Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout94-03134 .; J - 'Q.. J\ tV, .-;n \",", ~ . ~ l.. c5 \ ",,/ / / ~: IV' PI 1 -! '''1 dJ "':t' (Y)! - rY)' 679,~'1"11I.. v, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLBAS CUMBURLAND COUNTY, PBNNSYL VANIA 94. .JIl'/ CIVIL TERM CIVIL ACTION - LAW CARLISLB HOSPITAL, I'lalnllff RICHARD D, STBTS, Defendallt JURY TRIAL DEMANDED COMI'LAINT AND NOW, comcs the Plaintiff, hy its allonleys MARTSON, DEARDORFF, WILLIAMS & OTTO, and herehy livers as lilllows: I. Plaintiff is Cnrllsle Hosphal, a Pennsylvania non-prolit corporation wilh i1s principle place of business at 246 Parkcr Street, Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pennsylvllnia, 17013, 2, Thc Dcfcndant, IInlldnlt singlc indivldulIl, residing at 34 Sonth Hanover Street, Carlisle, Pennsylvnnla, 17013, 3, The Dcfcndant, Richard D, Stcts, was lreated lit Carlisle Hospilal on an out- patient basis Oil May 29, 1993, for a total cosIoI' June 3, 1993 IInd July IS, 1993 for Injuries resultlug from a motoreycle accident. 4, Pllllntlff, Richard 0, Stcts, WIIS pJ1lvided reasonable lIud uecessary medical care by Ihe Plaintiff and the Plalntlff's agents, servants and employees, 5, A copy of the hills for thai treatment which have becn previously sent to the Defendant, are hcreby altllched as Exhlbil "A, 6, The outstanding balance of $9,419,89 represents Ihe reasonable and necessllry vnlue of the services provided to Ihe Defcndant, for which he hilS yelto pay, 7, The Dcfcndant has breached IIn expresscll or llIlplled agreelllcnt to pay the reasonablc vlllue of Ihe services rendcred, 8, The Defendant Is liable to thc I'llllllliff and/or has becn unjustly enriched In Ihe an1l1untof $9,419,Kl/ plus pre- and posl-judgementlntcl'estand costs, , ! .':1".. i' tHHC,H( - " r, . w . .. " --_...__..~ ...-,t.t-t"0 .. ?J .. ,.w 2:" fill . ~ ~ - ~,....eeee :'t . .. i.'~ ~:: .......... t ., . __IIft"'~ ,-- I , ..'Ii ~ .. ;O!'t :: l' ... ~ ~ !~ ~ Q ~ .. ..l'J I~ 'ell ~ D ~ " ~ ~. -- . IU -. :aD;(~=-~ --0'_ ...,.,..~'" .~..Dilil.. ..-.ao:"" ..... ., ~. ..J ... '...: i:~ I:!.~ 3~ ~_~ 'I ~ ~,. '(Q~~t" : .... .. .. ... ~ ~.... ~ ~ .. "~I~~& I ...."".ooc U .,. ~~ . .,. ~ ... aa :; ~~ ... " D an . r~ uu .. .. . ... ... .. .... .,. .. J a~ . ~ ~ . ::> ., u .. d ~ . . J s i .. .. a . .. " ~ ~ I~ . ~ ,. ~ .. .... ... 0 .... WII' .. . ~.. .. u .. "......... i :; ..".. : . 0(1 ... u.. IWVI <If "^' i ~- "oM' ~ :; ~,2j: ~ ! .""'.1- a " .. .. ... .. . . ... ~ . . . ... .J .. .. .. ,. " - ,-. :1 :~ - . . oJ . ,.... .,... .:. . ." ", ~~~~~~~~~~5!~~~lI':~~~ll!