HomeMy WebLinkAbout94-04246
"
1'1.'1
,'t '-',
~
i,
V)
,
,
"
I,
, ,
'il
"
'I
I,
;1
"
,
I'
"
",
;,'
"
,
I
(
"
"I
, '
~
f!;
" '
"
I,
"
"
"
I
'I
l i
1"1 j'
I
I ,
-::r '
cri
"
,
, "
. !
0:
<I
I,
"
,
:'i I
~- ~
-.
,
'\.
,
t'
I
,
.,:,1"
'j"
,:'1
It
J"I:
"JI'
l':)!l
"',"t.
;~,r:
~'I ' I~
i~jl"
rtfI't
lit'\1
"'. j
~..
,.
"
,:
q
.
~
.'
..
, I
till/III!! IIllI' hll IUIlI II /lUll /111,1 HII,VIlIg, "I'll hlow ,V1,IUI' hUllol
off."
Il. On or Ilbout MlIl'dl 21. 1'1"4, thll pllllllt Iff IIwukc to lh",
IIllfcrldllrll hllVlrlg HlIXUlI1 Inllll'l:uUI'HI' wllh 1ll!1'. tolll him tn
stop. IIl1d wlll!11 HIll! tl'ilId tll /l"l him Ilff lll' h"I' hu plnrwd hur
wri H t H IIhoVlI hll I' IWlld, I'll," t I'll IlIlId Ill! I' ')JI till! IllId IIl1d CUll t I nuu,1
to hllvl' intllJ'l'UIlI'HlI wllh hlll' "l'spltll h,,1' pll'IIH for him to
stop.
c. On nl' IIh<ll11 MlIl'l'h H. I'J'I4, thu ",.relldlllll thruw II ,wt of kuys
/l,t thu 1'111111111'1' Hll'lkltl/l 11"1' 011 the hllc" or hel' helld clIllslng
hcr plIllI, Wh,'1I the plllltlllfr weill 11Ilck IlIsi"e lhe IIp/ll'tlllllllt.
the der"lIdlllll 1'0111,111"" her. .I"l'k..'ol')JI" of lhei I' dllUl!htcl'H fl'Om
lh.) plllllll i fr's II rills , 1111" shoved lhl' pllllllllrf hllckwlIJ'l1
CIIUSIIlf.! Iwl' to 1'1111 II/lllln"t the c"fr"1! l/lhll'.
II. III 01' IIhollt Oclohl'l'. 1'1'1,', I h.. .k'fl't1""l1l cho"cd thl' (llllintlff
uslll!! hulh his hllllds IIIlol IIpplyill/l such fOl'clI lhllt she could
nol bl'lIlIthe, Till' "l'r"tIlllIlIl lhrllw II hook lit lhu [lllllllllff
/ltl'lklng hel' .)JI Itlll lefl l'1I1', slIutshed housuholol IInd pl'I'sonlll
uhJects hlllotl/lllll>\ lo the plllillllfr IIl1d llll'lIW llwlII /lh"Ut till!
IIpllrlmllnt. TIll! plllllltHf's nelghh,,1' luil'phnrllld thl' police /lnd
thll de fllndllllt WIIS IInl'st,'d /lnd 1"'lIIovud frlllll the l'e"ldencu.
The plllinll rr sllstllllled hl'uiNeS lIIul HOl'ene,,,s IIhoullwl' neck liS
n result Ill' this IncidulIl.
In the Plllil lhu ddund/lnt h/ls /lltempled suicide' in WIIYS
including pUlling II shotgun bnl'l'el IlIto his mouth IIl1d
c.
I", 'l'J'1oI1~)IIMY Cl/S'J~)I)Y
21, 'l'hu pllllnll ff /iuuk/i lUlllpornl'Y <cu,/ilody of lhu followln!! l:hll<lnm:
N_ pnmenl Ke/llllencu AAu
Am"n"" Lynn Shnvul' 11\1 F. III~h /it,. ""I. 3 YUIIl'/i old
"111'1 hlu, "" u,o.n. Mnrch I, I 'I'll
Ilnlluy Ann Shove I' Ihl 1':, IIll1h /iI, . "pi, 3 YUIII'/i old
,'/I I' I i Ii I ,', "" !l,CI,n. MlIl'ch I, 19'11
The chi Idrun WUI'U horn out of wudlock.
