The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About94-04038 .' , , ',-, \, \ I ~I Pi I j ()o tV) o :r " .. , , , i, I .., , , I, I' 'I, " ! '" ,,1, ":} ; i ".~ , .r" ~j " " " , ',:'\\ '" ., , , " , '1 ,~" , 'I;: I'. 1;'1 .t~ , i ,;. I'il ;','i .,';1 CoMMoNWIAlfH Of ,.NNIYlYANIA C_' Of C_ 'lIAI NOTICI 0' APPIAL fllOM JUDICIAL Mlllef DISTIICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT 94-4038 Civil Term COMMON ,LIAI N. NOTICI 0' APPIAL Nolle. I. ;1_ thot the appellant h," filed in the above COUtt of COl11mon Plea. on uppeol from the judgment r.nder.d by the Di.triet ~j.lie. on the ..... and In the COM "",,'lou.d below. ......or AmUANT -----------------.----JM215Bf"No 01 NAMI or Dl OtNNIS ALaR/Mil l\.{ CHEEL_E~E:~/VI8r_J?- ....._______ H~_~~~---~.:sHVl~ ~0ERl~E~ ADDIUIOfIAmUANT .,JT't ~'.I. ZPCClDI ~ A ~ LI 'SLE[H ~~Of {";;'"~-~)~-ER.III-~~ -..- - -- --.-- __E'1__________--.!=?.~~,~---_---:-- a ~E~I ~;," 1- q c+ ~~~~.J'____51 j; ne,t:z [IlGNAI"'.-'" m~fOltTi!~r-7l-.AL[31?'~~i.- 'U"~E'c-"'AI>1 CV1900oao,:?Q-'llf . (.Q 'tJ>a U19 ,( Thi. block win be Ilgned ONLY when thl. notation I. ~;quir.d und;;-PO:ii.cP,J Ifapj;eiia,:,iwas-CLAIMANT (see Pa.-R,CP,J.P. No. 10081. TN. Nolie. of Appool. when recol....d by the Di,trict JUltie.. will opore'" o. 0 /001 (6) in nella" before Disltiet Jus/ice, he MUST SUPERSEDEAS to the Judgment for po"...1on In thi. co... FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty (20) days after I filing his NOTICE of APPEAL. .&g"atu/c- o-r'~othonot;;iiYOr--bL>pt;r-y-- PRAICIPE TO EiiifElfilu"-ETO-FiiEcOMPLAINT AND RULE TO 'ILE (This section of form to be used ONLY when appel/ant was DEFENDANT (see Pa. HCP.JP. No, IF NOT USED. detach Irom c~y 01 notice 01 appeal 10 bo served upon appel/co), 'RAICIPII To Prothonotary Enfwr rule upon N A I-l C '( 1001 (7) In action bo(ofP, Distrlcl Justice, (Common Plea. No. SIt:. 8e&._____________________ . oppeIlee(s). to file 0 complalnlln this appeal N/PIfJoIOW01IeC'isJ 94-4038 Civil Term ) within twenty (201 doy. ofter...",vic, of rulo or .uffer oetry<;;).judgment of non ""'" ~~a~c ~ SorJf1ll'uro oI......{/(I'or,.. "''''''''Yor_ . oppell..(.), -7 L-.. -.... 5/ €.B'E~ Name 01 8PlJd1 5 J . RULI. To ,IJ A '" c. '( ( 'I You ore no~fiod thot 0 rule i. hereby entered upon you to filo 0 complaint In thi. oppool within twenty (20) doy, of to.< the dole of _vlcI. of thi. rule upon you by ,*""",1 .lfvicI. 0< by elfHfiod or rogi.tered moiL DaM: (2) If you do not file 0 complolnt within thi. ~me. 0 JUDGMENT Of NON PROS Will BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU. (3) The dole of ",vIcI. of !hi. rule if .lfvicI. wa. by moil i. the dole of moiling. j J __ Ju'y 20. ,,,-1!< ) H.'- I i i~ ..c 312-84 COURT FILE TO BE FilED WITH PROTHONOTARY >>-._....._ .,.~,~ .d_" I'H:'.~,.,.I" " ,*",1';" ". . lIP .'!i.,,'" !.I., , ." t ,t I , . J. ,,' I (j, ,~ I; i' . ,'~ ( " I" .. I..' '::" 1!' ,;1 , . I !:I ,,;), \ " ~ ~ I t ,~:~ I- ": " ,. f. ) I Ii.' " f ~ 1) .~ ' .1. " ~ 2 "II " i ,)l .. o Q )' '~ '; IJ ~' a,: t ! .... !t, , '" " Wll.( . ,'" ..I ~ j , ll1 , z ~i 1 '5 ',10 Ij I ',;' , I ~ i :::,0 1 ~ go J i Ii ~ ~ ~ S ~ 0 IO! ! 'if] II} w~ J )", ~'":II i ' - "S' 5 ~ g I ~ ": ,I. i\ ~9 i 1 ll! J'fi~JI&I~ ; ,,) .1": 11'1 ~ I ~ -I - i ~ "- ,'f rl. ! I i ~ ~ .! ~lf I~ie . ~ ~ r~ 1 ,1 I > 0 0 ~ a ,C ~ i~ ~ <Il I ~ <Il ~ ro'., I. " ,I , , ij"" , , '~t ,i ~'I'. .. I,,)' I . ,tC' - ''''''h'''' ql-~bt C!~,J~ I 1 JUL 20 IU ~lJ AH '9~ I . 'L , i.' . -i ,,\r,) ,,,! I 'j (Y ", .:,ii \. " '. :/ . ,q :"i if, , I" I " ; .. , ... i.