The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About94-05051 . .J' " / t , ,,! - u ~ ',., " , i , \...", . // ! " , . .' GEORGE T, CARR, PLAINTIFF IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V, TIMOTHY L, CLAWGES, DEFENDANT 94-5051 CIVIL TERM IN RE: ~flELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF DEFeNPAtfi OPINION AND ORDER OF eOURl: BAYLEY, J" Mey 22, 1998:- On September 8, 1994, a document titled "Civil Action" filed by plaintiff, George T, Carr, against defendant, Timothy L, Clawges, In the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania I was transferred to this court, The "Civil Actlon," aileges that plaintiff was "unlawfully arrested on November 1, 1991, on a violation of a court order that was lodged on June 28, 1991." Defendant, Timothy L. Clawges, was appointed to represent plaintiff, Plaintiff aileges that he told defendant that he had a witness to verify that he did not violate a court order, He advised defendant to subpoena the witness "[a]nd to subpoena the photographs and medical records also to the plaintiff's defense," Plaintiff alleges that defendant did not Investigate or prepare his defense, Plaintiff alleges that because of inadequate, unprofessional and Ineffective assistance of counsel, there was a "wrongful conviction" of plaintiff for aggravated assault. He seeks monetary damages for this wrongful conviction, Defendant flied preliminary objections to the complaint. In Beney v, Tucker, 533 Pa, 237 (1993), the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania stated: [t]oday we hold that a plaintiff seeking to bring a trespass action against . .' 94-50151 CIVIL TERM a criminal defense attorney, resulting from his or her representation of the plaintiff In criminal proceedings, must establish the following elements: (1) The employment of the attorney; (2) Reckless or wanton disregard of the defendant's Interest on the part of the attorney; (3) the attomey's culpable conduct was the proximate cause of an Injury suffered by the defendant/plalntlff, I.e., 'but for' the attomey's conduct, the defendant/plaintiff would have obtained an aqulttal [sic] or a complote dismissal of the charges,'2 (4) As a result of the Injury, the criminal defendant/plaintiff suffered damages, (5) Moreover, a plaintiff will not prevail In an action In criminal malpractice unless and until he has pursued post.trlal remedies and obtained relief which was dependent upon attomey error; t~ addltlonally, although such finding may be Introduced Into evidence In the subsequent action It shall not be dispositive of the establishment of culpable conduct In the malpractice actlon,14 t2, The defendant/plaintiff must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that he did not commit any unlawful acts with which he was charged as well as any lesser offenses Included therein, Resolving this question will perhaps cause the greatest consternation, However, the only one way to protect the Integrity of the system Is to permit the attorney to Introduce whatever evidence that Impacts on the defendant/plaintiff's entitlement to compensation, Such evidence can Include any and all confidential communlcatlons, as well as otherwise suppressible evidence of factual guilt. 13, This requirement does not I however, relieve the plaintiff of his duty to Initiate this cause of action within the statute of limitations period as hereinafter discussed, but It does raise a procedural question I to wit: what Is to be done with a civil action filed prior to the completion of the post.convlctlon process? The answer Is that an attorney defendant who Is served with a complaint alleging professional malpractice for the handling of a criminal matter may Interpose a preliminary objection of the grounds of demurrer, See Pa,R.C,P, No. 1017(b)(4), The trial court shall then reserve Its ruling on said objection until the resolution of the post-conviction criminal proceedings, -2- . .' 94-5051 CIVIL TERM I. In this regard we wish to emphasize that a finding of Ineffectll/eness Is not tantamount to a finding of culpable conduct. Plaintiff's complaint does not allege specific facts sufficient to support a cause of action against defendant. Pa, Rule of CII/II Procedure 1019(a) provides that the material facts on which a cause of action Is based shall be stated In a concise and summary form. We will allow plaintiff sixty days to file an amended complaint with respect to his action Inl/olvlng his conviction for aggral/ated assault.' On NOl/ember 10, 1997, on this docket, plaintiff flied a "complaint" against defendant without leaI/o of court. He alleges that defendant was negligent In his capacity as his criminal defense attorney while representing him on a citation to hold him in contempt for violating a protection from abuse order, This Incident Is unrelated to defendant's representation of plaintiff on the charge of aggravated assault. This complaint must be dismissed because It was flied without leave of court In violation of Pa, Rule of CII/II Procedure 1028(c)(1), ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this "J--'L day of May, 1998, IT IS ORDERED: (1) Within sixty (60) days of this date, plaintiff shall file an amended complaint on his alleged cause of action Involving his conl/lctlon for aggravated assault. (2) Plaintiff's complaint on his alleged cause of action Involl/lng his hal/lng been found In contempt of a PFA order, IS DISMISSED, 1, The extended period Is because plaintiff Is a pro se state prisoner, .3- (?, .:r.r (.-'.-I~ E...n"'J~Jj.</ Ar r/..... 1':).,.(,""'1'''''-/ /":;"n'1 rr J....? ;J. ,/<;-';( By .1< L/ .M;A'~ /1 ,,4'#~~. r"t- rL 04//-.",../ .4';~nlv,..:n-/ ,#~u,r -'AK/d.vr r~' ...,t,.l''',..;\$' /~F/ tC....4.:. ~ ,.4"/....... ~~.rr-, .L!"".J07?'/ ~ ~n"m.~J>J dJ..,.r"J, ,J,..Mr'v"'< -4-" ~p",.y ~ fi,4,/, j), J::'.r- ~"'. ~~!J~.utc/ rA"r c',1 ..,.,10 ....-3' ",<;/, /';;"".,."..4- #.::>.. ("/ /'.1.. 6~_t:N .P4.:. t"Z"r -'.:::.~U[ " &<J'r <"..-~,< ",-L.,- d ~~rnr:.;.l ~n,f~ ~":c/ t'"4 ..A.,,-,. on,.. /~~/, 7'C~ A.- ..z"H ",':r,'o. r ~If" r/) C,I(' 0-mf', ~, .-:r-.,- .:t.-.-I:; ?J-rAb,,{,/-'/ ;r,,(,r <'W 4~".,'/"/ /. /rr/, .d-.:..../?/F (",,-,A~ A..r/,--.J'7.>'c/ ~,,,/ a....,7'?":>"/ 7'C ",...L a,,-,~/("/ ~"'7 '/-:;".Jt:'d t"H ,.L ,4/~~,/ U/r~nt:,/ r/' A<7;>c?Pe,/ C"..-.?It", ~ ~,.) ",he, C'~:rNMJLr/' T';;'-' ,4rrrA! T L /~o~,r,',r:.> ""''''''',.-r- "'"../ 8"""r"",''''- h/ rL C-?'...6#.'~N/ A':"'./r,Y /J.,.___ /4o~,/;~ IV.", /.v "'.f' "'/~".r/ ,4/".,cr'''T'>'~ a..,,...( "hI' a,"',cr,c:.,v" t::""/nt"....tC' 8;"...,.,.,- Be",.",'\.....; ~ , '~c'-r., ?d:"r,o-; ,;f,;"/4 r &1< r..> ,,"t:r ""/,.(.~'''I C'~,,..,,,../ ,A1'A""'),.-,UnC-4.-. 2c.r') ,4,/.0'>"'/ t"/' 7/;,.,./ ~d"'/ "r-;-,o: /#,,(,,..... T.t:: ...;r-~'/n,..,.~e,..~ """..,).~.' ),.......,...C'.-A- ~/~,.~t?.< ("'"e-" C/';;'.h'I""-J -? ~....)C6AN'''- n.. n;. ~~ '" "-.'T7CW filt" /:./ ;- (c,1 ,4,,/ ~c:.,,<J~N">'J,,:>~1 r' r~ /:;;?,,?;y rrc:.,/ c-,.,,,{.... (? /,4) -.:) ,/:'... rL fi~,...",~ /:".C"{~) I. rL ,4//.-,.,/ ~7fn'.....""/ ';':'.j,-,-"r 'POo?"r r'" ~......J..A", / "ff/ .rA../ ~"'..>.. He"......... 76... ~,.,."r AI"I't:/ ~"."".,,.,""r r," rL ~c-n-, ",c..1' r-IY't:kK v"c/.N,,~,/, J. r.L r.& ",,,/"1',,/ /t,-n--c rUI,/ n-~,<( ..r-,.:;;..,,~ n4"/ An...... /,.-,;,..... ",//"~"c/ 4"f"'''''''''./ ,I.:;;.:;c"-,,r ,,rN,'/,,,,r r" --'-n,., .,;Ill, "FF/, .:J r.L ",//"",,,/ ,4'~$,,,","n/ .A'.:;;.:;;,,--,r /"",.."..'/;,r r-/, J.,n;", "'" "':;fl', e-4,;, C'';'7':,N,6h..'/'-/ ~ ...3.. '" fi/A-A.- ..c::"Prn- 4pl'n/ ~ ..?il_..~.......... .r:. J""'r A, t..A-#r,c, -0/ "r,//M'/ <!' .r.-,4,/ ...."'....,(."f .;) /ff/. f/, rL ~/4~,/ ./~C'77'''''7Cd ........~K ,/,./ "',.,........ .H"-" rL A/~ .,2"",.",,- r,1' ..../...H;", at I'>F/, :Z-H ~,/,,/ ~", ?,rAbh.,(,,/.;r.rL ./:z..../,.".,'-I'.n..,... /,.{."""""'j r"'....I..1 .J /fF/. I I /, . .I 1 , ~ 1,/ 1'1 :, I I ->-. rL AI'//....",/ /"J""",, T>'C'.d ........tA" (? ,/: "d) ...::.,1c...// /_ 4.,-,,/ ":>"'<);1''''''''''/ ,I,...c'-'-. ,..;. .46"...,,,,('/ 2.3/ .r'-:::' h"";"'" ,..,4/......... .2,.A-"''''~ '7l'- /;,.~, ?,.".~"....'rl.,.'r .4.."..1",,,<,,.., .Z),,~'/A./7'7 77.-,.r-?' -P O"{"',,.. ..J ,.{......t/"I;....... "':'~j3Y""j.,'/ rri. (/'?,r:"I) <'''' ~..,..."-,y: 7. /,.F/ (Oif' .:z-,v r.tt ~"1'>.,..,/,,,......., .. /~.-r..c../ fi"K J.,,,,,,cr?<< /2nc,,.,.,r 7C A/ r.l Cl) ~ /.."1..- 7C. .TL /;:..,- T~.r.7'-:::' ftr7?"rc.r1' ""C;/;K ~ ..:::rr~,IJ// .A;'~..J,...; /";-c." /,,/~/r;~/,r,r ~ /.A/GlrA..-,;v" /?//rK' /J,.t""'I"""~~"';;J ~, 4//1""/' 7.tf ,rI"/,.,,,.,/ 4 """"..n',/ ~.J.x,,",...,,- /" Ar/~J"- ./IN~/ c~~:r,,.,/r/H"'~ ..-# .-rr~"/, ''''{''/.4' ?....... ~"'-"'" /L rL A~ n<Y/ "hw:'K t::-'/t:"":;",.,./ ...."r' ~""~,A..- r. ,,"1'. "'r~",..,.-,."'-' /. ,;:J~H'T,":i" A,..,VoJ' ,.1_ ,r ~....,1" "'jr"..I,I'J~./ t'..1 ..A../; .:1 ,H,~ -",- ~,.vn""'~ ~~.h_",~.y ".,/,.....",), rl..,- aN'h/Y' """"'Ny nyl-A'.-J ,4"t>fIr.~. ",11</ ...,..",/-,,/ ,)""L-.. _""".;,,/ A~,..",",,,,.../ ,q,..:x.,_,- ;N'o,,(...,.. rr ..A.,.... .,It. ,If' ~..'. ,# /.04.00- .L.,pu,... ~/.../,..; .an.'............ ~~,,,,.. ~ """-rl<Yr. ,J,,,. ..v"'~y t", n/"./, "'rJt/ ,/",- r.t /..f,,,n,ol-;A' ,r/"/",'"",, ~__,,- d r/~H'.... r,c ,4~~,,...,,,Wt/ ,,:uc..,-,., .7, :r'r e-A. ''/)0 c'.,ni/,,;,L.'/;lr rL ....l/.....,,,....,. '/'/"CWH) 1::,1"..,{./'/ ::l ,Hr" 7'/,.,- rL /?,""" "'CA tC'~I<' ../,'/ ~n''''''''' ~_... rL /1,.(,,> rr nL.- ';'/,A.Io- "G.~r ell ..."{.,...,,...t. ,dF/. 3 A .vn/~ /t., ,1L..- ;f'I........ r./..,. rL .4/k~/ .4;.""....';./ ..#'~,. ~'H/~'- ~.tif ;f/cv".n/"'., ",: IFF/. ~./ A"....... /,:.,....... rL ~"~J'- "."../ ,..e,...~...,.- f"r rL )J...rr.r,CA t'd,;:.... t!...","';'"...,,. "1/ #c.."....,""'" , I' /~f/, of /h,,,,,// /1.-'~,J rj'T" rL /-l.'rnr,,,-,, c;,'/""" (//.4) ,a/,.c/" Ad....... r..c.-t rL .1/;:.,..../ /f77""'-"""~ 4..>.J,...,r ,,#o~4r r',c...,,{.,.., .?t, ,IFF/., "'../ P.-/:-,,6,..,- ~L". ..>),..../c/.&-<....I h~/ " .Jt...pp""....C/ .,&.,.......... rL (/'.(,,4) /1.-''u,J H':-' rL /1,/,,,> r'/ h/~ .L"."""". 7t> ./c.-,CNA'..-,..""'''....r- ""''''jI-;'rKf''''~ s-. .Tr 1'. .-',,/,.UI"'rY./ J# p..,r.:,"..{,';T'. tl3n.-,c "'T ...,j,j,r-':6"(prA) C..,!"K, "'r /J,.-"~",,.;7, r)"r /'0..",,//" n ""~tCA.,/..,/..r...c.- "".../,~ c.."k-...../ 7(; ":'7"'0/ /lL-J.'-T ,,;,..... rL ..G.,"'?'".L- .-4,,,,,.../ Ar /IN ~, A'~.......... n- t""";'_II.t. /)., TL r/"'.,,{,...,,// "",,'-'--' rhr,4 c:-..,n /o/r'- r-,...:.....cl <"K etif rL ~:,../....... "..- /\/.7. ...>. /;(.,.,........., ~r r-""Jt',~./ .III' r.4. ..4l..,r , , 'I' ev"I,.,t"I ,i...;> r:......~ /11 /,J.,,- /1/ /;l:(;',r'/:r'.:. 0-,,,, ~JI.y(.,.,,-,- /..~"...../ ,;r ;J"'<l _r/l' /-,1 /'.L.. /X,../. (vL" T,(,J .J/h,J''''' C/,,.,4."~., "';./ -,.:r-r.-n-,/' ,L. /};:',,.,.,/7-" "I.;" /';"(1/,/".,/ ,i}";::"."'"r r4 ~/""'" ~'r,. ~(,..,.,.~/ /1/,1,. "" dH") wlc. t-..J~J r.:.,,I; ,t!:f,'rK ~/() I~) '''.....-<r "J(.//tI~y t". :w,l,,/ n rL ~,,.,.,~~,J ~-;J'."r..,A.. ,/"""...t' ~ 3",,, ~,/-V AhL.- /,(...../ -,,,,/ .:.,4 e..."..,,/''/w.-t a~,. j,,'m../,L #''''''~~:J A,,{'i, ;2~,,,-.. .#...""""......... rr ",4t,,,,,.,~/ ':J A":~I ':-OH,.J:J /,.,/y Ar~ '-If,) ~l"...."r Ar .rL- A/..,,,,,> ,'" Hev.-.., ~" ;7, ,f.,/. ,.,;?,{,..,....".."'.:J ,.p/,', ~"..'rJ" ~.....,c/ A~ (''lc.''~br.~"r,..,1 ~'r MI',,)'" ? n/..w .:-..., oAr p..{..,~,,r/::J L:J,.,?,.,....., ",- 3_.:;. ",../,y- AA~.. A,-,./ ",.,/ ,/-or /::I,...,,/~ (_", N..r c............/ c.. ..,./ rL ~J,ur"c.L- ,./ /V,.7 ..) /~,,<'U...V<' ~r: oAr AMmy ~ .7'ld,,:J ~o?.-...., ;r,L,....~, TL .#-.--,// d.. /</"/II-"L.. n/ c.-..,.,.{nc" ,.." rL r:fJ.""""?Y~ /""- A 1uJ-A- ,.,d.K -'J /,</,.,I,....n-c/ /I/.rL. ,4'~..r Cr..,.?"I\" ,.;r- ..A"y .,7:3 jP~/, A,...~,.~,-.:2 tfP../:."""",,,;) 0,1,/.r- ':a" ..-LA...,'.... ......,r', 4' ;I!J.~,.,~r :J ...r;,,,- ro ..:z?n;>,.,,{,c...J /1,.,/ ~""(""""" rL '7rJr'_<AY ..',. ,,;;;,~ "ckr.t' t:....,r';' ~/i(,/""r ~/6rM"~ rose- 4,~,.,,:~H?". AH"/ ,I." TL ";b~,~, rr "./,.. ~.rr'-"'Y" .r, r/'/ ~./,..,I'-A- rL ~.-{",....,/,r'.j />,1,- __ ",.. ~,Ji ,.,.,of" /_p...,." / 7;i-', ..I"., .Jfv,L,.,.. 'T'~ t!--, > ~ ,G''jeA' "G... A"<,6,/'~ T/'"r &,.. /f., LJ/i"nr~..r~ ,r,;;k TC ~/ ~dy Ad' 7~ --e.",,,, ,,/ d :;7.;;,,/ A..t....IC/ ~"- L", ...;/,'r,#,....-r-. t.. $"".r/ /z'..I'/', , /1'/......" 7),.".- q- ,:.....,'j "j","bluL,/ ,.." ....I./;- ,3, ,.~~/, Ar- .;P/',..r'~/:J ~;/'...,.wc.., /.4-",.;;') ".J..r- /J{.",.,/." .4r?r.','"y r",yI'.k,,tJ ,4.~,v.; (.. ..1',,'/ __~mbl'JL T~r- T./... ")"'/")"'/ ~).> OK_,^'", / ,,(1;;',) "'<" r ",,.,,;,,,/,,.,,... ..,. ...A.1-oJ ~, ;HI ~ ~ r)"r- c.-.,c,l ~I'l:"""',,/ '7'C /?-,". T........ /..~,..,...4 tA...&r',,,:. J." ;<ho#c r' Z 77 /;11/ ~C ~ /'~'-" 7G A.....,. /lo/......... "e;.,p.'~r fi"c,/ ....0 ~'r..... ~;./t:.",.,..".....,r "4",Jc,,nI'J A,"/ ,.J',.r ):;?",,.,n- ,,1../ ""...... ~....,,.:. rL ,'r~",-,- /f-". (.... i",t ..4. c:-c- ) r'~";I'.I /3/ :J ~.._/~ "'''''''~h.J''''j .rJ",.- /I /io1J.4... h"'",- '-"'1> 4~''''''''/ ore ,/.'...... .,-';,/15.""" 'H,',,'- .A..,,J(',,,n"~ "K ...i-~/" .,It. I~V ,IT" ./-',4;,.,,//;; ";?"/;,..O/A^j /,1..;_,,,/ O~ ..A~, :;),/H/, ~ i-J1l1 ~"..:_" A,) (~~r) 7)",.. /UN"";//' '...,11:> ;,A/,A/C,'..,.,- r-#,L 4//",1"/ ;f,~,.,...."",,/ ~j,J ,,-,",'r: ",;./u6.d': 7: /~"r~r/ /,,-,,1,{;,. ;<I...;.....,,,. rhr rL ~//.-).../ Al'ff"''-U;4,...,./ 4~~",-,_ "WCl'at....,.- ,1r {0i7I7(. .r'1I"'_'H'/ /If/j A""o r,.e.- rL- 0-,."'.,.... r-n nf, IJ,.".'....CA he..... .11~~ <....-k1C "r Ia:.'~ ("7...../ ,IHI) C::I" ,.".~_...L, ,I ;HI "";vc/ .r/..,- ,:J,~,.a4.r ..::,ic..../,/ A~ ,,;/.../.. ~,..".;cn /C"" J;..tt?.c ;2".J~-r?'G J!!.[ ~,(c.) ~'c.....___ b..r.t ..r~"""" e...-...... ~,.......A'- /,A/ "',(",IInoo-K ..hot" '/P"uN'~ .L~m/ z....,,.,../..,, ,;/- /--e~I', ./~"Nff ;/;f......., ri..r,l,., t:I.J77lrll./ /J.,'r..vt"./,y 6......c/ ~c,"'___ A~n..t.".r- fi,~./ .1'CJ ~,t. ...}"Ick,; :/?.'J....MT' ~ .L..{ y.(<:}, t..-L... i/,/,.,..",,/,/:J A ~r,.,,,, ,fr/ #//..pn/ ,(~~,<'C_""../ ,,4JJe-.-, r .....,".k"r ",,-I'.;N7't. ~K"""H'/ /JFd "'"..... fr~ r/' ,4"",,... eM r.L. ~"?>-rfYe" Co',)., t:,...",/~, "''''rQi7tO~''>, rl...,,-/ /Hod .i2.4",..(,- ,/;./ hL ,.. ~.-:rn.rl ~ fi:..o- JI'na?JI(' fi,Jt-"..r ?C .e.{ y.re.) AT' (0117' ":',,,,,,,,,.1 ;,~~I') "',"'/ __ (01Cc'.,) ;"~"Wcl /r-r;/} tfJk,,,?,rr'J d~ ~r (ol.:;C;ol, "'-?-",,;'/$~/) t--C_lc! /Vrr N'C""-' i...... /Jc"""/~rc/7' 6......,.../ ~ ~,...c....- .:/.2.,;tt:""./".",- "":,4./ Jt; hI! ;d A<,~Cfl ,/0;" ...A;..h r/2,.>o-",,-r 70 ;i! l ,,"<1 ,41/../ ~~.,,~;'r"J ,,;;,(.,...... rc:- .~;1""'." rL ":J"..,,.,.rl"t"CA C'~..., ~;I' de"........ ' 7 /~<;,/ 7)",- ./,,/ P"........ ,;r,r_, rL.. /",.{"'> ,.rr;./~ ;2p...rJ TC ..Lt:>...J .".;';:e,d..........r ,4'.1'"-",;",,,;, "'1../ ..."I...., .,J(. /H/. , ". ~ ,. c;n ). ~ , ,~ ,.. " 1E '" :'~~:j .~, .., (:;j . L " = , ., ,. ~~) 0.. ,. ,I .... '" v-, , '. (e) othor lnculI\o within tho p~ut twulvo lI\unths 13\ltllnouo> 01.' [il.'oCotllllun.. ._.",lr"::''!,';'-..... ....--.-"..-,--".'-- ..-----, Other uo 1f (~It\ploy munt '. ..II.:=!!.~...., .,. "...,-,.-.. ....,..,--.-.-,-.......-...' Intorl!~;t t __..,..LI:.>.'I,<I. '..............,. .-' .,.....,.. .--"'. ,.-.,.-....---~.-.._..--"-.- D 1 v 1 ,I (l nd.., __d.. .,M(H-':~.. .,... ....-...,-,. ..-....'.' ..-......, ..- .--......-.--..-- ..,--..--- ponslonR .111<1 "l1l1ultlu<,;, _.J!,!!.I:.~'..-.,....- ...,.,-" .-....---....-..--.-...-- Social ReCUl: 1. ty ben'2 [i t", .,If..~r.~.~_......,._...,.._,__.._'__.._._.___.__ S UppOl: t pay ~Ir'n t [, t .... Itl ~!I,l{' ..._ ..dd...... ..-- d_."_'" .-.-.-.......,-----....----- niR<lbillty l''''lIllC!ntu }/~~<{<... ....,.--.. . . ---.-.. ..- .-...., -- -..-. ".-..~-_.._-,._...__.~ lJncIIlploYI1Hlnt ,.'OIIl[iCIH;C1tiun ,111<1 UUl'Ll1.I.'"\1~III~ )CI\Crit151 _I</....,'L..;__...-,- ~..- ~.--_.~...' -.' - ~- ._.__._-_._-.~-_._......-._--_._--_. ._~ _.,-.----w.....-~-. ..._........ ..dCI'~!c., ,., ----.-.--........ --..-.....-.-.-----...-....---..-- workman"S COlllpOllGation: ~'llbl II; other, ~,s ~ i fi t :\I1CO t ...-_.____ __.I/(J/!..~~.- .__;.._~- ..n_.'__' '-'-~"---"--". ....-..........----- -.-- ___.' ._._..,.d.._ jj.s;.,J!~~......- ... ..----..- -......---....--------.-.-.---.- -.-.-.--.-......... - -.- --~ -" --...-...----.., .---.. ..-...---'-'--'- ""-~'-----"" .-.--...-.-.----.-.... .----.---.- (d) other contri\Jutlolls to houud101d GUpportt ._...._.J_@r/~~. (W IKg,L.i!!..'!Rb,'!J!.dL..t1-~~U-.-._-.--, -..-----...' "...-...-.-------.-- If your (v/lfe) (1l11:.iP:'IIHI) Is 011\ployud, tit.iltc Employer' ..._.._.,.._,.._.._L/(I.!i!c..-..-.---.--.,---..' .--" -.---- Salary or wa'.JoG pOl.' mont.ht,..._._IICf-..~--_..,.,....----_..--._". 'l'ypa of work I _....,..___...._L/QI./.,L-,-.,--.--..dU.-...----- contri but Ions from ch i 1 d L' en: .._._,5JCli~L.__._.,.._ Con t d bu t ions r rOI\\ ch 11. elL: c: n : ..__1l91.l:.S..-..,-....------.-'..------ Contr 1 but ions r rOI\\ pa ron t Ii' _._..._.ff0.l_/!,_.._______ ...-.--..-..--,----- oth13r cant d b1\ t; ions ,{!jIJU.._.JI,.,#>c.'d-.LLh.l.Lic.!t.r<'1J (e) property owned: c ~ ~ h t ____.__...!:h~~.(i?. .. _..... .._ _".._ . .....__. _...._..u ..~----- -. _.._....____u..._ -...----~---_._-...._--_.-- CILccldnq ;.le"ount:, .~l,.:'Nc'_...... _ _'_'__~~" u______.._.___ .~_____. ....-..--p.-----. -.-- fjavit\IJ:3 Account. :__ ...~!~~'i~'_ ..d. .-....-... cort,1.Cicat(l3 01" DOP,);:i!: ,...!(,~l,:: Heal e:itat.c ( inc1.\ldi.l1\J h'''i'''),../l.Ih' Not.or vohiclc: Ha}.:(~_._~.. :.(, .'r,.'... Yr!ar -.-.-----------..- -'-- .----- _...--...__.~-"' ..-.-.--- .-.--... . .--,,-....-.---.-. --.--- .-. .---~------.. ,(/r 1\' t' Co~;t. _.~::..~~-'/...':~ ..---.-."--- _. ..._"._..~-~- AmoHnt owed $ StOCKS; Bun,],;: (/~ -,II ~ ~ . . (~~~-~:~::.._.. ... .____~____ .~___ u_.___._._ __....____...~__ Othur: ,(.' '( (,~" ...._.._.__.. __..._._u._.______..._~~._.___.--.-._- ....-. ~ --_.-~ . .... (f) Debts .\1\\1 Obli'.l"tir)IH:P,'-"J,- '2 CUI'lf'fUII\'II';M.'I'J[ CUlll,!.' 1)<,<:g/'.'1' /'.IITI'II:~; Ml<fllnl: :~(j, 1'):1.1 0299 M.D, 1994 CURn V CIDWGB~ ORG JUR 1)" nLED !.lNI'B: O'l/11/~4 AMOlJNT PAID: ,00 \~ArVElll cl\::H: 'l"ll'l-;: civil Action Law APPLD ORDER PlI'l'E: CLOSE DATE: July 1(3, 19901 DISPOSITION: Transfer DATE: July 10, 1994 P1\R'l'IES GEORGE 'I', COHH Pct.i t iOller TINOTIl'! p, CLOHGES r~fJr:;pondunt ___._____~__.__~~..__ _..~_.~_._'.. _, ,_.4___._.____._.._._._._.._._~_...._ .... _._.. ..... ..... ....______,...___.. COlJtlSEL George T, Con- ~'AX I Petitiollor 1 Kelly Drive Shatno)<l n P1\ 1"11366 "'DOCKET ENTRIES'" 07/11/94 Petition For Revlew/NotieD of Appeal Filed 07/11/94 Certificate of Service 07/11/94 1\pplicatioll,to Proceed IFP 07/18/94 Order Filed 'rhj~; In"t:tc;r in trc,ln:J[cn'<.,,1 to the Court of Commoll PlG,w of CUlIIbl.'rl.lnd County, Tho Cldof Clerk shall cct'tiry C,l copy (It tho dockl~t and \:h<., re,;ord t.o the Pt'o\:h. ~;('(' ord<.:r'. Fel' CurL\Il.1. On]".. e:<it, '1/19/94 08/26/94 Filed-othur '1;(<lll~:I.(:r'J:"."! I,> j;ll' 1:')\Jl't (:.f. CUlllli]('li Pl,.,.\:) ')1:' Cun~h"l'J.,ln,l (', \lllt"',. !'" '" 1IJ.J.OCi\'L'Ul\1< U ..--..r.-.....---;-- ..---"., ..... . --~r--___.-h.___._~~.._-'~---- UI< OPINION "'lrlr ~----.o--r-._- ....-~-,_..- ..-.----......-. . ..._..--_.~_..~_.---_.-.-.. , , STORAGE LOCATION I Procas~Gd shelr Ir** CAP'l'ION 'Ir** G1,:ORGE '1', corm, Petitionor v, TIMOTHY p, CLOWGEB, Houpondent p(J'tit:iol1or Hm,pol1dr.1l1t: , , , CERTIFIED FROM THE RECORD AUG 2 6 1994 C':e ~ Ocpuly Prot~onotllry . Chief Clerk I' II \ \ ~"::;'O?i tr. I-- I , 1\ " " " , Ii (, '; I (f (~,' tJ /1.1) 1\ ..-[-;1 ., iI' j /1 (,,~"""""'VJ (...R!~ //.- "J l- f.. .(......Jr.'-. ... ,,-) . ..-I:f:.....,.l~,'.!.!!!7f.fr!f:!!.!.!;; ~ 7_' /,) . f,.. C;;A)/C! ..t:P...:s... t1C1: "PI7I.., .:'l!dl!Jrl \) ::-, " i __ .,~ "'J (-;:~/.., ' ~. I /"....,..~...~/1: /', -. . .rJ....,r;:r: .-~, '; w_~...~ _--___.41...__. ; /i ; , / /;, , /;; I. "1 :' t.' i.J.::!:~:::!'/ i"::''::::..~t? __ fJl,R/I-!.J..'.!:!:.;. I , 1\ I' ('.-',' , -- /," ,/ I' , " II_Ie, I It? IC,"? _ ._....::nJ.i_a... I. " :\ 1\ 11 II Ii .1 II " I: [I Ii " II I' !" I ~"'C--jft:, r a~r.', /0 j j., IJ /:4: rU:'-C: /d.!. IhiS <7 / '''J/ I '/ . 0/1.:/ 4ot......Co::vne.:. 'T;L~ hc.!",I-LC:j I-n/h jJ.~ CiI'O/<!":'CI<:/ e...,';/ c:chv,1 /..) , j CC-.JO"f Clc" /I.,' ...sJ..k cr,' 7'?"I/"71<,,'vllc.:... I o-l "7;r(. , Cle. J"'7l c;:' ,.J<'/;/ Jl"e-..- IN'V. , // I I-J"',);:J,..JrcJ~j ;})I'<f'.i-<.-";'''''j I!...., ;:eel; /II /;;,,;, C{"...", I O'>d enf.."L; /Ct }h"C/i..'P (/k. fc(:("/J, /.;;/ Co_'er'l c:r- jph:'/cI"'i?J.::.. ,,-,,.:./ /))~'d;',:.;/ /?<""::c-(/j a"'k....-:.r- ///v'/li,!. ,.;-,/;11/ (:,...)/i,.'<"J':' . .____.,__~__..~._~-.--.. (." ----,--.-~--- "-'l I ~ I,' I ;:;"L'.- ,.:- ?:5::.:!.~ / )JG7' " " " (,,"j,/,. -; Cu~t ," /. . '-. .. /"-' C, /. "<.A/ 1':\ (/ IA., ~ ").~)t..' /.4.,,,/:1.../ " ,,' Ii ,'/ ;),';';:",.;1- ii., i t..~. i / / /1C (,...i " ,.,' " , I :; , . r.~ ,/c;",tr} .---.. ,70(1 H (J ('Itl ..._~ l/~:~.l..J 0,';'- 1 7;!~' -- -:'l/ ,'.' ~ o ~':","'I ,-1,'''/-', .--- ' /' {'_:;J'::'~,:,)~!( e- II )),:~(.I""",'.r'Jhr.!,J I :J (; <;,t!I2 r. Cv':;,'> ~nl.~;""-'F'~//r a c./I.:-Icll'ia ./~;. 1 /';'71, C':'/2,.:!,,".:, ;.,:.1 On On I I I I I I I I I II ,I ~ I; t..?"';'7r I, c"!1u I: '::'._~l() ,! tAd ()...,~ I " :; t.A"Or'f 1/)'/ Ii/I : I ol?.c#t2 :i I' :J I, 7Ik,1 cF' c ') (.c><.,..f a,..dNo!. I tJC"~ /. <> ~'7 J!'.:I C 1-' .J,..~ ne. I ,pJ;I,' I / '1 'f I. ;r;Ye c i:xJ<..M! ? C.lc.'C.i!~<!. 7' ('!,;;I"(,~, "7 J_tL 2Jr.t;.;:,....#'/~Jc,.) f .._.-~I..-- .Ct:,) (")/-1:k'",;",</ {~'''',';1",e;; T''''1~{')(f P {',60il.:'" /n I.~~,<~ ['~~:).).~:. '/~J J~)(fl)I'~~a..)f !,~~~ .l!/cl;)l..~i::'I': .' (""";"?J c. ;'/J I/.~ ,) {,,,,:,,,,/o,,),,,fi.., 1':'- -J.) .,.',1.1''' Ol,...(e, II,:';) ,';:.' J, I~} I 7 i //:..' IVcl,] /, ,:?.:' '-._.~..../ "',; " . '{ , 1-:) '-'i... / ' . h.. )" I, .1(,," ,,~ r:.,'" -.-.-.......'--;). ... ..~_. '. ,.._.....~. /'1'- ~ (. ,J,. r;. J ;/, "Ie " .J '... ..... \ '_.r ,_..~ .:",. I, ., '/(. ,1Y.h~, , .~... 7. ('J ,,'" .,<..,,-/.., 'C.','.'.) \.. il/;1 0.. ~. '.., 1 . f '.. ~..}.,.l.-'~. ,,1."C! .Il...' ,/ ,.' ~') ...' .,...... , - .. , .I /J. ,I {~~~':,:\).!..,_.~'~-_.Gj?!/. , '/. /; ,,,,..',) '., , ( " /L ,J .' , "',- ." I ('-J' " ?' ..,,' "'. "h-,.'-Jf .t1 ('-~ /-- _~:'::'~._':"-'M"':':_'~~ ".j.',~: .... l';" l;., ~" :'<'<.-h' J / ':J/ ,'j /,'- ,.-' / I .- -I,),: )'1':./1', ;111-1-- (<....1.',). ur)/..'''~A''-'/:f (::-(-Y'<"_~' ,'cor I.:;.'.,k: C,) "v~ L , ' "r. ,0< ' ", /(/{j"~~'~"O';"~"1 _..~., I /r':i. ./ ).;: .'. , . ,II" ,,'~~;;.. . ,. /f.' . , -'/ -)j . ", - Q _ /. ' ~ M .-)/'(c;,j IJ~; 6<!.:Z; '::;1' f.;,: '}~f). TIt' ,Dr.'f.;-",'/cd-" 0,,,<:I?l/ /, Ck,~;} i!.~ T/i.;: I- (,';C,'", 'I'J.~ 2&";/lr",...',~_ /,.../,,/,.)t'J>':;, .,/c, 4.<!.s/""'),"<?(;r'''''~/ I,., (?~,.. Qd'-'I.:>...J ?-J,:';.,-") ,L....../ .1 " II I!Cbr!." I' I 1.),))1, 0J ,.c/~ I I. ?)'''''::';''?,~e, , I: Ie. j<Jj'7 .J /.... f 1')/, '1/'-".-, /{,lr)I' T ,~ /.:; G/~~/' -s'~..b(J.!!cJ")'''.:'/ ",.<:;, .~ .L.....~ r,-,h4l.-. , ui:; -Ii" /}c./r~~/~l; /..5 -- I c.....-?Cc' /I"r'.::/'':'~~'/ ,et'}(Jr::,....:;/~ --~. C, ~_h:. ,'/ /"7"~) (,:...~.A.'..t. I.....,~ , Ii 7/" , , (. ~ /r:; "-....::'~i ~_.. ~ ..'~~.--l/...--'~ ,.:~.I' -i/."; , / - J !..::.!..~,.I.H_I I 7' '~-i'" ,.-.. J' .'" 1/ ~./. (' I;./.~.(:.~..",)I..C'" I' ,./-'~., . ~ .,/ . .. ~ . ., ..r.;::. - . .-..:._---~.,..-_.~..-.. L)/~ /"}..:.I, ...2'-, ,. -' ::' '1/'" ,~l:, . ',';' \, (, ,.- .I}"'~/:)-';"< , ')1, / t':- ,.' I. ,'- ~ ".1 ..,' {.-,'. , , ---...-...-.- ? ( \'. j ,(.. '-", , I' -";.") \ ~ /"~,,,~lt.....C './' c' ' 1 /. ('" ~. .~,/ ," ,,"~.- ',"/ , ....c:,,J1 it:.~.. ,-: .... .~. ,7 / (~ ,',/ _J ... .-jj ,...1.', ~; , , ,~ I ,.' ,. c~ 'I~I' ~ ",,' I ...1.. . I"::.,'. lei'; '-':-:-1.> 'j,l_,' /..-_' :. '//J,- ,I' l,~ .":'1 ";' ", ",' f' "/,,,.1' .'i J'"i/:' 0'1/' /1 ( .',.'",,' " 1)/2; I.. 1../ ).:' l~""'lI.11 I i i I UIc;.J(c./ICv, )),~".:;, IJ,,;' c./'~J/' t..../.' /N~.:o,', 'I ' 111,-/ , ) ..., ',. /.. /. /. (..."