The children IIru PJ'{!liClllly III Ih,' r.:lI/ilmly of the r1ufundllnl. Rllndy A.
Shnvul'. who f'lllildu/i III Ihl Flllil t1ll!h Slruel. "pl. I. C:lIl'llslu. l'ennsylVllllln.
During the chlldrclI'li IlvCIi lhuy hllvu l'e"l<le<l with the following pCI'50nR
and III the followln!! 1I<I,lre/i/iC/i1
~ ~!JcIrcmlU.1I lliIll1li
!lefendant 161 F, High SI. , A"I. ,July 20. 1'1'14
('111'11 s I u, P" to the pl'csent
Plllint I ff {I" dcfenrlllnt 161 E. lIillh lit. , "pt. MIlY. 1'1'14
1'111'111' Ic, "^ 10 July 20. 1'1'14
Pllllntlff IInd her pnrents, 2~ Wllrwlr.:k Circle "pl'i 1. 1'194
Joyce nnd Til1l spu I' I'y Mcdllllllc/ihul''''. "A to May. 1'1C)4
Plnlnl I fI' nnt! ,II, f endlllll 161 I':. Iflgh lit., ApI. MlIl'ch, 1c)93
('111'1 l/i lu, pA 10 Apl'! I, 19c)4
Plnllltiff IIl1d r1ef"nrlllnl 12~ N, Wllst lit. Fehl'lIl1l'Y, 1'Ic)2
Cur Ii r"i It', PA to Fehl'lIl1ry. 1 '1C),1
Pllllntlff, de fundlln l IIl1d 2~ Wllrwlck ,'I rei" Mnl'ch I. 1'1'11
pllllnt i ff' s plll'enls Mcchlllllr.:/ihul'll. P^ 10 Fehrlllll'Y. 1c)c)2
Thc molllcr of lhc r.:hllt!rcll Is /ill'phlllllllc Ii. lihovel', lempol'lIl'i Iy residing
lit 2~ WlIl'wi"k Circle, Mur.:hnlllcshul'lI. ,'ul1Il)erlllnd County, Penllsylvllnlll.
Shu Is I1Inl'J'ied,
The fllther of thl' chi Idren Is Hnndy A, lihover. r.:lIl'l'ently residing lit 161
Enst Hillh :>trcet, Apl. \, ('nrlhle. ['ul1Ihurlllnrl Counly. l'ennliY I vlln in,
WlmJlEFOJ{I':, pUrHlIllflt to the prllvislllns of thu "protectllln 1'1'011I Ahuse Act"
of Octubul' 7, I'n/l. 2.1 I'.~. ~ (>/01 l.t NC<\" IIN IIl11endud, the plllintiff PI'llYs this
Ilonor/lhle {'OUl't tll ~I'/lnt thu fnllllwlnll l'ul tuft
A. ll/'llnt 11 TUlllpul'/lry Onlur pllrsll/lnt tll thu "Protect Ion from AbuHU
Actl"
I. Ol'durlnlol thu dcfendll111 tu I'ufmin from abusing the
pl/llnt i I'f lind/or pl/ldnlol hur in fellr ul' nhusu:
2. Ordurlllg thu dl'l\'ndllnl tu rufrnln frolll !lnrlllSsing nncl
stnlklng thu pl/llntHf IInd frlln! hllrllNslnlol the pl/llntlff'l'l
f/lmllYI
J. Prohlhltlng th,' dl'fundul1t frlllll enterlnlol thu pl/llntlff'll
plllee or ulllplllYIIII'nt I
4. Prllhlhlllll~ lhl' ddund"'nt from relllov I nlt , damnging,
desll'uylng or HId Illig IlJ'UPl'rly jointly llwnud hy thu plll't ICllor
oWllud stlll'ly hy !tIC pllllnt i ffl
5. 111'1I11tlng I","scsslon of thl' IIpllrllllcnt locntud lit 161 ElIllt
High ~tl'uul, ApI., I. ('111'1 isll', C'ulllhcrlnnd County,
PUllnsylvllni'l, III llll' pllllnt I rr III the exclusion of the
dufendllnt I'XCI'pl to l'xl'relse his pl'riods of p/Htill1 custody
MondllY thl'<lllgh Fridll,Y 1'1'0111 ~:1I0 11.111, 10 4:.10 p.III.. pencling II
flIlIll order ill this IIIl1tll'n
h. onh'rlllg the del','n,llInl 10 sIllY IIWIIY 1'1'011I nn)' reslclenc\!
