HomeMy WebLinkAbout94-04258
'I
'I
,n
'I'
,
II
, I,
, .1.
IIU
'~
,I
"
~;f
"
\(
I'
"
"
I.
'\'
,
iV,
,"I
'~I
"
,
,
Ii
'fi'
:~
'~~
',~
i)"
"
'I;I~" "
t
J
:,';1/
,~
i e.
i~
""i
II
"
"
I,
'i
"
,
,
r~
,
iI,
,)
, ,
,
"
, ,
"
',I
!~
.'
E
~
"
"
"
"
"
'I
" ,
"
I,
"
"
"
,
,
,
'11,
'-n
-
'-
(:~
~'~
',.,
r
15
v.
I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I CIVIL ACTION LAW
I
I
I
I 94-4258 CIVIL TERM
SHIRLEY M, HESS,
Plaintiff
DARVIN M. MYERS and
CHERYL M. MYERS,
Defendants
IN REI PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE
At a pre-trial conferenoe held Wednesday, April
30, 1997, on the above-captioned oase before the Honorable
Harold E. Sheely, President Judge; preBent for Plaintiff,
shirley H. Hess, was Joseph E. Dixon, Esquire; present for the
Defendants, Darvin M, Hyers and Cheryl H. Hyers, was stephen L.
Banko, Jr, Esquire.
This is a jury trial which should take two days
to complete. It was continued from the last term by order of
Judge Bayley since Mr. Banko had several cases on the trial
list. I would recommend that we start with this case in
Courtroom 1 for that reason.
This case arises from a motor vehicle accident
which occurred in Cumberland county on August 3rd, 1992, and it
is alleged that the Defendants struck the Plaintiff from the
rear. Liability has been admitted in this case so the only
issue will be on damages.
The only damages claimed by the Plaintiff are
physical pain and suftering, mental anguish, discomfort,
inconvenience, distress, embarassment and humiliatl.on, and loss
of life's pleasures. There is no claim for lost wages or any
~
future loss of earning capacity,
plaintiff had $100,000.00 medical insurance
coverage with ner own carrier, and I was informed that as of
this date only $14,000,00 in medical bills have been paid.
Plaintiff indicated that there ie a large number of medical
bills that ~emain to be paid, but apparently for some reason her
carrier has refused to pay them, and she is seeking to have the
bills presented at trial.
I would ask for a memo from the plaintiff's
counsel and defense counsel on that issue as to whether or not
she is entitled to recover any medical expenses in this trial
since Plaintiff had sufficient insurance coverage from her own
carrier to pay the bills that have not been paid. Plaintiff
proposes to call all of her expert witnesses in person at trial,
and most of Defendants' expert witness will be by videotape,
although some may be called in person at trial.
According to the Plaintiff's pre-trial memo, the
problems in this case to Plaintiff, shirley M. Hess, have
resulted from a closed head injury and soft tissue injuries.
She claims difficulties have continued since the time of the
accident and will continue in the future.
Plaintiff was about 40 years of age at the time
of the accident and was divorced. Apparently during the
marriage she assisted her husband doing tax work, and it was
noted at the pre-trial conference that even though they are
divorced that they are apparently now back living together.
The Plaintiff was taken to the emergency room
Iff:;,'"
iill"1;,,I
"",,-(
. "~I.i~ ';;- \
"'IIi
11,) ,
\h, I,ll ()
I Jl,ir';
1~\~1~!lrl~:f};!_:> :;~I
~'i'-"l\,I,JK}'J'I,j'l
) ',/'11...,1,'(;:'
'il/"i",')I;\,) ,
"!,'tw-;',;
~ ',' i -","':." ,H
'j1'r"~-n I I I') I
!1 :~( f,~k I;
~J, 11(' {jl.~~1 'IL
~\'j'llrJI" I;,
I \r ',\10/,1,
~'~'" ,It ill ,1
1 ~jJill.l:.c;" :'1'
~;:\11,~{,~Ii'!,", '
~~(''''';' I,
" _I I ~ I '
fI~"I"\!!"" ,
~; 11~,;\4\' '
II, ~Il\ " I
;Jlt:1(;{~:':,; :,
rlj/"~'H' ""',: ' )
:~~,t~j:!:l!i:.',-:,.!,;t:",I.',( . I
!)~(!, :;,)1'-" I"
'h~(I;_".!-!!',l
,Jlr,i'''.''.':;l./t
:i{f(\,(':,:f'lr:,,:_),!
~lf.i':)i;j'I;)::_:'ll
,_~~.iii,','_':!~'.~' '\:' I
'~:JI(',;J;;,.' (1~'-~1.'i I~
i!ht.;\,'h,:~;{
tJt!: ',;,'--',',",,"--'"
(~f!jt ,fi :'-r~\1
:Il,:;!:;:'}::;';"'(
1;1,'["':_"'_ -,!~j,',I,'
tr~,i;>il.':"i"'i!_,
!l+:;"i!,!,'_':';,i'
(7, "'~'I 'I ,:",..' '"
,m;h,I\~Y;':,:'
41110~;1,";"""_" I
Itttl:/,.,L.'i,1
l~["~~'~' I , .
'"I",' J
/':v',lIj It,)
~tr(l,~n ~_::;r
~~:~~,!:_.! \'I'i'i':;
'-r,;'!!'"';-;;!.";" i~
~f~~;t>:.:'l.'
, ,
Film orncl:
or: 11 i' rJ')f.'i" 'r)TlIlV
"
'97 H~IY .. I
d.
('Ii 12t nti
'.r;
",'
,
"UI' "IV
\J \'~"" 'i, I ',_1 , '..' 11\ ,
~l~N1\~'rLWNV\
'"
.;;
i'l
,
1','
,il
",
"
, ,
, ,
'r
t'.,
"
!,
"
"
,
"
"
"
,
"
'I
"
I,
"
,!
,
,
"
"
'I
" I
.t'
'I
'i!
,
,
"
! '
,
"
" '
"
"
'I),'
;1
'!
"
. I-I
,
,
,
"
'i,';::
"
,'1,
'II;'
I;, r:
','
, I
"
I
, ,
, ,
, ,
'!i,'
,
,
,
""'"
, '
"
, ,
,
l'li
1 r~l1r. "\.fr", rlld~~~
............, r,- ,,~.t" 't'"
-'--,-~,
, ,
i
in''"_'''IIJr;''''!:''"-''''
."of" .