_'l".',1,{.. kJf...a.:. Ie. //.~ cr' c;; '~.. '1 /1~_ j),.r':;'.I'''k,,,/',.\ ,fC1/Vi'-t! IY/ i)~~'-) C.,- t..Jb"/~ /\.Jill i.J.L C -) . /,.} J ./ / ' 1',.."'JrJ7/uc"',.tv ,C:C''7J~' fe., 1".;'/ .<...II...;.,: ,tG~e I 'n 1/11 ~ .C:h." 111,,>-,< 11,,1' P C:?/r;::y;,E:2 ..z:;,c.i,'J/ifc,4.,o <-:./(/ /-ld~'1. /f.., 2),~,r.:.",~C! (.. .,.., , I 7" ". / I (' ") /.? / .~0!;..:.s2J';,' . ,1,,""c+jI'~_.._~~~}~':) /,:::, j),.,r~""ll'J <:,0,/".,'; ,-/,,' C ,/ -If} u 01""r~. .,...}", .lJ'''/:-,'1 ,k2;? ~ Did {.,;,I.:' I .,JJ..t. r" .' / . I/." /ll'::' f,..J,;rl.('fl..I..:.l-i",i'. tf- II /.'. . i',. '_.~d.4/., C"..:', ~.....Jr'J/'f~ II Ii ,-,'/'t t.J I j)ld /),:;l [.;,.d;~~rl(""",.:-I/~/' '_:!'1'11~J.~.J/.if~ ,/(1 (. / ( 0, /~.I~~~';J 1......11)(,11,//.....)0 J .:'....,'_ Jr. ,'rl'I.:.H~.-. J{' / /. T .-l t)r''/'::'' ~-'r_J." 0"0 ;/ ./"...:/ t,-A.'" r e / " . ,--.? /)C ,l /)i'1.J.i.~: J): I' / (~/I ,;,1/ ,:, "..' I ,'I,-J.I //i~ I' /'.1, ,,' ;) ..' .-........,....},".'.y I " ,. '., I: :, I: / . "", "'_~11'" ...J (~ r. IN Ie I.,,: J "") // ) / / ' / .'(),..'.r.:.'..'r/c:.,,/....J /.'.,..r'~)...\..-;/..)(:-j.'l:..~. lo. '....1) Ilf..~/('/11 C,,.,;,' !.1.Jf~'...j 71tJ _t, 't" ;./;,1-1/;....,: r..;{,',;,,I ,).le 'N c" ,,:/'" /;;'....4;'''> ,./, Ci..l heu"....',,) j.,. ../ I: 'r! ,,,,:,-/,<:~j"/.f ~ C"'?' Ik '7t>'''~(1Ii.,Jc;;''?''~ t"?:"",,/, ;(,.t<.':'J~ II ./)/.,J <! Jo ~ ! -tle i ,;0:.: .I;1 (!~;;'ec ,J.i'.x"'le~:J ~'.;.:' ;j.{J Ol',c...,-;.)u:> ) =-.--.--/ :; T {c,e,e, t.....k:J..l ,,?i,..':u:l-h'-j P. c.!Ic'f! e::, t..Jr(;>,/r-<J/~ 6:;,:;,c(.,II, J),cl- 7j{} Pk,,:)),I'r:/ ({"""U/c:..L.,j <','7 <::: -..S/.~>nl,.,,,l ;;~'<}r,., " r"':'~'1,1 {} , C/;~;,-cij'C cl' {;<;f'iJ'''~lcl..,.J /... 'pi ., (/ j 1:..' . Ie f.!:0/t:/ ,/'':'<' .,{<: r tI /3." (-',;." ,. c..-,.?/'c.(....J/'",/1 c; /cl,t? ~ j,/, \1 C,~c/ ;;"";,,,,j,~')I-.. /"."'11," IlhL j, c//c"..J"c~_'. ----.,-.".'''..",. -- ""."-'-7/ -"---"'-7/-' "" ,/..:.,.',})."I...,-_/",'. .~..,._.l.'!,',-'",."....) ,c',. ? I'L.{/ ,"--~ I . / . / (.-.,.." ~ . . . _, r.._l'j' ~e,' l. ...! I,., 1,,-,..) }r'. I,~. .01':';/ ! ~p)},: hjfY"~ ./('. Gl ('r,','j:,~~ C. 1 .:./ ;~.' .1..:~.I(_ " /~.,(.... .../~ -.." ".....- .,. ...-.--...------. ':.//I,;c:L /~_.)C) c!'(.)JJ:,:,Y)."'l'-~ 1 ~ " I ~~. / , Ci ~. '. . I. ,'I , ", , II I . . .. .. ",.~: '... _,,:,.~Ot::- ,i, ? I i,. ,.', ,''""I ~'.J '..J.J I _ .," j .., C" c..-;It:.'''-~ ---....- c.,I, ,( I. I, , I 1/, I!> ,/ / / 1 i 1 ("l. ,; ,~I /, I' ,.' ~':'../' ,'" . " ., " , ',~.J ./ ~.' (..' ,~/ .:: ., (. r.'......>1.'... ,,/ J ../i' :..,'C III'}'" .1 I.. r/ I " . /, " " I I,,'.i .")<'; 'I I, ,I"~ , ' .. I, .,_.,' ,::1- /.J ' . \. '-',yl.'r'( / / " . . I-I\.. C ! I: I, .' " ii' I' ~ /...,,;.(./:0/ .,;', 1 , Ii I I Ii" (;,:'11,;:.7 ',j (?Cll'~)'''''1 ji.."~/ 1/ /-1-, elowJe~. 01''/ 7 /...Illhlid"~?J i),,'I-,~.rl dc..,1 .. -~/ cJ::' I/t.? Z!;z -.- . 1/ (.'/) '/,"""'.t;:~":' .!v'l'I,..~l/''''1 /A;~~\et!':H...I;"'''/ 0'1 /~ 1,-,,-.:;,,-,.<;;,(:;"// (f:'r?Ul(,jlc~ ,,;::: i (), ' \! -r; f' 'iYc,,:,l):t-; d('(J~? <! 7.:_~};>q 0.:, t.'-',..// ,t....JI J.L J u I .:r:11"Ocl 7:J"Ic""rYI''r,fl CO""/ cl"r/I'(./":)'tK,. i d" c.?rl"I7I,,~1 JUli,oc. () I', 'I I I ;i !I i .J k c,~";);"",/;JyC/~CA 7/...'1'''. ,re,,!!: , 7.1., i , 1,1 .. -v. '! ~,< ~ ,d '-r' /7 /~Cn.)':'I/....ir . 1~"..:."r;.."',K"I'" /~ Lt::J.V -..------ / /,,/' - /' j. . ( , I I /, /' / </ [I; /' I A b'-JV':) j(./II _o"o,)F<'./l ("'-r~") "'<J'; C) ,C/ (,/,',', 'J"O""/(I' (. ,::,,;':CI-o'>(, I ..:J'l.h,; JeJ i {!{!l'.k,'/ /~ ,"J: ~I.~(' ..f!.:',~(~~!?(/{_'.._J / /ir""c/P" " ,,r:? ('/dt~..lrnl~'~ <_ ,"---71 .-.-; ..~=--' tl"~-' / ' ~-;~_."~/"'I)'''''' J c./,"l /.Ic" _.7).11...-'.:".1 1\.r:~J.~,.)\, , , U J (/',,/ ;)r,~.\,o!:I''''j' c', ~ hi (._h~"".:..5 }-)h~/.)J/~/)J.:.:~ V).:/ /.1,1,..,!to:-/ 10 (_....dJI(~,')l,S c/ "~,Jijll/)~rll.'/II'):- '/ .') " ' ,) I \! !!.!:~~_r~_L::~__.:;2,.. t.>~k!J/ tf.~j,'lr't'~J c~~> '{! /Ie / /J:e.:....?I,j lJ.. .t'':>ccrd.:. h.~k, CI.I/q(..d('t.! ..-- . II ,\ , ;1 I: II 7-,t T!E:.,,-,/~jYI i (..01 Jv,)I, Pt.;.:! Cr1 ! -r-/ r". / ,.:..tI';~~ !'C1~'i 71.(' [?c..'7I..N <: 1- .;;, c,t:: /'<"e,'l't! ;1'; (J,;1<"((. ......,ou~ ,k ..:),1 /9<;,""'" ,; ~',..VJ~y- / ~ Y, "" /'H..JC(,'J C/}d ~~..JC .) CY1C/ P/-",,:;;'/?-; ~fI'<>r. To ~,../I_'.j.....,,4//;I J,::},o>k,,.UC:/ c;1 tJ:,J./ r!/.,/I,uJ/I!) , -) '/1 j ?~.:: I ~1-,.,I. -1...!..~~. C"~r.Vl '~ . j. (;, I' , I .. I . / ;. 71<" (':,.,,1,; i~(.j.-: ~I'.r"j. .; l',t.J ~../':";",,,J' )f~~f..,C.'/) i I I: (Ie,?,?, II ,. he;) )}~""7 (/> ./ /) SI-,il LIPI'?), ) , ~ (..4~,r'p<.: Itv1 "J ./I~' /'. ]")/'/:);.',./11',,,,,/1- c/:' 11./ .' / , , .: <' .), ", "''', 'ei'>; J. ,) -- ---...----. ::.T/ J Ii " i .J ).....~~(I ~ CI.- _:1 ;.) e/<';,."rl.' .II':"'"'' ,,?( '.~.'l ,- I~....:."} ,;' , ' c/' (') , . _ I"u"j.i..,j,'/ ,-/\.~.,l,..::. '" ,<" //1.'! ,j, J ,- , ,,- (/. <,,', > 1 ,. I ..(~.l,~~1 Lf:.l!.:6-U.~:..t..L_ I ,I I: r I II " I' " l\ I ' I . _-::;"n,J.CI1~-~. ,1 II Ii l: I' 'j/ I, . .,,' 7- /./, ~ . /.... ,/ ~/....(.,hl /-, Ih"C(a7<~ ,r.J;t:<-.', .P'-J('.;) ,:"" ,;;o:...JI-"7 C.,..r't'Jj..."I, G"c/ I.Jrr.'.':.J 1-7..,/:; t)c 'J un: 11""/ C-? 7:lou",,'>,J h?1'1 .;,y./ ,~k /i~ JiH'/-l.~....;,.J", cu:;,!,S .10,-:, <! (;..,t;' ~v"....~/, 7-k /-/.. 7;".,..-, C"./ JUI.~ ,,) (';'f' ",,'J /0 J~ t'~d. In It. f)..."a;.-..Jm'Ylf: Ik J;}r:!n1-<:I'<")"/1~~::' c"c Ii.. JJ....4v'/c.I~ /t.> , ., cr' {(;/",.,>" L"~lJ , -?-' ') !"'!!:!"!.f..t!7f- I, (; 'lJ.........<< 10 ~?knvJ"~ ,{...,/~,~ ,~.~ , ri.. iX',,.,;',/."/', 4,y,'7ie. II __or' / , ()()~12 , I j~_ ,..:~e'i,_.e,~ J 0:1 ~ ,~-- ,/)'1.. 1//':-~~1 clc/I/~-.,..'j ;;::, II (.. ';',/'.,(..,.;.: /.~~, ') ':>'/ , /'7';":.~. J ),~<i. '" ,iF"" I " t'Jrc''-:JFo:..1/ (';"1 ,'" / ,,I, r'i ' ":.,,,,,' ,~.' I 1_,,- /'./,' II) I' /'" I./.',)C f.J.:/I~hr~/:J t.,' 1M <.,n' ~"I:: (:>/,;.",.",../ r.<.'jl{":J,,'~':t (''/ " ('~;."...11f'1;'( ,-JU,)/'(.'L~ "-/J,CO'I,J. ell ,f,' u." j'r1i, () I ,/;::.... I, I.~,) I " , ... ..._. d" ( /.L- .r-~,~ ~.,;, /hhldl''J (.~0",,,<,,,,,~"'::.p ~ -' 'I ) '?I 7,),,~/;'J' / LIC(.....~/....). , . ,--. ,/'-". '.".,_.,-- ..,,_... ,. .1 !' /.)j, '> ,,/ -1 -..:."'!::.:.!!.:.i-,,C-y, c'.J "'<';1 e,. r. t..':'r'l! JotJ h,,~,..~.... If.-, ,j"'r')e",,,,..:. cF ,,:' Jel j~ 7~.:;.r!. /~ cha,.J J),~;:;'''kl<Yl/~ C~JIC/) 1,5 C? C::'~O/'-',/(:'.4 C.Ae/ ft, 1..),//;hd~":J' c.,c- .?Ur"J.../X.'e' -) j,' / hC("J '?,.";U ,.,,' I Cl- /h'"" ,n'~J V/lj.c;.J~I/ On';,)I", " ~~'r' Ih"v' l'l-i4,,'/.;, i il Uc'~ C. kef; d~ /0 ,I ., ..:r; 1 t'o''l~;.,.. /"u:e ., -I),J t...x:v/(I " (.J.1t'/ If,x:...,I.,/ Aa.>--J1 7Jre{.......,kd' Ii..? 7ft.,,.,;'!',?', d,.,-o,y. ;r: d""", c-') I: c~;' .'?-)'J(-'....r.,/~/ I / JI- I i <;9/ Ii ,; 14 wrl,r'J-H;/1 ";),1':'-'.: Vlh,OV'/ {JC/1UIC-/((/'1 Cr' ,;J'l, /"~.,'l. C:; ,,/ kJ ))/l"',14 II~ , i. . I '/ ,j:''''')~) t'.'f ....", t"~ <'..'4':' iL ,rlco.J ( ~. ~ "./ ., " ,/, ,.., l'tu..I( I r.. f. !{... I.. ~;r':)/:"""/ (I ~- ./ ." ). "' ' " L' '/-'" '.-"' "..../,. U' /,' ,n.'" ',! I,/'.I-'.~l ,\ :; '- ~!.., .r: " . .. ,/ ..'" ..'/ .;7' y" .' !'1;9~)1:'. .')I:_:il':YV.J~;i r tHHl1by cl!rtiey l.}p,t 1 alii LhiE.__7/i._._ d.,y /oJ' j' 6urv i Ilg thl.! (IH"V')" i 11\1 _.r,,;.,lJ..x.L_',2.~ '(~d__. ....._ I',;r:;ontl nlld ill thv llIilllnVr lndicdtL'd Ic'llow, l)[ ~___._, 199'1, _._~.:::.--. ll-?>oll t hll Which norvicu NdtlHfl~s the rll'l"lr':IIl.'ntll U( l'a. H.^.P. 1:.'. , /. 1/ .J I - 'J) I . <.. ,1"''','''Oh..J ".', I (, r.. O'-'/~ c'f-',' ,-,.", '\V ',kn'lI t..... t. ~(,. ..5, (,:V.;t'ir-,. ,(J'''ld/t'} ~/.::K"'f.I ;'u,.1 il=,/ 7/';;~> (, S IGNNruHf.. 'ld -~~,-,-,..i.\~_..J~-LfZ!L_'h_ /J ,'/ ,..- A~~.~~H_hdL~~~._..___.______ (/' " , ..., I ^ d.] r cs!; ,lU{L~''I..',T..L.lLLt.x::i.LZi.Y,jL,JJiI)j2. , J ~) V,>,:;,,,,,, ,f'1,.j 1'(; /7 J-t.t.. .....-,"'.---...-.--.-.-.---..-- .-.- ...--.- I', Under 10 P.^.C.S. !H904 (Unsworn falsification to authoriti(3) a know- ingly f~lHD proof of Hervicv constitutes d lIlisdemeanor of tha Bacond {h!~! r(!0. ,] rJ f of servic"" to b'1 ser'/0d \lpon tho fOllCWl.ll';J: a'~1,.-x:'7t...J...<, lit... ~. ._1 CF- jl'{ J ' (,/,; ~. -""'(/10.)60/"- c.,~~ j, Cl'h,~ /Jc";,/",,,:, J -;') l;'l';~.'.:' I~~J,:::,?/,<.. 1111,.:1(1 ~~~;,k')!1 ~ L>l..'~ O'''r:-O'"f'''' T L"'~'t:! . ,..C'".., rL- L~',,-,,-r ") ,;~" ~"""~'::H ~tIIh, "..qffr..Jr",r~ -I / ~; .. c:., L-.~, n,b""":h-JI'?-.: "-l.._.;1~ 'l ' ~~')"'-7"~'oL- c;.J C"~"'-',.JL. .L14'-'-' ,I:)/'-IN;c:.,.., h:;'H.:;.r,fy ,4, (.~,4......;.,.. I.';;; . .... - c~:.....- NO.' ..:.-0.:,-1 .. t:;'Iu.> I' - ;'c;.W, ~~~"-'~':J~- ~/'7t::'":''' TZJ ;Jot~r;;,.,J__ . '/ /7 ;/, /.J:;7 . /"''-..J';A1nr ro /~"'I"'J.>y/'--"Jn,"-'- ,<(..J/.. c.:/ c..-;,-",,/ /,.:".C"q{.~ /01.r.1 :?-'?"-7;,... 7Z "J,o;;;,-,,/ .:z;-,:, .h",c.6/ A~ :.-,.,....;, , -&L.c-/:.' /') ~, 1/:::'""" h~,-...... I 0;;C01-" ~ .6.....,...., n ,..::....;..,/ ;,,/ c.?"._',-, .r'/- Y"'-" <....A-I..:>h C:.'X:~n..;; ..J..-r /.!:,'/h ,01 ",.L... ...-c:.//"".:....Jo-~ ~C?<.~I y c.....J , aYJ~'~;'dr .4n~ ...<r(::......""/C -c~_ /.J?,-,~;--' //J.c:....... A,' 'l?c.,.., .:....-, /.{"I'/ ;Tl..,...,."r/ r;;Vu) e./o/-' ..o/'T<"",-: 7/7-'0 0/,/'''''''0-'#''''-'.. tA--I, If. ,L .67 ~rJ r,., '/'/ AJ. ~,'I ,-,-...."J j-4.-,--"-c"",,J1r' 0,- J.7""rr.::-...",,/ ".,.,.,,/ /:~'?l -,,? 'A_lnTo'J e......,r Y'--~I' (./""~;'''Jfi!,~ C"... ".JbJ~"rTc,'J'J T"C..; rL. C:::~..,..~~ 4~ --J"'r,-"...~;: -.s,.r ~,,'.If. c.;'7 ,:,,-1-",,- y",...., y'uo...J 41"< t......X:,.-/I...Jc /;{"...-.I.:-,7'........ /A,I ;r.:::- d'G> 00 ,r,/" C':.i___ '~h""" /?";,-,,.>,/ ,^-" )h,.../- '7''---- />,.,d; .4- J,-,4",N?'."T "'h.......,.. .:........, r/u.____f A.,,' 1-1.,. /.L.-J._. ~,.;J?~',,-Cl/ o;"<-//I...;r '7"'~ "";-J,,:r;.,. <.... /--r- " ,'.. 'J 7 /1'h:.., ',..''( / ,r. ,6 7 r"--<. L- c_....., r- c;';~_.";;I"'1r'"'-;/ /r' .......L.. .....;: L:.c~...?/f-.l',,'T c.>f' /(;",,' j..... I ,/1 .Jl ~r -T -rL..... ,/,/<',n,. ,'/r, c,,,,.,, r::i'L.,. C~(... ntl...J r.", "G.lh~'r- ~..........,;......'/" v.:~ r)--J'"7 /~j.~- 1 """"'''''''7'' c,- /^"'/'- '/ c,c- (Jfl,. fel'/.) ,',.., ;:r.,r7;1I1r1r rtJ )/c:....J. y'~ ..:Jh.......IJ .?;J,G<- ~.i,.;. //;1;0"" 7"'c;j y,--,r h'-"Jt",. ," r G;.,.t"~, ,. r y........ de.. pc;.r h",~- c.... ,'(~I.A.;YtJr Co" C-hr,~< r .4/~',;"../ ern'. I 7''' n:.r c...- n/--,.u/''''.w'''- ,rL. C,";CAt- ~r /<:,,,~1.. 4../c:......; ,;TO /'r",,/ ~r L.-<."J.J...I-<'-' '1"'--' C~N"" )i','r ~"?N/ A..~ L'.-,...../ .4/C'~ _. ~_,.,,--,/r#-' l -~",......., ...Jr. ::r~:!:::~?~fy/''' C''..I''J/r.....;..o..) '7/2 ,yy~ - 5u.-.o ~' '/ --- -- --- C;;'''~r/x'''''' A/':",nA.,K',) "';Vr/ c,;~ ."",,,,..,-,.,,rf>."'" ,'n,,/'..."''-'''d) .r;l~""r ~ C-'-;-".-"",,,,/ ,.d..,... (.....J""--,,, ?""~.J,-",<,/' /N rL ~",1 I'L" r"I~".r;//':.i '///CA:: /J...:r"''''c0,,:;",. '--..J/>,~L ~.,)v,l,t~/ (h..,.L.....,<~/ .::/r.~,o-,''''' t")I!' rL.. /Un,n/~ ,,;-1../ 7'';:'''' ,.)...,0/ :;l'''7i''cT;-C'} /;.',...7 /;1"":.,,, <.-..:k< '/>:~r'" ,o,.,,,,,rr.-L' ''('./?';;.4) ~,J--' , '//",5>",/->--- J..,o""./ .67 ,..., /,;"'(...~~7,. ",//..;",/;~ e.-;" /2-1'-'....~ 70 rL /~..J..."":r,,u':> t!.~ ./A/~- ./:~... '"-'"..~.J.rJ /~.., .AN .,./CJ&:y",...".",J/' '-.J~" -k',c/ ( ? .r; /J) >'''''-~-..J <'""r ctr r.L..... c'-' 1)0 ",# ." "' //~l.J.hf.. /~r: t:~('yJ ~." ~"r~,nAnr#,' -?.Nn~,~~ .~~ /~ ... /,r, ;4, ~,,),.4 -7 '/r// ,'~ / /';J /::-0 r,.- r.L.-,;?'A,~. "uH,j C'..l,k.. ,.,L .:k;'i~'h~-; ;;-;;..,r?.4 c:::-;S'----;;<' 0 "/,J/h',r c.~ /.IN./J.',.-n-c/'rc. ,." ,/1r1~' "'':'~.(/ 7/,J~"_ /J~~/n7?J7~' c"Y" ..')'-""t:.L " / j / I ...",,1/,Cfra" /;'~ C;;''''rn~rJc..:. C_;:-",..:;,.r'-'....'-"aT /) / / / i.~''':.,.~I''r''..,)..u'../ r:'/ A (. Jr.lrlf('! t..-.....;~..." J ~ ~rl>';;)'.., c, /<7'- , n .,;{. J ,-";'~/:c:",J/ L"-;~'~rJc'~y.. , .) ;'1cft--"'/ Go.- /-i.-'i"'c.-r.'</' C:",:--",,',r/ ~?'7rt: /"......w77,J) ;;T'l::; .;;/",,;r-,.,'/ rL... ,on r":-" ?J"."......;..,,'n,.-J) c'/" ;d 4...-0-.._ ,;~." .;,_~~ .-.. 1';-- / ,(",, A., /J,J /./-:,........./,...1). (.....,,H J /;;/.; <'- " ,/1" ./' ...-: //h,r- ,II.' r- .:-,. /L" '?IJ (l'{,'/'r. TO ~~.:...,....,..?'-"........)~ ,..,L., ,,/~ ,>"n/ rv,' ~r.Jr.___<- '" 1"1'" /;) / r"'-' h"';.rl,., ..q,-.I;i.~:", .r/r'...J 2~,... oJ.n', L /,,'/";.,,/ ;+,,'r.:> .77:/ ;~ ?' - / .........:: ..::'",-./___'-'" A....,....... .1'- / . ........",. 7..,,,....,,. _ "~/"'..::.,, ~ ,,~ r':::'-/""",,) 7c.. ~~ ,4 NC-..,;?~ C,' C', ,.,;J/~.).__~./ /.1>" / /;) /,."-4. ,-.,..I~tl_ /..iJuG,...,I .c.; ...,"'/ I':-!).,.' A / / r-:. ._, /,',,'; /~""'d hA' ,.,/J,.,':',..,. ,~ n ~ :;/ , .~ / /c...)- _)-,)~,./~.. p;!€'n,."" 7C".J c:"-/,/,;t:,Y,..:",,,,-' ? v,'-"7 ;J ,I (J'll.> ./-J?, --' , ~/....../ /; ~~'4 ,,( i"" // .v.,;,.. ..""o(.~ .-r;'u.J ,,,"/" ",'*'/c "";J?";//,.) /..;..u / 7t' .h/',5-"'-'" rL.'__ ~";,l.'~ "I) / /'~- '} , ,.;~ .- 1/ /~-"O,/-,1 / /" h~, / . C:?.A-,hJrc. ~ /n /.L " /t:.-"~.~ / . ?,' <:/ ~',,>.../ "<j)/Jh,.., /#.1 .ck~"',~,,,,:) r/.:.. /..?}fl'JlJ':',., 0 c;-.~~..~,,/.6/ ),-/ ,~h:'''",,/~/,;,'-- c:.~".~" h, j ,L2... (' ~./;:d~;'/'.-") -,;;?::/.;>- "'?'" '"--'- 7 //t..'c~~~ h' /"L,-q .:.....Ji/,('~j ,-;-/'? I " L ,/./" /C.-......-"- '''? r _ ,.,~- /-, ,'-' j, <.,/ ~AI.>, A,., ,/ ,,,,,::'nlAf<'-' -.-Jr..7L.rr- ,,',," ~OO/ r..-v,-'(.-,..... ,/ " ,"'.' L./.-/...." (. .//. .,r.1 ,4,-"/"1.::r, j ,,-t/. G;tr-"t;;,. ~ :,,-- ( ; ~v, /~~';7//.. / ",:;r"y' rL_ (;'~~-~.....;;-- ~,,'. Cc;:"'j.~/,t /~",-.) ...<, /- ) .-) , ._ (..-......//_,4,,,/ r.F.~'7 .,I,;i.""-7U::/K"- - (~I - aoJ / ./A4<--' ~J r.dN<'''/ '. -;0,~~'~,4 ':';%."""") .Ii: - c1-;J ." "I#j..,._ ,Alt...., . ":'~-I' -C;'UI / /~~Y. .D"..c::.(.1 ..-::;...",-~. .-."} //,..,~~. ,"'~_._ ).......v/,::: <- ,. ..-~). , ..-' ;4, L ,/ ,/ - -,'_ ./......'.1./ ~# -,-' ..r; ...':"Y....&.'j:.-4.'- ,-,,..tr"; /1-~... '/ c:.:-.:n-'7 ;-.I"';r-"'....,,,. ,..l' - .. .,... ?,,J.-:' l:~~' ,'" .. ..~ >.r/ 7< '~r ,/>..22/ ...:;"...-...."/:.".;'7:02"1 ~ r- .;r. /~ ...)..,..-r/'/... /i:;,,,-,p",;i ~.'nc:-.,'..l) /2"-,),,-,,,/,70 ./7,/ ("'-Jr..- /!..'f" /o:>r ,<IN,..;' /01',';1' /r:.' /L J'.-t ~l:_" 0) '/'..>>'?",/4k--..; A :/ ",,) ,qUJ,/, -r;~N.,If A {;9c'''''''-:'>'''..) "21' ) , - " ' //) / ,~.,,. / ~"~"'I.. /_;;-'.'lr~,J ("'.... ,;r,;. II(.. // /' /:J .~/ / c-,:" ".,~t'~..;, ,/(..---7 ,:'~..-.,."'~. ) /. ,..---;...." 1';1:........' ~.- ~I ~-' /-' , /' /' --' . .:' ~"'.'... ,/1'..J4. ,AI', /'Z;'_J , c?~..../' c'/ A~ r:> ,) " /L" ) /2 ~'" L.",/"',,,./ t" '::'-'7 t"'f.~r/.".,.....,.' / r'f:..-r/---~ 7:Jc.:----. ~~.;;_',{ d /;','/.:J, _,..5.....,;.-..',.. J.,?7..J/("/'....J ..rL :~~""'____r.J r."c-,/,1, /o~~ .A,/~./,z/. .' '.. <":) ~ G::~ lJ1 " ~-- . .. ;'~"3.': ," e:l 1'-") 1'1.', "I",. ( ,-,. ,-, '..J:.t' ' ' I':';, h: ',\ <,) I: I~\;.~ I c. r'bt ',lr7 fjJ ~! ~- ;_1: l"? " ' ~ll . . . ,'3W u.:' r ,,1~ ..- :J.; ~~ I, II, ,-- d (') tJ' 'I PYS510 Cumberland County Prothonotary'~ Office Page Ctvi1 Ca~o Inquiry 1994-05051 CARR GEORGE '1' (VB Cl.AWGEB TIMOTHY P Reference No., I Filed...... ., I 9/0e/19~~ cage Type.... ,I PE'rITION Time. .1..'... I -+-1~8 Ju gmeflt '1' . . . I .00 Execut on Dltte 8/881 Ju ge A~s gnedl BAYLEY EDGAR B Sat/Dls/Gntd. , I I Jur~ Trial.... Hi~ er Court 1 Hi er Court 2 *******..**.**.....******.****....*.....**.....**..**** *****.*..**...***.****** General Index Attorney Info PETITIONER PRO SE 1 CnRR GEORGE T o E KEL Y DRI S AMOKI~ PA Y~e66 CLAWGES TIMOTHY P PUBLIC DEFENDERS OFFICE CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE CARLISLE PA 17013 RESPONDANT MOORE SCOTT D **.............................................................................. * Date Entries * .................................................**..................**......... 09/08/94...PETITION TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS FOR CASE TRANSFERRED BY THE ~ " COMMONWEALTH COURT 8~/1011194 ORDER OF COURT IN RE PETITION FOR IFP DENIED EDGAR B BAYI,EY J 2 97 PRAECIPE TO APPEAR FOR ARGUMENT BY GEORGE T CARR 1 118 1197 MOTION FOR LEAVE TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS 1 97 MOTION FOR APPOINTMENT OF COUNSEL 18/08/97 MOTION FOR EXPEDITE DECISION 1 114/97 ORDER OF COURT - DATED 10/14/97 - PETITIONER SHALL BE ALLOWED TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS - PETITION FOR THE APPOINTMENT OF COUNSEL IS DENIED - BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J - COPIES MAILED 10/14/97 U~~~~2~ MOTION FOR EXPEDITED DECISION 1~~COURT DATED 11/14/97 IN RE 1997 PURGE - IF NO ACTION APPEARS ON THE DOCKET BY 7/1/9B THE CASE SHALL BE PLACED ON THE 11124/97 ~~f~~~~L2t6N~~~~N~~RGE LIST 12/08/97 PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS 12/22/97 RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS 81110511ge REPLY TO DEFENDANT'S RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS 1 22 ge ORDER OF COURT - DATED 1/21/9B - CASE SCHEDULED FOR 1/2B/9B ARGUMENT COURT SHALL BE SUBMITTED AND DECIDED ON BRIEFS ONLY - BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J - COPIES MAILED 1/22/9B ....**....**.........*...................*......*.........*.....****...**..**.*. * End of Case Information * ..........................................................***................... c--- ~ () \.~ '.. i 1 / ... ,.' r;= l,t) >. r ,~ I,; f': .. " ~'I; , \,'; '. , '. - Ii' ~' , , , ~'" . -, (> ; " " f.j I, tA , " I , :...: " ,. r~ ) '..' (\' (.1 . tit . - . ,.-- i J~U ~~~~ ~~!::!:: ct:. ~!~ ~ ol$ i~ tIl ~ . ~ J ::; ~l <Ii l'!~~ ii-"'~ fIl' =~~~ e ~.... f c~, -< ~~~~ tIl ,- 4 . "'" "'. . . GEORGE T. CARR, PLAINTI FF IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 94-5051 CIVIL TERM v. TIMOTHY P. CLAWGES, DEFENDANT PRBLIMINARY OBJICTIONS AND NOW, comes Defendant, Timothy P. Clawges, by and through his attorney, Scott D. Moore, Esquire and files these Preliminary Objections and represents as followsl 1. On July 11, 1994, Plaintiff filed a Complaint in the Commonwealth Court alleging that Defendant failed to properly defend Plaintiff in a criminal proceeding involving charges of aggravated assault. A copy of Plaintiff's pro se "civil action" is attached hereto as Exhibit "A". 2. Plaintiff failed to serve a copy of the "civil action" on Defendant. 3. On July 18, 1994, the Commonwealth Court transferred the matter to the Court of Common pleas of Cumberland County. A copy of the Commonwealth Court Order, Certification and docket entries are attached as Exhibit "B". SAIDIS, GUIDO, SHUFF 81 MAS LAND 26 W, Hiah Slit" Carll. I.. PA 4. On September 6, 1994, the Honorable Edgar B. Bayley denied Plaintiff's petition to Proceed In Forma Pauperis. A copy of Judge Bayley's Order and Plaintiff I s Petition are attached hereto as Exhibit "CO. 5. Defendant was served wi th any of the above- not referenced orders or documents. 6. Subsequently, on October 8, 1997, Plaintiff filed a Motion for Leave to Proceed In Forma Pauperis, a Motion for SAlDiS, GUIDO, SHUFF" MASLAND 26 W, HiSh 5'...' C8III,le,PA ~, ., Appointment of Counsel and a Motion for Expedited Decision. Copies of these documents are attached hereto as Exhibit "0". 7. On October 14, 1997, the Honorable Edgar B. Bayley granted Plaintiff's Petition to Proceed In Forma Pauperis, but denied his Petition for Appointment of Counsel. A copy of the Order is attached hereto as Exhibit "E". This Order was served on Defendant by the court. 8. On or about November 2, 1997, Plaintiff filed a Complaint against the Defendant alleging that the Defendant was negligent in representing the Plaintiff in a proceeding involving a Protection from Abuse Order. A copy of the Complaint is attached hereto as Exhibit "F". DEMURRER 9. Plaintiff has failed to state a claim upon which relief can be granted. 10. Plaintiff has failed to allege facts that show that he is innocent of the criminal charges filed against him. 11. Plaintiff has failed to allege that the Defendant's negligent representation was the proximate cause of his conviction. 12. Plaintiff has failed to allege that he pursued all available post-trial remedies and obtained relief based on attorney error. Plaintiff has pursued post-conviction relief and his appeals have been denied. A copy of the criminal docket is attached hereto as Exhibit "G". 2 .\ -, CIRTIPICATI or SIRVICI On thist '1'.... day of f.i, ~ J .e- , 1997, I, Scott D. Moore, Esquire, hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of the foregoing Preliminary Objections upon all parties of record via Uni ted States Mail, postage prepaid, addressed as followst George A. Carr CA-5933 1 Kelley Drive Coal Township, PA 17866-1021 SAlOIS, GUIDO, SHUFF & MASLAND By: 'r ~ 8 _~ Scott D. Moore, Esquire IIl1lflltA .. i. ~ . IXHIBIT "A" I' " ..- _____.____.___ _._..____ ..::z:;,..._7:i~._ L~""'C/i(..)(o!cl.(( ___.._______._._..._'___'.._ Cr' J;lr1"~/t-lCr1I~ j 0 C{ tJi f) Cf ~ t?cu..:I-:..... ' .,.,..._to. "/' ,/' ...--..---..... .. '-'-"'-'" ......... ,......-------...--..--.....-. . ,.--- ---~_. ---...----...---........--. .-- ._.... .---. ....,_...... ..-.---. ...--.-...-..-....-... ..---,....-.-----........-.,-..--. ...... ..-..----- ac"O ~ -:T: c?aK/~ _,,_..........___ _....".... ,_..., _,_" ..,." CO::>4. /'10:,. ~17t., ~;!,./FfrL_ ..-..----. .------..'" -----~-_._-_._--_._..... .....-.----- .------...----. -.-...---.' --.......---.----.--.---------- .....--....--.... ----'-- \),~,~-,--_._.._.----_._."-,-,, --,----,-,-'.._--- ....-...-.- ,--,._-------_....,.._,_._,- . -.-.-------.... __...____.__..._......_..___.... _...._.._._....__._____..__~-....__ .. .._._...... _.__n ._..__._. _..._.__ .-.-.--_____._ ..____,,_,__. -;;r.:.-..;~/'y )::? c:?/c;t...Jf~,S _....".___.....'_".. ,.... ,___..." "., ,,,_,,"".' .."...,..,....,--..-,- , I pr {?,-".-,ho>,./C?/' c?",,-,,?~, L6l?h,4 71:. ::=:----1 ~. :=..-=.'~ !:........:....:-.=:..-:....=..:~~=-.::.:...:-:::.:.:.::~ _ .___._......... ..__.___.w.__u__.__ __ .__ __ ~ ."_."_."_ , ___ ..._..._. ..._~_.__._.. ,_ u - _._ .___. ____ ......... ~..____._._.____.,_. -.......--.- ____.__u....m..__________..___ C',,'u';/ o(!./'c;'" ....----...-... ------.-.- , " --- ------..-.---..-.------.-.--. ...~..~ -.-- ...---.----------.----.--- ..._.______ r~._C,.1L...,,<(a&L..eqm,e.:,~__,_r,t_'_ ?kl,,1-)0_d'...o/-e..._.'T.:--&If~~__~ ._.. ..' ,,,__~..0I!/J _jJe__O,c;:,,~.xI-C/._e(.,lC',/ CCIt0/._jq__J.I7!_.L~""c.'Cb{,,,~ . ._____...___11 _j3'JcL..d'.:...;cI.. .sk.k ...<'E. j}~''1A'e'L,;...~"",~.,tluL.~"!, .. '. ',:~ ,___u_,.._____z!!------;_oE;__JCJt,____c:LJr:L_Li~~~"__. /.. ?.L'I._._____~ . .' " .. . "-,, -- -- ------" -- ----,----.. ,,'.."'.-- ------.. --- --------- j?".J;:"""'/~Zz.: ...:.-- ,.. I ',' \, '1" _____._ \__ iJ21."<'~_VJ_l:.ug----/:l~---ECc:.L5.. /.Y.:I___lh_' J_c3<..JLO::JLea C1dI_i& h__._ ..-.._ ,_.._?.cr:x<-p'___,.;.t.__Kal.s,-- .6;;--- ?-'Z--C:L--PhGj.Olr.~,o/...s,-o,-"L--- ._______._____ r --..././..2..-: a/C,d:/... j2....Cc.-~ -----.(f:./c,.-(f ,,1-/11'<'_ a I- i,L 6~Jl~J,.j';;5--~-- __..___'d ,..'_, \ __ d.____.,..,..__ __ ___ ,h___'.__ ___ _'d ,-_..,...', "" ' _____ ____ _,,__ --- ------'.-,.--- /:K:"'7.?~" __,_,,, ____. __ ff'eO?-.r:__{!c./.?.e tJ;/!' ~ct-l.__. /2"'J/,~c/Kt/I;;t_ pf~Su--,I-.__-I.Le______.__ ... , f .,_____.__......_' _'___'__'_i'..-c:,/!,;;.4,./ljd:,--__ _...., -- ,;. ..'-'''' -- ---.-------.., .." -" -..-- --,-.----' ----..-, ~_._H""'_',_ -;___~___.. ,,__ _~.. ._._ _ 0--._...... -0'- __ --._.___ -. ."'.. ._.--. '.~I---- --,~--~~ .._~_.._ .n_',_,___"' .._.._... _ _'"'_'_.' - ... - ... ---. .-.-..---. . ..__' '_"~___'____" _ ...... ._...._......_. .n,__ _ ..___..____ "','" . ,.., " ", r' 1 ~ '" .'. '\':\ '~\'l: '., :k~'~. .. '1......'1.',.''''., ;,. ~!\o}I~~i:?,' I :"I~',,~. .~.';., ___~ '__"'_~.h_______._ - ')lcleIY1Mia~ t?/a,.;n -. ..:?99...HD-9..!1-_._ _. -'-.'-"'..--' h--__-;-...._:--:--___M.___ ___._~_.._____.. . _.._.. _, 'U.. _h. ... . _.."'_ h.. _., _. ...._~.. ~~.. _.. ~._....._~.~__..______. p..----...-..--- z-.t -..I?~,,;A~E~.....aea7e-,~:-C'Q~-. tvo.:.___ ~.mL.a.~~CJllt~- '-- '''' ---.. ..Q~~~esr:.C/..m.O".J_.220/.l~rl:1bt!!J2.I-".:t "--1.L_7..71. ~.,' OI:1_Q,_(.oo,.C'-'ICO_--;-_, ".,--..