HomeMy WebLinkAbout94-00376
'I,
r
, .
"
( I
. ..
GROrr TRACTOR
INC. I
, JQUIPMBNT,
Plaintift
IN THE COURT or COMMON PLIA. or
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PINN8YLVANIA
NO. CIVIL 1994
v.
BESHORE EXCAVATING, INC.,
Detendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
COMP~INT
Grott Tractor' Equipment, Inc" by it. attorneys snelbaker
, Brenneman, P. C. file. thi. Complaint aqain.t Be.hore
Excavatinq, Inc. and in .upport thereof .tates the followingl
1. Plaintiff Groff Tractor' Equipment I Inc. is a
Pennsylvania bu.ine.. corporation with it. prinoipal office and
plaoe of busine.. located at 6499 Carli.le Pike, Mechanio.burg,
Cumberland County, penn.ylvania.
2; Defendant Be.hore Excavating, Inc. i. a Pennsylvania
bu.ine.. corporation with an office and place of bu.ine..
located at 3293 N. Georqe street, Emig.ville, York county I
Penn.ylvania.
3. Plaintiff i. in the bu.ine.. of .elling, lea.inq and/or
.ervicinq oon.truction and related equipment I toqether with
acoes.orie. and part. therefor.
COUNT .1
LAW O"IC..
'NIL.BAKI"
.
I"IN~IIMAN
4. The averment. of Paraqraph. 1 through 3, inolu.ive,
above are incorporated herein in their entirety.
U.W f,l"l'lCIlI
.NlL.IAKI..-
.
."INNIMAN
, .
,
~
,"
~. Beginning on or about July 38, 1993 ~nd continuing
thereafter, plaintiff, at the .pecific reque.t of Defendant
and/or Defendant'. authorized agent., repre.entative. and/or
employee. did .ell/ provide and deliver to Defendant, at
plaintiff'. place of budne.., vadou. etluipment part., product.
and ..rvic.. at Plaintiff'S then cu.tomary charge., which
charge. Defendant orally agreed to pay.
6. Defendant reque.ted, received and acoepted from
plaintiff equipment parts, product. and .ervice. at the time.,
in the amounts of and for the prices and charges a. stated on
the parts/ service and work account invoices of Plaintiff, true
and correot copies of which are attached hereto and incorporated
by reference herein as "Exhibit A-1" through "Exhibit A-6".
7. At Defendant's request and agreement/ Plaintiff
permitted Defendant to charge its various purchase. of part. I
products and .ervic.. provided it by plaintiff and to maintain a
part. and .ervice account with plaintiff with a servioe charge
thereon in the amount of eighteen percent (18') per annum.
8. The cu~rent account balanoe due Plaintiff by Defendant
for equipment part. I produots and .ervice. i. $1,066.80.
9. The price. charged by Plaintiff to Defendant for
equipment part./ products and .ervice. provided Defendant were
-3-
LAW O''',CU
INILIAKI"
.
...INNIMAN
"
,
J
~
fair I ou.tomary and reuonable and at no Ume objeoted to by
Detendant,
10. Defendant has failed and refu.ed to pay for the
equipment part., product. and .ervice. charqed and the aocount
balance thereof when .ame has become due and owin9 in .pite of
Plaintiff'. reque.t and demand to do .0.
11. Defendant's failure and refu.al to pay for the
equipment part. I products and .ervic.. and the aooount balanc.
th.reof is D mat.rial br.aoh of the parti.sl aqre.m.nt.
WHEREFORE I Plaintiff demand. judqment again.t Defendant in
the amount of $1,066.80, tog.th.r with intere.t on the principal
balance thereof in the amount ot eight.en percent (18') per
annum and costs of this action.
COUNT II
12. The .verment. ot p.r.qr.ph. 1 through 11, inolu.ive,
are inoorpor.ted by reterence herein in their entirety.
13. Beginning on or .bout April 28, 1993 and continuing
there.fter, Plaintitt, .t the sp.oitic requ..t of Def.ndant
.nd/or Def.ndant's authorized agents, repre..ntatives and/or
employee. did lea.. to Defendant and Detendant did .gree to
1.... from Plaintift the equipment identitied below .t
-3-
L.AW O"IOU
.NILIAKI"
.
