The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About94-03697 ~ 1 ~ 1= . ., (, lJ :1 I t ~ p J r- 0- ...j r0 .' ";.;; ~~'(t fli'l ~~!~~ r~~ J KASSAB ARCHBOLD & O'BRIEN, L,L.P. By: William C, Archbold, Jr. Attorney I,D, No, 08605 By: Richard A. Stanko Attorney I,D. No, 29973 214 N, Jackson Street Media, PA 19063 (610) 565-3800 MOLLY DIANE HOPFER and CHARLES HOFFER, JR" wife and husband, Individually and as parents and natural guardians of ALLISON HOFFER and ABBY HOFPER, their minor children Plaintiffs v, TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA, INC, and GEOROE HENRY HECKADON Defendants ORDER 'I, AND NOW, this ~~ '7' I , ;JJ6 Il' Attorneys for Plaintiffs : COURT OF COMMON PLBAS : CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PA : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED , , : NO, 94-3697 Civil Term day of I" .'l" t; ,'IlL:' " (l_ II , 1996, upon consideration of the foregoing Petition of Plaintiffs for Court Approval of a Minor's Compromise, It is hereby ORDERED and DECREED that a hearing shall be held on the _fL.t~ .' , i)' j ,', ( { I .r of finalizing said Petition, day of , 1996 at , I ' II II {(\ I I l I I ,',,/ J, .'. ' (' () o'clock for the purposes 5Y-o /f/L 1. ~ ,h_ !~i ' i' .. .' < ! , .... , \. - ,~, " .: 'I I , I ': III j,cl \.: - \ rt) -~ 'I i . ' I,.,;.... ' " I .",:1 1\','';(\ -i i MOLLY DIANE HOFFER IIl1d CHARLES HOFFER, JR" wife IIl1d hushlllld, IlIdlvldulllly IIl1d liS pllrellts IInd IIl1turnl gUlIrdllllls of ALLISON IIOFFER IInd AIlBY HOFFER, their mlllor children, Plulntifti; vs, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY CIVIL ACnON . LAW TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA, INC" IIl1d GEORGE HENRY HECKADON, Defelldllnts 1)4-361)7 CIVIL TERM IN RE: PLAINTIFFS' PETITION FOR COUlrf APPROVAL OF MINOR'S COMPROMISE ORDER AND NOW, this , .. II duy of Murch. !1)96, the heurlng III the uhovc captioned muller set tin MIlY 6, ]996, is rescheduled to Monday, April II, 1996,lItl):OO lI,m, III Courtroom Numher 4, Cumherllllld County Courthouse, Cllrllsle, PA. WlIIlllm C, Arehhold, Jr" Esquire A. Mllrk Wlllter, Esquire For the Plullltlffs Rohert p, Reed, ESlJulre For the Defendllnts :r1m IlY THE COURT, K--:5f;1cS~,d- I / AI ~'....... I)..<~.l..l ,)1 r,f 114. 'J ~.. a .~ 1 ' ,~j ~ (,1 ~ fTl .' . I~ ~ I') ~ o '..., \...\ ". ,. ... ~ . , / III 'Jl' ~)1 ~: /i, ~ 1; (" / I, I I' 1~('J":fl(.J, '\}fl'/.."""I(I.... . 1 J.~ ~, / ' . ) I',L' /.1 :)' \" ~ tl ,. '. ',' '\f(J' U l"' , _ ....." ' (. I' Ii - - ... 5J J () f J J . . -r ~ 11 ~. I I I ~! ~ f o r "5 - is .- II · ~j I I " . ~U~ t o c <i 'I Ui~ ;j 'E il,IIIlII!llll : ~g 11 iJ f - , U .. uJ Jlp a ~ I 0;.. .; L uu 1 '" ... j' ! J Ii! ' - 0 1= ! i#. .. " KASSAB AI{CHIlOW JACKSON & ()'IlIUEN By: William C, Arehbuld, Jr, Ally, J.D,Nu, 08605 214 N, Jackson Street Media, PA 19063 215,565.3800 .,.,-" .1 /loUt... pf'" r I~~/MOLL Y DIANE IWllIi/{ and CIIAI{L11S "" 1 ~ HOFFElt, Jlt, Wirll allll husband, CI" JY'~' . individually und us parcnts nnd ~ r J."" natural guardians of ALLISON 1I0FFEI{ V and AUBEY HOFFEI{, their minor childrcn, 5889 L1urel Strcct Harrisburg, PA 17112 Allurncy fur Plaintiffs coulrr OF COMMON PLEAS CUMIlElU.AND COUNTY, /lA Plaintirfs v, NO, 91./.. dl..1t1 CW;) I~ TRANSPOIrJ' CORPORATION OF AMERICA, INC, 142 North MaKwell Allentown, PA 1910J and JUHY THIAL DEMANDED aEOIWE HENHY IIECKADON /1,0, BOK 83 Foster, MO 64745 Defendanls I'I{AECIPE TO ISSUE WHIT OF SUMMON!; TO THE PIWTlWNOTARY: Kindly Issulla Wriluf Summuns againstlhll Delcndants In t1tllubovc mailer. ......*..- ,. ,/ .~ /',) ~ ,',1 L' . \. ~~ ill \v,'n:LlAM C; AHCIIBOLD, JR, Attorney 1\11' Pluinlirrs / / / I ..- ... .{.. - Commonwealth of Pennsylvania County of Cumberland Molly Oiane Hoffer aOO Charles Hoffer, Jr., wife and husband, individually and as parents and natural guardians of Allison Hoffer and Abbey Hoffer, their minor children 5889 Laurel Street Harrisburg, Pa 17112 Court of Conunoll Plw VI. Transport Corporation of America, Inc. 142 North Maxwell, Allentown, Pat 19103 and George Henry Heckadon P.O. Box 83, Fbster, MO 64745 No, u,9_4.:~~9L\;j.xU_:r_~IJ!1mu_._._.. 19._.. III __._~..i.~g_.!lS~~ffi:~~____m___m____m_ To '!'!!'I.l}~~.r::t~fllp?r!l_UQ!luQL~tJ9,l!l_lJlq. and George Henry Heckadon You art Imtby notilitd that Molly Diane Hoffer and Charles Hoffer, Jr., wife and husband, individually and as paieiitii-iiiicf -iiiiturai-gua@"{aiisnof'AYiIsori-iiCiHei-Brrl'Ai:ii:iey- iioffer;-thi;rr'iiiiiiCir"ctiI1dren tlle Plaintiff havecolllmtnced all action In _..Ci'lll_Lm'l.u...__._.__.___u_.___________....______ agalllll )'Ou which you an! requin!d 10 ddtl1d or a default judgment lIlay be ellten!d agalnll you. (SEAL) ,.!,{l:t{lJ.!OI:Jt _~J _ .It~!~!l.r.., '.m_.'.'....,... _ ____ Prolhonotal)' Date ...J~.7._.._____uu__u___ 19,.!l.4. Dy ..,~/~~-~Z.r?!p~~-----.------"---". , , /1(/ 1 tI ,;I .J Ir I ~q 4) , I\J '( (,,' I'> /11..$';111. ' , " I' '1111~\ I"" ", . ).' I J"l!! (( .\~. (I ~ ~' , , . .. /J" . ( d ~ ~ . J ~~ I Ji~~.1 ~M M ~ I ~ ~ ~~q ~~ ~ 'B .& ~ ~. ~ J I I ~:>.~ i ~ u r- j~~ I r '" \D ~ M It~qi~ I ~h I ~ f '" tl '" ~ lJINIl< ~ Molly Diane Hoffer and Charles Hoffer Jr., wife and husband individually and as parents and natural guardian of Allison Hoffer and Abbey 1I0ffer their minor children vs Transport Corporation of America Inc. and George Ilenry Heckadon In the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania No. 94-3697 Civil Term Summons in Civil Action Law R. Thomas Kline, Sheriff, who being duly sworn according to law, says he made diligent search and inquiry for one of the within named defendants, to wit. Transport Corporation of America Inc. but was unable to locate them in his bailiwick. lie therefore deputized the Sheriff of Lehigh County, Pennsylvania to serve the Sununons in Civil Action Law according to law. LEIIIGH COUNTY RETURN. Return hereto attached R. Thomas Kline, Sheriff, who being duly sworn according to law, says that he served the Sununons in Civil Action Law in the following mannerl The Sheriff mailed one of the within named defendants, to witl George Ilenry Heckadon a notice of the pendency of the action by certified mail to his last known address at P.O. Box 83, Foster MO 64745. This letter was mailed under the date of July 8, 1994 and was received on July II, 1994 with return receipt card signed by George Henry Heckadon. Return receipt card is hereto attached. Sheriff's Costs. Docke ting Out of County Surcharge Lehigh Co. Cert Mail 18.00 5.00 4.00 29.15 2.29 54.88 So answerSI . / :t ~"'-d"/,:"" R. Thomas Kline, Sheriff Pd. by Atty. 7-18-94 Sworn and subscribed to before me this J/.".J. day of 1.1,1" , I 1994, A.D. - I. }r,...p[~'t~o~~~~ry t~;'\',l:;;'J<,':C- _.;'_l'~ 11;;; 1- 1\'. '. CIilllIII!.\I...1 IIndIDl. a fDl IddllJonof IIrvIct.. F' ,+C.......'.ll.m. a, end C.. b. i" 1--' rrirtt YOU' ntnM end 1ddrI1' on the ,.....fI. of tN. '0Im 10 thI. W' cln '" _lIlIowd'o"". :' - ..._ ... form to Iht front of 1M maflpltc.. at on the blck It aplCt ,.._"",,...,u. ; · . W","''llltumRlcolotRI\lUI.lod''onlhom_"bolowlholrtldonumbor 2, 0 Rnlricltd Dellvl/'( '-.- . ThI fMtutn JIltcelpt ..m ~w to whom the In'elI,," dtIIvtred and ItIt dll. : U....... Con.ull Ollm.ller 101 IN, "13' Artlcll. A. dd.....d 10: 4.. Arllell Number : Ge#Fge Henry Heckadon Z305-865 724 . P. O. Box 83 4b. Slrvlee TVp. , Foster MO 64745 0 R.gllI...d Dlnlur.d C,,'III.d 0 COD o Exprl.. Mill 0 R.'Um Rle.lpllor 7, 0111 of 0111 ~ ~. "..,....:.. ; -'.-. ..... -.,' ..iT.; :', I ,110 wllh' to recllve, lIii.., lollowlng ..IVlei. Ilor In IX"" IHI: 1. 0 Addr.I_'. Add.... ""4'!' 8, Slgn.lu.. IAglnll I'; .. . D.cemb.r 1881 oIJ,',OPO: '..........fl. "~'l .~' : ,I Ii 11111 ' 'i II! '1 1:'.1111'11" 1)1 1IIIi'.,11 (;OUldl Ii ill~;! III Hi)\ I~"ii~ 'I' 'I" j 11' . .rv. IJ . ,) ~n.1. Y III ",'it 111ft'I:" AN) 1l,)(:I\IIIWil iNIIMI1II1_..._!212.::_... 'J1i-Jh'J7 (CUMtlERI./ll'iJ) CHAkU:S hlloTLK, JR, I t::T N.. VS .. ----- TRANSPOKT CORPORATION OF 1./1',1 IllU,lIlIll I XPIIIAIIOIIIIAII __....!.!..:~/1J11 IJIi'O~i1l____....._.____~?y.15 N-ILi<l C ^ I I Nt:. I LT /II. Willi SUt'MONS IN CIVIL ACTION --- SliM TRANSPORT COf(I'ORATION Of Wf.11ICP" INC. AI 142 N, MAX\~ELL S1REt:T, (-1.I.W1O\ll\, 1'1, ---~- -~._--~_._------ ._....... ow .....................__... _n.. ..~.....'..... ...u_.. .... ..... - ..... . _... ._.._....._...... ....nu.._......................u....... NM~I OIINDIVIIJUAI SUIVLIJ III IlJlH~ 01 ~.llIvIl:I ,J" Sil(:~ aJJr'Sj _l.Jl..I~r (1'/*...d. AII()~wJ 2, III I AIIONSIIIP ro DFFENOMH :1 DAII: _ill 111.11 /If) ~ ItOlJllS 1[I.2!1-_ .1. I oeA liON OF 5UWICE -..-.-----.... --.--- [, IJlJA\lLE 10 I.OCAIE: ( ) NUMIlt:n 01 A1IFMI'I:; 10 I OCAIl' 1lllllJliMlI All N,II\HUWtl ^lJlllllSS I IJAIL 1\ lIMI _.._______.......__:' 1).\11 f,llMI 3 IlA II: f. IIML !1 IJA 11: 1\ 11M!: ,1 11t"1 1\ IIW Ii IJAII ,~ IIMI AccrPIANL[ fir :c1:1i\'ILl II1[H!.BY ALClI' I clRI'IU Of llll 1I GM l'IiOC! ~~ A~', \JUllllillliJI< 1>" 1I10'1I Of '''' Iii 'LlIIII NI 1I11~, HI1VIClISAClll'llll ON ClIIAU' 0' 1111 liS IIIl DlfUmMlIl:1 N.!1II1! lilil' CLlill1 Y 11<0\11 AI,\ ^IJIIlGliIZI iJ 10 PI) [.f) 1'1i:1<1I [) NM.W 0' AlIIIll)li17[IJ MllfH ~.;iCiW\lUm Of AIJ1/i1;1,1.'[ n A(iH~l I!.\II , 11;~l ---,-"p-,_.~--"-_..- .... ............__..............~.n......--.-.. .., ........._......._..... _u.~_" ....... ,'. ...... ~....-... ........... SW(lIW-ff~1J SIJlI~;t:1l1111U jlllOll1 MI III1S . / Y t IJA Y III I.:Y" jt If- 1~1 7'/. ' . i'-, I ' , I , I.f. I. ' _____..~)-~u!,,1....,~-- bU Af~:iI'vl H,.__A~ 4....-1;2---' , / 1) i'IJlYmlll~ll:y/ . '. 1 "'. , _II',J" , .. . . '..,.',f,,(,/I AU I ' .. 1 · ..' _..~ 1111111 01 IIIIIGII COWJ IY _o! : PIII,':l' . Commonwealth of Penllsylvania County of Cumhel'lund ~l()ll\' !llnll!! lIorfer .Ilkl ['Ikld.." 1I0frer, ,II'.. wHe lInd hu!ilJilIld, Jlldivldlhllly lII,d au \':Wl'll1.11 .md IhllU/iI\ <ju.ltdiIllHl "I' ^IJhwn 1101 h.' I .Illl! ,\\11.,\, lIuflf'J, lll,~irlllillnr cldltlll'lI 5/1Il') I.illll")I !HIEet IIdll'j"lnn,/, 1',1 171];' e'llllt If C",,1l1l01l l'Ielli \'1, Nil. .. :J;1 <.W!.'I CjSUJ'I~\l!1............ 19.... 'IT{,1l:111lJ I t\.dp'liJ\ \lln I;) j\Jl.~l'h'd, lljc,.. H,! I-",t!, 11i1Nwcll. ;\llt'nl(~.II, I'oi, \')10.1 l\llll , :"11111" 11"'1\1 Y I leek", VII I.u, 11<,:< liJ, 1\111101', PO tA7,1!. III '.. .rlvILN:!i~ll:t'i~^'....., ..., ,..__.......u To '!I,~I!tlp.),l:~\~\IlJ.!.'r!lll'.ln}!Lh'!;l.k,hJIl'1, ilnd Ceorgn ihml'Y 1I'i'I-l....(\oll \'olt a,. hrlebr Ilotif;.d ,hot I-lolly lJlmm 11011','1' Hlld Child 1m IInllor, ,1t'" wil" fllld huubillUl, itKI1Vl,\uillly .llId illl ) ~i()\;i)l ij 'ili;i ',i,ijiit:,ii - rj,jiiiiiiill~';l-i;f' ^'i)j ,;;:,; 'Ii,;i jj;;' I,i;i . ill Ii ~:y' lit ;t:j .::;:- ti K,"ii' Ilit,i,;i ';:l~ iI, II (!/l Ih. Plnillllll haVElI'I'IIII''''''''') a" nction III ..XJ.'dl.l,lW. ....... h... _ ...d. ___.............. i\t{idli!lt )01. ",hid, )'IHl uU' tl'liiJin'd hI lldl,tlJ {It j\. i1l'1ault jmJ!{lHrUI IlIay br t'llll'l"cd a~lliliit )'ut! TRUE COpy FnmJl nf':GORD In Tt):lIrnCfly rlllcrcot, I ~n.' 1)!1\.I:;t I tOy IlJlld afill Ihe tO,11 01 \OJld 1'(IU~l.:: G;.IUlllo, Pi, ThIS--J,!:-.OOy, 01 (/u1., . 19 '1'1 (~I,,,L; ~' If }1LI~. ~r;, Prolhonotary 1,1\,1 (Jl~ I 1<. .~-i<_' 1 !".~-'.!_ _~.~ . _. _ _. ))tnt!llil1\)laty Ii..", .. .}.\tl.'i..;.... ............... l'I.:l'l III ): 'I" ' (/ ,. )III'-u::.. D"Ptll\ r ,.~. . J~L i -, III i I ~ I !~I ,'~ (. J~ ~ . ij l! ~i 'E 8 (' ~.N j'].~ 'g tJ Po ~ ~ .!j ~~a"_J~ IU O..J I m ~ lli N~l~; 4-1 IH "tJ . rJ; ... "'-rl f::iJ" ,,' .. 9 t'l II 1.1 ~l ~, . ~ 0 tV .. P:; ~: ~ \:::1 1 it.' ,0 '~i!l rl cJ ~. 05 rl~ :h '/'I ,t po.. .. I ;:j:t:lJj~'E go"!:lp,u ~ m'M ~ 'f'" ~I' (~. \.: .'1 I .t" O' ~ . tJ .~ . N '~ f- .~ 4_ o .~ "R +J e ') ~'H M 8 ij' t ,~ a " ~ ~ {-< & .a J c .~ 1~ .:: ;.j " .~ u ~I ...,1 ~ ~, or':! .." M ~~~ ~ ~ ~8 .~ ~ E ~ <0 ~'g , ~~ S7 lJfi &:2 Iii t ~ ,,' ~' 'rl~ ~'- oj.., d' ~ ;1ri' N :llNIl. .~ M a 1< I I I I I I I r I I 1M Ti1~ Court CT C.:mmo;-\ rle::s or C:J:'..:":~i!';:::1d (;'::W:-;',''11 Psnr:sylvc:r:io Molly ll. Iloffar at al 'is. Tranport Corporatipn of America Inc. :-10, 94-3697 Civil ---. :?.-.-. ~OWJ July 8 .'9~ r. S'.-_"":'"';t_'!'-:',""",." 0.'::' ,. ~r:::-:-:t'f"~ CO~~' v ~.l ":0 _ _ _:'..,-,,__on.,... ....,':'.,.._ \0 I. ' ....o:::::;y ccpue:: ch:: St=:.:r 01 LahiQh C.:JU:1ty :0 e...":::,,.u: =.is ',V:-::, ~ '::pu::::icn =:!:1r _",ol.. ~t ~ ::qu::n ::d :isk of :.:C ?!3.!:::5. 'J. .' ...." .\4'.... , '. ., .'.",; .' . .'~ . Sh~ at C=!luUcd C~U:1t1', :'3- . Affida.vit or Sem~ ~OWt ~9 .. . -~ . o'dea ~r. I=-.-e:i :.:: ~ r.!:in 'JFOn u by::u:~t.o ~ c::py 01 . ::e :1r:~ ~ ,- 1%1d -!!"'. Clown :0 :!:.e ..:::u:::s :.~::::i. So :U:SW~, --. .5hc:iii 0/ CoWllT, P:L" 5WOr:1 :1Ild rJI::sc:-J:d bdc~ =::!:.:s_6yol 19_ cem SD-VICE ~lII.!.\GZ ,~:mA"vTI .s __._4..0-__..__... s 1- '-.1 . :::""~. ~,..: ~. .... . ..:J~li"-. t~ , - H?1~l~"''', - ~ ~~ijJ:'\i' l~~' ~?i>.o.',~ ~ .... ;rHo _.~-< . MOLLY DIANE HOFFER AND CHARLES HOFFER, JR., wife and husband, individually and as parents and natural guardians of ALLISON HOFFER AND ABBEY HOFFER, their minor children, IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW Plaintiffs v. NO. 94-3697 TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA, INC., and GEORGE IlENRV IlECKADON, Defendants Juny TRIAL DEMANDED PRAECIPE FOR APPEARANCE TO TilE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY: Please enter the appearance of Robert P. Reed, Esquire, of the firm of Metzger, Wickersham, Knauss & Erb on behalf of Defendants, Transport corporation of America, George Henry Heokadon. Inc., and METZGER, WICKERSHAM, KNAUSS & ERB J BYI Ro::f:'~'~!;::~,1 ~~~~~~ Attorneys for Defendants 111 Market Street P.O. Box 93 Harrisburg, PA 17108-0093 (717) 238-8187 Datedl August 10, 1994 ~ERTIFICATE OF SERVICE AND NOW, on this 10th day of August, 1994, I, Robert P. Reed, Esquire of Metzger, wickersham, Knauss & Erb, attorneys for Defendants, Transport corporation of America, Ino., and George Henry Heckadon, hereby certify that I served the within Praeoipe for Entry of Appearance this day by depositing the same in the united states mail, postage prepaid, in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, addressed tOl William C. Archbold, Jr., Esquire Kassab, Archbold, Jackson & o'Brien 214 North Jackson street P.o. Box 626 Media, PA 19063 .--". '/I;:~':t1 y/ /dJ' Robert P. Reed - - ;~ ; ~ /"- ,+ .i!i~ 1"..01.' )']:i:l.. 'to It 9 m ,....... .....j. ~J ul;., ~I r;Jll :~;. ~!;,,!'--'::i u ., .~"'; --. - - J - ....... d .. ~ .' '. a . 'E 0 ! J. S S S ., r; -< 0 oj c:i .,. -I ... VI .![I ~~! ~ I ~ ~ .. 0 ... ~o~~ t: a 0 .... u., 0 .. o ~ < Ii 'll 'C I~ Hllll! Ill! u i ~ 4 t: ~ ~ ~ ~ '" 0 II ~ ", ::: a J uIJ'p a"l ..~~~ II a o ~ .11 .; t..l UU Q fU 0 I lid > .. '" ... .t' f - 0 Ci l! J 1= .,. :E ...5 - ~ " eo g~' " , " ~1;~::.~: ~ " . .'1 \~. N ;;~< c!.; ~\ ~ ,,' "-.f';, ct "~"'l I i ~ j f li ' .; -I 0: :~ ~ KASSAB ARCHBOLD JACKSON & O'BRIEN Attorney for Plaintiffs By: Willlam C, Archbold, Jr, Ally. I.D.No, 08605 214 N. Jackson Street Media, PA 19063 215-565-3800 MOLLY DIANE HOFFER, et at. COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA Plaintiffs v. NO, 94,3697 TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA, INC, 1425 North Maxwell Allentown, PA 19103 and GEORGE HENRY HECKADON P,O. Box 83 Foster, MO 64745 Defendants PRAECIPE TO REISSUE WRIT OF SUMMmiS TO THE PROTHONOTARY'S OFFICE: Kindly reissue the Writ of Summons against Defendant Transport Corporation of America, Inc, in the above mailer. ( ,'1 J J" /;t' . ~ L{(~'.c"1 ( --f'" l. ILLlAM C, ARCHBOLD, JR. Attorney for Plaintiffs ',", "," . SIlEllI FF' 'S IlETU/lN COMMONWEALTH OF' PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF CUMBEIlLAND In tho Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County, Pennsylvnaia No. 94~3697 civil Term Summons in Civil Action [,aW Ileinstated Molly Diane Hoffer and Charles Iloffer Jr. Wife and husband individually and as parents and natural guardians of Allison Iloffer and Abbey lIoffer the ir mi nor chi] d VS Transport Corporation of America, Inc. and George Ilenry Heckadon Il. THOMAS KLINE, Sheriff, who being duly sworn according to law, says, that he made diligent search and inquiry for the within named defendant, to wit. Transport Corporation of America but was unable to locate them in his bailiwick. He therefore deputized the sheriff of Lehigh County, Pennsylvania, to serve the within /leinstated Summons in Civil Action Law On September 6, 1994 , this office was in receipt of the attached return from Lehigh County, Pennsylvania. Sheriff's CostSI Docketing Out of County Surcharge (,ehigh Co. 14.00 5.00 2.00 29.15 50.15 Sworn and Bubscribed to Pd'9~~_~4t . before me this II f!. " .J..'-iJt"llll ll~ , day of 19 .;'" ,A.D. '*' (" i . ,....(-- '. Jift(f1. Al'IJ(,~i I I r. Prothonotary ~~, , SIIU1111 01-1 ICl: COUN lY OF LEIIIGH COurHHOUSE PO BOX 1548 215.1320.3175 \ I-'/U.Y lilN'l1. l~nl:R N'!J 1l0GKII I'AULttjUMIlL Il 72131', IH\RI.I.S IUFER, JRd El N.. ... VS _JRN'lSl'lJRT COI~PORAT ION of I*lLRICA, INed ET N., CAst NUMIlEll 94-3697 (CUMBERLAND) EXPII1AlION DAlE 9/28/94 $29,15 IJEI'OSII Willi RElsSUUJ SUM'/)NS IN CIVIl. N:T1lJN SliM TRN'lSPllRT ClJRPORATICJN Of I*lERICA, INC. AI 1425 N. w\xWELL STREET I t.LLENlOWN, I'A .... ...~.... ....,....,...,.,.........,',.,..."...........iiEi.lili'N'oi:siiiivlcr.....'....,....,..........,...,.................................... I IjAM!: 01 INIlIVIDUAL SUM 0 A. {:. . ~ l;L..tJ , c ,r 2.I1UA110NSllIPlOLJEFENOANl /C't) 11 f._'{. 'I {':? ~a.JlJ/ {;J.5' , /'/7 /h..-..r :1 (JAIl' S"',{; 10 f)l! liME: ./.,IU,I y.;?// HOUIlS , , , .,c- ,1 I OGAlImJOF SEIlVICl?V(J; " - / "II[ :7/1' .&"vJ " II ~) 1,0' ,,/( ,//c ,'C.;' ,,IV 'I r:~ ~" { /' h , I Ii If /,)-o/..I"r.rs ~ !, UNABLE TO l:OCA~ ( ) NUMBEfl OF AllEMl'lS 10 LOCAlE PEFENDANl AI LAS! KNOWN ADDllESS: DAlE & liME 2, DAIF & liME :I OAIF & TIME s DAlE & TIME ,1. DAlt: & 11M!:: 6, DAlE & liME ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE I tlllillll ACClPl SERVICE Of T HII EGAI PROCESS AS OUTlINED ON IIIE FRONT Of THE DOCLJMENl THIS SERVICE IS ACCEPTED ON BEHAlF Of III[ IISII.O D[FLNOANIIS) AND I HLRUlY ClIHIf Y I HAl I AM ALJIIIORI,'W 10 UO W /'1i1l1TlD flAME or AU I HORlZED AGEtH SIGNA lURE OF AlII HOlllZED AGENl I!,\II liME ___.~..._~.__....~.____...______u.._....._._...._.._.._..---....-....----...........----.---.......-.. .. ~ ....__.....___u. SO ANSWU1S . .' ~ j " SW(\I1N AND SUllSCI1IB~,U Bllonl ME THIS IJ^'( (ll' ," I \ I " _~"\l;,'t ( , .' " AD, 1(1__..__'..._~ , ... I ,. ._...__........). :.i~ ~I.:.J' . , ....~,-.,,_....__. t~StaI fi'?1l<.1_.~J'\ti~ ,'1.1r:VNl'lLt'~11 ,,),:1"/ t' {I . .;, '. . I T' C . c .,.\ . .. r...l ., PI' M 'ne ourt CT .::mmrm r =:::3 or ....:.J:..;.:""'l::n...I,,,.::W:-;','y, . S:1r:SY'lc:r:IO Molly Diane lIoffer and Charles Iloftel' .Jr. wife and husb~Afl invididual1y ('nd ('s parents Bnd nntural guardian of Al'!'lson lIoffer and Abbey lIoffer their minor child Vfl ' :--to. q d - 1 (, 9 ., CJ..IL.i.L., ---. :?.-..-. Transport Corporation of America ~ow, AUQust 29. :9-!l4!. SEZP~'F 0::' C~~GE?.!.A.\fD COt.-:-l':'Y, ?A., co \,., .J ' \, ~"-'- I M=OY "=?U= t!::: Mu::"..::l 0 t.Ahigh C"u.::ty :0 ::''-::':''.It: :.:.is 'tVri:., :.:;s c...f'uc:iDn beht -~,.:- ~, t!:.: :-:qucn ::d :J..1k ol :.:C ?1:L!:6i. :# /! ", ~z:.,-- ,J ~,''/.'"'' . /..1' ,,/.f~"-'-" . Shed at C:::!l~d C~WltY. :':1. . Affidavit or Sem~ ~OW, ~9 '. . ... . ol:!ca ~[. 1::-.-d :.:: within 'Jpol1 ~l -. '=r!;!1":O 'w~ ~ .1 C':C'Y of :::e ::n.:~...~1 .. - .' lDd -~~. bawu :0 :.!:: ':::1te::s ~~::::i. So iI.lmY~. !he'S of COllAlT, h. Sworn md fJ/::sc:oJ:d bdcrc =::!:i1_6yol 19_ cern SE.Av'CZ ~m.!AGE. .-\.:o'7iDAVIT .s ---~-_._--. s r_'~ "~I' ,f \. I ' ~ ' ' , , cP' (C', t\\ii 'J \ , I" '(", ,," \'\ 1..1i.\':: . , /}II'1(UI ,!~. 17r/1 )'. N,11 (.r.f)l.J'~~II\nt~, 111~\l(l) I ./,~~/'r/ jo..,..., '. ('\ (.'~ '. II '/Y'J ~., ,..i.~ F' J .. ~ ~~ ~~ '~ :E '~~nl~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ,~ 'E ')1 it.... E., III ~ 0 'J ~ ~ m ~ .; \H l~.j 't:f ill ., .... '<4 G" _. " o :t r. '1.14' :t~ . H f.J .. ~ lU:tZ 1'0.1 . '"' ~J L: ~ ,., 51 '~' ,~ " ~ '1 J Q . '(, IU. 1,,1 IJ'~ t,., \i.I ~# : r-4 '-'4 'd oIJ 't1 I t--i \.~ 1:1 '[) r; Q q I, " '" :t. :.t-;.-I " ;., .,. U r- 0' \&:' (', I "1 a. d :z: . u r: H . ,~ ~ 4.. o :"'l~ ~ ~ lJ ~'t1 l;J hH:-C , 'Il a ~ t ;W ~, ~, I t: fj \) Ie' IS .El j c.: c .tJI ~, 'r-; :~ .,~ u I , .".." j"i .,-/ r':," 1.'1 ," , ~. oM .., ('1 .v o 0' M '. ,~ ~.1 ~ "t. ~ lj L 'lJ U) "j ,-,,..1 't I, ~ r:: 'J n ~ [, ~ ~'~ '" ~'2 iii I"~~r( ii.i u J~ ~i lfl .~ U~ v.lt", li ~ f~ In ~ .:1 ~,o ,j.. (I) rl . .,-4 u, ('J ., "r 0 'f1 ,., f' .,J r.o/ I ~j (-~ ~ ~ ("j no ~: ~_ Ii !