Market Street, Lemoyne, cumberland County, Penn.ylvanie 17043.
j;)~J... G,(./o-~
David J. roa&:t.r;- ..qu1re
Board of Arbitr.tor.
Jackie DeArmond, ..qulre
49 South Pitt Street
Carllale, PA 17013
Jame. Johnaon, ..quire
301 Market Street
temoyne, PA 17043
DATil J' "1 '-'lj~ C6'
CIRTlrICATI or IlttVIClIi
I, Davi4 J. roet.r, I.quir., arbitrator in the above.
Qaptioned matt.r h.reby c.rtify that I hav., thie day, eerved the
loX',voing docum.nt by "epol! ting a copy of eame in the Uni t.d
Itat.. Mail, poetag. prapaid, at tlmoyn., p.nn.ylvania, .ddr....d
tOI -
~ar.n I. Coat.., I.quir.
THOMAS, THOMAS ... HAFER
3011 NoX'th Front Strait;,
Sixth Flcor
P.O. Box 999
Harri.buX'g, PA 17108
Ma:rc". A. McKnight, I.quire
IRWIN MC~NIOHT ... HUGHIS
60 w..t Pomfr.t Str..t
Carli.le, PA 17013
J.cki. CeArmona, I.quire
49 South Pitt Str.et
C.rliele, PA 17013
Jam.. John.on, lequire
301 Muket Street
Lamoyn., PA 17043
,I
,
I
,
, ,
"
(ii/",
David J. r
Chai",an 01
ArbitratoX',
I .
1./.. "I-
t.X', .equiX'.
the Board 01
DAtil
'~
\, '~I "20, t(N,)'"
"
(
,I,
, '
,
"
;.1
WILLIAM C;, C;CltTOI'OlJLOt
DAVID /, rcrna
LULII 101. "ILllI
CHAIL" ..cro.
ALLIN c;, WILCH
,ImlY L ITONI.
COSTOPOULOS, FOSTER Ie FIELDS
ATTOINIVI ANDCotJNULLOU AT LAW
131 MAlnr milT
p,o, lOX au
LIMOVNI, PINNSVLVANIA I~
I
TlLlPHONI'6I.II11
AI'A CODITI'
JAX'SI'4O:I1
,
'"
,;'1\
/,
I
!'.i
July 7, 19915
M.~cu. A. McKnight, III, F.squire
Irwin McKnight , Hugh.e
We.t Pomfr.t Prof...ional Building
60 W..t Pomf~et St~..t
Carll.l., PA 17013.3222
ll.1 Gll1augh Y. McGinl.y
111 Civil 1994
I,
"
i/
.
. ..
D.ar Markl
Thl. h.aring was originally schedul.d for January 11, 19915,
.nd wa. continued at your requeat on January 4, 19915. Since than
% h.v. h.ard nothing about reacheduling thh hearing. Pl.u.
advi.. a. to the pre.ent .tatue of this matt.r and 1f n.c....ry, w.
.hould r..ohedul. the hearing.
1 look forward to hearing Irom you.
Very truly your.,
(':Q C
David J. Fostar
DJF/t.w
COI Kar.n Coat.., F..quire
Jackle D.Armond, I.quire
Jam.. John.on, lequire
L'I
, '
"
, ,
"
!.AW O"ICII
IRWIN McKNIGHT" HUGHES
-,~.,-
_UU_1fT1II
IAM/I'D, I/lIOHI'
,....CCA" I/lIOHlI
wriT PaM,Il.T ""~""ONA4 .IJILDlNli
.0 WI.TPaM,,,,rIr""r
OAIlUla, fIINNIYLVANIA IrOlHm
(TI7) '4"'~~
'AX (TIT) I4..U'4
/IAIlO/.D'_ (If""'"
_0' _I~, ('IMo'1HI
_ I/fWINUIWW ('....'IHI
_, 1/lWlN' ""I<N/II/fl (I....',..)
January 4, 1994
Cavid J. PO'I'T, Elqulro
COllopoulo.. FOller " Pield.
831 Markel Slreel
P. O. BOll 222
Lemoyn., POM.ylvanla 17043
Re: Gl1Iau,b v. M~G1nl~X
111 Civil 1994
Cear Cavld:
Thll leller I. to confirm Ihat you have granted an continuance in Ihl. cale Ilnce Ihe
plaintiff i. currently unavailable. AI .oon al he becomes available our office will call Ihe
arbltraloTl and counlello reschedule,
Karen S, Coalel, Esquire, does nol oppose this requesl for continuance, Tho helrlng .01
for Wednelday. January II, 1995 a19:30 a,m. il cancelled and will be reschedule by counsel.
Very lruly yours,
'-J1:;uau&C! ~(~~ ~4
Marcu. A. M~Knishl, III
MAM:.I.
cc: Karen S, Coatea, E.quire
Jackie CeArmond, Esquire
Jam.. JohnilOn. Elquire
Margarel E. OIUaua/l
, ,
, I
"
MARGARET P. OILLAUGH, a8
parent and natural guardian of
GRIGG I. OIL~AUGH, a minor and
MARGARET GILLAUGH,
Individually,
Plaintiff.
v.
MICHAEL P. MCGINLEY and RUTH
ANNI MCGINLEY, a. parent8 and
natural guardians of MICHAEL
MCGINLIY, JR., a minor,
Defendants
I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLIAS
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I
I No. 111 CIVIL 1994
I
I
I
I
I
I
',.,.l,
NOTICI or ARBITRATION HIABlHi
TOI Karen S. Coates, E8quire
MITZGER WICKERSHAM, KNAUSS & ERB
111 Market Street
P.O. Box 93
Harri.burg, PA 17108
Marcu. A. McKnight, III, E8quire
IRWIN, IRWIN , MCKNIGHT
60 We.t Pomfret Street
Carli.le, PA 17013
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the Arbitration Hearing in the above-
captioned matter has been .et for Wedneaday, January 11, 1996, at
9130 a.m. in the Law Office. of COSTOPOULOS, FOSTER & FIELDS, 831
Market Street, Lemoyne, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17043.
DATil ..Ie ..Qa.~\
David J.
Board of
I' 1~1
r ster, Esquire '
Arbitrators
Jackie DeArmond, Esquire
49 South Pitt Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
James Johnson, Esquire
301 Market Street
Lemeyne, PA 17043
g.,'I.loa,. Q' ...VIO.
I ~o h.r.by certity that on thi. ~ay I .erv.~ a true and
corr.ct uopy ot the torlgoin9 P.tition for Appoint..nt of
Arbitrator. by firlt ala.. mail, p08tag. pr.pai~, .4dr....d to the
following I
Harold s. Irwin, III
Irwin, Irwin , Mc~night
60 W..t Pomtr.t Str..t
Carli.l., PA 17013
Dat.1
''J
.)
r.n . Co.
Attorn.y. tor
, 1994
1'1
,
, ,
( ~ ()t:)
~. ~
","1"' ~ d.. Q
('1'''. I"- ('()
, t-'~ (T"'I -
" 2 ;..
r
Vi ~. '.'l"Cl....
- tS <.l
..,. , ~-l.
., ,
i
," I
-'=--~:;-~~..-::.r=:
.-
,
-+--..t=---o::r.-'-
-,.
~
~ ~ ~ ~
J " Ii ~ ~
~ J:; ~I
J" !i
~ %
~
.=
t:;"'-==~ ~--..J-
-
-==--=::::-.::..::::...-:::-:::-.:=::-::-...:.--.
"
"
"
"
I'
'I
"
\.j"
,j',
. .
.
,
,
I'
,I
"
"
"
"
..
.
"
UOMMllNW'AL TH 0' PfNN'VLIIANII\
...--~---.~-~--_.~~ .-----
COIlRT O~ COMMON PL'I\'
Cl}HBE/U,AND COUN'fV
JIIOICII\L plnRICT
NOTICl: OF APPEAL
, flOM
[)ISTRICT JlISTICE JlJOQMENT
COMMON PLi AS No
ill clvil 1994
NOTICE OF APPEAL
NOtlClllfl 11''11)11 thlll ltlll .IPIII.'II,1I11 h,l\ 1111/1' III llw i1hl)\lU CllllI'luf COnlll10n Phlll\ ,It I ,'''lm.11 "rlftl thl! IwlfJ"HI/l1 fl1/ldll/Illllly IIlt1nl~lrlC1 .'USIICU
un thu dilll1 jJnd III lllv CUM! IlltHlIHllllld lIolow.
._..~.t~."aeLP, 11fG~I)~.!'h Jr,
"...... 1lI~ ""llol.,"'''
CI'Y
1M"", ,un. 'UJ. Q" ...'Ma Q~'u-,;~-
.9.1.!.nl). .R!., Fll,rller
.,,,n
""--"--'ii",aoiii--
h"iai... A.......",.,.
_.~u .IJ).d~.8!l _cre"r.Il[J.ve
..,.., ,.........'rn ." '"It c"., 0.. ",
____.}!I)\jJ!ry 4, '1~91t . <!rllll&&.Haraaret
...oIUM HO.
Mf!cl)an/qburg
PA
1711U.
CV 19--90Q.Q.~J.:.Yl_._.__
LT 19._____._______
Thl$ hlod-, Wll! till \HIIII~d ONL.Y wlwlI IIll\ 1101.)111111
R.C.fI,J P No 10088
Thll Nullol tlf ApPll.ll, wtllln "!t:11.\Il~d try till' DI'>IIIl,\ JII5IIr:II, V\ldl <IpntJl1I ,U
11 SU"'[RSEOEA~ '0 ltw ludtJtl1l'tlllot PO'~1~1~liltlltllI11' C.t~iI,
!'.' HC,9 LllJ illY 1 Jr,
"......,
II JpptJlhmt Wi" CliJimilnt ('Of} PlI. R,C.P.J.P.
No 10lJ 1 (6J In iH:tidO Im{",,} Distri,:t Justice, he
MUST fILE A COMPLAINT within rwen/y 120)
clays ;,,,", f"m9 IIis NO riCE of APPEAL,
u_._--'--"--'_._"-'-Sr-;,n:itu'-;.~uTp;;i;;;;i"j;"ir,IrV.(j'O;jil/tV.-----
PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE
IThis seerion 01 fa,,,, 10 I", ,;s"." ONL Y willi" a",,,,II.HlI was I1EFfNOAN r (s/III p" RCPJP, No, 100/17) m at.'rion II.fo,. Oislfier .I//Sriee.