lhe plulnlirf IIII1Y in th... rutllr... ...stllhllsh for herself except
to exel'dse h!.s pcrllld" of pllrlllll cUNt",ly Mundny through
FrlclllY frlllll ~:oo lI.m. to 4:JO ".11I.. IInd
7. 1l1'l1l1111l1ltl'llIlkll'llrv <:u~tody of ttw 11111101' <:hildrelltothe
plillllllt'l' lillhJel'! III pilI' I 1111 l:lI:\tody III Ihe "cfeudllut 1'1'0111
IlIO[j /l.III. IlfItll 4:,10 p.lII. MOlldllY thl'llllllh l'rldIlY. Ilul'lnll Ihe
defendlllll's IIllerulIll' Wel!kl'ud perl<lllh M plll'lllll <:uslody every
olher wel'kelld "1'011I l'rldllY lit H:OO p,lII. lllll I I SundllY lit HIOO
p.III.. hl' ~/1I1i I rC'1II1l111 lIutsldl' till' frollt door of Ihe
pl/dutl i'r's 1I1l/11'l1l1""1 h"US" durlll!! lrllnsfl'r of <:uslody ulllcHIl
olher IIrrllllMl'lIIellls Ill'c' II/Hl'c.d UpOIl hy lhl' pllrlles.
Fl. Sdll'du I e II hel,lr III~ I II Ilc<:ordllll~'e w II h t Itl' pmv i H Ions of the
"Protl,!cll<m 1'1'011I i\hll.s" i\d." IHld, lifter su<:h hellrillg, l'ntel' IIn order
to hI! In efi'e<:t f'l!' II pl!rlo" of on" yelll':
I, Ordl!l"llIll ltll' ,kfelldllllt to refmln i'l'llRl IIhuslng the
plnlllt 11'1' IInd/OI' plll<:ing !Il'r ill fellr lIf IIhuse.
2. nrd\!rill~ llll! ,kfellihmt tll refl'llln 1'1'0111 Itllrtlssing lInd
stalking the plllintii'i' IInd 1'1'0111 hllrllssing Itll' plllintiff's
film! Iy.
3. Prohlhiling the dcrendlllll fl'llllll'ntl'ring lhe plllinllff's
pi/Ice of elllployment.
4. Proh i hili ng till' dcfl!ndlln t frolll remov I nil., dlllllng I ng,
,Icslroylng or sl'11 IlIg properly Jolutly owned ill' the ll/lrlieH or
owned so It! I Y ill' the pili i ut I I' i' .
5. tirllnt iu~ posSl,!s,slolloi' the Ilpllrlment IO<:lltedlll 161 Ellst
IIll1h S~rc'l!l. Apt. I. ('/lrllsl", ''1.ullherlllud ('ouuty,
Pennsylvllnlll, to the plllilltii'f to the \!xcluslon of I hI,!
defendlllll C'xc'\!pl to l'Xerdsl' his periods oi' Il/lrlllli custody
MOIli/IlY Ihrough J'ridllY 1'1'01111\:00 11.111. to 4,:30 [>'111,.
.