-""lp"" -1"'-'"
I
Iter"
1S;
,~ ' \\ I,
I
" ~
I
'I'"
"
, d
.
,.
/,
,,:'
'Il'
I'
~I
'.
, ,
, J'
,', .
" ,
,
,)
t
r..
'j
,
.
.
'"
;'
, .
..
1\
, '..
J
','I "
^
,
-
.
"
""""',
.
~'
, ",
"
" ..'[;1.
, ,
'"("1"
.", '>.
,I" i','''ll, 1""1
';r,\'~"~rrl
'\
t~,,".j)f'~""'1;lr' ,!,' "r'
'/
"
i'
';:,'
FIl.ErHlFACe
Or- TI I(nnritJ,ioNOTMY
!l'"
l\;,<'
r~/-'
YI:.'f, .
"""
~!;!!I "'II
\c\ :_~~~' ~i1i "
rlit!.'r'." r!
~l"I' ':~
!f~I'II,1 .
,11,1.
q'/.JMI-:.! PIlI:5Q
CLJMl.lCI W;li I,.\JUNIY
PeNNSYLVANA
.'
'I
1\
'"
"
. ,
"
,
I'
'I
(,
"
, \~
, f '~i I
, ,
i
I'
"
"
,
,
.'
,
"
I'
" ,
,"
,
"
,
"
, .
,,'
'I 'I
"
, ,
,I..p~"",,- -.,..1'...........
" '"'1'''
I
..'-....-.1",.
. ,..,1.. "
j,
'h",W1~'''''~~t'''M\i"~lt''~_i'f~~-'''''~i'.'
'rrtn:
It"'"I
I~
I
.'
t'
\,
, I
,
t
I
\
,
.,
I' !
~
.
.
,
,
,
.
,',
,
4'
"
.'
I
.'
1 ;1,
, /
..
..
.
I .
'..
~'
.,
,
I'
I
, ,
,
1'!1i'..Cj,,!
""';)";/
'1,'1'j
, '. ,I"" ~ ':1
','....',.'..,il
,'.- ,j
" ,'I
,.~~!:\t
')1 I "d'} ,
i>_ {/,
. ,~- ,'.- ,:
,
.
.
;' -t"'''II
....,f 1.
,
;.;,.......~"
i T ..~.
"
;','
,
,_I,
'11,,1
IF"II"!I';i
I ,,::~t!rtt~{iR
; k' '. /~ 'f!~_'
I'.~'ni!r"{/'
;-1' ;,:' r l'~~: ~ ~ "
~ i' ' ,.- 1, ,i "
I-:,-:~\',l;
11,'lu,.!.
T
.',:.'J,';:'/'f,Ht
":,H iJl,
'.K;{~,~}.t~,
:"~.! 1'~r::.I~;1 tW~l,
1")"'\""il~'J-'~lW-
_ .\-,"',:,'ihf)i
'1"'/"1'1' ",l"l;"~'
1.'f'I' ,.1,'1',1,' 1~
[, 1-",c,-'J",.II,,,\.;'ft
, .' 'I :,I;{;,';, Iq-, ii ;~(I'rn,-I'
,I l;-"h(\lr~:~;:i'i}il-~1'!/-~
.,,- 'l/iJ" l \i.r~Wl'rli.'
""/",,;,,l'I,rJi\I'\Cr',.-u
..,,,.' -"i".!.l..;d l~
' ' !~i\f~1 ~tl! ri ~,'- _I
, 'Y;\!~~/);',jn!
, ,'!!"r:)lli
1'\", 'lV!;',~!
',,\1111' ;
'! ,;"\,"'k'q'!;:
i; i~tl"~iwi,r "'~l.
t 1/-" -~'"Aj!'HfM
, '}~i'I','~,)itt~!,~\,~rl' :~l'll
','..'{i.!' VI" '_~
,''';'fi''I_l':''''j',
""\'f~fi'iT);'I!I.r
'.". ; l! i,,_ (,\.~~; ;',_"::,,". ;~jr;
,,' ). "1"JJ
[. "l"l:h~,'U.,_i:'!iW
' i : ,I:! . ,; , ,)1: I, ~;~(Ij~_,~ ~ I
,1,-
,
, "
"
-,""'.,;'f'OI
1.1(1;11t:;d';i;:,I'~('1
,ii, ,.j , d.i'.,'!-"
I II ""j'i'_,d:
,{c_,'-lil!!.
" ~.t7i,t;}]
'.-'-11.' [/;.,lii
'I" _,!.:I,/;~\Ijt:il
;"1\.")":
;_,; """'-'"-,,.:V
. ,:)".;,:t!:
"'t "":,'1
',':i",I!j\\W
,"',1i~r\l"""-~'_-'
il.:i:\'''Ti'I'
, I ' '.: ,r;,1i;'i,,:
, ' I " \' f r t ~I(
, ' '.) I ; ,-' _~ j "
,n'll','
I'
",
1'1
:1'
i.':"\
,',:-';',:"1\,1
';.r,;'\', ..
,If I! \.
, '
...
,
SHIRLEY M. HBSS, I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
I CUMBBRLAND CO., PBNNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff I
I NO. 94-4258 CIVIL TERM
v. I
I
DARVIN M. MYERS and I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
CHERYL M. MYBRS, I
I
Defendants I JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRE-TRIAL MEMORANDUM
This case is a motor vehicle accident case in which there i.
clear 100 percent liability with the Defendant, Darvin M. Myers.
Despite the fact that the Plaintiff was rear-ended while making a
left hand turn by a vehicle driving at an unoafe speed, the
Defendant, Darvin M. Myers, to date has not otipulated as to
liability. Therefore, evidence will be presented at the trial to
prove the liability of the Defendant, Darvin M. Myers, J.n this
CA8e.
Concerning damages, the Plaintiff suffered from a closed head
injury, as well as soft tillsue injuries.
The Plaintiff has
residual cognitive difficulties and has been disabled since the
time of the accident. In addition, the Plaintiff has residual
physical problems from the accident.
The principal issue in this case is the extent of the damage..
This author doe. not feel the Defendants seriously are contesting
the liability issue, but they, of course, can speak for them.elve..