IFNOT USED, dr1tiJch {rom COI>V tJ! noticI1 of ill""..,11 to 1m s,..,vIJc!ulum ,Ip/Wllfm)
PRAECIPE: To P'OI'''lIlola,y
Entorrolo "110" Greaa & Haraarr:t GL llau-i!!-
Ntlm" of Jppell,M(s) /r'"
(Commo" Ploa, No, _,.:l.l1. .civil ,19,9A....,__, \'1"'"'' 1\'I.II11Y 1201 day' "fto~orvi<:. 01
-.--
RULE: To_,.C;~.'8g.~. !l1l~8I1rl!~. G,1 Ua.118h.. 'u,. _.,..,01/1/611."111
NiJftw of rlppel/oMs1
(1) You aro notllll.ld tiltH .t will 15 hurehy ullwrlfd UPOfl you 10 file d compl"I'" in thiS appoal within twunty (201 day, after thlt dale of
se'vlce of th" rule upon 'lOll hy porsonal sUr\lIce or by curllfwd or rllYlslerlld mail.
m "you tlo /lot fll" a <:oml/lol/II \'Iltll,,, tll" WIl". a JI,HlGMENT OF NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU,
(3~ The datu of \IHIJICe I)' thiS rule I' serlJlCII IN"" hy maillS the datu 0' maihng.
O.lt: -.J.4n..,1D..--_, 19..9A.,
-r..Kc
AOPC 31100
'; ,
I
!II"',jI.' i" ,',,/1/. 1,(11.'"
,,'
11'1i. li'lI ,I I jld 1';' 'I /"1 " "~,I 11'11'1 ,Lid /,',1 I
,
, I , "H,I'I' '11'11! IIi! II>ldll iP'll/IIV /'1, ""I,IIIN ,IMlqll ,"II
'I
II
il'\!
I
"
'.
"
"I', ':1"
,
Ii
"
L
"
II
"
, ~..-- "., (j I
'-'II~I \;II,dlr.illlnl"~;IlI,lIill,) ^W
,1l111l,'1 I" ,JlI'I.
,"~'..' ) ..,
.'Oli'" '....\' I',H'I'II/'I 1I11J1,r.A .,111/.11, /1'1 )'0,1 "I ,'IIIII'II"'b'
H^I
III
IHIlW,1l1 fI'IHiW~lifHl';
JIJ ^V(J
UNV III H',111 J IVI
~tHl
f!1I0MR
",
j hi
, '
1,l\li^ln'dl~IL' 1111; 1IIII>IIIIIJlI') I'
rlljjl,ll\ 'P111l;11"IW 11.11,1')1/', ',.,ill,lli'll, 'I'I;'UI
Ill' 1"",,,I'll!!I' W,,\ 'IPlfJ Illlll.li"II,"
Il' I III oIlll]l 1)1\1 P,L\I" I p'ljl ,,"111 Ill) 1)111'
'I"~
"id I II. l,oIll-lI', ii' 111',-''''' I ~,I"I'II.:\ ", "J II '" I,il:
"llll""I'II;II) ?,Il
I' :
1-1111/1
'I"~ <I'
'III ifl,'1 "I,,-'lilJl ,'/I:!ll lhl Jl^tI f
"I' 1'1'1, 1,1"'1" 11',"1' '1,\ I" II ,1111
I'll,' 11"1 1"I,'I'lld An
11'11111
,',I",,', ,",
,','",,1)\'1
HI
,I"illl"J()
"I,' 1.",( I''''! wIll ,d'll,)1
,'"'lj.>lj"';'III;)I'IIIl'!1111
, ,
I.
''it!
Ii! . ,(~II.III"" /" ,Ijll 'J
'il'.I',d Ji')llIlllll') '1'~.Ht'lv III ,-I.lIll)~; '\111 1'/ fd,I)I'
lid,II.I' 11'111 1111'111' J' I 11',11'-", '-\"i',)"cq I
:ll^VOIHV
~" -.
II) AlNflO:>
IIIN~^' ASNN Id "" 1I1'IV11,'rH1WWO,'1
1NIVldVlln~
/0' 1\ 0,/ ,~J'II/ 'i," /, II \~, "I i Ii "d,1/ JII.,', j!ll/ ,I" II, i 'I I .1 i I 1\' " ' \ - I ( I 'JI 11\' I ,V,l.I/1.I"': IJ I /I J III.l SI H V '! 'I,' "I.~ 11.1 I' ili 1<1 ,\,11/ , )
~() ,1:lIAlUS ',10 WOHd
)'1 01
4
W-'
~
'Ii ,..>
",
~ .,
,
~ "
'-~
--
=
'-
Jq
.~. \
~ ~:
\/~ "-
f) ~
~~
IlllU
UNV
""
('
.~
I'<j
"-
~
lVhldV .10 :J~)I10N
{8,
'"::T
-:r
\.
~
; I'
, ,
,
,
,
'II,
"I""}
~, n
'I ~;
/," I,~,
J'
,,'
:' ,I;'
',"/'j ,,,
-~'!.~'A
1"- I,..,
I'"-.t ,\,
, .,i~
.'11 ..t~ '
,"
'"
<0,1
IT
'-
~.
~
,8
'''-1
::.JO':
~
,lil'i
If> I!,' 1 /,'/ ! {,. ,.1 !: /11' I~'! f ,II, Ii
,
1"'1 '{I \ '1".\ r ,I'i iI /.Iii/i'l {\i,' 10 If', , "ri'd.' I' I I',
,
I'll!,)'" Of ~arlVlC:F OF Nr.J1li,'J (11' M'I'f.:AI. AND rlULI' I(hI'II.I,COMi"l./\INI
Ii 'I ! i" ,1/ ~il.1 I J tI , II 'i 1
l.I)i\HIlcIN,'HJ\i I (II I'l i\'!'.J'i't'I\J/\Nt/\
Ct)l!i'J I" III
Cllmbedllnd
"
AI fll )(11111
'11.',1' I
'I'
11-, .1
"I!
x
'II, 'I " ,1'111" (1'1'1, IJI.I I, L L "II il "
"I JUlll!\lfY 12 I 1991, 11,11' " I , "
1 Harold 8, I.rwin,
JanUllt'Y 12, 1994 X ,
(,"
I' I; ';-1 ;1'"
XI (I'y II ",1 I
III,
j'-',II;,),;\,,) 1,'1.",\,111111
Ji:squLre "I'
\,1,'1:: 11',1 'Id Jlll.tl,1 I \';-"'II'J
,j 11\"jl'dl ,,'.!III\" I, " 11ilp\',
,\ I", 1'-, ;.1.,,' r,,), ~i'f" 'I' ",PlH .I; ; If";I' d'" 1'( i '"~,d \ t,
(\
-~i~'~" "
'.....,
.... '..,
, "
, "" '.....
I ..t-.........\.'"d,,j,/
',(.II/HI ,\lJIll. ,II ~I -I ( \ I '1 I
""' I~U ',\ " _AU.~~
~...IA-~vo. .,d4~t.j
:"'1' ,.I,,,' I
'71
, '11'(
oJ.'
v' ,J
" "'~' ""
/' ",
" ,,"
r. rio ",I <fll
9~ 1(,
'1}
.1'1' 'I
NoIoMI s.J
C<lI'doo M BGiIIlr, NoblIY NlIIC
H~nloWQ, Olll.\iin COOtI
My ('AlInn,'sm<1 ~1JI," JI.'" 16, 1001
I, I)
"I'
I , I; ',/, d I
",'(.'/'./I/,l
~,'~
.....4
,/
~,a':"tI"ll
.,,,,"
'.
,I
"
"
,
F1
0115 SJ.? Sill!
Reeelpl fen
Ce,llffed Moll
"
'~
,
"
, :,
,f"
,
,
2
N,) j'h1HIH111' 1:",111.1\111 P,tllihlltd
1)0 ,,,:I II',!: lor IlIlt'/tI,'lIlHI,jl M,lIl
I~j,," fll'\I"I'H.'!
~._.. "
'..'Il" ,_
"', . 'Ai /<1 S, T,ffu r.u. ill, 4.tPu
. 'Ii? ' in, t1Jmf.<t.r ,f?'mr
~a;{'r'J'I,1f1 /'/,j/J
I '1,"1' $
"
,
l
~-....._.._-
, -'d"
" '
~~!,,'J'
I.,
I 'I' I
" .1"-;.,.
':':)'"
. ,\ :,'1,1
", L '
:,!,r"1
''I''
....----...-.
'''>1''',.."
""""
~ ",,,,,,
", ,
h",,, 10,
~ "", "
I
~
u-
K'
"It'l
1\1"
$
1'<1""""" ,I,
~',;(~ ,f (/, t1/~6/"kv
~tjlJ. ''1
Ii?ln .:\,
r Ale #"
((,'4'/' -t;'qU,'IU.
.%#10. jr?"?
"
"
, ,
,'I
q
~,."..'
I,
! '
,
,\
.
,- .
'" '-
".1....
"
dJ.,l,"'!t..",
:J
"
..
P 0'15 517 54i!
'2' ~;~~~r.~~~~~~~""" """,,10',1
.';J\fll[l~'/:t,' Oil JlIII lJi,1! 10f tnl'Jlllollltll\ol1 Mall
(~)lltJ Ill!,,"I'Jtll
, ,
r
,) ,
1'.'
'.hiT. .;r;SfI~ f, t/!f1t1I!!~lll
, . . I.
,SClM." ttll(f~.;y.ft.f,.r:...
j(1.~c"-rml~~4I!tffJ;/?~~ ~
$
, ,
,
"
~--'_." .-._-~ .
"
,'I \1
\,
,
, ,
, ,
"
I
,'''' ...
TIlCIMAI. 'NOM" . IWU
IYI leI/In'. COIlII. I,qul,"
kl.nll"OIdon No. U....
ao. North "In, '''"'
'.0. "0 ...
H"ri.~u,.,'A 1710"0'"
MARGARET GILLAUGH, a. par ant and
natural guardian of QRIGG I.
GILLAUGH, a minor, and MARG~RET
GILLAUGH, individually,
Plaintiff.
IN THI COURT or COMMON PLIAS or
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PINNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION ~ LAW
NO. 111 CIVIL 1994
v.
MICHAEL P. MCGINLEY and RUTH ANNE
MCGINLEY, a. parant. and natural
guardian. of MICHAIL P. MCGINLEY,
JR., a lllinor,
Defendant.
110'1'%01 '1'0 JL~
TOI Margarat Gillaugh, a. parent and natural guardian
of Gregg I. aillaugh, and Margaret aillaugh,
Plaintiff., and Harold S. Irwin, III, I.quire,
Attorney for Plaintiff.
You are hereby notifiad to plead to the enolo.ed New Matter within
twenty (20) day. from .arvioe hereof or a default judgment may be antared
again.t you.
,.~., I.
e
BYI
DATil
.2;" I
I~i
aren.
