The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About94-01440 ','j '~ , , " " , " , " , ,I, ., " " , 'I'il , " " , , ,I " I, " " , , , " I I II J ;1" "i , , , II " " , "', ., I " " " H, ,"~ ,..II 'I " " ','\" i, , , , " " / , ,/ /,/" i I , , ! i !I ~! j " ", " d " 'I ," " II I !\ I II , , " " ,I i I' , , " , i " " '.. ,! " " " " , 'I' "~I '~ ~ " " \ , ;1, ! i' , , ;'i " ,/ " , , ':' /,1 , '1 '\~ " !.j "j PATRICIA A. POPI, PlaintJ,U I IN THI COURT or COMMON PLIAS or I CUMiIRLAND COUNTY, PINN8YLVAHIA I I CIVIL ACTION - LAW I I NO. 1440 CIVIL 1994 I V. CUC THU NaO, Defendant II U I VAGA'. AUITItATOa ORDIlR or COURT AND NOW, JULY 22, 1996, the appointment ot David rOlter, lequire is hereby vacated and George A. Vaughn, III, I.qui~., i. appointed in hil Itead. By the Court, ( ~. -(. . I {U'/ H rold B. She.l , P. . hquire - ()'Jt~ I,,,~...l..( 1/:l~/?r.~, ,~ . (\1"k ,.La.., ..~- ef\ ,V\N,:1 '11).'f/~t.. J, 1', George A. Vaughn, III, Chairman Court Adminiltrator - Idd II 1,\ " I' ,.> I " " , I ,,)l I" " .'1: IiI , n II I, t /i I I IN TIlE COURT OF CO!IMON PLIliAS OF PATRICIA A. POPE, I ClItlBERLI,ND COUNTY. I'ENNSYLVANIA I Plaintiff, I NO. 1440 CIVIL 1994 I I V. I I eue THU NGO, e I Defendant. I I ~VLE 1~12-1, Th. Petiti~n for Appointment of Arbitr.torl Iholl b. lub.tantial1y in the 10110W1nl forme P~TIT!ON FO~ APPOINt~IENT OF ARBITRATORS TO tHE HONORABLE. THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT I KARL J. JANUZZI . counsel for the pla1nt1f~/~"1IllIlll in the abov, action (or action.), re.p.ccfully r.pro.ence thatl 1. Th. abov.-caption.d .ccion (or action.) i. (ar.) at iA'U'. 2. Th. claim ot the plaintift in the action 11 $oIith~n Mount Requirin9 Tll. countllfclaim of ch. defendanc in the .cHon i&ompuleory Al:b~tratS.on Th. followinl .ttorneYI ara inter.sted in the cal.(I) aa coun..l or or. oth.r- wi.. dilqualiH.d to ait ss arbitrators I Defense counsel in t;u,h matter is Scott D. Moore WHEalrOR!. your patition.r praYI your Honorable Court to appoint thr.. (~) arbitrator. to whom the coaa Ihall b. aubmitt.J. 'Zi/ctf~U .ubmitt.d, (" ~1 al:l J. Jft~uzzi, Seq. ORDER OF COURT Counsel f.01: Plaintiff AN'D NOW, W~ 11J..l.. ;.. Y. ,19.1k.. in cOlllid.ntion of the ~ fonloinl p.tition, ~v/d ~ .) E.q., V' , I.q., and IYJAIl..Y..&i~ bq., an .ppoinud arbitraton 1ft thl above-c.ption.d action (or .ctiOD.) a. prayad for. Court, r-. ltc ,- --, " " ! , " " " " I ' " " ,I " ~~ ih~a l.!l ~I I . ~ .. a 16 ~tl rol p.. ~~ ~ ... .jJ ~8 ~Q ... l'l ro..p: 'rl . . I1l : ~ ~~~ . .jJ I> g ~ rolO ..: l'l ~ p..ro.. 'rl z ~~ ;:l I1l ... .... ~ 2! ~ ~~~ u p.. ~ Il-< p.. ~ :i~~ B Ii: - " , " I II ' '\ , , 1 ;) I , ' " . Arr.JQlVI'J.' COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF DAUPHIN SS ~~ici~ Pope ., being duly sworn aocording to law deposes and says that flh~____ is the Plaintiff in the t'oregoJ.ng action/ that the facts and allegations contained herein are based upon facts given by the al~jn~iff to --Per counsel and are true and correct to the best of . her._ knowledge, information and belief/ that the language of said Answer to New Matter - - is that of counsel and that ___..i.laint:liL___ has relied upon counsel in making this Answer to .NjlIL&ll.!U__, based upon __.J>J,.!!intJ,ff ~ infOrmati.9n-.j // 4' c;;/O~ i:t:1l L. :,~c.~; "7782/'/ .J2._ Sworn to and subscribed be~ore me, ~- ~rY pUblio,' this ~)t) day of "-- " 19 ,Ai . _,_, ..:L.1- " <-- ...........'rftlTARIAl. . ..PlCC^ 8 RUIIlATCH, ttoT~ I'I8JO HAIIRI8IUIlO, DAUI'HIN COUNTY MY cot.IMllIION IXI'lIlU JUN.... 'M , , II; 1.II\IiIOfFlr.IllIOP TIMOTlIV II, lllOI.LIN81l\OIl\ IlIO UNIII.I!51\1WN l\()IID . P,O. IlOX 60\41 . IIAl\l\llBUI\O, PII 11106,0141 1717) ll'.)7oo . FilX 1717) m,llll PATRICIA A. POPEl I IN TijE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS Plaint ff I CUMBERLAND co., PENNSYLVANIA l v. I NO. U-1440 CIVIL I CUC THU NGO, I CIVIL ACTION - LAW Oefendant l JURY TRIAL OEMANDED Nonel TQ PlI.") TOl Patricia A. Pope c/o Rarl J. ~anuzzi, Esquire 1820 Lin~leetown Road P. O. Box 6015415 Harri.burg, PA 1710S~015415 Attorney for Plaintiff You are hereby notified to plead to the within N.w Matter within twenty (20) day. after service hereof, or a default jUdgment may be entered against you. DATIDI June 27, 1994' ..--:-:" KITTI, IYAft8 I WOODIIDI /' BYI ~"l~._(t L)2.~-_r_f ~~. MOO~, Esquire sup. ct. I. D. 11515694 3401 North Front street P. O. Box 159150 Harri.burg, PA 17110-09150 (717) 232-15000 Attorney for Oefendant CUQ Tl\u Ngo v. . I I . I . I IN THE COURT or COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND co., PENNSYLVANIA NO. g4~1440 CIVIL CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ~! "':+/ ii~j J,:' '>/1 , I ;t'~ \1 'l~ j':~ PATRICIA A. 'OPI, , plaintiff MI..I,. WITH liD IlATTIa cue THU NQO, Defendant AND HO. OONI. the Defendant Cue Thu Nqo, by and through her attorney., Mette, Ivan. , Woodside, to tile the followinq An.wer. With New Matter to Plaintiff'. complaint, and in .upport thereof aver a. follow.. 1. Denied. Aft,r reasonable lnvestigation, Defendant ie without knowledge or information .ufficient to form a beliet a. to the truth of the averment. ot paragraph 1 identity1nq the 'laintift. said averment. therefore are denied and .trict proof thereot, it admi..ible, i. demanded at the time of trial. a. It i. admitted that CUc Thu Ngo i. an adult individual. Although .he re.ided at 2142 North Sixth street, Harri.burg, Dauphin county, Penn.ylvania on or about October 7, 1993, .he currently re.ide. at 1524 Wayne Drive, Meohanic.burq, Penn.ylvania 170515. :). Admitted. ''''li ,~" ),) ',~. I i'IIH~ 4. Denied. It i. .pecifically denied that at the afore.aid ti.~ and place, Plaintift Patricia A. Pope was etopped in tr.ffic in the right, we.tbound l.ne of the C.mp Hill By-P.... To the contrary, Plaintiff h.d been travelling we.tbound in the right-hand line and h.d .truck the re.r of William strouso who w.. .topped in the right-h.nd lane. It i. admitted that Plaintift w.e operating a li84 Old.mobile. ~. Admitted. S. Denied. It ie .pecifically denied that at the .tore..id time and pl.ce, Defendant, cuc Thu Ngo, f.iled to bring her vehicle to a .top and collided with the rear of Pl.intiff.'s vehicle, cau.ing the Pl.intiff'. vehicle to be pushed forward into a 1987 Dodge Shadow being operated by William strouse, III. To the contrary, Plaintift'. vehicle had collided with the Willi.m strou.e'. vehicle. The remaining averment. of paragraph S are conclu.ion. ot law to which no relponsive pleading i. required. To the extent. re.ponse ie deemed required, it is specific.lly denied that the eUbject accident resulted from any .ct or omis.ion on the part of Oefendant. To the contrary, at .11 time. relevant and material hereto, the Defendant acted and comported with the requi.ite degree of c.re under the circum.tancee then and there exi.ting. By way of further response, the New Matter below i. incorporated by reterence .. though fully .et forth herein. - 2 - 7. Denied. The averment. of pa~agraph 7 and it. .ubparaqraph. are conclusion. of law to which no re.pon.ive pleadinq i. required. To the extent a re.pon.1 i. deemed required, each and every alle9ation of fact i. epecifically denied and placad at i..ue, it being aver.red that the Defendant at all time. acted and comported with the requi.ite degree of care under the circum.tancee then and there existin9. Any implicit averment that Defendant took any action or failed to act in any manner relevant to the circumetancee of the lubject accident i. denied. By way of turther. reeponsel I. It is epecifically denied that Defendant failed to have her vehicle under proper and adequate control. To the contrary, Defendant had her vehicle under proper and adequate control. b. It is epecifically denied that Defendant Nqo failed to operate her vehicle at such a .peed and in a manner .0 a. to be able to .top within the aesured clear dietance ahead. To the contrary, Defendant Ngo kept her vehicle at a proper .peed within the rules of the road includinq the a..ured clear di.tance ahead rule. In addition, Defendant was contronted with the eudden emergency. c. It is epecifically denied that Defendant failed to apply her brake. in time to avoid a colli.ion. To the contrary, DOfendar.t applied her brake. in a timely faehion and made every effort to avoid etrikinq the Plaintiff'. vehicle. d. It i. .pecifically denied that Defendant permitted or allowed her vehicle to strike and collide with the rear of the vehicle operated by the Plaintiff. Any implicit averment that the phy.ical contact between the two vehicle. was the fault of Defendant is specifically denied for the rea eon .et forth above. e. It ie epecifically denied that Defendant failed to drive at a .peed and in a manner that would allow her to .top within the aeeured clear distanoe ahead. The above an.wer. are incorporated herein by reference. - 3 - t. It i. .pecifically denied that Detendant failed to k.ep a proper lookout and to notice within a reaeonable time that Plaintiff'. vehicle .topped in tront of her. To the contrary, Plaintift had collided with the vehicle in tront ot her. To the contrary, Defendant kept a p~oper lookout for other motor vehiclee and reacted appropriately to the .udden emergency. q. Thi. paraqraph has been .tricken pureuant to .tipulation of the partie. and Court Order dated May 26, 1994. B. Denied. The averments of paraqraph B regardinq the cau.e of the alleqed injurie. of the Plaintiff are conclusion. of law to which no respon.iv~ pleading i. required. After reasonable inve.tigation, Defendant i. without knowledge or information .ufficient to form a belief a. to the truth of the remaininq averments ot paraqraph Band eubparagraph a through g. Said averment. therefore are denied and strict proof thereof, if admi..ible, i. demanded at the time of trial. 