.
h, Onl~rlfllol lhe deft.'lltllllll III 'lilY IIWIIY 1'1'011I IIny ru,\lluncl'
lhe plnlnllff IIIIIY ill the future el'itllhllllh I'llI' herllelf excupt
to exurd,c hi, pel'lmhl llf pllI'tllll cu~todY Mondny thrllul\h
~'r1dny 1'1'011I 11:00 11,/11, III ~:.10 p.lII.
7. ()rnntlllloll'illppml III the 11I11101' l'hi 1<11'1111 III the nlllount of
li50.00 pel' we~k plIYllhlc to thu plnlllllff 111 tl,c 1',)1'111 of 1\
chuck 01' lIIoney onl"l'. 1II1111ed tll her re,ldeIlCe.
fl. Ol'del'in!l lhe defelldllnt III PIlY 1111 co,t, llf fi Ilnll Imd
Ilervic:c of this IlIwsull IInd .IIIUl'lIey's fe~s III I.egnl Sel'vicCll,
IlIc.
The pin lilt Iff further IIskll thlll thl s Pelllllln he 1'1 led IIl1d served wi thout
p/lyment of Costll, pend In!' II furlh,,1' ul'del' III. lhe hellr 11111 , IIn,1 lhnt cert I filHI
copies of thi,; Pdltlon /llId Order he delivered III lhe ('111'1 Isle. ('nml' 11111 /llId
Silver Spring TowIIship Pollee Ilepllrtlllenls whll hllve Jurlsdlcl Ion to enfurce thill
Order,
The plllintlff pl'lIYS for l'iuch ulhel' relicI' liS mllY he jusl IImll'ropur.
COUNT II
!:!m'J'()!)Yllfflll)H PI':NNSYI.VANI^ CUSW/)V.lM
26. The IIllelolnl ions of ''<lunl I IIhllve lire Incorpornte<l hUl'eln liS if fully
set for,th.
27. The hest Interel'it 1111<1 pel'mllnent welflll'e of the children will he
served by confi I'm in!! custody In 'thu plllllltl ff n~ set forth III Pnrngmph 25 of the
Pet I don.
,
,'.'il
".! 1,1
'1,I"TI'_f,1 fr,
''''i'tit'
''''"'~
',}"",)1
/"'\';
(Ii ,~y,
','T1
,d'
':
1'\'
":'{,
'i'
"
"il,"'\'
, !
, \,
.t'
2 1,f~ 1M
l\l~lj.Off\OI
01 11\1. V'I'.I.;11101l01AA'f
Cllll1IEI\I."1I0 ~Oll\l"
Pf.III1!,y~~"lI\"
p;d U. .3S".()O
,
,
"
,
" i
"
,
",
" "
,
, I
" "
"
'.
,
"
,
'"
,
'01
"
II'
,
"
...j-.....-,.......
, ,~~~l-........ I
i ',1 '1 ..;~.....~"-"
I ',,' -." ,"i" l'1j~~.-,-'I.,...... . ,.
't'; ';, ,j' ,t'"h/t~.....'r-:rI'"
",;,1, ::;'- I, ",'
" I it
)1' 'I
I ,-Ii' rl
"
"
',' "r-.i' 'p.,.--~_. '
,.:;:\,,:,'If[.r-'T''~ll ~
'q' j') 'i. . I
\ ;;iir ;\1
-,
" ,I,
" . ,!
.
,
,I .
"
"f' ~
....
.'
I ~..-
I'
"q .."..,""~
. ."',' "'r"I"lllll.,
:,>~:,:.Ihlil'l:(',!' '..
. ,.~- .,
"
','
,
,
I I 'l
"
'1
"
,I
i
"1'
, -I'
I
:l ~'"G:''l''''-'::\'(C:. t'
" .i',
,
"
tII ,"
I. ,
~
.
,
.
,,\'II,'r~-'
;,,;;_';~I\I'fl'_I.,:,
",1-.,,: '\ .'{l, ,
"
'f' ,I,
o'
,
,.,
,,):,t'!:-".
HI,
l',
..
