The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About94-04119 , ~ f ~. i I I ' // / I ( I ., l " ~ 1 ' , "" '" '" ,. I ~ r , , , , " , ' ., I '(1 If ~lir.4 , , !~ I :J,~ , ~.'~ /!~ II 11 ! Ij " il it " ".I ,~ " :1 ) (f~ . "'I . " ,I ,!"f II' , j ,,'I '/..: 'Ii '! :,f, ','~: :~t ~l ,;. " iJ "t :It. {f~ ~'N TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, Plaintiff, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA ti<lu,ly NO. 94- 41N Q!VIll TERM I I I I I I I I CIVIL ACTION - EQUITY va. GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, Defendants NOTICE You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with a court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the Court without further notice for any money claimed in the Complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. Court Administrator One Courthouse Square Carlisle, PA 17013-3387 (717) 240-6200 N, p.e. By for Pla nt tt LAW O'''ICU SNILDAI<IR . BRf.NNIMAN TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, plaintiff, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA l' . ~,..~ NO. 94- ~/I? ' n' I. TERM vs. GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, CIVIL ACTION - EQUITY Defendants COMPLAINT AND NOW, comes TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, Plaintiff, by its Attorneys, SNELBAKER & BRENNEMAN, P.C., and avers the following cause of action in equity: 1. The Plaintiff herein is TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, a municipal township of the second class located in Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, having its municipal office at 350 North Middlesex Road, Carlisle, PA 17013. 2. The Defendants herein are GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, husband and wife, adult individuals, whose last known addresses are 22 South Letort Drive, Middlesex Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. 3. Defendants are the owners and are in possession of the premises known and numbered as 22 South Letort Drive located in the Township of Middlesex, county of Cumberland and Commonwealth LAW Ol'''Jc.I!S SNII.BAKER 6 Blur~NIMAN of Pennsylvania, as more fully described in a certain deed from Edward R. and Carol A. Stover to Defendants dated March 25, 1985, and recorded on the same date in the Office of the Recorder of Deeds in and for Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, in Deed Book "E", Volume 31, Page 42 et seq., which description is LAW OI"I"ICEB SNILBAKIlR . BFlI:NNltMAN incorporated herein by reference thereto (hereinafter called "Subject Premises"), The principal building on said Subject Premises is a single-family detached dwelling house, 4. Plaintiff enacted a land use/zoning ordinance known as "Middlesex Township Zoning Ordinance" as Ordinance No. 3-89 on June 30, 1989, the provisions of which ordinance are incorporated herein by reference thereto (hereinafter called "Zoning Ordinance") . 5. Commencing at divers times prior to Hay 4, 1994, the Defendants have caused or permitted the following acts to occur on or about the Subject Premises: A. Disposed of trash by discarding the same on the Subject Premises causing it to spread on the properties of others in the residential neighborhood in which the Subject Premises is located. B. Storage or placement of three unlicensed and/or inoperable motor vehicles in the front yard of the Subject Premises. C. Placement and maintenance of a semi-trailer for storage purposes in the front or side yard closer to the adjoining street than any portion of the dwelling house erected on the Subject Premises. 6. The foregoing acts or uses set forth in paragraph 5, SUDra constitute violations of the Zoning Ordinance in the following respects (the following subparagraphs being identified by corresponding letters to the subparagraphs in paragraph 5): -2- LAW O"lCIHI SNlLaAI<&:R . B"INNIMAN A. section 14.17A which prohibits use ot any land which discharges or disperses solid waste which adversely attects the surrounding area, or which causes annoyance or disturbance to any of the surrounding properties or to their owners or occupants, or which is unwholesome and may be prejudicial to health and general welfare. 8. section 14.17F which prohibits the parking, storage or placement of unlicensed motor vehicles for more than thirty days on any exterior premises (except within a licensed junk yard). c. Section 14.01A which prohibits the placement of any acoessory structure on any lot which projects nearer to the street on which the principal building fronts than such principal building. 7. Written notice of the above violations was delivered to the Defendants by personal service upon Defendant Julie A. Johnsen on or about May 4, 1994. 8. Defendants have failed and refused to comply with the notice aforesaid and the cited provisions of the Zoning Ordinance. 9. Defendants have failed to remove the three motor vehicles mentioned in paragraph 58 hereinabove. 10. Efforts to encourage compliance with the Zoning Ordinance have been rejected by Defendants. Defendants, through Defendant Julie A. Johnsen, protest, inter alia, that they do not -)- LAW O"lcn SNIL.BAKIR . BRENNEMAN have funds with which to comply. 11. Based upon the statements cited in paragraph 10 above, the Plaintiff believes that its remedies via civil penalty would be futile, leading to a multiplicity of actions and that the violations would continue. 12. Plaintiff has no adequate remedy at law. 13. Equitable relief is needed to obtain actual compliance with the Zoning Ordinance in order to protect and preserve the welfare and common good of the citizens of Middlesex Township. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests your Honorable Court to: A. Enjoin Defendants from discharging solid waste, storing unlicensed and/or inoperable motor vehicles and placement of accessory structures in prohibited areas on the Subject ~remises; B. Order and direct Defendants to abate the continuing violation of the Zoning Ordinance by removing all trash from the exterior of the Subject premises, remove all unlicensed and/or inoperable motor vehicles from the Subject Premises and remove the semi- trailer storage structure from the prohibited area of the Subject Premises; C. Order and direct Defendants to obey the Zoning Ordinance; D. Order and direct Defendants to pay the costs of this action and Plaintiff's expenses of enforcement -4- LAW O,,,IClB SN~I.BAKER III IJIUNNf!MAN TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA I CIVIL ACTION - EQUITY I I I I NO. 94-4119 EQUITY TERM VB. GARY G. JOHNSZN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, Defendants PLAINTIFF'S PRETRIAL MEMORANDUM AND NOW, comes Plaintiff, TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, by its Attorneys, SNELBAKER & BRENNEMAN, P.C., and submits the following Memorandum pursuant to this Court's Order of August 18, 1995, in accordance with C.C.R.P. 212-4: 1L--BASIC FACTS AS TO LIABILITY Defendants are the owners of a single-family dwelling house in a residential neighborhood. Their yard area is objectionable to their neighbors and in violation of the Middlesex TownShip Zoning Ordinance in the following ways: A. Disposal of household trash by discarding it in the yard area causing it to spread unto the properties of neighbors. B. storage and retention of unlicensed and/or inoperable vehicles in the front yard. C. Placement and retention of a semi-trailer for storage purposes in the yard. These uses are in violation of sections 14.01A, 14.17A and 14.17F of the Zoning Ordinance. Notice of violation was given to Defendants on or about May 4, 1994. Defendants have refused to comply. AUl:il.~ll~l!r\>I\_.L_/)/2'_d N ' IJ1 11LL~~"'t7eL( ;, (~oel'"t~~/~ .1 /'I,. 9'1 - 'II ICj C7Vlc... ~I'"""", i - ~W:~S~...... of ~'J)..l , 'r rl~ \(~~ c; ~r-!:J_f; JO. h I'\.S 4>.. ~ (J(jj. fl.. J~~-.-.J d v,' L.. A<: TIer>" ()~DEfZ I I r: ~ , t'\ o-w th;-.r- (U'\ ^ ) J......., ttf- /11tf ~ ~~ ~?; oe:t-~ . -- 'T~ ~t\s. h j P "f fYl ~ tAJ l...s~y f' I ~;-n 4- tff ~ VS. k-, ~r~ ~.:ro h n.se",/", ..../i'f!... . To h., Se-. De.fc!''''.JA.~ f S' '! h -f" eo c;, v..r"t elF~ MtnA..p/~, S b f ('c....1'k be r la.-.J Qu.~ I Po.... No. q 4 - ~/' 9 , C f v; /..- A-cT j' a-v-. ._-_._~ A- -H- e 4itr"'l'- : r re.lu..~ s -+ +-0 f~ +,. + i' a-..... ~ e Co w'1- ~ ("' a..V\ e )( +-e "" OS ''-~ 0 f 30 cAe... 'is I ^ oy-o(~ r' ..-ra C~f/'1 +c ~wV\.S"i'f of M,'J..,( /eSleX " ("' J:, "'~ '" C ~ . M ~ e s~ e J... k.v...S b 0... "-4 ol., ~S' l'\at- res ~ .?---r 2.-'2.. $'. Le+e (+ Dr. 0...,,). h eo ,. ~ w ,I( I') 111 C' w ..ft.('~ I a.. \IV 'I E: r +L~-t.A..S ~ /~ r 0 ) " 1-1.. S --t-a 5 '''3 'Y\ "'- ( ( a...lJ. fz, l'\^.Cl L" i' I eo s ., I{ e r -I.., 1M- e.- ii r ~ A-A-A s~ T {" iC..'" ..f..... ~ e -f-k +1+/ e -I-e ~ ()~~kYAr~ tL".,{ I~-,a.}(y ('€W\ed...'( f>Y'e~/eW( ~ 1. 1i\. LL.s ") w, II c ~f 1'1 it '1 S e p+ / / 19 q 4- , GotIiLr'1 C;, 3D h......seV\ ;--nSI"'s +e.J. ::]::"ol., 4(11 -tI\~.s, -J-r......./I' S"t.C +/lJVt,.J' iYt -t-e.. PL..-J--d...i. r.J. 0 )'\0""f-,k.,td"W 'VVk'1 ~u...+a:f+eY"" (~e6(r T'M tA"i'II,"'d -f..:Jd c;t I (j)I..; w i# h. /:S d ;' V 0 r ('~ I ~ uJ '!~ r f.,.. 'el. c ..("0 Ii Iso ~ 1 er.)." r 1t"'7 LJ- s f .J..- ~~./ / ~e.f+ A fytt,Je It.." Oey W, II CO s-f J'k.!...1 1; lOCi ' ~~ -h; L ~ f; -Iz; re~ Ve -"<- {f .e fi (e- 5 s tJ r.A:f~ -rr'''-.S A of u p -t-o c~ t7"t~c~UJJWaJie f1A:J +- -f~ Ke1- '1$e.Je/' ~/ 5 +"0 C' c:t4A J, e .50 Iv ~d. . . 6i ('455 (S ~Q7 ~cco-~ ~ ~ 'f'~vJCA.:f/~ tt t\- A ~ + -/ c C':l k' 'if 2() 0 ' (j CJ ~ cJ 2_ /tU:d . :t~J ~>1,",'tA. O'V\ ) i ;; ~$" " +j f,.O'YV' 5 --r-cd-e ~ ~ '{-;~ ~ e rJ +r-: 20 V.eO[S !:e(V/c~ --f-?:J fI.M.t 40 vecy\~~,..J. -:r::, ~M ~I -fd 10.,.... ~"..d.S ~ r lV\tLlA 1<: ., J ~f f'Iio-ss I V~ I I( ~('> 5 .s 'f.flqSh 1/11'416 'J' f) l:SeQ.Se . 'J .t\e{E'V' ~"",ol:r NcMA.(.) Y\o~ (~f~, ')\A 1 c k. ~ (J r e... /A tLyI..).. r- ~ --e.lA--+ -fc, ~ s-.4t-r ~~ ~3 a..vvl--:t ve(bl~/7 -h{~t ~ -r W?( / CtJVI..-f/i T {<L~ trK.('1 perf'fYf'~ ,'r\ 5 ( ~CA.) 11A~ vi f\ e , , r a riA -1-(' e pL/+EJ- b '1 ~ :;; +-e if e4^- 1:5 of VA VI^ ej-C;+", ~ C k--+--.J' 0/ V1A-eJ .. c (IVJ ff'r:ryV1 L l tL~ ~ S'-/-e 14 z.. I 'A ~ ~ () T' {'" It-f/'- {"'en^- +-t- ~ ( ~ .5 -e r-r ~ f,'-J u. ~ ~o-w -tG> &- ~ ~ l)J-(~t-- IS tt s kQJ. At\. vr c c;t2Se W a (' k€ (" ~-U IttU2 S,---'" C e ~1r?r' ckvl-(:s~ +0 \Nor];: ~b~. 'j-l r-d.-r-J C e:u..t 5 e CJ'{ Y1j 't ~~;- ( J. o:? '" . elf -s/Wh r ~~ f~ .J-.C I&-~ f)Je:r..5 (w..:pal'~' f-o JL-.ee ~ ~ vv ,-+R C{.fH?f" be"(; ~ ~,S€IJUI'<..... Vl^-e.J. I C r "e . 