1.0.152654
301l North Front street
P.O. Box 999
Harri.burg, PA 1710B-0999
(717) 237-7121
Attornay. for Defand.nt.
i
, I
. ,
'MOMAt. 'MOMAt . HNIIl
IV, K."n'. C...... IlqIIl"
lcIlntifl.lti.n N.. .at..
aOI N.rth ',.n, .."..
'.0. ... "'
H.,riMu',,'" 1710..0..'
MARGARET GILLAUGH, .. parant and
natural quardiln of GRIGG I.
GILLAUGH, a ainor, arul MARGARET
GILLAUGH, individually,
Plaintiff.
IN ~HI COURT or COMMON PLDS or
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSVLVANIA
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
No. 111 CIVIL 1994
MICH~EL P. MCGINLEY and RUTH ANNE
MCGINLEY, a. plrent. and natural
quardian. of MICHAEL P. MCGINLEY,
JR., a minor,
Defendant.
D.... '1'0 OOXlIoal1l'l' .1'1'. II.. 10.'1''1''. ~ OOQII'l'..OIoaIIl
1. Admittld.
2. Admittld.
3. Admittld in part and dlnild in part. It i. admitted that on
Ootober 1~, 1993, at or about 21~~ p.m., Defendant Michael P. McGinley,
Jr. wa. operating a 1991 Chlvrollt Cor.ica .outhbound alonq U. S. Route
11, Carli.la Pikl, in Hampden Town.hip, Cumblrland county, penn.ylvania,
and wa. approlohinq the intanlction of sportinq H111 Road with U.S.
Route 11, Carlilla Pike.
It ii, however, .pecifically denild that
Defendant Miohall P. McGinley, Jr. wa. oplrating hi. vehicle on thl right
berm. To tha oontrary, Dlfendant wa. about to enter thl right turn lane
to maka a right turn at tha intlr'lction of Sporting Hill Road with U. S.
Route 11, carlille Pikl.
4. Admi ttld.
5. Admittad.
6. Danied. After n..onabll inv..tiqaUcm, Daflndant. an without
knowlldga or information auffioilnt to form a bllilt a. to the truth of
tha aVlrmlnt and proof il dlmandld.
7. Dlni.d. Th. avermlnt. of Paragraph 7 oon.Ututl leVll
oonolu.ion. to whioh no napo"". b required. By wlY of further In.wa..,
it ia .paoifiollly d.nild that Daflndant Mioha.l P. MoOinllY, Jr. WI.
nl911vant and olrel... in any manner what,olv.r. Furtharaor., it i.
.paoifioally d.nild that D.fendant'. vlhiol. 0011 ieSad with the
PlainUff '. v.hiol. a. Plaintiff WII lawfully prool.ding into the pI..kinv
lot of Hollywood BilUard.. To thl oontrary, Plaintiff'. vahiol.
oollidld with Dlflndant'. vlhioll whill Plaintiff wa. makinq a lift-hind
turn atter Plaintiff tailld to yield thl right of way to Dlflndant '.
lawfully prooa.din9 v.hiol..
a. Daniad. Thl aVlrllllnt. of Paragraph 8 oonaU tuta leqll
oonolu.ion. to whioh no rl.pon., i. rlquirld. By way of furthlr In.wer,
it i. ,ploifiollly d,niad that Dlflndant Miohaal P. MoGinllY, Jr. WI.
oarlll.., rlckla.. IneS/or nlgli91nt in any manniI' what,olver. Moreove..,
it i. ,ploifioally dlnild that Dlflndant Micha.l P. MCGinlay, Jr..
A. failin9 to hlvl hi. vlhiol. undlr prop.r oontrol,
B. improplrly drovl on thl right barm of tha hi9hwlY,
c. midi In improplr pa.. on thl ri9ht: of othlr vlhioll. lawfully
in thl .outhbound lane of U. S. Rout. 11, carliale Pika,
D. failinv to taka appropriate action to Ivoid tha Plaintiff'.
vahiob, IneS
I. othlrwi.1 failaeS to Ixaroi.. appropriatl carl Ind elution.
9. Dlniad. Tha aVlrmant. of Parl9rlph 9 donatitut. la911
ooncluaiona to which no r..ponaa il raquirld. By wlY of furthar In.war,
- 2 -
however, it ie .pecifically deni.d that Defendant w.. nevllvent and
carele.. in any Dlann... what.c.v.r. With reap.at to the allevation
cono.rninv the a.ount of Plaintiff'. prop.rty da.aq.., the allevation i.
.peoitically d.nied .inoe aft.r rea.onabl. inve.tivation, Daf.ndant. ar.
without knowledv. or infor.ation .uffioi.nt to forDl a b.lief a. to the
truth of the av.r..nt and proof i. d..and.d.
10. p.ni.d. The aver.ent. of para9raph 10 aonaUtut. laVal
oonolu.ion. to which no r..pon.. i. r.quir.d. By way of furth.r an.w.r,
how.v.r, it i. .p.oifically d.ni.d that Defendant Mioha.l P. McGinley,
Jr. wa. n.Vliv.nt in any mann.r what.o.ver and th.r.for., it i.
.paoifically d.ni.d that the n.gligenc. of D.f.ndant Micha.l P. McGinley,
Jr. i. .0 ol.ar and oonvinoinq that D.fendant.' r.fu.al to pay tha
prop.rty da.av.~ and r.quiring Plaintiff. to litigate thi. matter i. an
abu.e of proo.... To the oontrary, D.f.ndant. have a valid d.f.n.e to
the within acUon, naDlely the Plaintiff'. neglig.no., and therefor.,
Plaintiff. ar. not entitl.d to any award of attorn.y'. f....
WHEREFORE, D.fendant. Michael P. McGinley and Ruth Ann. McGinley, a.
parente and natural 9uardian. of Michael P. McGinley, Jr. d.mand jud9Jllent
in th.ir favor and againat the Plaintiff, and r.qu..t that the
Plaintiff'. co.plaint be di..i..ed.
liD Ka""..
11. Tha property damage. all.gedly .u.tained by the Plaintiff. are
the reeult of the n.91i9ano. of Plaintiff Greq E. Gillauqh whioh .erve.
to redUce or bar any recovery to which the Plaintiff. may b. .ntitled
pur.uant to the pann.ylvania comparativ. N.gligence Act, 42 Pa. C.S. S
7102.
- 3 -
u.
directly,
ne9ligence
followin9
A.
.. .
c.
D.
I.
r.
G.
H.
I.
J.
The ClclUaion occurrin9 on octobu 1!'1,
proxi.ately and/or .ub.tantially by
1993, wa. oAu.ed
the oarele..ne."
and reckle..ne.. of Plaintiff Ore9 I.
partioular..
Gillauqh in the
fa1l1n9 to yield the ri9ht of way to onoomin9 veh101e.,
fa111n9 to .aintain a proper lookout for other trattic,
be1n9 inattentive to the condition. of the road and the traffio
thereon at the afore..id time and plaoe,
operatin9 hi. vehiole without due reqard for the right, .afety
and poaition of Defendant'a vehicle,
fail1n9 to keep hi. vehicle under proper and adequate control
.0 aa not to expo.e other u.er. ot the roadway to unreaaonable
riak of harm,
operatin9 hi. vehicle toe ta.t tor the condition. exi.tin9 at
the afore.aid time and place,
operatin9 hi. vehicle at a .peed greater than w.. rea.onable,
proper .nd prudent under the condition. then e)(i.ting,
tailin9 to u.e that degree ot care, caution and akill
re..onably required under allot the circum.tance.,
tailin9 to look and tailing to a.certain that it we. aat. to
.ake a left"hand turn into Hollywood Billarda, and
taUin9 to take appropriate aotion to avoid the Defendant'.
vehicle.
COUII'l'l.CL~IM
13. paraqraph. 1 through 12 ot Defendant.' Anawer to complaint with
New Matter are incorporated herein by reterence.
14. A. a r~.ult of the atorementioned carele..ne.a and neqligence
of Plaintitf ore9 I. aillaugh, Detendant Michael P. McGinley and Ruth
Anne MCGinley auatained damagea to their vehicle in the amount ot
$5,872.47 and incurred rental coata ot $420.46.
- 4 "
."lIfICaIJIOM
I, M10hael P. MoGinley, Jr. .tate that I am familiar with the
fact. and alleqation. .et forth in tha fonqoinq .....1' to
OOllPlalat vi tit ..v ..tter aad aO\latualala. I have read the
fora9oin9 dooumant and hareby .ffirm that it ia true and oorreot to
the ba.t 01 my parlonal knowlld9a, information an4 baliaf. Thi.
Verifioation ia mada purauant to 18 Pa.C.S. S 4904 relatinq to
unsworn fa11ili04tion to authoritial.
)'11 ' </.'-'~J'~'" ,
'ht".;'t'1.,J(~ /.. ..;/<,..:::t #I.,....,y' 'J/~.
liIo .el P. MoGinley,- Jr.
DATil n) It, t('1
"
",
I
I 'q
,
, , '
':
, '
','
'<,:
, '
"
,I,
:
"
"
,I
",
.
a...I'Joa'l O. ...Wlql
I do hereby certify thllt on thi. day I ..rv.d a true and
carr act copy of the toregoing AA.ve~ '0 0..,la1a' vi'b .av Na".w
aa. C1eu'e~.lai. on the tollowin9 by tint 01... .aU, poataqa
prepaid, to the followin9 addra"1
Harold s. Irwin, III, I.quire
60 W. Po.fret street
Carli.le, PA 17013
'.OICA., '.OKU I lIA,n
DATil ;/7/,y
BYI
~aren S. coate., laquire
30& North rront street
P.o. Box 999
Harri.burq, PA 17108-0999
(717) 237-7121
Attorney. tor Detendant
, I
, I
, ,
"
I' ,\
"
I'
"
dI; ,. ..
. ,r I
~1 "II ;.,
12
.,-,
, .
.n
,;,1
I.....
, '
',I
,
"
\
"
11,i'
,II
,
,',
"
'I
"
"
,I,
,
,
, , ,
"
,
1 ,
I
1 " 'I, " ,
,
"
"
"
" , , "
, , "
" '
, ,
'\
"
,I
i
"
\
',I,
...
MARGUIT GILLAUOH, a. parent and
natural guardian of GREGO I.
OILLAlJOH, a minor, and MARGARET
OILLAUOH, individually,
Plaintiff.
IN TH! COURT OF COMMON PLEAS or
CUMBERLAND CoUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 111 CIVIL 1994
MICHAEL P. MCGINLIY and RUTH ANNE
MCGINLBY, a. parent. and natural
guardian. Of MICHAEL P. MCGINLEY,
JIl., a minor,
Defendant.
