HomeMy WebLinkAbout94-01413
)(
j
, ,
't
11
r \;{I
'i(\
11'. !!,';11
I' d,~'
i)~~
,." ",.,.1'1'.'..1.
;'.x,.
, ~l
, "\:1
t'"
I, I ~'l
, ',i:1~
~
I, It
, ![.
dl
'j
I)j~
"i,\iJ
::\)'lj\
II,I,:"U!
'.{:;~
.\,~
'~
' ,':':rj
""11
III
1'1
1,\
,\
',if
\'1
"
"
,
,
"
'J
"
111
'1,1
"
;'1
"
I
,
"
1'1
'I
, ,
I,
"
,,'
! '
,I
I
)
,
!
\....
,
"'.
"'\
\
\
)
/
-I
',II
I".'
',.1
I
J d
'Ii
.,
.,
\
'.
'I
.,i,"
1'1
i:
!,\
"
II'
.1
, 'I:
1:'1
.
'I
, ~,\
i.d:
I
\
. I
oJ
.
0..'1.101'. O. '..YIO'
I do hereby ol~titythat on thi. day I ..rved a true and oorrect
oopy Of the tortqoinq 'rllolpe tor W1I:1141'&"a1 of lppelrlllce/IDtrr of
"pllrlDol on the to110winq by tir.t ola.. mail, po.taq. prepaid, to tha
tollowinq addra"1
Jama. R. Ronca, E.quir.
'CKNIDT . aOIOl, ',C,
209 state Straat
Harri.burq, PA 17101
Attorney. for Pla1nt1ff
DATIl
~/t,11(1
OlaMAl, G1LL10N.a . aUaT1VGI
1..../. /:J '
By, '~-7)c f'o--, L,,- C'It1-~A "" '_
n I orr-Sweanay, .qu
40 Ba.t Grant Straat
LancI.tar, PA 17602
(717) 293-8070
Attorn.y. for Dafandlnt,
Jama. A. Yata., M.D. and
Pla.tic Surqery Canter, Ltd.
,I II
,
"
',>' ,
111'r"
100. ~Ll - /4/3
ClvI/ Turn
!. ~, qo~, a. cftUUft. .L...
QDIIIt"U~ CODll'lI. .....yLVUU
HARGII DUBY,
P. O. Box 336
Dunc.nnon, PA
170:10
I
I
I
I
I
V.nuI
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
'laintlff el)
Addn..e.l)
JAMIS A. YATES, M.D'L F.A.C.S.
Gr.ndview Corpor.t. plao.
:lOll Grandvi.w
c.lIIp Hill, PA 17011
aV1d
PLASTIC SURGERY CENTER LTD.
Gr.ndview Corporat. Pl.~.
:lOll Granclvi.w
Calllp Hill, PA 17011
Daf.nclantel)
Addn..e..)
.nICIlII .0. nIT or ItlVVO..
TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF SAID COURT I
Pl.... illu. a Writ ot Summonl jn the abov.-caption.d action.
Writ of Summon. .hall b. ilau.d and forward.d to
e ) Attorney eX) Sheritt.),
~~~~~:~~:::::~~ :~:::~.::f~:~~:~=,~"
Nam../Addr..I/Tel.phon.
No. ot Attorney Dat.1 $.,:)1 '/'-/
I'I .'.;"
,j_~~.,l ,
r',:.'.".
11
.,
I .
I i
I, 'I
,.1'
nIT or IUIIIlOII
TO THE ABOVE NAMED DEFENDANTeS)I
YOU ARE NOTIFIED THAT THE ABOVE-NAMED PLAINTIFFeS) HAS/HAVE COMMENCED
AN ACTION AGAINST YOU.
, ~a,I.<.Jlfll.~ (ti hJr, Mh /""
,
Prothonotay.y
DATE I IhtJlI"/\ .il.3 1'11'/ by 'j.n fL'c .I2L.-f..:(!J.I'J':::'~~~
e ) Ch.ck h.r. it r.Ver.. i. i..uld f~r additional intormation
,."
'iI
1/.:",.1,.,
l~l,'Jti
"i
'~'('ll"1 'I
I
,.