13 e c ~ S ~ ~ f ~ r'- elAJ S po... f ~r A-v--d.. r- e f' I:l- r+~ 'I" ~ c ~ ')\..JLUJ SJ ~ /)\S (.l. f1V\ Ct {p-""f. """;'1 d.. r"'f f <J ~.... to T 1........... '"- h gee.. ~ I e.. J ,,-L Co- u-"-c ( I <LW ~ S ~ h';--,-, f L~ to keep -e Iter If~::r" ~. 1':-1 JGy ~ 'Ie!) ho...c~ -f-o .5cJ:_o-~ (~ ~.s-f--~ +&1 f' e~c ct...;f-;'lf'>''\ r S.s'CJ l~ ~ I~ ~ ~ r +'t~.5 -f1A.J. +.e..d ~ I ~ '" -f ~. ;r~ .:5 -I- . .s-" c: X -f-e-.....s ~ w ,I! h. e.. ( L-.., ~Jee!C /q~L C~CI'( [~! jJ ~I'\-d tlA.-~.(17 ~"7t. I1A.J e M;i;--~A {: '1 ~~- 1\ eA- I f{ -'LoS N€ I! 4 -S M e. v\.. +--f' ~ /t/~~ tf ?:-b/J V' .... "'- e)" '" t' "I", ' I I',? r'-'J. F:~~~ I~:i;," A-v\. fs S uLt::'" ~ lU:J'Ut :.>~ ~ c~ tJJ.. ''''' ~~. ~ '11 {]. k;-L).I'e.i\ C(j." v e. f ~( f< ~ ~ '1. ^-,,-. ~ cv-bJ~ i i-~.J. ~~ _ . I Ji)A.1'l S~ Ju. (ie/(Jtr4./l~ .M+iA-+c.~eJ 7L) /911 J~ s-h:d-.e~.. ~, IS-; ") lA.t'- +0 fk (I V\A. i+~ -+ (VV\.t: tJArJ Y'Mrl~ tv..f 5M'-rzce vAlu:...tle ~rlitt.-n~~ f,~ I/'gIJ -b -t-~"'r col!~ -bPt-~~ 54 ~{ T ~ '}'vwXe-!- -b t:?-~(/(~-n'~LIs-1- ~-h-I 0/ t 1??!. ~~. 'J-1; 1'1f1; ,Ji ~m +. be MLHIU /~ iL lAf- slafi ;Vew jd uIIJe-. )~ I?' 7' M<-f h--~r~~ -b; rf -ILe-rZ . 0- y/kle-r i p~A ~ , , TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. CIVIL ACTION - LAW GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, Detendants NO. 94-4119 , /l ,n .... EQUITY TERM t',.) r,~ PLAINTIFF'S ANSWER TO DEFENDANT'S PETITION FOR EXTENSION , > ,,, -., ::.J,; - LoU ..c.. Plaintiff Township of Middlesex by its attorneys, Snelbaker , Brenneman, P. C. files this Answer to the Petition of Defendant Julie A. Johnsen .s follows: 1. After reasonable investigation, this party is without sufficient information to form a belief as to the truth of the various averments contained in the Petition for an Extension filed by Defendant Julie A. Johnsen AUgust 15, 1994; therefore, same are denied. Nonetheless, Plaintiff has no objection to the Court granting Defendant Julie A. Johnsen a thirty day extension beginning Allgust 15, 1994 in which to file an Answer to the Complaint, based upon Defendant's representation that an extension is being requested in order for her to comply with township ordinances. By: LAW OIl"ICU SNI.LiJAl<lR 6 B..ENNIMAN Date: september 2, 1994 I.AW O",CI. SNILBAKIR . B'UNNEMAN TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, Plaintiff , IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA VB. NO. 94- CIVIL TERM GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, CIVIL ACTION - EQUITY Defendants COMPLAINT AND NOW, comes TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, plaintiff, by its Attorneys, SNELBAKER , BRENNEMAN, P.C., and avers the following cause of action in equity: 1. The Plaintiff herein is TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, a municipal township of the second class located in Cumberland County, pennsylvania, having its municipal office at 350 North Middlesex Road, Carlisle, PA 17013. 2. The Defendants herein are GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, husband and wife, adult individuals, whose last known addresses are 22 South Letort Drive, Middlesex TownShip, Cumberland county, Pennsylvania. 3. Defendants are the owners and are in possession of the premises known and numbered as 22 South Letort Drive located in the Township of Middlesex, County of Cumberland and Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, as more fully dascribed in a certain deed from Edward R. and Carol A. Stover to Defendants dated March 25, 1985, and recorded on the same date in the Office ot the Recorder of Deeds in and for Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, in Deed Book "E", Volume 31, Page 42 et seq., which description is incorporated herein by reference thereto (hereinafter called "Subject Premises"). The principal building on ..id sUbject. Premises is a single-family detached dwelling house. 4. Plaintiff enacted a land use/zoning ordinance known as "Middlesex Township Zoning ordinance" as ordinance No. 3-89 on June 30, 1989, the provisions of which ordinance are incorporated her"lin by reference thereto (hereinafter called "Zoning ordinance") . 5. commencing at divers times prior to May 4, 1994, the Defendants have caused or permitted the following acts to occur on or about the subject Premises: A. Disposed of trash by discarding the same on the Subject premises causing it to spread on the properties of others in the residential neighborhood in which the Subject Premises is located. B. Storage or placement of three unlicensed and/or inoperable motor vehicles in the fr~nt yard of the SUbject Premises. C. Placement and maintenance of a semi-trailer LAW O"I~I. 8NILeAKER 6 8"INNEMAN for storage purposes in the front or side yard closer to the adjoining street than any portion of the dwelling house erected on the Subject premises. 6. The foregoing acts or uees .et forth in paragraph 5, SUDra constitute violations of the Zoning Ordinance in the following respects (the fOllowing subparagraphs being identified by corresponding letters to the subparagraphs in paragraph 5): -2- A. section 14.17A which prohibits use ot any land which discharges or disperses solid waste which adversely attects the surrounding area, or which causes annoyance or disturbance to any ot the surrounding properties or to their owners or occupants, or which is unwhole.ome and may be prejudicial to health and general welfare. B. Section 14.17F which prohibi~s the parking, storage or placement ot unlicensed motor vehicles tor more than thirty days on any exterior premises (except within a licensed junk yard). C. Section 14.01A which prohibits the placement ot any accessory structure on any lot which projects nearer to the street on which tho principal building fronts than such principal building. 7. Written notice of the above violations was delivered to the Defendants by personal service upon D.tendant Julie A. Johnsen on or about May 4, 1994. 8. Defendants have tailed and retused to comply with the notice atoresaid and the cited provisions ot the Zoning Ordinance. LAW O"'/CIII 8NIL..BAKIR . e"I:NNIMAN 9. Defendants have failed to remove the three motor vehicles mentioned in paragraph 58 hereinabove. 10. Effort. to encourage compliance with the Zoning Ordinance have been rejected by Detendant.. Detendant., through Detendant Julie A. Johnsen, prote.t, inter alia, that they do not -3- have funds with which to comply'. 11. Based upon the statements cited in paragraph 10 above, the Plaintiff believes that its remedies via civil penalty would be futile, leading to a multiplicity of actions and that the violations would continue. 12. Plaintiff has no adequate remedy at law. 13. Equitable relief is needed to obtain actual compliance with the Zoning Ordinance in order to protect and preserve the welfare and common good of the citizens of Middlesex Township. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests your Honorable Court to: A. Enjoin Defendants from discharging solid waste, storing unlicensed and/or inoperable motor vehicles and placement of accessory structures in prohibited areas on the Subject Premises; B. Order and direct Defendants to abate the continuing violation of the Zoning Ordinance by removing all trash from the exterior of the Subject Premi.ses, remove all unlicensed and/or inoperable motor vehicles from the Subject Premises and remove the semi- trailer storage structure from the prohibited area of th~ Subject Premises; C. Order and direct Defendants to obey the Zoning LAW g"ICU 8NILIAKlER 6 I!I"INNIMAN Ordinance; D. Order and direct Defondants to pay the costs of this action and Plaintiff's expenses ot enforcement -4- I, I , , t. - I, t,.J L. ~:I " 1 I" ~ ~ ~ Gii\l TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESBX, Pla intitf IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - EQUITY NO. 94-4119 EQUITY TERM v. GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, Defendants ORDER AND NOW, this ~ tt. day of ~, 1995, upon consideration of Plaintiff's Petition to Join Additional Person as Party Defendant, a RUle is issued upon Defendant Gary G. Johnsen, Defendant Julie A. Johnsen, and Jasmine J. Johnsen to show cause Why Jasmine J. Johnsen should not be added as party Defendant in this matter. The Rule is returnable :to days after service thereof by first-class mail, postage prepaid upon Defendant Gary G. Johnsen and Defendant Julie A. Johnsen at 22 South Letort Drive, Carlisle, PA 17013 and by personal service upon Jasmine J. Johnsen. as Party Defendant and this Rule to Show Cau be held on , 1995 at . M. in Courtroom o'clock No. in erland County Courthouse, carlisle, LAW o"tCIr$ SNELnAKER III SAENNlrMI\N BY THE COURT, ~~L J. Io.AW O"ICII aNIL."KI/lI . .'tlHNIM....N TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, plaintiff, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS or CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 94- ~ II~ CIVIL TERM vs. GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, CIVIL ACTION - EQUITY Defendants COMPLAINT AND NOW, comes TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, plaintiff, by its Attorneys, SNELBAKER' BRENNEMAN, P.C., and avers the following cause of action in equity: 1. The Plaintiff herein is TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, a municipal township of the second class located in Cumberland county, Pennsylvania, havin9 its municipal Office at 350 North Middlesex Road, Carlisle, PA 17013. 2. The Defendants herein are GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, husband and wife, adult individuals, whose last known addresses are 22 South Letort Drive, Middlesex Town.hip, Cumberland county, pennsylvania. 3. Defendants are the owners and are in possession of the premises known and numbered as 22 South Letort Drive located in the Township of Middlesex, County of Cumberland and Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, as more fully described in a certain dee~ !~om Edward R. and Carol A. Stover to Defendants dated March 25, 1985, and recorded on the same date in the Office ot the Recorder of Deeds in and ~or Cumberland County, Penn.ylvania, in Deed Book "E", Volume 31, Page 42 et seq., which description is Page 2 "f 7 ....w O,,.CII .NILo.AKI" . '''INNIMAN incorporated herein by reference thereto (hereinafter called "Subject premises"). The principal building on said sUbject premises is a single-family detached dwelling house. 