DEFENDANTS' REPLY TO PLAINTIFFS' NEW MATTER
15. Dafendant hereby incorporate a by referenoe Paraqraph. 1 through 14
of it. An.wer to Plaintiff.' complaint with New Matt.r and Counterclaim.
16. Denied. It i. .pecifioally denied that the poaition of Defendant.
a. .et forth in their An.wer to Plaintiffa' Complaint ia in direot
contradiotion to what Defendant Michael P. McGinley told the inve.tiqating
police offioer at the .oene of the aocident and proof ie demanded.
17. Denied.
It i. apecifically denied that Defendant Michael P.
McGinley told the inve.tiqatinq officer at the acene nf the aooident that he
entered the berm of the highway approximately 90 feet north of the point of
impact and proof i. demanded.
18. Admitted.
19. Denied. After rea.onable inveatigation, Defendanta are without
knowledge or information .uffioient to form a beliet aa to the truth ot the
averment and proof i. demanded. By way of further anawer, however, it i.
FEO 2 Ij1994
, ,
901.112&'1'10.
I, luth Anne MCGinley, a. parent and natural ~uardian of MiChael P.
McGinley, Jr., a minor, .tate that thia Verification i. .ade on behalf
of Oefendant Michael P. McGinley, Jr., and that I am familiar with the
fGct. and allagation. .et forth in the fOrlgoinq complaint with New
Matter and Counterelaim. I have read the foreqoinq document and hereby
effirm that it i. true and correct to the be.t of my per.onal knowledge,
information and baUet. Thia Verification i. made punuant to 18
Pa.c.s. I 4904 relatinq to un.worn tal.ifieation to authoritie..
i1&~'-YJ1df.:.d, (f
-
Dated. /~6 21;", IP9c(
: '
"
'I' '
I,
I'
, ,
"
I
, " ,
, I
:1,
'I
, I
!I' II
,
"
I I,
r'rn }) H 19~4
,.al.IC&'1'lp.
I, Miohael P. Mo<Unley, 8r., u parent and natun 1 vueX'dian of
Miohael P. MOGinley, Jr., a mlnor, .tate that thi. Verifioation 1. made
on behalf of Defendant Michael P. McGinley, Jr., and that I am familiar
with the fact. and allevation. .et forth in the foreqoinq complaint with
New Matter and counterclaim. I have read the foreq01n9 document and
hereby affirm that it i. true and correct to the be.t of my per.onal
knowledqe, information and belief. Thi. Verification i. made pur.uant
to 18 Pa.C.S. S 4904 relatinq to unaworn fal.lfication to authorltie..
91f-'~tf~-!i4,
Datedl It 6' 2S,I1'11,/
, '
I"
"
;'1
, ,
\,
, .
"
I; ,
"
, "
,III
iJ;
.
Tl'
PI
,"
.,J'
,''I'
I
"
"
"
"
"
(")
I"'l
1,'....\'
",
,I'
":r-
I
,,,
';~,'
"I
,-
~
otl~; ~
..~Ii
=--
,
,
"
i,
"
"
"
';1 '
, .
"
.
MARGARET GILLAUGH, I' p....nt
and nlturallulrdlan or GREGG E.
GILLAUGH, I minor, Ind MARGARET
GILLAUGH, Individually,
Plal"tif/i
IN THE COVRT 0' COMMON PLEAS or
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
VB.
NO. III CIVIL 1"4
MICHAEL P. McGINLEY and
RUTH ANN McGINLEY, a. parent.
Ind naturlllulrdlan. or
MICHAEL P. McGINLEY, JR., . minor
Oq,,,da,,', IN TRESPASS
e!4I!i'llf~f' RI,YPQNS/i TO PEFQ.NflANT$:.
B6JJJlE$T flJ.B. Pjflj},UClI0N OF I)OCl//tmt:{Q
NOW come the plaintiffs, by their allomeys, Irwin. Irwin &. McKnlsht. Eaqul..... and reply
to defendants' request for production of documents, .ubmittinlJ Ihe followlnlJ:
1. 1iXl(J81T "A": Copy of Hampden Township Police Depll1menl notiflcadon of
accldenllnvestigadon,
I
2. 1i1UIJ.JlJI..:J: Copy of Pennsylvania State Police report prepared by inve.dgatina
officer and dated October J 5. J 993.
"
3, 1lfll.JJJJI.::J: Copy ofleller lTom Fetrow Insurance AalOciate., dated Octob.r 21.
1993. which was .ubmhted to defendanla' insurance carrier a. a cove, letler to plllnlift't' property
damqe "timat..
,I
4, 6JJJJJJJJI.!!.J: Copy of dllllllo. olllmlto propared by Varllty Volk.wlj.lI. I,",..
dlted October 18, 1993,
IRWIN, IRWIN. McKNIGHT
February 22-. 199"
~.........-'l
We.t PomfTot Profelllonal Bulldlna
60 We'l PomfTol Slreel
Carll.le, Penn.ylvanla 170 I 3
(717) 249.2353
Supreme Court lD No. 29920
"
~
1b.e attached document. are lrue and correct cople. of all document. requ..ted III the
forolOlna reque.. for production of documenu, 1 under'land Ihal false Itatement. made herein
aro .ubjectlo tho penaltle. of 18 Pa,C,S.A. Section 4094, relatlnl 10 un.worn faI.lftcatlon to
authoritl...
FebJ'Uary --LL-. 1994
~A.uT/Y~~
ARET OILLAU -
",
"
I
"
"
i'l,
, ,
"
"
,I
"
"
,
,"
,
,
"
i'
'I'
"
'I
"
"
,I"
"
I!
,
"
, ,
!
II
'.
"
"
"
.
,
, ,
, "'.
"
"
,
"
, ,
I
"
'"
,,'
"
"
"
"
, ,
IXIIIBIT "A"
i!
NOTIFICATION OF ACCIDINT INYlaTIOATION
HAMPDEN TOWNSHIP POLICE DEPARTMENT
230 IOUTH lPORnNQ HILL ROAD. MECHANIClIURQ, PA 17011.1Ot7 I 17171781.2108
Nolin I. her.by glv.n th.lth. .eeld.n' Id.nllll.d bllow II b.lng InVI'llgllld by thl H.mpd.n Townlhlp PollOI .nd 'h.t th.
Commonwl.I'h 01 P.nnlylv.nl. Polle. Aeeld.nl R.po" will b, lubmlUld II plllellbld by Ii.ellon 3'411 (0) 01 thl V.hlel. Cod..
POlle. tf~r.IDfN' N1JI.l III
LOCAl ION Of ACCH>fNr
t"", /,,'r I, ,.(
-
"UIINIIIIIII '1CtIOlNI
I'IS~
1<-. f\ .,~'
OHlCIR'B NA'-'l
{n r f1 ".1,..""
U IT 2
3~~:~:~~_L~_.~J~lL.f.rf..,1.UJ ... 38J}H". .35~~~:}l>LLL. _.._"~.._.._I1Y.t4.'i~~L____ ".!!"
~~. ;;~~!;,~!"-'_.,,-'i '117ft} I 'Ui,I,J.~ .. .30;!'~(,!~,~ "" ... _. V.CJJ I..Q!J.J:.!_Y.~"-".
:: :~~~.,,/!.~J!!'Lf.'.J~,f!lt'1(. Lid'}!] /"1 ;: ::~::: .~!W ..r:.!.Jr".'::j!!" l'i!.!!:?!J 4
~~~.-l-'-U.!'.'!".J-'L~L,!.t_J:, L..__.___ .., ~1I~153__."L_/~!'.i~! I,,~~!~__._.__
:: t~~:;!!_fF~~0:':~.j1;='" ~?:~r,~__.._ -. -;}~~:J~_:~.'=r~~~~~~~1~~::L H.
.5 MODEL INO' .6 INS .~ ~OOflINO' (' ., IN
IOOYT'I'Pll r"n',~,', Vl< NI UIlKI IOOYTVPII ...,r"'GiLl Y
" ,00,-- 'ujSpir.iiL- ..--.-. ~)YiHlrLf-u.-" . ,,,,iioD,..'.-.--'.-. (.aj&PICiAL ----. .1 vtHiCll
'. TYPf ,- U610f ~.' OWNUSHIP hP( -- USAOE CWfNIASHIP
t>O)' 'NilI'-~-'- (ii)VEHIcLl"-..----- (52)IAiVii----.. ;0)""',;:...;;,6.----- '~i'TIEHIC"..---.--.- iii"ITIlAVIl
\- POINt --' 51AfU5 \:. SPUD ' POINT ,. TATUS \J IPIIO
iii)YfHim---,T.'joiiiv!il-r=-::J'.'-- (!o)o.iVi,----...- n.__ ,iiTiiHIcLl---------- ,.-iiiiV",-r-, 5')DAIYIR
... Q,u.OI(Nr '- . PRf!ENCF L_ '- CONOtTIQN . GRA~~Nr -- PRfSfijCE l---J CONDItiON
5e ~~~'!...___~~~,'~~.__._ _~_._____.__.m_.... .__. ._~7_t~~~~___ ~_~~~J!_R______~' II ~ ~~~l=.1.
'5 DR'''' . . 65 DAlYIR /. (, /.
51 :~:. _.Jl!.....l.!tL L_ ..!..!.,~t!'J]!9--Yf,--.--... li"i.~:.---~!W...!:.:.......!' f .1 'j.__
..!:PE~"!_......1JL_/..!.._'_~._!,'..!.'I_~!.!L_,..J..!.L.. _.u_..__.__~~E55 ._~.L___r'~!~,t..,I,,~.1 7./.
~Cln.!mf MCln,S~TE I
,,{tf",CO}Qf. 52 D":O~':::f:J;~i'-.~ -,L~jl. -l~J "'ONI--.--.-. -- dti'~ C9~~ .O/~:;. 'j-!:~; '1: 7 'J ,t ";3 : ~:NI
BIRTH '. - f .. 1 81RTH .~ .... .
e4 (O~~ ~EM \. e~ (Jnlv(A (- 615 DRivER 6. (;011'.1 VfM.. e5 ~lvEA ft6 I)fIr~fA
Y N J Cl.ASS. 5S, Y : N '"" ClA65 ~U
ii'- c.R.itiER'-'-'----. . .-----....~-.-.-. --------.--------- -..~.....-----. "6-i--'''''RlfR'--'-.--.'-..-.-- --------- ------------
Hr!
lJfjKO
17 "~,,
r
___~__.. -,.----__._.,_.. -___._~~__ _._._..__.._______.__h_.__._._n_._.____
e8 t.flRlfR
89,~~A~~11 -.---.~-----.-.-- - ..____.__h_.._.__~______._._ ~--'--." -.-------
~~.~---_._.-
10 USOOT, .-J-ICG'----.-n.---.-- PUC,-----..---..-n-----.
------.- ,..... ----..-.--....---..-.--.-.-- -.-----..-.--.----.---..--.---
~1 VEH (J.l\CAIlOO ,. G'rVtR
.. CONFIl) ...'Y BODY TYPE
-;&. r.o-cii----- l76i.H;:;"RDOUS. ------~----- 71 Rflf.5ioi~-H.;-~ii..-.--'-
..lf6 .- ....'F.IlI.lE '!' '. I I.,tjl(
~ CO~r'~!~L7!.,H!_L;'J~'r:_f..uLltJ:'_'_'''Q___
-11II111- POl,cnlO ^'rz.JJ 7'7(,,.,
'6 DISCPIPMN 0' OAI,IAGfO PRI)PfRTt
U CA"Rlf~
ADDRISS
... ...._--. .----.-.-.--.