~ 1< I I I I I , I I , I I I I . j . , .. KASSAII AIH 'IIIIOLD .IA( '''SON & O'IIIUEN lIy: Williulll (', ,\r~hhold, .II'. Allolllc)' I.D. No. OKlllI~ lIy: (kOll!l' C. tlkFurlilnd, .II'. /\IIOllll')' I.D. No. 41~KN 114 N, .luc~:;on SII\'l'l Mcdiu, I'A 1l)0l>~ ((dO) 5l>5-.1KOO MOLLY I>IAI\I' 1I0WI-R ul1ll('IIAltLES 1I0FFER, .lit.. wili: ul1d hu~hlll1ll. individuull)' IInd 1I~ pUll'nls ilnd nlltuml guunliul1s of ALliSON 1I0FFI~R IInd AIIIIEY IIOFFI:It, Iheir minur childrcn !'lilil1li1'1\; COURT 01; COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBElU.AND COUNTY. PA \" NO, 94,3(197 Civil Tcrm T1tANSI'ORICORl'lllt\TlON 01' ,\MEItICA, INC. und OFOROE IIENItY IIITI\A\)ON Ill'Ii:ndunls JllltY TRIAL DEMANDED rmru:.E You hu\'l! hccn sucd In Cuurt. If yuu wish 10 dcli:nd IIl!ulnsllhc cluhlls set forth in the tilllowing Imlll'S, )'IlU Illusltllkc uctlon wlthlnl\\'cnlY (20) dul'S uncI' Ihls COl1lplalnt and Notice urc scrved. hy Cn!l'r1nl! in writing wllh Ihc ('ourt yuur dcli:nscs or ohjcctions 10 lhe clahns scl tilrlh ugulnsl )'IlU. YIIU mc Wllrllcd thutll' )IlU HIli 10 do Ml Ihe casc l1Iuy procced without you IInd II judglllcnt I1Ii1Y 11l' Cnll'rl'd ugulnst YIlU hy thc ( our! witholll fmther no(lce thr an)' money duimcd In thc COlllphintllr Illl' lIItl' Illhcr duil1lllr Iclicf rcqucstcd h)' the pluinllff, YOlll1lay losc 11I0ncy or 11I0pcrI)' or ('Ihcr righls il1lporlllnllo you, YOII SI10\JIilIAI\E TIllS I'AI'F1t TO YlHiR I.AWYER AT ONCE, IF YOU DO NOT IIAVI' A I.,\\\'YLR OR CANNOT AFFORD ()NI~, tiO TO OR TELEPHONE TIlE OFFICE SET HIIHIIIII.I.lIW TO FINI> OIlT WIIFRI: YOI! ('AN (WII.E<lAL IIELlI, 1IIMIII\HI.ANI> ('( l\ INTY ('( lllln ,\I>MINISTRATOR ('ulllhcrlund ('uunll' ('uurlhuusc Onc ('uurlhousc SllUlIl'C ('U1'lIsk PA 170 I.l ( 71711411-62110 KASSAII ARC( mow .IACKSON & (l'IlRIEN lIy: Wllllllm C. Archhold. .II', AtlOrncy I.D, No, 08()05 II)': Gcorgc C, McFllrllllld, .II', Allorncy I.D, No, 42J88 214 N, Jllcksllll Strcct Mcdill. PA IlJ[}()J (() Ill) 565-J80[} Allol'Iteys Ihr PllIllltlll's MOI.L Y DIANE 1I0FFER IIlld CIIAfU,ES 1I0FFElt JR,. wire IIlld hushllllll, illllividulllly IIlld liS pllrcllts ulld IlllturnfllUllrdillllS or ALI.JSON 1I0FFEJ{ uud AIIIIEY flOFFER, their millOI' childrcn 5HHlJ Luurcl Strcct IllIrrishurg. P A 17112 Pluillllrrs COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMUElU,AND COUNTY. PA v, NO, 94.3697 Civil Tcrm TRANSPORT nml'ORATlllN OF AMERICA, INC, 1425 North Muxwcll Allentowll, I'A IlJlIIJ IIlld CiEOfWE IIENRY IIECKADON 1',0. Box 8J Fostcr, MO 64 745 Delelldllllls JURY TRIAL DEMANDED COMI'L"I~T Pfllintiffs. Molly Dillne Iloller ulld Chudes Iloller, .II',. wile IIlld hushund.lndlvldulllly IIlld us purcllts ulld Illlturulguunlilllls or Allisolllloller IIlld Ahbcy Iloller, their minor children. herchy slutc the 1l1llowillg complulnt Ulluillsl dclelldullls Trallsport Cnrporntinll nr AmcriclI. Inc, und Georgc Ilem)' Ilcckllllnn: I, PluilllilTs Mnlly Dlulle Ilnller uud Churles IlnllCr'. Jr,. ure udult ludlvidulIls. wile ulld hushlllld. rcsldillllut 5HHlJ !.uurel Slreet, Ilurrlshurg. Pellllsylvulllu 17112, Suld pluilltlrrs urc /11111'/'.\ IIII/lido!', 11I1I1fi'/' ( '( 1.1/ UISlllhc purcnls und nlllurulgulll'lllllns of pllllnliffs Allisollllollcr und Ahhcy Iloncr. holh minor chlldrcn, \\hll IIkcwlsc rcsldc ut 5HHI) I.uurcl Strccl, lIurrlshurg. Pcnnsyll'unlll 17112, 2, J)clcndllnt Trunsport Corpllrullon or Al1Icricn, Inc, Is II lilr-pl'll Ii I clll'plll'ulion orgllnlwl Illll( cslstlng ullllcr thc Illws of Ihc stlltc ul' Mlnncslltll, Sllld dclcl1llllnt hils hccn IIUlllllicd III do huslncss within thc Conllllonwcllllh Ill' Pcnnsyll'unin sincc Augusl 15. II)HH liS U motor curricr 1111' hirc. with u rcglstcrcd oflicc IiII' scrl'lcc Ill' proccss within Pcnnsyll'unllllocutcd III 1425 NllI'lh Mllswcll Strcct, Allcntown, Pcnnsyll'llniu II)IOJ. Sllld dclcndllnt Iilrlhcr. In Ihct, lit 1111 tlmcs rclcl'llnt hcrclo hilS rcgulllrly conductcd hllsincss within Ihc Conllllonwcllllh of Pcnnsyll'llnill, including wilhin l'umhcrlllnd County, J. ()clcndllnt OClll'gc IIcnry IIccklldon Is Iln Ildull indll'idulll whosc last known nddrcss is P,O, Bos 113. Fostcr. Missllurl 64745, 4, AI 1111 Ilmcs rclcl'llnl hcrcto, dclcllllllnl GCllrgc Ilcmy Ilccklldon WIlS Iln ugcnt. scrl'unt, workmun und/or cmploycc of dclcndllnt Trunspllrl Corpllrution of Al1Icrlcu. fnc,. ucting within thc coursc und scopc of his Ilgcncy lind/or cl1lploymcnt. 5, On nr uhllut Sutllrdll)'. Murch 20, 11)1)3.ul upproslmulcly 1):53 U,I1I,. pluinlllTMolly Iloncr WIlS thc owncr ullll opcrulor of u II)HH Suhllru passcngcr uutomohllc (hcrcinllHcr rclcrrcd to us thc "Pluinlllfs Vchiclc") which WIlS trul'cling in thc right hllnd Illnc ol'southhound Intcrstutc HI upprosimlltcly Iwo-Icuths of u I1Illc norlh of ROlllc (,31 in Eust Pcnnshol'llugh Township. CUl1lhcrlllnd County. Pcnnsyll'llnlll, Plllinlil'lS 1\1 Ii son Iforlcr und Ahhcy Iloner wcrc pllsscngcrs In thc Pluintltrs Vchlclc ut thc ulilrcsuid dulc und limc. 6. At Ihc sumc timc, dclendllnl Ocorgc Ilcnry Ilccklldon WIlS opcmtlng u Iruclor- Imllcr tllllt WIlS llwncd. l1Iuinlllincd IlIllI cllntl'llllcd hy dclcndllnt Trllnsplll'l Cllrpnrutlon of r '''"'/.\\/11I,I'/'"'.III/IIIII'/ ('( 1.\1 .2- Amcricu, Inc, nnu wus trllvcling in thc miudlc Innc ur sllulhhuulllllntcrslutc K I whcn, nil ur u I f . suddcn, whllc in Ihc proccss ur u\'crluking nnd pussing thc Plulnlilfs Vchlclc. thc dcrcndunt's trllclur-truilcr crosscd Intulhc right hund lunc ur IrlI\'clun InlcrslulC K I suuthhuund, slriking thc Icn sidc ur Ihc I'luinllrrs Vchiclc, ullll pushing thc I'luintilfs Vchiclc duwn Ihc highwuy I, I. t upproximulcly unc-tcnlh ur n milc und Ihcrcuncr ulf thc highwny, with thc I'luinlirrs Vchiclc ultimalely cumin!! lu rcst inthc snow upproximulely lhirty lecllhllnlhc righl hcrmur Inlcrstutc K 1 suuthhuund Ihcing wcst. 7, As u dirccl unu proximulc rcsult or thc uli1rcsulu mutor \'chiclc uccidcnl plulnlirr Molly I loner sullercd scriuus und possihly pcrmancnt injurics 10 hcr pcrson, including Icn wrist mcdiunncr\'c ncurilis (curpultunncl syndromc). Icll elhllW cuhitullunncl syndrumc, right wrist mcdian ncr\'c ncuritis (CUrpallunnel syndrumc), right elhuw cuhltul tunncl syndromc, IInd II lumho sllcrlll spinc spruin und struin with rcsulting puin rlldlutlng duwn hulh hcr Icgs rrom hcr lowcr huck urClI, ullur which hllw Icll hcr sick. sorc, Inmc IInu disuhlcd, K. As n furthcr dircct und proximutc rcsult or Ihc IIlbrcslIld molor vchlclc IIccldcnt, plninlirr Mully 1I0ller hilS hccn uhligutcd tu rccci\'c IInd unucrgu cxlcnsi\'c mcdicul cllrc IInd Irclllmcnl - incluuing Ibur surgcrics - in un Cni.lrttO ullc\'iutc ullll/ur curc thc uli.lrcsald inJurics, IInd hus incurrcd suhstanliul cxpcnscs IiII' such mcdiclIl curc und Irculmcnt. 9. As u rurthcr uircclund proximutc rcsult or thc ulbrcsuld mutor vchiclc IIccldcnl. pluinllff Molly linneI' has sullercu und will conlinuc 10 suller mcntulnnguish, cmolionul dlstrcss, humllluliun, cmhurrllssmcnl, leur, Cllnccrn, Inss or conl1dcncc, unxlclY, III1lI grclIl physlcul puin und sullering, 11""'nl/ll/,I",,...\\/I,,/"',,( '/1.\/ -3, 1 (I, As n tilrthcr dlrcct nnd proximlllc rcsullllf Ihc IIlhrcsllld mlllor vchlclc IIccldcnl, plnintlff Mlllly Illlffer hns sutlercd IIllllwlll cllnllnuc III suller drnmntic Impllirmcnt In hcr nhllily tll CIUllY lite nnd lite's plcllsurcs, IInd \llIlIlCIllI hcr usulllllnd cushllllnry IIclivlllcs, dutlcs IInd nllitlrs, II, As n thrlhcr dircclnnd proximlllc rcsullllf thc nlhrcsald mlllor \'chiclc ncddcnl. plaintiff Mlllly Illlffer has sullercd and may cllntinuc III suller a Inss nf carnings nnd/Ilr n IllSS Ill' carniug capacity, 12, As n furthcr dircct and proximatc rcsullllf thc alhrcsaid mlllnr \'chlclc ncddcul, plaiutlff Allisnn IlollCi' hils suffercd nllll cllnlinucs tn suner from dllcumcnlcd pnsl-traumatlc strcss nnd nnxicty, stcmming in part from thc Iilct Ihat shc witncsscd Ihc truck appruaching and thcrcancr crossing iUln plninliffs' lanc nf Irn\'C1 and cnming Inln cnnlllct with Plainlll'l"s Vchiclc, llllimatcly pushing Plaintitfs Vchiclc off thc rnad, 13, As n furlhcr dircct allll proximatc rcsullnf thc nlilrcsnid l1l11tor vehlclc ncddcnt, plalutlll' Allisoullnffer has hccullhlignlcd tll rcccivc aud uadcrgn profcssional psychlllogical carc nnd trcntmcnl in nil cffhrt 10 allcl'intc and/nr curc thc nlllrcsaid injurics, und has Incurrcd suhstnntinl cxpcnscs Ihr such cnrc and trcnlmcnl. 14, As n fUrlhcr dircct and proximatc rcsullllf thc nlilrcsnld mlltllr \'Chiclc ncddcnt, plnintlff Allisllll Illlffer has sullercd nnd will cnntinuc tn snlTcr mcntnl nngulsh, cmlltillnal distrcss, humillutinll, cmharrussmcnt, tear, conccrn, Inss Ill' cnnt1dcncc, ulld grcat physlcul pain nud sullerlng, 15, As n furthcr dlrcctnllll proximatc rcsullllf Ihc nlhrcsnld mlllllr vchiclc accldcnt, plnlmllT Alllsnllllllffer IIns suffercd nnd will CllllllllllC tll Nuller Itrnmullc il11pnirmcntln her IIhillty '11/.../'.\ \/11/,\.1",'\11/,,1/,"'/'( /1/ -4- (c) Allcmpting to ovcrtukc und pass Pluinlifl's Vchlclc to thc Icn withoUI leuving u sufc distuncc to do so und without sluying 10 the len of thc Pluinlilrs Vehiclc until sufcly c1cur of thc ovcrtukcn vchicle, in vlolulion of 75 pu.r,s,^, * 3303(u); (d) Operuting lhc truclor truilcr ul un cxcessive rutc of spccd undcr thc circumstunccs. in violution of 75 Pu,(',S,A, * 3361 und/or * 3362; (c) Fuillng to kcep u reusonuhle lookout IiII' olher vehicles, including the Pluintil1's Vehicle. luwfully on the roud; (I) Fuiling to upply thc hrukes Intilllc to uvoid the collision; und (g) Pcrmitting und cuusing thc trnctor tmiler 10 strikc und collidc with the Pluintilrs Vchiclc. und thcrcuncr permitting und cuusing the delcudunt's tructor tmilcr to run the Pluintiff's Vchiclc off thc mud, 21. As u dircct und proxilllutc result of the dclcndunt's ufllrcsuid ncgligcncc, pluintil1' Molly Iloncr sul1er-cd thc injurics und dlllllugcs sctlilrlh in parugruphs 7 through Ilullllvc, which injurics und dumugcs wcrc in no way ell used hy any IIctions or iuuctious on hcr own purl. WIIEREFORE, pluintllf Molly Iloncr hereh)' dcnlUnds judglllcut in hcr IhVllr und uguinst dclcndunt Gcorge Ilcnr)' Ilcckudon in un IImonnl in cxccss of Filly Thousllnd Dollurs ($50,000,00), together with dcluy dunlllges IInd the costs of this uction, Cuunt II ' Ncelhrcncc 1\1011\' Hoffcr \', Trunsllurt Curporutlun or Alllcrlcu 22, Thc UVCrlllcnts of purngrnphs 1 through II, und II) lhrough 21 ubove, urc incorporutcd hcrcin hy rclercncc, 23, Thc ulilrcsuld motor vchiclc uccldcnt, us stuted ubove. wus tllrcclly uml proxlmutcly cuuscd hy thc ncgllgcncc of delcndunt Gcorge Ilemy Ilcckmlon, IInd bccuuse suid delcndunt ut /1/1WI'.\I"",1'/"".\\llo("',. ('(HI -6- thc timc of thc uccidcnt \\'us u scrvunt, workmun, ugcntund/or cmploycc of dcfcmlunt Trunsport Corporutlon of Amcricu, ucting \\'ithin thc coursc ul1ll scopc of his ugcncy uml/nr cmploymcnt, dcfcndunt Trunspnrt l'orpol'lltion of Amcricu is vicuriously liuhlc to thc pluintiff lilr thc ncgllgcncc of its ngcntund/nr cmploycc, 24, In uddition, dcl~ndunt Tnmsport Corpol'lltion of Amcricn \\'us indcpcmlcntly ncgllgcnt, umong othcr \\'uys, hy Iililing to hirc propcrly lIuulllicd truck drivcrs, hy Ihiling to properly truln its truck drivcrs, und hy Iillling to ptllpcrly supervisc its truck drivcrs, which ncgllgcncc ulso dircctly und ptllximutely cuused the suhjectmotor vchiclc uccldcnt to occur, 25, As u result of dcl~ndunt Tnmsport Cnrporutionof Americn's ncgligcncc us sctlhrth in purugruphs 22 through 24 uhovc, pluintiff Molly Ilon~r sun~rcd thc injurics nnd dumngcs sct lilrth in purugruphs 7 throogh II uhovc, which injuries und dumugcs wcrc in no wuy cuuscd hy uny uctions or inuctions un her parI. WIIEREFORE, plnintiff Molly Ilon~r hcrchy dcmumls judgmcnt in hcr Iilvor und uguinst dcfendunt Trunsport ('orporution of Americu in nn nmount in cxccss of Finy Thousand Dollurs ($511,O()(),lIl1), togethcr with dcluy dumugcs und thc costs of this uction, Cllunt III - NCIlIIt:cnllnnlctllln Ill' Emlltlllnnllllslrm 1\11111\' IIl1ffcr \', GCllrl!c IIcnn' IIcckndlln 26, The nvcrmcnts of pnrugruphs I through 21 nhovc mc incorporutcd hcrcin hy rcfcrcncc, 27, As u dircct uml proximatc rcsult of hcr contcmporary und scnsory ohscrvutlonof injury to her two duughtcrs us sct lilrth uhovc, pluintlff Molly Ilon~r, who \\'us within thc zonc of dungcr crcuted hy the dcl~ndunt's ncgllgcnce nnd whouctuuliy sun~rcd physicul impuct /'//\('I'."IIIIM""."II"//l'I' ('()I/ .7. thcrcfrom, IIlso suffcrcd slgniliclInt cmoliolllll dlstrcss rcsultlng In physlclIl hllrm, illcludlug hul uol IImltcd to, hypcr\'cnllllltlon, III1XiCIY, hCllduchcs und slccplcssncss, 2M, Pluintiff Molly Iloncr's ulilrcsuid cmolloulIl dislrcss wus dlrcctly und proxllllutcly' cuuscd 1I11l! Inl1letcd h)' thc dclcndllnt (Ieorgc IIcmy IIceklldon's ncgligcncc liS sctlhrth IIhovc, WIIEREFOIW, plllllllil'f 1\lolly Iloftcr hen:hy dCllllluds judgmcnt in hcr Ihvor und IIguinst dclcndllnt (icorgc IIcnry Ilcckmlon in IIn IImOllll1 in cxccss or Fitly Thousllud f)ollllrs ($50,()()().()()), togcthcr with dclllY dllmllgcs IIl1llthc costs of this IIclion, Count IV - NCl!lIl!cnt Inmctlon of Io:mollollul Dlstrcss Moll\' lIoffcr \', Trllnsllurt CUrllorutlon uf AmcrlclI 21), Thc u\'crmcnts of pllrngruphs 1 through 2M IIhow urc ineorporntcd hcreln hy rclcn'nee, 3(), ^s II dircetllnd proxlmulc reslllt of her cOlltcmpornry' und scnsory ohservlltlon of injury to her two dllughtcrs us setlimh uhol'c, plllinlifr Molly (lolTcr, who wus within the zone of dllngcr erculed hy thc dclcndllnt's ncgllgencc und who IIcluully suftcrcd physiclI\ illlpllct thcrclhllll, u\so suflcred slgniliellnt cmolionlll distress rcsultlng in physicul hllrm, Including hut nOlllmltcd 10, hypcrl'cntllution, unxlcty, und slccplessncss, 31, Plulnlll'l'Molly Iloncr's ufilresllid cmolionlll distrcss wus dircetly IInd proximlltcly cllllscd IInd inl1ietcd hy thc dclcndllnt (icorgc IIcnry IIccklldon's ncgligcncc liS sctlhrth IIhovc, Ilccllusc sllid dclcndllnt WIIS IIcllng liS Ihc ugcnl IInd/or cmploycc of dclcndllnl Trllnsporl CllI'porullon of ^mcrlclI IIllhc timc of thc suhjccl lIecidcnl, dclcndllnl Trunsport CllI'porlllionof Alllcricu is I'icurlonsly lIuhlc fill' Ihc ncgllgcnlly Inllletcd clllotionlll dislrcss hrought uhOUl hy thc IIcllons 1I11lllnllctlons of Its IIgcnlllnd/lll' cmploycc who \\'IIS IIcting within Ihc coursc 11111\ scopc of his IIgcncy/clllploymcnt III thc limc or thc suh.lcclllccidcnl. r \1I.h'I'.\\"'I,\dl1l',\\/lol/.'" ('I H/ .N, 32, Dclcnuunl Trunsport l'oqlllrutlon of Amcricu is ulso rcsponslhlc lilr ncgligcnlly intlicting cmotlonul dlstrcss upon pluintilf Molly Iloncr hy rcuson of lis dlrcctncgligcllcc, us sct lilrth In purtlgruph 24 uho\'c, which dircctly unu proxllllutely hrought uhoUI plullltlff Moll)' Iloll'cr's ulilrcsuid clllolionul distrcss, WIIElWFOIW. plulntilf Molly Iloncr hcrchy dClllullllsjudgmcnt in hcr liI\'or ullllugulnst dclcndunt Trunsport ('urporutlon of Amcricu in Unl11111l\I11t in cxccss of Filly Thousulllll>ollurs ($50,O{)(),{){)). togcthcr wilh dcluy dunlllgcs unu lhc costs of this uction, Counl V - Loss of COllsortlulI\ ClUlrlCS Hoffer. ,II'. \', (;eorl!e Henn' Heekudoll 33. Thc ul'crmcnls of purugruphs I through II. II) through 21, und 26 through 28 ubovc. urc incorpornted hcrcin by rclcrcncc. 34, As u dircct und prnximutc rcsult of thc injurics suncrcd hy his wilc. pluintilT Churlcs Iloncr, Jr, hus in thc pusl und wiil conlinuc in thc Iilturc to bc dcprivcd of thc scrviccs, ussisluncc, cOIllPunionshlp, socicty und consortium of his wi Ic, ull of which hus hccn und will bc to his grcut dUlllugc und loss, und lilr which hc mukcs cluim hcreln, WHEREFORE. pluintiff Churlcs Iloncr, Jr, hcrcby dClllunds judgmcul in his IiiI'm uml uguinsl dclcndunl Gcorgc Ilcnry Ilcckudon In un umounl In cxccss of Fin)' Thousund I>ollurs ($50,OOO.{)O), logclhcr wilh deluy dumugcs ullllthc costs of Ihls uction, CoulIl VI - Loss of ConsorllulI\ Churles Hoffer. ,II', \', Trllnsllorl Cornorlltloll of AlI\erlclI 35, Thc uvcrlllcnts of purugrnphs I through II. IInd II) lhrough 32 Ilhow IIrc Incorpol'lltcd hcrein by rclcrcnCl', r Ir/l.....\ Iml'l.lII".\ II/II""" ( '( 1.1/ ,I), J6, As u direct uml proximulc result of lhe illjurles suflcred hy his wife, pJuilltirf (,hurles linneI'. Jr, hus illlhe pusllllld will eOlltillue ill the futurc to he deprived of lhe serviccs, usslslUIICC, compulliollship, soclely ullll cOlIsortium of his wile, ull of which hus hecllullll will hc to his grcat damugc and loss, uud liJr which he mukes c1uim hercin, WHEREFORE, pluilllilT Churles IllllTcr, Jr, hcrchy del11unds judgmcllt in his li\Vor ulld ugulllst dclclldullt Trnllspllrtl'orpllrulillll of Amcrleu IlIulI umounl in cxccss of Flny Thousund ))ollurs ($50,000.00), togclhcr with deluy dmnagcs ulld thc costs of this uctlon, COllnt VII - NCLllluclIcc Alllsoll Hoffcr \', (;corl!c IIcnn' Ilcckl\llnn 37, The uvcrmcllts of purngrnphs I through 6, ulld 12 through 15 uhovc, are IlIeorporated hereill by relcrcllee, 38. The uli.Jrcsuid motor vehicle uecidclltwus directly and proximutcJy caused by thc IIcgllgellce of dcfendant Gcorgc Ilcnry I /cekudoll, us Ihetuully rccitcd uhovc, which includes hut Is not limited 10 the 1i.Jllowillg: (u) Fulling to huvc thc lrnctor trailcr ulldcl' propcr und udcl)uutc control; (h) Muking un ulIsulc IInd improper luue chunge, in violution of 75 Pa,c'S.A, * 3334(a), and in lilrther violntion of 75 Pu.C.S,A. * JJOI}( I); (c) Allempling to o\'crtuke und pass Pluinllfrs Vehicle to lhe Jen without leaving u sufe distunce to do so und without stuylng to the len of the Plulntilfs Vchlclc until sulcly c1eur of the overtukcn vehicle, In violutiou of 75 Pa,C,S,A, * J3llJ(u); (d) Operuting the tructor tmiler ut un cxcessivc rute of speed undcr the clreumstunces, in vioJution of 75 Pu,('.S,\, * J3(, lund/or * 3162; IIIIWnlll/lrldo<'.,llIo/l"1' ('( J.\I -10. (c) FlIiling to keep n rellsonuhle lookoUI Ihr olher vehicles, including the Pluintlll"s Vehicle, lu\\'l\llIy on the rolld: (I) Falling 10 upply Ihe hrukes in time 10 lIvold the collision: lInd (g) Permitting lInd ellusing the Irnctor Irnilcr 10 strike nnd collide with the PllIintifrs Vehicle, olllllherenl\er perl11iulng and enuslng Ihe delcndllnl's lruclnr truller tll run the PllIinlll1's Vehicle on'lhe rolld, 39, As u direct nnd proximllle result 01' the delcndllnl's 1Ililresnid negligence, pllllnlll1' Allison 1I011cr suncred the Injuries lInd dllmllges set thrth In pllrugruphs 12 through 15 ulmve, \\'hich injuries lInd dlll11nges were In no WlIY ellused hy lIny lIctions or Inuetions on her own pllr\. WHEREFORE, plllintil'l' AlIlsonllolli:r herehy demnndsjudgmenl in her I\l\'or lInd uguinsl defendunl George Ilenry Ileckndon in nn lImounl in excess of Flny Thousund Dollurs ($511,Ollll,OO), together with delny dUlllnges nnd the cosls of Ihis nction, Count VIII . Nellllllence i\lIIson lIoffer \'. Trnosport Corporntlon of Amerlcn 40, The nverl11ents of purugruphs I Ihrough 6, 12 through IS, und 37 Ihrough 39 nbove, ure incorporuled herein by reference, 41, The ul'oresuid molor vehicle uccidcnt, liS slllted lIhove, WllS direclly lInd proxhnlltcly cllused hy the negligence 01' delcndunl George lIenry lIeeklldon, lInd hecuuse suid defendullllll the lime of Ihe lIccidenl wns n servllnl, workl11l1n, lIgentnnd/or employee 01' delcndnnl Trunsporl Corporulion of America, nCling within Ihe course lInd scope of his lIgency lind/or employmenl, defendllnt Trllnsport Corporutlon of Amcrlcll is v\cllriously !llIble to Ihe plninlill' thr Ihe ncgligcncc of its lIgentllnd/or employee, f 11I.""...IIIII,\,II",.,ll/oU,'" ('(J.II -11- 42. In lllldilion, dcl'cllllllnl Trunsport l'orpornlion of AlllcriclI \VIIS indcpcndcntly ncgllgcnl, nlllongothcr wnys, hy Ihlllngtll hirc propcrly l)unlll1cd truck dri\'crs, hy Iilillng to propcrly trnln Its truck drivcrs, nnll hy Ihiling III propcrly supcrvisc ils lruck drlvcrs, which ncgligcncc ulso dircctly IInd proXillllltcly causcd thc sul~icct Illlllor \'chiclc accidcnllo occur, 43, As a rcsult of dclendllnt Trunspllrl t'orporlltilla of Alllcrica's ncgligcncc liS sctlhrlh in purngrllphs 4U lhrough 012 uhovc, plainlilT Allisllnlloller sullercd thc injnrics lIad dlllllUgcs sct lilrlh in pllrugrnphs 12 through IS IIho\'C, which injurics IInd dlllllagcs wcrc in nil WilY clluscd hy IIny IIctions or inllcllons on hcr purt. f I I WIIEREFOI<E, plaintiff Allisonllofler hcrchy dCllllll1llsjudglllcnt in her Ih\'or und uguinsl defendunt Trunsport Corporution of Alllcricu in unUlllllunt in cxccss of Fj(\y Thousllnd Dollllrs ($SU,OOO,OO), togcthcr with dclllY dUlllllgcs und thc costs of this uction, Counh' IX . N~lllll!cnt lnnlcllun of Emotlonul U1slrcss Allison llotTer ". Georl!e Henn' Hccklulon 44, Thc u\'Crlncnls of purugruphs I through 18, llnd 37 through 39 ubovc, are incorporatcd herein hy rcfcrcncc, 45, As u dircct und proxllllulC result of hcr contelllporllry und scnsory obscrvutionof injury to her Illolher und sislcr us sct filflh uho\'c, pluintiff Allison 1I0ller, \Vho \Vus within thc zunc of dun gel' creutcd hy thc dclendllnt's ncgligcncc and whouclulllly sullered physlcul illlpUCI thcrcfrolll, also sullered signilicunl cl11lllionlll distrcss rcsulting in physiclll huran, iacludlng hUI not Iilllited to, hypcrvcntilation, unxiety, and slccplcssncss. 