4. Plaintiff enacted a land use/zoning ordinance known as "Middlesex Township zoning Ordinance" a. ordinance No. 3-89 on June 30, 1989, the provision. of which ordinance are incorporated herein by reference thereto (hereinafter called "Zoning ordinance") . 5. commencing at divers times prior to May 4, 1994, the Defendants have caused or permitted the following acts to occur on or about the Subject Premises: A. Disposed of trash by discarding the same on the Subject Premises causing it to spread on the properties of others in the residential neighborhood in which the SUbject premises is located. B. storage or placement of three unlicensed and/or inoperable motor vehicles in the front yard of the Subject premises. c. Placement and maintenance of a semi-trailer for storage purposes in the front or side yard closer to the adjoining street than any portion of the dwelling house erected on the Subject premises. 6. The foregoing acts or use. set forth in paragraph 5, SUDra constitute violations of the Zoning Ordinance in the following respects (the following subparagraphs being identified by corresponding letters to the subparagraphs in paragraph 5): -2- Page 3 \Jf 7 .' LAW' O'''CII 'HaL.AIeI,. . ."INNIMAN A. Section 14.17A which prohibit. u.e of any land which di.charges or di.perse. .olid va.te which adver.ely affect. the surrounding area, or which cau.e. annoyance or di.turbance to any of the .urrounding properties or to their owners or occupant., or which i. unwholesome and msy be prejudicial to health and general weUare. 8. Section 14.17F which prohibit. the parking, storage or placement of unlicen.ed motor vehicle. for more than thirty days on any exterior premise. (except within a licensed junk yard). C. Section 14.01A which prohibits the placement of any accessory structure on any lot which project. nearer to the street on which the principal building fronts than such principal building. 7. Written notice of the above violation. was delivered to the Defendants by personal service upon Defendant Julie A. Johnsen on or about May 4, 1994. 8. Defendants have failed and refused to comply with the notice aforesaid and the cited provisions of the Zoning Ordinance. 9. Defendants have failed to remove the three motor vehicles mentioned in paragraph 58 hereinabove. 10. Effort. to encourage compliance with the Zoning Ordinance have been rejected by Defendants. Defendant., through Defendant Julie A. Johneen, protest, inter alia, that they do not -3- l'ng(' ,'t of 7 IoAW ome.. SN.L.'KI~ . I~.NNIM'N have fund. with which to comply. 11. Ba.ed upon the .tatements cited in paragraph 10 above, the Plaintiff believes that its remedies via civil penalty would be futile, leading to a mUltiplicity of action. and that the violation. would continue. 12. plaintiff ha. no adequate remedy at law. 13. Equitable relief i. needed to obtain actual compliance with the Zoning ordinance in order to protect and pre.erve the welfare and common good of the citizen. of Middle.ex TownShip. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests your Honorable Court to: A. Enjoin Defendants from discharging solid wa.te, atoring unlicen.ed and/or inoperable motor vehicle. and placement of acces.ory structures in prohibited areas on the subject Premises; B. Order and direct Defendants to abate the continuing violation ot the Zoning Ordinance by removing all trash from the exterior of the Subject premi.e., remove all unlicensed and/or inoperable motor vehicles from the Subject Premises and remove the .emi- trailer .torage structure from the prOhibited area of the Subject premi..s; C. Order and direct Defendants to obey the Zoning Ordinance; D. Order and direct Defendante to pay the coet. of this action and Plaintiff'e expenles of enforcement -4- l'''ge 5 uf 7 herein, includin9 Plaintiff'S rea.onable attorney's tee.; and I. Order and direct such other and further reliet a. the Court shall determine to be ju.t and proper. , P.C. By ar C. Sne a er 44 We.t Main street Mechanicsburg, PA 17055-0318 Attorney. for plaintiff IoAW O"'ICII aNIUAUR . ....NNIMAN Page 6 uf 7 -5- VDIPICATION I, R. Anne capozzi, Middle.ex Town.hip Zoninq Otficer, do declare and atate: that I am authorized to uke thi. veritication on behalf of the Plaintitf, that the fact. .et forth in the foregoinq Complaint which are within my personal knowledqe are true and correct, ~nd as to tho.e ba.ed upon information received from others, I believe to be true and correct. I under.tand that fala. statementa made herein are subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. 54904 relating to unsworn fal.ification to authorities. ~ U;:'I_/ ~ ~ " ,~. / R. Anne apozrt (Zoning Otficer) Dated: July 23 ,. 1994 Page 7 uf 7 11,1 I ~ , . 1/ '. I,!' . ~ . II". I., .11,1 , ! '11'1,.11,/1 i\! , " 'If' 1\1'1111' 'r'l '.'11/1 I f' , '1'1; "; III , 11/'.1., h! f\'I' I" , ! d ,I , I'll I' 1/1/ II I I Ii!, ,. , I. ."!I FlI I,AI",' '; 1.'1. (,I, I 1)'ll '1 11'/ hi.' I. Ii' . I I ,. Ip'p I hi ,\IU.. , ,111'1' ,. I I,ll " , ",)11 , '. ',,'1"1 I; 11'1 ,jl,lJ 'f r""I")' 'Ill J j II "1 .".".' '1/ 'I' ", i ,111,,1 .;.,', .I ',;i I Ii" wIt III Ii I (i1'!1 I,^ r rl'l 1",IIII'f' "",i 1,'1 , ., 'If' 'II 111,1111: FIl 1,\ .1"/11, J. , I" '1' r, 'fl' I HI I I' I" 'ii : 'l~'':1 Hili 110:' " "11 I, j I ,I I '! 1/ Ij'i'l"lill'l ',;" .".1"'.11 U.I"!,,' l'I..,'n , " 'Ii' I , I/li, I ',',111 , ." 1/1 II I lIt, "iflll ',l.;ri ill .I ",t t ,':.'-,',.1 I . ,'/, I i,l I .' I 1,1l , II;'IIFh, 11',' Ii 11;',i',II'1 I/'! I I, I),' I II ('II, ',I.'h,I)\ r; II " 111/'1' -'II, r.p 1/11/.." "I. ,\'.1 I,ll. -'1./1 '; I,",' .-: 'I ,! '.1." I ,\111 r )I,lllI ,\1il'1 T !lltl/ll" ".I}III 'r 1:1. I I 11111 r, "I',. '11.1 1\.; ',\In., [11:'1 Ii! ,/111 Ii,'; " I,/i" :.1 Hlt, t. I illJ' '! i ( . , I I (1'1' p, I , III i I" t,111 '''''''11 "fll lHI'f ",tt. I " I,' I 11,'/ " Iii: '"rl! : ",'1' ~qd',.::.....",,~... ~ ..... '.~4._~.(~~ II "I"i I: I"" ')",,! ( (, f 1,1,j"! I ,Il; 11'1/';" I', /,11,1 ,.1,1;) 1,'1' 1.)1'\ I.. '-II rll;j) I;,', !', I h ,. ~;:jc!: ;2T ~ '../ ' . " J6~ ~S' C),tA- C. ~-w.~...; lh..(.i.~ , # ,.: i" ! : , v. : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS or CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - EQUITY NO. 94-4119 EQUITY TERM TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, Plaintiff I I : Ji' t,1 GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, Defendants I' AND NOW, ORDER this -3~~day of December, 1995, upon : I I: consideration of Plaintiff's Motion to make Rule Absolute, said Motion is GRANTED it is hereby ORDERED and directed that Jasmine J. Johnsen is joined as a Defendant in this matter. i' BY THE COURT, ! I, " i-, J"f ,'! ; : t. ! ~ ,', "',\ :1 " " ') "I " ,j. ., , 1\ LAW O""'ICIB SNIL.BAI<IEI4 a B"ENNI:MAN "1'" . ,'. ,I J ,-~ ., ~, I "",,'.~:' " , .1:.: ^..Itl II' \ 1 ., ',. 1""""'["1"1 - '-.I .1" ,~, ,.' 'I:,.; ~ (I: fl :.:',' !tlJ' :J 1:'(' .. oM') I LII.'ll'" '~'J. . "'l. ;'.".1 ..,./ -"I' JO .,,, .... .h.. ...f '- :l."I:,UO-JJ;/j TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - EQUITY NO. 94-4119 EQUITY TERM v. GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, Defendants MOTION TO HAKE RULE ABSOLUT~ AND NOW, comes the Plaintiff, Township of Middlesex, by and through its attorneys, Snelbaker , Brenneman, P. C., and files the within Motion stating the following in support thereof: 1. By Order dated November 8, 1995, upon consideration of Plaintiff's Petition to Join Additional Person as Party Defendant, a Rule was issued upon Defendant Gary G. Johnsen, Defendant Julie A. Johnsen and Jasmine J. Johnsen to show cause why Jasmine J. Johnsen should not be added as a Party Defendant in this matter. The Rule was returnable twenty days after service thereof by first class mail, postage prepaid, upon Defendant Gary G. Johnsen and Defendant Julie A. Johnsen at 22 South Letort Drive, Carlisle, PA 17013 and by personal service upon Jasmine J. Johnsen. LAW O"I'tCbli SNELnl\Kl:.1'f & e"!NNl!MI\N 2. Counsel for Plaintiff served a certified, true and correct copy of the November 8, 1995 Order of Court and also a true and correct copy of the underlying Petition to Join Additional Person as Party Defendant in this matter by first class mail, postage prepaid as evidenced by ldtter dated November I.AW O"ICIUJ SNlL.DAKIi:R Ii BIUNN[M.\N 10, 1995, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and incorporated herein by reference thereto. 3. Jasmine J. Johnsen was served with a copy of the Complaint in this matter together with the November 8, 1995 Order and a copy of tho Petition to Join Additional Person as Patty Defendant on November 16, 1~95 by Timothy Reitz, Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County as evidenced by the Sheriff's Return, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit liB" and incorporated herein by reference thereto. 4. More than twenty days has elapsed since service upon the effected persons. 5. As of the filing of this Motion, no response to the Rule issued November 8, 1995 has been filed. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, Township of Middlesex, respectfully requests your Honorable Court to make the Rule issued November 8, 1995 absolute and to order and direct that Jasmine J. Johnsen be added as a Party Defendant in this matter. Respectfully Submitted, SNELBAKER & BRENNEMAN, P. C. Date: By: R~1~~~;lbaker, Esquire Philip H. spare, Esquire 44 W. Main street Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 (717) 697-8528 Attorneys for Plaintiff December 8, 1995 Township of Middlesex -2- ..l ~~-~ IIIIa.-l... "L~~~ ~ ,,,, I;'; I ,,',.:, =-r 1.:;:: I "It -, ~ L J",,:::, I,..., _ I~'I;,~' -c"c '.!":r" -~,... . " ..... :.HEMJV~'J ~ETUkN - kEUULAR .:: A:SF: W': I'~'H -021411 ',I J' CCiI'fMONWEA!.TH OF" PENNS'fLVANIA I ':nUNTY ',)J." 1~IJI1Bl':RLANr' 11 rr""LJ;i'EX TOWNSH t.P OF" " V5, 10HNSEN GARY G ET AL ..11ll.QIH:L REIT: CUMBERLAND Coun t >', Penn:sy Ivan ia, who ~(1 law, says, the '<I1thin COI1F:b..HNT - upan JOHNSEN JASMINE J . Sheriff or Deput.y Sheriff of beinQ duly sworn accordln~ EQUITY was 3.rvwd th~? d'?Il?rl'jant, :ai: 85710'4l HOURS, '.'n t.he !6t.h day of !t9,Y.!i'!'.!.~~~L.,..... ., ~, 192~ at. 2: SOUTH LETORT DRIVE I~:.^.R:..!:::LE. fA 1701..;1_ Count.v, P"nnsylvanl-a, b'" handln\) . CUMBERLAN['...m, , t.o JULIE A. JOHNSEN MOTHER OF ~-----~---,---,.. :U;:l'll.t/r::_~!.QHNS~1L-._____, a t.ru~ ~nd att.ested copy ot t.he CQnfLAINT - EQUITY togE.'t.her with QB.I>J;li..._ PETITION. TO JOII:! AQQ1.TIONAL PERSON Q.[E~l~~ol~L.