HomeMy WebLinkAbout94-00484
, , , 'i I "
I " , ,
,
: " ,
0'",
,
I ,
" I ., ,
I " "
, ,
.,
" " ':i
" .
I ,
'J' ,
" I
I , .,
., , , ., I "
I " .,
.,
i' I , ,it
I , "
, ...iji
" t) 't~
. " . i,'I~.
~' I, " 11)ljl
" M
,', " oJ ,
, I, I','
'" , 1,1:i\,
, , ',') 'i,l
I " , " , : ~ 1,
I'
~ I ,I I , (,
;\V
'1 , 'I '1 ", I <:~
" I;,
" ',-',
~ it,
, I ;"/1,
, ')~
, I UI
., , I I , i'l~
I I,
., "r~
., , , -OJ,
, , ',:",',.
I "f
':'i~
\ I , I ":1
,
I' I. ,llf
"
'. ii'
" iI'.
"\, '.."1
" ,rlr,
i I "
I I,'j
, " 'J
, I
I ,
'I I
, , i,'-;
" C,..,
i-I!
,,' r.\,:
/,1
" I , , 'Ii',,;'
'I
I, I I , ,\J
'1,',1
, I' , "
I
I " T
I
'I "
( ,,I
I , I '1 -"I
,
'I I , ; '.1
'I
i,1
" ,
" I'
,
, ,
I
, 'I' " ,
., ...
,
,
.1
,.
,\ I ,
,
>111
I I,
1'1
,
,
'.
'I
""H.f/J~/wIi"-"I/..,.", ,IN
1"
I
1:1;
"
(',
v,
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
IN THI COl1l'T or COIOlON PI.IA. or
CUNalRlAND COUNTY, PIlNNIYI.VAHIA
NO. 11'-1 CIVIl. 11t4
AllY L. 'WUTHOUT IACH,
Plaintiff ,
aAHKY TRUCIING, INC., and
ItIOHAJU) WINrIlLD DUNN, III,
Dafendant.
JURY TRIAL DIKANDID
I"
i'>
"Uft'll. .01. "1'1 O. .Innltlll.
{,Ii
1'1
!j
"
Ii
TO TN' PROTHONOTARY or SAID COURTI
Pl.... i..u. two (2) writ. of Summon. in the .bov.-o.ption.d
.otion for ..rvica upon the followin9 D.f.ndant.1
"
);,
IAHI(Y TRUCICING, INC.
5113 OAIC TREI ROAD
W.8TMINSTER, ND 21157
RICHARD IfINrULD DUNN, IU
308 8 MOUNT STRaIT
BALTIMORI, MD 21223
,
, 1
INItlIL, UDI.,OM I .ac..
Dat.1 F~.;.J '1., l't 1 Y
c..L~'i:. ~~c"5~
c. I... And.rlon, ..quira
2117 North 'ront stre.t
Harri.bur9, PA 17110
(717) 234-2401
Supra.a Court ID No. 31315
f I
, 'l
':,1'
",
,
I
, ,
,I
'II
''',\
I
, I
"I
\'I'j
I, I
I
I,
, I;'
1 L
1
, '
I '
I,
, ,
,
,
"
,
I,JI
~ ~... , ~ ~
IE "If"
I ,* \
;;t :'! \: I ~l ~ .~
,. ..
IL,-.,I.);;
!::J I !'. \ ,~ '\ \r)
I., :'; .~! "-
" ~
-:r ' cr.:t
~111j ;1' "- '-
r'o ,:ul
/-- ~ ' : ~ j '1. ~&
-,
>;~ t;~ ~ ~
"
, "
"
.1
"
'I
"
,',
1 '
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
County of Cumberland
, "
Ptrry L. 'SWarthout llach
w.
CQurt .01 Uonunon PI...
Bonky Trucking Inc.
563 OlIk Tree Road
Weebnineter, MD 21157
and
Richard Winfield Dunn, III
308 S lIt>unt street
BoltiJoore, MD 21223
No. .__AQ4m~~YJJ.m............. ..... t9.~.f.
.n ....~'lU.~t.J..Q!J.::.J.m...___.....u___...