46, PluiatiffAllisonlloller's llfi.lrcsuid clllotionul dislress wus dircctly und proxilllulely cuuscd und inllielcd hy thc dclendllnt (lcurgc IIcnry IIccklldlln's ncgllgcnce us set Iilrth uho\'c, f 1""'1\\"'1,1,,"....111"""1' ('( I,ll -12- WIIEREFORE, pluintlff ^lIlsonlloncr herehy dell\ullllsjudgll\ent in her lill'or und lIguinst defendant George lIenr)' lIeekllllon in un ull\ounl In excess of Filly Thousullll I>ollurs ($50,000,00), togelher with dcluy dUll\uges lIllllthe costs of this uetion, Counl X . NClIlll!cnllnnlclllln of Ell\lllhllllll U1slrm Allison lIoffcr \', Trllnsllllrl COnlllrlllllln of Alllcrlcll 47, The uvcnllenls of purngruphs I through Ill, und 37 through 411 lIhow, ure Ineorporllted herein hy relcrenee, 411, As u dlrectund proximute rcsnlt of her contemporury uml sensory ohser\'ution ot' injury to her mother und slstcr us sellbrth uhol'c, pluinliff Allison lIoner, who WllS within the zone of dunger crcuted hy Ihe defcndunt's negligence uud who uctuully suncred physlcullmpuet therefrom, ulso suffered signilicunt emotiouul distress resulting in physlcul hurm, including hut not limited to, hypervcutilution, unxiety, uml sleeplcssness, 49, Plulntill' Allisonlloncr's ulllrcsuid emotlonul distress WU5 directly und proximutcly cuused und inl1icted hy the delcndunt {]eorge lIenry lIeckudon's negligence us set Ibrth uho\'c, Bccuuse suid dclcndunt wus IIcting us the IIgent lind/or employcc of dclcndunt Trunsport Corporation of Al11ericlllltthc timc ot'thc suhjcctuccldcnl, dclcndunt Trnnsport Corporlltion ot' America is \'icuriously Iiuhle III I' Ihe ncgligently inl1lcted emotionul dislrcss hroughtllbollt hy thc actions und inuctions of its ugcntund/or employce wbo WIIS IIcting within the course IInd scopc of his ngency/cmploYll\cntllt the time of the suhject uccldenl. 50, Delcndunt Trnnsporl Corporntlon of All\ericu is IIlso rcsponslblc Il1l' negligcntly inl1lcting cl11otionul dlslress npon plulntiff Allison Iloncr hy rellson of its direct negligcncc, liS scl Illrth in purngrnpb no, 42 uhol'c, which directly ullll proxhllutcly hrought uhout plulntiff Allison Ilol'lcr's ulllresuid cmotional dlslress, / 1/1"'1.\ IIII/lidll".. 1/1"/1,'/' ( '( 1.1/ .13. WIIElWFORE, plulnli 1'1' ^lIIsollllollcl' hCl'ch)' dcmullds Judgmclll in hcl' 1i1\'()J' und uguillsl ddcndulll Tl'lIllsJllll't l'llI'plll'utioll of ^mcl'icu in 1111 umllllnl in cxccss of Fill)' Thousund Dolhll's ($50,O()(),OO), logelhcl' with dduy dumuges ulld thc cosls of Ihis uction, Count XI - NClllIl!cncc Ahhcy Hoffer \', (;corl!c Henn' IIccklulOll 51, The uWl'lllcnls of Jlul'IIgl'llJlhs I Ihrough 6, und 16 Ihrough 18 uhovc, lire ineorp()J'nled herein hl' relerellec. 52, The ulhresuid 1110tlll' \'ehide ueeidcut wus directl)' uml Jlroximulel)' euused h)' the negligence of defcmlulll (]c()J'gc Ilenr)' Ileckudon. us Ihcluull)' recited uhow, which ineludes hUI is 1101 limited to Ihe lilllo\\'ing: (0) Fuiling 10 hu\'e the Iroctor Il'lIiler under propcr und udcquute conlrol; (h) Mllklllg ullullsnlc ulld improper IUlle chnnge, in \'iolulion of 75 Pu,C,S,^, ~ 3334(11), und in Iilrlher \'iollltion of 75 Pu,l'.SA ~ 3309( I); (c) ^lIcl11pling 10 ovcrtnke und puss Plninlift"s Vehicle to Ihe lell without leu\'ing u sufe disllIllee to do so und wilhout slu)'ing 10 thc lell of the I'luintift"s Vehiclc unlil snlCl)' c1enr of Ihe ovcrluken vehicle, ill \'iolulion of 75 Pu,C,SA ~ 3303(u); (d) Opel'llting thc Il'IIclor Il'lIiler ul nn excessiw rule of speed under Ihe cirCUl11stnllces, in vlolnlion of 75 Pu,C.S,^, * 3361 und/or * 3362; (e) Fuiling 10 keep u rl'usonuhle 10okouI for olher whicles, including the Pluiulifl"s Vehicle, In\\'fully on the rond; (I) Fulliog 10 uppl)' Ihe hl'llkes III lime 10 u\'old the collision; und 1111",/",111/1""0..,,11/0"<'" ('0.1/ ,14. (g) I'crlllilling 11m! cnusing Ihc tmclor Imilcr 10 slrikc IInd collidc with thc I'llIiutiffs Vchiclc, und thcrclIl\cr pCrll1itting und cuusingthc dcrcnduut's trllctor tmllcr to run thc I'luiutlfl's Vchiclc 011' thc rolld, 53. As II dircct und proxillllltc result of Ihc dcfcmlllnt's ulilrcsuid ncgligcncc, pluintill' Abbcy 1I0ller sullercd Ihc injurics IInd dlllnugcs sct Ihrlh in pllrugruphs )(, through I H ubovc, which inJurics und dUlllllgcs wcrc in no \l'IIY clluscd by IIny IIclions or inllctions on hcr own purl. WIIEREFORE, plllintirr Ahbcy Iloncr hcrcby dcmundsjudgmcnl in hcr llavor IInd ugllinsl dcrcndunt Gcorgc IIcnry lIecklldoll in 1111 umount ill cxecss or Fi Ily Thousund Dollurs ($50,OOO,()()), togcthcr Wilh dcluy dumllges IIl1d thc costs of this IIctioll, ('oulII XII . NCllIIl!cllcC Abbc\' IIuffer \', Trllllsllorl Cornorlltloll uf AmericlI 54, Thc llvermcllls or parugruphs I Ihrough 6, 16 through I H, and 5! lhrough 53 IIbovc, arc incorporulcd hcrcin by rclercllcc, 55, Thc 1I1i.lI'csuid molor vehiclc IIccidcnt,us stlltcd IIbove, WIIS dircclly und proximutcly clluscd by Ihc IIcgligcncc or dclcndllnl Ocnrgc lIemy IIcckudon, und bccuusc suid dclendunt ut thc limc or thc uccidcnl WIIS II scrvunl, \l'orkmun, IIgcnl und/or cmploycc or dclcndunt Trnnsporl Corporation or Amcricu, aCling \l'ilhinthc coursc IInd scopc or his ugcncy und/or cmploymcnt, dclendunt Trnnsport Corporulion or AmcriclI is vicllriously Iiublc 10 Ihc plaintirr for thc ncgligcncc or its ugcnl und/or cmploycc, 56, In uddition, dclemlant Trnnsport Corporation or AlJ1crlclI WIIS indcpcl1llcntly ncgligcnt, ulJ10ng othcr \l'n)'s, by llailing to hirc propcrly ljuulilicd truck drivers, by Ihiling to propcrly truln its truck drivers, und by llailing to propcrly supcrvisc Its truck drivcrs, which ncgligcncc ulso dircctly und proximulcly cuuscd Ihc subJcctlllotor vchiclc IIccidcnt to occur. / 1/1"''''' 1",/,1"0(',\ II/ot!",. ('(i.1I -15- 57, As urcsult IIl'dcl'cndunl Tnlllspnrl ('nrpnl'llllnnlll' Alllcrlcu's nCllllllcncc us scl filrlh in pnfllllrnphs 54 lhruullh 511uhnw, 111nlnlltl' Ahhc)' Ilnller sullercdlhc Injurlcs undlllllllugcs scl filrlh In pnrugfllphs I () Ihrnugh III Uhll\'C, which Injurll's uud dUlllugcs wcrc In nil WII)' cnuscd h)' IIn)' ncllllns nr Inncllnns IIn hcr pnr\. WIIElmH>IW, pluinlll'l' Ahhcy Ilntler hcrch)' dcnllllldsjudglllcnlln hcr fnvnr nndllglllnsl dcfendllnl Trlluspnrll'nrpnrntinulll' Alllcl'lcu luun IIll1nuntln cxccss Ill' Fin)' ThousllndDnllllrs (S50,OOO,OO), logclhcr wilh dclll)' llulllngcs IInd Ihc cnsts nl' Ihls IIclllln, ~' ffi.( , .1 f '~f. ( ;rl. t:::&-l )., William C, Archbold, .Jr. (.corge C. Md'nrlnnd. .Jr. Allorne)'. for l'lnlnllff. Dolcd: Ifd!lj( !III.II'I'.lllll!,I"'k'j Il/oDcl' ( '( 1.11 . J(). ; ; d !l ., , YI~JUFICA'J'J('N MOLL V DIANE 1I0FFER. suhJeel hI Ihe pelllllties Ill' I K I)II,C.S, * 4904 relllllnll lu unswurn Iillsllielltlun lu lIulhllrilles. herehy livers tlml she is une ul' the Illlllntll1:~ In this IIctlun. IInd II1IIt Ihe lilcls set limh In the lilrelluinll CUlllpllllnl lire trlle IIml correct lu the hesl ul' her persunlll knuwledlle. intimnlltlull IIlld helieI', Doled: fJ I.2Q hv 1\1I.\.I',..IIIIII'\'''...,'\I'''''~,..('(),\1 r1~lnWICATI~ <)to' SlmVICE Georgc C, McFnrlnlld. Jr,. ESlJlllre. hcrcll)' ccrtlfics thutollthc dnte imllcntcd hclow. u truc nlld correct copy ofthe fhregolllg C0ll1plulll1 wns served U(lOIl coullscl fhr the defelldunts hy I1rst. elnss l11ull. poslnge pre(lnld. nddressed us lilllows: !tohert p, Reed. ESlJuire Metzger Wlckersluull Kllnuss & Erh Melloll BUllk Bulldillg III Mnrket Street. P,O, Box 93 Hurrishurg. I)A 17108.0093 j:jj:l~ c tih :J;-J.-I J. ' Gcorllc C. McFarland, Jr. Allorney for Jllalnllffs \ . 1 I Duted: '110!9( III/WI',I 11II(llt/",',\1I 1t11T~I'. C '( 1.1 / m ~ ~~ ::C 4,..,.... ", rl S'.:.! ......1 " JI,;lr - ' ;; ~, lA .. if: ~ "r .r . ....- t,., \/:",t' :; \~ Ie,.., " .t ~ .. II'''' , ~' ,; i :~ I r- ";1. .t;) l~_ i..." i".'~ J! ~ ~ 14 g III , III 8 i ~ ~ E e~~~~1 llll!l ~ r: ~ ' \ll m ( ~ 1 2: MOLLY DIANE HOFFER AND CHARLES HOFFER, JR., wife and husband, individually and as parents and natural guardians of ALLISON HOFFER AND ABBEY HOFFER, their minor children, I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS I cUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW Plaintiffs v. NO. 94-3697 TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA, INC., AND GEORGE HENRY HECKADON, JURY TRIAL DEMANDED Defendants ANSWBa WITH NEW MATTEa OF DBFENDANTS. TaAHSPOaT CoapoaATION OF AMERICA. INC.. AND OEOaOE HENRY HEOKADON AND NOW, com~ the Defendants by their counsel, Metzger, Wiokersham, Knauss & Erb, and represent the following: 1. Admitted. 2. Admitted. 3. Admitted. 4. Admitted. 5. Admitted. 6. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. By way of further answer, it is admitted that Defendant Heckadon was southbound on Interstate Route 81 in the center lane when oircumstances required him to suddenly veer to his right. As he returned to the center lane, said Defendant looked in his mirror and saw the Plaintiffs' vehiole in the ditch. All other details oonoerning the incident not specifioally admitted are hereby denied and proof there is demanded. 7. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof there is demanded. 8. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof there is demanded. 9. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof there is demanded. to. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof there is demanded. 11. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof there is demanded. - 2 - 12. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. By way of further answer, this paragraph violates Pa.R.C.P. 1020(b) which requires that damages and demand for relief of each Plaintiff be stated in a separate count. 13. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. By way of further answer, this paragraph violates Pa.R.C.P. 1020(b) which requires that damages and demand for relief of each Plaintiff be stated in a separate count. 14. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. By way of further answer, this paragraph violates Pa.R.C.P. l020(b) which requires that damages and demand for relief of each plaintiff be stated in a eeparate count, 15. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information suffioient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are - 3 - therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. By way of further answer, this paragraph violates Pa.R.C.P. 1020(b) which requires that damages and demand for relief of each Plaintiff be stated in a separate count. 16. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information suffioient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. By way of further answer, this paragraph violates Pa.R.C.P. 1020(b) whioh requires that damages and demand for relief of each Plaintiff be stated in a separate count. 17. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information suffioient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. By way of further answer, this paragraph violates Pa.R.C.P. 1020(b) Which requires that damages and demand for relief of each Plaintiff be stated in a separate count. 18. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and p~oof thereof is demanded. By way of further answer, this paragraph violates Pa.R.C.P. 1020(b) which requires - 4 - that damages and demand for relief of eaoh Plaintiff be stated in a separate count. COUNT I - NEGLIGENCE MOLLY HOFFER V. GEORGE HENRY IlECKADON 19. The averments contained in paragraphs 1 through 18 above are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 20. The averments of this paragraph and each and all of its subparts are denied in that I (a) Defendant George Henry Heckadon did not fail to have his tractor-trailer under proper and adequate control; (b) Defendant George Henry Heckadon did not, under the circumstances then and there prevailing, make an unsafe or improper lane change in violation of 75 Pa.C.S.A. S3334(a), and in further violation of 75 Pa.C.S.A. S3309(1); (c) DefenrJant George Henry Heckadon did not attempt to overtake and pass the Plaintiffs' vehicle in the manner described in the Plaintiffs' complaint; (d) Defendant George Henry Ileckadon did not operate his tractor-trailer at an excessive rate of speed under the oircumstances in violation of 75 Pa.C.S.A. S3361 and/or S3362; (e) Defendant George Ilenry Ileckadon did not fail to keep a reasonable lookout for other vehicles inoluding the Plaintiffs' vehicle lawfully on the road; - 5 - (fl Defendant George Henry Heckadon did not fail to apply his brakes in time to avoid a collisionl and (gl Defendant George Henry Heckadon did not permit or cause his vehiole to strike or collide with the vehiole of the Plaintiff in the manner desoribed in the Plaintiffs' complaint. 21. While denying the Plaintiffs' averments of negligenoe, after reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. WHEREFORE, Defendants demand judgment in their favor and against the Plaintiff, Molly Hoffer, By way of further answer, the Plaintiff's ad damnum olause is in violation of Pa.R.C.P. 1021 in that it states a specific sum and makes no reference to arbitration limits. COUNT II - NEGLIGENCE MOLLY HOFFER V. TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA 22. The averments contained in paragraphs 1 through 21 above are inoorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 23. While it is admitted that at all times material to the Plaintiffs' cause of action Defendant George Henry Heckadon was the agent, servant or employee of Defendant Transport corporation of America, any negligence on the part of said Defendant ie - 6 - speoifically denied for the reasons set forth above which reasons are incorporated herein by reference. 24. It is specifically denied that Defendant Transport corporate of America failed to hire properly qualified drivers and to eupervise the operation of said truck drivers, and proof thereof is specifically demanded. 25. After reasonable investigation, Defendant Transport corporation of America is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of the numbered paragraphs and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. WHEREFORE, Defendants demand judgment in their favor and against the Plaintiff, Molly Hoffer. By way of further answer, the Plaintiff's ad damnum clauee is in violation of Pa.R.C.P. 1021 in that it states a specific sum and makes no reference to arbitration limits. COUNT III - NEGLIGENT INFLICTION OF EMOTIONAL DISTRESS MOLLY HOFFER V. GEORGE HENRY HECKADON 26. The averments contained in par~graphs 1 through 25 above are inoorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 27. While it is believed and averred that Plaintiff Molly Hoffer's two daughters were passengers in the Hoffer vehicle, after reasonable investigation the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the - 7 - averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof iB demanded. 28. While it iB believed and averred that Plaintiff Molly Hoffer's two daughtere were paBBengers in the Hoffer vehicle, after reasonable inveBtigation the Defendants are without knowledge or information BUfficient to form a belief as to the truth of the avermentB of this paragraph and the Bame are therefore denied and proof thereof iB demanded. WHEREFORE, DefendantB demand judgment in their favor and againBt the Plaintiff, Molly Hoffer, By way of further anBwer, the Plaintiff'B ad damnum olauBe iB in violation of Pa.R.C.P. 1021 in that it BtateB a Bpecific Bum and makes no reference to arbitration limite. COUNT IV - NEGLIGENT INFLICTION OF EMOTIONAL DISTRESS MOLLY HOFFER V. TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA 29. The avermentB contained in paragraphB 1 through 28 above are incorporated herein by reference as though Bet forth at length. 30. While it iB believed and averred that Plaintiff Molly Hoffer' B two daughterB were paBsengers in the Hoffer vehicle, 3fter reasonable inveBtigation, the DefendantB are without knOWledge or information Buff icient to form a belief aB to the truth of the avermentB of thiB paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof iB demanded. - 8 - 31. While it is admitted that Plaintiff Molly Hoffer's daughters were passengers in her vehiole, and that Defendant George Henry Heokadon was at all times material to the Plaintiff's cause of action the agent, servant or employee of Defendant Transport corporation of America, after reasonable investigation the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the remaining averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. 32. The averments of this paragraph are denied for the reasons stated in paragraph 24 above, which averments are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. WHEREFORE, Defendants demand judgment in their favor and against the Plaintiff, Molly Hoffer. By way of further answer, the Plaintiff's ad damnum olause is in violation of Pa.R.C.P. 1021 in that it states a specific sum and makes no reference to arbitration limi ts. COUNT V - LOSS OF CONSORTIUM CHARLES HOFFER. JR. V. GEORGE HENRY HECKADON 33. The averments contained in paragraphs 1 through 32 above are incorporated herein by referenoe as though set forth at length. 34. While denying any negligence on the part of the Defendants, after reasonable investigation the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to - 9 - the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same at'e therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. WHEREFORE, Defendants demand judgment in their favor and against the plaintiff, Charles Hoffer, Jr. By way of further answer, the plaintiff's ad damnum clause is in violation of Pa.R.C.P. 1021 in that it states a speoifio sum and makes no reference to arbitration limits. CQUNI VI - LQgg OF CONSORTIUM CHARLES HOFFER. JR. V. TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA 35. The averments contained in paragraphs 1 through 34 above are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 36. While denying any negligence on the part of the Defendants, after reasonable investigation the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. WHEREFORE, Defendants demand judgment in their favor and against the plaintiff, Charles Hoffer, Jr. By way of further answer, the Plaintiff's ad damnum olause is in violation of Pa.R.C.P. 1021 in that it states a speoifio sum and makes no reference to arbitration limits. - 10 - COUNT VII - NEGLIGENCE ALLISON HOFFER V. GEORGE HENRY HECKADON 37. The averments of contained in paragraphs 1 through 36 above are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 38. The averments of this paragraph and each of all of its subparts are denied for the reasons set forth in paragraph 20 and its subparts above, which averments are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 39. Although denying any negligence on the part of the Defendants, after reasonable investigation Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. WHEREFORE, Defendants demand judgment in their favor and against the Plaintiff, Allison Hoffer. By way of further answer, the Plaintiff'e ad damnum clause is in violation of Pa.R.C.P. 1021 in that it states a specific sum and makes no referenoe to arbitration limits. COUNT VIII - NEGLIGENCE ALLISON HOFFER V. TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA 40. The averments contained in paragraphs 1 through 39 above are inoorporated herein by referenoe as though set forth at length. - 11 - 41. It is admitted that at all times material to the Plaintiffe' cause of action Defendant George Henry Heckadon was the agent, servant or employee of Defendant Transport corporation of America. After reasonable investigation, the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the remaining averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. 42. The averments of this paragraph are denied for the reasons set forth in paragraph 24 above, the averments of whioh are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 43. The averments of this paragraph are denied as set forth in paragraph 25 above, the averments of which are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. WHEREFORE, Defendants demand judgment in their favor and against the Plaintiff, Allison Hoffer. By way of further answer, the Plaintiff's ad damnum olause is in violation of Pa.R.C.P. 1021 in that it states a specif ic sum and makes no reference to arbitration limits. COUNT IX - NEGLIGENT INFLICTION OF EMOTIONAL DISTRESS ALLISON HOFFER V. GEORGE HENRY HECKADON 44. The averments contained in paragraphs 1 through 43 above are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 45. While it is admitted that Plaintiff Allison Hoffer was a passenger in the vehicle operated by her mother, after reasonable - 12 - investigation the Defendants are without sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. 