IIUNNIMMI
"
.,
Plaintitt'l then cUltomary rental charge., which charge'
Defendant agreed to pay.
14. Beginning on or about April ~8, 1993, Detendant agreed
:
to lea.e and did le.ee from Plaintiff the following equipment
for the rental per i od noted below I
EOUIPMENT SERIAL ,.,Q..... RENTAL P~RJOD
C..e 1840 unlload.r JAF0118884 4/~8/93 through 9/23/93
Wack.r I Rammer 674602803 6/~~/93 through 7/13/93 and
8/23/93 through 10/1/93
Gradelight ~a..r GA306112 8/11/93 through 9/~3/93
Gradelight La..r GA306129 8/18/93 through 8/23/93
Tr.u. .nd correct copies of the 1.... agreement. and
invoic.. noting rental by Defendant of the above equipment for
the above period. and the charg.. for .am. are attached hereto
and incorporat.d by ref.renc. h.rtain a. "Exhibit B-1" through
"Exhibit B-27".
1~. At Def.ndant'. request and .gr..ment, Plaintiff
permitted Defendant to have po.....ion and u.e of the above
equipment and to maintain a rental account with Plaintiff with a
.ervioe charg. th.r.on in the amount of .ighteen p.rcent (18')
per annum.
16. The total balanae due Plaintiff by bef.ndant for
Defendant'. r.ntal of the above equipment a. of January 4, 1994
18 $14,31~.72.
-4-
"
,
oi
17. The prioe. oharged by Plaintitt to Petendant tor
rental ot the above equipment ",;ere tair. ou.tomary and
rea.onable and nev~r objeoted to by Detendant.
18., Detendant haa tailed and refu.ed to pay plaintiff the
rental oharge. and aooount balanoe a. .ame have beoome due and
owing in .pite ot Plaintitt'. reque.t and demand to do .0.
19. Detendant'. tailure and retu.al to pay the r.ntal
oharge. and aooount balanoe oon.titute a material breaoh of the
partie. I agreement..
WHEREFORE, Plaintitt demands judgment again.t Detendant in
the amount ot $14,31~.72, together with intere.t on the
prinoipal balanoe thereot at a rate ot eighteen percent (18t)
per annum and oo.ts ot this action.
COUNT I II
(In the alternative to count. I and II)
20. The averment. ot Paragraph. 1 through 19, inelu.ive,
are inoorporated by reterenoe herein in their entirety.
21. The part., product., .erviee. and equipment provided
by Plaintitt to Detendant a. more fully de.eribed in Counts I
and II of thi. Complaint were not provided by Plaintiff to
Defendant a. a gratuity.
LAW O,,.OU
.NII.IAKI"
.
...INNIMAN
-'5-
LAW o,,,alll
aNILIAl<lIlt
.
IPtINNIMAN
I' ~
33. The charges tor the parts, products I services and
equipment a. more tully described in Counts I and II of this
complaint were fair, oustomary, reasona~le and never objeoted to
by Oetendant.
33. OQtendant wron9tully soourQd benetits from the
equipment I equipment parts, produQt_, services and u.. ot the
rental equipment trom Plaintitf that would be unoonscionable tor
petendant to retain.
34. Oetendant has been unjustly enriohed at the expense Of
Plaintift in the amount ot $15,382.52.
WHEREFORE, Plaintift demande judqment aqainst Oefendant in
the amount ot $15,382.52, toqether with interest and costs ot
thia suit.
The total olaims ot Plaintitf in this aotion, exolusive ot
interest and costs, do not exceed the jurisdiotional limite tor
mandatory arbitration in Cumberland county.
BYI
SNELBAKER , BRENNEMAN, P. C.
, )
I ,
'I ~(j I \ ['.,' '(' , ,,< 1__......._
" . / . 1'1 I. (I
Keith O.Brenneman, Esquire
44 West Hain str.et
Heohanicsburq, PA 17055
(717) 697-8528
Attorney 10 '47077
Attorneys tor Plaintitf
Grott Traotor , Equipment,
Ino.