To .__..~M~.1.~g~j.J1.~I...I.n.q!_!!.~.~_~c:~.r:.:<!.t:linfield Dunn III
You are hereby noufied thaI
.''!!!i__T:. ~..!lJ!I!~!ffi~!. ~c:~........ ..._ _ _....__ ___.. __ __ _... _. _.oo.. _.... '" ............ _..... ._...
the Plaintiff hae commenced an aclion In ..--.....---.civll..Act!l:ln.^.LllIII._...................u
',Unlt you which you are nqulred 10 de/end or a default Judgment may be entered aplnn you.
(SEALI
I
II
iI
"
.~l\ll.Il.f:J..I1'~~~n~ia';:'" -- -. -..... _....
nllle _.._...~~~.!~........._........ 19...~~
By ..~~Jtt<...__K..kitf~.,.a,/'h-Z__._..
/ D.puty ~.
"
, .,
I I
"
,
, ,
.,
,
"
'I'
"
I,
I,
~ ,"ot~
'II' ~.
"! ~ ,.
:.'ii 'r
" ,
. ~, .":
~' -,
'..,
-. ,"
, ,
, ,
t'XJ \\
.
,.. " ,j
.~ .>
, '.,
',I
"
I,
"
,
, ,
"
"
"
I'
,
I, I
i
,
.,
,1,
, ,
I
,
.,
"
"
I.
"
, ,
,
I,'
"
'I ,
"
"
!
jI
,
"..'11
;!
"
"
, I
,
!
"
h
,[
,
::
Ii
/:
,
I,
!
~
I
,
,
11
'.1
.\
,
,
'I
I ~_
I
,
11\
i
'I;
"
"
'j
, ,
Ii
, i
,
r
i'
I,'
\
,
"
,I
" .
.
;'I
;r; ~~',~' "
- ;"1
~ ..
,
.f~
Nt
"
... " , , oj,'
"
1; i,
',~~TJ ,
"" " ,.,
" ,
:.1.:-,
,I'
"
, \
, "
!Iii d
'I
'I'!
"
" ,
, ,
: ,I ,
"
I
I" \' !
! I ,
,
"
, , "
I
" , "
", " "
,
I, "
, "
"
j'll
iil "
, "
,,'
.
.. ,
.'
ANY 1.. SWAR'l'HOU'l' BACH, I IN THS COUR'l' OF COMMON PI..AS
PJ.a.i.lltitt I CUHBERl.iAN/J COUNTY, PA
I
v. I NO. 484 - cIVIl. 1.994
I
BANKY 'l'RUCKING, INC., and I CIVIl. AC'l'ION - I.AW
RICHAR/J WINFIEI./J /JUNN, III, I
/JetencJan t I JURY 'l'RIAJ. /JSMAN/JS/J
NO'fICE
YOU HAV' B"N BU'D IN COV.H'l'. If you wish to defend.
against the olaims let forth in the following page., you mu.t take
aotion within twenty (201 day. after this complaint and Notio. are
oervedi by enterinq a wr tten appearance perlonally or by attorney
and ti in9 in writinq with the Court your d.ten..s or objeotion. to
the olaims set forth againlt you. You are warned that if you fail
to do so the oase may proceed without you and a judgment may b.
entered a9ainet you by the Court without further notioe for any
money olaimed in the complaint or for any other claim or reli.f
requested by the Pia intH!. You may 1010 money or proporty or
other riqhts important to you.
YOU SlIOULD TAjt;E THIS PAPF.R TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE, IF
YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE
THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL
HELP.
court Administrator
Cumberland County courthouse, 4th Floor
One courthouse Square
carlisle, PA 17013-3387
(717) 240-6200
NO'fICIA
Le han cJemandedo a usted en J.a aorte. Si ulted quier.
detendere. de eatal de~1andas expuestae en lae paqina. .iguiente.,
usted tiene ~iente (20) dias de plazo al partir de la taohe de 1.
demanda y la notitieacion. Usted dabe pl'ellentar una aparieneia
escrita 0 en Persona 0 par abogado y arohivar en la corte en torma
esorita SUI detenlas 0 sus objectionel alaI demandas encontra d.
su persona. Sea avisado que si ulted no Ie defiende, la cort..
tomara medidas y puede entrar una orden contra usted sin previo
aviso 0 notificaeion y por cualquier queja 0 alivio que el pedido
en la petieion de demanda. Usted puede perder dinero 0 SUS
propiedades 0 otros derechos importantes para usted.
LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABODAGO INMEDIATAMENTE. SI NO
TUNE ABOGADO 0 S1 NO T1ENE EL DINERO BUFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL
SERVICIO, VAYA EN PERSONA 0 LLAME POR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA
DIRECC10N
SE ENCUENTRA EBCRITA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE BE PUEDE CONSEGUIR
ASISTENCIA LEGAL.
Court Administrator
cumberland county courthouse, 4th Floor
One Courthouse Square
carlisle, PA 17013-3387
(717) 240-6200
thllfliu.. .\LVIIIII.U'ON' ,. It.H'IIoN
28' 1 NORTH 'RONT STREET. HARRISBURG. PENNSVLVANIA , 1110-1223
olCIll.HI"I'^"'""I....,IaloIIIN..........' II, I~
v.
I IN 'l'H. COlIR'l' 01 CONNON "UM 0'
I CfJHURLAND COUN'l"/, ".NNSrLVANZA
I
I NO. 484 - CIVIL 11194
I
I
I JURr 'l'RIAL D."ANDlID
,
ANr L. IMAR'J'HOU'l' BACH,
Pl.JnUrt,
BANlC'1f 'tRUCKINO, INC., end
RICHARD NINI'ULD DUNN, 111,
netendent.
00Ml!LA00
1I0W 001l1. Plaintiff, Amy L. Swarthout Bach, by and throulJh her
attorneya, BmilJel, Anderaon , Sack., and in .upport ot this
complaint avera the tollowingl
1. Amy L. Swarthout Bach (hereinatter reterred to as
"Plaintitt"), is an adult individual currently reeidinlJ at.
972 snyder Hill Road, Ithaca, New York.
2. Richard Wintield Dunn, III (hereinatter reterred to as
Detendant "Dunn"), i8 an adult individual currently reeiding at 308
South Mount street, Baltimore, Maryland.
3. Banky Truckinq, Ino. (hereinatter reterred to as
Defendant "Banky"), is II Maryland corporation with ita prinoipal
place of busineas looated at 563 Oak Tree Road, Westminster,
Maryland.
OOUNT I
AllY L. '."TROUT 110H v. RIOK"D .IIl.IILD DUIlV. III
... paralJraphs 1 through 3 are incorporated herein by
reterence.
HHUIH'.. A1VlJlIRNON ,. HA".N
a"l NOIITH '~ONT ITIIUIT. HA~IIIU'U~O. PINNIVLIIANIA 11l 10-' a23
5. On Fe~ruary 17, 1992, at approximately 41~OPM, Plaintiff
Waa stopped ~ehind traffic in a 1986 Honda Aocord in the Bouth-
~ound lane of Interstate 83, cumperland county, Penn8ylvania,
6. At the aforem~ntioned time and place, a 1985 Chevrolet
cavalier operated Py Rose Moore Noss was stopped in traffic pehind
Plaintitf's vehicle.
7. At the aforementioned time and place, Defendant Dunn,
'lIhile driving a 1992 Ford truck, collided into the rear end of R08e
Moore Ness's vehicle which was Dubsequently pushed into the rear
end of Plaintiff'D vehicle, causing her serious bodily injury a8
more fully Bot forth herein.