46. The averments of this paragraph are denied for the reasons set forth in paragraph 20 and its subparts ahead, the averments of which are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. WHEREFORE, Defendants demand judgment in their faVOl' and against the Plaintiff, Allison Hoffer. By way of further answer, the Plaintiff's ad damnum clause is in violation of Pa.R.C.P. 1021 - 13 - in that it states a specific sum and makes no reference to arbitration limits. COUNT X - NEGLIGENT INFLICTION OF EMOTIONAL DISTRESS ALLISON HOFFER V. TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA 47. The averments contained in paragraphs 1 through 46 above are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 48. While denying any negligence on the part of the Defendants, after reasonable investigation said Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. 49. The averments of this paragraph are denied for the reasons set forth in paragraph 20 and its subparts above, the averments of whioh are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 50. The averments of this paragraph are denied for the reasons set forth in paragraph 24 above, the averments of which are inoorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. WHEREFORE, Defendants demand judgment in their favor and against the Plaintiff, Allison Hoffer. By way of further answer, the Plaintiff's ad damnum olause is in violation of Pa.R.C.P. 1021 in that it states a speoifio sum and makes no referenoe to arbitration limits. . COUNT XI - NEGLIGENCE ABBEY HOFFER V. GEORGE HENRY HECKADON 51. The averments contained in paragraphs 1 through 50 above are inoorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 52. The averments of this paragraph and eaoh and all of its subparts are denied for the reasons set forth in paragraph 20 and its subparte above, the averments of which are incorporated herein by referenoe as though set forth at length, 53. Although denying any negligence on their part, after reasonable investigation the Defendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and the same are therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded. - 14 - WHEREFORE, Defendantslemand judgment in their favor and against the Plaintiff, Abbey Hoffer. By way of further answer, the Plaintiff's ad damnum clause is in violation of Pa.R.C.P. 1021 in that it states a specific sum and makes no reference to arbitration limits. COUNT XII - NEGLIGENCE ABBEY HOFFER V. TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA 54. The averments contained in paragraphs 1 through 53 above are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 55. While it is admitted that at all times material to the Plaintiffs' cause of action Defendant George Henry Heckadon was acting as the agent, servant or employee of Defendant Transport corporation of America, the remaining averments of this paragraph are denied for the reasons set forth in paragraph 20 and its subparts above, the averments of which are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 56. The averments of this paragraph are denied for the reasons set forth in paragraph 24 above, the averments of which are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 5? The averments of this paragraph are denied for the reasons set forth in paragraph 25 above, the averments of which are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. - 15 - WHEREFORE, Defendants demand judgment in their favor and against the Plaintiff, Abbey Hoffer. By way of further answer, the Plaintiff's ad damnum olause is in violation of Pa.R.C.P. 1021 in that it states a specific sum and makes no reference to arbitration limi ts. NEW HATTER 58. The averments contained in paragraphs 1 through 57 above are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 59. It is denied that the subject accident giving rise to the Plaintiffs' cause of action was caused in any way by th~ reoklessness, negligence or carelessness of either of the Defendants. 60. The Plaintiffs' causes of action and damages are barred or limited by operation of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Finanoial Responsibility Law, 75 Pa.C.S.A. S1701 et seq. 61. Plaintiffs have not sustained such severe psychio shock and mental distress as to entitle them to maintain actions for negligent infliction of mental distress. By way of further answer, it is believed and therefore averred that only Plaintiff Allison Hoffer has received any psychological care for any matters arising out of the subjeot accident, which was limited to a brief course of treatment from which she has made excellent recovery. - 16 - 62. The damages of the Plaintiff, Molly Hoffer, are barred or limited by operation of the Pennsylvania comparative Negligenoe statute, 42 Pa.C.S.A. S7102. 63. The consortium olaim of the plaintiff, Charles Hoffer, Jr., is derivative in nature and is therefore barred or limited by the comparative negligence of his wife, Plaintiff Molly Diane Hoffer. WHEREFORE, Defendants demand judgment in their favor and against the Plaintiffs. METZGER, WICKERSHAM, KNAUSS & ERB By *~(r{i rV 4L/ Robert P. Reed, Esquire Attorneys for Defendants 111 Market street P.O. Box 93 Harrisburg, PA 17108-0093 (717) 238-8187 1.0.1 15624 Datedl Marc~ 6, 1995 - 17 - VBRII'IOATION ~ I, JbIJCf\1 t=: 'J I ':r ~,',f~~ ~\/I ~ ';"1\ , of Defendant, , being the Transport corporation of America, and as such officer am authorized to exeoute this Verification, do hereby certify that the facts set forth in the foreQoinQ Answer with New Matter are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief and that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.e.S.A. 54904 relatinq to unsworn falsification to authorities. TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA }1"<7 ~ ~- Datedl ,r;~fl.M"1 J): {ti'l5 I I ., j ! oeaTIFIOATB OF SBaVIOB AND NOW, this 6th day of March Robert P. Reed, Esquire, of Metzger, Wickersham, Knauss & Erb, attorneys for Defendants hereby certify that I served the within Answer with New Matter this day by depositing the same in the united states mail, postage prepaid, in Harrisburg, pennsylvania, addressed tOI George C. McFarland, Jr., Esquire Kassab, Archbold, Jaokson & O'Brien 214 North Jaokson street P.O. Box 626 He~ia, PA 19063 :I!JI!ar7.t ~ Robert P. Reed . , I, KASSAB ARCHBOLD JACKSON & O'BRIEN By: William C, Archbold, Jr, Allorncy I.D, No, 08605 By: Gcorgc C, McFarland, Jr. AlIorney I.D, No, 42388 214 N, Jackson Street Mcdia, PA 19063 (610) 565.3800 MOLL Y DIANE HOFFER, ct al. Plaintiffs COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA JURY TRIAL DEMANDED v, TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA, INC" et al. NO, 94.3697 Civil Term Defendants I'LAINTIIIFS' REI'LY TO NEW MATTEll Plaintiffs hereby reply to the new mailer averred by defendants in their answer to plaintiffs' eomplaint as follows: 58, The avenncnts containcd in paragraphs I through 57 of the complaint are incorporated herein by reference, 59, Inasmuch as this paragraph tails to set Ibrth any material facts which arc not merely denials of the uverments of the complaint, no reply is required, 60, The allcgations of this puragruph arc mere conclasions of law to which no reply is required, 6 \. II is admilled only thut only pluintiff Allison Holfer, to dute, has received uny psyehologicul cure for the emotional dlstrcss arising out of the subject uccldenl. However, Ills denied that such psychologicul cure wus "limited to u brief course of treulment" and further that Allison has "mude excellcnl recovery" thcrefrom, On the contrary, her psychological cure .r III.fr/'"lml'lcI,,<,sl/ M'~".I/N,\I covered a fairly extensive period of time and she Is stili troubled by emotional distress stemming from the subject accident. The rcmalnlng allegations of this paragraph arc mere conclusions of law to which no reply Is required, 62. The allegations of this parngraph lire mere conclusions of law to which no reply Is required, 63, The allegations of this pllrllgrllph arc mere conclusions of IlIw to which no reply Is required, By way of further response, it is specillcally denied that plaintlfl' Molly Iloll'er was in any way negligent In this matter; on the contrary, lit all times relevant hereto she exercised reasonable care In the operation of her vehicle for the safety of both herself and her tiunily, WHEREFORE, plaintill's demand Judgment in their fllvor and IIgllinst the defendants, jointly and sevcrally, in an II1l10untin excess ufthe arbitration limits,togcther with delllY damages and the costs of this action, .j] cl/J,'i:J!j t,. Gcorgc C. Md'lIrland, .Ir. Attorney for Plaintiffs Dated: March 21. 1995 f 11I.f'!r.IllIIl'lrI''''.f1/ lriffer.IINM -2, ,. VF.IUFICATION MOLL Y HOFFER, subject to the pcnulties of 1 K Pu,C,S, ~ 49114 relutlng to unsworn fulslllcatlon 10 uuthorltles, hereby uvcrs tllllt shc Is onc of the pluintlll's In this uctlon, und thuI the: fuels set forth In the lhregoing Reply to New Muller IIrc true und eorreetto the best of her personal knowledge. Inlimnutlon und bellcf. Dated: r \".\j''''\II/I'\fl'4'11J{,!n~,. HNM gmmJCATE OF SEI\VICE Georlle C, McFarland, Jr" Esquire. hereby certitles that on the dale indicated below. a true and correct copy of the forellolnll reply to new muller wus served upon counsel for the defendants by lirst-class moil, postulle pre-puld. uddressell us lililows: Robert p, J{eell. Esquire Metzller Wickersham Knauss & Erb Mellon Bank Buildlnll III Market Street, P,O, Box 93 Harrlsburll. PA 17108,0093 KASSA II ARCIIDOLl) JACKSON & O'BRIEN 1',. crli?;-JJ Geo ge C. McFarland, Jr. Attorney for l'lalntlffs Dated: Mnrch 21. 1995 t tt ti,t f i1/.1mlntflld,,,'!l/lldlrf.//N ^ I lR rs VI >II N - .'t: ~il': J....,....., It ~ \. l : . '-:: I.#~>,., l~ l.r.t~~ II .~ ,; ., Y,; __, i ,.(., ;:1 I ; ; I ;.,~ . ';~l '!' ~ ,,- , t)\./ ~ ... :i<! 1 II '1 I ~: i i I I , i PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL (Must be Iypewrlllon and submllled In duplicate) r:> <1 -. r--' TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY l..'} C) ul --,;> :;.,: (Check one) Please list the lollowlng case: ( XX* lor JURY trial at tho nexl term of civil courl. .. ) lor Irlal wllhout a jury, . 1.0 j.J1 ............................................................................................................................................................................ CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be staled In lull) MOLLY DIANE HOFFER and CHARLHS HOFFER, JR" wife and husband, individuallY and as parents and natural guardians of ALLISON HOFFER AND ABBEY HOFFER, their minor children, PLAINTIFFS (check one) Assumpsll Trespass Trespass (Motor Vehicle) (xX ( ) .--' (OlhOi)- ---- v. (f,taI1lt(tt)X vs, TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICAN, INC. and GEORGE HENRY HECKADON, The trial 1151 will be called on and._._ Trials commence on - -----.--... (Defendant)S Pretrials will be held on -.-...--.----.-' (Briefs are due 5 days before pretrials,) (The party listing this case for trial shall provide forthwith a copy 01 the praecipe 10 all counsel, pursuant to local Ruls 214.1,) vs, No, 2.4-:1.!!.21 Civil ..___. .. . _'_'_'_-_' 19 Indicate the aHorney who will try case for the party who Illes this praecipe: .Richar.Q A,... Stanko, Esqu i re, cO_\In_B.~l..-!E~P la !_ll.~i.!!.~. a!l<!l~r.l'!!1lia.!" .c_!l\~<ohl?<?!.d.' .J~., Esquire Indicate trial counsellor other parlles II known: _.Detll.lll3e-l::()u.nl:lE!l- is .RClb..ert.'p. _~e<<!L-g.B..!1u i r.!3._____ ...-' -.-------- -.,.-. --- -'-'-- -- -------.-..----. ~=S1,:d-Cli~; ~"hOO1~..Jt ~. ..~l re """- ...." Print Name:1l~~llARD A. STANKO,E. QUIRE This case Is ready for trial. Date: October 9, 1995 Allornoy lor: PLAINTIFl'S ~: In ,. t.; I .. II'" .-.- '. I' .... f .\ I ~ ~ ',\ ,. r ., I, , I. . ~ i,.". \1.' : : ;,"J l. it<. . ~; ) I. i J . ~l'i~~ ~ (5 ~i~ ::l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I g .c ~ ~ ' .~ ~ i ; ~ ~, ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~~ .~ i! ~ ' ~ i~ ~ ~ ~ @ ~ ~ ~J @ .~, ! ] ~ m i I ~ ~~~&~~ <~ [:):5 S '~-1 ti , E-<ei ~~'~~~g t> Sa ~ @ ] ~ !i! .g , ... ..... . ,t MOLLY DIANE HOFFER and CHARLES HOFFER, JR., wife and husband, individually and as parents and natural guardians of ALLISON HOFFER and ABBY HOFFER, their minor children Plaintiffs v. TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA, INC. and GEORGE HENRY HECKADON Defendants PRABOIPII To the Prothonotary I I COURT OF COMMON PLEAS I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA I I I : I : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED I I : I NO. 94-3697 civil Term Please enter the appearance of the undersigned as co-counsel on behalf of Plaintiffs. . . , Respectfully sUbmitted, a.~J~ A. Mark Winter, Esquire 310 W. chocolate Avenue Hershey, PA 17033 (717) 533-4868 ID #23178 1', ii, Ill' , __.u_~.-:;:;:::.:.:::=:~_..~.-;.,;-:~;:;z:~~-=-~-~-...,;;;:;:::.~::;::;;;.~~.~""-' -.-,.-------. _..-,.._,..~~-.-,.~ . 5 oC 1:l If, .. ~ '"'Sin 15 uJ '0 ~ :d I: 15 '.... In 0:"V1 OJ "- itj~ &i! o('O....Vl5 "- ::::V1~"" '.... >- u::: -J +-' u.~" 51 1:. ...J. c o 'c 'I." "'<0: '.... OJ n. VIe{ c. 1: 0- lu '" 6~"- 0- <<(a. otlC "-u. -. ~ c( W 'u VI Ou.. 0. ...J . L'" '" 0 t:c~ I-W 0.>- lulli V1:I: !3~ t:: u. It. " t: ex z~. u...- c ru> &;liJ oIL 0::1 o 3. ro...... c:o c: U12 ~5 :r 'O~ Q, 0:0: .. >'''' . ~ 00 e~ 0 UJ 1_ l1j "t:: UW ut., ;zu-=t- l!l ::~ c( f-j ~ o. c ..... I- U u.c( .... ..;: - res: . o:'t Z O...J 0 U v: ~Fc CVl ,~ 0.:'.... "'ffi > -- ~.w >-w>~ ~ ~' 1- 0: g5!p' ...Jt::....:Jt:: 0 t::i ...J "...., I: 0::1 ~g c: "'!f'.... ~ ~lE uu .._'~ C E .... ~ ~I g !~pl !~i:~ .( ~ ~ ~ -.--- .---..----.--.. ~ ____....___. ._._.~... .0_"__'" -----~~.-.-.---. -.-,.--.. .. ...,--"'~~,--_.~,-"---- .. I I; . I ." , f r KASSAB ARCHBOLD & O'BRIEN, L.L.P. By: William C. Archbold, Jr. Allomey I,D. No, 08605 By: Richard A. Stanko Allomey I.D. No, 29973 214 N. Jackson Street Media, PA 19063 (610) 565-3800 MOLLY DIANE HOFFER and CHARLES HOFFBR, JR., wife and husband, Individually and as parents and natural guardians of ALLISON HOFFER and ABBY HOFFER, their minor children Plalnliffs v, )> Allomeys for Plaintiffs : COURT OF COMMON PLEAS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA, INC. and GBOROB HENRY HECKADON Defendants : NO. 94-3697 Civil Term ORDER AND NOW, this J ~ day of lyJ'l/ I 1996, upon consideration of the foregoing Petlllon It Is hereby ORDERED as follows: 1. The selllement of the above-caplloned acllon for the sum of $160,000 Is APPROVED. 2. Proceeds of said selllement are to be distributed as follows: Total Gross Settlement: Less LIligatlon Costs: Pee Computation As to Molly & Charles Hoffer: 5158,203,87 x 80% co 33 1/3% of 5126,563.09 co 5126,563.09 5~2,187.70 584,375.39 5160,000.00 :$1.796.13 5158,203.87 542,187.70 ". ~ Pee Computalion As to Allison Hoffer, a minor: $ 3,955.10 $158,203,87 x 10% ... 25% of $15,820.39 ... $15,820,39 $ 3,955,10 $11,865.29 Pee Computalion As to Abby Hoffer, a minor: $ 3,955.10 $158,203,87 x 10% .. 25% of $15,820.39 .. $15,820.39 $ 3.95'.10 $11,865.29 Total Allomey's Pees: $ 50,097.90 Total Dlstribulion to Clients: Molly & Charles Hoffer: Allison Hoffer, a minor: Abby Hoffer, a minor: $84,375.39 $11,865.29 $11,865.29 3. Recovery to Allison Hoffer Is to be deposited In her name In a federally Insured savings account or a certificate of deposit or other similarly secured Investment vehicle with the more appropriate Interest rate and to be marked as not to be withdrawn without prior approval of this Court or until Allison Hoffer reaches the age of 18, 4. Recovery to Abby Hoffer Is to be deposited In her name in a federally insured savings account or a certificate of deposit or other similarly secured Investment vehicle with the more appropriate interest rate and to be marked as not to be withdrawn without prior approval of this Court or until Abby Hoffer reaches the age of 18. IT IS SO ORDERED: BY THE COURT: ^ , t ,/ IIIL ~ I J 1J'1-9'~ }lit- Ct l L. ,,'Li'-(L"l C, ,L . (1,1 1';) ,\\.L'-i.f'- f( Uffo Illy l, p1j )1/') ( -. (>oj r I L'~ .. i UII (1'\ , . .. I J ( \. )t~l C' , '. ,. :.,j (:)j . ;J [, ", , ij; I l~~ .- ~) lL. l' I ~'iJ .. '..- I \ ., I. ..J ~ . I l,j ,,; . 'i .. .. KASSAB ARCHBOLD & O'BRIEN, L.L.P. By: Wllllam C. Archbold, Jr. Allomey I.D. No. 08605 By: Richard A. Stanko Allomey I,D. No, 29973 214 N, Jackson Street Media, PA 19063 (610) 565-3800 MOLLY DIANE HOFFER and CHARLES HOFFBR, JR" wife and husband, Individually and as parents and natural guardians of ALLISON HOPFER and ABBY HOFFER I their minor children Plaintiffs v. TRANSPORT CORPORATION OP AMERICA, INC. and GEORGE HENRY HECKADON Defendants Allomeys for Plaintiffs : COURT OF COMMON PLEAS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED . . : NO. 94-3697 Civil Term J'LAINTlfFS' PETITION FOR COURT APPROVAL OF A MINOR'S COMrROMJSE AND NOW come Plaintiffs by their allomeys before the Honorable Judges of the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County In petition as follows: 1. Molly and Charles Hoffer are husband and wife, are adult individuals and are the parents and natural guardians of Allison Hoffer and Abby Hoffer all of whom reside at 5889 Laurel Street, Harrisburg, Pa, 17112, 2. Defcndant Transport Corporation of America, Inc. Is a corporation licensed to transact business within thc Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. 3. This cause of action arises out of a collision which occurred on March 20, 1993 on Interstate 811n East Pennsboro Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, At that time, Molly Hoffer was driving her vehicle In which her daughters Al1Ison and Abby wcre passengers, At or about 9:50 on the aforesaid morning a tractor trailer drlvcn by an employee of Dcfendant struck and collldcd with the Hoffcr vehicle causing Injuries as wlll be set forth hereinafter. ,. . 4. As a resuit of the aforesaid col1lslon, Molly Hoffer suffered carpal tunnel syndrome in her left and right wrists and cubital tunnel syndrome In her left and right elbows, along with other Injuries and dlsabllltles. Molly Hoffer underwent four separate surgical procedures In an effort to repair the Injuries that she suffered in this collision, In addition, Molly Hoffer was disabled from her employment for a period of approximately one year by her injuries. Attached hereto and marked as Exhibit" A" are the office records of Dr. Keith Zellger. 5. Allison Hoffer at the time of this colllsion was a minor child of age 6 at the time of the collision. She did not suffer any physical injuries as a result of the collision. Alllson did suffer with severe emotional distress as a result of this collision. She came under the care of Rosalee B. Keller-Brandt, M.S., a psychologist who provided psychotherapy to her for a period of time after the colllsion, Attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "B" is a report dated August 3, 1993 from Rosalee Keller-Brandt, M.S. in which she reports that Alllson had satisfactorily completed her psychological therapy and required no further treatment. 6. Abby Hoffer was a minor child, age 3 years old, at the time of the aforesaid collision. At the time of the collision Abby Hoffer was recovering from a Wilm's tumor In her right kidney. She was taken to Harrisburg Polyclinic Hospital, treated and released In the emergency room and found to be without traumatic injury as a result of this colllsion. A copy of the hospital records applicable to Abby Hoffer are attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "C" and Incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof. 7. Representatives of Defendant Transport Corporation of America have offered a total amount of S16O,OOO to settle the entire claim. 8. His the request of the Petitioners thatlhe settlement proceeds be allocated by the following proportion: 80% to Molly Hoffer; 10% to Alllson Hoffer and 10% to Abby Hoffer. r . 9. Petitioners believe that it would be In the best interest of Allison and Abby Hoffer to accept said settlement alllounts In full and final settlement of theIr causes of action, 10, Petitioners acknowledge and understand that by accepting said selllement offer neither they nor Allison Hoffer nor Abby Hoffer, nor anyone else acting on their behalf can ever again make claim against Defendant Transport Corporation of America for the injuries that they suffered which form the subject mailer of this lawsuit. 