HomeMy WebLinkAbout94-03173
~
I
j
.~
L
:i"
t
(J
c..
e-
If
\
\
\
\
i
)
::,f
~
j
--1;t
J
,
,
.,
j
!
,.
STI':PIII':N I.. HI.()()M
~(Q)lPJV
A I'III"'~I'\' \"'1 "III N.d 111111 ,11' 1.\11
'11111 I lit..' (... 'j \ I' HI' 11
C \ ti. i" I, "I" hI \ I \ ,,~. 1;\ 17111 ,
ftlLI',lllt.I' 717 ..I:-4U ',:71"
I.. '111111, 111,24~.17H
Tnl,I.Fkhl' "71.~.IH.'J(,1l2
S 1111111\11. III ijl' "I '"''
Utl~mbcr I, 1999
H, Anthony Adams, ElKlulre
128 E Kinll Strerl, Suite A
ShippenAburg, I'A I72S?
Jeny A Wcilolle, Esquire
Mark, WCilllc &. Perkins
126 F. Killll Strl'Cl
Shippcnsourll,l'A 17257
RI: Wayne 11I1m-Klfr, d/b/a Jlolfe.ter Buildllr. v, Lewis Hill & Linda HlU
No 94.) m Civil 1\194
(Jentlemen
Ench~'i(l(1 plCftIlC find Ihe Nolicllllf Ilellrinll by Buard of Al billators for the above retCrcnced
clSe Thank yuu
Vel)' truly yours.
Stephen L Bloum
SI.B/seh
Enclosuro
ec Jallles 12 ReuJ, Jf , ESllllire (wlcnclusurel
James Kollns, EsqUire (w/encloKllle I
('1111I1 Adllllniltrftlnr's Oftlcc (wlencloliure)
, 1'1111 f/tl'./oY~.HIII
1'1<" II' . J , "I '"I I +, I HI' 11:1\ ('11\'1'11 II\,?
!.---.--,
F\\.EO-OfFlqE
OF 1" t,,(\n:r1,IQTM'f
CUi,',.\ I I, ,,\.J ').j,Jl111'
1"""'''1\''1,:1\1\
[i'll\d .~ .' ,.
nLED-OFFICE
OF THr: r.fnIHOI.JOTAFlV
99 OCT 25 PH 17.1 fi I
CUM5LHV;,:) I;OUNlY
PENN5YLVN~LII
990\170 M1\(11?9
-t/s,ocJ PeL r2'as4
R..L jJ717$
.
) .
.
~ ~
. .
"
p
-
,
.
.,
-.-
i r
..
t,';j,~,-
Ocr IZ 3 4S rn '9~
1"1
fl' "I'H I ,-,hI
r;l"'~ Iii Y
'"',. OJ " ,,1,'!,
,
I ,
',,"""'n . t# , ..
,
) ,
"
..
,
_. ,
-
,
'. .
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY - PENNSYLVANIA
Wayne Forrester, d/b/a
Forre.ter Builders,
Plaintiff
I
l NO. 94-3173
l
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
VS.
Lewis Hill and Linda Hill,
Defendants
PRAECIPE
TO THE PROTHONOTARYl
Please re-instate the complaint filed in the above oaptioned
matter.
Respeotfully submitted,
1!l~''''. 't~,>;,. . ....
.,,:}j ~". '.i'..... .. ..' c_._ .';(.,:
.,.....~'1:...
OF 1tI~lMY
95 ore 19 ^H 91 1 ~
CUMIlEflLlND COUNtY
PENNSYlVANIA
t .~.. i..
t
, ;
".-:..,.,""",,,:,,.
to
J '
,\,
,
. '
1# ~
,I
..
-'
.
.
..
J
.
!,1"
.~ ,,~~......,
...,..",.:....,....':. ,
,_... ,..,.-.....
~J \,/;'/;. j :'; ,', -,;:;jC~~~".;~{.,I:' ~.."-.. I; ',:,;.:;., ;.1', ':;'i.;":';"'l;" -' '-'-"::_T'1 " 1 .-'...
. , ",te, . "'L'>Il~'d'U'lUY~:.Jii'~;'~~' ""'J:h1f,*'it'r l' '
:,).~\i.i;.-,,~ >, >' -"';3',F~' ' >"~'!.'.\~. .r~:\l';f!':,
,
@
nlm-Wlce ,
OF i1\': Wt1\\0!!01In(
% n~n .. G t.t\ 01 16
CU\bI:Ioi./: U CO\JI~\"i
1'\"11'1 "'II'" I' ~
': 'iI" I ..~j \lld\
'-_#-
J'
~
.
