The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About94-00938 ~ '-- " ~ ~ ~' ~ .~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ,,- c ~ '- '" ' "t d!::' J h .,., <:- f '"\;. . 1 i ~~'ti d~ I., "., '", ':r '" .-;, r J . fl . ~~ -1. .. .~ . " ~ \:'" ~ ,.. ". ... , '~ j 'I 1 I \f~ ~ G! ~ ~ ? ~ '5 , .~ Q \) " ~~ " 1 .. "- i" 1 :J -~ -' / I I~ ~ :.... .-:> en '::-' "--."1 ... ',~ . - '" "'1 l' .... ''I :'0, ..., ,.. ,.... In The Court of Common Pleas of York County. Pennsylvania 7l.D. 1.Jf~ Iq<;~ RENTAL UNIFORM SERVICE OF HANOVER VS JOHN'S MOBILE REPAIR & JOHN A CUNNINGHAM Case Number 93 NO 02209 02 Case Type Transcript Certification of Docket Entries and Judgments I. the undersigned Prothonotary of the Court of Common Pleas of York County. Pennsylvania. do hereby certify that the following is a full. true and correct copy of the docket entries in the above captioned case. APPEARANCES D 001 JOHN'S MOBILE REPAIR 909 GRAHAMS WOOD REPAIR NEWVILLE PA 17241 UNREPRESENTED D 002 CUNNINGHAM. JOHN A 909 GRAHAMS WOOD RD NEWVILLE PA 17241 UNREPRESENTED POOl RENTAL UNIFORM SERVICE OF HANOVER 121 N BLETTNER AVE HANOVER PA 17331 UNREPRESENTED DOCKET ENTRIES 93/08/03 JUDGMENT ENTERED ON TRANSCRIPT FROM D J MARGARET L KLINEDINST DATED 6/3/93 IN THE AMT OF 56432.00 DISTRICT JUSTICE COSTS ON TRANSCRIPT IN THE AMT OF 585.00 9.25 93/08/03 85.00 93/08/03 NOTICE GIVEN RE: PA R. C, P. 236 0.00 JUDGMENT INDEX FOR PARTY AGAINST PARTY RENTAL UNIFORM SERVICE OF JOHN'S MOBILE REPAIR AMOUNT I2ATI1 ~ 6432.00 93/08/03 A ......'-'., .; ._..~..,.. '~4':" ._ __ __ '3&.. I,~j , . .:. FOR PARTY AGAINST PARTY ,RENTAL UNIFORM SERVICE OF CUNNINGHAM. JOHN A AMOUNT I2Anl ~ 64!2.0q 93/0B/03 A ATTY COMM: PROTHY DUE: THIS RECORD: 3.00 5.00 10.00 I further certify that judgment was entered in favor of Rental Unifonn Service 9f Hanover and against John's Mobile Rep.idr Ii John a CUnningham AD 19 93 on the 3rd day of August in said case in the amount of $6432.00 w/costs IN TESTIMONY WHEREOF. I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the seal of the Court. on the 3rd AD 19 94 day 0 f January ~'7bfiAA /-1 ~ Prothonotary By I; dS)) /t;J , " Deputy OFFICE OF THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNI'Y I'ftOTHONOTAIIY (717) 240-6195 ....~.. Lawrence E. Welker 1 Courthouse Square Carlisle, PA . John's Mobile Repair John A. Cunningham . 909 Grahams WoOd Road Newville, PA 17241 Datel February 16, 1994 QJi Ct.vJ /'1<)"1 No. . RB: RENTAL UNIFORM SERVICE OF HANOVER, INC. , Plalndff VB: JOHN'S MJBlLE REPAIR and JOHN A. CUNNINGHAM , Defendant Notice .. liven thet a judg}OOnt In the above ceptlonecl _tter .... been entered agelnllt you 011 j~ .:Jf {""ii . 8taeta-tl. OtIlell l!flO'PItelhTA"I\RY OP y~y POOTHCN1l'ARY OF CUMBERLlIND COON'lY Dy iL ,,"". P (.~~~~"~t a~uty If you have any quelltlonll concerning the llbove cue, pleue oon"Cltl Alan M. Cashnan, Esquire A Horney or PWng Parly 141 Broad\~ay, Suite 230 Addreoll Hanover, PA 17331 1.D. #16678 Telephone I (717) 632-9580 (Ph Ruin of Civil r~c(llIrl! nn. "n r'!vln~tI) PRAECIPE FOR WRIT OF EXECUTION (MONEY JUDGMENTS) P.R.C.P, 3101 to 3149 RENTAL UNlFURM SERVICE OF ........................................... HANOVER, INC. ........................................... IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF ~COUNTY , PENNSYLVANIA CUMBERIlIND VS, JOllli'S MOBILE REPAIR AND ........................................... r.~r ';;.: ~'o. Judgment No. ." t.... .~erll1,19 !i:t. JOHN A. CUNNINGHAM PRAECIPE FOR WRIT OF EXECUTION (MONEY JUDGMENT) ........................................... To the Prothonotary: ISSUE WRIT OF EXECUTION IN THE ABOVE MA ITER, (I) Directed to the Sheriff of, . . ~\>l:!.dcw~, . . , . . . . . , . .. . . . COllnty. Penna,: (2) against. .~q~.'.1! .~",~~~. F~~~~. .~~. ~.~~. ~... ,~~~".....,."...,..........,......,... . . .. , . ... . . . . . , , , , . . . . . . , .. . . . . . . , . . . . . . . , . , . . . . . . , . . , . . . . .. . .. . . . .. , . . . , .. , , l>efendnnl(sl: (3) and ..ainst .......................................................................... Garnlshee(s): (4) and Index this writ (a) ,against... .