HomeMy WebLinkAbout94-03440
A
,
....
"
CBIl'I'II.'ICA'I'B ANI> 'l'IlANHMI'I"I'AI. m' ImCOllll
UNI>BII
I't;NNHY.!~Y!!!!!!LB!!I.BQI:'.A"'I'BI.I.A1'I'; I'IlOCt;I>UIlE 1,93!~
'1'0 the Prot honotarr of the Appel1ilte Court to which the
within matter hilS becn 'lppeiJ]ml:
6UI'EIUOIl alJllT Qt' I~YJ.vANIA
'I'HE UNIlEIlSIGNEIl, I'rothonotilry of the Court. of Common Pleas
of C\.ntJerland Count.y, t.he said court being iI court. of record.
do hereby certify that annexed heret.o is tl truc and correct copy
of the whole i1nd entire rocord, including an opinion of the court
as required by PA (loA.P. 1925. the originill papers i1nd exhibits.
if any on file. the tranacript. of the proceedings, if ,lny, and the
docket entries in the following matter:
Case No. 94-3440 Civil Torm: No. 84 HOG 1996
6HAIlON E. Mc:MICIIAEI.
VB.
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL
The documents comprising the record have been numbered
from No. I to No. l22. and i1ttached hereto as Exhibit A is a
list of the documents correspondingly numbered and identified with
reasonable definiteness, including with respect to each document,
the number of pages comprising the document.
The date on which the record has been transmitted to the
appellate court is February 29, 1996
(!leal of Court)
Prothonotary
An additional copy of this certificate is enclosed. Please
sign and date copy, thereby acknOWledging receipt of thia record.
RECORD RECEIVlml
Datel
RECORD F1l Fa /II sllP~n!nn r!1! rnr
MAR 1 4 1996 ~)
HAHHISUURG
/-81,e}
(signature & title)
r
("\
()
Commnnweullh nf l'enns~lvIIIIIII
Count~ nf CUlllberlllnd
1 hS;
\, Lawrence E. Welker ,I'rnthonnlar~
of Ihe Cnurl of Common Pleas In und fnr suld
C\llllll~, dn hereb~ cerllf~ Ihal Ihe foregnlng Is II
filII, true and correcl cop~ oflhe whnle record of the
clIse Ibereln slaled, wherein
Shamn E. McMichael
Plulnllff,and
Case No. 84 HOG 1996
Jeremy,). Mri>lit-h"" 1
Defendant _, as the same remains of recnrd
befllfe Ihe said Court nl Nn, 9 4 -] 440 of
ci v 11 Term, A.D, 19--2.Q..
have hereunto set m~ hand and IIffixed the seal nf said Cnurt
~I' uJ~12;'
\n TESTIMONY WItERHlF, \
Ihls Twentv-ninth
Ilrnlhtll1nllllY
I. Harold E. flheelv I'resldenl.ludgenfthe Ninth
Judiclall>lslrict, cnmposed nf Ihe Cnunl~ nf Cumberland, dn certif~ thai l.nwrence E. Welkor.
Prothonotary , b~ whnlll the IInnexed record, cerllficate and
atteslatlon were made and given, and who, In his nwn prnper hllndwrlling,lhereonto subscribed his name
und affixed the seal nf the Courl nf Comlllnn l'leas of IlIhl Cnnnt~, wns, at tbe time nf sn dning,and nnw Is
Prolhonntllr~ In II lid for said Cnllnty nf Cumberland In
the Commonweallh of I'ennhylvanlll, duly cnmml"loned and qnllllfied In II110fwhnse IICtSIIS such full fllllh
IInd credit arc IInd ought 10 be given as wcllln Courts nf jlllllcature as elsewhere, and Ihallhe said recnrd.
certlflcale and IIttestallnn arc In due Inrm nf IlIw IInd rIa e b~ the purer officer,. . .'
'\ (L \....j C \...lu.. L,;-
111l'\ilh:nl .11IlJ~c
Commonweallh nl l'cnnsylvlIllill
Cnunl~ nf Cumberlllnd
} ss;
I, l.awrence E. Welker , I'rnthnllnlllry of Ihe Cnurlol Commnn l'leas In
IInd for the sulll Cnunty, do mlily Ihllllhc Ilnnorllblc Harold E. Sheely
by whnmlhe fnregnlng uttclllltlnn WIIS mlldc, IIml whn hilS thercuntn suhlerlbed his name, wus,althe time
nl maklllg lhcrcnf, II lid sllllls I'rcsidcnl.ludgc nf the Cnurt nlTnmmnnl'lelll, Orphan' Cnurl and Courl nf
Quarlcr Scssiolls nl Ihe I'cll"c IlIlIml 1111' sllill ('nunly, dnl~ ('nmmlnlnncd lIud Ijuallfied; 10 all whnse aels
liS su..h Inlllullh IInd ('lc,llt 1111' IlIul oughlln hc gilen. III well III Cnurll nf judlcalure al elsewhere,
IN II'S'IIMONY WHl'ltHlI'. I hlllC hl'll'untn
Icl m~ hllnd IInd II111xI'd Ihc 1,'111 nl said ('lIIl1llhls
~l. '. __,_ 'IY nl __fllllllillY;::, AD) I~ ~.~./ ..
,/ _ u.~-~..-v Ji,(0~d
_ 1I'1I1hllHll!,II\
I I ~ oJ J &
c
c -
:l g
0
5!: '" I.J 1
Q -
j j ..:I ~ lli 15
a 0 N
..
I.J ~
is III
~ U lli
,001 I-l !9 I-l S
\Q > ~ ~
(II '001 G ti: lli ...
(II U IE > IE 1Il "B
~ ., ~
c . . - if
Ilo
~ . 1Il .., ~
. ~
= M I I III
I ~ ]
. .
CID (II e ~ e ~
~ -
0 d ,g Ji
z Z I.J
.
.
PIG: tv.
.
.
1 - 6 JWlC 24, 1994, Callplllint:, filed.
7 Oct. 3, 1994, Praecipe to Transmit Hecord, filed.
8 Oct. 3, 1994, Acceptanco of Service, filed.
9 Oct. 3, 1994, Plaintiff's Mfidavit: of Consent, filed.
10 Oct. 3. 1994, l~fendant's Mfidavit: of Consent, filed.
11 - ]4 Oct. 3, 1994, Agreeoent, filed.
]5 Oct. 11. 1994, Final Decree in Divorce, entered.
ny: Edgar n. Bayley, J.
]6 - 42 Aug. 9, 22, 1996, Petition for Contempt, and Order of Court, filed.
AND NCJ.oI, this 22nd day of August:, 1995 a Hule is entered against sharon
E. McMichael to show cause why she should not be adjudged in contempt of
court. Hule return,lble al a hearing to be held in contempt of court. Hule
returnable at a hearing to be held in CourtnXJIl No.2, Cumberland County
Courthouse at 2:]0 p.m., Thursday, September 211, 1995, at: which time Sharon I.
McMichael is ordered to appear,
ny the Court, Edgar n. Bayley, .J.
4] - 44 Oct. 5, 1995, Order of Court, filed.
AND NCJ.oI, this 5lh day of October, 1995, following a hearing, IT IS OHDE 'DI
(l) The petition to hold Sharon E. (McMichael) Riddle in contempt for
failing to coply with the custody provisions in a marital settlement agree-
ment that was incorJXlrated into a final decree in divorce by an order of
October 11, 1994, IS DENIED. The m)ther, however, froll this date forward,
shall provide the father llt least five (5) days notice when she is not 9Oin\1
to exercise her tellpxary physical custody rights.
(2) A petition to IK)ld Sharon E. (McMichael) IUddle in contempt for not
carrying nedlcal coverage on Ihe parties' Iwo children IS DENIED since the
children are being covered free in il government progrilm. Should that free
covemge cellse, the mol.her shall he restnnslble, ilS per the order of October
11, 1994, 10 either provide heilllh .lnsurolnce cllverage thrmJ\lh an employer's
JXlUcy or reimburse I he filther fllr such m1dH ionill cosl as may be necessary
lo add the children to health insurance covernge through his employer.
(]) Shilrnn E. (McMlchilel) Illddle is adilKilcilted .In contempt for f,l.l1ure
to PilY regulilrly $]]7 per IIlml h lor the lluppol-1 of her t \\n minOl' children ilS
per the onler of october II, IIJIJ4. The nnther Shilll purge hersolf of conletlll
by hereilfter timely lIIilking such pilymenls lo'lether with $:,0,00 per nnnth on
HCC(l\lI1t of nrrcarilqeR.
By Iht' r:"orl, I'll'lilr B. Bilyley, .1,
Nov. 13, 1995, Pel 111011 fllr f;JK),'lill II!' I l<'l 1 I il"l.
Nov. 17, 1995, Onlt'r 01 Courl, fl It'd.
ANIl Nt 1.'1 , Ihlll 171h <lilY III Nn"{'llIlx'I-, I'JI)r., 11 Hul" IF! enlen.,t agalrml
<I<'l'cn<lillll, .'('n~IIY .1. M,'M kll.11' 1 , In "lInw ,'oIUBI' wily t II,. n,llol 11',!IIl'flll,1 Illtnul,
l'iiFflHh I f' t'PjrTiM-rn<inrr1'''iiTiT't'Fl~tlMii'l - - '
Plillnl In Hlklll IIII' III 1111" ,'1""111"", 01 """'''0111<111111 willi \ (''lol I oII1111l.rlly III
IlIII'J"I-1 nj ItPI' J"Hltlnll 11l.1 \0111" 1110111 Illilly (1111 dol\,H 1"", Illh; <lollI', Till'
45 - 74
75
Among thc Rccurd\ IInd Prncccding\ cnrnllcd in Ihc l'ourl of Common J'lclI~ in nnd lur the
county of
CUlIlber..111n<l
No. 84 HOG l'J<J6
94-]440 civ.l1 Tellll
Tcrm.19
is contllincd thc lollowing:
in the COl1ll1lonwcllllh of I'enn~ylvllnln
10 No,
COl'Y OF
AnnellrilnCe
DOCKET ENTRY
SHARON E. McMICHAEl,
VB,
,JEREMY J. McMICHAEl,
.
.
PAtE tv.
issue will be decided without Il hearing.
By the Court, Fdgar 13. l3iIy1ey, J.
Jan. 16, 1996, Opinioll llnd Orner of Court, filed.
AND NCM, this 16th day of .January, 1<)96, the within petition, IS DISMIS ED.
By the Court, Edgar 13. l3iIyely, ,J.
Jan. 19, 1996, Respondent, .Jeremy .J. McMich,1el's, Answer to Petition for
Special Belief and New Matter, filed.
Jan. 25, 1996, Notice of Appeal, filed.
Notice is hereby given that Sharon E. McMichael, Plaintiff above nlll11ed,
hereby appeals the Order of Court of the Court of Coonon Pleas of Cumberland
County, Pennsylvania to the Superior Court of Pennsylvania entered in this
matter on the 16th day of ,January, 1996. This Orner (attached to this notic
hc1S been entered in the docket as evidenced by the attached copy of the
docket entry.
By: Linda M. Gross, Esq.
99 - 100 Feb. 7, 1996, Superior Court of Pennsylvania Notice of Appeal Docketing
to No. 84 BOO 1996, filed.
101 - 122 Feb. 26, 1996, TranscrIpt of Proceedings, filed.
75
(cont. )
76 - 80
81 - 89
90 - 98
~
1"'\
SHARON E. McMICHAEL, I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
plaintiff I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I NO. q If 3 I( /1 b (1~~I.L ;jlJvrr...;
VB. I
I
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL, 1 CIVIL ACTION-IN DIVORCE
Defendant I IN DIVORCE
NOTICE TO DEFEND AND CLAIM RIGHTS
YOUR HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT, I f you wish to defend
against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take
prompt action,
You are warned that If you fail to do so, the case may
proceed without you and a decree of divorce or annulment may be
entered againat you by the Court. ^ judgment may also be entered
against you for any other c iaim or rei ief requested in these papers
by the PlaintIff. You may lose money or property or other rights
important to you, including custody or vlsi.tation of your children.
When the ground for the divorce
irretrievable breakdown of the marriage, you
counseling, A list of mardage counselors
Court Adminiatrator's Office, Cumberland
Carlisle, P^
Is indignities or
may request marriage
is available in the
County Courthouse,
IF YOU DO NOT FILE A CLAIM FOR ALIMONY, DIVISION OF
PROPERTY, LAWYER'S FEES OR EXPENSES BEFORE A DIVORCE OR ANNULMENT
IS GRANTED, YOU MAY LOSE THE RIGHT TO CLAIM ANY OF THEM.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF
YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE
THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIIlD OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL
HELP,
Court Administrator
4th Floor
Cumberland County Courthouse
Carlisle, pA 17013
(717) 24()-6200
I
/"1
('\
SHARON E. McMICHAEL,
Plaintiff
1 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
1 CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
1
1
1
1
1
VB.
NO.
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION-LAW
IN DIVORCE
COMPLAINT IN DIVORCE
330l(c)
1. Plaintiff Is SHARON E. McMICHAEL, who resides 41
Regency South, Car.lisle, CUlIIlJerland County, Pennsylvania.
2, Defendant JIl JEREMY J, McMICHAEL, who r.esldes at 19
Richard
Road,
Mochanicllbur.g,
Cumber.land
County,
Pennsylvania,
3, PlaJntJ ff has boon a bona fide rosident in the
Commonwealth
for at least sJx months Immediately previous
to the filing of this Complaint,
4, ~'he Plaintiff Ilnd Defendant were marr.ied on
November 26, 19BB In per.ry County, PennsylvanJa,
5, 'I'her.e has been no prior action for divorce or
annulment between the parties.
6. 'I'he Defendant Is not a member of the Armed Forces.
7, 'I'ho marriage is Ir.retrievably broken,
B, PlaJntIff has baen advllloci of the availability of
marriage counseling and that sho may have the right to
request the Court to roquiro the par.tles to participate in
sllch counllal I ng ,
Reing IlO advised,
PlaIntiff does not
request that tho Cour.t require the partioll to participate In
counseling prior to a Dlvorco Decreo being handed down by the
Court.
2.
~
r"I
WHBHEFOJlB, Lhe pJ/IJIILlCf praYII your Honorable Court Lo
enter a Decree in Divorce from the bonds of matrimony.
Hespectfully submittedl
r1
,
tddL f
ith A, Ca! in, Bsquire
torney for Plaintiff
220l North Second Street
Harrisburg, PA l7110
(717) 23B-23l2
J
1\
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
r"\
I, Judith A, Calkin, do hereby certify that a true and
correct copy of the within Divorce Petition was mailed at
Harrisburg, PA., certified-restricted delivory, postage pre-paid to
the following personl
Jeremy J, McMichael
19 Richard fload
Mechanlcsburg, PA 17055
Datet
,1~~
Calkin, Esq,
~ ... \;J iJ ~
. r: ..~ lQ '() .
~ ! ; I~ ~ If) ~ '~ '(j
"
:.? -- t..o
t'.' ,
C'J ."'" ........
- ('(l
r_j I?1~~1 Ii
:a: 11
..~ ~
<:)0- Il
\:t - f'<'I
'- ~ (()
C':rl -:;> . ~
~ ~ c3 ~\~\
r-
\X:)
'_J
III
'0-1
p.
~e
I III t
011. . H
II . o-l ..: ~!Il ,
>- rol... tl~ ....1
~~ ~~ e~ ~~
tJ~ OU
E-<O H I: tJ~
~r' ):..... SJI'l ...
U III U III 0 <ilil~
):.-l rol rl
O~ 11. X'" tJM
, ~ ~
'o-l rol . 0
. t-:l I>-
Eel ~ ~ H i <iI E
ffi ~
~l~ ~
Hill P1
1II III
t-:l
. ., .
t . .
. .
w . .
v
,
.e .t. ' /J.l./ /~lf
6; :J>.o...
.. .J.,.
... .
E . '.
,., "
;}
M ". , , ,
.
'::J ".. ..' " .
-:r
.~"~
, ,
"'"1 I',
Jii :i
0",.
wi
r"',
(""'\
vs,
1 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
1 CUMBERIJAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
1
1 NO. 94-3440 Civii Term
I
I CIVIL ACTION-IN DIVORCE
1
SHARON E, McMICHMIJ,
plaintiff
JEREMY J, McMICHAEl"
Defendant
ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE
I, Charles Gerow, Attorney for Defendant, in the
above-captioned case,
do hereby accept serv ice 0 f the
Divorce Complaint and hereby acknowledge
receipt of a true,
correct and complete copy.
I understand that false statements herein lire
made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C,S, Section 4904,
relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
Dat~,IJ %6;1'1
dL / f2-
Charles Gerow, tsquire
~
" If
\ , "
c t..Y
4
.' fj
. dl
, " ~
,
~
,
d';
.
.'1>-
,t ~...
:t,~ .
iii, .:.
., ,? .r , ~ .'"
,~. ~.~ .
:c
O-
M
1":,1
~:r
....,
.g '~:"
~.-1
'-
f ~ "
~1'"
,
I'~"
I"
r~""!
';.,~
t.,,*
,~)
,.
I""',
,-.,
.
SIIARON P.. McMICHAEl., 1 IN 'I'HP. COlJR'1' OF COMMON PLEAS
Plaintiff I CUMBEIILAND COUN'I'Y, PENNSYLVANIA
I
VS, I NO. 94-3440 Civil 'I'erm
1
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL, 1 CIVIL ACTION-LAW
Defendant 1 IN DIVORCE
AFFIDAVI'I' OF CONSP.NT
1. A complaint in Divol'l:e unrJur Section 3301(c) of the
Dt.vorce Code was filed ,JUliO 24, I !)94 .
2, The marriage of Plaintiff and Defendant is
irretrievably broken and ninety (90) days have elapsed from the
date of the filing of this Complaint.
3. I consent to the entry of a Final Decree in Divorce,
4, I understand that I may lose rights concernIng
alimony, division of property, lawyer'a (oes, or expenses if I do
not claim thom bflfore a divorcfl is granted,
5, I understand I may request that tho Court require my
spouse and I to parUcipate in mar.rIage counesling, being so
advised, J do not. rp.'luest that tlm COllrl, re'luJ.re my apouse and I to
pat'ticlpaLe ill IlhUl'lIl<J'" l"UUIIB',llfl':J'
I understand that falee atatemonts herein ar.e made
subject to tho penaltiea of lB Pa,C.S, Section 4904, relating to
unsworn falsification to authorities,
Datej:fJIIf)( b:( ()ftll'1~1
c T~~tf~~r,~~[~~
a; ~.~,
J. ~.,~
.. ., ...~
.
~ ,.-
0- q
'" 1.t-
<;l ~'.~< , .;, .":
'':3'
C.,)
.E\ ,
'..I
'--
,-.,
.-
IO/3/Qtf
. ~
BIIAltoN E, McMICII^,~I"
Plaint! [[
I N 'l'lIl~ COUIl'1' {J/" COMMON 1'1 ,Mfl
CUMIIEIlI,ANIl COlIN'('Y, PENNHVI,VAN I 1\
NO, 94 J44U C I v 11 '('orlll
VIl,
.TEIlEMY J, McMICIIAr.L,
lJefendnnt
CIVil, AC'I'ION'I,AW
I N III VOIlCr.
API' IIlAV J 'I' 01' CONHF:N'I'
1. 1\ complaint in Divorco undor Snclioll 3301(c) of t.ho
Divorce Code was filed June 24, 1994,
2, The marriage of PlaIntLff and Defendant LIl
irretrievably broken and ninety (90) daya have elaplled from t.he
date of the filing of t.hill ComplaLnt..
3, T conBent t.o t.he ont.ry oC n Pinal DecreR in Divorce.
4, I underat.nnd t.hal. J mny loso rights concerning
alimony, division of proporty, lawyer'a [eea, or expensea if I do
not claim thorn hoCom n dlvorco la grnnl.ecl.
5. I understand I may roquest that the Court rRquire my
spouse and I to participate in marrLage counseling, being so
advised, I do not. requost that t.ho Court require my spouae and I t.o
participate in marriage counseling,
I undorstand that. faloe at.at.ement.s herein are made
subject to the penalties o[ 19 Pa,C,S. Section 4904, relnting t.o
unsworn falsIficat.ion to authotillea,
Dnlel rlP.N
,
~u/"r-i ?Jtt~~vI
.IE EMY . McMICIlML
/D
('V')
ti
c;::)
6;
-
t.'r::
"""..
f ~ , ",. ~l
.J :x~
~ i., Itl
,t .'~ ~
If:
..,
/"~,
:r
I
.. .
,
.....;
'-
,-.
ra-,
5han)}1 E. f1~/I1"AIt'/
- vs.
:Jerem,/ J: flell" Ate/
AGREEMENT
This Agreement is made this zt,a day of
AlIIr-sr , 1994
by and between JEREMY J. McMICHAEL of cumberland County,
Pennsylvania ("Husband") and SHARON E. McMICHAEL of
Cumberland County Pennsylvania ("Wife"),
WIT N E SSE T HI
WHEREAS, the parties hereto are Husband and Wife, having
been married on November 26, 1988 at New Bloomfield, Perry
County, Pennsylvania;
WHEREAS, Husband and Wife are the parents of two
children, Mark Andrew McMichael, born May 4, 1990 and Zachary
James McMichael, born September 17, 1992; and
WHEREAS, certain unhappy differences, disputes,
misunderstandings and difficulties have arisen between the
parties and the parties have decided that their marriage is
irretrievably broken, that it is their intention to live
separate and apart for the rest of their natural lives, that
they are desirous of settling fully and finally all of their
respective financial and property rights and Obligations as
between each other inClUding, without limitation, by
specif ication 1
(1) the settling of all matters between them
relating to the ownership of real and personal property
including property heretofore or subsequentl, acqulr9d by
either party;
'. ~he 3a::::~a ~t 1:: 1a::a~3 ~~:,~:~~ ::
':~5'::fi'/. '/:'J:':.1t:;r. li,''; :t.:::cct"-: :: :::: "7I;,:":C: =~':"_':=1;-'. ::.'~
-.
,.."
.
.
parties/
(3) the settling of all disputes, rights and/or
interests between them arising out of or by reason of their
marriage including but not limited to the past, present, and
future support, alimony, counsel fees, costs or maintenance
of Wife by Husband or of Husband by wife/ and
(4) in general, the settling of any and all actual
and possible claims by each party against the other or
against their respective estates.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the premises and of
the mutual promises, covenants and undertakings set forth in
this Agreement and for other good and valuable consideration,
the receipt and adequacy of which is hereby acknowledged by
each of the parties hereto, Wife and Husband, each intending
to be legally bound hereby, covenant and agree as followsl
1, ADVICE Qf COUNSEL
The provisions of this Agreement and their legal
effect have been fully eKplained to the parties by their
respective counsel, Judy Calkin, Esquire, for Wife and
Charles Gerow, Esquire, for Husband. Each party acknowledges
the fact that they have received independent legal advice
from counsel of his or her selection and that each fully
understands the facts and has been fully informed as to his
or her legal rights and obligations and each par~( accepts
that this Agreement is, under the circumstances, fair and
dqU:':..lt~o:l lr.d :~J: ~~ ~3 ':~:':-.() ~H~~J~1'~ :'~-:J :~'3<3~'.' Jr.d
.;r;.....1r.~l:"~~' 1::'=:''' .-:.1''':~r1 ::'~'=d:,'/q i 1'. ;~. 1'':'/'_:3 1:-:...:,;:'::1 J'~C:".