~~~~~'tlC~:~l:.l~: ~: UlPN_r.. ~ -DO'" rNf\.IlllChllrr... _1.tUIUH/h.O,.. ....., U1., , I~' , ....a_ "'~ "".. _......UI~~ ... t4\ '" ... )C.............. , . . " ~ tJ.t . ~u~;;fl ol;1~~C i: 4 '" .. ... u ... .. t "I \!'i r 000 will tj~""- ::10 ~ 2: -"u UI \II V 0 ~ ....; ~w.... & :~ .r err ... ~~ ~... ~.2 D~ w "" g ~ I.... :. ioo0a ... ~fi: ~ ...... ~_.. "'0". ~ 0 -io,. O~ D ::>::> . a. .. "......~ ..... u..-. .J~ _._. .. ....00 ""ft'VlI OI\ftUl .. &."....b_Cu "'-0 -~ v>t... i l.~. koofS ~ u ;;~~~U~~~~_U W2~~ ~~ " 01 ..... & r.JE . !'" gg .i~u..~i.~~..,~.. LO I luWWM~ug~ ua ~~. a.~W _~~...-~_;;~~~ j~ --lW ...w-. fa ...\Ua xC WD 0_ C ILClu ".~... 'J'Il R-rJi.'O .....- oW-,.. wr>j' .",.,,,, ~ ~.' .~~~ ~ EE~!;aWli~!s-u~o~~O:~ ~~ -~~a~ 8, ii...l'~i-oeo~ !~~g~l~~ Jfi; -~!~ ~~--~~~r ~~!Qi200~"'~u~ ~ul ~ ~~tot=!!!~S~ ~.~: ~~~~~~~~ f~~~~~(fS~~~S~~~~ss~~~~~f~~ ~~~tt~A~M~M~~MMM~~NONN~~ 'l~~~~~~~~~ ~"'~~~'~'~'~~,~"""'~ ~aoaooD01)b7:j a~~~aoa~o~c~r;c~o~~~~~~~~~ '" .., .. . ,... ..~ .... .,.., ... u... a., f~ L' N"'~l~""D"'D~III-"'",,N"'D--"'NaC10"'lI"r.""\I' V'I".I) a~ ... ~~M-~~-OM_-~DO~tnO~"'~~~.onn_~J~' -g ~ ,......O'M~r~gQ_...""V1l11a.W...VClO.'j,u'.,..N,.,n"j o o. . a~.~ "'~ ~"'~O~~~Ok4"-. oa~waar o#~..,.. ,.. .N,..t-- ~_ "'UH"..-'-~a:o...%....lZ -.....:H.'.'" oOl'ofofoDDDOOOllt - --lDoooo'ioOt:)ooanN~jUJ tU II . Z lZzzzzx_--- rxrxr 1JrlrJZOI)O~ .. ~ ~ ~~~~~~ouuu ~"~"~~AA~AAAA~~UI' "'~"'MMf"'\~~"'''''''''''''''''''P\'''''''''''''~'''M'''MM'''''M''''''''l''''''''''''' ~(ttt~tttttttt~t~~~~~~~~~t~t~~~~~~~I' ~,. P ..... ..ar. ..... "ooClo~aooot:JQadno.... ._'\.4"''''''. ~~~NNNN",,.,,...,..,,..,t'\""M"'''''''''''''M''''''''''''''''I.JC)IJ()II "" ""................,................. ............"........................,,,,, ., ' , '.' ~~~~~}';~~~~~~~~~~~~~~g]~~~~~r.~~:.~:~;~:t~;;':;~;'; . . .. , " " " '" , . .- ~~ '/ (((((((~(~~((~~~~t~n~~~utn t n ~. ~" ,0 . I. i ~ ' "", . .. I . .. - . .. HHlUlUUt ~1 . ii.iitt~ t~i i i ~ ~ ii i, &&r.r..~j.i.i.~r.i.r.r.r. .. II .. - ., . .. ~1 .. . : ... \.j8 , ~ ~~ V N :s ... ~ I::, ~ ! :;(1 ~ ;; ~ ~ ~ ... :;. ~3 :'l .. ani 'l~ - .- ~ ~ .. .. .. 1_. .,. .- J . t. . ,. , !. " U N " . .. .. . .,. N ... . . , . ,. ,. ...... ,- :; t. ~ . I ,. ...1Il ... I~ , ..... ~~ ~.. ., ~~ ..... . JU -. t).. .. .. ..... k ...... .t- wv..... '" .'itllOW ... ..--! ... .... 13 0.. ..J .. ,- ..I:; k _ tI ,.. ....t"' , a: ~.. ... t:: ~~ 't_'"' ~.:, ':.:~. ":: u -f?'f..L.~ : ......,. ~, .uoa"',... '" ~N_ "00 ~ t-1Iu..c ~ :~",.~82 i u ... ~~ ,. ... , r ~ ~ .. . ~ ~ 0 I ... 0 .. .. , '" ,- f. .. .. . ,. .. . ... ~~ I.J ." wol' __ ~ 04 "'........ ...... ? , 110 _ , ..... n4J^4 w ....,. ~ l..,.j- ~ ." u ..~. t# .",.... :' ~ .. -....~. . U ... .. .. .. - II . o ~ .. .. , . u . .. f~ ~~xr.~~~~~~f!~~~~~~~~~':~~t!