~,
., ". !~.,;.I'....I"~""
,
.".1' .";,,....., ."~,*"."..",..",,.,..-..,,-, ,
"
i'
"
,
I
"ii;II'!,1Hf;:
!tNj,J~'"
Ij A[J:;~'1rl,
!;i.l",!/lf\i)-,-
. ,Ii't')
1!I'ii'~l
;rifhlfi~'l'~
H,J~t).H~i'
,,:,;~~'~y! ,
'1>"I;Hj""\f~;1
:<}\;>L~I-\. :JH!"i'l~\n
,. ,,:I';;~_~('~'~' l;}t~!~,;!_~{ji
_ }i~f,',~~,;l\t!-t \J)
, ! ' I.~ ,::V!;"'\' ,. .";]", }1,\,
I "".11,,1/,;-;1
II. i,,:'I!(ll'
,t'l I\\,;.])t~r;l'
"j"t'I\tl;1l)t"
Ii I ,::,:;'1}::
I ~.i.\\~~./ ''Ll.
" rl\l'JI'I1\i
'.', JJ L);:' IJ11!\\)
:.< 1'''~I)~\'l~1
""""1"'1
t/l;,l, I
';,J,::\~~,;~N,
I" "tili1jli',t-
'Ir": \ ,."'.lllL!!.
I, ~ ".~ \WW;~:.;'.i\;:f
I 'c',', ,I "-l;I~-!;~l;il"):1
>\ Li;/ I;; il'\I'!y;llll,
'" \I:!",'! ,_t).tJ~;
, " "1 ,,~j
;-'1 (,\"Li,-;
Ii ,t,i_',j,/d,;:
'1,\,,',jl,II'a~
~\, "'. :',' '.fh]
t "",j'l
~. ' ::.j>/'!
1\, ,'i,,\';lll'i:f1
"~~iq;;\' i,~:l'~
, t
\, It
1\'"
, "
'Ii'
,\\, '
" ,~r,-':I ' i'i!
, It;
-'I\"J:)
;;":dl'
"
"0. ~ ,_>Ot~
\"",,"l;'..nr<il""""""'.""'.'''''''.'''"
"'I!'''''
"
,,'" .
I
I;'
,
;'
"
(1).
~..n
6 ~l. ~ .",
"
,"~I ()rF\Q~
0\ ,.,\. \'i'()1\\OIl',l~k'l
Q\I\oIOE\"'~~\) cr,\1~1'1
\It:MM'; 1l'. ~M\'
4f 1./0,50
f;'
::;,00
Iu'.tdiff
,"
'l II
"
.-....-~,. ..-..-------.
rJ '-15, 50 ,,"
'j',
Cr~
OO,;;I&Ofa
~cpL~ 7l#O 1I
.
.
(I,t
!,','
. ",\
"
.',
I. ~ ,; ,
,
"',;
ii"
:1
, '
"I
\'l
"I"
Ilil
,
)'i'
," "
I
, '
"
"
,
il
ji'
"
H
'I
"
,.'
'.,
"
it
.,
"
'I>' ,'~
~'.l-,L" 'I; "~
,
;,"1.''-'''..';'
I'
'I""'"
'JI' t.'1fJ~'i:'"
1.")
~-~,ri~,'7't'~ I,
,/~
r-
....
..~
'"
j
't:~
~ ~
....
I
-<:::t.
t ('-j
--t
I~
~ .~
(~
~
~
'4-
=--
~
'.
II'l
I I II
.'
"
~
,.,
~
~
I'.,
"
"
~::::':":'-'--::="~'P""- >---:.-.-.-... __p::'.::\
~
~ ~ ~ ~
J ... ~ ! ~
~ t~ ~ ,.
~ till; .
__........:::Ja-
-':'.:=:.:..-=-_._-~
,
,
"
, .
,"
, \
, '
. .
..
. ~
I., '
.
MARGIE DUBY,
pldntitf
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 94 - 1413 - CIVIL
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
JAMES A. YATES, M.D., F,A.C.S.
.nd PLASTIC SURGERY CENTER, LTD"
D.f.nd.nt
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
.RAICI.. rOR IHTRV or A"IARANCI
TO THE PROTHONOTARY I
Pl.... .nt.r the appearance of Thomas, Thomas' Hafer, a. attorney.
for Defend.nt. James A. Yate., M.D. and Plastic Surgery Center, Ltd. in
the above matter.
I
TROHA', TRO~ ' JA".