-'
.
I
.
. ._:.0
,
',1""'--
II ~
11
"
...
1111,. III
hi iiHdl
!d.f,ii! AI-.
fASt' 11111 I'T"'I") 'J " I
'fltlMlilnolFA'111 iiF I FHlb\'l VAllltl
'i1lltrl I' 'iI ,lltll'l hLAlll'
FlihhF~,l FIi \011,1'111 I-l AI.
.,
.
11111 1.1-\011' 1'1 AI
M'i'l:I\! !.. fllll:, -,
,-0\
;;lI'nHf 01 lll'Jlllly SlIentf 01
qlHI'Fhllilll' ! ,,,"l,'. '''''''f''Y'''''Hlla, \Ill" hUill\! ,hd,' '1worn ,If.'':onhlll)
10 I~w. "il)'''. '.Ii". ~Jllilr, fiJl1!'Lr\!l1.'L.__
'.'1".'" II! l.J, I UILA
WidJ CPI Vl?d
l lil'
dpl"ll";l1I t. I >.tt
1?~. t I \",i/I ltillJh~'r un t.lit
i~trl iJUY E~t J~eblV~I:Y
J ~l'..}(. il'
_,I'i I:tLL '1/11'" I FU:,nn:l
~"qF'J FW-;IIUhG, I ^ j'-'
, \:\.JJ't!JJ;ru.,MH!
CnlJnt y, rl'f1f1f:;-lt:tJfi lH, bv 11.:Jlptllll} l,.~ IJt~J~A..HJ~.:b.
;1 trul.' ;ll1d '1lt":.itl't 1"1'),' f.{ tIll' .':OMFL1\JHL.
Ino,_II"'.'1 WI'Ii 'IV11. AI rl"1l l.,.,101
..'
..__.r
'lOti dl t ht, 1',dl!1.-C t If!'I:::' dl.f._~i.t lll~l lk"~ di I, fltl':IO tf; I tit:" t'jlllt.l'ntfi ttH?tpuft
1,'1 '.'1 I
^ j ! 1 1 i'.' J t
';111' t j ,1/ \J \..
l.. .,'ll
.~;'.'J'r'
1 . . ',' f~
ih';
+. '!"
) ,,--,I
"'. "'~l";. "1(
if;: ',(Iel;.:
',11'-1 \11' '''.,'
f' 'I i',I.-ltIILl
~~,. ,,1
, t~..(.' :......-...
.~ ,-~.-~"
't'" . .. >." "'L.4
I !l"'\i.' 1'. -'- llji, 'L,ff ~
~ ,
~ I~)
Afj'lll' 'IlY
l'<' t \.~ 1
Ii! II f'
~) '- A;:;Z'd ~
/-~-p:~. - t-r 'f.J7
art~~>{.7!i~~ . - -. P.
"'-r-'d' .11'-'1 I! I
. WI' t I j j I . d .~ 111, Ie' IlL I d , ! ' I I' ':..
il" /,) 't I" 1 tal...;..,
l'i </1. ^,'
-'J:"L/L"- {~, )1 1 d:i.... dftk'l
rl ' I!. I '; , I
.'
i
lid
(I'
Ii,'
1.-':
I.
"I
iLl
.
"
,
ft,
~
...
..
!.;
"
,j
I:'
;'1
.
t.
II
lJ,
1'1
\.'
;
('1
.L
~ lJl
....
l'< <( '" ~ 1Il
0 .... ~ , j.J 7..
~ '" o-l ....
lJl ~ Ii!: '" '" ~ t
~ > 0 '" lJl
g .... . '" ~. o-l ~. ~ e ~ I
o-l .... t; ::j~ ~ ,l
... .... .... .... .... $ '" ' , Ii!
~ > .... .~ <( .... 01 ~ <(:I: < <...
Z .... '" u :I:"" r>:~<( Q.lj:!"l;l~
0 U .... " o-l 7.....""t:~
~ ... ..c .~ .... <( ~WQ <l( <It t: ~...
.... . '" > ~ l'<Z
. '" "'.... .... w.... Wl r," t: I
U ~ ... '" u .... ;'j""...l ,.I i::,;c~,"E J
.01 ...l
l'< ='" ~l:;~ t; , 1':' "t:
0 ~~ '" Clo~iile.. f
8 " ~ :oJ '" :: ><
~ '" ~:r: ~<~~~~
M ~~ .......l
~ .... , ::l ~d~
8 .... > ;.c ...... I
M o 01 .... CIi ~
I I'< j.J II: r>: ~ '
~ of '" i~
'" ~ ~ Ul ~
~ ....