Oat-el
January 24, 1994
-6-
l
I
I . RIMIT TO:
"'" CAIIUIL. PiKa
,.o.IOXIW
, IlICHAHICIIUIIO, PA '7061
t1l11"1.'11I
,At 17111 'N.11IO
Il\AHCHJI;
1IHM,A,rwtlYLYNM
IrAr. rAJJOI.,rwtlYLY'f'A
.'",
TlII""1 HIT iIO tUHLI.. OTMIAWI.I HOTlD~ A"'" ""'1'101 CIIAIIOI ON ALL INYOIOI. OV'I' ~o OAV' (I'" "" ANHU,..!,
"'TUIIHII ALL IIITUIINI MUIT ., ACOOM'ANIID IV TMIIIHVOID'. ALL lllTU,.,.' ""I IU..,IOT TO A ,... III"OOKlNO OHAIIOL
rlOI"AL 1.0.': .~" lUI41I 'LIAI.IHOICATlIHVOIOI HUM'I" WITH VOUII ".MITTAHOI.
~iltll"()
',0111 ,()
~E700P DEDHONl EXCAVATING-POt REQ'O
llOX :3aa
YUNK 1''' 1740~
1301d 1'1)' ,I JH I'll .1 1 '10 Dale 1:)123/'13 PARTS SALE
Uh1 II Twx .1 H'i10415 NTI
T D ~l)' Ou~cr'ption ---,,----------------------------* Price
PANTS COU/HE.N
1 J 1 YAA 1006802
1 J 1 YAA 6002142
1 J 1 ESE ~B6
1 J 1 CAS H20460
A6116'13t:i
1
AIAollnt
BELLOYS
SHOE Al:lBY,
OIElP EARPLUG
TAPI,
0184-210
22ENO
0183/CAII
YALl.5
.. TOTAL PARTS
1~~:8~
4~.,~~
COUNTER
l~~', 88
4l:~~
305,91.
,
H SUBTOTAL
U IiIALES TAX
303.96
19,31.
Chery. a~19 X ~
Phollel (717)76'1-4
11J\'( llll',
1\1',\1)11111
.324 I a~l
"
.
11'1
I'"
.
E>>lIllIt A.~ "
, ,
,,"'.,,~ ,","
,\lICHANI~RO, rA 11066
(1I1111Htll
,All: (111P'" 'NO
.rMlwUlu..'_,,,.....
,
TlAnD'" IDUII'Mlf(f, I.
TI..M.: N.T to (UNL..' OTH."WI,. NOT.Oj; A , "......VIO. OHA"G. ON AUINVOIO.. OV." to OAV' (1'" ,... ANNUM),
...TUIIH.: ALL ".'U"N' MU'T .. AOOO""ANI.O .nHI. IHVOIOI. ALL ..I1U..N. A..I .UIJIOT TO A ,... "..,OOKlNG OHA"GL
'.OI..AL I,D,': n.m.." 'L.A'. INOIOATI INVOIO. HU"'.... WITH VOU" "."'lnANOI,
',or I) 1 ()
IIl'/()O~ IIUilll/HL t:XCf,VAf JlW-'I'LJ. ~t.fI'1.!
1'1) 1I0~ : III I I
VIII,I<. I'f, j /40l,
..
ij~ hi IjYI IlU I"ll +1 I),llt, ll/.ll/'I;J 111:JHAL ,iNCll/1F.: Illlo\:~lfI
l'hi,. II I I~~ ., (1144,;'1\ 'Ill', j
,. 11 ,~t:/ Iluu<:l'il~ t1~ 1'1 -....-,...--...,."."'.,...... -......:_..;-,-......,-,~-.:.;..' 'plr hi. Alftount.
, . , ,
'deN'( l Nt: l,,^(;K~:J1 ..
j.J -J',ll~~ "'At:K~R IJ~/,OV JII HI'II'I~I.;H 165.00
Ilfl/1111i!l
SI:.Il+, 6'/I\6021IU"
H~:HO
1 .,
1 ,J
meCCl'~U ",nKU RI::NTAL ~ ~Oll
(:I/:Il/va I'U 'I/'J/'1'J
"
. ".",.:.:,;:. i,'"
"
" ,,'
"
-
Ch.)"~," !I.,lu X' '
.' h \I 'IV , ( '/ I '/ ) 'Il. 7-'"":11-"--- -'-'-"""'--"''''''- ......--,'-
~~ Illi..,'oTAL'
.. SALES rAX
16~', 00
Y,"O
1'1\'( 1111',
J\i',H lIJrl I
. -- - - - - - - --- - -- - ---- --. - --:- -.-..- -- ------- - --_..-- --- -----
.