12-
r"\
r'\
.
result of any collusion or improper or illegal agreement or
agreements.
2. DEFINITIONS
(a) Divorce~, The phrase "Divorce Code" shall
be defined as Act No. 1980-26, 23 P.S. 101 ~ ~., au
amended.
(b) ~ g{ Execution g{ ~ Aareement. The
phrase "date of execution" or "execution date" of this
Agreement shall be defined as the date of execution by the
parties if they have each executed the Agreement on the same
date. Otherwise, the "date of execution" or "execution date"
of this Agreement shall be defined as the date of execution
by the party last executing this Agreement,
(c) Distribution~. The phrase "distribution
date" shall be defined as ten (10) days from execution of
this Agreement, unless otherwise specified within the
Agreement.
3. EFFECTIVE ~ Ql AGREEMENT
This Agreement will become effective and binding
upon both parties upon execution of this Agreement by both of
them.
4. DIVORCE COMPLAINT
A complaint in Divorce shall be filed within thirty
(30) days of the signing of this Agreement in the Cour~ of
Common Pleas of cumberland Count, under Section 201 (C), said
3ction to :0 oaid ~or by ~i:3.
13
--
1'""'.
5. FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE
The parties have disclosed to each other they are
aware of the extent of each other's income, assets,
liabilities and estates by virtue of their delivery to each
other of Schedule "A" attached hereto and hereby made a part
hereof entitled "Sharon McMichael's Statement of Financial
Disclosure as of July 15, 1994" and Schedule "B" attached
hereto and made a part hereof entitled "Jeremy McMichael's
Statement of Financial Disclosure as of July 15, 1994". Both
parties acknowledge that said Schedules "A" and "B" have been
prepared principally by the parties hereto and are not
intended to represent precise accounting valuations but
rather good faith estimates by the parties.
6. MUTUAL RELEASES
Except as otherwise expressly provided by this
Agreement I
(a) Each party hereby absolutely and
unconditionally releases and forever discharges the other and
the estate of the other for all purposes from any and all
rights and obligations which either may have or at any time
hereafter have for past, present or future support of
maintenance, alimony pendente lite, alimony, equitable
distribution, counsel fees, costs/ expenses, and any other
right or Obligation. economic or other~ise, including all
~~.Jn:J 1nlj :end~:~j ~~:jJ~ ~~~ ?1~~S':~'!'~~1 ~:.:~~~~ ::1:9 :~
: ,lJ:: .'":.3 ;'.;~c~.-3:;le;,~,j 1.-.: l~,~nl~;;ler.-:.'j l~J v"~_ _ L; "::-.'::a:.- 1:-'"
IV-
""
.-..
.. ,
other law of any other jurisdiction, except and only axcl.lpl:
all rights, agreements and obligations of whatsoever nature
arising or which may arise under this Agreement or for the
breach of any provision thereof. Neither party shall have
any obligation to the other not expressly set forth herein.
(b) Each party hereby absolutely and
unconditionally releases and forever discharges the other and
his or her heirs, executors, administrators, assigns,
property and estate from any and all rights, claims, demands
or obligations arising out of or by virtue of the marital
relationship of the parties or otherwise, whether now
existing or hereafter arising. The above release shall be
effective regardless of whether such claims arise out of any
former or future acts, contracts, engagements or liabilities
of the other or by way of dower, curtesy, widow's or
widower's rights, family exemption or similar allowance, or
under the intestate laws, or the right to take against the
spouse's will, or the right to treat a lifetime conveyance by
the other as testamentary, or all other rights of a surviving
spouse to participate in a deceased spouse's estate, whether
ariSing under the laws of Pennsylvania, any state,
Commonwealth or territory of the United States, or any other
country. It is expressly understood, however, tha~ neither
the provisions of this release nor the subsequen~ en~=: or a
divorce decree are intendeu to dereat the =ight or either
:Ja=,,:'/ :: :'3t;3:"!'31r~'" ~;;J'''::'1r.''::'3
.......",....~~,~~ ,- ......l -4~\.,_... .... __.,
-- "".._-,,~ .. ...- ... -.. ~.. -,,-
Jt.'1t:l:"
'.r.':'::: :.-.~ ';:- ':~ _.j :."',.J ~.t:1'.:-'': .-=-'~."'~~_::'-'i:-" '~:""::'''''.~~
IS
.. .'
"""'
the beneticiary designation was made prior or subsequont to
execution hereof), nor to defeat the right of either party to
receive any legacy, bequest or residuary portion of the
other's estate under his or her Will, or to act as porsonal
representative or executor if so named by the will 01: the
other, whether such will was executed prior or subsequent to
this Agreement.
7. PERSONAL RIGHTS
Wife and Husband may and shall, at all times
hereafter, live separate and apart. Each shall be free from
any direct or indirect control, restraint, interference or
authority, by the other and shall be treated in all respects
as if they were unmarried. Except as otherwise provided for
in this Agreement, each may reside at such place of places as
he or she may from time to time choose or deem fit. Each
may, for his or her separate use or benefit, conduct, carry
on and engage in any business, occupation, prOfession or
employment and at such locations which to him or her may seem
advisable. Wife and Husband shall not molest, harass,
disturb or malign each other or the respective families,
friends, colleagues, employers or employees of each other or
compel or attempt to compel by any means the other to cohabit
or dwell in any manner whatsoever with him or her.
The Agreement is not in~ended to condone and sha:l no~
be deemed to be a condona~ion of the par~ of ~i~her par~1
he:'e':~ ::: 1;-:" lC~ :~ :.;~ ";,l:~ ..... :.",:.~ J':::8:' ":J:"~" '<ir.'..::!"'. :-;:1.:':
::GC:1S~~r::-~': -:.....} :':'J:::'~-:'::'; ::- ;r:~1.~!:" ::~:J:"3r.'.-:.~~~ .,~-~':;' ;.\'/.~
/(,
occurred prior or which may occur subsequent to tho datn of
execution of this Agreement.
8, CUSTODY/VISITATION AHa SUPPORT Qf MINOR ~LDB~N
(a) custody and Visitation
Husband and Wife agree that the best interests
of their minor children, Mark Andrew and Zachary James, are
served by a shared joint custody. Husband and wife further
agree that the best interests of their minor children are
best served, at this time, by Husband being the primary
physical custodian of the minor children. Accordingly,
Husband and Wife agree that Husband shall have principle
physical custody of the minor children, Mark Andrew and
Zachary James, with Wife afforded liberal visitation
including every other weekend from approximately 5:00 p.m. on
Friday until 6:00 p.m. on sunday, and each Tuesday from
approximately 5:00 p.m. until 8:00 a.m. the following day at
or about which time Wife shall deliver children to the day
care provider, and every other major Holiday (being defined
as Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve, Christmas, New Years Day,
Easter, Memorial Day, July 4, and Labor Day), and at such
other times as the parties shall mutually agree. It is
understood and agreed that the parties shall put for~h ever,
effort to accommodate the schedules and needs oe the ~ther i~
order to afford each party the maximum amount oe time .itn
-:::a :h~:j=~~. 1': :.3 ''':'J::~'J j? ::>1 '>l~~:';.'!:j. -. ~3 'lnd9=-1-":r:r~
1r.0:.1
IIJr~'~': -:.~.1:
-::..~ ;,::;.J'.:~..~
~ .....
'/~.j:':..l::":n :.~-; _~::Jr.'-':<2'~ -:.~ .~,.!
/7
'1
,-...
flexible and that the times listed are approximate and not
intended to necessarily be strictly followed, with the
understanding that neither party will do anything to
unnecessarily inconvenience the other.
It is further agreed that any major deciuion
regarding the education, health, safety or welfare of the
children, including the religious training, education, social
activities, and medical treatment of the children shall be
discussed between the parties to the greatest extent possible
and that no non-exigent major decision to alter the course of
any'of the above shall be made without the mutual consent of
the parties,
(b) suooort Q! Minor Children
Wife agrees to pay Husband the sum of $337.00
per month, effective september 1, 1994, in support of the
parties minor children, Said payment includes Wife's share
of child care payments. wife covenants and agrees to
continue to provide health insurance coverage for the minor
children through her employers policy. Should Wife cease to
be employed by her current employer for any reason, Wife
agrees to continue to provide health care coverage of equal
or greater benefit for the minor children through an
alternative plan, or, in the alternative Wife agrees to
reimburse Husband for such additional costs 38 mal be
necessary to add children to cover3ge through hi3 employ~~.
,=,'-,,,,,".
~::~:~~~!...:j ~~:.:
. :1.'--~ '~;:-.';. !-;:~,
,~
r\
Husband and Wife agree that, for the purposes of filing their
annual returns with the Internal Revenue service that any
unfiled returns as of the date of the making of this
Agreement shall include neither spouse as a dependent of the
other but that Husband shall claim Mark Andrew as a dependent
and Wife shall deolare Zachary James as a dependent.
9. EOUITABLE DISTRIBUTION Qf PROPERTY
(a) Motor Vehicles
With respect to the motor vehicles owned by
one or both of the parties, they agree as follows:
1. The 1987 Pontiac Grand AM shall
hereafter be the sole and exclusive property of Husband,
subjeot to any existing liens and encumbrances and the 1993
Hyundai Excel shall hereafter be the sole and exolusive
'.
property of Wife, subject of existing liens and enoumbranoes.
(b) aAnk Accounts
The parties agree and warrant that there are
no joint CheCking or savings accounts at any commercial bank,
savings and loan, credit union, private bank or other
finanoial institution at the time of the making of this
Agreement. The parties further agree that each savings
and/or checking account now held in either par~ies'
individual capacity shall be the exclusive and sole property
of said party and tha~ the other ~aives all claims that he ~r
she may have in said account.
: ?'3nS:'-::n-~9t:'=3men~ ?'.]~~ _ :~:.'!:d~
~: ::''lmenr. ,\C::O'Jn":"3,
',v'..: ~ 'w'il:"/95 H":,/ lr...:: L. _ _.-;:J:"'3S-: :::3:' 3;:~ '7h1':
N
r""\
ro..
have in Husband's pension, profit-sharinq, IRA and/or 401-K
plans and benefits by virtue of his employment. Husband
waives any and all interest that he may have in Wife'S
Individual Retirement Account and/or 401 (k) Plan, panMion,
profit-sharing, or other benefit by virtue of her employment
except as hereinafter provided. The parties aqree that any
such rights and/or benefits shall be and remain the sole and
exclusive property of the party now vested with such
right/benefit and each agrees to and hereby waives any claim
that he or she has or could have to such rights/benefits.
(d) Marital Premises
Husband shall have sole and exclusive
possession of the marital premises known as a 1991 Commodore
Mobile Home situate at Regency South Mobile Home Park at Lot
141, it being understood and agreed that within thirty (30)
days of the signing of this Agreement a qualified appraisal
of said mobile home shall be made at Husband's expense, and
Husband shall within thirty (30) days following the date of
.
appraisal obtain a commitment for financing to the maximum
limit of the lending institution take sole ownerShip of said
mobile home. It is further understood and agreed that Wife
will fully cooperate in the process of conveyancing and
financing the same and ~ill timely execute any and all
documents necessary to accomplish said transfer, It is
further agreed that, should Husband be able to obtain
~~nanci~a ~~ 1n l~CU~~ ?=3a~3~ :~an
;~==g~~:l :'~a,~ =~
... ...-., "
I... .....-:
~t 1n JU:~:3~~:~~ ~C~J lnJ ~cr~~3aa :: ~~ll: 3~~~, :~J
2..0
. ,I ,
-.
-
difference will be distributed in the following mannerl
1. the first $1,850 to Donald and Pauline Myers, and
2. the remainder evenly divided between the parties.
(e) Personal Procertv
Husband and Wife do hereby acknowledge and agree
that they have heretofore divided or so marked and identified
between them any and all of the furniture, furnishings, rugs,
carpets, household equipment and appliances, pictures, books,
jewelry, musical instruments and household goods of whatever
nature situated in the marital residence. Wife's
identification of those items of personal property which
shall be transferred to her pursuant to this Agreement are
attached hereto as Schedule "C". Hereafter, Wife agrees that
all of the above property in the possession of Husband or so
marked and identified as belonging to Husband shall be the
sole and separate property of Husband. Husband agrees that
all of the above property in the possession of Wife or so
marked and identified as belonging to Wife, inCluding those
items identified on Schedule "C", shall be the sole and
separate property of Wife. Each of the parties does hereby
specifically waive, release, renounce and forever abandon
whatever claims, if any, he or she may have with respect to
any of the above property which is the sole and separate
properti of the other,
2/
......
.-.
10. SEPARATE ASSETS
Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement,
each party shall keep and retain sole ownership, control and
enjoyment of all property transferred to him or her purflllflllt
to this Agreement, all of the jewelry, clothes, furniture,
musical instruments, and other personal property titled in
his or her name or in his or her possession and all bank
accounts, securities, insurance pOlicies, pensions (inclUding
any benefits and other sums payable thereon), any Social
Security benefits to which Husband or Wife would have been
entitled to by virtue of his or her marriage to the other,
financial interests, or other intangible property held in his
or her name and he or she shall have the exclusive right to
dispose of such property without interference or restraint by
the other as if the marriage had not taken place and he or
she had remained unmarried.
Each party shall indemnify the other and hold him
or her harmless from any liability, cost or expense,
inclUding attorney's fees, which is incurred in connection
with the interests and/or assets referred to in this
Paragraph.
11. WARRANTY AS IQ EXISTING OBLIGATIONS
During the course of the marriage, Wife ~nd Husband
:1J','q ~;",,;c'.l::-:'9d :::e=--:.]:~ ~':'];::~::'''::':3S lr.r~ :.: :'3 :1erQC'/ 10::-3e11
~::~cu~ ~~e ~ecaS5::Y J~ JS\:3r~a:~~~~ ~:: ~na: :ur~cse
l~' .
..-
2l
"""
r".
for whose use each of the bills was incurred, that of those
liabilities that were incurred prior to the date of the
execution of this Agreement, Wife and Husband each covenants,
represents, warrants and agrees that except as may be
otherwise specifically provided for by the terms of this
Agreement, no unpaid liabilities remain which were incurred
by him or her on his or her behalf for Which the other party
may be deemed liable I and, if any such debts or obligations
should be determined to have existed as of the date of
execution of this Agreement, or thereafter, except as set
forth below, the party who incurred that debt shall indemnify
and hold the other party harmless for and against any loss or
liability and costs or expense, including attorney's fees,
incurred as a result of those liabilities.
Those liabilities known to the parties to exist at the time
of the making of this Agreement are set forth here and made
the sole and exclusive responsibility of the party so
indicated. The other party hereby agrees to indemnify and
hold harmless the other for any and all liability for the
samel
SHARON: Members First FCU Auto Loan
Account Number 108662-05
Members First FeU Visa
Account Number 4121-4499-9LOl-6625
Sears Charge (Acct.i5-58972-61889-Ji
JEREMY: PNC Bank Mobile Home Loan
'-can ~Iumbe!:' 10-'1:-J009JO, ;~~
'""".
I'"""
Members First FCU Auto Loan
Account Number 108662-02
Members First FCU Line of credit
Account Number 108662-01
contingent liability for Lot rental for
mobile home
Montgomery Ward charge
Account Number 112-086-552
Each party agrees to, within one year of the date of this
Agreement, obtain new financing for the above outstanding
obligations so that the obligation is in the name of the
party agreed to be responsible only and all encumbrance,
obligation, lien or other attachment to the other is
extinguished completely and forever.
12. WARRANTY AS IQ FUTURE OBLIGATIONS
Wife and Husband each covenants, represents,
warrants and agrees that except as may be otherwise
specifically provided for by the terms of this agreement,
neither of them shall hereafter incur any liabilities
whatsoever for which the other or the estate of the other may
be liable, and each now and at all times hereafter shall
indemnify and hold the other party harmless from and against
any such liabilities, costs or expenses, including attorneys'
fees, relating thereto, incurred by the other party after the
date of execution of this Agreement.
1 J , WAIVER QE ALIMON'{
:iuSCJr:\~ lr.t.1,Y~:1 :c ,id~'~r:':, ~'l_':.:, ::.;;~1J,il~.': ::.
J~ In'! :::...:n:.:; .;n~;~ 1:'-:'.-:'.~: ::1.:1': .~.j':') 1';1:'.;:.3": :.~]:-:.""'3::'" ::
2Lf
~,
"""
J..j
receive alimony or other post-divorce maintenance or support.
It shall be, from the execution date of this Agreement, the
sole responsibility of each of the respective parties to
sustain themselves without seeking any support from tho othBr
party.
14. AFTER ACOUIRED PROPERTY
Each of the parties shall hereafter own and enjoy,
independently of any claim or right of the other, all items
of property, be they real, personal or mixed, tangible or
intangible, which are acquired by him or her after execution
of this Agreement, with full power in him or her to dispose
of the same as fully and effectively, in all respects and for
all purposes, as though he or she were unmarried.
15. ATTORNEYS' ~ fQR ENFORCEMENT
In the event that either party breaches any
provision of this Agreement and the other party retains
counsel to assist in enforcing the terms thereof, the parties
hereby agree that the breaching party will pay all attorneys'
fees, incurred by the other party in enforcing the Agreement.
16. EFFECT QI DIVORCE DECREE
The parties agree that unless other~ise
snecifically provided herein, this Agreement shall coneinue
in full force and effect after such time as a final decree in
divorce is entered ~ith respect to the parties.
17. AGREEMENT ill lli: :~CORP()RAT::O r:f DIVORC::: DEC~E!
~~.9 'Ji1:--::?'S 1\~~:~ :::.1': 1 ::-:r:'/ :: :::':'J .\~.::r)l;;!!':ltdr.:
"ii~,)_~ '::0 ~:H':Jrr;crl:'-1'~ ;~~.; 1:'.'," :: :'::---::~ ~d'::-:~'? ~.~::;: ...:
r'"'\
1"\
entered with respect to them. The parties further agree that
the court of Common Pleas which may enter such divorce decree
shall retain continuing jurisdiction over the parties and the
subject matter of the Agreement for the purpose of
enforcement of any of the provisions thereof, unless another
court has jurisdiction to enforce the provisions of this
Agreement.
18. WAIVER QE MODIFICATION rQ ~ IN WRITING
No modification or waiver of any of the terms
hereof shall be valid unless in writing and signed by both
parties and no waiver of any breach hereof or default
hereunder shall be deemed a waiver of any subsequent default
of the same or similar nature.
19. MUTUAL COOPERATION
Each party shall, at any time and from time to time
hereafter, take any and all steps to execute, acknowledge and
deliver to the other party within a reasonable period of time
any and all further instruments and/or documents that the
other party may reasonably require for the purpose of giving
full force and effect to the provisions of this Agreement.
20. ~ QE PENNSVLVANIA APPLICABLE
This Agreement shall be construed in accordance
'I/ith the laws of the Commonwealth or Pennsylvania,
'.
;~~"~~..\,::' :~I'!'~~~R::':.\:': :~,
~
~
. " ,
For purposes of contract interpretation and for the
purpose of resolving any ambiguity herein, Husband and Wife
agree that this Agreement was prepared jointly by their
respective attorneys.
22. AGREEMENT BINDING YfQH HEIRS
Except as specifically provided herein, this
Agreement shall be binding upon and shall inure to the
benefit of the parties hereto and their respective heirs,
executors, administrators, successors and assigns.
23. INTEGRATION
This Agreement constitutes the entire understanding
of the parties and supersedes any and all prior agreements
and negotiations between them. There are no other
representations, terms, covenants, conditions, agreements or
warranties, express or implied, oral or written of any nature
whatsoever, other than those expressly set forth herein.
24. HQ WAIVER gr DEFAULT
This Agreement shall remain in full force and
effect unless and until terminated under and pursuant to the
terms of this Agreement. The failure of either party to
insist upon strict performance of any of the provisions of
this Agreement shall in no way affect the right of such party
hereafter to enforce the same, nor shall the waiver of any
breach of any provision hereof be construed as a waiver of
any subsequent default of the same or similar nature, nor
3na:: :: =e =ons:=~ed JS 1 ~a:~~:
J:=:;: ~~=:~:~3~C.l ;:
Iny ~t~e~ Jc~:?a~:;n ~e=~:~.
27
,-.,
~,
26. SEVERABILITY
If any term, condition, olause or provision of this
Agreement shall be determined or deolared to be void or
invalid in law or otherwise, then only that term, condition,
clause or provision shall be stricken from this Agreement and
in all other respects this Agreement shall be valid and
continue in full force, effect and operation likewise, the
failure of any party to meet her or his obligations under any
one or more of the paragraphs herein shall in no way void or
alter the remaining obligations of the parties,
26. HEADINGS fiQ ~ QE AGREEMENT
Any headings preceding the text of the several
paragraphs and subparagraphs hereof are inserted solely for
convenience of reference and ahall not constitute a part of
this Agreement nor shall they affect its meaning,
construction or effect.
27. COUNTERPARTS
This Agreement may be executed in counterparts,
each of which will be an original and which together shall
constitute one and the same instrument.
28
,")
/'""'
. ,.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have set their
hands and seals the day and year first above written.
2 '7
il~ ?fi2
9.tdZtd ~
tnesB
'/
'.
J::H: ~ ~.,i..r
J em . MeM ehael
....,
(i.:?-,., ,/ I
. Il.'" ,I. ,... /.Y ':./ (" ,'<j,tf' .. .
. ....~.~ I,' '. __ _ ,.'
Sharon E. MeM ehael
1""\
'""'
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF ('''.....I...L..,{.-, Q
IS
On this, the
}'-day of a~f""~/" , 1994,
v
public for the Commonwealth of
before me, a Notary
Pennsylvania, residing in the County of Cumberland,
personally appeared Jeremy J. McMichael, known to me to be
the person whose name is subscribed to the within Agreement
and acknowledged that he executed the same for the purposes
therein contained.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and
off icial seal.
":n'elJJoll I
. '.." ' . . 1:." ~'"~l'/!5.,\,o'''
,\ .. " -"" "'.. r.....
;.~. ...... :~~,.d....ar: ,;'''.
, .'" "..... '''~J
..... . . ........"