, :0
Ii!: 0 :i~ ~ ~8
.... Ii!:
.. ....
..~-, ......
...... ,..
MMth, \\ 111,11 ~",I'I Hh"', ~llIIH" \, " I'"
Ufll '~ll\I'I,"'lHIII "'11l1'1'1'''Ulkl. III"~ PH" Itl 1 1'1111\1 11l11~.U.'7.\U 1\\11l11~U,t!~U
..
.,
.'
.
..
-
~
.
,
IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA
WAYNE FORRESTER, d/b/o
Forrcster Builders,
Plllintll1'
NO. 94.3173 CIVIL TERM
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LA W
LEWIS 1111,1. IInd LINDA 1111.1..
Dcfcndunts
ANSWEI{ ANI) NEW MATnm WITlI COlJNH:RCLAIM
(W I>EJlENI>ANTS LEWIS 1IIL1. ANI> UNI>A 11I1.1.
NOW, come thc Dcfcndants. Lcwis llillllnd l.indllllill. by thclr uttOrllcy, Jerry A. Weigle.
Esquirc. IInd thc IlIw linn of Mllrk. Wclglc IInd Pcrkins IInd unswcrs thc I'lointifl's comploint us
follows:
I. Admittcd in pllrt und dcnicd in pllrt. It Is IIdmlned tllllt I'lalntllris II pllrticipont in the busincss
known os FOITCstcr Bulldcrs. Ilo\\'cvcr, it is spcciliclllly dcnicd thllt I'lalntll1' Is thc solc participant
and opcrator of Forrcstcr Buildcrs and strict proof thcrcof is dcmandcd at trial. By way of further
answcr I'lalntll1's wifc, Carol A. Forrcstcr Is IIlsou participant and operator in thc day to day husiness
of Forrestcr Builders.
2. Admittcd In pnrt WId dcnicd In purt. It Is admlttcd that thc Dcfcndants arc husband and wife.
It Is specllically dcnicd thut thc Dcfcndunts rcsldc at 3lJ6 E. Clurlicld Strcet. Shlppcnsburg.
I'cnnsylvunlu. By \\'uy of furthcr unswcr Dcfcndunts prcscntly rcsldc ut 3lJ3 E. Clurlield Strcct,
Shippcnsburg. Pcnnsylvunlll.
3. Dcnicd. It is spccllically dcnicd tlmtPlalntitr guve Detcndunts an csthnulcd cost to construct
un addition to thclr homc and strict proof thercof is dcmwldcd uttriul. On the contrary. the I'lulntll1'
and Dclcndwlts vcrbully ugrccd tlmt thc \oIul contruct pricc lilr ull construction and rcmodcllng work
onthc Dcfcndant's homc wus not to excccd $7H.lJlJO.lJO. By wuy of furthcr IInswcr, ancr reasonable
invcstigatlon. Dclcndllnts arc without kno\\'lcdgc or InliJl'lnlltion sull1cicntto thrm a hcllcf as to thc
truth of thc IIVCl'lncnt tllllt thc contruct \\'IIS cntcrcd into on or about Muy 2. 11)l)lJ und strict proof
thcrcof is dcmundcd IIttriul.
4. Dcnlcd liS sllllcd. Dclcndllnt only IIdmits thllt II spccltlc conlrnct WIIS cntcrcd Into with
Plllintiff lhr 1111 of thc homc Improvcmcnts In qucstionlltll tolll\ contrnct price of scvcnty-cight
thousllnd ($7H.OllO,Oll) dollllrs und IImt pursullnlto sllld contruct thc Pllllntlllhcganto work on the
Dclcndunts' homc, und strict proof to the conlrnry is dcmllndcd IItlrllll.
M1\!fH, Wlle,.1 (IN!) 1'lllIIH~', 1\1111ll'~1'I'. 1\1 ,"'W 1.'1> IfI'., l\lt41j 1,111111 '.llII'I'IN',UIIIHI I'n 11jl".t<.I'
.
.,
.
5. Dcnlcd. It Is spccllically dcnlcd thllll'llIintlll's work WIIS hillcd to Dcfcndllnts as timc und
matcrlulund slrict prnofthcrcofls dcmundcd ultrlul. Onthc contmry.ull \\'ork pcrlimncd by Plalntin'
hillcd to Dclcndunts us p1ll1 ofthc totul contract pricc 01'$78.000.00 und strict prooflothe conlrary
is dcmunded at triul. By wuy of Ihrthcr unswcr, J)clclIllunls' did not rccclve original bills lin matcrials
lIscd hy Plalnllll'inthc conslrnction \\'ork. nor did Plllintltrevcr quotc I>clcndunls'un hourly luhor ratc
or give Dclcndunts' hills lilr Plulntitl's luhor und strict proof to thc contrury is dcmandcd nt lrial.