11. Petitioners acknowledge and understand that even if Allison and Abby Hoffer should begin to manifest injuries which can be causally connected with this collision, neither they nor Allison, nor Abby, nor anyone else acting on their behalf could file another lawsuit against Defendant Transport Corporallon of America, Inc. for injuries arising out of this collision. 12. Petitioners acknowledge and understand that their allomeys have Incurred a tolal of SI ,796, 13 In litigation costs. A copy of the ledger card for these costs is attached hereto and marked as Exhibit liD" and is incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof. 13. Petitioners acknowledge and understand that an allomey's fee In the amount of S50,097.90 has been claimed by the allomeys for representing the Hoffer family In this IIligatlon as follow: Total Gross Settlement: $160,000.00 Less Litigation Costs: :Sl..226JJ S158,203.87 Pee Computation As to Molly & Charles Hoffer: $ 42,187.70 S158,203,87 x 809(, - 33 1/31'1> of 5126,563,09 '" $126,563,09 S~ $ 84,375.39 ". Pee Computallon As to Alllson Hoffer, a minor: $ 3,955.10 $158,203.87 x 10% '" 25% of $15,820.39 .. $15,820.38 $.3.955.IQ $11 ,865.29 Fee Computation As to Abby Hoffer, a minor: $ 3,955.09 $158,203.87 x 1096 .. 25% of $15,820.39 '" $15,820.38 $-3.955.IQ $11,865.29 Less Total Attorney's Fees: ;:$ 50,097.90 14. Petilloners request this Court to approve the allocation of the remaining settlement proceeds as follows: 80% to Molly & Charles Hoffer: 10% to Allison Hoffer, a minor; 10% to Abby Hoffer, a minor; $84,375.39 $11,865.29 $11 ,865.29 15. Petllloners acknowledge and understand that the proceeds to be distributed to Alllson Hoffer are to be deposited in the name of the minor in a sequestered account in a federally insured bank or savings and loan institution in either a savings account, certificates of deposit or other appropriately insured investment vehicle which yields the greater retum and to be marked that said funds cannot be distributed to Alllson Hoffer until she reaches the age of 18 or until otherwise ordered by the Court. 16, Petllloners acknowledge and understand that the proceeds 10 be dist.ibuted to Abby Hoffer are to be deposited In the name of the minor In a sequestered account in a federally insured bank or savings and loan Inslltutlon in either a savings account, certificates of deposit or other appropriately Insured investment vehicle which yields the greater return and to be marked that said funds cannot be distributed to Abby until she reaches the age of 18 or until otherwise ordered by Ihe Court, r WHHRBFORB, Petitioners request this Court to approve thc settlement In the terms set forth above. Respectfully submitted, O. 1W 11)4; A. Mark Winter 310 W. Chocolate Avenue HcrsheYl PA 17033 Co-Counsel for Plaintiffs , KASSAB ARCHBOLD & O'BRIEN, L.L.P. By: William C. Archbold, Jr. AlIomey I.D. No. 08605 By: Richard A. Stanko AlIomey I.D. No, 29973 214 N. Jackson Street Media, PA 19063 (610) 565-3800 MOLLY DIANE HOPFER and CHARLES HOPPER, JR., wife and husband, Individually and as parents and natural guardians of ALLISON HOFPER and ABBY HOPFER, their minor children Attomeys for Plaintiffs : COURT OF COMMON PLEAS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA Plaintiffs v. : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA, INC. and GEORGE HENRY HECKADON Defendants : NO. 94-3697 Civil Term VERI FICA TION I, Molly Diane Hoffer, hereby state that I am the parent and natuml guardian of Al1ison Hoffer and Abby Hoffer, minor children, that I have read the foregoing Petition for Approval of a Minor's Compromise Settlement, that I understand the facts and conditlons set forth In the foregoing Petltlon for Approval of a Minor's Compromise Settlement, and that I agree to and accept the terms as outlined in the foregoing Petilion for Approval of a Minor's Compromise Settlement In the above mailer. ~L~,n^ +1# Molly ane Hoffer Sworn to and Subscribed Defore me thls.:'>I~ay of'1'...~~, 1996, ~) ~ l~"U- tJ -.:~ JIJ-\ Notary Public NOTARIAL SEAL DIANE III IlITZ, NolalY Pulllie IIml"y, I 'A Daupllin Counly My CUlnll\l"lun hpues Nuv U, lUUU , KASSAB ARCHBOLD & O'BRIEN, I..L.P. By: William C. Archbold, Jr. Auomey I.D. No. 08605 By: Richard A. Stanko Auomey I.D. No. 29973 214 N. Jackson Street Media, PA 19063 (610) 565-3800 MOLLY DIANE HOPPER and CHARLES HOFFER, JR., wife and husband, individually and as parents and natural guardians of ALLISON HOFPER and ABBY HOFPER, their minor children Plaintiffs v. TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF AMERICA,INC, and GEORGE HENRY HECKADON Defendants Attorneys for P1a1nliffs : COURT OF COMMON PLEAS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA . . : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED : NO. 94.3697 Civil Term C:1!:JtTIFlCATJJ; OF SERVICE I, A. Mark Winter, Bsqulre, hereby certify that on the below listed dale I caused a true and correct copy of the foregoing Petllion of Plalnliffs for Court Approval of a Minor's Compromise to be served by first class mall, postage prepaid upon the following counsel: Robert I'. Reed, Esquire Metzger Wickersham Knauss & Erb Mellon Bank Building 111 Market Street, P.O. Box 93 Harrisburg, PA 17108,0093 a. .~1j ~;ix A. MARK WINTER, ~QUIRB DATED: I- - Ilj - '1" ,.r Cvhlhl' A ... ......,,,.., "..,,;,~" 11-' N""II (!) . '.. H01.1.Y BOHEIl H\.E NOTES . 5/10/94 Seen today in follow-up. lIer shoulder isn't any better. There are symptoms radiating down her arm and up towards the neck. 1 really believe it's rotator cuff in origin. I'll give her an injection to her shoulder which will be diagnostic, in that if it relieves her pain, we know it's the rotator cuff, and therapeutic, in that the corticosteroid in it can help relieva the inflammation. I'll see her in a week. KLZ: eer 5117/94 Seen today in follow-up. The injection to her ahoulder didn't help at all. 1 feul we cen rule out the shoulder es the source of the problem. 1 think since she's having palpatory tenderness at the base of the cervical spine in the musculature with trigger point noted there today, we can consider more of a muscular problem. I cennot juatify evidence of a disc bulge or herniation in the neck. I'll treat her with physical therapy to the neck for muscular problem in the base of the cervi- cal spine. We can call it a cervical strain if We want 2" spasm. 1'11 soe her after one week of P.T. K1.Z; ser 5/31/94 She is seen today in follow-up. lIer neck is improving with the P,l', to this point. 1 feel that the muscular problems from which she is suffering are related to the way she sits at her desk at work and positions herself. Right now her employer is investigating what can be done to repoaition her at the desk in the way of poaitioning her CRT acreen ao aa not to strain har neck and shoulder. I'm going to continue her P.T. in the meantime, es it doea help, and we'll do what we can to try to facilitete getting her a mora ergonomically aet up work aituation. I'll recheck her in three weeks. KLZ/jep 6/21/94 She ia aeen today in follow-up. lIer neck ia doing much better. She has good days and bad days; some dsyo ahe has no discomfort whatsoever, and other dsya it can bother her. She has only rare, occasional symptoms going do~'l\ her arms, mostly juat a tired sensation after using them a lot. She is in the process of having her desk and the workplace set up more ergonomically correct, and once that is completed I think she will do well. She can continue to do what she has been doing in p, T. on her own, and a t this point I will see her only on an as needed basis if there are other problems. If there are any concerns or problems she will give us a call. KLZ/jep . MOl.1.Y 1I0FFER. FILE NOTES . 12/21/93 She's seen todny in follow-up. Tho Oruvoil dramatically improved nny symptomatology remaining in her left arm and has improved the right arm to. One day when she didn't take it, she noticed a definite incraase in her symptomD. I'll kanp her on it over tha next three weeks and then have her Dtop it for a week. I'll see har in four weeka, if being off the medication ahe' s improved, we'll go with it. If there 10 increase in aymptomatolo!l)' nnd the medication isn't hen ling it, only masking thn symptoms, then I think we should consider ulnar nervo transposition of the right elbow. KLZlser Cl Betsy Allison @ CNA Ins. Co. P.O. Box 593925, Orlando, F1. 32859 Claiml 9365973 1/20/94 She is seen todsy in follow-up. lIer right elbow is not improved st all. She still has symptoms of cubital tunnel syndrome. There has baen failure of complete resolution with the medication; the medication only calms it down a little. At this point I am recommending an antsrior ulnar nerve trsnsposition of the right elbow. We arc msking arrangements for this at Community General Osteopathic Hospital on Thursday. 2/3/94. and I'll recheck her in the office the following Tuesday to change the dressings and remove the splint. KLZ/jep 2/8/94 She is seen today in follow-up. She is five days status post ulnar nerve transposition of the right elbow, and it appears to be working, as the pain from her elbow up toward the shoulder is gone; from the elbow down toward the ring and small finger yet has to disappear. I'll recheck her next Tuesday to remove the stitches. In the meantime we are putting a light dressing on it. and she can get it wet in a bath or shower starting tomorrow. She can either cover it with a dressing or leave it open to the air. She no longer needs a splint, and docs not have to use the sling. I would like to hsve her begin using it and moving it. and we'll see how it does, KLZ/jep 2/15/94 She is seen today in follow-up. Her elbow ia healing nicely. We removed the sutures. Her pain is now gone in the ring and small fingera; she has some occasional d1ocomfort up toward the upper arm, nnd the elbow is aore. We are going to have her continue to work on motion, as well as using the elbow as she's comfortable to. I'll recheck her in one month. KLZ/jep . . ~~~~ ~-~:~:lM!!~-=---~~.__. __. ...d.!:f.. '___ -J/oW J ______._ -----0...-".- _'''.n ----"-~ ...z_~ r -. ...--- _.__ --- -'\0--- -.--- ...--- ---~- ----- --------.--.----- -------- -..- -_._--~,----.__. - ----.--- --.--- ....---...- .-. ---- .~._._~. -- --- ------. -------- -_._._.__.._------_....,_.~~_...- -.------.---- . - -...........- -.-.-- -...........--.-....-.- .-.........-....0....- -"-- .- ..--..- .. ..... ._---,~- ..~..~...~_._~~~.._...._------~._.~---_. ............... -- ..- . .... _.-. -,_..- ...---.-.,..... ......- . . .'- ----.---., ._,_.. .....__.._.._....__........_.._-_..._.~..... -' .....,...-.-.. --.----.-..-..--.-. --.------.. ....--...--- _.-.< ..",,,.-...-. --...-. .-...--.---..- --.- --- ._-.... -. ..+- ----...-. .----- ..-..-..,...,-.---- -..- ----...---- - -~ --..- .- --- -- -- -----...-- ..... --.- --..-------.....= -----......--...--..,..... ..-_._- _...- ...--- ... .- -..,......-- ---- --...-.....- ----.-.------ ~...- .. _.~'-.._-_.._._.- -----.....--...... .......,~...._,-.. -........-.. -----~-_._--_.. .- -._- .-..---. --..-..--. ---~-~--.. .._.-.. .,. .._t... '_"'_'__' .~......._.-,.-,...._..._.--.....- ..~-~ ...--.-.-....-....-- -- _.- --.... -- ..--- --- ......... .----..--. ..'... - ... .~~_._. ._~. ----.-.-.-........--........-----.---. _.~-_....-........_._- . ......--...... -.-.-.......--....-...-- ....-- ._......~-- .........................-.- -..---.. -"-'''''''-- .' .... .-...-..-----....---. ...-.... -.-...-.-..... _.~- -dS~' _~cQ i' f(;- 'j ~i=--rr;-~_.f"/~-_~~ _'K.d-'~~.______ .!J..k/~.~ _______..___._..._.____..._...___..__._ , . , I I I . I @ , -)./-13i ~l: . M1pt2!~' ~ I!.:(/o/ t1a-<V GIlt &. tL ~.'t <--. .;2w1s- ~-I'#~ . 11;lI'/t~_______ 6cLulS~~ SdYl\.Z. ~..Lt.1~ ; VI0>~ CC')t\..< . . ,{.:'bw {~ ,g't'<-- ~C{)/~ ;'0- 'i7- ; : 7l'.,,~j~~--~-Ad.i{L,ar._o~...~.-_._-. ! ~l# ,..: ~t{e, ~~r-.:t;-----.- I ~~-&.jL- - ---. r-9'} 4--i::tt--:~-'lJ/ . _ :____: J I~ - . -.----. ..-'-- . ..fl,d A-- Jll-~=u;d-:C;J"7;):tLi---- ----- --- -- .--.----1..._.#__.... ..___(,_.___p_____ ./.._ ....___. _. ... _...". .._....... .. . ......_ _.. i / . ..... ClItiDpIIIo AIIodalll, LId. IIInML., 0.0, .. R.1CIiIIdI. 0,0: I<IMl L fAIgIr, D.o. 4SO Fuwn Aw, Han\IbIIv, PA 17109 (717) 658-8222 FILE NOTES MOLLY HOFFER 10/11/93 - Note to file - Phone Call from therapist Physical therapist called stating there Is Improved function of the left arm. Continued discomfort right wrist. Progressive manual resistance exercises have been occurring with success. Treatment progressing fine. If any suggestions, please advise. kir 10/12/93 She 10 seen today in follow-up, First of all, her ulnar nerve transposition seems to hsve done welll she is having no symptoms in relation to the ulnar nerve or the median nerve in the left arm. She does have evidence of some rotetor cuff tendinitia in both shoulders on examination, which saems to have occurred over the last couple of weeks since she was leaning over a whirlpool and leaning forward with a hot pack on her shoulders in P.T. We are going to switch from using heat modalities there to ice message and ultrasound to the should~rs, and maybe electrical stirn, but have them keep working on strengthening to the left upper extremity. We ere also going to have them treat the carpal tunnel syndrome in her right hand with modalities as needed, as well as strengthening to the hand. r'll recheck her in two weeks, and if there is no res 1 improvement we can consider decompressing the corpal canal in her right wrist. I'm not going to obtain an EMG because previously the carpal tunnel syndrome and the ulnar nerve symptoms in her left arm did not show on EMG evaluation, although the problem was there and disappeared with surgery. I have no reason to believa, tharefore, that an EMG would be aignificantly positive in the right hand at this time. I think she has definite symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome involving pain, numbness into the thumb, index and long fingers, has a positive Tinel's and Phalen's at the right wrist. Therefore, I feel if it fails to respond to P.T."" we can consider surgical intervention. KLZ/jep SU5qUllhanna (\rlll"o"~" ~'~ocI818l, lid. BII" ' ' Robel~" ,.. c.' J. Kellh L.Zlligel, llO. 450 Powell AVe. 9/7/93 HanIsbuIll, PI. '7109 (7'7) 658.8222 She is seen today in follow-up. lIor left wrist carpal tunnal is doing wel1. The left elbow cubital tunnel is doing okay; thero ia much less pain and her preoperative symptoms seem to be casing. She is having some pain on the back of the forearm, which I think might be a mild tendinitis from over-use and weakness. We are going to have them work on that in therapy. Aside from that, she has carpal tunnel and cubital tunnel symptoms down her right arm now, 1 am also going to have them work on that in r. T.. put a cockup splint on her right wrist. If thore is not significant improvement in two weeks, we might need to consider other alternatives on the right aide, although I hope we don't have to. KLZ/jep . MOLLY D. 1I0FFER FIJ.E NOTES 9/21/93 She ia seen today in follow-up. lIer left elbow incieion hae healed nicely, The elbow is better than it Was before surgery, but still has s ways to go yet. she has a lot of soreness in the elbow, but it's posterior in the tricepe insertion. lIe'll have them working on strengthening to her triceps, biceps, foreerm muse lee and her grip atrength in the loft hand, as well as trying to treat and calm down her carpal tunnel symptoms on the right. She has been using a cockup splint and they have been working on the right, but so far it I S bean to no avail. I am hoping as the left gets stronger and she can uaa it more. the right will get less abused and therefore the symptoms will dissipate, If not, wa might need to decompresa her right carpal tunnel. KLZ/jep I- HOLLY lJ. nOFFER FI U: NOnS lqUthlnna OI1hoptdic Assoclales, lid IIInWd I.l.Illglr. D.O. IIolIII R. KndI. D,a. I<IIt1LWgIr,D.O, 450 PoMrIA'lt. Hanlsburg, PA 17tOG (717) 558.8222 . 7/20/93 She is 6een today in follow-up. P. T. has helped her elbow and her wris t to some degree, but it is not completely batter. I om going to continue her in therapy lit this time, seeing her again in two weeks to note how she's doing at that point. KLZ/jep 7/28/93 She is secn today in follow-up. lIer left elbow is still very bothersome I the injection didn't help. She hes cubital tunnel syndrome, on physical examination, involving the ulnar nerve at the left elbow, although tho carpal tunnel syndrome is nearly completely resolved at the wrist, I'm going to place her into a resting splint on her elbow for the cubital tunnel syndrome. If this doesn't help, in conjunction with the therapy, then we'll need to consider an anterior ulnar nerve transposition at the left elbow. I'll recheck her next Thursday and determine further care. KLZ/jep 8/6/93 She is still having problems with her left elbow. The splint actually worsened the condition. She has a significantly positive Tinel' s at the elbow. She hss failed to respond to splinting or bracing, failed to respond to conservative management in the form of physicel therapy, injections, hea t, anti- inflammatories, and therefore I feel we can proceed with an anterior ulnar nerve transposition of the left elbow. We are going to schedule her for Honday, August 16, for outpatient surgery at eGOn. I'll recheck her in the office then on Thursday, August 19, for redressing. KLZ/jep ~ 8/19/93 She is seen today in follow-up. She is three days status post anterior ulnsr nerve transpoRition of the left elbow. She is having a fair amount of discomfort at this time, but there is very little swelling or bruising sround it. We are placing her back into the splint, and I'll recheck her next Tuesday in the office at which time we will remove the oplint, possibly remove the sutures and begin motion to her elbow. KLZ/jep 8/24/93 Seen today in follow-up. We're removing the sutures from her elbow and discontinuing the splint. She'll begin motion to the elbow. I'll see her in two weeks. She's much less painful than she was and I think will go on to have a good result. A lot of the tingling is disappearing in the fingers and as time goes will continue to get better. She should avoid over doing it with her elbow, just slowly gradually working on the motion and activities with it as she can tolerate it. KLZlscr ~peiJc ~\IS, LIO. ~,.lAI\g1r,D.O. RobIC\ R.~' D.O. ."....lAIgIIl D.? .,...AvI, 4/26/93 PA 17109(717)&58-8222 PIlONE CALL from pationt at Community Imaging - was there fo~Y MRI but could not tolerate due to claustrophobia. Per Dr. K. Zeliger, prescription phoned to The Rx Place, Colonial Commons, for Ativan, two ,5 mg tablets. toke one one hour prior LO MRI and second tablat 10 minutes prior to MRI. Patient cautioned about having someone drive her to and from HRI appointment, Recheck as scheduled in office. Ikas . FILE NOTES MOLLY 1I0FFeR 5/4/93 see letter to Dr. Bird 5/18/93 Seen today in follow-up. lIer back was doing very well with P,T. until this last Sundsy when sitting in church, her back went into spasm, it is getting batter at this time and is not as painful. There is no significant radistion on a continual basis down the legs, but she does get aome irritation of the L5 nerve root, giving her pain down the side of thigh and towarda her knee on occasion. even making her leg with a lot of activity feels as if it is getting weak. I feel if they continue working on her yet s couple of weeks in P.T., hopefully that will pass to the point that she can do it on her own and with continued exercising at home. hopefully this will all disappear in the back. Her carpal tunnel syndrome is still bothersome. She still has a positive Tinel's and Phalen's test at the right. She has pain from the elbow into the tip of the long finger and I think haa significant median nerve problems in the left wrist. Continue P.T. Although it has been improving overall, if it is not a lot better in two weeks, I think we should consider the possibility of surgically decompressing the median nerve to get rid of this problem. If she is still having difficulty with grabbing things, using her hand at home for daily activities. chances are it is due to the median nerve problem, The arm is awakening her at night. We will give this another two weeks to see if it improves, if not, consider surgical decompression as an outpatient under local anesthesia to take care of the median nerve problem in the wrist. I'm hoping the back will continue to improve with exercising. RKlser 5/25/93 PIIONE CALL - patient reports that aeveral days with her right hand as she has with left hand. to discuss with Dr. Zel1ger at that time. /kaa , ago sha began having aar.e symptoms lias recheck appointment next week - . SUSQU~HANNA ORTHOPEDIC A~SOCIATES) LTD. GIIT/fOPWIC. TR^U~\."TIC. IWID t; SPI"...l SUI/JEllY' SPOI/TS NEDIClNE t; o."NCE OllmOPE:DICS Bernard I. Zelloer, D.O. Robert R. Kanede, 0.0, Keith L. Zellget. 