-.......,-..---.-
f..:r:::r.j<tJ(U'Wi,i.t.a,.,.~li.ilt~
$tttf dA~
!I Not,try PUbfio
.30
.' ,I I
"..."
r--
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA :
COUNTY OF D ~ ~1'v\A.v :
ss
On this, the -L day of ~.+-
, 1994, before
me, a Notary PUblic for the commonwealth of pennsylvania,
r
residing in the County of 0 ,,~. ~ ....... , personally
appeared Sharon E. McMichael, known to me to be the person
whose name is subscribed to the within Agreement and
acknowledged that she executed the same for the purposes
therein contained.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto, set my hand and official
seal.
o~ e~~~
Notary Publ c
~IOIARIAL SE/lL
ELLEN ROSENBLOOM, Nc~ary PubliC
H.\lrl$OU~,l)3u~nln \;0U"l'f
My C~mll\l$!l~n E.olres M3't 8. 1995
. . t ,
. .-..,
--
Schedule B: Sharon McMlchael's Statement of Financial Disclosure as of September
12. 1994
Awt1
Automobile: 1993 Hyundal Excel
CheCking Account: Members 1st FCU '119399
Estimated Value: S8.000
Estimated Value: S300,OO
~
Members 1st FCU 1108662.mc.05: Auto loan: Principal 8alance: S7.678,60
Members 1st FCU Visa: Account '4121449991086625 Prlnc1pal Balance: S686.11
Sears Charge: Account 15.58972.61889.3 Principal Balance: S500,OO
Ch11d Support: 'Currently pa1d at the rate of 5337.00 per month,
Jnccme
Current net Income on a bl-weekly schedule Is S518.83.
:.''?' :
;~Jg-tvS-~t~ SeO :sc~: ~n-3 .~: ~ee2It: vs. 2: oJS
32-
ro.
, ,
..-,
Schedule Bl Jeremy McMichael's Statement of Financial Disclosure
as of July 15, 1994.
Assets
Mobile Home I 1991 Commodore Capewood
Estimated valuel $40,000.
Estimated valuer $ 4,000.
Automobile I 1967 Pontiac Grand AM
savings account I Members 1st FCU #140622-00 Estimated valuel $65,
CheCking accountl Members 1st FCU #140622-11 Estimated valuel $750.
Liabilities
PNC Bank t30-02-3009303346/ Mobile home loan/ Principal balancel
$35,000.
Members lst FCU #106662-01/ Line of Credit/ Principal balancel
$ 4,950,
Members 1st FCU #106662-02/ Auto loan/ Principal balancel
$ 2,000.
Regency Southl Lot R~nt/ currently paid at a rate of $245./month
Montgomery Ward credit card,#ll2-066-552/ Principal balance I
$ 1,100,
Income
Current net income received on a bi-weekly schedule is $552.02.
33
" .
,.-..,
,.-.
SCHBDULB "C"
Wife .hall be entitled to remove from the marital premises
and have as her own subject to the provisions above mentioned
all of the following I
1) stereo, tapes and CDs
2) Dresser
3) Gold Mirror
4) Coffee and End Table
5) Collectibles as agreed
6) Plant stand
7) Cookware as agreed
8) crib
9) Microwave cart
10) Patio furniture
11) pictures/wall hangings as agreed
12) Christmas decorations as agreed
13) suitcases as agreed
;5!; ,-.. ,...
. ~..'
:c .,
C>- !.' l ;
", " .,
r.J ,
,
~ "
,
...., "
~ ,. ~,
v
" .
.
'-.I
"-'
,-
'"""\
_lft<>aD<>aD< ~ - *<,.~
--~-----~---~~~----
.
~
~
.
.
~
~
.
.
.
.
~..".. ,..,.., ,,' '
.
, ..",,rt;Rt;HY...J.,..,HctHCHAEL,. '
.
, ................., '
i
~
.
.
;
.
I
~
,
.
~
~
~
,
.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
STATE OF .. PENNA.
SI.1AROti !,:"McMICHAEL,
I
" II
I
N (), .......9.1~}.'140..,c,1.y.,l..l, 1994
PIa inti ff '
Versus
Defendant
DECREE IN
AND NOW. u~~' ~ ~ ~ ,: :.~.. It I. ordered ond
decreed that ,."""".". .1?11}\,~QI;J, ,1;" ,t-fs=J1TCI1^E~, . ,.. , . . . , ., plaintiff.
and. .. .. .. ,.., .... .... , , .. , v,r;II~fof.Y..-1.. ..t1c;~l.C;IJH1-l . .. .. .. .., defendant.
are divorced from the bonds of matrimony.
The court retalnl jurisdiction of the following c1alml which have
been rolled of record in this action for which a final order has not yet
b.en entered; NONE
D y T
....., ..T.ll11l..<\gr~,e,l1)'i!l1,t. ,Qf. .I\lJ<;J11,S,~, 7,2"" J.9,9.1.}A .l)~,
....... .i.l'l~9, ,t;I}l,1.F:\l)il.1. ,1?tY,(m~r-, ,1)'?9.r.qef: ,~,~,'.,....
, "'''a'' ,......,(1.. ',:.1....'
AlIelll (W.I-U1Ul.,.. c.. ~I'" ' ..~ J.
7~r: t!(j;ttl.-/;I,--,~, J~ I ~
Prolhonol.ry
.
.
.
.
,
.
..
8
*
8
~
.
.
t
.
.
.
.
.
"
.,
~
.
~
-
.
.
8
iii
,
8
8
8
~
8
~
~
~
~
_'-'''.,''' .. -.-..-... _ ., ,lK<J4IIX:_ ;4Co:* ;...--;w.-:-..;".-..:-J
!,\
.,.-.." ,
.
:1/ q J l.1- / W1 S
SHARON E. McMICHAEL,
PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL,
DEFENDANT/PETITIONER
.
.
: 94-3440 CIVIL TERM
~
AND NOW, this "l.-1..- day of August, 1995, a Rule Is entered against Sharon
E. McMichael to show cause why she should not be adjudged In contempt of court.
Rule returnable at a hearing to be held In Courtroom No.2, Cumberland County
Courthouse at 2:30 p.m" Thursday, September 28, 1995, at which time Sharon E.
MoMlohaells ordered to appear,
By the Court, , ,~/'
I
J
Sharon E. McMichael Riddle
R. D, 21 v.o" ct'"l.
Dover, PA 17316
Plaintiff/Respondent
Charles A. Gerow, Esquire
For DefendanVPetltloner
-"
)
(!~u.., (hl~J(.(l b' I ;lo1./ ~5"
.A.f .
:saa
36
AUG 22 10 00 rlH f95
. ',![flU/:
'.' ' . . " ,IO"OL~H
"~'" ii,4NQ COLl~n
. . '!IW:LV,\~,
....J
.
'-'
I (
"
..-.,
~I ..
~I '''1.5
SHARON E. McMICHAEL
Plaintiff, Respondent
vs.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
NO. 94-3440 civil 1994
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL
Defendant, Petitioner
ORDER
'lou, Sharon (McMiohael) Riddle, respondeantt, must appnear
in person in court on i
Room cumberland Co. Courthouse.
IF YOU DO NOT APPEAR IN PERSON, THB COURT NAY I88UB A WARRANT
FOR YOUR ARRBST AND YOU NAY BB COMMI'l"I'BD TO JAIL.
If the court finds that you have willfully failed to
comply with its order for support, you may be found to
be in contempt of court and committed to jail, fined or
both.
DATE OF ORDER 1
BY THE COURT I
Judge
"
37
'\ .
1"'"'\
...
SHARON E. McMICHAEL
Plaintiff, Respondent
vs.
I
I
I
I
I
I
NO. 94-3440 civil 1994
JF.REHY J. McMICHAEL
Defendant, Petitioner
NOTICE
Legal proceedings have been brought against IOU
alleging, a~ng other things, you have willfully d sobeyed an
order of court for support.
If you wish to defend against the claim set forth in the
following pages, you may but are not required to file in
writing with the Court your defenses or objections.
YOU SHOULD TAKE TillS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO
NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CAIfIIOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE
THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET
LEGAL HELP I
Court Administrator
4th Floor, Cumberland Co. Courthouse
carlisle, PA 17013
(717)-240-6200
."""1
,.-..
,
SHARON E. McMICHAEL,
Plaintiff
vs.
1
1
1 NO. 94-3440 civil 1994
:
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL,
Defendant
PETITION FOR CONTEMPT
TO THE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT:
The Petition of original Defendant, Jeremy J. McMichael,
respectfully represents that:
1. Petitioner, Jeremy J. McMichael, is an individual
residing at #41 Regency South Mobile Home Park, Carlisle,
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
2. Respondent, Sharon E. (McMichael) Riddle, is an
individual residing at R.D. 21, Dover, York county,
Pennsylvania.
3. On or about October 12, 1994, a Decree in Divorce was
entered by the Honorable Edgar B. Bailey. Attached to
said Decree and made a part thereof was an Agreement of
August 22, 1994, directing, inter alia, respondent to pay
the sum of $337.00 per month for the support of the minor
children, Mark Andrew and Zachary James.
31
1'""'\
{\
4. Respondent has steadfastly refused to honor her
obligations in this regard and is not complying with said
Order and has willfully failed and/or refused to pay in
accordance with the Order of this Honorable Court.
5. The arrearages under the Order amount to $2,298.00
as of August 1, 1995.
6. Despite repeated warnings from counsel regarding the
importance of fulfilling her obligations and
responsibilities for the support of her children,
Respondent has refused to do so. Despite demands for
payment, Respondent has likewise refused to make such
payments.
7. Respondent is able to comply with the Order entered by
your Honorable Court.
8. The Agreement made a part of this Honorable Courts
Divorce Decree further gave rights of shared joint
custody of the minor children and set up a specifio
sohedule of visitation and physioal oustody.
'1-0
........,
/"'""\
9. Since the entering of the Decree in Divorce, Respondent
has in all manners refused to fulfill her obligations and
responsibilities for custody of and visitation with the
minor children. She has, instead, chosen to perform her
duties only when convenient and has refused even the
common courtesies of advance notice to Petitioner,
choosing instead to rely on Petitioner as a free-of-
charge babysitter,
WHEREFORE, Petitioner prays that a Rule be granted on
Respondent to show why she should not be held in contempt
of Court for failure to comply with said Order of
Support and to further show cause why she should not be
held in contempt with respect to custody and visitation
of the minor children and to further show cause why the
provisions with respect to custody and visitation should
not be vacated.
Respectfully submitted I
DYI
CHAR
4125 Charles Roa
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
717-975-3536
Attorney I.D. #32868
Counsel for Potitioner
'1/
1"'\
. ,
VERIFICATION
I verifY that the statements made in this Petition for
contempt are true and correct. I understand that false
statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.
Cons. stat. Section 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to
authorities.
-F-1I1 if IJnt ~'1A1
Petitioner
'fl
m
"
:-.::
....... '.,
i
'.I
;J'
<71
L.,
fJ
......;.
,-..,)
'-'
1'"\,
1''\
SHARON E. McMICHAEL,
PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL,
DEFENDANT/PETITIONER
94-3440 CIVIL TERM
~
AND NOW, this 5th day of October, 1995, following a hearing, IT IS
ORDERED:
(1) The petition to hold Sharon E. (McMichael) Riddle In contempt for failing to
comply with the custody provisions In a marital settlement agreement that was
Incorporated Into a final decree In divorce by an order of October 11, 1994, IS
DENIED. The mother, however, from this date forward, shall provide the father at
least five (5) days notice when she Is not going to exercise her temporary physical
custody rights,
(2) A petition to hold Sharon E. (McMichael) Riddle In contempt for not
carrying medical coverage on the parties' two children IS DENIED since the children
are being covered free In a government program. Should that free coverage cease,
the mother shall be responsible, as per the order of October 11, 1994, to either
provide health Insurance coverage through an employer's policy or reimburse the
father for such additional cost as may be necessary to add the children to health
Insurance coverage through his employer,
l/J
II
r",
1""\
(3) Sharon E. (McMichael) Riddle Is adjudicated In contempt for failure to pay
regularly $337 per month for the support of her two minor children as per the order of
October 11, 1994. The mother shall purge herself of contempt by hereafter timely
making such payments together with $50.00 per month on account of arrearages,
I
,II
,
( \
Sharon E. (McMichael) Riddle
R. D. 21, Box 97
Dover, PA 17315
Plaintiff/Respondent
_ ~~~'''('''(''-c..,t.. /6/"'19$'
.....s. -(l .
Charles R. Gerow, Esquire
For DefendanVPetltloner
Domestic Relations Office
:saa
.2.
'-14
Ocr 5 3 ~5 fH '95
: I J!'f
t' ~i " ';" A!t 'f
r';!' -ip 11 r
.
\.
.......,
~.
.",
t""\
rJ
.
"
,
.
IKJ11IU:O.u Rl~O"'.1:0l\1l\10IULEAS~E
_CUl\1DERLANDf:OUNIY .1'ENNSl'LYAlSJA
SIIARON .:, Mcl\lICIIAU./ RllmU:
I'LAINTIJlIi.
VS.
CUSTODY
JEREMV J, McI\IICIIM:L
m:....:NDANT.
94-3440 CIVil, TERM
ORDER
AND NOW. 10 wll.this
day of
, 1995 based uJlon this foregoing
Petition it is hereby ORDERED AND DECREED that the Office of Domestic Relations in
Cumberland County shall oJlen a file and set an Order in the amount 01'$337,00 per week;
and they shall also schedule a Modification lIearing Ihr purposes of determining the
present and proper amount of child support
BY THE COURT,
J
.
'f~
""'"
I"".
"
I
~
IN Tilt.; COlIIHOl" COMMON l'Lt.;AS O}l
CUJ\lUt.;RLAND l'OllNT\' ,l'EN NS\'L VANIA
SIlARON .:, MrI\IICIlM:L/IUUIH.':
I.LAINTIJi...,
VS,
ClISl'OUY
JEREMY J, Mrl\lICIIM:L
lU:n:NUANT,
94-3440 CIVIL TERM
l'J::TITlONfon.Sl'J::CIAUU:LlEl~
(I~I'
ANI> NOW, 10 wit, this ...... ___ day of No\'cl11hcr, IlJlJS ,omes the Plaintiff,
Sharon Riddle, by and thlllugh her counsel, Linda M Gross, Esquire who files this
Petition for Special relief and in support thereof states as tbllows
Petitioner is Sharon Riddle, (herein aller referred to as "Mother"),an adult
individual who presently resides at R D.# 21 Box 97, Dover, York County. Pennsylvania,
1731S
2
Respondent is Jeremy J McMichael. (herein aner referred 10 as "Father"), an adult
individual who presently resides at 41 Regency Street, Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013,
3
The panics were married and subsequcntly divorced by Decree of the Coun of
ComlllDn Pleas ulTumberland County. I'ennsylvnnia The Divorce Decree of October II,
1994 incorporatcd thc terms of a Marital Settlcmcnt Agrecml'nt dated August 22, 1994
A copy of the Agrccmcnt is llttached hcrctomarked as exhibit "A" an incorporated by
relerence hercin
4
The parties arc the palcnlsoftwo minor children, namely Mark Andrew
McMichaelllnd ZlIchalY James McMlchllcl The parties ShlllC l.egal cusludy and Primary
r-,
f""'"
,
"
Physical Custody ofthc childrcn is with Fathcr Mothcr hils rights OfPIl11ialPhysical
Cuslody as sct forth morc fully in paragraph II of thc Agrccmcnt
5
In addition. thc partics Ilgrccd in pllrugl'llph IIh ofthc Maritlll Scttlcmcnt
Agrccmcntthllt Mothcr would PIlY thc sum 01'$ .H700 Jlcr month as child support,
6
Whcn Mothcr WIlS cmploycd filii timc, shc WIlS ablc tomcct thc agrccd upon
amount of support 1I0wcvcr, subscqucntto thc cntry of thc Divorcc Dccrcc, Mothcr
bccamc uncmploycd Ilnd was collccting uncmploymcnt compcnsation in thc amount of
$188,00 pcr wcck As a rcsult, Mothcr was notllblc to mcct hcr full obligation pursuant
to thc Marital SClllcmcnt Agrccmcnt
7
As a rcsult of Fathcr's liIing of a Pctilion for Enlbrccmcnt and Contcmpt ofthc
Marital Scttlcmcnt Agrccmcntnnd Divorcc Dccrcc, an Ordcr wns cntcrcd by this Court, a
copy of which is nttllched hcrcto mnrkcd as cxhibit "II" Dcspitc Mothcr's argumcntthat
shc was uncmploycd and as n rcsult. shc should bc cntitled to nlcmpDrnry rcduction in hcr
support obligntion. thc Court rcfltscd hcr requcst
II
Mothcr hns rcpeatedly rcqucstcd thllt Fllthcr nllow hcr to procccd to pay hcr
support through thc npproprilltc Court chnnncl. nllmely thc Domestic Relations Office of
the Court of Common PICllS of York County which would thcn in turn, forward paymcnts
to thc Cumcrland County Domcstic Rclations Scction
l)
Dcspltc this rcqucst. Fathcr has rclltscd to COOpcflltc in any rcgard.
1f7
"",
f"',
"
,
.
10
The 11ennsylvllnia Supreme Court has established guidelincs for the payment of
child support. Based on these guidelines, IInd Mother's unemployment compensation,
Mother would be entitled to a reduction in her child support Ilowever, Mother is being
denied due process orlllW,
II
Mother hils requested that she be entitled 10 open a DR 0 tile in either York
County or Cumberland County for purposes of paying her child support payments Her
requests have bccn dcnied by both York County and Cumberland County's Omce of
Domestic Relations claiming that a DelendantmllY not opcnll child support case.
12
Although it is unusual for a Dcfendllnt to request payment of child support through
the Omce of Domestic Rclations. Delendllnt cllnnot be denied thc same rights and services
ofthe Domestic Relations Ollice as are provided to I'laintill's
13
Mother is willing to allow the Ollice of Domestic Relations to determine an
appropriate amount of support
14
Case law has clearly established that a child support amount set in a Marital
Settlement Agreement is not set in stone and may be modi lied through the liIing by the
Plaintill' for an increllse or a modilication through an Ollice of Domestic Relations This
law should equlllly IIpply to II Delendant who requests tllllt an amount of support be
reduced where II pllyor sullers linllncial hardships
IS
Nowhere in the Agreement do the terms prevent a request to modify the amount of
support
1"\
r'
.
.
..
ICl
Although the child support amount in this case may not be signif1canl based upon,
Mother's $188.00 per week unemployment compensation, she is not in a position to pay
the total amounl Mother fears that her continued inability to comply with the Divorce
Decree and Agreement, will put her in a position where she may nnd herself in Contempt
of Court and nnd herself in prison
17.
It is patently unfair to allow Plaintiffs the benents ofthe Office of Domestic
Relations and deny Defendants the same benelits
18
A Marital Settlement Agreement is a contract and Mother does not dispute that,
However, if Mother were to request a Modilication in the child custody provisions of the
agreement, Mother would then be allowed to proceed through the Custody Courts in an
eflbrtto seek what she believes would be u filiI' and rellsonable child custody Order. I do
not believe the Court would disagree in this regard.
l'l
Likewise, with the support matter, a party should have a right, whether they are a
I'laintifl' or Defendant the request thllt the proper channel of the Court address her child
support matter
20
In addition. Mother believes that the payment of child support through the Office
of Domestic Relations will provide Father with lIdditional enlhrcement benefits if she fails
to pay pursuant to lIny Order Furthellnllle. Mother will then be IIssured that II proper
accounting of her payments will result lInd. she will be assured that she is paying the
proper amount and that her payments are being credited III her account
21
'Ii
r-.
.
As a resull ufthe fhreguing, MUlher respeetlillly requests Ihut lhis Ilunorable
Court direct Ihe Olllee uf[)umestie RcllIlluns in Cumberland Cuunty open a flIe and selan
Order in the amount 01'$33700 per week Silllulluneously wilh lhis Order, Mother
respecUully requests thut the Court of Conullonl'leus uf Cumberlund ('ounty schedule a
Modil1cution Heuring for purpuses of delenllining the presenl und proper IImounl of child
support.
Un ~ M. Gross, Esquire
52 outh Duke Slreel
York, PA 17401
(717) 852-7232
Supreme Court 1011 58999
j-O
'"""
t"'\
.
AGREEMENT
This Aqrsement ie made this ~1.~o day of AlJlt'fltr, 1994
by and between JEREMY J. McMICHAEL of cumberland county,
pennsylvania ("Husband") and SHARON E. McMICHAEL of
cumberland county pennsylvania ("Wife").
WIT N E SSE T HI
WHEREAS, the parties hereto are Husband and Wife, having
been married on November 26, 1988 at New Bloomfield, perry
county, pennsylvania,
WHEREAS, Husband and wife are the parents of two
.
children, Mark Andrew McMiohael, born May 4, 1990 and Zaohary
James MoMiohael, born september 17, 1992' and
WHEREAS, certain unhappy differences, disputes,
misunderstandings and difficulties have arisen between the
parties and the parties have deoided that their marriage is
irretrievably broken, that it is their intention to live
separate and apart for the rest of their natural lives, that
they are desirous of settling fully and finally all of their
respective finanoial and property rights and obligations as
betwesn each other including, without limitation, by
speoifioationl
(1) the settling of all matters between them
relating to the ownership of real and personal property
inoluding property heretofore or subsequently acquired by
either party,
(2) the settling of all matters relating to
custody, visitation and support of tho minor children of the
/ ./11 \! 1 \ "11.'
!it
.
r"'o.
-,
(
.
parties,
(3) the Aettling of all disputes, rights and/or
interests between them arising out of or by reason of their
marriage including but not limitsd to the past, present, and
.
future support, alimony, counsel fees, costs or maintenance
of Wife by Husband or of Husband by wife/ and
(4) in general, the settling of any and all actual
and possible claims by each party against the other or
against their respective estates.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the premises and of
the mutual promises, covenants and undertakings set forth in
this Agreement and for other good and valuable consideration,
the receipt and adequacy of which is hereby acknowledged by
each of the parties hereto, Wife and Husband, each intending
to be legally bound hereby, covenant and agree as followsl
1. ADVICE Qf COUNSEL
The provisions of this Agrsement and their legal
effect have been fully explained to the parties by their
respective counsel, Judy calkin, Esquire, for wife and
Charles Gerow, Esquire, for Husband. Each party acknowledges
the fact that they have received independent legal advice
trOll COlUJlel ot his or h4r ,o!fIIJtlfln 1JfJ!J tflJJt t/J/lt! filJ J '/
~ . .... .. ....,
understands the facts and has been fully informed as to his
or her legal rights and obligations and each party accepts
that this Agreeme t i
n s, under the circumstances, fair and
equitable and that it is being entered into freely and
voluntarily after having received such advice and with such
52-
.-
{'\
(
.
result of any collusion or improper or illegal agreement or
agreements.
2. DEFINITIONS
(a) Divorce~. The phrase "Divoroe Code" shall
.
be defined as Act No. 1980-26, 23 P.S. 101 ~ ~., as
amended.