)-'
Bye /-; C'
P.ter ""J', Cu
1.0.11662
Sarah W Arosell,
1.0.158 97
305 North Front Street
P.O, Box 999
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0999
(717) 255-7637
Attorneys for Defendant.,
Jam.. A, Yates, M,O. and
Pla.tic Surgery Center, Ltd.
DATil sj~,y
.
alRTI.laaTI or _,RVla.
I do hereby certify that on thi. day I served a true and correct
copy of the foregoing .ra.oip. for Intry of app.ar.no. on the following
by first class mail, postag. prepaid, to the following address,
Jam.s R. Ronca, I.quire
.aHMIDT , .OHca, '.0.
209 state street
Harrieburq, PA 17101
Attorneys tor Plaintitt
THaNA' ,
THon. , HUI.
..~ .
\,... ...,
..-") .. ..,..... . ~
~.,,,.- '"
By'
17108-0999
Attorney. for Defendant.,
Jam.. A. Yate., M,D. and
Pl..tic surqery c.nter, Ltd.
DATil
.511'1
"
, '
;1 "
\,
: J,{j". ',;
/.
I
,~..,',.\
"
, ,
O..TI'IQ~T. O' '..VIe,
I do hereby certify that on this day I served a true and correct
copy of the foreqoinq 'raeaip. for aula to .ile complaint and aul. to
,i1. Coap1aint on the followinq by first class mail, postaq. prepaid, to
the followinq address I
James R, Ronca, Esquire
.OHKIDT I RONCA, '.0.
209 state street
Harrisburg, PA 17101
Att~rneYB tor Plaintitt
I HArI"
,/1/
aYI
Attorneys for Defendants,
James A. Yates, M.D. and
Plastic surgery center, Ltd.
DATIl
.ff1,.t/~1
, ,
,
I~;,I"'''"
MAROn: DUBY,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS or
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 94 - 1413 - CIVIL
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
JAMES A. YATES, M.D., r,A.c,S.
and PLASTIC SURGERY CENTER, LTD"
Defendant
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
RULI TO 'ILl A COMPLAInT
TOI Margie Ouby, Plaintitts
and Jamee R. Ronca,
Esquire, her counsel
You are hereby ruled to tile a Complaint against Detendant. Jame. A.
Yate., M.D. and Plastic surgery center, Ltd, within twenty (20) day.
atter servioe ot this Rule or a judgment ot non pros will be entered
against Plaintitt, pursuant to Pa, R.C.P. 1037(a).
DATE I )I'l ~'t 'I. 11 'i 'f
i} (')' " ~
itlt<- I. IL/.U.J,., /o.J/lf....~
PI:' onQtary /
" I
"
'I
,'~ .u.~.. ."
,
I
,
"
GERMAN, GAI.UGIIER " MURTAGH
By: Linda Porr Sw~~n~y, Esqulr~
Id~nllll~allun Nu,: 34811
^"11rn~ys fur D~limdanl,
Jamlla II, YIIlIl8, M,D,
"
40 EUI Oranl Slr~~1
Lan~lI8ler, Pennsylvanlu 17602
717/293.8070
MARGIE DUBY,
Plalnllffs,
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
COURT Of COMMON PtEAS
/1./13
Nll,:__S-199f
VS,
JAMES A, YATES, M.D,. and
PLASTIC SURGERY CENTER, LTD.,
Defendanls,
PRAECIPE FOR ENTRY OF Al'PEARANCE
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
Kindly enler llur upp~aran~~ In Ih~ ahow-~aptl(lned mailer on behalf uf Defendanl,
Jam~s A, Yales, M,O,
GERMAN, GALLAGIIER " MURTAGII
Daled I AUiIIsl 3, 1994
G.~, GALLAG... I NU.TAG.
IVI KllTA '1.1"-."..'01
ID 10. 1'1'71
IVI LIIDA .0.. ......Y
ID 10. ,.IU
T.. '.LLIVU., 'I'TH 'LOO.
100 I. Il0AD .TIIIT
..ILAn.L..IA, 'A 1.10.
(111) "'-7700
JWlGII DUlY
Atto~ft.y. 'O~I D.,..4ant
J.... a. Yat.., N.D.
lULl TO .IL. COMjLa!1T
AND NOW, thil -1S.1L day of I ( I,l, 1994, a RUle i.