~9 ClT'!' !;tAU
& lIP COOf
.10--USDor.-.--.----- ICct-----~--- PuG,
72-j,iHm-.--n- (71)C~Rr,D.-._.
CONFIG - BOCY l'rPI
r~ .NO.-Of~---"~ (1i) HA~ROOU5 .-
._US '-' tlATEIIlIAL5
l;l,)I,IPANY
____ t..!....!~!.~_~_, ."~'r ~f.'r,'''''''
POllCYNO 4!C~'('S (JV'~H " -
7. GVWR
INUIMCI
IUOIMATIOII
-11II111-
OWNfR
.ODRms
"'DNF
MOI~lI.Il._rlOfl
L
." , )'/l" '1..'
"
" ,
'1\
,
I,
,
,
"
:/"
,
'I
,
, '
"
"
Iii
"
,I
"
,
",
I
1
1\'
\
,I
\,
"
",
1'1'
, ,
,I
,
i
[:
.~
,
,
I
, '
BXHIBIT "B"
, '
,
I
@ m~R\fi,~~rn,~
COMMONWEAL TH OF PENNSYL VANIA rT;"..u"J .'
~ POLIC. ACCIDENT REPO!!T ' !,
RIPOHTAIU ~ NON . R~PORTAILI l ) '~NNOOT UI ON Y
-",,"",." --
" ' i;i~, ' Ii. 'II ') ~ IQN
.~~:~ 2 2HL-.__._.__ ._____________ ij-ij~~:~lbtnJ.-~-,,---...
l r~~ ~.,..J/I~ ~~~~:f.gJltt~~~f-~~~: -~~~H)RINClP~;.~.fjN~ORMA rlON
., iiNilTlQAtOll IAPOI P ~.. ROUll NO. OIl
-==_~-...h'".-~/J.JreN..--.!!lJ~~A."---m , .. _.I!~E.EJ.!!t!~L Glt/1#/I_1!1!.L....__-ym. c
.~~' IAPOE 2J SPUD _~rPI O..J~
'~iOOAfiiN 'O~;;.1)-- -n:VALN..~;::C;-" ~~~_~ --.L~~IT~__-=~~~~"fE~;id~/N~JjgAD.~()N~
."J" '''\ .t~_ '"."',F" '. -.-- -- , ' - '.. ., . 2~ flOUTE NO UM
"i~c;';~ii"\~;~,j;, t~qcl~NT INI'O"~!tqH ,'; .'; , ' SIAUT NAME
~,~DEo;__Jlir~!1_.~_ ::~~{J.!I~" .,,-.. -.- 27~~r~"~~-",;~rl~~~i~:R~~c7!ld~~~!-
'I , ~~~~O ,. ~~~~-'''Y tC~.it~ iO"'~tg~f;l~~~t='-Slo ---~Jt11iioaJ"
II DiDVlI1lClI~'IlTOIIRIMOVlO 1,VIHICLI0AM,AOI ,--, JIOIRECTION. N S E~ ~iATANC~. I."
f1\OM IHIICINI! 0, NONE UNIT I [..'I ...1]\0101 SII~ ~Ji~.Q~..!.I!.L..J.Jl" n-.
UNIT I UNIT' . L OHT ~.J JJ DISTANCI WAS r1 /Of
, I :.:-. MEASURED !r.j ESTlMATlO->>L
Y KJ N 0 Y 181 NO:: ~~ER'rTE UNIT' [~ 34 'coNsTiiij'CTlON I "I ETRmlC PRINCIPAL INn~..CTJ/jO
,. HAZAADOtJ' "-~~EN'NIlOr'-'-O"'.------- lONE () g~~:OL [Q] I-I
M TERIALS yON PROPIRrY V N
Ii,' . . "i~'~~:k:':~~' ~:lL:', UNIT lj ";I.'~r;~~'~.~"..'~', ).,.:," ,~'~Jf; r::~:l:,:.ik.~~j~':~~:~'~'~h' '~_:'tl~ltUHI'.':'''~'Y ~;~,i,~t~tJ~. ,.
LAR ,L~6i 17~~TE ,,,,, Jfi7L, 3SSTATE 3I'~~~~~~7 b~ 7'~~TE z:"J~
:II 'A TI L u). 1'4 II PA TIll I OR UL .6, 0 """"7'
7Y 7(, 7.LJ_~ OtiT.!.. &,~YI .Wl .J..UL..YL!-!..OO~
.0. OWNIA dI..1 U~1M~ ~~WNIR- 6,- /; f 6,ff.lJIIIIf
.1. ;o~~_J'LTt!JI""_Y~.d'_~___._ _____ .I_J~D~~R~L __ ~f.~"'~1Jf.
.2 CITY, S,.TE " CITY, STAlE
'lIPC~,,_]..~j{,J_J,~ 7'~ W}.~__._.~.J}PC9!!!..-P1."'''''lEJ ~Je1l '1'A 17~
U I R .. MAKE ve '3 YEAR ~.-l7i'M^"E V,
__dJ.JL_ -------'gj~~('!r.,,_____.____.Jtl'L_.J_ ~R
.& Mgg~'I-Y INOT .e, IN~.. '& MOORL ,tNOT ..
H mt2!~-- ~@if~~:L--O'--- 'I V~~I~~~~p~~K Cd '!J~~fY!!:O/f .. ~~;gl:L
o INITIAL IMPAC1- I~E;iICLe-' ---- &2 "ffiA~tiLnL.---" - 00 'N'TIAL-'MP;\'CT--,- IvvlH'CLE
3 ~~~~Li-J~- . ~~~~~__{L_ ,{~fV\qA--.7.9.--. '~~~:~~'L'-- -,- -- ~~~:~~
!=tADI T PR Sf: NC C NOITION ' OR.A r NT PA NC .
.1 1 fi.AE ~81
N!1.M.~!.A._.___~ J U!-'l~~____._____ _ _114__ nO- _._'!.UM.~~R____~"t~~'1!.1.'I.____
&1 DRIVER .. ORIVER
"~~~:5~-mj_~M~_~~!!kql1/rr--~L--_----_----__ 10 ~~i!:~~--G./~~- E. __V:.~\
-..-- .-.--.._".s.,,"!1_1uct_~___.__ ___ ____. ..__~r.~.J"H.U~ .
10 CITY, STATE 50. CITY STATE
II :l~OOE i'i ~~o/.F~:~~~(;t\J.-IA. .{7C~'f-~---- .-, :1;'OOE e'-~~~:;.~:-;~v.:j" ~ 1~~~T!(,"v
, ~l ell fWvf,A C. 615 OHI\lEfI 64 C M \lJt1. 811 0 I lSe t
Y.C;;LN "CLAS~ _. 5 S , __ .'. y t1 N 15 CLASS C S s.
61 CAR~'E" --. - --.~ -...- -..-- - -- --.- ---.- - -- __._n -- ~TcAmi;F.'fl- - ---._- '.--- ___4__.
MI,
61 CARiiiIR'-.-----.'
AODAE"5R
ii'cWY~iAj[--..-,... ."'0---,--
IIIPCODE
70 usoo"T', -.-_n_....-.llc(:.,- .-..-....--- --
~~Q~.~~~=-~~~~].. 1.3a~~:IjT~~';-"-_- ._-~-..
7& NO Of ~ .'I~/"Ai10lj'S --.
AlHI:S ~ ...AUntAlR
M,,,"I"'''-- ---,,--,--.
--.---~-...-.-_. -.----, .---- - . -_. '-- .. ~ti"CARR-iE '-1 . ... - - - -----.-. -- -'-"-'- --.--.------- ----~
Atmnf!3S
._..._h_'.. --- P--'-'-- -.-- !\!)-C-if.,. ;-STATi---.---.----..--....-- -------- ----- --_.__
& ltPC:OOF.
. 1',Ji;. ' -..no. "nO. 10 ,i~ooi'.'--' ----pr.c.-----~'i.iC-'--"-
-.,- :~.,~;~::~~i";;:;; ~y~~::ij.--..-,,=~!~jEii,;=."'.~=~_~F.;i~B H~~
PAGE -1_._ CENTlA 'Oil HIGHWAY .,.,m
0775912
,
, "
t','
"
AutO * IONI * LI'I * .V.I....
717,,'''-1300
"
,.,aOlf III.VIWICI AI.GeIAtI.
.2.. I. '.I.DLI AD.
NlClWIIC..UM, 'A 17011
1-'00-"'-..1. (1"1)
'AI '17-7"-""
,
"
Ootoblr 21, 19$3
Commlrcial Union Inl Co
noo Ritter Rd
POBox 2025
Mlchaniclburg PA 17055
Your Clilnt.
Polioy ..
Our Clilnt.
Polioy ..
Mioha.l P McGinley
NPZJ37770F
North.rn Allurance Co of America
Gregg I Gillaugh
Q06 650U67 H
Iri. In. Group
,. "
Gentlemln.
At the requelt of our ineured, we are forwarding to you the
.etimah to repair hiB automobile .e a reeult of th.accident
on October 15, 1993.
Your prompt attention to thie matter ie greatly appreciated.
Very truly your.,
Itllly Murphy
IkUl
.nelolur. vi
ce. Grigg I Gillaugh
fU.
'I
, ,
H
I'
I An Independont Agent AepreMnllng
ERIE INSURANCE GROUP
ERIE.
"
,
"
"
"
"
,
, ,
"
, ,
I;)
'"
"
IXHIBIT"D"
, ,
"
"
,
ih Xf~" '
,~ ,."
0... "', ,,/
'10 ' :.' d ,
in .1 i'.I--
"
I'
I,
, -I
I'"
"
, "
",.'
(""
~:J "
I....
.