8. The injuries and damageD hereinafter set forth were
caused solely by o~ were the direct and proximate result of the
neg 1 igence of Defendant Dunn in any or all of the following
respects:
a. In fai ling to have his vehicle uncier proper controll
b. In being inattentive and failing to maintain a
sharp lookout of the road and surrounding trafficI
c, In 1.ailing to exercise caution and care;
d, In failing to avoid a collision when Defendant Dunn
should have seen Plaintiff on the road in full view
of th~ Defendant Dunnl
e, In failing to sound a horn or give other warning of
the approach of his vehicle;
t. In failing to operate the brakes in such a manner
so that his vehicle could be stopped in time to
avoid a collision; and
- 2 -
COUNT II
~Y L. SWARTHOUT DACij-YJ->>ANKY TRUCK!NG, !~C~
11. Paragraphs I through 10 are incorporated herein by reference,
12. 'rhe vehicle which collided with Plaintitt was owned by
Defendant Banky and was at all times relevant hereto being operated by
a servant, agent, or employee of Banky TrUcking, Ino., who wae then and
there engaged in and upon the performance of duties of employment within
the scope of said servant, agent or employee's authority and upon the
business ot the Defendant.
13. The injuries and damages hereinafter set forth were cau.ed
solely by or were the direct and proximate result of the negligenoe of
Defendant Banky in any or all of the following respects I
a. In failing to employ competent driVers;
b. In employing drivers who in the course of their
employment fail to operate vehicles in accordance
with the statutes of the Commonwealth of
pennsy 1 vania.
IfHIRII'081l, Plaintiff brings this action against Defendant Banky
Trucking, Inc. to I'eeover damages in excess of '1'en Thousand Dollare
($10,000.00) and in excess of this county's mandatory arbitration
limite.
Datet A,I..) J ;2 ~ I '"f rN_
BYI
SHIGEL, ANDERSON & SACKS
<6~~,~cL__
c. Anderson, Esquire
1.0. No. 21315
2917 North Front street
HarriSburg, PA 17110
(717) 234-2401
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF
- 4 -
II'
"
,
, ,
,
"
VERIFICATION
I, Amy L. Swarthout Bach, verify that the .tatement.
contained in the foregoing Complaint are true and correct to the
beet of my knowledge, information and belief. I understand that
false statements therein are made subject to the penalties ot
18 Pa.e.s. S4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
Dater
\\ / I:1i!3Lf
;(~~
~ Amy . SWar ou ac
" ,
, '
"
"
"
Ii
I
, I
"
" '
,
\,'
,
F
"" ". .MtrIICf1't 1Mm,
PlaJntttt,
v.
, I' 'I'" 0Dl1", or 001IIIOII PUM or
, CU~D 'Yllfn, P..."lNMlIA
,
, 10. 414 ClVI" 1114
,
,
, .mar 'I'UM. DBIINfInD
,
UIIR 'I'1I1cn.Q, I'C., .....
IUCBMIIJ "1"IBD DUD, Ill,
Detendant.
x c. Lea Andarlon, Ilquira, heraby oartify that I hava .arv.d
the ori9inal and two true and oorr.ct oopie. of Pl.intiff Aay L.
Iwarthout .aoh'. InterroCJatod.. Direoted to Defendant Riohard
Winfiald Dunn, IU, upon the tollowin9 .. addu...d below by
dapo.itin9 the .... in the United statal .ail,
Harri.bur9, '.nn.ylvania on thi.
i day of
po.ta9a prepaid, at
l/~j , un.
HARVIY FREEDENBERG, ISQUIRI
IICNIIS, WALLACB , NURICK
100 PINI STREIT, P.o. lOX 1166
HARRISBURG, PA 17101.1166
IIIIOIL, AlDI.,OM I .ac..
Data. ).(j!.J l I '7 {i { By.
.. er.on,
I.D. # 21315
2917 North Front stra.t
H.rri.burq, PA 17110
(717) 234.2401
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFr
~,
,
~l'; If
':"111',
,j'
"
,
, ~I
.
j' '
" ~
Mr Ji. "Mf'l1IOl1f' UD.~
I'laJaUtI ,
Y.
, I. 1'.. 00fI1IfI' 01' 001IIIOII "IJIM or
, COIINIUMD ctJf/JI'n, "..nlNNlIA
,
, 110. 414 ozvn 11'4
,
,
, .nJRr I'UM. DMIINIUD
,
I
I
UlfR I'IIlIOn.G, 1.0., and
UC1lAltD ,,1.rlnJJ w. , I:n,
Delead.at.