6. Dcnicd. Allcr rcusonuhlc in\'csllgulion. Dcfcndllnl is without knowlcdgc or inliJr/lIutlon
sulllclcnllo limn u hcllcf us lolhc trulh of thc u\'cl'mcnts of purugruph 6 und strlcl plllof thcrcof Is
dcmandcd ultriul. lIy WilY of Iilrthcr IInswcr. 10 thc cxtcnt it is impllcd in I'lalntifl's uvcrmcnt,
Dclcndant spceiticully dcnics thalthc conlruct with Plulntitr wus onlllimc and matcrilll basis and
strict proof to thc contrury is dcmundcd ut triul.
7. Admittcd in purt IInd dcnicd In purl. II is admittcd that Dclcndunts rcccived hills Irom
Plolntitl Ilowc\'er. it is spceilicully dcnicd tllUt thc umountofthosc bills was $73.585.87 und strict
proofthcrcofis dcmandcd at trial. By wuy ofl\1I1hcr llnswcr.thc totul amountofthc bills Dcfcndants
rcceivcd froml1luintit1' wus $76,451),89 which includcs a hilllhulIPortcr Brolhcrs FUrlliturc In thc
IIIl10unt 01'$6.747.17 \\'hkh wus puid hy Dcfcndants dircclly toPortcr Brothcrs Fumiturc with t\lIIds
nllocatcd as purtof thc totul contract pricc of $78,000.00
8. Admittcd in part and dcnicd in part. It is admittcd that Dclcndants paid dircctly to Plaintiff
on umountof $()1).712.72. By wuy of furthcr unswcr, the ulorcmcnlloncd umount included thc
lUllounlof$5,715.52 paid toPllllntitrhy Dclcndunls fin thc costofkitchcn cuhincts purchased from
McCunc Lumhcr Company. It is speeiticully dcnicd.lothc extcnt it is Implied in I'laintill's avermcnt,
thot $69,712.72 is allthc monics Dclcndants paid lor work pcrliJrlllcd undcr lhc contract with
Plaintill' and strict proof lolhc contrury is dcmundcd ul trial. By way of Ihrtllcr unswcr, Dclcndants
paid, with I\mds uliocutcd as part of thc tolal conlruct pricc. $6,747.17 for curpctiug and $1,200.00
tilr lights, which cuiculatcs to u lotulumountof $77.659.81) paid hy Dcfcndants pursuunt to thc
contract with 11Iaintltl'.
9. Dcnicd. It is spceitlcally dcnicd thai Dclcndunts paid scparutcly lor lhc carpctund lights us
Plaintlll'has u\'crrcd und strict proof tolhc contrury is dcmandcd at trial. By way of furthcr answcr
Dcfendants at Pluinlill's dircction selcctcd cllrpct and lights li~r thcir homc und paid lor thosc with
funds allocutcd us purtofthc lotal conlruct pricc 01'$78.000,00.
to. Dcnicd. It is spceitically dcnicd tlllltl>clcndunts owc Pluintill' uny moncy whatsocver us
IIVcn'cd in purugruph 10 of Pluintill's compluiuland strlcl proof III the contrary is dcmandcd ut trial.
II. Admlttcd in purl uull dcnicd in purl. II Is udmlttcd thutDclcndunts ordcrcd, atPluintill's
dircction. kitchcn cuhlncts Ihull McCunc Lumhcr Company ut u cost 01'$5.715.52. II is howcvcr
spceitlcully dcnicd. tolhc cxlcnt Implicd in Plulntill's u\'crmcnt. tllUtllctclldanls owc the ulorcstalcd
umount to Mct'unc I ,ul1lhcr ('ompllny uud slricl proof tothc contrury is dcmunded uttriul. In filct.
in u civil uction tilcd in Mugislcriul Ilislrict No. ()1).].OI, ugllinstDclcndunts hy McCuuc I.umher Co"
ut Dockct No: CV,0000056.94. it \\'us judieiully dclcnlllncd thut Delcndunts did noto\Vc any
umounts 10 the McCunc I.ulllhcr Co,. IIl1d thut dceision wus not uppculcd hy McCune Lumher Co.
MI\III\ Wlll,ll 1.I~tll'IHhltj', ,.11111"11\',1\111\..... 1.'1,11\'.' 1'.11,1, ',111111 ','W'l'ltl',lllllll. .'/\, 1'....,'11."