The Plaintiff may call one or more of the following exper.ts in
person or by videotape I
1.
2.
3.
4.
Dr. Bruce Albert
Dr. Russell Youngberg
David Nicodemus, Neuropsychologist
Economic Expert Harry M. Leister, Jr. of
Conrad M. Siegel, Inc.
Dr. Richard M. Seldow
5.
The Plaintiff will be presenting the testimony of one or more
of the following lay witnesses I
1. Shirley M. Hess
2. Peter A. Hess
3. James H. Hess
4. Robert Wendell
5. Ronald Peifer
6. Ray Reinfeld
7. Richard M. Leach
8. Alma Waugh
9. Jeff Lambert
lOt Rabbi Carl Chopper
ll. Janet Pappas
12. Rosemary Smith
13. Tonya Lear
In addition, if necessary, the Plaintiff will be calling the
representative from Nationwide Insurance Company who took
photographs of the physical damage to the Plaintiff's motor
vehicle. The Plaintiff will be calling representatives from the
2
silver Spring Township police Department, including, but not
limited to, Sergeant Stiegleman. The Plaintiff will be oalling the
Regi.trar and/or d,a.ignee of Temple University conoerning the
gradeB the Plaintiff received in oourBes prior to the aooident.
AB exhibit., the Plaint,iff will be preBenting the unpaid
medical bills from the Reading Rehabilitation Hospital.. A1Bo, the
drawing or diagram on the Police Report will be submitted a8 an
exhibit. Additionally, any other records of the silver Spring
Township Police Department of their investigation of this acoident
will be presented.
The Plaintiff's report card or grades she
received from T~mple University and photographs of the vehiole will
be preBented. The experts, through their testimony, will refer to
other exhibitR, including, but not limited to, business reoords,
tax returns, polioe report, medical reports or resumes.
Concerning settlement negotiations, the Plaintiff has demanded
the policy limits of $100,000. The Defendants have offered $7,000.
The Plaintiff has indioated that there is the possibility of 80me
flexibility in lowering the demand, but this overture has been
summarily rejected by the Defendants.
ReSpe~lly submitted,
./ /
",,~
~ J. Dixon, Esquire
101 South Second Street
Harrisburg, PA l710l
(717) 233-8743
Attorney for Plaintiff
"
~ ,I !
) J I ;: 8
~ iai I~
oil CII ! ) ~
, ,
, "
'j I
, ,
,
, '
"\1
I '
, ,
, ,
"
'I
@
\
IJ~~ 1 9 iUG()~
"
.
'if
.
",
, ,
/"
"
i',.',
I":/'
" 'I
,I.;!,
r;i(.
,it'
I~III,
JIJl)jl:I
fIi'1if'+
?n~~il-\f;1
", .'\1
';\:'1'11."';'11
!;1,'!.;1~;"
fi'I,I".!:::'
,,'../1..'1,,'
I"t.lr"
',,-'i\
,. r):fl
_~~;r.!}!tJ
I' ,\'.~I'
,,'I
V,tili,l;1,
"}'\";
ivJk;;I'
Itj':-;i(.1
Iji,}I"'--.,
'f't'"
~~I:I,'L.
~!i\i',~,;t
(:!i..
,It...',!
f'{1
'i ~
f\\.E~
Of 1\ r I'pn1H(')NifTfoR'l
"
9G OCT24 M~ I}I ~3
\',,1
,,'1
"
CUM'ilchLI'l' a ()j'JI'M
p\:Nt'lS'Il'JN'lIA
.
:,
:i
.'
'.
,
".
I..,
"
'."
d
/,
t:
'I'
,'f
"
"
I
, I,
,.j
"
,I
,/
"
"
1.',-,
i"
'I
I II
,'t.
,
"
,I
"
1'1
" ,'~, ')
111\
r.d,
':' ,
I'
II!
"
t,'l;; ,I
ill
/''-' ,
..',
( i
1',,;
I."
:'..
..
';"
;,.:-
..,f
,"
,,,
"
F'
~.;;
"f;
"
'I
"
"
~i ",'
,
,
ill
Ij;
'"
'.j
I"'"
i ~
,.1
'I
.
. '
':~.".. ""1 ,\"..oj"
'i ..,....
, ,"'... ....'''''.''7...".'''...~....'>..
.. ""..........~""I'.
,.. , ~ I
"
~
t
.'
~'
~
t'
I"';
.
I'
.'
"
"
,
-
"
.
-
" -
..~..
..,
,
""f
',I.
ii 0,/1-:
,.;
",.: .
I A,,_,~JIVIA''''
C~~-:,,--,-_
.'
'f . .'
;_, .'..,-:,., ,;.,l,,;,J_i,,;il)' i;:;.;/,'-:liiJ,\I J" I ~"..'." - ',',_'. .- '....;:>'"'.,, ".1\.
j," i .' il!! "-;-\e,<,,WIJjY>'}' ~'~-;':~,Iiljh"!-"!I: ~,I,;, _;":,,,,_!,','J.';!J;I~I'l:'j!~I.~
".\\":/ ':';_\;J!;':JIP-;~-I/':1 krd;Xd;t::1\Ll;'~ilr\ :,o:,,;r ',.1.'\:;'1, I,,:.".. 'ii~\;.i'~itr!1i
, (ljJJ :).'.:'+fi,;,''':,1:",'lJ;\(J'IINll-:F-'':' ,,("~Jqr;'ii,L',11, -li'~I-'r;Jnaf
"i'"" :', I"~ ';:,~:;: ,ii' ,\;'",:!,),:J:":I:;,;i;~,;1IWiY,ii"!,
I ':,:J-WT' _ li';.I' i, i/,1;:-"111'"I-,, Ji.J');!~;';_:I.jfy1fl'~~
"i" r';" ' ' ,'i.11"_ I:.., J-"'I'J~'\I';,11.-"1t
, ,I "I'. ,,:,:t;r~:;':k\'
'II, " '>:,!,!:\::/ir:/~t':~1II'"
,!.,.H1h./J'ltN
" ',' 'I' ".'" "~I~
" Cl:I~'9:~,I~':' ":;~;~I
0,,-_.,,:_. .n!\Y~_j,
_....~'" ,"c. ""1""" I;'
, -..,.,-,..., ""[<-' ,:; ,"t-;"~J~,tlll~'
I, _ -=~,., ;i;'.!r;r,'di-,~r!)r'rr~~'
.. '''1OlWM -; _ L,.' _::';i.,;/Ii'.':/)i:r-'l\tr
~'l _ ,..........,,=.....1.'1,':'1 ii,.