(b) I2W gf. j!:lIecution 2! .th1a Aqreement. The
phrase "date of exeoution" or "exeoution date" of this
Agreement shall be defined as the date of execution by the
parties if they have eaoh exeouted the Agreement on the same
date. Otherwise, the "date of exeoution" or "exsoution date"
of this Agreement shall be defined as the date of execution
by the party last executing this Agreement.
(0) Distribution 12W. The phrase "distribution
date" shall be derined as ten (10) days from execution of
this Agreement, unless otherwise specified withJn the
Agreement.
3. EFFECTIVE ~ Q.E AGREEMENT
This Agreement will become effective and binding
upon both parties upon execution of this Agreement by both of
them.
4. DIVORCE COMPLAINT
A complaint in Divorce shall be filed within thirty
(30) days of the signing of this Agreement in the court of
Common Pleas of Cumberland county under Section 201 (c), said
action to be paid for by Wife.
53
~
-,
5. FINANCIAL pISCLOSURE
The parties have disclcsed to eaoh other they are
aware of the extent of each other's inoome, assets,
liabilities and estates by virtue of their delivery to eaoh
.
other of schedule IIAII attached hereto and hsreby made a part
llereof entitled IISharon McMichael's statement of Financial
Disclosure as of July 15, 1994" and Schedule IIBII attached
hereto and made a part hereof entitled IIJeremy McMichael's
statement of Financial Disolosure as of July 15, 199411. Both
partiss acknowledge that said Sohedules IIAII and IIBII have been
prepared principally by the parties hereto and are not
intended to represent precise accounting valuaclons cur
rather good faith estimates by the parties.
6. ~TUAL ~ELEASES
Exoept as otherwise expresslY provided by this
Agreement:
(a) Each party hereby absolutely and
w"''''ll.t.te.t.m-all}' :-wl~ .and LorBver tffachltrges tbe otber and
the estate of the other tor all purposes from any and all
rights and Obligations which either may have or at any time
hereafter have for past, present or future support of
maintenance, alimony pendente lite, alimony, equitable
distribution, counsel fees, costs, expenses, and any other
right or Obligation, economic or otherwise, inoluding all
rights and benefits under the Pennsylvania Divorce Code of
1980, its supplements and amendments, as well .as under any
Sf
.......
I"'.
,
other law of any othe~ jurisdiotion, exoept and only exoept
all rights, agreemants and obligations of whatsoever nature
arising or whioh may arise under this Agreement or tor the
breaoh ot any provision thereof. Neither party shall have
.
any obligation to the other not expressly set forth herein.
(b) Eaoh party hereby absolutely and
unconditionally releases and forever discharges the other and
his or her heirs, exeoutors, administrators, assigns,
property and estate from any and all rights, olaims, demands
or obligations arising out of or by virtue of the marital
rslationship of the parties or otherwise, whether now
existing or hereafter arising. The above release shall be
effective regardless of whether such olaims arise out of any
former or future acts, contracts, engagements or liabilities
of the other or by way of dower, curtesy, widow's or
widower's rights, family exemption or similar allowance, or
under the intestate laws, or the right to take against the
spouse's will, or the right to treat a lifetime conveyance by
the other as testamentary, or all other rights of a surviving
spouse to participate in a deceased spouse's estate, whether
arising undsr the laws of pennsylvania, any state,
Commonwealth or territory of the united states, or any other
country. It is expressly understood, however, that neither
the provisions of this release nor the subsequent entry of a
divorce decree are intended to defeat the right of either
party to receive any insurance proceedS at the death of the
other of which she or he is the named beneficiary (whether
5"S-
-.
the benefioiary designation was made prior or subsequent to
execution hereof), nor to defeat the right of either party to
reoeive any legaoy, bequsst or residuary portion of the
,
other's estate under his or her Will, or t9 aot as personal
.
representative or executor if so named by the Will of the
other, whether such Will was executed prior or subsequent to
this Agreement.
7. PERSONAL BIGHTS
wife and Husband may and shall, ,at all times
hereafter, live separate and apart. Each shall be free from
any direot or indirect control, restraint, interference or
authority, by the other and shall be treated in all respeots
as if they were unmarried. Except as otherwise provided for
in this Agreement, each may reside at such place of places as
he or she may from time to time choose or deem fit. Each
may, for his or her separate use or benefit, oonduct, carry
on and engage in any business, occupation, profession or
employment and at such locations which to him or her may seem
advisable. wife and Husband shall not molest, harass,
disturb or malign each other or the respective families,
friends, colleagues, employers or employees of each other or
compel or attempt to compel by any means the other to cohabit
or dwell in any manner whatsoever with him or her.
The Agreement is not intended to condone and shall not
be deemed to be a condonation of the part of either party
hereto of any act on, the part of the other party which has
occasioned the disputed or unhappy differences which have
66
.-,
I""',
ocourred prior or whioh ~ay ooour subSequent to the date of
eKeoution of this Agree~ent.
8. ~USTODY/VISITATIOH AND ~UPPOR~ gl H]NOR CHII.DREM
(a) ~ustod'l AIUl ~
Husband and wifs agree that the best interests
of their ~inor ohildren, Mar~ AndreW and zaohary Ja~es, are
served by a shared joint oustodY, Husband and wife further
agree that the best interests of their ~inor ohildren are
best served, at this ti~e, by Husband ~eing the pri~ary
physioal oustodian of the minor ohildren. AcoordinglY,
Husband and wife agree that Husband shall have prinoiple
physical oustody of the minor ohildren, Mark Andrew and
zaohary Ja~es, with wife afforded liberal visitation
inoluding every other weekend fro~ approKi~atelY 5100 p.~. on
Friday until 6100 p.~. on sunday, and eaoh Tuesday fro~
,..ro.i.,t.'Y '.00 .... until ..00 .... the 'ollowin. d.Y ,t
or about which ti~e wife shall deliver children to the day
care provider, and every other ~ajor Holiday (being defined
as Thankegiving, Christ~as Eve, christmas, New years Day,
Easter, Memorial Day, JulY 4, and Labor Day), and at suoh
other times as the parties shall mutuallY agree. It is
understood and agreed that the parties shall put forth every
effort to accommodate the sohedules and needs of the other in
order to afford each party the maKi~u~ amount of time with
the children as is wished by the parties. It is understood
and agreed that the schedule for visitation is intended to be
S7
.-..,
~
flexible and that the ~imes listed are approximate and not
intended to neoessarilY be striotly followed, with the
understanding that neither party will do anything to
unnecessarilY inconvenience the other.
.
It is further agreed that any major decision
regarding the education, health, safety or welfare of the
children, including the religious training, education, social
activities, and medical treatment of the children shall be
discussed between the parties to the greatest extent possible
and that no non-exigent major decision to alter the course of
any of the above shall be made without the mutual consent of
the parties.
(b) supDort ~ Minor ~hildren
wife agrees to pay Husband the sum of $337.00
per month, effective september 1, 1994, in support of the
parties minor children. said payment includes Wife'S share
of child care payments. wife covenants and agrees to
continue to provide health insurance coverage for the minor
children through her employers policy. Should wife cease to
be employed by her current employer for any reason, wife
agrees to continue to provide health care coverage of equal
or greater benefit for the minor children through an
alternative plan, or, in the alternative wife agrees to
reimburse Husband for such additional costs as may be
necessary to add children to,coverage through his employer.
(c)' IRa DeDendenc~ DeductLon
)-~
,,.-.,
~
Husband and Wire agree-that, ror the purposes or riling their
annual returns with the Internal Revenue service that any
unriled returns as or the date or the making or this
Agreement shall include neither spouse as a dependent or the
.
other but that Husband shall claim Mark Andrew as a dependant
and Wire shall declare Zachary James as a dspendent.
9. EOUITABLE DISTRIBUTION Qf PROPERTY
(a) Motor yehicles
with respect to the motor vehiclss owned by
one or both of the parties, they agree as followSl
1. The 1987 pontiac Grand AM shall
hereafter be the sole and exclusive property of Husband,
subject to any existing liens and encumbrances and the 1993
Hyundai Excel shall hereafter be the sole and exclusive
property of wife, subject of existing liens and encumbrances.
(b) aAnk Accounts
The parties agree and warrant that there are
no joint cheCking or savings accounts at any commercial bank,
savings and loan, credit union, private bank or other
financial institution at the time of the making of this
Agreement. The parties further agree that each savings
and/or checking account now held in either parties'
individual capacity shall be the exclusive and sole property
of said party and that the other waives all claims that he or
she may have in said account.
(c) Pension-Retirement Plans L Individual
Retirement Accounts,
~\tQ ~a\ves any and all interest that she may
:?I
.-.,
have in Husband's pension, profit-sharing, IRA and/or 401-K
plans and benefits by virtue of his employment. Husband
waivss any and all interest that he may have in wife's
Individual Retirement Account and/or 401 (k) Plan, psnsion,
profit-sharing, or other benefit by virtue of her employment
except as hereinafter provided. The parties agree thut any
suoh rights and/or bsnefits shall be and remain the sole and
exolusive property of the party noW vested with such
rlpht/benefit and each agrees to and hereby waives any olaim
that he or she has or could have to such rights/benefits.
(d) Marital Premises
Hushand shall have sole and exclusive
possession of the marital premises known as a 1991 commodore
Mobile Home situate at Regency south Mobile Home Park at Lot
141, it being understood and agreed that within thirty (30)
days of the signing of this Agreement a qualified appraisal
of said mobile home shall be made at Husband's expense, and
Husband shall within thirty (30) days following the date of
appraisal obtain a commitment for financing to the maximum
limit of the lending institution take sole ownership of said
mobile home. It is further understood and agreed that wife
will fully oooperate in the process of conveyancing and
finanoing the same and will timely exeoute any and all
documents necessary to accomplish said transfer. It is
further agreed that, should Husband be able to obtain
financing in an amount greater than curr.ently owed by virtue
of an outstanding note and mortgage to PNC Bank, the
60
.-,
difforenoe will bB distributed in the following manner I
1. the first $1,850 to Donald and Pauline Myers, and
2. the remainder evenly divided between the parties.
(e) Personal prooertv
Husband and Wife do hereby aoknowledge and agree
that they have heretofore divided or so marked and identified
betwsen them any and all of the furniture, furnishings, rugs,
carpets, household equipment and appliances, piotures, books,
jewelry, musical instruments and household goods of whatever
nature situated in the marital rssidence. Wife's
identification of those items of personal property whioh
shall be transferred to her pursuant to this Agreement are
attached hereto as Schedule "e". Hereafter, Wife agrees that
all of the above property in the possession of Husband or so
marked and identified as belonging to Husband shall be the
sole and separate property of Husband. Husband agrees that
all of the above property in the possession of Wife or so
marked and identified as belonging to Wife, inoluding those
items identified on Schedule "C", shall be the sole and
separate property of Wife. Each of the parties does hereby
specifically waive, release, renounce and forever abandon
whatever claims, if any, he or she may have with respeot to
any of the above property which is the sole and separate
property of the other.
~f
~
10. SEPARATE ASSETS
Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement,
each party shall keep and retain sole ownership, control and
enjoyment of all property transferred to him or her pursuant
to this Agreement, all of the jewelry, clothes, furniture,
musical instruments, and other personal property titled in
his or her name or in his or her possession and all bank
accounts, securities, insurance pOlicies, pensions (including
any benefits and other sums payable thereon), any Social
seourity benefits to which Husband or Wife would have been
entitled to by virtue of his or her marriage to the other,
~..J.Mn:l~2 1.T\.~~:S, ..."1:" ..."\.~hn:. J.rJ\Z'&f'J'JJ'\.J... ..^'~~ ~.." ,~tw<l l.. .""l,..
or her name and he or she shall have the exclusive right to
dispose of such property without interference or restraint by
the other as if the marriage had not taken place and he or
she had remained unmarried.
Each party shall indemnify the other and hold him
or her harmless from any liability, cost or expense,
including attorney's fees, which is incurred in conneotion
with the interests and/or assets referred to in this
Paragraph.
11. WARRANTY Aa TQ EXISTING OBLIGATIONS
During the course of the marriage, Wife and Husband
have incurred certain liabilities and it is hereby agreed,
without the necessity of ascertaining for what purpose and
62..
,-,
tor whose use eaoh ot the bills was inourred, that of those
liabilities that were inourred prior to the date ot the
exeoution ot this Agreement, wife and Husband eaoh oovenants,
represents, warrants and agrees that exoept as may be,
otherwise specificallY provided for by the terms of this
Agreement, no unpaid liabilities remain which were incurred
by him or her on his or her behalf tor which the other party
may be deemed liable, and, if any suoh debts or obligations
should be determined to have existed as of the date of
exeoution of this Agreement, or thereafter, except as set
forth below, the party who incurred that debt shall indemnify
and hold the other party harmless for and against any losS or
liability and costs or expense, inoluding attorney's fees,
incurred as a result of those liabilities.
Those liabilities known to the parties to exist at the time
of the making of this Agreement are set forth here and made
the sole and sxolusive responsibility of the party so
indioated. The other party hereby agrees to indemnify and
hold harmless the other for any and all liability for the
samel
SUARONI Msmbers First FCU Auto Loan
Account Number 108662-05
Members First FCU Visa
Aooount Number 4121-4499-9101-6625
Sears Charge (Acot.I5-S8972-61889-3)
JEREMYl PNC Bank Mobile Home Loan
Loan Number 30_02-3009303346
'.....
,-...
Members First FeU Auto Loan
Acoount Number 108662-02
Members First FCU Line of credit
Acoount Number 108662-01
contingent liability for Lot rental for
mobile home
Montgomery Ward charge
Account Number 112-086-552
Each party agrees to, within one year of the date of this
Agreement, obtain new finanoing for the above outstanding
obligations so that the Obligation is in the name of the
party agreed to be responsible only and all enoumbrance,
obligation, lien or other attaohment to the other is
extinguished oompletely and forever.
ii. ~ N I!S &Zlif./,,2W.!!JiM'.10NS
Wife and Husband eaoh oovenants, repressnts,
warrants and agrees that exoept as may be otherwise
speoifioally provided for by the terms of this agreement,
neither of them shall hereafter incur any liabilities
whatsoever for which the other or the estate of the other may
be liable, and each now and at all times hereafter shall
indemnify and hold the othsr party harmless from and against
any such liabilities, oosts or expenses, inoluding attorneys'
fees, relating thereto, incurred by the other party after the
date of execution of this Agreement.
13. WAIVER Ql ~LIMONY
Husband and Wife do hereby waive, release and give
_ ..:rr -;-- .3''" .-" ~''''hp-..JII8V .have against the other to
b'Y
,-,
1"""1
, .
reoeive alimony or other post-divoroe maintenanoe or support.
It shall be, f~om the exeoution date of this Agreement, the
sole responsibility of eaoh of the respeotive parties to
sustain themselves without seeking any support from tbe other
party.
14. ~FTER bCOUIRED FROPERTY
Eaoh of the parties shall hereafter own and enjoy,
independently of any olaim or right of the other, all items
of property, be they real, personal or mixed, tangible or
intangible, which are acquired by him or her after exeoution
of this Agreement, with full power in him or her to dispose
of the same as fully and effectively, in all respsots and for
all purposes, as though he or she were unmarried.
15. ATTORNEYS' ~ fQB ENFORCEMENT
In the event that either party breaohes any
provision of this Agreement and the other party retains
counsel to assist in enforoing the terms thereof, the parties
hereby agree that the breaching party will pay all attorneys'
fees, inourred by the other party in enforoing the Agreement.
16. EFFECT Q[ DIVORCE DECREE
The parties agree that unless otherwise
spsoificallY provided herein, this Agreement shall continue
in full force and effeot after such time as a final decree in
divorce is entered with respect to the parties.
17. AGREEMENT ~ aB INCORPORATED 1H DIVORCE pECREE
The parties agree that a copy of this Agreement
shall be incorporated into any divorce decree which is
(p!J
i"'"
,"'""
r--.
, .
entered with respeot to them. The partiss further agree that
the oourt of Common pleas whioh may enter suoh divoroe deoree
shall retain continuing jurisdiction over the parties and the
subjeot matter of the Agreement for the purpose of
enforoement of any of the provisions thereof, unless another
court has jurisdiotion to enforce the provisions of this
Agreement.
18. WAIVER Ql MODIFICATION ~ w:: lli WRITING
No modirioation or waiver of any of the terms
hereof shall be valid unless in writing and signed by both
parties and no waiver of any breaoh hereof or default
hereunder shall be deemed a waiver of any subsequent default
of the same or similar nature.
19. MUTUAL COOPERATION
Eaoh party shall, at any time and from time to time
hereafter, take any and all steps to execute, acknowledge and
deliver to the other party within a reasonable period of time
any and all further instruments and/or documents that t~e
other party may reasonably require for the purpose of giving
full force and effect to the provisions of this Agresment.
20. LAH Ql PENNSYLVANIA APPLICABLE
This Agreement shall be construed in accordanoe
with the laws of the commonwealth of pennsylvania.
21. CONTRACT INTERPRETATION
~6
.
.-...
i
r"'o
For purposes of oontraot interpretation and for the
purpose of resolving 'any ambiguity herein, Husband and wife
agree that this Agreemont was preparsd, jointlY by their
respeotive attorneys.
22. ~GREEMENT BINDING UfQH HEIRS
Except as specificallY provided herein, this
Agreement shall be binding upon and shall inure to the
I..."..rl" 0" t-hA pRrties hereto and their respeotive heirs,
OKocutcra, administrators, successors and assigns.
23. INTEmu..TIOU
This Agreement constitutes the entire understanding
of the parties and supersedss any and all prior agreements
and negotiations between them. There are no other
representations, terms, oovenants, oonditions, agreements or
warranties, express or implied, oral or written of any nature
whatsoever, other than those expressly set forth herein.
24. HQ WAIVER Qf DEFAULT
This Agreement shall remain in full foroe and
effeot unless and until terminated under and pursuant to the
terms of this Agreement. The failurs of either party to
insist upon striot performanoe of any of the provisions of
this Agreement shall in no way affect the right of such party
hereafter to enforoe the same, nor shall the waiver of any
breaoh of any provision hereof be construed as a waiver of
any subsequent default of the same or similar nature, nor
'\}I:~,:, \ '. \ ~ ~Qns'trueb. as il. 1oI~ ~ II\!". 11'. ~:.'. '":. 1lU"."."1J::'1a11C'.A ~f..
,I." ,,"hn'" nhl f"Atlnfl htlrl1in.
,...-...,
..--
/'
25. ~EVERABILtT'i
If any term, oondition, olause or provision.of this
Agreement shall be determined or deolared to be void or
invalid in law or otherwise, then onlY that term, condition,
olause or provision shall be strioken from this Agreement and
in all other respects this Agreement shall be valid and
oontinue in full foroe, effect and operation likewise, the
failure of any party to meet her or his obligations under any
one or more of the paragraphs herein shall in no way void or
alter the remaining obligations of the parties.
26. IJEADINGa li2 fbB1 QF. l>GREEMENT.
AnY headings preceding the text of the several
paragraphs and subparagraphs hereof are inserted solely for
convenience of reference and shall not constitute a part of
this Agreement nor shall they affect its meaning,
construction or effect.
27. COUNTERPARTa
This Agreement may be executed in counterparts,
eaoh of which will be an original and which together shall
constitute one and ths same instrument.
-
."
. .' "
,
r...,
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the partiss hereto have set their
hands and seals the day and year first above written.
il~ J:f1
Wltness
~ t.~.1
J em . HeM c asl
Sharon E. HcMfChael
'.i,;"
, .
,
/"\
r-..
~ I I '"
, I ,
.
SHARON E, MoMICHAEL,
PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v,
JEREMY J, MoMICHAEL,
DEFENDANT/PETITIONER
.
.
: 94-3440 CIVIL TERM
~
AND NOW, this 6th day of October, 1995, following a hearing, IT IS
ORDERED:
(1) The petition to hold Sharon E, (McMichael) Riddle In contempt for falling to
comply with the custody provisions In a marlta] settlement agreement that was
Incorporated Into a final decree In divorce by an order of October 11, 1994, IS
DENIED, The mother, however, from this date forward, shall provide the father at
least five (6) days notice when she Is not going to exercise her temporary physical
custody rights.
(2) A petition to hold Sharon E. (McMichael) Riddle In contempt for not
carrying medical coverage on the parties' two children 16 DENIED since the children
are being covered free In a government program. Should that free coverage oease,
the mother shall be responsible, as per the order of October 11, 1994, to either
provide health Insurance coverage through an employer's polloy or reimburse the
father for such additional cost as may be necessary to add the children to health
Insurance coverage through his employer.
\ II 0.)11
\" 1'\\\1 \ . \
70
..---
.1""\,
. I I ...
{'\.
- ., ,
(3) Sharon E. (McMichael) Riddle Is adjudicated In contempt for failure to pay
regularly $337 per month for the support of her two minor children as per the order of
October 11, 1994. The mother shall purge herself of contempt by hereafter timely
making such payments together with $50.00 per month on account of arrearages.
By the Court; / ,j
, I
\\..
Sha~n ,,(McMichael) Riddle
R. D , Box 97
))e er, PA 17315
/Plalntiff/Respondent
Charles R. Gerow, Esquire
For DefendanVPetltloner
Domestio Relations Office
:saa
. TRl1n <:''''It>'! FROM RECORD
In I' 'i I;" , " ;, 1', r. . 'In ~lll my hand
Gild ihu .,;al ~': ~" ,/ U;Jrl Jt CJriilll1, Pa.
lhl. ....,5:!f.... day oL(]d..;.., 19..?'{
'''''''''''''''~>; /l I . 'Rot:;' , .
o .....fr(!,o, ,.,CI~ MU.......M..
ol>~ ' Prothon lary
.2.
7(
... ." t
uUtiE.COURT Qt' COMMON t'LEASD(<,
-'..'lll\lDERLAND COUNTY.l'ENNSYL\'ANJA
SIIARON E. McMICIIM:I.lltlUnU:
PL.AINTIH',
VS,
ClISTODY
f""',
4 .' ..
JEItEMY J. McMICIIAEL
D[I<'ENnANT,
','
94.3440 CIVil. 'l'ERM
CER1'u:tCATEj}jo~SER\'JCE
I, Linda M Gross, Esquire, dll herehy certify that I alll this day servinll a copy of
the fDrelloinll Petition upon Jeremy 1. McMichael in the fllllowinllmanner
By United States Mail to
Jeremy J McMichael
41 Rellency Street
Carlisle, IlA 17013
LAW OFFICE OF LINDA M GROSS
"'J
BY
Linda M
Attorney, No, 58999
52 South Duke Street
York, PA 17401
Tele (717) 852-7232
~
..
~
t\-
o
L1\
'-"-l
.<
, )00
~I t:.:
'.
;.t
,. .~
Co
l4".
II
Q'"
, ,
:;~ i';
'I",
,',..'
,-,..t
,,~
,.,..,
C!';>'.
,." ." U
~; ;l!1.
'-,
~!i i~~
.a
-
. ..
.. 't i
t , . .
.of ." ""
.