-lQm',Il.l:I9k~ll? ~,~P.<;1~:r. .!!I:l~. ~,q~. f\... .~~,.,..,..,' ............"...... ...,..............,..."".,.,....,.....;,.,............,............, Defendanl(s)nnd (h)' lIainst...,............,...,...,.................,....."."",..... ........................ . . . .. . .. . . . . , . . . . . , . , . . . . . , , . . . , . . . . . , , , . .. . , , .. , . , . . . . . . . . , . . .. , . . . . . , . ,Garnlshee(.), as a .Iis pendens ...Inst the real properly of the Defendanl(s) in the name of the Garnishee[s) qs follows: (Speclficallydeserlbeproperty). Any and all personal property belonging to the Defendant, including but not limited to all cash on hand, inventory, stock, tools, machinery and all of the attached vehicles pursuant to PA Dept. of Transportation Vehicle Record Abstract setting forth identification numbers, license plate numbers, etc. (all of which being unencumbered). Levy to occur at 909 Grahams Wood Road, Newville, PA 17241 and R.D. #3, Box 893, Newville, PA 17241, being the same property. m Amount due S.. 9,~?f..,qq.. ,...... IlIteml from 8/3/93 208.82 .................... TOlal .. p.,.6.~Q..&~. . , . . . . . . PIli' cOSls. Daled .. f~~r:t18!i'. .16,. .19?4. . . . , ~~. ^llolntyrml'I"illlii,(,i '1111 Illld" l'U",.,,1l II) ,,114.'11 Ihr '41" h tlilf'llnl '" rhr \I,tltll , ',-.,'1, '''ltU,.1\ ""lhtl,l'nl h" Rool, 1101lhl ,h' h . . . . t {nunl,. , nuld toe mdic'lIt't1 Ilndl"l Rult .1lnljrlll ",ill""rll 1'111 """1"1111"11 ilhl,llIr'nllll," l'i" ,)i,,., 0,.', '..' .1.< '.11.., ,/0, "'111I1\ In "hil-h l"llrd . "olf;t"lIrhf'IIIICI,,.,hf'ultll'-f'n"",,,'r'l'1II1I1I\ if 11111\",1'11 _;t'''id,ot,\ I..!<r ':1, I."J. 1.. .1"',.,, I""""rh 141(.llt.o\,C' ,h'IUld t't' '"""'I,ltlhJ onh illndr,ln, I II - .. ,'1 Ir"'l"n''''''1 'I. ,I.,. (. '1"'\ 'I ""1'". r, ullrdltd l"lnlhn,brd hv Mult' 111~lllJ \\ hili Iht """' h'ut' llllln,'lhtr ,t'Ul1h 111I1"\11I11 j. Il'q1llrt'l' a1\ 11',(IUhl' In 11111 . ......1\ t>\ " ~ I "1..""."" "I't flult 111~lf".. ",II:1'tarh 14) IN .hllUItI t!f r"'"rll"lrll IIlIh. il'tRI rl IIf"('U \ illlh" n~",.. "Ill,!" '.I",.,ll"~ _. I" . 1 \ ....,1 ,-,,'''',n,;n :IIi, p'nllni, I'Mh".1 t;.." Rull' 1I''''lt) ., """lirl'''"nr1rt'I',li. r1nrtll\ '..ho:- 1..,il'l' "",'n III ,1tl". ht,I"IIl\ I-I' ,... 1",Ih ill,II"'''I', "". ,,' ' , . .! !'. .I"hllll:'!, hi'll '" - ~ t-: o 7. ,oj- , , , . I&. . 0 , , , . , , ~~ . . . . . . , . . . . . . z ~i . . , . 0 u . , , II . ~ - ~ . ~ ! . . Ii :! . . II! t ... . . . . r.1 s 8l1: . , . . . I . ~ . , 2 . , . , , II. . 0 ... U . to ... . . . i 0: . . . c . . . . . 0 u . . . . . ~ . , . . a: ci . . Ii! 0: . , . ~'~ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . ~ . . , . . , . . . . . . . ~ .~ 1I~\I";):"II(lN 1I0ISS~JUO~ ~q Jl~J~tll~ nil 11I>lIIRrn I UO!SS~JUO~ ,(q p~J~llI~ IIIJlUllpn I . . ..:: ~J :~ ~ f ::i o!2 ...... "' c: "" ,::'.: .1 ...., "',.:" a:> ~,. ~ - - - l.I1 ~$ co .. ~ ,- , :" J.~ i .., ~ - tu .. '. U)'" " , ..c.. <.. ". " ~ '" !-- ? ~, -- ~ e u.. I:... ~e r -- .-a VI C 1/\ .,. ~ ~ $ ~ c. C' 1>. - ... r.> J r- ,... f J1 , ~ p ''-'~ - t AVH ," .~ " .lHDIMJI:lJ'l "8 N:IJ.\HI 'N:L\\UI , . S''''!/IO ,"11'/ \. . , . I-< '-<'-< ;1 nH ~ 00 ~Z ~ iHi - l'lS! >> . >tIl ~l'l r II ~ ~ .... . 0 zn ~ w o-!~ :J:: ~~ OH n r 0 ~ no <: . < 0 . I-< .~ ~ 0 OH ~~ . :>OH H c:: . ~ . ~ o-! - "1 H\Ot'" :>0 ~ ~ ~ tIlH Zt'" 0 Z.., no-! ~ . z ~ ~ =0 Hl'l ~!J! 00>0 ~ oz Z ~n~~~ z . . ~ 0 . Z :0:"1 C>1:1 n < z 0 a i~ . tIl tIlHH ~ no ~<O n ~ ~ ~ - ~ >> w R' ~ E;:>O HZ" 0 . ~ w - H tIlt"'I....~ z (; " ~ .. tIl:>O t::l :>0 .... H . ~ ~ :;( .. l'l? lD .... n H..... ~o ;; ~ ... III III l'l o-!:g~ Z " . 0 '" lD =' ..... 