I
I C. Lee Ander.on, I.quire, h.r.by c.rt~fY that I have .erved
a true and correct copy cf Plaintiff by L. Swarthout aach/.
Reque.t for Production of Document. to Riohard Winfield Dunn, III,
upon the followinv .. .ddr....d below by depo.itinq the .am. 1n tha
United state. maU, po.taqeprepa1d, at Harr!aburv, P.nn.ylvania on
r t~,
).
day of
, 199!l.
thb
HARVEY fRIEDENBERC, ESQUIRE
MCNEES/ WALLACE' NURICI(
100 PINI STREET, P.O. BOX 1166
HARRISBURC, PA 17108-1166
Date.
j~tI/ l. /? 'if'"
Iy.
.KIOIL/ AMnla.o. I .ACI.
J(j ftJtu
-' .elL .---fIAt _.
. n arlon, ..qu ra
I.D. I 2131!l
2917 North front street
Harrilburq, PA 17110
(717) 234-2401
ATTORNEYS fOR PLAINTI"
\ \
I'
I
I
\
I
I \i
~
.
:I~
I..j
it)
1:1
~.I
en
't.l
'-I,.
"
"
-'I II
, ,
'I-I
, '
,
." ':
I ,
"
i'
'II
, ,
" ,
i!
II
1;1
Ii,'
"
"
I',
I'll
:i
I
l
'I
"
'Ii
1/
I,
"
,I ., 1\
I' "
, I
,-I, 1,1
I,
"
"
I, I,
,
'I "
1 , 1 i'
II
, "
Iq
,'I
II, I,; ~
: ,
"
,
.Ii ,
I ,
, ,
"
I I
, ,
I,
i'
I
\ 'I', "
" ,jl
II
,I,
, 'I
~~
I
" I
,
,'I
1
'. ",
, "
';
[,.1
"...,
,
,
,
I I
!; I
, I
I'
I'
'"
" II
\,
,I
"
"
, ,
,I
II,'
\,;
..,
,I
;"1
, '
I',l
'I
.,11
,I
I,
,
"
"
~
Ie
;;t
('oJ
',I
"
?i.r
" .
\, ,I
I. ~ " ,
c'..f, H
Ii. I".' ~
'10 J,I
",' ,
1,'1
,
I'
,
'i
",
I,
"
--:r 'I)
l ;.
-
It' ..
1,.1
~
I,
"
"
, ,
, I,
'il
"
I'
"'i
"
"
I'
.
.
ANY L. 'WARTHOUT BACHl
Pldntlff
I IN THB COURT OF COMMON PLIAS
I CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PBNNSYLVA~IA
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I
I NO. 484 CIVIL 1994
I
v.
BAN~Y TRUC~ING, INC. and
RICHARD WINrIELD DUNN, IU
Dahndanta
ANSWER TO COMPLAINT
1.-13. Pursuant to Pa. R. Civ. P. 1039(a), as amended
affactive Saptember 1, 1994, all averments of Plaintiff's
Complaint not deemed admitted under the provisions of said rule
are hereby denied.
WHBREFORB, Defendants Banky Truokinq, Inc. and Richard
Winfield Dunn, III demand that the Complaint of Plaintiff Amy L.
Swarthout Bach be dismissed with prejudioe and that the oosts of
t~is action be awarded to Defendant.
MaNBBS, WALLACB , NURIC~
'.::;>
erq
o. 331!52
17108-1166
Attorneys for Defendants
D.t~ISI 2/tr {f~'"
-
VIRIPICAfION
'ubjeot to the penaltie. ot 18 Pa.C.B.A. 14g04, relatinq tQ
un.worn fal.ifioltion to authoritie., I hereby certifY thlt I I.
one of the Defendant. named in the foreqoinq An.wer to complaint,
thlt I hive reviewed the foreqoinq An.wer, and thet the
adai..lon. and denial. .et forth therein are true and correct to
the be.t of my information and belie'.
_//~~
....
~~-~
Dated.
II
\
I'
, I
I'
I"
, I,
, ,
,,'
"
,I
"
I,
I '
"
I ,
),'1
I
,"
"
I
I
" >I
"
"
, 'I
,I!