. . -:4f ~71r ,(j"
,.. "It'~ " ,
',# 'l." I) "
.
11
t""
SHARON E. McMICHAEL/RIDDLE,
PLAINTIFF
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL,
DEFENDANT
94-3440 CIVIL TERM
~
AND NOW, this 17th day of November, 1995, a Rule Is entered against
defendant, Jeremy J, McMichael, to show cause why the relief requested should not
be granted. Rule returnable by defendant thirty (30) days after service, Plaintiff shall
file In this chambers a memorandum with legal authority In support of her position not
later than thirty (30) days from this date. The Issue will be decided without a hearing.
By the court,;:I//
( JJ/
'=LJvJ
Edgar B. Bayley, J.
',y Linda M. Gross, Esquire
~J).; For Plaintiff
1''' ~
Ill' '1\1\~ Charles R. Gerow, Esquire
\ /.l For Defendant
:saa
7S"
\fl
.~
=1
,ro
~r
:3
r
, 1
c'f'"
r-,
"
,
\--''f
"
"
;'.1
"
I"
# ,l,
"
~
FiLED-DFFICE
I"r: n 't: I"'Y)TLlI1~8)T'I:lY
\/1 I'. ,I,., ,n......" Iln
96 .IMI 16 PII 31 19
el)"""f' \"- C'QU\ITY
IVj.>~: \I..i \u I'
P:"\I'~'11/';v!A
1-.111 ,"-'1 ~\f\i ,
\,J
'-"
!'"\
("I.
SHARON E. McMICHAEL
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERU\ND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V,
JEREMY J, McMICHAEL
94.3440 CIVIL TERM
BAYLEY, J" January 18, 1998:--
On August 22, 1994, Sharon E. (McMichael) Riddle, and Jeremy J. McMichael,
the parents of Mark Andrew McMichael, born May 4, 1990 and Zachary James
McMichael, born September 17, 1992, entered Into a comprehensive written marital
settlement agreement that provlded,InW~:
8(b), Support Qf Minor Cblldren
Wife agrees to pay Husband the sum of $337,00 per month,
effective September 1, 1994, In support of the parties [sic] minor
children, Said payment Includes Wife's share of child care payments.
Wife covenants and agrees to continue to provide health Insurance
coverage for the minor children through her employers [sic] polley.
Should Wife cease to be employed by her current employer for any
reason, Wife agrees to continue to provide health care coverage of
equal or greater benefit for the minor children through an alternative
plan, or, In the alternative Wife agrees to reimburse Husband for such
additional costs as may be necessary to add children to coverage
through his employer,
. . .
18, WA!YE.B QE MQQlE!.QAIlQti IQ e.!; 1M ~
No modification or waiver of any of the terms hereof shall
be valid unless In writing and signed by both parties and no waiver of
any breach hereof or default hereunder shall be deemed a waiver of any
subsequent default of the same or similar nature,
On October 11, 1994, a decree In divorce was entered which Included the
following clause: "This agreement of August 22, 1994 Is hereby Incorporated Into the
'77
1"""\
t"'.
94-3440 CIVIL TERM
Final Divorce Decree,"
On October 5, 1995, following a hearing on a petition flied by Jeremy J.
McMichael, the following order was entered:
Sharon E. (McMichael) Riddle Is adjudicated In contempt for
failure to pay regularly $337 per month for the support of her two minor
children as per the order of October 11, 1994. The mother shall purge
herself of contempt by hereafter timely making such payments together
with $50.00 per month on account of arrearages,
No appeal was taken from that order.
On November 16, 1995, Sharon E. (McMichael) Riddle filed a petition for
Special Relief, Petitioner reques~ed that the court:
direct the Office of Domestic Relations In Cumberland County open a file
and set an Order In the amount of $337,00 per month, Simultaneously
with this Order, Mother respectfully requests that the Court of Common
Pleas of Cumberland County schedule a Modification Hearing for
purposes of determining the present and proper amount of child
support,
Petitioner entered Into a contract with respondent as part of an overall marital
settlement agreement to pay $337,00 per month for the support of her two children
who are In the custody of respondent. The contract contained a provision that no
modification of Its provisions can be made without the agreement of both parties,
The Divorce Code, at 23 Pa,C,S, Section 3105, provides:
(a) Enforcement...A party to an agreement regarding matters within the
jurisdiction of the court under this part, whether or not the agreement
has been merged or Incorporated Into the decree, may utilize a remedy
or sanction set forth In this part to enforce the agreement to the same
extent as though the agreement had been an order of court except as
provided to the contrary In the agreement.
.2-
78
, '
~
,....,
94-3440 CIVIL TERM
(b) Certain provIsions subject to modlflcatlon.--A provision of an
agreement regarding child support, visitation or custody shall be subject
to modification by the court upon a showing of changed circumstances.
(c) Certain provisions not subject to modlflcatlon,--In ths absence
of a specifIc provision to the contrary appearing In the agreement, a
proviSion regarding the disposition of existing property rights and
Interests between the parties, alimony, alimony pendente lite, counsel
fees or expenses shall not be subject to modification by the court,
(Emphasis added),
Reading paragraphs (b) and (c) of Section 3105, it Is arguable that a child
support provision In a marital settlement agreement may be modified downward upon
a change of circumstances notwithstanding a non-modification clause In the
agreement. However, the Superior Court In Nicholson v. Combs, 437 Pa, Super.
334 (1994), has held that a bargained for non-modifiability provision for child support
Is enforceable and cannot be modified downward. The Superior Court, however, did
not analyze Section 3105 of the Divorce Code In rendering Its decision.'
Nevertheless, we are bound by Nicholson, See, Colona v. Pierce, (opinion In
support of the order of December 21, 1995, at 432 Support 1994),
There Is no authority to force the opening of a support file In the Domestic
Relations Office, Even If such a file were opened, the support required to be paid
pursuant to the parties' marital settlement agreement cannot be modified downward.
Nicholson v. Combs, supra, Accordingly, given the status of this case, we will not
schedule a modification hearing,
1. The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania has granted allocatur In Nicholson.
-3.
I'
ti
I'"'.
94-3440 CIVIL TERM
~
AND NOW, this ,(, day of January, 1996, the within petition, IS
DISMISSED.
~/
By the COU~I/ _.
./I,J
Linda M. Gross, Esquire
For Plaintiff
I
Charles Gerow, Esquire
For Defendant
:saa
-4-
80
"
r-...
,.......
SHARON E. McMICHAEl"
Plaintiff
I
I
I NO. 94-3440 civil 1994
I
vs.
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL,
Defendant
HESPONDEN'I.', JERt:HY J. HcHICHAEL'S, ANSWER
'ra PE'rITION FOR SPECIAL UELIEI" AND NEW MA'l'TER
TO THE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT:
Respondent, Jeremy J. McMichael, by and through his attorney
Charles R. Gerow, Esquire now comes before this Honorable
Court respectfully setting forth the following Answwer to
Petitioner/Plaintifff Sharon (McMichael) Riddle's Petition
for Special Relief and New Matter in the form of an
additional Petition for Contempt I
1. Admitted.
2. Admitted.
3. Admitted.
4. Admitted.
5. Admitted.
6. Denied. It is denied that Mother fully met her
Obligation for support of her minor children prior
to her separation from employment. The remainder of this
averment is denied becauso it sets forth allegations
whioh Defendent, after reasonable investigation, is
unable to determine the truth or falsity of.
1/1 q I~
8/
."""
",...,
7. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is admitted that
this 1I0norable Court ontered an Order finding, inter
alia, Mrs. Riddle in contempt for failing to meet her
obligation of timely paying child support. The remainder
of this averment is, in part, argument to which no
response is required.
8. Denied. It is denied that Mother has offered to make
timely payments for support of her minor childron through
any mechanism.
9. Denied.
10. Denied. The contents of this averment are legal
conclusions and argument to which no response is
required.
11. Denied. After reasonable investigation,
Defendent/Respondent Jeremy J. McMichael is without
sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as
to the truth or falsity of this averment.
12. Denied. The contents of this averment are legal
conclusions and argument to which no response is
required.
13. Denied. After reasonable investigation,
Defendent/Respondent Jeremy J. McMichael is without
sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as
to the truth or falsity of this averment.
:rl
I'''~
t""\
14. Denied. The contents of this averment are legal
oonclusions and argument to which no response is
required.
15. Admitted.
16. Denied. After reasonable investigation,
Defendent/Respondent Jeremy J. McMiohael is without
sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as
to the truth or falsity of this averment.
17. Denied. The contents of this averment are legal
conclusions and argument to which no response is
required.
18. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is admitted that
the Marital Settlement Agreement is a oontract which is
legally binding on both parties. 'I'he remainder of the
averment is denied as the contents of this averment are
legal conclusions and argument to which no response is
required.
19. Denied. The contents of this averment are legal
conclusions and argument to which no response is
required.
20. Denied. While Father appreciates Mother's concerns over
additional benafite that might be conferred upon him,
this averment contains only legal conclusion and argument
to which no response is required.
~J
"""
f"',
Acoordingly, Hespondent/Defendent Jeremy J. HcMichael
respectfully requests this 1I0norable Court to deny, in its
totality, Plaintiff/Petitioner Sharon (McMichael) Riddle's
Petition for special Helief and to enter an award for counsel
fees to him as provided in the Marital Separation Agreement.
HIDi 1fA'l"l'ER
ADDITIONAL PETITION lQR CONTEMPT
21. Paragraphs 1 - 20 are incorporated by reference and made
a part hereof.
22. On or about October 5, 1995 this Honorable Court entered
a learned and correct Order adjudicating Petitioner
Sharon (McMichael) Riddle in contempt and ordering her to
make timely payments of $337.00 per month plus $50.00 on
account of arrearages.
23. This Honorable Court has correctly retained jurisdiction
over this matter and has now jurisdiction over it.
24. Since the date of this Honorable Court's clear and
correct order, Petitioner Sharon (McMichael) Riddle has
made only sporadic and token payments with an aggregate
total of $125.00, thus accumulating an additional
$1,423.00 in arrearages.
?I'f
"......,
f""',
25. Petitioner Sharon (McMichael) Riddle has further flatly
stated to Respondent Jeremy J. McMichael, and others,
that she will steadfastly continue to defy this
Court's Order.
WHERE~'ORE, Petitioner prays that a Rule be granted on
original Petitioner, Sharon (McMichael) Hiddle to show
why she should not be held in contempt of court for
failure to comply with said order of this Honorable Court
and further directing that original Petitioner, Sharon
(McMichael) Hiddle pay all counsel fees of original
Respondent, Jeremy J. McMichael, in connection with this
action as provided for in the Marital separation
Agreement.
Respectfully submittedl
BYl
CHARLES R. GEROW
4725 Charles Road
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
717-975-3536
Attorney I.D. #32888
counsel for Petitioner
~lr
"--:1.''''''
----
,...,
VERIFICATION
I verify that the statements made in this Petition for
contempt are true and correct. I understand that false
statements herein are made subjeot to the penalties of 18 Pa.
Cons. stat. section 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to
authorities.
,
-Ill.ltlt ~ ?Ju ?/kt/tatl
Respondent
Datel '.'9.9("
t6
,"""
r..
SIIARON E. McMICHAEL
Plaintiff, Respondent
vs.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
NO. 94-3440 civil 1994
JEREMY J. McMICIIAEL
Defendant, Petitioner
NOTICE
Legal proceedings have been brought against you
alleging, among other things, you have willfully disobeyed an
order of court for support.
If you wish to defend against the claim set forth in the
following pages, you may but are not required to file in
writing with the Court your defenses or objections.
YOU SHOULD '1'AKE '1'IIIS PAPER TO YOUn LAWYER 1.'1' ONCE. IF YOU 00
NOT IIAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO '1'0 OR TELEPHONE
THE OFFICE SET FonTH BELOW '1'0 FIND ou'r WIIERE YOU CAN GET
LEGAL HELP:
Court Administrator
4th Floor, Cumberland Co. Courthouse
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717)-240-6200
. '
.
r'"
SHARON E. MoMICIIAEL
Plaintiff, Rospondent
VB.
I
I
I
I
I
.
I
NO. 94-3440 civil 1994
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL
Defendant, potitionor
ORDER
You, Sharon (McMichael) Riddle, respondont, must appear
in person in court on at in
Room Cumberland Co. Courthouse.
IF YOU 00 NO'!' APIlEAn IN PEnSON, TilE coun'l' MAY ISSUE A WAlUtANT
FOR YOUR ARnEST AND YOU MAY DB COMHl'lvl'ED '1'0 JAIL.
If the court finds that you have willfully failed to
comply with its order for support, you may be found to
be in contempt of court and committed to jail, fined or
both.
DATE OF ORDER.
BY THE COURT.
Judge
,'"'\
,-..
. ,
IN 'mE COUU'l' OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PBNNSYLVANIA
SIIARON E. HCHICIIAEI./RlDDLE
PLAINTIFF,
VB.
CUSTODY
JEREMY J. HCHICIIAEI.
DEFENDEANT,
94-3440 CIVIL TERM
CERTIFICATE Qf SBRVICE
I, Charles R. Gerow, Esquire, do hereby certify that I am
this day serving a copy of the foregoing Answer and New
Matter upon Linda M. Gross/ Esquire, in the following
manner:
By United States Mail, postage pre-paid tOI
Linda M.
52 South
York, PA
Gross, Esquire
Duke Street
17401
~ If,IQ1t
BYo ~ I
CHARLES R. GEROW
4725 Charles Road
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
717-975-3536
Attorney 1.0. #32888
Counsel for Petitioner
If'l
.
,,..,\
. l
fA.
'N TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYI,V ANIA
SHARON E. McMICHAEL
PLAINTIFF,
VS.
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL
DEFENDANT,
I NO. 94-3440 CIVIL TERM
I
I
I
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notice is hereby given that Sharon E. McMichael, Plaintiff above named, hereby
appeals the Order of Court ofthe Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania to the Superior Court of Pennsylvania entered in this matter on the 16th day
of January, 1996. This Order (attached to this notice) has been entered in the docket as
evinced by the attached copy of the docket entry.
"
qtJ
~
J~"""
"...
,.....
SHARON E. MoMICHAEL
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
.
.
V.
JEREMY J. MoMICHAEL
.
,
: 94-3440 CIVIL TERM
~
AND NOW, this I to day of January, 1996, the within petition, 18
DISMISSED.
./
LIP~M. Gross, Esquire
...For Plaintiff
/
Charles Gerow, Esquire
For Defendant
:saa
"
o
SHARON E. McMICHAEL
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL
94-3440 CIVIL TERM
QfllilQ.N AND 08.DER OF COURt
BAYLEY, J., January 16, 1996:--
. On August 22, 1994, Sharon E. (McMichael) Riddle, and Jeremy J. McMichael,
the parents of Mark Andrew McMichael, born May 4, 1990 and Zachary James
McMIchael, born September 17, 1992, entered Into a comprehensive written marital
settlement agreement that provided, Inter g)ill:
8(b}. Support ill Minor Children
Wife agrees to pay Husband the sum of $337.00 per month,
effective September 1, 1994, In support of the parties [sic] minor
children. Said payment Includes Wife's share of child care payments.
Wife covenants and agrees to continue to provide health Insurance
coverage for the mInor children through her employers [slo] polloy.
Should Wife cease to be employed by her current employer for any
reason, Wife agrees to continue to provide health care coverage of
equal or greater benefit for the minor children through an alternative
plan, or, In the alternativE. Wife agrees to reimburse Husband for such
additional costs as may be necessary to add children to coverage
through his employer.
. . .
18. WAIVl;B OF MODIFICATJ.QN TO m; ill Yi8.lII.t:ill
No modification or waiver of any of the terms hereof shall
be valid unless In writing and signed by both parties and no waiver of
any breach hereof or default hereunder shall be deemed a waiver of any
subsequent default of the same or similar nature.
On October 11, 1994, a decree In divorce was entered which Included the
following clause: "This agreement of August 22, 1994 Is hereby Incorporated Into the
12-
.
,r,
(\
94-3440 CIVIL TERM
Final Divorce Decree."
On October 5, 1995, following a hearing on a pelltlon flied by Jeremy J.
McMichael, the following order was entered:
Sharon E. (McMichael) Riddle Is adjudicated In contempt for
failure to pay regularly $337 per month for the support of her two minor
chlldre;, as per the order of October 11, 1994. The mother shall purge
herself of contempt by hereafter timely making such payments together
with $50.00 per month on account of arrearages.
No appeal was taken from that order.
On November 16, 1995, Sharon E. (McMichael) Riddle flied a petition for
Special Relief. Petitioner requested that the court:
direct the Office of Domestic Relations In Cumberland County open a file
and set an Order In the amount of $337.00 per month. Simultaneously
with this Order, Mother respectfully requests that the Court of Common
Pleas of Cumberland County schedule a Modification Hearing for
purposes of determining the present and proper amount of child
support.
Petitioner entered Into a contract with respondent as part of an overall marital
settlement agreement to pay $337.00 per month for the support of her two children
who are In the custody of respondent. The contract contained a provision that no
modification of Its provisions can be made without the agreement of both parties.
The Divorce Code, at 23 Pa,C.S. Section 3105, provides:
(a) Enforcement...A party to an agreement regarding matters within the
Jurisdiction of the court under thIs part, whether or not the agreement
has been merged or Incorporated Into the decree, may utilize a remedy
or sanction set forth In this part to enforce the agreement to the same
extent as though the agreement had been an order of court except as
provided to the contrary In the agreement.
-2.
13
,"
r--
94-3440 CIVIL TERM
(b) Certain provisions subject to modlllcatlon...A provision 01 an
agreement regarding child support, visitation or custody shall be subject
to modification by the court upon a showing 01 changed circumstances.
(c) Certain provisions not SUbJect to modlflcatlon...ln the absence
of a specific provision to the contrary appearing In the agreement, a
provision regarding the disposition 01 existing property rights and
interests between the parties, alimony, alimony pendente lite, counsel
lees or expenses shall not be subject to modification by the court,
(Emphasis added).
Reading paragraphs (b) and (c) 01 Section 3105, It Is arguable that a child
support provision In a marital settlement agreement -may be modified downward upon
a change 01 circumstances notwithstanding a non.modlflcation clause In the
agreement. However, the Superior Court in Nicholson v. Combs, 437 Pa. Super.
334 (1994), has held that a bargained lor non-modifiability provision lor child support
Is enforceable and cannot be modified downward. The Superior Court, however, did
not analyze Section 3105 of the Divorce Code In rendering Its decision.'
Nevertheless, we are bound by Nicholson. See, Colona v. Pierce, (opinion In
support of the order 01 December 21, 1995, at 432 Support 1994).
There is no authority to lorce the opening of a support file In the Domestic
Relations Office, Even If such a file were opened, the support required to be paid
pursuant to the parties' marital settlement agreement cannot be modified downward,
Nloholson v, Combs, supra. Accordingly, given the status of this case, we will not
schedule a modification hearing,
1. The Supreme Court 01 Pennsylvania has granted allocatur in Nloholson.
.3.
.
94-3440 CIVIL TERM
,"'.
('*"I
~
AND NOW, this I (, day of January, 1996, the within petition, IS
DISMISSED.
Linda M. Gross, Esquire
For Plaintiff
Charles Gerow, Esquire
For Defendant
:saa
.4-
r'>
.
IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PUAS OF CUMBERLAND COlltITY.
I'ENNS\'LV ANIA
SHARON E. McMICHAEL
PLAINTIFF,
: NO. 94.3440 CIVIL TERM
VS.
JEREMY J. McMICllAEL
DEFENDANT,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I. Linda M. Gross, Esquire, do hereby certifY that I am this day serving a copy of
the foregoing Appeal upon Charles R. Gerow, Esquire and the Honorable Edgar B.
Bayley In the following manner:
By United States Mail to:
Charles R. Gerow, Esquire
4725 Charles Road
Mechanicsburll, PA 17055
and
The Honorable Edgar B. Bayley
Cumberland County COUl1house
1 Courthouse Square
Carlisle, P A 17013
LAW OFF 1 E OF LINDA M. GROSS
\
BY~
Linda M. Gro
Attorney 1.0. o. 8
52 South Duke reet
York, PA 1740
Tele: (717) 852.7232
PYS510
1994-03440
Cumborll 'd County Prothonotary's O~ce Page I
Iii CaRO Inquiry
l:OMP!.AIN1' - DIVORCE riled......... 6/24/94
2114
Judge Assignedl
Judgment I
BAYLEY EDGAH n
.00
superior Co
Execution Date
sat/Dis/Gotd. .
Jury Trial. . . .
0/00/00
10/11/94
..........,....................,.,..."..........,..,...........................
General Index Attorney Info
MCMICHAEL SHARON E PLAINTIfF CALKIN JUDITH A
MCMICIlAEL JEREMY J DEfENDANT GEROW CHARLES R
".",..,."."......,."",.".""""",..,..,.....................,."..,.,.
, Date Entries '
.,.,...,.",.".,...,.".".""""""""".."""...,..........."..,."...
06/24/94 COMPLAINT - DIVORCE
10/03/94 PRAECIPE TO TRANSMIT RECORD
ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE
AFFIDAVIT OF CONSENT - PLAINTIFF
AFFIDAVIT OF CONSENT - DEFENDAN'I'
AGREEMENT
DIVORCE DECREE ENTERED BY JUDGE EDGAR B BAYLEY
PETITION FOR CONTEMPT
ORDER OF ~OURT - IN RE PETITION FOR CONTEMPT - RULE RETURNABLE AT
HEARING 9 2~/95 2130 PM CR 2 - BY JUDGE EDGAR B BAYLEY - COPIES
MAILED 8/ 2 95
ORDER OF CO RT - DATED 10/5/95 - IN RE PETITION FOR CONTEMPT -
DENIED (SEE ORDERl -BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J - COPIES MAILED 10/6/95
PETITION FOR SPEC AL RELIEf
ORDER OF COURT - DATED 11/17/95 - IN RE PETITION FOR SPECIAl. RELIEF
RULE TO SHOW CAUSE ISSUED AGAINST DEFENDANT RETURNABLE 30 DAYS
AFTER SERVICE - BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J - COPIES MAILED 11/17/95
01/16/96 ORDER OF COURT 1/16/96 EDGAR B BAYLEY JUDGE OPINION
TilE WITIIIN PETITION IS DISMISSED
COPIES MAILED 1/17/96
01/19/96 RESPONDENT JEREMY J MCMICIlAEL'S ANSWER TO PETITION FOR SPECIAL
RELIEF AND NEW MATTER
....,......................,...",..."..........,..............................
. Escrow Information ·
. Fees & Debits Beo Bal Pvmts/Adi End Bal ·
"............,............,...,....."..,......,...........................,...
Ag~Ma~
08/22/95
10/05/95
11/13/95
11/17/95
35.00 35.00 .00
.50 .50 .00
5.00 5.00 .00
125.00 125.00 .00
10.00 10.00 .00
5.00 5.00 .00
------------------------ ------------
180.50 180.50 .00
"..,.......................................................................,...