~ ~
. :1 .a:1
!!ii Iii ~ ~
~I~~ R ~ i j:l~'" ~ I ~ ~
1 i'c; ~ ~
l~ ..!l I~!
o 1 "'~ d : Ii I
I I ~ :! jP< ~ ~ . ~
~ .~ ~
I!S~ HH ~~
IS ~~ ~ ~ ~ !~ 0 ~ ~ IH
- .
~ ~~~ ;~!
. ~ ~ ' ~i
~IUi M . . i~l~ ~p~
I~n P<AP< ~ a
)1~1)J ,e:
, "
II
, ,
, '
, , '
: ,\
1
" 1
,
I ' I;
,
, Ii,',
1 '
"~'I i
1 I
1
I I ;1'
I r I ;
Ii I ",-j
,
, ,
I ;1
,I
< J' ,I
jl,
. ~ \
,
j )'.1,;
'. l ~
,I
/.11 \\1 I)/I:r't''''
..
litWIN, HIWIN & Ml'I<NIOII'l'
.
MARGARET GILLAUGH. .. p....nt ,IN THE COVRT or COMMON PLEAS or
.ad natur,'.u.rdlan 0' GREGG E. I CUMBERLAND COVNTY PENNSVLV ANIA
GILLAUGH, a minor, and MARGARET I
GILLAUGH, Individually, I CIVIL ACTION. LAW
Plllllft(fJi I
v. I NO, III CIVIL 1994
MICHAEL P. MeGINl.EV .nd RVTH :
ANN MeGINLEV, a. par.ntl .nd natur.':
luardl.n. 0' MICHAEL P. MeGlNELV, :
JR., a minor, I
DI/'lfdlllft, .IN TRESPASS
TO: MICIIAEL P. MeGlNLEV .nd RVTH ANN MeGlNl,EY, .. p.rent. .nd n.tur.'
IUllrdl.n. 0' MICHAEL P. MeGlNELV, . minor, .nd KAREN S. COATES, ESQUIRE,
attorn.y 'or de'.ndant.:
You .re hereby notlned to pleld 10 Ihe within New M.ller within twenty (20) d.y.
from aervlee hereor or a derault Judlmenl m.y b. entered alllnn you.
IRWIN, IRWIN" McKNIGHT
(>7 1 /~ ;61' --JJy../'l'---.
HOLD S, IR , III
Allomey for plain tr.
WIlt Po""'" Pro Blllldllfl
60 Wilt Polflfm S"",
Carll"" "'''If'ylvanla /'10lJ
('1m 149-1JU
,'JIIP""" COli'" ID No. 19910
MARGARET GILLAUGH, I' par.nl I IN THE CQURT OF COMMON PLIAS or
Ind nllural auanllan or GREGG E. I CUMBERLAND COUNTY PJ:NNSYLVANIA
GILLAUGH, a minor, and MARGARET I
GILLAUGH, Individually, I CIVIL ACTION. LAW
Plal,,'1IJi I
v. I NO. 111 CIVIL 1994
MICHAEL P. McGINLEY and RUTH I
ANN McGINLEY, I' par.nll .nd nalurall
auanllan. or MICHAEL P. McGlNEl,Y, I
JR., I minor, I
VI/'Ildall" IIN TRESPASS
NOW, come Ihe plalnllfti, by Iheir atlorneys, Irwin, Irwin & McKnla)lt, E.qulre., and
relpDnd to the defendanls' new matler. representing as follow.:
11, The averments of paragraph eleven of the defendanls' new matler con.titul.
conclusion. of law to which no response Is required, However, to the .xtenl that a response I.
required, these averments are specil1cally denied, To Ihe conlrary, plalntifti' damag.s were .01.ly
Ihe result of the nellligence .nd carelessness of Michael p, McGinley as averred In plalntifti'
complaint.
12, The averments of paralll'aph Iwelve of the defendants' new matter con.lltul.
conclusions of law 10 which no response I. required, However, 10 Ihe eXlent Ihat a relponJe I.
required, Ihese avermenls are specll1cally denied, To the contrary, plalntlfti' damaa.s were aolely
the result of the negligence and carelessness of Michael p, McGinley as averred In plalntifti'
complaint.
I WHBRBFORB, plllnlift\ demand judament allaln.t Ihe defendanl' I' requ..tod In
plalntlfti' complaint.
lID&M
13, The Ivermentl of plaintllfl' complaint, parlsraphl one throullh len. and plalntlft\'
relponl" to defendanll' new maller, plrlllraphl eleven and twelve, are hereby lncorporalod by
reference u If fully HI forth herein IllenBlh,
14. The Ivermenll of parlgrlph fourteen of the defendantl' counterclaim are denlod by
roalOn Ihat after reasonable InveatlSltlon phllntilf la without knowledse autllcienl to form I belief
u to Ihelrulh oflhe avermenls and prooflhereofaltrlal i. dem.nded,lfrelevanl. To the extent
that the avennent. of Ihlt parallraph conlain concluslonl of law, no further relponll It required.
However, by way of further re.ponle, plaintllf. believe and aver Ihal any damlll" 10 the
defendant.' vehicle were solely Ihe caused by Ih. nealisence and carelesane.. of Michael P.
McGinley, Ir,
I~. The avennent. of plalnlilf.' complaint, parllll'aphl one Ihrouah ten. plalntlft\'
relponlel to defendanu' new matler, paragraphs eleven and twelve, and plalnllft\' re.pon... to
defendant.' counterclaim, paraaraphl thirteen and fourteen, are hereby Incorporated by referelUle
a. if fully 101 forth herein IIlenBlh,
16, Plaintiff believes and Iherefor aven thatlhe position of defendant. In their retponll to
Ih, complaint, spec:iftcally paraaraph three, liven and elallt. are in dlrecl conlradlcllon to what
, ,
~
Tilt foresoina retpon". and new matter are baled upon Infonnal(on which Iw beon
1II111tred by my coun,,1 in Ihe preparation of thi. lawlult, The IllI1jluaae of Ihe documenl il lilt
IlIIjp,Iase of my coun.el and not my own, I have read Ihe relpon"l and new l11atter and 10 lilt
.xlenl lhal II II baHd upon Information which I have Biven 10 my counHl, illl lru. and correcllo
lilt be'l of my knowledse, information and belief. To Ihe eXlenllhall1lt content of Ihe relponH'
and new matter II Ihal of counsel, I have relied upon counlel in maklnll Ihll verlftcatlon. I
underlland lhallilse slllemenls made herein are lubjecllo Ihe penaltlel of 18 Pa,C,S,A, Section
4094, relatins 10 un.worn falliftcation 10 aUlhorltiel,
\\.
February l4L, 1994
" 7'
..l,~' of '~" r
I hereby certifY Ihal a copy of Ihe foregoinll relponses and now matter wal Hrved thll
dale by depo.ltins lame In Ihe POll Office al Carlllle, PA, ftrll da.. mall, pOltaae prepaid.
addrellled u follows:
KAREN S COATES ESQ
THOMAS THOMAS" HAFER
PO BOX 999
HARRISBURG PA 17101.0999
February I~. 1994
IRWIN, IRWIN" McKNIGHT
/~\~ /',7)1{~' /-.~ .-- .
HAROLDs.lRWIN,III
Attorney for Additional Oe I
WII' Pomfrct Proft"'o,,al Blllldl",
60 Wilt Po"lfrt,.'i',,"
Carll,'" P,",,'ylva,,'a l'IOIJ
('1l1) Z4'-1JJJ
I'
i,
"
~
..'
I,
"
~. I"
, ,
('('I' ,I"."
-'/'
I I,
, ,
III I '
", I, I
'I" I
,
"
1'1:1
- ,
. ".
" '
,
f, ,'J
~~ ':;.,
I.....
. ~ a
~i "I ,
~~ ~ G1i i
~I~~ ~ ~ I ~ ~
a... ..~ 121~ql U
~!~f~ ij ~... ~ ~-
!U~I ;["df~ ~ ~ II ;
r
l~ .. , ~ ~.~ : . . J~111
I> ~ ."ll ~ "''''
~I~~~ ~,,] ~~i. sl
I'n f i I
~~1~ ~~
1..,~ )l! U
, 'I I
Ii'. '
" '
I'
I ,'I
, ,
I', ",
i, 11,1
,
1
,'.1 ,
,
, ,
"
, ,t '
I,' j
, ,
i I,
I,
j ,
.11
, "I
"
,
, ,
, ,
I;
,,11 .
, .,
~ '. I' ~ .,
I.rI\\I OIl,'"..
~ . · IRWIN, IRWIN 81 McKNIOIlT
VARSITY VOLKSWAGEN, Ino.
BODY SHOP
1143 tlerrltburg PI~.
C811111e, PA 17013
Carllll. - 243-7"15
Harrllbu10 - eel.0leS
-.---. - - - -, I oW ~
" n'lr 1 .
"WHIR .~ Ii A.... DATE
AIWRESS 'l 't. \ ').... ~ ~ rO'A ~~I ,~~~ o. ;. . ~ t~,~~E f' i c,{,-',,'4 ft.
YEAR MAKE ~ MODEl BODY' SE~IAL NO - LIf,lENSIi NO, (! MILIAOE
',,~ ~W ,,-'. ~ W' ijCAOfi'ifK own A ~I {~~ 1t U$ol}
...",-
RIPOIR II"PLOC" - HOUHn '0"0 P"'T ~~~r'N"
I . A'A j7 1..AIl 6.4..\ ~ ~.
( '1. .. mJ. r' r: I" .. (.J 0.0 of 'f..of: ~o,~ J1X uJ
filLY ,.... 11' 1.1' ot r} 11IJ,V~' S I.v
.
I, :.:-L. h-.. fl,...\H~ r:Rl4- 17nol - (,7 ~
'.1/'" ,
'I!j,-// ".71. A....... t. ,
IJ I.J...' ~.:'L 2:~ ."
I 7r: . J . ~ -T It) '-'oJ
- .~- A.A. ' (S, 1 f) I.)
-l
'l ,- .r.........., - J~ ~
'I),
". O.v.. C;' A..... i Nvo /H.4 ~
-,,").. " -~, I .5
:-ri .. I '. L II.. I~ ()'.J..~ ,j ,~ II" T I"'>
.. t;\
/10._ rr- 10 w
I)", ( .:?....,Il.. . 5
I;.J~q:;;u.-':.L,:".r:11I · .J~II,IJ.3 .(.
- ~ r . 'AU (J\J L., 1/--1.,., .4-
:/~ .;J '\.&...... /?,lof 'f/): V ,.f,J ~ ,c),~ t?b ~n
v
-
.
"
-- - ~ 1C;,,"\ ~'() 14(, c: '1'6 7C51 fl?,
.