. i ' " " ,. __,nr',i)IIT;'JiI.
'. .' 'I!' !:":::;:I);;'L),~
,! 'j ~,"'I'-;i'i:'S."'W
j" ,.
",
Ji"h'
"
,'II
,
,
'(: .,',('"
'I' 'LII;-d'~ : ,
'i ',~ J/ J I '; I '
;/'; ..
,{,I,
'j ';1";
....
I
,.
,}/'-i:
, ~'lj
',I:'
.1
Ii
i I
, ,
, ,
.A
t.
~ ~ 9'J.i.
'I
.~
f
I
..
,'i"
I ^'~
t~
~,/I
\1 '
t. ,I,
',1-'-,
',or
'II.
l{('i
~, I, ~'.
/ #:.1.1
1"'-..
/'
'/Ii
'I,
I
I'
.,
J:
I ~
.
"
..'
..
...
SHIRLEY M. HESS, I IN THB r.OURT OF COMMON PLBAS
I CUMBBRLAND CO., PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff I
I NO. 94-4258 CIVIL TERM
v. I
I
DARVIN M. MYERS and I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
CHBRYL M. MYBRS, I
I
Defendants I JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRE-TRIAL MEMORANDUM
This case is a motor vehicle accident case in which there i.
clear lOO percent liability with the Defendant, Darvin M. Myers.
Despite the fact that the Plaintiff was rear-ended while making a
left hand turn by a vehicle driving at an unsafe speed, the
Defendant, Darvin M. Myers, to date has not stipulated as to
liability. Therefore, evidence will be presented at the trial to
prove the liability of the Defendant, Darvin M. Myers, in this
case.
Concerning damages, the Plaintiff suffered from a closed head
injury, as well as soft tissue injuries.
The Plaintiff has
residual cognitive difficulties and has been disabled since the
time of the accident,
In addition, the Plaintiff has residual
phy.ical problems from the accident.
. I
Silver Spring Township Police Department, including, but not
limited to, Sergeant Stiegleman. The Plaintiff will be calling the
Regbtrar and/or designee of Temple University concerning the
grade. the Plaintiff received in courses prior to the aooident.
As exhibits, the Plaintiff will be presenting the unpaid
medioal bills from the Reading Rehabilitation Hospital. Al.o, the
drawing or diagram on the Police Report will be submitted as an
exhibit. Additionally, any other reoords of the Silver Spring
Town.hip Police Department of their investigation of this accident
will be presented.
The Plaintiff's report card or grades she
reoeived from Temple University and photographs of the vehiole will
be presented. The experts, through their testimony, will refer to
other exhibits, inoluding" but not limited to, business reoords,
tax returns, police report, medioal reports or resumes.
Concerning settlement negotiations, the Plaintiff has demanded
the policy limits of $100,000. The Defendants have offered $7,000.
The Plaintiff has indicated that there is the p08sibility of some
flexibility in lowering the demand, but this overture has been
summarily rejected by the Defendant..
Respeotfully submitted,
.-'
Dixon, Esquire
10 South Seoond street
Harrisburg, PA 17101
(717) 233-8743
Attorney for Plaintiff
..
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
SHIRLEY M. HESS,
plaintiff
No. 94-4258 Civil Term
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
DARVIN M. MYERS and
CHERYL M. MYERS,
Defendants
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE
MEMORANDUM OF DEFENDANTS,
DARVIN M. MYERS and CHERYL M. MYERS
I. Statement of Facts as to Liabilitv
This action arises out of a rearend motor vehicle
accident which occurred on August 3, 1992, on State Route 1011
(silver spring Road) near its intersection with Basehore Road in
Silver spring Township,
cumberland county,
Pennsylvania.
Defendants do not contest the fact that Darvin M. Myers was
negligent i.n the operation of his motor vehicle by failing to be
able to bring his vehicle to a stop within the assured clear
distance ahead.
II. statement of the Facts as to Darn~
plaintiff alleges that she sustained various orthopaedic
injuries to her cervical,
thoracic and
lumbar spines.
Additionally, she contends that she sustained a closed head injury
which precludes her from gainful employment which will result in
loss of earning capacity in the amount of more than $500,000.
.
3. Reading Rehabilitation Hospital,
4. Polyolinio Medioal center,
5. Physioians of Rehab Medicine,
6. Reading Rehabilitation Hospital1
7. Reoords from Plaintiff's first party oarrier,
Nationwide Insurance company (inoluding wage
loss verification, claims for benefits and
other documents completed by or on behalf of
Plaintiff) ,
B. plaintiff's scholastic records from Harrisburg
Area community College;
9. Plaintiff's complaint;
10. Plaintiff's Answers to Interrogatories;
11, plaintiff's Federal tax returns from 19B7
through 1995;
12. Federal tax returns for James Hess from 19B7
through 1993;
13. Federal partnership tax returns for 1992
through 1995;
14.
Neuropsychological
Thomas G. Bowers,
1992;
15. Report of Scott A. Stoner, D.C., dated
November 2, 1992; and
evaluation report from
Ph. D., dated November 14,
16. Written statement (undated) of Monica M. Hess;
17. Written statement (undated) of Peter Anthony
Hess;
lB. Written statement (undated) of David H. Hess;
and
19. statement of economic loss of J'ames H. Hess
dated October 2, 1994.
- 4 -
SHIRLEY M. HESS, I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLBAS
I CUMBERLAND CO., PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff I
I NO. 94-4258 CIVIL TERM
v. I
I
DARVIN M. MYERS and I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
CHERYL M. MYERS, I
1
Defendants 1 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
COMPLAUIT
AND NOW, this 4th day of October, 1994, comes the Plaintiff,
Shirley M. Hess, by and through her attorney, Joseph J. Dixon,
Esquire, who respectfully avers as followsl
1. The Plaintiff is Shirley M. Hess, is an adult individual
who resides at 5 Davis Drive, Middletown, Dauphin County,
Pennsylvania, 17057.