~~~H~I~I~U':.l~:'.'J: \-1 Ch"~-...rt~-""'''''''::)~'''''"'ft-)Qt....,,,,'t.L''W'' ,lit, "j"\U';tIJ I ~ tA.. .....-!. -"B~....- ............... .... ... I '.. I 04 ~ , " .. - - . i ~ ~IS~i~' ; 04 ~,.~~ ~ ,~ ~~ N '8<< t~ ~'tl ~, ~ 9 !~2 !~ ~ ~ B ='i.~,. :~' f.,..A.t-- wi i. ~ ~ IR~~~ ..~ ~.-o~...- ua u ~ .. W"',.. UII __ ~I. z.... ..w ....... .. z "..~ ~ tOUU 0 u..k" ' ., ..- g ~~..,' - '... -' ~ ~....... .:1 KI: -. ~ \..un C..,JZ I .~ C 't,...- la,' 0-11 0 J:: .............., 'Ill U W8itllU1 .. ...UlCf ... '.Jl I-Q '.l It~u-- t-O"raD.:W- .. " VI _r- MWO""". hI.. I Cfi8 -.~D ;~ "'.!..fi-- ~.. ~ ~w (:)"",glD::'~Wp,~~'~ u -' -~1I -..0' I: ""'~.\"I"''''~'''''.=U'' ........ -Co> w ~ ~.~ (~ ____ ._I-~ -~~ ~E34"~ ~~~~I~ .. ;zt !; 5111Ii:~~~ilcol:~w!:w'~:~~~j~~~ ~ W" I"~-" ~!3v....J W_t- .-ILIlt:.. I~~_~!~O ........'.. ..~...o ~...... ~~ ....t",&e ... ~ :J W.. -. 0 ...w~ i:g~&~~~;. ~o_&..~ DW~ co!I'ou!r-"'~"''''..IL.Vll.3U::a''",.. , . , " ,. ~ .. " " " .. U .,. .. o .. u 1'"\""_. " .. .....M~,.".,r'lM,..,Mr'lM,..,,..,,..,...M,..M,..,r'l,.,,.,,..,I"',.I,.,,.".".1 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ OOOODOO~OODODDDDODODODOOOOOuoouoonl.'" ""'" """""""""""",~.. ~ ~. ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~'D ""f' ~O~~CO~ ~:!:!:!l:!:!l:!l~ooooo~ooooo;1;ooor.ln;i;,,,, ,.. ..~ ... ...n .. u.. 00 1~ u ~r. ;:~~~Of;~o!)~~~~o,;[,~;;;gU\~g~g~b~;.~~'!~'r ;t;;'. OQ:;) GI o~... QOOOaONOO...,"'" ,.,_~t"",o- "VI.-l'\.I~Qt', !)CJ'"", f..~~~!~:~~~~,r,~~G;t,~~ r.g~~~r..~ r-r. r?~ r. r ~~~:.~:,: ooooooooOODoooooOO~~Vo-o-~VPDVVUUU~uUI', I: J II S' 111111 S'::r III J' 1,..,......~t"Do4)~I4t.......~..........'4l..,...I. &&&~&~&~&&&"~~&&&IL..b~DGDDQ"QAQQ"I.",a ,. . .. o. , """'~"'M"'''',",''''''M'''''''"''"''''''"'''''''M'''''''fYt'''''''1''''M'''''I'.''''"''''II'I''' ~~~~~~(~~~(~~~~(~(~~~t~t~~tt~!~~!!UII ~~,.,,",,.,,.,,.,,.,~,..,Mr'l,","""'Mrr""""".""."" l?~e~~~~e~~e~~~~e~e~e~~~~~~~~c;:'~~~)~~~.~~I~H" ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~i~~~;~;~;t';t';;'; , .. .,... ..:.4 .n ". " . , ~ ~ . ; , . ! ~...... ii (((((((((((((((((((( (III" . , " ..,."...... .. I. i ., ~ ~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ t.t- h' . ., - .... .....~, ...... .. . H ~ - "......... .. .,.,. , ... l'.\ ~uu~~ n!!!!U~Uf,..w.r.!"!:: 4 ""'~~I-' " . .. ,...... I. .. . ~. .,... . rJ ,-, 13" .... a '"'. . .... .... _"'..,J "" ...'tVtOW t. ~ 1..0:& ~ ;:1: ~ ~ 4 ~ ....~ Il"''' ..J ~ !:::l: 't_... 'I ~ t~ u U -f!'fA~ .....~... ~~. ~l,ti := ,. ,(t...c i'" 40 u.oO . c ""... D...... U I , . ,. , ... l;" ~ ~ ... i::- ! ~~ ~ e n ... ~ .\ ~f .,. ~ .,. h' ~ .... . .,." ... n .. on u vu . .. " .. o ... h .. , . o .. ... .. . . .