SUB TOTAL
LAlOR 'I~" .>
mltl'Nun.. .."D<<:r. 0'-'" """CYION AND DO.INO' COY'" ADDmONAl. PM" Oft
LA,O" wtflCHIII'VII "I U1"IDAnI" '"' WO"KH"I'IMI1A'1IT1D,A"I"''''WQIIlK P~RTS /4'" it,
ttAt" '''YlD. W~"M DflI DAMAQIO,,,nTl WltltH A\III M3T 'ViOl"' ON""" ....c.'toH
"u I. DtftCova;:: N.nm'LLY TMII ..,1...." CIHH 'COVI.. IUCHCOHtItlOlNCI... 1ui . ,
'''''" ".)C... c1 to CHAHO' vrnHOUT MOnCI, I'MII ..,.....'l..'~ .....,..,. IUBllTltIET ITIM!) , J
Ar:tl"AHC:I.
It... ,.,rJ:( l' ,IJ
HilS WORK ^UTHORlZlD BY - .. ...- - .. ----_...._--..- T^X 710 ~r
TOT~\ ~'I'I( I
ESTIMATE SHEET .'.
I
i.,1 .... \w\1\AA~~~'T ~ I L.l Au~ t.\t ~'-\C ~_~~_
"
~ . ~~ ~vr'Y'l6.1)L. e
, m6C"4""C!.e.~ ~ ' ~
b
I d, t)',IJrqcK
III' MOLl(;N 9 1/~ qlf I~ b 11 04 ...
~ \003 ~~"~V~l S, ..
I , '~ (:\A~IS l(5, PA- 0 ~
'I If,;',,' ''':TA '" 0 fi
(." . .~t 0
0 0
a T WIK~
~ ObI WNAflJRI
6 .,~~t.r ~LI COV~~I
'I
"
,I'
I
, ,
, "
,
"
"
, ,
I, .,
.j ;
"
,/
" ,
,I' \ . I
, '
,
"
",
'1,1
"I '
,
, ,
,:,
,
'."
I, I,'
InUI'~lt1rcl i.!, (f,1I1ulI~lh
~P U:l1Il1brrlullh Drill' lun.UU4P
Illrdllllllu!111111, pa. 11P3~
J'tL.
-;n,
2905 JT.,
'f&ii
~ <!.
Jl~;~(k.i,j..b.l-)7'ld' em/.j (.lJ-J - ,>~ I S4~ :~~
)l " n
.d ~I~~ ____-'____.u. -.. -. Fif;~F~;f!a~di",'I'llJ,
'lm~~ .
~ "" . /~~1'..:TC'- ...!/:!::fJy(, ..
I:OB~OItHOI: 1I15"'~0.??1I' fc!O'S ,1'000000,","50,"
..J!)":'t!.., ...J
iJI). ~3
1J.:j)~
-m
tilul'~\tm'l 1.:. (}jlll(lll~\I,
211 \!lIIl1lll:rI:lllh Drhlr iun-Un,11l
11IrdlulltrLlhlllll. 1),1. "I1H
('"if' I
2918 '
\'~
,
;h,~~!:
,\. "I
01.1'" ,III
Jl.!!l~h:-' " '1 J -r' ,{I J U IS ,.,1.11-
,~..~ol:-.""l:i.r'-'-.. ,L:' J....t'{.-'I~,.-:'.tl( .". "M..(
. ~" "J . ,_,._ ..... ._._,______.------__._,_.___ '. 9", W1llU1t~
.... , ~... '"" ~\'. _' - -.-. --......-., .,- ---- -:_"J" ,..
1m lu\.,ST , Fifty Forwardl
'I\llsrLL.
....,t,I.....,....'..",
.../J.
D4-c.. j~-iJD.1.!...
!.2.:ill
'13
:.'rl..J:.wJJ
.. . ~;:;.I:';JkT~ ..G!tfd",,<-, ..
1I'5"'~O.??II' '2~.a ,1'oooodoo?lm.,'
':0 ~ . 10 It? 201:
,
, '
CJ:RTI,ICATI: OF SERVICE
I do herlby certifY lhal on IhI. day I ..rved . INe and CQrreCI copy of Ihe fQrelJollllJ
NOllce of Inlenllon to Offer Documenl. .1 Arbitration on tho followlnlJ by Firlt CI... United
State. Mall, pOltllJO prepaid In Carlllle, PeM.ylvanla 17013 10 Ihe followlnlJ addrell:
Karen S. Coalel. J:,lquire
THOMAS, THOMAS &; HAFER
305 North Front Slreel
p, 0, BOll 999
HoUTilburlJ. P A 17108-0999
IRWIN, MeKNIGHT A HUGHES
, '
BYI
DATE: lanuary 3, 1995
,"
,I'
,
,
;.;\, i~,
,\\1 (;'; I I ~
~ili. ',': ,.,
~"~~"'I',! 1
,1.% 1,\,
~/\r~d:"; >J Ii'
~"'\Iil' 'I
,l},llll/ ~ >I~,,' " 'I, ! I
"i~ "t' ~! \ t ;, ~ II :' r J' ,I I ,/ I I,
, ",\" II [, I" 'II ,',I
) ,I,' H . . ~ 'l~ lJ), \ I I' I I I
')"11,) '.1, 'j,I', .II !. )1 I, '1,
~" .r. r.~, '. 11 -I \ I h 'I 1 '.
1f,'J .";/1 Ij'\'o,/" 1,', I j"
f \fr/~l'\~ ~ _II .' '1,', J.
'~~ "r . II I , Ifi"
;..1:h,~"II'. !f, ,'[ j' :l' ~II, I" '"
, j L'I" J " , ,
?~11~ \.f +~ I:' j' j Iri ij, r I "I. r, I
""U"""I"'" I""" '1'1'1
'~i~flili' ~ll' ,)", 111 . I I
'''I il"II' ,'.." 'I l"~' '''"
.. .' ~ IV ~ " I 'f t~ ". i.'lr" , I ,
~),I'~ld,,' r. ~ I lat' ,I'
tJi~fl ,/i " !, t1 ':,'
ft: t I' 'fh! 1'11,1 \~, I j
'''' ".,'.~..,:", "('~"",If~ I" '
l\" ,Nc IT:ll.,j~\ l" ~flt.~ "
lit' "'J'i\\"~,"ll ;,..'1 ,,'..' ~"'In
l';I"^b~""~'~ lJ 111'1. I",~ '"
'"11,','1, '/1 ','I 'I' ," ',', ",. " ' \
;\~t~!lj~\~"J~:,I,IJ,l,l,(/fi\l' : 'I'
"\'/.:,liI'P'''i,''I' 'i"I"I~ 1',';'\ .,,,
f' 11~tNf,V'"'' "," lit ""
"\.i'l'," 1\1.(. ! l;,~\ ~~1, ,; ,;1' 1:.'" 'I'
1'~\I,ftr, r I' .:11 '\',1 'I" ,;./'. : /
"11~'~i\'I,\;J~"l",,,,~! I/.t'" h~.<'
:jlif,\V II ';i,l~~ ;~' I' , I I' " (\ ,r' \ I' I
.\,1,\ 't~ .J V' I ;"11" " "\'Itli ' , ." '" '
'~\tlj,'ir J!lln},,'l,\t.\JI~ " II, I I .' \::1
'U,,!\ll, ""i I I", \,] 01
"'Ih.tl/ "j' ~ 1'1<1 I ,J J '~.' }'II
11\ '\1,' .. t,,',)I'I,'I,,I"1 ,1'.'0'_ L:"
",
,
.,
I,',
, "
;1-"
,
,
,'1"
"
'I
'.
'"
"
,
,
,
"
,/.1'
,
I
"
" " , " :/ 'I'
",!\ ,
, '.'- , "
" " " I "
"
.' \ , ,
" ,
, ,
, 'I ,
, , " I
."
,
, ,I 1 " "
,
":' ", " ,
" ,
"
.11,' 'I;
,.1'; !Idl
,
""
,I',
"
, .
'I,
!'.
"
,
..:"/;'"
,.
:'t"'I'."
; ,"t,\" ,
'. ',: ~', "
";1, ,I
L:, """
ii
,,'
,','",11::
, ",'1
,I-I.'
::iil
,\
'I'
I!
,I,
\
','
"
Ill'
"
, '
,I'
i,
~:, r'': ' "", ,
" "
'-,'
I" I'
,'l'
"
\'1
,
,)"
'''.
"I.
,:-h',: \1
!'
.,I'
"
;,\1
,
.. .' I
, ,\,,1 I,,'il
tl,
"
.,
I.-I
I.~W OHUIP.A
,
,
,'1'~'''-N.
~.'4;;r~ &~
.
,\
-',t,',
'1,1' ;-Or' ,r I','
'"
"
,
,'/ ,,'-
;,"'1\,'
;,11 ,,-" l)
,
,'" "
.' "
('
,f'
','.';':1':'
,'I,
" i
'..'
, \
': ~
'"
I, '('.l;,b:
,
"
'.
,I
,I"
.'
/1,> :
, ,;,'0','('
," .j
,,'1\-; "
d,
'.
\
'.
.\ ,f
"
I' ,I
"
"~'I
,
"
-",
"I,
I,
,
I,;
"
,I
, ,
" ,
,
,,'"
It,
,
"
"
, ,
'i"
';1'
,,'
ll,
,)1;
," iii,
I;j
i"
';'
,'~l "'" I ,1:1 .'
1,,'."/'1,,,,
'1.;.1,'
'\,11\1 ,.l)/
:1,1\"
'I'
'",.
',r'l
\
"
\
I
",{
.
"
I'
i \J ~
,
"
I;
,
, '.\
,
:It'
'" t
I "'-:, \
','
;, .: ~j"" I ~ t\, ' J'I ''\1 f t,A t~ " ,.;c\
'll}'llt ,t ! 1 ..II" t""Yfl"'1':t
. /Ih, 'It/I ?' I ~ 'I II/':' I,~f"'llilll'
" ,,' ,",I.." Ii '~'V'I'~"~I,I~:\, ,
',1.< \,1 ''11~ / j~,}, \' 'I~J ~l'l'/, '\'r,~H~
' ' I' ,,",':,',.," ~...\ "i. ""~II.~. i'&h~J '..
, I j' I' ," ,[,I:" ~ ':1'1, I
, ,J' , I ' ~ \", '" II ' ~~ J. jl~
,~ II', 11\~d;," "'~J\ II, "jfiliv~'
I 10 I , . I '. I ~1'!' I~' \" ~l'.Jt ~
" ,,1.,,'1 "!l"~ " '\/tl,\ "'1'!J\f~~'111~'
! 1,lrl':, ,I, ;', 1'1 '1,1 '~~t,l ~ \'~!