. End of Case Information ·
.,...,....,.................................................................,...
DIVORCE
TAX ON CMPLT
SETTLEMENT
MASTER'S FEE
DIV VA SURCHG
JCP FEE
~
If') 1-
f "-I ("II
00
~ 1:
'.. -~ ',- . J.
(y~ "/ (, '"'I:. .J
.'
., . . ~
I. .. . -'. " ~
"~S ! II (:,.';
( ,. "
\". '
I..," .., ....
l-r" .,
(~, " .
w/ " ~
( ,r ('J i ~', :
1\1
G;!' . . lid ~
"'. ,
I .,
I' I"';' : ~ 1
l) (I', l. I
.. .,
j
\o.J
.NDA M. GROSS
Attorney at Law
f,2 s, Dukp StlllPI
York.I'A Il,\OI
.
. ~ . .
I/.~!;!lf
~
,---
r
Superi~~ Court of Pennsylvania
Office of the Prothonotary
434 Main Capitol BUilding
P.O. Box 9300
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 1710B
(717) 772-1294
February 6, 1996
Notice of Appeal D,)cketing
Superior Court Docket No. Assigned
OOOB4HBG96 ,,' ',/ TtM
tfl/- 3 L/YO l..H~ . I-'-'
PROTHONOTARY
Cumberland COUNTY
Cumberland Cty. Courthouse
Carlisle, Pa 17013
REI Mcmichael, S V Mcmichael, J
You are hereby advised that the attached docket
information has been entered into the superior court rscords
in a case in which you appear as an officer of the court.
Please review this information carefully and notify this
office immediately if you believe correction(s) are in order.
Thank you.
David A. Szewczak
Prothonotary
... - '-
f'; ... 1-
~ .
1.,- o. ~ . ~ .
.
IU!.~ t>, . ,
l ., ~ .
..\ .
I': '-'f I
:\'
'.. r. I
r"
IJ_" I , ,
. I ,
C. I
I
I..
O. ,'l
, 0
9i
.....
"
,/."
02/06/96
1500
SUPERIOH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
OFFICIAL DOCKET
DOCKET U 000B4HBG96
FULL CAPTION
DOlT SHARON E MCMICHAEL
V
002E JEREMY J MCMICHAEL
COUNSEL
56999 LINDA M GROSS
52 SOUTH DUKE STREET
YORK, PA 17401
32666 CHARLES R GEROW
4725 CHARLES ROAD
MECHANICSBURG, PA 17055
CONSOLIDATED DOCKET NUMBER
BACKGROUND DATA
TRIAL COURT RECORDS
CATEGORY:
COURT NAME:
COUNTY:
JUDICIAL DISTRICT:
CASE TYPE/CHARGE:
TRIAL COURT CHARGES:
JUDGE (S) :
DISPOSITION TYPE:
DISPOSITION DATE:
APPEAL FILE DATE:
DISPOSITION ENTERED:
TRIAL CRT DOCKET NO. :
OFFENSE TRACKING NO. :
CV
CIVIL
CUMBERLAND
09
DIVORCE
BAYLEY, E
ORDER
01/16/96
01/25/96
94-3440 CIVIL TERM
STATUS INFORMATION
02/20/96 DOCKETING STATEMENT DUE
03/05/96 LOWER COURT RECORD DUE
DOCKET ENTRIES
02/06/96 NOTICE OF APPEAL
02/06/96 DOCKETING STATEMENT EXITED
T=APPELLANT E=APPELLEE *aCOURT APPOINTED
r.
TITLE
FOR MAIL
DOlT Y
717-652-7232
002E Y
717-975-3536
FOR
001T
001T
10 (J
- '-
'.. ~. V.
i.'~ .-
-' .-
i.~ .. :' .t:"
, , l,\ , l :l
\11. .~.... ". .
(.\, . . ,,:j
" . .'
I" ~" .
'-I . ..
l)i \- ,,' -, ~ j~~
1"1
Ii:'. I l'~ I;
""1 ('" Itn"'J
Ll:" t.:, ,~H..
I ~:'i
t'. ,n .:.1
(} ,.;;' U
""'"
..
. ,
""".
r
("",
SHARON B. MoMICHA~L/RIDDLB, I IN THB COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
Plaintiff I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
v. I
I
JEREMY J. MoMICHAEL, I
Defendant I 94-3440 CIVIL TERM
IN REI TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
Prooeedings held before the
HONORABLE EDGAR B. BAYLEY, J.,
Cumberland county Courthouse, carlisle, Pennsylvania,
Courtroom No. Two,
September 28, 1995.
APPEARANCES I
SHARON MoMICHAEL, Pro Se
CHARLES GEROW, ESQUIRE
For Defendant
10 (
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
--
,
0.
September 28, 1995
Carlisle, Pennsylvania
(Whereupon, the following proceedings were
held at 213B p.m.)
THE COURT I This is a petition to hold her in
contempt for what, violating the terms and conditions of a
separation agreement?
MR. GEROW: Yes, Your Honor, which was made
part of the final decree in divorce with this Court's
signature in October of 1994.
THE COURT: All right. And the allegations
are what, that she hasn't done what?
MR. GEROW: That she has failed to make
regular payments, the arrearages being greater than the
aotual payments made over the course of the past year; that
she has failed to maintain medical coverage for the
children, and she has failed to comply with the terms and
conditions of the visitation schedule.
THE COURTI What are the payments due?
MR. GEROWI The payments, Your Honor, are 337
per month.
THE COURT:
MR. GEROW:
THE COURT:
For how many children?
For two.
That he has?
2
r.
r
1 MR. GEROW I Yel, Your Honor.
2 THE COURT. How old?
3 MR. GEROW. Three and five, Your Honor.
4 THE COURT. Okay. And she's obligated to
5 provide medical ooverage under the agreement?
6 MR. GEROW I Yes, Your Honor.
7 THE COURT I And the visitation schedule i8?
8 MR. GEROW I The visitation schedule, as set
9 forth in the agreement, calls for the wife to have
10 visitation with the children every other weekend plus on
11 Tuesdays. The couples apparently have reached some sort of
12 amicable reeolution as to the Tuesdays, but the provisions
13 relating to the weekends are etill in full force and effect.
14 He is saying she is not --
15 THE COUHTI He wants to hold her in contempt
16 for not exercising her right to visitation?
17 MR. GEROWI That's right. She has not been
18 seeing the children on Tuesdays.
19 THE COURT I She is not seeing the children at
20 all?
21 MR. GEROW I sporadioally.
22 THE COURT I Okay. How old are you, sir?
23 MR. McMICIIAELI Twenty-five.
24 THE COURT. And you, ma'am?
2!l MR. McMICIIAELI Twenty-five.
J
.. J
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
,.-.
"
EXAMINATION OF SHARON McMICHAEL
BY THE COURT:
Q
A
Q
A
Q
or do you?
A No, I do not have any for the children.
Q You do not. Are you employed?
A Well, that's the problem. I lost my job,
that's why I could not pay, and do not have medical coverage
for them. I don't have medical coverage for myself.
Q Where were you working?
A Capital Blue Cross.
Q What did you do for them?
A Administrative assistant.
Q When were you hired?
A March of '91.
Q And when did you lose the job?
A November of '94.
Q Why did you lose it?
A They say that I breached confidentiality
You are representing yourself?
Yes, I am.
Do you admit you are behind on your payments?
Yes, I am.
You have no medical coverage for the children
issues.
Q You were fired?
4
, ,I J
r\
(\
1 A Yes, I was.
2 Q Ballpark, what we~e you earning there?
3 A $16,000.00 a year.
4 Q Have you had any employment since you lost
5 the job in November of 19941
6 A Yes. Shortly after that I got part-time
7 employment where I couldn't see the children on weekends
8 because I worked.
9 Q okay. Hold on. Let me get this down. And
10 where was that? I'm sorry?
11 A The part-time employment? Builders Square.
12 Q And what did you do for them?
13 A I was a cashier.
14 Q And you worked weekends?
15 A Yes.
16 Q And when how long after you lost your jOb
17 did you get that part-time job?
18 A About five weeks.
19 Q What were you earning there?
20 A $5.00 an hour.
21 Q How many hours a week?
22 A 5 to 20.
23 Q And have you since changed jobs?
24 A In Maroh I obtained an executive secretary
25 position.
5
/OS-
, .. J
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
~
.-
a And where is that?
A That was at Hereon (phonetic) Laboratories.
a Full-time?
A Yes.
a Do you still have that job?
A No, I do not.
a You lost it when?
A June.
a Why?
A I don't know. I was just told after my 90
days probation not to return the next day.
a Were you on a 90-day probationary period?
A Yes, I was.
o Were you fired or just not retained after
90-day probationary period?
A I was fired.
o You were not told why?
A No.
o Why do you think you were fired?
A I don't know.
o Nc idea?
A (NEGATIVE RESPONSE)
o Did you make any inquiries as to why you
were?
A No.
6
(\.
(\
1 Q Have you had employment sinoe?
2 A No. Right now I am cOllecting unemployment
3 oompensation, which will run out in approximately three
4 weeks.
5 Q How much?
6 A $188.00 a week.
7 Q And how much -- in three weeks how much bulk
8 payment -- how many weeko total would you have gotten that?
9 A Well, I started to claim unemployment after I
10 left Capital Blue cross, so I had been claiming on and off
11 almost a year because my claim was still open. I just
12 Q Essentially have you been paid the $188.00
13 psr week since you lost your job in June of 1995?
14 A Yes, since I left in June of '95.
15 Q Are you looking for work?
16 A Recently I became a licensed real estate
17 agent, which I have not made any money off of.
18 Q You are a licensed real estate agent?
19 A Yes, I am.
20 Q Are you looking to stay in that field?
21 A Yes, I am.
22 Q And you work for whom?
23 A Caldwell Banker. Bob Yost.
24 Q You've secured that position with Caldwell?
25 A Yes. I am an independent agent. I am
7
107
. '
(\
r'
1 ..If-employed but I do have a oontraot to work with them as
2 an independent agent.
3 Q That's what you are going to do?
4 A I'm sorry.
5 Q Have you started?
6 A Yes, I have.
7 Q Have you earned anything?
8 A No.
g Q Are you due some commissions?
10 A I'm sorry?
11 Q Are you due some commissions?
12 A No. I've just been licensed about a month.
13 Q What are the terms of your employment?
14 commission only?
15 A Yes.
16 Q Or do you have anything else? Do you have an
17 advance or anything like that?
18 A No.
ID Q commission only?
20 A Yes.
21 Q What do you antioipate being able to earn at
22 this?
23 A I really don't know.
24 Q You are not looking for other gainful
25 employment with a steady wage?
8
108
()
r
,
III I' "
1
A
My oontract with Caldwell Banker states I
2 must be a fUll-time agent.
3 EXAMINATION OF JEREMY McMICHAEL
4
BY THE COURT I
Q
A
Q
A
Q
A
Q
A
13 EXAMINATION OF SHARON McMICHAEL
14 BY THE COURT I
15
single?
Married.
Q
16
A
17
When were you married?
October 14th, 1994.
Is this your husband with you?
Q
18
19
A
Q
20
21
Yes, he is.
A
Q
Anybody live in the home with you other than
22 your husband?
23
24
A
No.
Q
A
Is he employed?
Yes, he is.
25
9
/or
r-.
r
.
.
.
1
2
Q
A
What does he do?
3
Q
He's a remodeling contraotor.
What's his ballpark annual income?
$19,000.00.
Do you support any children?
Yes, I do.
4
A
5
Q
A
6
7
8
9
Q
How many?
A
Four.
Q
Court order?
10
A
Yes.
11
How much?
Q
A
$79.00 for two of them, 34 for one of them,
12
13 and the other one is not a Court order.
14
Q
How much do you pay for that one?
Whenever she asks for it. It's just -- we
15
A
16 help support her just cash-wise.
17
None of these children live with the two of
Q
18 you?
19
20
A
No.
Q
Did you ever have -- I haven't looked at this
21 marital settlement. Was it a provision that you would oarry
22 the medicals for these children?
23
Through my children.
That was at the time you worked --
Capital Blue Cross.
A
24
25
Q
A
10
/10
I fl ,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
r
r
Q since you left capital Blue Cross, have you
.ince had the insurance?
A No.
EXAMINATION OF JEREMY McMICHAEL
BY THE COURT I
Q
A
Union.
Q
A
Q
A
Q
A
paragraph?
Paragraph B.
of Section 8.
Where do you work, sir?
I work for Members First Federal credit
What do you do for them?
I'm the assistant manager of the branoh.
Ballpark income.
Twenty-two one a year.
Twenty-two?
TWenty-two thousand one hundred a year.
THE COURT I What paragraph is that medical
MR. GEROW I May it please the Court, it's
It's sub-paragraph B, excuse me, Your Honor,
section 8, a custody support of minor
children. The language reads, Your Honor, Wife covenants
and agrees to provide health insurance coverage for the
minor children through her employer's policy. Wife agrees
to oontinue to provide health care coverage of equal or
greater benefit for the minor children through an
11
III
r\
0.
1 alternative plan or, in the alternative, wife agrees to
2 reimburse husband for such additional costs as may be
3 neoessary to add coverage through his employer.
4 THE COURT I AU right.
5 EXAMINATION OF SHARON McMICHAEL
6 BY THE COURT I
7 Q Now, since you stopped working that weekend
8 job for that, in which you weren't seeing your children, how
9 often have you been seeing the children since then?
10 A I see them every other weekend unless it's
11 physically not possible. One weekend I was in the hospital
12 and it was not possible.
13 Q When you say every other weekend, do you get
14 them overnight or during the day or what?
15 A I get them at least overnight. Friday night
16 through Saturday or through Sunday.
17 Q Have you been seeing them on the Tuesdays?
18 A No. I live in York. I live an hour away
19 from them. When I worked at Capital Blue Cross it was -- I
20 could drive by the baby-sitter's and pick them up. Since
21 then I thought it was mutually agreed, since I wasn't
22 travelling in that area anymore, that that part of the
23 visitation was okay.
24 TilE COURT I Is the problem, one of the
25 problems, with the visitation that she's scheduled to see
12
II~
00 .
,"'"',
o
1 them and doesn't show up?
2 MR. GEROW: Exaotly, Your Honor. He has
3 become a oonvenient baby-sitting service, Your Honor.
4 THE COURT: Do you have any money to make any
5 payments on account of the arrearages you owe under the
6 support arrangement?
7 MRS. McMICHAEL: No. I have paid him svery
8 other week what I can pay him.
9 THE COURT I Has there been some steady
10 payment every other --
11 MR. GEROWI He gets at least $30.00 every
12 other week.
13 THE COURT: Is that correct, sir?
14 MR. GEROW: Your Honor, my client has kept a
15 pretty good log, if the Court would like to look at it.
16 THE COURT: No, I just want to know if it's
17 correct.
18 MR. McMICHAEL: I would say that that
19 statement isn't totally correct.
20 THE COURT I Go through -- do you have a log
21 that says the amount she's made to you starting today and
22 backwards?
23 MR. McMICHAEL I Yes.
24 THE COURTI okay. Just give me the last 5 or
25 10 of them, and that will let me know what it's like.
13
113
("'.,
(""\,
. " ,
1 MR. McMICHAEL I May 11th, '95 received
2 $30.00.
3 THE COURT I Was that the last time?
4 MR. McMICHAEL I You want me to go back from
5 the present to
6 THE COURT I From today.
7 MR. McMICHAEL I Last I received, september
8 20th for $25.00, september 13th for $40.00, september 1st
9 for $40.00, August 22nd $30.00, July 6th $30.00, June 22nd
10 $30.00, June 7th $30.00, May 28th $50.00, May 24th $50.00,
11 May 17th $35.00, May 11th $30.00, April 25th $30.00.
12 THE COURT I Okay. That gives me an idea.
13 Are the children now covered by any medical insurance?
14 MR. GEROWI Yes, Your Honor.
15 THE COURT I okay. I will do the same. I do
16 these oontempt things, especially in the last few monthe,
17 informally as you can tell. I have found that's the easiest
18 way to do it, I should say. Are the children covered by
19 medical insurance?
20 MR. McMICHAEL I Yes, they are.
21 THE COURT I You cover them?
22 MR. McMICHAELI What I have done --
23 THE COURT I I shOUld ask you a better
24 question I How are they covered?
25 MR. McMICHAEL I They are covered under the
14
(',
r
, ,I I
1 Blue Chip Program ot Pennsylvania. I am under a certain
2 income limit so I can get the coverage tor tree because I
3 can't attord it under the ciroumstanoes.
4 THE COURT I And it is tree or isn't it?
!S HR. GEROW I I'm sorry, Your Honor.
6 THE COURT I Is it free?
7 HR. GEROW I Yes, it is, Your Honor, at this
II time.
9 THE COURT I Does that coverage -- is it equal
10 in scope to the type of coverage that your wife had?
11 HR. GEROW I I feel that it is, Your Honor.
12 THE COURTI That's a good program. And
13 that -- that's dependent on finanoial status of both
14 parents?
15 HR. HcMICHAELI Just me.
16 HR. GEROW I Custodian parent. There is a
17 concern, obviously, at this point that he is on the cusp.
18 THE COURTI Are you close?
19 MR. McHICHAELI Yes, I am.
20 THE COURTI How close?
21 HR. HcHICHAELI About $600.00.
22 THE cOURTI It's a heck of a thing not to
23 want to make any more money.
24 MR. GEROWI It's extremely close, Your Honor,
25 not worth the difference.
15
/I,)
'1 " .
(\
HR GEROWI
THE COURT I
of some property?
HR. GEROWI
THE COURT I
off or sold?
MR. GEROW:
THE COURT:
HR. GEROW:
r
16
II~
" I I .
("..
f""'
MRS. McMICHAEL: Yes, I do.
THE COURTI Okay. Is there a mortgage on the
home now?
MR. GEROW I Yes. It's a mobile home, Your
Honor. I guess it's still considered a mortgage loan.
THE COURT: Okay. Now, am I -- I want to be
1
2
3
4
5
6
7 sure I am correct with what you told me. It's your intent
8 at the moment to work full-time selling real estate?
9 MRS. McMICHAEL I Yes.
10 THE cOUnTI On a commission-only basis?
11 MRS. McMICHAEL I Yes.
12 THE COURTI If this works out like you hope
13 it works out, and you would think it might work out, which
14 is based upon your taking the jOb, what do you believe you
15 will earn?
16 MRS. McMICHAEL: The average salary is
17 $16,000.00 to start.
18 THE COURT: And that, looking at my notes,
19 was about what you were earning when you entered into the
20 marital ssttlement agreement regarding support, which at the
21 time I did agree, I felt it was excessive --
22 MRS. McMICIlAEL: And he knows that.
23 THE COURT: But you signed it.
24 MRS. McMICHAEL I I signed it because he
25 wouldn't go to Domestic Relations.
17
" It.....
("'.
r'
1 THE COURT I Don't tell me why you signed it.
2 It's signed and that takes care ot that. Now, are you now
3 in a position to regularly exercise the custody arrangements
4 you have?
5 MRS. McMICHAEL I Yes, I am.
6 THE COURT I And are you now in a position
7 to -- well, let's not -- I don't want to tool with the
8 medical stuff for now. Counsel, what are you looking for in
9 an order?
10 MR. GEROWI Your Honor, I think we would be
11 looking for payments now to be made through the Domestic
12 Relations office rather than directly to my client so there
13 is an accountability for attachment of any and all wages and
14 for a dramatic increase in the account. The arrearage now
15 exceeds the amounts actually paid on this agreement for the
16 past year. Further, that the Court make clear that the
17 terms and obligations --
18 THE COURT I Of course, there is no money to
19 do that right now. Right?
20 MRS. McMICHAEL I (NO AUDIBLE RESPONSE)
21 THE COURT I I can transfer it to D.R.O. and I
22 can require payments. We can attach wages, that's
23 reasonable. But as far as payments on arrearages at the
24 moment--
25
18
II~
I"".
r"
, ., .
1 MR. GEROW: At such time there is attachment.
2 W. would just ask for that.
3 THE COURT: Did you just get your real estate
4 lioense? Did you study for it and just get it?
5 MRS. McMICHAEL: (POSITIVE INDICATION)
6 THE COURT: She doesn't plan to sit at home
7 and do nothing, that is to her credit. Although it will
8 develop 16 -- unless you are lucky -- luck in real estate
9 business also depends on a lot of hard work -- you'll be
10 luoky to make 16 grand your first year. You never know.
11 You know something about the real estate business, Mr.
12 Gerow.
13 You are looking for attachment, payment on
14 arrearages, attachment of wages, payment of the order. You
15 are looking -- at least you are hoping -- well, I'll enter
16 an order. I think I can solve the difficulty regarding the
17 custody by entering an order requiring her to get advance
18 notice if she is not going to exercise the scheduled
19 visitation, that will solve the disability in that. What
20 kind of advance notice do you think she should give?
21 MR. GEROW: Your Honor, and that it be more
22 than just the mere convenience of the moment. Mr. McMichael
23 has kept a log for a year detailing a rather unusual pattern
24 of behavior where it was not the fact that I had to work or
25 I had to do this, but it was the convenience of the moment.
19
/ /1
.. .. ..
("\
r-
1 He wae used as a tree baby-sitting servioe. It is patently
2 untair. He needs a life as well. He has shared joint
3 oustody in this agreement, which frankly, if we had known
4 then what we now know, we might not have entered into.
5 MRS. McMICHAEL I I have never not shown up.
6 THE COURTI What kind of advance notice do
7 you think you need? Reasonable.
8 MR. GEROW: Your Honor, she -- it is true she
9 gives advance notice. It happens to be maybe two days
10 beforehand.
11 THE COURT: I am asking you what type of
12 advance notice you need.
13 MR. McMICHAEL I One week. So I can make
14 arrangements, if necessary.
15 THE COURT I Anything else you feel I need to
16 know?
17 MR. GEROW: I don't think so, Your Honor.
18 THE COURTI Fine. Do we have a good mailing
19 address on you? That is R.D. 21 Dover.
20 MRS. McMICHAEL: Box 97.
21 THE COURT: 17315?
22 MRS. McMICHAEL I Yes.
23 THE COURTI Okay. I'll enter an appropriate
24 order. I will send it out, and I expect it to be complied
25 with. Court's adjourned.
20
/2-0
.. . ,,"..'-4
f\
f'"
CERTIFICATE
I hereby certify that the prooeedings are
contained fully and accurately in the notes taken by me on
the above cause and that this is a correct transoript of the
same.
6' ... ,-..
L rraine K. Troutman
Offioial Court Reporter
. . .
The foregoing record of the proceedings on the
hearing of the within matter is hereby approved and direoted
to be filed.
./
.1J~ I '1'
Date
,
22
c:'
Pin')
';1" I
r;:j.:Ct
,.
; -PI'
f'r f" ~'~ f'.-.,
J(1 1.'<1
'''''1'1 "
i i I 1~. . '\1
.. . ., 'C{
CI'. .' .".