9. Denied. The averments of paraqraph 9, regardinq the cau.. of Plaintiff'S alleqed injuries, are conclusion. of law to which no re.pon.ive pleading ie required. After reasonable inve.tiqation, Detendant ie without knowledge or information .utticient to form a beliet as to the truth of the remaininq averment. of paragraph 9 reqarding Plaintiff'. alleged injuri... Said remaininq averment. therefore are denied and .trict proof thereOf, if admi..ible, is demanded at time of trial. - 4 - 10. Denied. The averment. ot paraqraph 10, reqarding medical expen.e. alleqed by Plaintiff, are conolu.ion. of law to which no r..pon.ive pleadinq i. required. After rea.onable inve.tigat10n, Defendant i. without knowledge or information .ufficient to form a belief a. to the truth of the remaininq averment. of paraqraph 10. Said remaininq avermente therefore are denied and .trict proof thereOf, it admie.ible, ie demanded at the time of trial. 11. Denied. The svermente of paraqraph 11, ~eqardinq alleged !njurie. and lo.. of earnings, are conclusions of law to which no re.pon.ive pleadinq i. required. After reasonable investiqation, Defendant i. without knowledge or infQrmation SUfficient to form a belief a. to the truth of the remaining averments of paragraph 11 reqarding Plaintiff'. alleged loe. of earning.. Said remaininq averment. therefore are denied and strict proof thereOf, if admi..ible, i. demanded at the time of trial. 12. Denied. The averments of paragraph 12, reqardin9 the cau.e ot Plaintiff'. alleged injuries, are conclu.ion. of law to which no reepon.ive pleadinq is required. After rea.onable inve.tiqation, Defendant i. without knowledge or information .ufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the remaininq averment. of paraqraph 12 regarding Plaintiff'. al1eqed 10.. of earninq capacity. Said remaining averment. therefore are denied - 5 - and etrict proof thereof, if admi.eible, i. demanded at the time of trial. 13. Denied. The averm.nt. of paragraph 13, regarding the cau.e of Plaintiff'. all.g.d injuri.., are conclu.ion. of law to which no re.pon.ive pleading i. required. Aft.r rea.onable inve.tigation, Det.ndant is without knowl.dg. or information .utfioient to form a b.li.f a. to the truth of the remaining averm.nt. of paragraph 13 regarding Plaintiff'. enjoym.nt of life and lif.'. plea.ur... said remaining averment. th.refore are deni.d and strict proof thereof, if admis.ible, i. demanded at the time of trial. 14. Denied. The averments of paragraph 14, r.garding the cau.. of Plaintiff'. alleqed injuries, are conclusion. of law to which no re.pon.ive pleading i. required. After reasonable inve.tigation, Detendant is without knowledge or information eUffioient to form a belief as to the truth of the remaining averment. of paragraph 14 r.garding additional .xp.n.e. ond 10.... allegedly inourred. Said remaining averm.nt. therefor. are d.ni.d and .trict proof ther.ot, if admissible, is demanded at the time of trial. ....Iro.., the Defendant re.p.ctfully requ..t. this Honorable Court to di.mi.. the Plaintiff'. Complaint with prejudice - s - I . PATRICIA A. POPE, plaintitf IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND CO., PENNSYLVANIA NO. C((( - I ~/./l) (JL,,v.....t -...Jvvr~ v. CUC THU NOO, Defendant CIVIL AC'rION - I,AW JURY TRIAL DEMANOED NOTICE YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the f~llowing pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defenses~or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that, 'if you fail to do so, the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the Court without further notice for any money entered against you by the Court without further notice for any money clal.med in the complaint or. for any other claim or relief requested by the plaintiff(s). You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF yOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, 00 TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE Court Administrator's Office 1 courthouse Square Carlisle, PA 17013~3387 (717) 240-6200 '. C'l~ ;1Ii:1.- ~ai~ , ~!r.~c. <""a~' ~~n~ ~~ ... if ~ - - fa II rJ.. EXHIBIT ~AW onlcu 0' TIMoTllY A. IIIOLLlNIlI\llIIl I 1110 LINOLISTOWN I\OAO . PO BOX to<llll . HA~l\lsaUJ\O. M 11106.011 11111114.)100 . 'AX 17I711H.IIII It , l_~~ . " .' PATRICIA A. POPE, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND CO., PENNSYI,vANIA NO. v. CUC THU NGO, Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED COHIi'LA IN'l' AND NOW, comes the Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, by and through her attorneys, LAW or'FICES OF TIMOTHY A. SHOLLENBERGER, and does respectfully represent the following I 1. Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, is an adult individual wh~ currently resides at 1513'South 12th Street, Harrisburg, Dauphin County, Pennsylvania. 2. Defendant, CUC THU NGO, is an adult individual whose last known address is 2142 North 6th Street, Harrisburg, Dauphin County, Pennsylvania. 3. The facts and circumstances hereinafter set forth took place on October 7, 1993 at or about 5155 p.m. in the 2700 block of the Camp Hill Bypass, camp Hill, cumberland County, Pennsylvania. , , 4. At the aforesaid time and place, Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, was operating a 1984 Oldsmobile stopped in traffic in the right, westbound lane of the Camp Hill Bypass. LAW onlc!.S 0' TIMOTUV A. IHOI.LINIlIlOIIl 1110 lINOL!.STOWN I\OAO . PO IIOX 60111 . HMIl15IUI\O. PA 17106.0\41 17171114.1700 . 'AX 17171114-1111 ; ~ 1'1' ~ I; '; \' . ,; \..'" , . . 5. At th~ aforesaid time and place, Defendant, CUC THU NOO, was operating a 1991 ~l~nQuth Van in the right, westbound lane of the Camp Hill Bypass. 6. At the aforesaid time and place, Defendant, CUC THU NGO, failed to bring her vehicle to a stop and collided with the rear of Plaintiff's vehicle, causing the Plaintiff's vehicle to be pushed forward into a 1987 Dodge Shadow being operated by william Strcuse, III. 7. The aforesaid coll~sion was the direct and proximate result of the negligence of Defendant, CUC THt1 NOO, in operating her vehicle in a careless, reckless and negligent manner as followsl a. In failing to have her vehicle under proper and adequate control, b. In failing to operate her vehicle at such a speed and in a manner so as to be able to stop within the assured clear distance ahead in violation of 53361 of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Code, c. In failing to apply her brakes in time to avoid a collision, d. In permitting or allowing her vehicle to strike and collide wl.th the rear of the vehicle operated by the Plaintiff, , In failing to drive aL a speed and in a manner that would allow her to stop within the assured clear distance ahead, 'I e. f. In failing to keep a proper lookout and to notice within a reasonable time the plaintiff's vehicle stopped in front of her, and, LI,W omc!.S 0' TIMOTIIY A, "'OLLINIlIlOIIl 1110 L1NOL!.5ToWN I\OAO ' po IlOX ""14l ' HAIlIlISIUIlO. PA 11106.0111 1117111'.1700 ' FAX 1717\ IlHIII . , 9" In otherwise operating said vehicle in a careless, reckless and negligent manner and in a manner violating the Motor Vehicle Code of the commonwealth of Pennsylvania. 8. As a direct and proximate result of this collision, Plaintiff, PATRICIA POPE, has suffered serious and permanent injuries including but not limited to, a. Severe strain and spraJ.n of the nluscloes, tendons, ligaments and other soft tissues at or about the lumbar ~pinQ; b, Severe' strain- and sprain of the muscles, tendons, ligaments and ot~er soft tissues at or about the cervical spinel c. Left sacx'oiliac syndrome; d, Left knee bruise; e. Chest bruise; f. Severe strain of the nerves and nervous system; g, Extreme mental and physical anguish, 9. As a direct and proximate result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, PATRICIA POPE, has undergone and in tho future will undergo great pain and suffering for which " damages are claimed. , 10, As a further result of this collision, Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, may incur reasonable and necessary medical and rehabilitative costa and expenses in excess of the lAW onlc!.S or TIMOTlIY A. SIIOLLINIII\lIIIl 1110 L1NOLIISTOWN 1l0AO ' PO IlOX 60\4\ . HA~1\15~UI\O. rA 11106.0\41 tlI7IIl..lloo . MX 17171114.UII . II.' !". '. "j I,,: .. ~ ' ,t' " ~ 't. .. . . . . . all1iOunts pai.d or payable pursuant to subchapter a of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehiole Financial Responsibility Law, worker's compensation or any program, group contract or o~~er arrangement for payment of benefit.s as defined in 75 Pa. C. S. A" section 1719. 11. As a furt.her result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, PA'I'RICIA A, POPE, has suffet'ed and may continue to suffer a los~ of earnings for which damages are claimed. .' 12. As a furthar result of the aforesaid injuriQs, plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE,-has suffered a permanent . . diminution in her aarning capacity and power for which damages are claimed. 13, As a further result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, has sustained a permanent diminution in his ability to enjoy life and life's pleasures for which damages are claimed. , . 14. As a further result of the aforesaid injuries, plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, has incurred or may hereinafter incur financial expenses and losses which exceed sums , recoverable under the limitations and exclusions of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law for which damages are claimed. LAW O"'CU or TIMonlY A. IHOLLINIlIlOII\ 1110 L1NOL!.STOWN 1l0AO ' po IlOX to<l14\ ' tlA~IlIS8UI\l.I, PA 11'06.0141 1711l114.1700 ' 'AX 171711.\4.11I1 \._'1 1~~....lF ' ~:\v " Ii .,'t ,'-', f, \ . \ J ;. ~ I t \ ,\ " d "'.. I ~. :/\ ,.' ", .' cOMMo~,nIOFP~~~~LV~ f-OlTRT OF COMMON P1JlAll. CUMBI1RLANn COl)'NTY ~ .nJD1CIAL Dl~TRIC1 WILLIAM J, STROUSE, m 4S07 Chari.. Road MtoiINIk.burlf, P A 1701111 P\&lntLlJ', v. CIVIL A01'lON . LAW No, 434 ClvU 1994 TRUE COPY FROM RECORD In TI.lIlr,lIlOY WlwllOl. I t\I),'O unl" ~i,llny 1,,"(lIl iNlO Iht ~aal crt IiJld Court III Call1<.