- -cE.....Q-,(lo,-,,-,-i:.__ar..dt:/Z.,_L/1C:i:.__t..JO~. /.. odJ~d_cn._../'_m-e,_ 0l~"__1.,~..2t... , '.,,,,-.- -, ----- -, --.-'----.-.-. ~--- -- -..------ - __..u_. -----____.... ,_.... _ T II~ __ a bo~ __ Rle,,.,,(, i'l ...-- ----. -.f.1c20R~~..-..-r:..-.c.?.;>~t?./ '_t...J:::.~_:o,opcl,.;I("d_ L?=--r.?.se~__ -r"';'c-l-ho P.. ~Io~~~ --."...-. __ri..~ ))eG"c'c,...1 . ,,-n._I/u,j.__ eo:...z.._.__-ICl__ ;2epl'~.se.7L.I:.<..i._ lJ/o,,.,I,,F'1-!. _ ------.. C:~01 ~..-. r.~_Cb2,C_o n.__ t~__ (.),Cric I,cn, , cE.._I-k." c?O<J,,!: o~dt'~,--, "_"" , -"-'-.. ------" ...... ...--------.--... ..... -.. -.'.... ---, - --- - ,--.-, --, .. -". ' - 74, PIC'"/'E';-:', .----. . r;:"1J'--T. .ea.,. '0,;; . 0 dw-,< . :r;'''dJ/:.. A ~~,,~ .. ~ . "'--"'..-- cllor-rlI''-f___.lt.'c,t, (";CJ....cpp:',,,;;"'/ /0 K<";:J , ,f.., /.~ /J/c,,~j,,~-;:::.,.n_. ---,--....... -:r/n!:t.e1.:..e.,._Th"'f. -&-E""'1.e ,T l?C'!/~,.. /S,:;./_cc .u,A,'7e!S:o._.IQ '- ------_. U.tr::-',E{;~~. .I.hd::_ hec,...c,e..'Jf.. C1?-/2.. 2),,/, ac,c u,.c,ick , .;L. (!CVfl.:f:.. -i '. -- ----....._Ot<!a' 'K,__-:Ih.~/ -~!o/l.~/d5l=-.tv:,,),,.. {.mL"t.o./cuI7...-0cK'~!>/~./._ ;:;..K...~L_..___ -- .. ,-, . 72,t:<u.~',n IxN! 1",:!.':,..l.rf/._ ___ ...,..____, _...____,_.. ,__ __..._.__ _ _ _ ____..___ ______ - " ...1 _____.,_____ ------_-:-7k. 1Yc,,..,t.EZ;-C:e-,e_z:._~o~.__.o'/w..)~d'... '.. ------ _m -D"*~~,-~e,.,~r-u..vd/:t_B_c/c,....O o,__zhc,,t. fJl':;I",!,i',.r' h..>:;~~LL "?:Y. 'l;.-~" ,. ,,/. (/.;, I,.s b / // J. ) / /J:" ' C", Ir'~__J.--:- ,'" ~.\~__ ___e". P-'-'. '-' ,/:)(2Cr7<'!a,_'-IJ_,--Cvl' ---"..r.o_r.e~"J7- -.---- _C'.r.L,Ik .P/c,,.,I,r-.r...'J.__.l:>c~I'?~~ ,_ _c"c-L_/o_.. S"'bpec,',./_iIL_________ , ;:>hc+e, <;KC-;OA.,S ___c,., L /I/~d/c'j.j?e(!c-./:,__ C,0a ...Io__c-lk_ plc./~/,rE' ".$__h ' 0 ,,c;>C&"1Se.,_________.._,__.. .._._ ,.,._ __...'____....__....._______ '___"""___...__ '. ______ _.._____ .....,,-- --- h",,____ .__ .--./;(ot<..<-:-t.'~....,....- __h. ... _ ..._____ _'_"____ ....., , ________._, _..",. _.__.._ ________._. .. -- , '- --- - - - -.. .rh_ ])....,/(..,.,./c..,I...-/'/",;..../lllf__? c-.%L-V;?<!' ~ __... __ - - - p. .. ----...- ... -?:.>,:L.._ac/:... ...r",-){?)IIJ;'/c..- c~ ..;;7re/b~__ ~jt!__ ~4,.,ce._ c;:c_../k______ .;? ... '" % .------ -- ~)/'-."71rE'~,--,7.:~"',J-t. E... e,...:.I -- c?C.i.e. ._C'.,..,/ t',-,c,J ...r,., c:l~e::;,'Z-.---d- , - -r cu/,':""> ':.."J ;r~FrC.lIC,~:-Ci. J.e:: ,clll'c(. , .c;..,./ IvC.L //..~ en A.~...e::./;'-~ u.... f _C'~_:.,J,4~.~" ~. (1:v~t:/_.'Ik_1_ l',e.,Ju/!.,.J /'1 1.t-.0rc'n<J/-~II. ,.___.,_, 1/ ... // '. .-....-.---..-....... ~.L?C;;I.H~lton ,~c/_ .rLL"g~1'. j)~k''';m",..,t oE .-Ik J'/c,';.I,,.r!,c::I____'__ -- {gcOJ!,'----'I.---l?orel2. _u__..______ '. ,,_..,_, - _,__'____ ____._..____________,_.__________.._ ~--,------,,--,----..-..-..-.-.-,___T~ ,-.P/CI,.;/,.i:'t"'/, .. A~"7e.-- '77_. t3c.A!.e'___""'lnj: ., E:"dL__.J~,_ Ecdlo"..n'1-" t;C c.f- ,. ___ '_. .,.." __.",,' ''- _. ..,____ "__________. ~_-;- ....----,---- -.- ---.. -----.-. -.--- ...,.. ,..---. ..s",q, :-..-. ~h'''lfk.f1 .'. U~ ,.. 7<=lI'e~, I_.:ti~&.' -,U";~'..h.t.V.__{/9,"7)----.___.___,.._____"...,.._.. .....,,__ '.,___._ _.... .." __ .., .___..... ____...,._____,-.... ------------.-,. ------ t"dJ1?_"'___ ~lokJ :.___ _ .. __.. ----------- ----..-- .--.... --- xl- I1c.i be",..,.. D'f../a;""'d'G . /"..1-4__ .. LCr".J___c;E_d~ _(..!~,c,.,/ /VT~ __C;,.n...",~,c...,.t, 0;:::,1.f., V"'?/__. __-..J/~..kJ__. C1.,"J/. ,,(,kc:., , . /'h= I: 0 _ .ZJ~,r:-r?c/C.., I ,m Q... c?r.o';",';cL ' -}J"'-GC,(1_(!d/~_, ,6c~._.1.4__ ~/J>,I , I(.J-}Jr~~",f ---T4!~/''';''''7 ",Lh,.l C<-ut?__,_ ,beJ1i:.tE..._ t_u/-j) ,-""I.. .,1-/.,,_.. (.m/o, _t"r7;"'o'.I7"~r/("~__ c..c.:_ Jk _nau..,.,.-,n-t",.,j,....__., ..._ _ '- - c,?,.____(bv,.,,:,.d, .. -- -"-'--- 2ao?Iu:..,,(c:..., -----,-.------ '---..-,....,---..- --- . ---------..--,-,--..---- ,..-. c;/~,O"..z;.,__ .t...)C':'h,;'g!c.t"I_ /---T~-~'I"o',~__._(]ou,.f___ S/ck-/L__, ,,, __:' _'__'.____._._____ ---- ,,- .-------.. - - -- - _n__ --..---- ----. -.---------..-7.kI?!Jhi._lo__ CCl5:g". T~ -.-z;.~l-/~.1---c.c:..- ~_jl:2~J.5 ~~ __C"rJ '/'/Ou. _ c?c.--.-.~,,~_. ,1,L.--e... c/-;"",./o."'~-e.. _ IF__l1u!c ~7 1- /.5.--'''7-,..~/c<__7.u''''I7'?..L..-Ih_ 12IJhLlo.-_?r~~I:-_o____ =a ,,6-~;c~. /- Jhd'.__ .jY_L2~ h/:.u_ ~L pre" ,!,ro" f _ ..,lie ,. j)~;:;'~./cn./:s. ---VI! ....1.-:0__ _cJ;;._-I:k._Eccl.s. _.__,_______ _:_ ',_.____..__._,__ _ , _,_ ____ __ _ ___,_, __________ _'_'_ -...-, -- ---..,,------,,-------A..r.,,/-,L,,:'~~/-----.----,--. _____......,. _____.. __, ____,_.. _'____",_ ____._ ---.-,---------- ---- - -'_u,.. ,. _c'M.:/.--'-: .;L-_F'?,c",,/;c..--e .O.:,~/:,k,r?Ce.___ . '''0___.. '~"n ._ ._.u______ ..__... ___ _ .... o J__ 6QI..n,.~)I-..",J ~. _ (:;".2IIf;~L.L f ? , {?c.-?jkk,/-c:,____ _..___, ,___ ,__ ". , _:z::l . 5kk..:,:__ cE.. ,1-.4____ ___ __. -'--,--' 'h_ -::: -----.-C?:vm4!/ ,.,..,,,,,::.1--...04'7,-,C:)l7- ..::r;1U~jt(8C.k. C/1 cl._ ;J.>r.:e,tZr.e... Ik_ ])6",f'~_ cE: c eO.i4!!. -----..-"..-.--.----0-- -- ,'" --..- --- "'- -- ---- - -- --- - -, ---.., _ --- - c"c/ {!cu..,~L.m'ujf_ Cd-;j'1..1c:1;r , -~r;,'-'e,JI8ck____jJq" ])(6rl/J;,;;, {'Ic,~ _ c:;:: cllt/: Iv,/'It!'.J..S___, . '.+';~-;':'..,-; :-"-'~ '. . <, .;}:):)>~.<.~~," , /~ <"'I~i': ',' ' ,,' '~;.)r~'. '.1: I . .,'\)"1,\', . '.n--. ,~. .,1" " ~ -;.' j.o_.}2a.5f!n.t C,/>I:J/.t0dnt'.:,:;,.I/?.::1. ~.,;,. Cf..JC.,lcht.1!- lo.j!A-_.,___ ':D.::,6'at!C-."..,__., ______.___" .........._ "__,_,___.__ '. ., , . __. '.____' _...,. '______________.__. ---- ..__Cru/._ c ")1' Ecj"",~_..I n. jJo.J: ' Cr. t...J/?c:/~__ tv II L I:u.....o_... _.OL~/~.bcv.:,_..3;:F'..,-J..k.".J)~Gr,~"l'~, '?,..nr?71(')Cn/~ .em.!:/ "4.i'M_. __'___'.___..________..__,_..'_..._______'n_ .'..__..__________,. .".____~!.t_r<:.G,~/-..--,.,-, ___u<::d:.:_de._ .2J",G-r1.:hn.i"ja_.-IIu..~_ c:c~,---7in'7clh'-l' P.. c?la"1~:J-- ___.DuL._/.?c..t... '. Cd'7uc,{Iry'_-.:&;:1<")o1'JI-~ ck_.. O?C/ P~~._1-.:4_~~e__ ---cG'_._Jk____.(3,;J,.(lr_c,Lt0(.;'-<!__ j),-ho"'dC?I, _r;~cll,';,(.. p_ &~.".5 . --~/~';oC.~_,Cd':!ucl/;7-. I/?I./.!').,I {Jc Ie Ii. .2>...;l'''r1~/:J.. c:?/CJrt-t_"ce:__ .cl.L.t.J/_uilm'.J.S _t0ho(!4..Jc.J CvC/k~, . Ie- -/.~, ..Z>....,;:;...."..~r o.-r-?L..db~Z_ .oc.f..._p~u...,t.. C klL. t,oJl i-,:1<'JJ__ ,6:-,,: ,,/ Ie j)",&;r?~~" ___ __ .__ ______ __ _m._ ____._____.__n___ "'_n_" '. t'JcJ':; _ C _ OI<:lqltc~,L . c;;':'__&GJ!/c<-,I'J__ 'j';,r};?I/f/LJG'lU':"- &.,);., .(/,0,__ 0-, ./_luCd.________ .. --'-' -----_Tk._.:r;1Cr~c<'c_k~__cf)j~ J.-!.C-?C~._. c/!..__{'''L,p.r...~__ ~.J _ ha"....~r?_k.LL .-.....- .~__,();:II.(:c.L_1. J _.z_.cc:.__ -Ik.2J.,?-';17/'-'C/J/~" &...,~;;_t..;jc,-!-). __.._...___..___. U".", t ---- -'".----.---------- '---..'.,...----..--,-- . - -------- -- ,__...._ , '"... _____,))/...1 e. ,_..[0______" I.... ;:Le._...r;, er.~ec~{"';~,'e~c,___c,E l J" _])rr::-,.,../C/OJ 1_ 7i~c.,ih,-/ - P e!ct1e5. _______Ik_. }?/C',l!Jf/_ bC'e,'J <J._ _7:. L?c,.e,e,._ tU::; .L, t...Jr(4')fI-U/~;-,-_._-_. __(?-/'1w;k,.L.~r? c.--C:/7C1t!. C"~_o~&,.cuck<LCj.5C0IL_ /-hC:/:...__,n... --------1 -5_ke_d.._6::~n:L_:d_R, -- P/C'r1/,r:;-:/_.6ec?~_7:... e,,,,,_ t..,rr7.Lc,wE.t../L_ - ._, ..,..... .....C/.?,i!.c:;;'!,.. ~.._ _. h,__ n. _u."._.. n. ._> _._~ '~~"__'_ _ __________.. ,. 'n .", _______h. ,..,__QnJ. _ ])c-.f;..,.)'/c-J /_ 7)!-~;c/h,( _I) _ C jc;'r'"'' DI'~/, ,___.,,___,_ --- A_u_.J:b/1Ck,f.... {,W:::!;','J.~.2-__.6C:1'''' ..1'L//6-,-" l. t.,.Ij,(d-_.~Je.-e_ ;.!.e__ ..__n.1 ':phcJ-oJ,-c;2!..."> C,1d ),11/,c/c::'/ /2,.,cc.-c!J. /0)I/t.L _t...Jc..J C(.J~j~~.._.._.._ , -..,- ---__j()_._C_j::r:,/~o!.- r:~'.."':'"r>" /'?<C?JC/~~,t .1'--'. PjC(,..;;' ;--E; -:;cor; e._.:c___ --- -- - ~{?arCl2--.--,0h,'-( ---~'1" t..; d h(,)c!~/j - _c!'v,('J.",')('.e,' ~'7_c;_ a,..../1::~'~::,I_c/1..__. ._r:::E:"'_ C__J:c/,',""', ,..j 11__ Ch~l-y&"I"J- _ -!-I.I!. ,.0 ,/..,..,....-,lo./..-ck:;1_ c;:;.. ____C?rru',r1d[ _ \ / ,I'r::~ ,.,_" , ___ _., ____ "',____.._________.... __ __,________ . .'. ~ .. '.I . '~' .'\' , '," , ....,. . . ..' , I'." ../' ~. '., , H " ,I 't' , . l.,'\'r,~~,i" ,.... ''f'~' ,', ' . ~'.'~";t.. ;' . '. ' ".\Z\;"",.! .'<~~: .. ,,1 ......___._ ,,'" _u.L-..t.?O,-e" ' ". ,.',', - - . ' ' ,,- ---..,... ,. ____._ _______._, ~;l -Tk.. odic:., 'S--(?OrYIMI'~~'/-j,/l- rk.. }),1;;',.,./o,.,~.__ _'" _ .. ___71';':~i:h'-l-- tp"elowle~, ,CJ,'~/. ~. I0llhlfd~?- a~ /-Lc?_____u ,..____ L..t.ll_~"kl u..____ __._ ____ _..__.._ u..__.__.._.._ ,,- ..-..--- ". ,-----,--,- ..--.".. -.,... ..-.------ ..-.. __ _ ._ _____. _.__..:.____.___,j/c.,:. __/r?eJt...l.kd. /,,?_"k__ "...N~'Oy'/tf;;'dL- c?t:4?ul(,.i'c:~Lc;.E:._... _Ti~__ ?/c,;,;,;:-r.;.. P<!<:/I'l<!.-"r:.., (bM_. CJ~_ ~...N'_ - .,W~)t._ ,j~-----. _..____ _:r:::JI.~gcl_:_1Jek:Mnor,.",t.I-__ c:.--.d. . Ob41y:vdm8--.Jk- a./;nI"'I.skc.4~.. ... ___ ____ ,__cE:._.er..u'Y""'l~f_ JUl!Jt.e... -..-... . - -- ,,----- -- -.. -.-..---... ,.... .--- -... -. .------- .. .. _________ _ _____' ._.__.......___________ ".. ....________,_/ -LI'<.;::C.~',__ _ ,___,_____...__'___' .- - --- .-----. ________.._____ ,. . .. __ __ ._..' _____ ..__...,___1./..._ ?Ic,;'/'):J:'/ n-::c?~, 7:, a. .._____._ -&xt:>.-(.",?t.O<--JFC.-I1"- o".~>J-.,~ c-, c/ ~r.c,(f~/7 - {?CJI'?<.JI<:I..../,_ dv, _......_.._.__ __ 10._ ,lie _ ReJ<JIA,.. cE_.lie :Df"t:-",,/c-,f / 7i",,",<:,I/',<:/. /-? ~/~<-J'hE? ,-. ,___ ____ ___ ___c2c!./(::",.,5 ,c,c" tJl!i'h<JeIt'j'. ,!"wk"....r;:" ,Crl A /?C~' .n,~"':!lt;t/'>j _,__ ..____ __bt'~ .T.._ ('""",,'J ..C//..(;/:" ~.uln"~.J.t?>L.p~~,t,d'-- c/t6/.I..IJ,;'.s..s .....__._ n_Cr:lc/_~-_ /?c f. .?re-:W>'1IY1~_..J./~__ Dhclo<;rcr.2J...s ,C>I L ~-,,1..c/;C:;/_. .CI ~ (? u l?.(>cdS__jnh__ c:c.11krJre______ _, .._...______________u____......__ ----,-.--- __, _. In______'~.__ _,._, .__.., ______,__". ,.,._..___.______ __...IJ.,ye_~/_ u______________ _..., ,._____u_..__ .___________ ___________ _..__________ _________,- . '__"_ ___ _..__7-~__(!(Y.1<.J{~i.~___6E___ :-_---rk 1?!4.I;t'r'rl. ;;~~1'e...;r.- e,retl.___"'-'~.;}.j~U(;xcL__C'1L.;::.-7..:..;;.:... J .., / I ,/ . j i' _ _________ _'-1:.1 /J.J/,VCd.____Or::L_/.:)OU..rY?tPr 1- dJ'1'l.j9.2..2...------~'---------:::-~-..-7 / 0/ . /" .,.'.- ....______________________.._ _ ___, __ _--:.___ ,. __,______CY.1~._ rl<:i"j,j::~__O~:Z _C>~.__hCJ, ~_.n(/1.1_./.L sl,if ~/r:1},--(,J;'1J..O""-'EC.-l--- t:Jelc",,;d. ,.' ______. _::L., --ik. '1'H,o::d~".M~ 0:::... ~.!'C/,c/,~, Cl_&4IJe ,'n.sh,iL___~_.. n.2)........,,/<:. .-Ik'7).~;:;'r'clc.,J'J>, 71r>-'<:'I:!:;t., -p eIO""'j"5__nC(!,.{Ic,/'l.!,L, ,.____.____ ., c;~__.:z;., f'~L..o::4~/"It':d.. 0d ,Tk "C{,(lr(..l~/,,'j' -I~ OO~~W;J;In:.4c/, .___..____r;:L___a,0',.,JI_...;'-'J4.~ _ 0:::-;::' ~,Ihhdc~rj C(.ll.,loo/.l~e,_ _._ .._u_____ I -----------------, ..,--.---,--..-" -----I - ! f,'J.( : .:..~ "'., p, .r .\; . "t,"" '1' ,,' - .- .. . ,'.1..... .'..--' ""'~'~""'j " ';.~Jl": \~. :.f, I ,~. ...., ..,\....1 'l;'J' , .'\';./" ",', "r .',~)/ '/-.- ,. , , ~ t7./Uj/C'r, _____, ___._.._._......___~_...n.8__'__ ..._........._.._. . . _'___'__'" ____/~,.__7?/C/~lli'E;" !f..O_Ch~~ - -r.-c;~"""'.~~J...., t.'".,l.af..J;;1..~.__'__ _._..___.._ ._.CdX'')&d,._ ea,,,.Ltvrc<:lJEL ,. cc.?~Ie..fl!'Q'< ,c-? 7'7ou",,-n "J:"pLL.o>.YJf;, __ ______, __ __ ~_.4_..:I:i4._.fn C?~E'~ -k _",_, O~::.e f.ka~_cL_ ~4-<''-2J.41, . ._______ __.______ ___""__________.,______._.____ ..,.___._.___._____. ._____._..C"L.tl-Ja~._ ! , '. '. ".,," i ... ._.______. -.s.~7~~.;<<)--l-k-:-~!'.t~_eE"k.,,2-/0-k-- ~ec:.!>,..-;!n_-/~_/~.,<<..J'md i. ._______ _cL.._~~_(<%lJ,'--2;~--,b,-.l:. -...r;'~&~t:IV#/I~S.~._~._I--J:,L.]),.~..M.: _ __.____ _._t;fl2~l.-j~'-I___.7?, _e/(JW:J.4~_._.._..________...._n.___'. . ,.: (j f/ / ~ .~ ,___,,__ __ ..________,__..___O~~~;,.!2,,_____________.. _.... __..,_. ____________,____________ _.._______" __._' ..____._T.t._.7?kLo./dc:._~e,----- _ _ ..." ...._...1 _,J,....r?.oi!/2/. ___'s'eeJtS. --- o?.S':_ .-h,I//o'r1__dotl::t'.5___"c:4:_.-Ik-______. ------ __u __._____I__~.J~6E.rIL_L?0(.1f.:.I(c_?..c...._7J~I.JIOn7wl. ~<lI,./'i7J;>., ,'. __ --_ ----___ _ __..______ -----'----1-- 'u______:h,.,.. ---------.---..-... . .'-i. C".<_j~ 6~/j______ _.__ ____'[ __d_J?r">1!,.,cf...Chc,t!:>?:;::-ct)-'-.trU~I'~' -I 0.#-"","'/S/..-:/(0, CE.____ ____ _______J._Cf:'.r::>::1.IL1~L_Jl.J)I(~___ O'cC<t1.\t-. ..pl'lY.-",./c-,. I 71,.,.,dh,--;/ ,_p, (-'/~~.s. --_ I U - II 'r-'. 'I / ' , v ----II--.r..?:-=:'h,L.,.Jr.lnhcldlrj--Cu'd..""!:-<!.._--_-' ---'.' -" __h__ -- ----.,.----- , --..----.---i------:-----'..---':------------------- -',-' ?.Ic,n/'rr:;. bec~~ .or., {?,~iZ__.__ ----.-----~ n~.d:.b~.-:.. __.ft1.k?d.:,__jpj1~ ___--/k._ .5&;7,4,.,CA..-_cL.. ~-- /0._ ?-r~~ __n._______I_ UC~ck/,-:..-d~-;jcL-j~..,c~---7J~;;.r.?d'O')/.:s-.a~~':-chl.5--~"::' ,;..1 - , ,____on_on. ~ _.:ri:JLt'C&dfl.H'!_CHf JJC/JC~___QJ/_ -/:4 __ t'''')l/6f,cI~':J--'~'_l'U( al~LX"<1~__ ._ ,."" u__J_dhcf.__ 00...../ c/..._ hc.vJ._ -preu..M_. cE:._.PIC'JrlbE'E'J.. VI1J.c.-.J~1/. cJ,r:Y.d~ .' ___,___ _cE:...&U5tr1b.oL I_L J/- 1.-t.Y:9.L-_o'1 c/_ ~c.vIL .Ac~ __ ~tHl?kL .j-/; ---.u-------I-tv.CC::lt~/L_6,,'1l../aja;L,?'c:...-f/..e--1fr!-,.;.?i't!I- /feory-_ :C__a~_~__ _ 'J ___u --.. --' ___I' -- '22C(..l~Y7/~ / -- ~y,- _1..~7~. ,,___u_'_ .-----.-- -----.-- ----.---------.. . -.--~-.--- ______.___.. _u ______.__,__________n _____'nCrJd._Je, '. ;p~~I:._ .;-k:s.. t!'tJ(t!~4~,j,C~_ i ----- - ----ua<.<'-'j:'___Lc:_.l?(C-,r1Or,~~..L_{'d"d CC.k.c/, I:'.. -J rcnU_ O:7L C - k=,,., i-- .__m _ ____ ...'..J__ SdJ.(. I, /. __ _____ _ ,___ _______u I,'" 1,;:,.'.,.\ ","i" '" 'r.~J. ".,' , ~;;, /,~ Ii, ., i '. ..f,h~'~';;J;:. I~ ~ . '~.L) i;:,:'"j.,:,:r ,p."J- , I"~ ("7~ . _ ,..__ ,\ ,,' .1 "err HK..)/."c.rf,;!e I . . _ , rk PJcl,;/,irl I'~'-">?-?~' r. c..?c,2P-, pr"yo!. ,;:ce , C,-? '~rlt/l CF JU~""rl..,,;.. Q6CII~Jf -Ik lJ.,.,r,..,'1dc..,I-:s,/ L?cmm"0dll~ H lie ,l)d:'McIc.,.,/:.r 10" ' Uc.::c4, --Jk ..s.'n/"~"I.e.,__ _ C~', o? /0 S~ '1"(;/..5- -I A r I (...Jc,J. . /rn,?c,:,..p,/ _ '-';t:Jco? .,tie _ ,P./t;!<1''?.9:: -,- --. "_H_ _m_" becr"-r... a-,,:!__ &t'1/"C<..JH-(j__ c-,J.._ ~nnrlr . -.-----____"..__"__'" ,__ ___om __ ____,.. __ _m__' _,_ ___...___ ___H__________ ______ ...___. .._____.__ c", r/.... /e,_?~I:.. __ _,_________' _7k_.. 7>/~,,.)IEr;-~b~""1r!.-]7- a,,,,....____1: ~_ ,_ cP,_ s::., n'Mlle.IJ__Ddks .______ .___. _ __" __ hY-___.j~ _ t_.Jr::'C--:!~/L C'Cr?UI':'?C'; __ c~ --??,,~~t!J- ~'1,u~12';'..___.__ "'._ _._ _____CrJ.d.___-Ik_u,do.4'j- cc.__ -d-l.- __?ICM/'/~' .5___'J?.r?'1~/UC/u ~____._._.. ., u_____ ,_.._._CtY-l~.It_/...J./c.-i 1_ __ 0.':>____ bC0d'I"? 4,.oL_'?/__o,e/J.c-;:Z_ .t..J_ 2. _ r:E- ~____" -----..00.r?(lIUC-71 v:.,,, (?C/I J /, /.....1, C/J r C j t..,NII_ -hIll.. . 'P1<:!t'1.I,-~/j_..___.__" ,,____t,,!~., Cr> d" ./'1'_': .C~I"r:1J,.-;1I..s__ cr~,t4, V..ut.-/ 54k;._..." _ ____ _(~,)LUc/1, C:.> s/cLecl.ln ~c:JllInrJC/) us, 7t'>rcS s.7_ /r1,__. U _ tVC.Jh/~.I<%) I Svf'r"'~ (!c...,.-I sL<^kj__ "._ ,- __, r--- --- . , , , ,C/?cl a"(j c",/ Ci/ c:/j,.~_., f ..Ja~"""""1f/ C t./rif,_ 1/1<:1 ;;",(:" ('&.-,1- ..5.~.....,..,j. ,L; J, la, ' " f ,. C /);;..;,:,'.;...; h:..---",J!-e pv~,~u I f cf!_-Ju>llc.e. _ u - ,..-----:---~--. I' , ,-- ---- H - ----- ..---.--. Cnci_/2/CJ.<1IpEf-_. "" "l~e~~e r:HCcr~_::h_~/L ~'" ~',<rol_~--'~.::=---_:-.~------.~-.~_:':-_~=- I ".__________.___H_______ --.- --, -- j)~"c.IE"dt SUhfff,./ltL,____ ... -:--: :._' _ -_:,_:::-_=:____._:...-=-..,_--- ~~~ - :;". (J~-----"-_- , _'_Hm _". " .. '.' i7e:.-Z: _ ~ ., \ 17Y'-/ . .. I.~. ') n 4, " , , .. . IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA GEORGE T. ~, Petitioner v. TIMOTHY P. CLAWGES, CUMBERLAND COUNTY, CARLISLE, PA., t Respondent I No. 299 M.D. 1994 PER CURIAM ORDER NOW, July 18, 1994, upon consideration of petitioner's pro se "civil action," which action names as the sole respondent the Public Defender of Cumberland County, and it appearing that that individual is not a Commonwealth officer within the meaning of 42 Pa. C.S. 5761, accord, Pennsylvania Gamefowl Breeders Association v. Zimmerman, 122 Pa. Commonwealth Ct. 52, 551 A.2d 361 (1988), (district attorneys are not statewide officers since their functions are limited by geographic area), we hereby transfer this matter to the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County. ~ 42 Par C.S. 55103. The Chief Clerk shall certify a photocopy of the docket entries of the above matter and the record to the prothonotary of the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County. CERTIFIED FROM THE RECORD AND ORDER EXIT JUL 1 9 1994 C?):~ ,40!::3:~. O~nuly Prothonotary - Ci;:~! Cld: i") " EI.*" C ("'I Ellllbll D @OCT 091997 .. ".. ae?,~ 77 a.K.t:'.. -:2 . /",.r;71~#A!!' _,... _.A~,d. CJc.-r~~a~ d:.. , - ~&.-,k,/ 4 4~/..:c-/4t.' .., " ----.. ,___.. -- H__"__" v..__ .._..._........____ _", .. --,--.7i~4 /.? a",*~ ~: ..._.___ n_........._..._._~.~..... :[J..~,,-~k~_. -----..----. " 911-'.50S'1 -.. - _&(K/.4~~'.:sas-/. c:9CK'/., ., -.-.----.. ---..-------.-------0.. ...-." .u. __.___..______... _.+..._..........___.. _ _ "____"__._ ___.___.._......_ __.n.__.__ , - --.---.-..----..-.-..-..------.--------, ~0'7,1'<<";- /1,c, h~~ . 70 /~t::<'t",../ -.d..._____________ . . .._ .0...-__---..---.--------------. k""~A 'Q . /:. .o...//~_. . ----------- -.------._________.._ ..~__, ___ ..n._....__ ., . ._. ~_..._ ...._ 0...._ _._._,___.~.._._____._.___._~__. --------..,--u;Z,S G-4,.-n::-_Zb_,_jZ.',t/~r...G-?~~....?uL c-;C'. #;O~/~~.#cc..../'~. --------. ,-...zL_ S~/,__2-n774'1"'~_ -A.. rL. ,,4~,- a~,..L __",,~-c..-. '---'-'-'-'--7-kk'r- ~...)-- rL- d~c6L._. 6? ,,';C'.. /i".K-. hc.......i_ 77::1_ /-:?cr,....L ._..--......._-.-.E!---~/n?A--..12 r"'1//:!J ~..-- /,if. ~/"'L,r,4H/.e.._ i!'"/.., ~~ AlCC<::.rr1,Pi>o/h'(;/. " -. /'1?t"77e"/"_ ~K-_ .AI/~,//rffr'-~_ ...~ ~"-'---Y>~,,,, ._____.:_______ "" ____ _______ .----..--"..---...-...- --.---.--------", ". " ,- '.. .---.~...) a-n/7,..",L --L2_ rL.u. , -. ,,4rTAcLL h~"'/'T,..r, .'~",c'/~,../ "::'/~h?'-"7T ~/ j:C~L. sc. /. __ __,_, , , , -' /4-n-r~1I'K -4_ c.,N/ltL.___70 --,i?:~/"./ ~~/ i!'"~?A-;/-- L. _______,,_u__ h-C'.),_ .dnL ec..;7-S,- .../ r~.. a~rL Acr/c.J, ___".,_" _____ _. ,__ __...._....__ .. ---~..,~~~:- --.--.-. -.-.~ --==.-, '.. '------" ---2~~~~---~,:z=L' ._u__..__'_-._-._-.-.~__.===:_.=~===_~~~~~_...-_=~~_._.:_ .~-.--~~" "t:/'2 - -.,-. ---::~~__ .:;:;?:4;... ~. ;t..-;;; -- V2. /7J-Cc._~/C>-"/._'_'H__'U'___' . ~__."_M. ___ ._._.__.____.____....___~__._.._.___._.________._.___._. _ ... -'.0--__.. ._.___.____.__.. "------.-.--.----- " :;Z.~A"~ , - ,....'. _ Jf. rL &J'-r'~'- &... .~ d: , .,- .,_cZ"k-k./ ~~.tl\.' ,. . __., " a~t!_ /7 a.K'.,., . ~""., - .~..,;~-4: R a f~:' '{!;f: _ _._._____.___,:LJ,;t;:.rl..L..~., '" , ..--~_.__.__.~"..."..~". .. ./? q~ \ _ ~ ~U"/,At?'1'r~ ~. .sr:;.r/ &~/:'....,..,., _..-.~~_..____....____.__.._....,. "_'_'''_n__. ._,_u' _........,___.,._____u.____ .__._._---_._._-.-~-- . ....... _..-- ..>--.....-..-....... ......----- ------. '--'- -- ..-..._._'~._--._-_.._--_._--_._--- __...__.-....._...._ ___".___..._ __u_,._ __ ._._......_._..........._______.. .._._. ....._...,....._........ ,.,....__....'......_...._~,_ '...... _.___..._ ...._______ _._.....__.' (.J/r/~,...e/ ,_:J7.i!7(1I"r,rl-"V- .~-.==-' ;?r:;,~i:':~~~Z-~L.'.'..,~~~:d.:.8~~~=~:.,'.:~~~~~=~~.,',~,. ,,,..__,.rL._y'Z,,-/,,{....J. 2ot.../'d':,L 0/ - /J-. ,A,.. c-? .s._~ Yfcv. ~,4/..h,.__A:'.d..,,- ,__u__. "'" _._..__/4/.s,.F/eAT"G4'.. 7I::L ,4"",t.lc~d)-7~r/_____" ,.' "'__,,, _..__, ___.. n'_____.______ -.-- ___.'_____n__________._____n'_h.___/)_..L t:::'".-rL-&fi7?'C4~___, ,.----~ TL,,4~_ c:;:?"",p:/,,;,cr,.c"'// ~nL,6t"c~.t:"~-r?_v----...----- " --' _____........t/WA,vCM/:_ ~...dfr,'~ i .:r "'''1. ~<l6t:.._7lJ ;P"':/-..rL., /C/~N'''?-- .' ,&;.<'..) , ",.../.c/ &r..l, -___n'(t:V._ >2r,"1r'~_ r'~, ~'--'-'rl~/._ ,,___..'___ ._______.,__, __....____.____...., ___._____....__ (ilL &n-:-.. <'~. /'1c,c/c..,,c,";j' T.e/J,'./jC"K"/:J;-~. ",..-1/ 2.cc.-cY.f~ /3""'/__.'" ",. (c) C-,l--,t,,___ L?c..l7..l _ """J ".-:;:..,) _ /1~Cc/;JT"...L ~",LL rh &u-/ /7<:'//<"0</'__. .- ..~,.,~)_7.'L. /C//~rd ~7~'~d~_/Z~~/(j': 'rc,./H7 4~Z~~'~~..._. ..-.,--.....j~T-'-h- rL H<'~ /JncL., a7'.!>-,-CE-j'7as~C:CJr/7J: c"/"", C'~~"H'?d--"- "-... .-- r';:J.. ~(..J"./. .-?c;r,'c../ /J..e--a-__ /~ ,p"c/ &,.,.,CT". 7'0. r-L- ~"'T-: c-F__ ".,----.;.a:y...-hc-..)kcjt!..,r.:z:- HH-r1??A77C',,/,,' ~ncL.J3'...h~A':.__ ---..-, -7-.---...-----'--- ., :-. -- ., ,- - ,,- -....... '. :L?-,....-. .~~..~ ~ "f2;:;:. __ ..a.P",'-__"'7;: _ a.c!I!, ;.?nn"""'~ ..4. -nL. c:?.......,,,,,-..:.,r:. a.........u. ?,.(,1~, " ,_C'C-.l..,k../_&'~7" ~r'/.........,~ .. """_'_''''___'_ V'.m ,. ,,_,_...__ ___..' ...... ".. .... . .. . ..,-...,._, ?7.....,,.cy_ /-1., c?d,-,,~..._,..__.,_, ,.____ '__ .."..."..0__.__... ~,.;:..""rlr ,.._..... __..'., ....",.. __" . C~<.I'" /' ..cr,w,. NCh =,/,. ,..__ __" _... _ _ _ /J.'?... n"",_ ~.c. ""~?O,wr,...." r.:" __, _.,.. c/. &'-'__ / ,....~.. _.__._-----~-_._-----,&------~----..- --- .., ~ -. --.--.-..-...-...---..---.-.-...-.-.---.-----. ---_. ..' __........__..L?Z;Z;~,...._A...T.L_cbov4- ~r,.T>!L e...c/'."..,,,,,.,,;..'...,,,... A'",c."r- ~.:;.....,.. ,_,..___ -- ..---.--_ rLJ-.#tJH'OI'A.t'-___ c?",r_r.G-.-L, A,P..-.>"",.,.',r,>,,,r._ Go<"',_&c...-.o.- /....70_.4':''''''';'' A,. , / .. ---.. '__'_'_0 ,4C1.J'" a ......,"1 .. A.....d ~,- d':h"~"";-_".r.<, ..,- e<.lC /.. #C r,,,H"._ ,4.> .. ~r"'r'~_ --4. ....... . __"-'''__' ....s....?.":>"""r_,rlE_.;r..IJ,, /1"1C'",,";-,_ d,. r.,c.:..,.<._ h ",4" .._. rkr:___________.....___ . .,-------1)_ ,;f,J.. A<.J,,.,.L-A__ 7.:4.._ ACCCr11?""'7''''d:'' AUT7C',J_ ';:-;-'1___,,?,.~~,,Au,,../ .4 ~:2 ./,' " I' " L . .._...~.._., c:-,.""....../c""'/J~,,~~~ A"d--...~~?",;Cr""d (..J.-,,~r;t"c._._~r.4;-,_""-?~,.,r, _ "I'':' ~,,/,),.,,-,.. 4,'/ "",,,,61..., /0 /":-rA,d ,~c.....--I""'-/.. _ __ ._.".. _m O?)._ '/?/, r/t;'MX. ' U __ lJ,H' /..",.",.,,/ --4 /,.,....." hU"(J'_--I.?... /-, LIo_ ~r~,. rL__. L, ,," ;-,.c.! roo< ?'Ol!....~_ ('rc_ ./1,,, h-J"/ / 'J/~"''''_K 'J;,/-.. ". ___ ________..___ ,--h---._..JL_,r..~J___I'J" ,""" C'As..,...__c:lf.. .&KJ""'--- ,1n-t'pr...~,...,.,-.--___ -Ii. rL__ ,/.)..:."-'-<-.) __ TV". A~. /, T/~,n<-L An/. 40CJ~ C",.r.-Lh.. _ T.~: "_n____' ..", ,'....... '" rr,.K., a~ ';:'.-1':,._ c?~,_,.....c/.':.~v(J/l.f,,..,,,,T.'__ c... L__'.)ft:./"n,,"/~__ cF":_ ;-:L.., ,L,........,,, ....,.:: r~ e.""Y7~~tA-J".,.. /,1/.. 'T rL .:rtH~~nr; oMx'., eL~C'...;. ,;4,11.// rL &.,r?,r,."'-4A//L A.,) ./~KTn~"'~I#,.,,-;j. .r) ,-.-4-.. J,s,.,""r", "''''ff~4..., C"oI" :nt::., ,,-ro<,r/C.../, c;:J.:;.,..,,~..4... /'?n".~...<- rCl, ,", .J",J,..,,;.. ...tt.c:.-....?"'''Y,,,'i:!' n~~n."../r~). ......"'/o!:., ,,""', .,...,P'./-r../ ~dIJ~~ ,14"~1C' //"..",.,j ~I'i:r~ rL.j ,..;/CN-/""..6/..., t!L..,.r-, .....n+--...---..'" """ , _ __ " C.)." A.t!. rL 4,.",>c:.,,;}:_ ,?.;I':;GH,.('~)" j:?,,-~....~,~'.../. ,4"":;"'..rlflWt:-c....",..;,,, ,,__. __.________" ?;?...,,....d-'_,, 70., d:,.:'t!-_ ~/r.l.__ r.6__ /c.?IJ;"c:.'._ C"r.': rLh tP......./>/.,Jt. "'''':'(,J#~~ ..',_. __ 4,:.-L.. "4",,,j.. ""/_,, 70, At:: ,.{,,.,,~',_ ~., J...rr, , c.....,-c""",,-, ."_.,_ ___" ...._ " __..____._.""'-'L~,, j?n n~r~,.?"A-/.s _ ,-'/"r.:."rL':.J, AI~".,..cb~.. e?-,r::_ ,...m/-.. ___ ____,_ .4/,;),/,,7<<,...-7.::-_. t?c....,,., ...../.____ "T.'C;__ ....:;:;" ,,,,,'''." -4.__ Tk.- /G." ,tL.",.,.,.GA..__ c-:E....r.4j. .___._,__, .._...._.___.._. e (.,.1,4/._ Ae T7~"/ .~._ .._._, ___._.__~.___.._._....__._._...___, ..-___..~,_.______._._..,. ..,_..________._,,__._.._. ,____,,_,,___,,_,. .."....___.." '''' ". '" _"m'__" ;J:...."Po;r/t-/1/_-5u6.-'rr,./ 'n..__'___m__:_~'...----~~.,~--.. .,. .-, Z~~--?:l._;?L~.""-'-'" --.. , ,__ /. &/9:.-_.vK......~.~_a../~r-r:..s.h,?_ ,. .____.,,,_,,,_... ..___".______" _" ____ _"'__n_' _______________,__._.._. --..$4..mc J(;,.,. _ /~ ._ r!7..n:C,,-c ~~ t'..."._____ __.".____.. ........ ..._. . ....---.____. o. '0. ,_",',.._. ._,__..__.__..._.~._ ,. " cZ , . . - 'of'0C0,."., r.- C:4!. .A r4 6-'_r.....,., &._.....",~... . ct.... L,.~,../ &:'..'7 ~...p//..-,...:, ;,?,., ,...:........~ - . (."I. , __, - ,...,. 77",,-0/- 2.. ~.4....,~..". ..____._._._...." _ C?..../ __~n."". ,.,..c:>.~ ..s>=>:N'......,_,_..".._,."._, . D,.",..~I..r-....,_-'.._. '.....~...... --... '-'--.-.---...- ...~,.,-----~_.__.- ,-. ".'--. - .-. "'. ..,-_.~._.._-..._-._-_._.. ..- -. .. . . -..---..---.-...--..--. .-....-..., .......__.u._. ....,._..__.. /l"'?fIl'''&~ ,.-~ ~<4#~~~ ..D,II!;",~,c.;" .----., -..- ....---.----.--.-...------......--. ------.-.....--....-------.. -.--. - ______.u___, -... ,. "..-.. Z,J-"'~...-r.:::._ 7/:J.. ,';:.?",....>y/~,.m....:..., ,t?,.~ _ ",,,,,"-. ...""............4,.,.7-::',,2"'.. ,d,....I, _ K...,(._ --" "CI.)~_ (.. "~3."._ '1"''''--''-- /-:?:r,n...,.;>K..A.. rL.. ....~ c:;.......,/. A <,r'C"/'r- ,,"'-~.. L. /J '," ..______.-H........,j ,To N, M.?r..",ttf., C-<-~~" 7'0" C)C".::>,~n: ...., c;/{"",..'C:......" ,.,.,.-" rL........".__ -..-... .. .,. ~""'-L. - -A__ "':':'-,rJ".Jcrr':.. r~__ rL~... .rn.:-r/G';,. ";:?r, 7?~r"'-. h.Jlp~~,~/~_ ._._.___.. ..--_._.~-_.."Jt.J',-n~ rr.J ~~.........-_..".... ..._ ~._.---~-_.__~__..___.~h__..___._ _ _ .~__._._ ___._._______ ____~ -......... ...---..-.... ~.._-_. .. -....... ...~_.. ,..- ..-.--_. -.. u-o __..._u__.. _. .... .__ __._.. .__.._._..._. .~_ _.u_. _ . '..... .........1)._" 7""4",_. ,oJ.. A,.. ~......., <::',.:',..a,rl-1I""..../. a....~~;r ~.. rL, ~,r,::r?~_=_ .n_.." , ,,,,??K'., ~ 4""';,.... ,d,.,/ TL a.........~,.".e-..J.."'/,/.t.. ""''?.1''4<-",..;r.n:- ,,r, ?,d. e.~, , ~n _.....p//,. ...-....--...-,. ._,.~. . ....~..._--_.__..__.....-._.._-_..~-_.__._. ... ...._..-......-.... .... -..--.-.-..--.-. ."-- .--.- .-. '------.---,..-..-.,...~ -.-..--..---..._._.___._ .._.__._._u ~L 7'L_,4,/,""-'-<-._ J?"r/,:."r'::'__ A.." ~,., ''.D..mr/'' rL. .AO~j/._JCI... ...-g4Mr:"":'"L./?oa"C,,~__ c....,v?,;c-<-, "'M./ 70" k_ .Ar/Gr~/"".. A:// --..----,,.,,L_6,,"-__/'/'-"'''''''j,_ ~I-L_ ~.4., "')":'<..A.J.':'_ ~","#'.", ________________, ...__.._."'_..__._..,_____.'" ...........-.-.. -.. '.- . ...~...... _'___"U_ ....,___ ____._..______...___, .--- ..-...-. -..--...-.. -. ~--.~_.. ...._._ ..-. _..._ n"n"__'_ '_'h_ -3)... rL__ ;:?:nn",,,,.K_.?,.,,yJ ,?-.Ior r'/'.:. //4-1<:,-cK.. e,r.-. G...-d/ a~~.. '.- ,f#'" ,,!'..- ;>'~rrL,.. Z..e./uTl'e/... ~;::.__ ';'/..1 n?~rt.,./,__ A"'cL_ p,."..r:, .4__ /.t:."'''-i ,<"07 rL.. /.JJ~.:. /1'",.,.""",,,. _ _. .... ..., ....".._.~....R___ ...,_ .....~.__.._. ......_.... _ ~.....'.. ... ''''''' .., ... ...... ._.,.. _ ... ... .... . ........ ... 'Z..>r-",r/<.Y ~.a,"_~.. ~_~~ << U-. I. ~/1"- .P....,,'-',~_ C?:.../ ~..J,.(~ ....sA...,..,,,, .r;..-;_ /'Z........o/...t...,.,...:., ,;7'~~.,..,;O'>;'..." ".".__.._ .._.. _.... ....._.__......._..._..._,..._ .... .......,_, ,,__. _"'R" . .' ~.._._._----_.....- ..-. ._.,... -_. ..._.- .,............-.-... ~,.__....._.._......._--.-...._._-_..._~------_._- .... .,......--........,.--..,-....... .._.~..._--_...~.. ..,..,.......-,,--..---...--... .. ... ......-. ....... ._-...~.__.,....~ '... ..,..._..~. ..-.... ......... --"..-...._- .... -..-...-...--..... .~-_........-..........._-"......- -_..__...._,..._-~---_._.-- '.-.- -.....-......--.........--....-.---. .-..----,--. ...,.. ,... .....-.-.-. -.. ,-....,.--..---.-----.--------... -.--.----------....- ._'..... ...- ~,-... -........ . ....-_. ....-._...... ,......~..-~..__.......-..._-'-..... ,-.". -_....._-_._...__..-.._-....-.,...~_..---_...-----~_._- .-. --..... .-.- . .--.....""........ "...-....-.... ...~ r ..._..M"'M.._....___________________._..._ . ............__... "___"__"'_"___'_"__.._n_' "__M _..___n.. .... ......._..._,...___._.._ "_"_'" .___...... .._ ...__.. ..._...~. ._.- .-... ~__.. _,...__ ...._ _h_" "_~M___'_'_"_~_M"_'" __'R.............__. ._......_.... ........ _,.... ~"h_"""'____,_"___,_,__,,,_,,,,_ '__ .__. ..__. ._ ..-. -.....-...--......----... ..-.-.---_..._-._~---'.'_. . ~.__._-_.... ...- ...... -- .___.~_ ..__~__. _._._....._..M_....__.__..____.__._.__ ____ __ llhllllt E GEORGE T. CARR, PETITIONER IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. TIMOTHY P. CLAWGES, ESQ., RESPONDENT 94-5051 CIVIL TERM ORPER OF COURT AND NOW, this 14th day of October, 1997, petitioner shall be allowed to proceed in forma pauperis. His petition for the appointment of counsel In this civil case, IS DENIED. George T. Carr, Pro se 1 Kelly Drive Coal Township Shamokln, PA 17866-1021 Petitioner '" ,. 'r- (Y>'\AU ,c/ I .,/9? _ ~ ".., . L> ~"W). r, Timothy P. Clawges, Esquire Respondent :saa 'j (" Ex"iblt , I 'I 1 :1 :~c- ;T:" an'"' 1 ,I p~j"'''''' ~ !I .. ..,;,# ni a.-- rr a...~ P""-.. ~ cl....L"k./~"-7- ~'4~'~ /.-1. ~ 6'....-/ "/.,,kJ ::1/......., ~,..4 I I ,j?7''"~'''''/ /I. e~,A>' .t:2f: ,~ a__~.- ~'Q)-" .:;.>,....../ ~'v.. ,'.....1:2.1-'_ ~~ a " '1 JJ/~" -:r- ,;2"....)......",.,- ;?t:) ..;:;:c..r1J//o"JCH;,.A J?....t?. c:, a"",./ :/'?.;k'.....,(,/,-:. /o~.:s- A'N'd ,I'~r,~ 1"...4. Obo""'-J c?~.:f7kM;- ~_JlrL ~""r;~ ,:n:. ek",;:;"",/ ,6"""bT 1 ~ur"""j: I I) .::r ~--=.~~~ ;;-; ~.../~ rL ,;t?~'.rln;;'- ,;./ rL ()~ ,:c?""",nC4"/ n1d;7;>,c, ;II...,.,..J rL :;;:?.~"ar;,.r -:nh1'~' ..d t?k.-.,.." <2f' 0') rL M"'r.:> ':1""'''' ~'-',{,cL r/'.J a......,;Jk'-,r'..) .6...../ 4",,/ :~?"?,,,... ,/?,4/....~ ...." ....., ~~: 3). -rL- rM-#"J'1n0 :77.-w..r/r, L...-II9-' //('f/'-/",,/ /n //>,/,,? n, ,h,.J ~.r/"'.J 7"0:'" ,11..;- I .. />7; :.-c'. ~/"'-"-';;"'.J ~ ;4...., rhh" G' .z,,N.x4'J..-~,....{ -;r;"f'~ 1 ,~~,""h,/;IJ.~ ~".n/?;, /'''/1- /'?",J, 4.JL.... ;H~ C':/A-4",j ~.) a~;...../ ,:~ ~<,,.~r .c-c...-..?../c:-<., ~J""--"nJ ... ,rr.?,.,n,,.;/r/....vl.J7>'~ r)"r- 4.:c"",..,.d "" r..i :;:J{,,,r,.'/:J j2rK )Pk',,~ : 7C- ;'; k /..2J~ ......)-,:'"."..:.-- ;/'?"?r.7';'t......) 7D ;Z).Hnd':,,,:r; hh1"'nt7 A. ah'..Jrc'>l c...../,,:, ;</t";'/;r."r /n ,h/j ch,n-r.!., "-J,t.,., L." ,h/1/ 4Xl...J/d-af..- . C"'/" .4:",~,,.f:'"/ /"i,:-,J ",,/ C::::C'L"':J.?_i77J~~ /,., ch~Jn,? -r;)Ar c., " I i .:Ic::?n_,,,c/ A~r L.,.hI:. :;P-"...,u.c/';n :rL ~",n""/u fi,"-K ~,.x"~rll; I ,i(...,.I,cL ./?....,n-/.,,, rL~",.Lo..-.,,rt./ ~",,,nc-";- ,..,,-.nG.. ",;:?"(",,,nr...c; ,~J"// ,r,t.,.. ~,.,/ ;?':'7P"C~ M-_ ~~~ c,.a?, ';/,.",.'H"""'.I' " (?' r. A) ~"'..) '/'/"1C/,y ..:.,.,oL..,/' ..17 rL tP,,.J,.nr,H) 1'",' ..r,;/~ ..:lCc.......-~,....), ;~ ('''' ....,(,..00.../ /?c:t".....,..{~" "'-J,L." ...:.-,./ (,;?r:.4) ?ffc..J C:4Jr ~.,,- L f-'~'.w.../ ,....i..,s:A/-.y r,t:" ~""'fr""/ I',...u.t~ ~6l~ .,4.c~q{ ..-,<- M(,,".-...-77C-N; ,~.)o:..w......-.n:. / Yo ~. ~~A, :Jt '01'';// ....,r,..6.... /J, 6,,,,;') a..t. .rL, ,~.prl..4'"..r; h,...,.r~ A. &-. ',Pr.) ~ ,/'04.-7"" .:;... ;p--,-'p~oi?'f"/ 7"Co :~t"r- ;r> A,.. c,r",e;-I'''''/ &,-M"-'--7' Arl./ ,y(/ ",K.-.-",,y.'~nlrc ..-F ....5,;".,,( .4crt--./ Co"'" ~"-/l''''''''c/ c::1'?"""'7 ",,,,?,I~':" h" C~/"."nr'/ t55!.kr .4'7 ~:r"'''r~n",} ,'n rL &.."..u...",t"Nr' c,I:'" a a,--, ~L'.", Lo-, """,~c9-<'d = (iP/cr,.,./;n rL. ~""'':'-d7''nj' ~,:- ,. /A./~ ;Dccc,...,......r 'r)",.-.L, ,h"./ ~c....-,/..,1-t:. '--'.-I.. /:f/"-C.-1 Ana/' .0/ ,A./cr" ~<"r- AJ,//,,if A,,,, dnt";' ;ro ...x...p,Prl'-''') rL, ,r//-.,j,ll/ ....."../..,J<:_"-... c-~ 2p......- ...:x...~ ,I/"~"'/ A'T-:> 70 L /?c/,-,r" ..4",,,';;',,7';,,,,, -:aT otfrn~",r'; -"'t";7"""-,> ...0</ "~,,t..j :n;. hk ,# ..<"'c:.nc-..:. cl"-' ,.<1,o"",..c'/ ",# rL a~ (o?O~ Q...../ ,~../" A'I'-I<"/ /5,,:, ,/C,,,s....... 7U hL ;/l,JT '-'::"',?7?"d"-"-_ a-'..';n""'J ~ c.-...."I-j/~ ;'--,/-7 /Iu j~ "w /' ;;'...J<-v',t /-'> 7L .L:'.>,J d' .TLf?{",r,r/;.> ..h.;;AI/ .2;-./;; 7D L 77';;-"7" .TL".~ (_:";;!,.....,;" 0;/) ~ ~",r,~ L / L / /./ ? "r>AJ d<=-rl">-t" " r",./ r; ~c.->. r,;:-' L.;;A/ /;~/-->I a....,,,p,j (€.-.~L ~ d,,<:,'~~.T:i ~;'''''y,.{/,.""....A- ~') "~}..-"/~"""')i r~ ~,,~n~;c r-/ ~.j' ~ :i{.:.,....),J /0-.1/.;, A,v<,,/ ~_c>,,..J ,-IV .,..,.?/,:;;,,6.......-..,) ......T?C-A.).",,:: ~//c;.....,,.,-;? ;rt'.._ ..:Jrn.n_rT <",' /..rl~ 'r....nrH'.> ..;{~/ ~_ ,J/c~,.- h,t".> ...:,..,,;- ~""( Z..J."r.-"/ m ,L. /~'>.J ""~/"//~.I/' '~) r4 ./-:J{,nn//; ~"G-:t- t.. 7: ary, e......;.,,...,) .I,,) al.,w,rrc:.-1 , :1 ~"'~"7'/'/, ~Jt' rL. A".4"/~Jr ,/"...LJ",........ Thilr O,~r:.",..."/',,, .h,.,)' 1/'''...... d"'), .-",/ ~. rL, '/~r"/ .JI<'T') rJ", ,'. 'I' t.. a....-,~/ -'7 I i7;ly.kK .P "f"r:/,.-....,:" t!:!t;, AI""',,/' ~<:J",- ~ c:?~/ I'W,..(, r~ ?",..-..J_''7?';> /.4/->-c... ...a,<,~?r..> ".."., a"" ...A.,,/;C:/~/' ~,.~..~"").. :fI'-,,Jo!.J,,,,,r;1t.l /1". ~, (',...loA. 3 c;..<;//, c~ "t,. ,;/, C';',.....,o,J C..;..t.. t.). ",t ~'O?/,e; ~L- 7'; c2"",:.: "'''''--7',) ~ a", "''''''Y ~ ....A.-..,f..-"r- C'9"",,,,.r rL d':-"r.:.,.,v?1"r Z?-,,~<. A t!?",h.'Yf'') ~' ,/.-K' '</"'}h,J''''-?G..A- ,o'Nc:/""'J''''~''',4<,nc....:.., ,4/.// ~;"M7'''..J''''' rL A""c:.-rlr- :'''''':P.~.GOQ A-r L e"..,,,,;/ "N'~.J.n"'- ",,./ c9'.-,Hc/ .d..r.. , r./.-r (-...G,) d4?~ 70 rL ./~,.,;?/"~ "H ,I,,) p'/"'~r'..~,,}i , I /~?"." r,r../.y- -.5..-.t3-,T:n'/ ~, r::~ /L, / ,4,..;y fl""'/G~~ C~/ ~',J,/,/';:J, ,J,/,.,.......,4/ a. /7,,-Lt, ~ ~ '~~ ~ t2...-, , 'I I , '! I ~C"".~.- ?7' ~ct, P~nJ~ ~S" ~ . _ 3:'"1'1' ,L, a.-,. ~~ C2.."".", ,Ph:. .//2 a . . a"l~,4..., a:.....~/ .;'-7""""""'- ~ 'I u. c1,",~~ 4'-J , . :;iJ1,-'I""~~ ,I ,I~_~,(" ,I. ~"'-J~, ~., - ~-,>c-,Nt::>,' ...n:A.s'1 tC'/.....1' /1W. ~~,.......h~-;- - 'I -:??~77/"; 7G D-k,~C"/' " .,;:2,..Je..",.,-r 7'0 /?'M,)//""""'/~ L~ c/ L?",../ /1.:r..dtl'f" 1't::J1'1r. /, ,;:P;1r7i'l"~ 7~ .atH'~/ /.;) h.I''''~ I/u--,,). 'I ~'~?7/.~'. ~ .h4Vl!. k..,,? ...:>'-'rd /"/ C~....n-, .:r~ Y"- G._Jl~h 7"'GI c?Nrld ,laf<<'ln.>,r ,l.... C?~_~ ":"-7'" ".;./,,1/ /n rL ~//c.,,,,,u"'l /,Oft!"'" v"""'" ,,#<<17" '7h.G.... ,,4"no/ t!!_JI ,..j,,./ /~..-" r-/ (070) ~Y~ A/"'7?'K rAt"; 0'''''?/t!07r "H'/ ?knce' A/~ j.,.,v",~ -'Y' ,",,,r;-,,,,/ '" e....."rrr,J O;o~"...,..,.,t"e /:J",,,c.,,..//y' CIC b;/ ,dr;oe:.,,,"'/' ",n'/hh",i ...n o:..,.,"',rl/~ t.r.JlrL rL c?.......'r Y<A.-o,r o/..,t;;dJL'J ~ c-0," rl,"/.) ~ ,..L C?,{",.,. ...)..- r /0::;.,,-,1.( ~? """",,- y'~, Y'",,-, c,rl. L.......c,,,"'/ r/"r I',c y"-'-J /,;;, / ,'fi:r 06 ..JC rL a.>.A- ,I1'1.47"'(;pI'CCN/ t",..u"lAc..--f- yC-o-l. /1,,/ A, --A.,df.,.,,.,..-,.,r- /J'1o/ k ,."Tr/'/ c7,,,,'." 7'-'-" .17 rL {'L" ~/r/'~r ,K.-,.IL,. /7<0<_..... HK en/, /11.:-"''''7 C-,,/c:;'rlrL'/'.In ,..L, . Ct)~MONWI:::^('TIl VB GEOP<lE T. CAPP 2176 Crlmln.1 1991 PI~EO. 7128192 M01'ION rop PEDUCTION or BAI L rI~EDI JU~1 lQ, 1992 OPDEP AND NOW, Thies 10th day of July, 1"'1)2, a hparlng 11 ec:h.dulpd in Courtroom No. ) of th~ Cumb~r14nd County Courthouesp. Carllel.. Ppnn,ylvar.la on thp 4th day of Augult, 191)2 at 1 t)O p.m. at which tlmp t..timony w1l1 bp taken or:. Oetpndant's Motlon for R~duction of Bail. By th(l> Court. apor9~ E. Hoffer, J. ~OOGED. AUGUST 12, 1992 IN RE. PCRA COLLOQUY PROCEEDINGS HELD BErORE TilE 1l0NORABLE GEORGE E, HOrrER. J.. CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE, CARLISLE, PENNSYLVANIA. ON THURSDAY. JULY 2, 1992, COMMENCING AT 9.07 A,H.. IN COURTROOM NUMBEP THREE, PILED. AUGUST 20, 1992 IN RF., MIL RF.DUCTION ORDER or COURT AND NOW, August 4. 1?92. 3:10 p.m.. after h..--tlrlr.'J ar.d cor:sldcorati.or. of the t~Gtimony pru9vnted on th~ d~f~nddr.t'~ motior. for a reduction of b~i1, und~r all th. c1.rcumstanc('Q prcos(I'ntpd. w(' ria fr:oe1 that ball in thco amount of 625.000.00 is proper in th(' CdSP and w(l' r.fus~ to rQducf' it ar.y turth~r. By th. cOlin. Georg(' ~. t'offpr. J. FlLEU. AUGUST 20, 199~ IN RE: pellA COLLOOUY Proc~('d ir.gs h('d 1 b..-- f arC' t h... HONORABLE GEORGE E. HOfFER. J.. Cumbrrland County CaurthousC'. Carllsl.. P('r.r.sy1var.la. Ol~ 'rl"lUr!HJ<1Y. July 2. l?');!, CQmml'r.c~r:g dt 9:07 a.m. in COlJrtrllom Number Throo. rILED, SEPTF.MDE" 1, 19')2 MOTtON FOR POST CONvtc'rlON COLI.ATERAI. RELIEf. flIed by detend~nt. f'ILEDt SEPTE:-1~,";R 4. 1992 ORD~R AND f;')W thlS Jrd day of :,ept. l'j92. Upon C':lllhldt,t.ltl0n of tIle fqregoing moOon: 5. 1'h~ Cll.!t'k of this Court is ordered ~llld ..hrect'ld to do tIll! folLow1nq tl)rthwithl (a) To serve a copy of thLti motion and thitl order upon the Dlstrict Attorney of CumberLand County. (1)1 To send a copy at thLs motion and thi.!, or-der to It. G11roy tl\q., the Lawyer tor the dafcndant. (c) To !Send a cop~' of thlo. order to thl.:' defl'nddnt. 6. Till? motion 1.9 reflwr~d. Defend.lnt's .1PPI.:'.ll on post tt"l{1l motions ,is stiLl pendlng. Geo rlJl' t:. Ho! f t! r, J. e.A.. Deft. copy to CCP. .Iubert GLlroy. Esq. copy 9-4-92 .12322308141997 . . ........Il-H.... J.II.UU \..uuu~~ Case 1991 - 02176 CARR GEOllm: 'l'ERI{ANCE Init. Issuing Auth... 00000 Docket No. Init Auth. - 0000000 - Pre-Sentence Invest.. Trial Commsnced Date. Trial Judge.. ........ Sentence/ARD Date.... Effect. Date of Snt.. Superior Court ,..... 0/00/0000 63 HOFFER GEORGE E 11/24/1992 0/0010000 841HBG94 10' 06277 Filed/Reopened Description 11/27/1991 INITIAL FILING Disposition 4/24/1992 Disposition Code F NON-JURY TRIAL ...................... ALIAS OR CO-DEFENDANT INFORMATION ..................... Alias or Co-Defendant Name Type ............................. CHARGE INFORMATION ............................. Date Chrg Cnt Section Sub Grd Desc 11/01/91 A 11/01/91 B 001 CC2702 001 CC2706 Al Fl AGGRAVATED ASSAULT Ml TERRORISTIC THREATS .......................... DOCKET ENTRY INFORMATION ........................... Case Type..: CRIMINAL Case Action. .: COMPLAINT - - - - - - - - - - - - - FIRST ENTRY - - - - - - - - - - - - - . 4/27/94 MOTION FOR POST CONVICTION COLLATERAL RELIEF, FILED BY DEFENDAN'r. -----------------------------------------------------------------_. 7/14/94 MOTION FOR POST CONVICTION COLLATERAl, RELIEF, FILED BY DEFENDANT. ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7/06/94 OPINION AND ORDER, FILED. IN RE: DEFENDANT'S MOTION UNDER POST CONVICTION RELIEF ACT, BEFORE HOFFER, J. ORDER OF COURT, 7 -6-94 DEFT'S MOTION IS DENIEI)' GEORGE E. 1I0FFER,J. 7/15/94 ORDER OF COUIl'I', FILED, 7-l4-94 MICHAEL SCHERER, ESQ IS APPOINTED, HEARING IS SET FOR lO-21 9,\ 1\1' 9 AM, C'l'HM 4, KEVIN A. HESS,J. --------------------------..---------------------------------------. 11/21/94 PETITION FOR ALLm/ANCE OF APPEAL NUNC PRO TUNC, FILED -------------------------------- .----------- .---------------------- 11/2l/94 CERTIfICATE OF SERVICE, FILED. ---.--------- ------.------ --------___..0______----------------------- 11/22/94 ORDER OF COURT, FILED. ll/22/94. IN RE: PETITION FOR ALLOWANCE OF APPEAL NUNC PRO TUNC. THE PETITION IS GRANTED. THE DEL IS DIRECTEI TO FILE illS NOTICE OF APPEAL TO THE SUPERIOR COURT WITHIN 10 DAYS. ORDERED BY GEORGE E HOFFER, J. --------------------------------------------.----------------------- 12/02/94 MOTION FOR LEAVE TO APPE^I, IN FORMA PAUPERIS, FILED. ---------------------------~~-------------------------------------- ----.------------------------------------..----.----------------------- ,1232~308141997 Case Print . 1991 - 02176 CARR GEORGE TERRANCE 12/02/94 ORDER, FILED. 12-2-94 APPLICANT IS IIEREBY GRANTED LEAVE TO APPEAL IN FORMS PAUPERIS. PATRICIA ANN SMITH, DEPUTY CLERK OF COURT. -------------------------------------------_______________________M 12/02/94 NOTICE OF APPEAL NUNC PRO TUNC TO SUPERIOR COURT, FILED. DOCKET ENTRIES, ATTACHED. ----------------------------------------------------------------_..- 12/02/94 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE, FILED. ------------------------------------------------------------------- 1/19/95 AUTHORITY TO PAY COURT APPOINTED COUNSEL, FILED. MICHAEL A SCHERER, ESQ. (O'BRIEN, BARIC & SCIIERER) $480.00. ------------------------------------------------------------------- 1/31/95 PETITION FOR EXTRAORDINARY RELIEF, FILED -------------------------------------~._---------------------------- 4/17/95 MOTION FOR MODIFICATION OF SENTENCE, NUNC PRO TUNC, FILED. MOTION TO MODIFY SENTENCE, FILED BY DEFT 4-17-95 THE MOTION IS REFUSED, GEORGE E. HOFFER, J. ------------------------------------------------------------------. 4/25/95 CASE MAILED TO SUPERIOR COURT ------------------------------------------------------------..------ 9/19/95 MOTION FOR POST CONVICTION COLLATERAL RELIEF, FILED BY DEFENDANT. ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9/21/95 MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF POST CONVICTION MOTION, FILED BY DEFT -------------------------------------.------------------------------ 9/26/95 PETITION FOR APPELLATE BAIL, FILED BY DEFT ----------------------------------_.~------------------------------- 10/05/95 CASE RETURNED FROM SUPERIOR COURT --------------------------------.----------------------------------- 10/05/95 JUDGMENT FROM SUPERIOR COURT, FILED, 8/25195. IT IS ADJUDGED THAT 'l'IIE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY BE AND THE SAME IS HEREBY AFFIRMED. BY TilE COURT, DAVID SZEWCZAK, PROTHONOTARY. ------------------------------------------------------------------- 10/05/95 MEMORANDUM SUPERIOR COURT, FILED. 8/25/95. BEFORE: MCEWEN, TAMILLA, AND OLSZEWSKI, JJ. ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5/22/96 OElDER OF COUR'l', FILED 5/17/96. IN RE: PCRA. THE MOTION IS RETURNED FOR AMENDMENT AS OUTLINED IN ORDFR, TO flE RETURNED ON OR BEFORE 8/1/96. ORDERED BY KEVIN A HESS, J. -----------..-------------------------------------------------------- 9/18/96 MOTION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL NUNC PRO TUNC IN FORMA PAUPERIS, FILED. BY DEF. -----------.-----..--------------------------------------------------- 9/10/96 ORDER OF COURT, fILED 9/10/96. THE MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AN ^PPEAL NUNC PRO TUNC IN FORMA PAUPERIS IS DENIED. ORDERED BY KEVIN A HESS, J. ----.----..-------.-.---------.----------------------------------------- 11/04/96 MOTION FOH POST CONVICTION COLLATER^L RELIEF, FILW BY DEFEND^N'l'. 6/04/97 MOTION FOR APPOINTMENT OF COUNSEL, FILED. ------------------------------------------------------------------- 6/04/97 MOTION fOR LEAVE TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS, FILED. ------------------------.-.------------------------------------------ 6/04/97 MOTION fOR EXPEDITING DECISION, FILEU. ------------------------------------------------------------------- 7/14/97 OPINION AND ORDER, FILED. 7ii4/97. IN RE. DEFENDANT'S MOTION UNDER POST-CONVICTION RELIEF ACT. PETITIONER'S MOTION IS DENIED. THE ------------------------------~------------------------------------- J:<32~ JOB 141997 .....,~.'-... Io.UU... ~""'UH~I ......uJ.^ UI.. \,.UULL..~ Case Print 1991 - 02176 CARR GEORGE TERRANCE RIGHT OF APPEAL EXISTS. ANY APPEAL MUST BE TAKEN WITHIN JO DAYS OF THE ORDER. ORDERED GEORGE E HOFFER, J. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - LAST ENTRY - - - - - - - - - _ _ _ _ .......................... COSTS' FINES INFORMATION ......................... Case Type..: CRIMINAL Case Action: COMPLAINT Last Description Costs/Fines Pd To Date Amount Due In Escrow Pymt ..--------- ---------.. -.._------- ---------- ---------- Cost/F ines Total .00 .00 .00 .00 0/00/0000 Cash Bonds Total .00 .00 .00 .00 --- End of Listing . .. /~,,.cc,u~ ~ ~~''''~~ a~ L. ~c:.L" .,Af,J:.;.;........A/r-': 7Z:J.' .r~ /]c>r,k,./,4;?J...y' ~~ &.....L~,(.,..,/ ~?"-' .P..t'~...... /...,.. rL t:......'"...I/,.; A:1"'''''''''.K HL ".L, N',....,-r- ,,4"~V'rl"'d'""" cL7-. - ~ .#7"/C. LV .v:- cfij... (f!'.HTJI'J'.... c:a~,oc..A/ ..........~ k "",.",,...,/ oZ''; r...,.-/,) ~~c:. 7: dr.<<, (' /~A./"".-,c), , (..I:' . ./ 0 ~/ -;;:;-~,"'/ ./. ~ ""'.....~'.' ~ ('./::?~;;_.L.vr- .J #c::;,t, 7.;/'- ~T/~-/ ~......4If ./ ~ S; ~, /, ,.>".""n::. A'7;>1771'",c' ..n:;J "-'-.A I'~ L'''' ./- ~,c.., "ZJ,.r,:,../~ r:> ~ _oJ,." t!!!K = a""l;)k'M~ ~.I""T///Cj /'1,..,,/,.-'....."'''7' c;6...J...J"?<.,V.>" .4'Lh'/ ~ 7"0 .D........,.~...,..".,:j /"?,.,/,,.,..,,,,,,'"7" c6J.....,..".,r>->, A""J .~L t::...-/~"/C'd.s ./ ~) ~ '/' J ~ ,4L. '/_,,./ A,,-,~ C,"-.r~ c~".......:.c..-",//L /.....~.,....../r- Tel :) /7 -,;I ./ /ti, /""_ &,,JA1, .:i' v>'// ,:j,- /""'--' /... C'Rn""'"" ~--d...... c-.:-:r,.J: \ " ..,.;} , .~... ~"I IW-" , " . , i\ ,,. *,~,'il'''. , ~ v' , ,,7 Name .",' C;::,c: Number d. rl' n I Kellev Drive Coel Township, PA 17866.1021 /, . i'7 " ,/ /" /~/C' ,v-/~A'r'e a...-r "4'~~~,~;1'7',.,,;r-,,r. ~~A--~~/ ~-7' d~AV1JP' .:z, c::l.......".-,hcv'-, 'Z7~' ~ hJ4~ /l '/7C'/ 3 << PA"., 11-11 : ~ IDIHl _'.':1!1c)f;T.H1E :, _......4_. " 1...111,,,111.1.,1111,.11.,.11...11,,,1.1..1.11I...,..1,111.11 ,.. " \, ,. . \i .....\ .. ,. .... (;) ,- " ~ J:: to-' '.' I'.' ~~ j ! t I ~- .1 \ , )- ): '., I ~ : I oJ.. j (")1-, i' , , ') ";I h 1: ~ , . ~.1 -,\/, 'il) ll. I l , , !(L 1 . : " .' I' ) l , I'" (J f' t I I, " " " " ~ I,~ ~: --r' 1- .. t';.; . ~11 ~i (:1I'r" 1 :",1. . 'I.:: ': 11--1 ,.:: };,::! ' j I" ~r '- \,u , -:.'t u, C\! , :..,. [i: LI-' f.i "!rJJ , f~U.. r.. (,ol ;'3 ts r- <11 (: I' \',-' '1'.1", .. '" -- r . -., OJ> ./ ----",.. Neme ~~, ./. id.. Number ~~ -..:.-~:J.3 1 Kelley Drive Coel Townahlp, PA 17888.1021 /0,' C~..rr c~ LiuKr~ Ci"" I...;ftn/ ~;1r/ ~h~~ -Z I &~Acu~_ '-27 c........... . O"./;~~ /3. /701"3. /",1/,...11/"""11..11."11,,,111,,11,,,.1..'..11 ! t I r , I I ~;J ' , /I .. "':".. ~U_I.",1 -/-/~-9/~ ~JI ~ Jo.J f2M0/4~ J.aJzJ / .2-()~.9) I ~, , . 'I I " ., e' 1, I , "I (~.~ ' , j ,I , lorl ';>J, f' "J'~ ~,' ';/~;'I 'i"~:l ,..~. , :;; 1, \. ., ;j " , ,'; , .1 r'; \I' , r I , , , I> . I ~ ," -,. '- ..., I 'i",' ..'''''[, ~" ~-(.jIr'lf' "", ........ \,1" ", 'I",' , ' , . ~ ,~j ~ I I,'; I I.,j,..U 1"'\"'1" ~, )' , , , ,. I,,';' , ' .----- i I' ..,.j.t. r L2 -6;) I ~~ /.. ~ It, ~A. -~-".:J.:3 , 'IV Drlvl Town.hlp. PA 17888.1021 U.!1.r~" ~ \ .,~f ~~ Y ~' :;";0,' ~.;?~f ~ aKr.:. c-t,~ ,...,~;1/ ct"r/ ~k~ ...:z, &~C"-...L. '23 t:.v...... . C:::;r-/'j~ ~. /7013 I.. ,11I",1/,.,,, ..1/,,11,..11,..1/,..11..1,1,,/../1 .'i4;I~I" "~I I." ;J.,...,u.,L""" 10, .,,-h'_'_ . ' .. H"........_.~ , , I"~ , o. " , f; . , , 1"" ~\J I ~ ,', \ . ~ I". . .. .,,- . t - -- ~ .. J/& nCl 0 9 1997 o /) {..;......'r;;.:.- r (~):'J:. ? . /i' r; '7'1~.I'J~N:.__ /7 / J ;' . _ -?-~I r~., G'~r ,..:; c:.'M.U.~J ",..~"":;, -;J /' , ./ - 6>?14-,,1,1'/ (''--'7 /-,.--Ir17....c-'-'I..-~ v' 91/- - 51,)!>- I _c?.../ A'~..v; M.'l: ..:lW-/ C-/...../ "//rrlo.'dl /'1 C-%kf<':" ? /.J.k'.JI~...r:r- . :lr.knc./ H.K ~.P<..e' 7U /~~.--~,../ ~ '7 ' .k......~.;. /L._~n.,,/~ "7 '/':7 / ? / ~ /"v/.> l.4:Id7"'"' r0 /;;...........v.J/~.u~ /...,L. <'" ,n".o~/h,I"1:r /,.<A-___~_./ ~"?,{ ..r,,)'":;), :/'?7"IT?.e-.-1",'C! ~ rL,tII~ a~,/Gri"C/.-?:MnP'<, ;:'-'-7 ~......) r~.) ,.of,{:n.-".,tt::: a,.r- ~.K' ~"'-" n;;, ./l..:"{'.,..,./ :E1::! - "tt;ol',i~ /2: )",-,~ n/ /t:.....,t~,..,/1,1-/...,*" <'''/'~;. A1Cc:.:::,"?,t--lP"'}/'(j' /1?r77e"/ ,.r;:,K' .I'1",w?-",l-/r/?:1--"r ....~- 6. ..,::...../. an/7N/~7 ,L, ,.9.) ,,4""1'1(;" L,/ ,,!..rr.*p/"T,-,r, "'V,-,K'IH,./ ._:.;rT,If17c'.,,~,.;1T ,I /G L, sc. /, ../Jrl7"'K4,-K -/j- "'........Hb[ 7C-r /':77JIIo/ ('--2.......~-.. /'. ft",c /:J,dy" rL, "e;.~.J .41"1./ ~r..) ,~' r~ c/"'''/ ..4ft'n..:./, /l-")/.R~r7~Y-~b'/r.'_~/ , ~" ,.~", ,... ,(../' ~-- y/ ~_. ,. /. -;1 /. /5,./.y' ..hY/"'r'"' " ~...../ t:,-,-~j~ ,)'2 a.rcC -10>"/ ., , ~I<-./:;/ ~ <,tl (.,; N i"> .. " , I.J.I~: ! r;L; , " " , , I',: , , " "J(, cO ':.-" .'.1 b" I , , - I'J1l-', ,. ,'1f;..1 (,; t;1ll.. j"", co: " " ,. I'" ) r.' 0', U , . ar,;c: :r: a.<:,. '2 rdTiT1r-A,L /) /' ./:' -/' _ ~ ,.4 a_~,/c;eo;'_........~",,~ _ a~k.~,./ ~ /Z~.'~' <-, _ / ,;7 ~}/ /,,,~.nt'/.f L;0~('::' .;.-:J,~.J~L_~ ?!f,' /'? "'4, _ C f'f..<"/A~n..~ ....~. ..n;;.r/ &c..,,''/' - t) /r/ Hr"C / ....)--;?,;i ~/''':7,,;F/ . ?7/n~..e:;. ..A rL c:c"=-~ ~T,IJ-n-'/ e(.K/ ,4<"To"c~/, ..>-r.D7r.:. r:-n..kK -rL. /10'/'/"':' //<.Ju,I'r../.6-/ /d, /-;., C-:~, ~ c/;<~ (d.-"/.:,<--X'~,,./. /luo/ r, ~" ro"c..'/7'O /I....,t ,(.'"c,r r/C' .:,) 7' h r / L --? ' I) -// C...'1.r V"'Hnc.,~.,e ~ rL, p~~ C'1'-,,()/,4,,-r,-c"/, "'nd .6t!'cr..'