0 ~ c III =' e- =' -P-:E:cn"C " W ~ 0 e- M ><.... , ~ z Z III ..... ~~ w 0 =' ... N l-< M ... ~tIl N (;) Ol N III !;:~ I-l ~ RENTAL UNIFORM SERVICE OF HANOVER, INC., Plaintiff : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : CIVIL AcrlON - LAW v. JOHN'S MOBILE REPAffi and JOHN A. CUNNINGHAM, Defendant : NO. 938 CIVIL 1994 : IN ASSUMPSIT ORDER OF COURT NOW, this.:M day of May, 1994 on petition of defendants and on motion by their attorney, Harold S, Irwin, III, Esquire, a rule is hereby issued upon the plaintiff, Rental Uniform Service of Hanover, Inc., to show cause why the judgment filed to this number and term should not be stricken as requested. ~ r Rule returnable -.J ) days after service by certified mail upon the plaintift's attorneys of record. All proceedings to stay pending tJte.disposition oflllis malter iR IlBtk YliIrk . ~, H4Y 3 3 38 fJJ '91/, , ,', 'c'i'f/CE OF "It .', ,r,IOl/n'RY CUkefk~':I/D COUfih I'f/tItS (L \A'~!4 RENTAL UNIFORM SERVICE OF HANOVER, INC., Plaintiff : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : CIVIL ACfION - LAW v. JOHN'S MOBILE REPAffi and JOHN A. CUNNINGHAM, Defendant : NO. 938 CIVIL 1994 : IN ASSUMPSIT PETITION FOR RUI.E TO SHOWCAUSE NOW come the defendants, John's Mobile Repair and John A. Cunningham, by their attorneys, Irwin, Irwin & McKnight, Esquires, and file this petition for a rule to show CBuse why the judgment entered in this mBtter should not be stricken, representing as follows: I. Plaintiff is Rental Unifonn Service of Hanover, Inc., a corporation hBving a place of business at 121 North Blettner Avenue, Hanover, York County, Pennsylvania 17331. 2. The defendants are John's Mobile Repair, a sole proprietorship, and John A Cunningham, an adult individual having a place of business and residence at 909 Graham's Woods Road, Newville, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17241. 3. This matter concerns B contract between the parties which was negotiated and executed in Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. Furthennore, to the extent that plaintiff perfonned services for the defendants, those services were in each instance completed upon the delivery ofunifonns to the defendant in Cumberland County, PennsylvaniB. .' 4. During the course of the arrangement between the parties, defendants became dissBtisfied with the perfonnance of plaintiff in that plaintiff defaulted on the tenns of its perfonnance of the contract by failing to provide its services in the time and in the mBMer to which it had Bgreed. 5. As a result of plaintift's failure to satisfactorily perfonn the services to which it had agreed, defendant tenninated the contract and refused to make further payment for future services under the contract.. 6, Plaintiff subsequently filed an action in assumpsit for the recovery of various amounts such as would have become due under the contract hBd it not been tenninated, 7. This action was inappropriately filed with York County District Justice Margaret L. Klinedinst, of20 Wayne Avenue, Suite 2, Hanover, York County, PennsylvaniB. 8. The proper venue for this action was Cumberland County, since the location of the defendant, the execution of the contract and the completion of services under the contract all were SitUBted in Cumberland County 9, On June 3, 1993, judgment was entered on behalf of the plaintiff and against the defendant in the amount of$6,518.50 10. On June 25, 1993, defendants' counsel filed a notice ofoppeal and forwarded a copy to plaintiff, together with a rule to file a complaint. Plaintiff received the rule to file a complaint , , on June 28, 1993 as indicated on the copy of the notice of appeal and rule to file a complaint which is attached as Exhibit II A" and incorporated herein by reference as if fully set forth at length. 11, The notice of Bppeal, however, was inadvertently filed by defendants' counsel in Cumberland County, the proper venue for the suit, and not York County, the county in which the District Justice judgment was rendered. 