2. The Defendant, Darvin M. Myers, is an adult individual who
resides at 1600 Lisburn Road, WellBville, York County,
Pennsylvania, 17365.
3. The Defendant, Cheryl M. Myers, is an adult individual who
resides at 1600 Lisburn Road, WellBville, York County,
Pennsylvania, 17365.
4. The facts and occurrences herein took place on August 3,
1992, at approximately 4100 P.M. on Silver Spring Road near the
intersection of Basehore Road in Silver Spring Township, Cumberland
County, Pennsylvania,
5. At afore.aid time and place, the Defendant, Darvin M.
Myer., was driving a 1987 Pontiac Sunbird owned by the Defendant,
Cheryl M. Myers.
6. At all times material hereto, the Defendant, Cheryl M.
Myers, had given permission and consent to the Defenaant, Darvin M.
Myer., to operate said motor vehicle at said time and place.
7. At all times material hereto, the Defendant, Darvin M.
Myers, had the authority both real and apparent to act on behalf of
and drive the motor vehicle of the Defendant, Cheryl M. Myers.
8. At aforesaid time and place, the Plaintiff was driving a
1991 Chevrolet Prism motor vehicle owned by her son, James Hess,
II.
9. At aforesaid time and place, the Plaintiff was traveling
in a southerly direction on Silver Spring Road when she stopped to
make a left-hand turn into a private driveway.
lO. At said time and place, the Plaintiff utilized her left-
hand turn signal and was waiting for traffic to clear before she
made the turn.
ll. At aforesaid time and place, the Defendant, Darvin M.
Myers, was traveling in a southerly directipn on Silver Sprin9
Road.
2
12. At afore.aid time and place, the Defendant, Darvin M.
MyerB, turned onto the berm of the road to pass a tractor/trailer
which had stopped to make a left-hand turn onto Basehore Road.
l3. After passing the tractor/trailer on the berm of the road,
the Defendant, Darvin M. Myers, re-entered the southerly lane of
traffic on Silver Spring Road and struck the rear portion of the
motor vehicle driven by the Plaintiff.
14. As a result of said collision, exten3ive damage oocurred
to the Plaintiff's vehicle, including the breaking of the
Plaintiff's seat in her motor vehicle.
15. As a result of said collision, the Plaintiff sustained
severe personal injuries and damages whioh are more particularly
described herein.
16. Said oollision was due to the negligence and carelessness
of the Defendant, Darvin M. Myers, as more particularly described
below in this Complaint.
l7. Said collision was in no way caused by the conduct of the
Plaintiff.
18. As a sole and proximate result of the negligence of the
Defendant, Darvin M. Myers, the Plaintiff has suffered severe and
permanent injuries. These injuries include, but are not limited
to, a concussion, closed head injury, brain injury, headaches,
3
blurred vision, depression, post traumatJ.o stress disorder,
inoontinenoe, right carpal tunnel syndrome, tingling in the right
thumb, tingling in the fingers, ringing in the ears, right
myooervioal sprain, lumbosaoral strain/sprain, oervioal
strain/sprain, L-5, 8-1 herniated diso, cervical radioulopathy,
lumbosacral radiculopathy, post traumatic cephalgia, cognitive
deflcits, memory problems and myofascial pain syndrome.
19. As a result of said injuries, the Plaintiff has undergone
in the past and will in the future undergo great pain and
.uffering.
20. As a result of sald injuries, the Plaintiff has been
advised and therefore avers that she will always have continuing
problems and limitations in her personal and professional
activities.
21. As a result of said injuries, the Plaintiff has been
obliged to receive 6nd undergo medical care and spend various sums
of money and incur various expenses for the injuries she suffered.
The total amount of these losses is unascertained at this time.
22. As a result of sald injuries, the Plaintiff has lost
substantial lost wages to date. In addition, she continues to lose
4
lo.t wage. and opportunitie. to earn additional wage.. The total
amount of thi. lo.s is una.certained at thie time.
23. As a reault of aaid injuries, in the future the Plaintiff
may have to incur additional financial expenees or loue., the
total amount of which is unascertained at this time.
24. A. a result of said injuri$s, the Plaintiff has euffered
a substantial inconvenience in her life and a decrease in the
quality of her life.
25. The collieion described herein was caused by the
negligence and carele88ness of the Defendant, Darvin M. Myer.,
which con.i.ted of the following I
(a) Driving a motor vehicle at an unsafe
speed,
(b) Improper changing of lanes,
(c) Improper passing of another motor
vehicle on the berm of a road,
(d) Driving a motor vehicle too fast for
conditions,
(e) Driving a motor vehicle too close to
another motor vehicle in front of it,
(f) Failure to keep a motor vehicle under
control.
5
/'
"
I
,', II
,
~
Otr " ~!r '~o r ~ '9~
J J Hi
',1'1
"II-~' j\.,~
I, (, IN.1','/'f/,rtY
1:1', ,I'.!,/"l1, "1;/11 y ,
I\, Ifd(I.V,\!,:~ "
'I , ,
'I
I:: I"
"
,I
I'
.1
''I
"
"
'"
I'",
"
"
"
I'
I,
"
,I'.
. .~". ,
,l
I'\~&"'.W
";'
"
,
",
'r"
I.'
;,'
,,'
,
I" I
"
,..
"
"
. ..
" ...
..,....
'"
\1, . .,~,,"
, " j
"
,
II'
". ,
',,' 1
'.
"
, '
,,'
,
, '
/,
'~'
.
i~ ~ --..".
- .\,"
" '; "
;, 'i' - i' ,
"
.
"
.
II 'f
II
.
".
. ~I:U','
"
:1,
"
"
','
.,
,.
.'
, ,
',c,-_
./
','
i
, 1
.
,.1'
':
"
"
r
, ,_".,." ,".',""'" ..........',.:.iri"".",~.......I".",.;
H" .-,~. .,
.I~' , .-,
(~
-"I
'fi-'-j
r't~'~ji
i;j,Vi,1<,
>I~I./!I
,-"lr~!fj;
"li);:I~"J.'
1;_'.'r
"dljl1-j
'I' j 1';1 jl~"
. i':.I.~~
,,'/[f.,
'<hili;
IHUi:~;'
,~'-J'-'al
{J:I;iJ,
,':II~:mJ;hiJ
'~rtl;'Ji /,. "/l!'