,I
"
ElOIIIIIT 11.15 .
"
,1
H~MIIIU:
utI CARLlBU P1Kl
',0, BOX '03'
, 'lIlCHAHlCIIUIIO,'h 11086
11111 ,...,'" " i,.
IAX:11I1"88.,... '"," ,"
, I
I/W/CHfB
UHRATA.PfNNIYlVNIIA
BTA'fCOl.lfOI. ".'MAMA
TWAm""QU''''''T,'M~,:' '
. " , '. ..' ,,'
'UTl"M': N'T 110 NNI.... OTH.IIW1" No'rlDll A"'" "'WlCI CHA"O' ON ALLINVOIC.. OV'" 110 DAV""" "'" ANNUM).
"ITUIIN.: ALL II.TUIIN. MUll I' AC9OU"ANIID IVTHII INVOICI.,AU. "ITU"N' All. .UIJIOTTO A II" ,,"TOCICJNlI OHA"~L
PlDI"ALI,D,': Ia."alm "LIA.iJ INDlCAT.,NVOICI NUMI.II WITH VOUII IIIMITTANC.. '
:.01 Il 10
SIIIP TO
" '
.
HI', i (JON
1I~.Bfll\r.Ii, .:Xl:- PU+N.:l.IlI (H),
I'n!ll ,UN
YllflK 'II 1 'I 1\ Of,
IU14:JEJ6li
UloItto ''il/;W/'iI:i
II,Y I 11(1
I'U .
-
tlty on~I'1rt 1u I' -::':::':':"-~~-'--'~::!";':_-;':';';':"::~~--~:_:'--'~.., ':' ',P'; 1,/"
. ~,' , I :: ~ . ' .J '. I
tJr-:/H INC UACK~:R ' , ",I ;. I' ,.'",,, "
I .. "OM"~ ue&;'~ .,~:;:::. '.. '.'~~i:" '..:~iH~~~,.. . .' CP \\Pv; . "',:;:1~ ·
t :J ~~~Q~~~T~8. ~~1l~7~~~~~I:' ':,:, " .;,'.' " '! -tf\~~'..: tJ>'y:>' :,}';I'"
" '... " ., ",'" ,', :.,'. " Jk" """l' "~';,' '~', C).
, '.' .,.,' .",. .' f , r"
.. ',1.' \ , , . ,..., . .... . .' IIi(' .
VJ' " Qi' : ',n :, \, (.~ 'n. '1/) ,"', '::'1 " ,
rIA 0~ ; 1 ;....:.
, ' " ,'; ',:' - i, . '.
..I~",.l"' ',:'. .~". . ~ :~.:u',!' .,~jl ,.,,',:... t.~~lt"/,~.i_~:""';':~\~""~'''':''''j
" ,,' -, . '",;r., '/" ," " 1~''',"r~~''I".;:..,~..a''''I'';' '.
',' ". "u SUBTOTAL.
" ,
Hr ~Al.t\r:) rAX
I II
, ,
Amouilt.
"II,~'" I",. !J:.a 1.' X
I'iI/'lll'1 (717) jl6?::''lO\,'r'' ..._....:-'.___u..'
495,00
:,~?, 70
.,~.._-,........ .-....--..
1'1\ Y 1111',
JH,llllJrll
- - --.- - --- --- -- ------ -------- --------
, .
, '
EXHIBtt 8-17
, ,
"
, , .'1
TWACTDR 'IOUII'M'N r. INe.
',0, 10M .oa, .. 'LUtAN' VAUIY NDAD 1l.IIOU,III0 IUMIIIM"
...."AN~..UIIO.'A, 1101140" ""NA'A.'A "'" IILl:~,:,"II,'" i.':::.