~"1 \ I'..; " ... 1 , ,?L~j u . IttJ;,r S - 't6""),r (!f (t u;' J 'p..;. . ': /33$'{ I av ~ 'It L~1 I I .j I , , ,.' .. I :1 I: I ,,~ 'a ,. i 'a .., ! f ., ;." ' .. 1 " . . , . . , . .1' " . -"- . .' , : II',> 'I: '! ~:';_"llt~ '~" Il.jl_'-~frFrt,'J.,'f;' " .. I I , , JUt 20 10 S6 AH '9~ I, r' I, " l.)t Ii' ~fJ,~i, .1;) ,_ ,Ill HI:"; ~ ",/;t;r " ,::,;!l "i) {' , , '.il. If,) . "J r , " , . .. :", ., " , , ,I; '" i,' , " , , '.. "I .. , '. ,."".,." '''L ._'j'_r~" .' ,11' .,..., . . , ltc....-'. , I.' , .. I , . . " " " ,< . , t . 'j. " ." .. . "It , ,;" * "...--~ . ,"" ;;;r; . ie ">- '!; ~:~ I -, .~ II~ l .... CI'\ '_hl ~_, , ~ "" I~- ! ) ~, .., 1.,'f,.1 "I ~ ClO '.:'1 J " II ,.. Jt ",!lId ,','':L. <.- ,;~ ..) - '-' -ll < H a~., ~ 01 'tl l1lUlOl C Z- III ~ &1 . Z ~ . ;j i:ll1le !:l &; til !-t ~ ~ ,.Ii o .Q) t:l til Z U~fo< III ~ ~ H til .:( ~ i 1511 l'&. Z,-j H III ..:l 00,... Ul . ..:l H l1. 0> fII .:( lll: J: fo<U'... >l > til 0 ~ c = !i ~QU U Ul :<: U Z H U o~oo .:( Z U ,., Z Z ~o til tillll:., Q :<:til fo<~ . zoo HUZ . ," 4. The events hereinafter complained of occurred on March 25, 1994, when the Plai nti ff and Defendants entered' into the following oral agreement: Plaintiff would trade her Tennessee Walker Painted horse named Duke for the Defendants' Fox Trotter brown mare named Lady, along with a cash payment of $300.00 from Plaintiff to Defendants. 5. On March 25, 1994, the above orally between the parties and at the D~fendants the sum of $300.00. agreement was entered into that time, Plaintiff paid 6. On March 25, 1994, the Plaintiff and the Defendants agreed that the exchange of the horses and cash payment by Plai tiff would be contingent upon a thirty (30) day approval period by both Plaintiff and Defendants. 7. The Plaintiff took the Defendants' horse to a veterinarian within the thirty day period and discovered that the Defendants' horse was lame. 8. Approximately two weeks after March 25, 1994, well wi thin the thirty day grace period agreed upon between the parties, Plaintiff contacted the Defendants informing them that she was not satisfied with the exchange of horses and requested the return of her horse along with the payment of $300.00 previously rendered. -2- Ie) An additional bill for a veterinary visit in connection with the Fox Trotter horse of the Defendants in the amount of $50.00. 13. The Plaintiff has been forced to lose time at work and has suffered loss wages in the amount of $68.00 per day for two days. Plaintiff demands the Defendants reimburse the Plaintiff for said loss wages in the amount of $136.00. 14. Plaintiff has expended the sum of $300.00, cash payment to the Defendants at the time of the exchange of the horses pursuant to the oral agreement entered into by the parties on March 25, 1994, and Plaintiff demands a return of said sum of $300.00. 15. Defendants have rendered one payment to the Plaintiff, thereby affirming the debt owed to the Plaintiff, in the amount of $328.00, and Plaintiff is agreeable to a credit to the Defendants in said amount. 16. As a result of the Defendants' breach of the oral and written agreements, as well as their breach of the express and implied warranties, Plaintiff has been forced to expend sums for payment of suit and costs in connection with this action. -4- . . . {Jn~ ,...., /.() , (, " j , ' , " ~-' , I .. ' -{il ~ 0 ...... Ctl~)IY, c, i '1'l:2 6-0 . ,j I '! ,,.1 '\ 0.- ' ~;.,~ ~,~ II '.' " . ,- '- I , , ';-,"' /1 I ( ) 1,-. ,"} ,\' ,',' '-- ) ; , I"" , ,.,. . / ,.." J _-1./ , I 1.jJ' .. .