\r!. f'll. TIM ~tJ. ~ of :(,Lt:"y. ~~f r .uf. -... ,)~t.t..c._ 'Lt!fI." , PrQlhonOlll'Y PATRICIA POPE 11114 S, 12tb Strllt Harrilburlf, P A 17104 Derelld.ult. ~ YOU HAVE PEEN SUED IN COtmT. U)'ou wiab to derelld epln.It tbe ~ .ct rortb 111 tb. roUowlnlJ pII''')'ou mlllt take Illthln witbill tW'llt)' (20) ~ aner tbIa C4mplall1t and Notill. are Mrved, b1 ,nt,rlna a wrltt,n app.arll.llCe p.nonall)' or b)' LItoi'll')' and I1IIn8 In wrIU1l1 wilb Ib, Court )'our d,fenae. or obJtoUona to tbe clA\nl4..t rorth IlpinIt )'ou. You are wam.d tliat Il,ou fall to do 10 lb.... IU1 proceed without you and judIDI.nt DlAY b. .nter.d apiDlt you by lb. Court without I'urth.r notill. ror Irl,)' mon.y cIaIm.d Ln the Complall1t or tor Irl,)' olh.r clalm or r.Uet rlqu.ll.d by the plalntLlJ'. You 1U1101t mOIlll)' or prop.rty or olb.r risbll Important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYEIlAT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE '1m OFFICE SET FORTH PELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP, Court AdIIlInIatrator 4th Fl., Cwnberlalld County Counbolll' Carllll., PA 17013 (717) 240,62QQ X.. ban d.DIAlIdado a IlIt.d en Ia cort.. 51 U4t.d' quln. d.rend.ne d. ..W d.lll.IIldaa eapu..W .nlal pIiLnae .Iqulent.., lilted tl.n. vI.n~ (20) cIlM d. plalo al partir de Ia recba d. Ia demanda Y Ia notl1lcaclon. U .t.d debe pr...nw Illla aparitnda eICI'i~ 0 .n p.nolla 0 por abopdo y arcb1vw enla oorte .n torma .1llI'I~ ,1lI d.r.1\I4I 0 IIlI obJeelon.. a Iaa d.lIlIInd.u en contra d. IU penona. S.a avl.M.do que III lilted no It cW\.nd.a, Ia corte tOlllan medld.u )' pu.d. entrar WlA orden contra IIIl.d .Ln pr.vlo avlao o noUl1caclon y por cualqul.r queja 0 aIIv10 que .. p.d1do en Ia petlclon d. d.DIAlId.e. U.t.d puede p.rd.r d1n.ro 0 .1lI propl.dad.. 0 o.trol d.rechol Important.. para IlIt.d. LLIlVll ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABODAGO IMMEDLATAMENTE. 51 NO T1ENE ABOGADO o SI NO TIENE ilL DINIlRO 5UF1CIENTIl DE PAGAR TAL BERVICI0, VAYA EN PERSONA 0 LLAMII POR TELIlFONO A LA OF1CINA CUYA DD\ECCXON BE ENCUEN'I'RA E5CIUTA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE IlE PUEDE CONIlEQUUl ASIBTENCLA LEGAL. , Court ,\dDIlnIatrLlor 4th Fl., Cwnb.rland Counly C4urthollle Carlllle, PA 17013 (717) 240,8200 . ..1 . .., ~ . .-.' .." . .,.._..'-_..~.~ , .,._._......~,. EXHIBIT I --P- i , ~.... NI~I~ J, 'TIlOV", III 1.01 Ch.rL.. ...4 "..h.n1..b~r,; ,~ IIO" h1n' II, v, CIVI~ ~CTIOH . ~" H.. III Civil 1..1 '~TIlIC I~ '0" IIII .. II'h .,..., '..rlo..." ,~ I!IOI Dlhndlnt I 'lilkJt.AIN'r I. rldnUII, "L1U.. ~. "...... Ill, I. In In4IvI4..L r..~dln, ., .'07 Charla. ~o.d, H.ah.nlG.b~r" 'A 110". I. 0,'.n4.0" ....101. .op', I. .n 104IvI4..1 ...Idl.. ., IIII I. 12th "u", ....Llb~... .~ 17104. ~, On.. ..... oo...u !, Inl .. .pp..d...lly 1.11 P'.'6 .h. rhloUII .... h..,.lly .04 o...,.lly .p....ln. hLl In! od,. h.4... ....'.0.04 on 'h' Cup 1111 .~,... 10 ClIJl.bul.04 Co.n.y, 'Innlyhlnl.. .. At thl. .... lUI, d.,.nd.,,' WI' n.,U."ntly; UQkhnly .n4 0...1...1~ 0",,'10' . 1.11 014....11. ......o..d on 'h. c..p 1111 typll. in Cuablrllnd county, ,.nn.ylvanla. I. At or about thl. ,... &1.., plalntl"'1 v,hLol. WI' It · coapl'_. "DP ., . rldlltht whln delandant'. v.hLole "okla.,ly r.....od.4 'h. pl.lo,II'" v.hlol. .'o.~'. 'h. 4,'.04.n, '.II.d '. do, har IaQtor v.hLah 1n I ..., Inli adlq\il" .u~1qn. 1.ldhuly .,... d".n4.0". v.hloll ..o~I...ly 0.\Ud.4 ..lth pllln'Ll'" ".hloh, . ,hhd OU, d.lv.n .y C.. Th. "'0, oollld.d ..lth d.,lIndant" dlr. I. ~. . ....1' ., d./ln41.'" hLl~.. '0 ..1I1ahn,ly .nd ,.'11V .\op hu' v.hloh, phlnHU'. v.hlah lnaur....d d...,.. to th. r..r-end bu.p., 1n in. "oU~I 0' ,'10.41. r. The 00111e10n b.tween p161"t1t"6 v.h101e and d.t.ndan." v.hlo ,W" 0."''''' by tll' n'-JUt,na., a6r.hune.. .nd nokhun... 01 dll.ndant 1n ih., thl dlf.ndlnt. ",. ,.J.1.I4 t.o have her .olor v.h1al. under propll Ind l'l.on.b~e GGnlrol, , ' " .' , , . I' , , ~. .pa'II'~ h.r aGI.r y.hl.la 1n .uoh . ..nn.r .. I. c.~.a 11 I. ccl11da 1nl. Ind ',11n.' p111nl111'1 y.hlcl., o. 'rU.d 10 ~rln9 h.r ....r y.hloh I? 1 II.p In ,Ia. .. ly.1d Ih. c. 11.lon, d. 'a,Lhd to pI)' proper Ind r,,,cRabl. attentlon to the I..IU. II,hl .19noll, I. Op.fllld hi' lIolor' v,hlQl, ..,ithoUl dlfl re,uel 'or 'hi 11,h"" ","ty Ind podl1ou 0' the oth.r v'hLol.. on thl Iud, 1n.lud,n, pl.ln'I"', y.hl.I., Ind I. othl..'d.u oonduol.d hIU'U 1n I nl,UljJI"t, uohhu .nd o....h.. ..nn." I, A. " ,..ull a' d.e,ndM"l" .'or".l~ ".,L191"t glr,LI" Ind UClkhu dllu'iud 'or hlr obUqltlon. .nd dUlL,. und.r thl 11.., \0 op.rat. hi' vlhlale 1n a rl.aon.ble .n~ I." ..nn.r, plalntl" ha. IUIU1"ed propllt)' d....,. to h1. ar;l\r)r vehlal, 1n the amollnt 0' "10,1&. Wln.lrO"., thl pl..LntlU, NOli.... 3. Itrou.., XU, prlY' that \:.1\1, IgnorabLe Court Int.r jU4q..nt 1" hh lavor .nd .,a1n.~ de,"nd.nt, '"trl011 'oP" 1n an I~o~nt 0' ,'LO..a, p'~1 oourt 'n~ '111n9 ,.... . \I1.111;~~u.., III In .ro ..r , , " " I' .. '{ERIPICA'VION I, "L11LIJII J. Strou", IU, do hereby vedfy thAt the atatement. made in the foregoing Complaint are true and correot to the beat of my knClwledg8, information and belief. I under.tand that fahe .tat.menta oontained herein are .ubjeot to'the penaltie. of 18 P. S.C. 54904 relating to un.worn fahifioation to .' authol:itie.. . ~..:~f;;u.., III II' , , I " 1.1 . " \'\ , 1 ,;1 ,I , I, 1 ' VI. IN THE COURT OF C~MMON PLEAS CUM8BRt~ COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION . LAW NO, 4H Civil 19 ~4 WILLIAM J. STRaUSS/ III Plaintiff PATRICIA POPS, Defendant VB. JURY TRIAL DEMANCED CUC THU NGO, ~14~ North 6th Street Harrilburg, PA 17110 Additional Defendant ~DITIONAL Dlr~ COMPLAINT AND NOW comes Pefendant, Patricia Pope, by a~d through her attorneys, Caldwell' Kearns, who submits tho foll~~ing Additional Defendant Complaint and states in support thereof as followSI 1. The Additional Defendant, CUc Thu Ngo, is an adult individual who resides at 2142 North 6th Stree::, Harrisburg, Dauphin county, Pennsylvanl.a 17110, 2, A tru$ and correct copy of the Plaintiff's Complaint is attached hereto as Bxhibit "A" and incorporated here:.n by reference without admission or adoption, 3, A true and correct copy of Pefendant's hnswer with New Matter is attached hereto as Exhibit "B" and incorpc:-ated herein by , r:eferenco. , 4. on the date and time referred to :.n Plaintiff'S Complaint, Additional Defendant CUc Thu Ngo was the operator of a 1991 Plymouth travelling westbound on the camp Hil: Bypass, , . . 5, Just prior to impact, Dofendant Patricia Pope was at a tull Itop behind Plaint i tf William J. Strouse, III, both vehiclu being stopped in traffic, Thereafter, Additional Defendant CUe Thu Ngo hit Defendant Patricia pope's vehicle from behind which in turn pushed her vehicle into that driven by the Plaintiff, William J, Strou18, III. 6. Tna accident referenced in Plaintitf' s Complaint WAl caused in whole or in part by the negligence of Additional Defendant Cue Thu Ngo which consisted of the followingl (a) (b) (0) Failing to keep a proper lookout and to notice within a reallonable time that Defendant, Patricia pope was stopped in front of herr Driving at an excessive rate of speed for the traffic and other conditions there and then existingr Failing to have her vehicle under control and at such a speed so as to be able to stop within the assured cleared diltance ahead in violation of the Pennsylvania Motor Code, specifically 75 Pa,C,S.A, 533611 and Failing to avoid a rear- end accident with a vehicle stopped ahead of her, which vehicle was drl.ven by Defendant, Patricia pope. comrr I Patricia POp. v. CUe Thu Hao "ola Liability 7, Paragraphs 1 through 6 of. the Additional Defendant Complaint are incorporated herein by referenc~, " that (d) 8, Defendant, the accident Patricia pope believes and, therefore avers and property damages referred to in the " ,.I Plaintiff's Complaint were caused exclusively and solely by the negligence of Additional Defendant Cue Thu Ngo, f,i " '0 I.. I' 9. Oefendant Patricia ~ope believes and therefore avers that the Additional Defendant is solely liable to the plaintiff, WHEREFORB, Defendant Patricia pope respectfully requests your Honorable Court to enter judgment in her favor and against the li'laintiff and Additional Defendant CUc Thu Ngo for sole liability to the Plaintiff. comrr II ,atrieia Pop. v. CUe Thu Nqo Contribution/IndAmnifieation 10, paragraphs 1 through 9 of the Additional Defendant Complaint are incorporated herein by reference, 11, If the Plaintiff is entitleu to recovery for the damages alleged and Defendant patricia pope is held liable, which liability is expreslly denied, then in that event, and in the alternative, Defendant believes and therefore avers that the accident and property damage alleged in this accident were caused by the direct and proximate result of the negligence of Additional Defendant CUc Thu Ngo as more specifically set forth in paragraph 6 above, and that Additional Defendant CUc Thu Ngo is jointly and severally liable, and Defendant Patricia pope il entitled to contribution and/or indemnification from Additional Defendant CUe Thu Ngo, " , . , . . . ~tIR1'~~t1NTY ~J.8TROU8~m 4107 Owl.. Roe.d .....I--"\l-.b\ll'lo 'A 17064 'laIDll.lI', CIVIL AC'TION . LAW Y. No. 4$4 CMI1~ TRUE COPY FROM RECORD In T~ny wl\r.rllOl, I hore unto ~ my l",~ and Itle sui of ~:d COIJt1 .1 ~ll~, n. Th\I 1/;tJ- ~ ~ ~!~'l~ ,gfr ~'~ ,~( rAJ: . , - PrOlhOnOlllY 'ATRIetA PO'E 11514 S. 12t.b Streel Hurilbura, 'A 17104 D.r.ndanl. fjCYl'lCE yOU HAVE BEEN BUED IN COURT. U)'Ou wIab lo derend aplDI\ 1II. ~ III rllrtllllllll. roDowllllllll" 101,1 Ill""" Lak.lolltlon wllhlD l....nl1 (20) da)'I al\4r lhl.I ColllplalDl aIld Nol.let an M,.,ed, b1 enw\nl a wriUen appeU'tDCt pel'lOnaIIy or b7 altQm.,. IUlcl Illlnc III mit.\nc willi lbe Coun JOIlt d.rellHt or objectlollllO the cl&1nlIMl rorth aplDn )'ou. You an wtmed Ulalll )'01,1 r..Il tQ do I/) 1II. elM IIla1 proceecl wUhoul )'01,1 IUld Judilllenllll&)' be enured eplnn 701,1 b)' lbe Coun wlllloul ~.r .nol.let for 1Ul)' lIIon'1 clalmecllll the Colllplalnl or ror all)' olll.r clalm or reUer re<\uuLed b)' lIIe pll.lDua'. You IIla1IOM 1II0ne)' or propert}' or olll.r rl&hlot IIIlportanl tQ )'ou. YOU SHoULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT RAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE. 00 TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GE'l' LEGAL HELP. C<Jun AdInIDlaualor 4th FL. CUClbarlAnd County Courthowa CarUale, P A 1701G (717l 2~'6200 Le ban dellllLllclado a uated .n la corte, Sl Ulted qulere darenda". cle eeW darlWlclaa 'Jjluutu en laI pac\naa IIqulenl", ""led U.n. vI.nla (20) cl.la.I d. plazo el partir de la reeha d. la d.lIlILllcla )' la notlJ\alcion. U.led debe pr'''lltAr una aparI.llcla eterIla 0 en persona 0 por abopdo 'f uclllvar .n la corte en rOrlllA eeerita IIUI der.naaa 0 11II obJecloll" alai dellllLllclaa .n llonua d. IU pel'lOl\.L Sea ..vl.lado que II ""\.ed 110 .. dllI.llda, Ia cort. tQmar& 1IIed1d.u )' puede enlral' una orden conlra ueted IIln prevlo avl.lo , o notltl<*lllll '1 por cualquler qu.Ja 0 allvIo que at pedlclo en Ia peUclon de dellllLllcla. Ueled pued. perd.r ..un.ro 0 IIUI proplecladee 0 0Ill'0I derechoe IIIlportlLlllal para Ult.ed. , LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABQDAGO tMMEDlATAMENTE. 