~ .. !. u u ... U , ... , . r . h , .. r ... .. . . .. ... ... , . ." .. - ,... :: ~!, . r . h n n . .. 1 ~ u . h .. , ... . .. . () . n .. .. ... .. . ~ .. .,.~ , , ... . () p. .,. ~ . . ... . . 0 .. 0 h . . . . .,. .. ..... .. ~ .. U'l.-C... ..... .:0 I U() _ ..... U4~ .... . I"'~' u .... ..,..,. ..MLI- ... .. . ... H~ , ..'" ... ~. D 'f' ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~...~o~~aa.~r.r.... ri ,..._N_~... -)CI ~ J: ... .. - . . ~ ~ ~"'~~ "'--II e.,\l!; .N_ ~- e ~~ r ~.. ~ .....\It ow '!. VlW .... "" u ~~h!i:'!:: l I -"'-.>>01._'0, u; . ~ Ut,~: ~ . - 0 u.......Vt~lJt. o.~ ~ ~;~S!~i!ll..i~ ... "'g~~"'rI5W~!u~ o~c~'; .NI-&': ;:'" ;:::!~~r;~~ ! 'e'~ ........__..ul.." __:i..i. ,. ,. '" .,. u '" . ., " . . - . u o .. u .. .. , l'! ~ ... u ~~,...,..."",..."',.,'"' ~~~~~~~~~~~trr( ............_r.~I.Mrlrl... ~~~~~~~, ,~~~~~ ................ ............ 00000000 000000 "... .... :::~ ... "'... =g .u u UtrNO."'UlOU""'O.....O.. 1. ......51"'.,u"..."'R -.,. .' .~~.l.~~~t.f?~~:i' t. UlY'''' r:... C J; l:,... NN'~ f\j ",NNNNNNODO_.."CD ,.,.,.t.t-,~t.. S I 1:"''''''''''''' ...c.c.cccca...raDlCUllll ,. . .. '" . ,",""''''M'''Mf'''l''''''~'''''''''''' ...."',....,........... ",.... ",.........",.... " ~~[;bL~~~b[,~~~r,~ .~ , , , , , ... " , .... .... , ... , .... ...~...~..~~.......~........... (lllOnOClQOUOOOOOO ..... ~.. .:... .n \l 'J .. i ~ -- w ... e . . . ~ ., ... 'i . - e ... a u . o . ,'- " " . "... -~ .... ~" ,.""".".,.."..'.".II.'..I'.".U.I...,..... ~~(tt{{~t~~t~~~., d..... ......I'"I."V. , U,lt.II' "''''Dar1r'...'''I\4'''N~H-JI J.', ....,........,...., .......... ..." ...... . ~:;~~~~a~Jr.~-1ilfl~~~!::;: : . .... .... .. ..." f"'1"'r1Mr"'I"I""""'I'I.",'I""'I'" 1t1t1t~~V"""VV""UU" ...............,.......................,... , ~;t~~;';~i~~~.t.t:tIH~J~~ ~~ I .... .... ~. .... , , ... '- .... ... .... .... "~ " .~r,w.....IU""" "'It V IH:JtJ.. lJOI"JODUI:lt'JC'JOtJ.' "... .. . " , ~. .~ .- aha t~Q.. Ill. .. ,hJ.-'- Og>QUU)- r.'unt:i:: "'''4'''~4 ,. t. t~ \&IOo4I...n .J u ., '-' '. oJ> "' ." r ..f\jl\4U' .n " I.' tl-l.' '-+-'-1") v...,.,.."ut ... .... . , . ,. ... ".... Q.~~ "..J W'i 0"'- ~'JS ..~ ,.... ..'" . H> "".1\ "V' ,. W L .. '-'-J lit.":> ...JJ: , " , . "'h4 U... , Ai< . ..... ,. . UJI. ."r ,. , IJ.a '" II... ,~ L I' <J. ~.:.'wv,.j.. u. 'Z.CJ . 14........J..' ~ WI"'. nll.to--'l., . '- 'Ih I.JI t I ~ , 10'1' .............. I" Z' __II" III IlI'I.'" .. ....II.' , tJ".-I- '41 '100 .......,J l:JkJ'-' I I IW 1" :J.:Ju4 I:J~' 'lloJlo./l l'Il;l'.... " a I u ',I \) , ~., u" ,. I \.1\/. , I. V". W':;'OVl .1\...1 1.11." ~. ,(") (',.' ... ioU " h' .a Z 1 .'1_" II "Z I J , II Z I Ill' .....,1 ." II. I :-,,1 ."" . .1. I' , h""" 10111 .. I h' H..,.., '" \l'Vl""""'k "1,\ \J"." "I" ." ""'.' ." tll."