>.iH :,,~; ;':l, '.", ',",:. .j
h.,llh..}ji."--I~-' c-
.. . . <.-
"wi
...,;
J.A52014.96
SHARON E. McMICHAEL
Appellant
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
PENNSYLVANIA
VS.
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL
NO. 00084 HBO 96
Appeal from the ORDER January 16, 1996
In the Court of Common Pleas of CUMBERLAND CQunty
CIVIL
NO. 94-3440 CIVIL TERM
JUDOIIBNr
ON aJNDJI{&ftION wmrvoF. it is now htre ordered and
04/udged by this Court that Iht judgmt/ll oJ tht Court oJ
Common Pltos oJ Cumberland CoU1llY be. and Iht lame
U ht~by Affirmed.
~; "I ..
j .
I ,
Ill' . ('"
t If
F.
l, ~ :
b\ .1
(.
fl. \ -. mE COURT:
I ! . BY
...
IJ ,.. .,
U lJ' (.J
Dtutd: October 3. 1997
J.A52014.96
SHARON E. McMICHAEL
Appellant
IN TilE SUPERIOR COURT OF
PENNSYLVANIA
vs.
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL
NO. 00084 HBG 96
Appeal from the ORDER January 16, 1996
In the Court of Common Pleas of CUMBERLAND County
CIVIL
NO. 94-3440 CIVIL TERM
BEFORE: HUDOCK, SAYLOR, HOFFMAN, JJ.
OPINION BY HOFFMAN, J.:
F I LED OCT 3 1997
This is an appeal from an order entered on January 16,
1996, dismissing appellant sharon (McMichael) Riddle's petition
to modify a child support agreement. Appellant presents the
following issues for our reviewl
1. Did the trial court abuse its discretion by
failing to schedule a hearing on [appellant's]
request for a modification of the child
support provision of the marital settlement
agreement pursuant to 23 Pa. C.S. Section
3105(8)?
2. Did the trial court abuse its discretion by
entering an order which acted to discriminate
against [appellant] by treating her
differently and denying her the same rights as
other child support obligers in violation of
the Due Process Clause of the 14 th Amendment
to the United States Constitution?
3. Did the trial court abuse its discretion by
failing to apply the rules, statutes, policies
and procedures used by the Domestic Relations
office and by failing to refer the matter to
the Domestic Relations office, wasting
precious court time which offends public
policy and is not in keeping with the concept
of judicial economy?
Appellant's Brief at 9.
1
J. A52014 .96
Appellant mother,
sharon
(McMichael)
Riddle,
appellee father, Jeremy J. McMichael, are the parents of Mark
Andrew McMichael, born May 4, 1990, and Zachary James McMichael,
born September 17, 1992. On August 22, 1994, the parties entered
into a written marital agreement in which appellant agreed to pay
appellee $337.00 per month in child support. Furthermore, the
agreement provided that:
No modification or waiver of any of the terms
hereof shall be valid unless in writing and
signed by both parties and no waiver of any
subsequent default of the same or similar
nature.
Trial Court Order 1/16/96. On October 11, 1994, a decree in
divorce was entered which incorporated the August 22, 1994
.
agreement. Appellant mother subsequently filed a petition to
decrease her child support agreement, which the trial court
denied. This timely appeal followed.
Initially, we note that a child support order will be
overturned only where it is found that the trial court abused its
discretion either by a misapplication of the law or an
unreasonable exercise in judgment. Schneidemantle v. Senka, 371
Pa. Super. 500, 536 A.2d 552 (1966).
Appellant claims that the trial court erred in denying
her petition and determining that the child support agreement
could not be modified downward.
The statute governing the effect of a divorce agreement
between parties provides in pertinent part:
(A) ENFORCEME~r.-A party to an agreement
regarding matters within the jurisdiction of
the court under this part, whether or not the
agreement has been merged or incorporated into
2
and
J.A52014.96
the decree, may utilize a remedy or eanction
set forth in this part to enforce the
agreement to the same extent as though the
agreement had been an order of the court
except as provided to the contrary in the
agreement.
(b) Certain proviaions uubject to
modification. -A provision of an agreement
regarding child support, visitation or custody
shall be subject to modification by the court
upon a showing of changed circumstances.
23 Pa. C.S. !i 3105(a), (b) (effective Dec 19, 1990, replacing
former Rule 401.1).1 Thie Court has stated, however, that with
regard to the reduction of child support provided for in an
agreement between parties,
[A] support provision in [an] agreement
constitutes the level below which support may
not be modified. Courts have general
authority to modify their own support orders
based upon changed circumstances. However,
thitl does not permit modification below the
level of support Bet forth in the agreement of
the parties where the court has incorporated
that agreement as part of its support order.
The support obligation set forth in the
agreement is an independent financial
obligation between the parties. Support may be
modified upward based on the unavoidable
obligation which a parent owes to meet the
reasonable needs of a dependent child, llli.t.
this rationale doee not extend to downward
1 Appellant also argues that she is entitled to relief pursuant
to Pa. R.C.P. 1910.16 et ~, governing the application of support
guidelines. However, in her statement of questions, appellant
cites only 23 Pa. C.S. !i 3105 in support of her claim. See Pa.
R.A.P. 2116 (a) (no point will be considered which is not set forth
in the statement of questions involved). Furthermore, appellant's
petition to reduce support was based on section 3105. Moreover,
we note that Rule 1910.16 appliee to actions in support where a
trial court has entered a support order and a party subsequently
requests recomputation of the support award. Here, appellant did
not file an action in support but rather an action to modify the
parties' agreement. See Klahold v. Kroh, 437 Pa. Super. 150, 649
A.2d 701 (1994) (Rule 1910.16 et ~ applies to cases where an
initial support order has already been entered by the court and a
party now seeks to have the support obligation recomputated) .
3
J.A52014.96
modification of the level of support set forth
in parties' aqreement once the court has
adopted their agreement.
Nicholson v. Combs, 437 Pa. Super. 334, 342, 650 A.2d 55, 59
(1994)2
(citations
omitted) (emphasis
added) .3
Accord
Millstein v. Millstein, 311 Pa. Super. 495, 457 A.2d 1291 (1983)
(a separation agreement will not preclude a court from increasinq
a parent's child support obligation beyond the amount provided in
the agreement, but the agreement may preclude a parent from
decreasing his or her child support obligation to an amount Ieee
than the amount provided in the agreement); Guerin v. Guerin, 296
Pa. Super. 400, 442 A.2d 1112 (1982) (father could not escape his
promise to pay an agreed amount of child support by proving a
change in circumstances), Snivelv v. Snivelv, 206 Pa. Super. 278,
212 A. 2d 905 (1965) (parent cannot bargain away the right of a
minor child to adequate support). See ~ Sonder v. Sonder, 378
Pa. Super. 474, 549 A.2d 155 (1988) (II [Section 3105] preserves to
2 The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has granted allocatur in
Nicholson and a decision is pending. See Nicholson v. Combs, 540
Pa, 613, 656 A.2d 119 (1994).
3 ~ ~ Knorr v. Knorr, 527 Pa. 83, 588 A.2d :03 (1991),
where our Supreme Court held that while parties to a divorce had
the right to bargain between themselves, such parties
have no power [] to bargain away the rights of
their children. Their right to bargain for
themselves is their own business. They cannot
in that process set a standard that will leave
their children short. Their bargain may be
eminently fair, give all that the children
might require and be enforceable because it is
fair. When [the parties' aqreement] qives
less than can be qiven to provide for the best
interests of the children, it falls under the
jurisdiction of the court's wide and necessary
powers to provide for that best interest.
4
J .1\52014.96
the court the ability to modify child support, [an areal where the
ability of the court to ensure that the child's best interests are
served has always been regarded as being of paramount
importance.") (Beck, J., concurring and dissenting) (emphasis
added) .
In the instant case, the trial court relied on Nicholson
v. Combs, suora, in concluding that the parties' bargained- for,
non-modifiability provision for child support could not be
reduced.4 We find that the trial court properly relied on
Nicholson in reaching its determination, and furthermore, we agree
with the reasoning of the above-cited cases that a reduction of a
child support order does not comport with the best interests of
the child. Thus, we find that the trial court did not err in
denying appellant's petition without a hearing.S ~ Knorr,
suora (appellee father entitled to to have his petition to reduce
support considered on its merits where father did not seek to
modify the agreement entered into between the parties, but rather
sought to reduce amount of the support order entered by the court
in response to a separate and dietinct petition filed by appellant
4 While the Nicholson court did not specifically analyze Section
3105, it relied on Sonder v. Sonder in reaching its conclusions,
and the Sonder Court did analyze Section 401.1, which has since
been replaced by Section 3105.
5 Furthermore, we note that appellant did have the opportunity
to present the trial court with evidence supporting her request to
reduce her child support payments at the October 5, 1995, hearing
on father's petition for contempt. Appellant's Brief at 11.
Accordingly, we find that appellant has failed to establish that
her due process rights were violated.
5
, ..
.
SHARON E. MoMICHAEL
Plaintiff, Respondent
VB.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
NO. 94-3440 civil 1994
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL
Defendant, Petitioner
NOTICE
Legal proceedings have been brought against IOU
alleging, aaong other things, you have willfully d sobeyed an
order of court for support.
If you wish to defend against the claim set forth in the
following pages, you may but are not required to file in
writing with the Court your defenses or objections.
YOU SHOULD TAKE TillS PAPER '1'0 YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO
NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE
THE OFFICE SET FORTII BELOW '1'0 FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET
LEGAL HELP I
Court Administrator
4th Floor, Cumberland Co. courthouse
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717)-240-6200
....
NAY 211006tf
SHARON E. McMICHAEL
Plaintiff, Respondent
vs.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
NO. 94-3440 civil 1994
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL
Defendant, Petitioner
ORDER
You, sharon (McMichael) Riddle~ respondent, must appear
in person in court on~, n, IQql,1 at~'X>ftr1, in
Room ~ Cumberland do-. Courthouse.
IF YOU DO NOT APPEAR IN PERSON, THE COURT MAY ISSUE A WARRANT
FOR YOUR ARREST AND YOU MAY BE COMMITTED TO JAIL.
If the court finds that you have willfully failed to
comply with its order for support, you may be found to
be in contempt of court and committed to jail, fined or
both.
J .
,
. /
/
I
I
DATE OF ORDERI
~11(ld ,jE, /(if(,
1
/
/
/'
. ..
. i
;LI,. .
- , , J
4. Respondent is not oomplying with said Order and has
willfully failed and/or refused to pay in accordanoe with
the Order of this Honorable court. Respondent has made
only sporadic and token payments since the date of said
order, with an aggregate total of $265.00.
5. The additional arrearages under the Order amount to
approximately $2,456.
6. Respondent has flatly stated to Petitioner. and others
that she will steadfastly continue to defy the Orders of
this Honorable Court.
7. Respondent has engaged in a pattern of expensive legal
maneuvering in a blatant attempt to avoid responsibility
for payment of support for her minor children, including
the filing of appeals of previous decisions of this
Honorable Court in the superior Court of pennsylvania,
all of which are additional financial burdens upon both
Petitioner, Respondent and their minor children all
without any apparent good motive or reason.
8. Respondent is able to comply with the Order entered by
this Honorable court.
9. The Agreement made a part of this Honorable courts
original Order specifically allows an award for counsel
fees and expenses incurred in its enforoement.
10. Petitioner has incurred significant expenses in the
enforcement of the original Agreement of the Parties and
the subsequent Orders of Court.
WHEREFORE, Petitioner prays that a Rule be granted on
Respondent to show why she should not be held in contempt
of Court for failure to comply with said Order of
support. Petitioner further prays that this Honorable
Court grant him an award of counsel fees and expenses
necessarily incurred in the enforcement of this action.
, ESQUIRE
ad
PA 17055
CHARLES R. GER
4725 Charles
Mechanicsburg,
(717) 975-3536
Counsel for Petitioner
Attorney I.D. 132888
~w,rt ~ ~ 'hht"ttl/
Pe it n r
I verifY that the statements made in this Petition for
contempt are true and correct. I understand that false
statements herein are Inade subjeot to the penalties of 18 Pa.
Cons. stat. seotion 4904 relating to unsworn falsifioation to
authorities.
IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA
SHARON E. MCMICHAEL/RIDDLE
PLAINTIFF,
VS.
JEREMY J. MCMICHAEL
DEFENDANT,
CUSTODY
I
I
94-3440 CIVIL TERM
CERTIFICATE Qf SERVICE
I, Charles R. Gerow, Esquire, do hereby certify that I am
this day serving a copy of the foregoing Petition for
contempt upon Linda M. Gross, Esquire, attorney for
Respondent, in the following manner I
By united states Mail, postage pre-paid tOI
Linda M.
52 South
York, PA
/J1"" Z f1 /lf9t
Gross, Esquire
Duke Street
17401
BYI
CHARLES R. GEROW,
4725 Charles Road
Meohanicsburg, PA 17055
717-975-3536
Attorney 1.0. #32888
Counsel for Petitioner
If)
",
..
UI ;':1 .
<; : ':
I" \..:.. <J
L"
C, '.') .'
, (',
E.. ,
, I
I I.....
I , )
( ..
.,
C~;1l'1'I ~'J CM'I-: ANII 'I'IIANHM 1'lurAI. ew II"COIUl
l/NIIIW
I'ENNSYI,vANIA 1I111.1': 01' AI'I'I':J.I,^,I'" 1'1I0CI':lllJIIB 1931 tel
--..---.---..--...- -. .._..-'.-- ...---.-.'.-------..- -
'1'0 the I'rothonotal'y 01 I he Appelldte Court to which the
withIn lI1atter hils been ilppeilled:
Sl/I'EIlIOII mllrl' ell-' I'EI>HlYI,VIINIA
TilE UN()(WHIGNfW, I'rotllonol.i1ry of the Court of C0ll1111on Pleas
of __._~l8nd County, t1w !wid court beIng a court of record.
do hereby certIfy 1:1101t ilnnexed hereto ill il I.rue and correet copy
of thc wbole and cnlire record. including i1n opinion of the court
aB required by PA Il.A.I'. 1<J2r), I.he orIgilwl papers and exhibits,
if any on file. the transcript 01 the proceedings, if any. and the
docket entries in the following lI1atter:
i
!
lJ I ~
,",.
n:!
t,'
L.
L,'
iL
I~'.
Case No. 94-3440 civil Term; No. 84 HOG 1996
SIIAIION E. Mr:MICIIAEL
. j
VB.
.1
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL
'-
The documents comprising the record have been numbered
from No.1 to No. 122 ,and attached hereto as Exhibit A is a
list of the documents correspondingly numbered and identified with
leasonable definiteness, including with respect to each document,
the number of pages comprising the document.
The date on which the record has been trapsmitted to the
appellate court is February 29, 1996
(Oeal of Court)
l: {1.Mr
Prothonotary
An additional copy of this certificate is enclosed. Please
lIign and date copy, thereby acknowledging .-eceipt of this record.
RECORD RECEIVEDl
Datol
ReCAlvmf In 8111'lI1r1or Court
(signature & title)
i~A!I 1 rfJ%
HARRII-iOlJHl,
Ct:IlTH'ICM'I': ANI> 'l'IlANBMI'I""A1, (H' 1lI':COIlIl
IINUlW
!'ENNSYloVANI A!!.l!I.I'Q!:: 1\1'1!1'~I~I.A:~I':I'!I()<;I'I)IJlm 1931.-!JU
'1'0 the I'rothonotill"y 01 lho Appellillo Court to which tho
within matler has boon appoil]od:
SlJI'F.llIOII CDJll'I' <W I'IN>flYINIINI^
TilE IINDEIlSIGNEIl. I'rothonotary 01 Iho COlll"1 of Common I'le.1s
of CIntlorland County. the Baid coul"l heing a court of record.
do hereby certify tllilt annexed herolo IB iI tnw and correct copy
of the whole and entire record. includIng an opinIon of tho court
as requIred by "A II.A.I'. 1925. the orlCJinill p.lpers and exhibits.
if any on file. the transcript of the proceedings. If any. and the
docket entries in the following matter:
Case No. 94-3440 civil Term; No. 04 1I0G 1996
BII^RON E. McMICIlAEI,
VB.
JEREMY J. McMICIlAEI,
The documents comprising the record have been numbered
from No. 1 to No. 122 . and attached hereto as Exhibit A is a
li~t of the documents correspondingly numbered and identified with
reasonable definiteness. including with respect to each document,
the number of pages comprising the document.
The date on which the record has been transmitted to the
appellate court is February 29, 1996
(Seal of Court)
An additional copy of this certificate is enclosed. Please
sign and date copy, thereby acknowledging receipt of this record.
IlECOIlD RECEIVEDI
Datel
18iCJnature & title)
CUllllihlllWCllllh ul I'CIIIII)'lvllllill
("UUIII)' uf CUlllhClIlIl1l1
} u:
I, 1.,1wnmce (':. We I ker ,I'rulhullutllry
uf the Cuurl uf CummulI l'lelll ill IIl1d fur IlIid
CUllllty. du herch)' ,'cllil)' Ihllt Ihc IIIICguillg il 0
lull.lruc 1111I1 ,"Hlerl cupy ullhe whule lecnrd ufthe
cIIse thereill !Il1lcd, whereill
Sharon \.;. Mt:MichileL
1'llIintilr. IInd
Case No. 84 HOG 1996
,Ierrnlj' ,). Mr:M I <'I iii" 1
I>elendonl _, a. the same remains uf recurd
helOle Ihe said ("uull 01 No, 94 - ]4 4 0 01
Civil Term.^.1>.19~,
hove hereunlo sel my halld alld lllfi~ed the seol ul .aid Court
,ay( 'lrllarv uJX'
In TI'S nMONY WIlI'ItI'OF, I
Ihi. Twenty-ninth
1IIIllhllnllllry
I. Ilarold E. Sheely l'residenlJudgeollhe. Ninth
Judicial Dislriel. composed ul Ihe County of Cumberland, do eerlily thai Lawrence E. Welker.
Prothonotanr , by whom the ollne~ed record, certificate and
olleslotinn were made ond given, IInd who. In his own proper handwriting, Ihereunlo subscribed his name
ond olfi~ed Ihe seal ollhe Cnull 01 Common I'leolufsllid County. wos. olthetimeulsodoing, and now II
I'rothonolary in and lor said COli nIl' of Cllmberlarrl In
the Commonweolth 01 l'eunl)'lvanlo, duly eommlssiuned ond qualified IU1111 ufwhOie aetsusueh lull lalth
and eredil ore and uughtlu hc given 05 well III COlllls of judicalure os elsewhere, and thotlhe sold record.
eertifieale ond IIl1eslalinn arc in due form of low ond achy Ihe ~rn~er ullieer, ',. Q..
(L \~'-;\ L ~J\...(v
I'Ir\lllcnt .Iudric
Conllllonwellllh of I'cnns)'lvllllla
Counly ul Cumberland
} ss:
I. . Lawrence E. Welker . I'rolhullolary uf the COUll 01 Commoll )'Ieuln
IIl1d lur Ihe sllid COUllt)'. dll cerlily thotlhe Ilunulllhle lIarolcl E. Sheely
h)' whumlhe fureguing IIl1cstllliun WIIS made, IInd who has Ihereuntu suh.erihed his lIame, Will, otthe time
ul mllkillg Ihereul, IIl1d still is I'residenl Judge of the CuurlulCummuu l'lells. Orphall' Cuurt and Court 01
Quaficr Sessiulllul Ihe I'ca,'c illllod for said CUllllty, duly Cummlssiulled olld quolified; 10 011 whose aell
liS such lulllailh IIl1d crcd,llllC lIud uughtlu he givell. as well in ("ulIIIs 01 jlldiclIlure os elsewhere.
INII:STlMONY WIII'III:OF. I hove herculltll
ICI lilY halld IIl1d IIHixcd Ihc scalllf soid CUllrllhis
k?" ,,' -'cl."__ ^:242,;.-
_~~~Lt
~ PWlhUlIlllilf)
I J ~ ,.J J
..5 ~,
~ I
'" 0
Q U
j j ~ ~ III
0 l
u
III ~
r-I III
~ ,~ H ~ H S
> ti ti
a- .~
a- U lE lE ~
r-I > ~ 'B
0 . . .. it
~ " III ~ Il.
... ~ 1
M ~ ~ III
I X
or or III 1
CD a- Il( E ,.J '"
ci ci III ~ ~ E ~ ~
~ 0 Ji
'7 Z .: u
.
Anlllng lhe l~ecord5 And ProcccdinR' cnrollcd in lhe courl of ('nllll11lln picAs In And fllr lhe
counlyof
Cunberlllnd
No. 84 1100 1l)<J6
94-.1440 civil 'I'eou
lerl11. 19 ___ II CIlnlAlned Ihe fllllowing:
_______.___.n_ inlhe COllll11llnwcAlth of Pcnlnylvnnin
III No.
COPY OF
^lJPCI'lrllllCO
,___ DOCKET ENTRY
HIlAIION Il. McMICHAl-:I,
VS,
.JEREMY .J. McMICIlAEJ.
I'NiE 00.
I - u JWle 24, 1994, Callplaint, filed,
7 Oct. 3, 1994, Praecipe to Transmit: Hecord, filed.
8 Oct. 3. 1994, Acceptance of Service, filed.
l) Oct. 3, 11)94, Plaintiff's Affidavit of Consent, filed.
10 Oct. 3. 1994, ~fendant 's Affidavit of Consent, filed.
11 - 34 Oct. 3, 1994, Agreement, filed.
3~ Oct. 11, 1994. Final Decree in Divorce, entered.
By: Edgar B. l~lyley, .J.
36 - 42 Aug. 9, 22. 1996, Petition for Contempt, and Order of Court, filed.
/lND Nail, this 22nd day of August, 1995 a Rule is entered against Sharon
Il. McMictklel to show cause why she should not be adjudged in contempt of
court. Rule returnable at a hearing to be held in contempt of court. Rule
returnable at a hearing to be held in Courtroan No.2, Cll11berland County
Courthouse at 2130 p.m., ThursdilY, Septemher 28, 1995, at which time Sharon I.
McMichael is ordered to appear.
By the Court, cdgar n. Bay ley, J.
41 - 44 Oct. 5, 1995, Order of Court, filed.
/lNO Nail, this 5th day of October, 1995, following a hearing, IT IS ORDE '01
(1) The petition to hold Sharon E. (McMichael) (llddle in contempt for
failing to coply with the custcx:ly provisions in a l1Iarital settlement agree-
IOOnt that was incoI'JXlrated into a final decree in divorce by an order of
October 11, 1994, IS DENIED. The l!\Jther, however, frno this date forward,
shall provide the father at least five (5) days notice when she is not ~ing
to exercise her ten1JXlrary physical custcxly rights.