__. _.._.__._____.__, ._-~_., AS PARTY._u ....' ._-_.~-' an,j i]t. ~;ht'-" sam.:: t.l.mllEt d.lrectlrlg H~.L at.t.entl.()n tL"' thp. cont~nf ~i t.h~n?l;)t. ~t"~rii['.~ ~o~t,~. ~ .. r'f)~:- ;';I?t: inQ'" .'. . SeJ. \'leE' Ai! 11!avlt SIJrt:'haI'~.H" So answers: 18.01/1 ~I'"'~ :::. 81/1 r ~_____ Z: &~ fr." Thome:"K7~~~- -l2':;:'P.:G\. ':~NELBAKER AND BRENNEMAN : 1 ! J "1 I 1 "":'15 -- bY.sf:. .~~. SW':'l'r) ;:tr:",1 ~H'~ ='0:-: lClE'.j tl;1 b~~t~lr.:> "11': . h:.1 d:,:: .~.. f ! '3 10\. f.. Fl- .~ +: ~:I' ~ r.'" t, ;-l'j "i'-" .- EXHIUIT II ",'1 i'" .1 " ,f', " , ,I, '." , Ii" lliri d, :':1 ,'t:! , , , " " " " I " d I, ",II " , " ':,'1.'.'1'.' I' " ',: , '. . 1,l;;"J,'j' ::,),1 \';';';f'.'I,: :' ":11 I ' I "!",I"I;' ,I",' ",,11"":\, " ,I" II, , .. ~ ri ;_:~~\ ,!i' 'Jllj '.,1' 1 I,' '(' :,';1. '" " ," I" , , 'ij 'II" I' " '!' { ,'I' {',''II I,' , " , , , '. ,I, " " ',:' I,r; f"J,1 '>!'I !i I. 113 " " " " .';; '., ;\j I,' ", I." p', "/'1.. " , ,', ':1-1 ! ." "',i" ',lIVI :,' ", "jl [Jf;L "I l,',~ ;,1,1':' " " t.AW o.l~~II:1 " f;1,.., IIIAlt:t If " DnI'Nt'H'MMI - TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, Plaintiff, I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA I I NO. 94-4119 EQUITY TERM I I I CIVIL ACTION - EQUITY I I vs. GARY G. JOHNSEN, JULIE A. JOHNSEN and JASMINE J. JOHNSEN, Detendants PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT DIRECTED TO ~J. JOHNSEN AND NOW, comes TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, Plaintiff, by its Attorneys, SNELBAKER , BRENNEMAN, P.C., and avers the following cause of action in equitYI 1. The Plaintiff herein is TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, a municipal township of the second cla.. located in Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, having its municipal office at J50 North Middlesex Road, Carlisle, PA 17013. 2. The Defendants herein are GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, husband and wife, and their daughter, JASMINE J. JOHNSEN, adult individuals, whose last known addresses are 22 South Letort Drive, Middlesex Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. 3. The original Complaint in this action was filed on or about July 25, 1994. At that time, the Defendants were Gary G. Johnsen and Julie A. Johnsen. Defendants are the owners and are in possesslon of the premises known and numbered as 22 South Letort DrivQ located in the Township of Middlesex, County of Cumberland and Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, as more fully ,. LAW O"'ICEB SNELFJAKI:::R II BlltE:NNI!:MAN described in a certain deed from Edward R. and Carol A. stover to Defendants dated March 25, 1985, and recorded on the same date in the Office of the Recorder of Deeds in and for cumberland County, pennsylvania, in Deed Book "E", Volume 31, Page 42 et seq., which description is incorporated herein by reference thereto (hereinafter called "Subject Premises"). The principal building on said subject Premises is a single-family detached dwelling house. By deed dated February 15, 1995, Defendants Gary G. Johnsen and Julie A. Johnsen purported to grant and convey the subject premises to Julie A. Johnsen and Jasmine J. Johnsen, as joint tenants with right of survivorship. Said deed was recorded on May 1, 1995 in Deed Book 121, Page 554 in the Office of the Recorder of Deeds in and for Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. 4. plaintiff enacted a land use/zoning ordinance known as "Middlesex Township Zoning ordinance" as ordinance No. 3-89 on June 30, 1989, the provisions of which ordinance are incorporate herein by reference thereto (hereinafter called "Zoning ordinance"). 5. commencing at divers times prior to May 4, 1994, the Defendants have caused or permitted the following acts to occur on or about the subject premises: A. Disposed of trash by discarding the same on the subject premises causing it to spread on the properties of others in the residential neighborhood in which the subject Premises is located. 2 I.^W Ol'I'ICUI SN[LIJAKE.~ & BRENNEM^N B. storage or placement of three unlicensed and/or inoperable motor vehicles in the front yard of the subject premises. c. Placement and maintenance of a semi-trailer for storage purposes in the front or side yard cloeer to the adjoining street than any portion of the dwelling house erected on the subject premises. 6. The foregoing acts or uses set forth in paragraph 5, sunra constitute violations of the zoning ordinance in the following respects (the following subparagraphs being identified by corresponding letters to the subparagraphs in paragraph 5): A. section 14.17A which prohibits use of any land which discharges or disperses solid waste which adversely affects the surrounding area, or which causes annoyance or disturbance to any of the surrounding properties or to their owners or occupants, or which is unwholesome and may be prejudicial to health and general welfare. B. section 14.17F which prohibits the parking, storage or placement of unlicensed motor vehicles for more than thirty days on any exterior premisea (except within a licensed junk yard). C. section 14.01A which prohibits the placement of any accessory structure on any lot which projects nearer to the street on which the principal building fronts than such principal building. -3- 7. written notice of the above violations was delivered to the Defendants by personal service upon Defendant Julie A. Johnsen on or about May 4, 1994. 8. Defendants have failed and refused to comply with the notice aforesaid and the cited provisions of the Zoning Ordinance. 9. Defendants have failed to remove the three motor vehicles mentioned in paragraph 5B hereinabove. 10. Efforts to encourage compliance with the Zoning Ordinance have been rejected by Defendants. Defendants, through Defendant Julie A. Johnsen, protest, inter alia, that they do not have funds with which to comply. 11. Based upon the statements cited in paragraph 10 above, the Plaintiff believes that its remedies via civil penalty would be futile, leading to a multiplicity of actions and that the violations would continue. I.AW Ol"lICIlII SNIlL19AKI!:.R a BAE:NNIMI\N 12. Plaintiff has no adequate remedy at law. 13. Equitahle relief is needed to obtain actual compliance with the Zoning Ordinance in order to protect and preserve the welfare and common good of the citizens of Middlesex Township. 14. Following the filing and service of a Petition to Join Additional Person as Party Defendant, a Rule was issued to show cause why Jasmine J. Johnsen should not be added as a party Defendant. By Order of Court dated December 13, 1995, Jasmine J. Johnsen was joined as a Defendant in this action. -4- . , 15. The prior pleadings in this case consisting of a Complaint, a Petition For Extension, and Plaintiff'. Answer to Defendant's Petition For Extension are attached hereto as Exhibit. A, Band C, respectively, and are incorporated herein by reference thereto. 16. Trial is scheduled in this case for February 1, 1996 at 9:00 A.M. in Courtroom No.5, Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle, Pennsylvania before the Honorable J. Wesley Oler, Jr. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests your Honorable Court to: A. Enjoin Defendants from discharging solid waste, storing unlicensed and/or inoperable motor vehicles and placement of accessory structures in prohibited areas on the Subject Premises; B. Order and direct Defendants to abate the continuing violation of the Zoning Ordinance by removing all trash from the exterior of the Subject Premises, remove all unlicQnsed and/or inoperable motor vehicles from the Subject Premises and remove the semi- trailer storage structure from the prohibited area of the SUbject Premises; C. Order and direct Defendant. to obey the Zonin9 Ordinance; L-AW O","ICII:II SN!LEI^KE:~ III BR[NNIrMAN -5- VERIFICATION I, Frank Gall, Middlesex Township Zoning Officer, do declare and state: that I am authorized to make this verification on behalf of the Plaintiff, that the facts set forth in the foregoing Complaint which ace within my personal knowledge are true and correct, and as to those based upon information received from others, I believe to be true and correct. I understand that false statements made herein are subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. S4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. Dated: January It; , 1996 (J LAW O"ICIUI $NlEl.rJAK!R (!o BRENNEMAN . . . , .,.w omell SNI~.AKU . IUI<NIMAN TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, plaintiff, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS or CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 94- ~ /I'i CIVIL TERM vs. GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, I I I I CIVIL ACTION - EQUITY Def.ndants COMPLAINT AND NOW, comes TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, Plaintiff, by its Attorn.ys, SNELBAKER' BRENNEMAN, P.C., and avers the following cause of action in equity: 1. The Plaintitf her.in i. TOWNSHIP or MIDDLESEX, a municipal townShip ot the .econd cla.s located in cumb.rland County, p.nnsylvania, bavinq it. municipal offic. at 3S0 North Middl..ex Road, Carli.le, PA 17013. 2. The Osfandant. h.rein are GARY G. JOIllfSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, husband and wif., .dult individual., who.. last known .ddr....s are 22 South Letort Driv., Middle..x Town.hip, Cumberland county, Pennsylvania. 3 . D.fendants are the owner. and are in po.....ion of the premi.e. known and numbered a. 22 South Letort Driv. located in the Town.hip of Middl.sex, County of cumberland and Commonwealth ot Penn.ylvania, as acre fully d..cribed in a certain d.ed :&om Edward R. and Carol A. stover to D.fendant. dated March 2S, 1985, and recorded on the same date in the Otfic. of the R.corder ot D.eds in and for cumberland county, Penn.ylvania, in D.ed Book "E", Volume 31, Page 42 et .eq., which description i. Page 2 uf 7 . incorporated herein by reference thereto (hereinatter called "Subject prui.es"). orbe principal buildinq on said SUbject premises i. a .inqle-fuily detached dwellinq hou.e. 4. Plaintiff enacted a land u.e/zoning ordinance known ae "Middle.ex Town.hip Zoning Ordinance" as Ordinance No. 3-89 on June 30, 1989, the provisions of which ordinance are incorporated herein by reference thereto (hereinafter called "zoninq Ordinance"). 