12, Subsequent to the filing of the notice of appeal and service of the rule to file a complaint, and subsequent to the expiration of the thirty day appeal period, defendants' counsel discovered that the appeal should have been talcen in York County. However, having heard nothing further from plaintiff or its counsel, including the fact that no complaint had been filed within the twenty day period, defendants' counsel assumed the plaintiff had decided not to pursue the case. Accordingly, defendants' counsel took no further Bction at that time. 13, Without notice to defendants, however, plaintiff did enter B judgment on the record of the York County Prothonotary in August, 1993, despite the existence of the appeal. Then, in February, 1994, plaintiffs counsel Bpparently transferred this judgment to Cumberland County at the above tenn and number, It was not until that time that defendants and their counsel were notified of the existence of the judgment. 14. On March 10, 1994, within a week of learning of the judgment, defendants' counsel sent a letter to plaintiffs counsel advising him of the situation and requesting him to withdraw the judgment so that the parties could proceed to litigate the matter on the merits. A copy of this letter is Bttached as Exhibit liB" and incorporated herein by reference BS if fully set forth at length. , , 1 S. To date plain tift's counsel hBS not responded to that letter, However, Bgain without notice to defendants or their counsel, plaintiff directed the Cumberland County Sheriff to levy against the personal property of defendants. 16. On May 2, 1994, defendants' counsel filed petition for a rule to show cause why the judgment filed in York County should not be stricken. Although on April 28, 1994, plaintift's counsel hBd been notified of the court appearance to tiled the petition for a rule to show cause and of his opportunity to object, Attorney Cashman did not appear, 17. On May 2, 1994, Judge Uhler, York County Court of Common Pleas, entered an order granting the motion for a rule to show cause and provided that all proceedings in York County are stayed pending final disposition of this matter, Judge Uhler also suggested, based on the fBcts as presented in defendant's petition, that defendants' request to strike the judgment in order to proceed on the merits of the case would ultimately be granted and thBt, therefore, the parties were encouraged to resolve this part of the case Bmicably, if possible. 18. Because plaintiff has also entered its judgment in Cumberland County and the executed on that judgment, it is necessary for this Court to strike the judgment and stay the execution proceedings in Cumberland County, pending the resolution of the proceedings in York County on the merits of the case. 19. Defendants have a viable defense to the basic claim filed against them in that plaintiff failed to perfonn its services in accordance with the tenns of its contract. Furthennore, plaintiffs have perfonned virtually no services whBtever for the amount of monies claimed due from defendant since the basis for the claim is what would have been charged to defendants under the f,.;O::' -7-;-,-.~ . . contract for services had the contract not been terminated, In short, plaintift's claim is for services that it has not performed at all. 20, Plaintiff will not be prejudiced by the granting of this motion to strike the judgment in order for the parties to proceed to handle this case on the merits, since such action is no more than should have occurred in the first place had plaintiff responded to the notice of appeal filed in June, 1993. Defendants' assets will not be dissipated in the meantime as the business is a continuing going concern. WHEREFORE, defendants request that your honorable court issue a rule upon plaintiff to show cause why the judgment entered in this case should not be stricken. May 3, 1994 HAROLD S, IRWIN III Attorney for Defenda West Pomfret Professional Building 60 West Pomfret Street Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013 (717) 249-2353 Supreme Court ID No. 29920 --~~~- ...,,--., VERIFICATION The foregoing petition is based upon infonnation which has been gathered by my counsel in the preparation of this lawsuit. The lenguBge of the document is the lenguage of my counsel end not my own, I have read the answer end to the extent that it is based upon infonnation which I have given to my counsel, it is true and correct to the best of my knowledge, infonnation end belief. To the extent thBt the content of the enswer is that of counsel, I have relied upon counsel in making this verification. I understend that false statements made herein are subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C,S.A. Section 4094, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities, May 3,1994 ~ CL CJ/1A~~~ (} HN A CUNNINGHAM ,"......._-"'." .' " EXHIBIT "A" .