~" , , .' -' ./- ~. t l l.. " , i ~/,( , , , 'I I ,( I I /T. "jJ~ -, . I( , t"" ,~ . I I .. ' ." I, .-' , I, I ': 1 I'" , :. , , " , (, I I , . . (, . " . ( . , i , ,,;1"/ .~ J (' , , . / , .I' I' , , " , , ./ "........ 'I '. I- ~ ;f 1ir' \ 1/ / ../.:r f. ". , I ,J ,... . . " i' " J "..~' . .~......-- .!> , ~ . ""-'Jt~ )J '-!-;-'II / /kl) . 'l t ,0..4",-to I(J cd..i/.!.., ~II" " )y~,'t \ LI /:'i l)~7 ')9 J2 I (." "-f, .... /, _.1.)' I (J · r cfl j\.,.." ; I",,'&-. I.~, \.0 (~)' c . . j l.\jQJ f.J'r'~>\...(:{.._, ,.tl'( /1....; 7>/,', . ." \. I " J./ (-..I (j () [,; C,' ,'I(C '._-' \..J , \ T) /. " '" I~.' .. /.-.(.~, t'.u I (" f I ~ . )1 1(,' I , -~.~. ~. (' '. ... \ \" \'.-J-' ,vr~~'" . . .' U ,( (2 /'~".,-,..- .~. : . .... - ....~ , ~ . .,...,i . ..~ )1 f , ,I ) ,1'/) - ' S',. f:/.!'~c_~<'!~rr~J_ --.----- ) , , , -, - II' ;1" ( -..,' . -,_.u,-L_::i..L;.V-.l~ Exhibit "A" ;sr; . ~.~r "'. ',r ., :II: 0..' <:) II> <'I '" .J:. ,--, I >;:, ", "".. ...'-1 f5 ..s . '. , c' 14: '"' CIl r:i>'" rol ..:l>1~ t.) !:1lCll~ 'tl '"' Z ila , &:: :> ! ." 13'. Orole rol ~!:1l Q) ~a CIl ~ ~ Iii o 'E-o gj i:&. U>t III 0 ~ ill E-o.... r.l Hrol r.. ~'''; H . gjt:; ... o > CIl "" H ~ Ili!1 E-08tJ > ..:l > >t 01:,", 01: ~Q U CIlt:'J Q Ii!: H O~(I) 01: H:rl i:&. U I"') Z ~t.) i:&. 0 Z 01: roll3'.... rol carol Q ... ~ . ZOO HUZ ~ , . \I NANCY SIEBER, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 4038 civil Term, 1994 CIVIL ACTION - LAW IVS. DENNIS ALBRIGHT, and CHERI FREEMAN, Defendants !pFIDAVIT OF SERVICE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF DAUPHIN Personally appeared before me, a Notary Public, in and for said Commonwealth and County, Arthur K. Oils, Esquire, who being duly sworn deposes and says that a certified copy of the Complaint was served upon the Defendant, DENNIS ALBRIGHT, at his address of One Mt. Zion Road, Carlisle, Pennsylvania, 17013, by Certified Mail No. P 016 242 119. Attached hereto is the return receipt executed by Florence Albright, as agent for Dennis Albright, dated August 10, 1994, eVidencing receipt of ther U(j-zi;/!l~ Arthur K. Oils, Esquire Sworn and SUbGCribe~to bet'ore llIe ttliS.~(,I/~!lY ~' If.J:j . (~/f ,r ~~~_4,!-___ , f ' ,), .;, ,,. '-'* ' \" t.... ,(".. e , ....~..... ~....,-. _~~.' -'-/. Notal: lil:..lic 1lIn"'~~'" 11II..-.. ~~ 'ttct.;... '-:~~t., ffi ~ 151 Z F ~ Cl ... cl: ~ i ~ a1S p. ~~ill z a: ~ cl: W" ~:I Voft. ~H~:.oI'Y .iP~T1!.YD tw U..Cll:l~fi11 'llll101..' IV LAW O"ICIS ~&J-AM'HlMI-'rNt)lIl'IWIf hi ~Ilit ~....""Inl" I'IU"OH8. 10 I". !lJ!FP~!'t' ~ OA~" 'MM ii1~ ~.I~~ AGAl,J,J~~N.Nt "'~-IffilIIIHr'i A"...." --- MANCKE, WAGNER, HER!!HEY & TULLY NANCY SIEBER, plaintiff I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA I I I NO. 4038 CIVIL TERM 1994 I v. DENNIS ALBRIGHT and CHERI FREEMAN, CIVIL ACTION - LAW Detendant. D..-I....' a 1I.ILIIlIIlUY OIJICTIOlla '1'0 lILaIII'1'U.' a CftllllLAIII'1' AND NOW, comes the Detendants, Dennis Albright and Cheri Freeman, by and through their counsel, MANCKE, WAGNER, HERSHEY & TULLY, who respectfully tiles these Preliminary Objections to Plaintift's Complaint and avers as tollows: I. 1I.ILllll1lUY OBJICTIO. LACK O. 'l.aOKAL JURlaDICTIOII 1. The causes ot action asserted in Plaintift's complaint involved breach of oral and written contracts and breach ot express and implied warranties. 2. Detendant Dennis Albright currently residos at 1075 Carlisle Road, Biglerville, Adams County, pennsylvania 17307 and has resided there since January, 1994. 