0.0, 450 POWtt1 Avenue, Suite 101 liac"Iburg. l'ennl11vanla 171 09.~926 reiephone (717) 558.8222 rax(7171561'2555 Auaus~ 11, t994 AMP Incorporated ATTNI Karen S. Kreisar, R.N, P.O. 80K 3608 Harrisburg, PA 17105-360B REI Molly Hoffer Dear ~urse Kreiserl This is in response to your latter of June 2B, 1994 in which you addressed three recommendations towards improvina Holly Hoffsroe work e~s~ion. 1 agree and approve of each modification listed, This should alleviste the stress and strain to her neck and shoulders by elevatina the computer Icreen, keyboard and work papers to eye level. Should you have any additional questions, please do not hesitata to contact me. Sincerely, K~tl~~. ~1i::' !!~ KLZI tlb OCT-21-1994 11105 FROM SUSQUEHANNA ORTHOPEDICS 16108910460 P.Ol TO . SUSQUEHANNA ORrHOPEDIC ASSOCIATES, LTD. ORmOPlmlC. TRNJMI\TIC. HAND (, SPINA~ SUI<<1ERY. SPORTS MEDICINE li /J.'oNCE ORmoPEDlCS Ikmard I, ;tellgv. D,O. Robert R. KanI4a. D.O. Kelth L.leIJlI", D.O. 4!lO PoWllfl AWlIlue, Sulle 101 HlrrtwUrg, I'lonlll)lvanl. 17109,,5926 Telephone (717) 558~222 FII<(717)56lr~55 , ! November 23. 1993 William K. Bird, D.O. COMMUNITY FAMILY MEDIOIN! CENTER Bloom Diagno.tic Centar 4300 Londonderry Road Harri.bu~g, PA 17109 i I I I II , I , , Ii REI Holly D. HOff'7l' II : ! I I .; I " 1 sa~ Molly Hoffer today in follo~-up. H~r right ~aud'is,doina ~ell. Her carpal tunnel' decompression 18 working in that her pr!loperat1ve l)'1j'PtolU art much relieved; sha is able to sleep much batter at night; ; ; w. removed the suturu today, dhcontinuad tba Bpl~nt,. and Ih~ ~li :baain motion of thl wrist and l\&nd. She ~ill jutt u.. a cockup splint at ~ept1aa oval' tbe uext month. I'll ncheck her ic t~6 ~eekl and 1..!ho~'sho'l dofJtg at that, tima, ' ; i 1 thank you very cuch for allowiug m. to particip4to in tho e~~1 of your patient, : , , Dear Dr. .Bird: i I Sincsrely. I' I KLUjap Keith L. Zlltger. 0,.0. I , ,I :1 , I I , , , I d :1 Poel.II" Fa. Note T. ----------- 7671 On F.... Co. Plio". . &ld.). ~.. . , I TOTAL P.Ol " .. · , ~IIII REiiAB1UTATION 1111_ l~artEof N T E R - Mechanlcsburg Rehab System HE C g I\' H D IIOV 2 61993 November 19, 1993 Keith Zeliger, D.O. 450 Powers Avenue lIarrisburg, PA 17109 RE: MOLLY 1I0FFER OX: R ARM CTSI CUBITAL TUNNEL SYNDROME, L ARM TENDONITIS SiP CUBITAL TUNNEL SURGERY DISCHARGE SUMMARY DISCIIARGE DATEI 11/3/93 Dr. Zeligerr Ms. Hoffer has been discharged from our facility as per your instruction. Following is a summary of her discharge status: REASON FOR ADMISSION: 1. Chief complaint: Weakness L arm SiP surgery) pain issues, pain R hand/UE. 2. Posture: Forward head, c-spine protracted, rounded shoulders. 3. C-spine: AROM within normal limits, no UE symptoms. 4. Limited B shoulder AROM, limited L elbow AROM, limited B wrist extension/flexion AROM. 5. Decreased B UE strength. 6. Palpation: Tenderness posterior L elbow, L lateral epicondyle and L medial elbow, tenderness R wrist. 7. Healed scar L medial elbow. PHYSICIAN'S ORDERS: 1. Modalities as needed, strengthening (9/93), 2. Continue P. T., strengthening (9/93). 3. Resisted L UE exercise, cold pack, ultrasound/phonophoresis, electrical stimulation L shoulder/UE exercise bilaterally (10/12/93) . 4. Continue P.T. (10/25/93). SERVICES PROVIDED: 1. l~hir1pool 2, Ultrasound L elbowlR wrist 3. Exercise (ROM, stretching, resisted) 4. Whirlpool replaced by moist heat pack 5, Cold pack, electrical stimulation L shoulder 6. Phonophoresis L shoulder lOHO Lin~lc"o\\.n Ho..J . I b'lhhu,~, I'A 17110 . Telephone( 717) 14H1IO . E.. (717) 545.2956 ,,' .. Molly Hoffer November 19, 1993 Page 2 RESULTS OF THERAPY' (Key: V=Goal achieved I N=No progress I P=Progress, but goal not achieved) 1. P Patient reported decreaae in pain nymptoma L elbow. 2. P Functional improvement noted by patient regarding abilities of L UE. 3. N Ongoing complaint of R wrist pain. 4. P L ahoulder diacomfort aubaided after modality intervention. 5. V Full L ahoulder AROM. 6. N Decreaaed B wriat AROMI V- Full PROM B wriat flexion/extension. 6. V Patient 1a independent with current exerciae program. COMMENTS: Patient waa diacharged from P.T. pending surgical procedure to addreaB R wrist pain/dysfunction. Thank you for referring thia patient to us for her therapy program. Sinoerely, -p..;..~-\~. W.......-c.-, /'.r. Patrioia R, Hoover, P.T. PRll/bjb . SUSQu~HANNA ORTHOPEDIC ASSOCIATES, LTD. ORTliOPED/C. TR"'UN"'T/C. II^ND C SPIN"'L SURGERY' SPORTS ~lEDICINE C OI.NCE ORTHOPEDICS Oem.rd I. Zellger. D.O. Robert R, Kanede. 0.0, Kellh L. Zellger. 0.0, 450 Powerl ^venue, Sulle 101 Herrilburg, Pennl~venla 17109.5926 Telephone (7171558.8222 Fax (717) 561.2555 July 6, 1993 William Bird, D,O. 895 South Arlington Avanue Harrisburg, PA 17109 Dear Doctor Birdl Kelly Doffer is seen todsy in follow-up. She's three weeks status post carpal tunnel decompression in her left hsnd, it is slowly improving. The etrength is slowly returning to the hend, the motion is getting better, stretching of the wrist still causes s pulling discomfort and the elbow is still pinpoint tender over the triceps insertion. I'll send her to physical therapy to and strengthening to the wrist and inflemmation in her triceps area. get this over tha hump for atretching hand, aa well as decreasing the I think s he has triceps tendonitis. messagu as needed to a resolVing carpal tunnel decompression, as well as Physical therapy will use ultrasound, moist heat, ice the elbow and wrist and strengthening to both areas. I'll see her in two weeks. Thank you very much for allowing me to participate in the care of your patient. Sincerely, @) Kaith L. KLZ/ser SUSQUEHANNA ORTHOPEDIC ASSOCIATES,LTD. ORTHOPEDIC. rR....UM....TlC. H....ND 6 SPIN....L SURGERY' SPORrs MEDICINE 61l'oNCE ORTHOPEDICS Bernard I. Zellger. 0.0, Robert R. Kaneda, 0,0, Keith L. Zellger. 0.0, 450 Powel'l ^venue, Sulle \01 Hamlburg, Pennl~Vlnla 17109.~926 Telephone (717) ~~8.8222 FIk (717) ~61'2"~ June 22. 1993 William Bird, 0,0. 895 South Arlington Avenue Harrisburg. PA 17109 Dear Doctor Bird: I saw Holly Roffer today in follow-up, Her left hand 1& doing better, The carpal tunnel is improving. She still haa pain at tha elbow in ths ere a of the triceps insertion. I will have her continue the splint, She will use her arm and hand as she'a comfortable to. hoping the elbow will calm down. I'll see her in two weeks to see how she's doing. She may get her hand wet in bath or shower. Thank you very much for allowing me to participate in the care of your patient. KLZ/ser Sincerely. I!I-";~ Keith ~~ger. 0,0, ([) SUSQUEHANNA ORTHOPEDIC ASSOCIATES, LTD. ORTIIOPEDIC. rRAu~t.~T1C. IIM'/D Co SPINAL SURGERY' SPORrs ,..tEDICINE Co n~NCE ORT//OPEDICS Demacd I. Zellger. 0,0, Robert R. KIIneda, D.O. Keith l. Zellger. 0,0, 450 PoWer1 ^VtIlUe, Sullo 101 Harrisburg, Pennl)1vanla 17109.5926 Telephone (717) 558.8222 Fax (717) 561.2555 June 16, 1993 William H, Bird, D.O. COMMUNITY FAMILY MEDICINE CENTER 895 South Arlington Avenue lIarr1&burg, PA 17109 REI Holly 0, Hoffer Dear Dr. Bird I I aaw Holly Hoffer today in the office, 6/16/93, Her left hand is two daya status poet carpal tunnel decompression. Overall the wound ia healing nicely, We redreseed it today and reapplied the splint, The pain in her thumb and index finger is a little bit less at this point. The long finger 1& somewhat irritable, and the ring and small fingers are somewhat irritated. The elbow also still hae some irritetion. 1 think aa tho swelling goes down in her hand and she starta uaing it mora after wa discontinue the eplint next Tuesday and remove the suturea, she will be feeling better. At this time I would like to have her move her elbow. her thumb. and her fingers ss ahe is comfortable to, elevating it and icing it, and using the pain medication aa she neede to. We will determine further care next Tuesday. 1 thank you very much for allowing me to participate in the cere of your patient. Sincerely, KLZ/jep K.,,!(<jf?2 . .' Physical Medicine. P.~. Edwin A. Aq~lno, M.o. Physical Mrdlclnr and Rrhabtlllallon . Clcclrom)'osrap/lY and Elcclrodlasno51s 450 Powers Avenue .ltarrllburg. Pennlylvanla 17109 '(717) 558.8511 Hay 4, 1993 REI HOLLY HOFFER Dear Dr. Keith Zeligerl Enclosed are the reaulta of the EHO and NeB performed on Holly Hoffer on Hay 4, 1993. Hmi1. Peroneal and tibial nerves bilaterally reveal normal diatal motor latenciea with normal conduction velooitiea. Sural nerves bilaterally reveal normal diatal senaory latencies. Tibial H-reflexes (testa of the 51 reflex arc) are bilaterally symmetrical and within normal limita. ID1llL Root acreening of both lower extremitiea and the correaponding paraspinals of the L4 to 51 myotomes reveala normal insertional activity without fibrillations and positive sharp wave potentials, The voluntary motor units sre of normal morphology with full recruitment pattern. The paraapinala teated reveal no abnormalitiea. IMPRESSION, Easentiallv normal atudv. There ia no evidence of lumbosacral radiculopathy or peripheral neuropathy at this time. There are nc electrophyaiologic abnormalities to the patient' B aymptoms. Thank you for this referral. Sincerely, ~v- Edwin A. Aquino, H,O, EAAlvjb - c(l . w S? u ffi - < fl ~ '" c:t - W .1 Ll- lli ~ N 0 , :t:. I' ',{ cr d. " I J t A J I >0 (J '" 5: 1(1 fl ~ ~ '" lol ~ ~ ... < lol :z: c:> ~ . ... , >0. ~ III l;: 0 .... t; P ~ 8 w ~ :z; '-. . U c:i . P-4 ~ .. a (l) t:: ~ r- '0 b _ ..... :::i . 6 ~ >tj a << In (l) " i:5 ~ ::8 , " ...... ~ ~g ~ r;l ~!C' Q u 511: 5 ..... a ..~ g 11l >, l.lJ ..t:: P-4 Oi:~ .... u I:i...... (f U In po.... ri 1" e..JX ..... _w..... (II I./' 0:> U ~ 5 ..... lol -t J ..9 u :;t c<' ?;2 ~ rf\ rf\ .- ,. Ii; rfI I .... c:> , ~ > ::> )( ..... 0 ~ lol ll. ... ~ ..J ~ ':> ~ ..l ~ ':J. ~ .. ~ :I R 0 :t 0 .... c{l 0 c(1 rl ::l rl ... ~ >< 00 lI' \1' 0 u 0 . . . d " ~ ()O 0" tJ .. "" - .... e ..... tl . ..l r(\ 0 .0 5 ~ d) - r- ~ ~ (1 , . . iO ff1 ('j , . .... . ~ . rt ::l ,{I f6 . rt n . . . , ~ ~ ~ t1 ~ ~ :;;j ~. ~ . 0 0 .... . ~ ctl ei ctl w ~ iil H ::- l>o ... III III tc f:i :z; ~ ~ ~ ~ l: ~ r; E .... .... ~ ::: ~ ..J ..... ~ ..... I . j . . r(l ~ , 0 :>: I>J 1!1 (;l u :J < '" u. ~ € ~ , I g' ~ t;[ J I ~ I ~ '" (;l ~ ~ ~ " :>: l'l , " ' ! I . u ci . " ~ ~ ... , .~ ~ 2fi :: :a 5 e~ ; QJ ~ <.. ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~h 9 .~ Cl 0 ~ ~ Vl ... ... >-,.... - ~ ~ . .J l>- . .J ..: - ::l ~ - U. IJ1 t.! ~ j../- -" 0 0 ~ ~ , - ~ ~ "2 I>- ,. l'l ~ ~ ~ ~ -:.) I ~ p.. ~ " ~ IJ1 ~ l::l ~ ~ , . . < ~ - , . H 4 ., ...... I IJ1 !:;! => j Iii @i 8 .... ..... IJ1 IJ1 H III I III H ~ ,13 .." < H ~ I ...l H ..: ~ u e H ~ d E ~ :!l III ~ ~ o:l IJ1 ..: III III ~ ...l '" ~ 0 8 ~ < III H 0 H ::l ~ '" ei ~ H < H < '" :- ... l>. :>: H ~ I>- 15 III 0 ;:! o:l < '" (l. I . ., " Pl'lyslcal Medicine, P.\... Edwin A. Aqylno, M.D. Ph)'jlcal Medicine and Rehablllla/lon " flcctrony'Osrap/!y and ElrctrodlJSnollj 450 I'owm Avenue "Ilarrilburg. Penn~ylvanla 17109 "(717) 558.8511 April 27, 19'33 REI MOLLY HOFFER Dear Dr. Keith Zeligerl Enclosed are the results of the EMO and Nes performed on Molly Hoffer on April 27, 1'3'33. I!mlL Median nerves bilaterally reveal normal distal motor and sensory latenoies, The motor conducticn velocities are within normal limits. Ulnar nerves bilaterally reveal normal distal mctor and senscry latencies. The motcr conduction velocities are within normal limits. '. Ulnar F~waves are bilaterally within normal limits. IDm.1. Sampling of some of the median and ulnar innervated muscles of both upper extremities reveals normal insertional activity without fibrillations and positi ve sharp waYe potentials. The voluntary motor uni ts are of normal morphology with full recruitment pattern. I"PRESSIONI Essentiallv normal study. There is no evidlPnce of peripheral neuropathy, including entrapment, at this ,'time. ThlPre is no evidence of carpal tunnel syndrome. There is also no evidence of ulnar nerve involvement. Thank you for this referral. I .1 , I ! I ; , I Sincerely, ~~ Edwin A. AqUino, M,D, EAAlvjb Oi:~ 6 H ~ U III ('{I ::>0___ eel::: 1Il \9 .g - -- 0> ~ , u w 0 Ll :: < fl cI. '" w - .J ~ U. Ii ~ III u -- I' ~ !oJ I' t . u r{ & () cr :i ~ rl d I/' VI I . .- ..Ii; ~ It rt .... ~ IT C c ~ P J I>- 0 <t '" ~ fl ~ ~ '" > = I:: ti :> >< ... -- 0 < < ~ ::: l'l '" . l>l lloo ~ - . ~ I>- ~ ... ...l ...l ~ '\J ~ ~ :z: ~ ~ ~ s 0 8 (I ~ g 6 .... - - c - - - - ::> ~ 8 g: >< r- .;IJ lJl p- ~ . . . tl u 0 j (fI -.9 ({1 ., ~ :z: III .... --- Ii -- l>o U ...l 0 ~ - ~ ~ I <f lfJ (6 q cr ~ rl VI . . . . . . . . .... r{l n ci , . r( 11 - ~ V ::> - cl (i . U ci . p.. ~ 0 N ... c:) ,., ClJ '" t1 l:l t; t; I:: ~ I '0 i~ '" '" 0 '" 0 '" 0 '" 0 :3 '" 0 VI 0 VI 0 VI ~ VI ,~ '" f-o i5 ~ i5 f-o i5 i5 ~ ~ .... Ci I !f !f !f . 'tl . < " VI VI VI III ClJ "" <... - ri ri ::E ~~. ~ I I I I I I I I "" !oJ l<< l>. :> ...... ~ - a !t '" :ij ~ ~ '" !oJ I'd ~ !? - Q ::: .... '" '" ~ u RE 5 ~ ~ .... < z f.l :z 5 5 .- e ~ < ,.J 5 l/) = t: :c "" UJ ..t:: ~ ~ ~ !;; !;; !;; ~ P... t f;: u u u .... ..... '" .... '" '" '" o-l '" o-l ~ ~ ~ ~ " . j Iio . J ~ - rr: - ~ ,(l ;:j . u. 0 ~ ;;0 W r;! l,) < <!1 .. ~. a III ~ ~~ ----~ 0 ~. N ~ Iio - ~ . ~ ~ 'f. . . . CJ . - -\ I ct. '1 ~ .." rt . :J 1 A I:: J l>< ~ .. ~ q-. ffi rr: ~ "- , rr: ~ ~ .,. w ~ m ~ :z: l:l rr: , I a I Iio ~ - . III ~ III - t;: ~ . . ": ,. H ~ -t- -" , III III U . ... ... ... ... , Q. III l:l t III l:l ~ P-t ~ ... III ~ ... ~ l:l ~ 0 ~ " . ~ ~ aJ Q III ... III 'B ~ i~ :: ~ t1 ~ tl ... ... ... ~ 5 ~; ... ,.J ::I ..... ~ ~ s ~ ~ Iio aJ ..;: <.. g ~ ~ 'r d 8 rr: ~ ..;: ~~ rr: ~ ! Z li\D ~ ~ ~ r.l ~ at III 5! Q .~ 8 ~~ ~ ~ ... lC t;: III ... < < ~ ~ B ~ ~ t ... Lol '" ,.J ..... - L.- , I SUS~LJEHANNA ORTHOPEDIC l1SS0CIATES, .LTD. ORTHOPEDIC, TR"'Um,TlC, 1/""'10 [, SPIN...t SURGERI'. SI'ORrS MEDICINE 0 D"'NCE ORTHOPEDICS Bernard I. Zellger. 0,0, Robert R. Klneda, 0,0. Kellh L Zellger. 0,0. 450 Power. Avenue, Sulle 101 l1amlburg. Pennlylvanla 17109.5926 Telephone (717) 558-8222 Fa_ (717) 561'2!l55 April 23, 1993 William M, Bird, D.Q, COMMUNITY FAMILY MEDICINE CENTER 895 South Arlington Avenue Harrisburg, PA 17t09 REI Molly Hoffer Dear Dr. Bird I I saw Holly Hoffer today in the office, 4/23/93, at your request. Molly is a 31-year-old female who works for Amp Inc. as a customer service representstive. She presents todsy with symptoms srising out of a motor vehicle accident of 3/20/93. She was the driver of a car that was struck on the driver's side by a tractor trailer. She was wearing a seat belt at the time, and denies any loss of consciousness. She states that in the accident shs was holding very tightly to the steering wheel, alternating the brake with the gss pedal in an attempt to try to get out of the way. However. when unable to do so. she slanuned on the brakes and braced herself for the impact. She waa thrown around somewhat, but did stay within the seat, and the seat belt remained intact. She was unable to get out the driver's sida door because the automatic door locks januned in the locked position, and she therefore had to climb out of the window. She was able to leave the car under her own power and walk away from the scene of the accident without medical assistance. Shortly after this, Harch 22. she began to have severe pain in her lower back with some radiation beginning down her left leg. across the buttock cheek, as if something was stebbing her in the left buttock, down the posterior aspect of the left thigh, behind the left knee, the left calf. and onto the bottom of the left foot. She slso hed similar symptoms, but to e much lesser extent I down the right leg. She says they are worse when she is lying in bed et night, that it is uncomfortable and makes it difficult for her to find a position to sleep in. Coughing or sneezing or valsalva meneuvers do not increase her symptomatology. On physical exam we note good heel-and-toe walking. There is no weakness to the extensor hsllucis, calf muscles, or quadriceps. There are no reflex chenges involving the petellar or Achilles reflexes. but there is a very positive sitting-root sign on the left end positive straight leg reising on the cV SUSQUEHA1~NA ORTHOPEDIC ASSuGIATES, LTD. ORTHOPEDIC. TRI.U~II.TlC. liMO C, SPINI.L SURQE"Y' SPORrs MEDICINE c, D.A.NCE ORTHOPEDICS William H, Bird, D.O. REI Holly Hoffer Page Two April 23. 1993 left for leg pain very dominant at that point ovar the back pain. She hes Dome symptoms in the right leg, but mostly just in the buttock. and definitely not nearly aa severe as the left. There is minimal apasm noted in the lumbar apina to palpation, and significant tendernesa to palpation in the left sacroiliac joint and in the left buttock in the sciatic notch which reproduces the symptoma through her leg. She complained of symptoms beginning in her left arm on April 7. Examination of her upper extremitiea shows tingling into the ring lInd small fingers of ths left hand. She has some minor soreness in her neck which is intermittent, but is not nesrly as symptomatic as the tingling and pain she has into the fingers. She is right hand dominant, She hos a scar in her left palm from a previous carpal tunnel decompression done in 1982 or 1983 by Dr. Scott Harrison, en orthopedic surgeon now retired, but who had been in practice at Harrisburg Hospital. Ha operated on her wrist for apparent csrpal tunnel syndrome. and found sn abnormal muscle in the hand, which does occur on occasion, specifically the palmaris msnus brevis which causes compression. but actuslly when released along with release of the median nerve. usually causes the symptoms to resolve. Her initial carpal tunnel type symptoms did completely bO lIway in her hand and were not bothersome to any degree prior to this accident. She describes holding the steering wheel very tightly during the accident, and may have suotained an extension type injury, or impaction injury, to the wrist as a result of this. She has a positive !inel's and Phalen's at the left wrist on examination, reproducing the symptoms in her fingers end all the way up her arm toward her neck. Compression of the head reproduces some symptoms into the base of the neck, but 1I0t all the wsy down the arm to the fingers. X-rsys of the neck taken today in the office are essentially unremarkable. We do note on x-raya of her lumbar spine that she apparently has six lumbar vertebrae, or essentially a lumbarization of the first sacral vertebra. At this time 1 sm going to place her into a cockup splint for hsr left wrist, have her take the snti-inflammatory medication she has at home including the Tslscen, but stop the muscle relaxant. 1 will obtsin EMG's of her upper and lower extremities to evsluate for carpal tunnel, as well as for an 51 root radiculopathy in the left leg, We will slso obtsin an MRI scan of her lumbar spine. We'll hold her preeent physicel therapy, rechecking her in the office following the studies, snd will determine further care st that time. SUSQUEHA1~A ORI'HOPEDIC ASSUGIATES, LTD. . ORrHOPEDIC. TRAUMATIC. I/AND {j SPINAL SURGERY' SPORTS MEDICINE {j IN\NCE ORrHOPEDlCS William H. 8ird, D.O. REI Holly Hoffer Pelle Thr.. April 23, 1993 I viII keep you informed aa to har prosreaa. and I thonk you vary much for allovinll me to participate in the care of your patient. Binctre1y. "'ib t~~.o. KLZ/jep _._I_U.. _ / 'P '. ASSOCIATED PSYCHO LOG ISTS 200 Sbe11 Street Hl1'riaburr. P A 1710D (717) 6&7.3867 . . Auqust 3, 1993 Ms. Joanne sinqleton Nationwide Insurance 1000 Nationwide Drive Harrisburq, PA. 17110 RE: Allison Hofter DOBr 07/20/86 Claim 1- 5837B62689403209301 Dear Ms. Singleton: Enclosed is our statement for professional services rendered on the behalf of Allison Hoffer. As you are aware, our services were in treatment of a post traumatic stress situation followinq a motor vehicle accident which I believe occurred March 20, 1993. As of our last visit, Allison appeared to be adjustinq well. As is often true in post traumatic stress situations, however there may be a brief period of recurrence of the anxiety pendlnq a particular set of circumstances. Barrinq any severe trauma/ however, we are closing our files on this child with a provislon to reopen if any serious symptoms recur. ~~ ~ -LlJr}o-n&:f- Rosalie B. Keller-Brandt, M.S. Licensed Psychologist RBK-B/pkl CCI Mrs. Mellie Hoffer Hot,;..