"'11'\ ,. II~\, '.IM I ~II"I' Ij/o 'I' 1 't.
" i' ,li"':"'''~ ",1"',: \I:''''.I,~,
~ J J ' I lL '1, iL ~ '! ,.1r. l\',I, (
I " I \ '~~' \'. 'I ,,,l"l"J/' "
: '\ Iii , : f' ~/~")'-\' :;'1/;' )
, ,",t' ... 1 \,: l';~t.lI~~! (J \~,'\;U'
1 \ I I, " ,,' \ ' Q II '~,"
1,' ,''11, ',ft,,~ "j, ~'!~'ll
, I jr,.~\ 'il/,'i:"f 1,i ,',J~,'
fp"rj. l,jtlll'~' I ,,t
, I . I " \'1, ~ J, ~
".'1' jG.t,\, "
'," ,',1 (" ~'" 1 1 ,'N'
.' t' v i\ 1< r I' 1/1 'tI !I~~' ~I
"'I", I '\""'1<1 I
I '" 1 \ ,,\1, ;1. !~\ , ~,
'I .- I'tl~' l' ,\ r !,:J N' <
" i'V,' , >"I'I'U'.j ,1/,lii~'1 'l~': J
j , \ ~ " I \., ',' \~I'~\\ If, '
II ,\ l ' I, ,it ~lll
I" ',\ ' '\ j'."1]:\' ~'l'
" \'" I, "'1'" a} 1
",' t r . '., I!: "'n J
'l' " ,.; ~r t'~' ,I
II': 'I, ,,',\, ".,.,J"( ','..WJl
, ,Ii ,r ,', _; Ii "I),~\,Jb"'\';
, (II)', I, 1,;~lll"'l;~I':h'~;;?'~~\~i
,.,', '1,1"[',,'.',"'." IX,f,iIV
" ". :1" "'~ ~'~1
r;,\',';:~>l 'I~~ ,',\:~< f'!t\'::l~':;;l\~):'~~,~]~\
" I' ",) 1 l I"~' 'h\t!J ", i 1 ,\
. .1,'", J, "'. 'if, /'1 "~') ", ,"'''' "I '.
,; - \.. ".' j "\''''\ I.I'~ Hf' I\~ i
,,'I:Y;i;';, '.',;" ~'I""ll ,.\, { , '~I';~~l}ir"l'~"\'
,- ,< , I' ' f "L "
',' '\ I' <<",.' " ,1,'1(','/ i'l'
\'!o' '\ ! ; - r "" . ;.' ~
"1'
LI'
I,
iJ
,
'"
"
,
"
,I
,': I ,J
"1,
"
"
','-
,
, ,
I"~,
,I:
"
,',
I.
"I.
,
"
I,
:'
8, Plalndfli believe and therefore aver thai the .;olli.ion between Ihe partie.' vehicle. wa.
. the direcl re.ult of the carelellnell, recklellnell and nelJli>>ence of defendant Michael P.
McOlnley, Jr., includini but nOllimlted to the followina:
A, Faillnato have hla vehicle under propel' conlrol;
B. Improperly drlvina on the rllIht benn ofthe highway;
C. Makina an improper pass on the rllIhl of other vehicles I.wfully In Ihe .outhbound lane
of U.S. Roule II, Carlisle Pike;
D. Failing 10 take appropriate acdon to avoid the plalndlTs' vehicle; and
E, Otherwise failing 10 ellerclse appropriate care and caudon,
9. As tho direct result of defendant's negligen.;e and carelessness as aforeuid and the
collision thai resulted therefrllm, plalndlTs sulTered property damages to their vehicle in the
amounlof$3,991.16,
10. PlaindlTs believe and therefor aver thai Ihe negligence of defendant Michael p,
McOlnley Is so clear and convlncinsthal defendants ,elUsallo pay the property damages re.uldna
therefrom and requiring plaindlTs to Iidsate this mailer is an abuse of the procell of this court
which enthle. plaintilTs 10 be awarded allomey fees.
Tho foroiolni complalnl it balod upon Information which haM been illhorod by my
counaelin Iho proparatlon of Ihl. lawluh, Tho laniuaio of Iho document I. Iho laniUliO of my
counael and nOI my own, I havo road Iho an.wer and 10 Iho o"lonl Ihal it I. baaed upon
Informltlon which I havo ilvon 10 my COUIlJol, It I. lruo and corrocl 10 Ihe botl of my knowlodao.
Informallon and boUef. To Iho e"lOnllhallhe conlonl of Ihe complalnll. Ihal of counlOl, I havo
reUed upon counlelln maklna IhI. verlficallon, I underaland Ihal tll.o 11.lomenl. mado horoin are
lubJCCI 10 Ihe penaltlOl of 18 P..C.S.A, Soction 4094, relallna 10 unlwom tilliftcltlon to
IUlhorlllOl.
January ;)4/ , 1994
~7 ~~~~
ARBT OILLAU .
"
, ,
, '
I ,
I' , I,
,I
'I
.'
" I
',1'
I",
"
I'!
It
I
"
"
I'
,
II, L
,'I,
,\
~i
~~!~
i~!~~
~~~~I
I ~~~
~IUi
~
.
I' ,I
1) ;,
, ,.....,
\ ','1
,I
, '
"
,I
<J".'
'.....1
'"
-,
-.;
t" 'I'
.
"i 8~
ij ~'H
!:l "5l .~ 'C
~'H ta 'M .!l
o "5l 01
~!~.~~
~1~~
ul~u
~~~~
allola
i
~ I ! I
~ :a: I ~
~ ~ i I
~~'ir
~ i ~ I
~
~ ~:J
ij ~~
'" l "(; Iil ~
~ '~~
~:~~
u~ ~u
i!u i!
,~~ .
"'~~'"
~~~~
)J~1)l
to'
3
~
,
I>
" "
I,
,
",I
I'
, ,
, '
Ij,
,
',I I, "
:1,
, " 'I
, I
. 1', I
1<' I III
, '
I I 1'1
,',I
,
I' 1\
,
I",
"
. .
, ~; I I
, ,
,
/,t\\' (1/1;(,(""
IlfWIN, lUWIN HI lIId(NUHJ1'
.
MARGARET p, GILLAUGH, I' per.nt
.nd "Itur,1 gUlrdlln of GREGG E,
GILLAUGH, I minor end MARGARET
GILLAUGH, Indlvldullly,
Plllntlffl
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLI!AS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA,
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
NO, 111 CIVIL 1994
v.
MICHAEl. p, MCGINLEY end RUTH
ANNE MCGINLEY, II plrlntl Ind
nlturellluerdilnl of MICHAEL
MCGINLEY, JR., I minor,
Oefendlntl
PRAECIPE TO DI8CON11f31UI
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
Kindly mark the Ibov. eotlon II I.ttled, dllcontlnued end endld with
preJudice.
IRWIN, MCKNIGHT & HUGHES
8.pteab.t 12th. 199'
/
,
,I
,
, ,
MARGARET 1', (;II.J,AU(;jI, 11M pnrullt nll<l
IHlturll~ Klllll'<llllll uf G1U:Gli ":. 1;1 I. I.A IJI: II
u minur ~nd MAIU;ARLo:'l' (llt.1 Alle:1I )
111<11 V 1<1111111 Y . )
l'lllllltlffu 1
)
)
)
MICIIAH 1'. MClilNI.EY nlld IUITII MN~: \ t1
MCllINl.t:y, 11M pllrlllltH /lIlU IIntllr/ll !:::.:-
KunrullIlIH Ill', MICIIAI':1. MC(;INI.EY, ,Ill'.OATH
II mlnor, DufUIIU/llltu
We do ,olamaly .we.r (or .ttirm) chat wa will .upport, obey and d.tand
e~. COD.cic~e10n of e~e Unic.d Scac., aDd eh. CQa'ticuCioD ot cbi. Common-
.".dch and ;c w: ~ill i:!.,c:har.a Chi d~t:!... ~~ 6u~)ot 1~~~ .~i~h~..fid'UCY'
!.i ., .' r.ull
III Th. Courc of Co~oa Pl.I. 01
C~erl~d CQuncy, 'annaylvln1a
V,
1I0. I " ,
C LVII.
19 '1'1
CIVIl. ACTION - I.AW
.
...
.. ")
,
co
, ,
.,
/
l'
,--.J
"
::3
.....-r.
AW.w:J
We, th. undlr.:!.zued .rbicrators, havin, baan du11 app01nt.d and .vorn
(oi at'iroD.d), =aka the followinl award I
(~OC" If d8m&I" for dallY ara avar~.d, thl1 .hall b.
aaparat.ly .taCad.)
\.NR Cy,J \ '" ((I.\jf'r 0(\\.(>
"''']. 1 L!l, . I ~
'\>\'" \vA,\C \ v,~""
~,^liJ (~..J 'i~^)('.lA L,v,^J,,...J
(r~t
(N"
I
().A~c._
-
appl1C'iil.. )
DacI 01 R.ariZlll41t J 1
/1 r
Dace 01 Avard 1 ~ ,)l~
. Arbierltor, dia..at..
(II1..rt 1111II1 it
I'HS
) I{~r;-
(
~J!,'
30ttC% or ~t or AWARD
Ifev, tile ~ZLt -1~y of (l........,.... ..:t ,U_~,1_, It!.:.JL, ..d.ll. Che above
award val enclrad ~pon tbe doc~t and Docie. Chiflol lIViD by =ail eo che
plrcie. or c~e1: ecco~e,..
Arbitr.cor.' campeDeacion co b.
paid ~pon Ippa&ll
II") L' ("
. aLlsJ (J.
~1'
\.: 1'\..' ll.. .' II.
IYI
~\l'l"~" .
,y
c' . 1~~;.u Lj
troc ODOU,.,.
C~ 'D~' ,
; j
. ,
,
",....,J
y, ill. ,t, l, I ~ , f61<J"'I' ',,.... I,~. 14.., I. ,.i./, \
,) 01. ( J t t~l. ~,( AI:, (I, ",,,,.. . Ai, Ii, II' ~"..( /
-r"" .
t~){I.M",j
(; ( f 1,.._..
) . l' I
I ...^-....."" , f\(.1t4..- ,
, ,
....d,.... (
., ill . .t' ,.
"
" 'I
" n,
.
.1":
"
'"
" ( ~ Ii
,
I'
",I
"
" ,
, , "1 ,
" ,
"
.j 'I
I
r
1 "
"
'.
It,)
-
I.J
"f' "
~ -
.0 if
~ ~
"
(I ','
" , "
" ,I
,i
"
",
" I
,
I'
\