I ,
,I
<11l~TIPIC:~1! or 8':~VICIl
The undar.i9nad hereby cartifi.. that a trua and complate
,
copy of tha fora90in9 An.wer to complaint wa. ..rved by fir.t-
01... ..11, po.tage prapald, u~on tha followln91
C. Lae Ander.on, I.qulra
SMIGEL, ANDERSON , SAC~S
2917 North Front Stre.t
Hardaburg, fA 17110
er9
dInt.
Of
p.tedl1.'~'/f('
, ,
, '
,
I
"
,
, ,
"
'.'I
, ,
:1
i'!
1 '
, ,
, ,
"
, I
"
,'l
,
I,
, "
-
MuNEES. WALLAmr 6 NU/lICI<
100 "m" ,.T,url"T
P. u. .cu 'IU
..,..""Iu..a, PA t1l01
1,~,.I. ,_~",
MI'I I.. "MI'I'~ lAC.,
PJ.l.nt1tt,
v.
, IIf ,..a CtJUIfI' or COIIIIOII PUAII or
, CU"IJIfIlLMD COf1If'I'r, p"'NnWNUA
,
, NO. .,. OIVIL 1,..
,
,
I JUIl" S'RIAL DaHANDBD
,
INfn S'IfI]C.INa, INC., ud
ItIC.ARD "INrIa"" OUNH, III,
DIItenduab
I C. Le. Ander.on, E.quire, h.reby o.rtify that I have ..rv.d
. true and correct oopy of thl foreqoinq Plaintiff'. R..pon.. to
Def.ndant.' R.que.t tor Production of Dooument. upon the following
a. addr....d b.low by d.poaitinq the .am. in the Unit.d stat..
..il, po.taqe prepaid, at Harri.burq, penn.ylvania on thi. 23rd day
of February, 1995.
Harvey rreedenberq, I.quir.
McN.e., Wallace , Nuriok
100 Pin. street, P.o. Box 1166
Harri.burq, PA 17108"1166
Date I )~-6
~ j . 1'/9 (
,
BYI
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF
, :
""1.1-I'l'Ultr, UI' MltkVIt'JlllUM NOTlt'1I ()II t)M^I.lnWUIjI'f1oN"'l^/klll~'/hlU~ J4. l'ili.'
AMY L, SWARTHoUT BACH, . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
.
Pl aln tl ft I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
v. I NO. 484 - CIVIL 1994
I
BANKY TRUCKING/ INC., and I CIVIL AC~'ION - LIlW
RICHARD WINFIELD DUNN, III, .
.
Det'fllldllnt I JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
CEln:lll.C.ATIt~
I, C. Los Andoraon, Esquire, heroby certify that I have served
a true and oorreot OQPy of tho foregoing Plaintiff'a Notioe of Oral
Deposition of Defendant Richar'd Winfield Dunn/ III, upon the
following as addressed below by depositing the Slime in the United
states mail, postage prepaid, at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania on this
26th day of June, 1995.
Harvey Freodenberg, Esquire
McNEES, WAll,ACE & NURICK
100 Pine street, P,O. Box 1166
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1166
SMIGEL, ANDERSON , IlOl1
BYI
e/.
re
Date, t'tJ... ~ ~ I qq J~._
U/
C, Le dorson,
1.0, # 21315
2917 North Front Strest
HarriSburg, PA 17110
(717) 234-2401
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINrIFF
"
I ,
I'
1)'1
F
~t
.f .
," .,
~~)'..,
~'
~~
IJ~
~
'It ,,.
no
~
~
. ~",
, .
:.' ~; ~I ~.j
I ..11
, I
t;~:
'I'
"
'1
'I
il
I
"
I
,
'I
'I
, I
I'
I
, ,
1'" , "
'I
I
I'
'I
'I
"
I'
"
"
"
:1
"I
, '
" ,
"
ii'
,I
,
,I
I
',\\
,,')
, .
I
"
"
"
"
"
, !