5. commencinq at divers times prior to May 4, 1994, the Oetendants have caused or permittsd the tollowinq acts to occur on or about the SUbject pruises: A. Dispo.ed of tra.h by discarding tho same on the subject pruises causing it to spread on the properties of others in the re.idential neiqhborhood in which the SUbject prubes i. located. B. storage or placement of three unlicen.ed and/or inoperable motor vehicles in the front yard of the Subject premises. c. Placuent and maintenance of a semi-.trailer LAW 0'''"11 'N&~.AK&II . '"&NN&MAN for storage purposes in the tront or side yard closer to the adjoininq street than any portion of the Qwellinq house erected on the Subject Premises. 6. The foregoing acts or uses set forth in paragraph 5, SUDra constitute violations of the Zoning Ordinanc. in the fOllowing respects (the following sUbparagraphs being identified by corresponding letters to the subparagraphs in paragraph 5): -2- l); \...: l' \' ~ , " " LAW aWtCII SNI~.AICIIt . SltlNNIMAN A. Section 14.17A which probibit. uae ot any land which discharqes or di.persa. eolid waste which adversely atfects the .urroundinq area, or which cau.a. annoyance or disturbance to any ot the .urroundinq properties or to their owners or occupants, or which i. unwholesome and may be prejudicial to health and qeneral weltare. 8. Section 14.17F which prohibits the parkinq, .torage or placement ot unlicenaed motor vehicles tor more than thirty days on any exterior premi.es (except within a licensed junk yard). c. Section 14.0lA which prohibita the placement of any accessory structure on any lot which projects nearer to the atreet on which the principal buildinq tronts than such principal buildinq. 7. Written notice ot the above violation. wa. delivered to the Oefendants by personal .ervice upon Detandant Julie A. John.en on or about May 4, 1994. 8. Detendants have failed and refused to comply with the notice afor.said and the cited proviaions ot the Zoninq Ordinance. 9. Detendants have tailed to remove the three motor vehicles mentioned in paraqraph 58 hereinabove. 10. Ettorts to encourage compliance with the Zoning Ordinance have been rejected by Oetendant.. Detendant., throuqh Defendant Julie A. Johnsen, protest, inter alia, that they do not -3- P:ll'.l' '. ut -; . '. YW omell IN_AKE" . ."INNEMAN have fund. with which to comply. 11. Baled upon the .tatement. cited in paragraph 10 above, the Plaintiff believes that its remedie. via civil penalty would be futile, leading to a multiplicity of action. and that the violations would continue. 12. plaintitt has no adequate remedy et law. 13. Equitable reliet is needed to obtain actual compliance with the Zoning Ordinance in order to protect and pre.erve the welfare and common good of tt.e citizen. of Middle.ex Town.hip. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully reque.t. your Honorable Court to: A. Enjoin Defendants from discharqinq solid wa.te, storing unlicen.ed and/or inoperable aotor v.nicle. and plac..ent ot acc...ory structure. in prohibited areas on the Subject Premise.; B. Order and direct Defendants to abate the continuinq violation ot the Zoninq Ordinance by removinq all trash from the exterior ot the Subject premi.e., remove all unlicensed and/or inoperable motor vehicles from the Subject premi.e. and remove the semi- trailer storage structure from the prohibited area of the Subject premi.e.; C. Order and direct Defendants to obey the Zoninq ordinance; D. Order and direct Defendants to pay the co.ts of this action and plaintiff'. expen.e. of enforcement -4- I\Jge 'j lit ; . .' ~~I'\shjpcf f\1 ~Jd (,ps'"Y f 1"\;-1'"1 +'-ff ~ VS. k t$..("'~ G\..:1O h l"I.te"/'" ...../i'e.. , Joh..,~-- D ef~""JAA. f r 1:1'\ -f"o:!' c:'V.rTdF~M~}/~'9S () f LGo.. ~be r la-J. au~ Pc... No. 14 - 4-1 , ~ I CIV i t- A-cr fa-v-. A- -t + e ....t-il1"'l'- : T rer"'''e.:s+ +c 'fe..+, +/~ +{,.e Cd W.,... ~ (" a..V\ e 'f. f-e "S I~ d f 30 cAa.. '-(S I ^ 0\""0(<:> r .-fa CC'M..f' 17 ~ "1;w ~k 'f of MI'-J~ J e~.>< o r J.T'r\...~ '" c~. , tv. ~ e s~e J... kc.L.S '" a""4 ot,~5 no+- res ~ ,?.:r 2-'2... $', Le~r+ Dr, 0..,,). he I~ wltl,; '}'t"W %('~ /a..wye y +l&~,d ~/~rcj)o IA..S Tr:1 5t~'Y\ 4l\..(( a...u..-to YIAOL., fe-s ~ \fer -to !Me.... 'H.r~ Ih4A s~ T ,~ #~e ~ +,+Ie -Jo ~ () ~ ~k Y Ar d- A.",{ / ~ a. J{ y f'e W\ e..J...i y>Y'c ~ I eH.< ::H f. 1'1\.lJ..-S J w7/1 c~fl'1 b'1 Sep-f // tC;q'/- , G,~r'1 C;, JD k~..s e '^ j'/-\.s'/:S + e.J. :r oI.~ ~ II -H'\~.S', -r-r",- t^ $ .-..c +~....r rYt # .,J-d.../' r ~ 0 )'I." -f- }c.n cr-w .. INk '1 k CA- +a.f'+<- r ('t eo #( r L'M lYv"" 111"d- -f... .3" c:t. ( (j)A.." wi#.. h. /:S d l' Va r c~ I ~ uJ 7'E> r f,.. 'cI. 0 ~a A (S' 0 ~ '1 er-.) 0 { A-4 L-l- s i- .J- r::~, / > e-f + It. fya..?e {~ u 0 e v IA.I ., / / Co s -f Yk...C..! $/0 Ci ' ~?' --hJ L ~ f7 -/7; re#'Vl..a Ve A... (( .{?fi (~S 5 6 c.A:fer -{-7--A....SA 01 u f' ~ C~ K~ CcwM..f UJJ Wa 5ie TV-. d i- --;-r, Re 1- ~ eJe I' W ,5 +"0 [" c;J.4A... ~ e .so / V ~d.. . ' (V'- 6 yet 5 5 r s t. u..:f ~cc c-~ ~ -fa . \'~ ~fcA;f 1m....... ttr-....~ ~ + -f~6 k;: 'It 2<50 ' /:J 0 1?:J d..d"ff.M. ~A. M OV\ ) ,-,:} "'-$i ,.. +j f,-evv- 5 I .ocl-e ~ rJ ~ of e rJ tA-f+e r: .2J:, v.eO..[> ~e('VIC~ ~ ,....,u., 4cj ver:~,....eJ, -r aW'- pi -f6/0..,.... &.~s er t1^o....\.'\.IC _J~ ~ss rV(' J If VIe 5.s t-flqSh'i twi"k'S[)':Sea..S~ EXHIBIT B (PaRe 2 or _) . ';'7 tI (?Vf!? V" ~ <It.. I' 01.. :C. ,N c-u.( J Y\O"" c~fLy., 'l'A.'1 c IiI Jr eJ'. a.-,o.."z r !\..,..d- -k. ~ >-& ~ "'1 ~ 3 ct...d.- 'T. "e r h ,- /7 -It I J.. ~ T W I { I C 6V'/o..- f /; T (' .:L. ~ eN-- {r pe rp:1' /4A-. ,""'r\ 5 ( ~ I'\A~ vlfl e , I ;:-- a ,v.... +r e;cf--eJ. j, '1 ~ . ~+e.Ve4^ ':; -I- VA ",,:,\c;+r. '"ft.., c.l---,yo/ ,Kkd Ie {ILQ. ~ L I ~f-k.-~ tcr S'-/-ela. z..,....I\~ ~ 0 T C L0- C67^-~o ( ~ s e ~ ~ {t--, L..( ~ ~o-W .rz, d-6 ~ ~~ J.s. AS keJ , M t.-f C CJ2.S e IN a (' /::::;€_ ,. -/er-U ~ s /)1. c e 41r:=> r tll-r:s ~ -h:J lAJ c r'D7 .k b ~ 'j- t fo/y- J C eu.l 5 e erf "'I 1- ~ ~ ( J. re" , elr 2/.L4 r ~ ~ ~ .J-C I tr~ W a- 5 ivU: P CJI' f-ct-.,J- i-o /Lee f '::1' N ~-tR ,,-.p...t. (' b eo, "(J "'" "'- s e 7j u.r '--- V1^-eJ. I c.. I "e . 13 c c- 00--<-\.. S. c... ~ f ~ t'\ e w .s -po... f' e. r A.,vvl l' e f' tr r+~ 'I" L...e c ~ ~.-fj ~ iI\S c..<.tCv\ Ct Cc>-"'f. ~ ,{ r~ f-d """'-'" Ni.L . /0.......... ~ -1-0 gee /C.. kY'LL c" v.-A~ ( I tLr-.ol yL, S ~ 'h...';-r, f [",-, t-c k.ee p -e V' E'r l~:]''' ~. ~ JGy~ qf:!J ha.c~ i-n SG ~ I~ ~.s~ +-e.a.1 f' e~cd.)f-;"'~ f s ...s~o l~~ r~ ~ r +I~..s -f-Jv- +-e.d ~ ! ~ r f ~. ~.. -1-, J. C'" ;( -4.--s ~ /..u ~ 1/ h. e.I <-. 0'+t-Jeefc /qet./L C~CI"'( [dY1-1.f1 ~ ,&o-d l><-a_NI <hv---- "'7 e M';f-l-.~.,..j, ''''_ '1 ~~ . 'k. v<-l f/: ......s IV € ! I <1..1 M e .....+..../' ~ /l!i? r <- 4J V't?- l-telfJ ~f'1d. f/!(7-''/y, FZ~ /~~f...... ~ 1:sS~ ~ ~ $'~~ c~ ~ ~J;.J, ~ --r, tJh.-;-l)/'Vt 've r~ ,~~~ ,r..(I...~~~ ;~J. ,~as - / Ji) ~ i1 sfY'... k (;e;t'-.Tb-f(/l~ EXHIBIT D (Page 3 of ~) . ';:..' ~+Ck~J . J ~ S-/z;:;l-e ",......,.1 .. "1LL, I.J, / <J "1 )~~ +0 itv.- livv..iM +/VV\L t'vvJ. . vvve-t~ ~f 5~ifl C~. vJ~/e c{n/V\.rl;~~ b~ ~~-t~ -bJ ~"'r c~I/~ ,tM-~nr: 54 a-J T ~ '}'yu}(t!-/.- --b a-~t:hi ~-li! 0/ t 1??l ~. 'J-I; Ifff; JZ IMM -b u/!Je. )~ If' 7 M'-f /-r7~h... -b r-f -I~. ~ . y/k1~ Lfi:l~A ~, EXHIBIT B (page 4 or 4l CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, RICHARD C. SNELBAKER, ESQUIRE, hereby certify that I have, on the below date, caused a true and correct copy ot the toregoing Answer to petition to be served upon the person and in the manner indicated below: rrRST CLASS MAIL. POSTAGE PREPAID. ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS: Julie A. Johnsen 22 South Letort Drive Carlisle, PA 17013 <.ok~/ R - r C. Sne er, Esqu re SNELBAKER , BRENNEMAN, P. C. 44 We.t Main street P. O. Box 318 Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 (717) 697-8528 Attorneys for plaintiff Township ot Middlesex /' ate: September 2, 1994 LAW O'''C'' SNILIIAKIPI 6 ."INNIMAN EXijIBIT C (PAge 3 at 3) .' LAW O'''l~.rll SNlELflAK[1't III eAINNI:MAN . . CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, PHILIP H. SPARE, ESQUIRE, hereby certify that I have, on the below date, caused a true and correct copy of the foregoing Plaintiff's Complaint Directed to Jasmine J. Johnsen to be served upon the persons and in the manner indicated below: FIRST CLASS MAIL. POSTAGE PREPAID. ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS: Julie A. Johnsen Gary G. Johnsen 22 South I,etort Drivo CarliSle, PA 17013 Jasmine J. Johnsen 22 South Letort Drive Carlisle, PA 17013 ~'YJ{I/) ~ 1 :.{il vX ~. p P lip H. pare, Esquire SNELBAKER , BRENNEMAN, P' c. 44 West Main Street P' O. Box 318 Mechanicsburg, pA 17055 (717) 697-8528 Attorneys for Plaintiff Township of Middlesex Date: January 16, 1996 . . III::/i 11'1; . , Ii I': 11'1111 III II 1','111111. '~A:"r.: H'') I !"'.J.l. _).1 II 'J I ClnIWINWI:ALTII OF J't:rHl:,;YL'I^,~ f" I ';CIUNTY 1.1F ',UNI1EI~I,MW , ' Mtlllll~E::':I-::< '1"JW.w:nIlP OF' V:":.i. IOlllj:,:F.N GilJiY r:, !';T 1\1" _B. Thqmf\tJI5J ~..rH.I , ~;:lll-i'J" I.t1, wi'll] bL'l.rlLl du 1'1 :dWl1\'n ucc(lr'I.:/tno t.ll ldw, ~:,dyn, t.hill t\l:l fl).':,tJ.-} ,'j dll.l.qlfnt~ Lil-_'arl.~h dnd J.flql)lry flJl- I:hl:! withlrl """",01 ,j,..r"",J,,,,,. I CI 1/11 I,IUJIN:.ir-:(I. JMil'll(W I 1J1.ll W:\o.:i unab LI";' t.() Lt:.ca(,,7 11,1'1 llf hl~:; IJi;jtllw.lt..:h. , 11lf t;h0J'~for~ ruturns Ih~ CaNP~^JVT- EOUlTY .-.J tlOT FUlJtlli ;.'1;.:; ",0 1..'11.' \.'J(hJ.(1 n._ll\l,.~,j ,Jt;'!":.'n,.l,lrll JOIINSF.I~ JA::;.l'fI (II~ DEF.EtlJ'AllyqVE:3 ilT.. ::'o'LillJlI!DTI]N FA l?h'l'J, . ~JT,_.J. HA.Rp: I::;I1U,,'i, '=;; h ~:~ J I. J 1 ' .~' ,(; '-1 ;~:, t., lei : [luck,.:.' t'lllll :::" ,~; r '/ J. l~: 12 1\ f.t l.d;J'/l.. I: :~l\) J <;hd r'q':.J ~:;i (I :In;-::,'t/;J;~! r 18. (%, .:. ,1},lil . lJl{) ,;2.l:h) r.J l...~~'~t ,""(~ 'TlllJ lIi;j'~;' 'J{ r rn;~~; >,..;::. '~::;h-f~;i;i'f ["i':'" _.l...._ 1=~,8G SNELQAKI-:R ANr BRENNEMAN v.':'l/l,'.~r/ L(7'I"J"~, ::JWIJr\'l ;][Jd r.~UJ:.,~t::l~ It;c,J t'_lii !;HfIJJ'':: liW' 1.1, J' , l'l!c ,.1 H 'I ':I t i. t~'."'tj 1 '.1 '1 (.. I, , L', .t- ii')..' .', . . - c .;.._ . h..l(......,u. J 1 'rnl'.tlnrlutdl'V l'i . vs. I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA I I NO. 94'-4119 EQUITY TERM I I TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, plaintiff , GARY G. JOHNSEN, JULIE A. JOHNSEN and JASMINE J. JOHNSEN, CIVIL ACTION - EQUITY Defendants PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT DIRECTED TO JASMINE J. JOHNSEN AND NOW, comes TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, Plaintiff, by its Attorneys, SNELBAKER' BRENNEMAN, P.C., and avers the following cause of action in equity: 1. The Plaintiff herein is TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, a municipal township of the second class located in Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, having its municipal office at 350 North Middlesex Road, CarliSle, PA 17013. 