~-,; '.~. :r~:_" , COMMONWEALTH Of "NNSYIVANIA COUll Of COMMON PllAS NOTICE OF APPEAL .' FROM JUDICIAL DISTlICT DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT COMMONPlIASN.. dO'l" ~~~ J??..J ':1 J.) .'.~ '" .~ _ NOTICE OF APPEAL "'"'" ~'. 1. Notice i. gi.on that Ihe o'ppellcM11';. filed in the aba.e Court of Common Plea. an appeal from the judgment ",ndered by Ihe Di.triel JUlliee on the dole and in I~e ffjo men~ocl bolaw: ,~ ' . . ! .... '. ... u...O( ..., ..: ;~.; ;::;'~. ;. MIl'.JOB :A. ...~:~~ .JL MAG Dl5ol.t.lQ OIHAMl Of D.J ? , 19-3-415 ,0........." .I01111'S JIJIlILE &PAUl AID 's IIJBILZ OAllOl'~IO( .JUJIE:3 1993 - cu ...... . CLAIMANT (... Po. R.C.PJ.P. ,,~ TA19 CV-oooDI0B-93 IT 19 This block will be signed ONLY when this notation is required under Pa. R.C.P.J.P. No. looBB. This Notice of Appeal, when received by the Dilfrict Jus'ice, will ope rote 01 a SUPERSEDEAS 10 Ih" judgmonl for po..e"ian in thi. ColO. odion 1,.10" District Judice. 5';"Oh"" 01 '''0'"0"0'0'' 0' o.plII, he MUST FILE A COMPLAINT wilhin 'wenly (20) day. o/Ier /ilinll hi. NOTICE 0/ APPEAL, PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE (Thil IOc/ian 0/ farm '0 bo ulOd ONLY whon oppollanl lOa' DEFENDANT flOe Po. R.C.PJ.P, No. 1001(7) in aelion be/ore Di,'riel Ju.,ice. " IF NOT USED, doloch from copy 0/ no'ice 0/ oppeal'~ be ,",.ed, upon appellee). PRAECIPE: To PrOlhonOlory .' Enter ,ule upon ....,...,. UIII JJUIUII .,. , oppelleoh),lo filo 0 complaint in thi. appool .' (Common Ploa. No. d 1"1 9'1 HOlM 01 ap".IIt9(I' I"~ul ~~~ '? 0/ judgmenl 0/ non pro.. lion' " Itis afro'''''.' ogen' RULE: To UJI'UL 1IIfU'OIlK ,appellee(.). No"..alaplMlfft{l' '._ _.1' .,.,\;'"1'1'.;,. ',-";'_,..". " '. ..", '; l .' :'..~'\~. \' \ . ,~..'" . , - ' ", ....... '. ......... ,'.....;. ....:. " (1) You or! noliliod thaI a rulo i. hereby enlerod upon you to filo a comploinl in thi. app!"T ';i>>.in twenly (20) dO;' a,i.,( tho dole 0/ service of this rur, upon you by personal service or by certified or registered mail. ";..... .. 6' .'.' i..... \:'::.; . .. '. ' ,'...,,---- . i' ,... . '.. .. i~ ...'. , (2) H youd~ nOl file "complaint wilhin thil time, a JUDGMENT OF NON PROS Will BE EN!~RED Ac;AtNST'yOUC I-:~~ ~,_ ',. " ;', ~. ._ . : .-. . . '''''I'~. 1;_.." .,. \'it,. I ' . : ..'.. '.', . .1\ .\' :t.' J ..,. (3) The date ~f service of this rule if Hrvw:e wo, by mail i, the date of mailing, ~';.' :. . ...,..". ~. :~,:~:'2:':,:~~t. ,.'," ,," , ~ v.. . f" . . ..~. .. ": '. '.: .' '. \' 0;'.1':~" \'\..' Dole, (JH.r~ ,:JI" ,19h.. ."g,'J/"~ ~. ~~~..~tL;'';J;,( ..,.". " ',ofltotto'a"., o./HIfr , '. ,\QP(3"'1O I";-::~ 'J:i'!. ((;.y :., .' ;10' "f .,....'t;. ,~'.; '-:"'. ' ,. .",' - ~. .. , - .;1: '.:....::. ~ . ~ . ~ '1:'..' '. t '., :0', 1. .' i.- .~ --I . " ~, . '"". ::::. :';.':1 to: : . .... ..... ,~ .. . ,~ . ..... .' ,;~: . " '. " '. .'~ t" ne c'" ~~:. ::: :::' , "'j -: ~:~+;~:} -, ..~7.,;. " ~ ,..t:,. \ .~'" . ..". .'.. . ;...a...:, ',' '\:''1'' ~..: ~'\;"~. 7'~ ":'. :.' . '.', <-.;' ~ ,,:-' ." ~l,-':: '.. c..,) .j :rt:I""-'",\,'~" ~;:::"~:;'.:.: '. '. t.',r !.: II .1... :'t..,' .... !:.. -<~ c. ", '" t..~. r- ...-10 ..<O:x,-"'-c.,,:': .{~ .___...,....-_:'u.....,~. "no:!.' '.m ,... ,zo:EC').,. . . -'f.._.r"'Jll~l>~~ _H~,.,~ ro.\..'!;~'t~JI{::W. ~/:~ =:~ ..' ..~: . ,_ .. u_.., J!?lt:Uf:~~'-*1 ,__~::'..:~ft:l_,L')i,!'~: .. . " - ;,...1, :.'. .,1..... ,j. ... '.1'" '. .. . lr;-~-4!l CAr; JlJ^-:~r 3,}!