"
" ,
41171.1.".lIUIlIOl JolQI'II)H ~ IWICTlOHtIC\.MIeoI/'" 37, 1191
A (J(i ():! ImJ.~)
Jlrv
AN'i L. lMAIf'l'HOU'l' lJACH,
Pla:J.ntJ.tt
, IN'l'H. COtJR'l' 01' COHHON PL.AS
, CUHURLANDCOUN'l''i, P.NNSllLVANIA
,
, NO. 484 - CIVIL 1114
I
I CIVIL AC'l'10N - LAN
I
I JURY 'l'RIAL DEMANDBD
v.
SANKll 'l'RUCKING, INC., and
RICHNtD WINFULD DUNN, Ill,
Detendant
RULE
AND NOW, this ~ r J. day ot ~~... ~ t I UU, upon
con.ideration ot the within Motion for Sanction., a RULE i. hereby
i.sued on Defendant Richard Winfield Dunn, III, to .how cause why
sanction. should not be impo.ed on him.
Rule returnable in 2.0 days. fc . _ W.., C L
BY THE COURT
'I '
! :!
.. j'.' 1'1 II
I, . ~. i I i II I
1
! ii
\
S6~ H,! V -J "I
~111
4f/1.1.IlNarIllllI'lll MJK.7Illll11Cl.v./I" 7/, '''1
.
v.
r IN 'l'H8 COURT 0' COHHON PL.A8
r CUHBlRLAND COUN'l'Y, P8NNS'iLV ANIA
,
, NO. 484. CIVIL 1"4
,
, C1VIli AC'l'ION - LAN
,
, JURY 'l'RIAL DfHANO.O
ANY L. lMAR'l'HOU'l' BACH,
PlaJ.nUtt
IANKf 'l'RUCICINO, INC. and
RICHARD ,.,INl1.LO PUNN, 111,
oetendlnt
MOTION FOR SANCTIONS
NOW COMES the plaintiff, by her attorney., smiqel, Ander.on .
Sack., and make. the following Motion pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. No.
40191
1. The Plaintiff 11 Amy Bach, who re.ide. at 972 snyder Hill
Road, Ithaca, New York.
2. The Defendant. are Richard winfield Dunn, III, of 30.
South Mount street, Baltimore, Maryland, and Banky Truckinq Co.,
Whioh i. headquartered in We.tmin.ter, Maryland.
3. Thi. action ari.e. out of a motor vehicle accident which
occurred on February 17, 1992, at Exit 18-A on Interetate 83 in
Cumberland county, Penneylvania.
4. Plaintiff noticed the depodtion of Defendant Richard
Winfield Dunn, III, for June 30, 199~.
Notioa attached hereto a. Exhibit. "A".
~. Defendant Dunn failed to appear for .aid depoe1tion.
See copy of Depoeition
6. Couneel for Defendant Dunn agreed to produce him for
depo.ition at a later time, but hae been unable to do '0.
7. Defendant Dunn" action are a violutio" of pa. R.C.P. No.
4019(a) (1) (iv).
.
WHIRIFORI, Plaintiff reque.t. that thi. Honorable Court enter
I
an order refu.ing Def.ndent Dunn frol t.ltifyin9 at thl trial of
thi. aotion, or .uoh other aotion the court de.m. ju.t under the
ciroumatane.. .
R..peotfully lubmitted,
SMIGEL, ANDERSON , SACRS
/
~l- ~t 95"'
By.
Date.
Harr 11 ur9, PA
(717) 234-2401
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF
II '
"
II i
",
il
,
, "
"
Iii
"
,
,
, ,
,
1.1,
"
,
"
"
,'I
'; >i
'i'
"
, "
"" 2 .
"
'I
" "
.
I' .i' ,\1 I, ~~
I'
",.j:., ,
I I ~'i
I ~
I Oi
" '1
I i' ,I
, I
, "
,
.\ " ~
,I ,
I
" ,
,
" ,
~
.
:'r;:
, j~..
....,
N
',r)
/II,
U
";",1..'
",
II
,I
II
'I
I
!
,
,I
I;")
-?;~
"
,
iA
"
I'
"
, ,
,I
"
,
,
,I
"
,
'i
I
,
"
"
"
"
.