2. The Defendants herein are GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. I..AW o".tCU $NII.I!IAI<IR III SIUNNIMAN JOHNSEN, husband and wife, and their daughter, JASMINE J. JOHNSEN,adult individuals, whose last known address.s are 22 South Letort Drive, Middlesex Township, Cumberland county, pennsylvania. 3. The original Complaint in this action was fil.d on or about July 25, 1994. At that time, the Defendants were Gary G. Johnsen and Julie A. Johnsen. Defendants are the owners and are in pos~ession of tne premises known and numbered as 22 South Letort Drive located in the Township of Middlesex, County of Cumberland and Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, as more fully , LAW OI""ICIU SNILBAKIEPI & BRENNEMAN described in a certain deed from Edward R. and carol A. stover to Defendant. dated March 25, 1985, and recorded on the same date in the Office of the Recorder of Deeds in and for cumberland county, Pennsylvania, in Deed Book "E", Volume 31, page 42 et seq., which description is incorporated herein by reference thereto (hereinafter called "subject premises"). 'l'he principal building on said subject premises is a single-family detached dwelling house. By deed dated February 15, 1995, Defendants Gary G. Johnsen and Julie A. Johnsen purported to grant and convey the subject premises to Julie A. Johnsen and Jasmine J. Johnsen, as joint tenants with right of survivorship. Said deed was recorded on May 1, 1995 in Deed Book 121, Page 554 in the Office of the Recorder of Deeds in and for cumberland county, Pennsylvania. 4. plaintiff enacted a land use/zoning ordinance known as "Middlesex Township Zoning ordinance" liS Ordinance No. 3-89 on June 30, 1989, the provisions of which ordinance are incorporate herein by reference thereto (hereinafter called "Zoning Ordinance"). 5. commencing at divers times prior to May 4, 1994, the Defendants have caused or permitted the following IIcts to occur on or about the subject premises: A. Disposed of trash by discarding the same on the subject premises causing it to spread on the properties of others in the residential neighborhood in which the Subject Premises is located. 2 B. storage or placement of three unlicensed and/or inoperable motor vehicles in the front yard of the subject premises. c. Placement and maintenance of a semi-trailer for storage purposes in the front or side yard closer to the adjoining street than any portion of the dwelling house erected on the subject premises. 6. The foregoing acts or uses set forth in paragraph 5, SUDra constitute violations of the Zoning ordinance in the following respects (the following subparagraphs being identified by corresponding letters to the subparagraphs in paragraph 5): A. Section 14.17A which prohibits use of any land which discharges or disperses solid waste which adversely affects the surrounding area, or which causes annoyance or disturbance to any of the eurrounding properties or to their owners or occupants, or which is unwholesome and may be prejudicial to health and general welfare. LAW O"ICIS SN[l.laAl(lta/t eo S"INNftMAN B. Section 14.17F which prOhibits the parking, storage or placement of unlicensed motor vehicles for more than thirty days on any exterior premises (except within a licensed junk yard). c. Section 14.01A which prohibits the placement of any accessory structure on any lot which projects nearer to the street on which the principal building fronts than such princip~l building. -3- LAW o"rCII SNIEL.BAKEFt II BRENNEMAN 7. written notice of the above violation. was delivered to the Defendants by personal service upon Defendant Julie A. Johnsen on or about May 4, 1994. 8. Defendants have failed and refused to comply with the notice aforesaid and the cited provisions of the Zoning ordinance. 9. Defendants have failed to remove the three motor vehicles mentioned in paragraph 5B hereinabove. 10. Efforts to encourage compliance with the Zoning Ordinanoe have been rejected by Defendants. Defendants, through Defendant Julie A. Johnsen, protest, inter alia, that they do not have funds with which to comply. 11. Based upon the statements cited in paragraph 10 above, the Plaintiff believes that its remedies via civil penalty would be futile, leading to a multiplicity of actions and that the violations would continue. 12. plaintiff has no adequate remedy at law. 13. Equitable relief is needed to obtain actual compliance with the zoning Ordinance in order to protect and preserve the welf.are and common good of the citizens of Middlesex Township. 14. Following the filing and service of a petition to Join Additional Person as Party Defendant, a Rule was issued to show cause why Jasmine J. Johnsen should not be added as a party Defendant. By Order of Court dated December 13, 1995, Jasmine J. Johnsen was joined as a Defendant in this action. -4- LAW U"ICU SNILBAI<E.. a S"ENNI:MAN ! 15. The prior pleadings in this Qase consisting of a Complaint, a Petition For Extension, and Plaintiff's Answer to Defendant's Petition For Extension are attached hereto as Exhibits A, Band C, respectively, and are incorporated herein by reference thereto. 16. Trial is scheduled in this case for February 1, 1996 at 9:00 A.M. in Courtroom No.5, Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle, pennsylvania before the Honorable J. Wesley Oler, Jr. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests your Honorable Court to: A. Enjoin Defendants from discharging solid waste, storing unlicensed and/or inoperable motor vehicles and placement of accessory structures in prohibited areas on the Subject Premises; B. Order and direct Defendants to abate the continuing violation of the Zoning Ordinance by removing all trash from the exterior of the Subject Premises, remove all unlicensed and/or inoperable motor vehicles from the SUbject Premises and remove the semi- trailer storage structure from the prohibited area of the SUbject Premises; C. Order and direct Defendants to obey the Zoning Ordinance; -5- D. Order and direct Defendants to pay the costs of this action and Plaintiff'S expenses of enforcement herein, including Plaintiff's reasonable attorney's feee; and E. Order and direct such other and further reliet as the Court shall determine to just and proper. N, P.C. By C. Sne a er 44 West Main street Mechanicsburg, PA 17055-0318 Attorney. tor Plaintiff -6- " . Dehndant. I I I I I I I I IN TRE COURT or COMMON PLEAS or ctJHBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA " ~,.w NO. 94- .J/lh IE. TERN TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, Plaintiff, v.. GARY Q. JOHNSEN and JOLIE A. JOHNSEN, CIVIL AC'l'ION - EQUITY NOTIC! You have been aued in court. If you wiah to detend aqain.t ~. clatm. .et torth in the tollowinq page., you .uat take action within Oienty (20) daya atter thi8 Coaplaint and Kotic. are .arved, by entering a written appearance p.r.onally or by attorney and filing in writing with a court your deten.e. or objection. to the claima .et forth aqain.t you. You are warned that it you tail to do .0 the ca.. uy proceed without you and a jud9lllent may be entered aqainat you by the court without tvrther notice tor any money claimed in the COIIplaint or tor any other claim or relief requa.ted by the Plaintiff. You..y lo.e money or property or other riqbta important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE TRIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYD AT OKCI. IF YOU DO KaT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD OK!, GO TO OR TELEPHONE TRE OFFICE SET rORTH BELOIf TO rIND OCT IfIIERE YOU CAN QET LEGAL HELP. Court Admini.trator One courtbou.e Square Carliale, PA 17013-3387 (717) 240-6200 SN , P.C. By EXHIBIT A Page 1 of 7 loA. omell .Ha-...UR . IRENNEMAN ", ,,,,.j ..... Omell SN&~.AlCl" . I"INNIMAN TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, plaintiff, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF cmlBERLAHD CODNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 94- ~ /1'1 CIVIL TERM I I I vs. GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, I I I I CIVIL ACTION - EQUITY D.tendent. COMPLAINT AND NOW, com.. TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, Plaintiff, by its Attorn.y., SNELBAKER' BRENNEMAN, P.c., and .vers the followinq cau.e of .ction in equity: 1. The Plaintiff herein i. TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, a municipal town.hip of the .econd cla.. loc.tad in CUmberland County, pennlylvania, having it. municipal office at 3~O North Middle.ex Road, Carlisl., PA 17013. 2. Th. D.fendants herein are GARY G. JOHNSEN and JULIE A. JOHNSEN, hu.band and wife, adult individual., who.e l..t known .ddr..... are 22 South Letort Drive, Middl..ex Town.hip, cumb.rland County, Pennsylvania. 3 . Defendants are the owners and are in po...ssion ot the prllJllis.s known and numbered a. 22 South Latort Drive locatad in the Township of Middlesex, County of cumberl.nd and Commonw.alth ot pennsylvania, as more fully d..cribed in . cartain dee~ ~&om Edward R. and Carol A. Stover to Det.ndant. dat.d March 2~, 1985, and record.d on the sama date in the Offic. of the Recorder of Oe.ds in and tor cumberland County, Penn.ylvania, in Deed Book "E", Volume 31, paqe 42 .t s.q., which description is Page 2 uf 7 ~. o"'u. SNI~.AM&IO . SIlINNIMAN incorporated herein by reterence thereto (hereinatter called NSubject premi.e."). The principal buildinq on laid Subject Premi.ea i. a single-tamily detached dWelling house. 4. plaintitf enacted a land u.e/zoninq ordinance known a. "Middle.ex Town.hip Zoninq ordinance" .. Ordinance No. 3-89 on June 30, 1989, the provi.ions ot which ordinance are incorporated herein by reterence thereto (hereinatter called "Zoning ordinance") . 5. Commencing at divers time. prior to May 4, 1994, the Detendants have cau.ed or permitted the following acts to occur on or about th. Subject premis..: A. Di.po..d ot trash by di.card1nq the same on th. subj.ct premis.. causinq it to .pread on the propertie. ot others in the re.idential neighborhood in which the Subject premiae. i. located. B. Storaqe or placement ot thr.. unlicen..d and/or inoperable motor vehicle. in the front yard ot the Subj.ct Premi.... C. Placement and maint.nance of a .ami-trailer for .torage purpo... in the front or aide yard clo..r to the adjoininq .tre.t than any portion ot th. dw.llinq bou.e er.cted on the Subject Premi.... 