-'~ r/'"-y .01-/;I,vO.../ c:....c,,{ r/~, r /1,,1 <,--,,v',.II:.,l, 7'Cj ,r"'?"';/ rL /C//&""o,? H""> ;J......d ecur..) ((J..) /r?rolJ/H ('~ t!-~ ,.,...,/ (",) &...7'" c~ .//uc-/ucu;) 7-F"'''''J~K,/.Jr~ /1,,/ ~"c.;-.-61' /3"'// t'c:) c-",L." (?c,-'T~ And h('..> ;'1..::....c.c.O~T,..('/ ~.,tL r';;..> c?c.r/ //c-Tk.../ c9) rL /C//u.-"(t ~T/~7;",y,1"'~T~ /Z'~7"n-(:i 1"(:_ /Y7/ //.6,/), 70 ,jJ/ rL<-- kn /1/1'/ 60n c,c >lw~<"_';-'J. c'k' c."":',.r;:.~H""':d ' T/-J C~UN/ /},,-7'((',J /J,i'...... //L..--"-. .4"'./ ~""'r.r ~ rL AJT r""'- /1'1--/ //{;"'-'/--0'-'/ ..r-.../k,n1"'77o~ ;-1,-,./ ./3.......:...,t.- ;] // .ty rL /. 7/ /A. "/4'~' ~. '. I .. ~..7 t 2. >- I'" '," C'" ,-, L K .. I ~, r:.:) lU " C)' C"' , /'.'J ."" t'j t,} ( I I..:) ,,; r.): I I.,', ....11 , ,. ~ J C.I~ ' I ( ,!!t'l. r C. ., 1- 0 O' '..J ,/ . . d",,,?ol.. r. C~4! , ' . .At r4 &oCr .~. c:""~..._ ~.. . cf,.~ ~,.'/",../ tf"':'.,/ ~__.y/IJC~""';' "" ~:r; T7~rI;.IIL. '-I. / -;}/ ;:-;""",,,.,:1' ? C:.,"'.....,... ) .. ",~/ ,,4&' n."". ,.~~, ..f';..l~.;", D,.I~~,,~..r- .,A? ~,.;;., ,;~~ tf-~.&/:~ ~,~..,~;,,,.,, Z...~...Hr 7'" ? ' ' '" ""U'~//~""".II"'" ~~j. ,~ Ap,;-l.;//"""r /.?c;.il"",..~,..,,.....,, .4~. ,t;J~'- .( ,..,~, '1"......,. r.tJ /"'--""'~ (,~, ,/i .1'4 ....6rx..-~ c-;...,../ A.,,,,,/, ,(,......~ ~.Jc~,d~.n.. ~ ~c~~"c.~ ,.,.-' r/~ ;/ ,/ r" r,''''-rl.-1H''. """'::'~J ~...-.~,- /'-l ~........ ~ ,."..~ /'h... nl," r,..,-I' ? ./-,. r, n"",r~ ~".P"< r/i-/1/ -:A../J,,.,h ...r" -.)",t~"~rr~,' I), -rLoJ ,oJ .-- (1"........ C""- '/ ::;.J / / ./ C~""/~-/"/ ~.....,.:'~...,- ,,6/ r4. c:I"'...;#:::,.~~....,r ~~~_n'H''''''~''/'''.(. /'?.",J...,.,.,-.n:;. .... it", ?AI, C'.':'. ~K'. e~....,~,.,_ """./ r-4 ~ 0;;;,1/, .,o) :l'L "'C"u-. .J ' ./ ,'r,,.,..~,.,,.;C. ,?,oJ L..", , ~J,."".~/~' rL ~c::1":/ 7'0 ~,-" <"?,J<--<--, ",,,vI A::.> l-c..- ,d,..r.:,r.~/'" h.// /,) ,) /'/ I"',J",,,r ~,..'/ /;\.', ,y{, .. ,.,,,./ /#".. "/""',or; ".4 ;",J~f-.J ~ kl1"ltl1;/. ,.,1 J) .rL... /,k..,q.'u' fL,r- ~,// o,..;';.r. ,) . ,/',.), n """.K ,iJ,. ,./0:. r'/.. r- r.t~ r'/'..I /#lcr,c,J'. 10,"/ ;',,,,,.1, ,4 ~P'''N'/ .Ad .r A ? u-: r,-./ /7.-... Co /.... n- "" <',t: ("',I ri.... A~r,..,,,,,~ . /.,j,JI...... ~ . . Z->~"T/<.r ~.Jm'~/' J R~~~ (/,/ rY {- "'--, /. ,I,},./1" "cJ"",,-,,', C~.../ 7C:>~.h,,,,:J ...sA",.....,r';-{ jZ"'N-;/~"''''''' "'7~~ ',.c.i>/, , , , , , " -.. en if; ........ I' " .. I'" ,e; 'J;. . ..' b' , (, ~ ~ . 'r.t l.'~ J ' [ij I .' . Ii L ." '-rt (,: 'U. C..., ,. ,.~ , u u' U l . ~ - ,,,, '/ ~, I'. -r: CiA'A!, .. .::.. ,..,i,' C::L.,,- .;:~ U_.....--Y/ ,;<'...{"'. . C;;'~~j",,//.,,/C:~:'7' .4-"'7:"""'~ r~~.dZ:. c:...J, _ ,t/?, ,fY-.SJ:,V'/ a../ ......:....'"", -;1m...rf' /) C::~:')V' ,~;"dac- 73.' ._',)6'"/'7" ~'"') ,;'/O{........-:-- ~/." , _c.;... It..J/~, -..... , ~, A,v-t? .J""/f/ ~'-;V;.-',/ ?Z;; h',,{ ,.14 o!'......,',77'?'rI /.::/~:,.,.....- 7'V rL ~m~~'/ ~7,.'m.. ~',;!' .. '-:;::;'.L.:; ) t!-..;, rL" (.?l..::J L',/j /;:''-''''', --.:5-.. ",.,'..... /I...,...",.:' c,. ,4- _1.. dj,.,,,,.,,,.- ,'?"N~ L ....,.7:"....../"")'..--,,"".v- y~, /) 'a? '>'" ~// ~..f. ~~_~, "....-4.- ? ~~7' h~j /;:;"7 ..3) rL ,.....:J{,"7/,rF ".(,~~ ,11.1/"';''': _..';>:4'/;""-,,,- /;;.T,) '..:h..___.,/, A~~ /N'...,1~Jc",.,.t'.: .67 '- '-'C~/ " /' /..' T7.""...' ::OC" /~"l.,,;;. ,.A.",,- ,oil:. ,~r~7t-c/ c.4,,,-'-" .:;....__. .1"" .11,-- ,4" /,,,,,,,'/~J" ~"'"',,;,/...,/ u) ?/ .- -,. J/,,,,/f:""",/-,/r ,., / -- ./,.',),~ , .... ,_.c_',,r,;t,,.-,J, "-';/,,,,.,,,.'1 ~,)'~'" ,:.....,.4',,,;,/ A,,,:. _'7717:'"';/ ,;4 ~-?...kr' c:?, h-.. II"''''''~'.-( ~~LJ :'/ /,/ ..=-.......:.....; r()n~ ,;9,.J./ -;;--'7." ,~'.... ~ ;-,,-- /' ;/~",,-,r,:' ',' fl/,.,'~r ':j ~"A:.......,. ;,n:, /;~ ,4 -;;-;;n....,y /.J<? 77<~1 "/"?,;"'.,,,y' ,--)...,,./ .-'l_"".4A<_ .u? ,rL. c;:-:......- (~;(.,;. ".....h:c',I ".. ;1,. /' _ ~,..... / _, .,. ....,,,."'J""..'. ,,~ ;/",1. ,,_ ~, T~I",~~I."'" An./' :n:: .:':.:.~......"'.!> c-;....',-/ ,,~.,/J /J":-,~ ~ .i' .;/" ,,,,,~./; ~; -":::'?'k~, ~".r :; /;7?1r....,.7~ /.::?~--- /-L ~../.. L-,I" , ,-;,.7'74......,..) '7 .7L:" /''-'JI ,.;T;.,I "I)//c.:.~"'/ ~,1~c.....;- /:"";''/ ":'<-" '-, -:// - . '/,/~.I";r,,r/ ~ ......-z:; ...,.),-'J~rr- c.~;- ,-L L..-'" 7 / ..,,,( -'...J...../r~~ .-';7 ,'/./>..../ /?(;IA!J :/ t-....,,/c.,I ~""'-J"~ .r;:.) ,1.J;p/,:",.~> /j' ~,I/"''''''/''~d'''''''::'''' ~,-~~ T'/,~ c;;.........,.) .....k/J,/,.../ ,.4 a....-r ......,,?...:: /,5 ,IJ:?7,/.::,L/ A-,-n::, ,,9.,) , ~ ci, ~___ ./ n C,:,-,",,7'""'; -;-? " , /"-"N~;G..-,-,,~~__ ~&.o...-J <<./ 4~ ,rL c.....,(.i,/ "'c:? " I . S) /"'}{,H'T//r /!1AJ.,':;, ~-"IJ"-<-/ ,),:_~,q;'''-'''-dr L3-:;m'~ --...:>.h~''-'''(j :r-L 'P"'/';~"knr:J /),-i_ ,A/rrJ,d,n:; C::..::"'~. c',,;'-' rL ,/'-;;:::;"A'?r/-~'';' c:;~~'-.,' ..r/.:d' ~L" 7L__ /:J./,.;,.~;/,- ~-<..JC>" c.;/-.?....'^I~",.C/ cr:- / ~ / .T~/~4 /?."DhJ,//' ,/.J.;:n......-..n 7L. "-/"":'>-,,, / "),,..r ,:/- ---/.'--7, ,:'1. L' / / / /99/ ,lQN"/ /' /""(:X4~ c'/' /,L~ '/'/.,//',-" ",,'r />>,0.17-- ;.7"~,, ,,-'/'r~,,,J ') / ;rL /J.I..-:"'IJ"7 <.,/ ".1." //".,r""'/?-'J /;,.;"., /J.b...,,::.....,_ c-rq(..c', ~/., :2),..,./:":;')..~.n;:--" h~,/'../' ;..~C /~/".J.L~'~. ~/';~,1/.-,,}..,t;/J7 ....z-"c,/(..J.-.::,r"'..~,,~"/7\:-.f.} ~/-... /"?';','/J7i// ~.) /~'-:/:-'4'C'~.1;- .~';,;,,:'r) "'/l../''-//;I'~''4.}/_I/''',o,lJ.. ~~_.} //~r /~ /.--- H....../.,.,.,,'.//~')f c--...-...v.) ;J,-/(~.,~-'t:_,/,'~,,,~- /J~ /;;~".L..:"i ..._)~,)/n/7""'rr-.:.'/-?d / ,,L").....A';;,....{;,~- '::",)./ 7l....",,O,,vJ-,, //, " >-~/ ,;7",--,</ ?:{;,:.....",J~,-" /,:,- 17~/ 'rr'I..';/~'/,4,~ c<~,/, /,/; ';.4" /1""-,,/ H.c;., .) --J/ t./ /;'lJ".,-/~ ~~~'-t'k.j. / / '--? ,;,'" ~ / .'2-, )'-"~< .p// /J(...'c', k ~(..,,_. /i!'), 7:t.>,1.1 / .In ,-,-,'hit': L " c::ii:..<-,., 77.~/u.:, ~,or- t::-<..J/J.::. ~/-,/ ./ 9<;..;z . / "'''~ r.i.-<t- ,/:' /' ''7/: L~'.__T. C'/ ~_;:;"":7,-~~'3 /;...-s.-J~ -)/ ..} / J /'/'#//'/TI/';"<' C:i...J,,' ,Afb;~~'".,) C:-r7 ./?~""',n,6.,,-,/ /, .i.:?/,'.../- b ~ ,/ ,....., ~v,/,c L ,,A)7"?'i!::.""'I/,Y ,.."........", /;{'L....._;...-/; rL_- ,6~Jj ..6'......,,) ,.."...J ZJ,':'~:~'n'<:v? ,A.:J c/' /r''- 70 7L c:2-""."r, ,neb,,;, ';<.J,~/:r )?'.J<--/'/'''? /on , ,4.</ c--~....L~r/,c;,46t.- /~)~".;;/ .A' a;r d-" /~_ ..2."'J.:'.-.i:"'r- /.~ /7'"T~df. ,/ /1'" N"7C J /OU .c~:.,J,L/ I. /.) .. / -)/7 '7 / ~',t;"-,/,;"",,, ///I1/~/.rr/'/-', .A<.)/.!-,... 7/<:../r-' ~,--,,-,~r ,;r-,L,..... a~,-r 76 !",:.--,;-- rL ./-~"'T,,'7"-> 7-f'--":';r?N1G,'7 Q~"'crlc",;, /In,/ )7/..>n?/..),;, 7:)-/;;"./-;",,",-::> /2.."n---'-~""/~, A~ /?1.-, ,rrc.....-.,) /'Jfl./ /;,./..)~:rt':'/""I7- ;:J,-r;-,/ "7 , / " ,_, _' //--::>/"t ''', ;7<,/)/ _X."/JH,' n-r-y/' ay )../' / , ~ /(~-~ ._~~-._ ~"1 c;:./ ~;::~', ~7r;,-,~', ?;,/ 7 / p' ~ ,---5..,.....,.A..~1,,~'.:J.. -/:";"'/)'7 ,-,"-,'''",,- ,'/'.;r;'{, ,/ c; ,~,) /, ~L-ol''''''c.:' r -7 6;7' / /-(.. /f' ~,,-,u/'/ ,) erl,r;,c "''''- .. ,;,'.. ~...",-J,,- .i..... c::w' T j.j 4.......~('. _ J J't::.~~';J~'. .) />->-7 .:= .:T/f.-r- .r /M~ ~rL c.'h.y.,r-' ", /) ?c-: C ;u.'/. '/",,.1r C::! nr'7 //:. ,/)/, 7/' ,i 77-f.J~ ,;'If I-./' c.. ;:;K",':'-.. T c_ ;/'7 ,..,r.r-:-: ';<:v"'>"'''/? ~?""/-"?'J/rA::/ C-!jJ"~ rl':'''~) ~p'" ,11,'/ ,Ie; n/'~ ,y' /;.~.;,./ (/,,14 ~",'r",../ -V'tf/17':>~ v' ... ' . ' ../ /' ,;?('".,~ ,.';-{;';'T~)''' /p,..../h,/ ,;f'.1-c,d,---.u,~c ,;'tf,,::> ,r;;://C<..o-J::': ~,,~r./ -5c.'crr "D /'-1f:.c.~(" <:!"~,?-<' c' <9(.., tv"").,.- d..:J,;/ ':>77'--...r -') 0 C"iS.<./h.Jk, /~;'/~0".-1f"'- ,/;;t;,,:J, I' "" CA,), ". \. (-{'~, \ I~\ ,';~.....~, '-.(........:)( "c.-, . ~ ~ , .! :::s::.... -:":"'l"-~ ........:::t...,~.-'~ .V..,. ~_.'t,;.g.~.~.... ;=-- '__~'" ~"--.....Q '-'.....'-.......~...(.~ '",,,-,,-- ~~,'\..;:\ ~'- D ,,_ ,:r~ I;V"J..><>...."'\;,)....... "\' ::....".,......, '~c... _ '(".,.;.~ '. '", ___\~ \.'v....._ ,f.:::>..,~-,....<:.C...."'. ~~"- ,~ '_.:o~...:'\.M"""" ,,'\.___ ..-......A.. c...~..._._.. .;S:..~.:.,\.......c. ~J;....~...,,,,<t:_,,'--...,. ~r'\~ :::!:... .."~""~ ...~,,'-.,.....~........~.... ,~..."..",,~_ ,c..... '" ~... ~ -";;:'-, '- '-" ... ,-,->'- ''''; \." 'Cl~c "-.....\ ~ ~ "- C.~Q' \, '" -.....>"..f'Q!"": ,c;.~ ....'\..- c.:..,"',,~ "'?...\,........ '\.')~""~. .......~ ~c...~" y,. ....""t- C--,," _. ..'-" '-'-.. (' ~,.....,:..."....,\1'\"~ ('....""~ \?1',,,,-,,, '~"""c.. _o.~ ~ a.o-~......~. -...'---- ~...\.-"- C:';'","~c...........\. \'J.Q.,.,tY'o ,,::-.....~... .. '.- ~'.;..;U ~"I"~ '-\'-... 10.....- . .~~ ~--....-~~...C.;",>>.... "'\-'l.- .V....r;..,.~,(;..~"'c;,,, ~....~....c:a.~ ~~c...~._.t.- '"' \.::a.. H ~ "'....,.--"- ~c::.t..'~'......c:..,,~ \,c..c...J..... .--4. ,,," \..: \:.......,,~ <:;.,,\,\, <::.~. ....~__._. ,~,,'~ <2.."""" .;;:.\...,,,,,,-. c;\ ;,:,......""- "...... \"'~-\ \ . :=:s:: ..........::><'..r,' ~~ _.... _._.. \-.,~(.'~ -- ~"'~- .. ~ ,'I., ......~...... '" ''''' '" r.. ,,"":,"n.;,,"';:' ~"'\s ... '" . ..\<- ,...C'.......:::. c.. ~ """', ..........t\,C-.C:::..--..c....a..... .c:;.......',"' t- ~. ~~,,~ c.~'....,~q.....~ \~___ . " .... ~\~. .~ ,--,--,-,,,,, ~~ >..>..s-v_\:. """= c....\L.. --...." '" ",<- .....,~, .. .c.C. GQc....~~ '"3": c<;......... \\.C,,\. c'y,:.,..........."....... '<-~. ., >;:> c ~ ""- ~o. 'r C~~\,~~. \""\0\;;"_ I '<' c.~, \.s-, ,t.;" t~ , i ti '''4,~... I c..\.:....~I2.... 'r-,c..........._ "0; "<:' \,Q..t...."'~ ,...........,.... ",........... \ 'l.' '...-r '- ."__.... ":3:.....__ ........:a ~ '- ~ ~ Cj ~ :I .;Qc t)'''~'''r'\ ~O;~ ......., \0;..."..... ,I ~. .1 "r\.''-' '. -::z;; .,.''..............a.... C._" ".~ , ~ ..-\~ <,;.~,,-... \;....._..... -:a::. "'~"'''' ~'I;).~ 'I.__~ ~..)t;l---- ," Ct;..___.~ ..' -=. ~'N'.. ........:0",--......,,\ c...~c....,,___\.._<;J \Q..~..__ .:,< .. '<-"...._....) \.."'...... ::: ~,~ o{'\c.'- c:<.......,,"-.., ~ ~\, ~ c::: ~.""""'- C~ . .:C~~...o:..-"")Il..._ ~ n........'._\.~. ......." ,,,",- --~<:.. ~ "'..,.,y........ c..", ~~~. .. \ "'-'\.,, c::" ~'. c:. Co .~' C"I. - ..,..,.....:>, "'t> """', ,"''''<:..c 1;1./\'-40. -= "'"'c.... . .:-.<:..,~ '\S--'- <.:.~ '1"",\ '-'~ ,\"{'o,,,,~,,,C.. ""'':''''Q .........Q...- -'i?'i"~'".....~ ..,....... .\,>.......... ~___"~.....,~ ~..,....\ ....,~ -......::.y--e;.o 'h.'",,~ c.\c,c-.,_ ~\..a..... ~"-"'_ c...............>;?,Q...,........ \u~"'~ 'I:;.,.......~ C'~""'''''~ ,"'-la. Cr,~ """r.........;);,.. c.. ~ 'N-..,,\ '"",,c.:.<; 'LS'\~ .. oc:a.....~ ~,~ ......~......'-~ :s:: \"C:.~~ ~""""-\", '",\'_ ~.... "'f'", \~""""-'Y.. .::s: <;....x..a ~ ~~.. ''"\.......... \~~ __ ==-.. C. ('n _. __" ., ............C.C ~~ I C...~ ~"--"- -;:.~...~........."'...J"'\ c:....~~. -.........:.a..... ...:..........&ll...~... ...........u._ .:-~ t'~'~-:>f"\\.. "",-'- ~ "':.r.r- 'S-..' ~ .....\') ~.... -,. (",.",:, t7,""'---N"CJ'";" ~t.._-:. .,~ ("'V"t...~'''''''''''-..J''\. _....~,~.....,... :3: '\"'r..-"..,}'~ '~'{v.:.""-'~rc.~)-'.,,}t_ .......~ <""''l.'~<...'- ,~~~ ~., """'--.....~-- - ~<'\~ m~~~ ~, \..... "\ ---"-"'- ~~~. --- -.::-<:.. '. "" ~~ ,~ .C... ,_~~~"""", c;...,..,:~ \.., "'-A-'C~ ~~~~ ~{-'-'- ~'~'_'::'''''-'.~ . ~"(J""""'C_'" ~~ . "''''''''--'''- ~.. C,C"i G ~c;. ...~" j. c.c.... _ . .,' c." ~\(;,... Q ...........\" '<..~ I~ c:..~... ~Q. CQ...",~ ~ \,<;.~..-- flLl:Uf ~H:I''''.MIlI';1i 10. PlIO IN lil;l lI~n:NOAN'l'tl' I'Oei'J' 'rItlAl. 110TlONS OPINION IN 1I~~t lH:n:NIJAN'I'li' I'UG1' TIt1A!. MOTION6 Olllll-:" or COU/IT ANO NOW. bl'ptL'mlHn 16, 11)1);.1. punw4nt to ttlt' opLnion fih'd thLII dat.. lh'frl'ld4nt In pORl tr HJ 1 mot luna .Ir..- th'n1t"l! and (SUlnLtlllrd. dnd hJllowLng com,)h.tHHl of .1 1111llrt furm prl'IJ~lltl'I1CI' lllVl'IJtl1lnt1on rt>p-:lrt by till' Probation orflCI', hi' u' to "pp...U fut tH'ntl'I~CI' at till' enll of th.. 01IJtrlct Attorn.y. Ily thr Court, Georqt' E. Iloft..r, J. GLED' DECEMUE~ 1, ""J~ I PETITION rOR CORAM NOIlI" WRIT. 1".<1 by <I.rondont. I rlLtDI Or...: CMIHS fl 1. 1 'JILl IN IH:, 51:N'I'f~NCr. COL!.O'lUY I-'lhwIH'd\"9~' twid tll~t,'r.., thl..' lIonol4b111 Gk;Of(';;t: r.. HOt't'Ef~, ,I., curnburItlnd COlJnty CourthouslI, C"rhale, Venneylvan14, on TuelSdtJy, Novl!mblH 14, 1992, eommancln~J at '1140 ..J.m. ln Courtroom Number ThrllQ. rILED' '"CL';MOr.Il J, 19'J2 IN RE. SENTENCE OI<PER or COUR'r AND rlO.-l, Novumber, 14. 1992, dt 91~4 a.m., Ceorge Terrence Carr, havlng Appeared tor !Sontence, and the Cl1urt havlng rece1.ved a PSI, !Sentence at the court on Count ^ 16 that the Oefendill1t pay the coste of pronecut Lon and thAt he undur'1o lmprl6lJnmont 1/1 d ~itat... Corrl1ct1onal In!Stltutlon tor It poriod of not 1ltsG than two yedl"rs nor more than l.'llfht yedrtL We glVE the defendant credit toc" the I5crVI..Cl2 ot time on thl5 sentence trom November 1, 1991. Sentencl.' of th€:' court on COllnt H 15 tildt the defendant PdY the coste of prosoeut ton. By the Court. George E. Hofter, J. rILED. DECEMUEI' 4. 1992 ORDE:~ AND NOW. thllS 4th day of Dec.. 11)92 Upon conslderatlon of the foregolng motlon61 5. The Clerk of this Court iG nrdt..!red and directed to do the fo110w1n9 forthwithl (a) ro ~fHve it copy at thls motlon lJnd th16 order upon 01Btriet Attorney ( bl To send il copy of thl!.. Ulot ion, and thin order to ______ ESQ., the lawyer for the def~n(Jant. To ~end It copy of this order t.tJ the defendant. mrJt10n iH refused. Defend.1nt currently h<18 a dlrl]ct appeal 6. (~ I The pendlng un th~6C very 6dme 165ueB. George E. Hottor, J. ~opy 12.'1.92 D.A. Hubftrt Gilroy, Esq. Dett. copy to CCf.' U-7-l)2 SAIDIS. GUIDO, SHUFF & MAS LAND 26 W. Hllh S'n:" CACHllle. VA GEORGE T, CARR, PLAINTIFF IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBER~D COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO, 94-5051 CIVIL TERM v. TIMOTHY P. CLAWGES, DEFENDANT R8SPONS8 TO PLAINTIFF'S PR8LIMINARY OBJ8CTIONS AND NOW, comes Defendant Timothy P. Clawges, by and through and his attorneys, Saidis, Guido, shuff & Masland and responds to Plaintiff's Preliminary Objections and represents as folloWsr 1. Denied. It is specifically denied that on November 11, 1991, Defendant advised Plaintiff to withdraw his guilty plea. By way of further answer, although Defendant received letters from Plaintiff in November and December of 1991, none of the letters request a withdrawal of plea. 2. Denied. It is specifically denied that on November 15, 1991 Plaintiff advised Defendant once again of his innocence and witnesses and what Plaintiff wanted Defendant to do. By way of further answer, Defendant received a number of letters in November and December of 1991, but none of the letters discuss anything similar to the letter attached as Exhibit "B" to Plaintiff's Preliminary Objections. 3. Denied. It is specifically denied that Plaintiff has alleged sufficient facts showing his innocence by way of lett<!r to Defendant. 4. Denied. The averments of paragraph 4 are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required. To the extent a response is deemed required, it is specifically denied 1 ..... 1,(1 I:: ~r: l.i~ t" .. 1.,= >JJ' '. ,.~ ...; , ... f': . i. . 1..';' " r\ , i!", ! ',' I"'J i, I i.~.. ; .1 . ::..1 " II. ,.,.. '. n ~, U , , ~~'r'....A'.''''''.J .6..<".""," /'.:: -,l,r C:.,'"",,,,,.,-,/r:;(.,,,. ,.,hr C':;4,,.y . ,/"", ,..I'"j "r;.'",,:,.,... ~ .f'i:,..".. ../..., 1.......- '.'~"','./7"ri,,"'":l ~A/.....tl. .. .:.Jr..nh"J~. ~ /JA(..J~_ "",~,- l'.4/-J"", '-'l'/ N,"I./ /-:!...r::.."'c/J /r~/.';!Ir ....c:...' /,(~"I-A- ,,:.......,;k....."'_ ~.';).."AP'7'.,.,O:'-'__. A"''':::}'._!..'~fJ''''''( ~) (j~'2!.:.t.."::.t~.:4';// _u~ /~r'''I' t.!., ~~,..,/:~,-.,.,,' rL ,/"~"'N-''''',-~' .;,?~ .J,.;J,/ ~,.... ;,,;t, ~, -.::,,,/,),,~' "... ~CJ) U-.' .' .'........rl /~.:6,.. -/ . c.:v,<,r CC....d~/ ~I ,"- L... _7:niC"C"/_"'~,#r}'L'~/ ". ,,/rt', ,-4 7 L,/ ,; c~.) ,- C. c....,,~,.r n~'p'" .~,.r ~',',.("4,"""j } /.~~_) _I'J/I,/- 7'-' ) /-;';,.. c' ,~ ) '1 /J ,.J,/ NT' :;;~" ~ .,j;_,J,'.c' ,If ,"0) ~...~. .' " E"I: /"r- .i). ~/ (. (o...,rr.:,...". 7l:/ rL ,.,4 ~/./ .' /.:) ) /W,n_';,'.~- ,. ,4,./ ./~'''~LJ~_ c/ c?,....,."... ??....6, ~ ,:""..-,r tA...;.L~, a ~...r,r(c.'J,~ /1".,,J /~/~ .jF"r:-~~/ c.) ..~..J,ff"J':"'.~_ //:'~1e~~/ ~ ,.""^,,r.,.-/ ~"'r....;" ?G.o/ /: .,.;J,/ ?>Y. 7~7 (:r~L c..1,,.: /f~"y) ..,(J-->../ ,;...,..--., c'" /i-.. /~,. , / e.W,J,....,.-, , rL 7/ / X~"",.r"//.J C!",m ;)-,,, i'J ~..c,r c........o..) ~~ /" ~...../ ';;;"r~ T,;{;, .r ~~,..., ~"-'''.)",ck ,'" L 'l r ./ "'l:,(r>~,-/; "",nJ &u.,~ "1,,....../ eN ~ /i':,., ~""','orN /' '.{~~"'/ ...V........ ~ .r /",,- e..,.,~../ /I ({.rn#"?h ,??,/..JO:"'.'..,..r'I'-.) 4~ ",,- ~..r''-'-.. /IN''''/ ",/,,/ .<kr ,,-/,,,/':'.,4 cJ"t,""J ;./., /'id"/ /......__ .,J.....~'I ? / ./4"'/~.... c/.,,1 ~'/"'I CJ.....".I"'''''/'' ~.' ~.r,,'t.,../ -#?o.n'.j (..J, c..>.jj4?"c' . .!r(..Y /':";;c/ /c,~'(., /o~". (...; (3r./ (',~ "~diT) 4' i-o.,('1' ,y' /.:::,., /L.< r'// r;;:'" /~,,~r;,/./'~ c;'k"". OI"Vl.. ,b.4....../ C',;! 4..-r~ r4r- C-'n,J'-.....JfM"" . c.rw# c_"ur~, ck ,-/. J' /L'...- '7 ,/fF...C'C,~'/ ""';;'1:/ AI ,/z// Alr",./ /'Ar,.; /~"'r"') A.::~ ,c/O'r .6..._" ~/</.-,." .rL...~ ~~.("'~~ -';:-.,.y .Jr~~:"",.""". /~L-~.. C;(;q,.. ? /.... /r',.,.-' ') ,/ ?;cr,"" t/...."';.> C'",;?" ~..vt,h..~_,,-. . .).h.~'dY (4...,,?~, "-'..-,..- Aey"{~..)~....c/ ..,.~ '''''''/ /)/</r/ .,..L.' L )./:."., ..;~~.-- C:<7 ,d 7" ./ ;i,:'..Jc- 6---..-rv_, r7'''':''1 ,-r-~r /,L 7' 7-./J...... ~'--.'" ~,-,,~,....,.. -/. ;II~ '.??'C / r'r -"J 4..~;' r"r,.,,/ r/"'r rL .tJ./~.,~.r- .:.....'tJ) .#,,~.uc/ :n;, (/~, /~".r.:.~, rL /y',.,,r,//:> ;;....,./..,.. /.1,/.:~, .-'7N,/.rL /i'r,...". ".r,J ./,:\.,., ttjA'~~~ t"'.>',v:1'..< "~""'-j""..",,~:r"'''''' ,... ('/;J",- J)-::"-;!-J-"J.-J"."/ ..::z:-.-/ Ac//n"'.....' ...-.:; rL ,y' ~ .'.. .~'-" "',~~",.") ,.'......, " ,.,J ,- ~ ~ .---.,J rz, ~~..'f/ ....>,... .. .r..,i .I / ' A ..J-' A'c,,{...n--,.-,/ ..z:-r -" J .4.'/';",rn,,/ r~r rL..... ~./ ~ r~r /%,n"",,<:r c:hq /f'-',- 6~,,.,/.r- G.4...JC..) '::-'-'1 ~.,~-'- /,,0(..."-'/1 ..4~''''t/''r?'/ /,lJJG....,,/ .rL' ~,,~ r/ G...-/,'/ (,.__,',J /h.,;,....., ,';-/..A..f: J. /<;7/' .A'r 0;;2).' c.c:; ~'H, T L ..(?k~,.4"..- c..-r:.J ,v-d'J ,-./.-/ .rL ~H' A..//77.-~';, /Xn.r,.,.~r.j ~,""".J.),'j t1-'-/~ ,0"',,"';. /;..l....",.J~.J ~ ~<'fI.r- rL /~".r,~/..,~ /7./-,.,. '''''',/, d,,''''J' ,,;,</,/ t-'/<J ~"""'-' "r 7L.... ..;:;0/............ 6f../,d,,,;"- .&-U'J- "r;~</ C)l-omr- 7L /2/MT47, ,AJ ?<...J..//.Tz:. rL .r}t"n,r.r:; .F-",f~/,/- 3, /H,vt:-t"...H'C.. ..J I!..L. t. "~,,,./ ~.r n ./I.v::.. "7""/ ~ -'~.,..... )'r.r4..;7 .,.s:.,/ .//. A 4d~/./"'''''''f''-po(,.:.J c... A:L/. ~3, :/4"'- /...t.AgL,,--- ~j .4LJ"/ <l'" ._..:../'/, " ,...,,7-- ...-;i",r.::> .. ,;.U.{ -.:...."(f 7,L /]1,,,,.-;/;;- j ,-""''''/~:-'''N;;_''', . 'C;Jc,-,-77".J " r~'~ C')};;~':'c.:./#f"'??C/ 7k- rL /.~,.,;-;/7 "/'/""""- c:::.,.",,~ rL C,,""'. ~Jc;O(7' /o/c/ .rLr ,r- c:.....,,:> ?~.::,-".,) ,p/'......(0 .:} "~~/. -,r ,,:J.',,,,, ".:J,..." . / .. /m/ r./- r,{,. ./--~;~J.rl/~. ck~,.) ,{~u-; ~_"r/.1r~,9j ~~ ~'-'4I~~ ?rY'-J.." r .ir- .r4 ./Z/"..,,,..y /;?"'''"'''/ "'"./ 4-';{,' ~.__ 'i.........r- ,-L ho/~"'- ~~rv:..".. r- .-- '/ ~/~" / ,;.,,~~/ C:';';~."'~'l.'- , / ,r...< ,.),// - ~- ,"'~."'''''-'/' , "AI.) t:.-I../'/ ....) /,)'-;',,,,,,-,, ,rl J' c'-" J" I....- ~~ ?/.t...,,,,-, I:> ') /",..'.1~,,,.~,, ~ t',-,4..~:...,.., C-%. ". rJ..r .,&/ ".;;, ';;;;,-~"'c' '//"-/-f" /,'}(",,/;/.' /.....:. "y,?,:-..,./ ~//;;'::/~dr ./;'i.'r';;, / ./ A,) ,,~i'~.....,...~' (', /,0 / /--- /.2*-:'11.//",/,,--: Ti,. ........,k..."ni , ////.I'rJ ,n~...Y'/ rL /' /' ~ ,/~).../;:"./,J"7.- A",.,) ",.,.-.,,- ,....,,.J./.:/ 6,,) "'~7- ~?rl.-:C:~"'" ,. I CI,n/ ,..,~;,~~....~ ",.-,L",- ?--,// ~..)/,Jurc" ",.-4, ./U~",,/,;/7 J c-x.,."._:. , /~"",/ ~..-,,/L-~ , , ':;',11:/ ~;~;,f' t' c-/' Ll-/;,'..~nT:J CY./-... ~'./ C'/X/A?.-t:-r> ~'J /:A:."..." ~....5~"" ...,/;'r,c.r ~~n/ ~_../..I--..T ~'-.K',r T'::; ;L 6~/;L '7/ ," ,/ '#/...rT;//'- ...-L. ,,4~,) / .[~ no "//0'/'/ ij r L- /-.}..... /-;JC'U''''~''A''/C''''' r/.t.,r- /4' /-',~'-JT;/7.:) r::::-:Jh~"._. ",a;'c/ c/-" ?"",J,- ~_~,fl" ,no .I ~-'.:../~4:A"7rC/,..{/ rL. /;;'c> <,/ ~~~,' E,',1/ / -~ .?",;{ /: 7'. (-J ..4",./'",-"';.,/ /' /- /] .:C-A:L /- is, ~ ,4t:y';'" ,rr...c/ .;Cr t:.....'C:-'. ".aufn,7'?"7-'c/,..(/ rL j?./':o~nr ;r;{.,r /":J---/;.~/~,:- .;/,/.:z-.v<,''''~r,/"..rc'' /4 /~,.,.////j ~_~ ~",t:/ c':../ .z;...~,K? V',;rc~' rL ;Y'.,,,,,;.,,//.:.; "'-Y''-'''7n~'..J'''''''':' ~L ../."X:...~c:.J"'.....t; '/:?.<"J,'///', e.-'"....' T.) ;rc;, /..!-.> C::X'''--''-4' .,f';"~c/ C-"..-:) ~~'... / /~c''''7 . .7~.r- ...r./ ./..-7..,..:/.::';'~n,- c,.(c/ .:;:-,.,-"'.....T'/...J7C rL, /'-!.!/O,Q/;r' J cXO,WJ, /L /,.)./;:;h4"....-- /" Tk. i<-'~'-./~./ /l..:~...... /)~J,.C',.""...,~c/ .7 h.;r. Cn ...... (~.....-, ,;,J(;., / ~'" c..:.... ~:,.;..";,,.-''''~ / c2.~~.J....-:'/,_lr' ...'..L.....cJ /;:r:.,/'., ;':<'NJ,J ~- -, TL ~. ./ .}:::/"",r///-- .-6> /.~, d',/' c' ;;-;"...:.,,/ /J.;",~/ .r".; rl-c_ < ."l.r":'J.h,~,.r r:;:, .J,G.".. ./ .z-""""'~~.J''-'''"JA'''''';'Il.':''- , ..-c. 7_/..:~... ':::"r" e..,,":.../c'/' .A.,<........ ~"'......... ../ r.l..,- ,.4- ..,;:?-.::r....-'7'N....' /1"1>-1 G'A~ ""'./..c" ./(..........",/A"-;:../ "()? /A) ~...x-..) C67~:''''.-./ ~"r'j---- ,,~. rL..- c"i',m.,,, / c;:".v!~"r ,##('/,,r .l'k.. .LJ",~;"..A":".r- ~....,1:L.:' ..r;'/"~"",,..r..</,',L / /.""....".~,~- (,,-,,<'. ...,:.'/h" .... ./--;;J,,~,.,,'V-/ 7'&-*;- rL c'1r-',nnA-/ c:?...'/..J4-:...,,,... <'r......,L"'...,...,It: /,'9/ ~.. r-.Jr...M,Jj..../' .n;I ~ C' ,/;0/-"-- L'f!_!,.#,,,,,,... en ...A..-,y, .J, /~fl, ,AT fL /-:K'~"'JT'/';'-'j fl,~../-m",.. 7' /~~,....,Y ...zr' /'L /.J./';,.~r ~""'''''~?'''.7>'/ r,.(~. C}({....~.,j :7""/ ..i}.-w~,.:4,r .."-o-J<'...../<'/ A.'G'-4' ~:'..A~,_/~"t,r rL ;X~.I.r,....-.r"~ ~...,....... Tn".... /.7...70'-...................., "l-:-.t6~",,'r C,-c:;"p,..,c' t..,.x'.,j .......L ,4/;r;....""r ",-,,J;;; /Co:-,c rL, C~:/""".rl' / C::~?/.-,......r ,,-,r ....A.,...- ~ /f'f/, And ':'-'C1-J /1~ ~- rL ./7,.."":",11),'7 /;i.",..,? .'~ ---'--"/ 3/J}"/, evL..,.. -i ~'.j br"'~/'.J,i;/ r/.'- rL c:-;:,'/...n',,,/ /?..--/-J/':'07'-- ,d.- ---'---' ~.: /J-Y'/ t.....A J /1 ,.t;;.t..- -;::/ . ~'~.:.:~"''''Ir- /J"-'e/ r..t/ r-L... ;}(.,,.,7"/// '..J ,.y~..... ,,,....~... .....:? / / <)/ .-...- ~::> c.. ....."'./f' ?V;r,L., '/-/l-'/r/r,./r.';' ..L/...~~, ./J/ c.....,.'7 ..../- A:,../L:- c..~/J.),~,., ./ / /2/ ;:-,- P.../....;,'../..nr .:z-.....I7:"', "-<O,.'.......,,e/ '/L< /:#>1~??/7~ 1"')1''''''''-_ .....",.........." 4.14- .(c_LlJ 11/ rL, ,?~''''Jr/~:.J ,...p,~- Tn.....:>> ..Jo...6/J...."N'/ 'TO ,;;r-~"'7 ~L,.., r~J ....'7''''~'....,',./,J...-:.>... t:......"",j ,;<1 c-;.~~. / 4.-/'n.....,j.:> ,11",-/, 8..../.c./ /.?.I"- -~.P............,...,.../.rL. ;~""'7",,/;r~ ~",(...._... ,4,<,// r.4 ~~.....r,""n /,v""~"""''''.It'' ~ ..1",." ,4",// r/...../ / L '"-)...,,;;...~..~""/' e'..."/c'/ -4.::<-,-, ~"".r'J<.J"''''/ ,rA..,r- .r~ /?..,.,..'"..~/ ;'^',~I ..6.",.>" ~/".A" c:.........> ./h.........-9' .,:;",-r,./ '-&.J, ~r'1I' ~-" ,6f"c-c.......u...4- ,. ~ :;",,,,..-..J c.",_r r""'~ rL.- a,..,.......,~...r;'./~.~ ",. /A/.,l....,. C';'-,~,)A'-,,,,;",,,,, A"..I' J,""~,,,c /' "'r/~ ",,'/ .' ....../-)../. ~ ,',;' .~..:.,~"r.,11/ ~""""""/'''I' ..n./ .....-\A.......",/ h.~ / . ? /.. .rk . e"....c ,,{,J.01C''Y -L 0:./,. k_..J ~"-?,..J"'''''.),'''.~/ ,;cc~c~.~tL~7 ~ 7"c' c'; <' /.:J'" ........,y .f':: ~ c;-,...".,.?'r... r-a t'.//- '''~}i,,4/~ -J..-".'",/ ~~. h?l...A- ""'t:/",,,~......c'I~~..J ,AJJ ~..// ./"'"4 .~~,.........JW""'CW c''''' ~N .r,4 /""""-''''''''':1 .........' rk,,,'''' r,.{..r- 7":........ c;c....~ rY-' ~ C"jo"'''/ ,.,/~../...y c;.//-.,/d ~./."..",- .......L~,/2........-..-..... ...A""'__'" A?C"'''''u:!. .rL a,7j ...-.L...> d/.-~"/ ....""'~~A.4!! rr/:. M-....J AN"..... .AI' "?".,6 70 "'''n,/ <3...,/ ...,t,L..- o1.JI.,?,,<.-4- (.rL', /'..-..-~.J jr~.,'j ''<.Jr- r":' d..-- C--",.1''''' '/ "n,tC',-,~/ ,.,.."..,.... .6--- .-r.:,,{.'/''/',,#..> .:"...."."../ ~- rL /;J-v'';';',,~,r- /0/ '/ ...... /-:.r-'",rJ.",/Jk ..