"'"I4ONIIIII" ,..."" "'"140"1' e"', 11'.11' "1.1'__" lOt.,_
,All'.,,,,,,.'....' 'AIlII""'....." 'AIlI ",.,---'
DISTRIBUJ'ORS OF CONTRACTOR AND INDUSTRIAL EQUIPMENT
GROFF TRACTOR II EQUIPMENT, INC. ("LESSOR") ANO THE LESSEE AGREE AS FOLLOWS TO
THE lEASING OF THE EOUIPMENT DESCRIBED BELOW:
LlSSU~'
SUIP 10:
PF'J,',(II" nl"~'HOI,r f'~I:,."Hr1l1' -","11 f"loU'I'
..." 7<0)' '"f..'
ji)Pt' ", ~ '. j "'--,
I.ri: r I 'j , l'lf. ~ 11 t~1
~.1~
, I ',..1.1 I
. "I , \'
Ill::
H:> II:
~ ,
, ".1,
:. I',..~'.. I""N!,!!.. ,,1'1 ~J'r:r)....I'~II",:'1
I ,"I
ill
'.Jl.lt . " 11' t. ,( ,',',
... ....
,'1111 1111', .,1'11
I . ,".1nr
:,(',1,
",PM'II....II ,'.' I ,,~;.~,
'~F,HII r;,,'I:.l(I~ I \,'
.
'6',117
~LL TIRM' AND CONDITIONIITATlD ON THI RIVIRII HIRIO. Al'l A PART O. THII CONT~CT, IY IIONINO TH~I
~II~LI 'II~OR"I TO THI TlRMI AND CONDIJIONI lIT 'O"TH ON THI .ACI AND IlIVI IIIIDI HIRIO'. A Y
!PI IN g" DDITIONAL TIRMI WHITH.R WRlnlN OR OtHIRWlIll, A"I HIRIIY OIJICT D TO AND IHALL HA I
NLI AL' II I OIlAPPLlCAIILITY WHATlGIVIR.
.----------- --.-....-...----..-.. - .-.-.....--..-- -......--.------- .--..
.
El>>ItBIT B-20
, '
.\
I':
.'
REMIT TO:
14" CA/lLlIU 'I~l
'A. .oX 1031
MlCHNlICltURO,'A 17011
1111)71"'171
'AX: (1171111.1110
~ ,,',.,/
TWACTOW .IOUI,MINT. IWe.
I/lANCHfS
f'HRAr~ 'fNNITYLVAHlA
erA rf CQf.UOf, NHNlYl.V~
TlIIMI: NIT ao (UNLIIS OTHEIIWISE NOTED): AI"" IERVICE CHARGE ON ALL INVOIC" OVER 00 DAYS (II" PER ANNUM).
IIITURNI: ALL IIITURNS MUST I. ACCOMPANIED SY THIS INVOICI. ALL IInURN. A"I IUIJICT TO A 10,. RESTOCKING CHARGI.
'IOIRAL 1.0, Ii 1a.1UUre 'LEAlIE INOICATlINVOICI NUMBIR WITH YOUR'RIMlnANCI. '
Sill!' 10
"t',
SOl () 10
11'1,'/\/01, lIL~lIl(JI,~t. I;':'. ;,111,1 J IW"I'Ui,
1'0 IlO/ :,Jnli '
'(UH~ JI;, :1 /11'.)' j
"'l.l~ ' L/
-'
. ... ~, I
11;.1,1) (./11/'/;) tH,Ni'(\I. ,(NCllN~: IH14'::i3'"
),0 I ,1(' I ;,'(, ",n I 1
'"U ! oj II)' I II"
Bhj,p IIy I
II I } I:' ~
1 \.l ~ to I
r u WI',)' Ihl''':'' ,1,1' l J.UIl -'.-,......""""..,.., ..,.,..,...,..,..-".-....-..-,....,...
kl'.lil Hie AUt "
j, J 1(61'1:.1 i'itH. tlfMIJLI,mil Kll LAstR '
Oll,\IJ'"I.HIIIt' I"Ml,11
!IEAI, (l(,~iOi>I1:l
'.. r 1,:"
Anlll 1.1 lit
. :-100 . 00
. ',"
MEI'IlJ
I ,)
), .J
~lNEn I~El::IW I.~:IHAL FNtltl
0/11/93 TU H/ll/ya
,
..
.".,. UUIlHI1 i'iL
....'... UAI.I::t3 TI\X
300.00
lI~,OO
1~1l;)rn',1 ~1 \lp ~(_
"hullt I UJ'l)'1(,'1 ';I\il
, .,.,,,",,._,.,.~.-
I'J\V 1 ttlll
I\MOlJrll
..=1J.U,OO
---_._-_._,-.----~----------~~-----------------------
'E)littalT a-21
'j , "
.'