51 NO T1ENB ABOGADO o SI NO TIEN!l EL DINERO SUFlClEN'l'E DE PAOAR TAL SERVlC10, VAYA EN PERSONA 0 LLAME POR TELEFONO A LA OFIC1N^ CUY^ DlRECClON 5E ENCUENTRA ESCRITA AlWO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE BE PUEDE CONSEQUIR ;.slSTENClA LEOAI. C<Jun ,.\dIll1nIatratQr 4lh FL. CUClberlAnd Counl1 Courthou.se CarUal., PA 1701G (717l 24o-e200 I' ~.,.........., , . , CO~'l' g~~~It!: P~~COtnl'l'Y WXLLXAM J. 'T~OU8I, XII .'01 Cha~la. ~oa4 M.ohanlc.bu~9, PA 17055 Pla1nt:1U, , I , I , I , I , , , CIVIL ACTION - LAW No. U4 CLvU UU v. PATRICIA pon 1514 s. 12th Straat Sarri.bur9, PA 17104 Defandant. . COMPLA I N'l' 1. plaintUf, William J, StroulI, In, 11 an individual re.iding at 4807 Charle. Road, Mechanic.burg, PA 17055. 2. Dafendant, Patricia pope, iG an individual re.iding at 1514 S. 12th Straet, Sarri.burq, PA 17104. 3. On or about Ootober 7,1993 at approxinlately 5,55 p,DI" the plaintiff wu lawfully and carefully operatinq hil 1987 Dodge Shadow we.tbound on the Camp Bill Bypau in Cumberland county, penn.ylvania. 4. At thi. .ame time, defendant was ne91iqently, reckle..ly and carele..ly operatinq a 1984 OldsDlobile westbound on the Camp Bill Byp... in CUmberland County, penn.ylvania. 5, At or about thi. .ame tinle, plaintiff', vehiole wa. at a C10mplete .top at a redliqht when defendant" vehicle reckleuly rear-ended tha plaintiff" vehicle becau.e the defendant failed to .top her motor vehio1e in a lAte and adequate h..hion. IlIlII\ediate1y after defendant'. vehicle reckleu1y collided with plaintiff" vehicle, a third car, driven by euc 'l'hu Nqo, collided with defendant" car. 6. A. a re.ult of defendant'. failure to sufHciently and .afely .top her vehicle, plaintiff" vehicle inClurred damage. to t~e rear-end bumper in the amount of $610,45. , 7. Tha colli.ion between plaintiff" vehicle and defendant" vehiole wa. cau.ad by the negligence, careles.ne.. and reckle..ne.. of defendant in that the defendant' .. failad to have her Dlotor vehicle under proper and reaoonable control, '1', I' .. . , .' b. operat.d her motor vehicl. in luch a aanner a. to caUle it to collid. into and again.t plaintiff" vehicle, c, failed to bring h.r ~otor vehicle to a .top in time to avoid the colli.ion, d, failed to pay proper and rea.onabl. att.ntion to the traffic li9ht .L9nal., e, op.rat.d h.r ~otor vehicle without due r.gard for the r19ht'1 ..hty and potition of the other vehiolu on the road, Lnolud ng plaintiff" v.hiol., And t. oth.rwil. conducted heruU in a n.gligent, uckle.. and oar.le.. IllAnn.r. 8. A. a r..ult of d.f.ndant'. afore.ai~ n'91i9.nt, oar.l... and uckle.. dieugArd for her obligation. and duti.. und.r the law to operate h.r v.hicl. in a reA.onabl. and .afe mann.r, plaintiff ha. .u.tain.d prop.rty damage to hi. motor v.hicl. in the amount of $510.45. WBIRlFORl, the plaintiff, William J. Str.ou.., III, pray. that tlhie Honorable Court entel: judgment in his favor and a9ain.t defendant, patricia Pop., in an amount of $610..5, plu. aourt And filing feu. N~use, III In Pro Per , ' >I ' " " , , .. , " 'I I ''I ," \ " 1;\ Jf'1 II!il " , 1",'1 i.~J DRIPJCATIOH X, W111iam J. .tro~.e, III, do hereby verify that the .tate~ent. made 1n the fore90in9 Complaint are tr~e and oorreot to the but of my knowledge, infonnation and belief. I ~ndeutand that fall' Itat.mente contained herein are I~bj.at to the penalti.. of 18 P.S.C. 54904 relatin9 to unllworn fAhification to a~thoritiu . .' " ~~~~ am J. strouu, IU , ., " I, I I ,I l,j '. ~ , , .1 ; , , , , <. I "',' . VI, IN THI COtTRT or COMMON PLPS ~IRLAND COUNTY, PBNNSYLVAtfIA CIVIL ACTION . LAW WILLIAM J, STROUSI/ III Plaint it e PATRICIA POPEl, NO. ~H Civil U9~ Cdendant TOI William J. Strouse, III, Pro Se ~807 Charles Road Mechanicsburg, PA. 17055 .. YOU ARB H2RBBY NOTIFIBD, that the New Matter set eorth herein contains averments against you to which you are req\lired to :t'Bspond within twenty (20) days atter service thereot, Failure by you to do so may constitute an admission, CALDWELL &. KEARNS , Catel BYI Deborah A. Cavacini, Esquire Attorney's I,P. *67900 Attorney tor Detondant Pope . , . , 'I II ,< , , , ., , , . ,. t. VI, IN THB COURT or COMMON PLIAI CVMBBRLAND COUNTy, PINNSYLV~IA CIVIL ACTION . LAW NO, 434 Civil 1994 WILLIAM J, STROU,I/ III Plaintiff PATRICIA POPI, Dofondant A,ltSWIIlll "~TB Nl:W MA~R AND NOW come. Defendant, fatricia PO!?, by and through her attorneys, Caldwell &t Kearns, and submits the following Answer with New Matter and states in support thereof as followsl 1. Denied, Defendant, after reasonable investigation, is without information or Knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of paragraph 1 and proof thereof i. demanded, 2. Admitted, 3, Admitted in part and denied in part, It is admitted that an automobile accident occurred on October 7, 1993 at approximately 5155 p,m. on the camp Hill Bypass in cumberland County, Pennsylvania, The remaining allegations of paragraph 3 are denied as legal conclusions which, under the Rules of Civil procedure, need no response and are deemed to be denied. . . , ". Admitted in part and denied in part, It is admitted that Patricia pope was operating an 1984 Oldsmobile at the time and place alleged. The remaining allegations of paragraph 4 are denied I " . , II , al legal conclu.ion. which, under the Rule. of Civil Procedure, need no re.pon.e and aro deemed to be denied, 5, The avennentl of paragraph 5 an conclul1on. of law and/or fact to which no respon.ive pleading 11 appropriate or nece.sary under the Pennsylvania Rule. of Civil Procedure, By way of further answer, Patricia pope maintain. that the .\1bject accident occurred when she was at a full stop, hit from behind by a third party, CUc Thu Ngo, and was pushed forward into the vehicle operated by PlaintiH, William J, Strouse, -III, 6. The averments of paragraph 6 are conclusion. of law and/or tact to which no responsive pleading is appropriate or necessary under the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. By way of further answer, Pefendant, after reasonable investigation, is without info~tion or knowledge sufficient to fonn a belief as to the truth of the averments regard Plaintiff's property damage and proof thereof is demanded. 7 (a) , (f), The avennents of paragraph 7 (a) . (f) are conclusions of law and/or fact to which no responsive pleading is appropriate or necessary under the pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, 8, The averments of paragraph 8 are conclusions of law and/or fact to which no responsive pleading is appropriate or ' .necessary under the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. By way . , of further answer, Pefendant, after reasonable investigation, is without information or knowledge sufficient to fonn a belief as to the truth of the avennents regard Plaintiff's property damage and. proof thereof is demanded, . " , , I, " Nn 10.'1"1'.. ~, paragraph. 1 through 8 or the Dehndant /. An.wer to Pla1nt1fr'. Compla1nt are incorporated herein by rererence. 10, The damage. allegedly ,ulta1ned by the Plaintirr were C1au..d in whole or in part by the act. andlor omillion. or ind1viduall other than Defendant patricia Pope. WHEREFORE, Defendant respectfully requestl that judgment be entered in her favor and against Plaintiff, Respectfully luhmitted, .' CALOWBLL , ItBARNS 3631 North Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717) 232.7661 Oate, By Deborah A, Cavacini, .Iquire Attorney'l 1.0, _67900 Attorney ror Defendant Pope 27887 ,I 'I " I I , , , I' . '1',. '~)i .1 I,' I I ,. " I, " [': 'I I , , J \, " " YOrifl,cation I, r,.r.ricia pope, verify that the averment. made in the foregoing Additional Defendant Complaint, are true and CQrrect, I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa, C.S,A. 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities, Datel"il\C\,1(!.A 1'1, Iqq4 ,--~ . . ~y""arUc.'l.(X G . Patricia Pope r. ~<'f2 p I 1 ' " , \ 1 I, '1 , , , , I. , i , . , GI'D~'A\DAe"."'."71S,' .<-, II;'" ' ~.....~, I 't 11II , I. , CIR1I'ICATI 0' ,,_VICI AND NOW, this 18!tL day of ~~ , 1994, %, ~athy J. Murray, an employee of the law firm of Caldwell , ~earn., do hereby certify that I have served the foregoing document, on the following by depositing a true and correct copy of same, in the United States mails, postage prepaid, addressed tOI William J, Strouse, Ill, P~o Sa 4807 Charles Road Mechanicsburg, ~A 17055 ~ I- ,~ 'fat y J. ray ~ , ! ,\, , , , , , " ,'I , I I~ , I ,I MAY 2 6 19~L~\~ 'ATaICIA A. PO,. I IN THI COURT or COMMON PLIAI ,hinUff I CUMIERLAND COUNTY, 'ENNSYLVANIA I',. I , ~ V. I CIVIL ACTION - LAW :1' I I CUC THU NGO I Defendant, I No. 94-1440 CIVIL O.D.. o. aOD'!' laaed on the attaohed stipulation of the parti.., .ubparavraph (V) of paravraph 7 i. .trick.n from the complaint. tfftJ.r v~' III! BYI -~ /14- J. DATIDI / .tJ 1\', :1' ,., ._f;, r-' ~":~ r .~ ....... I' '.\1 :;J.... , ,.ij .<:;. , \ i , , 'I, 'I , I " PATRICIA A. POPE. Plaintiff : IN THE COURT O~' COMMON PLEAS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. . : CIVIL ACTION. LAW CUC THU NOO, Defendant : No. 94.1440 CIVIL PMJl1CIPIll FOR ENmY 0' APJlJllAMN~ TO THE PROTHONOTARYl Pleaae enter the appearance of the undersigned on behalf of Defendant Cue Thu Ngo, in the above-referenced matter. ME'M'E, EVANS & WOODSIDE By: JaYllo R. Wolfgang, Sup. t. l. D. *6207 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrillburg, PA 17110-0950 (717) 232-5000 Attorneys for Defendant Cuc Thu Ngo DATED: May 23, 1996 " " gJlTlflCA1E of ellJ.YICE I hereby certify that I am thll day lervini a copy 01' the foreiolni document upon the perlon(I) and In the manner Indlcnted below, which larvel latllfiel the requlrementa of the Pllnnlylvanla Rule. of Civil Procedure, by depolltlni a copy of lame In the United Statel mall, at Harrllburi, Pennlylvanla, with fir.t-cI8ll1 pOltaie prepaid, addrelled 811 follows: Karl J. Januzd, Esquire 1820 Llnglestown IWad P. O. Box 60545 Harrlsburi, PA 17106-0545 METrE, EVANS & WOODSIDE By: 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrilburg, PA 17110-0959 (717) 232-5000 AttorneYI for Defendant Cuc Thu Ngo DATEDI May 23, 1996 , ' , ~ . ;. ,. " v. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND CO., PENNSYLVANIA NO. 1440 Civil 1994 CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIM, DEMANDED PATRICIA A, POPB, Plll.int i ff CUC THU NGO, Defendant AND lULl NOW, this ~ of within Motion, a Rule is , 1994, upon the ted to show cause why this action should not be consolidated with the action filed at 434 civil 1994 which is presently in compulsory arbitration. RULE RETURNABLE in ~ daYSI~ .. ~V\O-f · BY THE COURT I J. \'11',' "',' ill!!,,\ i I, ~llVI I.rll' l;' 1'"l/1 ;,\ .j'; "1 ~61 W' \11. II G\ k1\l l~W U'FIC&~ llF TIMOTIIY ~. SHllLllN811W11l 181~ I.INlll&~lHl1IN 1l0AIl ' "0 I\l.)X MlI4I , IIAI\IlI~RLJI\l.J, I'A 171""0141 (117) 114.1700 , FAX 1717) llU111 /. . /.,: .. , ~ " . PATRICIA A. ~O~~, Plaint iff . IN TII~ COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND CO., PENNSYLVANIA NO. 1440 Civil 1994 CIVIL ACTION . LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED v. CUC THU NOO, Defendant MOTION TO CONSOLIDATI ACTIONS AND NOW, comes the Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, by and through her attorneys, LAW OFFICES OF TIMOTHY A. SHOLLENBEROER, and does respectfully represent the following I 1. On March 24, 1994, a Complaint in the above'-captioned action was filed with the Cumberland County Court, filed as number 1440 Civil 1994. A true and correct copy of tbe Plaintiff's Complaint ir. attached hereto, incorporated by reference herein and marked as Exhibit "A". 2. On or about February 18, 1994, William J. Strouse, III filed a Complaint against the above-captioned Plaintiff in Cumberland County Court. That action was filed as Number 434 Civil 1994. A true and correct copy of said Complaint is attached hereto, incorporated by reference herein and marked as Exhibit "B". lAW "HIl.f.S 'If T1MOTIIV A. 8t111I.LINBII\1111l 1~1~ IINlIIJST\ lWN ItllAO . rl) l\llX ~~H f HA'UtISI\IJI\c, IIA l7Il\fll,)~,n 1717) 114171\l , FAX 11171IlHIII }"I:I''1Ihl: I " ~ 7, ThE! Plaintiff believell and therefore avers that, if consolidation is not ordered, an adjudication of the Strouse action, 434 Civil 1994, would act as res judicata or collateral estoppel to thE! Plaintiff's action versus the Defendant herein. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, respectfully requests this Honorable Court iBsue an Order pursuant to Rule 213(a) of the Pennsylvania Rules of civil Procedure consolidating the above~referenced actions in mandatory arbitration. Resp'.lotfully submitted, LAW OFFICES OF TIMOTHY A. SHOLLENBERGER By Date ,"5" ~ I? "9'1 ~/lWll"I(;UllP , T'~OTI'Y A. 11IOLUNIIMlll 181~ L1NlllrSl\l\VN 1l0A" , pO 11<1X "<'141 ' IIA~IlI.IU"'), PA 171~ft.~I" 17I71114.1700 . fAX .7171l1UlIl -~- , I. ,.........".. I, PATRICIA A. POP~, plaintiff IN TH~ COURT OF CO~MON PLEAS GUMBERLAND CO., PENNSYLVANIA NO. C((( ~ I ~ LID (} l -tf'-t ....:J".-r'f'-... v. CUC THU NOO, Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED NOTICE YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COUR'f. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing lon writing with the Court your defenses-or objectio~s to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that, if you fail to do so, the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be cntered against you by the Court without further notice for any money entered against you by the Cour.t without further notice for any money claimed in the complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by th~ plaintiff(s). You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER '1'0 YOUR LA.WYER AT ONCE, IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN OET LEGAL HELP. CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE Court Administrator's Office 1 CoUr~houBe Square Carlisle, PA 17013-3387 (717) 240-6200 g~ :1: -. ~i-,jro;, :', r.ar'" r' :7 ,~ .,,," "".""" ..( J- r.l ' ,..' ~~ ~ ~,.;, <. (,').,\ ~':~;&'" \:.'~'.l,l rn J~ . ..-4 ~!;. ... LAW omC15 0' tIMOTHY A. III0LLlNPlllOIll I 1'10 LlNOLl!TOWN 1l0AIl ' po IIOX 1>0\4\ , IIMIlI,nun, \, rA 1710'.0\' 171711141700 . 'AX 171711l1.'1II if ~ - - fa II 'i. EXHIBIT It / PATRICIA A. POPE, plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS l,EBANON COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. CIVIL AC'fION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED v, CUC THU NGO, Defendant NOTlqa.. LE HAN DEMANDADO A USTED EN LA CORTE. si usted quiere defenderse de estas demandas expuestas en las paginas siguientes, usted tiene veinte (20) dias de plazo al partir de la fecha de la dcmanda y la notificacion. Usted debe presentar una apariencia'escrita 0 en persona 0 por abogado y archivar en la corte en forma escrita sus defecsas 0 sus objeciones alas demandas en oontra de su persona. Sea avlsado que si usted no se defiende, la corte tomaro medidas y puede cntrar una orden contra usted sin previo aviAo 0 notoficacaion y por cualquier queja 0 alivio que es pedido en la peticion do demanda. usted puede perder dinero 0 sus propiededas 0 otros derechos importantes para usted, LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO IMMEDIATAMBNTE. SI NO TIENE ABOGADO 0 SI NO TIENE EL DINERO SUFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICIO, VAYA EN PBRSONA o LLAME POR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DIRECCION BE ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEOAL. CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE Court Administrator's Office 1 Courthouse Square Carlisle, PA 17013-3387 (717) 240~6200 LAW O"ICI5 OP nMOTllY A. 8110LLINIlllOIIl 1110 L1NOl!.STOWN 1l0AO ' ro IIOX 60\41 ' IIA~~15IlUJ\O. M 17106.0141 11I11ll!.)7oo . PAX 11I111l4.8111 r', 'I'. " , "'1 ,I: ", , 'q-,. ~\, ' , I. !i, At the aforesaid timo and place, Defendant, eue THU NGO, was operating a J.991 Plymouth Van in tho right, westbound lane of the Camp Hill Bypaos. 6. At the aforesaid time and place, Defendant, CUC 'rflU NGO, failed to bring her vehicle to a stop and colJ.!ided with the rear of Plaintiff's vehicle, causing the Plaintiff's vehicle to be pushed forward into a 1987 Dodge Shadow being operated by William Strouse, III. 7. The aforesaid coll!sion was the direct and proximate result of the negligence of Defendant, eue THU NGO, in operating her vehicle in a careless, reckless and negligent manner as followsl a. In failing to have her vehicle under proper and adequate control, b, In failing to operate her vehicle at such a speed and in a manner so as to be able to stop within the assured clear distance ahead in violation of 53361 of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Code, c. In failing to apply her brakes in time to avoid a collision, d, In permitting or allowing her vehicle to strike and collide with the rear of the vehicle operated by the Plaintiff, e. In failing to drive at a speed and in a manner that would allow her to stop within the assured clear distance ahead, f. In failing to keep a proper lookout and to notice within a reasonable time the Plaintiff's vehicle stopped in front of her, and, i.: I' lAW I.lHIC~~ OF TIMOlllY A, IIIOI.I.1NBlll<llll I!lO LIN<lU~T'lWN 1l0Ml , 1'0 I\OX 1>0\45 ' IIAJ\J\I~I\Uk<1. PA 1110~.014l 111/1 ll\ \100 . FAX 171711111111 i . ;,t..i I ..' . " I . g. In otharwise operating ~aid vehicle in a careless, reckless and negligent manner and in a manner violating the Motor Vehicla Code of the Commonwealth of Pennnylvania. 8, As a direct and proximate result of this collision, Plaintiff, J?ATRICIA POPE, has suffered serious and permanent injuries including but not limited tOI a. Severe strain and sprain of the muscles, tendons, ligaments and other soft tissues at or about the lumbar spinel b. Severe' strain- and sprain of the muscles, tendons, ligaments and otoer soft tissues at or abo~t the cervical spine, c, Left sacroiliac syndrome I d, Left knee bruise, e. chest bruisel f. Severe strain of the nerv~s and nervous system, g. Extreme mental and physical anguish, 9. As a direct and proximate result of the aforesaid injuries, plaintiff, PATRICIA POPE, has undergone and ion the future will undergo great pain and SUffering for which damages are claimed. 10, As a further result of this collision, Pla.intiff, PATRICIA A. ~OPE, may incur reasonable and necessary medical Bnd rehabilitative costs and expenses in excess of the '^W OPFIC!.S or TIMOTHY A. UlOLLINBOOIIl I~l~ L1NOI.~5TOWN 1l0AO ' PO IlOX 00141 . ft^1\1l15AIII\O. PA 1110'.01'1 1.7171/1. \100 . PAX 17l711lUlII I I, alThounta paid Ot' payable pUl'auant to subchapter B of the ~ennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financi~l Responsibility Law, worker'/J compensation or any program, group contract or other arrangement for payment of benefits as defined in 75 Pa. C. S. A., Section 1719. 11. As a further result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, has suffered and may continue to suffer a loss of earnings for which damages are claimed. 12. As a further result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff., PATRICIA A. POPE,-has suffere~ a permanent diminution in her earning capacity and power for which damages are claimed. 13. As a further result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, has sustained a fermanent diminution in his ability to enjoy life and life's pleasures for which damages are claimed. 