<'--:2".""./.1 .......,i..,.. c;'/........ .rL c ~L,,-- """"",6,~ ....z-;..'-'..,,'-,~"'T...'/ rL ./-'J.(~,r",rJ c?4......,; rL, rL L/-k;'.~ ""-.....,./ ~""" .Ai?../-.).../ .rL".. I'? ~:.. .......;;>.....;P--K Tc;. ./;~ G' ..n,--r,......, ~....:,,-'-"'~,-..J rL /~....r,-'.r;c:.o h~-rr7 c'L:cJ~.. c:;-,,,~,...r; br.- c:-o....-. ~:J../,:...,J~~....- ~C:.4..;//. .h..:....... ......,;;'.....'''--r.-c/ ~/'r ,,/- cL'./jr.t:-......I C"""r ...,...-."..L ,;2.J_.".r,~ ~./ "..1,4/......... ./A-c:"..,.,~,....,,,-::. /.h ~~ r;,t&';:;~.,,~/ /~~:,............ (.~? ,d(.o.,,-I .r-L ~---:;)"/;'11 c ~"r c:-/',/ /1. r ...=;.,t,.;....j,..? tIfJ.n: rL ......~".r;r,r.) "L ';:j{.n"'"I"r~ ~~_./ A/.:,K :;z:>, ,/ r~ ;:J.h,.~--'r .....z-#./"")',~~.,.,,_ ~y~...,,,~.,),~ . rL ,4)./;;r1,~"r ,,-/./ /L n!.: ~"..)c.:t;"',;G~ c:. ~"" ,,r:' c',..,. vi~n,-,- ",,-.'-// ",rr /f~ 7A,iC..o /?{c'~ ,A./lC,K' ;IfJ~~c.c:.~,....../. -;-..- ~' ;/ ~ II' .. ,- ", ...-: (7; ~--~ .. "'\ r u.J~, ., (.? i: ' .,' . ,. " il- '<.: 0: , \, " 3f. (' In ,"': ., d I I. " 'I" r.: b' .'. , ,:it" -'. F" .., " , ~ .. . t, u: ':, (1', u ....-. /.' . ~ " LAW OfJ'lCllIl , 'AlDIS, GlJIDO, SHurr II M,ULAND :II W,llIOH IITUIT IIOP ......kHT STUIT c:....~ P/\ 1'/fI" C....., HILL, f... 17011 PIIOHI C1J1) 14'.6122 · I'IlGMI (117) lt7'J405 CEkTll'l1lD COPYI -~., . 11 ~Nlal999~ v. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 94-5051 CIVIL TERM GEORGE T. CARR, PLAINTIFF TIMOTHY P. CLAWGES, DEFENDANT BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO COMPLAINT lL p'ROCEDURAL HISTORY On July, 11, 1994, Plaintiff George T. Carr filed a Complaint in the Commonwealth Court against Defendant Timothy P. Clawges, a public defender, alleging that defendant failed to properly defend plaintiff in a criminal proceeding involving charges of aggravated assault, This Complaint has never been -- properly served on defendant. On July 18, 1994, the Commonwealth Court transferred the matter to the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland county, Plaintiff filed a petition to proceed in forma pauperis which was denied by the Honorable Edgar B. Bayley of the Court of Common Pleas of cumberland County on September 6, 1994, On October 9. SAlOIS, GUIDO, SHUt'F " MASLAND 16 w, Hiah SlI... Cnlll.I., PA 1997, plaintiff filed it second motion to proceed in forma pauperis and a mot ion for the appointment of counsel. On October 14, 1997, Judge Bayley granted plaintif f' s pet i tion to proceed in forma pauper is, but denied appointment of counsel, On or about November 2, 1997, plaintiff filed an additional Complaint against defendant alleging that defendant was negligent SAIDIS, GUIDO, SIIU.'F &< MASLAND 26 W, Hllh SIr<<. Clllh.lt. PA . . . . .. with a maximum of three months imprisonment for violation of the PFA. Ex. B, PFA docket at 4. Plaintiff was paroled immediately because he had already served the minimum oentence. ~. On April 29, 1992 a non-jury trial was held in front of the .........t Honorable George E. Hoffer at which plaintiff was f~und quilty of aggravated assault and terroristi~ threats.' Also on April 29, 1992, Judge Bayley appointed Hubert X. Gilroy, Esq. to represent plaintiff on a motion for post conviction collateral relief related to defendant's representation of plaintiff in the aggravated assaul t charge. Ex. C, Agg. Assault docket at 3. Plaintiff's motion for post conviction relief was filed by plaintiff on April 27, 1992 and was denied and dismissed by the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County on September 16, 1992. Plaintiff, he is thus adjudged. Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Office of the Prothonotary, Civil docket, Protection From Abuse, Case Number 2062/1991, Order of Court dated November 7, 1991, Docket page 4, attached hereto as Exhibit B (hereinafter referred to as "Ex. B, PFA docket") . The Courts of Pennsylvania have long recognized that courts are permitted to take judicial notice of their own court dockets. See Commonwealth v. Bond, 516 Pa. 171, 178, 532 A.2d 339, 343 (1987); CommQnwealth v. Bvrd, 325 Pa. Super. 325, 332, 472 A.2d 1141, 1145(1984); Commonwealth v, Socci, 177 Pa. Super. 426, 28, 110 A,2d 862, 63 (1955) (explaining that a court may take judicial notice of a record which bears the seal of any court of the state) . Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas, Office of the Prothonotary, Criminal docket, Aggravated Assault, 2176/1991, Order of the Court dated April 29, 1992, Docket page 3, attached hereto as Exhiblt C (hereinafter referred to as "Ex. C, Agg. Assault docket"). Exhibit C is at tached to this Brief in Support of Defendant's Preliminary Objections because Exhibit G to the De fendant' s Prel iminary Obj ect ions was an i.ncomplete record of the docket entries related to Criminal case 2176/1991. 3 SAIDIS, GUIDO, SIIUFF '" MASLAND 26 w. Hilh 5....' C",Ii.lt, PA ~ . .. . 1019 (a) . Courts have determined that this requires a complaint to define the issues involved in the complaint and set forth "every act or performance" essential to show the cause of action asserted in the complaint. Miketic v. Baron, 450 Pa. Super. 178, ],83, 675 A.2d 324, 330 (1996) (quoting SantiaQo v. Pennsvlvania Nat. Mut. Cas. Ins. Co., 418 Pa, Super. 178, 183, 613 A.2d 1235, 1238 (1992)). Plaintiff's complaint alleges "ineffective assistance of counsel," Defendant assumes that Plaintiff is attempting to set forth a claim of criminal defense malpractice. The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania has established that a plaintiff seeking to bring a malpractice action against a criminal defense attorney, resulting from the attorney's representation of the plaintiff in criminal proceedings, must establish the following elements: (1) The employment of the attorney; (2) reckless or wanton disregard of the defendant's interest on the part of the attorney; (3) the attorney's culpable conduct was the proximate cause of an injury suffered by the defendant/plaintiff, i.e., "but for" the attorney's conduct, the defendant/plaintif f would have obtained an acquittal or a complete dismissal of the charges. (4) as a result of the injury, the criminal defendant/plaintiff suffered damages. (5) moreover, a plaintiff will not prevail in an action in criminal malpractice unless and until he has pursued post-trial remedies and obtained relief which was dependant upon attorney error; additionally, although such finding may be introduced into evidence in the subsequent action it shall not be dispositive of the establishment of culpable conduct in the malpractice action. 5 "i I . .. .. Bailev v. Tucker, 533 Pa. 237, 250-51, 621 A.2d 108, 114-15 (1993) (footnotes omitted). Additionally, with respect to the third e~erneflt e!,!!:.~p.~~!:I~_e.~i.?~a.i,:~:" the sup~em~court noted':,~at "[t]he defendant/plaintiff must prove by a preponderance of the , . ... ,.' _'C"_ ___ . ~ " ...."....- .p." , . . .",..~ evidence that he did not commit any unlawful acts with which he " was charged as well as any lesser offenses included therein." ",. ....._,._~----.. --'.-"-'~--~-~""-"'.'.-'~ p.'...... ..". Bailev, 533 Pa. at 251, 621 A.2d at 115 n.12. Plaintiff has failed to allege all the facts necessary to satisfy the elements of a criminal defense malpractice cause of action as set forth in Bailev. 1. Plaintiff's complaints fail to allege that plaintiff has pursued all available post-trial remedies and has obtained relief based on attorney error. In bringing a criminal defense malpractice cause of action, a plaintiff must aver that the plaintiff pursued all available post trial remedies and obtained relief predicated upon attorney error. ~ Bailev, 533 Pa. at 250-51, 621 A.2d 114-15; Slauqht.er, 453 Pa. Super. at 383-84, 683 A.2d at 1236 (1996). Plaintif f' s complaints fail to do so. Plaintif f has pursued post -conviction reI ief alleging inef fect i ve assistance of counsel with respect to both of his convictions and has been denied relief. Exhibit "B", PFA docket and Exhibit "C", Agg. Assault SAlOIS. GUIDO. docket. Plaintiff's latest Post Conviction Relief Act petition SHun' " MASLAND related to his aggravated assault conviction was denied by the 26 W. HiSh 5'"" ClUli.le,PA Honorable George E. Hoffer on July 14, 1997. Judge Hoffer's order required appeals from the order to be taken within 30 days of its issuance. Plaintiff failed to appeal the Order, and thus 6 SAlOIS, GUIDO, snUFF & MASLAND 26 W. Hllh Sir"' CIlIi.le. fA . . . . . plaintiff has waived his l'ight to appeal the matter. Exhibit lie", Agg. Assault docket. Further, plaintiff's PCRAs alleging ineffective assistance of counsel relating to plaintiff's violation of the PFA have also been rejected. Exhibit "B", PFA docket. Plaint if f' s complaint has not alleged that he has been granted post-conviction relief based on claims of ineffective assistance of counsel.. He is unable to allege facts necessary to satisfy all the elements of a cause of action for criminal defense malpractice. Based on the dockets in both the criminal matter and the PFA matter, Plaintiff cannot in good faith allege that he has prevailed in his post-conviction remedies. 2. Plaintiff has failed defendant's negligent was the proximate conviction. to allege that representation cause of his In order to support a valid claim of criminal defense malpractice, a plaintiff must show that the defendant's culpable conduct was the proximate cause of an in1 ury suf fered by the plaintiff. In other words, "but for" the attorney conduct, the plaintiff would not have been convicted of the criminal charges. See Bailev, 533 Pa, at 250-51, 621 A.2d 114-15; Slauqhter, 453 Pa. Super, at 383.84, 683 A.2d at 1236 (1996). Plaintiff has failed in his attempts to convince courts through PCRA petitions that his injuries resulted from culpable conduct on the part of the defendant. In order to satisfy the proximate cause element in a criminal defense malpractice action, a plaintiff must show that he has previously obtained relief based on attorney error 7 SAIDIS, GUIDO. SHun' & MASLAND 26 W. Hiah Slrnl Carlisle:. PA . .. .. through post-conviction proceedings, As stated above, Plaintiff has been unable to obtain such relief. 3. Plaintiff has failed to allege facts showing that Plaintiff is innocent of the criminal charges for which is was convicted. In order to prevail, plaintiff must prove beyond a preponderance of the evidence that he was innocent of the crimes with which he was charged and any lesser included offenses. ~ Bailev, 533 Pa. at 251, 621 A.2d at 115 n.12; Slauqhter v. Rushi..ng, 453 Pa. Super. 379, 383-84, 683 A.2d 1234, 1236 (1996). While plaintiff' B complaints do alJ.ege that he was "wrongfully convicted" (Plaintiff's 1994 "Civil Action" at 4), plaintiff does not allege facts showing that he was innocent of either of the crimes for which he was convicted.' In fact, at his PFA contempt hearing plaintiff admitted to Judge Hess that he was in contempt of the PFA. Ex. B, PFA docket at 4. Plaintiff's complaints fail to set forth facts essential to show the element of innocence as required in a criminal defense malpractice cause of action, and demurrer should be granted, Even assuming that the letters attached to plaintiff's "preliminary objections" as exhibits "A" and "B" were sent to the defendant, the fact remains that plaintiff does not allege sufficient facts showing his innocence, If accepted at face value, the letters merely show that plaintiff has in the past declared to the defendant that he was innocent of the PFA violation. A mere statement of innocence cannot satisfy the preponderance of evi.dence burden placed on the innocence element by the Pennsylvani~ Supreme Court in Bailev. 8 . . " IXHIBX'l' "A" 2176 CRIMINAL 1991 This opinion will first review the history of each crime and then discuss the latest petition. In July of 1991, the Court granted a Protection from Abuse Order (hereinafter .PFA') to Nancy Tolan. This order was to protect her from abuse by George Carr. The court granted the order based on a Consent Agreement signed by Carr, In this agreement, Carr consented to refrain from abusing and harassing Tolan. He also agreed not to enter Tolan's apartment and to stay away from her altogether. (Protective Order, 7-23-91.) On November 1, 1991, Carr violated this order. He went to Tolan's apartment and broke one of her windows. That same evening the police arrested Carr for Indirect criminal contempt based on this violation. (Police Report, 11-1. 91.) A hearing was held in Cumberland County before the Honorable Kevin A. Hess. Carr admitted to being in contempt of the PFA. He was sentenced to a minimum of seven days with a maximum of three months Imprisonment. Carr was paroled immediately because he had already served the minimum sentence. (Order of the Court, 11-07-91,) In 1 994, Carr filed a petition for Post Conviction Relief based upon the contempt conviction. The Honorable Judge Hess denied this petition. The court 2 2176 CRIMINAL 1991 found that Carr was Ineligible for relief because he had already completed his sentence. Therefore, the petitioner had no standing to challenge his conviction, (Order of the Court, 10-21-94.) Carr's second crime occurred on the same day In which he violated the protective order. The pollee took Carr to Cumberland County Prison after he violated the PFA. As Carr was being escorted to one section of the prison, he grabbed Brent Barrows, an unarmed corrections officer, Carr placed Barrows In a 'full nelson' hold. Barrows tumed red In the face, was unable to breathe, and began to choke. At this same time, Carr alternatively threatened to kill Barrows or break his neck. Two other correcllons officers had to Intervene and subdue Carr. (Order of Court, 9-16-92.) A non-Jury trial was held In front of this Judge concerning this incident. Carr was found guilty of aggravated assault and terroristic threats. (Order of Court, 9-16-92.) After this trial, Carr filed a pro se Post-Trial Motion alleging that his trial counsel was ineffective. The trial court appointed Carr counsel for this motion. The appointed attorney, Hubort Gilroy, determined that trial counsel was not ineffective. Gilroy found that trial counsel cross-examined the Commonwealth's witnesses and argued disputed issues to the judge. Based on these findings, the defense counsel filed a brief in support of Carris posttrial motions which disputed 3 2176 CRIMINAL 1991 only the suHlclency of evidence to support a convlcllon of aggravated assault. (Order of Court, 9-16-92.) The trial court found that there was substantial evldenc3 to convict Carr. It denied and dismissed the petitioner's mollons. (Order of Court, 9-16-92.) Petitioner appealed this decision to the Pennsylvania Superior Court. The Superior Court affirmed the trial court's decision by order on May 19, 1993. (Order of Court, 5-19-93,) Carr then filed a pellllon under the Post Convlcllon Relief Act again alleging IneHectlveness of trial counsel. Petitioner argued that the trial court was Incorrect in finding that the Commonwealth's witnesses were more credible than the defendant. The Court held that the trier of fact has discretion In determining whose testimony to believe. The trial court found that Carr's petitions were based on his dissatisfaction with his convlcllons rather than on a recognized ground for relief under the PCRA. For these reasons, the trial court denied Carr's petition. (Order of Court, 6-06-94.) Carr also appealed this judgement. It was affirmed by the Pennsylvania Superior Court on August 25, 1995. The Superior Court found that the petition was nothing more than a variation of Carr's post trial motion claim of insubstantial evidence. The Superior Court noted that overwhelming evidence supported Carr's 4 2176 CRIMINAL 1991 aggravated assault charge. Therefore, he could not obtain relief on the basis that trial counsel was ineffective for failing to advance a meritless claim. (Order of Court, 8-25-96.) Petitioner has now filed at least his third petition under the PCRA, In this he alleges that during the hearing for Nancy Tolan's PFA, the Commonwealth falsified evidence in order to procure a protective order. Additionally, Carr claims that his lall time, based on this finding of contempt from the PFA, amounted to false Imprisonment. DISCUSSION A court may dismiss a petition for post conviction relief when a previously counseled petition "raising the same Issue or Issues [is] determined advorsely to the petitioner. Otherwise, the court must appoint counsel and afford an opportunity to amend." Commonwealth v, Garrison, 303 Pa,Sup.555,557, 450 A.2d 65,66 (1982). In this case, Carr has already petitioned the court raising the same Issues, Carr claimed ineffectiveness of counsel in his first PCRA petition. The court dismissed this petition because Carr had no standing to sue. His parole had ended and there was no relief available to him. This reasoning can be applied to the present petition. Carr's maximum 5 2176 CRIMINAL 1991 sentence from the contempt hearing expired on or about February 1, 1992. Tho current petition was flied four years later. Therefore, this court can offer no relief to the petitioner. Additionally, these Issues are similar to those raised In the earlier pelltlon. Carr previously claimed that his counsel for the contempt hearing was Ineffective. He now claims that the evidence used In determining the PFA was false. This Is a variation of the same theme. Based on this, the Court does not have to appoint counsel for Carr, These Issues have been previously raised and decided adversely to the petitioner. Additionally, the PFA was ordered pursuant to a consent agreement signed by Carr. Therefore, Carr's claims concerning false evidence and false Imprisonment are meritless, The court issuing the protective order based It on the consent agreement by Carr rather than any evidence submitted by the Commonwealth, Furthermore, the PCRA "limits eligibility for relief to person who is 'currently' serving a sentence on the conviction which he or she seeks to attack collaterly." Commonwealth v, Pierce, 397 Pa, Sup. 126,130, 579 A.2d 963.965 (1990). Carr does not have standing to bring this petition, His parole for violating the PFA ended on or about February 1,1992, This petition was not filed until 1996, Therefore, there is no relief available to Carr concerning this matter. This Court finds these claims to be meritless. Furthermore. these issues 6 VUI I oJ, CaslI /I 10'11 ,hJllH lJ s DIIII) "I [ntry Appoiltancos: Plnintl": N.1l1cy f:, 'I\:> Ian v., Defendant: George T, Carr , 9'11 01 M Entry by Summons I Complaint I Petition I x Appeal I Revival I !'!!!.t1_1p:lm Abu'!.'!...._. I X Acllon in Assumpsit Trespass Habeas Corpus Divorce Grounds Equity Mortgage Foreclosure Ejectment Quiet Tille Replevin Condemr11ltlon I ( I I Juno 13, 1991, PDtition for I'rotDcnvo Ordor, and Tenporary Protect(vo Ordor, filed, IWD t-a-I, ttu. 13th day Df Juno, 1991, at 10,10 a,m" upon pre.entation and conoidorat:on of tho within Petition, and upon finding that the plaintiff, Nancy E, Tolan, now reoiding at 142 SOuth flanovor Street, Carlisle, t\Jtbcrland County, Pennsylvani.a, is 1n i.nTood14tc end present danqctr Qf obuse from the defen~nt, George T. Carr, t~lQ followlng 'l'<<:JT'POcary Order 15 entered. The dc[cnddJlt, George T. 0lee, whoso cuctl:!nt addrclSlS io unkrooI.n to the plaintiff, io hereby enjoined fran physicall abuoing tho plaintiff, Nancy E. Tolan, Dr placing her in fear of obuse and i8 excluded frun and is ordered to stay lrWay from the reoidonce located at 142 SOuth Hanover Street, carlisle, C\.JIrbcrland County, Pennsylvania, 8 residence leased 5011!1y by the plaintiff. The dcfcnd/Ult is hereby not Hied that if l1e r('~; l<ler. in the plllint 1 ff 15 domicile contr.\ry to this Order, he may be in lndircct crDninal contempt which i.s punishable by (1 fine not to C'xcccd Sl,OOO.OO lind/or by a IScotence at up to six rronths lrl jall dlld any otMr appropria punist"v'rent. Consent of the plllintiff shall not invlllidatc this Order. Tho defend8nt shall seck rmdificati.on (chango) of this OnJ(~l h,~((lre rC5lJ1Ung r"~iid')ilCC in the plol/lt iff's daniello, ....neccver it IMY be. The defendant is restrained frorn entering the place of elTfJloym:mt of the plalntiff andlor from hMasoing the plaintiff or the plaintiff'. relative.. '1115 Onll'r shall rCll\lln in Cf((Kt until II fin\11 order 15 entered in this case. A /lcunng stldll b() hl'1d on this Imtter (Hl the 19th day of June, 1991, at 8145 <I.m.. in Courtn)(I" No.4, (\lTt),'r:,1I1c! County Court/lot:',e. (,1["11510, Pcnnljylvdllia. The plillnt 1ft ~y procf..'(!d in (omu pauperis pending d further order after the heanng. '110 OJdJl.rl.1nd County Sheriff's [~p<'rtrrcnt Sh.lll attL'1ll't to m.lke s(~rvice at the pll1intlff's refJUcst, but set-vice ll\lY blJ occonplishcd under dllY applicc1ble rule of Civil Procedure. 'l"a Carlisle, Police OJpartrront wlll be provided with a copy of this Order by attorneys for plaintIff. Tins Order. :;h,1l1 lx' pilforcN by llllY \.1..... enforccrront dt]011C:Y shere a violdt1011 (X";c;urs by anl'lit for lnc!lmct cnmind! contefTl1t without ...';lrC(1nt up::m prob..lblc caw)c thc.1t thu Order 11<]:.> Ocell vlolcJtcd, whetheL- or not the VJ.oldtlon ia cx:xnnitted 1n the presence of the police officer. In the e\'l~nt that nn I1rn~"t is m,de under this ~(\ction, the dcfend,l:H 'shall not LJI~ tdkell to ).111 but ;;1:"111 t.. tdxcn wllhout Ultw!ccssary delay bcf()n~ till.! CQun th.lt issued the Ol:dar. When th,lt COllI t i!i U11<1v.:,ililulo, tile defendallt Gl'\.lll be arraig'lcd before rJ dl:;t'-lCt Justlce wtll) 51\0111 ~;I't b.lil ilccordlfl<] to the provislOn~> of Cl~ptcr 4000 of the PotUl5ylvimiil Rules of Crinun,ll Proc<..."durl2 (23 P.5. Section 6113). by 111(' Court I Kevin A. Hess, J. Taxation of Cost,; L 11 q, il, I.. ~ .,..... "'))"', I Service by SHF: 4 ,90!? of ~ ~~I~~n: It /U-(/L '\ 'J,J, ; ,~"'L;. $3'j.O~~111 County LNI<ll Sl'LV1Ll!!; ,ul'-I l't ' J j, (' II ~ coo_,jJd {l-H..~-,~r.ml(f. .1.1.- I/_.~~'._~'" __ __.:~_.L..:'~t-:::._,. '--~..n' , ~,,~,l. /J Receipt of r el~S (:~h.~ ). J .,/ - ----1 .1 .---'-1-- , '---r-~ --------~~-- J'J/," jI!. II"'" 1"P III Wl'hll".... "" 11',,1. f Ill'oj ^ 1'1'111jI,1I 111'1'11111'.11'1/\ nl,rI AlII',.. ""'d', IIII'd, .II~) ...01', 1'1111'1 I,d III '/1" .It,,,'.'1' ."pll"III'rll ,I','> ',fI/llIlI' I J, IIJ'}I. 'hI' 01" P"I I,. ....'llh,jJ,IW'lI, Ihl 'j'1",,,",lty '11,1"1 "'''':,Il/'d, ,UlI) j't ,'ljfl'-Itl ,I Tl'jI~"Jl"IY I"Iltl,..t Ivn I/.dl/I I'll" pl,lllllllf ''''rll''.!', 1/1011 Ill} "ll I hr" J It 1'~lt )1"1 pIJl',ljl'd ltYl .).).1/1 f "'1'" I.hq, IUtll'iH, 1'1'11, 1't'tll1o/l lill 1'1,,11'1;11\11' 111111', .lJld TI",X)rIJry I'PH,'cllVI' ont(,l., fl1mJ. ANI I "'M, tll1ft JIHtl 1111Y 01 ,huJI!, 191H, lit JaOll'.H., upon j>tt"HJCntiltlon Junt Cl>l1tudurdtloll Ilt ltll.' .....IUllfl 1'lll1tH1J\, ,uld upon fllldllllJ tt'lllt the 1'14111tHf, ~ 1':, ToLan, now n.!luduII, at 142 South IIon<Mu' SlrDOt, eArUoln, ~",*",rl_ cwnty, ''''''''''ylvlVilil, 10 In uJlTlldla.o ,1m) pnHwnt dnnqcr of dbUIi!] fro'l Uu.' dt>h'I\l:t.Ult. CbJrga T. DirT, the followlnq TmfXlr4ry nrd'Jf 16 I.HltllrrJd. nil! l>tr..mdNlt, GtYJr-t,., T. (:'lrr, .....h{j!il~ lh ulrrr.'/llly lnCl\fCl1ratL><t Ul CuttJcrland County 'nbcln, 1~ tlurlJUY OnjOUH'l! ftulI phYtill.'dUy .,blHHIlI.llha pla1nuff, N.:VleY .:. Tnl.un, or plannq ,lor 111 r.....1I IJf .Ibu~... and II> I})([:lulled '1I"" ,Uld 1" l)utrJrcd to ISt.,y "-'ilY Crun thl1 rntudlJnco Icx:"tf:>tl "t 147. rOJth IlJulIl'VI.r titnYlt, ('..,rIlAln, Ollbuland CrJU1ty, l'r.lvulylVN\l.4, .1 rmHdcncQ lelJl.ild ~l)l.Jly by thl! pl.llfltltf. 