~ ASSOCIATED PSYCHOLOGISTS 6e7ZB67 P.l!l2 1 ASSOCIATED PSYCHOLOG ISTS 200 Shell Btfeet llatrlDbWltl..P ^ 17109 (717) 657.3bu7 PSYCHOLOGICAL REPORT Confidential information not to be released without proper written consent. 'P Name Sex Birthdate Age Handedness Grade Teacher school Parents Address Telephone Referred by Examiner Date of Evaluation I I I I I I I I I I ALLISON HOFFER Female July 20, 1986 6 years, 11 months Right 1ST MRS. GIPE LINGLESTOWN ELEMENTARY CHARLES R.,JR.& MOLLIE HOFFER 5889 LAUREL STREET ItARRIBURG, PA. 17112 (717)657-1869 DR. WILLIAM BIRD ROSALIE RELLER-BRANDT,H.5, certitied School Psyohologist June 17, 1993 Tests Adainiotered Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - Rev!58d Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement - Comprehensive Rorschach Ink Blot Test projective Drawings Reason for Referral Allison was referred by her family doctor, William Bird, because she is experiencing emotional reactions to several significant stressors. She and her mother and sister were recently in a vehicle accident and her younger sister, Abby, is being treated for cancer. This treatment has included hospitalization and surgery. Because of these stressful events, Allison has had difficulty sleeping and has developed several fears. She is fearful of riding in vehicles on major roads and is feerful of trucks passing by. She has had a few behavioral problems at school and her mother worries that she is underachieving in her academics. Allison is currently enrolled in the first grade class of Mrs. Gipe in the Linglestown Elementary School, Central Dauphin School District. primary source of information for this report was discussion with Allison's mother. Background rnfo~ation Allison lives with her parents, Charles and Molly lIoffer, and her younger sister, Abby, age 4. Allison has attended preschool and kindsrgarten. She was five years old when she started kindergarten at Linglestown Elementary. f1GliUCIHlliU PS"'Cf~DLUGlS1S (,513067 p.e:! 2 )ur'ing infancy, motor mileatones wert! ruaGhed al all advanced rate. Motor :Ievelopment between tho ages of 2 and !i WIIB daRer i hed AS advanced in ::omparison to othor childrell of her age, and early langulllju formation wae also advanced. Her sociul skills were advanced in comparison to her peers and her mantal development wos normal her mother reported. Allison receives regular medical checkups and vision tOlitS. She has just recently been evaluatod and discovered to bo in need of eyeglasses. It is hopeful that the glasses will help her be more successful in the classroom. !{rs. 1I0fter is concerned that she has always shown '\load ability but is not having diffiCUlties. She iu questioning tho offoct of the stress on her performance. Observations Allison is a blonde haired girl with light eyos. She appears to be of average height and weight for her age. She was generally restless and talkative. The examiner had been working with her in consultation and counseling since April of 1993 following the vehic10 accident March 20, 1993, Abby was riding with her mother and sister when they were hit by a truck which crossed the road and pushed their vehiole over 200 yarde. Subsequent to that event, her sohool bus was involved in an accident on April 2nd and, at a later date, the family witnessed a tractor trailer truck losing part of its tire -- smOking and loud sounds were observed -- adding to the trauma. For awhile, Hrs. Hoffer said, they all felt as if they were "cursedll because of the frequency at the traumatio events. Because of the previous counseling seasions, Allison was fairly relaxed about the evaluation session and was looking forward to it. She showed a oooperative and friendly attitude Rapport was easy to establish and maintain. inetructions without apparent difficulty. She adapted readily and easily to new tasks as testing progressed. in completing the evaluation. She recalled and understood lIer motor behavior was marked br fidgeting IInd reatlessness during testing. Attention and concentration 'sk lls appeared to be normal for a child of Allison's ag8. Given the above observations, the results of tho evaluation are believed to reflect a reliable and valid estimate of her current lovel of functioning. Wecbsler Intelligenoe Scale for Children - Revised The Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Rsvised (WISC-R) ils a standard battery of teats that assesses different Aspects of intellectual functioning. The WISC-R consists of two scales, the Verbal Scale and the Performance Scale. Each of these scales has several subtests. WISC-R Co.posite Scales IQ Scale Pore. ConUdence co.posite Soales Soore Rank Interval Classification ----------------- ----- -------- -------------- Vorbal yo (no) 121 96 120-134 superior Performanco 1Q (PIQ) 136 99 128-144 very Superior Full SCale lQ (fBIQ) 136 99 130-142 Very superior ASSOCIATED PSYCHOLOGISTS 6573867 P.ll" 3 In:SC-R sootest Scores Percentile strength or Scaled Difference Subtest Score from Mean Rank Weakness ------- ----- --------- -------- Verbal Sootests Infonation (IN) 15 0.6 95 Siailarltios (51) 15 0.6 95 Arlthaetic (AR) 12 -2.4 75 Vocabulary (vo) 18 3.6 99 strength Co.prehension (CO) 12 -2.4 75 Pcrforaanc8 Sootests Picture Co.pletion (PC) 16 0.8 98 - Picture Arrang_ent (PA) 19 3.8 99 strength Block Design (BD) 14 -1.2 91 - Object Asseably (OA) 14 -1.2 91 COding (CD) 13 -2.2 84 - WISC-R Soale Differences and Subtest Scatter FSIQ VIQ VIQ-PIQ Scatter Scatter Difference Score Score PIQ Scatter Score ---....----- ---..- .......... 9 7 6 6 WISC-R Test Interpretation Allison obtained a WISC-R Full Scale IQ of 136, which places her in the Very superior range of intelligence. While this score is subject to a small degree of error, the probability is 90' out of 100 that her true lQ score is betweon 130 and 142. lIer Verbal IQ and Performance IQ scores did not differ signif1cantly, indicating that her verbal and visual-motor skills are practically equal. Accordingly, her Full Scale IQ score is a valid indicator of her general intellectual ability. A more detailed analysis of her performance on the WISC-R can be obtained by oxamining her performance on individual subtests within the Verbal and Perfornance scales. Subtest scores can be compared to those of other children in the same age group. These comparisons provide an indication of strengths and weaknesses relative to her age peers. In addition, her profile of subtest scores can be examined to determine her personal strengths and weaknesses. 'l'hese comparisons can be especiallY valuable in pointing to remediation strategies which focus on Allison's personal strengths and weaknesses. Allison's score on the Information subtest indicates a strength in long-term recall of factual knowledge or greater exposure to a wide range of experiences and learning. Information questions are factual items that are answered best by children with verbal fluency, good recall of facts, and an enriched background. On this subtest, her performance was substantially better than that of her age peers. The similarities Bubteat score indicates superior skill in verbal concept formation and abstract thinking. Inoluded ara questions such as, "lIow are a sook and a shoe alike? II Answers which rely on concrete, functional, or abstract associations can be given in response. ASSOCIATED PSYCHOLOGISTS 657~B67 P.B5 4 liar score on the Vocabulary flubtcst suggests a supador ability in expressive language and word knowledge. Defining words such liS those in the Vocabulary subtast also demands a wide rango of learning experienoes, good memory, and verblll fluency. On this subtest, Allison'll performance was Ilubstantially better than that of her age peers and was also a personal strength. Allison's score on the Picture Completion subtest suggests a strength in the dittorontiation of essential from nonessential details or good visual alertness and jUdgement. The goal is to find the missing part in pictures. concentration, persistence, and visual skill are necessary to do well. 'l'he Picture ^rrangement subtest score suggests qood planni ng ability and undorstanding at' the sequences nnd patterns ot sochl situations. This Gubtest requircs the child to put pictures which tell a story into a correct order. Knowledge of behavior, understanding temporal eequences, and the ability to comprehend a total situation are helpful skills on this subtest. On this subtest, her performance was substantially better than that of her age peers and was also a personal strength. lIer Block Design subtest score shows a strength synthesis and nonverbal problem solving ability. figure with colored blocks demands an ability relationships and visual.motor skill. Allison's score on the objeot Assembly Ilubtest showa good visual-motor constructive ability and perceptual organization skill. Her higher score on this subtest indicates good coordination, persistence, and the ability to recognize a familiar object trom its parts. in visual analysis and Reproducing a geometrio to work with spatial rhe Coding subtest score points to good speed of eye-hand coordination, good visual short-term memory, or high motivation on this rote learning task. This subtest requires filling in designs on a paper within a specified time limit. Allison's Arithmetic, Digit Span, and COding Bubtests indicate a consistently lower pattern of scores on tasks that require freedom from distraction. This findina sU9gests that tho obtained WISC-R 10 scores may be an underestimat~ gf AU.ISON's ability. due to behavioral interference and poor attention, Scores based on groups of selected Bubtests were also calculated. These scores provide additional hypotheses about factors underlying sceres on the WISC-R. In Allison's caso, examination of these altsrnate subtest scores revealed added findings about her strengths alld weaknesses. 1I0wever, because of the speculative nature of these scores/ any hypothesis bssad on alternate subtest groups should be considered tentative, Performance on tasks involving people or things was superior to thoBe involving abstraot symbols or designs. Host school learning tasks, such as reading and mathematics, are abstract rather than conoreto in nature. KaUf~n Test of Bducational Aohievoaent - Coaprehen81ve The Kaufman Tost of Educational Achievomont~comprehenBive form (KTEA-C) 1s IIn ulltimed, individually administored teat of school achievement which contdns five subteBto: Reading Decoding, Reading Comprehension, Mathematics Applications, Mathematics computation, and Spolling. ASSOCIATED PSYCHOLUGISTS 6573867 P.06 5 The Roading Oecodintj lSubtest mellllures the ability to identify letters and pronounce words. The Reading comprehension subtest examines underBtandlng the meaning of short passages. The Mathematics Applications and Mathematics computation subtests measure knowledge ot ar! thmetic concepts and computational skills, respectively, Tho Spelling subtest requires spelling words Which are read aloud by tho examiner. Scorso on individually administered achievement teats Clln differ from those on group achievement tests, Various factors can Clluse a disparity, such as the fact that individuals maintain more consistent attention and effort in a struotured testing setting or the fact that each test measures distinct ski l1s . XTEA-C Subtest llJld Composite Scores Raw Standard Percentile Subtest Score Score Rank -----..- ----- ----- ""'.-- Mathematics AfPlications 17 118 88 Reading Decod ng 23 118 88 spelling 8 101 53 Reading comprehension 17 128 97 Mathematics computation 13 122 93 Reading Composite 23 100 50 Mathematics Composite 30 122 93 Battery composite 78 120 91 These scores indicate that she is average to above average in all areas,but, in comparison to her own performances and ability indicators, is lOWer in Spelling and in the Reading composite scores. l~jective Personality Testsl The Rorschach Ink Blot 'l'est and several projective drawings were administered earlier, during individual counseling sessions, to assist in assessing the emotional effect of the accident. The Rorschach Ink Blot responses were reflective of Allison's intelligence and visual awareness. All the rosponses were accurate and appropriate in form quality and in content. There were, however, an inordinate amount of references to winged creatures, butterflies and birds. Even in her drawings of House-Tree-Person, she added birds. Frequent references to winged creatures in an indication of a desire to escape or to be free from current oppression and fears. In addition, Allison covered the sun with a cloud, an indication of some depression. Educational Rec~ndations Based on current evaluation results, Allison is eligible for consideration for placement in the program for Gifted students in her school district. Sho is Ilignificahtly above average in many of her Bubtests and shows no evidence of any learning disability. Based on her level of intellectual ability, Allison oan perform substantially above 1lI0st of her age and <Jude mates. This assumes that no learning or behavior problems contribute to difficulty in school. A score at this level shows excellent learning potential. Accelerated instruction, advanced materials, and Lhe opportunity to be challentjed at her high potential and learning speed should be part of an individualized educational plan. ASSOCIATED PSVCHO~OGISTS 6eT3e6T p.eT 6 Compared to her expected learning ability based on the total intelligence test scorea, Allison's reading and spoIling skills were much lower. This indicates an aroa for investigation. One consideration is that she has been in need of eyeglasses. difficulties can interfere with optimal learning. Another consideration is the amount of trauma Allison has experienced recently, not just the accidents and other traftic-related events, but the family stress surrounding the illness of her younger sister. Vision She evidences some restlessness and "hyper"verbal12ation tendenoies. This situation must also be monitored with oonsideration of the stressors she i. experienoinq. SOllie question of possible ADHD is worth keeping in mind it these tendencies increase. This examiner will be available tor consultation upon permission of Allison and her parents. ('~ f/ ", .~Q'. 7J..dA. ~~ ROSALIE B. KELLER-BRANDT, M.S. Certified SChool PSYChOlogist 'Of\M,.a IU'~.I,lt1nLV7 . .. DATE ~:/:::(I/1':I'.-''---t 10._...: MED REO' 800218:3(:... ~ . 13.(11);: 11,:1364 . EMERGENCY DEP;ElNTCORD 3RD ST HOFFER, ABBEY [I . \"\ IBURO, PA. 17.110' . ,SCRIPTl0Ill11IolEnNmAL8 NAME: "'51 DESCRIPTlONlT1IolEnhmALS ORDERsmlolEnNmALS -, jence Kit tube_Y.ul ey_Oralnaga bag Venipuncture ., Brua_hr" _liM :tlon _ABG_L 0' -'f. CBC - Lyles BS _ BUN _ Amylase _ PT PIT HCG _ Creal _ Roullne Throat CultUle _ T&C_PC_WB _ UiA.)C. U/AC&S _ Unmoler _ Wet prep ~r..-.:;;l TO: _ PA&LChest _ Pon Chest _Skull _ C.Splne pon C.Sp,ne KUB G -~- 'lAST AI Y '" FROM: _ DPT D.6eo 1M Exp. Date: _ Hypenet 250u 1M ~ 1=1~~AL I,J'ItJ. 11'.90' IClI"~s/t} - ~~~~~~OOIMLoI' ~ ~TYIoIP (. C..J _ dTO.5oo1M l(PT. nME DR Ii \~ PtiV6ICLAN 8 REPOAT IHIP, IMPAEU,IOO & T'I i.v-L 1- L t IJ ,~.:._ +.... ..-...... ~ I.. J t~~ ~ ~.~ r 1..1 ~.. \ a )ICAL EMERGENCY 0 YON ~ ACCIDENT [J AM"I'LASE_ PHYSIC'AN 6 REPORT CONTINUED 00 B"CK RECHECK lEE PHYlICIAN'S ORDER IHEET FOR ADDITIONAl ORDERS CATH lMS \lOIOEo URINE(!.fL!J..'/4~ .......CT ABO_AMAIA_O, )(.RAY sa I.d/~ BLOOD PH r:. 0 wee pO, GlU . A~r PI!C or S.I ALe CASTS pee. EKG BILE BACT HCO, lEUK EST NITRITES ~ flESUI TS co, aUN OLU ,,, . CL CAUT AtT. Hea PI PIT ~~t~~ . STAB , LYMPIl MONO ,4fi'" EOS 1lJ> A5I r",. IE! NURU'S NDltS e T'RANUER _ DATEITlMEIT;.l_ J-01tJ.u , 'CJ S- ~-.. CONDITION ~SCHAROE [j] o 'R .OS"C 'MPR'SSION .) sIP fI V c.. ~ ~ (. Lu J,.,... c ~-.......... ,AL STUOEtil .. ~. AOMI! EeSIC1AN PRiVATE PHYSICIAN fO\l.OW-U' f IlVf.I""'L NURSE PH t.{)---~"'FiTilN'Ii,U.,ll 4264E:4..LHCiFFEr,. ABlJEY [i AODRUS - 'f :0<':1 LAUREL ST HAriR I SBURIJ IIAtH DAtE .T.~' t.u. t<<)W l'; D WMtA JII060l 06/04/198~~L~ S AMBU OTHER b AC.G OATl1lUt - .- -r' iOfNllOCA 10ft 03/20/93 tOIOO MVA :lNi All ~ii (.OI1thiWr------ ., tOoll ANDP~.L~TARRY .ROBERT 243-1123 \:',""-]'r,,.~ ftllUL , I,ltOICJ.I.J;Tq", . . L _(/-'-lYW1~ ABOVE ..,., I 0(11)-(1(11)1) .....l\JIOl ,u, Ctl>H C'OU""...iN "t\ 1;'\ l.'At' 11"'- ,-j.lr",-I:r:tj !"IIIT U(D IIEe f<<J E:O(l~ 1 :;::;:,~,. lAST Ul ~tQ ARRIVED W'W -~-t'1 5__.,-____ _..__ } -# cY' J . OY _ fi.. 'I CJrLlt.(yd_ [J OIW. ,t ~ // f AJ1:' o RECTAL .//..- ,?", - W 0 ~.L!'W< "" clTl~ R"'Cp p.LI'-U_ R~ M'_ I .. WE,Gur2U mANUS~ .M"'UNLt,A1'1C>NS._ r",l . Aup - C'rV ~.L ~ t.i {('c.JI I,;., I, . !I.t:. <; '- J,. -,{ UEDS IT'''',rl~'f''I,v-J JECTlVE. . () ;:: , r.' 'l5 J N ..>-..- ~ tv, ",,} A-<A'f. ' .~" ,; 'N:i~ ~' -p.~ Uh~ eJ,;{/ . p'cj(,J I;' ~ k 4~L.t.'~S,J.LLE"O'ES 1I/111j? ,,~,.""' ""'"~ .-" - ~/..~. a ~,vJ . . . NON URGENT ~ URGENT oi1UllO~ ""lD~~Oj;,[~rtil SKI~ SY~ETRICAlI UNLABOAED OOlSOllIENIED flflNK ClEAA OCONFUSED ~U SHAllOW ORESPONSE 10 S11MUU E(ooy WORED o CYANOTIC \\liEEZlNG 0 lOR 0 DUSKY RETRACTlOHS OHEADACHE OPAlf RAlfMlHONCH 0 lOR 0 STIFF NECK 0 flUSHED COUGH 0 DIZZINESS 0 HOI EXPECIORATlO o WEAKNESS OCOOl HEUOPTYSIS 0 DIAPHORETC DlliEA ONUMBNESS OJAUNDICE o RASH OBRUISES OOIHER GU uEN,E5 [j hA OFREOUENCY o URGENCY o RmNTlON o DYSURIA OHEUATlJRIA o INCONTINENCE o URETHERAl DISCHARGE OOIHER GYN ODEMES ~ OG_P_G_ OVAGINAl BLEEDiNG o NORMAL FLOW OABNDRMAl FLOW _ o DISCHARGE CULA nON PULSES 1'''1 llPRESENIOABSENT to smONG OWElJ( tJl\EGUlAAO IRREGUlAA EDEMA NO CAPII.l.IoRY REFIll _ OGLASCOW COMA SCAlE EIlDTlONAl fl,'rCOOPERATlVE OUNCOOPERATlI't o ANXIOUS OCOIoIBATlVE o HYSltRICAl OIlABY OOIHER G1~IESONA o DYSPHAGIA OANNOREXIA o NAUSEA OVOMlnNG ODIARRHEA o CONSTIPATION OHEMAIEMESIS o ABDOMEN o SOFT OFIRM ODISTENDED OlENDER __ OOIHER UNI ~NIES DNA VISUAL ACUITY OU 00 OS OBlURRED VIS'ON o FHDTOPHOBIA o SORE IHROA I ONASAl CONGESTlOIj OEARACHE DR Ol OEPISTAlIIS DR Ol ' - OOIHER IUUA ~DENIES DNA ~~ 9fl~~; DNA NOllilNG VlSIBLf ABRASIONS lACERA liON SEVERITY (nooo . """1 123 I 5 118 i 10 BLEEDING OCONSIANI BURNS o INTERMlnEflI OBVIOUS DEFORMITY o RADIATING SWEWNG o SHARP OlliER. o DUll OIIEAVY o BURNIIIG o BOWEL SOUNDS OIHER: IAGE NURSE SIGNAIURE: SESSMENT COMPlffiO BY f'~' ...,.., . . liMO 0 APPROVED 0 NOT APPROVED '. . .' P'iH' __.._ TRIAGE Ol5POsmON TRIAGE INTERVENTION o 6PUNTS 0 ICE o STERILE DRESSING DOTHER PRE.HOSPITAL CARE VITAL SIGNS LOSS OF CONSCIOUSNESS!1No 0 YES AIRWAY ONASAL OORAL OET TUBE OXYGEN o MASK 0 NASAL UMIN MAST OAPPLIED OINFLATED SOLUTION SITE GAUGE IV TIlERAPY SPLINT ;;ec COLLAR J2tACKBOARD OOTHER DYES ONO TIME BEGUN CPR MEDICATIONS ADMINISIEREO IN ROUTE ~ , . DAlE .);:?O13 TlME/O Y2 POLYCLINIC MEDICAL CENTER DIVISION OF PATIENT CARE SERVICES EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT ADMISSION DATA BASE '. . . . . . , , PAGE I: ....f2,. OF: INTAKE A WTlME ORAL rI OUTPUT URINE EMESIS .?..M'Y~ DA TE/11ME OTHER )/2 (/2 i/J 1,1 '7 10(( InfiFI noV )~"--.;'" .j.JoO OP P R ,~-- ~ NURSES PROGRESS NOTES Z2;> - -/-J.rCJ, An 'J,. <: k)A7"/L;'/'" ~ '- '" ~A-7vJ~d -W- ~ / ~ .....,J 700 . Ij J~. 72k,/J.-Ib - _ 1/).2 20 'J. kr AI! F. ,/..7 ' ~' -;- 1. -M~) ~ 'bI-@', Lf -a (/((1'-"/ 1 L)" r. 7l..f. ../r, '/'7. J , _./1 - ?' ,{l.C cV -- ~'/ I .-:r/.~ .-.I r ~ 'v.l tLJ J l: ~J~ dr /,,, J,..J,.-Ud."tJ ~...//.h' #.J.J.-L,.J ~...~~..,.... -;Y .I '...7... u7 J.~... Ar- IA.2" /.. 'J .':"".n. =-- /'J:5"~ ~,,1i!.. . > L'>". .i.~ ...,T7fi:,~-, L. . "::r'?'=, ~IIL. LUJ.r~ ' ~ v lATElTIME PUPILS R/L NEURO CHECKS RA LA RL. LL OTHER INT ... ,. . , :, Ie-"l )AWTlME CONSULTS NOTIFIED PHVSICIAN/SERVICE TIME SEEN INT DA TE/TIME DRUG MEDICATIONS AMOUNT ROUTE SITE INT I, . L ~ DISPOSITION iE1iSCHARGED TO ~ Dm,t...;,p.@ TlMelf~ DISCHARGED IN THE CARE OF D SELF D SPOUSE ~ENT 0 GUARDIAN o OTHER INSTRUCTIONSjPVEN ~ DNO (REASON) IV SOLUTIONS MODE ~ULATORV DWHEELCHAIR DAMBULANCE DCAnRIED DOTHER DATE/1IME ~OLUME CATH SITE SOLUTION RATE INT D ADMlnED TO MEDICAL CENTER ADMISSIONS CALLED: ' BED ASSIGNMENT: BED READV REPORT CALLED ACLS PROTOCOL: DVES oNO TO UNIT: ,MODE DAMBULATORV DWliEELCHAIR [ IS~~.pCHER DonlER . J . Hb4 n , DISCHARGE IWRSES SIGNATURE -J,f 1ft. t'-W ~IC-2~-eeL4 717-~'j7-'8f19' pbLVCLlNIC MEDICAL CENTER . lBBEl 01 ~cr FE R 5~J~ llUREl ST Itlfl~' S6URG U/~C;IH 51 CeCTOR UHlKOWH '. I f Pl 17\12 Ob/04/8Q r ~ ) DIVISION OF PATIENT CARE SERVICES EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT NURSING PROGRESS NOTES . .' ... . . . . 'ED N~:J/.{J,g~pI. ':' INSTRU"lI~S..1'b.THE PATIENT ~. . .. (FII . . The examlnalion' and Ireatmenl you have received in Ihe amergency department have been rendered on an emergency basis only, and are noi Intended 10 be a subslitute lor, or an elforl to provide complete medical care. IF YOU DEVELOP NEW PROBLEMS OR COMPLICATIONS, CONTACT'Y.QUR PHYSICIAN OR THIS EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT. FOLLOW THE INSTRUCrtoNS BELOW AS INDICATED FOR YOU . . 