."I"" ,. ..,. \.:1,--.,. ".. '" I' .1 ~ a ... 11111.'" \.. '-'''/I"'''' . ~ ... i, .. ~!'!~ . " ;, ", i.... , .. I .. ...~... ,..' . ,. , . .' ......... ~. tw...'" - v -- HI .. ... (1IIu'd1! r:......"'.. ~' H . . w ........ .. - "...... :1 ~\, ....,... -.....JW.I w. ............' .. w IMMMJ ..~, .t) 'hh......'.."~. .. . I .. .. ... w , ~ ~ ,. .. w .. .. . .. .. .. w r .. . '~ " " n - y , ", '" J ,. - ... r, . I II .... . , .. . I" 1. .~ \I :'l ~ 1 ~ r. ~ ". ~.. ,. u " ~ ". " ,. ~ -. w. ~., .. ." '''' w , . .. . . . , ....n I II:! " , , ~, , 1" .., u.. , I r\& I , .. w...... I "" P ,...., . ...... , &-;;:1 ':': - ,~.. ,.. a ... I..'; ~..;' ~~ 't'..~ 1':' '..:::.- -t!t.. b~ '.~Ji:' ... -. ...." n ~ ,.. ~~lt~:~A .. .""".n04 J u ~.. '.. ~. " .. ... .. u .. M w . 1 , " " , ~ , ~ : ,- . ~ " 1 . . ~ , , w~ . . .. 01'" ..', ~. , , , 'HI'~~ j" -::"" ~ . ,. ..' ..,.., ..to.., , , ~ .. . . .. . t ~ '.1 . , , M - , .. ~ ! . ~ w . . .. .. .. 't' :f~;.~~~ ~ ... ..t. ~~ ~ . - . ~ 'i 'l~ :;; -6 ,#'If ","'''' !J i~h~ . ill~'S~ t ~ia~! ~ We .. I ..~... u · W ..... ... j:1 rw;; .. ;&..! ....-- "'--.c t.. ",t:;~; _t 1ft:-.. ~u ""'"..JV , .. , . .. . " .. w " - . . ... .. ,...r"\r-\,.,,.,'" ~~nH ~/h/h^\Il"" . -............... ........ ".... , f"""-"" uouunu ,... .,- .... 11'0 ... .,~ .n 1~ .. t\jOf.llJ,U M'N,,,,.. UlIlN"C'.lI' ~............ """"'I\I.JN UUUDUU I J I . J . ............ "''''''1''''''''' ."0.." , '........,' ~U'tV\V\'.fI , . .. ., I . ,. "'.- .:.. "10, >, -........ ,.,.,.,>,.,. ,JtIUlUHI I .. . ... <> - . . .... . ~.. In ~:\ ... .- ~ .. .. f> l:' .- - - . ". " .. !... .... t.~ . rt"''''P'''U~I",~''' f l. J J J ~~~~~~~!~ .n, l.~l.~.r.tl(.""'''~;eJ , w ,.....~ ~"~~~....'-"\I., ....Ut -,.....'\1'..,....,.:....,.. ot..a_..........._..,.... 1111 ~';';'~';'~;';'~I~II J J J .............................. ... '0 '0 ' ~~bb~::1t~~~;e,!H'J ~: ............................. -..',' .."'UliU......."',..,,..,..,..,,,,'.. uO....................IHhIlJ . .. " , ....... ... u...... ~ uuu ,..."'...... ~ ..,'1,.,,., ....w , , , , '_1_ ::f " ... , " " ... IJt) vt "''''''W . till,) ~~!1 --h, ..' ..' " ". ... 'i ~ ~ ... . " ..,. nol' 1.0'" 1.11 w""nJ~) .'NI\; M, .,ow ~I ..._,101I.... "I\IlI'14 t:ItI:QII ..~. CH ........ _H-"'~ WI ./h/h/'lt.oJlJhll t/'I I~ .....~.. ., 1</' ... 10. --JI.oII" II U.'"" .,.,. ...lw ..........."'OU 'tU nul II ''''11.' Q, l' ~~~~ ~~ tt~~;~' I _'II-I- . I ul; "UIl' .1 U " ~ f. IJIt ":'1 ,., r , (H- \.f,'. ,I, Wt.6 I..... J .., .;"~znr:'f.i'i~t.\ V:-':J, II tit: I'-vu-lt I....:...,..., ~.:;;~.~~~:;.11.~:: ::':: ~I ::, , . , ..' . ,-, ..' I w