3. The Detendant Dennis Albright runs a business known as Albright Concrete which said business is operated trom One Mount Zion Road, Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17013. 4. Detendant Cheri Freemen currently resides at 1075 Carlisle Road, Biglerville, Adams County, Pennsylvania 17307. 5. All face to face meetings between the Plaintiff and the Defendants took place in Adams County, Pennsylvania. 6. All telephone conversations that took place between the Plaintiff and the Defendant occurred while the Defendant. were in Adam. county, Pennsylvania. 7. All contracts, both oral and written alleged in plaintiff's Complaint were executed in Cumberland County. Moreover, both express and impli,ed warranties alleged in Plaintiff'S complaint were rendered in Cumberland County. 8. Because the cause of action asserted herein arose in Adams County, Pennsylvania and the Defendants reside in Adams County, pennsyl vania, this Court does not have personal jurisdiction over the Defendants. 9. There are insufficient contacts for this Court to exerche either general jurisdiction over the person of the Defendants Dennis Albright and Cheri Freeman or specific jurisdiction with respect to the cause of action. WHEREFORE, the Defendants Dennis Albright and Cheri Freeman respectfully request that Plaintiff's Complaint be dismissed. II. 'RILI.I.UY OaJ~TIO. .AILUIlI '1'0 CODOIUI TO RULa lOOllDI O. Tal DI.TRIC'1' JU.TICI RULI. O. CIVIL .ROC.DUIlI 10. Paragraphs 1 through 9 are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 2 11. Pl.intiff comm.nced thia action by filing a complaint on Auqu.t 8, 1994 in the Cumberland county Court of Common Pl.... 12. Rul. 1005(d) requires: "Th. party filing complaint under Rule 1004 .h.ll forthwith aerve it upon the oppCl.ite p.rty in the .ppe.l by l.avinq a copy for or m.iling a copy to him at his addre.s a. ahown in the District Juatice recorda mentioned in aubdiviaion . of this Rule . . . " 13. Rule 1005(e) of the District Justice Rules of Civil Procedure states: "Service and proof of service my be made by attorney or other agent." 14. Defendant Cheri Freeman wall never served wi th the Complaint filed by the Plaintiff nor has there been any certificate of aervice or proof of service filed with the CUmberland county Prothonotary indicating such. WHEREFORE, the Defendants respectfully request that Plaintiff's Complaint be stricken. Respectfully submitted, MANCRE, WAGNER, HERSHEY & TULLY Dat.:J// ~ 'II ;' . r(J''/'L' / / /:'/'1 . V? /./T . I '_ ,/ (/ ,/'~ /_<c-" -"". .... " f I" .-' /' , ".r' I . .._;"" By \,,)- , I: i/f , ( I . D~I6 R. BRESCHI, ESQUIRE Attorney ID # 59001 2233 North Front Street H.rri.burq, PA 17110 717/234-7051 Attorn.y. for Def.nd.nt. 3 COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA s. s. 1~ lJ..u,t{I);r~O %ID {l. (j'~lnc!",' 1<I(/';;'1I.-1/1.I'l1> "-tllj '-'let 'IIJ: /./ho /) it", .' lk.(/!y ,fry i)fl,~,)J/I?''J11 ~i ('41': //;('e/~4v, J.. ;'H r'j II tl YtC'1 (~j/ ,f, 1'~,fr4; I/C'v) ~)/(,/'(/l..I"'t d, t '14//r bd~jJ;; c , 5. 'Tt.'s vl,t,~(('I,[I' ~.,. /l.lol~ /;.J ((!t~~'li//1k45'~'.'( fr: f/4. /( (',/: (Z~ ;th lot'! (l), I {. f&, )-10 trt,'-i,^~ vI' lrd( }" tW Iu cv.,../) (i('ttV([&f ~. 'ffo (.lJ 0e&rf . J '/tiJ rf;t(JfP'/.j. //(It)~''fMll dl i{~~ ipsJ (J III k[Mt~c>, 1:vf;,)-elp,lA 5' tip /'i t/.~~{P I;l!tI-~ (,. ^) r:,.rtlk I'R.,~ l-\'AJ,'.~ ..\tl ftfP,/0 J~,.f!rl,f ~ .;~ ~J~il i II ~/~. r. J,' j tiroy /(';~~;.') (d ()N5"':'!~ ~ /",/;,.'1, c" .(0 ,", Jt '1 ''0 .' # 0~-:r /// ~~ o lJ'f7: (/;(itf?1 If!; IffY .'/JiJ",f) It'. iY/'c!