RE.m TO:
IleV CAALIIU PI~I
',0, lOX to:"
1IICHAHICItUAO,'h 110U
(71111110711I
'~11l7'1".16IO
,/WICHfl;
mjM1A, "N/lfYLVAN'~
'1~" CQLllOUINNIYLVNIM
.
'flACTlJU 'DUI'MIMT,lftl:.
TI"MII NIT 10 (UNLI.. OTIlI"WIII NOTIO): A Ill.. .I"VICI CIlA"OI ON ALL INVOICII OVIA 10 DAYI'lI... PIR ANNUM),
RITURNII ALL "ITU"NI MUIT II ACCOMPANIED IY TIlIIINVOICI.' ALL "ITUJlNI AM IU,",ICT TQ A ,... AIITOCKING CHA"O.,
IIDI"AL I,D,': 11.111141. 'LIAUINOICA'fIINVOICI NUMII" WITH YOUR "IMlnANCL ' 'I
SHIP I ()
~;()I Il 10
I/I:./()('f.' IU.tHllJfll, . X!:(,VI\T JlW"f'O" 1<1:(,j'1I
I") 111)'.( '1"'1
nIP-ii pn ) /'tll~1
MF..:MO
1 .,
I. ,J
."." ElUlIHITf\l.'
',-II l~ALI!9 TAX
900,00
:H,OO
1;1\~ P')l} a;'lJ..t X
"110'''', (/ Il/61'-"",j',ri'j'""-.."..,..,"'"....". ,.......,.,.-.. '"
IJ,\y 1111',
IH.lI)IHJ I
.'Iti4, Oil
---------.---'j....--- -...--------------- ---------------
I,
" ,
EXHIBIT B-24
TW~tm1W "DUI'M,NT,INC.
'0 MO~Joa' ""'~UH,y~"yftOAII 1I0ft0I,1IH'I!I.0I1HIIVI
"'CHAHICJl~"q, 'A, ""uta, .'HIlAM.'A "... OIU.OOHlI,'A IH"
'n"~H.1 l1"r'''''''' IIL"HOH'I p""a..... 11"'.',1114'_
,All. "",'H.'1tO 'All' P""M~" 'AlII1114'''_ '
DISTRIBUTORS OF CONTR~CTOR ~ND INDUSTR/~L EOUIPMENT
GROFF TRACTOR & EOUIPMENT,INC ("LESSOR") AND THE LESSEE AGREE AS FOLLOWS TO
THE LEASING OF THE EOUIPMENT DESCRIBED BELOW:
I I. SSH'.
SItIP 10
BE7(IOR fCESHClRIi l'.XCAVAT I NO-PCltl nEO' 0
PO f)OX ~'JEIU
YOf~t< r'A I 740e;
IIr'Fn.Y flHHAL
: 4MH#-tlIL
,
I T DOt"
PO II ~
..~ 111-
I I O..h. R/17/9"1 1'11.';1'11.31 r'.l~F'(~V n<;IP~,"I'" I
101 I 13 f'f' I J
[lflller' Ipt I Coil ------...------------------------*
REN1
I J
HIe AGL
t:b!:!b8
SERIII
AGL
GA3t)b129 '
Gr<ADl.l BHT
VfC LACiER
I
,
I
I
I
i
,
.....
I
I
",IS
II'"AOINT'IIIONAYUR. ATlRITU ID II II'SlIO U I A I
AL IIIMS AND CONDITION II STATIO ON THI IIIVIIIIII HIIIIOF Alii A PAIIT OF THII CONTIIACT. BY IIGNING TH'I
1..IAlla;:LIIII~QIIIII TO THE TERMS AND CONDITIONIIIIET FORTH ON THE FACE AND IIEVERIII! 11101 HIIIIOIf, ANY
111"1 H'lGJ'\ DIlIJ!QNAL fllIMI WHITHIII WIIITTIN 011 OTHIIIWIII, Alii HIIIIIV OI.lICTlD TO AND IHALL. HAV.