\
hereby granted upon plaintiff to file a mplaint herein within
twenty (20) days after service hereof or sUffer the entry of a
Judgement of Non Pro.,
'" At' t.q
.,-Xi J
Plaintiff
I
I
I
I
an4 I
I
I
COU.T O. CONKOI 'LIAI 0'
CUMI.ILAMD COUNTY, 'A
10. '4-141' CIVIL
V.
JAMI. A. YATI', M.D., ,.A,O...
.La.TIC .URal.V CIIT.., LTD.,
D.fendant.
'IlA~Cnl TO 'ILl COM.LlINT
TO THE PROTHONOTARY I
Plea.e enter a RUle upon plaintiff to file a oomplaint
within twenty (20) day. hereof or BUffer the entry of a Judgment
of Non Pro..
GERMAN, GALLAGHER , MURTAGH
~Y~~ 11M.. L/JA~"L
nda Porr swe~7
Marta Sierra Epperson
Attorney. for Defendant
Jame. A, Yate., M,O,
"
.'
'\
..
I. ~~ _., ". ,..t> .......... "'
MARGIE DUBY I
PlainU tf
IN TH~ COURT OF COMMON PLe:A~!
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO, 1413 S 1994
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
v.
JANES A. YATES, M,D" and
PLASTIC SURGERY CENTER LTD.,
Defllndant
h ORD.a
AND NOW I thi 5 -L day o~w-, 1996, upon good
oause shown, it is hereby ORDER~D AND DECR~EO that the above case
ahall be marked as active and that the above-captioned matter
will not be terminated, the case will be removed from the
inactive list of Ocl~ber 27, 1996, and, the case ia stayed
pursuant to the Silicone Breast Implant Coordinating Court's
Order, Case Management Order No.9, Jurisdiction of this case is
hereby transferred to the Silicone Breast Implant Coordinating
Court for all pre-trial matters, As aoon as thi~ case has been
certified as resdy for trial, it will be transferred back to this
Court, st which time the trial will take place,
BY THE COURT t
.
"
,
J,
MAR-17-93 WED 15:45
CHIEF JUSTICE NIX
.....'...." .-"'
FAX NO, 12155602551
P.01/03
vi
IN 'l'HE SU5'R&:MJ; COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
IN REI.
S:tLtCON'E IMPLI\tn
t.lTIGA't'ION
Nu,
JUDICIAL AOMXNIST~rIV8
COCKET NO,
--
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW. this 17th
day of March
_______. 1993, upon
the recommendation 0' the Ad Hoc Committera on Silicol16 Inlpllnt
Litigation. it is nereby ORDERED as followsl
1. This Order governs all pending and future lawsuits filed
in all courtl of the Commonwealth of Pennlylvania. seeking damage~
for personal iUJuries alleged to have been sustained ln the USI of
silicone brQast implants:
;Z, The following Judges an appointed to Blt as a thrce.judgo
Coordinating Panel to manage and coordinate cases governed by thiw
Order I
A, Honorable R, Stanton Wcttlck, Jr" chalrporlon
8, Honorable .anura Mazer Mo.s
c. Honorable ~manuel A. Caaslmatis
~ I The
^llQghflnv
-'--
County Court (,f Common [Jleu ill
designated as the Coordinat 1ng Court and the J UOqllS appointed to
thl coordinating [Janel in the preceding paragraph lu.e anigned to
sit as C'OIMlCln pleas Court Judges on this COUr!: tc:r tllQ purposes of
coordlnatlng litigation,
4, The mel\\bers of the Coordinating PAnel sn03l.l. Iletve at thlil
pleAsure of this Courtl
'j
I
!L Cases claiming injuries IU & relult ot sllicone
~AR-17-93 WED 16:46
CHIEF JUSTICE NIX
FAX NO, 1215~02651
p, 02/03
~m(ll/l.nttl shall b. filed in tM local judicial dl.nJ:J.cl; a.e l.'llquiud
by the Penn8ylvania Rulen of civil Procedurer
6, The Coordinating ~anel may tranBfer any case co any Court
of Common Pl~a' within chJ.. commonwealth for good cau.e;
7, The President Ju~ge. ot all of the Courts of Common Plias,
the coordinating Panel members, and till! Adminil.'ltrf\tlVliI Office of
Pennllylvania Court II shall develop a proce.. CrUl.t will pel'lllit
notification of the Coordinating Panel of the filing of a silic~n~
bre.st implant lawsuJ.t within a judicJ.al district and pr~vide ear
the dissemination of all ordel:"B and ruHnga of ths Coordinating
Panel,
e, The Administrative OHice of Pennllylvania Courts shall be
charged with the rSlIponsibJ,lity of arranging for expendicurefl
necessary to pay for the work of the Coordinatin9 ~anel;
9, The Coordinating Panel maYI
(a) enter, stay or modify case munaqement ord.r~
affecting px:actlce and procedux:e whJ.ch do not enlarge or D.bridgli
the sublltantJ.ve r1ghts Of the litiganr.a wh1..:h Ilhe.ll apply 1n all
judicial districts of the commonwealth,
(b) stay, vacar.1lI or modHy any exhtJ.ng ordet of lIny
Common Plells Collrt that 1s inconsistent witll anv order which the
,
Coordinating Panel has issuedr
IC) ex.rCl.S6 any and all powex:s glven to 1\ COU!:'t pUt'iSU!l.llt
to Pa, R, C, p, No. 213.1 Coordination of I\C~ iona 1tl oiUer.ertt
CountiCls,
(d) ramand II matter to the local Court of Common ~lea.