( H~,- 1,-' i::"i{1 ,;, : ,cWl'lJll., I ,''', 11,-1 Ii f" . r--, _ ;I;ii:":, ~'}{; "~;,f ,"",1. tl" :_""1"',',''- ~ "Hrl.1",<;:~ ",-,,;i'~}:'i 'ih 'i , , \,-,i :F 'J'I'IL' ': :~'o '/ j~,,\,!y/:" t", '''~','''i :,N,{!,;/,,: 'I' ""! Ocr ZO 10 29 ~11 '9~ ':1,; ! , , " i f I\~~; ,)t III ','ONCr^~')' ~/JH})II'; I' 1,1 C'."J'lIY ; t: "11 J y, ,/\.'11,.\ " ,I ';_ ,1 " '~tJ'i j'.1 ,,', ,'I.~~,tl';: I,t' !'j (ji'\-l'!,.'-,',jF\', I,'" ,"': .1[' "t 'lil_r\',y,_:,V'_';':lt!:,\'lt "(lj\,+,I'I.'IIi'-l>l:ii','" :~{':'-' JtY~','1y~~:,J " '., ]ri';~I"I[:" J.:tJ 1,'1 :!!;'::~:;;ij,:'-i~,1-'!{{:L ,',1I_;_I"I;"",/(1_-,'/'; i,' I'll"" ',' 'I,k,' I", ,,'0:',-:1..'-, ," "~I i,I; ..,I__i ..;,,1-'(1/).'_' 'l~' 'ih'.l~b'~,i,~, ;I'\I:':":\,~:,.'I:.- ;'': ;'," !.i I'" ,1'1 " , ,of' " " ,\ , '1'" ,/ " I " " jl" ,. , ' " " ,J " " , 'I; I. " I{ , , , , " " " " '1,- ,I} ~._.l ~ '''''''"''--1''-'1".1.''';1 .. -"~:"'1"~"" ""~"'.""''''q' "",.~-~ j'" ,l . .. '" " .. t ~ L~ " " . " 6 ~' I"~ . NANCY SIEBER, I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS Plaintiff I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA I v. I I NO. 4038 CIVIL TERM 1994 DENNIS ALBRIGHT and I CHERI FREEMAN, . CIVIL ACTION - LAW . Defendants DI.IHDAKT'I AXlKOID PRILIMIMARY l2IJICTION8 TO PLAINTU.' 8 COMPLAINT AND NOW, comes the Defendants, Dennis Albright and Ched Freeman, by and through their counsel, MANCKE, WAGNER, HERSHEY' TULLY, who respectfully files these preliminary Objections to Plaintiff's Complaint and avers as follows: I. J..ILI"INARY OB~.CTIO. - I"PROPI. VlNOI 1. The causes of action asserted in Plaintiff's Complaint involved breach of oral and written contracts and breach of express and implied warranties. 2. Defendant Dennis Albright currently resides at 1075 Carlisle Road, Biglerville, Adams County, Pennsylvania 17307 and has resided there since January, 1994. 3. The Defendant Dennis Albright runs a business known as Albright Concrete which said business is operated from One Mount Zion Road, CarliSle, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17013. 4. Defendant Cheri Freemen currently resides at 1075 Carlisle Road, Biglerville, Adams County, Pennsylvania 17307. 5. All face to face meetings between the Plaintiff and the Defendants took place in Adams County, Pennsylvania. 6. All telephone conversations that took place between the Plaintiff and the Defendant occurred while the Defendants were in Adams County, Pennsylvania. 7. All contracts, both oral and written alleged in Plaintiff's Complaint were executed in Adams County. Moreover, both express and implied warranties alleged in plaintiff's Complaint were rendered in Adams County. 8. The venue of this action is improper in this county, since under Pa.R.Civ.P. 1006, plaintiff may only bring this action against the defendants in the county in which they may be served or in which the cause of action arose, or where the transaction or occurrance took place out of which the cause of action arose. WHEREFORE, the Defendants Dennis Albright and Cheri Freeman respectfully request that Plaintiff's complaint be dismissed for improper venue and transferred to the Adams County Court of Common Pleas pursuant to Rule 1006(d)(2). II. PR.LINIKaRY OBJ.CTIOM .AILUR. TO COKrORX TO RUL. 10051D) O. TB. DI8TRICT JU8TIC. RUL.. O. CIVIL PROC.DUR. 9. Paragraphs 1 through 8 are incorporated herein by reference as though set forth at length. 