6. The foregoing act. or u.e. ..t forth in paraqraph 5, suora con.titute violation. of the Zoning ordinance in the followinq respects (the followinq subparagraphs beinq identified by correspondinq letters to the subparaqraphs in paragraph 5): -2- r;l~e , .. .. ,J1; I , " ...W O",..SI INIUAIlIII . IIIINNI"'.N A. Section 14.17A which prohibit. u.e ot any land which di.charqes or di.per.e. .olid va.t. which adver.ely attects the .urroundin; area, or which cau.e. annoyance or disturbance to any ot the surround in; properties or to their owners or occupant., or which is unwhole.ome and may be prejudicial to health and qeneral welfare. B. Section 14.171 which prohibit. the parkinq, .toraqe or placement ot unlicen.ed motor VehiCle. tor more than thirty days on any exterior premise. (except within a licen.ed junk yard). C. Section 14. OlA which prohibits the placement Of any acce..ory .tructure on any lot vhich projects nearer to the .treet on vhich the principal builelinq tronts than .uch principal buildinq. 7. Written notice ot the above violation. va. delivereel to the Detendants by personal .ervice upon Detendant JulieA. John.en on or about May 4, 1994. 8. Detendants hllve tailed and retused to comply with the notice atoresaid and the citeel provi.ion. ot the Zonin9 Ordinance. 9. Detendants have failed to remove the thre. motor vehiclea mentioned in paragraph 5B hereinabove. 10. Efforts to encourage compliance with the zoninq Orelinance have been rejected by Detendant.. Defendants, throuqh Defendant Julie A. Johnsen, protest, inter alia, that thay do not -3- Paec .~ ,)[ ~ . . . . have tund. with which to cOlllPly. 11. Ba.ad upon the ata~emanta cited in paraqraph 10 above, the Plain~ift believe. tha~ it. remedie. via civil penalty'would be futile, leadinq to a multiplicity of action. and that the violation. would continue. 12. Plaintiff ha. no adequate remedy at law. 13. Equitable relief i. n.eded to obtain actual compliance with the Zoning Ordinance in order to protect and pre.erve the welfare and common good of the citizen. of Middle.ex Town.hip. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff re.pectfully reque.t. your Honorable Court to: A. Enjoin Defendants trOll cU.cbarqinq .olid wa.te, .toring unlicensed and/or inoperable motor vehicle. and plac..an~ of acce..ory .tructure. in prohibited area. on the Subject premi.e.; B. Order and direct Defendant. to abate the continuinq violation of the Zoninq Ordinance by raovinq all traah from the exterior of the Subject premi.e., remove all unlicen.ed and/or inoperable motor Vehicle. from the Subject praiae. and remove the .emi- trailer .toraqe .tructure trOll the prohibited area ot the SUbject premi.e.; C. Order and direct Defendant. to obey the Zoninq IoAW omell SNIUAICI" . ."INNIMAN Ordinance; D. Order and direct Detendanta to pay the co.t. ot this action and plaintiff'. expen.e. Of entorcement -4- l'.:)ge 3 ut ; .,' .. , . . . her.in, lncludinq Pl.intiff'. r.a.aRable attorney'. fe.., and I. Order and direct .uch ot:ber and further relief a. the Court .h.ll detlll'llline to be ju.a1: and proper. fIN By c. 8ne er 44 ...1: "in street lIeahaniC8bur9, PA 1701515-0318 A1:1:orneye for Plaintitt ,... oma. aNIlI.U..IN . SIlINNIMAN PSlle 6 uf 7 -15- ., , --r; ~I'\S hip 0 f fYl j'.J..J l,.s-t'Y P I ~"I"\ ~"ff ./' v S , h-,., U) 6.r~ G; ,.JO h n.se,,/,", .....'I...e..., It. ::Jc hl"l Se- D e.fe",J-AA f ~ . 1: '" -i" eo ~ \A ,.. 1" df a..... ttA.,..., }.I~, (Jf ('C4.,,"be,-{--.(~u~ Po. No. q 4- _ 4-1/9 _ I c... C I V; I- .+c. T 1 O'""'v\ fr-t~e "'"*~: T re.lu..e...s.+ -/-0 ffL+i +;-~ ~e Co W"-t- -F:>' a.V\ e )(+-e "'-Sl~ of 30 cAeJ...'1s i^ OY-o(c->r -t?J C~fl 7 +c 1";w ~k,r' of M/'J.J lesex t:J r J.'ll"'\..cv"\ C ~ . . M 1 e s~ e J.. kc..c..S b 0.,,,4 ot,e:-5l'\a-t- res ~ tL-r 2-'2.. S, Le.+er+ Dr, ~rv4 h Ie' I~ wIlli; 1-1c>W ~('~ /4.wye y t{o-V-s ~/~rd j" ~s Ta st3Y\ <'\..(( a...u..~I"\^.OL.i'(es d\{er -k, ~e....f/.."'6-~ A-A-A 'S" 'I {'~ ~~e --/l..A- +,+Ie -+e, ~ (J~r\.kYArd. A.",J.. 1~-,a.Jfy f'erY\e.J..i r-rc~/eH-( ~ f, 11\. v- oS J W ';" /I c 6);tAf 1'1 1, '1 S e p-+ / / {c; q 4- , G~'1 C:;. JO t.. ""oS e '^ i'f1,.s /:S + e.J. :r- 01" 4( II TI,eos, -j-'" A.. ~ $ ~ -f- /tJY1....I' rYt -fa .,d--c!../, T ~ 0 )'\, d -j-. }<n d"W . !AI kilt, v... + a.:{h> y- (1.. e ~ r L' M. tN ,"II,""{} -h, .3 t1 ~ I tn<-.? wit!. h.;-:s d / v ~ r c~ Ie(. v.J ~~r fr 'de ~c A (s 0 ~ 1 e,,) t:J { .4-~ u.. sf-";'" ~~r / C;; e.f+ A -fra. yt. It.~ u Oe V IN., / I Co s -f YkJ.,/ $/0 () I d"()..-fa C ~ '; / -fz; reW\.O Ve A.. (( efi c.~5.s If t.A:fer p-S/1 olu (0 ~ c~ f?j~c~~WaS* (tA.a+- -fc ~i- ~e.Jel W. ~5 +~O (o-iI\ p€ 50 /V'c:.-~ , ' . [r\.- 6 ('.::? 5 5 r s e...u.:+ ^CC~ ~ -!-a .f'~C)...;1,~ t:tY\..A ~+ (~CJ k;: ft~o ' ~ 0 -rz, ~d jtU;of, '.J}JAM OV\ )'-~~l?j ;+J {rcYo^ 51 c~e ~~ 1=:eeJe rJ ~~ ~ V.~.o[> ~ervIC~ --f?; fI.A...<..t GfO ver:n.""e.."";/, T ~W'- ~I -fo lev-- / .......d. 5 e r r1I\a...~ t..le _ J fo'l ~s rS i'v(' , If ~e 5 S ...,. f/q sit I ~ ~ J f) 1-.s~ctS~ EXHIBIT B (Pa~e ~ of 4) . '. 7 h e {" e V"" ~ Ill. 'I ol :r . N c-u.. l ~ Y\ 0 1" C.~f ~ . 1\1\.'1 c"k.; ("At,,-,,- "-"').. T ",-.w.:;f- *' ~~ ~ "'1 ~ 3 &t...d-- T V er b ,- /7 ft {.J. -ff.:--. r w~( I c~fl1 T ca...~ ~C( pe+f'~ ,')<.. S(rnAJ WtA...-rne,. ;;:- a tK +('e_~ },'{ ~ ;;:+-e. Ve4A 15 + VA w-e!- c;+r-, ~ cl-+-:Jo/ , ~ ~ c;-...... ~ L .-t-L.. . -, -f". S'-I-e / '" z. ,'" <:. ~() T CLt^- C~~ ( ~..sel-f ~f~--' c..{~ ~GrW -t-z> d--~ ~ ~ IS I{ S k<2J , M '1 c c;r2.-S e war- k (" 10> W IftA-I2.. S flt c e .c....f"tr? r t1.1-i:s ~ -h:J iN 0 r'il<< ,leb ~ 'jf. IoI-r J c <UA. S e. tfrf. "'7 'I d!~ ( J. re" , e/'r .P-We r tfl ~ ~ -I-C I (r~ w a. 5 I~ P "'" f-ct.-J- i-o fCee I' I.A-f 1Al,'-fR &L~f' beJ'Q ~ t:t.. seiju/'<.... V1^-eJ. ,e.. r f'. e . 'Be c~ S Co- "f ~ y\.ew.s-P~fe.r /Lvvl r e r ~ rt-~ I" L-e c ~ <yo..JU.)J ~ ~ I)\S c..(.f1t..A Ct [""'""'f. '"""";1 J.. "'7 f-J """'.... ~ J.. J.-........ e... +-. gee. /<'. I e:'J CL L C t!r o.J-A'--<- ( I "'-~ 1f.., S ~ h.... ';-,., fL~ to ke~p -e\l'erl~:]""~' ^:I JG'-rf-~ q~ ba..c~ +a ~c- ~ 0 ~.s~ ~1 f' ~ca...;f-,"'--lfx r S.5'o I AAJf~ r~ ~ r+~..sn..J~ ~/~ r-f ~. ;4+ .. -I- , ....5'. ~ ;( +...-....S;-"....., w ;-! / h. e.1 <-. -VN-J'eetc: /"Ojet../L C~ci"( {"~I'! I ,0 .&- d "'-<<-1-'" </7c.J -", "'-7 e ""-(!>- 'f-i-__ /, 'L '1 ,~- 'h.es<-I if "--' we (I d..J /1.1. e '^-~ ~ /1ff:1 tl <-4I 11"...- I,. e! r.. '" r-,... v I I jr"-y. n~ I~};, f-- A-v\. 1sS~ ~ Iurw $~~ C.ez-- ~ ~~. z;:;..Q.., ~ C! t..;-Ut Vt '" e y..... >-;,,(.""2 ,L ^--~ w.e:. ~/;~. .::-z:z. / ,-as' _ I J5A. J1 Sf)-JA-- h lie ;LJ&ft/lS-e'-. EXIlE, l T B (page 3 or II) . CERTXFICATE OF SERVICE I, RICHARD C. SNELBAKER, ESQUIRE, hereby certify that I have, on the below date, caused a true and correct copy ot the foregoing Answer to petition to be served upon the person and in the .anner indicated below: prRST CLASS MAIL. POSTAGE PREPArD. ADDRRBBED AS POLLOWSe JUlie A. John.en 22 Sout.h L.tort Drive Carlisle, PA 17013 . .{~~/ R C. Sne er, Zsqu re SNELBAKBR , BRBIfNBIIAN, P. C. 44 W..t Main Stre.t P. o. Box 318 Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 (717) 697-8528 Attorneys for Plaintiff Township of Middlesex at.: September 2, 1"4 UW O",CII .N.L.AKI~ . S~.NN.MAN IXHIBIT C (PAge 3 at 3) 01"": ' JAil I ( , J I i I .... \D b; r.: f;!i - It~ .. ::) ~y' ~ - - I J~:: ._~. .,- ,--J '" \r.i:;) -I": ~ ~. ('''I''; C ,.,-! Cj, _ n, -,0 :....'I.'l C:;:>, <'- r ~ r' ~ ~ rev' -- .. . ;:Il'i~j I:':: . ~ -, ~,!~ L'l " c 'f.) ::i r;n q " "I I , '1 1 , , , " . . " " .. . v. I I I I I I I I I IN THB COURT OF COMMON PLBAS OF CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PBNNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX, Plaintiff GARY G. JOHNSEN, JULIE A. JOHNSBN, and JASMINE J. JOHNSBN, Defendants NO. 94-4119 BQUITY TBRM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this Zl~Jday of April, 1996, upon consideration of the Petition for Extension filed on behalf of Defendant Julie A. Johnsen, and over the objection of counsel for the Plaintiff, the petition is GRANTED and Defendant is granted an extension of time until May 1/ 1996, for the completion of removal of property and belongings now stored in the yard of the premiseo at 22 South Letort Drive, Middlesex Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. BY THE COURT, J. Wes Richard C. Snelbaker, Esq. 44 West Main Street Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 Attorney for Plaintiff Lindsay Dare Baird, Esq. 37 South Hanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 Attorney for Defendant Julie A. Johnsen Jasmine J. Johnsen 22 South Letort Drive Carlisle, PA 17013 Defendant, Pro Se :re l" o-r"'\'~ I ,~....c. J....; c:\.. il.l'fIH,' , .>, ., , 'ii'i~~ri;II_;'.'I,'(-l,"_;; \,':.,1 ',1'::;1-/1:-,:/",:".. I"'''. ......,.. ,.AM. ........0 TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX. PLAINTIFF : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA : CIVIL ACTION. EQUITY V, GARY G, JOHNSEN. JULIE A. JOHNSEN. AND JASMINE J, JOHNSEN. DEFENDANTS : 94.4119 EaUITY TERM ~DER OF COURT AND NOW, this day of April, 1996, being In receipt of the attlched Petition for Extension which WIS flied by Lindsay Dare Baird, Esq" Attorney for Defendant Julie A. Johnsen, the Court grants In extension of lime until May 1. 1996 for the removal of property snd belongings now stored in the yard of the premises at 22 South Lelort Drive. Middlesex Township, Cumberland County. Pennsylvania, BY THE COURT, J, Wesley Oler, Jr" J, Richard C, Snelbaker, Esq, 44 West Main Street Mechanlcsburg, PA 17055 Attorney for Plaintiff Lindsay Dare Baird, Esq, 37 South Hanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 Attorney for Defendant Julie A, Johnsen Julie S, Johnsen 22 South Letort Drive Clrlisle, PA 17013 Jasmine J, Johnsen 22 South Letort Drive Carlisle, PA 17013 Defendant, Pro Se . GARY G. JOHNSEN, JULIE A. JOHNSEN, and JASMINE J. JOHNSEN, Defendants I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA I I CIVIL ACTION - EQUITY I I I I I 94-4119 EQUITY TERM TOWNSHIP OF MIDDLESEX/ plaintiff v. DECREE NISI AND NOW, this 1st day of February, 1996, upon conaideration of the complaint in equity filed in the above-captioned matter, and following a trial, and it appearing that Defendants Julie A. Johnsen and Jasmine J. Johnsen were served in this matter/ and that Defendant Gary G. Johnsen was not aerved with process/ the Court finds that the premises at 22 South Letort Drive, Middlesex Township, Cumberland county/ Pennsylvania, owned by Julie A. Johnsen and Jasmine J. Johnsen, are in violation of Plaintiff's zoning ordinance with respect to sections 14.17A, 14.17F, and 14.01A, by virtue of the storage of unlicensed automobiles, a semi-trailer, and various items of trash in the yard of the premises, and accordingly, it is ORDERED and DECREED as follows: 1. Defendants Julie A. Johnsen and Jasmine J. Johnsen jointly and severally are enjoined to remove within 60 daya of today's date the three automobiles, semi-trailer, and trash raferred to in testimony in this matter from the aforesaid premiaee. . 