,\ i",L~".t':_;\!lM.;~
., :'f~I/:!':~\:~j
II ',."'\1-,. ,r1i\l.dl_.
..,,}~I"'.-j: -v'! ~'l'\Hj
M!','i,i;{/'~I-(!':!
,lu~)_~i '('.i_!J:Lr\,~fi
I., ._-'.;I~l!t,:: '; ~(I';J~tjUj~,~
',' .[ I', II': '.. ,1i
':I"f,\ r't"'.'.'';\\,'-';'{:'J
'i.'l-""~J__'_l',-,)
l~^'~~_~J" ',;,-"
; ij_')r~~~,:"~;
" 1,~i-JW,
, " ,I,; , iii<,
, , " "','/I"IJ . ~
:":{~1i:'I':la'}~
F"!,..,,,,:-~~I!'.:,
'!;'1\-"','-;I-'p'.li
'.;'~':'IH;lA;"i
{'l'<,(' ';/1
,I !" .,' I)' . ' I ' I (l~lll'
, .I' '\ !,r-\
',I_'lf,;:l1W. t~_i~:
, ; y JJ",I,' :H'?
~-",l-l'1'" ". 1-"i- M
~.'-:' I """"'J;'~'
','~,i,,~". -,ftt~
!':~'\'~' ;:-i!I?l:?\,;'r
':~_\. If~A1~,:,,\n'
,.!~ ,1'.,1;'\),','/
:!,[:,:'~ ';t.:,,'7,.t;
. '.- ."J.(~,Ui'll
'i .-'F., _ .,-{' "'~'".-'~,
,;:I-H,;("J~.;I'h
J (',t'_-'(M_\~
, ' ,y I
','::,),.)
"
" q', "
,
, ,
"
I, ,
~ d
I
.lilt 19
, "J III .tI
Of 1 ,,/;," '~ff'OI
CUllUIiR~1tH:~NOT.ur
PfHNSY~VA:,~nr
r
, '
,
B~
~ c) JU
6
Lf 5 ~li
!_',
,
,
',',
"
'"
"
~
~
/D1 1!J3
J(?~
/j 307
"
~ ,I
"I
,..
,
;'!,t
if
,
'iI'
"
I"
, ,
,
"
"
,','
. ,;
, ,
""!,
.,:1
"
"
I
.1',
,
"
"
"
,.__-"'1,,,
,\,..:-_I(~,i)'i,; 'I:)
,-.,.I,.ii-VI-:'\,J
I, j'1j"""""jl
'I :i:'h:~:;:ir';_~;':
\ (/:-' . ".',!I,'
"" '.,,'-:;~Ai:,\~V,~:-;
>I ',,":",.1:,
! r .-~ Ii l' 1 . . - '1-" ,
.,1',::"
",l
'I
')
"
,
,
,
"
"
,
"
,
,
,
:'
,
"I,
i
,
, ,
'I!',,'
."....._.__._.._~~..~.j,iJ~_..,.'.~.'r
, ,j-ll ,',1.'1 I . ,~,IIfr-,
. I' " .' "I' ',1
, .,1.:,"
I'
"
, ,
\ I:
'~
, , ,I
I
.. i'
" " I
"
, \
Ii 1 .
, I )'4
,
,: I 'I;
.1 .
,1 . "
'..'
,
I
,
.
II'
.
"
, '1,
," t' ,(1),1 1 ~
i~. I
I
;11,'
,,'I
... ..!!.-_~t.~~_.~!'!J..~..'t!::",I._.
, i
.,f
')
, ,
~. I,.
, "
\'"
, i
,
I"
I'.
;;
I,
.............................-.~....
\'
i I,t
'j.,
,
I,
,
'i
"
"
Shirley M. Hess
"
, '
"
Oarvin M.
Cheryl M.
Myers end
Myers
oi,
..
'"
--_......_~-------_.~----_._.-.-...-
'i,
,,'
Summons In
"
"II
" ,
"
--.......--...--.-------------------
Civil Action
Law
'l'
,I :1
,I
'I ill
," '[
.,
, ,
"
DIlB & DlJC(fi
Byl JOIJBIil J. DbDn. Fsq.
101 s. Second st.
HIIrriBbJrg PA 17101
(717) 233-8743
"
,
,
,
',11j
-.----.-------~u;;;;;----.-.-....--
":T~ :'.. "1
'PI"""'"
.,."".........,..............u...-'~- ,
~( .."
"
;1
~
~
,
1\
,\
.
,~
"
~
"
.
.
......,-.
'1,1
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
SHIRLEY M. HESS, I No. 94-4258 civil Term
plaintiff I
I
V. I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
DARVIN M. MYERS and I
CHERYL M. MYERS, I
Defendants I JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRAECIPE FOR RULE TO FILE COMP~INT
TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Please issue a Rule upon Plaintiff to file a Complaint
within twenty (20) days from service hereof or suffer judgment ngn
IU:QA .
Respectfully BUbmitted,
Date I q )1 ~)o.. y
BYI
FOULKROD, REYNOLDS & HAVAS
A pr~e~eionel Corporetion
en~. Benko, Jr.
ey I.D. *41727
S
At
101 Pine Street
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0932
(717) 236-3200
I'
"
Counsel for Defendants,
Darvin M. Myers and Cheryl M. Myers
;1'
i., \
';(
mu&
i'.
I"">'
'.' 11 ~
I'!"l
~: I"
! l;,~
II'.'!
1'1);
1)1';
I .
"
I .';~
,
,',I
TO THE PLAINTIFF:
You are hereby ordered and directed to file your
Complaint against Defendant in the abov~-captioned matter within
twenty (20) days of service of this RUle against you or suffer
judgment D2n QtQa,
"
9
(";" q 4
Date
J.';
;1\
,.
I:
l::l
('Y)
en
-
~5
.... --,.(
..'~J' ._.
~'';ff:
ff _",.~
h'''~~~.J
'j....~....
" ':)-',n
.,111'. ,("
',':..,-, ..;
t t..J-..
. 1"'1)1.'
. I~~' ,.1.: n.
-'
:~(...\
, ,
Ji
~ . ~
! j ~
.. ~.( 8
~qlil !I
~ (
Ii.