2 10. Plaintiff commenced this action by filing a complaint on August 8, 1994 in the Cumberland County Court of Common Plea.. 11. Rule 1005(d) require.: "The party filing Complaint under Rule 1004 shall forthwith serve it upon the opposite party in the appeal by leaving a copy for or mailing a copy to him at hi. address a. shown in the District Justice record. mentioned in subdivision a of this Rule .. " 12. Rule 1005(e) of the District JUlltice Rules of civil Procedure states: "Service and proof of service may be made by attorney or other agent." 13. Defendant Cheri Freeman was never served with the Complaint filed by the Plaintiff nor has there been any certificate of service or proof of service filed with the Cumberland County Prothonotary indicating such. WHEREFORE, the Defendant Cheri Freeman respectfully requests that plaintiff's Complaint be stricken. Respectfully submitted, MANCKE, WAGNER, HERSHEY , TULLY B~(.1i'&:[,( Attorney ID # 59001 2233 North Front Street HarriSburg, PA 17110 717/234-7051 Date :jj - I rt/ !-~?)lr?1 Attorneys ~or Defendants 3 vanIOATIOK I The undersigned, David R. Breschi, hereby verifies and .tate. that I 1. He i. the attorney for Denni. Albright and Cheri Freeman, Defendant.. 2. He is authorized to make this verification on their behalf . 3. This verification is made by counsel pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. No. Rule 1024(C). 4. The statements set forth in the foregoing Amended Preliminary objections to plaintiff's Complaint are true and correct to the best of his knowledge, information and belief. 5. He is aware that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. 54904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. DatejllM{A 0, ff91 i - a. ~ .'~ . - ,L . ::=1 .'J .," , , ,-..; .... ... =, ,d 14: H >... ..:l>1~ tJ !:1lCll~ ~ ila ' H 'tl > I~ ~ &:: 13'. ! ." r.l CIl ~ ! I Ii 8~E-o gj , ... i:&. E-o'" III CI:I 0 ; -II ra.~'''; lal t:l ~ o > ... H r.l 8'''; II) . 13'. ... ~ Ili!1 lot U III III r.l ..; ~~~ >t > :01 r.l U U 13'. '"' Z r.. i:&. 14: CIl '"' Z H H ... ~i~ z ~ 13'. Z r.l r.l U Q U zoo HUZ '.. .. . NANCY SIEBER, Plaintiff vs. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA 94-403!1 CIVIL TERM DENNIS ALBRIGHT and CHERI FREEMAN, Defendanls CIVIL AcrlON . LAW ~ ", , IN RE: DEFENDANTS' PRELIMINARY OBJEcrlONS BEFORE BAYLEY AND HESS. JJ, 9RDER AND NOW. this /'1'" day of Dccembcr, 1994, aftcr argumcnt lhereon, the preliminary objections of the defendants are DENIED, BY THE COURT, $ 1z,/r'/~~ Arthur K. Dils, Esquire For the Plainliff David R. Bresehi, Esquirc For lhe Defendants :rlm NANCY SIEBER, Plaintiff W TilE COURT Of' COMMON PLEAS OF CL'MBERL.\ND COUNTY, r~NNSYLVANIA NO. 4038 crnL 1994 VB. DENNIS ALBRIGHT, and CHERI FREEMAN, Defendants CIVIL ACTION - LAW RULE 1312-1, The Petiti"n for Appointment of .\rbitmtors shall be subst.:mt~Qll:' in the following form: p"T!~rO~1 :'OR APPOr~mIENT Of' .\RBrTRATORS TO THE HONORABLE. THE JcDGES OF SAID COURT: Arthur K. Oils, Esquire . counsel for the pLlintif~~~ in the abovl! 1. 2. action (or aceions), respectfully roprosents th3t: The above-captioned action (or aceions) is (ar~J ~e iHsue. The daim of the plaineiff in the .lceion b $ 1,483.00 plus The count~rclaiCl of the defendant in the aceion is costs and . interest The EoUolling attorneys are wise disqualified to sit as interested in th~ case(s) ~s counselor are other- David R. Breschi, Esquire arb icraton: WHEREFORE. your petitioner prays your Honorab1~ Coure co appoint th~ee 0) arbitrators to woom the cose shall be submieted. ORDER Of' COURT Respect: fuHl' ~UbjltY'd. (/{It1I//~- Arthur K. Oils, Esquire AND NOW. j) J.. I Y / /) , 19 '['j , in consideration of the eft. <-/v, deIL'.:I () ) Esq., VJS':!.IJ. .