14. As a further result qf the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, has incurred or may hereinafter incur financial expenses and losses which exceed sums recoverable under the limitations and exclusions of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial ResponAibility Law for which damages are claimed. lAW 0"'<:1'1\ 0' TIMontY A. IHOLLlNBIIUlIJl 1110 lINOlE5TClWN Il11AO ' ro I\OXOO\'\ . ItM1l158lJ1l1l. M 11106 0\41 11l1l114.1100 ' FAX 11111114~11l ,. -' C;Ot6MONWEALTH OF PENN8YLVANIA COURT OF CO~9~~~ ~~~ COUNTY WILLIAM J, STROUSE, m 4807 Clwllt. Ro.td MlCbanIilIblllJ, P A 1701111 PIllnUtT, y, CML ACTION. LAW No. 434 Clvlll111l4 TRUE COPY FROM RECORD In T.oltlr,lIlnV wMruol.IIW8111i11l ~",llf)y ".,od illId In. liaal of II.1ld Court ill Cblill.\.!, "II, ~. ~ 01 =I...t:t lQl!.- . ',.~ '. '}/kii:. /*"f ProlhonolllY PATRICIA. POPE 1814 S, ll1lb Street HmIIbur" PA 17104 D.feneWIt. tlOTIcm YOU HAVE BEEN SUEP IN COURT, If )'ou wl.Ib to defend qalnIt tbe cl.almJ ,at fQrtb In the foUowtna pap.. )'Ou I11l1.1t take aotlon within twent)' (110) dip a.l\er tbl.t Col11plllnt lUll Notice.... IIrved, b)' enterin. I written IIlP'lU'lIIll1e perlllnall,y or b)' attol'lll)' and llIIq In writlna wilb lb. Court )'our c1ef.lIMe or ObJect101ll to tbe cLelr:nl.et forth qelnIl )'ou. You lU" WlU'lIecl that lI')'ou /laII to do III the_e IlII)' proclld without )'ou end JudlJllent r:na,y b. .nterecl qelnIt )'ou b)' the Coun without l\lnber notice for IIIf 1110ne)' clalr:neclln the COl11plllnt or for IIIf other cIalm or r.U.f requllt.d b)' lbe plalntUT. You IlII)' lOll 1110ne)' or propert)' or otber rillht. lI1lportanl to )'ou. YOU SHOUlJ) TAKE TlDB PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE, IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHElUl YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. Coun AdmlnIIU'ator 4th Fl., CwnberJand Count)' Counhouae ClU'lIIle, P A 17013 (717) 1I40'II1I00 L. ban deJJllll1.udo I II.Ited .n Ia corte. SllI.It.d qulere defenders. d. ..1.1I dell'andu ell'p\lllw enlu pIIInu s!qulente., II.Ited Uene mnta (1I0) .u.. d. plaso el partir de Ia fecba de Ia delll&Dda )' Ia nollfl~.cl()n, Ust,d debe prllllnw WI.& aparlencla .lCrita 0 .n pll'IOllI 0 por abopdo)' archlYII' en Ia cort. .n fol'lJlA ellCrita .11II d.f.lII&I 0 111.I obJeclonll alu d.lJlIlI\du .n contra de IU pereona. Sea avlMdo que II ueted no Ie dlttenda, Ia corte tODlAl'a 111.d1dae )' pu.d. entrlU' una orden contra II.It.d IIn previo avllo o notUlcaclon )' por cuelquier queja 0 allvio que.. pedldo .n Ia p.t\elon d. dellllll\lla. U.t.d pu.d. perder dlnero 0 .11.I propledad.. 0 oshoa derlC!hos lI1lportantll para II.Itlld. LLIlIVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOPAGO IMMIlDLATAMENTE, SI NO TIENE ABQGADO o SI NO TIENE ilL PINERO BUFICIENTE Oil PAGM TAL SERVlCIO, VAYA EN PIlRSONA 0 LLAMII POR TlIL1lFONO ^ LA OflCINA OUYA plRIlCCION SE ENCUEN'I'RA ESCRXTA AlW'O PAM AVlRIGUAl\ DONnE I9E PUEDE CONI9EQum ASISTENCLA LEGAL. Coun AdIn\IllItrator 4th fl., Cwn~rlalld Count)' CourthoUM ClU'lIIl., PA 17013 (71 '7) 1140.61100 EXHIBIT .---- I A , I , I' 1.ll 1/ oplro'~ ho. ..,.. Vlhl.11 In ouoh 0 ...... o. ,. oouo. it 10 ool~idl i.'o ond 0'01.., plOI.'I"" v.hloIO, 0, 'tU.d t. .0111' how ..tor v.hl.h t. . ..., 1. tlao to ovoid 'hi .0 11.1'.' d, 'oll.d t. "1 ,..,.. I.d ........1. .....tl.. .. thl "0"10 l~,ht .1,,,.1., .~ op,rat,d hlr aotQ' Vlhtall wlthou. Oijl I.,..d 'or the .1'h'.! ""'1 ..d ,.'IU,. ., t I ,'how Vlhiol.. .. .hl ...d, 1.01ud ., ,1.1"11"-. ..hl.II' ." I. athllr"hl GQnd~G..d h.r..U in I n.,U,.nt, 'Iakle.. .nd ~.r.l... ..nn.r. I, ^' . ,..,,,It 0' del.nd.nt'l "nf...id, n,,,119In'/ a.rel... .nd rlokl... 41.rl,I.4 'or hlr abl19.t1on. and du,tl.. under thl law to op.r.'. hlr v.hloLe 1n I rlllon.bl. .nd 'If' ..nnar, pLllntl" h.. .u.t.l..d """'1 d&Ol" t. hi. ..... v.h .1. I. .h. laGu.t ., ..u.n. N.IJ\lrO~I. .h. ,I.l.tl", Nl111.. J. It..u.., Ill, "'1' th., .hh I.....bll Court ..... jud91'..t 1. hh '..0. ..d o,.lnn dt'lndlnt, 'l,rl011 'oP" 1n In &aQUAt o' "lQ,tS, p1u. Gourt .n~ , 11., ,.... . wtfti~u.., III In h. ... , II "II I " , ' , " , , , , " " ., , , , , I' .".-.. . ~...oM. .. " .._-_.. _'4...1 100' e..'!.I~A~ o. ...V!~. I, "4111.. ~, It~OUII, xxx, do hl~lby olrti'y thlt a oopy 0' thl Jon,oll\' COlplall\t waa thll dlY Invld UP"I\ thl '0110.,11\9 p.~IOI\ 11\ thl ..nnlr indloatld bilow, ClMU1J.Q...IIAlL ..tdoll 'Opl 1514 ., 12th It..lt Hlr~llbu~" ,^ 11104 . D~'.D, .1 " " " " ,;', '~"j~ll." .....L. VlRIFICATION I, WUu'... J. Strou.e, nI, do hereby verify that the .tatement. made in the foregoing Complaint are true and correct to the be.t of my knowledge, information and belief. I under.tand , that tabe .tatement. oontained herein are .ubject to the penalUe. of 54904 nlating fal.ification to 18 P.S.C. to un.worn . authoritie.. ~':~~.e, In " " " 'ii' , ' ", , ' rl.'j lri,' ,I, " ; o . I,. .. .. VI. IN THI COURT 011 COMMON Pl.IAS CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PBNNSYl.VANIA CIVIl. ACTION . LAW NO. 434 Civil 1994 WILLIAM J. STROUSI, III Plaintiff PATRICIA pon, Defendant VI, JURY TRIAL DEMANDED CUC THU NGO, 3143 North 6th Street Harrilburg, PA 17110 Additional Defendant AW2ITIONAL DnlllNDANT COMPLAIlfT AND NOW comes Defendant, Patricia pope, by and through her attorneys, Caldwell & Kearns, who submits the following Additional Cefendant Complaint and states in support thereof as followSI 1. The Additional Cefendant, cuc Thu Ngo, is an adult individual who resides at 2142 Noreh 6th Street, Harrisburg, Dauphin County, Pennsylvania 17110. 3, A true and correct copy of the Plaintiff's Complaint is attached hereto as Bxhibit "A" and incorporated herein by reference without admission or adoption. 3, A true and correct copy of Defendant's Answer with New MAtter is attached hereto as Exhibit "B" and incorporated herein by reference, 4, on the date and time referred to in Plaintiff's Complaint, Additional Defendant cuc Thu Ngo was the operator of I. 1991 Plymouth travelling westbound on the camp Hill Bypa.s, 5, Ju.t prior to impact, Defendant Patricia Pope wa. at a full .top behind Plaintiff William ~. Strouse, III, both vehicle. being .topped in traffic, Thereafter, Mditional Defend-ant Cuc Thu Ngo hit Defendant patricia pope's vehicle from behind which in turn pu.hed :\er vehicle into that driven by the Plaintiff, William J, Strou.e, In, 6, The accident referenced in Plaintiff's Complaint was Clu18d in whole or in part by the negligence of Additional Defendant cuc Thu Ngo which consisted of the followingl (a) Failing to keep a proper lookout and to notice within a reasonable time that Defendant, Patricia Pope was stopped in front of her, (b) Driving at an excessive rate of speed for the traffic and other conditions there and then existing/ (c) Failing to have h~r vehicle under control and at .uch a .peed .0 as to be able to stop within the assured cleared di.tance ahead in violation of the li'ennsylvania Motor Code, specifically 75 Pa,C.S.A, 533611 and (d) Failing to avoid a rear-end accident with a vehicle .topped ahead of her, which vehicle was driven by Defendant, Patricia Pope, COUNT I 'atrieia 'oDe v. Cue Thu N90 ,.ole Liability 7, paragraphs 1 through 6 of the Additional Defendant Complaint are incorporated herein by reference. 8, Defendant, Patricia Pope believes and therefore aven that the accident and property damages referred to in the Plaintiff" Complaint were caused exclusively and solely by the negligence of Additional Defendant CUc Thu Ngo, ,.,\ I', ' ' "....~l/i~I. 9, Ddendant Patricia pope believel and therefore aVlrl that the Additional Defendant is lolely liable to the Plaintiff. WHBREFORI, Defendant Patricia pope re.plctfully rlquelt. your Honorable Court to enter judgment in her favor and againlt the plaintiff and Additional Defendant CUc Thu Ngo for lole liability to the plaintiff, ~ Patriaia pqp. v. CUa Thu Wqo ,ontribut1QD/Ind.m~iliaatian 10, Paragraphs 1 through 9 of the Additional Dehndant Complaint are incorporated herein by reference. 11, If the Plaintiff is entitled to recovery for the damagel alleged and Defendant patricia Pope is held liable, which liability i. expressly denied, then in that event, and in the alternative, Defendant believes and therefore avers that the accident and property damage alleged in this accident were caused by the direct and proximate result of the negligence of Additional Defendant CUc Thu Ngo as more specifically set forth in paragraph 6 above, and that Additional Defendant cuc Thu Ngo is jointly and severally liable, and Defendant li'atricia pope is entitled to contribution and/or indemnification from Additional Defendant CUc Thu Ngo. \ ' . . I I ;' ~'.\ !. \' WHSREFORB, Defendant Patricia pope re8pectfully re~e.tl that Additional Defendant CUe Thu Ngo be found lolely liable to the plaintiff, or in the alternative, that Additional Defendant CUe Thu Ngo be found jointly and 8everally liable to Plaintiff, or in the further alternative, that Additional Defendant CUe Thu Ngo be found liable over to Defendant Patricia pope for indemnity if the Defendant i8 adjUdged liable. Re8pectfullr submitted, CALDWELL & KBARNS 3631 North Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717) 232-7661 ~ Catel J-I'}.q + - re By De 27892 " II ;1 ! , " 1_) \' II; I , I' " " . . . . e M1J'~ I, rraoU11, m 610'1 CbIr'" IoU t.rt'l~bllllo PA 1'1011 PllllltIlr, 'f, PATRICIA POPI 111148. Wh I,,"' Hvriabllllo P A l7l04 Olrllldanl. -- I I I I I I I I I I I CML ACTION, LAW No.... 0vIl1* TRUE COPY FROM RECORD In T~ny w"'~reol, I hor. unlC \lit my t..,~ and Itle $UI of s,:id Court at c., Ih:,lle, /1. ~!'l, ~L..~~e!f ProthonclWf tfOTlCE YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. U1Q1I wIab 10 dlrend ~ Ibl cIIlmI.., ronllln Ibl roDowlq pqee, 701l1ll11n Itkl MtIolllrilhln IWIlIl7 (~O) clip al\I1' thIe Cllllplaln' IIIId Nolke ......md. '" IIlIIrInI a wrll"" tppeuaDCI penonal17 or b7 11101'11" and IIlInt III wrilllll wllb \he CoIIft 7fNI dlrllllll or ObjedlollllO Ibl cIIlmIMI rorth 1pIllII1011. VOII.... WW'Iled lila, 117011 fall 10 do 10 Ibl CUI 11I&7 p..-.4 wlllIolIl YOlland jlldllllellllll&Y bt elllere<! aplJlI' 70u b,lbe CoIII'I wIlboll' furlher I10Ike ror ~ 1II01lI, clal.Dled In llIe Colllplallll or ror Ill1 olber cIalm or fluer reque.&ed by Ibl plalntllr. VOII 11I&1101I mOlllY or proper\)' or olber rich" ImporUllllO 7011. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO Nal' HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNal' AFFORD oNE. GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE BET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OU'l' WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. CoW'l AdIIIblIIInllOr 411I n, CUIllbtrl4nd CoUll', CQUl'tbollle earUale, PI. 17013 (717) 240.6200 lA !wi dellWldado I UI&ed In II corle. SI lilted qulere derender.. dl IIW de"'....,.. IlpuellU III IN pec\Iw IIqu1enl", UI&ed Ilelle v\ellta (~O) diu dl plalo al parilr de II redia dl II dalUAda , II 1I01Ult&el0n. U.1ed debt prtllllW UIlI apulellda llICl'Ita 0 III perIOlII 0 por abop4o, arcb1var III II corII ell forma ucrIta IIIlI derelllU 0 IIIlI objaclOll" . Iaa demandaa ell conln dl au penolloL B.. aYlMdo que II UI&ed 1I0 .. clItIenc!a, II corle IOlll.II'Illlledldal , puede Inlrar UIlI ordlll conln UI&ed aIn preYlo av\lO o Ilollftctdon 7 por cualqu1er quejl 0 aIlvIo qUI" pedlcIo In II pellclon de demandL UatltS pUldl perder lAInero 0 aut propledadll 0 0I1r0l deredlo, ImporUll'" para lilted. IJ.EVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABODAOO IMMEDlATAMEN'l'E. Bl NO TIENIl ABOOADO o Bl NO TJ!lNIl EL DlNERO SUFlctENTIl DE PAGAR TAL BERVlClO, VAYA IN PERSONA 0 LLAMll poa TELEFONO A LA OFlCINA COYA Dll\!CC10N BE ENCUEN'l'RA ISClUTA ABlJO PAM AVEIUGUA1\ DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEQUtR ASISTENClA LEGAL. CQW'I ,\dallnIItrelOr 411I n, CUlllbtrJaDd CQUIlI7 CoUl'thoUM Car\lllt, PA 17013 (717) S40-8200 . . ~ou.~ .~ P1~~O~1Y WILtIAM ~. 'TROU'., III · 4107 Charl.. Road · M.chlnic.bur" 'A 17055 · 'laintiff, · . . I . . . . v. CIVIL ACTION - LAW No. 434 Civil 1..4 PATIIICIA P01'l 1514 8. 12th 8tr..t Barri.burg, PA 17104 Defendant. ,OMPLAIHT 1. plaintiff, Willillll J. Strou", UI, 11 an individual re.iding at 4807 Charle. Road, Mechanic.burg, PA 17055. 2. Defendant, 'atricia 'ope, i. an individual re.iding at 1514 S. 12th Street, Rarri.burg, 'A 17104. 3. On or about October 7, 1993 at approximately 5155 p.m., the plaintiff w.. lawfully and carefully operating his 1987 Dodge Shadow wlltbound on the camp Bill Bypa.. in cUlllber1and County, 'enn.ylvania. 4. At thi. same time, defendant wa. negligently, reckle..ly and carele..ly operating a 1984 Old.mobile westbound on the Cllllp Bill Bypa.. in cUmberland county, 'enn.ylvania. 5. At or about thi. .ame time, plaintiff" vehicle wa. at a cOlllplete .top at a redlight when defendant /. vehicle reck1e..ly r.ar-.nd.d the plaintiff" vehicle becau.. the defendant failed to .top her 1II0tor vehicle in a ufe and adequ.te fuhion. IlIIDIediAtl1y after defendant'. vehicle recklellly collided with plaintiff" vehicle, a third car, driven by Cue Thu Hgo, collided with defendant'. c.r. 6. A. a re.ult of defendant /. failure to .ufficiently and .afely .top her vehicle, plaintiff/. vehicle incurred dam.ge. to t~e re.r-end bumper in the amount of '610.45. 7. The colli.ion between plaintiff'. vehicle and defend.nt/. v.hicle wa. c.u..d by the negligence, carele..ne.. and r.ek1e..n... of d.fendant in th.t the def.ndant. a. failed to have her motor vehiel. under proper and r.aeonable control, k.lWJ; ...~ I ~ It; ,',- . , . . .' ," I', b. op.rat.d h.r aotor v.hlcl. 1n luoh a ..nn.r al to caul. Lt to oollld. lnto .nd a,.Ln.t pl.intLff'l vlhiol., 0, ,.il.d to brln, h.r motor v,hicl. to . Itop in tLa. to avold the oolli.Lon, d, 'ail.d to pay prop.r and r.a.onabl. .tt.ntion to the traf'io light li,n.ll' " op.rat.d h.r ~otor v.hiel. without due r.,ard for the dghtl, I.,.ty and polition 0' the other v.hiel.. on the road, Lncluding p1ainti"" v.hicl., and t. oth.rwi.. conduct.d h.r..ll in a n.glig.nt, r.ckl... and car.1... ..nn.r. Ii I: I ! . f , I. A. a r..ult 0' d.I.ndant'. afor..aid n.glig.nt car.l... and fickle.. dilr'9ud for h.r obligation. and duti'l under the law to op.rat. h.r v.hicl. in a r.a.onabl. and .af. mann.r, plaintiff ba. .u.tain.d prop.rty damag. to hi. motor v.hicl. in the amount of U10.45. WBIRlrvRl, the plaintiff, William J. Strou.., III, pray. that thil Bononbll Court .nt.r judcpnent in hit favor and .gain.t d.f.ndant, 'atricia Pop., in an amount of $610.45, plu. court and filing h... ~~~u.., In Pro Per III , " Ii " i' , . , . ~'.~I.ICA~I o. .I~VJ~I I, WL~LL.. J. 'tro~.., lIZ, do hereby eertLfy th.t a eopy 0' the forl90Ln9 CODlpla1nt. "'II t.h.l.l day ..r:vad ~pon the '01l0wLn9 p.r.on Ln the ..nn.r LndLcated belowl CIRTl.IID NAIL ,.t.deb 'ope 1514 IJ. 12th Sh.et .arrL.burt, 'A 17104 DAT.DI " " " ,I " II I, I , ' , , " " I;, . ,I " , I 1;.1 " I, . . . .' YJBI'Je~'1'JON I, William J. .trou.., III, do h.r.by v.rl'y that the .tat.m.nt. mad. In the 'or'9oln9 Complalnt ar. true and corr.ct to the bllt of lilY knowlldfJ" intol."lllltlon and b.Uer. I und.ntand that fal.. .tat'lII.nt. aontalned her. in ar. .ubj.at to the p.nalti.. of 18 P.S.C. 54904 r.latlnfJ to un.worn fal.lflaatlon to authoritlll. wttr.:.~.., III " :' I: I, " " , , I, I .. I, , , I,! , I I_;~~~,j r.t '~ I 'Ii' .. VI, XN 1')11 CO\1aT 0' COMMON 'LW CUMB..LMD COUNTY, .ltflfIYLVNfIA CXVIL ACTION . LAW NO, 4:U Civil itU WILLIAM J. STROUSI! XXI 'lalntiU 'ATRICIA POPI, Defendant TOI William J. Strouse, III, Pro Se 4807 Charlel Road Mechaniclburg, PA 17055 YOU ARB HSRIBY NOTIFIBD, that the New Matter let forth herein contains avermentl against you to which you are required to rupond within twenty (20) days after service thereof, Failure by you to do 10 may conltitute an admission. CALDWELL & KBARNS DatIl BYI Deborah A, Cavacini, ilquire Attorney" I,D. .67900 Attorney for Defendant Pope , , . 1'1 " v.. 1" THI COURT or COMMO" PLIAI CUMBIRLAHD COUNTY, PINNIYLVAH1A CIVIL ACTION . LAW "0, 414 Civil 1994 WILLIAM J. STROUII1 111 puintiff PATRICIA POPI, Defendant IW awn "I TB NJ:1f KA'1"l'I1 AND NOW cornU Defendant, patricia pOlle, by and through hel' attorneys, Caldwell' Kearns, and submits the following Answer with New Matter and states in support thereof as followsl 1. Denied, Defendant, after reasonable investigation, is without information or knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of paragraph 1 and proof thereof is demanded. 2, Admitted. 3, Admitted in part and denied in part, It is admitt.ed that an automobilll accident occurred on October '1, 1993 at approximately 5155 p.m, on the Camp Hill Bypass in cumberland County, Pennsylvania. The remaining allegations of paragraph 3 are denied as legal conclusions which, under the Rules of Civil Procedure, need no response and are deemed to be denied, 4. Admittod in part and denied in part, It is admitted that patricia pope Will operating an 1984 Oldsmobile at: the time an4 place alleged. The remaining allegations of paragraph 4 an denied a. legal conclu.ion. which, under the Rule. of Civil procedur., need no re.pon.. and ar. de.med to b. denied. !5 , The aveJ."\l\ent. of paragraph 5 art conc1udon. of law and/or fact to which no r..pondve pleading 18 appropriate or nece..ary under the Penneylvania Rule. of Civil Proc.dure, By way of further an.wer, Patricia Pop. maintain. that the .ubject accident occurred when she wa. at a full .top, hit from behind by . third party, CUc Thu Ngo, and wae pushed forward into the vehicle operated by li'laintiff, William J, Strou.., ,IU, 6. The avermente of paragraph 6 are concludon. of law and/or fact to which no responsive pleading 11 appropriate or necessary under the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. By way of further an.wer, Defendant, after reasonable inve.tigation, is without information or knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments regard Plaintiff'e property damage and proof thereof is demanded. 7 (a) . (f). The averments of paragraph 7 (a) . (f) are conclusions of law and/or fact to which no responsive pleading is appropriate or nec.seary under the Pennsylvania Rulee of Civil li'rocedure. 8, The avermente of paragraph 8 are conclusions of law and/or fact to which no responsive pleading is appropriate or ?eceesary under the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, By way of further answer, Defendant, after reasonable inveetigation, is without information or knowledge sufficient to form a belief ae to the truth of the averments regard Plaintiff'. property damage and proof thereof is demanded, Y1lW ....'l"l'... " paragraph. 1 throUih . or the Defendant" M.wer to Plaintirr'. complaint are incorporated herein by rererenoe. 10, The damage. allegedly .u.tdned by the Pla1ntiU were oau..d in whole or in part by the acta and/or omiaaion. or individual. other than Oer.ndant patricia Pope, WHIRBFORE, Defendant re.pectfully request. that judgment be entered in her favor and again.t Plaintifr, aeepectfully eubmitted, CALDW'B1.o1.o Ii ItBARNS 3631 North Pront Street Harrieburg, PA 17110 (717) :132-7661 Oatel By Deborah A, cavacin1, I.quire AttorneY'e I,D, *67900 Attorney for Defendant Pope 27887 " , , , ", " " , .., , , " I, q , . I' " , I ",I I I! , I 'Ji' I .,.j. 1,\ \ , 'I , " , , 'I , , " ,I , H, " i , V.rifiea~ion I, Patricia Pope, verify that the averment. mad. in the foregoing Defendant'l Anlwer with New Matter, are true and correct, I underltand that falle Itatementl herein are made lubject to the penaltiel of 18 Pa, C,S,A, 4904 relating to unlworn fallification to authoritiee, Datel ~atricia pope , " , , "1 " , ' ',' " " O,\DA'A\DAC""""'''',I /' ! ; 1:/",:tait..J ,I''''', ,,; ,j,'l{~. L'.I'1'I!t'" ". ,'--,.' . COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF DAUPHIN ss 1, KART.. J. JANUZZI, being duly sworn aC'cording to law, deposes and says that he is the attorney for the within Plaintiff, that he is authorized by the Plaintiff to make this Affidavit on her behalf, and that based on information supplied to him by the Plaintiff, he believes that the facts set forth in the foregoing Motion to Consolidate Actions are true and correct. , Esquire Sworn PD~,subscrib~)pefore me, this .J..:L.1:b. day of LUr I 1994 y p C NoiARIA. SEAl J HfBECCA S. RUSBATCIf, NOTARY PU81.1C ',..rfIISA!JRG, OAllrrllN COUNTY .~:..:.~M.~6SI~~I:'i...IlJ!l~2~~illl4 lAW \)mcE.~ 0' TlMOTIIY A. 8110LUNBUOIll . 1~lo lIN<lUST\l\IVN 1l0Af> . 1'\) I~)X ""'ll ' IIAlllll5BlJ1\lJ. PA 111"".Q\41 11111114-1100 , FAX I111111UIIl . . '~.TI.ICAT. o. a..VIC. ~D NOW, this ~day of Y1cl-L::\..-...