for deeillion of selected issues or for trial,
MAR-11-93 WED 16:46
CHIEF JUSTICE NIX
FAX NO, 121SSeo2661
P,03/03
(.) ent.r .ny order n.o....ry to ettect the purpo.e ot
t.b18 order.
10. '1'h. Coordinating Panel Ihall lit a. D court En Bane on
any matter. betore the cOQrdinatinq Panel unle.. the panel ent.r.
.n order ...iqninq one memb.r of the Panel to con.ider . ~atter on
behalt of the entire panel,
11. Rule 341 of the pennsylvania Rule. of Appellate Proa.dul'Cl
.ttective July 6, 1992, shall apply to all silicono brea.t implant
oa... certified to the coordinatinq Panel, inoludinll those tiled
priar to July 6, 1992;
12, All appeals trom any decision of the Caardinatinq panal
.hall be tiled in the suparior Court af penn.ylvania;
13, Appeals taken to the superior Caurt or penn.ylvania at
ca.e. involvinq n.w and novel silicone breest implant litiqatian
.hall be elqleditioully heard and disposed of initially by a
permanent panel campo.ed of five (5) ju~qeR of th~ Superior Court
who.e deei.ione shall have the full torce and eftect ot a court En
lane, Atter the r..alution af a lelJal iUU8 by the perman ant
panel, appaal. in other ca.8. involvinq the Bame ieeue wauld be
heard betore a thr..-judq. panel III the Superior Court Dlay d.irect,
BY THE COU'RT I
/- (" ." .._-,
,e ~ /" /
~"'-j~.u.:.
-3"
"
~"d
Page 2
The Honorable George
October 1, 1998
E. Hotter, P.J.
Thank you tor your consideration.
Very truly yours,
AjAND RONCA,
Scott B, cooper
Attorney at Law
SBC/drb
P.C.
, I
.,
,
Enclosures
CCI Linda Porr-sweeney, Esquire
'I 'I
,
, '
I !II
"
,
,'I
"
"
I
'I
/1,
,
,
, .
,"
"
, ',:'1
"
IIJ I .
..,~ I
MARGIE DUBY~
Plaintiff
v,
IN THE COURT Ofi' COMMON PI.EAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO, 94-1413 Civil Term
JAMES A, YATES, M,D" and
PLASTIC SURGERY CENTER LTD"
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
JURY TRIAl. DEMANDED
CERTIFJCATE or "ERVI~~ '
AND NOW, this 16th duy of Januury, 2004, I, Shuwn 1', Peterson, hereby
certify that I have this day served a true and correct copy of the foregoing by
depositing a copy of the same in the United States Mail, postage prepaid, Ilt
Harrisburg, Pennsylva,niu, addressed to:
Linda Porr Sweeney, Esquire
Porr & Devine
16 East King Street
Lancaster, PA 17602
8CHMIDT, RONCA" KRAMaR, P.C.
I
,
By:A~-
Shawn 1', Peterson, Paralegal
209 State Street
. Harrisburg, PA 17101
(717) 232-6300
" ,
.,
" ,