7. {MEmC'A'L INSTRUCTIONS 1. Bed rest lor 2. Take aspirin or Iylenol every hours. 3. Clear liquid dlel ' advance as tolerated. " LACERATIONS, ABRASIONS OR BURNS 1. Keep wound clean and dry 24-48 hours. 2. Alter 24.40 hours wash wllh soap and waler or peroxide. 3. Walch lor signs 01 swelling, redness, tenderness, heat or drainage. ", 4. Tetanus ToxoldfTetanus diphtheria given _ (yes). 4. Drink plenly 01 liquids. 6. supplementallnstruclion sheet. OTHER: (L,l (~ 'u<>; ~ ~ 0\. ..-... h..JI '..I tt ~ dJ EMPLOYMENT/SCHOOL 1. Return to normal dUly on 2. Limited duty unlil 3. Llmltalion 4. r~rn to S~~OI on LABORATORY INSTRUCTION: Call the Emergency De'part- ment on for results of your pending lab lests. 782,4132 FOLLOW,U? CAR~.'--.'~ ), Relurn to Emergency Department Immediately if une.~-Io"'y worse or nollmproved. 2. Emergency Department on ,;3. Family Physician ,_ ' .y See Dr. f ~ ~... : on al AM/PM 6. Clinic, call for appointment within hours/days 6. Occupalional Medicine. call 782.4239 aftar 9:00 AM for eppolnlment. X.RA Y INSTRUCTIONS: Your x.rays have been reed by the Emergency Physician. For your edded proteclion, your x,reys will be reread by our Radiology Department. If any abnormalllies are found that have nol been called to your atlentlon, you and your doctor will be called Immediately. Somelimes fraclUres or abnormalilies may not show up on x.reys lor severel days. II symptoms persist or get worse, call your Physician or return to this Emergency Department. More x.rays may have to be taken. ... @ ~~ EMEROENCY OEPARTMENT 2601 NORTH 3RO STREE1' HARRISSURG, PENNSYLVANIA Phone 717.782-4132 - 83550 LABEL ALL PRESCRIPTIONS \ ,~. DAT~: V () I 0, ~~}~.( .,<\ "l.. 'lj::,:...... ,; J ____ ::.. - "., ,I.' 1 r ~ ,.., . \. .' ~;,.~ T..: '~.\ ..F~. ". . tr,' ,I..r'. ,'-;\ ' ~. ", ., t_..:. 1,1 SUBSTITUTION PERMISSIBLE'~:";~:"\ "...".10. ...... ,M,D.O. IN criDER FOR A SRAND NAME PRODUC. TTO. DE OISPENSED. THE PRESCR:SER MUST IlANDWR:JTE "SRAND NECESSARY" OR "BRAND MEDICALLY IjECESSARY" IN TIlE SPACE BELOW PAT1ENT'I~F9RMATIO~(\.;i .' '\....,.. ~..\ .........:;..-.. . ETR E "32426484 eCQ-Z 1-8864 ''\t:,''717-b57-IB69 OFFER. ...... ,ABOEY 0 "ell LAUREL Sf " IIQRISBURG PA 17112 ~/ZD/93 3Y 06/04/89 F OCTOR UtlKNOWH , , J I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF THESE INSTRUCTIONS THAT I HAVE HAD EMERGENCY TREATMENT ONLY AND THAT I MAY BE RELEASED BEFORE ALL OF MY MEDICAL PROBLEMS ARE KNOWN OR TREATED. I WILL ARRANGE FOR FOLLOW.UP CARE AS I HAVE BEEN INSTRUCTED. X' Signature 01 P person OATE~-PO-~? X Plwr;iriiln . ~y REFILL '. \ TIMES PA lie. , DEA No ..' \.... .'. . , I , ". " . (' . , . . . . . CONSENT Tb MEDICAL TREATMENT . I consenllo Ihe rendering 01 medical care, which may Include routlna diagnostic pro(;edures and such medlcaltreetment as my attending or consulting physician considers 10 be necessary. I also understand It Is customary, absent emergency or extraordinary circumstances, that no substantial procedures will be performed upon me unless or until I have had on opportunity to discuss them with 0 physician or other health core professional to my satisfaction. If I om 0 compatenl adult, I hove the right to consent or refuse to consant to any proposed procedure or therapeutic treatment. I will not be Involved In any research or experimental procedure without my full knowledge and consent. I understand thai the practice of medicine and surgery Is not on exec. science and that diagnosis and treatment may Involve risks of InJUry or even death and acknowledge that no guarantee has been made 10 me as to the results of any examination or treatment In this Hospital. I understand many 01 the physicians on the stall of this Hospital are nol employees or agents of the Hospital, bul rather are Independent contractors who have been granted the privilege of using these Iscllltles for the care and Irealment of their patients. Further, I realize this Hospital Is a teaching Hospital and at this Hospital ere health care personnel In training who, unless exprassly requested otherwise, may participate or may be present during my care as part of their education. Stili or motion pictures and c1osed,clrcult television monitoring of patient care mey also be used for educational purposes, unless I expressly requesl otherwise. ~ -? Relationship '// Dale ~';,;:o zj Slgn8:t,ure To Patlenl~"1' '-'--. RELEASE OF MEDICAL RECORD INFORMATION I authorize Polyclinic Medical Center to release to requastlng health Insurance carrler(s), their representatives and auditors, such diagnostic and therapeutic Information (Including any Information relallng to treatment for elcohol and subslance abuse and/or treatment 01 psychiatric disorders, and/or confidential HIV related Information), as may be necessary for them to determine benefit entitlement; and to process payment claims lor health care services provided during this hospitalization/ treatmenl episode. This authorization shall be valid for the period 01 time necessary to process payment claims pertaining to the patient. A photostatic or carbon copy of this authorization shall be considered as ellectlve and valid as tha original. The undersigned also authorizes Medicare, when applicable, 10 releasa to another Insurance carrier, upon their raquest, medical inlormation needed to make payment upon that claim. I understand and consent Ihatlhe manulacturer of any Implantable device Inserted by my physician during the course 01 my surgery/procedure may be pro 'ped with my Identification Inf rm tlon as mandated by Federal Law. ~ ,.5 \ RelatlonShl~/: Date.!'.;o 7J Signature ../' To Patient ~. INSURANCE ASSIGNMENT I authorize payment directly to POLYCLINIC MEDICAL CENTER and for physicians of all benelils payable under my Insurance policies. I understand I am responsible to the Hospital for all charges nol covered by this assignment and/or photocopy of this assignment.. ^ C, \~ 1\ n. 'T\ J Lt n . Relationship' Dale J .- ~ -7' i Signature cJ J r \ jY\A~ To Patient ~4 FORM WITNESSED BY ~ ... Date';;;,;o -rJ Signature ~~ , I .. [Tr. [ ]2426484 ~tC-2 l-eell4 717-B"57-0IB69"1~.' ttCFFrR . AB [Y . . ~e6'J lAURrL ST IlARRISBURG PA 17112 C3/Z0/91 l' 06/04/B9 r QCCTOR UWKNowK .. f'el,onl Idenl,l,eatlon ., \, .. ' ."1 POLYCLINIC MEDICAL CENTER HARRISBURG, PENNSYLVANIA 17110 PATIENT CONSENT FORM .) ,:,~ ....!;~.J :17 . . . '. [ R 3/1. I'.'AGE: 1 POLVCLI~IC MEDICAL CENTER . FRANI( R. r,UDV, M.D., 01RECTUR Or- LA[lORATORIES HARRISBURG, PA 17110 HOSP NO: BOOllS864 NAME: HOFFER,ABBEV D PHVS I DOCTOR UNI(NOWN , LiJC: ETR ACC NO: 3Z4Z6484 BO/AGEI 060489 3V PHVS Z:SHAW, LEWIS ::,1')(1 F C I II .. " ....' ."1 MMKKUMMMMKKKMMKMKMMKKUUU 13TIIT/rlOUTINE cec W11<10 ItlTEr<Ff\ETIVE DIfF. .KM.MMMKMMKMMKM.MM~MMMMKMMKK., . WIle RBe: ItoB HeT F'L T MF'V 1'<01<1 MCV MCH, " . .'.\ . .. '... .... ,._ .., . I" --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------. .---------.. . I( 1'1 (l/[tL X K IIlL 5.5-16.6 3.70-4.90 11.0-14.0 31.0-44.0 1fjO-460 FL X FL PG 6.5-11.0 1~.2-15.0 70.0-86.0 22.0-31.0 /93 245 ~.mt 3.J:!* G.6. CM27 (A) ~!4. ?If 463K 7.4 15.4K 74.8 25.1~ ." ..- ,..... '..1 .....---....- D/[lL X 28.0-36.0 20.5-151.1 ------- ------------------------..----------------------------------------------------- ---------.. x X 1.7-12.0 42.2-75.2 x X 0.0-10.0 0.0-5.0 IIlTEr<PRETIVE 011'1' ...U....==...."""....""L~"..=..U..==.. BASO X ABS ABS AB3 L VMI'Il MONO GRAIl KKK 1.2-3.4 0.11-0.69 1.4..6.t1 ="==,,,,==,,======,,..==......====.. 5T M Il'\OUTIllE CE;C 101/1010 MCHC L VMPHX MONOl: GRAN?: EOS l: ?, , " 24'5 ~41,6 24.4 m:o 21.2* 153.4 0.7 0.3 0.9M O.S. 2.1 ,- ..====="..=====,,=u....=nn="". !lTAT IROUTINE CBC W/WO INTEriPRETIVE 011'1' .........=.....n........."...,..".===..,. f\~;G ACS !:oo BASO K K I 0.0-0.7 0.0-0.2 -_.~-'..-- ---.---------------------------.------------- ----------------...-----..----------- ._------ --- /93 241j 0.0 0.0 . ... IK .HHU...U.M.....K*U.......HMU. MAllUAL IJIfF .MK.KKM.~....*"..*II***...Kll....J l: u 'HH~"* ,:: SED BAN[I L VMI:H MONO EOS E:A5n META MVELO mo BLAST NRf:C GMUDGE PLASMA ' o. r. x x x x " x " :< x 1100 1100 X --------------------------------------------------------------~----------------------------------- <{ RESULTS CONTlNIlED ON NEXT PAGE :.> '- . , 'OTNOTES--- fLOOri Oil F'liVGICIAfl NUTIFIfD. INTEI\pr;ETIV[ [111'1' TO EiE CUUrtR~I[[1 BY WINUAL r!lFF CIUDV \l 1335 (:1 ll-JT I NUED , . .~ ~J'-' .~ -..'I f~.:J : 17 . . . '. . i"IIGEI '" ,- POLYCLINIC MEDICAL CENTER . . FRANK R. RUDV, M.D., D1RECTOR OF LABORATORIES HARRISBURG, PA 17110 --. '.. . Ace NOI ~Z4Z64e4 BDI AGE I 060489. '3V ~;I:H: F 'PHVS.ZISHAllh.LEWIS (:'((1 . . ,. HOSP N~: 800Z18864 NAME: HOFFER,ABBEY D PHYS: DOCTI)R UNI<NOWN'. " ". LOC': EfR .' ..UU....HU.........MK.......UUMUUU. MANUAL liIFF ......ii....il**imi..it.II....tillti....tI.KiIKU..Uh.. .~. sm BANO L VMPH MONO EllS ;.: X X X X rWlII META MVI:':LO PRO BLAST NR[lC SMUDGE XX ,X.. i: '.' X . ./100.. /100 PI-ASMA r. .' \ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ,--------- <.: CONTINUED 'FROM PREVIOUS rAGE >:> 193 :45 40 16. no. 6 o o ~ ..uu....nU*...UHOO.UIIUUM.. R[:e AN[I wee Mor~FHOLOGV UU*U**K***KU"K**tI.lIt1M~UK.~.~'"'' ~~!!E. PC!Y. peL\' ~!C~Q . HY~ ~C..\NT!~ . . . ..... ........--..,.... ....., --------------------------------------------------.----------------------------_.. .. ------- --- t93 24'5 2" 1+ 1+ 2+ ~.t RARE ..UU.U*...**IIO..U..O.**.***U URINALVSIS -- MAcr,OSCOPIe ..**HK..OU.O.II.U..*..:lM....UKH. COLOR SP SR PH DLUCOSE REOUCING BILE KETONE BLOOD ALfiUMIII SUGAR NCO 1.003- 6.0"0.5 1.030 NED NE:D NEO NED NED -------------------------------------------------.----------------------------------- ---------- 193 ....".. ~ ~..l CLh'\R LVEL 1.01~ 5.0 NEGATIVE: NEGMIVE NE3ATIVE NEGATIVE: NEGATIVE NEDATIvr: ====,,~~==.,========:======c==..,,="'=='" Uf\IllAL'ISIG -.- NACRoseOPIC =c=cc=ccc:=c========:,=,,=,. URO- I.EUKOCVTE NITRITE E:I1. INOGEll "S./ERIISE NORM NEG NE:O :;:=::'r.:::l1=:~':;T . --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------. .:.: RESULTS CONTINUE(! ON NEXT !'flGE > > '.... ... ... " . . ,,' t. .,', OTNOTES--- . LIOIH VEL LOW , C(INTINUED " , ': no" Nor DISCARD. THtS"IS.' "'. Pt:RMANEN'U'1 RECORD' " ., . ' '.1 ;:J5/9:3 . ': 17 . FRANI( R. HOSP NO: 8002181364 NAME: HOFFER,ABBEY D .fHYS I DIJCTI)R UNI(NOWN . . . . [-'AGEl 3 POLYCLINIC MEDICAL CENTER . RUDY, M. n., 0 I REC TOR OF L/\OCIRA TOR I ES HARRISBURG, PA 17110 LOC I ETR Ace.NOI 3Z426464 BD/AGEI 0604139 3V GEHI F PHYS ZISHAW, LEWIS C III . .. ""1 . .' ... ~ ===================_=c=::======a==== lJr~INAL vals -- MACROSCOPIC cl:n::a:=======acuc==ccac=====!1======::===" . .,.... " . URO-.. LEUKOCVTE NITr<lTE . . . . ' ." - ..'...:, E:I1..INOnEN ESTERASE ' , . . 0' ~ .... ,~"." ........ ~.~.1 NORM NEn NEn 11 -------------------------------------------:..--.:--..------------~~:-----.--'-~~ .:.! MMM~:.M*.Ui(MMU~MMMMK*"MUMM*MUU"*MM.MM !llOnO CUI_ Tur,ES MMMM..KU'(......M....*..MUMMMM..UM..MU. 03120/93 E:lOOD CUI. TURE (F'EOIA 12'15 ACC. NO.: S72197 SPECIMEN DESCRIPTION: SPECIAL REQUESTS: ....... UM.....HUMM....."Mun.. K. ..nM M urdNE CULTURE MMM **"MMMll"*""*.... ******MMMMU~ ~KMMM**"** 03/20/93 URINE CULTURE 1335 ACC. NO.: V5?33 SPECIMEN DESCRIPTION: SPECIAL REOUEGTSI '()/'I~ 1~J!5 .....- '-..- NURMAl NEGATIVE CLJlTLJIlE: 03/:0/93 BLOOU CULTURE (PEDIA 1245 ACC. NO.: 572221 SF'ECIMEN DEscraPTIOlI: SPECIAL REQUESTS I CUl TUI\E I << CONTINUED FROM PREVIOUS PAGE >> '- . - ,.~ .. ...-... ' ..~...... . .... . ..... . ;; ....,'..;. . ,,,. ;..f.'~:~ :.':;:~. ~:i NEGATIVE TRANspor,T WIE: BLOOD NONE 0.'1 FINAL 03/26/93 1. NO G1lmlTH F.i OM'S mI\NSF'ORT TIMEI 0.4 ElL.OOD NOliE FINAL 03/26/93 1. NO orlOIHH 5 DAYS TRANEF'ORT TIMEI 0.3 WA5HErl MIDSTREAM NONE FINAL 03/22193 ....... '.1- , . GrlAM SMEAR I 1. RARE POL YG ., << CONTINlIED ON UEXT PAGE }) '. ., .,. . .', ~( . . . . ~ .. , CONTINUED . I Zt5 il'~J 117 . . . . . I"AGE: 4 POLYCLINIC MEDICAL CENTER FRANf( R. RUDY, M.D., D'IRECTOR OF LABORATORIES HARRISEURG, PA 17110 , ., ,,,.. . , Hasp NOI 800218864 NAMEI HOFFER,AEBEY 0 p,HVS I DOCTOR UNI(Nl1WN .. LOCI ETR ACC NOI 32426484. ED/AGEI 060489 3Y ~IXI F PHYS ZISHAW, LEWIS 'c'.! 1 I. ,.. UWH~MUMUMUWUM**UMUUUUUM URINE CULTURE (CONTINUED) 'U*Kk*"UMUMM"MUUMMM*K~MM*UMMIIU . <{ Ace. NOI V5933 - CONTINUED FROM PI(EVIOU9 PAGE >> .., t,.. ..._ .' . I .. . 2. NG ORGANISMS SEEN COLONY COUllT I <1 ,000 CFUIML CULTURE: 1. NO GROWTH .' " ....... '" '....nIi..--....... .. .'. .,,' .1 l , '.; " ,." .1; " .......... , , .' . ,.t. ., u_o. .' -t.--...:'.,... " END O~' REPORT "',.U.'""<......"'... II'" _"".11< @ . . . flU [I. .i i;. ~I :. Ir I thi, l~n~)ltil: ..;;;.,\, i, AuHol~ (lIIIUm, ~dijH (. Illt,t.d, 1l::H. una~d ; U~I~ I, ,".. lIidi; !!lOImOl, .""Il,mmi HIm I/lfill :/II/Ii 1I1111.W:l: !oll, Olin. ,nd (hlll.1 ;. .off'f nlf hUlblnd 104 !llilOn IlH., ~olllf th.I, Ilno, chi 14:tn luto InJu,,'I!n v.lth II: v ItlnlJ'Ht (OII,Ollllor. of II"il', Int. ;n4 i,orl' ~,nrl H.rtldon Iuto IttWnt '1. Ilr~ ~lnl'I, Ilquir., ..,lh'I Oil! Of(!(O I/Ii/11 IIlII!i Wll!lf!1 . I H~: I ;:1\. W[ ; /11/11 1J![ Il.ll,\: H11fIIW ...____...................................................[ ~ F [ ~ ., [ i.......................................................... \/il/Il III; ~(I I.dilll r,,0141 IIcor41 PH\\ICII ![Oltllr II/It/II III; ~CI 1110141 fhllilll lhl'lrl ,.co141 Il,~uff Ilnnlnitol HIHolt ii/It/II 1112 ~(I 1141cII r'lordl (,IIU!III I(![III II/II/II "II m !,41ul 11/0141 billl ~IlIIIIUII m\lH!lIII\H( :1/11/11 III1 ~(I l,dlcll 'Icordl l.co,41 IUliUIHI!!1 OIIHO/[OI( II/II/II "12 m l,dlcll 6111 bllll COI!UNIH mllll '(IIlIIil I/II/It III1 ~(A 1,41cII IltO,41 thlrl (OI!U!111 6111111 :/11/14 III1 ~i! 1,41tll "to,dl IUIOUI~A!il OIIHO/IOIC 2//1111 III1 ~(A Ildltll 'Ilordl 10/1 of 1.41cll bllll COIIUltl1 'INllll Hul/11 Al l/II/lt III: ~Cl "'41111 "loldl chill IICHl!I(IIUli llHl1 1\1111 1/1;/;1 Ill: ~(! IIdilll rmldl COli 01 "dIClI bill HIlRIIIUII lilllhl\l! 1110, e/II/14 III: ~(! l,dll,l I'CO'dl COIII!II\ 6111111 1/1'/14 11I1 ~(1 Photmplll '////11 /11/ ~CI COI/ut" I,",'ch 1/1' 1/11/11 11/1 ~(A (Ol/ut" 1'1'I,ch 1/14 1/10/14 /111 ~Cl 1IIInl f"1 flOIHOIIIll1 01 CUIIIIIINO 'tlllllli :/II/!4 Illl ~(I I"vltl IHIIIII 01 CUI/IIIA!D CII 'CIII7111 '/HIII IIIi ~ll 'Idllll hp:tll/U f I 1/1'1'1 111/ Wel Ilrvlll IHlfll1 01 (UI/IIIII, (1\ '(1/11141 1/11/11 Illl 'CI Pholocorlll 1/1'/14 1111 if '/16/11 1m (F 1/11/11 nil (f '/Iiill 1111 (f fhotocord,\ Holoto/llI fholOll/ill PhOIOIOpl1l 11/11/'1 1111 IC! 11/11/!1 /111 1(1 11/lt/14 /111 6C! !.dlcll ,Icordl COIIUNIII IINIIII Ildltll 'Itordl IUIOUtHIMMI OIIHO/IOtC 1110 1lIII'Iflllno dlnntr II/II to prlplrl for tonftrtntl with clllnll It 1/.1. 1IIIIt ( 1(1111110 JI mUllH 1t.1I 11.11 I '/11 1.11 :1.11 1.11 11,11 11,11 · 11/\1 1\.11 1\.11 ' II/II 11,11 11.11 1,11 '11111 lIt ItIIO! 1111111 1\1 ..,....,.... 111\111 III ....,..,.... 111111I III .........,.. IIUI1l III ............ 1I!!1ll III ............ 111811I HI ............ 1111141 III ..,....,.... Iltllll III ........,... Willi III ............ lI.a' :/14 11.11 1171111111 ............ 1.11 111!11I III ............ :\.11 ' 11.11 11.11 .41 1/.11 II.U ' 1\.11 II.U 1\.11 111.11 ' II. II U," 11.11 ' .21 .41 .41 ,41 1.41 ' 11,\1 11.11 1f,l1 1/11 II8IH1 III ............ 1181111 214............ 11I1111 Iii ............ 111111I11I ,..,........ I/H II III fl I:! ............ 1II1ll14ll ............ 11198\1111 ............ 1/94 1191461 l\l ......'..... 1II1!IIIl4............ 1/14 111111111I ............ W!III lI4 ............ 111141111I ............ 1111111111 ,........... 1/\\ ItlIlIIlIl ............ 1111I11111 ......,..... 11I111\111............ flllfli Ulllilll. I,thllld 11\11[, IlChICIt i (,HII i I.l.f, 11\1\\,11111; 1111, Olin, Ind :hlll" I, "1,,, lit \ Ilmrnrllorrl'll!ln d ittrlfl, Int. fll[ Z Ill!: om :/Il/H lllE 11.11.11 IIml flH ~.........................................................r ~ f f ~ \ ( ~.......................................................... II/II/II I111 0(1 0"(\10' rhllllOrll' tllor lorll\ "0111110111 oUrllll!111 'm !I mmM I: ,II 11/12/11 1111 6(1 11/1\/11 1111 6(1 11/11/94 1111 iCl 11/11/94 llll (J II/If/II 11/1 (/ "01111 "tl,dl tlr, 01 t'Oill1 "11'01 Ino bllllo\ NflllHHUIM Il6l11 mlml 'C1111141 I,dllll "tl'O' MOSIIll1 (OllfIIOIOII[1 '11"1111111 In,"lliltlln tMOIII I III[MISI! /hltml!" Fhllmrlll 1\.11 ' lI/1l 1(,11 II/II/II Illl 6(1 II/IS/I. 1111 1(1 II/II/II 1111 (I II/ZI/I. 1111 6(1 Freold! drldng '111'0 II I V ; fl' Fhltltlrl'l \1 COI11\-O'llt [Olrlllnl II'tllllnlou' flrll' of III lill' (011UI1II 1111111 1110( 'CII\f.HI 11.1\ 111.11 2.11 .:1 111.11 . 11/1I a.1f l.1t I t.1I 11.11 I/II/!! UIl (f 1/l1/!! Illl CI 111.11' 12/11 1\./1 3.11 11.11' 1/1\ l.1t l.It' NlI 11.11 11.11 61. II FhotOlori'. 11 C.flll Fhotlllrll' II C.'IEI 1/11/11 1111 6(1 fl. l/Il/S\ 1111 HI fldll,1 ftPIH/U r ~ 3/11/9\ 1111 (F IholOlofll' II (.FIIS 1/11/\1 1111 tCI lllllgl l'E.~lrrl'burl 1:\ Ilil' 111~1[li ! \ 1115 . (III! ill ;/11/11 1111 i(1 IIlll'IIIt!ng Ilf'MI"I'buII lunth 111~IIIN . \ SIlO 'CII II stE ;/11/\1 illl ill Illv,l !IE-'Ir,llb"'g toll, IAtMlfEN . I 1110 '(111111' " ]I 1.11 \I!.'" 1/11 \1,11 \,11 \.11 ~ I. ~, 11\.11 \2.11 1/11/\1 1111 ;11 111111' 191 11111 6f.llf ( lelAlllN. JF l/II/II 1111 ill 1,lvII 11111 lEOIIE [ 1(1111110 JI 1/11/111111 6CI 1I,IIni 6f.16f [ ICIIIIIll JI '/11/1\ 1111 ill 1'll..I"tlnl I"nth ulth 1II,nll If 0111 C ICIIIIIID II 1/11/\1 1111 6(1 f'rl\illon tllnllrlrt ,UlMEI llPl16,I 15111 'I~ '!r~.\ll '/21/91 1111 ICI tlllrhon' 1111, 1/11 phonl rllll II' o'rllltlln 110161 I WllllHlI HUll II( IlIIOI IlIlm t:' """".", 1II111l III "".""" 1111111 !It ,,,,,,,,,.,, 12114Il 12l ,,,,,,,,,,,. 11IIlU ZII "'",,''''' mlll\ 111 """""" millE lEI,,,,,,.,,,,. 1:1II1l :11 "".""." mWI:le ."".".". Imllll1t """.".,, I1IUIl :14 ".""",,, 1111111 a4 ""."."" 1111\1\ at ",,,.,,,,,, IZIIIIl Iii "".""", 11I1111 :11 ""..""" l1\1m 1\1 "".".",, 1111411 III ""."..". IIIlllll11 ""."..,,, 1111411 ill ",,,...,,,, 1111111 71t "",,""" 1111111 ill ""......" 1111111111 """""" 1111111\11 """".", 11 I I III III """""" 1/11/1\ 1111 (f Ihotororll' 211 (O/![\ OIF.\lll"l\ 1/11/1\ llll il FhotltOrll' III (01111 fllOSltlON m,l\' 4/t\ 11.11 121\111 :Ie "...",,,,, :l.!1 1111141 :14 ",,,...,,,, II.'" 1/1& ............ IG III [l HI HI 1111.11 . , . illl!l: .i Iii" i. Archbold Il\\H, IliHfOIO , m!! N I.I,f, 'III 1 III II UIl l/ll/II 1I\1',!, III il; HI \ lm'ro" CHrO/ollon 01 hlllll, In.. 111I 14.11, I! 'rll, ('1101 Hd (hllllll. ,of"r IlIm III! ...,.."..."."".......,..".,..................,...'.'111111 IISTIUCT1III....,............."...,.............,.,...".....'".. illl PlUIII v llllmll uvom 'm! mill!!' lKIU co ctl/ f , 1>1I'0111101 Oll[ IUlll . mE HlClJlmN mUll fIe vIII ~/'/o mUll I K ~/I""' 110m IlVI 11111 , fll I,ll ill 1/11/11 " '''''' EO ,..... ,,,,,. " rhotm,III 161.:1 :14 I/Il/I\ " """ 10 ,...,. """ " r,d.,,1 II,r'II/U , I 11.41 m l/II/\!. " ".... ((, Ill'" "".. " io_,ut" l'l'lrth 11.17 III l//I/ll " ...... f 0 " 111111 ,..". " N I It ,ll1nto"1 1\.11 411 Il/ll/IC " """ [0 '1'1" ,...., " iuvlCf 111.\1 III 1/1I/11 " ",," [0 " IHIII ,,"" " tnmtllltlon 111.11 m 1\/\1/14 " ,,,'" [0 I..... "III' " l,dlc 11 1111 1\.\1 lilli/II/II " ...... (D " Ill'" 110'" " Outlld, fhotoco,I', II,U 11I11/11/14 " ",... [ ~ " HIIII '"'H " l,dlclllHO/dl m.lL \11 II/I\/ll .. ...... [0 " 'I.t.' .,.", .. O"llltloo tClnlc/l,t 111,11 \\1 1/11/11 ,. "".. [0 " "I.., .1'.,. " ;mrdl 11.11 III \i/II/14 " ,,,.., [ ~ " "11" """ " Tllt,hon. (1111 11.11 '" 1/11/11 " "".. 10 " 111111 "'11' " i,,,,1 11.1\ III 1/11/1\ .. ,"". lO ,. '1.,'1 ....,. " lllllgl 114.\1 III lilt/II .. ",.,. [t 111111 1111,. " filii nl loll ill 1/11 III " "".. [0 " ,.,... 11"" " 11I11.llltlnj lI.11 III 1'11/11 .. """ [0 II"" ,..,., " illing '"l 4\, !I III 1/11/14 " II"" (0 " 1"1" """ " ".",..,. .... 1/11/11 " ..,... [[I " "'1" 1"'1' " .".,1.... ..,. 1/11/11 " ..".. f 0 "1", '11'" " ............ Hill fllllll! !limB !l11.11 I/ll/II " """ f 0 " ,".11 '''''1 " lOTI I MIlO [If[H\[1 ,II ......... 10TII UNIIIIIO !If[I\E\ 11II.Il ,,, - ,J . ~ <( ~ . H ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ 0 ~ 'tl k'>< 14 0 c: '. 0 ~ M ~.. I'd ~ jg /:l 'rl lj j 0 ..0 .., lJ) 'N ~ ~ Q P<~ ~ Il.... I! /:l I.o..IlJ ~ p 01 ~ .,; .~l8~ I<':~ .c k k 0 . ~ 'tl l'il 'rl ~ ~m oel Il'tl ." OIP< H ~p. l'il Il '><J: ~ o . ~ I'd ~ 0 ... 8 ~ P ~ ~~ 01 ~. .;;:!~ E'" g ~ ....'tlll III 'rl P l'il ~ >~Ill .... ( j . I o ) l'il'rl Q 0 :>: 'tl ~ ~.i' I-<U . to, k lil 8~ III ~ 1- ~ ....! Ii: . - ~ ~~ '" ~E'q i:i P '" I-<'tl . ~ il '" Ol ij ~ I A ..'tJMJQ~ ~ ! J '" ~ 'rl l'il ~ k .... '" ~ > k 'tl III . U 'M D t-f ~~ ~ ~~ , ::l 'tl... 'tl'rl ~ O!ilP~PJ: :0: 'rl I'd U % ~ l ~..~' _,,.;,4,.r"'U':.;.JL '._-