- , 1994, I Darei M. Briggs, an employee of the LAW ~FICES OF TIMOTHY A, SHOLLENBEROER, hereby certify that I this day served a copy of Motion to Consolidate Actions by placing the foregoing in the United States First Class Mail, postage prepaid, at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, addressed to the attorneys or parties of record as follows I Scott D. Moore, Esq. METTE, EVANS & WOODSIDE 3401 North Front Street p, O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 Deborah A, Cavacini, Esq, CALDWELL & KEARNS 3631 North Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110-1533 Mr. William J. Strouse, III 4807 Charles Road Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 , .~;}bi~ LAW OFFICES OF TIMOTHY A. SHOLLENBEOER 1820 Linglestown Road P. O. Box 60545 Harrisburg, PA 17106-0545 , " I I, I, I 'I " " If I I !' .tJ 'l PATRICIA A. POPE PlainUtt IN THI COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW v. CUC THU NOO D~fend.nt , No. ~4-1440 CIVIL >>~.CI'I. >>Q. INT.Y 0>> a..I....o, '0 ,.. >>.OTIO.O'..YI Pl.... .nt.r the .pp.arane. ot the und.r.iqn.d on b.h.lt of Def.nd.nt Cue Thu Nqo, in the abov.-ret.renoe~..tter, BYl C/~;q IM.~ ~O~D. Moor., E.quir. ~ sup. ct. I. D. #~~694 METTE, EVANS , WOODSIDE 3401 North Front Str..t P. 0, Box ~9~0 Harri.burq, PA 17110-09~0 (717) 232-5000 Attorney. tor Det.ndant DATIDI Hay 5, 1994 ", , ' ,;.. ' :l~_ 'In 'l'ne Court QT C.:;mmc;-\ rl.:t::~ or C:.J:'.., ;wl::nd C:Ju';j','" ?8nn~yl'l=nl= , I , ,iJ., Patricia A, Pope 'IS, Cue Thu Ngo ~Io. ....,JL..U 4 () .1:.J.llJ..L.:i:l.l./JlI-..._,-. :~..._,.. ~ow, March 2'\, J')'H :9_ I, SE:Zl'U:7ll' 0'1 <;~~,(:Sl::a!.A.'ro COt.~-=Y, i'A.. ~Q hl;'lby cicpue:. r.b.e Sh.r::I..tr 01 _ 11IIIIllh I II :.!:.fa ~u=d.oQ bq :=aU ~I :!Ie rwq\lll' ~Q rWr. 01 Ill, l'!;'/':::H, Co)W11'f 10 e.'l1lCU1O ::.Is Writ, . , /." ....-,.. ,/// r. ,.~';' .... /''>'/'' ....;..~t..,.., :..~....4f"'""1.Ar;4.."~ ShIll4 ot Cll:l!luU.llG C~lIIIrr, I'll. . II , , :} A.Sdavit 01 S.rrit:e ~OW, t9 I :.~ . o'.:!ea ~[,I~ ~. ~tlUD -, '~FOQ ------ ~l .-. '-- by !wlc!lnf 1.0 , CllPT 01 Ill. oniUW -- - " U1d =adI knOWll to :he :::nteets :hc~i. !clUIIWllrt, ---. Sbd6 01 C:OWII." h. SWllrll ud 1Ilbk:rtJMd Ila'OI'l =.ll:.!I_ clAy 01 L9_ com saYlCZ ~aLZAOZ AI"71DA '.1T , oS .. --_._~-_..__... s ;J; ,- . .~ t~ .0 r ~ H'~, i~1 I.,) r ," ~ l"':""".' ~ I , I I. r / 01 ) I:i) , .' '" ' "" ~ '1'~ .". \ ' ......J .() ..::::;... '~ I~ ---:r-- I I ,~ '~ -+:! ~ ,) '~"-]i - - .- -< ~ "''' ,.,0 V'" I" i--\\ '---i. - . "'- '~,,'.-~ \ \;(1 ) "l'\ 1 ' " l~ i . , 'f"'(<0l) ~7" ....., It' OJ "... :' ; '''1\ 1"\1 '.,.. " ~i iL~ ! ~ ! r:: . ~ I ~ tal t ~. I At ~8 ~ ~ .... .~ g .... . l:l , .,-l . 8 III ~ 8 ~~ I( +I ~ 'tl ~ l:l :;!i l:l .,-l Q) III ~ .... ~ E~ u .-i ~ ~ p. ~ iu~ u p. e I' ; , I , I, , ' I' .' , ti!:I'I\:I;J' PATRICIA A, popm, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS LEBANON COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO, CfLI' /1/1./0 C/vl/ Tam I I I I 1 I 1 CIVIL ACTION - LAW 4URY TRIAL DEMANDED v. CUC THU NGO, Defendant NOTICIA LE HAN DEMANDADO A UST~D EN LA CORTE. Si usted quiere defenderse de estas demandas expuestas en las paginas siguientes, usted tiene veinte (20) dias de plazo al p~rtlor de la fecha de l? demanda y la notificacion. Usted de be presentar una apariencia escrita 0 en persona 0 por abogado y archivar en la corte en forma escrita sus defensas 0 sus objeciones alas demandas on contra de su persona. Sea avlsado que si usted no se defiende, la corte tomaro medidas y puede entrar una orden contra usted sin previo aviso 0 notoficacaion y por cualquier queja 0 alivio que es pedido en la peticion do demanda. usted puede perder dinero 0 sus propiededas 0 otros derechos importantes para usted. LLEVE ElSTA DEMANOA A UN ABOOADO IMMEDIA'rAMENTE. SI NO TIENE ABOGADO 0 SI NO TIENE EL DINERO SUFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICIO, VAYA EN PERSONA o LLAME POR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DIRECCION SE ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEGAL, CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE Court Administrator's Office 1 Courthouse Square Carlisle, PA 17013-3397 (717) 240-6200 lAW IlmCI~ IlF TINonlY A. SHOLLlN.11lIl11l "l~ UNIlU'l\l\IiIN IlIlAIl , ,,<) l\llX ""141 , IIAIlIlIS8lJl\Il, "A 171"".~14\ "'71m 1700 . FAX 17171 114 "HI PATRICIA A, POPE, Plaintiff IN THli; CQUR'r OF COMMON PLli;AS CUMali;RLAND CO" Pli;NNSYLVANIA NO, 1tJ. jl/t/O (/"" I I"h) CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED COMPLAINT v. CUC THU NOO, Defendant; AND NOW, comes the Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, by and through her attorneys, LAW OFFICES OF TIMOTHY A. SHOLLENBERGEf", and does respectfully represent the following I 1. Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, is an adult individual who currently resides at 1513 South 12th Street, Harr.isburg, Dauphin County, Pennsylvania. 2. Defendant, CUC THU NGO, is an adult individual whose last known address is 2142 North 6th Street, Harrisburg, Dauphin county, Pennsylvania. 3. The facts and circumstances hereinafter Bet forth took place on October 7, 1993 at or about 5155 p.m. in the 2700 block of the Camp Hill Bypass, Camp Hill, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. 4. At the aforesaid time and place, Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, was operating a 1984 Oldsmobile stopped in traffic in the right, westbound lane of the Camp Hill Bypass. I.AW (~Hlc~:s \)~ TIMOTHY A. 511111.LINBIIl<lIR I "'JL\ UNtllfSfllWN IhMP . Ill) l\l.\X I'I\)'H . IIARRISl\lIRll, ItA 171"tH)~4~ 17171114.17.\' , fAX <117111HlIl 5. At the aforesaid time i!nd place, Defendant, CUC THU NGO, was operating a 1991 Plymouth Van in the right, westbound lane of the Camp Hill Bypass. 6. At the aforesaid time and place, Defendant, cue THU NGO, failed to bring her vehicle to a stop and collided with the rear of Plaintiff's vehicle, causing the Plaintiff's vehicle to be pushed forward into a 1987 Dodge Shadow being operated by William strouse, III. 7, The aforesaid collision was the direct and proximate result of the negligence of Defendant, CUC THU NGO, in operating her vehicle in a careless, reckless and negligent manner as followsl a, In failing to have her vehicle under proper and adequate control I b. In failing to operate her vehicle at such a speed and in a manner so as to be able to stop within the assured clear di~tance ahead in violation of ~3361 of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Codel c. In failing to apply her brakes in time to avoid a collision, d. In permitting or allowing her vehicle to strike and collide with the rear of the vehicle operated by the Plaintiff, e, In failing to drive at a speed and in a manner that would allow her to stop within the assured clear diotance ahead, f, In failing to keep a proper lookout and to notice within a reasonable time the Plaintiff's vehicle stopped in front of her, and, I_^W l,ltHU."i u~ TIMOTllY A. ""()I.uNB!R1II~ IIIJI) UN(lIbr~lWN Ih)AII ' (Ill I\l.})( tI\.\~H ' "A~P.I!'Il\"\.\I. I'A l7Il'l'l,l'~H (;1111\4 )il\l I fAX 1117) 1I41l2l1 ':;""1;"') 9, In otherwise operating said vehicle in a careless, reckless and negligent manner and in a manner violating the Motor Vehicle Code of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. e, As a direct and proximate result of this collision, Plaintiff, PATRICIA POPE, has suffered serious and permanent injuries including but not limited tOI a. Severe strain and sprain of the muscles, tendons, ligaments and other soft tissues at or about the lumbar spinel b. Severe strain and sprain of the muscles, tendons, ligaments and other soft tissues at or about the cervical spine, c, Left sacroiliac syndrome I d, Left knee bruisel e. Chest bruissl f. Severe strain of the nerves and nervous system, g. Extreme mental and physical anguish, 9, As a direct and proximate result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, PATRICIA POPE, has undergon~ and in the future will undergo great pain and suffering for which damages are claimed. 10. As a further result of this collision, Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, may incur reasonable and necessary medical and rehabilitative costs and expenses in excess of the I AW ll"ll.I~.S Ufo TIM.)TIIY A, 8ltOlUNBlltOlll 1,Il/l.lIINIII.FS'T~ lWN ttllAIl . P~) I'OX w~H . UAAftl~R\Jl\lI, PA 1111-lfl (l~H 111711l411\J\J . FAX 17111214 !lll amQunts paid or payable pursuant to Qubchapter B of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law, worker's compenlllation or any program, grollp cJOntract or other arrangement for payment of benefits as defined in 75 Pa. C. S. A., Section 1719. 11. As a fUrther result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, has suffered and may continue to suffer a loss of earnings for which damages are claimed. 12. As a further result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, has suffered a permanent diminution in her earning capacity and power for which damages are claimed. 13. As a further result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintiff, PATRICIA A. POPE, has sustained a permanent diminution in his ability to enjoy life and life's pleasur.!s for which damages are claimed. 14. As a further result of the aforesaid injuries, Plaintif.f, PATRICIA A. POPE, has incurred or may hereinafter incur financial expenses and losses which exceed sums recoverable under the limitations and exclusions of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle FinanciaL Responsibility Law for which damages are claimed. lAW llHll .~s ll. TIMI)TIIY A. 8t111IUND!lItllR IIlJ~l UNllI.:lh)\\lN Jh)AII , Illl. 1\1.1)( 1'1\.""1 . tlA.Jtl\ISI\lJl{tj, PA 11IuniJ1." 17171114 \7<" . fAX 17\71114 8/1/ WH~REFOR~, the Plaintiff, PNrRICIA A, POPE, demands judgment of the Dijfendant, CUC THU NGO, in an amount in excess of Twenty Five Thousand ($25,000) Dollars and in excellll of the amount requiring compulsory at'bitration. Reapectfully submitted, LAW OFFICES OF TIMOTHY A. SHOLLENBEROER , ',.1 i 'h Date I 3 J~W ,I, " , ' , ' 'i " \' I....Wl)nICI~l)F tlMontY .... !lIl1I.L1N~llUJlll I!IO I.INIlIH1\l\IIIN 1l1).\1l ' I'll "'IX f>\IH\ , IIA1lIlIMIlIllll, 1'.\ 111011,0\4\ 1117111417"" , FAX 11171114 !III