-
"
t-
i
.'
"
WIIEIWFORIi, DclcndlU1\S' rcspcclllJlI)' requcst Plalntifl's complaint be dismissed, und that
judgcment be cntercd ugulnst Plaintlfl'in favor oflhc Dcfendants in thc wllounlof lillJrtcen thouSWld
nlnc hundrcd c1cvenund twclve ccnls ($14,1)11.12) togclhcr with such uddltlonal rcllcf us may be
appropriatc.
RcspcelliJlly submlttcd,
to.~../ C J,;/-l...1A,.
David C. Sehanhacher, Esquirc
Attorney I.D, #48446
Mark, Weigle and Perkins
126 Eust King Strcct
Shlppensburll, I' A 17257
(717) 532.7388
MAnK, WlIOlt ANU f'lUkIN5 AtlcmNlcYfi AI lAW ti!lt r_ASI HINn ~tUUl ~IU"l'fN!>UUIHJ, fill. lilli/Ii-I'
, II,pl.,"'
'l~bO' p, ',', I: ( "
:hhg :i'H~\G
,.-.,
'M r:lINF. I . i.l.~~'t. ,"I'-,i\r.~ANV
c." . .1.1\' !..-r... '.' ,.1/11
lI~rvlce-' IllJILult.(j !JUJII'llH" -UualltY
18 ~1:,l1'1 '.I~l" ~tl'l.lI
DH:flrt.':1~'.'rH~, l't:-..,~,\, ~~~:7
, ..
....
~.\.. ~J~J.;l.
INVOice S 9 80 600 " L.
o
'.....
" .8If.I'l-.._._,_ ._hlll, _....
T"TT:1~-'~~l'~"='-:-:":'~ ,""I. ;:.:.01..,; ..".....-~t=':tr;:.l..._
_J(~~:l ~IP' \I.,,'n . ._-"~:I..- .....J b""HU .", DAn
_..... !.. ...... ...J ,t/J,{,.,~"....,..~l_L!t 1..1
{I.'", ~N"111"1 ~,~C
, , . ',-,.,.-., .,..-'.',',
--.... _.'~. .. . ... , ........
I T.;li!-: \L...I"IJ., I~"',t ,_ ..JI"~'~"
"--f}rrC::UiiT\--" I' :-, fI'" ., ..' .....
__._.__. ___....._. _ , ~ ,rn...I..\I~... "._
.... _. ._~_51;;C>t\~.,..G,IJ'f:'.
\ 111
(10
N~
.~._..,..
._--_._-_.~._-~. .. .-..----.....-.. .. -..... ..-.....-..,
..........~.. .... ..,......,,~----_.__...-._-
------" -_.__._- .--...~ ,,---.-
. ... .., . .............--- ...'. .-..-
1:95 NU~""
- --
I (1.\(.111, ,~.uJA.C,!, ",I.o'to~fl", , i~ : <'\',".jU'" ,I' "l :".\I,I,','~ '.'
..1'~r tf IC'\ wilt... ~..f, "\1" ;",", 1,..61l VI ..~ I'l,'row I\""tol'
, \>0., ,J' .'" "". - I \,.1'" 'f . ' . "I f' .,., \, .I; ,'01.' ,:
OHIClINAl. INVOICl:
-... .,~."
.~.It t-,
IUI, TOTAL
WI' TAll
TOTAL ..
-_.... "-._--
, 'o'.. '.'~:;I ;;' ...." .-
'. " ..... "',,,~
-..-"'.-
-"...., ,.,.- -........,..,..._--~ 4.
':
.'
~~\
\" If-
n r \ '\ , \ ,\.1.
~ l\. 1.
~'lV ~
",
'I
\
.
,,' ,
.;.;
,I:
t.,.
..'I.
'J "
KXIIIBIT "^"
..
,
.
~
OF 11~_lMW
9G Or.12 3 p~ 311'9
CUI/,(,UO:t) COUNl'(
r~NI'lSYLV~1A
("It
\,'1'
.. -
. ~
. II
) "
. ,~
.
..
-
.
,
j
.
,1"'"-.^
t .. i
,
~'
~;!'~'i:;, c. ,', >
.. ,.r., ", .. '.://
,~,""" ",c".
-
''"\
;' Ii'
'.'ll.!.L'1
\."'. ;,
".1,1' 1(1
1./' ..' ...
C"Li' '.': ' "'J"IV
, :I~ " .f. ,.," '". l\ I
f'CN;'~j'I'LV,\NI/\