.,
, '
,
"
, ,
" ,
. ,)
..
....'
('
"
~
.
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
SHIRLEY M. HESS, I No. 94-4258 Civil Term
plaintiff I
I
v. I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
DARVIN M. MYERS and I
CHERYL M. MYERS, I
Defendants I JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PROOF OF SERVI~E
The undersigned hereby oertifies that I am serving a true
and oorreot copy of Defendants', Darvin M. Myers and Cheryl M.
Myers, Rule to File Complaint upon the person and in the manner
indioated belowl
Servioe by First Class Mail
Joseph J. Dixon, Esquire
Oils & Dixon
Executive House, suite *1
101 South Second street
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17101
}' If (l,j
Datel4 . ,. I J
BYI
Jr.
41727
101 pine street
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0932
(717) 236-3200
Counsel for Defendants,
Darvin M. Myers and
Cheryl M. Myers
Ma. Myers is not vicariously liable tor any alleged negligence ot
Mr. Myen.
8. AdIlitted.
9. Ac1IIitted.
10. Admitted.
11. Ac1IIitted.
1:1. Adllitted.
13. Admitted.
14. Denied. ~fendants are unable to ac1llit or deny
Plaintitf's characterization that there was Hextensive damage" as
a result ot the accident. Furthermore, with respect to any
allegation that Plaintiff's seat broke as a result of the
collision, without any other tactor beinq involved, after
reasonable investigation Defendants are without knowledge or
information sutticient to form a beliet as to the truth of laid
averments and, therefore, they are denied.
15. Denied. Atter reasonable investigation Detendant.
are without knowledge or intormation .utticient to torm a belief a.
to the truth ot the averments contained in this paragraph and,
theretore, they are denied.
16. Denied. The allegations contained in this paragraph
state a legal conclusion to which no response is necessary.
17. Denied. The alleqations contained in this paragraph
state a legal conclusion to which no response i. nece..ary.
- 2 -
18. Denied. The answers oontained in paragraphs 115 and
16 hereof are incorporated herein by reference as if set forth in
their entirety.
19. Denied. The answers oontained in paragraphs 115 and
16 hereof are incorporated herein by reference as if set forth in
their entirety.
20. Denied. The answere oontained in paragraphs 115 and
16 hereof are incorporated herein by reference as if set forth in
their entirety.
21. Denied. The answers oontained in paragraphs 115 and
16 hereof are incorporated herein by reference as if set forth in
their entirety.
22. Denied. The answere contained in paragraphs 115 and
16 hereof are inoorporated herein by reference as if set forth in
their entirety.
23. Denied. The answers oontained in paragraphs 115 and
16 hereof are incorporated herein by reference as if set forth in
their entirety.
24. Denied. The answers contained in paragraphs 115 and
16 hereof are incorporated herein by reference as if set forth in
their entirety.
215. Denied. The allegations contained in this paragraph
state a legal conolusion to which no response is necessary.
WHEREFORE, Defendants, oarvin M. Myers and Cheryl M.
Myers, demand judgment in their favor and against Plaintiff.
- 3 -
"
,,)
FllElHlFFlCE
or: T1'r: 1:'niln~()T/Il1Y
.1,
"
,J., "
",I ,
,
'II
I ,
, , ,
, '"
"
'I" ,
"
"
9'/,JMI 29 PII :It 02
1\
i'!' I,,'
I~' '''iI '
\.I\JI',Il..I,.I,'.'.<) I.'j,
Pl::NNSYLVNIIA
',1.'1
"
,. "
,
, " "
1,1
,
"
Iii
"
"
I'
:1
,;/;'
,,' ''I' ~
'J:ttf~,I,y,~r
~.tl:L..}",;,
.!",r",i,I.::_""
l\i"I',ii_,,", I.",
'Wi/I!, .
I ~IH -", "
, u" ,.,.",.~
{';fii';~-',' '.-,.1,',\:':
I""'I~ 1,1,1
" "'i,,J""j'U;I..','
Jr'!"l 'it '" '-
, J}'~:r~'_k:lf:;"l;
l;~Vr";:i-.'Yi ' ,
~f';V!i'/\;':l;'I; l,:it
&!~jnXg'/i~i,!;N,i,! '
l1~!l ,(j';if \,;/"
fff~ ~,~II,,!j "'-'
ttll~lllt(i,:;' ,;. ..I,
'll'~\r',lM'J:lnf"",
"...."r1l.11' '1
IWVI-~l, '10.".
~if\"'I';
, \!, '" I. 'I
'),!Wl I":~I\' 1
1'/;/ ,~t \ 11'11 II 1)' II
," ,,' "
~llllll,.t Jj,
;'~j,: 'I), I, I
L:.ti'ii;_')iki'f--,
~;i~}ltf;t~:\~::!{' ~':':\;"
rjW~'\r!:\:tr"!
<1f\~J""." , "
:';o'J{.lt/i,\"l, -.:1 I
1Vt~1; -/;1 . j l'
M~~'h' , '1,1 ," ,: I
T,,~r,:' .I'!I I I
t:;~!:,;\,;;",:, ,,'
[1,,:,I.'IJ11'I(_':'''
V\'I/I'II',' ','
lJt.li""; !{_',',- ,I
il!'!'''l!.!'
Ij\~i'\\lnr,.\'::'r '
, .'1.,-',
"I
..
Ii
" ,
, " :
, , ,', ,
"
,
"
,
"
, , ,
,
, ,
, ,
" , "
" "
:' ,
" , , of' !
" ','
,
1'\
I
,
,"
, I , "
,
,
f', " I
" , I
I
.,'
, 'I
" I,
, ':
"
I "
"
,
;.I
{
"
,I'
"
"
jjil
,,'
i'l,
.,
,
"
,
,
,
,
II
"
I:>:;:
...P'",.,..t...-.....'-+~....~,
.1 'i
-"I,e.
,
~
"':'I"T
:,:,';':";..\~-;" f<< ~;~
I' . j'
"
"
.
,
~',~" ,
. ,
,
I
, .'
'! ~
".
'.
.'
it .'
.
.
)'''''\ "
.
-Iti~:'
" '
l
'...