1t~J. '0,111 QW'4IC~'ILITYWHATeOIVI",-- --------,.--
,
--
~- ----------~--._---------
"
, ,
EXHIBIT B-26
8.
Denied, for the rea.on that the defendant teel. that it h.. made
paymenta t.o the plaintiff for which proper aredit haa not been
'liven.
9.
Admitted.
10.
Admitted.
11.
The defendant feal. that it ha. paid for .ome of the materiala
involved I and feel. that the amount a.ked for by the detendant ia
inoorreot ae it i. too hiqh.
WHEREfORE, the detendant requests that the within pray for
reliet be denied and that, upon proper aocountinq, the detendant
only be required to pay to the plaintift the principal amount of
what i. aotually due and owinq.
COUNT II
12.
The anawer. to paraqrapha 1 throuqh 11. are inoorporated by
referenoe and made a part hereot.
1.3.
Admitted.
14.
Admitted. Althouqh the detendant a180 aver. that it haa paid a
.ub.tantial portion of the charqe. which are a part ot thia
Complaint, and believe. that the plaintitt i. not entitled to the
reliet requested in the amount requested.
2
115.
Admittld, althouC}h thl detandant doe. not recap a9nlin9 to pay 1.
perolpt plr annum lervioe oharql'.
16.
Dlnild, tor the r..lon that the detandant haa made lub.tantial
I
paymentl on thb account. It i. believed that the plaintiff 11
..ekinq to recover thouland. ot dollar. in exce.. ot what i.
aotually due and owinq at thl pre.ent time.
1?
It 11 admitted that the pricel charqed were tail'. It i. aho
averred, however, that the plaintiU has not rendered a proper
acoountinq tor the actual acoount balance.
18.
The detendant hal retused to pay the charqe stated as it i.
believed that the charqe is excessive.
19.
Denild. 81 the detendant has made lubstantial payment tor which
credit hal not been qiven.
WHEREFORE I the detendant requests that the plaintitt'. pray
tor reUet be denied, and that atter a proper accountinq the
plaintitf. be allowed to recover only the principal amount ot what
i. currently due and owinq.
COUNT I II
20.
The an.were to paraqraphl 1 through 19 an inoorporatd by
reterenoe and made a part hereot.
3
21.
Admitted,
:U.
The defendant denies aotinq wronqtully and in taot has made payment
to the plaintitt tor a substantial portion ot the matters tor whioh
recovery is souqht.
24.
The detendant aqree8 that it would b8 unju8tly enriohed it it were
to reoeive allot the item8 at no chanqe, but believes that the
amount requested by the plaintiff under a theory at unjust
enriohment is exo88.ive.
To allow the plaintiff to reCOVer
exceseive amount would, in of itself, constitute unjust enrichment.
WHEREFORE, the defendant requests that the relief requested be
dlnied, and that after the plaintiff has rendered a proper
accountinq, that the plaintiff be allowed to recover ite principal
ooet..
OOUNT." QIL..aT AND....
,
1
I
I
!
Bye
I'"
awrence V. oung
Supreme Court No.
29 North Duke Stre
York, PA 17401
Telephone I 717-848-4900
,I'
I ,
1,1
"
\
'I
,
.
It ie hereby represented by ooun~el to this stipulation
that they exeoute the same under and pursuant to the expre..
instructions and authorizations of their respective client..
COUNTESS, GILBERT, ANDREWS
By
JLlo/. V, C,
Lawrenoe . Youn , ,eq
29 North Duke st e t
York, PA 17401-1 2
Attorneys for Defendant
Beshore Exoavating Ino.
Supreme Cllurll,[), No. 21009
e
By'
I<e
44 W. Main str.et
Mech~nir.Bbur91 PA 17055
Attorney. for Plaintiff
Groff Tractor , Equipment,
Inc.
Datel '1' A....i1 "1'1'
Date, 5/5/'14
APPROVED BY THE COURT I
--
J.
, I'
"
, '
, "
I.A'It Q"ICI.
eNII.IAKI"
.
."'INNIMAN
"
.~
.l:.
~
.,
i,
"
, ..
,
.,
, '\
II
, "
"
1,1
,'I'
\',
~!1
tf)
~
q C:l
,~. -
~
..) .:t~
.J
~" 0.'1
~
...;
c.J v...
,
\
,