,
"Ill';:
~,J" I
l't,;,_):-1
iIi,f"
":'1''''(. "
(-.",.);! ,
l,{'b,t_!I'1
H[,I'II-~~I',
\ ,-~f _ OJ""
~tl "
~'''(1J~;;
,_1_1'__',')
III
li'Y,;:,':' I
';->t,}.r:j,j
~1;":'tJ~"':'
,;ifl'l~~-,,"i":"
'iL'r/--,:-i;l"\'
JL~;i,:l\\JJ',f- :
fhJ;:rr~lhi
-,jVW\\-f,I~;,~i-:'
Ivllf"~I,-j',
1,;;d;<\:il! .'1,
,1!\I"I','
\,.,!i'_;r"\'" i'
iQ' -,' ik~t~;',l;
.,):.j,l{ -f/~~t~(J..T-i I' ,J ~u 1
rl;' '\'1'1;." ~",
r:;'.l;(:'i-I~_ 'I.. J'i,,_,,'l
~';J\ ': -'," ,~~-_ --~'" ;f
f "'1/'1 -, '"
'\'iJ:.I.-h1i l'i
IT.,'{'),\,-:
. 1"'1,. M
111/'i,I:"11
Ii il,'l"'\ .
I t ~Ij, ij1f, I .
;ill '(.' 1"\: h i
: ~vt{ltl ~,Il::~ ',,' '.
!i~fi.VI ;I~!, ,.I' ~"
~"""'I':'IL'"""
.1 V ,;JI1,: i11r;, , '.,
r.,' ':LX"-r:!,,ir., ';,' ',-'
f. ''I''!'\
'f' j't; -~jl.'
\'i"'I'~i",,~j';r' ,,"
":(l'!l';.e')il!hJ
I'\-~\"~!' :<,(,-,
'\'lei, IlJ."!~d
11~'1[~\,111\1~ IV
1'\, hi- V\'~',li,1
.' I ,1-,' 'II "
~l;-l~~lfP,~!,j p{r-".i
.'~Ifi'\.'r:"\':,'
,,~itl'I_"~"1 I'
f,~i,'{!":'"'' ':' ,
I,f,'-:i"ll--'H(~ '
I"~,,,,\'i";'::\i::' \1'
,l~ I,H\ji J':,,,, _, '
~'" <\,~,I",'-i\,ddl! -)"
t1;iffl;'ID';',r";;",lti,,
",lll,vl','" :,1;"
"JfY>"'i'",:I,\,;, "
, 'Iji' .'yl~,
_.,' ,dbl'
qJ__"
',I
"
"
,
,
,
1',
,
SfP 23
2 25 PH '9~
''',
I:,
,It '"
r;1,I~1'1: I
PI Ii I~
irt 11;(
: ,,(,Ii: i ~~y
'11I t:',:, III Y
',', I. 'I' I~' II i ..
, ,
,
'1'
"
,
tr.-/
"
'I'
""
1\
i
,
,
;(;
I
,
" ,
,.
\ it
'I,
;11
')
"
"
,
,
n
"
,',
,
,
" ,
"
, ,
,I,
,Ii
:1 "
,
,
,.
,:'i
, " ,',
"
"
"
'l
"
, "
.
'[
"
':1
..
"
C,'
<I',
,,,
..'
I'
.'
"
"I
'I
"
,
"
",',!.
~"---_""7'~!L.'''''_''''''''''''''''~!~''''''''',_,''___~ .'"
1..-.ft~II~"W-
:i '" ,
jW, JI,
T ......,...~'!'.
.; t- j' ;"
'r'
'. ,'I
"
,
'I
, I
,
,
"
I
. ,
'f;'
"
1/1
"I ..
'..
"
.
,~
.
.
.'
Irlw~,'-'~,11fi'r-I';"d;r--~!"
l'-))'~'~" ,,'/\\"'-":"- t - ,
'1;\, ,:-, ' ,'l :'l~ i, '~
~-,:' . 'ii,,:",: I
I/t'
,r"l:'"
to,"~
..;".jt<1r;\', ~i\'"
, 'i ~ i ,- ',L
, I ~-.(I;,
<I",.",