2. The said Detendants are directed not to further .tore trash and similar items, including unlicensed vehicles, upon the premises. 3. The said Detendants are directed to notity the owners ot any such property directed to be removed of this Order of Court within 10 days of today's date. 4. In the event that the aforesaid materials and items are not removed trom the aforesaid premises within 60 days of today's date, the plaintiff is authorized to enter upon the premises and remove and dispose oft as it sees tit, the said automobiles, semi-trailer, and trash, and to tile a municipal lien against the property for the costs of doing so without further Order of Court. Nothing herein is intended to prevent the plaintitf trom proceeding with a petition for contempt as an altern~tive or supplementary measure of obtaining relief in the event that the Defendants do not comply with this Order. It is noted that this Order has been entered with the consent of Defendant Julie A. Johnsen through her counsel, and that the Order was dictated in the said Defendant's presence and in the presence of representatives of the Plaintitf. This Decree Nisi shall automatically become a Final Decree, unless post-trial motions are filed by a party in the matter within 10 days of the entry of this Order. , li "".... ..-.. .- .. ...:JumIJ4f. Pl~.IWJOU'~....__ ............ In lhe Colan 01 C_ P1_ 01 ClIIIIlMdud eoa"" 'llIUIIY1\'IIIl& ............__......____..~~g!a!~Jl..._____.. VI. N.), 1)4 -411 9 I:)lUIT'i TDtM ........~...-......_...-_. GAIlY G. JOHNSm JUT,IE A JOHNSEN und ..................L._.__.__.~..._____...._____ CIVIl, Ael'ION - EXJl}IT'i ...................................--....-..... JASMINE J. JOllNSm Defcndimta ._..........._.._-_.~.__.....----.---------.. ........... ....... .. ...... ....................... .._........____.__.___....___...._....~.~~DpADa~.............._..__.................... .. ..l...w~~~,,~_.naJ.r.rJ..f~Ll.te..~.ht:.l;eby,_cot('.r JW.~<lQ,"e_ ,M, At.t.Qn~l,~.LQ~. ....... ~~~.e:!~.~~~L.i~}_~~.~:.~~~~~~J.}p~~~_~~~;~2~~~~~~..S~~~:..._....__....._.._._..... ..................................---..............................---.........................-...-- ._.........__.-...._....................~..........__............................................ .........--------------...........-.............................................................- ..--.....-------.-........ .........-...-..--.....--..... ...................... ......-.-........ To Lawrence E. Welker .......------............-..--------.-... ProdlollOlary ~~.Jl. 19_2~._ ~4t~-tf~ ly-torney for Defendant .--................-----... ,i ,. , .. \., ~....,..~,-,! .. I, , Ilo-i, j :tll 't ~ t i j\ en " - - 1:!I:IJcrF/n: ," ! '" , ..:B . , ( , f!i',', r' ,C ".I'" Ii',,,,y Ial ,., '.-'1 . ~l I -~.i Ilo 'C '... ' , , !"I :1/ ~ .... U.ll1OG ... '... .s u ~ I ''l, Ial . ,I. " J' II'il'f" ~ ~ i < M ' , n,' IlIl .,/, ,';1,', ~ , ~ Ilo '" ~ B , - ~ I - ,. ~ ... , , '" ~ ~ , , ~ ~ ~ .... .", ",I , " ' :4<, '>:! I \if'.' 1,1' . , , , " " , , , i " . . ~. " (fp'rec:i ~ e ,Sf"'" t\-thd c "-',0 , 'f;OJYl5hip 1~1 icld If" 6.-:' ~ :p/o ill f iff v ~ APn () ; ,~)~jG I I' ' t N 'I~'t'_ ~'L1r T o{c;:w--w-''Y/'P/r'Qf i>f 0lvv,~"~'ICt,,..i (eLLA/'ll 'PA, (,. Vi L. lk"r (()N ~..EQ U /T'Y GeJ. {' If t;;; / ,Tu I r t' 1\, 1A S" VI/l i1to J ' .Jc+If\}SEf\J PEfFNDANT~' Yn\l/oN --, -f. ~ 11- - ?/ ( / 1E~(J trY 7FR/VJ ( Cl t'\C=-X1 e f\ s: 'I c~ 1.. ~ . 11 ND tv~u,), "fll':" 4i~1 J.a.'fCJfAp(';L (CJ91, :r -:Ju lie" A ,J~, h (J S (-' n h CIl .. '" i h u -s (' '-"' m r III"' ~ .J (}J ; th t" ~ n I \,1] N (ll ,,(\ n (' ~.:, vi ('\ I q 'i IcrYl of 5;['("7 ia N S 14, 1711) 1~,/7F) !P'ICX IL~, 0111. r ;I'SpC'~#-'<"~ CI.Y1(,~ j u.. VI. t '(" eX ~t h W't' t-..'. ',,1(' P(-f 0.+; \(~ ~ i:-'Ll Ie le'..s .3 I Mo...r(" h I Cf q C, T l(';y,In-;I'\~-.J ctl' f' 'f'ot L") ~ c< n ci +v ct s( o v-. tf.l -pn"'1"'Y'+<' witl- l]"" ((\f\.-Inl'nc,b (r +('~.sC-. fe c -e p-r.... C (e S I .., fl (' r lAc! "'^J (1l I..U a S -~ t"-' re>wo VCl~ .f'l/eY~1 W<"J.s, 0..('vt,a.{J-er". .r cl..H{J'^<-t't'c:~, ti- -h_",(.,-)~'\s.~"i-f rV\€'t"+i'"Tt~) I\p'l(~ -3 ('1~' C<YIA.;r ~v <1., oS C l" \Iv" W"- ,~' v" J~cl -p, r' -.(<~ /1 ~ c.u ",. / l....r ~ V"o{ (trYv\ .p t~, iy\.' ..f 0 C" r el. v\ C' v) ('~, S , ..1- a. Iso ry... a. J e-.. AYra!("l.'7,....\iv,...."'.ts --0~ ,<;;evl,\.i_+rct', I.... V f'1C"k-L'f C'Y' 8 A\')(' 11Cf{" 1/'t:' 'Tc-,(...;,nS'~\ie 9'CI.("rC1'c,~~, .er<-~-e~.J-f->c\ h\{' -tLe t7'/It\.t-' /,Yj,\; +. ~V\ hr-'(" t7 f +k... ('l b ("I v C J n n'\ T:J 'f-'-~ ;-1 i CiYI \ Y\"<r -r A..~ ( C, l H'_ -f -0:_ v C' ,f) t..:(-~_~'~,,?.-:(~:,~~,' of; I I , /V\ Cll ( '1 '7 ~ '{O'l fl" C;t~l.l,~:t(fl\ Il't i f"'fl,\C'Ii rd ~6"'I ""k( I ("-'('(<.o.('.~' S "'f-C'lfC" II (" c. U , l.. I. .1 (r1H'I~.c'.I....,(1 Sf' (1'1+ ;t,1t'lI-J.ill t1tVI1~r- ('of '!(;._r S'q I (I -" l'r ; /t'r I T s.ll'" t C;' ,'.Ic>(V\. J '( n t;; ,) (' L Lt" -C (t-'n S' e-I ,",-c ..,,- r tl ;' I~ r rr("~ h/~'Y' ,S.'/)C-:---t, t" ,,:~ a ~""j~-JI'qbl'f:1 L II _~ ,. ;tl" _":. s: fl,\ n V' ~ tt J II t n~' 1J ~T h ll' V "',' Ci...~ (C' )'- .,. f (I (:~I -, (") e (l <'I }l IVY' ,; '{I"I .<1, n.' t,,,(J /.. 'f /Jet s ,S J ,1 c1 CJ Vl (1'/ I, CI ~ ~ .. tl rl d ~{rJ PCPll I, i W\ +i /I f1vi tt '/ f.) I "( 7 k, 2 I t I 'f" s..rC(-~ _~ .J J u.J', /1 VI 0 -t P r- () - I' n.. f-e.... ('t V\'1 J C( '-I s,/ .:r r f' <"6 I l , r e 'It I ~() . tLQ. cJ r ~ t" W ~ I { Yl C'lT (f->l-yl. (1 \/~' I +, A s j l:J n_~ (T $ =r 'PCUf r-~' ~'l T- /)..~: L,--' ct p i ~ !. + I e C;CI 111"1. he. l{ II A J <; ( (\. ('r' J () LV ph., 1''V'-~f>PI'OX- I /l-1..c<.:>I-.{J LLt 11. / ZO. C'r> rl:{ r,-~.d IL! -r;,r- F":e.G-Y'U(I,r. c:>( V'\A 11/"- ct r (' C" ,S" j n (("-> -f h of-' '" rA t" r +-0 1 r -eWl 0 " ('; t :r LV nl}", A ,-fc, rl P j 0 +t'?-. i ~, -t~ f' r Cl </ VV\ fO ...\. t Sin l y~ I ~I ~ V t' ('lfC-. .... r S" -(-l"-f' Cl ') e-I 1\ ;V ~ LV V " I t ~ . f-~ cc'l- _l t::>CL') 1J 7 -31m" l.~^ Ii/'" LA of 710, 0/""- ~ ~r p d_~-I ~ c' (J -f 1 (V\. a ( -+ 1 r) , '5 ::1 r t' Co l( t<-' S T 'l-l, i S e ,x .{."'T ,... .s ., c+'>-, -h-, . I (1.. V Ci / c.( eti, -I f-' ,0'\ P '-r-./ et I So .-f-() fCl<1 m 7 J f' (, -( I 11 f'L(_'U ~ n I MAY /1 '7 t../ .j~- ~.v j /I p ct l '- ), i rVl 11/ ~ 0 , C' c, if!, y I, i" s reo t' v kc'J', =..1--( ,-t r, j s 1>- ',' 0 -, "X-l<""11 j ....) J l.V~. II t' LlJ e. d.1 ooA ct.f..} {C"' r (fic" b.~", I j ~1 t' C' ~(NJ... tA c"-,' of fa r.,>e ':l c. i^'l-)C1 J~ I L.) "-'d~ .3 tll,-~lf-'" t1. <:J l:'_ (' L, tcJ. t^ f'" / II, I '-II/{' y, (I, J (,(~ ~i(\-f Lei Ml'it'.' .5 '-fe" h If P rt't\ I , . i!; 1I~:..()f 10 11 ^'\ !) A P r 11 c'I'. ~T +r' <",~ +~ r"([ H'iJ,ir" "y-jo'f - "C. f~ a" -/<<.. '1 c:;c<o ,t., 7."~. < i fr !l '" ,t p1 r. (' t,., 'w ,.., ,"<,.t,,,. (> f'" < LJ t,,, A ~" ( "7 s ~ <" 0'''' ~ (' l ; , f'-( {1. {, ( ~ Iff, e r\ ("'~f '('I \ (.? -~ '"~ ( l I <::' . 11- I~' (-' (r \' t " \ ,)~, 1.'.- Lv ~ :>.'- ',;{ :; l{'l"~ '\.'> r:{", . -ICd l .v ,I ( ft"1({"'f'I I J t ~ "J .,,, {; (r' -/ ~ j.5 -f,..Ji" 'I ~ 10 '" c,,..J, S ". =-!--t:.. (ee c{ It (s (' (n ~...,J .J> I .~ /leY' ~11(, J ~ 01 F" s .,,, f LeU>' r ,. ,.,1. f(;." ',,, 'n'" skip II C( 5 ~ f-' l'-' t't r~' r ,l i . ( l C( . \. ..Q ~t I)\. Cl I ~ --f{.....~, a I' ~ .,., " " 'f ,. .. (.t.:,.; r f'" i " e,' 0'" ct. /1'- ....l '+_'1 v"',--c ) l" . '." 1'-') '+ fr- (' r;; ~:..'- I tl. <;-f- --th r-t" e- Y t"' a ( S I lJ ' .:t IN' S '1" -I-' _ ,( .5 <. " ,.J 14',,,. Jl.1 ~"C{ .[rc'"" ['1 '12- .' (1 '1 ,-. //, '" f /1 <7 (, :T <t '" "",^ n {' <V 1> S l' { [."' ( ; c 1'1'1>...1 in' A.(. ilT ., C,;'5 -~ i .,,-, i 1 0;'" s.l,,;" s: hc<. ' /"1 'J -f;d (., {r "'" {o ,., .( ,~ ,,, j /.. If P I f ~,J, lJo-! :r,I,,1 I.", ,. .{",,, ,p"Hic,,<'P7<:'/.fI".5'> T C( /I'" ,',..'- ~i.5> cr L / I,'"! 'I E~.' J. J ~ !!:.' V ~V'\. -t' ( ~ L (-(-1-(' t , ('-' r.L. /r ) C'L(~ I .r- e-o., (,,{ V ,. i.{ ,,! ( S' ,'-I u " 1 .." >' j) ~T b '7 t/...<, . ~. ll, -I -(C" l' /1 ,'1"/1 y! /1'1 b t'.k -, _~'(' (' . C. I" f ....f (.I )( "-'ft j ( ~ I ()l>'- f" 'I vt/ r hl . U 1-' . -/ \ ~ C ' r ~ · l' . t' a ( ('f"~' /t ." {' (' >L \. P !-(' -f (' H L. A ( , .' I I j ( ~ ".pt '<" f I'- ( -.I'('r.I' S' <? r..( l '( f'''--- .,'1...>. tls "t- 'II '/<".11 1/ (,., _)t'"t:""/-; /11.... '/,. " , . . , c t.J II S ( I' ",. S "; c. · 't.. ' ,., l t't.l Y' HI " vI. '1 , ( t Cl f\. /. (I(. { ( lil J, / (' "'g: i' ( C ( ( <<,' A.. . > t1 . - t."Tt. .... . j#- 1 'if ? ? 6 c" ...., 2. The said Defendants are directed not to further store trash and similar items, including unlicensed vehicles, upon the premises. 3. The said Defendants are directed to notify the owners of any such property directed to be removed of this Order of Court within 10 days of today's date. 4. In the event that the aforesaid materials and items are not removed from the aforesaid premises within 60 days of today's date, the Plaintiff is authorized to enter upon the premises and remove and dispose of, as it sees fit, the said automobiles, semi-trailer, and trash, and to file a municipal lien against the property for the costs of doing so without further Order of Court. Nothing herein is intended to prevent the Plaintiff from proceeding with a petition for contempt as an alternative or supplementary measure of obtaining relief in the event that the Defendants do not comply with this Order. It is noted that this Order has been entered with the consent of Defendant Julie A. Johnsen through her counsel, and that the Order was dictated in the said Defendant'a presence and in the presence of representatives of the Plaintiff. This Decree Nisi shall automatically become a Final Decree, unless post-trial motions are filed by a party in the matter within 10 days of the entry of this Order. r' r- . " : I! till , t"' l::' , .' ( , , ( .. I ." f I ,.j " I , , ' " " "