~~' ~t2~ .._..It"t. ..:.iIJJrelEf....t~, .:-.... ~L , : t,,:-,'-' .'.. ":'....'" .' "=;" '}" '. '. \ \ ~ ~~. \:........, I, t:~;...f.I\H~ot~..''''7~ .. t. . _._--t~"'''J "~,;" ;" , \ ' .. J , ' . , 1 \ / PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT (Thi. p,ool o/..,.ico MUST BE FILED WITHIN FIVE (51 DA YS AFTER li/ing 'he noli,e 01 appeo/. Check oppli,oble bolO.) ;'1 I ~ \ ~.; "" I. .. .' i'; .t.':, . :.... ":1 ~ . ~. ,,:' . .r: ~OMMONWEl.l't4 Of PENNS',,\ f..'~IA COUNIYOF ({."V;r.~tf..t.-"'N!) ;IS " t'.:.. ,.. , ' " ,",-.. .~. . ~ " . AFFIDAVIT: J hereby 'wear o~ affirm that I"rv.ed .'~' .~ '......'.....::..... .: .' " ...: tfl.': ~ .'. . .... . "'.' ~ 0 copy of the NOli,e of Al'p.ol, Common Pleo, No 1.dM Cu),i 9;$ upon the Di,"ict Ju,ti,e d.;;;~olod ;~.reil\ o~ (da'. 01 service' . I'''/k~ , 195:1.' by pen nol lervice 0- by 'certified, (;e'gi~te'ecii' m~i1. ,ende,i,' receipt 9"qched hereto, and upon the appellee, (nome) I... ......... . ....... on l-/'JA( Ir/I!L.- 0 by pe"onol ....i'. P!l by (certified I (fOg;,te,ed) moil. ,ende,', ,eceipt otto,hed herelo, , I. ", .. "'. . .. '\. ....\r ~ . ;'. ," .. ~ . ... .. ... ~_~n~.!~:!.~;. ~har. i .\!~v,<l..~~, Ru!e ~F!'i 0 Comploinl' occomp03ing the ;'D~.. Noti~~'DI App~or~pon'ih. oPP.U..(" to' wli~m th~ llullt. WQ~\iIdd,.~il:.oh.t .'Y-/1-Y ,If. ,Dby p""onot service Wy (certi/ie~l (regilt. red) .. mOll. Hnele,', ,eteipl attached he~eto,.j. XJ , '.' 'rTI' J ....,t \ ' .. ~.~.~ SWORN (AFFIRMED) AND.SYBSCRIBED BEFORE ME ' , ,THIS 'J"rrnAyo!, ~-^'- '!' :.1'13-. }, . . ......~ ~ '., Sifnoture 0' oH.ciollH'." "0,. aU,d .i'_ NoIarIaI Seal '.'..'oH... . Bcir~.c..rrIloItIhll~ ". My co....i.lion p~;m~ E>piIw6Otl. 3.1 . .....':, .',.'~~.t... ....... , .,..,..\" ',. ~. .,.." \'.. < ....~.,.: ,,--. (.' . ....... ...~.~..: .,..... -' . . ,..... .,..;..:,.....,..1'~ ..... -.....-rl.....~..,~.'"'"'.._... '. ' ''', .' . '.' )\01 ." Y..'~: ...., i. :'. .,' ,. "'. ~ ..~~,,~.~'.H~' : ..~:~ : 1: ~..iYb '.:.,..,..... " ....,...1...... .., ..,. " ' .' -'i' ~. . '; ""0 "ll'" . , ' ~ .. ~ . . ..,!, ...~ '" .1 . ..... ..' " '.. I ',.' ~"'. ' .. . ..,,:.. ;.. I,(!' ','.. .. "'l:.~'. .' ."~ ~t.. ,~;.~~. l .:~...,.; ((, -.... ":':: " '. . ...;'.,~ .' . . . .-:..... .:;'U ,'t: .:.:-~5:. .!t.,~\~_.fIic.? . . EXIlIBn'''B'' " LAW OFFICES IRWIN IRWIN & McKNIGHT " IIOGER.,_ 1WlOUl. "-. IWlCUS A. IkI<NlGHT,. JAIIESD HUGHES /lOECCAR I/UGHE' WEST POIrlFRET PROFESSIONAl. BUILDING &0 WEST POIrlFRET STREET CARUSLE, PENNSYlVANIA 17013-3222 (717) 24j.2353 FAX (717) 24U>>4 IWlOlDS _ (1"'"1177) IWlOlDS_.Il (I~I~ --,- (I_'~ March 10, 1994 AUN M CASHMAN ESQ 141 BROADWAY STE 230 HANOVER PA 17331 RE: RENTAL UNIFORM SERJIlCE v.t JOHN'S MOBILE REPAIR Dear Alan: I was surprised to learn from my client today that you had put a judgment on record in tbis case. That is because on June 25, 1993 I filed an appeal of the district justice decision. Subsequently, I served your client and the district justice with a notice of appeal and a role to file a complaint within twenty days, No complaint was ever filed and as far as I was concerned the case was over. I then realized thBt our appeal was filed in Cumberland County rather than York County and that is probably why you were not aware of the appeal, In any event, I would suggest that in order to resolve this matter, you withdraw the judgment and file a complaint. Alternatively, if you are not willing to proceed in that fishion, I will file a motion to strike your judgment. I feel certain, under the circumstances, that the Court will pennit us to proceed with the appeal in York County. I would, nevertheless, like to avoid the needless expense of time and money to force the issue ifpossible. Please respond to this leuer as soon as possible so that we can move on with a resolution of this case on the merits. hsl,lli Slncerel)', ~'R.f~ , IRWIN & McKNIGHT .' { Haro 'd S. Irwin, III JOHN'S MOBILE REPAIR 909 GRAHAMS WOODS RD NEWVILLE PA 17241 @ "'< 0.... lIl~ i5~ :c ...:1>< ~ Polll:>:l>l Z<H ZZ...:I Ol>l ...:IH :CPo I"""" :c >lIl o . Z H f;l u~SuS "'ZHCXllll O::>UMtn 0<"'< HU 0 E5!;:lJ.