\,,,''''''';!,dl
4lI71"''IHll1'IC~ 0' OIlAI.IIIII'IIlIrrI<l/l'''...,....'A.....'. 1991
~Y L, liWAR'l'HoU'l' BACH, I IN 'l'HIl COUIl'l' OF COHHON Pl..M
PldntUt r CUHBEIlLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
v. I NO. 484 - CIVIL 1994
I
lANKY 'l'IlUCKING, INC., and I CIVIL AC'l'ION - LAW, 1~
" fil
RICHARD "'IN1'lILD DUNN, Ill, I "
Detendant I .lUllr 'l'RIAL DEHANri~Q , -J
NOTICE OF ORAL DEPOSITION
,:jl
, .
,," ,
-
-
, " w
, I " '"
-. r")
, .: '11 it.:
" -
.c' 1~
.<
tfi
TOI
RICHARD WINFIELD DUNN, III, Detendant
BANKY TRUCKING, INC., Detendant
and HARVEY FREEDENBERG, ESQUIRE, their counsel
fLllII TAJtI HO'IIIC. that pursuant to the Rul.. ot civil
proaedure, the underaiqned will take the depoaition at RO'I KOOal-
HI", upon oral examination, tor the purpose at discovery and tor
U$e a. evidence in the above action, or tor both purpoae., betore
a Notary Public tor the Commonwealth at Penn$ylvania, or before
aome other person authorized or commissioned to adminiater oatha,
at .NIOIL, ABDIIIOH , IAO~8, 2917 North Front street, Harri.burq/
Pennaylvania, on Tuesday, Auqust 8, 1995, at 10100 AM, on all
mattera, not privileqed, which are relevant and material to the
i.aue. and .ubject matter involved in the pendlnq action,
inaludinq, but not limited to, the tactl of the alleqed inaident,
event a leadinq up thereto, Bnd the lnjurielil and damaqes suttered a.
a reault ot the inoident, and the said deponent is requb:ed to
appear at the atoreadd time at the above address and submit to
.uah examination.
SMIGEL, ANDERSON & SACKS
Datil
/IV?
~
) , rIft \
I
BYI
~ ru!t:.A
C. L
ID# 2 3115
2917 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110-1223
(717) 234-2401
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF
I.,' r
4Cl71....lnA*"'. TQ DMnlItJ'IHUJl/L"'l.AIUof/I",...t..II. 11l'I5
ANY 11. BNAR'l'HOU'l' J~CH,
PldntJ.tt
I IN 'l'H' COU~'l' 01' CONNON PI/8AB
I CUHB1&lIliANO COIJN'l'Y, P8NN8YZ,VANIA
I
I NO. 484 - CIVIL JU4
I
I CIVIL AC'l'ION - Z,AW
I
I JURY '1'IIIAL D1&HANDED
v.
JANICY 'l'IUICIC:rNQ, :rNC., IInd
~lCHARD WINl'IlILO DUNN, III,
Oetendant
PRAECIPE TO DISCONTINUE
TO THE PROTHONOT~RYI
Plea.. dbcont.inue the above-captioned action with prejUdice.
Dat.el
I.~., I~ It'/'/(
SMIGEL, ANDERSON ,
/ I
BYI . C . non, i.~J{t -..
2917 ort: Front Street
>>arrisburg, PA 17110-1223
(717) 234-2401
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF
Ii'
; ,I
,
"
\I ,I
, ,
"
, "
II
" ,
<,<
< ,
"
"
"" Q (.;
fro ,..., " <
~', ,
':1. ",
~O :'J.
,{, I.."....
('; .".. I'.J .~ ,I
{-. I.... 1:,\ ~f ",
}I ,
~:, .- ,:...)
" ... (,) ,'I ""j
fr:!i I (..) "jii.)
~<I
r: ..I f:.."'-
l,r. tn 13
u .:n , 'I
'I
Ijl
,
, '
< ,
I'
"
\,
\"
\
"I
,
<
"
"
,
, I
'I'
I,
,
;,1
,
"
I
;I
"
,