'I'h., dlttfmdmll lK hurcby notlfwd thl1l If he ruludeG 11'1 U., pl.'1ntlft'(\ domell,' contr'frY to tlUh Ordl'r, IIn ""lY 00 In 1I1dnoct crJJTUnnl contlYll)t ....tlll-.:h 1:; ptlIlUih"blc by .1 fUll.! not tll IJ)lU'f'd SlOOO,OO lUld lor uy .1 ticntencQ of up to 61)( "k)I'lth~ U\ JI'll MId 11I1Y utllQr appropnnto punu~tmmt, Cont5cnt of tho plaint 1ft to the dcfcndrlllt'!J roslIt'ptlon of rcsldl.'nco .....1th the plaintiff shall not Invalidate thu Ordor. 't1w defendant Bhall 15t!ek nudH lcotlon (ctWlgrl) of thh Order bofon! rcsU1\lng reruooncu Ln ttlQ p141ntlff't5 dooUC11c, .....hcrcvl!r 11 n't1Y bu. Tho dchmdNlt 1ft. rcritr,onncd fran I1ntunnll thu ploce of ooy>loyrTll!nt of tho pltUntltf olnd/or Lrcxll hdrLll:ilung UIlJ plfunuff or tho plaintiff's relatives. Ttns Order shall rC'mun 111 nff,'ct 'mtll .1 flnd order 1!l entered In th16 caso. ^ hearUll) st1illl be huld em thu It\1ttcr un ttv.o 6th dllY of July, 1991. ~t 10130 A.M., in Courtnx,1 t-tJ. 4, ClITt....'rl.1I1d County COlJrtIIOlJfiC. Cdrlui11!, l\!IV'lsylv6J'1ilJ. The pl.,nUCC moy proceed ,in COrtM pIJU(lIll''' pending a CIlrthor ordor aftcr tho heM1J1q, Thl!' CurriXlrlMld County Sherl(f'f\ Dcp.utlnmt 6h,,11 ~tt<Yf11t to rMk~ servico at the p14U1t1tf'~ requcst, but 5(!tvlCC fl\:lY be c1ccrn,)lIShcd under MY appl1cilble rule of CIvil Procl>dura. "h,' Cilrl11'\to i'lUO! I'\'pilrtrll'nt 1.1111 he prrwich-rl with a copy I)f thus Order by .It tomt'YJ ~t)r plollllllft. Hlln l)rr!p/ ttt\"fl br~ I'rlfofn",-t Ly c'l/1Y 111..... l'nfurcC'f11-'nt <1<Jellcy where d v1nldt Ion u:curl', !JY dn-l'!)t tor Wdl!I'ct '"fllmn,ll cnnt,'u'lt Without w.u"r,\Ill ulJ()f1 pcobc1bll! CrlU!;1! t"hiJt Lhui ()tuur l\c.l:i lM..'Cn vlol;ttcd, ....,lcttlor ur not the Violation 115 catmltted 1" the presence of th~ o()llr~ offlcer, In ttj{l ('vrmt that Lm ..'rre!it 15 IMde under thllS Hcetian, the rh!fendillH 511.111 III)t L,! tak('n tc,; ).J1l but ~;tl.,11 be taken without WV1CCC!j5ttry delay before the court that ..6Ued tho Ordor. When thllt court 16 unavailablc, tho dcCondont shall be arroigned before dlstnct jUt5tlcc who Shl111 50t b,lll acconHng to the proVisions of Chapter 4000 of thf' 1l,"'nr"iylvel1\1.1 Rl.Jlp~) ",. ('~'I'~llnt11 Pnx:l."'dll:" {,J1 P,5. Scct)'()f1 {,ll'). Uy the"' (mlrtl KeVin A. Htl':;:i, J. July 8. 1991, Order for Contmu()ncc, flled. NoD ~"J.oJ. thu 8th d,)y of ,lilly, 1991, upon ~Inq infonrcd that thr:? defendant, c.'oro17 l'. ColI;, L,I:; te~[UCritl.'{j 1 l:Il"L':\'':ltdUCll 111 the.! .rllo.l\'/'-c,lplioncd n\fUt.'r ,md ha has not t"d" ,m (.)Pr"rtLrllty to d1:iC\I:iS tt~ Cunsent ^(lrl.........,!lI~I"t "'"ltl1 counsei, tt\l! hf.'dr-lllg scheduled [at" Jq:,. 1:, 1')'.11 at lOI.i0 ,1.0., 1:1 ("curllOUll ~;, , ,i, :;1\1111 be contl.f1ucJ tl) ruday, July 12. 1991 .H 1130 p.m. 1n Cnurtro1m t'-<<,. .1. nll~ '"~!IIp,)r.,ry Prolcct.1VI' tkder wlll rL'rnlln III L'ffect tUltl1 .1 floal Onter 15 ('nt'~n...l In thl!l c..:1!;'~. ^ copy of thiS "~I' H~" lrr"rnnys for order for ClHlt1rlUilllce .....111 W ~ ~'" I' Lllr~' Iff. :\',. Tt)l" ,"Olll_-t I fo"VII\ ". provided to the Carlisle Pollee Dcpo.utrrunt I k~!;~;. J. JulJ" ~I.), .r.ll. hHll1011 tor ~'o[ltll1 t....ltleas l"ntpl.l~ Ad Cnrpl'; !\II 'j"""itlfIC,lfKiltl1. 1"11.'!. :...0.;1 :;11';, tillS lUttl d,IY II July. t'191. III C,"Il:l1der.1tlLlIJ II Wn t 01 ft.llx'<1:) ColpU!l ~I TI'",t If l(',llldllll It, J ~iBu,'d d1nlct Lng Shl.'rlt(':; l\!pdt'trrcnt brln',l tl:,' defl'lld.llll. (~Ot-ql' 1'. Carr, to (.'o\lrtnx.n No.4, at 1130 p,m. on f'r1d<1Y. July 11, 1991. By The Court I KeVin A. Uess. J. Tt~!5 t 1 t 1(,~1 t Ion. I!nd Wr 1 t of 1l,lne<15 1)( tile ....'lttun 1'l't~tlOn. tholt tb' C\Jrct)l.~rli1r1l1 Cmulty ttlt' l\,"'herldnd COWlty l'lHU' IIl1U!.' .. ,!>-..1.L"'J.. it<- (I~ v I":it'~' A t,l. )11'1.' , 1'.'11 1'1'0 111.1. I I'''' 1"1. III/Ill Tql,lll ,",'i '.,H' " July II, 19'il, Ordar, fllad. NID NaI, thlS 11th day at July. 1991, at tha raquost of cDunsel for tho dDfendMt and wLth tho concurrenco of cO~~6cl for the pl41ntiff, heAring in tho abovQ m4tter _at for July 11. 1991, is contlnuL'<l to Thur.day, July 15. 1991, at 9.30 ~.m. in Courtroan M.JJtxJr 4, o.IIt>erLvld COWlty Courtmu6c, Carh5le, PA. lllQ tuntXlt"nry protectivo ordf!r of JWlQ 26, 1991. to nYMin in fu.ll force 4nd effect, fly 11lc Cou.rtl Kevln A. Ho61S, J. July 2J, llJlJl, Conl'1ent Agrcomnt i\/ld Protectlve Order, filt..>d. AND NOW, th15 231~ day of July, 1991, upon con6Lderation of the Consont A~~nt ot thl! partics, the follOWing Order 15 entered I I. Tha dafandMt. Georgo T, Corr, Is an)oined from phys~colly obu.lng tho plaIntIff. Ndllcy t. Tolall, or fran pLaclng tier in fear of abusc. 2, Thu dofendant, Gcorgo '1', (Mr, us horeby excluded fron the prCJTUS05 located at 141 SOuth Hanover Stroot. /\pI. ), Corlisle, PennsylvNlla. The defend""t iO hereby notified thAt If he cosidas in tho plolntiff's domicile contrary to this Order. he moy be In lndlrect criminal contempt whlCh lS puni_hoble by a fine not to exceed $1000 ond/or by 0 _antanca of up to six months in )oil ond MY other oppropriate punishment. Conoent Df tho plalntlff to the defendant's re_umption Df residence with the plaintiff to the dafendant' _ rcsU1ption of residence wHh the plaintiff sholl not in"ahdate this Order, The defendant shall seck modificatlon (chango I 01 this Order before rcs\l!\ing rc5idence 1n tho pllilntiff's danlclle. 3. The defendant, Gci:lrgc T. Carr. i5 ordc!rcd to stay away fran .!tny residence the plolntlff moy estoblish lor horoDlf In tho futura, The defendant .hall seck modification (change) of thls order before llvlng wlth tht! plaintiff in a dcmicile she IMY establish for hcrself 1n th6 futuro, whcn~ver It rruy be, The defendant is hereby notified that if hc rcsidc6 1n the Plai.ntHf's dc:micile contrary to this Order, he may be in indirect ct"lInlncll CQntl'/lpl: ....tllch Hi plJIll5hilblc by a 1lnc not to l!xCl..'cd 51000 nnd/or by iJ sentence of up to six /mnUm tn J,}il c1Ild MY other ilPf1ropriciltc pllnui~nt. Consent of the plaintiff to the defendant's rCBUTt>tion of residenco with the plaintiff shdll not invl/lidate this ordrJr. 4. The dcfcndolllt. li:xJrge 1'. (fln-, 15 l..'llJolnod Crun l'lltcrll1g the pltlHltlll'S place of <'I11>loyrrcnt, S. The d,.:!Ccndllnt, <JCOrg<> T. Cilrr, is ordorcd not to hilrass the plaintlff or the pldUltlff'5 rl!l,ltl\'l",. 6. Th1~ Otdl!l" ~tldll r('(lutn In ~ll~ct lor I) penod ot one year. 7. The CBrlislc Police ~pa.rtrmnt will be provid~ wHh 8 copy of this Orr.:ler by attorneys for plaintiff and ~y enforce this Order by arrest for indirect ~rllninal contempt without Wdttilnt 1Jr--ln rrotklble call~~ th;tt thi!.i Order has br">cn violated, whC'thcr or not the vtolatlon IS CLJ1l:uttl.,<l in the Pl"(':;''tlc:e of t~ police officer. In the ewnt th.lt an dl.'"rcst lS rr.':lde lllld,)t'" this sectlon, th,~ ddend,mt shall not be taken to Jc1il but fitldll l~ tdXOIl wtthl)ut urull.!cc:;:.>dry delilv tx'iun,! tlll~ Court tt\.Jt 155ued the order. WIlen t.t\.lt Court 15 IJn.W,ll ].1blt', thf' defcnddrlt r,t~,lll h(' arrc:ugncd tx>forc 11 district jllstlce who sht111 fiet MlI .lccordlnq to the prnVllilOflS of Chapter 4000 of the PC':nnsylv~mia Rull's of CruI\inol1 lJn>CL'dur(' f) J PS Sl~ctlon (1l13). By the Court, KuVln A. Hess, J. ~<<.lYCJrtJcJr 12, IlJ'H. Ol.d(~r, t11l~. IN IJ1:l Nl D"n'l, Ltu5 Hh dtly of NOVI..'/:ltJ('l.'", thf.1 l).'fr:!Ildant. Ap~.) 1 n t"~n t 0 f Counse 1. 1<)')1, tile PubJ.l<.: DJfcndcr is appo111tl.>d to represent By 'I'll!! l\lurtl Kl~"'ll\ ,\. Hr..':;:>. J. r/.lVl'11Lo.!r 12, 11)'H, Orxl,.!r, flled. IN 1\1::: Il,'.Ji-long Olltc l. B.llI &~r., N'-iU NCW, thu\ 4th day of tt>Vl''fT'bJf", 1991, ,J( 11135 ,l.rn., cl hc.1rLng is 5C!t for ThlllsddY, ,'.tNc",t~r 7th, I'J'll. ilt 1);00 a,m. rl~l1du\[J s,un..~, ooil 15 !"H tn the drl'Cunt of 5500.00. By The Court I Kev1.n A. UC5S, J. l' I (.I")(~/~ , / .,,,.,.,, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY. CRIMINAL. DIV, COIla~ONWf AL' U .0 Qllor,.. Terr,}n.;., eM r ._~_~. CAI~I~!_~-~-1-"--- ~_" CH,,~a\r....aUd "..aull r ~ --"'.~Tl'l)rlo'IIoC; Tnr./lt....-"'.--r---- A"IANt Ttlf.func:LI D_2nn!.!lx.....P.!'- c.rm!!-_ .'ADICT ~9YdY"X i"A", ".." J, "orn' O"fNaE DATI llillJ.l.._______. ,AIL J.l1 1l/4/9l ...~,Ia.ooo, orN. IOOl4H~4 "LID Corua ~STAICT JUsnCE CONSTABLE lB'o"" ,1 -'..(--- --.- COMIlaITMENT MOTION 'OR NEW TRIAL -. \. DIStRIC' A"ORNEY _--~~J_9t~ SHERI" COSTS !SHEAIFF " I'. '.10 I CEAT TO STATE ------'.. ";' : T.--."'--'-- ;;~";A~_.__.. ~ I: ]r:~:~~,--- :;:CII w,AAANT . ,1- l,.. t .J!".k__.'..:!..!.:.' 2 __u___ w. -t C:!S,__._,..~._!.~____. \ -,_v.. ~_,-__..~~-'L,__. o.v. , 00 10. 00 1!l..: 00 l!l-,.J!!L 10. 00 _!~KI~~~"I_L_~_~.~_VO,t<_~ -! _ !.!!:1!'lOPA!~~ETC____.~(}JI~o_1 _ ~(l:~Ef~A~_________ ~"~ -f NDLll 'ADO, '-H I ~N~U~~~______. ~ ~~~NIZANC:JES..I.1-- - ...-- rORf(IIURE Of RlCOONIZANCU - , C05 T P.AID: A,B .' J"ti; . W .'{t;r'l- IllJb ~t' t;l~rOY' f j)tll Ie l (I.. UbfHt K. ~QY. 15 ------,--......_- ,_.,,,____.,,,.. .-_c .............--...,...'--,.,-.'" 'lI.EO,1 DECEMUt:R l,). 1991 HOT tON FOR REDUCT lOti OF D'\ ll. fa.tol on:,.~\t'!1 I. l'I'Jl ORot:~ ur (OUNT "NO NI),\', tln~ l)r<l d"y of Dl!cember, 19'Ji. upon CoJnlHdur"tlon of tht.' ~l.thHI mtlll'j;ll1"J ,III l~IH\ of T~,n,}ltlY !., ll,lwgulI, (';11'1 \t \!t '"",,,by .n.lltrul.l ,II'" JII'Je",'d ",It .1 h"'tll~I\'J ~'llch,'l_Jlutl for r....".\,I). 0'" H'It .t,,)' I)f DI}'~"l'lI."q'. l'I'1l ,It lOd~ (,'cLock ...,n. In Court ron."n t-;.l. ). (urnberlan,1 (O)\i"ty (ou~t H<llJ'e. (,Il..l~lil., P"IHI.ylval'll.... Oy tho Cuurt, F.dgar n. lhyley. J. : r.l\IL (I.,r", [.:: ,l~l ,! ~~l'-l,r.' ~." "Ill,; w'!INflnl.1 hl!lf> 11I\1" ..pi r.1Y I' "r', ~".I' ~,'~I nl ."1111:"11I1 .,~ '''"lltl~Il', I'f. 'J, A. nl) r ~ D " \.-2L-._--,d,~' "'- U9 .' , II \~t~.'\.."l.)l,.JJjlil-'- 1. \ l .. ,- . -)1"1'1. j\'''fl\. 1,1,. ,',1-0"\"11,'" CO!)) "..' I ~ copy lJ-J J.H . ,Ii. .12 ~ ,10 III 4 I ') ~., 1991 . 0~176 _C^,IH GI';Ollm; 'l'~;IlIlANCE 12/\)2/94 orlll~;H, Fll,lm, 12-2-94 APPLICAN'l' IS IlEREBY GRANTED LEAVE TO APPEAL IN ~'oHMS PAUPElllS, PATRICIA ANN SMITII, DEPU'ry CLERK OF COURT. C.Hill I'rlllt ----..------------------------------------------------------------- 12/02/94 NOTICE OF APPEAL NUNC PRO TUNC '1'0 SUPEIUOII COURT, FILED. DOCKE'!' ENTRIES, ATTACHED, ------------------------------------------------------------------. 12/02/94 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE, FILED. -----------------------~------------------------------------------- 1/19/95 AUTIIORITY TO PAY COURT APPOINTED COUNSEL, FIL'm. MICHAEL A SCHERER, ESQ. (O'BRIEN, BARIC (, SCHERER) $480.00. ------------------------------------------------------------------- 1/31/95 PETITION FOR EXTRAORDINARY RELIEF, FILED ------------------------------------------------------------------- 4/17/95 MOTION FOR MODIFICATION OF SENTENCE, NUNC PRO TUNC, FILED, MOTION TO MODIFY SENTENCE, FILED BY DEFT 4-17-95 TilE MOTION IS REFUSED, GEORGE E. HOFFER, J. ---------------------------..--------------------------------------- 4/25/95 CASE MAILED TO SUPERIOR COURT ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9/19/95 MOTION FOR POST CONVICTION COLLATERAL RELIEF, FILED BY DEFENDANT. ----.--------------------------------------------------------------- 9/21/95 MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF POST CONVICTION MOTION, FILED BY DEFT ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9/26/95 PETITION FOR APPELLATE BAIL, FILED BY DEFT ------------------------------------------------------------------- 10/05/95 CASE RETURNED FROM SUPERIOR COURT -----------------------------------------------------------..------- 10/05/95 JUDGMENT FROM SUPEIHOH COURT, FILED, 8/25/95. IT IS ADJUDGED TIlA'I' TilE COUIl'l' OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY BE AND THE SAME IS HEREBY AFFI RMED. BY THE COURT, DAVID SZEWCZAK, PROTIIONOTARY. 10/05/95 MEMOIlANDUt.! SUPERIOII COUln', FILED. 8/25/95. BEFOIU;: MCEWEN, '1'AMILLA, AND OLSZEWSKI, JJ. ----------------------------------..-------------------------------- 5/22/96 ORDl';R or (,OUR'!', f'lLUl :,/17/96. IN HI';: PCllA, TilE NOTION IS Hf;'1'UHNEll FOR M1ENDfII-:tfl' AS OlJT!. [tH':1l IN ORllFH, TO BE RETURNED ON OR BEFOIlE 8/1/96. ORDERED BY KEVIN A IIESS, J, 9/18/96 MonON FOil LEAVE TO APPf:Al. NUNC PliO TUNC IN FOR~lA PAUPERIS,FII,~;D. BY DEF, 9/10/96 ORDLlI 01.' ('OlJJ(T, I'lLUJ 9/10/96, TilE NOTION rOJ( LEAVE '1'0 FlLL ,\N APPEA!. NUNr PliO 1'llNr TN FORMA PA!fPERIS IS DENTED, ORDERED nv KEV I N A Ill':~;~;, .J, 11/04/96 MOTION l'Oll POST CONV[l:T10N COLLA'I'EIlAI. lIEI,lEF, FILED BY D[.;n:NIJI\N'I'. 6/04/97 MOTION FOR APPOINTMENT OF COUNSEL, FILED. 6/04/97 MO'l'ION FOil LEAVE '1'0 PROCEED IN FOHMA PAUP~;RIS, FILED. fi/04/97 MOTION FOI( EXPEDITIN(; [H-:crSION, FILm, - -. - -.... - - -- - - - . - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. . - - - .. - - - - - - - - - - - - ., - - - - - - - . 7/ 14/97 OPINION ANn OHnER. FILED, 7/i4/97. IN RF.: DF.FENDANT'S MO'l'ION UNlJEIl POS'l"CONVICTION HF.LIEF ACT. PE'I'I,!'IONER' S MOTION IS DENIED, TilE . , , .Ja]2~J00141991 1991 - 02176 CA/llt (JI-;O/lG~; 'l'E/lltANC~; , . C.l110 Print . RIGIIT OF APPEAL EXISTS. ANY APPEAL MUST BE TAKEN WITIIIN TilE ORDER. ORDERED GEORGE E HOFFER, J, - .. - - - - - - - .. - - - - LAST ENTRY - - - - - - - - 30 DAYS OF ----- .......................... COSTS' FINES INFORMATION ......................... Case Type,. I CRIMINAL Case Actionl COMPLAINT Last Description Costs/Fines Pd To Date Amount Due In Escrow Pymt ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- Cost/Fines Total .00 .00 .00 .00 0/00/0000 Cash Bonds Total .00 ,00 ,00 .00 End of Listing ~,-:. '. MAY 1 8 1998tb rl .. ....,-; r,t t'1\:",.r ,",#' 6,:",n./ /'~IJ , /) , /.,.' / . ... ~ '~",i..,;::..,/ c..::",.,r/.. ./.,r"uo/4..u..... ,") .("'...11::.....)' ~ ') r6,..... ~,""..,/~. ' ~ #<J, ~''1'. .>U.)'I' ('"1...,/' 7."...,.." y, -r:.,~,~ , )' // ,(-%.o.J>n d/i",~"r &~....,r ~',,, -~"",.J~r""'" 4....,r,fi":" ~,(,"'","'';/ ~f!:..GL'.U_~a..,../ d.....d...r /. /:?<-::!"~""/ /;/;.>,rU,.,v , '-' ~,,'" .../OJ~ ",/ .- ~>v /-U'."r,o ~cr,J'- ,;r: a:<, /:~/',.. d~,.d;"r . '/ -::J ..1 . ? .;J/ .'fotL, rIC.A- ~~rr~,'k;,1........,'~/,.,.,L ~~..-r "'>"""/~/- ;;r::',#~1~'/, c-/~...~, ".-' /-?.I/.. p,h,,,~/, ,4/"r.;'>>"~ .rhr C'/"N,,~,r ./.-,,?/ no ~r"P".f ~~,;",/ ~,,{...dr'//;;" ,,'J',1 ~_ C'-?c-,on",/II/ /.j......,..r.~",:',1.> /N'V~/";'#,1 ~k.,.~..,:) ..,.~ Pj:JI'"'(.",,,rr'c./ H.~,Jtl.,...,~'-. fA,.) tC~"r/;,{",r ~~,,-, /""A,a,'~;::';''''~/'h.'rYf /L :) ;' :J /'/ C-:"'YY'",..",..,~p/,/.L ~~.-r'r ,rt/ ,,-~ CJ.."r1,rlt.'~J ~,:...::. ~ ~.:....,.,r/- a...,. e-/ cent., ,/.,,/ c:: H rr' e'lK__r "</",,,,,...,,., L" ~ ~e,"/.)/C'"",r /.?!"i,/,-/,' h~'/ "'n' ",-v{,/"",...,'/ ..,;1, /,j7 A/ ~)>h ~,,~r /?c7,..r-r/"~ a,i-..:;,,~r e..~.,,:oe,,.;,:Jr ;J'/,,{.>"'I) rhr c~~'J~d,r ?4.J"..,) I n /."....#,.,....J,.,,',."'~. /-<<n~r'/)t. /,1/ e: .po,;"'~"~0 """"v~'~,,#,/""'" hl',rl u6.....,~- c..t'~""', 'A;"""'I"'~/~"" ,o('r/';ffJ.J ',-./ /J c.-p' .,(/~,nL...." ~ if ,,>-> /' ~"':,;;:,,~u- ~/f. /---:. "k.l"'w..y"- C6./.-..1?h"~ ..v ./,.,,( ,,~- /-1(, or,.r/'j ~),r> //,{."r ~ , .rd ~J,..A"">~' /-f(",r,/~' ~:/.-/ ./1"'~"";'.I4'7 ,"6J.,..~T~d~ c,',v ~'y ,-:"k~"r. '//"-,,_,rJI-,,., ~ /~'7, ~ ~n/ ,/,..'/;:n~~"r "';~c//,.,b .L"-~"-t,,,.,,,,,,,,,,,,., .I"L- J;J(.Nl/7r/.:J fi-~/'#.",C"y./ ~'6'/"t."'c/>.::J c,',J./ /.J~r~'rlA". d~ /}',../" U~//'''r,{,,1r .r:~~// c.: O,.I....~. //",7 _.:L......-'........c/-.~-~ '1 r~ l /' ".~~,,..,.~"",./ ~. '..,I,.tI'''~:rl~ h-t.. .4IN/ ,r-!,.. ~f.o,...,;' - rn' ~'~/"'.""','r' ,.-1" L).../;" J~~" .J ....1 .,A,;,Iv".y' .Y';, ~'H,y , rL ~4".r""r / ;? ,4- /...."".~~H';~. CM(-'h""~ c...M,-,..,tIG":' ;r/f.;1'J.n~r"~ .}'t: .r L;' .:ii, "r;;,.,.,~/ //....J"-l~../ /~",r,//-' ~,. .,v"""j.n'~/ en' vG#,. ..,It. ~'ff" ",.:" ;<IN' ",,//r!~,/'..4,)',...""n-c:/ A~,,;r ;'H.-~~';:'"r /h",,. t:A..;",) /c:./J..,.r~~/ 7ZJ ~~"".:r....'r;..,>~ ~'6-;-r-.A. C...t""I1,"A', ,,6y >>""r ? n',,{.';/, " ",/.r,.,c "",.. -",,,,.,..r; ~/""/</ c!". ft-,4.,,, .....6n..,,,,'../. a /..:?,.,.,., r~,'''' ...-;.".0 /lb./......., .........,,?,-, ';<~,rl,,,,,,,~,c" ("v .r.A) Co''' ,-",-,.,.., ,.7';, /if/ r./-.r (.0...0". p /.//.......,,.- /t:::."Lff',r ,,~~ .r..t:- ..#h?.Ji"'/'-"">7'''<'J,-'",-,/ .-I~r /,.,;,,-'--r. ~ e,., ...A.,(; ,;J "ff/ -J 2. ' /. -;J /~~~7'''''/~~ ~....Jt..) .../-".,,G,.~r. A,Ae',4 /;'~~""''''''-'''/jIJ'';/ ? /.........~.' ..J,r, ,6,./..;"., rL.. '/'/'jr,,,r ..L..r/L-A- r... r.L.... -<I//-.".../'.4,f"."v..vo-,/ .#'''~~r /,./,,-,.c'h;,., ,J 4,.c:,.~,.,; ,. r "",0/ ../-?.../~ pl ,4,.,...,. / /",{",,r,;7.J c'l"',H_ / 7;;;//'" "'>0....,,,,,,,./,,,/ r'/"r /.kq<.y ..: ..I~.....r,...c" ,....vf!.. ~LJ"...'r-,J, ~,-'Cf"";,),'.r'. pJ ,d"J-"-.Jj C""..,. J/,.,.{,../' c;,</ V",,,,,... ./l:./tllh" .;6,-.) ;;;,u"'r~ ", h'/~ 4,..t.."",.".... .r ~ A'fi;'/V,r C.r1 ..,("fJ -', = """'/" ""-''''.. ,ff" ,a,'1C/ ~~ ~,:,.) G.~u /4"~..."r ,.r r~ A,.~'n"~:JG'';/ /..r~.,/,~ en ~/~. J /If/ ;il.,,(,~Jr,/.7".J c:!....... / .T<--yA'..c,/j ,.4"./{........'" /~'-'-..,.."',/ /L d..v-A></" ~Jl'n~....A~ /:?_A.. / 6:"".../ :';"""'0 ~".lc.....1t./.r~ //j.(",r;/~~ ,,(n...r rc; rL a~7A-,~~'~/ ~~~'r/ /;?,.).",rl /:-,.c ./:.r/L.,,, ",..:i,,-,.....-....c~,.,.~ ~"" / 'J TL.L. '/},'..J,r,-,ur J...,.u-,~.4- /~.4. ~..-f_.......r. ........./ c..,.'/";',.,/' /L ?C;J') / ~.........,..../I' /~-/.J{"'~ e" rLA- "Q>>"'.II~.r,~&:/... ..N~,,:.N.r. /./ c'~"..".;/ ?""',......../ 7;;1~~ ././ AI,.'<~. // ,- ,,'~.. ,/ /./ / ./ / p/";,,,.n/;JII- J'''~~A- ;C, .r"""" /",...A--"/""A," ,; .-.... /L ".,/'... "'/./ / /;1-....,'r,/1'- t:..-Jt-'J .--(...,./,.."'...~.../ .;.:,./ e~?'l.:-iJ..~.. ,/'..J" /f.,/, c:,,;, ~ .:,,,,,/......,,:.,,//' .;;( 1 r';" ~""';"''''''''.I'':~ ,i. ::'AAI~' oN ~';,'J.,,,.; (".,.,1 .' ", "....r;! I /,r..'".'; ...'/,u;/; """',../ ./.2-.64-.. .......". ....k.. " t..-,IC'h"'",/ ;rL ,r~ /k/,.';~..~~-:J.r ~ "':;;,,,t,J..M-, ,..;:,;. ri.~/ /..:::."~ ~''-ooI. "".k'~.~ ,-~.I r"<:...,.,~/ 4,.<1, ;;'",{..I,It.//,?",;,r";:) ~4..J, J',,~,,~:,,-,~ t!f,...I;1 ~ A /;N,..r~ --A';~.,,.~,.,r- rc ,/~~.L/'/'// ~ r?'~" 7,6,::. .7?...rh"......?-". .....,~" J:-~ /1".,,- ..;,,>";r;.,.,...;- A".'/~M.;~~ ~../ /.10'7' ,.,.""~_ ~"')';"-h.6t... r/'A:..;~ ~ /Hr:::.:.~., .r~J ;;-:....JT""'-'Y, /;~~,'/r,,/;" ':.,) ~*,~/.L /hJ.I.""""~1.J...,.,r. ,(-.~A"""'" /G /:z......)......~.~ 70 7.~i ~~.:.=:__~.r..-f4.!I..z;: /"v".(;,..,..... ~ rn",,t.:....-~.:'O..-:--x6L ",-/)lc.,r,Jo, 7'-" ,~'C~-,...c._ ;;r;;-..,.,-,nc:,,)'/ ;J _ 2J,,;e-;''''''''''''''''- ,/ .r.,' k........rMJ"t/~.., ,..,.- ,A/, ~;, ~.....,...,.................a~,......) a'Jr,,~ /L )/ ' . / ..... . ...., ",/;-/7 ~"'j .,:,p".-,.v;,../ ~ h'v..Jr .-:;:/ ,r' ,.."\~?,-:,--.1""",.I rt.../..../~ ..J~.'/~-.r,~"-'/' /;~.:J,,~ ,) Lly t!- '-'-'7 ~./ ft.-/L .A.r.'J....-.-~ 21/ L)~h; ,..-:::~ :.> ,A/; ,..,.h,.)l..,...".- ""'rr''';-1~ -A ~,'7- .......,/-;:;~oJ.r.,..>,,:r/''? /Jnc/ --A';~.'~'~~",JI~ .,.,4. r,/;J;:;~',1n.;;r'~ ,,44-~ ~ ,,;~,.-u~~, ~"';:'.r~~J."-'j ""~";~"'~ Jh fl~"" /}.{.;?:....'A.,JI-';> / . ..) / J./ '/ rk", 77".Jr,n';-A.y ...:2,c,/ /,..,...,A.~,,-,- /.<:, /~".;.r,.,~ ~/ /"'- .#.6.J~#~ ,.- /' /L."... 7?- -"',,,-L-Jy' " , tUL /' /A:::.... t:....~:J A ~;>I::.'-'" /L.. >fc/:..~Ct1- /hr /. r /' .7/ -- .;) /' /.-, / .,_ / . / p~ r/f:.. _//....!".''.I''~// J t'..'--.o.... :; .......-/1/~~ .J"(., ,...-."." /~"'-4... (,............r~.....:. ;I'J~ "";"./- t~, ;rr",,;>,',. /L, ~:,J,,/.r ,;/ /4 #/"'/ t~,~/u/A........, ,,{...,. J ):),;n;:.,~'/T ~:!,-;!!-'.!~~':::._<-.,:-,~J..!.:.!'.J'!.-J., o;-c.;c: .....,~ //r Gl--Y ,..oV....) .-7-- A r '~~;4,' _ .7La) /.};",,;/....../;c" ,.I,,,.') ..~'/J//,.-,/ /~' ":;;fPCC,~,. c"~"""?"'.J..;~~.~...- ~~~ /4 ~).TN~,..';..r.4'// /":".;'Jr: \""'. ~ .-;:? , . C '~',J-.I':':""Y<lc:..".1' H; I"/'/ t"/ r4-<L. ....JIi~...1iI! , /,' .V~,,,,.&./ .,l.",:.,.x..o)..}, /'-II~;"'''''~'''''''/ ",;1".,).....,..,.?.:. /1"J~".r,l.'/ ,r,/.,..... /ii<r~ p~",;"t.'~,J; ~ ~/t,,,.''-J,II'f/!',. c.,' -'-' ..,..,.:....... rd ~ 1"4 ,/';..",/ ~ r w...'-I"/ 4....,. ~\.... "-?''>'' .r /. ...}{;,I,/'d/ /,i,.,.., r) /' _/' ('~,/";; ""h/ )/",,.",,,''.> /"~ &-/,c.~.;.", .;;,.'rlr ./.&;, ,.r;/./"..) /,/ ,or /../ 4 "../,~,,,.'../.r ~"':')/.) /I~"'.r rn,'.J c:::.....~r. I-v,// ~..,.;-),.;{,,,-,~,. ,.'" .../ r:h.),.,u~.:.t ....a,~;nd,'.r ~ ~~I"'I,",I"''''''' ,,',,~" ,,4. .r#h,"".Jr ~/ ..-L...n,.r.....: ..D"'r..~ ~/ , /"/I'L , ,~n", , \...;,) ~~..r~/p ....::v.dm4?~? /F) /.~ ",1' _::;) 4-~~ k-~ fi' ?J j ~.J'~ ,/'" Ca,.;, /;..;, ~ ' " ,.G/,y _",:k'..,,~ c~"?O~.>A,~ ....-J~o'H,...L;~/. . /Z".y-~~/t:..' . /?r~. \...' " II I ,\ GEORGE T. CARR, PETITIONER IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. TIMOTHY CLAWGES, ESe., RESPONDENT 94-5051 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COUIiT AND NOW, this 1st day of May, 1998, IT IS ORDERED that petitioner file a brief In this chambers not later than forty.five days from this date In response to the brief filed by respondent In support of respondent's preliminary objections to petitioner'S complaint. The preliminary objections will then be resolved without oral argument. George T. Carr, Pro se 1 Kelly Drive Coal Township Shamokln, PA 17866-1021 Petitioner -, C ' jI'~.LJ.... ~/ l/q8 . - ~ .~,'f, Scott Moore, Esquire For Respondent :saa " , ~" ,U 1.-, Zi "... l..:: ~ .' " \':' - '7 (' .; '.' 't~.., ',1 ; t. l. ~ ' ... ,. ,~ n \'->' ,,' '.\.~~, t .\, ' "', ((~ ," '0, " -) ~I"T t~l .~ ?, \ ~ \. l' Cl' () , , ~/t:- T L~'~' - .,,, ".,L, ci'.....",.. <:-,-" ~~.....,... ~. <JF ~......r,,,;." 1 .;? ..~,..,,A.,,,~,A';~C/ L,,;/, ./-n'''7~.''''i.'''' (,./, . ~.. *V" ,)our'- .. C,...../ 7;:>",1'_ ;:-:;-_c-r/y- A c?A....,,.-,, <,'r.,N, _ ~"/" .....-:K:,...,.....' p..""""'~/ ~~::,,~:.r.r ~ 2/ .. L? /r""h~"'''/''''7' ~ C.l'7"r'2...lt. AI""'/ ..</"'''''-', ~c-.-."J ./;1::';"",r"./.?' ~:,.~~ T a....., ~ ~..~..ocr/Z"'~ ./::J....."..,.r~ .T~ /C',-A......,''? /, /~....n/7, 4.../", ;r &.-V, 4...,;, A..""..n-,/ AN./' d...,.. , rr.../ ~ TL d....~/k,.,/ ~~,./ /-:t,.J.'.... Cv'/ ......G.-...... oYt!. ...H/ c../ "",v .4-'/..,.,./' AjT"",,,,,,,,,,iI,..../ A.:J...JG~r ",;,.../C',,~r 7"/",,, ~....."'..) .L,;#C".....J"Y/ ?'t'; ~~~ .-I?. ,b..#7" ~ e:.....r,.,4.."c' ..6/ ...v"'h/t'/ ~ T~.-/ 0'7. /~_T,,,;r ~C"j' T B;,.,...., (.....X::~ ~.,k',,</ hN' ".(0 ;;?,...::.....,.....:/ ~,,/ E. Lc-..rL", ,0,"- ~x.__ rL ';>>">,/.J,.,.,A-",, .A.0... ~........, c;,/-I ../::-1' J "..lif/ c<,,,. r~ /7/./--,,>"/' ';;;';;;"_h"/"'~,,,, #;'~',1.u/ ""'r- :? &.-../ /#<",,-?..r. ?,.;"t...--,o/r- rL /:?.~''''''''<'7 .""......",,;>. rr ~C... L'.JTHb/'J.L/ T)"r rL "'/./--",./.47:;............."../ ,J,).<:....N'r- r/ ~, --', />y/ ~~ "'-;;/~1' 2,;.;1<'''''''</ A:. .IJ~n-,r,,~ ";-;6..;,-"g. ~....n'.K ~;/ N.......~ 1'. 7C/..../ , I !I I ii i I; I ...3 rL. ~",<."...14 ? AJ/ /..;e:"J"". ,.,~'A ,,/:..~..-/ ", '/H~ J ,r',F .r4 6'~r c';'" r;~-",...:..".) ,..~~ ./ ~,I&.J"'c/ Cr./--.K' ell J...-r .."I.J ,/~)i,/ 7Z;. .-v...."y '" ~~,/ "",,_.,? ~m rL., h/~ Lp,," c/ ",,/ ,/J//..~.,./' .#:i->n...".,..'/ -#J",~r ,,.;C-'~,,. .r.tr ~u.> .,!'",...(/,-,L,/'c;.</ J..// ..) ,.~~,/ v. T,<~ /;?.".'c nc.../ Cn/--"r' or'" -A-.-f' 0:>':> /H'/ ...:x.-.??~~.>...c/ .6:/ ~/;:,u.4.,,,r k '.L......,.._lI- ~..-/ A........... L,~ ",,,'J",, ~"'_' ,L //-...; ,"" c, ;r;./.......- .A::!:/Jc'A'T.> Fe.." ~~:..,-, c~)/i~"".,.."....,,,,r' ...,"/~,..,.",..~ d,-JL.__"."r I"CJ - --- ,--- ;n:. ,. ,./ 2 ~,;,. J y'>C:>~' /UN/ /~ /,'...,.....",.":.> ,'/" .rL- ~/........ ....;:........, / / ,,} ,/ ~ttFl€ '" ~......Jjr,'t...,...,/ r.L..-. r.://;;,,~.... ~~~,..I", . Ii' A. .7"'..... ,~,J"/. ,:.." r.L ~ .1/< $ -,/}-//, , .rL 4~,.,.L "I" .r"ul/c'.",.,,,,r,cr1 ~ .1,1,,,- ''''H.'-- n:> />-' ~, ~.) ........::A..";1_",,r ~L,'r ~.. A4'/'/ ,/,t.,. / /'~- -^-.,IJp.r-.:a..>.rCn ~/ ~....." c'/"",-,- ,. ~ ~'-':':I'p~",. ~-,.G..., c.""';'.~ .i......."r '. '~..t" A'~&'.k...,,:..>~ G',.".".)~..e."'/ ~~ck_ 6/ ,,; C-;/C:-~""''Y",...,r ,,'/,"). Olll/.J, ".,~..,., ttA.../~ I' I c:./";~ ,../ H<r rk- Ar/,,,,,r. ~: ~,.). U Dt.4(._.~/ ----,. C'/ti /~t;cY); /2.....