~ o >'" U .... U, l>l 0 :I:l>l Z :~ ....u .... .... ..... ... ~ l>l '" U .... .... ".. ;; l>l . lIl' ~~ o '" . ....e>: S~ o ~~ ~l;) '" ... <l '" "" "" <l <l .. '" .... .. e>: "" ~~ ~Z l>l.... ~~ Ou :0: lIl< - ~~ ...,..., fool = C) ill 1-4 0 N ~ ~ ti Z u ~ ~ g ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ dJ a ~ ~ C) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ s ~ ~ ..::s ~ ~ ~ CL 1-4 2 ~ !:f ~ E ~ 3 ~. 5 1-4 . :> l>l ~~ ...:I 00 HlIl z~ o ....l>l ~5 He>: l>l Po , . LtllV Omces , a'L' MAY 2 6 19~" IRWIN, IRWIN & McI{NIOIiT . RENTAL UNIFORM SERVICE OF HANOVER, INC., Plaintiff v. JOHN'S MOBILE REPAIR and JOHN A. CUNNINGHAM, Defendant : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : CIVIL ACTION - LAW : NO. 94-0938 CIVIL TERM : IN ASSUMPSIT ORDER OF COURT NOW, this '2b day of ~ 1994, on petition of Harold S, Irwin, m, Esquire, the rule issued upon defendan~l cause why the judgment entered against defendants in this matter should not be stricken is hereby made absolute, The judgment entered by plaintiff Bgainst defendant is hereby stricken. 11M Z.j I 31 PH '911 C:.l, itr;!. .,,~,. '^'4~ ~: ;;i r t, .at, ,l ~:' ,~ . " {,L RENTAL UNIFORM SERVICE OF HANOVER, INC., Plalndff : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : CIVIL ACTION - LAW v. . . JOHN'S MOBILE REPAIR and JOHN A. CUNNINGHAM, Defendant : NO. 94-0938 CIVIL TERM : IN ASSUMPSIT PETIT/ON TO MAKE RULE ABSO/.UTE NOW comes Harold S, Irwin, III, Esquire, attorney for defendants and presents this petition to make the rule absolute, representing as follows: 1. That your petitioner obtained a rule upon plaintiff to show cause why the judgment entered by plaintiff against the defendant in this matter should not be stricken, 2. That said rule WBS made returnable within fifteen (15)- days of service by certified mail upon the plaintiffs attorney of record by defendant. 3. That service of said rule was made upon the plaintiffs counsel of record, Alan M, Cashman, Esquire, on MBY 9, 1994. A copy of the postal service return receipt No. P282 242 305 is attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and incorporated herein by reference thereto. 4. That more than fifteen (IS) days have elapsed since service of the petition and rule upon the plaintiffs counsel, but plaintiff has failed to respond to the petition and rule and has not contacted defendants or their counsel in any way relative to this petition, the motion to strike or any other aspect of this case since the service of the rule to show cause, WHEREFORE, your petitioner requests that your Honorable Court make the rule issued upon plaintiff absolute and in Bccordance therewith strike the judgment entered by plaintiff and against defendants, BY: West Pomftet Profession 60 West Pomftet Street Carlisle, P A 17013 (717) 249-2353 Supreme Court ID No. 29920 ^~..,~,"';.',;,,;.O;.'~.,.. VERIFlCA TION I verifY that the statements made in the Bbove petition are true and correct. I understand that false statements made herein are subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. Section 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities, May~ 1994 P 282 342 305 ~ ReceiN for CertifLd Mail . '. Nrtt - ~~UiJnco Covmago Provldod == 00 nut uSe for 'ntefODtional Mail """'<OI~1 ,Set! Revers"' '".q, ALAN M CASHMAN ES ~!'''' , ....,' 'jr, 242 BROADWAY STE 230 I" n ',\..1., ,;'.,j :,1', ,..,._ HANOVER PA 17331 ~".. X $ f...t'..-Jll" X ,>,_.,. '. r ~;..,. "-'. I" ,..,'.'<1,.,1;)0.../..,.... en jid',..,fj""'II',"...."."1 en to ....' ,>r','" :).1',- n,.. ",,,_,1 - " "'-'i.,,' I":V"I_\ ~'''''''' 'J ,., ,'"" c:: D..'" .'".1...,'.1"..".....~ 10'1"," . , :(;':,1 l'-"'.N'- X $ ;,75 o f,l..,. o CO l'l E 1; ... r,,~I:T;,i'" .,t ~) I'.. :r Hal ~-05-94 H.~"""""",.!!i, ',;\~, '';~h.;;;"i'.'~~~'~i' .},<,.; \l"ir';~~'".f:Jl"'W' .!~~........ .. ,1_.. or.. '," .~',i.'.-"':;._;:'_>,...,'-. ."_}:~..._''',.~~!';~, ~~\:::i.t~:~~~"'~.,;.;;.;.~..;~. .:~f'~~~.'