~"" L/[~ ~ I,~ ,: ;: I- t, ,: I ,Esq., :ire appoint"d a;bitrators in the tongoing petition, , /~ \c " )1/- !:lq .. and above-captioned action (or actions) as prayed for. B~J .t~e (.C. ,o:ll' t('. L Ie L . , \' r ./-_...;.~:.- NANCY SIIlBER, I IN THE COURT or COMMON PLEAS plaintiff I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA I v. I I NO. 4038 CIVIL TERM 1994 DENNIS ALBRIGHT and I CHERI FREEMAN, I CIVIL ACTION - LAW Def.ndant. I D..mmUl'l". Dawn &lID .n Oft.. '1'0 .UIII'!'I..'. COUUIII'!' AND NOW, COlli.. the D.f.ndant., D.nni. Albright and Ch.ri Fr..man, by and through th.ir coun..l, MANC~I, WAGNER, HERSHEY , TULLY, who answ.r the Plaintiff'. complaint and in .upport th.r.of r..pectfully av.r: 1. Admitted. 2. Denied. It is deni.d that D.nni. Albright resid.. at One Mount Zion Road, carli.l., cumberland county, PA. By way of furth.r answer, Def.ndant do.. r.o.iv. .om. mail th.r.. 3. Admitt.d in part d.ni.d in part. It i. admitted that Ch.ri Fr..man r..id.. a. 1075 Carli.l. Road, Bigl.rville. All furth.r av.rm.nt. are d.ni.d. To the contrary, Bigl.rville i. in Adam. County, p.nn.ylvania. 4. Ad.itt.d. !S. Ad.itted. 6. Deni.d. Th. .gr....nt .nt.r.d into by the plaintiff and D.f.nd.nt. w.. not oonting.nt upon. thirty (30) day agree.ent. 7. Denied. To the contrary, when the Defendants sold the horse to plaintiff, the Defendants indicated to the Plaintiff that the horse had arthritis. The Plaintiff responded that she did not care because she wanted a horse that was quiet 80 that a child could ride it safely. 8. Denied. To the contrary, the Plaintiff came back after thirty (30) days and requested the contract be rescinded and for the Defendants to return the horse. Defendant Cheri Freeman indicated to the Plaintiff that the horse that the Plaintiff exchanged in the agreement was already sold and it would be impossible for the Defendants to give back the horse. 9. Admitted. 10. Admitted in part denied in part. It is admitted that Defendant Dennis Albright signed the piece of paper attached as Plaintiff's exhibit. All further aspects of this averment are denied. To the contrary, a check was never issued to Dennis Albright. Therefore, no consideration was ever given and a legally enforceable contract was never executed. U. Denied. This piece of paper attached as Plaintiff's Exhibit "A" did not constitute an agreement. If the Court determines that this was an agreement, it is denied that the Defendant breached the agreement between them and the Plaintiff. 2 12.(a) Denied. After reasonable investigation, the Defendant i. without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of these allegations and proof thereof i. demanded. (b) Denied. After reasonable investigation, the Defendant i. without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of these allegations and proof thereof i. demanded. (c) Denied. After reasonable investigation, the Defendant i. without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of these allegations and proof thereof is demanded. 13. Denied. After reasonable investigation, the Defendant i. without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the.e allegations and proof thereof is demanded. 14. Admitted in part denied in part. It is admitted that Plaintiff paid the sum of $300 to the Defendants at the time of the exchange of the horses pursuant to the oral agreement. All further averments are denied as after reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief a. to the truth of these allegations and proof thereof is demanded. 