(2) A petition to hold Sharon E. (McMichael) IUddle in contempt for not
carrying nedical coverage on the parties' t\\\l children IS DENIED since the
children are being covered free in a govermcnt pro9r,lIn. Should that free
coverage cease, the lI'Other shall be l'es(Ylnsihle, as per the order of October
11, 1994, to either provide health insurance coverage through an employer's
policy or reimburse the father for such addil:ional cost ,1S lIlay be necessary
to add the children to health insurance coverage throllgh his employer.
(3) Sharon E. (McMichael) Iliddle ill itdjudlcittcd In contempt for failure
to pay re9111arly $337 per oDnth for the sllPlxlrt of her t wn minor children as
pet' the order of October 11, 1994. The nnt her shall P1trge herself of conteml
by hereafter t::IlI1ely 11'<1king such payncnts tCK}ether wi t h $50.00 per nDnth on
accollnt of arrearages.
By the Court, I'llllar B. lIity I "y, ,J.
NlJv. U, 1995, Petition for Sped,ll He I II'f, 1'1 I [~l.
Nov. 17, I'J95, artier of COllrt, f i1 ed.
/lN1l NeW, this 17th day of November, I IJ'J'i , ,I HilI<' i,; elltered againsf
defendallt, .Jeremy J. McMichael, to Bhow GlIlSe why till! 1l!llef requested shoul!
. - f'ffilbre-tJoj J~ ""oJ""l H .1. ty=t1
1'1ailll.\Ir Hhilll fHe in tllin Chillllberfl it nHlnl'dllChun with legal authority ill
Buprnrt of h(~r rnAif-inn nnt li1tpr thilll IIdrl" lUll ,hu,' fn...,l1 Hdn ,1...,.,... 'rh,.,
45 - 74
75
PNE t<<>.
issue will be decided withollt II IIO.lrln~).
By the COllrt, 1'~I!liII. II. lIilyley, .1.
JI.U1. 16, 1996, (~)inion and Onlor of COllrl, riled.
^NO tn-I, LhiA 16th day of .I/lllllllry, )<J<J(" the within pet it: ion, IS IJISMIS Ell.
By \:110 Court, EdlJilr n. Bayely, .J.
.Ian. 19, 1996, lleHpondent, .len~ny ,I. Mc:M\c:lliml'H, ^nHwor In !'eUtton for
Special Ilellef and New Malte,., rllL'(I.
.Ian. 25, 1996, Notice of ^ppcal, riled.
Notice is hereby given t:hilt S1klmn E. McMkhael, !'1,1intlfr above named,
hereby appealH the Order of COllrt: of the Court. or Crmlnn !'leml or CUlloorland
County, l'ennsy1vanlo to the Superior Court of I'enllsylvanl.l entered in this
mller on the 16th day of Janllllry, 1996. This onler (illtm:hed to this noUe
hilS been entercd in the docket: ilS evidenced hy \:Ill'! .,\lm:hecl r:opy of the
dor:ket: entry.
By: Linda M. Gross. Esq.
99 - 100 Feb. 7, 1996, SUI~rior Court of Pennsylvania Notice of ^ppeal Docketing
to No. B4 HOG 1996, filed.
101 - 122 Feb. 26, 1996, Transcript of Proceedings, filed.
7~
(conI. )
76 - Bll
81 - 8'l
'lll - IJll
"
1.1,
.
. ... . ... ... ... ....... ."1 ... '. ... ... .:c. _ .lI/.. .;c. ... ... .~. )::.. -:W<>ft('>>>;>M< '.. '. "''411<'"
. -~-- - .-~~-~--.- ...----.-- ",--~--._, --~~-. .
..
.
8
,
,
.
.
8
.
8
8
8
8 ...J~REMY J. McMICHAEL,
.
.
i
8
.
.
.
I
,
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
STATE OF .. PENNA.
SHARON E.. McMICI/IIEI"
No. .... 91~}440CJyu' 1994
Plaintiff
,
"
v",.us
Defenrlant
I
II
il
,I
DECREE IN
d'VORCE
AND NOW, ..\?(~~.......... U......., 19.91... It Is ordered and
decreed that...........,.. .~\II\I~Qt:J. .I;.., ~f~.MTCJlAEr.....".."... plaintiff,
and",......",..."....,.. .J.f,llf.l'-1,Y, ,<7 ....t1r.t:1,t.c:,,~f..4,....,,'" defendant,
are divorced from the bonds of matrimony.
The court retains jurisdiction of the following claims which hove
been raised of record In this action for which a final order has not yet
been entered; NONE
",.,., :r,~I/l, ,ilgrP,CI1)'illl.t, .Qf. ,/'\\)911.8,1;, (,2"" 19,~1, 1.8, ,l)\!r,~ ,I,tJr;\lr.tNrfl.t.qd
..,.". ,1,IJ~p .I,I)\!, 1':(1)(1.1 ,T:JIY,'1r:c;r-. ,l?\,~.r,qq..""..", '//'" ,/"..,.,..
/ / I
( / .'
lIy Th'~~1(' ...
Allell, ,.(.1'/'11"7.",,,- t. W,)kL-ll\c?"Il'~,Lu.; J.
7J.} : (;'11t1/.! fJ,- r/ H~1r':I1.- /.Kt(lu.:t1
Prothonotary
'" ".,.. "'."" .. '.,' . . - ".... --" " , -- """ 'il!
.. ... . ... ... '. .;c. '*' 'w., 'ltC. .w.. 'le. 'llC' .w.. ':.:. ,w.. .w., ~. .:-:. -:.:. .w.. :w..'
8
.
.
.
8
.
~
8
,
8
.
.
.
t
.
.
.
,
8
>'I
8
.
~
-
.
~
*
Ei
8
~
~
~
8
~
,
~
~
~
I ..Jt;.'
. ...
. . "
IN TIIEJ.:OURLOfo'XOl\l1\lOIH)1EAS_m~
..cUMBERLANDCOUNl'Y. J'ENNSYL\'ANJA
SIIARON E, McMICIIAH/lmmu:
PJ,AIN'I'WJi,
VS.
ClJsroJ)V
JEREMV J. McI\IICIIAt:L
O.:....:NJ)AN'I'.
94.3440 CIVIL Tt:RM
Ar!Sl\'Ell'I'ORESPDNUtNT'S.Nt\\'.1\lA'IHR
1-21. No responsive pleading is requircd and that thcse paragraphs have alrcady been
addresscd thc Pctitioncr's allcgations sct forth in her original Pel it ion
22 Admilled in part and dcnicd in part It is admittcd that an Ordcr IVas entered on
Octobcr 5, 1995 adjudicating Sharonltiddlc in contcmpt and ordcring hcr to make timely
payments pursuant to thc Propcrty Scttlcmcnt Agrccmcnt cntcrcd into by the parties. It is
denied that thc finding IVas corrcct
21 Admillcd in part and dcnicd in parI It is admittcd that the Honorable Court has
jurisdiction ovcr thc support matter 1I0lVcver, hy IVay orthrthcr answcr, thc malleI' has
bccn appcalcd to thc Supcrior Court of Pcnnsl'lvilnill As IIlcsuh, pursuant to the Rulcs of
Appellllnt Proccdure Rulc, Ihis lIonorllblc Court lacks jurisdiction ovcr thc matter until the
Supcrior Court has fhlly rcspondcd tothc Appcal
24. Admillcd in part IInd dcnicd in purt It is admittcd thatlhcrc are arrears olVing to the
Respondent in this casc and thatthc full amount ofthc monthly paymcnts had not hccn
made by thc Pctitioncr By way of fllrthcr anSlVcr, thc Pctitioncr is is f1nancially unahlc to
makc Ihll paymcnts pursuantlotcrms ofthc Ilropcrtl' Sclllcmcnt Agrecmcnt Thc
Pctitioncr has rcqucstcd that this Ilonornhle COll11 schcdulc a (lccreasc rcvicw hcaring
pursullntto Scction3105 (b) ofthc Divolcc Codc of 1980 liS Amcndcd 123 Pa C S
Scction3105 (b) I Thc lIonol'llblc Court has dcnicd thc rcqucst of the Petitloncr despitc
..
the provision of the Divorce Code which allows modification of child support as set forth
lnlhe Property Selllement Agrccmcnt.
25 Denied
WHEREFORE, the Petitioncr, Sharon Riddle respectfully requests that this
Honorable Court dcny thc request as stated in the Respondent's New Maller and forego
the scheduling of hearing until the Supcrior Court has had the opportunity to address the
appcaled issues. Furthcrmorc, inthc event that this Honorable Court determines that it
has jurisdiction over the enforcement of the Property Selllement Agreement. at this time,
Petitioner respectfully requests that this Court schedule a hearing allowing Petitioner the
opportunity to present evidence In support of her contention that amount of support is
excessive based upon her present income and her unemployment compensation.
Respectfully su~milled,
I
,
"
:
INlllECOU RT m~ COJ\t1\10lSl'.LEASjlE
.1JlMBERLAND_CUUNIT.l'.t:NNSYL~1A
SHARON E. McMICIIAELI Rmnu:
PLAINTIFF,
VS.
CIJSTOny
JEREMY J. McMICIIAEL
DEFENnANT,
94.3440 CIVIL TERM
CERIlElCATE 01' SERVICE
I. Linda M. Gross. Esquire hereby am certilying that 1 alll this day serving a copy
ofthe foregoing Answer to counsel for Defendant, Charles Gerow. Esquire in the
followinglllanner:
BY UNITED STATES MAIL TO
Charles Gerow, Esquire
4725 Charles Road
Mechanicsburg. P A 17055
Respectfully s~~i:)ed,
Lind M Gross, Esquire
52 , outh Duke Street
Yo PA 17401
(717) 852.7232
Supreme Court I.D 1158999
.,.
':"..... 1.1')
I' \-.
i .. .
I'l' \', i
\" I,' I
I .- )
( ,
,
L~
I
'-
. ,
..
.
, . '.'..
..
SHARON E, McMICHAEL/RIDDLE.
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
V.
JEREMY J. McMICHAEL.
Defendant
94-3440 CIVIL TERM
ORDER.JIF. .COURT
AND NOW, this 18th day of June. 1996. following a
hearing on 0 petition of Jeremy J, McMichoel to hold Shoron E,
McMichoel in civil contempt for foiling to comply with the terms
ond conditions of the porties' marital settlement agreement. the
Rule entered on Moy 23. 1996. IS MADE ABSOLUTE. A heoring on
final adJudicotion sholl be held in Courtroom No, 2, Cumberland
County Courthouse. Corlisle, PennsYlvonio. ot 3:45 p.m..
Wednesdoy, June 26. 1996, ot which time Shoron E. McMichael is
ordered ond directed to appear,
By the
(
BaYley. J.
I
Linda M. Gross. Esquire.
For Plaintiff ~~
Chorles R. Gerow. ESqUire41;i~
For Defendont
: prs
~ Cl ',-
,..
lil ..
~ .. {j~
!Xl 'l~
It ~
.,
( I.'
"tM
'" !O
.11. 1~
.,.
1.'1 .
rfl:' ::r: "
~
r. "
l' I.()
0 C'
FlLtD-Or-F1CE
OF T/T r "."" ''''UnI'
9G JI.!I ~a HI 3: :'6
Cu. 'I;'; ",I,.
";c.L' \',..1 ~ ;," \,. 'oJ", 1
PEN,,\SYLVN\[,\
~r
IN TilE SlJI'EIUOI{ COllin (W I'ENNSVLV ANIA
IIAIUUSlJlllW IHSTIUCT
CElnlFICATE OF CONTENTS OF I{EMANIn:n IU:COl{n
I'A. ItA.!'. 2571 ANn 2572
TIlE UNDERSIGNED. ChiclTlerk of thc Superior Cuurlof Pcnnsylvanla. Ihe
said Court being u Cuurlof Record. dues hcrehy cerlify IIml unnexed 10 the uriglnal
hereof is a Irue und correct copy of the whule und entire record us remanded from said
Cuurt. inlhe foIlowingmllller:
I'artsl 1 purl
Capllon & noekel Numbers:
Sharon E McMichael
v
Jercmy J McMlchuel
Dockel Nu. 84 Ilarrlsburg. 1996
Cummon Plcus Court Cumberland Co. No. 94.3440 Civil renn
In compllllnce with Pennsylvuniu Rules of Appellule Procedure 2571.
The dalc on which thc rccord hus hccn remunded Is NOV.1 9 \997
An udditlonal cupy of this cerllt1cule Is enelosed wllh the original hcreof. and Ihe
Clcrk of Prolhonotary uf Ihc lowcr cuurl or Ihe heud. chalrmun. dcpulY or sccrelary of Ihe
governmenl unit Is hcrchy dlrectcd to ucknowledlle rceelpt of the rcmundcd record by
executing such cupy atlhe pluce indicaled und by lilrlhwlth rClurningthe same.
fJ~tl.tJ
ChicI' Clerk - II1Irrishurg District
Superiur Courl of Pennsylvanill
IUlCOIUJ. ete. IUlC!HVED DATE
I. th,. ,.Jf1p...;t., PI,.t'~)I.t~
~N.tll,,,,.ll
'"
",1
'"
/.
~il
II Ii
i,l ~IA (; d
1.1 ~. :!
I," ;1
,!'/>;Y1ijl
J i I.
,iI' /"'1 ,I
1//1 II.
, I," 'If '/" :
'I' , ,
',I I
Illi /~ I
/. ,I, i'i :I~ I
II, ' I
U 1 ,/,}~S I'
I '
y 1 , '
l' I
10 /'J;'II'
II ~'lrl,;!
, ,I
IJ "
" Ii
1.1 il!'<:' ill II
IJil,~i;'7f 'lei'
't'" ,
1')1 /~'I;'''r ,.
'1/,. ,/J II
Ii . ,:
Ibll . ii
t:;fl~I/7.\'S ,I
. iII!>i,'?l;\
IVI'I~/f9f Ii
,u r ';
:j ! ;1
lill/,';r\ ,I
ii' I' ,I t!
)}li~/i1:'il II
II' , I'
nlf~:f;li~ ;1
lJil.%',., 9s '.1
I ' '1
1',11 d
illt /' '!
nil/I 95' I,
I u /f n
IIi ,/ I, (~ :I
i I" ...,' ~! '
JIIII?, Ii
i'I>~ ,J~ ,I
lil,1 ' q
"'11 ' ;.
'8/. "
II .:'1/'''1 (' '.,1
! . ~ ,.) Ij
1.'1' ,!
II ' II
"i.' /' "
i'/' Ir"
"!'~iS .,
",Yi.,H
I ii J \ 'I
)'/'"1''1 11,1((.1 ii II'
,...11..;."",/1/ ji ) ,/,.:,,") Ii I
Ii i
'I II ! , !! 'II II
\ "'<('1 II I' I
I I' .1 I
I I:' , II,., I 11
II ' '.. I 11.." 1 t' I)
Ii ~ i,lj~~"t~~f'''~ j~('~l (I
, , 'I 1\
i" :, .J.h1/ldj II,',,'
:....i.~,1 U ii "I,,:"'~fr/~~'1\l>fi ~j"1"'" . 6
I .' Ii t\lIjI (W!( 1~,"dJjjtl, ,I
<iLl/coil ,', IIU
;JIUJt, H'!" I II i;"
I I. 'i I I' 19
i I II'! I
, jl I I' i 10
i: . I, , , I!! I
0,1 ,,~() II I, II
,"'" I rl.' 'I ti , 11
I' ,I!
. I I: 13
" I II
II d ; 14
, !!! I 11 1
,'vntJo i II ; 15
'. ; .! I It ' 1"116
" . i'
I II :1
I Ii \I II'::
, ,',' II II"
119
II:~
!' ,
I' :,1, I i, iln
',In
. j i 'I Ii II
li~'1' odl !: 1'1' Iii'
: ' ," Ii 'I ill\
I i;., ~ . I I ; I . ; , , ; I \:
': I !iJI""ldlll'~:Jlw~lfl<'~ t
,I ,ItYII,llJ'..1 .11HlIoHJj.'.{f~";I "!'1"!.I! I
I :, IJI~I{ ~:fIj,l. H ,... [ilU
I I liJY
1,1.(t I:W" ." "
.1
iPO
'I
(II
,I
IIJI
,I
!lll
liH
ii
TIll
,I J
d
jl a"l~fll~t ,I ..J,I..I<,(,,(
II (""1"'.1 Ii frlt''''.t
II i I Ii ,/"' ""'''Ufl
, '. /,t<. 'I' ',n) I'
11. " "'\ I, '
I, II' .1
I' 2 i I I' I I lilt>
:1 ;'()oUi "'.1
'I ,. I 'II ,! I
t,ll ':. :' I I,,;.. 1
i ,j,,; o.):! ;5nl""
I ,i!l ' i
'I '3., lui!3 \ II,u
I ) .. ~ Ii ! ,l' !
:1.11 '5:)[. ):1 'J'l)(.o
1 It! 'Ii :! ' I
:, :,,- I.u!i I
11 i! ,. ~" 1 j , I
:i " I
1,11,1 :~:om;! :~~L+~
JL-ll.>" I
l: ': I l' ,I I
Ii SPflJ i 1
II ; :7+';;' ,J3.7r' ,
Ii ! i~:~~lj I
ill I ! i j ;; t' !' ; I
/,.11'1 i !!Iol";>' i! .3,\...-ll'"
:,<\c.lli; , '
II ' :, I! ! f'
'III 'n''''.: ' ,I,
., I i!
,I S'o\.ui i
!! . ~ 1 :1 I
ii !
~; I 'I I! oj , i I
,. I " I
i; . 0" "ll) ': '} pO,
H i .--, " H . ' , I,
i;~<lClD' i
:; ~, 1 ' h 1
'" i' ,
,1 '! I 1
"I . j .. !
.) . l ' 3 J I
H 1 ,,'L.ll '\I !.: _ .I:U'
p 1:1 ,.
It I' ;; I i" ." j
II }(1 !ct'. H ,;i:l. :';t.1) j,
I I .
,
Ii
ii
i!
'i
,'10t~il
; .:
qlll'O :.
~ SCC>
.H 7.c)O L
"
jl
,.
v
"11/
,,..-' ,,, 'I~'
1[/
/J7.is
J%/I
.,
It, (t'
3 ~ .1 Ct "
2el"(.
2.(..(...
I Ii
. o' l.l,
, i ;.., r h
j r
I II
'1:11,1
I ,
. , ,
" 'I .
I' I:
,1..0 .11'0 Ii
: ;j
l! i !!
i';C 11.1)!'
1"1 II
, l I:
',. i ,I
1 I'
" 'j II
/10>1,(;>.'11
I ,I Ii
- 11
! . i 'I
I . !
j,' Ii
, ' 11:/1.1j'V)j'l.
i" !.
I Ii
, ' , III
i.'i,€.l.fvjll
! I I
. , . '."1 ,'I
i;' !
, . '. il
I!! I '1
I Ii
I I:
. ' ,
, ) I'
! . '1 11
, /.7,lll"lI
1 ..
I ;1
1 i1
!. I I!
; l I'
;'.'}/i..'t:.i:
,', ! Ii
I \
, "
1 ;;
;;:,~ 11(1\
.,
l
!'
" ,
10700,1
"
,. i J,tA
5~.
;> l< , ((
Ii
, ,
. ,
, !
~ lit 900 "
it
"
",tc.ct ..
II
H
i'
H.eaw
17t,lI.
,
......N'j,,,...,
,,-, ii
Ii
II . !:
p. ",t..
11
l!i~YI
i,W9S
;j il
:,,~ '
.1 :i~. l' " ,:
I
'1/'
i!/~1'"
Ii . . ,... ~ i
Iii
"1
II Ii 'II. "
y ii
lIl,i?i '/lo
I'il:d\l:..,
1)11' ' I!
,,'i~ / ",."
,,/11 IV It
].1i!
,
I"'"
i
,l~
It!,i
)' ':~/1\1. "
, "
,~
III i ~ ~(t 'I
I', ,I
i!)'1 !;
" i!
I'
; ~!I If
;1
rll
Jj! II
I
I I:i ,
i\ t!
I';,!
" .
III ,
.1 ji
"
Jli! ,
il ,
"
Jlill iI
,
" iI
"
,I'
~') )! "
h!![ I
'I
II !: ;!
I;
i! I!
n
,ii "
, II
u,!
i;
,~~
~'- ,
"
'i
J,A."lIwj
:j tu.u.wul
:1
!i
Ii
11
II
ii
'I
,
:1
ii
II
"
,
"
Ii
ij
!i
;1
"
!1
Ii
li
it
..
I:
"
!i .
H
lj
"
:1
"
i!
,
lO~c"
2,,(0
! n
Jo:el,:
1S'Cb
,
I "
11
,Io:a:.
'0,<<> ,:
t~~
,
.e'.
S'O.w
,
: lOO;ltl,
I
!.
:i
Ii
:1
N '
il
Ii '!
1i
I'
.I
'I
!1
if" j
i!
,
i:
II
Ii
l!
it
i
l: 'I
"
"
l]
I!
I'
,I
,I
il
, '
I;
,ok'...."",,!
, '1'''',,1 i"l
.Ill.llitl\
.H 7,w,
.j J 1.0" i,
J31Cl.l,
i
H1'eI.'"
111,/b
111t\..
,n(l.:l
, )1 00"
it I'
il
!i ! i
r.
II
Ii
Ii
"
h i ~ ~ \ , I
n
it
j!
f
II
if
, .1'/"':";
, 'AI.ilIA .4'u,.t#!
l Y /00;;
,~t 7'l); Ii
,3 I 1.Oc."
.1.11.0,,:,
n 7tX)
31 l~,
1>1.00
J,ai
1,.( iJ.''1
jen,W"
"
j It CoW"
31.? (\,CO"
.,
~.o H W
I I'
~ l' lCc
, I"
'1!JJ,l/,Cb"
.'/'I,t.t:OO
"
,!
if
.'
"
,
!;
,
:1
L ! i
;1
Iii
1
ii
I!
ij
"
:1
H
!!
p.
Ii
iI
II
H
ji
"
!I
Ii
\< I j ! t
\f
!I I; I
i!
H
i'
1:
i,
Ll~(,l
t~/ I'
~, ,~\,k
::r;<\t . ~~~~r
. oi1 ~ "
I
I
.,
, ,
I
,
i .
II \
,.
t.
"
I
.'
I!
II
II
'I
I
I,
Ii
'I
I,
It
.1
'I
I,
, '
I
n
, , ,
'I
, ,
10
II
11
1:1
I
II ::
16
11
III
119
, ,
, ,
i.
.! tt j'
Ii
11
i, II'
il
! 1 'I
i '/,:.,,1
! !
I '!
I Ii
II
!i
Ii
"
~ i
I. l!
, ;1
;1
I~~
1174
,115
1116
i
IU
, '
70
II
H
Ii
i!
1'111
11'1
1110
:1.11
"
il'l
q
1"1
Iii 14
tl'l
I
!Ijf
I'
::'1
Ii
,111\
,I
',.
'I
'i
~i
il
I'
h
I
':
11
'i
fl
, I
II;'