~~~ ~~.~'...,toYOU~:;~~":; <:~:,,:\,',>':: ":" ):'_:'.<:'.,:;-::-- '/: ',,\:,..~~,-;>'{i;~n--rt:_ d __ . f"f^'*"1hIi~Jo;....t~o,............... Of"'1.... bIcll~ioplCO" :"i:P,~~~~.'~~~t, ~':"=ri...~iri~';;'IIlo';;i"llI"'bIlciw"",ri:i.<~ ":tOR~~Di7t~1 , r~~~~"""""'~~~.ItIk:Io~IlI"',Ivofwd~""~ ClIflIUlt' "liirijQ'iii;i~;':'i'&, I "<,~~"m.~,';:, A~d~~ ESQ "'48, ~rti~8:f3%',t"3C;5,"'.':"'.;";.\;'i,:!.'~~-Jt1.. ~'~.;:':2.42 BROADWAY 8m 230 4b" SlrvlceType "'J.,,".:il~ ':1;:;;';,HANOVER PA 17.331 ORoglotorod Oln.urod,'.."W"i " ~ ~::~~ ~."' . g ~~~m R~IIPfl~~f; 7. 0..101 OIIlVI"'M'1 ,'& '1~.rt~li 8, Add"....'. Add".. (Only II ~,,' ',"', JJi . Ind t.. ,. plldl,,'::, '~I! 'i;r~;; DOMESnC RETURN ,RECEIPT"', . ,DooemborlBlll Ml.l.GPO:' EXHIBIT "A" In t~e OIourt of OIommon fIeu ofCl.nb2ru4Jountv RENTAL UNIFORM SERVICE OF HANOVER, INC. 938 Civil Tenn, 19.2!1.- No, vs. JOHN'S MOBILE REPAIR and JOHN A. CUNNINGHAM PRAECIPE TO SETI1.E & SATISFY PRAECIPE TO REMOVE To the Prothonotary: I Please mark the Bbove captlonBd action -I _ " , " OR x I Please mark the above captioned JudgmBnt or IIBn selllBd and satisfied. . ~~.~ AlIomBY for I:' lalI1tU t Supreme Court No, 16678 ~q ,19 95 on en - E II> N ~ C'..I z -9 >-~ "'... "'Z w~:':'''' C::r: c.;: I.\..Ol,)..... "",%0> Oo.....z-: , c~~... -1.:: ....lei) WCl..n::Z .::!ww:Z: u..:::mw >-XCL ...'" 0<'> ! ~ vehicles pursurant to PA Dept. of Transportation Vehicle Record Abstract setting forth identification nunbers, license plate numbers, etc (all of which being unencunbered). Levy to occur at 909 Grahams Wood Road, Newville, Pa. 17241 and R. D. #3, Box 893, Newville, Pa. 17241, being the sane property. R.Thomas Kline Sheriff who being duly sworn according to law, says this writ is returned ABANDONDED. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing Law Library Prothonotary Service Levy Surcharge Poundage 14.00 .50 1.00 5.60 10.00 4.00 .70 $ 35.BO Advance costs Sheriff's Costs $ 100.00 35.80 64.20 refund to atty 5-9-96 Sworn and Subscribed To Before Me So ans~)lf~'" 4' . r;.~<<.' '4' . :r1 R. Thomas Kline, Sb~~ff BY.&U~ Deputy Sherif . 1996, /7'!: day of ~ A.D.~~a ~.tJl"1' Prothonotary ..::, v.. .., ~ -I: This \n"" ' ~lJd l,r,. l~V I.!: 9 I H~" . .- ~j;{L.1b'': :..il. jv ~J:j.:lO en I ~c~l ..)1> NIt,,3'1'I"& WRIT OF EXFX:l1I'ION and/or A'M'AOI1ENI' CCM>OfoMEAL'I'H OF PENNSYLVIINIA) COlJNl'Y OF ClMBERLAND ) No.q1R CIVIL 19.JlL CIVIL ACTION - LAW 'lU THE SHERIFF OF Cunberland COUNl'Y : TO satisfy the debt, interest and costs due Rental Unifonn Service of Hanover, Inc. 121 N. Blettner Avenlle. HAnnver. PA. 17111 fran John's Mobile Repair and John A. Cunningham Newville, Pa. 17241 PLAIm'IFF(S) 909 Grahams Wood Road, DEFENDAm'(S) (1) You are directed to levy upon the property of the defendant(s) and to sell Any and All "",monal nTTl"",rty belonging to thE' I)pfE'nr'lAnt. in"l.rling hilt not limttP<l to all cash on hand, inventoIY, stock, tools, machineIY and all of the attached (Coot. on back) (2) You are also directed to attach the property of the defendant( s) not levied upon in the possession of GARNISHEE( S) as follows, and to notify the garn1shee(s) that. (a) an attachment has been issued: (b) the garnishee(s) is/are enjoined from paying any debt to or for the account of the defendant(s) and fran delivering any property of the defendant (s) or otherwise disposing thereof: (3) If property of the defendant (s) not levied upon and subject to attacbrent is found in the possession of anyone other than a narred garnishee, you are directed to notify h:im/her that he/she has been added as a garnishee and is enjoined as above stated. AnDunt Due '1W~st Atty's Comn Atty Paid Plaintiff Paid 56,432.00 208.82 % 139.75 L.L. Due Prothy Other Costs 50.50 1.00 5.00 (York County) DATE. Februarv 28. 1994 Lawrence E. Welker Prothonotary, Civil Division by'-I:j'T () n'LJI.~--" Deputy REQUESTING PARrY, Name Alan M. Castman, Esa. Address: 141 Broadway Hanover, Penna. 17331 Attomey for: Plaintiff Telephone. (717) 632-9580 Supreme Court 10 No.