3 15. Denied. To the contrary, the money that was paid to the Plaintiff from the Defendants was prooeeds from when the Plaintiff'. horse was auotioned off. This was not an affirmation of the debt owed to the Plaintiff. 16. Denied. As after reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of these allegations and proof thereof is demanded. 17. Denied. As after reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of these allegations and proof thereof is demanded. 18. Denied. As after reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief aa to the truth of these allegations and proof thereof is demanded. WHEREFORE, Defendant demands judgment in its favor, plus co.t. in connection with this suit. II" MATT" 19. Paragraphs 1 through 18 are incorporated herein as though .et forth at length. 20. There is a failure or lack of consideration regarding the alleged contract or agreement alleged in paragraphs 10 and 11 of Plaintiff'. Complaint and attached as Exhibit "A" in Plaintiff'. Complaint. 4 ~ - ~;_: I ~ I' :r:: -":'- 1"1 I"-J ,Y) " ", ~'":l '''-,I :.r: ... -., < H r:i>'" ..:l~~ !:1lCll~ :z: ila , l>: r.l =~ Or.le 'tl ~ ~!:1l~ &:: ." ~ o '... t:'J ~ ~; U U~.-f ... ; ill ~ = ~ r..~...; r.l ~z ~ o > '"' . HOII: Z ~ Ili!1 0,,,; Ul III 13'.:1: "'UU ~ ~r.l 0 ~O >t ~~ ... U OZ<o :z: i:&. >< Uj:ti < Ul .... Z HH " r.l13'.... :Z:l>: r.l CI:Ir.l Z~ l>: ...lll r.lCI:I :I: . OU z:;)o HU:Z: to. . , . . , ,', CPr " ' _J~"'L/' In !he Court of Cornmon Pl.as of '" .;' "'-, d ~ "" ' 'I ( /)" U\/'" bit \ ",. I \ ,.. tV~' , "1'.J,'.,' ) 1" , ,'." ') } ) ) ) ) Cumbarland County, ?ennsylvania ~o, ,'j", ~ ,'j", I _19 III , ,'/'It ,; OATH We do .ol.moly swear (or affirm) tha CODatitution of the United Statls ~ealth and that wa will discharge the ..,.,. ~ that WI will support, obey and defend and the Constit~Cioft of this Common- duties of our oHi~e wlth, f deUty, <-~//(d_ ~ "~ . I,; a 1- " '. ,,0 ,.., ~ I"~' .... 'I[f.hlll\}~ ld(i('I/ J' / J , ' , . ( ""- -, ',' -) AWARD We, the undersigned arbitrators, having been duly appointed and sworn (or affirmed), maka tha following award: (Nota: If damage. for delay are awarded, they shall be saparataly stated.) \ J ,,",,' -... , '/ - II. r., ,N f , /- (., C, ,..r..' ( ,_. . . .. ('II',~" ( rc;.. '., t.',\ c I 1tJ _<r\.~ " .! ,< ,"<I.-V,"!',; 1\ 7 L " 'f, I' ,~ ': ,.' !: I).. f. ;"4/,,, t... /':\- v"v' iJ ~,\ "J ~ f.. r- 'f ,J, N \ L '( ( I Lj'" " C'" J N . Arbitrator, dissents. ,(Insert n,me i! .,1..0::, ~~ -~/;,' , L~~a1 :Z'hS;Y/ /'~' If ~ '_ J,~:! I l: ~/ {II 1><. " I j ~onc~ OF mTRY OF AW;\!iJ) , applicable. ) Oate of aaaring:_:..JJ.: II)! , OaCa of Award: ' ;1, II/:J :fow, tha 17 n... day of '~k..("'J Avard wa. .ntared upon tha dockat partial or t~air attorneys, . 19.:JJ::... at/~, LL,~I,. tha abova and noticl .harlof glveu by ,~il to tha Arbitrators' companaat1~n to ba paid ~pon appeal: $ "M'JO. (10 ,~tL~:1; IU'L. r. ')~(Ld.LC1... . ' ?r',chonotary By: {(~.. ,~(~Lt. L f'n ~~ fee I... --;r Dellut:, " ,I 1"\.' yj" "Ie','.,- ! :'il : ~! ) "j' : I /J"",j~..,M '~~1l,1J." ,', ' 1;~4:i~~~~\';~~':" 1U:~~tj~;fP\"" L .' .,./' i/}'J,';/.I,O" . .J,. " OF Tl1~~~ ' " fi.:NOTN/ 96 AUr;.1 0 PLf/2 Y cu~.. '15/ M..Jll'f '/. ' fJENtJs}'i(~I\X~UNfY ',I ',i " '. ',' " , ;.1','1\ ,,' '" ,"1,.1".'1 i' , , ),' ,.1, '. , , 'I, ',I "I t'. I '. " 'I , ., i , I ',,' , I , , I ", , . .".\ , " , ',,"-' , , , ' , I"J ," ',-1 , ' ':1 'I '1,,\ '. '" ,.,,',., \II'. >,.' ..,,',,' ." ,~, ,. '.,. 'I'" ~ ........ . , '" . . " .. ,,/ " ,,. , \, \ I' .. . .' ,,",-" '. . ':~ '" ~'