.--All ~~
I'
,
,
I Ii'
,
, JAil' , !, j ~.! I' l'{JII ,,'. " r,i . ',.1' , ,'" " ,I,(:t_
t~ :/,;t't;', ,h.;;~. t,f r/.,l/f "':"/1 'i:;'!I~:':P/Xlil'~': ~ 'I.'f j~;lrhl\~':;II1'fl~~\
I, l,"'f 'J' ',",lh\i1"I,:,l ~V" ~fiL"" I~I.'.t'~"'11 fl'U.~'1 '
, \' I, " " 111'/ q' I{ \. "
11,(, 'JlI .j) )'t 1'1'1'/\ I, 11 1"lJIlI, ., \ f If' '.
I', I' , ) II q" f "J j , /1,' f ' /'[1 "J l i ~ .', lj II I I; OJ, III
! L _ ,_l"I':lll!,'__:Ji:~II,~O,/,,~'I~l,I_.,l 'l'f!_!I_,_'!I':::{:;:II'-I."~:'\~
II '1.,,1 "'1.,'-I,-,""",,I,,:'.l.i-.J""!I"""""';"'i'i;/ ,-._l.
,I J' j ,-1< -,'" ".'" ',;:1"">,1,,, -,::''.>'-r\'i, J; ""!"'-I:'I'~,-,:,,\,ftl'i!'~
- J I,.;. 'I_-:,;:tlfil\_~ ,:11" oj,''',_ ,- \i-i"!',(i.-j't-Ji!-I,I
),\ 1.'1 . ....'.:}i,'tL ,,',,1'-."'1' _ 'fell.),,!;;:
; 11I.1t ;_" ", ",-.-1'1'>1'( ,}.,-L,.:,.
I ,',;, , "I;"; ;,'1'1-:',-":1,' li,;!;'I.,
!:' 'I i,l/i,-/,!.':',);,!X~j~-
, _.,':, _"'i/:i~lr:f!.fJ
"d I'",'",';l....h_ '"
;\, . \L.':,'I:_'lkIJI)~t\'
1"1.'. 'l_,:;r j,~:I..\l;lr'i~
, [!,\,--,'r"~.' HI';:
1-- ,,;I_'II,,:,,\-_II,-',_;j'
, rh' -:~,'..I",I_'il.\:;'t:!k_IY~'I?
1"11-" . " , ." '.,.' HI,
;11;1'''"' L." "_"I,,_,,,q\;
HAAA~'MliI.1~1'," i.::'\."'"
, ',.' ,A. :"1
' -., ;.,,"'"
. " ''',' '\'~l
IM';~')
;'}i~--.'~l;l
',U_ \ -'_ _~f.-i;, ,"'l;'~
1,'l/,'dil\I'
"'_t,lL,:::I"li, ,
,',_d".',".);
,
"
"
"
,',
\ Iy~='
l}n~;(J<:':i:':' ,,' ~i I';
, "h<,.
',.."l..." '" 'I
, q-,.."..AJ.. c.r (;}f . . ,
.' c:r-rv dJ ""fwrt)lll
ATTORNEY AT LAW
. .
'L
r
i,
I. ~
,I
"
!"
'"
~
I
,:
1.1
~
.'
'. j~~ '--
,
,"
,
I.,
it'
...,t
"j
1'.1'
',,.'!''i.(i i-}-r
,: l."".'l!"'-,h
J.;Li"~f~i;';r
i.'[':/;
11}li\~:\:til~\M:'
-'!/:'?(~'Ii'\ll;
," . h r -1"';,U}' ,
I ,', 1"'J:<""f<~ I
/,: !,' i~!,'IIiNttJ
, 'I,; ):\j;'~\':~I'j
. ",' '!it~ i,m'
, '.; ;JI~~~ i',;i~I'~~'
'1,.'"t',;Jl..!r','
,;',) ,:j."ii1.~-' ii".}
,'-,\;Jl;:j",Pl ~,-
,.i~)iftj,-- i, 'l
~~. ~~I
'Iljf@(,.<', ,
::~,}ii;ll~\q; ,
i~YH:~'i!,u '
".~'b~'J~\ ~ I'"
.. """Ih'l~~'
'ii;,1.:_V,,'lt;l,:/ .~
~j.,l;JX'I'Cv,J
1-I",:11::J:(1I:\V' ;
,', '1o""t":"'~I'
, jl,I,_'Il\l,!L,j~'
,'h"I' .'e,L."-I'''',''_..,;,_,
, ';;\ii:,~~~
, "(('in~' '-',4).
';','!t",:-I;;!';~j~
", i'+~~l
,ii'~ f 'I.'",}"ry;~f
i';"Jt;.\~_~1
<I'I,' "', '1,li':'1
.. tl',1,
,1,\,' J.'~W~
i'I,L\_JI
,/ l:'~
''1'.' 'it
",r'/;
;:;'<~':\I~
. 'j"l;
'I
:-,"'.tI:\
:.
nLlTJ-OrF\CE
OF 1f1',~ 1'I~n-HlIlOTMY
1)1 .lIl1l21 ~illJl ~e
I'
CUMlil:1 L."i,') l/J~JI'frY
PI:' ""'lllhl"/A
~I' 1",)1 "'I \
"
,'Ii
"
.1
,
,,I
I
"~I
"
'I
.11'
"
,I
I
"
"
"
II
"
,i" 'I
.'
"I
,1,1;
.,
,.
) I,
'/,'
I
,
,
"
",
I",
,',
i
t"
i,,11
,."
;'1
,.
.,
, I
,
!I
Ii
i
,I,
,
I"
, ,I
;1
,
"
I'
'/
';'
"
"
"'!",a'''--'''lli1q' },; t,
1'- .,j'
'f\1
IL' ." "j
'r ,'1_ ',1
\ ,,'
I'
1-"
,~ .
"""".~-;"""""'''---'--'~'';''''I'
-',':' .: L '.]1'.' ,ii' "I.. "'." ,,,
Ii..... '.'\'.,-'.','(:--".',:'" :.,"", ""'1
\llio,1 '\1 ,/-
" J'. '"
I,'. ,''Ie ",
'.' ,,\ t .
I,'i'
-.
.
!....-
,""";""1'"'''.'''-''''1'1:'''
"
j, I "
. ,
" i .
,
..t ..,..
.
." ,
,
'. .. ,I'
, ... "
... I, "
. .,'
,
.
.
.
-,
-~ ( .