-"-,.'rlr;c, rL-- ""Jhr.'~" (";,.,./ /;; 11I..; c,....~~ ~A,.........,.c/ ,h~.;.",-*, ~" ~'-'....-J."..J'''''~J'''/ ~,.,.".......,,~ >-;>, /'" ,.,./ ;~" ?"V' ~.....,(. ,L ~'n', ""c;;/ €' ~~"""""J""''- e'/~/~~,,/~ ~~It'k~... r'"..u/.>.~,c..-; c4}- / ' /,. . /.::/~, "". ->. --. -', ~ . -",__'Jr,,~,.. ~.......---...' _ , _ _ 'n', ./..-"No/, .TA..r ,4:,.,/ ;rc., ,L /.A-''o...J~'~ C'/" ~L /~r. ,,~. ';C-../ c.,-ut",., .>: 2/ /~'A./r,/,/ ,/1,/"". -,/ .L.J....~;.."A"'.r.. /,1." . / /~r-~'" "''-'" ~ -A~..,.v'~'''''''''''''''') .? ' ,',//c /;/',/,) ,A""., ./",..I......'rJ ~~.~.r,.,},...".,...'Jnc...,/ ,...)~.,."-<o...J,,,N) /,t;,,- ,,,.::-.:.~.n,,,',.,,,r ~ "r;; /.........., ,/ ~.."'A'.r-. rr... ,., 7':'-" /6.,..."./, ,/J/o./.:/ .r "i.,,- rL ~'n-..n<~ c,atf,~ "".K/~"'~ k....~, /~ ""r;~~ ,"'''''''''''''' (;//;"""/.J v,i1/L.,"-/Z./ .;./",..~../.;,.. ,n;.",/ T~.r- 7L / ?.r"'.T;~.,/ ~__ ..~/t ,/,., ...,,,, j...d ~,/ ~..., ...'-'-'- ,r .n#<'....),,~ v..~......, rL_ ') ./ ;"'.J-,., "7"'/ ,r ~/A.'. ".J /.;..../.1, ,.fl") rt. ... T/r...Jc-"h /: ~ ., rL.. ./u,.~,,,;/ ~'':;':-'-..) ..z-"'............'/"".""d It'" rL..... ./,/,q.. .cr' "i.:J"r.:"~,,.,r /d.~"~c/.......,. .....4-tuN.... .., fi..,.. 0" rL. /d........ -,., .....d,_/'",y ......,;.<...'"r~ ;;;2.~,..ut~,- ~':-/ic./ A~--....; ",j,Ft.""",~c./ ~~,u-....",- fi",~ ,n~../ ~~""..".,~ ...s"p~,1''''''~ ~-U"...r,r/.) Ck,,,,.) ~UJ..r" .d.4,..4;"r- ~/'./ .7<J &...Lr A.v "";? ",..-c /..z' a".;;,~:..r /;"'''~.J.r~)''''r/c;.,./ t::.,I#' rL "';:'11''') c;/ ,.)-?/~..^"/",,,..j/'';.) c:i...... "..1.,.,/ r,,(.-..... (J) d.........,.Hh? /'4 /2-"".....,,,,/ .,,.'~........ ~-;'~'~'r..l ~ ~ -....,. f ./ ~/ ..''// _ "".. , &;,7~~"'rl"",,.,,,. t;;I'~"",.-,-.;", ""'.-...; -.....:;G-. ........h. ,,_, ,,/,.. J 7':'''''/'- eN ,...,-,u~ ~~/L,.. "",.y(;".~/ ..#;/ "-~""/:I//; "r,L.,- ./'Pf',_r#,,;ro# .,;2".,,r/-6/ ,.,,-,"":6, ,("_",~....J 4'-'~ ~.-~~~./ ~e.-""""'~0e-- .n- c,.; ....-:;;".6:..",,/1/ -r-NNCI"'....~ r,...:- _.ah".p~,,- '.rAJ'~.r;>.-~ """",e/ ...c-~"",_~/~,--/ /?.....n-C",./~ ...r:/f-,.,.,,-,,,I. ~yn'~, p~'c~,r ~4-'<'-// .....{~ ~t:'tr:'c...-,_/- .T"'.r- .....-,..7~...-,.........-- ....-r~~..-orr-.J. ~:r"""'~ A..". -,~L ,dfi~"'N"'" c::"" ..A:..."", o/t:, ,,~,...... /L./'---'-7 rL ".#-';/.."'~.//' ~'>'''-'''''''~/ ~..>.><~"r- -'.H.h,?"r ........, h4/ << ~..v./ C 7C~" "",-,</ ~~/'/~ c:h..)t..,"~".r/ ,7..6"~ ,AI/X".J".,.,.,.- '.v....;rr. .r,~ /~ .J-A"-~. t:-.;c_~. t:-.r;.:) /~~~.....- "Ir rL /-::"'/-"""""'''7 //;""..<n'~ c:,,, -.A-.{/ J /,>-/. ~L., "r ~C-J E oJ 7'1> 6/. -' L ,/ //".r' .TL .......//~ .>,. ,/ 4)' j:,.--..rl,rr/ ......,:",c.....-r- ~~...d:.,r- c-r' .....4...... ...?' /"/, ~".# h/...-... ..c;'ft........-, ~~"L ~c.> p?'-.)_..,~./ r<--' ~ -:;;;; , .fu",,,/ ..4.1/€/ ,,/ /;;~/;;",.~;".r- /,A/(..I".~r"/.4n- / .,h,~€/ ...z,-....,J'.>"""',,...,.......,/. ...u /"uif c.....u:'_.,/,..~ /~'.../ ~n', /;-/,~:;:,~;r- ~.c-;fo~C/ ~~, ft.~~t:""-~_.L! TA....- /2'p~;/' t'~C'_~"':J cc_/ ...r;,,,... .? j /"...i,.j.....J~~~/ /.Jn~'-/.....0tC- 7,,{;'--- 7/, ./'7. .~ or...-/' .-.....,c-, ,L "'.? ?....,.,.../&,.:..._/;::/-:;Y' ~....n.....#"./ c:;? " .? ......-;;/______ A::..~ ~~ /' /' A.h../ TA';"r- ":/ /...../':'<~r'...-,,/r 1A-Jt;; .,) .... """'''''./';';;~'''r1r ,-,' / / ~..- /""-4- ~>~''''''.A''''''''_ "'~L_/.r- ~{..,...;D/~,.,n..r' ~-:...e:' ,~~'-' ..,.,c. / >:Y/ ,--.;J'/.> a ,,/ i,kA,....-.,;;.'r ~, / . / ',;o/l.,J"",rl..;.""-"./ A..../ r,;",n'",~""",,~,_~ /,..rl4y ..GJ... <<. ,r .LJ",~,#..~,r ~,-,.:.._-,'J ,,4,~ ~hJt'J"'-"""""'./ .J")"...~ /,;,..L/ .V.I;~' ..b,r"'''f...I.);tIr ,A../".;w"y ~, 71............, ~ /'/__ /~.J,..ri/;)',,) -~""'''..4'h__ ".,,- ..),.JQ ""'1."'1/ ~...~rtJ~ ",,,../ .r~r- "",..U..,o.r,,/-;-~ ""~J.~:) .A.rit,~ ~;r..'--...,../ C',.c:' CJ,J /~ '~.J"''',,{''''.IL.~_ /JI"".,:,r".~ rr "v~.l-It.V r!' ".17../.............) y'-"";)""Y, t:-,,,t,,, .r.L:- ".4//....>..../ /~...n..,.,I.~, c;"../.....< ("JI"/'-'''~:'~'' Aer.'f..IY"~"1': c~ .L "'~'-..~ .T#,.> a~-,.. ~... "i."./ ",1...,..." ') J /J /",.,.,"1I.;......-'1rl,.,1'-- t:rl K........,~ / ...,.rc~~v?.J ~,..,."".'~L..... "'",/v",oJr,,,,>..,rrc-/ ." r.L._ ,~., ,., </ /-.1- .4~~ _ ""../ "'-.u' ......~,,,..-"". "' (""--1_" .~/ ".{~:) AI-- ~~,-y . 7?- /1 / /"',,"J"".J_'>,,~ .;11",/ ~"""'N"").j""~ t~,CJ A....../......../;y' ~...~.-.. /~...../.-~"- /..l..u.-......"..'Y rL ...I;;J,k,.,cA,~r..) ;;~..."r C;"" .J"""',U_I'~rl'-c.... ~: ".c ~.......,__ rl___._ u, A''-n-1~,~r;u.-r , x;'o /~./ ,.".}7 ,. Ie 1';""-' ...,~ ~JG) .TL ,4:),.";,, ~.,.r- /://,.,/ --'Z> ..... A-'~"'.r~) tM"""'" .r.L. -"",,~ ..., rL /;;1__.. ,.,..,/ /::,/-./ TO /N,",",jr,>~,-e... c.:// ~r-~ _/'J(O,.rI//~ ~ ~ .rn"~,~~~ tA-J/~ AJ.).~(,,/4u.....J/,,0c.... ./,) L t-t,...."I'7,,;,? rL /!,(,,,.,',,r/....) ,',,'/,./G.~...,'1c..-L. A../j rA..r; -;:.; ~,-,.,~./'~ ..hc.;;uc-#'7 ""'t', ..:&:"A,I' /J,..",.,c;,v.T').lc:.......;,- rh...... ~.",...,- I ..Je:, ""#r..-~?""'~ ""',H/ ~,..J____ .T~.) .c:"'...., -k ""-"- ctd,.,rl&-'- ~ J.... J.r",//., c/. "'.)", .~r"..",,,""r'>/' .d,,-,/.),C/J. T#,,- .P'~'''..I...G'''' 'n:- "';./.TJi-",,,-,,',r~ ... ./"1' 7"-"r,,,/ ~. rJ-/~~~ ".) nr r ;II .../- OJ<--", /C:~,....,/......, //>",../ ...jT;"r...",y"'" ~.rL,-',r "J ,III> ~ht"'.JJc""" .Lh,....,,/..,7't; .J~kCJ...,/"1:. ?..........;'\"',.....~ ~,.; 7';t'M/' ~ C:';"{",,.,~,,, (.J ,i,.,,,,,,,,,,n--,,-,"-,-,> ~7 /..;>/ l,yj-, "....-lr (;;L<:-...:) (-:-,1/ .6~",..)_ ('~,...r~,."...r.('- ,--,,~ ~ ,//.:J,(",- J,-,. /".,i' ".....tf'./"J,y".JJ/(/'f/) .r~__ / ;'.,) ;"?Cj /""tI'J;W".-lC iL- .; /'''''''::''j.J'''~'-~-lc' / . -,1'..:v:::~ "n~,,'- -r,k",.1 u,.......,/ ~ ,k,,,(,.......... n.- ....-'I.J,.~r"..>""~ /:e:.~ ?..... ,.rN"-~")"'.), /,,1,.,.. ~....."-'-'// ':'~A~""~'" / .r',,/ /'6 ",4/r"#,,.,~ ./.J"~-:'I"~'J'-" ,,;,.1/ ,;'/('.r'* /",v"""..J.r"?.>".n:._ /'.L /; ~;,..",L...orl'1')-'Ml~"") ~ rL. /-J,,~-. ~ "'L~ ,-"p/c...,..., r// ,,4..-,,~.) ~.:......'~,. , J"C;; ~c::..~f.""..-P'- /';'rJ c/ ?,,,-,,,,.. e... ./ ,./,...--- . /" t:~: /,,,,'/r/ .r /f. J c:;:;) "c.h ",- ~"./ ,AI rL/,~.) C ,,-__,....,,- --. L// 7k- J./ ./.;. /L'.... ~,,{.,./ ,L /c.......y..., ,/}",{: c', n::. ,c..:..1 ,-".r p //r\.'....;-v- / 'J ~Nu~~n)vtl,?tt:- ,.~.- r~_. ('-"',..C.. .yr,),,t!f,/I'o#J ",- rL /,.; ~ ,+n./ "'AI-''''''''' "',/ ,4'--,.~J y I I , ! , ~"''/''') .no /'1..../')/ I I I '. "",I ~"""'''''II,.-...,r- ~ .7~.'/r ,11~../ fL'k>~ ,,,- ,;~"""" ~ M'r~ t!' /d,,,A<< ...' ..;r,v","\I '''~- /'. ~,/ ,.7~I"', ~.J..J, !.i-"t/ ..,1ft '" S ,,,,j I' I' I J'''..r'''l J",,,,,-,,-, ,II,.,..."...,.,,~ A,'"" A..)~"'~'''''r:.,.1 '7, /'''I../'~ ,- ~.K ~,,..,,..;#"'.. / C:,,J ~.rltl-rl,."l.....h ..}''',t~''fL4 ~/".,~,') rG rL /?,:,~.......-,~, ./t.",r"-.:",, ,,.,J rL. ;:2.';,.6..- ~".- r,CA -' 'V. I, ("""."...:._./ ;>,,1 L,.!'./ J/ C', ~.,,,,,.rl// j c.,/,.,.,rr "'~::>I)),1 <:::,,:r drl,l~"( VJ"(", /~ 1"', (','~'..J) T~ ;.Zfi,,,_,.~ U,...) :;/C, , ,1<)-, ...:> c'r /7&.(',J, c:L,...../ ~'.) ~k/7,; ,,-,.,,... k . ~ _ CkN~ ,,,t,_ r ..~../ ~,.,- .7;t...c:..- .2/'h~' ,tt:..... :.,-c; o:;6,J"t..r) rL ;r;.Jr".,.,....~ G/ rL, ./~,.,,//~ ..:>r.-.",.'.J .i1",..,.,../ ..4/,~ 4/ c2"'....h ,a,A...--"- ;or. _A:4... "L....",.., ~~ . .......,.....N...J~..). ,.'-/.:"r = /,-.;.,;-.-4.- ~Ar~"",c-c... ~' r,.,)",~/ ,..,.. ,JIJ/,", ~;'N'.J')"> ~,.,.,.).r, ,..,.,..,,~./ cr?".;r;'.:.""-",:",,, 'Y"/y ('.>-;".( ..,~ ,1';V --L ;J'(',,,,,~ -I... A?,,,. ,,t./ /' L ,;;2/.;,v::"r- ~.,,..L /'L .?;\.......~ c/ ./~rln.'/ .,;/,J/ .:...-. "H"'."'~ "'/" (wo:...."d,,{~ C'{,......"'hc-..,......./ rL .;?~..r,//'-' .c:%,.... &JA '"', ../""%,,6,,,,<;, ;"'7) ./:.4"/ <;,t/~, /;rc;~{.J.J~~ .r~ ~ /;,/C;""yJ"'~ &/ J.// ,.r' ../" "/i-,nr"" ;.) .r4 ','7/ /" 'A...",,,,/';"~ ~';,J /'4 ,r:;.r,,.,.,....y /7./~../...../ ~/ TA,.,,) /?..~,. "",-' ) ~/;""~",,, .L'2V:,,~/r '.,) ,/N N,'r ?..-v...:~..."',..",> "" /, ,j, w,'r"."r.l..V,) rL ,/ /.'-" r;l oJ.r,c"'.I';,4,,,< ~ ~__'J""- ~,.)r'rHWY: ~,1~ .r,l"r: ". aKf-"''''''''/ c~,"'-:"~';:',J~r.) c='"{.,,,, r~"r- tfL~.:...../~ ""'..)J.......""'~ we; .) -"<.. ~hn..,.'_ ~~.-- r4 ~4J.,,,'..),,/ c.'" ;ID .({?"","",.. rYc.A' P.J "" A.. t:~,..".,~CJ"./,.~"'r~" - ,,,,, ~r; ./.2';:'J'4,.,~ ".,,,,,,- ~t;~ rA:..,- n.... Co ({_n~/.) /-;:......:::...,......,...,''_'__ ~&...) ,/"',;..,,,.,,r. ~"c'c'rl/ r.6-.. , " ,/ /, r../." ,/ ./ / ;",~r ./~ .:7~/'~04,~ ,,.-,,,..:.,..,,,,/,........ /"'?;I'~oY"~. ' ~;;"..M,lr ""....r- JA,-.-. rL "'/''';n,.., _./ /, . , ~.."'Al:,tl..ch".J"/ ~ ~")n,"'./1.i..../ ---- ~ ---, ....... ~~,. ~ ;- 7 /0..... ~<., .:;,.!'~ ..) ..'T. u1Jc:,y~. ..:i/~~V, ~ 0'./ ~./, ,;,; ~V (';'''''1) ~U'I"// ,J y c.'_.~/ .n:.; t:..- <-- > c~//.,,,__,,r '-0.-; L..., ...jr,.~~, ~~"...../ .'./../ -",,.- 77>.L-- /..,~.... 6~ 7ti c:6n'oJ ,L. ;r;.~"""".-y/ c'~' ;J Ai- ~-A""'" ..J ~'~,,'.K'I L.J .,,-yf ,"'-'-- /J.-P"'l .' AJ""',t.. ~,'~/ .r:.,~ "'.../ ~.r,,/ jJ.,t., ~' /Z'),.,(. ,,/~..~'Ac."<r ;'7> "r,~</ <,'1.;1, "oilY t~..,( <',.... nn) r~ "":U.",N'/ "-...',) ./t.,,I'::',- c: ~,. )I:""~ i,t..- rL-. "",,~,"'-L ./ {.' "" 6. /. 'T ..., rlt,.,) T...~,."......Ay, k.r.:'-....._ r.L,__ ...........,..,) /1""./.,,0......;/ .II r)..r /.].,.- ^,,,,' .tA'~,..h.,,' ~ h,~....... ,0:. c11/ ./.J".r,.c n~ -:? .,;Ii'.' I...../r ""', ~""""':,"""'.I', .L-:2",...."'J' ...........,.4, ~,_I ~,,y, ...",/ ~r4 ~I'.L ,A.\ "'~~. ,:....,"N....JJ'.~" .rL. --e...~.,.r CI/ r.L:... r"",.../ G..".:_"J ,4......- L-.. ./,r..,~,.r. .::...~, ~r...'..,k.h.,{ <,I" V.~ A,. 6}Y, ,1CoII ~..'r "",. .;7.::...:." 7,1~. '7 / ./>,X...",,,,/ /J",.) j_r,,~/7"I/ .....c3..,r,L. aH"I->n".,.,,,.~ C,,~ ..:>rKU,t"/",,,./ .T.".'- ;>"./ 'j C',wr.rk,/ = L"'{_~: 7. r.i ./-?{.,.r',1~' .hh N~ ...//.'),./ ./,/1...- dA,.h.r ,/.',/../ 7'() .h'L c ,QI,,,.,.,, ~.. ..,k,.../....: ,', c:,rr-,',)'~ /,-2"'.)'~"A.r .1t:i /:'L" ,y (;I) ~,L;" rk- ,,;iI//',.. all ,,4>j,""'--"'-/ .I6..)...H..-r- ,/"""'~"~,,,- ~/ ~o::......,".A.'" /' /H~/ ,A/,.."..)...~ ~"'rrl rL "",,,,,,,,,,,....,- e;,./ ~ L '7 /c.-.,""~"",/;7",r t"~ ,..,.-; ./ -"'\ ."...~,~ c",..~,L ~"lLh.r....~ .,,,' ......"'...........k.., ,I I>SI, A,J...."..,,- ,7lJ ..<::"/ Ir ,...) /4 /."~_..... '-,,"',( .:...x..) /?......../.4./ "'" rL "",.",~._/'f1'r:/ ""~.IC---.,r """.,/ ./Z.",. ,/~ c,~~ ~"-...4,,,,c..A ci:...>" /" .h re ~..t..";"j ,;C",... Tk',j"/ t'......,L,"'1 ~crL C/PrN,i",) ""I'~~ """-r ,.,,: r~ ~IXJ ~K"'''''''''/ ,../J,,)....fi.,. ",h/ ~~,......, 7?-~,.,/r~/ 2~,.,;I"/ n::.- ,;0',11II..,,(, cF' ~ /Ht',/d'",~ ~~" ;'7~r &-,.~.4:f' :::.J ' .(:.......-'/-,~~ iA../L.. ,6",d ..c:,.{{",/ o'-<J ('?H'""", G~ ~ /C./..",-,- "J~ C:~j,,,>,./ /,., ....,..~/(.J......? ",./c" ~~r~ ~G ~hr.,..c/'.;o ......,(. c,L.- rA..r /~<...,.: 0": .. ^--' f;:.,,/',/ ~ /'<,~ /4. c:,,<L./. ~. ,rL. ~:?'rr../ ..r..{,,,. T"'- fA,,) ./;,,>...,.,.,,..,r" ,.> r~",- .,.,i7.,~,.,~.r' h~</ .# ~,,.,,-,.I' /1.)l' .-<.~".,,t-< ./Z.r.h:...,-,.,r A.: /:"L. ;- 'A) 06,.'/ ""',/ rL. ./-,?(",,,,,,//, ~ A/'~,' ""'-" ,,';A/....J,J,.J /,.I'~".r- /"L,."". ';7'";jrnh..."".., /L c:~~..",...,........, .:__"',~'- c:.-.:...-/.../ ./5"...._ .A--" d",Id-;s....,,' 7'r; a~I./,,~,~ /,,4 ,?:A':.r",~ ./;. A' T.4"~I.J/, c'......, L.-- T~_ h,Jr..,'.,I....,/' ,,.," ~ '"%',,.,,..1/'&. ~ ~ "./-i, ~..,,./,'~~,~ . "".../ rL.. ./Z,,(.~..,.......,,- .>>r<&:......"..,..",.".."'~~ ~.....;r-'"a,...,..,.~") r~ U/r../"',./r....r1 ~'P' ~".,.'c. ~':'-..J A/ ~'--.nn-9.....'r e,''-.rl':'''/~~' rL- r......,.,/ /L, t:~_,,:./ ,4..___ .c:(..~ ;Tt:.. rLJ //~'h ~ ,IC/I r,A..r- d// c'...... .fi..",-",- (J.....,., J..Hf'I,;/ ".,../ I'L..- /1.".,A JH~ L.1"'L--..L..oO., rL. "''''~'''Id".r~ '-"-'~--- ~ hr..../ 'ft.. ....,,<;i < "'/"'. /1,,'/ r/"". ,/.In' ",' C/ C',..., ;1?",/.,/ ~ ;p,~ rL '.n!.... wL--... r..~,....'~..,...7 .~~,,,,..,,,> -;J A.~~/-, ......,,/. ,r#.-, rt:.. ,"C,(. ~~ :J"C.-JCJ "N'c', d,,,r;) t-A..~ /I'''' t:I"c".{.f' .7;v",wJ"''-'',,:,,? t:...J,4~~" J..",,,- JZ/If~/ ..;t:: "~l~.r... ./'/,...;0-,/ c::;?....,_...., .jc~.~, ?".:-". ~H C~~".$" /""'t.Jd~.. ""''> " ~N.'"./"....~;:. -,,<, / .,...;;....../ ..,......,.( ,/',i. - ...P....~~. ~ c/ ~ .:...-.....".../ .h~ ~,/ ,-k.- o<-'rL.,,'. ~L,., /"", .~,,'~ t:r rL ~"."..v- /dC,.u?,U- ~~;,J "C~ /,...:.<-., ,,-,/,.,r ..v:.....;/ __ ;;/--1/ 2.....",-,/ ..,/ (..-:!~.-A) C,-/ "'I" /;;/........... 4x.,Arr, An/" rL,..-- ;(-!'-"-.",.."".....,r C"//1r ;';/,) ;--:7 / _/ -",,, ...? r~..."Jr....../ /;4,,- /"";'~ ~pc::..c.7"' 7'" G r;.,A-.,./. ..:>.-, .r.4.. (/)/A) t::;Z~;</ ~ C '>-"'"u""--' /'<"_r- c/ rL ~c......./ c~. ~,/"::.....",,.,,'rrc..../ '" ANd" r,L ....;J,.,.l.:.,.,c,/ 7:;""~~.,.,,Co.J~/ n:;, ~.J.r1l6/' ".t' r.i /.!.-,.~nc..-' ~;N .r~ /1//...,>..,,/ /.J~),."'rl"""""~'/ /,)J...J~~''- ~~ ~~"""'~'r~lJ")~ c,l'''~~ d,-",. 4--~'L-~,J ~L~,w /r:~L~>#'''''C/7 C~. /:?{...",,;,YJ "';__'/'C~j ~".J Tt ~'-"~IC/ ~,1/ '-'#~c'-.-/;'/ /~r,.",..J'-, ""n.e/ /.4 ~"v';c../""/?C/t1I./ e:r' ?~".r~//'J , /'.A..~"Y ~L,. rL ~.:J-""'Y1ri"'- C/hc ,.J1I/,) O'c.M;-"'/ ,L .?~#T/~~ '". ~"r~,.~,t:. A,.-H. ,,~~,"r /',.../ ~",Y 1,( ~;H"dck,."r,N",.,...4 /1,k'.Jr /,/~ ~~/r: "'n/~,J /r";"vc;~/ /.nrG ~r..rr.r'n/ ~.) / J ,/'.4- h':..<-, ,.,,...,,,,r #///../.> t.-,.",c.. c'-'''' d"'Jr/J,....r/';'".,."./ /')Ar~ ,1. "?/."N7.> t:...JL.... t/.<~M,> f,)'hr> Cn"-"- "'>0: 0" /,/ rL ~)~C'c..Ac// ;,./t'/~r~ rL d~~>,/ ~'") 7 ~ /'rt::(..u.~t'/ /H'n- /J,,,-r;-, r",,/ "4,,, c"~/ a....r"__,.'c......". / /0hn, <...;L., n~ ) .r::. 1.-_,',11,..""r h ,~.../' ;,n;., /'1"".. J....,,.... /' h",.~ A<>.hr~ "d .T.It hl..v- ".../(" /o;,(1v-, 0L".../;::."... JOJ</-..c' ~<',l /r"r>---": Lc)',oN.y' /.:;"~'.r,.4/ &..,.G::,., /.J,-,.- L /,I/~/uI",,> ,;.......,~, c:.!.....-7rl'~',.'./ .A.,../' .7 cZ.>>",,,;.,,,~ e/ ~'IJ"r-A- "N r~J, ..:J'7 ~/~ "~ ~....~~~:.C_ -,. /;'JY. .:c, ~....,)', -r cR.....,. ,L......, ~ r:2~,...y rA.r .r k~ ~._./... a .} /';1/ ---?' '7""",--- .A..../ ,,-r'YY##,r- c;..1"7' ",- r~ h....-,j<"",? ./r,"8.T,r/.,j /'~./._'''''7 cM~"<A" {'P~ ,-,./ .,..a,,.rl,.,, ,.,..- ~:a,..../' ~,." .:......r",/ J"..",,,...,,, ........, /' tJ1,r"':jt.' ~. -",vue/ ./...4.LJ.,.,/,IJ ./f'/~;. .:U','ry"- -0, ~.'_, ?~"'d'_'_ ..>t., ~ ,d,,j~' Jr.--r: 6!.;:..t:,. ,;4, /~:J ,;,..,.,..",., /f',c- .a~,../~ ~ If) ~~ .,~ ,..;I q N l~" ( .-:r ~ .~' .1 . c_ !1~ c') ~' f' .- ,s',a ~1 - '~~ _~"V ~ ',,:~ '0' ..' '6 o::l d If' GEORGE T. CARR, PLAINTIFF V. TIMOTHY L. CLAWGES, DEFENDANT IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA 94.5051 CIVIL TERM IN RE: PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S AMENDeD COMPLAINT BEFOB~ BAYLEY. J. ANI) HESS. ,I. OPINION AND ORDER OF COURT Bayley, J., October 28,1998:-- A document titled "Civil Action" flied by plaintiff, George T. Carr against defendant, Timothy L. Clawges, in the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, was transferred to this court. Defendant filed preliminary objections to the pleading. An order was entered on May 22, 1998, supported by a written opinion, that provided InW AllI that ''Within sixty (60) days of this date, plaintiff shall file an amended complaint on his alleged cause of action Involving his conviction for aggravated assault." On July 21,1998, plaintiff flied an amended complaint to which preliminary objections in the form of a demurrer were flied by defendant. In his amended complaint, plaintiff avers that he was convicted of aggravated assault when represented by Timothy L. Clawges, a full-time assistant public defender in Cumberland County, Plaintiff alleges numerous errors by Attorney Clawges regarding his representation, but he also avers that he "[I)s not alleging criminal malpractice, but is alleging the Ineffective assistance of trial counsel." Plaintiff seeks: 94.5051 CIVIL TERM [R)ellef In the amount of S185.000. In punitive damages for the deprivation and denial of the plaintiff's Constitutional Rights under the 6th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution and Article 1, Section 9 of the Pennsylvania Constitution. And an order of relief In the amount of $165.000 In nominal damages for emotional duress, mental anguish and the deprivation and denial of the Plaintiff's Constitutional Rights under the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution among other Constitutional InJuries that this court requires In the Interest of Justice.' In Baney v. Tucker, 533 Pa. 237 (1993), the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania stated : [t)oday we hold that a plaintiff seeking to bring a trespass action against a criminal defense attorney, resulting from his or her representation of the plaintiff In criminal proceedings, must establish the following elements: (1) The employment of the attorney; (2) Reckless or wanton disregard of the defendant's Interest on the part of the attorney; (3) the attorney's culpable conduct was the proximate cause of an Injury suffered by the defendant/plaintiff, I.e., 'but for' the attorney's conduct, the defendant/plaintiff would have obtained an aqulttal [sic] or a complete dismissal of the charges,'2 (4) As a result of the Injury, the criminal defendant/plaintiff suffered damages, (5) Moreover, a plaintiff will not prevail In an action In criminal malpractice unless and until he has pursued post-trial remedies and obtained relief which was dependent upon attorney error;'3 additionally, although such finding may be Introduced Into evidence In the subsequent action It shall not be dispositive of the establishment of culpable conduct In the malpractice actlon.14 1. These claims for specified amounts of unliquidated damages violate Pa. Rule of Civil Procedure 1021 (b). -2- 94.5051 CIVIL TERM Ii, The defendant/plaintiff must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that he did not commit any unlawful acts with which he was charged as well as any lesser offenses Included therein. Resolving this question will perhaps cause the greatest consternation. However, the only one way to protect the Integrity of the system Is to permit the attorney to Introduce whatever evidence that Impacts on the defendant/plaintiff's entitlement to compensation. Such evidence can Include any and all confidential communications, as well as otherwise suppressible evidence of factual guilt. 13, This requirement does not, however, relieve the plaintiff of his duty to Initiate this cause of action within the statute of limitations period as hereinafter discussed, but It does raise a procedural question, to wit: what Is to be done with a civil action filed prior to the completion of the post-convlctlon process? The answer Is that an attorney defendant who Is served with a complaint alleging professional malpractice for the handling of a criminal matter may Interpose a preliminary objection of the grounds of demurrer. See Pa,R,C.P, No. 1017(b)(4). The trial court shall then reserve Its ruling on said objection until the resolution of the post-conviction criminal proceedings. 14, In this regard we wish to emphasize that a finding of Ineffectiveness Is not tantamount to a finding of culpable conduct. In the opinion In support of the order of May 22, 1998, that granted plaintiff the right to file the within amended complaint, we quoted from Bailey v. Tucker, supra, exactly as It Is set forth In this opinion, Despite having told plaintiff the elements of an action In trespass against a criminal defense attorney, plaintiff has flied an amended complaint and falls to plead facts sufficient to support such a cause of action. There Is no civil cause of action for Ineffectiveness of trial counsel. Plaintiff has not pleaded, and cannot plead, that he has pursued post-trial remedies and obtained relief which Is -3. p, Folher will hllw Ihe chil<lonllhcllllltinll wccken<ls Ihull FridllY lit (1:00 p,m. until Sun<lllY lit CI:OO p'm' b. Olllhe other weekends. hither will hnw the child frnm FridllY lit ():OO p,m, until SlIturdllY lit 2:00 P,I1l.. IInd then IIgllin on SundllY beginninllllt 8:00 t\.lll, until SundllY lit 2:00 p'm' e. FlIther shllll enjoy plll1illl physiclll custody of the child lit such other times liS lire Illutulllly IIgreellble between the Fllther IInd the mlltellllllgrllndmother. Mllry Ann McCoy, S, Mother, Amy SehWlll1l.blluer. IlOW by remllrrillge. Amy lIt1n1elle. shllll enjoy ptll1illl physical custody of the child tit such times liS arc mutually tlgreeable between the Mother ollll the mtltemal grandmother, MlIry Ann Me{ 'oy, CI, In the event that Mary Ann McCoy predeceases Mother, becomes pemJanently incapacitated or is otherwise unable to serve as legal custodian of the minor child "Ir any reason, the primary custody shall revel1to Mother. Amy Sehwlll1Zbauer now by relllarritlge Amy lIalllelle. with all other provisions of this Stipulation Agreement remaining in effect which tire not inconsistent with this ptlragraph, 7, The pal1ies will keep etleh other tldvised immediately relative to any emergencies eoneelllingthe , child and shall ful1her tuke any necessary steps to ensure that the health. welfare and well being of the child is protected, w...:a.:AS, Father, M.lther um! Orundmother desire to enter Into an agreement regarding custody relative to the minor child, Ilrcndon August Schwart7.bauer. III be in cllect hereal\er ond until alter~'II by subs~"luentorder of conrt; und w...:a.:AS, Fnlhcr, Mother und Orundmother dcslrc to conllnn their ogrcement relotive to custody oflhe minur child nnd C.\ccute u Stlpulutlonund Agrcementto elli.'Ctthe some. NOW. """:REFOR.:. in considerntion of the mutuul covennnts, promises oml agreements as hereiual\er set t,)rth, nnd iutendiug to be legnlly bound, the parties hcreto agree us 1,)llows; 1. Father, Scoll M. OIenn, hereby ucknowledgcs Ihut he wus previously represent~'II by MOllhew J. Eshelmon, Esquire of the Law Oflices of Putrick F. Luuer, Jr. in o.~socialion with prior custody proceedings which resulted in un Order of Court dated October 28. 1996. Father. however. acknowledges and allinns that he is no longer reprcsented by counscl and has lIecn advised that he has a right to scek legal counsel, but hus chosen not to retuinlegal counsel. 2. Mother, Amy Schwurtzbuuer, hcreby IIcknowledges that sbe wus previously rcpresented by Joan Carey. Esquire of Legal Services. Inc. inussociution with prior custody proceedings which resulled in an Order of Court dated October 28, I'll)(,. Mother, however. acknowledges and allirms that sbe is no longer represented by counsel and has been advised that she has a right to seck legal counsel. but has chosen not to retain legal counsel. 3. Mary Ann McCoy. the maternal grandmother of the minor child. Brendon August Schwar1zbauer, dute of birth, Novembcr 28, 1991, shull have primary legal custody of said minor child. 4. Mary Alln McCoy shnll hnw primary physicnl custody of thc llIinor child. Brendon August Schwal1zhauer. s. Father. Scoll M. (Jlelln. shall cnJoy pnl1ll1l physlclll custody of thc child IIceordlng to the "lllowillg sch~'IIulc: a. Father will hnvc thc child onllltcmntllll! wcekcnds from Frldny at 6:00 p.m. until Sunday lit 6:00 p.m. b. On thc othcr wcekcnds, Fnthcr will hllvc thc child froml'ridny lit 6:00 p.m. until SaturdllY nt 2:()0 p.m.. und thell ngnin Oil Sundny bcginning at 8:00 lI.m. until Sunday nl 2:00 p.m. c. Fllthcr shall cnJoy pnrtinl physicnl custody of thc child lit such olhcr times as are I llIutually agrceablc betwccnlhc pnrtics nnd thc Ornndmotber, Mary Ann McCoy. 6. Mother sholl enjoy partial physical custody of the child al such times as are mutually agreeable betwcen the parties and the matcrnalgrandmother. Mary Ann McCoy. 7. In the event that Mary Ann McCoy prcdcccnscs Mothcr. bccomes permanently incapacitated or is otherwisc unublc to scrvc us icgul custodiun nfthe minllr child Il1r nny rellson, the primllry custody shall revert to Mother, Amy Schwurtzbuucr Barnelle. with ull othcr provisions ofthb Stipulation Agrcement remaining in eflcct which lire not inconsistcnt with this pllrllgrllph. q.: \lQ ~ <l- " '):- ~ , ~ , .1 t. ~ F '.. rrJ r ; I .. .- II: , I , " ,.-: I , I " ., " .. I ."'; " '. ,_I" ".) .'